id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00013v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.00013v2 | Machine Learning Approach for Cancer Entities Association and Classification | 2023-05-30T07:36:12 | 2023-06-24T07:12:20 | G. Jeyakodi, Arkadeep Pal, Debapratim Gupta, K. Sarukeswari, V. Amouda | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | According to the World Health Organization (WHO), cancer is the second
leading cause of death globally. Scientific research on different types of
cancers grows at an ever-increasing rate, publishing large volumes of research
articles every year. The insight information and the knowledge of the drug,
diagnostics, risk, symptoms, treatments, etc., related to genes are significant
factors that help explore and advance the cancer research progression. Manual
screening of such a large volume of articles is very laborious and
time-consuming to formulate any hypothesis. The study uses the two most
non-trivial NLP, Natural Language Processing functions, Entity Recognition, and
text classification to discover knowledge from biomedical literature. Named
Entity Recognition (NER) recognizes and extracts the predefined entities
related to cancer from unstructured text with the support of a user-friendly
interface and built-in dictionaries. Text classification helps to explore the
insights into the text and simplifies data categorization, querying, and
article screening. Machine learning classifiers are also used to build the
classification model and Structured Query Languages (SQL) is used to identify
the hidden relations that may lead to significant predictions. | [
0.0471501686,
0.0378246903,
-0.0098443916,
-0.0490386337,
-0.0231158249,
0.0461587049,
0.0032755854,
0.0303488355,
0.0458992459,
-0.0490456149,
0.0259454735,
0.008141133,
-0.0105369128,
0.0238346178,
-0.0115960008,
-0.0106979199,
0.0028554387,
0.0375403985,
0.0311800186,
0.0242895968,
-0.0276240744,
0.0370344594,
-0.0037358899,
0.0269817747,
0.0395415016,
0.0397522338,
0.0427660644,
-0.0409423336,
0.0058800005,
-0.0776212662,
-0.0006439547,
0.0009167964,
-0.0612973496,
0.0246756431,
0.0000017554,
-0.0938031003,
-0.0685350746,
0.0352860391,
0.0166858304,
-0.045511663,
0.046717532,
-0.0541032851,
0.0045595751,
0.0141703198,
-0.0031800347,
0.0053829299,
0.011748503,
0.0773594156,
-0.0164614953,
0.0963156223,
-0.0154633094,
-0.0501069911,
0.0531319343,
0.0218491573,
0.0275521204,
-0.0084923692,
0.0781509131,
-0.02768928,
0.0204304885,
0.0055527147,
0.0548023954,
0.0419183485,
-0.0493945889,
-0.0035516138,
0.0529493429,
0.0570967048,
-0.0176401362,
-0.0076814648,
0.0223998204,
0.0084641734,
-0.0031411774,
-0.036384806,
0.0918001235,
-0.0259811059,
-0.0250052139,
0.0470050611,
0.0153611805,
-0.0209707469,
-0.0534115918,
0.0005082485,
0.0317341946,
-0.0112954667,
-0.0007248098,
0.0047637364,
0.0246580634,
0.0153666884,
-0.0202920195,
-0.0083535835,
0.0347605757,
-0.0127420705,
0.0314855985,
-0.0486850217,
0.0474909246,
0.0512916483,
0.0005334367,
0.0278727934,
-0.0036150655,
-0.0290883128,
0.100929603,
-0.11329519,
-0.0461328886,
-0.0530652478,
0.0229102541,
0.0461437106,
-0.0406851396,
-0.050146129,
0.0033194378,
0.0397898704,
0.0018071126,
0.0298198014,
-0.0476462506,
-0.0117473071,
0.0065608863,
0.0459241755,
0.0284084417,
0.0114428811,
-0.0646853969,
-0.0153812831,
0.0264514405,
0.0233942457,
0.0399693213,
0.0246063545,
0.0043269694,
0.0449229777,
-0.0403783955,
-0.0064210743,
0.0133541487,
-0.0144684212,
-0.0764960423,
-0.0329561979,
0.0642701983,
-0.0303241778,
0.0362612233,
-0.0292021576,
0.015826704,
0.0572264344,
0.0184386689,
-0.0574416704,
-0.031876415,
-0.0176320039,
-0.002024252,
-0.0233986918,
0.0001860203,
-0.0248601716,
0.0053762333,
0.0309373904,
-0.0275131762,
-0.0201051943,
0.0297119543,
0.0012704715,
-0.0517336689,
0.0421998948,
-0.0328760445,
-0.018116273,
0.0828271061,
0.0052267243,
0.0212941244,
-0.0009487735,
0.0102628162,
-0.0296941102,
0.0049057836,
-0.0187754314,
-0.0264956076,
-0.046201203,
0.0168486442,
-0.0629074574,
0.0266232509,
0.0214571208,
-0.06404268,
0.0460058078,
-0.0678568259,
0.0483081304,
0.0127393845,
-0.0312402882,
-0.0036625527,
0.0407998934,
0.0581734367,
0.0523323901,
-0.0355990902,
0.0177250039,
0.0161828697,
-0.024195198,
0.0002630518,
0.0098851779,
-0.0530754551,
0.0137626622,
-0.0125354985,
0.005174526,
0.0209403187,
-0.0430965982,
-0.0116881644,
0.036262203,
0.0020100486,
-0.048883833,
0.0649914294,
-0.0337691791,
-0.0487069637,
-0.0465921834,
0.0599078685,
0.0139131071,
0.0011840318,
-0.0167369638,
-0.0077671278,
0.0243008286,
0.0305690747,
-0.0838651508,
-0.0369229279,
-0.0220123474,
-0.0626526251,
-0.0262406319,
-0.051147379,
-0.0093324324,
-0.0303916428,
0.0150848143,
0.0096681155,
0.0232754201,
0.0133207757,
-0.0307199173,
-0.0186135713,
0.087495327,
-0.0286254007,
-0.0137545243,
-0.0184794944,
0.0523833409,
-0.0112510007,
-0.0331404768,
-0.0131327948,
0.0213129111,
0.0260564722,
0.0380378328,
-0.006541057,
0.0188528262,
0.032258559,
-0.0332694128,
-0.0720112845,
-0.0275241863,
0.0439117216,
0.0061174985,
-0.0220407844,
-0.0375459529,
-0.0205575805,
-0.0348801129,
-0.0174777042,
0.0089223245,
-0.0342623033,
0.0105344243,
-0.0008605227,
0.0025462001,
0.0011690131,
0.0128820762,
-0.000418274,
-0.0412785783,
0.056980513,
-0.0310241915,
0.0034335046,
-0.015518629,
-0.0995668247,
0.0339025594,
-0.012871732,
-0.0060704364,
0.0128628397,
0.0040388666,
-0.0138676073,
0.0287602618,
-0.0305927061,
-0.0043085366,
-0.0027145436,
-0.0609674081,
-0.0059511377,
0.0199654326,
0.0311048217,
0.0147341508,
0.0025839536,
0.0116673186,
-0.0286276136,
-0.0432133637,
-0.0055453395,
-0.0019167941,
-0.0064655049,
0.0508269221,
0.0319772772,
-0.0050918874,
-0.0050943745,
-0.0053922436,
-0.0621036887,
0.046238564,
0.0737117231,
-0.0833577514,
0.0317950249,
0.0666682199,
-0.0107938126,
0.0076595214,
0.0174963437,
0.0049055805,
-0.0112488093,
-0.0099769169,
-0.0770626068,
0.0547566414,
0.0026750122,
0.0369870737,
0.0212578699,
0.028603889,
0.0175422095,
0.0178428311,
-0.0477355644,
0.0192914363,
0.0189312994,
-0.0461604409,
0.0555271842,
0.0218743347,
0.0011746753,
-0.0298179556,
-0.0145435594,
-0.0095083257,
-0.002791848,
0.0112733189,
-0.0418067798,
0.0265832655,
0.0131703541,
0.0063197394,
0.0179597065,
-0.0267921407,
0.0920555145,
0.0152226202,
0.050944522,
-0.1123153642,
-0.0012523609,
-0.0009320835,
-0.0074465172,
0.0228853934,
0.0255370978,
0.020245159,
-0.022190595,
0.0282241944,
-0.0101340283,
0.0189885702,
-0.025981687,
0.0285562649,
-0.0017209498,
0.036224965,
0.0106162233,
0.022812305,
-0.0448539183,
0.0230362378,
-0.0172175802,
0.0206199102,
0.0273917541,
-0.0181736853,
-0.0431505181,
0.0216824114,
-0.0181586575,
0.0283369925,
0.0218507629,
-0.0168857202,
-0.0011899875,
0.0175806768,
0.0580813214,
-0.0625854433,
-0.0104616079,
0.0228096955,
0.0247910991,
0.0277872607,
-0.0487742051,
0.0079355836,
0.0100251138,
0.0070095281,
-0.0016753975,
-0.0876691341,
0.0200127009,
0.0061192634,
-0.0207064897,
-0.0148481997,
0.0151325148,
0.0705233738,
0.0257825609,
-0.0417582802,
0.0166107677,
0.0230044406,
-0.0741507038,
-0.0329202041,
0.0660196766,
-0.0744096339,
0.0203940198,
-0.0294223856,
-0.0366042033,
-0.056309551,
-0.0772120729,
0.0111482432,
-0.0055723442,
0.0005686748,
-0.0288473479,
-0.0673352927,
0.0026096734,
-0.0931076258,
-0.0387376994,
-0.0475344025,
-0.0685920194,
-0.0310994349,
0.0075927363,
-0.0317743197,
0.0094655817,
-0.0507426597,
-0.0792587772,
-0.017929988,
-0.0316916592,
-0.0137404259,
0.0356998108,
0.057384111,
-0.0276620481,
0.0178499427,
-0.0447212979,
0.0056812624,
0.0036726433,
-0.0293296501,
0.0866598561,
-0.019746745,
0.0087582944,
-0.0557474941,
0.012584988,
-0.0102570038,
0.0099138916,
0.0151193747,
0.0695446283,
-0.0421552435,
-0.0320480466,
-0.0526182875,
-0.003842094,
0.0071624327,
0.0220023394,
-0.0692432523,
0.0013743301,
-0.0418859497,
0.0270565953,
0.0558573976,
0.0406900905,
0.0259365831,
0.0436065532,
-0.0598759949,
-0.0254198238,
-0.068250306,
-0.0046147383,
0.0311554205,
-0.0236081574,
0.0388070755,
0.0644153059,
0.0332527161,
-0.0296739731,
-0.0570131168,
-0.0025874965,
0.0721304417,
0.0215068199,
-0.0293410849,
-0.0780253112,
0.0325746723,
0.0012559576,
-0.0194473621,
-0.0335461982,
0.0022761116,
-0.0247367397,
-0.0499209464,
-0.0082087042,
0.0080519477,
-0.0200437531,
0.004393307,
-0.0768063962,
0.0580056421,
0.0260992497,
-0.0397133753,
-0.0496053547,
-0.0724993199,
-0.0022866193,
-0.0075341491,
-0.0148780467,
-0.019865185,
0.0187945608,
-0.0166421253,
0.0041166395,
-0.0285020061,
-0.0411236919,
0.0423158519,
0.042163264,
0.0426537804,
0.0097169727,
-0.0095189232,
-0.0203763898,
0.024478348,
0.0098374076,
0.0215519145,
0.0027590082,
-0.031243898,
-0.0023217141,
0.0317970924,
-0.0300538745,
0.0265555084,
-0.0398954973,
-0.0312657543,
-0.0356257297,
0.0716454908,
0.065181531,
0.0271425154,
0.040071331,
-0.0202419665,
0.024965046,
-0.0360647328,
0.015170468,
-0.0047666361,
-0.0160855968,
-0.0173277892,
0.0200280994,
0.0375775136,
-0.0290332157,
0.0161179509,
-0.0326996557,
0.0267627612,
-0.0229085721,
0.0185081065,
0.0364248902,
-0.0357420966,
0.0193241946,
-0.0308590159,
-0.0029502027,
-0.0315474495,
0.0424548909,
-0.0133843245,
0.0438583232,
0.0309688058,
0.0153504387,
-0.021942623,
-0.0350691378,
0.0170685221,
0.061490722,
0.0062701041,
0.0141338212,
-0.0575982481,
-0.0273771491,
0.013162191,
0.0768829808,
0.005405067,
-0.0510659888,
0.0050065625,
-0.0293590929,
0.0099859163,
0.0625016019,
-0.001383618,
-0.002673253,
-0.0128456829,
0.0128777018,
0.0113244625,
0.042680975,
-0.0560116433,
-0.0644516647,
0.0092539368,
-0.0410058349,
-0.0330785178,
0.0146300215,
-5.446162306e-33,
0.0330867991,
-0.0571360737,
0.0173791926,
0.0092223482,
0.0371886678,
0.0169640034,
-0.0275801122,
-0.0497317426,
0.0450366959,
0.0249117091,
-0.0029155225,
-0.0007205035,
-0.0071608,
-0.0145210801,
-0.0107158953,
-0.0082767336,
0.0295485947,
0.0019703805,
0.0115788905,
-0.0127132479,
0.0180775281,
0.0829796642,
0.0124868648,
-0.0759828687,
0.0090628099,
0.0494084246,
0.0188842472,
-0.0254843049,
-0.0007892752,
0.0314087011,
-0.0171612818,
0.0274822991,
0.011260787,
-0.0182905234,
0.0404058173,
-0.0155345248,
-0.1017860919,
-0.0204577744,
-0.0237018,
0.0307802409,
-0.0127211073,
0.014712207,
0.0549572594,
-0.0096461875,
-0.0021524625,
0.0130474018,
0.0844452009,
0.0010246979,
-0.0582505912,
-0.0668701306,
-0.0254119374,
0.0481837392,
-0.0008484647,
0.0699497908,
0.0209605955,
-0.0350258723,
-0.0243909769,
0.0203319304,
-0.0313989073,
-0.0189253166,
0.0342009664,
0.0163001791,
-0.0046662693,
-0.0033700799,
0.0106516108,
0.0396379903,
0.0099607669,
-0.0377079435,
-0.0039103013,
0.054767739,
-0.0075360066,
0.0197772887,
-0.0476421677,
0.0147605203,
0.0362301804,
-0.0052794502,
-0.1037959456,
0.0613126978,
-0.0407040007,
0.0279525165,
-0.0145027526,
-0.0066915411,
-0.0197241716,
0.0056535215,
0.0036072286,
-0.0039210566,
-0.0119754514,
-0.0400035791,
-0.0191197544,
-0.0257889871,
-0.0445448384,
0.041857861,
-0.0283919424,
-0.0260434281,
-0.0671665221,
0.0221976861,
0.0579002872,
0.0051800557,
-0.0498580188,
-0.0159617569,
-0.0581294298,
-0.0360870957,
0.0032715406,
-0.0561026372,
0.0433920547,
-0.0231997427,
0.0281430036,
-0.0453420579,
-0.0302586649,
-0.0041389619,
0.0301997904,
0.0041630161,
0.0176641755,
0.0443921871,
-0.0100044897,
0.0122765601,
0.0340650976,
0.0479631908,
0.0348662883,
-0.0051274449,
0.0140877692,
0.0084663006,
0.0337383226,
-0.0090154679,
-0.0415664576,
-0.0049763275,
-0.0032576721,
0.0250791144,
0.0273382366,
-0.068287693,
0.008464545,
-0.002099144,
2.681e-7,
0.0909951702,
0.0400376283,
0.0207835641,
-0.0429503657,
0.0104646906,
0.0030825965,
0.0241768323,
0.0258709323,
-0.0439263843,
0.0249839723,
0.0580599681,
-0.0141868731,
-0.0147369392,
0.0219966006,
-0.0581792183,
-0.0199795216,
-0.0312780365,
-0.0249500796,
-0.0188031048,
0.0284536649,
0.0671349019,
-0.0026512709,
0.0010395653,
-0.0016730144,
0.0019612419,
0.0109509313,
-0.0067568044,
-0.0384797715,
0.0633826628,
0.0317892395,
-0.0053174431,
0.0059268503,
0.0141295558,
0.0783787742,
-0.0270511378,
0.0049870526,
-0.0026707598,
0.0228422657,
-0.0347251631,
0.0396070257,
0.0635288283,
-0.0186054539,
0.032146614,
-0.020951882,
0.0523289591,
-0.0214791019,
-0.0588706061,
0.0162918251,
0.0292360894,
-0.0300253108,
0.0532733724,
0.0163844898,
-0.0532427244,
0.0328935124,
0.0138008166,
-0.0023040685,
0.0182725452,
-0.0523307249,
0.0508231372,
0.0716466606,
0.0158442613,
0.0322734043,
0.0155642172,
0.0098921591,
0.0391470715,
-0.0203523021,
0.0383691676,
2.219027522e-34,
-0.0051233736,
0.0143061355,
-0.0422886349,
0.0427717976,
-0.0043365723,
-0.0056462898,
-0.0162487254,
-0.0135077005,
-0.018837044,
-0.0717911497,
0.017320076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18787v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18787v2 | Universality and Limitations of Prompt Tuning | 2023-05-30T06:47:07 | 2023-11-16T08:26:59 | Yihan Wang, Jatin Chauhan, Wei Wang, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Despite the demonstrated empirical efficacy of prompt tuning to adapt a
pretrained language model for a new task, the theoretical underpinnings of the
difference between "tuning parameters before the input" against "the tuning of
model weights" are limited. We thus take one of the first steps to understand
the role of soft-prompt tuning for transformer-based architectures. By
considering a general purpose architecture, we analyze prompt tuning from the
lens of both: universal approximation and limitations with finite-depth
fixed-weight pretrained transformers for continuous-valued functions. Our
universality result guarantees the existence of a strong transformer with a
prompt to approximate any sequence-to-sequence function in the set of Lipschitz
functions. The limitations of prompt tuning for limited-depth transformers are
first proved by constructing a set of datasets, that cannot be memorized by a
prompt of any length for a given single encoder layer. We also provide a lower
bound on the required number of tunable prompt parameters and compare the
result with the number of parameters required for a low-rank update (based on
LoRA) for a single-layer setting. We finally extend our analysis to multi-layer
settings by providing sufficient conditions under which the transformer can at
best learn datasets from invertible functions only. Our theoretical claims are
also corroborated by empirical results. | [
0.000904379,
0.0548844151,
-0.0173053164,
0.0050220769,
0.001787273,
0.0191607047,
0.0112856738,
-0.0288325418,
-0.0555757992,
0.006933671,
-0.0778642297,
-0.0357650444,
0.0220305752,
0.0263697281,
0.0298847631,
-0.0538691655,
0.0432636216,
-0.046725478,
-0.0464542694,
-0.0278948974,
-0.0261816625,
-0.0516055003,
-0.0159448404,
0.0391272157,
0.028424697,
0.0089544086,
-0.0194884054,
-0.0312421992,
0.0012022009,
0.0041783694,
0.0246696398,
0.0567066185,
0.013390216,
0.0111073172,
0.0000020117,
-0.0196365733,
-0.0123828137,
-0.0514261015,
-0.0691408068,
-0.0420632362,
-0.0375019349,
-0.0620179139,
-0.020826919,
0.0148517778,
-0.012010131,
-0.0431489274,
0.0678453222,
-0.0224932935,
0.0587552451,
0.1040795147,
-0.0102394642,
-0.0519132093,
0.0044835368,
-0.0475383662,
-0.0337508284,
-0.0151325669,
0.0001580441,
-0.0787858218,
-0.0262124836,
-0.0047159228,
-0.0602809042,
0.0459026359,
0.0528327003,
0.0186467599,
-0.0016348098,
0.0223645624,
-0.0188538805,
-0.0553575382,
-0.0366717316,
0.061270725,
-0.0891920105,
-0.0162371472,
-0.0208973624,
-0.0160727818,
-0.0044221589,
-0.0044414424,
-0.0051457565,
0.0207779426,
0.0253711157,
0.010901304,
-0.0313764848,
-0.0054118233,
0.0066952463,
-0.0367776118,
-0.0443129838,
0.0437170677,
0.0175528824,
-0.0400027297,
0.0189294443,
0.0128772398,
-0.0076240962,
-0.0443492495,
0.0204623118,
0.0613233447,
-0.0614412315,
0.0205654055,
-0.0725073665,
-0.018053975,
-0.0320363604,
-0.0177595187,
0.0603007711,
0.045404546,
-0.0462092459,
-0.0077495058,
-0.0264317859,
0.0622170381,
-0.011823941,
0.0534028485,
-0.02472388,
0.025413638,
0.0158027764,
-0.0124148773,
-0.0623144247,
0.0118403658,
-0.0204243083,
0.0096498197,
-0.039637614,
0.0742685571,
0.011878062,
0.0142948749,
0.0016144108,
-0.0327013656,
-0.0905850306,
0.0027464298,
-0.0240200143,
0.0450217463,
-0.0106617175,
0.026076382,
0.01681979,
-0.0422392301,
-0.0256306864,
0.0025122624,
0.027573511,
-0.024496505,
0.0156643391,
0.0593810454,
-0.0432366244,
-0.0446729474,
-0.0153752472,
0.0057700761,
0.0074322042,
-0.0219437983,
0.030297786,
-0.0206762943,
0.0211784467,
0.0182283856,
0.0162623748,
-0.0233961213,
-0.037008971,
0.0120065399,
0.0198860317,
0.066202648,
0.0212460645,
-0.0099816937,
0.0081131328,
-0.0158780999,
-0.0137296207,
0.0518607087,
-0.0182225592,
0.01218809,
0.0137902284,
-0.0452075601,
0.0078727705,
0.0621128231,
0.0210033283,
0.0121250702,
0.0018065266,
-0.0044262316,
0.0419974551,
0.0190472212,
0.0064198249,
0.0306446683,
-0.0440079086,
-0.0186194256,
0.06356325,
0.0123198545,
0.0635173842,
0.0545131601,
0.0510345399,
-0.025875587,
0.0088186217,
0.0667292699,
-0.0405405015,
0.0232825279,
-0.0201182291,
0.0109896781,
-0.0254598502,
0.0329939276,
-0.0760460645,
-0.0381456837,
0.0391383767,
-0.0166318621,
-0.0186237041,
-0.0322694741,
0.0136139095,
0.0518328324,
-0.0619485378,
0.0869876295,
-0.0165338665,
-0.0351181217,
0.0288659427,
-0.0370060951,
-0.0156996567,
0.0191154834,
0.0041019116,
-0.0346075892,
-0.0228519309,
0.0045395503,
0.0230451617,
0.0411603674,
0.0503876619,
-0.0043072551,
0.0202795453,
-0.0421487316,
-0.0215961579,
0.0115735624,
-0.0268540587,
0.0282093044,
-0.044010628,
0.0130030559,
-0.0060689608,
0.044241529,
0.0180842709,
0.0214910097,
-0.0293919165,
-0.0378772989,
0.0136814443,
0.0371386819,
0.0324886627,
0.004652333,
-0.0161892064,
0.0118885636,
0.0226179902,
-0.0134679917,
0.0056290687,
-0.0142974611,
-0.1025990471,
-0.0032534115,
-0.0098881414,
-0.0143221533,
0.0060496228,
0.0591591336,
-0.0324308798,
-0.0604128242,
-0.0230568592,
-0.0288156662,
0.0403103083,
-0.0195834637,
0.0386018232,
-0.0144679388,
0.0368518233,
-0.0352442637,
0.0252310894,
0.0148393977,
0.027968673,
0.0427399725,
0.0387866795,
-0.0069378139,
-0.0430820733,
-0.0899006501,
0.0202261079,
-0.004278657,
0.0396734625,
0.0361147113,
-0.0085662147,
-0.0008701522,
-0.0532662161,
-0.0445547439,
-0.0088813277,
-0.0546095446,
0.0008191149,
0.0256016031,
0.0483693853,
0.008501838,
-0.041036848,
-0.0430180468,
0.017687019,
0.002575937,
0.0446091965,
0.0380686,
0.0293657687,
-0.0343384631,
-0.0027725096,
-0.0351696424,
0.0286890659,
0.0438984223,
-0.0171305202,
-0.0169336647,
-0.0651960671,
0.0068718106,
-0.0003842935,
0.0610178858,
-0.0176390763,
-0.0317378528,
0.0254064538,
0.0174873956,
0.0598030016,
0.0749392807,
0.0313296542,
0.0181353744,
0.009301547,
0.0214887615,
-0.0167364515,
0.0026805908,
-0.0790247023,
-0.0792802051,
-0.0651373267,
0.0752099529,
0.0476839766,
0.0792279243,
-0.0125558851,
0.0079958858,
-0.0866585076,
0.0041685458,
0.0196080711,
-0.0012051797,
-0.0061892681,
-0.0196749549,
-0.0358341746,
0.0265726242,
-0.0085904924,
-0.033891242,
0.0526058599,
-0.021691788,
-0.0073160832,
-0.0139701944,
-0.0082472637,
-0.0092483656,
0.0163534582,
0.0368777961,
-0.0093094101,
0.017171992,
-0.0181602743,
-0.0827030167,
0.0198948421,
0.0158054195,
-0.0138854012,
0.0647096336,
-0.0109258015,
-0.0000131592,
-0.0233713184,
-0.0682042837,
-0.0402915888,
-0.0266807321,
0.0145252971,
0.0140249738,
0.0377716236,
-0.0079846419,
-0.0420623496,
0.0101730693,
0.0186134502,
0.0999425054,
-0.0196903609,
0.0028328332,
-0.0495784543,
-0.0007759426,
0.0171561167,
0.0511449985,
0.0003180363,
-0.0311011393,
0.0544770099,
-0.0269451551,
-0.0107709225,
-0.0041897516,
-0.0444951542,
0.0395824946,
0.0445372686,
-0.0274512637,
-0.0310733989,
0.0265433528,
0.0426191725,
-0.0040711947,
-0.0294278692,
0.0780516267,
-0.0123485019,
-0.0838789493,
0.0110305883,
0.0277532563,
0.0245654229,
0.0231293608,
0.025206577,
-0.0689059272,
-0.0193164591,
-0.0050076656,
0.0312646441,
-0.005814563,
-0.0060408399,
0.0005197973,
-0.0981903225,
-0.0097859576,
-0.0096588098,
-0.0075666597,
-0.0241369978,
-0.0031337426,
0.0044804742,
-0.0166201126,
0.0552941263,
0.019222619,
-0.008972045,
-0.0094225248,
0.0323756151,
0.0129381828,
-0.0617748238,
-0.0115960333,
-0.0092101712,
0.0114707248,
0.0525863133,
-0.0331149921,
-0.0112226624,
-0.062892355,
0.0448390394,
0.0012247765,
0.0150658945,
0.0333342366,
0.0291761067,
-0.0064744069,
-0.0380372033,
0.0266033802,
0.0408893153,
-0.0198774058,
0.0220278613,
-0.0133362794,
0.0585088134,
-0.0352017619,
0.0175783243,
0.0278991777,
-0.0492238142,
-0.0061286325,
0.0232441016,
0.0178551748,
-0.0702008307,
0.0059846235,
-0.0135786152,
0.0300296266,
-0.0405913703,
-0.0527571514,
0.0225115549,
-0.0303089581,
-0.0500455722,
-0.0118078608,
-0.0078629106,
-0.0000222628,
0.0665946975,
0.0192814879,
-0.0705394894,
0.0357469544,
0.0183860511,
-0.0134516284,
0.0013886952,
-0.0073938565,
0.012045336,
-0.0903503522,
-0.0176520087,
0.0636835992,
-0.0258715618,
-0.0311026499,
-0.0204007886,
-0.0612765811,
-0.0339583308,
0.0480833687,
0.0517406799,
0.017787816,
0.0624197535,
-0.0008895404,
-0.0522436164,
0.0996439233,
0.0151461912,
-0.054229524,
0.0415928178,
0.06173243,
-0.0388550349,
-0.0157726947,
0.0359519012,
-0.0673755258,
0.0355567001,
0.0462562889,
0.028981844,
0.0117073786,
-0.0617193617,
0.0435483158,
-0.0046615037,
0.0721076727,
0.0241878871,
0.0177419577,
-0.0087238764,
0.043749053,
0.032681413,
0.022366263,
-0.0452576578,
-0.0366181768,
0.0059510772,
0.0227262918,
0.0129742548,
-0.0194838196,
0.0058738878,
0.0554265194,
-0.0238034539,
0.0164377,
0.0210529361,
0.03342418,
0.0321421325,
0.0287540369,
-0.0124389585,
0.0286520105,
0.0246755499,
0.0204717554,
0.0047093178,
0.0350327566,
0.050927829,
0.0542182662,
-0.0380222946,
0.0329246596,
-0.0760117248,
-0.069171086,
-0.0294813123,
-0.0014792864,
0.0225293059,
-0.0027949705,
-0.0201947913,
0.0028086288,
0.0051313196,
-0.0020311465,
0.0060584098,
0.0259926245,
-0.0300361216,
0.0371814854,
0.0108482046,
0.0267530922,
-0.0135322148,
0.044504147,
-0.0543539785,
0.0337876901,
-0.0224071592,
0.0455871485,
-0.0319115408,
-0.0270254239,
0.007827674,
-0.0063277809,
0.0053281565,
-0.0185279716,
-0.0035443755,
-0.0556422472,
0.0188069232,
-0.0032510187,
0.0252970569,
-0.0230230782,
0.0396927707,
0.0410039052,
-0.0056429589,
0.0061251284,
0.0117594246,
-0.0152988583,
0.0158262365,
0.0014961134,
0.006710201,
-6.153681702e-33,
-0.0472580642,
0.0315285325,
0.0160277374,
0.0179891139,
-0.009157856,
0.0191632323,
-0.0107988529,
0.0015934466,
-0.0229074061,
-0.0381346792,
-0.0344283246,
-0.0212493874,
0.0194187853,
0.0338496417,
-0.0094695399,
-0.028711848,
0.0570623092,
-0.0396593362,
-0.0547617488,
-0.000133551,
0.0192217566,
0.0140515771,
0.0546892919,
0.0394638069,
-0.006357993,
0.0182918534,
-0.0205542557,
0.0254793037,
0.0125579899,
0.0478871427,
-0.0042273016,
0.0452209376,
-0.0021274707,
-0.0949472412,
-0.0383540131,
0.0503454618,
-0.0832906514,
-0.0641027167,
-0.0054408885,
0.0577488244,
-0.0089727957,
-0.0045682061,
0.0537952743,
-0.0241535194,
-0.0300282333,
-0.0149820587,
0.0234564152,
-0.0048795757,
-0.0204881355,
-0.0606946014,
-0.0230711587,
-0.0109473933,
0.0047458159,
-0.0342491306,
0.015320939,
0.0918521062,
-0.0311937332,
0.0059196339,
-0.0592815466,
0.0004276161,
0.0247508828,
0.0596063323,
0.0205630232,
0.0449201502,
0.0016833087,
0.0086424118,
0.0372778848,
0.0054411222,
0.0113382963,
0.0031326092,
0.029135678,
-0.0122677935,
0.033450529,
-0.0101118311,
0.029763421,
-0.018937815,
-0.0211603418,
-0.0253492892,
-0.0059977435,
0.0131497933,
0.030284198,
-0.0011498593,
0.0300336126,
-0.0265957043,
-0.0658642352,
-0.010473446,
-0.0141999824,
-0.0211037789,
0.021940086,
0.0157437641,
0.0021680284,
0.0052289106,
0.0642160922,
-0.0045357049,
0.0287507772,
-0.0133921755,
-0.0162493605,
0.0410027467,
0.00336501,
0.0181972869,
-0.0511363037,
-0.0600949228,
0.0204520673,
0.015648758,
0.0113266381,
0.0070929639,
0.025638314,
0.0868004337,
-0.0495061241,
-0.0343871713,
-0.0249661691,
0.0161620267,
0.0159044415,
0.0608436093,
0.0329000093,
0.0068520964,
-0.0170471743,
0.0545900464,
-0.0352625139,
-0.0529079288,
-0.0260441341,
0.0232095011,
0.029430991,
0.0672911704,
-0.0322908796,
-0.0335321054,
-0.0306880288,
0.0314813256,
0.0089084944,
-0.0835751817,
-0.0007670803,
0.0205796584,
2.891e-7,
0.0037540807,
-0.0363196805,
0.0472089089,
0.0112623991,
0.0069497214,
-0.0094839334,
-0.0032180061,
0.0421479605,
-0.0008638353,
0.0115041193,
0.0279789306,
-0.0030605835,
-0.00955493,
-0.0087701995,
-0.0882605836,
-0.0219969321,
-0.0834969208,
0.0559104346,
-0.0395965874,
0.0149113154,
0.0202269908,
0.0997514129,
-0.007871775,
0.0021357564,
-0.0104173608,
0.0133241117,
0.0419527814,
-0.0149757266,
0.0263379738,
0.0088154981,
0.0432866067,
0.0032925913,
-0.0275674891,
0.0396573544,
-0.0137429647,
0.0466993339,
0.00628208,
0.0346607529,
0.0172217023,
-0.0480754673,
0.0391667411,
0.0111838765,
-0.0272755716,
-0.0381120257,
0.0544666275,
-0.1043064222,
-0.0123677533,
0.0053336397,
-0.0364805609,
-0.012576079,
-0.0029526541,
-0.0339827053,
-0.0049348166,
0.0076382556,
0.0575294867,
0.0543590263,
0.0073282709,
-0.0667795613,
0.027037615,
0.0123719089,
-0.0339190513,
-0.0373504013,
-0.0654044077,
-0.0611266866,
0.0364366919,
-0.0270890072,
0.0062884572,
2.380347591e-34,
0.0293808877,
-0.0062641888,
0.0466611944,
-0.0252207182,
0.0088707004,
-0.0288377423,
0.0377019495,
0.0349484533,
0.0478318892,
-0.090400435,
-0.0500853695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18786v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18786v2 | Scalable Performance Analysis for Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-30T06:40:08 | 2023-05-31T17:55:44 | Santiago Castro, Oana Ignat, Rada Mihalcea | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Joint vision-language models have shown great performance over a diverse set
of tasks. However, little is known about their limitations, as the high
dimensional space learned by these models makes it difficult to identify
semantic errors. Recent work has addressed this problem by designing highly
controlled probing task benchmarks. Our paper introduces a more scalable
solution that relies on already annotated benchmarks. Our method consists of
extracting a large set of diverse features from a vision-language benchmark and
measuring their correlation with the output of the target model. We confirm
previous findings that CLIP behaves like a bag of words model and performs
better with nouns and verbs; we also uncover novel insights such as CLIP
getting confused by concrete words. Our framework is available at
https://github.com/MichiganNLP/Scalable-VLM-Probing and can be used with other
multimodal models and benchmarks. | [
0.0162642989,
0.0447210222,
-0.0021448818,
0.0888494179,
-0.0427922495,
0.0057787397,
0.0061562592,
-0.0027092381,
-0.037835855,
-0.0679818243,
-0.0388459079,
-0.0415043421,
0.0535884798,
0.066448167,
0.0373072512,
-0.0455800742,
0.0481478907,
-0.0547007136,
-0.0577711649,
0.0124988817,
-0.001504529,
-0.0025133737,
0.0024710486,
0.0481630899,
-0.0327010453,
-0.0080523985,
0.0016951256,
0.0250087138,
-0.0055811647,
0.0205364991,
-0.0207026396,
0.0206768028,
0.0230609179,
0.0213726703,
0.000001802,
-0.025260143,
0.0207538996,
0.0152111053,
0.0202666018,
0.0015344595,
0.0435881838,
-0.0515379198,
0.0095702168,
-0.0005429432,
0.000864819,
-0.0207955036,
0.0536741205,
0.0168412346,
0.0127058309,
0.0347431563,
-0.0111580295,
0.0188930351,
-0.0009065347,
-0.0306893885,
0.0049502519,
-0.0427475907,
0.0262614042,
0.0159694534,
-0.0051677208,
-0.0082020834,
-0.0514436662,
0.048531428,
0.0141903767,
0.0137298098,
-0.0129973385,
0.0153164966,
-0.055294022,
-0.0625287592,
-0.0141262729,
0.0449119434,
-0.0660199076,
-0.0088160736,
0.004068241,
-0.0214340221,
-0.0144247096,
0.0028364838,
-0.0260953587,
0.0363097675,
0.0132526783,
-0.0001238844,
-0.054759901,
-0.0271215364,
0.0332558006,
-0.0028466578,
-0.0136480173,
0.0099920901,
0.0179631673,
0.0219611675,
0.0111684911,
0.0277865399,
-0.0260741916,
-0.0391062498,
-0.0282626152,
-0.0106559293,
-0.045605097,
0.0107550593,
-0.0633065999,
-0.0195353124,
-0.0022186057,
-0.023083616,
0.0789229423,
0.0257490817,
-0.0558864176,
0.0586998649,
-0.0378203839,
0.0811366811,
-0.0094282618,
0.0515880212,
-0.0063756183,
-0.0331124142,
-0.0179463085,
0.0159275513,
0.0000063631,
-0.0078899227,
-0.0578310005,
-0.0659546182,
-0.0122121098,
-0.0032340609,
-0.0350169949,
-0.001273189,
0.0146259107,
0.0053733075,
-0.0281268358,
-0.0037907597,
-0.0048696119,
0.0129985642,
-0.0008323622,
0.0438091718,
-0.0194790866,
-0.0866630152,
-0.0132365283,
0.0433710441,
-0.0082387207,
-0.0226758476,
-0.0019251648,
0.0835377574,
-0.0289984737,
-0.0655264929,
0.0097519951,
-0.0145146307,
-0.0396758616,
-0.0506784245,
0.0118927117,
-0.0748359188,
0.0300016049,
-0.0108595435,
0.0162558891,
-0.0425798371,
0.018195631,
0.0010665307,
-0.0279573966,
0.1162351072,
0.0149739701,
0.0028315252,
-0.0248593166,
0.0108245499,
0.010270495,
0.0745907202,
0.0129323332,
0.0235718954,
0.0349457823,
0.0286015701,
0.0186689701,
0.0459876433,
0.0004394694,
-0.0084589496,
-0.0908600986,
-0.0334044546,
0.0151558388,
0.0139686903,
0.0265340507,
0.1032803729,
-0.0137514127,
-0.0382929072,
0.0514224097,
0.0637496486,
-0.0186824501,
-0.0475049727,
0.0445883833,
-0.0191249885,
0.0006776853,
-0.0145075228,
-0.0554498285,
0.0127061615,
0.0023874419,
-0.0054963515,
-0.001676108,
0.0269143526,
-0.0316807628,
-0.0002437241,
-0.0549833365,
0.0008276898,
0.0117166741,
0.0258883834,
0.0756599605,
0.0194010269,
-0.0155328307,
0.0087923752,
0.0085025001,
-0.0211353377,
-0.0197573602,
-0.0631228611,
-0.0094604557,
-0.004988532,
0.0334684886,
0.0257298835,
-0.0169487335,
0.0217341185,
-0.0124836257,
0.0459237024,
0.0221456699,
-0.0193653889,
0.0369409211,
-0.0307782013,
-0.0481500588,
-0.0114269825,
0.0220446959,
0.0006938764,
0.0372348763,
-0.0178053696,
0.0266233236,
-0.0642493516,
0.0099040437,
0.0576621704,
-0.0086674998,
0.0282160677,
-0.0237510707,
-0.0036214739,
0.021831071,
-0.0222058836,
-0.0420404226,
0.0132307885,
0.0338175334,
-0.0337344334,
0.0194024295,
0.0244608559,
0.0258247536,
-0.0245063547,
0.0444016494,
-0.0554839894,
-0.0183642171,
0.0743745118,
-0.0183596313,
-0.0308736581,
0.012616924,
-0.0278848521,
-0.0222411454,
-0.0462454259,
0.0096851084,
-0.0092175975,
0.032044068,
-0.0272351094,
0.0275688749,
-0.0320003256,
0.0215232652,
0.0123478491,
-0.0037299104,
0.0069276146,
-0.0130762542,
-0.0446213372,
0.0159816034,
-0.0286784582,
0.0233118441,
0.0000998757,
-0.0233531147,
-0.0240933578,
-0.009119953,
-0.0673773289,
-0.008480005,
-0.0437470749,
-0.0172640868,
-0.0167966615,
0.0065725055,
-0.0005998949,
-0.0591216609,
0.0227033906,
0.0417396165,
0.0136376917,
0.0307140835,
-0.0029183212,
0.0176916588,
0.0140840048,
-0.0397327431,
-0.0155300703,
0.0140900705,
0.0455469191,
-0.0159201343,
-0.0494147614,
-0.0028507954,
0.0459861979,
-0.0184475239,
0.0545079783,
-0.0315135904,
0.0210782159,
0.0233655311,
-0.0403034538,
0.0305054039,
0.0791864544,
-0.0085427295,
0.0525082126,
0.0438377932,
-0.0066232155,
-0.0310173854,
-0.0068764188,
-0.0007386447,
-0.0306994934,
-0.0279891919,
-0.000919972,
-0.0254471973,
0.0346497856,
-0.0028389057,
0.0066238833,
-0.0576576367,
0.0541445985,
-0.0399455652,
-0.0717878938,
-0.0930153877,
0.0280443262,
-0.0175269768,
0.0426217914,
-0.0346845686,
-0.058472611,
-0.0016067694,
-0.0324036144,
0.0091706878,
0.0095246295,
0.0047872337,
-0.0131091988,
0.125016138,
0.0382820778,
0.0022030172,
-0.0273769181,
-0.0141052697,
-0.0807884336,
0.0029274689,
0.0044242931,
-0.0166712757,
0.0785273612,
-0.0769094899,
0.0330494717,
-0.0254175402,
-0.0228271037,
-0.0377084836,
-0.0100011239,
-0.0575510673,
0.0082961712,
-0.0133082457,
-0.0225284807,
-0.0340128578,
0.0333210193,
0.0132096084,
0.0383219905,
-0.0056679407,
-0.0136405658,
-0.0142948041,
0.0102272667,
0.0700105727,
0.0154117486,
0.004853108,
-0.0655276179,
-0.0491547137,
0.064517349,
0.0160054173,
0.0186156146,
-0.0638302565,
0.019732967,
0.0324399769,
0.0291930642,
-0.0089016948,
0.0089911176,
0.0473537333,
-0.0570769161,
-0.019279113,
0.0641999915,
0.0228727311,
-0.030043954,
-0.0133068571,
0.0013603334,
0.0231789351,
0.0479504503,
0.0107413372,
-0.0593274608,
-0.0553164855,
0.0076646945,
-0.0094423359,
0.0325450227,
0.0108159045,
-0.0298349392,
-0.11736013,
0.0486951657,
-0.0231443364,
-0.0327652469,
-0.0476816297,
0.0233377758,
0.0265169926,
-0.0288898014,
0.0061882692,
-0.0005717219,
-0.029036209,
0.0059881494,
0.013291209,
0.0218631402,
-0.066066727,
0.0245161131,
-0.0511167049,
0.0352782384,
0.055226393,
-0.0016180731,
-0.0000536348,
-0.050519418,
0.0495829731,
0.004528407,
-0.0025288372,
0.0056248698,
0.061567612,
-0.0383828916,
-0.0424768217,
0.0367418416,
0.0138237979,
-0.0211214852,
-0.0252296366,
-0.039794948,
-0.0041467389,
-0.0187486224,
-0.0290719718,
-0.0453221649,
-0.0087769628,
-0.01611563,
0.0652380064,
0.0043314337,
-0.0160976127,
-0.0377402902,
0.0163179338,
-0.0330142416,
-0.0310606342,
-0.0716638565,
-0.0033219315,
0.0258887503,
0.0107585788,
-0.0496957712,
-0.0237115454,
0.0386149585,
0.0474623367,
-0.0248035099,
-0.0238934439,
-0.0104257902,
0.0223225486,
-0.0703607127,
0.0664782226,
-0.0059624128,
0.0487509854,
-0.0421728268,
0.0332444087,
0.0068338416,
-0.0006462367,
-0.0200187508,
0.0426728018,
-0.1360712051,
-0.0404860899,
-0.021144148,
0.0624972843,
0.0224634297,
0.0409747846,
-0.0071359533,
-0.0415095352,
-0.0070660077,
0.0240933578,
0.0162564293,
0.0721341297,
0.0025564018,
-0.061755158,
-0.0240181889,
0.046393048,
-0.0466579571,
0.0172642637,
0.0043943804,
0.0435176902,
0.000535099,
-0.0034987179,
-0.0014541161,
-0.0172103252,
0.0784234703,
-0.020602379,
0.013933789,
-0.0336930193,
-0.0080400603,
0.0126325954,
-0.0144431992,
-0.0884824172,
0.0059263273,
0.0123505443,
0.0268251076,
-0.0034948557,
0.0075493795,
-0.0170162376,
0.0225390457,
-0.0375220701,
-0.0360097401,
0.0260488987,
-0.0594881214,
0.0106838644,
0.0382823348,
0.0053010969,
0.0181802809,
-0.0071681389,
0.0303259436,
0.0153896473,
0.016561484,
0.0098226815,
0.005173889,
-0.0106031075,
0.0169291943,
-0.0278165545,
-0.0420896821,
-0.0089739151,
0.0503562577,
0.0289702192,
-0.0274625979,
0.0691071153,
-0.0292986855,
-0.0233141351,
-0.0492793806,
0.0291475374,
0.0124396291,
-0.0083656823,
0.0693476945,
0.0224706884,
-0.0128330709,
-0.0286465157,
0.0714545995,
0.022339033,
0.0156368911,
0.0041172514,
0.0100490144,
-0.0239825863,
-0.0321427025,
0.0467567518,
0.002111011,
-0.0185900461,
0.02503746,
-0.038078066,
-0.0840624124,
-0.0101062907,
0.0445114076,
0.0257308204,
0.0233123116,
0.0426762365,
0.0580823682,
0.0199357383,
0.0229229461,
-0.0334100574,
-0.045967944,
-0.0132947145,
-0.0146735003,
0.028461922,
-5.818277899e-33,
-0.0486200266,
0.0017595226,
0.0236608367,
-0.0015698774,
-0.0070247096,
0.060550157,
-0.0251587778,
0.0515590496,
-0.0178791881,
0.0413566381,
0.0379206501,
0.0309851747,
0.0143377241,
0.0387230664,
0.0047742464,
0.0084163435,
0.0381317697,
0.004475873,
-0.0209466778,
-0.0481380634,
0.009981161,
0.0183577519,
0.032814458,
-0.0272578821,
-0.0068908674,
0.0328381285,
-0.0306878015,
0.0305339824,
0.0129188923,
0.0773544982,
-0.0201127026,
0.0217459649,
0.0133464094,
-0.0028277733,
-0.0557613,
0.000554314,
-0.0385164842,
-0.0092487233,
0.0416446067,
0.031494271,
-0.1102874652,
0.0592956059,
0.0393203199,
-0.0075710886,
-0.0030269451,
-0.0477744564,
0.0206580739,
-0.0062859929,
-0.0441303663,
-0.0024013836,
-0.0585154966,
0.0229991302,
0.0316434242,
-0.0348136276,
0.0842305794,
0.0324428342,
0.0063588796,
-0.0068853353,
-0.0264266431,
-0.0117888665,
-0.0151798492,
0.0465593562,
0.0921874791,
0.0801231042,
-0.0231666379,
0.0935550332,
0.0069766054,
-0.0248233527,
0.0045228936,
-0.0415808298,
0.0697801709,
0.065813452,
0.0383817255,
0.0590234287,
0.0120471111,
0.0354876965,
-0.0135536343,
-0.0011000503,
-0.0231354535,
0.0615998507,
0.0456651747,
0.002710212,
0.0075136507,
0.0025265815,
-0.0565259941,
0.0044083218,
-0.0616093799,
0.0137348119,
0.0682040453,
0.0424678437,
-0.0094789872,
0.0437983908,
0.0557342395,
-0.0467402302,
0.0152840642,
0.0107598789,
-0.0375859626,
0.0539835729,
0.0077528493,
0.034021534,
-0.0409797579,
-0.0050494163,
0.0179027449,
0.0219369195,
0.0140152983,
-0.0085326694,
0.006333529,
0.0063307234,
-0.0451999791,
-0.0161120556,
-0.0432053469,
0.0072347526,
-0.0376738384,
0.0675892383,
0.0661391169,
0.0052899765,
-0.0417561792,
0.0290768705,
-0.0193746984,
-0.0420873575,
-0.0106709711,
-0.0240008198,
0.0101306578,
0.014430875,
-0.0205321219,
-0.0131258033,
-0.0465472154,
-0.0191714671,
0.0562115647,
-0.0371098965,
0.0014071312,
0.027415989,
2.469e-7,
0.0638506487,
0.029464731,
0.001949986,
0.0292388592,
-0.0052382974,
0.0300170891,
-0.0201450344,
0.0479722656,
-0.008157948,
-0.0364224352,
-0.0326855294,
0.0379688442,
0.0503581166,
-0.0143177221,
-0.0120382868,
0.0069520432,
-0.0181548391,
-0.0147086456,
-0.0186760593,
-0.0348831378,
0.0090331649,
0.084743239,
-0.0132730277,
-0.0270123221,
0.0063131149,
-0.0164533034,
0.0720365793,
-0.0284280088,
-0.0108443741,
-0.0186025593,
-0.0088134138,
0.0372065827,
0.0199957769,
0.0465880297,
-0.0216918979,
-0.0113595231,
0.0744643807,
0.0337587371,
-0.0283881649,
-0.0108315973,
-0.0430282243,
0.0322661474,
-0.0142740821,
-0.0505413748,
0.0707651749,
-0.0455603227,
-0.0055608652,
-0.076368466,
0.016768245,
0.045538526,
0.0278256517,
0.0054948232,
-0.0202350616,
0.0167813748,
0.0547390468,
0.0029859827,
-0.0561342724,
-0.0872960314,
-0.0227004029,
-0.0115628447,
-0.0361364037,
-0.0191027299,
-0.0381793045,
-0.0298087914,
0.0124328323,
-0.0295070857,
-0.0783541501,
2.072843091e-34,
0.0336799994,
0.023695264,
-0.0005376462,
-0.0179577693,
-0.0186137371,
-0.0196988638,
-0.037580587,
0.0211627949,
-0.0438840836,
-0.0235130358,
-0.0070859571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18760v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18760v1 | Shuo Wen Jie Zi: Rethinking Dictionaries and Glyphs for Chinese Language Pre-training | 2023-05-30T05:48:36 | 2023-05-30T05:48:36 | Yuxuan Wang, Jianghui Wang, Dongyan Zhao, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce CDBERT, a new learning paradigm that enhances the semantics
understanding ability of the Chinese PLMs with dictionary knowledge and
structure of Chinese characters. We name the two core modules of CDBERT as
Shuowen and Jiezi, where Shuowen refers to the process of retrieving the most
appropriate meaning from Chinese dictionaries and Jiezi refers to the process
of enhancing characters' glyph representations with structure understanding. To
facilitate dictionary understanding, we propose three pre-training tasks, i.e.,
Masked Entry Modeling, Contrastive Learning for Synonym and Antonym, and
Example Learning. We evaluate our method on both modern Chinese understanding
benchmark CLUE and ancient Chinese benchmark CCLUE. Moreover, we propose a new
polysemy discrimination task PolyMRC based on the collected dictionary of
ancient Chinese. Our paradigm demonstrates consistent improvements on previous
Chinese PLMs across all tasks. Moreover, our approach yields significant
boosting on few-shot setting of ancient Chinese understanding. | [
0.0266834758,
0.0236800127,
0.0022348461,
0.0630233809,
-0.012042501,
0.0233791694,
0.002463171,
0.0279722977,
-0.0060364162,
-0.0309289694,
-0.0378192328,
-0.058826685,
-0.0108455429,
0.0113622788,
-0.0141544892,
-0.0320588611,
0.1049199179,
0.0236831363,
-0.0489195585,
0.0075536724,
-0.0008096601,
-0.0133370319,
-0.0167219676,
-0.0197265092,
-0.0317054167,
-0.0263120141,
-0.0108014457,
0.0057738582,
0.0113282334,
-0.0774493143,
-0.031502191,
0.0326018296,
0.0341887251,
0.0470105447,
0.0000021717,
-0.0807717741,
-0.034667857,
-0.0209951829,
-0.0397081263,
0.0021504001,
0.0346650518,
-0.0272276644,
0.0125248581,
-0.0141807459,
-0.0185857136,
-0.0521200784,
0.0558165237,
0.0480947644,
0.041708421,
0.0530263446,
-0.0166084655,
-0.0478037819,
-0.015111492,
-0.0250401665,
-0.0084549831,
-0.0631201044,
0.0211558994,
0.0008878863,
-0.0519435257,
-0.012972516,
-0.0482451059,
0.0171166174,
-0.0051301164,
0.0380857587,
-0.0134625807,
0.0325986408,
0.0221457835,
-0.0006440379,
-0.0042967983,
0.0505666845,
0.001957674,
-0.0018102516,
-0.0513101779,
-0.0056187343,
-0.0347632319,
0.0069491505,
0.0004788518,
-0.0348851271,
-0.0261704586,
0.0273518749,
0.0473075956,
-0.0156669505,
0.0395321958,
0.0189527217,
-0.0731629804,
-0.0205195192,
0.0307669826,
-0.0389730483,
0.0128120007,
-0.0132367378,
-0.0101621244,
0.0266890842,
-0.0169808213,
0.0138842911,
-0.0250513088,
0.0381118506,
0.0274309162,
-0.0517605208,
-0.0240022969,
-0.0618594736,
0.0571959093,
0.0623786598,
-0.0459351614,
0.0358631872,
-0.0465683751,
0.0208849963,
0.0331507139,
0.0484858863,
-0.0396796018,
-0.02748858,
-0.0297049116,
-0.0053737559,
-0.0727730095,
0.0518286675,
-0.0016812411,
-0.020571284,
-0.0029936628,
-0.0017015465,
0.0210390687,
-0.002561918,
-0.0063048615,
-0.0488930531,
-0.0169716552,
-0.0133292237,
-0.0561898462,
-0.0038815527,
-0.0073244628,
-0.0176638979,
-0.0517982878,
-0.0016623664,
-0.0064678495,
-0.0136547433,
0.0073168757,
-0.0440044552,
0.0354653336,
0.0638663918,
-0.0378724001,
-0.0563727729,
-0.0398522243,
0.0316160396,
-0.0053834547,
0.0058891997,
-0.0144079821,
-0.0324082635,
-0.0065776925,
-0.0085457852,
0.0414918326,
-0.0406421684,
0.0307193846,
-0.0324579962,
-0.0141150989,
0.1011858955,
-0.0218024123,
-0.0099456217,
-0.0286937375,
0.0071870419,
-0.0454059616,
0.0334463343,
0.0035156596,
-0.0188126825,
0.0299638528,
-0.0251704995,
-0.0486692488,
0.0164122581,
-0.0093177771,
-0.0284159351,
-0.0491879173,
-0.0130824978,
0.0529501103,
-0.0032295478,
-0.0011049397,
0.0456831791,
-0.0205017999,
-0.0333764143,
0.0572264828,
0.0247127116,
0.0335530899,
0.0029028985,
-0.0265582185,
-0.002856517,
0.0099668605,
0.0208279807,
-0.0466512814,
0.0049120728,
-0.0093565071,
0.0167913381,
-0.005500379,
0.0004106466,
-0.0145210801,
-0.034648452,
-0.0302348714,
-0.0074159675,
0.0168135352,
0.0232981257,
0.0623997822,
-0.017279651,
-0.0408053249,
0.0234731752,
0.0361613929,
-0.0214746054,
0.030770978,
-0.0229163859,
0.0236332417,
0.0806924254,
0.0369025879,
-0.0331112146,
-0.0088969097,
0.0350011997,
-0.0213003568,
0.0747475699,
-0.0011435251,
-0.0199381243,
0.0329486094,
-0.066520825,
-0.0105850287,
0.0114082471,
-0.008687227,
0.0023795273,
0.0227084532,
0.0077881543,
0.0080682738,
-0.0212069768,
-0.0075226887,
0.0729551762,
-0.0398590267,
-0.0406650454,
-0.0477748699,
0.0362739526,
-0.0165113565,
0.0146653205,
-0.0559231006,
0.0043931659,
-0.0025856714,
-0.0741320848,
0.0363510065,
-0.004197571,
-0.0495625921,
-0.0661882311,
0.0809854567,
-0.0356460661,
-0.019328516,
0.0619720332,
-0.0241846833,
-0.0315625668,
-0.0280352253,
0.0275397077,
0.0753025636,
-0.0864395574,
0.0147143574,
0.0161942393,
0.0214979742,
-0.0065477896,
0.0786753818,
0.0034351856,
0.0280617829,
0.002685304,
0.023664711,
0.0575318672,
0.0143533163,
-0.0623444058,
-0.0226260014,
0.0066960203,
-0.0134124178,
0.0032188748,
0.0056949379,
-0.0218569804,
-0.0086321533,
-0.0281394664,
0.0093710143,
-0.0271665137,
-0.012175885,
0.0183403045,
0.003790342,
0.0058735856,
-0.0315112323,
-0.0280851051,
0.0432865061,
-0.0426422693,
0.002237808,
0.0356712788,
-0.0063185934,
-0.0043347101,
-0.0089863334,
0.0119663421,
-0.0004284925,
0.0085026696,
-0.0186534096,
-0.0667400062,
0.0288539156,
0.029166922,
-0.0054862369,
0.0096541578,
-0.0183248613,
-0.0536718518,
0.0005650705,
-0.0358221047,
0.0075747785,
-0.0181365982,
0.0236476753,
0.0038652832,
0.0340753086,
-0.0307853371,
-0.0076474058,
0.0026271073,
-0.0128232157,
-0.0205301587,
-0.0396059602,
0.012908332,
-0.0236894563,
0.0740193874,
-0.0127351638,
0.0019309507,
-0.0646920055,
-0.0743695945,
-0.013569166,
-0.0035978281,
-0.0150028318,
0.0408327207,
-0.0483608544,
-0.0142564373,
-0.0715593547,
0.001412304,
0.081384182,
-0.004378133,
-0.0123799043,
-0.0257843304,
0.00205955,
-0.0327121504,
0.0761583447,
-0.0175576415,
0.0365846977,
-0.0000929494,
-0.0375304669,
-0.0833719522,
0.0430567153,
0.0128674451,
-0.0567311347,
0.0339268595,
-0.0024270709,
0.0262541343,
-0.0432296507,
0.0081652692,
-0.0501745008,
-0.0213370584,
-0.023390187,
0.0376825742,
0.0511665121,
0.0075350674,
0.0386720151,
0.0442235284,
-0.0503238738,
0.0399822742,
0.0584125929,
0.0165156424,
-0.0109269451,
-0.0122520002,
-0.002929813,
0.0655072257,
-0.0067587509,
-0.0346098952,
0.0759371519,
0.0058386861,
0.0034012422,
-0.0536435917,
0.0307913572,
0.0305581242,
0.0397064276,
-0.0344196111,
-0.0101436852,
-0.0189307891,
-0.0162049141,
-0.0436812267,
0.0173080917,
0.1059724391,
0.0297167897,
-0.0313874967,
0.0050845686,
-0.0189942326,
-0.0386351161,
0.0384689011,
-0.0476360768,
-0.1525561363,
-0.0468442701,
-0.0170308724,
0.0008438482,
0.0467029363,
-0.0162669886,
0.0056822146,
-0.1233078614,
-0.0099204183,
0.0080366749,
-0.0196107626,
0.004696277,
-0.0061126305,
-0.0016373764,
-0.018731067,
-0.0017106028,
0.0103112226,
0.0120787043,
-0.0278130602,
0.0177219976,
0.0182738118,
-0.0373155698,
0.015934851,
-0.0647937357,
-0.0126411328,
0.0438460149,
0.0296761375,
-0.010706272,
-0.0147910649,
0.0243183039,
-0.0306108464,
0.0094525674,
-0.0251903199,
0.0555333532,
-0.0202662852,
-0.0404164158,
0.0211221427,
-0.0213442165,
-0.0322546251,
-0.0539727733,
-0.0118167438,
0.0169319268,
0.0016498709,
0.0168546364,
0.0100814728,
-0.0014857569,
0.0001201611,
0.1067228094,
0.0124469055,
-0.0043214667,
-0.0171425827,
0.0120740077,
0.0408313461,
-0.0354999825,
0.0042205132,
0.0472966991,
-0.032189697,
0.0362742878,
-0.0702265203,
-0.03112977,
0.0071009295,
0.016317796,
0.0051598335,
0.0532409362,
-0.0691645294,
0.0340379626,
-0.0907213688,
-0.0274076574,
0.0126360031,
0.0098290024,
-0.0610308647,
-0.0594450235,
0.0408683829,
-0.0257680174,
0.0061759814,
0.0333857127,
-0.021923732,
-0.032188803,
0.0573095381,
0.0186267328,
0.0063614906,
0.0325036049,
0.0073772008,
0.0259704068,
0.0562296808,
0.0106110359,
0.0337803587,
0.0114612291,
0.0248472579,
-0.0314209424,
-0.0222013518,
0.0073758569,
-0.0044394666,
0.0164187625,
0.0028889403,
0.0524688847,
-0.0411316231,
-0.0267073903,
0.0666482523,
0.0327106901,
0.0509594828,
-0.027225649,
0.0225106273,
-0.0547570363,
0.0517120063,
-0.0049615214,
-0.0224929191,
-0.0195367783,
-0.0449037254,
0.0327731892,
-0.0424683802,
-0.0131249307,
0.0692645088,
0.0214094669,
0.0132857766,
0.0022533776,
0.0112650916,
0.0138443988,
0.0109036965,
-0.0467869453,
0.0259435587,
0.002786767,
0.0272139329,
0.0102735925,
0.0149763869,
-0.0176648982,
0.037382219,
0.0026485086,
0.0085042734,
0.0029711421,
0.0018184956,
-0.040523354,
-0.0417728052,
-0.0294341687,
-0.0377063118,
0.0698360577,
-0.034010563,
-0.0031528359,
-0.0534553267,
0.0048417808,
-0.0216247346,
0.004317503,
-0.0269048996,
0.0042015775,
-0.000418052,
0.0327379294,
0.0070220875,
-0.0524609759,
0.0706292316,
-0.017767081,
0.0688670874,
0.0241619907,
-0.0003860439,
-0.0304194856,
-0.002886446,
0.0533882007,
0.0899505988,
-0.0010078056,
0.0371548273,
-0.086915046,
-0.0774646476,
0.0199598372,
0.0065170671,
0.0319962464,
0.0217352528,
0.0031084111,
0.0131819267,
0.0176570788,
0.0083271982,
-0.0255283993,
0.0063091507,
0.0289781075,
0.0192881338,
0.0008299719,
-6.847435326e-33,
-0.0388085507,
0.0174075831,
0.0194474403,
-0.0288859271,
-0.0006041262,
-0.0057273954,
-0.0377718918,
-0.0026844905,
-0.0525090843,
0.0086123832,
0.0091206254,
0.0103451936,
0.0037593334,
0.0225189999,
-0.0328330621,
-0.0097843688,
0.0482208095,
0.008470634,
0.0339588411,
-0.0352265388,
0.0900005102,
0.0862816647,
0.0831061304,
-0.0401164107,
-0.0087594073,
0.036272116,
0.0430105664,
0.0313777179,
0.0228365082,
0.0555763729,
-0.0111130206,
0.020759536,
0.0287427902,
0.0230750032,
-0.0092636384,
-0.0403556228,
-0.1269580126,
-0.0409778841,
0.0188836008,
0.0409598425,
0.0192106571,
0.0066770623,
-0.0431639925,
-0.0421942472,
0.0163092576,
-0.0135264657,
0.0222502835,
-0.0509268977,
-0.0109857414,
-0.0125639429,
-0.0417947769,
0.0425870866,
0.0140376119,
-0.0148820728,
0.0551755466,
-0.0529571176,
0.0046023377,
0.0222223196,
-0.0417160578,
-0.0058179684,
0.0136385178,
0.0345406085,
0.0025786934,
0.0978490859,
0.0118494872,
0.0560078993,
0.0402586199,
-0.034182094,
0.0337939039,
-0.0002560398,
0.0515248589,
0.020248495,
-0.0088338125,
0.1072906032,
0.1052110195,
-0.0171840377,
-0.0546641126,
0.0255115703,
-0.0013072179,
0.0011408465,
0.0015720959,
0.0097449245,
-0.0086193318,
-0.0069391034,
-0.0384960324,
0.0115265166,
-0.0411381461,
-0.0160863325,
0.0145613691,
-0.0119591132,
-0.0583614632,
0.0394594744,
0.0509566776,
-0.03943979,
-0.0015009815,
-0.003744575,
0.0378647186,
-0.011678189,
-0.0020798603,
-0.0072933375,
-0.0549026467,
-0.0691028982,
0.0113907,
-0.025964478,
-0.006817719,
-0.0050413525,
0.0252835471,
0.0171075463,
-0.02841953,
0.0040257121,
-0.010283716,
-0.0655020922,
0.0343481191,
0.0146747176,
0.0294966623,
0.0163805,
0.0007427135,
-0.0140878549,
0.054506287,
-0.0131168598,
-0.0197049212,
-0.0013640376,
-0.0135629755,
0.0361429565,
0.0350700952,
0.0079065021,
-0.0071354806,
-0.0220331028,
0.05901324,
-0.0496590026,
0.0050675366,
0.0159695763,
2.886e-7,
0.0784540549,
-0.0265516583,
0.0246989932,
0.0939034447,
-0.0314755663,
-0.0025913252,
-0.0562695153,
0.0305179916,
-0.0521498658,
-0.0392779373,
0.0580511875,
0.0607154444,
0.0346849188,
0.0308820996,
-0.0220159274,
0.0428899974,
0.021244375,
0.0058846162,
-0.0193508994,
0.0714202225,
0.0758790597,
0.091533266,
-0.0173747204,
-0.0150049981,
0.0052693179,
-0.0135950623,
0.0639855936,
-0.0192965511,
0.0459537059,
0.0143182203,
-0.0342410505,
0.0016638804,
-0.0234602448,
0.0352015682,
-0.0221466236,
0.0440445095,
0.0386829264,
0.0221999008,
-0.0195900667,
-0.028708132,
-0.0217529126,
0.0033498474,
0.0031614511,
-0.0286212489,
0.0557050519,
0.0307535082,
0.0032365511,
-0.0369910002,
-0.0475529544,
0.0217076819,
0.0021734424,
0.0005490502,
-0.037136402,
0.0250157937,
0.0105869872,
0.0042566052,
-0.0174502861,
-0.0697560012,
-0.0415093862,
0.0038669927,
0.0085686212,
-0.0477083921,
-0.0028356428,
-0.0454943329,
0.0073934621,
0.0062143165,
-0.0003609107,
2.294471301e-34,
-0.0157152936,
-0.0480689295,
-0.0227012057,
0.0845107734,
-0.0003435382,
-0.0436769202,
0.008019113,
-0.0013999012,
0.0109287845,
-0.0214789528,
0.0059777494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18756v1 | VSTAR: A Video-grounded Dialogue Dataset for Situated Semantic Understanding with Scene and Topic Transitions | 2023-05-30T05:40:37 | 2023-05-30T05:40:37 | Yuxuan Wang, Zilong Zheng, Xueliang Zhao, Jinpeng Li, Yueqian Wang, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Video-grounded dialogue understanding is a challenging problem that requires
machine to perceive, parse and reason over situated semantics extracted from
weakly aligned video and dialogues. Most existing benchmarks treat both
modalities the same as a frame-independent visual understanding task, while
neglecting the intrinsic attributes in multimodal dialogues, such as scene and
topic transitions. In this paper, we present Video-grounded Scene&Topic AwaRe
dialogue (VSTAR) dataset, a large scale video-grounded dialogue understanding
dataset based on 395 TV series. Based on VSTAR, we propose two benchmarks for
video-grounded dialogue understanding: scene segmentation and topic
segmentation, and one benchmark for video-grounded dialogue generation.
Comprehensive experiments are performed on these benchmarks to demonstrate the
importance of multimodal information and segments in video-grounded dialogue
understanding and generation. | [
0.0146131208,
0.0191209298,
0.0134845898,
0.0744303614,
0.0021046691,
-0.0077833491,
0.0146178026,
-0.0028980123,
-0.0706951916,
-0.0516296439,
-0.0147972684,
-0.0146388551,
-0.0049340762,
0.0443481766,
-0.01395158,
-0.0678027943,
0.013189883,
-0.0010625061,
0.0245419033,
0.0286709517,
0.0343490466,
0.0317200981,
-0.0334157199,
0.0272559207,
-0.0609340817,
-0.0276743229,
-0.0165548511,
0.0141925393,
0.0654642209,
-0.050877437,
-0.0070392406,
0.0139265815,
0.0919988528,
-0.0132408934,
0.0000015259,
-0.0076741492,
0.0213697944,
-0.0410284027,
-0.0435740016,
-0.0003863602,
-0.0307286289,
-0.0655203909,
0.0256041307,
-0.0102166869,
-0.0298421625,
0.0325899944,
0.0290215202,
0.0563353375,
0.1026792973,
0.0370011404,
-0.0496047027,
-0.0616570786,
-0.0277408268,
-0.0174002443,
0.0182000417,
-0.0309559442,
-0.0174720194,
0.0621462017,
-0.0021442645,
0.0086603342,
-0.0538706295,
-0.0092015537,
0.018914748,
-0.0478161126,
0.0053050318,
0.020861838,
-0.0833575353,
0.009400418,
0.0042718616,
0.1213512719,
0.0327376202,
0.0565510914,
-0.0048245676,
-0.0187765062,
-0.0151160294,
-0.0561008081,
-0.050677862,
0.0248814169,
0.003421572,
0.0169450101,
-0.0155679425,
0.0320448615,
-0.009722787,
-0.0078786891,
0.0391553529,
0.0405804217,
0.0159805696,
0.0149023654,
-0.0490754731,
-0.0069561298,
-0.0228705909,
-0.0483308956,
-0.0093955984,
0.0261621773,
-0.0223830175,
0.0250160135,
-0.0567405261,
0.0461893193,
-0.0437530838,
0.0054413718,
0.032925386,
0.0213172454,
-0.0500348657,
0.0669881776,
0.0071728933,
0.0484740399,
-0.0351144858,
-0.0012580057,
0.0040618144,
0.0280693918,
-0.0440387018,
0.0029073595,
-0.0441416651,
-0.0057122568,
-0.0990414247,
-0.0341761671,
0.0053069871,
0.0324904658,
-0.0207736269,
0.0156254042,
-0.0071468088,
0.0216218308,
-0.017712364,
-0.0261282641,
-0.0072097247,
0.0360286944,
-0.0861908272,
0.0431499518,
0.0221674163,
-0.0301842354,
-0.0241309535,
0.0331976712,
0.0247587282,
-0.0293081049,
0.0001843652,
0.0135157974,
-0.0483094081,
-0.0312808603,
-0.0210782476,
-0.0440500341,
-0.0458764508,
-0.0294502918,
0.0071308166,
-0.0135227172,
0.0410066471,
-0.0268277936,
-0.0452807508,
0.0076613305,
0.0082211224,
-0.021844551,
0.0020359785,
0.0640014857,
0.0160993543,
0.0043211933,
0.0252236985,
0.0422505252,
0.0060743117,
0.075294815,
0.0168403592,
0.0488645174,
0.0433284827,
0.0360987037,
-0.012855324,
-0.0109062027,
-0.0009815694,
0.041155301,
-0.0627207085,
0.0255372673,
-0.0257448517,
0.0652808249,
0.0310136266,
0.0230261087,
-0.0569677129,
-0.0436781682,
0.0448383614,
0.0513602346,
-0.0553158633,
-0.0118933572,
0.0323255919,
0.0269589443,
-0.014350581,
0.0076033394,
-0.0108172772,
0.0659310743,
0.0447539985,
-0.0021011359,
0.0025803605,
0.0017918305,
-0.059988413,
-0.011993017,
0.0006706385,
0.0190782882,
-0.017698044,
-0.0473393872,
0.017725572,
0.0111218011,
-0.0605590343,
0.0893977135,
-0.0328487419,
-0.0233942177,
0.0056219571,
0.0045779631,
0.0283635464,
0.0561989211,
0.0175880492,
-0.0239858925,
-0.0615428165,
-0.0154313156,
0.0846711323,
0.0460752472,
-0.0162856802,
-0.0559277423,
0.0616789386,
-0.0952786505,
-0.0204921737,
-0.0644789264,
0.020726528,
0.0347545967,
-0.0011121808,
0.0149898734,
0.0265776254,
-0.0423625521,
0.0929777101,
0.0301503334,
0.0229827687,
0.0288596433,
-0.032899648,
-0.0025384307,
0.0338895991,
0.0326137468,
-0.0137193566,
-0.055184193,
0.0073241461,
-0.0425451659,
0.0145545313,
0.0650947914,
-0.0659695491,
-0.0592820682,
0.0131593207,
-0.0542554073,
-0.0300687701,
0.0139954826,
-0.0557409152,
-0.0333520249,
0.0322140567,
0.002686379,
-0.0298424065,
-0.0572784059,
-0.0367483385,
0.0349304713,
0.0443020463,
0.000342723,
0.0382886119,
-0.0284162536,
-0.01800243,
0.0440106764,
0.0398787148,
0.0331947207,
-0.0478259325,
0.0286750104,
0.0002127377,
0.0031010532,
-0.0202057846,
0.0004851366,
-0.0096476246,
-0.0648421347,
-0.0233808197,
-0.0917173475,
-0.0094499681,
-0.0223694611,
-0.0030935679,
0.0277137067,
-0.012254674,
-0.0016107582,
-0.0250602402,
-0.0338834375,
0.0124026462,
0.0191413984,
0.010085959,
0.0330249071,
0.0241619255,
-0.0025949634,
-0.0165515821,
0.0128165195,
0.0398310572,
0.0547269285,
0.0102768373,
-0.0117351552,
-0.0096329339,
-0.0214584209,
-0.0227651354,
0.0035828238,
-0.0521102101,
-0.0191221163,
0.0257707592,
0.0038953032,
0.023984842,
0.0452953726,
0.0210522115,
0.0531094521,
-0.0159981418,
-0.0675110668,
0.0182492044,
0.0071752816,
0.0134001989,
0.0442334041,
-0.0081017185,
0.0021140962,
-0.0119643789,
-0.0002853624,
0.0001604031,
0.0642641783,
-0.049686797,
0.0204947442,
0.0312122889,
-0.0256247539,
-0.036016807,
-0.0063195974,
-0.0155455731,
0.0406034701,
-0.0560725071,
-0.0204876736,
0.0389523171,
-0.0489665568,
-0.044052545,
-0.0066622454,
0.0165510532,
-0.0019765154,
0.065297544,
-0.0264302772,
0.0222199149,
-0.0604172535,
-0.0451995693,
-0.0659133717,
-0.0313147642,
0.0259299409,
0.0224986281,
0.0729222968,
-0.0351444297,
0.015543987,
-0.0143589098,
-0.0043201954,
-0.0567022376,
-0.0425820388,
-0.0433425456,
-0.0218284056,
-0.0459924005,
-0.0226190593,
0.0343378633,
0.0206277966,
-0.0039731818,
0.0332690589,
-0.0023089638,
0.0240880679,
-0.0072958418,
0.0593730211,
0.0609650873,
0.0131911431,
-0.0575000159,
-0.0355487391,
0.0820297077,
0.0436875708,
0.0368551463,
-0.0457469374,
-0.0361323096,
0.0475499928,
-0.0067453552,
0.0182416569,
-0.0060428809,
-0.0297099538,
0.078471452,
-0.0310209021,
-0.019148251,
0.0819750801,
-0.004069753,
-0.00454226,
0.010035241,
-0.0240613203,
0.0057284767,
0.0327230319,
-0.0098873423,
-0.0884568021,
-0.0456103869,
-0.0061054016,
-0.0268558208,
0.0445895605,
-0.0398126692,
-0.0447944924,
-0.0689719245,
0.0479141176,
-0.0049936245,
-0.0571235754,
-0.0333352238,
0.02881179,
0.021609053,
-0.0011783213,
0.0208547395,
-0.0202632211,
0.027076263,
0.0041447366,
0.0008906075,
0.0365726389,
-0.0171633959,
0.037316706,
-0.0233882871,
0.0473933034,
-0.0146045992,
0.0231388919,
0.0128111932,
-0.0176902488,
0.0432786494,
-0.0161009654,
-0.0098774675,
0.0254516434,
0.0396720693,
-0.0413629003,
-0.0303690936,
0.0385212936,
0.0484030843,
-0.0142734973,
-0.0500721335,
0.0094051147,
0.02538714,
-0.0315842815,
0.0330075137,
-0.0056507704,
0.0612702519,
0.0199037977,
0.0594558194,
0.0303242709,
-0.0025049271,
0.0029909641,
0.0260016117,
-0.0015657331,
-0.0372693799,
0.0258351248,
-0.0282960255,
-0.0120559959,
0.0366173908,
-0.0663878471,
-0.0065239412,
0.0423853397,
0.0653412491,
-0.0552444197,
-0.021399647,
-0.0238921084,
0.0262229443,
-0.0403297283,
0.0577808544,
-0.0100385416,
-0.0100916708,
-0.0463113263,
0.000915324,
0.0547175482,
-0.0321337096,
-0.010821172,
-0.0110680237,
-0.0505276918,
-0.043449305,
-0.0138596008,
0.0215661861,
0.0197120626,
0.0850932226,
0.0273291711,
0.0164237581,
-0.0111430362,
-0.014122122,
0.0006747163,
0.0152841117,
0.0004823131,
-0.0035530105,
-0.0172069147,
0.0354593769,
-0.0261832289,
0.0429612361,
-0.0305239819,
0.0297512077,
-0.0593114831,
-0.0577481054,
-0.0260962602,
-0.0432988368,
0.0580054484,
-0.0050112624,
-0.0029421579,
-0.0573630296,
0.017136693,
-0.0188616794,
0.0058618342,
-0.0859628469,
0.005508312,
0.0020981794,
-0.0190056078,
-0.0221556351,
-0.0040738932,
-0.0348115973,
0.0490607657,
0.0064503555,
-0.0227375478,
-0.0099935038,
-0.0022924361,
-0.003473955,
0.0265510045,
0.0117241358,
0.0306240581,
-0.033514116,
0.0227791276,
0.0150191952,
0.1356361508,
0.0245101433,
-0.0227522105,
0.0189504381,
0.0622257292,
-0.0155454772,
0.0351876616,
-0.0143974489,
0.0356412493,
0.0004756057,
-0.0218023006,
-0.0016622288,
0.0290566143,
-0.0136362864,
0.008184569,
0.0912316665,
0.0067522158,
-0.0835605189,
0.0459330678,
0.0347992741,
-0.0252816342,
0.0390835963,
0.0514922813,
-0.0076927301,
0.0273468811,
0.0168014895,
0.0138982637,
-0.0220025517,
-0.0119337859,
-0.0160258636,
-0.0007914101,
0.0301370434,
0.0374733545,
-0.0267392397,
-0.0483924001,
-0.0086193345,
-0.0041627209,
-0.0011483631,
0.0539378934,
0.038705036,
0.0415864103,
0.0051910868,
0.0079847397,
0.0155609269,
-0.0112542221,
-0.0371007398,
0.0000676559,
-0.0132235857,
-5.083150181e-33,
-0.0568014458,
-0.0194903165,
0.0249633398,
-0.0125469835,
-0.0459044054,
0.0243860446,
-0.0471630767,
0.0012945719,
-0.0021096875,
0.0431434549,
0.0325100012,
0.0508579388,
0.0054728393,
0.0470943227,
-0.0304902401,
-0.0866295695,
0.0430715047,
-0.0059889234,
-0.04263556,
0.0283709485,
0.0494299904,
-0.0008268075,
0.0327667184,
-0.061185766,
-0.0526247025,
-0.0094816443,
-0.0211955626,
0.0550412014,
0.0577435941,
0.0371385925,
-0.0038193576,
-0.0307174306,
0.0277308524,
-0.03970645,
-0.0175955184,
0.0115773194,
-0.0414971374,
0.0111395372,
0.019412484,
0.0269610304,
-0.0458679236,
0.0032461798,
-0.0325069837,
0.0003133661,
0.0458656475,
-0.0331326649,
0.0101560922,
-0.0388504267,
0.0127227651,
0.0028262159,
-0.0405410193,
0.0148535427,
-0.0399730243,
-0.0444779135,
0.0160780717,
-0.00642141,
0.0565245524,
-0.0350215919,
-0.0207819417,
0.006159747,
-0.0630758628,
0.0083990302,
0.065348722,
0.0179201346,
-0.0164099336,
0.0679948479,
-0.0099682119,
-0.0530212373,
-0.0263738874,
0.0156502835,
-0.0264471993,
0.0609873831,
0.0012823668,
0.0311611947,
-0.0340548567,
0.026234651,
-0.048115775,
0.0184184816,
-0.0284804665,
0.0287418813,
-0.0126412027,
0.0420429483,
0.0327121951,
0.0001197113,
0.0122548603,
-0.0353485644,
-0.0007457761,
-0.0141766947,
0.0169811808,
0.0005252596,
-0.0059417249,
0.005279527,
0.0711051673,
-0.004508527,
0.0655970126,
0.0679961517,
-0.0491703041,
0.0199231468,
0.014610989,
0.030673245,
-0.0325726382,
-0.0080763036,
0.0607344843,
0.0379898585,
0.0165830236,
-0.0141736986,
-0.0047975788,
0.0030127924,
-0.0112760402,
0.0021778259,
-0.0183559693,
0.037676435,
-0.0604240596,
0.0592302643,
-0.0012243669,
0.0118379304,
-0.0669375956,
0.0839622542,
-0.0064293398,
0.0093570398,
0.0106873941,
-0.0291204527,
-0.0082906317,
0.0357678235,
-0.0400675051,
0.0237243474,
-0.0035711571,
-0.0495827533,
0.0522396602,
-0.0511335582,
-0.0108287912,
0.0105270213,
2.316e-7,
-0.024077652,
0.0040829252,
0.0494986996,
-0.0250503961,
0.0063325516,
0.0493547209,
0.0079798717,
0.05057,
-0.0079560308,
-0.1013268307,
0.0367550962,
0.0478951186,
0.0195883736,
0.0066646896,
-0.0290898755,
-0.0105441147,
-0.0779710263,
-0.0461759195,
-0.0409313925,
-0.020489648,
0.0336763561,
0.0493085384,
0.0110203261,
0.013944054,
0.0163665786,
-0.0380272269,
0.0322035477,
-0.0064796754,
-0.022920778,
-0.0009157949,
0.0193003975,
-0.0199943408,
-0.0103784511,
-0.0089584189,
0.0011924128,
-0.0086963084,
0.0460950434,
0.0700949132,
-0.0000793171,
-0.0512238964,
-0.0329970531,
0.0250227973,
-0.0123865046,
0.004708597,
0.0380653217,
-0.0217644535,
-0.0347400159,
-0.0346767269,
-0.0327651836,
-0.0075878655,
-0.0322166793,
0.0094464933,
-0.029814966,
0.0264727399,
0.0165715553,
-0.0287302639,
-0.0029941488,
-0.0969781205,
0.000531257,
-0.0119964583,
-0.0617267564,
0.0084339371,
0.0098837689,
-0.0093671633,
0.0410215408,
-0.0140621075,
-0.0627523959,
1.528841524e-34,
0.0131348921,
0.0015237242,
-0.012275828,
-0.017299382,
0.0185634494,
-0.0060307453,
-0.0328499004,
-0.0308903474,
0.0090480447,
-0.0074676289,
0.0129892686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18752v1 | GPT4Tools: Teaching Large Language Model to Use Tools via Self-instruction | 2023-05-30T05:27:21 | 2023-05-30T05:27:21 | Rui Yang, Lin Song, Yanwei Li, Sijie Zhao, Yixiao Ge, Xiu Li, Ying Shan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper aims to efficiently enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to use
multimodal tools. Advanced proprietary LLMs, such as ChatGPT and GPT-4, have
shown great potential for tool usage through sophisticated prompt engineering.
Nevertheless, these models typically rely on prohibitive computational costs
and publicly inaccessible data. To address these challenges, we propose the
GPT4Tools based on self-instruct to enable open-source LLMs, such as LLaMA and
OPT, to use tools. It generates an instruction-following dataset by prompting
an advanced teacher with various multi-modal contexts. By using the Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) optimization, our approach facilitates the open-source LLMs
to solve a range of visual problems, including visual comprehension and image
generation. Moreover, we provide a benchmark to evaluate the ability of LLMs to
use tools, which is performed in both zero-shot and fine-tuning ways. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on various language
models, which not only significantly improves the accuracy of invoking seen
tools, but also enables the zero-shot capacity for unseen tools. The code and
demo are available at https://github.com/StevenGrove/GPT4Tools. | [
-0.0072865784,
0.0424494669,
-0.0332164168,
0.0853398591,
-0.0199696533,
0.0017185587,
0.0326235965,
-0.0145480288,
0.0240680501,
-0.0324529037,
-0.0573081374,
-0.0037887024,
-0.0270191599,
0.0047709718,
0.0306065809,
-0.0919464901,
0.0246521812,
-0.0605355762,
-0.084457159,
-0.00154022,
-0.0196070895,
0.0195131823,
-0.0351281911,
0.0322946571,
0.0143835805,
-0.046557866,
-0.0604518391,
0.0269542802,
0.0150429616,
-0.0165879335,
-0.0177409239,
0.0761323273,
0.0415460989,
0.0573619604,
0.0000023899,
-0.0427768119,
-0.0175409075,
-0.0213936064,
0.0128174145,
0.0244406592,
0.0488136709,
0.0113206767,
-0.0182648133,
0.0191694275,
-0.0269277729,
0.0065221367,
0.0578157902,
-0.031153813,
0.1006916761,
0.0552118346,
0.0217864811,
0.0188185293,
0.0028625953,
-0.0129781766,
0.0237645842,
-0.0199696198,
0.0029120813,
-0.0014423562,
0.025813939,
0.0223205313,
-0.0483940616,
0.0550194979,
0.0556803718,
-0.0207534935,
-0.018183874,
0.0258193091,
-0.0090348143,
-0.0224824417,
-0.0360808149,
0.0848632604,
-0.0098234201,
-0.0169277545,
-0.0112565476,
-0.0095225768,
0.0193982944,
0.0142430943,
-0.0822381228,
0.0421687067,
-0.0031336339,
0.0134200081,
-0.0204963908,
-0.0463304855,
-0.0135732582,
0.0083062435,
0.0210863296,
0.0052082897,
0.0312201418,
0.0091918455,
-0.0214776415,
0.0014210193,
-0.0253788475,
-0.0394203626,
-0.0117642246,
0.0593060851,
-0.0269341487,
0.0470118262,
-0.0677829087,
-0.0097757922,
0.0091470219,
-0.0042786426,
0.0690047666,
0.063181676,
-0.0619405992,
0.0344206467,
-0.0505399182,
0.0384162255,
-0.0051546833,
0.0440184884,
-0.0336026959,
0.0297469255,
-0.0404515304,
0.0012579174,
-0.0466215834,
-0.0289639346,
-0.0664589331,
0.0168360043,
-0.0350097194,
0.0522129834,
-0.0158022307,
-0.0041191173,
0.003886543,
-0.0137503194,
-0.0639831573,
-0.014547606,
-0.0278065316,
0.0289135091,
-0.0044018836,
0.0010207687,
-0.0099209985,
-0.0732104331,
-0.032098759,
0.0292863753,
-0.0031390896,
-0.0190741662,
0.0028355476,
0.1112019569,
-0.0605386309,
-0.0242990982,
-0.0436137766,
-0.0269943178,
0.0144128967,
-0.0466366708,
0.0206909403,
-0.0783740208,
0.0133993886,
0.0017081524,
0.0138447527,
-0.0298248455,
0.0046391478,
0.0107273916,
0.0168408584,
0.0483430587,
-0.0071333712,
0.0011774835,
0.0354297757,
0.0286842827,
-0.023165267,
0.077932924,
0.0121317627,
0.0289764274,
0.0076805446,
-0.0335201547,
0.0035617007,
0.0704618245,
0.0183914658,
0.0437511913,
-0.0296171773,
-0.004683964,
0.0189457219,
0.0350090303,
0.0450650491,
0.0284459535,
-0.0177191161,
-0.0221539307,
0.0473854579,
0.0170527995,
0.0298581216,
0.0181207992,
0.0619125739,
0.0145924157,
0.0181737766,
0.0087579126,
-0.054036662,
0.0490810983,
-0.0545430034,
0.0017898873,
0.0019290131,
0.04774905,
-0.0149199218,
-0.0426378064,
0.0052871648,
0.0085010864,
-0.0401213206,
0.0055202916,
0.0576548055,
0.0143867657,
-0.0398531184,
-0.019358281,
0.0397339575,
-0.0589380711,
-0.0033756916,
-0.0817110166,
0.0228230152,
0.041625604,
0.0361445434,
-0.0175029598,
-0.0560154319,
-0.0052553769,
0.0182911474,
0.0434528925,
0.0190782268,
0.005932657,
0.0128881186,
-0.0490717366,
-0.0345219485,
-0.020501744,
-0.0041359109,
0.0711011663,
0.0190046877,
-0.0039511081,
0.0101263709,
-0.0472581834,
-0.0002389705,
0.0497700535,
-0.0182922296,
-0.0575180911,
-0.028692143,
0.0011656352,
0.0174717195,
0.0051222579,
-0.0026377891,
-0.0200978536,
0.0259458572,
-0.0113217114,
0.0260535348,
-0.0112411864,
-0.0594305731,
-0.0296888165,
0.0381357521,
-0.0410439074,
-0.0185727663,
0.0216682255,
-0.0378110223,
-0.0520507097,
0.0338722095,
-0.0129283573,
0.0150169879,
-0.047654707,
0.0063084248,
0.0135140596,
0.0082177352,
-0.0340754464,
0.0515179448,
0.0093172481,
-0.0055195889,
0.047030583,
0.0306330994,
0.0023785303,
-0.0441169776,
-0.0171613786,
0.0070946887,
0.0043579177,
0.0361466855,
-0.0294319652,
0.0695553273,
-0.067913644,
-0.0280731693,
-0.0846023783,
0.0131245172,
-0.0247709639,
0.0010818458,
0.021651879,
-0.0064753336,
-0.0342034735,
-0.0355436951,
-0.0212349929,
0.0662451237,
-0.0157180391,
-0.0003788507,
-0.0026923053,
0.0027936106,
-0.0211282056,
-0.0313786939,
-0.0072591202,
-0.0068015275,
-0.0037699861,
0.0071236226,
0.0230724961,
-0.0281607676,
0.0589313246,
-0.0151050976,
0.0397963971,
-0.0151770767,
-0.0263240784,
0.0229952335,
-0.0367140174,
0.0485810526,
0.0658732429,
-0.0107265068,
0.0548687615,
0.067752108,
-0.0241353083,
-0.0725040436,
0.0372285992,
0.0083795097,
-0.0812053308,
0.0030929414,
-0.0071903043,
-0.0162748285,
0.0470228456,
0.0116581712,
-0.0081521291,
-0.0463453494,
0.0268867221,
0.0125235682,
-0.0294569563,
-0.0442072488,
0.043569997,
-0.0202184115,
0.0140805934,
0.0057889041,
-0.0657662079,
0.061167337,
-0.057523258,
-0.0289918426,
0.0028726805,
-0.011933689,
-0.0323861912,
0.0571771003,
0.0236719958,
0.0159794111,
-0.0029613075,
-0.0047853622,
-0.068169415,
0.0260872263,
0.0410366282,
-0.0248346142,
0.0116008911,
-0.075024344,
0.0008903228,
-0.0483320057,
-0.0035803029,
-0.0271736961,
-0.0035321792,
0.0002557436,
-0.0203909501,
-0.0299009476,
-0.0286172424,
0.0178322867,
0.0026182074,
0.0419364721,
0.0573379099,
-0.0155867171,
-0.0083978977,
-0.0426313579,
0.0264935009,
0.036308594,
0.026020376,
-0.0597577728,
-0.0505006611,
0.0426572748,
0.0381401442,
0.0422493145,
-0.0324017033,
-0.0450645164,
0.039108865,
0.0380504914,
0.019112533,
0.005755554,
0.0377778076,
0.0623439439,
-0.0613452196,
0.0086240387,
0.0661159381,
0.0231811199,
-0.0476369224,
-0.0229308549,
-0.0055371565,
0.0547653362,
0.0383386426,
0.0486883856,
-0.1126038954,
-0.0475273766,
-0.0046607084,
0.0301191434,
0.0053477907,
-0.0298969597,
-0.0332694463,
-0.1333874017,
0.0584912598,
0.0214324296,
-0.0485172234,
0.0279001705,
-0.0155679053,
0.0353161059,
0.0068578194,
0.006821346,
0.0218247175,
-0.0260036308,
0.0250941776,
0.0122329379,
0.0468919724,
-0.0439438559,
0.0002637565,
0.0229280107,
0.0538589321,
0.0348725282,
-0.0122203762,
-0.0134110488,
-0.0298818797,
0.0575378947,
0.0132935243,
-0.0009446208,
-0.0386233255,
0.0391357765,
0.0050871344,
-0.0299865082,
0.0072942427,
0.0658390671,
-0.0119974101,
-0.0060732528,
0.0293737072,
0.084514603,
0.0003856644,
-0.0031432235,
-0.0163337216,
-0.0283128023,
0.0105006639,
0.0381873213,
0.0335590839,
-0.021164814,
0.0002944868,
-0.0537874661,
-0.0161005277,
-0.0381748453,
-0.0382456407,
0.0215410274,
-0.0233140495,
-0.0036845666,
-0.0287380163,
-0.019708205,
0.0797187462,
0.0398988612,
0.0113515658,
-0.0289380439,
-0.0375645943,
0.0276765618,
-0.0402464643,
0.0616147742,
-0.0481884591,
0.001799533,
-0.0735890344,
-0.0597967505,
0.0072258417,
-0.0629383698,
0.000054347,
0.0495311841,
-0.0319287144,
-0.074242346,
-0.0290103201,
0.058761023,
0.0236264188,
0.0381512158,
0.016353203,
-0.0442242511,
0.0337160118,
0.0494135097,
0.0174334794,
0.0109718135,
0.0132297063,
0.0091933766,
-0.0086428504,
0.0188982915,
-0.0142293684,
0.0205906462,
0.0070688999,
0.0143747851,
0.011432643,
-0.0296564642,
0.0445174091,
0.0175900403,
0.0073677325,
-0.0181142129,
0.0006681469,
-0.0662061423,
0.0119455261,
-0.0106220124,
0.0026235364,
-0.0723848119,
0.0112779634,
0.0093213888,
-0.0484377742,
0.0373967513,
-0.0322137699,
0.0112311058,
0.0187365804,
-0.0481681041,
0.0308942664,
0.0182995386,
-0.0086285537,
0.0247477442,
0.0378573649,
-0.0028485111,
0.000107337,
0.0125867575,
0.0503584556,
0.0048921956,
0.1026168317,
-0.0086811054,
0.0020822037,
0.0143260788,
0.0270674359,
-0.0222680587,
-0.085139215,
-0.05586363,
0.0592439733,
0.042271439,
0.0246964078,
0.0381717756,
-0.0445408896,
-0.008021066,
-0.0159108881,
0.03653441,
0.0098224431,
-0.0166908968,
0.05136526,
0.0291755628,
0.0375215039,
-0.0256665759,
0.0657305494,
0.0088122413,
0.0493064225,
0.0154381432,
0.0447167233,
-0.066526562,
-0.0343668275,
0.0443647765,
-0.0032688719,
0.0222661477,
0.0325946771,
0.0025782655,
-0.0751371011,
-0.0719148591,
0.0351835787,
-0.0475681089,
-0.0299328212,
0.0467571616,
0.0415253937,
-0.0249203127,
0.0063659637,
-0.0114786057,
0.02266041,
0.0035539775,
-0.0312582515,
0.0097043021,
-6.528847704e-33,
-0.0756716952,
-0.0324577838,
0.056520056,
0.0159885306,
0.0121738454,
-0.0121048698,
-0.0493768863,
0.0374644808,
-0.0088737356,
-0.0090861563,
0.0080304425,
-0.0224301033,
0.0106193498,
0.0302527454,
0.0052922759,
0.0260900743,
0.0277982503,
-0.0096345451,
-0.0203104075,
0.0482018478,
0.0187849626,
-0.0007962678,
0.0509250835,
-0.0264781807,
-0.0028623564,
-0.0023478218,
-0.0245373677,
0.0259084292,
-0.0363095179,
0.0532619171,
-0.038692262,
0.0591967106,
0.014852345,
-0.0161584355,
-0.0165759213,
0.007233297,
-0.0436255373,
-0.0507982783,
0.0040036775,
0.0054452079,
-0.0806649625,
-0.0317270197,
0.0275329687,
-0.0160363819,
-0.0214695595,
-0.0205870289,
0.0310440771,
-0.0061835288,
0.0065248688,
0.0367076471,
-0.0551524721,
0.0220836848,
-0.0424673893,
-0.0746979192,
0.0175248161,
0.0377243273,
0.014806062,
-0.0073191458,
-0.0104868067,
0.0325795226,
0.0686360598,
0.0451490767,
0.106167309,
0.0263813268,
-0.0188533049,
0.0178769566,
0.0360366926,
-0.0551540703,
0.0172824208,
-0.0238025282,
0.0292543918,
0.0554426722,
0.011623973,
0.0540138707,
-0.0158055257,
0.0426591076,
-0.0244465433,
0.0445986018,
0.0273493789,
0.0256642997,
0.0051245443,
0.0077327969,
-0.0090597393,
0.0057478198,
-0.0343768187,
-0.0547336005,
-0.0480341353,
-0.0236646496,
0.0441174768,
-0.0080671767,
-0.0024789935,
-0.0469769686,
0.0381987095,
-0.0053273099,
0.0117535116,
-0.0109575223,
-0.0357264541,
0.0448701456,
0.0013312127,
0.0541293435,
-0.0079422137,
-0.0419737026,
0.0332539603,
-0.0291314609,
0.0182579141,
0.0057204035,
-0.0009947725,
0.0262595452,
-0.0646142662,
0.0133776302,
-0.0835186094,
0.0232499987,
0.0036009115,
0.0026952683,
0.0042932322,
-0.0404864848,
-0.0409275442,
0.0284409057,
0.01723288,
-0.0371155478,
-0.0508195162,
-0.0454423502,
-0.0236347094,
-0.0005621704,
-0.0427753851,
0.012632451,
-0.0239034947,
-0.0218074955,
0.0360150002,
-0.0532840304,
-0.005646436,
-0.0069879387,
3.026e-7,
0.0255949162,
0.0218585171,
-0.0096929055,
0.0121198166,
0.0122164888,
0.03876739,
-0.0516172536,
0.030247882,
0.0316939391,
-0.0361216441,
-0.0151681555,
0.0402479246,
0.0383610576,
0.02858386,
-0.027592402,
0.0270652901,
0.0011587155,
0.0310859382,
-0.0769468173,
0.0214978494,
0.059113998,
0.0504005849,
-0.0197671391,
-0.0239982754,
0.0167924948,
-0.0250483174,
0.0517772771,
-0.0320171043,
-0.0209943186,
-0.0024123534,
0.0095716221,
0.0243354235,
-0.0192971341,
-0.0060929065,
0.0017680743,
-0.0039611785,
-0.0251759049,
0.0641639829,
-0.0013578344,
-0.0157488398,
0.0442285463,
0.0081519252,
-0.023024777,
-0.0549494661,
0.0656994879,
-0.0179991815,
0.0029399341,
0.0165648833,
0.0044644382,
-0.0302504897,
-0.0029519168,
-0.0560556501,
-0.0247763265,
0.0041083232,
0.008198292,
-0.0313571617,
-0.0353296027,
-0.0272012241,
-0.022500746,
-0.0080932509,
-0.0530300774,
-0.058046855,
-0.0688731298,
-0.0090277847,
-0.0086183036,
-0.0368990488,
-0.0017533784,
2.800979878e-34,
0.0088281343,
0.0066172238,
0.054894805,
0.020878084,
0.0072412263,
0.0009623456,
-0.0018123694,
0.0272023957,
0.0259751212,
-0.085863933,
-0.0635255575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18747v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18747v1 | Adapting Multi-Lingual ASR Models for Handling Multiple Talkers | 2023-05-30T05:05:52 | 2023-05-30T05:05:52 | Chenda Li, Yao Qian, Zhuo Chen, Naoyuki Kanda, Dongmei Wang, Takuya Yoshioka, Yanmin Qian, Michael Zeng | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | State-of-the-art large-scale universal speech models (USMs) show a decent
automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance across multiple domains and
languages. However, it remains a challenge for these models to recognize
overlapped speech, which is often seen in meeting conversations. We propose an
approach to adapt USMs for multi-talker ASR. We first develop an enhanced
version of serialized output training to jointly perform multi-talker ASR and
utterance timestamp prediction. That is, we predict the ASR hypotheses for all
speakers, count the speakers, and estimate the utterance timestamps at the same
time. We further introduce a lightweight adapter module to maintain the
multilingual property of the USMs even when we perform the adaptation with only
a single language. Experimental results obtained using the AMI and AliMeeting
corpora show that our proposed approach effectively transfers the USMs to a
strong multilingual multi-talker ASR model with timestamp prediction
capability. | [
-0.0271251276,
0.0518855006,
0.0161318984,
0.0338831954,
-0.0058510737,
-0.0014014639,
0.0574300103,
-0.0243782587,
-0.007536232,
0.0067592347,
-0.0576980338,
-0.081829235,
0.0011513936,
0.0325354412,
0.0092195924,
-0.0171227735,
0.0387060083,
-0.0548791811,
-0.0406832956,
-0.0209443867,
-0.0052542496,
0.0099884961,
-0.0172297861,
0.0222170372,
0.0120891677,
0.0210144706,
-0.0226595048,
-0.0181889106,
0.0203573704,
-0.0141165536,
-0.0226927809,
0.0378226712,
0.0543077849,
0.0272482913,
0.0000019918,
-0.013982797,
-0.0526851714,
0.0059912959,
-0.0574931614,
0.019005971,
0.0039043813,
0.0034063109,
0.0000138505,
0.0557723269,
-0.0227047037,
0.001618256,
0.0250509344,
0.023604406,
0.0070611564,
0.0389029421,
-0.0059575178,
-0.0347358547,
0.0259797107,
-0.0093383705,
-0.0312267449,
-0.0527686961,
0.0012334947,
-0.0060080248,
-0.038946785,
-0.0195177905,
0.011579711,
0.0501102172,
-0.0002211417,
-0.0170330554,
0.0046970942,
-0.0243917089,
-0.0328837633,
-0.0276922416,
-0.0693016425,
0.0323131457,
0.0375365466,
-0.0187420025,
0.0279255137,
0.0112476414,
-0.0589987263,
-0.0352374874,
-0.0344866477,
-0.0103081334,
0.00815563,
0.0039230012,
-0.000942621,
0.0574734695,
0.0037606407,
0.0041975118,
-0.0302857589,
0.0262821633,
0.0024289475,
-0.0056651141,
0.004385754,
-0.017260598,
0.0305830929,
-0.00444854,
0.0612405501,
0.0012427715,
-0.022548601,
-0.0092268409,
0.00267766,
-0.0502942875,
-0.0132123092,
-0.0654557943,
0.0276171509,
0.0493422039,
-0.0326941274,
0.0160968844,
0.0040517156,
0.0544054918,
-0.0096133724,
-0.0347815901,
-0.0112762302,
-0.0329803415,
-0.0173859652,
0.0150599806,
-0.015021327,
-0.0059455186,
-0.0249516666,
-0.0215147212,
-0.0526880808,
0.0321535245,
-0.0170274936,
-0.0330339037,
0.0149894208,
-0.0274123903,
-0.0405870788,
-0.0332137756,
0.0141600855,
0.0784357414,
0.0192966498,
0.0078590773,
-0.025253864,
-0.1078169122,
-0.0050691701,
0.0176702067,
0.0347645842,
0.0237985253,
-0.0213988591,
0.0644422099,
-0.0266642887,
0.0123136053,
-0.0321469419,
-0.0158465486,
-0.0262613799,
-0.0269485973,
0.0177403428,
-0.0558398105,
0.0545653105,
0.0207777657,
0.0357436351,
-0.0073087174,
-0.0060450197,
-0.0668536797,
0.0355665013,
0.0451202802,
0.0451037772,
0.0595439337,
0.0497953855,
-0.02734299,
0.0182731282,
0.0763915032,
0.0157634821,
-0.0355038494,
0.0211372841,
-0.0386242494,
-0.0276826862,
0.0871440247,
-0.007052619,
0.0057592839,
0.0261992682,
-0.0094512533,
0.0390213318,
-0.0018498559,
0.0257798713,
0.01428778,
-0.0084794089,
-0.0177066643,
0.0091933552,
-0.0117016407,
-0.0109724188,
0.0229146443,
0.0536654964,
0.0094018523,
-0.0224711001,
0.0283470973,
0.0090805981,
-0.0143175889,
0.0025070885,
-0.0098721357,
0.0588421337,
0.0573166125,
-0.0315092765,
0.0052850218,
0.0174473803,
-0.0327775031,
-0.0258036423,
0.0382558927,
0.0515091196,
-0.018089667,
-0.0374646261,
0.0764746368,
0.0286020227,
-0.0293587744,
0.0138769029,
-0.0022680708,
-0.027233338,
0.0354310758,
0.000007688,
-0.0152672697,
-0.0355473049,
-0.0266666003,
-0.0119040813,
0.0509409383,
0.010268704,
-0.007512162,
0.0993775129,
-0.0534323826,
-0.015052937,
0.0745682567,
-0.045225516,
0.0946839824,
-0.0112442067,
0.0077955471,
0.0250332914,
0.0108706784,
0.013374459,
-0.0208393317,
-0.0533367209,
0.0031110113,
0.0313382335,
-0.0095131453,
0.0992032439,
0.0451975167,
-0.0336380228,
-0.0298180133,
0.0589130111,
-0.0272114854,
0.0145366089,
0.0548348203,
-0.1022758111,
-0.0452507436,
0.0720655397,
0.0387072451,
0.0081474939,
0.0291549172,
0.0074833329,
-0.0942059532,
0.0272744428,
-0.0012059412,
0.0453989506,
-0.0575219989,
0.0609232187,
0.043878492,
0.0309826992,
0.031353958,
-0.0195692237,
0.029376328,
-0.0050949669,
0.0084351338,
-0.0434659384,
0.0008747671,
-0.0988167897,
-0.0141358702,
0.0344018936,
-0.0040326118,
-0.0019681249,
0.0130468346,
-0.0145966643,
-0.0022205382,
-0.0015445364,
-0.110881038,
-0.0151107674,
-0.007232538,
0.0182276685,
-0.0305517428,
0.0342108123,
0.0052136951,
-0.0561493188,
-0.0406767875,
-0.0358627327,
0.0338673852,
-0.0016511093,
-0.0573825017,
0.0298356656,
-0.0328917019,
-0.0034234896,
0.0126056736,
-0.0100088287,
0.0275294706,
-0.0180708766,
-0.0808012038,
-0.0346584655,
-0.0142899575,
0.0105050253,
0.0455500968,
-0.0108768139,
0.0028984507,
-0.0482388251,
0.0249248426,
0.013000601,
0.012086858,
0.0158391129,
-0.0061573503,
-0.0000884978,
-0.0316183902,
-0.0617217422,
0.0090412311,
-0.0058061727,
0.0141037898,
-0.0341888145,
-0.0084522069,
0.0091033122,
0.0407499336,
0.0078320075,
0.0458268821,
-0.0333983265,
-0.0671099797,
-0.0013526883,
-0.0731924772,
-0.0050353357,
-0.0341661125,
-0.0433414318,
-0.000411205,
0.0226884671,
-0.0307104178,
0.0045716683,
-0.0884012505,
-0.0465653539,
-0.0102684768,
-0.0538778529,
-0.0361417569,
0.0205654949,
0.012792524,
0.0297009051,
-0.0024319475,
-0.0432670861,
-0.0213394668,
-0.004579823,
0.019480262,
-0.0502050444,
0.0184566528,
-0.013838754,
0.0012844577,
-0.0149876894,
-0.0443619713,
-0.0113754086,
-0.0006113694,
-0.045662228,
0.039294865,
-0.0293270424,
-0.0206055734,
-0.0594910458,
0.0506022088,
0.0040144161,
0.0175308734,
-0.0147603918,
0.0437353775,
0.0007905335,
0.0506648719,
0.0446150899,
0.0377211981,
-0.0594034009,
-0.0473201871,
0.0488825217,
-0.0305601917,
0.0600155741,
0.0027196012,
-0.0331438854,
-0.0303204078,
0.0445526727,
0.0178031903,
-0.0137031609,
-0.008510734,
0.0344265662,
-0.0209075622,
0.063778162,
0.1270448416,
-0.004782998,
-0.0304214377,
-0.0322133489,
-0.0352070369,
0.0373909771,
-0.0181717258,
0.0252477191,
-0.0677966624,
-0.0230047777,
0.0089567769,
0.0205571465,
-0.0068083922,
0.0215905886,
-0.0159241576,
-0.0938111097,
0.0126995919,
0.0465722941,
-0.0673873574,
-0.0044829524,
-0.0293855295,
-0.0442456231,
-0.0437289998,
0.0715132803,
-0.0143409185,
-0.0261405017,
-0.0414599665,
0.0744626671,
-0.0837488025,
-0.0531137697,
0.033080291,
-0.0125017483,
0.0884622037,
0.0493364148,
0.027965676,
-0.0174134485,
-0.0087694079,
-0.0074429531,
0.0311447792,
0.0148954447,
-0.0283950511,
-0.0011581603,
-0.0178844128,
0.0030612049,
0.0216226913,
0.0168175548,
0.0257561691,
0.0018723803,
0.0474481098,
0.0412869379,
-0.0164413843,
0.0123640662,
0.0268944465,
0.0200063176,
0.0025250623,
0.0547339208,
-0.0082325721,
-0.0119698066,
0.010410442,
0.0278478339,
0.0653619245,
-0.0165422391,
0.0037709526,
-0.0052950676,
-0.0376981832,
-0.0624663979,
-0.0383996107,
-0.017006889,
0.0277682077,
-0.011998754,
0.02555006,
0.0225358102,
-0.0086024376,
0.0449810997,
-0.0009678346,
-0.0241568778,
-0.0318999514,
0.0262429826,
-0.0827927962,
0.0016522619,
0.0215591621,
-0.0317840427,
-0.0159832183,
0.0608113371,
-0.0695685893,
-0.0947203711,
0.0066540227,
-0.0214623921,
0.0131703829,
0.074339062,
0.0056249495,
-0.0186978113,
0.0661006346,
-0.0116523346,
-0.0022138136,
0.0242089722,
0.0670896322,
0.0327815413,
-0.0356448814,
0.0250407774,
-0.024071645,
0.0420961455,
-0.0505404845,
-0.0016607131,
-0.045696117,
-0.0883482173,
-0.020770086,
0.0564899035,
0.0499871075,
-0.021268338,
0.0054511772,
0.0070677316,
0.0292479247,
-0.0009416539,
0.0514626317,
-0.0605351888,
0.0061929137,
0.0002603813,
0.0135653634,
0.0173806753,
0.0376972966,
-0.0067006187,
-0.0360172205,
0.0097363573,
0.0510753281,
-0.0013988093,
-0.0153873106,
-0.0219749976,
0.0256139748,
-0.0187762249,
-0.0095213922,
0.0743034482,
0.0063972375,
0.0006395194,
0.0317862108,
-0.0203947537,
0.0185768586,
0.0379636697,
0.0098258611,
-0.0700154155,
-0.0132907657,
-0.0212711208,
0.0288453959,
-0.0001132221,
-0.0107940855,
0.0932142884,
-0.0009911287,
0.0506890267,
-0.0716544762,
0.0637160689,
-0.0279869251,
0.0074835187,
0.0214150231,
-0.0115415026,
-0.0363994464,
0.0476306751,
0.0824641585,
-0.0003620214,
0.0221418142,
0.0075945649,
0.00706222,
-0.0368054546,
-0.0335389599,
0.0089038014,
-0.0437424965,
-0.0268724076,
-0.0351991653,
0.0139007131,
-0.0308919922,
0.0513936058,
-0.0123830233,
0.0152788311,
-0.0557765327,
-0.0139185851,
0.0099121528,
-0.038547799,
0.0221762657,
-0.0181557406,
-0.0315762013,
0.0009854141,
0.0213883556,
0.0066725151,
-6.343837383e-33,
-0.0579127185,
0.0133219417,
-0.0109539144,
0.0187113844,
-0.0348661095,
0.015312884,
-0.0086413082,
0.0004295758,
-0.0168348122,
-0.0461315103,
-0.0181184597,
-0.0016228675,
0.0531746075,
0.0029737928,
0.0090461196,
0.0261350628,
0.1016357169,
0.0073021152,
0.0210393332,
0.0142365033,
0.0192704331,
0.0342953503,
0.0403785706,
-0.0444293059,
-0.0496683009,
0.0172818843,
-0.0087113464,
-0.0116714463,
0.0488182269,
0.0147434948,
0.0107829655,
0.0437541045,
-0.016357651,
-0.0422695167,
-0.0319325477,
0.0529535413,
-0.0681448206,
0.0080954395,
-0.0127195418,
0.0599849783,
0.0525897183,
0.0070788544,
-0.0262801722,
-0.0151286237,
-0.0205700677,
-0.0171329863,
0.0274191555,
-0.0141859939,
-0.0461865179,
-0.0223159548,
0.03328152,
0.0591953732,
-0.0211551841,
-0.0004556304,
0.0706698,
0.0653720275,
0.0162750222,
-0.0476094671,
-0.0378801897,
0.0674331486,
0.0249041393,
0.0162624959,
0.0392595269,
0.0475632921,
0.0197712593,
0.0496257618,
0.0401351377,
-0.0562177934,
0.0435431562,
-0.0413951166,
-0.0011895918,
0.0205573905,
-0.0098357992,
0.0516990088,
-0.0004455159,
-0.0054661417,
-0.0153852087,
0.0139895165,
0.0651871562,
0.000636188,
0.0317592621,
0.0294253416,
-0.0114202416,
0.0130809397,
-0.029691508,
0.0163234323,
0.0200533252,
-0.0464791507,
0.0316775441,
-0.007113752,
-0.0037265255,
0.0389092192,
0.093138434,
-0.0384913981,
0.0070313402,
0.0006386198,
-0.0084561557,
-0.0275180396,
-0.0250912067,
0.0390724726,
-0.0468688495,
-0.0483524762,
0.0288556591,
-0.001431374,
-0.0048279613,
-0.041098658,
-0.0106462492,
0.0596598797,
-0.0616516508,
-0.0148788653,
-0.0074398727,
-0.00102963,
-0.012047749,
0.0285332836,
0.0521097369,
-0.0175377019,
-0.0166551303,
0.0266653392,
-0.0217633154,
0.0232138112,
-0.0036631469,
-0.0371819511,
0.0331623256,
0.0502944738,
-0.0601672232,
0.0065735453,
-0.0140556544,
-0.0539799854,
0.0535752438,
0.0194583759,
-0.0173406545,
-0.0370183997,
2.83e-7,
-0.045988299,
0.0088677984,
0.0264891554,
-0.0146497488,
0.0050557228,
0.0193719678,
0.0063080247,
0.0163664185,
0.0173387658,
0.0310603231,
0.0213141609,
-0.0149792423,
0.0949578434,
0.0304436889,
-0.0721113533,
-0.0531913526,
-0.0853354037,
0.0060544601,
0.00398057,
0.0044567697,
-0.0014111145,
0.078638047,
-0.0191078838,
-0.0057376623,
-0.0002319756,
-0.0522442646,
0.0474454463,
-0.0371281542,
-0.0475876033,
-0.0035158005,
-0.0197648238,
-0.0265808832,
-0.0283163711,
0.0264641866,
-0.0342453122,
0.0570487529,
0.0114968792,
0.032968197,
-0.0346995629,
-0.0347686335,
0.0063431328,
0.0555222109,
-0.0624489896,
-0.006873908,
0.0345449373,
0.0211405996,
-0.0224639773,
-0.0316174552,
-0.0499568842,
0.0074757584,
0.0111931842,
0.0203766972,
0.0095124496,
0.0315822698,
0.0075802244,
-0.0424630083,
-0.037709754,
-0.003566033,
0.0078180423,
-0.0225189961,
-0.0462533273,
-0.0089377016,
-0.0306757875,
-0.050578516,
-0.0195641611,
-0.0179822501,
0.0245662369,
2.011065123e-34,
0.0407564864,
0.0215284135,
-0.0027407049,
0.0444386266,
0.0014326087,
-0.0732693598,
-0.0259705391,
0.0397513174,
0.0025680237,
-0.0464097112,
-0.0344000384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18742v1 | Graph Reasoning for Question Answering with Triplet Retrieval | 2023-05-30T04:46:28 | 2023-05-30T04:46:28 | Shiyang Li, Yifan Gao, Haoming Jiang, Qingyu Yin, Zheng Li, Xifeng Yan, Chao Zhang, Bing Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering complex questions often requires reasoning over knowledge graphs
(KGs). State-of-the-art methods often utilize entities in questions to retrieve
local subgraphs, which are then fed into KG encoder, e.g. graph neural networks
(GNNs), to model their local structures and integrated into language models for
question answering. However, this paradigm constrains retrieved knowledge in
local subgraphs and discards more diverse triplets buried in KGs that are
disconnected but useful for question answering. In this paper, we propose a
simple yet effective method to first retrieve the most relevant triplets from
KGs and then rerank them, which are then concatenated with questions to be fed
into language models. Extensive results on both CommonsenseQA and OpenbookQA
datasets show that our method can outperform state-of-the-art up to 4.6%
absolute accuracy. | [
0.0374855809,
0.0219501518,
0.0192985442,
0.0537602119,
-0.0185762998,
0.0034359673,
-0.0291732643,
0.0150624895,
0.0854859054,
-0.031910371,
0.0167714301,
0.0360569097,
-0.0267428774,
0.026466215,
0.0338839181,
-0.013383734,
0.0332753919,
0.0033781603,
0.0106626255,
-0.0281896014,
0.0136972256,
0.0685755387,
-0.0144253634,
-0.0068971752,
0.0015097855,
-0.015602015,
-0.0117968954,
0.0351003706,
0.0000117489,
0.0123454537,
-0.0010205653,
0.0049460935,
0.0342723168,
-0.0085170669,
0.0000016855,
-0.0234391335,
-0.035594631,
0.0013329589,
-0.0356651209,
-0.0045019779,
-0.0624449961,
0.0083253412,
0.0605105534,
0.0075103426,
-0.0622575991,
-0.0022849792,
-0.0040164953,
0.0126982639,
0.0664312467,
0.0489302278,
-0.0044480735,
-0.0307644866,
-0.0260650497,
0.009924083,
0.0024612288,
-0.0442520082,
0.0274129771,
0.0694781244,
0.0407260694,
0.0119538428,
-0.0191145595,
0.0232533347,
0.0354444571,
0.0108959004,
0.0025569033,
0.0192028042,
-0.055867184,
0.0518943928,
0.019606974,
0.1354380697,
-0.0019556568,
-0.0028347801,
-0.003133903,
-0.0025692338,
0.0035052926,
0.0332358517,
-0.04470139,
-0.0408349037,
-0.0169059951,
-0.0130165583,
-0.0514456779,
-0.0354429297,
0.0393700749,
-0.0070869653,
-0.0341726877,
0.0908132941,
0.0063743968,
0.0047534127,
0.0322415829,
0.0056234421,
-0.0617797375,
-0.0068122,
0.016213933,
0.0437383987,
0.0072571323,
0.0194489434,
0.0203815475,
0.0066089514,
-0.0234403312,
-0.0020600618,
-0.045676209,
0.0158614758,
0.0042269807,
0.0787339732,
-0.0174804237,
0.0474386215,
-0.023867052,
0.0726971105,
-0.0459281057,
-0.0298763756,
-0.0411080755,
-0.0253236853,
-0.0469362289,
0.0535019189,
-0.0342986174,
-0.0275086742,
-0.0059703016,
-0.0053339433,
0.0014883288,
-0.0091692172,
0.0782436132,
0.0838977993,
0.0210405011,
-0.0380113423,
-0.013699118,
0.0592510961,
-0.0555735342,
0.0042545125,
-0.0211364292,
-0.0185815822,
-0.0344537273,
-0.0151957991,
0.0585082583,
-0.036837358,
-0.0117155872,
0.0433250628,
0.0091552874,
-0.0023235884,
-0.0105546536,
-0.0453866832,
0.0135170203,
-0.0266300365,
0.0237545315,
-0.0650853142,
0.0505423695,
0.0122407442,
-0.0125507489,
-0.0284060612,
0.0128634386,
-0.0033071658,
-0.0448655821,
0.0534679182,
-0.0435774922,
-0.0262707528,
-0.0021053064,
0.0086180698,
-0.0060064271,
0.0252436548,
0.021157844,
-0.007925977,
0.0487001985,
0.0105369361,
-0.0374366492,
0.0173755493,
0.0538172908,
-0.0036529857,
0.0225226134,
0.0367677249,
-0.0476075634,
0.0199333131,
-0.0084012523,
0.0471620746,
-0.0520166494,
-0.0296826251,
0.0091806939,
0.0477902293,
-0.0081260158,
0.0085971728,
0.0239362866,
0.0268045925,
-0.0031835756,
0.0216409508,
-0.0042278687,
0.0179115683,
0.0007041126,
0.0202191174,
0.0131243682,
-0.0043079159,
-0.0091125779,
-0.0147517547,
-0.0033570495,
0.0082814926,
0.0142054353,
0.037952587,
0.0495796539,
0.0055266311,
-0.0175322164,
0.024510134,
0.036415305,
-0.0145944003,
0.0237876065,
0.0115512153,
0.0067599486,
0.0534183867,
0.0418142043,
-0.0126533518,
-0.0467290767,
0.0155024845,
-0.0311338305,
-0.035433393,
-0.0004377024,
-0.0447589606,
0.0072743078,
-0.067162782,
-0.0256569814,
-0.032557901,
-0.0381864198,
0.0082408115,
0.048431199,
0.0291297007,
0.0051917797,
-0.0963015705,
0.0462606139,
-0.0286185667,
-0.0056164553,
-0.0154012265,
0.0119940247,
0.028316034,
-0.0303467195,
0.0281457193,
0.0250029601,
0.0270059556,
0.0128434785,
-0.0234950446,
-0.032408651,
-0.0123296799,
-0.024687767,
-0.1064181551,
0.0322081931,
0.0118480232,
-0.0120797837,
0.0308781844,
-0.0487802327,
-0.0532119088,
0.031624537,
-0.0343470834,
0.0546281002,
-0.0071206866,
-0.0711133927,
0.0539078303,
-0.0257543307,
-0.0269649997,
0.0826874375,
-0.012374348,
0.0082588932,
-0.0036123605,
-0.0293856598,
0.00628212,
-0.028590342,
0.0044905287,
0.0372233652,
0.0089492071,
0.0031427424,
0.0194430761,
-0.0045412262,
-0.0745329782,
0.0293571819,
-0.0654889569,
0.0165989101,
-0.0151700079,
0.02321814,
-0.0020486596,
0.0223570317,
0.0257512555,
-0.0354520455,
-0.0728783235,
0.0278309491,
0.0060429154,
0.0080698663,
0.0409445465,
-0.0032161674,
0.0167417806,
-0.004169838,
-0.0677408129,
-0.0270922426,
0.0924477056,
-0.0201613028,
-0.000228446,
0.0239189882,
0.0106376242,
-0.0780460984,
0.0300226044,
-0.011419368,
0.0351964086,
0.0004401586,
-0.0474547483,
0.0105805779,
0.0576976798,
-0.0645484775,
0.0005218737,
-0.0038835357,
-0.0254104193,
-0.0785144493,
0.0212053228,
-0.0506870337,
-0.0130840214,
-0.0210813638,
0.004201605,
-0.0449642316,
-0.0174293071,
0.0220907237,
-0.0456788838,
-0.0619654283,
0.0260257702,
0.0186120179,
0.0326796286,
-0.0646975189,
-0.002233603,
0.0341809429,
0.0055765025,
-0.0433498994,
0.0186598171,
0.0852556899,
0.0197760835,
0.0027015728,
-0.0074865511,
0.0241845772,
-0.0680990815,
0.0667232946,
0.0002917427,
0.0046363799,
-0.0237806458,
-0.0543497875,
-0.030753905,
-0.0363363102,
0.0239296872,
-0.033855509,
0.002602431,
-0.0115081314,
0.0484328791,
0.0200828761,
-0.0300856996,
0.0146406721,
0.0265663322,
-0.0313775949,
0.0385638513,
-0.0348302647,
-0.0139224352,
0.0084473174,
-0.0138080707,
0.0124865388,
0.0032171044,
-0.0379187651,
0.0099396305,
-0.0251694657,
0.0972027555,
0.0487224869,
0.0412360393,
0.0066577806,
0.0002861848,
0.0000618784,
0.08114402,
0.0335701481,
-0.0150665818,
0.004722748,
0.040270552,
0.0175254047,
-0.0251448601,
-0.0083339838,
-0.0331301242,
0.0464176796,
-0.0555450954,
-0.0162384156,
0.076908946,
0.0179559998,
-0.0118883718,
-0.0070426175,
0.0024768505,
0.0117201544,
0.026989948,
0.0087477835,
-0.1018704027,
-0.041464746,
-0.0122845983,
0.0427189916,
0.025377186,
-0.0518931411,
0.0056767804,
-0.0937027708,
-0.0082874447,
0.003757389,
-0.0151907653,
-0.0545112155,
-0.0280157253,
-0.0080120573,
-0.0192182641,
-0.0363616981,
-0.0008478854,
0.0053876219,
0.031369891,
0.0092148362,
0.0295486078,
-0.014575528,
0.0337798931,
-0.0121874521,
-0.0263963882,
-0.0109590925,
0.0276879463,
0.024718659,
-0.0202931874,
-0.0116721857,
-0.0256422237,
-0.0318125524,
-0.0056284075,
-0.0012624541,
-0.0062517854,
-0.0174787007,
-0.0446361639,
0.0280915536,
-0.0641303137,
-0.0155565105,
-0.0201519933,
0.0750000626,
0.0102448734,
-0.0376939103,
0.0056624976,
-0.0071429475,
-0.0327701792,
0.0202908497,
0.0300025009,
0.0550870001,
-0.0237250961,
-0.0368750729,
0.0156802237,
-0.0555355363,
-0.0338529609,
0.0550560132,
0.0225934591,
0.0302983783,
-0.0577442758,
-0.031797234,
0.0516980253,
0.0255739298,
-0.0222398657,
0.0164443366,
0.0693927109,
0.0140682459,
-0.0607090555,
0.0554629639,
-0.0348423421,
-0.0056836079,
0.0157220066,
0.0124659352,
0.0184503738,
-0.0100882743,
-0.0513084158,
-0.0130026061,
-0.0547859967,
-0.0557140596,
-0.0539194271,
0.0309887808,
0.0111966329,
0.0391970687,
-0.0304320958,
-0.0064032204,
0.0155437859,
0.0102629261,
-0.0277548302,
-0.0067625991,
-0.0149375768,
-0.0073126969,
-0.0183267221,
0.0365176573,
-0.0726687759,
-0.0300000757,
0.0106571494,
0.0649128258,
-0.0480612926,
-0.0299907979,
0.0097235925,
0.0537039191,
-0.0138400951,
0.0689419806,
0.0322982557,
-0.0626955926,
0.0041251807,
-0.0207443126,
-0.0107866414,
-0.0490299463,
0.0040849461,
0.0200903155,
-0.0193713941,
-0.0365017131,
-0.0392894559,
0.0205012485,
0.0287003238,
-0.023451481,
-0.0367089622,
0.0437673554,
-0.0250117891,
0.0353965424,
-0.0440838337,
-0.0366587192,
0.0562682562,
-0.008024402,
0.0355607942,
-0.041274175,
0.0347742662,
0.0439542867,
-0.0400232822,
-0.0266465768,
0.0090465052,
-0.0654220507,
-0.0459775403,
0.0052567809,
0.0019951598,
0.0426421687,
0.0272427332,
0.0018914862,
0.0306757577,
-0.0362490527,
0.0072077634,
0.0275508203,
0.0155598586,
-0.0318637639,
0.0413741283,
0.0431357957,
0.0046599638,
0.0322900936,
0.0368915237,
0.015303486,
0.0144637106,
0.0279212482,
-0.0562579148,
-0.0169896614,
-0.0455627479,
-0.0075178021,
0.0556806996,
0.0124883475,
0.0455994718,
-0.0258356184,
-0.0683034733,
-0.0120479725,
0.0114663886,
-0.0349815525,
0.0124127744,
0.0428397991,
0.0380681492,
0.036986053,
-0.0618235022,
-0.0315341204,
0.0503538698,
-0.093583867,
-0.027193917,
0.0283775162,
-5.725335969e-33,
-0.0142401149,
-0.0531344637,
0.0210286286,
-0.0232274327,
-0.0547910854,
0.01890729,
-0.0386382751,
-0.0280776415,
-0.0547537282,
0.0010917538,
-0.0084290719,
0.0221248399,
-0.0144687817,
0.0336565226,
-0.0313053019,
-0.0424763449,
-0.0327498727,
0.0013173016,
0.0068564238,
0.0378685147,
0.0543074943,
0.0420931205,
0.0807926804,
-0.0204092953,
0.0222742092,
-0.0308730043,
0.0318419784,
0.0380595103,
-0.0329688154,
0.0342813469,
0.003797923,
0.0312044993,
0.0300630052,
-0.012365859,
0.0401588567,
-0.0015169642,
-0.111284852,
-0.0450073816,
0.0101357494,
0.0151918717,
-0.0839598402,
-0.0130206496,
0.0311018173,
-0.0041829115,
0.0684824586,
-0.0520873144,
0.0425876752,
0.0347935446,
-0.0380627997,
-0.025074454,
0.0129484888,
0.0401312299,
-0.0537400581,
0.0004893341,
-0.019931104,
0.0170560256,
-0.0030134916,
0.00656464,
-0.0306419972,
-0.0141998529,
-0.0416994877,
-0.0015362838,
-0.0022878295,
-0.0021200734,
0.0047770641,
0.0425235145,
-0.0287017394,
-0.0413772911,
-0.060280025,
-0.0050280942,
-0.0000524265,
0.0516152345,
0.0103319744,
0.0192023944,
-0.0119680418,
0.0178738888,
-0.1301544905,
0.0075244615,
-0.0147971548,
0.0345491283,
-0.0383079648,
-0.0037269061,
-0.0092690717,
-0.0314468257,
-0.0251304228,
-0.0127158538,
-0.0363906175,
-0.0098289885,
0.00889281,
-0.0321316496,
-0.028047625,
0.0368444249,
-0.0066532553,
-0.0429742113,
0.0136174001,
0.0899919942,
0.0148435859,
0.0050777746,
-0.0091693727,
0.0974432081,
-0.0306262374,
0.0274344366,
0.0060502021,
-0.0273599811,
0.0103827491,
0.038754832,
0.0166010521,
-0.0002873795,
-0.0164025649,
-0.0240231343,
-0.055088535,
-0.0087843342,
-0.0668785572,
0.0219991375,
0.0410080999,
0.0850801393,
0.0200616345,
0.034319438,
0.0235032272,
0.0539707318,
-0.0034659593,
0.0301074833,
0.0392939523,
0.016383633,
-0.0142537393,
-0.0055784499,
-0.0228957571,
0.0088486327,
-0.0204075016,
-0.0394507051,
-0.0029440124,
0.0457500629,
2.482e-7,
0.06336236,
0.0096121076,
0.0412965789,
0.0511992909,
-0.0047024069,
0.0199758559,
0.0142255314,
0.0289690532,
0.0312535428,
-0.0244583078,
0.0144709144,
0.0794489682,
-0.0196670536,
0.0469098762,
-0.074602209,
0.0352776013,
-0.0529637598,
-0.0773453638,
-0.0434254296,
-0.0187556949,
0.0647080168,
0.0306285266,
0.0271252021,
-0.0056444621,
-0.0159452856,
-0.0662555546,
0.049149029,
0.0356714986,
-0.0136687439,
0.0001873271,
0.0403905697,
-0.0008169643,
-0.0033792958,
0.0296632517,
0.0087870071,
0.0438406691,
0.0493261404,
0.0421765,
-0.0210035332,
-0.0589906275,
-0.020069899,
-0.0319713913,
0.0267767049,
-0.0360745378,
0.1136808842,
-0.0197279043,
-0.0298130233,
0.0344947688,
-0.0313771702,
-0.0320329741,
0.0132191088,
-0.0187187269,
0.0039495551,
0.0178363211,
0.0322620012,
-0.0203844607,
0.0401777439,
-0.0836164877,
0.013816908,
-0.0034100376,
-0.0123642348,
-0.033129856,
0.0336742662,
-0.0183216799,
-0.0056139058,
-0.010887594,
0.0130573018,
1.86643914e-34,
0.0116832405,
0.0176648218,
0.0278715324,
0.0019969593,
0.0371611379,
-0.0483788252,
0.003278198,
-0.0277869422,
0.0279132966,
-0.1132833064,
-0.0149023663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18741v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18741v1 | Grokking of Hierarchical Structure in Vanilla Transformers | 2023-05-30T04:34:13 | 2023-05-30T04:34:13 | Shikhar Murty, Pratyusha Sharma, Jacob Andreas, Christopher D. Manning | cs.CL | cs.CL | For humans, language production and comprehension is sensitive to the
hierarchical structure of sentences. In natural language processing, past work
has questioned how effectively neural sequence models like transformers capture
this hierarchical structure when generalizing to structurally novel inputs. We
show that transformer language models can learn to generalize hierarchically
after training for extremely long periods -- far beyond the point when
in-domain accuracy has saturated. We call this phenomenon \emph{structural
grokking}. On multiple datasets, structural grokking exhibits inverted U-shaped
scaling in model depth: intermediate-depth models generalize better than both
very deep and very shallow transformers. When analyzing the relationship
between model-internal properties and grokking, we find that optimal depth for
grokking can be identified using the tree-structuredness metric of
\citet{murty2023projections}. Overall, our work provides strong evidence that,
with extended training, vanilla transformers discover and use hierarchical
structure. | [
0.0359588824,
0.0523581617,
-0.0286326185,
0.0160610117,
-0.031464871,
0.0156541262,
-0.0593645647,
0.003681446,
-0.0416901782,
-0.0369228087,
-0.0254602171,
-0.0588923544,
0.0224566944,
0.025469888,
0.0378709212,
-0.0908847526,
0.046213761,
-0.0602876879,
-0.0206494853,
0.0204279944,
-0.0487044826,
-0.0276657697,
0.0201674253,
0.0447977521,
-0.0028291473,
-0.0278797131,
-0.0302994568,
-0.0227954853,
-0.0168803222,
-0.0350654833,
0.0131838005,
0.0283932667,
0.0115830386,
0.064496927,
0.0000019264,
-0.0081760203,
0.0109233689,
-0.0130986972,
-0.0274270345,
0.0026901662,
-0.0055571003,
-0.0583883896,
-0.0169488043,
-0.0046773478,
-0.0294702891,
-0.0162177086,
0.0313410163,
0.0702994913,
0.0151270013,
0.0585245192,
-0.0012540717,
-0.0938063487,
0.0544597171,
-0.0510028861,
-0.0222322382,
-0.0018614598,
-0.0097282855,
-0.0052970769,
-0.0088159787,
0.0448836721,
-0.0419931412,
-0.0132782217,
0.0323932022,
0.0185081121,
0.0065780203,
0.0408632047,
0.000858341,
-0.0401922502,
0.0104204947,
0.0286496673,
-0.0462868363,
-0.026967233,
-0.0049782866,
-0.013594944,
0.0190639514,
-0.0046327072,
-0.03149461,
0.0484616943,
-0.0018383713,
-0.0026316119,
0.0195675548,
-0.0039682142,
0.0330488309,
-0.0396132357,
-0.0331040435,
0.0972368494,
0.0024606797,
-0.0440656096,
-0.020637678,
-0.012649348,
0.0102003645,
-0.0747491047,
-0.0054707192,
0.0222519655,
-0.0146769164,
0.0187208783,
-0.0072552338,
0.0073090666,
0.0004978315,
-0.0272058491,
0.016701011,
0.0250129513,
-0.0364363417,
-0.0105313463,
-0.0122648897,
0.0880725458,
-0.0456098057,
0.0570412017,
-0.0389794782,
0.0270645339,
-0.0527129322,
-0.0395870805,
-0.0390921794,
0.0144731738,
-0.0282917041,
-0.025797097,
-0.0459896438,
0.0341609009,
0.0439195521,
-0.025093209,
-0.0080678016,
0.0100450693,
-0.0695478246,
0.0117784878,
-0.0210138503,
0.0444742627,
-0.0210095346,
0.02623564,
0.0396266393,
-0.0090204384,
-0.0223657507,
0.010867645,
0.0063005886,
-0.0087528843,
0.0091606332,
0.0720274672,
0.0147329327,
-0.0430484451,
-0.0367270745,
-0.0079302955,
-0.0466337949,
-0.0458214357,
0.0517195128,
-0.0386938043,
-0.0126438616,
0.0047234874,
-0.0080456818,
-0.0012942842,
0.0040107225,
0.0374374986,
-0.0225522891,
0.0417938568,
0.0344058983,
-0.002558908,
0.0002853397,
0.0120662581,
0.0031012616,
0.0207026508,
0.024248803,
0.0317712724,
0.0110048205,
-0.0565306917,
-0.0153864501,
0.022548385,
-0.0137051856,
-0.0445801914,
-0.0002413874,
-0.00342479,
-0.0634331033,
0.0237783976,
0.03278457,
0.0267866533,
-0.0253120195,
-0.0217895415,
0.0551799908,
0.0816912651,
0.0143719949,
0.0250981227,
0.0528429821,
-0.003292219,
-0.0193419401,
0.0741674379,
-0.0498691462,
0.007017029,
0.0117386561,
0.0457875468,
-0.0513263531,
0.0176211577,
-0.0246062148,
-0.0349563621,
-0.0369081795,
0.0099381283,
-0.0099246623,
-0.0468418412,
0.051036559,
0.0861641988,
-0.05605397,
0.0808145106,
0.0176708288,
-0.0408697575,
-0.0007548137,
-0.0260642897,
-0.0104192337,
-0.0051662652,
0.0141851809,
0.0082675647,
-0.0028542404,
0.0027426484,
-0.0385799967,
0.0367599279,
-0.0190971997,
-0.0062889699,
0.0261113197,
-0.007682946,
-0.0137892803,
0.0055084708,
0.0240695588,
0.0012691007,
-0.0190013163,
-0.0743465796,
0.0239323881,
-0.0682915747,
0.0038712784,
0.0411664285,
-0.0555431396,
-0.0040195985,
-0.0138306515,
0.0094513595,
0.0344871841,
-0.0082175275,
0.008374026,
0.0271540843,
0.0440148711,
-0.035327632,
-0.0454990305,
0.0064542461,
-0.0733245388,
-0.027992921,
-0.0117193582,
-0.0562087037,
0.0211915188,
0.0656528845,
-0.0015644371,
-0.0325414725,
0.0290093664,
-0.0591789819,
0.0697765052,
-0.024792796,
0.03894528,
-0.0203143191,
0.0411148295,
-0.0459421352,
0.0660208166,
-0.0298690926,
0.0033725121,
-0.0204630364,
-0.0237021446,
-0.0105605591,
-0.0152153429,
-0.0016601044,
0.0544735342,
-0.0307405386,
-0.0119241877,
0.0123567637,
-0.0219731387,
-0.0431660302,
-0.032143876,
-0.0249655284,
-0.0138319843,
-0.0164345019,
0.0551752187,
0.0240757968,
-0.0089571411,
0.0227418989,
-0.02607923,
-0.0172526129,
0.0031007484,
0.0174955409,
0.0335121565,
0.0608447157,
0.0131857488,
-0.0370941274,
-0.0242719054,
-0.0385402478,
-0.0221949238,
0.0746399164,
-0.018358238,
-0.0025737155,
-0.0575043373,
-0.0122198025,
-0.0056430851,
0.0009702448,
-0.029682776,
-0.0607682168,
0.0005199198,
0.0276399031,
0.0593549348,
0.0541136004,
0.0247699413,
0.0323603973,
0.025595177,
0.0114825508,
0.0115610138,
-0.0053227763,
-0.0429828912,
0.0051623876,
-0.0648662299,
0.0017357174,
0.0229075216,
0.1580625474,
-0.0126701612,
0.0048543606,
-0.0362664126,
-0.0193739422,
-0.0218841992,
0.0039815228,
0.0237714555,
-0.0358452983,
-0.0517975576,
0.0534679666,
-0.0115801673,
-0.048354432,
0.0396565236,
-0.0220723953,
-0.0337567106,
-0.018874038,
0.0040970603,
-0.0384689197,
0.1003758237,
0.0600335561,
-0.0039157919,
0.0494297072,
-0.0516996607,
-0.0632785931,
0.0553718172,
0.0171778481,
0.0108181797,
0.0635278523,
-0.0121308798,
-0.0160432551,
-0.0199430808,
-0.0412126929,
-0.0543560423,
-0.0173258353,
-0.0178611018,
0.0146331871,
0.0406727754,
-0.0365690701,
-0.0594478846,
0.0124608437,
0.0158649776,
0.0530686416,
0.0181020591,
-0.0182390958,
-0.0319581442,
0.0428945273,
0.019526463,
0.0129304267,
0.0517965071,
-0.0330326967,
0.0181007087,
0.0345331617,
-0.0082180705,
0.0348586254,
-0.0200748034,
-0.004482307,
0.0232944414,
-0.0128957778,
-0.064222984,
0.0346069336,
-0.0014718808,
-0.0592496879,
-0.028424453,
0.0640243739,
0.0117357895,
-0.0074334657,
0.0749382302,
-0.0206417907,
0.0837916732,
0.0389860421,
0.0045247343,
-0.0502507761,
-0.0028484636,
0.0184868705,
-0.0200573914,
0.0025760545,
-0.012168576,
0.0294056702,
-0.1092478484,
0.0013993852,
-0.0150255961,
-0.0467097126,
0.004608056,
-0.0260528103,
0.0071769427,
0.0101331351,
0.0255359095,
0.0273104478,
-0.0523135178,
-0.0289937072,
0.0267752651,
-0.0461460128,
-0.0549594164,
0.0451123491,
-0.0010135992,
-0.0031213257,
0.066580072,
0.0211894345,
-0.0147900963,
-0.0309787765,
0.0522318967,
0.0063503236,
0.0381665826,
0.0416764058,
0.0377510563,
0.0257107466,
-0.0058794888,
-0.024008723,
0.0190048795,
-0.0291039534,
0.0061824615,
-0.0332237445,
0.0734172687,
-0.0048443447,
-0.0705506727,
-0.0023621328,
0.0018467748,
-0.0533450022,
0.0308277216,
0.042267859,
-0.0369615406,
-0.0305660106,
-0.0322762281,
0.0431505516,
0.0063307937,
-0.0517836027,
0.0962435976,
0.0399488956,
-0.0197193194,
-0.0972763821,
-0.0298039056,
-0.032216765,
0.0156900045,
-0.0056297388,
-0.0206687264,
0.0204390436,
-0.0285749212,
-0.0234390497,
0.0251324177,
0.0123815648,
-0.0127013093,
-0.0775598586,
0.0167148169,
0.0198948234,
-0.0053618108,
-0.0580597445,
-0.0198538229,
-0.0916345194,
-0.055817578,
0.0405958854,
0.0328922682,
0.0197659992,
0.0211334154,
0.0348555148,
-0.0184623785,
0.029444769,
-0.0124047287,
-0.0401842855,
0.0420324281,
0.0486668348,
-0.0286481809,
-0.0168075506,
0.0538143665,
-0.0273971744,
0.0383484364,
-0.0036475004,
0.0304609612,
0.0308042578,
-0.006914001,
0.0410127044,
-0.0172772445,
0.0473593026,
0.0073562358,
0.0134814689,
0.018547751,
0.0503759794,
-0.0163668059,
0.0012989275,
-0.0238589346,
-0.03290914,
0.0237043332,
0.0215082075,
0.0100164618,
0.0160179082,
-0.0031726966,
0.0589937828,
-0.0095371474,
0.0118742911,
0.031889949,
0.0084585054,
0.0338753164,
0.0312903598,
0.0050085634,
0.0100000976,
-0.0235162973,
0.0321124159,
-0.0015083798,
0.0359177925,
0.0268842224,
0.0326159485,
-0.0517643951,
0.0103471903,
-0.0885924548,
0.0169506371,
-0.0042545209,
-0.055046346,
0.0329670422,
-0.0293865334,
0.0386165045,
-0.0150108524,
0.0107947113,
-0.0041793417,
0.0326946229,
-0.027496038,
-0.0515351407,
0.024841873,
0.0229710843,
-0.0243709963,
-0.0021711159,
0.0889474526,
0.0533799604,
0.0235498827,
-0.0051329439,
0.0256346427,
-0.0316257477,
-0.0171254557,
0.0120155746,
0.0131769665,
-0.0119294608,
0.0060139284,
-0.0671923161,
-0.0553338192,
0.0057237297,
-0.0171815436,
0.0468180627,
-0.0344885178,
0.0344102792,
0.0684223771,
0.0086520873,
-0.0562544912,
-0.0108174421,
-0.0237517282,
0.0116934236,
0.0165446624,
-0.0292490441,
-6.282898286e-33,
-0.019767059,
-0.0236877613,
-0.0017201733,
0.0121407006,
-0.0194923524,
0.0120594464,
-0.038442824,
-0.0002871569,
-0.0137441996,
0.0241203159,
-0.0235883519,
0.0089054629,
0.0012470447,
0.0370605774,
0.0592934452,
-0.0091794264,
0.0636149049,
0.0091208294,
-0.0170819871,
0.0043124207,
0.023474101,
0.0167814214,
0.1134137064,
-0.0019936652,
-0.0110659217,
-0.0035622385,
0.0031419408,
-0.0061053243,
-0.0126237515,
0.0630486831,
-0.0216346066,
0.0085621439,
0.0336909369,
-0.0451211743,
-0.0299749356,
0.0182912238,
-0.0747950599,
0.0134905661,
-0.0200676695,
0.0039114174,
-0.0575169027,
-0.0135734929,
0.0477180742,
-0.0337984227,
0.0186778922,
-0.0600882545,
0.0270570144,
-0.0195202194,
-0.0270225741,
-0.0282064397,
-0.0658842996,
0.015481404,
0.0006375124,
0.0002013228,
-0.0136838146,
0.0729516149,
-0.0050873128,
0.0383734554,
-0.0206528194,
0.0074696103,
0.0159504786,
0.0783488154,
0.0211633574,
0.0361283459,
-0.0181047376,
0.0482086278,
0.0240931958,
0.0472981483,
-0.0207839254,
-0.0255194195,
0.0305855162,
0.051018741,
0.0176269375,
0.0015671727,
0.0734209493,
-0.0206319243,
-0.0491117761,
-0.0282985643,
-0.0422689207,
0.0776359364,
-0.0085263364,
0.0184376743,
-0.0064790747,
-0.0125727151,
-0.0488470122,
-0.033655677,
-0.0199760105,
-0.0205132384,
0.0166444983,
0.0156565383,
0.0328113027,
-0.0046658507,
0.0132490126,
-0.0260591414,
0.0059730499,
0.0095928982,
-0.0327382647,
0.0165234618,
-0.0010473636,
0.0161156021,
-0.0411812179,
-0.0340138674,
0.0053042001,
0.0146545656,
0.0323731452,
0.0004713069,
0.0496084541,
0.0365162343,
-0.0475240648,
-0.0240722448,
-0.0214044414,
-0.0037234363,
-0.0043078596,
0.0416585952,
0.0710956603,
-0.0081820739,
-0.0239959843,
0.0693458468,
-0.0143247368,
0.0122119309,
-0.0361132063,
0.0765145645,
0.0048952801,
0.0415730476,
-0.0049056811,
-0.0230144374,
-0.0431867316,
-0.0146226073,
0.0658905506,
-0.0629723668,
-0.0293995794,
0.0165890958,
2.697e-7,
0.0125877783,
0.0683667958,
0.0396752246,
-0.0009435464,
0.0290437583,
0.0305667575,
0.0060270331,
0.0443825535,
-0.0227261968,
-0.0293431617,
-0.0136971455,
-0.058113955,
0.048987411,
0.0056750146,
-0.0967419147,
-0.0315607041,
-0.1120490953,
-0.0087557836,
-0.0229367614,
-0.0005370387,
0.0173071884,
0.1081429422,
-0.0193286035,
-0.0279638879,
0.0037447067,
-0.0268671419,
0.0505963191,
0.0187464282,
0.0259096194,
0.016543597,
-0.0121317999,
0.0037318219,
0.0294008125,
0.0452223457,
-0.022405006,
0.0486591645,
0.0110070808,
0.0385463051,
0.0053289146,
0.0021127465,
0.0015211054,
0.0126209389,
-0.0304500926,
-0.0600255206,
0.013188933,
-0.1107889041,
-0.0371924937,
-0.0163945165,
-0.0315606445,
-0.0003156304,
-0.0018014386,
0.0070540518,
0.0094159395,
0.034707576,
0.0227856115,
0.0025347087,
0.0122187678,
-0.0555645451,
-0.0170456115,
0.0273754951,
-0.0464144461,
0.0110359024,
-0.0509164743,
-0.0273356643,
0.0293317512,
-0.0000076025,
-0.0350752324,
2.673240606e-34,
0.0288893413,
-0.0280629825,
0.0020735385,
0.0108747035,
0.020902615,
-0.0473486595,
0.0371697806,
0.0102586029,
0.0072153336,
-0.0866886303,
-0.0181733556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18736v1 | LonXplain: Lonesomeness as a Consequence of Mental Disturbance in Reddit Posts | 2023-05-30T04:21:24 | 2023-05-30T04:21:24 | Muskan Garg, Chandni Saxena, Debabrata Samanta, Bonnie J. Dorr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Social media is a potential source of information that infers latent mental
states through Natural Language Processing (NLP). While narrating real-life
experiences, social media users convey their feeling of loneliness or isolated
lifestyle, impacting their mental well-being. Existing literature on
psychological theories points to loneliness as the major consequence of
interpersonal risk factors, propounding the need to investigate loneliness as a
major aspect of mental disturbance. We formulate lonesomeness detection in
social media posts as an explainable binary classification problem, discovering
the users at-risk, suggesting the need of resilience for early control. To the
best of our knowledge, there is no existing explainable dataset, i.e., one with
human-readable, annotated text spans, to facilitate further research and
development in loneliness detection causing mental disturbance. In this work,
three experts: a senior clinical psychologist, a rehabilitation counselor, and
a social NLP researcher define annotation schemes and perplexity guidelines to
mark the presence or absence of lonesomeness, along with the marking of
text-spans in original posts as explanation, in 3,521 Reddit posts. We expect
the public release of our dataset, LonXplain, and traditional classifiers as
baselines via GitHub. | [
0.0841731355,
0.0455488414,
-0.0193341263,
-0.0184032954,
-0.0100484844,
0.0418304242,
0.0627077669,
0.0133246873,
0.0608333312,
-0.0465995483,
0.0407731496,
0.0240831003,
-0.0206740219,
-0.0056809508,
0.002772935,
-0.0553255342,
0.0117818816,
0.0589330494,
0.0442664474,
-0.0239628758,
0.0374136865,
0.0477640703,
-0.0152477799,
0.0424847044,
-0.0203116331,
-0.0453352667,
0.0556579083,
-0.0008510101,
0.002565057,
-0.0315089189,
0.0328964628,
0.0854483992,
-0.0340678915,
0.0118119838,
0.0000020182,
-0.0303514749,
0.0013134117,
-0.0122165726,
0.0377261192,
-0.0576247387,
0.0327957757,
-0.0126601607,
0.0402426124,
0.0394598655,
-0.0260942243,
-0.0136005385,
0.050750494,
0.0607296973,
0.0460283495,
0.0282591283,
-0.0286252238,
-0.0282486901,
-0.0374029316,
0.0219114274,
0.0502476729,
0.030941885,
0.0215719249,
-0.0072519989,
0.0092359968,
-0.0279710181,
0.025567688,
0.0111194635,
-0.0289303418,
0.0012382339,
0.0211459324,
0.0144876223,
-0.0424600691,
-0.0681661218,
0.0037739512,
0.0673593953,
0.0482618064,
-0.0083088093,
0.0247483179,
0.008434088,
0.012188836,
0.0144388173,
-0.0094190082,
-0.0117489351,
0.0005323528,
-0.0046514762,
0.0256977323,
0.0448216088,
0.0189567339,
0.017085623,
0.013413365,
-0.0036180699,
-0.0187985115,
-0.0135688903,
0.0114821559,
0.0139852958,
-0.0724920481,
-0.0353033207,
0.043281436,
-0.0038423196,
0.0297484193,
-0.0065987445,
-0.0449652299,
-0.0198939741,
0.0131565286,
-0.0050392887,
0.0084544746,
0.0102876155,
-0.0283076856,
0.0061620316,
0.0558293127,
-0.0407372564,
0.0410816707,
-0.0252669584,
0.0014227532,
0.0257561281,
-0.1024053097,
0.0296082776,
-0.0233059172,
0.0210364927,
0.0289751627,
-0.0135310357,
-0.0154180555,
0.0374736823,
-0.0024315871,
-0.040961314,
-0.013459201,
-0.0158855263,
0.0031366593,
-0.008139262,
0.0121937776,
0.0188660454,
-0.043575529,
-0.0292803776,
-0.0141770747,
-0.0542903729,
0.0373143069,
0.0070811878,
0.0425734222,
-0.0856553912,
0.0003483302,
0.0081693083,
0.057619106,
-0.0607771948,
-0.0275780112,
-0.032885164,
-0.0449535809,
-0.0147493696,
-0.053618513,
-0.041276779,
0.0447010621,
0.0152882449,
-0.0020340097,
-0.0395008102,
0.0306301005,
0.0068909046,
-0.0330607556,
0.0561292097,
-0.0986504257,
0.025642436,
-0.0106657753,
0.0219589919,
0.0588993914,
0.0226768628,
-0.0181185156,
-0.0160439219,
0.0812573954,
-0.0452645421,
0.0423871614,
-0.0450337902,
-0.0245762765,
-0.008986474,
0.019807728,
-0.0209684726,
-0.0359151512,
-0.0332265534,
-0.0132906502,
-0.0103610447,
0.0217299759,
0.0427537076,
0.0418149866,
0.0922871605,
0.0352893546,
0.086461015,
-0.0322411209,
0.0464096665,
-0.0151383476,
-0.0150983045,
-0.032637421,
0.0230541117,
-0.0369627587,
-0.0420725755,
0.0572274327,
0.0104905814,
-0.0166813359,
-0.0618890934,
-0.0606369041,
-0.036114458,
0.0230072979,
-0.0193827506,
-0.0074688913,
0.0193285141,
0.0081796832,
0.0053088507,
0.0613441207,
-0.0584889799,
-0.0359092131,
-0.0136320535,
0.0421600416,
0.0360227823,
0.0039799823,
-0.045491796,
-0.0210749377,
-0.0267549101,
0.0590546727,
0.0262568034,
-0.0003040278,
0.0554403514,
0.0365615264,
-0.0251708571,
-0.0099730147,
0.03139963,
0.001401789,
-0.0373092107,
-0.0133892307,
-0.0082508689,
-0.0333175696,
-0.005857185,
-0.0505347811,
0.0489150025,
0.0352375731,
-0.0292102545,
0.0152398553,
0.0427024066,
0.0356111154,
0.0575563945,
0.0086921742,
-0.0178849734,
0.0068881121,
-0.0034438425,
-0.0237010401,
0.0267713647,
0.0030600044,
-0.0326564796,
0.0148173124,
-0.0389707685,
-0.0237546619,
0.0612307675,
-0.0047898875,
0.002038128,
0.0638144389,
-0.0587130375,
0.0330293886,
0.0256288331,
-0.0378715619,
-0.0361912809,
0.0624621026,
0.0005715437,
0.0615785979,
-0.0495893955,
0.0256312452,
-0.1010517552,
-0.0743775144,
0.0046842932,
-0.0239967927,
-0.0509051122,
-0.0756946951,
-0.0423045307,
-0.0197590571,
0.0087557659,
0.0242457241,
-0.0460727178,
-0.0505294688,
-0.0617461391,
-0.0007730975,
-0.0530977398,
0.0346119218,
0.0303557571,
-0.009273232,
-0.0143235959,
-0.0108939074,
-0.0128744338,
0.0428804122,
-0.0027625749,
0.0189943053,
0.0411785431,
-0.010546213,
0.0059190495,
-0.0488554016,
-0.0262799375,
-0.0381295122,
0.011378726,
0.0224063676,
-0.0632202402,
-0.039409861,
0.0539361164,
-0.0785649344,
-0.0088763665,
0.0019756213,
-0.0381855965,
0.021342665,
-0.0226480644,
0.0259006899,
0.0160105769,
0.0233564004,
0.0930378512,
0.0168143213,
0.0594464578,
-0.0032596516,
-0.0110822441,
-0.0297038574,
0.0141846146,
-0.0578205436,
-0.0605292432,
-0.0134253539,
0.0278039295,
0.0160021782,
-0.020848386,
-0.0526267998,
0.0053184298,
-0.0087843426,
-0.0153686972,
0.0041306643,
0.0200743861,
0.0393135622,
-0.0086515425,
-0.0073112096,
-0.0521396138,
0.0192308016,
0.0326935872,
-0.0189811066,
-0.0018490677,
-0.0769621059,
-0.0022215915,
0.0717540607,
0.0113890516,
-0.0197934173,
0.0219440851,
-0.0199843105,
0.0451638401,
-0.042031154,
-0.0287975445,
0.0279615447,
-0.0050037233,
-0.0083407853,
-0.000103192,
0.0411389209,
-0.0029660226,
0.0001843712,
-0.0652888641,
-0.0462017059,
-0.0646444336,
-0.0064193411,
0.0111524099,
-0.0159046203,
0.0002159102,
0.0061349142,
-0.0235236008,
-0.0213203728,
-0.0512419902,
0.0070150704,
-0.00087534,
0.0407585353,
-0.0016814873,
0.0581649207,
-0.0053184326,
0.0136371637,
0.053551089,
-0.0340460092,
0.0171019826,
0.0080659259,
-0.0009537456,
0.0030682015,
-0.0001788403,
-0.0472799987,
-0.0152338762,
0.0559162647,
-0.017767122,
-0.0090569081,
0.091093801,
0.013638163,
-0.0261045583,
0.0268758554,
-0.0369603857,
-0.006251914,
0.0311499387,
-0.0071085151,
-0.0182519108,
-0.0142770661,
-0.0619297735,
0.0401222296,
-0.0223314203,
-0.032433562,
0.0017044963,
-0.0288641695,
0.0324521624,
-0.0241965652,
-0.0098249186,
0.0117522543,
-0.0361916013,
-0.014757962,
-0.0251041614,
-0.0098130628,
-0.0336822569,
-0.0105608786,
0.0187097285,
0.021412164,
-0.1028643399,
-0.0079573244,
0.0014019336,
-0.0215398893,
0.0995036587,
-0.0199579131,
0.0967003927,
0.0197054539,
-0.0324028768,
0.0173848309,
0.0088999104,
0.0157651026,
-0.0310754701,
0.0926963612,
0.0010660148,
0.0111245466,
-0.0626152232,
0.0478372015,
-0.0744713321,
0.0123408185,
0.0105123166,
0.0193298552,
-0.0223784354,
-0.0274620131,
0.0157775823,
0.0537400395,
0.0217173994,
0.0451553389,
0.046161402,
-0.0275882613,
-0.0225259494,
0.0238227081,
0.0072906213,
-0.0307014585,
-0.0419795923,
-0.0402357429,
-0.0159115475,
-0.007598795,
-0.0355916061,
-0.0635054857,
0.0464426801,
0.0307530705,
-0.022850452,
-0.0134047838,
-0.0587063655,
0.0375905633,
-0.0339294262,
0.0522393063,
0.0079150824,
0.0010036677,
-0.0024231528,
-0.0044547524,
-0.0134567916,
-0.0246170145,
0.0240470394,
-0.0339086615,
-0.0090609789,
-0.0055105593,
0.0496472158,
-0.0148228994,
0.0176565889,
0.0024144561,
-0.0097864028,
-0.0868610665,
0.0128877144,
0.0314459763,
0.0222437158,
0.0052976129,
0.0285590701,
0.0480876677,
0.0030962816,
0.0348659083,
0.0073234146,
0.0272502564,
0.0037154057,
-0.0528317951,
-0.0586581044,
-0.0055588041,
-0.0371979661,
0.0098323515,
0.0263871551,
-0.0091430591,
0.0031711981,
0.0012424582,
-0.0707358196,
0.0003703032,
0.0006449987,
-0.0291895308,
-0.0074658827,
0.0209549516,
0.0263599791,
-0.0482121818,
-0.0176780298,
-0.031673301,
0.0193740465,
-0.0856899321,
0.0060117184,
-0.0006427083,
0.0312428437,
-0.0307458602,
0.0139851822,
-0.0100320317,
0.0187103264,
0.0200826712,
0.0283220597,
0.0047543491,
0.0502236374,
-0.0137311723,
-0.0171398018,
0.014515155,
0.0493403897,
-0.0233740434,
-0.0135387443,
-0.0090973862,
-0.0399037078,
-0.0042184605,
-0.0268626716,
0.1155482531,
0.015890047,
-0.0102243498,
0.007261022,
0.0526934564,
-0.0126530575,
-0.0317292958,
-0.0447529107,
0.0058127688,
-0.0278532282,
0.0181062575,
0.0478261225,
-0.0386746228,
-0.0114597976,
0.0629597455,
-0.0257839132,
-0.0108217001,
0.04247538,
-0.0056115054,
0.0844348371,
0.0094185704,
0.0181573909,
-0.0146243377,
-0.0520561263,
0.03442562,
-0.0486367196,
0.0269413814,
0.0091992011,
-0.0178851746,
0.0032440918,
0.0108407121,
-0.0073746415,
-0.0627939701,
-0.0068389135,
-0.0252048858,
-0.0097069247,
0.0052216323,
-5.826427014e-33,
0.021276366,
-0.0743817389,
-0.0536759645,
0.0431086682,
-0.0231922977,
-0.0022427505,
-0.0175114293,
0.0354632623,
0.0190031994,
0.0445170403,
0.0359151326,
0.0603993274,
-0.0077223526,
0.0221440922,
0.0052890657,
0.0149829816,
-0.0138139054,
0.0062923152,
0.0158526413,
0.0135038681,
0.0198604092,
0.0577427559,
0.0155867031,
-0.0993040949,
0.0389997028,
0.000902714,
-0.0158753116,
0.0255189333,
0.0708932877,
0.0197530035,
-0.0183776058,
0.0560344718,
0.0439474508,
0.0407363959,
0.0200897846,
0.0495912358,
-0.0787301436,
-0.0737237781,
-0.0190162193,
-0.0094185844,
-0.0360280238,
-0.023450993,
0.0173250306,
-0.0118213333,
-0.0103555163,
-0.0390168428,
0.0751262829,
0.0055940626,
0.0406731255,
0.0288911164,
0.0117234308,
0.0113153122,
-0.0193865001,
-0.0059000379,
-0.0175382588,
0.0201805308,
0.0042079794,
0.0181038678,
-0.0626286417,
0.0072593964,
-0.0781112909,
0.0033670135,
0.0068175648,
-0.0857923478,
0.0116377054,
0.0352562927,
0.0477910414,
0.0371259227,
-0.0346039459,
0.0223514587,
-0.0151521545,
0.024825735,
0.0721630454,
0.0253202356,
0.0256968532,
-0.0508794822,
-0.0352699049,
-0.0058168634,
0.0057417406,
-0.0542807207,
0.0353675112,
0.001981508,
-0.0442311056,
0.0105312383,
0.0449079089,
-0.0593101606,
-0.0272246469,
-0.0335256867,
-0.0317632221,
-0.0300723594,
-0.0931589007,
-0.0274045561,
-0.0169746615,
-0.0392139181,
-0.0368169583,
-0.0082952362,
-0.0203764662,
0.0441378318,
0.0282336138,
-0.0195054077,
0.0287368465,
0.0032629762,
0.028189363,
0.0182616692,
0.0750892088,
-0.0197369456,
0.0720592737,
-0.0144883934,
-0.0404879004,
-0.0315437838,
-0.0226434134,
0.0129021769,
0.0051483875,
0.0304898154,
-0.0400165617,
0.0193209536,
-0.0126894554,
0.0378266945,
0.0845344067,
0.052379135,
-0.0533083528,
-0.0051170313,
-0.0409504063,
-0.0340193287,
0.0119558694,
-0.0631279424,
-0.0376322269,
-0.0021738561,
0.0603298768,
-0.0000370509,
0.0002422712,
-0.0578425266,
2.661e-7,
0.0085803289,
0.0806699693,
0.0032826422,
-0.0921195298,
0.0346726477,
0.0271973759,
0.0396839939,
0.0152129671,
0.0164717566,
0.0085645914,
0.0342027508,
0.0248928592,
0.0447240956,
0.0073566954,
0.0258329883,
0.0307085719,
-0.0241524391,
-0.0323239267,
-0.0409360975,
-0.0100967428,
0.0561257005,
0.0232654158,
0.0500561483,
-0.0136047918,
-0.0089169703,
-0.0203550141,
-0.0207300205,
-0.0138201546,
0.0030644531,
0.021649519,
0.0418602973,
-0.043771673,
0.0008332587,
-0.0325294994,
-0.016663637,
-0.0284290537,
0.0070345295,
0.0254109204,
-0.0326860733,
-0.0148714771,
0.0449312963,
0.0490346029,
0.019940855,
0.0097134858,
0.0426436029,
-0.0818204656,
-0.0382161662,
-0.0186381936,
-0.0003231635,
-0.0516006015,
0.0610540695,
0.0371059515,
0.0076970318,
0.0253682379,
0.0151758352,
-0.0175940804,
-0.0219964404,
-0.0865921453,
-0.0166913643,
0.0120685939,
-0.0225849263,
-0.0060408358,
0.0100832423,
0.0122025879,
0.0325692408,
-0.0300363097,
0.00802211,
2.069642853e-34,
-0.0538348034,
0.0317837372,
-0.0034016608,
-0.021555867,
0.0451500863,
0.0232824814,
-0.056918405,
0.0047728941,
0.015641138,
-0.0450767316,
0.0121135628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18727v1 | An Annotated Dataset for Explainable Interpersonal Risk Factors of Mental Disturbance in Social Media Posts | 2023-05-30T04:08:40 | 2023-05-30T04:08:40 | Muskan Garg, Amirmohammad Shahbandegan, Amrit Chadha, Vijay Mago | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | With a surge in identifying suicidal risk and its severity in social media
posts, we argue that a more consequential and explainable research is required
for optimal impact on clinical psychology practice and personalized mental
healthcare. The success of computational intelligence techniques for inferring
mental illness from social media resources, points to natural language
processing as a lens for determining Interpersonal Risk Factors (IRF) in human
writings. Motivated with limited availability of datasets for social NLP
research community, we construct and release a new annotated dataset with
human-labelled explanations and classification of IRF affecting mental
disturbance on social media: (i) Thwarted Belongingness (TBe), and (ii)
Perceived Burdensomeness (PBu). We establish baseline models on our dataset
facilitating future research directions to develop real-time personalized AI
models by detecting patterns of TBe and PBu in emotional spectrum of user's
historical social media profile. | [
0.0760072619,
0.0279887058,
-0.0218887515,
-0.0306418799,
-0.0285671707,
0.0241446793,
0.0204040483,
-0.0021469719,
0.09059567,
-0.0249698088,
0.0286604911,
0.0247518625,
-0.0257943422,
0.0222291239,
-0.0042639589,
-0.0580670871,
-0.0089625716,
0.0469565429,
0.0699272007,
-0.0037629164,
0.0109065166,
0.0406217314,
-0.0050803688,
0.0519307777,
-0.024196852,
-0.0281313807,
0.0536505356,
-0.0187969767,
0.0279839318,
-0.0581717081,
0.0079395007,
0.0652403012,
-0.0146007733,
-0.0334170051,
0.0000019144,
-0.0363816023,
-0.0201208517,
-0.0245211888,
0.0042412118,
-0.0924484134,
0.0603328049,
-0.0324089676,
0.0311514009,
0.0260726772,
-0.0449077822,
0.0205122214,
0.0320745893,
0.0792144984,
0.0522791892,
0.0528035462,
-0.042335812,
-0.0208952092,
-0.0057723704,
0.0109129045,
0.0026490404,
0.0062612682,
0.037075419,
-0.0143469423,
0.0216508526,
-0.0422473699,
0.0113232359,
0.0045809317,
-0.0147327539,
0.0176905617,
0.0132895401,
-0.0203205403,
-0.0386633538,
-0.0432747044,
0.0196325239,
0.0832583308,
0.0352687836,
0.0008390469,
0.0169312954,
-0.0171495043,
0.0026535199,
0.0157270133,
-0.0146777472,
-0.0058486792,
-0.0304003805,
0.0134430658,
0.0575472079,
0.0459792018,
0.0078447266,
0.0130380029,
0.0397718102,
0.0643276796,
-0.01761958,
-0.0111073731,
0.0143346982,
0.0036038621,
-0.0427333601,
-0.0457345545,
0.0201086644,
0.0099193593,
-0.0416818336,
0.0235154983,
-0.0689867586,
-0.057542216,
0.0071345787,
-0.0172842555,
0.0214107111,
0.0270110108,
-0.0047259592,
-0.0244420283,
0.0751126409,
-0.0194088295,
0.0244965088,
-0.018744044,
-0.0128282728,
-0.0082659051,
-0.0879500061,
0.0009150001,
-0.0025029415,
0.0175050255,
0.0250234641,
-0.0201894511,
-0.0346722007,
0.0234290063,
-0.0556468256,
-0.0312387999,
-0.0103860004,
0.0067544603,
-0.0252470337,
0.0027140747,
-0.0136966435,
-0.0198520236,
-0.0499400347,
-0.0023885127,
-0.0314700194,
-0.045918785,
0.0470227785,
-0.0138858622,
0.0297925863,
-0.0547317378,
0.0169490073,
0.0291433595,
0.0608129054,
-0.0534768216,
-0.0553403273,
-0.0384319499,
-0.0246045999,
-0.0085918661,
-0.0359664634,
-0.0228488855,
0.0292203482,
0.0250818636,
-0.021925088,
-0.0834539831,
0.0229672696,
0.0272571556,
-0.0647526085,
0.0557600744,
-0.0701468736,
0.0189068858,
0.0005358601,
0.0127980188,
0.0155975446,
0.0171777643,
0.0083633559,
0.0022587227,
0.0713500381,
-0.0455874763,
0.0289345216,
-0.0282010734,
0.0173929222,
-0.0295529142,
0.0065171951,
-0.0176274627,
-0.0712850615,
-0.0087701045,
-0.0331908986,
0.0252361726,
0.0366238542,
0.025206577,
0.0344300605,
0.1009262204,
0.007784253,
0.0613807738,
-0.0149736824,
0.0376902893,
-0.0161364991,
-0.0064857537,
-0.0460315049,
0.0012025217,
-0.0294865649,
-0.044669535,
0.0379093774,
0.0139257303,
-0.0095433565,
-0.0542362705,
-0.0481010079,
-0.0051640337,
0.0093009435,
-0.0084153088,
-0.0309741832,
-0.0016590937,
0.0172370709,
0.0121924542,
0.0543310195,
-0.0386522822,
-0.0310471151,
-0.003440008,
0.0330808461,
0.0737546161,
0.0239579342,
-0.0628778487,
0.0011722397,
-0.0225833971,
0.0584087558,
0.0267220493,
0.0019008837,
0.0192885399,
0.0143669583,
0.0136869708,
0.0031302935,
0.0593768358,
-0.0107668573,
-0.0291355308,
0.0068545234,
-0.0071291719,
-0.042065423,
0.001689935,
-0.0542339869,
0.0562005565,
-0.00437713,
-0.0479053445,
0.0216215868,
0.0333465487,
0.0571826547,
0.0643025041,
0.0131956832,
-0.0030274445,
0.0007126734,
-0.0183331911,
-0.0603596568,
-0.0045438283,
-0.0093917148,
0.0265339483,
0.0229098126,
-0.0576881543,
-0.0093640247,
0.0498104133,
-0.0331365019,
-0.0326759666,
0.0653680786,
-0.0565168895,
0.0051237461,
0.0131451804,
-0.0611629784,
-0.0145500656,
0.0394984037,
-0.0010609141,
0.0677704066,
-0.032102339,
0.0132310102,
-0.0362395793,
-0.0952161252,
-0.0175713208,
-0.0234044883,
-0.013516861,
-0.0592140183,
-0.0387253724,
-0.0081213135,
-0.0039577158,
-0.0109021878,
-0.0385471657,
0.0256414078,
-0.0996247083,
0.0026693305,
-0.0278670192,
0.0227197446,
0.0007961504,
0.0002609938,
-0.0290426388,
-0.0190380774,
-0.0202697199,
0.026689101,
0.0511219688,
0.0352545753,
0.039170932,
-0.0159977078,
0.0251192357,
-0.0599823184,
-0.0270185824,
-0.058000192,
0.0283033103,
0.0211453289,
-0.0379484035,
-0.0125596104,
-0.0210141577,
-0.0557640903,
0.0142814796,
0.0191520974,
-0.0172447115,
0.0072248541,
0.0039146272,
0.0291776508,
0.0154554443,
0.026598759,
0.0887834653,
0.0208670646,
0.0393753946,
-0.0054192683,
0.0018758223,
-0.0498724468,
-0.0013565217,
-0.0403354615,
-0.0414944626,
-0.010343736,
0.0321498141,
0.0347909108,
-0.0412803851,
-0.0508416817,
0.0337149613,
-0.0126545774,
0.0044479691,
0.0211157296,
-0.0172919296,
0.0201501492,
0.0304144975,
-0.0045820475,
-0.0347433016,
0.035813462,
0.0258787759,
0.0343237072,
0.0086412551,
-0.0766213611,
-0.0039730528,
0.0481127761,
0.0334669538,
0.0128204403,
0.0415170938,
0.009385569,
0.0436345674,
-0.0116770929,
-0.0213275831,
0.005126914,
-0.0201518834,
-0.0284323636,
-0.0084861293,
0.0368454643,
-0.0185064301,
-0.0198603719,
-0.0479488634,
-0.071677126,
-0.0302784406,
-0.0212868247,
-0.0153068444,
0.0110451337,
-0.0466127396,
-0.003722057,
-0.046886798,
-0.0125582218,
-0.0444993116,
0.0013777484,
-0.0042215562,
0.0550777726,
-0.0094323605,
0.0518108197,
0.0384404249,
0.0036419712,
0.0245361794,
-0.014323974,
0.0388651937,
-0.0043069609,
0.0278926287,
-0.0246946514,
-0.013494296,
-0.0057851817,
0.0030534782,
0.0378775522,
-0.0009775585,
0.0022144825,
0.0985063016,
0.0139944442,
-0.0043119173,
0.0594420545,
-0.0236184616,
-0.0031599151,
0.003076005,
0.0099206632,
-0.0066234837,
-0.034656968,
-0.0546928532,
0.0390341841,
-0.0453652069,
-0.0561173931,
0.0004395683,
-0.0402151346,
0.041886311,
-0.0363215283,
0.0174457133,
-0.0029212427,
-0.0465365164,
0.0009948204,
-0.0492884703,
-0.0101897987,
-0.0656070858,
-0.0053501152,
0.0200934317,
0.0003987527,
-0.1090379581,
-0.0413148701,
0.0318477973,
-0.0195238236,
0.0711790547,
-0.0456973352,
0.0860865191,
0.0049450002,
-0.0396129005,
0.0072763078,
0.0261494238,
0.0058830311,
-0.0008726201,
0.098886013,
-0.0071485848,
0.011200143,
-0.076988034,
0.0685916469,
-0.0844705626,
-0.0240300819,
-0.0122124944,
0.0637394711,
-0.0303017814,
-0.0129017187,
-0.0266064014,
0.0459895134,
0.0435018539,
0.0691410974,
0.0314889215,
-0.0547236167,
-0.0085263578,
0.0042284611,
0.0187619347,
-0.0117743909,
-0.033660125,
-0.0009846371,
-0.0308240689,
-0.037375439,
-0.0504395775,
-0.0569301397,
0.027782321,
-0.0104106329,
0.0077895159,
-0.0316099972,
-0.0049861604,
-0.0043748971,
-0.0724957883,
0.0432629585,
0.0122766988,
0.0233543757,
0.0214393344,
0.0395291708,
-0.0170208961,
0.0011780058,
-0.0081816642,
0.00237801,
-0.0355425589,
-0.0276848357,
0.0409382135,
-0.009364794,
0.0152343893,
-0.0057704253,
0.0020878685,
-0.0826595053,
0.0065870667,
-0.0028793698,
-0.0038301174,
-0.0314420313,
0.0077389944,
0.0091943378,
0.0158466268,
0.0418083705,
0.012298842,
0.0277297553,
0.0308052581,
-0.0427050181,
-0.0320994928,
0.0076193786,
-0.0302879773,
0.0162891671,
0.0326440185,
-0.0158308223,
-0.0556270964,
-0.0094490899,
-0.0740182772,
0.0002806495,
-0.0276909694,
-0.0050401976,
-0.0355429165,
0.0148039879,
0.025357727,
-0.0492323935,
-0.0500251539,
-0.0560449995,
-0.0104335668,
-0.0420351811,
0.0243126508,
0.0230088308,
0.0361004807,
-0.0265779197,
0.0079248101,
0.0177375991,
0.025713006,
-0.0042354246,
0.0307330526,
-0.0032895235,
0.0471699722,
-0.0051958906,
0.0194747709,
0.0234313626,
0.0521873981,
-0.0167768653,
-0.0536764525,
-0.0040078536,
-0.0363509394,
0.021056829,
-0.0374816097,
0.0642257482,
0.0170626938,
0.0063712448,
-0.0017732359,
0.0472380295,
-0.0303710941,
-0.0544141531,
0.0012217942,
-0.0052555227,
-0.0308118742,
0.0238495041,
0.0606764928,
-0.0106935613,
0.0037343386,
0.0411100909,
-0.0260145962,
0.006419831,
0.0247404873,
0.0208626017,
0.0760348216,
0.0015249832,
0.0161165725,
-0.0439494252,
-0.0609792434,
0.0696664602,
-0.048069708,
-0.0169119872,
-0.0057501304,
0.0102743013,
0.0133359721,
0.0238252822,
-0.0158867724,
-0.0490122922,
-0.0115868608,
-0.0253821313,
-0.0338562317,
0.0065981103,
-5.76699402e-33,
0.0122774439,
-0.063541159,
-0.0204734318,
0.0249904897,
0.000648227,
-0.0047134231,
-0.0117654298,
0.0077073886,
0.0147146601,
0.0385953411,
0.0008945584,
0.0691230893,
-0.0043267105,
0.0481049456,
0.0107136201,
-0.0088053048,
-0.0309769623,
0.0074598533,
0.001164032,
0.0265028235,
0.0359364413,
0.0551081859,
0.0196350068,
-0.0851039812,
0.0529551841,
0.0290980935,
0.0115831038,
0.0248166136,
0.0662893876,
0.0229226742,
-0.0349966176,
0.085782744,
0.0626674145,
-0.0032299736,
0.033403676,
0.0756328106,
-0.0471379161,
-0.0738927796,
-0.0258161556,
-0.017806001,
-0.0400732756,
-0.0299902763,
0.0203718413,
-0.0075604082,
-0.0143105313,
-0.0391358957,
0.0718542263,
0.0001084937,
0.0827402025,
0.0142082991,
-0.0203029811,
0.0140460851,
-0.0368537977,
0.0205981918,
-0.0244121738,
0.0235848967,
-0.0181205384,
0.0044909716,
-0.0444654785,
0.0095904125,
-0.0578354895,
-0.0272226278,
0.0132466778,
-0.0958316401,
-0.0321172699,
0.0377580076,
0.0147264889,
0.0061362428,
-0.0465319753,
0.0316573791,
-0.017451413,
0.0724036917,
0.0631707907,
0.0197005197,
0.0150483418,
-0.0352618732,
-0.0299639851,
0.0169071835,
0.0136202676,
-0.0227100197,
0.0034705347,
-0.0132481623,
-0.0288621653,
-0.0101744896,
0.019903874,
-0.0718908906,
-0.0107069518,
-0.0136824567,
-0.0016246631,
-0.0523220524,
-0.042534627,
-0.0198851656,
-0.0055939476,
-0.0346842855,
-0.0075477352,
-0.0141301937,
0.0273547899,
0.0220144764,
0.0324020758,
0.0028591175,
0.0071812542,
0.0148175396,
0.0157841966,
-0.0198038891,
0.081392087,
-0.031972453,
0.0709483847,
-0.0033054159,
-0.0028917589,
-0.0288323108,
0.0088008456,
0.0274118725,
-0.0031392789,
0.0514967404,
-0.0055669788,
0.044044923,
-0.0135699259,
0.0123085007,
0.0700257272,
0.0345062613,
-0.0448160097,
-0.0162516553,
-0.0443652309,
-0.0426557697,
0.0171305817,
-0.0530733876,
-0.0290134158,
0.0143309953,
0.0364300944,
-0.0381128043,
-0.0096574007,
-0.0530276299,
2.658e-7,
0.0432386547,
0.0920208767,
0.006588113,
-0.0157383345,
0.0237798542,
0.0230503213,
0.0664969012,
0.0591027588,
-0.0001577413,
0.0134494267,
0.034184251,
0.0269900654,
0.0279227346,
0.0360017903,
0.0218153708,
-0.0197301004,
0.0027022688,
-0.0218917187,
-0.0696932226,
-0.0027472444,
0.0884567946,
0.0373577289,
0.0332989506,
-0.0407835953,
-0.0051536313,
-0.0013995457,
-0.0281619355,
-0.0358608142,
0.0310423672,
0.0189520679,
0.054769665,
-0.010414999,
0.0126918508,
0.0059764669,
-0.0136369951,
-0.0261839963,
0.0174061265,
0.0239606984,
-0.0475242883,
-0.0060343412,
0.0174645912,
0.0321616158,
0.0155317253,
0.0051991562,
0.0530926026,
-0.0484765731,
-0.0615084767,
-0.0378599688,
0.0006423363,
-0.0513514765,
0.02475252,
0.0278808847,
0.0016235503,
0.0302817468,
0.0494278856,
-0.0069215558,
-0.0061863451,
-0.071552664,
-0.0166363753,
0.0445332862,
-0.012797771,
0.0534260981,
0.0104213674,
0.0196899865,
0.0454410128,
-0.0334140398,
0.0218033493,
1.948198445e-34,
-0.0468520075,
0.0530020259,
0.0099909632,
-0.0420727059,
0.0506790802,
0.0286178719,
-0.0706391484,
-0.014701738,
-0.0000128324,
-0.0831141397,
0.0129247177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18725v1 | AdapterEM: Pre-trained Language Model Adaptation for Generalized Entity Matching using Adapter-tuning | 2023-05-30T04:03:23 | 2023-05-30T04:03:23 | John Bosco Mugeni, Steven Lynden, Toshiyuki Amagasa, Akiyoshi Matono | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB | Entity Matching (EM) involves identifying different data representations
referring to the same entity from multiple data sources and is typically
formulated as a binary classification problem. It is a challenging problem in
data integration due to the heterogeneity of data representations.
State-of-the-art solutions have adopted NLP techniques based on pre-trained
language models (PrLMs) via the fine-tuning paradigm, however, sequential
fine-tuning of overparameterized PrLMs can lead to catastrophic forgetting,
especially in low-resource scenarios. In this study, we propose a
parameter-efficient paradigm for fine-tuning PrLMs based on adapters, small
neural networks encapsulated between layers of a PrLM, by optimizing only the
adapter and classifier weights while the PrLMs parameters are frozen.
Adapter-based methods have been successfully applied to multilingual speech
problems achieving promising results, however, the effectiveness of these
methods when applied to EM is not yet well understood, particularly for
generalized EM with heterogeneous data. Furthermore, we explore using (i)
pre-trained adapters and (ii) invertible adapters to capture token-level
language representations and demonstrate their benefits for transfer learning
on the generalized EM benchmark. Our results show that our solution achieves
comparable or superior performance to full-scale PrLM fine-tuning and
prompt-tuning baselines while utilizing a significantly smaller computational
footprint $\approx 13\%$ of the PrLM parameters. | [
0.0160096865,
0.0721602291,
0.0039968048,
0.030717833,
-0.0046074302,
0.0242968425,
0.0127743706,
-0.0073493766,
0.012435698,
-0.061636731,
-0.0195406396,
-0.0039372221,
-0.0013910575,
-0.0181933679,
0.0092175053,
-0.0190612637,
0.0717550516,
0.021567395,
-0.0270038564,
-0.0060866987,
0.0061633098,
0.0383966491,
0.0090211248,
0.0254452359,
0.0024157753,
0.021157559,
0.022325879,
0.0333885513,
0.0260095093,
0.0016070608,
0.0075752689,
0.0302342251,
0.0034266307,
0.0440820679,
0.0000019642,
-0.0733077005,
-0.0563003235,
-0.0108480575,
-0.0257415827,
-0.0238134209,
0.0027398784,
-0.0136693092,
0.0019512761,
0.0119809965,
0.008438576,
-0.0927554071,
0.055762846,
0.0685593337,
0.0553168729,
0.090391703,
-0.0256090611,
0.0025474024,
0.0312956497,
-0.0036509202,
-0.0197898559,
-0.0568430908,
0.0310632847,
-0.0333414823,
-0.0021944765,
-0.0223764647,
0.0027994015,
0.0350922607,
-0.0406205952,
0.0364887454,
-0.0031676372,
0.0014868197,
-0.0450835526,
0.0303818285,
-0.0292454548,
0.0828668103,
-0.0698165223,
-0.0559413768,
0.0042902152,
-0.0338606089,
0.0101147676,
-0.0192633364,
0.0112520931,
-0.0295165107,
0.0033820826,
0.0345123075,
-0.0267228205,
-0.0361065678,
0.0400998332,
0.0028898227,
-0.0740804374,
0.0261084046,
0.0266247503,
0.0006862641,
0.0142791821,
0.0108873639,
0.0014053581,
-0.0478144437,
0.0321358927,
0.0374853499,
-0.0272080842,
-0.0245116893,
-0.0897659659,
-0.0588329025,
-0.0243187547,
-0.0073179249,
0.0483121499,
0.0479990356,
0.0030887655,
0.0577475391,
-0.0696050301,
0.0370226242,
-0.0096649099,
0.0169811714,
-0.0254481956,
-0.0635224953,
-0.0467680469,
0.0215149,
-0.0645972416,
0.0315222293,
-0.0206570365,
-0.0170944296,
0.0038207627,
0.0133191217,
-0.0310371723,
0.0169664696,
-0.0311610699,
-0.0016948885,
-0.0155521091,
-0.0240134019,
-0.012531748,
0.0546165034,
-0.024079578,
0.0085911863,
-0.0338875428,
-0.0487943776,
-0.0116493097,
0.0042715911,
0.0561379194,
-0.0587124936,
0.0463870168,
0.047465954,
0.0235855076,
-0.0318078697,
-0.0351117887,
0.0430855192,
0.034961395,
-0.0326885283,
-0.0072681396,
-0.0433824062,
0.0874137878,
0.0051492127,
0.0126765985,
-0.0887799039,
-0.0116429003,
-0.0108932359,
-0.0667438433,
0.1053892151,
-0.0124837756,
0.0159551632,
-0.0052099088,
-0.0405672789,
0.0137093263,
0.0456789136,
0.03870897,
-0.0407856442,
0.0219726413,
-0.0324713588,
-0.0231852364,
0.0656519681,
0.0478801876,
-0.0230961386,
-0.025008386,
0.0198254883,
0.0547143631,
0.0134122157,
0.070721373,
0.0478399582,
-0.0063632391,
-0.0238156039,
0.031543348,
0.0166368634,
0.0249051843,
0.0179508384,
0.0184342489,
0.0065138796,
-0.0131426034,
-0.0192206372,
-0.0506630726,
0.0177218542,
-0.0178661849,
-0.0485854745,
0.006167802,
0.0912887827,
-0.0558036491,
0.0426891372,
0.0146380384,
-0.0221821424,
-0.0151053825,
0.0066100764,
0.0073129083,
0.0166126732,
-0.0442635268,
0.0882463977,
0.0268686134,
-0.0069447095,
0.0097697359,
-0.0390368477,
-0.0252905469,
0.023965301,
0.0069623026,
-0.010520109,
-0.0212364811,
-0.03445125,
0.0218291581,
0.0037252684,
0.0667837188,
0.0128429616,
0.0304796472,
-0.0367481858,
-0.0283068307,
0.0320934244,
-0.004288909,
0.0502748229,
0.025063362,
0.0417262167,
0.0292296931,
-0.0218316987,
-0.0377782173,
0.0425718501,
-0.040628314,
-0.0235763192,
0.0342406146,
0.031612467,
-0.0037781447,
-0.0056260522,
-0.0036812925,
-0.0095602265,
0.0107540227,
-0.0164935309,
0.022842491,
-0.0020029978,
-0.0315983742,
0.0014815879,
0.0313316993,
-0.0113594234,
0.0101763196,
-0.0044159363,
-0.02464341,
-0.0540659614,
-0.0125518106,
0.0136379618,
0.0883105919,
-0.0135273756,
0.0341108926,
-0.0267646592,
0.0304427631,
-0.0266447943,
0.029711524,
0.0567968525,
0.0087053794,
-0.0017445444,
-0.0246688519,
0.0202040598,
-0.0267428346,
-0.0549006872,
-0.0162600167,
-0.0024500818,
0.0252205376,
-0.0151491901,
-0.0288932249,
-0.0362200513,
-0.0155039318,
-0.0751337484,
0.0147560518,
0.0023136381,
0.0033021439,
0.0159820225,
0.064745307,
-0.0049144314,
-0.0233450178,
-0.0201169439,
0.0028746838,
0.0315434523,
0.0158902202,
0.0235152505,
-0.0179166682,
-0.0025240188,
-0.0374218337,
0.0123920124,
-0.0299478751,
0.0336456038,
-0.0109003317,
-0.033917807,
-0.0525161177,
-0.0071913218,
-0.0184341576,
0.0316905268,
0.0106768757,
0.0134842405,
-0.0377739668,
0.0244999807,
0.0299624093,
0.0558855198,
-0.0113108195,
-0.0405449979,
0.0013789956,
-0.0128989303,
-0.1076806039,
0.0208015461,
0.0155500071,
0.0131289093,
-0.0101145776,
0.0183164217,
0.0043950924,
0.0180978514,
-0.0629344583,
-0.0131984334,
-0.0429541431,
0.0497748554,
0.0379105061,
0.0266730376,
-0.0023927214,
0.0006891222,
0.0101019042,
-0.0013491155,
-0.0251873899,
-0.0046349042,
0.0527551919,
-0.0431503169,
0.0112100942,
-0.0239643212,
-0.0019718546,
-0.0350429639,
0.0021923529,
0.0340758301,
0.0402925499,
-0.0096278936,
-0.002889097,
-0.0430831835,
0.0161665175,
-0.0237941276,
-0.0039987322,
0.0800688937,
0.0235963706,
0.0312776193,
-0.0301466268,
-0.0480290838,
-0.0456028394,
-0.0289415307,
-0.0339162573,
0.0200551804,
-0.0093609262,
-0.0197311193,
-0.0959656686,
0.0348858386,
-0.0027549851,
0.0261854045,
-0.0061350777,
0.000273457,
-0.0244458281,
0.0186591037,
0.0496302173,
0.038194716,
0.0523983911,
0.0234631188,
-0.0000518731,
-0.0069729779,
0.0546607114,
-0.0075130169,
-0.0182418246,
0.0028462871,
0.0505413488,
-0.04912249,
0.0048621963,
-0.0094416989,
0.0749229416,
-0.0105330935,
-0.0086057996,
0.1007337496,
-0.0165389255,
-0.0392579362,
-0.0273943562,
0.010120064,
0.0185667779,
0.0032267878,
0.0656515807,
-0.0575521477,
-0.0382583551,
0.0142843015,
0.0126690166,
0.0197362825,
-0.0541313998,
-0.0231926292,
-0.1104492992,
-0.0296807438,
0.0090756956,
-0.0657435879,
-0.0163304601,
-0.031037014,
0.0116093494,
-0.0210785754,
0.0610284284,
-0.022838736,
-0.0418416001,
-0.0129786134,
-0.0062458469,
-0.0098570818,
-0.0288081914,
0.0167840663,
-0.0928802714,
0.0751503929,
0.036808867,
0.0281783491,
-0.0119309984,
-0.0142989233,
0.024731122,
-0.0355824903,
-0.0362792537,
0.0081529478,
0.0138387252,
-0.034817446,
-0.0360199586,
0.0246461593,
-0.0076977848,
-0.0225975644,
0.0072481725,
0.0041192374,
0.0585746355,
0.0075824265,
0.0031609582,
0.0041356958,
-0.0435470231,
0.0005720143,
0.1031715795,
0.0284384321,
-0.0453567132,
-0.0077589485,
0.0023476898,
0.0151056014,
-0.0446958728,
0.0035014588,
0.0262886621,
-0.0296587888,
-0.0014651171,
-0.0248201825,
-0.0142926658,
0.0468677394,
0.0388611518,
0.030907711,
0.003876701,
0.0034487019,
-0.0267944261,
-0.0531178676,
0.0485155918,
-0.0604820959,
0.0183968283,
-0.0664344281,
-0.0128382966,
0.0164034124,
-0.0211176295,
-0.0217069946,
-0.0108966762,
-0.0658871308,
-0.0608865023,
0.0367204361,
0.0058442294,
0.0122214891,
0.0861622617,
-0.0430871248,
-0.0436764956,
0.0400880277,
0.0780553594,
-0.0155475251,
0.0056389659,
0.0036589692,
-0.0289653707,
-0.025446089,
0.049000971,
-0.0677755773,
0.0155100627,
0.0759363398,
0.014785937,
0.0096881008,
-0.0592993647,
-0.0047078668,
0.0280359071,
0.0077400999,
0.0226642992,
-0.0074801832,
-0.0504001938,
-0.0140205091,
0.0208124369,
0.005190325,
-0.0376628302,
-0.0374128483,
0.0086692842,
0.0444999486,
-0.0190468412,
-0.0120776743,
0.0086963242,
0.0480766296,
-0.061444331,
-0.0001771253,
0.0029070696,
0.018993536,
0.0311480742,
-0.0129402848,
-0.0115497336,
0.0435615592,
0.0564566329,
0.0569488741,
-0.0826104209,
-0.0304690935,
0.0314069763,
0.0361900628,
-0.0486765951,
0.0292125959,
-0.0091268942,
-0.0489384308,
-0.0253707599,
0.0155114653,
0.0704634562,
-0.0492119081,
0.0313171819,
0.0428198464,
-0.0084281452,
-0.0128481835,
-0.0086478218,
0.0070061074,
0.0073022163,
0.0229618773,
0.0192439761,
-0.013681788,
0.0349526405,
0.031550765,
-0.0374201313,
0.0885389447,
-0.0048615881,
0.0187807232,
-0.0142407389,
0.0037869255,
0.0064998907,
-0.0001948065,
-0.0298806243,
-0.0164027251,
-0.0105844503,
-0.0654970258,
0.0245799925,
-0.0441584364,
-0.0536561981,
0.0184391029,
0.0083297295,
0.0134777501,
0.0181528088,
0.0113000656,
0.0106865941,
-0.0176903456,
0.0195574835,
-0.0243930649,
0.0111312671,
-6.403646535e-33,
-0.0467928536,
0.0185604822,
0.007547989,
-0.0483255684,
0.0065945303,
0.0045891679,
0.0030256987,
-0.0458156802,
-0.0670132861,
-0.0620291159,
-0.0173583888,
-0.007118538,
0.0222705118,
0.0235502142,
-0.0264396016,
-0.0108959153,
0.0519478247,
0.0292790569,
-0.0176825989,
0.0081770429,
0.032192748,
0.0560405292,
0.0412020758,
-0.0516907535,
-0.0083499644,
0.0012446078,
0.0159735661,
0.017565757,
0.0464328378,
0.0581099503,
-0.0026367253,
0.0188184474,
0.0151126292,
0.0192397591,
-0.0102330577,
0.0129420003,
-0.1352480501,
-0.0332991183,
-0.0071384143,
0.0337673575,
0.0639284924,
-0.0198420286,
0.075642094,
-0.034620773,
0.0083406456,
0.0010732932,
0.0481957942,
-0.0067190412,
0.0003257791,
-0.0014893082,
-0.0586845055,
0.0138914194,
0.0295197815,
0.0432059094,
0.0336298645,
-0.0040014354,
0.0032174094,
0.0236039404,
-0.1135080233,
-0.0079546459,
-0.0158861876,
-0.0063861846,
0.0205884315,
0.0289589111,
-0.025224911,
0.0446925536,
0.030798465,
-0.0203098096,
0.0106624393,
0.0187863037,
0.0655769333,
0.0044961385,
-0.0081656324,
0.0347131863,
0.0340337083,
-0.0537062623,
-0.0610992983,
0.0363204814,
0.0274799131,
0.0007719434,
-0.0026495263,
-0.0060130828,
-0.0195927825,
-0.0138210449,
-0.0535015911,
-0.0370906852,
-0.0544204675,
-0.0340726487,
0.0351604633,
-0.0068012276,
-0.0270852167,
0.0227795765,
0.0369902067,
-0.0480483584,
-0.0532752685,
-0.0151407095,
0.0183750801,
-0.0521921515,
0.0139282085,
0.0477683395,
-0.0452519357,
-0.0715792552,
0.0410157517,
-0.0311045088,
0.0323044397,
0.0310734492,
0.0590013973,
-0.0095538152,
-0.0856511965,
-0.0017969616,
-0.0218643472,
-0.0064296266,
-0.0430209823,
0.0285063349,
0.0306503661,
0.0326263979,
0.020305384,
-0.0061011515,
0.0566465743,
-0.0491966009,
-0.0027497311,
-0.0055038524,
0.0301235709,
0.0343102477,
-0.0169326253,
-0.0223358218,
-0.0352065191,
0.0015762836,
0.0204537939,
-0.0720111653,
-0.0041917916,
-0.0111170327,
2.792e-7,
0.0233084932,
0.0090970099,
0.0102026239,
-0.0394486189,
-0.0013027438,
0.0047372468,
0.0040868409,
0.0427857712,
0.0148952464,
0.0425300412,
-0.0159558319,
0.021709023,
0.0165870693,
0.0179091711,
-0.0723304003,
0.0178544652,
-0.0405685641,
0.0423454307,
-0.0641467199,
-0.0006682877,
-0.0035813402,
0.0845798925,
0.0266557559,
-0.0151001904,
-0.0159451198,
-0.0448599271,
0.0517347306,
-0.056725584,
0.0147843966,
0.034303423,
0.0109384852,
0.0515030734,
-0.0096742995,
0.064673543,
0.0002737239,
0.0888988599,
0.0206318721,
0.0382095873,
-0.0164816044,
-0.0245847665,
-0.0281471033,
-0.0343985334,
-0.008390747,
-0.0686303303,
0.1008780599,
-0.0554935373,
-0.0015239349,
-0.0182260498,
-0.0348940976,
-0.012492653,
0.0136929927,
0.0145899029,
-0.0174581427,
0.0378801189,
0.0513899624,
0.0106730452,
-0.062546052,
-0.083101131,
0.0160429776,
0.0225119591,
-0.00504464,
-0.0107130632,
-0.0426535234,
-0.0292362142,
0.0578922182,
-0.0437219776,
0.0434411913,
2.701137474e-34,
-0.0184109379,
-0.0052512167,
0.0061994796,
0.0062517412,
0.0355747938,
-0.0257478338,
0.0089616459,
0.0334099345,
-0.0188884158,
-0.0655861646,
0.0050986055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18703v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18703v7 | Domain Specialization as the Key to Make Large Language Models Disruptive: A Comprehensive Survey | 2023-05-30T03:00:30 | 2024-03-29T14:05:07 | Chen Ling, Xujiang Zhao, Jiaying Lu, Chengyuan Deng, Can Zheng, Junxiang Wang, Tanmoy Chowdhury, Yun Li, Hejie Cui, Xuchao Zhang, Tianjiao Zhao, Amit Panalkar, Dhagash Mehta, Stefano Pasquali, Wei Cheng, Haoyu Wang, Yanchi Liu, Zhengzhang Chen, Haifeng Chen, Chris White, Quanquan Gu, Jian Pei, Carl Yang, Liang Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of natural
language processing (NLP), providing a highly useful, task-agnostic foundation
for a wide range of applications. However, directly applying LLMs to solve
sophisticated problems in specific domains meets many hurdles, caused by the
heterogeneity of domain data, the sophistication of domain knowledge, the
uniqueness of domain objectives, and the diversity of the constraints (e.g.,
various social norms, cultural conformity, religious beliefs, and ethical
standards in the domain applications). Domain specification techniques are key
to make large language models disruptive in many applications. Specifically, to
solve these hurdles, there has been a notable increase in research and
practices conducted in recent years on the domain specialization of LLMs. This
emerging field of study, with its substantial potential for impact,
necessitates a comprehensive and systematic review to better summarize and
guide ongoing work in this area. In this article, we present a comprehensive
survey on domain specification techniques for large language models, an
emerging direction critical for large language model applications. First, we
propose a systematic taxonomy that categorizes the LLM domain-specialization
techniques based on the accessibility to LLMs and summarizes the framework for
all the subcategories as well as their relations and differences to each other.
Second, we present an extensive taxonomy of critical application domains that
can benefit dramatically from specialized LLMs, discussing their practical
significance and open challenges. Last, we offer our insights into the current
research status and future trends in this area. | [
0.0601567887,
0.0566992201,
-0.0368635282,
0.0579355992,
-0.0832683444,
-0.0045131124,
0.0286312569,
-0.0055571357,
0.0226047337,
-0.0924711823,
-0.0200352129,
-0.0603189431,
0.0021846995,
0.0174179859,
-0.0016634347,
-0.0588482581,
0.0436288081,
-0.0403461307,
-0.0066731325,
0.0053988956,
-0.0001421673,
0.011776288,
0.0513324551,
0.0331901424,
-0.0048248507,
-0.0100426441,
0.0326567553,
-0.017427966,
-0.0158843882,
-0.0053969771,
0.005780417,
0.0282170009,
0.0428380892,
0.0211693626,
0.000002188,
-0.0770057365,
-0.050071571,
0.0187209956,
0.003594744,
0.0155254053,
0.0586040057,
-0.0457455516,
-0.0023283917,
-0.0095682191,
-0.0297481529,
-0.038076669,
0.0493084528,
0.0263158511,
0.0468055792,
0.0595139302,
-0.015717743,
-0.0530041493,
-0.0272365566,
-0.0296880994,
-0.0935477316,
-0.0431892797,
0.0803204924,
0.0410243124,
0.048887644,
0.0201108996,
-0.0197651014,
0.0262634344,
-0.0171557125,
0.0129897958,
-0.0275814906,
-0.0342979208,
-0.0018949683,
-0.0156546067,
0.012742037,
0.0068952334,
0.0299355239,
0.0004405514,
0.0451197065,
0.0073388913,
-0.0240429416,
0.0257620048,
-0.0349345654,
0.0581388958,
-0.0094249668,
0.0213261042,
0.0298519023,
0.017064821,
0.036871776,
0.0504342541,
-0.0607823357,
0.0748267397,
0.0163143184,
-0.0343299136,
-0.0556878187,
-0.004553284,
-0.0528561957,
-0.0598908216,
0.021957811,
0.0088528143,
-0.0058089392,
0.0316903479,
-0.0491313897,
-0.0200646091,
0.0220765136,
-0.0204189904,
0.0474640615,
-0.0047179032,
0.0158581138,
0.0474310517,
0.0357900038,
0.0323028304,
-0.0460840687,
-0.0481639095,
-0.0193131808,
-0.0365062878,
-0.039177604,
-0.0032065308,
-0.0396521129,
0.0240022112,
-0.0385707989,
0.012993102,
-0.0192885865,
0.0282256715,
-0.0161136426,
-0.0021565626,
0.005228736,
-0.0301569737,
-0.0202007964,
-0.0536518767,
0.0066271182,
0.0232617818,
-0.0194623359,
0.0295852777,
-0.0383204743,
-0.0373524725,
0.0425614975,
0.0462183282,
-0.0280046277,
-0.0188023131,
-0.0032751549,
0.1128068119,
0.0598837733,
-0.0133842286,
-0.0206237603,
-0.025941845,
-0.0389384665,
-0.0653637424,
-0.0115106171,
-0.0745954067,
-0.0075862058,
0.0158120878,
0.0273196176,
-0.0775831789,
-0.008226431,
-0.0066703297,
-0.0219038818,
0.0631582439,
-0.0060730199,
0.0409083143,
0.0412340909,
0.0080679869,
0.015996635,
0.0744928196,
0.013312228,
-0.0193911325,
0.0640060678,
-0.0031929086,
-0.0093660615,
0.0683973953,
-0.0289998595,
-0.0008075518,
-0.0329830348,
0.005728581,
0.0021580355,
-0.0220138486,
-0.0067199105,
0.0566587448,
0.0048350613,
-0.0063110818,
0.0436035022,
0.0646137744,
0.0045102439,
0.015616186,
0.0531022139,
0.0251689572,
0.0030913476,
-0.00544476,
-0.0277130194,
-0.0612823032,
0.0060008476,
-0.0056838645,
-0.0100471918,
0.0672368705,
-0.0051293569,
-0.0310027637,
-0.0418165661,
-0.0205686297,
0.0121351862,
0.0070366831,
0.0959665105,
0.0126600731,
0.0301292352,
0.0314020105,
0.0213693883,
-0.0048942501,
0.0259516984,
-0.0489100851,
-0.0166943502,
0.0243874472,
0.0466690995,
-0.0587977841,
-0.0008861166,
0.0060465941,
0.0274742134,
0.0640425161,
0.0365204923,
-0.0204232931,
-0.0393412597,
-0.0289937463,
-0.028019581,
0.0112911761,
0.0388316177,
-0.0099646635,
0.0563117601,
-0.014520999,
0.007241182,
-0.0508821048,
-0.0181631967,
0.0148227969,
-0.0398816653,
-0.0097658755,
0.0119619491,
0.0120693929,
0.0519620031,
0.0242652651,
-0.004224122,
-0.0122918962,
0.0025523473,
-0.0378648862,
-0.0248892028,
-0.026103856,
-0.0004887339,
0.0342282616,
0.0461702235,
-0.0251413211,
-0.0026947598,
0.0285936035,
-0.0262947343,
-0.0247607473,
0.0170797613,
-0.0143978205,
0.022492636,
-0.0407917462,
0.0499949083,
-0.0316699296,
0.0003894299,
-0.0730351508,
0.0537849702,
0.0160047431,
-0.0273813922,
0.0202136263,
-0.0342945345,
0.0237108599,
0.0070670475,
-0.0620996468,
-0.0015995692,
-0.0069518327,
0.0579887405,
0.0440791138,
-0.0202474538,
0.0015475688,
-0.0140513815,
-0.0583317615,
0.0308989082,
-0.0100990273,
0.0373222716,
-0.0114796674,
0.04261709,
-0.0167707689,
0.023143651,
0.0104609635,
-0.0393547677,
0.0214116592,
0.0325859226,
0.0032241195,
0.0079822754,
-0.0513129495,
0.0128879901,
-0.0277251825,
0.0058122133,
0.0468455851,
-0.0264379978,
-0.0440181978,
-0.0868078694,
0.0351885706,
-0.0235982407,
0.0464899652,
-0.0040972573,
0.0246406868,
-0.0314189233,
-0.0065654516,
0.028332632,
-0.0033934079,
-0.0189482998,
-0.0014580179,
0.0472857878,
-0.0108022587,
-0.0129100149,
-0.035119582,
-0.04754458,
-0.0045563029,
-0.0327332839,
-0.001427445,
0.0201018397,
0.062235944,
-0.0214980654,
-0.0342641138,
-0.0174064673,
0.0099784536,
-0.0686593801,
-0.0075332182,
0.0172283705,
-0.0411903746,
-0.0102690188,
0.0419032015,
-0.0126951234,
-0.0542167872,
0.0544968098,
-0.0162865911,
0.0345558822,
-0.0656018183,
-0.0313838758,
-0.0748629048,
0.0532785021,
-0.0227555539,
0.0227882378,
0.0801575482,
-0.0250127632,
-0.0247413218,
0.0132665923,
-0.0032987273,
-0.0159431137,
0.1125541553,
-0.0373141244,
0.045695316,
-0.0099230753,
-0.0391377322,
-0.0398067944,
-0.01416458,
-0.0452722535,
0.0305465292,
0.0091086905,
0.0080837142,
-0.0169004891,
0.0422073565,
-0.0170347467,
-0.0089412117,
0.0152546605,
0.0131837986,
-0.0399949811,
0.0181573518,
0.01742878,
-0.0072522778,
-0.0047588856,
0.0072038961,
-0.0023198761,
0.0253276415,
0.008715854,
-0.0053046024,
-0.0071984385,
-0.0015080944,
0.0703532845,
-0.0662945509,
-0.0296089966,
0.0008273984,
0.023926748,
-0.0756020471,
0.0199986454,
0.1076297686,
0.0260631777,
-0.015591355,
0.0074091339,
-0.0039716288,
-0.00047888,
0.0266551599,
0.024243053,
-0.0709468648,
-0.017993629,
0.0155221624,
-0.0263234545,
-0.0175726954,
-0.0042572985,
-0.0075941589,
-0.1030429304,
0.0176050477,
0.0212464053,
0.0002489251,
-0.0292428341,
-0.0315414816,
0.0236811005,
-0.0083099697,
0.0093415817,
-0.0570349395,
-0.0212869048,
-0.0643937066,
0.0248143021,
-0.0366819985,
-0.0980534926,
0.0236309171,
-0.0472610444,
0.0461435616,
0.0655572116,
-0.0016005357,
0.0081471568,
0.0198497474,
0.0273761582,
0.0019577427,
0.0038426425,
-0.0171327684,
-0.0205385759,
0.0009761873,
-0.0154525246,
-0.0192310065,
0.0056888931,
-0.0257832333,
-0.0175308082,
0.0206162352,
0.1081425771,
-0.0161425509,
-0.0055623185,
-0.0305150356,
-0.0200212784,
0.0010798473,
0.0796706006,
-0.0000104876,
-0.0639941692,
-0.0052602831,
-0.0066766762,
-0.0486880392,
0.005602126,
-0.0685666054,
-0.0022556162,
-0.014185817,
-0.0123245157,
-0.0234674122,
0.0204539709,
0.0229286067,
-0.0102594784,
0.0515102819,
0.0373194106,
0.0528155081,
-0.0176351201,
-0.0372915119,
0.0120137418,
-0.0841973275,
0.0302649438,
-0.0620393716,
0.0105289482,
0.0600187294,
-0.0260535385,
-0.019606242,
0.035526067,
-0.0547327101,
-0.0830260441,
0.0092210956,
0.0006898035,
0.0221364349,
0.0405268781,
-0.025566645,
-0.0769658089,
0.0281399749,
0.017065404,
-0.0213491637,
0.0130705107,
0.0219590478,
-0.015770942,
-0.0065109716,
0.0543302409,
-0.0326519124,
0.0612379722,
0.0105053857,
0.0180859398,
-0.0251968894,
-0.0284642559,
0.0147353625,
0.005875912,
0.0214145072,
-0.0220125206,
-0.0438497588,
-0.0258860439,
-0.0233464707,
-0.055949226,
-0.0555283837,
-0.036991246,
-0.0273377039,
0.0100110583,
0.0058483826,
-0.0228449628,
0.0142440302,
-0.0270239003,
0.0198172312,
-0.0373953059,
0.0656686053,
-0.0051174113,
0.0024003668,
0.0204832405,
0.0114966631,
0.0034123063,
0.0220391713,
-0.0137883285,
0.0036520171,
-0.0293361396,
0.0401476696,
-0.0042665387,
0.0161345918,
-0.0352452844,
0.021911297,
-0.0001242657,
-0.042338945,
0.0066019837,
0.0269317478,
0.0466638245,
-0.0146147748,
0.0463924296,
-0.0336021446,
-0.0302416179,
-0.0306444261,
0.0070394715,
0.0568644255,
-0.0411572494,
-0.0014631833,
0.0358053409,
-0.050565362,
0.0168802962,
0.0541362241,
0.0519872904,
0.0423378758,
0.0032651254,
-0.0465949327,
-0.0142462952,
-0.0351217017,
0.0367002264,
-0.0145728448,
-0.0562833771,
0.0173975043,
-0.1289327592,
-0.0715363026,
0.0076402309,
-0.0164864026,
-0.0136326142,
-0.034790501,
0.0234790593,
0.061850559,
0.0023793106,
-0.012835524,
-0.0533999354,
-0.0112473862,
-0.0023783764,
-0.0261811037,
0.02323737,
-6.258201885e-33,
-0.0174133107,
-0.0109905005,
0.0220541283,
-0.0270553641,
-0.0152707016,
0.0149121527,
0.0093135303,
-0.010025816,
-0.0010398442,
-0.0284803789,
0.0203848034,
-0.0084477412,
0.0122044086,
0.0321454555,
0.0020883884,
0.0248580556,
0.0584946722,
0.0097737908,
0.0059821391,
-0.0141848829,
0.0205712505,
-0.0115665114,
0.0231581908,
-0.0885592476,
0.0381952412,
-0.0146180177,
-0.0056579453,
0.0371878259,
0.0303866081,
0.0788550377,
-0.0466243289,
0.0639443249,
0.0381515771,
-0.0741816238,
-0.0288152918,
0.0304635782,
-0.0809381008,
0.0188851915,
0.0338297896,
0.0044280486,
0.0458004363,
-0.0359740332,
0.0307637788,
0.0003877014,
-0.0071673626,
0.0048029758,
0.0234363638,
-0.0422270261,
0.0000964493,
0.015359072,
-0.0889347717,
0.0391042233,
0.0294226427,
-0.0047464711,
0.0778513923,
0.0070535769,
-0.006140002,
0.0411416329,
-0.0128031839,
0.0358478576,
0.0349930786,
0.034760721,
0.0732928365,
0.0195816103,
-0.0000219045,
0.0290351175,
-0.0272890441,
0.0226290338,
0.0197823979,
-0.0377681665,
-0.0017033943,
0.0524883941,
-0.0192978773,
0.0519226268,
-0.0169768482,
-0.0055908202,
-0.0655672029,
0.0029174949,
-0.0208122842,
0.0027740491,
0.0490987822,
0.0136783868,
-0.0507615991,
-0.0421240665,
-0.0204100609,
0.0081099616,
-0.0285908394,
0.0006387461,
0.0355183557,
0.0189500935,
-0.0499107912,
0.062846601,
0.0287188273,
-0.0947485119,
-0.0390045755,
0.0023503904,
0.0205053743,
0.0153978784,
0.0040967846,
0.0191742722,
-0.030415656,
-0.0547546744,
-0.0143276695,
-0.023682883,
-0.0081235012,
-0.0205399897,
0.0032817486,
0.0110897338,
-0.0332360044,
0.0151902242,
-0.0087880008,
0.0018590492,
-0.0182956643,
0.0763757005,
0.041115161,
0.0341027305,
0.0216428284,
0.0412771404,
0.0696520433,
-0.0541956052,
0.0049098385,
0.0345117897,
-0.0163965933,
0.0112493411,
-0.0009366985,
0.01619526,
-0.0145721156,
0.00896353,
0.0532862023,
-0.0027742295,
-0.0262862332,
-0.0501386859,
2.874e-7,
0.041687008,
0.0433731191,
0.0058602314,
0.0275595021,
0.0285961814,
0.0301853418,
0.0040791379,
0.0050748968,
-0.0132101038,
-0.0014591974,
0.0072874087,
0.0232208557,
0.0554505251,
-0.0054851081,
-0.0688126683,
0.0215063151,
0.0402384549,
0.0124558862,
-0.0729309246,
-0.0066668559,
0.0029537205,
0.0918496773,
0.016485367,
-0.0065967906,
-0.057405293,
-0.0453525409,
0.051464621,
-0.0318680406,
-0.0204186235,
0.065809615,
-0.0087162713,
0.0264117159,
0.0062649678,
0.0034039402,
0.0100332564,
0.0433889516,
0.0449432321,
0.1024883911,
-0.0002769021,
0.0567470267,
-0.0251029097,
-0.0313553177,
-0.0195597075,
-0.0328162946,
0.0592748374,
-0.0549810752,
-0.0387310758,
-0.0379697457,
0.0069066063,
-0.0213368479,
-0.037582323,
-0.0025964088,
-0.0128183328,
0.0152722234,
0.0267751925,
0.0040668026,
-0.0251507089,
-0.0735865012,
-0.0029688941,
-0.0116671678,
-0.0526845492,
-0.0117342034,
0.0111208986,
-0.0057341536,
0.0285454262,
-0.0626072437,
0.0151739689,
3.259736982e-34,
0.0257307664,
0.0022141314,
-0.0195385832,
0.0249717552,
0.0126044648,
0.0108596971,
-0.055468943,
0.0475692414,
-0.0009881104,
-0.0683916211,
0.0069822627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18679v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18679v2 | KEYword based Sampling (KEYS) for Large Language Models | 2023-05-30T01:35:04 | 2023-06-02T02:35:03 | Jyothir S V, Zuhaib Akhtar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Question answering (Q/A) can be formulated as a generative task (Mitra, 2017)
where the task is to generate an answer given the question and the passage
(knowledge, if available). Recent advances in QA task is focused a lot on
language model advancements and less on other areas such as sampling(Krishna et
al., 2021), (Nakano et al., 2021). Keywords play very important role for humans
in language generation. (Humans formulate keywords and use grammar to connect
those keywords and work). In the research community, very little focus is on
how humans generate answers to a question and how this behavior can be
incorporated in a language model. In this paper, we want to explore these two
areas combined, i.e., how sampling can be to used generate answers which are
close to human-like behavior and factually correct. Hence, the type of decoding
algorithm we think should be used for Q/A tasks should also depend on the
keywords. These keywords can be obtained from the question, passage or internet
results. We use knowledge distillation techniques to extract keywords and
sample using these extracted keywords on top of vanilla decoding algorithms
when formulating the answer to generate a human-like answer. In this paper, we
show that our decoding method outperforms most commonly used decoding methods
for Q/A task | [
0.0858844742,
0.0310616083,
-0.0100062676,
0.00651658,
-0.0236424003,
0.0146184405,
-0.0559574999,
0.0297563281,
-0.0062913839,
-0.0516637117,
0.0148227913,
-0.0361108705,
-0.0240987502,
0.0323592946,
0.0353737548,
-0.0670233369,
0.0206221845,
-0.0491943844,
0.0148175023,
-0.0201481376,
0.029163938,
0.0230392963,
0.009029014,
0.015152134,
0.0281643141,
-0.0035848252,
-0.0429884978,
-0.050089255,
-0.0189296044,
0.0396098047,
0.0264228247,
0.0538337566,
-0.0050036982,
-0.0075037754,
0.000001809,
-0.0458621979,
-0.0004007935,
-0.0165636074,
-0.0335391872,
0.0290240571,
0.0122640897,
0.0138988262,
0.0325653404,
0.0458658636,
-0.0668177605,
0.0079875728,
0.0337451585,
0.0333976187,
0.0625704154,
0.0427994989,
0.0294043869,
-0.0153233074,
0.0004928875,
-0.0122281173,
0.0195365921,
-0.0548357964,
0.0227182191,
0.0210987087,
0.0116850045,
0.0158232003,
-0.0250564497,
0.0162781235,
0.0174763016,
0.0265721511,
0.0283096172,
0.02886061,
-0.0377342254,
-0.0203336868,
-0.0155260582,
0.0748751014,
-0.0204633083,
-0.0208744779,
0.0425400659,
0.0192729961,
-0.0060845595,
0.0463440828,
-0.0529110767,
0.0311170276,
-0.0137122776,
0.018499637,
0.0204919335,
0.0082560508,
-0.0136877047,
0.0108658364,
-0.024643708,
0.0626132861,
0.017069729,
-0.0279477499,
-0.0161974318,
-0.0077825622,
-0.0447137207,
-0.0941460654,
0.0262635294,
0.0394115113,
0.0024075694,
0.0119747268,
-0.0492562577,
-0.0184054933,
0.0516961738,
-0.0392552614,
-0.0029290761,
-0.0025079772,
0.0480897911,
0.0232945122,
0.0057510678,
0.0454463288,
-0.0165241696,
0.0070342133,
-0.0663926527,
-0.0095072165,
-0.03631806,
-0.034362182,
-0.0426813737,
0.0505725108,
-0.0444792993,
-0.0124341697,
-0.0054974519,
0.0117236916,
0.0466271751,
-0.0464381762,
0.029297946,
0.0540696383,
-0.0566007122,
-0.0133471685,
-0.0139502389,
0.0228347834,
-0.089845255,
0.0086154388,
0.0079419417,
-0.0510115251,
-0.013803686,
-0.0173244476,
0.0548731945,
-0.0223011766,
-0.0272435211,
0.0306620244,
-0.0236455873,
-0.0071680807,
-0.0082571004,
-0.0691613033,
-0.0217047185,
-0.020240549,
-0.0048179775,
-0.0941823125,
0.0447636656,
0.0094725825,
-0.027662931,
-0.0404620655,
0.0329436995,
0.0453785732,
-0.0258656591,
0.0410437733,
-0.0104750423,
0.0277615283,
0.0074014231,
0.0012856026,
0.0221409146,
0.0619640276,
0.0387245901,
0.0511813909,
0.0452752933,
0.0203690771,
0.0320359133,
0.0143528646,
0.0393163599,
-0.0022492444,
0.0226252563,
0.0099886134,
-0.0265963227,
0.0060765776,
0.0452738591,
0.0675129518,
-0.0369758569,
0.0121558411,
0.0486628525,
0.0262253918,
-0.0283503514,
0.0321183838,
0.0078654597,
0.0595373213,
0.0116175469,
0.0343399122,
-0.0259464253,
0.0122403549,
-0.0155698191,
0.0262027048,
0.0403558537,
0.0369709879,
-0.0103327613,
-0.0332209989,
0.0185732916,
0.0278212242,
0.0038633544,
0.0230820663,
0.0554406494,
0.064246133,
-0.0035618502,
0.073867321,
0.0254284572,
-0.0236149151,
0.0340546742,
-0.0508893318,
0.044131726,
0.0067247134,
0.0409762934,
0.0041763121,
-0.0218462925,
0.0017426484,
-0.00138706,
0.0243002251,
0.0231505278,
-0.0464956909,
-0.0183908716,
-0.0203546733,
-0.0094180554,
-0.0125295902,
-0.0033094271,
-0.0182541814,
0.0357933007,
0.0215290766,
0.0223053768,
-0.1011157632,
0.006679798,
0.0373527333,
-0.0189519357,
-0.0490488596,
0.0036947986,
-0.0190987401,
0.0118097831,
0.0306339152,
-0.0155135924,
0.0398040563,
0.0107563799,
-0.034199819,
-0.0387405418,
-0.0110712387,
-0.0049543036,
-0.0507901497,
0.0327295922,
-0.0434604697,
0.0344191864,
0.0477081835,
-0.0302651133,
-0.0416734219,
0.0118570719,
-0.033338882,
0.0444875285,
-0.0524104014,
-0.013687809,
0.0237223394,
0.0141076604,
-0.0416349657,
0.0684643984,
-0.0081026061,
-0.0040606097,
-0.0408781059,
-0.0531910621,
-0.0223928131,
-0.0325639173,
-0.0252037942,
0.0469602048,
-0.029362008,
0.0438609794,
0.0476894937,
0.0166212525,
-0.0575782582,
-0.003059742,
-0.0782016441,
0.0135412812,
-0.0216035601,
0.0344835445,
0.0239858646,
0.0413214341,
-0.0088389637,
-0.0350389294,
-0.0737466514,
-0.0574403293,
0.0258284826,
0.0241177883,
0.0175887085,
0.0151391206,
0.0254598744,
-0.0140235052,
-0.0106857875,
-0.0023034574,
0.0459283702,
-0.023275109,
-0.0103298342,
-0.0271929242,
0.0434218943,
-0.0162899904,
0.0057224855,
0.0100702746,
-0.0274263136,
-0.0113588031,
-0.0213930253,
0.0273659527,
0.0277111772,
0.0281552095,
-0.0117811486,
0.0040331488,
-0.0199977439,
-0.0614195429,
0.0061601857,
-0.0447228588,
-0.026231885,
0.002270171,
-0.0591265857,
0.0372678451,
0.0685496852,
0.035351865,
-0.0208809245,
-0.0288964733,
0.0462253131,
-0.0140038198,
-0.0561668575,
-0.0567559972,
0.0378067903,
-0.0297308229,
0.0702396631,
-0.0277525857,
-0.0160442851,
0.0436960272,
-0.0112499567,
0.0084343795,
-0.0707075223,
0.0227834564,
0.0030879115,
0.0576649755,
-0.0202959776,
0.0204415061,
0.009157774,
-0.0087444037,
-0.0386772752,
-0.028127132,
0.0070156371,
-0.0714383349,
0.0408133119,
-0.0642504692,
-0.0084923347,
0.0176021624,
-0.016904518,
-0.0781161115,
-0.0108242584,
-0.0394304246,
0.0053384164,
0.0091717504,
0.0079887351,
0.039513506,
0.0236580875,
0.0068817902,
-0.0018098995,
-0.0244841333,
0.0006708828,
-0.0165457521,
0.0975702778,
0.1044886038,
0.0205726624,
0.0265222602,
0.0038531816,
0.0239831842,
0.0842487514,
0.0756304637,
0.034718655,
0.0226865336,
0.0121582719,
0.0206175372,
-0.053938318,
0.0026908503,
0.0253740475,
0.0402442478,
-0.0316866077,
-0.0358605348,
0.0946100429,
0.052950412,
-0.0132546211,
0.0117767481,
0.0005044212,
0.0184655003,
0.0100342417,
0.0493188724,
-0.0509992614,
-0.0256070141,
0.0185055509,
0.0438157804,
-0.0146412812,
-0.0387872905,
0.0028816587,
-0.1153202876,
0.0264103096,
-0.0154642612,
-0.0388512202,
-0.0696481243,
-0.0545709431,
-0.0032519915,
0.0094477162,
-0.0168272518,
0.0346791856,
-0.0095069725,
0.0579746068,
0.03846265,
0.000801129,
-0.0413099751,
0.0197485667,
-0.0503631942,
0.0476455688,
0.088398084,
0.048630923,
0.0029293955,
0.0052911402,
-0.0612760745,
-0.0453238785,
-0.0265800506,
0.0049150554,
0.0043953499,
-0.0102393627,
-0.0093629789,
-0.0275007896,
0.0607152358,
-0.085490033,
0.0076846564,
0.0383219868,
0.057450112,
-0.0087506194,
-0.0486561432,
-0.0264524668,
-0.0088235363,
0.0235214047,
0.0761103183,
0.045775339,
-0.0318283066,
-0.0502128117,
-0.0234831925,
0.0169854984,
-0.0800098479,
-0.0555877276,
0.0108659491,
0.0042316695,
0.0376320407,
-0.1229644641,
-0.0415940918,
0.033201281,
0.0366817713,
-0.0275224354,
0.0414080024,
0.0525521785,
0.0014789947,
-0.0448505282,
-0.0262491368,
-0.049105145,
-0.0163211767,
-0.0019458011,
-0.0328160599,
-0.0146415411,
-0.0581930615,
-0.0459506363,
0.0267090965,
-0.0804227367,
-0.0384566933,
0.0225148685,
0.0393781736,
0.0225178301,
0.0202399883,
-0.0402659364,
-0.0338825174,
0.0369408578,
0.0151296817,
-0.0339161679,
0.0196059383,
-0.0050552557,
-0.0029259964,
-0.0074328273,
0.0552804619,
-0.0655002668,
-0.0031037126,
-0.0047918386,
0.0786140636,
-0.0480433032,
-0.0384714156,
0.0363549218,
0.0380852558,
-0.0126210405,
-0.0149600944,
0.0120112263,
-0.019853076,
-0.0143173868,
0.0093711885,
-0.021095613,
-0.0529382899,
0.0196197052,
0.0156839341,
-0.0126164351,
0.0091681471,
0.0146705182,
-0.0179509353,
0.0132533358,
-0.0181200262,
-0.0182716642,
0.0245180782,
-0.0005555659,
0.0212467723,
-0.0010365824,
-0.0011688365,
0.0047405954,
-0.0121939508,
0.0704829097,
-0.0050489716,
0.0228150804,
0.0083769122,
-0.0447201729,
-0.0220848694,
0.0173311345,
-0.083660543,
-0.0465775914,
-0.0435988307,
0.0209232755,
0.0206349585,
-0.0099509563,
0.0249600913,
-0.0153760361,
-0.0128852921,
-0.0082016485,
0.0155615546,
0.0017725057,
0.0081366003,
0.0159164295,
0.023097042,
-0.0184474476,
0.0064827246,
0.1173398569,
0.0316427462,
0.0484106466,
0.0114704985,
-0.0222876724,
-0.0263042133,
-0.0163073596,
-0.0144003807,
0.0208172388,
0.0069636921,
0.009419078,
-0.0536547527,
-0.0659452528,
0.0329834595,
-0.0060148234,
0.0174721591,
-0.0484606549,
0.0508307628,
0.062204089,
-0.0009999824,
-0.0299138688,
-0.0860437304,
0.051374726,
-0.0604237914,
-0.0378416553,
-0.0229673106,
-6.232032442e-33,
-0.0170907099,
-0.0195339341,
-0.0079167513,
-0.0049745948,
-0.015812397,
-0.002174797,
-0.0165247414,
-0.0121272262,
-0.013202237,
0.0254091006,
-0.039524354,
0.0038280112,
0.0064936019,
0.028468553,
0.0032721178,
-0.0294205081,
0.0090971151,
-0.0475101992,
-0.0171059985,
0.0318733416,
0.0007107829,
0.0308440793,
0.0200634692,
0.0195113644,
0.0230481327,
-0.0542068072,
0.0106011089,
0.0223660953,
0.0005046209,
0.0639886782,
-0.0393263623,
0.0653355569,
0.0273981187,
-0.0560763925,
-0.0231844261,
0.0596913211,
-0.0989381522,
-0.0555616058,
0.0330313742,
-0.0149319274,
-0.0466545485,
-0.0066407858,
0.0229750294,
-0.0168530475,
0.042565383,
0.027079029,
0.0229841005,
-0.0126705803,
-0.0397088937,
-0.0523259193,
-0.0201439112,
0.0063067689,
-0.0068078618,
-0.0401883572,
0.0032838422,
0.0142667275,
-0.0376090407,
-0.0068757068,
0.0004146339,
0.0095623229,
0.0704652518,
0.0452654362,
0.0412250943,
0.0438069552,
0.0095340181,
0.0572793782,
-0.0262756143,
-0.0422785208,
-0.0369324759,
0.0265856162,
0.0161366649,
0.0339270271,
-0.0249732677,
0.0752413943,
0.028903937,
0.0160497595,
-0.0074204705,
0.0316950791,
0.0286894366,
0.0229168572,
0.0249099787,
-0.040662609,
-0.029139176,
-0.0274260305,
-0.061084196,
-0.0152457217,
-0.0254311543,
-0.0205661692,
0.0536702164,
0.010343886,
-0.09486112,
-0.0199613962,
0.0138033824,
-0.047902476,
0.0321854465,
0.0192717649,
0.0040685688,
0.0197815485,
-0.0036257927,
0.0242894571,
-0.044604931,
0.0272756349,
0.0039556613,
-0.0262409337,
-0.0298963469,
0.0063470704,
-0.0356986634,
-0.018530665,
-0.0245550014,
0.009206445,
-0.0369201303,
0.0508655347,
-0.006518492,
0.0202345829,
0.0305443816,
0.0283427369,
-0.0159270149,
0.006091496,
0.0312274508,
0.0094785746,
-0.0137497839,
0.0153238866,
-0.0004109851,
0.0206040051,
-0.0312676877,
0.0057562501,
-0.0598543361,
-0.0037078382,
-0.0160683375,
-0.013823742,
-0.0170596745,
0.042171333,
2.518e-7,
0.050876569,
0.0314210542,
0.0574394278,
0.0334737636,
0.0270355698,
0.023109708,
0.0725510046,
0.0392472893,
0.0103849936,
-0.0523166321,
-0.0013752801,
0.05561167,
-0.0035809341,
0.0139347492,
-0.1084443554,
-0.002478671,
-0.0343968682,
-0.0120037366,
-0.0083170244,
-0.0539843366,
0.0407846048,
0.0569274426,
0.017521983,
-0.0193278324,
-0.0140394708,
-0.0333229266,
0.0215483457,
0.022453757,
-0.0239683203,
0.0553645752,
0.0009382295,
-0.0019221089,
0.0215954967,
0.0383919999,
-0.0018072607,
-0.0056830477,
0.0494619608,
0.0548277982,
-0.0004989928,
-0.0247092843,
-0.0286567491,
-0.0289426055,
0.0365543999,
-0.0657255352,
0.0915910825,
-0.0420001149,
-0.0147826811,
-0.058235947,
-0.0265853405,
-0.0116435196,
-0.0537188835,
-0.0341800302,
-0.0108275488,
0.0239155479,
0.0233128071,
0.0226605348,
-0.0052485284,
-0.0359030701,
-0.0125387609,
-0.0068519814,
-0.0469760038,
-0.0559993535,
-0.0285009742,
-0.0363269597,
-0.0109536378,
-0.0465487987,
0.0055759996,
2.047575702e-34,
0.0254632067,
0.036103379,
-0.0055028293,
0.048457697,
0.0257977769,
-0.0121814907,
-0.0210121516,
0.0040327087,
0.0194049384,
-0.0831336975,
-0.0210124571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18675v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18675v1 | History Repeats: Overcoming Catastrophic Forgetting For Event-Centric Temporal Knowledge Graph Completion | 2023-05-30T01:21:36 | 2023-05-30T01:21:36 | Mehrnoosh Mirtaheri, Mohammad Rostami, Aram Galstyan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.6; I.2.7 | Temporal knowledge graph (TKG) completion models typically rely on having
access to the entire graph during training. However, in real-world scenarios,
TKG data is often received incrementally as events unfold, leading to a dynamic
non-stationary data distribution over time. While one could incorporate
fine-tuning to existing methods to allow them to adapt to evolving TKG data,
this can lead to forgetting previously learned patterns. Alternatively,
retraining the model with the entire updated TKG can mitigate forgetting but is
computationally burdensome. To address these challenges, we propose a general
continual training framework that is applicable to any TKG completion method,
and leverages two key ideas: (i) a temporal regularization that encourages
repurposing of less important model parameters for learning new knowledge, and
(ii) a clustering-based experience replay that reinforces the past knowledge by
selectively preserving only a small portion of the past data. Our experimental
results on widely used event-centric TKG datasets demonstrate the effectiveness
of our proposed continual training framework in adapting to new events while
reducing catastrophic forgetting. Further, we perform ablation studies to show
the effectiveness of each component of our proposed framework. Finally, we
investigate the relation between the memory dedicated to experience replay and
the benefit gained from our clustering-based sampling strategy. | [
-0.0109722959,
0.0278257616,
-0.0156237232,
-0.0050486713,
-0.0113396253,
-0.0004772238,
-0.0557383448,
-0.0205214098,
0.0752932131,
0.0228133798,
0.0330975875,
0.0151542816,
-0.0052522551,
0.0619492531,
-0.0088372286,
-0.0602055192,
0.0564300083,
0.0241901632,
-0.0267839972,
-0.0100205746,
0.0039466363,
-0.0232167523,
-0.0283779334,
0.0008130975,
-0.0287111476,
0.0036914861,
-0.0668429434,
-0.0267767366,
0.0331133977,
-0.0554061942,
-0.0033273192,
-0.010348781,
0.0334390588,
-0.0330614261,
0.0000022684,
-0.0067633898,
-0.0336029306,
-0.0451878682,
-0.0291639678,
-0.0178474654,
0.0003318363,
0.0279191975,
0.0205546916,
-0.0344741754,
-0.0436148532,
-0.0309243873,
0.0252417978,
0.0507540666,
0.0123554524,
0.0211034324,
-0.0062481337,
0.0371463895,
0.0638741702,
-0.0203490574,
0.027798878,
-0.0226256009,
0.0207505208,
-0.0006880063,
0.0090603326,
-0.047038909,
-0.0185435861,
0.0332322307,
0.0429613106,
0.054075554,
0.0711521208,
0.0622264668,
0.0104896734,
0.0507502034,
0.0115132397,
0.0478878245,
0.0349482559,
-0.0157531891,
0.0172745883,
0.0305168964,
0.0061023417,
-0.0174919292,
-0.0503058247,
-0.0595211759,
-0.0444063321,
0.0031877272,
-0.0639871135,
-0.0204837285,
0.0316298865,
-0.0030143929,
-0.0207394045,
0.0280622952,
-0.0078442646,
-0.0054839128,
-0.0463608094,
-0.0079392251,
-0.0074447929,
-0.0273597185,
0.0228609182,
0.0468147397,
-0.0167496316,
0.0107716219,
-0.018777892,
0.060014911,
-0.0025070575,
0.0020333133,
-0.0119471597,
0.028003905,
0.0030637134,
0.0419906862,
-0.0177395809,
0.0078132208,
0.0078422651,
-0.0000778345,
-0.0379390195,
0.0237129182,
-0.0953640938,
0.026062984,
-0.0156211341,
0.0790719911,
0.0520959981,
0.0102847284,
-0.0419375338,
0.0484578311,
-0.0222142264,
0.0351184793,
-0.0546526909,
0.0183265526,
-0.0401849337,
-0.0021072263,
-0.0102649219,
0.0066999025,
-0.0122966515,
0.025106525,
-0.0068909368,
0.02499176,
-0.0221213084,
-0.0465753041,
0.0217609499,
0.0013791944,
-0.0068239328,
0.0096263466,
-0.0341407694,
-0.0366241522,
-0.1024445891,
-0.0336553678,
-0.0060508321,
-0.0064277956,
-0.0300573371,
-0.0426337011,
0.0424243473,
-0.0120769395,
-0.0171011649,
-0.017233137,
0.0088663697,
-0.022579005,
-0.0564664789,
0.0508027673,
0.0218117293,
-0.0206896383,
0.0193621907,
-0.0021315012,
-0.0160199683,
0.0144421104,
0.0370768793,
0.036393635,
0.0013016646,
0.0369205214,
-0.0346637517,
0.0005605675,
0.0595914647,
0.0098519977,
-0.0528661236,
-0.0322117954,
0.0065423963,
0.0208413024,
0.0377196819,
-0.0071760169,
-0.0703145415,
0.0059026922,
0.0288409367,
-0.0178258587,
-0.0344694667,
0.0212489497,
0.0034522291,
-0.045791585,
-0.0008504235,
0.0431410298,
-0.0559706576,
0.0223443825,
-0.0145475119,
0.0242274813,
-0.0134389959,
-0.0106074437,
-0.0359993465,
-0.033991091,
0.0643981993,
-0.0292004365,
0.0769862905,
0.0292269289,
0.0758608952,
0.0263258442,
-0.0275625437,
0.0643280372,
0.0403007604,
-0.0032271384,
0.0266913678,
0.0107401013,
0.0333489627,
0.0660508573,
0.070579119,
-0.0419983678,
-0.0505742952,
-0.0130454749,
0.0217252411,
-0.0603873171,
0.0274497718,
-0.0411277637,
0.0096051954,
-0.0237075705,
-0.0681197792,
0.0229669083,
-0.0062750634,
0.017282946,
0.0601582006,
0.0371208973,
-0.0025430175,
-0.037792597,
-0.0365745649,
-0.0055661337,
-0.0524435267,
-0.0211672112,
-0.0186889414,
-0.0110983923,
-0.0042324332,
-0.0078404052,
0.0177285112,
-0.0127965203,
0.0610803738,
-0.022608133,
-0.0247992538,
0.0306134541,
-0.0456719398,
-0.0434245653,
0.0662507191,
0.0111101428,
-0.016067287,
-0.0057044183,
-0.0494991057,
-0.0468376949,
0.0710006729,
0.0201919675,
0.0965431184,
-0.0051661092,
0.0205931328,
-0.0085354038,
-0.042028904,
-0.0265281722,
0.0386940576,
-0.0255121458,
-0.0243786518,
-0.0367074832,
-0.0205392372,
0.006076653,
-0.0538828224,
-0.0196765363,
-0.0168022159,
0.0051217494,
-0.0056292354,
0.0173631925,
-0.0442665219,
-0.1006332561,
0.0049054194,
-0.1056139097,
0.0203263462,
0.0390953571,
-0.0098259021,
-0.0206388142,
0.0020908134,
-0.002454926,
-0.0539334156,
0.0129927536,
-0.0060347561,
-0.0389914773,
0.0248021111,
0.0095741367,
0.043589022,
-0.0009135192,
-0.0216233581,
-0.0227276981,
-0.0181848817,
0.031571418,
-0.0094227316,
-0.0194604844,
-0.0105697475,
0.0140806679,
-0.0304438714,
0.0196343157,
-0.0390426554,
0.022005992,
0.000274729,
-0.0298442263,
0.0258132499,
0.0820999816,
-0.0065735052,
0.0128827617,
0.0214990731,
-0.032392744,
-0.0555725992,
0.0243129581,
-0.0706763938,
-0.0264377985,
-0.004721323,
0.0198075958,
-0.0379420035,
0.0035753625,
0.01323504,
0.0030166169,
-0.0423654318,
-0.0415825136,
-0.0322417431,
0.0071033225,
-0.0393583886,
-0.0009756369,
-0.0255418755,
-0.055467993,
-0.0589963496,
-0.0163821299,
0.0689229146,
0.0660384074,
0.0127759557,
0.0196370482,
0.0182769559,
0.0094524352,
0.0768828467,
0.0020803411,
-0.002016335,
0.0101812277,
-0.0326746143,
-0.0305194873,
-0.0240199529,
0.0240847431,
-0.0076738088,
0.0103668524,
-0.0192350838,
-0.0010476131,
0.0381563045,
0.0010045081,
-0.0701175705,
0.0023882424,
0.0284494143,
-0.025042817,
-0.0460722968,
0.0279191472,
-0.0438041314,
-0.0270352941,
0.038866356,
0.0150821684,
-0.0068571302,
-0.0479883216,
-0.0047945762,
0.0541004427,
0.0209611487,
-0.0178368948,
-0.0022079737,
-0.0091483919,
-0.0192760937,
0.0791234225,
0.1335853189,
-0.0323971845,
-0.0175338909,
0.0142653733,
-0.0376818031,
-0.0494093299,
-0.0144673474,
0.0166611392,
0.0017373359,
-0.0659487545,
0.0149534708,
0.0538306944,
0.021144066,
-0.0364672318,
0.0134782782,
0.0364216641,
0.0312698558,
0.0147961676,
-0.0036414438,
-0.062946707,
0.0194753408,
0.0000513462,
0.047249686,
0.0218328983,
-0.0529621355,
0.0045983354,
-0.0277197678,
-0.013332543,
0.0604707226,
-0.0034166267,
-0.0000880229,
-0.0557484776,
0.0061780033,
-0.0135090183,
-0.0125796441,
0.0381401777,
0.0035455266,
-0.0090830037,
0.0437471867,
-0.0406520776,
-0.0583272539,
0.0432451963,
-0.0135128135,
0.0400521196,
-0.0243866686,
0.0133136874,
-0.0066980119,
0.0105658369,
0.0137421172,
0.0488917492,
0.0084648179,
0.0023078555,
0.0473062322,
0.0155774849,
0.0076242979,
0.0141804535,
0.0479392819,
-0.001168295,
-0.0299622323,
0.0320611186,
0.1080777645,
0.0068935012,
0.0072497129,
0.0143804811,
-0.0624443144,
0.0178159587,
0.0143213701,
0.0036060917,
0.0138915135,
-0.0234561339,
0.0070644212,
0.0211117081,
-0.040418908,
0.0221661068,
0.0199794825,
-0.0270539094,
0.0341315456,
-0.0290658958,
-0.0508307852,
0.0121684326,
0.0152883548,
-0.0067581316,
0.0081303008,
0.0222654622,
-0.0314631201,
-0.0960386172,
0.0378738679,
-0.0425409526,
-0.0179991592,
-0.0053766202,
-0.0080897547,
-0.0339128152,
0.0039597992,
0.0077863745,
0.022020312,
-0.0714002848,
-0.0402186476,
0.0108943349,
0.0125922561,
0.0028693317,
0.1390216202,
-0.0026225061,
-0.001505285,
0.0753003359,
0.001512688,
0.0037961069,
0.0181972403,
0.0112793632,
0.0014883145,
-0.0179719832,
0.0252217483,
-0.0490443781,
-0.0139284851,
-0.0024623249,
0.037356846,
-0.0209151804,
0.0352065712,
0.0048149498,
-0.000367336,
0.0364699624,
0.0205217078,
-0.0183497984,
-0.0217512343,
0.0039028616,
0.0176264774,
0.0236209929,
-0.0220056344,
-0.0082294066,
0.0246217027,
0.0058581061,
-0.0007367972,
-0.0541093349,
0.0266834684,
0.0264359768,
-0.0538924746,
-0.0553176887,
0.01086789,
-0.0497388206,
0.0650073215,
0.0286176633,
-0.0526789241,
0.018799372,
0.0023788386,
0.003895313,
-0.035553731,
-0.0015316678,
0.0293774009,
0.016742792,
-0.0753499717,
-0.0261596534,
-0.0672973022,
0.0152443238,
-0.0114125935,
-0.00668609,
0.091194436,
0.008116358,
0.0288798641,
-0.0261054169,
0.0149254417,
-0.0326436274,
0.0000833793,
-0.0186356977,
-0.0427388027,
-0.0223812982,
0.0069257277,
0.0015486302,
0.083277531,
0.0855335891,
-0.0297894515,
0.1028513908,
-0.0201958958,
-0.0239240751,
-0.0403600149,
-0.0182862971,
0.0387573279,
0.0434998125,
-0.0230339337,
-0.0141971717,
-0.0061398097,
-0.0377353169,
0.0531865619,
-0.0287349671,
-0.0281124376,
-0.0332523026,
0.0166463815,
0.0161002409,
0.0210188068,
-0.0105994195,
-0.0187888518,
0.0312881693,
0.0646159723,
-0.0302767679,
-0.0100680236,
-6.348044918e-33,
-0.0066186539,
0.0132129062,
0.0270493161,
0.0262238141,
-0.0627119467,
0.0032706182,
-0.0440158062,
-0.0093078958,
0.0089614969,
0.0160704385,
-0.0221773833,
0.0217216853,
-0.0042350893,
-0.0091723949,
0.0569513068,
-0.0076740799,
0.0589027405,
0.0139350807,
0.0220605955,
0.0739811286,
0.085692063,
0.0633761212,
0.0369579829,
-0.0650895908,
0.0066746571,
0.0330476426,
0.0306525659,
-0.0099426256,
0.0433862954,
0.0602551922,
-0.0113416715,
0.0434623137,
0.0003797363,
-0.0384677537,
-0.0340472199,
-0.0686962381,
-0.1372616142,
-0.060494449,
-0.0375140458,
0.0073159081,
-0.0121149952,
-0.0193390232,
0.0237638764,
-0.024176687,
0.0152118681,
-0.0457428545,
0.0167962536,
-0.0299304705,
-0.1193231717,
-0.0395085029,
0.0253124628,
0.0199469011,
-0.0160720553,
-0.012552049,
-0.0225580707,
-0.0231337175,
0.0013169046,
-0.0520128421,
-0.0681656599,
0.0068768868,
-0.0198387019,
-0.0023049791,
-0.0037886587,
-0.0048929723,
0.0222994443,
0.0341172814,
-0.0054184264,
0.0299526919,
-0.0070157214,
0.0380090736,
0.0380449407,
-0.0026735396,
-0.0546747334,
-0.0144073488,
0.0001369759,
-0.0502474532,
-0.0347678177,
0.0364740752,
0.0434260331,
0.0631365478,
0.0003250449,
0.0262719207,
-0.036139071,
-0.0256713722,
-0.0417594127,
0.0277294405,
-0.0112928916,
-0.019077478,
0.0132118165,
0.0533271432,
0.0044607464,
-0.0163679719,
-0.0037959884,
-0.0350778662,
-0.0117025618,
0.0452599488,
0.0008568875,
0.013279032,
0.0156406797,
0.0353018381,
-0.0419912301,
0.0048118331,
-0.003290802,
-0.0557222366,
0.0020673671,
0.0063285092,
0.042155955,
0.0670512617,
0.0098630032,
0.0056118495,
0.0178246256,
0.0009176756,
0.0367322452,
-0.0661319047,
0.0607830361,
0.0459106602,
0.0110820299,
0.026970746,
0.0589593388,
0.0299476199,
-0.0234616362,
0.0269888751,
0.0346234739,
0.025611205,
0.016802201,
-0.0226080362,
-0.0426544361,
-0.0091675548,
-0.0095543982,
-0.0388417765,
-0.0119247055,
-0.0012227133,
2.892e-7,
-0.0446410626,
0.0047564465,
0.0448269732,
0.0080019562,
0.0309942048,
-0.0028239291,
-0.028416194,
0.0185587294,
-0.0019731808,
0.045694191,
0.0525146872,
0.0330806635,
0.0136979967,
0.0213842355,
-0.0405762866,
-0.022684101,
-0.0210219324,
0.025828246,
-0.0532481596,
-0.0322868414,
0.0097272107,
0.0228656307,
0.0999093875,
0.0145919509,
0.0446008928,
-0.0670194998,
0.089650847,
0.0177899841,
-0.0163011588,
0.0124203712,
0.0277532879,
0.0372250974,
-0.0215453077,
0.0234743375,
-0.0237274785,
-0.0111072827,
-0.0387921184,
0.0232993122,
-0.0121610342,
-0.0386282727,
0.0204505958,
0.0106782243,
0.0037588796,
-0.0363628455,
0.0824780241,
-0.1004492864,
0.0206407364,
0.0607386678,
-0.0255298447,
-0.0019110879,
-0.005972235,
0.052353248,
-0.04124384,
-0.0073004137,
0.0072188773,
0.0746483207,
-0.0102257719,
-0.083630994,
0.0102411173,
0.0440006442,
-0.0487804301,
-0.0320240818,
0.0056557828,
-0.0351359434,
-0.0250236094,
-0.0424842946,
0.0071850298,
2.414014025e-34,
0.0197498836,
0.0051848572,
-0.0217674542,
-0.0034388979,
0.0022688573,
-0.06551373,
0.0144654904,
-0.0146174692,
0.0665233955,
-0.0500309728,
-0.0231489111
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18657v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18657v2 | Representation Of Lexical Stylistic Features In Language Models' Embedding Space | 2023-05-29T23:44:26 | 2023-05-31T22:50:25 | Qing Lyu, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL | The representation space of pretrained Language Models (LMs) encodes rich
information about words and their relationships (e.g., similarity, hypernymy,
polysemy) as well as abstract semantic notions (e.g., intensity). In this
paper, we demonstrate that lexical stylistic notions such as complexity,
formality, and figurativeness, can also be identified in this space. We show
that it is possible to derive a vector representation for each of these
stylistic notions from only a small number of seed pairs. Using these vectors,
we can characterize new texts in terms of these dimensions by performing simple
calculations in the corresponding embedding space. We conduct experiments on
five datasets and find that static embeddings encode these features more
accurately at the level of words and phrases, whereas contextualized LMs
perform better on sentences. The lower performance of contextualized
representations at the word level is partially attributable to the anisotropy
of their vector space, which can be corrected to some extent using techniques
like standardization. | [
0.0155634787,
0.0360432155,
-0.034811493,
0.0396405682,
-0.0294234306,
0.0381449796,
-0.0105290841,
0.0182606038,
-0.0494172312,
-0.0788899362,
-0.0332803316,
-0.0631517842,
0.0153212054,
0.0314780064,
0.0446453802,
-0.0253157225,
0.0035314597,
-0.0064576557,
0.0331433453,
-0.0060325004,
0.0433880165,
0.0198101215,
0.0233775228,
0.0362748504,
-0.0206869319,
-0.0142171634,
-0.0093301935,
-0.0095183095,
-0.0214705784,
0.0006319619,
0.0005660849,
0.0686504021,
0.0352901369,
0.005849455,
0.0000018016,
-0.0397199877,
0.0259693172,
-0.0453769341,
0.0217198059,
0.0349998847,
0.0846071839,
-0.0233634096,
0.0033642929,
-0.0137899863,
-0.0200302079,
-0.0842073336,
0.0271972511,
0.0243430156,
-0.0111186132,
0.0725245848,
-0.0295643564,
-0.0807120502,
0.0381082781,
0.0045969943,
-0.0217718221,
0.0224166457,
0.0279730111,
-0.0121836644,
-0.0687077194,
0.0362273604,
-0.0417396016,
0.0029760115,
-0.0127816452,
0.0256130658,
0.0114919264,
0.0194326304,
-0.0160239693,
0.0173186492,
0.0008272665,
0.0470787883,
0.008719922,
-0.0536534637,
-0.0123990243,
0.0051435288,
-0.0205671992,
0.0143619701,
-0.0172902849,
0.0210131258,
-0.0064170845,
0.0429654531,
0.0364525653,
0.0269768406,
0.0298894029,
0.0153597835,
-0.0014169669,
0.0083010625,
0.0290561486,
-0.0263556205,
-0.0159501843,
-0.0245554559,
-0.0225652307,
-0.0274111796,
0.0049090078,
0.0188953429,
0.0464720093,
0.0187054686,
-0.0408331417,
-0.045407895,
0.0333574265,
-0.0968722254,
0.0754814744,
-0.018405281,
0.0064551295,
0.0169030689,
-0.0479804613,
0.0183056388,
0.0051935785,
0.0370691419,
-0.0513811707,
-0.0101595847,
-0.0407983102,
-0.0292387642,
-0.0576198325,
0.0182317253,
0.0431087352,
-0.0294161048,
-0.0151929213,
0.0226421803,
-0.004974409,
-0.0018955222,
-0.0320804641,
-0.0095893955,
-0.0170688163,
0.0411736928,
0.0006480918,
-0.0566096529,
-0.020052379,
0.0195886139,
-0.0595453866,
-0.0162700415,
0.0334723927,
0.0441994928,
0.045705609,
-0.0142491087,
0.0031805963,
0.0389112122,
0.0171887316,
-0.0574633405,
-0.0184194669,
-0.0224926751,
-0.0105000073,
-0.0020715303,
-0.0306192897,
-0.0530316196,
0.0051193493,
-0.0099323746,
-0.0111621479,
-0.012445434,
-0.0312760584,
0.0172185097,
-0.0572874285,
0.0569880381,
0.0109348679,
0.0151598668,
0.0087852618,
-0.0194510724,
0.018428579,
0.0320527479,
0.0460046008,
0.0116153006,
0.0520867817,
-0.0131759495,
-0.0056607211,
0.01694181,
0.004313725,
0.0214952752,
-0.0906953961,
-0.0277187154,
0.0156983491,
0.0565201789,
0.0212885868,
0.0605443902,
-0.0244216323,
-0.0305098463,
0.0512978919,
0.0567733534,
0.0598312207,
0.0452858582,
0.0973197818,
-0.0025617797,
0.047964979,
0.0363848619,
-0.009414915,
-0.0221040156,
-0.0694756731,
0.0208633635,
-0.0043302909,
-0.0102597103,
-0.0399909765,
-0.024287777,
-0.0306000561,
-0.0223135408,
0.0024629303,
-0.0342471562,
0.034460336,
0.0101718875,
-0.0245869868,
-0.0170377903,
0.035780143,
-0.0506882146,
-0.0199716333,
0.0228304602,
0.0335653014,
0.0731910318,
0.0379493497,
-0.0167404935,
0.0028549242,
0.0116601177,
-0.0264769346,
0.014971179,
0.0412902683,
-0.0409861021,
0.0291957129,
-0.028796941,
0.0270247627,
-0.0321791321,
0.0123877469,
0.0190406591,
-0.0284076743,
0.0251045395,
-0.0043152911,
-0.0387009196,
-0.0325220563,
0.0688955337,
-0.0227385592,
-0.0293214712,
-0.0095275287,
0.024975365,
0.0060784393,
-0.0009928531,
-0.034109436,
0.0014851886,
-0.0034206717,
-0.0688257366,
-0.0131883966,
0.0440603606,
-0.0596433617,
-0.0303332843,
0.0354624689,
-0.0150655042,
0.0244704988,
0.0052618408,
-0.005223169,
-0.0264990535,
0.0244752727,
-0.0146188438,
0.0666546673,
-0.0975872651,
-0.0021713641,
-0.0491222702,
0.0202261787,
-0.0207279399,
0.048616942,
0.0187299866,
0.0502030924,
-0.0294502676,
0.0107590463,
0.0316076465,
0.0391492359,
-0.0452741385,
-0.0269218124,
0.0532322191,
0.0288219657,
0.0051891622,
-0.0374322645,
0.0019207218,
-0.0422317982,
-0.102456443,
-0.0169034563,
-0.0239951815,
-0.008945914,
0.0287310369,
-0.0289382841,
-0.0163313709,
0.010191055,
-0.0542879328,
-0.0002926243,
-0.0317908265,
0.0002990268,
0.0671566278,
-0.0065608863,
-0.0114107933,
-0.0319474228,
-0.0081223426,
-0.0261757541,
0.0760918707,
-0.0035754228,
0.0394344106,
-0.0187719204,
0.010135252,
-0.0134005779,
-0.0042182705,
0.0051945508,
-0.0716778487,
-0.0178392194,
-0.0417533778,
0.0094960993,
0.0192520022,
0.0471881256,
0.0495959632,
0.0988000482,
0.0026878749,
-0.0159561094,
-0.0506939515,
-0.016794797,
0.0465252176,
-0.0147037189,
-0.0087929647,
0.0242462605,
0.0667401999,
0.0297867414,
-0.0385331959,
-0.0190939382,
0.0343321003,
0.0098683797,
0.0284322519,
0.0229888503,
-0.0042025298,
-0.0451041125,
0.0108576976,
-0.0053779655,
-0.0556946881,
0.0389026403,
-0.0541330837,
-0.0165101066,
-0.0230318382,
-0.0455879867,
-0.0359660201,
0.0514321029,
0.017840514,
0.0150594255,
-0.0047327159,
-0.0266088173,
-0.0289147999,
-0.0112039298,
0.0413677581,
-0.0203911681,
0.0266473033,
0.0119943386,
-0.0119678918,
0.0182493329,
0.0226312783,
-0.0249107871,
-0.1034268513,
-0.0119397389,
0.0072562182,
0.0136785442,
-0.0068836669,
0.0372277349,
-0.0210924782,
-0.0387780368,
0.0428211913,
-0.0094720135,
-0.0190542042,
-0.0120886145,
0.0491036437,
0.023096554,
0.0081485324,
-0.0257586557,
-0.0043665706,
0.0303560104,
-0.0038597158,
-0.0574383028,
0.0276491493,
-0.0689281747,
0.0002338257,
0.0313433111,
-0.0498256013,
-0.0438100733,
0.0054632882,
0.0126458379,
-0.0047550402,
-0.0189216491,
0.1419323385,
0.0468581356,
-0.0458442643,
0.0267032441,
0.0195660237,
0.0290460289,
0.0317653865,
0.0197306685,
-0.0474858768,
-0.0042815744,
-0.0050246874,
-0.0259146094,
-0.0109925224,
-0.0060456367,
-0.008688678,
-0.0629478097,
-0.0175361782,
-0.0019440436,
-0.0630140454,
0.0313330553,
0.0124784177,
-0.0075822617,
0.014887955,
0.0096474774,
-0.0283969212,
-0.0203990489,
0.0091824839,
0.00119366,
-0.0433857478,
-0.0387159698,
0.0061042607,
-0.0353596099,
0.025554128,
-0.0114802923,
0.0590464547,
-0.0488761328,
-0.0399520397,
-0.0367595963,
-0.0307112224,
-0.0184376705,
0.0094389897,
0.0622903369,
-0.000046547,
-0.007234863,
-0.0219856929,
0.0036693239,
-0.0093689915,
-0.0001864876,
-0.0266374722,
0.0445301235,
-0.0236166101,
-0.0254985932,
-0.0307947639,
-0.0133938156,
-0.006874661,
0.0673055723,
0.0658441558,
-0.0617780462,
-0.0299629644,
-0.0285762101,
0.0431539677,
-0.023848746,
-0.0368386544,
-0.0019675437,
0.0191715285,
0.0181089249,
-0.1104055494,
-0.037827041,
-0.0209528431,
0.0495040789,
0.0128216343,
0.0043637655,
-0.0324567035,
-0.0506181382,
-0.0596927255,
-0.0059538214,
0.0158885457,
-0.000637339,
-0.0087953322,
-0.0286147781,
0.0458039492,
-0.0179912392,
-0.0003922159,
-0.0220855456,
-0.0265146308,
-0.0608972758,
-0.0104581919,
0.0145570682,
0.0019342514,
0.0010459869,
-0.0142248841,
-0.0545408465,
0.1045914292,
0.0009951354,
0.0057640569,
0.0355281457,
0.0569224656,
0.0257321913,
0.0257873796,
0.0703732371,
-0.0083607947,
0.0441135801,
0.0072335415,
0.0041944631,
0.0161129776,
-0.0133317513,
0.0170465522,
0.004560438,
0.0623351112,
-0.0068902378,
0.0002240894,
-0.0298542269,
-0.0320435837,
-0.0380070657,
-0.0309085995,
-0.022392137,
0.0113207838,
0.0144077474,
-0.0024804948,
-0.0614639521,
0.0009293752,
-0.0080181146,
0.0483672954,
-0.0312292408,
0.0214638468,
0.0331156515,
0.0232652668,
-0.028050106,
0.0578379631,
-0.0297472365,
-0.0015639913,
-0.0480221473,
-0.0127924094,
-0.0178352445,
-0.0107373931,
0.0072340206,
0.0353157073,
-0.0575920939,
0.0232444834,
-0.0521142073,
-0.0007011093,
-0.0007374689,
-0.007009381,
0.0472636372,
-0.0655872673,
0.0215412062,
-0.04424683,
0.0020267211,
-0.0330447443,
0.0513611063,
0.009781545,
-0.0269005112,
0.0220370702,
0.0203011595,
-0.0510312729,
0.0124212392,
0.0757332444,
-0.0189371649,
0.0241037831,
0.0376589522,
-0.0094963629,
-0.0196518302,
0.0209289547,
0.0730403438,
0.0740435347,
0.025914114,
0.0323124044,
-0.0522736572,
-0.0564753078,
0.0771361291,
-0.0126439314,
-0.0067416904,
-0.000113897,
0.0115320189,
0.0280395802,
-0.0092431596,
0.0456401743,
-0.0608621277,
0.0193554256,
-0.0033748876,
-0.0038809909,
-0.0168905556,
-5.735720727e-33,
0.0015295693,
-0.0234208964,
-0.0676176623,
0.0338450037,
-0.0243728627,
0.0397792682,
-0.0151208434,
-0.008775413,
-0.0120417541,
0.0488789715,
-0.0045956373,
0.0088579087,
-0.02883498,
0.0245368462,
0.0085013108,
0.0251999963,
0.0087433979,
-0.0234747604,
-0.025554968,
-0.0098379636,
0.0718674958,
0.0180550981,
0.081338048,
-0.0690407753,
0.0042075198,
-0.0295844395,
0.0047673387,
0.0145957237,
0.0421473384,
0.0610346533,
-0.0174788032,
0.0768414289,
0.0040427619,
-0.0024760119,
-0.0318295248,
0.0131287128,
-0.0342795849,
-0.0949957073,
-0.0058953268,
0.0076778294,
-0.0133395549,
-0.0385157093,
0.0400082096,
-0.0232071914,
0.0001135349,
-0.001793911,
0.066921927,
-0.0000575949,
-0.0408721305,
-0.0578465126,
-0.072272554,
0.0157402661,
-0.0062651881,
0.0192326158,
0.0571142957,
-0.0478351414,
0.0132936323,
0.0143473856,
-0.0327149443,
-0.0125626596,
-0.0560825169,
0.0043387357,
-0.0431921668,
0.0115294438,
0.0173510592,
0.0874590874,
-0.0155288428,
-0.0061356029,
-0.0250509884,
0.0419437848,
0.0811845064,
-0.0124558834,
-0.0050237239,
0.0545034148,
0.0534806177,
-0.0092601646,
-0.0229527578,
-0.0006187351,
0.0372143909,
-0.0123494714,
0.0405272916,
-0.0131640462,
-0.0478741042,
-0.0333944671,
-0.0617942847,
-0.024677122,
-0.0227242466,
-0.0167786591,
-0.0172373168,
-0.0350682661,
0.0039727055,
-0.024951309,
-0.0047410713,
-0.0478946567,
-0.0411047153,
0.044263389,
-0.0404314175,
0.0744209066,
0.0141045824,
0.0214066245,
0.010922838,
-0.0557170324,
-0.0023820288,
0.0041829115,
0.0145729491,
0.0194395687,
0.0767483935,
0.0340655297,
-0.0506637767,
-0.0171686839,
0.0034386907,
-0.0567536056,
-0.0162528679,
0.0119140828,
0.0278008785,
0.022173224,
0.0107503729,
0.0285053644,
0.021063704,
-0.0024929952,
-0.0337527692,
-0.0365017764,
0.0214894339,
0.037932191,
-0.0299950596,
-0.0151528809,
-0.0006598796,
-0.0407098681,
0.0524413809,
-0.0344518609,
0.0276641138,
0.005416031,
2.523e-7,
0.0522444285,
0.0494193025,
0.026790319,
0.0195179433,
0.0419869795,
0.0257087462,
0.0017820896,
0.0494658649,
-0.0634336323,
-0.0125143416,
0.0315298252,
0.0233454462,
0.0428289659,
0.0047537833,
-0.1009117067,
0.0387147181,
-0.0674001202,
0.0470205769,
-0.0173164755,
0.0290652122,
0.0768005699,
0.0891779363,
0.033253137,
-0.0109207947,
-0.0102002826,
-0.0460548364,
0.0766033307,
-0.0507017896,
0.0445926338,
-0.002191744,
0.0141457729,
0.0100921001,
0.0212422628,
0.0245836396,
-0.0146651547,
0.0427592956,
0.0061908187,
0.042551782,
-0.0109172966,
-0.0169654507,
-0.0057008914,
-0.0414039828,
-0.0122771608,
-0.039850384,
0.0633453354,
0.010364187,
-0.0526316948,
-0.0627891719,
0.0281313919,
0.0305715762,
0.0196434017,
0.0109163597,
-0.0374257565,
0.0617135577,
0.0326981843,
-0.0298589841,
0.0081881173,
-0.0895500332,
-0.0193033293,
0.0320771746,
-0.0235198382,
0.0091565037,
0.0144598177,
-0.0005147471,
0.0674020424,
-0.0441080332,
0.0440247282,
2.393408665e-34,
0.0468346775,
0.0120427301,
0.0328665525,
0.0378724672,
0.0020751238,
-0.0035176517,
0.0809871852,
0.0034283847,
0.0324568488,
-0.0984920785,
0.0106393164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18654v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18654v3 | Faith and Fate: Limits of Transformers on Compositionality | 2023-05-29T23:24:14 | 2023-10-31T16:35:07 | Nouha Dziri, Ximing Lu, Melanie Sclar, Xiang Lorraine Li, Liwei Jiang, Bill Yuchen Lin, Peter West, Chandra Bhagavatula, Ronan Le Bras, Jena D. Hwang, Soumya Sanyal, Sean Welleck, Xiang Ren, Allyson Ettinger, Zaid Harchaoui, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Transformer large language models (LLMs) have sparked admiration for their
exceptional performance on tasks that demand intricate multi-step reasoning.
Yet, these models simultaneously show failures on surprisingly trivial
problems. This begs the question: Are these errors incidental, or do they
signal more substantial limitations? In an attempt to demystify transformer
LLMs, we investigate the limits of these models across three representative
compositional tasks -- multi-digit multiplication, logic grid puzzles, and a
classic dynamic programming problem. These tasks require breaking problems down
into sub-steps and synthesizing these steps into a precise answer. We formulate
compositional tasks as computation graphs to systematically quantify the level
of complexity, and break down reasoning steps into intermediate sub-procedures.
Our empirical findings suggest that transformer LLMs solve compositional tasks
by reducing multi-step compositional reasoning into linearized subgraph
matching, without necessarily developing systematic problem-solving skills. To
round off our empirical study, we provide theoretical arguments on abstract
multi-step reasoning problems that highlight how autoregressive generations'
performance can rapidly decay with\,increased\,task\,complexity. | [
0.0084729791,
0.0893348604,
-0.0285744462,
-0.0033666929,
-0.0632760525,
0.0182576347,
-0.0084221028,
-0.0150418542,
-0.0264186095,
-0.0058798939,
0.0104037598,
-0.0202012733,
0.0271601211,
0.0234589335,
0.0061068702,
-0.0097644366,
0.040793132,
-0.0869490132,
-0.0376086682,
-0.0200631302,
-0.0691355988,
-0.0166928302,
-0.0248865783,
0.0370294303,
-0.0041985535,
-0.0126082357,
-0.0157153793,
-0.0415653549,
-0.0094846562,
0.010474449,
-0.0455084145,
0.0122714322,
0.0125760688,
0.075879693,
0.0000021623,
-0.0394687057,
0.0176275969,
-0.0022745705,
-0.0659846291,
-0.0132737337,
0.0051235817,
-0.0092185922,
-0.0177902058,
0.0350013822,
-0.022695668,
-0.0233584717,
0.0429186448,
0.0291559845,
0.0580148324,
0.0495846868,
0.0162333604,
-0.0475758538,
0.0387682132,
-0.0118679563,
0.0415879749,
-0.0194939747,
0.0105085578,
0.0428640954,
0.043413721,
-0.0281556267,
-0.0432806984,
0.0222391523,
0.05129252,
-0.0135353189,
-0.024278935,
0.0275486019,
0.0048145829,
-0.0347203203,
0.0117467334,
0.0422838964,
-0.0174533818,
-0.0129765701,
0.0016354163,
0.0041045612,
-0.0102189193,
-0.0056843013,
-0.0579433367,
0.0587439612,
-0.0333475731,
0.0073816716,
-0.0119560221,
-0.0257463194,
0.046832826,
-0.0211207848,
-0.0403343774,
0.1274965405,
-0.0017855708,
-0.0285138283,
-0.0081511494,
0.0010483474,
-0.0014188151,
-0.0501372069,
0.0016974016,
0.0498612039,
-0.0299557075,
0.0006516353,
-0.0045305863,
-0.0106086601,
-0.0201606657,
0.0372764207,
0.0508891568,
0.0665283352,
0.0511956103,
0.0346762687,
-0.0182120129,
0.0893077329,
-0.0643778667,
0.0108014783,
-0.0477924049,
-0.0071151503,
-0.0475840643,
-0.0339267701,
-0.0609745495,
0.0400805362,
0.0108677251,
-0.0335148908,
-0.0196245816,
0.0358932093,
-0.0077872174,
0.0209823903,
0.0027764714,
-0.0163828842,
-0.0043488643,
-0.035327293,
-0.0318406262,
0.0441196077,
-0.0170152783,
-0.0076845414,
0.003756532,
-0.0206759106,
-0.0188274104,
-0.0051316549,
-0.0033575383,
-0.0172452666,
0.0071823602,
0.0597360432,
0.0052787755,
-0.004921352,
-0.0145217227,
-0.0184609499,
-0.0175864212,
-0.0677227378,
0.0546830334,
-0.0663532838,
0.0266093705,
0.0310072601,
-0.0088204453,
-0.015654074,
0.0117133111,
0.0112550939,
-0.0309900325,
0.0630745068,
0.0561927818,
0.0397598594,
-0.0210530311,
-0.0192699749,
-0.0172768794,
0.037611831,
0.0626284108,
-0.0251431931,
-0.030729223,
0.0049027517,
0.0231621657,
0.037955448,
-0.0130198644,
0.0040571541,
0.0164956823,
-0.0191783309,
0.0037520221,
0.0373238586,
0.01145586,
0.0837806463,
-0.0151533801,
0.0009803554,
0.0544861816,
0.029198397,
0.0271888319,
0.0463056788,
0.0386794433,
-0.0127718188,
0.004179283,
0.0368224941,
-0.0666451156,
0.0445386618,
-0.0059340731,
0.0058508706,
-0.0226031039,
0.0263066981,
-0.0233406071,
-0.0424607284,
-0.0085394522,
0.0154831242,
0.0400173627,
0.0037883951,
0.0451049432,
0.0258199181,
-0.0489062704,
0.0558691621,
-0.0306710135,
-0.0398167334,
-0.0137572074,
-0.0721951202,
0.0238637142,
0.0392825603,
0.0538183674,
0.0124671925,
-0.0149443168,
0.0107911127,
0.0456515439,
0.0002399059,
0.0323415995,
0.0034998988,
-0.0127587123,
-0.0345229991,
-0.018061338,
-0.036076773,
0.00578456,
-0.0173548106,
0.0320511982,
-0.0575684868,
0.0056171976,
-0.0169746969,
0.020787321,
-0.007633592,
-0.0455069058,
-0.0041628364,
-0.0389484502,
0.0076813521,
-0.0029078515,
-0.0359253958,
-0.0002665015,
0.0625625327,
-0.0034566012,
-0.0259852633,
-0.0678867549,
0.0411915742,
-0.0644080564,
0.0046096644,
0.0231763367,
-0.0363925062,
-0.0236648545,
-0.004553251,
-0.0192972384,
-0.0267551951,
0.0667063817,
-0.087786153,
0.0419042222,
0.0217450503,
0.0630172566,
-0.0040325983,
-0.0558999069,
0.0036191046,
0.0868784636,
-0.0102107041,
0.0045507816,
0.0040421858,
-0.0133709358,
0.0034026585,
-0.0170291774,
-0.0112348376,
-0.0035931109,
-0.0099425623,
0.0080220783,
-0.0056837699,
-0.0280705821,
-0.0278175958,
-0.0611837246,
-0.0057169022,
-0.017412208,
0.0051763132,
0.0428981669,
-0.0165284667,
0.0079685701,
0.0126254996,
0.0081839161,
-0.010977054,
0.0358259976,
0.0464433506,
0.0410818756,
0.0288445,
0.0066263229,
-0.0472948812,
0.0130030476,
-0.0236928444,
-0.064231053,
0.0376604646,
-0.0046257884,
0.021894319,
-0.0378192626,
0.0196365099,
0.0065783677,
0.0065383809,
-0.0429553054,
-0.0068441965,
0.0283609759,
0.0019677086,
0.0824946016,
0.0806794092,
-0.0242745709,
0.0020880345,
0.0356538743,
-0.0419680178,
-0.0073781535,
0.021247074,
-0.0400035493,
-0.0543366931,
-0.0170118958,
-0.0219511613,
-0.0298881847,
0.0927514732,
-0.0289602019,
0.0064047747,
-0.064735502,
0.0521705598,
-0.0298568681,
0.0344461761,
0.0051669609,
-0.0447434448,
-0.0074620615,
0.0346215144,
-0.0587794669,
-0.0288623739,
0.0760711804,
0.0102365846,
-0.0199953225,
-0.0163028166,
0.019786736,
-0.0570261739,
0.0879493654,
0.0372082852,
0.010562093,
0.0268158708,
-0.0203629211,
-0.0855282694,
0.0262494087,
0.0332910605,
-0.028433295,
0.0790425986,
-0.0330987871,
0.0086714476,
0.0004564879,
-0.0701976642,
-0.0222068969,
0.0476044714,
-0.034712214,
0.0394480117,
0.0249038506,
-0.0419523679,
-0.0591536798,
0.0047331098,
0.0457695723,
0.0255470518,
0.0045972923,
-0.0341984294,
-0.0036247564,
-0.0005454008,
0.012881713,
0.0227812957,
0.0623815581,
-0.0651466474,
0.0404305793,
0.0197597947,
0.066465579,
0.0215800796,
-0.0301779937,
0.0183378272,
0.014519928,
-0.0097929398,
-0.0199421663,
0.024636019,
0.0312818624,
-0.0602736883,
-0.005127274,
0.0575487912,
0.022765182,
0.0090711955,
0.022379389,
-0.0450977273,
-0.0044982219,
0.0429001413,
0.0341722816,
-0.1017826125,
0.003994816,
0.0431345552,
-0.0077804676,
-0.0022791077,
-0.0539082885,
-0.0113824112,
-0.1218467578,
0.016226463,
0.029423777,
-0.010758576,
-0.0117516136,
-0.0090031493,
-0.0274377335,
0.0054926416,
-0.0016229635,
0.018885171,
-0.0368813276,
-0.0280334838,
-0.0037650173,
-0.0174990632,
-0.0044633606,
0.0172230005,
0.0014804974,
-0.0035792689,
0.0326969028,
0.0136773093,
0.0091158766,
-0.0725958124,
0.0594578385,
0.0047402871,
0.0208327826,
0.010495564,
-0.0095361061,
0.0452388301,
-0.0070674019,
-0.0373759158,
0.0052906829,
-0.039193321,
-0.032165613,
-0.0093508083,
0.0913872942,
-0.0109850354,
-0.0733084008,
-0.0003243061,
0.0083564417,
-0.032478109,
0.0591992699,
0.0326062702,
-0.0178090073,
-0.0463884585,
-0.0637015998,
0.0143281799,
-0.0394066162,
-0.058058247,
0.0514405333,
0.0504859351,
0.0116344206,
-0.0191545468,
0.0364044793,
0.024323402,
0.0266756658,
0.0065332931,
-0.065136224,
0.0370101817,
-0.0236941967,
-0.0452773385,
0.0041581891,
-0.0595580786,
0.0377298407,
-0.0660484061,
0.0233936086,
-0.0160557311,
-0.0297595914,
-0.0218224302,
-0.0548550822,
-0.1284554452,
-0.0438010097,
0.0070726722,
0.0351014733,
0.0379474312,
-0.0101749673,
0.0010572093,
-0.0232722498,
0.0128736533,
0.0025477135,
0.00795893,
0.0139484964,
0.022002887,
-0.0180771556,
0.020827841,
0.0217049699,
-0.0341334492,
0.010382995,
0.0164660383,
0.0730739757,
-0.0175668802,
-0.0014582522,
0.0433786586,
0.0081054429,
-0.0112145627,
0.0373226367,
0.0438536927,
0.0052862037,
0.0237418264,
0.0171055011,
-0.0175767895,
-0.038056843,
-0.0406987928,
0.0234177094,
0.0228970107,
0.0355695337,
0.0157321878,
0.0337130167,
0.0524962209,
-0.0032627613,
0.0254845768,
0.0098035112,
-0.0213803221,
0.0709033757,
0.0018102907,
0.0029600549,
0.0317403227,
0.0048016678,
0.0191372912,
0.0227428917,
0.0399302058,
0.0132762725,
0.0169731714,
-0.0604709797,
-0.0364385135,
-0.0794775784,
-0.095608376,
0.0426105857,
-0.0297057312,
0.0472802594,
0.006422482,
-0.0151838576,
-0.0499434881,
-0.0030252396,
-0.0097753229,
-0.0165774189,
0.0204445682,
-0.040860109,
0.0258393493,
0.0493476018,
0.0261495169,
-0.0160223674,
0.0653637052,
-0.0216756053,
0.080296129,
-0.0044366666,
0.0176608562,
0.0003566271,
-0.0742713138,
-0.0354854204,
0.0105538592,
-0.0080175037,
-0.0152641153,
-0.080279626,
-0.0706735104,
-0.0169366132,
0.0141204745,
0.0134119112,
-0.0479979031,
0.0343708843,
0.0406600609,
0.0105300006,
-0.0480492488,
0.0180928092,
-0.0154927308,
0.0034259236,
0.0287494957,
0.002745037,
-6.356499661e-33,
-0.0162815303,
-0.0478045717,
0.0497801602,
0.031791795,
-0.0158663746,
-0.0085365279,
-0.0519303717,
0.0181076359,
-0.0378222801,
-0.0154178524,
-0.0046025305,
0.0236415602,
-0.0037478989,
0.0082695512,
0.0328691676,
0.0192060005,
0.0482129753,
-0.0097327922,
-0.0451466404,
-0.0100567369,
0.0139424596,
-0.0461128131,
0.0030619865,
-0.0079374956,
-0.0081605464,
0.014765854,
0.0012167377,
0.0472651236,
-0.0422197841,
0.0725210607,
0.0141807375,
0.0412998199,
0.0290505737,
-0.0702610686,
-0.0062149111,
0.0297509357,
-0.059843041,
-0.0175318569,
0.0140766688,
0.0005925131,
-0.0151992226,
-0.0458813533,
0.0449429192,
0.0141809108,
-0.0205519591,
-0.0468388125,
-0.007852735,
-0.0195862539,
-0.0100778807,
-0.0289497245,
-0.0708632097,
-0.0079537826,
0.0023068963,
-0.0301015265,
0.0085537685,
0.0243516285,
-0.0067083901,
-0.0029792697,
-0.0367037542,
0.0571658649,
0.0003540225,
-0.0017914746,
0.0470453575,
0.0042964504,
0.0171376076,
0.0103023984,
0.0316311419,
0.0307461303,
-0.0564817972,
-0.004432145,
0.0149288261,
0.0680127069,
0.0388887785,
-0.0388414003,
0.0423779562,
0.0243941955,
-0.0319878571,
-0.030852912,
0.0206399392,
0.0818068311,
0.0156541206,
0.0057014292,
-0.0213801935,
-0.0414045751,
-0.0583281815,
0.0368411615,
-0.0418584608,
-0.0096136983,
-0.0049047908,
0.0196373425,
0.0063023665,
-0.0248059127,
0.0051424582,
-0.0473610684,
-0.0110548446,
0.0304474309,
-0.0039640027,
0.0281645562,
-0.0241571069,
0.0481688902,
-0.0408105701,
-0.0636221617,
-0.0133935353,
0.0243991595,
0.0197374113,
0.0352959074,
0.017949488,
0.0443550162,
-0.0695126504,
-0.0286126677,
-0.0570588,
-0.0012672537,
0.0258313119,
-0.0045925137,
0.0754421875,
0.0260009412,
0.0041878377,
-0.0221810248,
-0.0204692837,
-0.0035551793,
-0.0142914494,
0.0812474415,
-0.0169876907,
0.0231107827,
0.012669825,
-0.0350570455,
-0.0735931173,
0.0478231274,
0.02261924,
-0.0543328449,
-0.0503438227,
0.0281130895,
2.969e-7,
0.0228205789,
0.0552369058,
0.02922903,
0.065309234,
0.0579891428,
0.0170229115,
-0.03090306,
-0.0600341707,
-0.0048346887,
0.0093319668,
0.0073147668,
0.0421534739,
0.0419825651,
0.0366121158,
-0.0393597111,
0.0024403618,
-0.0668385476,
0.0237803459,
-0.0516319647,
0.033929985,
0.0244456008,
0.0410437994,
-0.0022986119,
-0.0017237379,
-0.0167537816,
-0.063290596,
0.0617333837,
0.0183240362,
0.0368766487,
-0.008772267,
-0.0269554108,
0.0092086205,
0.0014711812,
0.0217065997,
0.012613412,
0.0222565643,
-0.0139410803,
0.0436541922,
0.0297831707,
0.0015264765,
0.0041429936,
-0.0351077914,
-0.0242344327,
-0.0219540708,
0.063722074,
-0.1141254306,
-0.0497616641,
-0.0153659992,
0.0092251291,
-0.0154012926,
-0.0093874997,
0.0156973414,
0.0041917684,
0.0026103805,
0.0153262634,
-0.0011948922,
0.0286339987,
-0.0667639151,
0.0005793502,
0.0206447151,
-0.0403562263,
-0.0570652559,
-0.0491497964,
0.0197145175,
0.0254073963,
0.0119631896,
-0.0234475117,
3.042726031e-34,
0.0437660292,
-0.039333649,
0.045764029,
-0.0312882401,
0.0450728089,
-0.0232081655,
-0.0179399159,
0.0185211897,
0.0230813939,
-0.0772090703,
-0.0449448526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18641v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18641v1 | Enhanced Chart Understanding in Vision and Language Task via Cross-modal Pre-training on Plot Table Pairs | 2023-05-29T22:29:03 | 2023-05-29T22:29:03 | Mingyang Zhou, Yi R. Fung, Long Chen, Christopher Thomas, Heng Ji, Shih-Fu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Building cross-model intelligence that can understand charts and communicate
the salient information hidden behind them is an appealing challenge in the
vision and language(V+L) community. The capability to uncover the underlined
table data of chart figures is a critical key to automatic chart understanding.
We introduce ChartT5, a V+L model that learns how to interpret table
information from chart images via cross-modal pre-training on plot table pairs.
Specifically, we propose two novel pre-training objectives: Masked Header
Prediction (MHP) and Masked Value Prediction (MVP) to facilitate the model with
different skills to interpret the table information. We have conducted
extensive experiments on chart question answering and chart summarization to
verify the effectiveness of the proposed pre-training strategies. In
particular, on the ChartQA benchmark, our ChartT5 outperforms the
state-of-the-art non-pretraining methods by over 8% performance gains. | [
-0.0340454727,
0.0322066247,
-0.008505444,
0.0347342603,
0.0161977112,
0.0265020262,
-0.0209913272,
-0.0045539029,
0.0290825833,
0.0305661373,
-0.0604909584,
0.0173395723,
-0.0043503991,
0.0578461327,
0.0188287552,
-0.0725965798,
0.0472436659,
0.0043332013,
0.0002067696,
0.0231189579,
0.0016536644,
-0.0320014022,
0.0006695403,
0.0144615192,
-0.0327353142,
-0.0446097814,
0.0017742523,
0.0133650396,
0.0046729236,
-0.0432150587,
-0.0201673564,
0.037095651,
0.029055262,
0.0290758889,
0.0000019555,
0.0109394724,
-0.0245608855,
-0.0067885253,
-0.0455703698,
-0.039243646,
0.0135724014,
-0.0916017517,
0.0448744446,
-0.0330250338,
-0.0434206538,
-0.0123438183,
0.0293657091,
0.0451400317,
0.1043555066,
-0.0039466368,
0.0013299504,
0.0124870641,
-0.027087409,
-0.0369359031,
0.0466477908,
-0.0879101008,
-0.0067696809,
0.0590026118,
-0.0139311571,
0.0268552471,
-0.0689194873,
0.0708916485,
0.0341319367,
0.034225136,
-0.01390603,
0.0627302602,
0.011081378,
-0.0131180044,
-0.0214325152,
0.1272339821,
-0.013756033,
-0.0083245318,
-0.0118069369,
-0.0096886465,
0.0212770626,
0.0256391596,
-0.0829354674,
-0.0247803051,
0.0100086741,
-0.0396244749,
-0.0195393506,
0.0132509908,
-0.0066610323,
-0.0216082837,
-0.00052544,
-0.0286173709,
-0.0407862701,
-0.0109565286,
0.0072039743,
0.0031480901,
-0.0547721647,
-0.0509208664,
-0.0197214279,
0.0511984676,
-0.0056147384,
0.0035777371,
-0.0174423195,
-0.0805535316,
-0.0244477801,
0.0006991096,
0.0500653535,
0.0108831059,
-0.0545493104,
0.0717268065,
-0.0341358483,
0.0126265353,
-0.0115881125,
0.0252615288,
-0.0312571675,
-0.0285713952,
-0.0166266542,
-0.0236442816,
-0.0500732325,
-0.0102362111,
-0.0557216257,
-0.0425775573,
0.0155831445,
-0.0132851861,
-0.0158292074,
0.0317365527,
0.0196593665,
0.0232132971,
-0.0503006503,
-0.0228227042,
-0.04022073,
0.049179405,
-0.0516152084,
-0.0055969288,
-0.0320398137,
-0.0304691941,
-0.0422414429,
0.0176737979,
0.0247134864,
-0.0132403644,
0.0332849286,
0.0981409848,
-0.0180350076,
0.0149127739,
0.0094076423,
-0.0524014868,
0.0027211625,
-0.0157116205,
0.0383772627,
-0.0134565355,
0.0483117886,
-0.0133814188,
0.0044027576,
0.0066819387,
0.0075011919,
0.0279247575,
-0.0148529736,
0.0835621059,
0.0113444692,
-0.0239479113,
0.0080322837,
-0.0003278711,
-0.0717167705,
0.0621282458,
0.0391131677,
0.0178303532,
0.0123916669,
-0.0282406304,
0.0182677228,
0.053281039,
0.0530752726,
-0.0352803916,
0.0007153232,
0.0427979864,
-0.0180190429,
-0.010359955,
0.0529158153,
0.0085226092,
-0.0402839966,
-0.0399641767,
0.0417048112,
0.0416686051,
0.0476965383,
0.0142776696,
0.019585913,
0.0141266156,
0.0245284736,
-0.0050759772,
-0.0356949009,
0.0623032115,
0.0329895914,
0.0448718071,
-0.0526144765,
-0.0468723178,
-0.0293539744,
-0.0502905808,
0.012905526,
0.0188823938,
-0.0056029535,
0.0411021151,
0.0242645722,
0.0279067699,
-0.0582309924,
-0.0070462851,
-0.0122645162,
0.0071025211,
-0.0100692697,
0.0154168345,
0.0242446028,
0.0158671625,
0.0101801036,
-0.0331153497,
-0.011631581,
-0.0200392772,
0.0092862891,
0.012032547,
0.0362860858,
-0.0313081369,
0.0067721563,
-0.0161528476,
-0.0220193677,
-0.0280661732,
-0.0017067695,
0.0303032342,
-0.0177817866,
-0.0124184368,
-0.0137509974,
-0.0855760351,
-0.0012088979,
-0.00314248,
0.0160441343,
-0.0372597612,
-0.0069034467,
0.0228450205,
-0.012593722,
0.0005226124,
0.0009117798,
0.0272354875,
0.0000827478,
-0.0332452916,
0.0155295627,
0.021670416,
-0.0639415979,
-0.0600306317,
0.013133022,
-0.0535070151,
-0.0491721109,
0.0361161157,
-0.0293148309,
-0.0378680415,
0.0356483907,
-0.0643641278,
-0.0263263453,
-0.0118842283,
-0.0635901615,
0.0363932513,
0.029024655,
0.0002818756,
0.0659387857,
-0.0214309189,
0.0005855513,
-0.0128448419,
0.0181054957,
0.057093136,
-0.0010236035,
0.0523365662,
0.0175940096,
0.0074877841,
0.0237144604,
0.0022140839,
0.0111083919,
-0.0479885079,
0.0229814444,
-0.0933865085,
0.0025404973,
-0.0150609128,
-0.0027337628,
0.034207847,
-0.0126876226,
-0.0292689521,
-0.0787927657,
-0.055499021,
0.0112312958,
0.0127678271,
-0.0259003974,
0.0678162798,
-0.0002502003,
0.0196672771,
-0.0128935343,
-0.0098130433,
-0.0250209142,
0.0436485521,
0.0150934951,
-0.0151475044,
0.0404566117,
0.0036376512,
-0.013179047,
0.0152354548,
-0.0071404623,
0.0180195551,
0.0070017464,
0.0016960929,
0.0554267205,
0.0583135523,
-0.038312126,
0.0267585907,
-0.0141979186,
-0.0217243396,
-0.045221515,
0.0378115252,
-0.0066632177,
-0.001556989,
0.0121578043,
-0.0197830275,
-0.0089130728,
0.0900789499,
0.0017803137,
0.0060732858,
-0.0413231663,
-0.0057220976,
0.0117890127,
-0.0067996974,
-0.108575426,
0.0694034919,
0.0062281354,
0.0289960448,
-0.0434199274,
-0.0262861717,
0.0504660048,
-0.0216299444,
-0.0362069272,
-0.013994717,
-0.010721093,
-0.0582758971,
0.0564930551,
0.003896958,
0.0043779155,
-0.043579977,
-0.0511515141,
-0.0669775009,
-0.001531897,
0.0348724313,
-0.0347208157,
0.0105078081,
-0.0223567057,
-0.0069500739,
-0.0197541416,
0.0095376186,
-0.0098457532,
-0.0535185412,
-0.0391400866,
0.0339099094,
0.0065571973,
0.0132476008,
-0.0206726436,
-0.0228705108,
0.0312946402,
0.01045061,
-0.0123410011,
-0.00113391,
-0.0312861018,
0.0320832878,
0.0425611474,
0.0501865,
-0.0163429454,
-0.0717898011,
0.0534116141,
0.0318668298,
0.0133503741,
-0.0012330414,
-0.0074364343,
0.0296487696,
-0.0176273156,
0.0168372169,
0.0065455236,
0.0269372799,
0.0269249082,
-0.0252222214,
0.026232738,
0.0470960513,
-0.0032808408,
0.0044747316,
-0.0308840368,
0.0215699431,
0.0332870595,
0.02438494,
0.0449717268,
-0.1006183103,
-0.0444340669,
-0.0100212358,
0.0175957307,
0.0500769168,
-0.0403923765,
-0.0282006618,
-0.0852521583,
0.0498751104,
-0.0124498904,
-0.0512690395,
-0.0218088105,
-0.0209891815,
-0.0093994644,
-0.0045842873,
0.0165604278,
-0.0481386445,
-0.0150120771,
0.0175411478,
0.0470801927,
-0.044651065,
-0.0047582285,
-0.0104701417,
-0.0252250265,
-0.0761996955,
0.0197639521,
0.0345034897,
-0.0284980237,
-0.0064504864,
-0.0040227324,
-0.0069882246,
0.0204542819,
-0.0007497755,
0.0850061104,
-0.026807012,
-0.0444293134,
0.0022267301,
0.0347570218,
0.005089391,
-0.006083725,
-0.0232839044,
0.055293411,
0.0057849153,
-0.0311966632,
-0.013810995,
0.0511464663,
-0.0021880267,
0.0579238273,
0.0870734975,
0.0127230389,
-0.0463945493,
-0.0296336524,
0.0096343337,
-0.0792867169,
-0.0044724359,
0.0236063264,
0.0207055807,
-0.0076080179,
-0.0344132222,
-0.0373195037,
0.0475730337,
0.0408281684,
-0.014191702,
-0.0037689607,
-0.0186310671,
-0.0091318702,
-0.0589977242,
0.0556591861,
-0.0506680198,
0.0290101394,
-0.0143951867,
-0.0372795276,
-0.0048596142,
-0.0100699123,
-0.0616236739,
0.0330862962,
-0.1068054587,
0.0098632388,
-0.0266560651,
0.0319501199,
0.0163120031,
0.0495630056,
0.0008051701,
-0.0047658258,
0.0709638,
0.0243080407,
-0.0404444076,
-0.0341101401,
0.0091962721,
0.0091636889,
-0.0071849432,
-0.0092660654,
-0.0346824192,
0.0343406834,
0.0345288143,
0.010053671,
-0.0213698894,
0.0459807925,
0.0148746623,
0.0284928102,
-0.0058029657,
0.0479388125,
-0.0239621513,
-0.0084549785,
-0.0400595628,
-0.00922109,
-0.0311172884,
-0.0152654247,
-0.0162324943,
0.0210214332,
-0.0332374386,
-0.0347419232,
0.0386802219,
0.0309107769,
-0.006002998,
-0.0613363422,
0.0172200352,
0.0262260102,
-0.017501384,
-0.011483442,
0.0137384459,
-0.0059759193,
-0.0280254893,
0.0174251813,
0.0563786179,
0.0521157719,
0.0279756282,
0.0225925203,
-0.0124909384,
-0.0389053449,
0.0359113365,
-0.0850237757,
-0.0967893526,
0.0158030838,
0.0025369576,
0.0101617305,
-0.0228803288,
-0.0221680123,
0.0014982582,
-0.0002158961,
0.0267571695,
0.0213698186,
0.0048281956,
0.0191457141,
0.093924202,
-0.000953816,
0.0095722014,
-0.0501152091,
0.0935009569,
0.0130183948,
0.0228051525,
-0.0319148973,
-0.001928109,
-0.0737560466,
0.0328488126,
0.0213641804,
-0.0037381174,
0.0075501702,
0.040693216,
-0.0422015414,
-0.0760408491,
0.035222616,
0.0321237333,
0.003389112,
0.0387537703,
0.0213995166,
0.0343112759,
0.0639160648,
-0.0167481713,
-0.0121086109,
0.0311196595,
0.0193725992,
-0.0091534704,
-0.0435960367,
-5.674056865e-33,
-0.0254696291,
-0.0067641363,
0.0248485655,
-0.0018748967,
-0.0023856584,
0.0334279612,
-0.0629514307,
-0.0057178908,
-0.010329349,
0.0144521575,
0.0059542339,
0.0271622483,
0.0130302701,
-0.0147972135,
-0.021696426,
-0.0650368482,
0.0417540222,
-0.035051249,
-0.0215203632,
0.0061823823,
0.0046039578,
0.0601254851,
0.0259458423,
-0.0679941252,
0.0188794099,
0.0238979142,
0.004850789,
-0.0014162069,
0.0384208597,
0.0236390512,
-0.0313362107,
0.0109402472,
0.0218981951,
-0.0389390141,
-0.0598791726,
0.0509723835,
-0.1102148965,
-0.0450469516,
-0.0099781267,
0.0368806534,
-0.0494174547,
0.007248024,
0.0388189927,
-0.0216725469,
0.0117369667,
-0.0602413267,
0.0376724899,
0.0062184953,
0.0142424852,
0.0173390247,
0.006209183,
0.0091510611,
-0.0483468175,
-0.0380905159,
0.0815825686,
0.0821857974,
0.051735457,
0.0370664559,
-0.0414265506,
0.0406076759,
-0.0253491215,
-0.0504716672,
0.0570612587,
0.0305900685,
0.0220780745,
0.0559874587,
0.0244319774,
-0.0144888461,
-0.0404094905,
0.0171068553,
0.0163858216,
0.068553105,
0.0633955747,
-0.0052822954,
0.0384810194,
0.0023974553,
-0.0235917922,
0.0804620087,
-0.0451879613,
0.0190361831,
-0.0572042987,
-0.0086569563,
-0.0229761582,
-0.0205662306,
-0.0211389214,
-0.0127095385,
-0.0418782085,
0.0221046396,
0.0316664912,
-0.0007466712,
0.0167234838,
0.0609209388,
0.0272283331,
-0.0410643257,
0.023105355,
0.0130081009,
0.0297430325,
0.0313910618,
0.0255256128,
-0.0116034877,
-0.0356084965,
0.0079231998,
0.0519347489,
-0.0273224171,
0.0249018352,
0.0099580279,
0.0477436446,
-0.013344571,
-0.051571276,
-0.0181295034,
-0.024931198,
-0.0050028455,
0.0178526267,
-0.0008391227,
0.0359915495,
0.0145774558,
-0.0501444824,
0.0006602726,
-0.0112624737,
0.0452933349,
-0.0249451827,
0.0146109667,
-0.0374140106,
0.0398937948,
0.0014343143,
-0.0287831929,
0.0023177275,
-0.0447779968,
0.0054340693,
-0.0662686378,
-0.0039850101,
0.0063270689,
2.509e-7,
0.0695915595,
0.0185864326,
0.0763119236,
0.0287875999,
0.0140585983,
0.0417892337,
-0.0516667999,
0.00417451,
-0.0070200162,
-0.030965941,
0.0323322713,
0.0213762727,
0.044731807,
0.050080236,
-0.005160898,
-0.0584856458,
0.009056326,
-0.0003151837,
-0.0363538526,
0.0259275138,
0.0531870909,
0.0427814685,
-0.0406856835,
-0.0066523189,
0.0169496294,
-0.019605808,
0.0808457062,
-0.0455463119,
0.0117451819,
-0.035975229,
-0.0093415426,
0.0236441772,
0.0088598747,
0.0311403591,
-0.0247441866,
0.02058894,
0.0865497738,
-0.0044550067,
0.00736759,
0.02258504,
-0.0356789641,
0.0320777856,
0.0176876131,
-0.0282800272,
0.0732299238,
-0.0794866681,
-0.0645618364,
0.002773579,
-0.0590343773,
0.0307082571,
0.0338274203,
0.0032702666,
-0.0338629372,
0.0107852332,
0.038561333,
-0.0002317469,
0.0268215127,
-0.0406148434,
-0.0405973829,
0.0563763641,
-0.0191047639,
-0.0131837633,
-0.0177728906,
-0.0040124888,
-0.0013792029,
0.002561002,
-0.0615611039,
2.133290592e-34,
0.0357044674,
-0.027295921,
0.0174384918,
0.0073266095,
0.0561728254,
-0.0590456128,
0.0487228222,
0.001195001,
0.0386998989,
-0.0856073871,
-0.0317398347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18638v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18638v1 | Short Answer Grading Using One-shot Prompting and Text Similarity Scoring Model | 2023-05-29T22:05:29 | 2023-05-29T22:05:29 | Su-Youn Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | In this study, we developed an automated short answer grading (ASAG) model
that provided both analytic scores and final holistic scores. Short answer
items typically consist of multiple sub-questions, and providing an analytic
score and the text span relevant to each sub-question can increase the
interpretability of the automated scores. Furthermore, they can be used to
generate actionable feedback for students. Despite these advantages, most
studies have focused on predicting only holistic scores due to the difficulty
in constructing dataset with manual annotations. To address this difficulty, we
used large language model (LLM)-based one-shot prompting and a text similarity
scoring model with domain adaptation using small manually annotated dataset.
The accuracy and quadratic weighted kappa of our model were 0.67 and 0.71 on a
subset of the publicly available ASAG dataset. The model achieved a substantial
improvement over the majority baseline. | [
0.0248526633,
-0.0736583099,
-0.0264873449,
-0.0205286071,
-0.0198008474,
0.0204803515,
0.0216402467,
0.0105843199,
0.0269412324,
-0.0641829595,
-0.0094111301,
-0.0095237819,
-0.0332584418,
0.0440490246,
0.0076013641,
-0.0370547362,
-0.0014406045,
-0.0080734845,
-0.002720702,
-0.0194637757,
0.0079455161,
-0.0062661818,
-0.0004908867,
0.0079101482,
0.0373189151,
-0.0284812469,
-0.0001706902,
-0.0293020606,
0.0115330173,
-0.0160136987,
0.0078707859,
0.0821141824,
-0.0060961414,
-0.0053355126,
0.0000021789,
-0.0773885697,
-0.0031122693,
-0.0166324023,
-0.0166098159,
-0.0160403233,
0.032931067,
0.0779599175,
0.0435241535,
0.0226222128,
-0.0568754934,
-0.0111033637,
0.0053952746,
0.0105320252,
0.0699893758,
0.0072952351,
0.0100038117,
-0.0303016342,
0.0016861034,
0.010670823,
0.0273495503,
-0.0136325844,
0.0099447379,
0.0708761364,
0.0148913385,
0.0367273986,
-0.0440609343,
0.0115898401,
-0.0026090299,
-0.0300265942,
0.0706544146,
-0.0046108933,
0.0011666507,
0.0166401528,
0.0348236486,
0.0815347508,
0.009752864,
-0.0096436599,
-0.0270099305,
-0.0331123658,
0.043990247,
0.034376733,
-0.0789787769,
0.0025403111,
-0.000166061,
-0.0162898488,
-0.0002022474,
0.0077541228,
-0.0239526276,
0.0022839289,
0.0389959067,
0.0016794142,
0.0117430063,
-0.029123459,
-0.015299743,
0.0229718126,
-0.0003348191,
-0.0534096248,
-0.002660844,
0.0529571883,
-0.0098105082,
0.0024815414,
-0.0270583089,
-0.0442349203,
0.0500093885,
-0.0316979922,
0.0625228882,
0.0109413574,
-0.0172103848,
0.0261236671,
-0.0405698679,
0.0844607353,
0.0873506293,
-0.0148144048,
-0.0642241836,
0.0150072044,
-0.0699990839,
0.0003926593,
0.0271344595,
0.0635702834,
0.0125874206,
0.0208272673,
-0.0748222023,
-0.0286061727,
-0.0298954751,
0.007895086,
0.0112847025,
-0.0038080292,
0.0068732677,
0.0451421514,
-0.0287681203,
0.0541608781,
-0.0603434853,
0.0136129782,
0.0051340079,
0.0206790119,
0.0217351988,
0.0106545929,
0.0321247578,
0.0022422601,
0.0422104634,
0.0022098201,
0.0020099925,
-0.0146269863,
0.0080504511,
-0.0467772521,
-0.0185436178,
-0.023773605,
-0.0141174626,
-0.0717536062,
0.0060995952,
0.0442281812,
-0.0004710896,
0.021514222,
0.0080358991,
0.045632977,
0.0008337458,
0.0143398456,
0.0217401832,
0.0035434572,
0.0302692838,
0.0138343917,
0.0328147039,
0.0144052077,
0.0046542422,
-0.0011044383,
0.0506511405,
-0.0476879887,
0.0285853874,
0.013655562,
-0.0073391544,
0.0048995488,
0.0502048507,
0.0234971009,
0.0239993874,
0.0001018626,
-0.0358448587,
0.0134374313,
0.0463029779,
0.0092770113,
0.0246742666,
0.0507614501,
0.02786397,
-0.008487436,
0.0012715814,
0.0277687013,
0.0238182638,
0.0102770599,
-0.0165303349,
0.0237064008,
-0.0506586432,
0.0182049759,
0.065992415,
0.0021755972,
-0.0150305871,
-0.0670976862,
-0.0260551218,
0.0100929299,
-0.0358163379,
0.0255348161,
0.0526680835,
0.0091318311,
-0.0243433379,
-0.0186733659,
0.0173608623,
-0.0578736812,
0.0719813257,
-0.0471852012,
0.0604373254,
0.0497857034,
0.0452376716,
-0.0126878759,
-0.0097326832,
-0.0357866585,
0.0372165628,
0.0026454215,
0.0201678853,
-0.0384372063,
-0.0500054993,
-0.0375248566,
-0.026825808,
0.0207751337,
-0.0170753151,
-0.0192506835,
-0.0307566803,
0.0199902225,
0.0014163918,
-0.0246973429,
-0.0731241256,
0.0345929377,
-0.0094996365,
-0.0767009407,
0.0160078425,
-0.0090495711,
0.0042050262,
0.0659126863,
0.0162098929,
0.0173344351,
0.0112065496,
-0.0045062676,
-0.0264079105,
-0.0925654694,
-0.054634802,
-0.021193739,
0.0391204879,
-0.0168827698,
0.03771865,
0.0234169438,
-0.0142836617,
-0.0628055111,
-0.04287076,
0.0066360123,
-0.039165508,
0.0084392633,
0.0302652214,
-0.0298329294,
-0.0369600095,
-0.0664532855,
0.0110536283,
0.052693367,
0.0812513977,
-0.04935579,
-0.0083708055,
0.0543719791,
0.0202419516,
-0.0591187067,
-0.0129369618,
-0.033027716,
0.0170221534,
0.0383928567,
0.016157316,
-0.0625931844,
0.0043191896,
-0.0462242849,
-0.0229847468,
0.0243834872,
-0.0032032873,
0.0234786514,
-0.0118995328,
-0.0082536554,
0.0116931368,
-0.0777530968,
0.0059682,
0.0217504762,
-0.0011397507,
0.0131444298,
0.0172147434,
0.0255815294,
-0.0635184199,
-0.0207056683,
-0.0362521447,
0.0268156994,
0.0841978937,
0.0174526721,
-0.0263927951,
0.0647112131,
-0.009369093,
-0.0229060426,
0.0339634605,
-0.0280935783,
-0.0070490353,
-0.0057388903,
0.0293186624,
0.0287913438,
0.0192287937,
-0.0557672419,
0.0443447977,
-0.0276620816,
-0.0563685782,
-0.0214888956,
-0.0381701663,
-0.0320550166,
-0.0107684787,
-0.0607662797,
-0.0066363993,
0.0365818366,
0.0338281989,
-0.0530851707,
-0.0482430719,
0.0199127086,
-0.0572093241,
0.0289724525,
-0.0715989992,
-0.0162330493,
0.0077860868,
0.0093612941,
0.0278500449,
-0.0213647522,
0.0766748339,
-0.0297004208,
0.0229243413,
-0.0443311669,
0.0297678225,
-0.0177767426,
0.0420117527,
0.0011835829,
-0.02079021,
-0.0368711427,
0.0417143442,
-0.0361076221,
-0.0028385357,
0.0279591121,
-0.0494780354,
0.0549451299,
-0.0027426113,
-0.0353617147,
-0.0067140353,
0.0090525271,
-0.0385208391,
0.0106724594,
0.0032928425,
0.0085821934,
-0.02945235,
0.0061876937,
-0.0100370729,
0.0182983316,
0.0114243031,
-0.0009387481,
-0.0640678108,
-0.010634141,
0.0172480382,
0.039826341,
0.0684714317,
-0.0415501855,
-0.0203489754,
-0.0181407332,
0.0930505842,
0.0229467489,
0.0497879535,
0.0120088374,
0.0573860854,
-0.0059989667,
0.02646132,
-0.059364561,
0.0049398667,
0.0366121344,
0.0329693928,
-0.0484784059,
-0.006676761,
0.1056166813,
0.0311131943,
-0.0475302897,
-0.0293084122,
-0.067393668,
-0.0262107346,
0.0255031846,
0.0453184359,
-0.0523908921,
-0.0339296162,
-0.0215403009,
0.0644299313,
-0.0142667331,
-0.0388401598,
0.037546277,
-0.1076137796,
-0.0038086227,
0.0046623107,
-0.054820884,
-0.0241806004,
-0.0445671119,
0.0047637834,
0.0196876936,
-0.0425733402,
0.0014087501,
-0.022586396,
0.0250472464,
0.0326124541,
-0.0216892827,
-0.0009283203,
0.0717083365,
-0.0255958959,
0.0504951626,
0.0520708226,
0.0091957422,
-0.0379682854,
0.0047750156,
-0.0131721767,
-0.0253634397,
-0.0263214838,
-0.0061032074,
0.04457004,
-0.0259708948,
0.038571246,
-0.0232157577,
0.040901009,
-0.0161277615,
0.0060936068,
0.0795627832,
0.0773049444,
0.0146321701,
-0.0163786709,
-0.059648633,
0.0161638521,
-0.002927135,
0.0897142962,
0.0455894098,
-0.0863195509,
0.0296570305,
-0.0321954079,
-0.0051370356,
-0.0356671065,
-0.0571623482,
0.023160778,
-0.0393905044,
0.0026109561,
-0.0425228029,
-0.0701189637,
0.0719445795,
-0.0259994492,
0.0131993704,
0.0572995581,
-0.0424108692,
0.0110206464,
-0.0231736787,
-0.0033142073,
-0.0202577747,
0.0248023402,
-0.0586300157,
-0.0011366451,
0.0452130549,
-0.0406209342,
-0.0429009274,
-0.0014923712,
-0.0278582145,
0.0055315457,
0.0295342207,
0.0457640849,
0.0065623955,
-0.0322390124,
0.0321928635,
-0.0347918347,
0.0413507931,
-0.0074757277,
-0.0193773191,
0.0001833356,
-0.0425536968,
0.0130802961,
0.0045828149,
-0.012448783,
-0.055133339,
0.0353918783,
0.0462522246,
0.0525788628,
0.0299032256,
-0.0486689582,
0.0159163456,
0.057232026,
0.0211060122,
0.0130121792,
-0.0426445939,
-0.0231836475,
0.0024719669,
0.00699325,
-0.0203953795,
0.0002742035,
-0.0135303102,
0.0140781906,
-0.0348781198,
-0.0137010347,
0.0015027146,
-0.0660248473,
0.0547098219,
-0.0341168009,
0.0462694876,
0.0094477804,
0.0422273055,
-0.0028705711,
-0.0232457574,
-0.0422558822,
-0.070500806,
0.0276848748,
0.0131750405,
0.0041570514,
0.063885726,
-0.0041606664,
0.0025422685,
0.0273026116,
0.017978847,
-0.0033417922,
0.0151789123,
-0.0623779297,
0.0106157223,
-0.021421805,
0.0093483068,
0.0329510495,
0.0316864848,
0.0192083083,
-0.0472898372,
0.0026315281,
0.0122548277,
-0.0110013271,
0.0619535558,
0.0077793058,
0.0170848593,
0.0160923693,
0.0299745034,
-0.0295243394,
0.0016492016,
0.0002265059,
-0.0211786609,
-0.0333109349,
0.0196333583,
0.0298174173,
0.0443887562,
0.0023232263,
-0.0121830823,
-0.0648865998,
-0.0353617556,
0.0203561801,
0.0373168737,
-0.0044494928,
0.0027866112,
0.0123651819,
0.0569033511,
-0.0305728111,
-0.0237695388,
-0.0700686574,
0.0282191969,
-0.039417129,
-0.0489358306,
0.0043281601,
-5.881215704e-33,
-0.0268301461,
-0.0307405703,
0.0051698019,
0.0443297029,
0.0225439351,
-0.0274614822,
0.0098242043,
0.0417808965,
-0.0179925691,
-0.0049898392,
-0.0017980264,
-0.0231303181,
-0.0025728073,
0.0543089882,
0.0659356415,
-0.006418597,
0.0132489353,
-0.015849445,
-0.014135153,
0.039103426,
0.0048765312,
-0.0076195495,
0.0564540327,
-0.0312337689,
0.0721133575,
-0.0475531891,
-0.0058331825,
-0.037885502,
-0.0017171891,
0.0571585409,
-0.0190435853,
0.0587427989,
0.0412523933,
-0.0396709144,
-0.000929667,
0.0420739911,
-0.046043504,
-0.0466397367,
0.0214323457,
-0.0295126978,
-0.014089006,
-0.0424344428,
0.0090603596,
-0.0074057244,
-0.0445153415,
-0.0297302827,
0.0877491012,
-0.0309244879,
0.0064149811,
-0.0333377123,
-0.0380815715,
0.0052810679,
-0.0027830102,
-0.0100655844,
-0.0343603753,
0.1379362643,
-0.0030922191,
0.0423629992,
-0.0291507151,
0.0549185388,
0.0549959056,
0.0492558219,
0.0363877788,
0.0247248691,
-0.027631266,
0.0446295813,
0.0172588341,
-0.0147738997,
0.0095356489,
-0.0287386216,
0.0371898524,
-0.0465201065,
0.1223600805,
0.0605948977,
0.0178578254,
0.010076981,
-0.0701427907,
0.0811470747,
-0.0135594187,
-0.0081542693,
0.0162436329,
-0.0760486349,
-0.0546638295,
-0.0264927652,
-0.0840123296,
-0.0172246788,
-0.0367649607,
-0.0314338207,
0.0464366935,
-0.06657812,
-0.0117852679,
-0.0163899828,
0.02703337,
-0.018396385,
-0.0324824005,
-0.0392256305,
0.0207148772,
0.0503009222,
-0.0134413606,
-0.0077890074,
-0.0244640093,
0.0324929953,
0.0007173682,
-0.032465104,
-0.0011027812,
-0.0102318851,
0.0146328406,
-0.0262840111,
-0.0460150875,
-0.0430675074,
0.0131261665,
-0.0558547154,
0.0151559785,
-0.0021092244,
-0.0214347076,
0.0371852815,
0.0057130973,
0.0906309187,
-0.0039021419,
-0.0429372527,
0.0200846903,
-0.06560155,
0.0283796228,
-0.0289745666,
-0.03930692,
-0.0083666798,
-0.0292141419,
0.0053151334,
-0.0107816337,
-0.0174859054,
0.0158927329,
-0.0020111273,
2.655e-7,
0.0644753128,
0.0533719771,
-0.0549665913,
-0.0269381963,
-0.0343620777,
0.0267194398,
0.042357441,
-0.0014365214,
0.0727647617,
0.0365622528,
0.0142055703,
-0.0328989848,
0.0038307675,
0.0269267131,
-0.0683186501,
-0.0308603663,
-0.0073657357,
-0.0370120294,
-0.0272812787,
0.0226299744,
0.0881125107,
0.0305815563,
0.0387165248,
-0.0093259634,
-0.0421794653,
-0.0208703727,
0.0078981612,
-0.0405791104,
-0.0097035011,
0.0350733288,
0.0148202088,
-0.023789458,
0.0365828574,
0.0318811275,
-0.0147332409,
-0.0056498069,
0.0302075837,
0.0036848427,
0.0166774634,
-0.0032521479,
0.0131023545,
0.01036839,
0.0206405837,
-0.053313408,
0.0480794646,
-0.0421373621,
0.0037233036,
0.0170954168,
-0.0262545552,
-0.0024197605,
-0.002706486,
-0.0063057151,
-0.0050333305,
0.0300935134,
0.0222722422,
0.0042289286,
0.0016487198,
-0.0006263247,
-0.0008438146,
0.0104984604,
-0.0064008622,
-0.0285525508,
-0.0507721901,
-0.0329275206,
-0.0237073172,
-0.0601895563,
0.0008264995,
2.410725396e-34,
0.0182314068,
-0.0251945853,
0.017013263,
-0.0314464718,
-0.0058667813,
0.0040006745,
-0.0018090879,
0.0303876512,
0.0382102169,
-0.0991005301,
-0.0385345481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18624v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18624v5 | W-procer: Weighted Prototypical Contrastive Learning for Medical Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-29T21:17:52 | 2023-08-01T00:04:32 | Mingchen Li, Yang Ye, Jeremy Yeung, Huixue Zhou, Huaiyuan Chu, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive learning has become a popular solution for few-shot Name Entity
Recognization (NER). The conventional configuration strives to reduce the
distance between tokens with the same labels and increase the distance between
tokens with different labels. The effect of this setup may, however, in the
medical domain, there are a lot of entities annotated as OUTSIDE (O), and they
are undesirably pushed apart to other entities that are not labeled as OUTSIDE
(O) by the current contrastive learning method end up with a noisy prototype
for the semantic representation of the label, though there are many OUTSIDE (O)
labeled entities are relevant to the labeled entities. To address this
challenge, we propose a novel method named Weighted Prototypical Contrastive
Learning for Medical Few Shot Named Entity Recognization (W-PROCER). Our
approach primarily revolves around constructing the prototype-based contractive
loss and weighting network. These components play a crucial role in assisting
the model in differentiating the negative samples from OUTSIDE (O) tokens and
enhancing the discrimination ability of contrastive learning. Experimental
results show that our proposed W-PROCER framework significantly outperforms the
strong baselines on the three medical benchmark datasets. | [
0.0113706226,
0.0434074625,
0.0227396376,
-0.0029228108,
-0.0035535574,
0.042095501,
0.03284356,
0.0101871351,
-0.0360037945,
0.0078906631,
-0.0417318419,
-0.0670622289,
0.0322159827,
0.0119519988,
0.0487285107,
-0.0601127334,
0.0173739791,
0.0595067479,
-0.0042459881,
0.0199821331,
-0.0221792217,
-0.0226627365,
-0.0511242487,
0.0368941501,
0.0226844139,
-0.0031762565,
0.0224893801,
0.0231640879,
0.0542489327,
-0.1279491782,
0.0228654686,
0.0348706953,
-0.0516148768,
0.0158682,
0.000002082,
-0.0518310629,
-0.0264985077,
0.0310807526,
-0.0218683612,
-0.0608378313,
0.0810489804,
-0.0385508761,
0.0002049013,
0.0099515375,
0.0055988259,
-0.1018967777,
0.0521131754,
0.0891501531,
-0.0035028036,
0.0567845441,
-0.0085364403,
-0.0458511934,
0.0368000977,
-0.0164513309,
0.0027856505,
-0.0014566141,
0.0470481999,
-0.0701496005,
-0.022237964,
-0.0248937029,
-0.0125888735,
-0.0021641213,
0.0059734662,
0.0565269105,
0.0374513343,
0.0744968578,
-0.0258568395,
-0.0052842139,
0.0045582028,
0.0877402201,
-0.0132652409,
-0.0117080584,
0.0340525322,
-0.036776863,
-0.0148200532,
-0.0633943006,
-0.0174666382,
-0.0272507351,
-0.0240533128,
-0.0049197078,
0.0046430151,
0.0506261699,
0.0273382645,
-0.0158836599,
-0.028373586,
-0.0562161133,
0.0180909373,
0.0007077846,
0.0092937481,
0.014763495,
-0.0348500423,
-0.0203625821,
0.0504887812,
0.0226856079,
-0.007261069,
0.013777093,
-0.0225160904,
-0.0607015863,
0.0208237059,
-0.0152099123,
-0.0130623672,
0.0207116194,
-0.0089613833,
0.0311428718,
-0.0562832318,
-0.0031312753,
-0.0227083024,
0.0241729934,
-0.0041822805,
-0.0054376931,
-0.0314177684,
0.0210143197,
-0.0300978832,
0.0647485107,
0.025148008,
0.0070398538,
-0.0401076525,
-0.0285779871,
-0.0190441255,
0.0012676229,
0.0033930901,
0.0200864002,
-0.0220983457,
-0.0114218192,
0.0018328648,
0.0502198339,
-0.0120616443,
0.0022700601,
-0.0323000476,
-0.0423679315,
0.0077350396,
-0.0034837562,
0.0051394654,
-0.0090251975,
0.0627738386,
0.0790436417,
0.0372281596,
-0.0776662081,
-0.0359541997,
0.0147991553,
-0.0186339635,
-0.0100118481,
-0.0080052214,
-0.050272584,
0.0105045391,
0.0005822827,
0.0058124536,
-0.0647440553,
0.0069960942,
-0.0079229986,
-0.027739564,
0.0849179775,
-0.0770437419,
-0.0526343584,
0.0100241946,
0.0146019179,
-0.0326578431,
0.0240261182,
0.0277398098,
-0.0529400632,
-0.0264751799,
0.033289209,
-0.0087377196,
-0.0134710092,
0.0471223034,
-0.0593966953,
-0.0355368257,
-0.0108761471,
0.0158596765,
0.0546717197,
0.0244934633,
0.0433206186,
-0.0373800285,
-0.0591152646,
0.0016594878,
0.0480110832,
0.034436278,
-0.0005300986,
-0.0027333812,
-0.0277141742,
-0.0276577063,
-0.0219737217,
-0.0287716724,
0.0196126085,
0.0222368501,
0.0002496798,
-0.0428202376,
0.0102485586,
-0.0530677699,
0.0003390299,
0.0363872163,
-0.0291039478,
-0.0340601243,
-0.04111927,
0.0768030584,
0.0115880799,
-0.052802112,
0.0404043756,
0.066393517,
-0.0032266867,
-0.0023649884,
-0.0451095514,
-0.0049336022,
0.0477905832,
0.026934227,
-0.0410475731,
-0.0629958361,
-0.0303706117,
-0.0273224339,
0.0152347265,
-0.0032108952,
0.0046590208,
0.0449193716,
-0.046825327,
-0.0136402119,
0.0285121184,
0.0162600316,
0.0042763813,
0.0068790331,
0.0564998426,
-0.0087868618,
-0.0481345132,
0.0268193558,
0.0428338088,
-0.0282710455,
-0.0415592007,
0.0392939523,
0.0397155322,
0.026154615,
0.0293138716,
-0.0022329008,
0.0010504121,
0.0017423538,
-0.0412876979,
0.0110722659,
-0.0250505786,
-0.0338576958,
-0.070194751,
0.0260467436,
-0.0450750478,
0.0164105296,
-0.0140355267,
-0.03514966,
-0.0422990546,
-0.0014535773,
-0.003183922,
0.0150345014,
0.0078158937,
0.0386177227,
0.0133011835,
-0.0018184591,
-0.0242444146,
0.0228190348,
-0.0155943902,
0.0366341323,
0.0012259589,
0.034435641,
-0.0052365847,
-0.0026282535,
-0.03960618,
-0.0100523513,
-0.0326977111,
-0.0097297477,
-0.0313563198,
-0.0066857319,
-0.0483407974,
-0.0250099991,
-0.0424153768,
0.0110463267,
0.0209841393,
0.0480884239,
0.0220096987,
0.0319207422,
0.0116019417,
-0.0354319587,
-0.0106958542,
-0.0068694884,
-0.0424505547,
0.01153831,
0.0464324579,
0.0246895514,
-0.0205672886,
0.0181668513,
-0.0027799453,
-0.0185715109,
0.0242669247,
-0.0171763357,
-0.0195733421,
-0.0208516195,
0.030235067,
-0.031026721,
-0.0006288208,
0.0107204141,
0.0149831139,
0.0239782762,
0.0382012203,
-0.019028917,
0.0803205743,
-0.0205846336,
0.0097988835,
-0.0131231463,
0.0108754104,
-0.0126769384,
0.0005898126,
-0.0299364515,
0.0363119245,
0.0202638935,
-0.0391726792,
-0.0176931396,
0.1080785692,
-0.0240702927,
0.0331539623,
-0.0309952479,
-0.0124382144,
0.0133633642,
0.0098897107,
0.0117004616,
0.0390344262,
-0.0524901822,
-0.0189263877,
-0.0302770808,
0.0026587411,
0.0835271254,
-0.0118169431,
0.0149260201,
-0.0081470115,
-0.0020988071,
-0.0197384804,
-0.0037682762,
0.0234476365,
0.0014208142,
0.0621062145,
-0.0724338889,
-0.037340939,
0.0176234208,
-0.0157590378,
-0.0566660352,
0.0184260737,
0.0261307154,
0.0039156773,
-0.0317531228,
-0.0517155118,
-0.0212167408,
0.0283257887,
-0.0349097401,
0.0313482583,
-0.023503121,
0.0269820318,
-0.061386887,
0.0428658985,
-0.0033493675,
0.0985793397,
0.0199576784,
-0.0050595985,
-0.0283270329,
0.0586364716,
-0.0105547048,
-0.0347406603,
0.037540473,
-0.004427792,
0.0335322879,
0.0495667085,
0.0185976531,
-0.0072048586,
-0.0206001066,
0.0002966081,
-0.0047200206,
-0.0339466929,
-0.0224047545,
0.0146383746,
0.0305341464,
-0.0346914828,
-0.01081602,
0.0898548737,
-0.0155111551,
-0.094425492,
0.0003786122,
0.0358400866,
-0.0008149123,
0.0034936664,
-0.0094961254,
-0.0359332673,
-0.0533027984,
0.0304616522,
0.0282503236,
-0.0182512049,
-0.0612091534,
0.0260629691,
-0.0810419247,
0.0185815692,
-0.0203102771,
-0.0778537095,
-0.0055229231,
-0.057325501,
0.0224098098,
-0.0451021977,
-0.0107258391,
0.0002696311,
-0.0143790245,
-0.0082993498,
0.0159511399,
0.0010146337,
-0.0593548752,
-0.0124462675,
-0.0411885493,
0.0412226617,
0.0099543715,
0.0142064178,
-0.0075783106,
-0.01421938,
0.0021334204,
-0.0818709284,
-0.0521394573,
-0.0254349168,
0.0912163928,
-0.0284935124,
-0.0204942096,
-0.039967265,
0.0133769112,
-0.0420682244,
-0.0476189144,
-0.0278372783,
0.0258740131,
0.0094832443,
0.0056336592,
-0.0299731586,
-0.0130223241,
0.0130434083,
0.0471344888,
0.0175124127,
-0.018542977,
-0.0101931365,
0.0546508804,
0.0539120436,
0.013873796,
0.0224401057,
-0.014986719,
-0.0085004102,
-0.0468687229,
-0.019370988,
-0.0055918144,
0.0054205125,
0.0468951277,
-0.005115767,
0.0044225613,
-0.0024833784,
0.0055146799,
-0.0820713639,
0.0261933189,
0.007268134,
0.0224318635,
-0.0629010424,
0.0150000742,
0.0822509378,
-0.0020467241,
-0.0462666564,
-0.0118163032,
-0.0590985678,
-0.0150970062,
-0.0235289261,
0.0177146271,
0.0086406572,
0.0030593132,
-0.0119622219,
-0.0176917277,
0.0671681836,
0.0622012205,
-0.0327616185,
-0.0301783234,
0.0100149009,
-0.0253267493,
-0.0121204304,
0.016342029,
0.0050599743,
0.034430854,
0.0664398819,
0.0101988195,
-0.034540154,
-0.0194138326,
-0.0313925222,
0.0072546573,
0.0832856372,
-0.0263037011,
-0.0222207084,
-0.0396838598,
0.046177201,
0.0292118248,
0.0589562804,
-0.0134543693,
0.0122036273,
0.013293949,
0.0273464005,
-0.0441165753,
0.0016893777,
-0.0047089132,
-0.0161462091,
0.0110779973,
0.0102731902,
0.0289629772,
0.0360033549,
0.0192224402,
-0.0338169709,
-0.013303292,
-0.0017843596,
0.0467887893,
0.0309370849,
-0.0444417223,
0.0181775801,
0.0156093929,
0.0334688947,
-0.0322628208,
0.0354274772,
-0.0293222666,
0.02862004,
-0.0621749759,
0.0259216055,
-0.002256314,
0.0493694581,
-0.0035794543,
0.0265784599,
0.0012780679,
-0.0086767552,
0.0151535375,
-0.0779954344,
0.0190443117,
0.0625747591,
0.0220491476,
0.0046700109,
-0.0003824453,
0.0510025062,
0.0075731929,
0.047049161,
-0.0069547859,
0.0088801123,
-0.0476983227,
0.0130441906,
0.0130204633,
0.0187047552,
-0.0418646596,
0.0168560501,
-0.0475047491,
-0.0346739553,
0.0719777197,
-0.0402902849,
-0.0048498218,
0.0272652972,
0.0383815803,
-0.0250688922,
0.0179471914,
-0.0512063056,
0.0395363458,
0.0039011112,
0.0135635426,
-0.0283705033,
0.0361432061,
-6.088281605e-33,
-0.013742486,
-0.0242797434,
0.0096676322,
-0.0323570371,
-0.0314323828,
0.0377140641,
-0.0303559303,
-0.0095648905,
-0.0026609153,
0.0056409827,
-0.003749154,
0.0069577484,
0.0172203835,
0.0279088207,
-0.0218789149,
-0.0489376634,
0.0715695545,
0.023025699,
0.0004091407,
0.0413901284,
-0.0348607004,
0.0690389052,
0.0444784798,
-0.0588115901,
-0.0382724255,
0.0174470786,
0.0055560367,
0.0262658019,
0.0456788056,
0.0652383417,
-0.0461782701,
-0.0063834256,
0.0315416828,
-0.0277959444,
-0.0053968616,
0.0033805103,
-0.1505609602,
-0.0049143247,
-0.0645295456,
0.027901521,
-0.0089845993,
-0.06172809,
0.0645651519,
0.0037460055,
-0.0027678905,
-0.0250829123,
0.0402858704,
-0.0294059254,
-0.0297395382,
-0.0172499754,
-0.0242407154,
0.0777534992,
0.0079721324,
0.0190107096,
0.0197756849,
-0.0222340394,
-0.0096036931,
0.0552811064,
-0.0836028829,
-0.041418694,
-0.0004416186,
-0.0164282415,
-0.013199782,
0.0437834598,
-0.013243407,
0.050133191,
0.0661061853,
-0.0096609062,
0.018481113,
-0.0361141413,
0.0055451617,
0.0088834781,
0.0464938395,
0.043170426,
0.0767787769,
-0.0282883681,
-0.098445937,
0.0083907275,
-0.0727954656,
0.0461470187,
0.0054946416,
-0.0163826104,
-0.0410829261,
0.0044965222,
-0.0041064043,
-0.1220675111,
-0.0365944356,
-0.016275784,
0.0101528428,
0.0167530589,
-0.0390397198,
0.0721980631,
0.025327947,
-0.0198358763,
-0.0316549651,
0.0050993455,
0.0559097342,
0.0468394198,
-0.0257661492,
-0.0240937099,
-0.0834053978,
-0.0395858735,
0.0370014347,
0.0292074364,
0.0398613699,
0.0000117047,
0.0521892086,
-0.048193261,
-0.0912881643,
-0.0362910219,
0.0216315445,
-0.0074708061,
-0.00631645,
0.028644152,
0.0517874062,
0.0030410429,
0.0165621247,
0.0692886636,
0.0249823276,
-0.0337013118,
-0.0155310864,
0.004729507,
0.0173005313,
0.0484851748,
-0.0344389901,
0.00184978,
0.0070750276,
0.0662464872,
0.0487711132,
-0.0505397767,
-0.0221448373,
-0.0212949067,
2.91e-7,
0.0226097032,
-0.0132337911,
0.0195673015,
-0.0405377522,
0.0082130665,
0.0296189617,
0.0368556529,
0.0303786602,
-0.019975232,
-0.017424535,
0.032864105,
-0.0019391392,
0.0289494097,
0.0345130712,
-0.079657644,
0.0572802834,
-0.0442156792,
0.0036360906,
-0.0130254952,
0.0002044374,
0.0504912287,
0.0656488761,
0.0109716328,
-0.0480976254,
0.0179607999,
0.0022253634,
0.0415112898,
-0.011141072,
0.0688399896,
0.0166561101,
0.0011870584,
0.0436331332,
0.0058646393,
0.0527535267,
0.0065728035,
0.035444621,
-0.0042446828,
0.0444061942,
-0.0453199223,
0.0038005088,
0.0176077075,
-0.0108642029,
0.0215427876,
-0.0132155586,
0.0662630275,
-0.0794516727,
-0.0223948192,
-0.0038246047,
-0.0461651124,
-0.031095393,
0.0717050955,
-0.0135265682,
-0.0209369529,
0.0317199863,
0.0234820582,
-0.0096614845,
-0.0413056314,
-0.0745418817,
0.010490627,
0.0408397168,
0.019267749,
-0.0240955744,
0.0278611276,
-0.0262194611,
0.0096866805,
-0.0409895517,
0.0046445336,
2.353359665e-34,
0.0174506847,
-0.0180858895,
-0.0074865054,
0.0505546071,
-0.0144092748,
-0.0320349932,
-0.0115969488,
-0.0218590554,
0.0211733263,
-0.0321184844,
0.0084447134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18623v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18623v1 | Alfred: A System for Prompted Weak Supervision | 2023-05-29T21:16:42 | 2023-05-29T21:16:42 | Peilin Yu, Stephen H. Bach | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Alfred is the first system for programmatic weak supervision (PWS) that
creates training data for machine learning by prompting. In contrast to typical
PWS systems where weak supervision sources are programs coded by experts,
Alfred enables users to encode their subject matter expertise via natural
language prompts for language and vision-language models. Alfred provides a
simple Python interface for the key steps of this emerging paradigm, with a
high-throughput backend for large-scale data labeling. Users can quickly
create, evaluate, and refine their prompt-based weak supervision sources; map
the results to weak labels; and resolve their disagreements with a label model.
Alfred enables a seamless local development experience backed by models served
from self-managed computing clusters. It automatically optimizes the execution
of prompts with optimized batching mechanisms. We find that this optimization
improves query throughput by 2.9x versus a naive approach. We present two
example use cases demonstrating Alfred on YouTube comment spam detection and
pet breeds classification. Alfred is open source, available at
https://github.com/BatsResearch/alfred. | [
0.061076533,
0.0443251356,
-0.0010438301,
0.0035263442,
-0.0060278266,
0.0260252859,
0.0694369376,
-0.0066585713,
0.0690389127,
-0.0423480906,
-0.0233907942,
0.022338476,
-0.0535784103,
0.0451846421,
0.0118823843,
-0.0661110133,
0.0169190541,
-0.0446965694,
0.0548143908,
0.0072337226,
0.0028103008,
0.011126563,
-0.0196927898,
0.0212003961,
-0.0393413194,
-0.0472269468,
-0.0317693874,
-0.0049212012,
-0.0180198569,
-0.0245592333,
0.0304563623,
0.0610236935,
0.006092967,
0.0498751476,
0.0000020123,
-0.0300615467,
-0.001720804,
0.0011000799,
-0.0004729093,
-0.0187203996,
0.0353063978,
-0.0387860686,
0.0066509084,
0.0160829853,
-0.0517841093,
-0.0239013247,
0.0712049752,
-0.0008805548,
0.0910331458,
0.0313586369,
-0.0070037264,
-0.0011168704,
-0.017291015,
0.0061858948,
0.0279532764,
-0.023037333,
0.0169600509,
-0.036013972,
0.0050926167,
0.0201752465,
0.036903847,
0.0249885581,
0.0138032613,
-0.0532867759,
0.0390063003,
0.0289087296,
-0.0365401544,
-0.0740127638,
-0.0519978814,
0.0360687822,
0.0144937309,
-0.0202274378,
0.0069564134,
0.0102847824,
-0.0146996798,
0.0101296818,
-0.0263313539,
0.0548694767,
-0.0118621765,
-0.0246507749,
-0.0161586702,
0.011023704,
-0.0181701183,
0.0334480554,
0.0317275226,
0.0366405509,
-0.0030191296,
-0.0159174763,
0.0047421395,
0.029444214,
0.0080894055,
-0.054507345,
0.0105970195,
0.0390007086,
-0.0617988296,
-0.004769722,
-0.0508540533,
-0.0617902353,
0.0234911274,
-0.0237135682,
-0.0110106049,
-0.0202612728,
-0.0638051182,
0.0811237097,
-0.0133205066,
0.0205803439,
0.0279663019,
0.0083857803,
0.022865558,
-0.0023561502,
-0.068231158,
-0.0306344889,
-0.0432745516,
0.0181102585,
-0.0175989605,
-0.0053421408,
-0.0126364874,
0.0482846797,
-0.0341774821,
0.0183113348,
-0.0059994138,
0.0287853498,
-0.030904999,
0.0607235059,
-0.0290127732,
-0.0026626284,
-0.0532031022,
0.0229714736,
-0.0007999267,
-0.045495443,
-0.0014978767,
0.0248448327,
-0.0036999974,
0.0000167873,
0.037200518,
0.0605198294,
-0.0092624938,
-0.0078871641,
-0.0635682419,
-0.0546003506,
-0.0163218156,
-0.0189812686,
-0.0233165398,
-0.0738751367,
0.0075539649,
0.0139707616,
0.0010849662,
-0.0312810019,
-0.0095945038,
0.0204493608,
-0.0218880177,
0.0549270324,
-0.0697811395,
-0.000770753,
0.0529282875,
0.0148893343,
-0.0143049415,
0.0510903224,
-0.0488939732,
0.0609023198,
0.0636264458,
-0.0053769359,
0.0509116277,
-0.0032021541,
0.0029601408,
0.0235871486,
-0.0567517094,
0.0190283228,
-0.0053529684,
0.0034656052,
0.007810771,
0.0453920253,
0.018520603,
0.0076463451,
0.0630751625,
0.0674208328,
-0.0198173486,
0.0008128416,
0.0434290171,
0.0145970397,
0.0049750158,
-0.0558967181,
-0.0369716063,
0.0403069034,
-0.0281595234,
-0.0321622416,
-0.0096194772,
0.0299062431,
-0.0259852502,
-0.0330000259,
0.0110925324,
-0.0319021419,
-0.0260359719,
0.0046020751,
0.073079817,
0.0365970917,
0.0225728918,
-0.0321636945,
0.0275120437,
-0.021248946,
-0.0419005938,
-0.049501963,
0.0689485893,
0.0942749977,
0.0125118289,
-0.0289693177,
-0.0090153972,
-0.0257103518,
0.0650230497,
0.0090326918,
0.0189227704,
-0.0343235917,
0.0003339369,
-0.0036738506,
-0.0458340235,
0.0022972173,
0.0095880302,
-0.0063588894,
0.0296057556,
-0.004166632,
0.0051559233,
-0.0109409727,
-0.0505749248,
0.0654539913,
0.04737157,
-0.0425429009,
-0.0120248627,
0.0283696912,
0.0167066175,
0.0145794926,
0.0116667124,
-0.018843228,
0.0510854609,
0.012367134,
-0.0104183517,
-0.0562605113,
-0.0063357092,
0.0009545581,
0.021498071,
-0.0268246345,
-0.0291837361,
-0.0081357118,
-0.0402076244,
-0.0149501087,
-0.021645708,
-0.0321851224,
0.005240337,
-0.0252030399,
-0.017735457,
-0.0060615921,
-0.0134239718,
-0.0335457698,
0.0576668344,
0.0557777993,
0.0047519025,
0.0303150341,
-0.0014105026,
-0.0059550139,
-0.0035187807,
-0.0166845433,
-0.0310654081,
-0.0110017825,
0.0315575153,
0.0248022769,
0.0444333404,
-0.0333386771,
0.0087177698,
-0.0989396349,
-0.0057341061,
-0.0278036669,
-0.0258750301,
0.011837353,
0.015320532,
-0.0108262692,
-0.0570638217,
-0.0176691953,
-0.0198317114,
-0.0314244255,
0.0498941801,
0.023058176,
0.0259976033,
0.0011768286,
0.0068533611,
0.0020495974,
-0.0032435115,
0.0322428271,
0.0674081892,
-0.0363233052,
-0.0488384739,
-0.0012203833,
-0.01664133,
0.0139353694,
0.0166856758,
-0.0138712618,
0.0216832384,
-0.0160489567,
0.0261905305,
0.0440160222,
-0.0044834102,
0.0369035602,
0.0468809046,
0.0276926495,
-0.0464711823,
-0.0032244725,
-0.0098863151,
-0.047959242,
0.0329067186,
0.0003923028,
0.0199516192,
0.0319193304,
0.0074649095,
-0.0188446548,
-0.039542269,
0.0543687977,
0.0129853366,
-0.0168971922,
-0.0652449057,
-0.0021554388,
0.0215757582,
0.0147154042,
-0.0055881352,
-0.1048173532,
0.1098211035,
-0.0095349755,
-0.0295062941,
-0.0234761685,
-0.093912743,
-0.0106358901,
0.067548573,
0.0057407878,
0.0262162406,
0.0132549554,
-0.0115699098,
-0.0287872422,
0.0307976659,
0.0184626319,
0.0051492201,
-0.0436749607,
-0.0477597266,
0.0133876139,
0.0168866683,
-0.0192790199,
-0.0525786616,
-0.0584201328,
-0.0613610931,
-0.0207065344,
0.0210217889,
-0.0422204733,
0.010941457,
0.0386563167,
0.0457718968,
0.0559121259,
0.0074612778,
-0.0428028964,
-0.0065433192,
-0.054685276,
0.0334985107,
-0.0420473218,
-0.0692213327,
-0.0271549076,
0.0206565652,
0.0703331456,
0.0809302405,
-0.0371687822,
-0.0563407429,
0.0056656213,
-0.0044459854,
-0.0119798789,
0.0175627638,
0.0172421336,
0.0236473083,
-0.0537777916,
-0.0045434018,
0.0824250877,
0.0406067334,
-0.0899045765,
-0.013306926,
-0.0169442426,
0.0281631537,
0.0576943941,
0.0436860546,
-0.0470191799,
-0.0503479876,
-0.0169234965,
0.1020370647,
-0.0053153988,
-0.0378719456,
0.0105946427,
-0.077032499,
0.0390170328,
-0.0254240781,
-0.0323379375,
-0.0045905681,
-0.0873298049,
0.0003191083,
-0.0284885895,
-0.0536610149,
-0.0125577068,
-0.0059115519,
0.0187104866,
0.0289963,
0.0123669403,
-0.0251995698,
0.0046889782,
-0.05844374,
0.0442681834,
0.0484110266,
-0.0164036546,
0.0036258555,
-0.0354681462,
0.0109458435,
0.0029234809,
-0.0099139558,
-0.0347271301,
0.0694306418,
-0.0290733706,
-0.0253979564,
0.009375589,
0.048967544,
-0.0219241884,
-0.0006558927,
0.0512762628,
0.0932327881,
-0.0267099217,
0.0023035423,
-0.0470808297,
-0.0319084451,
0.0615219884,
0.0798356459,
0.0159891043,
-0.0795869902,
0.0024087089,
-0.0145863872,
-0.0271905418,
0.0506134257,
-0.0343472287,
0.0008975425,
-0.0485915057,
-0.05984262,
-0.0672182143,
-0.0079696532,
0.0859111547,
0.0469160564,
0.0396772213,
-0.0205523148,
0.0147399623,
0.0154636903,
-0.067153953,
0.0672950223,
0.0042867055,
-0.0010880633,
-0.0873168409,
-0.0777215436,
0.0551742986,
-0.009443718,
-0.0087897656,
0.0301554203,
-0.0053478978,
-0.0463100523,
0.0072028502,
0.0888539106,
0.0217343457,
0.0103399064,
-0.0062698042,
-0.0580078065,
0.0520365499,
0.0939959064,
-0.0497605726,
-0.0290679503,
0.0037063274,
-0.0268518794,
-0.0037175813,
0.0000300562,
-0.0583162121,
0.0270542428,
-0.0173136797,
-0.0265227556,
-0.0394866653,
-0.0130372085,
0.019652525,
0.0046642395,
0.0870299414,
-0.0160497241,
-0.0206596144,
-0.0180239715,
0.0015743686,
0.022288572,
-0.0427997597,
-0.0421638601,
0.0511829369,
-0.0048161335,
0.0007409044,
0.0274635088,
0.0092286225,
0.0129584661,
-0.0138069177,
-0.0462947227,
0.0032359981,
0.0091399793,
0.0433100946,
0.0412051417,
0.0031549518,
-0.0047528432,
0.027034739,
0.0164118949,
0.0541526042,
-0.0131738055,
0.0252239462,
0.0515395142,
0.007573612,
0.0098010506,
0.0147271836,
-0.0509338006,
-0.0596416742,
-0.0140551478,
0.04634149,
0.0000223206,
-0.0154834166,
0.005605557,
-0.0460911691,
-0.0224658567,
-0.0277435072,
0.0223731473,
0.0282125548,
-0.0325030945,
-0.0073793055,
0.0179936569,
-0.0341103896,
0.0273318477,
0.0654382259,
0.008956519,
0.0390946157,
0.0017035098,
-0.0677207336,
-0.0526767373,
0.020737974,
0.0389080308,
-0.008247084,
-0.0208557993,
-0.0205373522,
0.0122658927,
-0.0325160064,
-0.0204942971,
-0.0228658486,
-0.0233470127,
0.0056291418,
0.0854412541,
0.083189249,
0.0046989205,
0.0175591987,
-0.0204076767,
0.029496735,
0.017918298,
-0.0429165736,
-0.0123929055,
-6.45147887e-33,
0.0074451966,
-0.0719147846,
-0.0007841852,
-0.004487223,
0.0698219761,
0.0042708465,
-0.0037438814,
0.019007951,
0.0286850277,
0.0436449051,
0.003205823,
0.0084953308,
0.0169809349,
0.0133661106,
0.0537359379,
-0.0082416041,
0.0423159376,
-0.0177316442,
-0.0055808956,
0.0695768744,
0.0512801409,
0.0467346981,
0.0058973175,
-0.1279823929,
0.0150961271,
0.0035162214,
-0.0140784401,
0.0251109377,
-0.0055215559,
0.038227044,
-0.0044569303,
0.0405130908,
-0.0064102923,
-0.0278647114,
-0.0015855052,
0.0266270433,
-0.0444028117,
-0.0205963571,
-0.0208018161,
-0.0181956384,
-0.0571216233,
0.0086572273,
0.0431348234,
-0.0173683036,
0.0224233493,
0.0648700669,
0.0740140304,
-0.0077247736,
-0.0290242098,
-0.025496196,
-0.0259224065,
0.007369556,
-0.0294865221,
-0.0022522071,
0.0235670954,
0.0166926067,
-0.0035616783,
0.0078510558,
-0.0104792332,
0.0298736338,
0.0035817884,
0.0091520417,
0.0538002886,
0.030982716,
-0.0272151511,
0.0411623344,
0.0377534628,
-0.0149940485,
0.0066040331,
0.0052700234,
-0.0282846112,
0.0726769641,
0.0560213029,
0.0074805198,
-0.0021082149,
-0.0027878224,
-0.0344306268,
0.0055562556,
0.0309078731,
0.0069997362,
-0.0033504721,
0.000894274,
-0.0417358316,
-0.0150429271,
0.0018852121,
-0.0338492393,
-0.0287941042,
-0.0091160266,
0.0152526712,
0.0303577669,
-0.0697144344,
-0.0126151387,
-0.010462868,
-0.008029826,
-0.0113966232,
-0.0197652429,
0.0012135148,
0.0096876062,
-0.0074492544,
-0.0127037475,
-0.0317159183,
-0.0252844226,
0.0237913132,
0.0005615949,
0.0525068417,
0.0234491322,
0.0674674213,
0.0289338622,
-0.0692113265,
0.0084739756,
-0.0206235219,
0.0483357944,
0.0031297489,
0.0144336615,
0.0173533782,
-0.0207625702,
-0.0063827168,
0.0464797169,
0.0196394455,
0.0122906603,
-0.0375132114,
-0.033316236,
-0.0098320274,
-0.0241625533,
-0.0165541451,
-0.0242610481,
-0.0397104621,
0.0193322171,
0.0345145948,
-0.0616773888,
0.0090104816,
0.001398509,
2.876e-7,
-0.0087566152,
0.0734458342,
-0.0150460768,
-0.0293507148,
0.0001827029,
0.049327448,
-0.0017991412,
0.0156130223,
-0.0181188118,
-0.0377340466,
-0.0261444878,
0.0033425358,
0.0452497974,
0.0403891876,
-0.0999254063,
-0.0519192182,
-0.0721124113,
0.0155899087,
-0.0982630849,
0.0369950384,
0.0301525686,
0.0667447895,
0.0317911729,
-0.0201984961,
0.0430754125,
-0.0749163181,
-0.0225779153,
0.0186353382,
0.0324201733,
0.0113103371,
0.0710144639,
0.0415969342,
-0.0026016221,
0.0285186358,
-0.0428833924,
-0.0370543972,
-0.0284173507,
0.0336309932,
-0.0012413861,
0.0227432996,
0.0185179505,
0.0100012347,
0.0157858618,
-0.0066951024,
0.0541095436,
-0.0148395589,
0.005097338,
-0.0173681043,
0.0288763288,
-0.0638976619,
0.020115383,
-0.0457068346,
0.0117875226,
0.012510079,
0.0043578111,
-0.0285017528,
-0.0577547885,
-0.0609290302,
-0.0052737878,
-0.0323467962,
-0.0240748469,
-0.0391808935,
-0.0354500078,
0.024908822,
0.0236638971,
-0.0256926212,
0.0265531987,
2.789398963e-34,
0.0115329465,
0.0141610876,
0.0028813812,
0.0061378684,
0.0074204528,
0.0099256616,
-0.0293325651,
-0.0091912011,
0.0096371388,
-0.0287576839,
-0.0199472923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18602v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18602v1 | From `Snippet-lects' to Doculects and Dialects: Leveraging Neural Representations of Speech for Placing Audio Signals in a Language Landscape | 2023-05-29T20:37:06 | 2023-05-29T20:37:06 | Séverine Guillaume, Guillaume Wisniewski, Alexis Michaud | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | XLSR-53 a multilingual model of speech, builds a vector representation from
audio, which allows for a range of computational treatments. The experiments
reported here use this neural representation to estimate the degree of
closeness between audio files, ultimately aiming to extract relevant linguistic
properties. We use max-pooling to aggregate the neural representations from a
"snippet-lect" (the speech in a 5-second audio snippet) to a "doculect" (the
speech in a given resource), then to dialects and languages. We use data from
corpora of 11 dialects belonging to 5 less-studied languages. Similarity
measurements between the 11 corpora bring out greatest closeness between those
that are known to be dialects of the same language. The findings suggest that
(i) dialect/language can emerge among the various parameters characterizing
audio files and (ii) estimates of overall phonetic/phonological closeness can
be obtained for a little-resourced or fully unknown language. The findings help
shed light on the type of information captured by neural representations of
speech and how it can be extracted from these representations | [
-0.0245256331,
0.0386882573,
-0.026371235,
0.0265801493,
-0.0571538806,
-0.0142308725,
-0.00257996,
-0.0160795636,
-0.0649302304,
-0.0272167157,
-0.0893800408,
-0.0292491876,
0.083679162,
-0.0288346875,
0.0606599227,
-0.0443669595,
0.0275418237,
-0.0334469676,
0.0019621777,
-0.0285803489,
0.0197264589,
-0.003289778,
-0.0066475929,
0.0487922691,
-0.0179462191,
0.0226653069,
-0.0181021784,
0.0145565169,
0.000384953,
0.043356929,
-0.040361505,
0.0039051382,
0.0263053048,
0.0408234224,
0.0000016788,
-0.0361465998,
0.0218148734,
-0.0171738677,
-0.0194289777,
-0.0032867314,
0.0077401223,
0.006550754,
-0.0478245504,
0.0089572687,
-0.0068935179,
-0.0250582695,
0.0479337871,
-0.0237591099,
-0.0006865622,
0.0444094241,
-0.021564858,
-0.0412139222,
0.0022728653,
-0.0173757859,
-0.0162730757,
0.0099071814,
-0.0134770488,
-0.0352330506,
0.0298510101,
-0.0508111529,
-0.0379089117,
0.0417667255,
-0.0163689982,
0.0114562027,
-0.0333254896,
0.044314988,
-0.0471335351,
-0.0255297665,
0.0074580805,
0.0338405631,
-0.0243878458,
-0.0538026169,
-0.0043790797,
0.0459465608,
-0.0206925999,
0.016584428,
-0.0337756388,
0.015320194,
0.0167540144,
0.0352733061,
-0.0114830211,
0.0017063459,
0.0153453602,
-0.0339108966,
-0.0010691111,
0.0281176064,
0.0069870264,
-0.0466891453,
0.0502407476,
-0.0096068326,
0.0154476464,
-0.0057340031,
0.030862892,
0.0036779752,
0.0281733461,
-0.0174718481,
0.020273447,
-0.0292011574,
0.0213172734,
-0.0430121608,
0.0317216963,
-0.0126006296,
-0.078478843,
0.05151942,
-0.0147419386,
0.0110130198,
-0.0075009055,
0.0136426156,
-0.0577543415,
-0.0345362686,
-0.0671576634,
-0.0024191441,
-0.0238765422,
0.0111860512,
0.0193667933,
0.0010092423,
-0.0022178942,
-0.0321925581,
-0.0184245035,
0.0263405889,
-0.0059559606,
-0.0115632722,
-0.006415613,
-0.0027124502,
0.0122873494,
0.045354329,
-0.0476757623,
0.0456939116,
-0.0637730286,
-0.0579813011,
0.0070769396,
0.0487356521,
-0.0009566297,
0.0045969482,
0.0266983006,
0.0217618085,
0.0150209293,
-0.0049139713,
-0.0441399813,
-0.0030833029,
-0.0435857289,
-0.04004943,
-0.0190041158,
-0.0987812951,
0.0703784823,
-0.0102651287,
-0.0193453301,
-0.0304855164,
-0.0591450632,
-0.0257771257,
-0.0131990789,
0.0571714342,
-0.0047265869,
0.0549368858,
0.0584357306,
-0.0097776428,
0.0045399107,
0.0442933701,
0.03027004,
-0.0216856413,
0.0303371698,
-0.0183893535,
-0.0380929336,
0.0515107997,
-0.0105299298,
-0.0016139535,
-0.0690318644,
-0.0523104966,
-0.0101111764,
0.0076427329,
0.0666407198,
0.0605792291,
-0.0251188353,
-0.0878135785,
0.0535592735,
0.1431944072,
0.0332029946,
0.0018645265,
0.0145590091,
0.0380850919,
0.0052429717,
0.03665144,
0.0123679861,
0.0035965177,
0.018219091,
0.0122628398,
0.0194421895,
0.0739197508,
-0.0378145464,
0.0267766397,
-0.0222089868,
-0.0517756566,
-0.0071853069,
0.0060035856,
0.0384270772,
-0.0213197675,
0.0072418889,
0.084847115,
0.0420515947,
0.000030046,
0.0139850685,
-0.0064085177,
0.0014627249,
0.0034663558,
-0.0286559016,
-0.0436104797,
0.0324885026,
-0.0265496597,
-0.032967452,
0.0448518321,
0.0407262892,
-0.0271818545,
0.0649558306,
-0.0455881134,
0.0265404321,
0.0184170455,
0.0083243754,
0.0846986547,
-0.0704626068,
0.024038244,
-0.0104399398,
-0.0426414721,
0.0401083343,
-0.0270287134,
-0.0232567377,
-0.0016269955,
-0.0088457279,
0.0186632685,
0.048114609,
0.0523516275,
-0.0590672083,
0.0357768424,
0.0168222301,
-0.0378125906,
0.0439671166,
0.0748026073,
-0.029876804,
-0.0026413954,
0.0535366163,
-0.0330140293,
0.0288746022,
-0.0050559239,
0.0207152907,
-0.0333108194,
0.0780727416,
-0.0654632524,
0.0713874474,
-0.0740507916,
0.0350955091,
-0.0360271968,
0.0230604503,
0.0175000969,
0.0236777514,
0.0224204157,
0.0021180206,
0.0096764043,
-0.0153534506,
0.0594521798,
-0.0644279122,
-0.0221503526,
0.0549453273,
-0.0407232009,
-0.0025258858,
0.018074384,
-0.0651964247,
-0.0141833853,
-0.0194152165,
-0.1040449068,
-0.0174253359,
-0.0254445858,
0.0330877006,
-0.0026218947,
-0.0044340473,
0.000319483,
-0.0237771329,
-0.0304981116,
-0.0223597493,
-0.0118039129,
0.046219822,
-0.0359373465,
0.0215532016,
-0.0067149373,
-0.040675506,
-0.0254945029,
0.0008914003,
0.0308088399,
-0.0546616092,
-0.0522373058,
-0.0319235437,
-0.0425250344,
-0.0392068326,
0.0380322263,
0.0129906274,
-0.0385170802,
-0.013191225,
-0.0267424788,
0.0558420531,
0.0172016677,
-0.0358956605,
-0.0244657546,
0.0792186782,
-0.021137841,
-0.0557580851,
-0.004892644,
-0.0035491111,
0.0425650179,
-0.0580874793,
0.0049948581,
-0.0337758176,
0.0381992348,
0.057958141,
-0.0000647677,
-0.0127515616,
0.0030643132,
-0.0227536913,
0.0045215236,
-0.019478485,
-0.0512066558,
-0.0394550562,
0.0659417883,
-0.0283051562,
-0.0411764756,
0.0633028299,
-0.0738346651,
-0.0340738669,
-0.0511108488,
-0.0693382993,
-0.028880354,
0.0153881451,
-0.0112095131,
0.0190437119,
-0.0305425711,
-0.0313958414,
-0.0423950963,
0.012186016,
0.0069249333,
-0.0266254377,
0.0330119506,
-0.0054220646,
-0.0118404105,
-0.008837061,
-0.0374350585,
0.0054437541,
-0.0200559832,
-0.0082123391,
0.0363857821,
0.0139176669,
0.0059656557,
0.0035041668,
0.0237089302,
0.0352593325,
0.0493760593,
-0.0056059216,
0.0346997268,
-0.01064118,
0.0879075155,
-0.0012386456,
0.0459476262,
0.0023914671,
0.0049300143,
0.0451763608,
-0.018874038,
0.0401133671,
0.0618885905,
-0.0282136016,
0.011827277,
0.0242226403,
0.0043525756,
-0.0634303465,
0.0176861044,
0.0143644074,
0.0150152845,
-0.0137186851,
0.1040886939,
0.0142304581,
-0.0302477311,
0.0123692993,
-0.0200014003,
0.0123493318,
0.0145377908,
0.0313500129,
-0.0137332268,
0.0216973107,
0.0210329723,
0.0115422411,
0.0556132682,
0.0322736315,
-0.0107417265,
-0.080191195,
0.0257413164,
0.0253986642,
-0.0384844504,
-0.0110990275,
-0.0270292778,
-0.0115971407,
-0.0069151758,
0.0090066707,
-0.0096360389,
-0.0035523945,
-0.0280501191,
0.0528565794,
-0.0214745738,
-0.0689968541,
0.0365559943,
-0.0470974259,
0.0644236356,
0.0202380028,
0.0380536951,
-0.0693535358,
-0.0632378608,
0.0142755955,
-0.013629579,
0.0037378399,
0.0280184746,
0.0425046012,
0.0553154983,
-0.0063292221,
0.036490716,
-0.0148675647,
0.0254298653,
-0.0019556715,
-0.0095756939,
0.0703362003,
-0.0122567918,
-0.0011035984,
-0.0023189359,
0.045164153,
-0.024284821,
0.0536874086,
0.0676067546,
-0.031132549,
0.0336371548,
0.0421391726,
0.0450762063,
-0.0139606986,
-0.0105404975,
0.0466371477,
0.0049734511,
-0.0644074231,
-0.0557630025,
-0.0173424091,
-0.0342004821,
0.0268182587,
0.0643913969,
0.018055249,
0.0312865861,
-0.0260480233,
-0.041479256,
0.014845876,
0.0472883023,
0.0324732624,
-0.0092304461,
-0.0457986221,
0.0862651542,
-0.0359918848,
-0.0212838966,
-0.0339420699,
-0.0739915147,
-0.0857149512,
0.0147072729,
-0.0143806115,
0.0279856939,
0.0319163054,
-0.0191758331,
-0.0377860814,
0.0550110005,
0.0267441906,
-0.0227149222,
0.0365362465,
0.0338071287,
-0.0135969268,
-0.009364401,
0.0282371044,
-0.0466127805,
0.0463533327,
-0.0080783246,
-0.0381559879,
-0.0494935587,
-0.0283427536,
-0.0165306907,
-0.0391657576,
0.0344401561,
-0.0023654776,
0.0212032739,
-0.0390590169,
-0.0196660273,
0.0155510334,
0.052471254,
-0.0042219912,
-0.0449614041,
0.0506316796,
0.0214090981,
-0.0022698683,
0.0151914628,
-0.0157343168,
0.0179581586,
0.0106288213,
0.0227792747,
0.0506802574,
0.0141773419,
-0.0226869266,
0.0445625037,
0.0080398945,
0.0268585794,
-0.014479924,
0.0446882769,
-0.0359550416,
0.0154293738,
-0.0018646047,
-0.0019297828,
0.0224734135,
0.0325918756,
-0.0189777911,
-0.0286483541,
0.0083426349,
0.0110230939,
0.0544692315,
-0.0371228904,
0.0369038731,
0.007272155,
0.03148726,
-0.0317861624,
0.0072257654,
-0.0350554511,
-0.0245681312,
-0.0057854778,
0.012916442,
-0.0308665615,
0.0428567491,
0.0470753461,
-0.0314306617,
-0.0153102847,
-0.0062852609,
0.0164587162,
0.0034597078,
-0.0294187404,
-0.0291124005,
0.0593965203,
-0.0325368568,
-0.0058176471,
-0.0524989851,
-0.0836250931,
0.0228388105,
-0.0000667698,
0.0317592882,
0.0368065611,
0.0083015841,
0.012054828,
-0.0181441344,
0.0392349213,
0.0269354265,
-0.0019726704,
-0.0251409411,
-0.0328937061,
0.0101045994,
-5.734088994e-33,
-0.0115752639,
0.0015228322,
-0.0304117221,
-0.0018822032,
-0.0017352443,
-0.0014233097,
-0.0446771234,
-0.0070885816,
-0.03645996,
-0.0179846846,
0.0056857555,
-0.0049902005,
0.012787885,
0.0082827099,
0.0191623755,
0.020065099,
0.027709242,
-0.0163124185,
0.0226448961,
-0.0344444476,
0.0490386821,
0.0183555558,
0.0698270425,
-0.095253177,
-0.0347865336,
0.01757567,
-0.0001272374,
0.0076730554,
0.0262696613,
0.0698833615,
-0.0129569191,
0.0557111725,
-0.002332757,
-0.0142688276,
-0.0310846139,
0.0351488888,
-0.0448033549,
-0.059859626,
0.021676328,
0.0567604341,
0.0274753738,
0.0164088942,
0.0345238075,
-0.0320378728,
-0.0153700998,
0.0048629539,
0.0365055948,
-0.00315241,
-0.004987902,
-0.0147128105,
-0.036981076,
0.0006220748,
-0.0139630949,
-0.0090777092,
0.0793951228,
0.0358254462,
-0.0202864148,
-0.0240909457,
-0.077423431,
0.0351613797,
0.0171759427,
0.0639946982,
0.0571657307,
-0.0084990598,
-0.0121812494,
0.0534049347,
0.0834404081,
-0.0888279453,
0.0355789624,
-0.0268582534,
0.0858736709,
-0.015753746,
-0.0031351815,
0.0213829726,
0.040046785,
-0.03640588,
-0.0059604184,
-0.0166840851,
0.0813702196,
-0.0100589255,
-0.0133583378,
0.0224911626,
-0.0085557802,
-0.028229624,
-0.0194977298,
-0.0760135204,
-0.0198023282,
-0.0302331727,
0.0229256004,
-0.0409719348,
0.0659156814,
0.0224502683,
0.0490743108,
-0.0324171595,
0.0078764558,
-0.0032009757,
-0.0136942612,
-0.0014053569,
0.0256574601,
0.0058914768,
-0.044690311,
0.000787992,
0.0079229996,
0.0142491162,
0.044374153,
0.0031841153,
0.0373968296,
0.0631022826,
-0.0379169956,
-0.0043391217,
-0.0000060223,
-0.0275520831,
-0.0080835847,
0.0163892526,
0.0288996883,
0.0420826226,
-0.0214186031,
-0.0056867646,
0.0435445085,
-0.0049449722,
-0.0046658409,
-0.0301087499,
-0.0263098497,
0.0236812755,
-0.0270232782,
-0.0053384774,
-0.0016963984,
-0.01961983,
0.0555774495,
0.0136493417,
-0.0005446548,
0.0280107092,
2.665e-7,
-0.0116488328,
0.0116480198,
0.0319350585,
-0.0490036868,
0.0553448461,
-0.0144305462,
-0.0546996593,
0.0135783292,
0.0035773616,
-0.0354325511,
-0.0168375671,
-0.0109365089,
0.0692709908,
0.0713120922,
-0.123057209,
0.0230750646,
-0.1078667864,
0.0084997742,
-0.0472951122,
-0.0002845984,
0.0108764134,
0.1140308529,
0.0019997801,
-0.0472224355,
-0.0121829584,
-0.0332602672,
0.0313113146,
-0.0382961668,
0.0202184748,
-0.0332299881,
0.0027050369,
-0.0141920876,
-0.0235290267,
0.0098744091,
-0.0133820064,
0.0718091279,
0.0070462706,
0.0008488094,
-0.0117557868,
-0.0731652677,
-0.0170179885,
-0.0009012767,
-0.0506301634,
-0.0147197265,
0.0050389548,
0.0212132316,
-0.0530277379,
-0.013554859,
-0.0145838391,
0.0290197972,
0.0315251015,
-0.0040322556,
-0.0155217107,
-0.0110506294,
0.0155255022,
-0.0220259223,
-0.0349475294,
-0.031951692,
-0.026747847,
0.0650526956,
-0.0445508659,
-0.0247041956,
0.0247146934,
-0.0078311125,
0.0568558574,
-0.0729263201,
0.006199263,
1.824837315e-34,
0.003706478,
-0.0230805743,
0.0417951159,
0.0059051281,
-0.0044136504,
-0.0351789147,
0.0108289905,
0.0189793352,
0.0124024851,
0.0030531825,
-0.0349711701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18599v1 | Improving Generalization for Multimodal Fake News Detection | 2023-05-29T20:32:22 | 2023-05-29T20:32:22 | Sahar Tahmasebi, Sherzod Hakimov, Ralph Ewerth, Eric Müller-Budack | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.MM | The increasing proliferation of misinformation and its alarming impact have
motivated both industry and academia to develop approaches for fake news
detection. However, state-of-the-art approaches are usually trained on datasets
of smaller size or with a limited set of specific topics. As a consequence,
these models lack generalization capabilities and are not applicable to
real-world data. In this paper, we propose three models that adopt and
fine-tune state-of-the-art multimodal transformers for multimodal fake news
detection. We conduct an in-depth analysis by manipulating the input data aimed
to explore models performance in realistic use cases on social media. Our study
across multiple models demonstrates that these systems suffer significant
performance drops against manipulated data. To reduce the bias and improve
model generalization, we suggest training data augmentation to conduct more
meaningful experiments for fake news detection on social media. The proposed
data augmentation techniques enable models to generalize better and yield
improved state-of-the-art results. | [
0.0630503148,
0.0565926619,
0.002495368,
0.0776496381,
-0.0076891477,
0.0081099961,
0.0132916505,
0.0108640576,
-0.0336570218,
-0.0678990483,
-0.0238258597,
-0.0171126965,
-0.0235927347,
0.0567511916,
0.0414943062,
-0.068580538,
0.0686119199,
0.0243317075,
0.019853292,
-0.0001309997,
0.0722764507,
0.0097262673,
-0.0103274072,
0.0330378301,
-0.0757227615,
0.0197649021,
0.0250810105,
0.0356678516,
0.0483911633,
-0.0023643593,
0.0241759364,
0.0215438008,
0.0583956391,
0.0795861483,
0.0000016879,
0.0082139922,
-0.000543425,
-0.0119473841,
-0.0073919878,
-0.0196225699,
0.0666223839,
-0.1043198258,
0.0182333421,
0.0259781573,
-0.0285036545,
-0.0291073974,
0.0496083051,
0.0861844048,
0.0969630629,
0.0970920101,
-0.0377183445,
-0.0197926853,
0.011253613,
0.0075941798,
-0.0004534972,
-0.0241023116,
0.0230635144,
0.023469761,
-0.0249845944,
0.0329136178,
-0.0017407335,
0.0078178896,
0.0142021105,
0.0052168365,
-0.0075473231,
-0.0053476817,
-0.0120529719,
-0.0388012752,
-0.0013229705,
0.0488362908,
-0.0804992542,
-0.0326499492,
-0.0028194189,
-0.0122827552,
0.0179772712,
0.0492789522,
-0.0123918047,
0.0176523216,
-0.0109793758,
0.0125767356,
-0.0409891121,
0.0003591543,
0.0452491902,
0.0414843038,
0.0109365042,
-0.003350758,
-0.006485668,
0.0109246764,
-0.0035186319,
0.0170098487,
-0.0317808613,
-0.0185319278,
0.0216877926,
0.0031280559,
-0.0040498869,
-0.0039721048,
-0.0827317536,
-0.0597209595,
0.0181776155,
-0.080327034,
0.0058626737,
-0.0108362697,
-0.0343972184,
0.0357637852,
-0.0051636589,
-0.0089983363,
-0.0578438118,
0.0641569346,
-0.0224147458,
-0.0177405775,
-0.017226262,
0.0266169216,
-0.0023626373,
-0.0153421629,
-0.0231728926,
-0.0177700184,
-0.0251026656,
0.0146894697,
-0.0076393206,
-0.0063361689,
-0.0296007041,
0.0104226898,
-0.0482901447,
-0.0167058147,
-0.0012856805,
0.0617286526,
0.0139342165,
0.0327389762,
-0.0090825306,
-0.0485157222,
0.0055770804,
0.0466907136,
-0.017197188,
-0.0125281066,
0.0121511836,
0.0229815505,
-0.015677724,
-0.0278355479,
-0.0370851643,
-0.0262618475,
-0.0344387963,
-0.0441769287,
0.0362828188,
-0.0410940386,
0.0298754722,
-0.0384665318,
-0.0097544696,
0.0051985905,
-0.0385629795,
0.0197252948,
-0.0376349762,
0.068247132,
0.0016720105,
-0.0278087445,
0.0559645891,
0.0288363509,
-0.0103584444,
0.0942743495,
0.0019094482,
0.0918314904,
0.0591247678,
-0.0016940699,
0.0421618298,
0.0352189578,
0.0390926152,
0.0271563698,
0.0210177936,
-0.0198438,
-0.0416385718,
0.0023758234,
0.039477516,
0.0028574606,
-0.0186147708,
-0.0767131373,
0.0771009028,
-0.0594532602,
-0.0032844208,
-0.0165248383,
0.0429318249,
0.0073217605,
-0.0095306775,
-0.0019494288,
-0.062440753,
0.040545132,
-0.057334125,
0.0016577472,
-0.0279254932,
0.0619242936,
-0.0255471282,
0.0062085669,
0.0103456993,
-0.0261220168,
0.0163426064,
-0.0084208893,
0.0230774153,
0.0367452726,
-0.0306328628,
0.0176035706,
0.0232244674,
0.0016405624,
-0.0026435456,
-0.0260263681,
-0.0070016608,
0.0222389158,
0.0277062152,
0.0130248424,
-0.0014706741,
-0.04363757,
0.0230693389,
0.0322456248,
0.0129471654,
-0.0145166293,
-0.0073681553,
-0.0216889698,
-0.0465008095,
-0.0229042321,
0.0146746794,
0.0044327099,
0.0243786629,
0.0058873058,
-0.00165166,
-0.0362684131,
0.0023310487,
0.0133560337,
0.0216631368,
0.0254425388,
-0.0389244929,
0.0276936553,
0.0227817055,
0.0152460756,
0.0014311582,
-0.0551193655,
0.044022385,
0.0038181965,
-0.0399518795,
-0.0074620629,
-0.0128913494,
-0.0315666497,
0.0105912965,
-0.0776921511,
-0.0229181033,
0.0814858377,
-0.0709244385,
0.0369627587,
0.0301749613,
-0.0444184989,
-0.0031990176,
-0.0444150083,
-0.0587014817,
-0.0083251754,
0.0404821001,
0.0287865847,
0.0280054305,
-0.0461585447,
-0.0273975469,
-0.0039713653,
0.0152486637,
0.0165550373,
-0.0031421499,
-0.0238273665,
-0.0077373995,
-0.0123458831,
0.0259855036,
0.0155234886,
-0.0364006348,
0.0060176686,
0.0116805751,
-0.0712212622,
-0.04332963,
-0.0376214013,
-0.0369343124,
0.0383430161,
-0.0088139968,
0.0178855509,
-0.0184392817,
-0.0226548929,
-0.0172896385,
0.0251951944,
0.0477763638,
-0.0030136076,
-0.0065860562,
0.0252004303,
-0.003690307,
0.0182838421,
0.0163697228,
0.0588457398,
-0.0099945366,
-0.0523048006,
-0.0389299802,
-0.0799115524,
-0.0323714651,
0.0450735502,
-0.0372131355,
-0.0363796055,
-0.0043638842,
0.0263312012,
0.0044506276,
0.0175511092,
0.0408946946,
0.0424703434,
-0.0041352552,
0.066168949,
-0.0109523442,
-0.034337271,
-0.0177509878,
0.0297835581,
-0.0361308269,
-0.0601416714,
0.0085024564,
0.027642861,
0.0124304565,
0.0148710348,
-0.0101594841,
0.0366687402,
0.0099248309,
-0.0504309386,
-0.0030199736,
-0.0359945893,
0.0023484938,
-0.0104614524,
-0.0305429697,
-0.0196845233,
0.0689152926,
0.0008738542,
0.0009301619,
-0.0097704977,
-0.024491787,
0.016872216,
0.014434143,
0.0217796825,
0.0294220373,
0.0104156742,
0.0241538212,
-0.0029944328,
0.0049401782,
0.0504164733,
-0.0126163149,
0.0128938928,
-0.0068895654,
0.031943731,
0.0215022843,
-0.0096600587,
-0.0643612817,
-0.1042133346,
-0.0065587545,
-0.0532725826,
-0.0261247456,
-0.0201820843,
-0.0725013167,
-0.010102828,
0.0072389599,
0.0449750051,
-0.0040691826,
-0.0000635885,
0.0231306124,
0.0522926711,
0.0505824983,
0.020531904,
0.0181578845,
-0.0319960155,
-0.0505640246,
0.0745844916,
-0.008118893,
-0.0172895677,
-0.0744878799,
-0.0250690859,
-0.000365359,
0.0385544784,
0.0361319222,
-0.0210366081,
0.0058288206,
-0.0351688936,
0.0301482994,
0.0513074547,
-0.024714727,
-0.0232542977,
0.0159300044,
0.0610080175,
-0.0260622222,
0.023586465,
-0.0187405907,
-0.0628880113,
-0.0424179621,
-0.0230664816,
-0.0039418279,
-0.0327414982,
0.0187545959,
-0.0086300112,
-0.0753194094,
0.0253959652,
-0.0145586757,
-0.0226813667,
-0.0351673029,
-0.0457210727,
0.0022436655,
-0.0429221317,
0.0457319841,
-0.0097243749,
0.041875802,
-0.0295828339,
-0.0325936936,
0.0212071706,
-0.0851819068,
-0.0252817664,
-0.005054215,
0.0263167638,
0.0378611051,
0.0047116145,
-0.0165803693,
-0.0550852381,
0.0214638989,
0.0451724045,
-0.0116992695,
-0.0022854093,
0.0957251117,
-0.0599162728,
-0.0162662398,
-0.0169541501,
0.0404678732,
0.0249523036,
0.0011887155,
-0.0483928695,
0.0426011942,
0.0142637454,
-0.053137742,
-0.0705851018,
0.0114952242,
0.0403447747,
0.0376365334,
-0.00397901,
-0.0253802855,
0.0070034279,
-0.0114410156,
0.00211554,
-0.0166577064,
-0.0468257405,
0.0382760391,
-0.0266226195,
-0.0429648198,
-0.0493106358,
-0.0116582904,
-0.0205738582,
0.0220607109,
-0.0336552598,
-0.0486036316,
0.0006719217,
-0.0161209162,
-0.0502351262,
0.0449034125,
-0.0047425963,
0.0504481681,
-0.0023308548,
-0.0012645712,
-0.0143992482,
-0.0363939516,
-0.0214529168,
0.0454045422,
-0.1087494418,
-0.0275644194,
-0.0066478592,
0.0541097783,
0.0161457378,
0.0498191901,
0.0133737056,
-0.049620185,
0.0289698578,
0.0270997602,
-0.0264128838,
0.0111787198,
0.0450626016,
-0.0190802366,
0.0168615077,
0.0080657825,
-0.0176867303,
0.066953972,
0.0167860594,
-0.0538719967,
-0.0705487356,
0.0394684523,
0.0088596838,
-0.0078249015,
0.0467670858,
-0.018395111,
0.0127128651,
-0.0166510865,
-0.0467729568,
-0.0156386532,
-0.0270488206,
-0.0263785738,
0.0414054617,
0.0312451385,
-0.0052266051,
0.0084266225,
-0.0061932364,
-0.0208097715,
0.0317229964,
-0.0608453415,
-0.0380472429,
0.0124568306,
0.0036568383,
0.0073434631,
0.0207486376,
-0.0195305515,
0.0405505113,
0.0274537895,
-0.0056568403,
0.0107716247,
0.0185748003,
0.0359738879,
-0.0369182713,
0.0293877833,
-0.0034724497,
-0.0188954007,
0.0501068532,
-0.0768847466,
0.0356773809,
0.0122356247,
0.0102246543,
0.0284204576,
-0.0057047335,
-0.0272960961,
0.0004511973,
-0.0144565077,
-0.0166589599,
-0.0296366271,
0.0001174815,
0.0033635492,
-0.0037146644,
0.0401369706,
0.0558518283,
-0.007386155,
0.0272253193,
-0.0119831432,
-0.0365115441,
-0.052256979,
0.0064790957,
0.0220473707,
0.0464789271,
-0.0087111406,
0.0076354099,
-0.0410186984,
-0.0290098898,
0.0040112399,
-0.0170713719,
0.0216637999,
0.046912387,
-0.0057516443,
0.0829098821,
0.0026014952,
0.0206940621,
0.0028931047,
-0.0421781689,
0.0254793894,
-0.0228146538,
0.0309380665,
-6.174770438e-33,
0.049078051,
-0.0283214394,
-0.0419053398,
-0.0455815941,
-0.0022631115,
0.0455392413,
0.0272573866,
-0.0215656776,
-0.018585844,
0.0278902855,
0.0597549677,
0.031908527,
-0.0208653063,
0.0343356803,
-0.0699727088,
-0.0059128618,
0.0533615984,
-0.0031053061,
-0.0443172604,
-0.0080887545,
0.0595812649,
-0.0017907426,
0.0524180047,
-0.0607460216,
0.0380127057,
-0.0246222857,
-0.0780887529,
0.006376863,
-0.00168837,
0.040108081,
-0.0401357934,
0.060064245,
0.0596374609,
-0.040574111,
-0.037705332,
0.0442403629,
-0.0449304394,
0.0037992815,
0.0122071542,
0.0368324704,
-0.0560478829,
0.0370028578,
0.0764340237,
-0.021535024,
-0.0146525567,
-0.016789319,
0.025496956,
-0.0217851847,
0.0320056528,
0.023856448,
-0.0346382596,
0.0003219312,
0.0079166368,
0.0027172989,
0.0004553979,
0.0809900016,
0.0384125113,
0.0287517533,
-0.0771594122,
0.0221398901,
-0.0416763611,
-0.0290626679,
0.0465507396,
-0.0440509059,
-0.0486276969,
0.052507896,
0.0133101782,
0.045498535,
-0.0322754197,
0.0164126996,
0.0163087305,
0.0369428396,
0.064080283,
0.1291164905,
0.0445776284,
-0.0473725721,
-0.0377401784,
0.0229080413,
0.0189767592,
-0.0282424502,
0.0085586943,
-0.002691733,
-0.0141324224,
0.0139038367,
-0.0107987998,
0.0175250694,
-0.0301032793,
-0.0288441423,
0.0099164667,
0.0470625423,
-0.0469733737,
0.0753763244,
0.0448728353,
-0.0520901829,
-0.0026581588,
0.0233712103,
-0.0170964506,
0.0404121876,
0.0315557271,
0.0237537865,
-0.0217224658,
-0.0089865522,
0.0813451558,
-0.0088707274,
-0.008882775,
-0.0352790169,
0.0689602792,
0.0370647497,
-0.0288490131,
0.0149687184,
-0.0145011181,
0.046361655,
-0.0236481801,
0.0052217273,
0.0153138768,
-0.0013708764,
-0.0476021394,
0.0089743529,
-0.0137621118,
0.0306119174,
-0.0196751822,
-0.0042954534,
-0.0353507511,
0.0307602435,
0.0089389086,
-0.0015606374,
-0.0286551062,
-0.079503566,
-0.0004106577,
-0.1031451002,
0.0072963447,
0.0191198718,
2.515e-7,
-0.0068540154,
0.04006017,
0.0027766072,
0.0078321863,
0.0193341281,
0.050965298,
0.0339737386,
0.0320536867,
-0.0081287604,
-0.1132805645,
-0.0379400663,
0.035170868,
-0.0164869726,
0.0210654587,
-0.0091698198,
-0.0176143404,
-0.0410767011,
-0.017387582,
-0.0418697856,
0.0103783291,
-0.0099520106,
0.0870669559,
0.0450440198,
-0.0708579049,
0.0287361257,
-0.0040462175,
0.0634654537,
0.0521819517,
-0.0611748397,
-0.0193618443,
0.0711943507,
0.0065001408,
0.0242568497,
0.0213174392,
-0.0215693135,
-0.0341120325,
0.0114179421,
-0.0049199173,
0.0094011463,
-0.0383695886,
-0.0178338699,
-0.017545132,
0.0009171675,
-0.0406594872,
0.0539039522,
-0.0392320864,
-0.0303566288,
-0.0608395971,
-0.0599910878,
0.035289716,
0.0230534114,
-0.0192610361,
-0.0331239328,
0.0354392081,
0.0406650528,
0.017448049,
-0.0239602439,
-0.0594193339,
0.0048249564,
0.0094749089,
-0.0718509257,
-0.0168317202,
-0.0130425952,
-0.0592585541,
0.0718831941,
-0.0198795982,
-0.0272525232,
1.754428074e-34,
0.0516587272,
-0.0161243677,
0.0143890725,
-0.050140325,
-0.0109546436,
0.0186924674,
-0.0354293808,
-0.0203357674,
0.008027452,
0.0149509823,
-0.0039546327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18598v1 | A Method for Studying Semantic Construal in Grammatical Constructions with Interpretable Contextual Embedding Spaces | 2023-05-29T20:30:38 | 2023-05-29T20:30:38 | Gabriella Chronis, Kyle Mahowald, Katrin Erk | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study semantic construal in grammatical constructions using large language
models. First, we project contextual word embeddings into three interpretable
semantic spaces, each defined by a different set of psycholinguistic feature
norms. We validate these interpretable spaces and then use them to
automatically derive semantic characterizations of lexical items in two
grammatical constructions: nouns in subject or object position within the same
sentence, and the AANN construction (e.g., `a beautiful three days'). We show
that a word in subject position is interpreted as more agentive than the very
same word in object position, and that the nouns in the AANN construction are
interpreted as more measurement-like than when in the canonical alternation.
Our method can probe the distributional meaning of syntactic constructions at a
templatic level, abstracted away from specific lexemes. | [
0.0174353775,
0.0403168201,
-0.0447059721,
0.0716992542,
-0.0445416346,
0.0034404129,
-0.004829512,
-0.0498659946,
-0.057066083,
-0.0604478307,
-0.0401911065,
-0.0453767776,
0.0110922875,
0.0025720759,
0.0466539823,
-0.0055160937,
0.0323734842,
0.016226219,
-0.0178991538,
0.0246971324,
0.0036112324,
-0.0319063663,
-0.0033186837,
0.0242792647,
-0.0298940241,
-0.0070697623,
-0.009863331,
-0.0352309123,
-0.0235526133,
-0.0429628715,
-0.023557391,
0.0064911912,
0.024639044,
0.0074919434,
0.0000016684,
-0.0471048281,
-0.004120396,
-0.0243882518,
-0.0145942885,
0.0407385528,
0.0483117402,
-0.0501147471,
0.0068815439,
-0.0467658639,
-0.0524070747,
-0.0149131464,
0.015299228,
0.0240074228,
-0.0257168561,
0.0439587906,
-0.0158757642,
-0.0284294505,
-0.0192935485,
-0.0119683519,
-0.0062000062,
-0.0045848223,
0.0275921505,
-0.0183224529,
-0.0300240796,
0.0228619203,
-0.0718764663,
0.0268815942,
0.0238021407,
0.0304409359,
-0.0050775502,
-0.003728515,
0.0023857474,
-0.027762197,
0.0044833641,
0.0302459374,
0.0329751708,
-0.0131573891,
-0.0060672993,
0.0031916986,
-0.0107329022,
0.0124802301,
-0.0147665022,
0.0459535755,
0.0425742567,
0.019669624,
0.0709931701,
0.0076560979,
0.0030491846,
0.014394491,
-0.0076180035,
0.0612574331,
0.0088806888,
-0.0502210371,
-0.0045480323,
0.0266938861,
-0.037181519,
-0.0224337839,
-0.0169355944,
-0.0473784506,
-0.0016288179,
0.0479123816,
-0.0070764087,
-0.0291220658,
-0.0046180971,
-0.0499023572,
0.0307811107,
-0.0054138009,
-0.0434559807,
0.0371694081,
-0.0117322393,
0.0596165657,
-0.0322080888,
0.009361431,
-0.0838601142,
0.0297487713,
-0.0228540543,
-0.0091749001,
-0.0059341281,
0.0269841012,
-0.039745152,
-0.0421022885,
-0.0616234057,
0.0211824942,
-0.0181372277,
-0.0110929944,
-0.0248352587,
0.0402377993,
-0.0270079002,
0.0501224808,
0.0025577575,
-0.0199295003,
-0.0475217551,
0.0467701517,
-0.0595972091,
-0.0388998725,
-0.005603408,
0.045993492,
0.0101197492,
-0.0399745218,
-0.0436536074,
0.0410765782,
0.0372789614,
-0.0357449614,
0.0192866791,
-0.047183305,
-0.0552624911,
0.0005285013,
0.0148111889,
-0.0234882515,
-0.0220669378,
0.0010095278,
-0.0197045058,
-0.0815272629,
-0.008021717,
-0.0204629116,
-0.0012571494,
0.083151646,
0.0633006468,
-0.0087438775,
-0.0853983015,
-0.0129547957,
0.0022236747,
0.04061969,
0.0465461053,
0.0227454212,
0.0503484681,
0.0079505201,
-0.0137033109,
0.0053116474,
-0.0034421815,
-0.0302280392,
-0.0482228436,
-0.0110886367,
-0.0116136428,
0.0586890578,
-0.0116567574,
0.0641304329,
-0.0089955693,
-0.0195768755,
0.0103485081,
0.0385079272,
0.0151984151,
-0.014549003,
0.1003702357,
-0.0239670351,
-0.0193541218,
0.0401051082,
-0.0556100048,
-0.0037227944,
-0.0197983608,
-0.0040854723,
-0.0612770095,
0.0098066619,
0.0155318566,
-0.0368500762,
-0.0435325131,
0.0026337688,
-0.001385882,
-0.0171088856,
0.029577462,
0.0097237919,
0.0029354701,
-0.0310986619,
0.019492168,
-0.0401642621,
0.0079443455,
-0.0087041995,
0.0350067429,
0.0113309734,
0.0071871006,
-0.0171897374,
-0.0036644123,
0.0182681046,
0.0338591114,
0.0204391256,
0.0303412136,
-0.0273974966,
-0.0005163574,
-0.0212738067,
-0.0006660127,
-0.0460685194,
0.0382361598,
-0.0022452478,
-0.0291959587,
-0.0094205113,
0.013269064,
-0.0161486864,
0.023539003,
0.0402635001,
0.0068208207,
-0.0340747423,
-0.0180463474,
0.0611487329,
0.041466292,
0.0177254621,
0.0114297708,
0.0461083241,
0.0505839586,
-0.0537007675,
0.0257644095,
0.079831548,
-0.0394240804,
-0.068185471,
0.0098756449,
-0.0234442186,
0.0103404811,
-0.006655897,
0.0021390889,
-0.03135157,
0.0608341172,
-0.0354123116,
0.0894634798,
-0.0533262417,
0.0087209065,
0.0024501309,
0.0238511078,
-0.0496721454,
0.0494877994,
-0.0015484415,
0.048781611,
0.0068421955,
0.0235588774,
0.0305143949,
0.0222004317,
-0.0110087944,
-0.0125579089,
0.0227091927,
-0.0180619154,
0.0086791432,
-0.0139888665,
-0.0426009968,
-0.0330612287,
-0.0451894216,
-0.0082588661,
-0.0225222595,
0.0322894901,
0.0384387076,
0.0107232593,
0.0196326599,
0.0317997187,
0.0071807462,
0.0069708335,
-0.0349839255,
0.0500895232,
0.056665685,
-0.015850462,
-0.0539853722,
-0.0455667935,
-0.0055543412,
-0.0650333017,
0.0452575833,
-0.0111004738,
0.0042836326,
-0.0179094262,
0.0239770431,
-0.0202123653,
-0.0156962052,
0.0007625904,
-0.0585353598,
0.024047194,
0.0079013873,
0.0409196168,
0.0752712414,
-0.05487106,
0.1129022911,
0.0590214208,
-0.0271636266,
-0.0284414161,
-0.0350337364,
-0.0240139291,
0.0146508729,
-0.029390607,
-0.0374945477,
-0.0094596241,
0.0949411541,
0.0403654277,
-0.042753946,
-0.0161657427,
0.0675125346,
-0.0959974602,
-0.0434368886,
0.0012969483,
0.0101748044,
-0.0625378862,
0.0263723452,
-0.0067547481,
-0.0078947004,
0.0548792258,
0.0050123539,
-0.02868459,
-0.0452162996,
-0.0223214719,
-0.0376700275,
0.0778635666,
0.0179234203,
0.0110838506,
0.0080555873,
-0.0187938288,
-0.0689091384,
-0.0153873721,
0.0177238956,
0.012656223,
0.0265328418,
-0.0719373077,
-0.0289023444,
0.0382123366,
-0.0310254116,
-0.0074070743,
-0.0815625414,
-0.0309966411,
0.0191588346,
-0.0156136192,
0.0030797718,
0.0456646644,
-0.0242850333,
-0.0035615861,
-0.0157880168,
-0.0025486513,
-0.0049008015,
-0.0501692817,
0.0330909006,
0.0365054682,
0.0065711634,
0.0319095775,
0.030069489,
-0.0388035104,
0.0507802777,
-0.0129715027,
0.0491073653,
-0.0484497137,
0.0525986254,
0.0106237009,
0.0094432048,
-0.0459007733,
-0.0048285904,
0.0362298898,
-0.0179718453,
-0.0100175673,
0.0924812406,
0.0625528097,
0.0167077649,
0.0815418065,
-0.0161141902,
0.0165101066,
0.0175061934,
0.001960357,
-0.0226993393,
-0.0262274761,
0.0020320697,
-0.0521870777,
-0.0380697623,
-0.0115723554,
-0.0014487051,
-0.0587768145,
0.0033642363,
-0.0344161615,
0.0082753347,
0.0036582516,
-0.0090979785,
0.0359299853,
-0.025638584,
-0.0000632159,
-0.0039648502,
-0.0174301602,
0.0415467806,
-0.0031619403,
0.0370301455,
-0.0378263965,
0.0048505152,
-0.0121677937,
0.044069659,
0.036447525,
0.0434923507,
-0.0330885239,
-0.038754601,
0.0309580266,
-0.0220712628,
0.0082643209,
0.0121928593,
-0.0353388228,
0.014299253,
-0.0244038943,
-0.0375218019,
0.0584844239,
-0.0437961034,
-0.0216499269,
-0.0067883944,
0.066121161,
0.007502317,
-0.0130461473,
-0.0195930712,
-0.0045196675,
0.0003511668,
0.0786862373,
0.0728121698,
-0.0301724095,
0.0099607334,
0.0007333594,
-0.000495018,
0.0444027372,
-0.0218227115,
-0.0088348845,
-0.0054869293,
-0.0131646674,
-0.0882110223,
-0.0661543086,
0.0239061993,
0.017022796,
0.0320620276,
-0.0364263617,
-0.0010583502,
-0.0511102639,
-0.0253592338,
0.0136688268,
0.0117852567,
0.0672066733,
0.0342204086,
0.0202992968,
0.0815881938,
0.0172013845,
-0.0566574112,
-0.0258507244,
-0.0192440934,
-0.0531976968,
0.0485527925,
0.0004380808,
0.0182966609,
0.0101503823,
-0.0077707972,
-0.0031947691,
-0.0267912727,
-0.0292470399,
-0.0307191908,
0.0831328332,
0.0378333926,
0.0155881606,
0.0370894857,
0.072431542,
-0.0083316965,
0.0297747944,
0.0278624594,
0.0407839455,
-0.0218103919,
0.0119894948,
0.0263929516,
0.0093234805,
0.0430532321,
0.0048030126,
-0.0166395642,
-0.0332146026,
-0.0177346449,
-0.0515276939,
-0.019320393,
-0.0321601965,
-0.0073571932,
0.046922788,
0.0391677134,
-0.0640836731,
-0.0162909888,
-0.0047083707,
0.0151862409,
0.0044375793,
0.0215939451,
0.0448321775,
-0.0493308827,
-0.0190054178,
0.0634274557,
-0.0122538162,
0.0438162535,
-0.0588958599,
0.0204591025,
-0.0261866786,
-0.030174505,
0.0170730334,
-0.0323558375,
-0.0875600949,
0.0282720458,
-0.042200692,
0.0752562582,
0.0436013266,
0.0053298292,
0.0136775058,
-0.0747351497,
0.0611346364,
-0.0511643961,
0.0069257999,
0.0116329445,
0.0242674146,
0.0096726101,
-0.0261582974,
0.0532005243,
0.0146068083,
-0.0204682648,
-0.0118724788,
0.0501836315,
-0.0262796637,
0.0209026188,
0.025457507,
-0.0093357544,
-0.0350807682,
0.0163297281,
0.0179372989,
0.0367501564,
0.0059948433,
0.0575172827,
-0.0888938829,
-0.0617067218,
0.0182989929,
0.0176679939,
0.0077676568,
-0.0382791944,
0.0014462718,
0.0687391907,
0.0004129129,
-0.0249847807,
-0.0119162826,
-0.0117107788,
-0.0001083152,
-0.0409649499,
-0.0470929407,
-5.625611804e-33,
-0.0230355095,
-0.0153402602,
-0.0250730533,
-0.0130919255,
-0.0497697443,
0.0522972941,
-0.0090526687,
0.0142804515,
0.0073025059,
0.0550285429,
0.0004038683,
0.0129309623,
0.018291967,
0.041071035,
0.0378073491,
-0.0083880676,
0.0151539473,
-0.00822879,
-0.0040649259,
-0.0559705868,
0.0366431139,
-0.0123470407,
0.0606365204,
-0.0502351858,
0.0417546593,
0.0451847352,
0.0305709913,
0.0508218147,
-0.005883099,
0.0474879332,
-0.0111399507,
0.0603299998,
0.0240945574,
-0.0089984089,
0.0077932212,
0.0122997062,
-0.0310374107,
-0.1065852717,
0.0962925404,
0.0175495818,
-0.0509239919,
-0.0618320666,
0.0441108979,
-0.043068178,
-0.0292446371,
0.0347774811,
0.030376479,
0.0232576709,
-0.0172121637,
0.0286438409,
-0.0772773251,
-0.0241372399,
-0.0294354577,
-0.0020767995,
0.0482685976,
-0.0664796531,
0.0084878262,
-0.02949531,
-0.0236114524,
0.0109619042,
-0.0564735532,
0.0391718671,
0.0074219303,
0.0078201694,
0.0179741811,
0.0555817485,
0.0337741449,
-0.0266666543,
-0.0176523626,
0.0267191883,
0.0358980224,
0.0444062836,
-0.0133669721,
0.0647167936,
0.0120664127,
-0.0067591066,
-0.0184000693,
-0.0485541001,
0.0528903902,
0.0157109238,
0.0299542043,
-0.0031986302,
-0.0584833287,
-0.0217410643,
-0.0379683822,
-0.0125265429,
-0.0269157756,
-0.0334813073,
0.0383728445,
-0.0247245133,
-0.0125068584,
0.0308046471,
0.0082147522,
-0.050147742,
-0.0208406225,
0.01547693,
-0.0186538678,
0.0517745614,
0.0163195487,
0.0367928371,
-0.0328224786,
-0.0139967659,
-0.013121509,
0.0337110907,
0.0236388557,
0.0272507276,
0.0296069365,
-0.0044754781,
0.0140459687,
-0.0306722224,
-0.0487347953,
-0.1034812927,
-0.0777331591,
-0.0451151766,
0.0407223403,
0.0750133321,
-0.0256778393,
0.0060912431,
0.0345972553,
0.012217598,
-0.0251766834,
-0.0291098282,
-0.0008688999,
0.024737522,
-0.0490146168,
-0.0395509638,
0.0115144746,
0.0270214584,
0.0966710672,
-0.0233874805,
0.0054823635,
-0.0313143469,
2.613e-7,
0.0512114838,
0.0533447377,
0.0074879122,
0.0192454569,
0.0194695406,
0.0008847708,
-0.0072517456,
0.0157988407,
-0.0150782047,
-0.0524214879,
-0.0042825844,
0.0037577015,
-0.0216708183,
-0.0071773403,
-0.0251964107,
0.0458726883,
0.0110144354,
0.009520201,
0.0007458877,
0.0360252634,
0.0865887329,
0.083475478,
0.0447530895,
0.007006309,
-0.0468978547,
-0.0307578351,
0.0262457877,
-0.0445086285,
-0.0203021094,
-0.0054230993,
-0.0149949286,
0.010272176,
0.0517923236,
-0.0017285516,
0.0129210223,
0.0278086793,
0.0296378247,
0.0273403898,
-0.003804028,
0.0246424787,
-0.0322577916,
-0.0458628498,
-0.036440447,
0.0038502989,
0.0650485381,
-0.0747359768,
-0.0583844259,
-0.00097539,
0.0205063168,
0.0220070258,
-0.0072511146,
0.0239850599,
-0.0297160335,
0.0005355029,
0.0356195755,
-0.0352998674,
-0.0223865863,
-0.0680708215,
-0.0418615416,
-0.0038928136,
-0.007948841,
-0.0170640144,
0.0185985975,
-0.0126892729,
0.0190183055,
-0.0838043839,
-0.033716049,
2.275587627e-34,
0.043459788,
0.0298414044,
0.0763537139,
0.0086173778,
0.0219367146,
-0.0246843342,
0.0417627059,
0.0230618324,
0.0377728753,
-0.0797668099,
-0.0132110817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18596v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18596v1 | Building Accurate Low Latency ASR for Streaming Voice Search | 2023-05-29T20:24:14 | 2023-05-29T20:24:14 | Abhinav Goyal, Nikesh Garera | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) plays a crucial role in voice-based
applications. For applications requiring real-time feedback like Voice Search,
streaming capability becomes vital. While LSTM/RNN and CTC based ASR systems
are commonly employed for low-latency streaming applications, they often
exhibit lower accuracy compared to state-of-the-art models due to a lack of
future audio frames. In this work, we focus on developing accurate LSTM,
attention, and CTC based streaming ASR models for large-scale Hinglish (a blend
of Hindi and English) Voice Search. We investigate various modifications in
vanilla LSTM training which enhance the system's accuracy while preserving its
streaming capabilities. We also address the critical requirement of
end-of-speech (EOS) detection in streaming applications. We present a simple
training and inference strategy for end-to-end CTC models that enables joint
ASR and EOS detection. The evaluation of our model on Flipkart's Voice Search,
which handles substantial traffic of approximately 6 million queries per day,
demonstrates significant performance gains over the vanilla LSTM-CTC model. Our
model achieves a word error rate (WER) of 3.69% without EOS and 4.78% with EOS
while also reducing the search latency by approximately ~1300 ms (equivalent to
46.64% reduction) when compared to an independent voice activity detection
(VAD) model. | [
0.0077850902,
0.0184999518,
0.0176559445,
0.0094924849,
0.0058264094,
-0.0228620358,
-0.0181138832,
0.0016430977,
0.00874836,
-0.0243139155,
-0.0322736129,
-0.1058732495,
0.0145872245,
0.0519661084,
0.0045324047,
-0.0284973364,
0.0338698402,
-0.0111832311,
0.0239825957,
0.0203189831,
0.0460613444,
-0.005910161,
-0.0186132006,
0.040852759,
-0.0021042149,
0.0112416316,
-0.0368462093,
0.0370929167,
0.0102257933,
-0.0319089964,
-0.0044992273,
0.0013398078,
0.0234325286,
0.0610520765,
0.0000018122,
-0.0139270611,
-0.0119120935,
-0.0071439827,
-0.0556001775,
0.0039933054,
0.0396195874,
0.0613727868,
-0.0070298943,
0.104907766,
-0.0081992354,
0.0444834791,
0.0397043787,
0.0116653172,
0.0145551441,
0.0852166936,
-0.0114823272,
0.0139973341,
0.0334219933,
-0.0268906821,
0.0101059591,
-0.0253998879,
-0.0373887494,
-0.0673845857,
0.0419711918,
-0.0034913914,
-0.010252296,
0.0660217777,
0.0142895477,
-0.0135636562,
-0.0133006433,
-0.0087868441,
-0.0568023399,
0.0082410006,
0.0069972198,
0.0214863531,
-0.0176502839,
-0.0221313071,
0.0371913239,
0.0175857414,
-0.0361458026,
-0.0580240898,
-0.0144977737,
0.017161347,
-0.0094156321,
0.0048753247,
-0.004869997,
-0.0095960703,
0.0281389374,
0.0038690006,
0.0045893351,
-0.0332948193,
0.0150538282,
-0.0506560281,
-0.0334390216,
-0.0451257937,
-0.0022667518,
-0.019872874,
0.069927685,
0.0272192731,
-0.0522586033,
-0.0025045052,
-0.0014294756,
-0.024361793,
-0.0434486382,
-0.0403646417,
0.023313472,
0.0482684486,
-0.0409682468,
0.0151098985,
-0.0048314827,
0.042685464,
-0.01365034,
-0.015787797,
-0.0048536062,
-0.0161573775,
-0.0015747324,
-0.0208779741,
-0.008201451,
-0.0110573266,
-0.0239219945,
-0.0590670146,
-0.0258606765,
0.0215360876,
0.0052751983,
-0.0338504314,
0.0336594284,
-0.0073310812,
-0.0465201288,
-0.0243310351,
0.0417364016,
0.034196347,
0.0111219529,
0.0461662225,
0.0078716017,
-0.1027851179,
-0.0202316698,
0.0334243439,
0.0314501971,
0.0132377464,
0.0121481931,
-0.0304001514,
0.0051619457,
-0.0336281657,
-0.021373786,
0.0197713375,
-0.0092548411,
-0.0231853705,
-0.0054115839,
-0.0288337264,
0.0178805813,
-0.034896601,
-0.0040561063,
0.018225763,
-0.0093467068,
0.0120861437,
0.0327792093,
0.0520941913,
-0.0006217274,
0.0428859852,
0.0167993437,
-0.0065199127,
0.0372309126,
0.0489143096,
0.0520380996,
0.0017297707,
0.0303580239,
-0.0303245075,
0.0116057508,
0.0499247499,
-0.0009253455,
-0.0115132872,
-0.011589516,
0.0080440501,
-0.0308410823,
0.0704944283,
0.0313476697,
0.027250411,
0.0118968366,
0.0025218262,
0.0827148408,
0.0519954562,
0.0467509814,
-0.0156500842,
0.0048352606,
0.0510822088,
-0.0211774558,
-0.0480682813,
-0.0210351311,
0.0387512408,
-0.0023183643,
0.0190888308,
0.0616621114,
0.0113378083,
-0.0389567986,
0.001420289,
-0.0250110738,
-0.0306771472,
-0.0506875515,
0.0540574118,
0.0236702524,
-0.0142470896,
-0.0394990481,
0.0300261658,
-0.0374394581,
-0.0585585684,
0.032738179,
-0.0558976866,
0.0063685216,
0.0691021755,
0.0098518757,
-0.021366518,
-0.0050066523,
-0.0342671499,
-0.0006062602,
0.0482517518,
-0.0063349125,
0.0230653193,
0.0172473714,
-0.0700967982,
-0.0040988582,
0.0652444661,
-0.0185664743,
0.0466766469,
-0.0240502022,
0.0596536398,
0.0142646404,
-0.0095917368,
0.0022161927,
-0.0012940702,
-0.0045985831,
-0.0264894813,
0.0016109748,
0.0251842868,
0.048857566,
0.0178006124,
-0.0119532673,
0.0052350778,
0.0145851281,
-0.0277101882,
-0.022611741,
0.0455168895,
-0.0273391437,
-0.0252698865,
0.0274882931,
-0.0199463777,
0.037402492,
0.1230883971,
0.0198071115,
-0.0805033371,
0.0315885171,
-0.0339763947,
0.0279692169,
-0.035356313,
0.0447943881,
0.0267987046,
0.0204281621,
0.0415105261,
-0.0272872671,
0.0124976924,
0.0215946492,
0.0263079442,
0.0249312315,
-0.0113388998,
-0.1016325057,
-0.0436346382,
0.0138885016,
-0.0104664611,
0.014865879,
0.0151899401,
0.0104058729,
-0.0182155203,
0.0255149063,
-0.0968659371,
0.0409148969,
-0.0450620577,
0.0243841186,
-0.0020134093,
0.0589652359,
-0.0191593859,
-0.0607122146,
-0.0070171528,
-0.0534053892,
0.0255001467,
0.0240172818,
-0.0499738418,
-0.0185643733,
-0.0391696692,
-0.0382749699,
-0.0108865025,
0.0045944215,
0.002354004,
-0.0306806955,
-0.0381386094,
-0.0228804145,
-0.0273202043,
0.0218087323,
0.0425935127,
0.0078593241,
-0.0381670371,
-0.0232064594,
-0.0129820677,
-0.0182310119,
0.0378843658,
0.0430249088,
-0.0637290403,
-0.0264680125,
0.007933598,
-0.0457180254,
0.0376231708,
0.0165820755,
0.0151946405,
0.0063634478,
0.0144022666,
0.0356112719,
0.0276483782,
-0.0173482895,
0.0434184186,
-0.056924127,
-0.080575034,
-0.0143253049,
-0.0181133449,
-0.03439641,
-0.0015858405,
-0.0865209922,
0.0242771823,
-0.0014984458,
-0.0454143733,
0.0207048431,
-0.0293149669,
-0.0377091803,
-0.0599434748,
-0.0356127322,
-0.0232594609,
0.0129009625,
-0.0084220031,
0.0037828819,
-0.0181023218,
-0.0825333819,
-0.0081043215,
0.0391383655,
-0.0013064566,
-0.0656277761,
0.0254279189,
0.035326723,
-0.0117715048,
0.0011581061,
-0.0293660443,
-0.0233155489,
-0.0223637559,
-0.0233890358,
-0.0118322447,
0.044262521,
-0.0328542516,
0.0004865532,
0.0470011868,
-0.0112600522,
0.0648391098,
-0.0173412673,
-0.0058923461,
-0.0064796302,
0.0578062981,
0.0597740412,
0.0441298857,
-0.0102196308,
0.0390504338,
0.0295633171,
0.0137649272,
0.1061513498,
-0.0206516404,
-0.032623332,
-0.0352094695,
0.0565378182,
-0.0245745108,
-0.0196538959,
0.0403547212,
0.0240884982,
-0.0607668236,
-0.0111307679,
0.0995557085,
-0.0026081065,
-0.0379137211,
-0.0509488583,
-0.0105519108,
-0.0149891581,
0.0231797732,
0.013576977,
-0.063865453,
-0.0209691655,
0.0328582823,
0.0602054782,
0.0230205394,
0.0218901094,
-0.0173750855,
-0.0799210221,
0.021080181,
-0.0015217024,
-0.0247212332,
-0.0204200726,
-0.0455754437,
-0.0162979458,
-0.0233527012,
0.0452952199,
0.022454286,
-0.0214643925,
-0.0299172159,
0.0502806641,
-0.0898522362,
-0.041936405,
0.0393570215,
-0.0908724144,
0.0796354637,
0.0785752982,
0.0329651274,
0.0049751899,
-0.0276962295,
0.0033423537,
-0.0311503392,
-0.008787089,
0.0336943083,
0.0090066763,
-0.0434734561,
-0.0086980378,
-0.0095090913,
0.0108608706,
-0.0336070098,
0.0345111191,
-0.007755694,
0.0606615469,
-0.0228366945,
-0.0154472506,
-0.0107497098,
0.006811209,
0.0404124558,
0.055377949,
-0.0067813648,
-0.0363093764,
-0.0332420059,
0.0175359268,
0.0285545923,
-0.0336816199,
-0.0365787037,
0.0097374748,
-0.001197653,
-0.0366291143,
0.0021988859,
-0.0190861374,
-0.0191600714,
0.0095528672,
0.0133635141,
0.0700915679,
-0.0081103779,
0.01632661,
-0.0379797406,
0.0125684049,
-0.030038463,
0.057696335,
-0.0653945357,
0.0402172357,
0.0309790466,
-0.0513229109,
-0.0084488243,
0.0231975373,
-0.074767895,
-0.0363193825,
0.0014498753,
-0.0367437415,
0.0203749333,
0.0538089834,
-0.0659216791,
-0.0506973304,
-0.0006105051,
-0.0139573934,
-0.0280763227,
0.004305203,
0.0675086677,
-0.0139963329,
-0.0293120984,
0.0191117488,
-0.0625879392,
0.0160937011,
-0.0537305661,
0.0279611498,
-0.0059639169,
-0.0240857005,
-0.0132377418,
0.0187126361,
0.0752269924,
-0.0120178359,
-0.0006054894,
-0.0264410023,
0.0386476666,
0.0485106297,
0.0521026999,
-0.0148571292,
-0.0008591703,
0.0319627486,
0.0220404938,
-0.0082196342,
0.0456310287,
-0.0008578945,
-0.0915356204,
-0.0521593466,
0.0549512319,
0.0158850364,
-0.0067842081,
0.0144417547,
-0.0177085474,
0.0202391353,
0.0131279286,
0.0678214654,
0.0275311079,
-0.0201336127,
0.0152607113,
0.0088478513,
-0.0055175931,
0.0509988442,
0.0312688686,
-0.0600675344,
-0.0224243365,
-0.0270392336,
-0.0181156844,
0.0644064322,
-0.024964558,
0.0420640782,
-0.0003077382,
0.043769341,
-0.0470648631,
0.0235608239,
-0.0425418429,
-0.0033423516,
0.0292712394,
0.0120983114,
-0.0169091281,
0.0302204061,
0.0294507425,
0.0168033876,
0.0232926123,
-0.0134718949,
-0.0210302602,
-0.0063224579,
-0.00619234,
-0.0398834646,
0.0318771638,
-0.038520813,
-0.0257700011,
0.0171403475,
-0.0741944462,
0.0272803809,
-0.0320400149,
0.0342239141,
-0.0442430563,
0.0361202471,
0.0385950841,
0.009957891,
0.0143190864,
0.0028191411,
-0.0545372814,
-0.011978549,
-0.0131390011,
0.0119911637,
-6.043771879e-33,
0.0190761294,
0.0284799412,
-0.0052857189,
-0.0296203066,
-0.0416834168,
0.0293159857,
-0.0280228667,
-0.0263143331,
-0.0155427009,
-0.0329091772,
-0.0454500653,
0.0861766413,
0.0311476309,
0.011051653,
0.016278306,
-0.0326076001,
0.0918545872,
-0.0259592291,
-0.0039007305,
-0.0030131713,
0.0484357923,
0.0360242762,
0.015769545,
-0.011832675,
-0.0391450636,
-0.0205652472,
0.0074841846,
-0.0113199037,
0.0200388972,
0.0662334561,
0.0018544825,
0.035846144,
-0.0012553093,
-0.0502572842,
-0.0236796364,
0.0398931429,
-0.0837291554,
0.0091241756,
-0.0165520832,
0.0580016412,
-0.0210675877,
0.0027671985,
0.0254225433,
0.047269702,
-0.04129586,
0.0002647877,
-0.0062039448,
-0.0084018214,
-0.0225413386,
-0.0679007173,
0.0035305966,
0.0218068212,
-0.0322337635,
-0.0395301804,
0.0318942815,
0.0309857111,
-0.0095550865,
-0.0217019264,
-0.082178764,
0.0354344621,
-0.0084039727,
0.0494243354,
0.0392138287,
0.0421408266,
-0.0155419484,
-0.0007214409,
0.0208130516,
-0.0447808169,
0.0166759267,
-0.0225663967,
0.0439200848,
0.0126119452,
0.0107563194,
-0.0372737162,
0.0584148988,
-0.0479279682,
-0.011842004,
-0.005456883,
0.0342956856,
0.049165912,
0.0357534401,
0.0243587643,
-0.0901369825,
-0.00784247,
-0.0126163764,
0.0016810644,
-0.0490381941,
-0.0278624613,
0.0934295654,
0.059053693,
0.0214242227,
-0.0037060052,
0.0650885254,
-0.0083722798,
0.0646037012,
0.0027346595,
0.0040678489,
0.001598703,
-0.0000823436,
0.0460483469,
-0.0418692194,
0.0066675809,
0.01571762,
0.0181613788,
-0.0294015724,
-0.0371572338,
-0.0120128421,
0.0828878209,
-0.0682513639,
-0.0094688898,
0.0255766101,
0.0416705497,
-0.0101784775,
0.0050482294,
0.0603512153,
-0.0332935266,
0.0142505188,
0.0632997677,
-0.0333016403,
0.0108184712,
-0.0211617909,
-0.0530320145,
0.0112332255,
-0.0182724409,
-0.0404840074,
0.022799382,
-0.0320986956,
0.0285250284,
-0.0056213313,
-0.0559013672,
-0.0316519141,
0.0138570415,
2.75e-7,
-0.0462015942,
0.0035011633,
0.0128609985,
0.0206424408,
0.0041540908,
-0.0125583634,
-0.0065773195,
0.0121645713,
0.0022172064,
0.0312340558,
0.0181486104,
-0.0359952636,
0.102851443,
-0.0074463137,
-0.1169886813,
-0.0696083307,
-0.0868397206,
0.0342246667,
-0.0108151529,
-0.0209978055,
-0.0035227798,
0.1096666306,
0.0049282382,
-0.024676349,
0.0231815521,
-0.0447303429,
0.0295762178,
0.015710339,
0.0099766711,
-0.0154613992,
0.0249180458,
0.0064936141,
-0.0329808854,
-0.0310062673,
-0.0534635,
0.0233258381,
0.0227944534,
0.0211972408,
0.0023551716,
-0.0579896271,
-0.0191868022,
0.0287505593,
0.0066001075,
-0.0096177636,
0.0589191578,
0.0422834828,
-0.0071728486,
-0.0237163119,
-0.0278229136,
-0.0349265784,
0.0137933306,
-0.0107230851,
-0.0019081098,
-0.0283606481,
-0.0146672837,
-0.0047916826,
-0.0077030715,
-0.0934731364,
0.0233217739,
-0.0163252223,
-0.0378722697,
-0.0057479073,
-0.0590216033,
0.0174574461,
0.0301294662,
-0.013452217,
-0.0120908553,
2.102627867e-34,
0.0463569425,
-0.0047417851,
0.0105834007,
0.0427106097,
0.0113340309,
-0.0107261436,
0.0560016148,
0.0094921766,
0.0510641672,
-0.0684798583,
-0.0465405807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18585v1 | Exploiting Explainability to Design Adversarial Attacks and Evaluate Attack Resilience in Hate-Speech Detection Models | 2023-05-29T19:59:40 | 2023-05-29T19:59:40 | Pranath Reddy Kumbam, Sohaib Uddin Syed, Prashanth Thamminedi, Suhas Harish, Ian Perera, Bonnie J. Dorr | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of social media has given rise to numerous ethical challenges,
with hate speech among the most significant concerns. Researchers are
attempting to tackle this problem by leveraging hate-speech detection and
employing language models to automatically moderate content and promote civil
discourse. Unfortunately, recent studies have revealed that hate-speech
detection systems can be misled by adversarial attacks, raising concerns about
their resilience. While previous research has separately addressed the
robustness of these models under adversarial attacks and their
interpretability, there has been no comprehensive study exploring their
intersection. The novelty of our work lies in combining these two critical
aspects, leveraging interpretability to identify potential vulnerabilities and
enabling the design of targeted adversarial attacks. We present a comprehensive
and comparative analysis of adversarial robustness exhibited by various
hate-speech detection models. Our study evaluates the resilience of these
models against adversarial attacks using explainability techniques. To gain
insights into the models' decision-making processes, we employ the Local
Interpretable Model-agnostic Explanations (LIME) framework. Based on the
explainability results obtained by LIME, we devise and execute targeted attacks
on the text by leveraging the TextAttack tool. Our findings enhance the
understanding of the vulnerabilities and strengths exhibited by
state-of-the-art hate-speech detection models. This work underscores the
importance of incorporating explainability in the development and evaluation of
such models to enhance their resilience against adversarial attacks.
Ultimately, this work paves the way for creating more robust and reliable
hate-speech detection systems, fostering safer online environments and
promoting ethical discourse on social media platforms. | [
0.0560076237,
0.0888238251,
-0.0237323735,
0.0440736189,
0.0005408741,
0.0188784804,
0.0694977045,
0.017858116,
-0.0146481777,
-0.0360858701,
0.0275586974,
-0.0031819025,
-0.0004246442,
0.0335945711,
0.0280872192,
-0.0525676087,
0.0046484591,
0.0045112991,
0.0213537123,
-0.0126019372,
0.0482018553,
-0.0037944838,
-0.0133907739,
0.0429042056,
0.0048980149,
0.015238761,
0.0006408432,
0.0123533681,
0.0163913686,
0.044364471,
-0.002635309,
0.0129853347,
0.0092893923,
0.0589479804,
0.0000019043,
-0.0132645452,
-0.0349289887,
0.0055108722,
-0.0319823809,
-0.0021342004,
0.0644627139,
-0.0421601422,
-0.0076134191,
0.025356153,
0.003169249,
0.0643902272,
0.0499811508,
0.0673700348,
0.0454796255,
0.0765753612,
-0.0131691853,
-0.0376935117,
0.0344178714,
0.0175569933,
-0.0074468837,
-0.0009322534,
-0.0007522005,
-0.0426986553,
-0.0518843308,
0.0082644084,
0.0021709849,
0.0113701671,
0.0273327176,
-0.0110607175,
0.0177008472,
-0.0577744767,
0.0326535664,
-0.030262785,
0.0056996192,
0.0420406573,
-0.033612337,
-0.0206112918,
0.0352851748,
-0.0191005711,
-0.0023266375,
0.0168599859,
-0.0264786556,
-0.0295160729,
0.0125787836,
0.0026940641,
-0.0115531944,
0.0205627028,
0.0926013961,
0.0553979091,
0.0044796173,
0.0250177979,
-0.0269096866,
0.013566711,
-0.0488888547,
-0.0504676625,
-0.0276812017,
0.0080190646,
0.0374738201,
0.026861826,
-0.0218625478,
0.0363583267,
-0.0632171556,
-0.0416100435,
-0.0031153811,
-0.0468402505,
0.0311755668,
0.0185618419,
-0.0063422411,
0.0164595135,
0.0128014656,
0.0508342125,
-0.0477061421,
0.0177627187,
0.0111463824,
-0.0153139913,
-0.0409579165,
-0.0243639965,
0.0198208857,
-0.0311019551,
-0.0326665416,
0.0593741387,
-0.0087182717,
-0.0000821742,
-0.0621668994,
-0.0084448578,
-0.0310694482,
0.0004491952,
-0.0038768384,
-0.0222824328,
-0.0014135615,
-0.0123529583,
-0.0408052504,
-0.0051000481,
-0.0129960226,
-0.0866582915,
-0.0135774994,
0.0316459984,
-0.0329754129,
-0.0220446158,
-0.0132524893,
0.0957394242,
0.0520726442,
-0.0115492269,
-0.0392377563,
-0.0698414966,
-0.0230137501,
-0.0410735235,
0.0181185063,
-0.0219255351,
-0.0063606678,
0.0020980043,
-0.0250131264,
-0.1074703634,
-0.006397848,
-0.0030444472,
-0.031582389,
0.0891222805,
0.0100319637,
-0.0048951623,
0.0167481247,
0.0493612811,
0.0032904255,
0.0363553949,
0.0133384829,
0.0435521267,
0.0661979914,
-0.0200453959,
0.0323303156,
0.0162407532,
0.0711474866,
0.0125599299,
-0.0394233502,
0.0208010674,
-0.0835556984,
-0.0258418266,
-0.0218419973,
0.0179611687,
0.0090736216,
-0.0715712011,
0.0615498237,
0.037317194,
-0.0442619659,
0.0267269146,
0.049054224,
0.0149652073,
-0.0215393621,
-0.0099131735,
-0.0579193607,
0.0129469885,
-0.0551510155,
-0.052338466,
-0.0207330119,
0.0303672161,
-0.0278467759,
-0.058765728,
-0.0221411381,
-0.0230481494,
0.0592782721,
-0.0117858881,
0.0313680246,
0.0283637326,
-0.021122314,
0.0135844778,
0.0130980182,
-0.0321553238,
-0.0048858761,
-0.0906282142,
0.0231788307,
0.0455886386,
0.0199696347,
-0.033442311,
0.0216290262,
-0.0443413928,
-0.0049636294,
0.0253087878,
0.0155629916,
0.009378803,
0.0227854569,
-0.0250699073,
-0.0064903875,
-0.0371887535,
0.0277681928,
0.0220752377,
0.0346137099,
-0.0245022643,
0.0042011179,
0.0026125477,
-0.0541080497,
0.0262590442,
0.0218536258,
-0.0288934279,
-0.0228197798,
0.0137033258,
0.055995889,
0.0427617766,
0.006415471,
0.0000348169,
0.0253587142,
0.015870899,
-0.0472014584,
0.024138784,
-0.0181681681,
0.0309645645,
-0.0178104248,
-0.0357705951,
0.0002218366,
0.0664420575,
-0.0297407731,
0.0349498764,
0.0758049488,
-0.0318785198,
-0.0220820364,
-0.0119501706,
-0.0271465164,
-0.0513578355,
0.0311878938,
-0.0004854468,
0.050325837,
-0.035820175,
-0.0087253433,
0.0148207415,
-0.0241086669,
0.0313730761,
0.0160642155,
-0.0282535572,
-0.0050436575,
-0.0637819245,
0.0097008012,
-0.0155870477,
-0.034575779,
-0.0142904967,
0.023514865,
-0.0346305855,
-0.0226591881,
-0.0340022072,
-0.006906237,
0.0290509965,
-0.0140111083,
0.0120639699,
0.0029298582,
0.0141128488,
-0.024987746,
0.0184350833,
0.0303842761,
0.0107111232,
-0.0602203533,
-0.0490672924,
-0.0219048336,
-0.0236813109,
-0.012798572,
0.0709790289,
0.0196049754,
-0.0316075832,
0.0287655052,
-0.0004996606,
-0.0354039632,
-0.0061770063,
-0.0258146096,
-0.0693022683,
0.0273237899,
0.051810652,
-0.0490302928,
0.029215103,
0.0451540723,
0.1285297573,
-0.0020515178,
0.0496515185,
-0.0027674309,
-0.0340354629,
-0.0129271019,
0.0133915152,
-0.0248475932,
-0.0496489778,
0.0082893455,
0.1020989791,
0.045888707,
-0.0191046316,
-0.0636324286,
0.0659766868,
-0.0492580645,
-0.0466763228,
-0.0378508866,
-0.0725079551,
0.0188136287,
0.0063272621,
-0.0516632795,
-0.0754025653,
0.0800840035,
-0.0044535394,
0.0265799351,
0.0031440977,
-0.0449159071,
0.0017408322,
0.0475155413,
-0.0108125573,
0.0138393575,
0.0021393425,
0.0119174067,
0.0063104574,
-0.0629732683,
0.0559581444,
-0.0098860003,
0.0073477696,
-0.0227046385,
-0.0187662635,
0.0340759084,
-0.0092526311,
-0.047828868,
-0.0551686697,
-0.0478271954,
-0.0124605829,
0.0259204004,
-0.0298888795,
-0.0244759917,
0.0273521021,
0.0549546033,
-0.0177263431,
-0.009838908,
0.0095096007,
0.0091249282,
-0.0125799589,
-0.0133563057,
-0.0113028204,
0.0417971574,
-0.0213141628,
0.0226721,
0.0430296883,
0.0078858109,
-0.0184906181,
-0.02512406,
0.0091771353,
-0.0121066766,
-0.0034998986,
-0.0054568029,
-0.0086549008,
0.0602992289,
-0.038069699,
0.0204029121,
0.040534135,
0.0018655059,
0.01848354,
0.0152464444,
-0.012313541,
-0.002446518,
-0.0064295093,
-0.025899509,
-0.017484786,
-0.0166778062,
0.0044133924,
0.049903512,
-0.0569915622,
-0.019770015,
0.0024903999,
-0.0137712797,
0.0089234328,
-0.0127011072,
-0.0330522805,
-0.0353130959,
-0.02949607,
-0.0425309874,
-0.0122618703,
0.0272521824,
0.0046518883,
0.0456362143,
0.0150036765,
0.0260843914,
-0.0533134975,
-0.0269797556,
0.0086276103,
-0.0073265946,
0.0351398997,
0.0577816181,
0.0539702848,
-0.0104147773,
-0.0175495725,
0.0095624719,
0.0055039879,
0.004798024,
-0.0263137165,
0.0806074813,
0.0377011113,
-0.030842172,
-0.0316615105,
0.0707722455,
-0.0095549012,
-0.0439902544,
-0.0164773408,
0.0205951016,
0.0187798087,
-0.0033492374,
-0.0379513316,
0.0113358358,
0.0161112342,
0.0854959264,
0.0465238169,
-0.0446882397,
-0.022495456,
-0.0909023732,
-0.0078928433,
-0.0643656328,
-0.0827953294,
-0.0029534777,
0.0203995351,
-0.0336845294,
-0.0127695268,
-0.0205726326,
-0.0439785346,
0.0315552875,
0.0016224915,
-0.0137321958,
-0.0320097283,
-0.0205910299,
-0.0351957008,
0.0039864867,
0.0191648081,
0.0317985378,
-0.0018898097,
-0.0104631232,
-0.0257313699,
-0.0624134466,
-0.0328302756,
0.011434718,
-0.0231608562,
-0.0398426987,
0.0662720129,
0.0360986516,
0.0291833375,
0.0296935551,
-0.0350098796,
-0.0946837068,
0.0423394814,
0.0325334817,
-0.0112573374,
-0.0033032023,
0.0993140712,
0.0029401702,
0.0327435955,
0.0338732041,
-0.0145372562,
0.011568618,
0.0479825214,
-0.0411742628,
-0.0432137884,
0.0293641742,
-0.0246170107,
0.0013090648,
0.0295593515,
0.0076778769,
-0.0730429217,
0.0004236653,
-0.0024790976,
0.0046947626,
-0.0153685389,
-0.0150171034,
0.0408862419,
-0.0016882062,
-0.0257435981,
-0.015363059,
-0.042374447,
-0.0370317139,
-0.017688781,
-0.0030236063,
0.0375714377,
0.0230663456,
0.0620678589,
-0.0004414748,
0.0335078686,
-0.0138910981,
0.0564976409,
-0.0173612293,
-0.0119653903,
0.0194701739,
0.0606249422,
0.01008025,
0.0054993564,
0.0086087612,
-0.0158625711,
-0.0375910625,
-0.0108076865,
-0.0102720084,
-0.0183422174,
-0.01826372,
-0.0050121523,
0.0299015697,
0.0294029955,
-0.0046327733,
-0.0043791202,
0.0458547771,
0.0299490243,
-0.0509250797,
0.0084942738,
0.0169700589,
-0.0117891319,
0.0042822557,
0.049901817,
0.0272672772,
0.0228437819,
0.0418000296,
-0.0488290936,
-0.0100809168,
-0.0059172297,
0.024853345,
0.0357729532,
-0.0010566991,
0.0165043026,
-0.0621426105,
-0.0638329536,
0.0085471328,
-0.0359189622,
0.0224962849,
-0.0184565745,
-0.0180142932,
0.0795080885,
-0.0087223174,
0.0456809737,
-0.0522811897,
0.0320524387,
-0.0222335141,
-0.0308807306,
0.037927933,
-5.834827758e-33,
0.0129115628,
-0.0581180938,
-0.0538190082,
-0.0387933291,
0.0265905578,
0.0090214862,
-0.0155312,
-0.0107057076,
-0.0299604703,
0.0384477936,
0.0206958223,
0.0341739841,
-0.0065004504,
0.0200817343,
-0.0490487479,
-0.0646824837,
0.0263673905,
0.0021332272,
0.0001324974,
0.0194627512,
0.0783291087,
0.0015733876,
0.0328172632,
-0.0816539526,
0.0929989591,
0.0008409538,
-0.0167812351,
0.000486511,
-0.0152615989,
0.0784147307,
-0.0101980502,
0.0406092294,
0.0266775191,
-0.0164406467,
0.0008590678,
0.0106646987,
-0.0155518334,
-0.0082019009,
0.0426205583,
0.0008348482,
-0.016096605,
-0.0226559825,
0.0311930459,
-0.0087177344,
-0.0108343866,
-0.0239334311,
0.0222316422,
-0.0302679669,
0.0244761799,
-0.0182335954,
-0.0417963341,
0.0307981875,
-0.0732789487,
-0.0090694511,
0.0060767438,
0.0079529807,
0.0461989902,
0.0306340214,
-0.0330661722,
-0.0198623799,
0.0163490381,
-0.0287495665,
0.0514652207,
-0.0298143458,
0.0031713191,
0.0645704716,
0.0067774914,
0.012679223,
-0.0604235642,
0.0018103642,
0.0015600092,
0.0588438809,
0.1210464239,
0.0801153108,
-0.007052972,
-0.0529039577,
-0.0719383657,
-0.018735595,
0.0045284466,
-0.013689762,
0.0558115579,
-0.0076726135,
-0.0693547428,
-0.0057151639,
-0.0246009566,
-0.0985452235,
-0.0419489592,
-0.0224063843,
-0.0021212543,
-0.0343832448,
-0.0649630129,
-0.0198544618,
0.0024367676,
-0.056018468,
0.0350512303,
0.0878825486,
0.005717617,
-0.0177987888,
0.0226021018,
0.0249868184,
0.0116309971,
0.0012848468,
-0.0060465569,
-0.026082918,
0.039831683,
-0.0136667658,
0.0370104946,
0.0468715839,
-0.0059926338,
-0.0115533816,
-0.0501485541,
0.0422118232,
-0.0398126617,
0.0347953513,
0.0236253478,
0.0589935333,
-0.0469538458,
-0.0193764661,
0.0422346815,
-0.0260278601,
0.0117053706,
0.0389019884,
-0.0743769333,
0.0162986312,
-0.0161599256,
-0.0569791384,
0.0135053722,
-0.0047999495,
0.0431152508,
-0.0890495703,
0.0119989021,
-0.0385233946,
2.636e-7,
0.0009476898,
0.0081491461,
0.0103026144,
-0.0312010385,
0.0671971962,
0.0748321265,
0.0370647423,
0.0260172691,
-0.0311109312,
-0.0284135249,
-0.0174907167,
0.0533530191,
0.0464023314,
0.0161228441,
0.0389587991,
-0.0194185097,
-0.0752618536,
-0.0040384736,
-0.0268956702,
0.0287947562,
0.0072039887,
0.0616097897,
0.0671224818,
0.003022542,
-0.0119829038,
-0.0124622658,
-0.012084539,
-0.0600404963,
0.0253089312,
-0.0242585801,
0.070058912,
0.0068381219,
0.0464201421,
-0.0174337383,
-0.0210885219,
0.0006655001,
0.0017074858,
0.0638446584,
0.0155105516,
-0.0003582974,
-0.0171901695,
-0.0438078605,
0.0072864541,
-0.0725893006,
0.0487303361,
0.0002593365,
-0.0465536229,
-0.0138417743,
-0.0247060899,
-0.0446452498,
0.0000887117,
-0.0028309538,
-0.0029936121,
-0.0209065489,
-0.0195146706,
-0.0154639026,
0.0303756706,
-0.0771821588,
-0.0201898292,
-0.0374597199,
-0.0088744666,
-0.0009074057,
-0.0500229225,
-0.0004182009,
0.0914225802,
0.0149210859,
-0.0076830932,
2.281202219e-34,
0.0241718832,
-0.0117605478,
-0.0329291672,
-0.0172013361,
0.0492334664,
0.0189391561,
-0.0051116417,
-0.0049039922,
0.0620090924,
-0.0017092688,
-0.0226762015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18582v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18582v2 | Information Association for Language Model Updating by Mitigating LM-Logical Discrepancy | 2023-05-29T19:48:37 | 2024-02-09T06:37:51 | Pengfei Yu, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models~(LLMs) struggle with providing current information due
to the outdated pre-training data. Existing methods for updating LLMs, such as
knowledge editing and continual fine-tuning, have significant drawbacks in
generalizability of new information and the requirements on structured updating
corpus. We identify the core challenge behind these drawbacks: the LM-logical
discrepancy featuring the difference between language modeling probabilities
and logical probabilities. To evaluate and address the core challenge, we
propose a new task formulation of the information updating task that only
requires the provision of an unstructured updating corpus and evaluates the
performance of information updating on the generalizability to question-answer
pairs pertaining to the updating information. We further propose a novel and
effective pipeline approach for the task, highlighting a self-prompting-based
question-answer generation process and a associative distillation methods to
bridge the LM-logical discrepancy. We develop two datasets for evaluation, one
sourced from news articles published in March and April 2023, and the other
from the Natural Questions benchmark. Experimental results demonstrate the
superiority of our approach, significantly increasing the factual consistency
score (on a scale from 0 to 1) by up to 0.16. Furthermore, our method
effectively mitigates forgetting utilizing a compact replay buffer with only
2.3% of the training tokens. | [
0.0350827463,
0.072787419,
-0.0057076691,
0.0144755971,
-0.0594699122,
-0.0027304194,
-0.0277143698,
-0.0242726449,
-0.0059051616,
-0.0641571134,
0.0172884595,
-0.0347059034,
0.0031603994,
0.0383223183,
0.0211425908,
-0.0184544344,
0.0887434334,
-0.024577111,
0.0168136768,
-0.0193337388,
-0.0042023761,
0.0151405763,
-0.0196567401,
-0.026455801,
0.0196900405,
-0.0289798807,
-0.0249262787,
-0.0020026113,
0.012184835,
-0.011038349,
-0.0003851902,
0.0789829567,
0.0139878057,
0.0357324369,
0.0000021774,
-0.0958435461,
-0.0081923585,
-0.0166977234,
-0.0559512153,
-0.0133387093,
-0.0207870789,
0.0053239586,
-0.0033493633,
0.0266116709,
-0.0380851924,
-0.0070364932,
0.0468937121,
0.0071477937,
0.0940049067,
0.0716625601,
0.0069563929,
-0.0081159212,
0.0523337498,
-0.0140461856,
0.0306586754,
0.0108833546,
0.0379674733,
0.0293520447,
-0.041908741,
0.0240871496,
0.0036554479,
0.0239782576,
0.0264120102,
-0.0568218268,
0.0233841408,
0.0171271432,
-0.036135342,
-0.0225948263,
-0.0139053911,
0.0478118621,
0.0067598778,
-0.0373912305,
-0.016613258,
-0.0062311501,
0.000796914,
0.0090362066,
-0.0362404361,
-0.0097466893,
0.0027803159,
0.0050945096,
0.035021022,
-0.066133894,
0.0169394147,
0.0366053842,
-0.026931515,
0.0641569793,
0.03064638,
-0.0143113211,
-0.0381378569,
-0.0064999601,
-0.0143217724,
-0.1225893945,
-0.0213443991,
0.0477238223,
-0.0553291328,
0.0249538403,
-0.063341774,
-0.0120487977,
0.036331661,
-0.0514328033,
0.0047049047,
0.0413068645,
-0.0116962884,
0.0569647029,
-0.0299948379,
0.0397462025,
0.0183236729,
0.0134455729,
-0.034835685,
0.0260999128,
-0.0281126257,
-0.0330198742,
-0.0165329799,
0.0427980348,
-0.0193115231,
0.0233049095,
-0.0155232549,
0.0249167476,
-0.0105298907,
0.0408407263,
-0.0052632079,
-0.0080483016,
-0.0464773513,
-0.0132274171,
-0.1098700538,
0.0622014217,
-0.0261586476,
0.0232226867,
0.0277608316,
-0.0751877502,
-0.0254693758,
-0.0115233604,
-0.0137512432,
-0.010374845,
0.0020552825,
0.0179239307,
-0.0476517081,
-0.0195251368,
-0.0425685421,
-0.0400497057,
-0.0062553491,
-0.0781411752,
0.0038061447,
-0.0857859701,
0.0620942302,
-0.0059553417,
-0.0280130301,
-0.0337033384,
0.0058586756,
0.0387542471,
-0.0216956586,
0.0653330758,
-0.0094323689,
0.0225391295,
0.0515605882,
-0.0203526821,
0.029897375,
0.0800882801,
0.0180173088,
-0.0142198112,
0.0366006009,
0.0003224357,
-0.0237077661,
-0.0107298568,
0.0148365451,
0.0483039841,
-0.0028067799,
0.0601607673,
0.0173052661,
0.0439689718,
0.0351612903,
0.0421155617,
-0.0076644947,
-0.0354816914,
0.0743261576,
-0.0327821523,
-0.0001641179,
-0.0061788526,
-0.0052704765,
-0.0148980329,
0.0175842233,
0.042266909,
-0.0533638671,
0.0320360027,
-0.024519546,
0.0168841965,
0.0330389515,
0.0514787734,
-0.0397270769,
-0.0617312454,
0.0097498978,
0.0144418245,
-0.0063182591,
0.0213061571,
0.0306978635,
0.0371979438,
0.0073583783,
0.1012161747,
0.0333392695,
-0.0287078731,
0.0289221276,
-0.0452917479,
0.0309091657,
0.035465952,
0.0509299673,
-0.0345894732,
-0.0580527969,
-0.0279315859,
0.0185180325,
0.0309731551,
0.0586832128,
-0.0223360807,
0.0016864054,
-0.0159752443,
-0.0090542799,
-0.0094772503,
0.0088245543,
-0.0124433776,
0.0268587787,
-0.0040992377,
-0.0060841185,
-0.0395080782,
-0.0101148766,
0.0260950942,
-0.0313836373,
-0.0253158491,
0.0301305819,
-0.0155897317,
-0.0057161851,
0.0222368613,
-0.0011727909,
0.0177143179,
0.0245041084,
-0.0024390628,
-0.0320499763,
-0.0179874934,
-0.037267141,
-0.0185783505,
0.0670425072,
0.0491432622,
-0.0225861762,
-0.0052410476,
-0.0617466979,
-0.0362466089,
0.0019271952,
-0.0044706757,
0.0215868223,
-0.0473042578,
0.0443838127,
0.0098957643,
-0.0132098934,
-0.0425405949,
0.0782611221,
-0.0103963632,
0.0068648551,
-0.01415605,
0.0148779945,
0.0254863966,
-0.0456313677,
0.0146778142,
0.0381394587,
-0.0193703771,
-0.0094726318,
0.0362242609,
-0.0168322884,
-0.0552677661,
-0.0146791544,
-0.0434486121,
0.0190901831,
-0.0240899138,
0.026014559,
0.045475293,
0.0306785963,
-0.0141692879,
-0.0253077876,
-0.0452300124,
-0.0137767764,
0.0209605545,
0.0399320163,
0.0524727963,
0.0076432535,
0.0403276905,
-0.0284651853,
-0.0081054335,
-0.0229401458,
0.0263854377,
0.0305777527,
-0.003257314,
-0.0854222402,
0.000402657,
-0.0863512009,
0.0320368446,
-0.0039451923,
0.0086290166,
0.0046114367,
-0.0052031903,
0.0609564222,
0.0273811743,
0.0160274319,
-0.0213025454,
0.0830097571,
0.0019257034,
-0.0450966768,
0.0380545966,
-0.0201494414,
-0.0386549421,
-0.0162855554,
-0.0383944958,
0.0216764417,
0.0284924041,
-0.0049833599,
-0.0392398164,
-0.0091637224,
0.0216762871,
-0.0102810683,
-0.0269599035,
-0.0350838713,
-0.0353493243,
-0.0020895535,
0.0462614521,
-0.039997723,
-0.0366992913,
0.0821826532,
-0.0218072925,
0.0522255003,
-0.1030881703,
0.0046718689,
-0.0243835002,
0.0358851515,
0.0153715108,
0.0283223987,
0.0322039537,
-0.0230873153,
-0.0925169736,
-0.0485167727,
0.0125732599,
-0.0551710427,
0.0756411925,
-0.0825230926,
0.0356889069,
0.0194871295,
-0.0413855091,
-0.0561173074,
-0.056045644,
0.0047701984,
-0.0100965286,
-0.0212807674,
-0.0227561723,
-0.0164535306,
-0.0239878017,
0.0260103419,
0.0249095596,
-0.0200657006,
-0.0158340465,
-0.0199585985,
0.0429646596,
0.1043982804,
0.0718230903,
0.0257059969,
0.0110411011,
0.0388577506,
0.0593750514,
0.0373586081,
0.0175655726,
-0.0088848062,
-0.0045203008,
0.0069703739,
-0.0522809289,
0.0079426263,
-0.0040529384,
0.0499088541,
-0.0402897894,
-0.0249828808,
0.1026643366,
0.0526764169,
-0.015205388,
-0.0178722516,
-0.0049881213,
0.0176496338,
0.0252160318,
0.0540997833,
-0.0996162668,
-0.0050588339,
0.0062366892,
0.0018985014,
-0.0198344309,
-0.0475422069,
-0.0441994704,
-0.0950927138,
0.0023595651,
-0.0003808156,
-0.0199546516,
-0.028773265,
-0.0789304078,
0.0370535254,
0.0176036041,
0.0337080993,
0.0301976912,
-0.002024926,
0.0083360542,
0.0010202591,
-0.0152634811,
-0.0383220389,
-0.0080160927,
-0.0118751032,
0.0304123387,
0.0910804346,
0.0097407978,
-0.0018719228,
0.0122914864,
0.0155791538,
-0.0013420098,
-0.012610361,
-0.0184744876,
0.053096693,
0.0137112271,
-0.0045799948,
-0.0022492728,
0.0181839168,
0.009676788,
-0.0216942299,
0.0060116551,
0.0588937774,
-0.0312863477,
0.0151955271,
-0.0168727003,
-0.0217492543,
0.0255360231,
0.073722586,
0.0033411456,
0.0033022077,
0.0101822363,
-0.0422891788,
0.016613273,
0.0073536765,
0.0349463373,
0.0083888508,
-0.0170666091,
0.0019706555,
-0.0818988606,
-0.0386921205,
0.0353373475,
-0.0092392033,
-0.0032957259,
0.017624354,
0.047483936,
-0.0263177957,
-0.0537820309,
-0.0075580347,
-0.0421665534,
0.0083716549,
-0.0112751685,
0.0038939673,
-0.0015103299,
-0.0071645291,
-0.0167620201,
0.0135913147,
-0.1117421761,
-0.0549467839,
0.0112698618,
0.0284793731,
0.0244032983,
0.0503892601,
-0.0213189423,
-0.0321043245,
0.0356507562,
0.0389360599,
-0.0042378008,
0.0410329401,
-0.0398158282,
-0.0026607958,
-0.0226223394,
0.0230844934,
-0.0528612025,
-0.0161141101,
0.0046091611,
0.0748199746,
-0.0090235844,
-0.0533155091,
0.0498603694,
0.0359698422,
0.0133871185,
0.0383141376,
0.0219442528,
-0.0153108863,
0.055077944,
-0.0107082846,
-0.0267109033,
0.0082027027,
0.0169198122,
-0.001066579,
-0.0261788927,
0.0132132843,
-0.0051848125,
-0.035309881,
0.0441665389,
-0.0108031789,
-0.0580052994,
-0.005268164,
0.0229194313,
0.0374283381,
-0.0087544508,
-0.0144623946,
-0.0005174049,
0.0225416012,
0.0501202047,
-0.0043101516,
0.0499219298,
0.0251354109,
-0.0099694449,
-0.0230758488,
-0.0168811418,
-0.078401193,
-0.0613771714,
-0.0467444584,
0.0281007364,
0.0173740219,
0.0117768878,
0.02246687,
-0.0282762628,
-0.0265174005,
-0.0378659889,
-0.0127931302,
0.0445354506,
-0.0256082173,
0.0436864235,
0.0276947822,
-0.0141487094,
0.0160674062,
0.0549391471,
-0.0501801297,
0.0718114898,
-0.0080988994,
0.0060195997,
-0.0197761878,
-0.0481168181,
-0.0398377962,
0.0278819036,
-0.0193405207,
-0.0204791334,
-0.0347791202,
-0.0519837923,
-0.0000540086,
0.0169402566,
0.0011176736,
-0.0090710418,
0.0085200639,
0.0736355856,
0.012015407,
-0.0297709648,
-0.042927146,
0.0325813629,
-0.0519223437,
-0.0399468355,
-0.0077422946,
-6.819773005e-33,
-0.0235015173,
-0.0157935526,
0.036512088,
-0.0615439788,
-0.0123481071,
-0.0039192438,
-0.0249828137,
-0.0261443201,
-0.0484622121,
0.0061571323,
-0.0212961771,
0.0360078067,
0.0063588214,
0.0198804755,
0.0111673521,
-0.0415216424,
0.0673434585,
-0.0104901604,
-0.0190986339,
0.0150136929,
0.0387675241,
-0.0053253234,
0.0411160961,
-0.0436747819,
0.0589741319,
0.0086437156,
-0.008078753,
0.0665530413,
-0.0240799375,
0.0441700779,
-0.0060946345,
0.0712573603,
0.0187292863,
-0.0434132963,
-0.0337107889,
0.0135131106,
-0.0891166702,
-0.0749091059,
0.0202307124,
-0.0001652995,
-0.0355823636,
-0.0059423428,
0.0319663845,
-0.0008636862,
0.0228563137,
-0.0267613456,
0.0103269173,
-0.017805675,
-0.0047959387,
0.0020491376,
-0.031433478,
0.0084325671,
0.0055161784,
-0.0079702027,
-0.0553418361,
0.0320953056,
0.0319843963,
-0.0055601033,
-0.0699196756,
0.0098239407,
0.0399508253,
0.0722468719,
0.0601956658,
0.0097475657,
-0.018371718,
0.0516596809,
-0.0047048987,
0.0050714072,
-0.0106982542,
0.0249506906,
0.0030489019,
0.0007883206,
0.0163423549,
0.0377638564,
0.0527096093,
0.0106802918,
-0.0717446804,
0.0322656073,
0.029885821,
0.0618618242,
-0.0083594704,
0.0090668499,
-0.0051211175,
-0.0151867587,
-0.0672709644,
0.0389643721,
-0.0430366658,
-0.0515285321,
0.0042755338,
-0.0032302914,
-0.0105975792,
-0.0015102979,
0.0045177848,
-0.0239677727,
-0.0551973619,
-0.0000180548,
-0.0077645322,
0.0108631477,
0.0072205821,
0.0499429367,
-0.0332594775,
0.033301916,
0.0321565419,
0.0096736746,
-0.0147980889,
0.0405749679,
0.0074941157,
0.0050515318,
-0.0731014982,
0.0187658127,
-0.0205116328,
0.0250482596,
-0.0139305191,
-0.0202546529,
0.0064800051,
0.0298978128,
0.0041320045,
0.0264402665,
0.0371347778,
-0.0082011195,
-0.0242405441,
0.009432815,
0.0033862712,
0.0457697697,
0.0047594453,
0.0191140417,
-0.0349914879,
0.0214038435,
0.0128960842,
-0.0572594143,
-0.0014587947,
0.0145554291,
2.965e-7,
0.0545356534,
0.0415963456,
0.0225510504,
0.026466066,
0.0043035061,
0.0158342961,
0.0015505544,
0.020140769,
0.0548000298,
-0.0288053397,
-0.009456154,
0.0256186314,
0.0112767816,
0.0500766449,
-0.0788610354,
-0.0012126064,
-0.0937175006,
-0.0056256861,
-0.0683307499,
-0.0063011977,
0.0739231408,
0.0652657822,
0.0328568667,
-0.0254783351,
-0.0118007036,
-0.0303475689,
0.0296688601,
0.0113765914,
-0.0340353027,
0.0488698259,
0.0573921464,
0.0155777531,
0.019916065,
0.0356975719,
-0.0476010554,
-0.0146731697,
-0.0379543789,
0.0243044682,
0.004590326,
-0.0067302869,
-0.0521796271,
0.0105354097,
0.0368888378,
-0.0711070523,
0.088948451,
-0.0573434606,
-0.0032636202,
-0.060725905,
-0.0356083028,
-0.0034244098,
0.0240876488,
-0.0084953792,
-0.0486355536,
0.0329852179,
0.0093015032,
0.0473836698,
-0.008994177,
-0.0486122742,
-0.0349470116,
0.0096687656,
-0.0258843843,
-0.0621380806,
-0.0271663815,
-0.017027555,
0.0046325093,
-0.0713713169,
0.0246961694,
2.694343714e-34,
0.0113339331,
0.0233239457,
0.0223051142,
0.0056657521,
0.0196593739,
-0.0043329196,
-0.0418340489,
0.0228205789,
-0.0040307548,
-0.0915677547,
-0.0196457915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18576v1 | TreeMAN: Tree-enhanced Multimodal Attention Network for ICD Coding | 2023-05-29T19:37:26 | 2023-05-29T19:37:26 | Zichen Liu, Xuyuan Liu, Yanlong Wen, Guoqing Zhao, Fen Xia, Xiaojie Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | ICD coding is designed to assign the disease codes to electronic health
records (EHRs) upon discharge, which is crucial for billing and clinical
statistics. In an attempt to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of manual
coding, many methods have been proposed to automatically predict ICD codes from
clinical notes. However, most previous works ignore the decisive information
contained in structured medical data in EHRs, which is hard to be captured from
the noisy clinical notes. In this paper, we propose a Tree-enhanced Multimodal
Attention Network (TreeMAN) to fuse tabular features and textual features into
multimodal representations by enhancing the text representations with
tree-based features via the attention mechanism. Tree-based features are
constructed according to decision trees learned from structured multimodal
medical data, which capture the decisive information about ICD coding. We can
apply the same multi-label classifier from previous text models to the
multimodal representations to predict ICD codes. Experiments on two MIMIC
datasets show that our method outperforms prior state-of-the-art ICD coding
approaches. The code is available at https://github.com/liu-zichen/TreeMAN. | [
-0.0112907439,
0.0549521819,
-0.0009979281,
-0.0225510914,
0.0022867131,
0.0245894622,
-0.0095371157,
0.0325646847,
-0.0147188427,
-0.0282013528,
-0.0277934652,
-0.0394494645,
0.0215021987,
0.0606079511,
0.0133643001,
-0.0659151599,
0.0245881807,
0.0378435664,
0.0261222739,
0.0298852809,
0.0146303698,
-0.0038928688,
0.0023608555,
0.0577969626,
-0.0523647442,
-0.0475972071,
-0.0085874135,
0.0353639238,
0.0180575792,
-0.0941746309,
0.0063380324,
0.0275068544,
0.0142243039,
-0.0366517045,
0.000002322,
0.0038092253,
-0.0221447051,
-0.0159568507,
-0.014034681,
-0.0458008163,
0.027290076,
-0.0680070892,
0.0379188694,
-0.0360783413,
-0.0174389277,
-0.0471959114,
0.054548122,
0.0941550806,
0.0624066107,
0.0524241664,
-0.0200271197,
-0.0209861379,
0.0435914509,
-0.0101226643,
0.0704064667,
-0.0367612578,
0.011626075,
0.0057064551,
-0.0000084203,
-0.0226433557,
-0.0635880828,
0.0413506553,
0.0385165811,
0.0396429338,
0.0681011602,
0.0920707062,
0.0034612161,
0.009294929,
-0.0301138479,
0.0800398365,
-0.0350133777,
0.000193368,
-0.0032069443,
-0.0221099388,
0.0016062309,
-0.0443154387,
-0.0443981253,
-0.0138126761,
-0.041041784,
-0.0054512648,
-0.0346275046,
0.0303075369,
0.0240320731,
-0.0433278941,
0.0083537279,
-0.0227638427,
-0.012450533,
-0.0176418517,
0.0129725384,
-0.0475054793,
-0.0000187594,
-0.0361875892,
0.0125761358,
0.0243640356,
-0.0205722786,
-0.0087479139,
-0.0527750701,
-0.0355081782,
0.0298488848,
-0.0481310859,
0.0356040001,
0.0099486439,
-0.0348243825,
0.0304802209,
-0.0143764578,
0.019566521,
-0.0328745544,
0.0558013432,
-0.0071669365,
0.0022232959,
-0.0585892238,
0.0064868373,
-0.0320055895,
0.0012518021,
0.038591668,
-0.0228828862,
-0.0223561488,
-0.0092220567,
0.0120269144,
-0.0011594469,
0.0387399122,
0.05922262,
-0.0305462386,
0.0081302039,
0.0105038062,
0.0121431127,
-0.013851108,
-0.0078617847,
0.0071241744,
0.0239117388,
0.0319067277,
0.055589024,
0.0223964769,
-0.0104598459,
0.0189291686,
0.0705964863,
0.0226455592,
-0.0306522902,
-0.0137347328,
-0.0178721603,
-0.0699836537,
0.0318227299,
0.044942148,
-0.0211363025,
0.0230147447,
-0.0101231197,
0.0197509993,
-0.0395656787,
0.0138812773,
0.0145821413,
-0.0187441111,
0.0451136604,
-0.0475568213,
-0.0153975971,
0.0142242014,
-0.0053636022,
-0.0042546466,
-0.0008831392,
0.0676639974,
0.0204853714,
0.0032858197,
-0.05694158,
0.0267829187,
0.0061665322,
0.0129877338,
-0.0450217016,
0.0097792139,
-0.0044256183,
-0.0098355832,
0.0301873796,
0.0106005864,
-0.0053229178,
0.0097952662,
-0.0514760315,
0.0634899586,
0.0066252165,
0.0419327952,
0.0016258761,
-0.0095566604,
-0.0407500826,
-0.0573356375,
-0.0257011671,
-0.0079820054,
0.0668184608,
0.0307629947,
0.013929951,
0.0255321935,
-0.0260514636,
-0.0168327335,
-0.0267316382,
-0.0106987199,
-0.0141145401,
-0.0039471872,
-0.0086909551,
0.022432629,
0.0078436472,
-0.0259667877,
0.022057401,
0.0058764108,
-0.016815925,
-0.0506728366,
-0.0259389449,
-0.0418998115,
0.055756323,
0.025614351,
-0.0385054126,
-0.0240258127,
-0.0356361568,
0.0312295947,
-0.0116692334,
-0.0239548609,
-0.0008617784,
0.0289559066,
-0.0545721091,
-0.013705601,
0.01985313,
0.0062911632,
-0.0028210036,
-0.0537141003,
-0.0046324325,
-0.0333103016,
-0.0180177595,
-0.0291215423,
0.0444918983,
0.0359393843,
-0.0208483841,
0.0072902665,
-0.0005865832,
0.0493358336,
0.012504071,
-0.0079464428,
0.0273627322,
0.0419745818,
-0.0318441875,
-0.0154426545,
-0.0223823283,
-0.0522733778,
-0.0220247395,
-0.0080414489,
-0.0298420321,
-0.0252330042,
-0.0212216321,
-0.0299303681,
-0.012009793,
-0.0373881571,
-0.071802564,
0.0058710426,
-0.018997537,
0.0150430202,
0.0752847567,
0.0125423791,
-0.0260211639,
0.0735688582,
-0.0594690852,
0.0177149363,
-0.0080238609,
-0.0170812942,
0.0421888568,
0.0029341681,
0.0398221277,
0.021205185,
-0.0450393669,
0.0086142607,
-0.0099487333,
0.0253350902,
-0.0161023978,
0.0236042701,
-0.1231236756,
-0.0118677905,
-0.0026952466,
-0.0115579031,
0.0261733755,
0.0160191189,
0.0122484583,
-0.0409093276,
-0.0374252871,
0.0078009693,
-0.0292176362,
-0.0061279954,
0.0409331694,
0.0011405445,
0.0295100044,
0.0160384644,
0.0075750086,
-0.0469248593,
0.0534351952,
-0.0063558011,
-0.0753489584,
-0.0089380303,
-0.0479514338,
-0.0130573958,
0.0085734883,
0.0162723362,
-0.0114252027,
0.0212904476,
-0.024384141,
0.0369464718,
0.0577379204,
0.0037520984,
0.0304999147,
0.0121469907,
-0.0035756112,
-0.0160314757,
0.0359646603,
-0.0019563148,
0.0435489677,
0.0198547784,
-0.0552800968,
0.0355053023,
0.0862415433,
0.0304053873,
0.024309447,
-0.0373264551,
-0.032070078,
0.047867626,
0.0218489096,
-0.0485471785,
0.049538251,
-0.0514507852,
0.0156935882,
-0.0289192367,
-0.0382353067,
0.0549327582,
-0.0200352538,
-0.0181122404,
-0.0296827443,
-0.0007331089,
-0.0510691479,
0.0732420236,
0.0083611915,
0.0376455188,
0.0086679896,
-0.0376727171,
-0.0010638499,
0.0470605493,
-0.0035969166,
-0.0047060479,
0.0452578254,
0.0387010872,
0.0024100023,
-0.0009771787,
-0.0084078126,
-0.0101396311,
-0.0385950357,
0.0104496162,
-0.0003170979,
-0.0111422557,
0.0114452094,
-0.0512263142,
0.0134113068,
0.0056697456,
0.0630441085,
0.0170467235,
-0.0250062533,
0.0164160803,
0.0632606372,
-0.0081216451,
0.0137232048,
-0.0403532423,
-0.0437061116,
-0.0024411534,
0.0635595918,
0.012978903,
0.0448568203,
-0.0214892868,
0.0162546057,
-0.0241178684,
0.0047811889,
0.0041620252,
0.0437109731,
0.0053456356,
-0.0606333241,
0.0352606475,
0.0455150642,
0.022332048,
-0.0996180996,
0.0160488207,
-0.0153415957,
-0.0045406991,
0.0073414831,
-0.0148842549,
-0.0303541366,
-0.0684102848,
-0.0174678862,
0.0070371805,
0.0272559356,
-0.0294076856,
0.0130775739,
-0.0016992374,
0.0231833216,
0.0067732944,
-0.0589667186,
-0.1006903648,
-0.0148115577,
0.0078600151,
0.0452008806,
-0.0556296334,
0.0128720338,
0.0027693994,
-0.0265822988,
-0.002018674,
-0.0753676966,
-0.0459408537,
0.0172689874,
-0.0150977299,
0.0088498481,
0.1173334569,
0.0587671362,
0.0022222076,
-0.0409175493,
0.00132199,
0.0193117876,
0.0179193951,
-0.0170579422,
0.0802252665,
-0.0469355546,
-0.0093282349,
-0.0208671819,
0.0203620568,
-0.0201477986,
-0.0191096608,
0.0145051992,
0.0764267221,
-0.0492535569,
-0.0518474095,
-0.0648303553,
-0.0084813545,
0.0123288119,
0.0062208981,
0.0265504625,
-0.0557111278,
-0.0223120973,
-0.0187154729,
0.0549237579,
-0.0047304244,
-0.0067378487,
0.0957123712,
-0.0458701216,
-0.0880929902,
-0.0616855472,
-0.0288725682,
0.0213703159,
0.0023029679,
-0.003544878,
-0.0303284153,
-0.0246371441,
-0.0049270568,
-0.0367772356,
0.0199869368,
0.0073604519,
-0.0048507107,
-0.0262861829,
-0.0097886641,
0.0317469053,
0.0082323151,
-0.0015010885,
0.0291459095,
-0.0150533132,
0.0387475044,
-0.0306611452,
0.0344512202,
0.0070215859,
-0.0072537931,
0.0083580492,
-0.0189579744,
-0.0450599194,
0.0266268365,
-0.027026426,
-0.0218027662,
0.0169801246,
-0.0312866904,
-0.0138917537,
0.0010409188,
-0.0384411328,
0.0560325235,
-0.0136255883,
0.0113341613,
-0.0181503519,
-0.0051218895,
0.0101689436,
-0.0058748722,
0.040992979,
-0.0195333194,
-0.0399313308,
0.0096732657,
0.0445678607,
0.0363506861,
-0.013530286,
-0.0270589571,
-0.0149722947,
-0.0036599159,
-0.0066165701,
-0.0357753932,
0.0044302326,
0.0149360336,
-0.064496696,
-0.0612239763,
0.0261793174,
0.0349156633,
0.0153996246,
-0.0172297638,
-0.0108508775,
-0.0186917987,
0.0161716994,
-0.0012944946,
0.0197267849,
0.0156012168,
0.0746482611,
-0.0076493938,
-0.000017265,
-0.0172481015,
0.0274730511,
-0.0365190133,
-0.0155840432,
-0.0433044955,
-0.012977072,
0.0330966935,
0.0366064012,
-0.0248017274,
-0.0206690505,
0.0337194465,
-0.0264281891,
0.019883994,
0.0069249487,
-0.0102377143,
0.0335358791,
-0.0080969566,
-0.0105647882,
-0.0196126103,
0.0682149455,
0.0364988372,
0.0011624609,
-0.0283361841,
-0.0327224582,
-0.0561047159,
0.0334151089,
0.0549802259,
0.0472231731,
-0.0160176884,
-0.0047627636,
-0.0407971144,
-0.0223392118,
0.075524427,
-0.0234593563,
0.0019776614,
0.0007953137,
0.0579870753,
-0.0003092274,
-0.0013248913,
-0.0188687555,
-0.0111980727,
0.0365947634,
-0.0141834123,
-0.0093007078,
-0.0357283987,
-6.280641337e-33,
-0.0224633291,
-0.0464481041,
-0.011840635,
-0.0073264265,
-0.0037710494,
0.022377301,
-0.0549625047,
-0.0247258078,
0.0387484394,
0.0082107252,
-0.0096455049,
-0.0102460319,
-0.0059878454,
0.0492456257,
0.0416813493,
-0.0418244228,
0.0049364599,
0.0076810247,
-0.0124740507,
0.0641862005,
-0.0053603952,
0.0499618091,
0.0604948178,
-0.0816422701,
0.0109749138,
0.0132331355,
-0.0016975899,
-0.0398786888,
0.0013695575,
0.0390433259,
-0.0324515514,
0.0284634177,
0.0493815504,
-0.0248875674,
-0.0355230458,
0.0564584769,
-0.0879786909,
-0.0302081984,
-0.038674701,
-0.0374159552,
-0.0530263856,
-0.0482792594,
0.0773111582,
-0.010401695,
0.0341685824,
-0.0426573455,
0.057059478,
-0.0140304556,
-0.0384225883,
-0.0619142838,
-0.0100849951,
0.0451112837,
-0.0126090785,
0.0008628873,
-0.0081707779,
0.0666009337,
-0.0028384523,
0.0686892495,
-0.059506271,
0.0034088853,
-0.035303887,
0.0197654627,
0.0046570306,
-0.0168481693,
-0.0111752553,
0.0960065275,
0.0455794223,
-0.0377640575,
-0.0544584282,
0.0170412045,
-0.0311226789,
0.0512044504,
0.0753745809,
0.0132708903,
0.029357532,
-0.0152945751,
-0.0591307618,
0.0270502903,
-0.0732119828,
0.0519809276,
0.0456555299,
0.0016420046,
-0.0280157644,
0.0028223975,
0.0302181728,
0.003613814,
-0.0135177504,
-0.0110353688,
0.0496041439,
-0.0114397639,
0.0155637898,
0.0505504981,
0.0404878557,
-0.014294575,
0.0069334107,
0.0056892303,
0.0506692901,
0.0883334726,
-0.0117911389,
-0.0207412522,
0.0007747017,
0.0104052667,
0.061342556,
-0.044230435,
0.0509986058,
0.0195882358,
0.041062668,
-0.0198026057,
-0.0328513458,
-0.048874367,
0.0575582422,
-0.0433544815,
-0.0310212914,
0.0641121417,
0.0497003533,
0.0047000372,
-0.0294617936,
0.0464629233,
-0.0147583447,
0.0181932058,
-0.042017445,
-0.0913815945,
-0.0040904917,
0.0079275109,
-0.0037236828,
-0.0058428692,
-0.0685678199,
-0.0147596328,
-0.0093974341,
-0.0399287567,
0.0083733834,
0.0578751341,
3.001e-7,
0.0713195205,
0.040777266,
0.0048890556,
-0.0559650324,
0.0550842658,
0.0184967555,
-0.0001912102,
0.0373895988,
-0.0074200951,
-0.082014069,
0.0604764819,
-0.0057457788,
0.034894567,
0.026990734,
-0.0716111138,
-0.0589606203,
-0.0634724498,
0.0283703171,
-0.0150008779,
-0.0179873426,
0.0854120776,
0.1029392704,
-0.054092139,
-0.0115619237,
0.0613012277,
0.0153756309,
0.0334938206,
-0.0211666152,
0.029381508,
-0.0411485657,
-0.0012014837,
-0.0040732184,
-0.0436110049,
0.0532891825,
-0.0117451949,
-0.0288524926,
0.0277779996,
0.0582918115,
-0.0904360712,
-0.0054967306,
-0.0026011853,
0.0300051197,
-0.0083272895,
-0.0174679756,
0.0756819919,
-0.0498215109,
-0.0252268855,
-0.0004822337,
-0.0068532773,
0.0378043652,
0.0537551977,
0.0048744683,
-0.03413013,
0.0288895033,
0.0148030063,
-0.0193613861,
-0.0289123375,
-0.0898991898,
-0.0443011224,
0.0503766909,
-0.0191473644,
0.0136648389,
-0.0238370765,
-0.0172960535,
0.0318126045,
-0.0687283278,
-0.0485907383,
2.769150384e-34,
0.035235621,
-0.0193580519,
0.0006871374,
0.0464964882,
0.0150883282,
-0.052491758,
0.0409660563,
-0.0084130345,
0.0243935063,
-0.0522873886,
-0.0360948071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18565v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18565v1 | PaLI-X: On Scaling up a Multilingual Vision and Language Model | 2023-05-29T18:58:38 | 2023-05-29T18:58:38 | Xi Chen, Josip Djolonga, Piotr Padlewski, Basil Mustafa, Soravit Changpinyo, Jialin Wu, Carlos Riquelme Ruiz, Sebastian Goodman, Xiao Wang, Yi Tay, Siamak Shakeri, Mostafa Dehghani, Daniel Salz, Mario Lucic, Michael Tschannen, Arsha Nagrani, Hexiang Hu, Mandar Joshi, Bo Pang, Ceslee Montgomery, Paulina Pietrzyk, Marvin Ritter, AJ Piergiovanni, Matthias Minderer, Filip Pavetic, Austin Waters, Gang Li, Ibrahim Alabdulmohsin, Lucas Beyer, Julien Amelot, Kenton Lee, Andreas Peter Steiner, Yang Li, Daniel Keysers, Anurag Arnab, Yuanzhong Xu, Keran Rong, Alexander Kolesnikov, Mojtaba Seyedhosseini, Anelia Angelova, Xiaohua Zhai, Neil Houlsby, Radu Soricut | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | We present the training recipe and results of scaling up PaLI-X, a
multilingual vision and language model, both in terms of size of the components
and the breadth of its training task mixture. Our model achieves new levels of
performance on a wide-range of varied and complex tasks, including multiple
image-based captioning and question-answering tasks, image-based document
understanding and few-shot (in-context) learning, as well as object detection,
video question answering, and video captioning. PaLI-X advances the
state-of-the-art on most vision-and-language benchmarks considered (25+ of
them). Finally, we observe emerging capabilities, such as complex counting and
multilingual object detection, tasks that are not explicitly in the training
mix. | [
0.0119546214,
0.066231437,
0.0058810581,
0.0931984484,
0.0139871025,
0.0124879833,
-0.0016156283,
-0.0266117081,
-0.015733853,
-0.0237490237,
-0.0631465539,
-0.0561481416,
-0.001986753,
0.0446425341,
0.0175357927,
-0.0624497607,
0.0430391841,
-0.0531091876,
-0.0129570868,
0.0074836994,
0.0224383287,
0.0201949403,
-0.0073518697,
0.0160945728,
-0.0074969176,
-0.0307423454,
0.0096584922,
-0.0111514116,
0.0228919182,
-0.0294058174,
-0.0014278934,
0.0404490083,
0.0578223467,
0.0246332865,
0.0000015321,
-0.0178493578,
0.0244434364,
0.0107163116,
0.0192553308,
-0.0049623335,
0.0299315546,
-0.0647763386,
0.0126750497,
0.0224811919,
-0.0250246357,
-0.0409246832,
0.0270375814,
0.0164697003,
0.0670583621,
0.0447085127,
-0.0272392649,
-0.0613553636,
0.047616329,
-0.0401145071,
-0.0134063521,
-0.0556901395,
-0.0174080636,
0.0143090189,
0.0103054075,
-0.000002132,
-0.0342239961,
0.0447670817,
0.0403472409,
-0.0240754653,
-0.0160238612,
0.0512354821,
-0.0080252001,
-0.0160029661,
-0.0160735752,
0.077303648,
-0.0151647348,
0.0179917831,
-0.0244123787,
0.0043929261,
-0.0125915427,
-0.063565962,
-0.0501824133,
0.040016681,
0.023047993,
0.0136893671,
-0.0207632296,
0.0156232715,
0.0104614031,
0.0346377492,
0.0430520475,
-0.0142602352,
0.030233318,
0.0387946256,
-0.00128364,
0.0174780004,
-0.0169135761,
-0.040071696,
-0.0289732218,
0.0415177345,
-0.013197748,
0.0018120549,
-0.0341966711,
-0.031837415,
-0.0072804843,
-0.0491643958,
0.0688722134,
0.0417203903,
-0.0588410497,
0.0965830684,
-0.026147861,
0.0671442673,
-0.0331070945,
0.0312955938,
-0.0279433932,
-0.0509491302,
0.013781189,
-0.025928434,
-0.0328394622,
0.0107181724,
-0.0253057256,
-0.0270487443,
-0.0308612064,
0.0268358737,
0.0155231664,
-0.0027673063,
0.0148180071,
-0.0066351462,
-0.0276229009,
-0.0407201946,
-0.0096411835,
0.0686079413,
-0.0534113832,
0.027311286,
-0.0221578553,
-0.0583149269,
-0.00294592,
0.0428585559,
-0.0007557672,
-0.0384101011,
-0.0044127759,
0.0716054291,
-0.0651292428,
-0.0515778996,
-0.030723827,
0.0179361794,
-0.0360859893,
-0.0423447751,
0.004554328,
-0.075701654,
0.0480460338,
-0.0293303132,
-0.0069451616,
-0.0266512521,
0.0061121969,
0.0364781432,
0.0129808998,
0.0684722215,
0.0173185226,
-0.0213219393,
0.004167628,
0.0221909937,
0.0233545508,
0.1148381159,
0.0310101938,
0.0146725532,
0.0448675379,
0.019795686,
0.0328481458,
0.0616064779,
-0.0095618851,
0.0465149209,
-0.0396417938,
0.0176201444,
0.0225120001,
0.0027478966,
0.0434672199,
0.0491158105,
-0.0299108755,
-0.0271789674,
0.0455387905,
0.047982458,
-0.0109337252,
-0.0019833569,
0.0242629237,
-0.0290788189,
0.008946144,
0.0047321776,
-0.0323729366,
0.0836630836,
0.0291054007,
-0.0230066329,
0.0104715927,
0.0395867266,
-0.0686383098,
-0.0210176725,
-0.0024751618,
-0.0259016026,
-0.0364284255,
-0.0013020207,
0.0522275344,
0.0161898248,
-0.0087759038,
0.0218082797,
0.0209331587,
-0.023892127,
0.020412825,
-0.0299080554,
0.0187845584,
0.0464086272,
-0.0042490261,
-0.0148956068,
-0.0390316024,
0.0092862109,
0.0521067902,
0.0663586706,
0.0423479266,
-0.0037178483,
0.0742028579,
-0.0535405129,
0.0011935285,
-0.0021225819,
-0.0020277991,
0.0437930599,
0.007121658,
0.0033072443,
0.0110295136,
-0.0047805109,
0.0064741117,
0.0332962535,
-0.0039823814,
0.0000132234,
-0.0129971532,
0.011878089,
0.0107262377,
-0.0190179348,
-0.0088402238,
-0.0127101224,
0.0244406257,
-0.061507836,
-0.0110555813,
0.0365409218,
-0.0146002145,
-0.0450699441,
0.0563340113,
-0.0259559732,
-0.0164089296,
0.0219213217,
-0.0274093132,
-0.0422649086,
0.034509629,
-0.0370736532,
-0.0157246292,
-0.0774126202,
-0.0233998951,
0.0005473312,
0.0354849435,
-0.0084429188,
0.0305249002,
-0.0244337171,
-0.0029422878,
0.0080897715,
-0.0019653905,
0.0166587979,
-0.0290883947,
-0.061614193,
-0.005201289,
0.0025914144,
0.0274893679,
0.0138601959,
0.0078570675,
-0.0145144491,
-0.0244010445,
-0.0584642068,
0.0101790996,
-0.021391619,
0.0006846472,
-0.0077512334,
0.0093118884,
0.00627612,
-0.0512319244,
-0.0646544397,
-0.0098345503,
0.0576338768,
0.0408047102,
0.0505964831,
0.0215516593,
0.0255617853,
-0.0190243013,
-0.0158064906,
0.0079720821,
0.0620851554,
-0.0196378771,
-0.020842528,
0.0038190272,
0.0089771273,
-0.027835561,
0.0222912766,
-0.0337120667,
-0.0584877431,
-0.0179321263,
-0.0125758117,
0.0152524719,
0.050304953,
-0.0222318247,
0.0266276859,
0.0061274227,
0.0112513201,
-0.0114849117,
0.0246030353,
0.0212892033,
-0.0266482234,
-0.0172506887,
-0.012102901,
-0.0391052738,
0.0458543673,
-0.0460804775,
0.0034886838,
-0.0664636642,
-0.0092416489,
-0.0207883827,
-0.0457999296,
-0.041493848,
0.0302331094,
-0.0117860036,
0.0314123258,
-0.0359824859,
-0.0229694583,
0.0322473273,
-0.0345683768,
-0.0411511697,
-0.0135203134,
0.0069080284,
-0.0429876335,
0.0515269898,
0.0369936191,
0.0316613764,
-0.0440311581,
0.0084345257,
-0.0642391592,
-0.036480125,
-0.0071621467,
-0.0174946841,
0.0854038298,
-0.0617472865,
0.0224507302,
-0.0672946721,
-0.0473761819,
-0.0380548164,
-0.0138036944,
-0.0334071741,
0.029858198,
-0.0547983758,
-0.0227846764,
-0.0294084214,
0.0181060117,
0.0451909825,
0.0533407964,
-0.0077451463,
0.0172011871,
0.0023093864,
0.0574822798,
0.0742207393,
0.0431744382,
-0.0207350254,
-0.0574240535,
0.0244805012,
0.0546166003,
0.0273617525,
-0.0017187984,
-0.0349532217,
0.0160939433,
0.0148242228,
0.0581782535,
-0.0088852728,
0.0113676162,
0.0469327495,
-0.0254438911,
-0.0162506234,
0.0843869522,
0.0192025267,
-0.0599176958,
-0.0313028805,
-0.0115252435,
0.0223864149,
0.0591132529,
0.020146424,
-0.0782039538,
-0.0384496935,
-0.0404875502,
-0.0251923334,
0.0259534419,
0.017415667,
-0.0454289429,
-0.1036126688,
-0.0044506751,
-0.0223249346,
-0.0811182782,
-0.0343899764,
-0.009930932,
-0.0052690092,
-0.0200550165,
-0.0235359427,
-0.0285324436,
0.0080497507,
-0.003812829,
0.0355683491,
-0.0099640507,
-0.033273641,
0.026627101,
-0.0452076346,
-0.0093583483,
0.0293842535,
0.004400671,
-0.0514203124,
-0.038109839,
0.0214821771,
-0.0226613097,
-0.0286621898,
0.0435814634,
0.0415297635,
0.0063841492,
-0.056403812,
0.029694356,
0.0001488922,
-0.0471795984,
-0.0116401361,
-0.0110412324,
0.0371054746,
0.0386878923,
0.0100180507,
-0.0074332915,
-0.0014214524,
-0.0244740676,
0.0407227688,
0.0173295084,
-0.0212937687,
-0.0130847096,
-0.0170630421,
-0.0421338677,
-0.0901774094,
-0.0253367815,
0.0027756668,
0.0086087007,
-0.0126818735,
-0.0702863708,
-0.0466543287,
0.033280544,
0.0683393627,
-0.0188888665,
-0.0140443603,
0.0040768678,
0.0093393968,
-0.0362592936,
0.0121462708,
-0.0300234929,
0.049211096,
-0.0552187525,
0.0234153699,
0.0309443045,
-0.00791464,
-0.0126494579,
0.0245781131,
-0.1013197675,
-0.0384429321,
-0.0438143089,
0.0841530785,
0.0172899086,
0.0141536165,
-0.0319339223,
-0.0353210308,
-0.0429897867,
0.009975926,
0.0246669017,
0.0135636125,
0.0149874547,
-0.0257919021,
-0.0122185471,
0.053817369,
-0.0110260425,
0.0210332926,
0.0101853115,
0.0074787172,
-0.0476579666,
-0.0218963362,
-0.0217326786,
-0.0026544773,
0.0141683575,
-0.0252951887,
0.0141886696,
-0.0254973639,
0.0096927416,
0.002205872,
-0.0218906272,
-0.0575767867,
-0.0157206226,
0.0483189262,
-0.0004871641,
-0.0148039609,
0.0250933226,
0.0281638019,
0.001072122,
-0.0298292115,
-0.0162489843,
0.0589787327,
-0.0120153697,
-0.0231039133,
0.0098723192,
-0.0250924714,
0.0170607381,
-0.0134584811,
0.0480888486,
-0.0114591634,
0.0503399819,
0.0043063927,
-0.036244221,
0.0007625298,
0.0286868215,
-0.0251450986,
-0.0223506521,
-0.0403334536,
0.0652581379,
0.0672865659,
-0.0191619415,
0.0011009441,
0.0024135583,
-0.0246762317,
-0.0413210243,
0.0363578536,
-0.0140726333,
-0.0319242366,
0.0623194091,
0.0290858801,
0.0137754092,
-0.0251232386,
0.1068855375,
0.0106252795,
0.0264126845,
0.024718903,
0.022967888,
-0.0029957795,
-0.0210552085,
-0.0088953972,
0.0035305149,
-0.0109772654,
0.0561511219,
-0.0258764569,
-0.0756096542,
0.0003743318,
0.003369886,
0.0252035856,
0.0366101749,
0.049152568,
0.0479141697,
0.0262119453,
0.0051102648,
-0.049723234,
-0.0089396024,
-0.0066108098,
0.0314790346,
0.0377371795,
-5.303158275e-33,
-0.0490503572,
0.0007361594,
0.0272649713,
-0.0155782662,
-0.0092679439,
0.0061286027,
-0.0235397927,
0.0175876729,
-0.0509179756,
0.0023145552,
0.0174428336,
0.0246528722,
0.01082661,
0.0681145936,
0.0179327838,
-0.0173827335,
0.0214126129,
0.001783237,
-0.0112419063,
-0.0131259374,
0.0249465909,
0.0050158072,
0.076852046,
0.0132136643,
-0.0359306522,
0.0217451584,
-0.0209842399,
0.0445094593,
0.0185176264,
0.0777443498,
-0.0561459027,
0.0190910138,
0.0261474624,
-0.0260639656,
-0.0311316382,
0.0304469634,
-0.0613111928,
-0.0106050456,
0.0408347473,
0.0673763677,
-0.0429853536,
-0.002999542,
-0.0253882837,
-0.0458749272,
0.0333098136,
-0.0082214624,
0.0293401554,
-0.0399475172,
-0.0408678167,
0.0360565223,
-0.0349987186,
0.0134214479,
0.0020664972,
-0.0341234356,
0.0215739384,
0.0309376791,
0.0182105675,
0.0191137213,
-0.0434042327,
-0.0038879528,
-0.0170848407,
0.039066337,
0.0392233804,
0.0474671163,
-0.0401619151,
0.0509122908,
0.0110064493,
-0.0371260121,
-0.0251370296,
-0.0113302507,
0.005239144,
0.023821108,
0.0766177997,
0.0732328743,
0.0068240864,
0.0303928908,
-0.0761500001,
0.0163355228,
-0.0051217033,
0.069477953,
0.0192272421,
0.0016797554,
-0.009840183,
-0.0009753663,
-0.0115777608,
-0.0001333118,
-0.048672542,
0.0243251249,
0.0464165024,
0.0150997108,
-0.0187502783,
0.0511581078,
0.0673909113,
-0.0424245074,
0.0161003377,
0.0302459486,
0.005241198,
0.0396384113,
0.0177875087,
0.0601880699,
-0.0505266711,
-0.0063890778,
0.0224011019,
0.0133653302,
-0.0280181933,
0.0184476338,
0.0900214612,
-0.0094214594,
-0.06509123,
0.0051476234,
-0.0615847893,
0.0058432482,
0.0059082494,
0.1094836369,
-0.0224695858,
-0.0220017154,
-0.0695533976,
0.0336333774,
-0.0275595412,
-0.0223098863,
-0.0177373309,
-0.0241152905,
-0.0002270915,
0.0152116604,
-0.0238568597,
0.0281793065,
-0.0426800959,
-0.0025017431,
0.0079436507,
-0.0535645299,
-0.0021013091,
0.0575663261,
2.123e-7,
0.0537565127,
-0.0037360794,
0.0185324941,
0.0049034799,
0.0212393533,
0.0246449411,
-0.0678987801,
0.0687288567,
-0.0196781047,
0.0166214053,
-0.0285719819,
0.06292779,
0.0504708998,
0.0252111983,
-0.0306467023,
0.0144690219,
-0.0573187061,
0.0084242383,
0.000537961,
-0.0473758876,
0.0137690464,
0.1037862971,
-0.0355796292,
-0.0053686318,
0.0023135196,
-0.0711489096,
0.1058963984,
0.0182108767,
-0.0140723949,
-0.0072878338,
-0.0413022004,
0.0644209981,
-0.0091547146,
-0.0042617382,
-0.0342532694,
0.0050536655,
0.0835913792,
0.0749138519,
-0.035144221,
-0.0116001964,
0.0058383229,
0.0270087235,
-0.0298098195,
-0.0357553698,
0.0946032181,
-0.0249648374,
-0.0034785788,
-0.0379579067,
-0.0203774981,
0.0013563837,
0.0546119213,
-0.0164677501,
-0.0575093217,
0.0266263634,
0.0635571405,
-0.0742525607,
-0.0420219898,
-0.0566132218,
-0.0326387994,
-0.0078784246,
-0.0242814496,
-0.0258898791,
-0.0696468204,
-0.0210972391,
0.017614929,
-0.0228196569,
-0.018361086,
1.228958222e-34,
0.0625692904,
-0.0221598353,
-0.0094498238,
0.0066395402,
-0.013530612,
-0.0218970571,
-0.0438954197,
-0.0325698853,
0.0114357146,
-0.0677338317,
0.0045596166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00008v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.00008v2 | Brainformers: Trading Simplicity for Efficiency | 2023-05-29T18:42:01 | 2024-04-25T05:46:01 | Yanqi Zhou, Nan Du, Yanping Huang, Daiyi Peng, Chang Lan, Da Huang, Siamak Shakeri, David So, Andrew Dai, Yifeng Lu, Zhifeng Chen, Quoc Le, Claire Cui, James Laudon, Jeff Dean | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Transformers are central to recent successes in natural language processing
and computer vision. Transformers have a mostly uniform backbone where layers
alternate between feed-forward and self-attention in order to build a deep
network. Here we investigate this design choice and find that more complex
blocks that have different permutations of layer primitives can be more
efficient. Using this insight, we develop a complex block, named Brainformer,
that consists of a diverse sets of layers such as sparsely gated feed-forward
layers, dense feed-forward layers, attention layers, and various forms of layer
normalization and activation functions. Brainformer consistently outperforms
the state-of-the-art dense and sparse Transformers, in terms of both quality
and efficiency. A Brainformer model with 8 billion activated parameters per
token demonstrates 2x faster training convergence and 5x faster step time
compared to its GLaM counterpart. In downstream task evaluation, Brainformer
also demonstrates a 3% higher SuperGLUE score with fine-tuning compared to GLaM
with a similar number of activated parameters. Finally, Brainformer largely
outperforms a Primer dense model derived with NAS with similar computation per
token on fewshot evaluations. | [
0.0075761862,
0.0266280081,
0.0081855245,
0.0179216992,
0.0051829051,
-0.0190583039,
0.0508353002,
-0.015212534,
-0.0047937143,
-0.0040550269,
-0.0383212194,
-0.0610802546,
0.0163266417,
0.0811909363,
0.0291566104,
-0.061871849,
0.0389134809,
0.0040868237,
0.0020434782,
0.0187317077,
0.002187958,
-0.0148360478,
-0.030975109,
0.0826483294,
-0.0425726585,
0.0074973754,
-0.0352882035,
-0.0031537313,
0.0252863541,
-0.0170215964,
-0.0035523626,
0.0536971353,
0.0148616834,
0.0402156003,
0.0000023294,
-0.0215522256,
0.0298035629,
0.0008312293,
-0.0593736731,
0.0201208945,
0.0047962526,
-0.0247062985,
-0.0233981516,
-0.0059053106,
-0.0151248695,
-0.059167631,
0.0548446402,
0.1218212545,
0.0428257436,
0.050258562,
-0.0246616397,
-0.0598558486,
0.0719238892,
-0.0277677607,
-0.0306235515,
-0.0144372918,
-0.0242441557,
-0.0662877411,
-0.030875776,
-0.0077578682,
-0.0082015004,
0.0347136743,
0.0587325171,
-0.0235905033,
0.0543563329,
0.0431791767,
-0.0502086915,
-0.0426057056,
-0.0183769371,
0.0706573427,
-0.0674755126,
0.0080359466,
-0.0221341196,
-0.0048167263,
-0.0167431664,
-0.0242587496,
-0.0232138354,
0.0178223103,
0.0442809947,
0.0210788343,
-0.032105267,
0.0205729771,
0.0598941892,
-0.0049973726,
-0.0314773023,
0.0524082147,
-0.0067360359,
-0.0077433665,
0.0416681468,
0.0124520054,
-0.0309164301,
-0.0347972214,
0.0123750679,
0.0115961609,
-0.0300452672,
-0.0351229608,
-0.045146849,
-0.0533723086,
-0.0116112018,
0.0165225584,
0.0402221344,
0.0373723954,
-0.0378180258,
0.0324107707,
-0.0553303957,
0.0464857928,
-0.0592755973,
0.0634877235,
-0.0206788331,
-0.0178977232,
-0.0137568256,
-0.0067959824,
-0.0497580096,
0.0664236173,
-0.0385956764,
-0.1030078754,
-0.0560429096,
-0.0020049422,
-0.0144711025,
-0.0401869342,
-0.0058309129,
0.0605970062,
-0.0167993549,
-0.0275008064,
-0.0097400658,
0.0454430096,
-0.0100883683,
0.0319998749,
0.0515812784,
-0.0573769026,
-0.044459749,
0.0396965705,
0.0003235152,
0.0051943632,
0.0208101999,
0.0385811888,
-0.0445671417,
-0.0321881324,
-0.0565635264,
0.0078512002,
0.0026390809,
-0.0378407016,
0.0158979502,
-0.0608817749,
0.0161821246,
-0.0027441545,
0.0098468252,
-0.0590418316,
0.0053850375,
0.0069709639,
-0.0059185592,
0.0406121947,
-0.0183878392,
-0.0525727943,
0.0183594637,
0.0239599273,
-0.015986884,
0.0456129238,
0.0335654281,
0.0421249792,
-0.0204690527,
-0.0333416089,
0.0467453487,
0.0179546606,
0.0237187799,
-0.0224806219,
-0.0382582881,
-0.0421102121,
-0.0121621238,
0.0229703225,
0.045202408,
0.042440597,
-0.0310378745,
-0.0225797631,
0.0531866625,
0.045726642,
0.0089184046,
0.0590738207,
0.0171687882,
0.004157152,
0.0038186365,
-0.0179690365,
-0.0749282017,
0.0710224807,
-0.0196858626,
-0.0440687537,
-0.0059027537,
0.0278432071,
-0.0632700697,
-0.0241470691,
0.0371089317,
-0.0077788583,
-0.006599294,
0.0107015297,
0.0326952897,
0.0141850458,
-0.052635204,
0.1015935093,
-0.0032524804,
-0.0404053815,
-0.0267579257,
-0.0593283139,
-0.0175124016,
-0.0016598082,
-0.0034455808,
-0.001880193,
-0.027741177,
-0.0227041245,
0.0144712524,
0.0617878996,
-0.0085673984,
0.0419865139,
0.0618994609,
-0.0520308241,
-0.0321388803,
0.0039292681,
0.0124124372,
0.0100921122,
-0.0025440422,
0.0092100194,
0.0096316077,
-0.0034983435,
0.0209193677,
0.0249640159,
0.03519243,
0.0017780645,
0.0355993696,
0.0004941917,
0.0326983109,
0.0174666122,
-0.0076295449,
0.0037761068,
0.030111555,
-0.0632472113,
-0.0590392314,
-0.0091632428,
-0.0634556785,
0.0084194206,
-0.0084129395,
-0.0152537283,
0.024190085,
0.0894601792,
-0.0352886617,
-0.0571472608,
0.0134737976,
-0.0456755124,
0.0262781866,
-0.0200147517,
0.0147973541,
-0.0257845856,
0.059783753,
0.0083718998,
0.0223097242,
-0.0174210407,
-0.0518798642,
-0.0234731082,
0.0074460311,
0.0215632208,
-0.0269338004,
-0.0433275178,
0.002382356,
-0.0604807138,
-0.0046906252,
0.0051923366,
-0.0298143439,
-0.0234399084,
-0.0074050664,
-0.0560187399,
-0.0165486131,
-0.0517752729,
-0.0042289458,
0.0105259055,
0.0504614338,
0.0172144677,
-0.0192631837,
-0.02542869,
0.0178064313,
0.001926387,
-0.0225523263,
-0.0060126889,
-0.0004731425,
-0.0365327783,
-0.0323036946,
-0.0417329967,
0.0289766304,
0.0345900208,
-0.0003624617,
-0.005557972,
-0.031483978,
-0.0243726242,
0.0318736434,
0.041704461,
-0.0122711388,
-0.0432959683,
0.0021780448,
-0.0167337153,
-0.020019386,
0.0831488669,
0.013734716,
0.0015700561,
-0.0047177104,
0.0310424305,
-0.021096224,
0.0363563858,
-0.0186471902,
0.0422484949,
-0.050647229,
0.0115644606,
0.0242203716,
0.053390719,
-0.0049825339,
0.0220490471,
-0.0386249684,
-0.0061183274,
0.0181394611,
-0.0411597043,
-0.0041173208,
-0.0073631057,
-0.01078605,
0.0178439394,
-0.0147040207,
-0.0475770868,
0.0357774012,
-0.0367897674,
-0.0400013551,
0.0067442846,
-0.0312078986,
-0.005531447,
0.0054907389,
0.0171575192,
0.0095138475,
-0.0037296682,
-0.0605893694,
-0.0162732825,
0.0058382191,
-0.0224211924,
0.0095089804,
0.0543304086,
-0.0089041814,
0.0179963931,
-0.0221380293,
-0.0258423258,
-0.0551832467,
0.0144396257,
-0.0189619511,
0.0590829141,
0.0808734149,
-0.0112951091,
-0.1196995378,
0.0147968624,
0.0290740505,
0.0649639964,
-0.0109008253,
-0.0093758013,
-0.0074590417,
0.0507354662,
0.0217884202,
0.0756441578,
0.072863698,
0.0227902532,
0.0346410386,
0.0629318058,
0.0197136216,
0.0184250046,
-0.0859983861,
0.012511244,
0.0151986452,
-0.0039998787,
0.0046233796,
-0.0036298786,
0.0602323115,
-0.0645070896,
0.0208663978,
0.0889545977,
-0.0028809335,
-0.0660877898,
-0.0105193211,
0.0167880692,
0.0209158417,
0.0127021242,
-0.0011273521,
-0.0171876308,
-0.0451359414,
-0.0034030743,
0.0263987277,
0.0263748914,
-0.0203642081,
0.0336718857,
-0.0648322925,
0.0462879166,
-0.0079172216,
-0.0481989868,
-0.0137214009,
-0.0230523944,
0.0020701573,
-0.0180470571,
0.030953465,
-0.0123705221,
0.0085204113,
-0.0601755194,
0.0080989022,
-0.0227972176,
-0.056297075,
0.0265912842,
-0.0483404398,
0.0246810745,
0.0687957928,
-0.0427751131,
-0.012631882,
-0.032455463,
0.0539012812,
-0.0031060076,
0.0124693606,
-0.0133776013,
0.0371516608,
0.0308346841,
-0.0302536227,
-0.0170383472,
0.0076594641,
-0.0145580452,
-0.0051056687,
-0.0509806164,
0.0632865205,
-0.016913224,
-0.004066966,
-0.0389604755,
0.0060960911,
-0.0098147308,
0.0400022082,
0.0241753161,
-0.0372221731,
-0.0571349673,
0.0113416845,
-0.0075226622,
-0.0718217418,
-0.0850810036,
0.0218084529,
0.0363121293,
-0.0244055148,
0.000917302,
-0.0223401748,
0.031283617,
0.0388178937,
0.0055668717,
-0.050068751,
0.0493899956,
0.0025334721,
-0.0195125993,
0.0558140166,
0.0139981182,
-0.0058294283,
-0.1043026,
-0.0198623128,
0.0208338052,
0.0052908501,
-0.0027237558,
0.0409722514,
-0.0554302633,
-0.0285033621,
0.0134650683,
0.0468414575,
0.0152216693,
0.0021606502,
-0.0070222593,
-0.0429744944,
0.0586871244,
0.0550050475,
-0.0589103624,
0.0117609873,
0.0225651171,
-0.0639778674,
-0.0035067475,
0.0340013653,
-0.0095849233,
0.0680254772,
0.0338087752,
0.0368574075,
-0.0059327967,
0.036381539,
0.0217204411,
0.0014967446,
0.0806113482,
0.0011719102,
0.0720065832,
-0.0047520301,
0.0172688812,
0.0141401924,
0.0357625335,
-0.0620485917,
-0.0213038474,
0.0313491002,
0.0176373199,
0.0329413712,
0.058487989,
0.0002535449,
0.0128356162,
-0.0323414691,
0.0214020666,
-0.0474296063,
-0.033597935,
0.0058366749,
0.0221574064,
-0.011803641,
-0.0198472682,
0.0425849296,
0.019753674,
-0.0021481887,
0.0505247526,
0.0213498063,
0.0037853487,
-0.0603388622,
0.0364154465,
-0.0610384233,
-0.0775844827,
-0.014424582,
-0.010233487,
0.0409003012,
-0.0069632819,
0.0170458388,
0.0217134878,
-0.0156382173,
-0.0206794739,
0.0180178974,
0.002358265,
-0.0180046912,
0.0293095019,
0.0184959434,
0.0140294004,
-0.0257864837,
0.0445694104,
-0.0213373825,
-0.0047097416,
0.0152589669,
0.0299166702,
-0.036063116,
-0.0142977517,
0.0073560015,
0.0259906575,
-0.0269863084,
0.0181826912,
-0.0071250955,
-0.0602988265,
0.0370685682,
-0.065022558,
0.0321173184,
-0.0281351544,
0.0485760458,
0.001311395,
0.0122609325,
-0.0349584408,
0.0229687747,
0.0052249017,
0.0087153288,
-0.0196559876,
-0.019274855,
-7.109819624e-33,
-0.012184252,
-0.00196376,
0.0042956606,
-0.0043169078,
-0.0443963073,
0.0262678359,
-0.0268139001,
0.0448384397,
-0.0501038432,
0.0155033292,
-0.024824854,
0.0084259212,
0.0197377466,
0.071024172,
0.0118198711,
-0.0247309972,
0.0570412576,
-0.0138203418,
-0.0143372994,
0.0145484405,
-0.0097044678,
0.0263302829,
0.0507780649,
-0.0731460229,
-0.0629243255,
0.0240405872,
-0.0311853997,
0.0015541909,
0.0059641837,
0.0357815064,
-0.0361123085,
0.0547000021,
0.009731058,
-0.0757925063,
-0.0055940542,
0.0310698655,
-0.0797205567,
0.008623803,
-0.033874549,
0.0187221505,
-0.0515102558,
0.0066204583,
0.07388179,
0.0010408626,
-0.0162542984,
-0.0238839593,
0.0281821229,
0.0006541334,
-0.0292985905,
-0.0077467635,
-0.0633766875,
-0.0007871003,
-0.0223176107,
-0.0049607875,
0.0095462687,
0.0309803728,
-0.043622423,
0.0448823385,
-0.1163417324,
-0.0397911072,
0.0098559763,
0.0471326411,
0.0220057126,
0.026914835,
-0.0088572931,
0.0288955513,
0.0637019351,
-0.028089596,
-0.0972386897,
0.0038790333,
0.0545270294,
0.0613521077,
0.0733916312,
-0.0287616197,
0.0588520244,
-0.0147851994,
-0.0744302869,
-0.0059115281,
-0.0080237137,
0.0740785301,
0.025834091,
0.0052547059,
0.0045104837,
-0.0037950412,
0.013246268,
0.0017508122,
-0.049112875,
-0.0032091297,
0.0274809431,
0.0487505049,
-0.0075299777,
-0.0004914671,
0.0334054679,
-0.0243116878,
0.0567447916,
-0.0105741611,
0.0304958317,
0.0486083627,
0.0234138612,
-0.0260121766,
-0.0324857011,
-0.0228481311,
0.0090425182,
0.0143760825,
0.0237742811,
-0.0033985996,
0.0257782675,
0.0487489216,
-0.0475797728,
-0.0273121316,
-0.0277475864,
0.0289649069,
0.0247343592,
0.0629863515,
0.0078523299,
-0.0182772744,
-0.0149499085,
-0.0058024111,
-0.0595111027,
0.0280407239,
-0.0098061357,
0.0244981516,
0.0195504241,
0.0255917944,
-0.0192925707,
0.0011361325,
-0.0559764095,
-0.0304911509,
0.0167527348,
-0.0762445927,
-0.0341087505,
0.0286941398,
3.079e-7,
0.0250659566,
0.0258013215,
-0.0030684483,
0.004943518,
0.0119860647,
0.031650845,
0.0219236538,
0.0204360597,
-0.0083563961,
-0.0032050759,
-0.0095113935,
0.0315949731,
0.0231248327,
0.0010033712,
-0.1018301994,
-0.0090531325,
-0.042636402,
0.0148783373,
-0.0207986087,
0.0059959786,
0.0136356736,
0.1011566371,
-0.0061956421,
-0.0408885553,
0.0270218197,
0.0019704197,
0.0432617664,
0.0219721235,
0.0630663186,
0.0060955626,
0.0313481204,
0.0527137518,
-0.0396449491,
0.0389712304,
-0.0085662268,
0.0355654545,
-0.0053108796,
0.0445203111,
-0.0178728588,
-0.045111198,
0.0196490735,
0.0233256314,
0.0183009077,
-0.0369898751,
0.0364084095,
-0.0712791905,
-0.0399221703,
-0.0224123616,
-0.0459783748,
0.0033317704,
0.0403320268,
-0.0015927141,
0.0115996217,
-0.0037772311,
0.0385781266,
-0.0366658233,
-0.0227029566,
-0.0745251775,
-0.0109825274,
0.0101566799,
-0.054846406,
0.0266286023,
-0.0593116321,
-0.0244373344,
0.0499298349,
0.0043090875,
-0.0126883136,
2.70222871e-34,
0.0305458996,
0.0155323511,
0.0449077487,
0.0394682139,
-0.0168595091,
-0.0056244433,
0.0159350913,
-0.0289593786,
-0.0354104303,
-0.076199457,
-0.0189855322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18554v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18554v2 | Forgotten Knowledge: Examining the Citational Amnesia in NLP | 2023-05-29T18:30:34 | 2023-07-31T17:38:03 | Janvijay Singh, Mukund Rungta, Diyi Yang, Saif M. Mohammad | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DL | Citing papers is the primary method through which modern scientific writing
discusses and builds on past work. Collectively, citing a diverse set of papers
(in time and area of study) is an indicator of how widely the community is
reading. Yet, there is little work looking at broad temporal patterns of
citation. This work systematically and empirically examines: How far back in
time do we tend to go to cite papers? How has that changed over time, and what
factors correlate with this citational attention/amnesia? We chose NLP as our
domain of interest and analyzed approximately 71.5K papers to show and quantify
several key trends in citation. Notably, around 62% of cited papers are from
the immediate five years prior to publication, whereas only about 17% are more
than ten years old. Furthermore, we show that the median age and age diversity
of cited papers were steadily increasing from 1990 to 2014, but since then, the
trend has reversed, and current NLP papers have an all-time low temporal
citation diversity. Finally, we show that unlike the 1990s, the highly cited
papers in the last decade were also papers with the least citation diversity,
likely contributing to the intense (and arguably harmful) recency focus. Code,
data, and a demo are available on the project homepage. | [
0.0434441715,
0.0205862653,
-0.0044036708,
-0.0468521826,
-0.0006504948,
-0.0134949256,
0.0071374206,
0.0241146311,
0.0243241657,
-0.075222671,
0.0291078351,
0.0493414514,
0.0195097141,
-0.0263697151,
-0.0051845997,
-0.0314752162,
0.024037661,
0.0333409309,
0.0497386903,
-0.0182336252,
0.0025403365,
-0.0087521458,
-0.0113010742,
0.0300152749,
0.0384388864,
-0.0687666312,
0.0226918533,
-0.0441038758,
0.0111256018,
-0.0687369406,
0.0411184765,
0.0512024052,
0.0053707329,
0.0315553471,
0.0000018596,
-0.023197202,
0.0149036804,
0.0043832567,
-0.000466084,
0.0526221581,
0.0252597928,
0.0177226905,
0.0013448092,
-0.0259254426,
-0.0371318199,
-0.0153803872,
0.0353015736,
0.0378322303,
-0.0102423821,
-0.0109987315,
0.0174298137,
-0.0169252567,
0.046349477,
0.0367401466,
0.0326146372,
-0.0025214062,
0.0279645156,
0.0000787864,
0.0494401082,
0.0286176912,
0.0103542339,
0.0685915053,
-0.0148834428,
-0.0320985578,
0.0546009727,
0.0642818063,
0.0028852418,
0.0399313085,
-0.0091890516,
0.0030834242,
0.0406287313,
-0.0490206555,
0.0507937856,
-0.0000832478,
-0.0330896713,
0.0397980362,
-0.0565199219,
-0.0070910989,
0.004577558,
-0.0331086963,
0.0098824333,
-0.0289652292,
0.0309914015,
0.0468499772,
0.0399147794,
0.0474783294,
-0.0023795806,
-0.023543058,
0.0285425782,
0.019002758,
0.0298120137,
-0.0255591888,
0.0144149009,
0.0333730206,
0.0436673909,
-0.0087160179,
0.0589233451,
-0.0073779826,
0.0568967201,
-0.0084243361,
0.0074669444,
-0.0438365415,
-0.0113205761,
0.0405695401,
-0.0162858889,
-0.0155208604,
-0.023584377,
-0.0653641671,
0.030339079,
0.0536986366,
-0.0873055533,
-0.0416233018,
0.0075985119,
-0.0060213236,
0.03678146,
0.0270085316,
0.0002782064,
-0.0061637117,
-0.0405547395,
-0.0278904289,
-0.0554314516,
0.0309338272,
0.0057499469,
0.041504994,
-0.0175645649,
0.0390634649,
-0.0259772222,
0.0166816413,
-0.0219431873,
-0.0364134908,
-0.004028725,
-0.0134106297,
-0.0008182712,
-0.0609619804,
0.0079839546,
0.0072672553,
0.0122400848,
0.0072123702,
-0.0540385768,
-0.0442705043,
-0.0052982494,
-0.0132576721,
0.0456402935,
-0.0684769005,
-0.0119651826,
0.046431005,
0.0283710007,
-0.0749740601,
-0.015033015,
0.0289869551,
-0.05986242,
0.0033998485,
-0.0299991723,
-0.0103711234,
0.0223964918,
-0.0060131946,
0.0338439122,
0.0321323462,
0.0151598789,
-0.0753533393,
0.0085419081,
0.015995957,
0.012663886,
-0.0241628308,
0.0160860922,
0.0291729923,
0.0461562797,
-0.0171370674,
-0.0236838013,
0.0074280044,
0.006038717,
0.0015779193,
-0.0284189172,
-0.0001607338,
0.0201964621,
0.0271896627,
-0.0459115915,
0.0301915742,
0.003733281,
-0.0148344822,
0.0385936275,
-0.0251653772,
0.0176446773,
0.0105923889,
-0.0062464112,
-0.001723649,
-0.0329710729,
0.0240516681,
-0.0221086014,
0.000696824,
-0.0144973621,
0.0422618911,
0.0142995948,
-0.0370251909,
0.0239482,
0.01663577,
0.0052152728,
0.0905804262,
0.0127339466,
-0.0127155297,
0.0131790899,
0.057791993,
0.0185764171,
-0.0146956556,
0.0235261545,
-0.0181669202,
0.0504956581,
-0.0280375481,
-0.0088345194,
0.0147810243,
-0.0214031115,
0.0139142107,
-0.0139149558,
0.0075399275,
0.0016567651,
0.0143544022,
0.0399594791,
-0.0311684627,
0.0269874055,
0.017126672,
-0.0267170724,
-0.0340491608,
-0.0514727011,
0.0432263948,
-0.0459909476,
-0.0124277109,
-0.0671668723,
-0.0359325185,
0.0340867229,
0.0221521799,
-0.012431005,
0.0258632004,
0.0371552184,
-0.0104322946,
-0.004305318,
0.0237898603,
0.0317205079,
0.0268838014,
0.024309352,
-0.0760943219,
-0.0254647955,
-0.0347895995,
-0.0021439185,
-0.0052317637,
0.060945455,
-0.022418458,
0.0237976946,
0.0118164793,
0.0012995747,
-0.0456264429,
-0.0322388336,
-0.0636843964,
0.0691684708,
0.0085406005,
0.0585039482,
0.0347033106,
-0.0335988067,
-0.0109239658,
0.0009157124,
-0.0305256452,
0.0072702118,
0.0062326472,
-0.0188236237,
0.0649363846,
-0.0210612789,
-0.0674671158,
-0.0048803077,
-0.0163823087,
-0.0137694236,
0.0158076957,
-0.0047707516,
0.0226920024,
-0.0486757644,
0.0019264516,
0.0026255907,
0.0300159361,
-0.0142595489,
-0.06336537,
0.0308865421,
0.0526341461,
0.0261391848,
0.0579032339,
-0.0406920686,
-0.004847012,
-0.0461518243,
0.0574245825,
0.0462938584,
-0.0178728942,
-0.0377468541,
0.0268182233,
-0.0364189893,
-0.0207515508,
-0.0175836757,
0.050210461,
0.0209168363,
0.0358339958,
0.0290819965,
0.0660637021,
-0.0053590606,
0.0268106144,
0.0444724634,
-0.0015301114,
-0.0745292455,
-0.0047147525,
-0.0503988899,
-0.0144814532,
0.0159787498,
-0.0188793726,
0.0509845242,
0.0358511955,
-0.0195935424,
-0.0038040038,
0.0135844732,
-0.0093592536,
-0.0648344234,
-0.0014355021,
-0.0359548181,
-0.0147888483,
-0.0265778378,
0.0293133911,
0.0070744702,
0.0018182305,
-0.0021128394,
0.0343377441,
0.0048653483,
-0.0518824123,
0.0210029967,
-0.0011080345,
0.0424641743,
0.0146017084,
0.0000789664,
0.0878954306,
-0.0421517901,
-0.0530553572,
0.0011755187,
0.0014929988,
-0.0220401734,
0.0339492522,
-0.0206227973,
0.0404433347,
0.0200802404,
-0.0003446836,
-0.0141671365,
-0.0114105381,
-0.0503139682,
0.0099509489,
0.0265633315,
-0.0395054221,
-0.0722581074,
-0.0441431589,
0.0762135386,
-0.0014975268,
-0.0081682717,
-0.0543918721,
-0.0169123951,
0.040275123,
0.0291414689,
-0.0194327403,
0.0734675452,
0.0015481217,
-0.0747678578,
0.0615549125,
0.0367056467,
0.0077809929,
-0.0416914448,
-0.023327196,
0.0213159602,
-0.0823861733,
-0.017846901,
0.0099968296,
0.0433268212,
-0.0443087704,
0.00827384,
0.0309111755,
0.0408675596,
-0.0686589628,
-0.0119159305,
-0.0167425405,
0.0133251771,
0.0275842249,
-0.019552419,
-0.0606680959,
0.0118381744,
-0.0088076442,
-0.0169649888,
-0.0458192006,
-0.0484629534,
-0.0017251383,
-0.082786575,
0.0061294134,
-0.010542701,
0.0186307393,
0.0341608748,
-0.0595463663,
0.0083709741,
-0.0049445825,
-0.0195977017,
0.0411995053,
-0.0582472868,
0.018407071,
0.0258737188,
-0.0494470932,
-0.0157710724,
0.0453707688,
-0.0087708179,
0.0389276221,
-0.0092151314,
0.0763033032,
-0.0331014097,
-0.0328779668,
0.0097667146,
-0.0597141571,
-0.0099408189,
-0.0308740959,
0.0430188887,
0.0232540406,
0.0296523236,
-0.0191278383,
0.0178005658,
-0.0249773711,
-0.0101998262,
0.0241201837,
0.0539801754,
0.0109807961,
-0.0313814692,
-0.0270434786,
0.006298596,
-0.0301699191,
0.0309700761,
0.0055947574,
0.0283950251,
-0.0340144522,
-0.0408851616,
0.0416561216,
-0.0115849087,
-0.0835890472,
-0.0172423031,
-0.0525109097,
0.0274025761,
-0.0443550088,
-0.0164643116,
0.0180435367,
-0.0100535657,
0.0640428513,
0.025417693,
0.0527835339,
-0.0150137255,
-0.0726692453,
0.0241034739,
-0.0145633668,
0.0033533613,
0.0087639904,
-0.0112944655,
0.0252723824,
0.053865876,
-0.0225741751,
0.0316978656,
0.0061883647,
-0.0092033567,
0.0509184301,
-0.0176834576,
0.0226062033,
-0.0282733794,
-0.0101785511,
-0.0185409002,
0.0287672095,
0.0727928802,
-0.0080529731,
0.0083755227,
-0.0129540954,
-0.0057617882,
0.0190746617,
-0.0126505271,
-0.0449780598,
-0.0276184566,
-0.0014737386,
0.0033229426,
-0.031215325,
0.0288926158,
0.0101613086,
-0.0252026152,
0.024610851,
-0.0349937789,
0.0324262567,
0.0137555953,
-0.0610346943,
0.0324533582,
0.0171495136,
0.0195947271,
-0.0007268124,
-0.0282599255,
0.0101564946,
-0.0193356201,
0.0720927194,
0.01197273,
0.0741140097,
-0.044248987,
0.0345611982,
0.0098599037,
0.0321519226,
0.014294914,
-0.0029763319,
-0.0026982031,
-0.0311108343,
-0.0461764969,
0.0618351065,
0.0488449372,
0.0285555813,
0.0150967091,
-0.0385704562,
-0.0257043615,
-0.0379487127,
-0.134710595,
-0.0208741352,
0.0450232439,
-0.0808783546,
0.056899637,
-0.0328292921,
0.0757594779,
-0.0350676663,
-0.0086289858,
-0.0148425438,
0.0180413052,
0.0448445491,
0.0080724331,
0.0068306671,
0.0128114903,
-0.0213149041,
0.0011592624,
0.0629501417,
0.0089779161,
0.0214714482,
0.0349005982,
-0.0013654348,
0.0203391295,
-0.0421449281,
-0.0655039474,
0.0336929113,
0.0052161892,
-0.0150015689,
-0.0623352751,
0.0053283954,
0.0278994553,
-0.0667281672,
0.0168373678,
-0.0345831662,
-0.0005528924,
0.0024715778,
0.0092589427,
-0.0332267694,
-0.0440570563,
0.0907528549,
-0.0190449841,
-0.0230073947,
-0.0581739731,
-6.155707594e-33,
0.0387748405,
-0.0254076235,
-0.0246362407,
-0.0165455919,
-0.0450010598,
0.0304299388,
-0.0558308065,
0.024217302,
-0.0614099056,
0.0215500724,
-0.0579745956,
0.0089612436,
-0.0002891588,
-0.0087228324,
0.0850665197,
-0.0028727341,
0.0147591243,
0.0192719214,
0.0068343673,
-0.0111952173,
0.0624315552,
0.0233955272,
0.0832318366,
-0.0941702724,
0.0938600749,
0.0166974906,
0.0068405624,
-0.0305690132,
0.0664745346,
0.0052407808,
-0.0238884687,
0.0491719581,
0.0135878772,
-0.089306511,
-0.0254291501,
-0.0206109136,
-0.0814638659,
-0.0158734415,
0.0482421592,
-0.0124754952,
-0.0044265855,
-0.0309124161,
0.0243819561,
0.0130466213,
-0.0533667766,
-0.0258569177,
0.0852803737,
-0.0202110857,
-0.0299070254,
-0.060758464,
-0.0071041682,
0.0066503235,
-0.0139578972,
0.0762527362,
-0.0272936095,
0.0234798286,
-0.0108846836,
0.101257734,
-0.1256837547,
0.0171300452,
-0.0228257198,
0.0312991813,
-0.0269868914,
-0.0491851456,
0.0460313149,
0.0741256624,
-0.008353292,
0.0360600911,
0.0316792801,
-0.0185428225,
0.0091310497,
-0.0015939673,
0.0060951584,
0.0278478842,
0.0725967437,
-0.0218630135,
-0.0104831289,
-0.0071706823,
0.0279782638,
0.0618921258,
0.0502087772,
-0.0014336831,
-0.020715123,
-0.0145352222,
-0.0118529778,
-0.0129559319,
0.0116224205,
-0.0290687066,
-0.0515173972,
-0.0095625827,
-0.0023199001,
0.002650796,
-0.0041486896,
-0.0178253166,
-0.0896082446,
0.0347275026,
-0.0070286752,
0.0439184271,
0.0238908958,
-0.0048743901,
-0.0695592761,
-0.0038104169,
-0.0410453491,
0.0512211546,
0.0311761182,
-0.0140174814,
0.0214916375,
-0.0060041253,
-0.0502171591,
-0.0475980975,
-0.0108240973,
-0.0102387881,
0.0268675052,
-0.0398015715,
-0.0037505655,
0.0489075705,
0.0374307558,
-0.0039883261,
0.0729718432,
0.0254625119,
0.0123963738,
0.0158172455,
-0.0086848158,
0.004574012,
-0.0051613827,
-0.0493482985,
-0.0472520217,
0.0992577523,
0.0202182885,
-0.0263278987,
-0.0097319381,
-0.0598022453,
2.642e-7,
0.0508762263,
0.0386974849,
-0.0234011393,
-0.0377643928,
0.0456249155,
0.0100713195,
0.0048408983,
-0.0001441634,
0.0124754356,
0.001321348,
-0.0461751297,
-0.0318129137,
-0.011630985,
0.0041564312,
-0.0993687883,
-0.0578320138,
-0.071146369,
-0.0266260412,
-0.038223356,
0.0162801333,
-0.0436712429,
-0.003481237,
0.0076043257,
0.0339911282,
-0.052013889,
-0.0423542261,
0.046279572,
-0.0435635671,
0.0289239548,
0.0157019719,
0.0258305948,
0.0110513922,
0.041012127,
0.0038504265,
-0.0245668832,
-0.0289176106,
-0.0250048488,
-0.0011400917,
0.0296502057,
-0.0126692187,
0.0179529581,
-0.0208838098,
0.0244010743,
-0.0549941845,
0.017009208,
-0.0132683665,
-0.0498834625,
-0.0355242901,
-0.0816564485,
0.0083752424,
0.024314791,
0.0195110012,
-0.0309069827,
0.0196159389,
-0.0733173266,
0.026989609,
-0.0270142704,
-0.0427766107,
-0.0428087041,
0.0660976171,
-0.000007121,
-0.066850096,
0.0140871126,
-0.0500896014,
0.0011634643,
-0.0418024622,
0.0390401408,
1.820022266e-34,
0.0331952013,
-0.014681044,
-0.0008758328,
0.0538364165,
0.002052746,
0.0083143068,
-0.0033855499,
0.0103475014,
0.024802668,
0.0050211158,
0.0105276778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.00007v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.00007v1 | Datasets for Portuguese Legal Semantic Textual Similarity: Comparing weak supervision and an annotation process approaches | 2023-05-29T18:27:10 | 2023-05-29T18:27:10 | Daniel da Silva Junior, Paulo Roberto dos S. Corval, Aline Paes, Daniel de Oliveira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The Brazilian judiciary has a large workload, resulting in a long time to
finish legal proceedings. Brazilian National Council of Justice has established
in Resolution 469/2022 formal guidance for document and process digitalization
opening up the possibility of using automatic techniques to help with everyday
tasks in the legal field, particularly in a large number of texts yielded on
the routine of law procedures. Notably, Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques
allow for processing and extracting useful information from textual data,
potentially speeding up the process. However, datasets from the legal domain
required by several AI techniques are scarce and difficult to obtain as they
need labels from experts. To address this challenge, this article contributes
with four datasets from the legal domain, two with documents and metadata but
unlabeled, and another two labeled with a heuristic aiming at its use in
textual semantic similarity tasks. Also, to evaluate the effectiveness of the
proposed heuristic label process, this article presents a small ground truth
dataset generated from domain expert annotations. The analysis of ground truth
labels highlights that semantic analysis of domain text can be challenging even
for domain experts. Also, the comparison between ground truth and heuristic
labels shows that heuristic labels are useful. | [
0.0452850349,
-0.0148758376,
-0.0078916503,
0.0039702817,
-0.0547395647,
0.0393236205,
0.0064044693,
0.0153588578,
-0.0163764767,
-0.0692192614,
-0.0016548425,
0.0335193649,
-0.028565865,
-0.0355401561,
-0.0233283211,
-0.0305143595,
0.0037153717,
0.0418460555,
0.011246454,
0.007877836,
0.029542366,
0.0195883419,
0.0048139263,
0.0052203098,
-0.0340068787,
0.0313351676,
-0.0020140591,
-0.0306498632,
0.0036292584,
0.0173125993,
-0.0271123722,
0.0556234159,
-0.0156970154,
0.0239434484,
0.0000019105,
-0.0613051541,
-0.0517022796,
-0.0201909449,
-0.0034362804,
-0.0285843126,
0.0483777858,
-0.0080015613,
-0.0129899681,
-0.0238264594,
-0.0604727827,
0.0067384583,
0.0059048994,
-0.0298551787,
0.0268905573,
0.0639686659,
-0.0344013833,
-0.0547466464,
0.0100053353,
-0.0007071608,
0.017609477,
-0.0398512222,
-0.0102538783,
0.0725046843,
0.0266919918,
0.0091488734,
0.0501100086,
0.0090054255,
-0.0030411785,
-0.0302322432,
-0.0421708189,
-0.0244527012,
-0.0272382125,
-0.0043901145,
0.030629782,
0.0002092529,
0.0772604495,
-0.0558150783,
0.0244193748,
0.0018402067,
0.0350895822,
0.0268180203,
-0.031880118,
0.0821903422,
-0.0484517813,
0.0225665253,
0.0851128921,
0.0533763617,
-0.0008040656,
0.0006740235,
-0.0104524139,
0.0731347054,
-0.0064553004,
-0.0430824794,
0.0562567562,
0.0091995513,
0.0240033232,
-0.0522645377,
0.0245531742,
0.0380248651,
-0.0017383249,
0.017203765,
-0.040945556,
-0.0763834044,
0.0543826073,
-0.0708538219,
0.0125512332,
-0.0030029358,
-0.017978495,
0.084661305,
-0.0391111337,
-0.0316047855,
0.0000397376,
0.0410692245,
-0.0273402054,
-0.0697357282,
-0.068427749,
-0.0247419402,
-0.0469560511,
0.0645020977,
-0.0604357682,
0.0264372211,
-0.0122660426,
0.0175329745,
-0.027661182,
0.0218733922,
-0.0192840192,
-0.0386577807,
0.0007478244,
-0.022121951,
-0.0775018036,
-0.0558570288,
-0.0780303776,
0.053175848,
-0.0567287765,
-0.0012640501,
0.0545985326,
0.0321902819,
0.0138734831,
-0.0097031193,
0.0119425422,
0.0463014096,
-0.0008471663,
-0.0122689893,
-0.0490713753,
-0.0768808275,
0.004153267,
-0.0594803467,
-0.028148694,
-0.0693897977,
0.0169054177,
-0.021453863,
-0.0245221183,
-0.0525233783,
-0.0073608775,
0.0358059853,
0.0271911211,
0.0644601211,
-0.0646994859,
-0.0156626105,
0.020406073,
-0.0009241162,
0.000656661,
-0.0247755107,
-0.025032023,
0.0201606173,
0.0430737846,
0.0301439203,
0.0162776727,
0.0099811777,
0.003350111,
-0.0072959978,
0.0171787404,
0.0305116046,
0.0161105767,
0.0216176771,
0.0279048029,
0.0307630729,
-0.0195793696,
0.0173420403,
-0.0096329432,
0.0568573736,
-0.0235159993,
0.0614724383,
0.0416307189,
-0.022768734,
0.0326798335,
0.0135687487,
-0.0134905446,
-0.0305822045,
-0.0292264968,
-0.0012710745,
-0.064142637,
-0.0174824018,
-0.0215785615,
-0.0566320047,
0.0103673544,
0.0226203445,
-0.0148675367,
-0.0360204615,
0.0449518114,
0.0406656899,
0.0018484422,
-0.0023835718,
0.0017308426,
-0.0540311299,
-0.0641942471,
-0.008184745,
0.0197961219,
0.0104975794,
0.03301543,
-0.0709336549,
-0.0100910636,
0.0082952352,
0.0529102869,
0.0247106999,
0.029508207,
-0.0403863527,
-0.0637027621,
-0.0405035801,
-0.0504904538,
-0.00799884,
-0.0099874688,
0.0267864279,
-0.0476468801,
0.0204807967,
0.0526519045,
-0.062436305,
-0.014591244,
0.0954651982,
-0.0164181255,
-0.0110219121,
0.007903303,
0.0261135995,
0.0150450207,
0.0478725135,
0.0362694934,
-0.0225329287,
0.0266765356,
-0.0031150866,
0.0023134085,
0.013257266,
0.0253496114,
0.059357103,
0.0538172983,
-0.074930273,
-0.0156602096,
0.0040145842,
-0.0141929295,
-0.0054237535,
-0.0347246304,
-0.0118098678,
0.0141259059,
-0.0319894478,
0.0391468666,
-0.0232322235,
-0.0122649083,
-0.0128806904,
0.0488494188,
0.0391383283,
-0.0037032107,
-0.017157929,
-0.0120735094,
0.0615572929,
-0.0071354243,
-0.0001845654,
-0.0541467033,
-0.0014660385,
-0.0164760072,
0.0233486518,
0.0217313226,
-0.0110368654,
-0.0177179053,
-0.0863828361,
0.0211817194,
-0.0198273752,
0.0010024809,
0.0373735093,
-0.0152469222,
-0.0108294152,
-0.016771974,
-0.0007277236,
-0.0134804789,
-0.0394767486,
-0.0316683091,
0.0291016456,
-0.0008476945,
-0.0049565304,
-0.0194769688,
0.0142138014,
-0.0200209301,
0.0074162902,
0.0728702843,
-0.0645330176,
-0.0191945191,
0.0639038607,
-0.0304339267,
0.0050386847,
-0.0281341709,
0.0355179273,
-0.0078332908,
0.02732802,
-0.0246726871,
0.0126656936,
0.0096713351,
-0.0072650341,
0.0584299825,
0.0367969647,
-0.0261649545,
-0.012981425,
-0.0010263387,
0.0396378264,
-0.0466432236,
-0.0106586199,
0.0687447712,
-0.0132099418,
0.0088684373,
0.0290385317,
0.0122768758,
0.0257417317,
-0.0157434493,
0.0039096465,
-0.0081577208,
-0.0193605442,
-0.0083135394,
0.0651086718,
0.0404702052,
-0.0050829821,
0.0492480025,
0.0022156928,
0.0700543821,
-0.0793116838,
-0.0200906247,
-0.0288169757,
0.0912474841,
-0.0123708779,
0.0114779752,
-0.0351315364,
-0.0099788941,
0.0413452052,
0.0112985978,
0.1004278511,
0.0143039618,
0.0395203158,
-0.0408025458,
0.0542086512,
-0.0277539156,
-0.0521898903,
-0.0076987618,
-0.0147441356,
-0.0173413381,
0.0186109021,
0.0293647218,
0.0620851368,
-0.0279895384,
0.039303232,
-0.0301698148,
0.0666095391,
0.0191328246,
-0.0381252579,
-0.0375594385,
0.0335748531,
-0.0165990256,
-0.0708711892,
-0.0233629085,
0.0187836587,
-0.0020976388,
-0.0106410682,
-0.033152923,
-0.0139369909,
-0.0078028282,
-0.0126181999,
-0.0320484787,
-0.0796541125,
-0.0324537866,
-0.0204279236,
-0.0385788158,
-0.0186747108,
0.017555071,
0.0696921051,
0.0555828959,
-0.0403327867,
-0.0097641964,
-0.0498394072,
-0.039170254,
0.029416224,
0.0238192547,
-0.1005254909,
0.0204006154,
-0.0017947768,
-0.0025941976,
-0.0415367633,
-0.0268651564,
0.0040244274,
-0.0506678037,
0.0541804247,
-0.0224957839,
-0.0422784314,
-0.0218042713,
-0.0062290989,
-0.0088354433,
-0.0259946343,
-0.0386289917,
-0.0042193821,
-0.0035282637,
-0.0006792197,
0.0388613157,
-0.0245750304,
-0.0230602715,
-0.0262662582,
-0.0397462659,
0.0256040245,
0.0222491268,
0.0380341113,
-0.0094987629,
0.0220856164,
0.0608018413,
0.0172252133,
0.0030008904,
-0.0149067789,
0.0428037122,
-0.0106334575,
0.0301482882,
-0.0471027195,
0.0387518518,
0.0258747991,
-0.0093879383,
0.0884907767,
0.054475382,
-0.0494913943,
0.0046607913,
-0.03071291,
-0.0515926294,
-0.0295372494,
0.0203270875,
0.0327557512,
0.0295461603,
-0.0240159594,
-0.0074588545,
-0.0150936702,
0.0009275099,
-0.010129232,
0.021725947,
-0.0462317578,
-0.0315093435,
-0.0529259369,
-0.0368220359,
0.0010820379,
0.0281583276,
0.0321222395,
0.008961034,
0.0195019525,
-0.0309525542,
-0.0491509102,
-0.029621128,
-0.0420227312,
-0.0017957757,
0.0196269732,
0.0009104151,
0.0299846772,
0.0502765439,
-0.0319247581,
-0.0310243722,
-0.0045037339,
0.0146058258,
-0.013704801,
-0.0461187139,
0.0155065991,
0.0256559085,
-0.0567477085,
-0.0446538292,
0.0177590251,
0.0270266589,
-0.0368460231,
-0.017061552,
0.0125014586,
-0.0386927426,
-0.0168928299,
0.0007532658,
0.0061544962,
0.0719024464,
0.020726664,
0.0016025744,
-0.0334624052,
-0.025169665,
0.0447371565,
0.0545313545,
0.0188957807,
0.010269261,
-0.0216205381,
-0.0297893658,
0.0005708268,
-0.0150191365,
-0.0233906154,
0.0205854941,
0.0291830245,
0.0059604077,
-0.0124273915,
-0.0054999529,
0.0575935319,
-0.0455197133,
0.0202484764,
-0.0223151464,
0.0240022205,
0.0372123271,
0.0771298409,
-0.0499163866,
-0.0178137068,
0.0043720389,
-0.0037961539,
0.0037692725,
0.0649880543,
-0.0384022184,
0.0221435651,
0.048269473,
0.0000836425,
-0.0051759784,
0.0494856089,
0.0145989666,
0.0158867408,
-0.0513780005,
0.0298906229,
0.0711504146,
0.0040123179,
-0.0126302065,
-0.0409694239,
-0.0089020897,
0.0388253406,
-0.0025913303,
0.0166246612,
-0.0146223176,
0.0143969171,
-0.0131656509,
-0.0305517055,
0.034183085,
0.0201753825,
-0.0195942521,
0.0204926133,
-0.0027361845,
-0.0476774685,
-0.0214156546,
-0.0319516137,
0.0196850281,
0.0043701013,
-0.0141274789,
-0.0945970565,
-0.0678309947,
0.0011860663,
-0.0280893147,
0.010633965,
-0.0287106615,
0.0332018398,
0.0296838488,
0.0536225587,
0.0169547927,
-0.0237384848,
-0.0303349216,
0.0316851772,
-0.0347221233,
-0.0066991677,
-0.02863832,
-4.940558675e-33,
-0.0350439586,
-0.0535633862,
0.0372759551,
0.0314347669,
-0.0088441232,
-0.0188686065,
-0.0052395104,
-0.0459062755,
-0.0042479546,
0.0395916849,
-0.0048241564,
0.0089253774,
0.0324336737,
-0.0402055159,
0.0126980664,
0.0084119225,
-0.0144504029,
-0.0100785876,
-0.0351639986,
-0.0175279509,
-0.010509829,
-0.0195639469,
0.0331369303,
-0.1256585866,
0.0555244386,
0.0023848794,
-0.0049208612,
-0.0270723421,
-0.0050272681,
0.0711278692,
0.0049400637,
0.0028428207,
0.0312775299,
-0.0236321203,
-0.0060782158,
0.0362370089,
-0.0496755242,
-0.0441708229,
0.0136931334,
-0.0002559306,
0.0401630104,
-0.0319607817,
0.009806348,
-0.0026544032,
-0.0337743238,
0.0481865741,
0.0875967816,
-0.0584518537,
-0.0361525118,
-0.0824001729,
-0.0780333355,
0.0614878722,
-0.0160299968,
0.0315191187,
0.0560124815,
0.0423726439,
-0.0163969547,
-0.0045087957,
-0.0675134957,
0.0134324888,
-0.0423759334,
-0.0071230144,
0.0350852348,
-0.0640053824,
0.0132396827,
0.0254689511,
-0.0082403636,
-0.0120683368,
-0.0071110716,
0.0192486271,
0.0197205096,
0.0426667184,
0.0211344827,
0.0578325018,
0.0256553106,
-0.0137432516,
-0.0358268842,
0.0208094735,
-0.0045409687,
-0.0036238309,
0.0131351361,
-0.0346622132,
-0.0588490218,
0.0022277941,
-0.0414903127,
-0.0237350054,
0.0131086605,
-0.0089861201,
0.0052362131,
-0.0423678495,
0.0346464776,
0.0082082609,
-0.0400397554,
-0.024382446,
0.0158898309,
-0.0129363844,
-0.010145423,
0.0542885251,
-0.0261503831,
-0.0006111333,
-0.0458131433,
-0.049143631,
0.0104847671,
0.0476873145,
0.0283049569,
-0.02890913,
0.0509245247,
-0.0647044778,
-0.0268973149,
0.0137146888,
0.0253790282,
-0.0126885716,
-0.0040328256,
-0.0105262166,
0.0024280057,
0.0486876667,
0.0468525998,
0.0117226932,
0.0428475067,
-0.0143427216,
-0.0274533089,
-0.0270011425,
0.0267278291,
-0.0232181735,
-0.0043356288,
0.0099945944,
-0.0159048755,
0.0314716771,
0.0135013107,
0.0339102633,
0.0156932715,
0.0374284051,
2.549e-7,
0.0629011542,
0.0411526039,
0.0123751611,
-0.023194639,
-0.0179372281,
0.0214783959,
0.0554041304,
0.0034175473,
-0.0243170317,
-0.0055658515,
0.0839340538,
-0.037770398,
0.0603388324,
0.065592438,
-0.0547750145,
-0.0311525594,
-0.0323163308,
-0.0901586488,
-0.0863770992,
0.0344031267,
0.0069922959,
0.0592305027,
0.0535060912,
-0.0226555299,
-0.0395680629,
-0.0108637968,
0.0091421148,
0.0124439411,
-0.0030542871,
0.0058186785,
0.0845363215,
-0.0351733752,
-0.0233410969,
0.0774744675,
0.0349851288,
0.0417430103,
-0.0258347392,
0.0311146118,
-0.0230442677,
0.0987240523,
-0.0131941196,
-0.0858837515,
0.0292088799,
-0.0223089773,
0.0349965356,
0.0099382084,
0.0024052244,
-0.0114505813,
-0.0059300419,
0.0014185732,
0.0063117719,
0.0352746658,
-0.0397589877,
0.0027025836,
0.0387028717,
-0.0105291335,
-0.0089492137,
-0.0754516944,
0.0516154952,
0.0513442159,
0.0166974831,
0.020923011,
0.0142546967,
0.0344472975,
0.0693066493,
-0.0807983056,
0.0598215163,
1.740731383e-34,
0.0007557429,
0.001773053,
0.0031092237,
-0.0062272744,
0.0350581631,
0.0632436946,
-0.0285791978,
0.0318082608,
-0.0263817888,
-0.0198571496,
0.060257826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18294v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18294v1 | Transformer Language Models Handle Word Frequency in Prediction Head | 2023-05-29T17:59:15 | 2023-05-29T17:59:15 | Goro Kobayashi, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Sho Yokoi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prediction head is a crucial component of Transformer language models.
Despite its direct impact on prediction, this component has often been
overlooked in analyzing Transformers. In this study, we investigate the inner
workings of the prediction head, specifically focusing on bias parameters. Our
experiments with BERT and GPT-2 models reveal that the biases in their word
prediction heads play a significant role in the models' ability to reflect word
frequency in a corpus, aligning with the logit adjustment method commonly used
in long-tailed learning. We also quantify the effect of controlling the biases
in practical auto-regressive text generation scenarios; under a particular
setting, more diverse text can be generated without compromising text quality. | [
0.0174260903,
0.0452269875,
-0.0199206918,
0.0052699069,
-0.01153774,
-0.0055469652,
0.0021501619,
0.0082788756,
-0.03953816,
-0.0107693328,
-0.0037713489,
-0.0940862894,
0.0370808132,
0.0150227761,
0.0304542128,
-0.0427275747,
0.0285177678,
-0.0171207171,
-0.0123317027,
-0.0141791655,
0.0325965956,
0.0099650864,
0.0282621533,
0.057055071,
-0.0402355492,
0.0219036676,
0.022478994,
0.0004603765,
-0.0082061067,
0.0010832264,
0.0254365448,
0.0859759003,
0.0018673096,
0.0727920905,
0.0000016317,
-0.0412017964,
-0.028549308,
0.0142446645,
0.020884322,
0.0175033379,
0.0195146948,
-0.029162243,
-0.0231109262,
0.0678144991,
0.0019276827,
-0.0082214624,
0.0639090091,
0.0390867665,
0.0091804666,
0.0313598812,
-0.0206459891,
-0.0153543008,
0.0313101262,
-0.0478104092,
0.0426587798,
0.0257937219,
0.0238428228,
-0.0458447374,
-0.0639455244,
-0.0369259417,
-0.0516583696,
0.0025970188,
-0.0083258366,
0.0231797844,
-0.0170285497,
0.0514343232,
-0.0390496328,
-0.0388587788,
-0.00130411,
0.0015739467,
-0.0185409617,
-0.0435392335,
0.0068513383,
0.0090964502,
-0.017555492,
0.0254195873,
-0.0374670513,
0.0312415473,
0.0078833159,
0.0029130362,
0.017537944,
-0.0091660833,
-0.0070503321,
-0.0122656589,
-0.0490279496,
0.0537002496,
0.0493965745,
-0.0358901918,
-0.0076679545,
0.0370658897,
-0.009685968,
-0.0176847968,
-0.0193896964,
0.0028386666,
-0.0087469993,
0.0226662774,
-0.0279393271,
-0.0412008204,
0.0126462681,
-0.0255757663,
0.0421333797,
0.0284583382,
0.0003525153,
-0.0292380862,
-0.0211018398,
0.0317962803,
0.0155987162,
-0.0131201828,
-0.0172521174,
-0.0128574176,
-0.0015177752,
-0.0232786518,
-0.0603245683,
-0.0161038991,
0.0208200924,
0.0012274922,
-0.0492761657,
-0.0049636019,
0.0475603789,
-0.0517987385,
0.0410066769,
0.0071671596,
-0.100887537,
-0.0153766358,
-0.0035413804,
0.0613560155,
-0.0005315335,
-0.0059179547,
-0.0010262396,
-0.0583210327,
-0.0240620896,
0.023826573,
0.0219472498,
-0.0478662811,
-0.0160446838,
0.0371412113,
0.0076823728,
-0.025527779,
0.0132738799,
-0.0026200421,
-0.0543438457,
-0.0408099405,
0.0136403274,
-0.0591001213,
-0.0127593409,
0.0427887775,
0.0178006031,
0.0081532849,
0.0011679379,
0.0195997879,
-0.0264611728,
0.0027643037,
-0.0058976933,
0.0242581405,
0.04119974,
-0.0121306172,
0.0041118846,
0.0720958635,
0.0596579611,
0.0303153042,
0.0107181473,
-0.021203123,
0.0047380994,
0.0751105919,
0.0185418427,
0.0127217919,
-0.0230998006,
-0.054683622,
0.0090186,
0.0029925245,
0.0460053422,
0.0776593834,
-0.0062559173,
0.0083011976,
0.0827768594,
0.0220183469,
0.0562013723,
0.0421237312,
0.0329054557,
0.007621997,
0.0020039061,
0.0431473069,
0.0003167744,
0.0002449508,
-0.0148905022,
0.0173953194,
0.0008474551,
0.071847938,
-0.0105829025,
-0.0253773294,
-0.0054169139,
-0.0032789872,
-0.0072133127,
-0.0689883605,
0.0521135703,
0.0260260105,
-0.0507710949,
0.104117848,
0.033836592,
-0.0526812561,
0.0311765578,
-0.0386219397,
0.0068852743,
0.0144196479,
0.0406040065,
0.0320870019,
0.0032667045,
-0.0009020139,
-0.024902897,
0.0694144368,
0.0236275196,
0.023723755,
0.0023698218,
-0.0563885011,
-0.0161623769,
0.0578179657,
0.0279882234,
0.0367128551,
0.0090569537,
0.0032262874,
0.0441946425,
-0.0591656789,
-0.0424424857,
0.029698588,
-0.0496840626,
-0.0251793601,
-0.0142465541,
-0.014218648,
-0.0072838143,
-0.0281645171,
-0.0428135246,
0.0335470401,
0.0162939709,
-0.0186857376,
-0.0153138088,
0.0194219667,
-0.0380002744,
0.0080747427,
0.0251888428,
-0.0535926856,
0.062480133,
0.0348436944,
0.0236204639,
-0.0305484198,
0.0002463743,
-0.0846353397,
0.0761955604,
-0.0490479432,
0.027638996,
-0.0151799945,
0.0286460798,
-0.0326513276,
0.0405974239,
-0.0014041029,
0.0170731861,
0.004404549,
-0.0313943103,
0.025640551,
-0.0157919675,
-0.0334046967,
0.0178393349,
-0.0127523206,
0.0092569096,
0.077647917,
-0.0251204912,
-0.0112892315,
-0.0618931912,
-0.0580952987,
-0.0152699528,
-0.0391420275,
-0.0045287572,
-0.0014781663,
0.0082950694,
-0.0190612935,
0.0280423854,
-0.0411730856,
-0.0111761838,
0.0204301439,
0.028782608,
0.0195072107,
-0.0137313306,
-0.0241147671,
-0.0330496393,
-0.0177571345,
-0.0208474509,
0.0432816669,
0.0229137409,
-0.0039076386,
-0.0591138899,
0.0122203864,
-0.022563722,
-0.0107065104,
0.0088401511,
-0.0569859594,
0.0002094475,
0.0005389962,
0.1138446629,
0.004443598,
0.0704360008,
0.0223146118,
0.0268135611,
0.0079204235,
-0.0258844085,
-0.0295319092,
-0.0736267939,
-0.0226195585,
-0.0393649489,
-0.0563195124,
0.009812559,
0.0993871614,
0.0357847624,
-0.0032411281,
-0.0808569118,
0.0077581736,
-0.0259155873,
-0.0043288497,
0.0380933844,
0.0029969625,
-0.047920499,
0.0373256244,
0.0105599239,
-0.079995282,
0.055498492,
-0.0477082506,
0.0112230247,
-0.0303669367,
0.0339005031,
-0.0390293114,
-0.0131687587,
0.0334405452,
0.0214062687,
0.0164717231,
-0.0159399342,
-0.0748322755,
0.0337390192,
0.0419315882,
-0.0401776023,
0.0322451293,
0.0025946847,
-0.0102920067,
-0.0007178367,
-0.0217597,
-0.0406399742,
-0.0352183059,
-0.004428382,
-0.01094779,
0.0878892019,
-0.0414085425,
-0.0424514003,
0.0096012186,
0.0191056672,
0.0359160565,
-0.0319297016,
-0.016098164,
0.0062613403,
0.0129009262,
0.0900066942,
-0.0178079642,
0.0312176514,
-0.0496473201,
-0.005194115,
-0.0071251555,
0.0340708233,
0.0320978947,
-0.0095656188,
-0.0279795583,
0.0353102945,
-0.024353208,
-0.0207415316,
0.0411710069,
0.0368580334,
-0.0042763939,
-0.0187759344,
0.1238295808,
0.013106606,
-0.0309512522,
0.0185887404,
-0.0056646438,
0.1138330027,
-0.0077261948,
0.0302392058,
-0.0566529669,
0.0129582062,
-0.0103581501,
0.0232268572,
0.0019695389,
-0.0147855179,
-0.0231003445,
-0.135928914,
0.0106979841,
0.0063309791,
0.0032572492,
0.0074195415,
-0.0345767364,
-0.0196580514,
-0.0365839452,
0.0014722468,
0.0048238966,
-0.0466726124,
0.012253141,
0.0622938089,
-0.0605258942,
-0.0224011317,
-0.0211473554,
-0.0293565765,
0.011529942,
0.0778015107,
0.0167815704,
-0.0388358235,
-0.029318342,
-0.0050278595,
-0.0482968017,
0.004274426,
-0.0079110656,
0.062848486,
-0.0112400353,
-0.0046736589,
-0.0263046455,
0.0189767461,
0.0162065402,
0.0088657299,
-0.0148563245,
0.0397033058,
0.0103642736,
-0.0576098673,
-0.0099458937,
0.0136530735,
-0.0057694847,
0.0709095746,
0.0341096222,
-0.0557824746,
-0.0182472859,
-0.0283079948,
0.0355540887,
0.0003028362,
-0.0439918637,
-0.0051183878,
0.0105240569,
-0.0604921766,
-0.0815625787,
-0.008852697,
0.0070765112,
0.0383849591,
0.0145922303,
0.011395216,
-0.0138486195,
-0.0005439955,
-0.0157582145,
-0.0079749702,
0.0092814434,
-0.0007734037,
-0.0964623019,
-0.0080913147,
0.0300082304,
-0.0354679748,
-0.0339934155,
-0.0048363241,
-0.0887996927,
-0.076483123,
0.0507517122,
0.0264157671,
0.034777686,
0.0364824086,
0.0213673133,
-0.0591290258,
0.0300737564,
0.054213386,
0.0068492917,
0.0334362164,
0.008563986,
-0.0240562391,
-0.0171272699,
0.0194258001,
-0.0258368254,
0.054027576,
-0.0126691833,
0.0317899622,
0.0137658874,
-0.0500434004,
0.0165773649,
0.0029280246,
0.0659217685,
-0.0785895362,
0.0239412542,
-0.0309822205,
-0.0084280195,
-0.0030890002,
0.0265023988,
-0.0291079096,
0.0084602926,
0.0399233364,
0.0063132495,
-0.0344738439,
0.0331495702,
-0.0339553542,
0.0031788384,
-0.0400601402,
0.0057943608,
-0.0462689698,
-0.0095125539,
0.035985861,
-0.0079909498,
0.0027740449,
-0.0130728818,
0.0141384182,
0.0495923012,
0.0220074132,
0.0442041047,
0.0041487799,
0.0238553546,
-0.0030609185,
-0.0146713806,
-0.0722003058,
-0.0347502083,
-0.0646465644,
-0.0094805053,
-0.0154942898,
-0.0497758985,
0.0746562332,
-0.0485524312,
0.0295282695,
-0.0251672193,
0.0035359508,
-0.0013720962,
0.0079833856,
0.0287822038,
-0.0192699693,
-0.0385292284,
-0.0168929324,
0.1140926331,
0.068924509,
0.0193779115,
-0.004160075,
-0.0128196133,
-0.0126933651,
-0.0360727124,
0.0257364921,
-0.0568990149,
0.0011008315,
-0.0055763219,
-0.0749958083,
-0.0464145094,
0.0461957343,
-0.0257390942,
0.0563823767,
-0.0617494881,
0.0065589384,
0.0532174073,
-0.0576152839,
0.0100166099,
-0.0271726437,
-0.0105145499,
0.0005331573,
0.0201600064,
-0.0056177494,
-6.047338402e-33,
-0.0350444205,
-0.0197331384,
-0.0048611895,
0.0089964177,
0.0034416455,
-0.0012876927,
-0.0186367072,
-0.0018531334,
-0.00846784,
0.0136911133,
-0.023806287,
-0.0001839392,
0.0269277543,
0.031776417,
-0.0038529346,
0.0038277949,
0.053707011,
-0.00046789,
-0.0532475673,
0.0120374449,
0.0101767331,
0.0531240366,
0.0587405749,
0.0143972971,
-0.0062385681,
-0.0110714165,
-0.0135401683,
-0.0252664238,
0.0216067377,
0.0517115146,
-0.025935214,
0.0506912582,
0.0085580256,
-0.0482539758,
-0.0197238848,
0.0168689135,
-0.0275448263,
-0.0219257008,
0.01713649,
-0.0057047713,
0.0324097015,
0.0305792335,
0.0145551302,
-0.0206464678,
-0.0691663921,
-0.0289390683,
0.0524478815,
-0.0059833745,
-0.057982564,
-0.0513544455,
-0.0629250854,
0.0419287384,
0.0204623248,
-0.0184473787,
-0.0158758294,
0.0566411279,
0.0265240818,
0.0162260327,
-0.0350759365,
0.0362739787,
0.0375370048,
0.0710920021,
0.025666872,
0.0324217342,
-0.0185832139,
0.0540630482,
0.0185330641,
0.0263795424,
-0.0058859279,
-0.0345440805,
0.0591875724,
0.0071408022,
0.0410161018,
0.0250896569,
0.0756922215,
-0.0427174568,
-0.0249893032,
0.0509534106,
0.0159007926,
0.0433936901,
0.0459100418,
-0.0354550444,
-0.043803148,
-0.0443039984,
-0.0525260419,
-0.0237870384,
-0.0009479275,
-0.0183942746,
0.0068388009,
0.0326437838,
-0.0196747426,
-0.0069320532,
0.0350602157,
-0.0260315649,
-0.0129150022,
0.0319223367,
-0.0511650369,
-0.0027495811,
-0.0262271129,
0.0456676185,
-0.0367366411,
-0.0195483807,
0.0330093242,
0.0629060566,
-0.0207797978,
0.0068169795,
0.0243734363,
0.0403174795,
-0.0898309052,
0.0002527784,
-0.0333496518,
0.0003510996,
0.0288379565,
0.0110832248,
0.0262344554,
-0.0292352196,
0.0018323535,
-0.000265087,
0.0099004703,
0.0022969588,
-0.0180624109,
0.0134663032,
0.0363331661,
0.0167016219,
-0.0364831612,
-0.0119361058,
-0.0255421642,
0.0029450299,
0.0577564798,
-0.0526103973,
-0.0313147344,
-0.0254907906,
2.428e-7,
0.039134644,
0.0613432489,
0.0265910104,
-0.0010395751,
0.0123808309,
0.0024221437,
0.0048522106,
0.0525136366,
0.0245297644,
0.0202119276,
-0.013836056,
-0.024630934,
0.0558775701,
0.0096060904,
-0.0641818345,
-0.0362954475,
-0.094549872,
0.0519927144,
-0.0504462607,
0.0062331986,
-0.0065881275,
0.0797886252,
-0.04078684,
-0.0137405135,
0.006188476,
0.0064760111,
0.0754161701,
-0.0271244254,
0.0025465612,
0.0348005928,
0.0602240898,
0.0067497874,
0.0098677026,
-0.0303202681,
-0.0553748384,
0.0354574099,
-0.0022352133,
0.0311676692,
0.0021284774,
-0.0092691304,
0.069448851,
0.009239886,
-0.0266786814,
-0.0528018251,
0.0298617911,
-0.0285892561,
-0.0129809082,
-0.0315654688,
-0.0118561517,
-0.005261777,
0.0125947529,
-0.0483629592,
-0.029846523,
0.0141792623,
0.0280411206,
0.0013541081,
-0.0109363766,
-0.0299870949,
-0.0418337807,
-0.0151723018,
-0.0365059152,
-0.0604118519,
-0.0505368635,
-0.0308023486,
0.0040987292,
-0.0147710145,
0.0322048888,
2.371571103e-34,
0.061814934,
-0.0197933875,
-0.0042696786,
-0.0093287593,
0.0420650505,
-0.028246548,
0.0939556062,
0.0479868017,
0.0033161698,
-0.0928760543,
-0.023978794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18290v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18290v2 | Direct Preference Optimization: Your Language Model is Secretly a Reward Model | 2023-05-29T17:57:46 | 2023-12-13T18:48:48 | Rafael Rafailov, Archit Sharma, Eric Mitchell, Stefano Ermon, Christopher D. Manning, Chelsea Finn | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | While large-scale unsupervised language models (LMs) learn broad world
knowledge and some reasoning skills, achieving precise control of their
behavior is difficult due to the completely unsupervised nature of their
training. Existing methods for gaining such steerability collect human labels
of the relative quality of model generations and fine-tune the unsupervised LM
to align with these preferences, often with reinforcement learning from human
feedback (RLHF). However, RLHF is a complex and often unstable procedure, first
fitting a reward model that reflects the human preferences, and then
fine-tuning the large unsupervised LM using reinforcement learning to maximize
this estimated reward without drifting too far from the original model. In this
paper we introduce a new parameterization of the reward model in RLHF that
enables extraction of the corresponding optimal policy in closed form, allowing
us to solve the standard RLHF problem with only a simple classification loss.
The resulting algorithm, which we call Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), is
stable, performant, and computationally lightweight, eliminating the need for
sampling from the LM during fine-tuning or performing significant
hyperparameter tuning. Our experiments show that DPO can fine-tune LMs to align
with human preferences as well as or better than existing methods. Notably,
fine-tuning with DPO exceeds PPO-based RLHF in ability to control sentiment of
generations, and matches or improves response quality in summarization and
single-turn dialogue while being substantially simpler to implement and train. | [
0.0651013926,
0.0783086345,
0.0147244073,
0.029014349,
-0.0302554462,
0.0152501622,
-0.0479327776,
-0.0156397559,
0.01193933,
-0.040628247,
-0.0346588157,
-0.0064770416,
-0.014571812,
0.0100298226,
-0.0111518288,
-0.1055308282,
0.0466492437,
-0.0483391844,
0.0399600379,
-0.0256374292,
0.0106983613,
0.0181717146,
0.0036673835,
0.0273785815,
0.0005712877,
0.0021578921,
0.0112434458,
-0.0196081623,
0.0264357198,
0.0082121091,
0.0371617116,
0.0507218949,
0.0393916108,
0.0058506015,
0.0000022753,
-0.0458089672,
-0.0176299587,
-0.039264597,
0.0125069441,
-0.0108928829,
0.0737269372,
0.0360066816,
-0.0028432945,
0.0192046501,
-0.046552714,
0.0093580922,
0.0314196199,
0.0513948724,
0.0549690798,
0.0845502988,
0.0251156222,
-0.0302646849,
-0.005425693,
-0.0341972671,
0.0124235516,
-0.0101372572,
0.0101364451,
-0.0006143893,
-0.0154412026,
-0.0057123443,
-0.0207806304,
0.0175649375,
0.0030964587,
-0.0284220949,
0.0202316828,
0.025470376,
-0.0033949499,
-0.0049368935,
0.0100481082,
0.0935827792,
-0.0071009286,
-0.0184169803,
0.0227343533,
0.0014933249,
-0.0128472727,
-0.0287699681,
-0.004975447,
0.0265583582,
0.0268872865,
0.0502510406,
0.0305230021,
-0.0158091486,
0.0198567137,
0.0375275202,
-0.0227917619,
0.0876157805,
-0.0063736984,
-0.0169525854,
0.0165880211,
0.0104433419,
-0.0316137001,
-0.0420141369,
-0.0006948459,
-0.0029440064,
-0.0707233101,
0.0180129744,
-0.0447297506,
0.0369861908,
0.0048056692,
-0.0533621609,
0.038425032,
0.0233322401,
0.0318664685,
0.042998977,
0.0213393439,
0.013822021,
-0.0214204509,
0.035828732,
-0.0281891003,
0.0180124044,
-0.0499798618,
0.0083194179,
-0.0056994753,
0.0423554443,
-0.0241583176,
-0.0033447791,
-0.0463578738,
0.0291730482,
-0.0208738074,
0.0110836364,
0.0005797726,
0.0485337712,
-0.0410464108,
-0.0072956509,
-0.074349165,
0.0625428855,
-0.0506622121,
-0.0108484095,
0.0189826377,
0.0081092184,
0.0106860371,
0.0393055081,
0.0082456535,
-0.010477297,
-0.0074186106,
0.0768932104,
-0.0306250099,
-0.0084680086,
-0.020310495,
-0.0290150661,
-0.030731529,
-0.0654207692,
-0.0086283227,
-0.0534520932,
0.0172775146,
-0.0212201308,
-0.0206675529,
-0.0328792594,
0.0181892551,
-0.0049387724,
-0.056173183,
0.0403350219,
0.0111120129,
-0.0285735894,
0.02021496,
-0.0171871558,
-0.0035930215,
0.051260151,
0.0547147691,
0.0410936885,
0.0300112609,
0.010464278,
-0.0130224368,
0.0235302001,
0.0256174132,
0.0386763103,
-0.043471396,
0.0190599989,
-0.0127061037,
0.0368282385,
0.0649216399,
0.0455730371,
-0.0264658183,
0.0041060168,
0.0834350958,
-0.0005347207,
0.0001389773,
0.0072332001,
0.0058193947,
0.0559961013,
-0.01350943,
0.0118272807,
-0.0227541067,
0.0266668405,
-0.0301183276,
0.0066324817,
0.0586057417,
-0.025442224,
-0.0260850508,
-0.0644387752,
0.0262050387,
-0.0249361619,
0.0198088717,
0.0396988541,
0.0279692225,
0.0091618681,
-0.0374986455,
0.0107332533,
0.0471212603,
-0.0368171632,
0.0280196797,
-0.0370925553,
0.0744013637,
0.0798468888,
0.0317319259,
-0.0252272561,
0.0102542378,
-0.0218388792,
-0.0438158885,
0.0659087971,
0.0528439544,
-0.03704568,
0.0100578982,
-0.0327591524,
-0.0423458442,
0.0141969826,
-0.0014166335,
0.0326884687,
0.023749413,
-0.0213987809,
0.0053761797,
0.0027947205,
-0.0420945771,
0.0132270642,
0.009624755,
-0.0343001559,
0.0534521043,
0.0138192736,
0.0533748567,
0.0110502401,
0.0012709597,
-0.0111411912,
-0.0074570915,
-0.0123203583,
-0.041483812,
-0.010315421,
-0.0833770111,
-0.0525301173,
0.0207857098,
-0.0373164304,
-0.0173004009,
0.0560841337,
-0.0358132459,
-0.0287458599,
0.0274141934,
-0.0119367819,
0.0589822121,
-0.0320500098,
0.0042641512,
-0.0229867268,
-0.0383345075,
-0.0620456114,
0.0544365868,
0.0062395819,
-0.021947071,
-0.0053447145,
-0.0212457236,
-0.0190536194,
-0.0518432036,
-0.014374584,
0.0216192305,
0.0116310958,
0.0328502543,
0.0661090538,
0.0468864366,
-0.0592662171,
-0.0424121097,
-0.0345778205,
0.0018698936,
-0.0110425455,
0.0070796888,
0.0221422855,
0.0054970616,
0.001118844,
-0.0357194878,
-0.0503983833,
-0.0169922821,
-0.0002199924,
-0.0014944128,
0.029816024,
0.0256731864,
0.0432045385,
-0.0812610835,
-0.0041763936,
0.0139442701,
-0.0115184132,
-0.0219917763,
0.0345266946,
-0.0374706239,
0.0372497551,
-0.0504805893,
0.0226216055,
0.0027998856,
-0.0385212041,
-0.0122112352,
-0.0307872109,
0.0248991605,
0.0960818827,
0.0603601597,
-0.0163600594,
0.0576874427,
0.0273861382,
-0.0858638734,
0.0073846579,
-0.0730354562,
-0.0142670609,
-0.0208757706,
0.0309484918,
0.0220370665,
0.0606681481,
0.0215653796,
0.0034358767,
-0.0580986738,
0.0185531098,
-0.0132704731,
-0.0133206677,
-0.0134492703,
0.0171766635,
-0.0296829622,
0.0244724862,
-0.0211892705,
-0.0472131222,
0.1007202789,
0.0101742316,
0.0223121755,
-0.0840691701,
-0.0036447281,
-0.0333564244,
-0.0127117326,
0.0087272814,
0.0245342087,
-0.0430706888,
-0.0033087886,
-0.0637823418,
-0.0543630347,
0.044592347,
-0.0104349256,
0.0608259328,
-0.0327637643,
-0.0087469993,
0.0012750055,
-0.0751988217,
-0.0543183014,
-0.0391216204,
-0.0318957865,
-0.0000917907,
0.035880819,
-0.0268660728,
-0.0097707957,
-0.0240510646,
0.0425881818,
0.0209454093,
-0.0292748399,
-0.0089194635,
-0.0218043774,
0.0127399536,
0.0991869569,
-0.0062550227,
0.0070363912,
-0.0272794366,
0.0133945215,
0.0269247219,
0.0324607641,
-0.004373292,
-0.0155085241,
0.0145489154,
0.0269468129,
-0.0379913896,
-0.007911602,
0.0252833664,
0.0232108161,
-0.0382888727,
0.0111018391,
0.1215455458,
0.0235458612,
-0.0799583942,
-0.006287782,
0.0027646665,
0.0541975461,
0.0174230356,
0.0507678092,
-0.0270709023,
-0.0220628604,
0.000238792,
0.0666204914,
0.0189690366,
-0.0176126081,
0.0173226427,
-0.1215475574,
-0.0050538164,
0.0166421067,
-0.0459677987,
0.0039680381,
-0.0115810959,
-0.0065904134,
-0.0293288883,
0.0131485481,
0.0029020966,
-0.0065575987,
-0.0028229041,
-0.0076360214,
-0.02402227,
0.0028234124,
0.0235140715,
-0.0346858986,
0.0280279666,
0.11773251,
0.0330476351,
0.0330810025,
-0.0164107066,
0.0038180321,
0.026420977,
-0.0296418257,
-0.0435235053,
0.0376099162,
-0.0337214135,
0.0013356588,
-0.0260636508,
0.0644051954,
-0.0224375334,
0.015565074,
0.0025718608,
0.0292295143,
-0.0055788816,
-0.0178684071,
0.0126114693,
0.034112107,
0.0198047701,
0.053990379,
0.0107273404,
-0.0917741135,
-0.0341589637,
-0.0365170501,
-0.0233093984,
-0.0735568926,
-0.0281470045,
-0.03118922,
-0.0088037057,
0.0168336593,
-0.0917233676,
-0.0063964785,
-0.0104342289,
0.0055726692,
0.0029907255,
-0.0249135047,
0.0113850525,
-0.0116179092,
-0.0003823889,
0.0075580571,
-0.0609519705,
-0.0170028713,
-0.0926528648,
-0.0439206064,
0.0326076895,
-0.0437155552,
-0.0155149819,
-0.0355133414,
-0.0055655269,
-0.0756720901,
-0.0111744627,
0.0969873592,
0.0099325506,
0.0970420018,
0.0022041602,
-0.0670211762,
0.0612632744,
0.0312149338,
-0.0158539619,
-0.0042304574,
0.0212400407,
0.0713145435,
-0.0070449086,
0.0499918945,
-0.0419679806,
0.0097089605,
0.027370071,
0.0281345565,
-0.0173436608,
-0.0553722195,
0.0132353641,
-0.0089472374,
0.0482064933,
-0.0053843861,
0.0009159101,
-0.043913886,
-0.0063175415,
-0.0050549847,
-0.0465206578,
-0.0303837471,
-0.0168454647,
0.0162412971,
-0.0202245582,
0.0074364562,
-0.0134781059,
-0.0233077891,
0.0221232697,
-0.0090761622,
0.0054733246,
0.0226262175,
0.0092680594,
0.0076360116,
0.0466908813,
-0.0142989643,
0.0045714569,
0.0200821105,
0.0548540317,
-0.0099827126,
0.0690921098,
0.0309885684,
-0.0098778307,
-0.0171217676,
0.0000685365,
-0.0417009257,
-0.0421591587,
-0.0302102305,
-0.0018432034,
0.0596750677,
-0.0301006436,
0.0670199841,
-0.0260723531,
-0.0080312937,
-0.0229341239,
0.0374628082,
-0.0196883474,
-0.0184698366,
0.0152889015,
0.0128621887,
-0.0184581503,
0.0407911576,
0.0693550259,
0.0098871905,
0.0223558508,
-0.0019771638,
0.026479302,
-0.0602860302,
0.0023961312,
0.0163470898,
0.0310115889,
-0.0271761902,
0.0106580965,
-0.0139260022,
-0.0366566032,
-0.0153502636,
0.0208273269,
-0.0120985443,
-0.0174999312,
0.0660286918,
-0.0026052645,
-0.0403553993,
-0.0190205183,
-0.0884560645,
-0.011967496,
-0.0181089751,
-0.0074971355,
-0.0328511782,
-7.100690441e-33,
-0.0251338352,
0.0021912609,
-0.0204993077,
0.0146200331,
-0.0227109026,
-0.0328381918,
-0.0212193802,
0.0328945108,
-0.0072228899,
-0.0001822229,
-0.0200579017,
-0.0228652135,
-0.0059106024,
0.0514913052,
0.0188714042,
0.0011813035,
0.0398804769,
-0.0246947892,
-0.0478311516,
0.0388562717,
0.0595073514,
0.0183145534,
0.0270963535,
-0.0661796555,
0.0199329946,
0.0144156851,
-0.0213246327,
0.0576579832,
-0.0008307938,
0.0616897605,
-0.0175193585,
0.0237147901,
-0.0125081893,
-0.042898532,
-0.0241866298,
0.0230120774,
-0.0636499599,
-0.0236193668,
0.0055970638,
-0.0179638602,
-0.0524228029,
-0.0425607264,
0.0110080047,
0.0199099034,
-0.0027225609,
-0.0109357368,
0.0378254354,
-0.0151840504,
-0.0222753752,
0.0060185231,
-0.0422628634,
-0.000098317,
-0.0187124573,
-0.0388436541,
0.0293860845,
0.0377163514,
-0.0078480346,
0.0493246056,
-0.0592213534,
0.0532022081,
0.0057223924,
0.0282553062,
0.0629487559,
0.033319518,
0.0142188668,
0.0596859865,
0.0032287391,
-0.0041685291,
0.0201278608,
-0.0140034296,
0.024272982,
0.0255533308,
-0.0062026712,
0.0443766415,
0.0185955223,
-0.0175368041,
-0.0174732283,
0.0184571706,
0.0097849024,
0.0076232068,
0.0305519849,
0.0281814672,
-0.0222528558,
-0.036551334,
-0.0535628423,
-0.0293538589,
-0.0306914877,
-0.0382675268,
-0.0001675793,
0.0425859429,
-0.0542837046,
-0.0772812515,
0.0164164416,
-0.051152274,
-0.0091552921,
-0.0040725158,
-0.0541125797,
-0.006506125,
0.0214925669,
-0.0076198573,
-0.0916697979,
-0.0113127977,
-0.0097379601,
-0.0363667235,
-0.0416244306,
0.0348031446,
0.0386620052,
0.0105092442,
-0.0501558147,
0.0281009153,
-0.0004846297,
0.0239802189,
-0.0103566488,
0.0383702405,
0.0047676647,
-0.0131376833,
-0.0012665581,
0.0865291208,
0.0059141368,
-0.005180818,
-0.0083680619,
-0.0110366149,
-0.0002375255,
0.0193026178,
-0.023488041,
0.0076076458,
-0.0228357445,
0.0096721537,
-0.0053738235,
-0.0433740839,
-0.0163661558,
-0.00345045,
2.891e-7,
-0.0008691038,
0.0819090307,
0.0121894404,
0.0122527406,
0.014701779,
0.0844953805,
0.0163941439,
-0.0042722397,
0.0381910428,
0.0232297145,
0.0193098467,
0.0083064865,
0.0642390922,
-0.0084661609,
-0.1214513704,
0.0028163965,
-0.0564835221,
0.022553293,
-0.0196069833,
-0.0513557568,
0.0481743887,
0.0715918541,
0.0172396451,
0.0052160458,
-0.0024504759,
0.0291091576,
0.075569436,
-0.0523517579,
-0.0273443386,
0.0091454647,
-0.0278648753,
0.0113213658,
-0.0222170334,
-0.0297740437,
-0.021417072,
0.0006455886,
-0.0322850458,
0.1061540768,
0.0217158366,
-0.0914821997,
0.0035198983,
0.0545991808,
0.0293526761,
-0.0511787273,
0.0643870234,
-0.0686825663,
-0.022360133,
-0.0186299663,
0.0096624959,
-0.0329642445,
0.0053088861,
-0.0467265546,
-0.0579199903,
0.0142954551,
-0.0003290865,
0.0244337749,
-0.0115976306,
-0.0534455813,
-0.0155339874,
-0.0039530317,
-0.0315429606,
-0.0406966321,
-0.015380552,
0.0690566525,
-0.0216427594,
-0.0213676915,
0.0231677592,
2.699996648e-34,
0.039090205,
-0.0054971608,
0.0046917256,
-0.0494950861,
0.0257222131,
0.0329595953,
0.0177393574,
-0.0157059096,
0.0776387155,
-0.0547240973,
-0.0216031838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18287v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18287v2 | LaFTer: Label-Free Tuning of Zero-shot Classifier using Language and Unlabeled Image Collections | 2023-05-29T17:56:35 | 2023-10-23T12:32:47 | M. Jehanzeb Mirza, Leonid Karlinsky, Wei Lin, Mateusz Kozinski, Horst Possegger, Rogerio Feris, Horst Bischof | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recently, large-scale pre-trained Vision and Language (VL) models have set a
new state-of-the-art (SOTA) in zero-shot visual classification enabling
open-vocabulary recognition of potentially unlimited set of categories defined
as simple language prompts. However, despite these great advances, the
performance of these zeroshot classifiers still falls short of the results of
dedicated (closed category set) classifiers trained with supervised fine
tuning. In this paper we show, for the first time, how to reduce this gap
without any labels and without any paired VL data, using an unlabeled image
collection and a set of texts auto-generated using a Large Language Model (LLM)
describing the categories of interest and effectively substituting labeled
visual instances of those categories. Using our label-free approach, we are
able to attain significant performance improvements over the zero-shot
performance of the base VL model and other contemporary methods and baselines
on a wide variety of datasets, demonstrating absolute improvement of up to
11.7% (3.8% on average) in the label-free setting. Moreover, despite our
approach being label-free, we observe 1.3% average gains over leading few-shot
prompting baselines that do use 5-shot supervision. | [
0.0121953208,
0.0518087819,
0.0202226173,
0.0438437946,
-0.0083333468,
0.0384679288,
0.0746967793,
0.0361912511,
0.0118190264,
-0.1062326431,
-0.0420603491,
-0.0312304515,
-0.0223166589,
0.0181386769,
-0.0110960025,
-0.0162710771,
0.0119778458,
-0.033728607,
0.0163825955,
0.0047649629,
-0.0070452695,
0.0060043433,
-0.0200444572,
-0.0053352625,
-0.0083344281,
0.0023094285,
-0.0149581274,
0.0185340103,
-0.0014549702,
-0.0349599272,
-0.009371195,
0.0780979618,
0.0323222987,
0.0550131388,
0.0000020273,
-0.0709662139,
0.0281630699,
-0.0256434735,
-0.034108419,
-0.0209366679,
0.0418922007,
-0.0414611101,
0.0104701985,
-0.0263510402,
0.0125994952,
-0.0628291517,
0.074070774,
0.0277245715,
0.0152340336,
0.0619940907,
-0.02752042,
-0.0409582071,
-0.0074970541,
0.0017799373,
0.0635529682,
-0.0579966195,
0.0224477034,
-0.0286625214,
-0.0134890657,
0.0231095832,
-0.0540386476,
0.0277804956,
0.0170483068,
-0.0248193722,
0.033110559,
0.0589165054,
-0.0854638368,
-0.0539346822,
-0.0110565126,
0.0899892896,
-0.0336229391,
-0.0344151966,
-0.0187955536,
-0.0419589803,
-0.0263808426,
-0.0116102742,
-0.0190295596,
0.067835696,
0.0193988439,
0.016137518,
-0.0256558079,
0.0037591474,
-0.0025571012,
0.0074675404,
0.0090703499,
-0.005497877,
0.0101047093,
-0.0094165169,
0.0161720552,
0.0301085729,
-0.0145311905,
-0.0695594996,
-0.0526615679,
0.0381757654,
-0.0027124402,
-0.0032646139,
-0.0474878587,
-0.0328503773,
0.0033280132,
-0.0395627581,
0.0571492277,
0.0198805723,
-0.0735641867,
0.0724833682,
-0.0330292732,
0.0191928241,
0.0276024882,
0.0330137685,
-0.0337214358,
-0.010895961,
-0.0369872376,
0.0115969777,
-0.0418911725,
-0.0071993433,
-0.0192140173,
-0.0184533466,
-0.0243532117,
0.0132838031,
0.018096108,
-0.0179414898,
-0.0061510811,
-0.0062712641,
-0.0152859883,
-0.0203634966,
0.0150139993,
0.0243830569,
0.016439192,
0.0109945126,
-0.0389680006,
-0.0698168352,
-0.0025694228,
0.0517884605,
0.0476011746,
-0.0088450108,
0.023088064,
0.0466255024,
-0.0356062949,
-0.0988293812,
-0.0364666469,
0.0092469389,
-0.0248600449,
-0.0365266949,
0.0046628215,
-0.0627273917,
-0.0083140461,
0.0013308419,
0.0209106971,
0.0017589665,
0.0018266576,
0.0095764641,
-0.0510835275,
0.0909755677,
-0.0367492288,
-0.0267607141,
0.0095920432,
0.0122559723,
0.0497776903,
0.0861031339,
-0.0381516255,
0.0274386685,
0.0346299373,
0.0085985819,
0.0692917109,
0.0361252949,
-0.0205419213,
0.031561777,
-0.0480506532,
-0.0166713316,
0.0396041237,
0.01101592,
0.0285101682,
-0.0212853588,
-0.0168552231,
-0.0098121455,
0.0370260105,
0.0545993298,
0.0369366184,
-0.0126133654,
0.0330892392,
0.0103817414,
0.0054066721,
-0.0425543115,
-0.0376289189,
0.016939817,
-0.0351203121,
-0.0120420167,
0.0058890954,
-0.0202520825,
-0.0754448995,
-0.01067302,
-0.0069779516,
-0.0448910929,
-0.025071986,
0.0065378845,
0.0658146217,
0.0119043086,
-0.0184833556,
0.0157296825,
0.0626868382,
-0.0251890663,
-0.00950184,
-0.0457310937,
0.0394562595,
0.0447180234,
0.0075687487,
-0.0203303229,
0.002124496,
-0.0061530895,
0.0747913569,
0.07793466,
-0.0049283924,
0.013291101,
0.0431186035,
-0.0643876791,
-0.0551980175,
-0.0082056001,
0.0150106652,
0.0211394783,
-0.0150074549,
0.0524024777,
0.0283157863,
0.0241803136,
-0.0185497403,
0.0391329266,
0.0281650815,
-0.0666827559,
0.0496374294,
0.0176755581,
-0.0232362077,
-0.0104519902,
-0.03883183,
-0.0450536944,
0.0007855483,
-0.0256125256,
-0.0022977062,
-0.041488409,
-0.0462359749,
-0.0338563621,
0.0198349431,
0.0224937592,
0.0057878541,
-0.0085180812,
-0.0389989801,
-0.0230834261,
-0.0086961817,
0.0337307528,
-0.0041845306,
-0.0397963859,
0.00897252,
-0.0268515833,
0.0087123113,
-0.0328395441,
0.0487789437,
0.0298593491,
0.0165507179,
-0.0176448841,
-0.0110511016,
0.0490667969,
-0.0202652067,
-0.0328541249,
0.0203544479,
-0.0033541766,
0.0322569944,
0.0198900849,
0.0757333338,
-0.0507275611,
0.0174684599,
-0.1091424525,
-0.0319207981,
-0.0463794842,
-0.0297701545,
0.0097371889,
-0.001201928,
-0.020669274,
-0.0278940629,
-0.0215275493,
0.0597397387,
-0.0046671117,
0.0147428708,
0.0197483115,
0.0016284252,
-0.0058937343,
0.0185699072,
0.0019001549,
0.0176073126,
0.0585935861,
0.0305394102,
-0.024221275,
-0.0185204316,
0.050210204,
-0.0254089627,
0.0285354313,
0.0201096628,
-0.0247940794,
0.0018499068,
-0.0335462652,
-0.0393427089,
0.0596792549,
-0.0082144234,
-0.0220872369,
0.0207613092,
0.0177375935,
-0.0274732113,
-0.0296115596,
-0.011214029,
-0.0834829509,
-0.0000568951,
0.0259836633,
-0.0343135521,
0.0620986186,
-0.0262070447,
-0.0043831328,
-0.0637965053,
0.0157923736,
-0.0195651278,
-0.0063688229,
-0.1081498265,
0.0442524739,
0.0046986449,
0.0507765077,
-0.0101637039,
-0.0607273914,
0.0148502886,
-0.0218252856,
-0.0270610917,
-0.0023678897,
-0.0040576551,
-0.0362320244,
0.0507177226,
0.0187538043,
0.026096141,
0.0178223606,
0.0013376977,
-0.0247229636,
-0.0229374263,
-0.0154028153,
0.0128192054,
0.0237525832,
-0.0232784618,
0.0437229574,
-0.0364525579,
-0.0115863271,
-0.0544524528,
-0.0493458323,
-0.045573391,
0.0021943825,
-0.0813717395,
-0.0214474797,
-0.0137028052,
0.0051751575,
0.0154801002,
0.0683559999,
0.006867236,
-0.0154866111,
-0.0039398856,
0.0482448861,
0.0276947897,
-0.0422575176,
-0.0556188561,
-0.0164870638,
0.0176723357,
0.0208872221,
0.0078597907,
0.037854746,
-0.0213783048,
0.0224771202,
0.0259596296,
0.0230693668,
-0.0051809768,
0.0153154358,
0.0099979555,
0.0007239577,
0.0090066753,
0.1153340042,
0.020614516,
-0.0703925341,
-0.0381041057,
-0.014870028,
-0.0081548197,
0.0341872685,
0.0156593025,
-0.1213137656,
-0.0561170503,
-0.0335962772,
0.0012975166,
0.0029706953,
-0.0182655994,
-0.0347307883,
-0.1033872068,
0.0342120714,
0.0227913819,
-0.0413784571,
0.0443923473,
0.0046318593,
-0.0019686234,
-0.0256749671,
-0.0441894755,
-0.0082416665,
0.0081578009,
-0.0321115255,
-0.0126843601,
0.0539956652,
-0.0688488632,
0.0407416746,
-0.03039423,
0.0306515321,
0.0115719447,
0.0119689154,
-0.0209197029,
-0.0219828356,
0.0655645728,
-0.0486328751,
0.0001198632,
-0.0338875279,
0.0505643301,
-0.0414601229,
-0.0238235276,
0.0273250006,
-0.002193799,
-0.0200093593,
-0.0264039431,
0.0054598921,
0.0355905406,
0.0129271084,
-0.0171773303,
-0.0090550864,
-0.0278778598,
0.030485142,
0.0520426184,
0.0162822958,
-0.0559820086,
0.0020258506,
-0.0098234294,
-0.039417658,
-0.0232936367,
-0.0539958365,
0.0169701837,
-0.0275649782,
-0.0835549682,
-0.0243056137,
-0.0143758878,
0.0444235504,
0.0468140692,
-0.0144558819,
-0.0123108309,
-0.0401733369,
0.025370894,
-0.0494402424,
0.0416424721,
-0.0598075502,
0.0062940703,
-0.087190561,
-0.027167473,
0.0313303657,
-0.0490263328,
-0.006652873,
-0.0014274953,
-0.026705794,
-0.0425718427,
0.0012409545,
0.0556451716,
0.0075219781,
0.0269547757,
0.0174308047,
-0.0993681177,
0.1058907285,
0.1036376655,
0.0156860519,
0.0453866832,
-0.0064758183,
-0.0123814652,
-0.0059567387,
0.0359997973,
-0.0242275596,
0.0538660847,
0.0634403005,
-0.0285421629,
-0.0373420306,
-0.0298495628,
-0.0084584197,
-0.004421887,
0.0819804817,
-0.0371547602,
0.0167805161,
-0.0176241286,
0.0112236906,
0.0015119748,
-0.0124410279,
-0.0370711051,
-0.0248804186,
0.0333657488,
-0.0251203589,
-0.006272573,
0.0412704162,
-0.0630562752,
0.0457087755,
-0.0072668889,
-0.0055303643,
0.0296422187,
0.0486791171,
0.0194172245,
0.0183720477,
0.0033034156,
0.016076142,
0.0183508936,
0.0433867835,
-0.0078177126,
0.0665866509,
0.021092739,
0.0205400921,
-0.0465997867,
0.0204284564,
-0.0173583347,
-0.0237990394,
-0.0183374975,
0.0414026044,
0.0373008177,
-0.0369372778,
-0.0142370611,
-0.0118618375,
-0.0228888765,
-0.0459384322,
0.0225677975,
0.0131984185,
-0.0540491864,
0.0124185849,
0.0242865402,
-0.003864958,
0.0312343985,
0.0689378381,
0.0494879447,
0.0082775773,
0.024296185,
0.0435412191,
-0.0225481298,
0.0413652919,
0.0447764918,
0.0046789306,
0.0198136326,
0.0586221516,
-0.0136347106,
-0.0311015081,
0.0206362437,
-0.0321702883,
-0.007726457,
0.039776139,
0.0479429625,
0.0143796038,
0.013540769,
0.0037421945,
-0.0367209353,
-0.0115703661,
0.0133279357,
-0.0067239432,
-0.0045027104,
-6.276173724e-33,
-0.0224547666,
-0.0291262325,
0.0259039979,
0.0027268305,
0.0158515424,
0.0342970379,
-0.0063825785,
0.0229212567,
-0.0088178907,
0.0048177,
0.0045164512,
-0.0125803174,
0.022676317,
0.0456606969,
0.0079034548,
-0.0086219003,
0.017566571,
-0.0198815987,
-0.0152243376,
0.0144231161,
0.0314040706,
0.0279859975,
0.0567461364,
-0.0576957054,
-0.0246319082,
-0.0164273083,
-0.0013868363,
0.0097563481,
0.0661251321,
0.0287063308,
-0.0122901201,
0.0528042763,
0.0220246967,
0.0143271871,
0.0118464679,
0.0248010717,
-0.0460558981,
-0.0172922537,
-0.026440898,
0.0425774753,
-0.0191965308,
-0.005644985,
-0.0114384089,
-0.013524971,
-0.0159491617,
-0.0239826031,
0.0387773626,
-0.0245440602,
-0.0102357557,
-0.0101671088,
-0.0508844145,
0.0187163781,
0.0185724348,
-0.0443115793,
0.0606548227,
0.0395246111,
0.0109189572,
0.0499626361,
-0.0561058037,
0.0354461111,
0.0127504617,
0.0018683122,
0.0555928648,
0.0790439397,
-0.0055386615,
0.0435329191,
0.030433882,
-0.0034507269,
-0.0320163593,
-0.0122389728,
0.0518526547,
-0.0008000236,
0.0115908012,
0.0622678548,
0.0713404715,
0.0042117904,
-0.0778779835,
-0.0021276711,
-0.0520866886,
0.002946506,
-0.0051121153,
0.0053246212,
-0.0246867184,
-0.015987251,
-0.025446374,
-0.0332753696,
-0.0712717995,
-0.000617672,
0.0392663963,
0.0484716408,
-0.0309433714,
-0.0094439844,
0.0684953034,
-0.0199338663,
-0.0114102848,
0.0126274545,
0.0010537247,
0.0380243696,
-0.0103393029,
-0.0216275603,
-0.0869307145,
-0.0581729375,
0.0511852056,
0.0217306595,
0.0116819972,
0.0154878749,
0.0931267142,
0.0347198956,
-0.0626871064,
-0.006626185,
-0.0058323061,
-0.0197855216,
0.0301459804,
0.0644350424,
-0.0135711562,
0.0193017367,
-0.0240490641,
0.0970662832,
0.0143975979,
-0.0469065309,
0.0336629972,
-0.0242823027,
0.0008445239,
0.0095811673,
-0.0194745809,
0.0065174317,
0.0006383118,
0.0011544719,
0.0480845682,
-0.0488759428,
0.0053552669,
-0.0091433926,
2.704e-7,
0.0196128767,
0.0142315384,
-0.0355613828,
-0.0060413503,
0.000687159,
0.0617600344,
-0.0034637507,
0.0255652629,
-0.01265164,
-0.0100590643,
0.0050148112,
0.0351693481,
0.0197223332,
-0.0305252206,
-0.0620589443,
0.036835473,
-0.0165334903,
0.0051660291,
-0.0724983364,
-0.0007867633,
0.053808976,
0.1013460606,
0.0023995193,
-0.0303434078,
0.0483609512,
-0.0567038804,
0.0796908811,
-0.0041314666,
0.0050712572,
-0.0106243091,
-0.0206171777,
0.0573026389,
-0.0310906209,
0.0252222624,
-0.0087219561,
-0.0030449161,
0.0099853836,
0.0176727064,
-0.045554243,
0.0075660287,
0.0060603376,
0.0316907167,
-0.0270611178,
-0.0178826544,
0.0886192769,
-0.0588524379,
0.0009585829,
0.0022687037,
-0.0233360641,
-0.023296928,
0.0706268549,
-0.048820179,
-0.0163781792,
0.0248008203,
0.0434352495,
-0.0367243588,
-0.0420890637,
-0.0759561434,
-0.0019625607,
-0.0187230613,
0.0059877401,
-0.0006217964,
-0.0239794087,
0.0016804021,
0.0327976868,
-0.0283474773,
0.0133641064,
1.823681107e-34,
0.0115551585,
0.0043641836,
0.0218396392,
-0.0432480238,
-0.0244394448,
0.0018136398,
-0.0331079215,
0.0035665622,
0.0092163272,
-0.0682425797,
0.0063853958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18283v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18283v1 | CommonAccent: Exploring Large Acoustic Pretrained Models for Accent Classification Based on Common Voice | 2023-05-29T17:53:35 | 2023-05-29T17:53:35 | Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Sara Ahmed, Danielius Visockas, Cem Subakan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | Despite the recent advancements in Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), the
recognition of accented speech still remains a dominant problem. In order to
create more inclusive ASR systems, research has shown that the integration of
accent information, as part of a larger ASR framework, can lead to the
mitigation of accented speech errors. We address multilingual accent
classification through the ECAPA-TDNN and Wav2Vec 2.0/XLSR architectures which
have been proven to perform well on a variety of speech-related downstream
tasks. We introduce a simple-to-follow recipe aligned to the SpeechBrain
toolkit for accent classification based on Common Voice 7.0 (English) and
Common Voice 11.0 (Italian, German, and Spanish). Furthermore, we establish new
state-of-the-art for English accent classification with as high as 95%
accuracy. We also study the internal categorization of the Wav2Vev 2.0
embeddings through t-SNE, noting that there is a level of clustering based on
phonological similarity. (Our recipe is open-source in the SpeechBrain toolkit,
see: https://github.com/speechbrain/speechbrain/tree/develop/recipes) | [
-0.0596908256,
0.0682341307,
0.0072202669,
0.0190463625,
0.0034676823,
0.0021095171,
0.0625187829,
-0.0477396287,
-0.0116145238,
-0.0001116278,
-0.0667104349,
-0.0479267463,
0.0359222628,
-0.0080732061,
0.052977629,
-0.0146272248,
0.0149166221,
-0.0322000049,
-0.0056014876,
-0.0491409115,
0.0155946929,
0.0068407538,
-0.0316733681,
0.0581120364,
-0.0208930932,
0.0687695146,
0.0023417668,
-0.0008682858,
0.0499830507,
0.0107926307,
0.0107075647,
0.0165412482,
0.0160570648,
0.03341645,
0.0000020999,
0.0036639625,
-0.0130608985,
-0.0041629127,
-0.0489916354,
0.0449272096,
-0.0015939029,
0.0617626198,
-0.036467839,
0.0662083179,
0.0343506709,
-0.062433999,
0.0808189213,
0.0153348744,
0.0348418243,
0.0348526388,
-0.0087886443,
-0.0726156011,
0.0137486169,
-0.0253437348,
0.0124526201,
-0.0048015313,
0.0033749228,
-0.0816095397,
-0.0334440768,
-0.0097633377,
0.0195968971,
0.0189486183,
0.0115963984,
0.023021955,
-0.0171213914,
0.0339554287,
-0.0512173027,
-0.0143912341,
-0.013129225,
0.0358990319,
-0.0216794666,
-0.0425258875,
0.0008238911,
0.023434056,
-0.0435776748,
-0.0448478088,
0.0159594454,
-0.0305472817,
0.0254614037,
0.0192166939,
0.0130773233,
0.0775464624,
0.0330937393,
-0.0279897787,
-0.0330857672,
-0.0135690263,
0.013021444,
-0.013153662,
0.0386097878,
0.0235806983,
-0.0194069147,
0.0006092775,
0.0559033193,
0.0105646448,
0.0051723965,
-0.043213997,
0.0054517514,
-0.0276909955,
0.0216569211,
0.0003045437,
0.0463905707,
0.0200663246,
-0.0919806436,
0.0078212591,
-0.0423704237,
0.0541844591,
-0.020139331,
-0.0403857492,
-0.0131624984,
-0.0536699034,
-0.0183508508,
0.0089913141,
-0.0402262658,
-0.0216623433,
0.0121598244,
0.002653925,
0.0049643628,
-0.0486892723,
-0.0671643615,
0.0494159162,
0.033628393,
0.0000802158,
-0.0107024806,
-0.0005926948,
0.0607039072,
0.0594966896,
-0.0198889952,
0.0322286487,
-0.0606013834,
-0.0595824532,
0.0025757186,
0.0227848236,
0.0239959676,
0.0001610096,
0.0399961919,
-0.0713729039,
-0.006948275,
-0.0201105718,
0.0057554268,
0.0106961029,
-0.0341098942,
-0.0320929885,
-0.0361228697,
-0.0631986037,
0.032961987,
-0.0425208583,
0.0120140361,
-0.0170005318,
-0.0307771917,
-0.024366023,
0.0238379519,
0.046999231,
0.0111907618,
0.0033420494,
0.0691337362,
-0.0270055775,
0.0343676023,
0.0239009671,
0.0032933338,
-0.0141133741,
-0.0139342761,
-0.0074498472,
-0.0145511022,
0.0615519322,
0.0475690402,
-0.0395523719,
-0.0009086355,
-0.0248789918,
-0.0243008174,
0.0211096946,
0.0499582924,
0.0216065496,
-0.0192191377,
-0.0339307934,
0.0111933397,
0.036113359,
0.0188410953,
-0.0183984712,
0.0593179651,
0.0074444944,
0.0009158155,
-0.0144306105,
-0.0297670905,
-0.0266981907,
-0.0127564743,
-0.0171894543,
-0.0111603616,
0.0660589635,
-0.0759568438,
-0.0070632361,
0.0374541432,
-0.0569441803,
0.0174574703,
0.0134403137,
0.0225095153,
-0.0146308253,
0.0004094969,
0.0024068558,
-0.0218834821,
-0.0424439795,
0.0129198274,
-0.0412839167,
0.0331551507,
-0.0013130613,
-0.0311489645,
-0.0272387099,
-0.0382557586,
-0.0243261419,
0.0019025136,
-0.0323172361,
0.0427947082,
-0.0124692535,
0.0678495467,
-0.087961711,
0.0073506841,
0.0246597696,
-0.0004422692,
0.0549463406,
-0.0141084911,
0.0354918018,
0.0154409744,
-0.0130310347,
0.0523376316,
-0.012906705,
0.0189505387,
-0.0117663397,
0.0397467911,
0.0396495201,
0.0270709265,
0.0650203303,
-0.0459282622,
-0.0095491577,
0.0376294442,
-0.0498388819,
0.0404225923,
0.0239960365,
-0.0448739529,
-0.0405462533,
0.0318766534,
-0.0279713646,
-0.0112712849,
0.0092729777,
-0.0119465059,
-0.0810536221,
0.0240006894,
-0.0117946723,
0.0740946531,
-0.0502250269,
-0.0003346387,
-0.0084437439,
0.0666024983,
0.0499071628,
0.0048785354,
0.0363001414,
-0.0341946594,
0.0185757149,
0.0438731872,
-0.0051301722,
-0.0647454038,
-0.0625398308,
-0.0120326085,
0.0235827155,
0.0173046682,
-0.0163697917,
-0.005715664,
0.0414321497,
-0.0156386923,
-0.0965011716,
-0.0032501451,
-0.0265968088,
0.0248425547,
-0.0218029525,
0.0005621634,
0.0146907261,
-0.025370609,
-0.0519224145,
-0.0328687467,
-0.0145359756,
-0.0221779589,
-0.0458546169,
-0.0276279487,
-0.0317084417,
0.0009317428,
0.0000556286,
0.0102070142,
-0.0071130847,
-0.0533002093,
0.0182986446,
-0.039446827,
-0.0472832583,
0.0255723055,
0.0204502828,
0.031099692,
-0.0198851265,
-0.0459005497,
0.016541373,
0.0238651223,
0.0046417178,
-0.0353194177,
0.0069672754,
0.0087719942,
-0.0112365279,
-0.0178941209,
-0.0129215615,
0.0291471221,
0.053133335,
-0.0113936672,
0.0042853975,
-0.055639755,
0.0361110978,
-0.0075115878,
0.016242262,
-0.0448970906,
-0.0408566631,
0.0011442126,
-0.030462591,
-0.0273334216,
-0.0573101789,
-0.0084177405,
-0.0136772646,
-0.0127495071,
-0.02439286,
0.0140087148,
-0.0863829926,
-0.0494720787,
-0.0896253809,
-0.0533738136,
-0.0102596944,
-0.0070859985,
0.0178479925,
0.0210098308,
0.0067954813,
-0.0352765247,
-0.0009293006,
0.0243399721,
-0.0190877784,
-0.0288903732,
0.0643232986,
0.0351633988,
-0.0519669652,
0.0087870182,
-0.0337095372,
0.0136575326,
0.0013253231,
-0.0591557547,
0.0289575625,
0.0598910302,
-0.0250381995,
0.0312682986,
0.0252789948,
0.0044198809,
0.0531359315,
-0.010854939,
0.0405967832,
-0.0065853121,
0.0559691712,
-0.0079716183,
0.0894477367,
-0.0297429785,
0.0086903237,
0.0225177519,
-0.0031824617,
0.0656239986,
-0.0189178213,
-0.080917418,
0.0186050031,
0.0490123592,
-0.0069492073,
-0.0410056561,
-0.0230184477,
0.0353629328,
-0.0055114846,
0.0143083157,
0.08472123,
0.0183607005,
-0.0149670653,
-0.0228045657,
-0.0108082686,
0.0229212493,
-0.0133160902,
0.005898362,
-0.0355967693,
-0.0336665772,
0.0512274094,
-0.0053613302,
-0.0009091158,
0.0288489498,
0.0048139594,
-0.0841681287,
0.0390122719,
0.0134524843,
-0.0582416803,
-0.0169079658,
-0.0401924215,
-0.0337657109,
-0.0661632121,
0.0218324494,
-0.0204320215,
0.0141992215,
-0.0407981649,
0.0340476148,
-0.0687424839,
-0.0365667753,
0.0439291075,
-0.0537803583,
0.0927394629,
0.0351562873,
0.0142643051,
-0.0291319024,
-0.0489290468,
0.0006059427,
-0.0693939328,
0.0067025069,
-0.0429841727,
0.0138225565,
0.041500587,
-0.0132034058,
0.0107858414,
0.030369645,
0.0103906617,
-0.0121166287,
0.0127812354,
0.0633422211,
-0.0295942109,
0.021093417,
-0.0082609588,
0.0251791645,
0.0021479896,
0.0452854298,
0.0264628734,
-0.0382830165,
-0.0067848242,
0.0344098844,
0.0394447297,
0.011668073,
-0.0149865206,
0.0268878862,
0.0368744992,
-0.0390076861,
-0.022590261,
0.0025956384,
0.0093611041,
0.0445756055,
0.0134284506,
-0.027089715,
-0.0294579025,
-0.0105282124,
-0.0089016743,
0.0049704509,
0.0085144881,
0.0881733447,
-0.019684827,
0.0158415083,
0.036782451,
-0.0568257831,
-0.0371266045,
-0.0153929982,
0.0037230728,
-0.0381902233,
0.0385792404,
0.0217213817,
0.0153479772,
0.0403249227,
-0.0590708442,
-0.071764119,
0.094443582,
-0.0373150147,
-0.0028789791,
-0.01865918,
0.0808869377,
-0.0226373039,
-0.0005247674,
0.0153345643,
-0.0320343599,
0.0764895231,
-0.0370643847,
-0.0443657003,
-0.0441853926,
-0.0441580787,
-0.028335942,
0.0039841421,
0.0591795631,
-0.0112302229,
0.0560590178,
-0.0656073689,
0.0285853464,
0.0323394313,
0.066861771,
-0.0094310269,
-0.0032009808,
0.0301285554,
0.0008393414,
-0.0163267907,
0.0168141909,
0.0172634088,
-0.0366758369,
-0.0021297724,
0.0684490204,
0.0412226543,
0.0648731664,
-0.0236951299,
0.039423462,
-0.0128983865,
0.0325964428,
0.0206410326,
0.0135816662,
-0.0301417205,
-0.0084845908,
-0.0141447112,
-0.0065614535,
-0.0173946992,
0.0675877407,
-0.0235894881,
0.0206651054,
-0.009397232,
-0.009241404,
0.0707211867,
-0.0339173973,
0.0773048252,
0.0093674073,
0.0185853932,
-0.0023487641,
-0.0122887483,
-0.0317307375,
0.0079891598,
0.0254108515,
-0.0106673501,
-0.0062802085,
0.0324256532,
0.0318202786,
-0.0621477477,
0.0376108997,
-0.0091359951,
0.0427636206,
-0.0196411107,
0.0112490868,
0.0345843807,
-0.0129363909,
-0.0750618652,
-0.0596123487,
0.0163910631,
-0.0713984668,
0.032277178,
0.0125190876,
-0.0068466072,
0.0224448405,
0.0051389299,
-0.0049897903,
-0.0188576691,
0.0168097671,
0.0463882461,
-0.0504139699,
-0.0110726384,
-0.0043469127,
0.0407113247,
-5.989087881e-33,
0.0083947284,
0.0619612634,
-0.0047394321,
0.0302488152,
-0.0082239825,
0.0534582697,
-0.0087620439,
-0.0137628978,
-0.0315551683,
-0.0112796072,
0.0007038839,
0.0033331092,
0.0304627009,
0.0033873594,
-0.0074454225,
0.0251776092,
0.0914007649,
-0.0035378572,
0.0291810445,
0.0138044581,
0.034456864,
0.0107244179,
0.035253685,
-0.0827699378,
-0.0596390516,
0.0298236012,
-0.0137036135,
0.0018270649,
0.0227394998,
0.0415099226,
-0.0074972264,
0.0747940093,
-0.0163346007,
-0.0519084893,
-0.0128703918,
0.0264959373,
-0.0842162594,
-0.0419448167,
-0.0505624376,
0.0314692482,
0.0394343212,
-0.0245454144,
0.0168788787,
0.0151004763,
-0.0421030819,
0.0051591033,
0.0281960964,
-0.0155275287,
0.0167620387,
-0.0031720304,
-0.0293224175,
0.0459031314,
0.0038614552,
0.0055576409,
0.0555141866,
0.0417878926,
-0.0068561682,
-0.0340389051,
-0.1229148656,
0.0125886276,
-0.0262481254,
-0.0107002221,
0.0120024243,
-0.0167359598,
-0.010794119,
0.0070813377,
0.1251334548,
-0.1007856652,
-0.010351182,
0.0049068364,
0.0463223755,
0.023650961,
0.0396185443,
0.0137551017,
0.0536286347,
-0.0686255395,
-0.0480935499,
0.0280666482,
0.0758052096,
0.0063909502,
-0.0150850266,
-0.0038692895,
-0.0210297965,
0.0056446516,
-0.0253870338,
-0.0377626792,
-0.0260373037,
-0.0453872345,
0.0296157822,
-0.0065785553,
0.008884267,
0.0772803724,
0.0328924917,
-0.0034399068,
0.0018196033,
-0.0044537811,
0.0085051795,
-0.0130916173,
0.0063721146,
0.0614225157,
-0.0663142875,
-0.03654062,
0.0214604717,
0.0113590853,
0.0240656286,
-0.0017939045,
0.0277088527,
0.0788803548,
-0.0709377006,
0.0063156965,
0.0063494253,
-0.0152576063,
-0.0028136482,
0.0160700995,
0.0415560268,
0.018222224,
0.0430111289,
-0.0087045906,
0.0209041592,
0.0182970818,
0.0181844551,
-0.0664414018,
0.0380515009,
0.0462117158,
0.004386758,
0.0122294165,
0.0172574595,
-0.0408916697,
-0.0041366583,
-0.0351802893,
-0.0148247797,
-0.0190925915,
2.79e-7,
-0.0287472606,
0.0015043908,
0.0145667503,
-0.033476986,
0.0261211451,
0.0003357341,
-0.0384016931,
-0.0063230265,
-0.0285302512,
0.0453192256,
0.0188467707,
-0.0057846517,
0.0673681051,
0.06738244,
-0.0301240571,
0.0059325206,
-0.0579232983,
0.0304408353,
-0.0103339683,
0.0129218521,
0.0322826169,
0.1052555889,
-0.0119098658,
-0.041410882,
0.0168405324,
-0.0298839249,
-0.000201826,
-0.0223338231,
0.0283966176,
-0.0194734614,
0.0525905974,
-0.0076651177,
-0.0110322842,
0.0325603336,
-0.0166474748,
0.0783708468,
0.0221414436,
-0.0020867283,
-0.023891734,
-0.0415569954,
0.0086528659,
0.0009437205,
-0.062456768,
-0.0549657606,
0.0801730976,
-0.0072808554,
-0.0238217022,
-0.0317052081,
-0.0253008138,
0.0135844313,
0.0346129648,
0.0080963653,
0.0194459036,
-0.0130289262,
0.0276763421,
-0.0315363444,
-0.0268808734,
-0.0701875836,
0.0109665254,
0.0465661585,
-0.0587962307,
0.0161116626,
-0.011150633,
0.0050740056,
-0.0141725736,
-0.0189741608,
0.0113151427,
2.343977291e-34,
0.0011261082,
-0.0591876432,
0.0127966702,
0.0140782986,
-0.0356728621,
-0.0390132405,
0.0082583455,
-0.001346315,
0.0033790825,
-0.0137167433,
-0.0513090864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18281v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18281v1 | HyperConformer: Multi-head HyperMixer for Efficient Speech Recognition | 2023-05-29T17:53:04 | 2023-05-29T17:53:04 | Florian Mai, Juan Zuluaga-Gomez, Titouan Parcollet, Petr Motlicek | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS | State-of-the-art ASR systems have achieved promising results by modeling
local and global interactions separately. While the former can be computed
efficiently, global interactions are usually modeled via attention mechanisms,
which are expensive for long input sequences. Here, we address this by
extending HyperMixer, an efficient alternative to attention exhibiting linear
complexity, to the Conformer architecture for speech recognition, leading to
HyperConformer. In particular, multi-head HyperConformer achieves comparable or
higher recognition performance while being more efficient than Conformer in
terms of inference speed, memory, parameter count, and available training data.
HyperConformer achieves a word error rate of 2.9% on Librispeech test-clean
with less than 8M neural parameters and a peak memory during training of 5.7GB,
hence trainable with accessible hardware. Encoder speed is between 38% on
mid-length speech and 56% on long speech faster than an equivalent Conformer.
(The HyperConformer recipe is publicly available in:
https://github.com/speechbrain/speechbrain/tree/develop/recipes/LibriSpeech/ASR/transformer/) | [
-0.0219100975,
0.0358065069,
0.0173791647,
0.0380295143,
0.0187200811,
-0.0035526224,
0.0344416872,
-0.033151336,
0.0089240931,
0.0051478758,
-0.0496592484,
-0.0298328418,
0.0473316722,
0.012094574,
0.0229361262,
-0.0238420889,
0.0197835229,
-0.03936572,
0.0029097751,
-0.0166599341,
0.0053482847,
-0.0038795774,
-0.0211149938,
0.0256198309,
-0.014608115,
0.0412423313,
-0.0295000076,
-0.0184015818,
0.0596458279,
0.0093686366,
0.001363516,
0.0079209749,
0.0386730731,
0.0338385813,
0.0000021493,
0.0100960685,
0.006236047,
-0.0157094263,
-0.0345429741,
-0.0002035102,
-0.0336859599,
-0.0342283137,
-0.0183650609,
0.0375815034,
-0.0145311607,
-0.0403650887,
0.0498900749,
0.0342921019,
0.0144162159,
0.054362759,
-0.0068039917,
-0.0445215479,
0.0358280763,
-0.0208358951,
-0.0253612902,
-0.0334546454,
-0.0090268366,
-0.0627606511,
-0.0247604977,
-0.0270023793,
-0.0255449321,
0.0229597576,
0.0292487629,
-0.0098844944,
0.0362252891,
0.0018593203,
-0.032205455,
-0.034508232,
-0.0342078619,
0.0700049251,
-0.0432302319,
-0.0168092363,
-0.0034443815,
0.0086073074,
-0.051456593,
-0.0179437082,
-0.0027927803,
0.0343138464,
-0.0090182805,
0.0010948433,
-0.0014659582,
-0.0035468712,
0.0220565703,
-0.01580883,
-0.0403969884,
0.0168543942,
-0.0097984262,
-0.0268026758,
0.0193121526,
-0.0284417961,
0.0052110641,
-0.0203920621,
0.0421179384,
0.0472812131,
-0.0305899922,
-0.0236319844,
-0.0361814015,
-0.0597057231,
0.0121483644,
-0.0926229358,
0.0225409083,
0.0527011789,
-0.0178062301,
0.0304978546,
-0.0396135934,
0.0844976977,
-0.029618511,
-0.0126455277,
0.0080762366,
-0.0179309696,
0.0138952443,
0.0367975719,
-0.0351632126,
0.0375630558,
-0.045523487,
-0.0729763284,
-0.0159983095,
0.0159842335,
-0.0197878517,
0.0147401709,
0.0281957332,
-0.0197576396,
-0.0190893803,
-0.0050346055,
0.0301710907,
0.0827606618,
-0.0093330611,
-0.0199950412,
0.0047227954,
-0.060861975,
-0.054782737,
0.0502127558,
0.0484008677,
-0.0388028137,
0.0062509109,
0.082158193,
-0.0040601846,
-0.0499158502,
0.0169752557,
0.0202782359,
-0.0095389364,
-0.0340643078,
0.0397867113,
-0.0258104149,
0.0560993031,
-0.0231665913,
-0.0097860089,
-0.0094552645,
0.0227181409,
-0.0162508506,
0.0095801856,
0.0383169912,
0.0032035243,
-0.0332348123,
0.0230895709,
-0.0247697439,
0.0188468359,
0.0320614651,
0.0301900078,
0.0001617581,
-0.0389951617,
-0.0655867383,
0.0201163124,
0.0130864047,
-0.0085954061,
-0.0553408079,
-0.008038193,
-0.0231222138,
0.050471805,
0.0180341825,
0.0565507337,
0.068707861,
-0.0358660705,
-0.0140410475,
0.0285108723,
-0.0164188724,
0.0239638332,
-0.0163328163,
0.0264253505,
-0.0190399587,
-0.0113908816,
-0.0007668497,
-0.0703740641,
0.0596405007,
-0.0082063153,
0.0045553627,
0.0381998233,
0.0429844074,
-0.0353920236,
0.003780233,
-0.0015607851,
-0.0230630767,
-0.0284976475,
0.0131614842,
0.0374353826,
0.0125785712,
-0.0609607175,
0.0728925318,
0.0047290488,
-0.057733655,
-0.0018151478,
-0.0213339385,
0.0148471324,
0.0319001339,
0.0232847631,
-0.040952459,
-0.0346825458,
-0.0502752103,
0.0017788759,
0.0369237997,
0.033116661,
0.0235802531,
0.0735377371,
-0.0914665312,
0.004334013,
0.0467611812,
-0.0025277301,
0.056698814,
0.0053199111,
-0.0016661398,
0.0024280613,
0.0500498004,
0.047086034,
-0.0018599888,
0.0365685858,
-0.0076306495,
0.00398375,
0.0389898568,
0.0462657362,
0.0094503472,
-0.0224322919,
-0.0329966247,
0.0557076596,
-0.06056026,
-0.0056528458,
0.0010259307,
-0.0757994428,
-0.0280465297,
0.0318977088,
-0.030709153,
0.0100216232,
0.0586022362,
-0.0010108348,
-0.0877854601,
0.0272822995,
-0.0520200357,
0.1143212616,
-0.0108006671,
0.0656495392,
0.0264393389,
0.0680490583,
0.0189747382,
0.000850543,
0.0008962833,
0.0040756287,
0.0212948062,
-0.0289487336,
-0.0424367227,
-0.0657810718,
-0.0360972174,
0.0365193859,
-0.01062751,
-0.0114389556,
-0.0184003692,
-0.0238974113,
0.0258892123,
-0.0349393822,
-0.0181826614,
-0.0379079841,
-0.0215779897,
0.0233918224,
-0.0207330268,
0.0460986644,
0.0356753916,
-0.0116378032,
-0.0015110256,
0.0309369527,
-0.0169192031,
-0.0182936266,
-0.0291958079,
-0.0084975082,
-0.05936037,
-0.0157180894,
-0.0280637871,
0.0202096161,
0.0186230484,
-0.0107276198,
-0.0271946695,
-0.0293763094,
-0.065976873,
0.0163426418,
0.0452946126,
-0.0101431254,
-0.0306729954,
-0.0294714794,
-0.0065423883,
0.0253646374,
0.0576439798,
0.0075121741,
-0.0256472081,
0.0262257848,
0.0206393283,
-0.0356575064,
0.0132835731,
-0.0064841346,
0.0339184999,
-0.0301919207,
0.0278390739,
-0.0455296412,
0.0587284826,
0.0149039673,
0.0257780589,
-0.0322433151,
-0.0240365341,
0.0589006655,
-0.0264042001,
0.0105694085,
-0.0470676571,
-0.037632294,
-0.0146319307,
-0.032123331,
-0.0338301808,
0.0486948229,
-0.0661222339,
-0.0318044238,
0.0094919307,
-0.0127071142,
-0.001147007,
-0.0006194714,
0.0390550271,
0.0285630077,
-0.0113134049,
-0.059801966,
0.0259337127,
0.033362139,
0.0013143966,
-0.010943044,
0.0591514409,
-0.0165571403,
-0.0152974306,
-0.0302859358,
-0.0221586265,
-0.0151518406,
0.0334915519,
-0.0156397931,
0.0549092554,
0.032660041,
-0.0422122404,
-0.0648298189,
0.0352316573,
0.0415777974,
0.0640823171,
0.0013860062,
0.0251354203,
-0.0500889719,
0.0422407836,
0.0243918467,
0.0741501376,
0.0311454218,
0.0096687106,
0.0332663208,
0.016341608,
0.0614082925,
0.0040338999,
-0.0612367317,
-0.0163612161,
0.0296333581,
-0.0173247233,
0.0438920259,
-0.0100139277,
0.0558767505,
-0.0649781302,
0.0317836553,
0.0970177352,
-0.0012097118,
-0.0424178578,
-0.015185412,
0.0030889839,
0.0177360326,
0.0193986893,
-0.0129346522,
-0.0275212266,
-0.0182609484,
0.0547677875,
0.025633309,
0.0090830438,
0.0206003096,
0.0297513288,
-0.0600328967,
0.0200584624,
0.0087479483,
-0.0752818137,
-0.074194178,
-0.0637636557,
-0.0249496773,
-0.049514696,
0.0638264641,
0.029319128,
-0.0069076046,
-0.0637270287,
-0.0196293965,
-0.0616397187,
-0.0255008116,
0.0220972504,
-0.0079392791,
0.0651929304,
0.041711472,
0.0046239165,
0.0030065752,
-0.0675408766,
0.0165495649,
0.0077131661,
0.0244076792,
-0.0264574364,
0.0343884081,
0.0069687678,
-0.0338323191,
0.0279747434,
0.0143304449,
-0.0413162746,
0.0278786942,
-0.0054026167,
0.0825744718,
-0.0328462087,
-0.0148815699,
0.0198601969,
-0.0056133731,
-0.0029523885,
0.0425588414,
0.0386710651,
0.0007427756,
-0.0427815989,
0.0006384259,
0.0077755898,
-0.0063841497,
0.0100458274,
-0.0190618914,
0.0343464091,
-0.0619558133,
-0.0044443295,
0.0008139315,
0.0219023749,
0.0567858368,
0.021272555,
-0.057590086,
-0.0006031134,
0.0056308722,
-0.035555765,
0.0105856862,
-0.0080932435,
0.0027445836,
-0.0701349452,
0.008748292,
0.0430294201,
-0.0046609337,
0.0080588162,
0.0848409757,
-0.0205571987,
-0.0657140762,
-0.0217958353,
0.0597735532,
0.0147321168,
0.0639043897,
-0.0334197916,
-0.0239245947,
-0.0072973985,
-0.0584792122,
-0.0289796498,
0.0609750375,
0.0600087009,
-0.0397576429,
-0.0108778616,
0.0242035966,
-0.0124163795,
0.0238560624,
0.0022968624,
0.0134808784,
-0.0346783735,
-0.0447190553,
-0.0044612936,
0.0278164912,
0.0553742647,
0.0383643694,
0.0574825406,
-0.028822843,
0.0574835017,
0.0132403821,
0.0685661584,
-0.0239142329,
-0.0155563336,
0.004795257,
0.0267732013,
0.0180012323,
0.0383265503,
-0.013115597,
-0.0395478159,
-0.0132462205,
0.0873549432,
-0.0317325369,
0.0122804344,
0.0077808811,
-0.0045814961,
-0.0314941816,
0.0190092996,
0.0581208989,
0.021082649,
-0.0147729851,
0.015628241,
-0.0034012427,
0.0092637297,
-0.0025663744,
-0.0109452829,
-0.0726351961,
-0.0218263213,
-0.0240973812,
0.0012410458,
0.0327987261,
-0.0011701833,
0.0691068321,
0.0326283723,
-0.0002054352,
-0.0132914158,
0.046372015,
-0.0306016933,
-0.0242534485,
0.0384430028,
0.0277290903,
-0.0046638022,
0.0162450075,
0.0266869981,
-0.060206484,
0.0186779611,
0.013416525,
0.0592039786,
-0.0542788431,
-0.0612113476,
-0.0099767605,
0.0349500254,
-0.0295487009,
-0.0270187818,
0.0291362684,
-0.0366045572,
0.0634603351,
-0.0330846831,
0.0162081793,
-0.034744218,
0.0158984419,
-0.0633459613,
-0.0081943506,
-0.0422993079,
0.0267346278,
-0.0174085535,
0.0097430628,
-0.0111307213,
-0.0077650328,
-6.469021654e-33,
-0.0290996693,
0.0199326258,
-0.0069579184,
-0.0003878649,
-0.0831213593,
0.0099258488,
-0.0461212173,
0.0109107364,
-0.0577594861,
-0.0432443283,
-0.0039962428,
0.0127870245,
0.0246364959,
0.0398304202,
0.0289783087,
0.0122750923,
0.0792463794,
-0.0123223951,
-0.0093532233,
0.0000703491,
0.0323434062,
0.0241540242,
0.0579855368,
-0.0337357633,
-0.0817958489,
0.038095884,
-0.0132005494,
-0.0074861776,
-0.0156851783,
0.0178504586,
-0.0118565131,
0.048709888,
-0.0090169339,
-0.0487319678,
-0.0013802323,
0.0271719545,
-0.1030814946,
0.006681039,
-0.0465745702,
0.0322971158,
0.0094533106,
-0.047822766,
0.0708772615,
0.0212748442,
0.0121351229,
-0.0298459958,
0.0323829427,
-0.0267190468,
-0.0604132302,
-0.0154054854,
-0.0295057073,
0.0241261721,
-0.0029540514,
0.0196024869,
0.0503277481,
0.0624768995,
-0.0150094479,
-0.0184657928,
-0.0751791075,
0.012884682,
0.0040671802,
0.0381572396,
0.0342589021,
0.0386856459,
0.0276205745,
0.020693291,
0.0816979036,
-0.0551062226,
-0.0083276005,
0.0175976902,
0.032379847,
0.0188145917,
0.0212874226,
0.0191353206,
0.0336590447,
-0.035459362,
-0.0181732085,
-0.0319791846,
0.0032149856,
0.0617002286,
0.0184593629,
0.0081993248,
-0.0344084352,
0.0053681554,
-0.0112186838,
0.0139812985,
-0.0512042977,
-0.0041510579,
0.0123080481,
0.0352256857,
-0.0044000475,
-0.0014955255,
0.0376381464,
-0.0093161287,
0.0780580863,
0.0520950258,
0.0605905354,
0.0193888303,
0.0065784771,
0.0123772873,
-0.045891691,
-0.0502838716,
0.0130306343,
0.0228816364,
0.004052191,
-0.0103304042,
0.0058933175,
0.065531075,
-0.0774037763,
-0.0365522876,
-0.0110773044,
0.0304153822,
0.0028276274,
0.0257087387,
0.0428403132,
-0.0480546467,
0.0210928898,
0.0257059578,
-0.0584644377,
0.0062370477,
-0.0078214929,
0.0312934667,
0.0344364494,
0.0196546093,
-0.0354569331,
0.009347884,
-0.0051517542,
-0.0109493667,
0.0223649554,
-0.0541338176,
-0.0112363836,
0.0230098665,
2.915e-7,
-0.052519951,
-0.0002737643,
0.0287562683,
-0.0337041505,
0.024828501,
-0.0528975278,
0.0311608762,
0.0118504083,
-0.0347394943,
0.0039000406,
0.0130825005,
0.0407341905,
0.0492025502,
-0.0062202481,
-0.0838830322,
-0.0531518795,
-0.0236232001,
-0.0098546827,
-0.0092489673,
-0.0054192338,
-0.0092738103,
0.0947615355,
-0.0129341055,
-0.0142680751,
0.0135639077,
0.0322437286,
-0.0044534998,
0.0111114411,
0.0526819117,
-0.0218392555,
-0.0230031516,
-0.0354477689,
-0.0746240094,
0.0349329114,
-0.0057591922,
0.0412399732,
-0.0299823321,
0.0787198991,
-0.0272488501,
-0.1222119182,
0.030085599,
0.0362868905,
-0.0129071632,
-0.0198398959,
0.0311574824,
-0.0329181366,
-0.025074074,
-0.0375848375,
-0.0368562452,
-0.0028603149,
-0.0261257049,
-0.0236322116,
0.0394630693,
-0.009251805,
-0.0076839994,
-0.0461074896,
-0.0006637601,
-0.0769694075,
0.0292839687,
0.0203275271,
-0.0748966262,
-0.020606529,
-0.0121724103,
-0.061092779,
0.0445085429,
0.0062003038,
-0.0507404394,
2.308145836e-34,
0.0498274229,
-0.0631332546,
0.0169833042,
0.0308065154,
0.0098857153,
-0.0482686125,
-0.0278347209,
-0.0112619977,
0.017814273,
-0.107139051,
-0.048846364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18513v1 | SlimFit: Memory-Efficient Fine-Tuning of Transformer-based Models Using Training Dynamics | 2023-05-29T17:50:52 | 2023-05-29T17:50:52 | Arash Ardakani, Altan Haan, Shangyin Tan, Doru Thom Popovici, Alvin Cheung, Costin Iancu, Koushik Sen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based models, such as BERT and ViT, have achieved
state-of-the-art results across different natural language processing (NLP) and
computer vision (CV) tasks. However, these models are extremely memory
intensive during their fine-tuning process, making them difficult to deploy on
GPUs with limited memory resources. To address this issue, we introduce a new
tool called SlimFit that reduces the memory requirements of these models by
dynamically analyzing their training dynamics and freezing less-contributory
layers during fine-tuning. The layers to freeze are chosen using a runtime
inter-layer scheduling algorithm. SlimFit adopts quantization and pruning for
particular layers to balance the load of dynamic activations and to minimize
the memory footprint of static activations, where static activations refer to
those that cannot be discarded regardless of freezing. This allows SlimFit to
freeze up to 95% of layers and reduce the overall on-device GPU memory usage of
transformer-based models such as ViT and BERT by an average of 2.2x, across
different NLP and CV benchmarks/datasets such as GLUE, SQuAD 2.0, CIFAR-10,
CIFAR-100 and ImageNet with an average degradation of 0.2% in accuracy. For
such NLP and CV tasks, SlimFit can reduce up to 3.1x the total on-device memory
usage with an accuracy degradation of only up to 0.4%. As a result, while
fine-tuning of ViT on ImageNet and BERT on SQuAD 2.0 with a batch size of 128
requires 3 and 2 32GB GPUs respectively, SlimFit enables their fine-tuning on a
single 32GB GPU without any significant accuracy degradation. | [
0.0454959087,
0.0298709273,
-0.0081733093,
0.0433297046,
-0.0059227059,
0.0010012875,
0.0185823478,
-0.0218546707,
-0.0261959061,
-0.0453714468,
-0.046615418,
-0.0268190671,
0.0152066741,
0.0047356808,
-0.0039843596,
-0.0831577778,
0.0474028252,
-0.0030882049,
-0.0153483674,
0.0214573219,
0.0097400835,
0.0126872212,
-0.0043551084,
0.043853242,
-0.0238116886,
-0.0148884999,
-0.0074138655,
0.0216529798,
0.0400466025,
0.0180462785,
0.0115855075,
0.0715722591,
0.0212068614,
0.0083178179,
0.0000022685,
-0.0109724719,
-0.0183451623,
0.0031419757,
-0.0158068389,
0.0223171748,
0.0299851056,
-0.0292203017,
-0.0221279413,
0.0143218506,
-0.0229736306,
-0.0161020067,
0.0325531587,
0.0031740943,
0.0534979738,
0.0449651293,
-0.013033268,
-0.0313684829,
0.0294567086,
-0.0239918437,
-0.023897972,
-0.0660963655,
0.0013885738,
-0.0497723259,
-0.0396660157,
-0.0790462568,
-0.0291037746,
0.0399425104,
0.0407901742,
0.0202134717,
-0.0158471707,
0.038323056,
-0.0804650187,
-0.0590408407,
-0.028348593,
0.0355505124,
-0.1006897762,
-0.0175912604,
0.0178997666,
0.005955121,
-0.0227209851,
0.0028869079,
-0.0090151988,
0.0167440865,
-0.0114544341,
-0.016021587,
-0.0346786529,
0.0011307783,
0.0320505984,
0.0328684077,
-0.0224721078,
-0.02765847,
0.0212061238,
0.0084663769,
-0.0095318574,
0.0172200445,
-0.0436646231,
-0.0396905467,
0.005804033,
0.0080694612,
-0.048265405,
-0.0067625432,
-0.0908221602,
-0.0716023445,
-0.025061531,
-0.0251668897,
0.0351720564,
0.0391110256,
0.024814941,
0.038938649,
-0.0349189825,
0.0577302873,
-0.0112101212,
0.0296911709,
-0.0157691706,
-0.010568439,
-0.0267656986,
-0.0049465941,
-0.0776675791,
0.0137611367,
-0.0439047255,
-0.0506154113,
-0.039444562,
-0.0209267773,
-0.0109383389,
-0.0261759404,
0.0300359037,
0.0540211424,
-0.0399271138,
0.0241560042,
0.0202431306,
0.0367058069,
0.01142071,
0.01176685,
-0.0100553418,
-0.0802312717,
-0.0055350768,
0.013514108,
-0.0006547086,
-0.0271473452,
0.0404040962,
0.0345964879,
-0.0147168003,
-0.0803630576,
-0.0303334985,
0.0363318585,
-0.0042797448,
-0.081033811,
0.0153561626,
-0.0517048649,
0.0253772661,
-0.01903864,
0.04256339,
-0.0025347772,
0.026652528,
0.0306534301,
-0.0304035041,
0.0876692981,
-0.0084226318,
-0.0165005308,
0.0042884676,
0.0105961449,
0.0459215231,
0.0516297892,
0.0633907244,
0.033480566,
0.025650233,
-0.0279225875,
0.0132139176,
0.0437530503,
0.0130581912,
-0.0085135223,
-0.061434228,
-0.0100271562,
-0.0480445214,
0.0286447387,
0.0158669967,
0.0613744892,
-0.0355907753,
-0.0300932843,
0.067515336,
0.0510601215,
0.0103155784,
0.0493936576,
0.0182869639,
-0.0123590296,
0.010764502,
-0.0389762484,
-0.0644889101,
0.0616285875,
0.0166857354,
-0.0103934212,
-0.022024883,
0.0707641318,
-0.0191258248,
-0.0122396806,
0.0009535055,
-0.0278856438,
0.0038058984,
0.0134718679,
0.0210334305,
0.0274237525,
-0.0352010615,
0.1281401217,
-0.0212453343,
-0.0353415795,
-0.0520282686,
-0.0702784434,
-0.0034358557,
0.059102688,
0.0237168837,
0.0065761688,
-0.0851043388,
0.0062038568,
-0.0001179574,
0.0401086062,
0.0326187164,
0.0097212661,
0.0372050367,
-0.0850732252,
-0.0119841844,
-0.0018082876,
0.005718559,
-0.0075315777,
0.0688444376,
0.0093538323,
0.0041470686,
-0.0244555511,
-0.0044994266,
0.0333733931,
0.0129390405,
-0.0028234264,
0.0202201214,
0.0063475911,
-0.0040887771,
-0.0128695956,
-0.0373289511,
-0.0262384731,
0.056197565,
-0.0280546024,
0.0111977281,
0.0171945971,
-0.030278556,
0.0214227755,
0.0086282613,
0.0019998541,
0.0258999262,
0.0296694618,
-0.0568348356,
-0.0374210849,
-0.0038228282,
-0.039150916,
0.0193722416,
-0.0197829455,
0.0138924774,
-0.0144910729,
0.0224347673,
-0.0118255876,
0.038761802,
-0.0279460605,
-0.0005301854,
0.040916793,
0.0271055289,
-0.0031968565,
-0.0187877994,
-0.0099383267,
0.0155146066,
-0.0035336006,
0.0121671716,
0.0066107349,
0.0079509262,
-0.0169514623,
-0.0452929139,
-0.0637052506,
0.0314825326,
-0.0406389758,
-0.0059383386,
0.024646705,
0.0419860259,
0.0047964025,
-0.0139537081,
0.0313546918,
0.0300604478,
-0.0071570803,
0.0096141677,
-0.027087573,
-0.0187820029,
0.0050938507,
-0.0118044335,
-0.031319093,
0.0286405776,
0.0532004088,
-0.010036747,
-0.0369097106,
-0.0162664577,
-0.01534844,
0.0097766481,
0.0460012816,
-0.0072478894,
-0.0609599762,
-0.0035854739,
0.0200997051,
0.0342451334,
0.0973316282,
0.0345208608,
0.0160112977,
0.0169667639,
-0.0008022253,
-0.0349254832,
0.0373635069,
-0.0180068631,
-0.0157618094,
-0.0461187549,
0.0122887203,
-0.0424471572,
0.0908880904,
-0.0429696254,
0.0314881168,
-0.055029884,
-0.0036390077,
-0.0058350642,
-0.0190221183,
0.018946711,
0.0077626659,
-0.0320520885,
-0.0192744657,
-0.0298004393,
-0.0675953031,
0.0186856277,
-0.0416434109,
-0.0107844975,
-0.0551705621,
0.0053434675,
-0.0144944135,
0.0502234139,
0.0135313291,
0.0179012213,
-0.019888984,
-0.0011593993,
-0.0164839476,
-0.023966413,
-0.0116925891,
-0.0273999516,
0.0373396277,
-0.017938558,
0.0093693193,
-0.0312457141,
-0.0323015414,
-0.0318673961,
0.0104915667,
-0.0442452282,
0.0166765954,
0.0232138876,
-0.0688858926,
-0.0745396316,
0.0284729004,
0.0156988185,
0.0780844465,
-0.0116296904,
-0.0175466128,
-0.0235952474,
0.0283014458,
0.0588952601,
0.0834888071,
0.0137471342,
0.0023321987,
0.0006635323,
0.0611668788,
0.0200009309,
-0.0064953733,
-0.0925936103,
0.0120645603,
0.0237787515,
-0.0029741458,
-0.02252491,
0.0082269376,
0.0625978261,
-0.0943970904,
-0.016152449,
0.0690076649,
0.0200344231,
-0.0338014774,
-0.0010121097,
0.067662783,
0.0278514884,
0.0377943031,
0.0260162577,
-0.0464121476,
-0.0592226572,
0.0191569105,
0.0441989042,
0.0151347611,
0.0036251426,
0.0033227834,
-0.0762230083,
0.0379116684,
-0.0178393777,
0.0185227599,
0.0133435419,
-0.0223472957,
-0.0172822457,
-0.0368621312,
0.0094664358,
-0.037281476,
-0.0042812801,
-0.0148405852,
0.0292973462,
-0.0079629198,
-0.030550275,
0.0174201857,
-0.0335102491,
-0.0067132474,
0.0619726703,
0.0076495265,
0.0177667923,
-0.0631554648,
0.0619789101,
-0.0121807875,
0.020324925,
-0.0324574038,
0.0636868477,
-0.0211267453,
-0.0238048714,
-0.0061678751,
0.0064851698,
-0.0094084628,
-0.0505041815,
-0.0416560657,
0.0428645238,
-0.0014500041,
0.0041122399,
-0.0268753525,
-0.0022121419,
-0.0293121394,
0.0461887307,
-0.0015264541,
-0.0286945943,
-0.0407961383,
0.0079723513,
-0.0008274392,
-0.0829483941,
-0.0464096963,
-0.0009590714,
0.0002716215,
-0.0513146594,
0.0025804588,
0.0129342517,
0.0120681878,
0.0544353314,
0.0050752554,
-0.0407245159,
0.0302527789,
0.0540866368,
-0.0869352296,
0.0549702868,
0.0025944742,
0.0454052091,
-0.0621300712,
-0.0112755969,
0.058602713,
-0.0184348673,
-0.0165702831,
0.0343841314,
-0.0986779854,
-0.0381010436,
0.006890743,
0.0719989166,
0.0260733459,
0.0602575839,
-0.0059531103,
-0.0357744098,
0.0125837252,
0.0979270115,
-0.0448661372,
0.0303537566,
0.0012400991,
-0.0782203004,
-0.0180497076,
0.0246464033,
-0.0223793611,
0.0236650147,
0.0322484896,
0.0276981201,
-0.0352751054,
-0.0346485265,
-0.0048037828,
-0.0397487134,
0.0545138009,
-0.0195045955,
0.0137351258,
-0.0015552561,
0.0406432264,
0.0533620752,
0.0207235236,
-0.0547653101,
-0.0138984527,
0.0258753113,
0.0187064428,
-0.0219957009,
0.029094493,
0.050119143,
-0.0492391996,
-0.0383222364,
0.0220230464,
0.0108896336,
-0.0152044781,
0.0154723423,
0.0126170162,
-0.0098303948,
0.0247344561,
-0.0003881531,
0.0263664257,
-0.02507779,
0.0162864476,
0.0240994953,
0.0039777402,
-0.0517730527,
0.0407469347,
-0.0342761315,
-0.056661617,
-0.0398729816,
0.0185771119,
0.0410697572,
-0.0366414897,
0.0251840241,
-0.0168088228,
-0.0069838786,
-0.0033141105,
-0.0009036198,
0.0196288973,
0.0010030471,
0.0303634964,
0.0099353222,
-0.0005664639,
-0.0031458561,
0.0496445261,
-0.0096793938,
0.065360643,
0.0092718471,
-0.0271366611,
-0.0415790416,
-0.0315100066,
-0.0220633149,
-0.0159988515,
-0.0124835065,
0.0130382087,
-0.0253849048,
-0.0356812589,
0.0286251456,
-0.020468181,
0.041723188,
-0.0245545115,
0.0395500176,
0.0477893353,
0.0154170422,
-0.0360831805,
0.0056876391,
0.0096195126,
0.0035504776,
-0.0044633741,
0.0051944694,
-6.520046925e-33,
-0.0184336808,
0.0071448432,
0.0333922096,
0.0142285107,
-0.0176432803,
0.0426770747,
-0.020171525,
-0.0138933994,
-0.0249119513,
-0.0064088851,
-0.0225582682,
0.0136200394,
0.0335051715,
0.0250738412,
-0.0195642151,
-0.0063591385,
0.0772494525,
-0.023818817,
-0.0347454846,
0.0282066241,
0.0035387939,
0.0552527718,
0.0533847623,
-0.0308882184,
-0.0881761163,
0.0241783336,
-0.0023145678,
0.0138160167,
-0.0210048966,
0.0491860136,
-0.0238794759,
-0.0037546859,
0.0036068191,
-0.037405517,
-0.0134816105,
0.0254348554,
-0.1083505973,
0.0233992077,
0.007133191,
0.0569250323,
-0.0356167406,
-0.0168133508,
0.0571720712,
0.0244398899,
-0.0113039548,
-0.0202681106,
0.0057872618,
-0.0209497027,
-0.0301747937,
-0.0855851546,
-0.0693269074,
0.0338339917,
0.0134350127,
-0.0516296811,
0.0506638698,
-0.0221472066,
-0.0286803562,
0.0200623162,
-0.0996433198,
-0.0311539192,
-0.0147653492,
0.0630416349,
0.0657883584,
0.0414335728,
-0.0074452362,
0.0457255878,
0.0202491507,
-0.014550711,
0.0039151669,
0.019432215,
0.0625170097,
0.0673512369,
0.0545344204,
-0.0050758719,
0.0637709573,
-0.01826928,
-0.0389008373,
-0.032627251,
0.0278569367,
0.0617574304,
0.0361811109,
0.0061180592,
0.0105838375,
0.0095239552,
-0.013125482,
0.0210269578,
-0.0209591556,
0.0149165979,
0.0518087856,
0.0732986256,
-0.0413897149,
0.0289471652,
0.0424457379,
-0.0273303073,
0.0647253692,
-0.0199536979,
0.0291119702,
0.0338453911,
-0.0022061693,
0.0146960374,
-0.0506529845,
-0.0557595231,
0.0172315426,
0.0263279509,
0.0242760908,
0.0083440403,
0.0519270636,
0.0493031107,
-0.0617709048,
-0.0024690104,
-0.0312110521,
0.0461765416,
-0.0029571606,
0.0708208084,
0.0275497977,
0.0172481257,
-0.0180023815,
0.0088683059,
-0.0342603922,
-0.0018647653,
-0.0140915643,
0.0134330597,
0.0357735157,
0.0404751934,
-0.0144824097,
-0.0065650824,
-0.0705299452,
0.0053055952,
-0.0190074239,
-0.0849896446,
-0.0355950072,
0.043905247,
2.988e-7,
0.006231627,
0.0476798639,
-0.017388653,
-0.0288224686,
0.0218727645,
0.0019194984,
0.011291381,
0.0062601203,
0.0048284316,
0.0043106047,
-0.0111281546,
0.0321279764,
0.0568825044,
0.0115445247,
-0.0638017356,
-0.0112521797,
-0.0581601709,
0.0358605832,
-0.0315670297,
-0.0058426503,
-0.0137317842,
0.1089447439,
0.0086722039,
-0.0271860417,
0.0445188507,
-0.0248458143,
0.0259086397,
0.0012876269,
0.0387631841,
0.0086077508,
0.0146209477,
0.0652730465,
-0.038621176,
0.0191997699,
-0.0378539972,
0.0039110328,
-0.0032689839,
0.051296901,
-0.0375497453,
-0.0270844717,
0.0175472703,
-0.0023442013,
-0.0208796095,
-0.0556116328,
0.0503944904,
-0.0651195124,
-0.0093737412,
-0.0240235068,
-0.0034284825,
0.0164004155,
0.0248668417,
0.0029043111,
0.018304063,
0.02990482,
0.0360674448,
-0.0235504229,
-0.0528088138,
-0.0973533764,
-0.0095862364,
-0.0025808269,
-0.0525961705,
-0.0155625418,
-0.085872516,
-0.0387989692,
0.0412898399,
-0.033849325,
-0.0496560596,
3.10550248e-34,
0.0307747312,
0.0001240413,
0.0165167954,
0.0267375596,
0.0072362074,
0.0093584992,
0.0299220718,
0.0136680584,
-0.0324610695,
-0.0856056735,
-0.0350790843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18278v1 | Mathematical Structure of Syntactic Merge | 2023-05-29T17:50:32 | 2023-05-29T17:50:32 | Matilde Marcolli, Noam Chomsky, Robert Berwick | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.QA, math.RA, 68Q70, 16T05 | The syntactic Merge operation of the Minimalist Program in linguistics can be
described mathematically in terms of Hopf algebras, with a formalism similar to
the one arising in the physics of renormalization. This mathematical
formulation of Merge has good descriptive power, as phenomena empirically
observed in linguistics can be justified from simple mathematical arguments. It
also provides a possible mathematical model for externalization and for the
role of syntactic parameters. | [
-0.0091713555,
-0.0072955419,
-0.0409739651,
-0.0061448761,
-0.0446674824,
0.0304531753,
-0.0514618829,
0.0145069622,
0.0092534944,
-0.0461891368,
-0.0069690677,
-0.0548662357,
0.0293982495,
-0.0272639934,
0.0524323583,
-0.0634336621,
0.0865478143,
-0.0133961812,
-0.0640250593,
0.0153320152,
0.0152180279,
-0.0292988028,
-0.0124853672,
-0.0031162754,
0.0031921021,
-0.0111751007,
0.0134271216,
-0.0336704291,
0.0396703109,
0.0681721941,
-0.0539532937,
0.0285896566,
-0.0781151131,
0.0113810292,
0.0000012145,
-0.0643304288,
0.0095229903,
0.0108441496,
0.0039071566,
-0.0100685209,
0.02738587,
0.0095920376,
-0.040044073,
-0.0037113198,
-0.0143644772,
0.0192309991,
0.053712897,
0.0436329432,
0.0340883657,
0.0226697214,
-0.0019109509,
-0.1156159416,
0.0445466675,
-0.0003208476,
0.0146500068,
0.0286848247,
0.0751338005,
0.0030492274,
0.0097366292,
-0.0529860742,
-0.0176615007,
-0.0233432166,
-0.0064516091,
-0.0383483544,
-0.0061396696,
-0.0184689257,
-0.0136713972,
-0.006341673,
-0.0135986889,
-0.0005385715,
0.0001414244,
-0.030818712,
0.0009226096,
0.0488440581,
-0.0023390364,
-0.0067669461,
-0.0768151358,
0.0048810137,
0.0120796366,
0.0631736591,
0.0646812171,
-0.0250828248,
0.0038221802,
-0.0145881567,
-0.0403361246,
0.1083536744,
0.0739184245,
-0.0314913094,
-0.0257383753,
-0.0178110171,
0.0024364532,
-0.0691519603,
-0.0591978356,
0.019194942,
-0.0045412187,
0.0173723474,
-0.0297462624,
-0.0393169932,
-0.0127588976,
-0.0197763965,
-0.010357162,
0.0156896077,
0.0347604714,
0.039686542,
-0.0110280914,
0.0487633534,
-0.0196927488,
-0.0312228445,
-0.0556618646,
0.0201850198,
-0.0341278836,
-0.0364274643,
-0.0405525938,
0.0489088744,
0.0070521762,
-0.00677492,
-0.068958573,
0.0049262187,
-0.014444137,
-0.0307675041,
-0.0624679066,
-0.0482962392,
-0.0377112366,
0.002786505,
-0.0323994681,
-0.0111805582,
0.0084070209,
0.0040577445,
-0.0130577376,
-0.031850338,
-0.008496847,
0.0592587553,
-0.0120570688,
-0.0212344211,
-0.0683008656,
0.0517336205,
0.0232419632,
0.0548416115,
0.0430569276,
-0.0240782984,
-0.0206357576,
-0.0153846927,
-0.0117797861,
-0.0404345356,
0.0120057408,
-0.0207023025,
-0.0055279867,
-0.0298790652,
-0.0092978673,
0.0040718582,
-0.0236603729,
-0.0010449457,
-0.0191982742,
-0.0118294321,
-0.0406240709,
-0.0246515907,
0.0072163106,
0.0247160122,
-0.0262871925,
-0.0225925017,
0.0033210195,
-0.0217461046,
0.0123501038,
0.0207350384,
0.0127229458,
-0.0011999762,
-0.0651504844,
-0.0595153011,
0.0362429172,
-0.0381503925,
-0.0026321565,
0.1299110949,
-0.0145318164,
-0.0191548001,
-0.0270616282,
0.0584275052,
0.0867857039,
0.0363289304,
0.0009606106,
-0.0120146479,
0.0201985314,
0.0821698979,
0.0186184105,
-0.0247885119,
-0.0568274409,
0.0112073086,
-0.0036376414,
0.0318939574,
0.005797849,
-0.0284751765,
-0.0280589033,
0.0017078191,
0.0151805803,
-0.0734281018,
0.0407955237,
0.0335411839,
0.0122135272,
0.0282158386,
-0.0017563832,
-0.0245553292,
0.0674148649,
-0.022442041,
-0.0305398069,
-0.0148821305,
-0.0311682839,
0.000570589,
0.0417378545,
0.0030858202,
-0.0538119562,
0.0336703099,
-0.0042322599,
0.0076822448,
-0.0458798707,
-0.0005690077,
0.0173066296,
-0.0132930279,
0.0345615484,
-0.0154745691,
-0.0732475296,
0.0001124211,
0.0266248304,
0.0300369728,
0.0054810797,
0.0300809499,
0.0202070549,
-0.0212494452,
-0.0574101955,
0.0320168473,
0.0232958272,
0.0171947293,
-0.0068907528,
0.1052898467,
0.0209912602,
-0.0190257076,
-0.0235490017,
0.0677494332,
0.0173664261,
-0.0112958029,
0.0561755821,
-0.0075255772,
0.0761920512,
-0.0329489522,
0.0505538471,
-0.0602974743,
0.0754006654,
-0.0720229745,
0.1143973246,
-0.0126954969,
0.0550841503,
0.032060042,
0.0074343621,
-0.0122476434,
0.064899236,
0.0302844569,
0.0607439391,
-0.0228310507,
-0.0254741423,
0.0341775157,
0.0108342106,
-0.0170810595,
0.0091537507,
-0.00391278,
-0.0143220099,
0.0262201019,
-0.0519060455,
-0.0301478244,
-0.0466246493,
-0.0093826354,
-0.0153214056,
-0.0076415492,
0.0392903201,
0.0324693471,
0.0230118409,
0.0235479455,
0.0412905067,
0.0176221412,
0.0380409025,
0.0387975574,
0.0271305498,
0.0188127216,
0.0227738824,
-0.0712336004,
-0.0114543801,
-0.020433465,
-0.0307923332,
0.0350702107,
-0.0021035667,
-0.0493580922,
-0.0568290502,
-0.0198475923,
-0.0362001397,
0.0130301863,
-0.0245984085,
-0.036716871,
0.0347539112,
-0.0247418303,
0.0873238146,
-0.0285091903,
-0.0176094808,
0.014907076,
0.0041233879,
-0.0228689015,
0.0258565992,
-0.0407073013,
-0.0319491699,
0.0158435684,
-0.0552005917,
0.0088788373,
0.0233231895,
0.1085071117,
0.0000315235,
-0.0327283889,
-0.0547057129,
0.0071956199,
-0.0830183104,
-0.0120783309,
0.0129672904,
-0.0753746331,
-0.0632128045,
0.0323181935,
-0.0440309756,
-0.020825984,
0.0289629027,
-0.0205997005,
-0.0121927289,
-0.0313740745,
-0.0180004351,
-0.0566120781,
0.0533404611,
0.0264257677,
0.0123070152,
0.0380540639,
-0.0566647388,
-0.0300926268,
-0.0359267741,
0.010911664,
0.0063131279,
0.0212313533,
-0.025451161,
0.0315196626,
0.0122931032,
0.0282027163,
0.0103956508,
-0.0218780283,
0.0284438301,
0.0217545666,
0.0257920027,
0.0015443208,
0.0531626791,
0.0403125845,
0.0144165698,
-0.0285125002,
0.0191382524,
0.0207774341,
-0.0199026857,
0.0043399855,
0.0251252037,
-0.0043571829,
0.0076360055,
-0.0056135221,
-0.0136766564,
0.0225797445,
0.0234900471,
0.0217970535,
0.0023924136,
-0.0430463776,
0.0376361199,
-0.0137145966,
-0.0286494773,
-0.0072768801,
-0.0349791609,
0.0244848169,
0.0458138548,
0.0103433179,
0.0319510102,
0.0440355204,
0.0627491251,
-0.0466786474,
0.0030272927,
0.010403676,
-0.0234726127,
-0.0799186081,
0.0542624816,
0.0008354665,
-0.074474968,
0.0151225347,
-0.0178678259,
-0.000905043,
-0.0353384279,
-0.0153389201,
0.0478434153,
-0.0378252566,
-0.025607923,
0.0221569967,
0.036696367,
0.0311617423,
-0.036580991,
0.0340462327,
-0.0389837176,
0.0275166817,
0.0146275628,
0.0325600915,
-0.0142814647,
-0.104827866,
-0.0281930696,
0.0078093917,
0.0474508218,
0.0439718477,
-0.0417438187,
-0.0271560177,
0.0709372237,
-0.0366085246,
-0.003306139,
-0.0191537514,
-0.0550061055,
0.0702287778,
-0.0129026026,
-0.0560355149,
0.0223358702,
0.0006461004,
-0.050447017,
-0.034197472,
0.0388913155,
0.0015479163,
-0.0277072005,
0.0026338429,
0.0387212522,
-0.0321526416,
0.0624008849,
0.0224325657,
0.0242072307,
-0.0074273325,
-0.0191481244,
-0.0241134278,
0.0482745096,
-0.0804165453,
-0.0018855679,
0.0361935496,
-0.1299985945,
-0.067875877,
-0.0246335771,
-0.028009532,
0.0343624912,
-0.0014585441,
0.0463240296,
0.0079344045,
-0.0394105501,
0.0136257438,
-0.001387123,
-0.008159833,
0.0180292465,
-0.0031667291,
0.0479160883,
0.020059647,
0.0337645635,
-0.0521857031,
-0.0256364979,
-0.0172928106,
-0.0743925124,
0.0199076626,
0.0200142264,
0.0339734741,
-0.0482767038,
-0.0134141762,
-0.0130557232,
-0.0551149882,
0.0438026339,
0.0041933674,
0.0936987177,
0.0105797015,
-0.014808083,
0.0328226611,
0.0200557169,
0.0018879401,
-0.0151098128,
-0.0381765254,
0.0132533712,
-0.0522941947,
0.0165177938,
0.0403416343,
0.0243336745,
-0.0034417724,
0.0116282795,
-0.0047756196,
0.0007176785,
-0.018621197,
-0.0602256991,
-0.0232151579,
-0.035725493,
-0.0279468466,
0.0259059034,
0.0268962234,
-0.0030187417,
-0.0041116844,
0.0086049372,
-0.0214172956,
0.0813645944,
-0.0293297432,
-0.0119855544,
-0.0199639816,
0.0428963751,
0.0507648215,
0.0329949446,
-0.0020603733,
-0.0600077026,
0.0243943837,
-0.049042359,
-0.0558171943,
0.0402084626,
0.0035084013,
-0.0194159187,
-0.0331141613,
-0.0202031713,
-0.0596376583,
0.0118207475,
-0.0211522244,
0.0093116472,
0.0056719673,
0.0837563351,
-0.0616299212,
-0.0008467421,
-0.0026926014,
-0.0191530194,
-0.0092499536,
0.0042723967,
0.0134027759,
0.0337144993,
0.0033561389,
0.0086125396,
0.0411627069,
-0.0835173056,
-0.0054174666,
-0.0207409225,
0.0181026123,
-0.0256846864,
-0.0380151831,
-0.0392822884,
0.006601098,
0.0527110659,
-0.0099935737,
-0.0724228993,
-0.0256601255,
-0.0145581858,
0.0263088495,
0.0095797572,
-0.0150548918,
0.0108841434,
0.0362798646,
-0.0174931474,
-0.0373458676,
-0.028135052,
0.0332143791,
0.0335213207,
0.0024428829,
0.0290380139,
-4.721153757e-33,
-0.0426769741,
-0.002384596,
-0.0148054995,
0.0057334234,
-0.0363348871,
-0.0174509045,
-0.0067469096,
0.0051386766,
-0.0013500905,
-0.0068921898,
0.0103783831,
0.0206685755,
0.0068577542,
0.0063648801,
-0.0156412981,
0.0328255445,
0.0200306661,
-0.0272891019,
0.0274399873,
-0.0362591967,
0.0114015834,
-0.0501687899,
0.0302706361,
0.0098241223,
0.0341013633,
-0.0215997733,
-0.0420418121,
0.0630792528,
0.0065787411,
0.0226083826,
-0.036899671,
-0.0043613813,
0.0088713821,
-0.0157753229,
-0.0296504665,
0.0154343368,
0.018088311,
-0.0806322545,
0.0746729821,
-0.023220405,
-0.0033215214,
-0.0187368765,
0.0390050039,
-0.00214315,
-0.0186378993,
-0.0016807923,
-0.0005381175,
0.0235149935,
-0.0234229509,
0.0520644672,
-0.0601290315,
0.0070925346,
0.011513669,
0.0498973541,
0.0389569663,
-0.028321391,
-0.0129654342,
-0.0283541083,
-0.0197426565,
0.0586255789,
0.0094056474,
0.0649120435,
0.0053643216,
-0.0086599644,
0.0013550514,
0.0333292261,
0.080879584,
0.0024171325,
0.0292215068,
0.0479528531,
0.0036558106,
0.0737501383,
0.008473671,
0.0393185988,
0.0337368436,
0.0391704589,
-0.0131494086,
0.0160224028,
0.0721667036,
0.0253454316,
-0.0450317562,
0.0629961193,
-0.0316851586,
-0.0413347669,
-0.006283144,
0.0206759479,
-0.0093297809,
-0.0096609341,
-0.0246328991,
-0.0157634486,
0.0114873955,
0.0289237555,
-0.0116921468,
-0.042137146,
-0.0384746194,
-0.0116547691,
-0.0047409353,
0.0645849109,
-0.0039165472,
0.0227022357,
-0.0063638198,
-0.0143061671,
-0.0117512345,
0.0384294093,
0.0222405139,
0.0147229843,
-0.0231934469,
0.0254976209,
-0.0249372423,
-0.0009593469,
0.0165619645,
-0.0503323376,
0.0318761654,
-0.0323321037,
0.0545179397,
0.0469035171,
0.0320639461,
0.0165773574,
0.0191706717,
0.0119824484,
0.0141972965,
0.0264255423,
0.0282693394,
0.0268990695,
0.0037723226,
-0.0221038628,
0.0214782972,
0.0346867666,
0.09373983,
0.0049139652,
-0.0219456349,
0.0102822697,
2.339e-7,
0.0343123339,
-0.0173260923,
0.0661651865,
0.0403158143,
0.0234578699,
-0.0126945628,
0.0036067264,
-0.0152457338,
-0.0117288493,
0.0133454651,
-0.0228658728,
-0.0163511075,
-0.0288515668,
0.0121285524,
-0.0337631218,
0.0274926629,
-0.0176638048,
-0.0899551436,
-0.0127138663,
0.0168996118,
0.0445387661,
0.0209382996,
0.0344641022,
0.0010523867,
-0.0503879115,
-0.0246946439,
0.0428780988,
0.0214221515,
-0.0238114875,
0.0338130035,
0.0142684346,
-0.0362280831,
0.0093834288,
-0.0097666727,
-0.0042885565,
0.0415721834,
0.0206866637,
-0.0112761408,
-0.0423107259,
0.0121473772,
0.0020386116,
-0.0467293188,
-0.0259195901,
-0.0010333005,
0.0379172713,
-0.0345748886,
-0.0211489163,
-0.0249600951,
-0.0424385592,
0.0361357033,
-0.0105944891,
0.0374768786,
-0.0229909681,
0.0058350307,
0.0405727774,
0.0076585356,
-0.026198063,
-0.0391243063,
-0.0080460533,
0.102927044,
-0.0527768508,
-0.0329720005,
0.0031492247,
0.0168550592,
-0.0121805314,
-0.0617313273,
-0.0457542948,
2.288964155e-34,
0.032416597,
-0.0225038733,
0.1023092866,
-0.0094686896,
-0.0298334528,
0.002312738,
-0.0334957093,
0.0845379829,
0.0230743587,
-0.0820058063,
-0.0357231796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18265v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18265v1 | Check-COVID: Fact-Checking COVID-19 News Claims with Scientific Evidence | 2023-05-29T17:39:22 | 2023-05-29T17:39:22 | Gengyu Wang, Kate Harwood, Lawrence Chillrud, Amith Ananthram, Melanie Subbiah, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | We present a new fact-checking benchmark, Check-COVID, that requires systems
to verify claims about COVID-19 from news using evidence from scientific
articles. This approach to fact-checking is particularly challenging as it
requires checking internet text written in everyday language against evidence
from journal articles written in formal academic language. Check-COVID contains
1, 504 expert-annotated news claims about the coronavirus paired with
sentence-level evidence from scientific journal articles and veracity labels.
It includes both extracted (journalist-written) and composed
(annotator-written) claims. Experiments using both a fact-checking specific
system and GPT-3.5, which respectively achieve F1 scores of 76.99 and 69.90 on
this task, reveal the difficulty of automatically fact-checking both claim
types and the importance of in-domain data for good performance. Our data and
models are released publicly at https://github.com/posuer/Check-COVID. | [
0.0196010489,
0.0251594521,
0.0169076268,
0.0259370245,
-0.0494459532,
-0.0031001524,
0.0078547895,
-0.0170923267,
0.0248179827,
-0.0324731432,
0.0209578741,
0.0200126916,
0.0216826387,
0.0676928908,
-0.0018065802,
-0.0023348453,
0.0773639455,
0.0335492007,
0.1068423018,
0.0033071169,
-0.016719766,
0.0320199206,
-0.0508061089,
0.0217068233,
-0.032939177,
-0.0205446109,
0.0570124127,
-0.0195190571,
0.0740924403,
-0.0912589952,
0.0267680269,
0.0169636253,
0.0165276919,
0.0637419373,
0.0000016273,
-0.0347067975,
-0.0174316783,
0.0460118502,
-0.0172765628,
0.0283725336,
0.0251341965,
-0.0273915771,
-0.0111750858,
0.0352031551,
-0.0373654626,
-0.054266531,
0.0366036966,
0.0347614624,
0.0789500475,
0.1189647689,
-0.0200303216,
-0.0230157301,
0.0440753438,
0.0262317955,
-0.0370607227,
-0.0071644029,
0.0554985888,
0.0513995364,
-0.0117409211,
0.0180407558,
0.0722502545,
0.046550639,
-0.000219293,
-0.0064789006,
-0.0392617621,
0.0750628337,
-0.0441681556,
-0.0406888053,
0.0063282633,
0.0240126122,
0.0274277646,
-0.0497350208,
0.0353465416,
-0.0090119019,
-0.0203069486,
0.0140510313,
0.0091059711,
-0.0063235024,
-0.03987021,
0.0106839649,
0.0271207672,
0.0018640311,
0.0435562804,
0.029020045,
0.0276523493,
0.0836278126,
-0.0180983599,
-0.0587649792,
0.0224711336,
-0.0026517564,
0.0150627363,
-0.0718562752,
0.03940247,
0.0127748018,
-0.0141951814,
0.0128545659,
0.0022288475,
-0.0407662578,
0.0785899684,
-0.0948404372,
-0.0396278948,
-0.0145563567,
-0.0322139561,
0.0439475402,
-0.0012127135,
-0.0193721447,
0.0018526177,
0.0113357017,
0.0566812791,
-0.0036886765,
-0.0161557216,
0.0060161278,
-0.0219167229,
-0.0035670693,
0.0029450147,
0.0427600443,
-0.0355512425,
-0.0555637851,
-0.0082895448,
0.0451478735,
-0.0189705696,
-0.0106238322,
-0.0378835239,
0.0083891833,
-0.0254323855,
0.058480259,
-0.0227547344,
0.0235151611,
0.0083163613,
-0.0295673702,
-0.00258565,
0.0074013295,
0.0079150554,
-0.010517193,
0.0027217071,
-0.0437472984,
0.0095187407,
0.0296796411,
0.0208971016,
-0.047604315,
-0.045875214,
-0.0769130662,
-0.0005688529,
-0.0688714832,
0.0017540512,
0.0024783788,
-0.0119722495,
-0.0231236294,
-0.023135528,
0.012386295,
-0.0398715883,
0.0175722726,
-0.0500728898,
-0.0390664451,
0.0705642998,
0.0059775282,
0.0196296852,
0.0071545341,
0.0415370278,
0.0503286719,
0.0189300738,
0.0530335866,
0.0127232615,
-0.0252360739,
0.0507841371,
0.033331994,
0.0671061054,
0.0154377567,
0.0112306932,
0.0427777953,
-0.0196287092,
0.0481198952,
-0.0158740394,
-0.0136329886,
0.0458403602,
-0.0340694264,
-0.0470340513,
-0.0528854579,
0.0425732061,
0.0240568556,
0.063372016,
0.000008819,
-0.0322962366,
0.0157699548,
-0.0078864219,
-0.0018048936,
0.001219315,
0.0532748029,
0.0158561878,
-0.0221009087,
-0.0334225744,
0.0112406239,
-0.0308968611,
-0.0307976976,
0.0007947836,
-0.0184550807,
-0.0400490686,
-0.0183817949,
0.0437547527,
-0.0241738893,
-0.0124339173,
-0.0577111319,
0.015537939,
-0.0097211292,
0.0350642204,
-0.0064348369,
-0.0430280454,
-0.0256147087,
0.0145428721,
0.0382694006,
0.0635980964,
-0.0139816636,
-0.0246655345,
0.0008047665,
0.0115282256,
-0.0242448114,
0.0497784317,
-0.0051016263,
0.0365083441,
0.0397616401,
-0.0122743119,
0.0123958793,
-0.0587794483,
0.018183168,
-0.0124060204,
0.0061959946,
-0.0227008443,
-0.0039532641,
0.038388405,
0.0011075379,
-0.003946214,
0.0215764903,
0.049395211,
0.0036662365,
-0.0254118722,
0.0212433822,
0.0291233473,
-0.0165245887,
0.0136180157,
-0.053361088,
-0.0520811751,
0.0446607582,
-0.0284530129,
0.0128517263,
-0.0296506919,
-0.0015319114,
-0.0020289514,
-0.0225364305,
-0.0316733867,
-0.0039036546,
0.0107220104,
0.0419568233,
0.0641739592,
-0.0144498879,
-0.0197632629,
-0.0216661468,
-0.0382152647,
-0.0157334879,
-0.047083661,
0.0023157657,
-0.0113159372,
0.014640348,
-0.0097316969,
0.0149786798,
-0.0461591668,
-0.0277547408,
0.0177387539,
-0.0652823225,
0.0183212589,
-0.0070334645,
0.0290180761,
0.0299268719,
-0.0339156464,
-0.0065185805,
0.0201791357,
-0.0100925062,
-0.0161376782,
0.0101858098,
0.0163902007,
0.0520287864,
0.0064970069,
0.0053594401,
-0.0337050669,
0.0318357907,
-0.0773363262,
-0.0013589666,
0.0420048833,
-0.0572548136,
-0.0179093257,
-0.0350597836,
-0.0576179735,
0.004154176,
-0.0054249326,
-0.0114196129,
0.0183818284,
0.0188172422,
0.0077614882,
0.033432506,
0.0147945983,
0.0067035933,
0.0490870327,
0.0136413965,
0.0070181764,
0.0315411761,
-0.0375995636,
0.0270043556,
-0.0041610235,
-0.0535503477,
0.0346039012,
0.0257638078,
0.017158106,
0.00404074,
-0.015384593,
0.0336358547,
-0.0392116569,
-0.0228452012,
0.0629037619,
-0.0063059023,
-0.0211636331,
0.0326048732,
-0.028240202,
-0.021800166,
0.047723379,
-0.0272137802,
0.0400724746,
-0.0784637704,
0.0115030892,
-0.011100769,
-0.0229100678,
-0.024806194,
0.0184240304,
0.0401390977,
0.0336208232,
0.0384682678,
-0.0364144519,
0.0530727021,
-0.0170249771,
-0.026673235,
-0.0379904173,
0.0535134487,
0.0344756916,
-0.0373163298,
-0.0260500498,
-0.0652470365,
-0.0599393994,
-0.0028568427,
-0.021033356,
-0.0155586144,
-0.0905835927,
-0.0332807265,
0.047524672,
0.0710087642,
0.0008238748,
0.0103969928,
0.0113166366,
-0.0009134109,
0.0174755827,
-0.0013178159,
0.0483547449,
0.02598699,
-0.0254344922,
0.0623448528,
-0.0367908441,
0.0389186069,
-0.0305492207,
-0.0505936779,
-0.056368053,
-0.0582814589,
-0.0152645679,
-0.0095432121,
0.0293918531,
-0.0581807904,
-0.006865344,
0.0657225326,
0.018368423,
0.0204360876,
0.0015002777,
0.0126887979,
-0.010868649,
0.007121142,
0.0314514637,
-0.0844214335,
0.0056193643,
-0.0041474919,
-0.0293176137,
-0.0510827638,
-0.024016967,
-0.0516549684,
-0.0232213829,
0.0460477658,
-0.0187492017,
0.002068165,
-0.0138340583,
-0.0894164816,
0.0009620209,
-0.0066342312,
-0.0144450385,
-0.0125932451,
0.0310155358,
-0.0014891683,
0.0091100829,
-0.0302123856,
-0.0582049154,
0.03643452,
-0.0154814608,
0.0234181713,
0.0272151008,
0.0749052763,
-0.0196758416,
-0.0729832649,
-0.0078030922,
0.0303735696,
-0.0498026349,
-0.0085048648,
0.0780228898,
-0.0400464647,
0.0184895322,
-0.0218073353,
0.0297421608,
0.0248718131,
-0.0322995968,
0.0232832339,
0.0889510587,
-0.0001011799,
-0.0772012249,
-0.0264849626,
0.0479594581,
0.0162508655,
0.0558493733,
-0.0165720768,
0.0564324856,
-0.0134725878,
0.0107663414,
-0.0053930711,
-0.0246916041,
-0.0463648178,
0.0288182758,
-0.0129743079,
-0.0829475373,
-0.0692382306,
-0.0123320082,
0.0071783247,
0.0181963816,
-0.0546461083,
-0.0531695262,
0.0571467765,
0.0143917678,
-0.0204822458,
0.0030269653,
-0.0119580738,
0.031619411,
-0.0080146492,
0.0025755563,
0.0454219282,
0.037474867,
-0.0216933712,
0.0660221577,
-0.02525644,
-0.0520009957,
0.0011262277,
-0.0089296391,
0.0233764146,
0.0344031975,
-0.0241971537,
0.0362354852,
0.0336935036,
0.0415985845,
-0.0411212146,
-0.0116014723,
0.0074986299,
-0.0633816794,
0.0080015305,
-0.0264743138,
0.0082210666,
0.029713586,
-0.0287695602,
0.0005993501,
-0.032656353,
0.012068064,
0.0457511246,
0.0446027368,
0.0579694584,
-0.0172192156,
-0.0048843538,
-0.047307644,
-0.0048065353,
-0.0329001285,
-0.0210201293,
0.0270232409,
0.0295683257,
-0.0346146151,
-0.0158655327,
-0.0345613658,
0.0590620413,
-0.0509440228,
-0.0147754243,
-0.0274191126,
-0.0160201192,
0.0114691211,
0.0672807023,
0.0182861984,
-0.0664592981,
-0.0310239084,
-0.0103355525,
-0.0224178415,
0.0203703847,
-0.0070200628,
-0.0343641341,
0.0206807517,
-0.0109027065,
0.0223015435,
-0.0253679492,
-0.0886041597,
0.0164534803,
-0.0558671318,
0.0151691213,
0.0102064228,
0.0363590345,
0.060961239,
-0.0605542623,
-0.0435101502,
-0.017579006,
0.0122036953,
-0.0016937553,
-0.0031139783,
0.0112003917,
-0.0157654844,
-0.0595023707,
0.0033189149,
0.0324784033,
0.0062705851,
0.0826637819,
0.0527140982,
-0.061069835,
-0.0326097272,
-0.0482083857,
-0.0692528412,
-0.0025314863,
0.0000913643,
-0.0258982349,
-0.081327863,
-0.0248258412,
0.0499186032,
0.0311254784,
0.0053477143,
0.0004106047,
-0.0425618999,
0.045426026,
0.0234656613,
-0.0517487638,
-0.0250284504,
0.0447312742,
-0.0226330254,
-0.0236276127,
0.0006698798,
-6.269316184e-33,
0.0132410843,
-0.0408109315,
0.0164269041,
0.0101089552,
0.0106908716,
0.0652753934,
-0.0397317335,
-0.0530999638,
-0.0339604802,
0.0880137905,
0.0151854036,
0.0363018513,
0.0172311459,
-0.0359057821,
-0.0202150308,
0.0238346942,
0.0685792416,
0.0005128764,
-0.0515040234,
0.0111518102,
0.0351541191,
-0.0100832898,
0.0700415745,
-0.0889985785,
0.0675395206,
-0.0056143822,
-0.0314275771,
0.0165329184,
-0.0433733687,
0.0246697664,
-0.0097288508,
-0.0006072824,
0.0351109765,
-0.0298794881,
0.0178005472,
-0.0094203167,
-0.0711850151,
-0.0053297756,
0.0460323542,
-0.0412914082,
-0.043191798,
-0.0061332774,
0.0121437237,
0.0206283219,
-0.002820581,
-0.0071362173,
0.0180607028,
-0.0185079593,
0.0199961737,
-0.0473507419,
-0.0708695576,
0.0455165245,
0.01511735,
0.0305463076,
-0.0569502264,
0.0607472733,
-0.0203957967,
0.0430170298,
-0.0450105481,
0.0197306368,
-0.0014677008,
0.0082244882,
0.039978072,
-0.0671678782,
-0.0385264978,
0.0458309725,
-0.0269772019,
0.002162416,
-0.048614867,
0.030602036,
0.0094138049,
0.0452696197,
0.0362295173,
0.1070327833,
0.0280141905,
-0.0395925827,
-0.1037692949,
0.041494105,
0.01810796,
0.0277644526,
0.0001375933,
-0.0316782407,
-0.0164627749,
0.0239841733,
-0.0096355211,
0.0046421653,
-0.0186738018,
0.0065209931,
-0.0143618193,
0.0126821324,
-0.0173821431,
0.0669851527,
-0.0243368205,
0.0048226099,
0.0141468318,
-0.0063209562,
-0.0207318068,
-0.0104975784,
-0.0119220763,
0.0587063842,
-0.0814001858,
0.0252845045,
-0.0025173731,
0.073986575,
0.0306239817,
0.0028733332,
0.0622661114,
-0.0111650201,
-0.0334053747,
0.0080276197,
-0.020750083,
0.033433076,
-0.0129244048,
0.0045009456,
0.0206680149,
0.0134043777,
0.0163709112,
-0.0087714242,
-0.0121575361,
0.0436230153,
-0.0042809588,
0.006996857,
0.0042722761,
0.0369472168,
-0.0118745761,
-0.0016067664,
-0.0164181087,
0.0143263694,
-0.0152314492,
-0.0773292631,
0.0229120199,
0.0207483415,
2.495e-7,
0.0539489388,
0.069143936,
0.0039268229,
-0.0168156307,
0.0115047283,
0.0215015244,
-0.0026876121,
-0.0006390423,
-0.0072316583,
-0.0694761202,
-0.0297336821,
0.0205167253,
-0.004656049,
0.0726752356,
-0.0406363495,
-0.0063191052,
-0.0608241297,
-0.0111336028,
-0.0575932115,
-0.0269113574,
0.007050992,
0.0135604069,
0.0132678915,
-0.0009414992,
-0.0041361898,
0.0186574049,
0.0300390273,
0.0578362085,
-0.0471966267,
0.0247590784,
0.0319531895,
0.0091021862,
0.0301201344,
0.0299514811,
-0.0526628643,
-0.0370522588,
-0.0335447714,
0.058236666,
0.008697845,
0.0089889765,
0.0010938863,
-0.0354348719,
0.0151432892,
-0.0245240647,
0.0460059457,
-0.0425032079,
-0.0453872904,
-0.0598510616,
-0.0607683994,
0.0352214351,
0.0261619631,
-0.0039266357,
-0.0364239253,
0.029372083,
-0.0524876229,
0.0249572266,
-0.0225929562,
-0.0087852711,
0.0052566621,
0.0187356342,
-0.0342530347,
-0.0769248232,
0.0477002487,
-0.0083607435,
0.0216651354,
-0.0616003349,
0.0464846678,
1.836205058e-34,
0.0343083031,
0.0095649343,
-0.0276514683,
-0.0467028134,
0.0428422838,
0.0219067167,
-0.0257543456,
-0.0062145665,
-0.0123666907,
0.0051416671,
0.0007932489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18248v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18248v3 | Do Language Models Know When They're Hallucinating References? | 2023-05-29T17:12:03 | 2024-03-20T13:12:48 | Ayush Agrawal, Mirac Suzgun, Lester Mackey, Adam Tauman Kalai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | State-of-the-art language models (LMs) are notoriously susceptible to
generating hallucinated information. Such inaccurate outputs not only undermine
the reliability of these models but also limit their use and raise serious
concerns about misinformation and propaganda. In this work, we focus on
hallucinated book and article references and present them as the "model
organism" of language model hallucination research, due to their frequent and
easy-to-discern nature. We posit that if a language model cites a particular
reference in its output, then it should ideally possess sufficient information
about its authors and content, among other relevant details. Using this basic
insight, we illustrate that one can identify hallucinated references without
ever consulting any external resources, by asking a set of direct or indirect
queries to the language model about the references. These queries can be
considered as "consistency checks." Our findings highlight that while LMs,
including GPT-4, often produce inconsistent author lists for hallucinated
references, they also often accurately recall the authors of real references.
In this sense, the LM can be said to "know" when it is hallucinating
references. Furthermore, these findings show how hallucinated references can be
dissected to shed light on their nature. Replication code and results can be
found at https://github.com/microsoft/hallucinated-references. | [
0.0632024184,
0.0506842472,
-0.0327969044,
0.0446638986,
-0.0389176682,
0.0196042228,
0.0135636115,
0.0136492159,
0.019760618,
-0.0592061244,
-0.0053201015,
-0.0301425271,
0.0257653594,
-0.0359178372,
0.0353858583,
-0.0077897809,
0.0490387604,
-0.0186702628,
0.0026985782,
-0.0226390623,
-0.010383158,
0.0276259631,
0.0290942658,
0.0253239349,
0.0237950198,
-0.0273441244,
0.0119648278,
-0.0010699463,
-0.0101898024,
0.0209895056,
-0.0063418066,
0.0566597283,
-0.0212529059,
0.0791239291,
0.0000019089,
-0.0411281399,
-0.0202722009,
-0.0048608603,
0.0018142249,
0.0276902653,
0.0420125909,
0.0049263253,
-0.0091445521,
-0.0093706669,
-0.0238298122,
-0.0466649681,
0.0231944248,
0.0627104416,
0.0162049104,
0.0512628928,
0.0016687308,
-0.0062147528,
0.0498345494,
0.0197159704,
0.0561347641,
0.0165640358,
0.0451405533,
0.0262155998,
0.0071847504,
0.0293665398,
0.005824409,
0.0411308371,
-0.0112967277,
0.0313312039,
-0.026903173,
0.017967362,
-0.0896776468,
-0.0144083789,
0.0495252609,
0.0123057179,
-0.0234887917,
-0.0818343014,
0.0302693229,
0.0210869648,
-0.0140411844,
0.0671508461,
0.0031832142,
0.0152092259,
-0.0317983255,
0.0138371903,
0.0657687634,
-0.0296407286,
0.0852714404,
0.0157673433,
-0.0073079783,
0.0989783704,
0.0170387011,
-0.0191060081,
0.043255385,
-0.0068967571,
0.0180364903,
-0.0624505021,
-0.0088848341,
-0.0008318496,
-0.0055050906,
0.0177940782,
-0.0143263638,
0.0436283424,
0.0534199923,
-0.0809002593,
0.0035961319,
0.0017117324,
-0.06057062,
0.0504549928,
-0.0230508465,
0.0245287288,
-0.04942571,
0.0370393321,
-0.025138285,
-0.0086549269,
-0.0176201835,
-0.0329454541,
-0.0158068966,
0.0057720738,
0.0253929235,
-0.0061992356,
-0.0181646273,
-0.000210768,
-0.0255216863,
0.034435682,
-0.0671264082,
-0.011701379,
-0.0123655293,
-0.0237169359,
-0.0167695582,
0.0250926167,
0.0053924848,
-0.0114368731,
-0.0476711728,
-0.0825555027,
-0.0076438314,
-0.0119208256,
-0.0433785208,
-0.0244514123,
-0.0020550515,
0.0369401611,
0.0482103601,
-0.0086675268,
-0.0299340896,
-0.0362581052,
-0.0071162037,
-0.0750092492,
0.0516162291,
-0.0587910637,
-0.0029541692,
0.03912073,
0.0147874793,
-0.0785780028,
0.002461141,
0.0077691693,
-0.0741023421,
0.0721013919,
-0.0424149148,
-0.0010857059,
0.0350164026,
0.0201129504,
0.0064140856,
0.0630917102,
0.0077834679,
0.0001162393,
0.0287009738,
-0.0233975779,
0.0708379075,
0.0217963662,
0.0033890633,
0.0302785877,
-0.0383326113,
-0.0366492793,
0.022232268,
-0.0165000334,
-0.0057528708,
0.0540443994,
-0.0075602536,
-0.0142157534,
0.0547231361,
-0.0032433309,
-0.035976734,
0.0245466176,
0.0130478125,
-0.01818919,
0.0190157406,
0.0632040873,
-0.0626698583,
0.0026210637,
-0.0294144358,
0.0071395598,
0.0539294221,
0.0020475606,
-0.021618804,
-0.0122777643,
-0.0130321756,
-0.0014924631,
0.0212158505,
-0.0097434716,
0.0345182791,
0.0037359081,
-0.042842757,
0.0804250017,
0.0372000299,
-0.0174289588,
0.0310319159,
-0.0291504972,
-0.0060899765,
0.0584517531,
0.0714974031,
-0.0148371039,
0.0268223528,
-0.0256001167,
0.0300928988,
0.0661950931,
0.0237542819,
0.0028966984,
-0.0170840714,
-0.0167532824,
0.0016550638,
-0.0145176202,
0.0546347089,
0.0098708794,
-0.0131052081,
0.0165679716,
0.0158330891,
-0.0548522547,
-0.0766540989,
0.0260566603,
-0.0524687059,
0.0051103993,
-0.0607738793,
-0.0429738797,
0.0090161124,
0.0123812417,
-0.0232484136,
0.0207214281,
0.0098396381,
-0.0199582763,
-0.0141965002,
0.0284959786,
0.0042917663,
0.0651134998,
0.0504038371,
-0.025149459,
0.0163106117,
0.0215622876,
0.0050134244,
-0.0324234776,
0.0488580912,
-0.0183459017,
0.0704895407,
-0.0256053004,
0.0436132252,
-0.0292317569,
0.0243200343,
0.0147398263,
0.0797315314,
-0.0231740102,
0.0764180198,
0.0268460587,
-0.0133200558,
0.0216742065,
0.0139090307,
-0.0369289331,
0.0320062116,
0.0155148115,
0.0239368416,
0.0141301462,
-0.080772616,
-0.0313585922,
-0.0199408308,
-0.0351039432,
-0.0169880744,
-0.0210436992,
-0.0201880652,
0.0120152039,
-0.0263313595,
-0.0069048931,
0.0057125636,
0.0174380522,
-0.0180466324,
-0.0179610904,
0.0440255776,
-0.0047115893,
-0.0106131388,
-0.0164042488,
-0.0181501862,
0.0102094086,
-0.0203306954,
0.048281759,
0.0129690263,
-0.0292139258,
-0.1125832126,
0.0261614062,
-0.0599325486,
0.0083299438,
-0.0429481976,
0.0087529877,
0.019413257,
-0.0062416852,
0.0195670296,
0.0374048389,
0.0046752333,
0.0137857953,
0.0788861513,
-0.0255988091,
-0.0453247316,
-0.0259251278,
-0.0076642367,
-0.0075185751,
-0.0297036543,
-0.0620368198,
-0.0146199549,
0.0092058675,
0.0075362725,
0.0024225672,
-0.0334925465,
0.042317491,
-0.0492115207,
-0.0287672821,
0.0399709716,
-0.0358414315,
-0.0299214404,
0.0487984382,
-0.0036847498,
-0.0409862213,
0.0334191546,
-0.0459164083,
0.0090503888,
-0.0230691098,
0.0316931978,
0.0141360965,
0.0214652717,
0.054376673,
-0.0002201255,
0.0098577859,
-0.0104402453,
-0.0327204876,
0.0267581046,
-0.0066366778,
-0.0517533049,
0.009659905,
-0.0260973535,
0.0041024457,
0.0176552106,
0.0144902477,
-0.0414833575,
-0.0164454971,
-0.0399803743,
-0.0124081206,
-0.028137587,
-0.0032787113,
-0.0558742397,
0.0073510311,
0.0224791802,
0.0272137895,
-0.011946626,
-0.0168170892,
-0.0194729045,
-0.0276768804,
0.0654976517,
-0.0392051749,
0.0588465221,
-0.0359182805,
-0.0519263111,
0.0287517402,
0.0254007578,
0.0307724886,
-0.0171280559,
-0.0363113359,
0.0293064043,
-0.0443704948,
-0.0806678534,
0.0069865952,
-0.022181619,
-0.0587988496,
-0.0087726042,
0.1208291873,
0.0346398652,
-0.0869007632,
-0.0135272779,
-0.0612499826,
0.0122786965,
0.0139650116,
-0.0172926858,
-0.086862728,
0.0249800775,
0.0123538682,
-0.0151478564,
-0.0338263884,
-0.0103587303,
-0.0281010531,
-0.0754986331,
0.0212830696,
0.0289491545,
-0.0323323123,
-0.020858489,
-0.03819355,
-0.0086222934,
0.0018176129,
0.0272086002,
0.0047773654,
0.0148998313,
0.0074313153,
-0.0114313029,
-0.0197400991,
-0.0225748457,
0.0097936699,
-0.0167961717,
0.0727079883,
0.0778942332,
0.0528162904,
-0.0245951265,
-0.0466373414,
0.0343582444,
-0.0490279347,
-0.0342483073,
-0.0095742485,
0.0674342364,
0.0097456612,
0.0080731902,
0.0159860738,
0.0157328099,
-0.0306135174,
-0.006169172,
-0.0146234892,
0.0660547689,
-0.0255910363,
-0.0650027767,
0.0077233361,
0.0409753211,
0.0124094198,
0.0834883675,
-0.008337168,
-0.0144974981,
-0.0363121442,
-0.053369876,
0.0802813098,
0.0186339654,
-0.0541071072,
0.0469434075,
0.0343435258,
-0.041619271,
-0.0588593483,
-0.0567926168,
-0.0234513339,
-0.0086473553,
0.0445463285,
0.0929819942,
0.0076561412,
-0.0235491134,
0.0081139207,
-0.0046474882,
-0.0353764556,
-0.0103704995,
-0.0178217925,
0.0003495956,
0.0294077192,
-0.0035116381,
0.0105155902,
0.0385737047,
-0.0345132723,
-0.0639539808,
0.0661243275,
0.0095372582,
0.0368814096,
0.0285717901,
-0.0177893266,
-0.0523122177,
-0.0077124857,
0.0362248272,
-0.0084560765,
0.03364072,
0.0102689257,
-0.0135546178,
0.0038224501,
0.0381773785,
-0.042294126,
-0.0057653934,
-0.0023084101,
-0.0370919444,
-0.0425875373,
-0.0080713779,
0.0304443259,
-0.0051673464,
0.0230245739,
-0.0296740085,
0.0392889865,
-0.002502105,
0.0019969943,
-0.0181654729,
-0.0250909068,
-0.0113844518,
0.0049473201,
0.033222381,
0.0033439286,
-0.0005880755,
-0.025569059,
-0.0372834243,
0.0491871238,
-0.0230275262,
-0.0394649804,
0.0324687809,
0.0462780111,
0.02997078,
-0.0306101292,
-0.0109999152,
0.0513794497,
-0.0026300058,
0.0800737143,
-0.0054600402,
0.0489068329,
0.017686611,
-0.0311959516,
0.0032310819,
-0.0057033929,
-0.062686801,
-0.0613088645,
-0.0071623195,
-0.0226203352,
0.0390456207,
-0.0122063318,
0.0978084207,
-0.054710377,
0.0070226816,
-0.0253836233,
-0.0113808233,
0.0584911667,
-0.0250771567,
-0.0273635779,
0.016828293,
-0.044283703,
0.0364486985,
0.0825647861,
0.0429313071,
0.0438061543,
0.018259773,
-0.0182563663,
-0.0189178102,
-0.061775133,
-0.092230618,
0.0156802982,
-0.0149937905,
-0.0267195851,
-0.0715241879,
-0.0534612425,
0.0232568234,
-0.0088728108,
0.0071228691,
-0.0395230502,
-0.0227945819,
0.0793996602,
-0.0183198247,
-0.0233346559,
-0.0381641462,
0.0254129823,
0.0431074202,
-0.0020963016,
-0.0076414794,
-6.197971024e-33,
-0.0047656908,
-0.0448021553,
0.0124160619,
-0.0212064274,
0.0072423071,
-0.0225146376,
-0.0177312493,
-0.0002173548,
-0.0214563236,
0.012671724,
-0.014560516,
0.0248663649,
0.0163860023,
-0.0313719399,
0.016686894,
-0.0124940965,
0.0364311635,
0.0206175521,
-0.0334244408,
0.0375934653,
0.0726531148,
-0.0091418736,
0.0665619671,
-0.0842993483,
0.0874005631,
-0.0616124906,
-0.0191346649,
-0.0175874438,
-0.00573528,
0.0187353957,
-0.0275896136,
0.0169539861,
0.0196675062,
-0.041307196,
-0.0211580452,
-0.0472625755,
-0.0511604063,
-0.0105184242,
0.0545470417,
0.0317710452,
0.0282960199,
-0.0257037915,
0.0477803051,
-0.0282953512,
0.0025299049,
-0.0022850616,
0.0496489033,
-0.0393234007,
-0.0393137559,
0.0465412475,
-0.0531863868,
-0.0009627251,
0.0228689723,
0.0707490668,
0.0303663071,
0.0503406748,
0.0106404955,
0.0011247509,
-0.0965261981,
0.0266272482,
-0.0068496955,
0.0312292837,
0.0331216864,
-0.0097634913,
-0.0055277538,
0.0678606257,
0.0445270315,
-0.0013530049,
0.0071090199,
-0.0161145385,
0.0362873785,
0.018747827,
0.0340723731,
0.0284936298,
0.0241410173,
-0.0099887075,
-0.0037348436,
-0.0093141478,
-0.0207839366,
-0.0019539134,
0.0656104237,
-0.0318815187,
-0.0472119525,
-0.0476446152,
0.0007056,
-0.0329588614,
-0.0259425305,
-0.0509251691,
0.0042892322,
-0.0266270414,
-0.0240577608,
0.0272118319,
0.0268037487,
-0.0605174974,
-0.054351218,
0.0491332971,
-0.0435307547,
0.0104640508,
-0.0017222337,
0.0180549473,
-0.0285188407,
-0.0334977619,
-0.0121009592,
0.0081238514,
0.0180632565,
0.0206291918,
0.0023547926,
-0.0108652031,
-0.0617849752,
-0.0054210443,
-0.0224245936,
0.0173446834,
0.0107167903,
-0.0301640797,
0.055484198,
0.0007706714,
0.0041880645,
-0.0257677529,
0.0586196445,
-0.001304712,
-0.0224481951,
0.0562444404,
-0.0459523946,
0.011331127,
-0.0307456069,
-0.0296757352,
-0.009478068,
0.0509207398,
0.0413338952,
-0.074330546,
-0.005394177,
-0.011484025,
2.672e-7,
0.0248225164,
0.0352766626,
-0.0099188127,
0.0119799096,
0.0175181665,
0.0084386598,
0.0057604187,
0.0115265232,
0.0356571898,
-0.0339357778,
-0.038581267,
-0.0136189647,
0.0429150574,
0.0574518479,
-0.098962374,
-0.0231624227,
-0.0275501795,
0.0041015893,
-0.0591418929,
-0.0173348635,
-0.0625922009,
0.0480804294,
0.0374114364,
-0.0167869851,
-0.0318084061,
-0.0698322579,
0.0461928956,
-0.0337173641,
-0.0012750945,
0.0474321879,
0.0513903238,
0.0359757729,
0.011048967,
0.042955678,
-0.0146512445,
-0.0028430712,
0.0122090867,
-0.002078037,
0.0121473931,
-0.0431939103,
-0.0199648961,
-0.0371401384,
0.0036023597,
-0.0860375613,
0.0712459534,
0.035874702,
-0.0062224548,
0.0168304183,
-0.0655028373,
-0.0089231608,
0.0218279175,
0.0033999342,
-0.0216720961,
0.0449839719,
-0.0145335225,
0.016929647,
0.0046341275,
-0.0440252014,
-0.0222674012,
0.0024688779,
-0.0146503551,
-0.0595519431,
-0.0005148791,
-0.0170399267,
-0.0170304403,
-0.0840137526,
0.0297967717,
2.468724104e-34,
0.0466821827,
0.0012803922,
0.0236907881,
0.0256807767,
0.016970342,
-0.0030643232,
0.0340530723,
0.0426837169,
-0.0072778901,
-0.0336308219,
-0.0023628306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18201v1 | A Critical Evaluation of Evaluations for Long-form Question Answering | 2023-05-29T16:54:24 | 2023-05-29T16:54:24 | Fangyuan Xu, Yixiao Song, Mohit Iyyer, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long-form question answering (LFQA) enables answering a wide range of
questions, but its flexibility poses enormous challenges for evaluation. We
perform the first targeted study of the evaluation of long-form answers,
covering both human and automatic evaluation practices. We hire domain experts
in seven areas to provide preference judgments over pairs of answers, along
with free-form justifications for their choices. We present a careful analysis
of experts' evaluation, which focuses on new aspects such as the
comprehensiveness of the answer. Next, we examine automatic text generation
metrics, finding that no existing metrics are predictive of human preference
judgments. However, some metrics correlate with fine-grained aspects of answers
(e.g., coherence). We encourage future work to move away from a single "overall
score" of the answer and adopt a multi-faceted evaluation, targeting aspects
such as factuality and completeness. We publicly release all of our annotations
and code to spur future work into LFQA evaluation. | [
0.0312231071,
0.0346279144,
0.0120734144,
-0.0152732385,
-0.0271679293,
-0.015418835,
0.0070269504,
-0.0256030075,
-0.0256083421,
-0.0399976186,
-0.0127511425,
-0.0418911949,
0.0012569544,
0.0182480011,
0.0266596489,
-0.0631164461,
-0.0158421397,
-0.0114671774,
0.036798697,
0.0012965368,
0.0076302225,
0.000987536,
-0.0146463402,
0.0219209008,
0.0092966072,
-0.0407018624,
0.0116781881,
-0.0173604451,
0.0347407348,
-0.02654914,
0.0141235655,
0.0567803606,
-0.0148502346,
-0.0248200111,
0.0000022335,
-0.0794048458,
0.0176024064,
0.0145840999,
-0.0331729986,
0.0491523109,
-0.0236055572,
0.0539251231,
0.045626469,
-0.0007898611,
-0.0350461081,
0.0180591475,
0.0099946326,
0.024007583,
0.0837710276,
0.0348410048,
0.011088633,
-0.026990816,
-0.0024315487,
-0.0264460184,
0.0340582542,
-0.0387472995,
-0.0304554198,
-0.0028828215,
0.0352732837,
0.0080590071,
0.0208031163,
-0.004160461,
0.0192306954,
-0.020748375,
0.0605184212,
0.0249222759,
-0.0062506869,
-0.0184437018,
0.019311782,
0.0731292889,
0.0519177206,
-0.0042434004,
0.0172902402,
-0.0009911597,
0.0072346027,
0.0219108202,
-0.0213197656,
0.0202650335,
-0.0054497444,
-0.0332767032,
-0.0182406493,
0.0627268553,
-0.0054550245,
0.0255312901,
0.0012025571,
0.0591981895,
0.0028115886,
-0.0366643853,
-0.0004927578,
0.0012283543,
-0.0186965987,
-0.1268532127,
0.0010119412,
0.0539910123,
-0.031967219,
-0.0292910095,
-0.0092755286,
-0.0127357552,
0.046552781,
-0.0405586585,
0.0241369344,
-0.0055069178,
-0.0093585392,
0.0118804378,
-0.0463143177,
0.0497723222,
-0.0024608613,
-0.0459344164,
-0.0651421845,
0.0111141643,
-0.0290039424,
-0.0264068786,
-0.006147115,
0.0322480202,
0.0096797626,
-0.025011804,
-0.0161689427,
-0.0185422506,
-0.0225051399,
-0.0094304439,
0.0154362628,
0.0671959594,
0.0051871007,
-0.0022850714,
-0.0782596767,
0.0458836854,
-0.110467352,
0.0104749352,
0.0276679434,
-0.0186705813,
0.0041197864,
0.0376414545,
0.0181441996,
-0.0160939004,
0.0384232588,
0.0523487404,
-0.0308575332,
0.0207020994,
0.0134229176,
-0.0513028391,
-0.0362961441,
-0.0474325679,
-0.0126439789,
-0.080901362,
0.0144321155,
0.0270210318,
-0.0240642112,
-0.0085403314,
0.0214302242,
0.0503032953,
-0.0082046539,
-0.0040891659,
-0.0242811013,
0.0203965139,
0.0713451281,
0.0074210521,
0.0105332555,
0.0146837896,
0.0512358099,
0.046692986,
0.0562809557,
-0.0078000356,
0.0444411188,
-0.0071401079,
-0.0055348515,
-0.019556528,
0.0486791655,
0.0849801004,
-0.0388645045,
0.0457729511,
0.049932301,
0.0368911251,
-0.0096482513,
0.0003048672,
0.0280130673,
0.0370458476,
0.0237482525,
-0.0056557003,
0.0611303225,
0.0170592591,
0.0372256711,
0.0408010781,
0.0038751194,
0.0638046414,
0.006353633,
0.0107556423,
0.0384812169,
0.0237882212,
-0.0132436724,
-0.074813351,
0.0040186392,
0.0096827252,
0.0073620556,
0.0228399485,
-0.0025737528,
0.0190343857,
-0.0171218775,
0.0159334838,
-0.0276232716,
-0.0502940081,
0.038406115,
-0.0224818308,
0.0452336594,
0.0730005726,
0.0057681422,
0.009106515,
-0.0092817815,
-0.0304760337,
0.0362207927,
0.0261868276,
0.0312078893,
-0.0001672776,
0.0042244047,
-0.0286875032,
0.0013646674,
-0.0456868894,
-0.0079760104,
-0.0090157781,
0.0151020624,
0.0378241278,
0.0700681433,
-0.05036797,
-0.0266018994,
0.0182145182,
0.0235858243,
-0.0408849046,
0.0303145088,
0.0061818664,
0.00446596,
0.0562244467,
-0.0412673689,
0.0571982712,
0.0023099559,
-0.0193760656,
-0.0525385477,
-0.0191840138,
-0.0335123055,
0.0267476514,
-0.0016907746,
-0.0902152061,
-0.0281168818,
0.0179301389,
0.0046894224,
-0.0282668434,
-0.0253353845,
-0.0834011957,
-0.0303471237,
-0.0445133522,
-0.0222271848,
0.0212357715,
-0.005670398,
-0.0560122915,
0.0755419508,
0.0323992223,
0.0265968181,
0.0093116518,
-0.0218009017,
0.0275215749,
-0.0568102971,
-0.0085227555,
-0.0314696953,
-0.0082598682,
0.0195883866,
0.0626735464,
0.0156556461,
-0.0625891015,
-0.0333494693,
-0.0792498291,
0.0186255015,
-0.0226890352,
0.0447598211,
0.021027131,
-0.0162527263,
0.0046923701,
0.0039329906,
-0.0798674077,
-0.0384615883,
0.0207472574,
0.0116756149,
0.0575822219,
0.0156506952,
0.0194008071,
-0.0195778236,
-0.0006330225,
-0.0044479677,
0.0343830436,
0.0620419867,
0.048354622,
-0.0512646958,
0.0024485774,
-0.0710960925,
-0.0456652828,
0.0445137694,
-0.0662840307,
0.0206643045,
0.0239343625,
0.0021763523,
0.0648400187,
0.0788198262,
-0.0241176356,
0.0314624161,
0.0206519216,
-0.0159758795,
-0.0142104458,
-0.0244802963,
0.0027180049,
0.0074021937,
-0.0463241488,
0.0373639613,
0.0227428712,
0.0153158428,
0.0002974052,
-0.0228396226,
0.0120250667,
-0.0277094766,
-0.0365238748,
-0.0205334015,
-0.0179379769,
0.0016443951,
0.0606036447,
0.0140106529,
-0.037107043,
0.0757840723,
-0.0374952815,
0.0002286004,
-0.0364111215,
-0.0074750958,
-0.0662486255,
0.0395135172,
-0.0151415821,
0.0253783204,
-0.0029004181,
0.012333842,
-0.0522294119,
-0.0020370304,
0.0264579281,
-0.0342247747,
0.0293137375,
-0.0277949087,
-0.0062483856,
-0.0095200595,
-0.0306491535,
-0.0207095984,
-0.0738108829,
-0.0237805974,
0.0065910183,
0.029321041,
-0.0161299314,
0.0211655181,
-0.0136437202,
0.0592559837,
-0.0387598872,
-0.0279885866,
-0.0023769499,
0.0151893198,
0.0571988411,
0.0900604352,
0.0758017525,
0.0244615376,
-0.0290151574,
-0.0143539971,
0.0493598096,
-0.0151266288,
0.0321463943,
-0.0048732497,
-0.0379177816,
0.000905899,
-0.0392228514,
-0.0315796956,
0.0351639353,
0.0496226922,
-0.0520443879,
0.0015082187,
0.101676248,
0.026838772,
0.0160009377,
0.0041076457,
-0.0122731291,
0.0397999436,
0.0120838974,
0.0368900299,
-0.0756339878,
-0.0336904302,
-0.0120145595,
0.0500277132,
-0.0038358008,
-0.0060526365,
0.0049411897,
-0.0981586501,
0.0073965471,
-0.0175077114,
-0.0095400708,
0.0016102584,
-0.0392937176,
-0.0081578847,
0.0056113517,
-0.0485614948,
0.0163324326,
-0.0253373329,
0.0376440659,
0.0386066437,
-0.0481566601,
0.0120573286,
0.0471833013,
-0.0249413215,
0.0256566238,
0.1112295091,
0.0195630472,
-0.0348946229,
-0.050298281,
-0.0258489698,
-0.0569317602,
0.0221819207,
0.0457100421,
0.0534012131,
0.0017685373,
-0.0022311134,
-0.0524306297,
0.0384236202,
-0.013350551,
0.0037606407,
0.0667443946,
0.0415966101,
-0.0089289024,
-0.0310452636,
-0.0174381174,
0.0398942344,
0.0052690213,
0.1046830043,
0.0328527242,
-0.0734528452,
-0.0507356077,
-0.0135359131,
0.001569099,
-0.0693535656,
-0.0576034226,
0.0056849369,
0.0520473979,
0.0194453914,
-0.0911415666,
-0.0578519776,
0.0292794444,
0.0253468677,
-0.0314197429,
-0.0078619057,
-0.0538267493,
0.0369989835,
-0.0161300618,
0.0205980856,
0.0061360011,
0.0428719297,
-0.0760538727,
-0.0075591258,
-0.0034362008,
-0.038190268,
-0.0305856559,
0.0233170837,
-0.0341660976,
-0.0042046458,
-0.0045110541,
0.0544803254,
0.0176000483,
-0.0368804485,
0.0059897439,
-0.0436968245,
0.0374886952,
0.0423186384,
-0.0417368226,
0.029941868,
0.0175966378,
0.021551799,
-0.0030146691,
0.0040215827,
-0.0591823086,
-0.0089410441,
-0.0158788022,
0.0302430112,
0.0370428897,
-0.0720377415,
0.0132802166,
0.0396060906,
-0.0482692719,
-0.0133633418,
0.0201682448,
0.0195553973,
0.0000404176,
-0.0228554122,
-0.0300546158,
-0.0316806138,
-0.0059416154,
-0.0126271676,
-0.0074434271,
0.0138254818,
0.027277343,
-0.0201252997,
0.0220788363,
-0.0355404094,
0.0364782512,
0.0325263105,
-0.023564674,
-0.012071576,
-0.0212441143,
-0.0591024123,
-0.060897693,
-0.0005251229,
0.0584051795,
0.0102607263,
0.0362990685,
0.015745461,
0.0113226743,
0.0121801775,
0.0228410792,
-0.0800117031,
-0.0637175441,
-0.0076251812,
-0.0101141185,
0.0163742118,
0.0014902976,
0.071434781,
0.0315110497,
-0.0012213995,
-0.0068950946,
0.018772345,
0.0072367783,
-0.0092884749,
-0.0142891072,
0.0282025505,
-0.0496866517,
-0.0278854277,
0.0978849456,
-0.0011990946,
-0.008566374,
-0.0111366399,
-0.0136224786,
-0.0119928457,
-0.0533573255,
-0.0673112646,
0.0256980937,
0.0380165167,
-0.0315523185,
-0.0670499504,
-0.0240312368,
-0.0042368206,
0.0142008299,
-0.0035074034,
-0.0002562051,
0.0614685304,
0.056627892,
0.0013243119,
-0.0335865393,
-0.0585537404,
0.0282870401,
-0.0326806307,
0.0425308123,
-0.0542249493,
-6.752839622e-33,
0.0032400668,
-0.0610770658,
-0.0056617544,
-0.0250189509,
-0.0341291241,
0.0047792871,
-0.0222488791,
-0.0140206274,
-0.0139548751,
0.0365299769,
-0.0049523874,
-0.0364660248,
-0.0072277333,
0.02418378,
0.0145828258,
-0.0523911268,
0.013465045,
0.0091530178,
-0.0551955514,
0.0289033856,
0.026510302,
-0.0276982673,
-0.011122263,
-0.0297980346,
0.0408925191,
-0.0149713848,
-0.0344121605,
0.0003044028,
0.0046987045,
0.0763434321,
0.0233576074,
0.0317324772,
0.0400011688,
-0.0623663776,
0.004591465,
0.0513376072,
-0.0542873479,
-0.0270957667,
0.0058541391,
-0.0609814562,
-0.0739798397,
-0.0455679931,
0.0333628096,
0.0097820256,
-0.0046824529,
-0.0388679542,
0.0622566976,
-0.0135476515,
0.0473774262,
-0.055444371,
-0.0199119374,
0.0145351393,
-0.0176113844,
-0.0310931001,
-0.0449829772,
0.061562743,
-0.0071277097,
-0.0094882045,
-0.0250973981,
0.0199532825,
0.0122610219,
0.0453980044,
0.0440391712,
-0.0197382141,
-0.0092194565,
0.0455783606,
0.0158697031,
0.017555112,
-0.0450722761,
-0.0192862097,
-0.0711042359,
0.0176759064,
0.0913431123,
0.0516322069,
0.0413983017,
0.0217272788,
-0.0536293276,
0.0671583265,
-0.0299099181,
0.0187240653,
0.0038682523,
-0.048266679,
-0.0224039853,
-0.0081739724,
-0.0619298443,
0.0450856537,
-0.0459858477,
-0.0383547097,
0.0255100057,
-0.0065556779,
-0.0278066695,
-0.0273983106,
0.0010903579,
-0.0084872805,
0.0225458276,
0.0306850094,
-0.0468994677,
0.0294710435,
0.0383167528,
-0.0127112158,
-0.0141718751,
0.0600103512,
0.0061355811,
0.0371885598,
0.0438682064,
0.0041043675,
0.0054163872,
-0.003387355,
-0.0433124304,
0.0061357561,
-0.02668944,
0.0164704379,
-0.0211885795,
-0.0564247705,
-0.0060684653,
0.0241848081,
-0.0174992718,
0.0260161869,
-0.0413877703,
0.0085239047,
-0.0140253939,
-0.0480432771,
0.0426413715,
0.02377888,
-0.049752079,
0.0373915583,
-0.0125096776,
0.0030610713,
-0.0156707168,
-0.0131562082,
-0.0202067345,
-0.001218766,
2.797e-7,
0.0516014807,
0.0104702897,
0.0184881426,
0.0402957126,
0.0000241457,
0.02309216,
0.0404663645,
0.0030917127,
-0.0035597133,
-0.0135149211,
-0.0184630621,
0.0056963204,
0.0482906215,
0.0383239686,
-0.0758616179,
-0.0410546511,
-0.0764000192,
-0.0076995096,
-0.0194993243,
-0.0068668663,
0.1043409705,
0.0055701742,
-0.0139062451,
0.0135856504,
-0.0028637892,
-0.0167103298,
0.0353528932,
-0.0145911388,
0.0267684441,
0.0341400243,
0.0515774451,
-0.0410908163,
0.0140388906,
0.0168787818,
-0.034240786,
-0.0235565584,
0.0633630455,
0.076278381,
0.0288660154,
-0.0433694683,
-0.0228687264,
-0.0435047895,
0.0294736754,
-0.0505655445,
0.08144252,
-0.0491720513,
-0.0238875542,
-0.0159310922,
-0.0512769595,
-0.013710618,
0.00025212,
-0.0113042807,
-0.0049327365,
0.0160017218,
0.0026404234,
0.0124057056,
-0.0064218845,
-0.0176982265,
-0.0551260076,
0.0479528531,
-0.0305799115,
-0.0329998434,
-0.039824117,
0.0070710424,
0.0105917128,
-0.0532738045,
-0.0065937932,
2.331934902e-34,
-0.0029743845,
0.0065074982,
0.0227714293,
-0.0099448897,
0.0507973395,
0.0027055189,
-0.0121381171,
-0.0291663241,
0.0458859131,
-0.0612099394,
-0.0054911692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18200v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18200v1 | Contextual Knowledge Learning For Dialogue Generation | 2023-05-29T16:54:10 | 2023-05-29T16:54:10 | Wen Zheng, Natasa Milic-Frayling, Ke Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Incorporating conversational context and knowledge into dialogue generation
models has been essential for improving the quality of the generated responses.
The context, comprising utterances from previous dialogue exchanges, is used as
a source of content for response generation and as a means of selecting
external knowledge. However, to avoid introducing irrelevant content, it is key
to enable fine-grained scoring of context and knowledge. In this paper, we
present a novel approach to context and knowledge weighting as an integral part
of model training. We guide the model training through a Contextual Knowledge
Learning (CKL) process which involves Latent Vectors for context and knowledge,
respectively. CKL Latent Vectors capture the relationship between context,
knowledge, and responses through weak supervision and enable differential
weighting of context utterances and knowledge sentences during the training
process. Experiments with two standard datasets and human evaluation
demonstrate that CKL leads to a significant improvement compared with the
performance of six strong baseline models and shows robustness with regard to
reduced sizes of training sets. | [
0.0577421077,
0.0252445694,
-0.0067344354,
0.0237656776,
-0.0076287268,
0.003220326,
0.0278287344,
-0.0327032581,
0.0024687054,
-0.0593204238,
-0.0113673816,
-0.0240925979,
-0.0115573695,
0.0387514941,
0.0378059112,
-0.0668657422,
0.0091784894,
0.0075601386,
0.0134608652,
0.0024584639,
0.01870263,
-0.0019959458,
-0.0462083705,
0.0242374502,
-0.0527158342,
-0.0156760346,
-0.0239098892,
-0.0045531839,
0.0524193458,
-0.0318497121,
0.0703987479,
0.0403800756,
0.0391814671,
-0.0031860594,
0.0000019082,
-0.0358112119,
0.0122429403,
-0.0448401906,
-0.0020364148,
-0.0225798935,
0.0140577797,
0.0001918255,
0.0182945877,
0.0294310469,
-0.0608534776,
0.0234537553,
0.0312731527,
0.068424359,
0.0642077997,
0.0431854948,
-0.0132998126,
-0.0187561028,
-0.0259187445,
-0.0232373346,
0.0321591422,
-0.0428965129,
-0.0058372235,
0.0933060423,
-0.0232284889,
-0.0025738357,
-0.0075001279,
0.0378293097,
0.0093042795,
-0.0472122468,
0.0205213372,
0.035994865,
-0.0109396987,
-0.0035512678,
-0.0146722617,
0.1168117672,
0.0507602543,
-0.0039699953,
0.0022711633,
-0.025119463,
0.0042120316,
-0.0278820712,
-0.0609673262,
0.0362476483,
0.0048904354,
-0.0045179557,
-0.0336220823,
0.047398366,
-0.0207676329,
0.0162347574,
0.0068487441,
-0.0086942334,
-0.0012605621,
-0.0277396832,
-0.0261560082,
-0.0042540855,
-0.0430260524,
-0.0487656854,
-0.0017161698,
0.0372378901,
-0.0450844467,
0.0283861645,
-0.0277807657,
0.0089772278,
0.0295300912,
-0.0263981149,
-0.0238143634,
0.02062409,
-0.008817086,
0.0197371598,
-0.0097350562,
0.0542957895,
0.0115672741,
-0.0289717093,
-0.0288530868,
0.0228075963,
-0.0571682081,
-0.0361003131,
-0.0316787623,
0.0297684912,
-0.0498875678,
-0.0459999479,
-0.0370959975,
0.0421871357,
-0.0146199139,
-0.0076840762,
0.0104979686,
0.0583962686,
-0.0401912034,
0.0451834053,
-0.0100301029,
0.0048625879,
-0.0448007286,
0.0331410877,
0.0306626558,
-0.0292472951,
-0.0056099389,
0.0540153384,
0.0333965048,
-0.0151256677,
-0.0219663065,
0.0274062492,
-0.0543586276,
-0.0047416459,
-0.0256023873,
-0.0475917645,
-0.0635731816,
-0.0564525649,
-0.0160095561,
-0.0060804463,
0.0078656562,
0.0005442862,
-0.0224918425,
0.013176702,
0.0079286313,
0.0201091897,
-0.0060986271,
0.0268317349,
-0.0005046196,
-0.015337239,
0.0487244129,
0.0319746584,
-0.0081638442,
0.0296971723,
0.0175640956,
0.0107504893,
0.0123336175,
0.0156011581,
-0.0206496138,
-0.0382513516,
0.0462366417,
-0.0004667932,
0.0098334616,
0.0188146587,
-0.0093083829,
0.0466949567,
0.027104212,
0.0407661498,
-0.0748715401,
0.0364489518,
0.0549957678,
-0.0045709223,
0.0223651323,
0.0122771123,
0.0663205162,
0.0306430738,
-0.0217903759,
0.0123931095,
-0.0104685398,
0.0361543298,
-0.0026798383,
0.0311916005,
0.0413866825,
-0.0023557215,
-0.024300402,
-0.0256217979,
0.04789114,
0.0119194379,
0.0026104599,
-0.0057623181,
-0.0019294589,
0.0253770314,
-0.0433453098,
0.040554937,
0.0055809054,
-0.0687198117,
-0.0132272663,
-0.0062215449,
0.0438890085,
0.0408689268,
0.0341528468,
-0.0031365941,
-0.0638504177,
-0.0199807324,
0.0268690065,
0.0378679819,
0.0186945703,
-0.0621208139,
0.0207836907,
-0.062636219,
-0.0273461938,
-0.0268657748,
-0.0037123256,
0.022283433,
-0.0096327346,
0.0151341828,
0.0643383637,
0.0295731444,
0.0200862307,
0.0185467731,
-0.0065518157,
-0.0332109928,
0.0232159644,
-0.0019677905,
0.0311347041,
0.0444632061,
0.0128148124,
0.0154727781,
0.0378053002,
-0.0082200281,
-0.0101728141,
0.0639708117,
-0.1084745452,
-0.1083505899,
0.0197690539,
-0.0107016414,
0.039152272,
-0.0466471389,
-0.0108211683,
-0.0763732716,
0.041823566,
-0.0196396895,
0.0419169478,
-0.0687807575,
-0.0239624698,
0.0351228975,
-0.0119378874,
-0.0314026736,
0.0782683417,
0.0175269973,
0.005511146,
0.0834631249,
0.05425236,
0.0178957675,
-0.0289048422,
0.0258142352,
-0.0295441858,
-0.0258505791,
0.0288714655,
0.0453860946,
0.0501860157,
-0.0688088387,
-0.0164477807,
-0.1281132847,
0.0139821637,
-0.0215213727,
-0.0117912889,
0.0340917967,
0.0043630125,
0.0179851279,
-0.0237875395,
-0.0809210464,
0.0244169459,
0.0377160534,
-0.0125545319,
0.0244671255,
0.0428564921,
0.0010396848,
-0.0359111205,
0.0398392007,
0.0369588137,
0.0376542434,
0.0313738734,
0.0233037546,
-0.0215936322,
0.0610095039,
-0.0268401671,
0.0062378529,
-0.0293014999,
-0.0259228032,
0.0391569026,
0.0318294317,
0.0296459142,
0.0405060574,
0.0599642806,
0.0297383126,
-0.0024894965,
-0.0287592951,
-0.057487458,
0.0294457842,
-0.0384087749,
0.0045976555,
-0.031943664,
0.0091071688,
0.0170162953,
0.0082878917,
0.0443371572,
0.0166110415,
-0.062539883,
0.0209851209,
0.0292041861,
-0.0736033395,
-0.0257945396,
-0.0059404243,
-0.0348956622,
0.0168430693,
-0.0274308175,
-0.0090018595,
0.0375280865,
-0.0138693945,
-0.0074718543,
-0.0286867768,
0.0028263198,
-0.0200836807,
0.0084682265,
-0.0185425859,
0.0299992058,
-0.0193693768,
-0.0152288014,
-0.049208235,
-0.0065004118,
0.0462222621,
-0.0077179689,
-0.009243628,
-0.0519912392,
0.0076746857,
0.011841191,
-0.0314010754,
-0.0901183039,
-0.0102437474,
0.0155160744,
0.0191248283,
0.026703544,
-0.0012529506,
0.0023574559,
0.0093303891,
0.0275714025,
0.0336123668,
-0.0075575151,
-0.0066749598,
-0.0133259958,
0.0690526366,
0.0446720272,
0.0273274668,
0.0111983875,
-0.0373849571,
0.0550997481,
0.0332763046,
0.0198778454,
-0.0248095896,
-0.0131175201,
0.0139045548,
-0.0088295648,
0.0110457567,
-0.0052542663,
0.0293441247,
0.0585117601,
-0.0064928061,
-0.026077928,
0.1177532598,
0.0259790514,
-0.0202442296,
-0.0037401803,
-0.0075174524,
0.0417488776,
0.028325038,
0.01622306,
-0.0738693923,
-0.0243350882,
-0.0327861048,
0.0120094754,
-0.0390315093,
-0.0445107371,
-0.0177223124,
-0.0791114122,
0.0193971992,
0.0179614313,
-0.0752955973,
-0.0288405158,
0.0129815461,
-0.010868147,
-0.0090908539,
0.031194225,
-0.0096159922,
-0.0127116693,
0.0203767009,
0.0342988446,
0.0007663037,
-0.077048853,
-0.008361578,
-0.0075336676,
0.0790680349,
0.0566623807,
0.055831857,
0.0443124659,
0.0149608795,
0.0276657082,
-0.0528197512,
0.0221769102,
-0.0155530553,
0.0389754996,
-0.0303753857,
0.0115829855,
-0.0174384676,
0.0477306657,
-0.0222606678,
-0.0482990444,
0.0295241401,
-0.0001872527,
-0.0352770649,
0.0020552657,
0.0076116072,
0.0631920174,
0.0846469998,
0.0670494884,
0.0444269441,
-0.017351931,
0.0079695256,
-0.0075849057,
0.0393554531,
-0.0529611558,
0.0435968824,
0.0000679143,
0.0231916085,
0.0406950489,
-0.1305508912,
-0.044393193,
0.0414859578,
0.0345112979,
-0.0094753932,
0.0037917255,
-0.0227522925,
-0.0096310563,
-0.041679427,
-0.015345335,
0.0000500431,
-0.0172847994,
-0.0200702734,
-0.0213473886,
0.0354957469,
-0.0690349191,
-0.0170887932,
0.0080412868,
-0.0560548082,
-0.0782793537,
-0.0415524244,
0.0840266347,
0.0202854704,
0.0724530593,
0.0244961921,
-0.0186753944,
0.0354631096,
0.0180635732,
-0.0550299548,
0.0002735623,
0.0153625943,
0.0510861687,
-0.0183134377,
0.0057551144,
-0.0154851619,
0.0261797868,
0.0052890461,
0.0536341332,
-0.0588264316,
-0.0648371801,
0.0237628743,
-0.0258799624,
-0.0329390615,
-0.0099146497,
-0.0247987527,
-0.0496544875,
0.0160450637,
-0.0385714211,
-0.025217725,
-0.0639700443,
0.0170999486,
-0.0270791501,
0.0131045328,
0.0110163018,
-0.0356259234,
-0.0225791056,
0.0476798899,
-0.0300490186,
-0.0025731288,
0.0231002625,
0.0175446831,
0.0094277505,
-0.0092768371,
-0.0317878947,
0.0172572061,
-0.003880051,
0.0257607084,
0.0200055577,
0.1062781289,
0.0135398917,
-0.0416929647,
0.0359250791,
0.0050886022,
-0.0793242753,
0.023301281,
-0.0412637889,
0.0111095719,
0.0206713323,
-0.0150910085,
0.0428455956,
-0.0407646745,
0.0254643243,
0.0010745489,
0.0750497729,
-0.0126903243,
-0.0542241484,
0.0326619819,
0.0177376755,
-0.007788552,
0.0216673929,
0.0771915019,
-0.0136006903,
0.0192031544,
-0.0215626955,
0.0164916869,
-0.0771262944,
-0.0131655755,
0.0555298887,
0.0440651476,
-0.0033111554,
0.0514509343,
-0.0244611949,
-0.0367666744,
-0.0092899939,
0.0132521736,
0.0003977631,
0.0117816618,
0.0525904931,
0.05877373,
-0.0152479177,
-0.0172101278,
-0.0540571101,
0.0088682678,
-0.0467357524,
-0.0017032102,
-0.0686568394,
-6.114018686e-33,
-0.0472055487,
-0.0655271262,
0.0447009318,
0.0018710818,
-0.0376873203,
0.0064478805,
-0.0513375513,
-0.0180163514,
0.0075293328,
0.0120564001,
0.0270837806,
-0.0073609287,
-0.010520068,
0.0636857897,
-0.0206833743,
-0.0109995576,
0.0559243299,
0.004561061,
0.0001713143,
0.0772003755,
0.050365705,
0.0376919284,
-0.0090198871,
-0.0786348581,
0.016627036,
-0.0074873972,
-0.0255116802,
0.0308680534,
0.0174192395,
0.0502085537,
-0.0465884134,
0.0006119677,
0.0260659922,
-0.0141789652,
-0.0154127367,
0.0329113938,
-0.0476434156,
-0.0182198156,
0.0224533658,
-0.0147130247,
-0.0334424041,
-0.0409501903,
-0.0209536366,
-0.0376546383,
0.0395573303,
0.0013139665,
0.0267208349,
-0.0264981594,
-0.0433558971,
-0.0678665489,
-0.0611808263,
0.0150186522,
-0.045616772,
-0.0286455955,
-0.0317810252,
0.0630618855,
0.0010937568,
-0.042237401,
-0.0120362239,
0.0196873974,
-0.005705087,
-0.0147855859,
0.0365132354,
0.0568388067,
-0.00198028,
0.073152408,
-0.0224304069,
0.0010530151,
-0.0242082551,
-0.0296565704,
-0.0213540159,
0.0492311195,
-0.0029956196,
0.0885321721,
-0.0308912005,
-0.0149233229,
-0.050772924,
0.0226544384,
-0.0033830851,
0.0092018973,
0.0207149219,
-0.0179839805,
0.001447676,
-0.0034527297,
-0.0365184844,
-0.0135832215,
-0.0189962126,
-0.0278520249,
0.0344340242,
0.0470333062,
-0.018534949,
-0.037508104,
0.0180663224,
-0.0300319921,
0.0236435607,
0.0270343926,
-0.0372521691,
-0.0031078646,
-0.0317409635,
0.0102914618,
-0.0647265017,
-0.0354864486,
0.0793757141,
0.0080031799,
0.0108915092,
0.0192757528,
0.0426568724,
0.0038279865,
-0.0220865291,
-0.0097050294,
-0.0382942893,
0.0682330728,
-0.0383690409,
0.0124732116,
-0.0242027603,
0.0111984974,
-0.0404635705,
0.0199533328,
-0.0134318992,
-0.0349476449,
-0.0124442475,
-0.0569401756,
0.0228728764,
0.0254024807,
-0.0782167763,
0.0003978382,
0.0246926825,
-0.0146492086,
0.0453719273,
-0.0173030272,
-0.0101254508,
0.0024356274,
2.557e-7,
-0.0052200458,
0.0157038588,
0.0173454192,
-0.0252787862,
0.005618237,
0.0266603902,
0.0028358307,
0.0452779867,
0.0145531921,
-0.031078849,
0.0500225127,
0.0097373789,
0.039065998,
-0.0092498828,
-0.079880625,
-0.0350870229,
-0.0738779008,
-0.0623800568,
0.0089835813,
-0.0188851263,
0.0785321146,
0.0152611025,
-0.0574143529,
-0.0160905868,
0.000970335,
-0.0196862537,
0.0747519359,
-0.0219351184,
-0.011448361,
0.0048164995,
0.0342236646,
-0.0212975629,
0.0073977644,
0.0461495221,
-0.0246284548,
0.0105213169,
-0.0182581358,
0.043210648,
0.0254546124,
-0.0605052635,
0.0015929242,
0.021494247,
0.042096477,
-0.047365468,
0.0478948914,
-0.0771399587,
-0.0111964028,
-0.0192510299,
-0.0356505364,
-0.0031076858,
-0.0180913433,
-0.0213971287,
-0.0217581093,
0.0102402512,
0.01046101,
0.0115515236,
0.0398718379,
-0.0721295699,
-0.0123726754,
0.0166339464,
-0.061677482,
-0.0348128192,
-0.0337529369,
-0.048599638,
0.0117163341,
-0.0242506471,
0.0327612311,
2.066229557e-34,
0.0330546089,
-0.0241599455,
0.0064089843,
0.0174963772,
0.0279221274,
-0.0090212282,
-0.0058387048,
0.0058447281,
0.0541218445,
-0.0700726882,
-0.0202679262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18189v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18189v1 | Marked Personas: Using Natural Language Prompts to Measure Stereotypes in Language Models | 2023-05-29T16:29:22 | 2023-05-29T16:29:22 | Myra Cheng, Esin Durmus, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | To recognize and mitigate harms from large language models (LLMs), we need to
understand the prevalence and nuances of stereotypes in LLM outputs. Toward
this end, we present Marked Personas, a prompt-based method to measure
stereotypes in LLMs for intersectional demographic groups without any lexicon
or data labeling. Grounded in the sociolinguistic concept of markedness (which
characterizes explicitly linguistically marked categories versus unmarked
defaults), our proposed method is twofold: 1) prompting an LLM to generate
personas, i.e., natural language descriptions, of the target demographic group
alongside personas of unmarked, default groups; 2) identifying the words that
significantly distinguish personas of the target group from corresponding
unmarked ones. We find that the portrayals generated by GPT-3.5 and GPT-4
contain higher rates of racial stereotypes than human-written portrayals using
the same prompts. The words distinguishing personas of marked (non-white,
non-male) groups reflect patterns of othering and exoticizing these
demographics. An intersectional lens further reveals tropes that dominate
portrayals of marginalized groups, such as tropicalism and the
hypersexualization of minoritized women. These representational harms have
concerning implications for downstream applications like story generation. | [
0.0398855284,
0.0880405009,
-0.034782894,
0.0215277839,
0.0167084187,
0.0285343416,
0.0319923945,
-0.0256245229,
0.0190614704,
-0.0880138353,
-0.0016238755,
-0.0541820861,
0.0464464724,
0.0279180612,
0.0312901177,
-0.0438645966,
0.0326167643,
0.03611397,
0.0216865521,
-0.0132312281,
0.0122133149,
0.0773359239,
0.0346167795,
0.069185704,
-0.03603651,
-0.0412481986,
0.0666734353,
-0.0182614289,
0.0010325789,
-0.0187559519,
0.0566324629,
0.0713321418,
0.0084606633,
0.0273649488,
0.0000018774,
-0.0755022168,
0.0247556679,
-0.010405791,
0.0245288964,
0.0015349006,
0.0568983927,
-0.0047811181,
-0.0070196362,
0.0269542243,
-0.0240273438,
-0.0115418499,
0.0420503356,
0.0035246105,
0.0294934697,
-0.0006319237,
0.0028537617,
-0.0102014178,
-0.0737811774,
0.0039666248,
-0.0068106712,
0.0437928773,
0.0378166772,
-0.0607926659,
-0.0246781465,
-0.0462072045,
-0.0064784815,
0.0031565148,
0.0006338533,
0.0220910478,
0.0145348161,
0.0034232989,
-0.0357903801,
-0.026965661,
0.0072861374,
0.0299115181,
0.0398241132,
-0.0018115644,
-0.0282853059,
0.015654169,
-0.0035732256,
-0.0123182777,
0.0017834278,
0.0540420376,
-0.0078840517,
-0.0045872,
-0.0276146978,
0.0119056506,
0.0189523678,
0.0304478332,
0.0129655069,
0.067166023,
0.0454961248,
0.0215629097,
-0.0401702113,
0.0050180228,
-0.0013819558,
-0.0633093268,
-0.0167317409,
0.0117768068,
-0.0261875484,
0.0254401751,
-0.0192250386,
-0.0132451439,
0.0266766082,
-0.0201342274,
0.0169686433,
0.0473851562,
-0.001435075,
-0.0189204104,
0.0319790803,
0.0243733246,
0.0363009684,
-0.0227774214,
0.0163245667,
-0.0106477207,
0.013982824,
-0.051147256,
-0.0019223846,
-0.0087319249,
0.0445135906,
0.0584794357,
-0.0276035145,
-0.0129517894,
-0.057686992,
0.0087619722,
-0.041394446,
0.0289911609,
-0.0455548801,
-0.0041696024,
-0.0522493124,
0.0051545613,
-0.0553314686,
0.0117909331,
-0.0450983383,
-0.0758659244,
0.0437596068,
-0.0075854803,
-0.0195351616,
-0.0337017737,
-0.0119241429,
0.0485285521,
-0.0014716063,
-0.0305709764,
-0.0463146903,
-0.0483603813,
-0.0251119602,
-0.0428542905,
-0.0267615896,
-0.0676744059,
0.0107958447,
0.0071278615,
0.0267134588,
-0.0653861612,
0.0019135564,
0.0365682244,
-0.0303467643,
0.074597083,
0.0353325792,
0.0020333363,
0.0594533272,
0.0317550674,
-0.030302383,
0.0764373317,
0.0318126455,
-0.0008910223,
0.0263240039,
-0.0194213949,
0.0030847352,
0.0370468497,
-0.0087099839,
0.0212523751,
-0.0385987833,
-0.0009624304,
0.0309905801,
-0.0059145954,
0.0475924723,
0.0538433455,
0.0287121423,
-0.0295388531,
0.0437888391,
0.0985134467,
-0.0615416244,
0.050682202,
0.0828833356,
0.0101123815,
-0.0148411738,
0.0419327468,
-0.0660820976,
-0.0366494991,
-0.0106657883,
-0.0694542229,
-0.0142731434,
0.0744298324,
-0.0147237917,
0.0029075516,
-0.0234215707,
0.0294695348,
0.0365884043,
-0.029809434,
-0.0101981321,
0.0431393012,
0.0058902185,
0.0589640141,
0.0599751957,
-0.0211108793,
0.0130610373,
-0.0341456905,
0.0198764447,
0.043744348,
0.0164474752,
-0.0050723953,
0.0271646623,
-0.0446783938,
-0.0368836075,
0.0660506859,
0.0315614603,
-0.005691153,
-0.0106528793,
0.0042336662,
0.0375302695,
0.0034736288,
0.0353696831,
0.0645773038,
0.054280851,
0.0385887846,
0.0283759553,
-0.0310970936,
-0.056236688,
0.0143618258,
-0.0467162468,
-0.0259538852,
-0.0177015066,
0.0088374242,
0.0211674888,
0.0201231856,
-0.0293363202,
-0.0178784057,
-0.0506541841,
-0.0036633965,
0.0021424713,
0.0515411906,
-0.061298769,
0.0284556076,
0.0270135179,
-0.0786616579,
-0.0443599783,
0.0358951725,
0.0367552079,
-0.0028409583,
0.0636218339,
-0.0119256489,
0.0139672784,
-0.0260001868,
-0.0187690817,
-0.0239085685,
0.0204173848,
-0.0206298903,
0.0440391675,
0.0189423077,
0.0098696565,
0.0252647046,
-0.0407203659,
0.0169785023,
-0.0073294099,
-0.0245461185,
0.035851948,
0.0016077452,
0.0018853646,
0.0184962768,
-0.0130664734,
-0.0210259426,
0.0138090132,
-0.0854510963,
-0.0013997217,
-0.0143902879,
-0.0348802507,
0.0115116304,
0.0160789564,
-0.0476506054,
0.016687192,
-0.0246001296,
-0.0623376146,
0.0214829035,
0.0263861064,
-0.0049061552,
-0.0200223885,
-0.005823262,
-0.0042128004,
0.0154944137,
-0.0384612978,
0.073429659,
0.0202949252,
0.0024346178,
-0.0197700001,
-0.0410154015,
-0.0682949051,
-0.0172320493,
-0.0008700679,
-0.0246911291,
0.0420923419,
0.0386676677,
0.0646331608,
-0.0097557129,
0.0324670263,
0.0439175591,
0.0415026583,
-0.0416117646,
-0.0092256535,
-0.0355766565,
-0.0043326658,
0.0132831018,
0.0394603238,
-0.123003833,
-0.0089088669,
0.0626046807,
0.0559153259,
-0.0318131596,
-0.061175365,
0.0657334998,
-0.0612719916,
-0.0345815904,
-0.0015474366,
-0.0398333333,
-0.0237082429,
0.0143416598,
-0.0283154659,
-0.0372969694,
0.0589656681,
-0.0184980165,
0.0032019748,
0.0002234453,
0.0007543475,
-0.0377595015,
0.0399752408,
0.0195249561,
0.0445997007,
0.0400612429,
-0.027724199,
-0.0332596302,
-0.0159674659,
0.0088352337,
-0.0302480794,
0.0442068093,
-0.0569674596,
0.0005025954,
0.0148072327,
0.0046619913,
-0.0516160838,
-0.047735896,
-0.0320718288,
0.001517301,
0.0177172665,
-0.0227948539,
0.0316071995,
0.0045601134,
-0.0059191743,
0.0081129782,
-0.021950746,
0.0008130502,
0.0021565496,
-0.007550735,
-0.0030362331,
-0.0191843137,
0.0190029461,
-0.0193759371,
0.0031675955,
0.0135151623,
-0.0584276058,
0.0309289731,
-0.0092282649,
0.0148412697,
0.0317616798,
-0.0138779767,
0.0030697854,
-0.0107672894,
0.0480356701,
-0.0344291478,
0.0073910169,
0.0881956816,
0.0373712145,
-0.0334319547,
0.0299623534,
0.005237218,
0.037241634,
0.0309419893,
0.0087250341,
-0.0859364718,
0.0336289145,
0.0041246074,
0.0326057449,
-0.0671465099,
-0.0544835404,
-0.0549637079,
-0.1095144674,
0.0282927398,
0.015272134,
-0.0459292345,
0.009372904,
-0.013988113,
0.0357901901,
0.0374120027,
0.0230244789,
-0.0369301066,
0.0025129318,
0.0093922792,
-0.0228099152,
-0.062322598,
-0.0328494497,
0.0246869493,
-0.0141963968,
0.0365654789,
-0.0022887553,
0.0415134504,
-0.019643778,
-0.0053205797,
0.0299231634,
-0.0241098087,
-0.0097261406,
-0.0378718823,
-0.0036357869,
-0.0253658462,
-0.0203628186,
-0.0237662755,
0.019232437,
0.0182888042,
-0.013348599,
-0.0084583452,
0.0381769575,
0.0189494714,
-0.0491173305,
-0.0407868624,
0.0108123468,
0.0059250328,
0.0913482234,
0.0516927093,
-0.0273897983,
0.0217329767,
-0.0807471648,
0.0330647454,
0.0284527652,
-0.097164914,
0.0317389704,
-0.0085888123,
-0.0507829897,
-0.0242930781,
-0.0872509778,
0.0519696623,
-0.0027952595,
0.0408837721,
-0.0510548763,
-0.0234109424,
-0.0095282337,
-0.0499517284,
0.0488534048,
-0.0482660681,
0.0423819497,
0.0157785472,
-0.0292559657,
0.0038829912,
-0.037836045,
-0.0006812906,
0.0101616429,
-0.0135180214,
-0.0598976798,
0.0389465317,
0.0002935407,
0.0241138544,
0.0281948969,
-0.0022341653,
-0.0650099814,
0.0244835801,
0.019590728,
0.0252293684,
0.0340003334,
-0.0515373982,
0.0347706415,
-0.0019148618,
0.0364926942,
-0.0080778906,
0.0638687611,
-0.0107103437,
-0.0109900003,
-0.0477077663,
-0.0463413633,
-0.0103939492,
-0.0092968512,
0.0015807939,
-0.0658099726,
-0.0024644018,
-0.0616384,
-0.0827300996,
-0.0303828064,
-0.0521580465,
0.00146977,
-0.0195991118,
0.0010159533,
0.0252471007,
-0.0440702513,
-0.0034219068,
-0.0719011202,
0.0622322187,
-0.0371796899,
0.0019713056,
0.0424952209,
0.0086544482,
0.019574983,
0.0218840111,
-0.0086784856,
0.0173881501,
-0.0660034344,
0.0305610225,
0.0314519852,
0.0354555845,
0.0122150201,
0.0152206225,
-0.0074681332,
-0.0199542958,
0.0234951284,
-0.022028761,
-0.0019017197,
0.0137372073,
0.0200233851,
-0.032691732,
0.0271545891,
-0.0009964738,
-0.0173857771,
0.0127650248,
-0.0149465064,
0.0340282656,
-0.0507555492,
0.0464557335,
0.0092185521,
-0.0113198133,
0.0002018541,
0.0324373245,
0.0195655655,
0.0394213796,
0.0312985368,
-0.0682199895,
-0.0133474134,
-0.0033933774,
0.0310732387,
-0.0238195509,
0.0243310239,
-0.0025669278,
-0.1123313904,
-0.0628501326,
0.0097090844,
-0.0213921443,
0.0071911346,
-0.000667142,
0.0053846603,
0.0321029425,
-0.0144772651,
-0.0212915484,
-0.007833126,
0.0246859826,
-0.027626548,
0.0003312148,
0.0176545065,
-6.289292976e-33,
-0.0495174117,
-0.0862108693,
-0.0256245658,
-0.0198955163,
-0.0392164402,
-0.0064145396,
-0.030385403,
-0.0000956201,
0.0220868979,
0.0176143162,
0.026902657,
0.0013965127,
0.0047162306,
-0.0258267373,
-0.0080325836,
0.032698568,
0.0695315897,
0.0013476687,
-0.0604063161,
-0.0223317239,
0.0109748514,
-0.0019382717,
0.0298551936,
-0.0546161979,
0.0624610633,
-0.0407589786,
-0.0413191579,
-0.0009733566,
0.0197738782,
-0.003589008,
-0.0444437079,
0.0742284581,
0.0367856063,
0.0083947601,
0.0157317668,
0.0891137645,
-0.0216564089,
-0.0334630758,
0.0462395884,
0.0151448045,
0.0313946195,
-0.0516216084,
-0.0002927657,
-0.0085015902,
-0.0178348348,
0.0185702052,
0.0674893409,
-0.0149651496,
0.0757493749,
0.0086853951,
-0.0624860674,
0.0091101583,
-0.0054431651,
0.0352667868,
-0.0315767005,
0.0240722839,
0.0201821048,
0.0187190548,
-0.0495260507,
0.0086445808,
-0.0072434712,
-0.0237037316,
0.0531578586,
0.054173734,
-0.0058488911,
0.0564440675,
0.0324343741,
0.040153008,
-0.0163768232,
-0.0341173001,
0.0529264957,
-0.0459296331,
-0.0009734994,
0.0733594224,
0.0033356026,
-0.0361772403,
0.0273975264,
0.0077415188,
0.0371493436,
-0.0354077369,
0.0378219895,
-0.031646952,
-0.0533221923,
-0.0709717795,
-0.0416275449,
-0.0686086416,
-0.006050712,
-0.0251985788,
0.0275379047,
-0.0225647222,
-0.040638689,
0.0261565503,
0.0112856114,
-0.0201755594,
-0.0416520946,
-0.0130941803,
-0.0395260751,
-0.0275844485,
0.0272809509,
0.0239638072,
-0.0281931702,
0.0345360786,
0.0163858254,
0.0181243103,
0.0383083783,
0.006987276,
-0.0147219002,
0.0259081703,
-0.0566467866,
0.0083981836,
-0.0085295811,
0.0217444375,
-0.0100962268,
0.0228203591,
0.0362631306,
0.033424288,
-0.0104635963,
-0.0098351603,
0.0468595065,
0.0002606601,
-0.0329624899,
0.0348803699,
-0.0451702774,
0.0359963663,
-0.0569231622,
-0.0180118382,
-0.0004659274,
0.027727671,
0.08841943,
-0.0261441879,
-0.013921448,
-0.0784173161,
2.482e-7,
0.0058194846,
0.0369594805,
-0.0181256253,
0.0464942642,
0.0542415902,
0.0297745876,
0.0387657993,
0.0298559032,
0.0514165238,
-0.0312755927,
-0.0364900008,
0.0315687694,
0.0219961442,
0.093942903,
-0.0671591759,
0.0348091722,
-0.0362659134,
0.0195672736,
-0.0587667897,
-0.0152816614,
0.0223076344,
0.0399563462,
0.0280951653,
-0.0216301866,
-0.0550516397,
-0.0392837003,
0.0422887988,
-0.0369731747,
-0.0153199928,
0.0122700641,
0.0250079054,
0.0327465273,
0.0356936567,
0.0023689745,
0.0199649613,
0.0339296609,
0.0170316175,
-0.0094457874,
-0.0165360887,
0.0205168687,
-0.0028239507,
0.0174966063,
-0.0360674113,
-0.066511482,
0.0541187674,
0.0166944377,
-0.0296140146,
-0.0372096039,
-0.0170965809,
-0.0221714918,
0.0183635801,
-0.047190778,
-0.0629196391,
0.0303523391,
0.0224486832,
-0.033131212,
-0.0033080648,
-0.0529883578,
-0.0174967498,
0.0033495834,
-0.0359854288,
-0.0362506136,
0.0059031616,
0.0017297562,
-0.0396573655,
-0.0566194542,
0.0632276759,
2.416693785e-34,
0.0168443751,
0.0267999228,
0.0066705942,
-0.0332355201,
0.04467538,
0.007360362,
0.0217350516,
-0.0146593163,
0.0523301363,
-0.0135956276,
-0.0045814677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18185v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18185v2 | Syntax and Semantics Meet in the "Middle": Probing the Syntax-Semantics Interface of LMs Through Agentivity | 2023-05-29T16:24:01 | 2023-07-10T13:10:40 | Lindia Tjuatja, Emmy Liu, Lori Levin, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in large language models have prompted researchers to examine
their abilities across a variety of linguistic tasks, but little has been done
to investigate how models handle the interactions in meaning across words and
larger syntactic forms -- i.e. phenomena at the intersection of syntax and
semantics. We present the semantic notion of agentivity as a case study for
probing such interactions. We created a novel evaluation dataset by utilitizing
the unique linguistic properties of a subset of optionally transitive English
verbs. This dataset was used to prompt varying sizes of three model classes to
see if they are sensitive to agentivity at the lexical level, and if they can
appropriately employ these word-level priors given a specific syntactic
context. Overall, GPT-3 text-davinci-003 performs extremely well across all
experiments, outperforming all other models tested by far. In fact, the results
are even better correlated with human judgements than both syntactic and
semantic corpus statistics. This suggests that LMs may potentially serve as
more useful tools for linguistic annotation, theory testing, and discovery than
select corpora for certain tasks. Code is available at
https://github.com/lindiatjuatja/lm_sem | [
0.0317382477,
0.019143682,
-0.0568790436,
0.0610870793,
-0.0469908863,
0.0167103764,
-0.0263396427,
0.0013889641,
0.0066630696,
-0.0948901772,
-0.0411709435,
-0.0028723744,
-0.0337151214,
0.0043036714,
0.0482255034,
-0.0033287606,
0.0710999668,
-0.0065771462,
0.002618965,
0.0274808053,
0.0157946292,
-0.0043651261,
0.0127637312,
0.0341495723,
-0.0118586756,
0.0191005096,
-0.0080247978,
-0.0086214235,
-0.0071625821,
-0.0201904122,
-0.0225068145,
0.0420105793,
0.0131522613,
0.0413382165,
0.0000018343,
-0.0887029096,
0.0187955089,
-0.0091191344,
-0.0235840958,
0.0033656713,
0.0975873619,
-0.0014383292,
-0.0001438938,
-0.0217435267,
-0.0651348978,
0.0063931397,
0.0282444302,
-0.0271685552,
0.0254795514,
0.0719003379,
-0.0182926431,
0.0061641731,
0.0216164254,
-0.0061105844,
0.0205310751,
0.0051232665,
0.0228541791,
-0.0415799581,
0.0027917635,
-0.0011357422,
-0.0155690629,
0.0174434874,
-0.0122967288,
-0.0154521847,
-0.0245458987,
0.0120195597,
-0.003748917,
-0.014411008,
0.0252707992,
0.0360939987,
0.054988347,
-0.0068357559,
0.0043890462,
-0.0185904633,
0.0033873559,
0.0434689745,
-0.0259587578,
0.0404662937,
0.0266913697,
0.0488654301,
0.0716913939,
-0.0244669598,
0.0303994846,
0.0329481326,
-0.009875169,
0.1007042304,
0.0142210862,
0.0017757881,
0.0371380746,
0.0383181497,
-0.0146931987,
-0.0585443974,
-0.0517407991,
-0.0017439685,
-0.0471816659,
0.040304672,
-0.0200334135,
-0.0158497859,
0.0433622077,
-0.0496830828,
0.0593843907,
0.0235526022,
-0.0145682367,
0.0495686457,
0.0052346862,
-0.0023550177,
-0.0052148956,
0.0879600495,
-0.0582030863,
0.0195901804,
-0.0525124781,
-0.0076416009,
-0.0025507398,
0.0128669031,
-0.0312679149,
0.0073686657,
-0.018704094,
0.0282927286,
0.0196335167,
-0.0212781504,
-0.0199194532,
-0.0305093229,
-0.0492732227,
0.0302839987,
-0.0812359005,
-0.0356005989,
-0.0185330249,
0.0662626028,
-0.0279603116,
-0.082350105,
-0.0184979942,
0.0329337157,
-0.0312774852,
-0.05639036,
-0.0123617835,
0.0696434379,
0.013289636,
-0.0458225235,
-0.0381432548,
-0.0280551184,
-0.0120839626,
-0.0558439977,
-0.0045101652,
-0.0468492322,
-0.0101718446,
0.0214350633,
-0.0158602204,
-0.0779800862,
0.0134475632,
0.0061034379,
-0.0323681496,
0.0770526379,
0.0294105597,
-0.0207470655,
-0.0396664888,
-0.0389029644,
-0.0336402394,
0.0488205701,
0.0644471496,
-0.0123450812,
0.0434131511,
0.0193706192,
-0.0083232252,
0.0421270691,
-0.0335634872,
0.0134304501,
-0.0215529352,
-0.0057801129,
-0.0141153624,
-0.0031748877,
0.0150931953,
0.0542614684,
0.0031639088,
-0.0501195453,
0.0507443026,
0.0199976247,
-0.0262657851,
-0.0298682135,
0.0819290429,
0.0351453871,
-0.014932232,
-0.0123887928,
-0.0526574515,
-0.008622136,
-0.0423038714,
0.0049134553,
-0.0618310049,
0.0048045395,
-0.0094404547,
-0.0493032113,
-0.0465619452,
-0.0272085704,
0.0597502366,
-0.0191529077,
0.0576633289,
0.0239400733,
0.0113676311,
0.0233755931,
0.0489849523,
-0.0600938648,
0.0109291133,
-0.0685162619,
0.0179436076,
0.0417110436,
0.038721621,
-0.0342733823,
-0.0180259049,
0.0020419722,
0.020580953,
0.058815185,
-0.0012457919,
-0.0084683886,
-0.0045871465,
-0.032156758,
-0.0173860937,
-0.0531940684,
0.0343348347,
-0.0147185614,
-0.0342510305,
-0.0262810644,
0.0058138841,
-0.0632538721,
0.0073867957,
0.086538747,
-0.0372285061,
0.00742742,
-0.015931569,
-0.0008553042,
0.0698753595,
-0.0023713673,
0.008356085,
0.0386418179,
0.0346310847,
-0.0284315404,
-0.0016396048,
0.0549266264,
0.0375256017,
-0.0521818623,
0.0172698535,
-0.0021225933,
-0.0101293949,
0.0416495316,
-0.0106709665,
-0.0463588573,
0.0129153067,
-0.0641705841,
0.0457607359,
-0.0744424611,
0.0158884767,
0.0062203351,
0.0086821923,
-0.0663143471,
0.0702639744,
-0.00903189,
0.019624522,
-0.0155004328,
0.0284615681,
0.0192567967,
-0.0011139038,
-0.0416541509,
-0.0200896971,
0.0118847061,
-0.0172121879,
0.0174210295,
0.0087521784,
-0.0547906905,
-0.0471984632,
-0.0572806634,
0.0018194949,
-0.0280001387,
0.020432204,
0.012137996,
-0.0015480489,
0.0077163945,
0.0251002423,
0.0220789369,
0.0335822403,
0.0047064056,
0.0321093313,
0.0659665912,
-0.0099669984,
-0.0598782673,
-0.068445541,
0.0000508772,
-0.0480228253,
0.0271031912,
-0.0005983535,
0.000669763,
-0.0138718272,
0.0462033972,
-0.0380093791,
-0.0114208292,
0.0050225202,
-0.0454797223,
0.0140967658,
-0.0273734853,
-0.0118495934,
0.0318828076,
-0.0354145989,
0.0725868642,
0.0532033928,
-0.0108409105,
-0.0503426194,
-0.001829968,
-0.0235676691,
0.0135767674,
-0.0680318475,
-0.0200806353,
-0.0050061233,
0.0811605603,
0.0122002065,
-0.0260825176,
-0.0074190465,
0.0156357195,
-0.0452222638,
-0.0367288925,
0.026631346,
0.0074997684,
-0.0536181293,
0.0380598903,
-0.0201075003,
-0.046996586,
0.066306673,
-0.007742947,
-0.0376122147,
-0.0359819233,
-0.0051310649,
-0.0503551625,
0.0979186594,
0.0288496632,
-0.0332982391,
0.0062369844,
-0.0413785055,
-0.0391157418,
-0.0185614135,
0.0507922061,
0.0164622143,
0.0591633655,
-0.0816447884,
0.035844896,
0.0195172131,
-0.0162762795,
-0.0125654135,
-0.0744217709,
-0.0405255258,
0.0149286557,
-0.0043855654,
0.0328069776,
-0.005050661,
-0.0229653642,
-0.0195729285,
0.0043610106,
0.0180308316,
-0.0177360326,
-0.0675187632,
-0.0096117109,
0.004348272,
-0.0031588727,
-0.0008001082,
-0.0040545696,
0.020745445,
0.0494305827,
0.0033677949,
-0.0057029682,
-0.0312823243,
0.035079401,
0.0359349214,
-0.0126391938,
-0.059003558,
0.0193311553,
0.0204849951,
-0.0322459079,
-0.0084210122,
0.1063306108,
0.0621458255,
-0.0166529641,
0.0461174622,
-0.0300358124,
0.043675594,
0.035858281,
-0.0155951828,
-0.0516499206,
-0.0514733046,
0.0099573946,
-0.0292262267,
-0.024155397,
-0.0398909934,
0.0146801695,
-0.0620774627,
0.0484459139,
-0.0197364818,
0.0039943741,
0.0632308573,
-0.0446573384,
0.0454937704,
-0.0534171015,
-0.0014001699,
-0.0189095177,
-0.0027929035,
0.0127288019,
-0.0024292979,
-0.0045014345,
-0.0467992909,
0.0253975317,
-0.0317910239,
0.0286529325,
0.0682726055,
0.0241814665,
-0.0407573245,
-0.0473308042,
0.0523920543,
-0.02498045,
0.0042451699,
-0.0335979648,
0.0275515839,
0.0054644938,
0.001100832,
-0.0227470454,
0.0516614877,
-0.0435422771,
-0.0413429141,
-0.0115232477,
0.0846478716,
-0.0323023461,
0.0232294351,
-0.0047724103,
-0.0003575191,
-0.0191071015,
0.0740358084,
0.0313200727,
-0.0180103891,
-0.0189576391,
-0.0319983102,
-0.0322128572,
0.0252373945,
-0.053517241,
0.0112058138,
0.0018921746,
-0.0473412611,
-0.048622027,
-0.082171388,
0.0347579196,
0.0112401685,
0.0130366636,
0.0249034949,
0.0128336735,
-0.0087117283,
0.0040726252,
0.0378776938,
-0.0311006922,
0.0525216497,
-0.0047697676,
-0.0294694398,
0.042995844,
0.0065330728,
-0.0357289426,
0.0016542672,
-0.0520937406,
-0.0789022669,
0.036935132,
0.0439559668,
0.0288816728,
0.0262109097,
-0.0387302525,
-0.0220425073,
-0.0211509224,
-0.021406563,
-0.0424268022,
0.0427477583,
0.041732274,
-0.0236732215,
0.0199884009,
0.0517145433,
-0.0075306632,
0.0124765458,
0.0117646754,
0.0641115978,
-0.0580013134,
-0.0344521105,
0.0371939391,
-0.0057653286,
0.0613879189,
-0.005285331,
0.0089190137,
-0.0396097228,
-0.0264828652,
-0.0485995822,
-0.0170603413,
-0.0446458049,
-0.0169838611,
0.0409642346,
0.0258076154,
-0.0445120186,
-0.0200754963,
-0.069526732,
0.0430002324,
0.0434874184,
0.0142857144,
0.0336338989,
-0.004108551,
-0.0316701569,
0.0326287895,
0.003245688,
0.0248925369,
-0.0356953479,
0.0060347635,
-0.0168244652,
0.0290532373,
0.0186087172,
-0.009871576,
0.0036350933,
0.0067216274,
-0.0482465364,
0.0287547056,
0.0201957058,
0.0098422114,
0.0438578129,
-0.0247318521,
0.0751078203,
-0.0548552684,
0.0030148069,
-0.0077169212,
0.0373060927,
0.0238147117,
-0.039101325,
0.0577613339,
0.023263799,
-0.0493582487,
-0.0160965808,
0.0692130774,
-0.0127755934,
0.0487189665,
0.017179789,
-0.033311516,
-0.0394296311,
-0.0420125201,
0.0135227786,
0.0082384814,
0.0154265948,
0.0201084092,
-0.0860798582,
-0.0430129133,
-0.0096397102,
-0.0057214629,
0.0113425553,
-0.0663774088,
0.0384109989,
0.077062048,
0.0185830705,
-0.0250665545,
-0.0707925707,
-0.0261482336,
-0.0081843417,
-0.0073171011,
-0.0306101311,
-5.526538569e-33,
-0.0526481345,
-0.0074823084,
0.0109580103,
0.0610370003,
-0.0177793298,
-0.0339996442,
-0.0339538418,
0.0110281082,
0.0025737907,
0.0497207008,
0.0195975434,
0.0158143975,
0.0220133867,
0.0262571592,
0.0546971858,
-0.0267412476,
0.0022012636,
-0.0193754043,
-0.0037118495,
-0.0343830325,
0.0177299734,
-0.0020918222,
0.0285007507,
-0.021601228,
0.0576643497,
0.0171420481,
0.0122032696,
0.0450473987,
-0.0459046178,
0.0433575138,
-0.0109888241,
0.0484367386,
0.0226549767,
-0.0221131761,
-0.0167440977,
-0.0118277669,
-0.0170922391,
-0.0581124127,
0.070916459,
0.0074094255,
-0.0361580737,
-0.0436243825,
0.0164583027,
-0.0346092395,
-0.0536488332,
0.036822021,
0.0431112498,
0.0012712785,
-0.0154063748,
0.0528991707,
-0.0680174157,
0.0296411011,
-0.01834842,
-0.0164805148,
0.0317135975,
-0.0024879638,
0.0090614036,
-0.0275292862,
-0.0400158353,
0.0303223338,
-0.0294653364,
0.0176647343,
0.0283209458,
0.0185967088,
0.0051381122,
0.0702839121,
0.0117788929,
0.0107842619,
0.0048482446,
0.0573749989,
0.0280387495,
0.0805383474,
0.0067171678,
0.0487166159,
-0.0555956699,
0.0350675136,
-0.0348678157,
0.0025312228,
0.065417029,
0.0419390798,
0.0013545715,
0.0082818139,
-0.041791223,
-0.0462844893,
-0.044494696,
0.0026315241,
-0.0150730172,
-0.0504733734,
0.0338985138,
-0.0318437703,
0.0209824741,
-0.016208522,
0.0056646597,
-0.0099985898,
-0.0237075873,
-0.0108855395,
-0.0365780592,
0.0324654877,
0.0112599377,
0.025246283,
-0.0328725986,
-0.0342140794,
0.0137764774,
-0.0055645257,
0.0148128364,
0.0182006173,
0.0080917673,
0.0111667616,
-0.0079325493,
-0.0155783072,
-0.0451141261,
-0.0234691482,
-0.0383356288,
-0.0331543796,
0.0343733095,
0.0217567086,
-0.0080471728,
0.0501950011,
0.0111024035,
-0.0020283395,
-0.0184712131,
-0.0461419336,
-0.0101537555,
0.0099419411,
-0.0274211932,
-0.0219444707,
-0.0260275602,
0.0197730102,
0.0375069939,
-0.0027143676,
0.0083007393,
-0.0090187853,
2.677e-7,
0.0944763571,
0.0456228554,
-0.0359699987,
0.0436786972,
0.0106939068,
0.0410436429,
-0.0478996262,
0.0285845399,
0.0109351594,
-0.0227740034,
0.0084802834,
0.00639237,
0.0376746543,
0.0153975487,
-0.0609020852,
-0.0011169413,
0.0082343789,
-0.0068085617,
-0.02594533,
0.0148938289,
0.0406785533,
0.0861823335,
0.0476495214,
-0.0030694166,
-0.0515436046,
-0.07087069,
0.0456473529,
-0.0707703605,
-0.0424943082,
0.030658761,
0.0073258216,
-0.0044579329,
0.025521405,
0.0298591591,
0.0000778311,
0.0338374041,
-0.0281204097,
0.0628896654,
-0.0104820626,
-0.0036712941,
0.0042060898,
-0.0382318646,
0.0334402435,
-0.0143715376,
0.0650475025,
-0.022333296,
-0.0650064796,
0.0335678943,
-0.0018321811,
0.0146292802,
0.0068084407,
0.0116247479,
-0.0283712018,
-0.0008513727,
0.0374887586,
-0.0396359488,
-0.0153465066,
-0.0453414209,
-0.0330560803,
-0.007636548,
-0.0386717096,
-0.0577443317,
0.0162870996,
0.0345528647,
0.0070485906,
-0.0762229338,
-0.0377326161,
2.532898289e-34,
0.0488371998,
0.012785092,
0.0521713905,
0.0414141342,
0.0474054292,
0.0245810933,
0.0162726752,
0.0536397099,
0.0165452994,
-0.0844144523,
0.0084216259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18176v1 | Perceived Trustworthiness of Natural Language Generators | 2023-05-29T16:09:58 | 2023-05-29T16:09:58 | Beatriz Cabrero-Daniel, Andrea Sanagustín Cabrero | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Natural Language Generation tools, such as chatbots that can generate
human-like conversational text, are becoming more common both for personal and
professional use. However, there are concerns about their trustworthiness and
ethical implications. The paper addresses the problem of understanding how
different users (e.g., linguists, engineers) perceive and adopt these tools and
their perception of machine-generated text quality. It also discusses the
perceived advantages and limitations of Natural Language Generation tools, as
well as users' beliefs on governance strategies. The main findings of this
study include the impact of users' field and level of expertise on the
perceived trust and adoption of Natural Language Generation tools, the users'
assessment of the accuracy, fluency, and potential biases of machine-generated
text in comparison to human-written text, and an analysis of the advantages and
ethical risks associated with these tools as identified by the participants.
Moreover, this paper discusses the potential implications of these findings for
enhancing the AI development process. The paper sheds light on how different
user characteristics shape their beliefs on the quality and overall
trustworthiness of machine-generated text. Furthermore, it examines the
benefits and risks of these tools from the perspectives of different users. | [
0.0903476775,
0.0325342529,
-0.0299631823,
0.0025519626,
-0.0483840294,
-0.0285377689,
0.0197155476,
-0.0164112523,
0.0751944259,
-0.0268547218,
-0.0164714754,
-0.0064802971,
0.0246521644,
0.0670394301,
0.0149643552,
-0.0362757333,
-0.0204765443,
0.0293650255,
0.0452292562,
0.0200206172,
0.0354659371,
0.0703642219,
-0.00402644,
0.083240062,
-0.0368759073,
-0.0185991675,
0.0177982487,
-0.017371865,
0.0235748421,
0.0016644854,
0.013329139,
0.0345165618,
-0.0169903077,
0.032894332,
0.000001859,
-0.0447424762,
-0.0022122606,
0.0261717867,
-0.0228643473,
-0.0296955742,
0.077307187,
0.0436562113,
-0.0378278084,
0.0269351788,
-0.0585343279,
0.0706467628,
0.0526599512,
-0.0181411169,
0.0572505631,
0.049763415,
-0.0292577147,
0.036507234,
0.0102754813,
0.0259597171,
-0.0255863797,
-0.0068987454,
-0.0314939506,
0.0103082024,
0.002605835,
0.0126433894,
0.0280495454,
0.0222690795,
-0.0076572085,
-0.0670001954,
0.0278885253,
0.0185952485,
-0.0119222701,
-0.0752919763,
-0.0230262969,
0.0306640267,
0.0427068248,
0.0065243328,
-0.0178817715,
-0.007826129,
0.036547631,
0.0329589657,
0.0155512942,
0.0704983696,
-0.0392880924,
-0.0086351195,
-0.0033896719,
-0.0111598643,
-0.031478215,
0.0248452239,
0.0396875702,
-0.0167219415,
0.001680228,
-0.007556668,
0.00607801,
0.0121615278,
0.0451525636,
-0.0754164606,
0.022509018,
0.0227311328,
-0.0273862667,
0.0551326014,
-0.0374647677,
-0.0005843929,
0.0233329348,
-0.0469475873,
-0.0404568911,
0.0179738104,
0.0124264164,
-0.0123323454,
0.012026256,
0.0315665342,
0.011506319,
0.0273308847,
0.0013217207,
0.005657726,
-0.0267231688,
-0.0384923294,
-0.0310625192,
0.0050596218,
-0.0101256706,
0.0017759983,
-0.0385972969,
0.0189491268,
-0.0118126096,
0.048363518,
0.0089172646,
0.0423686877,
-0.0351994671,
-0.0131567325,
-0.0544451736,
-0.020436978,
-0.0191826392,
0.0485250689,
0.0119421389,
-0.0790938661,
0.0356999636,
0.0237496607,
-0.0083467895,
0.0166827925,
-0.0133179724,
0.0589687377,
-0.0213301387,
-0.0233715829,
-0.0305514112,
-0.05583065,
-0.0358935818,
-0.0416351557,
-0.0326088816,
-0.0220143721,
-0.0210931841,
0.020137893,
-0.0338713713,
-0.0346633047,
0.0214485619,
0.0526611693,
-0.0354942828,
0.0045669572,
-0.0839753672,
0.0134877078,
0.0146572953,
0.0055564558,
-0.0197835602,
-0.0104780607,
0.0614021942,
0.0719267204,
0.0293443482,
0.0158580579,
0.0201025978,
-0.0083566401,
-0.0371834338,
-0.0105775492,
0.0110093225,
0.001709298,
-0.0721435547,
0.0053164363,
0.0096920952,
0.0920802578,
-0.0282851309,
0.030068947,
0.0676851422,
0.0540722981,
0.0111915451,
0.0464523025,
0.041517783,
0.0314936973,
0.0231265165,
0.0076732351,
0.0042099506,
0.0245485231,
-0.0030610836,
-0.0153606711,
-0.0073393541,
0.0503923595,
0.0116207628,
-0.0662900582,
-0.0024081471,
-0.0411499888,
0.0493079461,
-0.0128722694,
-0.0012957765,
0.0192646366,
-0.036469426,
-0.0477563068,
-0.0202911105,
-0.0775068328,
-0.0114812301,
-0.0381208174,
0.018114673,
0.1201778501,
0.0205828995,
0.0484641269,
0.0088313548,
-0.0357328728,
-0.0498276465,
0.0816642642,
0.0077112373,
-0.0096501354,
-0.0332131684,
-0.0318360701,
-0.0218450241,
-0.0204586983,
-0.0304525476,
0.0160733964,
0.0042600245,
0.0589979216,
0.035933394,
0.0115963267,
-0.0533869117,
0.0272381399,
-0.0225255787,
0.0038948837,
-0.036511723,
0.0160989966,
0.0242467374,
0.0571093559,
-0.0277561732,
0.0398191251,
-0.0045871921,
0.0214874223,
-0.0364986323,
0.0585409403,
-0.0101218577,
0.051898431,
0.0093676802,
-0.0950640216,
-0.0069316421,
-0.0057812799,
-0.002150665,
0.0006957459,
0.0063028815,
-0.0703417659,
0.0070529864,
-0.0524512231,
0.0027711827,
-0.0353887267,
0.0005613491,
-0.0324058346,
0.0217989516,
-0.0015069759,
-0.0188197233,
0.0074066757,
0.0218634121,
0.0356720462,
0.0027715168,
-0.0077357781,
0.0380615108,
0.0043282807,
0.0437855311,
0.0774391517,
0.0207388457,
-0.0398657173,
-0.0231392253,
-0.0724297464,
-0.0424028262,
0.0039430121,
0.0066888365,
0.0137415566,
-0.0478898995,
-0.0089289863,
0.0111407787,
-0.0734971911,
-0.0114658633,
0.0007322099,
0.0088652102,
0.0534089655,
-0.0185625236,
-0.0155957974,
-0.0188589655,
0.0253202058,
0.004298877,
0.0141842933,
0.1210912541,
-0.029200295,
-0.0721404999,
0.0482426621,
-0.0553887524,
-0.0340417624,
0.0370885134,
-0.0618483275,
0.0372534767,
0.03440696,
-0.0055445968,
0.0139193702,
0.0523249842,
0.0375443883,
0.0229313653,
0.0324348137,
-0.0151011609,
-0.039654918,
0.0314563178,
-0.0124688447,
0.0313281789,
-0.0604305156,
0.0472707748,
-0.0056507313,
0.0390533842,
0.0119094728,
-0.0148091689,
0.0749360025,
-0.0174168926,
-0.0281614438,
0.0653273091,
-0.0681196675,
-0.0367673784,
0.0568583123,
0.0145973796,
-0.0696489364,
0.0707341209,
-0.0252433307,
0.0118274316,
-0.0380305499,
-0.035451103,
-0.0109047992,
0.0251265969,
-0.0284537189,
0.0644108281,
0.0524755009,
-0.0236004125,
-0.0368307941,
-0.0238068551,
0.0532472692,
-0.0315045081,
-0.0458307266,
-0.0168841407,
0.0094902609,
0.0080530401,
-0.00964031,
-0.0477587283,
-0.0268704388,
-0.0283103343,
-0.0068346197,
0.1086767986,
-0.0363728814,
-0.0000835047,
-0.0132469637,
0.0458693318,
-0.0080268532,
0.0156814922,
-0.0166224372,
-0.0056507559,
0.0112903798,
0.0057967976,
0.0006379004,
0.0284633432,
0.0218708403,
0.0002811765,
0.039911218,
-0.0350863412,
0.0116161294,
-0.0449080542,
-0.0568564683,
0.0018268758,
-0.0075380392,
-0.0305416677,
0.0270831175,
0.0252888445,
-0.0263062622,
0.0357759595,
0.039080441,
0.0207418986,
0.0070797084,
0.0082404409,
-0.0201150905,
-0.0180544909,
-0.0005835299,
0.0116093764,
-0.0899117962,
0.0162196495,
-0.0191042479,
0.0200863052,
-0.0620500669,
-0.0377984941,
-0.0224913284,
-0.0764538348,
0.0498250946,
-0.0068154437,
-0.0399356149,
-0.0120490249,
-0.024451267,
-0.0512116738,
0.0355388559,
0.0375569798,
-0.0022208765,
-0.0056734229,
0.0049310522,
0.0419008732,
-0.0710954368,
-0.0412761346,
0.0151958829,
-0.0316007957,
0.0824885815,
0.0703528821,
0.0521935187,
-0.0118825203,
-0.0462507531,
-0.0453685299,
0.0547158606,
0.0258943662,
0.0096191596,
0.0531665497,
-0.0284334719,
0.0057402784,
-0.0633343607,
-0.0104125459,
0.0193662178,
-0.0114809033,
-0.0021009876,
0.0217577014,
-0.021387469,
-0.028307531,
-0.0344324894,
0.0141570223,
0.0455096625,
0.0484296121,
-0.0048823939,
-0.0165381152,
-0.0288715791,
-0.0112394644,
0.022084007,
0.0040010149,
-0.0178956781,
0.0385900401,
-0.042588938,
-0.0342087932,
-0.1225879639,
-0.0612264834,
0.0107408501,
0.0098093776,
0.0330616497,
-0.028017953,
0.0665631443,
0.0134342778,
-0.0045481487,
-0.004476842,
-0.0212091319,
0.0202964582,
-0.0120103834,
-0.0157741141,
0.0112453727,
-0.0324816853,
0.0474729761,
0.0284024701,
0.0502685085,
-0.0371026546,
-0.014176867,
0.0437826402,
0.0222389363,
-0.001110156,
0.0101018455,
-0.0155131398,
0.0002149472,
0.0246481225,
-0.0635807291,
-0.0106750792,
0.0238160007,
0.0576155782,
-0.008794602,
-0.0046458598,
-0.0272544753,
-0.0256398544,
-0.0222737677,
-0.0124041038,
-0.000462654,
-0.0577141419,
0.052734144,
0.0634965748,
-0.0420025885,
-0.0660362095,
0.0933808535,
-0.0392395258,
-0.0419381745,
-0.0512113012,
-0.0165514946,
-0.0380989946,
0.021791812,
0.0017700045,
0.0037879916,
0.0414871834,
-0.0007835256,
-0.1110680625,
0.0218689684,
0.0289011989,
0.0140712401,
-0.0184929091,
0.056999784,
-0.0011460313,
-0.0066668829,
-0.0318945087,
0.0072619314,
-0.0455093496,
0.0360564142,
0.0493484214,
0.0296515487,
-0.0071399775,
-0.0426293239,
0.0155977495,
0.0169896614,
-0.031354554,
-0.079816632,
-0.0305410903,
0.0108122751,
0.0084144119,
0.0279486571,
0.0349058546,
-0.0411853567,
0.0339674465,
0.01474116,
0.010820183,
0.0018862751,
-0.0375140458,
-0.0125515927,
-0.0234570615,
-0.0700745061,
-0.0232328735,
0.049492985,
0.0037433191,
-0.0104138618,
-0.0679861531,
-0.0546287224,
-0.0315318257,
-0.0545414127,
0.0120851267,
-0.0163455047,
0.0053186612,
-0.0410802737,
-0.0714891329,
-0.0425488502,
-0.0262411535,
0.0048180576,
0.0180491563,
-0.0240727626,
0.0443714112,
0.0583622456,
0.0092013329,
0.0148281762,
-0.0444121547,
-0.0014833395,
-0.0214744266,
0.016751999,
-0.027545251,
-5.247935755e-33,
-0.0001041233,
-0.0884294957,
0.0153086837,
0.0039587165,
0.0207796972,
-0.0177021623,
-0.0280468855,
0.0210985467,
-0.0154347708,
0.0095910309,
-0.0136816259,
-0.0260744728,
0.0135617033,
-0.0286203027,
0.0083407629,
0.0106348787,
0.0501784123,
-0.0088631269,
-0.0165943112,
0.0150289154,
0.0242560077,
-0.016784668,
0.0526188165,
-0.0923160315,
0.087402381,
-0.0193938222,
-0.055652488,
-0.0205926225,
0.0192608405,
0.0013700039,
0.0245258976,
0.028033901,
0.0139716147,
-0.0171602946,
-0.021859698,
0.049104467,
0.0305506624,
-0.0212763529,
0.023515692,
0.0095333727,
-0.0213957876,
-0.0426428467,
0.0445121899,
-0.0601226725,
-0.0358534455,
0.0555017143,
0.0493652932,
-0.0270613749,
0.0107131107,
-0.0215594787,
-0.0615549795,
0.0090663731,
-0.031678047,
-0.0115425391,
-0.0415962227,
0.0782635286,
-0.0211355295,
-0.042750217,
-0.0274275336,
0.0487884209,
0.0149534009,
-0.0577082857,
0.0706530958,
-0.0369236581,
-0.0002661484,
0.0614706688,
0.0391900353,
0.0322308242,
-0.0428621769,
-0.0139719658,
-0.0131468456,
0.0411601439,
0.0297373813,
0.0893085226,
-0.0200165231,
-0.0566551387,
-0.0247593001,
0.0416172259,
0.0169949476,
0.0294096619,
0.002100179,
-0.0244829971,
-0.0648112297,
-0.0129995234,
-0.0059033665,
-0.0115004713,
-0.0151890684,
-0.0600403622,
-0.0030895371,
-0.0045786472,
-0.0052642548,
-0.0297742356,
-0.0138425352,
-0.034389697,
0.0403966531,
0.0014562861,
-0.0442871191,
-0.026490042,
-0.0116373021,
0.0155920479,
-0.0359375589,
0.0165988579,
0.0305047985,
0.0064990362,
0.041324582,
0.0262947995,
-0.0152824391,
0.0099151749,
-0.0212624203,
0.0255539231,
-0.0093546063,
0.0328804888,
0.0162397008,
-0.0280849691,
0.0137732141,
-0.0154607808,
-0.042293407,
0.0011735141,
0.0093464591,
0.0184294898,
-0.0363707617,
0.0073512732,
0.0020849009,
-0.0046488652,
-0.0536656454,
-0.0023022864,
-0.0209203474,
0.034490943,
0.0526867099,
-0.0127761774,
-0.0143476613,
-0.0532612875,
2.722e-7,
-0.0026021639,
0.0485074222,
0.0076293917,
0.0012904052,
-0.0075896438,
0.0433991216,
0.0390153378,
0.0313844755,
-0.0195629951,
-0.0054014204,
0.0093582105,
-0.0217925534,
0.0170039907,
0.0649388283,
-0.0492600016,
-0.0039692661,
-0.0612208284,
-0.0072413068,
-0.0515694506,
0.0309183206,
0.0979654118,
-0.0137447948,
-0.0075777797,
-0.0490929708,
-0.0274268929,
-0.0377645418,
0.0131869754,
-0.0031735324,
0.0012062826,
0.0132550029,
0.0534920283,
0.0454625115,
0.0099128811,
0.0403765589,
0.0016904488,
-0.0124505796,
0.0050731963,
0.0492274389,
0.0017099628,
0.0082233576,
0.0470126867,
-0.0533756167,
0.0075400295,
-0.0415975824,
0.0086394846,
-0.0346270353,
-0.0320240781,
-0.0315020159,
-0.0233969912,
-0.0350080244,
0.0288851373,
-0.0571716987,
-0.0016156558,
0.0229085013,
-0.0193964243,
0.0043226881,
0.0026340778,
0.0080839302,
0.0145560596,
-0.0192593541,
0.0076672318,
-0.0623466894,
0.0008143731,
0.0207237583,
0.0223870408,
-0.0078323772,
0.0482268855,
1.841032161e-34,
-0.0217242464,
-0.016975943,
0.0160285104,
0.02247563,
0.0655806661,
0.0602163561,
0.0079184407,
0.0201198496,
0.0280187298,
0.0358634889,
-0.0244875774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18170v2 | Leveraging Training Data in Few-Shot Prompting for Numerical Reasoning | 2023-05-29T16:01:40 | 2023-06-09T05:00:30 | Zhanming Jie, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting with large language models has proven
effective in numerous natural language processing tasks, but designing prompts
that generalize well to diverse problem types can be challenging, especially in
the context of math word problem (MWP) solving. Additionally, it is common to
have a large amount of training data that have a better diversity coverage but
CoT annotations are not available, which limits the use of supervised learning
techniques. To address these issues, we investigate two approaches to leverage
the training data in a few-shot prompting scenario: dynamic program prompting
and program distillation. Our approach is largely inspired by Gao et al.,
(2022), where they proposed to replace the CoT with the programs as the
intermediate reasoning step. Such a prompting strategy allows us to accurately
verify the answer correctness through program execution in MWP solving. Our
dynamic program prompting involves annotating the training data by sampling
correct programs from a large language model, while program distillation
involves adapting a smaller model to the program-annotated training data. Our
experiments on three standard MWP datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of
these approaches, yielding significant improvements over previous baselines for
prompting and fine-tuning. Our results suggest that leveraging a large amount
of training data can improve the generalization ability of prompts and boost
the performance of fine-tuned small models in MWP solving. | [
-0.0056789187,
0.0692429394,
0.0133865122,
0.0104333488,
-0.0411533304,
0.0407288335,
0.0252673104,
0.0092685018,
-0.0300104711,
-0.0282037389,
0.0144518679,
0.0012134266,
0.0069647152,
0.0009432331,
0.0410890616,
-0.0300327372,
0.0336912088,
-0.0598067231,
0.0353959836,
-0.0101337954,
-0.01357482,
0.0175435506,
-0.0489743054,
0.0251710638,
-0.0463928357,
-0.074252069,
-0.0129460655,
-0.0400592126,
0.0092723621,
-0.0379635282,
-0.023305919,
0.0789964199,
0.0420031995,
0.0432412736,
0.0000023988,
-0.0516608767,
-0.0142284399,
0.0223148093,
-0.0900145844,
-0.0256098844,
0.0028802985,
0.0075096395,
0.0465584807,
0.0294110589,
-0.0481163301,
0.011146998,
0.0353743769,
0.0006518547,
0.0765166655,
0.0475760996,
0.0026612526,
-0.0123069119,
0.0000118191,
0.0055646566,
0.0376602672,
-0.0526796244,
0.0061162799,
0.0472141877,
0.0308889784,
0.0054353112,
-0.0449118465,
0.0179514214,
0.0405484214,
0.018040143,
0.0003066291,
0.0140360976,
-0.0501818806,
-0.0138972634,
-0.0437978506,
0.0867489427,
-0.0083709322,
-0.0070960978,
-0.0161448102,
-0.0314390436,
-0.0001055755,
0.0046716612,
-0.0438543335,
0.0314356014,
-0.0170806665,
-0.0016726995,
-0.0128829926,
0.0129950559,
0.0062253354,
0.0047416468,
-0.0509931967,
0.0710172206,
-0.002069619,
-0.0533224866,
0.0213408265,
0.0034026965,
-0.0395672508,
-0.0598546639,
0.0090308841,
0.0404789597,
-0.0400589332,
0.0241719224,
-0.0368139558,
-0.0599640757,
-0.0182965659,
0.0142223639,
0.0497109033,
0.067055054,
-0.0156733822,
0.0354862511,
-0.0326061584,
0.0502280593,
0.0132566802,
0.000462298,
-0.0293305721,
0.0327444933,
-0.0645075589,
-0.0077076079,
-0.0535323806,
0.0616797917,
-0.0174528696,
-0.0060112332,
-0.0308581833,
0.0035373508,
-0.0048896433,
0.0373321474,
0.0043453989,
-0.0120925922,
0.0001412116,
-0.0165388398,
-0.0277827196,
0.0107638314,
-0.0873397961,
0.0182587113,
0.0343613736,
-0.0486321151,
-0.0531438068,
-0.0191046093,
0.0126754809,
-0.0338880494,
0.0505880266,
0.0557796843,
-0.0089622932,
-0.0244829785,
-0.001849866,
-0.0320262164,
-0.0064230273,
-0.0797918439,
-0.0093813669,
-0.1023800969,
0.0602331869,
0.0229135696,
-0.0246721525,
0.0251632389,
0.0095469104,
0.0390732363,
0.0002850746,
0.0867022797,
-0.0080811968,
-0.0086429939,
0.0115876282,
-0.0200149603,
-0.0444622599,
0.0578940809,
0.0399388559,
-0.0146658709,
0.0273344796,
0.0022196085,
0.0251959842,
0.0414680578,
0.0227052458,
0.0072585908,
-0.0082606822,
-0.0004492716,
0.0265250914,
0.0297587365,
-0.0170923937,
0.0195255578,
-0.0577360615,
0.0401028544,
-0.000060791,
0.0792752653,
-0.0064605293,
-0.0222559366,
0.0506425016,
0.0072947657,
0.014118623,
0.0019632506,
-0.0825334266,
0.0352612659,
-0.0450682119,
-0.0020485881,
0.0319962613,
0.0197924301,
-0.0117825428,
-0.0603357777,
-0.0201318003,
0.0485557914,
-0.0091462908,
0.0345244221,
0.0516142398,
0.0179964341,
0.0042593516,
0.0325881131,
0.0247342568,
-0.0107249981,
-0.0356607623,
-0.0474493057,
0.0403538719,
0.0424567424,
0.0470055342,
-0.0223769806,
-0.0128902569,
-0.0232203547,
0.043191988,
-0.0213214085,
0.0233985577,
-0.0133555094,
0.0171350017,
-0.0360131525,
-0.0115713421,
-0.0222074185,
0.006210818,
-0.0085360436,
0.0444733426,
-0.003446599,
0.001975575,
-0.0190701839,
0.0028762086,
0.0448470376,
-0.018114496,
-0.0688382462,
0.0066691302,
0.0194954667,
0.0026682704,
0.0037266253,
0.0100546135,
0.033298336,
-0.0227012597,
-0.0092120431,
-0.0009859295,
-0.0376183055,
-0.0529763997,
-0.073191762,
0.0516261943,
-0.0414614603,
-0.0338281132,
-0.0394583456,
-0.0608564168,
-0.0340860151,
0.0109424666,
-0.0322715193,
-0.0209684726,
-0.0001149322,
0.0293754432,
0.0329979099,
-0.0209081713,
-0.0336767025,
0.0875535458,
0.0124260932,
0.041646488,
0.0148999896,
-0.0126010235,
0.0246225744,
-0.0119781792,
0.0007934381,
-0.0215971265,
-0.0036422079,
-0.0076145455,
0.0038374865,
0.0411061645,
-0.0701772794,
0.0076894779,
-0.05526549,
0.0172950458,
-0.0100579113,
0.0293420516,
0.0015535158,
-0.0088155121,
-0.0140911685,
-0.0416458286,
-0.0401690938,
-0.0140776979,
-0.0095157856,
0.0154664908,
0.0415899381,
0.0154746957,
0.0077200267,
-0.0234890133,
-0.0284566153,
-0.0419042334,
0.0530385338,
0.0084366947,
-0.0219019577,
-0.0491596572,
0.0196348485,
-0.0302432589,
0.0240708273,
0.003549926,
0.0427646078,
0.0441138744,
-0.0151546048,
0.0435056463,
0.047185149,
-0.0437544659,
-0.0180577394,
0.0474040918,
-0.010997463,
-0.0882374272,
0.0254104678,
-0.0134018343,
-0.0139736971,
0.0489445552,
-0.0382319726,
-0.0177456308,
0.058176022,
-0.0021327569,
-0.009129025,
-0.0405338556,
0.0478621684,
0.0136646926,
-0.0278360639,
-0.0816967413,
0.0131946569,
0.0059761093,
0.0381816216,
-0.0186752025,
-0.0455268919,
0.1198782027,
-0.0023272778,
-0.0158462804,
-0.0578679703,
0.0087591987,
-0.0301771555,
0.0298995208,
-0.0156897046,
-0.0289525334,
-0.016934434,
0.0002246703,
-0.0590656996,
-0.0061230063,
0.0317025036,
-0.0144794574,
0.0596531406,
-0.058020521,
0.0092748581,
-0.0131005673,
-0.0519175865,
-0.0426696688,
-0.0323799737,
-0.0290166959,
0.009842094,
-0.000423184,
-0.0028770976,
0.0073898993,
-0.0197726209,
0.0418548211,
0.0631127805,
-0.0148959532,
-0.0421321318,
-0.0307588112,
-0.0042259851,
0.0261890329,
0.0140372748,
0.0378720872,
-0.0354442112,
0.0448331162,
-0.0072295121,
0.0946405828,
-0.0011159978,
-0.0149003519,
0.0277082156,
0.0157797374,
-0.032098528,
0.0034237362,
0.0563331097,
0.0474247783,
-0.0687064081,
-0.0304398313,
0.0840424597,
0.0654468685,
-0.0367794074,
-0.0017392833,
-0.0358548723,
0.0034989605,
0.0474563465,
0.0525164045,
-0.1025711149,
-0.0540770106,
0.0103882253,
-0.0027956532,
0.0015342928,
-0.0559483208,
-0.0158049334,
-0.1408950984,
0.032280013,
0.00669921,
0.0116061093,
0.0087175155,
-0.0409546681,
0.0024561235,
0.0070266658,
-0.0151120294,
-0.0172620378,
-0.0146640027,
0.0250670426,
0.0204158705,
0.0184337981,
-0.0217409879,
0.0422312692,
-0.0237001535,
0.0018142483,
0.0322409645,
-0.0136000784,
-0.0163439885,
-0.0594092943,
0.0382582694,
0.0272711236,
0.0006682083,
-0.0078069428,
0.0316766463,
0.001997445,
-0.0004084221,
-0.0020366989,
0.0642031878,
-0.016668696,
-0.0557309762,
0.0494766012,
0.1011300907,
-0.0316644125,
0.0178005621,
-0.0136595899,
0.0061516818,
0.0109943729,
0.0525659211,
0.0305089336,
-0.0267060697,
-0.0214196034,
-0.0245310236,
-0.0270685442,
-0.0342517309,
0.0098202508,
0.0089248074,
0.0221534576,
0.0244087223,
-0.047181882,
-0.0028826678,
0.0846543238,
0.0773838535,
-0.0051522614,
-0.0111800442,
0.0019971493,
0.0226581469,
-0.0155775407,
0.059434928,
-0.0458861925,
0.0329313204,
-0.0228051189,
0.0217123646,
-0.0380564891,
-0.0169353634,
-0.0444605127,
0.0305823814,
-0.131418556,
-0.0416595712,
-0.0410837606,
0.0538320169,
0.0187113732,
0.030038625,
-0.0229263641,
-0.0200094562,
0.0150323976,
0.0476536937,
-0.043369431,
-0.0088473363,
-0.0032278902,
0.0204146914,
0.0052774134,
-0.0001866734,
-0.0312776603,
0.0068594492,
0.0265168473,
0.0589897744,
-0.0137932356,
0.0307605658,
0.0464317054,
0.0553658828,
0.0261299182,
-0.0141086113,
0.0102439662,
-0.0344350487,
0.0337259024,
0.0023088525,
-0.0426002666,
-0.0393340811,
0.0184014067,
-0.0155482218,
-0.0538868271,
0.0158706587,
-0.0613227896,
-0.0047680582,
0.0235374402,
-0.0274034739,
0.0134414183,
0.0370553769,
0.0170829687,
0.0534245484,
-0.0330363736,
0.0077286502,
0.0424096845,
0.0040203258,
0.0358790383,
-0.0068272445,
0.0977459401,
0.0285685509,
0.0235376488,
-0.0707576573,
0.0047881803,
-0.0312234741,
-0.0904349685,
-0.0097333565,
0.055811394,
0.0173895322,
0.0095121488,
-0.0657612756,
-0.0225933027,
-0.0104932832,
0.0237647481,
-0.0002623275,
0.0261281542,
-0.0239394214,
0.0313330255,
0.0517904721,
0.0103261583,
-0.0478333309,
0.0469909124,
-0.0616068803,
0.0109993313,
0.0141869215,
0.0193962865,
-0.0389562994,
-0.0254504737,
-0.0157572515,
0.017848501,
0.0105663221,
0.0255091339,
-0.0816448778,
-0.0658704862,
-0.0419066772,
0.0029222486,
-0.0048678834,
0.0255191028,
0.0548744686,
0.0729938075,
-0.0268769413,
-0.0159478206,
-0.0018864113,
0.0269681141,
0.0329206288,
-0.0624365434,
-0.0307563804,
-6.403424661e-33,
-0.012082749,
-0.0174372289,
0.0493194088,
-0.0192198381,
0.0306750406,
-0.0050156587,
-0.0025188583,
0.0098623242,
-0.0155826798,
0.0107989563,
-0.0406069532,
0.0033353483,
0.018255841,
-0.0054660817,
0.0261644069,
-0.0214794744,
0.0024558036,
-0.0109543251,
-0.0740349069,
-0.0336387902,
0.0115932263,
-0.0017687844,
0.0370883942,
-0.0251931604,
0.0332244895,
0.0144515047,
-0.0159056783,
0.0342420079,
-0.0446858928,
0.0357308239,
-0.0160372891,
0.0301307961,
0.0122874295,
-0.0374458469,
-0.0208589137,
0.0357718617,
-0.0488515608,
-0.0609454922,
0.0433752984,
-0.019417569,
-0.0575668886,
-0.0290428642,
0.0065948581,
-0.0192226488,
-0.0215456169,
-0.0190303084,
0.0129049346,
-0.0157089606,
-0.0172125809,
-0.0055530146,
-0.0267129298,
0.008293814,
-0.0186269805,
-0.0386408269,
0.0216933303,
0.0522685312,
-0.0266070999,
0.0240735803,
-0.0108269835,
0.0150178121,
0.049132973,
0.0030239669,
0.0467208736,
0.0029521477,
-0.0159741063,
0.0388612263,
-0.0016432314,
-0.0260777716,
-0.0121660791,
-0.0156470332,
0.0293400399,
0.036893405,
0.0826060697,
0.0138192503,
0.1080226526,
0.0428163372,
-0.0358524807,
-0.0148694981,
-0.0032344866,
0.0113298101,
0.0091396328,
-0.0290076248,
-0.0536317863,
-0.0219698027,
-0.0774949044,
0.0069151595,
-0.071369715,
0.0034169022,
0.0411084257,
0.0027034678,
-0.0011456887,
-0.0145625751,
0.0343619511,
-0.0185498148,
-0.0103538623,
0.0155492909,
0.0064109643,
0.0194947273,
0.0047407635,
0.0065738186,
-0.0451748334,
0.006882837,
0.0117777223,
0.023737615,
0.0574850217,
0.0009820643,
0.0414422043,
0.0041305758,
-0.0577621087,
-0.0158739779,
-0.0586780682,
0.021167906,
0.0371323228,
0.026081875,
0.040424075,
0.0282791611,
-0.0099093113,
0.0155557999,
-0.0022873499,
-0.0452953652,
0.0227265283,
0.02118502,
-0.0290925819,
0.0134742521,
-0.0116093447,
-0.0044786837,
0.0057778535,
-0.0065073012,
0.0265603568,
-0.0372669697,
-0.0055668321,
0.0434446782,
3.061e-7,
0.0306123979,
0.053716328,
0.0219756905,
0.024293134,
-0.0159597583,
0.0201564878,
-0.0207247976,
-0.0122909537,
0.0128898686,
-0.0742533058,
0.0014017239,
0.0527474433,
0.0351875238,
0.0539531447,
-0.0658957735,
-0.0139823947,
-0.0357934348,
0.0021497605,
-0.0848346651,
-0.0052085537,
0.069957979,
0.0794309601,
0.0338993073,
-0.0065559326,
-0.0030634317,
-0.0306803212,
-0.002537393,
0.0016068721,
-0.0001936175,
0.0032082107,
-0.0283745192,
-0.031529285,
0.0329910815,
0.0571568273,
-0.0223166384,
0.0382216536,
0.014925017,
0.0507622957,
0.0187836587,
0.0424693376,
-0.0330308191,
-0.0177001897,
0.0078026261,
-0.0335717276,
0.0605056584,
-0.0779993758,
-0.0038134826,
-0.0300974604,
-0.000630525,
-0.0464486964,
0.0446531922,
-0.0136703113,
0.0569692515,
0.0330958664,
0.029484842,
0.010722219,
-0.0156963412,
-0.0665717199,
-0.0333167762,
0.0341276266,
-0.0207612533,
-0.0302273873,
-0.0384084173,
-0.0240146425,
0.035214901,
-0.0464324094,
-0.013387572,
3.11444037e-34,
0.0339674652,
-0.0261601601,
0.0430334844,
0.0492821373,
0.0308450777,
-0.0143831335,
-0.0420536175,
0.0144518921,
0.0459790528,
-0.0827625319,
-0.0223653708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18169v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18169v3 | LM-CPPF: Paraphrasing-Guided Data Augmentation for Contrastive Prompt-Based Few-Shot Fine-Tuning | 2023-05-29T15:59:51 | 2023-07-05T09:15:55 | Amirhossein Abaskohi, Sascha Rothe, Yadollah Yaghoobzadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, there has been significant progress in developing
pre-trained language models for NLP. However, these models often struggle when
fine-tuned on small datasets. To address this issue, researchers have proposed
various adaptation approaches. Prompt-based tuning is arguably the most common
way, especially for larger models. Previous research shows that adding
contrastive learning to prompt-based fine-tuning is effective as it helps the
model generate embeddings that are more distinguishable between classes, and it
can also be more sample-efficient as the model learns from positive and
negative examples simultaneously. One of the most important components of
contrastive learning is data augmentation, but unlike computer vision,
effective data augmentation for NLP is still challenging. This paper proposes
LM-CPPF, Contrastive Paraphrasing-guided Prompt-based Fine-tuning of Language
Models, which leverages prompt-based few-shot paraphrasing using generative
language models, especially large language models such as GPT-3 and OPT-175B,
for data augmentation. Our experiments on multiple text classification
benchmarks show that this augmentation method outperforms other methods, such
as easy data augmentation, back translation, and multiple templates. | [
0.0448196083,
0.0528579913,
-0.0030878386,
0.0246590357,
-0.046236895,
-0.0072816275,
-0.0155120026,
0.0028956034,
-0.0311378539,
-0.094402954,
-0.044607833,
0.0038972299,
-0.040380735,
-0.0433546826,
0.0426601321,
-0.07733915,
0.0436316542,
0.0061894977,
0.0083871381,
0.0188876744,
0.0090768086,
0.0367931724,
0.0186218526,
0.0092385244,
0.0630118921,
-0.0099963965,
0.0047047883,
0.0225471854,
0.023496002,
0.0015747048,
0.0319243595,
0.0541649312,
0.0275345482,
0.0256561097,
0.000001847,
-0.052098155,
-0.0275023393,
0.0036422026,
-0.0248687416,
0.0272815432,
0.0973403379,
-0.0326507688,
0.0275130123,
0.0225978419,
-0.0195764937,
-0.0526743419,
0.0258682463,
0.0355017558,
0.0748842582,
0.059246324,
-0.0108724209,
-0.0387430862,
0.0034476719,
-0.0447974205,
-0.0032036302,
-0.0100061605,
0.0211128648,
-0.0361839235,
0.0251156483,
0.0637640059,
-0.0187745988,
0.0261598639,
0.0092179831,
0.0492540896,
0.0334311314,
-0.0015948906,
-0.0182092022,
0.0086864848,
-0.0144391283,
0.0856490135,
-0.0149669712,
-0.0602662265,
-0.0334683619,
-0.0606216416,
-0.0081581064,
-0.0097908387,
-0.0359365381,
-0.0147891277,
0.014395955,
0.0330652557,
0.0160702579,
0.0040953443,
0.0230621081,
0.0468846001,
0.0003020619,
-0.0245106034,
0.032638289,
-0.0339854695,
-0.0220115557,
0.0023963444,
-0.0373394899,
0.0010001047,
-0.0191566385,
0.0101516657,
0.0020389552,
0.0077106268,
-0.085073784,
-0.0504568629,
0.0704589561,
0.0037118213,
0.066251114,
0.026103545,
-0.0315354615,
0.051851403,
-0.0409998409,
0.0299996566,
-0.0214235354,
0.039132636,
-0.0621680059,
-0.0138921337,
-0.0521296859,
0.0077069164,
-0.0702416599,
0.0145893423,
-0.020544352,
-0.0034224961,
-0.0446804278,
0.0189833269,
0.0181593653,
0.0051190378,
0.0074346676,
0.0011838538,
-0.0339175053,
-0.0088957809,
-0.0084001357,
0.030317476,
-0.0467137881,
0.0249047931,
-0.0155276153,
-0.0599455275,
-0.0313431397,
-0.0019935193,
0.040962778,
-0.0471354946,
0.0210824627,
0.0468528569,
-0.0013750221,
-0.0872872993,
-0.0404461473,
0.0116224485,
-0.0255879257,
-0.041977182,
-0.0268734302,
-0.0451223031,
0.03600448,
-0.0109277451,
0.0039415006,
-0.0202296469,
0.0035923661,
0.0301474873,
-0.0406707078,
0.0880830362,
-0.0404522642,
-0.0303236004,
-0.0163413789,
-0.0107897185,
-0.0089293318,
0.0440203361,
0.0173216742,
-0.0086784167,
0.047873687,
-0.0050289365,
0.0149923256,
0.0002465007,
0.0260606278,
0.0250898413,
-0.0366308838,
0.0121966619,
0.0240998343,
0.0084384372,
0.0188795254,
0.0281185545,
-0.034376055,
-0.0148819853,
0.0583694018,
-0.0052786851,
0.0161822606,
0.0132771591,
0.0580834597,
0.0324837193,
-0.0197376683,
0.0177681223,
-0.0362283364,
-0.0067205438,
-0.0356199034,
0.0251180865,
0.0265369378,
0.0158029962,
-0.0206341036,
-0.0329845101,
-0.0026487522,
-0.0046934271,
0.0222166553,
0.0192969013,
0.0096342145,
0.0417239964,
-0.0370545536,
0.006485499,
0.0324285924,
-0.0337266438,
-0.0047375495,
-0.0287953261,
0.0044172625,
0.0872237608,
0.0579131544,
-0.0421210751,
-0.0277040768,
-0.0396536253,
0.0246435907,
0.0048738495,
0.0731091797,
0.005883811,
0.0470117107,
-0.0554031581,
-0.0157105811,
-0.0563352145,
0.0393716507,
0.0027721592,
0.0209357645,
-0.0034937575,
0.0384173691,
0.0049882191,
-0.0652912706,
0.0426623262,
-0.0310954899,
-0.0734215081,
0.0234117974,
0.0266605355,
0.0083878776,
0.018427426,
-0.0028039333,
0.0089028571,
-0.0027260704,
-0.035014458,
0.0052601672,
-0.0114993816,
-0.0198083576,
-0.0648871362,
0.0139172971,
0.0076750228,
0.014381595,
0.0128287561,
-0.0861124918,
-0.0374363996,
-0.0282446444,
-0.0080893142,
0.0295753162,
-0.0575663634,
0.0370451845,
-0.0255883019,
0.0302636717,
-0.0511741079,
0.0427411012,
0.0194916707,
0.040008001,
0.0257258508,
0.0305468384,
0.0462409854,
-0.0220228694,
-0.0356330276,
-0.0173325296,
0.0205635857,
0.012062259,
0.001986604,
0.0063287644,
-0.0618997961,
-0.0029955555,
-0.062600024,
0.0211617257,
-0.0159174167,
0.0057375715,
0.0509467199,
0.0009419409,
0.0006102205,
-0.0187903102,
-0.0005760194,
-0.0107669998,
-0.0112858219,
0.0248444192,
0.0724276528,
0.0191332214,
-0.0071813497,
-0.0419355892,
0.004384778,
0.0053283176,
0.0457125083,
-0.0104091195,
0.0030424064,
-0.0397525616,
0.0274417698,
0.0120380111,
0.0318776332,
0.0008445997,
-0.0505128726,
-0.025131546,
-0.0280164145,
0.0068475204,
0.066776149,
-0.0016196554,
-0.0109094335,
0.0300455596,
0.03015217,
-0.0323485285,
0.0026309709,
-0.0146675836,
-0.0362875424,
-0.0086174067,
-0.0256366916,
0.0089140935,
0.0619440079,
-0.0140164485,
-0.0296871513,
-0.0643992946,
0.0143089509,
0.0059216442,
0.0037383288,
0.0047701066,
0.0012797549,
-0.0231357254,
0.0031974183,
-0.0386339873,
-0.0439380333,
0.0829041079,
-0.0538455993,
-0.0008454168,
-0.0415019281,
-0.0385168381,
-0.0375287011,
0.0170628615,
0.020004252,
0.0210689809,
0.0218475163,
0.0080737378,
-0.0670803636,
-0.0532521121,
0.0324393101,
-0.0096049774,
0.0242810622,
-0.0347701162,
-0.0019369378,
-0.0075950231,
-0.0568206385,
-0.0359793194,
-0.0990926176,
-0.0259703938,
0.0255286153,
-0.00596917,
0.0125932246,
0.0047566644,
-0.0279321168,
0.000011785,
0.0697422698,
-0.0179368313,
-0.0035184326,
-0.0594484955,
0.0221593585,
0.0782539994,
0.0257638451,
0.0132378424,
-0.0147262998,
0.0110245515,
-0.0040078829,
0.0217192154,
0.0143781807,
-0.0353913158,
-0.0120680798,
0.0167314224,
-0.049781546,
-0.0509594493,
-0.0008675616,
0.0483325832,
-0.0464039519,
-0.0179741345,
0.102507621,
0.0136328535,
-0.0523299649,
-0.0034552142,
0.0125058675,
0.0048117694,
0.0215128344,
0.0236882716,
-0.055144161,
-0.0619628057,
-0.0151174152,
0.0307978168,
-0.0075473706,
0.0044923876,
-0.0326475613,
-0.1289680451,
0.0213949606,
0.0070641637,
-0.0460596457,
-0.0376231894,
-0.0151957888,
0.0097502097,
0.0016173815,
0.0319495685,
-0.0355830081,
-0.0285172872,
0.0253410898,
-0.0042980458,
0.0148364864,
-0.0953440368,
0.006980693,
-0.0582065918,
0.0287355166,
0.0340102054,
0.0190145634,
0.0005041914,
-0.0132838683,
0.0222947337,
-0.0744886175,
-0.0000092829,
-0.0026026119,
0.0829133093,
-0.0246212669,
-0.0145792346,
0.0285386443,
0.0239268895,
0.005707812,
-0.0185230318,
-0.0031114242,
0.0445251204,
0.0041537802,
0.0064256792,
0.0088174539,
0.0050466796,
0.0065177921,
0.0755535662,
0.0347973071,
-0.0373782516,
-0.0195790157,
0.0056235828,
-0.0010790545,
-0.0790197849,
-0.0008639175,
0.0047809952,
-0.022986047,
0.0049700625,
-0.0493802987,
-0.046497006,
0.0288770478,
0.033678513,
0.0102501111,
0.0511246845,
-0.0542308912,
-0.0144678308,
0.0038728362,
0.0260633323,
-0.0464414321,
0.0220806412,
-0.0248233993,
-0.0332919993,
0.0672695786,
-0.0341462046,
-0.0232224576,
0.0071335472,
-0.0704275891,
-0.0340559334,
-0.0138709201,
0.0611086823,
0.0049631614,
0.0499786735,
-0.0304445121,
-0.0675688684,
0.0478973724,
0.0706184208,
-0.0132168913,
-0.0044217911,
0.0300445519,
0.005561783,
-0.0083553847,
0.0302397497,
-0.0438348837,
0.0115384925,
0.0702197403,
0.0221773144,
-0.0264543016,
-0.0434247181,
0.0205067694,
0.015121446,
0.0668888688,
-0.0225465894,
-0.0127590802,
-0.0195476152,
0.0503045321,
-0.0031913936,
-0.015598896,
-0.0441973284,
-0.0024642027,
0.0424734019,
-0.0077674552,
-0.02512688,
-0.003926585,
-0.0313126445,
0.0573407635,
-0.0624465272,
0.0034031013,
0.0151057253,
-0.0060274713,
-0.0083368542,
0.0236328412,
-0.024286909,
0.008362093,
-0.0206099246,
0.0086906264,
-0.0347910151,
0.0468090884,
0.018417092,
-0.0048252163,
-0.0469795801,
0.0547599308,
-0.0884750411,
0.0091799311,
-0.0276860949,
0.0363981277,
0.0625748113,
-0.028725734,
0.0312149208,
-0.0091273366,
-0.0459187999,
-0.0010261174,
0.0542973243,
-0.0077176956,
-0.0035730174,
0.0375108644,
0.0285241678,
-0.0058046747,
0.0045361179,
0.0515560135,
0.0270512048,
0.0532973371,
0.0105347084,
0.0018337796,
-0.0378012173,
-0.0185402203,
0.0262411963,
0.0420486778,
0.0091699157,
0.0465207398,
-0.0330247283,
-0.057473883,
0.0104884477,
-0.0055693327,
-0.0316935554,
-0.0118733449,
0.0439953916,
0.037607003,
-0.0262480639,
-0.0283452347,
-0.0335422792,
0.0213544723,
0.0440688692,
-0.0083357003,
-0.0191854779,
-6.091761803e-33,
-0.027857393,
0.0415243991,
0.0080684694,
-0.0353744291,
-0.0208502896,
-0.0300000664,
-0.0015343576,
-0.0365211293,
-0.0310530961,
-0.0036436717,
-0.0286281928,
-0.0071986429,
0.0101251118,
0.0398322344,
-0.0058705909,
-0.0238407571,
0.078312844,
0.0126777189,
-0.0152561646,
0.0059586894,
-0.0043604914,
0.0497440733,
0.0735716373,
-0.0257668514,
-0.0005150411,
0.0002232367,
-0.0179281253,
0.0056320638,
0.0160406828,
0.0232502446,
-0.0158581827,
0.036389485,
0.0300562792,
-0.0346441455,
-0.0168400165,
-0.0031174237,
-0.0953263044,
-0.0140617602,
0.0436635874,
0.0173891895,
-0.0573791899,
-0.0460254289,
0.0257158298,
-0.0374409892,
0.031912826,
0.0079590464,
0.035203103,
-0.0618119165,
-0.003434405,
0.0213979911,
-0.036562752,
0.0068245861,
0.02847578,
-0.0028868474,
0.0122026755,
0.0391212404,
-0.0092529152,
0.1220655441,
-0.0505020581,
-0.0237596352,
0.0473003462,
0.0484708324,
0.0021605596,
0.0237300806,
0.0026951467,
0.0160080418,
-0.0206886269,
-0.013244099,
0.0029592549,
-0.0002296759,
0.0311637353,
0.0195544865,
0.0349985212,
0.108137764,
0.0563738197,
0.0204428975,
-0.0190273728,
0.0089335563,
0.0123104434,
0.0015812445,
0.0342495404,
-0.005583399,
-0.0255063139,
-0.0300997626,
-0.0536958724,
-0.0607338771,
-0.0303937849,
-0.0179351177,
0.0250631068,
0.0488316603,
-0.052608937,
0.0153179774,
0.0320491046,
-0.0487336256,
-0.0335281491,
0.0093433093,
-0.0389645919,
0.0065320297,
0.0050716014,
0.0116950963,
-0.0416465886,
-0.0444913767,
0.0380365252,
0.0182699542,
0.0064457878,
-0.013973278,
0.0751865283,
0.0150952078,
-0.1030271277,
0.0359727368,
-0.005238167,
-0.0000660308,
-0.0133613292,
0.0051450031,
0.0089552449,
0.0405188017,
-0.0041420222,
0.0676531494,
0.0625944287,
-0.0180435404,
0.0198341813,
-0.0210061967,
-0.009438375,
0.0246524401,
-0.0117431106,
0.0013291688,
0.0049102656,
0.0305316839,
0.0099945562,
-0.0506279394,
-0.0053035086,
-0.0159548745,
2.582e-7,
0.0488905758,
0.0267816782,
-0.0120736966,
0.0160474554,
-0.0007107828,
0.0418625288,
0.0079336269,
0.0192673039,
0.0013284131,
0.0023160942,
0.0395992994,
0.0279325545,
0.0400584936,
-0.0312389508,
-0.0987544283,
0.0528561324,
-0.0606762208,
0.0391032808,
-0.0334569588,
-0.0375972353,
0.0769036263,
0.1456713229,
0.0377917923,
-0.0102631282,
-0.0080196476,
-0.0527196005,
0.0584580712,
-0.0465728492,
-0.0114527466,
0.0195233896,
0.0097757205,
0.0569830351,
-0.0150668006,
0.0164045505,
-0.0306052994,
0.0278741103,
-0.0127038741,
0.0758802965,
0.0312013235,
-0.0154060218,
-0.0125454469,
0.0001371517,
0.0050838948,
-0.0664292425,
0.1051658168,
-0.0892674252,
0.0142163923,
-0.0231901687,
-0.0485685505,
-0.0066044908,
0.028042106,
-0.0374944024,
-0.0392801203,
-0.0032529628,
0.0266346093,
0.0210757088,
-0.0540314242,
-0.0913322195,
-0.0039710873,
0.0117531195,
-0.0086611062,
-0.0216625668,
-0.0172042847,
-0.0298416875,
0.0341351293,
-0.0643175393,
0.0284666717,
2.516712513e-34,
0.0575622953,
-0.0080460235,
0.0294986758,
-0.0195470415,
0.0067841997,
0.0118232807,
0.0156905316,
0.0023478572,
0.0382767655,
-0.0648075715,
0.0031468244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18156v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18156v1 | Exploring Effectiveness of GPT-3 in Grammatical Error Correction: A Study on Performance and Controllability in Prompt-Based Methods | 2023-05-29T15:31:29 | 2023-05-29T15:31:29 | Mengsay Loem, Masahiro Kaneko, Sho Takase, Naoaki Okazaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large-scale pre-trained language models such as GPT-3 have shown remarkable
performance across various natural language processing tasks. However, applying
prompt-based methods with GPT-3 for Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) tasks
and their controllability remains underexplored. Controllability in GEC is
crucial for real-world applications, particularly in educational settings,
where the ability to tailor feedback according to learner levels and specific
error types can significantly enhance the learning process. This paper
investigates the performance and controllability of prompt-based methods with
GPT-3 for GEC tasks using zero-shot and few-shot setting. We explore the impact
of task instructions and examples on GPT-3's output, focusing on controlling
aspects such as minimal edits, fluency edits, and learner levels. Our findings
demonstrate that GPT-3 could effectively perform GEC tasks, outperforming
existing supervised and unsupervised approaches. We also showed that GPT-3
could achieve controllability when appropriate task instructions and examples
are given. | [
0.0682005286,
0.020054223,
0.0061963811,
0.0035683967,
-0.0443650633,
0.0276676249,
0.0063928938,
-0.0369466431,
0.0115156975,
-0.0728758797,
-0.0382659361,
-0.0248766765,
0.0195107814,
-0.0171958413,
0.0190459285,
-0.071103029,
0.0952979475,
-0.0037928983,
-0.0036064093,
0.0062101264,
0.0166829713,
0.0129287848,
-0.0330934487,
0.0501069352,
-0.024966117,
-0.0530051179,
-0.0045168502,
0.0196171738,
-0.0098680425,
-0.0027115482,
0.0591313839,
0.0869878009,
-0.0165019985,
0.0673803836,
0.0000020413,
-0.044252146,
-0.0205222052,
-0.0282316376,
-0.0209032744,
0.0738083273,
0.0224779081,
0.0041141626,
-0.0669366866,
0.0099503184,
-0.0066098929,
-0.0048207291,
0.0546249487,
0.0374835096,
0.0702146664,
0.0859251544,
-0.002025513,
0.0081774136,
0.0254349746,
-0.0015623047,
0.0205629021,
-0.0147707136,
0.0130575541,
-0.0262005124,
0.0060081384,
-0.005430168,
-0.0407843813,
0.0302425623,
0.0097504761,
-0.0405922048,
-0.0271602385,
0.0046987771,
-0.0231813546,
-0.0169571247,
-0.0712269917,
0.037681967,
-0.0284349918,
-0.0424305461,
-0.0308403485,
-0.0336495154,
0.0202825405,
0.0092475321,
-0.0062945262,
0.0016383668,
-0.0069005899,
0.0242553577,
0.0050413972,
-0.0799364448,
-0.0145573895,
-0.0060902378,
0.0157765243,
0.0614463873,
0.0431397632,
-0.0748209432,
-0.0159344506,
0.0771730617,
-0.0471526869,
-0.0421124324,
0.0223714877,
-0.0055164103,
-0.0654987469,
-0.0006502415,
-0.0640412569,
-0.061318025,
-0.0074366271,
0.0179389287,
0.0363564007,
0.0420756675,
-0.0313709676,
0.0195386894,
0.0029796828,
0.0785043538,
0.0127163511,
0.0488586053,
0.0117307985,
0.0288109686,
-0.0606013648,
-0.0070314202,
-0.0849523619,
0.0158195868,
-0.0148856277,
0.0245032273,
-0.0722595975,
0.0057517877,
-0.0055957693,
0.0188012924,
0.0229472946,
-0.0288992207,
-0.0592551641,
-0.035787303,
0.0046339338,
0.0418096706,
0.0050814538,
0.0302930456,
0.0005905677,
-0.0639380589,
-0.0262931641,
-0.0038454649,
0.0383132808,
-0.0222615488,
-0.0123566166,
-0.011853043,
-0.0381776989,
-0.0722678453,
-0.0389901809,
-0.0015858725,
-0.0124749327,
-0.0508539639,
-0.0643591136,
-0.0378790125,
-0.0266132392,
-0.0290602241,
0.0189387947,
-0.0152046829,
-0.0143706668,
0.0020009913,
-0.0165638495,
0.0717347711,
-0.0304716211,
-0.0067322352,
0.027566893,
-0.0128731709,
0.0172410235,
0.0166235045,
0.0176449865,
-0.0363874026,
0.0507510677,
-0.0078224624,
0.054962378,
0.0355967134,
-0.0053401762,
-0.0198021103,
0.0307511818,
-0.0269351229,
0.0167632774,
0.0306915976,
0.039972242,
0.0636239052,
-0.0079477085,
0.0523668379,
0.0718396828,
0.0315729305,
-0.0141570875,
-0.0160448551,
0.0726353303,
-0.0030284787,
0.0298107751,
0.0498363227,
-0.0612138622,
-0.0403321832,
-0.0569966659,
0.0074917101,
0.0119025223,
0.014607436,
-0.0199484639,
-0.0438414477,
0.0136103872,
0.0092404224,
-0.0354102887,
-0.0186406691,
0.0375803597,
0.0352719463,
-0.055395741,
0.0149398772,
0.0026217324,
-0.0749513209,
0.0123180868,
-0.0426501483,
0.0175621659,
0.0512221679,
0.0496199019,
-0.035681244,
-0.0500369482,
-0.0240869131,
0.0073378501,
0.0435767099,
0.0590305887,
0.0100990366,
-0.0153931547,
-0.0393785574,
-0.0092040338,
0.0082725035,
0.0281917583,
0.0035974961,
0.0301690828,
0.0242254436,
0.007781066,
0.0214049593,
-0.0122756083,
0.0228311643,
0.0042659612,
-0.0663481653,
-0.0223124716,
0.002083811,
0.0155857792,
0.0110241957,
-0.0308478121,
-0.0004533027,
-0.028372718,
0.0367160402,
-0.0036137041,
-0.0235545114,
-0.0572814122,
-0.0759985894,
0.0243864711,
0.0070503694,
-0.0682092458,
0.0272250529,
-0.0464208759,
-0.0544097833,
-0.0066338512,
-0.0370447673,
0.0301904231,
-0.0566146821,
0.0486609899,
0.0073138336,
-0.0157558564,
-0.0366572812,
-0.0006992967,
0.0280497987,
0.008822103,
0.0206915177,
0.0416421629,
-0.0174971428,
-0.0442905799,
-0.0561732277,
0.0109001156,
0.0337480344,
0.0196924079,
0.0297291242,
0.0414581969,
-0.0346551798,
-0.0065445704,
-0.0719510391,
0.0039491151,
-0.0429348424,
0.0233245715,
0.0426669344,
0.0071692429,
-0.0506815091,
-0.0465068184,
0.0190799981,
0.0421440192,
0.0409096666,
0.0013408177,
0.0331539027,
-0.0133571448,
-0.0117265191,
-0.0695188567,
0.0055097346,
-0.0264049266,
-0.0346618444,
0.0374545045,
-0.0360194072,
-0.0423365422,
0.0641192198,
-0.0108911656,
0.0521305613,
0.0642806888,
-0.05010245,
0.0073190043,
-0.0223484132,
0.0967622995,
0.0182432532,
-0.0378585048,
0.0356830321,
0.0144251315,
-0.0434775949,
-0.0117915655,
0.0051763048,
-0.023641957,
-0.07671009,
-0.0082275625,
0.0260400884,
0.032885924,
0.0821448043,
0.0487973392,
-0.0401402675,
-0.0614389591,
0.0219796542,
-0.034552712,
0.0056412374,
-0.038237825,
-0.0182354245,
-0.0315788053,
-0.0052486463,
-0.0249549095,
-0.0432720929,
0.0860192105,
-0.0011378168,
-0.0114816362,
-0.0460228808,
0.0184326544,
0.0040319283,
0.0061185304,
0.0210456047,
-0.0040315697,
0.0078502856,
-0.0691614002,
-0.0622298978,
-0.0012771501,
0.0541594923,
0.007865767,
0.0272178594,
-0.0875032768,
0.0225060116,
0.0108222505,
-0.0521537028,
0.0053112302,
-0.0432413928,
-0.0033062252,
-0.0133702382,
0.0130871031,
-0.0026414467,
-0.0148914624,
-0.0366804115,
0.024911603,
0.085112825,
-0.0233302638,
-0.0366938151,
-0.0382475033,
0.017009709,
0.0133102313,
0.0007612435,
-0.0053687766,
0.0024304807,
0.0212190952,
0.0451603048,
0.0164040662,
0.0122649409,
-0.0128986491,
0.0394431502,
0.0261047147,
-0.0626603365,
-0.024243176,
0.0055265771,
0.0727558434,
-0.0726023689,
-0.0448563695,
0.1072795689,
0.0578849912,
-0.0514322221,
-0.0288922787,
0.0185724441,
-0.0147054791,
-0.0074695777,
0.027646808,
-0.0637743101,
-0.0222677421,
0.0154892057,
0.0295765121,
-0.0255378988,
-0.0077783433,
0.0025173079,
-0.1548596025,
0.0699286014,
0.0136271287,
-0.0078163622,
-0.0543244146,
0.0049067717,
0.0175332837,
0.0153053449,
0.0440021083,
0.0297943428,
-0.018234795,
0.0062457658,
0.0221192557,
-0.0137445973,
-0.0854375288,
-0.0101848878,
-0.0201893076,
0.049442552,
0.0832280219,
-0.0118688457,
0.0070098173,
-0.0321183167,
0.0782891139,
-0.0004657336,
-0.0179505982,
-0.008269934,
-0.0010275809,
0.0080313291,
-0.0259276852,
-0.029830642,
0.0455587655,
0.0110348444,
0.000843689,
0.0016058611,
0.0965745077,
-0.0314978138,
0.0112497183,
0.0250457861,
-0.0048316959,
0.0488102883,
0.0426024869,
0.0357729271,
-0.0500766076,
-0.0436119884,
-0.0627696961,
0.0002886142,
-0.0333051533,
0.0017862563,
0.0225563757,
-0.0121361809,
-0.0057116956,
-0.0458348691,
-0.0598519035,
0.054726433,
-0.0111500183,
0.0211028438,
-0.0285070967,
-0.0013153803,
0.0051148375,
0.0419656523,
-0.0037930615,
-0.0094879521,
0.0100098206,
-0.1254606247,
-0.0060918666,
-0.007231243,
0.0245759636,
-0.0157419443,
-0.0126342578,
-0.0302542057,
-0.0565261655,
0.0304676332,
0.064855583,
0.0088718832,
0.0187419448,
-0.0166181959,
-0.0690359771,
0.0068853204,
0.0346651785,
0.0000871044,
0.0440976992,
0.0073111579,
-0.0002050511,
-0.0091543002,
0.0219778828,
0.0061852671,
0.0193693135,
0.0296519194,
0.0389384143,
0.0047956505,
-0.0271436106,
0.056991972,
0.0353386737,
0.0983205214,
-0.0154063795,
0.033393044,
-0.078723602,
0.0002603141,
-0.024931239,
0.0060428469,
-0.0415558852,
0.0014117727,
0.0226386227,
-0.0380937383,
-0.0498364829,
-0.0124473879,
-0.0609625578,
-0.0029673064,
-0.0600535832,
-0.0038863556,
-0.0065532457,
0.0143787945,
0.0306055527,
0.0113068298,
-0.0158811752,
0.031127464,
0.0434747376,
0.0170585625,
-0.0008948463,
0.0819065347,
0.0334473848,
0.0017477857,
0.0191701166,
0.0240837801,
-0.0463539325,
0.0234599374,
-0.0315172523,
0.033958219,
0.078699328,
0.0122165354,
0.0399601609,
-0.0504237041,
-0.024782531,
-0.0232961942,
0.0358384661,
0.0303663407,
0.0009386538,
0.0126891704,
-0.0206892975,
0.011378278,
-0.0100736842,
0.0454682149,
-0.0089733433,
0.0481060743,
0.0166067164,
-0.0259021167,
-0.0180026498,
-0.0039146212,
-0.0146550694,
-0.0459648147,
-0.0105931582,
0.0243496653,
-0.035357587,
-0.0344219431,
-0.0244846307,
0.0648379847,
-0.0101255337,
-0.0183224343,
0.0335068777,
0.0313391499,
-0.0478912815,
-0.0238186922,
-0.0229694303,
-0.0150050335,
0.0107279913,
-0.0313196108,
-0.027723169,
-6.05994815e-33,
-0.0849012733,
-0.0120634306,
0.0031606746,
-0.0024346167,
-0.0163716841,
-0.022829514,
-0.0398645289,
0.0195230171,
0.0391108617,
0.0453134887,
-0.0258903373,
0.0434529968,
0.0116409296,
0.0158868581,
0.0381148867,
0.0156147908,
0.0809223428,
-0.0104379272,
-0.0282787662,
0.0098607102,
0.0316787884,
0.0475477539,
0.0992662162,
-0.0068344763,
0.0472855046,
0.0272030197,
-0.0309493989,
0.0087832175,
-0.0270385444,
0.0254711304,
0.0113819949,
0.0444034338,
-0.0053086425,
-0.0331692658,
-0.0248542875,
0.0200354997,
-0.0484941341,
-0.0602197982,
-0.0005193879,
0.0380378291,
-0.0094323009,
-0.0062088449,
0.0017340281,
-0.0306387153,
-0.0301570278,
0.0099322824,
0.0133955814,
0.001564841,
0.0422342531,
0.003085946,
-0.0722043365,
0.007067102,
0.0018801441,
-0.018712854,
-0.0045179334,
0.0253056623,
-0.0175988954,
-0.0156041197,
-0.0411961265,
-0.0130404225,
0.0701867417,
0.0367319956,
0.0014875183,
-0.0270992294,
-0.0197623987,
0.0078443112,
0.0057955217,
-0.002233333,
-0.0273909215,
0.007614865,
0.0101880208,
-0.0161437728,
0.0470967554,
0.0329293385,
0.0363064483,
-0.0203889795,
-0.0303299874,
0.0044660359,
-0.0131699722,
0.0219726879,
-0.0226447284,
-0.0264719464,
-0.0158900991,
-0.0336036459,
-0.0105698453,
0.0078327376,
-0.0238280911,
-0.0038148323,
0.0634205043,
-0.0032420375,
0.0144827012,
0.0123223122,
0.0085214004,
0.0101140523,
-0.0246347729,
-0.0173031464,
-0.0145677496,
0.0433251038,
-0.0332761556,
0.0329429768,
-0.0457555689,
-0.0069236001,
0.0089318696,
0.0214375015,
0.0022611397,
0.0094047403,
0.0180832203,
0.0499577746,
-0.0687764511,
0.0297133494,
-0.0208252668,
0.0428148508,
-0.0108623495,
-0.0316177905,
0.023004083,
0.0009738919,
0.0173335969,
0.0341888331,
0.011123958,
-0.0572727621,
-0.008611301,
-0.0223473795,
-0.0182535779,
0.0291230828,
-0.0089223124,
-0.0037830381,
-0.027527459,
0.0254877862,
-0.006476772,
-0.0422096737,
0.015028704,
0.0117357811,
2.697e-7,
0.0221063662,
0.059625499,
0.0303967725,
-0.000834286,
0.0106930481,
-0.0056844531,
-0.0172658339,
0.0134427017,
0.0201785732,
0.045450855,
0.0479698181,
-0.0113548301,
0.0496480316,
0.0018449586,
-0.0538251512,
0.0041478854,
-0.0472327396,
0.0415681414,
-0.0605051704,
0.0057770796,
0.0650964156,
0.0260807388,
0.0328112766,
-0.0057861074,
-0.0000286958,
-0.0294037275,
0.0404411666,
0.0046881321,
-0.0141423475,
0.0217453837,
0.0836884156,
0.0253308062,
0.0115451822,
0.0241225138,
-0.0173500665,
-0.024732586,
-0.0016163777,
0.0400766507,
-0.0058268029,
0.0362670086,
-0.007156163,
0.0170047097,
-0.0260370728,
-0.0411208123,
0.0569953248,
-0.0542096645,
0.0514734574,
0.0424350612,
-0.0131114479,
-0.0446744189,
0.0199181382,
-0.0592973456,
-0.0433486886,
-0.0067623849,
0.0407587402,
0.0513894707,
-0.0236089285,
-0.0215002224,
0.0191205777,
0.0454774201,
0.020578498,
-0.0156758893,
-0.0179179385,
-0.0094772866,
0.0067376141,
-0.0477413572,
-0.0135609116,
2.511281361e-34,
0.0487837866,
-0.0324152671,
0.08645951,
-0.0261300132,
0.0062152673,
0.0273877755,
0.0308587346,
0.0137373433,
0.0195914507,
-0.0404926948,
-0.0397903398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18153v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18153v2 | Do Large Language Models Know What They Don't Know? | 2023-05-29T15:30:13 | 2023-05-30T15:14:06 | Zhangyue Yin, Qiushi Sun, Qipeng Guo, Jiawen Wu, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have a wealth of knowledge that allows them to
excel in various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Current research
focuses on enhancing their performance within their existing knowledge. Despite
their vast knowledge, LLMs are still limited by the amount of information they
can accommodate and comprehend. Therefore, the ability to understand their own
limitations on the unknows, referred to as self-knowledge, is of paramount
importance. This study aims to evaluate LLMs' self-knowledge by assessing their
ability to identify unanswerable or unknowable questions. We introduce an
automated methodology to detect uncertainty in the responses of these models,
providing a novel measure of their self-knowledge. We further introduce a
unique dataset, SelfAware, consisting of unanswerable questions from five
diverse categories and their answerable counterparts. Our extensive analysis,
involving 20 LLMs including GPT-3, InstructGPT, and LLaMA, discovering an
intrinsic capacity for self-knowledge within these models. Moreover, we
demonstrate that in-context learning and instruction tuning can further enhance
this self-knowledge. Despite this promising insight, our findings also
highlight a considerable gap between the capabilities of these models and human
proficiency in recognizing the limits of their knowledge. | [
0.0651326701,
0.0370054431,
-0.0360411666,
0.0500798859,
-0.0191242453,
0.0343451574,
-0.0033871022,
-0.004996825,
0.0382397212,
-0.0416412614,
-0.0584266968,
-0.0033654061,
-0.0325153247,
0.0039775507,
0.0265256986,
-0.0304394495,
0.0394227542,
-0.0524710193,
0.0170667358,
-0.0237940606,
-0.0313159376,
0.0020561146,
-0.0072732037,
0.0136709604,
0.006699407,
-0.0406286232,
0.002270268,
-0.0187241435,
-0.0489268005,
-0.0357096642,
0.0240015388,
0.0503128357,
0.0123494836,
0.0545545407,
0.0000017908,
-0.0737750381,
-0.0049111093,
-0.0471707806,
-0.0748355612,
0.0203321204,
0.0272073653,
0.0214044843,
-0.0081217065,
0.0268769041,
-0.0492489412,
0.0009115844,
0.0116341775,
0.0433596112,
0.0410534777,
0.0514129065,
0.0212359261,
-0.0028268483,
0.0071260654,
-0.0045437496,
0.0425332077,
-0.0554687381,
0.0164744593,
0.0293062441,
-0.0047457535,
0.0023600068,
-0.0306345671,
0.042346146,
0.0281805042,
-0.0084098717,
-0.0099797342,
0.0264254734,
-0.0084541459,
-0.0474052131,
-0.0190021247,
0.0381408669,
0.0216215998,
-0.0173168611,
-0.0268135443,
-0.0121262856,
0.0358640924,
0.0191102773,
-0.0506821685,
0.0190612059,
0.0065559307,
0.0026991379,
-0.0158496723,
0.0279321074,
0.0150834871,
-0.005015444,
-0.0131805148,
0.0992677882,
-0.0151007194,
-0.0289718304,
0.0315512195,
0.0067617921,
-0.0220629312,
-0.0607324801,
-0.0100545008,
0.0746753588,
-0.0119632613,
0.0518160313,
-0.0166993588,
0.0133935148,
0.0441829264,
-0.0457907878,
0.032958623,
0.0401317999,
-0.0246256813,
0.0564863719,
-0.0297671389,
0.03595265,
-0.0274484809,
0.0229148977,
-0.0222271066,
0.0029658694,
-0.0588071197,
-0.0603166483,
-0.0233463328,
0.0199797023,
-0.0124586886,
-0.0020972036,
-0.0040355111,
0.0489280038,
0.0093371645,
0.0019694839,
-0.0054412829,
0.0363025814,
-0.0084419493,
-0.0258079041,
-0.0876593292,
0.0311854593,
-0.0322102904,
-0.0057989862,
-0.0141022457,
-0.0650031939,
0.0091823488,
-0.0028798843,
-0.0053797336,
-0.0244476963,
0.038064003,
0.0783678964,
-0.004509856,
-0.0401976369,
-0.0554606989,
0.0012909091,
-0.0225169268,
-0.095474638,
0.0140521349,
-0.0448073447,
-0.0223220028,
0.0302081313,
0.0087996116,
-0.036465127,
0.0311957076,
0.0011351033,
-0.0147693371,
0.0912853926,
-0.0040877536,
0.0521509163,
0.061227072,
0.0177687053,
0.0218835417,
0.0855887532,
-0.0020618888,
-0.0073418706,
0.0383473113,
-0.0269756913,
0.0325097069,
0.0027104376,
0.0217571873,
-0.0166707374,
-0.0444532633,
0.0296265297,
-0.0418477505,
0.0119013283,
0.0298696868,
0.0482432432,
0.0317813568,
-0.0231125783,
0.0530495383,
0.0696466118,
-0.0063964268,
0.0304476395,
0.0317456722,
-0.0056438181,
0.0505965054,
0.0306999795,
-0.0492924228,
0.0424897373,
-0.0290267896,
0.0132131213,
0.0354093798,
-0.0039316579,
-0.0197082665,
-0.0746014416,
-0.0507785045,
0.0300190262,
-0.0081219655,
0.0426243134,
0.0669296235,
0.0172099173,
-0.0049795527,
-0.002494598,
-0.0178178512,
-0.0180899911,
-0.0030284578,
-0.0858176649,
0.0653181896,
0.0417498238,
0.0425055176,
-0.0428665094,
-0.0480403826,
0.0076874848,
-0.0164131001,
0.0539301261,
0.0584010407,
-0.0008340546,
0.0063243737,
0.0066477689,
-0.0111393426,
-0.0281899497,
0.034376394,
-0.0121985832,
0.0282463133,
0.0121746697,
-0.0142896231,
-0.0749177709,
-0.0213725977,
0.0458319373,
-0.0600688197,
-0.0580995753,
-0.0137758385,
-0.0068369745,
0.0239365548,
0.0073361713,
-0.0072283954,
0.023861343,
0.03992052,
0.0008123776,
-0.0605614372,
-0.0042785932,
-0.0390734151,
-0.0128395595,
0.0449992195,
-0.0187515691,
-0.052610185,
0.0130967498,
-0.0104154423,
-0.0510816909,
0.0371067375,
-0.0518871695,
0.0447961204,
-0.0427225232,
0.0189587772,
-0.0219241846,
0.0214390364,
-0.0224720836,
0.0724101141,
-0.0008493717,
0.0316223763,
-0.0020449539,
-0.0049266983,
0.0127224801,
-0.0122711733,
-0.0315504111,
-0.0039376658,
-0.0191839878,
-0.0103310654,
0.0220001452,
0.0072210953,
-0.0790868476,
-0.0263436921,
-0.0743349493,
-0.0076469132,
0.0054348125,
0.0177821331,
0.0324646272,
-0.022740867,
-0.0456921533,
-0.0545373075,
-0.0176403783,
0.0023688148,
0.0299657565,
0.0362074301,
0.0550958291,
0.0064540231,
0.0141168563,
-0.0438795201,
0.0116853649,
-0.0121458694,
-0.00262105,
0.0190961659,
0.0116450014,
-0.0508225448,
0.0416454449,
-0.034730047,
0.0320104547,
0.0040196036,
-0.04471986,
0.0199639071,
-0.018106699,
-0.009137989,
0.0710488036,
0.0048899306,
0.0645453483,
0.0707468167,
-0.0189018715,
-0.0411227196,
0.0345568433,
-0.0318670534,
-0.0631654114,
-0.0512419157,
-0.004100489,
-0.00757581,
0.083913818,
0.0133250142,
-0.0145797739,
-0.0275906641,
0.0355228521,
-0.0395625718,
-0.0492157154,
-0.0571317337,
0.0051341299,
-0.006908549,
0.0831288323,
-0.0007788143,
-0.0764632896,
0.0813531801,
0.00941699,
-0.0257469192,
-0.021345403,
-0.0036778182,
-0.0226439033,
0.0980935171,
0.0021274122,
-0.0064641028,
0.035797067,
-0.0476468056,
-0.0695816725,
0.0039297445,
0.0094014117,
-0.0306085944,
0.0452682711,
-0.0456662402,
0.0026938906,
0.0078901248,
-0.0190352779,
-0.0690059736,
-0.021088833,
-0.0400914513,
-0.0325639956,
-0.0084379157,
-0.0199438408,
-0.0062504322,
-0.0153249688,
0.0370916687,
0.0077881105,
-0.0117886849,
-0.0471859165,
-0.0041036359,
0.0136839217,
0.0485251695,
0.0349902995,
0.0679777041,
-0.0279242713,
0.0591222234,
0.0306703206,
0.0391923636,
-0.0005910164,
0.0013748247,
0.0254358277,
0.0238976348,
-0.0226974785,
0.0176510569,
0.036225535,
0.0651420727,
-0.0542972609,
-0.01759254,
0.132729739,
0.0538025498,
-0.0013262833,
0.0043327915,
-0.084355019,
0.0168768167,
0.0744309723,
0.0393963158,
-0.0370420925,
-0.0211847033,
-0.0077534029,
0.0179402661,
-0.0435132049,
-0.0380697213,
-0.0252723992,
-0.1289595962,
0.0375013053,
-0.0236434639,
-0.0295433272,
-0.0038425932,
-0.0090587772,
-0.0046999711,
-0.0019468229,
0.0371155664,
-0.0089695835,
-0.0418526717,
-0.0091648046,
0.017466642,
-0.053154178,
-0.0579463691,
0.0411769636,
0.0135781048,
0.0800333023,
0.0473300889,
0.0076910327,
-0.0029580353,
-0.009503793,
0.0239190273,
-0.0386744104,
0.0224975646,
-0.0145616531,
0.0569077767,
0.0132830264,
-0.006489119,
0.0039628777,
0.0141740162,
-0.0499147251,
0.0159663074,
0.0126931313,
0.0880252048,
-0.004069177,
-0.0370466337,
-0.0139080752,
-0.0128756873,
-0.0292425491,
0.0939440578,
0.0414040796,
-0.0117287142,
-0.0219634641,
-0.0345566273,
0.0037979991,
-0.0120524671,
-0.0529223867,
0.0452816188,
0.0347516723,
-0.0017679877,
-0.057213489,
-0.0485543013,
0.0483971052,
-0.0018186118,
0.008396362,
0.024715865,
0.014067268,
0.0192348249,
-0.0480224155,
0.0002254378,
-0.0339789316,
-0.0256647244,
-0.0562874377,
-0.0116311572,
0.014146856,
-0.0278236866,
-0.0009464393,
0.0094077326,
-0.0705033913,
-0.0709895715,
0.0009058755,
0.0356540941,
0.0379099809,
-0.0095604211,
-0.0178277846,
-0.0796279386,
0.0348186269,
0.0326658227,
-0.0495504029,
0.0159871913,
0.0070555778,
0.0480235331,
-0.004218142,
0.0632804558,
-0.009612103,
0.0148665709,
0.0034503627,
0.0147484494,
-0.0188886952,
-0.0336211473,
0.0522364192,
0.0255193077,
0.0241924617,
-0.0134214079,
0.0339011736,
-0.0334586576,
-0.0146514373,
0.0008433521,
-0.0121443449,
-0.0321335234,
-0.0126391444,
0.0467583202,
-0.0293249544,
0.0017069206,
-0.0384886973,
-0.0287779327,
0.0190539211,
-0.008079608,
-0.0040913369,
0.0168297049,
0.0002725131,
-0.0143002793,
0.014345292,
0.0136640724,
0.0090043638,
-0.0010328393,
0.0270594601,
0.0412713774,
0.0747860447,
-0.0100971451,
-0.0076596276,
0.003899087,
0.004282603,
-0.0833548307,
-0.0785882398,
0.000105362,
0.0385804772,
0.0343063585,
-0.0009123764,
0.0346612073,
-0.0342806876,
-0.0043840092,
-0.0130225671,
-0.0115934825,
0.0082708132,
-0.0022173247,
0.0591014437,
0.0224141181,
-0.0185371079,
-0.0143205225,
0.0895006731,
0.026273977,
0.0737489611,
-0.0033256484,
-0.0209086053,
-0.0511654578,
-0.0217001457,
0.0095389411,
-0.0100631276,
-0.0234868731,
0.0731129944,
-0.0528129563,
-0.1125509515,
-0.026312748,
0.0401752032,
0.0007754355,
-0.0494753197,
-0.0042322488,
0.0650379434,
-0.0047120196,
-0.0231094044,
-0.0383397378,
0.0225771125,
-0.0151065085,
0.0129812006,
-0.0021863619,
-6.622544889e-33,
-0.0476426035,
-0.0600900836,
0.016556412,
-0.0197662786,
0.0128949024,
-0.020221347,
-0.0577966496,
0.0468627475,
-0.0399027579,
0.0028492077,
-0.0395128764,
0.033296261,
0.0074769156,
0.0024026784,
0.0641427413,
-0.0215596315,
0.0271667484,
-0.0310538337,
-0.0242002588,
0.0037503084,
0.0462911241,
0.0185081847,
0.0574364252,
-0.0426883623,
0.0329654478,
0.0016196977,
-0.0039004076,
0.0655493513,
-0.0342004709,
0.0563452579,
-0.0653062239,
0.0314846486,
0.0329040512,
-0.0340875275,
-0.0218807757,
-0.0000141723,
-0.0414874479,
-0.0681195483,
0.0269946959,
0.0036795039,
-0.0354707167,
-0.0172429346,
0.0382891372,
-0.0132291112,
-0.0025515296,
0.0159745365,
0.0379843153,
-0.0235967301,
0.0447782949,
0.020543173,
-0.0320492126,
0.0089841541,
-0.0251039695,
-0.0377397463,
0.0178668816,
0.0161568727,
0.0009480798,
-0.0223433897,
-0.041254364,
0.0002994821,
0.0115086306,
0.0460397713,
0.092249386,
-0.0047402419,
0.0066043641,
0.0320142917,
0.0081371898,
-0.0066364463,
-0.0155237811,
-0.0400422215,
0.0128341066,
0.0318064578,
0.0189825781,
0.0417591594,
0.0328982323,
-0.0014404964,
-0.0209663082,
0.0141261723,
-0.0018503307,
0.0262197256,
0.0230089501,
0.0066294973,
-0.0179149359,
-0.0041774339,
-0.0474631637,
-0.0285797231,
-0.0456648506,
-0.0165032391,
0.0436874554,
0.0122869899,
-0.0055753007,
-0.0149690043,
0.0123776142,
-0.0412563756,
-0.0142913079,
-0.0023119343,
-0.010581865,
0.0400627591,
0.0379532762,
0.035501726,
-0.0613747984,
0.0065663098,
-0.0260353088,
0.0261973795,
0.0017107129,
0.000451662,
0.0214450117,
0.0126969591,
-0.0858920142,
0.0046142973,
-0.0439164825,
0.0414815061,
-0.0169589929,
-0.0248671509,
0.0267979056,
0.0058477204,
-0.0359157063,
0.0194833651,
0.0018532199,
-0.0344146974,
-0.0467334427,
0.0335528329,
-0.0010720674,
0.0057019214,
-0.0254690722,
-0.0383168794,
-0.0280574597,
0.023502361,
0.0225032698,
-0.0376839377,
0.0103368638,
0.0199692957,
2.643e-7,
0.0451779701,
0.0458009988,
0.0037374087,
0.0116296411,
0.0409440435,
0.0582179427,
-0.0516572334,
-0.0053148433,
0.0175072551,
-0.0531989746,
-0.0211175028,
0.0393062718,
0.0525983013,
0.0331232734,
-0.0461479574,
-0.0002103642,
-0.0330756642,
0.0168986451,
-0.0265061837,
-0.011327181,
0.0461668298,
0.0569005348,
0.0125993146,
-0.0124343112,
-0.0277722385,
-0.0472351201,
0.0507564433,
-0.0247660242,
0.0269377455,
0.016588347,
0.0403046533,
0.07034944,
0.0143654514,
0.0267857164,
-0.0005016327,
0.01651158,
-0.031224845,
0.0401611365,
0.0215071421,
-0.0216772668,
-0.0150946183,
0.0186883938,
0.0146696642,
-0.090009585,
0.0699601248,
-0.0808192566,
-0.0419986472,
0.0080807675,
0.0681402162,
-0.0386633538,
0.0364956483,
-0.0175755564,
-0.0310768634,
0.0029823044,
0.0063432218,
-0.0200627744,
-0.0017697945,
-0.0666330084,
-0.0050685038,
-0.0072775581,
-0.0389124863,
-0.0230974909,
-0.0627775863,
0.0234772246,
0.0212515853,
-0.0659009814,
0.0071227946,
1.856739704e-34,
0.0103239017,
0.0080090426,
-0.0050330046,
0.0023848074,
0.020227395,
-0.0066741458,
-0.0115246428,
0.0106883459,
0.0038238105,
-0.0562878251,
-0.0030588398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18152v1 | Extrinsic Factors Affecting the Accuracy of Biomedical NER | 2023-05-29T15:29:49 | 2023-05-29T15:29:49 | Zhiyi Li, Shengjie Zhang, Yujie Song, Jungyeul Park | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical named entity recognition (NER) is a critial task that aims to
identify structured information in clinical text, which is often replete with
complex, technical terms and a high degree of variability. Accurate and
reliable NER can facilitate the extraction and analysis of important biomedical
information, which can be used to improve downstream applications including the
healthcare system. However, NER in the biomedical domain is challenging due to
limited data availability, as the high expertise, time, and expenses are
required to annotate its data. In this paper, by using the limited data, we
explore various extrinsic factors including the corpus annotation scheme, data
augmentation techniques, semi-supervised learning and Brill transformation, to
improve the performance of a NER model on a clinical text dataset (i2b2 2012,
\citet{sun-rumshisky-uzuner:2013}). Our experiments demonstrate that these
approaches can significantly improve the model's F1 score from original 73.74
to 77.55. Our findings suggest that considering different extrinsic factors and
combining these techniques is a promising approach for improving NER
performance in the biomedical domain where the size of data is limited. | [
0.0371237546,
-0.0046690674,
0.0292516276,
-0.0111847594,
-0.0040903697,
0.0573041178,
-0.024860682,
0.0263105761,
0.0024375641,
-0.0087191416,
-0.0581729151,
-0.0373104028,
0.0032901254,
0.0445879363,
0.0213786215,
-0.0034441957,
0.0338711254,
0.0202099495,
0.0427927934,
0.0291929748,
-0.0251295175,
-0.0185741931,
-0.0346823335,
0.0145985624,
0.0233376883,
0.0350821167,
0.0020117837,
-0.0067841839,
0.0468022451,
-0.0829894394,
0.0035340122,
0.0152689796,
-0.0714095309,
-0.0016167177,
0.0000021636,
-0.0684800744,
-0.0655559525,
0.0632962584,
-0.0579358414,
-0.0306465756,
0.0430868715,
-0.0570445731,
-0.0085944654,
-0.0098558515,
-0.0074133165,
-0.0172074139,
0.0197070427,
0.083597064,
0.0180879105,
0.0802286342,
-0.0115060741,
0.0323275514,
0.030387884,
-0.001226522,
0.0025605655,
-0.01651025,
0.0521731377,
-0.0215620119,
0.0367894396,
0.0070862724,
-0.0055992012,
0.0141843157,
-0.0146308886,
0.0426606014,
0.0597148687,
0.0648004636,
-0.0481932871,
0.0109731341,
0.0138562331,
0.0402241275,
-0.0172778554,
0.008070807,
0.0582126975,
-0.0193058345,
-0.0460903943,
-0.0087857777,
-0.0126937553,
-0.0357437208,
-0.0527436733,
-0.003151559,
0.0259019751,
-0.0184609722,
0.0271489657,
-0.0299144108,
-0.006523448,
-0.0001956835,
0.0015232139,
-0.039106641,
-0.0045733023,
-0.0004407197,
-0.0023820575,
-0.0106445728,
0.0549817942,
0.0354572758,
0.0034575926,
0.0127065964,
-0.0202276539,
-0.0200895946,
0.0510579832,
-0.0690586343,
0.0018656014,
-0.013521675,
-0.0087117748,
0.0283422414,
-0.0562918261,
-0.0453316048,
-0.0234035607,
0.0436605811,
-0.0092919394,
-0.0066472329,
-0.0441533439,
0.0207720324,
-0.014281461,
0.0685237944,
-0.0209462512,
-0.0184801649,
-0.0753929317,
-0.0255628489,
0.0086649917,
0.0155177405,
0.0328693613,
-0.0045804586,
-0.0075553572,
0.0160990749,
-0.0022282784,
-0.0062387697,
0.021868296,
-0.0183444433,
-0.0527713187,
-0.0442933477,
0.0068204156,
-0.0249943584,
0.0398969837,
-0.0620339438,
0.0344443284,
0.0657729506,
0.0299177058,
-0.0968038142,
-0.0528679416,
0.0127674183,
-0.0138775697,
-0.010153926,
-0.0060565812,
-0.0178760421,
0.0142880855,
0.0037803703,
-0.007264819,
-0.0131282359,
0.0212572571,
-0.0315390714,
-0.0128078833,
0.0908005014,
-0.0823469236,
-0.043351721,
0.0196648333,
0.0052056629,
0.0267949607,
0.0206077024,
0.0360848792,
-0.0607983917,
-0.0040929145,
0.0003772799,
-0.0072285952,
0.0048178262,
0.0236208197,
-0.078985773,
0.0070120017,
0.0165578052,
0.0021860418,
0.0386379883,
0.0139237903,
0.0414050855,
0.0059302053,
-0.0399732552,
0.0040413989,
0.0198632292,
0.0232689232,
-0.0173101444,
-0.0311722998,
-0.0212848,
-0.0139142377,
-0.0206613168,
0.0077693048,
0.0055939672,
-0.0022508113,
0.0210757796,
0.0282316674,
0.0274149179,
-0.0063470444,
-0.0179551523,
-0.0292572826,
-0.016902335,
-0.0038149597,
-0.0192305651,
0.0702396259,
-0.0182123259,
-0.0296206549,
0.0666036457,
0.0452468507,
-0.0096673174,
0.021036163,
-0.0275572781,
-0.0152553525,
0.0125113195,
0.0239417478,
-0.0709492713,
-0.0658565909,
-0.0386239998,
-0.0597817786,
0.0079810508,
-0.0378667451,
-0.0015015365,
0.0453540422,
-0.026314659,
0.0046889256,
0.0175289419,
0.0222773217,
-0.0224356223,
-0.0112327579,
0.0351790413,
-0.018108394,
-0.0305466112,
-0.0384851843,
0.0386732742,
-0.0736813992,
-0.0336709432,
-0.0009393323,
0.0081062494,
0.0497075766,
0.0167418607,
-0.029136667,
0.0100403596,
0.0246921107,
-0.0546361431,
-0.0525764078,
-0.0360932276,
0.0098531134,
-0.0654646307,
0.0144943371,
-0.0211704206,
0.0109971929,
-0.0467110313,
-0.0284858104,
-0.0236187149,
-0.0509624332,
-0.0239279829,
0.025510136,
-0.0036470669,
0.0442232005,
0.037568301,
0.0020255835,
-0.0334251523,
0.0105169164,
-0.0412094817,
0.0366933495,
-0.0200937018,
-0.0654455647,
0.0276369285,
-0.0351894423,
-0.0207580943,
0.0282094982,
-0.0275567416,
-0.0369675905,
-0.0201451071,
-0.0342268981,
-0.0279642381,
-0.0202802457,
-0.0813355148,
0.0112612518,
0.0210721195,
0.0457846485,
0.0412528813,
0.0284834914,
-0.0146656362,
-0.0230417568,
-0.0142786866,
-0.0473028868,
-0.0146460235,
-0.0065777018,
0.0552873909,
0.0400917158,
0.0020198298,
0.0011263476,
0.0293406434,
-0.0428838432,
0.0047658565,
0.011532167,
-0.0603550896,
-0.023551885,
0.0383288972,
-0.0239635799,
-0.0101333484,
-0.0065381005,
0.0342686474,
-0.0111791082,
0.0334023535,
-0.0177440625,
0.0370878205,
-0.0007902666,
0.0087898094,
0.0057186456,
0.0169563349,
-0.0068242168,
0.0247566495,
-0.0344146341,
0.0188699421,
-0.0061108209,
-0.0825575516,
0.0443259142,
0.0603362136,
-0.015089252,
0.0014812562,
-0.0073065371,
-0.0118122883,
-0.0362921469,
0.0223110709,
-0.0279323328,
0.0264911484,
-0.0386995189,
0.0109306183,
-0.010233446,
-0.0200776476,
0.0809556469,
-0.0243051853,
0.0197270047,
-0.0706185997,
-0.0180678312,
-0.0604439266,
-0.0152070131,
0.0296061374,
0.0064026853,
0.0379601456,
-0.0495223105,
0.0437970571,
0.0628393739,
0.0092707425,
-0.0488647446,
0.0518112481,
0.038584549,
0.0412442014,
-0.0140310638,
-0.0340778492,
-0.0350301042,
0.0139711676,
0.0094586136,
0.0101620164,
0.0243868195,
0.0000487572,
-0.0174547601,
0.0647350401,
-0.0320358388,
0.0942700058,
0.0027539756,
-0.0055346163,
-0.0114135956,
0.0162884463,
0.0256031249,
-0.0069978028,
0.0195044354,
0.0043486496,
-0.0137940645,
0.0409194492,
-0.0505464412,
-0.0107614733,
0.0114401411,
-0.0108675277,
-0.022342395,
-0.0672814324,
0.0041342448,
-0.000953007,
0.0767817497,
-0.0098790303,
-0.0186464731,
0.0993623585,
0.0315844268,
-0.0285875797,
0.0122751901,
-0.0143208867,
-0.0300801918,
-0.003170161,
0.0087632844,
-0.0579366758,
-0.0087278299,
0.0003437393,
0.0263287593,
-0.0279541239,
-0.0963980258,
0.0297091566,
-0.0719672367,
0.0169187058,
-0.0196715649,
-0.0613447651,
0.0242664181,
-0.1047313586,
-0.0038553344,
-0.0545083657,
-0.0247311648,
-0.0346566141,
-0.0149215376,
-0.0176854692,
0.0251626298,
-0.0286727399,
-0.0921574831,
-0.0101443371,
-0.0363861918,
0.0398373269,
-0.0132879913,
0.0320628211,
-0.0227899253,
0.0331990905,
0.014740712,
0.0083617633,
-0.0252994392,
-0.0254293978,
0.1056544185,
0.0049200002,
-0.0166755989,
-0.0179238543,
0.0162209664,
-0.0133053791,
-0.0283166636,
-0.0182438549,
0.0570596047,
-0.0192251112,
0.0279171616,
-0.0401389226,
-0.046143461,
0.0164754353,
0.0373434685,
-0.0062207156,
-0.0166946221,
-0.0014298933,
0.0660852268,
0.0234688967,
0.0063126353,
0.0091262329,
0.037292134,
-0.0691469908,
-0.0417493097,
-0.0544962659,
-0.0246235766,
0.0241753925,
0.0124205342,
0.0256075505,
0.0400822274,
0.0438560881,
-0.0065595754,
-0.067901291,
0.051565025,
0.0266025495,
-0.0067775059,
-0.0618551001,
-0.0508983023,
0.0163879041,
0.0235964935,
-0.0247248523,
-0.0251899119,
-0.008352736,
-0.0111924037,
-0.0294639748,
0.0301679391,
0.0069310153,
0.0009297905,
0.0097365342,
0.0106877591,
0.0558008775,
0.0695261508,
-0.0330243781,
-0.0352374054,
-0.0326468125,
-0.0179824848,
-0.0333619975,
0.0022509021,
0.0104812142,
0.0542307906,
0.0323027708,
0.0525164492,
0.0003022738,
-0.0021949094,
0.039291393,
0.0705891699,
0.0707741678,
-0.0208493229,
-0.0179529637,
-0.0482354872,
0.0219987892,
0.0262183957,
0.0768395215,
-0.0072549973,
-0.0069342488,
0.0391573459,
0.0202119388,
-0.0317692757,
0.0432025231,
-0.0455109552,
-0.0188721213,
-0.0308128279,
0.046136301,
0.0357439667,
0.0210699737,
0.0401974395,
-0.0097924601,
0.0211608391,
0.0214417614,
0.0618115626,
0.0297810584,
-0.0035266443,
0.037540473,
-0.0020021459,
0.0793917552,
-0.0243774448,
0.0561224781,
-0.0380275436,
0.0484475046,
-0.0508912615,
0.0441969,
0.0074668312,
0.0077516446,
0.0495091826,
-0.0062013208,
0.0022315397,
-0.0146830585,
0.0443555303,
-0.0499903597,
0.0155851757,
0.0332498811,
0.0109788291,
-0.0285793282,
-0.0214461759,
0.0417510532,
0.0047725579,
0.0404722393,
0.0184500571,
-0.0356678218,
-0.0438635163,
-0.0045143859,
0.0391237698,
-0.0352808237,
-0.059417937,
0.0189878438,
-0.027966205,
-0.0312249381,
0.075448662,
-0.0202976633,
-0.0091833007,
-0.0190305486,
0.0272647608,
-0.0132786511,
0.0008406388,
-0.0114558134,
-0.0356263891,
0.0173177682,
-0.0051376768,
-0.0061087278,
0.0368021987,
-6.165644929e-33,
-0.004275755,
-0.0311061293,
0.0077903261,
-0.0363500044,
0.004132987,
0.0586073957,
-0.0153996386,
0.0034864864,
0.0409123376,
-0.0158332642,
-0.023502931,
-0.0279102959,
0.0151450727,
0.0250044446,
0.0058278134,
-0.0512276404,
0.0287704822,
0.0555855073,
-0.0344058275,
-0.0040786322,
0.0225205515,
0.0887627378,
0.0796599537,
-0.0927165002,
0.0121213617,
0.0408483073,
0.0260510221,
-0.0192485116,
0.0536198802,
0.0679396242,
-0.052619271,
-0.0115947397,
0.0270435382,
-0.0474955849,
-0.0071817338,
-0.0417148694,
-0.1058278307,
0.01871562,
-0.0191513691,
0.0213529076,
-0.0100853406,
-0.0228640139,
0.0340305455,
-0.0088017685,
-0.0410184488,
0.0102039333,
0.0345551111,
-0.0246244855,
-0.0327776968,
-0.0356983654,
-0.0804599449,
0.0640322194,
0.0158499312,
0.0403035097,
0.0214300044,
-0.0107713528,
-0.0343568027,
0.0245987102,
-0.0589628033,
-0.0656759068,
0.0708971992,
0.0073880032,
-0.0108080423,
-0.0088989018,
-0.0161917582,
0.0531555787,
0.0405557752,
-0.0011050761,
-0.0251446534,
0.0065291338,
-0.0235854071,
0.0246346332,
0.0128933135,
0.030358728,
0.0755360797,
-0.0217116307,
-0.0870181918,
0.0533605963,
-0.040886797,
0.0179389622,
0.0103552444,
-0.0221419446,
-0.0261579938,
0.0178522523,
-0.0126026468,
-0.0162464846,
-0.0085767088,
-0.0111055784,
0.025668947,
0.0013896485,
-0.0283924453,
0.0408737697,
0.0170707535,
-0.0105549153,
-0.0605739392,
-0.047883939,
0.0621571578,
0.034571249,
-0.0292900186,
-0.0051962677,
-0.0533862822,
-0.0415626541,
0.0125442138,
-0.0188747142,
0.0596157536,
-0.035606917,
0.0446587391,
-0.0232690889,
-0.0368140601,
-0.0118084978,
0.0174868573,
0.0148834484,
-0.0225306228,
0.0711115301,
0.0325657092,
-0.0037666301,
0.0066043912,
0.0623964816,
0.0301823728,
0.0039766049,
-0.0084276367,
0.0016684848,
0.054185614,
0.0078136874,
-0.003528605,
-0.0014118389,
-0.0128387148,
0.0365694351,
0.0054267235,
-0.0836718678,
0.0110579887,
-0.0051383972,
2.957e-7,
0.0884454101,
0.0298914723,
0.0180273168,
-0.0609987564,
-0.0002954019,
-0.0163698308,
-0.0349564329,
0.0248399451,
-0.0413759723,
0.0012821051,
0.0518735014,
-0.0258815642,
0.0119450483,
0.0077970871,
-0.0886460319,
-0.0849720687,
-0.0667564422,
-0.0278672911,
-0.0171539821,
0.0165027082,
0.0156370793,
0.0689347461,
-0.0313552581,
-0.0329307094,
0.0207175948,
-0.0246680584,
0.031897217,
-0.0289800446,
0.0200528186,
0.0651947185,
0.0005270142,
0.0259746779,
-0.0025590293,
0.0415580794,
-0.0112072593,
0.0197316483,
-0.0084770937,
0.0980949998,
-0.0451284312,
0.0241034124,
0.028928332,
0.0198066011,
0.0315134786,
-0.0145693729,
0.0536753722,
-0.0443774611,
-0.0460858457,
0.0035682798,
-0.023735974,
0.0310612023,
0.0804043487,
0.004096753,
-0.0030473794,
0.044599399,
0.0522554703,
-0.0242280234,
-0.0106600765,
-0.0634435266,
0.0266826749,
0.0782703236,
-0.0178538896,
-0.008377376,
0.0266973674,
0.0091383224,
0.0157225318,
-0.0557928942,
0.0086494097,
2.761069319e-34,
0.0088319555,
-0.0175892804,
-0.016190609,
0.0568180643,
-0.0039061701,
-0.0192529373,
-0.0366191827,
-0.0156808961,
-0.0264209732,
-0.0361831598,
0.0150151206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18149v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18149v4 | Multiscale Positive-Unlabeled Detection of AI-Generated Texts | 2023-05-29T15:25:00 | 2024-03-05T08:27:12 | Yuchuan Tian, Hanting Chen, Xutao Wang, Zheyuan Bai, Qinghua Zhang, Ruifeng Li, Chao Xu, Yunhe Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent releases of Large Language Models (LLMs), e.g. ChatGPT, are
astonishing at generating human-like texts, but they may impact the
authenticity of texts. Previous works proposed methods to detect these
AI-generated texts, including simple ML classifiers, pretrained-model-based
zero-shot methods, and finetuned language classification models. However,
mainstream detectors always fail on short texts, like SMSes, Tweets, and
reviews. In this paper, a Multiscale Positive-Unlabeled (MPU) training
framework is proposed to address the difficulty of short-text detection without
sacrificing long-texts. Firstly, we acknowledge the human-resemblance property
of short machine texts, and rephrase AI text detection as a partial
Positive-Unlabeled (PU) problem by regarding these short machine texts as
partially ``unlabeled". Then in this PU context, we propose the
length-sensitive Multiscale PU Loss, where a recurrent model in abstraction is
used to estimate positive priors of scale-variant corpora. Additionally, we
introduce a Text Multiscaling module to enrich training corpora. Experiments
show that our MPU method augments detection performance on long AI-generated
texts, and significantly improves short-text detection of language model
detectors. Language Models trained with MPU could outcompete existing detectors
on various short-text and long-text detection benchmarks. The codes are
available at
https://github.com/mindspore-lab/mindone/tree/master/examples/detect_chatgpt
and https://github.com/YuchuanTian/AIGC_text_detector. | [
0.0372237265,
0.0293636937,
0.0000464042,
0.0868104398,
-0.0182436295,
0.026867466,
0.0392312929,
0.0339313224,
0.0197945777,
-0.0352937356,
-0.0441808514,
-0.0535878837,
0.0029202423,
0.0628816113,
0.0348580033,
0.0039120866,
0.0155170104,
0.0083264308,
0.0303137638,
0.0109347776,
0.0362066031,
0.010063014,
0.0016640951,
0.0115455016,
-0.0184720997,
0.0103001241,
0.0037142274,
0.02482979,
0.0079315985,
-0.046732571,
0.0110892225,
0.0212310627,
-0.0263090115,
0.1059608832,
0.000001881,
-0.0349576399,
-0.0289203003,
-0.0167614073,
0.0020789853,
-0.0205935836,
0.1023379639,
-0.0417736992,
-0.0205721091,
0.0182023458,
-0.0007133214,
0.027514996,
0.0468136966,
0.0966577232,
0.0218890049,
0.0845088065,
-0.0313268937,
-0.0176636949,
0.0345884077,
-0.0293744393,
-0.0169817079,
-0.0289963484,
0.0318222791,
-0.0340706743,
0.0006207559,
0.0486874878,
0.0157399382,
0.0247122981,
0.0110847959,
-0.0048640822,
-0.0225452837,
0.0235040989,
-0.0096648447,
-0.0027415568,
0.0164232329,
0.0651242509,
-0.0461143851,
-0.0673522279,
0.0334343538,
-0.0219512153,
0.0023906154,
-0.0417951383,
-0.0010813888,
0.0199876707,
-0.0105240559,
0.0376831852,
-0.0152571956,
-0.0079636285,
0.0315076821,
0.0337377116,
0.0062779211,
0.0086293304,
0.0077553755,
-0.056521453,
-0.0175933521,
0.0001624885,
-0.0096949441,
-0.0257233176,
0.0764125064,
0.0208851658,
0.0456262715,
-0.0292720385,
-0.04327235,
-0.0676874965,
0.0191657897,
-0.0871113539,
-0.0075852405,
-0.0179811697,
-0.0027109745,
0.0310800485,
-0.063761726,
0.0496646352,
-0.0366105698,
0.0268046781,
-0.0272566844,
0.0001023684,
-0.0272159688,
-0.0060605449,
-0.032590434,
0.030304879,
0.0061383005,
-0.0063376497,
-0.0205487125,
-0.0145374443,
-0.0237479433,
-0.0104814535,
-0.0384399518,
-0.0195362251,
-0.0094216932,
-0.0195831712,
0.0169268679,
0.0394323729,
-0.0208720788,
0.0101737566,
-0.0363290943,
-0.034297131,
-0.0379757211,
0.0585913584,
0.0469186679,
0.002927012,
0.0150347492,
0.0582630485,
-0.0262712091,
-0.0634416267,
-0.0420267284,
-0.0396160595,
-0.0380038396,
-0.0426366515,
-0.0107831629,
-0.0588722453,
-0.0140765961,
-0.0486921221,
0.0098130452,
-0.0404361933,
0.0166022219,
0.0342689194,
-0.026069345,
0.0696198344,
-0.0105700959,
-0.0158070195,
0.021674443,
-0.0001939259,
0.023217719,
0.0461543351,
0.0283844881,
0.0715208352,
0.0492893755,
0.0369479954,
0.0576619804,
0.052123215,
0.026200695,
0.0258722994,
-0.0061534387,
-0.0518009961,
-0.0276029184,
0.0016579907,
0.0188279785,
0.0510832071,
0.0073927166,
-0.0528175831,
0.0723409206,
0.0379128978,
-0.032967113,
0.0040962328,
0.0303731244,
0.0560144372,
-0.0298048947,
-0.0025775465,
-0.0137447407,
-0.0360175706,
-0.0632945895,
-0.0141541706,
0.0004146682,
-0.0163667221,
-0.0363305956,
0.0064171082,
0.0016544308,
-0.0675830618,
0.0058664395,
-0.0649123117,
0.066137068,
-0.0000856183,
-0.0438309684,
-0.0147559466,
0.0052469121,
-0.0339682586,
-0.0058557675,
-0.0562705062,
0.0684372932,
0.010568385,
0.0399012454,
-0.0023888589,
0.0240376275,
-0.0474751629,
-0.0088548455,
0.0861610398,
0.0167753138,
-0.0156282932,
0.0028307945,
-0.0282872897,
0.0077312049,
-0.00083998,
0.0037026561,
0.0068932539,
0.018450588,
0.0522968397,
0.0493110679,
-0.0527403615,
-0.050709147,
0.0382008031,
-0.0241350364,
-0.044969961,
0.0252473745,
0.0094764009,
0.0239342041,
0.021105554,
-0.004706481,
0.0013984469,
0.0034639221,
-0.0420472734,
-0.0714423433,
-0.0105570825,
-0.0346450135,
-0.0451303944,
0.0297818724,
-0.015915582,
0.0095228739,
0.0674600154,
-0.0308785643,
-0.0387579054,
0.0243062042,
-0.0140042678,
0.0019412523,
-0.0299410466,
0.0407322533,
-0.0284135696,
0.0466953181,
-0.0097038699,
0.0341994725,
-0.0189567413,
-0.0037362124,
-0.0076125278,
-0.0406359993,
0.0539898686,
-0.0109189656,
-0.0569146425,
0.0189158656,
-0.0058973604,
0.0192117803,
0.0409524851,
0.0194467194,
-0.0238884632,
-0.0261074547,
-0.0839587674,
0.0207199119,
-0.0281000789,
0.0241072904,
0.0345795006,
-0.00763701,
-0.0021059308,
-0.0357179865,
-0.0173096675,
-0.0208718162,
0.0146089438,
0.0213183425,
0.0300489292,
-0.0240105968,
0.0296081267,
-0.012645334,
-0.0010996092,
-0.0386095978,
0.0525265783,
0.0059838546,
-0.0744132474,
-0.0472439304,
0.0274251904,
0.0058830469,
0.0257923156,
0.0080489507,
-0.0598841161,
-0.0272908807,
0.0004207322,
0.020792868,
0.0650460199,
0.0360282622,
-0.0102501055,
-0.006034791,
0.0695887357,
-0.0049175615,
-0.0090681938,
-0.0132605731,
0.0119576082,
-0.00978682,
-0.0325097442,
0.0312946327,
0.0932162255,
-0.0414243303,
0.0204413738,
-0.0226911325,
0.0002185824,
-0.0104858745,
-0.0421640463,
0.0182611793,
0.0084975464,
-0.0146318804,
-0.0052270526,
-0.0266836118,
-0.053061381,
0.0429931171,
-0.0542300157,
-0.0010241218,
-0.0208709389,
-0.033105094,
-0.0059413216,
0.0552110299,
0.0384287909,
0.0224299189,
0.0054460354,
0.0017784951,
0.0021359802,
-0.0010915176,
0.01931585,
-0.0112752328,
-0.0017375014,
-0.0138789229,
0.0097779753,
-0.023979675,
-0.0395806096,
-0.0399559885,
-0.0454189628,
-0.0132176029,
-0.0288756266,
-0.0165295247,
-0.0322924927,
-0.0576991215,
0.03932954,
0.0172293913,
0.0544190817,
-0.0429596417,
0.0157465972,
-0.0109603638,
0.0979083106,
0.0476215594,
-0.0323579051,
0.0336849988,
-0.0416096449,
0.016569335,
0.0527198017,
0.0000064167,
0.0151969194,
0.0054937326,
-0.0440051854,
0.0141912764,
-0.0075256522,
-0.0091063241,
0.0021909259,
0.0593767017,
-0.0209975448,
-0.0347770751,
0.1243190616,
0.0138969244,
-0.0587981939,
-0.005052682,
-0.0044352296,
0.0335754342,
0.0127361901,
-0.0286475196,
-0.0623026937,
-0.0415427499,
0.0073146271,
0.0005627545,
-0.0129332654,
-0.02247479,
-0.0286642872,
-0.1224186942,
-0.0347175375,
0.0152760921,
-0.0329701006,
-0.0438064262,
-0.0060204384,
0.0076072868,
-0.0004570037,
-0.0319359861,
0.002801209,
0.0001368376,
-0.0012453917,
0.0164919905,
-0.0398352072,
-0.0461777784,
-0.012168929,
-0.0387394503,
0.0395609066,
0.0202450715,
0.0444207862,
-0.0257410593,
-0.0236081462,
0.0301990993,
-0.0111284675,
-0.0427311435,
-0.0022425535,
0.0704370961,
-0.0320002325,
0.0027081871,
0.0124507872,
0.0545016602,
-0.0364656486,
0.0032143528,
0.0297051463,
0.0507795699,
0.014104885,
-0.0699380487,
-0.0123388181,
-0.0238286927,
0.0257121585,
0.0734409243,
0.0155287068,
-0.0445336439,
-0.0540461913,
0.0152648892,
0.0145790922,
-0.0287630688,
-0.0316311531,
0.0002892634,
-0.0111780688,
-0.0533221625,
-0.0782958046,
-0.0366801396,
-0.031832289,
0.0368911885,
-0.0082640117,
-0.0243692864,
0.0180951096,
-0.0087873274,
-0.0457125641,
-0.0134469932,
-0.0815478787,
0.0364572108,
-0.0504424162,
0.0188525096,
0.0457265824,
-0.0258115809,
0.0032534704,
0.017752504,
-0.1322107762,
-0.0326683335,
-0.0347987898,
-0.0123036793,
0.014115423,
0.0305165574,
-0.0435731225,
-0.0421423055,
0.0700053349,
0.0301819984,
-0.0299072023,
0.0050357524,
0.0449741483,
-0.0092310626,
-0.0118014663,
0.0459977947,
-0.0074287928,
0.0555126034,
0.0268784184,
-0.0277767275,
-0.029880438,
-0.0135152703,
-0.0086805094,
0.0238588862,
0.0326708741,
0.0006152138,
0.0069422633,
-0.0363585092,
-0.0133737251,
0.0093164034,
-0.0099644046,
-0.0329434909,
0.0190947112,
0.0329123475,
0.0036074417,
-0.0280865673,
-0.0025109462,
-0.0077585056,
0.0373351499,
-0.0151452972,
-0.0092969807,
0.0170370061,
0.0478285067,
-0.0064401431,
-0.0132980589,
0.0019661174,
0.0344168916,
0.0072775413,
0.0309442729,
-0.0152031938,
0.0550975055,
0.0116287135,
-0.0115992045,
-0.0022840337,
0.0422236659,
-0.027031824,
0.0332360081,
-0.0623518974,
0.0461572222,
0.0390915275,
-0.0233455934,
0.0474438332,
-0.0053489655,
-0.0029011855,
-0.039902322,
0.0181021988,
-0.0158648212,
-0.023566667,
0.0043363213,
-0.0038268692,
-0.0435336307,
0.0413869135,
0.0958506837,
0.0081950566,
0.0302047357,
0.0315276161,
-0.0271524731,
-0.0268489588,
-0.0066590169,
0.0015775351,
0.0300329402,
0.011324333,
0.0171906557,
-0.0182686877,
-0.0592154413,
0.0192411058,
-0.048927065,
0.0228748303,
0.0291686971,
0.0136602595,
0.0415697098,
-0.0265094396,
0.0300408695,
-0.0473279841,
-0.0161766857,
0.0226406939,
-0.0215401258,
-0.0196165871,
-5.596858477e-33,
0.0304328967,
-0.042334348,
-0.0393266231,
-0.0036802532,
-0.0143447546,
0.0196976513,
-0.0107030338,
-0.0049115657,
-0.016700644,
0.0265910253,
0.0023314336,
0.0180677045,
0.0069220765,
0.037649259,
-0.0385033004,
-0.0146272769,
0.0744616017,
0.004268555,
-0.0206421148,
0.0487068184,
0.0298287086,
-0.0028701609,
0.0534147024,
-0.0745006204,
-0.0127053717,
-0.0379699953,
-0.0253127348,
0.0060053044,
0.0385110751,
0.044637192,
-0.042704884,
0.0358288512,
0.0607425198,
0.0047475207,
-0.0203302838,
0.0319440104,
-0.0307650454,
-0.004969676,
-0.0502872653,
0.0113318898,
-0.0171148833,
-0.0388097018,
0.0611138195,
-0.035137821,
-0.0019594647,
0.0452802405,
0.0507149324,
-0.0302684903,
0.0245746616,
-0.0398211144,
-0.0685353875,
0.0524165966,
-0.0008878098,
-0.0191954467,
0.0494217239,
0.0258072726,
0.022562338,
0.0409772247,
-0.0468861945,
-0.004358537,
0.0153060518,
0.0144457808,
0.0315359198,
0.0132131772,
-0.0332069807,
0.0337151028,
0.0233320054,
0.0376217067,
-0.0085440883,
-0.0372005589,
0.0265842509,
-0.020716371,
0.0595579334,
0.0770800039,
0.0308631528,
-0.0701155216,
-0.0390978381,
0.0318122469,
0.0157078076,
0.0018829188,
0.0227193516,
0.0035098132,
-0.0401777141,
-0.0028489339,
-0.0014421671,
-0.0737065896,
-0.0348706581,
-0.0024564161,
0.0184907839,
0.0183875896,
-0.0326028243,
0.0403421782,
0.0340604931,
-0.0434224531,
-0.0204786491,
0.0266654231,
-0.0414220914,
0.0215520058,
0.019394299,
0.0187146496,
-0.0496162176,
-0.038724456,
0.0351970978,
0.0135030188,
0.0014632427,
-0.0216388144,
0.0853573456,
0.0047183759,
-0.104344897,
-0.0033821687,
-0.0196559038,
0.0063215932,
0.0359427556,
0.043285951,
0.0115286848,
-0.0230153911,
-0.0077640545,
0.0632191822,
0.0332800187,
-0.0145096947,
-0.0190077107,
-0.0019311606,
-0.0301405247,
-0.0027822123,
-0.0550182611,
-0.0196307264,
-0.0324234925,
0.0202191342,
0.0421525687,
-0.0924263224,
0.013072934,
-0.0244828556,
2.523e-7,
-0.0124741243,
0.0182681251,
0.0444960333,
-0.0507316962,
0.0557150915,
0.0883263052,
0.0181794092,
0.0418213494,
-0.0547663793,
0.0197419487,
-0.0015790204,
0.0092194276,
0.0497870781,
0.0057301936,
-0.0744988397,
0.0447053313,
-0.0881229118,
0.0147479447,
-0.0552762598,
-0.0026700331,
0.0566991493,
0.1101560444,
0.0485172383,
-0.0223855376,
0.0130800912,
-0.0854756236,
0.0649913624,
-0.0007912844,
0.0129816793,
0.0181142315,
0.0315323174,
0.0090747857,
0.0035354903,
-0.0033094366,
-0.0114280935,
0.0027738432,
0.0171268769,
0.0725804567,
-0.0032462643,
0.0462644212,
-0.0035597319,
-0.0353465267,
0.0019737459,
-0.0264891088,
0.0741767734,
-0.0294768233,
-0.0359333977,
-0.0870049223,
0.0020320313,
-0.034620408,
0.030213872,
-0.0193307362,
-0.035850741,
0.0533501767,
0.0246458482,
0.004673779,
-0.017745506,
-0.0646812469,
0.0092879767,
-0.0155845154,
-0.0172674209,
0.0265968945,
-0.0401157476,
0.0042322767,
0.041860912,
-0.0768765658,
0.0707836449,
2.220950557e-34,
0.0317632705,
-0.0352085009,
-0.0473853797,
0.0025368771,
0.0258017387,
-0.0115514686,
-0.0147292083,
-0.0032387082,
-0.0006935375,
-0.0252818819,
0.0253440384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18144v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18144v2 | GripRank: Bridging the Gap between Retrieval and Generation via the Generative Knowledge Improved Passage Ranking | 2023-05-29T15:15:53 | 2023-08-15T17:10:57 | Jiaqi Bai, Hongcheng Guo, Jiaheng Liu, Jian Yang, Xinnian Liang, Zhao Yan, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-enhanced text generation has shown remarkable progress on
knowledge-intensive language tasks, such as open-domain question answering and
knowledge-enhanced dialogue generation, by leveraging passages retrieved from a
large passage corpus for delivering a proper answer given the input query.
However, the retrieved passages are not ideal for guiding answer generation
because of the discrepancy between retrieval and generation, i.e., the
candidate passages are all treated equally during the retrieval procedure
without considering their potential to generate a proper answer. This
discrepancy makes a passage retriever deliver a sub-optimal collection of
candidate passages to generate the answer. In this paper, we propose the
GeneRative Knowledge Improved Passage Ranking (GripRank) approach, addressing
the above challenge by distilling knowledge from a generative passage estimator
(GPE) to a passage ranker, where the GPE is a generative language model used to
measure how likely the candidate passages can generate the proper answer. We
realize the distillation procedure by teaching the passage ranker learning to
rank the passages ordered by the GPE. Furthermore, we improve the distillation
quality by devising a curriculum knowledge distillation mechanism, which allows
the knowledge provided by the GPE can be progressively distilled to the ranker
through an easy-to-hard curriculum, enabling the passage ranker to correctly
recognize the provenance of the answer from many plausible candidates. We
conduct extensive experiments on four datasets across three knowledge-intensive
language tasks. Experimental results show advantages over the state-of-the-art
methods for both passage ranking and answer generation on the KILT benchmark. | [
0.054475531,
0.032418061,
-0.0155303646,
0.0123525728,
-0.0301304255,
-0.0036222662,
0.0030382881,
0.0002519083,
0.0256857686,
-0.0286115501,
0.0397374779,
-0.0389269181,
-0.0037887883,
0.0309364367,
0.0300511606,
-0.0423127189,
0.0154676009,
-0.0130911591,
0.0280211587,
0.0060556815,
0.0054896944,
0.032895565,
-0.0101811942,
0.024755517,
0.0237806104,
-0.0104100509,
-0.0213353075,
-0.0042741238,
0.0481295176,
-0.0099800788,
0.0496311896,
0.0388255306,
0.033897493,
0.01365731,
0.0000020208,
-0.038545832,
-0.0252782237,
0.0017794057,
-0.0189268831,
-0.0335327275,
0.0118133277,
0.0496110804,
0.0518495515,
0.0352747142,
-0.0500431806,
0.037191689,
-0.0086971195,
0.0061547542,
0.0732643157,
0.0593860298,
0.0217924267,
-0.0040140166,
-0.0071608066,
-0.0165057871,
0.0551692434,
-0.0284432322,
-0.0139165753,
0.0279376227,
0.0304434188,
0.0523293316,
-0.0216561239,
0.0261483472,
0.0256589185,
-0.0329971313,
0.039015431,
0.0441664197,
-0.0319346301,
0.0345890485,
0.0071850074,
0.0764250383,
0.0002926904,
-0.0179316644,
0.0226837844,
-0.020857906,
0.0145443501,
0.0372637138,
-0.0385919437,
0.0431021266,
-0.0204719398,
-0.008841251,
-0.0147620412,
0.0246260539,
-0.0174738746,
0.003356626,
-0.0120890485,
0.0445926599,
0.0214129519,
-0.0192327723,
-0.0079861274,
-0.0020263195,
-0.0409029536,
-0.0396189652,
0.0100894775,
0.051978983,
-0.015464887,
0.0129121467,
-0.0306536332,
-0.0391511172,
0.0027422979,
0.0078925295,
-0.0052758763,
0.0420000181,
0.0199340936,
0.0079042679,
-0.0252375379,
0.0598067939,
0.0314531252,
-0.0016160619,
-0.0859721974,
0.0069924458,
-0.0429826789,
-0.0336551368,
-0.0366996638,
0.027988432,
-0.078326501,
-0.0208225846,
-0.0215234421,
-0.0099435709,
0.0378825963,
-0.0193805024,
0.0107867774,
0.0516919345,
-0.0444833525,
0.0062851622,
-0.0565995723,
0.0190468077,
-0.044423148,
-0.0075774728,
0.034394443,
0.0046257987,
-0.0189229101,
0.0033435728,
0.0239780266,
-0.0209789425,
0.0063278978,
-0.0167827327,
-0.0623518154,
0.0087966481,
-0.0356507674,
-0.0514332317,
-0.0118680354,
-0.0497389138,
-0.0185640994,
-0.0695447177,
0.0506526306,
0.0214531999,
-0.0482674986,
-0.0379721709,
0.037576139,
0.0489206202,
-0.0214237869,
0.0075813457,
0.0188424606,
-0.0230233967,
0.0402303077,
0.0366479158,
0.0097205602,
0.0199318826,
0.0421580225,
0.0307430197,
0.0262987018,
0.0359296724,
0.019096408,
-0.0137058785,
0.0231890492,
-0.0075109103,
0.046206668,
0.0146457301,
0.0007331243,
0.0247925445,
0.017511487,
0.0449291952,
-0.0319573767,
0.0033464094,
0.050753586,
0.0290266313,
0.0058737155,
0.0085162017,
0.0460083149,
0.0264916942,
-0.0133502865,
0.0332423337,
0.0093893409,
0.0271806791,
0.0184286162,
0.0181804784,
0.0487624481,
0.0473017804,
0.0010890756,
-0.0521042198,
0.0271696057,
0.0220947787,
-0.0192893576,
0.0233185831,
-0.0034610014,
0.0371691324,
-0.0471044667,
0.0321602374,
0.016572468,
-0.0736439228,
0.0412067585,
-0.0165232066,
0.0295416992,
0.0522215478,
0.0618537627,
-0.010222652,
-0.043212153,
-0.0086356001,
-0.01879609,
0.0352443419,
-0.001137976,
-0.0249500852,
0.0014967852,
-0.054714255,
-0.0247233156,
-0.0170547664,
-0.0177376941,
0.0116734738,
0.0248628166,
0.0364816338,
0.0532919168,
-0.0793761984,
-0.0149877826,
0.0322025567,
-0.0116832582,
-0.0355092101,
0.0376164727,
-0.0115305418,
-0.0160148926,
0.0267342292,
-0.0048767193,
0.008635805,
0.0083147585,
-0.0444474332,
-0.0455395803,
0.0063438523,
-0.080237478,
-0.0827361718,
0.0105345137,
-0.0230336823,
0.0195696987,
0.0089289257,
-0.0312203616,
-0.0577481054,
-0.0234319754,
-0.0267882217,
0.0027590273,
-0.0335386693,
-0.011279217,
0.0563907698,
-0.0154176839,
-0.0789460242,
0.1103681475,
0.0073231026,
0.0439089499,
0.0410108268,
0.0584611893,
0.0206915289,
-0.0197120309,
-0.0057634208,
-0.0118830884,
-0.02054145,
0.0108646639,
0.0626974329,
0.0040306179,
-0.0580279008,
-0.0350873023,
-0.0587643124,
0.0317707732,
-0.0251676273,
0.0147674875,
0.030774001,
0.0180671401,
0.0020722146,
0.0088512385,
-0.0828468874,
-0.0043469905,
0.0401092805,
-0.0048086629,
0.0293884184,
0.0201501343,
0.0241852887,
-0.0209765621,
0.0180543456,
0.0118902056,
0.0368126072,
0.0174572263,
0.0550606549,
-0.0497887135,
0.0371611044,
-0.0633355305,
0.0119790668,
-0.014256468,
-0.0181288552,
0.0143425735,
-0.0278241318,
0.0556466058,
0.0153708477,
0.0446838923,
-0.0114242323,
0.0262661856,
-0.0190996919,
-0.0768929496,
0.0442586057,
-0.0361865573,
-0.0201181192,
0.028025087,
-0.0147729097,
-0.0002670876,
0.0181377977,
0.0438776463,
-0.0414028279,
-0.0509423055,
0.0141323199,
-0.0095276861,
-0.0212375652,
-0.0481772833,
0.008731693,
-0.0212825667,
0.0165637359,
-0.0177810919,
-0.0138576366,
0.0456968211,
-0.0187611431,
-0.0107967099,
-0.0744345859,
0.0183451921,
-0.0223733,
0.0550779551,
0.0098727867,
0.0483896583,
0.017485613,
-0.0162620265,
-0.0810179934,
0.0172708128,
0.0203053076,
-0.0572465584,
0.0187580045,
-0.0717096105,
-0.0065900101,
-0.010433699,
-0.0422848016,
-0.0791877955,
-0.0046246108,
0.0658564344,
0.0107947234,
0.0476777777,
-0.0159505177,
0.0063179964,
-0.021155538,
0.0440365076,
0.0424008779,
-0.013430777,
-0.0266463142,
-0.0188279003,
0.0968983918,
0.0738538206,
0.0187878013,
0.0046482882,
-0.0172677115,
0.0064351484,
0.0614718311,
0.0254740771,
-0.0169906486,
0.047650896,
-0.0021797905,
0.0230393168,
-0.0660271645,
0.0059318678,
0.0374356024,
0.0321249664,
-0.0490725152,
-0.0570015982,
0.1057370603,
0.0591825694,
0.0070614368,
-0.0112537015,
-0.0029433081,
0.0628731623,
-0.0047752382,
0.0382485241,
-0.0943674445,
0.0161821619,
-0.0183931924,
0.0630128011,
-0.0126214456,
-0.0449841581,
-0.0330368765,
-0.1261741817,
0.0323885716,
0.0096941907,
-0.0325058848,
-0.0344779976,
0.0019037422,
-0.0285313409,
0.0199108031,
-0.0366795845,
0.0562765077,
0.0069445088,
0.0538183525,
0.0149871595,
0.0128114093,
-0.0054893997,
-0.0101121105,
-0.0281882863,
-0.0026315814,
0.0090524098,
0.0387789197,
0.0346091054,
0.014411442,
-0.0580031648,
-0.0849789008,
0.0020456857,
0.0115610287,
0.0273387618,
-0.0031358798,
0.002096273,
-0.0465893112,
0.0566291437,
-0.0024880574,
-0.0018108173,
0.0208219569,
0.0169613045,
-0.0045304066,
-0.0090484349,
-0.0168976318,
0.0156725459,
0.0269498024,
0.0777896717,
0.0185229462,
-0.0075080805,
-0.0303656198,
-0.0501730479,
0.0537190847,
-0.0672700703,
-0.0412221514,
0.0165910758,
0.0455207229,
0.0540838726,
-0.1326458305,
-0.0457669757,
-0.0066328319,
0.0572170019,
0.0038860075,
0.0393173955,
-0.0276128333,
0.0031075224,
-0.03903348,
-0.0281864852,
-0.0192624535,
-0.0208517145,
-0.021030711,
-0.0532946289,
0.0015718536,
-0.0698006228,
-0.0418351702,
0.0240388606,
-0.0558377057,
-0.0743125379,
-0.0335943252,
0.0458629057,
0.0182984266,
0.0132674966,
-0.0059325402,
0.0008878174,
0.0767083392,
0.0589056946,
-0.0321402736,
-0.0034759929,
-0.0127497045,
0.0272724479,
-0.0094150798,
0.0104347328,
-0.0503967032,
-0.0066377134,
-0.023029672,
0.0719215721,
0.0024061352,
-0.0627240986,
0.0307176989,
0.0169698577,
-0.0277349222,
-0.0192291886,
-0.0105220871,
-0.050013639,
0.0260551423,
-0.0079678372,
-0.0395148024,
-0.0391491577,
0.0238510333,
0.0201320201,
-0.02646509,
-0.0083282376,
0.0175614432,
0.0200034268,
0.0679152459,
-0.0597728752,
-0.0348055661,
0.0220772065,
-0.0171015915,
0.0180722494,
-0.0031935622,
-0.0260248706,
-0.0013172607,
-0.0163036007,
0.0937508568,
-0.0047418606,
0.0770582631,
0.010575477,
-0.0109018646,
0.0237629749,
0.0134627931,
-0.099614583,
-0.0339236706,
-0.0565366484,
0.0103741838,
0.0213495642,
0.0054780194,
0.0533714443,
-0.0164298862,
0.002316694,
-0.0150094088,
0.0168208629,
0.0247756634,
-0.0284148548,
-0.0235901698,
0.0200819392,
0.0072521404,
0.0124297533,
0.1014038175,
-0.0172999278,
0.0215701926,
0.0121937115,
-0.0065711006,
-0.0438318737,
-0.0631627142,
-0.0164602455,
0.0203458797,
0.030313449,
0.0146042658,
-0.0446417704,
-0.0370104052,
0.0030352294,
0.01233395,
0.0162039082,
-0.013842212,
0.0465632901,
0.0309534334,
-0.0411077887,
-0.0343767703,
-0.0884930342,
0.0250499211,
-0.0388512239,
-0.0244473219,
-0.0388472639,
-5.86149348e-33,
-0.0432631485,
-0.0223664418,
0.0102277482,
0.0059372019,
-0.0396316946,
-0.0196249522,
-0.0330877975,
-0.0120046288,
0.0152363088,
0.0051544318,
-0.000880665,
-0.0218974054,
-0.0131556718,
0.0501683615,
-0.01592106,
-0.0064348024,
0.0286000725,
0.0024347885,
-0.0672457293,
0.0765170753,
0.1007095426,
0.0396578684,
-0.0019483638,
-0.0058577242,
0.0004142154,
-0.0703909025,
0.0075750882,
-0.0062046298,
0.0115295518,
0.0317383967,
-0.0105123008,
0.0389861055,
0.0104462896,
-0.0575777516,
-0.0142816808,
0.017887136,
-0.0491795801,
-0.0486525185,
0.0015849189,
-0.0340266451,
-0.0033106767,
-0.0354124196,
0.0063627744,
-0.0337433703,
0.0403467007,
-0.0228750277,
0.0269555952,
-0.0074943299,
-0.0032820755,
-0.0994700119,
-0.0312179718,
0.0017830277,
-0.0392799079,
-0.0574552417,
-0.0334288254,
0.0545727164,
0.0308626518,
-0.0312367417,
-0.0133267036,
0.0161583647,
0.0243706163,
0.0759353861,
0.0150841856,
0.0043882709,
-0.0417357609,
0.051536005,
-0.0505357161,
-0.0401765779,
-0.0057056011,
-0.0063283741,
-0.022045685,
0.0259896759,
0.023723904,
0.0652586371,
0.0189487971,
0.0135712139,
-0.0557255484,
0.0990572646,
0.0250398368,
-0.0089162495,
0.0101177897,
-0.0261138584,
-0.0104452847,
-0.0298539065,
-0.0585224591,
0.0231324621,
-0.0169212837,
-0.0133242439,
0.0642057732,
0.0171522088,
-0.0376978293,
-0.0450127944,
0.0319017544,
-0.0172782298,
0.0131987901,
0.054206904,
-0.0358786955,
0.0077793379,
-0.0036485235,
0.0233764555,
-0.0502674654,
0.0085627129,
0.0703693852,
-0.0051110946,
-0.0367425792,
0.0144175813,
0.0101127392,
0.0072078025,
-0.0424177907,
0.0277520847,
-0.048454389,
0.0529443063,
-0.0164864752,
0.0008378631,
-0.016313972,
0.0090982281,
-0.0170409791,
0.031891752,
-0.0037605336,
0.0165391844,
-0.0248766281,
-0.0094817746,
0.0098301023,
-0.009381948,
-0.0298574548,
0.0316872112,
0.0065788506,
0.0336568542,
-0.0168555919,
-0.0322674885,
-0.0013051577,
0.0229985658,
2.663e-7,
0.0401710011,
0.0005040798,
0.0138772065,
0.0443204455,
0.0031232266,
0.0033330373,
0.0287761502,
0.0402288698,
0.0334788188,
-0.0464995466,
0.0120674418,
0.0156825297,
0.0224140529,
0.0260395277,
-0.0929402709,
-0.0137850717,
-0.0291671976,
-0.0683172196,
-0.0266304966,
-0.0387219377,
0.0976590067,
0.0126744481,
-0.0324196145,
-0.0027895453,
-0.002686348,
-0.0327228494,
0.0564848483,
0.0204785559,
-0.0052767857,
0.0290226471,
0.0601882935,
0.0036578255,
-0.0132610062,
0.0172058865,
-0.0271005258,
0.0244959276,
0.0127665112,
0.034663178,
0.0409372374,
-0.0566816665,
-0.0181064215,
0.0122624142,
0.018752316,
-0.0740959272,
0.0485490821,
-0.0403415933,
0.0255424101,
0.0340640694,
-0.0472008325,
-0.0143487062,
-0.0196263567,
-0.0048299637,
-0.0335783437,
0.0426653735,
0.0032188329,
0.020105822,
0.0208805967,
-0.064316906,
-0.0291791279,
0.0045051337,
-0.037411388,
-0.0498883538,
-0.0242993049,
-0.0274351891,
-0.0478285328,
-0.06082692,
0.004081673,
2.526694801e-34,
0.0039484953,
0.00292464,
0.006439087,
-0.004490674,
0.0419504233,
0.0095622987,
0.017618278,
0.0015940523,
0.0166300982,
-0.0741303489,
-0.0400139317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18507v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18507v2 | Code Prompting: a Neural Symbolic Method for Complex Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T15:14:09 | 2023-10-07T08:07:46 | Yi Hu, Haotong Yang, Zhouchen Lin, Muhan Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have scaled up to unlock a wide range of complex
reasoning tasks with the aid of various prompting methods. However, current
prompting methods generate natural language intermediate steps to help
reasoning, which can cause imperfect task reduction and confusion. To mitigate
such limitations, we explore code prompting, a neural symbolic prompting method
with both zero-shot and few-shot versions which triggers code as intermediate
steps. We conduct experiments on 7 widely-used benchmarks involving symbolic
reasoning and arithmetic reasoning. Code prompting generally outperforms
chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting. To further understand the performance and
limitations of code prompting, we perform extensive ablation studies and error
analyses, and identify several exclusive advantages of using symbolic
promptings compared to natural language. We also consider the ensemble of code
prompting and CoT prompting to combine the strengths of both. Finally, we show
through experiments how code annotations and their locations affect code
prompting. | [
0.0004208017,
0.0649121702,
-0.0212263837,
0.0297352057,
-0.0433362313,
0.049729839,
0.0330612361,
0.0033711635,
-0.0124747278,
-0.0071225092,
-0.0022154895,
-0.0084713474,
0.0237875059,
0.0086170118,
0.0577544793,
-0.0089427149,
0.0536117107,
-0.0657036528,
0.0309986752,
-0.0040307459,
-0.0278630704,
-0.0097050453,
-0.0291586146,
0.0258417241,
-0.0109915137,
-0.0536279902,
-0.0165241137,
-0.0077550998,
0.0068988176,
-0.0479273796,
-0.0333909728,
0.0596486144,
0.0292465053,
0.049199421,
0.0000021311,
-0.0417413302,
0.03123031,
0.0174101964,
-0.0647175238,
0.0236895867,
-0.011207615,
0.0086333044,
0.024765458,
0.0325718373,
-0.0371896625,
-0.0149406726,
0.0539323166,
0.0111078629,
0.0441482216,
0.0541518852,
0.0122312838,
-0.0154205216,
0.0004130578,
-0.0321925431,
0.0325778089,
-0.028650254,
0.0063302401,
0.016697187,
0.0296027549,
0.026734028,
-0.0175209735,
0.0403978638,
0.0912366137,
0.0084671406,
-0.0320195183,
0.0562194511,
-0.0283775721,
-0.0026854977,
-0.0196617823,
0.0590841211,
0.0088597508,
-0.0174749047,
-0.0013185736,
-0.0038143592,
0.0146394242,
-0.0530516393,
-0.0566860661,
0.0577460118,
0.0077547408,
0.0092083616,
0.022228973,
0.0011661185,
0.0258172657,
-0.0023467804,
-0.0197045673,
0.0453431755,
0.010403241,
-0.0369783677,
0.0174733587,
-0.0093335677,
-0.02869674,
-0.0862320289,
0.001659157,
0.0518035144,
-0.0269948654,
0.0064319018,
-0.0118908025,
-0.0282107405,
-0.0080169784,
-0.0097772935,
0.0403196067,
0.0909614787,
-0.01464439,
0.0281883013,
-0.0641362667,
0.0611409992,
-0.0166963879,
0.0283761639,
-0.0012063226,
0.0397812091,
-0.0364543721,
-0.0265835207,
-0.0421334989,
0.0472671986,
-0.0230028275,
-0.0090784738,
-0.0289944075,
0.0197453089,
-0.0175782703,
0.0464808755,
-0.0263383202,
-0.0062247724,
0.015173221,
0.0113724424,
-0.0080872914,
-0.0174903516,
-0.0863131434,
0.0055489256,
0.0302344263,
-0.0459851809,
-0.0357097313,
-0.0003917172,
-0.0270767342,
-0.0154838879,
0.0237741116,
0.046199061,
0.0037683803,
0.0116710635,
-0.0249310546,
-0.0345742479,
0.0178690199,
-0.0587803647,
0.0242734123,
-0.091836758,
0.0251051094,
0.0016686623,
-0.0307256207,
-0.0326109789,
0.0185808875,
0.0274703819,
0.0107167009,
0.0607390143,
-0.0206880104,
-0.0094208689,
-0.0064004189,
0.0041889329,
-0.0457509123,
0.0370752029,
0.0376288183,
-0.0000630206,
-0.0219232086,
0.009701157,
0.010095682,
0.0292602107,
0.0270253923,
-0.0150099918,
-0.0333154909,
-0.0110395802,
0.0167780053,
0.0589849278,
0.0046975012,
0.0484033301,
-0.0514018275,
-0.0042915861,
-0.001006034,
0.0609236136,
-0.0097977798,
0.0007638706,
0.0743701383,
-0.0284754299,
0.0259662494,
-0.0205518454,
-0.1147601977,
0.0662368312,
-0.0535834655,
0.0017784334,
0.0094254306,
0.0267448202,
-0.027312994,
-0.0643110871,
-0.0071619181,
0.0366788879,
0.0005833468,
0.0265350528,
0.0356832258,
-0.0081058303,
-0.0075367661,
0.0310987309,
0.008070264,
-0.0195215456,
-0.0167657398,
-0.0626841933,
0.04087843,
0.0350254513,
0.0386955105,
-0.0227339938,
-0.0189499632,
-0.0137480209,
0.0127322087,
0.0244319066,
0.0111709936,
0.0030246105,
0.0010203352,
-0.0233971011,
-0.0070159221,
-0.0464697666,
0.0071295775,
-0.0099119609,
0.0346825942,
-0.0197146498,
0.0013741439,
-0.0003806597,
0.003911437,
0.049835559,
-0.022622386,
-0.0188346356,
-0.015370978,
0.0077764206,
-0.0222828742,
-0.0035570364,
-0.0046910234,
0.0460202284,
0.0104919141,
-0.0272774305,
-0.0254776757,
-0.0272046458,
-0.0686307624,
-0.086565353,
0.0447398387,
-0.0166734662,
-0.0346698835,
0.0055423882,
-0.045655977,
-0.0252612773,
0.0619843341,
-0.0298131946,
0.0051977001,
-0.0103984745,
0.0170083977,
0.006115221,
-0.0359213352,
-0.0196893346,
0.0755552351,
-0.0058966773,
0.0287031997,
0.0531913787,
0.0415111855,
-0.0152326515,
-0.0035778442,
-0.0096061788,
0.0051125754,
-0.0321907848,
-0.0104178339,
-0.0248054247,
0.0241875015,
-0.0463252068,
-0.0183435045,
-0.0724297017,
0.0130821541,
-0.0223681908,
0.0043194862,
0.0124772163,
-0.0076848357,
0.0067659151,
-0.0238882881,
-0.041582875,
0.0131625813,
-0.0278185513,
0.0340896733,
0.0379650518,
-0.016704509,
-0.0405606031,
-0.021275511,
-0.0266736988,
-0.0574578643,
0.0540124439,
0.0162374433,
-0.0081345327,
-0.0654170364,
0.0339026153,
-0.0287042148,
0.0274350233,
-0.0162477735,
-0.0007313573,
0.0522823669,
-0.0302049387,
0.0457393937,
0.0643171966,
-0.0453755297,
-0.0070440881,
0.0636029467,
-0.0021295857,
-0.0743886977,
0.0262091979,
0.020069221,
-0.0096910112,
0.0172340889,
-0.0331553109,
-0.0216217097,
0.0795455948,
-0.0042811548,
-0.0035429741,
-0.0489813946,
0.0391496196,
-0.0064672502,
-0.0110486243,
-0.032722611,
-0.0295615103,
-0.0072655603,
0.0643910989,
-0.0400418937,
-0.051859159,
0.0836270452,
-0.0083630728,
-0.0143331857,
-0.0298963077,
0.0269832723,
-0.0315341428,
0.0729413405,
-0.0154379215,
-0.0055390894,
0.0292506646,
-0.0330366641,
-0.0517968014,
-0.0069551775,
-0.0295559317,
-0.0026805301,
0.0602987558,
-0.0508471765,
0.0088046174,
-0.0137430234,
-0.0396935903,
-0.0438170321,
-0.0106330328,
-0.0482964702,
0.0252170078,
-0.0057732021,
-0.0181495603,
0.0496788733,
-0.0403960198,
0.0442191325,
0.0676991269,
-0.0218916573,
-0.0320307575,
-0.0298381057,
-0.0180243198,
-0.0023668197,
0.0044826642,
0.0536839329,
-0.0295567475,
0.0298947264,
0.0218691044,
0.0583221242,
0.0458275229,
-0.0673246756,
0.0219939481,
0.0165850651,
-0.029030988,
-0.0176858865,
0.0603069849,
0.0315397382,
-0.0760922953,
-0.0171494987,
0.1150892153,
0.0436628759,
-0.0644216537,
0.0143337902,
-0.0690246373,
0.0189461652,
0.0506027862,
0.0390708558,
-0.1088329554,
-0.0409557,
0.0390526131,
-0.0403561965,
0.0123535516,
-0.0376400575,
-0.0064850147,
-0.1126368493,
0.0224355254,
0.0030787431,
-0.040718019,
-0.0159274321,
-0.0094567221,
0.0027131287,
0.0310386345,
-0.0316311195,
0.0468234085,
-0.0016219933,
0.014363829,
0.0046174978,
0.0231139921,
0.0051350198,
0.0621188544,
-0.0596810021,
0.0412452184,
0.0646484867,
-0.0018164108,
0.0092779128,
-0.0377129987,
0.0368800312,
0.0195040144,
0.0214759279,
-0.0255408231,
0.0206052754,
0.0377887972,
-0.0097911181,
-0.0182145182,
0.0325431228,
-0.0443069302,
-0.0339094251,
0.0152099952,
0.0904128551,
-0.0221011546,
-0.0071932217,
0.0010319996,
0.0342113972,
-0.0275079962,
0.0538599305,
0.0534105264,
-0.025956098,
-0.0348370261,
-0.0297999345,
-0.0282373801,
-0.0315793268,
-0.0116996989,
0.0040935953,
0.0506299064,
-0.0086660581,
-0.0610702895,
-0.0430511385,
0.0641144663,
0.0475060605,
0.0093285237,
-0.0191529319,
0.0068128505,
-0.00970079,
-0.0282398053,
0.0339488573,
-0.0482053682,
0.0450858958,
-0.0192777794,
0.0389892347,
-0.0151034482,
-0.0201311223,
-0.0192141011,
0.0058911615,
-0.1142784879,
-0.0582683943,
-0.0496640317,
0.0470030643,
0.0271084011,
0.0257878527,
-0.0289134067,
-0.0397167429,
-0.047418572,
0.0152484849,
0.0013120935,
0.0152327968,
0.0190575384,
0.0198442414,
0.0236057267,
0.033887919,
-0.027270088,
-0.0068253144,
0.0197862573,
0.0570234135,
-0.0393670313,
0.054114189,
0.0239930451,
0.0232588965,
0.0068633216,
-0.0111338506,
-0.018006701,
-0.0205778554,
0.0213741902,
-0.0125903953,
-0.036857985,
-0.0304009803,
0.023723362,
0.0137922307,
0.0102441981,
0.0078089638,
-0.0382308736,
0.0383884721,
0.0217556916,
0.0144477133,
0.0024369154,
0.0363110006,
0.0464422069,
0.0452436469,
0.0078790365,
-0.0303574502,
0.0315562822,
-0.0130752847,
0.0393710099,
-0.0462034829,
0.0753730759,
0.0401464924,
0.0188353248,
-0.0557839647,
-0.0075640613,
-0.0392783657,
-0.0976281539,
0.0635975972,
-0.0047843284,
0.042394191,
0.0374274589,
-0.0197986756,
-0.0156890713,
0.0059543285,
0.0188958757,
0.0213136338,
0.0046391487,
-0.0521578155,
0.0375232995,
0.0481626913,
0.0273949169,
-0.0500753596,
0.0401019938,
-0.0636904165,
0.028904818,
0.0128050335,
0.0264082812,
-0.0053035445,
-0.0073641529,
0.0109420298,
0.0007967993,
-0.0104947304,
0.0056816656,
-0.0662371963,
-0.0657898113,
-0.0076778866,
0.0293082166,
-0.0044233482,
-0.0062092845,
0.0379181877,
0.0446386486,
0.0017987463,
-0.0394451991,
0.0037321826,
0.0173990056,
0.0167957917,
-0.0700611398,
-0.0681564584,
-6.457106549e-33,
-0.0184273031,
-0.0229454953,
0.056095168,
-0.0177865457,
-0.0129773049,
-0.0034959016,
-0.0703408197,
0.0164600164,
-0.0268534757,
-0.0031410281,
-0.0105573609,
0.0320507139,
-0.0053566517,
-0.0075338851,
0.0426632054,
-0.0347877853,
0.0019089511,
-0.0150492229,
-0.0476004854,
0.0112418402,
-0.0058031566,
0.0030359053,
0.0300139561,
-0.0015356382,
0.0477542467,
0.027186038,
0.0110105183,
0.0364288501,
-0.0621175133,
0.0186411999,
-0.0196316708,
-0.0000256689,
0.0103946673,
-0.0029820406,
-0.0150204124,
0.0282614008,
-0.0484416485,
-0.0670445487,
0.0530451573,
-0.0137012834,
-0.0576836728,
-0.0569485314,
0.0265530441,
-0.0140496967,
-0.0156385321,
-0.0318037271,
0.0068683363,
-0.0058288062,
-0.007550539,
-0.0316635296,
-0.0639106929,
0.0062444364,
-0.0270730779,
-0.0264238082,
-0.0116820643,
0.0493631251,
-0.0363651477,
0.0336589254,
-0.0300635397,
-0.0141331032,
0.039225895,
0.0165802278,
0.0304969121,
0.0114788562,
0.0034380616,
0.0389410108,
0.0563850105,
-0.0036526911,
-0.0574422181,
0.0379612632,
0.0499596931,
0.0284852125,
0.0933605209,
-0.0068689268,
0.0858788937,
0.0613712594,
-0.0531874299,
-0.0417878032,
0.0237953924,
0.0291570444,
0.0240709595,
0.0011618284,
-0.0214756858,
-0.0223498475,
-0.073180303,
-0.0326075777,
-0.0718224719,
-0.0270587113,
0.037905287,
-0.0065619377,
0.0158211328,
-0.0228017587,
0.0148840258,
-0.0243813451,
0.0208029728,
0.042323336,
0.0222634468,
0.0527213402,
0.0126417782,
0.0314167328,
-0.0543652214,
0.0270379502,
0.0135893095,
-0.0048655183,
0.0601948462,
0.0174077414,
0.0436625257,
0.0177762862,
-0.0430862121,
-0.0265803766,
-0.064099811,
0.0026822549,
0.0324301906,
-0.0194353666,
0.0403754078,
0.0309741478,
0.0005083561,
0.0068094851,
-0.0122416038,
-0.0258917343,
-0.0375400782,
0.06267149,
-0.0200195052,
0.0318761095,
-0.007170009,
-0.0221324898,
-0.0561975837,
0.0459817983,
0.0113318227,
-0.08104074,
-0.0272440277,
0.0339147672,
2.855e-7,
0.0111165904,
0.0313017443,
0.0316259414,
0.0591054372,
0.0144733889,
0.0180099178,
-0.0296324771,
-0.0362005085,
0.0310623776,
-0.042891968,
-0.0232281741,
0.0590795018,
0.0293468013,
0.016513845,
-0.0535827689,
-0.0071882894,
-0.0347366594,
-0.0073888702,
-0.0443436205,
0.0056731785,
0.0515892282,
0.0599149875,
0.0204957109,
0.0006364248,
0.0199518315,
-0.0382564291,
0.0307399835,
0.0002931876,
0.0415135957,
-0.0139115639,
-0.0580423847,
-0.0164737683,
0.0108147468,
0.0191528164,
0.0291815139,
-0.0009028458,
-0.0040223799,
0.0673259348,
0.0048487429,
0.0376766585,
-0.0361216851,
-0.0295228101,
-0.0056417109,
-0.0410069004,
0.0681438148,
-0.0766996965,
-0.0105765462,
0.0009886554,
0.0180944186,
-0.0128338775,
0.0139503712,
0.0005824144,
0.0279845577,
0.01309558,
-0.0011731928,
-0.0225949232,
-0.0099621173,
-0.0686957836,
-0.0596923307,
0.0303656571,
-0.0246093646,
-0.0242872853,
-0.0557990447,
0.014706566,
0.0190336648,
-0.0311477799,
-0.0189141501,
2.784628797e-34,
0.02727657,
-0.0571183823,
0.0504105613,
0.0593201108,
0.0440520756,
-0.0027979405,
-0.0713644698,
0.026196735,
0.0429141633,
-0.0778361857,
-0.0396725126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18503v1 | From Adversarial Arms Race to Model-centric Evaluation: Motivating a Unified Automatic Robustness Evaluation Framework | 2023-05-29T14:55:20 | 2023-05-29T14:55:20 | Yangyi Chen, Hongcheng Gao, Ganqu Cui, Lifan Yuan, Dehan Kong, Hanlu Wu, Ning Shi, Bo Yuan, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Textual adversarial attacks can discover models' weaknesses by adding
semantic-preserved but misleading perturbations to the inputs. The long-lasting
adversarial attack-and-defense arms race in Natural Language Processing (NLP)
is algorithm-centric, providing valuable techniques for automatic robustness
evaluation. However, the existing practice of robustness evaluation may exhibit
issues of incomprehensive evaluation, impractical evaluation protocol, and
invalid adversarial samples. In this paper, we aim to set up a unified
automatic robustness evaluation framework, shifting towards model-centric
evaluation to further exploit the advantages of adversarial attacks. To address
the above challenges, we first determine robustness evaluation dimensions based
on model capabilities and specify the reasonable algorithm to generate
adversarial samples for each dimension. Then we establish the evaluation
protocol, including evaluation settings and metrics, under realistic demands.
Finally, we use the perturbation degree of adversarial samples to control the
sample validity. We implement a toolkit RobTest that realizes our automatic
robustness evaluation framework. In our experiments, we conduct a robustness
evaluation of RoBERTa models to demonstrate the effectiveness of our evaluation
framework, and further show the rationality of each component in the framework.
The code will be made public at \url{https://github.com/thunlp/RobTest}. | [
0.0309683792,
0.0776880682,
-0.0212233793,
0.0499155335,
-0.0371485502,
-0.0095233116,
-0.0145808468,
-0.0039043869,
-0.0070990557,
-0.0564550981,
0.0057146926,
0.0145852249,
0.0119816735,
0.0114463242,
0.0452836454,
-0.0470036715,
0.040785253,
-0.021412259,
-0.0398716927,
0.032937143,
0.014389405,
-0.0326011032,
-0.0068460661,
0.0326797813,
0.0029058505,
-0.0203567259,
0.0189046469,
0.0136547191,
0.0331252404,
-0.0400039665,
0.0024879361,
0.0553287379,
-0.0175557379,
0.0726486668,
0.0000018569,
-0.0263336767,
-0.0214736331,
0.0528910272,
-0.0136144869,
0.0268416926,
0.0796223134,
-0.02124938,
-0.0151814679,
-0.0129011087,
-0.0197163448,
-0.004767471,
0.0130557632,
0.0465655588,
0.06456393,
0.1054858565,
-0.0005644233,
-0.0184036624,
0.0562840551,
-0.0309414715,
-0.0711015612,
-0.0531614162,
0.0152902063,
-0.0036563424,
-0.0053379969,
-0.0048141717,
0.0023409533,
0.024112843,
0.0436856188,
-0.0058487342,
-0.0539619364,
0.001518777,
-0.0320221968,
-0.0089393565,
-0.0038800605,
0.0573162995,
-0.0186343417,
-0.003513023,
-0.0116338842,
-0.0058005322,
0.0129343355,
0.0019400382,
-0.0147663988,
-0.0172353946,
0.0343278982,
-0.0085947923,
-0.0386249721,
0.0215070341,
0.0630907193,
0.0063697975,
0.0266046878,
0.0377471633,
0.0283926763,
-0.0179337058,
-0.0045716553,
-0.0241316725,
-0.0452549271,
-0.0118108299,
-0.0089459065,
-0.0008193153,
-0.0077071963,
-0.0024536632,
-0.0833837092,
-0.0556984693,
0.0425005704,
-0.0194336288,
0.0596228316,
-0.0139958849,
-0.0394250937,
0.0309166629,
-0.0269910339,
0.0545755848,
-0.0193926822,
0.0539665706,
0.0016237451,
0.0226288345,
-0.0331076309,
0.0079232296,
0.0117130848,
0.0254605357,
-0.0144489184,
0.0078796949,
-0.0345382132,
0.0187028851,
-0.0471316315,
0.0405435748,
-0.0477382764,
0.0358586051,
-0.0109874737,
0.0021581105,
0.0001584242,
-0.0385991521,
-0.0292070974,
-0.0002734318,
-0.0019567169,
-0.0732639283,
-0.0108417878,
0.0326125026,
-0.0603321046,
-0.0482543372,
-0.0137424935,
0.1234366968,
0.0578363761,
-0.0470581241,
-0.0179996006,
-0.0395075642,
-0.0526378974,
-0.0708409846,
0.0150894076,
-0.0163662992,
-0.024923237,
-0.0254311785,
-0.0023916028,
-0.0611513443,
-0.0055004111,
-0.0022316452,
0.0026709754,
0.0789914355,
0.0418353565,
-0.0611240007,
-0.0060873916,
0.0316409767,
-0.0162654594,
0.0767639801,
0.021139795,
0.0313013718,
0.0758318603,
0.0262023453,
0.0190537106,
0.015093226,
0.0238916855,
0.0056988792,
-0.0195617881,
0.034446381,
-0.0099216634,
-0.022244012,
-0.042309761,
0.0500536934,
-0.0228409693,
-0.0605185144,
0.07165806,
-0.0004505377,
-0.0203066748,
0.0415447652,
0.0299302675,
-0.0603225455,
0.0229560137,
0.0094440421,
-0.0788128749,
-0.0138663203,
-0.1192849502,
-0.0069840695,
-0.0108073978,
0.0122270593,
0.0036976999,
-0.0579110682,
-0.0330976024,
-0.0044664182,
0.0326989479,
-0.0324281901,
0.0435545444,
0.0364583135,
-0.0199532267,
-0.037013609,
-0.012200064,
-0.0240225531,
-0.0104927188,
-0.0603621453,
-0.0278537981,
-0.0052948366,
0.0835542381,
-0.0635109246,
0.0477416851,
-0.0343979448,
0.0084965779,
0.0156999007,
0.057528466,
0.013129605,
0.0397356115,
-0.0027208929,
-0.0072087883,
-0.0366993695,
0.0556788743,
0.0297577251,
0.0316749327,
0.0126659442,
0.0116591323,
-0.0367667116,
-0.0408481508,
0.0467719026,
0.0223498885,
-0.041607324,
0.0115409074,
-0.0021851507,
0.043524716,
0.0237756725,
-0.0689080805,
0.0365915261,
0.0414508395,
0.0021855291,
-0.0032301077,
-0.0053946082,
0.0369134918,
-0.0225202478,
0.0078989379,
-0.0266822502,
-0.0345403478,
0.0905925259,
-0.0365830138,
0.0273851305,
0.0618676506,
-0.0434710123,
-0.0245199595,
-0.0121185146,
0.0028341531,
-0.0048246132,
0.0508996658,
-0.0416454524,
0.0455118977,
-0.022124812,
0.0180653948,
-0.0091283554,
0.041971311,
0.01512565,
-0.0440189913,
-0.0762415677,
0.021793915,
-0.0335259438,
0.0075586764,
0.0105871996,
-0.0227170642,
-0.010362641,
-0.0119684041,
-0.01964847,
-0.0148698483,
-0.0341033712,
0.0234607104,
0.0297962427,
-0.0328200869,
0.0108062215,
0.0017430868,
0.0539311171,
-0.0006061817,
-0.0017440253,
0.0195720308,
0.0241617635,
-0.0172810219,
-0.0225812085,
-0.0380220525,
-0.0326631516,
-0.010535921,
0.0985070094,
0.0116032893,
0.0207597092,
-0.0160017237,
-0.0373463333,
-0.0125409076,
0.0516235121,
-0.0313153006,
-0.0674254224,
0.0223487206,
0.040128123,
-0.0239644833,
0.0724342167,
0.0126080476,
0.0505201556,
0.0385548621,
0.0326916575,
0.031932164,
-0.0009799753,
-0.0055064219,
-0.0065841745,
-0.0034838973,
-0.0214162469,
0.0317156017,
0.0333609805,
0.0098147681,
-0.0123573989,
0.0004759496,
0.0360245332,
-0.0295397751,
-0.0512027703,
0.0118703358,
-0.0161188282,
-0.0224016309,
0.0051197237,
-0.0325832218,
-0.0505019389,
0.0855672732,
-0.0419836082,
0.0091149379,
-0.0271555372,
-0.0339279436,
0.0165611599,
0.068117559,
0.0094550727,
-0.0030538721,
0.0122994604,
0.0244751237,
-0.0339261144,
-0.1003242955,
0.0646269545,
-0.0157993753,
0.0156045211,
-0.031542208,
0.0009060605,
0.0187285598,
-0.0204220898,
-0.0450378768,
-0.0317247361,
-0.012811807,
0.053764049,
0.0033685842,
-0.0165921226,
-0.0369737148,
-0.016456943,
0.0234530307,
0.0050514741,
-0.0082211681,
-0.0016128074,
-0.0011815361,
0.0456102826,
0.0330561958,
-0.0250647981,
0.0352275223,
-0.0043893675,
0.0458845571,
0.0602530241,
-0.0209109262,
0.0371812098,
-0.061816901,
-0.0081613092,
-0.0369806141,
-0.0197141785,
0.0349020176,
0.0236548483,
0.0229928568,
-0.0400083959,
-0.0216871668,
0.0222318452,
-0.0001901103,
0.0368304327,
0.0287969299,
0.0187956747,
0.032921277,
0.0096523603,
-0.0064536771,
-0.0199773591,
-0.0188065767,
0.0132626221,
0.0420704782,
-0.0107672969,
-0.0310846344,
0.0156076057,
-0.0723152608,
0.0010053234,
-0.0097216005,
-0.0635212585,
-0.0478055216,
-0.0416806825,
0.0017682874,
-0.0355847962,
0.0472779982,
-0.001118781,
0.0330378413,
-0.0148446122,
-0.0106171882,
-0.0223464537,
-0.0248514749,
0.0205241945,
-0.0423530824,
0.0234030504,
0.0985535458,
0.0228194539,
-0.0156632029,
0.0063450015,
0.0402447022,
-0.0138926245,
0.0017639986,
0.0348915868,
0.0572955459,
-0.0012819516,
-0.0208263472,
0.0097008245,
0.0125468858,
0.0081287371,
-0.0267720986,
-0.0038189443,
0.0039693988,
0.0192236491,
-0.0358196236,
-0.0488443412,
0.0051719975,
0.0162176415,
0.0587074719,
0.0294542387,
-0.0041583106,
-0.0682418495,
-0.0632342771,
0.0046144491,
-0.0735948756,
-0.0533402152,
0.017991446,
0.027352754,
-0.0283645522,
-0.0813390836,
-0.0272252001,
-0.0522255599,
0.0043632388,
-0.0183838066,
-0.038832482,
-0.0323767401,
0.0150446873,
-0.0419753008,
0.0005973614,
0.0019265701,
0.0331626646,
-0.0232656803,
0.0206440315,
0.0248879176,
-0.00735565,
-0.0274190996,
0.0356976427,
-0.060847804,
-0.0911578462,
0.0310198572,
0.0572090037,
0.0178465564,
0.013619897,
-0.0625222698,
-0.0781122074,
0.0667012036,
0.0461936146,
-0.0232621152,
-0.0000783006,
0.0957535654,
-0.0231117662,
0.0125942901,
0.0402754322,
-0.0342354886,
0.0012441614,
0.0221548583,
0.0089370022,
0.0218334813,
0.0023864435,
-0.0063820975,
0.0254560262,
0.0462120995,
0.0013867695,
-0.0293438621,
0.0385841243,
-0.0022501012,
-0.0315459408,
-0.0292255189,
-0.0116573451,
0.0437617041,
0.0176995508,
0.0072921431,
-0.0067195813,
-0.0036124559,
-0.0184940919,
0.0262680035,
0.012140099,
0.0156773012,
0.0343840159,
0.0234197974,
0.0027782777,
0.0228497237,
-0.0299668387,
0.0240640156,
-0.0443158112,
0.0286457278,
-0.0003436183,
0.0135361524,
0.0125713022,
-0.0131625095,
-0.0071833041,
0.0294302832,
-0.0962912515,
0.0271195918,
-0.0496636704,
0.017864421,
0.0179083515,
0.0209098384,
0.0045983596,
-0.0388997421,
-0.015842963,
-0.0268238485,
-0.0081739854,
0.0161154009,
-0.0106807621,
0.0311369766,
0.0269951783,
0.0069993339,
0.03582469,
0.0366119295,
0.0305175446,
0.0383947045,
0.0185564067,
-0.0228723958,
-0.0639558211,
-0.0552347004,
0.0094678393,
-0.008918277,
-0.0314766504,
-0.0226475932,
-0.0263649561,
-0.1054196954,
-0.0002439921,
0.048295103,
0.0404292122,
0.0302637797,
-0.0276875384,
0.0405074544,
0.0153292939,
0.0484694988,
-0.0485986099,
0.0392185934,
0.0135114398,
-0.0176357049,
-0.0061274231,
-5.709557162e-33,
-0.001443148,
-0.0278490819,
-0.0453825966,
-0.0745779276,
0.0302966293,
0.0000642338,
-0.0217269119,
0.0019194505,
-0.0317947716,
0.0127899228,
0.0132758562,
-0.0014379361,
-0.0172483679,
0.0105156424,
-0.0501201637,
-0.0606480837,
0.0176483039,
-0.0070309704,
-0.0584059656,
-0.0238386393,
0.0048301704,
0.0097092139,
0.0476797409,
-0.0714426413,
0.0758088976,
0.0053011109,
-0.0609174222,
-0.0084622316,
-0.0393385999,
0.0775331855,
0.002018773,
0.0204894524,
-0.0092946282,
0.0030999887,
0.0064612669,
-0.0201304201,
-0.0314379297,
-0.0256366767,
-0.0036103833,
0.00874463,
-0.0421854779,
0.0111634759,
0.0362446085,
-0.0304940902,
0.0052110562,
-0.0096275276,
0.0064102635,
-0.0228967909,
-0.0001379237,
-0.015474312,
-0.0031561784,
0.046719376,
-0.0342992544,
-0.01241861,
0.0074272291,
0.0076015145,
0.0276746769,
0.0180722438,
-0.0452437848,
-0.0305000655,
0.0195579231,
0.0159359146,
0.0372789428,
-0.0169358607,
-0.0065639,
0.0639389753,
0.0128337247,
0.0213817488,
0.0029744951,
-0.0195007212,
0.0133748427,
0.0285801403,
0.1121350601,
0.1119673848,
0.0440762378,
0.0113091273,
-0.0847337544,
0.0070679979,
0.0243021715,
0.0398949273,
0.0323705599,
0.0111041078,
-0.0785402209,
0.0252492242,
-0.0211995859,
-0.1067583337,
-0.0478667058,
-0.0324631669,
0.0281326473,
0.025193302,
-0.0630117655,
0.0219849832,
-0.0291770194,
-0.0617136881,
0.007492268,
0.032328926,
-0.0200634375,
-0.0095828241,
0.0092988219,
0.0076252501,
0.0475776345,
0.0006264609,
0.0333366431,
-0.0003293738,
0.0442616083,
-0.0552160889,
0.0502246954,
0.0416351929,
-0.031362351,
-0.006581252,
-0.0030467734,
0.0440455899,
0.0479758605,
0.0193983857,
0.0273527801,
-0.0140987737,
-0.0314674973,
0.0148275243,
0.0139948316,
0.0127192978,
-0.0308521315,
0.0476354025,
0.0089668129,
0.0011513056,
0.0034757615,
-0.0536260493,
0.011602778,
0.0179268625,
0.0302021578,
-0.0546317808,
0.0053290804,
-0.03032667,
2.624e-7,
0.0287903603,
0.037652567,
0.0199917182,
-0.004596449,
0.0273696296,
0.0372798294,
-0.0319068395,
0.047303766,
-0.0169716738,
-0.0284323692,
-0.0396551304,
-0.0135775972,
0.0616423786,
0.0318399779,
-0.0075704954,
-0.0451582521,
-0.0685095266,
0.0105743799,
-0.0081657739,
-0.0238105357,
0.0654534027,
0.0982180834,
0.0317729749,
0.0265619364,
-0.0364139862,
-0.0795662627,
0.0124343047,
-0.0280698054,
0.0282419827,
-0.026490394,
0.056288369,
0.0108297234,
0.0344501138,
-0.0067447987,
-0.0289367922,
0.000246178,
0.0336778387,
0.063487187,
0.0034357714,
-0.0592588075,
-0.0277997181,
-0.032378111,
0.0130289569,
-0.0414986983,
0.0759368017,
-0.0246142205,
-0.006159937,
-0.0157949049,
-0.0461587943,
-0.0232698303,
0.0846835077,
-0.0435562767,
-0.0368754007,
0.0249170233,
0.0113431001,
0.0253713708,
0.0024162191,
-0.0575232208,
-0.0414408147,
-0.0123079773,
-0.0270601157,
-0.0158667434,
-0.007936487,
0.0028372649,
0.0306559112,
-0.059050899,
-0.0033439773,
2.31845437e-34,
0.0430022068,
-0.0198868699,
0.0032146061,
-0.0208192375,
0.0489250273,
-0.0007108519,
0.0562704541,
-0.0260443855,
-0.0030351263,
-0.0501417145,
-0.0299283396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18500v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18500v2 | VAST: A Vision-Audio-Subtitle-Text Omni-Modality Foundation Model and Dataset | 2023-05-29T14:34:50 | 2023-10-07T12:58:26 | Sihan Chen, Handong Li, Qunbo Wang, Zijia Zhao, Mingzhen Sun, Xinxin Zhu, Jing Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Vision and text have been fully explored in contemporary video-text
foundational models, while other modalities such as audio and subtitles in
videos have not received sufficient attention. In this paper, we resort to
establish connections between multi-modality video tracks, including Vision,
Audio, and Subtitle, and Text by exploring an automatically generated
large-scale omni-modality video caption dataset called VAST-27M. Specifically,
we first collect 27 million open-domain video clips and separately train a
vision and an audio captioner to generate vision and audio captions. Then, we
employ an off-the-shelf Large Language Model (LLM) to integrate the generated
captions, together with subtitles and instructional prompts into omni-modality
captions. Based on the proposed VAST-27M dataset, we train an omni-modality
video-text foundational model named VAST, which can perceive and process
vision, audio, and subtitle modalities from video, and better support various
tasks including vision-text, audio-text, and multi-modal video-text tasks
(retrieval, captioning and QA). Extensive experiments have been conducted to
demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed VAST-27M corpus and VAST
foundation model. VAST achieves 22 new state-of-the-art results on various
cross-modality benchmarks. Code, model and dataset will be released at
https://github.com/TXH-mercury/VAST. | [
0.0300640408,
0.0515377857,
0.0008018294,
0.0579476878,
0.0007968465,
0.006053444,
0.0002189626,
0.0134386849,
-0.0198066067,
-0.080834195,
-0.0616391189,
-0.0337958038,
-0.0233554095,
0.0586425476,
0.0020692847,
-0.063317135,
0.0093696592,
-0.0429595932,
-0.0237825178,
0.0242811423,
0.0230652392,
0.0143328933,
-0.0121910144,
0.022675775,
-0.0325464271,
-0.0098485583,
0.001684881,
0.0051953034,
0.0156534184,
-0.0294579007,
-0.0163453948,
0.0297539718,
0.1015565917,
0.0097328378,
0.0000014003,
0.0004986174,
0.028197905,
0.0058878823,
0.0279774629,
0.0133185657,
0.0466763228,
-0.0215666555,
-0.0073938901,
0.0292554088,
-0.0195027906,
-0.0198326129,
0.0449322499,
0.0229238216,
0.0473045707,
0.0299561974,
-0.0473342836,
-0.0433447286,
0.0463887043,
-0.0403960496,
0.0089249946,
-0.0206551477,
0.0066177938,
0.0404901206,
0.0229573082,
0.0270163864,
-0.0294141043,
0.0529600158,
-0.0117249256,
-0.0283701364,
-0.0200711135,
0.0268754661,
-0.0195514914,
-0.0396057218,
-0.034547314,
0.1061051637,
0.0531818718,
0.0399626084,
-0.0122088175,
0.0249126516,
0.0094786724,
-0.015272175,
-0.0583891608,
0.0449201204,
0.0244254954,
-0.0097972592,
-0.0415841453,
0.0491962843,
0.0005558333,
0.0005852788,
0.0309744701,
-0.0519552827,
0.0431575887,
0.0163138285,
-0.0299520884,
-0.0182696227,
-0.0363254733,
-0.0481341407,
0.0274139978,
-0.0051012794,
0.0227628183,
-0.0081997886,
-0.0518372804,
-0.0326762944,
-0.0165006015,
-0.0123089263,
0.0035175295,
0.0135476589,
-0.1053015217,
0.0819476545,
-0.0335765332,
0.0479939505,
-0.0482743941,
0.0130778179,
-0.0201271791,
-0.0197351854,
-0.0612819232,
0.012686112,
-0.0182344057,
0.0175965894,
-0.0732635632,
-0.0358282439,
-0.0280500371,
-0.0011693814,
-0.0139773302,
0.0162851233,
-0.0250196718,
0.0273938775,
0.0183526166,
-0.0261636544,
-0.0174093749,
0.0462924205,
-0.0124776112,
0.0508976057,
-0.0100223431,
-0.0455040559,
-0.0107104778,
0.0414793156,
0.0299202036,
0.0007084016,
0.0251537282,
0.0678197145,
-0.0603462532,
-0.0452856496,
0.0008812207,
-0.0146750314,
-0.0593882017,
-0.0147670507,
-0.0318767279,
-0.0421986319,
0.0145565839,
-0.008067498,
0.0068363217,
-0.0124048302,
0.0212046094,
0.0114689833,
-0.0046325731,
0.0804348886,
0.0134576866,
0.0120362183,
0.0110337604,
0.0224217735,
0.0037893034,
0.0535416193,
0.0413515568,
0.046316497,
0.0473708846,
0.0378303118,
0.0299196988,
0.0515125468,
-0.0315781496,
0.0325793177,
-0.0539315753,
0.0162762683,
0.0192005336,
0.034203019,
0.0165596455,
0.06122436,
-0.0110487957,
-0.0038726595,
0.0752399191,
0.0334062688,
-0.0111771971,
0.0231002625,
0.0356140509,
0.0354602449,
0.0099139456,
-0.0252054296,
0.0066066114,
0.0649847537,
0.0375476107,
0.0129498029,
0.0200285725,
0.0204918794,
-0.0678627789,
-0.0232745465,
-0.0172460433,
-0.0162010472,
-0.0423241109,
-0.0051564835,
0.0463375561,
-0.0027510363,
-0.0791497007,
0.0233460851,
0.0019412916,
-0.0586562753,
0.0267965645,
-0.0341313034,
0.0075003551,
0.0287855603,
0.0262776818,
-0.0462044105,
-0.0145980706,
-0.025944246,
0.0634293482,
0.0583927706,
0.0323410295,
-0.035273239,
-0.0051453635,
-0.0838385075,
-0.0271895323,
0.0112918299,
-0.0011481858,
0.0416680612,
-0.0469453111,
0.0215567593,
0.028866807,
-0.0154604614,
-0.0284929052,
0.0292240307,
0.0284612719,
-0.0109113064,
-0.0126663465,
0.0103436224,
0.0008705773,
0.0364373438,
-0.0451755226,
-0.0112525551,
0.0232477691,
-0.0142004685,
-0.0142158307,
0.0571830533,
-0.0666421428,
-0.0152762961,
0.0284723844,
-0.0597306862,
0.0222649649,
0.0245501772,
-0.0104242871,
-0.0667448938,
0.0012146638,
-0.0089638261,
-0.0222000815,
-0.0774488598,
0.0032270185,
0.0184134189,
-0.000536019,
0.0038447997,
0.0133083062,
0.0175674055,
-0.0268480983,
0.0365421362,
-0.0071804416,
0.0303018931,
-0.0308796559,
-0.0445865542,
0.013089424,
-0.0282096863,
0.0290853735,
0.0225487445,
-0.0141634168,
-0.051158078,
-0.0525518917,
-0.1022278443,
0.0042290329,
-0.0150394319,
0.0055403635,
-0.0129870595,
0.0040691062,
-0.0092512425,
-0.0418976285,
-0.0197088495,
0.006226813,
0.0228406005,
0.0122493319,
0.0016838501,
0.0352102593,
-0.0023735892,
-0.0119988658,
0.0036332281,
0.004545013,
0.0329597741,
0.0088333525,
-0.0108038327,
-0.001364277,
0.0143509321,
0.0050366791,
0.0316203833,
-0.0212048478,
-0.0331259482,
-0.0116211697,
-0.0001422962,
0.0205497332,
0.0059530833,
0.0042012762,
-0.0029099272,
0.0213423632,
-0.0156128891,
-0.0035582336,
0.0220570732,
0.0382183231,
-0.0886744782,
-0.005815485,
0.0051732496,
-0.041733332,
0.0156762674,
-0.0065716612,
0.0341174342,
-0.0673324689,
0.0054933322,
-0.0233432055,
-0.0179352835,
-0.0378170572,
0.0074358783,
-0.0308385752,
0.013237468,
-0.0300859194,
-0.0284608956,
-0.0036897692,
-0.0637512133,
-0.0611957982,
-0.0127602946,
0.0150687331,
-0.0276823584,
0.0748296827,
-0.027958747,
0.0137856761,
0.0117057143,
-0.0570281819,
-0.0446769409,
-0.004506846,
0.0050300937,
-0.0259466488,
0.0555215143,
-0.0315828733,
0.0227010529,
-0.0186013225,
-0.036335241,
-0.0263966639,
-0.0629239157,
-0.0453440063,
-0.0054199896,
-0.0524853431,
-0.0264405329,
-0.0551077686,
0.0068921172,
0.0341043361,
0.0626633167,
-0.0156041412,
0.0180806927,
-0.0145482179,
0.0741176084,
0.0538224578,
0.049424611,
-0.0728091151,
-0.0359907188,
0.0450548343,
0.0205036718,
0.0404082127,
-0.0249136444,
-0.01281658,
0.0032991376,
0.0389423408,
0.0250908006,
-0.0108359605,
0.0309056584,
0.045972161,
-0.0251118019,
0.0158706196,
0.10442397,
0.0138601409,
-0.0507005863,
-0.0370404795,
0.0260352921,
-0.0008311115,
0.0469464622,
-0.0040317969,
-0.1032150686,
-0.0688411146,
-0.0188107956,
0.0014851752,
0.0569561794,
0.0271871909,
-0.0276224967,
-0.0588813797,
0.0668352023,
0.0064803693,
-0.0158285722,
-0.031102499,
0.0282097273,
0.0045593688,
-0.0248746797,
-0.027112063,
-0.0207891148,
-0.0514288694,
-0.0058805794,
0.0213195886,
0.0648840591,
-0.0505571701,
0.0416942053,
-0.062828742,
0.0425078198,
0.037178997,
0.0356540419,
-0.0499387719,
-0.0343907848,
-0.0003327318,
-0.0319810063,
0.0019745417,
0.0288545042,
0.0782746822,
-0.0385236144,
-0.0369661003,
0.007584969,
0.021744661,
-0.0138308471,
-0.0261988491,
0.0247823354,
0.0371514186,
0.0247124936,
0.0339954309,
-0.0400982909,
0.0282285381,
0.0121542178,
0.0782086551,
-0.0142455585,
-0.014653652,
0.0250115693,
0.019727923,
-0.0247665886,
-0.0558581725,
-0.0236131977,
-0.0182617325,
-0.0023063915,
0.0114834672,
-0.0535461716,
0.0114500858,
0.0483511128,
0.0127480151,
0.031026816,
-0.0042149089,
0.0047303205,
0.0317981802,
-0.077192232,
0.0699934885,
-0.0275215078,
0.0087975441,
-0.0758124441,
-0.0097988462,
0.1056135148,
-0.0655570328,
-0.0124225831,
0.0204139538,
-0.0610235371,
-0.0331940055,
-0.0343013778,
0.0300432201,
0.0136796031,
0.0408871174,
0.0228104778,
-0.0468301214,
0.0259650033,
0.0172098894,
-0.0129625183,
0.0113553209,
0.0190580264,
-0.0376366861,
-0.046715498,
0.0257182792,
-0.0428939834,
0.0164143834,
-0.0003579987,
0.0280106757,
0.0161012989,
-0.0061097853,
-0.0183584969,
-0.0452679172,
0.0171718374,
-0.0303114075,
0.0170489755,
-0.0795351863,
-0.0009654854,
0.009561602,
0.023885686,
-0.0663250983,
0.0367050283,
0.06783849,
0.0186774656,
-0.0235209726,
0.0340099521,
-0.009821319,
-0.0044031823,
-0.0150331967,
0.0448472314,
0.0150387781,
-0.0272013936,
0.0110345799,
-0.001589952,
0.0109556112,
0.0434376188,
-0.0144586246,
0.0334725976,
0.0045975866,
0.0676175505,
-0.0058673359,
-0.0311182849,
0.0048723524,
0.0671533123,
0.002314972,
0.0030207958,
-0.0292236004,
0.0715832338,
0.0655975938,
-0.0365804397,
0.008080909,
-0.0038896627,
-0.0079054991,
-0.0156404339,
0.0428813249,
-0.0429606475,
-0.0444475301,
0.0609061047,
0.0069599673,
-0.0097009912,
0.0329767875,
0.0645273924,
-0.0021912965,
0.0242178347,
0.0314944312,
-0.0043818424,
-0.0366412885,
0.013583716,
0.0088447835,
0.0155577632,
-0.042782288,
0.0526609719,
-0.0226946212,
-0.0496055745,
0.0170437116,
-0.0206155255,
-0.002598258,
0.0301456507,
0.0393195301,
0.0171279628,
0.0079263505,
-0.0112453932,
-0.0064999121,
-0.0338976532,
-0.0386542678,
-0.0059028319,
-0.0093576573,
-4.658075628e-33,
-0.0257723071,
-0.00877159,
-0.0094474303,
-0.0076507395,
-0.0379735455,
0.0421093926,
-0.0146142859,
0.0423874222,
-0.0103378017,
0.0085887881,
0.0172704346,
0.0048541557,
0.0267890152,
0.0562369339,
0.0008439555,
-0.04234666,
0.0613475069,
-0.0556412525,
-0.0000915632,
0.0059596994,
0.0228056852,
0.0168548115,
0.031869363,
-0.0843385085,
-0.0058987928,
-0.0182965398,
-0.0366895273,
0.0207513534,
0.0442446508,
0.0915695801,
-0.0096088517,
0.0202123635,
0.0072548338,
-0.0018734261,
-0.0080498112,
0.0384432934,
-0.0447313972,
0.0368096046,
0.0283403359,
0.0325583592,
-0.0301284641,
-0.0137166791,
-0.0013204237,
-0.0326551907,
-0.0176135879,
-0.0153753571,
0.0605935939,
-0.0311545581,
0.0453556627,
0.0107791321,
-0.0501678325,
0.004017402,
-0.0074858493,
-0.0726342872,
0.0690973178,
-0.0072920932,
0.0557302274,
-0.007369047,
-0.0245053079,
0.0515000485,
-0.0058050761,
0.0282102413,
0.0837666616,
0.0485741384,
-0.0272673946,
0.0574450195,
-0.0005373606,
-0.0399632566,
-0.034395285,
-0.0281970426,
0.0013871676,
0.0550185107,
0.030868927,
0.0688493773,
0.0038773625,
0.0165921077,
-0.015878221,
0.0181827955,
-0.0607367605,
0.0152867883,
0.0094516156,
0.0292809773,
-0.0140105449,
0.0459561236,
-0.0417059176,
-0.0076881796,
-0.0460299142,
-0.0057422821,
0.039084807,
0.0030201108,
0.0165978875,
0.0084095979,
0.0854478627,
-0.0343682915,
0.0207182262,
0.0174646229,
-0.0258644801,
0.0623003691,
-0.0153818326,
0.0235317368,
-0.035282515,
-0.0115857208,
0.0729970336,
-0.0110356156,
0.0025325571,
0.0042290264,
0.0048568761,
0.0371565185,
-0.048427362,
-0.0022638009,
0.0116993496,
-0.0064229518,
-0.0282148011,
0.0599008612,
0.0143910721,
0.0452991016,
-0.0640170798,
0.0529549941,
-0.0271352045,
0.0094369417,
-0.0291478299,
-0.0685508177,
0.0067399302,
0.0180661697,
-0.0182382129,
0.0511591434,
-0.0435107686,
-0.0652543306,
0.0118093546,
-0.0384226255,
-0.0094288243,
0.0400822684,
2.061e-7,
-0.011489775,
0.0173761528,
0.0205499213,
-0.0136715714,
0.0164591651,
0.0704541653,
-0.0335736685,
0.0267306101,
0.0265175756,
-0.0350904614,
0.0338432603,
0.0202093236,
0.0409229957,
-0.0421475172,
-0.0714608207,
0.0159890782,
-0.0144884745,
-0.0165632572,
-0.0384261757,
-0.0155748008,
0.0647160858,
0.1102308482,
-0.0200294722,
-0.0042565987,
0.0078063528,
-0.0782142133,
0.0839384422,
0.0036788762,
-0.036461968,
-0.0008684651,
0.0064549916,
0.0473634154,
-0.0669508204,
-0.0032658649,
-0.0121360328,
0.0160269234,
0.0953418165,
0.0447180867,
-0.0110219438,
-0.0160872154,
-0.0450886264,
0.0722943991,
-0.0320279226,
0.0083893286,
0.0546615459,
-0.0104433196,
-0.0194135476,
-0.0507120416,
-0.0123301027,
0.0061468538,
-0.0144003965,
-0.0392814279,
-0.0290073268,
0.0088259522,
0.0307127945,
-0.011580647,
-0.0484550968,
-0.0706178024,
0.0111322217,
-0.0251857601,
-0.0453313105,
-0.011612785,
-0.0473398566,
-0.004207537,
0.0294859074,
-0.0596139766,
-0.0376162305,
1.444018472e-34,
0.0256519932,
-0.0229399316,
-0.0219071079,
-0.0489839092,
0.0015460125,
0.0078443466,
-0.0067683547,
-0.0127482358,
-0.0218365714,
-0.0763719976,
-0.0117367553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18109v1 | Medical Dialogue Generation via Dual Flow Modeling | 2023-05-29T14:23:34 | 2023-05-29T14:23:34 | Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Cheng, Jian Wang, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue systems (MDS) aim to provide patients with medical services,
such as diagnosis and prescription. Since most patients cannot precisely
describe their symptoms, dialogue understanding is challenging for MDS.
Previous studies mainly addressed this by extracting the mentioned medical
entities as critical dialogue history information. In this work, we argue that
it is also essential to capture the transitions of the medical entities and the
doctor's dialogue acts in each turn, as they help the understanding of how the
dialogue flows and enhance the prediction of the entities and dialogue acts to
be adopted in the following turn. Correspondingly, we propose a Dual Flow
enhanced Medical (DFMed) dialogue generation framework. It extracts the medical
entities and dialogue acts used in the dialogue history and models their
transitions with an entity-centric graph flow and a sequential act flow,
respectively. We employ two sequential models to encode them and devise an
interweaving component to enhance their interactions. Experiments on two
datasets demonstrate that our method exceeds baselines in both automatic and
manual evaluations. | [
0.0431509577,
0.0450230576,
-0.0131126866,
0.0085837394,
-0.0119463457,
-0.0000843833,
-0.0016033381,
-0.0014788015,
0.022985775,
-0.0240591187,
-0.0015404089,
-0.0715036169,
-0.0031408824,
0.0942135751,
0.0103597753,
-0.0951235369,
0.0065504718,
0.0184014812,
0.0361890197,
0.0189847499,
0.0087751439,
0.0091243507,
-0.0631508306,
0.0502885394,
0.0011717264,
-0.005496081,
-0.0326921791,
0.0158307962,
0.0523836985,
-0.0566387773,
-0.0162772033,
0.0330134258,
0.0214903895,
-0.0249469224,
0.0000017614,
-0.0295212064,
0.0265224539,
-0.0042190328,
-0.0514504164,
-0.0641935319,
-0.0085062077,
-0.0312452428,
0.0124921687,
-0.0015454051,
-0.040756207,
-0.0359023809,
0.0227552056,
0.0467609018,
0.0851806104,
0.0714067668,
-0.0339684337,
-0.007254547,
0.0054583913,
-0.0074141496,
-0.0030992532,
-0.0639003366,
0.0242760591,
0.0096562849,
0.0370389894,
-0.0272218082,
-0.0099725276,
0.0231357627,
-0.0022578484,
-0.0392501019,
0.0133801345,
0.038574174,
0.0113390014,
0.0050391862,
-0.0153139699,
0.1168082505,
0.05100853,
0.036496561,
0.0403631218,
-0.0178739075,
0.0187864136,
-0.0243312251,
-0.0524308532,
-0.015499671,
-0.0286019742,
-0.0086203739,
0.0007169052,
0.0117162112,
0.0029695171,
-0.0168100689,
-0.0040133554,
-0.0027811874,
-0.0080409301,
-0.0033532467,
-0.0287356395,
-0.0005206814,
0.0144096427,
-0.0545698516,
0.0450896807,
0.0461615957,
-0.0853490904,
0.0171385705,
-0.0354836136,
0.0128368577,
0.0005603562,
-0.0201158784,
0.0129548656,
0.0072813984,
0.0255476255,
0.0122202616,
0.0295460746,
0.0183672868,
-0.0168785136,
0.020517597,
-0.0328651555,
0.0305128265,
-0.031632971,
-0.0080613354,
-0.0535076074,
0.0285924748,
-0.053431455,
-0.0453668721,
-0.0560522936,
0.0210476518,
-0.0141828917,
0.0089384895,
0.0324359424,
0.042111259,
-0.0084948121,
0.0228732955,
0.0015915731,
0.0183721054,
-0.010832347,
0.0002043298,
0.0418505631,
-0.0156658608,
0.0110343872,
0.032995306,
0.0094720246,
0.0196830984,
-0.0364522152,
0.0607437491,
-0.0169664528,
0.0115540037,
-0.00424622,
-0.0572077371,
-0.0224346127,
-0.0334496163,
0.0041790712,
-0.0156301036,
0.0476460941,
-0.0005868481,
-0.0160396565,
-0.0287400484,
0.0338571072,
-0.0079178931,
-0.0309579223,
0.0228088759,
-0.0215270501,
0.047801245,
0.0227477737,
0.0343205333,
0.028484704,
0.0125513105,
0.0478892922,
-0.0491795726,
0.0159172677,
-0.0149354283,
0.0107760895,
0.0130072851,
0.0288624093,
-0.0331867784,
0.0408150181,
0.020277027,
-0.0493152514,
0.0688460022,
-0.0091414722,
0.0614182092,
-0.0503111854,
-0.0316960588,
0.022260474,
0.0244503152,
0.0022306053,
-0.0079017458,
0.0783719122,
0.0006213913,
-0.0135912793,
0.0444622561,
0.0090953186,
0.0070510372,
0.0554195493,
-0.0079315659,
0.0152689219,
-0.0135819772,
-0.0320293047,
-0.0229004808,
0.0061347927,
-0.0257741027,
0.0057534962,
-0.0210155193,
-0.0073039141,
0.013303603,
-0.0597264878,
0.0754940435,
-0.0022700815,
-0.0372625031,
-0.0239828192,
-0.0482297875,
-0.0390040986,
0.1085049734,
0.068716988,
0.0049875542,
-0.0614651814,
-0.0273711048,
-0.0161018949,
0.0270179827,
0.0474548712,
-0.0400312096,
0.0348448195,
-0.0621502697,
-0.0077361525,
0.0054994617,
0.0037523382,
0.0113071082,
-0.0332106315,
0.0006458785,
0.0111520067,
0.0435995385,
-0.0034055433,
0.0028787018,
-0.068756029,
0.0311975405,
0.0228298046,
-0.0021118461,
0.052544564,
0.0471519977,
0.0051998622,
0.025681328,
0.0271747243,
-0.0053974907,
-0.008016617,
0.0777343735,
-0.0772707611,
-0.0802897885,
-0.0073184459,
0.010494723,
0.0050072093,
-0.0389771461,
-0.0141061358,
-0.0699689314,
-0.0151010025,
-0.0648201555,
0.0126313334,
-0.0024152717,
0.0237982795,
0.0773315057,
0.0034486991,
-0.0173197221,
0.0088456767,
-0.0279391389,
0.0220219679,
0.0309264101,
0.0364498831,
-0.0043125669,
-0.0568533987,
0.023778962,
0.0506432615,
0.0025678729,
-0.0115703857,
-0.0068538007,
0.0088926312,
-0.0512367897,
-0.0007870197,
-0.1209806874,
-0.0166025162,
0.0098429611,
-0.020107951,
0.0110192364,
0.0317020975,
-0.0037863725,
-0.0110671129,
-0.0801762491,
0.0343115404,
0.0896507725,
-0.0166360475,
0.0228991657,
0.0565583445,
-0.0272283461,
-0.0121154534,
0.0112736253,
-0.0275441613,
0.0526705161,
0.0007614843,
-0.0480832346,
-0.0201181844,
0.0003112419,
-0.0485729165,
0.0059101288,
-0.0142310942,
-0.0273949057,
0.0210185573,
-0.0049672476,
0.0207916405,
0.0196726192,
0.026442945,
0.0525360852,
-0.025114879,
-0.0599846244,
-0.0276739728,
0.0392881595,
-0.0447580814,
0.0302314125,
-0.0273356307,
-0.0304281563,
0.0078583304,
0.0683681741,
0.0439068973,
0.0415003896,
-0.0235247146,
-0.0350116603,
0.0365073457,
0.0034559683,
0.0403820351,
-0.0166891515,
-0.0428004973,
0.0299906321,
-0.0070782267,
0.0022960599,
0.091301024,
-0.0074027567,
-0.0210175589,
-0.026697794,
-0.010662985,
-0.0562913604,
0.0310788658,
-0.0097922953,
0.0334611908,
0.0139706377,
-0.0523155257,
0.0041144313,
0.0074781384,
0.0045024725,
-0.0674518943,
0.0427052192,
-0.0338839367,
0.0068217241,
0.014941249,
-0.0329180472,
-0.0531150401,
-0.0051554488,
0.0077546225,
0.0088448804,
0.0356097743,
-0.0180560742,
-0.0462505557,
0.0470772646,
-0.028602805,
0.0542890765,
0.0148880361,
0.007375496,
-0.007449002,
0.069929719,
0.0299174599,
0.0240048654,
-0.0302023795,
-0.0279630907,
0.0807603523,
0.0398393571,
-0.0030611996,
-0.0100713475,
-0.0014251093,
-0.0096201738,
-0.0079909088,
-0.0141658895,
-0.0185920577,
0.0161813386,
0.0394341536,
-0.0493401773,
-0.0300812405,
0.0977202803,
0.0151594123,
-0.0326682478,
0.0216604918,
0.0144870654,
-0.0031691752,
-0.0106121525,
-0.009725119,
-0.0739050284,
-0.0134943034,
-0.0145951398,
0.0365508832,
-0.0181566384,
-0.0480847582,
0.0095111737,
-0.0517564192,
0.0454476438,
0.0272034444,
-0.0128447097,
-0.0146769583,
0.0025591985,
0.015454038,
0.0288082678,
-0.0165294502,
-0.0210697539,
0.0160617847,
-0.0193571765,
-0.0036462159,
-0.0492841229,
-0.0487836301,
0.0119151846,
0.0373660177,
0.0472926125,
0.0451490283,
0.0616147779,
0.0553781576,
0.0045916759,
-0.0064068441,
-0.006087251,
0.002739799,
0.0056768251,
0.0770883858,
-0.0063902866,
-0.0003791856,
-0.046584703,
0.0492558517,
-0.0095676174,
-0.0434853919,
-0.0030905281,
0.0274054781,
-0.0783329681,
-0.0435744077,
-0.0361875445,
0.0728170872,
0.0660424009,
0.0450250246,
0.0149289509,
0.0046224641,
-0.0328718349,
0.0017669213,
0.0387034193,
-0.0595118254,
-0.0170808844,
0.0099269291,
0.0148829678,
-0.0024911172,
-0.0819649026,
-0.0489662923,
0.0114952736,
0.0134735107,
-0.0372104347,
0.0206035599,
0.0200142208,
-0.0041371235,
-0.018288441,
-0.0157258455,
0.0050523533,
0.0201767758,
-0.0386248492,
-0.0706504881,
0.0548521914,
0.0080803288,
-0.0049933488,
0.052585002,
-0.046776697,
-0.0466484055,
-0.0397110283,
0.0413240306,
0.0206778049,
0.0562563762,
0.0060626883,
0.0255928468,
-0.0174954087,
0.0201457776,
-0.0439847447,
-0.0324616879,
0.0069627399,
0.0539710373,
-0.0403330848,
0.0175126605,
0.011379688,
0.0154285477,
-0.0429714732,
0.0771389231,
-0.0617946833,
-0.1062097624,
0.0017342691,
0.0153160375,
0.012112285,
0.0073939729,
-0.0018091653,
-0.0279530231,
0.021912884,
-0.0565879643,
-0.0094711306,
-0.0458219498,
0.0066953772,
-0.003251205,
-0.0318734832,
0.0208355896,
-0.0306571145,
-0.0677012652,
-0.0170401875,
-0.0217721332,
0.0070709265,
0.0302353073,
-0.0258772317,
0.0342046693,
-0.0252471548,
-0.0023731429,
0.0337483026,
0.0236368552,
0.0110116322,
0.0074838907,
0.1146284714,
0.0056165289,
0.0030631803,
0.035751842,
0.0334848985,
-0.0721344501,
-0.0130348634,
-0.040449217,
0.035092812,
0.028335942,
0.0240449477,
0.0367975347,
-0.0165924653,
0.0318821631,
-0.0251025502,
0.0809429809,
-0.0127404165,
-0.0557017662,
0.0432438068,
0.0124858487,
0.0017182308,
0.00476564,
0.0694374815,
-0.0136978123,
0.0281479917,
-0.0030396732,
-0.0377240255,
-0.0826530531,
-0.0684982836,
0.0041171242,
0.0125162052,
-0.024683414,
0.0198207088,
-0.0622494929,
-0.0239393581,
0.0026860572,
-0.0316781402,
-0.0082982359,
-0.0171498023,
0.0617620759,
0.0186078083,
0.0197583027,
-0.0020795178,
-0.060722217,
0.0688624978,
-0.0458934121,
-0.0091919182,
-0.0209476743,
-5.231087614e-33,
-0.0391831137,
-0.0555494912,
0.0400917493,
0.0321339443,
-0.0543219671,
0.0004143469,
-0.0860143825,
0.0039501772,
0.0001015858,
0.029107485,
0.0185912941,
0.0025208455,
-0.0031489437,
0.0426336415,
-0.0331463329,
-0.0304348134,
0.041897431,
-0.0051160343,
-0.0196398124,
0.087152712,
0.0153694227,
0.0325073972,
0.0002128647,
-0.0842208192,
-0.0029878977,
-0.046193853,
0.0130061461,
0.0049695726,
0.014087853,
0.046947889,
-0.0053754589,
0.007241596,
0.0394501537,
0.0031529278,
-0.0229122937,
0.0126781175,
-0.0420806035,
0.0129389446,
-0.0013408737,
-0.0011425932,
-0.0720477402,
-0.0154350316,
-0.0085769268,
-0.0214751158,
0.0254378505,
-0.022342369,
-0.0001048777,
-0.0202074461,
-0.0231259316,
-0.0567979217,
-0.0350577049,
0.0404258221,
-0.0465909764,
-0.0511304326,
-0.0145881549,
0.0471971557,
-0.0035658949,
-0.0513708293,
-0.003200989,
0.0315665379,
-0.0069208723,
-0.0272419695,
-0.0040642638,
-0.0035900455,
-0.0288423095,
0.0565171316,
0.0138628017,
-0.025472831,
-0.0461658128,
0.0702532977,
-0.0597120561,
0.0752590373,
0.0041563674,
0.0304432269,
-0.0546489842,
0.0010300545,
-0.0651318505,
0.0308698118,
-0.0475278161,
0.0513660572,
-0.003550258,
-0.0036254628,
-0.0234217811,
-0.0186525416,
-0.0059365719,
-0.0463242941,
0.0201596208,
-0.0315081812,
0.0158376135,
0.0179323945,
0.0130995177,
-0.0008648598,
0.0304911863,
-0.0152408425,
0.0066976557,
0.0259121452,
-0.0209555887,
0.0194166303,
-0.0455163419,
0.0022357407,
-0.0338922702,
-0.0378680751,
0.0770875439,
0.0123298904,
0.0277226288,
0.047429543,
-0.0006305138,
-0.0280962922,
-0.0103849722,
0.0019397106,
-0.0053536939,
0.0421867408,
-0.0676274002,
0.0416979939,
0.0222331341,
0.0003297463,
-0.0355530009,
0.0803119913,
-0.0251390878,
0.0118287578,
-0.0498427749,
-0.0265074447,
0.0334107168,
0.0429048091,
-0.0744174495,
0.0232001059,
-0.0185169149,
0.0120143713,
0.0389520563,
-0.0278012734,
-0.0005726029,
-0.0011981577,
2.47e-7,
0.027496919,
0.0060059009,
0.0475688316,
0.0194310751,
0.0503372438,
0.0186402127,
-0.0052848719,
0.0239305478,
0.032512337,
-0.0461066924,
0.0417282544,
0.0121046286,
0.0403678082,
0.0179303382,
-0.0755726844,
-0.0504735559,
-0.0799913183,
-0.0533425324,
-0.0279609822,
-0.0249196626,
0.0866353512,
0.0193498451,
-0.0340429619,
0.0065007992,
0.0083790431,
0.0045556701,
0.0699047148,
-0.0040128506,
-0.0182338916,
0.0517898425,
0.0020067645,
-0.0298859179,
-0.0063522095,
0.0324700512,
-0.0359372757,
0.0106326453,
0.0082939584,
0.0869974494,
-0.0208605099,
-0.030122675,
0.0098795379,
0.0006390483,
0.0339152813,
-0.0079192175,
0.0186254382,
-0.0517625362,
-0.0461976789,
0.0023139883,
-0.0422771685,
-0.0161843672,
0.0470318571,
-0.0072774692,
-0.0299733225,
0.0554534793,
0.0141395796,
0.0228607059,
0.02530827,
-0.0727285221,
-0.0224800222,
-0.0053088753,
-0.056880936,
-0.0183588918,
0.0243633781,
-0.0407543704,
-0.0130225644,
-0.0287999045,
-0.0151780453,
2.068084634e-34,
0.0430055633,
0.0201476235,
0.0102208257,
0.0329616033,
0.0353739187,
-0.0331302732,
0.0084902709,
0.026467327,
0.0419650972,
-0.0578254387,
-0.0338145383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18498v2 | ANPL: Towards Natural Programming with Interactive Decomposition | 2023-05-29T14:19:40 | 2023-11-30T16:08:54 | Di Huang, Ziyuan Nan, Xing Hu, Pengwei Jin, Shaohui Peng, Yuanbo Wen, Rui Zhang, Zidong Du, Qi Guo, Yewen Pu, Yunji Chen | cs.PL | cs.PL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Though LLMs are capable of generating plausible programs, it's challenging to
interact with the LLMs further to revise the program, especially if the user's
specific requirements are different from the initial proposal. In this paper,
we introduce ANPL, an interactive programming system that ensures users can
always refine the generated code towards their specific programmatic intents
via structured decompositions. Borrowing the paradigm of sketching from program
synthesis, an ANPL program consists of a set of input-outputs that it must
satisfy, a ``sketch'' -- control/data flow expressed in precise code (e.g.
Python), and ``holes'' -- sub-modules to be implemented by the LLM specified
with natural language. The user revises an ANPL program by either modifying the
sketch, changing the language used to describe the holes, or providing
additional input-outputs to a particular hole, turning it into a sub-ANPL
program that can be solved recursively. This workflow allows the users to
offload programming burdens to the LLM as much as possible while retaining the
ability to pinpoint and resolve bugs locally, without exposing the rest of the
program to the LLM. We deploy ANPL on the Abstraction and Reasoning Corpus
(ARC), a set of unique tasks that are challenging for state-of-the-art AI
systems, showing it outperforms baseline programming systems that (a) without
the ability to decompose tasks interactively and (b) without the guarantee that
the modules can be correctly composed together. Additional evaluations on APPS,
HumanEval, and real-world programming tasks have validated that the ANPL
framework is applicable to multiple programming domains. We release the ANPL
solutions to the ARC tasks as a dataset, providing insights into how humans
decompose novel tasks programmatically. See our code at
https://iprc-dip.github.io/ANPL/. | [
-0.0000236556,
0.0177823696,
-0.0600196831,
0.0085099703,
-0.0215473585,
0.0085597141,
-0.0407596715,
-0.0113886632,
0.0249029323,
0.0078835441,
-0.0052664015,
0.0628999993,
0.0185205452,
0.0694527254,
0.0174650401,
-0.065156959,
0.0045819334,
-0.0324856006,
0.0155690927,
0.0432232395,
-0.018731514,
0.0214210618,
-0.0194701422,
0.0701309666,
0.0120847933,
-0.0176654141,
-0.0655621365,
0.0089778751,
-0.0052121733,
-0.0154525703,
-0.0501934439,
0.0121374428,
0.0121836672,
-0.0144790905,
0.0000023912,
-0.0193194859,
0.0032100521,
0.0117531866,
-0.030372113,
-0.0192879476,
-0.0009889465,
0.0267609637,
-0.0085446639,
0.0086853253,
-0.0538208596,
-0.0161472838,
0.0520988293,
0.0013001361,
0.0991972536,
0.0394780561,
0.0037833508,
-0.0290918238,
-0.0189334191,
0.0506243072,
0.0221317504,
0.006958615,
-0.0199951008,
-0.0025513594,
0.0634976551,
-0.0111194868,
0.0066869739,
0.0092574675,
0.0813676566,
-0.0214167088,
0.0378813185,
0.0057091238,
-0.0087672649,
-0.0725627467,
-0.0093234945,
0.0346270241,
-0.0484853387,
-0.0332328416,
0.028832702,
-0.0098924199,
0.0142681962,
-0.0272276755,
-0.0278371144,
0.0555283017,
-0.0485774167,
0.0090070404,
0.0132552655,
-0.0388571322,
0.0189362932,
-0.0174737871,
-0.0073152306,
0.0358400233,
-0.017563425,
-0.0138194747,
-0.0158188194,
-0.00976629,
0.0068720719,
-0.0562699847,
0.0429983027,
0.0492384657,
-0.0324818082,
-0.0003528428,
-0.0270137377,
-0.0138938501,
-0.0338871293,
0.0181475468,
0.0371841528,
0.0611533299,
0.0042395578,
0.0246066619,
0.0113586523,
0.0240122247,
-0.0049097743,
-0.0098793181,
-0.0492055304,
0.0192465279,
-0.0671074092,
-0.0141864419,
-0.0572476834,
0.0358169638,
-0.0484409183,
0.0609133542,
0.0133253979,
0.0735815763,
-0.0398604348,
0.0589240938,
-0.0141504509,
0.0280986186,
-0.0348405316,
-0.0082186498,
-0.0458353981,
-0.039666947,
-0.0448853523,
-0.0100706294,
0.0078087319,
-0.0259681195,
-0.0172450673,
0.0101378933,
-0.0488768257,
0.0120721254,
0.0051022382,
0.082299307,
0.0016615057,
0.0182806402,
-0.0235890653,
-0.0644320324,
0.0434827097,
-0.0442390852,
0.0166942421,
-0.0836501196,
0.0336591899,
-0.021836482,
-0.0211437587,
-0.0574032962,
-0.017194014,
0.0176512208,
0.0254446566,
0.0777220055,
-0.0507967621,
0.0253639556,
0.0138192549,
0.0317730047,
-0.0321312994,
0.0313800797,
0.0502247103,
0.0093323002,
-0.0067854198,
-0.000949766,
0.0325226076,
0.0049609663,
-0.0247510206,
-0.022851577,
0.0387825631,
-0.0066765225,
-0.0829795301,
0.0416741297,
-0.0134003218,
-0.0004611568,
-0.0238654856,
0.0200108085,
-0.0026131172,
0.0904482305,
0.0045466181,
0.0487752929,
0.0656809211,
0.0149839493,
0.0227267332,
-0.0023775338,
-0.0367789641,
0.0521974266,
-0.0169123076,
0.0006050972,
-0.0377415493,
0.0014543083,
0.0020180435,
-0.0959215239,
-0.0145700425,
0.0319597758,
0.0283664521,
-0.0083222548,
0.0002575028,
0.0446534678,
0.0045655658,
0.0171357077,
-0.0307658315,
-0.0408133343,
-0.0224008262,
-0.0660715029,
0.0431311615,
0.0762897804,
0.0320996493,
-0.0683753639,
-0.0165630281,
0.0130397864,
-0.0552174821,
0.0078184148,
-0.0246127006,
-0.034135785,
0.0165771712,
0.0130626215,
0.0054536872,
-0.0444241203,
0.0041580698,
0.0076525905,
-0.0076179714,
-0.0698832572,
-0.0281288158,
-0.0219329484,
0.0060330438,
0.0295316018,
-0.0259053521,
-0.0051149344,
0.0208237916,
0.0133350333,
0.008341114,
0.0127400169,
0.0000575226,
0.02192959,
0.0479664356,
-0.0306715015,
-0.0163702872,
0.0015595874,
-0.0209686887,
-0.0141689703,
0.0105029317,
-0.0879150033,
-0.042601645,
0.0285269208,
-0.0493389517,
-0.0028081166,
0.0653955266,
-0.0183956288,
0.0132982349,
-0.0044439631,
0.0292681549,
0.0217599794,
-0.0629740059,
-0.0135081206,
0.0403397456,
0.0043851002,
-0.0402902588,
0.03385574,
0.0194692723,
0.0093120588,
-0.0036845552,
-0.0115121333,
0.0074193296,
-0.0088141579,
-0.0058962544,
0.0065107453,
0.0567558296,
-0.0380040258,
-0.0008405639,
-0.0837266818,
0.0131384749,
-0.0107944096,
-0.0053927982,
0.0456991158,
-0.0007740336,
-0.0025696207,
-0.0287659746,
-0.0036283028,
-0.0234264676,
-0.0026052839,
-0.0226962566,
0.062873885,
0.0034749827,
-0.0252319537,
-0.02458735,
0.002089445,
-0.0251654107,
-0.001057832,
0.0087206224,
-0.0601077303,
-0.0826386288,
0.0776270479,
0.0079042902,
0.0119970245,
0.009676584,
-0.0111699039,
0.0347050056,
-0.0112110339,
0.0022749817,
0.0585690029,
-0.0757972971,
0.0619445555,
0.0827788711,
-0.0188072529,
-0.0310401078,
0.0415080264,
0.038011793,
0.0372353494,
0.0104274675,
-0.0399740487,
0.0205822885,
0.060842216,
-0.0069579761,
0.0256373081,
-0.0323154181,
0.063054882,
0.0162300654,
-0.0059247529,
-0.0083441706,
-0.0715457946,
-0.0169531554,
0.0571226142,
-0.0309405923,
-0.0603727065,
0.0956191868,
0.0052748388,
-0.0315348282,
-0.0217008311,
-0.0153379235,
-0.0378703587,
0.1097910181,
-0.0077147936,
-0.0143158454,
0.0546427928,
-0.0212354753,
-0.0371086486,
0.0447940938,
0.006488699,
-0.0099183926,
0.0741862878,
-0.0786543787,
-0.016338367,
0.0024754487,
-0.0622324161,
-0.0255019367,
0.0254852362,
-0.0189410783,
0.00215533,
0.024616098,
-0.0455843285,
0.01439106,
-0.0440612212,
0.0151604144,
0.0093368646,
0.050046429,
-0.0526893586,
-0.0123715401,
-0.0411352366,
-0.0169753321,
0.0507803746,
-0.0119217597,
0.0080196904,
0.0169304684,
0.0630206913,
0.0065434459,
0.016887024,
-0.0414703526,
0.0240344238,
0.0009770727,
-0.0143459234,
-0.0197064653,
0.0326822102,
0.0451523028,
-0.0691952556,
-0.0612361319,
0.0302563235,
0.0502807163,
-0.0115442276,
0.046598658,
-0.0291354898,
0.0245649628,
0.0517624207,
0.062105231,
-0.1090491638,
-0.0396028645,
0.0103346286,
0.0281985682,
-0.0046057003,
-0.0344986506,
-0.0254620463,
-0.0974465311,
0.0665219948,
0.0171427131,
-0.0147022847,
0.0101676118,
-0.0251091737,
-0.0045443159,
0.0109028593,
-0.0621642135,
0.0283218734,
-0.002959976,
0.0222515445,
-0.0217876956,
-0.0539123192,
0.000614379,
0.0356038958,
0.0094196666,
0.0258652326,
0.0377122946,
0.0227133501,
0.0263236314,
0.0073630344,
0.0314449742,
0.0375367738,
0.0399009697,
-0.0400321595,
0.008015166,
0.0324180946,
0.0030249003,
-0.0183865242,
0.0079568103,
-0.0485605933,
-0.0696377084,
0.0051578544,
0.0957287326,
-0.0551980957,
0.0062893154,
-0.0416502617,
-0.0194024574,
0.0026220386,
0.039505206,
0.0457537547,
0.0014644336,
-0.0615663007,
-0.0505150184,
-0.0301125869,
-0.0550380088,
-0.0450010113,
-0.0036770799,
-0.0125812721,
-0.0220581032,
-0.0702162609,
-0.0064399941,
0.0583003648,
0.0420380943,
0.0108947549,
-0.0567253567,
0.0361974612,
0.0062342309,
-0.0612857901,
0.0182741396,
0.0255616121,
-0.0106023829,
0.0496912077,
-0.034761522,
-0.0484042391,
-0.0363019779,
0.0052025351,
0.0437626801,
-0.0713682473,
-0.0304246899,
0.0044830125,
0.0780686066,
0.0307106934,
0.0017183222,
-0.0201022681,
-0.0387037136,
0.0164231434,
0.0388225913,
0.0033720501,
0.0166816898,
0.0007803694,
0.0276605356,
0.0323430784,
0.0040290095,
-0.0507103577,
-0.0167211201,
0.0121899704,
0.0007387373,
-0.0048822709,
0.0273772776,
0.0297990758,
0.0626824722,
-0.0179323386,
0.0175255872,
-0.0153117655,
-0.0250559449,
-0.0029370773,
-0.0044176136,
-0.0445362404,
-0.0558040887,
0.0440119319,
-0.0527444594,
-0.0223758202,
0.0574577674,
0.0345946625,
-0.0141310627,
0.045001734,
0.0138329314,
0.0358849838,
0.0660597831,
0.0362100489,
0.0202237498,
0.0369455479,
-0.0077034724,
0.0470557809,
-0.0277635045,
0.0657035485,
0.0039482233,
0.027957093,
0.0087811314,
0.0271669403,
-0.0310184751,
0.052151911,
-0.018094223,
-0.1186774969,
0.0203045718,
0.0144315716,
0.0156984963,
0.0624947734,
-0.0238789637,
-0.0475851595,
0.0198419057,
0.012476027,
0.0282383729,
0.0046009477,
-0.0575200319,
-0.0190031845,
0.0286475159,
-0.0029526637,
-0.0860966519,
0.0329871438,
-0.0868441686,
0.0360171758,
-0.0164117515,
-0.0179514363,
-0.0459542871,
-0.0334294587,
-0.024390107,
-0.0085017327,
-0.0141063286,
-0.0647439361,
-0.0465878211,
-0.0547779575,
-0.0087040011,
0.0439403616,
-0.0021589613,
0.0235548727,
0.0434878841,
0.057642702,
0.0308734234,
-0.0508901998,
0.024016669,
0.0009771195,
-0.0134609118,
-0.0453957357,
-0.0450935736,
-5.793544396e-33,
-0.0380492099,
-0.0523651987,
0.0334349088,
-0.0151405521,
0.0034052527,
-0.003842389,
-0.0608266443,
0.0483535826,
0.030555917,
-0.0127495416,
0.002455475,
0.0061973659,
-0.0169461183,
-0.043452099,
0.0380839631,
-0.0160304327,
0.0273596775,
0.023302611,
-0.0529071055,
-0.005461928,
0.0349691845,
-0.0158989895,
0.0049724365,
-0.0431134291,
-0.0062968815,
0.024285404,
-0.0225110911,
0.03242331,
-0.0098945443,
0.0246221498,
-0.0031520005,
0.0073601049,
0.0288733337,
0.028221868,
-0.0423216484,
0.0268059317,
-0.0282674301,
-0.0674623325,
0.0328377634,
-0.0069227754,
-0.096978806,
-0.0407207645,
0.0756703839,
0.0312695056,
-0.0267058536,
0.019236898,
0.0210803263,
0.0028609794,
0.0591519699,
0.0052756863,
-0.0458336361,
-0.0104960026,
-0.0468482338,
-0.0348949507,
-0.0131846527,
0.0105433688,
-0.0091188718,
-0.016528761,
-0.039009247,
0.0053281439,
0.0267124753,
-0.0173442978,
0.0506394915,
-0.0490834266,
0.0102120806,
0.0330397561,
0.0300768651,
0.0185393374,
-0.0793778822,
-0.0028409418,
-0.0014732388,
0.078758359,
0.0029632272,
0.0009398901,
0.0554038249,
0.0449143276,
-0.0193835162,
0.0521078072,
-0.0041004256,
0.0663824528,
-0.0223218054,
0.0616428033,
-0.0172573533,
-0.0018841404,
-0.0188548658,
-0.0102452179,
-0.0073022079,
-0.0369586349,
0.0095200296,
-0.0043265191,
-0.0107701905,
-0.0316765085,
-0.0353068896,
-0.018414123,
0.040800862,
-0.0352439657,
-0.0510937646,
0.0322054327,
0.0053901644,
-0.0063529485,
0.0163977873,
-0.0079041813,
0.0077722711,
-0.0046179066,
0.0918635353,
0.019964328,
-0.0204393044,
0.0544535816,
-0.0277769435,
0.0005414488,
-0.0653685406,
0.0172273312,
0.0148763033,
0.02937763,
0.0057321978,
0.0086357528,
-0.0199384335,
-0.00607409,
-0.012673256,
-0.0051250765,
-0.0629921407,
0.0781689063,
0.0079703461,
-0.0053925188,
0.010722978,
-0.0394452214,
-0.0243665483,
0.0222223047,
0.0486561917,
-0.0402763486,
-0.0245992094,
0.0272386484,
3.107e-7,
-0.0041229981,
-0.0078467317,
0.0359374806,
0.0375133269,
0.0213526357,
0.0412544794,
-0.0107534481,
0.0165188164,
-0.0129865259,
-0.018163316,
-0.0167184062,
0.0213277824,
0.0181191713,
0.0519589335,
-0.0930280834,
0.0252500232,
0.0263390634,
0.0012874199,
-0.0644454956,
0.0135824541,
0.0682220832,
0.0220444966,
0.0459983684,
-0.013842565,
0.0412953384,
-0.0057031908,
-0.0218108632,
-0.0111526437,
0.0339515135,
-0.0170730166,
-0.060787566,
0.0294743925,
0.0006118524,
0.0072383666,
-0.0171920024,
-0.0359530933,
-0.0254466496,
0.0468367413,
-0.0033265357,
0.0082155056,
-0.0161785707,
-0.0296323169,
0.0146249132,
-0.0189766306,
0.0208052229,
-0.0429710746,
-0.0177752264,
-0.0032317413,
0.0312302429,
-0.0056398008,
-0.0170531534,
-0.0103800911,
0.0273217056,
0.0093815485,
-0.0193034932,
-0.0192277096,
-0.029688444,
-0.0533420295,
-0.0212075897,
0.0068175886,
-0.0498637594,
-0.0087684244,
-0.0352449231,
0.0166812427,
0.0430101976,
-0.0452797078,
-0.007425474,
2.999567939e-34,
-0.0093506603,
-0.0034537159,
0.0297940988,
0.0551979356,
0.0387779437,
0.0291510392,
-0.0054899203,
0.0126105985,
0.0344573669,
0.002856811,
-0.0426715799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18099v1 | Writing user personas with Large Language Models: Testing phase 6 of a Thematic Analysis of semi-structured interviews | 2023-05-29T14:09:14 | 2023-05-29T14:09:14 | Stefano De Paoli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | The goal of this paper is establishing if we can satisfactorily perform a
Thematic Analysis (TA) of semi-structured interviews using a Large Language
Model (more precisely GPT3.5-Turbo). Building on previous work by the author,
which established an embryonal process for conducting a TA with the model, this
paper will perform a further analysis and then cover the last phase of a TA
(phase 6), which entails the writing up of the result. This phase was not
covered by the previous work. In particular, the focus will be on using the
results of a TA done with the LLM on a dataset of user interviews, for writing
user personas, with the model building on the TA to produce the personas
narratives. User personas are models of real users, usually built from a data
analysis like interviews with a sample of users. User personas are tools often
used in User Centered Design processes. The paper shows that the model can
build basic user personas with an acceptable quality deriving them from themes,
and that the model can serve for the generation of ideas for user personas. | [
0.0871383175,
-0.0098658092,
-0.0568531826,
0.0432052165,
-0.0158769302,
-0.009979777,
-0.0247418471,
-0.084721759,
-0.0167802647,
-0.0139390426,
-0.0030636289,
-0.0085427696,
-0.0142638357,
0.058827918,
-0.0042815674,
-0.053787712,
0.005181883,
0.0010722139,
-0.0057702474,
0.033234667,
0.0255849641,
0.0631811544,
0.0259175822,
0.0507593788,
0.0114212157,
-0.0414375477,
-0.0230475776,
0.0198164377,
0.0285569709,
-0.0326444618,
0.023496829,
0.0049299584,
0.0327381007,
-0.020345334,
0.000002565,
-0.0120695755,
0.0136963977,
-0.0017027563,
-0.01009716,
-0.009386762,
0.0431448631,
0.1041004211,
-0.0302874651,
0.0014645989,
-0.0256101675,
0.0079982793,
0.0129605364,
0.0570367686,
0.0734194741,
0.0297422335,
-0.027787324,
-0.1035682634,
-0.0436283648,
0.0183162075,
-0.0227652062,
0.0257002451,
-0.0477709398,
-0.0056213844,
0.0494125895,
-0.0013876676,
0.0393217988,
-0.014080382,
0.0087381369,
0.0042980695,
0.0177449416,
0.0003386409,
-0.0046437867,
-0.0575619899,
0.0026463552,
0.0386995003,
0.0905620679,
0.0278405342,
-0.0071200351,
0.0349599048,
0.0305924285,
0.0133884894,
-0.0150336716,
-0.0042995713,
-0.0403320156,
-0.0089501431,
-0.0311242249,
0.0304229073,
-0.0100649139,
-0.0214467272,
-0.0317381732,
0.0439784713,
0.0014166229,
-0.0108987819,
-0.0285660215,
-0.0318445899,
0.0402352586,
0.004873049,
-0.0391555578,
0.0088884803,
-0.0090617863,
0.0134400148,
0.0200879481,
0.0636246428,
0.0071025766,
-0.0714408681,
0.0281308554,
0.0224305782,
0.0402388461,
-0.0069087278,
0.0332002901,
0.0318740159,
0.0011861399,
-0.060009446,
-0.0354891866,
0.0196381211,
-0.0451374762,
-0.0241575204,
-0.0361938886,
0.0273874756,
0.002211438,
0.0054559736,
-0.0280700531,
0.0508236215,
0.0296146348,
0.029950548,
-0.0308079887,
0.008227882,
-0.0395165868,
0.0161966626,
-0.0113563919,
0.0113168759,
-0.0479211509,
0.0123480428,
-0.0326848552,
-0.0309553687,
0.0774618164,
0.0202776399,
-0.0194739532,
-0.0269960649,
-0.0282414574,
0.0233972538,
-0.0041783345,
-0.0007196233,
-0.079241477,
-0.0685638115,
0.028600255,
-0.05910483,
-0.0154614644,
-0.0592982993,
-0.0195665713,
0.0376149006,
0.0191500112,
-0.0473726131,
-0.0116094174,
0.0382120311,
0.0092000142,
0.0178443231,
-0.0221352112,
0.0402441435,
0.043802835,
0.0380799957,
0.0612552986,
0.0130817806,
0.0332731269,
0.0493602604,
-0.0123301176,
-0.0684164837,
-0.0062085674,
0.0371027961,
-0.0590383708,
-0.0040900065,
0.0107447682,
0.0237903614,
-0.0017244576,
-0.0005267639,
0.0170940813,
0.0495270528,
-0.0159669928,
0.0793417618,
0.0652470663,
0.0725928992,
0.0228588581,
0.0597377717,
0.0503906086,
0.0339471288,
0.0129780481,
0.0263004135,
0.0469799004,
-0.0185297132,
0.0288487524,
-0.0035108414,
-0.0435885973,
0.0281592589,
-0.0396846384,
-0.0181554835,
0.0149833979,
0.015473864,
0.0142275281,
0.0405232161,
-0.0360521711,
0.0111436155,
-0.027464278,
0.0005110587,
-0.0379043147,
-0.0962025523,
-0.0039203763,
-0.0180281103,
0.0368133858,
0.1132011339,
0.0018349985,
0.028450232,
0.005755771,
-0.0289048348,
-0.024326697,
0.0431829877,
0.0332148299,
-0.0140829673,
-0.0812425613,
-0.0020811346,
0.0195737705,
-0.0539410971,
-0.0443869717,
0.0308419038,
-0.0394429192,
0.0103791216,
0.023441432,
0.0346516594,
-0.0106743323,
-0.0124202427,
-0.068521224,
-0.0079123881,
-0.0138233611,
0.0085031632,
0.0104625328,
0.0708962679,
-0.007126458,
0.0159567855,
0.0285958182,
-0.0162543058,
0.0261233356,
0.0660673156,
0.0186398234,
0.0379063115,
0.0173327904,
-0.0390900187,
0.0045231115,
0.0215646848,
0.040908508,
-0.0239586961,
0.0673072487,
-0.0364131369,
0.0244860165,
-0.0077876463,
-0.0074263536,
0.007836787,
0.0033989393,
-0.032289777,
0.0272154845,
0.0155694447,
0.002971686,
-0.036356438,
-0.0249272082,
0.0537213497,
-0.0583774596,
-0.0158408042,
0.0327591859,
0.0207784958,
0.0251050666,
0.05215846,
-0.0304481685,
-0.0623505265,
-0.0215461385,
-0.1337739378,
-0.0157359485,
-0.0061375657,
0.0270498395,
0.0219169687,
0.0221791193,
-0.0574105196,
0.0005535788,
-0.057464648,
-0.0604668371,
0.0109363915,
-0.0116649792,
0.047392305,
0.0247503631,
-0.0207084995,
-0.0038499874,
0.0153195355,
-0.0183965862,
0.0206870176,
0.0453807898,
-0.0210680664,
-0.03084171,
0.0108695058,
-0.0099388147,
-0.073390156,
0.0117537947,
-0.0339431427,
0.042795714,
0.0262403339,
0.1048915759,
-0.0482871495,
0.0060919104,
0.0836067423,
-0.0348937996,
-0.0383668914,
0.0212840922,
0.0112394076,
0.0371877253,
-0.0260629766,
-0.021753855,
-0.1049212888,
0.0910067484,
0.0240980461,
0.0047901245,
0.0238675196,
-0.0552656464,
0.0469642133,
-0.024100339,
0.0344750024,
0.0258685518,
-0.0369542763,
-0.0087373434,
0.0625184104,
0.0232278723,
0.0146945193,
0.014388442,
-0.0142102577,
0.02262838,
-0.0129048619,
-0.0654338226,
-0.0428780615,
0.0512950756,
-0.0395158119,
0.0448768511,
0.0041970438,
-0.0036807237,
0.0048637879,
-0.0720492974,
-0.0045485324,
-0.0219550319,
0.012254592,
-0.0392352082,
-0.0187184289,
-0.0119187618,
-0.0182331204,
-0.0221035872,
-0.0122650405,
-0.0282241963,
-0.0179941952,
0.0055816127,
0.0304580554,
-0.0244232491,
-0.0103773829,
0.0056562661,
0.0269026123,
0.0012711593,
-0.0105540659,
0.0076391534,
-0.0069113169,
0.0174422916,
-0.036366798,
-0.024233805,
-0.0101800505,
0.0509289913,
-0.0037983116,
-0.0195188038,
-0.013626839,
-0.0327770002,
-0.0345626175,
0.0226856098,
-0.0190342497,
-0.0335262157,
0.0230402537,
0.0387450121,
-0.0057354076,
0.019442942,
0.0713261142,
0.0045943856,
-0.0054101166,
0.0318480097,
0.0062366189,
-0.0115955044,
0.0228012111,
0.0685956478,
-0.0442445688,
0.0373970978,
-0.0340413004,
0.0194208696,
-0.047431834,
-0.0151071008,
-0.036859367,
-0.0433654487,
0.0571026318,
-0.0004110125,
-0.0027434649,
0.024020467,
-0.0016509254,
-0.0261692945,
0.0364419222,
0.0212629009,
0.015889179,
-0.0310438387,
0.0124220541,
0.0232457221,
-0.0885904729,
-0.06137098,
0.0129780471,
-0.011983389,
0.0016631056,
0.0562949069,
0.0695257485,
-0.0160726104,
-0.0331047922,
-0.0215775985,
0.0275568496,
0.0301607884,
0.0389368981,
-0.0281354208,
-0.0243188236,
-0.0033836842,
-0.0525004305,
0.0509258062,
-0.0416822955,
-0.0293524303,
0.0408315212,
0.021606056,
-0.0724547952,
-0.0043960423,
-0.0443918481,
-0.0133739952,
0.0025195335,
0.017615933,
0.0188644491,
-0.0458780788,
0.0058121262,
-0.0167962331,
0.0135503905,
0.0217458811,
-0.0958557799,
-0.006783823,
0.0209399182,
0.0322329067,
0.0146589708,
-0.0920408368,
0.0034122192,
0.0235463399,
0.0149740931,
0.0123740435,
-0.0227292702,
0.0070598698,
-0.0493336804,
0.0289639439,
-0.0235416926,
0.0712199584,
-0.0411857404,
0.0127848601,
0.0136463055,
-0.033207044,
0.0405894741,
-0.0161656458,
-0.0141057549,
-0.0080479318,
0.004642495,
0.0363638848,
0.0240997635,
-0.0336059295,
0.0496877693,
-0.0610536747,
-0.0051062843,
-0.0167397596,
-0.069500111,
0.0154971257,
-0.0471737087,
0.0612574294,
-0.0304933339,
-0.0189084932,
0.0136479083,
-0.012060564,
-0.021654902,
-0.0188068021,
-0.0254586712,
-0.0377357453,
0.0277673174,
0.05791476,
0.0050857579,
-0.0273691509,
0.0290131606,
-0.0083419047,
-0.026854692,
-0.030765865,
-0.0616239719,
-0.021395538,
-0.0142792305,
0.0082565686,
0.0061003733,
0.0123411417,
-0.0596552528,
-0.1058985293,
0.0276255049,
-0.0338764004,
0.039874997,
0.0112935891,
0.0092802038,
-0.010913156,
-0.0230808239,
-0.0251874644,
0.0105906641,
-0.015125609,
0.0407021865,
0.0404350199,
0.0401721857,
-0.0084338067,
0.0559736602,
0.0232379157,
0.0575043559,
0.0205461066,
-0.0577448979,
-0.0027426942,
-0.0383749902,
-0.027258072,
0.0260798782,
0.0054662093,
-0.0471258573,
0.029031042,
-0.0258021057,
0.0258344319,
0.0028601456,
-0.0175127666,
-0.0111281639,
0.011990306,
-0.0451530293,
-0.0790785477,
0.0320582278,
-0.000311286,
-0.0184986964,
-0.0430867411,
-0.0577597804,
-0.0508165993,
-0.0212518033,
0.0215353705,
-0.011382021,
-0.0128771914,
-0.0310136825,
-0.093543835,
-0.0593892634,
-0.0117790056,
-0.0252812579,
0.0131003335,
-0.0468170233,
0.0230309535,
0.0264370628,
0.0036501768,
-0.0410970673,
-0.0630981848,
-0.0111067668,
-0.0772846639,
0.0320087522,
0.0412674844,
-6.634223426e-33,
-0.0404451638,
-0.0438181944,
0.0827195197,
0.0178520214,
-0.0535827763,
-0.0452646241,
-0.0101845097,
0.0231935196,
0.0208820943,
-0.0069034998,
-0.0231347512,
-0.0425855108,
-0.0052524162,
-0.0036001657,
-0.0004811692,
0.0410893783,
0.0947430432,
0.0203956459,
-0.023745941,
0.0270917378,
-0.0263322406,
-0.0012708509,
0.0179990642,
-0.0607405454,
0.0286596864,
-0.0557637773,
-0.0433999151,
-0.0119105885,
0.0389551222,
0.0023652066,
-0.0087694535,
-0.0007355119,
0.039459452,
0.0048539722,
0.0041486518,
0.0333935767,
-0.0213226769,
-0.0019831143,
0.0580000691,
0.0538654961,
0.0284539778,
-0.0741548613,
-0.013792349,
-0.0422173664,
-0.0297914911,
0.0318782255,
0.0369970538,
-0.0058416557,
0.0383169912,
-0.0108175874,
-0.0609028339,
-0.0096471468,
-0.0305820145,
0.0150171882,
-0.0164008737,
0.0392600223,
-0.0492162779,
-0.0369325019,
-0.0287226178,
0.0156777147,
-0.0030018543,
-0.0437689237,
0.0363323838,
0.0458688959,
-0.0079600895,
0.0123201916,
-0.0007198401,
0.0769669563,
-0.0481603481,
0.0179231819,
-0.007322209,
0.0320716463,
0.0021029515,
0.0376898721,
-0.0543232411,
-0.0172372311,
0.0243492946,
0.0338470377,
0.0332885124,
0.0196192134,
0.0393506698,
0.0133784218,
-0.0244532004,
-0.0527118519,
-0.0342463292,
-0.0082994709,
-0.0030255639,
-0.0643510148,
-0.0108697172,
-0.0689551085,
-0.026930334,
0.021925902,
0.008931512,
-0.0318424664,
-0.021182524,
-0.0376818366,
-0.0481435284,
-0.022863701,
-0.0189380161,
0.0403160863,
-0.0113238962,
0.006102758,
-0.0013912515,
0.0333251357,
0.0330501869,
0.0224089194,
-0.0335986279,
0.0111369351,
-0.0409540497,
-0.0241203494,
-0.0063934359,
0.0228172876,
-0.0044248644,
0.0124299936,
0.0052934238,
0.0078536766,
-0.0146733532,
0.0189555474,
0.0205962118,
-0.0217011813,
-0.0206585526,
-0.0117182583,
-0.0120958425,
-0.015798213,
0.0043840455,
-0.0056056143,
-0.0361459851,
0.0525337942,
0.1189698875,
-0.0150971841,
-0.0143702896,
-0.008598445,
3.355e-7,
-0.035305351,
-0.0050391024,
-0.0331587084,
0.0143266963,
0.0186564196,
0.0342683755,
0.0415725522,
0.0476367809,
0.0159928203,
-0.0034380849,
0.015850924,
0.0183285289,
0.0153264124,
0.0363899097,
-0.0959754959,
0.0428831652,
0.0155994687,
-0.0016279974,
-0.0963362083,
0.0725665689,
0.0646269247,
-0.0094568348,
0.0026658634,
-0.0150520131,
-0.0241938625,
0.0095270006,
0.0169607755,
-0.0286938548,
-0.0534021221,
0.0368885957,
0.0240340922,
0.0077008628,
0.0024754086,
0.0187255628,
0.0450912789,
-0.0049694423,
0.048300121,
0.0250056088,
0.0000013293,
0.0556709617,
0.0462725945,
-0.0121633615,
-0.0211387202,
-0.0322150402,
0.0225627013,
-0.0301949643,
-0.0509094,
0.015608035,
-0.0321180262,
-0.035690859,
0.0150478045,
-0.0384894833,
-0.0111347353,
0.0582806915,
0.0137950163,
-0.0502074175,
-0.012577666,
-0.0075855711,
0.0470699035,
0.0232070256,
-0.0095009319,
-0.0193710495,
-0.0221622288,
0.0346185192,
0.0330248624,
-0.0407049172,
0.0685752258,
2.552124509e-34,
-0.0136628812,
0.0375899002,
-0.0240770429,
0.0135730859,
0.0746731237,
0.0360793211,
0.0270828083,
0.0376735292,
0.0522495955,
-0.047686018,
0.0019940306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18098v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18098v3 | BigTranslate: Augmenting Large Language Models with Multilingual Translation Capability over 100 Languages | 2023-05-29T14:07:52 | 2023-11-21T11:01:24 | Wen Yang, Chong Li, Jiajun Zhang, Chengqing Zong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate promising translation performance
among various natural languages. However, many LLMs especially the open-sourced
ones, such as BLOOM and LLaMA, are English-dominant and support only dozens of
natural languages, making the potential of LLMs on language translation less
explored. In this work, we present BigTranslate which adapts LLaMA that covers
only 20 languages and enhances it with multilingual translation capability on
more than 100 languages. BigTranslate is built upon LLaMA-13B and it is
optimized in three steps. First, we continue training LLaMA with massive
Chinese monolingual data. Second, we continue training the model with a
large-scale parallel dataset that covers 102 natural languages. Third, we
instruct-tune the foundation model with multilingual translation instructions,
leading to our BigTranslate model. The preliminary experiments on multilingual
translation show that BigTranslate performs comparably with ChatGPT and Google
Translate in many languages and even outperforms ChatGPT in 8 language pairs.
We release the BigTranslate model and hope it can advance the research
progress. | [
0.0249758586,
0.0461772084,
0.0004487818,
0.0596373677,
-0.0245723817,
0.0214009136,
0.0548558012,
0.0112041561,
0.0095911566,
-0.0191510972,
-0.0558386557,
-0.0559417345,
0.0083899712,
0.011258916,
0.0299353637,
-0.039662499,
0.0318059772,
-0.0274347235,
-0.0362235457,
-0.002168166,
-0.0024765525,
0.0283877961,
0.0465578362,
0.0249454882,
0.0267805122,
-0.0154795488,
0.0184830818,
0.0467641652,
0.0448528379,
-0.0296729654,
-0.0014331074,
-0.0191053916,
0.0206143223,
0.0850339457,
0.0000020627,
-0.0343479216,
-0.033106111,
0.0148398848,
0.01805548,
0.0554596111,
0.0670678914,
-0.0581772514,
-0.0157834813,
0.0448798053,
-0.0102750976,
-0.032685969,
0.0708743781,
0.0484374911,
0.0458368808,
0.0919973403,
-0.0156312659,
-0.0651177242,
0.0267510414,
-0.0690437555,
-0.018209897,
-0.0489648916,
-0.0040887473,
0.0135173267,
-0.027852172,
0.0411376283,
-0.0108213834,
0.0414495096,
0.0019075914,
-0.0006468113,
-0.0219998974,
0.0119937724,
-0.0167144444,
-0.0398077071,
-0.0041533601,
0.0829617009,
-0.0719437078,
-0.0133572901,
-0.0164387152,
-0.0072537228,
-0.0347413868,
-0.0407011956,
-0.0453661531,
0.0181026645,
0.029164575,
0.0236225072,
0.0232442152,
0.0029292118,
0.0718784332,
0.0082969777,
-0.0433434471,
-0.015299106,
0.0375927761,
-0.0063444646,
-0.0097870352,
-0.0026491694,
0.0105869994,
-0.0241759401,
0.0662407279,
0.0049020355,
-0.0175495651,
0.0115298675,
-0.0173760392,
-0.0257366877,
0.0260682907,
-0.0771935135,
0.0170150492,
0.0760215148,
-0.029274242,
0.0586843081,
-0.0493999384,
0.0347796045,
-0.0663448125,
0.0040868921,
-0.0995459184,
-0.0354898535,
0.000771974,
0.0276213568,
-0.0327168703,
-0.0066191754,
-0.0510536358,
-0.0331062637,
-0.0378108658,
0.0083447453,
0.0269461349,
-0.0064101689,
0.0190957561,
-0.0326951593,
-0.0575151742,
-0.0362871885,
0.0286028758,
0.0781585723,
-0.0128777009,
-0.0105314115,
0.0058569009,
-0.0455547832,
-0.0132512031,
0.009790631,
0.0075447233,
-0.0258230492,
0.0206760745,
0.0681068897,
-0.022295177,
-0.0272339657,
-0.0381579138,
0.0111092357,
0.0134115377,
-0.0458520465,
-0.0227150414,
-0.0663977936,
0.0548082031,
0.0131680248,
0.0538857244,
-0.0222262032,
0.0315571465,
-0.0031551768,
-0.0193543509,
0.0682725981,
0.0019813478,
-0.0038620045,
0.0256460235,
-0.0089211063,
0.0080461642,
0.0831766725,
0.0270646848,
0.0226998478,
0.0443627462,
0.0087017277,
-0.0331827998,
0.0865875632,
-0.0105621368,
0.0317325667,
-0.0177374799,
-0.0042973319,
0.0393831171,
0.054727748,
0.0121861948,
0.0480854288,
-0.0243302472,
0.0307692047,
0.0486687683,
0.0213631913,
0.0022707866,
0.0570268035,
0.0256708823,
-0.0070577068,
-0.0059832837,
-0.0414078459,
-0.0293828398,
0.0213716514,
0.0175236985,
-0.0084395222,
0.0353553444,
0.0773426816,
-0.0124169532,
-0.0106182247,
-0.0121717649,
-0.0380915254,
0.0092461146,
-0.0025703493,
0.0362384841,
-0.0035173397,
-0.042553138,
0.0493046455,
0.0235623848,
-0.0430183932,
0.0140543394,
-0.0297037624,
-0.0156633928,
0.072206445,
0.0510501154,
0.0251814108,
-0.040638186,
-0.0209109634,
0.017155908,
0.0507039092,
0.0732345805,
0.0110289324,
0.0192686114,
-0.0763290823,
-0.0009170542,
0.0257503409,
-0.0038643216,
0.0274022166,
0.0374718495,
0.0558730811,
0.0368807018,
-0.0141994404,
-0.0718900114,
0.0227235686,
-0.0574470498,
-0.0136902276,
0.0205170065,
-0.0081338882,
0.0130958436,
-0.0015994861,
-0.0223274529,
-0.0182565898,
0.0251478665,
-0.0575761795,
-0.0417947918,
0.0342210568,
-0.0144389803,
-0.0361316279,
0.0584414229,
-0.0110640014,
0.0064963112,
0.0065571601,
-0.0765848011,
-0.0463292077,
-0.0110331969,
-0.0177863725,
0.0190617274,
-0.018818127,
0.0452258177,
-0.0132845668,
0.0414138436,
-0.0155090373,
0.0115103303,
0.0254409034,
-0.0066678436,
-0.0162477251,
0.0048895963,
0.0206849724,
0.0145099247,
-0.0412274748,
0.0568584576,
0.0125576928,
0.0391156524,
0.0131651545,
0.0280707777,
-0.0243692454,
-0.0332841538,
-0.0864503384,
0.0437334329,
-0.0052563413,
0.0293775182,
0.0326947868,
0.0590781681,
0.0021247943,
0.0020334832,
-0.0166691802,
0.0163569991,
0.0046931668,
0.0105939647,
-0.0164829697,
-0.0276233461,
-0.0099487761,
-0.0308875497,
0.0021026994,
0.0416803807,
0.0136851761,
0.0011002214,
-0.0293644443,
-0.0464895219,
-0.0014120959,
-0.0422119461,
0.0003440057,
-0.0035130279,
-0.0730067194,
-0.033555828,
-0.0223004986,
0.0427153744,
0.0352631435,
-0.0132912584,
-0.0205621812,
0.0303412061,
-0.0074118613,
-0.0451790504,
0.0101915626,
0.0047145681,
-0.0516344011,
-0.0326019861,
-0.0463250019,
-0.0299086124,
0.0298209749,
-0.02017406,
-0.0183552429,
-0.0458828919,
-0.0600720569,
-0.0346517228,
-0.0021903538,
-0.0008222392,
0.0497568361,
-0.0094162645,
0.0194237605,
-0.027213648,
-0.0411399268,
0.0432791188,
-0.0453822874,
-0.0201015919,
-0.0437823161,
-0.0022979241,
-0.0565406568,
0.0452344902,
-0.0271795709,
0.0426183417,
-0.0469909906,
0.0045170491,
-0.0148217669,
0.0331183523,
-0.0158414636,
-0.0332572833,
0.0318151042,
-0.0471106581,
-0.0046727443,
-0.0389585458,
-0.0254559461,
-0.0135766827,
0.0005621502,
-0.0392274112,
-0.013046572,
0.0276567712,
-0.029724285,
-0.0664901063,
0.0076590818,
0.0140845487,
0.0642138794,
-0.0202498995,
0.0076514413,
-0.005858487,
0.0091396524,
0.0085727833,
0.0070838029,
0.0175768789,
-0.0391994938,
0.0319184475,
0.0273099355,
-0.0053861174,
-0.0435643047,
-0.0224934947,
-0.0387879051,
0.0323075093,
-0.0072043152,
-0.04428133,
-0.0235546976,
0.0504373014,
-0.0490955859,
-0.0058174678,
0.101817131,
0.0265992284,
-0.0475604497,
-0.0162441675,
-0.037297789,
0.0204510596,
0.022843929,
0.0288716387,
-0.1080139279,
-0.0486370586,
0.0096578123,
-0.0108436737,
0.0345646851,
0.0349258035,
-0.0152144153,
-0.1073854044,
0.0300766751,
0.0421109684,
-0.0368087776,
-0.0364330932,
-0.0192323104,
-0.0315111913,
-0.0224729273,
0.0234299749,
-0.0120919375,
0.0204449575,
-0.0178819392,
0.0015637273,
0.0513885356,
-0.0353204235,
0.0119575914,
-0.0596650019,
0.0512215197,
0.0440547243,
0.0578026734,
-0.012808729,
0.0014791485,
0.0356656834,
0.0120029813,
-0.0255725533,
-0.0108745815,
0.0011547486,
0.0235348064,
-0.023236597,
0.0300058909,
-0.0005649329,
-0.0425811149,
0.0184474848,
0.0426333882,
0.0574258342,
0.0139218187,
-0.0122813592,
0.0187748056,
-0.0307070781,
-0.0181116629,
0.0462204814,
-0.0096030189,
-0.035058137,
-0.0234623495,
-0.0337404348,
-0.0429366976,
-0.0267107114,
-0.0238127038,
0.0073965895,
-0.0691268966,
-0.028706843,
-0.0806829482,
-0.0218091719,
0.003607234,
0.0104530929,
0.0375433974,
0.016590083,
0.0095579065,
0.0020820892,
-0.0147464639,
0.0090817446,
-0.0517256595,
0.0362702012,
-0.0501594245,
0.0399833992,
0.0500021875,
-0.0307863932,
0.0197510663,
0.0565616973,
-0.0858132318,
-0.0776072741,
-0.0276772305,
0.0265253261,
0.0150920302,
0.0059211338,
-0.0476159751,
-0.0451906919,
0.0135681527,
0.0317539684,
-0.0176359955,
0.0023998723,
0.0322526135,
-0.0018112126,
0.0068171578,
0.0646252707,
-0.0199569575,
0.0197091103,
-0.0311085768,
0.051618427,
0.0142608872,
-0.0344562009,
-0.0081502413,
0.0419966616,
0.0100303963,
-0.0403899886,
-0.0142868329,
-0.0351553075,
0.0437523015,
-0.0249350648,
-0.024772821,
-0.0465844572,
0.011318068,
0.0916195139,
0.0024727578,
-0.0012846484,
0.0168836378,
0.0290851593,
-0.0299227517,
-0.0065359646,
-0.0017625802,
-0.0317440219,
-0.0057819127,
0.0382479541,
0.0129033774,
-0.0198043957,
-0.0029782408,
-0.0066172895,
0.0126842838,
-0.0531122871,
0.0252819061,
0.0004993927,
-0.0031626849,
-0.0188416243,
0.0216899794,
-0.0264622644,
-0.0262326282,
-0.0097018154,
0.0462423153,
0.0912707746,
0.0345050618,
0.1246142015,
0.0015171386,
-0.0274624974,
-0.0174490549,
0.042472899,
0.0019145377,
-0.0287104994,
0.013520252,
-0.028965069,
-0.0211948659,
0.0310396198,
0.0602517314,
-0.0264972635,
0.0351429619,
0.0132172145,
0.000584321,
-0.0073695052,
-0.02098828,
0.0018098137,
-0.0005167401,
-0.0135829095,
-0.0199060012,
0.0073000286,
-0.0461747162,
0.004785656,
-0.0001613677,
-0.0181165878,
-0.0265414715,
-0.0191109162,
0.0685951412,
0.0006077796,
0.004405444,
-0.0444482788,
0.0157671962,
-0.0076087364,
-0.0114117255,
0.000267321,
-6.276967917e-33,
-0.00775326,
0.0034798523,
-0.0034415063,
-0.0230614357,
-0.0453774631,
-0.0133098578,
-0.0279235747,
-0.0271255672,
-0.0130372448,
-0.0009799023,
-0.0237355046,
0.0199407041,
0.0273069646,
0.0095621124,
0.0149982302,
0.0150146522,
0.0531777777,
0.0014365775,
-0.0107169235,
0.040867094,
0.0422237329,
0.0335115381,
0.0672748238,
-0.0463541038,
0.019417908,
-0.0322756618,
-0.0387521982,
0.008805884,
0.0037207501,
0.034718629,
-0.0223450288,
0.0108802952,
-0.0003761585,
-0.0154751102,
-0.0172549952,
-0.0282277912,
-0.085823372,
0.0238226876,
0.0353871398,
0.0514304452,
-0.0022821235,
-0.0487156622,
0.0386916809,
-0.0343349762,
0.0261431169,
-0.0060394374,
-0.0006303859,
-0.0654153228,
-0.0256188642,
0.000145546,
-0.0820085332,
0.0139705911,
-0.0057787364,
0.0113581894,
0.0217708368,
0.047606647,
-0.0211103745,
0.016683843,
-0.031558305,
-0.0150381364,
-0.0088425009,
0.0356150307,
0.0584199578,
0.0278826877,
-0.0119987959,
0.0050297794,
0.0030347907,
-0.0353386588,
0.0338132419,
-0.0013378094,
0.0202572849,
0.0125097977,
0.0452792235,
0.0717913881,
-0.0004889846,
-0.0361164287,
-0.0742025822,
0.0240232162,
0.0373151191,
-0.0175632518,
0.0301245414,
0.0410516001,
0.0131475497,
-0.0000388522,
-0.0311065651,
-0.008025256,
-0.0316026025,
-0.0345369317,
0.013829181,
0.0259683747,
-0.0304953698,
0.0062048505,
0.0679268837,
-0.0418205559,
-0.0208048057,
0.0204878096,
-0.035530135,
0.0162255317,
-0.026854407,
0.0619243309,
-0.0320314318,
-0.0714318603,
0.0079732267,
-0.0190066807,
-0.0087200431,
-0.0321709141,
0.0512131564,
0.0158478841,
-0.0726902261,
0.0197317414,
-0.0455467291,
-0.0130681647,
-0.004993639,
0.0325601697,
0.0082577299,
-0.0200640913,
-0.0061625503,
0.0488413833,
0.0523581952,
0.0351409167,
-0.0358639322,
-0.0211456623,
0.0034704192,
0.0227833968,
-0.0667660981,
0.0296016764,
-0.0542440563,
-0.006559555,
0.0311633423,
-0.0671914667,
-0.0439812057,
0.0016144392,
2.746e-7,
0.038977202,
0.0585162006,
-0.0118372301,
0.0403959006,
0.0047429204,
0.0263186954,
-0.0283862408,
0.0499481522,
0.020073615,
0.0615273565,
0.024520494,
0.0289937481,
0.077441223,
0.0161248054,
-0.0627150387,
-0.0106739076,
-0.0565394238,
0.0191716757,
-0.0549204238,
-0.025735287,
0.0202876236,
0.1484513432,
0.0120352963,
0.005238811,
0.0077498383,
-0.043737378,
0.0868069604,
-0.0357912444,
-0.0309320986,
0.0201245826,
0.0153441168,
0.0625548959,
-0.0676739961,
-0.0390508585,
-0.0253304467,
0.0200607795,
0.0469896756,
0.1052764282,
0.0093781818,
0.024758298,
0.0286581665,
-0.0313890465,
-0.012101477,
-0.0568460226,
0.0749737248,
0.0021443979,
-0.0034396602,
-0.022484228,
0.0032545095,
0.0032004607,
0.0546518601,
-0.0573472716,
-0.0224348065,
0.0418026485,
0.0428457521,
-0.03255108,
-0.0548225939,
-0.0519530289,
-0.0615353622,
-0.0316176675,
-0.0159163643,
-0.0263802484,
-0.030140968,
0.0116211604,
-0.0197566748,
-0.0465615913,
0.0181747936,
2.337452838e-34,
0.043255154,
-0.0192109086,
-0.0040607997,
0.0049197068,
0.0509305075,
-0.0395748056,
0.0064948276,
0.0268701389,
-0.0373574719,
-0.059541855,
-0.0106700873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18096v2 | Improving Textless Spoken Language Understanding with Discrete Units as Intermediate Target | 2023-05-29T14:00:24 | 2023-07-08T07:25:14 | Guan-Wei Wu, Guan-Ting Lin, Shang-Wen Li, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Spoken Language Understanding (SLU) is a task that aims to extract semantic
information from spoken utterances. Previous research has made progress in
end-to-end SLU by using paired speech-text data, such as pre-trained Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) models or paired text as intermediate targets.
However, acquiring paired transcripts is expensive and impractical for
unwritten languages. On the other hand, Textless SLU extracts semantic
information from speech without utilizing paired transcripts. However, the
absence of intermediate targets and training guidance for textless SLU often
results in suboptimal performance. In this work, inspired by the
content-disentangled discrete units from self-supervised speech models, we
proposed to use discrete units as intermediate guidance to improve textless SLU
performance. Our method surpasses the baseline method on five SLU benchmark
corpora. Additionally, we find that unit guidance facilitates few-shot learning
and enhances the model's ability to handle noise. | [
-0.0244007837,
0.0706475601,
0.0359638855,
0.0671613738,
-0.0013696316,
0.0416712686,
0.0717432797,
0.007558519,
-0.0298550725,
-0.0677183717,
-0.0183976721,
-0.026122069,
0.0217359383,
0.0066996464,
-0.0037817897,
-0.0372053608,
0.0440232493,
-0.0594478771,
-0.0155487368,
-0.0130802253,
-0.0077154161,
0.0067517213,
-0.0680139214,
-0.0257847197,
0.003755474,
-0.0323604904,
-0.0364788175,
0.0082937768,
-0.008203744,
-0.0405954607,
-0.0585974194,
0.038866166,
0.0680007041,
0.0403404422,
0.0000021131,
-0.0475526564,
-0.0222855825,
-0.0217024535,
-0.1199984401,
-0.0209588576,
0.001954406,
-0.0616784915,
0.0008724405,
0.013434181,
0.009334201,
-0.0199105106,
0.012151449,
0.0370015837,
0.0116071533,
0.0692204237,
-0.0241720695,
-0.0540423356,
-0.0259753615,
-0.037398953,
-0.0175586771,
-0.0265434887,
-0.0203818101,
0.0020051862,
-0.0093476223,
0.0153259672,
-0.0430058986,
0.0288504884,
-0.0049329326,
0.0091307396,
0.0204866398,
0.0458878763,
-0.041172985,
-0.0831878632,
-0.0169527661,
0.100290671,
-0.0044374885,
0.0080625694,
0.029104501,
-0.0167835262,
-0.0688490644,
-0.0305670053,
-0.0276577361,
0.0122767258,
0.0417041443,
0.0303473119,
-0.0028929755,
0.048628781,
0.0340322889,
-0.0012927207,
-0.0648831204,
0.0539459288,
-0.0243691988,
0.0042057214,
0.0022652822,
-0.0477957278,
-0.0122369379,
-0.055537533,
-0.02068392,
0.0173226688,
0.0098014288,
0.0208562203,
-0.0081705367,
-0.0322064869,
-0.0420531705,
-0.0305686928,
0.0108944168,
0.0688368082,
-0.0191344824,
0.0652184039,
-0.0176945925,
0.0323124863,
0.0419092625,
-0.0042217374,
-0.0386326835,
0.0149936555,
-0.0281043798,
0.0340462886,
-0.0335855,
0.0800093487,
-0.0753423721,
-0.0104240589,
0.0335473754,
-0.0195037834,
0.0276636519,
0.026246801,
-0.0062326123,
0.0013999733,
-0.0478833355,
-0.0283512939,
0.024405241,
0.0780620798,
-0.0118158041,
-0.0126091642,
-0.0447430015,
-0.0590575971,
-0.04434577,
0.0410042219,
0.0422898196,
-0.0189237371,
-0.0147871431,
0.0555148609,
-0.0141492793,
-0.0602970533,
-0.010821457,
0.0237867925,
0.0189660732,
-0.0437391028,
-0.0287845768,
-0.0576378405,
0.0340245105,
0.0101088621,
0.0238346495,
-0.0392089598,
0.0401488841,
-0.0468186624,
-0.0141125554,
0.1012369767,
-0.0561534017,
0.0021242232,
-0.0122465175,
0.0248098392,
0.054262381,
0.1041996852,
0.0118613318,
0.0128771802,
0.0106829507,
-0.0030330084,
-0.0476388708,
0.0026349493,
0.0317851938,
0.0138001032,
-0.0705971569,
0.0258022957,
0.025966173,
0.0014902411,
0.0428667963,
0.014269216,
-0.0640148148,
-0.010377313,
0.0331410728,
0.0707402825,
0.0285726171,
0.0303930603,
-0.0023957377,
0.0476721898,
-0.032504119,
0.0139453663,
-0.0001230516,
0.0114490753,
-0.0081779091,
0.007208976,
0.050822366,
-0.0000637865,
-0.056043189,
-0.042333629,
-0.0377057865,
-0.0410445817,
0.0031774691,
0.0337943509,
0.0790922716,
0.0120984195,
-0.0315116458,
0.0187508799,
0.0358565077,
-0.0425155349,
0.0270229764,
0.001091914,
0.0301134605,
0.0657909885,
0.038372051,
-0.0107593033,
-0.0375199504,
-0.0287248269,
0.0088019548,
0.0528116338,
-0.0200781953,
-0.0019978697,
0.1330619901,
-0.0708345696,
-0.0099776322,
0.0033643001,
-0.0093015935,
0.036792431,
-0.0545329452,
-0.0059045078,
-0.0018040576,
-0.0122761875,
0.0330271982,
-0.008718689,
-0.0188092142,
-0.0631872416,
0.045070041,
0.0118718818,
0.0437506922,
0.0408289991,
-0.0306128599,
-0.0373995192,
0.0325273648,
-0.0444343649,
0.0043445672,
-0.0052996837,
-0.0362909585,
-0.0971622318,
-0.0065600211,
-0.0069684638,
-0.0211545601,
0.0254524052,
-0.0169139728,
-0.081760928,
0.0497921407,
0.0194113329,
0.0233061612,
-0.0327610932,
0.0028297147,
0.043494653,
0.0369976871,
-0.013187144,
0.0184265655,
0.0208828095,
-0.0094282879,
0.017527312,
0.0120884422,
0.0469721109,
-0.0237053689,
-0.0105373589,
0.0119713834,
-0.0162508246,
-0.0034065703,
-0.0027677109,
-0.0020364155,
-0.0152797252,
-0.0001963846,
-0.0709977597,
-0.0195858348,
-0.0452663675,
0.0278979521,
0.0330946073,
0.0471728556,
0.0211227722,
-0.0704871491,
-0.0008926659,
-0.0369916931,
-0.0230848454,
-0.0203771032,
0.0199178755,
0.008509214,
-0.0172955319,
-0.0351434611,
0.0092816167,
-0.0049573015,
0.0237929933,
-0.0150592206,
-0.0373174064,
-0.0304268934,
0.0934458375,
-0.0087127555,
0.0450057723,
-0.0194064807,
-0.0241626073,
-0.002112316,
-0.0457816906,
-0.0109673031,
0.0559259169,
-0.0269537587,
0.0709122345,
0.0212829895,
-0.0469170474,
-0.0374626666,
0.0167953931,
-0.0125486646,
0.0578007288,
-0.010515349,
0.0503567159,
-0.0217740592,
0.0758154765,
0.0274294801,
0.0321772322,
-0.0377745107,
-0.042566251,
-0.0125415754,
-0.0210709758,
-0.0828390196,
0.0423858687,
0.0119333798,
0.0489830598,
-0.0050891624,
-0.0181444343,
0.037238609,
-0.0712954178,
-0.0331533365,
-0.0781005323,
-0.0270894431,
-0.0387244523,
0.0580399968,
0.0025313362,
0.0156978276,
-0.0546425097,
-0.0355274342,
-0.0130072488,
-0.0028313862,
0.0044175936,
-0.007873375,
0.0136591941,
-0.0384726226,
0.0328382254,
-0.0267045274,
-0.0378810652,
-0.046591524,
-0.0449680276,
-0.0337588526,
0.0084465016,
-0.0035249335,
-0.0135207623,
-0.0255363844,
0.0466625467,
0.0306462068,
0.039411515,
0.008419631,
0.0257372782,
-0.0369507633,
0.0619848073,
0.041133333,
0.0001709156,
-0.0143601885,
-0.0136922449,
0.0942582637,
0.0065553715,
0.0640158281,
0.0007400533,
-0.0528271049,
0.0226170346,
0.0207878221,
0.0151057551,
-0.0154563859,
0.0160116144,
0.0312838592,
-0.0286240112,
-0.0205468331,
0.1373872161,
0.0014713826,
-0.0118587743,
-0.0220795237,
0.0021629129,
0.004817191,
0.0178075172,
0.0014874013,
-0.0652246624,
-0.0691899061,
0.0095225647,
0.0076149772,
0.0190812033,
0.0048688836,
-0.0262190979,
-0.0567598306,
-0.0111345788,
0.0292386431,
-0.0286646932,
-0.0209583938,
-0.0436877012,
0.0055999854,
-0.038310159,
0.0249739829,
0.0168130621,
0.0041055614,
-0.0097941877,
0.0140227145,
-0.0429320559,
-0.0451309606,
-0.011195438,
0.0236071199,
0.0747228935,
0.0515546724,
0.0239445213,
0.009343124,
0.0054799505,
0.0164541602,
-0.0383357108,
-0.000296682,
-0.0270845611,
0.0367913693,
-0.0146567887,
-0.0126641598,
0.0277716871,
0.0289729219,
-0.0114200963,
0.0018421557,
-0.0146323862,
0.0116492128,
-0.0375168137,
0.0145863499,
0.0101213148,
0.0103450296,
-0.0146517819,
0.0747208968,
0.0323546827,
-0.0041780728,
-0.0401971489,
-0.0085252123,
0.0401315764,
-0.0176397469,
0.0072456505,
0.0099608386,
0.0205002651,
-0.0277385004,
-0.0153635982,
-0.0529000722,
0.0358852968,
0.0352999084,
0.0115071842,
0.0182514358,
0.016539067,
0.0269962773,
0.000668509,
0.0059808334,
-0.0228519309,
-0.0016763766,
-0.0574607849,
-0.0182405803,
0.0124673098,
-0.0484215766,
-0.0028534564,
-0.0095717246,
-0.0819542706,
-0.0520351715,
0.0195119604,
-0.0182652045,
0.025784811,
0.0712261349,
-0.0334139355,
-0.0399682187,
0.0633361638,
0.0195268318,
-0.0653782412,
0.0046385215,
0.0402533785,
0.0470240004,
-0.0114076231,
0.0271656737,
-0.0026921614,
0.0414646715,
-0.0336847827,
0.0256190263,
-0.0836994126,
0.016623145,
-0.0079583833,
0.0070099928,
0.0975550115,
0.0274379514,
0.060753569,
-0.0058779195,
0.0432673916,
-0.0173118506,
0.0429873616,
-0.0326358564,
-0.009032499,
0.0056466158,
-0.0308895018,
-0.0250745099,
-0.0174805019,
-0.0350821167,
0.0018065285,
0.0196356401,
0.020520905,
0.0099572409,
0.0187982842,
-0.018880818,
-0.0221387222,
0.0147712799,
0.0941065699,
0.0342547446,
0.0311694555,
-0.0034255807,
0.0535712615,
0.0057233199,
0.0013452601,
-0.0021608132,
0.0055765999,
-0.033058729,
-0.0232752711,
0.003068015,
-0.0154915964,
-0.008522423,
-0.0162431989,
0.0358111337,
0.0259164572,
0.0409536399,
-0.021137068,
0.0425568968,
-0.0443832465,
0.0119774733,
0.0458082519,
0.0189216733,
0.0112053026,
0.0328860581,
0.0579049438,
0.0191739574,
0.0079940306,
0.0223569907,
0.070948109,
-0.0402353816,
-0.0184370708,
0.0006449699,
0.0254575275,
-0.0133558726,
0.0641249344,
-0.0467716381,
-0.0336303264,
-0.0093305893,
-0.037447717,
0.0206860583,
-0.029969532,
0.0291830096,
-0.0169521198,
-0.0285429619,
0.0350074209,
-0.0156332944,
-0.0103801759,
0.0286188032,
-0.006466202,
-0.0012637365,
-7.566056899e-33,
-0.0505013168,
-0.0188402291,
-0.0139667541,
0.016598817,
0.0184335876,
-0.0058970354,
-0.037812449,
-0.0009135012,
0.0104028974,
-0.0251097605,
-0.0144805554,
0.0421194136,
0.0129425563,
0.0518379733,
-0.0455499068,
-0.0320993848,
0.0808776468,
-0.0196689889,
-0.013856533,
-0.001124442,
0.0624194182,
0.0622303151,
0.0273859259,
-0.0480412208,
-0.013529229,
-0.0210969448,
0.013934128,
0.0163491294,
0.0489032008,
0.0020290143,
-0.0122857206,
-0.0144515885,
-0.0071686096,
-0.0335665122,
-0.030931497,
0.0022687251,
-0.1092634648,
-0.0443893634,
-0.0017132428,
0.0270897746,
-0.0237560682,
0.0098539302,
-0.0117060542,
-0.0040729586,
0.0365255736,
-0.0463118739,
0.0002153814,
0.0162710566,
-0.0248060636,
-0.0039016448,
0.0033009823,
0.0577674694,
-0.0450494327,
-0.0223494526,
0.1219697893,
0.0223868471,
-0.0163658839,
-0.0199067835,
-0.0695160702,
-0.0057808128,
0.0257255472,
0.052576717,
0.0507093817,
0.0041105878,
-0.0063918168,
0.038017232,
0.0477174558,
-0.06624607,
-0.0086832792,
-0.0078908894,
0.0298185181,
0.0068122796,
-0.0080514923,
0.0117231589,
0.0567319281,
-0.0079626758,
-0.0759429261,
-0.019536702,
0.0152376415,
0.0368978642,
-0.0001443321,
0.0193460286,
-0.0421018898,
-0.0307224989,
-0.0345869288,
-0.051685188,
-0.0355676301,
-0.0224877801,
0.0275045577,
0.0105051966,
-0.0363528766,
-0.0242026635,
0.0722232834,
-0.0121621583,
0.016323857,
0.0235615186,
0.0264502782,
0.0071795131,
0.0162378326,
0.0240619425,
-0.077329725,
-0.0265079085,
0.0498907045,
0.0485667437,
0.0140962489,
-0.0120554995,
-0.0069577964,
0.017462736,
-0.0298417285,
-0.0453053638,
-0.0281885825,
0.0133432914,
-0.0497526154,
0.0195171405,
0.0355578959,
0.0129935117,
-0.0264024977,
0.0759842172,
-0.0310929548,
-0.0182250198,
-0.0163372643,
0.0307775959,
0.0048636864,
0.0133550782,
-0.0526514128,
-0.0338884182,
0.0124931689,
-0.0048358222,
0.0556272045,
-0.0262925718,
0.0035125772,
0.0349956192,
2.917e-7,
-0.0275930297,
0.0218495484,
0.0257647447,
-0.0558904335,
0.0370344669,
0.0510772988,
-0.0324724242,
-0.0236270949,
-0.033740744,
-0.0219149776,
0.0103260148,
0.0320203975,
0.0506842881,
0.0013242705,
-0.0679531917,
0.0298266839,
-0.0051420643,
-0.0017187566,
-0.0271127764,
-0.0232401863,
0.0155632589,
0.0701397061,
0.0007462664,
0.0111778714,
0.0303917229,
0.0417313762,
0.0257457923,
-0.0040667024,
0.003066076,
-0.0437637679,
-0.021055067,
0.00884197,
-0.0303567834,
-0.0131727755,
0.0169981401,
0.0413412005,
0.0054687695,
0.0553081818,
-0.0307653677,
-0.0261727143,
0.0105440188,
0.0261050016,
-0.0179706234,
0.01656943,
0.0800003856,
-0.0468414761,
-0.0380771197,
0.0197162218,
-0.0194918718,
0.0520635247,
-0.0238075294,
0.046908915,
-0.0125120049,
0.0201011412,
0.0097277174,
-0.048983831,
-0.0097949775,
-0.055475086,
0.0207173508,
-0.0090040825,
-0.0167461,
-0.0024636437,
-0.0175005384,
0.0064411056,
0.0023525332,
-0.0248459857,
-0.0274066553,
2.403198559e-34,
0.0150456764,
-0.0252280068,
-0.0288692676,
-0.001776911,
0.0022707148,
-0.062245138,
-0.0601821281,
-0.0048220693,
0.0489605553,
-0.0589433089,
-0.0028523221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18486v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18486v4 | A Systematic Study and Comprehensive Evaluation of ChatGPT on Benchmark Datasets | 2023-05-29T12:37:21 | 2023-07-05T16:19:38 | Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, M Saiful Bari, Mizanur Rahman, Md Amran Hossen Bhuiyan, Shafiq Joty, Jimmy Xiangji Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The development of large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT has brought a
lot of attention recently. However, their evaluation in the benchmark academic
datasets remains under-explored due to the difficulty of evaluating the
generative outputs produced by this model against the ground truth. In this
paper, we aim to present a thorough evaluation of ChatGPT's performance on
diverse academic datasets, covering tasks like question-answering, text
summarization, code generation, commonsense reasoning, mathematical
problem-solving, machine translation, bias detection, and ethical
considerations. Specifically, we evaluate ChatGPT across 140 tasks and analyze
255K responses it generates in these datasets. This makes our work the largest
evaluation of ChatGPT in NLP benchmarks. In short, our study aims to validate
the strengths and weaknesses of ChatGPT in various tasks and provide insights
for future research using LLMs. We also report a new emergent ability to follow
multi-query instructions that we mostly found in ChatGPT and other
instruction-tuned models. Our extensive evaluation shows that even though
ChatGPT is capable of performing a wide variety of tasks, and may obtain
impressive performance in several benchmark datasets, it is still far from
achieving the ability to reliably solve many challenging tasks. By providing a
thorough assessment of ChatGPT's performance across diverse NLP tasks, this
paper sets the stage for a targeted deployment of ChatGPT-like LLMs in
real-world applications. | [
0.0499479026,
0.0750148892,
0.0182082262,
0.0254403222,
-0.0488661639,
0.0105169341,
-0.0134080453,
-0.0102625517,
0.0350597538,
-0.0482129641,
-0.0116501683,
-0.000583075,
-0.011111822,
0.0174530782,
0.0435538366,
-0.0143406689,
0.0522305891,
-0.0204329062,
-0.0149246901,
-0.0083965985,
0.0188045911,
0.0494159497,
0.0138633251,
0.0687896758,
0.0044644545,
-0.0261874553,
0.0139431432,
0.0181303937,
0.0073978011,
0.0066208411,
0.0401028022,
0.0418954939,
0.0290303007,
0.0353423841,
0.0000019773,
-0.0227245335,
-0.0119585097,
0.0015740155,
-0.0007284436,
0.0258292388,
0.0489025638,
-0.0023174442,
0.0191345699,
0.0390266366,
-0.0592455678,
0.009313223,
0.0295253191,
0.0165696684,
0.0980421007,
0.0968669653,
0.0136495978,
-0.0370214321,
0.0418227538,
-0.0384626985,
0.0354654603,
-0.0596566088,
0.0195138063,
0.0255425051,
0.0087890439,
0.0386576466,
0.0046868543,
0.0377253555,
0.0378141925,
-0.0064377855,
-0.0222716667,
0.0414014421,
-0.0734513402,
0.0040506921,
-0.0142070353,
0.0864299536,
-0.0185526609,
-0.0448177531,
0.040129777,
0.0138592394,
-0.0115315551,
-0.0261933524,
-0.0534004048,
0.0387931503,
0.0013822023,
0.0246988554,
0.0157523304,
-0.000817441,
0.0085265236,
0.0308945626,
-0.0104073817,
0.0275014434,
0.0136182234,
-0.0247163363,
-0.020030221,
0.0034244852,
-0.0670639053,
-0.0660856962,
0.0039464752,
0.0480173267,
-0.0292133,
0.0106322262,
-0.0480883345,
-0.0092389351,
0.0372780226,
-0.0358752757,
0.0032356069,
0.0642746165,
0.0071103708,
0.0581729822,
-0.023642581,
0.059329845,
-0.0146295307,
0.039825771,
-0.0658920333,
-0.0186330806,
-0.0782690197,
-0.0246942285,
-0.0494310148,
0.0338929482,
-0.0491596237,
-0.0229091588,
-0.0248985477,
0.0241442639,
0.0137852151,
0.003272675,
0.0453343801,
0.0222146753,
-0.0326142199,
-0.0055318545,
-0.0125880167,
0.0021943697,
-0.0462938435,
-0.0202534795,
0.0271176044,
-0.0655150488,
-0.0272889286,
0.005610419,
-0.012617657,
-0.0265396927,
0.0278810021,
0.0725401938,
-0.0047145104,
-0.0140452422,
-0.0013820062,
-0.0260274019,
-0.0030578838,
-0.0759510547,
-0.0110011715,
-0.080001235,
0.0467630699,
0.0158362687,
-0.0327054337,
-0.0110288905,
0.0049510784,
0.0605183132,
-0.028144218,
0.0392617881,
0.0108813187,
0.0299926568,
0.0257712808,
0.019097494,
-0.0099497344,
0.0770069808,
0.0415595956,
-0.0009710933,
0.0411810428,
0.0141524496,
-0.0015342567,
0.0200329348,
0.0420489348,
0.0049044746,
0.0343072079,
0.0496142916,
-0.0068124258,
0.0159323644,
0.0124524916,
0.0756453797,
-0.0404588245,
-0.0298498496,
0.0266017914,
0.0306671504,
-0.008219257,
0.0178118609,
0.0294862874,
0.0417465121,
0.0021080903,
0.0092062913,
-0.0516197123,
0.0281852223,
-0.0264265221,
0.0322499201,
0.0477585234,
0.0406265669,
-0.0316685885,
-0.0355187356,
0.0033797475,
0.0207896512,
0.0113086347,
0.0225560851,
0.0141534787,
0.0099734981,
-0.0487387627,
0.0390508249,
0.0305344258,
-0.0534846932,
0.009580899,
-0.0815847218,
0.0144179845,
0.0264065843,
0.0788874924,
-0.0197593533,
-0.0477799028,
-0.0010465787,
0.0232068077,
0.0348211713,
0.0672696382,
-0.0069060312,
-0.0044699307,
-0.0480015278,
-0.0050095939,
-0.0225377232,
-0.0014149856,
0.0027048402,
0.0608556978,
-0.012633889,
0.0300120413,
-0.0475223958,
-0.0210107248,
0.0294575114,
-0.0323525891,
-0.011010957,
0.0010724396,
-0.0409693345,
0.0194088649,
-0.0026610626,
-0.0169293527,
0.0364337899,
0.0039880611,
-0.0173824262,
-0.0261316802,
-0.0163659081,
-0.0607451536,
-0.0867285579,
0.0435995758,
-0.0610282011,
-0.0189205203,
0.0337281711,
-0.0647047833,
-0.0516453758,
0.0213021543,
-0.0474658459,
0.0051077171,
-0.0607696772,
-0.0226968862,
0.0217041541,
-0.000899703,
-0.0412386619,
0.070094578,
-0.0068199732,
0.0097812489,
0.021826433,
0.0154289976,
0.0102562597,
-0.0266370401,
-0.0144684855,
0.0003835943,
-0.0146117061,
0.0344375782,
0.0388189666,
0.0660146475,
-0.0319711044,
-0.0515295416,
-0.1144720688,
0.0438808501,
-0.0315925367,
0.0171478353,
0.035941761,
0.0048021106,
-0.0064030015,
0.0085880356,
-0.0852876529,
-0.0174885709,
0.0458921567,
0.0081368489,
0.0455946401,
-0.0114819231,
0.0148243085,
-0.0457393713,
-0.0199824516,
-0.0210389066,
0.019136183,
-0.0076470627,
0.0258685108,
-0.0232021064,
0.0358495153,
-0.0361887552,
0.0040167649,
-0.0253636986,
-0.0237971656,
0.0105613424,
-0.0282279197,
0.0526532084,
0.0507934429,
0.0108566172,
-0.0007060519,
0.0048195128,
-0.0027429536,
-0.0596848913,
0.0287147369,
-0.0482334569,
-0.0272130203,
0.0178589411,
-0.0325257033,
0.0039073923,
0.0518445112,
0.0187492557,
-0.0252753571,
-0.0842590779,
0.0286161136,
-0.0074838893,
0.0085028103,
-0.0588665418,
0.0271450207,
-0.0001068828,
0.0293543991,
-0.0464564636,
-0.0372140817,
0.0752052143,
-0.026294006,
-0.0176566206,
-0.0823480114,
-0.0005466402,
-0.0727056339,
0.0382056199,
0.0104917912,
0.0137744518,
-0.0206131656,
-0.0061076297,
-0.0495500974,
-0.007907589,
0.0140428077,
-0.0457854159,
0.0501112752,
-0.0366750397,
0.0175186656,
-0.023646025,
-0.0366508849,
-0.0296049472,
-0.0544163845,
0.005789794,
0.0208529159,
0.0505143888,
-0.0096130297,
-0.0235007629,
0.0058514443,
0.0114403358,
0.0357169248,
-0.0433452055,
-0.0267086122,
-0.0221762303,
0.0178169254,
0.0806849077,
0.001713434,
0.017329799,
-0.0086277649,
-0.0014994167,
0.0766675472,
0.0490405709,
0.0158389416,
-0.0149661321,
0.0112585807,
-0.0048957262,
-0.0364135504,
0.0094456207,
0.0053955591,
0.0704211444,
-0.0396869555,
-0.0283974838,
0.1118899286,
0.0232607611,
-0.0198294781,
-0.0014066091,
0.0278988909,
0.0548779294,
0.0093523338,
0.0296352711,
-0.0866967738,
-0.0423527248,
0.0001409772,
0.0242636818,
-0.0152808195,
-0.0283376947,
-0.0271695796,
-0.1216216013,
0.0204339847,
-0.0067016562,
-0.0417791419,
-0.0221510753,
-0.0375263393,
-0.0139212254,
-0.0403394066,
0.0118282922,
0.0208650846,
-0.0211175438,
0.0201211087,
0.0227003787,
-0.0253164228,
-0.0218746569,
0.0436837077,
-0.0169232376,
0.0283921715,
0.0696138591,
0.0297518466,
0.0116734607,
-0.0001750243,
0.0401107371,
-0.008703012,
-0.0095967166,
-0.001072571,
0.043261122,
-0.0192964301,
-0.0070365481,
-0.0235020816,
0.0531153232,
-0.0737149864,
0.0029381751,
0.0417582206,
0.0508971959,
0.0018444327,
-0.0107269073,
-0.0576975197,
0.0309869461,
-0.0225491393,
0.1085233018,
0.0283441748,
-0.0125760855,
-0.0642667636,
-0.041525431,
0.001590577,
-0.0770645961,
-0.0356398821,
-0.0151433377,
0.0286936164,
0.0132138804,
-0.0660007894,
-0.0513719395,
0.0278274957,
-0.0020014078,
-0.0206804592,
-0.0244088341,
-0.0086803725,
0.0071195094,
-0.0303749852,
0.0151841445,
-0.0470103584,
0.0049834112,
-0.047529161,
-0.0139936469,
0.0306211691,
-0.0297853462,
-0.0507774167,
0.0110516278,
-0.1252099872,
-0.0651587546,
-0.0401614793,
0.0539570935,
0.0260103792,
0.0279006269,
-0.0452337116,
-0.0002344251,
0.0068642814,
0.0579742379,
-0.0625461265,
0.0047336258,
0.0122402972,
0.0165587123,
0.0048851869,
0.0278976504,
-0.0459927768,
0.0245334357,
-0.0015603958,
0.0609985404,
-0.02359882,
-0.0267747901,
0.0239871256,
0.0349571593,
0.0067587313,
0.0027073158,
0.0193092786,
-0.0225929711,
-0.0206139665,
-0.0132532213,
-0.0224412307,
-0.0594270006,
0.0149132907,
0.0109687978,
-0.0236398503,
-0.0115025267,
-0.0027609193,
-0.0240384396,
0.0274569616,
-0.0466970205,
0.0079793576,
0.0017811143,
0.0003975103,
0.0138066476,
-0.0313960724,
-0.0422592908,
0.0007269842,
-0.0214889441,
0.0221238807,
-0.0185460746,
0.0484469086,
0.0466417782,
-0.0157478768,
0.0343964472,
0.0246016011,
-0.1063937023,
-0.0247479659,
-0.0227391627,
0.0414550379,
0.056973014,
0.0260905046,
0.0397534072,
-0.0070480993,
-0.0124847731,
-0.0343104377,
0.0440392867,
0.0414312594,
-0.0096567767,
0.0133452117,
0.0192209408,
-0.0171683449,
-0.0179842412,
0.1028758809,
-0.0089424048,
0.0289991274,
0.0458369255,
-0.0022858575,
-0.0313387774,
-0.0389896557,
-0.0183993224,
-0.0063297604,
0.0157337952,
0.0250029843,
-0.0390341654,
-0.0507015139,
-0.027057169,
0.0246852469,
0.0207587834,
-0.0127078658,
0.0408567451,
0.0746883899,
0.0002115222,
-0.018992601,
-0.0575643927,
0.0114535457,
-0.0533472039,
-0.0211281851,
-0.030896144,
-6.479187476e-33,
-0.0153685296,
0.0089066168,
0.0314480066,
0.0040963525,
-0.0191168208,
-0.007887397,
-0.0545967668,
-0.016044654,
-0.0339495912,
-0.0159615185,
-0.0211212188,
0.0342587233,
-0.0112121664,
0.0388903469,
-0.0067022555,
-0.0418052562,
0.0182044879,
-0.0116866641,
-0.0253819991,
0.0497884117,
0.0179255493,
0.0062793386,
0.0350119956,
-0.0124680027,
-0.0033803154,
-0.0386619717,
-0.0070076017,
0.0223701391,
-0.0332641564,
0.0721547455,
-0.0148080066,
0.049428869,
0.026560802,
-0.0330693088,
-0.018501604,
-0.0051301424,
-0.0596791357,
-0.0388552584,
0.0286953859,
-0.0248643607,
-0.0252567753,
-0.0219397396,
0.0320370235,
-0.0201547146,
-0.0077809193,
-0.0437549911,
0.0215815194,
-0.0098974034,
-0.0256594904,
-0.0123667102,
-0.0171012115,
0.0334936455,
-0.0266902093,
-0.0451379456,
-0.0260059908,
0.0403715931,
-0.0122355046,
0.0276446603,
-0.0217763968,
0.0148309944,
0.024598442,
0.0271648895,
0.0429630838,
-0.0253988449,
0.0183715262,
0.0390385389,
0.0005230983,
-0.0035593717,
-0.0451938808,
0.0010800161,
0.0065395762,
0.0386336111,
0.0455579758,
0.0239622518,
0.0242834929,
0.0208563618,
-0.0521852113,
0.0470095165,
0.0260336064,
0.0333955698,
0.0392181836,
-0.0061215898,
-0.0459829941,
-0.0223660916,
-0.0361853689,
0.0130095258,
-0.0312603265,
-0.0168398656,
0.0437328182,
0.0075449138,
-0.0139635792,
-0.0169663616,
0.0374109335,
-0.055234503,
0.014449832,
0.0516095273,
-0.0399286635,
-0.0102340551,
-0.0021151991,
0.0578137673,
-0.0596334301,
0.0054843025,
0.0437753573,
0.0023847399,
-0.0164549276,
0.0104638506,
0.0139217479,
-0.0021714156,
-0.0413448438,
-0.0077645173,
-0.0384581499,
0.0456963405,
-0.0471506119,
0.0163000412,
0.0137794754,
0.0204840731,
0.0136637753,
0.0368705988,
-0.0005405199,
0.0047384072,
-0.0486171953,
0.009401924,
-0.000417785,
0.0223999582,
-0.0259515606,
0.0467188396,
-0.0311102904,
-0.009592439,
0.0063301558,
-0.0492956974,
-0.0193295199,
0.0385681726,
2.576e-7,
0.0478189364,
0.0452225246,
0.0307107288,
0.0598544814,
0.0002588749,
0.0218291339,
-0.019809885,
0.030724274,
0.0269998964,
-0.0079084365,
-0.0043264707,
0.0589904822,
0.0672080591,
0.0276849605,
-0.0651188046,
0.0048424117,
-0.0932977349,
-0.0221599061,
-0.0441836715,
-0.0051889685,
0.0745274574,
0.1121319383,
-0.0114234099,
0.0074346359,
0.0040150336,
-0.0339744352,
0.0577556379,
-0.0102705751,
-0.0435853302,
0.037920963,
0.0071738516,
0.0302248783,
0.0285655577,
-0.0000226377,
0.0016828486,
-0.0093319481,
0.0442009121,
0.0876277685,
0.027672207,
-0.0209065638,
0.0058564213,
-0.0370454863,
0.0150575973,
-0.0718789846,
0.099415198,
-0.0706560239,
0.0065414119,
-0.0341960974,
-0.0230597351,
-0.0101418886,
0.0234429259,
-0.0204954147,
-0.03599336,
0.0131192515,
0.0282733776,
-0.0097534582,
0.0047598234,
-0.0819234774,
-0.018045431,
-0.0013869094,
-0.0397117175,
-0.0471831523,
-0.0238457732,
0.0325280204,
0.0134423133,
-0.0420784168,
-0.0204882883,
2.927450443e-34,
0.0604756139,
-0.0455103852,
-0.0057933307,
-0.0073438147,
0.0509874821,
0.0109279091,
0.0046537612,
-0.0136381341,
0.0040888889,
-0.0693629012,
-0.0277042165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.04480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.04480v1 | Exploring the Compositional Generalization in Context Dependent Text-to-SQL Parsing | 2023-05-29T12:36:56 | 2023-05-29T12:36:56 | Aiwei Liu, Wei Liu, Xuming Hu, Shuang Li, Fukun Ma, Yawen Yang, Lijie Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | In the context-dependent Text-to-SQL task, the generated SQL statements are
refined iteratively based on the user input utterance from each interaction.
The input text from each interaction can be viewed as component modifications
to the previous SQL statements, which could be further extracted as the
modification patterns. Since these modification patterns could also be combined
with other SQL statements, the models are supposed to have the compositional
generalization to these novel combinations. This work is the first exploration
of compositional generalization in context-dependent Text-to-SQL scenarios. To
facilitate related studies, we constructed two challenging benchmarks named
\textsc{CoSQL-CG} and \textsc{SParC-CG} by recombining the modification
patterns and existing SQL statements. The following experiments show that all
current models struggle on our proposed benchmarks. Furthermore, we found that
better aligning the previous SQL statements with the input utterance could give
models better compositional generalization ability. Based on these
observations, we propose a method named \texttt{p-align} to improve the
compositional generalization of Text-to-SQL models. Further experiments
validate the effectiveness of our method. Source code and data are available. | [
0.0409625396,
0.0593751818,
0.0048246309,
0.0053036408,
-0.0344161279,
0.0243319478,
-0.0353974253,
-0.0090520754,
-0.0498176143,
-0.04544539,
0.0066018496,
-0.0116695575,
0.0135407597,
0.0253869649,
0.0508084297,
-0.0590901524,
0.0574011579,
0.029747868,
-0.0338518471,
0.0590186566,
0.0175616685,
0.0088576768,
0.0027480766,
-0.0113605214,
-0.0427229106,
-0.0148086306,
-0.0420052744,
0.0157465804,
-0.0217544697,
-0.0129081998,
-0.0174812954,
0.0252696108,
0.005125361,
-0.0228669215,
0.0000019193,
-0.0672807023,
-0.0707027763,
0.0216599815,
-0.0248255357,
-0.0086176218,
0.0380072258,
-0.0564960986,
0.0039685736,
0.0204848424,
-0.042618122,
0.0066224798,
0.0441114716,
0.0218256265,
0.0460630246,
0.1213444546,
-0.0245117843,
-0.0638788491,
-0.0140921753,
0.0193757042,
0.0495163761,
-0.0418777801,
0.0194723699,
0.0375522412,
0.0147019653,
-0.0399001017,
-0.0003854244,
0.0106257899,
0.0060199508,
-0.0181956775,
-0.007126885,
-0.0076678367,
-0.0286332965,
0.019265594,
-0.0025059679,
0.027012514,
0.0182874203,
-0.0307696853,
0.0097971614,
0.0019621653,
0.0307669882,
-0.0297035854,
-0.0252868105,
-0.0059312601,
-0.0439335518,
-0.0039486042,
0.0048480588,
-0.0051712962,
0.0004787684,
-0.0156513099,
-0.062193986,
0.0286708139,
-0.0057558883,
-0.0567681454,
0.0296290517,
-0.0164296888,
0.0066684377,
-0.0225516334,
0.0485567972,
0.042684149,
-0.0647931546,
0.0179135203,
-0.051482521,
-0.0361620896,
-0.0164853483,
-0.0430762433,
0.0302689765,
0.0845562816,
0.0349399038,
0.0346409678,
-0.023191072,
0.0538561679,
0.0123395957,
0.0150892427,
-0.0766448602,
-0.0141829858,
-0.1044792756,
-0.0164068285,
-0.0632523596,
0.0464016944,
-0.0618261844,
-0.03090504,
-0.0280099399,
0.0484187417,
0.0031082795,
0.060742937,
0.0395025238,
0.022154564,
-0.0439747348,
0.003051488,
-0.0050519831,
-0.0361942276,
0.0156716425,
0.0037624792,
0.010668599,
-0.0502613671,
-0.0051656235,
-0.0135361515,
0.0242222734,
-0.0343909189,
0.0001537299,
0.0436542183,
-0.0384069905,
0.0084042447,
-0.0752714276,
-0.0424457602,
-0.0148771033,
-0.0257197469,
-0.045613993,
-0.0397016853,
0.0806421787,
-0.0004112985,
-0.0302608889,
-0.0280367136,
-0.019685749,
0.0022124029,
0.0161657892,
0.0626574606,
0.0049081184,
0.008859789,
0.0153196612,
-0.0244503878,
-0.0218002982,
0.084926188,
0.0229500979,
0.00364238,
0.0013233784,
-0.0339444801,
-0.0114808176,
0.0166192465,
-0.01515863,
-0.016471561,
-0.0561938211,
0.0663006827,
0.0040304642,
0.0369349979,
0.0176520124,
0.076419346,
-0.0220828019,
0.0018812529,
0.0072511928,
0.0002777582,
0.0519545041,
0.0332392603,
0.0939403847,
0.0025572295,
0.0137744285,
0.0475688688,
-0.038742058,
-0.0413362756,
-0.0232037045,
0.0595717132,
-0.0163446553,
-0.0203427058,
-0.0139273209,
-0.0514336526,
-0.007025429,
0.0003862333,
0.0232186392,
-0.0243459232,
0.0092907576,
0.0531154312,
-0.0337754153,
-0.0100577641,
-0.0156164058,
-0.0439300723,
0.0163355395,
0.0135810897,
-0.0124542518,
0.0765395239,
0.0111786677,
-0.0732235759,
-0.0163433049,
-0.0196358543,
-0.0082773045,
-0.0125196036,
0.0193791222,
-0.0453956164,
0.0163494628,
-0.0133674368,
0.0053631803,
0.017544046,
0.01352253,
-0.0103123942,
0.0129615124,
-0.0358526409,
0.0367019698,
0.006864368,
0.013485712,
0.0303097703,
-0.0042084088,
-0.0280945767,
0.0076807272,
0.0014857036,
0.0447381027,
0.0297092907,
-0.0091132075,
0.0499186441,
0.0163227618,
0.0047602491,
-0.0334990434,
0.0214472003,
-0.0399452485,
-0.0408028997,
0.0113250278,
-0.0287192427,
-0.0202274714,
-0.0998141542,
-0.053980045,
-0.0481644683,
0.0102460524,
-0.0206661355,
0.0545540564,
-0.0136063527,
0.0236569643,
0.0134327644,
-0.0746589005,
-0.0260229073,
0.0468339622,
0.0046845991,
-0.0079280855,
0.007189665,
-0.018919671,
0.0117761875,
-0.0798934996,
0.0184783414,
-0.0268762205,
-0.0317176431,
-0.0018260706,
-0.0132472022,
-0.0090817614,
-0.0504685976,
-0.0337420814,
-0.0752497539,
-0.0047113528,
-0.0244089924,
0.0440552309,
0.0755869821,
0.0376750976,
0.0096957646,
0.0123726558,
-0.0185110141,
-0.0487389304,
0.0078004403,
0.0243503191,
0.0496720523,
0.0405370519,
-0.0055921716,
-0.0492794663,
-0.0114277955,
-0.065685302,
0.0621422455,
-0.0587647296,
-0.032484334,
-0.0342072584,
0.0368465148,
0.0323181264,
0.032852754,
-0.0021535947,
-0.0046809642,
0.0043402445,
-0.0253742356,
0.0138564641,
0.065902859,
-0.0217964668,
-0.0243129116,
-0.0307001863,
-0.02281739,
-0.039126046,
0.0202606581,
0.0019592526,
0.0185143072,
-0.0249513742,
-0.0422787853,
0.049181357,
0.0545951948,
0.0151114035,
0.0151362577,
-0.0467022508,
-0.0178210083,
0.0192572344,
-0.0262213983,
-0.0305544361,
-0.0354122706,
-0.005503824,
-0.0087259393,
-0.0236337613,
0.016237231,
0.0664893016,
-0.034166079,
-0.0034695792,
-0.0546943732,
0.001428184,
-0.0566924475,
0.0556563847,
0.0060344329,
0.0221576765,
-0.0115823932,
-0.0815427154,
-0.0414806418,
-0.05336551,
0.0209756065,
0.0115473792,
0.073894985,
-0.0378572568,
0.000649174,
-0.0069886716,
-0.0228344984,
-0.0155765638,
0.0390358903,
-0.0147302151,
0.0423889719,
0.0928071216,
0.0113281142,
0.0328737907,
-0.0031938786,
-0.0287624579,
0.0366841815,
0.0160966236,
-0.0247492045,
-0.0175824724,
-0.0478744097,
-0.0005784649,
0.0433338471,
-0.0369794481,
0.014335434,
-0.0052620289,
0.0246530492,
0.0344338566,
-0.0494031161,
-0.023664711,
0.012465775,
-0.0441524126,
-0.0391725823,
-0.0261958744,
0.035622336,
-0.0286725182,
-0.0588109717,
-0.0080594681,
0.0736364946,
0.0370081551,
0.0350974426,
0.0101541569,
0.0276134498,
-0.0021617396,
0.0365616791,
0.0425690301,
-0.1232476532,
-0.0112013612,
0.0105149429,
-0.0237387437,
0.020042032,
-0.0211880393,
-0.0246838946,
-0.1131408215,
-0.0064984988,
-0.0018363593,
-0.0434060097,
-0.0023392923,
-0.0018197661,
-0.0256234612,
-0.0531811006,
-0.0024713764,
0.0875950307,
-0.0525216833,
-0.0058390694,
0.0112546664,
-0.0236334223,
-0.0501311012,
-0.0428897701,
-0.0058899433,
-0.0240254197,
0.0495693386,
-0.0423188917,
0.0147493659,
0.0018695205,
0.0515908524,
-0.0173921548,
0.0215117261,
-0.0081366412,
0.0261818636,
-0.0081096869,
0.0319342501,
0.0497535095,
0.0224355236,
-0.0120028062,
0.0128476955,
0.0082328049,
0.0517413057,
-0.011408695,
0.0156155769,
0.0030668322,
-0.0044817417,
0.0168850161,
0.0579045191,
0.042974975,
-0.0044457647,
-0.0661781207,
-0.0436248668,
-0.0429340862,
-0.0909065902,
0.0602729805,
0.0479944013,
-0.0002492102,
-0.0140299238,
-0.0538784005,
-0.0135195572,
0.0622052923,
0.0537298173,
0.0013154184,
0.0188132767,
0.0357250385,
-0.0501251966,
-0.0135752056,
-0.0409944765,
-0.0040987348,
0.0301701929,
-0.0385139324,
0.0071934895,
-0.0327454358,
-0.0369918942,
-0.0456200913,
-0.0780057535,
-0.063816309,
-0.0477104709,
0.0264420193,
0.0203747954,
0.0146166217,
0.0209826007,
-0.0129891224,
-0.0499571003,
-0.0324797891,
0.0223561041,
-0.0242572911,
-0.0205285754,
0.0437565558,
0.0380784348,
0.0230011251,
0.015867671,
-0.0370137617,
-0.0250865202,
-0.0158718396,
0.0189012755,
-0.0242214184,
0.0204724967,
0.0764170438,
0.0227688607,
-0.0166663397,
0.0565281026,
0.0207609106,
0.0117664011,
0.03512007,
-0.05980267,
-0.0537182055,
-0.0327611119,
0.0320025012,
0.0300522521,
0.0225013196,
0.0565188043,
-0.0445678458,
-0.0482810177,
0.0609520338,
-0.0053078942,
0.0074381735,
0.0678713173,
-0.0133861229,
0.0487655811,
-0.0018026169,
-0.011714045,
0.036548052,
0.006444694,
0.0314655714,
-0.0322836787,
0.0058279815,
0.043672245,
0.0269553363,
-0.0596101917,
-0.0057836724,
-0.0356158428,
0.0478432402,
-0.0030047365,
-0.0148223089,
0.0341155641,
-0.0192318019,
0.017530065,
0.0200775154,
-0.0132277831,
-0.0063667265,
0.0417037234,
0.0390561596,
-0.0141629409,
0.0459941328,
0.0168033466,
-0.0193832759,
-0.0267695356,
0.0672246665,
-0.0079866191,
0.0220043287,
-0.017868856,
-0.0204497576,
-0.0315587297,
-0.0315684378,
0.004713797,
0.0378274843,
-0.0476152524,
-0.0462095216,
-0.0221379455,
-0.0060403319,
0.0175927784,
0.0208161548,
0.0148358066,
0.0004483378,
0.0694795549,
0.0744465888,
0.0450518653,
-0.0219382253,
0.0057635074,
-0.0137580195,
0.0065601794,
-0.0645670816,
-0.0337202251,
-5.887003177e-33,
-0.0418377034,
0.0035684505,
0.0441257507,
0.0202820916,
-0.0000238484,
-0.0183379501,
-0.0190097801,
-0.0128356926,
-0.0025872907,
-0.0064223306,
-0.0449046567,
0.011506523,
0.0267656576,
0.0183875896,
0.0191414803,
-0.0156748015,
0.0445518382,
0.0025015268,
0.0068724426,
-0.0232227147,
0.0512344129,
0.0433660299,
0.0585849807,
-0.0612924211,
0.017149074,
0.0170154069,
-0.0339604914,
0.0295817871,
0.0239384752,
0.0554850027,
0.0023764141,
-0.0271295197,
0.034635514,
0.0298951231,
-0.0326351188,
0.0032319012,
-0.0677085742,
0.0045952275,
0.0632622838,
-0.0036508099,
-0.0263901502,
-0.0455863923,
0.0481288731,
-0.0435873903,
-0.0055141649,
-0.0092565399,
-0.0066543105,
-0.0076036579,
-0.0104444278,
-0.0431049317,
-0.0786418021,
0.024913054,
0.0090752821,
0.043096453,
0.0061252718,
0.038446378,
-0.0152740488,
0.0273960158,
-0.0218375809,
0.0143157085,
-0.0044751409,
0.06731949,
0.0391818769,
0.0199083984,
0.0144731551,
-0.0402438566,
-0.014861336,
-0.0131887617,
-0.0322571434,
0.0541618541,
-0.0468898974,
0.0690160617,
-0.0087786531,
0.058983963,
0.0391743444,
-0.0565577038,
-0.0499826819,
0.0036246844,
-0.0280912966,
0.0266464837,
-0.0162323676,
0.0509228967,
-0.0481024534,
-0.0217494778,
-0.0180171989,
0.0366360024,
-0.0204162579,
-0.0354016349,
0.0478645749,
0.005506611,
0.0035406088,
0.0006700511,
0.0247874912,
-0.0227219127,
-0.0086339703,
-0.012323983,
-0.0501192994,
-0.0044543124,
0.005271133,
0.0145834479,
-0.0562421046,
-0.0708078817,
0.0406167991,
0.0379429795,
0.0418122038,
0.0256287903,
0.0537742265,
0.0452741273,
-0.0529758446,
0.0284329001,
-0.0292749964,
0.0203449242,
-0.0470358767,
0.0350375995,
0.0243048761,
0.0124951564,
-0.0048515368,
0.0458215363,
-0.0060038953,
-0.0032470084,
-0.0173764136,
-0.0221311469,
0.0314118452,
0.048902005,
0.0153807383,
0.0204833224,
0.0270226356,
-0.0243132021,
0.0578247085,
0.0107021565,
0.0035696442,
0.0701176673,
2.683e-7,
0.0936843008,
-0.0027071014,
0.0681997389,
0.0356996916,
0.0068875346,
0.0006865607,
-0.0028225579,
0.0110083008,
-0.017129086,
0.014969823,
0.0300707668,
-0.0500321612,
0.0161429457,
0.0209594164,
-0.0618742444,
0.0010113381,
-0.0681676343,
-0.0308486037,
-0.0302428752,
0.0268033277,
0.0573815443,
0.0465817414,
-0.0500910431,
0.0363955908,
-0.0020993911,
-0.0547995046,
0.0154776117,
-0.0038935831,
-0.0108535718,
0.0653111562,
-0.0052895518,
-0.0055844025,
0.0030522896,
-0.0035963852,
-0.0122087011,
0.0403739773,
-0.0002267516,
0.0731981769,
-0.0193384048,
0.0291778073,
0.0132323606,
-0.0749880746,
0.0110942358,
-0.025708843,
0.0621782839,
-0.0622496754,
0.0169300605,
0.0272061452,
-0.0238400735,
0.0059421048,
-0.0168369114,
0.0178199392,
0.014767454,
-0.0177754797,
0.0490451083,
0.0314501338,
-0.0327929407,
-0.0444330797,
-0.0375773646,
0.046805881,
-0.0224455986,
0.0254204832,
0.0133353537,
0.027603345,
-0.0068818685,
-0.0028559065,
-0.0487064049,
2.596969619e-34,
0.0446523242,
0.0089190621,
0.0645996407,
-0.0112332255,
0.0659984648,
0.003359068,
-0.0517546907,
0.0256091282,
0.0002418722,
-0.0745824575,
-0.0462613553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18034v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18034v3 | A Corpus for Sentence-level Subjectivity Detection on English News Articles | 2023-05-29T11:54:50 | 2024-05-24T12:17:28 | Francesco Antici, Andrea Galassi, Federico Ruggeri, Katerina Korre, Arianna Muti, Alessandra Bardi, Alice Fedotova, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL | We develop novel annotation guidelines for sentence-level subjectivity
detection, which are not limited to language-specific cues. We use our
guidelines to collect NewsSD-ENG, a corpus of 638 objective and 411 subjective
sentences extracted from English news articles on controversial topics. Our
corpus paves the way for subjectivity detection in English and across other
languages without relying on language-specific tools, such as lexicons or
machine translation. We evaluate state-of-the-art multilingual
transformer-based models on the task in mono-, multi-, and cross-language
settings. For this purpose, we re-annotate an existing Italian corpus. We
observe that models trained in the multilingual setting achieve the best
performance on the task. | [
0.020613974,
0.0734742656,
0.0116085205,
0.0450564362,
-0.0197091717,
-0.006799086,
0.0048222342,
-0.0239751898,
-0.0043809176,
-0.0357566252,
-0.0596606024,
0.0217267666,
-0.0362450927,
-0.0239121169,
-0.0639912114,
-0.00750414,
0.0108239437,
0.0372424088,
0.0227032658,
0.0088807968,
0.0353103019,
0.0084006079,
0.0135550974,
0.0202014111,
-0.0657138452,
0.0079576829,
0.0218279436,
0.0074595753,
0.0264590252,
-0.0058614174,
0.043331977,
0.0527491234,
-0.0471050628,
0.0032916141,
0.0000015198,
-0.010434147,
-0.0327900797,
-0.0275894795,
0.0714121163,
-0.027251754,
0.0852549896,
-0.0658333078,
-0.0205974933,
0.0185956415,
-0.0487960577,
0.0156407673,
0.0418218933,
0.0468331426,
0.0734899342,
0.1032772735,
-0.0416223854,
0.0105191665,
-0.0027675969,
-0.0128602311,
-0.0563130975,
0.0025761637,
-0.0006834405,
-0.0045819981,
-0.0896807835,
0.0159009639,
-0.0118605848,
0.0153688788,
0.0083762826,
-0.0322301798,
-0.0748027116,
-0.0466817394,
-0.0430475287,
-0.0174335446,
0.0106248986,
0.0173401758,
0.0085503515,
-0.0320544876,
-0.0022460332,
0.0298361145,
0.0192878284,
-0.0038254973,
-0.0090862196,
0.0346849486,
-0.0101736225,
0.0431324877,
0.0291844066,
0.0523967184,
-0.0170195848,
0.0209255815,
0.0262891278,
0.0605662465,
-0.0019554526,
-0.0422828943,
0.0328441486,
0.0627306029,
-0.0095707281,
0.0165840574,
0.0522300005,
-0.0029204844,
0.0343546197,
-0.0018668225,
-0.0222756322,
-0.030727746,
0.0223890133,
-0.1415265203,
-0.0439516753,
-0.0122045921,
-0.0505633131,
0.0321682282,
0.0334163494,
-0.0399039239,
-0.0136926388,
-0.0006070647,
-0.0488411747,
-0.0470401607,
-0.0102691101,
0.0396202393,
-0.0030284752,
0.0100317867,
-0.0554830283,
0.0211994201,
-0.0387661606,
-0.0218566004,
-0.0141264247,
-0.0384131856,
0.002630356,
-0.0223949905,
0.001185275,
0.0158403292,
-0.012172373,
0.0889081806,
-0.0308709256,
-0.0035191306,
-0.0479262881,
-0.0086292177,
-0.0038441666,
0.0465244129,
-0.0224226266,
-0.0139718242,
0.022003999,
-0.0154281864,
0.0007399736,
-0.0162959769,
-0.0291880369,
-0.0060781278,
-0.0511996448,
-0.0527676716,
0.0314628705,
-0.0516643487,
0.0098407408,
-0.0204151757,
0.0146200694,
-0.028726602,
0.0207967479,
0.010951791,
0.0048921141,
0.0271292105,
0.0259489883,
-0.0291132126,
-0.0049676187,
-0.0135360062,
0.0143432841,
0.0579852015,
-0.0092930151,
0.0451900214,
0.0501523614,
0.0507546812,
0.0079305163,
0.006270837,
0.0054891347,
0.0048061637,
-0.0012666202,
-0.0196146108,
-0.0586660765,
0.0047002421,
0.0301313102,
0.0391642004,
0.0123820025,
-0.0423749723,
0.0492747314,
0.0022197696,
-0.0456849225,
0.0185090527,
0.0073420363,
0.0228242129,
0.0002851803,
0.0226383228,
-0.0246715192,
0.0399233773,
-0.0016293353,
-0.0304919239,
-0.0758992061,
0.0434349962,
0.0035995655,
-0.0852991343,
-0.0010584879,
-0.0496745035,
0.0279794652,
-0.0170093309,
0.0278224796,
0.0306807123,
-0.0141606554,
0.0222669374,
0.0479729325,
-0.0865630656,
-0.0155412853,
-0.0163128059,
0.0448075458,
0.0237116888,
-0.0037185024,
-0.0209897216,
-0.0511563495,
-0.0327208862,
0.01960239,
0.0456710532,
0.0508369878,
0.0155016696,
0.0041303532,
-0.0390613861,
-0.0034977838,
-0.0088713234,
0.0227741431,
0.0268379599,
-0.0205530878,
0.0249812733,
-0.0059300768,
0.0033247632,
-0.0246226005,
0.0083812485,
0.0141417319,
-0.0032279964,
0.0187063701,
0.0234924164,
-0.0010644891,
0.0291212797,
-0.0132807512,
-0.0263696127,
0.020528378,
-0.04114509,
-0.0432751998,
0.0327907242,
0.0120219113,
-0.0514971167,
-0.0193401054,
-0.0658283234,
-0.0078564985,
0.0421655141,
-0.0146524217,
0.0057800128,
-0.0003607181,
0.0020437348,
-0.0284631737,
-0.0316515379,
-0.0203448981,
-0.0286789779,
0.052280724,
-0.0342723541,
0.0120264124,
-0.0234034695,
-0.0014098932,
0.0021011638,
-0.0789096504,
0.0384345353,
0.0114307357,
-0.052579537,
0.0221366044,
0.0089777038,
0.0173716396,
0.0623524934,
0.0075522307,
0.0102707408,
-0.0610151552,
-0.1048735604,
0.0249971151,
-0.0408652984,
0.0363448299,
0.0245379582,
-0.0031668989,
0.0088179633,
0.0017853944,
-0.04554414,
-0.0435053781,
-0.028990142,
0.0038743815,
0.0543886498,
-0.0329620093,
0.0651775226,
-0.0406004898,
0.0019403325,
-0.0393077098,
0.0366861075,
-0.0063397512,
0.0009278189,
-0.0117462426,
0.0198973697,
-0.0237597674,
0.0289131403,
0.0200278293,
-0.0756311938,
0.0094975857,
0.029009169,
0.0379804783,
0.1111316308,
0.0151025951,
0.0580108725,
0.0185893867,
-0.013596586,
-0.0074186609,
0.0129472995,
-0.021680275,
0.0054468033,
-0.0421142988,
-0.044079233,
0.0505882166,
0.0502115339,
-0.0081602298,
-0.0142079387,
-0.0365260094,
0.0132270521,
-0.0482017063,
-0.0069723921,
0.0441981629,
0.0266469195,
0.0143911568,
0.0371161327,
-0.0012936363,
0.0188876782,
0.0350306071,
0.0005309922,
0.0303911939,
-0.063741684,
-0.0070120697,
-0.0451709293,
0.0282428227,
-0.0285142194,
0.0285583232,
-0.0274469536,
0.0207473822,
-0.0025924558,
-0.0478019901,
0.0394126102,
-0.0245902184,
0.0126156993,
-0.0159724057,
-0.0270356592,
0.0170671474,
-0.0640346855,
0.0051625632,
-0.021700263,
-0.0035908043,
-0.0191833973,
0.0172980018,
-0.0245225672,
-0.0019092986,
-0.0119335204,
-0.0146960234,
-0.0006092987,
-0.0334529169,
-0.0085212206,
0.0358608924,
0.0423349068,
0.0230330974,
-0.0028393213,
0.043017067,
0.0249753445,
-0.0022757903,
0.0690244138,
-0.0463081971,
0.0425146781,
-0.0200280268,
-0.0274318382,
0.0102309473,
-0.0277946629,
-0.0387089401,
-0.07649979,
0.0542914458,
-0.034814544,
-0.0125632482,
0.1107344702,
0.0317336507,
-0.0437591784,
-0.0114371125,
0.0017788393,
-0.0329779796,
0.0233661029,
0.0276648812,
-0.0415167361,
0.0094036134,
-0.0388364419,
-0.0032763712,
-0.0249886438,
0.0011316662,
-0.0019701188,
-0.0541901104,
0.0132610761,
-0.0203501098,
-0.0118718864,
-0.0108911591,
-0.0476278923,
-0.0200930405,
-0.0621157326,
0.0018300341,
-0.0472133681,
0.0262603257,
-0.0079854764,
0.0145275677,
-0.01254074,
-0.018135909,
0.0196471345,
-0.0206047688,
0.0108160228,
0.0039646304,
0.0858353451,
-0.0117876604,
-0.0248163994,
0.0213727579,
0.0151740061,
-0.0320704803,
-0.0085076969,
0.0687280595,
-0.0289453603,
-0.0424711928,
-0.0333853103,
0.0218053684,
-0.0092156678,
-0.0036999926,
-0.0130788339,
0.0205532629,
0.0051888572,
0.0169561263,
-0.0378751121,
0.026077982,
0.0204328261,
0.0596238486,
-0.0004996954,
-0.0659010559,
-0.0024524799,
-0.0035583475,
0.0272923168,
-0.0447159521,
-0.0579378456,
0.0034943996,
-0.0259694662,
-0.0221532173,
-0.0892853141,
-0.0559247807,
-0.0171827003,
0.0259278622,
-0.0174589474,
-0.0741309971,
0.0391748697,
-0.0103841862,
-0.034374617,
0.0360932276,
0.0074997349,
-0.0134249898,
-0.0103580775,
0.007189732,
0.0755104944,
0.0281343143,
-0.0146119967,
-0.0009467917,
-0.0394324362,
-0.0069596898,
0.0137050115,
0.0477754585,
0.0045186942,
0.018778624,
-0.0269983429,
-0.0045424267,
-0.0440067425,
0.0261292271,
0.000422935,
-0.0122105759,
0.0704231709,
0.0398631878,
-0.005395276,
0.0258816034,
0.0158113688,
0.066861853,
0.0034274929,
-0.0233729538,
-0.0270014293,
-0.0377324149,
0.0136838323,
-0.0055665695,
0.0680395886,
0.0140905604,
0.0164842531,
-0.0245325509,
-0.003541308,
-0.0313990153,
-0.0208914708,
-0.0085746553,
0.0019971814,
0.0234906878,
-0.0075058318,
-0.0714421123,
-0.0048987851,
-0.0331875384,
0.0266702194,
-0.0476060137,
0.0427682884,
0.0380232558,
-0.0249080881,
-0.0512761101,
0.0256790109,
-0.0274093617,
0.0511551239,
0.026760146,
0.0293464512,
-0.0113421995,
0.0305738244,
-0.0018994407,
-0.0068143937,
0.031065708,
0.0146589242,
-0.0176685657,
0.0658722445,
-0.0358085744,
0.0277843196,
0.0239004306,
-0.0380225219,
0.0737757906,
-0.0247999895,
-0.008469047,
0.0192677788,
0.0242121387,
-0.0037885017,
-0.007633118,
0.0040542809,
-0.0138212349,
-0.0122320699,
-0.0025907087,
0.0336070582,
-0.0684413239,
0.0244449414,
0.0551312268,
-0.0415495187,
-0.0463818647,
-0.0195493717,
0.0379782952,
-0.0424746238,
0.0153375436,
0.0272630919,
-0.044037506,
0.010805144,
0.036849983,
-0.0164825786,
0.0198116656,
-0.0147652319,
-0.0221412182,
0.0936586857,
-0.0091178957,
0.0231183041,
-0.0485223569,
-0.0120308474,
-0.0200071838,
-0.0125136646,
-0.0344736651,
-5.505027757e-33,
0.0099387029,
0.0201604888,
-0.0550222956,
0.0855624303,
-0.0024313407,
0.020412568,
0.0116555253,
0.0324821919,
-0.0354888439,
0.0538636558,
0.0211295951,
0.0280288495,
0.0076690135,
0.0278251618,
-0.0042324751,
-0.0213976111,
0.0587583147,
0.0115602873,
-0.0322064757,
-0.0000798557,
0.0468055122,
-0.0092318961,
0.1240078434,
-0.1033171639,
0.0409066379,
0.0158583298,
-0.0513645783,
0.0182498619,
0.0485523045,
0.0574774481,
0.0250332225,
0.0627778918,
0.0167504624,
-0.0490294062,
0.0277989004,
0.0164239369,
-0.0049236929,
-0.0468274653,
0.0030240077,
0.058699429,
0.0313519984,
-0.049435135,
0.018729385,
0.0070211198,
-0.0201132391,
0.0190466251,
0.02712138,
-0.0255136061,
0.0385262519,
-0.0795416236,
-0.0867889971,
0.0178756993,
-0.0052183988,
-0.0277238861,
0.0194611475,
0.0276797228,
-0.0015180238,
0.0128194178,
-0.0293234754,
-0.005856764,
-0.0570597537,
0.0286207367,
-0.013986662,
-0.062145818,
-0.0206960533,
0.048754666,
-0.0005573283,
0.0566929244,
0.0126243951,
0.0585402176,
0.0355269574,
0.0229957793,
0.0615589917,
0.1019552723,
-0.0113705378,
-0.0117664775,
-0.0470832661,
0.0167811122,
0.0785420164,
0.0027876601,
0.0214840714,
-0.0332477912,
-0.0341914147,
-0.0027084001,
-0.0078027672,
-0.0593933053,
-0.0124260429,
-0.0139626758,
0.005235733,
-0.0284429025,
-0.0385301299,
0.0173290744,
0.016233597,
-0.0513242409,
0.0060474407,
0.0620157719,
-0.0546657853,
0.0327531993,
-0.008310793,
0.0349307358,
-0.0402289778,
0.0005107075,
-0.0157292373,
0.0375593901,
0.0164493639,
-0.0101512717,
0.087860927,
0.0332338102,
-0.0745484456,
0.0019281264,
-0.0114715649,
0.0497405082,
-0.0281559937,
0.0913112015,
-0.0275517683,
0.0175522026,
-0.0206611175,
0.0470624156,
0.0156278349,
0.0540729277,
-0.0182575583,
-0.0440792479,
-0.0016260578,
0.037586052,
-0.0264157932,
-0.0278293286,
0.0201793611,
-0.0076512638,
-0.0358679928,
-0.0743390098,
-0.013321803,
-0.0104916077,
2.327e-7,
0.0588493012,
0.0572914146,
0.0040840893,
-0.0098434882,
-0.0012635046,
0.0244650282,
0.0167008471,
0.0394607373,
-0.0175941736,
-0.0087043541,
-0.014453508,
0.0042764787,
0.0143552627,
0.0384578817,
-0.093196772,
-0.0416459441,
-0.0290991999,
0.0060715997,
-0.0254201461,
0.0151278079,
0.0739036351,
0.1042340323,
0.0137239117,
-0.008815418,
-0.0145908948,
0.0213620625,
0.0663979948,
-0.0303064827,
-0.065391548,
0.0406695455,
0.0498613864,
-0.0165936407,
0.0087409215,
-0.0336820856,
-0.014835461,
0.0071514356,
0.0055494537,
0.0607050285,
0.0411193185,
-0.0378230289,
0.0359622911,
-0.0164424311,
-0.0255839042,
-0.0172688086,
0.0432554744,
-0.062822856,
-0.0286027864,
-0.1103904322,
-0.0288369264,
0.013849359,
0.1003458276,
-0.0410946161,
-0.0182975084,
0.0272762626,
0.01950326,
-0.010731631,
-0.0092199007,
-0.0099971248,
-0.0602149479,
0.0074780388,
0.0093837976,
-0.0166900679,
0.0304117203,
-0.0082460335,
-0.0267790332,
-0.0169415828,
0.0388936251,
1.457464336e-34,
0.0626422912,
-0.0213975683,
-0.009323068,
0.010867456,
0.0204601604,
0.0111392234,
-0.0494157672,
-0.0212437343,
-0.0268679094,
0.0231905151,
0.0365701728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18029v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18029v2 | Faithfulness Tests for Natural Language Explanations | 2023-05-29T11:40:37 | 2023-06-30T15:41:47 | Pepa Atanasova, Oana-Maria Camburu, Christina Lioma, Thomas Lukasiewicz, Jakob Grue Simonsen, Isabelle Augenstein | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Explanations of neural models aim to reveal a model's decision-making process
for its predictions. However, recent work shows that current methods giving
explanations such as saliency maps or counterfactuals can be misleading, as
they are prone to present reasons that are unfaithful to the model's inner
workings. This work explores the challenging question of evaluating the
faithfulness of natural language explanations (NLEs). To this end, we present
two tests. First, we propose a counterfactual input editor for inserting
reasons that lead to counterfactual predictions but are not reflected by the
NLEs. Second, we reconstruct inputs from the reasons stated in the generated
NLEs and check how often they lead to the same predictions. Our tests can
evaluate emerging NLE models, proving a fundamental tool in the development of
faithful NLEs. | [
0.0370213613,
0.0552525558,
-0.0088732326,
0.0453182608,
-0.0191185717,
0.0177806523,
-0.003721314,
0.0025333036,
-0.0282397866,
-0.0273921024,
0.0163533725,
-0.0083094398,
0.0079001635,
0.0337614827,
0.0317856334,
-0.0597229302,
0.0354392342,
0.0059932601,
-0.0101023139,
0.0235510655,
-0.0067069586,
0.0236849207,
0.0024329869,
0.0582376607,
0.0098829288,
-0.0183773469,
-0.0303288251,
0.0028463742,
0.0088024605,
-0.00673377,
-0.023417905,
-0.009535348,
0.0097061088,
0.0304795634,
0.0000021515,
-0.0305733886,
0.0066279052,
0.0043502375,
-0.0539508983,
0.0272510219,
-0.0344797596,
-0.0175674483,
0.0032083262,
-0.0264830422,
-0.0135457451,
0.0600148104,
0.074772045,
0.0652198419,
0.0602202266,
0.0564397238,
0.010653547,
-0.0205959603,
-0.0071938797,
-0.0118499054,
0.0075088148,
-0.0011541132,
-0.0255509149,
-0.0176692158,
-0.0244601853,
0.0186675321,
-0.0110623352,
0.0011570894,
0.0413535908,
-0.0338816196,
0.032691557,
0.0410832986,
-0.0004075345,
-0.0342620052,
-0.0000813987,
0.0300534349,
-0.0133973043,
-0.0417107269,
-0.0115598813,
-0.037670128,
-0.013638163,
0.0301694423,
-0.0406169854,
-0.0039820424,
0.0007395819,
0.0263412744,
0.0011135368,
0.0187368095,
0.0644859523,
0.0110108778,
0.0078692511,
0.0460749418,
0.0012161543,
0.0000603153,
-0.0229226127,
0.0033830027,
-0.0159823447,
-0.0758965462,
0.0110328216,
0.0380714424,
-0.0289378818,
-0.003032143,
0.0064323093,
0.0351744927,
0.0129222674,
-0.0680841431,
0.0459674262,
0.0444688126,
-0.0567768738,
0.0286060944,
-0.0191859789,
0.0666792169,
-0.0383079201,
0.0288450215,
-0.0147889862,
-0.0170030817,
-0.0427633189,
-0.0209458899,
0.0076719653,
-0.0132884756,
-0.0313577354,
-0.022353882,
0.0017647275,
0.0147607196,
-0.0571416989,
0.0036520821,
0.0074009458,
0.0587556884,
-0.0232974477,
-0.0231747292,
-0.075940907,
0.00653863,
-0.0792983696,
-0.0008524816,
0.02742563,
-0.024126634,
-0.0281382166,
0.018935889,
-0.0080448668,
-0.0190709103,
-0.0193143804,
0.0920479447,
0.0291505326,
0.011827697,
-0.0446987189,
-0.0317251012,
-0.031060433,
-0.0424890406,
-0.0021882344,
-0.0060146223,
0.0070778858,
-0.0023019374,
-0.0095565943,
-0.0526959486,
0.0042409184,
-0.0008410518,
-0.0160262305,
0.1033487171,
-0.0188738536,
-0.0058820783,
-0.0281719603,
0.0074533727,
-0.0248280466,
0.0164128002,
0.0045378227,
0.0185176525,
0.0244089756,
-0.0523423664,
0.0399185494,
-0.0385968275,
0.0210962016,
-0.0335090458,
-0.0431543067,
-0.0054544867,
-0.0606397428,
0.046583917,
0.03422888,
0.02348537,
-0.0029235547,
-0.0440611392,
0.0530818067,
0.0424352586,
0.0128757916,
0.0348183364,
0.0466860719,
-0.0046404134,
-0.0365108587,
0.0781457499,
-0.093050234,
0.0751287639,
-0.0369827822,
0.011872923,
0.0215403438,
-0.0075528487,
-0.0070422888,
-0.0688223466,
-0.0461892225,
0.005837129,
0.0158680137,
0.0082262876,
0.0425948761,
-0.0123925973,
-0.0286605041,
0.0042432928,
0.0307700746,
-0.0242598224,
-0.0110404231,
-0.0669744685,
0.0332284644,
0.0830289125,
0.0162443127,
-0.0027191206,
-0.0276464913,
0.0073709511,
-0.02355179,
0.0434922799,
0.0601576082,
0.0005861726,
0.0413577259,
-0.0211698376,
-0.0271816142,
-0.0694895759,
0.0378940664,
0.0160315093,
-0.0102213304,
-0.0311595891,
0.0256262738,
-0.0301054735,
-0.0357769281,
0.0437931754,
0.0061657028,
-0.0357590318,
-0.0080177207,
0.0162249394,
0.0131637109,
0.024964137,
0.0160018299,
0.0415675379,
0.0363324173,
-0.0092710452,
-0.0040880423,
0.0474853329,
-0.0403679572,
-0.022390496,
0.0093711549,
-0.0558167845,
-0.0338980518,
0.044538673,
-0.0187241379,
-0.0340724923,
0.0306132603,
-0.0616082288,
0.0374253206,
-0.0353470631,
0.0172201619,
-0.0111948727,
0.002376108,
-0.0094284527,
0.0376921557,
0.007276603,
0.0122241536,
-0.0014159555,
-0.0079446472,
0.0371467695,
-0.0356518738,
0.0223479383,
0.015681494,
-0.0078777745,
-0.0367353633,
0.007659798,
-0.017954221,
-0.0296916999,
0.0353693366,
-0.0270033646,
-0.0156922396,
-0.0372237675,
0.0112893237,
0.0394238979,
-0.0338702388,
0.0349212997,
-0.0261303484,
-0.0079393219,
0.0011102497,
-0.02903313,
0.0164049007,
0.0623904318,
-0.0277634114,
-0.0124220783,
-0.057398513,
-0.0169269964,
-0.0431660935,
0.0710255057,
0.0200113486,
0.0111798225,
-0.0708809793,
-0.0248433016,
-0.0225828029,
-0.0128201507,
0.0005569717,
-0.0358867645,
0.0691042691,
0.0307365339,
-0.0348350555,
0.0587121509,
0.0115606682,
0.0526528545,
0.0505051613,
0.0307494607,
-0.0671199113,
-0.0143801803,
-0.0262448676,
0.0020934637,
0.0093093105,
-0.0723598897,
0.0133082075,
0.0704715028,
0.0053777797,
-0.0001330312,
-0.0847163945,
0.0405309834,
0.0074802232,
-0.0123616569,
-0.0286573078,
-0.0408418551,
-0.0079003442,
0.0786936954,
-0.0093049426,
-0.0731355846,
0.1129312143,
-0.0354739018,
-0.007039573,
0.0072390814,
-0.0238717087,
-0.0175925232,
0.0616505258,
-0.0112781245,
0.0087565351,
0.0564909689,
0.0176127516,
0.0006723317,
-0.0374065153,
0.0317674764,
0.0375975147,
0.0448755659,
-0.0570207722,
-0.0313140787,
0.0338388607,
0.0165636782,
-0.0417669564,
-0.0587730668,
-0.0267361607,
0.0263733622,
-0.0101259779,
-0.0114833778,
-0.0262638982,
0.0297258142,
0.0240670387,
0.0169981476,
-0.0046794522,
-0.0227460731,
-0.010102761,
-0.0057077585,
0.0290551297,
0.0680625141,
0.0708311647,
-0.0004939892,
-0.0012399821,
0.0174748357,
-0.0147628272,
0.0389734022,
-0.0660499483,
0.0263365973,
-0.0302356314,
-0.0159014221,
0.0146574695,
0.012148967,
0.0530778617,
-0.0754695833,
-0.0198157374,
0.087932162,
0.0234224238,
-0.0184663702,
0.0453636311,
-0.0188491475,
-0.0022145081,
0.0413771085,
-0.000120062,
-0.0104097836,
-0.0423794389,
-0.0045876382,
0.021538021,
0.0108675333,
0.0207008105,
-0.0059290323,
-0.0741903409,
0.0391427502,
-0.0168260857,
-0.0208470859,
-0.0552063286,
-0.0814608485,
-0.0014226832,
-0.0239406805,
-0.0078573236,
-0.0020342169,
0.0406920724,
0.0061504864,
0.000624434,
-0.0105432244,
-0.0298583768,
0.0297062788,
-0.0443890914,
0.0407244451,
0.1020061001,
0.0510145314,
0.014674738,
-0.0357722677,
0.0080429921,
-0.007493028,
0.056702435,
0.0125894547,
0.0519652553,
0.0235234592,
-0.0262142047,
-0.0473774895,
0.0113798613,
-0.0123732677,
-0.044157967,
-0.0214791223,
0.0593227781,
-0.0414238833,
-0.0396450907,
-0.0250307489,
0.0324189849,
-0.0083706835,
0.1041544825,
0.0955500454,
-0.019063374,
-0.03508633,
-0.0313673913,
-0.0043005156,
-0.0636900589,
-0.0572301,
0.0165444501,
0.0349379033,
-0.010077198,
-0.0415500365,
-0.0495238453,
-0.0264745951,
0.0053017358,
-0.0018615872,
-0.0579154305,
-0.0224465542,
-0.0437876992,
0.0059015569,
0.078725554,
0.0280168857,
0.007388101,
0.0081665134,
-0.0281038489,
-0.001524928,
-0.0403449386,
-0.0123921419,
0.0049715168,
-0.0111859208,
-0.0459911712,
-0.0215777662,
0.0286863633,
0.0294687953,
0.0643947348,
-0.0211907998,
-0.035454642,
-0.0318322182,
0.0005509969,
-0.0036581568,
-0.0311907865,
0.0513574891,
0.0017241732,
0.0053735133,
0.0422428995,
-0.0146576343,
-0.0044672359,
0.0022626235,
0.0367647894,
0.0186716523,
-0.0121476911,
0.0553712435,
-0.0191410612,
0.0863797739,
-0.0245318618,
-0.0062130215,
-0.0172623023,
-0.001248108,
-0.0123856524,
-0.0160319861,
-0.0213081464,
0.0136954188,
-0.0058740838,
-0.0113228131,
-0.0283764806,
-0.025182886,
-0.072487615,
-0.0007813349,
-0.0345589668,
0.009249704,
0.0475828648,
-0.0075986395,
-0.0412402675,
0.0242366549,
-0.0237372573,
0.0264663156,
-0.037882559,
0.0382715762,
-0.00130157,
0.0430961251,
0.0214219633,
-0.0054650456,
-0.013252411,
-0.0039602299,
-0.080684647,
-0.0433375537,
-0.0093162805,
-0.0077702394,
0.0153807625,
-0.052395843,
0.0379547998,
-0.0092724869,
0.0030576184,
0.0177544188,
0.0521729589,
0.0448477864,
-0.0052279877,
0.0179404337,
0.018754635,
-0.0198803414,
-0.0410683528,
0.0279733818,
-0.0140936906,
0.014918251,
-0.0193318091,
-0.017936511,
0.0018278754,
-0.0385310799,
-0.0010818011,
0.0548221804,
-0.025978731,
-0.0104778958,
-0.0602167323,
-0.0499140359,
-0.0155748436,
0.0214448553,
0.001682809,
-0.0104330676,
0.0188423116,
0.0555330366,
-0.0017536116,
-0.0133477999,
0.007151763,
0.0279963706,
-0.0253599621,
0.0489118248,
-0.0507024862,
-6.750964708e-33,
0.0046795974,
-0.0653671473,
-0.012994634,
-0.0528904274,
0.0162099283,
0.0004066394,
-0.0908810496,
-0.0422386602,
-0.0287710167,
0.0419514552,
0.0197651386,
0.0366464294,
0.0153583745,
0.0026749244,
0.0200610738,
-0.048254393,
0.0217719525,
0.0306136236,
-0.0283698943,
-0.0065922937,
0.0135672437,
-0.0182373039,
0.0751852393,
-0.0863195583,
0.0735083222,
0.0502062663,
-0.0064826035,
0.0227422938,
-0.0609311834,
0.0727966353,
-0.0250847172,
0.0418071263,
0.0186092351,
-0.0553681292,
0.0005466887,
-0.0166268218,
-0.0193706304,
-0.0335296318,
0.0349933766,
-0.0033591872,
-0.0658852309,
-0.0255675241,
0.063873753,
-0.014513839,
-0.0063009262,
0.0010185005,
0.034373045,
-0.0111778537,
0.0051220441,
0.0432350487,
-0.0781484246,
0.0113181993,
-0.0313375369,
-0.0422145575,
0.0008039806,
0.0537246056,
0.0068123732,
0.0295576006,
-0.031330388,
-0.009356996,
0.0389546901,
-0.0284266137,
0.0853780434,
-0.0124590155,
0.0032206376,
0.0790217146,
0.047847487,
0.0046423688,
-0.0734171048,
-0.023487635,
-0.0159649905,
0.056668587,
0.1242090911,
0.0545043349,
0.0677953511,
0.0451415628,
-0.0431139208,
0.0132737244,
-0.0589045249,
0.0317547806,
0.038441211,
0.0229177307,
-0.0363537222,
-0.0145496931,
-0.0305151958,
-0.0574995093,
-0.0508221351,
-0.0232590381,
0.0325909406,
-0.0370331034,
-0.0291407071,
0.0413087271,
-0.0020814829,
-0.0369736291,
0.0471868962,
0.02323444,
-0.0082933018,
-0.0276048873,
0.0199221354,
-0.0105487891,
-0.0011784992,
0.0189946461,
0.0109914187,
0.0170857217,
0.053195823,
0.010761586,
0.0195843782,
-0.0073798164,
0.0012569997,
-0.012457178,
-0.0809140429,
-0.0516552478,
-0.0211635418,
-0.0300259832,
0.0404770151,
0.0147894407,
-0.0391779654,
0.0328550376,
0.0063610054,
0.0198384393,
-0.0133566726,
0.031833902,
-0.0118219331,
0.025190033,
0.0041537872,
-0.0148002123,
-0.0254257824,
-0.0171875656,
0.0161477663,
-0.039354872,
-0.044000417,
0.0301408079,
2.748e-7,
0.0380657502,
0.0328719318,
0.0471534766,
-0.0199795738,
0.0315887816,
0.0512306541,
-0.0286310203,
-0.0239751022,
-0.0111401509,
-0.0337270498,
-0.0101400325,
0.0274105184,
0.0453830212,
0.0252466649,
0.0155164246,
0.0028480776,
-0.0765569657,
-0.0344399139,
-0.0161184426,
0.0123176705,
0.0675823316,
0.0558211468,
0.0324811526,
-0.0003952689,
0.0443138592,
-0.0104956133,
0.0290623885,
-0.0560800284,
0.0366019793,
-0.0312383119,
0.0203158204,
-0.0308474693,
-0.0017330375,
0.0054798778,
0.002476485,
-0.0210840385,
-0.0093250666,
0.0373516344,
-0.0532233641,
-0.0698016137,
-0.066351369,
-0.0267901178,
0.0420013256,
-0.0885746405,
0.0776699111,
-0.0269860104,
-0.0262052827,
-0.0280344971,
-0.0133103682,
-0.0045681656,
0.0415473282,
-0.0134822028,
-0.0147045348,
0.0042575411,
-0.017081501,
0.0106651457,
-0.0249684397,
-0.0647090152,
-0.0767335817,
0.0237044953,
-0.0221088417,
0.0275488589,
-0.0510254093,
-0.0067185983,
0.0942270234,
-0.0417257361,
-0.0211811475,
2.164378973e-34,
0.0034133382,
0.0520861968,
0.0199968591,
0.0221737474,
0.0482619479,
0.0168111622,
-0.0153558562,
-0.0267898254,
0.0563523993,
-0.0185330324,
-0.047291927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18028v1 | ADAPTERMIX: Exploring the Efficacy of Mixture of Adapters for Low-Resource TTS Adaptation | 2023-05-29T11:39:01 | 2023-05-29T11:39:01 | Ambuj Mehrish, Abhinav Ramesh Kashyap, Li Yingting, Navonil Majumder, Soujanya Poria | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | There are significant challenges for speaker adaptation in text-to-speech for
languages that are not widely spoken or for speakers with accents or dialects
that are not well-represented in the training data. To address this issue, we
propose the use of the "mixture of adapters" method. This approach involves
adding multiple adapters within a backbone-model layer to learn the unique
characteristics of different speakers. Our approach outperforms the baseline,
with a noticeable improvement of 5% observed in speaker preference tests when
using only one minute of data for each new speaker. Moreover, following the
adapter paradigm, we fine-tune only the adapter parameters (11% of the total
model parameters). This is a significant achievement in parameter-efficient
speaker adaptation, and one of the first models of its kind. Overall, our
proposed approach offers a promising solution to the speech synthesis
techniques, particularly for adapting to speakers from diverse backgrounds. | [
-0.0017358075,
0.038431026,
0.0040156716,
-0.0194988735,
0.0204967372,
-0.0156900492,
0.0553811826,
-0.0203671865,
-0.0200407468,
0.006468988,
-0.059295062,
-0.0013767637,
0.0229214914,
-0.0004649126,
0.0218772124,
-0.107277669,
0.0234094094,
-0.0223271474,
-0.0148635926,
-0.0319663174,
0.0116281668,
0.0208772793,
-0.0167297665,
0.0332184136,
0.0343681499,
0.0232474506,
-0.0082770819,
0.0285508074,
0.0516469292,
0.0424673893,
0.0057028583,
0.0343301073,
-0.0051682401,
0.0467743725,
0.0000018474,
-0.019184107,
-0.040351864,
0.0082418714,
-0.0306665022,
-0.0029044652,
0.0330678374,
0.0601818785,
-0.0218485426,
0.0476980023,
-0.000611974,
-0.0170325618,
0.0446351245,
0.0292233806,
0.0266503207,
0.0704485327,
-0.0118461205,
0.0113569666,
-0.0041031078,
0.010463086,
-0.0022440932,
0.0409818664,
-0.0197374299,
-0.0580661558,
0.0095509319,
-0.0409431979,
-0.0556852818,
0.0325098969,
-0.0057341587,
0.0196072478,
0.016360186,
-0.0271450561,
-0.0016948645,
-0.0286683962,
-0.0271060057,
0.0589154623,
-0.04476621,
0.0002898469,
0.0208051689,
-0.0099388612,
0.0024949282,
-0.0213867184,
-0.0030046538,
-0.0420061722,
-0.0127229597,
-0.0223644041,
-0.0310890153,
0.0117499046,
0.0025613981,
-0.0352248028,
-0.0881175101,
0.0062502269,
0.0106374891,
-0.0277801771,
-0.017356731,
-0.0099264886,
0.0237729494,
0.0001331706,
0.0494679213,
0.0134701151,
-0.0358520895,
-0.0097750593,
-0.0528941676,
-0.0622020811,
-0.0468047969,
-0.0413769819,
0.0351551585,
0.079338491,
-0.0219796859,
-0.0105998004,
-0.0611030348,
0.0146812852,
-0.0029066131,
-0.0386734754,
-0.0213322379,
-0.015974544,
-0.0271526333,
0.0392529815,
-0.0502708256,
0.0335573368,
-0.051838316,
0.007672111,
-0.008856779,
0.0533444248,
-0.0306558907,
-0.0061661494,
0.023982618,
0.0030322785,
-0.0749532431,
-0.02883178,
-0.0002026449,
0.069142729,
0.0009494838,
0.0241187289,
-0.0039069271,
-0.0768891722,
0.0161801241,
0.0245576464,
0.056571696,
-0.0101928189,
0.0203483813,
-0.0011580396,
-0.0114451302,
-0.0091097113,
-0.0124039697,
0.0132133728,
-0.0390341096,
-0.0061364886,
0.0010864479,
-0.0439404473,
0.0278911255,
0.0053676078,
0.0300776549,
-0.056611117,
-0.0425766781,
-0.0267854445,
0.0000222022,
0.0118113384,
0.0049924073,
0.0332600549,
0.0341949873,
-0.0208212771,
-0.0230446476,
0.0595028996,
0.0462302081,
-0.0176632646,
-0.0273026228,
-0.0597434379,
-0.0315893106,
0.0492945015,
-0.0132949892,
0.0345090367,
-0.0333380215,
-0.004099872,
-0.0056247441,
-0.0009949125,
0.0615555085,
0.0218796711,
-0.0132451318,
-0.0159952864,
0.0502883606,
-0.0018258498,
0.1022910029,
0.0424836576,
0.0628334135,
0.0272321515,
0.0195354316,
-0.0066195116,
-0.0117086601,
0.0134643661,
-0.0158110205,
0.0237110015,
0.0102304565,
0.0950441882,
-0.0409602486,
-0.0122424746,
0.0252060015,
-0.0099945134,
-0.028578151,
0.0030382008,
-0.0007439577,
0.0425683297,
-0.0438801534,
0.0242739487,
0.0153502896,
-0.0765408352,
0.037905775,
-0.0262563396,
-0.0187501796,
0.0480755121,
-0.0057955878,
0.0254461132,
-0.033318352,
-0.021911718,
-0.0142447744,
0.0151087716,
0.015456236,
0.0230913721,
0.0647023842,
-0.06621968,
0.0015359086,
0.0444914363,
-0.0208842289,
0.0858389735,
-0.0255305804,
0.0182327125,
0.0011422845,
-0.0228122436,
0.0310363136,
-0.0059036459,
-0.0645080283,
0.0010990339,
0.0777179673,
0.0133965435,
0.021087762,
0.0301053766,
-0.0438234918,
-0.026833564,
-0.0110457232,
-0.0180001725,
0.0079231635,
0.0786612853,
-0.0657423884,
-0.0322119556,
0.0220959745,
0.00236894,
0.0355542973,
-0.0246909354,
0.0532281138,
-0.1018492356,
0.0516609885,
-0.0125041585,
0.0716073215,
-0.0108752539,
0.0178130437,
-0.0059785466,
0.0366723128,
0.0376069658,
-0.0126635293,
0.0341362767,
-0.035275545,
0.0403610766,
0.0243573338,
0.002150987,
-0.0794157013,
0.0011963953,
-0.0036390757,
-0.0063642776,
0.0402675197,
-0.033387769,
-0.020119803,
-0.0191535093,
-0.0583652668,
-0.0715979263,
0.024703376,
-0.0057442142,
0.0160026867,
-0.0081311837,
0.0592282303,
-0.0182611942,
-0.0198614281,
-0.0329039283,
-0.0274428632,
0.0006402965,
-0.0160574447,
-0.054756403,
-0.0132531123,
0.001910866,
-0.018103756,
0.023034526,
-0.0035533132,
0.0149887679,
-0.064572297,
-0.0184892956,
-0.0051801144,
-0.0832251981,
0.0090591675,
0.0078218868,
0.024868995,
-0.0234159064,
-0.0335869268,
0.0104907434,
0.0887755528,
0.013452908,
0.0241193958,
-0.0145776188,
0.0126215247,
-0.0190489013,
-0.0606838502,
0.0318702534,
0.007160401,
0.0375777408,
-0.042710714,
-0.0082294447,
-0.0066900505,
0.0343484506,
0.0033235752,
-0.0011239869,
-0.0974996537,
-0.0003430701,
0.0195749514,
-0.0216440596,
0.0362408459,
0.0106146354,
-0.0386687182,
-0.0284309275,
-0.0132865859,
-0.0113098184,
0.0287441909,
-0.0455513075,
-0.0516947918,
-0.0614206716,
-0.0539620556,
-0.0164444558,
-0.0712225959,
-0.0207457859,
0.0431285501,
0.0077438876,
0.0082591483,
-0.0408612192,
-0.0151502769,
0.0304345209,
-0.0434693918,
0.0460838862,
0.0174720995,
-0.0240062084,
-0.0147690661,
-0.0205849223,
-0.0069547729,
0.0248162895,
-0.0229316056,
0.0179715548,
0.0047160811,
-0.0600070395,
-0.0337219089,
-0.0029256502,
0.0628139377,
0.0442777649,
-0.0272503607,
0.0181648154,
-0.0306027606,
0.0215595905,
0.0077645169,
0.0826686993,
-0.0316169336,
-0.0242198613,
0.0829426944,
-0.0505987033,
0.0761025548,
-0.0110075437,
-0.055459857,
0.0040843645,
0.0439196974,
0.026256999,
0.0123145413,
0.0338207595,
0.0669005141,
-0.0021903699,
0.0234187786,
0.0845243931,
-0.0136764757,
-0.0225624125,
-0.0132960072,
-0.0346897542,
0.0846157372,
0.0031349722,
0.0292201247,
-0.02083016,
-0.0093498295,
0.032356739,
0.0697437972,
-0.0111622717,
0.0284214802,
-0.0494589731,
-0.045810286,
0.0301426053,
0.0340529531,
-0.0590164252,
0.0070507815,
-0.019278504,
-0.0164806303,
-0.014287265,
0.0415316075,
0.0341788232,
-0.018023219,
-0.0445306003,
0.0435505472,
-0.0829879344,
-0.0549318381,
-0.0490253977,
-0.0387594886,
0.0814930797,
0.0051035988,
-0.0008698908,
-0.0265321638,
-0.0124094682,
-0.0316156186,
-0.037376076,
0.0025509037,
-0.0156776868,
-0.0176171213,
0.0368839689,
-0.0104155811,
0.0177147705,
0.0388961956,
-0.0120717231,
0.0043455022,
0.0259037446,
0.0394416936,
-0.0012034856,
0.0002941557,
-0.0100297499,
0.014971422,
-0.0029157803,
0.0350263417,
0.0419032946,
-0.1249881163,
0.0316664726,
-0.0055675567,
-0.0240426082,
-0.069642514,
-0.0077938959,
0.0073462874,
-0.0162848197,
-0.0334232226,
-0.0259696711,
0.0280053578,
0.005970811,
0.0920600072,
0.0080533521,
-0.0020954055,
-0.0386539698,
0.0025972233,
0.0027304785,
0.0140887536,
-0.0103253853,
0.0135393562,
-0.0683634654,
-0.0117256036,
0.0151450243,
-0.0775566548,
0.0057457383,
-0.0200373344,
0.0025153961,
-0.067403771,
0.0307015777,
0.0212116856,
0.0189971551,
0.0682967231,
-0.0176791549,
-0.0390978381,
0.0787759349,
0.0451025777,
0.0453833938,
0.0500135049,
0.1060546562,
-0.0069909147,
-0.0262542125,
-0.0023738611,
-0.070931226,
0.0100905122,
0.00616566,
-0.0066394308,
0.00241976,
-0.0521663874,
-0.0091770263,
-0.0022162509,
-0.0120253963,
-0.0071910643,
0.0126017416,
-0.0192575976,
0.0241485536,
0.0133419354,
0.0343739688,
-0.0312992968,
-0.0448166095,
0.0262111407,
0.0363238826,
0.0065063378,
0.018059548,
-0.0104846535,
0.0445984714,
0.0127139809,
0.0637830868,
-0.0023602715,
-0.0086260056,
0.0348069854,
0.0025248718,
-0.02161186,
-0.0024020949,
0.0310215075,
-0.0139968144,
-0.0166409165,
-0.0180278048,
0.0001421706,
-0.0225219708,
-0.0111133615,
0.0219735168,
-0.0295658652,
-0.0090631768,
-0.0449137688,
-0.0007389753,
0.0151403518,
0.0248334575,
0.0922991335,
0.0005459776,
0.052030962,
-0.0421830155,
-0.0139906639,
-0.0401528887,
0.0133557227,
0.0134485178,
-0.0284472033,
0.0051861173,
0.0072729508,
0.0255387407,
-0.0241900012,
0.0313250348,
-0.0352462456,
0.0763776451,
-0.0196473841,
-0.0188460499,
-0.0283345468,
-0.0107260169,
-0.0203754753,
-0.0353383534,
-0.0187041052,
-0.0254444312,
0.063619636,
-0.0088928873,
0.0136626754,
-0.0380967073,
0.0043364838,
-0.0544070378,
-0.0325336568,
0.016718382,
-0.005848472,
-0.0429170355,
-0.0070658159,
-0.0051330091,
0.0710330606,
-6.008989368e-33,
-0.0423860624,
0.0442772284,
0.005453486,
-0.0310495608,
-0.0033126541,
-0.0506585762,
-0.0304440893,
0.0162552558,
-0.035822168,
-0.0490701459,
-0.0268704388,
-0.0206944365,
0.0279069804,
0.0360986479,
-0.034980461,
0.0596921816,
0.0982126817,
0.0014984416,
0.0004093304,
0.0196986087,
-0.001800055,
0.0255215652,
-0.0031232384,
-0.0406994112,
-0.0412495136,
0.0191148091,
-0.0057944343,
-0.030140942,
0.0038409962,
0.0682716295,
0.0329778157,
0.0739227906,
-0.0119276531,
0.0147435479,
-0.0460123643,
0.0138445804,
-0.0634717718,
-0.0123374071,
-0.0227196813,
0.0575310737,
0.0019254131,
-0.0398526751,
0.0512570366,
0.0237176958,
-0.0192240775,
-0.0322914422,
0.0277860351,
-0.0474920683,
-0.0210831016,
-0.0081684096,
-0.0195199568,
0.0419160873,
0.0001800946,
0.0074648052,
0.0290055629,
0.0792686492,
-0.0303187761,
-0.0498899482,
-0.0326052196,
0.0222765561,
0.0305684004,
0.0031569672,
0.0038314483,
0.057555303,
-0.015189304,
-0.008784879,
0.0527851842,
-0.0382590778,
0.0516539998,
-0.0094378125,
0.0678562596,
0.0133013939,
0.0522006005,
0.0592332669,
-0.0090109259,
-0.0503468774,
0.0283935405,
0.0284971353,
0.0591409206,
-0.0249013416,
0.0262223687,
0.0398805439,
-0.0015622138,
0.0330461785,
-0.0602117367,
-0.0527147949,
-0.0161101799,
-0.0477568395,
0.0366680622,
-0.0031382691,
-0.0199041888,
-0.0326496586,
0.0873602107,
-0.0193719231,
0.0207804404,
-0.0094330534,
-0.0605345368,
0.0103563014,
0.0227917191,
0.0481680073,
-0.0236385595,
-0.0600892156,
0.085990265,
0.0103837587,
-0.0062631881,
0.0029904556,
-0.0080882255,
0.0658517331,
-0.08725214,
-0.0033713724,
0.0250045601,
0.0351326279,
0.0101393145,
0.0503325909,
0.0010977938,
-0.0108040813,
0.0000210504,
0.0069654151,
-0.0184915494,
-0.0329129919,
0.0016903623,
-0.0082041258,
0.0103630051,
0.0363990441,
-0.0616767555,
0.0073212357,
0.016081566,
-0.0068822522,
0.0392873473,
-0.0199070908,
-0.0262329336,
0.0002602771,
2.733e-7,
-0.04495712,
0.005831596,
-0.0081314864,
-0.0723273233,
0.0272471029,
0.0164270401,
-0.0214845501,
0.0068862126,
0.0112984534,
0.0532308966,
-0.0161883868,
-0.0106561054,
0.0773021355,
0.0076564485,
-0.0865138248,
-0.0004637894,
-0.0414849855,
0.0511734076,
-0.034277942,
0.0202302653,
0.0030607923,
0.0678998381,
-0.0164930783,
-0.0139446333,
0.0376620069,
-0.019694658,
0.0317727737,
-0.0329126753,
0.0182498787,
-0.0171082187,
0.0567836873,
0.0121725602,
-0.0332638733,
-0.0072590597,
-0.0225563571,
0.0776916519,
-0.0246212538,
0.0428557135,
0.0018229297,
-0.0397519618,
0.0496129505,
0.046372056,
-0.0303576533,
-0.013593805,
0.0413485691,
0.0087174475,
0.0071694748,
-0.0244232938,
-0.0401768312,
0.010407838,
-0.0163642168,
-0.0335311331,
-0.0143720834,
-0.0090404693,
0.0298130959,
0.0055077421,
-0.0263590161,
-0.0116171632,
0.0070463312,
0.0322230645,
-0.0492132157,
-0.0740237981,
-0.0447907634,
0.0120593393,
0.0401669107,
-0.0188998971,
0.007258561,
2.012848568e-34,
-0.0164420474,
-0.0118702492,
0.0338550024,
0.0153013142,
0.0066971001,
-0.0567307882,
0.0524300784,
0.022283433,
0.0372646898,
-0.0752719492,
-0.0562132224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18026v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18026v2 | Semantic Role Labeling Guided Out-of-distribution Detection | 2023-05-29T11:34:14 | 2024-03-18T23:53:50 | Jinan Zou, Maihao Guo, Yu Tian, Yuhao Lin, Haiyao Cao, Lingqiao Liu, Ehsan Abbasnejad, Javen Qinfeng Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying unexpected domain-shifted instances in natural language
processing is crucial in real-world applications. Previous works identify the
out-of-distribution (OOD) instance by leveraging a single global feature
embedding to represent the sentence, which cannot characterize subtle OOD
patterns well. Another major challenge current OOD methods face is learning
effective low-dimensional sentence representations to identify the hard OOD
instances that are semantically similar to the in-distribution (ID) data. In
this paper, we propose a new unsupervised OOD detection method, namely Semantic
Role Labeling Guided Out-of-distribution Detection (SRLOOD), that separates,
extracts, and learns the semantic role labeling (SRL) guided fine-grained local
feature representations from different arguments of a sentence and the global
feature representations of the full sentence using a margin-based contrastive
loss. A novel self-supervised approach is also introduced to enhance such
global-local feature learning by predicting the SRL extracted role. The
resulting model achieves SOTA performance on four OOD benchmarks, indicating
the effectiveness of our approach. The code is publicly accessible via
\url{https://github.com/cytai/SRLOOD}. | [
0.055682864,
0.004817809,
0.0106320195,
0.0789720193,
-0.0386558697,
0.0044735256,
-0.0415818505,
-0.0313437991,
-0.0191432796,
-0.0760050565,
-0.0261979382,
-0.0237739757,
-0.0221786909,
0.0229850765,
0.0024270101,
-0.0145510351,
0.0526788831,
0.0267632306,
0.0225144885,
0.0117829507,
0.0159596,
0.0277506616,
-0.0159464441,
0.0218331907,
-0.0104291951,
-0.0590448864,
0.0401132405,
0.0200727079,
0.0450723171,
-0.0131972218,
0.0464526303,
-0.0046092649,
0.0271020252,
-0.006715504,
0.0000020322,
-0.0533222444,
-0.0381375626,
0.0037640282,
0.0047193104,
-0.0051829079,
0.0342039205,
-0.0128856767,
-0.0348803997,
-0.0002640176,
-0.031165706,
-0.0179463662,
0.0471839942,
0.0670439601,
0.002837345,
0.0941098481,
-0.0124332467,
0.0106877778,
-0.0352954306,
-0.0206193179,
-0.0230635591,
-0.0219449922,
0.0319301784,
-0.0321481116,
-0.0363870338,
-0.0135575207,
-0.0403649397,
0.0142939938,
-0.0045159417,
0.016125571,
-0.0009801661,
0.0346413031,
-0.023285633,
0.0201495886,
-0.0014511042,
0.074647218,
-0.031504035,
0.0135256583,
0.0111954324,
-0.0308798607,
0.0206440613,
0.0302550755,
0.0123658972,
0.0304755513,
0.0287929717,
0.0335442126,
0.0149250878,
0.0482342616,
-0.000165338,
0.0165946949,
-0.0384529233,
0.0497453846,
-0.016503172,
-0.0450795963,
-0.0237289928,
-0.0009924299,
-0.0944771841,
0.0228524841,
0.0214403812,
-0.0130540775,
0.0315080173,
0.020114433,
-0.0461170226,
-0.0146588162,
0.0100794015,
-0.0347659774,
0.0306232031,
-0.0181096327,
-0.0840370059,
0.0257163737,
0.0182158016,
0.0225183032,
-0.0204200502,
0.0434003696,
-0.0213139877,
0.0143813808,
-0.057696037,
-0.0295330118,
-0.0446002707,
0.0619914159,
-0.0415630527,
-0.0598452725,
-0.008181572,
-0.0246274229,
-0.0455625467,
-0.0115480283,
0.0220689662,
0.0542825088,
-0.0101797134,
0.0215313323,
-0.0011896846,
0.0484624878,
0.0065873568,
0.0011542969,
-0.0237799138,
-0.0301632788,
-0.0478477627,
0.06509161,
0.0301798396,
-0.0102066593,
-0.0175340027,
0.0671894252,
0.014804394,
-0.0494267605,
-0.0259092618,
-0.0343546942,
-0.0728778541,
-0.0441566221,
-0.0229113363,
-0.0460577607,
-0.0561101846,
-0.0116605014,
0.0210552551,
-0.0415620729,
0.0295030158,
0.0330151767,
-0.0042091389,
0.0181032065,
-0.0091216955,
-0.033289887,
0.0034571863,
-0.0009710914,
0.056551531,
0.0729628578,
0.0065284418,
0.0021833021,
0.0361604728,
0.0461664237,
0.0195884183,
0.0326887295,
-0.0084872153,
0.0070178034,
-0.0021632058,
0.0003456994,
-0.0095501998,
0.0018624854,
0.0790259987,
-0.0267921295,
-0.0157443602,
0.0007814272,
0.0396646149,
0.0078995246,
-0.0056715412,
-0.0296766702,
0.0267396551,
0.0821729898,
-0.0488498323,
0.0287182573,
-0.030491665,
0.0022193443,
0.0315374173,
-0.0356870554,
-0.038845323,
-0.009313711,
-0.0085608633,
-0.0060085412,
0.0098644812,
-0.0328700915,
-0.0347370543,
-0.0037546824,
0.0599489287,
0.0708055273,
-0.013534491,
0.0793511793,
0.0430389792,
-0.0127898986,
-0.0226335935,
-0.0055053178,
-0.0334909931,
0.003170311,
0.0308832265,
-0.0802723393,
0.0018348584,
-0.0042772316,
-0.0036049983,
0.0509921797,
-0.0230926666,
0.0242151376,
0.0176733565,
-0.0449478216,
-0.0365648791,
-0.04111173,
0.0305618923,
-0.0088078752,
0.005083784,
0.0091579957,
0.0433862433,
-0.0873168409,
-0.0104289036,
0.017883271,
0.0705651268,
-0.0476147309,
0.0351735614,
0.033316087,
0.0293475296,
0.0110043194,
-0.0121806869,
0.005727815,
-0.0219291113,
-0.0446845293,
-0.0355915427,
-0.0135313021,
-0.0911807418,
-0.061985869,
0.0114382599,
-0.0476932526,
-0.0211339388,
0.0484221764,
-0.0596664026,
-0.0135247624,
0.0290980991,
-0.0355344191,
-0.0191940479,
-0.0423680581,
-0.0282742456,
0.0238955989,
0.0544437617,
-0.0344986431,
0.1199470237,
-0.0055405661,
-0.0103155728,
-0.0210132524,
0.0235905759,
0.050144881,
-0.0283320993,
0.0019675344,
-0.0166027602,
-0.0525394678,
-0.0034874026,
0.0105851879,
-0.0032506946,
-0.0399931222,
0.005016753,
-0.0054044211,
0.0143782077,
-0.0227381308,
0.0274197645,
0.0696636811,
0.0188591368,
0.0124507835,
-0.0328154825,
-0.0159686003,
-0.0158789027,
-0.029978903,
-0.0157114007,
0.0402568243,
-0.0088715293,
-0.0129590929,
0.0117174629,
0.037691351,
-0.0266365875,
0.0448189899,
-0.0584685393,
-0.0403489284,
-0.0731689706,
0.0367705263,
0.0152171236,
0.0234117154,
0.0134792533,
-0.0284164008,
-0.0445646048,
0.0437247753,
0.0193592533,
0.0569399856,
-0.0098848762,
0.0311502386,
0.0584022924,
-0.0188762322,
-0.0043334202,
-0.0076627396,
0.0035712218,
0.0113868937,
-0.0082512451,
0.0333889686,
0.0257940851,
0.040206708,
0.0359813981,
0.0060749892,
0.0029532025,
-0.0424473621,
-0.0555826649,
-0.0222537443,
0.0304219872,
0.0035580995,
-0.0292981528,
-0.0019882494,
-0.0327653736,
0.0119077768,
0.0178178307,
-0.0013358832,
0.000722602,
-0.0918458551,
-0.0199069846,
-0.0401386507,
0.0285597891,
0.0013871045,
0.0305243898,
0.0350500979,
-0.0813089162,
-0.0378186516,
-0.0292414706,
0.0190791152,
0.0097340392,
0.0162516423,
-0.0273838937,
-0.0096866321,
-0.0114990473,
-0.0323750563,
-0.0171687901,
-0.1044925377,
-0.0155881327,
-0.0040584039,
-0.0400753655,
-0.0082155932,
-0.0305109303,
-0.0153413918,
-0.0261878446,
0.04608896,
-0.0284453891,
0.0329332612,
-0.0288373306,
0.0928642452,
0.0607055798,
0.0027769096,
-0.0158994701,
0.0188121367,
0.0173355676,
0.0621271916,
-0.0451847911,
-0.0157927815,
-0.0010016612,
0.0022608691,
0.017941881,
-0.0197644439,
-0.0337736048,
0.0200872216,
0.0644871518,
-0.0495623499,
-0.0296243075,
0.0849587917,
0.0341421291,
-0.0512625016,
0.0267344657,
-0.0009263073,
0.014310604,
0.0290552657,
-0.0270983241,
-0.0804899037,
-0.0738889202,
-0.0010784891,
-0.0029316545,
-0.0286447946,
0.0065001077,
-0.0017149383,
-0.1322785467,
0.0559982769,
-0.0091437306,
-0.0454294607,
-0.0292640403,
0.019346619,
0.0284618605,
-0.0046676202,
0.0010616477,
-0.0433171876,
-0.0157162454,
-0.00853795,
0.0091451835,
-0.0466969945,
-0.0433650352,
0.0174062718,
-0.0371296816,
0.0205547474,
0.0821932405,
0.0282164738,
0.0186259747,
0.0155153265,
-0.0009798254,
-0.0596662015,
0.0138921533,
0.0161535088,
0.0935629606,
-0.0254175887,
-0.0376652293,
-0.0077601681,
0.0428239256,
-0.0671231896,
-0.0092998948,
-0.0035914301,
0.0721691549,
-0.0078201788,
0.0064721322,
-0.0027054991,
0.0222945753,
0.0404406451,
0.0453207232,
0.0010810075,
-0.0247129947,
-0.0455561839,
0.0008757084,
0.0161720291,
0.0262996983,
-0.0051204646,
0.0315289907,
0.0237100422,
-0.0534249172,
-0.0621898882,
-0.0321493,
0.0024522811,
0.0117475791,
-0.0042435001,
0.0032868227,
-0.0109445266,
-0.0166252479,
-0.0732467771,
-0.0140433554,
-0.0631124899,
0.0276990011,
0.0067153266,
-0.0030143543,
0.0588163324,
0.0061956928,
-0.0440009683,
0.0298613049,
-0.033012636,
-0.0386172831,
0.0291948654,
-0.00958155,
0.001021229,
0.018522352,
-0.0401617698,
-0.0003594731,
0.0879020616,
0.0746532381,
-0.0419380553,
0.0229766015,
0.0260992218,
-0.0555136241,
0.0134965098,
0.0530160852,
-0.0100040259,
0.0341913402,
0.0217688866,
-0.0035278704,
-0.0111751622,
-0.012909431,
0.0396495163,
-0.0387136638,
0.0814351961,
0.0078000599,
-0.0130271073,
-0.0276497584,
0.0277191214,
-0.0168939866,
-0.0656752586,
-0.0451117456,
0.0258157738,
0.0305989776,
0.0086466437,
0.0049071517,
0.0541475341,
0.0008467623,
0.0067808707,
0.0084500909,
0.0112355342,
0.0612806492,
0.0058918721,
-0.0353485346,
0.046416346,
-0.0164675415,
-0.014009391,
-0.0002450282,
0.0168574974,
0.0093352618,
0.0319795273,
0.0192310028,
-0.0110287825,
-0.0298455562,
0.0121218441,
-0.033895921,
0.0218029879,
-0.0251036379,
-0.0004728906,
0.0636654273,
-0.1066926569,
0.032526575,
0.0006568669,
-0.0003711005,
-0.0063681388,
0.0429005213,
-0.0423951596,
-0.0190929938,
0.0129904402,
0.0092953928,
-0.0320059732,
-0.0111849196,
0.0847203657,
0.0176046304,
0.0307525545,
0.0208751559,
0.0135955904,
-0.0274160411,
0.0170380585,
0.0423718281,
0.0534152724,
-0.0025523456,
0.039456524,
-0.0347744748,
-0.0429035276,
-0.0187761281,
-0.0464072786,
-0.0178410392,
0.0093713291,
0.0532783717,
0.0267752931,
-0.0010222609,
-0.0306650233,
-0.0125352992,
-0.0493503101,
0.0061763553,
-0.0116336253,
-0.0309520382,
-6.361707836e-33,
-0.0126981959,
-0.0440688245,
-0.0308049396,
0.0090520391,
0.0074383388,
0.0469681621,
-0.0007659151,
-0.0206860192,
-0.0010653548,
0.0645142794,
0.0294231568,
0.0299930777,
0.0289352015,
0.048398532,
-0.0175598543,
-0.0138023496,
0.0487069972,
0.0111279394,
0.0003813397,
-0.0086844331,
0.0416410342,
0.0501465946,
0.1181743145,
-0.0892089754,
-0.0258295611,
0.0020112148,
-0.0298080053,
0.0192228258,
0.0347868577,
0.0103303567,
0.0060155452,
0.0652994439,
0.016366357,
-0.0386655852,
-0.0163594689,
0.0199708734,
-0.0598894991,
-0.0309400279,
0.0031369883,
0.0154453991,
0.0039675669,
-0.0206344239,
0.0094409892,
-0.0066583436,
0.0203751847,
-0.0413282663,
0.0738739297,
-0.0255461987,
0.0108565846,
0.0227007028,
-0.0962792933,
0.0415438749,
0.00811336,
-0.0388269126,
-0.0002137918,
-0.0139152044,
0.0112447143,
-0.0104166223,
-0.0098576974,
-0.0240699295,
-0.058356002,
0.0545380265,
0.0058397162,
0.0275906101,
-0.0386918746,
0.0739044473,
-0.0209523551,
-0.0024813428,
0.0017128062,
-0.05100739,
0.0067418283,
0.056027066,
-0.0214518849,
0.0606318973,
0.0713615119,
0.0191362761,
-0.0764096677,
-0.0137637155,
-0.0530592725,
0.0116927447,
0.0278802458,
0.006629549,
-0.0490150675,
-0.0285887048,
0.0181597658,
0.0168716442,
-0.0187608283,
-0.0179371312,
0.0338280573,
-0.0102420514,
-0.0395850576,
0.0378986038,
-0.0053855013,
-0.0672694221,
0.0095032314,
0.0026567089,
-0.0125738913,
0.0050269775,
0.0003560447,
-0.0189858675,
-0.0354862958,
-0.0385221727,
0.0124144033,
-0.0020095007,
0.0003058549,
0.0231594127,
0.075974904,
0.0164149217,
-0.0664464682,
0.0018987854,
-0.0253279265,
-0.010773533,
-0.0482680984,
0.1029585674,
-0.0018524394,
-0.0032081432,
-0.0512754433,
0.0501144752,
0.0353907011,
-0.0012290333,
-0.0219784249,
0.0265010968,
-0.0383454375,
0.0237102639,
-0.0399963371,
0.001763783,
-0.0066565634,
-0.0104500577,
0.0183060784,
-0.0479977317,
0.0102028679,
-0.034013629,
2.827e-7,
0.0542244874,
0.0221183095,
0.0185955372,
-0.0153337969,
-0.0056007234,
0.0561228506,
0.0034683226,
0.0594661534,
-0.0221994072,
-0.0315752178,
0.0370790213,
0.0187811498,
-0.0062760036,
-0.0042169667,
-0.1193697229,
0.1035731882,
-0.0217878241,
-0.0164704286,
-0.0130204717,
-0.0196780525,
0.0304953381,
0.1005710587,
0.0269500688,
-0.0293871779,
0.0001793342,
-0.0655712932,
0.0378527269,
0.0177006721,
0.022969624,
-0.0265860986,
-0.0346545875,
0.0183787439,
0.0221968889,
0.0242036786,
-0.0050629922,
0.0304695517,
0.0184803549,
0.0260335505,
-0.026893273,
-0.0131040495,
-0.0345880277,
0.0431540608,
0.0027759722,
-0.0168162305,
0.0497847497,
-0.0708148032,
-0.0681509227,
-0.0478387251,
-0.0365900807,
0.0120883211,
0.001162252,
0.0279024411,
-0.0061218305,
0.0091309445,
0.0341628827,
-0.0025736934,
-0.055450581,
-0.0767408535,
-0.0288104825,
0.0128714442,
-0.0048521156,
0.0035591298,
-0.0027200333,
0.0097428532,
0.0344423726,
-0.0354253426,
0.0119671449,
2.706181539e-34,
0.0106854783,
0.0171744246,
-0.0197853539,
0.0194464754,
0.0101584475,
0.0082412949,
-0.0212649908,
-0.015244103,
0.0006207189,
0.0157356113,
0.0288375039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18023v1 | Abstractive Summarization as Augmentation for Document-Level Event Detection | 2023-05-29T11:28:26 | 2023-05-29T11:28:26 | Janko Vidaković, Filip Karlo Došilović, Domagoj Pluščec | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based models have consistently produced substantial performance
gains across a variety of NLP tasks, compared to shallow models. However, deep
models are orders of magnitude more computationally expensive than shallow
models, especially on tasks with large sequence lengths, such as document-level
event detection. In this work, we attempt to bridge the performance gap between
shallow and deep models on document-level event detection by using abstractive
text summarization as an augmentation method. We augment the DocEE dataset by
generating abstractive summaries of examples from low-resource classes. For
classification, we use linear SVM with TF-IDF representations and RoBERTa-base.
We use BART for zero-shot abstractive summarization, making our augmentation
setup less resource-intensive compared to supervised fine-tuning. We experiment
with four decoding methods for text generation, namely beam search, top-k
sampling, top-p sampling, and contrastive search. Furthermore, we investigate
the impact of using document titles as additional input for classification. Our
results show that using the document title offers 2.04% and 3.19% absolute
improvement in macro F1-score for linear SVM and RoBERTa, respectively.
Augmentation via summarization further improves the performance of linear SVM
by about 0.5%, varying slightly across decoding methods. Overall, our
augmentation setup yields insufficient improvements for linear SVM compared to
RoBERTa. | [
0.028277589,
0.0703340843,
0.0252912845,
0.0265351366,
0.0019480149,
0.0313168317,
-0.0202100445,
-0.0088544115,
-0.0334807746,
-0.0616647042,
0.0204938464,
-0.0124144051,
-0.0245967023,
0.0557553917,
-0.0022023963,
-0.0773189962,
0.0220533814,
0.0256817751,
-0.0171368066,
0.0395547561,
0.0407761633,
0.015720658,
0.0117272409,
0.0342232175,
-0.0007227064,
0.0327450447,
-0.0357372873,
-0.0122473594,
0.0347488895,
-0.022101678,
0.0061495099,
0.0249637645,
0.0572955981,
0.0395396836,
0.0000018692,
-0.0314328298,
-0.0421203673,
-0.0119524086,
-0.0135284737,
0.0113823479,
0.024993673,
-0.0898261443,
0.0278878845,
0.0096635353,
0.0047750017,
-0.0648729801,
-0.0093778884,
0.1127190143,
0.0064048036,
0.0839456916,
-0.0274225678,
-0.030592382,
0.1094003394,
-0.0192044787,
0.0031848308,
-0.0423420034,
-0.0185366198,
-0.0217719562,
-0.01174636,
0.0348540582,
-0.0031579731,
0.011562014,
0.0209093187,
-0.0189675596,
0.0131295063,
0.0365294218,
-0.0824062601,
0.0198881347,
0.0211773869,
0.0374791846,
-0.0224806592,
-0.0376285985,
0.0327175967,
0.0025766296,
-0.0016018644,
-0.0197222773,
-0.0659236908,
0.0473140329,
-0.0145735098,
0.0319147632,
0.0488884635,
0.0397508778,
-0.0111658359,
0.0488734059,
-0.0057967803,
-0.016874928,
0.0164717119,
-0.0016989822,
-0.0421311632,
0.0432892144,
-0.0455661714,
-0.0463520028,
0.0418638997,
0.0490268916,
-0.0308352467,
-0.0070044557,
-0.082063362,
-0.0633206293,
0.0190330278,
-0.0600468516,
0.0009141314,
0.041549664,
0.0213137846,
0.0395116247,
-0.0504132994,
0.0249084271,
-0.0164807048,
0.0079531483,
-0.0523771495,
-0.0228607506,
-0.0277947411,
0.0225543082,
-0.0444507077,
0.0441649072,
-0.0507044084,
-0.0338602066,
-0.0265413672,
0.0328385904,
0.0570892617,
-0.0263686068,
-0.0455000065,
0.0242314469,
-0.054137487,
0.0178425852,
0.0421715491,
0.0202467814,
-0.0361903459,
0.0101738544,
0.0141776251,
-0.0436296724,
-0.0037990983,
0.0139154913,
0.0495128259,
0.0151231829,
0.0070695621,
0.0022505929,
-0.0455427989,
-0.087675713,
-0.0290032625,
-0.0246743765,
0.0070405053,
-0.0110790478,
-0.0156501718,
-0.0604071394,
0.0262096375,
-0.0087320292,
-0.0118405977,
0.041833926,
0.0125832222,
0.0151494276,
-0.0071590841,
0.0250607356,
-0.0004824162,
-0.0128208557,
0.0553296655,
0.0095253056,
0.0066360063,
0.0484816208,
0.040795289,
0.0417215601,
0.0508972183,
0.0074181599,
0.0179149043,
0.0193523411,
0.017922949,
0.0117340228,
0.0446371399,
-0.0253994856,
-0.064598985,
-0.0166589189,
0.066065155,
0.0078128986,
-0.0314415656,
-0.0032768622,
0.0468891934,
0.0464148074,
-0.0083998572,
0.0139450105,
0.0168413166,
0.01801317,
-0.0109315431,
0.0318833664,
-0.0033095335,
0.0150565486,
-0.024571009,
0.0271882266,
0.022103643,
-0.0012549434,
-0.0575375855,
-0.0186820924,
0.0272504576,
-0.0064240852,
0.0062996564,
0.0166106876,
0.0427944772,
0.0320529155,
-0.0232829694,
0.0585483573,
0.0012136092,
-0.0700791255,
0.0414098576,
-0.0220584888,
-0.0019610287,
0.0289371125,
0.0419965237,
-0.0308190137,
-0.0245540906,
-0.0053786151,
0.013670722,
0.0468657166,
0.0788221583,
-0.0056455424,
0.0074575422,
-0.0399927162,
-0.0310730021,
-0.0259435084,
0.0107854344,
-0.0048168902,
0.0094429608,
-0.0257747993,
0.0322487839,
-0.0029980093,
-0.0898759812,
0.0520970598,
-0.0233171061,
-0.0595220402,
0.0014700153,
-0.0269509554,
-0.0091193477,
0.0102299899,
0.0182915069,
0.0043191016,
0.0236630067,
-0.0654899552,
-0.037630152,
0.0040484527,
0.0104350382,
-0.0589197017,
-0.0004578721,
-0.040145494,
-0.0058697048,
0.0722338185,
-0.054220099,
-0.0570540465,
0.0143759968,
-0.048344288,
0.001962401,
-0.0453316495,
0.0345921963,
0.030754365,
0.0028466936,
-0.0234109275,
0.0590624027,
-0.0142461555,
0.0236140471,
-0.000502528,
0.025612032,
0.018480733,
-0.0401974432,
-0.0416448154,
-0.005495586,
-0.0202700701,
-0.0050822911,
0.0582832471,
-0.0085645616,
-0.0389258824,
0.0093905944,
-0.1039264649,
0.0235229004,
-0.0229078047,
0.0169107858,
0.026875142,
0.0461271554,
0.0146329058,
-0.0067459815,
-0.0440459885,
-0.0443261117,
0.0260662567,
0.0105294334,
0.02558388,
0.0165938064,
0.0241569523,
-0.0445440002,
-0.0243753958,
-0.0120897526,
0.0580691025,
0.0145225935,
-0.0225042477,
-0.015238137,
0.0234581288,
0.029026743,
0.0198169481,
-0.0096450308,
-0.0083893295,
-0.0127219707,
-0.023404194,
0.0192674119,
0.0418208241,
0.0477767363,
0.0371700153,
-0.0064812242,
0.0369025879,
-0.0537977219,
0.0015138931,
-0.0503465012,
0.0206394773,
0.0096097812,
-0.0266405921,
0.0518228263,
0.0619073808,
-0.0202587731,
0.0152346576,
-0.0118994294,
-0.0350829661,
-0.0125962077,
-0.0067910268,
-0.0157250259,
-0.0499039143,
-0.0115654105,
0.0224173684,
-0.0427132696,
-0.0174503233,
0.054698579,
-0.021865923,
-0.0105445748,
-0.08038982,
-0.0139169134,
-0.0693836734,
0.0357734971,
-0.0027239579,
0.0080300067,
-0.0612499416,
-0.0586485602,
0.0081778243,
-0.0024878737,
-0.0021175861,
-0.0179720577,
0.0740238279,
-0.0083483774,
0.016345568,
-0.04675873,
-0.0163895264,
-0.0421026349,
-0.0609334074,
0.0116162132,
0.0295311343,
0.0283467304,
0.0019938974,
-0.0778350681,
0.0290330872,
0.0027075142,
0.0870224312,
-0.0397158675,
-0.0349298418,
-0.0276229903,
0.0858245343,
0.0628479794,
-0.0112485979,
0.0049813539,
-0.0340316035,
0.0029156709,
0.0636843368,
0.0253800787,
0.0029566593,
-0.0292336214,
0.0035728507,
0.0097228484,
-0.0548397638,
0.0021958873,
-0.0393505245,
0.023228541,
-0.0728066936,
-0.0324688703,
0.103005521,
0.028524885,
-0.050691653,
-0.014744645,
0.0133507811,
0.0203095302,
0.0059223687,
0.009149462,
-0.0334566794,
-0.0149770305,
0.0061560855,
-0.0010898138,
0.0095270751,
-0.0044663646,
0.0317315795,
-0.0837275013,
-0.0028883284,
-0.0139088957,
-0.0548636131,
-0.0124214273,
-0.0125633013,
0.0046934499,
0.0105347587,
0.0043653022,
0.0067703393,
-0.0169413313,
-0.014352357,
0.0344805196,
-0.0466676988,
-0.0143309906,
-0.0366670042,
-0.0553310886,
-0.0446496867,
0.0367799699,
0.0328751095,
-0.0180885177,
0.0239705592,
0.03006199,
-0.0538941212,
-0.0060076579,
0.0003817112,
0.0842495114,
-0.0307839476,
0.0033983721,
-0.0158295371,
0.0545073152,
0.0007928992,
-0.0280607622,
-0.0341320187,
0.0165945273,
-0.0357517153,
-0.0056039067,
-0.0589824952,
0.0045308722,
-0.0246049892,
0.0721965134,
0.0172154307,
0.0016948781,
-0.0222955532,
0.0055167186,
0.01493032,
-0.0865347236,
-0.0001891383,
-0.0218533445,
-0.010978085,
-0.059497539,
-0.0720196813,
-0.0567506999,
0.0322506987,
-0.006696688,
-0.0441452153,
-0.0267274659,
-0.0260268245,
-0.0065896576,
-0.0688817576,
0.0485117622,
-0.0042416332,
0.0074083041,
0.0218869019,
-0.0080360258,
0.0458212607,
-0.0092778271,
-0.0194570255,
0.0338619873,
-0.01762655,
-0.0337817483,
-0.0044869813,
-0.004526482,
0.0162325893,
0.0507782958,
0.0092017902,
-0.0352256112,
0.0329844803,
0.0120166056,
-0.0190349743,
0.0072219055,
0.0091620749,
-0.0073767598,
-0.0206446033,
0.0168793425,
-0.0591666698,
0.0272899922,
-0.0234495141,
0.0464097597,
-0.0435525887,
-0.0067095007,
0.0067716204,
-0.0295972452,
0.0316786282,
-0.0222128555,
-0.0087374728,
-0.0205224808,
-0.0174844805,
0.0000261081,
0.0010431194,
-0.0257768799,
0.0218444318,
0.014642355,
0.0321696363,
-0.0099752657,
0.102068685,
-0.0186817944,
0.0208496731,
-0.0374664553,
0.0062171612,
-0.0045698388,
-0.0084349206,
-0.0460767709,
0.0285456348,
-0.0633448139,
-0.0311461687,
-0.0080174934,
0.0012457641,
-0.0111960545,
-0.0108963652,
0.0556137078,
0.0412213095,
-0.0257304441,
0.0040274356,
-0.1103921682,
0.0404738188,
-0.0551696569,
-0.0031317279,
0.0473510437,
-0.0921349302,
0.0371749327,
-0.0271087345,
-0.0168243311,
-0.0165094975,
0.0004924547,
0.0090378262,
-0.0063615227,
-0.0042427066,
0.0376655124,
0.0087760128,
-0.0114639699,
0.0635459945,
-0.022535149,
0.0353636816,
0.0180020873,
-0.0236802418,
-0.0217322297,
-0.004636806,
0.0564288311,
0.0588884465,
-0.0297236834,
-0.0167675726,
-0.0196644533,
0.0052890624,
0.0248373933,
-0.0234834962,
0.0025680347,
-0.0241248235,
0.0449906886,
0.0345882103,
0.0377137512,
0.0027787078,
-0.0387741104,
0.017859932,
-0.0098248459,
-0.0096996613,
-0.04944003,
-6.048648344e-33,
-0.0163682979,
-0.011818504,
-0.0227923896,
0.0827164948,
-0.0337699316,
0.0600924194,
-0.0538522564,
-0.0012911244,
0.008775779,
0.012821679,
-0.0167725887,
0.0340284668,
0.0071116895,
0.03773956,
-0.0004189137,
-0.0047116857,
0.060474772,
0.0195824429,
-0.0280148536,
0.0458190218,
0.0365586169,
0.0408289656,
0.0486875065,
-0.0541701838,
0.002756821,
-0.0289244279,
0.0105975885,
-0.0177591238,
0.0584104359,
0.0572417639,
-0.0215875451,
0.0060585975,
0.0417386107,
-0.0337078199,
-0.0245705359,
0.0418145657,
-0.095821254,
0.0033982468,
-0.0003419777,
0.0241742451,
-0.0333942957,
-0.0367284566,
0.0487715118,
-0.0125700617,
0.0131327976,
-0.0360451229,
0.0424988009,
-0.0496036597,
-0.0301833618,
-0.1171604246,
-0.0542396158,
0.0291580446,
-0.0069916877,
-0.028478764,
0.0299770702,
0.0004869954,
0.0132237831,
0.0485939272,
-0.02145507,
0.0076589035,
0.0109300241,
0.0513446443,
0.003109263,
-0.0079170661,
-0.0389164649,
0.0571556203,
0.0073397565,
-0.0062039429,
-0.0075614047,
0.0163218137,
0.0287892465,
0.0349404365,
0.0610906668,
0.0207804162,
0.0861809701,
0.0523785353,
-0.0429401211,
0.0988790244,
0.0162160676,
0.0241858009,
0.0186925083,
0.0114769991,
-0.0369551368,
-0.000901787,
-0.0125090294,
0.0320132487,
-0.0381794795,
0.019586347,
-0.00010075,
0.0658819005,
-0.0107295597,
0.0143108936,
0.0360187851,
-0.0431993417,
0.0081203589,
0.028323276,
-0.0038870005,
0.0186965764,
-0.0113191847,
-0.0408365726,
0.0083204443,
-0.0252316166,
0.0428432897,
-0.0260743853,
-0.0244754329,
0.0047611683,
0.0725035593,
0.0053679585,
-0.0338506512,
0.0118344137,
0.0084437393,
-0.0035418693,
-0.0330471247,
0.0769506767,
0.0004007549,
-0.0218031835,
-0.0053244517,
0.0658248514,
-0.0169461891,
0.0568283349,
-0.0227238573,
-0.0245260522,
0.0174260866,
0.0455345549,
-0.0099258116,
0.0096277352,
-0.0361379758,
0.0408301763,
0.0378966555,
-0.0611653365,
-0.0208194181,
0.0017712608,
2.494e-7,
0.0575595796,
0.0237431172,
0.0687564835,
0.0262928903,
-0.0101266811,
0.0251001623,
0.0231959969,
0.0665915832,
0.0187040102,
0.0330303162,
0.0031869211,
0.0164900944,
0.0585019365,
0.0158185121,
-0.0719287395,
-0.0547372699,
-0.0712398738,
-0.0066427574,
-0.0428054556,
-0.0206761025,
0.0565397516,
0.0929830149,
-0.0048078438,
-0.0331437774,
0.0329401121,
-0.0275389813,
0.0502434261,
0.0116805509,
-0.0356919654,
0.0312691368,
0.0444501527,
0.0312028416,
-0.0218894724,
-0.0084022004,
-0.0356148705,
0.0070169433,
0.0366916806,
0.0357756689,
-0.001130527,
-0.0288422368,
0.0149610424,
-0.0167230479,
0.0133606717,
-0.014695989,
0.0548908412,
-0.0658538342,
0.0024127772,
0.0174605902,
-0.0672865734,
0.0154279321,
-0.0477881022,
-0.0076520978,
-0.0370598659,
0.0468785055,
0.0207266491,
-0.0052330331,
-0.0268393084,
-0.1012658328,
-0.0137535483,
0.0205128528,
-0.0110264095,
-0.0149440542,
-0.0348576233,
-0.0206405502,
0.0099028572,
-0.049651809,
-0.0223830082,
2.666091442e-34,
0.0594879538,
0.0446560308,
-0.0368450098,
0.0050166892,
-0.0009845495,
-0.0155047635,
-0.0056011328,
0.0009416136,
0.0145640001,
-0.085436359,
0.0008583372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18011v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18011v1 | Can We Trust Explainable AI Methods on ASR? An Evaluation on Phoneme Recognition | 2023-05-29T11:04:13 | 2023-05-29T11:04:13 | Xiaoliang Wu, Peter Bell, Ajitha Rajan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Explainable AI (XAI) techniques have been widely used to help explain and
understand the output of deep learning models in fields such as image
classification and Natural Language Processing. Interest in using XAI
techniques to explain deep learning-based automatic speech recognition (ASR) is
emerging. but there is not enough evidence on whether these explanations can be
trusted. To address this, we adapt a state-of-the-art XAI technique from the
image classification domain, Local Interpretable Model-Agnostic Explanations
(LIME), to a model trained for a TIMIT-based phoneme recognition task. This
simple task provides a controlled setting for evaluation while also providing
expert annotated ground truth to assess the quality of explanations. We find a
variant of LIME based on time partitioned audio segments, that we propose in
this paper, produces the most reliable explanations, containing the ground
truth 96% of the time in its top three audio segments. | [
-0.027799597,
0.0654372275,
-0.0234685037,
0.0243035685,
0.0241822638,
-0.0031220319,
0.0967149138,
-0.0322727971,
-0.0554048531,
0.0514683165,
-0.023742212,
-0.0079208724,
0.0429878235,
0.0548599474,
0.0151656801,
-0.0394322872,
0.0079132784,
-0.0477680266,
0.01671285,
-0.0096982196,
0.0074904528,
0.0109019326,
-0.0392819941,
0.0841538012,
-0.008145866,
0.006563195,
-0.0317155086,
-0.0012966752,
0.0044708126,
0.0371953733,
-0.0551923774,
-0.0562689826,
0.0332236141,
0.0316732414,
0.0000017443,
0.0041977065,
-0.0323565714,
0.0199379101,
-0.1240460873,
0.0271715298,
-0.0513320379,
0.0017922851,
-0.0060903118,
0.0248181298,
0.0064690937,
0.0389956199,
0.0929783732,
0.0494690984,
0.0287037734,
0.020671254,
0.0086295092,
-0.0371620804,
0.0042567295,
-0.0112222154,
0.01945276,
-0.0152702825,
-0.0440867022,
-0.0209893733,
-0.003256558,
-0.0250576083,
-0.0010540737,
0.0033462297,
0.0533808209,
-0.0397575758,
0.0483891703,
0.0159846172,
0.0014673955,
-0.0639578849,
-0.0302883871,
0.0325035006,
0.0095568961,
-0.0199792795,
-0.0160296112,
-0.0125323161,
-0.0341378413,
-0.002544929,
-0.0300068446,
0.0141414292,
0.0128537314,
0.0215185937,
-0.0181967225,
0.019009918,
0.07324671,
0.0254404806,
-0.0269081872,
0.0587998554,
-0.0314330049,
0.0185531434,
-0.0278638266,
-0.0204120018,
-0.0006919293,
-0.0154056204,
0.045470275,
0.0554130413,
-0.0068334197,
-0.0063305488,
0.0333278663,
0.0205578003,
-0.0213967469,
0.0082079852,
0.0292015225,
0.0372345559,
-0.0798083618,
0.0140090808,
0.0077257962,
0.0784158856,
-0.0092330612,
-0.0195342638,
0.0228582174,
-0.0209893286,
-0.055584237,
-0.0287713893,
0.0058164825,
-0.0098058423,
-0.0498373881,
-0.0182263106,
-0.0190214254,
0.0006691952,
-0.0390231535,
-0.0006380619,
0.0464974605,
0.0365554467,
-0.0519254617,
-0.0032610551,
-0.0078673912,
0.0290641412,
-0.0387970917,
0.0313897207,
0.0158558059,
-0.0783560425,
-0.0208273567,
0.0328681357,
0.0169144459,
-0.0063998462,
0.0218383223,
0.0185653064,
-0.0093188817,
-0.0213652495,
-0.0093089715,
-0.0050489712,
-0.0572228692,
-0.0575338528,
-0.012115567,
-0.0081305755,
0.0085801026,
-0.0168604609,
0.0079656895,
-0.0311090443,
-0.0144193172,
-0.0488748848,
-0.0050134682,
0.1076868996,
-0.0245143697,
0.0203843452,
0.0233023055,
0.0269205868,
-0.0068428484,
-0.0037606345,
0.0435802042,
0.0035365717,
0.0096713211,
-0.0698228553,
0.0329364687,
-0.0167469867,
0.0202240925,
-0.0229543857,
-0.0226603802,
-0.0317824483,
-0.0832166001,
0.0425516404,
0.0452415571,
0.0024924935,
-0.0042092064,
-0.0001583487,
0.0361885913,
0.0311997794,
0.0178616047,
0.0367687792,
0.0585401021,
-0.018177649,
-0.0099705867,
0.0416452736,
-0.0447743684,
0.0314812735,
0.0358963199,
0.0183123089,
0.0215957351,
0.0092124613,
-0.0250261538,
-0.0501393452,
-0.0070984862,
-0.025620684,
-0.0185660329,
0.050733678,
0.047678683,
-0.0164823588,
-0.0150185656,
0.0462904051,
-0.005487626,
-0.0143760638,
-0.0207814313,
-0.0935645327,
0.0646400452,
0.0794008821,
-0.0027325449,
-0.0423174277,
-0.006680768,
-0.0095052524,
-0.0028078328,
0.0481004342,
-0.0131302029,
0.0381297991,
0.0722687542,
-0.0505699404,
-0.0127187856,
-0.0307405666,
0.0174705721,
0.0548973642,
-0.0179267619,
-0.0108922143,
0.0148111507,
-0.0732456818,
-0.0186410714,
-0.0099287909,
0.005989043,
-0.0432810448,
0.0284722317,
0.0172170512,
0.05236331,
0.0596057922,
-0.0275039095,
-0.0018581706,
0.0272198487,
-0.0053112051,
0.018227933,
0.0476386622,
-0.0625179708,
0.0005328818,
0.0158724226,
-0.0467463918,
0.013034842,
0.05252783,
-0.0091678677,
-0.0786229149,
0.0429596342,
-0.0304367766,
0.0336568244,
-0.0400656871,
0.0199422687,
0.0325806253,
0.0426782854,
0.0388649926,
0.0050206198,
0.0276794787,
-0.0389141217,
0.0028213507,
0.0098927226,
0.0030917306,
-0.030518841,
0.0184061211,
0.0562554076,
-0.0204281434,
-0.0204365216,
-0.0208562538,
-0.0139611065,
0.0150580034,
0.0332704335,
-0.0628057942,
-0.0302457996,
-0.029165918,
-0.0096432883,
-0.0372151099,
-0.011697894,
0.0328423679,
-0.0292122345,
-0.0195634961,
-0.0017205162,
0.0085167028,
-0.0078726299,
-0.0254515447,
0.0081905136,
-0.0690161884,
-0.0450159125,
-0.0094639976,
0.0037952084,
0.0493859202,
0.0043299412,
-0.0196084231,
-0.045273751,
-0.0203679502,
0.0004162709,
-0.007026975,
-0.0105391312,
-0.0408706963,
0.0415556505,
0.0182450414,
-0.0483273678,
0.0321300402,
-0.0318916254,
0.0647563934,
0.0023138889,
0.0434390754,
-0.0339985043,
-0.0143955229,
0.0038426251,
-0.0016970941,
0.0019091559,
-0.0376542024,
-0.0507531948,
0.0591968596,
0.0255181715,
0.030257266,
-0.0569764003,
-0.0183939654,
0.0175648164,
-0.0355677642,
-0.0201312378,
-0.0810019374,
0.006195101,
0.0551716313,
-0.0341824368,
-0.0562248863,
0.0464027151,
-0.0722048879,
-0.0386754908,
0.0068058115,
-0.0771900639,
-0.0209957454,
0.0412055738,
-0.0246517695,
0.0022437938,
0.0296270102,
-0.0308737382,
0.0128436936,
-0.0432387739,
-0.0019235661,
0.0007968984,
0.0262228847,
-0.0389300846,
-0.0227551777,
0.0267644059,
-0.0023296294,
-0.0238566026,
-0.0191807598,
-0.0281263366,
0.0499180108,
0.0213158317,
-0.0452829339,
0.0085120751,
0.025950741,
0.040863283,
0.0038268033,
0.0038125385,
0.0195208024,
0.0008814957,
0.0416037291,
0.0159507766,
0.047137823,
0.0476371571,
-0.0066357348,
0.0339452848,
-0.0213302355,
0.0650101155,
0.0135140745,
-0.0953850374,
0.0359842889,
-0.0208712462,
0.008423985,
-0.0121117719,
0.0111865876,
0.0337897874,
-0.0510081202,
-0.0157058649,
0.0776423812,
0.02338209,
-0.0119338743,
0.0208488274,
0.0320884585,
-0.0085302349,
-0.0221471284,
-0.0325399227,
-0.020140063,
-0.0241218768,
0.0314310938,
0.0312333126,
0.0104533266,
0.0484090187,
0.0144458516,
-0.0219264813,
0.0506255142,
0.0140063995,
-0.0571109131,
-0.0175452773,
-0.0530217998,
-0.0484938696,
-0.0151206087,
0.0428703204,
-0.0073925327,
0.0423023254,
-0.0011393834,
0.0544467866,
-0.0495017357,
-0.0670722723,
0.0435867161,
-0.0262605008,
0.0651925504,
0.0720377713,
0.0259753875,
-0.0370659232,
-0.0622752123,
0.0014364324,
0.0226687696,
0.0761708692,
-0.0065747742,
0.0447738618,
0.0332840569,
-0.0384634323,
0.0094058253,
0.0512989387,
-0.040894974,
-0.0104900133,
-0.0479562581,
0.0674545318,
-0.0571928471,
0.0184250176,
0.0062279273,
-0.0078319777,
0.0177586619,
0.065961808,
0.055884093,
0.0230555627,
-0.0520050824,
0.011283231,
0.010813226,
-0.0420327,
-0.0075386786,
0.029304821,
0.0309475642,
-0.0731743872,
-0.0028379664,
-0.0221902765,
-0.0080370763,
0.0563409738,
0.000535915,
-0.0283720903,
-0.0734934956,
0.0413576551,
-0.0248381384,
0.0704333037,
0.025551362,
0.0324046612,
-0.0131301451,
-0.0232435204,
0.0108548859,
-0.0787190199,
0.0049849087,
0.0138291195,
0.0186731461,
-0.0146698384,
0.0053733555,
-0.0077492357,
0.0386607796,
0.0627915636,
-0.0213955157,
-0.055584684,
0.023675207,
-0.0101570571,
-0.025492752,
-0.0223344862,
0.0806113333,
-0.0299310461,
0.0107281646,
0.0262723062,
-0.0402379669,
0.0364942327,
-0.0230371896,
-0.0094362311,
-0.0280051194,
-0.0008105191,
0.0036053213,
0.0025587822,
0.05556795,
-0.0396230631,
-0.0240721256,
-0.0103091216,
0.0348052867,
0.0234697033,
0.0503384992,
-0.0284054149,
0.0049289484,
0.0348076783,
0.0137244938,
0.0035107518,
-0.015751591,
-0.0185351633,
-0.0400922522,
-0.0155476034,
0.0581668168,
0.0183338542,
0.0078976946,
-0.06045679,
0.0319183655,
-0.0107173119,
0.0052965097,
-0.0075318115,
0.0102743227,
0.0573189147,
0.0458941683,
-0.0022906859,
0.0318922997,
-0.0026422522,
0.0116840899,
-0.0691060424,
-0.0460413955,
-0.0021801575,
-0.0018826628,
0.026035212,
-0.0257514007,
0.0189121608,
0.0232777353,
0.0261842646,
0.0006202712,
0.0577916279,
0.0349349193,
0.0054014781,
0.0075945836,
0.0007841474,
-0.0306086037,
-0.0024578797,
0.0427376851,
0.0248869676,
-0.0007352821,
-0.0319258906,
-0.0028650197,
-0.0071828873,
-0.0250174757,
-0.025381526,
0.0323183797,
-0.0141030233,
-0.0271395873,
0.0077686021,
-0.0666692629,
-0.0186526608,
0.0013585923,
0.0286021344,
-0.013966904,
-0.0107766623,
0.0701111481,
-0.0152133219,
0.0040521286,
0.0192517918,
-0.0472516119,
0.0070366045,
0.034206707,
-0.0038322257,
-5.999479252e-33,
0.016927164,
-0.0293613002,
0.0032777342,
-0.025538478,
0.0198852178,
0.0549001619,
-0.0595015921,
-0.026218731,
-0.021650143,
0.0168180112,
-0.003515804,
0.0407575294,
0.0405868217,
0.0300723482,
-0.0092060305,
-0.0372102335,
0.0602237359,
0.0245004185,
0.0039532986,
0.0058571445,
0.0366283357,
0.0100956708,
0.0353340432,
-0.0760552511,
0.0313947909,
0.0529416911,
-0.0430905595,
-0.0244224593,
-0.0265185852,
0.0854308009,
-0.026553113,
0.0229136255,
0.007693192,
-0.066126436,
0.0019140699,
0.0075481632,
-0.0765719414,
-0.0095088771,
0.0246199649,
0.0619121715,
-0.0428438708,
-0.0303325783,
0.047708828,
-0.0098329103,
-0.008193248,
-0.0111468788,
0.0257438514,
-0.0247954279,
-0.0053179078,
-0.0213523507,
0.0219986942,
0.0181682911,
-0.0460726134,
-0.0566814654,
0.059534125,
0.0286217816,
-0.0428796597,
-0.0020830308,
-0.0298943482,
-0.004000653,
0.0561729521,
-0.0302118398,
0.0737226978,
-0.0086242091,
-0.0249952395,
0.03617616,
0.0930851847,
-0.0665194839,
-0.0525098071,
-0.0820614323,
0.0039259861,
0.0778699815,
0.0877015144,
-0.0061953911,
0.0284491125,
-0.0026179999,
-0.0504448563,
-0.0000903101,
0.0121457623,
0.0043158992,
0.0327573083,
0.0399854109,
-0.0942023844,
-0.0041443757,
-0.0140989032,
-0.0565239824,
-0.0552495867,
-0.0095252059,
0.043451108,
-0.0154974954,
-0.0420218706,
0.0329140164,
0.0379201435,
-0.0340880267,
0.0561192855,
-0.0053961431,
0.0122189466,
-0.0138329472,
0.0252615735,
-0.0222147815,
-0.0051822527,
-0.00944738,
0.0063939895,
0.0322881825,
0.0460087098,
-0.0119216386,
0.0185771938,
0.0709621385,
-0.0117093837,
-0.0046622534,
-0.0679233819,
-0.0290390663,
-0.0171504412,
-0.0113327941,
0.0433103777,
0.0042168065,
-0.0424300432,
0.0266911741,
-0.0223204903,
0.0413715988,
0.001962597,
-0.017295206,
-0.0500219837,
0.0116507225,
-0.0430197082,
-0.0325255208,
0.0357359089,
-0.0673836172,
0.023523435,
-0.0310784392,
-0.0102072107,
0.0228975993,
2.454e-7,
-0.048594512,
-0.0289339833,
0.0380594619,
-0.015827626,
0.0356080234,
0.0153141292,
-0.0210806467,
-0.0564943701,
-0.0412151925,
-0.0366851799,
0.0401182957,
0.0374683514,
0.090057753,
0.0050431355,
0.0097164074,
-0.0140007474,
-0.0567067675,
0.007405085,
-0.0426369645,
-0.0134198936,
0.0242929626,
0.0834822282,
0.0074021332,
-0.040090438,
0.0316997021,
-0.0343833975,
0.0045362143,
-0.0097710276,
0.047210481,
-0.0461872071,
0.0473189764,
-0.0233181026,
0.0099769672,
-0.0069173397,
-0.0110121518,
-0.0321367867,
-0.0160996933,
0.0163359065,
-0.0517665073,
-0.0797688663,
-0.0491753332,
0.0030835618,
0.0188988354,
-0.0594876483,
0.0441156216,
0.0642116144,
-0.0332398191,
-0.0052186009,
-0.0429055803,
-0.0406930596,
0.0146180149,
0.0028605512,
0.0441874005,
0.0118773859,
-0.0465137325,
-0.0441295616,
-0.0249038469,
-0.0716860071,
-0.006890309,
0.0120937759,
-0.0598375387,
0.0489695482,
-0.0347305797,
-0.0455628969,
0.0594332851,
-0.0109731089,
-0.0400939025,
1.684186661e-34,
0.0021774443,
0.0017286972,
0.028114425,
0.0384383872,
0.0334107094,
0.0075426032,
0.0053445599,
-0.0193790402,
0.0537447184,
0.0121831167,
-0.0279960912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18004v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18004v2 | The Effects of Political Martyrdom on Election Results: The Assassination of Abe | 2023-05-29T10:33:08 | 2023-08-28T09:34:39 | Miu Nicole Takagi | cs.CL | cs.CL | In developed nations assassinations are rare and thus the impact of such acts
on the electoral and political landscape is understudied. In this paper, we
focus on Twitter data to examine the effects of Japan's former Primer Minister
Abe's assassination on the Japanese House of Councillors elections in 2022. We
utilize sentiment analysis and emotion detection together with topic modeling
on over 2 million tweets and compare them against tweets during previous
election cycles. Our findings indicate that Twitter sentiments were negatively
impacted by the event in the short term and that social media attention span
has shortened. We also discuss how "necropolitics" affected the outcome of the
elections in favor of the deceased's party meaning that there seems to have
been an effect of Abe's death on the election outcome though the findings
warrant further investigation for conclusive results. | [
0.043273773,
0.0863682926,
-0.0117621403,
0.0035418812,
0.016076671,
0.0148733119,
-0.0128568029,
0.0186941307,
-0.0054525887,
0.0366025642,
0.0454518981,
0.0220604222,
-0.0030611306,
-0.0185167044,
-0.0162587706,
-0.0870917365,
0.0256939549,
0.0513123758,
0.0822198018,
-0.0040994473,
0.0061056372,
0.0129384054,
0.0256869569,
0.0197535064,
0.0067577208,
0.0435952954,
-0.0155641986,
0.0179491322,
0.0325067788,
-0.0219915826,
-0.0252341833,
-0.0134283714,
-0.0086773345,
-0.0133015988,
0.0000016295,
0.0115589136,
-0.037867859,
-0.0459308811,
0.0400486924,
-0.0048704543,
0.0709512532,
0.0341613144,
0.0012712508,
0.0099959169,
-0.0464711264,
-0.0251873862,
0.0072676456,
0.005309707,
0.0653653517,
0.0652209669,
-0.015559027,
0.0144659961,
-0.0011986325,
-0.0202382188,
-0.0097105866,
0.0220250841,
0.0288817175,
-0.1014667302,
-0.0499221012,
0.0189484283,
0.0102352975,
-0.0048763347,
-0.0210423432,
0.0503931567,
-0.0526725538,
-0.00952149,
0.0303843226,
0.0291693304,
0.0385751985,
0.0071911276,
0.0346060134,
-0.0240648631,
0.0518497713,
0.0240052585,
0.0418175608,
0.0309279729,
-0.0292073227,
0.0040925578,
-0.0164488815,
0.0157976989,
0.0855034664,
0.0394111648,
-0.0161505118,
0.037380334,
0.0067281229,
0.0246306844,
0.020364536,
-0.0404152013,
-0.0422767922,
-0.0044008293,
-0.0359070525,
-0.0170294158,
0.0215356797,
-0.0217177384,
0.0284835156,
0.0326444134,
-0.0046130125,
-0.0420760177,
0.0109840417,
-0.1145519912,
-0.0712435767,
-0.0056212163,
0.0123711769,
0.0251490567,
0.0992589146,
-0.0527159423,
0.016710991,
0.0001280343,
0.0059263529,
0.0287792962,
-0.0136568528,
0.0469301231,
0.0229854602,
-0.0235776342,
0.0226412434,
0.0349785611,
-0.0307661314,
-0.015485541,
-0.018234279,
-0.0003770946,
-0.0597499274,
-0.053897731,
-0.0206143763,
-0.0187764652,
-0.0361926556,
0.029740287,
-0.0675688386,
0.0269274861,
-0.0482002385,
0.0441590175,
-0.0078901611,
0.0173291489,
0.057927765,
0.0180940684,
0.0258961264,
0.0309790187,
0.0288899112,
0.0012750421,
0.0081475154,
0.006062808,
0.0031222899,
-0.0176137704,
0.0014885392,
-0.0082672201,
0.0171951726,
0.0082368311,
0.0086902473,
0.0206641145,
0.0393799767,
0.0051618395,
0.0284652095,
0.0046390998,
-0.012373101,
0.0437396765,
0.0329901911,
0.0012347758,
0.0154968994,
0.0547502749,
0.0082265921,
0.0409428999,
0.0318656377,
0.0299156681,
0.0485090278,
0.0102095623,
-0.0166595019,
0.0177532192,
-0.0201158263,
-0.0099688126,
-0.0676669851,
-0.050086882,
-0.0110527966,
-0.0331385992,
0.0137374578,
0.0453670211,
-0.0001092276,
0.0323452279,
-0.0900976956,
0.0106958766,
-0.039842505,
0.0020476312,
-0.0395324081,
0.0072919778,
-0.0017415029,
0.0053889891,
-0.024365874,
-0.0014365521,
0.0168622285,
-0.0094656525,
-0.0386772156,
-0.0001224122,
0.0096221752,
0.0008056944,
0.0022057565,
-0.0204394944,
0.0439283028,
-0.0273521077,
-0.02801512,
0.0239192601,
0.0615897514,
-0.0476141162,
0.0278635342,
-0.0199995656,
-0.021034481,
0.0101781441,
0.0219344012,
-0.0129389623,
-0.0053676157,
-0.0103362389,
0.0574422255,
0.0247240383,
-0.0394701064,
0.0137703195,
-0.0454186685,
0.0188688319,
0.0156106576,
0.0495249853,
0.0479406454,
0.0078302324,
-0.002673856,
0.0663653463,
-0.0607745759,
-0.0071403286,
0.0444509499,
0.0032872777,
0.0263123568,
-0.0044744601,
-0.0464352407,
0.025335988,
0.0225331616,
0.0079729585,
-0.0171742719,
-0.0208897106,
0.0303794462,
-0.0224681068,
-0.0426883698,
0.0415060967,
-0.0112784766,
0.0816632211,
-0.0093726953,
-0.0253550801,
-0.0142524755,
0.0130396346,
-0.0364821255,
0.0096989656,
0.1044893116,
-0.0007744538,
-0.0355003402,
-0.0087235738,
-0.0087264096,
-0.0625327379,
-0.0199521184,
0.0025410072,
0.0479637943,
-0.0406904817,
0.0056533911,
-0.015865583,
-0.0531712659,
0.0285211876,
0.0216734,
-0.0559285879,
-0.0151257282,
0.0047144466,
0.0210130382,
-0.0110022426,
-0.0574214309,
-0.0292496663,
-0.0391039588,
-0.0503756739,
0.0175237302,
-0.0271730125,
0.0095319562,
0.0208092462,
0.0335637815,
-0.0289388709,
0.0141229434,
-0.0107276272,
-0.0002684073,
-0.0104323383,
-0.0064261626,
-0.0063860631,
-0.0173210986,
0.0313641988,
-0.0268725585,
0.0045755901,
-0.0626761243,
-0.0067181503,
0.0127888583,
-0.0678663328,
0.0565822124,
0.0149723636,
-0.0210268199,
0.0070943795,
-0.0307229515,
-0.0860213265,
-0.020072734,
-0.0544897541,
-0.0026809231,
0.0641417205,
0.0529721081,
0.0745178834,
0.0249542929,
-0.0061547742,
-0.006833191,
0.0131315878,
-0.0826783776,
-0.0021723439,
0.0118578058,
-0.0194175318,
-0.0067228405,
0.0197672807,
0.0044962307,
0.0389438197,
-0.0226164758,
-0.0169198848,
-0.0567222238,
0.0029906479,
-0.0348910466,
0.013478186,
0.0166156683,
0.0072888681,
0.0202995352,
0.0153761515,
0.0187741835,
0.0799468607,
0.0958525166,
-0.0374680161,
0.0195198655,
-0.0122763859,
0.0520405658,
-0.0087782666,
-0.0102199083,
0.0286042001,
-0.0102142785,
0.013481345,
-0.0352795571,
-0.0062251231,
-0.055045113,
-0.0029123372,
-0.0131833786,
-0.004919339,
-0.0294759963,
-0.0105819823,
0.0223254431,
-0.1035904512,
-0.0547104627,
-0.0338748805,
-0.0001400876,
-0.0321149044,
0.0043873214,
0.0267213788,
-0.009645679,
-0.0892374367,
0.0028044416,
-0.01061978,
0.0232588928,
-0.0015315544,
0.010184166,
-0.047150895,
-0.0051441821,
-0.0276848115,
-0.0361883454,
0.0201613493,
0.0221539736,
-0.0002056976,
-0.0450389273,
-0.0220245793,
0.0232365374,
-0.0335089229,
0.0273585189,
-0.046019569,
0.0341820419,
-0.0250285491,
0.0677782819,
0.0861542597,
0.0365893543,
-0.0297082216,
-0.0185961053,
0.0071272859,
-0.0490633771,
-0.0138843814,
-0.0001268065,
-0.0852211043,
0.0259882249,
0.0320179351,
-0.0112153376,
-0.0231473539,
-0.0271296538,
0.04104219,
-0.0698900148,
0.0145579139,
0.0081803845,
0.0515710823,
-0.0030327155,
-0.0811407492,
0.0228924174,
-0.0574551709,
-0.0385896228,
-0.0009365345,
0.0170902349,
0.000493576,
-0.0259640925,
-0.0717621297,
-0.0380631238,
-0.0035227684,
-0.0225486793,
0.0402900204,
-0.0376684852,
0.0756883249,
-0.0066757416,
0.0416463837,
-0.0172045063,
0.0239879042,
-0.0288643185,
-0.0302726999,
0.0988776386,
-0.0032522765,
-0.0092547145,
-0.0622716881,
0.0026917439,
0.0064545744,
0.0258624554,
-0.0064025428,
-0.0292723365,
0.0117604304,
-0.0482450537,
-0.0237241387,
0.0144981705,
0.0543930568,
0.0032131153,
0.0174659509,
-0.0535373464,
0.0288402271,
-0.0213233177,
0.0151672214,
-0.0100929393,
-0.003304489,
-0.0809629485,
-0.0608004332,
-0.0740672052,
-0.0412509255,
-0.0293562189,
-0.0556482822,
0.0269017816,
0.0145420879,
0.0322559997,
0.0154045336,
-0.008717984,
-0.0024280124,
0.0067548677,
-0.0056193331,
0.0017547735,
0.0358940326,
-0.0247337818,
0.0029235859,
0.070599705,
-0.0007972147,
-0.0002718302,
-0.0532555617,
0.0062192534,
0.0178032815,
-0.0239721239,
0.0210395884,
0.0073882793,
-0.0309655666,
0.0192259904,
-0.0349023007,
0.046402242,
-0.0410041027,
0.0150948912,
0.0162749887,
0.044903107,
0.0344294384,
-0.0040292074,
0.0102846827,
0.0355719104,
0.0536753088,
-0.0981391072,
-0.0690524876,
0.0183481202,
-0.0219532903,
-0.0261433702,
0.0585032851,
0.0116861695,
-0.0909616426,
-0.0231135115,
-0.0261526257,
-0.0084739421,
0.0083947899,
0.0150611568,
-0.046106346,
0.0314773992,
0.0545439012,
-0.0691560954,
-0.0296273474,
-0.026467314,
0.0265101343,
-0.0651173517,
0.0195348673,
0.0282813665,
0.0614989027,
0.001892089,
0.0063802702,
0.005503214,
-0.0223036092,
0.0127931852,
-0.0197985079,
-0.0340179987,
0.0048617991,
-0.0252242554,
-0.0128880171,
0.0611083731,
-0.014827583,
-0.0448981524,
0.0189862866,
-0.0031790026,
0.0108697629,
0.0284420345,
-0.0188132245,
0.0042757024,
-0.0049563814,
0.0156936515,
0.001601512,
0.0230266247,
-0.031255424,
0.019983789,
-0.0033978203,
0.0082180928,
-0.0277131759,
0.0355183147,
0.017201867,
-0.0210964475,
0.0328365378,
0.1093855947,
0.0382161438,
0.029989453,
-0.0054557524,
0.0296320114,
0.0156091144,
0.0045112213,
-0.0179854874,
-0.041773878,
0.0170647986,
0.0762267187,
-0.0214578565,
-0.0009623736,
0.0535431504,
-0.0184806511,
0.0090887081,
0.0086283479,
0.1248729974,
-0.0234921332,
0.0268705022,
-0.0565305464,
-0.0595149398,
0.040294271,
-5.718726017e-33,
-0.0221160557,
-0.0119938897,
-0.0137901446,
0.025486622,
-0.0023668651,
0.0049133771,
-0.0045856531,
0.0413358025,
-0.0016193285,
0.0074178176,
-0.0011343105,
0.0360739902,
0.0155286295,
-0.0287441127,
0.0131484708,
-0.0628001019,
0.0139380796,
0.0229564533,
-0.0003601265,
0.0329903439,
0.044735726,
-0.0102071259,
0.0149205467,
-0.059102051,
0.0049770297,
0.0224091262,
-0.040158499,
-0.0618576147,
0.0847792625,
-0.0088420827,
-0.0243689176,
0.0318322852,
0.0364646539,
-0.0097446432,
-0.0146938358,
0.0553975441,
-0.0065068388,
-0.0237913858,
-0.0063332231,
-0.009659105,
0.0327260755,
-0.0297745038,
-0.0122891087,
0.0415712334,
-0.0524533577,
0.0055790455,
0.0485435165,
0.0110743931,
0.0208883956,
0.0003005342,
-0.0267250929,
0.0319438986,
-0.0129724462,
0.0282723662,
-0.0300983228,
0.0042328043,
0.0724401325,
0.015150696,
-0.0267722961,
0.0197491646,
-0.0139088668,
0.0122647341,
-0.035387639,
-0.0651100874,
-0.0101147871,
0.0437813103,
0.0352683328,
0.0590974167,
-0.0487002097,
0.0180172529,
0.0360152014,
0.023083793,
0.0461880751,
0.0838445574,
0.0446808115,
-0.1125082523,
-0.084992595,
0.0058751493,
0.0426289588,
0.0155474823,
0.0558273681,
0.0106479321,
0.0096656838,
-0.0099803098,
0.0231003091,
-0.0412931629,
-0.0633641332,
0.0056872652,
-0.0490796454,
-0.0084821349,
-0.0032660742,
-0.0220091548,
0.0404704474,
-0.0029181356,
-0.0125043392,
0.0666616559,
-0.0135743618,
0.0371350907,
-0.0200973768,
-0.032366693,
0.0196566544,
-0.0197380912,
-0.0375857763,
0.0612830631,
0.005299022,
-0.0400610045,
-0.0239093099,
0.0371912196,
-0.0214255415,
-0.0234633591,
0.0313154161,
-0.0182549879,
0.001735215,
-0.0166693889,
0.0160501562,
0.029239228,
0.0211851411,
-0.0632402673,
0.0432053506,
0.0496167541,
0.0159599409,
-0.0236577168,
-0.0611885265,
-0.0260477941,
0.0097459825,
-0.0209632404,
-0.0182754099,
0.0169359744,
-0.0563427657,
-0.0525875092,
-0.0224203616,
-0.0787456036,
2.528e-7,
0.0347063653,
0.0689547211,
-0.0399762578,
-0.0090062041,
-0.0025336475,
0.0373220034,
0.0054749316,
0.0322341844,
-0.0082790675,
-0.0127601037,
-0.0055328594,
-0.0124507369,
0.0378850438,
0.0062421877,
-0.1172768176,
0.0111329826,
-0.0049150772,
0.0399818942,
-0.0737632513,
0.0454111397,
0.0172178317,
0.0118407309,
0.0556526743,
-0.0037398094,
-0.0403013192,
0.0202140622,
0.020106297,
-0.0856376737,
-0.1031428576,
0.0223855637,
0.0395293757,
-0.0023768491,
-0.0051872153,
0.0122009227,
-0.0218739528,
-0.0243189279,
0.008013851,
0.0440445207,
0.0166339856,
0.0084360847,
0.0533436462,
-0.0250320155,
-0.0018773505,
0.0046291733,
0.0559646897,
-0.0502663702,
-0.0643395111,
-0.0938735306,
-0.0593251027,
0.0247186702,
0.0342183635,
0.0416294187,
-0.0354463793,
0.0161301084,
0.0132240988,
-0.0243945383,
-0.0048383418,
-0.005120812,
-0.022762673,
-0.0040595802,
-0.0071628504,
-0.0857207999,
-0.0260704365,
0.0408275723,
0.0389190242,
0.0279311463,
0.032982517,
1.859644461e-34,
0.0406010449,
0.0007408485,
-0.0283831414,
0.0183491148,
0.0130017893,
-0.0078252302,
-0.0484912582,
-0.0090175439,
0.0021588712,
-0.0398741923,
0.0232019629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17984v1 | minOffense: Inter-Agreement Hate Terms for Stable Rules, Concepts, Transitivities, and Lattices | 2023-05-29T09:47:36 | 2023-05-29T09:47:36 | Animesh Chaturvedi, Rajesh Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRGXiJGp3Cc&list=PLtvWi5o3JBnF3yxcjGdT4KCDLxRBIpsyR | Hate speech classification has become an important problem due to the spread
of hate speech on social media platforms. For a given set of Hate Terms lists
(HTs-lists) and Hate Speech data (HS-data), it is challenging to understand
which hate term contributes the most for hate speech classification. This paper
contributes two approaches to quantitatively measure and qualitatively
visualise the relationship between co-occurring Hate Terms (HTs). Firstly, we
propose an approach for the classification of hate-speech by producing a Severe
Hate Terms list (Severe HTs-list) from existing HTs-lists. To achieve our goal,
we proposed three metrics (Hatefulness, Relativeness, and Offensiveness) to
measure the severity of HTs. These metrics assist to create an Inter-agreement
HTs-list, which explains the contribution of an individual hate term toward
hate speech classification. Then, we used the Offensiveness metric values of
HTs above a proposed threshold minimum Offense (minOffense) to generate a new
Severe HTs-list. To evaluate our approach, we used three hate speech datasets
and six hate terms lists. Our approach shown an improvement from 0.845 to 0.923
(best) as compared to the baseline. Secondly, we also proposed Stable Hate Rule
(SHR) mining to provide ordered co-occurrence of various HTs with minimum
Stability (minStab). The SHR mining detects frequently co-occurring HTs to form
Stable Hate Rules and Concepts. These rules and concepts are used to visualise
the graphs of Transitivities and Lattices formed by HTs. | [
0.0270866081,
0.0193656161,
-0.0383347571,
0.0255642794,
-0.0182029922,
0.0354216434,
0.0006793863,
0.025115246,
0.0332574509,
-0.0393517911,
-0.0062595634,
-0.0088027501,
-0.011069282,
0.0097283106,
-0.0560297854,
-0.0470479168,
0.0363201797,
0.0704138726,
0.010680086,
-0.0149234142,
0.0653634518,
-0.0102598779,
-0.0116281277,
0.046955023,
-0.0853237882,
0.0085341884,
0.0558712855,
-0.0200844184,
0.0573956557,
-0.0084671108,
0.0244604629,
0.0309902765,
-0.0026963735,
0.038028188,
0.0000022246,
-0.0525193177,
-0.0096930563,
-0.0293603744,
0.0089927865,
-0.0689241812,
0.0752242953,
-0.0148797343,
-0.0023734285,
0.0537457243,
-0.0284364969,
0.0150612351,
0.0580497794,
0.0427349843,
0.084599331,
0.0138459662,
-0.0103275441,
-0.0289369021,
0.0002662691,
0.0266370419,
-0.0006398263,
0.0480566956,
0.0181947667,
-0.0301529635,
-0.064809151,
-0.0160188004,
-0.0126062417,
-0.0285032727,
0.0083688442,
0.0242393073,
0.0334266052,
-0.0263940208,
-0.0068482542,
-0.0447461903,
0.0192942861,
0.0340072624,
-0.0595673211,
-0.0136614991,
0.007347398,
-0.0031928853,
-0.0091946004,
-0.0051651895,
-0.0213889349,
0.0035747529,
-0.0407186821,
0.0203236956,
0.0148180751,
0.030068025,
0.0266512744,
0.0636770129,
-0.007008791,
0.0085070254,
-0.0113279941,
-0.0371604562,
-0.0100109316,
-0.0569299422,
-0.0534459576,
0.0231567081,
0.0356628373,
-0.0097469306,
-0.001138986,
0.0133670345,
-0.0324281417,
-0.0166853648,
0.0168275852,
-0.0970889553,
0.0288581997,
0.0208987761,
-0.0176321883,
-0.0147929341,
0.0375073254,
0.0127112512,
0.0264352355,
0.0099740615,
0.0066914987,
0.0242360756,
-0.0292312633,
0.0416462123,
0.0227934085,
-0.0168825947,
0.0234010667,
0.0640232563,
-0.0619037263,
-0.0147761526,
-0.0903102756,
-0.0131993024,
-0.024543887,
0.0105434945,
0.0818987042,
0.008983586,
-0.0388247743,
-0.0364797041,
-0.0786752701,
0.0204187836,
-0.0372613035,
-0.0297370795,
0.048212871,
0.0012299482,
-0.001989875,
-0.0054126414,
0.0198375955,
0.0372072905,
0.0701784119,
-0.0124481479,
-0.0154952155,
-0.0393677093,
-0.0213621799,
-0.0082684159,
0.004549508,
-0.0588250272,
0.0047093453,
-0.0264257379,
-0.0287354533,
-0.0660121292,
0.0013377332,
0.0241046641,
-0.0556834042,
0.0498090237,
-0.0315621756,
-0.0347571336,
0.0209191125,
0.0306767132,
0.0070226598,
-0.0123986099,
0.0204166435,
0.0290966816,
0.0558099151,
-0.0305508915,
-0.0068413164,
0.0269365273,
0.0383189283,
0.0197192244,
-0.0645841584,
-0.0055211554,
-0.0600773878,
-0.0613506995,
-0.0084185926,
0.0356606543,
-0.0180081706,
-0.1072294936,
0.0138428146,
0.0614173263,
-0.0193765033,
0.0298987255,
-0.0058680992,
0.0233577937,
-0.0392950736,
-0.0323116928,
-0.0402129591,
-0.0133354738,
-0.0355114155,
-0.0679268688,
0.0231523532,
0.04543804,
0.0095443297,
-0.0529039577,
-0.0555532016,
0.0104687056,
0.0659733787,
-0.0693975389,
0.0059996429,
0.0044661751,
0.0125548169,
0.0143987089,
0.0789932236,
-0.0195628498,
0.0007441852,
-0.037639942,
-0.005318772,
0.078477487,
-0.001424434,
-0.0018355498,
-0.0040931795,
-0.0405506641,
-0.0226106457,
0.0125845289,
-0.0211509857,
0.0017365606,
-0.0499416068,
-0.0248218291,
-0.011797362,
0.1000727713,
0.0170909185,
0.0058063711,
0.0276577789,
0.0182553511,
-0.0137433596,
0.0431091674,
-0.0361906253,
0.0082631847,
0.0846057981,
0.0631856918,
0.0250532366,
0.0212826021,
0.0613722466,
0.0324897431,
-0.0246999897,
-0.0468002632,
0.0302303508,
0.0014220336,
-0.0399408564,
0.0273542013,
-0.0062646144,
0.0438421257,
0.0285871644,
-0.0233334899,
0.0144720981,
0.0685204118,
0.0303887967,
0.0341836214,
0.0690683946,
-0.0298844334,
-0.0046037617,
-0.020958744,
-0.031750571,
-0.0577082597,
0.028879296,
-0.025631763,
0.0725996867,
-0.0369738117,
0.0223473739,
0.0053601353,
-0.0658488274,
0.0438288711,
0.0596842319,
-0.0026743237,
-0.0587118156,
-0.0482416376,
0.0289266072,
0.0044340403,
-0.0108321169,
-0.0084826499,
0.0197571181,
-0.0384598859,
-0.0188974962,
-0.012338331,
-0.0288181584,
-0.0098487986,
-0.0242039189,
-0.0171838291,
0.0186139774,
0.0262988433,
0.0033847368,
0.0609620363,
0.0229240041,
0.0147980116,
-0.0568971448,
-0.0891554803,
-0.0238208044,
-0.024133306,
-0.0030751904,
0.0089012748,
0.0301039256,
-0.0212770253,
0.0735010505,
-0.0050913165,
-0.0611894168,
-0.00846605,
-0.0075287353,
-0.0401459225,
0.0306228306,
0.0352016985,
-0.0400372073,
-0.0378273726,
0.0920043737,
0.1170985922,
0.0366435498,
-0.0306560863,
-0.0116869677,
-0.0056580771,
-0.0320440196,
0.0625484437,
0.0000926981,
-0.0310209189,
0.0091233822,
0.0531473085,
0.07054618,
-0.0441751219,
-0.0597761534,
0.0376449265,
-0.0591745898,
-0.0045611961,
-0.0447185822,
-0.0673195422,
-0.006925974,
-0.0333959199,
-0.0100129051,
-0.0897136256,
0.0257312506,
0.0222832356,
0.0668002442,
-0.0162789244,
-0.0292366669,
-0.001392583,
0.0228964239,
0.0105697792,
0.0480153598,
-0.0430167578,
0.0040332144,
0.0490788221,
-0.0226187147,
0.0201586224,
-0.0270405412,
-0.0264004786,
-0.0113796946,
-0.0062542707,
0.0294378307,
-0.012376287,
-0.0592259429,
-0.0138010103,
-0.007480944,
-0.0421163402,
0.0635210946,
-0.013301855,
0.0197866689,
0.0149560943,
0.0130075505,
-0.0549164675,
0.0493339524,
-0.0098325256,
0.0630449429,
-0.0336216725,
-0.0122502251,
-0.0039833244,
0.0317963287,
0.0416132845,
-0.047686208,
0.0540493466,
-0.0014600498,
0.0224172492,
-0.0093310066,
0.0265175216,
0.0184843373,
0.0184966587,
0.0114249606,
-0.020040188,
-0.0281176195,
0.0148178963,
0.0172453392,
0.0670576245,
0.0602148734,
-0.0155395642,
0.0150571791,
0.0148920147,
0.0126972189,
0.0056526065,
-0.0484464318,
-0.072043784,
0.0174602531,
-0.0364629999,
0.0053974143,
-0.086034961,
-0.0810039639,
0.0161914118,
-0.0024659911,
0.0209843311,
-0.005034436,
-0.0286108535,
-0.0370793268,
-0.0342155658,
0.0182771664,
-0.0004834392,
-0.0070791324,
-0.0410931632,
0.0337912776,
-0.0004576956,
0.0281145871,
-0.1144853756,
0.0215346497,
0.0416655988,
-0.0306635685,
0.0280285422,
0.0051997332,
0.0538778007,
-0.0645436198,
-0.0348724686,
0.0360222533,
-0.0118654128,
-0.015232251,
-0.0808867291,
0.0548778176,
0.0212672129,
-0.0498035029,
-0.049388621,
0.0295939986,
0.013449098,
-0.0128559982,
0.0267480388,
0.0495475829,
0.014546196,
0.0161583889,
-0.0692920387,
0.0369703136,
-0.0190198421,
0.0391050093,
0.0232941415,
-0.0430244543,
0.0666915327,
-0.06495592,
0.0038717224,
-0.0317114219,
-0.0860187858,
-0.0364357382,
-0.0072007184,
-0.0219149981,
-0.0349004194,
0.0005245924,
0.0065486291,
0.0111885471,
0.0202199761,
-0.0202451311,
-0.005961508,
-0.0054216241,
-0.0469220802,
-0.0278843455,
0.0366703421,
0.0279228166,
0.0128453411,
0.0068121077,
-0.0240915995,
0.0315573774,
-0.0569242537,
0.0108552873,
-0.0034643665,
-0.0104398979,
0.0984948501,
0.033921048,
0.0101476908,
-0.0234163254,
-0.0053181248,
-0.0195552446,
0.0693181455,
0.0590693876,
0.0180796739,
-0.031013513,
0.0345243998,
-0.0355498083,
0.0105276313,
-0.0052113221,
0.0139391804,
0.0537557416,
0.0089991475,
-0.0575632453,
-0.0754111856,
0.0050427238,
-0.0072623673,
-0.0241978355,
0.033404287,
0.0058690566,
-0.0836376324,
-0.041221112,
-0.0049548042,
0.006619459,
-0.0378510877,
0.0106199794,
-0.0078930585,
0.0112994919,
-0.0323309302,
-0.0597556159,
-0.0287124887,
-0.022624312,
-0.0179890003,
-0.0062884199,
0.0448423102,
0.0147141526,
0.037134856,
0.0197747238,
-0.0011999422,
-0.0169492308,
-0.0065475446,
-0.0214903802,
-0.022911869,
-0.0122578843,
0.0111728907,
0.0097725419,
-0.0114635313,
0.0339084379,
0.0040187184,
0.0525000729,
-0.0037560221,
-0.0375979356,
-0.0392815471,
-0.0219953172,
0.0118242083,
0.012750986,
0.0142583773,
-0.0106973574,
-0.0249271598,
0.0136397947,
-0.025430508,
-0.0620877147,
0.0019311631,
0.0310933925,
-0.0425647125,
-0.012229125,
0.0094326073,
-0.0234900508,
0.0204789229,
0.0336983651,
-0.0568148308,
0.000365688,
0.0226643533,
0.0114274574,
0.0341307782,
0.0397023559,
0.0129972752,
-0.0788091347,
-0.0151511747,
0.0209523235,
-0.0496136323,
0.0528259203,
0.0274166092,
0.0076765167,
0.0707010999,
-0.0020495846,
0.0414025858,
0.0135339973,
-0.0212910175,
-0.0242447872,
-0.0630506873,
0.0164800268,
-6.207621097e-33,
-0.0089262323,
-0.0714151636,
-0.0077049867,
0.006287009,
-0.0115589239,
-0.0545985103,
0.0568749979,
0.0257236473,
-0.0137369353,
0.0113311289,
0.0097505441,
0.0151751162,
0.0048977304,
-0.0007721869,
0.0158936512,
-0.0280400403,
0.0015237221,
-0.0052563529,
0.0123326061,
0.0099923071,
0.0612429008,
-0.0175501797,
0.0105300583,
-0.0700815022,
0.0445921682,
-0.0032510071,
-0.0152525203,
0.0167379994,
0.0112757618,
0.0497965813,
0.0120677361,
0.0737247393,
0.0289578345,
-0.0325899608,
-0.0022751293,
0.023447793,
-0.010274699,
-0.0304563921,
0.0117818341,
-0.007525288,
0.0515554212,
0.0079664951,
0.0071538673,
0.0228837375,
-0.0561387874,
-0.0337828323,
0.0472865775,
-0.0393999517,
-0.0012359564,
0.0007319369,
-0.0243877228,
0.0415511429,
-0.0612526014,
0.0005667375,
-0.010085308,
-0.0072301324,
0.0415979996,
-0.0057667592,
-0.0562961586,
0.0571824387,
-0.0249709003,
-0.0119209411,
-0.0306576528,
-0.0337749757,
0.0196973048,
0.0793213844,
-0.0193452276,
0.0131875165,
0.0193179995,
0.0459204391,
0.0184864849,
0.0605475344,
0.0165370237,
0.0395394228,
0.0268178508,
-0.0854500979,
-0.0487994254,
0.0100198332,
0.024744302,
0.0153573444,
-0.0171765219,
-0.0351355113,
-0.0667253062,
-0.0232947301,
0.0155664552,
-0.0336432829,
-0.0370424166,
-0.0386849456,
0.022554433,
-0.0356645063,
-0.0215719752,
-0.0074702897,
-0.0059356862,
0.0101863863,
-0.0178219769,
0.0577789806,
-0.0019795138,
0.0019363249,
0.0239177682,
0.0125873573,
-0.0398901775,
-0.00034588,
-0.0303838439,
-0.0376816951,
0.0505404361,
0.0031451627,
0.0506799966,
-0.0042357752,
-0.0575917773,
0.0226041265,
0.0263056345,
0.0116947731,
-0.0251075197,
-0.0060325316,
-0.0061121397,
0.0462195873,
-0.0131995454,
-0.0237176884,
0.0311067104,
0.0006574223,
-0.0125565799,
0.0110099306,
-0.0622556955,
0.0042252792,
0.0414153971,
-0.0221921969,
-0.0031212657,
-0.0264196303,
0.0327559598,
-0.0930814371,
0.0116035352,
-0.089846395,
2.857e-7,
0.0058901771,
0.0464789085,
0.0125754196,
0.021032922,
0.0184485316,
0.0427570455,
0.0531966612,
0.0135738691,
-0.0182254314,
0.0072472137,
-0.009506681,
0.0457402878,
-0.0238472745,
0.0955798849,
0.0377455391,
-0.0249355566,
-0.0416326486,
-0.0236221589,
-0.0368122384,
0.0145370411,
0.0222858265,
0.0487047061,
0.0668135956,
-0.0351567008,
-0.0286260471,
-0.0068611088,
-0.0113461018,
-0.0584580153,
-0.0158720836,
-0.0203616358,
0.0558556989,
-0.038462624,
0.0175787415,
-0.0079390006,
0.0041810917,
-0.0049529695,
-0.0032754389,
-0.0074232309,
0.0274569318,
0.0323590077,
0.0215675887,
-0.0179851446,
0.004846714,
-0.0209585205,
0.0262048654,
0.024483677,
-0.0008477324,
-0.0355420746,
0.0048535606,
-0.0032280155,
0.05291247,
-0.0047534229,
-0.0226819478,
-0.0223144144,
0.0116782263,
0.0010349719,
0.0433139689,
-0.0438482799,
0.0316463634,
0.0116885174,
0.0048819468,
-0.0435960107,
-0.0064468943,
-0.0135575561,
0.0343184322,
0.0827232823,
0.0302299112,
2.331223637e-34,
0.0392882936,
-0.0339878537,
0.0021747539,
-0.0331029035,
0.0397116058,
0.0048738411,
0.0028172315,
0.0302681029,
0.0395454578,
-0.0146383261,
0.0129054151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17968v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17968v1 | Data Augmentation for Low-Resource Keyphrase Generation | 2023-05-29T09:20:34 | 2023-05-29T09:20:34 | Krishna Garg, Jishnu Ray Chowdhury, Cornelia Caragea | cs.CL | cs.CL | Keyphrase generation is the task of summarizing the contents of any given
article into a few salient phrases (or keyphrases). Existing works for the task
mostly rely on large-scale annotated datasets, which are not easy to acquire.
Very few works address the problem of keyphrase generation in low-resource
settings, but they still rely on a lot of additional unlabeled data for
pretraining and on automatic methods for pseudo-annotations. In this paper, we
present data augmentation strategies specifically to address keyphrase
generation in purely resource-constrained domains. We design techniques that
use the full text of the articles to improve both present and absent keyphrase
generation. We test our approach comprehensively on three datasets and show
that the data augmentation strategies consistently improve the state-of-the-art
performance. We release our source code at
https://github.com/kgarg8/kpgen-lowres-data-aug. | [
0.0790220499,
0.0480068848,
0.0291353501,
-0.0006287632,
-0.017007811,
-0.0053131222,
-0.0088023338,
-0.0073256548,
0.0065984381,
-0.0567911454,
-0.0050343378,
0.0572243817,
-0.0340669714,
0.0177499913,
0.0251314547,
-0.0496610403,
0.0335463881,
-0.0085053621,
0.0011661192,
-0.0193406846,
0.0447550081,
0.0248418935,
0.0009294137,
0.0257493425,
0.0392520651,
0.0101230294,
-0.0248937756,
-0.0280026849,
0.0428435169,
-0.0077939709,
0.0168087967,
0.0292455126,
0.013734106,
0.0373499356,
0.0000015904,
-0.0356417671,
0.0003878738,
-0.0153429657,
0.0189327244,
0.0281971022,
0.0874692053,
-0.0544998161,
0.0384916514,
0.0119664809,
-0.0493401103,
-0.0161160305,
0.0502311103,
0.0400600694,
0.074468255,
0.0816968158,
-0.0163712893,
-0.0354120284,
0.0262943339,
-0.0355462059,
0.006154485,
-0.0544703566,
0.0180482063,
-0.0462217443,
-0.022658987,
0.0624600127,
0.0214565564,
0.0434444025,
0.0061158612,
0.0027123136,
0.1218342558,
0.0255640205,
-0.0989517793,
-0.0085825529,
-0.0201182887,
0.0736175105,
0.0026021665,
-0.0059313048,
0.0485444069,
-0.0346607454,
-0.0106393388,
0.0068619899,
-0.0545062162,
0.0008196488,
0.0096985064,
-0.00815327,
-0.0177980997,
-0.003305312,
0.0075080637,
0.0386028066,
-0.0100495685,
-0.0177251883,
0.0342793576,
-0.0315444544,
-0.0223771129,
0.0098184329,
-0.0630983561,
-0.0647701249,
-0.0087868618,
0.0376124866,
-0.0014786677,
0.0277461689,
-0.0695316941,
-0.0561324842,
0.0830816478,
-0.093273975,
-0.0167532284,
-0.030179346,
0.0086324038,
0.051123295,
-0.0490955412,
0.000533592,
-0.0082823457,
0.0200481582,
-0.0286202393,
0.002723404,
-0.0504145622,
-0.0226555746,
-0.0156677011,
0.0489162058,
0.0346249342,
-0.0469479747,
-0.0450965203,
0.0143048363,
0.0380922779,
0.0249626413,
-0.0015693859,
0.0402830392,
-0.0523126535,
-0.0076396717,
0.03959997,
-0.0044031213,
-0.0347873457,
0.0025640281,
0.0295994654,
0.0024364248,
-0.0086771548,
0.0155837927,
0.0605904944,
-0.0297375116,
0.0301543847,
-0.0169424675,
-0.0299561117,
-0.0188334268,
-0.0117447628,
-0.0485614575,
-0.0220610052,
-0.0081543084,
0.0045239935,
-0.0676952824,
0.030073937,
-0.00229463,
-0.0063464008,
-0.031059403,
0.0211041253,
0.0505452827,
-0.0779437423,
0.049352169,
-0.0486715212,
-0.0049724658,
0.007662599,
0.0079832021,
0.0261529833,
0.0438133664,
0.0343106501,
0.0555041544,
0.0566954575,
-0.0074627991,
0.0076949676,
0.0078881243,
0.0493580624,
0.0363134705,
0.0298505239,
-0.0041192872,
-0.0797410682,
0.0323767066,
-0.012169878,
0.007453924,
-0.0198450256,
0.0369685404,
0.0524159782,
0.0584113002,
-0.0123925935,
0.0458151102,
-0.0031488801,
0.0574102029,
-0.0031293395,
-0.0022606337,
0.0248538814,
0.0148039022,
-0.0130245192,
0.0673475936,
0.0872609168,
0.0362981968,
-0.0136093404,
-0.030813735,
0.0032201521,
0.0182864312,
-0.0056035179,
0.0104335481,
0.0595593005,
0.0400929414,
-0.0292786788,
0.0183335207,
0.0132593066,
-0.0716108829,
0.0062008989,
-0.0145402011,
-0.0217101388,
0.0399306491,
0.0680507794,
-0.019097643,
-0.0481940247,
0.0040203906,
0.0543495975,
0.0718036965,
-0.000897676,
-0.0048958086,
-0.0274289884,
-0.0728053078,
-0.0557417609,
-0.0414294377,
0.0117043117,
-0.023452349,
0.0229828265,
0.009876621,
0.0491026454,
-0.0177675076,
-0.0305077899,
0.014722704,
0.0054617194,
-0.013033797,
0.0157707483,
-0.0120457439,
-0.0163195617,
0.0480864197,
-0.0009436858,
0.0315841474,
0.0270131771,
-0.0283544678,
-0.0168617647,
-0.004122376,
0.0294839889,
0.0055510104,
0.0247186925,
-0.0602864437,
0.0149868317,
0.0112687284,
-0.0414649919,
-0.0565698929,
0.0338051505,
-0.0453072153,
0.050941512,
-0.0413066037,
-0.0108418427,
-0.0122452248,
0.0203988086,
-0.035315413,
0.0746087581,
0.0155051108,
0.0206626467,
-0.0314535759,
-0.0292933118,
0.0246241409,
-0.0306946132,
-0.0063227038,
-0.0419008806,
0.0248410627,
0.0001245371,
0.0437782258,
0.0049050776,
-0.0324134156,
-0.010589269,
-0.0840065852,
0.0098661557,
0.0128893964,
-0.0051291082,
0.0327513069,
0.0419764221,
0.0048188129,
-0.0247843228,
-0.0416479707,
-0.0280732587,
0.0015689406,
0.0219537783,
0.0337568484,
0.0268616211,
0.0109147718,
-0.0119311074,
0.0022983525,
0.0091432659,
0.0152351782,
0.0499111712,
-0.0292095765,
0.0082359156,
0.0389734805,
-0.0113097187,
-0.0610710829,
0.0256750192,
-0.0372260176,
0.0002985007,
0.0025004277,
0.0158180203,
-0.0279340204,
0.0389480367,
-0.0287071429,
0.0197458193,
0.0107119903,
-0.029497141,
-0.0288841035,
-0.0238794088,
-0.007763355,
0.0249578431,
-0.0191848502,
0.0601176172,
0.0301559046,
-0.014007465,
-0.016770497,
-0.0412180163,
0.0288038105,
-0.0050910078,
-0.0127286986,
-0.0385955907,
0.007020778,
0.0062324116,
0.0172566008,
-0.0311207585,
0.0002756356,
0.0482761376,
-0.0134302517,
0.0174005944,
-0.0600028485,
-0.003748551,
-0.0400319695,
0.019801911,
-0.0157209206,
0.0099321557,
-0.0062188222,
-0.0154116387,
0.0094291652,
-0.0107754134,
0.012160603,
-0.0310684256,
0.0732028633,
-0.0056331153,
0.0139173931,
-0.0148771005,
-0.0101627074,
-0.0278214123,
-0.0558702834,
-0.0206384063,
-0.0359650254,
0.0301190726,
-0.0378380008,
0.006769686,
-0.0027139434,
0.0174022876,
0.0606431663,
-0.0254982002,
-0.0180773977,
-0.0015073597,
0.0456983298,
0.0950824246,
-0.0201011393,
-0.0181236695,
-0.0028729376,
0.0017388059,
0.0239470955,
0.0589497052,
-0.0188311487,
-0.0186597388,
-0.0223070625,
0.0033947735,
-0.0476355702,
0.0241263025,
-0.0313551649,
0.0215109698,
-0.0112557802,
-0.0287520252,
0.0876535699,
0.031986706,
-0.0947478488,
-0.0203322303,
0.0041306391,
0.0160068255,
0.0027288627,
0.0111720189,
-0.0800837278,
-0.0101934643,
-0.0225305725,
0.0577427857,
-0.0170529112,
-0.0287268292,
-0.0259402785,
-0.0795922801,
0.0151098734,
0.0110104959,
-0.0477461703,
-0.0246834494,
-0.0513968095,
-0.0192231741,
-0.0341339558,
-0.0232030246,
-0.0150281396,
-0.0435900874,
0.0348370895,
0.001442916,
-0.0501034446,
-0.0546589494,
-0.0368305817,
-0.0224229395,
-0.0014765917,
0.0708647594,
0.0263600331,
-0.0106167682,
0.0073988209,
0.0073923483,
0.0117407553,
-0.0261071958,
0.0093950694,
0.0398145281,
-0.0189955756,
-0.0101185506,
-0.0087437807,
0.0617918111,
-0.0202909913,
-0.0230251029,
0.0758206546,
-0.000784129,
-0.0002593303,
0.0382932983,
-0.0286834762,
0.0090065235,
-0.0005487889,
0.0704245791,
0.0427278876,
-0.0178060811,
-0.0084079746,
0.0142349144,
0.0186148006,
-0.1328318566,
-0.0309194792,
-0.0241866093,
-0.0631713867,
0.0271100774,
-0.0759384409,
-0.0701739639,
0.0273906738,
-0.0048339115,
0.0063303816,
0.0269418005,
-0.0315489881,
-0.0000538986,
-0.0685001314,
-0.0082381805,
-0.0318444036,
-0.0494495817,
0.0135804983,
-0.0552520603,
0.0313789956,
-0.0495991074,
-0.0211024433,
0.0039624437,
-0.0580717288,
-0.0285258163,
0.0195181668,
0.0330668911,
0.0197789539,
0.0428298414,
-0.02630537,
-0.048546236,
0.0809251815,
0.0940203443,
-0.0205971785,
-0.00144905,
0.0253027827,
0.0019893358,
-0.007330135,
0.0293944944,
-0.0632012188,
0.0163716357,
-0.0045753014,
0.0632861629,
-0.0608005524,
-0.0169785004,
0.0159833897,
0.010828902,
0.0134091591,
-0.0619156472,
0.0093932338,
-0.0456487201,
0.0090652499,
0.0168925878,
-0.0177312959,
-0.04039561,
0.0325550139,
0.0022402783,
-0.03330395,
-0.005730032,
0.0469567068,
-0.0514001101,
0.044143226,
-0.0708093122,
-0.0116859162,
0.0336084813,
-0.022700727,
-0.0107285762,
-0.0097217597,
-0.0398549214,
-0.0094221476,
-0.0278849695,
0.001442739,
0.0002809537,
-0.0063415519,
0.0205243919,
-0.0319342054,
-0.0257500112,
0.0537036695,
-0.1084389985,
0.0190220159,
-0.0635183603,
0.0305397138,
0.0602177195,
-0.0223933868,
0.0406978391,
-0.0199430939,
-0.0394255631,
0.0012244307,
0.0441947952,
-0.0029505144,
-0.0109296227,
-0.0489037111,
0.0271209218,
-0.0023055451,
0.0306699052,
0.0935361162,
0.0136360712,
0.0481309071,
0.0178911407,
-0.0371786915,
-0.0256613251,
-0.0129629895,
0.0465247929,
0.0453861505,
-0.0117405858,
-0.0143307634,
-0.0165132061,
-0.0344813205,
0.0278684665,
-0.0011628515,
0.0084293224,
0.0141598592,
0.0194940642,
0.0334510356,
-0.0333550088,
0.0175162628,
-0.0765671283,
0.0403171666,
-0.0298044197,
-0.0293514989,
0.0336766914,
-5.972180599e-33,
0.010184139,
-0.0178834237,
-0.0044278791,
0.0246389713,
-0.0134820575,
0.034235321,
-0.0383544341,
-0.0273912344,
0.0241297632,
0.0026390355,
-0.0329767279,
0.0021963401,
0.0143982824,
0.0584475249,
0.0436205454,
0.0060911034,
0.0194920599,
0.0219523665,
-0.0045533804,
0.0720152929,
-0.0008353235,
0.0192894042,
0.0550116561,
-0.013289622,
0.0471823998,
-0.0625238717,
-0.0319730081,
-0.0330335684,
0.0655336678,
0.0484722666,
-0.0050877579,
0.0359300226,
0.0218625907,
-0.0693157017,
-0.0288634878,
0.0069118673,
-0.0363158435,
-0.0334943496,
0.0132062351,
-0.0130301462,
-0.0084296539,
-0.0367974043,
0.0265364442,
-0.051204592,
0.0339776389,
0.0129576223,
0.0580581762,
-0.0481246226,
-0.0680397078,
-0.0696909502,
-0.0323930643,
0.0195405725,
-0.0045217578,
-0.005144455,
0.0114465076,
-0.0003278719,
-0.0050553023,
0.0282974057,
-0.0218485203,
0.039629098,
0.0785471424,
0.0303520206,
0.0184224863,
0.0566865355,
0.0088057509,
0.0561965257,
-0.0090324143,
-0.0423023105,
-0.002366791,
0.096566312,
-0.008132061,
0.0055445256,
0.0163385607,
0.0861312672,
0.0546223931,
0.0275086258,
-0.0163890775,
0.0554718152,
0.0085666729,
-0.016252242,
0.0285051074,
-0.0007221118,
-0.0042339084,
0.0323151089,
-0.0029246372,
0.0171399899,
-0.0310309548,
-0.0482335202,
-0.0107286554,
0.0619329959,
-0.1187572256,
0.0660651475,
-0.013198291,
-0.0262427572,
-0.0031123175,
0.0298632886,
0.0286007598,
0.0107982466,
-0.0080553396,
-0.0307232048,
-0.0331708491,
-0.0060797124,
0.0603641793,
0.010563842,
0.0047391253,
-0.0216121171,
0.041988574,
-0.0169867408,
-0.031608019,
0.0000164215,
0.0029781682,
0.0097702779,
-0.0493936576,
-0.0020302024,
-0.002559386,
0.0248462018,
-0.0063169878,
0.0360721722,
0.0204729028,
0.0262110699,
0.0307715815,
-0.0095160706,
0.0139025003,
0.028489355,
-0.0019056583,
0.0217248015,
-0.0149266459,
-0.0276104324,
-0.0276076514,
-0.0513371117,
-0.0158753805,
-0.0198355056,
2.366e-7,
0.0033945383,
0.0264228843,
0.0492867343,
-0.0188363902,
-0.0273235254,
0.0098558897,
-0.0032059951,
0.0435941443,
-0.0285569243,
-0.0430844389,
0.0582485721,
0.0493214279,
0.0074209664,
-0.0112586217,
-0.0976846814,
-0.0151125109,
-0.0814853907,
0.0144566717,
-0.047831066,
-0.0015126118,
0.0506048985,
0.0501985587,
0.0244651157,
-0.0322367921,
-0.0103723994,
-0.0346811451,
0.0314584784,
0.0189105067,
-0.046753671,
0.0195746012,
0.034225665,
0.0641811118,
-0.0437615849,
0.0086204773,
-0.0270844102,
-0.0275225267,
0.0615755059,
0.012790774,
0.0127905095,
-0.0398173556,
-0.0172824543,
-0.014721375,
0.0286741946,
-0.0078034997,
0.06552919,
-0.0702553466,
-0.006962968,
-0.0454232097,
-0.049450513,
0.0334036872,
-0.0155580537,
-0.0393651761,
-0.0445261933,
-0.000164451,
0.0025043238,
0.0141725624,
-0.0177021734,
-0.0673784763,
0.0113198357,
0.0223956704,
-0.0184972491,
-0.008054438,
-0.0557274595,
0.0252397023,
0.0031052863,
-0.0698026717,
0.0027826962,
1.934592328e-34,
0.0610421002,
-0.0259807203,
-0.0360244475,
0.011436088,
-0.010615034,
-0.0257918965,
0.0052658794,
0.0051364233,
0.0128621077,
-0.0301881153,
-0.0052794795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17951v1 | ContrastNER: Contrastive-based Prompt Tuning for Few-shot NER | 2023-05-29T08:24:42 | 2023-05-29T08:24:42 | Amirhossein Layegh, Amir H. Payberah, Ahmet Soylu, Dumitru Roman, Mihhail Matskin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt-based language models have produced encouraging results in numerous
applications, including Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks. NER aims to
identify entities in a sentence and provide their types. However, the strong
performance of most available NER approaches is heavily dependent on the design
of discrete prompts and a verbalizer to map the model-predicted outputs to
entity categories, which are complicated undertakings. To address these
challenges, we present ContrastNER, a prompt-based NER framework that employs
both discrete and continuous tokens in prompts and uses a contrastive learning
approach to learn the continuous prompts and forecast entity types. The
experimental results demonstrate that ContrastNER obtains competitive
performance to the state-of-the-art NER methods in high-resource settings and
outperforms the state-of-the-art models in low-resource circumstances without
requiring extensive manual prompt engineering and verbalizer design. | [
0.0472177342,
0.0310419183,
0.008307117,
0.0116885668,
-0.0305110291,
0.0290235989,
0.0380942747,
-0.0221946072,
0.0153298099,
-0.0413248017,
-0.008461385,
-0.0482277162,
0.0046210554,
0.0249703284,
0.0288875494,
-0.0657250434,
0.0467590839,
-0.0378070399,
0.0358609594,
0.033112023,
-0.019634543,
0.0206154343,
-0.0325779729,
0.040164642,
0.0202727076,
-0.0137855597,
-0.0405064784,
0.0157004222,
0.0376521014,
-0.0592719577,
0.037236385,
0.0687372684,
-0.0061514867,
0.0342744105,
0.0000019951,
-0.0765883699,
-0.0622563437,
0.0178943891,
-0.0439860485,
-0.0344614014,
0.0199195556,
-0.0313758887,
-0.0151711106,
0.0270327739,
0.0087385522,
-0.0481496528,
0.0208083671,
0.0471799783,
0.027516162,
0.0691559389,
-0.0090764062,
-0.0063043302,
0.0421176888,
-0.0017478548,
-0.0257567111,
0.0146992207,
0.0174576212,
-0.1173786074,
0.0124357538,
0.0386066772,
0.0015397654,
0.0062402454,
0.0140103232,
0.0319693387,
0.0094506796,
0.0500395261,
0.0046521067,
0.0008455784,
-0.0492673218,
0.039848689,
0.011840634,
0.0218782164,
0.0495767854,
-0.0295215864,
-0.0182342827,
-0.0422068872,
0.0001296852,
-0.0075395838,
-0.0584117658,
-0.0108877039,
0.0413838662,
0.0114434427,
-0.0255473275,
0.0004170731,
-0.0206167083,
-0.0022453519,
0.0452013798,
-0.0387807302,
0.0005023748,
0.0103526982,
-0.0206273589,
-0.067532979,
0.0274202842,
0.0295959525,
-0.0574063472,
0.0092051169,
-0.0343423076,
0.0029014924,
0.0184529573,
0.0343694501,
0.005386,
0.0386227034,
-0.0203066505,
0.0300937295,
-0.0255630706,
0.0360453129,
0.0257586464,
0.0079033226,
0.0251062028,
-0.0190875102,
-0.0340735652,
0.004058165,
-0.0494643822,
0.0427324399,
-0.0314893536,
-0.018200459,
-0.007950142,
0.0199912339,
0.0254787374,
0.0300787706,
0.0417607911,
-0.012901633,
-0.0234578568,
-0.0200129356,
-0.0398488417,
0.0319592282,
-0.044585932,
0.0040044514,
0.0013896289,
-0.0622343421,
0.0025364924,
-0.0291330013,
0.0152869197,
-0.0571245849,
0.004572859,
0.0484695584,
-0.0064377245,
-0.090285711,
-0.081007354,
0.011380014,
-0.0148775112,
-0.0398890898,
-0.0425306857,
-0.0373930223,
0.0189529993,
0.0150480112,
0.0048370454,
-0.0339461751,
0.0063718786,
0.0039405725,
-0.0143138003,
0.1012394577,
-0.0528159477,
-0.0309579745,
0.0226200689,
-0.0152700124,
0.0014976002,
0.0370089412,
0.0156639889,
-0.0246952903,
0.0211575925,
-0.000419951,
-0.0088961739,
0.0202262755,
0.0033177268,
-0.0315185599,
-0.0217480045,
0.0180288907,
0.0054602199,
0.0014292548,
0.0339721255,
0.0838885829,
0.0262087584,
-0.0174356047,
0.0297538918,
0.0291446596,
0.019477522,
-0.0064128172,
0.0627552494,
0.0109095015,
-0.02212945,
0.0271360669,
-0.0247192699,
0.0048675234,
-0.0289420988,
0.0106610004,
0.0422185548,
0.0664352849,
-0.038472157,
-0.0087759942,
0.0106296325,
0.0091579072,
-0.032373894,
-0.0032973476,
0.0522172339,
0.0247335639,
-0.0882055536,
0.0439484231,
0.0354189016,
-0.0061786664,
0.0167009048,
-0.039936088,
0.0451919846,
0.081040144,
0.0173291285,
-0.0341673084,
-0.0390547179,
-0.0580896512,
-0.0153591707,
0.0814151913,
0.0135228839,
-0.019250866,
0.0212338679,
-0.0274913982,
0.0113036102,
-0.0062191449,
0.0253859889,
0.0283431839,
0.001618333,
0.0568570942,
0.0001784666,
0.0070465021,
0.003042256,
0.0453329906,
-0.0305029117,
-0.047875993,
0.0332740732,
0.0462038592,
-0.0165822227,
0.0513467826,
0.0022507939,
-0.0072470745,
-0.0144593511,
-0.0319142789,
0.0067647407,
-0.0383925885,
-0.0156708825,
-0.0824711099,
-0.0202070512,
0.0383919366,
-0.0003417765,
-0.0059622256,
-0.0265553761,
-0.0485424958,
-0.0401219167,
0.0099974452,
0.0369323827,
-0.0218035206,
0.0343961641,
0.0328859426,
0.0061001154,
-0.022683816,
0.0618207268,
-0.0082442341,
0.037476752,
0.0471919328,
0.0394336693,
-0.0335728563,
-0.046470087,
-0.0480920337,
-0.0066512586,
-0.0006468782,
-0.0187507719,
0.0160907004,
0.0002916191,
-0.0438044518,
-0.0205416381,
-0.0873391777,
0.0131491218,
-0.0332009047,
0.0390753374,
0.0029161179,
0.0355323851,
-0.0218184832,
-0.0125328545,
0.0181238558,
-0.0385976657,
-0.0303474758,
0.0338356346,
0.0322582833,
0.0163202025,
-0.0344317704,
-0.0156411938,
0.0050148717,
-0.0517133325,
0.0357847214,
-0.0034857152,
-0.0419101156,
-0.0735926256,
0.051596038,
0.012020872,
0.003405334,
0.0080650095,
0.031486962,
0.0139640337,
0.0181166716,
0.0484074205,
0.0532977879,
0.0175153408,
0.0172166862,
-0.0452977084,
-0.0211096741,
-0.0596382283,
0.0401551686,
-0.0148919458,
0.0224007405,
0.018908862,
-0.045536574,
0.0276684072,
0.1159674227,
-0.0032076226,
0.0193151943,
-0.0564965792,
0.0277953465,
-0.005923043,
-0.0050197341,
-0.0230293814,
0.0257647727,
-0.0211565718,
-0.0097280033,
-0.0128112538,
0.0016541759,
0.0929817706,
-0.0407463498,
-0.0158630647,
-0.0170279574,
-0.0166517347,
-0.0610636324,
0.0097948136,
0.0017321556,
-0.0222738516,
0.0831016824,
-0.0878938586,
-0.03754884,
0.0251715984,
-0.0206123255,
0.0103758341,
0.0401521958,
-0.0092914151,
0.00116565,
0.0026563671,
-0.0476611219,
-0.0424453355,
-0.0383203402,
-0.0475195907,
0.0519216843,
0.0113143837,
0.0050667305,
0.0025008654,
0.0480064824,
-0.0109004751,
0.0519753546,
-0.010814162,
-0.024661487,
-0.0318510495,
0.0822206661,
0.0501284711,
0.0166814663,
0.0149200493,
-0.0127782542,
0.0571075976,
-0.0012064801,
-0.013807646,
-0.0119857797,
-0.0126171233,
-0.0006338177,
0.0197416097,
-0.0629814491,
-0.0104141682,
0.0174883623,
0.0510210097,
-0.0330325551,
-0.0174648315,
0.121139586,
0.0112411994,
-0.0313532539,
-0.0152254244,
0.0030114313,
0.0310112946,
0.027858315,
0.0289266054,
-0.0494790114,
-0.0542759895,
0.0309145469,
0.0265082233,
-0.0153522026,
-0.077947326,
-0.0209251195,
-0.1242882162,
0.0136869112,
-0.0491084345,
-0.0652972534,
0.0258785635,
-0.0742466822,
0.031443689,
-0.0289775785,
0.0078028101,
-0.0082960185,
-0.0217272956,
0.0008583603,
0.0165656228,
0.0126239853,
-0.0295608845,
0.0004859211,
-0.0472688563,
0.0663850531,
0.0331454054,
-0.0048507364,
-0.0024105052,
-0.0069540231,
0.0212698467,
-0.080941461,
-0.0003217614,
-0.0251527578,
0.03148764,
-0.0497000217,
-0.0003116144,
-0.024456827,
0.0146885738,
0.00474197,
-0.025778234,
0.0191746652,
0.0520176888,
0.0142385857,
0.0067474847,
-0.0208148751,
-0.0266513042,
0.0576038323,
0.0866064951,
0.0301560424,
-0.0596704222,
-0.0257361475,
-0.0174846966,
0.0023229276,
-0.0229120087,
-0.0050806943,
-0.0247150958,
-0.0047106189,
-0.0242350213,
-0.0110793235,
-0.0317516066,
0.0334319882,
0.0342373513,
-0.0021809225,
0.0051989942,
-0.0155170839,
0.0264790729,
-0.0468090139,
0.0310761351,
0.0095161228,
0.0407227091,
-0.1107328534,
-0.0344459414,
0.0375759229,
0.0013067604,
-0.0489131212,
-0.016099466,
-0.0559763089,
-0.0436146222,
-0.0247860923,
0.0264688432,
0.0066319462,
0.0343184248,
-0.0059517901,
-0.0298109669,
0.0543614402,
0.0801703334,
-0.0565810651,
-0.0092975926,
0.0017349999,
0.0595621429,
-0.0222874768,
0.0180760939,
-0.0365154743,
0.0014331474,
0.0127927754,
0.0655165911,
-0.0294860899,
-0.052880615,
-0.0130227925,
-0.0032918584,
0.0668966025,
-0.0058138231,
-0.0339996256,
-0.0587173328,
0.0190585889,
0.0258470848,
0.0051271031,
-0.0197529141,
-0.0089961831,
-0.0121110771,
0.0063806889,
-0.0221798122,
0.0507228784,
-0.0133256931,
0.0420408398,
-0.0635472685,
0.0209785569,
0.0440347269,
0.0455263928,
0.028562706,
-0.0255677961,
-0.0087199183,
0.0409787782,
0.0550449193,
0.058808025,
-0.0317093432,
0.0713573918,
0.0022880714,
0.0130296163,
-0.0100701423,
0.018344311,
-0.0245962813,
-0.0069320882,
-0.0618562549,
0.04385598,
0.0004122527,
0.0260167494,
0.0025599559,
0.0130344797,
-0.0056623942,
-0.0085088648,
0.0124723455,
0.0123876324,
-0.0166587811,
0.0448647141,
0.0378874838,
-0.0202539768,
0.0075088041,
0.0415570028,
-0.021905018,
0.0235447846,
0.0324319638,
0.0123006357,
-0.0528631173,
0.0162472632,
0.0164367743,
-0.0053814612,
-0.0125784408,
0.0206531305,
-0.0676053613,
-0.0382572263,
0.0712843612,
-0.0257922933,
-0.0130971298,
0.0135588879,
0.021438349,
-0.0005736065,
-0.0081467405,
-0.0322821438,
-0.0307911336,
0.0046540848,
0.0099982806,
-0.0446725488,
-0.0263256673,
-6.252128252e-33,
-0.0608005859,
-0.0128553491,
0.021378953,
-0.049488835,
0.0242512934,
0.0455618575,
-0.0297154933,
-0.0199343115,
0.0216189865,
-0.0421224758,
-0.0277209915,
-0.0101232119,
0.0296723396,
0.0200803168,
-0.0024063538,
-0.0343067721,
0.0898557082,
0.0226328205,
-0.0307618417,
0.0043458287,
0.0110841114,
0.0779104605,
0.0376503244,
-0.0326001495,
0.0279111676,
0.0216098595,
-0.000174921,
0.0215707123,
0.0538175628,
0.0697771534,
-0.0441199839,
0.0181382932,
0.0059279855,
-0.0773938969,
0.0001763204,
0.0551084317,
-0.140592292,
-0.0177094862,
-0.0081495997,
0.0037843117,
-0.0351746455,
-0.0567606613,
-0.0144771077,
-0.0104980431,
0.0137261925,
0.0063065463,
0.037193127,
0.0052854517,
0.0048988517,
-0.0063081007,
-0.0443094783,
0.0366927572,
0.0039690635,
0.0095673017,
0.0209358335,
0.0362763368,
0.0274143051,
0.0118347909,
-0.0815568194,
-0.0096592922,
0.034370441,
-0.0109662628,
0.0232135653,
0.0367913023,
-0.0430776738,
0.0394486189,
0.0539941974,
-0.0214238819,
-0.0179677363,
-0.0046008034,
0.016786797,
0.0137618976,
-0.0220696758,
0.0451997779,
0.0300578177,
-0.0181437284,
-0.0188152697,
0.0206777006,
0.0349736437,
0.0027784258,
0.0179781206,
-0.0372267514,
-0.058835227,
-0.0213575829,
-0.0072374903,
-0.0817525387,
-0.0695560426,
-0.0032446671,
0.05165153,
0.035037037,
-0.0370126143,
-0.0056439908,
0.0548472106,
0.0071041407,
-0.0449627489,
0.0397085398,
0.0187406838,
0.0201027077,
0.0039972416,
0.0328587443,
-0.094311446,
-0.0489384308,
0.0397610255,
-0.0027492838,
0.0150643261,
0.0011807951,
0.0138450256,
0.0097616436,
-0.0925156623,
0.0173996612,
-0.0066035362,
0.0446268357,
-0.0295571778,
0.0213995874,
0.024962062,
-0.0149884308,
-0.0188234057,
0.0570654385,
0.0304544754,
-0.0337817408,
-0.0073045245,
0.0482113361,
0.0085450271,
0.0354345404,
-0.0019738674,
-0.0129695404,
0.0307872426,
0.0314280204,
-0.0071477513,
-0.033138074,
0.0031611731,
0.0021769502,
2.627e-7,
-0.0267031994,
0.0139191132,
0.0005685744,
-0.0119394446,
-0.0056359111,
0.0209828243,
0.0291925147,
0.0405368283,
-0.0126634669,
-0.0099132443,
-0.0016793256,
-0.0285907891,
0.0307575986,
0.0247253813,
-0.1216789633,
-0.0052653099,
-0.0303482786,
0.0461425744,
-0.0892382264,
0.0268289782,
0.0574587546,
0.0829057023,
0.0049606678,
-0.0049651861,
-0.0254353136,
-0.0123421168,
0.0118726892,
0.0139375376,
0.0221306439,
0.016493516,
0.0179246627,
0.0245294198,
-0.0192609187,
0.0298294853,
0.0024627817,
0.0503482744,
-0.0155940661,
0.0637273192,
0.0204314422,
-0.0531262904,
0.0080379946,
-0.0093196379,
-0.0078853434,
-0.0381977335,
0.0885652229,
-0.0489831045,
0.0062084366,
0.0149351675,
-0.0395970345,
-0.0177203659,
-0.0032694747,
-0.026857499,
-0.0279675685,
0.0216306578,
0.0251328088,
-0.0226053111,
-0.0167924836,
-0.0691650212,
0.0161849018,
0.0175502431,
-0.0095892632,
-0.0344286151,
-0.0250967145,
-0.0148150176,
-0.0021921452,
-0.0791081712,
0.0218290295,
2.643545368e-34,
0.0089567807,
0.0119626988,
-0.0297798105,
0.0561935827,
0.0151777016,
-0.0187036898,
-0.0252654664,
-0.0102725718,
0.0360407755,
-0.0896169469,
-0.0234422833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18466v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18466v3 | Test-Time Training on Nearest Neighbors for Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T08:03:28 | 2024-02-02T20:28:27 | Moritz Hardt, Yu Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Many recent efforts augment language models with retrieval, by adding
retrieved data to the input context. For this approach to succeed, the
retrieved data must be added at both training and test time. Moreover, as input
length grows linearly with the size of retrieved data, cost in computation and
memory grows quadratically for modern Transformers. To avoid these
complications, we simply fine-tune the model on retrieved data at test time,
using its standard training setup. We build a large-scale distributed index
based on text embeddings of the Pile dataset. For each test input, our system
retrieves its neighbors and fine-tunes the model on their text. Surprisingly,
retrieving and training on as few as 20 neighbors, each for only one gradient
iteration, drastically improves performance across more than 20 language
modeling tasks in the Pile. For example, test-time training with nearest
neighbors significantly narrows the performance gap between a small GPT-2 and a
GPT-Neo model more than 10 times larger. Sufficient index quality and size,
however, are necessary. Our work establishes a first baseline of test-time
training for language modeling. | [
0.0407821424,
0.0905863419,
-0.0047424678,
0.067689538,
-0.0083687846,
0.0209796652,
0.037027292,
0.0361183248,
0.020175064,
-0.0213433057,
-0.0432579219,
-0.0394697301,
-0.0365319438,
-0.0046879109,
0.0326308236,
-0.0153446449,
0.0186651349,
-0.0069661839,
-0.016461093,
-0.0274641775,
0.0073942705,
0.021715086,
0.0159151107,
0.0189101659,
-0.0116107073,
-0.0160533972,
-0.0220436212,
0.0162497796,
0.0044677793,
-0.0245257914,
0.0304459073,
0.0350538529,
0.0440261252,
0.0741654113,
0.0000019254,
0.0071946979,
-0.024911765,
0.0086137587,
-0.019276958,
-0.003609708,
0.0904985219,
-0.0297751836,
-0.0038179345,
0.0332568586,
-0.0301980209,
-0.0868680477,
0.0650677234,
0.0402886458,
0.0369680226,
0.0806531087,
-0.0119602522,
-0.0064905169,
0.0075277607,
-0.0441564918,
-0.0212012641,
-0.0367627069,
0.012827401,
-0.0038642306,
0.0269136243,
0.0505016558,
-0.0031654085,
0.0292649325,
0.0250673834,
0.028359849,
-0.0073917229,
0.0783038884,
-0.0013027521,
0.016471006,
-0.0152926715,
0.0353056826,
-0.0480211712,
-0.0349156708,
-0.0128119756,
0.0092766145,
-0.0585947782,
0.0217872094,
-0.0147970263,
0.001292774,
0.0105369361,
0.0356794894,
-0.0077739311,
-0.0030625989,
0.0505754016,
0.0192078911,
-0.0304003712,
0.015366531,
0.036412742,
-0.0504149906,
0.0037004757,
0.0050194226,
-0.0041514239,
-0.0154995453,
-0.0017080621,
0.009132769,
-0.0201872457,
0.014233646,
0.0207840148,
-0.0401807055,
0.0221229568,
-0.0322897211,
0.0539939478,
0.0156072844,
-0.0340467766,
0.061328128,
-0.0167300999,
0.0342052057,
-0.0196496155,
-0.0006160691,
-0.0435403697,
-0.0208951756,
-0.043834053,
-0.007577857,
-0.0748074651,
0.0168859605,
-0.0008466504,
-0.0119657703,
0.0284154024,
0.002244785,
0.0369510651,
-0.0202980302,
0.0270850752,
-0.0047848914,
-0.0767512545,
-0.0384660363,
0.0208853222,
0.0334197842,
-0.030013144,
0.0312838927,
0.0011430221,
-0.0294465404,
-0.0545996092,
-0.0204989612,
0.039367523,
-0.0281677414,
0.0396453589,
0.0187294353,
-0.0112323007,
-0.0746555254,
-0.0061959717,
0.0200673342,
-0.0180379059,
-0.0383433104,
-0.0244765747,
-0.0496170111,
0.0258330051,
-0.0014782775,
0.012305907,
-0.0432365052,
-0.0202725772,
0.0253181439,
-0.0317746587,
0.0491834208,
-0.0100407479,
-0.0020646341,
0.0216637962,
0.0001930656,
0.0133577399,
0.0681826025,
0.019213045,
0.0429020375,
0.0220989697,
-0.0169361364,
-0.0134281907,
0.0441340357,
0.0469620936,
0.0359532498,
-0.044411391,
0.0081237685,
-0.0072889137,
0.0397153907,
0.0162916295,
0.0627404377,
-0.0597368367,
-0.029505793,
0.0430945791,
0.0809758902,
0.043887008,
0.0459226146,
-0.0023048148,
0.0207271334,
-0.0361502431,
-0.0494783409,
-0.0374842025,
0.0184783507,
-0.011697839,
0.0049219923,
0.0443628058,
0.0588542372,
-0.0393314175,
0.0194489509,
-0.0030698087,
-0.0085459901,
-0.0005385018,
-0.0006672482,
0.0446866527,
0.0102294115,
-0.0222147033,
0.0523975343,
0.044143673,
-0.0463466123,
0.0014159807,
-0.0245359205,
0.0269040111,
0.0279785935,
0.0331747271,
-0.0312416311,
-0.0197129175,
-0.0079714973,
0.0159191955,
0.0481212474,
0.0204507615,
-0.0141603099,
0.0163980201,
-0.0462402776,
-0.0121577028,
0.0383606702,
0.0178904179,
0.0329092406,
0.0294182077,
0.0093766386,
0.0332535133,
-0.0620310716,
-0.0151308253,
0.0263368897,
-0.056140244,
-0.0303254705,
-0.0029778287,
0.0075210528,
0.0192748569,
0.0043021766,
-0.048483368,
-0.0157137644,
0.0565129407,
-0.0384647362,
-0.0282773878,
-0.0262839422,
-0.0423064828,
-0.0387940556,
0.041215267,
0.0040505868,
0.0130729582,
0.0700928047,
-0.0501188077,
-0.0212972909,
0.0029422992,
-0.0233679991,
0.05556456,
-0.0634996593,
-0.0227962639,
-0.0238345414,
0.0065756328,
-0.0431064703,
0.0512598492,
-0.0137667004,
0.0465653352,
-0.0268886071,
-0.0049764873,
0.0317069963,
-0.0192011185,
-0.0440808013,
0.0145165818,
0.0096254293,
0.0319115929,
0.044209443,
0.0191068761,
-0.025276551,
-0.0612556487,
-0.1288890839,
0.0184525084,
-0.0352183916,
0.021038672,
0.0114051551,
0.0331615359,
-0.0082570529,
-0.047302857,
-0.0433682427,
-0.0142849116,
-0.0033995111,
0.0441823974,
-0.0021219915,
0.0200846437,
-0.0149821118,
-0.0269064438,
-0.0426962785,
0.013556716,
0.0536655486,
-0.0310750809,
-0.0115842242,
-0.039348904,
0.0188522357,
-0.0288786702,
0.0338212252,
-0.0073597282,
-0.0468689874,
0.0011497607,
-0.0506598167,
0.0134864831,
0.0354864299,
0.0203788504,
0.0022087484,
0.0029316295,
0.01256302,
-0.0743981153,
-0.0021898269,
-0.0522871055,
-0.0316082574,
-0.043802321,
0.0031026688,
-0.0389440879,
0.0674782097,
-0.0235441923,
-0.0289018359,
-0.0540580936,
0.0063726166,
-0.0291357655,
0.0250170082,
-0.0304490346,
0.021476252,
-0.0068739583,
-0.017151773,
-0.0298521891,
-0.0484034568,
0.0848678276,
-0.0357167386,
-0.0192485545,
-0.0438363701,
-0.057447087,
-0.0278069675,
0.0544044077,
0.0107346047,
0.0206575487,
-0.0262434594,
-0.0254350789,
-0.0372710079,
0.0300641581,
0.0092177885,
-0.0439150557,
0.0235529151,
0.0130725047,
0.0424942896,
-0.0198440552,
-0.0861391723,
-0.0339044333,
-0.0641112849,
-0.0082882047,
0.0034390355,
0.0076513169,
-0.0387789235,
0.0048651914,
0.0289796684,
0.0100471843,
0.080980055,
-0.0159471761,
-0.0004147142,
-0.0204110369,
0.0091059422,
0.0451830514,
0.0185448322,
-0.0014048866,
-0.007572995,
0.0177953411,
0.039905414,
0.0880831927,
-0.0308574457,
-0.0715411901,
0.0142008709,
0.0134333977,
-0.0073013576,
-0.0133514265,
-0.0016416464,
-0.009706296,
-0.0348136835,
-0.0478517599,
0.1037175357,
0.0101447897,
-0.0977963284,
-0.0223043021,
0.0244029947,
0.0454143733,
0.0267519634,
0.0457688905,
-0.0577307194,
-0.0114688091,
0.0125787407,
0.0162721295,
0.0354267135,
-0.0210825168,
-0.0068148058,
-0.1224418879,
0.0138560152,
0.0176189765,
-0.0275165346,
-0.0287771095,
-0.0362616293,
-0.0233272333,
0.0021583161,
0.0312238168,
0.0441582762,
-0.002980985,
0.0036308786,
0.0496975072,
0.0512966886,
-0.0385085866,
0.0364527591,
-0.0465503819,
0.0488578379,
0.0392737314,
0.0080457162,
0.0060178018,
-0.0203866307,
0.0211583991,
0.0141911488,
-0.0025370941,
0.0048121531,
0.0427056625,
-0.0249402616,
-0.0135339238,
0.0256914049,
-0.0043359376,
-0.0259765275,
0.029359052,
0.0066139032,
0.1026313603,
0.0064134006,
0.0013221184,
0.0133394711,
-0.0374771617,
0.0240830872,
0.0290499777,
0.0090964707,
-0.0216189101,
-0.0055639264,
-0.0059345714,
0.0275092032,
0.0331287496,
-0.0418241061,
0.0072940546,
-0.0093986392,
-0.0018352756,
-0.0525281578,
-0.0373006016,
0.011204049,
0.0737683773,
0.0115669807,
-0.014666914,
0.0103836823,
-0.0096706543,
-0.0659542531,
0.0435612239,
-0.0452916324,
-0.0006390387,
-0.048289787,
0.0077840164,
0.0616938248,
-0.010641803,
-0.0386035889,
-0.0173419435,
-0.0976240039,
-0.0528399348,
0.0006160937,
0.0208019931,
0.0196187291,
0.0415654629,
-0.0065388163,
-0.0675915182,
0.0577265322,
0.0316791162,
-0.0909586474,
0.011481653,
0.0381205939,
-0.072778888,
0.0025449481,
0.0352394395,
-0.0634360164,
0.0556407087,
0.0006836001,
0.0260026455,
-0.0213525333,
-0.026213523,
0.0098494897,
-0.0044888933,
0.0975405723,
0.0176163558,
-0.0172905549,
-0.0480602942,
0.0533795021,
-0.0062376936,
-0.0102104219,
-0.0424920507,
-0.0045594606,
0.0297485627,
-0.0191308558,
-0.0365689658,
-0.003570776,
0.0331963263,
0.0633428842,
-0.0129107889,
-0.0281077977,
-0.0180776939,
0.0115599716,
0.0659680292,
0.0215302296,
-0.0302163661,
-0.0262705162,
0.0049612927,
0.0304690897,
-0.0439497977,
0.0196558908,
0.0477966852,
-0.01408708,
-0.0271869116,
0.022841692,
-0.0730692297,
-0.0644371957,
-0.0504315384,
-0.0258812588,
0.0530209951,
-0.0271612983,
0.0242433306,
-0.0256525129,
0.0080792848,
-0.0228347797,
-0.000923417,
0.0092653586,
-0.0718976483,
0.0287058596,
0.0201653969,
-0.0140898647,
0.0439246595,
0.0803691298,
0.02409417,
0.0210346021,
0.0119593507,
0.0017564492,
-0.0252420362,
-0.0176778696,
0.0029745055,
0.0168744698,
-0.0180977155,
0.0017464417,
-0.0087396391,
-0.0725970343,
0.032751739,
-0.0071961619,
-0.026243465,
-0.0274674352,
0.0284435079,
0.0286431611,
-0.0096085062,
0.0116844857,
-0.0229522828,
0.0135976905,
-0.0102659389,
-0.0352736302,
-0.0242139846,
-6.472033123e-33,
-0.0142116845,
-0.0028507966,
0.030648537,
-0.0357601829,
-0.0324378051,
0.0211652685,
-0.0222198572,
-0.0104878386,
-0.0138516603,
0.0207415409,
-0.0455372781,
0.0460438877,
0.006912142,
0.0416761152,
-0.0107089374,
-0.0063728699,
0.0499035604,
-0.0318098627,
0.0090731177,
0.0446009561,
0.0203876644,
0.0576015711,
0.0690344945,
-0.0477789305,
-0.0483651608,
0.0071080779,
-0.0040240344,
0.0286012962,
0.0095247654,
0.0252658129,
-0.0374725163,
0.0250914786,
0.001222342,
-0.0610583834,
-0.0189521499,
-0.0094043575,
-0.0642793551,
-0.0121492073,
-0.0488574095,
-0.0011562525,
-0.0035366497,
0.0357777365,
-0.0030590179,
-0.016310405,
0.0146015985,
0.0063643376,
0.0039522476,
-0.0251911562,
-0.0629944354,
0.0052217199,
-0.009131778,
0.0286101941,
0.019011179,
-0.0017696759,
0.0628615767,
0.0067500193,
0.0272981841,
0.0157267395,
-0.0434632115,
-0.0114929155,
-0.0058108228,
0.0710818768,
0.000703401,
0.0166442543,
0.0254885908,
0.0833739787,
0.0393208899,
-0.0233401638,
-0.00316512,
-0.0353591442,
0.0591954626,
-0.0048121945,
0.025169678,
0.0427195206,
0.0611489899,
-0.0296392906,
-0.0586412847,
-0.014851951,
0.0293580871,
0.0317794904,
0.0447721966,
0.0185252372,
-0.0426382832,
-0.022421984,
-0.0360338911,
0.0027290685,
-0.039335575,
-0.0416168384,
0.0208238624,
0.060966555,
-0.0283761006,
-0.0145938415,
0.035192132,
-0.0535881668,
-0.0351713859,
0.0578087121,
-0.018481968,
-0.0010127573,
-0.012349382,
0.0424717516,
-0.0537468046,
-0.0530325323,
-0.01395634,
-0.0102711394,
-0.0053957095,
-0.0090356432,
0.0391188823,
0.0498283841,
-0.0860099643,
-0.0118817985,
-0.0330302194,
0.0111824078,
-0.0157131143,
0.0261533335,
0.0298145059,
0.0159669723,
0.0307838023,
0.0644693077,
0.0458236448,
0.0009203676,
-0.0208066422,
0.0247066952,
0.0114969453,
-0.007804479,
-0.0013356043,
0.0096238712,
-0.0502962656,
0.0196566544,
0.032841716,
-0.0492158607,
0.0171158183,
0.038295038,
2.649e-7,
0.0251197573,
0.0573424622,
0.0399130881,
-0.0070451214,
0.0234947335,
0.015303609,
-0.027212346,
0.0560016371,
0.053183794,
0.0234686527,
0.020491628,
0.0030328925,
0.0729209185,
0.0372029431,
-0.1403026283,
-0.0020191553,
-0.0891803056,
0.0211831667,
-0.0498277731,
-0.0389852114,
-0.0155652734,
0.1393834502,
0.0181052797,
0.001569506,
0.0090687862,
-0.0598824881,
0.0693313703,
-0.0392518044,
0.0108050872,
-0.0121010719,
0.0195450038,
0.0290814657,
-0.0029040333,
-0.0203199238,
-0.0064578126,
0.0486042276,
0.0047349446,
0.0393876918,
-0.0055967709,
-0.0071900771,
0.0087752072,
-0.0324142985,
-0.0187203884,
-0.0142200161,
0.0404101461,
-0.0334808081,
0.0142709557,
-0.0435096771,
-0.0076193796,
-0.0360050686,
-0.0087814601,
-0.0293981936,
-0.0279208198,
0.0317655839,
0.0287787691,
-0.0207165685,
0.0086512016,
-0.1062467471,
-0.0216597784,
0.0211630631,
-0.0471076146,
-0.0260747764,
-0.0391308405,
-0.0012027629,
0.0225697421,
-0.0310959276,
0.0169174168,
2.57849071e-34,
0.0459736995,
-0.0193531085,
0.0132579291,
0.027748825,
0.034557987,
-0.0318453386,
0.031253811,
0.0098299477,
0.0002012894,
-0.0995317921,
-0.0228646472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17926v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17926v2 | Large Language Models are not Fair Evaluators | 2023-05-29T07:41:03 | 2023-08-30T13:22:35 | Peiyi Wang, Lei Li, Liang Chen, Zefan Cai, Dawei Zhu, Binghuai Lin, Yunbo Cao, Qi Liu, Tianyu Liu, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | In this paper, we uncover a systematic bias in the evaluation paradigm of
adopting large language models~(LLMs), e.g., GPT-4, as a referee to score and
compare the quality of responses generated by candidate models. We find that
the quality ranking of candidate responses can be easily hacked by simply
altering their order of appearance in the context. This manipulation allows us
to skew the evaluation result, making one model appear considerably superior to
the other, e.g., Vicuna-13B could beat ChatGPT on 66 over 80 tested queries
with ChatGPT as an evaluator. To address this issue, we propose a calibration
framework with three simple yet effective strategies: 1) Multiple Evidence
Calibration, which requires the evaluator model to generate multiple evaluation
evidence before assigning ratings; 2) Balanced Position Calibration, which
aggregates results across various orders to determine the final score; 3)
Human-in-the-Loop Calibration, which introduces a balanced position diversity
entropy to measure the difficulty of each example and seeks human assistance
when needed. We also manually annotate the "win/tie/lose" outcomes of responses
from ChatGPT and Vicuna-13B in the Vicuna Benchmark's question prompt, and
extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach successfully mitigates
evaluation bias, resulting in closer alignment with human judgments. We release
our code and human annotation at \url{https://github.com/i-Eval/FairEval} to
facilitate future research. | [
0.0525909737,
0.0589639917,
-0.0127542643,
0.0408033766,
-0.045351956,
0.0044217855,
0.0190330632,
0.0010802971,
0.0039015245,
-0.0805548057,
-0.0360079259,
-0.0516150258,
0.0144982114,
0.0050171465,
0.0288430303,
-0.0551058315,
0.0155256558,
-0.0270122867,
0.0272530913,
-0.0234301221,
0.0096803131,
-0.0251534041,
0.0062415092,
0.0479569249,
0.0452389382,
-0.0099997278,
0.0089011844,
-0.0051990282,
-0.0034408222,
-0.0282758921,
0.008474377,
0.0881771743,
-0.055317428,
0.0581816882,
0.0000019844,
-0.0473356619,
-0.0124944951,
0.0147886993,
-0.0220528841,
0.0483040176,
0.0460842401,
0.0388583206,
0.0122803971,
0.0587237068,
-0.0598739237,
-0.0377563536,
0.047085017,
-0.007242382,
0.0654156879,
0.0471124984,
0.0180779025,
-0.0008013845,
-0.0016052665,
-0.037906494,
0.001285397,
-0.0554189645,
-0.0121559659,
0.0144419074,
0.0082635647,
0.0290101226,
-0.0130660385,
0.0075672376,
0.0185921304,
-0.0164757576,
0.0060266643,
0.0116243763,
-0.0770421177,
0.0018711477,
0.0062400377,
0.0605007708,
0.0091895927,
-0.0143919261,
-0.0254947171,
-0.0164710972,
0.0396475047,
0.0151611576,
-0.0523287356,
0.0069989595,
0.0180276185,
-0.0157039631,
0.0012974165,
0.0210962407,
0.0347225778,
0.0151463021,
-0.0047924253,
0.0841177702,
0.0180012137,
-0.0385289602,
0.009415688,
0.0264153667,
-0.0248795152,
-0.0419408828,
-0.0038563944,
0.001945115,
-0.0568978637,
0.0123644508,
-0.0044728839,
0.0043998319,
0.0456849597,
-0.0557111949,
0.0103279185,
0.0336065255,
-0.0048741694,
0.0525670685,
0.0241182987,
0.0609268025,
0.004100441,
0.0185502525,
-0.0654163882,
-0.0157275256,
-0.0247636363,
0.0013858499,
0.021118924,
-0.0080891429,
-0.0303686224,
0.0231024958,
-0.0598074645,
0.006791411,
-0.0338903144,
-0.0100573888,
0.030080447,
0.0059672538,
0.0077312719,
0.0127215181,
-0.0431631766,
0.0368251354,
-0.0239559356,
0.0202397276,
0.0052397619,
-0.091777958,
0.0143025089,
0.0242984258,
-0.0278173499,
-0.0337179713,
0.0297810491,
0.0500350483,
0.0301910862,
-0.0219392497,
0.0261961147,
-0.0166217517,
-0.0121154496,
-0.0605999827,
-0.0180486478,
-0.0747137815,
0.0156807657,
0.0366533659,
-0.0042724698,
-0.0069141411,
-0.0180967357,
0.0229641553,
-0.0203047413,
0.0642066151,
0.0020151497,
0.0079485094,
0.012783519,
0.0179964621,
-0.038263768,
0.0951860398,
0.0107942447,
0.0227203835,
0.0375830941,
-0.0245462172,
0.014331677,
0.0425144024,
-0.0141465552,
0.0235343631,
0.0026339348,
0.0459987819,
0.0098303352,
0.025850879,
-0.0031898036,
0.0767646134,
-0.013794573,
-0.0007670785,
0.0687456802,
0.031436868,
0.0094209472,
-0.0120025855,
0.0063957032,
-0.0032374198,
0.011466518,
0.0236737803,
-0.0730435327,
0.0089351945,
-0.0305514857,
-0.0045606531,
0.0581300035,
0.0191913936,
-0.008778153,
-0.062196169,
-0.0121862618,
0.0402717106,
-0.0033003474,
0.0347277671,
0.0098715918,
-0.0297014248,
-0.014963326,
0.0185402259,
0.0114187011,
-0.0444384404,
0.0085295606,
-0.0545972772,
0.0037389179,
0.0485422872,
0.0627526045,
-0.0150869135,
-0.0015943208,
0.0099016111,
-0.0148286177,
0.0250531659,
0.0965409577,
-0.013450698,
-0.0213606115,
-0.0378491059,
-0.0579759702,
0.0133390585,
0.0180241279,
0.0041615958,
0.0151844379,
-0.0036943459,
0.0074878917,
-0.0596753843,
-0.0370589532,
0.0128915552,
0.039778728,
-0.0289421659,
-0.0091444533,
-0.0125360014,
0.0403042175,
0.0184004568,
-0.0099613909,
0.0475286506,
0.0143294968,
-0.0017044743,
-0.0065102801,
-0.0207939725,
-0.0222865045,
-0.0155357197,
0.0400373936,
-0.05023361,
-0.016337309,
0.0337616205,
-0.0374246053,
-0.0410763547,
-0.006275882,
-0.0177308079,
0.0251954347,
-0.0291170906,
0.0200883858,
-0.0339680202,
-0.0211470146,
-0.069729723,
0.0731548741,
0.0047659767,
0.061742913,
-0.0121969301,
-0.0104162078,
0.0117870048,
-0.0398926139,
-0.0575805455,
0.0079206917,
-0.0033867608,
0.0448343493,
0.043715544,
0.0225402396,
-0.0603625514,
-0.0235338695,
-0.1399446279,
0.0031611719,
-0.0335773677,
0.0300507862,
0.0231804233,
0.012529905,
-0.0002694621,
0.0079571027,
-0.0858379677,
-0.0448634699,
0.015355573,
0.0583106875,
0.0176647343,
0.0057642376,
-0.0151931979,
-0.0519169159,
-0.043466758,
-0.0352982581,
0.0538764782,
0.0208804216,
0.0499413311,
-0.0376902372,
0.0115368217,
-0.0209951233,
0.0077894162,
0.0019314871,
-0.0323223211,
0.0206200704,
-0.0154851442,
0.0030073721,
0.0590682067,
0.0195598081,
-0.0162906833,
0.0594191588,
0.0175124817,
-0.0699309036,
-0.0113893496,
0.0052542565,
-0.0071589919,
-0.0100656012,
-0.0339270309,
-0.0000143117,
0.0361591801,
0.0043018912,
-0.0081125656,
-0.0431113392,
0.0457373559,
-0.0431695841,
-0.0255634226,
-0.0638937429,
-0.0012647093,
-0.0218754262,
0.0315990373,
-0.0128877219,
-0.042323187,
0.055151809,
-0.0480254441,
0.0076997741,
-0.0625353754,
0.0107999416,
-0.0422844179,
0.0573611557,
0.0067735091,
0.0162009541,
0.0018107097,
-0.0104807653,
-0.0631482154,
-0.0144133661,
0.0626988113,
-0.070343554,
0.0498927347,
-0.0440093726,
-0.0042955712,
-0.0180486981,
-0.0621764623,
-0.0327487402,
-0.0519241989,
-0.0312066823,
0.0137700606,
0.0578238554,
-0.0001904698,
-0.0244824812,
0.0191590954,
0.0086240517,
0.0222012028,
-0.0390668139,
-0.0019049007,
0.0009551342,
0.0398649015,
0.0557987876,
0.0223614611,
0.0387842916,
-0.0160606951,
0.0138233025,
0.053742066,
0.06479913,
0.0026809559,
0.0036325622,
-0.003437032,
0.0414491482,
-0.0430055149,
-0.0290680565,
0.0226183534,
0.0364005789,
-0.0356441401,
-0.0017051075,
0.1197986677,
0.0254554525,
-0.0565603487,
-0.0006025074,
-0.0197158009,
0.0334952585,
0.0385950096,
0.0223171096,
-0.069935672,
-0.0189312603,
0.0161121022,
0.0569889955,
-0.0268079937,
-0.020335909,
0.0061889086,
-0.1511536241,
0.0269496031,
-0.0028146482,
-0.0224610213,
-0.0018682126,
-0.0523217544,
-0.0005017883,
-0.0491048954,
0.0519639254,
0.0342058167,
0.014287998,
0.03528722,
0.0187981706,
-0.0107663348,
-0.0410298631,
0.0627571493,
-0.0565265007,
0.0749380589,
0.0584334061,
-0.0017077051,
-0.023804225,
-0.0233921837,
0.0351458527,
-0.0414664485,
-0.0223678537,
0.0061729713,
0.0408547185,
0.0119855599,
-0.0066340771,
-0.0340633914,
-0.0187382828,
-0.0204921942,
0.0436351225,
0.0220672302,
0.0551707856,
0.0105548576,
0.0065103001,
-0.0164615884,
-0.0235515554,
-0.0145359291,
0.0873962417,
0.0358230434,
-0.0379609577,
-0.0383467227,
-0.0510380194,
-0.0175238866,
-0.0174737424,
-0.0521933399,
0.0406029262,
0.024030298,
-0.026598854,
-0.0429796427,
-0.0640093908,
0.0019594776,
0.0400546454,
0.0065698917,
0.0201508943,
-0.0079902923,
0.0108626662,
-0.0102211954,
0.0341499858,
-0.0454083681,
0.0206588712,
-0.0478591025,
0.0159596298,
0.0106775062,
-0.0048528109,
-0.0302696787,
0.030271627,
-0.0446136147,
-0.0592811927,
0.0084013417,
0.0487183891,
0.0325436033,
-0.0105337361,
-0.0383673273,
-0.061340306,
0.0043958379,
0.034367241,
-0.0452393927,
-0.0032297745,
0.0122922305,
-0.0418919884,
0.0000100323,
0.0282615907,
-0.0646376759,
-0.0042754048,
0.012817366,
0.0455227345,
-0.0010119174,
-0.0531913154,
0.050567545,
0.0459250323,
0.0581515469,
-0.012161186,
-0.0184613075,
0.0189754777,
0.0038543576,
-0.0331886113,
-0.0497826524,
-0.0112992376,
-0.0047511235,
0.0270524938,
0.0017849903,
-0.0038860168,
0.0157672595,
-0.0056347465,
0.0339004546,
-0.0753103867,
0.0149558606,
0.0268510599,
0.0080140345,
0.0079667224,
-0.0232280046,
-0.0274499096,
-0.0045711766,
0.013743747,
0.0508988649,
-0.0024304218,
0.0283700656,
0.0001222801,
-0.0098346891,
0.01576069,
0.0464842469,
-0.0989435986,
-0.0456177481,
-0.0117875878,
0.0301919375,
0.0553453341,
0.0055645569,
0.0353072286,
0.0196725409,
-0.0036967658,
-0.0273767356,
-0.0322250091,
0.0239229333,
-0.004952454,
0.0391985551,
0.0353345834,
-0.0127504924,
0.0011852174,
0.0728777424,
0.004560688,
0.0178992506,
0.0021703932,
-0.0279752295,
-0.0252191313,
-0.0452741906,
-0.0111618917,
0.0226187296,
-0.0368123911,
-0.0310788285,
-0.0784971491,
-0.062403053,
-0.0474553145,
0.0395944752,
0.0214236081,
-0.0021165388,
0.0331536271,
0.0987196043,
-0.0164504182,
-0.0282133911,
-0.0626979321,
0.0213829875,
-0.0214422215,
-0.0105729681,
-0.0136871049,
-6.703359391e-33,
-0.0054025236,
-0.0208808016,
0.0013998424,
-0.0294785164,
0.018441204,
-0.0067388732,
-0.0029987346,
0.0255026836,
-0.0482384972,
0.0048964452,
-0.0287978332,
0.0070897862,
0.0194739942,
-0.0034545332,
0.0215179231,
-0.043478746,
0.0272312351,
0.0018308164,
-0.0587898456,
0.0103739556,
-0.0065375911,
-0.0193465129,
0.0274725873,
-0.0573187582,
0.0685178712,
-0.0083733331,
-0.0190404262,
0.0237046406,
-0.0228300728,
0.0745954737,
0.0053571761,
0.0602105632,
0.0304326024,
-0.0586351827,
-0.0015928597,
-0.0174753703,
-0.0388047881,
-0.0182252359,
0.046745345,
0.0123931803,
-0.0067992662,
-0.012478522,
0.0593971051,
-0.0128373113,
-0.0603215955,
-0.001796053,
0.0224738698,
-0.0255760122,
-0.0103894435,
-0.0151446257,
0.0019777257,
0.0286933836,
-0.0122940615,
-0.0086863805,
-0.0294888187,
0.0479541309,
0.0094974609,
0.0243176762,
-0.044100713,
0.0247101467,
0.0151207084,
0.0565395057,
0.0772371218,
0.0007799436,
-0.0210446231,
0.0482572578,
0.01648454,
0.0118118674,
0.0137855196,
-0.0450101905,
0.007154827,
0.0046220981,
0.0821328461,
0.0660961568,
0.0409661122,
0.0074486234,
-0.0729578435,
0.0550670736,
0.0194787178,
0.0070170634,
0.0242274739,
0.0095504718,
-0.0919445828,
-0.0266574472,
-0.0522579253,
-0.0275443532,
-0.0646230429,
-0.0201092605,
0.0444686301,
-0.0120546594,
-0.0241895802,
-0.0424477942,
0.029438654,
-0.056540411,
-0.0138112856,
0.0285769925,
-0.0047327266,
0.0131582823,
0.0003171763,
0.0305155702,
-0.0135537386,
0.001639015,
0.0011353208,
0.0300045926,
0.0032560909,
0.0117309559,
-0.0075368877,
0.0003015331,
-0.0610130988,
-0.0066295597,
-0.0357377157,
0.0044806874,
-0.0108012222,
-0.0076095886,
0.0304938257,
-0.0089668669,
0.0086636143,
0.0304980092,
0.0300008506,
0.0291778613,
-0.0525722653,
-0.0183755755,
-0.0059805638,
-0.0146189081,
-0.0122921802,
-0.0102538457,
0.0011596535,
-0.00913205,
0.0249203872,
-0.0226109903,
-0.0160948206,
-0.0150929568,
2.655e-7,
0.0673044622,
0.047033295,
-0.0161197297,
0.015817482,
0.0037101391,
0.0591267236,
-0.0067728907,
0.035614565,
0.0337754115,
-0.013470483,
-0.0113443667,
-0.0074123731,
0.0337043069,
0.038837146,
-0.0658715144,
-0.019338306,
-0.0752770826,
-0.0128970547,
-0.016889384,
-0.0047447705,
0.0492055602,
0.1195780858,
-0.0053695142,
-0.00719713,
-0.0207342878,
-0.0780741349,
0.0296757221,
-0.0257395823,
-0.0403552949,
0.0392944925,
0.0810559615,
-0.0007638266,
0.0407920144,
0.0300344937,
0.0067744348,
0.0080984291,
0.0186271835,
0.0561616048,
0.0208182503,
-0.0106716668,
-0.0250648856,
-0.0585896298,
0.0309134871,
-0.10255941,
0.0818763822,
0.0106267855,
-0.0297284964,
-0.0282503087,
-0.0261229202,
-0.0399054177,
0.0567317717,
-0.0073395362,
-0.0371021666,
0.0100207841,
0.0003532367,
-0.0016041258,
-0.0105162226,
-0.0281014778,
-0.0668088049,
-0.0116362236,
-0.0185954347,
-0.0898400769,
-0.0081434222,
-0.0027585775,
-0.0035159902,
-0.0491788685,
0.0150282048,
2.648337804e-34,
0.0701495484,
-0.0053997529,
0.0413626172,
0.0055873026,
0.0510709025,
0.0317359641,
-0.0148752155,
-0.00340213,
0.0258470047,
-0.0922741964,
-0.0166890938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18462v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18462v2 | Membership Inference Attacks against Language Models via Neighbourhood Comparison | 2023-05-29T07:06:03 | 2023-08-07T06:32:56 | Justus Mattern, Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah, Zhijing Jin, Bernhard Schölkopf, Mrinmaya Sachan, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Membership Inference attacks (MIAs) aim to predict whether a data sample was
present in the training data of a machine learning model or not, and are widely
used for assessing the privacy risks of language models. Most existing attacks
rely on the observation that models tend to assign higher probabilities to
their training samples than non-training points. However, simple thresholding
of the model score in isolation tends to lead to high false-positive rates as
it does not account for the intrinsic complexity of a sample. Recent work has
demonstrated that reference-based attacks which compare model scores to those
obtained from a reference model trained on similar data can substantially
improve the performance of MIAs. However, in order to train reference models,
attacks of this kind make the strong and arguably unrealistic assumption that
an adversary has access to samples closely resembling the original training
data. Therefore, we investigate their performance in more realistic scenarios
and find that they are highly fragile in relation to the data distribution used
to train reference models. To investigate whether this fragility provides a
layer of safety, we propose and evaluate neighbourhood attacks, which compare
model scores for a given sample to scores of synthetically generated neighbour
texts and therefore eliminate the need for access to the training data
distribution. We show that, in addition to being competitive with
reference-based attacks that have perfect knowledge about the training data
distribution, our attack clearly outperforms existing reference-free attacks as
well as reference-based attacks with imperfect knowledge, which demonstrates
the need for a reevaluation of the threat model of adversarial attacks. | [
0.0253808834,
0.1034361497,
-0.0201682504,
0.0670876056,
-0.0449175797,
0.0086808158,
0.0352177508,
0.0061072293,
0.0221146122,
-0.0260838699,
-0.0360186063,
-0.0173045918,
0.0127496347,
-0.0103977257,
0.0574964844,
0.01374235,
0.0213288758,
-0.0213397797,
-0.0123312548,
-0.0611347631,
-0.0285397433,
-0.0165454373,
0.0287102982,
0.0161061138,
0.0030649414,
0.0147043038,
0.020460736,
-0.0047193076,
0.02278658,
-0.008265161,
0.0139939254,
0.0590346046,
0.0032914698,
0.0790898427,
0.000001854,
-0.0067407554,
-0.0572204925,
0.0539795011,
-0.016580414,
-0.0006929985,
0.0131183658,
0.0074118571,
0.0214498695,
0.0148572745,
-0.0162522141,
0.0013165767,
0.0292135905,
0.0327120423,
0.0262671318,
0.0956050307,
-0.011771665,
-0.0054948949,
0.001637482,
-0.0397980474,
-0.0075857281,
-0.03753791,
0.0240947083,
-0.0121889971,
-0.0315972082,
0.0158781968,
0.0169412829,
0.0366252996,
0.0017936144,
0.0349013805,
-0.029675981,
0.0459064916,
-0.0165178236,
-0.0094176391,
0.0503234491,
0.0271799378,
-0.0287716985,
-0.0181754623,
0.0104066348,
0.0159897171,
0.0347895771,
0.0456593931,
-0.002287874,
0.0185013693,
-0.0183736589,
0.0077016139,
0.0084894737,
0.0032323464,
0.0674901977,
0.0050790301,
-0.014031997,
0.0277160965,
0.0162295792,
0.0064212829,
-0.0081091458,
-0.0324515812,
-0.0163703449,
-0.0301508661,
0.0141243124,
-0.0236951727,
0.0435468219,
0.0161078554,
-0.094269596,
-0.014393555,
0.0298634656,
-0.0508979447,
0.0506201573,
-0.0093082096,
-0.0072592902,
0.0531923361,
-0.0049762693,
0.0158820432,
0.0005677405,
0.030770734,
-0.014710987,
0.0062960689,
-0.0194772687,
-0.0164954849,
0.0288316682,
0.02336674,
-0.0078070634,
0.0082951644,
-0.0243332274,
0.0095484331,
-0.0368003808,
0.0511188805,
-0.0545410626,
0.002471834,
-0.0207784958,
-0.0053444263,
0.0184266325,
-0.0533363037,
-0.0083812,
0.0069321129,
-0.025495572,
-0.0947043672,
-0.0407283716,
-0.0010154515,
-0.0309217814,
0.0018219439,
-0.0190388355,
0.094713293,
0.0461577252,
-0.0648119822,
-0.0170966163,
-0.0662062243,
-0.0085603585,
-0.0530878045,
0.0021609184,
-0.0565822758,
-0.0037676848,
-0.0058563096,
-0.0190708674,
-0.0861843526,
-0.00344826,
0.0000983799,
-0.0377687514,
0.0685325116,
-0.0015337538,
-0.004062613,
-0.0138955917,
0.0278942622,
-0.012288603,
0.050979618,
0.0015550624,
0.0118949236,
0.0468904041,
0.0195176229,
0.0450513288,
0.02581276,
0.0486987643,
0.031772431,
-0.0175484978,
0.021723859,
0.0209108349,
-0.0539634749,
-0.0617226735,
0.0527800582,
-0.0198895894,
-0.0807422176,
0.1071154699,
0.0565214008,
-0.0531307794,
0.016691288,
-0.0297200717,
-0.0134729585,
-0.0043973457,
0.016415447,
-0.0829820931,
-0.0442650989,
-0.0922834352,
-0.0465553254,
0.0307526812,
-0.0065433281,
-0.0053187031,
-0.0190105028,
-0.0122604221,
-0.008790154,
0.0084164208,
0.0193339214,
0.0036959711,
0.0324463286,
0.0332801603,
0.0533246025,
0.0355899669,
-0.0369936973,
0.0074144593,
-0.050612852,
0.0072037755,
-0.0198066831,
0.0462887883,
-0.0409669578,
0.0362432152,
-0.0206516776,
-0.0178345703,
-0.0132363578,
0.044423867,
0.0104120094,
0.0504823327,
-0.0064154132,
-0.0124960123,
-0.0260880403,
0.0460389182,
0.0290897563,
0.0416964851,
-0.0299757272,
0.0058543435,
-0.0642023608,
-0.0380418077,
0.0216252804,
-0.0072695417,
-0.0262643062,
0.0218850728,
0.0135647589,
0.0213306546,
0.0077471384,
-0.0480980016,
0.0101329377,
0.0416063555,
0.0127274012,
0.0030950468,
-0.0217927825,
0.0257424377,
-0.0110348407,
-0.0129079474,
-0.0233834796,
0.0088584144,
0.0415628999,
-0.0298062377,
0.011805403,
0.0143358437,
-0.0347063802,
0.0144349765,
0.0125542246,
0.0010088949,
-0.0265248548,
0.0581202246,
-0.0252895132,
0.0680249259,
-0.0410597175,
0.0214476977,
-0.009767795,
-0.0117420601,
0.022910418,
-0.0420962572,
-0.0510839671,
-0.0210160594,
-0.0331553593,
-0.0008420077,
0.0004794357,
-0.0402453691,
0.0020330716,
-0.0268158074,
-0.0152690336,
-0.0192921944,
-0.0126209436,
0.0288754757,
0.0040565045,
-0.0051475759,
-0.0340808854,
-0.0457006358,
-0.0023396374,
-0.0246782638,
-0.0263224095,
0.0519537516,
0.012690681,
0.0009936979,
-0.0071429126,
-0.0233899932,
-0.0281278472,
-0.0018521799,
0.1024191231,
0.0041910666,
0.0009174775,
-0.0181937683,
0.0151303727,
-0.02983924,
0.0479822494,
-0.0322093442,
-0.0182468873,
0.011830397,
0.0188050885,
-0.0235983413,
0.0746074915,
0.0125716412,
0.0264341962,
0.0702547729,
0.0147758853,
-0.0138227958,
-0.0417157486,
-0.0110586341,
-0.0205079634,
-0.049024839,
-0.0304350145,
0.0000638794,
0.0118636247,
0.0424088389,
-0.0506666042,
-0.0209745672,
0.0959689245,
-0.0083699524,
-0.0168777388,
0.0086931735,
-0.0031404584,
0.0074771848,
0.0090741748,
-0.0151117984,
-0.0837432668,
0.0656522885,
-0.0580984987,
0.0587383658,
-0.0049097468,
-0.0663994476,
0.0483361222,
0.0369917266,
0.0506552942,
0.0282121692,
0.0726411417,
0.0127717853,
-0.0459252298,
0.0008317568,
0.0701535791,
-0.0258741062,
0.0035416842,
-0.0011686783,
-0.0038122642,
0.0039487043,
-0.0281243641,
-0.0670908168,
-0.0506788567,
0.0062680999,
0.0027585942,
-0.0329458788,
-0.042228777,
-0.0243392903,
-0.0090625538,
0.0095308349,
0.0050482214,
-0.0164555144,
0.007437747,
-0.0145629654,
0.0416431874,
0.0155130448,
-0.0609465912,
0.0191142578,
-0.0535841472,
-0.0301707406,
0.0613654517,
0.0182310492,
0.0713213757,
-0.0087701743,
-0.0368059911,
0.0077729421,
0.0070842775,
-0.0346052349,
0.0169476625,
0.0221886951,
-0.0441412628,
-0.0273980368,
0.0467348248,
-0.0171338171,
-0.0186140612,
0.0003145984,
0.0315816253,
0.0349356495,
0.0009154521,
-0.0099544795,
-0.0732783824,
0.0178311076,
0.0498489775,
0.0453491807,
-0.0308008231,
-0.0423021428,
-0.0118513964,
-0.0825844929,
0.0056171669,
-0.0003820804,
-0.0590850711,
-0.0370925926,
-0.0481156297,
0.0084996829,
-0.008139316,
-0.001925742,
-0.0346606001,
0.0207719039,
0.0018386452,
-0.0037895807,
-0.0055165254,
-0.0580168031,
0.0002359739,
-0.0546343811,
0.0579299591,
0.0383375846,
0.0223673191,
-0.00520417,
0.0093169874,
0.0148295322,
-0.0084106484,
-0.0176197812,
0.039766416,
0.0775615126,
-0.0137980897,
-0.0161689371,
0.0331359059,
0.056405466,
0.0308834277,
0.0064339722,
0.0143990302,
0.0111934105,
-0.0102659035,
-0.0308444537,
-0.0013381583,
-0.0002835441,
0.0219832398,
0.0648338646,
0.0106317485,
0.0000312125,
0.0082307989,
-0.0663867295,
0.0412907116,
0.0356572755,
-0.0279419702,
0.0580554418,
-0.0056892047,
-0.0669657737,
-0.0471661761,
0.0063444944,
-0.0393389352,
0.0308110472,
0.0138005642,
0.0051391204,
-0.0128258904,
0.0000081367,
-0.0208098125,
0.002985762,
-0.0556879938,
0.0038496766,
0.0085757347,
0.027057793,
0.0280579161,
0.0162718259,
-0.0393348821,
-0.0350904241,
-0.0833408982,
-0.0938992426,
0.0133407405,
0.0514851771,
0.0159561802,
0.0386159644,
-0.0460366011,
-0.0992244333,
0.0867239758,
0.0462057814,
0.0006188821,
0.0132353613,
0.0782369077,
-0.0888947397,
0.0255511552,
0.0517147444,
-0.0536346585,
-0.0114529338,
0.0857065022,
-0.0503246933,
-0.0359613933,
-0.008558915,
-0.0128707476,
0.001716751,
0.0659539923,
0.0160271935,
0.0006949276,
-0.0045887837,
0.0392093882,
0.0073756874,
-0.0316247381,
0.000024374,
-0.0156003656,
0.0153807113,
0.0336898193,
0.0267792847,
-0.0186624117,
0.0233374685,
0.0681924373,
-0.022246249,
0.0089160334,
0.0703556985,
0.0348739326,
0.0519828871,
-0.0122772623,
-0.0304169618,
0.0610199422,
-0.0040077139,
0.0277941767,
-0.024385253,
0.021504635,
0.0031074446,
-0.0151072284,
-0.0112001626,
0.006401631,
-0.0730833709,
-0.025345182,
-0.0196532309,
0.0263912976,
0.0121131754,
-0.0083714444,
-0.0180809572,
-0.0047997083,
-0.0044755377,
-0.0375512652,
-0.0331004262,
0.0010922378,
-0.0761536881,
0.0357126743,
-0.0015795511,
0.0051028854,
0.0938011631,
0.0841338262,
0.0427335873,
0.0581256822,
-0.017430475,
-0.0458469875,
-0.017325351,
-0.0429878868,
0.0212209299,
0.0123586813,
-0.0343179591,
-0.0031404705,
-0.0347050242,
-0.0990880877,
0.0060967156,
0.0096919425,
0.0244248584,
0.0302808955,
-0.0183029696,
0.0192330275,
0.0011246208,
0.0117152752,
-0.0653591827,
0.023421891,
0.0259601884,
-0.0194450989,
0.0221000444,
-5.736312515e-33,
0.002694905,
-0.0264860615,
-0.0573426113,
0.0015380275,
0.0447716266,
0.0128886821,
0.0033604766,
-0.011094654,
-0.0482833944,
-0.0202950183,
-0.0262941383,
0.0234114323,
-0.014398979,
0.0288706552,
-0.0682265833,
-0.0571635962,
0.0167118106,
-0.0100844475,
-0.0333103016,
0.0050847474,
0.0557360612,
0.0110686785,
0.043802809,
-0.0567754656,
0.0424604714,
-0.0218509231,
-0.0168420915,
0.0016990372,
-0.047847975,
0.0466202423,
0.0048460015,
0.0031366167,
-0.0075337454,
0.0239012018,
0.0068200645,
-0.0070970114,
-0.0129424157,
-0.0091640558,
-0.0354467519,
-0.0146367112,
0.0353910737,
-0.0215172619,
0.0367019586,
-0.0187785588,
0.0173290148,
-0.0184253715,
0.0066173617,
-0.0445225388,
-0.031652648,
-0.0274186097,
0.0070111915,
0.0335679352,
-0.0139111411,
0.0215050504,
0.0334453098,
0.0164327305,
0.0665061325,
-0.0344810262,
-0.0228110682,
0.0236627162,
0.0540022291,
0.0382818878,
0.0437827669,
0.0002184509,
0.0312789343,
0.0524401255,
0.06338083,
0.0134218223,
0.0215371661,
-0.0275541805,
0.0185480379,
0.0319976844,
0.0430995114,
0.0855087191,
0.024016792,
-0.0002312319,
-0.0693699345,
-0.016125245,
-0.0180627387,
-0.0184125099,
0.0612090975,
-0.0022733947,
-0.0560815148,
-0.011449879,
-0.0681843981,
-0.0918490142,
-0.0535038821,
0.0021366822,
0.0010273362,
0.0179642197,
-0.0498978272,
-0.0358860791,
-0.0096188094,
-0.049213741,
-0.0245977584,
0.0585920401,
0.0093934266,
-0.0433754735,
-0.0219415296,
0.0137770185,
-0.0109159183,
-0.0070266137,
-0.0072866003,
-0.0542374663,
0.0312482994,
0.008960112,
0.0658253655,
0.0134538729,
-0.0498627163,
-0.0165124312,
-0.0060412884,
0.0292479303,
0.0170241222,
0.0249400176,
0.0644407719,
-0.026581157,
0.006318762,
0.0228896067,
0.0370742828,
0.0531657413,
-0.0355804861,
0.0589494705,
-0.0443858542,
-0.022101244,
0.006007384,
-0.0357059501,
0.001731345,
0.0524376519,
0.077732034,
-0.0545612499,
0.0121739469,
-0.0280526821,
2.73e-7,
-0.0059358547,
0.0079191094,
-0.0172878858,
-0.0234039295,
0.0186674409,
0.0697520301,
-0.0064841369,
0.0713664815,
0.0060436884,
0.0062305811,
-0.0321979448,
-0.0053136651,
0.0307305716,
0.0499176383,
-0.0639712512,
0.0185051616,
-0.0675632283,
0.0065675038,
-0.0441966578,
-0.0075803488,
-0.0038103438,
0.1155731827,
0.0509386212,
0.0063422127,
-0.0241640359,
-0.0851087198,
0.0124362316,
-0.03963219,
-0.0218148381,
-0.0125879049,
0.0719541758,
0.0378831401,
0.0203328896,
0.0113857416,
-0.0371978246,
0.0272001829,
-0.027123969,
0.0422808789,
0.0561051816,
0.0138946241,
-0.0339732021,
-0.0265803095,
-0.0070211184,
-0.0326818377,
0.0623203702,
-0.0345005244,
-0.017233612,
-0.0383923799,
-0.0189831816,
-0.0687231123,
0.0409220532,
-0.0267994069,
-0.0345600061,
0.0178998206,
-0.0032957892,
0.0017446189,
0.0246149283,
-0.0765169114,
-0.0226067882,
-0.0295014363,
-0.0188569166,
-0.0303023513,
0.0350718498,
-0.0085843354,
0.0243392568,
-0.0003766442,
0.014601917,
2.602937089e-34,
-0.008521975,
-0.0334809124,
-0.0102291871,
-0.0032745311,
0.0335715823,
-0.0193201955,
0.0269159339,
-0.0094746398,
0.0097657889,
-0.0648627952,
-0.0190407597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17911v1 | TotalDefMeme: A Multi-Attribute Meme dataset on Total Defence in Singapore | 2023-05-29T06:43:37 | 2023-05-29T06:43:37 | Nirmalendu Prakash, Ming Shan Hee, Roy Ka-Wei Lee | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, I.2.7 | Total Defence is a defence policy combining and extending the concept of
military defence and civil defence. While several countries have adopted total
defence as their defence policy, very few studies have investigated its
effectiveness. With the rapid proliferation of social media and digitalisation,
many social studies have been focused on investigating policy effectiveness
through specially curated surveys and questionnaires either through digital
media or traditional forms. However, such references may not truly reflect the
underlying sentiments about the target policies or initiatives of interest.
People are more likely to express their sentiment using communication mediums
such as starting topic thread on forums or sharing memes on social media. Using
Singapore as a case reference, this study aims to address this research gap by
proposing TotalDefMeme, a large-scale multi-modal and multi-attribute meme
dataset that captures public sentiments toward Singapore's Total Defence
policy. Besides supporting social informatics and public policy analysis of the
Total Defence policy, TotalDefMeme can also support many downstream multi-modal
machine learning tasks, such as aspect-based stance classification and
multi-modal meme clustering. We perform baseline machine learning experiments
on TotalDefMeme and evaluate its technical validity, and present possible
future interdisciplinary research directions and application scenarios using
the dataset as a baseline. | [
0.0414544307,
0.0690543056,
-0.0046024886,
-0.0370294377,
-0.0174740385,
0.0157427974,
0.0128116263,
-0.0190572515,
-0.0138333449,
-0.0511654131,
0.0147627303,
-0.0270670783,
-0.0121309813,
0.0327970609,
0.0326236263,
-0.0348615497,
0.0456955582,
0.0545383468,
0.0401870906,
-0.0085999342,
0.0377276652,
0.0278024171,
-0.0277747102,
0.0407469422,
-0.0240446404,
0.0155473333,
-0.0229534879,
-0.0284443684,
0.0636015758,
-0.06891983,
0.0145779597,
-0.0134867104,
0.0356677212,
-0.0200058557,
0.00000184,
-0.0504450314,
-0.0151837543,
-0.0512469485,
0.0405168422,
-0.0259683356,
0.081226483,
-0.0261985548,
0.0052519916,
0.0173604023,
-0.0177773722,
0.0006888604,
0.0695744976,
0.0545392036,
0.0814006403,
0.0690574199,
-0.0120588923,
-0.0517026111,
-0.0088369539,
-0.0170167834,
-0.0516044833,
0.0120980516,
0.0105965277,
-0.0220637247,
-0.0508486405,
0.0490467548,
0.031323351,
-0.0094193369,
-0.0269164797,
0.0430531278,
-0.0351874605,
0.0218553506,
0.0344444104,
0.0002759858,
0.0360130556,
0.0517939441,
0.0748265758,
-0.0131865144,
0.0340905339,
-0.0172296502,
0.0097710341,
0.0501970649,
-0.0408806764,
-0.0109412465,
0.0162644926,
0.0493765771,
0.0192470532,
0.0159923658,
0.0340657644,
0.028450679,
0.0008956407,
0.0382886156,
-0.058801759,
-0.0186785758,
-0.0067796409,
0.0261836331,
-0.0062872595,
-0.018241154,
0.0005560173,
0.0106356349,
-0.0006575708,
0.023679845,
-0.0046422244,
-0.0432826355,
0.0606644638,
-0.0652218983,
-0.0136193521,
-0.0040130634,
-0.035918016,
0.0538442768,
0.039642863,
-0.027213132,
0.003329606,
-0.0131921293,
0.0271467231,
-0.0012821669,
-0.0879845992,
0.0009261372,
0.0540026687,
0.0617461279,
0.0492990427,
-0.0492848679,
-0.1018105075,
0.0089120651,
-0.0421064906,
0.0008786974,
0.0237897057,
0.0251576193,
0.0284422319,
0.0285304394,
-0.0427665077,
0.0425111018,
-0.0427038334,
0.0621210225,
-0.021382289,
0.0342156962,
0.0335803181,
-0.0078449072,
0.0349466428,
-0.0034819865,
0.0051501263,
0.0508823507,
0.0198247321,
0.013709317,
-0.0118062533,
-0.0518820696,
-0.030756209,
-0.0338490643,
0.0183855351,
-0.104762271,
0.0206094813,
0.0020223041,
0.0226561036,
-0.0337754078,
-0.0035424195,
0.01829575,
-0.0124974269,
0.0408986807,
0.0229913965,
0.0008416847,
0.0094504151,
0.0443571471,
0.0548689589,
0.0519687496,
-0.0176832136,
0.0349294059,
0.0625438094,
0.0170213468,
-0.024029715,
-0.0055657336,
0.0235288274,
0.0362815224,
-0.0025035357,
-0.0063691912,
-0.0859368816,
-0.0399963073,
-0.0230853222,
-0.005403134,
0.009562742,
-0.0412537679,
0.0480728298,
0.027402211,
-0.0132314106,
0.0100811785,
-0.01386292,
0.0865471363,
0.002276133,
-0.0720331445,
0.0355435275,
0.0019218491,
-0.044344034,
0.0105624162,
0.0381343514,
0.0421403088,
-0.0126094734,
-0.0181113034,
0.0041770199,
-0.0437725112,
0.0369261242,
-0.0288366396,
0.062674962,
-0.0408951454,
0.0108174365,
0.0208432619,
0.0272098668,
-0.0330181271,
-0.0186894313,
-0.0493832268,
0.0016535441,
0.0138407666,
-0.0019404857,
-0.063071698,
-0.0464772433,
-0.0303245019,
0.0122457575,
-0.0052734683,
0.0087332148,
-0.0002444098,
-0.0086862054,
-0.0105523933,
0.0012697821,
-0.0327128731,
0.0184323359,
0.0023295807,
0.0043189977,
0.0460033603,
-0.020403577,
0.0375206321,
0.0403119475,
0.0142761432,
0.081865944,
0.0325428508,
0.0224485472,
0.0414873026,
0.0734104067,
0.0687916428,
-0.0200787894,
-0.0129148969,
0.0363609828,
-0.0077353478,
-0.0369428881,
-0.0021932889,
-0.0132457484,
0.0178986937,
0.0332270563,
-0.0626503602,
-0.0113021033,
0.0318751894,
-0.0376961045,
-0.0167695712,
0.0719542876,
-0.0079585947,
-0.0239579026,
-0.0220282003,
-0.0179371238,
-0.0218965523,
-0.0065506203,
0.0204793103,
0.0483431891,
-0.0392264351,
-0.0430529416,
0.0007482847,
-0.0199432038,
0.0496984385,
0.0193216223,
-0.0231751017,
-0.0265969317,
-0.0157284234,
0.0340741388,
0.0130314091,
-0.0125423418,
-0.0402083285,
0.0052970946,
-0.1039742529,
-0.0289894864,
-0.0054893279,
0.01202677,
0.0357310735,
-0.0308284406,
0.0063589434,
-0.0104099978,
-0.0401697829,
0.0183492918,
0.0042417403,
0.0131614516,
0.0271144621,
0.0103646442,
0.0345748998,
-0.026161762,
-0.0058754385,
-0.0365110487,
0.035474062,
0.0001727721,
-0.0082498724,
0.0227349009,
-0.0179701205,
-0.059479665,
-0.0103883706,
-0.0234306995,
-0.0497100167,
0.0444938727,
-0.005838898,
-0.0109251142,
0.0056810686,
0.0436204858,
0.0804823637,
0.0593787506,
0.0149589032,
-0.0480771288,
-0.0282293633,
-0.0567283072,
0.0443048775,
-0.014221645,
-0.0254644807,
0.0094080465,
0.0421031341,
0.0081338473,
0.0461031646,
-0.0152994068,
0.0504452251,
0.0010056511,
-0.0078911958,
-0.0555345267,
-0.0028311349,
-0.0026835289,
0.033424858,
0.0322384574,
-0.0159229264,
0.0440333672,
0.0298328921,
0.0322902352,
-0.023324253,
-0.0235705096,
-0.0171203073,
0.0938621014,
-0.0120214717,
0.0088986624,
0.0334670246,
0.0283476338,
0.0502625965,
-0.0361256376,
-0.0314665325,
-0.0251683537,
-0.0247966778,
0.0155789843,
-0.0148240048,
-0.0190709736,
-0.0022247718,
0.0254313722,
-0.0906226039,
-0.0551399551,
0.0042049945,
-0.0363797173,
-0.0432992801,
0.0221632738,
0.0198697653,
0.0258642472,
-0.0755295008,
0.0319713019,
-0.0423389375,
0.0096227443,
0.0424122363,
0.0201149862,
-0.0433202721,
-0.0174739324,
-0.0090064667,
-0.0593497008,
0.0581273623,
0.0066072852,
-0.023823414,
-0.0264211725,
-0.0200582389,
0.0282690153,
0.0085829394,
-0.0073334337,
-0.0309161469,
0.0597530566,
-0.0374386907,
0.0360110514,
0.0641817972,
0.0445564091,
-0.0276387613,
0.0102853803,
0.057573121,
0.0068514179,
-0.0017804329,
-0.0160495825,
-0.0684627295,
-0.0048661791,
-0.0140062524,
0.0047256593,
-0.0643927306,
-0.019969888,
0.0121725295,
-0.0927150398,
0.0183726028,
-0.0231558811,
-0.0327816568,
0.0030209452,
-0.0527178869,
0.0332124569,
-0.0283209719,
-0.0302176867,
-0.0778910071,
0.0336300917,
-0.0143189011,
0.0112857325,
-0.0499233641,
-0.0448071323,
0.0030283439,
-0.0471320637,
0.0560498312,
-0.0019691824,
0.0579657219,
-0.0245122351,
-0.0659191534,
0.0400461927,
-0.0167216826,
-0.0045641763,
-0.005541204,
0.0359387025,
-0.0258373525,
-0.020028716,
-0.0170148611,
0.022628881,
-0.0475605391,
-0.0351629406,
0.0028045073,
0.0319519341,
-0.051461421,
0.0195311196,
-0.0361871868,
0.0424771756,
0.0118403826,
0.0209344067,
0.0116497986,
-0.0635301322,
-0.0018354389,
-0.0218811706,
0.0234397817,
-0.0606021062,
-0.0627716631,
-0.0611361824,
-0.0237432718,
0.0193469319,
-0.0289469231,
-0.0474284142,
-0.04333774,
0.0567863733,
-0.0134241395,
-0.0428829342,
0.030090224,
0.0003025975,
-0.0176605992,
-0.010555381,
-0.0110437851,
0.0289379619,
-0.0100713018,
-0.0732241869,
0.0326907188,
0.0298559163,
-0.0249687079,
-0.0433914252,
-0.0450565256,
-0.0440839566,
-0.0002187008,
0.0153754409,
0.0193774942,
0.0038633377,
-0.0119679114,
-0.0080872774,
0.094337061,
0.0617775545,
-0.0434320271,
-0.0197534487,
0.0430182554,
0.0070059979,
0.0243977588,
-0.0070308475,
0.0295291301,
0.0021692496,
0.0326699689,
-0.0770359486,
-0.0697238967,
-0.0067599816,
-0.0045570196,
-0.0233875755,
0.0548053682,
0.0002339757,
-0.024971107,
-0.0164886788,
-0.0158184282,
-0.0174377095,
-0.0066725705,
0.0129657937,
-0.0369357765,
0.0155008575,
-0.0054746009,
-0.0551910885,
0.0605378635,
0.0188376475,
0.0622117743,
-0.0364696011,
0.0703805983,
0.0530352145,
0.0540080518,
-0.0271119792,
-0.0317103453,
0.0093539134,
-0.0002117799,
-0.0054032914,
-0.0292567741,
0.0000911378,
0.0456728451,
-0.0246459469,
-0.0088059241,
-0.0005532848,
0.0508563705,
0.0050062127,
-0.0301375668,
-0.0173355751,
0.0034246834,
0.023099212,
-0.0325284563,
0.0319743082,
-0.01762891,
-0.0167427696,
-0.0100136772,
0.0163830128,
-0.0620009638,
-0.0186301079,
0.0203128438,
0.0084234038,
-0.0324461497,
0.0558038875,
0.04408402,
-0.0694341063,
0.0154205123,
0.0428987332,
-0.0559142418,
-0.0040684217,
0.0021118284,
0.0247879624,
0.0914257467,
-0.0135375587,
-0.0255409423,
-0.0446417443,
-0.0491198897,
-0.0215170346,
-0.0001785527,
0.0215297509,
0.0346948057,
-0.0138307884,
0.034116786,
0.0271623041,
0.107270278,
-0.0677453429,
-0.0381374769,
-0.0392931476,
-0.0044514732,
0.0262281075,
-6.341700187e-33,
0.001544893,
-0.0089285057,
-0.0324302651,
-0.0282725617,
-0.02560254,
-0.0097206952,
-0.0290925615,
0.0385583006,
0.0230252072,
0.0000814072,
0.0091760959,
0.0080804285,
0.0043602521,
0.0074758036,
0.0305183381,
0.0126137612,
-0.007635341,
-0.0221743044,
-0.008953548,
0.0327344798,
0.0611990802,
-0.0239221826,
-0.0130137568,
-0.1269405484,
0.0592695139,
0.0680542514,
-0.0162405465,
-0.0070887115,
0.0501464419,
0.0863672718,
-0.0369308814,
0.0459403209,
0.061051894,
-0.0338101536,
0.0076627177,
0.062498834,
-0.050533995,
-0.0271817818,
-0.0200544856,
-0.0124332849,
0.0034223641,
-0.0332622156,
0.0338482633,
0.0168229099,
-0.0097131357,
0.0197217483,
0.0353695117,
-0.0002324319,
0.0486702435,
-0.0583747253,
-0.031330213,
0.0348482057,
-0.0367343687,
0.0391068496,
-0.0282067992,
0.0365336761,
0.0229354538,
0.0753670186,
-0.0529143848,
0.0614985041,
-0.0377066024,
-0.019355692,
0.0232245233,
-0.0052252221,
-0.0007146309,
0.0681445971,
0.0112544987,
0.0098183146,
-0.0163525604,
0.0178359598,
0.0461488031,
0.0409035422,
0.0270282626,
0.0845393389,
0.0426131897,
-0.0458977148,
-0.0719810799,
0.0257421006,
0.0067345663,
-0.0067586782,
0.0399560556,
0.042513676,
-0.0188368708,
-0.0158296563,
0.0149628241,
-0.0359606259,
-0.0350863039,
-0.055272121,
-0.0422657728,
-0.0217078216,
-0.0821402669,
0.0262191352,
0.0272934288,
-0.0303924512,
-0.005037915,
0.0021946961,
-0.0312264878,
0.031458661,
0.0107981972,
-0.0302972589,
-0.0772681013,
0.0124680549,
0.0129966056,
0.0143320132,
0.0170966592,
-0.0063626668,
0.0544843301,
0.0133660035,
-0.0779425129,
-0.0313481577,
-0.0022773144,
-0.0310837906,
-0.0430453718,
0.0228898171,
0.0332506821,
0.0271201804,
-0.0075367899,
-0.0109571386,
0.0081289923,
-0.0109668737,
-0.0029754781,
-0.0203609709,
-0.0438473187,
-0.0028449798,
0.0019424942,
-0.0337170251,
-0.0297789928,
-0.0040810872,
-0.0104704304,
-0.0322281495,
-0.0109018143,
-0.0120640947,
2.619e-7,
0.0523184687,
0.0128042223,
-0.0104438402,
0.0012608882,
0.0121884514,
0.0671310797,
-0.0294005685,
0.0223518685,
-0.0312523283,
-0.022111861,
0.0641882941,
0.0501779728,
0.0018062579,
0.0373331122,
-0.0555581301,
0.0383865051,
-0.0272617899,
0.0048051164,
-0.0549778379,
0.0713835433,
0.0173756536,
0.053714864,
0.0404869393,
-0.0229039434,
-0.0212345961,
0.0199450534,
0.0250197202,
-0.0387466475,
-0.0317452401,
-0.0463257246,
0.0395387784,
0.0092810774,
0.008163726,
-0.0103575597,
0.001742927,
-0.05155994,
-0.01154532,
0.0232787412,
0.0492441133,
-0.0366516188,
-0.0153543055,
-0.0150950467,
0.0215190742,
-0.0282513499,
0.0417866893,
-0.0283470061,
-0.0513012968,
-0.0675232708,
-0.0425801091,
-0.0006153303,
0.0701017827,
0.0098606404,
-0.0244796705,
-0.0102497358,
-0.0048504039,
-0.0109153604,
0.0192730408,
-0.0707050562,
0.0080118245,
0.0130496724,
-0.0391102284,
-0.0214106292,
0.0382205024,
0.0253958348,
0.0113223139,
-0.0000956305,
0.0119625693,
1.781036031e-34,
0.0073087071,
-0.027636338,
-0.0288445987,
-0.035679549,
0.0353721492,
0.0032491246,
-0.0406788997,
-0.0309657026,
0.0076126768,
-0.0381326117,
0.005584172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17906v1 | Byte-Level Grammatical Error Correction Using Synthetic and Curated Corpora | 2023-05-29T06:35:40 | 2023-05-29T06:35:40 | Svanhvít Lilja Ingólfsdóttir, Pétur Orri Ragnarsson, Haukur Páll Jónsson, Haukur Barri Símonarson, Vilhjálmur Þorsteinsson, Vésteinn Snæbjarnarson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction (GEC) is the task of correcting typos, spelling,
punctuation and grammatical issues in text. Approaching the problem as a
sequence-to-sequence task, we compare the use of a common subword unit
vocabulary and byte-level encoding. Initial synthetic training data is created
using an error-generating pipeline, and used for finetuning two subword-level
models and one byte-level model. Models are then finetuned further on
hand-corrected error corpora, including texts written by children, university
students, dyslexic and second-language writers, and evaluated over different
error types and origins. We show that a byte-level model enables higher
correction quality than a subword approach, not only for simple spelling
errors, but also for more complex semantic, stylistic and grammatical issues.
In particular, initial training on synthetic corpora followed by finetuning on
a relatively small parallel corpus of real-world errors helps the byte-level
model correct a wide range of commonly occurring errors. Our experiments are
run for the Icelandic language but should hold for other similar languages,
particularly morphologically rich ones. | [
0.078960605,
0.031963516,
-0.013738161,
0.0132833617,
-0.0417195447,
0.045304928,
0.0141009716,
-0.0249372553,
-0.0172902755,
-0.0901004821,
0.033531677,
-0.0774887353,
0.0478955619,
-0.0242178589,
0.0584633909,
-0.0453530625,
0.0767245367,
-0.0119965216,
-0.0136321634,
-0.0005975487,
0.0224410333,
0.0167996865,
-0.0138517432,
0.0030321605,
-0.0364701077,
-0.0133547569,
-0.0034492181,
0.0580888875,
0.0226353537,
0.0305258837,
0.0537263341,
0.0174421985,
-0.005687505,
0.0488302186,
0.0000016587,
-0.0203026235,
-0.0173346847,
-0.0014103944,
-0.005756841,
0.0631657839,
0.0445912592,
-0.0348792709,
-0.0868790299,
0.0391690843,
0.0437110998,
0.0091270385,
0.0725719258,
-0.0088971565,
0.0423335731,
0.081949383,
-0.0106251966,
-0.0235447008,
0.0532860532,
-0.0105285393,
-0.0438163728,
0.0557597391,
0.0233653411,
0.0222532228,
-0.0228039585,
-0.0039430414,
-0.0343487412,
-0.0029981085,
-0.043953158,
-0.0178380683,
0.0082990313,
-0.0131706046,
-0.0119014438,
-0.0274091326,
-0.0049614618,
0.0131586147,
-0.0241591912,
-0.0498768426,
-0.0179319009,
0.0074996613,
-0.0042190677,
0.0022726336,
0.0080281701,
0.0358054489,
-0.0321554914,
0.037549749,
0.0831089914,
-0.1087813899,
0.0090287887,
0.0103884293,
-0.0072168005,
0.0231564622,
0.0151413362,
-0.0843417272,
-0.0227578487,
0.0308712516,
-0.0016688083,
-0.0465693325,
0.0250511654,
-0.0192064047,
-0.041491285,
-0.0111887483,
-0.065879114,
-0.0840927511,
0.0208537858,
-0.057705123,
0.0643351972,
-0.0030712485,
0.003372584,
-0.0144469142,
0.0095765777,
0.0246362612,
0.0492424257,
0.0087593691,
0.0104867024,
0.0064443238,
-0.0275342222,
0.022615863,
-0.0684242919,
-0.0064670863,
-0.0694250911,
0.0402073115,
-0.0202008765,
-0.0193847604,
0.0190859605,
0.0324755907,
0.0180019066,
-0.0477934331,
-0.0555974729,
-0.0026303814,
0.0149831371,
0.0123134153,
-0.0054736715,
0.0477524437,
-0.0038059908,
-0.0614362843,
0.0051104943,
-0.0014221346,
0.030876752,
-0.0289058834,
0.0218905043,
0.0208838228,
-0.0141850458,
-0.0279610101,
-0.0622996613,
-0.0056781773,
-0.0112785436,
-0.0373380408,
-0.0774726421,
-0.0808093473,
-0.02727836,
-0.0232541021,
0.0158380531,
0.0108970981,
0.0086042788,
0.0054987124,
-0.0467576943,
0.0679666176,
-0.0985106155,
0.0021874965,
-0.0074262442,
-0.0509523302,
0.0615696982,
0.0097599654,
0.0670290813,
-0.0523024797,
0.0417145938,
-0.0106375851,
-0.0076340274,
0.0128329461,
-0.0496078953,
-0.0201987606,
-0.0092109237,
-0.0541633256,
-0.0335488729,
0.0419267751,
0.0596217848,
0.0931339115,
-0.0111465678,
0.0356913917,
0.0429818705,
0.0139610851,
0.0426943339,
0.0301489793,
0.0256034378,
-0.0141338017,
-0.0044944035,
0.0381860882,
-0.0308296364,
-0.0030676469,
-0.0029077139,
0.0057891342,
0.0362764262,
0.0330093801,
-0.0121855875,
-0.0378121324,
-0.0281822365,
0.0121361483,
0.0020816184,
-0.0447137542,
0.0189154018,
0.0285000894,
-0.0359369926,
0.0227094311,
0.0252106059,
-0.0811176375,
0.0274702534,
0.006322708,
0.0196663905,
0.0831799582,
0.064870216,
0.0103991684,
-0.0242118984,
-0.0237918645,
-0.0197347291,
0.046386715,
0.0459223352,
-0.0207823012,
-0.006862456,
-0.045861423,
0.0278091468,
0.0131878145,
0.0188198779,
-0.0177496057,
0.002372056,
0.0132912025,
-0.0125961192,
-0.0316457786,
-0.0585218482,
0.0170860738,
-0.0115672834,
-0.0134846494,
-0.0372517519,
0.0016215103,
0.027087003,
0.0161481053,
-0.074348852,
0.0158418678,
-0.022893833,
-0.0170389097,
-0.0385617092,
-0.0095426328,
0.0179225467,
-0.0669476315,
0.0344037004,
-0.0471113399,
-0.0305083338,
0.0321579352,
-0.0483148508,
-0.0362258404,
-0.0008650179,
-0.0641924962,
0.0151349977,
-0.0596547425,
0.0192772578,
0.0078883171,
-0.0087166391,
-0.0337421484,
0.0015260007,
0.0047434219,
0.0381460004,
-0.0470673926,
-0.0206624139,
-0.0007492483,
-0.0369320177,
-0.0187858175,
0.0277980864,
-0.0202606972,
0.0452494919,
0.038859468,
0.0113895545,
-0.0304304063,
-0.0340646394,
-0.0543583222,
0.005422879,
-0.04263632,
0.053330265,
0.0343912765,
0.0055396678,
-0.0174959004,
-0.0132992472,
0.0092158122,
0.0542727746,
0.0224124528,
0.0162279196,
0.0615967289,
-0.0336715207,
0.0001717232,
-0.0824659541,
-0.0320892185,
-0.0152482251,
-0.007991896,
0.0194464512,
-0.0670188516,
-0.0622137152,
0.0636607483,
-0.0181051958,
0.0423362032,
0.0464082658,
-0.093373403,
-0.0091158887,
-0.0140734883,
0.0903203934,
0.042985782,
0.003642861,
-0.0103677316,
0.0150363864,
-0.0327185392,
0.0121177379,
0.0025888702,
0.0019031264,
-0.0372906849,
-0.0458413027,
-0.0397636667,
-0.0058355047,
0.0697143376,
0.0040366799,
-0.0324195586,
-0.0140692191,
0.0202792939,
-0.0184113588,
0.0252630729,
0.0267466046,
-0.0154340928,
0.0049294271,
0.0404389463,
-0.0570788942,
-0.0301268622,
0.0584210083,
0.0070590801,
-0.0062952973,
-0.0474918075,
0.0052510747,
0.0130478078,
-0.0117158452,
0.0063296948,
0.0477851406,
-0.0341484621,
-0.0606310219,
-0.059238594,
0.005192453,
0.0709420815,
-0.0112346252,
0.0170991533,
-0.0824110806,
0.0216321573,
-0.010829865,
-0.0372656845,
-0.0011938364,
-0.0225713067,
-0.0045354664,
-0.0307873823,
0.0310418364,
-0.0134998066,
-0.0397844724,
-0.0245902482,
-0.0011522522,
0.0427762643,
0.0088628745,
-0.0161723308,
-0.0140188346,
0.0179171748,
-0.0288613513,
0.0119357994,
0.0254136268,
-0.0086753806,
0.0101196002,
0.0666271821,
-0.0149474191,
0.0441371873,
-0.0003649055,
0.0101693757,
0.048281949,
-0.0452291593,
-0.0594056882,
-0.0101369768,
0.0846733078,
-0.0451032594,
-0.0670611188,
0.0757976696,
0.0415266678,
0.0182161834,
-0.0063063977,
0.0020665994,
0.001946211,
0.000078245,
0.0042179013,
-0.0572138429,
-0.0166658405,
0.0553915277,
0.0360033996,
-0.023637794,
-0.0033105267,
0.0259822477,
-0.1117580086,
0.0446121693,
0.0620460734,
0.0014588922,
-0.0549842007,
-0.0026493196,
-0.0015583269,
0.018402379,
0.030060187,
0.0478302054,
-0.0248961281,
0.0157920197,
0.0396797247,
-0.0147829354,
-0.0775067657,
-0.0296003465,
-0.0455215201,
0.0844939277,
0.073860094,
0.0200395007,
0.0065378565,
-0.0167252254,
0.0348536037,
-0.0410525985,
-0.0103450334,
0.0089940038,
0.0553969704,
-0.0011911606,
-0.0076645287,
-0.0448495224,
0.0431140736,
-0.0186505038,
-0.0056554959,
-0.0488627516,
0.0404670909,
0.0125867482,
0.0021546639,
0.0146529544,
-0.0093028899,
0.0418906771,
0.0075062728,
0.0243765842,
-0.0134758418,
-0.0744885132,
-0.0579481348,
0.0015700833,
-0.0562051497,
0.0291127898,
0.03065948,
-0.0086804777,
-0.0188355036,
-0.0782833174,
-0.0838290453,
0.0008559399,
0.0131973606,
0.0392305851,
-0.0484893546,
0.0200248081,
-0.0254026372,
-0.0292107966,
-0.0228752736,
0.00595978,
0.0494854078,
-0.0710886344,
-0.01538656,
-0.0183952451,
0.0390735231,
0.0047634505,
-0.0173152778,
-0.0538110659,
-0.0636774078,
0.0347031578,
0.0536866039,
0.008953169,
0.0083915591,
0.0010687711,
-0.0810367614,
0.0098949699,
0.0612847172,
-0.0032066638,
0.035516873,
0.0286352187,
-0.0479251333,
-0.0072918995,
0.0140765179,
0.0141581539,
0.0223042555,
0.0078071905,
0.0484391414,
0.0014943423,
-0.012916903,
0.0469579697,
0.0188553445,
0.0445923284,
-0.0237654876,
0.0084828446,
-0.0689060017,
0.0090049421,
0.0006763859,
0.0032901121,
-0.021120768,
-0.0132177444,
0.0400010832,
-0.0110568609,
-0.0194360279,
0.0184066389,
-0.0724796206,
0.0122840926,
0.0125049921,
-0.0001146332,
0.0266734064,
0.0441434793,
0.0193566307,
0.023513535,
-0.0107675092,
0.0038833574,
0.0172838736,
0.0416831821,
-0.0104182716,
0.003597483,
0.0150101501,
0.0457049981,
0.0036659811,
-0.000378608,
-0.0212523248,
0.0357271098,
-0.0313685946,
-0.0029787598,
0.0897454098,
-0.0037389265,
0.0846131817,
-0.0394677855,
-0.0229067951,
-0.0285372362,
0.0514924675,
-0.0104802232,
-0.018597804,
-0.0023365216,
-0.0029081351,
-0.0114360349,
-0.0378661007,
0.0364585891,
-0.0280816928,
0.0249494482,
-0.0062299189,
-0.0257543754,
0.0133272037,
-0.0134427296,
-0.0429849178,
-0.0275562555,
-0.0042098076,
-0.0056702485,
-0.0598961674,
-0.0712092742,
-0.022014983,
0.0819191113,
0.0456004776,
0.0023788642,
-0.0116055254,
0.0348656923,
-0.0018399217,
0.0185529497,
-0.0600371808,
0.0102267815,
0.014456681,
-0.050867077,
-0.0326704048,
-5.369880436e-33,
-0.0411727801,
0.0270540528,
-0.0245381687,
-0.0100476267,
-0.0047959858,
-0.026990395,
-0.0281901583,
0.015326784,
0.0201745164,
0.0605762862,
-0.0101311626,
0.0147179291,
0.0071760267,
0.0175021607,
0.0481152497,
0.0614149608,
0.0867556855,
0.0011310602,
-0.0013492665,
-0.0342027619,
0.0346747972,
0.0211466309,
0.0858648643,
0.0035481683,
0.0557396896,
-0.0087816101,
-0.014704193,
0.0221531559,
-0.0029492718,
0.0090385098,
0.0305667911,
0.0534083545,
0.0066195326,
0.0475003272,
-0.0280061215,
0.0207236689,
-0.0946073234,
-0.0107230479,
0.018861454,
0.0326220803,
-0.0089067612,
-0.025623519,
0.0327531397,
-0.038454026,
-0.019199945,
-0.0045916666,
0.0136254448,
-0.0115896463,
0.0156330951,
-0.0115707116,
-0.0607058145,
-0.0002599685,
0.011438163,
-0.010100835,
-0.012050001,
0.0455139577,
0.0140397009,
-0.0350885354,
-0.0558744445,
0.0136460112,
0.0362388417,
0.0542657226,
-0.0058576409,
-0.0493944772,
-0.0642310232,
0.0155824255,
0.0215665083,
0.0167269073,
-0.0016247951,
0.0335982405,
0.0207510944,
-0.0081740264,
0.039302215,
0.0840871409,
0.0785126835,
-0.0514187738,
-0.0481410325,
0.0055561047,
-0.0140591329,
0.0461366363,
-0.0442890301,
0.0093219718,
-0.0221223347,
-0.0540272519,
-0.0346034057,
-0.021304341,
-0.0134383356,
-0.0061210915,
0.0441074483,
-0.0074294321,
0.0187191945,
0.0080866497,
-0.0071210484,
-0.0202687383,
-0.0300065689,
-0.04070355,
-0.0106377918,
0.0357663631,
-0.0269312207,
0.0129954927,
-0.0334132165,
-0.0497432612,
0.0072511602,
0.0337021016,
0.0041741463,
0.0309065543,
0.0403461456,
0.0506984293,
-0.0726238117,
0.0529777296,
-0.0133200595,
0.0496230833,
0.0006641218,
-0.0039508305,
0.0113677485,
-0.0068044513,
0.0252751894,
-0.013134798,
-0.0166419167,
-0.0089610368,
-0.0190741308,
-0.0077285012,
-0.0440296493,
0.0195827037,
-0.0063231122,
0.0058171172,
-0.0462151878,
0.0095767295,
0.0162760839,
-0.0084455805,
0.0207181051,
-0.0017554117,
2.403e-7,
0.0006571083,
0.0779414326,
0.0650199056,
-0.0213786513,
0.0216542408,
-0.0002151435,
-0.0295360554,
0.0501134023,
0.0025249894,
0.0401334465,
0.0248313844,
-0.0206358302,
0.0622257032,
0.0056205154,
-0.0473584048,
-0.0250876192,
-0.01813614,
0.0411491133,
-0.0378189385,
-0.0419083163,
0.0390786231,
0.0440658331,
0.0237428006,
-0.0253862794,
0.0019970371,
-0.0476746261,
0.0457442701,
0.0049668327,
-0.0174616799,
0.0197623186,
0.0302452892,
0.0317945741,
0.0331422165,
0.0136885354,
-0.0400962308,
-0.0542023517,
-0.0047026435,
0.0338229425,
-0.0151152732,
0.0580328517,
0.0112189846,
0.0183763579,
-0.0302346013,
-0.0163804702,
-0.008093168,
0.004558322,
0.0237650704,
0.0224177893,
-0.0340850018,
0.0365827605,
-0.0043124105,
-0.0482422076,
-0.0217438936,
0.0223705471,
0.0542356893,
0.0447698012,
-0.0174037516,
-0.0140805403,
-0.0005782359,
0.0490063019,
0.0320118293,
-0.0402251408,
0.0356146432,
0.0118429791,
0.0001320305,
-0.0396695472,
-0.0019747396,
1.989319396e-34,
0.0618818775,
-0.011189457,
0.0552322008,
-0.0352030136,
0.0045210533,
-0.0069665406,
0.0205261465,
0.0150624737,
-0.0277124383,
-0.0049111396,
-0.0193658303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17888v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17888v1 | LLM-QAT: Data-Free Quantization Aware Training for Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T05:22:11 | 2023-05-29T05:22:11 | Zechun Liu, Barlas Oguz, Changsheng Zhao, Ernie Chang, Pierre Stock, Yashar Mehdad, Yangyang Shi, Raghuraman Krishnamoorthi, Vikas Chandra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Several post-training quantization methods have been applied to large
language models (LLMs), and have been shown to perform well down to 8-bits. We
find that these methods break down at lower bit precision, and investigate
quantization aware training for LLMs (LLM-QAT) to push quantization levels even
further. We propose a data-free distillation method that leverages generations
produced by the pre-trained model, which better preserves the original output
distribution and allows quantizing any generative model independent of its
training data, similar to post-training quantization methods. In addition to
quantizing weights and activations, we also quantize the KV cache, which is
critical for increasing throughput and support long sequence dependencies at
current model sizes. We experiment with LLaMA models of sizes 7B, 13B, and 30B,
at quantization levels down to 4-bits. We observe large improvements over
training-free methods, especially in the low-bit settings. | [
-0.0214359164,
0.1055751145,
0.0148420176,
0.0289032534,
0.0130492756,
0.0198456682,
0.0104598319,
0.029789798,
-0.0407739691,
-0.0153315514,
-0.0051010177,
-0.0661394596,
-0.0289322045,
0.013759844,
0.033796791,
-0.0207857471,
0.0413959622,
-0.0161182228,
-0.0054988977,
-0.0289671365,
-0.0130642531,
0.004060694,
0.0283128805,
-0.0054921862,
0.0018687793,
-0.0299542584,
-0.0351906344,
0.0080893841,
0.0085799331,
-0.0323467366,
0.0024962875,
0.0534713231,
0.0369479693,
0.0277539957,
0.0000021083,
-0.0063489797,
0.0076077399,
-0.0148205645,
-0.0555229224,
0.0506491885,
0.0113631366,
0.0066603734,
-0.0329340026,
0.0147929164,
-0.0173293985,
-0.011458247,
0.0549158938,
-0.0032623846,
0.0494643934,
0.0580148511,
0.0020671836,
-0.0401321873,
0.0449545942,
-0.0592962652,
0.0134326695,
-0.0167749692,
0.0061972374,
0.0282457005,
-0.0137874307,
0.015237934,
-0.0315275788,
0.0388435423,
0.0264190696,
0.0081863441,
-0.0183051489,
0.0286151934,
-0.0440710708,
-0.0239269119,
0.0084654996,
0.0521016568,
-0.0623026937,
-0.0292484127,
-0.0052055703,
0.0076529281,
-0.0345518738,
-0.1040066928,
-0.031208016,
0.0363593549,
0.0302597545,
0.0555240996,
-0.0281850267,
-0.040460214,
0.0531136319,
0.0008877054,
-0.0493942425,
0.0181521103,
0.0316599831,
-0.0034068986,
-0.0319195464,
-0.0026726609,
-0.0640837997,
-0.0500046313,
-0.0426673926,
0.0017723744,
0.0322966985,
-0.0036779698,
-0.0457770564,
-0.0049182409,
-0.0035591861,
-0.0133920265,
0.0249443334,
0.0598579794,
-0.0105702346,
-0.0043615666,
-0.0298706964,
0.0271611437,
-0.0114582609,
0.0286627021,
-0.0484261625,
0.0260294154,
-0.0145968506,
0.007730681,
-0.0335682854,
0.0197041184,
-0.0437160768,
-0.0102443583,
-0.0611277521,
-0.0212579314,
-0.008538642,
-0.0450510569,
0.0321497321,
0.0278893877,
-0.0357402973,
0.0009166055,
0.0063617914,
0.0387521461,
-0.0217580684,
-0.0063121021,
0.0168859269,
-0.0797873512,
-0.0324155986,
0.0117538832,
0.02194231,
-0.0225717537,
0.0157330688,
0.0166453402,
0.0061233211,
-0.051394023,
-0.0423235744,
0.0212958604,
-0.0135376621,
-0.0850831643,
0.0149750262,
-0.0562519915,
-0.0105927754,
-0.0367709994,
0.0144665185,
-0.0398725159,
0.0292075388,
-0.0008902755,
0.0075107981,
0.0547412336,
-0.0105849979,
-0.0061965734,
-0.0154484315,
0.021077916,
0.0697958842,
0.0871068463,
0.0328262448,
0.0421028771,
-0.0168504976,
0.0082673011,
-0.0378880799,
0.0421845466,
0.0493757389,
0.0156792421,
-0.052540645,
-0.034237273,
-0.0105766095,
0.0350121334,
0.1129584908,
0.0579060912,
-0.0719853938,
-0.0286134798,
0.0401221998,
0.0135511048,
0.0618739314,
0.0177658461,
0.0089823473,
0.0011319179,
0.0179313608,
-0.0029991849,
-0.0222309269,
0.0245682299,
0.0355371796,
0.0178634375,
0.0504769087,
0.0692566186,
-0.0504257418,
-0.0357685611,
-0.0182874948,
-0.0095279077,
-0.0148241716,
-0.0028303091,
0.014082822,
0.0342082381,
-0.0033737542,
0.1074794158,
0.0366685726,
-0.0604882129,
0.0047660931,
-0.0734695122,
0.0206329785,
0.0641799122,
0.0297656767,
0.0213173572,
-0.0062999167,
0.0143006025,
0.0034950008,
0.0283823274,
-0.024946833,
0.0006052908,
0.033911936,
-0.0492895544,
-0.040830452,
-0.0294930171,
0.0006047677,
0.0204491057,
0.0361056328,
0.0237229113,
0.0129269445,
-0.0194485616,
0.0068262354,
0.0204108506,
-0.0245364867,
-0.073401615,
0.0281641465,
-0.0193191599,
0.030229995,
0.0111904005,
-0.0289986748,
-0.0033846067,
0.0368140079,
-0.0522315837,
0.0162223969,
-0.0303936955,
-0.0348704383,
-0.0505060889,
0.0637993813,
0.0370832868,
0.0512898825,
0.0248560477,
-0.0589005314,
-0.042861443,
0.032859087,
0.0034305449,
0.0409103259,
-0.0573859252,
0.0273449142,
0.0208757035,
0.0522421859,
-0.0272011198,
0.0300201941,
-0.0358158648,
-0.006627921,
-0.0004583921,
0.0152597679,
0.0063546612,
-0.0278121568,
-0.0312066842,
0.0355445333,
0.0223094132,
0.0363708027,
-0.0090024015,
0.0131290937,
-0.0016159544,
0.0012472313,
-0.0765650868,
0.0106991325,
-0.0549940057,
0.0445852205,
0.0202682763,
0.0366011895,
-0.0067471727,
-0.0018042917,
-0.0277612358,
-0.0074125165,
-0.0071861926,
0.0027194179,
-0.0149247795,
-0.0062032184,
-0.0049994159,
-0.0363036916,
-0.0450503789,
0.0354060493,
0.0469234511,
-0.0694420785,
-0.0065159644,
-0.0507539026,
0.0096129552,
-0.0352451801,
0.0546483956,
-0.0122932019,
-0.0454793163,
0.0265352167,
-0.0220704749,
0.0055875303,
0.0319265686,
0.0153361531,
-0.006887747,
0.0698605105,
0.007956937,
-0.052752357,
0.029722983,
-0.0097401775,
-0.0482975021,
-0.0162239429,
-0.0169643518,
-0.0418955646,
0.0846390426,
-0.0386423729,
-0.0208012555,
-0.0489586443,
0.0080210492,
-0.0024337769,
-0.0322051719,
-0.0322386622,
0.0266416166,
-0.0406893939,
0.0397361554,
-0.0158806536,
-0.0447148755,
0.0113196038,
-0.0361017473,
-0.0004719867,
-0.0107008377,
0.0006998266,
-0.0114975302,
0.0494628847,
0.0338107273,
0.0456615351,
-0.0062282649,
0.0013725626,
-0.0473593138,
-0.0081177754,
-0.0335750766,
-0.0183751062,
0.0139453951,
-0.0157651249,
0.0222169273,
-0.0335100256,
-0.0253330693,
-0.0183165856,
0.0344572738,
0.0048677051,
0.0197400376,
0.0244810488,
-0.040268939,
0.0569650866,
0.037654452,
-0.0178017169,
0.0632885695,
-0.0221151654,
0.0048520234,
-0.0200427137,
0.0605216585,
0.0469749123,
-0.0172472578,
0.0236320328,
-0.0116833737,
-0.016224578,
0.0403014831,
0.0249396898,
0.0435349606,
-0.0476337671,
0.0120519372,
0.0405063778,
0.0161844697,
-0.0151736243,
0.0067143315,
0.0472706854,
-0.0427316315,
-0.0135398516,
0.0686554611,
0.0129130436,
-0.0168834291,
0.0224992707,
0.0213711187,
0.0557758659,
-0.0012045274,
0.0246500392,
-0.128155306,
-0.0161436684,
-0.0021163479,
0.0130854705,
0.0316591971,
0.0194512289,
-0.02767835,
-0.0624289066,
0.0178358294,
0.0409088694,
0.0214867089,
-0.0219414961,
0.0068248063,
-0.0401333831,
-0.0346751548,
0.0602337234,
0.0502058342,
-0.025627451,
0.0003940866,
0.0480312407,
0.0249738786,
-0.0755720139,
0.0297869742,
-0.0033713395,
0.0389357954,
0.0846678838,
0.0167236961,
0.0319863111,
-0.0211503189,
-0.0038342611,
-0.0100842258,
0.0095397569,
0.0069162962,
0.0212280378,
0.0146114072,
-0.0256481227,
0.0470640622,
-0.0139991362,
0.0047387341,
-0.0206455532,
-0.0167702604,
0.0094131241,
-0.0091388784,
-0.0499588773,
0.0105392318,
-0.0457315072,
-0.0260189958,
0.0275525544,
0.0385190733,
0.0047811698,
-0.0632730201,
-0.0351665244,
0.0131189814,
-0.0565109663,
-0.027378181,
-0.0197570715,
-0.0174143706,
-0.0815258026,
-0.0669072419,
-0.0062061194,
-0.0049598874,
0.0412395336,
-0.0315177217,
-0.019621009,
0.0119134942,
0.0092363842,
-0.0802995563,
0.0106284898,
-0.0410352573,
-0.003159991,
-0.0524268597,
-0.0309153106,
0.0163270999,
-0.0062990487,
-0.0193762202,
-0.0146907093,
-0.1581710875,
-0.0778610185,
0.0114775067,
0.0297567695,
0.0164464489,
0.0653978586,
0.0210585427,
-0.0606892556,
0.0900238529,
0.0605981722,
-0.0038816233,
0.0403324999,
0.0441203043,
-0.0226061828,
-0.005087934,
0.0407316387,
-0.0030750299,
0.0446272865,
-0.0043659667,
0.0626396537,
-0.0530835055,
-0.00513463,
-0.0140334442,
-0.0103337765,
0.0352942534,
-0.0123897241,
-0.0050459835,
-0.0040135072,
0.0392799452,
-0.00055004,
0.0320306979,
-0.0504961833,
0.001055557,
0.0301176719,
-0.0047239121,
-0.0174298678,
0.0069886041,
0.0278000757,
-0.0059764506,
0.017817799,
-0.0039645922,
-0.036780376,
0.0249479227,
0.0511692688,
-0.0033504546,
0.0078713978,
0.0241409857,
-0.0003252688,
0.033756312,
-0.0435734876,
0.002610191,
-0.0207223278,
0.030951418,
-0.0268993471,
0.0470555983,
-0.0308557786,
-0.0400827788,
-0.0757320449,
0.0178671014,
0.0599963255,
0.0341667235,
0.0628112257,
-0.0051814793,
-0.0221171845,
0.0030566384,
-0.0035120845,
-0.0041181892,
-0.0144285979,
0.024061922,
0.0191457216,
-0.02596692,
-0.0129330596,
0.0850246549,
0.0307802074,
0.0470645726,
-0.0228375606,
0.0300389547,
-0.0066901925,
-0.0547417104,
-0.0466704853,
0.0164721347,
0.0122742364,
-0.0214277599,
0.0039823386,
-0.0570931807,
-0.0080929361,
0.0167550184,
-0.0210697986,
-0.0168555491,
0.0327474885,
0.0153344786,
-0.008233713,
-0.0454209708,
-0.0363975987,
-0.0433658697,
0.0334007256,
-0.0175852459,
0.0155028766,
-6.912978687e-33,
-0.0157314315,
0.0336568169,
0.0330296308,
-0.0368920118,
-0.0477843881,
0.0203774367,
-0.0335501134,
-0.0206301697,
-0.0134660713,
-0.0138726095,
-0.0329206474,
0.03471715,
0.0203342065,
0.0203463454,
-0.0150611615,
0.0180351045,
0.1082046777,
-0.0207963921,
0.0035880413,
0.0550532639,
0.0030462758,
0.0290779155,
0.0414870642,
0.0421561338,
-0.0319857933,
0.0143694449,
-0.0169849079,
-0.0124505106,
0.0103121847,
0.0097805997,
-0.0553992577,
0.021598449,
-0.013270977,
-0.023916183,
-0.040847335,
-0.0534767024,
-0.0821560994,
-0.0010518607,
0.0014541422,
-0.0001113974,
-0.0090816487,
-0.0469186306,
0.041535452,
0.0213485956,
-0.0179367606,
-0.0075194412,
-0.0351642966,
-0.0150268665,
-0.0235730559,
-0.0743341446,
-0.0203702077,
0.0198142305,
0.0255202297,
0.0143169556,
0.0695463568,
-0.0420833901,
-0.0175126772,
-0.0097536044,
-0.0589630939,
0.0083292909,
0.068482548,
0.1037125438,
0.067309849,
0.0477012359,
0.0341291465,
0.0361787342,
0.0204729699,
-0.0383388475,
-0.0126554072,
0.0495703779,
0.0646880418,
0.0397906899,
0.0085193943,
0.0200413726,
0.1043420658,
-0.0184209011,
-0.0548303835,
-0.0105370916,
-0.0045669377,
0.0312770009,
0.0059755524,
0.0555554852,
0.001754943,
-0.035917908,
-0.0298712812,
-0.0126998387,
-0.0331194215,
-0.0525427312,
0.0080442522,
0.0382453427,
-0.0294449423,
-0.0182300881,
0.0286029689,
-0.030163385,
-0.0190213136,
0.0230332967,
-0.0242171772,
0.0140858609,
0.0052844672,
0.0252124071,
-0.0534588024,
-0.0211485215,
0.0347469188,
-0.0101370048,
0.0015746809,
-0.0139265275,
0.0205221884,
0.0537962355,
-0.0745371133,
-0.0091822473,
-0.0474137068,
0.0182983112,
0.0162147768,
0.0546590239,
0.0245198309,
0.0145931561,
0.0107360734,
0.0326598734,
-0.0201725867,
0.0195131637,
-0.0082987742,
0.0174013823,
0.0422636271,
0.0606207289,
-0.0406129323,
0.0233630817,
-0.0527307093,
0.05132889,
0.039636787,
-0.0631514564,
-0.0436900258,
0.0384170748,
2.697e-7,
0.0313416906,
0.0092961462,
0.0188032519,
-0.0014230236,
0.0069125011,
-0.0160740707,
0.0167092867,
0.0267243069,
-0.0080884164,
-0.0116925351,
0.0194699969,
0.0421830043,
0.0241441857,
0.0241607353,
-0.0709623322,
0.0286407135,
-0.0419767462,
0.0035953915,
-0.0366158932,
-0.0848101154,
0.0101115312,
0.1206270084,
-0.0162660349,
-0.0232362803,
0.0665364489,
0.0043934407,
0.032055486,
0.0246046744,
0.018760033,
0.0373840556,
0.0159156658,
0.0158535689,
-0.0095377453,
-0.0511832982,
-0.0170201026,
-0.0226753037,
-0.049273897,
0.0880814269,
-0.0230379663,
-0.0409563296,
0.0151139265,
0.0252706017,
-0.0260280631,
-0.0046004397,
0.0627207682,
-0.0202818755,
0.0108537674,
-0.0966248512,
-0.0192813501,
-0.0133815967,
0.0084076962,
-0.020457251,
0.0228737518,
0.0453002676,
0.0025568979,
-0.0134192854,
-0.0270264484,
-0.0853617564,
-0.0301196557,
-0.0004380404,
-0.0215175916,
-0.0496401414,
-0.0647125542,
-0.0096845794,
-0.0026097766,
-0.019737944,
0.0080785071,
2.407851175e-34,
0.036093194,
-0.0158812776,
0.0207261126,
0.011687818,
-0.0051997355,
-0.0139482282,
-0.0130784102,
0.0070812148,
-0.0339541025,
-0.0562619008,
-0.0471051596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17878v1 | Ask an Expert: Leveraging Language Models to Improve Strategic Reasoning in Goal-Oriented Dialogue Models | 2023-05-29T04:19:35 | 2023-05-29T04:19:35 | Qiang Zhang, Jason Naradowsky, Yusuke Miyao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | Existing dialogue models may encounter scenarios which are not
well-represented in the training data, and as a result generate responses that
are unnatural, inappropriate, or unhelpful. We propose the "Ask an Expert"
framework in which the model is trained with access to an "expert" which it can
consult at each turn. Advice is solicited via a structured dialogue with the
expert, and the model is optimized to selectively utilize (or ignore) it given
the context and dialogue history. In this work the expert takes the form of an
LLM. We evaluate this framework in a mental health support domain, where the
structure of the expert conversation is outlined by pre-specified prompts which
reflect a reasoning strategy taught to practitioners in the field. Blenderbot
models utilizing "Ask an Expert" show quality improvements across all expert
sizes, including those with fewer parameters than the dialogue model itself.
Our best model provides a $\sim 10\%$ improvement over baselines, approaching
human-level scores on "engingingness" and "helpfulness" metrics. | [
0.1205903515,
0.0236273482,
-0.0033038489,
0.0351065993,
-0.0396299958,
0.0021860518,
0.0092769833,
0.0071251579,
0.0212815963,
-0.0386107229,
-0.0058452995,
0.0082385736,
-0.0339832716,
0.0472450815,
-0.0032459225,
-0.081997633,
0.0089063654,
-0.0267189108,
0.0871590674,
0.0119351419,
0.0298217088,
0.0322259739,
-0.0675639436,
0.084981963,
-0.0399812981,
-0.0029347369,
-0.019138528,
0.0420082323,
0.0352775343,
-0.0355456397,
0.0218670368,
0.0102767823,
0.0226290263,
-0.0301640779,
0.000002066,
-0.0296897385,
0.0062886658,
-0.0299878642,
-0.01966854,
-0.063769035,
0.0173394177,
-0.0221275967,
-0.0071868249,
0.0375973284,
-0.0331188329,
0.0536709428,
0.0111530768,
0.0887142345,
0.0898475125,
0.0748243332,
-0.0019650485,
-0.0048484094,
-0.0052249138,
-0.0021250572,
0.0016428927,
-0.0461355858,
-0.0000324913,
0.069771409,
0.059886869,
0.0055927793,
0.0062104864,
0.0441538468,
0.0264058001,
-0.0043575652,
0.0349881724,
0.0313055739,
0.0231381655,
-0.0304389074,
-0.0185722094,
0.0940487087,
0.0092105111,
0.0250309743,
0.0187600572,
-0.0193998497,
0.0396187268,
0.04241281,
-0.0324867517,
0.0143593214,
-0.0071845884,
-0.0143507021,
-0.0118148578,
0.0103700403,
-0.0060463673,
-0.0114338668,
0.0224505607,
0.0340125859,
-0.0244838316,
-0.0197860748,
0.01611582,
-0.0293475389,
0.0204561092,
-0.0781217888,
0.000865885,
0.0657017678,
-0.0638501421,
0.0241257101,
-0.0127046825,
0.0505176634,
0.0228387099,
-0.0157914665,
0.0010348074,
0.0478184111,
-0.0382310376,
0.0406985879,
0.0219145324,
0.0150851877,
-0.002830049,
0.0388724394,
-0.0367248505,
0.0109712081,
-0.0672707111,
-0.0150621636,
-0.0433316156,
0.0073053399,
-0.0456878096,
-0.0452980958,
-0.0110693332,
0.0376003198,
-0.0106341755,
0.0161275398,
0.0168255232,
0.043925982,
-0.0163446181,
-0.0240841471,
-0.0746892393,
-0.0099729095,
-0.0316947512,
0.0213469025,
0.0325649269,
-0.0633385628,
-0.0071192584,
0.0265131611,
-0.0172113385,
0.0033280649,
0.0203895234,
0.1000058949,
-0.0223130863,
-0.0126358727,
-0.0194704384,
-0.0388284884,
-0.036691539,
-0.0598529205,
0.0068022339,
-0.0226721298,
0.0066817016,
-0.0328224413,
0.0115031796,
-0.0468346179,
0.0315185003,
-0.0146727897,
-0.0225108266,
0.0567992888,
-0.0424853079,
0.0109041957,
0.0577231161,
0.0592037849,
-0.0250087343,
0.0607938133,
0.0419360064,
0.0169418473,
-0.002849197,
-0.00745305,
0.0144208623,
-0.0010210756,
-0.0357018225,
-0.0220662914,
-0.0093035111,
0.0053202366,
-0.0642001778,
0.0821012855,
-0.0173687767,
0.0409457497,
-0.0405704342,
-0.01728593,
0.0408986285,
0.0457997918,
-0.0308150556,
0.0117523614,
0.0339239612,
0.0150661943,
-0.0031837041,
-0.0261689685,
-0.0212382656,
0.0360348523,
-0.0054682307,
-0.0174280852,
0.0076764883,
-0.015480997,
-0.026861202,
-0.0640833825,
0.0073024253,
0.0044197752,
0.0146670677,
0.0413848795,
0.0075389198,
-0.0021285326,
-0.0423223898,
0.0243883636,
-0.0238076188,
-0.01314981,
-0.0607999824,
-0.0545396805,
0.0162817445,
0.0805116594,
0.042250704,
-0.0299808551,
-0.0781356692,
-0.0209529568,
-0.0009261052,
0.0446813889,
0.0168348048,
-0.0225530136,
0.0335769169,
-0.0287557393,
-0.0211712457,
-0.0304838736,
0.0135375531,
0.0163347721,
0.0086409645,
0.0050722067,
-0.0052704965,
0.0172036402,
0.0074851923,
0.0302321054,
-0.0262057353,
0.0054964107,
-0.0450973511,
-0.0105031636,
0.0371118747,
0.0158715732,
-0.0150087895,
0.0038039885,
0.0434160717,
-0.0345508531,
-0.0336290374,
0.0251133125,
-0.0268684253,
-0.0185105931,
0.0369918644,
0.0021580425,
-0.028584376,
0.0168202091,
-0.0171386357,
-0.0191854872,
-0.0250975545,
-0.0387800336,
0.0467784666,
-0.0140734222,
0.0132397674,
0.00907264,
-0.032171689,
-0.0518685579,
0.0066037732,
-0.0090440596,
-0.0221472476,
0.0273023527,
-0.016187584,
-0.0068901516,
-0.0777275562,
0.0315042138,
0.0275581572,
0.0259382818,
0.0071096634,
0.0117600411,
0.0305129103,
-0.0773056,
-0.0392033979,
-0.1020103991,
-0.0290844534,
-0.0136024822,
-0.0479431301,
0.0013362292,
-0.0341936946,
-0.0252324603,
-0.0286900159,
-0.0328885429,
0.0177626889,
0.0109362137,
-0.0057578175,
0.0482309572,
0.0430787355,
-0.0275985207,
-0.0353156254,
0.0263983626,
0.0193013474,
-0.012735364,
0.0360818133,
-0.016296437,
-0.0585024692,
0.0335755423,
-0.0574538819,
0.027881287,
-0.0296530724,
-0.0515540317,
0.0502065383,
-0.0110191107,
0.0193806626,
0.0697025582,
0.0214972794,
0.0346928611,
0.0273846183,
-0.0258874204,
-0.0852243379,
0.0450576134,
-0.0012457945,
0.0076543139,
-0.0530636311,
-0.0403255299,
0.0284016002,
0.0382832885,
0.0239068177,
0.062730439,
-0.0653796494,
0.0224640556,
0.0522569269,
-0.036390394,
0.0110855326,
-0.0070988233,
-0.0002967197,
0.0503453501,
0.0236629471,
-0.0227872692,
0.0970010906,
-0.0195420384,
-0.0226497632,
0.0138337146,
-0.0474701189,
-0.0253149346,
0.0164532661,
-0.0191538744,
0.0176159069,
0.0074951714,
0.004964625,
-0.0162285808,
-0.0202954877,
-0.0105064902,
-0.0314281769,
0.0147969546,
-0.0821030065,
-0.0046774643,
0.0381881744,
-0.0311890095,
-0.0771179274,
-0.0275689717,
-0.0902761221,
-0.0283573531,
0.0057614185,
-0.0250054318,
-0.0544656031,
-0.0025531687,
0.0222380366,
0.0501620248,
0.0103129623,
-0.0296262596,
-0.0068440158,
-0.0204613172,
0.0427840352,
0.0483842678,
0.0120592667,
-0.0015236876,
0.0644795075,
0.0643582791,
-0.0074881157,
-0.0169291347,
-0.0532561392,
-0.0093664648,
-0.0159223042,
0.0217471644,
0.0276310761,
0.0308996048,
0.0532960929,
-0.0395489708,
-0.0105161276,
0.1219865307,
0.0174045097,
0.0157231204,
0.0014437434,
-0.0616921894,
0.0385890678,
0.0052679679,
-0.0006952308,
-0.0301992185,
-0.0521510802,
-0.0068460507,
0.0261265785,
-0.0298239086,
-0.0182145648,
0.0002235336,
-0.0749244541,
0.0330800824,
-0.0194664691,
0.0092800036,
-0.0295661129,
0.0310399067,
0.0032136268,
-0.0150859598,
-0.0002690954,
0.0036320926,
0.0056560561,
-0.0021654386,
0.0160433929,
-0.0533371717,
-0.0381598957,
0.0517227352,
0.0246112291,
0.0815374255,
0.0553626083,
0.0206685401,
0.0238355882,
-0.0198038016,
0.0471211337,
0.0624654368,
0.0536689796,
-0.0188985523,
0.040748056,
-0.0458971858,
-0.0026119582,
-0.0098020462,
0.0286683999,
-0.0180807598,
-0.0299616568,
0.0453420319,
0.0359639637,
-0.0541195944,
0.0237368476,
-0.0453424603,
0.0688126385,
0.0136809535,
0.0641395375,
0.0346478187,
-0.0310657918,
-0.0287643,
-0.0218545031,
-0.0178045351,
0.0009653369,
-0.0587523691,
-0.0104451226,
0.0044300598,
0.0165425334,
-0.0608231016,
-0.0317585878,
0.0612362735,
0.0241592899,
-0.0127830971,
-0.033914011,
-0.0149824983,
0.0386209004,
0.0126131717,
0.0364790037,
-0.0239788182,
0.0005420611,
-0.0681184381,
-0.0035185223,
0.0297747087,
-0.0563299209,
-0.0130962972,
0.0072724945,
-0.0082265632,
-0.0396550186,
-0.0266536325,
0.0904715285,
0.028619973,
0.0543718264,
0.0061261635,
-0.0407506861,
0.0109330723,
0.019783834,
-0.0349388048,
-0.0074906801,
0.0308126863,
0.0671204031,
0.0078226812,
0.0247907825,
-0.0328484029,
0.0108917532,
0.0013124136,
0.0412827171,
-0.0618012734,
-0.0755333453,
0.0267086532,
0.023573583,
0.0357791409,
0.0080350172,
-0.0004824397,
-0.0159608778,
0.0342242308,
-0.020023426,
0.0033866819,
-0.0774734467,
0.0462243669,
-0.0079990011,
-0.0448876992,
0.0271028709,
-0.0483958758,
-0.074565351,
0.0056741158,
0.0017444725,
-0.0162702873,
0.0157593843,
0.0003112568,
0.0076686,
-0.0185360946,
-0.0071820118,
0.024644522,
-0.0313054994,
0.0452943631,
0.0303852372,
0.1169908047,
0.0195340645,
-0.032694947,
0.0033524763,
0.0444626659,
-0.0618985742,
-0.1437540501,
0.020549925,
0.0242705066,
0.0229094829,
0.0384755321,
0.0160411224,
-0.0561052822,
0.0227306206,
0.0076451707,
0.0446050316,
0.0069677169,
-0.0256749112,
0.059025757,
0.0323960893,
-0.0137661612,
0.0036680645,
0.0145953102,
0.0025242534,
0.0266767442,
0.0018469241,
0.0004644413,
-0.0651135072,
-0.0300056431,
0.0140077136,
0.0374975167,
0.0038791862,
0.0083700772,
-0.0592623875,
-0.0383219942,
-0.0044983793,
0.0288239121,
-0.0318347663,
-0.0420800112,
0.0346006118,
0.0313880928,
-0.0096920617,
-0.0271970052,
-0.0465008691,
0.0305405278,
-0.0114223873,
-0.0010500099,
-0.0323948376,
-5.426329512e-33,
-0.0102957934,
-0.0435351506,
0.0325585641,
-0.0255799778,
-0.0149961598,
-0.0175994299,
-0.0266622826,
0.0078555048,
-0.0350060202,
0.0153654981,
0.0126201659,
0.0324069746,
0.0003561426,
-0.0104402592,
0.0084367208,
-0.0331156552,
0.015656231,
0.0280228741,
-0.026506288,
0.0183496177,
-0.0152452281,
0.0103102662,
0.0254222248,
-0.1135699823,
0.0184119698,
0.0159238223,
-0.0288192295,
0.0333240852,
-0.0046392372,
0.0385511853,
-0.0134777268,
0.0012473998,
0.0135438917,
-0.038954936,
0.0191849787,
-0.0030365279,
-0.0234981515,
-0.0296296068,
0.0279284287,
-0.0278437696,
-0.0887718722,
-0.0227057245,
0.0001006962,
-0.0247030221,
0.0075101336,
-0.0255840123,
0.0099839857,
-0.0435763411,
0.0053752214,
0.0384370163,
-0.036603801,
-0.0041873395,
-0.0528728031,
-0.0656948462,
-0.0028143488,
0.0644274503,
-0.0206107721,
0.0108580338,
0.0017676011,
0.0135383485,
0.0087541388,
-0.045602072,
0.0445516482,
-0.0079256473,
-0.0166355874,
0.0858795643,
0.0270211194,
-0.015328045,
-0.051159557,
-0.0290345941,
-0.0300371572,
0.0754993856,
0.0424768068,
0.0519727506,
0.0104901968,
0.0053855381,
-0.0414759852,
0.0393842757,
-0.0126530975,
0.0692709014,
0.0123339863,
-0.0016649368,
-0.0320706293,
0.0142667228,
-0.0235617906,
0.0217588469,
0.0000531301,
-0.0290775914,
0.0504865684,
0.019640727,
0.0101194028,
-0.0346096382,
-0.0103313141,
-0.0188260674,
0.0299887396,
0.0155808888,
-0.0333083458,
0.0083207125,
-0.0295406915,
0.0098374281,
-0.0297871288,
0.0150720682,
0.0399321169,
-0.0163412523,
0.0391489863,
0.0006231391,
-0.0191541724,
0.0014509817,
-0.0226867143,
-0.0325494111,
-0.0270523131,
0.0431038439,
-0.0222664103,
0.016154388,
-0.015452004,
0.0206188187,
-0.0592303239,
0.0479582697,
-0.0478236899,
-0.0407201052,
-0.0601997413,
0.0035284115,
-0.0100275911,
-0.011555667,
-0.0536924936,
-0.0120167751,
0.0122056883,
-0.0135552147,
-0.0134401284,
-0.0385239534,
-0.0023898147,
-0.0145791629,
2.717e-7,
0.0097852265,
0.0389404409,
0.0053814906,
0.0272252634,
0.0034278503,
0.0524769872,
-0.0140747344,
0.0237507708,
0.0309317168,
-0.0736669898,
0.0292611439,
0.0570532158,
0.0434957668,
-0.0010224348,
-0.0539906621,
-0.0431064591,
-0.0229323823,
-0.0503388904,
-0.0371679552,
0.0105181243,
0.0876630396,
0.0332744643,
0.015475627,
-0.0184352323,
0.0179620385,
-0.0080270572,
0.0389539488,
-0.0759460256,
0.0187419802,
0.037136443,
0.044596456,
-0.0093107345,
0.0079557579,
0.0107008498,
0.0237288028,
-0.0019347713,
-0.0344590396,
0.1152286083,
-0.0374329463,
-0.0416636653,
-0.0004857091,
0.0228714775,
0.0033033222,
-0.0286239423,
0.0300905928,
-0.0557988696,
-0.0205242261,
-0.0197674055,
0.0010661617,
-0.0170170963,
0.0169342272,
-0.0330607444,
-0.0436927527,
0.019940313,
0.0145624699,
-0.0080580879,
0.0119913621,
-0.0492220968,
0.0033711977,
0.0025220439,
-0.0712769255,
-0.0440310538,
-0.0150220366,
-0.015303826,
-0.012214181,
-0.0376008153,
-0.0204414055,
2.161744443e-34,
0.0210918095,
0.0254464801,
0.0093595861,
0.0760601237,
0.0476098694,
0.0491004363,
0.0090041514,
0.0172054823,
0.0152266659,
-0.0568543226,
-0.0229192618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18449v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18449v1 | Taming AI Bots: Controllability of Neural States in Large Language Models | 2023-05-29T03:58:33 | 2023-05-29T03:58:33 | Stefano Soatto, Paulo Tabuada, Pratik Chaudhari, Tian Yu Liu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SY, eess.SY | We tackle the question of whether an agent can, by suitable choice of
prompts, control an AI bot to any state. To that end, we first introduce a
formal definition of ``meaning'' that is amenable to analysis. Then, we
characterize ``meaningful data'' on which large language models (LLMs) are
ostensibly trained, and ``well-trained LLMs'' through conditions that are
largely met by today's LLMs. While a well-trained LLM constructs an embedding
space of meanings that is Euclidean, meanings themselves do not form a vector
(linear) subspace, but rather a quotient space within. We then characterize the
subset of meanings that can be reached by the state of the LLMs for some input
prompt, and show that a well-trained bot can reach any meaning albeit with
small probability. We then introduce a stronger notion of controllability as
{\em almost certain reachability}, and show that, when restricted to the space
of meanings, an AI bot is controllable. We do so after introducing a functional
characterization of attentive AI bots, and finally derive necessary and
sufficient conditions for controllability. The fact that AI bots are
controllable means that an adversary could steer them towards any state.
However, the sampling process can be designed to counteract adverse actions and
avoid reaching undesirable regions of state space before their boundary is
crossed. | [
0.0381005034,
0.0248901229,
-0.0543261245,
0.0026787636,
-0.0508939773,
0.017099537,
-0.0194058958,
0.017861031,
0.0511814877,
-0.0112939514,
-0.032140065,
-0.0186004173,
-0.0338621251,
0.0591211058,
0.0497134924,
-0.0319159627,
0.0503028184,
-0.0353331901,
0.0063772434,
-0.0085939346,
-0.0219408683,
-0.0628687367,
-0.0048637236,
0.0408753157,
-0.0227060933,
-0.0255423561,
-0.0189850833,
-0.0572295003,
-0.0255070608,
-0.0201869309,
-0.0523522943,
-0.0093462467,
0.0215809122,
0.0496664904,
0.0000020109,
-0.0400441512,
-0.0233312622,
-0.0114475703,
-0.0571799576,
-0.0636235178,
0.0198297165,
-0.0109697348,
-0.011905387,
-0.0071212249,
-0.0310561247,
0.0364647694,
0.0475911312,
0.0480855145,
0.03287182,
0.0952102318,
0.0039137546,
-0.0029620312,
0.0471242554,
-0.0100836856,
0.0193850808,
-0.0747252777,
0.0261731595,
0.015947653,
0.0114243543,
0.0063957153,
-0.0631631911,
0.0189678948,
0.0281938892,
-0.0111368783,
-0.0084925145,
0.0211405344,
0.0119105307,
-0.0400189459,
-0.0097247018,
0.0471802466,
0.0003942153,
-0.001690774,
0.0304284059,
0.0026991188,
0.0181164388,
0.0184510406,
-0.011122928,
0.0381077603,
0.018086249,
0.0293000303,
0.011607823,
-0.0092691584,
0.0552712493,
0.0030464598,
-0.0252479743,
0.0711926743,
0.0065496517,
-0.0513547622,
-0.0051346449,
0.008480968,
0.0038683943,
-0.061858546,
-0.020115409,
0.0365682654,
-0.014785151,
0.0410372466,
-0.064339675,
-0.037455488,
-0.0286805965,
-0.0354771838,
0.021127684,
0.0261437837,
0.0095314467,
0.0583099984,
0.0104496097,
0.0648909733,
-0.0500400029,
0.1055898294,
-0.0288349316,
0.0183912497,
-0.0420076028,
-0.0020218194,
-0.049159728,
0.0519931093,
0.0161972288,
-0.0251964703,
-0.0336430296,
0.0411302634,
-0.0447817408,
0.0291660354,
-0.0754302889,
-0.0220429171,
-0.0140963728,
-0.0012674351,
-0.0444694348,
-0.0538171045,
-0.0246287882,
0.0189971086,
-0.0009008556,
-0.0529329255,
-0.0213419832,
0.0078565301,
0.0058789444,
-0.0267041419,
-0.0073050275,
0.103464283,
0.0282970723,
-0.0682061985,
-0.0025600763,
-0.0392802395,
-0.0163504127,
-0.0420656092,
0.0238019414,
-0.0127695911,
0.0085568279,
-0.0050260066,
-0.0112553285,
-0.0756336823,
-0.0209381767,
-0.0169802606,
-0.0338363387,
0.0947092995,
0.0219466835,
-0.0069248076,
-0.0144863203,
0.0086951526,
-0.0459149294,
0.0268707387,
0.0293060821,
0.0440881439,
0.0671569109,
0.0231243316,
0.0659541711,
0.0390731767,
0.0117311105,
0.0152298883,
-0.0265588947,
-0.0021029375,
0.0394933559,
0.0338400565,
-0.0206403416,
0.0656485707,
-0.0289419964,
-0.034950424,
0.0454235561,
0.0644456297,
-0.0367612988,
0.0097172577,
0.0519268662,
-0.0108920606,
0.0059452257,
0.0409304313,
-0.0829504356,
-0.0133490833,
-0.0225451775,
-0.0298787076,
0.0250029583,
-0.0445202962,
-0.0229679737,
-0.0465487204,
0.0120368171,
-0.0343030095,
0.0251494944,
-0.0024490755,
0.0592559054,
0.0081381835,
-0.0178818908,
-0.0093980916,
-0.0156801492,
-0.0319290236,
0.039486222,
-0.0926409662,
0.0409439914,
-0.0081766667,
0.0425529517,
-0.0659987256,
0.0184647515,
-0.0127842361,
-0.0032125551,
0.0518879779,
0.0346193276,
-0.0016470454,
0.007987665,
0.0022104247,
-0.0023270375,
0.0021986759,
0.0211949274,
-0.0175008476,
-0.0592728741,
0.0015098992,
-0.0525359176,
-0.0162260402,
-0.0365565121,
0.0379101522,
0.0046409937,
-0.0541291833,
-0.0377388857,
0.0381067395,
0.0776019022,
0.0078349877,
-0.0361794159,
0.0356660224,
0.0267582051,
-0.0265583154,
-0.0480773821,
-0.0129129523,
0.0085453475,
0.0213355236,
0.0296986178,
-0.0341443643,
-0.0144965667,
0.049813427,
0.0030460618,
-0.0319783241,
0.064415127,
-0.0526688695,
0.0208433494,
0.0170821287,
0.0359456316,
-0.0173132606,
0.0362201445,
-0.0064293025,
0.0459064282,
-0.0088601569,
0.0050370758,
0.0107374452,
0.0270442143,
0.0183601845,
-0.0031944911,
-0.0412990339,
0.0270887278,
-0.0107734362,
0.0117645198,
0.0578196347,
-0.0343500003,
-0.0299312882,
-0.0536541827,
-0.0125891641,
-0.0406262428,
0.016595019,
-0.0029581462,
-0.0014312823,
-0.0301345754,
0.0110103777,
-0.0067740083,
-0.0044925692,
0.0225665327,
0.0190039892,
0.0325524323,
0.045696035,
0.0059064575,
-0.0658362061,
-0.022732079,
-0.0021271545,
-0.016076969,
0.0019597881,
-0.0076996041,
-0.0183901023,
-0.0268323142,
0.0483870916,
-0.0314970464,
0.0458453521,
-0.0458152927,
-0.0450322479,
0.0230403282,
-0.0263527762,
-0.0356480889,
0.0954781845,
0.006610387,
0.0754663795,
0.0597595125,
0.0257718638,
-0.0148953563,
-0.0035090391,
-0.0061070784,
-0.0307293963,
-0.0538790785,
-0.0140835876,
0.0170809068,
0.082716845,
0.0427398607,
-0.0142590245,
-0.0495945178,
0.0467281565,
-0.0363874771,
-0.0536536239,
-0.0120463222,
-0.0029173847,
-0.062722899,
0.0722978488,
-0.0278575644,
-0.0717171878,
0.0586280786,
0.0046284767,
0.0253622066,
0.0155708101,
-0.0350183621,
-0.0088067902,
0.0676862523,
0.0345451832,
0.0079436032,
-0.0007397507,
-0.0181842353,
-0.0363768153,
-0.0499635264,
0.0124297114,
-0.0183448996,
0.0324068628,
-0.0215657279,
0.0386898741,
0.0015806262,
-0.022328347,
-0.0399319939,
-0.0347990431,
-0.0288395286,
-0.012685366,
0.0285726096,
-0.0373694301,
-0.0031210117,
-0.0034559201,
0.0413117781,
-0.0109833488,
-0.0117579168,
-0.011171408,
-0.0336011238,
-0.0164946243,
0.0158590749,
0.0310354885,
0.0097604888,
-0.0158828869,
0.007839377,
0.0257163607,
0.0076788445,
0.030888496,
-0.0032983392,
0.0294423047,
0.0173370596,
-0.005373308,
-0.0347591676,
0.0097593321,
0.0406239666,
-0.0029325816,
-0.0571452565,
0.0713243857,
0.0081721311,
-0.0302991495,
0.0186409317,
0.0027569167,
-0.0489832722,
0.0169837512,
0.0189604405,
-0.0789875761,
-0.0025520576,
0.0202008337,
-0.0019602557,
-0.0596796013,
-0.0429770499,
-0.0383284427,
-0.088625066,
-0.0110317972,
-0.0181316361,
-0.0454937182,
-0.0957337916,
-0.0054239654,
0.0114177,
0.0203025211,
0.0186493602,
-0.0173800495,
0.0240325127,
-0.0001816267,
0.0060380381,
0.0274287015,
0.0192856546,
0.0185891204,
-0.0234772246,
0.0995478034,
0.0728770718,
0.0650034174,
-0.0404917374,
-0.0142983282,
-0.0138517488,
0.0394303799,
-0.0189913623,
0.0306803323,
0.0118541187,
0.007518094,
-0.0308035351,
0.0207948275,
0.0278891604,
0.0399989672,
-0.0102263587,
0.0108007435,
0.0817084312,
-0.0463870727,
-0.0531574339,
-0.0047302721,
-0.0151886996,
0.0302667059,
0.072571665,
0.0376234315,
-0.0372507088,
-0.0343883149,
-0.0216912404,
0.0094774868,
0.006681229,
-0.0628742054,
-0.0022774052,
-0.0159730949,
-0.0306803845,
-0.0618068464,
-0.0292299874,
0.0004002562,
0.0392302908,
0.035291519,
-0.0024514333,
0.0514453948,
-0.0074985633,
0.0354710147,
-0.0071721897,
-0.0755466595,
0.0153060835,
-0.0413820334,
-0.004225478,
-0.0021861966,
-0.0719658434,
-0.0388270095,
0.0104401251,
-0.0204060543,
-0.0561346076,
0.0437493064,
0.0306176115,
0.0333477594,
0.0063575241,
-0.0280275214,
-0.0461994708,
0.037353728,
-0.0287064537,
-0.0026727293,
0.0364597216,
0.0710889623,
0.0433296077,
0.0136604318,
0.07629776,
-0.0707986727,
0.0118002603,
0.0466834493,
0.0052769389,
-0.0123162773,
-0.0035623515,
0.0334722064,
0.0307802111,
0.0101833707,
0.0317799412,
0.0003705984,
-0.0015497059,
-0.027610125,
-0.0053420044,
-0.0066019278,
-0.0474294871,
0.004891085,
0.0187819004,
-0.0017562381,
-0.002367171,
-0.0387841649,
0.004268704,
-0.0018032362,
0.046336852,
-0.0075859395,
-0.0097524347,
0.0234570708,
0.0066271666,
0.0315257385,
0.0160270948,
0.0410883538,
-0.0287090428,
0.0059472835,
0.0290044509,
0.0299428459,
0.0526988693,
0.0062202266,
-0.0533636287,
0.0127924113,
-0.0980581567,
-0.0735920519,
0.0828746632,
0.0654666275,
0.052522406,
0.0109010134,
-0.0197178517,
-0.0187599696,
-0.0045270487,
0.0016978047,
0.0271981005,
0.0449825935,
-0.0418337993,
0.0325635821,
0.0140969381,
0.015901817,
0.0114209065,
0.0291055851,
-0.0333474316,
0.0795324072,
-0.0139373969,
0.0019892768,
-0.0384663939,
-0.0004372975,
-0.0207613688,
0.0091847368,
-0.0105617698,
0.0288059674,
-0.0777516216,
-0.0952403992,
0.0075292503,
0.0501347072,
0.0123883551,
-0.0256565753,
-0.0133409305,
0.0375734642,
0.0144262938,
0.0188666005,
-0.0669480115,
0.0136073781,
0.0330348946,
-0.0261220653,
-0.0218701735,
-6.050901619e-33,
-0.0074537862,
-0.0366476066,
0.0067323591,
-0.0010162389,
-0.019151153,
-0.0145276627,
-0.0300578866,
0.0032028249,
-0.0345690921,
0.0108239669,
-0.0481701531,
0.0243465118,
-0.0007827026,
0.0306666214,
-0.0054408307,
-0.0581654161,
0.01322156,
-0.0301700067,
-0.0445070006,
0.0253248625,
0.0427311584,
-0.01735886,
0.0225355104,
-0.0316213034,
0.0618145354,
0.0106292684,
0.0029571601,
0.0386020765,
-0.0123560131,
0.0429634452,
-0.0249843355,
0.0281215888,
0.0183512401,
-0.0617115349,
-0.0149190435,
0.0389266275,
0.0002138853,
-0.0680179894,
0.0128165949,
-0.0034379978,
-0.0282694083,
-0.0429267138,
0.0286410823,
-0.0393918082,
-0.045265574,
0.0473715737,
0.0075549218,
-0.0162918661,
-0.0089230984,
0.0239738487,
-0.0334145874,
-0.0013490926,
-0.0126433223,
-0.0658092871,
0.0203027558,
-0.0326273516,
0.0054002097,
0.0008338374,
-0.0245999768,
0.0148969116,
-0.0215518177,
0.0099784052,
0.0297350176,
0.0018400474,
0.0461758785,
0.0692698807,
0.0485311076,
0.0176153593,
-0.0258486476,
-0.0395841785,
0.0074037621,
0.0306246448,
0.0213309117,
0.0134209739,
0.0247702319,
-0.032877259,
-0.024389673,
-0.0232074931,
0.0578502789,
0.0363105461,
0.031362921,
-0.0081998929,
-0.0734253749,
0.0053417273,
-0.0338738933,
-0.0814862028,
-0.0289923381,
0.0083257491,
0.0158148948,
0.0259046443,
0.0149794705,
-0.0749581158,
0.0362280197,
-0.079939872,
0.0002110775,
0.0330764465,
0.0121915517,
0.0139032779,
0.0157809015,
-0.0129221408,
0.0063299849,
-0.0264950115,
-0.0494324714,
-0.0250694025,
0.0222277362,
-0.0024825933,
-0.0140833585,
0.0224912502,
-0.010474314,
-0.0219621062,
-0.0385142937,
-0.0080091311,
0.0114718061,
0.0032421832,
0.0554138757,
0.0061701285,
-0.0044477787,
0.0353252254,
0.0052307197,
0.0058722501,
-0.003698953,
0.0527401753,
-0.0401392318,
0.0092967516,
-0.0744788647,
-0.018684404,
-0.0615516715,
0.0919658095,
0.0383469425,
-0.0824572667,
0.0113644069,
-0.0203414727,
2.928e-7,
0.0206000991,
0.0133691188,
0.0199265722,
0.0816675201,
0.0199013185,
0.0663756728,
-0.022547517,
0.0590102859,
-0.0442775451,
-0.0321896002,
-0.003925717,
0.0091601647,
0.0041508111,
-0.0204975978,
-0.0278264005,
0.0138394339,
-0.0213021543,
0.0260980129,
0.0153696751,
0.007443781,
0.0771011412,
0.0860340074,
0.0584962629,
-0.0081635257,
-0.017991839,
-0.0726289451,
0.0101609835,
-0.006149237,
0.0502934456,
-0.0070497766,
0.0356580168,
0.0358473323,
0.0206775423,
0.0225542821,
0.0205955822,
0.0400865488,
-0.0180893652,
0.0722361654,
0.0274601467,
-0.0013473138,
-0.051599212,
-0.0339603387,
-0.0138080781,
0.002985158,
0.0621244833,
-0.0814763978,
-0.0445132256,
-0.0354609862,
0.0303301699,
0.0188552421,
0.0028368135,
0.0116312029,
-0.0479517132,
-0.0117102973,
-0.0059989989,
0.0111448169,
0.0575662851,
-0.0435019732,
0.0214480422,
-0.0270680375,
-0.0434561297,
-0.0459501371,
-0.0108624874,
0.0274974648,
0.0142849237,
-0.0488105379,
-0.0307280384,
2.260437754e-34,
0.0220443457,
-0.0408678986,
0.0270363074,
0.0169966817,
0.0207296144,
-0.0292189587,
0.005206679,
-0.0105977468,
0.0688367039,
-0.049324397,
-0.0362756625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17855v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17855v1 | Vec2Gloss: definition modeling leveraging contextualized vectors with Wordnet gloss | 2023-05-29T02:37:37 | 2023-05-29T02:37:37 | Yu-Hsiang Tseng, Mao-Chang Ku, Wei-Ling Chen, Yu-Lin Chang, Shu-Kai Hsieh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contextualized embeddings are proven to be powerful tools in multiple NLP
tasks. Nonetheless, challenges regarding their interpretability and capability
to represent lexical semantics still remain. In this paper, we propose that the
task of definition modeling, which aims to generate the human-readable
definition of the word, provides a route to evaluate or understand the high
dimensional semantic vectors. We propose a `Vec2Gloss' model, which produces
the gloss from the target word's contextualized embeddings. The generated
glosses of this study are made possible by the systematic gloss patterns
provided by Chinese Wordnet. We devise two dependency indices to measure the
semantic and contextual dependency, which are used to analyze the generated
texts in gloss and token levels. Our results indicate that the proposed
`Vec2Gloss' model opens a new perspective to the lexical-semantic applications
of contextualized embeddings. | [
0.0079319971,
-0.0016954459,
-0.0220620167,
0.0930244401,
-0.0118424082,
0.0023928836,
-0.0226791166,
0.0302738305,
-0.020000197,
-0.0594310015,
0.0309091005,
-0.0409934595,
-0.0170422047,
0.0296378341,
0.032978829,
-0.034792915,
0.0564773753,
0.0621345229,
-0.0678063259,
0.0270217787,
0.0394942462,
0.0069292998,
0.0144471657,
0.0409853533,
-0.0604175664,
-0.0182257686,
0.043358352,
-0.0065996405,
-0.0020716246,
-0.0359248519,
-0.0093851853,
0.0305676032,
0.0181000941,
0.022488568,
0.0000018916,
-0.059978541,
-0.0299889371,
0.0002899957,
0.0212025065,
0.0315232873,
0.107769832,
-0.0368974507,
-0.0049377568,
-0.0363934264,
-0.0342382304,
-0.0294436477,
0.0324379206,
0.0272641256,
0.0260999873,
0.0074540647,
-0.0174251646,
-0.0851100013,
0.0127101019,
-0.0068079708,
-0.0065988493,
-0.0634650663,
-0.0032906334,
0.0879243314,
-0.0429188088,
-0.0033446285,
-0.0634556562,
0.0053177248,
-0.0138971033,
0.0107729528,
0.0280359369,
0.0192585103,
-0.001021741,
0.0033189277,
0.0284113549,
0.0672820807,
0.0093541853,
-0.0104099251,
-0.0288997106,
0.0012337096,
-0.0201052148,
0.054696206,
-0.0268930774,
0.0062844874,
0.0010860007,
0.0226208474,
0.051455915,
0.0098898103,
0.0305190105,
0.0136638964,
-0.047522191,
0.036540065,
0.0121804187,
0.0088607222,
-0.0484503359,
-0.028816374,
-0.0532872342,
-0.0131545654,
-0.0470549874,
-0.0157086831,
0.003785915,
0.0386271849,
-0.0006462847,
-0.0492817014,
0.0371447839,
-0.0540525243,
-0.0108083822,
0.0053967978,
0.0108675705,
0.0101021938,
-0.0614437945,
-0.0018536755,
-0.0289698076,
-0.0106687807,
-0.057632044,
-0.0350801796,
-0.0364502035,
-0.0008515571,
-0.0664501414,
0.0155090699,
-0.033335533,
-0.038635578,
-0.0491848849,
0.0261691939,
-0.0154333366,
0.0080649452,
-0.0522074923,
0.0088757155,
-0.0013772853,
0.0136293154,
-0.019464111,
-0.0673255175,
-0.0625999793,
0.0232219025,
-0.031620834,
-0.0032959855,
-0.0059066531,
0.0183540639,
0.0220110435,
0.0018030773,
-0.0321938321,
0.0748770311,
0.0626333877,
-0.0294600595,
-0.0258977134,
-0.057978835,
-0.0319708325,
0.0269949641,
-0.0483673923,
-0.0731148124,
-0.0286149494,
0.0048258035,
0.0082410499,
-0.0173262153,
-0.0078277448,
0.0180018991,
-0.0149321556,
0.0819728449,
-0.0397013314,
-0.0308086704,
-0.0027076562,
0.0074701142,
0.001418645,
0.0338246003,
0.0413401723,
0.0033610526,
0.0696512833,
-0.0179434773,
-0.027586991,
-0.0291351974,
-0.0033592714,
-0.0112790531,
-0.0846600384,
-0.0177096557,
0.0378535502,
0.0403382778,
0.0231465306,
0.0396742113,
-0.0701174438,
-0.0096871052,
0.0135581959,
0.0818438902,
0.0229507443,
0.028791951,
0.0767947882,
-0.0097886035,
-0.0410366431,
0.0235930756,
0.0068509583,
-0.0286021624,
-0.0169114433,
0.0017144275,
-0.0155813219,
-0.0147932163,
-0.0059717121,
-0.0391561911,
-0.015218325,
-0.0237103514,
0.0522622764,
-0.0796230882,
0.0449206047,
0.0186035335,
-0.0101989536,
0.027159404,
0.0457518511,
-0.028086042,
0.0268192273,
-0.021626601,
0.0362389162,
0.0775767267,
0.0730900392,
0.0061057336,
-0.0164497942,
0.0083336383,
-0.024420172,
0.0426122844,
0.0222116169,
-0.0426056907,
-0.0689097643,
-0.0426624529,
0.0034595001,
-0.0266654883,
0.00143786,
-0.00229304,
0.018500274,
0.0164019503,
0.0187392272,
-0.0347491316,
-0.0490418673,
0.034672711,
-0.0029115037,
-0.0095462296,
0.0020054192,
-0.0157497115,
0.0404663086,
0.0310817026,
-0.0468993671,
0.0320361331,
0.0269422103,
-0.0585484654,
-0.0564279817,
0.0000563604,
-0.0198181067,
0.0070092184,
-0.0043397383,
-0.0460607409,
0.0645600036,
-0.0054007471,
-0.0250882152,
-0.0177884065,
0.0208967235,
0.0142862787,
0.0978823826,
-0.0790524855,
-0.0205508079,
-0.0004107346,
0.0681971535,
-0.0205032863,
0.0736820847,
0.0023910131,
0.0557462685,
-0.0223594457,
0.0894251093,
0.0168785378,
0.0231630076,
-0.0478538312,
-0.0028433218,
0.0270491242,
0.0262510423,
0.0033460928,
0.0122002736,
-0.0141689563,
-0.0047864243,
-0.0928656235,
0.0282361396,
-0.0078170514,
-0.0013227188,
0.0406216457,
-0.0115039991,
0.023048088,
0.0221924111,
-0.0041180439,
0.0557303056,
-0.0271445923,
-0.0154682267,
0.0285571292,
-0.0288353022,
-0.0348813608,
-0.0103710722,
-0.0123710176,
-0.0036623378,
0.0396872833,
0.0129801091,
0.0053214156,
-0.004788918,
0.0108591039,
-0.053253945,
-0.0021195901,
-0.0055471705,
-0.0332575031,
-0.0095560309,
-0.0084768599,
-0.0236913972,
-0.0171533022,
0.0402208157,
0.0464163125,
0.0300224442,
-0.0266307145,
-0.0061813323,
-0.0330698751,
-0.0184873957,
0.0058340649,
-0.0262314379,
0.0148930782,
-0.0061823078,
0.0329541117,
0.0429135375,
-0.0129402131,
-0.0272262208,
0.0210163724,
-0.0753288791,
-0.0173265692,
-0.0388143845,
0.0175663643,
-0.0519784652,
0.0235590357,
-0.0007793951,
-0.0192826912,
0.0002260255,
-0.0151958596,
0.0346251205,
-0.0191296451,
0.0158820208,
-0.0282464419,
0.0539001934,
-0.0355906412,
0.0500148721,
-0.0210452024,
-0.0272248965,
-0.0150926085,
-0.0097376155,
0.0025299974,
-0.0342329331,
0.0288827382,
-0.0385755673,
0.0062796143,
-0.0116689038,
0.0504154414,
-0.0243310798,
-0.020444613,
-0.0048898826,
0.0578876324,
0.0918027684,
-0.0084894374,
0.0746659935,
0.0408775881,
-0.0323588401,
-0.0002926901,
0.019517757,
-0.0053515267,
-0.0437195785,
0.0640122592,
0.0382864103,
0.0264677741,
0.0138618676,
0.0509737022,
0.0313511267,
0.0430471078,
-0.0075867805,
0.0328097306,
-0.0337160304,
-0.0058093383,
0.0126977768,
-0.0244688988,
-0.0272301212,
-0.0104444856,
-0.033493869,
-0.0143090123,
0.000056774,
0.093840979,
0.0551721752,
-0.0595648587,
0.0504454598,
-0.0005604032,
-0.0038347994,
0.0306328516,
-0.0245313831,
-0.1066022366,
-0.0060188374,
-0.0059375586,
-0.0321754031,
0.04460885,
-0.019224653,
0.0032024472,
-0.0738293827,
0.0372269936,
-0.0120918546,
-0.0325780027,
0.0296575911,
-0.0251814201,
0.000039589,
-0.003468595,
0.0211913753,
-0.0166717023,
0.002805976,
-0.0316518731,
-0.0117902067,
0.0055493531,
-0.0428952202,
0.0648174882,
-0.0181525592,
0.0447508022,
0.0378734283,
0.0562658086,
-0.0453336425,
0.0199849289,
0.0238617845,
-0.0955947563,
-0.0225635618,
-0.0100100003,
0.0613157265,
-0.033896815,
-0.0032941781,
0.0360129401,
-0.0081975842,
-0.0251998659,
-0.0257089045,
-0.0199423097,
0.0413116664,
0.0033398545,
0.013031967,
-0.0250430908,
-0.0235577747,
-0.0091140261,
0.0613687597,
0.0093590431,
-0.0372769907,
0.0158389322,
0.0169122498,
0.0047881701,
-0.0065106931,
-0.0819853544,
0.0100361705,
-0.0045404825,
-0.0111984145,
-0.090658851,
-0.0477525219,
0.0007233163,
0.0219709314,
0.0092519093,
0.0688972026,
-0.0146074602,
-0.0332556553,
-0.0497388653,
0.0106000882,
0.0316586159,
0.0250210706,
-0.027391728,
-0.029973764,
0.0503170751,
0.0011936263,
-0.0327251367,
0.0706123486,
0.0259832963,
0.0036221307,
-0.002155832,
-0.0303500276,
0.008754503,
0.0054052444,
-0.0614192151,
-0.0167341772,
0.0372009054,
-0.0242315568,
0.0064810449,
0.0243014786,
-0.0069732037,
0.0392314605,
0.0099168438,
0.0539304838,
-0.0314464793,
0.041122403,
-0.0262238104,
0.0521224178,
-0.0298275445,
-0.0331963338,
0.0135702258,
-0.0137458295,
-0.0032803905,
-0.0493653454,
-0.0051176432,
-0.0538338535,
-0.0016196442,
-0.0789512247,
-0.035323482,
-0.0387674831,
-0.0036620602,
0.0112454854,
-0.0372218415,
-0.0271026324,
0.0212698299,
-0.0050780941,
-0.0181508213,
0.0113999937,
-0.0048441063,
-0.0174072571,
-0.0200453307,
-0.0050073997,
0.028827427,
-0.0073030489,
-0.0557410717,
-0.0787938014,
-0.0287136417,
-0.0739727169,
0.0221465062,
0.0234305579,
-0.0086413249,
-0.0534261018,
0.0465086848,
-0.010046836,
-0.017199276,
-0.0105795553,
0.0043101418,
0.038488239,
-0.0461540036,
0.0545465574,
-0.0433633812,
-0.0187605731,
-0.0111063179,
0.0299062841,
0.0231189989,
-0.0322853662,
0.0170606691,
0.0293432642,
-0.0317550227,
-0.0147146294,
0.074352704,
-0.0096431188,
0.027179921,
-0.0283292625,
-0.0228205044,
-0.0365572944,
0.0048526572,
0.0626872256,
0.0468831733,
-0.0172871016,
0.0436925143,
-0.1156867445,
-0.0699587688,
0.0304346383,
0.0291933995,
-0.011528112,
0.0058589606,
0.0458098352,
0.0616870858,
0.0514993109,
0.0063321339,
-0.034291476,
0.0098572923,
-0.0495429337,
-0.0382038914,
-0.0096518472,
-6.239518871e-33,
-0.0332582518,
-0.0540647432,
-0.00992011,
0.0322576948,
-0.0281600337,
0.0456107184,
-0.0248306841,
-0.0117552727,
-0.00306597,
0.0342503376,
0.0221559163,
0.0228853952,
-0.0050922921,
-0.0022317006,
0.0009048379,
0.0425368845,
-0.0219305269,
-0.0081936326,
0.0352828093,
0.0271108001,
0.0977356657,
0.0039806329,
0.0410173498,
-0.0489447676,
0.0432394929,
0.0019015366,
0.0361004733,
0.000632507,
0.0247285459,
0.0513639003,
-0.0511719361,
0.0568745732,
0.056688562,
0.0044256449,
0.0250237621,
0.0052271388,
-0.0521061271,
-0.0440490916,
0.009142898,
-0.0278937221,
-0.053955391,
-0.0099834809,
0.023558354,
-0.0035874017,
-0.0015863056,
0.0634353086,
0.0542939864,
-0.0056135957,
-0.064797692,
-0.0102339126,
-0.0746804327,
0.055726029,
0.0078339828,
0.0187670197,
0.0402132198,
-0.0710016415,
0.0074260919,
0.0176169332,
-0.015231546,
-0.0139163118,
-0.0543848239,
0.0468901359,
0.0004905794,
0.0342483334,
0.0077925157,
0.0706173405,
-0.0014816796,
-0.0369715504,
0.0113697154,
0.0062286099,
0.0205199048,
0.0542327203,
-0.0160348807,
0.0619181357,
0.0185514111,
-0.0306301843,
-0.0254133623,
0.0086061927,
-0.0126214428,
0.0525106378,
0.0373928957,
-0.0362597369,
-0.0212233625,
-0.0041395281,
-0.0370464958,
-0.0101390723,
-0.0368138701,
-0.0326683633,
0.028953284,
-0.0295243636,
-0.0168761574,
-0.0137525536,
0.0020310064,
-0.0596177094,
0.0044252095,
0.0278268065,
0.0085487226,
0.0136125581,
-0.0113149351,
0.0162179377,
-0.0115838544,
-0.0619007386,
-0.0294570699,
0.0009704015,
0.0177926887,
-0.0066274218,
0.0338962898,
0.0135453707,
0.0207838975,
0.007682154,
-0.025252942,
-0.0870912746,
-0.0522166379,
-0.000245632,
0.0248651765,
0.0158219747,
-0.0049085622,
-0.0107486835,
0.0819963589,
0.0275378674,
0.0156089934,
-0.0344298705,
-0.0124501558,
0.0111200148,
-0.0282572396,
0.025683837,
-0.0235968158,
0.0448385328,
0.0667942688,
-0.0225137342,
-0.006048603,
0.0029738601,
2.736e-7,
0.0737517402,
0.0221096706,
-0.0093421685,
0.0513123386,
0.0345574357,
-0.0119578978,
0.0035650362,
0.0456605852,
-0.0736916959,
-0.0247646905,
0.0248951986,
0.0338034108,
-0.0088268649,
0.0329314508,
-0.0475327261,
0.0759558156,
0.0025060296,
0.0421646312,
0.0036025606,
0.035735324,
0.1059074402,
0.0733450651,
-0.0059768823,
-0.0011142918,
-0.0428031906,
-0.0355832726,
0.0436986573,
-0.0210850984,
-0.0118318656,
0.0275989603,
0.0139015727,
0.0351285599,
0.0222526193,
-0.0003380246,
-0.0129991658,
0.0471735671,
0.0166303441,
0.009502436,
-0.0530285835,
0.0076826122,
-0.0211845916,
-0.0721809417,
0.0242320001,
-0.0517251119,
0.0640191361,
0.0192540772,
-0.0157829653,
-0.0098018097,
-0.0101953419,
0.0679027215,
-0.0109160338,
0.0020561602,
-0.0692963451,
0.0228588562,
0.0174719058,
0.0159662794,
-0.0364316441,
-0.0904896259,
0.0114048785,
0.0109958127,
-0.021197468,
-0.0244593229,
0.0282007065,
-0.0202100053,
0.0271676984,
0.0178726148,
-0.0065835803,
2.178000014e-34,
0.0397953503,
0.0274936277,
0.0188820083,
0.0415687896,
0.0313117728,
-0.0010329663,
-0.0107452152,
0.029666502,
-0.0147214085,
-0.0710250959,
-0.0277223494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17854v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17854v1 | E-NER: Evidential Deep Learning for Trustworthy Named Entity Recognition | 2023-05-29T02:36:16 | 2023-05-29T02:36:16 | Zhen Zhang, Mengting Hu, Shiwan Zhao, Minlie Huang, Haotian Wang, Lemao Liu, Zhirui Zhang, Zhe Liu, Bingzhe Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Most named entity recognition (NER) systems focus on improving model
performance, ignoring the need to quantify model uncertainty, which is critical
to the reliability of NER systems in open environments. Evidential deep
learning (EDL) has recently been proposed as a promising solution to explicitly
model predictive uncertainty for classification tasks. However, directly
applying EDL to NER applications faces two challenges, i.e., the problems of
sparse entities and OOV/OOD entities in NER tasks. To address these challenges,
we propose a trustworthy NER framework named E-NER by introducing two
uncertainty-guided loss terms to the conventional EDL, along with a series of
uncertainty-guided training strategies. Experiments show that E-NER can be
applied to multiple NER paradigms to obtain accurate uncertainty estimation.
Furthermore, compared to state-of-the-art baselines, the proposed method
achieves a better OOV/OOD detection performance and better generalization
ability on OOV entities. | [
0.0213829633,
0.1132304445,
0.0444787294,
0.0461502299,
0.0140057411,
0.0253966935,
-0.0155417677,
-0.0074373176,
-0.0086630955,
0.0276032723,
-0.0043077283,
-0.0265730228,
-0.0043678461,
0.0129515156,
0.0046540345,
-0.0126792891,
0.0133126387,
0.0003948306,
0.0493943579,
0.0037938377,
-0.0021744359,
-0.0130589223,
-0.0250396188,
0.0089023151,
-0.009538536,
-0.0068738912,
-0.0323038176,
0.0289428104,
0.0574222989,
-0.0862474516,
0.0109649198,
0.0244496558,
-0.0015232535,
0.0672934055,
0.000002067,
-0.0633965731,
-0.069342874,
0.0194047857,
-0.0751804337,
-0.0176676679,
-0.0024798189,
-0.0082801199,
-0.0224375762,
-0.0034028846,
0.0165178478,
-0.0656541064,
0.0683278665,
0.0858672112,
0.0017249099,
0.0730784386,
0.0051551848,
0.0346192233,
0.0523254089,
-0.0111892251,
-0.016293779,
-0.0283685736,
0.0257626958,
-0.0786228105,
-0.0593606792,
0.0148674659,
0.0053994805,
0.0230709538,
0.0235792678,
0.0128694698,
-0.0091180345,
0.0331196152,
0.0114029236,
-0.001026254,
-0.0276355799,
0.04783912,
-0.0032343536,
0.0179617777,
-0.0042288685,
-0.0217416175,
-0.0042921249,
-0.0362354144,
0.0011224748,
0.0344652459,
-0.030185163,
-0.0039230492,
-0.0166791826,
0.0378737301,
0.0294583105,
0.0194207504,
-0.0233737156,
0.0347609594,
0.0008202706,
-0.0196047667,
0.0287637133,
-0.0084122643,
-0.0454245694,
-0.0293193907,
0.0451628454,
0.0150109343,
0.01741134,
0.0281118471,
-0.056779027,
-0.0047058715,
0.0246860776,
0.0001527712,
-0.0110699711,
-0.0063536405,
-0.014394897,
0.0257429164,
-0.0342087932,
0.0090700202,
-0.0191193223,
0.0182037111,
0.0516489632,
-0.0267474018,
-0.008960207,
0.0016275476,
-0.0204706006,
0.0481228046,
-0.0124762245,
-0.0082743345,
-0.0618477091,
0.00566376,
-0.0542602167,
0.0431644619,
0.0126101989,
0.0383376293,
-0.0076664402,
-0.0369914323,
-0.0474306121,
0.0051783696,
0.0262561608,
0.0144789014,
0.0136320982,
-0.0866476893,
0.0088830981,
0.0093479082,
0.0105117075,
-0.0241920743,
0.0044242856,
0.0680799484,
0.0302002393,
-0.095433265,
-0.0459737107,
0.0014403502,
-0.0103109861,
-0.034171395,
-0.0228451211,
-0.0342353135,
-0.030695999,
-0.0284255687,
0.0158877838,
-0.0906064436,
0.0335394256,
-0.00060069,
-0.0097095752,
0.0757175311,
-0.0741313472,
-0.0701150745,
-0.001032974,
-0.0001078189,
0.0155009599,
0.0126838787,
0.0474671088,
0.0138878161,
0.0355442055,
0.0460809767,
-0.0060160002,
-0.0337076113,
0.0353938304,
-0.0287236255,
0.0343015492,
-0.0096402075,
-0.0507436022,
0.0197347254,
0.0170484483,
0.0706077293,
0.0071511646,
-0.0491811112,
0.0616935827,
-0.007190851,
0.0096878903,
-0.0213670544,
0.0125943776,
0.0090262899,
-0.000238298,
-0.0232410319,
-0.0429428704,
0.0040849294,
-0.034928333,
-0.0117668966,
-0.0167165697,
0.0459669828,
-0.008929383,
-0.031047048,
-0.0441901907,
-0.0085424613,
-0.0293518249,
0.0082072923,
0.0676458776,
-0.0308818053,
-0.0658249706,
0.0303455051,
0.0341429338,
-0.0038392066,
0.0003140357,
-0.041294042,
0.0378091969,
0.0107168993,
0.012617806,
-0.0406388044,
-0.0411411747,
-0.0515270978,
-0.0297710765,
0.0346573479,
0.0025974608,
0.0206137374,
0.06667725,
-0.0240392145,
-0.0155723784,
0.0127191991,
0.0127004208,
0.0327436663,
0.0410849825,
0.0607694313,
0.0238777231,
-0.0085630519,
-0.0272143018,
0.034226764,
0.0382799432,
-0.0312850587,
0.0418409705,
0.0466206931,
0.0347670652,
0.0518168882,
-0.0132251428,
-0.0095124608,
0.029330492,
0.0177060571,
-0.0626324043,
-0.0507955849,
-0.0113653177,
-0.0014096844,
0.0266628619,
-0.0383573547,
0.0055899429,
-0.0261788331,
-0.0255961809,
-0.0370991603,
-0.048020307,
-0.0175134782,
0.0216851234,
-0.022982832,
0.0038541255,
0.0153840873,
0.0362439379,
-0.023787884,
0.0559186935,
-0.0503449626,
-0.007603942,
0.0166404713,
0.0178523827,
0.0149433101,
-0.0405242555,
-0.0613860898,
-0.0288348719,
-0.0387146808,
-0.0052991258,
0.0421875417,
0.0144567238,
-0.0333863385,
-0.0184885412,
-0.0509180762,
0.0096243024,
-0.0338730328,
0.0357902236,
-0.0256708954,
-0.003263324,
0.0021415232,
0.0073432457,
0.002502487,
0.0100808702,
-0.0189467557,
-0.0006259687,
0.0284397136,
0.000725045,
-0.0363184512,
0.0442729369,
-0.0128599778,
-0.0172259212,
0.0178903621,
0.0084839221,
-0.0477090515,
-0.0699283704,
0.0496677756,
-0.0307317358,
0.0102654975,
0.0118990429,
0.0367945619,
-0.0051885052,
0.022634767,
-0.0370439179,
0.0373594277,
-0.020879237,
0.0324027091,
-0.0098128663,
-0.0281478669,
0.0032066735,
0.0320673659,
-0.0263041556,
0.0231716502,
-0.0022922021,
0.0061108405,
-0.0076563233,
0.0163013767,
-0.0323160663,
0.0090905661,
-0.0089991577,
0.0021538055,
0.0196705889,
-0.0252147727,
0.0087973299,
0.0217835288,
0.0104819732,
0.0123593621,
-0.0104382252,
-0.0285995454,
0.0861277878,
-0.0330829099,
0.0075624045,
0.0242421925,
-0.0037795934,
-0.0025025832,
-0.010317225,
0.0184177272,
0.006268817,
0.0889095217,
-0.0719899461,
-0.0035279894,
0.0050643752,
0.0222472902,
-0.0207667705,
0.0242595933,
0.0091857687,
0.0174657777,
-0.0191791337,
-0.0244059227,
-0.0580830909,
-0.0031175399,
-0.0060207294,
0.0402338728,
0.005748915,
-0.0381833464,
-0.0420751683,
0.0035980516,
-0.0252156612,
0.0357573926,
0.002216391,
-0.0170849115,
-0.0261921845,
0.0399993658,
-0.0036573724,
0.0287268944,
0.1211292073,
-0.0113560259,
-0.0379654542,
0.031521406,
-0.0108819883,
-0.0483917333,
-0.0342998616,
-0.0111308368,
0.0263421535,
-0.0350535922,
0.0238480009,
0.0092546083,
0.0579300448,
-0.0451690629,
0.0033735896,
0.0729236305,
-0.0336052999,
-0.0003222015,
-0.0313759893,
0.0132341441,
0.0552898906,
-0.0009690514,
-0.0068977796,
-0.0843939781,
-0.0535188168,
0.0192656126,
0.0027994772,
-0.0083473939,
-0.0779626071,
-0.0028627936,
-0.0849878192,
0.0131101506,
-0.0477069654,
-0.0465061739,
0.0024351827,
-0.0797730908,
0.0037259585,
-0.0582784601,
0.023037402,
-0.0386621803,
-0.0117903873,
-0.0434566773,
0.0069022272,
0.022373952,
-0.0531410538,
-0.0171751566,
-0.0843837932,
0.0695086271,
0.0029440909,
0.0029549594,
-0.019049041,
-0.0291898027,
-0.0568782054,
-0.0591182075,
-0.0385122187,
0.0006125829,
0.051097881,
-0.0501066782,
-0.0153444912,
-0.0159685835,
0.0340301208,
-0.0133786453,
0.0022897418,
-0.0206385367,
0.0474771485,
-0.0010177467,
0.0162474625,
-0.0152901588,
-0.0543222316,
0.0531664714,
0.0457589924,
-0.0262627769,
0.0076142806,
-0.0315595493,
0.0056276275,
0.0267885979,
-0.0007510171,
0.0580439754,
0.0166007653,
-0.0212075803,
-0.0828480348,
-0.0160136204,
-0.03717646,
-0.0096948482,
0.0507096648,
0.0020028132,
-0.0390495248,
0.0585198514,
0.015285993,
-0.0757329315,
0.0247052722,
-0.0173551589,
0.044564683,
-0.054318618,
0.0610632002,
0.0018465383,
0.0297854487,
-0.0261786524,
0.0452313162,
-0.1100229993,
-0.0602582656,
0.0103810336,
0.0351027623,
0.0120816734,
0.0121205198,
-0.0188621804,
-0.0425738059,
0.0766541287,
0.0556623824,
0.002450044,
-0.0373335257,
0.0487510562,
-0.000435031,
-0.007889431,
0.032225512,
0.0069843819,
0.0047619152,
0.0249485578,
-0.0033399989,
-0.010130926,
-0.0594099239,
-0.0221240427,
-0.0011154889,
0.0588605329,
-0.0121290712,
-0.0148498556,
-0.0593180284,
0.0418589823,
0.0340035185,
0.0302348584,
-0.0126203746,
0.007113683,
0.0160016809,
-0.0033765682,
-0.0140205016,
0.0581995621,
0.0375489667,
0.0054360516,
-0.0371127315,
0.010200995,
0.034045469,
0.0154567584,
0.0131056588,
-0.012888601,
-0.0145875895,
0.0950340778,
0.027272338,
0.0388116762,
0.0010121517,
0.0207393933,
0.0139068728,
-0.0135831283,
-0.0240942165,
-0.0116931163,
-0.0161563437,
-0.0105826063,
-0.0547301993,
0.0793350637,
0.0526704602,
0.0272339024,
0.0105435718,
-0.0471494943,
-0.005234364,
-0.0137579879,
0.0047116149,
-0.007421975,
-0.0058895843,
0.0474414304,
0.0116581079,
0.0119034238,
0.0490660407,
0.035256207,
0.0206456911,
0.0297006145,
-0.0262245722,
-0.0549146011,
-0.0530497208,
-0.0198305808,
0.0563964359,
0.0351057164,
-0.0376740657,
0.0225683376,
0.0124912905,
-0.0500264466,
0.0384325311,
-0.0250637606,
0.0115898428,
0.0023093056,
0.0062024561,
0.0139158368,
0.0008325235,
-0.0197265372,
-0.0130354017,
-0.0383750238,
0.0138714723,
-0.0008326608,
-0.0071556293,
-6.084670266e-33,
0.0120835323,
-0.0410053171,
0.0063455468,
-0.0115439063,
0.0023349258,
0.0700247511,
0.0021474091,
0.0012377445,
-0.0103679076,
0.0315634757,
-0.0035844005,
-0.0062324731,
0.0329107493,
0.0459461175,
-0.034292534,
-0.0358384848,
0.0651925206,
0.0274201427,
0.0135313598,
-0.0075216116,
0.0650161058,
0.0577240288,
0.0807143822,
-0.0839470848,
0.0541659482,
0.0423831157,
-0.0398697779,
0.0415148027,
0.0212609265,
0.0467770994,
-0.0453968681,
-0.0062664957,
-0.0294984728,
-0.0462185517,
0.0040134252,
-0.0397772193,
-0.1376988888,
-0.000562314,
-0.0486459993,
0.0358535573,
-0.0341351107,
-0.0033985833,
0.0492020212,
0.0047860602,
0.0093266135,
0.007058111,
0.0051472262,
0.0077465773,
-0.0163299721,
-0.0547340773,
-0.0338748209,
0.0713607743,
0.0198752452,
0.0128436768,
0.0509771518,
-0.0537157021,
0.0078615611,
-0.0514008142,
-0.0960304216,
-0.0646446571,
0.0127869667,
-0.0375721119,
0.0383862704,
0.0290198028,
-0.0568639636,
0.0330830812,
0.0178813059,
-0.0168774314,
-0.0285414774,
-0.0142475078,
0.0222865343,
0.0434247293,
0.0323279351,
0.0549190938,
0.073183693,
-0.0046294271,
-0.1115301773,
0.0064242939,
0.0154055879,
0.0522423014,
0.0182093475,
-0.0034311789,
-0.0768356696,
0.0176660977,
0.0058886656,
-0.062854588,
-0.0503270552,
0.0056101815,
-0.0072412589,
0.0321698636,
-0.0753476024,
0.0649309531,
0.0213202741,
-0.0020112223,
-0.0345046371,
0.0270186532,
0.0713103339,
0.0115751103,
0.0035367229,
0.0203662179,
-0.0640650019,
-0.012280399,
-0.002778006,
-0.0098946691,
-0.0113232248,
-0.0032869659,
0.0671616718,
0.005335879,
-0.0590784773,
0.0128015392,
-0.0065570646,
0.0182334129,
-0.0032773218,
0.0282616317,
0.0352993049,
-0.0434784628,
0.0076481556,
0.0384462737,
0.0339216776,
0.0285130832,
0.0102875279,
0.0308329817,
0.0476720519,
0.015655959,
-0.0060543395,
-0.0360467322,
0.0116635785,
-0.0567734204,
-0.038545046,
-0.0585182123,
0.0152147254,
0.0095906947,
2.781e-7,
-0.0334256887,
-0.0140115712,
0.036445599,
-0.0002260042,
-0.0170753654,
0.0223111846,
0.0413457714,
0.0458693579,
-0.0687239319,
-0.044345241,
0.0127503313,
0.0013763371,
0.0012425615,
0.0358888879,
-0.0647306517,
-0.0851067156,
0.0162216276,
0.0035453644,
-0.0258065425,
-0.0004206451,
0.0438602977,
0.0777719691,
0.0320225619,
-0.0543482602,
0.0073425462,
0.0044204029,
0.0416731574,
0.0289275814,
0.0452162623,
0.0248579141,
0.0946234316,
0.0503515489,
-0.0296176672,
0.0417552441,
0.0125222951,
0.0431210995,
-0.0090055875,
0.0546666197,
0.005475475,
0.0215222426,
0.0099753216,
-0.0394997671,
0.0153104896,
-0.0242497548,
0.0546244457,
-0.035858687,
-0.0330176018,
-0.0061644134,
-0.0234465059,
-0.0472124927,
0.0633862615,
-0.012731405,
-0.0079955645,
0.0021208406,
-0.0048375479,
-0.0200958736,
-0.0405773781,
-0.0616545305,
0.0409044102,
-0.0129072452,
0.0000977433,
-0.0061599067,
0.0107638678,
-0.0314179398,
0.0435666591,
-0.0657765716,
-0.007174274,
2.531250531e-34,
0.0241798405,
-0.007737692,
-0.0511264093,
0.0201640185,
0.0253507122,
-0.000855658,
0.0086570987,
-0.0188975483,
0.0035916532,
-0.0381272472,
0.0058110496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17846v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17846v1 | Retraining-free Customized ASR for Enharmonic Words Based on a Named-Entity-Aware Model and Phoneme Similarity Estimation | 2023-05-29T02:10:13 | 2023-05-29T02:10:13 | Yui Sudo, Kazuya Hata, Kazuhiro Nakadai | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | End-to-end automatic speech recognition (E2E-ASR) has the potential to
improve performance, but a specific issue that needs to be addressed is the
difficulty it has in handling enharmonic words: named entities (NEs) with the
same pronunciation and part of speech that are spelled differently. This often
occurs with Japanese personal names that have the same pronunciation but
different Kanji characters. Since such NE words tend to be important keywords,
ASR easily loses user trust if it misrecognizes them. To solve these problems,
this paper proposes a novel retraining-free customized method for E2E-ASRs
based on a named-entity-aware E2E-ASR model and phoneme similarity estimation.
Experimental results show that the proposed method improves the target NE
character error rate by 35.7% on average relative to the conventional E2E-ASR
model when selecting personal names as a target NE. | [
0.019176133,
0.0308108274,
0.0134811625,
0.0234143846,
0.0327742808,
0.0177238379,
0.0046987799,
0.0177518912,
-0.0078050653,
0.016123753,
-0.0618373416,
0.00065845,
0.0536213033,
-0.0151925031,
0.0003548648,
-0.0349523947,
0.0067500551,
-0.0186258424,
0.0293235164,
-0.026119519,
0.0347572938,
0.0227075424,
-0.0057302932,
0.0387005247,
0.0140455943,
0.0595765635,
-0.0069070277,
0.0363833904,
0.0470665134,
-0.0532143638,
-0.0230435468,
0.0031164521,
-0.0302195176,
0.0168149527,
0.0000018913,
-0.0571150333,
-0.0631379783,
-0.0265909806,
-0.0550633855,
-0.0395521447,
0.0025612731,
0.0242088884,
-0.0211487953,
0.040850535,
0.0274173561,
0.0049598874,
0.0829999819,
0.0180366486,
0.0222548824,
0.0294915531,
-0.0078104837,
-0.0282450784,
-0.0067047277,
-0.0116787497,
-0.042907577,
-0.0092476839,
0.0050939452,
-0.0752363577,
-0.075235866,
-0.0347342826,
0.0003191957,
0.0142615046,
-0.0405012593,
0.0344250314,
0.0487123504,
0.0052429675,
0.0017963909,
-0.002522721,
-0.0071028955,
0.0697036907,
-0.0310806837,
-0.016656436,
0.0339442603,
-0.0207789149,
-0.052530311,
0.007782721,
0.0512334779,
-0.0274721086,
-0.0531217493,
-0.0181599315,
0.0333156437,
0.0591399595,
0.0114844181,
-0.0122519499,
-0.0184134152,
0.0226827469,
0.0530569591,
-0.0626895726,
0.0124138957,
-0.0220207889,
0.0118025215,
-0.0104903169,
0.075364165,
0.0143928723,
-0.0110607967,
0.0441865623,
-0.013922371,
-0.0553247668,
-0.0041061286,
-0.0601447374,
-0.0182137862,
0.0480168648,
0.0075330315,
-0.0537422746,
-0.0274588298,
0.0271990821,
0.0506337993,
-0.0225783437,
0.0202556364,
-0.0115271332,
-0.0242085978,
0.0066385786,
-0.0950824693,
0.0464882404,
-0.0238983147,
-0.0265059285,
-0.0644655898,
0.0004056126,
-0.0228864327,
-0.0090575023,
0.0719623864,
-0.027914729,
-0.0377716757,
0.0014822448,
-0.0279361624,
0.00261426,
-0.007438364,
-0.0112277558,
-0.0277123004,
-0.0258887038,
0.0447219908,
-0.037892092,
0.0457655638,
0.0248467363,
0.0342702121,
0.0454569384,
0.0257643107,
-0.072219722,
-0.0806066096,
0.0227372572,
-0.0198355094,
0.0111302361,
-0.0307357758,
-0.0238826144,
0.0399451964,
-0.0292763896,
0.0274038501,
-0.0608362705,
0.0132881021,
-0.0139418496,
0.02102031,
0.0998653397,
-0.0148974583,
0.0141257942,
0.049348034,
-0.0056147403,
0.0428074151,
-0.0019584275,
0.0493495241,
-0.0582361892,
0.0519128144,
-0.0253774952,
-0.0030373798,
0.0433038883,
-0.0079579921,
-0.0171706695,
0.0146939885,
-0.0277448371,
-0.0395763926,
0.0165690631,
0.0226530656,
0.0518980213,
-0.0119739985,
-0.0157899,
0.0186303612,
0.0643363744,
0.0058821421,
0.008532322,
-0.0000138802,
0.0195803754,
-0.0259923749,
-0.0319245644,
0.0028745306,
-0.0178953726,
-0.022189945,
0.0323330648,
0.0357124247,
0.0107356431,
-0.0321795605,
-0.0087670973,
0.0161311142,
-0.046675615,
-0.0414725207,
0.0009846118,
0.0187326223,
0.009481662,
-0.0697498545,
0.061705932,
0.0323984176,
-0.064923346,
0.0256248619,
-0.022405548,
0.0118264593,
0.1014946923,
0.0487403907,
0.0071164798,
-0.0272215009,
-0.0002832332,
-0.1056602523,
0.0390379503,
-0.0403888412,
-0.0228660461,
0.0225068722,
-0.0855778977,
-0.0000963278,
0.0971163362,
-0.0262405835,
0.090893887,
0.0002089021,
0.0616405942,
0.0455910452,
-0.0011911958,
-0.0022962822,
0.0084816124,
-0.019986691,
-0.0121952351,
0.0302158445,
0.0484735966,
0.0667830557,
0.0409683511,
-0.0214162711,
-0.0185488686,
-0.0049252259,
0.0103099076,
-0.006101944,
0.0237731282,
-0.0548372753,
0.0008903383,
0.0229453314,
-0.0050529842,
0.0305452738,
0.0221493002,
0.0323991254,
-0.0788656771,
-0.0213006251,
-0.0077642184,
0.0412526615,
-0.053911522,
0.1077007279,
0.0166995861,
0.0184182543,
-0.0107372804,
-0.0111871045,
0.0107228495,
0.0101207132,
-0.028238019,
0.0155626163,
0.003814037,
-0.0866111368,
-0.0878952369,
0.0412990414,
0.0228854679,
0.0012431487,
0.0072962446,
-0.0241459366,
-0.0049309218,
0.0003536022,
-0.0405171365,
-0.0395850688,
0.0017773326,
0.035632465,
-0.029975323,
0.0605286583,
-0.0317843147,
-0.0513550304,
0.0061981962,
0.0063651921,
0.009660379,
-0.0205208715,
-0.0418461896,
-0.0305275526,
-0.0611754507,
-0.0110793021,
-0.0006997383,
0.0015595998,
-0.0071572778,
0.0035850136,
-0.0724030063,
-0.078991957,
0.025347868,
-0.0107118199,
0.030262664,
0.0161809456,
-0.0184195954,
0.0002917373,
0.0190586597,
0.021135794,
0.0037407463,
-0.0308740623,
-0.0239262003,
0.003729095,
-0.0112512754,
-0.0654216632,
-0.0149601977,
0.0204162896,
0.0037515236,
0.0394434184,
-0.0079832748,
0.0110349087,
0.0193064567,
-0.0096639767,
0.0283356141,
-0.0328871757,
-0.0291587021,
-0.0067915004,
-0.03961486,
-0.0140024247,
-0.0489061698,
-0.0121157523,
-0.0279089976,
-0.0170039125,
-0.0048613357,
0.0698017851,
-0.0742084607,
-0.0174364615,
-0.0592030846,
0.0256996229,
0.0007632344,
-0.0176040716,
-0.0157651361,
0.0009159503,
0.0515532419,
-0.1211397722,
0.0470858701,
0.0314213671,
0.0128493207,
-0.051011309,
0.0575640351,
0.0094010085,
-0.0149083147,
0.0284061786,
-0.0047438107,
-0.0184956305,
0.0418056883,
-0.0596977435,
0.0296121053,
0.0084429737,
-0.024525838,
0.0468073077,
0.0700333416,
-0.0195106547,
0.0070671965,
0.0254390314,
0.012083482,
-0.0250906833,
0.0228293408,
0.0108545078,
0.0113355909,
-0.0248393714,
-0.0054532085,
0.0535450242,
-0.0383144468,
0.0238196123,
-0.02414372,
0.0057087452,
0.0053755296,
0.0350097828,
-0.0455677621,
0.0183673576,
0.0065984316,
0.0131488694,
-0.0059027188,
0.0243560523,
0.099734962,
0.0108440667,
-0.0144852707,
-0.0304202586,
0.0174409915,
0.0179624949,
-0.0040666605,
0.0063692769,
-0.0168970115,
-0.018247366,
0.0704604238,
0.0678698048,
-0.0090108896,
-0.0362754688,
0.0250992645,
-0.1300942302,
-0.0187281128,
0.0040675425,
-0.0491512865,
0.0107356999,
-0.05037532,
0.0064360457,
-0.0252681728,
0.0223224983,
0.0037624799,
-0.0101091098,
-0.0493954942,
0.0237016082,
-0.0562492125,
-0.062350858,
-0.0042218259,
-0.0563019365,
0.0624011457,
0.0424401984,
0.0299969707,
-0.0072299233,
-0.0482777879,
-0.0625653714,
-0.0239307769,
0.0147275217,
-0.0393439457,
0.0171089042,
-0.0194576103,
-0.0393143669,
-0.0174547434,
-0.0002864764,
0.003458567,
0.019553449,
0.0410486311,
-0.0290061329,
-0.0057143727,
0.0260385368,
0.0310473721,
-0.0288745686,
0.0173865855,
0.0376489237,
-0.0051971842,
-0.0297760554,
0.0090403929,
0.0488830917,
0.05336079,
0.0115135489,
0.0395785421,
0.0123907877,
-0.0443089232,
-0.0475516208,
-0.0636590049,
-0.0299577452,
-0.0128363436,
0.0530967228,
0.0528843887,
0.0111617204,
0.0390381329,
0.0621768869,
-0.0371814221,
-0.025330605,
-0.0287492611,
0.0402694754,
-0.0714159831,
0.0091430126,
0.0277237426,
-0.005301944,
-0.0072142719,
-0.0094984043,
0.0269786902,
-0.0603948198,
0.0033716466,
-0.0155582363,
0.0142240478,
0.0531238243,
-0.0373815522,
-0.0582439415,
0.0303372741,
-0.0076626418,
-0.0291408934,
-0.0088650901,
0.049308233,
0.0472522452,
-0.0221826732,
-0.0056637265,
0.0068759704,
0.0131574273,
0.0091998558,
0.0159267765,
0.0008504312,
-0.0699645281,
0.0006631273,
0.0675797984,
0.031280119,
-0.0420087241,
0.0290437825,
-0.0680295229,
0.0518446229,
0.0229077581,
0.0699570924,
0.0007920571,
-0.0204165541,
0.0114454795,
0.0485423245,
-0.0305053759,
-0.0063604461,
-0.0476018339,
-0.0407818779,
-0.0127796168,
0.023685297,
0.0153184086,
0.0918893069,
0.0225589871,
-0.0205582231,
-0.0162019879,
0.0129816253,
0.0806186721,
-0.0050823018,
-0.0055176523,
0.0119859017,
-0.0168279428,
-0.0070566037,
-0.0170652997,
0.0305747781,
0.0286852531,
0.0408525653,
-0.0314027183,
0.047158733,
0.0184058715,
0.0297060572,
0.0166128539,
-0.0001426516,
0.0324588753,
-0.0266563334,
-0.0221794136,
-0.0523987599,
0.0144095328,
0.0402854867,
-0.0079725962,
-0.001298926,
0.0180834532,
0.0348628238,
-0.0130315218,
0.0180572122,
-0.0661760047,
0.0173951536,
-0.0421006903,
-0.0014042847,
0.0172972567,
0.0249367841,
-0.0710493326,
-0.0505752824,
-0.0095956307,
-0.0670155585,
0.0348211639,
0.0237142909,
0.0146755986,
0.0150879119,
0.0216203686,
-0.0340571888,
-0.0158773605,
0.0277575105,
0.0304061044,
-0.0842037275,
-0.0189388562,
-0.012381997,
0.0390434116,
-5.71720265e-33,
-0.0336828083,
0.0397656523,
0.0115042152,
0.0177680198,
-0.0127580762,
0.0291093457,
-0.0273440443,
0.0167407859,
0.0205502212,
-0.0514510944,
-0.0263891816,
-0.0332143717,
0.0331440382,
-0.0274138562,
-0.0087000122,
0.0147547573,
0.0754355639,
0.046800945,
0.0106910337,
-0.015468264,
0.0487513319,
0.0627235845,
0.0352890044,
-0.0374799035,
-0.0205434375,
-0.0039789709,
-0.0069764107,
-0.0227051694,
0.0377655998,
0.0492762551,
-0.0056822654,
0.0515722334,
-0.0172655396,
-0.0238608196,
-0.0170559324,
0.0269429311,
-0.155297175,
-0.0121289417,
-0.0321067385,
0.0489820279,
0.0506900772,
-0.0177696366,
0.0424393266,
-0.0014338952,
-0.0419395044,
0.0504159369,
0.0112541802,
-0.0215238463,
-0.0036732743,
-0.0156612899,
-0.006936077,
0.0282127522,
0.0372781269,
0.027820034,
0.0330107696,
-0.028852202,
-0.0145775797,
-0.0363318846,
-0.0806960911,
0.025351977,
0.0431350321,
-0.0214495864,
0.0051443307,
0.0567631535,
-0.0164815076,
0.0063172211,
0.0781414285,
-0.0634630695,
0.0125024961,
-0.0406212807,
0.0539871231,
0.0011099883,
0.0102473227,
0.0270430557,
0.0408950001,
-0.053044185,
-0.0044629043,
0.0104201185,
0.0142440032,
0.0080006383,
0.0180529393,
0.0069981483,
-0.0824536756,
-0.0173060894,
-0.038767904,
-0.0243211724,
-0.0537291281,
-0.0353798456,
0.0677895844,
0.0240597352,
-0.0364513583,
0.047539413,
0.0148088131,
-0.0114251254,
-0.0067093754,
0.0000499207,
0.0554919131,
-0.0252916925,
-0.0119479345,
0.0033510386,
-0.0422348604,
-0.0439635441,
0.0144379074,
-0.0047869817,
-0.0233379025,
-0.0669951141,
-0.0187682826,
0.0111036813,
-0.0654926673,
0.0124988044,
0.0164217856,
0.0093932124,
0.0014813995,
0.0045868941,
0.0296945665,
-0.016704699,
0.0062965555,
-0.0015608851,
0.0294762067,
-0.0357746407,
-0.0193515364,
0.016217282,
0.053712178,
0.0415581539,
-0.0025507794,
0.007143443,
0.0295189936,
-0.0392646752,
0.0182758924,
-0.0043319119,
0.0066028484,
0.0045213709,
2.751e-7,
-0.0559865162,
-0.0294291582,
0.043825075,
-0.0352805443,
-0.0117967948,
-0.0047368989,
0.0226711351,
0.0268421602,
0.0077170017,
0.0374426246,
0.0309736207,
-0.0233153086,
0.0527062006,
-0.0131864538,
-0.1105588153,
-0.0531633608,
-0.0223603453,
0.0299216956,
-0.0548958331,
0.0607079789,
0.0130789941,
0.0271959417,
0.0122921113,
-0.0541796051,
-0.0340681188,
0.0230483785,
0.0132759726,
-0.0050533609,
0.0314399973,
0.0227354635,
0.019407779,
0.0298462883,
-0.0170615986,
0.0631048381,
-0.0290945619,
0.0585142411,
0.0487645976,
0.0044811117,
-0.0523020439,
-0.0362878181,
0.0337268151,
0.0251365378,
-0.0364334024,
-0.0022382285,
0.0358249098,
0.033127021,
-0.0019706846,
0.0326354764,
-0.044095885,
-0.0115954168,
-0.0061890748,
0.0023282231,
-0.0179337654,
0.0245351009,
0.0284078494,
-0.0112573234,
-0.0249441266,
-0.0260084122,
0.0676940382,
-0.013462875,
0.0034891609,
-0.0101346932,
-0.0175579432,
-0.0304408781,
-0.0058810422,
-0.0090467585,
0.0248466004,
1.694129805e-34,
-0.0255429577,
-0.0050958605,
-0.0005873262,
0.0268500242,
0.0060102632,
-0.0263379347,
0.0093630999,
0.0251109786,
-0.0195803177,
-0.0227385666,
-0.0390498005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17826v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17826v1 | NOTABLE: Transferable Backdoor Attacks Against Prompt-based NLP Models | 2023-05-28T23:35:17 | 2023-05-28T23:35:17 | Kai Mei, Zheng Li, Zhenting Wang, Yang Zhang, Shiqing Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Prompt-based learning is vulnerable to backdoor attacks. Existing backdoor
attacks against prompt-based models consider injecting backdoors into the
entire embedding layers or word embedding vectors. Such attacks can be easily
affected by retraining on downstream tasks and with different prompting
strategies, limiting the transferability of backdoor attacks. In this work, we
propose transferable backdoor attacks against prompt-based models, called
NOTABLE, which is independent of downstream tasks and prompting strategies.
Specifically, NOTABLE injects backdoors into the encoders of PLMs by utilizing
an adaptive verbalizer to bind triggers to specific words (i.e., anchors). It
activates the backdoor by pasting input with triggers to reach
adversary-desired anchors, achieving independence from downstream tasks and
prompting strategies. We conduct experiments on six NLP tasks, three popular
models, and three prompting strategies. Empirical results show that NOTABLE
achieves superior attack performance (i.e., attack success rate over 90% on all
the datasets), and outperforms two state-of-the-art baselines. Evaluations on
three defenses show the robustness of NOTABLE. Our code can be found at
https://github.com/RU-System-Software-and-Security/Notable. | [
0.0408780761,
0.0343789272,
-0.0003393302,
0.0589155219,
-0.029378064,
-0.0078587839,
0.0110178711,
-0.0161717832,
-0.0028116584,
-0.0287553649,
0.0006734546,
0.0427329987,
0.0124267293,
0.0393585041,
0.0843238309,
0.0086922329,
0.0777219385,
-0.02155938,
-0.0130137773,
-0.0019337941,
-0.0081192199,
-0.0168050639,
-0.0163442902,
0.0360016413,
0.0203141272,
0.0036362715,
-0.0316874832,
0.0058100075,
0.03132727,
-0.0407020338,
-0.0143660558,
0.0352279469,
-0.0099146236,
0.0338592194,
0.0000019519,
-0.0379309244,
-0.0517169535,
-0.0098261992,
-0.0417264998,
0.0174284354,
-0.0256276727,
-0.0323822312,
-0.0256956685,
-0.001618932,
-0.0355728231,
-0.0118093286,
0.014243789,
0.0819408223,
0.0695943832,
0.0971204787,
0.0025984908,
0.0320389532,
0.0641988814,
-0.0513245314,
0.0117562646,
-0.0474394001,
0.0202308036,
-0.1154551655,
-0.0379351489,
0.0502447374,
-0.0118627548,
0.015151659,
-0.0018850395,
-0.0057503199,
0.0056038001,
0.0381479189,
0.04527862,
-0.0208245069,
-0.054921519,
0.0817377046,
-0.0117372908,
0.0268649627,
-0.0016403145,
-0.0135204429,
0.0281842686,
0.034464933,
0.0027251516,
0.0272916052,
0.0110713942,
-0.0028354323,
-0.0034961936,
-0.0066050752,
0.0320965946,
0.0031513469,
0.0367624164,
0.0453966334,
0.0231325533,
-0.0415622182,
0.0332555622,
-0.0434611812,
0.0131964702,
-0.0543258823,
0.0098295361,
0.0130544975,
0.0007777133,
0.0264694095,
-0.0601493567,
-0.0007801169,
0.0351084024,
-0.0054532881,
0.0503597334,
0.0399623476,
-0.045187939,
0.0275366344,
-0.0571083501,
0.0598179661,
-0.0121259457,
0.0699327514,
0.0388134159,
0.0368316509,
-0.0404729061,
-0.0347732827,
-0.0223872419,
0.0413553715,
-0.0426977314,
-0.0284933485,
-0.0253937766,
0.0250702091,
-0.0207877979,
0.0377518721,
0.0009913564,
0.0240916852,
-0.0111049423,
0.0236424953,
-0.0110349972,
-0.0139644025,
-0.0285171326,
-0.016638618,
0.0025138038,
-0.0689610168,
-0.0451361537,
-0.0070766937,
-0.0329945534,
-0.0219912753,
-0.0278155301,
0.0556479208,
0.0098708319,
-0.0499712229,
-0.0410960875,
-0.0665783882,
-0.0260292459,
0.0072188936,
-0.007407675,
-0.0444974564,
0.0017691966,
-0.0385465734,
-0.0001575107,
-0.054742191,
0.0241630282,
0.0572453476,
-0.0329351872,
0.1072641686,
0.0059271189,
-0.0315918103,
0.0113805579,
0.0271398462,
-0.0419137776,
0.0243259165,
0.0039093825,
0.0466356575,
0.0676533952,
-0.0260877963,
0.0267282836,
0.0128948512,
0.0377804711,
0.003900772,
-0.0108526414,
0.0074504637,
0.0741562918,
-0.0084762005,
-0.0135293454,
0.0671229959,
-0.0081539461,
-0.0624084063,
0.0906296298,
0.0458065085,
-0.0416008271,
0.001386501,
0.040873684,
-0.0091762738,
-0.0302359015,
-0.0009269891,
-0.0762166679,
-0.0087525044,
-0.099863708,
-0.0392335393,
0.0145843765,
0.0001236603,
-0.0018942613,
-0.0187496655,
0.0214661229,
-0.0085146772,
-0.0060728174,
-0.0146756582,
0.0095273405,
0.0648499206,
-0.0399060063,
0.0494310558,
0.0023327528,
-0.0263578501,
-0.0204050783,
-0.0588241257,
-0.0195806306,
0.0474491008,
0.0387663022,
-0.0022860332,
0.0377996154,
-0.0538973995,
0.0062180627,
0.0475903489,
0.0245522223,
0.0059569473,
-0.0078257723,
-0.0135925775,
-0.0270671509,
-0.0260619745,
0.0186998677,
0.015489853,
0.0078186356,
0.0179330315,
0.008732833,
0.0390869305,
0.0186762642,
0.0498149022,
-0.0196377393,
-0.0805249885,
0.0213772431,
0.0338165648,
0.0164790377,
0.0217958819,
0.0116682537,
0.0419316553,
0.0516109392,
-0.0125403935,
-0.0165450647,
-0.0280202851,
-0.0197345596,
-0.0262625571,
0.0141816931,
-0.0138967549,
0.0100971656,
0.0496884622,
-0.0343955047,
-0.0335932709,
0.0234623682,
-0.0247018915,
0.0263443645,
-0.0246290676,
0.0113362772,
0.0114287809,
0.0445894077,
-0.0332887247,
0.0548114367,
-0.0198273845,
0.0022451521,
0.0126542933,
0.0412977897,
-0.0039285785,
-0.0348176658,
-0.0554296635,
0.0180862769,
-0.0296714902,
-0.0142804822,
-0.0017772379,
-0.0167610776,
-0.0414618813,
-0.0068941326,
-0.0457125306,
-0.0001833132,
-0.0143458173,
0.0194728188,
0.0191744361,
0.0011570803,
-0.0141910911,
-0.03482439,
-0.0040393271,
-0.0062517491,
-0.0263370909,
0.0386573561,
0.0313061886,
0.0003852899,
-0.0137676075,
-0.0101427995,
-0.0154356128,
-0.0071229013,
0.0854202807,
-0.0344790518,
-0.0241575185,
-0.0436155908,
0.0103560397,
-0.0021074,
0.0240923129,
-0.0167744234,
-0.013278502,
0.0290212985,
0.0175039098,
-0.0096122725,
0.0625568926,
0.0216273014,
0.0535949767,
0.0304531772,
0.0038024383,
-0.05588191,
0.0046805725,
-0.0060918545,
-0.0274511147,
-0.0427582674,
0.0410090126,
0.0238937642,
0.0478608012,
0.0517219007,
-0.009846353,
-0.0424876697,
0.0192802753,
0.0050359615,
-0.0243545212,
-0.0483872667,
-0.0445981249,
-0.0482737981,
0.0058957534,
-0.0161420275,
-0.0705917478,
0.0745416507,
-0.0561449714,
0.0263965521,
0.0034808845,
-0.0376727954,
0.0050988751,
0.0512014516,
-0.0122362794,
-0.0056777019,
0.0614245869,
-0.0545229502,
-0.0329297222,
-0.0281668101,
-0.0045787729,
-0.0234576166,
0.0049489629,
-0.0073396894,
-0.011634781,
-0.0078521296,
-0.0628272966,
-0.0755613223,
-0.0842763111,
-0.0223115291,
0.0126161315,
-0.0228746794,
-0.0163652897,
-0.0079031922,
-0.0330513939,
0.0113067254,
-0.0107515333,
-0.0269303266,
-0.0153650623,
-0.0599778742,
0.0223151743,
0.0462334417,
-0.0404377133,
-0.0030487487,
-0.0090114335,
0.0325731523,
0.0915600806,
0.0131133422,
0.0082846405,
-0.0226290692,
0.0346565619,
0.0155900605,
-0.0487984009,
-0.0077664671,
0.0111902319,
0.0307413507,
-0.0297703706,
-0.0174550451,
0.0648095012,
0.0230440833,
-0.067040585,
0.0069432324,
0.0456050895,
0.010198947,
0.0136146285,
-0.0043313513,
-0.0436959416,
-0.045173686,
0.0342472605,
0.0402097143,
-0.0298708919,
-0.0107759451,
-0.0307443012,
-0.1594608724,
-0.0326239802,
-0.0092872353,
-0.0152164465,
-0.0265203342,
-0.056226261,
-0.0033261578,
0.0196809769,
0.0351916179,
-0.005795408,
-0.0062055099,
0.0068008131,
-0.0050336472,
0.0033269858,
-0.0404544361,
0.0099114673,
-0.0298491772,
0.068476513,
0.0781301409,
-0.0118626636,
0.0004786588,
-0.0298532993,
0.0403212421,
-0.0323238447,
-0.0007491925,
0.009641665,
0.0726212263,
-0.0359813347,
-0.0106116496,
0.0267465282,
0.0505751893,
-0.043433167,
-0.0205373596,
0.031638626,
0.0592703931,
-0.0135507081,
0.0086391224,
-0.0266352165,
0.0023514556,
0.039493341,
0.0737221166,
0.0226875581,
-0.0352571048,
-0.020653896,
-0.074313499,
-0.0110080158,
-0.007977345,
-0.0590023398,
0.0317903236,
0.0308983792,
-0.0450027287,
-0.0651762411,
-0.0176875722,
0.0068802936,
0.0350558385,
0.0143494466,
-0.0002121685,
-0.028214803,
0.0096113253,
-0.0556860194,
0.0134599721,
-0.0274369195,
0.0341351554,
-0.0517224185,
-0.0061581247,
0.0404824242,
-0.0134979701,
-0.0171445739,
-0.0072106812,
-0.0578083582,
-0.0562806576,
-0.0228053406,
0.0359367803,
0.0231461581,
0.0436568335,
-0.0489030778,
-0.036580883,
0.1081888676,
0.0276215076,
-0.0406885631,
0.0069531733,
0.0611230545,
-0.0148316333,
-0.0010407082,
0.0427177846,
-0.0292588249,
-0.0361701436,
0.0686535835,
0.0153405955,
0.0181747302,
-0.0349784233,
0.0035899151,
0.026517367,
0.0895923823,
0.0002582746,
-0.035163369,
-0.0058814315,
0.0285060089,
0.0057621459,
-0.0170671288,
-0.0104935234,
0.0449478105,
0.0134320529,
-0.0097188773,
0.0256185569,
-0.0359633751,
0.0119256871,
0.0284333117,
-0.0566700995,
0.0193663463,
0.0441014096,
0.0374680869,
0.0342057273,
0.0250097159,
-0.0203465298,
0.0405346937,
0.0147326859,
0.0201625712,
-0.0174013991,
0.0365773328,
0.0078757666,
0.0039587794,
-0.0314178169,
0.0417768471,
-0.0954889953,
-0.0142640453,
0.0090050967,
0.0313299149,
0.0021468843,
0.0193919614,
-0.0191141944,
0.0074648797,
-0.0147995846,
-0.0044227215,
-0.0011113203,
-0.0014029278,
-0.0545900203,
0.0439121202,
0.0074339341,
-0.007460447,
0.0447506383,
0.0587990694,
-0.0388246402,
0.0719739795,
-0.0011382925,
-0.0139003256,
-0.04855562,
-0.001151448,
0.0249862466,
0.0213924609,
-0.0296211988,
0.0090021882,
-0.0287724081,
-0.069056794,
0.0239735208,
-0.0016681353,
0.0124380765,
0.0336827151,
0.0203249976,
0.0414829813,
0.0236441419,
0.0222432036,
-0.0652437434,
0.0343956575,
0.0192955658,
-0.059018027,
0.006400201,
-6.050895742e-33,
0.0101725757,
-0.0304525401,
-0.0078201238,
-0.000028896,
0.0017809871,
0.0332416482,
-0.0178888422,
-0.0086348699,
-0.0080172298,
-0.0072620139,
-0.0236136112,
0.0116551397,
0.0091169439,
0.0335562192,
-0.0313354805,
-0.0518900566,
0.0038548617,
-0.0160079356,
-0.0359305255,
0.0303694662,
0.0772712603,
0.0457797423,
0.0375826247,
-0.0199673399,
0.0655214414,
0.0276601557,
-0.0394033119,
0.0060454924,
-0.043767143,
0.0783694088,
-0.0286229104,
0.0309213828,
-0.0046489458,
-0.0565180294,
-0.0106349075,
0.0945265889,
-0.0308676083,
-0.0233469531,
-0.0370091833,
-0.0193707328,
-0.0052681002,
-0.0563832261,
0.0340956151,
-0.0300649777,
-0.0114534805,
0.0097899213,
0.0081028063,
-0.0134255346,
-0.0356783159,
-0.0046661841,
-0.0216626432,
0.0110263405,
-0.014353524,
-0.0003466523,
0.0045128497,
0.0105537623,
0.0113035925,
0.0124277808,
-0.0600152723,
0.0170290917,
0.0067645558,
0.0173636004,
0.012015895,
-0.0101134321,
-0.0194161795,
0.0773196071,
0.0465650298,
-0.0390348546,
0.0065500815,
0.0230262391,
-0.0131859686,
0.050135076,
0.0799364448,
0.0370807312,
0.0570973232,
-0.0249203965,
-0.0511039384,
-0.0040723118,
0.0458419248,
-0.0075651417,
0.0579944737,
-0.0043418426,
-0.0538043752,
0.000456456,
-0.0458511002,
-0.0370765291,
-0.0342517756,
-0.0140829552,
0.0427993983,
0.0427382551,
-0.0310542621,
0.0034498887,
-0.0004113232,
-0.0507111922,
0.0011040327,
0.023148315,
0.0072880206,
-0.0248824507,
0.0061084712,
-0.0045029181,
0.0026319539,
-0.0044134567,
0.014680529,
-0.0696991235,
0.0398614556,
0.0018168456,
0.0201026034,
0.0207567196,
-0.0948901251,
-0.0175504703,
-0.0277854856,
0.0450171493,
0.0159570109,
0.0408146605,
0.0399596579,
-0.0191889834,
-0.0318155177,
0.0305282213,
-0.0002933647,
-0.0071852831,
-0.0326221772,
0.0422408096,
-0.0198788103,
0.0167225543,
-0.009952643,
-0.0063335462,
0.014499574,
0.0768813565,
0.0298193153,
-0.0436355695,
0.0129762823,
0.004176198,
2.811e-7,
-0.0049920487,
0.0031792857,
0.0317538492,
-0.0032509742,
0.0150595596,
0.0574229956,
-0.0380302258,
0.0951912329,
-0.0091317249,
-0.0685162693,
-0.0420303419,
0.0139639853,
0.0500238054,
0.0056707333,
-0.0953465849,
-0.0085127102,
-0.065082632,
0.0255486295,
-0.0476709604,
0.0186843127,
0.056756869,
0.0864193365,
0.0193834025,
-0.0079966458,
-0.0092880586,
-0.0517775193,
0.0152874468,
-0.0238682292,
0.0067031519,
-0.039067395,
0.0568397976,
0.0023165043,
0.0046336008,
0.0366950817,
-0.0478641056,
0.0184686258,
-0.040663857,
0.0384833291,
0.0310270116,
-0.0854407251,
-0.0435829721,
-0.0167126693,
0.0200323369,
-0.0161141194,
0.0828245282,
-0.0122527508,
-0.0321095474,
-0.0091355303,
-0.0091842636,
-0.0184916705,
0.0455236584,
-0.0307968799,
-0.0133723309,
0.0004229815,
0.0086589493,
0.0211075936,
-0.0018068616,
-0.1234229431,
-0.0015867159,
-0.0532931276,
-0.0218369458,
-0.0377930775,
-0.0083804158,
0.0105328849,
0.0061273635,
-0.0236115418,
-0.0077430685,
2.668039732e-34,
0.0064001884,
-0.0293143298,
0.0101256715,
0.0061546043,
0.0335940644,
-0.0081614973,
0.0341021568,
-0.0100886822,
0.0264362637,
-0.0624720305,
-0.0434888676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17819v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17819v2 | Large Language Models, scientific knowledge and factuality: A systematic analysis in antibiotic discovery | 2023-05-28T22:46:21 | 2023-12-05T09:51:55 | Magdalena Wysocka, Oskar Wysocki, Maxime Delmas, Vincent Mutel, Andre Freitas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Inferring over and extracting information from Large Language Models (LLMs)
trained on a large corpus of scientific literature can potentially drive a new
era in biomedical research, reducing the barriers for accessing existing
medical evidence. This work examines the potential of LLMs for dialoguing with
biomedical background knowledge, using the context of antibiotic discovery. The
systematic analysis is applied to ten state-of-the-art models, from models
specialised on biomedical scientific corpora to general models such as ChatGPT,
GPT-4 and Llama 2 in two prompting-based tasks: chemical compound definition
generation and chemical compound-fungus relation determination. The work
provides a systematic assessment on the ability of LLMs to encode and express
these relations, verifying for fluency, prompt-alignment, semantic coherence,
factual knowledge and specificity of generated responses. Results show that
while recent models have improved in fluency, factual accuracy is still low and
models are biased towards over-represented entities. The ability of LLMs to
serve as biomedical knowledge bases is questioned, and the need for additional
systematic evaluation frameworks is highlighted. The best performing GPT-4
produced a factual definition for 70% of chemical compounds and 43.6% factual
relations to fungi, whereas the best open source model BioGPT-large 30% of the
compounds and 30% of the relations for the best-performing prompt. The results
show that while LLMs are currently not fit for purpose to be used as biomedical
factual knowledge bases, there is a promising emerging property in the
direction of factuality as the models become domain specialised, scale-up in
size and level of human feedback. | [
0.0654632971,
0.0264522731,
-0.0016662935,
0.0164312329,
-0.0376727208,
-0.0086094905,
0.0383024439,
0.0148501666,
0.0328503102,
-0.0306443144,
-0.0249743387,
-0.0432894826,
-0.0157008283,
0.0496669747,
0.0141032031,
0.0025449083,
0.0393140055,
-0.0108156782,
0.0216249209,
-0.0039471122,
-0.0006865128,
0.013416281,
-0.0254740156,
0.0032976563,
0.0123065403,
-0.0180137642,
0.0279972013,
-0.0671393573,
0.0460166968,
-0.0564460345,
0.0049021374,
0.0354611538,
-0.0027420495,
0.0498153344,
0.0000017797,
-0.0786664486,
0.0037503755,
0.0318695381,
-0.0599368364,
-0.0176310651,
0.044220861,
-0.0111140804,
0.0086712763,
-0.002262715,
-0.0497613624,
0.0076959305,
0.0820317119,
0.0289256126,
0.0110011967,
0.0320738219,
0.0092692766,
-0.0431752466,
0.039546214,
0.0052973572,
0.0209860858,
0.0115349749,
0.070917055,
0.0263239369,
0.0793469548,
0.0364763923,
0.0203289445,
0.0297429413,
-0.0366196483,
-0.0370943323,
0.0222476572,
0.0330711342,
-0.0087701008,
-0.0619680248,
0.0296187401,
0.0639894083,
0.0463706851,
-0.0180844441,
-0.0224752352,
0.0060855211,
-0.0287177693,
0.0637016073,
-0.0382506922,
0.017682394,
-0.0563727133,
0.0206060838,
0.0205042176,
-0.0208079051,
0.0195411518,
0.0285727251,
-0.0029701388,
0.0978687555,
-0.0133740921,
-0.0300343353,
-0.0012202618,
-0.0173818506,
-0.0373982862,
-0.0421401672,
0.0315145999,
0.0374301746,
-0.0320748314,
0.0293625444,
0.0257169362,
0.0152470777,
0.0944923237,
-0.0651240572,
-0.024426071,
-0.0158265512,
-0.0105649,
0.0212005321,
0.0054544127,
0.0316034332,
-0.0222254805,
0.0092717232,
-0.0339483432,
0.0207318496,
-0.0952641293,
-0.039350275,
-0.0016348921,
0.0241881702,
-0.0069626537,
-0.00776219,
-0.0496496111,
-0.0130965058,
-0.0072655804,
-0.012789757,
0.0066006528,
0.011767529,
-0.0368781611,
0.0193055645,
-0.051950939,
0.0473739617,
0.0143532706,
0.0202757828,
-0.0236246176,
-0.0620655231,
-0.013521553,
-0.0153758721,
-0.0134388395,
-0.0328217968,
0.0177743025,
0.0914682448,
0.002013386,
-0.0213686898,
0.0227404311,
-0.0602490827,
-0.0101962285,
-0.0697340369,
0.0018851309,
-0.0348820016,
0.0628226399,
0.032426849,
-0.0163603444,
-0.0390699618,
0.0058096624,
0.0228010323,
-0.0764231011,
0.0727865845,
-0.0643518716,
-0.0184395444,
0.0330596752,
0.0118997162,
-0.0107292179,
-0.0197108872,
0.0149404164,
-0.0203180462,
0.0067657921,
-0.0123825734,
-0.0017373952,
-0.0380959138,
-0.0168713238,
-0.0498386361,
0.0423622504,
0.0283940807,
0.0320413113,
0.0993420705,
-0.0146236289,
0.0676160455,
-0.0060380646,
0.0006773953,
0.061290063,
0.0383955799,
0.0187896583,
-0.0082972543,
0.0524920896,
-0.0172068961,
0.0549225286,
0.0085152611,
-0.040257141,
0.0029703041,
0.0060454533,
0.0214053243,
0.016048979,
0.0316922031,
0.0194576941,
0.0034168216,
-0.0218532272,
0.0054971366,
-0.0306412112,
-0.0257082973,
0.0317091495,
-0.0329502113,
-0.0401696302,
0.0296526942,
0.0828635618,
-0.0325186439,
0.0066529727,
-0.0437156782,
0.0551734082,
0.0786248893,
0.0363772921,
-0.0182696898,
-0.0600271076,
-0.0188599136,
-0.0445669778,
0.0391830169,
0.0010369465,
-0.0431990586,
-0.0068707722,
-0.0135313775,
0.0059568938,
-0.0010803666,
-0.0048179883,
-0.0212100726,
-0.008340924,
0.0047263368,
0.0063243886,
-0.0331030339,
-0.0110705299,
0.0224218685,
-0.033468768,
-0.0240199305,
-0.0169404633,
-0.020765353,
0.0456698686,
0.0546172373,
-0.0018912591,
0.0453442968,
0.0456241854,
-0.0439510494,
0.0131859519,
-0.0047020908,
0.0184941646,
-0.0411406569,
0.0212762486,
0.0012668468,
-0.0036776152,
-0.0263880976,
-0.0064806109,
-0.0241557155,
0.0074572661,
-0.0306498762,
0.0254519861,
-0.0124719217,
-0.0012611775,
0.0124731958,
0.0191231854,
-0.0276121721,
0.0298607647,
0.0273243729,
0.0107039362,
0.0175283514,
-0.0302386545,
-0.0133216884,
-0.0519754738,
-0.0049379356,
0.0235703941,
0.067745015,
0.0052430611,
0.0272769742,
-0.0181406327,
-0.0349460952,
0.0023573125,
-0.064807184,
-0.0272241849,
0.035171207,
0.0453485735,
-0.0082904417,
-0.0296574999,
0.0176246371,
-0.0002700498,
-0.0071252356,
-0.0218170621,
-0.0193180032,
0.0346357152,
0.0344428048,
0.0502957739,
-0.0313903652,
-0.0451956317,
0.0036076647,
-0.033686325,
0.0613511242,
0.0438730381,
-0.0229959376,
-0.0179783702,
-0.0037289246,
-0.0493375026,
-0.0009873915,
-0.0028414349,
0.0119182393,
0.040910352,
0.0085566668,
0.0069606192,
-0.0043529966,
-0.0221966486,
0.0071543432,
0.0746406242,
0.0126339747,
-0.023475688,
-0.0039627631,
-0.0326260477,
-0.0060729864,
0.0159225203,
-0.0223447941,
-0.0110263675,
0.0700320974,
0.0009709591,
0.0088276463,
-0.0266187917,
0.028154267,
-0.031786412,
-0.0074999481,
-0.0436613411,
-0.0277622137,
-0.0330900662,
0.0397783145,
0.0105926627,
-0.0770691782,
0.0975618809,
-0.0459709056,
0.0083251027,
-0.0801874027,
0.0055294237,
0.0074973125,
-0.0106858993,
0.0131610576,
0.0401010774,
0.0473849699,
0.0003727622,
0.0049453294,
0.0000190366,
0.0271149911,
-0.0514774173,
0.0194650181,
-0.0738260001,
0.0474513397,
0.0168532841,
-0.01414451,
-0.0260777473,
-0.0009325427,
-0.035971649,
0.0257362742,
0.0154038854,
-0.0079844287,
-0.0111413393,
0.0578708276,
0.0371777341,
0.0023576936,
0.0197870433,
-0.004369441,
0.0116873197,
-0.009519944,
0.0619271472,
-0.0308721885,
0.0344373621,
-0.0104008196,
0.0511733405,
0.0286818929,
-0.0194585901,
-0.007064255,
0.005916635,
0.0125200301,
0.0049431254,
-0.013420485,
-0.0275444314,
0.0201605633,
0.00215069,
-0.0264867153,
-0.036566861,
0.1052002311,
0.0272337236,
-0.0145707596,
0.0248955972,
-0.0215741079,
-0.0728862584,
-0.0322921835,
0.0236489885,
-0.0782675222,
-0.0008848915,
-0.0483018309,
-0.0034036012,
-0.0450768508,
-0.0683774129,
-0.0447129272,
-0.076793924,
0.0435508341,
0.0121545186,
-0.0482062846,
-0.0325689949,
-0.0810453743,
-0.016861964,
0.0104538649,
0.024536917,
0.0264562368,
0.0075734309,
0.0082858335,
0.0264720768,
-0.0311762039,
-0.067343913,
0.0219664462,
0.0000883346,
0.0567693897,
0.0256045517,
0.0348094292,
0.0087590059,
0.0018230255,
0.0088208821,
-0.0207831562,
0.022292044,
-0.0078287721,
0.039165549,
0.0095416121,
0.0128467232,
-0.0640109107,
0.0241112597,
-0.0302943923,
-0.0465850048,
-0.034398213,
0.1204242855,
-0.0550875589,
-0.0222662576,
-0.0614572912,
0.0207933746,
0.0210696533,
0.0714805722,
0.0166557115,
0.0061844639,
-0.0358305611,
0.0222879294,
0.021308545,
0.008334293,
-0.0182991493,
0.02013449,
-0.0451301299,
-0.010091194,
-0.0606429391,
-0.0219045114,
0.0540261492,
-0.0175679829,
0.0102084978,
0.029967092,
0.0489290841,
-0.0362311043,
-0.0243278798,
0.0631896481,
0.0419082791,
0.0214512441,
-0.0576682873,
-0.0422186889,
0.0870647356,
-0.0039092661,
-0.005160938,
0.0145663675,
-0.0047578164,
-0.0803742707,
-0.0090090064,
0.0343752205,
0.0322041735,
-0.0097690914,
0.0214558057,
-0.0362088755,
0.0406239182,
0.0208639298,
-0.0183487032,
-0.0289306659,
-0.0336998478,
0.043012809,
-0.0157378465,
0.0012282776,
-0.022782024,
0.0383748002,
-0.011650729,
0.0385406874,
-0.0250022896,
-0.0589676462,
0.0743292719,
0.0245838258,
0.0555704571,
-0.028783232,
0.0059010624,
-0.0506537855,
-0.0220369957,
-0.009620849,
-0.0020048763,
-0.0042032436,
-0.0016128015,
0.0314581692,
-0.0027938262,
-0.0002874545,
-0.0304325521,
-0.0783596858,
0.0178274624,
0.0031830221,
0.011533007,
0.0096741011,
0.0047420394,
0.0866187513,
-0.014068028,
-0.0092745284,
-0.028919423,
-0.040841639,
0.0115803163,
-0.0038001826,
0.0596818067,
-0.0110317729,
0.0243656598,
-0.0273701269,
0.0321970209,
-0.0479986146,
-0.0350944251,
-0.0323412083,
0.0407141447,
0.0111067519,
-0.0010822659,
0.0265980847,
-0.0504375398,
-0.0029341285,
-0.0454568304,
0.0243874956,
0.0020998402,
0.0305049885,
0.086388126,
0.0137532074,
-0.0283657964,
-0.0453483351,
0.0956531763,
-0.0023508484,
0.0626235381,
-0.0143367155,
-0.0502357818,
-0.0116218897,
-0.0556150265,
-0.0805874616,
-0.0022459191,
-0.0532007553,
0.030394135,
-0.0916446745,
-0.0374996103,
-0.005235061,
-0.0047199107,
0.0002323164,
-0.0155044785,
0.0265527163,
0.0516704842,
0.0295442846,
-0.0586626865,
-0.0398200341,
0.0839727446,
-0.0219692234,
-0.0040423512,
-0.0190222766,
-5.569690966e-33,
0.0102617536,
-0.0497084744,
0.0287292246,
-0.0002613516,
0.0030098669,
0.0307245012,
-0.0625784174,
0.0045283921,
-0.0322517231,
0.0753498301,
0.0143333841,
-0.0227827895,
0.0032677446,
-0.0168830063,
0.0043757474,
0.0235668197,
0.0149137136,
-0.0019991826,
-0.0086881416,
0.0091607003,
0.0745710582,
0.0275117923,
0.0350722745,
-0.0563000105,
0.0328744091,
-0.0083811954,
0.0486393981,
0.0085708341,
-0.0606354401,
0.0632347316,
-0.035889037,
0.0795984194,
0.0248293392,
-0.0455653779,
-0.0104358373,
0.0160741452,
-0.0475664511,
0.0001969733,
0.0603551194,
-0.0366158336,
0.0001194192,
-0.0352559052,
0.0148987882,
0.0087831616,
-0.0574418865,
0.0237933807,
0.0142257912,
-0.0211252645,
-0.0163107105,
-0.0217538588,
-0.0768626034,
0.0122415116,
0.0267637707,
-0.0020643931,
0.0142837623,
0.0077912435,
-0.0152426139,
0.0019454424,
0.012640194,
0.0564591251,
0.0224540867,
0.022609368,
0.0567301996,
0.0034132134,
-0.0196889937,
0.0586947575,
-0.0221468545,
-0.0071634278,
0.02328212,
0.0259026345,
-0.065955162,
0.0412546657,
0.0103456182,
0.054124143,
0.010622059,
0.0212345663,
-0.0641047284,
0.0006401882,
-0.0350346528,
0.0506632067,
-0.0051093339,
-0.0159144513,
-0.0028784319,
-0.0374265313,
-0.017406771,
0.0401900783,
-0.0260268636,
-0.0237157978,
0.0102799684,
-0.0614377819,
-0.007275132,
0.0141833574,
0.0119267758,
-0.0089402823,
-0.0121670505,
-0.0242354833,
-0.0035949133,
0.0304611921,
-0.0173859131,
0.008756238,
-0.0821549371,
-0.0376263298,
0.0236110259,
-0.0216567833,
0.0255143344,
0.023473626,
-0.0101006478,
-0.0251803044,
-0.0030442516,
0.0201418381,
-0.065378353,
0.0105760563,
0.0163835138,
0.0050321235,
0.00830705,
0.0438786298,
0.0045701149,
0.058544904,
0.0163355805,
-0.0116300005,
-0.003562001,
-0.0107005937,
0.0174461473,
0.0145706329,
-0.0737356544,
0.0079284571,
-0.0065389252,
0.056240052,
0.0128650581,
-0.0516418144,
-0.0092447987,
0.003754006,
2.755e-7,
0.0953900665,
0.0422216207,
0.0028821295,
-0.0104593784,
0.0265721977,
0.0081940098,
-0.0020762924,
0.0306042209,
-0.0380284339,
-0.0508762188,
-0.0074427184,
-0.012352407,
-0.0066463817,
0.034379147,
-0.0378057063,
-0.0356490612,
-0.0875737742,
-0.0781613067,
-0.0728595778,
-0.0131827556,
0.0217145495,
0.0515739359,
-0.0224036369,
-0.0368269309,
0.0013082508,
-0.0264688749,
0.0102647832,
-0.0199222323,
-0.0228139106,
0.0696758777,
0.0305068735,
-0.0487321056,
0.0213898588,
0.0971847922,
-0.0162182935,
-0.023573827,
-0.0026205471,
0.0337433256,
-0.0381413177,
-0.0106138131,
0.0101542147,
-0.0397189483,
0.0241731778,
-0.0525551215,
-0.0001012216,
-0.0279055536,
-0.0457848832,
0.0071605882,
-0.02111708,
-0.004672308,
0.0272307228,
-0.033066988,
0.0148096448,
0.0359122828,
-0.0071638231,
0.0352128446,
-0.0197076425,
-0.0469767228,
-0.0048576025,
0.0417711027,
-0.0617600866,
-0.093199946,
0.0117112203,
-0.0726929232,
0.0009944527,
-0.0770500079,
0.0228011534,
2.213129387e-34,
0.0357276089,
-0.0056947037,
0.0279554594,
0.0290319808,
0.0208187141,
-0.0024971657,
0.0050253514,
0.0276861303,
0.0118175773,
-0.0858758464,
-0.0072777118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17817v1 | Transfer Learning for Power Outage Detection Task with Limited Training Data | 2023-05-28T22:36:35 | 2023-05-28T22:36:35 | Olukunle Owolabi | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.AP | Early detection of power outages is crucial for maintaining a reliable power
distribution system. This research investigates the use of transfer learning
and language models in detecting outages with limited labeled data. By
leveraging pretraining and transfer learning, models can generalize to unseen
classes.
Using a curated balanced dataset of social media tweets related to power
outages, we conducted experiments using zero-shot and few-shot learning. Our
hypothesis is that Language Models pretrained with limited data could achieve
high performance in outage detection tasks over baseline models. Results show
that while classical models outperform zero-shot Language Models, few-shot
fine-tuning significantly improves their performance. For example, with 10%
fine-tuning, BERT achieves 81.3% accuracy (+15.3%), and GPT achieves 74.5%
accuracy (+8.5%). This has practical implications for analyzing and localizing
outages in scenarios with limited data availability.
Our evaluation provides insights into the potential of few-shot fine-tuning
with Language Models for power outage detection, highlighting their strengths
and limitations. This research contributes to the knowledge base of leveraging
advanced natural language processing techniques for managing critical
infrastructure. | [
-0.0134279085,
0.0689545348,
-0.0001246963,
0.0315924212,
0.0258784201,
0.0293153208,
0.0088063516,
-0.0035202233,
-0.0399929918,
-0.0596582741,
0.0637520701,
-0.0335348137,
-0.0590552576,
0.0241411272,
0.0277658068,
-0.0811133757,
0.0539694354,
0.0134084113,
0.0489892885,
0.0182864051,
-0.0094970688,
0.0120155364,
-0.0177854225,
0.0067570624,
-0.0123494063,
0.025234567,
0.0051040784,
0.0066477857,
0.0597477667,
-0.0376121588,
0.0055625993,
0.0172743704,
0.0236343853,
0.0456161797,
0.0000018747,
-0.043168366,
-0.0547562018,
-0.0062978934,
-0.0225835089,
-0.0461999252,
-0.021813415,
-0.0520495698,
0.0248619094,
0.0259631313,
-0.0628287122,
-0.0173939317,
0.0710273981,
0.0602814481,
0.0295771826,
0.1266664267,
-0.0440080985,
-0.0115627944,
0.0116182659,
-0.0129642375,
0.0012612893,
-0.0555208549,
0.0253652968,
-0.0219859406,
-0.0118138539,
-0.0461231805,
0.0301239397,
0.0099065313,
-0.0292658433,
0.0351204649,
-0.0072984318,
0.05548862,
-0.0935114622,
0.055202011,
-0.0288906414,
0.0570195541,
-0.0360410772,
0.0011157928,
0.0426575728,
-0.0318167582,
-0.0009513625,
0.0202487949,
-0.0346684121,
-0.0295987669,
0.0057645161,
0.0499369837,
-0.0474093109,
0.0128927715,
0.0315239504,
0.0195506699,
-0.0256468318,
0.0643827543,
-0.0005888693,
-0.0286983885,
-0.0185129065,
0.0244006421,
-0.0577263944,
-0.0433647409,
0.0146850869,
0.0102664325,
-0.0081840642,
0.0129470276,
-0.0598167181,
0.0028637778,
-0.0061711408,
-0.031091392,
0.0173010454,
0.0380131528,
0.0025059734,
0.0595631637,
-0.0347200036,
0.0135625862,
-0.0052527059,
0.0699629411,
-0.0101675596,
-0.0310263783,
-0.1020487919,
-0.0078430278,
-0.0462941192,
0.0307014268,
0.027506683,
0.0011975042,
-0.0080852965,
-0.0155780185,
0.0165975764,
-0.0240242053,
-0.0407841168,
-0.0045872275,
-0.0250797812,
-0.028410662,
0.0283764638,
0.0768378228,
-0.0236770213,
0.0183467586,
-0.0294051934,
-0.0536200888,
-0.02487633,
-0.0063578286,
0.0555870011,
0.0102562681,
-0.015471884,
0.007140385,
0.0084977299,
-0.0516409539,
-0.0705364794,
0.0058078542,
-0.0023236067,
-0.0161265004,
-0.0070894496,
-0.0490159802,
-0.0271635558,
0.0149136214,
0.0368851498,
0.0006921238,
0.0183076393,
-0.0158700626,
0.0006191993,
0.0418566242,
-0.0630700067,
0.0316948034,
0.0118312575,
-0.0443418771,
-0.006019786,
0.0833110958,
0.026742423,
-0.0014438672,
0.0320986509,
-0.0490466692,
0.0439086258,
-0.0038034369,
0.0064655337,
0.0333413593,
-0.034657903,
-0.02742167,
-0.0409868956,
-0.0327007398,
-0.0166028067,
-0.0027109003,
0.0350998715,
0.0179351661,
0.0550428405,
-0.0136921946,
0.0213346109,
-0.0051680584,
0.0254824795,
0.0558859445,
-0.0593988076,
-0.0396795645,
-0.0170862526,
0.0227754954,
-0.0841554627,
0.0096462732,
0.0110357273,
0.0173280314,
-0.0264394078,
-0.0070582563,
-0.0477915406,
0.028490698,
-0.0230878182,
0.012092418,
0.0817880929,
-0.0095631257,
-0.0372223146,
0.0597907305,
0.0356517136,
0.0319158658,
0.0226809364,
-0.0398609601,
-0.036032211,
0.09508387,
0.010919855,
-0.0283834748,
-0.0123443576,
-0.0323999822,
0.0856418684,
0.0136544053,
0.0082398877,
0.0378076397,
0.0389678366,
-0.0442218594,
-0.0263223071,
0.008812679,
0.031308651,
0.0101850573,
-0.059114553,
0.0539801158,
-0.0030506274,
-0.040290948,
-0.0486023128,
0.0364206247,
0.0375036784,
-0.0179846399,
0.0020131133,
0.0375399031,
-0.0265055541,
-0.017280031,
-0.024981102,
-0.0124151437,
-0.0011676486,
-0.0459630042,
-0.0800345764,
0.0138540417,
-0.0486490019,
0.021960618,
0.0281453189,
-0.0149357766,
0.0131491227,
0.0282525867,
-0.0629394352,
-0.0553609692,
0.0487208851,
-0.0635996833,
0.0123881046,
-0.0383076407,
-0.0238622949,
-0.022143146,
0.0021794413,
0.0078836558,
0.0426669382,
0.0261834003,
-0.0096500712,
-0.0251202211,
-0.0069834907,
0.01413594,
-0.03676695,
-0.013780334,
0.0093727633,
-0.070553571,
-0.0121387197,
-0.0175612904,
0.012770013,
-0.0162354149,
0.0602102205,
-0.0654801652,
-0.019368792,
-0.0465022735,
0.0513071194,
0.0342734791,
0.0186396521,
-0.0231549479,
-0.0217572786,
-0.0046004346,
0.035023015,
-0.01573826,
0.0026018827,
0.0384205505,
-0.0006370872,
-0.0370697789,
-0.0338526852,
0.0060722609,
-0.0061724735,
0.0247275401,
-0.0014540872,
-0.0734219402,
-0.0486005656,
0.0306236483,
0.012232583,
0.0182668902,
0.0231501888,
-0.0688288882,
-0.0399993733,
-0.0383501127,
0.0190615226,
-0.0101122456,
0.0005288986,
0.006327149,
0.014383601,
-0.0363619179,
-0.016469961,
0.039049305,
-0.036786817,
-0.0367889218,
-0.0415062718,
-0.016394645,
-0.0095884707,
0.0483319163,
0.0035306758,
0.0137941465,
-0.0305881724,
-0.0243037362,
-0.0346482955,
-0.0306728277,
-0.0291726086,
0.0088733835,
0.0050124382,
0.0284426045,
0.0314293467,
-0.0027786461,
0.0355029032,
0.0172346514,
0.0204553064,
-0.0413453951,
-0.0834971443,
-0.0357404798,
0.0329636298,
-0.0293316636,
0.0443622097,
-0.001811038,
-0.0048351721,
-0.0171859991,
-0.0553925373,
-0.0210897103,
-0.0017585553,
-0.0500935726,
-0.0276067443,
0.0445426889,
-0.0093789864,
-0.0231770538,
-0.00638782,
-0.0487862527,
-0.0433116369,
-0.0036944293,
-0.0122644519,
-0.0276160371,
-0.0539958812,
0.0267641172,
-0.0127573386,
0.0640415326,
0.0034072481,
-0.0126733119,
0.0150174843,
0.0453409962,
0.0234125704,
0.020018518,
0.0173004307,
-0.0004928642,
0.0406726077,
0.0368180424,
0.0284011532,
0.0113041708,
-0.0455886163,
0.0020835241,
0.0009338778,
-0.0259376653,
-0.016187083,
0.0072596944,
0.0498091429,
-0.0204083454,
-0.0225152988,
0.1011123657,
-0.0000625498,
-0.0145677654,
-0.0010606499,
-0.0140194837,
-0.0282090176,
0.0181243233,
0.0258087721,
-0.0604657419,
-0.0500627533,
0.0344055146,
0.0654026121,
-0.0001198864,
-0.0442661718,
-0.0075802081,
-0.0704565793,
0.0011333169,
-0.0135723837,
-0.0158190411,
-0.048571296,
-0.0701546893,
0.0333267897,
-0.0518092774,
-0.0107233915,
-0.0386662595,
-0.0256761331,
-0.0124955,
0.0758124217,
-0.0470015258,
-0.0977213979,
0.0045675924,
-0.0176707525,
0.0458834767,
0.0459485836,
0.0222222134,
-0.0231041573,
-0.0092949402,
0.0347051546,
0.008289245,
-0.0100049162,
-0.0061463066,
0.0434061289,
0.0149888191,
-0.008901705,
0.0379970483,
0.0357947685,
-0.0352838747,
-0.016723711,
0.0153928101,
0.0538074523,
-0.016797578,
-0.0629639998,
-0.0358645655,
0.0188715663,
0.0854147598,
0.0252799224,
0.0080073019,
-0.0285532642,
-0.0429303125,
0.024221519,
0.0161827579,
-0.0500828512,
-0.0098467553,
0.0304698609,
-0.0048353365,
-0.0642304569,
-0.0364938043,
-0.0167231876,
0.0217679553,
0.0464274101,
0.0202959366,
-0.0566913076,
0.0422363169,
0.0235827081,
-0.025480872,
-0.0115764895,
-0.0080324132,
0.0116854208,
-0.0400043689,
-0.0046003517,
0.0136147877,
0.019721048,
-0.0252147559,
-0.0177290644,
-0.0700487196,
-0.0292775203,
0.0208774339,
0.0135781933,
0.0260630753,
-0.0151018286,
-0.0407277122,
-0.0343211778,
0.0140146054,
0.0846423581,
-0.0501188636,
-0.0167302415,
0.0221547727,
-0.0436707847,
0.0195083413,
0.0595872588,
-0.0445750393,
0.0549475513,
-0.0028436319,
0.0453547947,
-0.0523616821,
0.0595873483,
-0.0007904189,
-0.0083418563,
0.0311077517,
0.0340735689,
-0.093221277,
-0.0139134452,
0.014577914,
0.0010962321,
-0.0012958595,
-0.0323846266,
0.0074411849,
0.0163180586,
0.0177534781,
0.0016254185,
-0.0035167641,
-0.0038835085,
-0.0094634891,
-0.0503313728,
-0.0117485104,
0.0506191216,
0.0139987646,
0.0189635493,
0.0088724755,
0.0235613771,
0.0103995847,
0.0564557016,
-0.0198134705,
-0.0014629483,
-0.0118519058,
0.0340206698,
0.0067752525,
-0.0574719533,
-0.0075118672,
-0.0275281146,
-0.0460839532,
-0.0331462063,
0.0125551419,
0.0223717801,
0.0083519919,
0.0522026941,
-0.0324522071,
0.0047185901,
-0.0054243864,
0.0126814907,
0.0044194553,
0.0156665109,
0.0149545996,
0.0130573893,
-0.0314768516,
0.0497418195,
0.061161954,
0.0142863998,
0.0397651568,
0.018565895,
-0.0202246923,
-0.0286122728,
0.0355452783,
0.0249181986,
0.03924568,
0.0168347675,
0.0314075314,
-0.0358082764,
-0.0033621129,
-0.0051571373,
-0.0953714028,
0.0110928537,
0.0142916255,
0.0499475002,
0.0464009121,
0.0166217014,
0.0569883846,
0.0074300314,
-0.0135494173,
0.0341893509,
-0.0229729768,
0.0007735586,
-6.985074694e-33,
-0.0045189462,
-0.0683932528,
-0.0183875915,
-0.0183093306,
0.0103221284,
0.0468249172,
-0.0168222152,
0.0031536566,
-0.0102909738,
0.0170752965,
-0.0080883056,
0.0120738614,
0.0252376404,
0.0160277989,
0.0148256794,
-0.0112549094,
0.068669185,
0.0271408837,
-0.0309546851,
0.0245374497,
0.0805558935,
0.0551442616,
0.0935124159,
-0.054726664,
-0.0163209122,
0.0118312705,
-0.0106743826,
-0.0044736629,
0.0373294875,
0.0158151072,
-0.0252735578,
0.0640038848,
0.0333849415,
-0.0223837625,
-0.0046920893,
0.0655066967,
-0.029784292,
-0.0184147414,
-0.0178837907,
0.0011309239,
0.0177712273,
-0.0057133622,
0.0393822491,
-0.0133243632,
0.0333716646,
0.0006119268,
0.0580918826,
-0.0127973361,
0.0100395428,
-0.0099063013,
-0.0493543781,
0.0358280167,
-0.0752853975,
-0.0299904738,
0.0151001653,
0.041866634,
-0.0046392013,
0.0334328525,
-0.0382919572,
0.001141851,
0.0522559285,
0.0321057029,
0.0446473844,
-0.0200807024,
-0.0867371336,
0.0615095161,
-0.0149207786,
-0.0136279045,
0.0058571445,
-0.0231170636,
0.0287721436,
0.0628315806,
0.023188483,
0.02319251,
0.0416789651,
-0.0657698661,
-0.0911968127,
-0.0101053584,
-0.0220151693,
0.05778208,
0.053751342,
0.0408423878,
-0.0198910888,
-0.0168091189,
0.0384175144,
-0.0381085798,
-0.0234215986,
-0.0156567376,
-0.0066234046,
0.0120984614,
-0.0318589732,
0.0568814911,
0.0359432437,
0.0026641365,
-0.0224960949,
0.0170387421,
0.0170040522,
0.0165022872,
0.0010406673,
0.0145298727,
-0.0596361943,
-0.0374015644,
0.0453526303,
0.0516121387,
-0.0092940945,
-0.0557337552,
0.0429536849,
0.0706633404,
-0.0354229994,
0.0077989185,
-0.0101763438,
0.0092825228,
-0.0459605679,
0.0373868123,
0.0251847245,
0.0343596898,
0.0105978241,
0.0481643565,
-0.0023064725,
-0.042934373,
0.0546795502,
0.0236002654,
-0.021109283,
-0.0011965397,
-0.0436507501,
-0.0012014833,
-0.0519801416,
0.0000645453,
-0.0229326002,
-0.0122668734,
-0.0246743448,
0.002673792,
2.854e-7,
0.0579173751,
0.0530947633,
0.0088131763,
-0.026617324,
-0.0130456779,
0.0222350974,
-0.014460084,
0.0388685577,
0.0015880943,
0.0252105296,
0.0470993482,
-0.0071928259,
0.0334563553,
0.04585642,
-0.0583733395,
-0.0039274395,
-0.0644909292,
0.0358782671,
-0.0550142415,
-0.0339769423,
0.0821822733,
0.0460242182,
0.0579477586,
-0.0085524069,
0.029398419,
-0.0960672274,
0.0184343569,
-0.0505623221,
0.0012540767,
0.006388674,
0.0014586698,
0.0927766189,
0.0145118004,
0.008610907,
0.0037059106,
0.0303148627,
0.0306790192,
0.0003671563,
-0.0063374024,
-0.0279305093,
-0.0190956518,
0.0138184819,
0.0474931113,
-0.0350497998,
0.0539019965,
-0.1100443825,
-0.0619483069,
0.0490323938,
-0.0443832614,
-0.0187839922,
0.0053699529,
-0.0153667834,
-0.03923136,
-0.0116278352,
0.0041009919,
0.0022634098,
-0.0690763816,
-0.0345947929,
0.042007897,
0.0325244553,
-0.0014200732,
-0.045368012,
-0.0255337227,
-0.027045304,
0.0424720421,
-0.011139988,
0.0199789125,
2.115258692e-34,
0.0087233838,
0.012289458,
-0.0386804081,
0.0422664806,
-0.0062941066,
0.0220865346,
-0.0327614062,
-0.0079991538,
-0.0101417499,
-0.0808285922,
0.0176529158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.03763v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.03763v4 | ChatGPT Informed Graph Neural Network for Stock Movement Prediction | 2023-05-28T21:11:59 | 2023-09-18T20:26:04 | Zihan Chen, Lei Nico Zheng, Cheng Lu, Jialu Yuan, Di Zhu | q-fin.ST | q-fin.ST, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-fin.CP, I.2.7; J.1 | ChatGPT has demonstrated remarkable capabilities across various natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. However, its potential for inferring dynamic
network structures from temporal textual data, specifically financial news,
remains an unexplored frontier. In this research, we introduce a novel
framework that leverages ChatGPT's graph inference capabilities to enhance
Graph Neural Networks (GNN). Our framework adeptly extracts evolving network
structures from textual data, and incorporates these networks into graph neural
networks for subsequent predictive tasks. The experimental results from stock
movement forecasting indicate our model has consistently outperformed the
state-of-the-art Deep Learning-based benchmarks. Furthermore, the portfolios
constructed based on our model's outputs demonstrate higher annualized
cumulative returns, alongside reduced volatility and maximum drawdown. This
superior performance highlights the potential of ChatGPT for text-based network
inferences and underscores its promising implications for the financial sector. | [
-0.0118493568,
0.0573581867,
-0.0245042723,
-0.0074056182,
-0.003463266,
-0.0294468775,
0.0056208228,
0.0146187078,
0.0641164854,
-0.0184680372,
0.0173232146,
-0.0039441865,
-0.0335294269,
0.0773152411,
0.0366293751,
0.0118018677,
0.0179323256,
-0.0180669799,
0.0111308703,
-0.0313761234,
0.0185903683,
0.0172458906,
0.0520925336,
0.0049003707,
-0.0131307719,
-0.024771139,
-0.0372571535,
0.018003637,
0.0017192074,
-0.0228414964,
0.0098301452,
-0.0226828754,
0.0382515378,
0.0559190437,
0.0000022231,
-0.0023514093,
-0.0084534977,
-0.0096843485,
-0.0018497161,
-0.0068412051,
0.0234721731,
-0.0347188935,
0.0582157448,
-0.017373817,
-0.0572339892,
-0.0120426789,
0.0429700054,
0.0394825116,
0.0255551189,
0.0972374678,
-0.0167413838,
-0.0171379168,
0.0321080014,
-0.0724831671,
0.0161674358,
-0.0892663896,
0.0262564383,
0.0228997935,
0.0063635162,
-0.016857205,
0.0048791296,
0.0372359902,
0.0311448351,
0.0254150108,
0.038349174,
0.0191704482,
0.0094334763,
0.0232069734,
-0.0147642596,
0.0509605147,
0.0053539644,
-0.0099210255,
0.013141674,
-0.0284477826,
-0.0003691206,
0.0307741053,
-0.0241941046,
-0.0220146161,
-0.0095044477,
0.0179401506,
-0.0050737411,
-0.0168402363,
0.0403047018,
-0.0036677956,
-0.0030626974,
0.0465443693,
-0.0454851575,
0.0286855306,
0.0325869657,
-0.0010313572,
0.0039197179,
-0.058703851,
0.004182463,
-0.0004483432,
0.008328029,
-0.0140168043,
0.0043175886,
-0.0262478609,
-0.0530502275,
-0.0929919928,
-0.0273785554,
0.0057224026,
0.0091667781,
0.0486538187,
-0.0384491533,
0.0261652432,
-0.0453004614,
0.0030941668,
0.0049363691,
0.0144709758,
-0.0790293738,
-0.0276687406,
-0.0261172187,
0.0721674934,
0.0136882206,
-0.0470727459,
-0.0723247677,
0.0244962554,
-0.0130268745,
0.0106806355,
-0.0007096085,
0.066335313,
-0.0127204657,
-0.0088309385,
-0.0105369017,
-0.0133750495,
-0.0069144093,
0.0252617802,
-0.0012525173,
0.0007063333,
0.0256781261,
-0.0126500139,
0.0023445459,
0.0206268951,
0.0028970039,
0.1204066649,
0.0197008494,
-0.0333712399,
-0.0379686765,
-0.0477392375,
-0.0034918687,
-0.0119059095,
0.0243796259,
-0.0296666827,
0.0078048934,
-0.0241686814,
-0.0117140571,
0.0013173566,
0.0176341832,
-0.0402041525,
-0.0533569343,
0.0554721318,
0.0105982004,
-0.0359103605,
-0.0146542713,
-0.0561346225,
-0.0052976315,
0.0391507819,
0.0014477985,
0.0614146106,
0.0486654192,
0.0207530148,
-0.0368602127,
0.0320211202,
0.0214499775,
-0.087259464,
0.018730564,
-0.0142139643,
-0.047153797,
-0.0081697563,
0.0053860801,
0.0055220509,
-0.0397752337,
-0.0366520323,
0.052188307,
0.0471952483,
0.0375347845,
0.0837580115,
0.010516502,
0.0186622273,
-0.0054428475,
-0.0306437407,
-0.0287349839,
-0.0169324186,
-0.0242163725,
0.03004154,
-0.0515369438,
-0.0046005398,
-0.0209107827,
0.0030159811,
0.0246405341,
-0.0243605711,
0.0644236058,
-0.0335893892,
0.0238040052,
-0.042845685,
-0.0344297402,
0.0327913836,
0.0483630821,
0.0291415825,
-0.0066299606,
0.0010471417,
0.0100646326,
0.0593521707,
0.0056470963,
-0.0016076996,
-0.0218792446,
0.0064287586,
-0.015616185,
-0.0021328409,
0.0294592455,
0.0151808625,
-0.0267224796,
-0.0296970326,
-0.0030779259,
0.0087114507,
-0.0053741965,
0.0447184406,
-0.0315353274,
0.022843631,
-0.0013898674,
-0.0505890846,
-0.0074887564,
-0.0059900642,
0.0128520122,
-0.0192170087,
0.0571858548,
-0.0351527445,
0.0084073339,
0.0434007458,
-0.0159357879,
-0.0276937541,
-0.0253303777,
0.0081124911,
-0.0809804797,
0.0107549597,
-0.0678518414,
-0.0093373712,
-0.0073711481,
-0.0085611437,
0.0099403197,
0.0118568782,
-0.0268475618,
-0.007814087,
0.0689500347,
-0.0474967696,
0.0241218638,
-0.0139643932,
-0.0852731094,
0.0196996965,
0.0365269668,
0.0305496156,
0.037464343,
-0.0042123673,
-0.018036196,
-0.0322232805,
0.0289127156,
-0.007429041,
-0.0403281264,
0.027695572,
0.0127814803,
-0.0012490557,
0.0034962329,
0.0498845205,
-0.0055203163,
0.0334331095,
-0.0117723653,
-0.0595455021,
-0.0283094738,
-0.010773967,
0.0281644631,
0.0105823642,
-0.0012693098,
-0.0070240656,
-0.0346172079,
-0.0383558385,
0.057557743,
-0.0290568471,
-0.0277968794,
0.0409652963,
-0.0224566944,
-0.0094490247,
-0.0564336032,
-0.0500370599,
-0.0330826491,
0.084074676,
0.0481749848,
-0.0933312401,
0.0318351313,
-0.0298227295,
-0.0343534425,
0.0099684065,
-0.0197315272,
0.038664598,
-0.0326881818,
-0.0379777253,
-0.0118740061,
0.0457544401,
0.0015034343,
0.0271932501,
-0.060637489,
-0.0133155873,
0.0097266687,
0.0315663777,
-0.0481160134,
0.0285611488,
-0.0314547829,
-0.0013403663,
-0.0145968106,
-0.0097327568,
0.0056993719,
-0.0161610488,
-0.0838879347,
0.0110481624,
0.0056899833,
0.0418504998,
-0.0330001637,
-0.0049717622,
0.0175724179,
-0.0060675275,
-0.0178504903,
-0.0272323936,
0.0610747077,
0.0220760852,
-0.0307143237,
0.0147742005,
-0.0470380522,
-0.0808681324,
0.0645375028,
0.0342361405,
-0.0087725427,
0.0091484003,
-0.0284908041,
-0.0174466856,
-0.0004806802,
0.0104294317,
-0.0130105382,
0.0010368767,
-0.0050735478,
0.0466148034,
0.0488689467,
0.0052326489,
0.003890858,
-0.0173809752,
-0.043161016,
0.0380082987,
0.0502018109,
-0.0549788512,
0.01624077,
0.0019519654,
-0.048931133,
0.010113419,
-0.0380007029,
-0.0178014562,
0.0040449202,
0.0379438549,
0.0512922071,
-0.0407109298,
0.0193018485,
-0.0285704006,
0.0541547947,
0.0255907029,
0.011001586,
-0.0153190522,
-0.0484898277,
0.0163173769,
-0.0527971312,
0.0035101562,
0.0004493125,
0.0027995303,
-0.0054479213,
-0.0512668975,
0.0308195073,
0.0545430109,
-0.0073140617,
-0.0088570127,
0.0243966952,
0.0776966885,
0.0249358732,
-0.0288985167,
0.0272481535,
-0.0996964201,
-0.0217372049,
-0.0238968544,
0.0086228354,
0.057778649,
-0.0662538558,
-0.0269161388,
-0.0690266863,
0.0336950533,
0.0122734942,
-0.0223926399,
0.0065043094,
-0.0496347286,
-0.0026818682,
-0.0576743335,
-0.0210944545,
-0.0149442833,
-0.0040541119,
0.0146673722,
0.006974271,
-0.1249993593,
0.0220853649,
0.0137290703,
-0.0048932685,
-0.0374465995,
-0.0149187678,
-0.0018823091,
-0.0424692407,
0.0443478152,
0.0201674271,
0.0242645778,
0.0041982587,
0.0274165757,
0.0849021748,
-0.014896973,
-0.0278141405,
0.0001030463,
0.0534980111,
-0.0186180975,
0.014890654,
-0.0054353387,
-0.0014732133,
0.0072294753,
-0.0889188126,
0.0107378736,
0.0248086024,
-0.0135916593,
-0.0280160103,
0.0032941224,
-0.0273268148,
-0.0558182783,
-0.0640575364,
0.0196807832,
-0.0711059794,
-0.0280506946,
-0.0084814122,
-0.012403491,
-0.0114299962,
-0.0555305332,
-0.0402279049,
-0.0238806978,
-0.005899501,
-0.0139002409,
0.0061761583,
0.0700508133,
-0.0190206692,
-0.0623018667,
-0.0001684065,
0.0389888994,
0.0064279335,
0.0341840945,
0.0206267014,
0.0168497544,
-0.0178778488,
-0.0387982316,
0.0533765927,
-0.1221639514,
-0.0917858556,
-0.0213753283,
-0.0114603778,
0.0139021594,
0.0186683293,
-0.0291496757,
0.0090962611,
0.0582868196,
0.073898606,
-0.0051987055,
-0.0423522927,
0.0231479649,
-0.0005917556,
-0.0090180673,
0.023861574,
-0.0261868685,
0.0226850957,
-0.0254116114,
-0.0240751095,
-0.0306097735,
0.0264549702,
-0.029522879,
0.0104908934,
0.0433426052,
0.067503795,
-0.0306098331,
-0.0411070324,
-0.0537436157,
0.0310518518,
0.015867386,
-0.0197483879,
-0.0400712453,
0.0097637791,
0.0032857026,
-0.0475119352,
-0.0018486859,
0.0609781742,
-0.0086211953,
-0.0315718018,
-0.0383008644,
0.0001891817,
0.0059508067,
0.0202003885,
-0.0022143389,
0.0257510543,
-0.0138948793,
0.03373136,
-0.0026834651,
-0.0373237804,
-0.0175236203,
0.0078473184,
0.008766857,
-0.0303287134,
-0.0611424372,
-0.0880344659,
-0.051388409,
-0.0250336658,
0.0501244627,
0.0110171027,
0.0090426728,
0.0076372325,
-0.0414937399,
0.0303786863,
0.001881238,
0.0480619892,
-0.037146762,
-0.0194772221,
-0.0067807008,
0.0034106334,
-0.0650264174,
0.0125340773,
0.0459393412,
0.0540291965,
0.0178191159,
0.0019093184,
-0.031606745,
-0.0322567225,
-0.0229862183,
0.0397467539,
0.0555941835,
0.0233013928,
0.0193788595,
-0.0176790021,
-0.0579302944,
0.0514078438,
0.0219929833,
0.0560436584,
0.0270646922,
0.015926199,
0.0395697057,
0.0243350212,
0.025831759,
0.0201009922,
0.0109550003,
-0.0055197868,
-0.0096045434,
-0.0602148362,
-6.292547626e-33,
0.0254992284,
-0.0207319837,
0.0302073844,
0.0533551909,
-0.0608183146,
0.0584420152,
-0.0584317595,
0.0030191031,
0.0035716048,
0.0425565466,
0.0223777946,
0.0488460064,
-0.0078417547,
0.0181542393,
-0.0042207213,
-0.03727163,
0.0137241846,
-0.0207890347,
0.0285946261,
0.0285378192,
0.049208831,
0.0994397327,
0.0520614199,
-0.0237400234,
-0.0155538237,
-0.0273456872,
-0.0309358854,
-0.0382913686,
0.0721431524,
0.0147899566,
0.0022787312,
0.0608110316,
0.037440598,
-0.0338217206,
-0.000209624,
-0.0169373304,
-0.0155931218,
-0.0571834929,
-0.0158164799,
0.0104425997,
-0.0276088919,
0.0341003239,
0.0539379641,
0.0227535367,
0.0539245605,
-0.0266136359,
0.0486273095,
0.0524524972,
-0.0173450522,
-0.0073569496,
-0.0405058861,
0.0347360261,
-0.0222039949,
0.0407720022,
0.0158036537,
0.064896524,
0.0062109306,
0.0015072046,
-0.0393326133,
-0.0019152014,
-0.0317686945,
0.0071847904,
-0.0401869565,
0.0298703406,
-0.0018306293,
0.0739940479,
0.0067714667,
0.0094439322,
-0.0422431678,
0.0542351156,
0.0309969205,
0.080350697,
0.0260652844,
-0.0081713963,
-0.0020544387,
-0.0445591211,
-0.1057750285,
-0.0323354043,
0.0499644801,
0.0044532297,
0.00171584,
0.0259351693,
0.0135887032,
-0.0442315005,
0.0449557826,
-0.0345479213,
-0.0084506981,
-0.0070769703,
-0.0047825268,
0.0053058849,
0.0050768186,
0.0705050603,
-0.0144189969,
-0.0796559006,
-0.0285211597,
0.0379699469,
-0.0308883823,
0.0222012494,
0.0200741123,
-0.0002712822,
-0.0475790761,
-0.0264749993,
-0.0190933179,
0.0076996218,
-0.0077312654,
-0.0550336726,
0.0475680977,
0.0308180861,
-0.0150690069,
-0.0415091142,
0.0064624357,
0.0161206834,
0.0185666569,
-0.0031683003,
0.0304575358,
0.0333936289,
-0.0121042514,
0.0439904556,
0.058972504,
0.0799667835,
-0.0023928639,
0.0042271689,
0.009118136,
0.0015104907,
-0.0111377891,
-0.015736606,
0.0116863446,
0.0736955404,
-0.0001108638,
-0.0692765117,
-0.0360967219,
0.03594926,
2.846e-7,
0.0568637773,
0.0636537746,
0.0569205768,
0.0185527001,
0.0504866019,
0.0177687835,
-0.0126889059,
0.017798122,
0.0141190179,
-0.0178678539,
0.0754760206,
0.033175379,
0.0170061793,
0.0421610959,
-0.0636010543,
-0.0211035367,
-0.0826307908,
0.0081310822,
-0.0707907826,
0.0071901516,
0.0107056564,
0.0628771633,
0.0416640118,
-0.0142785357,
0.0084747151,
-0.0676989704,
0.0524704456,
-0.0164055768,
-0.0138242161,
0.0145466924,
0.0129180392,
0.0114320545,
-0.0576870181,
0.0168361384,
-0.0110113472,
0.0405702218,
0.002586121,
-0.0343906097,
0.0048793829,
0.0483693928,
0.0063989661,
0.0041056504,
-0.0202742461,
-0.0271228105,
0.0597098358,
-0.1007872969,
-0.012454831,
-0.0675978437,
-0.0590341724,
0.0215051807,
0.050242506,
0.0225107297,
-0.0137965074,
0.0351934843,
0.0120619116,
-0.0214211922,
0.0223003048,
-0.0682049021,
0.0017409775,
0.0230842605,
-0.0642256066,
0.0177556723,
-0.0270769056,
0.0242124703,
0.0482724495,
-0.0041277227,
0.0550724901,
2.134979906e-34,
0.0640281513,
-0.0039725993,
-0.0491487272,
-0.0000168055,
0.0548352115,
0.0170145985,
0.0040565915,
0.0126401372,
0.0120229321,
-0.0652409717,
-0.0533987619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17812v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17812v1 | Tab-CoT: Zero-shot Tabular Chain of Thought | 2023-05-28T20:49:52 | 2023-05-28T20:49:52 | Ziqi Jin, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | The chain-of-though (CoT) prompting methods were successful in various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks thanks to their ability to unveil the
underlying complex reasoning processes. Such reasoning processes typically
exhibit implicitly structured steps. Recent efforts also started investigating
methods to encourage more explicitly structured reasoning procedures to be
captured. In this work, we propose Tab-CoT, a novel tabular-format CoT
prompting method, which allows the complex reasoning process to be explicitly
modelled in a highly structured manner. Despite its simplicity, we show that
our approach is capable of performing reasoning across multiple dimensions
(i.e., both rows and columns). We demonstrate our approach's strong zero-shot
and few-shot capabilities through extensive experiments on a range of reasoning
tasks. | [
0.0138516463,
0.0230193418,
-0.005715277,
0.0093026506,
-0.0483087711,
0.0326636545,
0.0428479426,
0.0205670111,
0.0161848199,
-0.0220473967,
0.007572548,
-0.0210949033,
0.0048065423,
0.0269768294,
0.0175538901,
-0.056197416,
0.0157133993,
-0.0232358128,
0.0001588748,
0.0192636531,
-0.0063002398,
0.0057095299,
-0.0739017874,
0.0089578321,
0.0017754632,
-0.0410669334,
-0.0745329484,
-0.0072333692,
-0.0073033371,
-0.0509093404,
-0.0284097362,
0.0660973117,
-0.0010719268,
0.0267436057,
0.0000023052,
-0.019607909,
-0.0438264795,
-0.0082075791,
-0.0207425561,
-0.0273458753,
-0.0284931604,
-0.0093784025,
0.0129132327,
-0.0111171966,
-0.0330200493,
-0.0111525171,
0.0219450109,
0.0576650873,
0.0711077899,
0.0257131122,
-0.0100762388,
-0.038239304,
0.0002007227,
0.028754063,
0.0577444881,
-0.0408999249,
-0.0231401436,
-0.0186296497,
0.0515035018,
-0.0019042856,
0.0159232467,
0.0266915951,
0.0418565497,
-0.0285375249,
0.0286288261,
0.0284491833,
-0.0337694436,
-0.0171858799,
-0.0116168503,
0.0745595917,
0.0235087276,
-0.0023994441,
0.0248380676,
-0.032569401,
0.012948079,
-0.0187253356,
-0.0591561496,
-0.0028309328,
-0.0457081497,
-0.0232260954,
0.0052187108,
0.0443346165,
-0.0317744091,
-0.0167168137,
-0.0436810702,
0.0505216904,
-0.0213100035,
-0.0517356843,
0.0034524216,
0.0072306413,
0.0581619628,
-0.0689172894,
0.0192204826,
0.0634842366,
-0.0688927695,
0.0086372495,
0.0176585447,
-0.0236395281,
0.0181285553,
-0.0185801461,
0.0601246431,
0.0502522364,
-0.0033536693,
0.0372192971,
-0.0655804053,
0.023573108,
-0.0423945561,
0.006943542,
-0.0079711834,
0.0162548088,
-0.0653477237,
-0.0146661913,
-0.0358944312,
0.044993788,
-0.0523514673,
0.0022768867,
0.0220200848,
0.0173369739,
-0.0193819087,
0.0329926684,
-0.0098855356,
0.0326668061,
0.0378446132,
-0.0210974254,
-0.0514420569,
0.0280001704,
-0.0862563774,
-0.0167126376,
0.0192323904,
-0.0223895386,
-0.0286538638,
-0.0170496199,
0.0265043378,
-0.0258352924,
0.0116175218,
0.0540551953,
-0.0394768007,
0.0094651477,
-0.0458484925,
-0.055719804,
-0.0257907771,
-0.0604739413,
0.0203097388,
-0.0515084676,
0.0278858989,
0.0208043121,
-0.0102385236,
-0.0093143284,
0.0046228548,
0.0689428672,
-0.0239916462,
0.0899726897,
-0.0200315621,
-0.0219117999,
-0.024785256,
0.0018090303,
-0.0254632756,
0.03172566,
0.0266448278,
0.023923764,
-0.0206154343,
-0.0063703367,
0.0226195063,
-0.0077523566,
0.0107731773,
-0.0512486137,
-0.0162366126,
0.0349604487,
-0.0499460734,
0.043892052,
-0.0253678877,
-0.0009137952,
-0.0145475483,
0.0712796524,
0.0146639757,
0.0990354866,
-0.0012165383,
0.0471969768,
0.0296080504,
0.0030978241,
0.0063486141,
0.0360450856,
-0.0110991467,
0.0804253146,
-0.0268983748,
0.0058948398,
0.0444326997,
0.0249306243,
-0.0180018172,
-0.0668043718,
0.0054371865,
0.0613499284,
0.0207939986,
-0.0205129571,
0.0317469127,
0.0275706165,
-0.0393109843,
0.0103679383,
0.0266699195,
-0.0509725064,
-0.0668993294,
-0.0303091761,
0.0234155022,
0.0674170554,
0.0405439176,
-0.0266174134,
-0.0279880688,
-0.0226710755,
0.0408070721,
0.0253900848,
0.0080689909,
-0.0201345887,
-0.0468968749,
-0.0255792066,
-0.0093538128,
0.0258054361,
0.0073716436,
-0.0158914234,
-0.0113863219,
-0.0268617719,
-0.0301692821,
0.0157568846,
0.0104676858,
0.023746442,
0.0742066428,
0.0013952341,
0.0200236738,
0.0360228196,
-0.0032462783,
0.0418467149,
0.0248937029,
0.0227275677,
0.0184349529,
-0.0158081725,
-0.029403232,
-0.0230740458,
-0.0496332161,
-0.0647145957,
-0.0102884052,
0.0115258647,
-0.060425397,
-0.0612781309,
-0.0356122442,
-0.0073973807,
0.0219500046,
-0.0128202923,
-0.0312700346,
-0.0146501269,
-0.005216754,
0.0068643102,
-0.0294344984,
-0.0130487829,
0.1142609343,
0.0061514964,
0.0321289748,
0.0418938473,
-0.0657317936,
0.0100012394,
-0.0204300955,
0.0373074114,
0.029097518,
-0.0176890343,
-0.0018548303,
-0.0005699295,
0.0423949845,
-0.0536686704,
-0.0081392881,
-0.0591843799,
0.019777311,
-0.0176206436,
0.014057233,
0.0074987495,
-0.0057371706,
-0.0038919211,
-0.0409855172,
-0.0345099494,
-0.0005962028,
-0.0077242074,
0.0052556517,
0.0843530297,
-0.0255351551,
-0.018523505,
0.0127044693,
-0.0083150417,
-0.0687966496,
0.0575503111,
-0.0003390481,
-0.0365707316,
-0.0093646413,
-0.0100091388,
0.0032340225,
-0.0132231889,
0.030124208,
0.0241871886,
0.0630355179,
-0.0218315087,
0.0135484645,
0.0765237659,
-0.0263259765,
0.0392043591,
0.0260960925,
-0.0257848967,
-0.0280797072,
0.0600722916,
0.0048629637,
0.0405878462,
0.0414337814,
-0.0311465785,
0.0114126513,
0.0629655719,
-0.01165256,
0.0315154344,
-0.0613447577,
0.0343045443,
0.01630955,
0.0211063009,
-0.0668035075,
0.0373184122,
-0.015999807,
0.0619574375,
-0.0122604258,
0.0236024037,
0.0709137022,
-0.0285367463,
-0.0204004087,
-0.034826342,
0.0175462626,
-0.0308457427,
0.1194693223,
-0.0090636443,
-0.0253856536,
0.0549029894,
-0.0139847836,
-0.0181683507,
-0.0113396803,
0.0043308879,
0.0047436757,
0.0467534959,
-0.0433854982,
-0.0072690495,
-0.0181331355,
-0.0326683857,
-0.0262073148,
-0.028201472,
-0.0322553255,
-0.0016975572,
-0.0161497183,
-0.0130402306,
-0.0146109769,
-0.0309309959,
0.0579614192,
0.0637440085,
-0.0080948006,
-0.0503257476,
-0.056987416,
0.0709200576,
0.0040961411,
-0.0164550357,
0.0073577301,
0.0054094777,
0.0477577187,
0.0739475191,
0.0019339267,
0.020779945,
-0.0080257673,
0.0287850946,
-0.003124055,
0.001381268,
-0.0005722524,
0.0377547406,
0.0297823884,
-0.0763824135,
0.0009710476,
0.0918253586,
0.0545333885,
-0.0048526013,
-0.0014089774,
-0.0191366952,
0.0485925339,
0.0377030447,
0.0523306169,
-0.0980005637,
-0.0503695309,
0.008555783,
-0.03203113,
-0.0155505911,
-0.0678672045,
-0.0393878967,
-0.1095570028,
0.0466563702,
-0.04275617,
0.0171903521,
-0.0234799944,
-0.0326297134,
0.014680502,
0.0245040897,
-0.0508179106,
0.0456443205,
-0.0015823182,
0.0017795856,
0.0053711799,
-0.0219485257,
0.023996029,
0.0194497146,
-0.03544176,
0.0153119927,
0.0021088663,
0.0332202278,
0.0186836477,
-0.0457628593,
-0.0137263974,
0.0020056048,
0.0332088284,
-0.014375654,
0.0242729578,
0.0331827998,
0.0202673692,
-0.0448515452,
0.0114823272,
-0.031253662,
-0.0336927995,
0.0279158819,
0.0920845345,
-0.0431592911,
-0.0123826498,
0.0088876467,
0.0074129775,
-0.0160282329,
0.0569253117,
0.0382383689,
-0.0207505617,
-0.0538709983,
-0.0359531268,
-0.0680327415,
-0.0713926405,
-0.0301157236,
0.0128433313,
0.0325417854,
-0.0000968338,
-0.0658957213,
-0.0225840993,
0.0656424686,
0.0724236146,
-0.0256376602,
0.0162023138,
0.0040822648,
-0.0037341544,
-0.0033575015,
-0.019882543,
0.0099038323,
0.0165127199,
0.0205463022,
0.0009266292,
-0.0224780273,
-0.0127395745,
-0.0180360675,
0.0279287919,
-0.0323550738,
-0.0194787532,
-0.0633861646,
0.0203982536,
0.0233835317,
0.0109283384,
0.0044110157,
-0.0027963761,
-0.0037228691,
0.0255100038,
-0.0452217981,
-0.0411720611,
0.0134251239,
0.0001891681,
0.0170691255,
0.0387012213,
0.0230930578,
-0.0092900405,
-0.0407470763,
0.0521087907,
-0.0390528888,
0.0335283428,
0.045415502,
-0.0222778041,
0.0102618504,
0.0094002122,
-0.0410291627,
-0.0195341147,
0.0315688066,
-0.0600902885,
-0.0537482239,
-0.0081611043,
0.024276128,
-0.022152042,
-0.0229844954,
-0.01491528,
-0.0338562131,
-0.0256006401,
0.0483046062,
-0.0155435624,
-0.0111258524,
0.0429704487,
-0.012406541,
0.0092764003,
-0.0230140127,
0.0020016683,
0.0086079296,
-0.0142446971,
0.0477122329,
-0.0290637575,
0.0981123224,
0.0370232277,
-0.037784189,
-0.0523449257,
0.0158180408,
-0.0657412931,
-0.0633454397,
0.0313687585,
0.0074763219,
-0.0034079805,
0.0296025649,
-0.0080442941,
0.0049076402,
-0.0093482938,
0.0779802576,
0.0268747918,
0.0468725748,
-0.0337718837,
-0.0016463776,
0.0280289892,
0.0088005913,
-0.0827346966,
0.0366504937,
-0.0226649065,
-0.0229629073,
-0.0025045874,
-0.026350474,
-0.0336735621,
-0.0084994491,
-0.0502094366,
0.0632452369,
0.0045179143,
0.0079283044,
-0.0630008876,
-0.0181320738,
0.0143706361,
0.0168693643,
0.0045666131,
0.0057720463,
0.0445576161,
0.0489972979,
0.0416638292,
-0.0315815583,
-0.0226492714,
0.0213156864,
0.0092615141,
-0.0539271943,
-0.0418279842,
-6.890977841e-33,
-0.0201610439,
-0.0349657387,
0.047971271,
0.020067431,
0.0296464674,
-0.0212798882,
-0.0633669421,
0.0117751202,
0.022226667,
0.023248326,
-0.0455353446,
0.0006940042,
0.0103310738,
0.0037524174,
0.0308189727,
-0.0325267874,
0.0022987481,
-0.0023449855,
-0.0198344663,
-0.0123386355,
0.0131546687,
0.0066407719,
-0.0098632146,
-0.0206817277,
0.0649453402,
0.0185755342,
-0.0040831044,
0.0165090431,
-0.0033835813,
0.0161326881,
-0.0320141688,
0.0079863966,
0.0429157726,
-0.046941489,
-0.0049321582,
0.0587015636,
-0.1078576893,
-0.043534264,
0.0122415274,
-0.0061420458,
-0.0802097172,
-0.003470788,
-0.0110520199,
-0.0126255173,
0.0171647817,
-0.0393585004,
0.0231523905,
-0.0181642119,
0.0328022353,
-0.012124653,
-0.0370762907,
0.0062107798,
-0.0510336831,
-0.0419779867,
0.0315800793,
0.072234571,
0.0077320645,
-0.0215783473,
-0.0549322627,
-0.0025073271,
-0.010127156,
0.0024657263,
0.0381483659,
-0.0295419041,
-0.0114866896,
0.0511894785,
0.0263342727,
0.0006016076,
-0.0965578854,
0.0165995415,
-0.0372693837,
0.0400175899,
0.0477757044,
-0.021091342,
0.0682918578,
0.0571719632,
-0.0417051613,
0.0192377325,
0.0155103132,
0.0218412466,
0.0114378668,
0.0002894244,
-0.03074467,
-0.0185846277,
-0.0091125583,
-0.0438017957,
-0.0336468071,
-0.0103311967,
-0.0087237637,
-0.0101586208,
0.0236927345,
0.0168702379,
-0.0002522963,
0.027657792,
0.0033148874,
0.0134800449,
-0.0052863383,
0.029338453,
0.0106037008,
-0.007125983,
-0.0008184829,
0.0152573185,
-0.0006636948,
0.0148937237,
0.0407561325,
0.0243330169,
0.0686631873,
-0.0091482764,
-0.0744711906,
-0.024191875,
-0.0573967509,
0.0368407816,
-0.0028199155,
-0.0047514695,
0.0104768919,
0.0369222052,
-0.0246414989,
0.0882387683,
-0.0006838057,
-0.0261181798,
-0.030710509,
0.0501045585,
-0.0300312042,
0.0057707289,
0.0109618874,
-0.0153146451,
-0.0263499636,
0.0103612514,
0.0503151566,
-0.0637200773,
0.0016824144,
0.0533942617,
2.897e-7,
0.0232430268,
0.0319618769,
0.0181430466,
0.0089171482,
0.0160550904,
0.0430937447,
0.0099743875,
-0.0171275586,
-0.0312435459,
-0.081207484,
-0.0017233585,
0.0301397648,
0.0475394614,
0.0502980165,
-0.0915236101,
-0.0359395929,
-0.0367386676,
-0.0324467421,
-0.0560771562,
0.0130821969,
0.1184139773,
-0.0006238882,
-0.0045707044,
-0.0223794896,
0.0010909484,
-0.0068480722,
0.0061684973,
0.040857736,
0.0639811605,
0.0031141485,
-0.0184117518,
-0.0775385126,
-0.012420997,
0.0673253089,
-0.011649847,
-0.0184394009,
-0.0234540142,
0.0287909545,
0.012304143,
0.0371681526,
-0.0157889649,
-0.0616695657,
0.0001667309,
-0.0338475667,
0.0858363211,
-0.0449828804,
-0.0087772673,
0.0429370962,
0.0232709236,
0.0087059895,
0.0205219239,
0.0394506305,
-0.0157790165,
0.0086364755,
0.0080785658,
-0.0116466852,
0.0121336933,
-0.0766397938,
-0.0320777446,
0.020173816,
0.0119660031,
0.0262719113,
-0.0389107987,
-0.034702532,
0.0249640774,
-0.0757303461,
-0.0309169926,
2.899240415e-34,
0.0217068214,
0.0124819018,
0.048454769,
0.0541976206,
0.0782035738,
-0.0035238282,
-0.0097821122,
-0.0153089557,
0.049365133,
-0.0673948973,
-0.0207600538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.01768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.01768v1 | A Quantitative Review on Language Model Efficiency Research | 2023-05-28T20:25:20 | 2023-05-28T20:25:20 | Meng Jiang, Hy Dang, Lingbo Tong | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Language models (LMs) are being scaled and becoming powerful. Improving their
efficiency is one of the core research topics in neural information processing
systems. Tay et al. (2022) provided a comprehensive overview of efficient
Transformers that have become an indispensable staple in the field of NLP.
However, in the section of "On Evaluation", they left an open question "which
fundamental efficient Transformer one should consider," answered by "still a
mystery" because "many research papers select their own benchmarks."
Unfortunately, there was not quantitative analysis about the performances of
Transformers on any benchmarks. Moreover, state space models (SSMs) have
demonstrated their abilities of modeling long-range sequences with
non-attention mechanisms, which were not discussed in the prior review. This
article makes a meta analysis on the results from a set of papers on efficient
Transformers as well as those on SSMs. It provides a quantitative review on LM
efficiency research and gives suggestions for future research. | [
0.0333362482,
0.0389120765,
-0.011629357,
0.0415802673,
-0.0560692735,
-0.0139954761,
-0.0004936173,
-0.0011914225,
-0.0451094769,
-0.0613713339,
-0.0510027148,
-0.0812333003,
0.0345770866,
0.0193363167,
0.0230309628,
-0.0551625006,
0.0569768064,
-0.0253070407,
-0.0201294962,
0.0212900713,
-0.0235060751,
-0.0634978935,
0.0031858173,
0.0850845352,
0.0232000388,
0.0108897798,
-0.0072373203,
-0.0205486212,
-0.0047780499,
-0.0304375757,
-0.0017436687,
0.0656480342,
-0.0234685373,
0.0517286286,
0.0000020103,
-0.0123747252,
0.0019206498,
0.0027145157,
0.0019323375,
0.0223791152,
0.0194164272,
-0.0253926311,
-0.0197077356,
0.0366054364,
-0.0210259501,
-0.036209207,
0.0820151642,
0.0250713378,
0.0266086161,
0.099071689,
-0.0255558398,
-0.0302483533,
0.0256475396,
-0.0537531711,
-0.0208832417,
-0.0299448483,
0.0366868414,
-0.0414051563,
-0.0193119962,
0.0025169363,
-0.0630041137,
0.0619828142,
0.0074748062,
0.006989059,
-0.0098947594,
0.0246789418,
-0.0113392724,
-0.0081960736,
-0.0077106301,
0.0338080004,
-0.049697753,
-0.0025831964,
0.0062016672,
0.0068156999,
-0.0293979235,
0.0138688013,
-0.0531373508,
0.0254980344,
0.0195463393,
0.0478662774,
0.0072093965,
0.0209248476,
0.0255279224,
-0.0233355239,
-0.0488881245,
0.0682670698,
0.0226336028,
-0.0308654606,
-0.0171852857,
-0.0102085583,
-0.0114164194,
-0.0776212886,
0.0280418247,
0.0648517609,
0.0138209295,
0.0318816938,
-0.0168454293,
-0.0571460985,
0.0038089969,
-0.063397631,
0.0509990975,
0.0485094264,
0.0238366313,
0.011191939,
-0.0248481128,
0.0732038692,
-0.0430933125,
0.0374218822,
-0.0331336968,
-0.0007300223,
-0.0391038209,
-0.0176521819,
-0.0368163958,
0.0137511604,
-0.004036115,
-0.0425241441,
-0.0705251768,
0.0126221431,
0.0173696429,
-0.040845681,
0.0252990276,
-0.0043404102,
-0.0232415069,
0.0195230283,
-0.0446508825,
0.0673618838,
0.0188500509,
0.0022309534,
-0.001223716,
-0.0351942927,
-0.0179755893,
0.0249810033,
-0.0023402967,
-0.0253595281,
-0.0186291337,
0.0736863464,
0.0193702597,
-0.0746530369,
-0.0220164843,
0.0280608311,
-0.0176778417,
-0.0578091927,
0.0249289852,
-0.0504701026,
0.0113988062,
0.0230473615,
0.0033267813,
-0.034164153,
0.0181892123,
0.0334792137,
-0.0392659083,
0.0265857559,
0.0208694339,
0.0048559541,
-0.0390458554,
0.0112278964,
0.0084408671,
0.0575055443,
0.052972991,
0.0162078105,
0.0146371843,
-0.0441146903,
0.0054949168,
0.0382611416,
0.0040802662,
-0.0091502909,
-0.027351601,
-0.0429164581,
-0.008279385,
-0.0029581471,
0.0327923596,
0.1072463393,
-0.0159113966,
-0.01107419,
0.0659788996,
0.0525897518,
0.0602933429,
0.0305716489,
0.0375333391,
0.0031685035,
0.0263326466,
-0.0027363366,
-0.0300174281,
0.0272722859,
0.01256618,
0.0142681282,
0.0315326564,
0.018372206,
-0.0148430737,
-0.0370221138,
-0.0361120328,
-0.0267553926,
0.0144496672,
-0.0150220161,
0.07220947,
-0.0001834776,
-0.0709135309,
0.0899153054,
-0.0011983477,
-0.0274835993,
-0.0140986443,
-0.0724131912,
-0.0335444435,
0.0180112682,
0.0240160786,
-0.0150838755,
-0.0180032849,
-0.0025734277,
-0.0448333845,
0.0512161031,
0.0150766149,
0.0274520032,
0.0029065786,
-0.0287288222,
-0.0028438524,
0.0230516065,
-0.0008524167,
0.0122046741,
0.0129347285,
0.0043949308,
0.0430547372,
-0.0310780164,
-0.0000439214,
0.0356623381,
-0.0130370772,
-0.0031162677,
-0.007382852,
0.0011531026,
0.049120266,
0.0022492162,
0.0179457348,
0.044733759,
0.0388622358,
-0.036618609,
-0.023651896,
0.0281340312,
-0.0629826859,
-0.039032951,
0.0305623654,
-0.0173488725,
0.0449257977,
0.0794679597,
-0.0169245712,
-0.0742149577,
0.0084961019,
-0.0684897751,
0.0622826517,
-0.037805371,
0.0522855856,
0.0093505168,
0.0457363166,
-0.0478615612,
0.0406732708,
-0.0322489254,
0.0511947386,
0.0114145353,
-0.0148782395,
0.0120138023,
-0.0030082457,
-0.0370902009,
0.0169944931,
-0.0360484533,
-0.0124816084,
0.0008764834,
-0.0472627468,
-0.0047004647,
-0.0332233123,
-0.0405452177,
-0.0039262972,
-0.0418728627,
0.04360497,
0.0093663465,
0.0279141776,
0.025596505,
0.0264910869,
-0.0132343825,
0.0131590655,
0.0378297195,
0.0403485782,
0.0329409502,
0.0184087083,
-0.0665104017,
-0.0656414181,
-0.0520595051,
0.0111177601,
0.0682095811,
-0.0399372652,
-0.0080421893,
-0.0709728524,
0.0123338783,
0.0023899968,
0.0476345643,
-0.032263834,
-0.0470105708,
-0.0021726163,
-0.006003309,
0.0673164055,
0.0164096057,
0.0295511652,
0.0112747587,
0.0336293988,
0.0095386812,
0.0010781309,
0.0118596368,
-0.0381342955,
0.0170886386,
-0.0721901506,
-0.0100908233,
0.0407645404,
0.1191154495,
-0.0216121599,
-0.0248914678,
-0.0357329473,
-0.0478096753,
-0.0011184835,
-0.0201559886,
0.0209738631,
-0.0085379798,
-0.0456832722,
0.0293693431,
-0.0102167707,
-0.0343260691,
0.0284314565,
-0.0582626574,
-0.0121023878,
-0.0029195216,
-0.010090244,
-0.0429420806,
0.0575034879,
0.0525878705,
0.0003996711,
-0.0255554765,
-0.0303184744,
-0.011137452,
0.0093613006,
-0.0193532631,
-0.0270916745,
0.0905717537,
0.0041544549,
0.0172263868,
-0.0364785306,
-0.0083048381,
-0.0549711809,
-0.0193451196,
-0.0291722678,
0.016714396,
0.065317668,
-0.0214549564,
-0.0637858212,
0.0811684877,
0.0062585361,
0.0434743129,
-0.0171998646,
-0.0071286103,
-0.0043229815,
0.0316717289,
0.041314356,
0.0010607706,
0.0336132012,
-0.0067118504,
0.0009803503,
0.0546896383,
0.0421697013,
0.0439630747,
-0.0264534876,
-0.0320513174,
0.0551063605,
-0.0765061453,
-0.0443219021,
0.0291917138,
0.0035946327,
-0.0642670691,
-0.0183136743,
0.1185481697,
0.018782327,
-0.0244527757,
0.0378323756,
0.002296729,
0.0209198594,
0.0085943807,
-0.0044469414,
-0.0144366743,
-0.0087354286,
0.0111290794,
-0.0139833149,
-0.0174563657,
-0.0171694458,
-0.0103505226,
-0.084061861,
-0.0193806142,
-0.0155518781,
-0.0508214124,
-0.047919672,
-0.0531939529,
0.021930797,
-0.0135174571,
-0.0067312731,
0.0460746996,
-0.0384950303,
-0.0129056703,
0.0343193524,
-0.033380162,
-0.0459614322,
-0.0101765003,
-0.0365144871,
0.0432010628,
0.0587799512,
0.0102390181,
-0.0171381831,
-0.0712835863,
0.0304307658,
-0.0002835023,
0.0095397374,
-0.0039254529,
0.0207672231,
-0.0142323775,
-0.0199524835,
-0.0193568952,
-0.0025437528,
-0.0235912912,
0.0003217124,
-0.0454255417,
0.0525866337,
-0.0213958994,
-0.0101760868,
-0.0240537338,
-0.0059681009,
-0.012134566,
0.0799064785,
0.0383744575,
-0.0201996155,
-0.0611333102,
0.0040710801,
0.0016709042,
-0.0346070006,
-0.0363064744,
0.0016387255,
0.0468052402,
-0.0573376119,
-0.0560629703,
-0.0277882684,
0.0015836547,
0.0273021385,
-0.0094021764,
0.0149795562,
0.0518345572,
0.0012511507,
-0.0101519115,
0.0020466612,
-0.0186806824,
0.0213642884,
-0.07442417,
0.0111226533,
0.0398683324,
0.0405599251,
-0.0315459371,
-0.0306770951,
-0.1303055286,
-0.0447782204,
0.0388328917,
0.0369844399,
0.0253110882,
-0.0268270932,
0.0097431038,
-0.0072882012,
0.0036351215,
0.0190718472,
0.0083258813,
0.0108883921,
0.0447219461,
-0.0102387359,
-0.0016425224,
0.0119114183,
0.0060430351,
0.0332085453,
0.0170970093,
0.0630879402,
0.0093349246,
-0.0543664619,
-0.0015743106,
-0.002211523,
0.0736578181,
-0.003226029,
0.0008041555,
0.0316682756,
0.0210663509,
-0.0346529223,
0.0417596251,
-0.0495830886,
-0.0290121473,
0.0217707437,
0.0286867917,
-0.034059938,
0.0040584579,
-0.0222805161,
-0.0042135427,
0.0132566839,
0.0449756049,
-0.0404065587,
-0.0261044018,
0.0091859037,
0.0138906548,
-0.0091599999,
-0.0143125299,
0.0257662795,
0.0004211876,
-0.0305964351,
0.0291349087,
0.0086421408,
0.0279623345,
-0.0429868512,
0.0382614061,
-0.0705465451,
0.0042477865,
-0.0119369617,
-0.0077318079,
0.0613856614,
-0.0204840656,
0.0531831793,
-0.034773659,
0.0216423925,
-0.0323552899,
0.0318276696,
0.0078427801,
-0.0122251427,
0.0379418954,
0.0134146847,
-0.014058046,
-0.012153401,
0.10006769,
0.0353719555,
0.0069390838,
-0.0051348512,
-0.0107945967,
-0.0280068517,
-0.028419273,
-0.0379965901,
-0.0146610048,
-0.0173531361,
-0.014325873,
-0.0577552803,
-0.0776941255,
0.0425109975,
-0.0216648355,
0.0383187346,
-0.0502836853,
0.0151550891,
0.0463915691,
0.0296185091,
-0.0128204441,
-0.0369341522,
-0.0188606307,
0.0136426389,
-0.0169848483,
-0.0387726165,
-6.277981781e-33,
-0.0130691612,
-0.0276266448,
0.02099967,
-0.0097433487,
-0.0583409369,
-0.0023860869,
-0.0518559776,
0.0055572116,
-0.0042478391,
-0.032366503,
-0.0278839283,
0.0083940877,
0.0185044017,
0.0574079305,
-0.0167931747,
-0.0135805923,
0.0499849021,
0.0073416065,
-0.0029315976,
-0.0123014785,
0.0173743237,
0.0378815569,
0.0479998179,
-0.013226483,
-0.0307052694,
0.0033797119,
0.0172177069,
0.0088577187,
0.0026374483,
0.0464675799,
-0.0314959437,
0.0340516083,
0.0473428965,
-0.0948583931,
-0.0182004068,
0.0225387365,
-0.0361632667,
-0.0186438859,
0.0132695055,
0.0042032697,
-0.0052159131,
-0.0183038749,
0.0658918396,
0.0258617494,
-0.0127444332,
-0.0054194895,
0.018968137,
-0.019248141,
-0.0687221512,
-0.0295156445,
-0.0677553043,
0.0237742756,
0.0195650924,
0.016702462,
0.0213489085,
0.0669778064,
-0.0293013845,
0.0210482869,
-0.0466241091,
-0.0068458333,
0.0424136668,
0.0986110643,
0.0335356183,
0.0475017577,
0.0213310085,
0.0168658607,
0.0283653252,
0.0003181897,
-0.036288444,
-0.0078733861,
0.0775782093,
0.0196570326,
0.0458549932,
-0.0355736837,
0.0391608477,
-0.0318409801,
-0.0621226579,
0.0064098123,
-0.0144413039,
0.0658782572,
0.0429706573,
-0.0060101328,
-0.012054896,
-0.0245459378,
-0.0281504728,
0.0230367593,
-0.0038112206,
-0.0201825239,
0.0235686954,
0.0100197569,
0.0067879977,
0.0019833685,
0.0585150234,
-0.0404568054,
0.0019153137,
0.0166772064,
0.0061538266,
0.0521524437,
-0.0232680775,
0.0024876064,
-0.0749082714,
-0.0253400896,
-0.0037931553,
0.0333041884,
-0.0042334087,
-0.0333295241,
0.000952605,
0.0336752608,
-0.0814199597,
-0.0206386764,
-0.0436514653,
0.0206876919,
-0.0254595336,
0.0240684189,
0.0464486927,
-0.0112443669,
-0.0130564645,
0.0483167283,
-0.0145748872,
-0.0191474427,
-0.0332494527,
0.0196653847,
0.0311082564,
0.0386273079,
-0.0098928623,
0.007640128,
-0.0543796308,
0.044275593,
0.0252267066,
-0.0547449179,
-0.0288313013,
0.0170222372,
2.721e-7,
0.0594952181,
0.032935895,
0.0289773624,
0.0489077345,
0.030502636,
-0.0003157138,
-0.0049584121,
-0.0044379295,
0.0194442142,
0.045372393,
0.0125691481,
0.0000905655,
0.0308021717,
-0.0118172672,
-0.060613092,
-0.0367130227,
-0.0903846249,
0.0063201562,
-0.0124647934,
0.0322593674,
0.021174293,
0.0937328935,
-0.0147594577,
-0.0173489098,
-0.0095039513,
-0.0084454706,
0.0667654201,
-0.0153753487,
0.0336471871,
0.0214923378,
0.0521135367,
0.0187192727,
0.0133349858,
-0.0103026861,
0.0015124363,
0.0231680907,
-0.0182125363,
0.0556926578,
0.0018271772,
-0.0484384745,
0.0183636025,
-0.0104508484,
-0.0099981688,
-0.0302377809,
0.0507316962,
-0.0822382793,
-0.0388640836,
-0.0092181219,
-0.0214919038,
0.0460164361,
-0.0283754095,
0.0138723431,
-0.0161681306,
0.029365303,
0.0130287055,
-0.0214587227,
0.0088143386,
-0.0918807015,
-0.0227803048,
0.0079216333,
-0.0493622981,
-0.0312188957,
-0.0592296682,
-0.0248814076,
0.0428296477,
-0.0002396054,
-0.0590348206,
2.850894077e-34,
0.0282316152,
-0.0341027528,
0.022605205,
0.0427519828,
-0.0107410345,
-0.0085355779,
0.0052088602,
0.0035083087,
-0.0194129795,
-0.1199637577,
-0.0425751135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17804v1 | Targeted Data Generation: Finding and Fixing Model Weaknesses | 2023-05-28T19:36:50 | 2023-05-28T19:36:50 | Zexue He, Marco Tulio Ribeiro, Fereshte Khani | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even when aggregate accuracy is high, state-of-the-art NLP models often fail
systematically on specific subgroups of data, resulting in unfair outcomes and
eroding user trust. Additional data collection may not help in addressing these
weaknesses, as such challenging subgroups may be unknown to users, and
underrepresented in the existing and new data. We propose Targeted Data
Generation (TDG), a framework that automatically identifies challenging
subgroups, and generates new data for those subgroups using large language
models (LLMs) with a human in the loop. TDG estimates the expected benefit and
potential harm of data augmentation for each subgroup, and selects the ones
most likely to improve within group performance without hurting overall
performance. In our experiments, TDG significantly improves the accuracy on
challenging subgroups for state-of-the-art sentiment analysis and natural
language inference models, while also improving overall test accuracy. | [
0.0701569542,
0.1459382176,
-0.018475147,
0.0318825506,
-0.0181575511,
0.008221115,
0.0102373827,
6.255e-7,
0.0181219801,
-0.0844669417,
-0.0210571978,
-0.0279522333,
-0.0234360658,
0.0063352841,
0.0565464497,
-0.0596170314,
0.0536299795,
0.0049450039,
-0.004153592,
-0.0030095426,
0.0010934941,
0.0237707254,
0.0224768948,
0.0306235682,
-0.0064629414,
-0.0077676717,
0.0246154442,
0.0162065644,
-0.0150665231,
-0.0365531221,
0.0435253084,
0.0806508437,
0.0019392916,
0.0350295044,
0.0000021383,
-0.031082876,
-0.0141662415,
0.0057889265,
-0.0383254401,
-0.0066704489,
0.0894112512,
-0.0256300177,
0.0190482754,
0.0382343903,
-0.0536694862,
-0.0337560736,
0.0076091443,
0.0006578988,
0.0690720528,
0.0876257122,
-0.019041026,
0.0227834079,
-0.0284370501,
-0.0301874746,
0.0294506345,
-0.0450662561,
0.0164366085,
-0.0163261704,
-0.001267417,
0.0042540687,
0.0189743061,
0.0173805002,
-0.0063508744,
0.0096512344,
0.0386757813,
0.0031948914,
-0.0662262663,
-0.0285113193,
-0.0147948284,
0.0413601846,
0.011097813,
-0.0134011954,
-0.0274062082,
-0.00871439,
0.0025651169,
0.0213669315,
-0.0133300507,
0.0177631862,
-0.0010758577,
0.0010743743,
-0.0010420878,
0.011660113,
0.0363723673,
0.0549213514,
-0.0005455221,
0.0473329164,
-0.0027816822,
-0.0232282896,
0.0095880302,
0.0641939342,
-0.0593591109,
-0.0358505137,
-0.0288711935,
-0.0085425843,
-0.0660971329,
0.0358584225,
-0.0468438193,
-0.0454748906,
0.0444301777,
-0.0401496366,
0.0145702502,
0.0123304706,
0.0272084083,
0.0543571487,
-0.0007849224,
-0.017845748,
0.0021278562,
-0.0132040791,
0.0020105222,
-0.0274649803,
-0.0205183513,
-0.0115427198,
-0.0099804439,
0.0251136106,
-0.0599781796,
0.0044970177,
-0.04815007,
0.0192767885,
-0.0591708161,
0.0147499014,
-0.0094548203,
0.0086799832,
-0.0348426439,
-0.0204898603,
-0.0383322611,
0.0011032263,
-0.0463745482,
0.0451098196,
0.0020009705,
-0.0783771649,
0.0009986067,
0.0072037396,
-0.0203539468,
-0.0057081645,
0.0193970781,
0.062206585,
0.0318484828,
-0.0603158921,
-0.0738777146,
-0.0381659642,
-0.0163541138,
-0.03775068,
-0.0216346644,
-0.0694925934,
0.0375558026,
0.0289078932,
-0.0067529138,
-0.0440956801,
-0.0058686943,
0.0332133621,
-0.0381255113,
0.0517106913,
-0.0333028734,
0.0163369309,
-0.002796625,
-0.0082412288,
-0.0337450281,
0.1081263572,
-0.0097385645,
0.0296968017,
0.0562059022,
-0.0015836214,
0.0335122533,
0.0353672355,
0.026083881,
0.0239921845,
-0.0196010135,
-0.0025348547,
-0.0367285982,
-0.0030211189,
-0.00190076,
0.0567634478,
-0.0099803833,
0.02778369,
0.0486493073,
0.0375189185,
0.0041006352,
0.0559958257,
-0.0065873559,
0.0007376959,
-0.0196445938,
-0.0451405682,
-0.0425819717,
-0.0033918824,
-0.0368641131,
-0.029826995,
0.0184414368,
0.031071499,
-0.0101513863,
-0.0524357893,
-0.0475006104,
0.0153639875,
0.0544577464,
0.0435632244,
0.0517469719,
0.0302402992,
-0.0054325736,
0.0102089662,
0.061038658,
-0.0477257222,
0.022251334,
-0.0478529222,
0.0322810225,
0.0757131949,
0.0728681758,
-0.0350469239,
-0.003384263,
-0.0096464921,
0.0055823023,
0.0286631435,
0.0702907443,
-0.0130810607,
-0.0163998678,
-0.0103541687,
0.002952202,
0.0155504458,
0.0339142755,
0.0195991881,
0.0922729969,
-0.0216119979,
-0.0008890503,
-0.0408141986,
-0.059973333,
0.0352562927,
-0.0271851402,
-0.0116447583,
0.0173700061,
-0.0060483888,
0.0246938989,
0.0269283336,
-0.0061319782,
-0.0143344607,
0.0086061191,
-0.0235074516,
-0.0637483075,
-0.0341829769,
-0.0026710771,
-0.0416587628,
-0.0116241109,
-0.0348324254,
-0.0524953455,
0.0111105749,
-0.0616882853,
0.0060800062,
0.0372892469,
-0.0457568429,
0.0328364931,
-0.0355544984,
0.0126170712,
-0.0152003057,
-0.0157767329,
-0.0415340997,
0.0772515982,
0.0036705402,
0.0173666775,
-0.00336461,
-0.0250689965,
-0.0113850506,
-0.0247373395,
-0.0321479738,
-0.002450723,
-0.0048825294,
0.0232957862,
0.0522502996,
0.0005837082,
-0.0544118881,
-0.0247756578,
-0.082613565,
0.0165554751,
-0.010807002,
0.0096498821,
0.0186048783,
0.0100041572,
-0.0158560239,
0.009780243,
-0.0397894792,
-0.0412106179,
0.0367052257,
0.0300230533,
0.0359319784,
0.0102411713,
0.0274371728,
-0.0499362089,
-0.0043878206,
-0.0135029983,
0.0583234988,
0.0432985388,
-0.0221013147,
-0.0382705368,
-0.0134457834,
-0.0220226757,
0.012040779,
0.0062274081,
-0.0246985592,
-0.0057880194,
-0.0003698755,
0.0090896413,
0.0259058923,
0.0125322854,
0.0347279198,
0.0024105306,
0.018252274,
-0.0427106395,
0.0038701608,
-0.0408147573,
-0.0179757588,
0.0036804497,
-0.0539277941,
0.0404739007,
0.0610629357,
0.0181070305,
-0.0342644639,
-0.0629499555,
0.0379156619,
-0.0543634221,
-0.002680484,
-0.0232501626,
-0.0246774461,
0.006024153,
0.0135418857,
-0.0383312292,
-0.0435573459,
0.0597290322,
-0.0034999058,
0.0284776557,
-0.0684313029,
-0.0167125706,
-0.0528061874,
0.0403715931,
0.013098944,
0.0228596944,
-0.010818053,
-0.0017631054,
-0.0173721109,
-0.0139928339,
0.0196881928,
-0.0465861075,
0.0890811458,
-0.0522092097,
0.012757645,
0.0202956423,
-0.0467320457,
-0.0587806851,
-0.0640680492,
-0.0228007045,
-0.0418764353,
0.06518583,
-0.0171736516,
-0.0220670886,
-0.0308905803,
0.0180006232,
-0.0007014894,
-0.0268335752,
-0.0410956666,
0.0113335615,
-0.0239774194,
0.0263835974,
-0.0118760159,
0.0353911147,
-0.0562275164,
0.0087683229,
0.0723645464,
0.0297690276,
0.0073056985,
-0.0474362224,
-0.0134186335,
0.0255398024,
-0.0163090117,
-0.0003252859,
-0.026297193,
0.0739684701,
-0.0515601002,
0.0272731166,
0.1182979792,
0.0252159405,
-0.0567058288,
0.0046385964,
0.0055153491,
0.0310681835,
0.0367539451,
0.041321706,
-0.0789534301,
-0.0378615186,
0.01317525,
0.0814593062,
-0.041552823,
-0.0375619568,
-0.0196545981,
-0.1413927972,
0.0362846553,
0.0001478643,
0.0012577475,
-0.0129052838,
-0.0517989621,
0.0123067899,
-0.0355347618,
0.0546074025,
-0.0039594243,
0.0026225226,
0.0239192937,
0.0074260095,
-0.0844257921,
-0.054187458,
0.0275154375,
-0.0183804948,
0.0504566804,
0.0494871922,
0.0375162512,
0.0094339177,
-0.0022649535,
0.0397707634,
-0.018584406,
0.0123473275,
-0.0248685069,
0.1134017631,
-0.0017046803,
0.0058376486,
-0.0166311916,
0.0611049235,
-0.0302615911,
0.0054041455,
0.0105105285,
0.0013003481,
0.0216755066,
-0.0001270225,
-0.0159559883,
-0.0007885558,
0.0186022222,
0.0887984037,
0.0118143521,
-0.0651641265,
0.0269998014,
-0.0173854977,
0.0024575116,
-0.0561358482,
-0.0126517266,
0.0402752049,
-0.0366502032,
-0.0125473114,
-0.0636649951,
-0.0309451129,
0.0603801124,
0.0284657925,
0.0240054373,
0.0079903584,
0.010293683,
-0.0227226596,
-0.0075580319,
0.0522101186,
-0.0353142098,
0.0272670612,
-0.0450578108,
-0.04813857,
-0.008398938,
-0.0112901535,
-0.0051072137,
0.0162442867,
-0.0771370828,
-0.0711998045,
0.021834828,
0.0251726545,
0.0274808705,
0.0644825995,
-0.0014377371,
-0.0686910003,
0.0287219156,
0.0518874079,
-0.0571278259,
0.01070539,
-0.0092656463,
0.0182315949,
-0.008238174,
0.0196191557,
-0.0322167538,
0.0458711274,
0.0477484986,
-0.0152334981,
-0.0328636803,
0.0214119088,
0.0248897262,
0.0197643097,
0.0453576595,
-0.0262728222,
-0.0261220522,
-0.0385648459,
-0.0220221132,
-0.0157947466,
-0.037178468,
-0.0352126248,
-0.0156408809,
0.011879202,
-0.0189747512,
-0.0456033163,
-0.0149407014,
-0.0378401838,
0.0489925705,
-0.0905557051,
0.0397434831,
0.008527576,
0.013581031,
0.0351848863,
-0.0007623385,
-0.0119738877,
0.0071391063,
-0.0275373179,
0.0386922695,
-0.0164092649,
0.0179562736,
0.0176476799,
0.0067415982,
-0.0317052267,
0.0006653959,
-0.0315212458,
-0.044273112,
-0.0216659401,
0.005701127,
-0.008995044,
-0.0038910215,
0.0389399193,
-0.0271659493,
-0.0187815372,
0.0104743801,
0.008865267,
-0.0232529845,
-0.0303627308,
0.0000404522,
0.0130845746,
-0.0464285202,
-0.0225924402,
0.0721940026,
-0.0073448163,
0.0419475846,
-0.0242858343,
-0.0319820717,
-0.0470291115,
0.0065252408,
0.0470788963,
-0.011530783,
-0.004125494,
0.0135733858,
-0.0824817196,
-0.0616605841,
0.0039429888,
0.0052323346,
0.0118384697,
0.0077905231,
0.0246836003,
0.0524814837,
-0.0023661954,
0.0067141983,
-0.0610590316,
0.0035861987,
-0.0166642983,
-0.014842866,
0.0131409811,
-6.980231657e-33,
-0.0028112235,
-0.0527350381,
-0.0087102223,
-0.0153191602,
-0.0160193965,
0.0313298106,
-0.0219350439,
0.0164153371,
0.0033205459,
0.0104173198,
-0.0161300153,
0.0195474271,
0.0074260705,
0.0529361293,
0.0057656672,
-0.0068452572,
0.068140626,
0.0101465182,
-0.0411708429,
0.0229460504,
0.0366846137,
0.0272868369,
0.0177913476,
-0.0552411862,
0.0509862974,
-0.0020911302,
-0.0272223148,
0.0237931423,
0.0153639959,
0.0278605111,
0.0082023432,
0.0877122283,
0.0251738094,
-0.065827027,
-0.0076013184,
0.0060237511,
-0.0388934016,
-0.0101373009,
-0.0085912524,
0.0078877294,
-0.0114730885,
0.0103207445,
0.0493042693,
-0.0012818886,
-0.0088086585,
0.0115494328,
0.0282967295,
-0.031236764,
-0.0000349456,
-0.0102365296,
-0.0553030372,
0.0291124508,
0.0010332093,
0.0209354796,
-0.0151864504,
0.047543928,
-0.0104747266,
0.0235975049,
-0.0576255359,
0.0341025665,
0.0323759913,
0.0199316517,
0.0440443307,
0.0165240075,
-0.0067843986,
0.0793069229,
0.0022826723,
0.0361504927,
-0.0104168272,
0.0077796276,
0.0196310747,
0.0138049396,
0.0247563589,
0.0958055034,
0.0472087488,
-0.0440613739,
-0.0309285503,
0.0201446917,
0.0337444544,
-0.0161890835,
0.0502741709,
-0.0060238554,
-0.0863890201,
-0.0409090593,
-0.0249629654,
-0.0101003498,
-0.0370669775,
-0.030304933,
0.022912411,
0.0516168512,
-0.0873103067,
-0.0235228445,
-0.0063313073,
-0.0341406092,
-0.0149917016,
0.0078689437,
-0.012435955,
-0.0097905546,
-0.0079152752,
-0.0127225053,
-0.0455034003,
-0.0232814383,
0.017280031,
0.0219297688,
0.0183381513,
-0.004731243,
0.0543507114,
0.0164519679,
-0.0888477713,
0.0253001004,
-0.0162283834,
0.0785412341,
-0.0155467251,
0.0143077523,
0.0421734527,
0.035025198,
-0.0155872991,
0.061986886,
0.0353674293,
0.0071915998,
-0.0306273028,
0.040939793,
-0.0121389106,
0.004927061,
-0.0259669442,
-0.0209892299,
0.0104428902,
-0.0378471762,
0.0275812726,
-0.0613933057,
-0.0262386333,
-0.0306369998,
2.875e-7,
0.0604871847,
0.0861773044,
-0.0257149227,
0.0254738126,
0.0102990139,
0.0443805866,
0.0237736721,
-0.0060252836,
0.0315623693,
0.0035619328,
-0.0052691521,
0.0187831055,
0.0487868898,
0.0616693534,
-0.0621519126,
0.0402996205,
-0.0190834198,
0.0281164311,
-0.0347270481,
-0.0069713844,
0.0543042123,
0.0922463462,
0.0282200612,
-0.0283539295,
-0.0229749475,
-0.0303823054,
0.0479226373,
-0.0337208435,
-0.0709491372,
0.0393903144,
0.0419999138,
0.0594828501,
0.0110040391,
0.0321382359,
-0.0691461414,
0.0059904354,
-0.0457037464,
-0.0048697283,
0.0129321078,
-0.0221426971,
-0.0093076462,
0.0052959779,
0.011092741,
-0.0458014831,
0.0647118911,
-0.0580778942,
-0.0147667853,
-0.0306621995,
-0.015440478,
-0.0183531884,
-0.0028826445,
-0.0386088379,
-0.0025683218,
0.0149440896,
0.0181561448,
-0.0000925472,
-0.0423540138,
-0.0533781946,
0.0032934013,
-0.0220070984,
-0.046331957,
-0.0625911281,
0.0022525799,
0.0362634324,
-0.0109275347,
-0.0475444943,
0.0272240359,
2.894630962e-34,
0.0283869728,
0.0152753945,
-0.0000146284,
-0.0174248274,
0.0567207336,
0.0251654312,
-0.0007486791,
-0.0062770341,
0.0207315795,
-0.0351316966,
0.0087301778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18419v1 | Semantic Segmentation with Bidirectional Language Models Improves Long-form ASR | 2023-05-28T19:31:45 | 2023-05-28T19:31:45 | W. Ronny Huang, Hao Zhang, Shankar Kumar, Shuo-yiin Chang, Tara N. Sainath | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | We propose a method of segmenting long-form speech by separating semantically
complete sentences within the utterance. This prevents the ASR decoder from
needlessly processing faraway context while also preventing it from missing
relevant context within the current sentence. Semantically complete sentence
boundaries are typically demarcated by punctuation in written text; but
unfortunately, spoken real-world utterances rarely contain punctuation. We
address this limitation by distilling punctuation knowledge from a
bidirectional teacher language model (LM) trained on written, punctuated text.
We compare our segmenter, which is distilled from the LM teacher, against a
segmenter distilled from a acoustic-pause-based teacher used in other works, on
a streaming ASR pipeline. The pipeline with our segmenter achieves a 3.2%
relative WER gain along with a 60 ms median end-of-segment latency reduction on
a YouTube captioning task. | [
-0.0112554049,
0.0576751083,
-0.0051256851,
0.0431488678,
-0.0145419864,
-0.0094177946,
0.0604996756,
-0.0404065549,
-0.0455374829,
-0.0392899811,
0.0063962233,
-0.0299117547,
-0.0071822442,
0.0242347792,
0.0116789509,
-0.11389599,
0.0193857383,
-0.078222923,
0.015996363,
0.0170285311,
0.0392311588,
-0.0027451103,
-0.0454650447,
0.0075351875,
-0.0175178181,
-0.0115762223,
-0.0258519966,
0.0162924342,
0.0320146382,
-0.030410381,
0.0043329452,
-0.0026131188,
0.0002405279,
-0.0077563967,
0.0000017689,
-0.0133445542,
-0.0229725558,
0.0093835052,
-0.038665168,
0.0380642638,
-0.0193295386,
-0.0252207201,
-0.0099514993,
0.0514010116,
-0.0016230356,
0.0279376116,
-0.010406753,
0.0307281949,
0.0230000243,
0.0420212783,
-0.0273504592,
-0.0682437792,
0.0286575146,
-0.0159431044,
-0.0213199407,
-0.0069227824,
-0.0093801236,
-0.0084792227,
-0.0146291889,
-0.0093844989,
-0.0349490941,
0.0885296687,
0.0461725853,
-0.0310349409,
-0.0088536004,
0.0164467003,
-0.0327886641,
-0.0419376157,
-0.0128271775,
0.0241631903,
0.0228548963,
-0.007012967,
0.0514342226,
0.0227654409,
0.0105688516,
-0.0490523353,
-0.0370808691,
0.0370488353,
-0.0180077739,
0.0075220619,
0.0088802408,
0.0207515806,
-0.0087120337,
-0.0083324593,
-0.0135662798,
-0.0041691326,
0.0040695393,
-0.0368498303,
-0.0278291348,
0.0256650709,
-0.0090145953,
-0.0327784941,
0.0927010253,
-0.0291110631,
0.001021066,
0.012130117,
-0.0617534108,
-0.0208969638,
-0.0202003755,
-0.0056317858,
-0.0135854054,
0.0361264013,
-0.0324867889,
0.0360770822,
0.0107465498,
0.015105674,
0.0198354814,
0.0240163524,
-0.0225059967,
0.0200899187,
-0.0362972915,
-0.022348104,
-0.0433432423,
0.0181420017,
-0.0176369064,
-0.0459463149,
-0.0302677415,
0.0088107195,
-0.0061123986,
-0.0154543119,
0.0474346466,
-0.0358993635,
0.0088198427,
0.0006118112,
0.0398373455,
0.0502040498,
-0.0197095647,
0.0321147963,
0.0427597612,
-0.0380559079,
-0.0050980733,
0.0318700559,
0.0191092696,
-0.0117860679,
-0.0219696332,
-0.0095562888,
-0.0484860018,
-0.0275161266,
-0.0468011647,
-0.0582883768,
-0.0521674231,
-0.0225680377,
0.0015727796,
-0.0268296134,
0.0055059702,
0.0255597979,
-0.0069163353,
-0.0207472667,
-0.0174555946,
-0.0264010392,
0.0566790067,
0.0733166412,
-0.0036607645,
0.0265638512,
0.0247582849,
0.0090919212,
0.0342215002,
0.0492943414,
0.0720865279,
-0.000174476,
0.0412672646,
0.000058442,
-0.0180006996,
0.0549076758,
-0.0241326001,
-0.0360446796,
-0.074267976,
-0.0181035828,
0.0045392327,
0.0225687362,
0.0489204489,
0.0684613287,
-0.006641075,
0.0183392968,
0.0416890085,
0.0234351456,
0.0236325786,
-0.0104980655,
0.0446762554,
0.0582005121,
-0.0238914788,
0.0323880948,
0.001701862,
-0.0175297018,
0.0480594859,
0.0202122796,
0.0602436326,
0.0051620258,
-0.0156790335,
-0.049156256,
-0.0278211106,
-0.0149961598,
0.0130041949,
0.0359229147,
0.0161153506,
0.0068931961,
-0.0498587526,
0.0847042724,
-0.0573587157,
-0.0804633722,
0.0266174637,
-0.0359247848,
-0.0023414069,
0.0698499009,
0.0044541126,
-0.038589295,
-0.0128242951,
-0.0261938497,
0.0350939408,
0.0398585126,
0.001332221,
0.0070140944,
0.0401311815,
-0.0501300395,
0.016933741,
0.0379608274,
0.0194743127,
-0.003018419,
0.0079912292,
0.024881525,
0.0257325415,
-0.0085634701,
0.0406700112,
0.0206888542,
-0.0008637553,
0.0119458092,
-0.0552636422,
0.0093915462,
0.0244748201,
0.0333185829,
-0.0298041347,
-0.0108134998,
0.0252841096,
-0.0513031706,
0.0227755308,
0.032729961,
-0.106738925,
-0.0719184652,
0.0270009376,
-0.032310199,
0.0237361882,
0.0417137668,
0.0174131133,
-0.0641132817,
-0.0099700838,
-0.0148365311,
0.0603557453,
-0.0175361428,
0.0651775971,
0.05357223,
0.0107474634,
0.0306240786,
-0.0245377384,
-0.0026633767,
-0.022015864,
-0.0308010262,
-0.0113140428,
-0.0068789138,
-0.0711632222,
-0.0126751168,
0.0297523495,
-0.0432162583,
-0.0191106945,
0.009236428,
-0.0345374905,
-0.0492723398,
-0.0304175001,
-0.0538759008,
-0.0078535872,
-0.0297653321,
0.0306037422,
-0.0202952251,
0.0116150789,
-0.0267408434,
-0.0331356116,
0.0358648449,
-0.0406124815,
-0.0285672452,
-0.0084401639,
-0.0129777966,
0.0130514475,
-0.0325174853,
-0.0290765949,
-0.0203033108,
0.0058547272,
0.0232852884,
0.0165675879,
-0.0491729118,
-0.0607685223,
0.0516886413,
0.0449960791,
0.0266498085,
-0.0058391453,
-0.0621091276,
0.0067659314,
-0.0086929798,
0.0228141509,
0.0774475858,
-0.0030549963,
0.0053850184,
-0.0090615852,
-0.0044563464,
0.0062762639,
0.011346559,
0.0660413131,
0.0567340702,
-0.0401094407,
0.0277580209,
-0.0059812223,
0.0301215537,
0.0039878595,
0.0202817917,
-0.0299061742,
-0.0390187204,
-0.0305188932,
-0.0424799435,
0.0003793578,
-0.0589291267,
-0.0563875474,
0.0022440213,
-0.0134102162,
-0.0087642623,
0.007731528,
-0.055415716,
-0.0612106286,
-0.0297441408,
-0.0347315855,
-0.0229492448,
0.0445145145,
0.0471054949,
-0.0130683035,
-0.0225548651,
-0.0579545908,
-0.0193413682,
0.0386945829,
-0.0145281469,
-0.030905854,
0.0452734642,
-0.0421733409,
0.0046889074,
-0.0055687577,
-0.0334691405,
-0.0394666158,
0.0106369648,
-0.055082608,
0.040808253,
0.0333171524,
-0.0270580389,
-0.0096141351,
0.0360592678,
0.0260651223,
0.1187477559,
-0.000993458,
0.031528227,
-0.0256685261,
0.0230528954,
0.0194267295,
0.0029512169,
-0.0626445562,
-0.0244806055,
0.0846989527,
0.026847126,
0.0765794739,
-0.0343144946,
-0.0248521455,
-0.02983623,
0.0260412004,
-0.0421735011,
-0.046396248,
0.02137978,
0.0701244846,
-0.1040744856,
-0.0013707118,
0.118975468,
0.0272129085,
-0.0075227721,
-0.0404730737,
0.0234319642,
0.0256441589,
0.0233663209,
-0.0382927246,
-0.0695956349,
-0.0765816197,
0.0474408753,
0.0360469781,
0.0553278364,
0.0183724016,
0.003891709,
-0.0540079549,
0.0178411733,
-0.0022942815,
-0.0886389688,
0.0193906166,
-0.0246741939,
-0.0378232412,
0.0035591873,
0.0305844657,
0.017734386,
-0.0575862117,
0.010340102,
0.050249774,
-0.0955016688,
-0.0202875119,
-0.0240894873,
-0.0336096548,
0.0348041207,
0.0507101975,
0.0135702547,
-0.0101769073,
-0.0092850719,
0.0467962287,
-0.0700029954,
0.0007035479,
0.0114401588,
0.0658638701,
-0.0423625149,
-0.0010388257,
0.0171906855,
0.0432276726,
-0.0079634683,
0.0060877521,
0.0397986099,
0.034880612,
0.0039789174,
0.0121623967,
-0.0154047925,
0.0219663512,
-0.0253568608,
0.0918081403,
0.0185978971,
-0.0247416049,
-0.0652199984,
0.0152777154,
0.0551006831,
-0.0802471936,
0.0041230037,
-0.0057198373,
-0.0312714465,
-0.0368045978,
-0.0181903858,
-0.0258523151,
0.0661659911,
0.0052492223,
-0.0070728576,
0.0264740754,
0.0094899451,
0.0092325211,
-0.0493193418,
-0.00334096,
0.0026254058,
0.0076330458,
-0.0916434824,
-0.0329478383,
0.0345153101,
-0.0503472351,
-0.0227243192,
0.0339089744,
-0.0762131736,
-0.0515187047,
0.0379189812,
0.0072992845,
0.0092669539,
0.0683365017,
0.005830551,
-0.0297212042,
0.0290776938,
0.0534075871,
-0.0369988643,
0.034257289,
0.0513823293,
0.04773812,
-0.0054550623,
0.0124930851,
-0.0312288869,
0.0097084334,
-0.040956635,
0.0415038802,
-0.0838681161,
-0.0103715789,
-0.0183832832,
0.0255416427,
0.0832642391,
-0.0263230391,
0.0026972694,
-0.0316182934,
0.036118798,
-0.0229684785,
0.0693228468,
-0.0482629053,
0.0417737737,
0.0037361544,
0.0144308731,
-0.0219009314,
0.0235232711,
-0.0254179928,
-0.0304312799,
-0.0314886533,
0.0623505227,
0.0283756889,
-0.0494626947,
0.0135559263,
0.0095074465,
0.0120953759,
-0.0019262282,
0.0479603894,
-0.0008052956,
0.007098353,
0.060333211,
0.0070863627,
0.0346051157,
0.0035894008,
0.0474022068,
-0.049558226,
0.0264312178,
0.0224650875,
0.0895433873,
0.0133346682,
-0.0171610564,
0.050677862,
0.003339065,
0.0158263948,
-0.012603675,
0.0502525009,
-0.0126049919,
-0.0462132022,
0.0218041837,
0.012717247,
-0.0167073309,
0.0080027562,
0.0393767916,
-0.0217040759,
0.0215298664,
0.029301485,
0.0062059346,
-0.0421264358,
-0.0291302782,
-0.0220791344,
0.0051205526,
-0.0262251701,
-0.0028221393,
0.0089562638,
-0.077841416,
0.0031551614,
-0.0135419089,
0.0319877863,
-0.0401372537,
0.0152618308,
0.0096641099,
-0.0292312875,
-0.0529879704,
-0.0013518125,
-0.0409816802,
-0.0106689101,
-0.0177222844,
0.0122891571,
-5.821591324e-33,
-0.0324510448,
0.0296779796,
0.0082274545,
0.0093619898,
-0.0581581667,
0.0350380652,
-0.0174299274,
0.0229614954,
0.0304386783,
0.0075757704,
-0.0284768194,
0.0359291099,
0.0492305681,
0.0549326502,
0.0166989993,
-0.043826092,
0.1238531768,
-0.0310392454,
0.0216540545,
-0.0222799946,
0.0058346228,
0.0524041876,
-0.014928503,
-0.0018488077,
-0.0271583162,
-0.0082655791,
0.0002415226,
-0.0005379159,
0.0365361199,
0.0665629581,
0.0074123745,
0.0150080211,
0.0082809851,
-0.0173548814,
-0.0285315532,
0.038583491,
-0.0953690708,
0.0270636193,
0.0091990232,
0.0549980961,
-0.0458713286,
-0.0341558605,
0.0517080873,
-0.0071692015,
-0.0010447984,
-0.0059381872,
0.0352275781,
-0.0217889994,
0.0090466244,
-0.0135585796,
-0.0164428353,
0.0055095484,
-0.0299015902,
-0.0362213664,
0.0862898529,
0.0362856016,
0.0384923145,
-0.0358934738,
-0.0554497316,
0.0217480268,
0.0360473655,
0.0591397472,
0.0561844222,
0.0391682945,
-0.0116327442,
0.0263923947,
0.0624072291,
-0.0789703578,
-0.0039379997,
-0.033995226,
0.0083093802,
0.0036121558,
0.0007673436,
-0.0124801686,
0.06484285,
-0.0155146802,
-0.0095348889,
-0.0582743101,
-0.0019368925,
-0.0136303194,
0.0086765178,
0.0511477552,
-0.0593166836,
-0.0052649565,
0.0021457665,
-0.0306943376,
0.0096393358,
0.0174760111,
0.0793319717,
0.0258334745,
0.0072144847,
0.0048409496,
0.0799579844,
-0.0101959333,
0.03304483,
0.018635897,
-0.0217776,
0.0317304097,
-0.0241943356,
0.0200216155,
-0.0630148575,
0.0178264454,
0.0497850478,
0.0279802959,
0.0013541373,
-0.0032628577,
0.0106333429,
0.0240202248,
-0.0332629904,
-0.0058358228,
0.0028125241,
0.0522337854,
-0.0478781834,
0.0124149881,
0.034786582,
0.0261594132,
-0.0269553419,
0.0662116855,
-0.0072017652,
-0.0085140029,
-0.0061259121,
-0.0293781925,
-0.0092100501,
0.0160884187,
-0.0625359565,
-0.0169295631,
0.0060673077,
-0.0107901711,
0.0131040746,
-0.0703999326,
-0.0109812375,
0.0173482094,
2.483e-7,
-0.0087052565,
0.0224038064,
0.0572723597,
-0.0162014905,
0.0193339568,
-0.0060676741,
0.0004646311,
-0.004478619,
0.0111297667,
0.0116690481,
-0.0255495664,
0.0186764933,
0.0653789416,
-0.0097034099,
-0.1310243756,
-0.0184893943,
-0.0418545157,
0.0006070161,
-0.0375328138,
-0.01123311,
0.0725344718,
0.0319559686,
0.0082029095,
-0.0022830965,
-0.0094932206,
-0.0394716151,
-0.0165404882,
0.0081157694,
0.0057898457,
0.0049588899,
0.0213987082,
-0.0127512598,
-0.0458081998,
0.0266963262,
-0.0081556467,
-0.0379959457,
0.0405154265,
0.041231256,
0.0013448379,
-0.032076586,
-0.0152690336,
0.0538970754,
-0.0358807743,
0.0127348732,
0.0771964118,
0.0147022624,
0.021997923,
0.0153784733,
-0.0607181415,
-0.0218056757,
-0.0297350623,
0.0165953357,
0.0154935392,
0.0215427577,
0.0085551795,
-0.0241122767,
-0.0309663564,
-0.0425572991,
-0.0371537283,
-0.0481904261,
-0.0661461577,
0.0084104715,
-0.0376711115,
0.0306925531,
-0.0049639228,
-0.0329808183,
-0.0267731417,
2.036525366e-34,
0.0302316658,
-0.0038636494,
0.0183647871,
0.018959526,
0.0078461925,
-0.0125017306,
-0.0148624144,
0.0315592661,
-0.018705545,
-0.0358119346,
-0.037382029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2306.13089v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2306.13089v3 | GIMLET: A Unified Graph-Text Model for Instruction-Based Molecule Zero-Shot Learning | 2023-05-28T18:27:59 | 2023-10-22T18:13:40 | Haiteng Zhao, Shengchao Liu, Chang Ma, Hannan Xu, Jie Fu, Zhi-Hong Deng, Lingpeng Kong, Qi Liu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.BM | Molecule property prediction has gained significant attention in recent
years. The main bottleneck is the label insufficiency caused by expensive lab
experiments. In order to alleviate this issue and to better leverage textual
knowledge for tasks, this study investigates the feasibility of employing
natural language instructions to accomplish molecule-related tasks in a
zero-shot setting. We discover that existing molecule-text models perform
poorly in this setting due to inadequate treatment of instructions and limited
capacity for graphs. To overcome these issues, we propose GIMLET, which unifies
language models for both graph and text data. By adopting generalized position
embedding, our model is extended to encode both graph structures and
instruction text without additional graph encoding modules. GIMLET also
decouples encoding of the graph from tasks instructions in the attention
mechanism, enhancing the generalization of graph features across novel tasks.
We construct a dataset consisting of more than two thousand molecule tasks with
corresponding instructions derived from task descriptions. We pretrain GIMLET
on the molecule tasks along with instructions, enabling the model to transfer
effectively to a broad range of tasks. Experimental results demonstrate that
GIMLET significantly outperforms molecule-text baselines in instruction-based
zero-shot learning, even achieving closed results to supervised GNN models on
tasks such as toxcast and muv. | [
0.0056246985,
0.0411143117,
0.0300602689,
0.0012167573,
-0.0106734149,
-0.0114046,
0.0151319616,
0.017710438,
0.0544056818,
-0.0288923476,
-0.0261403732,
-0.0191988833,
-0.0185914859,
0.0448866636,
0.0512161665,
0.001107816,
0.0222373419,
0.0147332242,
-0.008703283,
-0.019517323,
0.0158416871,
0.0032074633,
0.0352556705,
0.0121413898,
0.0161353871,
-0.0249114595,
-0.0310914218,
0.0318196677,
0.0389153175,
-0.0452773385,
-0.0092585236,
0.0387462862,
0.0621458814,
0.0195926931,
0.0000018534,
-0.0079363147,
-0.0140964193,
0.0248904862,
-0.0364000276,
-0.0148871755,
0.0463599637,
-0.0453061089,
0.0090244878,
-0.0078603225,
-0.010719154,
-0.0094105667,
0.0963537097,
0.0039490215,
-0.0063659642,
0.0549276695,
-0.0041197692,
-0.0044973148,
0.0250180196,
-0.0266509894,
0.1151314229,
0.0001933608,
0.0329785496,
0.0066003953,
0.0322596394,
0.0417553037,
-0.0510289371,
0.0284191351,
0.001867956,
-0.0200958066,
0.0620185696,
0.0322205648,
-0.0264665056,
-0.0324187167,
-0.0057891393,
0.1316434443,
-0.0372440815,
-0.0352619663,
-0.0413124114,
-0.0317487791,
-0.0252638869,
-0.0143330516,
-0.0709636584,
0.0078425407,
0.0325977728,
0.0146265225,
-0.0228865333,
-0.0170305073,
0.0263502151,
-0.0222328138,
0.003969376,
0.0267578289,
-0.0212842077,
-0.0235673506,
0.0112353489,
0.0091996957,
-0.04979093,
-0.0139787775,
-0.0295019131,
0.0199312046,
0.0363296345,
0.021803163,
-0.0204002336,
-0.0038208377,
0.042469047,
-0.0250735525,
0.0630262643,
0.003717111,
-0.012292753,
0.0378890112,
-0.0191686936,
0.0401780047,
-0.0139635494,
0.0921063572,
-0.0364437737,
0.0175065212,
-0.0903481692,
0.0069817044,
-0.0326317661,
0.0438155271,
0.0014479149,
-0.0336366147,
-0.0234006587,
0.0026398927,
0.0255844109,
0.0045003034,
0.0214595534,
0.0490466952,
-0.0378092304,
0.0188842714,
0.0104597788,
0.0580626801,
-0.0016195668,
-0.0104046846,
0.0004482372,
-0.0254418552,
-0.0652513579,
0.0085902074,
0.0292933565,
-0.0346831977,
0.0211459137,
0.0866934061,
0.0083334921,
-0.0476255901,
0.0204417296,
-0.0512463003,
0.0016631968,
-0.0469293594,
0.0618855692,
-0.0474178642,
0.0533629283,
0.0211887658,
0.0122669879,
-0.0485739894,
0.0393739827,
0.0033939555,
-0.0573319271,
0.0997377709,
0.0143019846,
-0.0756483823,
-0.030587215,
-0.0038627952,
-0.0160823986,
0.013754026,
-0.0008888184,
0.0074173398,
0.0025433821,
0.002081448,
-0.0151578914,
-0.0296445377,
0.0557176173,
-0.0305482652,
0.0261855777,
-0.0175240654,
-0.0122142173,
0.0320868306,
0.0019226837,
-0.0121936668,
-0.0050119753,
-0.0157879032,
0.0305289011,
0.0398236513,
0.018279314,
-0.0448895209,
0.0102588637,
0.0684060901,
-0.0227067042,
-0.0217027478,
-0.03545928,
0.0637847781,
0.0219680946,
0.0256285053,
0.0084351674,
-0.017226737,
-0.0338885784,
-0.0198304281,
-0.0180652086,
-0.019195335,
0.0415855311,
-0.0368313827,
0.0502333045,
-0.0185833927,
-0.1049300805,
0.0110747209,
0.0397679061,
-0.0240958426,
-0.0154643953,
0.019288199,
0.0193519257,
0.0676610842,
0.0353036709,
-0.0558060221,
-0.0418784395,
-0.004127882,
0.00661529,
-0.0151720978,
-0.0069234273,
-0.0001943405,
0.0377392471,
-0.0425346941,
-0.0488471985,
-0.0758749694,
-0.0031632714,
-0.0057295342,
-0.0031685845,
-0.008069247,
0.0137690976,
-0.0575624481,
-0.0100744721,
0.018833613,
0.0411868989,
-0.0573116094,
-0.0160853434,
-0.0008289767,
0.0122824088,
-0.0032350284,
-0.0013878548,
0.0372314826,
0.0718142912,
-0.0165218916,
0.0056047621,
-0.0654257312,
0.0106604714,
-0.0570525154,
0.0307753589,
-0.0189861767,
0.0221234243,
-0.0104258191,
-0.058624085,
-0.0250003412,
0.0403292477,
0.0003023153,
-0.013221086,
0.0359435342,
-0.0343893096,
0.0135118356,
0.0491660908,
-0.0061966721,
0.0305633266,
0.0226903949,
0.0059986655,
-0.0006926076,
0.0012120778,
0.0148226712,
-0.0414302014,
0.0026336042,
-0.0038565963,
0.0389774814,
0.0198299699,
0.0223506019,
0.0014093756,
-0.0049690204,
0.0416984856,
-0.0502525344,
-0.0110194478,
0.0084119989,
0.0004384449,
0.0198562592,
-0.0131474687,
0.0420095697,
-0.016724024,
-0.028188711,
0.0191490594,
-0.051496435,
-0.0119175157,
0.0411975458,
-0.0139914174,
-0.024630392,
-0.0515760444,
-0.0506713316,
-0.0447011851,
0.064731881,
-0.0092813428,
-0.0679240227,
0.0305117704,
0.0096334722,
-0.0132172713,
0.0155982226,
0.0086983331,
-0.0345726423,
0.0240958408,
-0.0136789205,
-0.0174179673,
0.10974738,
-0.0482945591,
0.0332273953,
0.0564683862,
0.0296376329,
-0.0411347486,
-0.0080585619,
-0.0452909544,
-0.0091181798,
0.035480164,
-0.013282368,
-0.0216083806,
0.0626639873,
-0.0293179918,
0.0061949575,
-0.0561956577,
0.02080038,
-0.0025760764,
-0.0019793899,
-0.0178951938,
0.0472212322,
0.0143401371,
-0.0262832884,
-0.0241438821,
-0.0480376109,
0.0754940733,
0.0091041476,
-0.0090594664,
-0.003034292,
0.0015481855,
-0.008547117,
0.0350042246,
0.0624187402,
0.0231366064,
0.057670787,
0.0225274526,
-0.0347965583,
-0.0073695043,
0.0190160591,
0.0079491697,
-0.0112563558,
-0.0186874028,
0.0053105983,
-0.0127014667,
-0.0249949489,
0.0151221631,
0.0242152531,
-0.0001934442,
0.0637772605,
0.0032384782,
-0.0497437567,
-0.0401419736,
-0.0233575888,
0.0283475928,
0.0018803849,
-0.03531041,
0.0192615576,
-0.0537462346,
0.0102676284,
0.0256247539,
-0.0714176521,
-0.0132681541,
-0.0272704717,
0.0183722768,
0.0542260036,
-0.0184736177,
0.0108085191,
0.0029548458,
0.0109197423,
-0.0091087436,
0.0337396152,
-0.0230155475,
0.0036189405,
0.0347679108,
-0.0609148629,
-0.0160617307,
0.0315532871,
0.0286870394,
-0.0172069967,
0.0092774164,
0.0079208435,
0.0044486145,
0.0003479347,
0.0393501297,
-0.130077213,
-0.0534077622,
-0.0608858503,
0.0240497477,
0.0076503493,
-0.0103473291,
-0.0169775654,
-0.0524848513,
0.0329475291,
0.0425001644,
-0.0238540806,
-0.0296949502,
-0.0752913803,
-0.0344018564,
-0.0324774422,
-0.0271862354,
-0.0070632994,
0.000522231,
-0.0073469616,
0.0316446498,
0.0064238128,
-0.0599267446,
0.0234254189,
0.0159376841,
-0.0016515614,
0.0409337543,
0.0049484773,
0.0125823785,
0.00158629,
0.0099415826,
0.0166260935,
-0.0033538227,
0.0003588331,
0.0867670998,
0.0051368359,
-0.013404496,
-0.0067756213,
0.0249085743,
-0.038647566,
-0.0436076298,
-0.063950479,
0.1246597916,
0.0032324335,
-0.0359659046,
-0.0372163653,
-0.0001959458,
-0.0015459076,
0.0451436378,
0.0182331819,
0.0017009049,
-0.1014457345,
-0.0474267825,
0.0353998244,
-0.0631263629,
-0.0007459665,
0.006600413,
-0.0408324413,
-0.0049403273,
-0.0407685451,
-0.0395541489,
0.0613187514,
-0.0111508854,
-0.0156743359,
-0.016324047,
0.0212088283,
-0.0412234329,
-0.0789966807,
0.0211633835,
0.0113803456,
0.0212185513,
-0.0529410094,
-0.0860738531,
0.0342140608,
0.0196699016,
-0.0099608451,
0.0354967304,
-0.0603535175,
-0.0751276985,
-0.0521521233,
0.0403302088,
0.0132003436,
0.0324357003,
-0.0065923221,
-0.0255114511,
0.0752201378,
0.0410696007,
-0.0063761859,
-0.0119210379,
0.0492079183,
-0.0365930311,
-0.0176589191,
0.0117349373,
-0.0154442945,
0.0212156828,
-0.0029146604,
0.01092376,
-0.011173876,
-0.0022314338,
0.039219521,
0.001640886,
0.0503149368,
0.0270274375,
0.0238655936,
-0.0151552735,
-0.0057789809,
0.0113070793,
0.0095679974,
-0.061744947,
-0.0267765578,
0.0514028259,
-0.0242700055,
-0.0039551971,
-0.0058540022,
-0.0482094511,
0.0149872489,
-0.0070312289,
0.0158819612,
-0.0028819002,
-0.0238117408,
0.0668766126,
0.0130326664,
-0.0242345836,
-0.0001479958,
-0.0318813063,
0.0199445859,
-0.0127987619,
0.0043560131,
0.0179449879,
0.0508047156,
-0.063122116,
0.0337932333,
-0.0278357584,
0.0023173366,
-0.0459206328,
0.0209265463,
0.0265322477,
-0.0059107137,
0.0333536379,
-0.0168096125,
-0.0288166106,
-0.0278781559,
0.0470237248,
-0.0145934923,
-0.0327278115,
0.0890464261,
0.0426684283,
-0.0049324268,
-0.0276716501,
0.0900937691,
0.0795932189,
0.0347626396,
-0.0236263052,
-0.0400536507,
-0.0216882061,
0.0071299709,
0.0024960686,
0.0024119001,
0.0049415482,
0.0209360272,
-0.0281957593,
-0.0497613139,
0.0200748872,
0.0106919315,
-0.031031508,
0.0184151027,
0.0459390767,
-0.010520611,
0.0207982641,
-0.0767506063,
-0.0231583733,
0.0335865319,
0.0122569501,
-0.0375738554,
-0.0061393813,
-6.107547957e-33,
-0.0085054729,
-0.0366294049,
-0.0069625098,
0.0344730914,
0.0154906455,
0.027499795,
-0.070373401,
-0.025008738,
-0.0199414957,
0.0798367262,
0.0125458632,
-0.0003888434,
0.0134309949,
-0.0282358415,
-0.0019806442,
-0.0208140872,
0.001924656,
-0.021764664,
0.0004462812,
0.0403773636,
0.0559112206,
0.0541144423,
0.0890371278,
-0.0152252223,
0.0184532199,
0.0163520724,
0.025307402,
-0.0314537212,
-0.0195986181,
0.0526325516,
-0.0090491958,
0.0570923164,
-0.0123013631,
-0.0295186602,
-0.0521486551,
0.0307797808,
-0.0688478276,
-0.0210213903,
-0.0062007988,
0.0021903953,
-0.0448306613,
-0.0345225446,
-0.006519658,
0.0002827558,
0.0037362217,
-0.0508715026,
0.0383284427,
0.0158944987,
-0.0318633914,
0.0146876965,
-0.0736826509,
0.0115238111,
0.0052924054,
-0.013685897,
0.0445036218,
0.0357630365,
0.0340152159,
0.0239123181,
-0.03961806,
0.0439096838,
-0.0201208945,
0.034001451,
0.0222303867,
0.0102859503,
0.0259766188,
0.0439201333,
0.0019789422,
-0.0047914358,
-0.0216505509,
0.0219537076,
0.0063302047,
0.0421776213,
0.0291614868,
-0.0196248181,
0.0522308089,
0.0583176315,
-0.1124781147,
-0.0291108694,
-0.0527783185,
0.0516215898,
-0.031394992,
0.0451330617,
0.0165891908,
-0.0591800064,
0.0178115014,
-0.0027333798,
-0.0152973598,
-0.0481902584,
-0.0129846418,
-0.0290337373,
-0.0548581518,
0.0284123588,
0.0213795323,
-0.0462065078,
-0.0525210686,
0.0635531545,
-0.0109082079,
0.054166723,
-0.0012467477,
0.0007995744,
-0.0950494185,
-0.0215637535,
0.0627470389,
-0.0160051472,
0.0251933057,
0.0130456872,
0.0629217401,
0.0386140049,
0.000768674,
-0.0362312756,
-0.0893025547,
-0.0199766159,
0.0154986493,
0.0157834236,
0.0180006567,
0.0369866639,
-0.0082694711,
0.0793680996,
0.0130106285,
-0.01936597,
0.0145841921,
0.0377841145,
0.018579457,
0.0384033062,
-0.0680456907,
-0.013825465,
-0.0680770949,
0.0222350787,
0.0271585938,
-0.0626218021,
-0.0377610102,
0.0037122238,
2.652e-7,
0.0942302197,
0.0295739621,
0.0764886588,
0.0094283633,
-0.0180907529,
0.0327215567,
-0.0120386221,
0.0502794124,
-0.062651664,
-0.0366405211,
0.0361368582,
0.0190295577,
-0.0235490873,
-0.0210338775,
-0.05856058,
0.0216719601,
-0.0292876735,
-0.019771656,
-0.0561465658,
-0.0057873591,
0.024764467,
0.080109179,
0.0089493291,
0.0106165251,
0.028860651,
-0.0199306384,
0.0751153454,
-0.0029261755,
0.0224914402,
0.0197259001,
-0.0312103629,
-0.0229353011,
-0.0418748371,
0.0412947349,
-0.0352489129,
-0.0430265516,
0.0224439502,
0.0377087221,
-0.0647360906,
-0.0393875465,
0.0202657189,
-0.0122428443,
0.0169838089,
-0.0129416315,
0.033864554,
-0.0744387582,
-0.0448450893,
0.0099140042,
-0.0254657008,
0.0404133834,
0.0368179381,
0.0061128344,
-0.003188831,
0.0128030488,
0.0024509057,
-0.0012625628,
-0.0028277722,
-0.0454008542,
-0.0426920727,
0.019494582,
-0.0001426765,
0.0068579181,
-0.0451664776,
-0.0033803305,
0.0038207406,
-0.0165909044,
-0.0370973684,
2.412254227e-34,
0.0371288173,
-0.024825938,
0.0106968721,
-0.0000144616,
0.0251147393,
-0.0377420671,
-0.0220303424,
0.0050698412,
0.0192481875,
-0.0528468415,
-0.0360187106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17782v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17782v1 | RASR2: The RWTH ASR Toolkit for Generic Sequence-to-sequence Speech Recognition | 2023-05-28T17:48:48 | 2023-05-28T17:48:48 | Wei Zhou, Eugen Beck, Simon Berger, Ralf Schlüter, Hermann Ney | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Modern public ASR tools usually provide rich support for training various
sequence-to-sequence (S2S) models, but rather simple support for decoding
open-vocabulary scenarios only. For closed-vocabulary scenarios, public tools
supporting lexical-constrained decoding are usually only for classical ASR, or
do not support all S2S models. To eliminate this restriction on research
possibilities such as modeling unit choice, we present RASR2 in this work, a
research-oriented generic S2S decoder implemented in C++. It offers a strong
flexibility/compatibility for various S2S models, language models, label
units/topologies and neural network architectures. It provides efficient
decoding for both open- and closed-vocabulary scenarios based on a generalized
search framework with rich support for different search modes and settings. We
evaluate RASR2 with a wide range of experiments on both switchboard and
Librispeech corpora. Our source code is public online. | [
-0.0128121106,
0.0849712119,
0.0255537257,
0.0402862877,
-0.0514288396,
-0.0140593546,
-0.0015854629,
-0.021898983,
-0.0526032858,
-0.0170284305,
-0.0164525229,
-0.0495157689,
0.0409241207,
0.0305153485,
-0.0043461532,
-0.0175923742,
0.03855744,
-0.0496908054,
-0.0190978888,
0.0024666695,
-0.0008443905,
0.0272185486,
-0.0333142057,
0.057337936,
0.0148535855,
0.0193669535,
-0.0031729459,
0.0412329733,
0.0275302939,
-0.0546627454,
0.0172896162,
0.0104190828,
0.0541438423,
0.0413062647,
0.0000020139,
-0.0309933964,
-0.0189238172,
0.0083597591,
-0.0592375249,
0.0284739286,
0.0315418504,
0.0136291739,
-0.0068693282,
0.0696389899,
0.0043640099,
-0.0445927233,
0.0593854673,
0.0219234079,
0.0112632448,
0.0538629815,
0.0146968188,
-0.0693619922,
-0.0049460246,
-0.0418722928,
-0.0256116949,
-0.0363138802,
-0.0019864207,
-0.033751782,
0.0309085548,
0.0098872744,
-0.0052131889,
0.0424241982,
0.0024660968,
-0.0015988438,
-0.0296589993,
0.003641207,
-0.0565105006,
-0.0671381205,
-0.0503896661,
0.0603587218,
-0.0150797591,
-0.0193933826,
0.0425544083,
0.014776282,
-0.0567367002,
-0.0376599655,
0.011272816,
0.0334412046,
-0.0327741839,
0.0041941805,
0.0270972606,
0.035804119,
0.0264606625,
-0.0326612704,
-0.0311372913,
0.0499120206,
0.0012119348,
-0.0225766171,
0.0411166549,
-0.0233058166,
0.0368061326,
-0.0180405565,
0.0631242767,
0.0134528568,
-0.0308884662,
0.0408748537,
-0.0105483448,
-0.0222519618,
0.0186297745,
-0.0841630399,
0.0147340475,
0.0632482246,
-0.0107785249,
0.005461229,
-0.0010862151,
0.0253306814,
0.0144631416,
0.0045760032,
-0.043541424,
-0.0096206749,
-0.018910367,
0.0074532134,
-0.0856430754,
0.0279287603,
-0.0254970957,
-0.0657690763,
-0.0304963049,
-0.0128359664,
0.0625259206,
-0.03467663,
0.0452406481,
0.005310101,
-0.049779132,
0.0200419892,
0.0184916835,
0.0289016832,
0.0196766779,
-0.0362437926,
-0.0084658358,
-0.0397376157,
-0.0312879868,
0.010385015,
0.0383450128,
-0.0266971178,
0.0024181688,
0.0544366948,
-0.0077633439,
-0.0570118465,
-0.0329284035,
0.0444317199,
-0.0063214656,
0.0048539126,
0.0007054677,
-0.0291841533,
0.0600266643,
0.0129588116,
-0.0232199542,
-0.0169643927,
0.0211716387,
-0.0005964451,
0.013280917,
0.0594303496,
-0.016496202,
-0.0045988327,
0.0292818472,
0.0156994648,
0.0621396713,
0.0618946627,
0.0177323762,
0.0126325255,
0.0024590618,
-0.0540868714,
-0.0225194879,
0.037453346,
0.011330612,
-0.0379469097,
-0.0077229077,
0.0243264697,
0.0333327465,
0.0272107515,
0.0565655828,
0.0613392182,
-0.055254627,
-0.0348998383,
0.0067763599,
0.0661167726,
0.0358506255,
0.0421226136,
0.0379680321,
0.019844573,
-0.0066909655,
-0.0307353623,
-0.0168860182,
0.0205666404,
0.0204319619,
0.0151686156,
0.0237271525,
0.0295141377,
0.0120002059,
-0.0230228174,
-0.0186360329,
0.0013412011,
0.0093586287,
0.0085068,
0.0427850522,
0.0168983974,
-0.0798404589,
0.0965963751,
0.0056699808,
-0.0542978235,
0.0031792559,
-0.0291994009,
0.0178726874,
0.0372363701,
0.0572612584,
-0.0420379378,
-0.0373119563,
-0.0280753747,
-0.0644902065,
0.0510599166,
0.0384268761,
-0.0114696547,
0.0451937355,
-0.1146947965,
-0.012388085,
0.0654889271,
0.0108320788,
0.1229605824,
-0.0262037218,
0.0058545982,
0.0078826156,
-0.0108220791,
-0.0072822017,
-0.0054026232,
0.0175902899,
-0.034390036,
0.0130086681,
-0.0098005468,
0.0229281597,
0.0341570675,
-0.0505066924,
0.0120484699,
0.0411222987,
-0.0166481845,
-0.0135670081,
-0.0071690399,
-0.100216344,
-0.0234385319,
0.0080365343,
-0.0276045669,
0.0013586257,
0.0752663314,
-0.0017722864,
-0.0484858528,
0.055014994,
-0.0250241663,
0.0497535504,
-0.0382420681,
0.042387452,
0.026750695,
0.0552211292,
0.0034168961,
0.0050974549,
-0.0042476342,
-0.0167433023,
-0.0052134651,
-0.013356165,
0.00183609,
-0.0747029409,
-0.0081947781,
0.0268884338,
-0.0389985815,
0.0174380504,
0.0233385861,
0.023506999,
0.014574972,
0.0074878386,
-0.0400452577,
-0.0068203495,
-0.0325734131,
0.0425716415,
-0.0012834722,
0.0450305156,
0.020521488,
-0.0164740849,
-0.0126974676,
-0.0369644091,
-0.0094050048,
-0.0232773777,
-0.0136100454,
0.0225965921,
-0.0467874222,
-0.0583406165,
-0.0198752675,
0.0154130068,
0.0355130918,
-0.0305794124,
-0.0577912927,
-0.0470566787,
0.0366971754,
0.0307658706,
0.0271054972,
-0.0294026993,
-0.041436445,
0.0105374297,
-0.003809033,
0.0075880252,
0.0633995235,
-0.0043386533,
-0.0024099741,
0.0029506215,
-0.0082848575,
-0.0779131651,
0.015951179,
0.0042799138,
-0.0291466601,
-0.0162471738,
-0.0378956422,
0.0282085668,
0.0854054242,
0.0076195961,
0.0516085103,
-0.0378018208,
-0.0657958463,
-0.0077964547,
-0.0367330387,
-0.0324850269,
-0.0072128577,
-0.0337465629,
0.0118333623,
-0.0164749715,
0.0172904283,
0.0133921793,
-0.0804838017,
-0.0477636419,
-0.0617507324,
-0.0302731637,
-0.0383971371,
0.0266274475,
-0.0011829896,
0.0169649161,
0.0005744732,
-0.0755440965,
0.0313934274,
0.0267407075,
-0.0231026467,
-0.0575205944,
0.0250220709,
-0.0188519415,
-0.0082943365,
-0.0483796038,
-0.0304632224,
0.0062075532,
0.0371784568,
0.0017051826,
0.0551853217,
0.047714524,
-0.0362701081,
-0.0175253022,
0.0294683538,
-0.028866211,
0.0972097814,
0.0182484109,
0.0348906517,
-0.0229130741,
0.0526665337,
0.0591547564,
0.007528129,
-0.0057276804,
0.0184965376,
0.0040505994,
0.0097312415,
0.024505768,
0.0109969843,
-0.0512798838,
-0.0181319714,
0.0587362126,
-0.0002013427,
-0.0036712387,
0.0053122067,
0.0120029757,
-0.05529866,
-0.0167752281,
0.0756106973,
-0.0044862917,
-0.0437470675,
-0.0214573629,
-0.0298721679,
0.0542552955,
0.0092511708,
-0.0093489494,
-0.0376064442,
-0.0065383068,
0.0258473419,
0.0385559313,
0.0310870055,
0.0035986509,
-0.0086011961,
-0.0657682866,
0.0297629349,
0.0198898725,
-0.0837310255,
-0.0291653145,
-0.0340561531,
-0.033485543,
-0.0302826632,
0.0177714359,
0.0442900658,
0.0076188799,
-0.0123565178,
0.0354044102,
-0.0454677865,
-0.0508266687,
0.0069914497,
-0.0196096022,
0.0938746557,
0.1115073264,
0.0224901475,
0.00390584,
-0.0071631153,
0.0028652162,
-0.0179472156,
0.0116139706,
-0.0331671424,
-0.0046031903,
-0.0246751141,
-0.0097625954,
-0.0260480382,
0.0168025941,
-0.0443331338,
0.0331473425,
0.0044845459,
0.0591005236,
0.0258159935,
-0.0206295606,
-0.021132268,
-0.0033015427,
0.0517017096,
0.0579073131,
0.0170264728,
-0.0169519894,
-0.0443419889,
-0.0314993672,
0.0268921349,
-0.0641635433,
-0.0296725817,
0.021307515,
0.0061484915,
-0.0362738296,
-0.0204395689,
-0.0002396866,
0.0073384116,
0.0278891847,
0.00387131,
0.017147487,
-0.0336128473,
0.0209689829,
-0.0784957036,
0.000740869,
-0.0122024901,
0.0230610743,
-0.0978127271,
-0.0108837215,
0.007349404,
-0.0498582795,
-0.0217585042,
0.0641777739,
-0.0338286534,
-0.0638716444,
0.0232239813,
0.0266348943,
0.0238454994,
0.0391050391,
-0.0074575073,
-0.0238625612,
0.060722176,
0.0022823922,
-0.013275031,
-0.0015748696,
0.050508298,
0.003714167,
-0.047410626,
0.0089309104,
-0.0535973422,
0.0229468159,
-0.0284851883,
0.0431510545,
-0.0078998422,
-0.0404929072,
-0.0056421305,
0.0089497231,
0.0564645492,
-0.0032591959,
-0.0027371522,
0.0061991028,
0.0595164746,
0.0225684084,
0.0630857348,
-0.0127740307,
0.0236211866,
0.069818899,
0.0167509075,
-0.012016749,
-0.0134977484,
0.0172802228,
0.0073593729,
0.0369852781,
0.0605743341,
0.0208982881,
0.0569376163,
0.0461056754,
-0.0196866281,
-0.0333570242,
0.0035889866,
0.0059247995,
0.0577022769,
-0.0387340747,
0.0340363681,
0.0125826458,
0.0116849933,
0.0408810638,
0.0387440659,
-0.0173791051,
-0.0154658398,
-0.0468784533,
-0.0106231384,
0.0313385837,
0.0216299519,
0.0626798421,
-0.0076186978,
0.042680461,
-0.0243880991,
0.0244156495,
-0.0311611649,
-0.0201948266,
0.0180763975,
0.0069935438,
-0.0205272511,
0.0025345129,
0.0164406151,
0.0158360042,
0.0060442188,
0.0024993615,
0.0189074799,
-0.0443856046,
-0.0450773612,
-0.0038779823,
-0.0073576835,
-0.061842788,
-0.0240319483,
-0.0135300029,
-0.0529908314,
0.0342208706,
0.0239626486,
0.0235909708,
-0.0064679165,
0.0083318166,
0.0202544164,
-0.0203633253,
0.0058148913,
-0.0009382183,
-0.0006774425,
-0.048168432,
-0.0502080582,
-0.0230984557,
-6.68180009e-33,
-0.0533450395,
0.0263025705,
-0.0162916947,
-0.040691115,
-0.0215032008,
0.0059399083,
-0.0280530676,
-0.0192515627,
-0.0105454847,
-0.0438718796,
0.0034783005,
-0.0106766848,
0.0319094136,
-0.0027014159,
-0.0207889341,
0.0177768897,
0.0773170963,
0.005675545,
-0.0137943588,
-0.0110794455,
-0.0013987739,
0.0698047578,
0.0528034568,
-0.0485133827,
-0.0694101676,
-0.0034976243,
0.0685541481,
-0.0053996025,
0.0009554498,
0.0291144252,
0.0039336281,
0.0481847525,
-0.0216129608,
-0.0344606973,
-0.0164948981,
0.0302060768,
-0.1511358768,
0.0202791188,
0.0115089547,
0.0526766255,
0.0115817692,
-0.0116072437,
0.00453034,
0.017706167,
-0.0328659229,
0.00888249,
-0.0107054329,
0.0271944962,
-0.028031541,
-0.0351855606,
-0.0024936681,
0.020830771,
0.0101959622,
-0.0101696178,
0.0403866693,
0.0682531148,
-0.0337835997,
-0.0436462983,
-0.0376456417,
-0.0048107714,
0.0098203002,
0.0582064129,
0.0339389071,
0.0468653068,
-0.0226058345,
0.0089637106,
0.0752268881,
-0.0901428685,
0.0137296654,
-0.0207889751,
0.0392648652,
0.012015257,
-0.0057910299,
0.012409294,
0.0470390692,
-0.0243249536,
-0.006890377,
-0.0221608635,
0.0498704165,
0.0142563106,
0.0426452756,
0.0697033331,
-0.0427258164,
-0.0103915129,
-0.0246023349,
-0.0581309535,
-0.0390687473,
-0.0496276021,
0.0887852758,
0.050825946,
-0.0011402194,
0.0146755623,
0.0675092936,
0.0140514942,
0.038046658,
0.020157963,
0.0514614582,
-0.0200496688,
-0.0271143299,
0.035084337,
-0.054619167,
-0.0330858864,
0.0298148766,
0.0012392304,
0.0020621913,
-0.0204378795,
-0.0552526489,
0.0476308465,
-0.0328896195,
-0.0064122137,
-0.0205870476,
0.0411097817,
-0.0365349427,
0.0259081274,
0.0261099283,
-0.0466720089,
-0.0012866993,
0.0403643735,
-0.0383178256,
-0.0275813974,
-0.0321127884,
-0.0198231768,
0.030939864,
0.0241181292,
-0.0090659978,
0.0240383092,
0.0033613357,
0.0263337437,
0.0182424262,
-0.0138733098,
-0.0164339188,
0.0215036031,
2.89e-7,
-0.0251116529,
0.0353455879,
0.0717072934,
-0.0083299736,
0.0024537949,
-0.027951261,
-0.0000786583,
0.045202665,
-0.0182757173,
0.047392372,
-0.0123082642,
-0.0323141441,
0.0451699011,
-0.0309486054,
-0.1045210958,
-0.0514866076,
-0.0527638085,
0.0303032845,
-0.0260506291,
-0.0073556406,
0.0324664526,
0.0785645545,
-0.0456453823,
-0.0157812815,
0.0089293439,
-0.0070602526,
-0.0077688354,
-0.0421003252,
0.0186129436,
-0.0153814619,
-0.0299682077,
-0.0070102494,
-0.0320286378,
-0.0188035071,
-0.0044286004,
0.039289318,
0.0441208594,
0.0571595207,
-0.0003666109,
-0.1087215021,
-0.0009288314,
0.0197530463,
-0.0322135948,
-0.0252711922,
0.0021759716,
0.0003485556,
-0.0053239861,
-0.0006936554,
-0.0661881715,
0.0222420804,
-0.0460659899,
-0.0212399755,
0.0285195019,
0.008138027,
0.0009794675,
-0.012216758,
-0.0295840465,
-0.0789724588,
-0.0134382732,
-0.0071113752,
-0.0257235114,
-0.0227688849,
-0.0633684248,
0.0314196758,
-0.0183749571,
0.0105003379,
-0.0156424064,
2.342908556e-34,
0.0618340373,
-0.0343751274,
0.0062269391,
0.0158313923,
0.0372593328,
-0.0297892466,
-0.00293782,
0.0160393305,
-0.0091436543,
-0.0548160188,
-0.0716136619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17779v1 | Generating EDU Extracts for Plan-Guided Summary Re-Ranking | 2023-05-28T17:22:04 | 2023-05-28T17:22:04 | Griffin Adams, Alexander R. Fabbri, Faisal Ladhak, Kathleen McKeown, Noémie Elhadad | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two-step approaches, in which summary candidates are generated-then-reranked
to return a single summary, can improve ROUGE scores over the standard
single-step approach. Yet, standard decoding methods (i.e., beam search,
nucleus sampling, and diverse beam search) produce candidates with redundant,
and often low quality, content. In this paper, we design a novel method to
generate candidates for re-ranking that addresses these issues. We ground each
candidate abstract on its own unique content plan and generate distinct
plan-guided abstracts using a model's top beam. More concretely, a standard
language model (a BART LM) auto-regressively generates elemental discourse unit
(EDU) content plans with an extractive copy mechanism. The top K beams from the
content plan generator are then used to guide a separate LM, which produces a
single abstractive candidate for each distinct plan. We apply an existing
re-ranker (BRIO) to abstractive candidates generated from our method, as well
as baseline decoding methods. We show large relevance improvements over
previously published methods on widely used single document news article
corpora, with ROUGE-2 F1 gains of 0.88, 2.01, and 0.38 on CNN / Dailymail, NYT,
and Xsum, respectively. A human evaluation on CNN / DM validates these results.
Similarly, on 1k samples from CNN / DM, we show that prompting GPT-3 to follow
EDU plans outperforms sampling-based methods by 1.05 ROUGE-2 F1 points. Code to
generate and realize plans is available at
https://github.com/griff4692/edu-sum. | [
0.0624097809,
0.0409414135,
0.0102134794,
-0.0105957026,
-0.0136492914,
-0.0067296103,
-0.0383820534,
-0.0237515233,
-0.0284334105,
-0.0459937155,
-0.0092426762,
0.0153096514,
-0.0142429732,
0.036982365,
0.0041327523,
-0.0384078473,
0.0256800912,
-0.0121297315,
0.0264536664,
-0.0225047786,
0.0054181674,
0.0269639213,
0.0551333204,
0.0090664783,
0.0658581033,
0.0138732037,
-0.0301820207,
0.0171426013,
0.03019532,
-0.0494848043,
0.0163776651,
0.0669723004,
-0.0067956103,
0.037415918,
0.0000019965,
-0.0308428518,
-0.0709920675,
0.003283188,
-0.0021858586,
0.021412611,
0.0391039364,
-0.0325080939,
0.0076117939,
0.011037101,
-0.0427488461,
0.0092125386,
-0.0110733192,
0.0693777129,
0.0652443543,
0.0517836325,
-0.014866733,
-0.0368482284,
0.0412198082,
-0.0132214744,
-0.0399388932,
-0.0316259973,
-0.0049763825,
0.0328897536,
0.0030491601,
0.0776644051,
0.0084880553,
0.0301048961,
0.0277260169,
-0.0448434725,
0.023821868,
0.0142970281,
-0.0845372081,
0.0064125368,
0.0054535246,
0.0579523928,
-0.0126400162,
-0.0381624363,
0.0275052078,
0.0107710883,
0.0128945261,
-0.0129030356,
-0.0687843263,
0.0101872385,
-0.0254616197,
0.0168815274,
0.0629935712,
0.0213837028,
-0.0004513012,
0.0417700224,
-0.0257676411,
0.0338415094,
0.0182977095,
-0.0276166741,
0.0294199735,
0.0308791399,
-0.0145455897,
-0.0514532179,
0.0341607332,
0.0093289623,
-0.0295694806,
0.0010932167,
-0.0304329377,
-0.0739807636,
0.0230916068,
-0.0160523858,
-0.0078427214,
0.0399488024,
0.0218487922,
0.0324734561,
-0.0065740868,
0.033090394,
-0.0065754885,
-0.0018517826,
-0.0639084429,
-0.0023923432,
-0.017535381,
-0.0156391654,
-0.0303077847,
0.0497910231,
-0.0827706978,
-0.0249623246,
-0.0360640958,
0.0127769625,
0.0155660808,
-0.0335868075,
0.00584633,
0.0078169089,
-0.0500635691,
0.0065535242,
0.0155845117,
0.0286877099,
-0.0141432881,
-0.0279229078,
0.0145287504,
-0.0300002061,
-0.0143811693,
0.0195946936,
-0.0187782254,
0.0044367504,
-0.0076658195,
-0.0102487691,
-0.0582692698,
-0.0029838807,
0.0491440818,
-0.0339718983,
-0.0084657446,
-0.0260938313,
0.0345500521,
-0.1033055037,
-0.0074186372,
0.0170061458,
-0.004480741,
-0.0094983466,
0.0231889542,
0.0120821744,
-0.0417941175,
0.0037321264,
0.0389042199,
0.0101230564,
0.0471607596,
0.0149920173,
0.0257047582,
0.0625237972,
0.0033201738,
0.0438622236,
0.0475744233,
0.0428374149,
-0.0196239203,
0.0176419504,
0.0217493139,
0.0347858071,
0.074999094,
0.0020234964,
-0.0492878519,
0.0047708564,
0.0486744046,
0.0440329984,
-0.0569346696,
0.0025221792,
0.0195506439,
0.0229553692,
0.0132613285,
0.0168596264,
0.0029506318,
0.0507755801,
0.0068821777,
0.042376373,
-0.0004910169,
0.0197500344,
-0.0162072964,
0.0043409788,
0.0828409642,
0.0297414176,
-0.0204695314,
-0.0379799902,
0.0253005885,
0.0254628845,
-0.0035544296,
-0.0261482913,
0.0250928514,
0.0457042642,
-0.0449615903,
0.0335416645,
0.0154080763,
-0.0255692545,
0.0274077356,
-0.0079044728,
0.0043044682,
0.0375350937,
0.0857146457,
-0.0109295733,
-0.0118095186,
0.0303129312,
-0.009928287,
0.0456719957,
0.0461324528,
-0.0398842357,
-0.0161200911,
-0.061504174,
-0.0471948236,
-0.0433382764,
-0.0012438367,
0.037135981,
0.0264657382,
-0.0099525331,
0.0075326264,
-0.0222886484,
-0.0677976459,
0.0209901258,
-0.0344118252,
-0.0210290235,
0.0099493442,
-0.0306872539,
0.0371171758,
0.0368559435,
0.0186600983,
0.0137062594,
0.0219340101,
-0.0147777479,
-0.0144351507,
-0.0069923685,
-0.0444170646,
-0.0365788229,
0.0187003333,
-0.0950647071,
-0.00446655,
0.0499298796,
-0.0399964973,
-0.045123823,
0.0258149933,
-0.0311902743,
0.0048873164,
-0.0508833416,
0.0131765157,
0.034063518,
-0.0113405725,
-0.0482828878,
0.0836660713,
-0.0148375975,
0.0059659942,
0.1002074927,
-0.0601859652,
0.0099200718,
-0.0751769617,
-0.0078482013,
0.0031879295,
-0.0119023398,
-0.0116087357,
0.049477946,
0.0478204042,
-0.0321673043,
-0.0055533242,
-0.1296917349,
-0.0000845902,
-0.0519925244,
0.006955218,
0.0534463339,
0.0086427107,
0.0080151083,
-0.0133542018,
-0.0242131595,
-0.0571069941,
-0.0056820107,
0.0107647534,
0.001063694,
0.0102042612,
0.0422203057,
-0.0365164839,
-0.0485405959,
0.0048329034,
0.0199176371,
0.0022284291,
-0.0224016402,
-0.0481919013,
0.0586284325,
-0.012143868,
-0.0164737962,
-0.0039680749,
0.0084017692,
-0.0171048734,
-0.0259655882,
0.0303366743,
-0.000417443,
0.0280585457,
0.040830642,
0.023262918,
0.0070781331,
-0.07848607,
-0.0019651698,
-0.0541171245,
0.0419070348,
-0.0320333466,
-0.0367932953,
0.0363388956,
0.0227710269,
0.0063869641,
0.0125912298,
-0.0312977135,
-0.0139122596,
-0.0141650029,
-0.0464380197,
-0.056786146,
-0.0152123291,
0.0147540011,
0.0448172241,
-0.0174120348,
-0.0159735717,
0.0598623082,
0.0011035556,
0.032023225,
-0.0993474796,
0.01845829,
-0.0522966012,
0.0117116785,
-0.0240688864,
-0.0040287669,
-0.0265885871,
-0.0266514663,
-0.0375579856,
0.0057010129,
0.0142657412,
-0.044446215,
0.0540851653,
-0.0558211282,
0.0074137589,
-0.0172688086,
-0.0494610593,
-0.0286894869,
-0.064235881,
0.0401593708,
0.0391593687,
0.0148423193,
0.0094318995,
-0.0557089709,
0.0098465309,
0.028124107,
0.0605055094,
-0.0579274856,
-0.0074640578,
-0.0072970367,
0.0854111388,
0.0651950464,
0.0141572291,
0.0281125419,
-0.0311549455,
0.0201322939,
0.0576417223,
0.0192779638,
-0.0084156087,
0.0144072091,
-0.0054527852,
0.0294171777,
-0.0471071638,
-0.0120236902,
-0.0337355472,
0.0342310295,
-0.0291229691,
-0.0375894345,
0.0733410493,
0.0290433485,
-0.0333437584,
-0.0280619711,
-0.0296923947,
0.0633946583,
0.0010505824,
0.0406194814,
-0.0477582999,
0.0209643506,
0.0183794759,
0.0501208529,
0.0084546655,
0.0076344148,
0.0074582556,
-0.1066801101,
0.0439503603,
0.0040800855,
-0.0214276817,
0.0144855399,
-0.0328678936,
-0.0023743219,
-0.0140079334,
0.0039175139,
0.0369722396,
-0.0100715598,
0.02071812,
-0.0002261331,
-0.0181514621,
-0.0432521701,
-0.0233937036,
0.0198057722,
-0.0285378285,
0.0501234829,
0.0451746807,
-0.0170155279,
0.0176791716,
0.0169985052,
-0.071758993,
-0.0002335998,
-0.0250298567,
0.0213728473,
-0.0073671071,
0.0263094101,
-0.0355725177,
0.0782793239,
0.0097726677,
-0.0142352618,
-0.0133195855,
0.0275798626,
-0.0398093574,
-0.0011949897,
-0.0583198182,
-0.0077552162,
0.0177629776,
0.0672184527,
0.0084245577,
0.0078294873,
-0.0220759604,
-0.0378246866,
0.0301950332,
-0.0726400539,
-0.0392190777,
0.0121559585,
-0.0328623466,
0.0022418608,
-0.082976535,
-0.0565493405,
-0.0034197143,
0.0146083795,
-0.0090349391,
0.0021636388,
-0.0253088064,
-0.0266398545,
-0.0390914716,
-0.0048905476,
0.0101770954,
-0.0335768126,
-0.0121656619,
-0.0318789817,
0.024965845,
-0.0452104025,
-0.0457444191,
0.0212959852,
-0.0073398035,
-0.0434663333,
0.0188843254,
0.0129451863,
0.0235961806,
0.0412339345,
-0.0204508081,
-0.0044748946,
0.0937155187,
0.0289485864,
-0.0042076586,
0.0179169979,
-0.0011032945,
-0.0038578724,
-0.0332206897,
0.0144027378,
-0.0677768812,
0.0627232268,
-0.0148230968,
0.0802372396,
-0.0136126941,
0.0041005788,
0.0360946022,
0.051062271,
0.0161625817,
-0.0610119142,
-0.003902423,
-0.0458475277,
0.0401177183,
-0.0321780071,
-0.0072324369,
-0.0206947755,
0.0597456656,
0.026187811,
-0.001403104,
-0.0100808311,
0.0831497163,
0.0177304614,
0.043192327,
-0.0739698187,
-0.0086553767,
-0.0219627023,
-0.0238781981,
-0.0421391577,
-0.0165939555,
-0.0339801796,
0.0232120287,
-0.0098519232,
0.0477264076,
-0.0264197271,
-0.006390546,
0.0594851039,
0.0037821569,
0.0183989815,
0.0636280105,
-0.1154434979,
-0.0073325476,
-0.0555289946,
-0.0348183326,
0.0237450432,
-0.0108030234,
0.1185827553,
-0.027678946,
-0.0258951243,
-0.0365489796,
-0.0110004703,
0.0445062332,
-0.0234487653,
-0.0011453978,
0.0348578021,
-0.0030724562,
0.0240742769,
0.0665758178,
-0.05269669,
-0.0006908263,
0.0084562898,
-0.0170934852,
-0.0423219278,
-0.0512986816,
-0.017015921,
0.034146402,
-0.0132658519,
-0.0338349864,
-0.0277364217,
0.0311312899,
0.0248945709,
0.0184901394,
-0.0117650796,
-0.0367499292,
0.05418659,
0.0592617877,
-0.0147985239,
-0.0071049267,
-0.0607843995,
-0.0136612514,
-0.028355293,
-0.0479735471,
-0.0150637645,
-6.718803183e-33,
-0.0395524241,
-0.0071218638,
-0.016715521,
0.0230115801,
-0.010842884,
0.025914453,
-0.0787923038,
-0.0494571403,
0.0241858866,
0.0244798549,
-0.0248380378,
0.0127716577,
0.0225108452,
0.0188980475,
0.0149516566,
0.0433203056,
0.0462379083,
0.0035683133,
-0.0423681438,
0.0488988012,
0.0699841082,
0.0195893068,
0.0210102815,
-0.0308095403,
0.0157057215,
-0.0035395822,
0.0006165557,
-0.0249045696,
0.0093764653,
0.0573795661,
-0.0009068312,
0.0114223463,
0.0442860685,
-0.052516032,
-0.0289167892,
0.0004884211,
-0.0892488956,
-0.0481721163,
0.016469568,
-0.0533875711,
-0.0757648945,
-0.0321033411,
0.0256632324,
-0.0004589834,
-0.0296705123,
-0.040247675,
0.0396137834,
-0.0161669385,
-0.0191925801,
-0.0739724115,
-0.0320462547,
0.0242530629,
-0.0176404454,
0.0227852352,
0.0274591632,
0.0501500368,
-0.003608661,
0.0282273646,
-0.0133195035,
0.0488102064,
-0.0151444627,
0.0708807334,
0.0331982635,
-0.0538384169,
-0.0023568403,
0.0586366765,
-0.0317107327,
-0.0159744807,
0.0133537883,
-0.0175511651,
0.0214376822,
0.0018222044,
0.0159078725,
0.0194357298,
0.0276335794,
0.02618655,
-0.0547608659,
0.0816044435,
0.0138356825,
0.0546975918,
0.03286523,
0.0125332018,
0.000648572,
-0.0236031823,
-0.0238035191,
-0.0190167651,
-0.004249414,
-0.0285950545,
0.0249927919,
0.0363653339,
-0.0368598402,
0.0276741646,
0.0494537875,
-0.0330157429,
-0.0052344566,
0.0442500785,
-0.0225524511,
0.0264552999,
0.0207938179,
0.0123623777,
-0.0524124801,
0.0264766701,
0.0529122464,
-0.010844674,
-0.013971149,
-0.0094965249,
0.0266355928,
0.0199907795,
-0.0278685987,
0.0143252518,
0.0019817732,
0.0138320588,
-0.044285614,
0.0451967753,
-0.0138655324,
0.0262541063,
0.0180031005,
-0.01463807,
0.0408166759,
0.0431711487,
-0.0551157556,
-0.0085153133,
0.046428442,
0.0242205784,
0.0017246976,
0.0391822793,
-0.0145347714,
0.0107531715,
0.0039758086,
-0.0250231642,
-0.0194214731,
0.0498085469,
2.797e-7,
0.0416319221,
0.0497875623,
0.0484116562,
0.015158453,
0.0132528404,
-0.0193709601,
-0.0018969304,
0.0492948629,
0.0191222262,
-0.0314951874,
0.0241349433,
0.0191302914,
0.0449206904,
0.0314814039,
-0.090976648,
0.0437839031,
-0.0649895892,
-0.0668435171,
-0.0375651754,
-0.0383312851,
0.0120336218,
0.0674990788,
-0.0369747207,
0.0043739011,
-0.018863637,
0.0418222025,
0.0410916209,
0.0152474418,
-0.0406969376,
0.0312027782,
0.037561588,
-0.0009601597,
-0.0383961648,
-0.0308250096,
-0.0318477489,
0.0205595288,
0.0405357555,
0.0489987396,
0.0058612418,
-0.054362148,
0.0062259636,
-0.0248969607,
0.0260243043,
-0.0218364988,
0.0218023416,
-0.000563807,
0.0046674493,
-0.0164060686,
-0.0797738209,
0.0198042635,
-0.0046877856,
-0.0104919123,
-0.0143820764,
0.0633387789,
-0.0084906956,
0.0211256649,
-0.001749854,
-0.0788471177,
0.0008017803,
-0.0083090374,
-0.0200257488,
-0.0289712902,
0.0036259331,
-0.0042121559,
-0.0210069437,
-0.0907366127,
-0.0063111125,
2.911846673e-34,
0.0908416733,
0.0052057495,
-0.0324087888,
0.005737266,
0.0002582171,
-0.0076695178,
-0.0412898213,
0.0265680756,
-0.0043009506,
-0.1002757177,
-0.0306035858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18410v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18410v1 | Understanding Breast Cancer Survival: Using Causality and Language Models on Multi-omics Data | 2023-05-28T17:07:46 | 2023-05-28T17:07:46 | Mugariya Farooq, Shahad Hardan, Aigerim Zhumbhayeva, Yujia Zheng, Preslav Nakov, Kun Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, q-bio.GN, stat.ME | The need for more usable and explainable machine learning models in
healthcare increases the importance of developing and utilizing causal
discovery algorithms, which aim to discover causal relations by analyzing
observational data. Explainable approaches aid clinicians and biologists in
predicting the prognosis of diseases and suggesting proper treatments. However,
very little research has been conducted at the crossroads between causal
discovery, genomics, and breast cancer, and we aim to bridge this gap.
Moreover, evaluation of causal discovery methods on real data is in general
notoriously difficult because ground-truth causal relations are usually
unknown, and accordingly, in this paper, we also propose to address the
evaluation problem with large language models. In particular, we exploit
suitable causal discovery algorithms to investigate how various perturbations
in the genome can affect the survival of patients diagnosed with breast cancer.
We used three main causal discovery algorithms: PC, Greedy Equivalence Search
(GES), and a Generalized Precision Matrix-based one. We experiment with a
subset of The Cancer Genome Atlas, which contains information about mutations,
copy number variations, protein levels, and gene expressions for 705 breast
cancer patients. Our findings reveal important factors related to the vital
status of patients using causal discovery algorithms. However, the reliability
of these results remains a concern in the medical domain. Accordingly, as
another contribution of the work, the results are validated through language
models trained on biomedical literature, such as BlueBERT and other large
language models trained on medical corpora. Our results profess proper
utilization of causal discovery algorithms and language models for revealing
reliable causal relations for clinical applications. | [
0.0074277269,
0.1165893227,
-0.0221653599,
-0.0297206864,
-0.0302162133,
0.0223572906,
-0.0078726849,
0.0512169525,
-0.0158702377,
0.0102792894,
0.0848664194,
-0.0107881511,
0.0097287931,
0.0111895222,
-0.0338020772,
0.0371490754,
0.0255427733,
0.0295622647,
0.0139794182,
-0.0148543511,
-0.0269432236,
0.0042592534,
0.0202083383,
0.0374991,
-0.01794523,
0.0336492658,
0.0677643418,
-0.0228815749,
-0.0157646872,
-0.0061779949,
-0.0231735222,
-0.0058894814,
-0.0285154376,
0.0208886843,
0.0000019176,
-0.094608821,
-0.026830487,
0.0045185643,
0.0024729357,
-0.0222424939,
-0.0109701538,
-0.0479511283,
0.0266786143,
0.0021080566,
0.0071004773,
0.0139728319,
0.0381721817,
0.0218807105,
-0.0102033066,
0.0552253947,
-0.0208519623,
-0.0634810627,
0.0278167967,
-0.004953464,
0.0589583963,
-0.037021175,
0.0769793764,
-0.0075731631,
0.0357579067,
-0.037476249,
0.0110953664,
0.0571856797,
-0.0183284022,
-0.001556595,
-0.0038091098,
0.0256928038,
0.0644783974,
-0.0015348917,
0.0479682423,
0.0411374122,
0.0177962296,
-0.0532089919,
0.056505084,
0.0050943065,
0.0226124581,
0.0793944895,
-0.0220702086,
-0.0007681951,
-0.0438850038,
-0.0049232272,
0.0222740676,
-0.008204788,
0.0542087369,
0.0125387963,
-0.0195937231,
0.0998249948,
0.0073304023,
-0.0041374164,
-0.0410810448,
0.0000978286,
0.0054475218,
0.0046623824,
0.0025327464,
-0.0026213997,
-0.0518908724,
0.0190006495,
0.0270602629,
-0.0234485902,
0.049997218,
-0.0782176554,
0.0220831968,
0.0064734342,
0.0022092941,
0.0325639881,
-0.0136090023,
-0.0369591042,
-0.0633412227,
0.0541908182,
-0.0504434928,
0.0143853007,
-0.0451178141,
0.0088882158,
0.0334641784,
-0.0029110534,
0.0328932367,
0.0420595594,
-0.0800473168,
0.0010431517,
-0.0218332298,
0.009815068,
0.0108645465,
-0.0106942244,
0.0135225849,
0.0145689165,
-0.0188915096,
-0.0405598916,
-0.0200756937,
0.0178922769,
-0.0698306039,
-0.0460281782,
0.0021180229,
0.0010879975,
0.0401229523,
-0.0325997993,
-0.011499011,
0.0672509,
0.0497577153,
-0.0251425859,
0.0172037743,
-0.0064911549,
-0.0442822762,
-0.0472929738,
-0.0321559086,
-0.0336230323,
-0.0081383865,
0.0465120226,
-0.0303435344,
-0.0468220226,
0.0055610612,
-0.0431510136,
-0.0786093548,
0.0552975014,
-0.0110699562,
0.0079408251,
0.0191307738,
-0.016412748,
0.0172581524,
0.0047586397,
0.0238675512,
-0.0639373958,
0.0304364804,
-0.0578496642,
0.0021720116,
-0.0010383002,
0.0394955836,
-0.0178164002,
-0.0166282225,
-0.0011673258,
0.0393888615,
0.0396144427,
-0.0464956425,
-0.0391948111,
0.0092401067,
-0.0283853486,
0.0313185602,
0.0027730032,
0.026134355,
0.0612105243,
-0.0054002381,
-0.0434235334,
-0.0395783633,
-0.0397056863,
0.011049957,
-0.0291609168,
-0.0562753156,
0.0019891534,
-0.0018955033,
-0.0423451103,
0.0253809374,
-0.0466478392,
-0.0383511521,
0.0093516409,
-0.006974427,
-0.0316498987,
0.0600903407,
-0.0342362337,
-0.0121316006,
-0.0186211485,
0.0495293625,
-0.0063845641,
-0.0058652875,
-0.0296933986,
-0.0276181735,
0.0388105959,
0.0347520486,
-0.0670257881,
-0.0115754195,
-0.0094876587,
0.0045304922,
-0.07230784,
-0.0422402918,
0.0047645234,
-0.0137501629,
0.0261439662,
0.0090010911,
0.0618084632,
0.0232734103,
-0.0354712419,
-0.035466481,
0.0274438858,
-0.0290731005,
-0.0403583273,
-0.0249889065,
0.0574844405,
-0.0170480683,
-0.0096111335,
0.0295656901,
0.0018340533,
0.0417568684,
0.0290017202,
-0.0495606847,
0.0314535573,
0.0206098575,
-0.0587200634,
-0.0725484267,
0.0533394367,
0.0375411995,
-0.0192583539,
0.0034132358,
-0.0415884331,
0.0041636755,
0.019800745,
-0.0310149305,
-0.0211633909,
0.0347322039,
-0.0528413653,
0.0058261654,
0.0184091926,
0.0066224565,
-0.0177973006,
0.003610106,
-0.0192773007,
0.0483548343,
-0.0386440493,
0.0296159368,
-0.0038568173,
-0.058157064,
0.0549769141,
-0.034666229,
0.0100976303,
0.017225381,
0.0066760397,
-0.0173868071,
0.0556076802,
-0.0548723266,
0.0409112312,
0.0119916564,
-0.0470435843,
-0.0241720658,
0.0130197471,
0.0204129498,
-0.0115840891,
0.0172674041,
0.0213081911,
-0.0471533462,
-0.0436142683,
0.0199460275,
0.006052251,
0.0088880612,
0.0438505672,
0.0518909656,
-0.0657930896,
-0.0528968498,
-0.0299423449,
-0.0657838285,
0.0631528124,
0.0698551461,
-0.0346310437,
-0.0017413041,
0.0243806783,
-0.0209963415,
-0.002338839,
-0.0216554441,
-0.0090580666,
-0.0004048439,
-0.0187730081,
-0.0670467615,
0.0144593557,
0.0144623173,
0.0367420204,
0.0196765382,
0.0174064171,
-0.0190667026,
-0.034412846,
-0.0866269767,
-0.0527217686,
-0.015508025,
-0.0468637682,
-0.0003245562,
0.0178942923,
0.0191655066,
-0.0565385558,
-0.0660836846,
-0.0026250964,
-0.0063426723,
0.0168004502,
-0.0657316223,
0.0171694271,
-0.0089384988,
0.0226774458,
0.0092320042,
-0.0725028366,
0.0924299061,
0.0162833016,
0.0614052303,
-0.050938841,
-0.0064910655,
-0.0227970388,
0.0114675378,
0.0156501736,
0.0252243839,
-0.004384432,
0.0299240686,
0.0240460597,
-0.0223404896,
0.0490558036,
0.0047002756,
0.0122997891,
-0.0442311242,
0.0978410468,
0.0712584555,
-0.0347587876,
-0.0181156825,
-0.0376389064,
0.0248054545,
-0.0065129539,
0.0458090156,
0.0032516059,
-0.0810545236,
0.0042783064,
-0.0108275954,
0.0588113032,
0.0118227964,
-0.0051379325,
-0.0188130867,
-0.0444545299,
0.0058662277,
-0.0576341003,
0.0050288411,
-0.0430012532,
0.0321870148,
-0.02475884,
-0.0381276272,
0.0077547161,
-0.000903761,
0.0420412198,
-0.0034947647,
-0.0357503444,
0.0243601277,
0.0439915545,
-0.0398181714,
-0.0363311544,
-0.0137104653,
0.0732649043,
0.033370357,
-0.0385035612,
0.0394237153,
0.0130230216,
-0.0632527694,
-0.0166066829,
0.0372162499,
-0.0794279277,
-0.0072001102,
-0.0204276089,
-0.0243453607,
-0.0312601179,
-0.0710656047,
0.0392061435,
-0.0090337107,
0.0217163172,
-0.0118561657,
-0.0646178126,
0.0172408987,
-0.0747790635,
0.0061334805,
-0.0788373724,
-0.0696358234,
-0.0244873855,
0.0358548239,
-0.0159055144,
0.0046653678,
-0.0125844236,
-0.0951947719,
-0.0243962724,
-0.031284526,
0.0237436965,
0.0354217365,
0.0202346928,
-0.0486965775,
-0.0010310623,
-0.0357081071,
0.0635903701,
0.001047009,
-0.0186670031,
0.0613318309,
0.040395122,
-0.024117751,
-0.0315252729,
0.0385990031,
-0.0126216132,
-0.0003761831,
-0.0176928211,
0.0403004326,
-0.0434086584,
-0.0429814234,
-0.01557393,
-0.0032282716,
0.0133143216,
0.0614571273,
-0.0320632979,
-0.0148264887,
-0.0184081122,
0.0054840134,
0.0383185335,
0.0002403393,
-0.005082617,
-0.0130688651,
-0.0095609454,
-0.0225961395,
-0.0441938415,
0.0120600797,
-0.0059436238,
-0.0180872418,
0.0229463652,
0.0530653819,
0.009044122,
-0.0386423431,
-0.0743080005,
0.0684473664,
0.0317621678,
0.0463344939,
-0.0430692546,
-0.0656450316,
0.0342169665,
-0.0070967516,
-0.028097447,
0.0187285691,
-0.0263613202,
-0.0235597249,
-0.0452879108,
0.0468576364,
0.0205422007,
-0.0059814174,
-0.0180093236,
-0.0819487274,
0.0099717313,
0.0277329236,
-0.0247301944,
-0.015025273,
-0.0437460802,
-0.0665563792,
0.0003196459,
0.0061750123,
0.0002984498,
0.0234775301,
-0.0005976008,
0.0239331797,
0.0010809388,
-0.0075369501,
0.0466652401,
0.0339849256,
0.054853458,
-0.0024399266,
-0.0312463865,
-0.0142734507,
0.0288080294,
-0.0337765776,
-0.0064226473,
0.0070165955,
-0.0246110838,
0.0140673667,
0.0354135484,
-0.0233394317,
-0.0270757377,
-0.0571675003,
-0.0360311829,
-0.0601998903,
0.0512308069,
-0.0026506281,
0.0021290719,
0.0504767522,
-0.0034920466,
0.04505454,
0.0224399697,
0.0047840616,
0.0315270834,
0.0004737546,
0.0102875996,
0.0500986986,
0.0668438077,
-0.0241059698,
-0.0035821951,
-0.0524982773,
0.0015898616,
-0.0112857372,
-0.0289539304,
0.0478907339,
-0.0247734524,
0.0367123149,
-0.0346091017,
0.0003969163,
-0.0453687049,
0.0468424223,
-0.0194438174,
0.0517240316,
0.0015128095,
0.0143320905,
-0.0505301394,
0.0026226423,
0.0737864301,
0.0533543006,
0.0672275573,
-0.0629846901,
-0.0498034395,
-0.0149901975,
-0.0199439693,
0.0370091163,
0.0357795469,
-0.0538660325,
-0.008963557,
-0.0717018992,
-0.0271458309,
0.0315624774,
-0.0165935867,
0.0016205981,
0.0180305447,
0.0186595377,
0.000813628,
0.0057948427,
-0.0162241738,
-0.042502515,
0.012307643,
-0.0384131074,
-0.0602872968,
-0.0122998767,
-5.570668463e-33,
0.0113384807,
-0.0415716954,
0.0014058478,
-0.0012311626,
0.0517345704,
0.0085895685,
-0.0685130581,
-0.0026658676,
0.0505049899,
0.0388101414,
0.0128126396,
0.0398486182,
-0.0157510731,
0.0144538889,
0.0037532186,
-0.0337237194,
0.0164979585,
0.0247261524,
0.0129617313,
-0.0297787171,
0.021072479,
0.0673548281,
-0.0117957247,
-0.0447519533,
0.0397658944,
0.0330822915,
0.0056499261,
0.012592528,
-0.0522752181,
0.045758795,
0.0126269851,
0.0332488343,
0.0095286947,
-0.0221188702,
0.0360056609,
-0.0415056646,
-0.013628467,
0.0327219479,
0.0273758434,
0.0098711308,
-0.003603759,
-0.0176052134,
0.0288075134,
-0.006644432,
-0.0568156056,
0.0277378391,
0.0438932255,
-0.0307823643,
-0.0245043132,
-0.0138649866,
-0.0069064857,
0.0293801166,
-0.0556788221,
0.0463005416,
0.0126153687,
-0.0819474831,
-0.033406131,
0.0390846767,
0.0356461555,
0.0368174091,
0.0380321741,
0.0332802013,
0.00536216,
-0.0126182446,
0.0293748677,
0.0453205965,
0.0024189143,
-0.0013720122,
-0.0049575516,
0.0244209282,
0.0020492966,
0.0223919284,
0.0396772772,
0.0509657152,
0.0183260627,
0.0173823014,
-0.1235559732,
0.0418362208,
-0.036314074,
-0.0111508742,
0.0262534935,
-0.0060804063,
-0.0527743287,
0.0041340934,
-0.0379000157,
0.0191236641,
-0.0268560182,
0.0060395706,
0.0082597397,
-0.0487560816,
-0.0110944863,
0.0473799482,
0.0160363074,
-0.0572605953,
-0.0183479879,
0.0346121341,
0.0140916631,
-0.0216309074,
-0.0131489728,
-0.0034649393,
-0.0092319576,
-0.0279022828,
-0.0089542242,
-0.0366836824,
0.0644160584,
0.0002806103,
0.0174635183,
-0.024820298,
-0.034401685,
-0.0102730086,
-0.0068391073,
-0.0300639123,
-0.019566888,
-0.0365437604,
0.0077624973,
0.0475293733,
0.021704426,
0.0794455856,
0.0843113586,
0.030371489,
0.0277550276,
-0.0314457342,
0.0099235261,
-0.0226043351,
-0.0286909398,
-0.027338108,
0.0107007464,
0.0356384106,
0.0359481983,
-0.0646880344,
-0.0105948839,
0.0394094065,
2.879e-7,
0.1132712737,
0.082821466,
-0.0141274715,
-0.0213865563,
0.0328582898,
-0.0001054354,
0.0067823813,
-0.0060576755,
-0.0368895046,
0.0344147421,
0.0737275034,
-0.013809138,
0.0625034422,
-0.0279551875,
-0.0069929534,
0.012925094,
-0.0566013679,
-0.003568124,
-0.0179350637,
0.0043992661,
0.0368343815,
0.0448706299,
0.0151774548,
0.0025086377,
0.035884507,
0.0042758086,
0.0144822113,
-0.0605045818,
0.0284830332,
0.0077207112,
-0.0236572884,
-0.038965866,
0.0180575401,
0.0558960289,
-0.0062252027,
-0.009008701,
-0.001383223,
0.0431411564,
-0.0236609224,
0.074450694,
0.0212721284,
-0.0000505938,
0.0276056249,
-0.0341729261,
0.0516405851,
-0.0043453397,
-0.0694192797,
0.0279999729,
0.0301278662,
-0.0037113559,
0.049566377,
-0.0005461491,
-0.0236085262,
0.0476551913,
0.0210535377,
0.0406401493,
-0.0050035724,
-0.0230663866,
0.0001934257,
0.0695563108,
-0.0334593207,
-0.0342073441,
0.0197668951,
0.0270764008,
0.0622105598,
-0.0455016196,
0.0265960712,
2.518980161e-34,
0.0155293886,
0.0358015932,
-0.0045963121,
0.0040660794,
0.049607411,
0.0044896589,
-0.0064812289,
0.0278602168,
-0.0152401291,
-0.077198863,
0.0265469737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17760v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17760v6 | Language Models are Bounded Pragmatic Speakers: Understanding RLHF from a Bayesian Cognitive Modeling Perspective | 2023-05-28T16:04:48 | 2024-01-01T21:06:57 | Khanh Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | How do language models "think"? This paper formulates a probabilistic
cognitive model called the bounded pragmatic speaker, which can characterize
the operation of different variations of language models. Specifically, we
demonstrate that large language models fine-tuned with reinforcement learning
from human feedback (Ouyang et al., 2022) embody a model of thought that
conceptually resembles a fast-and-slow model (Kahneman, 2011), which
psychologists have attributed to humans. We discuss the limitations of
reinforcement learning from human feedback as a fast-and-slow model of thought
and propose avenues for expanding this framework. In essence, our research
highlights the value of adopting a cognitive probabilistic modeling approach to
gain insights into the comprehension, evaluation, and advancement of language
models. | [
0.0703497604,
0.0629430711,
-0.0369098783,
-0.0022687288,
-0.059302628,
0.0022378122,
-0.0269174576,
-0.0039538429,
-0.0123751471,
-0.0327862687,
-0.0280685965,
-0.0612551421,
0.0005684875,
0.0123219863,
0.0248318072,
-0.0879836753,
0.0369495153,
-0.0740911514,
0.0928437039,
-0.0174363758,
-0.0051013851,
-0.0289672576,
-0.02871144,
0.0505703092,
0.0298555493,
-0.0081228195,
-0.0037395579,
-0.0335819498,
-0.0212558899,
0.0163145978,
-0.0127842976,
0.0528361984,
-0.0083835898,
0.032298062,
0.0000016769,
-0.039574571,
0.0374586098,
-0.0455739424,
0.023114102,
0.010268691,
0.0638723969,
0.014803024,
-0.0361283422,
0.0053187506,
-0.0362536833,
-0.0319300219,
0.0151531352,
0.035722658,
-0.0035196187,
0.0688966811,
0.0197735243,
-0.0000975304,
0.0470172912,
-0.0372993313,
0.0374697447,
-0.0521538071,
0.0362650901,
0.0239178408,
0.0558718964,
-0.0175825339,
-0.0698178858,
0.029984381,
0.0145609537,
0.008902953,
-0.0073705488,
0.0189651512,
0.0303759985,
-0.0410991833,
-0.0271093491,
0.0328142233,
-0.0089328401,
-0.0240331031,
-0.0013861371,
-0.0098145148,
0.0007243936,
0.0481043719,
-0.0356454775,
0.0602715015,
-0.0022548037,
0.0124104246,
0.0214213263,
-0.031393446,
0.0326466896,
0.0101957731,
0.0181776267,
0.0922769979,
-0.01076137,
-0.0286960099,
0.0045004231,
0.0317673497,
-0.0098899798,
-0.0656032935,
-0.0325723998,
0.0235920809,
-0.0190292615,
0.0302513409,
-0.028148938,
0.0129143549,
0.0150345154,
-0.032588806,
0.0215980131,
0.022375172,
0.0328355208,
0.0239734054,
0.0255931895,
0.0203254614,
-0.0369783342,
0.008415238,
-0.0080647748,
0.0439746827,
-0.0543350354,
-0.0291169882,
-0.0164530147,
0.0336984359,
0.0374776199,
-0.0135729304,
-0.051307831,
0.0241448618,
-0.0394050814,
-0.0035249873,
-0.0158511661,
-0.0267515481,
-0.03224786,
0.0095734363,
-0.1173492596,
0.0284365732,
-0.0405696519,
0.0212742779,
0.0112598855,
-0.0348178297,
0.0066565215,
0.0009658392,
-0.0074845143,
-0.0202352535,
-0.0314111859,
0.0423407666,
-0.0046644621,
-0.0022563566,
-0.0112107471,
-0.0454016067,
-0.0296056364,
-0.0539649539,
0.0003755837,
-0.0569639429,
-0.020973023,
0.0095746592,
0.008068352,
-0.0743706971,
-0.019711243,
0.0048607504,
-0.0481121466,
0.0570718423,
0.0092581511,
0.037279401,
0.0418012179,
0.0002180026,
0.0005487445,
0.0642150268,
0.0418400578,
-0.0391111337,
-0.0114769051,
-0.0089878682,
0.025078848,
0.0511768237,
0.0142941726,
-0.0026251213,
-0.0606237426,
-0.0228870641,
0.0298858769,
0.0333604068,
0.0756082088,
0.0497024804,
-0.0270079859,
0.0110281268,
0.0437611155,
0.0246030837,
-0.0115690222,
0.00454007,
0.0690242276,
0.0291309953,
0.0191104319,
0.0404432788,
-0.017940281,
0.0114825163,
-0.0084241033,
0.0221850164,
0.0094553549,
-0.0206344351,
-0.0212469995,
-0.0337139331,
0.0146145457,
-0.0043210755,
0.0420149677,
0.0302345585,
0.0631402731,
0.028276721,
-0.0083183395,
0.0253805146,
0.0388619117,
-0.0006770462,
-0.0170744304,
-0.0487759188,
0.0423953794,
0.0569613427,
0.0476493277,
-0.0057355198,
0.0347641408,
0.0031074889,
-0.0130231027,
0.077961646,
0.0670180991,
0.0013021205,
-0.06677448,
0.0019711938,
0.0077235769,
0.0038608706,
0.0193246044,
0.0063498225,
-0.0227055736,
0.0177661311,
-0.0286075212,
0.0441934466,
-0.0263189916,
0.0143443523,
-0.0189461336,
0.0341376364,
-0.0557003133,
-0.0033551431,
0.0275279433,
-0.0265247524,
-0.0258348789,
0.0551202595,
0.0092942407,
0.0007212859,
-0.0001978523,
0.0498199761,
-0.0357437804,
-0.0159952212,
0.0275086462,
0.0044637062,
0.0168078002,
-0.0243599899,
0.0330795683,
-0.0311715212,
0.0717493817,
-0.0250453502,
0.0523742698,
-0.0102724731,
0.0406105556,
-0.0336822569,
-0.0120683545,
-0.0208157878,
0.067919232,
-0.0101622231,
0.0360728949,
0.010964633,
0.0058387695,
-0.0127480412,
-0.0812685862,
-0.0094259558,
0.0233020186,
0.0040017436,
0.0101553034,
0.0320306607,
-0.017116528,
-0.0386238769,
-0.0342552066,
-0.0347786509,
-0.0639226735,
0.0093521085,
-0.0120087676,
-0.0086840112,
-0.0174459647,
-0.0106011797,
-0.0016313145,
-0.0283066165,
-0.0245159809,
0.0192627888,
0.0301536154,
-0.0016415972,
0.0056047346,
-0.0371499136,
-0.0506397001,
-0.0096266679,
-0.0151117789,
-0.0026931001,
0.0173355304,
-0.0126080057,
-0.0264656637,
0.0195676386,
-0.0322732031,
0.0374957062,
-0.0114317769,
-0.037356656,
0.0454657897,
-0.0082410732,
0.0589023829,
0.0716922507,
0.0110924132,
0.0439533554,
0.0506731085,
-0.0121863512,
-0.0364563093,
0.0263918228,
-0.0453074127,
-0.0294349156,
-0.0449149944,
-0.0199098811,
-0.0434458293,
0.0888937637,
0.0175033901,
0.017588241,
-0.091419518,
0.0547954328,
-0.022815641,
-0.0848087147,
-0.0206919275,
-0.006218459,
-0.0354505442,
0.0494191535,
-0.0351296365,
-0.0378953405,
0.0846578553,
0.0299680158,
0.0253199637,
-0.0088414839,
0.0165986773,
0.0065557137,
0.0096914778,
0.0467489548,
-0.0001852864,
0.0210193284,
0.0080506038,
-0.0691629648,
-0.0112135019,
0.0122442292,
-0.0404114909,
0.0198368654,
-0.052900549,
0.015432585,
0.0313129351,
-0.0474450998,
-0.0398565345,
-0.0298853535,
-0.0696955994,
-0.001313411,
0.0178656578,
-0.0263340902,
-0.0127530899,
0.0270177796,
0.0454971455,
-0.0053449864,
-0.0131848352,
-0.0231232662,
-0.008753784,
-0.0154390987,
0.0829004049,
-0.0107540302,
0.0064952332,
-0.0334121101,
0.0250118952,
0.0309066493,
0.0677631497,
0.0601573512,
0.0000719749,
0.011569432,
0.0180895701,
0.0007356958,
-0.0282303225,
0.057064563,
0.048764281,
-0.0151176248,
-0.0497163013,
0.0955454037,
0.0221584458,
-0.039113041,
0.0293731038,
-0.0360007137,
0.0511948839,
0.0057719564,
0.0202398114,
-0.0483125672,
-0.0236114338,
0.0054028179,
0.00925167,
-0.0665902868,
-0.050767079,
0.0108190933,
-0.1073307842,
-0.0142899193,
0.0124359597,
-0.0191077702,
0.0081573501,
-0.0080294991,
-0.0156315528,
0.0281674825,
-0.0316376127,
0.0268596131,
-0.0215656869,
0.0349101089,
0.0131562948,
-0.0295049362,
-0.0386637636,
0.0352717564,
-0.0276384186,
0.0746038258,
0.0546085052,
-0.0037660173,
-0.001699945,
-0.0670432597,
-0.0109261349,
0.0059142518,
0.0005654772,
0.0017755342,
-0.0123179182,
-0.0112128202,
-0.0110788047,
-0.0250793938,
0.0313038677,
-0.0272001922,
-0.0036845189,
0.0209005009,
0.1003360003,
-0.0374949761,
-0.0214075539,
-0.0303835738,
0.050581608,
0.0323986337,
0.072215125,
0.0390736572,
-0.1039517596,
-0.033440344,
-0.0322186761,
-0.0283485949,
0.0025673464,
-0.0742665753,
-0.0044431644,
0.0575755127,
-0.006833836,
-0.0678426027,
-0.0455676913,
-0.0200850088,
0.0144668957,
0.025301598,
0.0271053221,
0.038457904,
0.0144202942,
-0.0262355376,
0.0080151754,
-0.0187227689,
0.0162296575,
-0.0951549634,
-0.0289335456,
0.00756054,
-0.0575127527,
-0.017198829,
0.0057924776,
-0.0732953623,
-0.0810863525,
-0.002639137,
0.022729259,
0.0342011638,
0.0049437392,
-0.0225970428,
-0.1026118174,
-0.0297926683,
-0.0225478671,
-0.044105269,
0.0856209919,
0.0096076233,
0.0242802016,
0.0131440619,
0.0568576418,
-0.0193376392,
0.0070477091,
-0.0010556742,
0.0403426662,
-0.0347713195,
-0.0482028276,
0.0344454125,
-0.003059563,
0.0177197773,
-0.0097931242,
-0.0170265473,
-0.009266505,
-0.0421181247,
-0.0141057707,
-0.0250005256,
-0.0189887621,
-0.0202228948,
0.0306886565,
0.0204454418,
-0.0108033968,
-0.0371312536,
-0.0049536945,
0.0452608094,
0.0219746083,
-0.0206420701,
0.0230433848,
-0.0021049571,
0.0114399558,
0.0024891826,
0.033822529,
0.0102711534,
-0.047143992,
0.042882394,
0.0490177087,
0.0950712338,
0.0366725102,
-0.0088067874,
-0.0018979076,
-0.0559475198,
-0.0552966781,
-0.0850022882,
0.0587541461,
0.0515927896,
0.0487960763,
0.0278718192,
0.0319053605,
-0.0686988011,
0.0031468072,
-0.0268154778,
0.0199027471,
0.014307078,
-0.0337946601,
0.0594488606,
0.0256521273,
-0.0168635771,
-0.0297786426,
0.0654293075,
0.0397504717,
0.0304237138,
-0.0192038827,
0.0042954884,
-0.0185367372,
-0.0195342749,
-0.0155523429,
0.0212805513,
0.0034155212,
0.035402,
-0.0803793445,
-0.0480127372,
-0.0018160478,
0.0428826213,
-0.0077712922,
-0.0671913847,
0.0256779511,
0.0391851962,
-0.0335256308,
-0.0310605168,
-0.0746710375,
0.0331801362,
-0.0335034505,
-0.0019872668,
-0.0271932837,
-5.832459504e-33,
-0.0312631205,
-0.0453051254,
0.0239190478,
-0.0133619001,
-0.0185133982,
-0.0479548387,
-0.0127569819,
0.0501814149,
-0.02530149,
0.0259452928,
-0.0150518753,
0.0236996394,
0.0073811617,
0.0137581611,
0.0317918807,
0.0045342725,
0.0151520018,
-0.0343882553,
-0.0179738607,
-0.0083767353,
0.0356081277,
-0.0094509227,
0.0088764066,
-0.0184560809,
0.0414486155,
-0.0029687756,
-0.0139039587,
0.0283003729,
-0.0142926704,
0.0744930431,
-0.0272532459,
0.041576311,
0.0217933282,
-0.0356982127,
-0.0141157573,
0.0440770984,
-0.0347077027,
-0.027191136,
0.0459670462,
0.0210026763,
-0.039538268,
-0.0171399303,
0.0333253667,
-0.0027334418,
-0.0492032394,
0.0420610979,
0.021297114,
-0.0285445973,
-0.0209644232,
0.0256501213,
-0.0426799171,
0.0085987141,
-0.0028651571,
-0.0028666987,
0.0168804564,
0.0002616428,
-0.0515654273,
0.0140417218,
-0.0498871133,
0.0303396136,
0.0278820638,
0.0388898998,
0.0652579591,
0.0458500758,
0.0444854498,
0.0397607423,
0.0283978414,
0.0195487533,
-0.0029345518,
0.0108804004,
0.0569468066,
0.0206843615,
0.0127317403,
0.0180421546,
-0.0046953452,
-0.0190733857,
-0.0146099571,
-0.0475079902,
0.0642850175,
0.0461506099,
0.0392427817,
0.0078431321,
-0.0795374736,
-0.0400404669,
-0.0642053261,
-0.0057824766,
-0.0083069094,
-0.0355818197,
0.0118780937,
0.0107057029,
0.0139290653,
-0.0468741134,
0.0129671423,
-0.0272519309,
-0.0428479537,
-0.0010287957,
-0.0770308897,
0.0510993712,
-0.0053288434,
0.0198436677,
-0.1001449972,
0.0054819915,
-0.0237811971,
0.0152173908,
-0.0352335311,
0.0351964831,
-0.012829381,
0.0214219429,
-0.0360941067,
-0.0165942237,
-0.0290885046,
0.0353207104,
0.0097248722,
-0.005795456,
0.070275709,
0.0019846689,
-0.0137981661,
0.0135421809,
-0.0067349761,
-0.0588846207,
-0.0004912453,
0.0353195183,
-0.0214063283,
0.0316284075,
-0.0269944817,
-0.0083300276,
-0.0349097475,
0.0448301211,
0.0226808228,
-0.0642930791,
0.0025546744,
0.0336257145,
2.45e-7,
0.0134923933,
0.0325401612,
-0.0105562434,
0.032071203,
0.0649793521,
0.0438465662,
-0.0224277284,
0.0069364621,
0.0369571932,
-0.0265685115,
-0.0125685176,
0.0386096202,
0.040639136,
-0.0359326936,
-0.0547164343,
-0.0135434642,
-0.0698846132,
0.0428696387,
-0.0138184987,
-0.0292094406,
0.0015246149,
0.0539030731,
0.0187327377,
0.0015722931,
0.0038305682,
0.0043783407,
0.0810130686,
-0.0376611799,
0.0022962615,
0.0210373215,
0.0042734612,
0.0123763112,
0.004124382,
0.0346548036,
0.0207990054,
0.027239671,
-0.0117586395,
0.0467094146,
0.0265951063,
-0.0255982913,
-0.0228307899,
-0.0084313424,
-0.0330023877,
-0.0495236069,
0.0529632308,
-0.0914123133,
-0.0527305007,
0.0127687966,
0.0342265405,
-0.0006103229,
-0.0062407837,
-0.0037836696,
-0.035912551,
-0.0130678397,
0.0213109069,
-0.0027055936,
0.0137185324,
-0.0351493955,
-0.0120980423,
0.0115981903,
-0.0410269722,
-0.049001839,
-0.0710569248,
-0.018752316,
-0.026530182,
-0.0604268909,
0.0016806975,
2.000607356e-34,
0.0515179634,
-0.0039561596,
0.0219187383,
-0.0337248072,
0.0176221058,
0.0084750541,
0.0173642412,
0.0412238613,
0.0673270077,
-0.0685264021,
-0.0120689869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.19148v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.19148v3 | Mitigating Label Biases for In-context Learning | 2023-05-28T15:37:39 | 2023-08-04T15:43:19 | Yu Fei, Yifan Hou, Zeming Chen, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Various design settings for in-context learning (ICL), such as the choice and
order of the in-context examples, can bias a model toward a particular
prediction without being reflective of an understanding of the task. While many
studies discuss these design choices, there have been few systematic
investigations into categorizing them and mitigating their impact. In this
work, we define a typology for three types of label biases in ICL for text
classification: vanilla-label bias, context-label bias, and domain-label bias
(which we conceptualize and detect for the first time).
Our analysis demonstrates that prior label bias calibration methods fall
short of addressing all three types of biases. Specifically, domain-label bias
restricts LLMs to random-level performance on many tasks regardless of the
choice of in-context examples. To mitigate the effect of these biases, we
propose a simple bias calibration method that estimates a language model's
label bias using random in-domain words from the task corpus. After controlling
for this estimated bias when making predictions, our novel domain-context
calibration significantly improves the ICL performance of GPT-J and GPT-3 on a
wide range of tasks. The gain is substantial on tasks with large domain-label
bias (up to 37% in Macro-F1). Furthermore, our results generalize to models
with different scales, pretraining methods, and manually-designed task
instructions, showing the prevalence of label biases in ICL. | [
0.0174313113,
-0.0124088274,
0.0011661522,
0.0531036966,
-0.0114250705,
0.0321919471,
0.0459814668,
-0.0126822982,
0.0302871726,
-0.066277869,
-0.0695154816,
-0.0359870195,
-0.0054053818,
-0.0114043821,
0.0100028031,
-0.042937953,
0.0159298684,
0.003639238,
0.0236986894,
0.0167942215,
0.0016008135,
0.0076279081,
-0.0027287458,
0.0229886062,
-0.0239788145,
-0.047512807,
0.0203695763,
0.0426845513,
0.0225339495,
-0.0526658408,
0.0710525513,
0.0420624465,
0.0077147214,
0.0200180039,
0.0000020712,
-0.0452038273,
-0.0369712152,
-0.0021240264,
-0.0290856622,
-0.0105159553,
0.0723184496,
0.0047046873,
-0.0047750012,
0.0252155326,
-0.030628508,
-0.0108687636,
0.0488285832,
0.0740125328,
-0.0185139179,
0.070954904,
-0.027799448,
-0.0170176905,
-0.0234933607,
-0.0361418612,
0.0429652594,
-0.0929794237,
0.0144218523,
-0.053445816,
-0.0501968972,
0.0474669039,
-0.0018212753,
0.0089674145,
0.0158638228,
0.0508521833,
0.0396918841,
0.0266142078,
-0.0084461421,
-0.0081795445,
-0.0074243341,
0.0542864129,
-0.0054590506,
-0.0299314652,
-0.0225037951,
-0.0466241986,
0.0532795228,
-0.0145577043,
-0.0258245859,
0.0154350856,
-0.0095150052,
0.0219459943,
0.0135162603,
0.0520521216,
0.0508650802,
-0.0021252437,
0.0196511373,
0.0608451664,
-0.0003474621,
-0.0354513861,
0.0288073365,
0.0469128527,
-0.0168848466,
-0.0350873172,
-0.0178289544,
-0.0082426453,
-0.044011686,
0.0336245336,
-0.0625966638,
-0.0164964255,
0.0109208701,
-0.0428006947,
0.0072702947,
0.0046698875,
-0.0473622158,
0.0251635984,
0.0134887286,
0.0147764767,
-0.0064054085,
0.008567553,
-0.0427237116,
-0.0258153006,
-0.034691181,
0.0150682647,
-0.01329289,
0.0088439975,
0.0007904915,
0.0161104482,
-0.0633264333,
0.0513663851,
-0.0092302654,
-0.0242730193,
0.0056554703,
0.0042538587,
-0.0457075872,
0.010349228,
-0.0257286746,
0.0139009701,
-0.0065539978,
0.0442740396,
-0.0177643523,
-0.0361554734,
-0.0191395115,
0.0200041365,
-0.0178274047,
-0.0782835037,
0.0219991449,
0.0827597454,
0.0057981643,
-0.0837176442,
-0.0396957286,
-0.0125714941,
-0.0354705751,
-0.0495004468,
0.0176789705,
-0.0129130287,
-0.0198580902,
0.0306778494,
0.0059618857,
-0.0394086763,
-0.0204415638,
0.0112248622,
-0.0280161146,
0.0817164928,
0.0264693573,
-0.0367982127,
0.0333007462,
0.029888114,
-0.0187479183,
0.0889746398,
-0.0078855129,
0.0176060684,
0.0337430947,
0.0275633298,
0.02176084,
0.0354766026,
0.0289110374,
0.0151664503,
0.0037465871,
0.0073661427,
0.0515091904,
-0.0026511853,
0.0421967916,
-0.0154003976,
0.0027960849,
0.0267145652,
0.0686046928,
0.018099295,
-0.0020657079,
-0.0021429504,
-0.0329260156,
-0.0098523591,
-0.0047105527,
-0.0100668408,
-0.0688896105,
0.0098858764,
-0.0195113178,
-0.0104389135,
0.0243239906,
-0.0104153631,
-0.0307186861,
-0.035288047,
-0.0204784386,
-0.0048990054,
-0.0121804783,
0.0103068789,
0.0391148031,
0.0252472218,
-0.0338984989,
0.0477824844,
0.0162208732,
-0.0160818938,
-0.0076723117,
-0.0249704272,
-0.0296745151,
0.0070636971,
0.0082036173,
-0.0659800395,
-0.0221042614,
-0.0003060666,
0.0547475927,
0.0389884673,
0.0459415279,
-0.0235028416,
0.0144540546,
-0.0311982632,
-0.0747375935,
-0.009542902,
0.027655948,
-0.0051143123,
0.0378097817,
0.0320991687,
0.0395176522,
-0.1074932888,
-0.0065802694,
0.0448095426,
-0.0061734109,
-0.095561713,
0.0262220819,
0.0230531488,
0.0476061814,
-0.0049003996,
0.0051005287,
-0.0142086567,
0.0124823153,
0.0030473794,
0.0153506473,
-0.0195470341,
-0.0634239018,
-0.0469233543,
0.0243390277,
-0.0238155294,
-0.0283851083,
-0.0033572733,
-0.0818095356,
-0.0177374985,
-0.0166646782,
-0.0048317485,
0.0135884546,
-0.0225258097,
-0.0096127037,
-0.0278098583,
-0.0093349218,
-0.0671525002,
0.0649626553,
0.0322945341,
0.0007014417,
0.0100373859,
0.0271334127,
0.022305252,
0.0176437367,
-0.0095413942,
-0.0248553269,
0.0070290808,
0.009213319,
0.0194051303,
0.0105088791,
-0.048133485,
-0.0176944342,
-0.0947209522,
-0.0085866116,
-0.0329122022,
0.0132131288,
0.0041353572,
0.0209622905,
-0.0166931991,
-0.0465522334,
-0.0379437096,
-0.0413188189,
-0.038818337,
0.0402238891,
0.0184017774,
-0.0161250699,
0.0227634888,
-0.0170038603,
0.0150360782,
-0.0173226837,
0.0446606576,
0.0215007551,
-0.0018076721,
-0.0704890564,
0.0430460721,
0.0036319005,
0.0076212352,
-0.0134917516,
0.0371714085,
-0.0023699135,
0.0076424605,
0.0135835037,
0.048948437,
-0.0124786897,
0.0148020815,
0.0398154706,
0.0252921339,
-0.0475319661,
0.002890313,
-0.0059741107,
-0.0424223319,
-0.0190280676,
-0.0041188844,
0.0181167815,
0.0689416304,
-0.0026240153,
-0.0130750788,
-0.0366703123,
0.0142234163,
-0.0211898722,
0.0178099759,
-0.0420451313,
-0.0040941085,
-0.0306917578,
0.0250882562,
-0.0092315618,
-0.0733792186,
0.0505146421,
0.0051493817,
0.0056453925,
-0.0924008861,
-0.0125334729,
-0.0208681114,
0.0428142287,
-0.0149647361,
-0.0051819454,
0.0854107812,
-0.0207043439,
-0.0914098099,
0.0012633529,
0.0429068878,
-0.0072937231,
0.0536152273,
-0.0175406318,
0.0276244152,
-0.0265495367,
-0.0455376543,
-0.0596791282,
-0.0360541865,
-0.0228045788,
0.0087832203,
-0.0268405471,
0.0312316567,
-0.0265938714,
-0.0365917869,
0.0052039321,
0.0309897996,
-0.0205362495,
-0.034475144,
0.0191580951,
0.0397599526,
0.0239498876,
-0.0280720722,
-0.0047776704,
-0.022461338,
-0.0289026126,
0.0176992454,
0.0462554283,
-0.0035906341,
-0.002235804,
0.0174048133,
0.042188026,
-0.0284368228,
-0.0058045187,
0.0487375632,
0.0564001463,
-0.015023753,
-0.0334303565,
0.1252509654,
0.0163106043,
-0.1140210778,
-0.0122706322,
0.0211484767,
0.0239924975,
0.0394159406,
-0.0058148415,
-0.0513114184,
-0.0576765761,
0.0061305356,
0.0162354223,
0.0068152831,
0.0027436498,
0.0066350419,
-0.0980110988,
0.0035812713,
0.0097167986,
-0.0381615646,
-0.0254050288,
-0.0461740345,
0.0022814851,
-0.0242405701,
0.0358568877,
-0.0309360083,
-0.0111281779,
0.0065893526,
0.0521672554,
0.003878135,
-0.0834201798,
0.0260116719,
-0.0223980621,
0.0338119455,
0.0701112151,
0.0114635574,
-0.0233141016,
0.0013455577,
0.1032684073,
-0.0200499929,
-0.0103554688,
-0.0060768491,
0.0608885214,
-0.0274126753,
0.0078187799,
-0.0091957059,
0.0049218093,
-0.0630832165,
-0.015219965,
0.0144104036,
0.0789965391,
0.0017056421,
0.0034242806,
-0.0293091554,
-0.0563127585,
0.0472009741,
0.0711516663,
0.0105043612,
-0.0530689843,
-0.0272454955,
-0.0234920662,
0.0073996414,
-0.0043696812,
-0.0070725055,
0.019047372,
-0.037861865,
-0.0198292919,
-0.0215058848,
-0.0528331995,
-0.0137123046,
0.0201417617,
-0.0042683301,
0.0089106532,
-0.0314429626,
0.0051746001,
-0.0431776382,
0.0298704877,
-0.0257361252,
0.0302416589,
-0.0301376916,
0.0009397332,
0.0409435108,
-0.0368019827,
-0.030641757,
0.0589710213,
-0.0741512626,
-0.0565198995,
0.0018478275,
0.0057635061,
0.011712159,
0.0717299804,
-0.0035810494,
-0.0389021225,
0.0786906481,
0.0583157726,
-0.0007678078,
0.025798738,
0.0279100761,
0.0034264484,
-0.0082534961,
0.0192486551,
-0.0686395615,
0.026761679,
0.0609446913,
-0.0081858123,
-0.0156729594,
-0.0297005996,
-0.0125167323,
-0.0508094057,
0.1057864353,
-0.0414713994,
-0.0178046767,
-0.0152114453,
0.0233700685,
0.0275852624,
-0.0485378988,
0.0043468946,
-0.0099039106,
0.0412717238,
-0.0070987027,
-0.0403726101,
0.0527682304,
-0.0179806836,
0.0555754639,
-0.0049942508,
-0.0052168602,
-0.0021648426,
0.0434491411,
0.0075936238,
0.0349102728,
-0.0179398209,
-0.0107162874,
0.0436820127,
0.0444059148,
0.0135093238,
0.0534792021,
0.0349074267,
0.0228465181,
-0.0161493104,
0.0147919152,
-0.0757257193,
0.0495369434,
-0.0565933324,
-0.0312981866,
0.0476140417,
-0.0511620864,
0.0181967318,
-0.0110585159,
-0.0146779604,
-0.0346505158,
0.0078377584,
0.004436933,
0.0111642815,
0.0259289071,
0.002410938,
-0.0240289476,
0.0100215767,
0.0667559505,
0.0718960762,
0.0166342258,
0.009292678,
-0.0212174673,
-0.0143289883,
0.0044989968,
0.0197643489,
0.0206698664,
-0.0029561869,
-0.0199876335,
-0.0495887361,
-0.0691104829,
0.0467934795,
-0.0473243296,
0.012624504,
-0.0100048399,
0.0432617143,
0.0613543093,
-0.0318355672,
-0.0423902981,
0.0039458121,
-0.0165569931,
-0.0011363561,
-0.0264868122,
-0.0544769093,
-6.092614771e-33,
-0.0277275462,
-0.0264785737,
-0.0097049084,
0.0161494054,
-0.0012587608,
0.010916844,
-0.0154913012,
0.0120067811,
-0.013402421,
0.005445654,
-0.0051611052,
0.0253084935,
0.0266449004,
0.0306563731,
0.0101940231,
-0.054474581,
0.0393379703,
-0.0206239242,
-0.0261931699,
0.0204248317,
-0.0163366105,
0.0247478969,
0.0656543449,
-0.1147285476,
0.0711926445,
-0.0142332949,
0.0068557812,
-0.0133323902,
0.0280226432,
0.0466179885,
-0.0241691936,
0.0774300247,
0.0447224863,
-0.0486656912,
-0.0075199143,
0.0403474309,
-0.0561355129,
-0.0532834232,
-0.0217905566,
0.028177632,
0.0362298377,
-0.0271544009,
0.0321564041,
0.0409007296,
-0.0605338104,
-0.0285137147,
0.0743800998,
-0.0096280649,
-0.0305346958,
-0.0277913939,
-0.0500578247,
0.0057912511,
0.0304215625,
0.0117814271,
0.0168143101,
0.0198573805,
0.0401068777,
0.0454088338,
-0.0650221035,
-0.0219794661,
-0.0339978449,
0.0098787332,
0.0192103758,
0.0660659149,
-0.0233120397,
0.0452903248,
0.0228764564,
0.0593021326,
-0.0146058835,
-0.0682568848,
0.0178117882,
-0.0189525634,
0.015972564,
0.077567704,
0.0677195489,
0.0071748099,
-0.0980886891,
0.0441485345,
-0.0302674994,
-0.0277182832,
0.0280199312,
0.0084500182,
-0.0517627299,
-0.0436308607,
-0.0415993221,
-0.0145431999,
-0.0466160253,
0.0082167806,
0.0469060205,
0.0180830862,
0.0457975902,
0.0102137905,
0.0016318142,
-0.0380332544,
-0.049413152,
8.226e-7,
-0.0009508631,
0.0041444483,
0.0030462947,
-0.0045171473,
-0.0486752577,
-0.0145957079,
0.0021700424,
0.0602438264,
0.020011751,
-0.0311130714,
0.0639083982,
-0.0082484335,
-0.0716129392,
-0.0098889554,
-0.0333116949,
0.0016808485,
0.0268879645,
0.0770135596,
0.0106731439,
-0.0092932852,
0.0071036704,
0.061936453,
0.0390204974,
-0.0424328968,
0.0033072163,
-0.0105411205,
-0.0190730803,
0.0027565723,
-0.0138154058,
-0.0271861032,
0.007432099,
0.0183707811,
0.0514268614,
-0.0526845604,
-0.0087820757,
-0.0184697974,
2.653e-7,
0.0430465825,
0.0394927673,
-0.0021889573,
-0.010461471,
0.0286412928,
0.0849484801,
-0.0042796703,
0.0453105085,
0.0168092735,
-0.01591851,
0.004263917,
0.0058899769,
0.0503049195,
0.0236444343,
-0.082118392,
0.0081487019,
-0.0097472761,
0.0600669906,
-0.0072837071,
0.0285182204,
0.0271534491,
0.0608836487,
0.0216345508,
-0.0249598064,
-0.0067978217,
-0.0209160727,
0.0696593523,
-0.0497153066,
0.0572954714,
0.0157429352,
-0.0357958376,
0.0364636034,
0.0150270499,
0.0436811857,
-0.0351764299,
-0.0047062528,
0.0122255478,
0.0440750681,
-0.0166465323,
-0.0488830693,
-0.0388848819,
0.0200092737,
0.0235377233,
-0.0551372282,
0.048173029,
-0.0549079701,
0.0033501789,
-0.0154470038,
-0.0109613566,
-0.0243037287,
0.0371275954,
0.0274645872,
-0.0093565704,
0.0076026684,
0.0120161166,
0.0151957301,
-0.0327608176,
-0.1033164784,
-0.042949345,
0.036265038,
-0.0311671067,
-0.0208824128,
-0.0106427716,
0.0436350256,
0.0544223785,
-0.0438379906,
0.0223994851,
2.262464334e-34,
-0.0196877997,
-0.0221023243,
0.0337570123,
0.0121393949,
-0.0289870221,
0.002791011,
-0.0161833037,
-0.014342689,
0.0373687632,
-0.0323466472,
0.0220118295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.18404v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.18404v3 | Conformal Prediction with Large Language Models for Multi-Choice Question Answering | 2023-05-28T15:26:10 | 2023-07-08T02:20:29 | Bhawesh Kumar, Charlie Lu, Gauri Gupta, Anil Palepu, David Bellamy, Ramesh Raskar, Andrew Beam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | As large language models continue to be widely developed, robust uncertainty
quantification techniques will become crucial for their safe deployment in
high-stakes scenarios. In this work, we explore how conformal prediction can be
used to provide uncertainty quantification in language models for the specific
task of multiple-choice question-answering. We find that the uncertainty
estimates from conformal prediction are tightly correlated with prediction
accuracy. This observation can be useful for downstream applications such as
selective classification and filtering out low-quality predictions. We also
investigate the exchangeability assumption required by conformal prediction to
out-of-subject questions, which may be a more realistic scenario for many
practical applications. Our work contributes towards more trustworthy and
reliable usage of large language models in safety-critical situations, where
robust guarantees of error rate are required. | [
0.0227431674,
0.0641124025,
0.0074118688,
0.0368380845,
-0.0164720807,
0.0067123575,
-0.0171630327,
-0.0057556937,
0.0100807073,
-0.0423972458,
0.0236234516,
-0.0986803696,
-0.0238402765,
-0.0273603816,
-0.0010678218,
-0.0341229662,
0.0333799981,
-0.078494899,
0.0052951341,
-0.0491062887,
-0.0223557837,
-0.0341335125,
0.0108170826,
-0.0054472382,
0.0122242197,
-0.021406224,
0.007458936,
-0.0095975772,
-0.0101049822,
0.0083049973,
0.0469396189,
0.0949215293,
0.0101982504,
0.0089856759,
0.000001768,
-0.0222523566,
-0.0264226012,
0.0141705349,
-0.0341929644,
0.0082884962,
-0.0300833713,
0.0267462768,
-0.0010302549,
0.0335407257,
-0.023017142,
-0.0043771951,
0.0463171825,
-0.0018121501,
0.0563259162,
0.0204156712,
0.0209436715,
-0.0189827364,
0.0224227458,
0.0027231199,
-0.0034846559,
-0.0643107966,
0.0489036404,
-0.0178743936,
-0.0090473397,
0.0560765341,
-0.0377045535,
0.02254311,
0.0172156189,
0.0476782396,
-0.0408784896,
0.0108988304,
0.0112890471,
-0.0091049718,
0.0004452252,
0.0234981123,
0.0039175595,
-0.0399384759,
-0.0445189774,
0.0126420893,
-0.0106086656,
0.0680625513,
-0.061428804,
0.0220207609,
-0.0116591668,
-0.0008053868,
-0.0024354518,
-0.0165320057,
0.0030125498,
0.02707492,
-0.0015979869,
0.0896247476,
0.030793583,
-0.0167042315,
0.0063194302,
0.0093299653,
-0.0713662207,
-0.0351409316,
-0.0143928938,
0.0541452803,
-0.0506192036,
0.020293491,
-0.029583171,
-0.0034084457,
0.0342115536,
-0.0616027378,
0.0166187361,
0.0096680094,
0.0484538786,
0.0336994082,
-0.0105445618,
0.0674950704,
-0.0162612312,
-0.0008200328,
-0.0549370535,
-0.0491519831,
0.0016643765,
-0.0104045235,
-0.0052453661,
0.0360276997,
-0.0366791785,
0.0153598646,
-0.0760596469,
0.0217508338,
-0.0209561493,
0.019662533,
0.0151626011,
0.0338304453,
-0.0177752264,
-0.030864615,
-0.0567745827,
0.058337342,
-0.0120014781,
0.0152024096,
0.0090044392,
-0.0504870452,
-0.0073778681,
0.0086355777,
-0.0077054175,
-0.0369845405,
0.0093090748,
0.0924652591,
-0.0180525817,
-0.0098952316,
0.0082018198,
-0.0216271505,
-0.0362630188,
-0.03167326,
0.017158648,
-0.0836844444,
-0.0141955838,
0.0343585126,
0.0167889073,
-0.0632939711,
0.0118768346,
0.0333288461,
-0.0113431243,
0.0376980305,
0.0042092162,
0.0208901875,
-0.0069192587,
-0.003678126,
0.010198541,
0.0528124906,
-0.0072892788,
0.0100089461,
0.0659367517,
-0.0439550243,
0.0388537347,
0.038668368,
0.0143154906,
-0.0067790197,
-0.0384414867,
0.0502919331,
0.0776980519,
0.0006753558,
-0.0335485786,
0.072689116,
0.0111007541,
-0.066840671,
0.0737870112,
0.0557967685,
-0.0198330693,
-0.0402465314,
0.0002103228,
-0.0132632032,
0.0209417697,
0.0240043942,
-0.0412871689,
-0.0015199606,
-0.0679268315,
0.0070826807,
0.0091894725,
0.0406925157,
-0.033991985,
-0.0494486764,
-0.0334864296,
-0.013045908,
-0.0001866424,
0.0559724383,
0.0497360229,
-0.0429697931,
-0.0130747166,
0.0434331335,
0.033778917,
-0.0203049146,
0.0244299415,
-0.0360191613,
0.0500441119,
0.012677772,
0.0169435721,
-0.033069741,
-0.057426326,
-0.004258425,
0.04536267,
-0.0195618197,
0.0553215146,
-0.0120441159,
0.0265223514,
-0.0268898886,
0.0006752299,
0.0660330579,
0.0107031576,
-0.0064197788,
0.0699377209,
-0.00327519,
-0.0332741588,
-0.0056733051,
-0.0424336083,
0.0040089646,
-0.000100276,
-0.0554313995,
0.0148755442,
0.0079976795,
0.040219266,
-0.0107257869,
-0.0073559498,
0.007106049,
0.0681376979,
-0.004146697,
-0.0550472103,
-0.0518878587,
-0.0306724254,
0.0329621695,
0.0564724579,
-0.0082708448,
-0.0248349253,
0.0231905095,
-0.0219447408,
-0.0357872471,
0.0142164361,
-0.0220899936,
0.0224258397,
-0.0116838207,
-0.0031737962,
0.0074280482,
0.0153807169,
-0.0754030347,
0.0362802111,
-0.003850512,
0.0517388135,
-0.0197529513,
-0.0065415418,
0.0001557123,
0.0189873148,
-0.0732587501,
0.0225839075,
-0.0407047234,
0.0499028154,
0.0438988842,
-0.0142191676,
-0.0098456629,
-0.0506748781,
-0.033152353,
0.0133117838,
-0.0129296118,
0.0083994875,
-0.0056106974,
0.0108109461,
0.0042039007,
-0.0192854404,
-0.041158814,
-0.0046614399,
0.0123867029,
0.0350547321,
0.0216603577,
0.0155680375,
-0.0103055425,
-0.0024502738,
-0.0523073934,
-0.0265012551,
0.0574399605,
-0.0065944651,
0.0487622321,
-0.0503234416,
0.0095609082,
-0.0411101766,
0.0536388308,
0.0117454836,
-0.0324669704,
-0.0023075212,
-0.0262645874,
0.0326727778,
0.0598510467,
0.0293291975,
0.0112634012,
0.047380697,
0.0012727279,
-0.0112666003,
0.0008843075,
-0.0833728984,
-0.0673807338,
-0.0288386531,
-0.0257368907,
-0.0034193459,
0.0488992371,
0.0005448096,
-0.0504737012,
-0.0457331575,
0.0170171428,
-0.025146082,
0.0055698892,
-0.0448031723,
0.0151333427,
-0.0157404356,
0.0562772453,
0.0193781462,
-0.03086075,
0.0831108391,
-0.0223758556,
0.0186420269,
-0.0178925954,
-0.0374977738,
-0.0076880064,
0.0220004227,
0.0093635004,
0.008976087,
0.0266341045,
0.0130491201,
-0.0746503398,
-0.0313333981,
0.0305770151,
-0.0479505844,
0.0488129482,
-0.0806463882,
-0.0063872305,
0.0090452423,
-0.0380520336,
-0.0318485685,
-0.0567716137,
-0.0384042338,
0.0242461618,
0.0063860808,
-0.0435915105,
-0.0026055924,
0.0002813377,
0.0033466311,
-0.0139277223,
-0.0655291975,
0.0043176715,
-0.028162539,
0.0387915634,
0.0712700635,
0.0204208717,
0.042624265,
-0.0420197621,
0.0070353309,
0.0917895362,
0.0590053238,
0.0016195546,
-0.0019602636,
-0.018196959,
0.0742831826,
-0.0257420335,
-0.0208895579,
0.0716219619,
0.0772166699,
-0.02715143,
-0.012105491,
0.116692774,
0.0227149408,
-0.0076541379,
-0.0197134856,
-0.0020577135,
0.0519043058,
0.0321619511,
0.0397311077,
-0.0272897128,
-0.0354003049,
-0.0161417853,
0.0223542303,
0.006516003,
-0.0449401997,
0.0098440619,
-0.0972761288,
0.0089515429,
-0.016966287,
-0.0701041967,
-0.0461860932,
-0.0621271096,
0.0152411461,
-0.0197868478,
0.0283564907,
-0.0124020018,
-0.0107550221,
-0.0166305061,
0.0579238087,
-0.0445154198,
-0.0151378792,
0.0373414755,
-0.0470621362,
0.0509530678,
0.0043267258,
0.0012510443,
-0.038949959,
-0.0353809446,
0.0117010809,
-0.0703509301,
-0.0344290063,
-0.0106259789,
0.0123728979,
0.0208994318,
0.0010279441,
-0.0303588361,
0.03679635,
-0.0243176501,
-0.0154254148,
0.0164648518,
0.1175604761,
-0.0012633695,
-0.0446416289,
-0.011670527,
0.0097025679,
-0.0002614509,
0.0550426617,
0.0055168592,
-0.0860615075,
-0.0172860287,
-0.0557354763,
0.0102787456,
0.0258064549,
0.0068773618,
-0.0205660705,
0.0286454596,
-0.0112701477,
-0.0554101393,
0.0123576578,
0.0264991783,
0.0305902902,
-0.0218503736,
0.0016005187,
0.0358296819,
0.0331632756,
0.0007245236,
0.0024645394,
-0.0213908087,
0.033039283,
-0.0761722252,
0.0781711861,
0.0289818775,
0.0084929382,
-0.0414272733,
0.0284440909,
-0.0851062685,
-0.0673457682,
0.0410068072,
0.0504429191,
0.0285831355,
0.0016346684,
-0.0346993133,
-0.0793516412,
0.0120408554,
-0.0042122919,
0.0057265856,
0.0097540757,
0.0291861761,
-0.0208095144,
0.0048023015,
0.0364955962,
-0.0220945645,
0.0017180891,
0.0041098208,
-0.0174922366,
-0.0395937897,
-0.1041712165,
0.0226503704,
0.0314140208,
0.0217943769,
0.0243073087,
-0.0117625818,
0.0207758751,
0.0335835293,
0.0095833829,
-0.0310812034,
0.0173848998,
-0.0015267025,
0.0198794175,
-0.029380057,
-0.0165784899,
-0.0167561863,
0.0396738276,
0.0371856727,
0.0026906312,
-0.0185230132,
0.039461609,
0.0112501932,
0.0604136586,
0.0154042253,
-0.0230578166,
0.0055230674,
0.0218986496,
0.0731487498,
0.0239731353,
0.0553779751,
-0.0023149075,
-0.0177771989,
-0.0042627449,
-0.0444510467,
-0.1102170497,
-0.0827003345,
-0.0500974134,
0.0352195352,
0.0018864451,
0.0213238653,
-0.0081582433,
-0.0333400145,
-0.0372526683,
-0.0455488451,
0.0199566651,
-0.0001805978,
0.0024187698,
0.0788228139,
0.0374694504,
-0.0049717212,
0.0187609326,
0.0800087899,
-0.0042271754,
0.0380307026,
0.0068378225,
-0.0331607945,
-0.0286096092,
-0.0291484632,
-0.0176847409,
0.012149483,
-0.0204478465,
0.0221335646,
-0.0614460744,
-0.0667812973,
0.0772382542,
0.0245943516,
0.0044273636,
-0.0295619201,
-0.0019118508,
0.0638555959,
0.00494124,
0.0046946756,
-0.0313796066,
0.0060103768,
-0.0254612844,
0.0131221749,
-0.0158240534,
-6.247789944e-33,
-0.0227049123,
-0.0435266234,
-0.0106963785,
-0.0359447189,
0.0391705185,
-0.0159127582,
0.0256755035,
0.0312327594,
-0.0369593091,
0.0162143987,
-0.0210899618,
0.0037557078,
0.0115171876,
0.0610153899,
0.0114685018,
-0.0526443794,
-0.0004891554,
-0.0092764627,
-0.0045628836,
0.005973476,
0.051006455,
-0.0018511731,
0.0479363687,
-0.0271733198,
0.0409097373,
0.0117187416,
-0.0096236756,
0.0643477291,
-0.0444190353,
0.0619715489,
0.0007962026,
0.0516939275,
-0.0054468061,
-0.031988088,
0.0203168578,
0.0069694207,
-0.0219352283,
-0.0355412699,
0.0075053172,
0.0086403135,
0.0213842541,
-0.0195247959,
0.0178540181,
-0.0018766578,
-0.0219898541,
-0.0449517071,
0.0243738536,
-0.010567056,
-0.0245474335,
0.0056364271,
0.0077289981,
0.0134157762,
0.0034460886,
-0.0114156781,
-0.0322038308,
0.1088110581,
0.0135323107,
-0.0060286424,
0.0048086504,
0.0264731925,
0.0064032855,
0.0409213565,
0.0435304977,
-0.0017680058,
-0.0227228049,
0.0473585613,
-0.0128597012,
-0.0422734208,
0.0063427729,
-0.0649980754,
-0.0113218362,
0.0157436002,
0.0727167279,
0.0775406137,
-0.0172659624,
0.0010988663,
-0.080800198,
0.036348816,
-0.0204418562,
0.0373033732,
0.0313938931,
-0.0369762741,
-0.0552229472,
-0.0539234504,
-0.0551424809,
0.0140916221,
-0.0187815707,
0.0128304716,
0.000441331,
-0.0395086482,
-0.0429853648,
0.0084053865,
0.0316655301,
-0.0690697134,
-0.0034540391,
0.0149410143,
-0.0055199554,
0.0250763427,
0.0092215845,
0.0682218745,
-0.024700772,
0.0259874351,
-0.0173154436,
-0.0612833388,
-0.0493887551,
0.0243499447,
0.0110032344,
0.0239652786,
-0.0768478513,
-0.0083107473,
-0.0354972221,
0.0013731497,
0.0287781823,
-0.0008015231,
0.0453567691,
0.0153449476,
-0.0014790832,
0.0482649654,
-0.0060429932,
0.0303792618,
-0.0121475542,
-0.0257566199,
0.0088809766,
0.0054527419,
-0.0130729405,
-0.0188189819,
-0.0201957561,
-0.0070694867,
-0.030937057,
-0.0336165093,
-0.0045176228,
0.0111818379,
2.473e-7,
0.0736926794,
0.0478177853,
-0.0053789555,
0.0137729198,
0.0103886854,
0.0340869427,
0.0095851701,
0.0078418823,
0.037561059,
0.0143540641,
-0.0083255665,
0.020490557,
0.0286175143,
0.05680779,
-0.0565452725,
-0.0531374402,
-0.043169491,
-0.0034679805,
-0.0014541309,
0.0068920674,
0.0517844856,
0.1016648784,
0.0275031142,
-0.0142711839,
-0.0269931778,
0.0270806272,
0.0508007668,
-0.0545546412,
-0.0212690718,
0.0148203187,
0.0175948404,
-0.0105736693,
0.0267924611,
0.0461870916,
-0.0054932246,
-0.0212821402,
0.0225264523,
0.0812772512,
0.0319930464,
-0.014109347,
-0.0257787704,
-0.0346919447,
-0.0025368482,
-0.0426150933,
0.0722680688,
-0.0598481074,
-0.016697621,
-0.0486239307,
-0.0300927777,
-0.0223508347,
0.0362738706,
-0.0195659138,
0.0062962561,
-0.0103780925,
-0.0118446462,
0.0326999202,
0.0149701908,
-0.0336613916,
-0.0123983137,
0.0187596902,
-0.04031609,
-0.0558322445,
0.0007368552,
-0.0351712778,
0.0150057413,
-0.0633157864,
0.0120316893,
2.25683367e-34,
0.0341060422,
0.0157906245,
0.0067549716,
0.0092422385,
0.0243064389,
-0.0423647948,
0.0430029742,
0.0164529122,
0.0476299375,
-0.0909022912,
-0.0122527974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.17750v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.17750v1 | Reliable and Interpretable Drift Detection in Streams of Short Texts | 2023-05-28T15:14:54 | 2023-05-28T15:14:54 | Ella Rabinovich, Matan Vetzler, Samuel Ackerman, Ateret Anaby-Tavor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data drift is the change in model input data that is one of the key factors
leading to machine learning models performance degradation over time.
Monitoring drift helps detecting these issues and preventing their harmful
consequences. Meaningful drift interpretation is a fundamental step towards
effective re-training of the model. In this study we propose an end-to-end
framework for reliable model-agnostic change-point detection and interpretation
in large task-oriented dialog systems, proven effective in multiple customer
deployments. We evaluate our approach and demonstrate its benefits with a novel
variant of intent classification training dataset, simulating customer requests
to a dialog system. We make the data publicly available. | [
0.0344283655,
0.0583918579,
-0.0266870372,
0.0276787784,
-0.0310214292,
0.0023566133,
0.0091332942,
-0.0023901947,
0.0348953456,
-0.046999801,
0.0258582644,
-0.0510807075,
-0.0085241599,
0.0844075307,
-0.0188361276,
-0.0477890857,
0.0614994615,
-0.0319497027,
0.0323714502,
0.0482600667,
0.0530629903,
-0.0186146107,
-0.0277144499,
0.0242699198,
0.0168740544,
-0.0724020228,
-0.0645188913,
-0.0028564432,
0.0217114929,
-0.0208003204,
0.0391300395,
0.0618845224,
0.008453534,
0.0773306638,
0.0000017546,
-0.0715312362,
-0.0281701982,
-0.0037468607,
-0.1155311838,
-0.006492483,
0.0347042903,
0.0064648027,
-0.0161423534,
0.0456981212,
-0.0268881693,
0.0602661856,
0.0367388315,
0.0309483837,
0.0646407232,
0.0772669241,
-0.0173854884,
0.021127684,
-0.0028310609,
-0.0126917819,
0.0512719266,
-0.0643005446,
0.0408515297,
-0.0004405236,
-0.0325664766,
0.0108580068,
-0.0055279629,
0.0004912273,
-0.0065208175,
-0.0352720916,
0.0052424944,
0.0123302983,
0.0083456589,
0.0218247026,
-0.0505889356,
0.0625957623,
-0.0025765591,
0.0051808357,
0.004875089,
-0.0399566181,
0.0158278085,
-0.0465364233,
-0.0226653274,
-0.0519065149,
0.0016478364,
-0.0184875857,
-0.0185129605,
-0.0234250054,
-0.0060378793,
0.0095554003,
-0.0498643667,
0.0082883295,
-0.0162545051,
-0.031451568,
-0.0308896601,
0.0038801481,
0.047467161,
-0.0838230625,
0.0245374162,
0.0098484326,
-0.0347913653,
0.0311556887,
-0.0369950868,
-0.0242075883,
0.0170775969,
-0.0879097879,
0.0094128605,
-0.0083055021,
-0.0490124263,
0.0505101159,
0.0329236463,
0.0384859033,
0.0369836278,
-0.0249995198,
-0.00589504,
0.0175553411,
-0.0847604871,
-0.0023283095,
-0.0359464064,
0.0212542787,
-0.0244545247,
-0.0123214908,
-0.0226762071,
0.0849950612,
0.0135992263,
0.0044518635,
-0.0226911325,
-0.0021744501,
-0.0484007932,
0.0100012915,
-0.0358897299,
0.0530703068,
-0.0187684819,
0.0368526205,
0.0230564792,
-0.0713264048,
-0.0089339092,
0.001526776,
0.0004695269,
0.0009656561,
-0.03921685,
-0.0090034772,
-0.0072762123,
-0.0301277135,
-0.0585047826,
-0.0431241915,
-0.032198064,
-0.0174960326,
-0.0556520969,
-0.0115792705,
-0.0036296751,
0.0038907838,
0.0041517569,
-0.0517272167,
-0.0280142464,
-0.0130011626,
0.006251887,
0.059487097,
-0.0289991815,
-0.005120147,
0.0047542369,
-0.0074879131,
-0.0391392633,
0.0993829444,
0.0245136954,
0.0320515558,
0.071653612,
-0.0086141368,
0.008314752,
0.0226965882,
-0.0093126623,
0.0107933255,
0.0557419285,
0.0514039062,
-0.0425438248,
0.0230676103,
-0.0037113028,
0.0166349057,
0.0041655819,
-0.0297342744,
0.0783773139,
0.0228588451,
0.0287359897,
-0.0036359124,
-0.0265982989,
0.083062984,
-0.0200206488,
-0.0126699982,
-0.0089826025,
-0.011149276,
-0.0076602302,
-0.0388323106,
-0.0043008588,
-0.0262081679,
-0.0359669998,
-0.0531015918,
0.0100590233,
-0.0182175618,
0.0035341443,
0.0003573619,
0.0558399186,
-0.0035783974,
-0.0022195908,
0.0227140412,
-0.0118689388,
-0.0181320105,
-0.0162179098,
-0.0521481521,
0.0299638212,
0.0835100859,
0.0034794093,
-0.0477708317,
-0.0575060248,
-0.0607099757,
0.0356497467,
0.0010037455,
0.048246447,
-0.0160139371,
0.0402639024,
-0.0310432669,
-0.0298726521,
0.0386137292,
0.016229786,
-0.0054660062,
-0.0516923256,
0.0092636002,
0.0115406122,
-0.0296618007,
-0.0543956645,
0.0190904513,
0.0153281847,
0.0119541297,
0.0523957051,
-0.0010295049,
0.0671992227,
0.0223639999,
0.0225394517,
-0.0261276364,
0.0078037949,
0.0333981551,
0.0018732906,
0.0606399029,
-0.0140824746,
0.001879007,
0.0359982662,
0.0371882804,
-0.0133995069,
0.0354499593,
-0.0747946724,
-0.0295485873,
0.0019959039,
-0.0438886397,
-0.0024250899,
-0.013706333,
0.0120725939,
-0.0102434987,
0.0214439388,
-0.00605777,
0.0165620688,
0.0234038234,
-0.0316742212,
-0.006737513,
0.021998968,
0.0428247675,
-0.031680923,
0.010630589,
0.0045768237,
-0.0433093533,
0.0202288292,
0.0049785073,
-0.0339959934,
-0.0708916262,
0.0367564149,
-0.0806307942,
0.0080008311,
-0.0350946337,
0.0389951579,
0.0280864164,
0.0303411242,
0.0018670784,
-0.0331164189,
-0.0124406554,
0.0056668124,
0.0113178752,
0.022100769,
0.0431819744,
0.0106541142,
-0.0287993643,
-0.0278181732,
0.0168888699,
-0.0146241728,
0.0518017076,
0.0245987941,
-0.0374006853,
-0.1216895133,
-0.0187881328,
-0.0320462957,
0.0141811632,
-0.0294906814,
-0.0034655691,
-0.0132261747,
0.0148193389,
0.0335304514,
0.0543982051,
0.073310636,
0.0330064781,
-0.0311349612,
0.0021549461,
-0.0769522637,
0.0124069788,
-0.0079798428,
0.0145829283,
-0.0702467412,
-0.013318358,
0.0379636884,
0.0322589353,
-0.0105469739,
-0.0105554666,
-0.0393224321,
-0.0004451793,
-0.0190770216,
-0.0041050301,
-0.0359224677,
0.016382996,
-0.0422091298,
0.0329847522,
0.0091462648,
-0.0681490526,
0.0578860119,
0.0294094812,
0.0001801048,
-0.0720639825,
-0.0426639132,
-0.0369439647,
0.0532168075,
-0.0324070305,
-0.0055108527,
0.0730662793,
-0.0289478414,
-0.0051574288,
-0.0080518825,
-0.0007328805,
-0.0261195302,
0.06829983,
-0.0484850556,
0.028553322,
-0.0069205794,
-0.0272081383,
-0.0637010336,
-0.0643873662,
-0.0176602136,
-0.0294856261,
0.0436467677,
-0.0210633911,
-0.0086886361,
0.025338782,
-0.0128636425,
0.042452272,
-0.0126543725,
-0.0265862662,
-0.0021175246,
0.0159865376,
0.0552553087,
0.0321197435,
-0.0045811562,
-0.0254844651,
0.0396295972,
0.051333908,
0.0469515175,
-0.0438659191,
-0.0703464597,
-0.0352857746,
-0.0043364945,
-0.0503407344,
0.0195665527,
0.0066099814,
0.058705315,
-0.0555252172,
-0.0266591758,
0.0946184322,
0.0370287634,
-0.0480594411,
-0.0164262708,
-0.0186591558,
0.0253423527,
-0.0083651822,
0.0077686482,
-0.0985190049,
-0.0621916577,
-0.0053450009,
0.0640103519,
-0.0084044784,
-0.0210360959,
0.0095492098,
-0.0357065536,
0.0288373753,
-0.0263927318,
-0.016120635,
0.0041408795,
-0.0660200268,
0.0074898037,
-0.0144636603,
0.0045771729,
-0.0076851593,
0.0157206822,
-0.0222345423,
0.0540887266,
-0.0890035108,
-0.0511651933,
0.0101350797,
-0.0313933417,
0.0550040081,
0.066817008,
0.0243447646,
-0.0062225782,
-0.0290397052,
0.0523286164,
-0.0333094411,
-0.0199881699,
0.0096444646,
0.0756576657,
-0.0058569741,
0.0003251827,
-0.0134581532,
0.0102909142,
-0.018789662,
0.0266673844,
0.037260253,
0.0565556288,
-0.0358720683,
-0.0133358985,
-0.0055755181,
-0.0386560895,
0.0659150779,
0.064501904,
-0.0002310368,
-0.0710236356,
-0.0335285291,
-0.0385162719,
0.0055282405,
-0.0058913738,
0.028401861,
-0.0177083407,
-0.0202437788,
0.0074375072,
-0.0554888882,
-0.029794218,
-0.0058047208,
-0.022953866,
0.0122090466,
0.0330813304,
0.0189181976,
0.0128466319,
-0.0405252166,
0.0162311345,
-0.0053299372,
0.0515399203,
-0.0514326692,
-0.0274203476,
0.0515549257,
-0.0152655914,
-0.0154924011,
0.0105121899,
-0.1173772663,
-0.0519005582,
0.016142305,
0.0203963555,
0.0250701196,
0.0511099063,
-0.0123318657,
-0.0098736864,
-0.0305717438,
0.0234274138,
-0.0038341398,
-0.015093348,
0.0491858199,
0.0226406548,
-0.0426360965,
0.0007496304,
-0.0558118336,
-0.014309898,
-0.0479214638,
-0.0068158833,
-0.0616223328,
-0.0292250495,
-0.0117725674,
0.0024894529,
0.0075313868,
0.0720351785,
-0.1019142121,
-0.0326237157,
0.0429925062,
0.0433311164,
-0.0036844478,
-0.0347384252,
0.0027734027,
0.0082727764,
-0.0383898467,
-0.0016816313,
0.0378730968,
-0.031584572,
-0.0418081731,
-0.0450386517,
-0.0031186363,
0.0396978296,
0.0474216528,
0.0306851305,
-0.0218327809,
0.0065000546,
0.0087462263,
0.0216878615,
0.0307463631,
0.0097965077,
0.048963502,
0.0409690365,
-0.0035127876,
0.0356952734,
0.0421393886,
-0.0654969439,
-0.0521800444,
0.0117594749,
0.0040200497,
0.0187565628,
0.020450227,
0.0666063055,
-0.0259157605,
0.0386249386,
-0.0451177396,
0.0510499664,
0.0055152737,
-0.0191582814,
-0.0243169498,
0.0210249256,
-0.0215522163,
0.0389759019,
0.0430111848,
-0.0317247026,
0.0429954566,
-0.0166368745,
-0.0404100269,
-0.0427553989,
0.0082620811,
-0.0019988979,
0.02580004,
-0.0141831981,
-0.0270130411,
-0.0222626887,
-0.0179549493,
0.0560346618,
-0.0325070545,
0.0481634811,
-0.0144653749,
0.0391223095,
0.054714676,
-0.007163357,
0.0033686212,
-0.0418182202,
-0.0223640129,
-0.0353804417,
0.0070199063,
-0.0403411277,
-5.354726478e-33,
0.0331635959,
0.0001709331,
-0.0049636369,
-0.0031809593,
-0.0172201581,
0.025312135,
-0.0266587213,
-0.0121214325,
0.0082995258,
-0.0118434438,
0.0161686558,
0.0650532916,
0.0262939259,
0.0147304786,
0.0000220932,
-0.0318548642,
0.0660289377,
-0.0420246758,
0.0015837629,
0.0494019724,
0.0749948323,
0.0269139037,
0.0171264634,
-0.0622264668,
0.0551833659,
-0.005203187,
0.0058999117,
0.0102021713,
-0.0031866136,
0.0589817539,
0.0006462712,
0.0328347906,
0.0208778773,
-0.0261023156,
-0.0407658517,
0.0044723088,
-0.0322639383,
-0.0089623043,
-0.0228070766,
0.0369885415,
-0.0347326957,
0.0164944492,
0.0294616651,
0.0130311297,
0.0143713243,
0.0266765561,
0.0373028927,
-0.0275974423,
-0.0155778872,
-0.0026775466,
-0.0303114224,
0.031132048,
-0.0536614247,
-0.0305786394,
0.0066412655,
0.0535039641,
0.0473762862,
-0.0232569408,
-0.0468384735,
-0.0146441674,
0.0310226697,
-0.0084687732,
0.017093759,
0.0272713397,
-0.0285883956,
0.0340258367,
0.0362705998,
0.0300549809,
0.0362004898,
-0.0193831511,
0.0129367001,
0.0089504486,
0.0319388993,
0.0167166386,
0.0471278541,
-0.0219826195,
-0.0507625751,
0.0261309985,
0.0417709984,
0.0254510026,
0.026837917,
0.0141423941,
-0.0452567637,
-0.0037235222,
0.0038786384,
0.0055824071,
-0.0073249857,
-0.0207207687,
0.0493390188,
0.0336481966,
0.0020197183,
0.0278341658,
0.0510698333,
-0.0250928849,
-0.034006089,
0.0061714617,
0.0022101768,
-0.0028445723,
0.0399208963,
-0.0131593114,
-0.0263383612,
-0.0093982397,
0.0137104746,
0.0222277846,
0.041474916,
-0.0314581729,
0.0264361072,
-0.0109059988,
-0.0192623809,
0.0188006107,
-0.0054608267,
0.0323701762,
-0.0599993803,
0.0660681427,
0.0095935427,
-0.0073797996,
-0.012693461,
0.1198165342,
-0.000134846,
-0.0049154866,
-0.0545177311,
-0.0182502065,
-0.0011078245,
-0.0018092524,
-0.033105474,
-0.0432971902,
0.0143825319,
0.0338197984,
0.0080854129,
-0.0356544144,
0.0092982892,
-0.0225040708,
2.479e-7,
0.024884738,
0.0565488674,
0.0501500145,
0.018982023,
0.0273301303,
0.0536552593,
-0.0353072174,
0.0074538402,
0.0228718799,
0.0274039004,
0.014550834,
-0.0232748948,
0.0565974005,
0.034450572,
-0.0540146753,
-0.0422120281,
-0.0406943262,
0.0184613373,
-0.0802114978,
0.0254123043,
0.0782571658,
0.0694849044,
0.0008492093,
0.0003639746,
0.0491648838,
-0.015722299,
0.0136613213,
-0.0282504149,
0.0653345659,
0.0244219657,
0.0639537424,
-0.0232835207,
-0.0066421009,
0.0060807015,
-0.041768875,
-0.0112767359,
-0.0505957566,
0.0416331366,
-0.0023462763,
-0.0214963723,
-0.0453507267,
0.0095913662,
0.0402415283,
-0.0375344008,
0.0540676266,
-0.0315110348,
0.0126713468,
-0.0510762371,
-0.0165019184,
-0.0468040705,
0.0220989008,
0.0370710865,
-0.0013333986,
-0.000097556,
-0.0093723414,
-0.0064523257,
-0.0248448234,
-0.0906052291,
0.0270462353,
-0.0447156616,
-0.0275046155,
-0.0133982133,
-0.0744329914,
-0.0069089793,
0.0213109702,
-0.0517434329,
0.0374920033,
1.867446345e-34,
0.0371884964,
-0.0173589252,
-0.0008752898,
0.0476458371,
0.0156980753,
0.0008257797,
0.0568822697,
-0.0077282307,
0.0536823608,
-0.0461707041,
-0.0124003775
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.