id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08659v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08659v1 | Uncertainty-aware Self-training for Low-resource Neural Sequence Labeling | 2023-02-17T02:40:04 | 2023-02-17T02:40:04 | Jianing Wang, Chengyu Wang, Jun Huang, Ming Gao, Aoying Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural sequence labeling (NSL) aims at assigning labels for input language
tokens, which covers a broad range of applications, such as named entity
recognition (NER) and slot filling, etc. However, the satisfying results
achieved by traditional supervised-based approaches heavily depend on the large
amounts of human annotation data, which may not be feasible in real-world
scenarios due to data privacy and computation efficiency issues. This paper
presents SeqUST, a novel uncertain-aware self-training framework for NSL to
address the labeled data scarcity issue and to effectively utilize unlabeled
data. Specifically, we incorporate Monte Carlo (MC) dropout in Bayesian neural
network (BNN) to perform uncertainty estimation at the token level and then
select reliable language tokens from unlabeled data based on the model
confidence and certainty. A well-designed masked sequence labeling task with a
noise-robust loss supports robust training, which aims to suppress the problem
of noisy pseudo labels. In addition, we develop a Gaussian-based consistency
regularization technique to further improve the model robustness on
Gaussian-distributed perturbed representations. This effectively alleviates the
over-fitting dilemma originating from pseudo-labeled augmented data. Extensive
experiments over six benchmarks demonstrate that our SeqUST framework
effectively improves the performance of self-training, and consistently
outperforms strong baselines by a large margin in low-resource scenarios | [
-0.1297614723,
-0.4611420035,
0.0879588872,
0.1111429036,
-0.2880845368,
0.1852500886,
-0.0827179179,
-0.2405974567,
0.1835052967,
0.3754022121,
-0.47913903,
-0.4296935499,
-0.4645318687,
-0.0499394536,
-0.2353512645,
0.8878645301,
0.1532287598,
-0.1063075736,
-0.0453381874,
-0.142846778,
-0.1593605727,
-0.7781003118,
-0.7184839249,
0.0416239351,
0.3600088656,
0.2382370234,
0.7108281255,
0.6578354239,
0.2295227498,
0.3042477369,
-0.0709022507,
0.1210891604,
-0.1422515661,
0.3712457716,
-0.3463312984,
-0.0314762183,
-0.3340338171,
-0.2878637612,
0.4979508221,
0.5524371266,
-0.1536485255,
0.2721016407,
0.2268142402,
0.3413991034,
-0.7417219281,
-0.0751075223,
-0.5436907411,
0.3180684447,
-0.3577832282,
0.4191758633,
-0.144541055,
-0.1761558205,
0.1807860881,
-0.5456911325,
0.1990688145,
0.1081333756,
0.7384536266,
0.7431581616,
-0.170861721,
0.1056350991,
-0.4110039771,
0.6509070992,
-0.9732607007,
0.4100917876,
0.7216079235,
0.2318400145,
-0.0280156806,
-0.7020469904,
-0.3024113178,
0.1392199099,
0.1493629813,
0.2862168849,
0.2871271372,
0.085690029,
0.2185792476,
0.0263252947,
-0.5532119274,
0.1006106883,
-0.2058920115,
-0.797046721,
0.6714769602,
-0.1864976734,
0.021142371,
-0.3086970448,
-0.5412067175,
0.0728794411,
-0.258661449,
-0.2487140596,
0.258285284,
0.3192480803,
0.0942156836,
0.4058288932,
-0.4378070235,
0.5266840458,
0.0910910517,
0.077333428,
0.4490754604,
0.0427583605,
-0.2556822002,
0.4378979206,
1.0052031279,
-0.0928119123,
-0.2067266554,
-0.0483082458,
-0.2417385131,
-0.3879624307,
-0.035936255,
-0.6713264585,
-0.4813792109,
0.2796820104,
-0.0368701108,
-0.197758615,
-0.3456620872,
-0.6094693542,
-0.4879072309,
-0.2011626363,
0.7790770531,
-0.5818986893,
0.1481289417,
-0.0583922043,
0.3839174509,
-0.3727411628,
0.3809095919,
-0.9230518937,
-0.070942089,
0.2334601432,
0.8672100902,
-0.0702319741,
-0.032308422,
-0.4431895316,
0.1534619927,
-0.2809785008,
0.2214487344,
-0.0949125662,
-0.1453583837,
-0.4413524568,
-0.2808747292,
-0.0970265567,
-0.1704465747,
0.454172492,
-0.4381620288,
-0.2196287066,
-0.0304841865,
-0.5999461412,
-0.1116871834,
0.3070583045,
-0.4719840586,
1.2023994923,
0.0842634365,
-0.8652698994,
0.13560085,
-0.127568379,
-0.4633372724,
0.1740209609,
-0.3132611215,
-0.6181535721,
-0.0294794422,
0.3911518157,
0.6057556868,
-0.0046335533,
0.5230975747,
-0.4411596656,
-0.1953088492,
0.5752615333,
-0.8370156288,
0.6251031756,
0.6002364159,
-0.4760754704,
-0.1211185902,
-0.8994985819,
0.4171105027,
-0.2984070182,
-0.1727149338,
-0.3171360195,
-0.1452935338,
-0.2295204997,
0.3927559555,
0.3302016854,
-0.49746719,
0.039333079,
-0.4567611814,
0.4909000099,
0.9158381224,
0.1380488873,
0.3671795428,
0.1262538731,
0.4725215733,
0.0485621467,
0.3159479797,
0.0193286762,
-0.3447670937,
-0.8619760275,
-0.3473167121,
0.9195686579,
0.5972796082,
-0.875205934,
0.376060009,
-0.0612296388,
-0.2513869107,
-0.6848132014,
0.1129616946,
0.4497881234,
0.7483530641,
0.53547436,
-0.2918845713,
-0.4324661493,
-0.8713053465,
-0.0685521364,
-0.052779302,
0.2365962863,
0.1888296604,
0.354363054,
-0.2420755327,
1.045548439,
-0.1820997596,
-0.1921849251,
0.200310871,
0.5282796025,
0.1320847124,
0.8306561708,
-0.0856349468,
-0.5871284008,
-0.521451354,
-0.0297297314,
-0.4674666524,
-0.0751974434,
-0.5465645194,
-0.1961532533,
0.2833065987,
0.4561578333,
-0.1087507755,
0.7709569931,
0.4015141726,
0.2434060574,
0.1937806159,
-0.3433621824,
-0.0486493111,
-0.9975203872,
-0.09762609,
-0.0736475065,
-0.2181713134,
-0.4698714316,
-0.5283923745,
0.4166161716,
-0.0695214346,
-0.6019468307,
0.3584581017,
-0.3646228909,
-0.1304971427,
0.0874161795,
-0.1311996579,
0.0599282607,
0.4062820673,
0.4314708412,
0.7897974849,
0.4531515241,
-0.4837880135,
-0.1839197427,
0.1228835061,
-0.2925959826,
0.266481936,
-0.5691520572,
0.1850195974,
0.0054588974,
0.0236848183,
-0.7987200618,
-0.4147440791,
0.6708654165,
-0.4838965237,
0.5643426776,
-0.3136787713,
-0.2809065282,
-0.3755096197,
0.2717290521,
0.4810208678,
0.3170169592,
-0.4212577939,
0.4406908751,
0.1993948072,
-0.1719036847,
-1.0166548491,
-1.0412291288,
-0.1203772873,
-0.128401041,
-0.3685693145,
0.1612325907,
-0.0691717714,
0.3143793344,
-0.1592122763,
-0.4669463038,
-0.4290922582,
0.3265608847,
0.5573164225,
-0.0383150503,
-0.0037898736,
0.5306629539,
0.3447256982,
-0.1834304184,
-0.0699260011,
-0.5667666793,
0.0575482473,
-0.2053388357,
-0.5785137415,
-0.3684761524,
-0.0076523493,
-0.2341887355,
-0.2379401475,
0.517092824,
0.7971184254,
-0.4027773142,
-0.3563330173,
-0.3623091877,
-0.1109515354,
-0.502927959,
0.3649199903,
-0.2562884688,
-1.0277653933,
0.3731806874,
-0.1000172347,
-0.3564066291,
0.4615023732,
0.1924485564,
-0.360751003,
0.728921175,
0.1611194462,
-0.0178534277,
0.0365899839,
-0.1408240348,
0.3306090832,
-0.7371122241,
-0.0478137024,
-0.2595749199,
-0.1882298142,
-0.2410014868,
-0.7797062993,
0.075648427,
0.2615056634,
-0.4078775942,
0.1854311973,
-0.8572355509,
0.4640457928,
0.7519174814,
0.1462112814,
-0.0150304791,
-0.1494228244,
-0.2114402652,
-0.2955002189,
-0.8193820715,
-0.2627498209,
0.7835524082,
0.1558109373,
0.8702728748,
-0.0006514619,
1.1143648624,
0.4018656611,
-0.0488063432,
-0.403300494,
0.3341649175,
0.1427303404,
-0.9497675896,
-0.616666913,
-0.625256598,
-0.6269925237,
0.1754387468,
-0.1753697097,
-0.8784860373,
0.5580062866,
0.4431701303,
-0.9061355591,
0.2864866853,
-0.3958744705,
0.8539169431,
-0.6843758225,
-0.4391593635,
0.4200600684,
-1.202539444,
0.1801954359,
-0.5126466751,
0.3867147267,
-0.4184824228,
-0.0526619442,
0.6755530834,
-0.6850411892,
1.0214990377,
-0.0016276086,
0.2741127908,
0.627382338,
0.2028448582,
0.5238982439,
0.3366803825,
-0.2276029289,
0.3067228794,
-0.078933008,
-0.2962185144,
-0.4093631506,
0.4786665142,
-0.7975139618,
-0.2904984653,
-0.8925925493,
-0.461684823,
-0.2484196872,
0.2560039461,
0.7306157351,
0.359821558,
0.1840619296,
-0.0393103994,
0.8222720027,
-0.3002592623,
0.5097375512,
0.0102934493,
0.0872270763,
-0.7856017351,
1.1555612087,
0.5661750436,
0.3486654758,
0.2716407776,
0.0952214152,
-0.5116503239,
-0.5484631062,
-0.4710450768,
-0.305393219,
-0.6997997165,
-0.4916190803,
-0.7172024846,
-0.6038388014,
-0.4663957357,
-0.2123521119,
-0.6752568483,
-0.8823458552,
-0.5571898222,
-0.0379707068,
0.3698002696,
0.3369853497,
-0.6359336972,
0.7594898939,
-0.5830386877,
-0.1767136306,
0.3578032851,
0.2221488506,
-0.2136288732,
-0.7905960083,
-0.4466145635,
0.2932939231,
0.0059867078,
-0.8324941993,
0.638856709,
0.4161071181,
0.4870256186,
0.3720057607,
0.634237051,
0.6762623191,
-0.1471195668,
0.5536651015,
0.2212647945,
-1.1197541952,
0.6894358397,
-0.2737249136,
0.2329362184,
0.8377848268,
0.4108864963,
-0.3940858543,
-0.0905920714,
-0.7696877122,
-1.2675805092,
0.6747803688,
0.2787811756,
-0.0421136506,
-0.1412957907,
0.3547080755,
-0.0235399976,
0.3254907727,
-0.5902675986,
-0.275703311,
-0.569889009,
-0.4190940559,
-0.0080957012,
-0.1534015685,
0.2257353663,
-0.1304436177,
0.9593035579,
-0.2327552736,
0.0385358594,
0.4620067179,
-0.3147420287,
0.3617652357,
0.3382768333,
0.1956483573,
0.0828222185,
-0.2943171859,
0.2880145609,
0.4167782366,
-0.3438616693,
0.3600494266,
0.2961679697,
-0.4619137049,
-0.0694123656,
-0.1414696425,
0.6716026664,
0.2752372921,
-0.4822581708,
0.4689658284,
0.0684140697,
-0.0623109154,
-0.2947111428,
-0.0542651191,
0.0326016098,
0.2004181594,
0.104861252,
0.4330594838,
0.4929592311,
0.2505413592,
0.4490967691,
0.0393980518,
-0.7444607019,
0.0335686654,
0.779405117,
-0.0290570967,
-0.0448709577,
0.7065213323,
-0.4893604815,
-0.5693483353,
0.5624914765,
0.4609765708,
0.6112923026,
-0.4651995599,
0.5672344565,
0.4403766692,
0.2891236246,
-0.1745042354,
0.127515167,
-0.1461836696,
-0.6000066996,
-0.4137275219,
-0.5841338634,
-0.3424048126,
-0.2326217592,
-0.6628867984,
-0.175896287,
-0.8528161049,
-0.5952159166,
-0.2416585386,
-0.2366142124,
-0.4886112511,
0.5226604342,
0.2684004903,
0.3019476235,
-0.4819251895,
0.937066555,
0.4226565063,
-0.331617713,
-1.0553014278,
-0.4198364317,
0.1431232542,
-0.4659726024,
0.5508639812,
0.26729846,
0.0570343025,
0.0780865625,
-0.4717932045,
-1.359760046,
0.9994408488,
0.2772966623,
-0.8439457417,
0.3835197091,
0.1739649475,
0.2466149479,
-0.0588309243,
0.2398294955,
0.2477200925,
0.1357883811,
0.4356432259,
-0.4800932407,
0.0122824907,
-0.0922899693,
0.1108221859,
0.2006673962,
-0.7448203564,
0.7684361339,
-0.2261797339,
-0.1101780385,
0.0480300821,
0.9453619123,
0.1157748774,
0.3428114355,
0.2136298567,
0.5397436619,
1.2803348303,
0.0742093325,
0.4591976106,
-0.1947307438,
0.4001471996,
1.8172749281,
-0.1565153897,
0.7550875545,
0.2496058494,
-0.0580956005,
0.0180439968,
1.1720107794,
0.0423150435,
0.4760852158,
0.3518974483,
-0.2973261476,
-0.6953888535,
-0.1478420198,
-0.4694211781,
0.1596135348,
0.4592370689,
-0.357835114,
0.0759031847,
0.0038138835,
-0.1518334597,
-0.2406672239,
-0.1871832013,
0.3643303514,
0.2273719162,
-0.09799961,
0.395847708,
-0.200168699,
0.5623310804,
-0.3534543812,
0.4194919169,
-0.1491106451,
0.0313426591,
-0.1929104626,
-0.5170485973,
0.0751301721,
-0.4174756408,
0.1344960779,
-0.0130832121,
0.8978889585,
-0.3772309422,
-0.5004790425,
-0.0759536773,
0.4073376656,
0.3018886745,
-0.0825379565,
-0.9811931849,
-0.1221030056,
0.0924708992,
-0.2565817535,
0.4133675992,
0.6227309108,
-0.0641098619,
0.7743541002,
0.4974558353,
-0.2226555496,
0.3041658998,
-0.0771590322,
0.489975214,
-0.4236827791,
-0.4269144535,
-0.6039696336,
0.5632477403,
-0.2741223276,
-0.4952905476,
0.822766304,
0.4289053977,
0.7026138902,
0.1290323138,
0.8457237482,
0.0080680661,
0.4149065912,
-0.2423584014,
0.940387845,
-0.4089630544,
0.3692869544,
-0.2828159332,
-0.5400918722,
-0.4620735645,
1.0029445887,
-0.3685580194,
0.0252266489,
0.21074301,
0.7578082681,
0.0391119346,
0.0972883627,
0.4247899652,
0.0628503114,
-0.1584552526,
0.3400167227,
0.8957531452,
-0.4970636964,
0.4429401457,
-0.7476389408,
0.0479319207,
-0.0816200972,
-0.8719830513,
-0.7284326553,
-0.4238662422,
-0.8473128676,
-0.32214728,
0.3110229373,
1.1702024937,
1.0074474812,
-0.9078919291,
0.2668271363,
0.0557375662,
0.0603123195,
-0.1184100658,
-0.0984688029,
0.5837611556,
-0.3841284215,
-0.2161733359,
0.2791584134,
0.2482825667,
0.5199053884,
0.1649571955,
-0.1674615294,
-0.2722782195,
0.0510083698,
0.1452798992,
0.4877028167,
-0.537727654,
-0.2893720269,
-0.2179147154,
-0.2840887606,
-0.0278805345,
0.1289435774,
-0.7772943974,
0.7888751626,
0.2096518129,
1.0233170986,
0.5638241172,
0.1825102121,
0.267677635,
-1.0380687714,
-0.0171762537,
0.5391987562,
0.2227116376,
0.3571581244,
-0.6149329543,
0.7670893669,
0.1025765687,
-0.7979257107,
-0.529615581,
-0.0169416461,
-0.8416770101,
-0.2155501097,
0.8922213912,
-0.4721705317,
-0.4186737239,
-0.3380814493,
-0.0714691952,
0.3288222551,
-0.5883348584,
0.619412303,
0.4351122379,
-0.0157075077,
-0.2397376597,
-0.5474355221,
0.4624242485,
0.6510738134,
-0.4393976927,
-0.3092584014,
0.5699608326,
0.1347091496,
0.0096714282,
0.5703766346,
0.4164383113,
-0.0188513678,
-0.0619709715,
0.2299788147,
-0.0870752409,
-0.2180635035,
-0.2511469126,
-0.0755136684,
0.072451219,
-0.2491263747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10915v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10915v2 | Conformers are All You Need for Visual Speech Recognition | 2023-02-17T01:31:55 | 2023-12-13T04:31:44 | Oscar Chang, Hank Liao, Dmitriy Serdyuk, Ankit Shah, Olivier Siohan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS | Visual speech recognition models extract visual features in a hierarchical
manner. At the lower level, there is a visual front-end with a limited temporal
receptive field that processes the raw pixels depicting the lips or faces. At
the higher level, there is an encoder that attends to the embeddings produced
by the front-end over a large temporal receptive field. Previous work has
focused on improving the visual front-end of the model to extract more useful
features for speech recognition. Surprisingly, our work shows that complex
visual front-ends are not necessary. Instead of allocating resources to a
sophisticated visual front-end, we find that a linear visual front-end paired
with a larger Conformer encoder results in lower latency, more efficient memory
usage, and improved WER performance. We achieve a new state-of-the-art of 12.8%
WER for visual speech recognition on the TED LRS3 dataset, which rivals the
performance of audio-only models from just four years ago. | [
-0.3634474576,
-0.2920159698,
0.4027873576,
-0.0089393249,
-0.2320077717,
-0.2895556688,
-0.0739017799,
-0.5256271362,
-0.1432658434,
0.3282073736,
-0.1540696919,
-0.2376666665,
-0.7453027964,
-0.256392628,
-0.5126025677,
0.5020458698,
0.3029202819,
0.057039652,
-0.3100489974,
-0.2400927842,
-0.2631928325,
-0.2380995899,
-0.3653689921,
-0.2444292903,
0.7085231543,
-0.0186971743,
0.4525223076,
0.8578609228,
0.5696254969,
0.421287179,
-0.2678618729,
-0.3725275099,
-0.3734619617,
0.1794819981,
0.0773470625,
-0.3916435242,
-0.5553382039,
-0.0887154862,
0.6396400332,
0.3895359933,
-0.3699778914,
0.3312277496,
-0.1736261547,
0.8415176868,
-0.8044459224,
0.4222471714,
-0.7623426914,
0.1611908823,
-0.3113722503,
0.0147055695,
-0.3852365315,
-0.3953549564,
0.5619753599,
-0.8501231074,
0.3626157641,
-0.1089907363,
0.8430005908,
0.4741725624,
-0.0304443222,
0.0260256771,
-0.7340536714,
0.5315111279,
-0.4099066257,
1.3271914721,
-0.1065200269,
0.5739096999,
-0.0138335535,
-1.0786784887,
-0.5620151162,
-0.0559699051,
0.3097850382,
0.1909871548,
-0.7230429053,
0.0229230635,
0.4398583174,
0.3792003691,
-0.4361307919,
-0.017387677,
-0.8457996249,
-0.3466505706,
0.3279065192,
-0.1208617836,
0.1132427379,
0.4267087877,
-0.202166602,
-0.3351176083,
-0.337649256,
0.5279521346,
-0.2773638666,
0.2474031895,
-0.1709867418,
0.3880328238,
0.1184253171,
1.1508716345,
0.3179443479,
-0.3801554739,
0.2541607022,
0.207603693,
-0.4171693921,
-0.1192250177,
0.6026368141,
0.3220699728,
0.6936619878,
-0.0219831634,
-0.3473981023,
0.3186332583,
0.4313645661,
-0.8863712549,
-0.3964754939,
-0.0614197813,
-0.3957513273,
0.1940665543,
0.1779844463,
-0.4575723708,
-0.2773478627,
-0.5612522364,
0.4126299918,
-0.5025568604,
0.0557670929,
-0.107241787,
-0.4890109599,
0.5638124943,
0.6292623878,
-0.7160691619,
0.4412327409,
0.5217294693,
0.8219166994,
0.0454725176,
-0.0006964022,
-1.0468639135,
0.3077161014,
-0.247164771,
0.865314126,
-0.6066114306,
-0.2476304024,
-0.0558667779,
-0.0689895228,
0.2210314721,
-0.6948273182,
0.2303535342,
-0.5006352663,
-0.1308944821,
-0.4259489179,
-0.3671135008,
-0.1679046154,
-0.4178611636,
-0.7909993529,
0.4083698392,
-0.1193397269,
-0.38504228,
0.6460658908,
-0.1319042146,
-0.4121663272,
0.2585941255,
-0.5635925531,
-0.7250890732,
0.4666765332,
0.3903904259,
0.5300365686,
-0.0598808303,
-0.3863108456,
-0.2077935636,
-0.4598319232,
0.3046945632,
-0.1388064325,
0.2395084798,
0.2997721732,
0.0654811263,
0.3235813081,
-1.0172516108,
0.0202922653,
-0.1199678779,
-0.405334115,
-0.075355202,
0.0200539883,
0.3474074006,
0.0298073161,
0.0872795805,
-0.7304852605,
-0.3769496679,
-0.192617178,
0.7213208079,
0.7880991101,
-0.3965006173,
0.6203411222,
-0.2431754768,
0.2766475379,
0.1787653863,
0.2059380412,
-0.1657013297,
-0.6698755622,
-0.7998732924,
-0.714299202,
0.0103618652,
0.4711485207,
-0.5602472425,
0.4403001666,
-0.3637858629,
-0.5070625544,
-0.5203718543,
0.0154592944,
0.530767262,
0.4199669659,
0.3011210561,
-0.2400237024,
-0.5548071861,
-0.8202772737,
-0.0647664964,
-0.0385691337,
-0.2653470337,
0.0890815184,
0.2590805292,
-0.0071277772,
1.0258635283,
-0.4303485751,
-0.670576036,
0.0049352734,
-0.494671762,
0.2461860627,
0.1725898981,
0.475659281,
-0.9278169274,
-0.4069963694,
0.2262939811,
-0.5638233423,
0.1460731477,
0.0262879375,
0.4009776115,
0.0861702859,
0.5247378349,
-0.1371552348,
0.5105662346,
0.5981191397,
-0.0441221669,
-0.2140938491,
-0.0403325446,
-0.2798871696,
-0.4352543354,
-0.0103047267,
0.4235223532,
-0.4471538961,
-0.7837911248,
-0.4131223261,
0.1306390613,
-0.3736481369,
-0.4481684566,
0.2578546107,
-0.5457282066,
-0.1620373577,
0.1157930344,
0.3147040009,
-0.06286975,
0.4191635847,
0.0648498982,
0.8581075668,
0.7927988172,
-0.6357270479,
0.4177114367,
0.5467727184,
-0.0841055512,
0.7488307357,
-1.0287277699,
-0.0025248842,
-0.4642088711,
0.1660195738,
-0.9024745822,
-0.2184276283,
-0.118166171,
-0.5095620155,
0.5482967496,
-0.1338253021,
0.2874450088,
-0.4091061354,
-0.2056373656,
0.017866388,
0.9590625167,
-0.4583353102,
0.8173115253,
0.6507132649,
-0.0484641232,
-0.1999753267,
-1.0121833086,
-0.1760824323,
0.0994701385,
-0.558141768,
0.2147466093,
0.1695384681,
0.1074026972,
-0.2569409907,
-0.4872990251,
-0.0384914912,
-0.5535136461,
0.6267484426,
-0.0218085591,
-0.4312747717,
-0.196598053,
-0.5716802478,
-0.3359859884,
-0.2188438475,
-0.3731893599,
0.0042180289,
-0.5936252475,
-0.272104919,
-1.153984189,
0.1362377107,
0.6907670498,
-0.4188577831,
0.1929528862,
0.8238577247,
-0.3294437826,
0.1858033836,
-0.9408416748,
0.1053153053,
-0.4801542759,
0.4456247091,
-0.4641801417,
-0.9183639288,
0.3111982048,
0.2187102884,
0.0030556526,
0.0862760395,
0.3640688062,
-0.1431031674,
0.5904484391,
0.7111705542,
0.1342124194,
0.8748545051,
-0.1063621491,
0.1127638817,
-0.9935968518,
-0.5197662711,
-0.2460683286,
-0.2002008855,
-0.508338511,
-0.2521890402,
0.6339161396,
-0.1172363088,
-0.1911485493,
0.3146803379,
-0.7802730799,
0.2531936169,
0.5826678872,
0.4208737314,
0.0052495836,
0.1573443264,
0.3279993534,
-0.3288554251,
-0.6218414307,
-0.1940354407,
0.634349525,
0.5147752762,
1.0250532627,
0.0505983494,
0.478109777,
-0.071556747,
0.0502776243,
-0.8027333617,
0.6305725574,
-0.5096467137,
0.0752881318,
-0.3268022239,
-0.2005241215,
-0.6419348717,
0.1962672472,
-0.3630085289,
-0.5652073622,
0.5593187213,
0.5376324654,
-0.5128464699,
0.1593001485,
-0.5695661306,
0.4987682402,
0.1673783064,
-0.1327911913,
0.3325264752,
-0.6702193022,
-0.0520549603,
0.0855102614,
0.0925766751,
0.1316934675,
-0.142960906,
0.6955116987,
-0.2984975278,
0.8520643115,
-0.3324217498,
-0.2303873897,
0.231779635,
-0.2008967251,
0.3204518259,
-0.3033587933,
0.1211656034,
0.1880414039,
-0.0353169888,
-0.1178912222,
-0.5536133647,
0.3929593563,
-0.5477696657,
-0.6073163152,
-0.4845447838,
-0.3764978647,
0.0526790284,
-0.0204474125,
0.1805595756,
0.7122488618,
-0.2151050568,
0.5023512244,
0.8048533201,
-0.0641909093,
0.3535811305,
0.1703589708,
-0.1830762625,
-0.8124895692,
0.9361517429,
0.1037540659,
0.431828171,
0.5498706698,
0.1931635737,
-0.0656689554,
-0.6655544043,
-0.180060178,
0.1500693858,
-0.6678480506,
-0.1684961617,
-0.378466934,
-0.4355985522,
-0.4863078594,
-0.3076373637,
-0.4797507226,
-0.3604392409,
-0.207733646,
0.2948486209,
0.6042313576,
0.6377640963,
-0.2432109118,
0.6119226813,
-0.7659540176,
0.7229772806,
0.8063656688,
0.2637918293,
-0.1837878078,
-0.5211399794,
-0.1753156334,
-0.2313904166,
-0.2469671071,
-0.5404381752,
0.2528580427,
0.7322344184,
0.6374699473,
0.4502280951,
-0.4213179946,
1.0670106411,
-0.9570508003,
0.5686491132,
0.5897347927,
-1.0290048122,
0.6156554222,
-0.0960848927,
0.332541436,
-0.003368096,
0.0698929727,
-0.3169350922,
-0.1527479738,
-0.236776039,
-0.3942911625,
0.4964501858,
0.2944810092,
-0.2056067735,
0.4207644165,
0.4683289826,
-0.1308760494,
0.1660802513,
-0.5523185134,
-0.0089827925,
-0.5990495086,
-0.1359829009,
-0.014501458,
0.0303059705,
0.0353019275,
-0.4632225037,
0.1808726639,
-0.0076904674,
0.2303563952,
0.4443649352,
-0.0020325773,
-0.3015859723,
0.2374757081,
0.4348865449,
0.7146968246,
-0.198714599,
0.0686524361,
0.2433721423,
-0.8447634578,
-0.098022148,
0.0492029116,
-0.0754215419,
-0.0809289292,
0.5158862472,
1.0403792858,
0.1433508545,
-0.3583131135,
0.8142954111,
-0.0894359499,
-0.0475415438,
-0.4931766093,
0.3357489705,
-0.0521618165,
0.6286817789,
0.2517022491,
0.3112979233,
0.1040834412,
-0.4937286377,
0.3911373913,
0.4640399814,
-0.7249994278,
-0.3728581369,
0.8715944886,
0.3250142634,
-0.4123439491,
0.3383668363,
0.4544673264,
-0.4721309543,
0.2022455931,
0.5744769573,
0.8040614724,
-0.6184604168,
-0.1166163683,
0.2561519146,
0.1282194257,
0.0852358267,
0.5604050756,
-0.386687547,
-0.4474745393,
-0.1726212204,
-0.7456777692,
-0.2793521583,
-0.1452041566,
-0.9942204356,
0.2714480758,
-0.5403613448,
-0.2277134061,
0.2125054449,
-0.6331692934,
-0.6703631878,
0.260268569,
0.5668439269,
0.8324292302,
-0.489656657,
0.6548806429,
0.444760412,
-0.3902852833,
-0.0528702624,
-0.2736424208,
-0.0136819864,
-0.8413487077,
0.7858448625,
0.1464713067,
-0.4381043911,
0.1034253761,
-0.4785687625,
-0.6465560794,
1.1795728207,
0.3199177086,
-1.2037746906,
-0.187368989,
-0.0566516966,
0.4474927485,
-0.3452804089,
-0.1777843535,
0.5066944957,
0.2778097987,
0.579562366,
-0.9154581428,
0.0768988431,
-0.0312837772,
0.7173449397,
0.1349260211,
-0.4319420159,
0.9295456409,
-0.5359231234,
-0.3068004847,
-0.0328496136,
1.0557568073,
0.3875788748,
0.2082083076,
0.6383917928,
0.3619836867,
0.5825250149,
-0.2637854218,
0.7787911296,
0.119784534,
-0.227914989,
0.8071618676,
-0.2613034248,
1.1997759342,
0.7121464014,
-0.179524526,
0.2721054852,
0.0932907388,
-0.2168651223,
0.6819294095,
0.2613147795,
-0.0344288461,
-0.4808928668,
0.1532619447,
-0.4400908649,
0.4826875031,
0.5110129118,
-0.0639450327,
-0.1010795385,
0.195613727,
-0.4884601831,
0.2376105934,
-0.3108280897,
0.9695527554,
0.3182710409,
-0.0811990425,
0.7023797631,
-0.760422349,
0.6025675535,
-0.6551383138,
-0.215808332,
0.2963582575,
0.5382831097,
-0.3600429893,
-0.8037890196,
0.2579888999,
-0.0979182273,
-0.1958677918,
-0.3408264816,
0.4644612968,
-0.451477915,
-0.4181607962,
0.1223956347,
0.1940952688,
-0.0140716247,
-0.1975392401,
-0.3060383797,
0.4310590625,
-0.0711511001,
0.0431984887,
-0.2241826504,
0.5626796484,
0.1997811943,
0.64650172,
0.771951437,
0.2808957994,
0.3605523407,
0.3175890148,
1.1180862188,
-0.7770673037,
-0.5895075798,
-0.5727084279,
0.6196957827,
-0.0235738717,
-0.0794365332,
0.383403182,
0.4692040086,
0.683724165,
-0.1709900945,
0.651430428,
0.1787602901,
0.3720825315,
-0.6931019425,
0.5202075243,
-0.5759633183,
-0.0529554896,
-0.2746136487,
-0.7063282132,
-0.6025797725,
0.8574142456,
0.1231019273,
-0.14410685,
0.3062965274,
0.5539954305,
-0.2180175781,
0.0725785121,
0.6381991506,
0.4324816763,
0.5139685869,
0.612801075,
0.8307358027,
-0.7775714993,
0.5954483151,
-0.0294994768,
-0.5410237908,
0.0048650033,
-0.6418935061,
-1.0435538292,
-0.9231580496,
-0.3684723675,
-0.1487035304,
0.2380950898,
0.6047118306,
0.9392153025,
-0.8086567521,
-0.212358132,
0.0121863494,
-0.3944691122,
-0.0721605718,
-0.0741318688,
0.0600656383,
-0.1979635805,
-0.4355785251,
0.1964220107,
0.444501847,
0.3153820336,
-0.0075513367,
-0.0538298711,
0.126756236,
-0.2333636433,
0.7077556849,
0.4025944471,
-1.1403404474,
-0.4131044447,
0.0022437475,
0.1228756309,
0.34697631,
0.8162519932,
-1.0355187654,
0.3946377039,
0.5573154092,
0.3738510013,
0.8058024049,
-0.1829545498,
0.6982306838,
-0.5076661706,
0.3063545823,
-0.0000800111,
0.52091223,
0.4407451153,
-0.0149458246,
0.1738565266,
0.1699763834,
-0.4473419785,
-0.6326587796,
0.3443966806,
-1.5412886143,
0.2893732488,
0.7343728542,
0.0523461066,
-0.5299319029,
0.0629066229,
-0.2137137949,
0.3129093051,
-0.6202052832,
0.2492474318,
0.1819929928,
-0.3020635545,
-0.4311757982,
-0.390032053,
0.5813949704,
-0.4131559432,
-0.4573173821,
0.0922944173,
0.4946549833,
0.4017188549,
0.4733367264,
0.4928252101,
-0.1194490343,
0.4845847487,
0.1233132109,
0.1175927445,
-0.2585114539,
-0.4471692443,
-0.5434430242,
0.1311759502,
-0.3207702041,
-0.5379242897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08624v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08624v6 | InstructABSA: Instruction Learning for Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis | 2023-02-16T23:29:22 | 2023-11-13T17:56:19 | Kevin Scaria, Himanshu Gupta, Siddharth Goyal, Saurabh Arjun Sawant, Swaroop Mishra, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce InstructABSA, an instruction learning paradigm for Aspect-Based
Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) subtasks. Our method introduces positive, negative,
and neutral examples to each training sample, and instruction tune the model
(Tk-Instruct) for ABSA subtasks, yielding significant performance improvements.
Experimental results on the Sem Eval 2014, 15, and 16 datasets demonstrate that
InstructABSA outperforms the previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) approaches on
Term Extraction (ATE), Sentiment Classification(ATSC) and Sentiment Pair
Extraction (ASPE) subtasks. In particular, InstructABSA outperforms the
previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the Rest14 ATE subtask by 5.69% points, the
Rest15 ATSC subtask by 9.59% points, and the Lapt14 AOPE subtask by 3.37%
points, surpassing 7x larger models. We also get competitive results on AOOE,
AOPE, and AOSTE subtasks indicating strong generalization ability to all
subtasks. Exploring sample efficiency reveals that just 50% train data is
required to get competitive results with other instruction tuning approaches.
Lastly, we assess the quality of instructions and observe that InstructABSA's
performance experiences a decline of ~10% when adding misleading examples. | [
-0.3887624443,
-0.857200861,
0.4243736267,
0.2737353742,
-0.412396878,
0.328020066,
-0.0419737846,
-0.2511259913,
0.243168503,
0.6723694801,
-0.7356324196,
-0.9755408168,
-0.3884795904,
-0.3051334023,
-0.3091122806,
1.2357954979,
0.1141815707,
0.4838045537,
-0.5045437217,
-0.1175684407,
-0.5997610688,
-0.4307349324,
-0.8019277453,
-0.1537955999,
0.002945987,
1.0077127218,
0.0003913265,
0.267026186,
0.4314229488,
0.179126218,
-0.1279352456,
0.1293499768,
-0.0370195843,
0.2091453224,
-0.3089600503,
-0.7548294067,
-0.592351079,
0.0311825871,
0.2882016003,
0.7536582351,
-0.2507213652,
0.2776396871,
0.2329740375,
0.9326854348,
-0.7808674574,
0.3593270481,
-0.306074053,
-0.0511033759,
-0.2123376578,
0.0367923193,
-0.5639759898,
-0.6286635399,
0.0242031608,
-0.2466836274,
0.330494374,
0.2355950475,
0.6024686098,
0.2301035076,
-0.2192585766,
-0.5922732353,
-0.3160732388,
0.8873724937,
-0.7362181544,
0.3139261007,
0.4231289625,
0.0917697474,
-0.0865985304,
-0.4849933684,
-0.2896470428,
-0.1865116805,
0.1867963225,
0.4670194089,
0.0006692893,
0.3973802924,
0.1038201004,
0.8055117726,
-0.152800113,
0.3487592936,
-0.1975335181,
0.1130714566,
0.6158836484,
0.2909306884,
0.1352274418,
-0.4086937606,
-0.3586065769,
-0.1430142075,
-0.9257802367,
0.5270855427,
0.5311684608,
0.199380815,
-0.2226439863,
0.3946616054,
-0.101281181,
0.3376810849,
0.340395391,
-0.0253589042,
0.2391343415,
-0.0468455516,
-0.2015839964,
0.2732251585,
0.679079473,
0.1654726118,
-0.4751529098,
0.1552279592,
-0.355039835,
0.0732254386,
0.6279726624,
-0.6481294632,
-0.5448769331,
0.1480502188,
-0.5759305954,
-0.2289121002,
0.1475582421,
-1.0014761686,
-0.492290616,
-0.4443367422,
0.6356974244,
-0.8121221066,
-0.0622032024,
-0.169895947,
0.2228827029,
0.4463701844,
0.2655172348,
-0.8608520031,
0.4230079651,
1.0656971931,
0.6785117388,
-0.1065986082,
0.0596871115,
-0.50470227,
-0.4034482539,
-0.7428382039,
0.8881701827,
-0.7550677657,
-0.5040281415,
0.099881649,
-0.0163364243,
0.0555534624,
-0.7220146656,
0.3007881045,
-0.3362417817,
0.2621876597,
-0.420750469,
-0.9268027544,
-0.8182934523,
0.2139537185,
-0.4197127521,
1.1777654886,
0.3866133094,
-0.363697648,
0.3667517304,
-0.9485958219,
-0.7207807899,
-0.1926693767,
-0.0215107519,
-0.6176528931,
0.3656949997,
0.3537426293,
0.6585096717,
-0.2322342098,
-0.3582780361,
-0.1327939183,
-0.2710944712,
0.079344295,
-0.1034243479,
0.6113048196,
0.1048790216,
-0.4328085184,
0.2593218982,
-0.601976037,
-0.0746262372,
-0.4285007119,
-0.0390460417,
-0.6546857953,
0.0099773789,
-0.2752712071,
-0.2447680384,
0.1445884854,
-0.787761867,
0.223746419,
-0.6778215766,
0.1298788786,
0.8805265427,
0.3431424499,
0.4161600471,
0.0982264802,
0.9363340735,
0.2930825651,
0.4903143644,
-0.2138578892,
-0.1558538079,
-1.221663475,
-0.2940161228,
0.3821219802,
0.4023773968,
-1.0674533844,
0.4616911113,
0.1626087874,
-0.6445381045,
-0.8147143126,
0.1889102161,
0.8561726809,
0.510997355,
0.5276811123,
-0.7257317901,
-0.4037090838,
-0.9729870558,
0.0742451772,
-0.1427743882,
0.2435415089,
-0.1540095657,
0.4223612249,
0.2694844604,
0.6341351271,
-0.5502225161,
-0.4453517497,
-0.7457849383,
0.4210036397,
0.1476947367,
0.3918015659,
0.5837157369,
-0.6012624502,
-0.5595307946,
-0.0525082313,
-0.6875892878,
0.0975123569,
0.0983595252,
-0.1137452722,
0.5179834962,
0.4688894153,
-0.0531488098,
0.3862707317,
0.3972262144,
-0.1923488677,
0.380033493,
0.0380410701,
0.2844257653,
-1.4884643555,
-0.5580706,
0.2935151756,
-0.1005725414,
-0.2726947665,
0.0320089385,
0.1813448966,
0.1348871887,
-0.501141727,
-0.0423570685,
-0.3442603946,
-0.0760071203,
-0.5030851364,
-0.4192155004,
-0.1593529731,
0.7297205329,
-0.1999128461,
0.9707779288,
0.5649377704,
-0.5867263675,
0.2023872733,
0.0788659677,
-0.714114964,
0.7349849939,
-0.4887557328,
0.3370540142,
-0.1747805327,
0.0125925802,
-0.7912157774,
-0.1307119429,
0.4638624191,
-0.0857121274,
0.7015820146,
-0.3211095631,
-0.0470276214,
-0.0601792,
-0.528100729,
-0.0108763436,
0.680650115,
-0.6358900666,
0.8232342005,
0.5324261785,
-0.2316816896,
-0.8138447404,
-0.2336643785,
-0.2792764306,
-0.1765665412,
0.1119837463,
0.2059061825,
0.2572212219,
-0.090770103,
0.314774096,
-0.2522230744,
-0.0296513941,
0.0508589447,
0.5760910511,
0.3080073893,
-0.3713635504,
0.1157292947,
0.5928615332,
-0.0091275126,
0.2614296377,
0.0373557694,
0.4446249902,
-0.3336831927,
-0.4763903022,
-0.8232596517,
0.3808990121,
0.1579525471,
-0.3119296432,
0.7065383196,
0.288692981,
-0.0990655869,
-0.5924582481,
-0.4652108848,
-0.1302857697,
-0.4613963664,
0.7344043255,
-0.1925250292,
-0.5031045675,
0.1382990628,
-0.1375136077,
0.3195261955,
0.1637449116,
0.1212867051,
-0.5398802757,
0.8470002413,
1.0963641405,
-0.1948708296,
0.8998705149,
-0.7474399209,
0.1649572402,
-1.0585376024,
-0.4599520266,
-0.3755599558,
-0.2377494723,
-0.2760634422,
-0.1337406933,
0.5861797929,
0.0181435402,
-0.1191363931,
0.2218047529,
-0.3793880939,
0.6309252977,
0.6084635854,
0.5378271937,
-0.1567249,
-0.1427485198,
0.4779243469,
-0.1791883856,
-0.5689986348,
-0.4456894696,
1.1167402267,
0.2503885627,
1.0134373903,
-0.1165121347,
0.9415050745,
0.5417075753,
0.6537132859,
-1.2704726458,
0.7202023864,
-0.7788113952,
-0.0141935032,
0.0377181061,
-0.023389332,
-0.5057008266,
-0.0793487281,
0.0558989197,
-0.2765353024,
0.1024575606,
0.4021293521,
-0.3254734576,
0.2915531993,
-0.8444082737,
0.7173424363,
-0.1591183096,
-0.105135709,
-0.5434829593,
-0.4274455607,
0.1498562694,
0.3059150875,
0.0577623472,
0.176323995,
-0.0019746742,
1.0153952837,
-0.246989578,
1.2994211912,
-0.4549820721,
0.0064348686,
0.5609223843,
0.0715638995,
0.1364303827,
-0.0721894056,
-0.0265892185,
0.2031335831,
-0.0658201203,
-0.2295741588,
-0.9598660469,
0.4670990109,
-0.6348375082,
-0.7210993767,
-0.3360853195,
-0.3058261573,
-0.4719072878,
-0.2298536301,
0.3934829831,
0.7442526817,
-0.1551369727,
0.4327996969,
1.1636931896,
-0.144830972,
0.3390164673,
0.3660422266,
0.1218988523,
-0.5892766118,
1.1563439369,
0.0860249326,
0.121766299,
0.566865623,
0.051137764,
-0.2714590728,
-0.6228736043,
-0.4184032977,
-0.0758221298,
-0.8204939961,
-0.4548255801,
-0.348287642,
-0.1625434905,
-0.1758740842,
-0.0677931681,
-0.8543950319,
-0.1689838022,
-0.204753384,
-0.2917844951,
0.2485799938,
1.0812273026,
0.1889882982,
0.4826589823,
-0.7149314284,
-0.0981501117,
0.1107993275,
0.0634748638,
0.1152412966,
-0.6401383877,
-0.643865943,
-0.0440324619,
-0.6926213503,
-0.9664192796,
0.1869095564,
0.1512432843,
0.5481005907,
0.565458715,
0.113627933,
0.5458729863,
-0.1922409236,
1.0889027119,
0.0420112051,
-1.2559299469,
0.7199561596,
0.2130682021,
-0.1038258225,
0.625459075,
0.5725493431,
-0.2770761251,
-0.530621171,
-0.5674409866,
-0.964419961,
0.9193534851,
-0.2379656285,
0.3574840724,
0.1387403309,
0.5818038583,
0.6252086163,
0.2583090067,
-0.2095116824,
-0.2260184884,
-0.5296922922,
-0.7865054607,
0.0833780318,
-0.4449208379,
0.0412909724,
-0.3256799579,
1.1862057447,
-0.1956007481,
0.0782852694,
-0.0395053029,
0.0247564651,
0.1422892511,
0.5018131137,
0.1165359095,
0.5618135333,
0.0567729361,
-0.031217467,
0.2306667864,
-0.5898259282,
0.0908607319,
-0.3348348737,
-0.1845134199,
-0.2910766006,
0.5630589128,
0.8668212891,
0.4121832252,
-0.3788014948,
0.4879211187,
0.1846144199,
0.0315133892,
-0.4517840445,
0.4799612463,
-0.2106959522,
0.3361281157,
0.1744747162,
-0.0795034543,
0.3381629288,
-0.6547193527,
-0.1380698383,
0.3417543769,
-0.7794367075,
-0.5995593667,
0.311835736,
0.2511098981,
-0.1228513867,
0.6106235981,
-0.2697785199,
-0.5798631907,
0.7566776276,
0.3491594791,
1.189324379,
-0.3957255781,
0.4688572586,
0.2072949558,
0.2592992783,
0.0555701703,
0.6008872986,
-0.1380146891,
-0.4790227711,
-0.3163097799,
-0.6582453847,
-0.8765838742,
0.2088367641,
-1.184685111,
0.0075093061,
-0.5208733082,
0.1662210375,
0.001460126,
-0.0016734978,
-0.1926723868,
0.3231797814,
-0.3272603452,
0.7010405064,
-1.0038379431,
0.7225218415,
1.3963528872,
-0.6029260755,
-0.9193391204,
0.3141272366,
-0.1258262843,
-0.3667865098,
0.3856033981,
0.2110309601,
-0.166674003,
-0.3253164887,
-0.8372625113,
-0.3248511553,
0.727142632,
0.3045216799,
-0.2206879705,
0.345849514,
-0.2282804102,
0.5323254466,
-0.5242992043,
-0.0630167425,
0.4978232086,
-0.1552453339,
-0.1262757033,
-0.3630543053,
-0.1156932935,
-0.0903970301,
-0.0619454384,
0.4141098559,
-0.8765303493,
0.7828131318,
-0.0970128179,
0.0497793406,
-0.0005055828,
1.262201786,
-0.1523004174,
0.5953235626,
0.7136384845,
0.4767353535,
0.3922607303,
-0.0564723611,
0.8820331097,
0.0033510176,
0.1131547317,
1.1609922647,
-0.0114037655,
0.9445431828,
0.2978126705,
-0.2067526132,
1.0334631205,
0.7613846064,
0.2897483706,
0.7049703598,
-0.4419828355,
-0.3463217616,
-0.5273429155,
-0.1979846954,
-0.2611165643,
0.6846057177,
0.7153810263,
-0.2245982289,
0.0104020089,
0.3323034644,
0.1808133274,
0.2996805608,
-0.521515727,
1.0271742344,
0.2104058266,
-0.693900764,
-0.0925029516,
-0.1680893153,
0.5719175339,
-0.7788703442,
-0.3612819016,
-0.5031034946,
0.3452418149,
-0.2548451126,
-0.8594182134,
0.2487402111,
-0.0810233727,
-0.2213715911,
-0.0137017053,
0.3002435565,
-0.3350279629,
-0.5023629665,
-0.1222062707,
0.0755124837,
0.0996257216,
0.132441774,
-0.3827168941,
-0.3403747082,
0.1871946901,
-0.426476866,
0.3738892972,
0.3546316326,
-0.2785382867,
0.5297817588,
0.221415922,
-0.0646960586,
-0.3094212115,
0.0176160131,
0.8454802036,
-0.6427432895,
-0.6588418484,
-0.6712914109,
0.3323630393,
-0.2576530576,
-0.4194762111,
0.8548011184,
0.565182209,
0.9913913012,
-0.1937460005,
0.7985713482,
-0.1800467521,
0.5744575262,
-1.0578633547,
0.4778122008,
-0.7261416316,
0.3196054399,
-0.1591357291,
-0.7289721966,
0.1367881,
0.3490247726,
-0.4336279631,
-0.1840771139,
0.7940919399,
0.8194475174,
-0.1347559094,
0.5783059001,
-0.025355747,
0.0711284429,
0.2742550969,
0.3258624971,
1.0281455517,
-0.2347671092,
0.1881504059,
-1.054172039,
-0.5127581954,
-0.0599190407,
-0.5305703282,
-0.9768894911,
-0.674826622,
-0.6139714122,
-0.1958405077,
0.102971673,
1.2225264311,
0.6356396675,
-1.2056314945,
-0.1811801642,
0.0917618424,
0.2060018629,
-0.7590153813,
-0.260334909,
0.6508245468,
-0.8039701581,
-0.8864186406,
0.5844885707,
0.2713769078,
-0.1682412326,
-0.2368462384,
0.2218866646,
0.2448322177,
0.0627278835,
0.7543243766,
0.1357325464,
-0.5213050842,
-0.2810856402,
-0.144677043,
0.181701079,
0.0080480073,
0.9816372395,
-0.4345558584,
0.3953281641,
0.3243437707,
0.5594434738,
0.1995828003,
0.2516457736,
0.2664761245,
-0.9536830187,
0.1646461338,
0.3707513213,
0.301649332,
0.2413848191,
-0.4786053002,
0.5026488304,
0.0150795998,
-0.3662895262,
-0.6793715954,
0.200078994,
-0.9564442039,
-0.2760291994,
0.8936473727,
-0.3693068922,
-0.552901268,
-0.0735704675,
-0.2795547545,
0.2648803592,
-0.5807340741,
1.0196449757,
0.479408443,
-0.6951155066,
-0.0201329868,
-0.2516368032,
0.433360666,
0.6994672418,
-1.0285390615,
-0.14377442,
0.546413362,
0.2959678173,
-0.0385054424,
0.3574615121,
0.0102647878,
0.3758226037,
-0.0813907683,
0.4065635502,
-0.3091790974,
-0.5416575074,
-0.2483657598,
0.3488187492,
0.0542781055,
-0.9081695676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10186v7 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10186v7 | E2E Spoken Entity Extraction for Virtual Agents | 2023-02-16T21:45:35 | 2023-11-09T20:51:27 | Karan Singla, Yeon-Jun Kim, Srinivas Bangalore | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | In human-computer conversations, extracting entities such as names, street
addresses and email addresses from speech is a challenging task. In this paper,
we study the impact of fine-tuning pre-trained speech encoders on extracting
spoken entities in human-readable form directly from speech without the need
for text transcription. We illustrate that such a direct approach optimizes the
encoder to transcribe only the entity relevant portions of speech ignoring the
superfluous portions such as carrier phrases, or spell name entities. In the
context of dialog from an enterprise virtual agent, we demonstrate that the
1-step approach outperforms the typical 2-step approach which first generates
lexical transcriptions followed by text-based entity extraction for identifying
spoken entities. | [
-0.5759019256,
-1.0254682302,
0.4165292382,
-0.2454970926,
-0.3292473853,
0.1182336211,
-0.3281446397,
-1.0284240246,
0.4266513586,
0.8933535814,
-0.6724058986,
-0.2311486155,
-0.4776804447,
0.3240071833,
-0.3234169185,
0.8683719635,
0.3753192723,
-0.1981021166,
-0.1159415543,
0.3009379506,
-0.2405826598,
-0.4217331111,
-0.9626275301,
-0.2130409181,
0.2756797671,
0.520295918,
0.5078892112,
0.618563652,
0.2009839416,
0.364941299,
0.1237879843,
0.4631223083,
-0.4974669814,
0.4148612022,
-0.1988305748,
-0.4505818486,
-0.5925459266,
-0.1428701729,
0.3794953525,
0.3822532594,
-0.2465522289,
0.2136706561,
-0.0049597928,
0.3069998622,
-0.5424861908,
0.3500688076,
-0.7994106412,
-0.1605060548,
-0.3760147095,
-0.3348421156,
-0.5950579643,
-0.1096954793,
0.4394984841,
-0.7469228506,
0.1947694123,
-0.0102934605,
1.3089169264,
0.3799186051,
-0.1956756115,
-0.4495528936,
-1.0553729534,
0.5308563709,
-0.239112854,
0.6704186201,
0.352417618,
0.1947287172,
-0.0042368202,
-0.93568331,
-0.7011324763,
0.0035111983,
-0.035513442,
0.1229894012,
-0.4352391362,
0.4292915165,
0.379823029,
-0.0424745008,
-0.3330825567,
0.282224685,
-0.4218344688,
-0.34852615,
0.3363075256,
-0.0923717991,
0.4102548659,
0.0523151532,
-0.1576776356,
-0.1452673972,
-0.5995285511,
0.0037779736,
0.2447458804,
0.2550012171,
0.3361081481,
0.5015126467,
0.0655727983,
0.2281359881,
0.3540769517,
-0.0367406011,
0.2195461988,
-0.0207412709,
-0.5046719313,
0.3275157213,
0.4200479984,
0.0472099334,
0.5442563295,
-0.5850319862,
-0.1516754776,
-0.1801608056,
0.41478163,
-0.9599195719,
-0.0678966343,
0.2755172253,
-0.17737858,
0.0752640367,
0.277510643,
-0.9835330248,
-0.0933866873,
-0.6151400208,
0.2364521772,
-0.2609885633,
-0.3726456761,
-0.1754638702,
-0.3022889197,
0.3794145584,
0.4719318748,
-0.9086947441,
0.7074041367,
0.7989838123,
0.3766914606,
0.0671361163,
0.1531388611,
-0.8778757453,
0.3807153106,
-0.0101047391,
0.8404202461,
-0.6978700757,
-0.3665004075,
-0.0998916179,
0.0605811998,
0.0806830153,
-0.9139718413,
0.3940412104,
-0.6192708015,
-0.0370354094,
-0.1025398523,
-0.6117808223,
-0.0282183662,
-0.1557786614,
-0.6251349449,
0.6440919638,
-0.1158396676,
-0.218097344,
0.339050144,
-0.6282313466,
-0.5312855244,
0.2421000153,
-0.3584981859,
-0.224299103,
0.0821430236,
0.4289314449,
0.3025814593,
-0.3892543316,
-0.2775312364,
0.0949167237,
-0.1332059205,
-0.0795330852,
-0.2788446248,
0.5467847586,
0.1324030906,
-0.7507090569,
-0.2579039931,
-0.9528968334,
0.3972429037,
0.1420692056,
-0.1736923605,
-0.3459517658,
-0.0378500111,
0.154404968,
0.1064210832,
0.1166492477,
-0.5433706641,
-0.0814852491,
-0.7044193149,
0.3516515791,
0.5944327712,
0.2717137933,
0.5483510494,
0.1142509431,
0.4325915277,
0.1062780395,
-0.1554847509,
0.108120501,
-0.3385590017,
-0.8871641755,
-0.4906778038,
0.3756879866,
0.797172904,
-0.9576621056,
0.4366426468,
-0.4939127862,
-0.5497915149,
-0.8227809072,
0.0898179859,
0.4494199753,
0.4149649739,
0.3539475203,
-0.2758585513,
-0.7837597132,
-1.0341457129,
-0.4115143716,
-0.1639211476,
-0.1844254732,
0.4411352575,
0.2006208301,
-0.3432116508,
1.0494724512,
-0.2818450034,
-0.1031167284,
-0.3904818296,
0.0103580533,
-0.3301106095,
0.4430966675,
0.1283220649,
-0.8926671147,
-0.3124615252,
-0.0146762021,
-0.4433230758,
-0.1298840791,
-0.1845450401,
-0.1848849058,
0.0409444682,
0.4312392175,
-1.0675967932,
0.1765647382,
0.0814137608,
-0.1207908988,
0.0621805266,
-0.2693382204,
-0.1642433256,
-0.8528295159,
-0.2646891475,
0.1820354164,
-0.640461266,
-0.9359592199,
-0.2532526851,
-0.094635278,
-0.2402835041,
-0.4591016769,
0.2756833732,
-0.9288284183,
-0.3026371598,
-0.0907371715,
0.5117907524,
0.080879502,
0.2902811468,
0.3784513772,
0.7591770291,
0.3365715146,
-0.7919360995,
0.1421483457,
0.4096970558,
-0.0724804252,
0.6276439428,
-0.7094346881,
0.9333380461,
-0.5272382498,
-0.0151381437,
-0.2889471054,
-0.0160269793,
0.3273916245,
-0.3728296757,
0.7319094539,
-0.0216473732,
-0.37816751,
-0.0072580548,
0.1243208423,
-0.2074165791,
0.4790368974,
-0.4111833572,
0.735419631,
0.8711870313,
-0.2872715294,
-0.0877868459,
-0.6221501827,
0.2237190306,
-0.0345160849,
-0.6464967132,
0.4147897661,
0.3699488938,
-0.3172859848,
-0.1371477246,
-0.1201483458,
-0.3903100789,
0.1625207365,
0.3326712847,
0.0785789341,
-0.3216124773,
0.0783902332,
0.0984101221,
-0.1561251432,
0.045574218,
-0.269588232,
0.4286899269,
0.023461815,
-0.0171516538,
-0.7664177418,
0.531134069,
0.3708865643,
-0.4792133868,
0.5978327394,
0.5164796114,
-0.7752484083,
-0.1696259528,
-0.671567142,
-0.3855539262,
-0.4756626785,
0.5665065646,
-0.6793715954,
-0.6925562024,
0.0692620873,
-0.4072706699,
0.1227928847,
0.4491136968,
0.225372538,
-0.10464257,
0.8451685309,
0.671970129,
0.1356330961,
0.5154054761,
-0.0795498714,
0.3408140838,
-0.6530527472,
-0.3958763182,
-0.726978004,
0.0302377064,
-0.5573903918,
-0.1551641971,
0.0301062539,
-0.0539129041,
0.062748611,
0.6753353477,
-0.3459029496,
0.4041581154,
0.5392279029,
0.2364292443,
-0.0670161769,
0.2417028993,
0.4189014733,
-0.247780472,
-0.1046280563,
-0.8629492521,
0.6540111899,
0.3631843328,
0.3064480424,
0.1924687326,
0.917662859,
0.2765935957,
-0.1522446126,
-0.654263854,
0.4599123597,
0.0011409263,
-0.5474230051,
-0.6035114527,
-0.344548136,
-1.0662441254,
0.3222102821,
-0.2971987724,
-1.0515546799,
0.3809142113,
0.0402270295,
-0.4609826207,
-0.011265371,
-0.9312666059,
0.7892584801,
-0.1218417659,
-0.0432583205,
-0.17497316,
-0.4389378726,
-0.3014383316,
-0.0491334274,
0.233924225,
0.1431695819,
-0.0572588257,
0.7284053564,
-0.5462465286,
0.5125860572,
-0.4447803795,
0.021325862,
0.508470118,
-0.0005333165,
0.9451024532,
-0.0801982433,
0.0417978428,
0.2897475362,
0.0105772549,
-0.2116209716,
-0.6568465233,
0.2575123012,
-0.8285963535,
-0.6394196749,
0.1275931448,
0.3520869017,
-0.3013414443,
0.3238265514,
0.339402765,
0.5260658264,
-0.3522535264,
0.1192252636,
0.7811691165,
-0.0863912553,
0.2860749662,
0.4742416441,
0.3835117817,
-0.3588569462,
0.934016943,
0.2840811908,
0.219524771,
0.4652549028,
-0.3334860206,
-0.4156213701,
-0.228502661,
-0.547529459,
0.1419042498,
-0.5994944572,
0.0500813387,
-0.9805842042,
-0.0434296541,
-0.7318943143,
0.1083230749,
-0.5692058206,
-0.2708916366,
-0.8061534762,
-0.3253268301,
-0.2884446681,
0.6808704138,
0.0691184476,
0.2576442361,
-0.8983359933,
0.4984717369,
0.3893033266,
-0.2578599751,
-0.3642783463,
-0.2858941555,
-0.0564611219,
0.308767885,
-0.1973751485,
-1.1205525398,
0.460916549,
0.7238397002,
0.5951201916,
0.5684243441,
-0.1165062115,
1.0184589624,
-0.6776938438,
0.8110634685,
0.0341724493,
-1.0324789286,
0.7725486159,
0.2966389656,
-0.2206285745,
0.5250974894,
0.0616078079,
-0.2762194276,
-0.1968177855,
-0.6524885893,
-0.9109734297,
0.7927241325,
0.5202792883,
0.0869113505,
-0.1766257286,
0.5747440457,
0.0048959614,
0.2121454775,
-0.2621748447,
-0.4961013794,
-0.0504497513,
-0.107640624,
-0.1270352006,
-0.5212264061,
0.219388023,
-0.0004507942,
0.7060793042,
0.3026436269,
0.4870977402,
0.5411130786,
-0.5888860226,
-0.0635700598,
0.4346033037,
0.4983919859,
0.2815826237,
0.0055274032,
0.1529380083,
0.235665381,
-0.7143421173,
0.0141024245,
0.0635194033,
-0.2213010192,
0.376389116,
0.1502875537,
0.9494982958,
0.1017255113,
-0.6189079285,
0.4266561866,
-0.119677864,
-0.0606134012,
-0.6694908738,
0.0903470367,
-0.1797731221,
0.4137761593,
0.1456272006,
-0.0407795161,
0.3902873397,
-0.5537905097,
0.1873961091,
0.2114656568,
-0.5518863201,
-0.5757181644,
0.6806313396,
0.4516521692,
-0.6782456636,
0.8032428622,
-0.1678576469,
-0.3180578649,
0.5863013864,
0.7603939772,
1.182615757,
-0.2004698366,
0.1322979778,
0.1266738027,
0.5560536981,
0.0878012925,
0.1046146005,
-0.199383378,
-0.7281384468,
-0.1001094207,
-0.3488542438,
-0.36594221,
-0.0533395261,
-0.7884789109,
0.3190027475,
-0.2359626889,
-0.3046253324,
0.4296054244,
-0.1171492636,
-1.1483963728,
0.2457936257,
0.514431715,
0.5651908517,
-0.2730510235,
0.9140720367,
0.7195975184,
-0.307610482,
-0.9469540119,
-0.2111595869,
-0.0409579836,
-0.465180546,
0.59106493,
0.3332368433,
-0.2444489747,
0.4897882044,
-0.3008020222,
-0.8040488362,
0.9870842695,
0.6625959873,
-0.9821282625,
-0.286796391,
0.3044609725,
0.5694471598,
-0.2504368126,
0.6624403596,
0.7694166899,
0.4528089762,
-0.2040934712,
-1.1038302183,
-0.0142525937,
-0.2267945111,
-0.1218726113,
0.1584226936,
-0.377250433,
0.431976974,
-0.0541833863,
-0.7611327767,
-0.3782405257,
0.8732243776,
-0.3586109579,
0.1380959302,
0.7168496251,
0.2544428408,
1.2658348083,
0.0125111761,
0.7931504846,
-0.0362527668,
0.0463067777,
1.1460351944,
-0.374581039,
0.76929003,
0.5391315818,
0.0221383534,
0.3605794013,
0.470390588,
0.2473671883,
0.6323118806,
0.1269599944,
-0.2371825725,
-0.3819829524,
-0.0462232716,
-0.0788577721,
0.7653577924,
0.475817889,
-0.1736504883,
0.0820375681,
0.0434633493,
-0.0240639281,
-0.2361095846,
-0.2368590981,
1.3724676371,
0.1763987243,
-0.4842095077,
0.3138195276,
-0.0041540135,
0.3112058938,
-0.1130982116,
-0.2740302384,
0.2764148116,
-0.0256507564,
-0.2153248787,
-0.1501260996,
0.3367094398,
0.1875174195,
-0.0642972142,
-0.2912293077,
0.9542847872,
-0.4543262124,
0.0970845297,
0.1554443687,
0.5150071383,
0.6128542423,
-0.5683290362,
-0.4185431004,
-0.3189739883,
0.0832434595,
-0.567846477,
0.0540105626,
0.6295588613,
0.2342536598,
0.3120532036,
0.6775122285,
0.2765603065,
0.0535656214,
0.1145782024,
0.6368525028,
-0.6799559593,
-0.4307830036,
-0.9795515537,
0.4891743958,
-0.3380078971,
-0.1547135562,
0.3000341058,
0.6157875061,
0.815449059,
-0.0130130528,
0.7032680511,
0.0775637254,
0.5830643177,
-0.5754801035,
0.5066488385,
-0.1863244176,
0.2135473043,
-0.245527342,
-1.0911284685,
0.1910916716,
0.4363432825,
-0.0213617869,
-0.3664222062,
0.4845491946,
0.7570067644,
0.2352073342,
0.1735853255,
0.5439680815,
0.2020491809,
0.5145899057,
0.2296114564,
0.5051243305,
-0.4479119778,
0.6271199584,
-0.1213995442,
-0.0364270508,
-0.015023767,
-0.3130792677,
-0.8635933995,
-0.3732160628,
-0.4607081711,
-0.3138240874,
0.1314720362,
1.2155601978,
0.7628111243,
-0.7301961184,
0.4042139649,
0.0219051912,
-0.1174607202,
-0.0548231043,
-0.1999586672,
0.1465078592,
-0.0876317173,
-1.1034857035,
0.5946500301,
0.3881253302,
0.1831168979,
0.0807147622,
0.007606097,
0.3329169452,
0.2924891412,
0.5067173839,
0.3029154539,
-0.7929814458,
-0.6477101445,
0.0367518961,
-0.2981441319,
0.1005767807,
0.5237205029,
-0.536734581,
0.4562112391,
0.0974929407,
0.770151794,
0.6781356335,
0.1614929736,
0.5053288341,
-0.6243822575,
0.2162390351,
0.2869746983,
0.1560327858,
0.0668318272,
-0.6631678343,
0.117948465,
0.1646470726,
-0.3880082071,
-0.5301343799,
0.0200714897,
-1.0007969141,
0.0997807384,
1.1354854107,
-0.2533495426,
-0.3717826307,
-0.3743245602,
-0.4578916132,
0.5132399201,
-0.5372964144,
0.3475216329,
0.3687170446,
0.0375403725,
-0.3650585413,
-0.612914145,
0.5021650195,
0.1372240782,
-1.0833611488,
-0.2999504805,
0.4335495234,
0.2089333534,
0.0492732264,
0.87590909,
0.1330427229,
0.0136719961,
0.2061712444,
0.3597688377,
-0.0725949034,
-0.3752275407,
-0.1391159743,
0.2854886949,
-0.0364253931,
-0.3301947415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08590v1 | What A Situated Language-Using Agent Must be Able to Do: A Top-Down Analysis | 2023-02-16T21:30:26 | 2023-02-16T21:30:26 | David Schlangen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even in our increasingly text-intensive times, the primary site of language
use is situated, co-present interaction. It is primary ontogenetically and
phylogenetically, and it is arguably also still primary in negotiating everyday
social situations. Situated interaction is also the final frontier of Natural
Language Processing, where, compared to the area of text processing, very
little progress has been made in the past decade, and where a myriad of
practical applications is waiting to be unlocked. While the usual approach in
the field is to reach, bottom-up, for the ever next "adjacent possible", in
this paper I attempt a top-down analysis of what the demands are that
unrestricted situated interaction makes on the participating agent, and suggest
ways in which this analysis can structure computational models and research on
them. Specifically, I discuss representational demands (the building up and
application of world model, language model, situation model, discourse model,
and agent model) and what I call anchoring processes (incremental processing,
incremental learning, conversational grounding, multimodal grounding) that bind
the agent to the here, now, and us. | [
-0.6040144563,
-0.9033187628,
0.6239513755,
0.1353061646,
0.1617428958,
0.2353527397,
-0.1308779567,
-0.7698290348,
0.234935075,
0.5129760504,
-0.4367351234,
-0.3744284511,
-0.4447275698,
-0.0863145441,
-0.1410663426,
0.522213757,
0.0091064731,
-0.4425224662,
-0.4952798188,
-0.351983428,
-0.7907954454,
-0.7800753713,
-0.5451537371,
-0.4277648926,
0.3977079093,
0.5270450115,
1.2228226662,
0.5975573659,
0.0942354202,
0.4151874781,
-0.1292042136,
-0.3240622282,
-0.370911628,
0.372097671,
-0.3038472235,
-0.3366505504,
-0.446490407,
0.5819269419,
0.5813511014,
1.0320124626,
0.2353753,
-0.2236840427,
-0.0808217078,
0.3411491513,
-0.4521244466,
0.0387483612,
-0.3175757825,
0.3035594523,
0.0410706103,
-0.2351113856,
-0.1888750196,
-0.3841029704,
0.2386331111,
-0.420694381,
-0.1596942544,
-0.1386725456,
0.8924339414,
0.1794368476,
-0.5604148507,
-0.2342826426,
-0.640909493,
0.6348448396,
-0.2678133547,
0.4258275628,
0.6865704656,
0.1425640136,
-0.1400373131,
-0.7080670595,
-0.2678108513,
-0.7138813138,
-0.2641538382,
-0.2299607992,
-0.1684572101,
-0.0187746193,
0.315321207,
0.2178683132,
-0.1699432135,
-0.0203618314,
-0.2404493839,
0.1233353913,
0.2692441046,
0.0488362126,
0.8389427662,
-0.0038089468,
-0.3022788167,
0.0469345376,
-0.6464152932,
0.182860747,
-0.1457550824,
0.5287626386,
-0.0940224156,
0.6848208308,
-0.2215826362,
0.3831148446,
0.2325842977,
0.3437988162,
-0.2085867524,
-0.0825153887,
-0.1147044972,
0.0057828599,
0.2649418712,
0.1603660136,
0.1925842017,
-0.0530698784,
-0.0334608704,
-0.1799289733,
0.6916556358,
-0.2791487575,
0.158615455,
0.5281643271,
-0.0827355459,
-0.2824197412,
-0.3265690207,
-0.468170166,
-0.5365274549,
-0.5203432441,
0.3828622401,
-0.2090761662,
-0.5404469371,
-0.6180745959,
0.0936686471,
0.4155144095,
0.0292844977,
-0.8942984939,
0.7136565447,
0.7070343494,
1.1127890348,
0.1908212751,
-0.626388669,
-0.3843484819,
0.1686769575,
-0.505931735,
0.8470419049,
-0.7931024432,
-0.3665949404,
0.1922194809,
-0.0421793573,
-0.212425977,
-0.0365525,
0.2916501462,
-0.644133687,
0.1994181722,
-0.4972548187,
-0.2938379049,
0.0438058898,
0.5612786412,
-0.9722322822,
1.2190303802,
-0.0478370003,
-0.6014999747,
0.1419029832,
-0.7500950098,
-0.3611278236,
0.2941533923,
-0.2343742996,
0.0915466323,
0.2099361122,
-0.1360522807,
0.5524256229,
0.0644487664,
0.3264252841,
-0.231721431,
-0.3444671035,
0.304199934,
-0.0664524361,
0.8265083432,
0.1430191249,
-0.3724810779,
0.0708821043,
-0.6363672614,
-0.0495683849,
-0.040635284,
-0.1415005475,
-0.6210973263,
0.2455794066,
-0.1703477204,
0.3849653304,
0.4597208798,
-0.2498241961,
0.0917149037,
-0.4964106083,
0.3243439496,
0.5538497567,
-0.181988433,
0.8660302758,
-0.3518572152,
0.511274159,
-0.5781893134,
-0.0734256059,
0.0409737751,
-0.1729393154,
-0.4827153087,
-0.0080626132,
-0.0506753847,
0.5048856735,
-0.6747205853,
0.0997202918,
-0.2793605626,
-0.3169993162,
-0.1122410521,
-0.3556609452,
0.188429907,
0.2249001712,
-0.053162355,
-0.1019652262,
-0.5271043777,
-0.4026349485,
-0.0213929694,
-0.2227765769,
0.2515330911,
0.0155580286,
0.3078862131,
-0.0300250538,
1.1912074089,
-0.1888472587,
-0.190748021,
-0.3470442295,
0.0701589733,
0.0712086335,
0.3941451311,
0.4262984693,
-1.169568181,
-0.5342805386,
0.3755522966,
-1.0294225216,
-0.2228230387,
0.0889396816,
-0.1659931988,
0.08093822,
0.8150665164,
-0.9496618509,
0.4242487252,
0.5335685015,
-0.2473767251,
0.011373926,
-0.4727928042,
0.1261464506,
-0.9294304252,
0.1406214535,
-0.2511619925,
-0.2019372433,
-1.1024296284,
0.4662205279,
-0.5196666121,
-0.6047340035,
-0.2014472336,
0.6187300682,
-0.8422214389,
-0.1427116841,
-0.6388319135,
0.337693423,
-0.1921536177,
0.2635371685,
0.3834430873,
0.5844070315,
0.4782657623,
-0.5876083374,
0.1249256283,
0.1958803684,
0.0852895305,
0.5692751408,
-0.7003806233,
0.2391728163,
0.131449461,
0.002157304,
-1.0475202799,
-0.4697195888,
0.3796555102,
-0.4709476829,
0.3474546671,
-0.019705629,
-0.1411798298,
0.1041388065,
-0.3927380145,
0.5126801133,
0.1384395659,
-0.2155934572,
0.9264757633,
0.972905457,
-0.5519578457,
-0.5219995379,
-0.4365079999,
0.4896564186,
-0.1424268633,
-0.6278048158,
0.2233528495,
0.3146206737,
-0.6374875903,
0.1601475626,
0.1238784641,
-0.3202786446,
0.292853564,
0.5056539774,
-0.1384839416,
-0.0011277625,
0.0351903327,
-0.1205030605,
-0.6112426519,
-0.037476223,
-0.1213288382,
0.2918680608,
-0.1687232256,
-0.2752279937,
0.0069737998,
0.8392337561,
0.8160379529,
-0.1282933652,
0.7433483601,
0.0769347921,
-0.8733533621,
-0.0517060421,
-0.248081848,
0.272465229,
-0.4552705586,
0.0805108249,
-0.544208169,
-1.0512586832,
0.4819710851,
-0.0802195221,
0.0832996964,
0.2082206607,
0.6467032433,
-0.1347463429,
0.8447895646,
0.9727334976,
0.0994044095,
0.4128652215,
0.2171357423,
0.4098885059,
-0.4910862744,
-0.0528873913,
-0.5794609785,
-0.0210297536,
-0.8248974085,
-0.4325480759,
0.3839138448,
-0.2184746414,
0.037532039,
0.6697774529,
-0.4475595355,
0.4589375854,
0.5437625647,
-0.3582848608,
0.1082075983,
-0.1658334285,
-0.3208236098,
0.0185914654,
-0.6045129895,
-0.8375185728,
0.355147481,
0.2659051418,
0.4212096632,
0.0783031508,
0.2598421574,
0.5422492623,
0.3936277926,
-0.6485522985,
0.8148388267,
0.3475064039,
-0.7622628808,
-0.6699699759,
0.1530257016,
-1.1555964947,
0.7136228681,
-0.0581576973,
-0.9887260199,
0.1953681558,
-0.0037914445,
-0.0901585221,
0.0768204629,
-0.4006976485,
0.8008487821,
0.0247199088,
-0.5419017076,
-0.2064686865,
-0.840739727,
-0.0433276296,
0.3336524963,
0.4861059487,
-0.1937459856,
0.0493689552,
0.0602691881,
-0.4446126521,
1.2256413698,
-0.1979852468,
-0.3926694095,
0.4850901067,
0.2677169144,
0.4334235787,
-0.4374697804,
-0.0368124284,
0.079209283,
0.2448535562,
-0.5664548278,
-0.4213904142,
0.6520873904,
-0.7143754363,
-0.6602468491,
-0.8111380935,
-0.2738683224,
-0.3193704486,
0.0916701853,
0.1602722108,
0.5677899718,
-0.6736597419,
-0.1124144495,
0.404776603,
0.0229708776,
0.3757407665,
0.2765232325,
-0.165221855,
-0.1401290596,
0.9031047225,
0.4225949943,
-0.0074351504,
0.5697677135,
0.0628900453,
-0.2494246364,
-0.512827158,
-0.0005017642,
0.104930155,
-0.7634052038,
0.378896147,
-0.6953027248,
-0.1755791605,
-0.3049419522,
-0.6393761635,
-0.4122255147,
-0.1262383908,
-0.2220905423,
-0.3665635288,
-0.0603587776,
0.8753803968,
-0.4205998778,
0.2624242902,
-0.8182138205,
0.2219767869,
0.2868339419,
0.3092021942,
0.1325233877,
0.0319733582,
-0.4564764798,
-0.0628106296,
0.072294496,
-0.8340600133,
0.1143830419,
-0.0026904382,
0.7222896814,
-0.0204905421,
0.175228864,
0.4186522663,
-0.5298466682,
0.7708986998,
-0.4520004988,
-0.9692826867,
0.4980356395,
-0.5272825956,
0.1721957326,
0.6717632413,
0.4951254725,
-0.7805948257,
-0.5741819143,
-0.4008213878,
-0.9708012938,
0.6712243557,
0.4675314724,
0.4752449393,
-0.0335794576,
0.2834523022,
-0.0067162723,
0.2050154656,
-1.0333019495,
0.1675250679,
0.1254389882,
0.1592256725,
0.1296735257,
-0.2705951929,
-0.165486902,
-0.1018299758,
0.396982342,
-0.1280219406,
0.378482461,
0.057687223,
-0.3255333006,
-0.1652876884,
0.2935458422,
0.2566205263,
0.7647567987,
-0.2457089871,
0.275595516,
0.1281217188,
-0.2237725407,
0.2055693567,
0.1025982574,
-0.1263525337,
-0.3138214648,
0.5141912103,
0.5476951599,
0.5089734793,
-0.3374468088,
0.3624038398,
0.0396165848,
0.1847120374,
-0.4902858138,
-0.0000149182,
-0.0647992194,
0.3602814376,
0.3851323128,
-0.2554166913,
-0.0062392573,
-0.8341873884,
0.3556459844,
0.2999599874,
-0.8253755569,
-0.5212455392,
0.5207949281,
0.3030744195,
-0.4164105952,
0.2802320123,
-0.0276193898,
-0.4997672439,
0.409286052,
0.329077363,
1.0469667912,
-0.129032582,
0.4592256248,
0.0010759906,
0.2982079983,
0.0455884337,
0.1890028566,
-0.4319548905,
-0.8523588777,
-0.4909813106,
-0.191890195,
-0.8427402377,
-0.3263736963,
-0.486818254,
-0.0023850638,
-0.2810398936,
-0.2786288857,
-0.1301314682,
0.2063921392,
-0.2168349922,
0.2560366094,
0.2167702019,
0.5915514827,
-0.7300412059,
0.484500289,
1.1678414345,
-0.2342064828,
-0.3390581608,
0.1233856231,
0.1761906892,
-0.451312542,
0.2494647056,
0.3004341722,
-0.5367073417,
0.0369581245,
-0.8779395223,
-0.994989574,
0.9732475877,
0.27280882,
0.2282731235,
-0.0966268852,
0.0672726557,
0.8671210408,
-0.5253408551,
0.2384702265,
0.508438468,
0.283855021,
0.2197356075,
-0.6931274533,
0.3783135116,
-0.4505179524,
0.0784064904,
0.2649456561,
-0.8265452385,
0.9200858474,
0.035685569,
-0.6628341675,
0.1312680393,
0.5990636945,
0.1794068217,
0.6237438917,
0.3964534402,
0.1529858857,
0.6864539981,
0.052556172,
1.1112463474,
-0.1775704026,
0.3006828427,
0.9800288081,
-0.6199998856,
0.8442117572,
0.3303205669,
-0.1062453985,
0.4683567882,
0.6742379665,
0.4119303226,
0.4601532519,
-0.0437094308,
-0.3068551719,
-0.1811067462,
-0.4394768476,
-0.1935748011,
0.5324741602,
0.4929441214,
0.2653209269,
-0.3605213463,
0.1128231362,
-0.1699826568,
0.3074911237,
-0.1150071546,
0.6601235271,
0.182709977,
-0.7822295427,
0.1249472275,
-0.0817480087,
-0.1004749909,
-0.4608551264,
-0.2402758896,
-0.0484749638,
-0.2549751997,
0.0568080582,
-0.7063623071,
0.4023764729,
-0.1121936664,
0.0273088962,
-0.5354297757,
1.1897594929,
-0.1965165883,
-0.0378281809,
0.6737075448,
0.8151392937,
0.2737177908,
-0.1248647869,
-0.3672904372,
0.1296517104,
-0.4167646468,
-0.4527989626,
0.4341241717,
0.6559336782,
-0.3812133074,
0.7183541656,
0.4772879481,
-0.0555177703,
-0.0908479393,
0.0087607345,
0.9112307429,
-0.9629682899,
-0.6260548234,
-0.6429774761,
0.70949018,
-0.0889802501,
-0.142807886,
0.4546867907,
-0.0090885712,
0.5101270676,
0.4481014609,
0.677349031,
-0.5733451247,
0.249911502,
-0.3886094391,
0.49777475,
-0.4360814095,
0.1209756657,
-0.195121944,
-0.8809041381,
-0.2191859037,
0.65834409,
-0.2555055916,
-0.0104477555,
0.6562455297,
0.2889870405,
0.0682280883,
0.1000317931,
0.6242247224,
0.1899126321,
0.0713845789,
0.355029285,
1.3159928322,
-0.115738079,
0.2290118635,
-0.054813087,
-0.2269368321,
-0.1278044432,
-0.860720098,
-0.8994714022,
-0.8871477842,
-0.2076918334,
-0.2975482643,
-0.1135445386,
1.204685688,
0.5788136721,
-0.6353923082,
-0.4777671099,
-0.0309879053,
0.4102859199,
-0.2217145413,
-0.1879391819,
0.0968332216,
-0.3687631786,
-0.9010852575,
0.5069601536,
0.4842610359,
0.0472486503,
-0.2629707456,
0.1053354591,
-0.5935197473,
0.1456325501,
0.756604135,
0.6868700385,
-0.3782759905,
-0.6325680614,
-0.1153582558,
-0.3364587724,
0.2588424683,
1.0214782953,
-0.6517229676,
0.4040122926,
0.2341929525,
0.6197047234,
0.2886257768,
0.1849099845,
0.9016588926,
-0.8910645843,
0.0837245956,
0.1840338856,
-0.0309003517,
0.3541061878,
-0.5049898028,
0.6139180064,
0.1144209653,
-0.5079302192,
-0.6440299749,
0.1361050904,
-0.7678312063,
-0.2865670323,
0.9043344855,
0.026986111,
-0.1809096634,
-0.5766611099,
-0.3570887744,
0.3642680645,
-0.1199007481,
0.6117576361,
1.148298502,
-0.339202553,
-0.2614506781,
-0.5711259246,
0.2824998498,
0.172691524,
-0.7040544748,
0.047589317,
0.7414102554,
-0.0505868867,
0.4225735962,
1.1891828775,
0.1878439635,
-0.0275771134,
0.3886686563,
-0.1449245661,
0.2494477183,
-0.5324776769,
-0.4685374498,
0.7373768091,
0.1664803028,
-0.1707709134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08589v1 | Syntactic Structure Processing in the Brain while Listening | 2023-02-16T21:28:11 | 2023-02-16T21:28:11 | Subba Reddy Oota, Mounika Marreddy, Manish Gupta, Bapi Raju Surampud | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | Syntactic parsing is the task of assigning a syntactic structure to a
sentence. There are two popular syntactic parsing methods: constituency and
dependency parsing. Recent works have used syntactic embeddings based on
constituency trees, incremental top-down parsing, and other word syntactic
features for brain activity prediction given the text stimuli to study how the
syntax structure is represented in the brain's language network. However, the
effectiveness of dependency parse trees or the relative predictive power of the
various syntax parsers across brain areas, especially for the listening task,
is yet unexplored. In this study, we investigate the predictive power of the
brain encoding models in three settings: (i) individual performance of the
constituency and dependency syntactic parsing based embedding methods, (ii)
efficacy of these syntactic parsing based embedding methods when controlling
for basic syntactic signals, (iii) relative effectiveness of each of the
syntactic embedding methods when controlling for the other. Further, we explore
the relative importance of syntactic information (from these syntactic
embedding methods) versus semantic information using BERT embeddings. We find
that constituency parsers help explain activations in the temporal lobe and
middle-frontal gyrus, while dependency parsers better encode syntactic
structure in the angular gyrus and posterior cingulate cortex. Although
semantic signals from BERT are more effective compared to any of the syntactic
features or embedding methods, syntactic embedding methods explain additional
variance for a few brain regions. | [
-0.2836276591,
-0.7404951453,
0.9215775132,
0.3927147686,
-0.1295417398,
-0.2233855128,
-0.4157802463,
-0.474696666,
0.3295202553,
0.0246510915,
-0.4628972113,
-0.4917308688,
-0.7052028179,
-0.1397321671,
-0.2441210896,
0.5177298188,
0.2606313825,
0.5114150643,
-0.3845411539,
0.0175420512,
-0.7477602363,
-0.9412987232,
-0.3397182226,
-0.3355907798,
0.4073698819,
-0.0827760771,
0.5056474805,
0.8522309661,
0.305274725,
0.3996495306,
-0.5373184085,
-0.5887812972,
0.0644735098,
0.2779645622,
-0.2081604004,
-0.8943820596,
-0.3023629189,
-0.1059727371,
0.5893456936,
1.1113272905,
-0.4671442211,
-0.130768016,
-0.0339247547,
0.4011879861,
-0.4631309509,
0.5246419311,
-0.6650053859,
-0.0529307351,
-0.1639624387,
-0.3337870836,
-0.4442334473,
-0.0827989653,
0.4333787262,
-0.2000446767,
0.110198833,
0.0403654426,
0.5057523847,
0.2627488971,
0.0309100691,
-0.3794012964,
-0.3020057976,
0.5649136901,
-0.7116199136,
0.8270398974,
0.6724177003,
0.0365337878,
-0.1447472572,
-0.6152679324,
-0.5378136039,
-0.1071836948,
-0.4237142801,
-0.0487824716,
-0.1857254505,
0.4084744751,
0.2600825131,
0.1426701099,
-0.3861629367,
0.0083601261,
-0.321808368,
-0.3370435536,
-0.0392907895,
-0.0271145981,
0.4760852754,
-0.5227279663,
-0.1379214227,
-0.2402464449,
-0.2839734554,
0.2287252098,
0.2497103363,
0.5067901015,
-0.0165150762,
0.5553057194,
-0.0187641084,
0.6489578485,
0.0338560231,
0.0337143689,
0.285209924,
-0.3527433276,
-0.2362851053,
0.3561843932,
0.5087262988,
0.0783217922,
0.1287263781,
-0.2919344902,
-0.1069419384,
0.4366981685,
0.2343384176,
-0.302467674,
-0.1816542745,
0.2857592404,
-0.5969544053,
0.0243624523,
-0.1149774492,
-0.4937015772,
-0.0514277965,
-0.4774025977,
0.2572085857,
-0.7171316147,
-0.1246349588,
0.2128004432,
-0.3342180252,
0.0175912455,
0.042541679,
-1.3333599567,
0.4360176027,
0.6152076125,
0.7927410007,
0.312417686,
-0.4010710418,
-0.250474304,
0.2559659779,
0.0803233907,
0.9506769776,
-0.6242209077,
0.0154706808,
-0.0583542809,
0.0749699399,
-0.4373550415,
-0.458868891,
0.4177336693,
-0.3484089375,
0.1337336898,
-0.5695453286,
-0.6552728415,
-0.3614917099,
-0.1768739522,
-0.7843222022,
0.3436509967,
0.1307723969,
-0.6812825203,
0.4761965573,
-0.4412704408,
-0.433935672,
-0.1811338514,
-0.432690531,
-0.2343745232,
0.3374059498,
0.3650231063,
0.5271454453,
0.2715585232,
0.3796943426,
-0.2708634138,
-0.2920906246,
0.408947587,
-0.0246841535,
0.917470932,
-0.1743689179,
-0.3865365088,
0.1401966065,
-0.4270501435,
0.1803501248,
-0.0090596341,
-0.3009395301,
-0.2755908072,
0.4771651328,
-0.0671595111,
0.1788073927,
0.0233410224,
-0.6384087801,
-0.0903211311,
-0.6066209674,
0.718994081,
0.6283162832,
0.1649901271,
0.3126250207,
-0.2066923529,
0.279482156,
0.198746264,
-0.206620127,
-0.253064245,
-0.4200363159,
-0.4384711385,
-0.025980277,
0.4972661138,
0.4150622487,
-0.1912355572,
0.5240790844,
-0.2585021257,
-0.0437644087,
-0.6218076348,
-0.2368651778,
0.478428334,
0.1976982504,
0.4751343429,
-0.2063773721,
-0.7095409036,
-1.0586483479,
-0.3175172508,
-0.4527489841,
0.0299264789,
0.0172492377,
0.2171118259,
0.2041320354,
0.6444172859,
-0.3053211868,
-0.3191927075,
-0.3405040503,
-0.1281676739,
0.2114288807,
0.3356966078,
0.4526016116,
-0.4245477021,
-0.1558573842,
-0.0526837669,
-0.6634046435,
-0.0418230854,
-0.0108806435,
-0.013982431,
0.0953932777,
0.4619567096,
-0.8247690797,
0.29110533,
0.4806868434,
-0.4617162645,
0.1250235438,
0.0728546828,
-0.2075495273,
-0.7308677435,
-0.1382692158,
-0.3227057457,
-0.0833064616,
-0.5765491128,
-0.1189503595,
0.1411505044,
0.0645498931,
-0.3015824258,
-0.1576707363,
-0.6079463363,
-0.3557543755,
-0.0306887049,
-0.0196002107,
0.0130936233,
0.7975692153,
0.1492125392,
0.5246619582,
0.5453110337,
-0.1372016966,
-0.0828663781,
0.3051283062,
-0.6875510216,
-0.0621279441,
-0.7586891651,
0.0622362494,
-0.2310325056,
0.1005002558,
-1.0687805414,
-0.0376424976,
-0.023063628,
-0.5475743413,
0.2914543748,
-0.0388852507,
-0.5135552883,
0.1948309988,
0.0830430463,
0.3609030843,
0.3236627579,
-0.3674974442,
0.3850055039,
0.5470661521,
-0.211584866,
-0.2536553144,
-0.869535625,
-0.2029942572,
-0.0593725778,
-0.5674516559,
0.5507218242,
0.3159450591,
-0.1806452125,
0.1674885154,
-0.1901053935,
0.3289821446,
-0.0533305518,
0.4399541914,
-0.0425994694,
-0.2783196568,
0.3259564936,
-0.0059884447,
-0.0639006793,
0.4375834167,
-0.2729987204,
0.7200162411,
-0.0871240869,
-0.2379142344,
-0.4998890162,
0.5544085503,
0.5351478457,
-0.2703025043,
0.7780153155,
0.2456740439,
-0.318854928,
-0.1918882877,
-0.3681391776,
-0.2298899591,
-0.4153800309,
0.3694737554,
-0.3388125002,
-0.8510919213,
0.6215661764,
0.0769399405,
-0.4271826744,
0.1807619929,
0.7263086438,
-0.299945116,
1.036557436,
0.4385717213,
0.0360342935,
0.6617488861,
-0.1360239089,
0.2480851561,
-0.918740809,
-0.3044760227,
-0.5591097474,
-0.535480082,
-0.5586031675,
-0.2243465036,
0.2954567969,
-0.0350128151,
0.2012917101,
0.4447953403,
-0.6256639361,
0.3990894556,
0.4176275432,
0.2267744392,
-0.0801973268,
0.2259876728,
-0.4660578966,
-0.1752799898,
-0.6140838861,
-0.179042533,
1.0240241289,
0.4561761916,
0.3694880307,
0.1179420948,
0.3690062463,
-0.0205959454,
-0.178015843,
-1.0676022768,
0.5544006824,
-0.095878154,
-0.4229611456,
-0.1885320246,
-0.005710314,
-0.8489719629,
0.4684768915,
-0.1814215332,
-0.90636307,
0.5895457864,
-0.1854644269,
-0.4267788827,
0.1498815417,
-1.0425621271,
0.734398067,
0.0630425885,
-0.0133522535,
-0.3009076118,
-0.5611230135,
-0.1396738738,
0.3312585652,
0.0223869104,
-0.008606405,
0.0699880123,
0.7851763368,
-0.0304369815,
0.8695927262,
-0.3689541519,
0.1820982993,
0.0772902891,
-0.1316459626,
0.1303968281,
-0.0897024944,
-0.2125676721,
0.4109653234,
0.1743039042,
-0.1453875005,
-0.8134128451,
0.5703454614,
-0.8400978446,
-0.6856488585,
-0.4268035889,
-0.4931560755,
-0.2689255774,
0.1642126441,
0.3820155859,
0.4369763136,
-0.0008516459,
0.4105415046,
0.3174718022,
0.0350562409,
0.5758958459,
0.0808825493,
-0.1708567888,
-0.4804005623,
0.4941483736,
0.3774547577,
0.1605337113,
0.6542160511,
0.0791292712,
-0.2734828293,
-0.8666632175,
-0.0261461791,
0.2211305946,
-0.712005496,
-0.0441907682,
-0.86002177,
-0.1442953497,
-0.3459049165,
0.0759576857,
-0.0526630655,
-0.5569085479,
0.1937796623,
-0.354934603,
-0.1211926639,
0.5270414352,
0.1252269894,
0.4522888064,
-0.3874008954,
0.126931712,
0.1643071771,
0.4241244197,
0.0325500891,
0.1347069293,
-0.4933600128,
0.0501266159,
-0.2036100477,
-1.1609349251,
0.2366704047,
0.0488117822,
0.6113628745,
0.0990003645,
-0.4972257912,
0.6261153817,
-0.6290426254,
0.6104741693,
0.1105138287,
-1.1290955544,
0.7635028362,
-0.3593676388,
0.4889665842,
0.4662089348,
0.1278849691,
-0.3421696126,
-0.5491188765,
-0.5987384319,
-0.6357206702,
0.819863379,
0.2428305298,
-0.1799419075,
-0.3678106964,
0.2555267513,
0.0762274042,
0.1980802417,
-0.5402614474,
0.0443585292,
-0.186548844,
0.1171990708,
0.0013767156,
-0.1573916674,
-0.125129655,
-0.6566599011,
-0.0235102884,
0.1600221545,
0.8814617395,
0.3622069955,
0.1164799035,
-0.2034419179,
0.2634941339,
0.3620620668,
0.595546186,
-0.4854272604,
0.18328996,
0.0053510908,
-0.4428713024,
0.0045491438,
-0.1598699242,
0.0793198049,
0.2543037534,
0.791985929,
1.1827653646,
0.22658135,
-0.2951805592,
0.4316980243,
-0.0934850052,
-0.1953887939,
-0.4950046539,
0.211182788,
0.3780249357,
0.308919698,
-0.0459766835,
0.2985883951,
0.2174018323,
-0.8631973267,
0.0125616733,
0.3239742219,
-0.0924331024,
-0.5281322598,
0.4562166333,
-0.2703080475,
-0.3067947626,
0.7183983326,
0.3800027668,
-0.5520552397,
0.6748024225,
0.8526300788,
0.9126310945,
-0.2489866316,
-0.2569883466,
0.3742474318,
0.1747854352,
0.2648628056,
0.6264551282,
-0.222723186,
-0.7921035886,
-0.6103419065,
-0.8204154968,
-0.2589510381,
0.0008997727,
-0.9101097584,
0.0449901558,
-0.513614893,
-0.5710629821,
0.5376588702,
-0.1805156469,
-0.664274931,
0.1155660152,
0.1370839477,
0.67368716,
-0.68404001,
1.0009167194,
0.8833313584,
-0.2115188986,
-0.9233694077,
0.2659708858,
-0.1577906609,
-0.5430307984,
0.4904996753,
0.2532862723,
0.1261931062,
-0.0610627979,
-0.2972197533,
-1.0251091719,
1.0194919109,
0.5807279348,
-0.5427253246,
-0.3109456301,
0.0635824054,
0.5939621329,
-0.4779078662,
0.2193629593,
0.6415905952,
0.4781025052,
-0.3342241347,
-0.8878602982,
0.3044443727,
-0.2734100521,
0.2214705348,
0.4689789712,
-0.2927577794,
0.8500213623,
-0.0282152351,
-0.4035701454,
-0.1312589049,
0.4687111676,
0.1819414645,
0.0064695105,
0.5940896869,
0.6256814599,
0.516339004,
-0.1764588952,
0.9379190803,
-0.4215553403,
-0.0365612023,
0.8313060403,
0.1590155959,
1.1389590502,
0.7377681732,
-0.3828612268,
0.9184538126,
0.348880887,
0.030390339,
0.8377771378,
0.1773521304,
0.0116278538,
-0.0375771523,
-0.1793967634,
-0.3563672304,
0.7586073279,
0.7414441705,
-0.6009796262,
-0.0535617582,
0.0499910973,
-0.1064595208,
-0.0139592765,
0.1071941853,
0.8596076369,
0.1569478363,
-0.7943186164,
0.5362782478,
-0.0550587066,
0.1001272425,
-0.7006486654,
-0.0435268544,
0.0667210817,
0.0783154145,
-0.3227373362,
-0.752486825,
0.6453556418,
-0.4937526584,
-0.4792374372,
-0.4584652185,
0.5341593623,
-0.3893834054,
0.0646538958,
0.8855371475,
0.528719306,
0.0283768121,
-0.0776277855,
-0.3729594052,
0.3028796017,
-0.0754386932,
-0.3188756108,
0.5763552189,
0.4478690326,
0.0668322295,
0.2567888498,
0.754193306,
0.4919555485,
0.0225955676,
0.2937442958,
0.9198032022,
-0.9683067799,
-0.8677158952,
-0.8727846146,
0.4388735592,
0.1892926097,
-0.0925020278,
0.4588985145,
0.1427510679,
0.9006049633,
-0.0553596132,
0.5269184113,
-0.1823170036,
0.2381422371,
-0.7683970928,
0.6031545401,
-0.256898284,
0.2121003568,
-0.060319826,
-1.1000561714,
-0.2486632764,
0.6852282882,
-0.5596794486,
-0.0041476483,
1.1696988344,
0.5321491361,
-0.0479345322,
0.4405730069,
0.2927607298,
0.3112566471,
-0.0303039569,
0.7201211452,
0.6747357845,
-0.0903152525,
0.1196676195,
-0.475654155,
-0.1480316073,
0.1411772221,
-0.5477361083,
-0.8074703217,
-0.8185365796,
0.0694848597,
-0.1572277099,
0.0491045229,
0.7775104046,
0.7047266364,
-0.8387987018,
-0.3308360279,
-0.3649455905,
-0.0729913786,
-0.5341018438,
-0.2188645303,
0.6207700372,
-0.5866602659,
-0.6311879754,
0.7425675988,
0.3699394464,
-0.3131039441,
-0.2302313298,
0.3170489073,
-0.3468837738,
-0.236216113,
0.5579870939,
-0.1428415626,
-0.9006775022,
-0.3498707414,
0.0125442035,
-0.1475315541,
0.1379156709,
0.8396228552,
-0.8617123961,
0.4386408627,
0.896032691,
0.4515432417,
0.2063482851,
-0.0224729795,
0.7204024792,
-0.6102722287,
0.176798597,
0.3080484569,
0.6529886127,
0.240722701,
-0.5244035125,
0.3398204148,
0.1510143429,
-0.4861429334,
-0.6034324765,
0.0332998298,
-1.0707103014,
-0.3443428576,
0.8319832087,
-0.0651580021,
-0.4481175244,
-0.1624112129,
-0.0634290054,
0.4183930457,
-0.2527231276,
0.6328569055,
1.1636101007,
-0.3426210284,
-0.206824258,
-0.5915583968,
0.494418174,
0.8768652081,
-0.2598508298,
0.0264304467,
0.3625504673,
0.1370015442,
0.4617823362,
0.6258267164,
-0.2657969296,
0.3228176236,
0.2793720365,
0.009121255,
0.01412619,
-0.3570217788,
-0.45121786,
0.4483858049,
-0.0974960327,
-0.2968566716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08583v1 | JEIT: Joint End-to-End Model and Internal Language Model Training for Speech Recognition | 2023-02-16T21:07:38 | 2023-02-16T21:07:38 | Zhong Meng, Weiran Wang, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Tara N. Sainath, Tongzhou Chen, Ehsan Variani, Yu Zhang, Bo Li, Andrew Rosenberg, Bhuvana Ramabhadran | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | We propose JEIT, a joint end-to-end (E2E) model and internal language model
(ILM) training method to inject large-scale unpaired text into ILM during E2E
training which improves rare-word speech recognition. With JEIT, the E2E model
computes an E2E loss on audio-transcript pairs while its ILM estimates a
cross-entropy loss on unpaired text. The E2E model is trained to minimize a
weighted sum of E2E and ILM losses. During JEIT, ILM absorbs knowledge from
unpaired text while the E2E training serves as regularization. Unlike ILM
adaptation methods, JEIT does not require a separate adaptation step and avoids
the need for Kullback-Leibler divergence regularization of ILM. We also show
that modular hybrid autoregressive transducer (MHAT) performs better than HAT
in the JEIT framework, and is much more robust than HAT during ILM adaptation.
To push the limit of unpaired text injection, we further propose a combined
JEIT and JOIST training (CJJT) that benefits from modality matching, encoder
text injection and ILM training. Both JEIT and CJJT can foster a more effective
LM fusion. With 100B unpaired sentences, JEIT/CJJT improves rare-word
recognition accuracy by up to 16.4% over a model trained without unpaired text. | [
-0.2882770002,
-0.6152329445,
0.2768425643,
-0.3753870428,
-0.4540524781,
0.2957398891,
-0.4105845094,
-0.6557406783,
0.0384481773,
0.5058960319,
-0.089880906,
-0.1384527832,
-0.5922883153,
-0.0763668641,
-0.3205088377,
0.7484310269,
0.0301735029,
0.3770855367,
0.0228641536,
-0.2250515521,
-0.6124433279,
-0.4844568074,
-0.5132026076,
-0.4107169211,
0.1170785278,
0.2910290658,
0.2795143127,
0.0964318961,
0.4868716896,
0.2809034288,
-0.1262762696,
0.030214997,
-0.3543378413,
-0.0203257389,
-0.3455074131,
-0.3122825325,
-0.252065599,
0.0068875826,
0.7002655268,
0.9426013827,
-0.0011360775,
0.0431832671,
0.2073488384,
0.6407698989,
-0.6358574033,
-0.0248135477,
-0.7521243691,
0.0064924941,
-0.3071139753,
-0.2406486571,
-0.4970710576,
0.1206010804,
0.3659749329,
-0.4564671218,
-0.2258184105,
0.1408326179,
0.6401165128,
0.2939341366,
-0.455330044,
0.0325393118,
-1.0772938728,
0.5619565248,
-0.7396789789,
0.7421235442,
0.0883868709,
0.0384394675,
-0.2546868622,
-0.5895360112,
-0.7735900879,
-0.3852336109,
0.1006649807,
0.562915504,
-0.1013951153,
0.4819872379,
0.1502308249,
0.4854269326,
-0.8802080154,
0.1243134215,
-0.409529388,
-0.0436833166,
0.2831792533,
-0.231948629,
0.4098877907,
0.1626850665,
-0.5227898359,
-0.17134884,
-0.4586026669,
-0.1107048616,
0.250730902,
0.3637107611,
-0.1221878305,
0.5905908942,
0.0187054724,
0.8575327396,
-0.0768976733,
-0.1983225942,
0.4710707664,
-0.0877142772,
-0.4412398338,
0.1985234171,
0.5933749676,
0.02737776,
0.450142175,
-0.3004121184,
-0.1621011794,
0.0455768779,
-0.0627669245,
-0.397675395,
-0.0904156417,
-0.1136985421,
-0.3563405275,
0.0180700589,
0.2214865386,
-0.3646998703,
-0.1728215367,
-0.5874820352,
1.0857419968,
-0.2877814174,
-0.5384935141,
0.3110224307,
-0.5440018177,
0.2166215777,
0.2736074328,
-0.5119224191,
0.610501647,
0.2555772364,
0.7971852422,
-0.2380861044,
-0.1540159583,
-0.5608563423,
0.4232924581,
-0.0874755234,
0.8687196374,
-0.5000964999,
-0.438188076,
-0.3168371022,
-0.0497207753,
-0.4950426519,
-0.511203289,
0.3134829998,
-0.1639306694,
0.5696237683,
0.2584018707,
-0.8388440013,
-0.4490903318,
0.1626233757,
-0.4556111693,
1.0567538738,
0.3225094378,
-0.8724983931,
0.2684186995,
-0.8728805184,
-0.3444784284,
0.163466081,
-0.2314535826,
-0.3106184304,
0.4158063829,
0.0617384166,
0.4223410785,
-0.418679297,
-0.1806754917,
-0.1538504809,
-0.5051910877,
0.0303668696,
-0.640599072,
0.7381395698,
-0.0638409182,
-0.2756102979,
-0.1708929688,
-0.9582139254,
0.0396882929,
0.2193790525,
-0.4959901869,
-0.693282187,
-0.3776211441,
0.4168423712,
-0.0186555106,
0.0354922004,
-0.7592246532,
0.0896171853,
-0.8546444178,
0.1824841052,
0.541418314,
-0.0256074443,
0.6358388066,
-0.1424515247,
0.3463693261,
0.0563211441,
-0.1124164313,
0.0184928402,
-0.2945795655,
-0.7288586497,
-0.1619119793,
0.5158121586,
1.0674997568,
-0.5713015795,
0.5412210822,
-0.1724695861,
-0.3988956809,
-0.2244959027,
-0.0721999556,
0.447130084,
0.5968198776,
0.2730061114,
-0.5109597445,
-0.5288104415,
-0.8369587064,
-0.3466303349,
-0.2715667188,
0.0536860488,
0.1474402398,
0.3669039309,
-0.0511532538,
0.7594406605,
0.1154218242,
-0.3854347765,
-0.6061166525,
0.2885926366,
0.366663903,
0.5169728994,
0.4172041118,
-0.6131305099,
-0.8017978668,
0.2572990656,
-0.5922335982,
-0.08002837,
-0.2522494197,
0.138837114,
-0.0275320318,
0.5181569457,
-0.2821850479,
0.5259469151,
0.568782568,
-0.0811102465,
-0.0562047623,
-0.1038592458,
0.1663649678,
-1.5086859465,
-0.1613466144,
-0.0948265865,
-0.4711434245,
-0.757992506,
-0.1714820862,
0.1008189544,
-0.1417038292,
-0.6497154236,
0.5404719114,
-0.8820773363,
-0.2474423796,
-0.5043606162,
0.0025513475,
-0.2744550407,
0.4659101069,
0.110739395,
1.0469812155,
0.4975515306,
-0.5119000673,
0.2396002114,
0.2063131034,
-0.0815709904,
0.5108169317,
-0.6334446073,
0.3751755953,
-0.0833277926,
0.1174460128,
-0.8894672394,
-0.1009339467,
0.1141767725,
-0.5450422764,
1.0345973969,
-0.1276158839,
-0.4823944271,
-0.4537689388,
-0.2057610899,
0.3182779253,
0.6605542898,
-0.6708477736,
0.7901124358,
0.5691527128,
0.0372074135,
-0.3259313703,
-0.8245266676,
0.144934535,
-0.2793000638,
-0.4395315349,
0.426220715,
-0.1065277159,
0.0271264352,
-0.0423351489,
-0.1252900511,
-0.1717655808,
0.0877693743,
0.1745916903,
0.0881188437,
-0.1515615582,
0.2297231853,
0.017840445,
-0.3484442234,
-0.2595928013,
-0.4354475141,
0.4850769043,
-0.0002631854,
-0.3541934788,
-0.53458184,
0.5172160864,
0.3854842484,
-0.0308448374,
0.5770834684,
0.755112648,
-0.6957400441,
0.0116625475,
-0.5620747805,
-0.0752417445,
-0.4295242429,
0.6092150807,
-0.4952352643,
-0.8717719316,
0.2015480995,
-0.4993796349,
-0.0923223644,
0.3967251182,
0.5263492465,
-0.0489908718,
0.8060602546,
0.7929571867,
-0.3156312108,
0.7012448311,
-0.1149513498,
0.2570003867,
-1.1195790768,
0.0910471007,
-0.3735286891,
-0.2038870454,
-0.4501001835,
-0.2720360458,
0.626707077,
0.2735933065,
-0.0430981629,
0.4628360271,
-0.6910848022,
0.773316741,
0.6870394945,
0.1752237976,
0.1603879184,
0.0443867818,
-0.1005647704,
-0.1118350923,
-0.609662056,
-0.202328831,
1.1127080917,
0.2695221901,
0.9002417922,
-0.015288027,
0.8707790375,
0.1973865032,
0.0683217198,
-0.710822165,
0.4448153079,
-0.2229882479,
-0.4858236611,
-0.3031083941,
-0.1942852885,
-0.4882317185,
0.0717394724,
-0.0833521113,
-1.0401291847,
0.2026370913,
0.2586180568,
-0.2261250764,
0.5251222253,
-0.8611282706,
0.4345606267,
-0.1519794464,
-0.1736957133,
-0.2176664919,
-0.760604322,
0.2655519545,
-0.1192978323,
-0.2324241251,
0.0307779033,
0.067536518,
0.791043818,
-0.2292574197,
0.7981516719,
-0.2837695479,
0.3129823506,
0.2199008465,
-0.1231935769,
0.7754966021,
-0.0993385762,
0.0984675288,
0.197841987,
-0.2869147658,
-0.0559550375,
-0.3586103022,
0.4957633913,
-0.6930464506,
-0.4744611084,
-0.7461706996,
-0.525069654,
-0.4432457983,
-0.003955442,
0.5445596576,
0.4146957994,
-0.295231849,
0.232714504,
0.9608069658,
-0.2723831832,
0.5926439166,
0.4188551307,
0.3365879655,
-0.5600643158,
0.8570078611,
0.1145556197,
0.5431684852,
0.7129846215,
0.2306673229,
-0.2145460695,
-0.7392629385,
-0.5357146859,
0.1654434651,
-0.71572721,
-0.2944665849,
-0.852425456,
-0.7175548673,
-0.2747986615,
-0.1324768364,
-0.5566861033,
-0.6050049067,
-0.3197223842,
0.062026415,
0.5584942102,
0.6822667718,
-0.4326091111,
0.4550427794,
-0.7207868099,
0.2421348095,
0.2319288105,
-0.0118375374,
-0.3746238649,
-1.0596815348,
-0.3227693439,
-0.1743946373,
0.0221088026,
-1.0320116282,
0.2693134546,
0.4936824143,
0.5454841852,
0.0681919754,
-0.1926826984,
0.7183212042,
-0.5179401636,
0.633174479,
0.4642497599,
-1.0118775368,
0.495860368,
-0.2387931049,
0.3998614848,
0.6372926235,
0.0455778539,
-0.5180057287,
-0.3661431074,
-0.3506379724,
-0.8006893396,
0.4586416483,
0.0433900394,
0.2875091434,
0.1598137617,
0.2106750607,
0.1842225194,
0.173360154,
-1.0311317444,
-0.0916611478,
0.0474571474,
-0.4767428339,
0.3876432478,
-0.3109914064,
0.1062427461,
-0.5408228636,
0.8619942069,
-0.0650528222,
0.6005126834,
0.2676904202,
-0.3387132287,
-0.1729358584,
0.5265224576,
0.3217172325,
0.2189127058,
-0.1827372313,
-0.0650020391,
0.5862281919,
-0.5783547759,
0.0710918829,
0.2074353248,
-0.0657031462,
0.1353214979,
0.2788302302,
0.7141497731,
0.1171564534,
-0.3493839204,
0.6828554869,
0.0411397815,
-0.3701417446,
-0.7306027412,
0.0100107649,
-0.0267777443,
0.3494957983,
0.1123798564,
0.0421254598,
0.3816835582,
-0.409427315,
0.1016137078,
0.5527445674,
-0.3284882903,
-0.2001670003,
0.8287842274,
0.1401931792,
-0.1749490947,
0.3721480668,
-0.213730365,
-0.5807125568,
0.3157918751,
0.8177924156,
1.1292710304,
-0.4650397301,
-0.1714860201,
0.4083279669,
0.439868778,
-0.0549168065,
0.6205841303,
-0.0301194936,
-0.5708250403,
-0.3894489706,
-0.5941438675,
-0.424631089,
0.3326231241,
-0.6089859009,
0.3117209375,
-0.3958878517,
0.2386575788,
-0.1763266176,
-0.2799487114,
-0.7676020861,
0.203685239,
0.2302255332,
0.6978714466,
-0.8475832939,
0.7877312303,
0.7092455029,
-0.5176645517,
-0.7849292159,
0.0071670986,
0.0317255557,
-0.746526897,
0.3111601174,
0.0608626604,
-0.0159054995,
0.2423068583,
-0.4352157712,
-0.9983910322,
0.9931725264,
0.2443573922,
-1.1655650139,
0.0565341972,
0.091510728,
0.2653106749,
-0.2425314933,
0.3088863194,
0.4190652668,
0.3708518147,
-0.2174098045,
-1.2497597933,
-0.3004618585,
-0.1736172438,
0.0282876063,
0.4760279953,
-0.5120337605,
0.4578135908,
-0.2353752851,
-0.1224136129,
0.1806922257,
0.6478916407,
-0.1121754572,
0.3388770223,
0.7968305349,
0.7881426811,
0.5951898694,
-0.0048389835,
0.6352364421,
-0.1527809054,
0.0840606317,
1.372723341,
-0.3782821298,
0.885145247,
0.5170829892,
-0.075629361,
0.0784789249,
0.5400600433,
0.1106071025,
0.6946351528,
0.2015669942,
-0.5674510002,
-0.1554304063,
-0.1411263049,
-0.5399629474,
0.550173223,
0.4194054604,
-0.3710004091,
-0.0800229609,
0.6349797249,
-0.1623897552,
0.0475122854,
-0.108785376,
1.0107424259,
0.2693952322,
0.0974198431,
0.2580004334,
-0.2978440821,
0.6864434481,
-0.509837687,
-0.0227825548,
0.0658087209,
0.2104004771,
0.0477468669,
-0.4385967553,
0.2248942405,
-0.0303861834,
-0.3116186857,
-0.0219136812,
0.9982796907,
-0.6228123903,
-0.5308212638,
0.4815008342,
0.7017817497,
0.2639299333,
-0.111878708,
-0.737051487,
-0.2132083029,
-0.0565280728,
-0.565030098,
0.2571973801,
0.4186882973,
0.0633148924,
0.1363963336,
0.6454184651,
0.2471174747,
0.0513945445,
0.4991754591,
0.979013741,
-0.7113874555,
-0.4996339679,
-0.5268005133,
0.5694097281,
-0.1244689077,
-0.2923315167,
0.4117827415,
0.4934589565,
1.0424413681,
0.0332371742,
1.0127396584,
-0.0079507409,
0.9060043693,
-0.6272625923,
0.3837770224,
-0.7377073765,
0.0901522487,
-0.3206121027,
-0.9967578053,
-0.2714830041,
0.6730805635,
0.1867704242,
0.1482451707,
0.8939190507,
0.650393188,
-0.3650272787,
-0.0882883593,
0.7800166011,
0.1984224021,
0.089285329,
0.7866274118,
0.7438381314,
-0.7017547488,
0.3960204422,
-0.1733372211,
-0.3294557035,
0.0496915318,
-0.5039372444,
-1.0876703262,
-0.6249645352,
-0.4198510051,
-0.0791050866,
0.3574765325,
1.1973208189,
0.7240557671,
-0.5992641449,
-0.084709242,
-0.4141587913,
-0.4177038372,
-0.0589155406,
-0.2222120911,
0.2253928632,
0.03911018,
-0.710557878,
0.838116169,
0.7106378675,
0.4780687988,
-0.0969566926,
-0.0729503781,
-0.215697363,
0.0298749432,
0.4210293293,
0.3730622828,
-0.6003284454,
-0.4012464881,
-0.1618218869,
0.1646726876,
0.040817678,
0.7203080058,
-0.792711556,
0.6230837703,
0.6963464618,
0.9106410146,
0.4157347977,
-0.4308640361,
0.6133694053,
-0.7183293104,
0.5058175325,
0.3443650901,
0.5598301888,
0.3202752471,
-0.404761672,
0.7690706253,
0.5026366711,
-0.5896346569,
-0.9510272145,
0.2087687999,
-1.2423728704,
-0.0797525346,
1.1286256313,
0.124052681,
-0.1472277641,
-0.2525785863,
-0.2409514934,
0.5292786956,
-0.3474568427,
0.4201049209,
0.5047029257,
-0.0817593262,
-0.3433932364,
-0.6620950699,
0.1012200713,
0.4918387532,
-0.8304665685,
-0.176758036,
0.2115524411,
0.2282737345,
-0.1073537022,
0.662653327,
0.0372530185,
0.4159787595,
0.0149899246,
0.2789182663,
-0.1427464783,
-0.4056474268,
-0.4025622308,
-0.283156693,
0.137847811,
-0.4642709792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08582v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08582v2 | Pretraining Language Models with Human Preferences | 2023-02-16T21:03:33 | 2023-06-14T13:27:58 | Tomasz Korbak, Kejian Shi, Angelica Chen, Rasika Bhalerao, Christopher L. Buckley, Jason Phang, Samuel R. Bowman, Ethan Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are pretrained to imitate internet text, including
content that would violate human preferences if generated by an LM: falsehoods,
offensive comments, personally identifiable information, low-quality or buggy
code, and more. Here, we explore alternative objectives for pretraining LMs in
a way that also guides them to generate text aligned with human preferences. We
benchmark five objectives for pretraining with human feedback across three
tasks and study how they affect the trade-off between alignment and
capabilities of pretrained LMs. We find a Pareto-optimal and simple approach
among those we explored: conditional training, or learning distribution over
tokens conditional on their human preference scores given by a reward model.
Conditional training reduces the rate of undesirable content by up to an order
of magnitude, both when generating without a prompt and with an
adversarially-chosen prompt. Moreover, conditional training maintains the
downstream task performance of standard LM pretraining, both before and after
task-specific finetuning. Pretraining with human feedback results in much
better preference satisfaction than standard LM pretraining followed by
finetuning with feedback, i.e., learning and then unlearning undesirable
behavior. Our results suggest that we should move beyond imitation learning
when pretraining LMs and incorporate human preferences from the start of
training. | [
-0.4242820144,
-0.3836507499,
0.5374797583,
-0.0433672182,
-0.1776472628,
-0.1551815122,
-0.6636213064,
-0.2027687579,
0.0972701311,
0.6181486249,
-0.5422295332,
-0.102872856,
-0.527648747,
0.0242709871,
-0.2804585993,
1.3085870743,
-0.1144729853,
0.0604018122,
-0.2969941199,
0.1979068816,
-0.2805789113,
-1.0637704134,
-0.6294893026,
-0.5131509304,
0.8421488404,
0.3589703739,
0.7815493941,
0.4892221391,
0.2374700904,
0.3362625241,
0.4830367565,
-0.1154886931,
-0.6074758768,
-0.253770262,
-0.1117658094,
-0.5496832132,
-0.2671845555,
0.6677187085,
0.3067141473,
0.5519917607,
-0.1753310263,
0.1050639525,
0.2888656259,
0.8044269085,
-0.7271081209,
-0.2027632743,
-0.4084908664,
0.1309814006,
-0.1874863207,
-0.3470619023,
-0.4446230829,
-0.4521657526,
0.4521001875,
-0.6376574636,
0.045691479,
0.0748848394,
1.1742910147,
0.3707106411,
-0.2371148318,
-0.2840310633,
-0.5647876263,
0.8447197676,
-0.6518298984,
0.6382108927,
0.8189315796,
0.0969330519,
0.0580581725,
-0.6303833723,
-0.5050447583,
-0.3969681263,
-0.3616924882,
0.1213761121,
0.1241087765,
0.3260141015,
0.1757225245,
0.1104983017,
-0.4847777188,
0.2797518969,
-0.1396065205,
-0.2843157053,
0.4600905478,
-0.0833818167,
0.3725261092,
0.0248004142,
-0.3001280725,
-0.2832694352,
-0.6733130813,
0.5240092874,
0.8190542459,
0.2845149338,
-0.0025531175,
0.4184198678,
-0.2502473295,
0.7608523965,
0.242205292,
-0.1534748822,
0.3131843209,
0.0129987141,
-0.0160971247,
-0.046044033,
0.7539579272,
0.2778888643,
0.4918924868,
-0.315354377,
-0.4672465026,
0.2531426549,
0.6597931385,
-0.7938014865,
-0.2350204289,
0.0199038927,
-0.6147097349,
-0.2676994503,
-0.0115824416,
-0.3307916522,
-0.1194062606,
-0.9254180193,
0.7616901994,
-0.3898676634,
-0.0278044194,
0.256133616,
0.0548744313,
-0.0026967244,
0.2217133492,
-1.1746670008,
0.3912676871,
0.4639578164,
0.3572213054,
-0.3389503956,
-0.5294552445,
-0.5748025179,
-0.1185296401,
-0.1858704388,
0.6190431714,
-0.4095594883,
-0.1805100888,
-0.0628092736,
-0.1063921303,
0.0663476512,
-0.3054883182,
0.446197927,
-0.5039296746,
0.6032118797,
-0.4872102439,
-0.6758388877,
0.0222650822,
0.1927240193,
-0.4281879365,
0.7246511579,
-0.0099359117,
-0.6708912849,
0.5701505542,
-0.5868700147,
-0.4493407309,
-0.2784263194,
-0.122841008,
-0.2343807518,
-0.1228954196,
-0.0301634241,
0.434781462,
-0.1584279984,
0.361068666,
-0.1626732349,
-0.2481042445,
0.3029730916,
-0.2370129675,
0.3726643324,
0.3005492985,
-0.419195652,
0.2562779188,
-0.4262937903,
0.2113739252,
0.0284658056,
-0.6465265155,
-0.3672548831,
0.2773157656,
-0.2172854096,
0.2033409923,
0.4669222534,
-0.3195463419,
-0.0699992925,
-0.5237474442,
0.1857115477,
1.0331952572,
-0.350892812,
0.7027998567,
-0.6052891016,
0.4954660833,
-0.0672592968,
0.3507845998,
0.2740344703,
0.0037744702,
-0.9857842922,
0.0486003458,
0.1894431114,
0.3770192564,
-0.6536391377,
0.5228396058,
-0.0513690673,
-0.2008318454,
-0.4669837952,
0.4047399759,
0.8028843999,
0.453400135,
0.3289826512,
-0.4890833795,
-0.8026114702,
-0.8931667209,
-0.4010405242,
-0.1643368304,
0.0614048205,
0.062688373,
0.1239186749,
-0.1215348914,
1.0635029078,
-0.4096131325,
-0.0799626261,
-0.3798812032,
0.0521766879,
0.1363185942,
0.4056688249,
0.6746053696,
-0.9025864601,
-0.7751123905,
-0.2770733833,
-0.2713034749,
-0.1797712147,
0.0340767801,
-0.166672945,
0.2029134035,
0.3103819191,
-0.3682585657,
0.1957713962,
0.5509385467,
-0.0021798639,
0.4978840947,
-0.2811306417,
0.1900437176,
-0.793843925,
0.1130417883,
-0.1891776621,
-0.371843636,
-0.7571004629,
-0.2486207783,
-0.0932777151,
-0.017128624,
-0.5761421323,
0.6923450232,
-0.3831597567,
-0.0039213453,
-0.3583063185,
-0.0236247964,
0.0826528147,
0.6622906923,
0.4920265079,
0.7671030164,
0.2321271896,
-0.8035915494,
-0.0935549363,
0.0543528311,
-0.276869297,
0.2930819392,
-0.5989186168,
0.2388580441,
-0.3466369808,
0.0142238941,
-0.5890862942,
-0.0288019404,
0.2508637607,
-0.5070171952,
0.1785518527,
0.0885196105,
-0.2130347043,
-0.1534351707,
-0.3390125632,
0.1113855913,
0.7483999133,
-0.5220359564,
0.2421416193,
0.4740584493,
0.0139678037,
-0.70126158,
-0.3683048487,
-0.3194478452,
-0.2544968128,
-0.0536984317,
0.3151917756,
-0.2807202041,
-0.0097204251,
-0.0817078725,
0.1755162776,
0.0089720665,
0.2049896419,
0.2553852201,
0.2291829884,
-0.0043516634,
-0.0390416272,
-0.27008304,
-0.3019945323,
-0.0834555775,
-0.5110513568,
0.7073284984,
-0.1784908175,
-0.3038674891,
-0.4104836285,
0.1425059587,
-0.0840514824,
-0.2960308492,
0.6467989087,
0.3853268623,
-0.1316114664,
-0.0302220769,
-0.5729122758,
-0.3539024591,
-0.4926273227,
0.2804717422,
-0.2281219363,
-0.8339006901,
-0.0026088357,
0.2270259559,
0.1389139891,
0.0718297735,
0.5097143054,
-0.3529524803,
1.1929810047,
0.5771022439,
-0.1684137285,
0.7966590524,
0.0469604954,
0.0910638794,
-0.3972538412,
0.0259347744,
-0.4956549704,
-0.314568013,
-0.4000226557,
-0.0108805262,
0.046277415,
0.3223978877,
-0.4864247739,
0.3322936594,
-0.3037391603,
0.6367227435,
0.7640433311,
0.3262421787,
-0.0761291459,
-0.1076872274,
-0.1616335064,
-0.2078872174,
-0.7084466815,
-0.7301727533,
1.1939595938,
0.1304320842,
0.634600997,
-0.0281752832,
0.9633334279,
0.1451641917,
0.5993130803,
-0.5146765113,
0.3515430987,
-0.3193257749,
-0.6542410254,
-0.4306564033,
-0.3651637137,
-1.0187351704,
0.0501790792,
-0.4346064627,
-0.7084979415,
-0.1311455816,
0.8110727072,
-0.3791931868,
0.2543062866,
-0.8938954473,
0.9739672542,
-0.7368654013,
-0.3267561793,
-0.1425654888,
-0.8233605623,
0.1200469881,
-0.0204770565,
0.2420649678,
-0.1050241962,
0.1008127704,
0.7173807621,
-0.325008601,
1.018006444,
-0.2928746343,
0.2637854815,
0.0614613891,
-0.1351384968,
0.3942895234,
-0.2082949281,
-0.0574286059,
-0.2101347893,
-0.0451028049,
-0.377998054,
-0.4729335308,
0.3611349761,
-1.2436783314,
-0.7609462738,
-0.2576846778,
-0.1747141927,
-0.3757240176,
0.4878647923,
0.5287982225,
0.2855092585,
-0.4345656633,
-0.0030360736,
0.4928537309,
-0.2908255458,
0.3082894087,
0.5125268698,
-0.4025151134,
-0.1998807788,
1.0408142805,
-0.1383046806,
0.515461266,
0.6769449115,
0.3661665916,
-0.4830323756,
-0.4488963187,
-0.1572966427,
-0.0546176359,
-0.6929190755,
0.0174093992,
-0.5599796176,
-0.1102548018,
-0.3257006705,
-0.3460684419,
-0.5095413923,
0.0312009081,
-0.5955931544,
-0.0077969744,
-0.0483693108,
0.5626914501,
-0.1532111764,
0.6441239119,
-0.7726845741,
0.2414832264,
0.5373238325,
0.4195860624,
-0.0503558442,
-0.4862491488,
-0.2469563931,
0.3549683988,
-0.2603075206,
-0.5280586481,
0.3281766772,
0.1328451782,
0.7716988325,
0.5847757459,
0.1342989206,
0.4996909499,
-0.6493774652,
0.4485867023,
0.4135421515,
-1.0312978029,
0.3979546428,
-0.127009064,
0.0221818499,
0.900534153,
0.7593661547,
-0.546984911,
-0.0618910864,
-0.3917273581,
-0.4325152636,
0.8182817698,
0.1116802916,
0.2550680339,
-0.075776808,
0.4331351221,
0.3253134787,
0.4117396772,
-1.0800018311,
-0.166279465,
-0.5505623817,
-0.0945366025,
-0.5599268079,
-0.2031128407,
-0.0083557852,
-0.2021584064,
0.6419320107,
-0.0300264712,
0.0318352319,
-0.0253330637,
-0.4882897139,
0.0659222454,
0.3409821391,
0.4244593084,
0.5731215477,
-0.2886485457,
0.2517091632,
-0.0197443571,
-0.1473356634,
0.4730505049,
-0.2045233399,
-0.2097219825,
-0.3967995346,
0.1438908428,
1.2313921452,
0.2753008008,
-0.6684898734,
0.6454902887,
-0.1247548312,
-0.1207177341,
-0.158491239,
0.2732449174,
0.1124639511,
-0.1580359936,
-0.0857175812,
-0.0193908419,
-0.0403207056,
-0.5145215988,
0.1102327555,
0.443433255,
-0.4438422024,
-0.4727717638,
0.5730628967,
0.193726778,
-0.474309355,
0.3280231357,
-0.2595168352,
-0.6931530237,
0.151432693,
0.403180033,
0.6199811697,
-0.2504118681,
0.3587737083,
0.1107574925,
0.2537091076,
-0.2366681993,
0.1779656559,
-0.0240617711,
-1.0773332119,
-0.2880356908,
-0.8269215822,
-0.2605317235,
0.0358587466,
-0.6903299093,
0.4804292023,
-0.364610523,
-0.2661349773,
-0.1014827639,
-0.1283775568,
-0.9813209772,
0.4361810386,
0.0622828342,
0.297408551,
-0.6686048508,
0.9506927729,
0.7693145275,
-0.472794503,
-0.8767968416,
-0.1313356161,
-0.0628464445,
-0.90802145,
0.7315991521,
0.2265838981,
-0.068524912,
0.1616378427,
-0.3727586865,
-0.7744325995,
0.5850651264,
0.624530673,
-0.5482456088,
-0.1588531286,
0.2788817883,
0.4627339244,
-0.3022022247,
0.3121399283,
0.510389626,
0.3665673733,
-0.3764422238,
-0.8345699906,
-0.230710566,
-0.1118409932,
-0.0324452966,
0.2713423669,
-0.5066816211,
0.839214921,
-0.1725393683,
-0.2294329256,
-0.0923259854,
0.292964071,
-0.0263880696,
-0.2346493751,
0.9978191257,
0.5071620941,
0.4994254112,
0.1357591301,
1.1763013601,
-0.3009365797,
0.1045989692,
1.1334972382,
-0.227770105,
0.7836359143,
0.5711593032,
-0.2492848486,
0.3892521262,
0.9067724347,
0.5580276847,
0.7128879428,
0.2337056696,
0.0553220138,
-0.5281071067,
-0.0224485006,
-0.2929890752,
0.4290013313,
-0.0682384446,
-0.1207763553,
0.0054333629,
0.0987605453,
0.0184524208,
0.2854245603,
-0.0183553509,
0.8768352866,
-0.0321118459,
-1.0095245838,
0.5855336189,
-0.0523653813,
0.836889863,
-0.8353477716,
0.3045831025,
-0.1639475375,
0.0957643837,
-0.073781155,
-0.3751402199,
0.0261845049,
-0.1071180701,
-0.3525313735,
-0.6558668017,
0.5551223755,
-0.5032076836,
-0.0364444964,
0.3115954995,
0.372101754,
0.1123490185,
-0.0474688821,
-0.7172960043,
-0.2357824892,
0.106646657,
-0.4900848866,
0.7482458353,
0.014033827,
0.087109834,
0.4728388488,
0.9461296797,
0.2217940241,
-0.038263306,
0.091059044,
0.7693067789,
-0.433011353,
-0.785513401,
-0.8676607013,
0.3781145513,
0.0553826913,
-0.3308829367,
0.5586389303,
0.380571723,
1.1167874336,
-0.0817077309,
0.8374451399,
0.0592429303,
0.6165590882,
-0.736859858,
0.7467344403,
-0.6374440193,
0.1599904448,
-0.2880846858,
-0.9351825118,
0.0821633488,
0.5699746609,
-0.5544636846,
0.1057682931,
0.6273954511,
0.5877328515,
-0.0760503784,
-0.158041358,
0.3443873227,
-0.2865538299,
0.1730211824,
0.5545320511,
1.0673251152,
0.1749072969,
0.3524439037,
-0.4476756454,
-0.2836757898,
-0.0874519572,
-0.994124949,
-1.0259689093,
-0.5965425372,
0.1485859454,
-0.1191054657,
0.2536873519,
1.3043564558,
0.9602662325,
-0.8258376122,
-0.4383106828,
0.0187163465,
0.0393819734,
0.2065417767,
-0.1451103985,
0.1606242806,
-0.7707808018,
-0.5873609185,
0.0669888705,
0.0347222313,
0.2643122971,
-0.1584480852,
-0.643530488,
-0.2076752931,
-0.153146252,
0.5298889875,
0.4175370336,
-0.6380470991,
-0.5190111399,
0.1191488206,
-0.2328911871,
0.0742784515,
1.0600076914,
-0.602234304,
0.3964897394,
0.4406960607,
0.7904561162,
0.3929390907,
0.019362431,
0.813293457,
-0.7152345777,
0.3930289745,
0.207121253,
0.2767932117,
0.2195000052,
-0.1151183397,
0.0092641804,
-0.0568583645,
-0.5582116246,
-0.7209955454,
0.2745232284,
-0.3621342778,
-0.4045217037,
0.9086796641,
-0.3319628537,
0.0396871045,
-0.0038062269,
-0.2563210428,
0.3103463948,
-0.2556682229,
0.6938998103,
0.5984687209,
-0.2062800378,
-0.0438726097,
-0.3700831234,
1.0602099895,
0.8041018844,
-0.9440012574,
-0.2102224976,
0.3233737051,
0.309627831,
-0.1403591037,
0.9460455179,
0.3078876138,
0.1998372227,
-0.4660900235,
0.4642282426,
0.1336199492,
-0.4523766041,
-0.0400473177,
-0.2903807461,
0.483915478,
-0.0998393297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08577v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08577v3 | For Generated Text, Is NLI-Neutral Text the Best Text? | 2023-02-16T20:46:36 | 2024-01-20T02:36:12 | Michail Mersinias, Kyle Mahowald | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore incorporating natural language inference (NLI) into the text
generative pipeline by using a pre-trained NLI model to assess whether a
generated sentence entails, contradicts, or is neutral to the prompt and
preceding text. First, we show that the NLI task is predictive of generation
errors made by GPT-3. We use these results to develop an NLI-informed
generation procedure for GPT-J. Then, we evaluate these generations by
obtaining human annotations on error types and overall quality. We find that an
NLI strategy of maximizing entailment improves text generation when the nucleus
sampling randomness parameter value is high, while one which maximizes
contradiction is in fact productive when the parameter value is low. Overall,
though, we demonstrate that an NLI strategy of maximizing the neutral class
provides the highest quality of generated text (significantly better than the
vanilla generations), regardless of parameter value. | [
-0.23275204,
-0.8543614149,
0.5890779495,
0.234535113,
-0.2319667339,
0.0275263861,
-0.0974484012,
-0.3922262192,
0.0124101499,
0.3441678584,
-0.6353647709,
-0.5087215304,
-0.3921317756,
0.5758442283,
-0.4195785522,
1.2809073925,
0.0917990878,
-0.3020491302,
-0.2312636077,
0.2041964084,
-0.4903601408,
-0.3382455707,
-0.6652109027,
-0.510142982,
0.3819012046,
0.1557473838,
0.8381338716,
0.489700675,
0.1398032308,
0.3344116509,
-0.0320518501,
0.1580871344,
-0.4357729852,
0.3084505498,
-0.1696301848,
-0.3475142121,
-0.2095928043,
0.1558785886,
0.2040437758,
0.6112639308,
-0.0742431805,
-0.1122607291,
0.1432548761,
0.6389225125,
-0.8045182824,
-0.2054678649,
-0.653283,
0.2372940034,
-0.2640761137,
-0.2787761986,
-0.6791946292,
-0.6840506196,
0.1680157036,
-0.7602553964,
0.6358621716,
0.0241640937,
1.2990648746,
0.3410835862,
-0.6041975617,
-0.470621407,
-0.7340991497,
0.9856433272,
-1.0066578388,
0.0562601238,
0.3150178194,
0.0207986794,
-0.1689188927,
-0.5176215172,
-0.8175177574,
-0.1885804981,
-0.0791001245,
0.7319492102,
-0.2433738708,
0.2752642035,
0.1924865991,
0.5947695971,
-0.8286647201,
0.0581114031,
0.0251257867,
-0.1072991043,
0.5547987223,
-0.0886547342,
0.6724672318,
-0.5161879063,
-0.0163370278,
0.0374202691,
-0.6952512264,
-0.4012465477,
0.9366960526,
0.1035361141,
0.0842518806,
0.8518814445,
-0.301217705,
0.9532637,
0.0794679374,
0.0807719082,
0.3076481521,
-0.7352845073,
-0.335214287,
0.0635262281,
0.9704665542,
0.5098381042,
0.5141623616,
-0.539447844,
-0.2316146642,
0.4039850533,
0.2839017808,
-0.6380319595,
0.0588716567,
0.2869612873,
-0.3987295628,
-0.6336632371,
0.0977245718,
-0.7270708084,
-0.2640815973,
-0.4722712338,
0.2797433734,
-0.5371471047,
-0.1094308496,
0.0613378361,
-0.4769092798,
0.1155777723,
0.0091654342,
-1.1175464392,
0.0962834358,
0.5554451942,
0.5101941228,
0.0432466976,
-0.1146679819,
-0.5160757899,
0.1490768045,
-0.4797409773,
0.770352304,
-0.1978032142,
-0.3407654762,
0.1517421752,
-0.4817506969,
-0.0173833035,
-0.6374137402,
0.9394618273,
-0.3311433792,
0.850482583,
-0.1497582644,
-0.8169257641,
0.0240400452,
0.0823787525,
-0.4737792313,
0.7987228632,
0.2298552245,
-1.0163769722,
0.6578574777,
-0.5099436641,
-0.502607584,
0.148988381,
-0.1129776016,
-0.3430109322,
0.1156067774,
0.1619078666,
0.2184378207,
-0.2897259891,
0.6902665496,
-0.0928609148,
-0.2258511484,
0.2655103803,
-0.5871129036,
0.8187229037,
0.3727524877,
-0.5299835801,
0.0155503135,
-0.8826355934,
0.1701205522,
0.2111959606,
-0.2782273889,
-0.1096845493,
0.1364857852,
-0.0147163337,
-0.1467439681,
-0.0956294909,
-0.7562769055,
-0.1376294345,
-0.7938540578,
0.4049069285,
0.4936510921,
0.3686979711,
0.4669789374,
-0.2391188592,
0.250783205,
-0.3289690912,
0.0113779046,
0.0523733161,
-0.854062736,
-0.7846554518,
0.2658323348,
0.3132198155,
0.7440915108,
-1.0776515007,
0.6946318746,
0.0402456075,
-0.1929084361,
-0.4452833235,
0.0534737334,
0.400403738,
0.6311876178,
0.3203173578,
0.0486910082,
-0.7653912306,
-1.0156503916,
-0.4093607664,
-0.3427409232,
-0.3464204967,
-0.1846730709,
0.2393655777,
-0.2686947882,
1.1638196707,
-0.3351598978,
0.2073084116,
-0.5036361814,
0.7791924477,
0.3639887869,
0.4033817649,
0.4222009778,
-0.6860718727,
-0.4000452757,
-0.2100830376,
-1.0160256624,
-0.444460541,
-0.5846350193,
-0.4231216609,
0.195405677,
0.1843969673,
-0.5820023417,
0.5188760161,
0.474463135,
-0.4830420911,
0.2919771075,
-0.1327511519,
0.060674157,
-1.1209192276,
0.0023583651,
0.1902090609,
-0.0150698014,
-0.9349566698,
-0.0361844786,
-0.1381490976,
0.1327376217,
-0.052081123,
0.2325157523,
-0.3047149181,
0.1985711008,
-0.4451865852,
0.221056506,
0.2842996716,
0.1419524848,
-0.0423535779,
0.8391561508,
0.2030690163,
-0.5641546845,
-0.0074262465,
0.2532063127,
-0.2483845055,
0.3031113446,
-0.6682773232,
0.1721713692,
-0.392862618,
0.1712592989,
-0.7722344995,
-0.3867732584,
0.2007096112,
-0.5115132928,
0.2862620652,
0.1128411293,
-0.4717472792,
-0.2445229739,
-0.10577555,
0.1001277864,
0.6867996454,
-0.4323419333,
0.5059152246,
0.0271247774,
0.0332252607,
-0.5812752247,
-0.8335783482,
0.3546016514,
-0.0224457942,
-0.3894810379,
0.4016772211,
-0.1439727247,
-0.2522901595,
-0.0248600245,
0.1725994647,
-0.1158396602,
0.0076369271,
0.0960085019,
0.2156875134,
-0.3069246411,
-0.2580656409,
0.2221775949,
-0.2235687375,
0.0380713828,
-0.18930839,
0.2460047603,
-0.0711052641,
-0.2810801864,
-0.3952778578,
0.4514644444,
0.1283642352,
0.0391317084,
0.6694415808,
0.6068321466,
-0.298419416,
-0.1519610733,
-0.5233379006,
0.1083612517,
-0.456307292,
0.0404414758,
-0.0632754788,
-0.6085974574,
0.1069237515,
0.3160922229,
0.1084721163,
0.675994277,
0.2098767161,
0.0507559441,
1.1396209002,
0.4936255813,
0.1425078809,
0.2176380008,
-0.2137893289,
0.4062155783,
-0.5111715794,
0.1350044459,
-0.5581695437,
0.0881501958,
-0.7152339816,
0.0298127066,
0.0570413806,
0.4556848407,
-0.3729370534,
0.202911064,
-0.6946347952,
0.730414331,
0.7664887905,
-0.0839357823,
0.2115078121,
-0.1062267199,
0.0009368036,
-0.1720590442,
-0.7068879008,
-0.7866618037,
0.8847839236,
0.1619965583,
0.196232453,
0.211520046,
0.9932552576,
-0.0181288049,
0.7475394011,
-0.4073705673,
0.4892756045,
-0.283061564,
-0.5985514522,
-0.0329160839,
-0.660605073,
-0.799456656,
0.0487589426,
-0.5392434597,
-0.5052649975,
-0.0196690597,
0.1600233465,
-0.2502140403,
0.3027700782,
-1.1195577383,
0.8465043306,
-0.0860635117,
-0.2467126548,
0.3127599657,
-0.6513569951,
0.526674509,
0.1734969169,
-0.1093457937,
-0.0403463021,
0.1494334787,
0.4534483552,
-0.1514673531,
0.7463302016,
-0.2262586355,
-0.0554528758,
0.7722762227,
0.0749369934,
0.3265572786,
0.1293644309,
-0.3699036241,
0.0239268523,
-0.5733128786,
-0.3683290482,
-0.7264416218,
0.2926384807,
-0.718947053,
-0.4557851851,
-0.2459513694,
-0.1271510422,
-0.2018508017,
0.3881517053,
0.9450075626,
0.5159816146,
-0.3432888687,
-0.0167037435,
0.5883211493,
-0.6349050403,
0.5349046588,
0.0095666591,
-0.0588342957,
-0.4644639492,
1.1074770689,
-0.1984489113,
0.4517751932,
0.5890201926,
0.4762396216,
-0.3897179365,
-0.8528629541,
-0.7924665809,
-0.0007877338,
-0.7436620593,
-0.1919530034,
-0.6965196133,
-0.5231225491,
-0.2929165959,
-0.3603152335,
-0.081394285,
-0.1571224183,
-0.4858512282,
-0.3502382338,
0.0398463048,
0.8820883632,
0.069846116,
0.1292352378,
-0.6335788965,
0.4289111495,
0.374040097,
0.1131245717,
-0.2295789123,
-0.2218995243,
0.3077445924,
-0.003437716,
-0.4420266151,
-0.9517570138,
0.3293964565,
0.2051382363,
0.43089059,
0.3070603013,
0.113819398,
0.2631862164,
-0.6495955586,
1.0886698961,
0.4528173804,
-1.0150388479,
0.5788838863,
-0.7292470932,
0.6222425699,
0.7065067887,
0.1485148668,
-0.4195869267,
-1.1936662197,
-0.6586533189,
-0.9592759013,
0.2152917832,
0.7719113231,
0.2393622994,
-0.5399191976,
0.4080215991,
0.2498372346,
0.2189130485,
-1.0974787474,
-0.2106019855,
-0.6904041767,
-0.734462142,
0.0235376172,
-0.2619754672,
0.141666308,
0.1421544254,
0.6747701764,
-0.2128472775,
0.4057946205,
0.2871562839,
0.1074520871,
-0.1866440475,
0.5735613704,
0.6584782004,
0.6565155387,
-0.3086198866,
0.1807184964,
0.3688754737,
-0.384465158,
0.0275035165,
-0.1576650143,
-0.6853044033,
0.2361514568,
0.6124004126,
0.9351803064,
-0.2019995153,
-0.3750330508,
0.6003910303,
-0.2255675048,
-0.5633867979,
-0.0007137757,
0.1737733185,
-0.0665558949,
-0.2406659722,
0.1832552552,
0.3062964678,
0.3707987964,
-0.3022236228,
0.1512489915,
0.25792557,
-0.0522008799,
-0.2406734377,
0.7994648814,
0.2472003102,
-0.2340226322,
0.5852190256,
-0.4609690011,
-0.2910347581,
0.4875195026,
0.6635987163,
1.1648926735,
0.1806893945,
0.6039893627,
0.6765164733,
0.3593832254,
0.1330827177,
0.2060936242,
0.2094467431,
-0.9220618606,
-0.8676070571,
-0.5571243167,
-0.4245721102,
0.2007426769,
-0.5022369027,
-0.0056386408,
-0.336787492,
-0.128948316,
0.0897100419,
-0.5037962198,
-0.4401439726,
0.5308482647,
0.2851417959,
0.4143573046,
-0.7355445623,
0.2804432511,
0.3628314435,
-0.4756934047,
-0.6524885893,
0.3736822009,
0.0049949558,
-0.2850788832,
0.561889112,
0.2565394342,
-0.2821622491,
-0.0383377522,
-0.5464043617,
-0.5922049284,
0.5864889622,
0.4091008008,
-0.2963319421,
0.0234807786,
0.2727365792,
0.6722531319,
0.0339590125,
0.5114689469,
0.1643144488,
0.3419367373,
-0.1226008385,
-0.3141212761,
0.0545460321,
-0.3426846862,
0.2071962208,
0.2540795207,
-0.2211583853,
0.573736608,
-0.070856899,
-0.5832588673,
0.2560865581,
0.922635138,
0.1692072302,
0.3863321841,
0.550111115,
0.7076622248,
0.5978756547,
-0.1951389015,
1.3480260372,
-0.0569232032,
-0.01130067,
1.0975464582,
-0.2377806157,
0.6216272712,
0.2573470175,
0.1436439008,
0.5822985172,
0.5308087468,
0.1078621894,
0.4501523972,
0.3013848662,
-0.4876698554,
0.0156863332,
-0.0535583086,
-0.2587481141,
0.1949761808,
-0.0601281337,
-0.164872542,
-0.2626136839,
-0.1009818763,
-0.0850962549,
0.4486094713,
0.2290885895,
1.0207290649,
-0.1958328784,
-1.1746698618,
0.5449368358,
0.1593925208,
0.757396102,
-0.3771337867,
0.0238038246,
-0.2737583816,
-0.0497699976,
-0.2749466598,
-0.7824717164,
0.4613083899,
0.3721162975,
-0.3760114312,
-0.519828558,
0.6980311275,
-0.3632897735,
-0.3247766197,
0.0224288534,
0.3600099087,
-0.1122937799,
0.2317098379,
-0.54493016,
-0.4200540781,
0.1938491613,
-0.2518102825,
0.1339164674,
0.5596282482,
0.3803072572,
0.1776092201,
0.6397768259,
-0.0407709219,
0.0536808819,
0.6575513482,
0.5107340217,
-0.5644388795,
-0.4096571207,
-0.8948022127,
0.6721456647,
-0.3996843696,
-0.7101058364,
0.7790426612,
0.5600408912,
0.696688056,
-0.0358064659,
0.9571813345,
-0.0267342739,
0.6141486168,
-0.8225783706,
0.4655201435,
-0.2050334513,
-0.1040583476,
-0.4397444725,
-1.0237103701,
-0.38561517,
0.5604096651,
-0.3548171818,
0.0435016714,
0.9079165459,
0.6620119214,
0.1169616431,
0.7041725516,
0.0430764146,
-0.1530337334,
0.349148035,
0.469050765,
1.2489441633,
-0.5788241029,
0.2881007493,
-0.2213211656,
-0.1196931601,
0.5000678897,
-1.0528415442,
-0.7759467363,
-0.1747397482,
-0.4994835556,
-0.503679812,
0.093110621,
0.6069604754,
0.4844377041,
-0.9527819157,
-0.0328231081,
-1.1722966433,
0.0859207511,
0.0304902755,
-0.2917571962,
0.0077392282,
-0.6813274026,
-0.677888453,
0.5601399541,
0.1549999565,
0.3031052947,
0.094570823,
-0.1763691604,
-0.163820222,
0.1417298764,
0.4352329969,
0.0520958938,
-0.6079303026,
-0.3310637772,
-0.0734642223,
-0.1841693521,
-0.1559742689,
0.841349721,
-0.3505010903,
0.455727756,
0.3986868858,
0.8349655271,
0.1810050309,
0.1166468635,
0.9160265923,
-0.9378995299,
0.0053368928,
0.4502756894,
0.1094213948,
0.4598522186,
-0.4958293438,
0.55463624,
0.3034145236,
-0.6548815966,
-0.6283003092,
0.3030103445,
-0.6628772616,
-0.3423027098,
1.2695293427,
0.2322348207,
-0.1576336324,
-0.2783461511,
-0.2178523839,
0.5122938156,
-0.1260825843,
0.5474783778,
0.6296572685,
-0.0069344654,
0.0014854865,
-0.9335625172,
0.6977968216,
0.7390657663,
-1.0532051325,
-0.2339707911,
0.3212303519,
-0.1751257479,
0.2412867546,
0.4697257578,
0.1095678806,
-0.0029868446,
0.245055005,
0.1355376691,
0.1696643978,
-0.0121649737,
0.0217595845,
0.1271827817,
0.0139761595,
0.0450703204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08575v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08575v1 | Foundation Models for Natural Language Processing -- Pre-trained Language Models Integrating Media | 2023-02-16T20:42:04 | 2023-02-16T20:42:04 | Gerhard Paaß, Sven Giesselbach | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM, 68W20, 68W25, I.2.6; I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.10; I.4.8; I.4.10; I.5.2; I.5.4; I.7.0;
J.1; J.3; K.4.1; K.4.2; K.5.0 | This open access book provides a comprehensive overview of the state of the
art in research and applications of Foundation Models and is intended for
readers familiar with basic Natural Language Processing (NLP) concepts. Over
the recent years, a revolutionary new paradigm has been developed for training
models for NLP. These models are first pre-trained on large collections of text
documents to acquire general syntactic knowledge and semantic information.
Then, they are fine-tuned for specific tasks, which they can often solve with
superhuman accuracy. When the models are large enough, they can be instructed
by prompts to solve new tasks without any fine-tuning. Moreover, they can be
applied to a wide range of different media and problem domains, ranging from
image and video processing to robot control learning. Because they provide a
blueprint for solving many tasks in artificial intelligence, they have been
called Foundation Models. After a brief introduction to basic NLP models the
main pre-trained language models BERT, GPT and sequence-to-sequence transformer
are described, as well as the concepts of self-attention and context-sensitive
embedding. Then, different approaches to improving these models are discussed,
such as expanding the pre-training criteria, increasing the length of input
texts, or including extra knowledge. An overview of the best-performing models
for about twenty application areas is then presented, e.g., question answering,
translation, story generation, dialog systems, generating images from text,
etc. For each application area, the strengths and weaknesses of current models
are discussed, and an outlook on further developments is given. In addition,
links are provided to freely available program code. A concluding chapter
summarizes the economic opportunities, mitigation of risks, and potential
developments of AI. | [
-0.5830917358,
-0.840071857,
0.2916354239,
0.3291559815,
0.0427347049,
-0.0881030038,
-0.2944139242,
-0.6102793813,
-0.2075686157,
1.0009839535,
-0.4656788409,
-0.3530264795,
-0.8915305138,
0.0355283469,
-0.8174825311,
0.7451372743,
-0.05224308,
-0.0505668782,
-0.2870166302,
-0.0769383013,
-0.3298494816,
-0.51458323,
-0.4628091753,
-0.3329074681,
-0.2781197429,
0.1235010624,
0.8010659218,
0.5413889885,
0.7967626452,
0.3950592279,
-0.0752411634,
-0.3321897089,
-0.2409845293,
-0.0582650639,
-0.2919757068,
-0.2457006872,
-0.4474952519,
0.1903312206,
0.7450556755,
1.1388018131,
0.0426292866,
0.0415207297,
0.0477904044,
0.8004156947,
-0.586233139,
0.1428519487,
-0.2771757841,
0.1084474698,
0.0894849226,
-0.1852346659,
-0.3608255684,
-0.3529483378,
0.4413274527,
-0.3718091846,
0.2354204804,
-0.3155096769,
0.7303257585,
0.4857549667,
-0.3345776796,
-0.5745458603,
-0.8826596737,
0.8262666464,
-0.615604043,
0.5965999365,
0.5237683654,
0.2008221596,
-0.3433600664,
-0.8788310885,
-0.3973231614,
-0.3014330566,
-0.1294904202,
-0.2077341825,
-0.3663044274,
0.39286834,
0.0096686678,
0.6827979684,
-0.6700586081,
-0.0700323135,
-0.3350540102,
0.1318142265,
0.5035262108,
-0.1545800865,
0.3628499806,
0.1130465716,
-0.1002109349,
0.0213776752,
-0.5009533167,
0.0451318696,
0.0655357465,
0.1886197776,
0.0975626409,
0.6978235245,
-0.5314908624,
1.2093894482,
-0.0314030312,
-0.0954085812,
-0.0432346985,
-0.5378571749,
-0.6014387608,
-0.2338031083,
0.5830184817,
-0.1408468038,
0.488445282,
-0.2550353706,
-0.1784886718,
0.1203665808,
0.2681592107,
-0.525857091,
-0.0656931922,
0.15430668,
-0.4924107492,
-0.3198980987,
-0.1301560998,
-0.6502702832,
-0.116802454,
-0.6780280471,
0.3284459114,
-0.3036815524,
-0.3415048718,
0.4754451811,
0.1862387806,
0.2340641916,
0.1457487792,
-0.9785915613,
0.8250747919,
0.4074252844,
0.6902709007,
-0.0418368503,
-0.2033407241,
-0.2691248655,
0.1542216837,
-0.2205864787,
0.7039433122,
-0.4183166921,
-0.1835489571,
0.2277143151,
-0.1801833063,
0.0852799565,
-0.4562323689,
0.5792160034,
-0.6698614955,
0.3571510017,
0.1040738896,
-0.537705183,
-0.2918623984,
0.3380076885,
-0.8136641979,
0.9389614463,
0.1374023557,
-0.5811400414,
-0.2070240974,
-1.1615915298,
-0.5800958276,
-0.1783338636,
0.1170081571,
0.219468087,
0.1339328438,
0.2807548046,
0.5231964588,
-0.4060141742,
0.5277794003,
0.176806584,
-0.007871002,
-0.1995206773,
-0.1078397036,
0.9484695196,
0.1364069879,
-0.3213810921,
0.2437744588,
-0.8844338655,
-0.0377576798,
0.1202350631,
-0.41020751,
-0.1852114946,
0.009571244,
0.1479743719,
0.182015866,
0.2152769119,
-0.2842912674,
-0.0907645524,
-0.578641355,
0.575979352,
0.3300208151,
-0.230295673,
0.7584766746,
0.0568727963,
0.4116073549,
-0.1013907269,
0.1296778023,
-0.5227755904,
-0.4288106859,
-0.7715815306,
0.0910105556,
0.411220938,
0.5921313167,
-0.5565705299,
0.4827440083,
-0.1000590175,
-0.3713503182,
-0.5462206006,
0.2253482491,
0.1653145105,
0.5438307524,
0.5641302466,
-0.4694981277,
-0.6148995161,
-0.7476323843,
-0.2057475001,
0.0094593698,
0.094070226,
0.0198874548,
0.4397550821,
-0.3092539907,
1.2530728579,
-0.3962957561,
-0.3165433109,
-0.3373979926,
0.3007192612,
0.2492890209,
0.6579896212,
0.4980215728,
-1.1413843632,
-0.2150543928,
-0.0923372358,
-0.7525628805,
0.0290721934,
0.1618558615,
-0.0929737464,
0.0882335976,
0.5316789746,
-0.7538488507,
0.5165702701,
0.7139453888,
-0.0964724794,
0.4423601925,
-0.0322527811,
-0.0174875371,
-0.9213559628,
0.3166623116,
0.21131441,
-0.246107161,
-0.8875445127,
0.2819359601,
-0.3175238371,
-0.4045839608,
-0.263079524,
0.8464778066,
-0.4931808412,
-0.2973118424,
-0.4673004448,
0.1125001758,
-0.1198198274,
0.4140439928,
0.5160236359,
0.4281953871,
0.3493823111,
-0.7230007648,
0.3775882721,
0.2997002304,
-0.5246312022,
0.271051079,
-0.6210840344,
0.0906425565,
-0.2177985311,
0.0627934039,
-0.6845340729,
-0.2249941826,
-0.002170691,
-0.4555089474,
0.3486543298,
0.0723931864,
-0.3666830063,
-0.2624855042,
0.1198695377,
0.0851431191,
0.2987558544,
-0.2115522474,
0.7631894946,
0.5955324173,
-0.4415156841,
-0.9264075756,
-0.6810467243,
0.1566448808,
0.3763648868,
-0.6172195077,
0.6426514387,
-0.1861892641,
-0.1382630467,
0.4681983292,
0.0301941205,
-0.6526882648,
0.2110923976,
-0.0667410642,
-0.1750282645,
-0.4774044752,
0.0582162552,
-0.0995858982,
-0.3265853822,
0.0049332259,
-0.3858458996,
0.5170776248,
-0.402458787,
-0.0677168891,
-0.2723136246,
0.595914185,
0.3582240641,
-0.5240988731,
0.6062273979,
0.4527415931,
-0.8804369569,
0.1598665416,
-0.516304791,
-0.1009900272,
-0.4100818038,
0.3695641756,
-0.1397840977,
-0.8259325027,
0.0928964019,
-0.2427830398,
0.2207208127,
0.2913118899,
0.5752019882,
-0.0346704312,
0.8392433524,
1.4079822302,
-0.1369440407,
0.6655448675,
-0.3733818233,
0.2966109514,
-0.4173622727,
0.0260197949,
-0.6752073169,
-0.025291346,
-0.0811577663,
-0.2602002621,
-0.2357641011,
0.4285412133,
-0.1721485853,
0.395648092,
-0.4056406915,
0.6772621274,
0.6788651347,
-0.3710345328,
0.5666441917,
-0.0843538344,
-0.0036666323,
0.1817686558,
-0.5451905131,
-0.7255783081,
0.9759498239,
0.4804712534,
0.5334200859,
-0.026780881,
0.4399478137,
0.3368053734,
0.5384675264,
-0.6646709442,
0.3503195345,
-0.1426187754,
-0.9650606513,
-0.3547650278,
-0.0037841965,
-0.5404691696,
0.0194806382,
-0.3095883131,
-0.6542332768,
0.0646327958,
0.2297568768,
-0.2859487534,
0.1514010131,
-0.5522392392,
1.1358326674,
-0.2724080384,
0.038411919,
-0.2259875536,
-0.8475888968,
0.5459356904,
-0.078407146,
0.1891566217,
-0.0025906069,
0.1533712447,
0.580950737,
0.1109740883,
0.8014779687,
-0.0568470284,
0.2315270007,
0.3627288938,
-0.1138515323,
0.1110739931,
-0.4398143291,
-0.1796849519,
0.0980609804,
0.2099784166,
-0.313200295,
-0.4675183594,
0.2654606402,
-0.7225783467,
-0.4214125872,
-0.2673715055,
-0.4906309843,
-0.2728989124,
0.507476747,
0.1483549178,
0.3043067157,
-0.6659205556,
0.4570613503,
0.8154748678,
-0.2443638742,
0.3602776229,
0.3342593908,
-0.2479483485,
-0.2408726066,
0.5446420908,
-0.0309731569,
0.1955859214,
0.6663355231,
0.022881534,
-0.2935330868,
-0.7242133617,
-0.1925646812,
0.105459474,
-0.9755907655,
-0.0430722721,
-0.8621064425,
-0.4675639272,
-0.590852499,
-0.3404974341,
-0.3289925158,
-0.3925504982,
-0.3650240898,
-0.1046933979,
-0.0016419161,
0.8187298775,
-0.0715821236,
0.7924049497,
-0.6958129406,
0.5158884525,
0.1962921321,
0.4833889902,
0.0282139424,
-0.1590169817,
-0.360331893,
-0.0194810107,
-0.3077958822,
-1.0271861553,
0.4314350188,
0.3194578588,
0.6801920533,
0.26630795,
-0.1250950992,
0.2867307961,
-0.4367941618,
0.515873611,
0.1482438445,
-1.0894492865,
0.7012558579,
-0.3497359753,
0.1623421758,
0.7262189388,
0.7019361258,
-0.5868359804,
0.0687502921,
-0.4979990125,
-0.6202471256,
0.6293876171,
0.1505209804,
0.0791671649,
0.0904953331,
0.2901962698,
-0.0823004916,
0.4625237882,
-1.0436751842,
-0.0360705778,
-0.3714769185,
-0.5618885159,
-0.1543485522,
-0.1631934941,
-0.089074187,
-0.2132631242,
0.7334186435,
-0.3011738658,
0.2987401783,
0.1372729242,
-0.6744024754,
-0.1513142735,
0.1467989832,
0.638676405,
0.754106164,
-0.3342199624,
-0.1854067445,
-0.2371557653,
-0.5093619823,
0.0598867983,
0.2298355997,
-0.1027462259,
-0.0475040041,
0.3579437137,
0.6565869451,
0.5063617826,
-0.7688185573,
0.483638376,
-0.1365938038,
-0.0057528936,
-0.3955537081,
-0.151437223,
0.0982354656,
0.1505462378,
0.2849459648,
0.1530067325,
0.2354028076,
-0.5423638225,
0.193190515,
0.3378895819,
-0.4202096164,
-0.2602109313,
0.5285567045,
0.3974245489,
-0.4640590847,
0.622160852,
0.1569114029,
-0.3993470371,
0.6174906492,
0.6684038639,
0.8526947498,
-0.3087603152,
0.161709711,
0.190570876,
0.5816705227,
-0.1701409519,
0.1312332302,
-0.1501337737,
-0.9867012501,
-0.5273084044,
-0.8488613367,
-0.4576365054,
0.3582406938,
-0.5158545971,
0.3019579947,
-0.6017321944,
-0.1851361841,
0.0521593839,
0.0852551311,
-1.0133472681,
0.4514896274,
0.0941233039,
1.2765467167,
-0.8337141871,
0.8586861491,
0.8703786135,
-0.4131334126,
-0.2078787535,
-0.2599636912,
-0.1411845237,
-0.3828678727,
0.5775166154,
0.1922867298,
0.042545978,
0.5527318716,
-0.5446227193,
-1.1351867914,
0.7078868747,
0.3629406095,
-0.1210465059,
-0.403611511,
0.1381375194,
0.4474440515,
-0.5654503107,
0.0819502994,
0.8936105967,
0.3629504442,
-0.1742290556,
-0.7512955666,
-0.4026835263,
-0.3173064291,
-0.125335604,
0.1535667479,
-0.0826326162,
0.6360271573,
-0.15059793,
-0.2137098759,
0.2934151292,
0.720236063,
0.0174518544,
0.0793228522,
0.2691052258,
0.638019979,
0.5271561742,
-0.252679199,
1.0055594444,
-0.4276773632,
0.0589052066,
1.0601409674,
-0.1085388064,
0.806976378,
0.3144240975,
-0.0960452557,
0.4704443514,
0.6428104043,
0.2429079115,
0.5565734506,
-0.0400491953,
-0.1482921094,
0.0612897389,
-0.2322234958,
-0.2642326355,
0.3747721612,
0.579098165,
-0.3730612695,
-0.2317580283,
0.0496730171,
-0.4357429743,
0.2181433439,
-0.2102666944,
0.677963376,
0.2016565204,
-0.5934634805,
0.1123231947,
0.374171555,
0.6109544635,
-0.7998083234,
-0.0531408191,
-0.0090366909,
0.1148616895,
-0.1070221961,
-0.6559978127,
0.5891968012,
0.0313846618,
-0.5468608737,
-0.3171396554,
0.9825536609,
-0.3212501407,
-0.406159997,
0.4131608009,
0.5548869967,
0.0162151624,
-0.12312904,
-0.74745363,
-0.0940729603,
-0.2755655348,
-0.4942978919,
0.1136756241,
0.0547005683,
-0.0641360059,
0.6536853313,
0.7864210606,
0.0022069283,
0.2519430518,
-0.0875132158,
0.6410186887,
-0.8820556402,
-0.535190165,
-0.4544150531,
0.5686614513,
-0.0128034931,
-0.2914178371,
0.0846009403,
0.1549117565,
1.0118916035,
-0.0183334574,
0.8250434399,
-0.1653555632,
0.3926760256,
-0.5148570538,
0.5756208897,
-0.2716889381,
-0.2751873136,
-0.3639616966,
-1.1271241903,
-0.4945694208,
0.8721075654,
-0.3325554132,
0.0773682073,
0.5215715766,
0.359362036,
-0.0286167841,
0.3243543208,
0.1640084535,
0.0075979568,
0.2182241678,
0.2504588664,
0.6181337237,
-0.4364835024,
0.1999385506,
-0.3836685419,
-0.3899249434,
-0.1938471645,
-1.1336396933,
-0.6701552272,
-0.6681234241,
-0.1420666128,
0.1089705676,
-0.0413430892,
0.8320575953,
0.9968528152,
-0.8783231974,
-0.3916516602,
-0.2165385634,
0.1606303155,
-0.1977234483,
-0.1810783893,
0.1755905002,
-0.3762234151,
-0.705303669,
0.6277211905,
0.2775769234,
0.2782436609,
-0.4301766753,
-0.1447909325,
-0.5571798682,
0.0911960676,
0.7222309709,
0.7321041822,
-0.6786889434,
0.2160649449,
0.0006314956,
0.0201828256,
0.0273724087,
0.9303843975,
-0.8499732614,
0.404150635,
0.5109499693,
1.110681057,
0.3836025298,
-0.067984663,
0.8160017133,
-0.7026839256,
0.367477119,
0.5443940759,
0.393088609,
0.5753180981,
-0.2920634747,
0.6686636209,
0.2116233408,
-0.3382987976,
-0.9348620176,
0.2598985136,
-0.5970739126,
-0.3686352372,
0.4627382457,
-0.0355880372,
-0.0800954401,
-0.119618848,
0.1575054079,
0.3499506712,
0.1757907867,
0.41525051,
1.0998374224,
-0.049058523,
-0.4403921664,
-0.8726604581,
0.6482464075,
0.1807162166,
-1.0014346838,
-0.0653361008,
0.2894251049,
0.0932556763,
0.442412585,
0.9576108456,
-0.2452726513,
0.1031794772,
-0.2660687864,
0.4258731306,
0.0294460543,
-0.735896945,
-0.6701028347,
0.2520035505,
0.1088635847,
0.2357206047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08531v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08531v1 | Learning with Rejection for Abstractive Text Summarization | 2023-02-16T19:07:08 | 2023-02-16T19:07:08 | Meng Cao, Yue Dong, Jingyi He, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art abstractive summarization systems frequently hallucinate
content that is not supported by the source document, mainly due to noise in
the training dataset. Existing methods opt to drop the noisy samples or tokens
from the training set entirely, reducing the effective training set size and
creating an artificial propensity to copy words from the source. In this work,
we propose a training objective for abstractive summarization based on
rejection learning, in which the model learns whether or not to reject
potentially noisy tokens. We further propose a regularized decoding objective
that penalizes non-factual candidate summaries during inference by using the
rejection probability learned during training. We show that our method
considerably improves the factuality of generated summaries in automatic and
human evaluations when compared to five baseline models and that it does so
while increasing the abstractiveness of the generated summaries. | [
-0.33472085,
-0.3001984358,
0.4989845455,
0.1093354672,
-0.6204696298,
-0.0190638527,
-0.1503334343,
-0.4308207631,
0.4549620152,
0.2474437505,
-0.5297904611,
-0.5757145882,
-0.73930794,
0.573887229,
-0.6485026479,
1.685939312,
0.0268194713,
-0.1178054586,
-0.393230468,
0.0549532808,
-0.2180165201,
-0.3793787658,
-0.4861686528,
-0.3431184888,
0.4466416538,
0.3116633594,
0.3177080452,
0.5161578059,
0.2796532214,
0.2544793189,
-0.3043627739,
0.1333359331,
-0.5572504997,
0.0340321064,
0.0906625912,
-0.5401524901,
-0.2661738396,
0.075107947,
0.6769546866,
0.9176803231,
-0.0734041482,
0.0365129933,
0.1197954714,
0.6157876849,
-0.8093975186,
0.4242608845,
-0.6996925473,
0.3738833964,
0.4120374322,
-0.3229100704,
-0.4868864119,
-0.6349090338,
0.2182791829,
-0.7605583072,
0.6758950353,
-0.1724956185,
0.8517386317,
0.0993798524,
-0.2148566097,
-0.512986362,
-0.6029332876,
0.69898808,
-0.526137948,
0.0849331319,
0.7217267752,
0.0184494667,
0.278192848,
-0.3953478336,
-0.4730776846,
-0.1416487396,
-0.2804807425,
0.5298139453,
-0.0576843619,
0.3865722716,
0.0454812311,
0.4042580724,
-0.6494740248,
-0.3044645786,
-1.0084792376,
-0.4772731662,
0.4677054286,
0.0220204107,
0.0258427635,
-0.0654440522,
-0.0170309991,
0.0770528093,
-0.3598644137,
-0.2600659132,
0.3462063074,
0.2916934788,
-0.1721741855,
0.450155884,
-0.4653618634,
0.4780566096,
0.1071072891,
-0.284788698,
0.4199810922,
-0.3454726636,
-0.0478613302,
0.3492258191,
0.2881573439,
0.5963897109,
0.2263433188,
-0.3755556345,
-0.5819882751,
0.1898958981,
0.0398857743,
-0.8135992289,
-0.2763822973,
0.1270812303,
-0.8698325157,
-0.586443603,
0.0943572745,
-0.5429944396,
-0.2013600022,
-0.3453290164,
0.3937509656,
-0.4685759544,
0.0731292665,
0.0692733899,
-0.7850791812,
0.0234654658,
0.5275469422,
-1.0513859987,
0.4772714674,
0.257165283,
0.9573452473,
-0.1914277375,
-0.1447469592,
-0.7114761472,
0.0794990808,
-0.3801060319,
0.8646066189,
-0.2692333162,
-0.5655905604,
-0.3380637765,
-0.3549314439,
-0.1191472113,
-0.6492472887,
0.4878028035,
-0.3933823109,
0.2433326393,
-0.1974366456,
-0.3723849058,
-0.561289072,
0.2108679116,
-0.3973571062,
0.2659901977,
0.1076822653,
-0.6977031231,
0.5065985918,
-0.3618932366,
-0.9795912504,
-0.3694073856,
-0.0463599861,
-0.6186189055,
0.5236028433,
0.2137782276,
0.3169314563,
0.3066993654,
0.044175256,
0.0491041765,
-0.6631991863,
-0.0850650296,
-0.3461660445,
0.3740995526,
0.4540400505,
-0.2250789106,
0.0541064739,
-1.0256714821,
-0.5093654394,
-0.1256379187,
-0.547616899,
-0.4840036631,
0.0117763532,
0.0555697195,
0.0459035449,
-0.1792906821,
-0.4688889086,
-0.1910315454,
-0.6867837906,
0.0103427097,
0.7389968038,
0.1978524178,
0.3625988364,
-0.6742076874,
0.5995594263,
0.0113059543,
-0.3206555843,
-0.2526142895,
-0.1899386346,
-0.6213468313,
-0.5135506392,
0.338272661,
0.5740433335,
-0.6373047829,
0.4302046001,
-0.1202811822,
-0.1159468815,
-0.2846004963,
0.0225082729,
0.5878013968,
0.6965487003,
0.3663111627,
-0.3751614094,
-0.8930485249,
-0.8387128115,
-0.1730355173,
-0.2844786346,
-0.3501048088,
-0.0990880802,
0.6353985667,
0.1076008976,
0.7234523296,
-0.4167747796,
-0.6951776743,
-0.5848147869,
0.4164424837,
-0.0323375091,
0.412281841,
0.5552760959,
-0.7651343942,
-0.3778789639,
-0.281555593,
-1.0218788385,
-0.1002777219,
-0.2537825406,
0.3502179384,
0.3439878523,
0.6022201777,
-0.6325838566,
0.7626743913,
0.3881612122,
-0.2635299861,
0.6848385334,
-0.1977515966,
0.0556033179,
-1.1478580236,
0.245548442,
-0.2067409009,
-0.4706070721,
-0.113143459,
-0.2624021173,
-0.3655011058,
-0.2403750718,
-0.2472147942,
0.3687351048,
-0.480587244,
-0.0524243861,
-0.4574609697,
0.1608294249,
0.0504003726,
0.5142142773,
0.4252885282,
0.6229299307,
0.2462179959,
-1.0066457987,
-0.1141971424,
0.5482939482,
-0.1569755971,
0.5281260014,
-0.7163985968,
-0.4540206492,
-0.906247139,
0.5812706947,
-0.9980334044,
-0.3080300987,
0.2748284936,
-0.6111750603,
0.089685142,
-0.0008499259,
0.1445403397,
0.0562085584,
-0.6840085983,
0.2991504371,
0.637774229,
-0.3168995678,
0.5425131321,
0.10394416,
-0.3763139546,
-0.6167033911,
-0.6367194653,
-0.0347599089,
0.0613869168,
0.0695946217,
0.4055831432,
-0.1990353316,
-0.2124516517,
0.1089173555,
-0.3472938836,
0.0687407106,
0.0858837292,
0.2456911951,
0.2464822233,
0.1038580835,
-0.04385655,
0.4198850691,
-0.3386208713,
0.2835720181,
-0.3550092578,
-0.061596334,
0.2978914082,
0.0833315849,
-0.8478028774,
0.3554682136,
0.4124474823,
0.0282282811,
0.8529983163,
0.3370404243,
-0.3591831326,
-0.1601749808,
-0.0911035314,
-0.5337030888,
-0.3363873661,
0.7003232837,
-0.4029318988,
-0.4910812676,
0.3884795904,
0.3546420634,
0.4617022276,
0.540594399,
0.3335437775,
-0.0369562171,
0.9117030501,
0.6422926784,
-0.3026964068,
0.4668409526,
-0.2391847372,
-0.1329638511,
-0.4690971673,
-0.1933559626,
-0.5389844775,
-0.1524912119,
-0.1185487732,
0.1182832271,
0.3590038419,
-0.1487422287,
0.2686986029,
-0.1012197658,
-0.5068746805,
0.6865112782,
0.2808302343,
0.4032926559,
0.7129099369,
0.5699512362,
-0.0135795185,
-0.0471867099,
-0.571267724,
-0.2520215511,
1.0910348892,
0.1361287087,
0.6255935431,
0.0584106334,
0.811024785,
0.628045857,
0.4970933199,
-0.773945272,
0.4108861983,
0.0065768883,
-0.3906169534,
-0.3484415114,
-0.8730642796,
-0.8130121231,
0.5188487172,
-0.4358576238,
-0.4779744446,
0.2177771032,
0.2658948004,
-0.2209475935,
0.3164084256,
-0.4263072908,
0.3272087276,
0.5919798017,
0.3276455104,
-0.4971704185,
-0.630467236,
0.5772886872,
0.1300856322,
0.386977464,
0.1729533374,
-0.0291629713,
0.8557646275,
-0.3503230512,
0.8300680518,
-0.232950896,
0.0305727702,
0.3484698534,
0.2250291854,
0.6947351694,
0.1102882028,
-0.2206136286,
-0.0986553207,
-0.2221533656,
-0.3306375146,
-0.4486898482,
0.1627239883,
-0.5672338605,
-0.1530855894,
-0.5072296262,
-0.5076882839,
0.1712747216,
0.3085386455,
0.8424569368,
0.4151675999,
-0.3263721764,
0.100479804,
0.67262429,
0.0554093011,
0.4591245651,
0.2655069232,
0.1009314582,
-0.5928849578,
1.2238380909,
0.0148414848,
0.2603596449,
0.4232572615,
0.0333096348,
-0.2537980676,
-1.1074402332,
-0.1931092739,
0.1056875661,
-0.8613669872,
-0.0916714072,
-0.9271717072,
-0.2682628632,
-0.2220044434,
-0.3119051754,
-0.1681816578,
-0.7771981359,
-0.3270553648,
-0.4626767337,
-0.0781214163,
0.6333687305,
-0.1956305206,
-0.0653969049,
-0.7223131061,
0.68908149,
0.1455137134,
0.320240587,
0.1170949414,
-1.0313065052,
-0.274353981,
-0.1807845384,
-0.2104650587,
-0.561783731,
0.3371009529,
0.4281812608,
0.3149840534,
0.370211333,
0.5442537665,
0.0654836521,
-0.1370983869,
0.3231665194,
0.1719816178,
-0.8428990841,
0.5259138346,
-0.3240853846,
0.1824623942,
0.9627003074,
0.3014423549,
-0.2336247563,
-0.7755076885,
-0.4273744524,
-0.7011847496,
0.6502232552,
0.4601431489,
0.1404476911,
-0.0331448503,
0.5773341656,
0.3676964641,
0.4662920833,
-0.93646878,
-0.3362390399,
-0.1424058378,
-0.3903843462,
-0.0441668667,
-0.2844310403,
0.062221013,
-0.1326227188,
0.9827131629,
-0.1759518236,
-0.0432558842,
0.5889000297,
-0.3821561337,
-0.0143163605,
0.1505408734,
0.8580065966,
0.6042557955,
-0.5170047283,
0.116112262,
0.2625810504,
-0.7382432222,
0.1599659175,
-0.0651809424,
-0.7980939746,
0.5122688413,
0.4910867512,
0.5512101054,
0.0590770654,
-0.7164109945,
0.5088831186,
-0.2616655231,
-0.8607902527,
-0.1336639971,
-0.0580072552,
-0.5411180854,
-0.2692693472,
0.4851788282,
0.4207826555,
0.6747899055,
-0.2979064584,
0.2921263278,
0.3510341346,
-0.5047582388,
-0.378174603,
0.7653266191,
0.2696026266,
0.1301634908,
0.4622190893,
-0.4673171341,
-0.3699224591,
0.5106492639,
0.5328672528,
0.9840061665,
0.2964888513,
0.3375283778,
0.4675303102,
0.4201582372,
-0.0731662586,
0.0900158212,
-0.3278068006,
-0.4361316562,
-0.4479590952,
-0.5987667441,
-0.625023067,
0.0067162528,
-0.7089372873,
0.1874424964,
-0.6234819293,
0.2301810384,
-0.1161581129,
-0.3840316832,
-0.040708635,
0.3528563082,
-0.0241444744,
0.4655286074,
-0.9136072397,
0.0986901671,
0.6059043407,
-0.5138872266,
-0.3229447603,
0.1076667011,
0.098903887,
-0.1695106775,
0.2371581793,
0.2053488344,
-0.1745143235,
-0.0437414348,
-0.3030064404,
-0.4928212762,
0.5710072517,
0.4709914029,
-0.1540533453,
0.0210630931,
-0.4226325154,
0.2407989353,
-0.1451370567,
0.176151976,
0.2470617592,
0.3124984205,
0.1814104617,
-0.6489989758,
0.2236696184,
-0.2151548862,
-0.2976202667,
-0.0705821067,
-0.4803783596,
0.8096765876,
-0.5087776184,
-0.1868710816,
0.1514672488,
0.9457470179,
0.1904326826,
0.480078727,
0.4932392836,
0.1691637337,
0.653098166,
0.2271891981,
0.9685228467,
0.020621581,
0.2228173912,
0.9851737022,
0.1412179172,
0.4969069958,
0.3026311696,
-0.0005445263,
0.4981407523,
0.596465528,
0.1461791396,
0.6203427911,
0.1998218596,
-0.3948682845,
-0.0337347798,
0.0596497096,
-0.321937263,
0.3054519892,
0.0664013103,
-0.4168297946,
-0.5056917071,
0.2267386168,
-0.0730833039,
0.4480614066,
-0.3741762042,
1.0372102261,
0.1094040275,
-0.6074730754,
0.8518294692,
0.1881518513,
0.8120526075,
-0.5888687372,
-0.2219126374,
-0.458101213,
0.0582785048,
-0.5888974071,
-0.0206036586,
0.6643933654,
-0.1138460636,
-0.6353803277,
0.0442278236,
0.4268662632,
-0.4045830667,
-0.4829110801,
-0.0749035925,
0.1759305,
0.4369785786,
-0.2907336652,
-0.2269947231,
-0.2425271869,
0.0705166757,
-0.1917969137,
0.5017451644,
0.2842398584,
0.0887713283,
0.6204352379,
0.5350250602,
0.2954864502,
-0.490039289,
-0.0128654856,
0.669056952,
-0.6591525078,
-1.0756280422,
-0.8791972995,
0.1883890331,
0.0169394631,
-0.1010687947,
0.7255301476,
0.8163072467,
0.582262516,
-0.2002516985,
1.3623155355,
0.0346447267,
0.5204124451,
-0.7082465291,
0.7921616435,
-0.4191301167,
0.4864082038,
-0.3938707113,
-0.9784775376,
-0.4518842399,
0.7749519348,
0.151851967,
0.1921664029,
0.6985232234,
0.4959882796,
0.0831255615,
0.0103406757,
0.3651232719,
-0.0396302231,
0.0808347538,
0.3932076991,
0.5631407499,
-0.5935091376,
0.8295798302,
-0.1723503321,
-0.4385686517,
-0.3745372295,
-0.5526663065,
-1.3094550371,
-0.3616181612,
-0.4375522733,
-0.6988971829,
0.3375947177,
0.9354072213,
0.611369729,
-0.8703215718,
-0.0226762407,
-0.228054747,
0.6684947014,
-0.3584141135,
-0.1973902881,
0.427849859,
-0.4755675793,
-0.7209337354,
0.229181692,
0.1260491908,
0.3509005606,
0.1863710433,
-0.0439804383,
0.1531517655,
0.1128381863,
0.8247383237,
0.5149089694,
-0.2512840331,
-0.1933951974,
-0.3353668749,
0.0235919729,
-0.1107070968,
0.824102819,
-0.9020700455,
0.2247902006,
0.4530499578,
0.4788460135,
0.5205616951,
0.1321211457,
0.6643325686,
-0.8261682987,
0.5303866863,
0.1428516358,
-0.0536938682,
0.0799534246,
-0.3869918585,
0.3270426989,
0.5183343887,
0.0334095396,
-0.76221627,
-0.0860340595,
-0.5016604066,
-0.4381887019,
0.7611607313,
0.0365126505,
-0.056445051,
-0.4956809878,
-0.341625154,
0.2200462073,
-0.6101518273,
1.1875520945,
0.4934096336,
0.00876584,
-0.1323734075,
-0.2639952302,
0.8271710277,
0.4911121428,
-0.5864230394,
0.1811542064,
0.6066075563,
0.2705509067,
0.0323412344,
0.7891529202,
-0.0474024154,
0.6943881512,
0.2207590491,
0.2794511318,
-0.2855735421,
-0.464720428,
-0.5669075251,
0.2313010097,
0.0776596516,
-0.19630678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08500v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08500v2 | Auditing large language models: a three-layered approach | 2023-02-16T18:55:21 | 2023-06-27T07:40:15 | Jakob Mökander, Jonas Schuett, Hannah Rose Kirk, Luciano Floridi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, K.4; K.6 | Large language models (LLMs) represent a major advance in artificial
intelligence (AI) research. However, the widespread use of LLMs is also coupled
with significant ethical and social challenges. Previous research has pointed
towards auditing as a promising governance mechanism to help ensure that AI
systems are designed and deployed in ways that are ethical, legal, and
technically robust. However, existing auditing procedures fail to address the
governance challenges posed by LLMs, which display emergent capabilities and
are adaptable to a wide range of downstream tasks. In this article, we address
that gap by outlining a novel blueprint for how to audit LLMs. Specifically, we
propose a three-layered approach, whereby governance audits (of technology
providers that design and disseminate LLMs), model audits (of LLMs after
pre-training but prior to their release), and application audits (of
applications based on LLMs) complement and inform each other. We show how
audits, when conducted in a structured and coordinated manner on all three
levels, can be a feasible and effective mechanism for identifying and managing
some of the ethical and social risks posed by LLMs. However, it is important to
remain realistic about what auditing can reasonably be expected to achieve.
Therefore, we discuss the limitations not only of our three-layered approach
but also of the prospect of auditing LLMs at all. Ultimately, this article
seeks to expand the methodological toolkit available to technology providers
and policymakers who wish to analyse and evaluate LLMs from technical, ethical,
and legal perspectives. | [
-0.0363431647,
-0.4435251355,
0.7097886801,
0.024814412,
-0.1177333519,
0.4071007371,
-0.121961683,
-0.650097847,
-0.039306581,
0.9558721185,
-0.2497262508,
-0.4125123322,
-0.5765357018,
-0.1087485701,
-0.6278010607,
1.1130679846,
-0.2154472321,
0.0938977152,
-0.0557169355,
0.0714610741,
-0.5226112008,
-0.482064724,
-0.7073582411,
-0.4893126488,
0.4918234944,
0.1300327778,
0.5395134091,
0.8993909359,
0.3085597157,
0.2919359505,
-0.3356124759,
0.1748361886,
-0.2419975102,
-0.2035291195,
0.0647606328,
-0.6403580904,
-0.7116032243,
0.2718352675,
0.646396637,
0.4208842814,
-0.2035136372,
0.2793830633,
0.3315241635,
0.6858661771,
-0.8728840947,
0.4054784477,
-0.5715784431,
0.0711426958,
-0.1242314428,
-0.1310306191,
-0.1897394955,
-0.4338692427,
0.1327079684,
-0.2825948596,
-0.3255404532,
0.0304697733,
0.4536461234,
0.1863712668,
-0.5393103957,
-0.5899176002,
-0.9321559072,
0.6379172802,
-0.8585764766,
0.2035158724,
0.3876574337,
0.2756390572,
0.0955057964,
-0.5364428163,
-0.6577625871,
-0.1921468675,
-0.0099757118,
-0.126425609,
-0.0506614856,
0.031514287,
-0.0956243798,
0.2792087793,
-0.0970173776,
0.3716110289,
-0.3356325924,
-0.2529595196,
0.7225381732,
0.2579617202,
0.3429969549,
0.0098700207,
-0.2823064327,
-0.067762211,
-0.9979403615,
-0.0933864042,
0.6515090466,
0.2770732939,
-0.3687311411,
0.5296545029,
0.2467493266,
0.2276387513,
-0.3433795273,
-0.2707299292,
0.1971564144,
-0.3570703268,
-0.0977539048,
0.2144687474,
0.5195339918,
0.1504035443,
0.4536153078,
-0.009479247,
-0.5236768126,
-0.0412228256,
0.3007668853,
-0.2855597436,
0.1596355289,
0.5534904003,
-0.5001618266,
-0.4717429876,
0.1114851981,
-0.5919708014,
-0.8673853874,
-0.5010493398,
0.5358248353,
-0.2093607634,
-0.4662326574,
0.2166682631,
0.0425489731,
0.4440667033,
0.3189528883,
-0.847980082,
0.2152230889,
1.3911613226,
0.7486689687,
0.142705977,
-0.5060122609,
-0.5287900567,
0.6610092521,
-0.4684206843,
0.2670947909,
-0.3512820303,
-0.2153962553,
0.3328747451,
-0.1550806016,
0.2201280296,
-0.4243524671,
0.2558321059,
-0.6020407677,
0.0345288552,
0.1170247197,
-0.5257601142,
-0.2929835021,
0.4976544082,
-0.5729610324,
0.6865075231,
-0.2885661125,
-0.5356974006,
0.4164551795,
-0.8688074946,
-0.2540913224,
0.1859919578,
-0.4489163458,
-0.3545909822,
-0.0460377,
0.2391686589,
0.4889682531,
-0.4141693115,
0.716042161,
-0.3058214188,
-0.5581639409,
-0.2261958569,
-0.3041464686,
1.2188215256,
0.0059578014,
-0.580239892,
0.4043926895,
-0.7696700692,
-0.0922541991,
-0.0708848238,
-0.3768627346,
-0.207601279,
0.3708068728,
-0.2778543234,
-0.1146903634,
0.3862609863,
-0.2865400016,
-0.0412328355,
-0.3233932555,
1.0325803757,
1.1035888195,
-0.0953322127,
0.3994867504,
-0.3538665771,
0.3923556805,
-0.033812739,
0.4833901525,
-0.1855148822,
-0.2734139264,
-0.694861412,
-0.4354790747,
0.2288262546,
0.6876311898,
-0.3242429197,
0.5499715209,
-0.3374488354,
-0.5954174995,
-0.5282304883,
0.1345153749,
0.2204175144,
-0.0304901041,
-0.1860242933,
0.0130239101,
-0.1687062979,
-0.9874790907,
-0.5578663945,
-0.7538503408,
-0.2318363339,
0.4948871136,
0.9160681367,
-0.3844013512,
0.6739655733,
0.1944688261,
-0.4059507847,
-0.1280250996,
0.1149465367,
0.4292335212,
0.6481692195,
0.1669038534,
-0.6330536008,
0.165006727,
0.3524121344,
-0.8148490191,
0.0184170119,
-0.131691277,
0.1927949786,
0.0327171385,
0.5280332565,
-0.5082592368,
0.2283501327,
0.3855692446,
-0.0747404397,
0.4140236676,
-0.119428575,
-0.1744893044,
-0.7822031379,
0.1569875777,
-0.404646337,
-0.0088435952,
-0.6033245921,
0.2648729384,
0.2950772345,
-0.0297320653,
-0.4295718074,
0.568533957,
-0.5609490275,
-0.5724378228,
0.1314661056,
0.0841432512,
0.0675458759,
0.2151384801,
-0.4632959664,
0.5550836921,
0.5493080616,
-0.4080024958,
0.4832214415,
0.1464076042,
-0.645403266,
0.5055161119,
-0.6170102358,
0.3740289807,
-0.0619586557,
0.2537708282,
-0.3942434192,
-0.2025571465,
0.0148176644,
-0.210691765,
0.10864117,
-0.1219311804,
-0.7728164792,
0.0002075,
-0.7127332091,
0.2988687754,
0.1797005832,
-0.4883419275,
1.312359333,
0.5767613053,
-0.1857879013,
-0.7001177073,
-0.6131607294,
0.4916320741,
-0.486561209,
-0.7297121286,
0.0914488956,
0.2250294983,
-0.494494915,
-0.0387656316,
-0.1473950893,
0.0389653035,
0.7052402496,
0.1171124578,
0.3353607059,
-0.295994401,
-0.4290910065,
-0.2933338881,
0.1571076661,
0.4476685524,
-0.1092201471,
0.3447841406,
-0.2125826329,
-0.6706507802,
-0.597881496,
0.284227103,
0.7890046835,
-0.3926104605,
0.4429599643,
0.3666268885,
-0.7058803439,
-0.2338031679,
-0.905171454,
0.0192718152,
-0.4951392114,
0.1320814043,
-0.0157139413,
-1.0459083319,
0.709109664,
-0.0132633355,
0.3699198067,
0.2115332931,
0.704069674,
-0.018437285,
1.0811617374,
0.8405889273,
-0.2882706523,
0.3882030249,
-0.2232481092,
0.6314455271,
-0.8201647401,
-0.670984745,
-0.6813822985,
-0.0265870355,
-0.7691929936,
-0.0418307781,
0.6610340476,
0.1079401448,
-0.5098697543,
-0.1792986393,
0.1823717803,
0.5590458512,
0.7381593585,
-0.1383557171,
0.3262909353,
-0.2099830359,
0.2011409849,
0.669355154,
-0.4452248216,
-1.085422039,
0.9514517188,
0.6985685229,
0.6437218785,
0.1687561572,
0.9395897985,
0.2558917403,
0.3561577499,
-0.6654245853,
0.5722131133,
0.0072349245,
-0.8616477251,
-0.3936507702,
-0.145071432,
-0.5030105114,
0.067833066,
-0.0852793008,
-0.8966915011,
0.1185605824,
0.0340639763,
-0.2574634552,
0.4897757769,
-0.703104496,
0.5952361226,
-0.4154885113,
-0.2643375397,
-0.2895831168,
-0.6932973266,
0.5433443785,
-0.4497593343,
0.4301369488,
-0.07820113,
-0.1687781662,
0.8499585986,
-0.2517260909,
0.9823048115,
-0.0202039629,
-0.3868108988,
0.1487802714,
0.1854753047,
0.6797751784,
0.082602784,
-0.0577492267,
0.3954525888,
0.3200353086,
-0.275878489,
-0.4293510318,
0.5366299152,
-0.9059628844,
-0.9804499745,
-0.4846214056,
-0.4679740071,
-0.4452246428,
0.3963679075,
-0.5688590407,
0.2583266497,
-0.1502172351,
0.211016655,
0.2918113768,
-0.2876774669,
0.4855469763,
0.4074285924,
0.1033943519,
-0.1505191624,
0.5910808444,
-0.219817102,
0.0341852233,
0.0263295658,
0.3962710202,
-0.1211646721,
-0.9851942658,
-0.1997906715,
0.2978444099,
-0.7087480426,
-0.0531627089,
-0.4399508834,
-0.1653888524,
-0.3379567862,
-0.1364531368,
-0.0650469363,
-0.1167989895,
-0.4116725028,
0.0415993258,
0.0785913989,
1.3571506739,
-0.1724443585,
0.1778168976,
-0.7300620079,
0.0845394954,
0.2588513792,
0.5651186705,
0.0948506594,
-0.1259080172,
-0.0564914718,
0.0460528061,
-0.137652263,
-0.3887238503,
0.0987988189,
0.0560428277,
0.5870929956,
0.542265296,
-0.3296974003,
0.4751850069,
-0.6966828108,
1.1768108606,
-0.071549274,
-1.2811281681,
0.4446037114,
-0.469665885,
-0.3087037206,
0.386051774,
0.1600577533,
-0.3773735762,
-0.47807163,
-0.2555438876,
-0.836568594,
0.7320235968,
0.0270665288,
0.4334102869,
0.185441345,
0.4171801507,
-0.0415246487,
0.2510089278,
-0.6620086432,
0.0527040958,
0.1096080169,
-0.0422401763,
-0.0276041087,
-0.3462975621,
-0.5078355074,
0.2089009136,
0.7730633616,
0.1029696167,
-0.1961349994,
-0.1380787641,
0.0187182371,
0.2884589136,
0.199409306,
0.3440114856,
0.9182944298,
-0.1530252695,
0.2277101427,
-0.0156557523,
-0.4048280716,
0.1502155662,
-0.2337108999,
-0.1538944989,
-0.4557148218,
1.0013557673,
0.3869256377,
0.0195557773,
-0.6140876412,
0.539270401,
0.2675958574,
-0.2477310002,
-0.416625917,
-0.0588989072,
0.2844033837,
0.6836323738,
0.2260861993,
-0.5015035272,
0.0053327815,
-0.8249893785,
-0.1082119793,
0.5572684407,
0.1371409297,
-0.1390405297,
0.5421946049,
0.3273044527,
-0.5463163257,
0.4358079433,
0.4036853611,
-0.5451902151,
0.6958013177,
0.2074893564,
1.1244949102,
-0.1140819639,
-0.092820175,
-0.2410120219,
0.7738446593,
-0.3334006071,
0.2932065427,
0.128229633,
-0.7641233802,
-0.3339479268,
-0.4141362011,
-0.5827081203,
0.4418699741,
-0.7392573357,
0.3418381214,
-0.707182169,
0.1380984485,
0.2783353031,
0.0834765583,
-0.535897851,
-0.0123599973,
0.28165555,
0.9401977658,
-0.7570741773,
0.4509843886,
0.4025933444,
-0.0537518002,
-0.6316857338,
-0.0683065727,
0.4299698472,
-1.4820266962,
0.5891960263,
0.0809506178,
-0.3668776453,
-0.2388934791,
-0.679272294,
-0.6328040957,
1.2115170956,
0.2822127938,
-0.5366593003,
-0.1884277761,
0.1896122843,
0.493894279,
-0.4712862968,
-0.1737319529,
0.8065462708,
0.5650690198,
-0.4939048588,
-0.9264725447,
-0.1081333384,
-0.1469106227,
0.1249584407,
0.1057859957,
-0.3829484284,
0.7954950333,
-0.0327961445,
-0.2541230917,
-0.0390790403,
0.206807524,
0.0518374257,
0.3640725315,
0.6274300218,
0.1200484782,
0.6508854628,
0.239957273,
1.0368386507,
-0.5427442789,
0.0835837126,
0.8188134432,
-0.792586267,
0.7060389519,
0.7708616257,
-0.0814885795,
0.1730548739,
0.483964771,
-0.0516211316,
0.088620469,
0.4265851676,
-0.1815976351,
-0.0317100994,
-0.3733048141,
-0.0524654388,
0.7326366305,
0.2362017483,
-0.3470730782,
0.0332324766,
-0.392927587,
0.1118422896,
-0.1209995598,
-0.4371643066,
0.9543383121,
-0.0260498859,
-0.5336580873,
0.17025657,
-0.0165500641,
0.3370849788,
-0.4441507161,
-0.1371814609,
-0.0831021294,
0.0798142776,
-0.0948494971,
-0.9131143093,
0.2307219505,
0.3375224173,
0.2193876356,
-0.4160598814,
0.1973828375,
0.0231619682,
-0.3620453775,
0.4633643031,
0.7575876117,
0.1060122401,
0.1816800386,
-0.4966902435,
0.4260980785,
-0.2494760752,
-0.1668729782,
0.1635039449,
0.3925937116,
-0.4107079804,
0.858384192,
0.5210607648,
0.3342951834,
-0.2300658524,
0.173210606,
0.678940475,
-0.6157208681,
-0.6696109772,
-1.2534046173,
0.2312486619,
0.044183556,
-0.1953416467,
0.4466853738,
0.402748853,
0.9484924078,
0.5287536383,
0.8761972189,
0.2771021426,
0.1306422204,
-0.7537142634,
0.769653976,
-0.5754265189,
0.6920643449,
-0.1770880669,
-0.9576045275,
-0.2944979668,
0.2619253099,
-0.074892804,
0.0690124929,
0.3282593787,
0.8376087546,
0.0702670738,
0.3534329534,
0.0999938026,
0.4464015961,
0.6297428012,
0.3473239243,
1.0769951344,
-0.0792231411,
0.3298200071,
-0.1186121851,
-0.2493987978,
-0.0580601096,
-1.3535398245,
-0.9902350903,
-0.5089324713,
-0.0501181856,
-0.24121885,
-0.0206254274,
0.5628986955,
0.5021172762,
-0.6808391213,
-0.5486007333,
0.1405417919,
0.1996588111,
0.0074448334,
-0.1058189124,
0.2927670181,
0.1062984616,
-0.3780211806,
0.3119855821,
0.5670132041,
-0.0339723229,
-0.6871291399,
0.1610826403,
-0.100335449,
0.2473412305,
0.5011098385,
-0.1151460335,
-1.1524764299,
-0.6312922835,
-0.4293875098,
0.1424296051,
-0.2352408022,
0.9854037166,
-0.1419139057,
0.143039912,
0.3423981071,
0.9412300587,
0.3288596869,
-0.5189560652,
0.669457376,
-0.354948014,
-0.2114142925,
0.5445187688,
0.5063345432,
0.2202907652,
-0.324734807,
0.6497762203,
-0.3513581753,
-0.5359797478,
-1.2627993822,
0.1589474529,
-0.7069180608,
-0.0763866529,
1.0568960905,
-0.1983194798,
-0.2425605059,
-0.145218581,
0.0706454292,
0.0912351981,
0.0081888782,
0.8974254131,
0.9363113642,
0.1657314152,
0.1934002489,
-0.7554571033,
0.3212452531,
0.1757108271,
-0.91935426,
0.4477083087,
0.4132225811,
0.3271385431,
0.1735075116,
0.4658504725,
-0.3283388615,
0.0863164589,
-0.3303440511,
-0.1961303651,
-0.156241715,
-0.3482988179,
-0.799393177,
-0.0456079468,
-0.0223496463,
0.2351667732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08468v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08468v3 | LEVER: Learning to Verify Language-to-Code Generation with Execution | 2023-02-16T18:23:22 | 2023-09-01T17:37:42 | Ansong Ni, Srini Iyer, Dragomir Radev, Ves Stoyanov, Wen-tau Yih, Sida I. Wang, Xi Victoria Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE | The advent of large language models trained on code (code LLMs) has led to
significant progress in language-to-code generation. State-of-the-art
approaches in this area combine LLM decoding with sample pruning and reranking
using test cases or heuristics based on the execution results. However, it is
challenging to obtain test cases for many real-world language-to-code
applications, and heuristics cannot well capture the semantic features of the
execution results, such as data type and value range, which often indicates the
correctness of the program. In this work, we propose LEVER, a simple approach
to improve language-to-code generation by learning to verify the generated
programs with their execution results. Specifically, we train verifiers to
determine whether a program sampled from the LLMs is correct or not based on
the natural language input, the program itself and its execution results. The
sampled programs are reranked by combining the verification score with the LLM
generation probability, and marginalizing over programs with the same execution
results. On four datasets across the domains of table QA, math QA and basic
Python programming, LEVER consistently improves over the base code LLMs(4.6% to
10.9% with code-davinci-002) and achieves new state-of-the-art results on all
of them. | [
-0.0805075914,
-0.5850897431,
0.2589075565,
0.3240186572,
-0.0175630059,
0.33852458,
-0.4637586474,
-0.0236832257,
-0.1171375588,
0.5620087981,
-0.2542071342,
-0.800029099,
-0.6153363585,
0.2774921954,
-0.6512979865,
0.8690749407,
-0.0894670933,
0.0644000992,
-0.2957136929,
-0.0258539245,
-0.5032518506,
-0.5190678239,
-0.3549855649,
-0.333171308,
0.3426566422,
0.4221298397,
0.3474198878,
0.7005540729,
0.3369517922,
0.2694580853,
0.2599355578,
0.4004106224,
-0.759108603,
0.0159278065,
0.1324156672,
-0.9756619334,
-0.1800540835,
-0.1113055125,
0.5455185771,
0.2605127394,
0.0955811888,
0.3361116946,
0.0252254829,
0.4847604036,
-0.7181544304,
0.214933157,
-0.8435800076,
-0.0465261526,
-0.1155969128,
-0.6972742677,
-0.8548059464,
-0.8325015306,
-0.6908602715,
-0.2570770383,
0.2102695256,
0.1094822884,
0.9446906447,
0.2584045529,
-0.4174166024,
-0.3134325147,
-0.6175282598,
0.8746788502,
-0.6958940625,
0.4168139696,
0.245059967,
0.4920258224,
-0.3540920615,
-0.819129765,
-0.6836422682,
-0.4358965158,
0.0186272655,
-0.119472377,
-0.0075954525,
-0.339627713,
0.522613883,
0.342564702,
-0.5244953632,
0.1376144141,
-0.5378351212,
-0.3797650337,
0.7038907409,
0.0469896048,
0.4085068405,
0.1819253862,
-0.2822737396,
-0.3384681046,
-1.2544794083,
0.2361677885,
0.5600857735,
0.3991810679,
0.0427379347,
0.737390697,
-0.2975710928,
0.7573973536,
-0.0828924999,
-0.0790251419,
0.3748963177,
-0.2649695873,
-0.2205165774,
-0.0519876331,
0.4677295685,
0.3389820457,
0.4214391112,
-0.2485576719,
-0.2452791184,
0.1564282775,
0.4134893119,
-0.7503475547,
0.0092901206,
0.1682442874,
-0.1661792547,
-0.5964403749,
-0.0136105306,
-0.2585630119,
-0.2016508281,
-0.3125599623,
0.3201190233,
-0.3795753717,
-0.0532483235,
-0.1659562141,
-0.025040444,
0.722415626,
0.1363228112,
-0.6673714519,
0.0495321117,
0.9602220654,
0.4715887308,
-0.129638046,
-0.4152445197,
-1.1454125643,
-0.0229737964,
-0.7900044918,
0.5912637115,
-0.246243,
-0.3344086409,
0.4005577564,
-0.1568851918,
0.1485368907,
-0.707636416,
0.4333001077,
-0.805061996,
-0.0663375258,
-0.3443357348,
-0.7789812684,
0.0140528996,
0.5296282172,
-0.3673593402,
1.1689462662,
0.2399687618,
-0.5222840309,
0.8625270724,
-0.3008393645,
-0.8257258534,
-0.0671906099,
-0.5526230931,
-0.6647264361,
0.1691559255,
0.2411452085,
0.3609663546,
-0.2038992196,
0.2346889377,
-0.2788217664,
-0.4275398552,
0.2907082736,
-0.2745927274,
0.6765313745,
0.2336165607,
-0.3035081923,
0.3069446981,
-0.7535296082,
0.4734202921,
0.0091606211,
-0.7166497707,
0.1894887239,
-0.0246194918,
-0.2510310709,
0.1062245667,
0.19441697,
-0.4170278609,
0.3453811705,
-0.4067619145,
0.137377128,
0.5433858037,
-0.1484501362,
0.3196441233,
-0.2660095394,
0.4455664456,
-0.0326898657,
0.1033857763,
-0.0904567614,
-0.3796567619,
-0.9311931729,
-0.1100207567,
0.4030424058,
0.7745961547,
-1.0296013355,
0.6811124086,
-0.3801812828,
-0.3129073679,
-0.3687894344,
0.5407658219,
0.3874007761,
0.4651006162,
0.1935521364,
-0.2051853091,
-0.4199832082,
-0.7514101267,
-0.4942652583,
-0.2673856616,
-0.1854192466,
0.0203265063,
0.2229332328,
-0.2119125575,
1.290293932,
-0.5163680315,
0.0436182469,
-0.6383627653,
0.2106593996,
0.2461908162,
0.3798716962,
0.2439421117,
-0.5244822502,
-0.4166469872,
0.0023647563,
-0.6900475025,
-0.3850952685,
-0.0571298301,
-0.0143260797,
0.1934609264,
0.603400588,
0.2390390337,
0.5664645433,
0.3646013737,
0.0018276564,
0.5016272068,
-0.3876495063,
0.3403002322,
-1.0058559179,
0.0617889762,
-0.2410425842,
-0.450894326,
-0.3258120418,
0.2151544541,
0.3520271778,
-0.1597914398,
-0.3801566064,
0.2079249322,
-0.4745545983,
-0.1826460063,
-0.3107439876,
-0.0243505239,
-0.1447631568,
0.442748934,
-0.0979920849,
1.0600937605,
0.5928614736,
-0.6278585196,
0.3825923204,
0.0586249121,
-0.5282107592,
0.272885561,
-0.5525348783,
0.1433053464,
0.1102296561,
0.1820026636,
-0.9992449284,
-0.0530990846,
-0.1190024391,
-0.511238277,
0.3970117271,
-0.2537451088,
-0.6684603095,
-0.3859629929,
-0.2474009544,
0.1267025769,
0.8641319275,
-0.6675858498,
0.3402026892,
0.1341272444,
0.1090272292,
-0.7417991757,
-0.7481197119,
0.2442399114,
0.1504294723,
-0.6729052067,
-0.0598141104,
0.2185304165,
-0.1122570038,
-0.4202984273,
0.0465305969,
-0.1595315188,
0.1367424726,
0.2004296333,
0.1940745115,
-0.0005309874,
0.0705730766,
0.1813042462,
-0.3556277752,
0.0801586732,
-0.0440317802,
0.4724901617,
-0.0974156111,
-0.7385421395,
-0.1104552671,
0.027789684,
0.4102892876,
-0.3327926695,
0.3800653517,
0.5937747359,
-0.0368980244,
-0.669572711,
-0.5612612367,
-0.3518266082,
-0.4351067543,
0.2842382789,
-0.4149332643,
-0.8219940066,
0.474301964,
-0.4672262371,
0.3593136668,
0.1125591621,
0.8397057056,
0.297390759,
0.7823473215,
0.5835644007,
-0.2965225875,
0.2577583492,
-0.4099397361,
0.6328050494,
-0.3759385943,
0.0297074821,
-0.5668489337,
-0.1540662497,
-0.4699991047,
-0.7633883953,
0.4677703977,
0.1957547218,
0.0725870281,
0.5314064026,
-0.4267058671,
0.5000373721,
0.6420875788,
0.1477449089,
0.2830055654,
0.1031718925,
-0.2002246082,
0.2608777881,
-0.6515339017,
-0.542580843,
1.279766202,
0.2733817399,
0.7966972589,
0.0246133897,
1.0972937346,
0.567718327,
0.7807211876,
-0.5386382937,
0.5210371017,
0.0715867952,
-0.4958288968,
-0.2644292712,
-0.6528992653,
-0.6818006635,
-0.0246792696,
-0.047135435,
-0.4756679833,
-0.1568729877,
0.3761987388,
-0.2512748539,
0.0135288239,
-0.6781196594,
0.7898799181,
-0.3051124811,
-0.5876261592,
-0.2405254096,
-0.5442674756,
0.5305433273,
0.1359629631,
0.1847929209,
0.0698326677,
0.148632586,
0.2655318379,
-0.8259927034,
0.8870880008,
-0.0622721799,
-0.4923591316,
0.4711234868,
0.1562326401,
0.7684853673,
0.1044118777,
-0.1738379598,
0.0288570989,
-0.3386868238,
-0.265796572,
-0.6936531663,
0.6148486733,
-0.5032224059,
-0.4366591573,
-0.0102473795,
-0.3683241904,
-0.2669502795,
0.0490639284,
0.4523189068,
0.5630202293,
0.0346595272,
-0.0472671613,
0.5538519025,
-0.4414084852,
0.1365094632,
0.3684393167,
-0.4327521324,
-0.3672707677,
1.0647882223,
-0.1832098365,
0.2024461329,
0.5590709448,
0.0283468645,
-0.4054993093,
-0.6227745414,
-0.7642354369,
-0.1645106077,
-0.7204474807,
-0.3615851402,
-0.2274883091,
-0.2235555053,
-0.4871650934,
-0.3540960252,
-0.2952435613,
-0.0694444776,
0.1777779758,
0.0411803387,
0.3823543489,
0.4867540598,
0.0991386101,
0.0403817482,
-0.7755208611,
0.2114133537,
0.283582449,
0.4050855935,
-0.2597182691,
-0.4386853874,
-0.2145622522,
-0.0363873988,
-0.282948494,
-0.7224957943,
0.2355402261,
0.0264831316,
0.5876226425,
0.2790751457,
0.2271854877,
0.4746857285,
-0.5948534608,
0.7332285047,
0.2274160385,
-0.990858674,
0.5210145116,
-0.0445417985,
-0.0968688279,
0.613478899,
-0.2465375215,
-0.2587480843,
-0.7173076868,
-0.3709626794,
-0.7886136174,
0.3099357784,
0.267832458,
0.1115567535,
-0.1006179675,
0.1559201628,
0.0651959404,
0.2713238001,
-0.786329329,
-0.1054217517,
0.0738963708,
-0.217588082,
0.0124767423,
-0.135716185,
-0.1275598407,
-0.0891082734,
0.5471516252,
-0.3404910266,
0.1432714462,
-0.1119895577,
-0.4674020708,
0.1589073241,
0.3507128954,
0.6753119826,
0.804482758,
0.0129918512,
0.255192101,
0.355594039,
-0.1253600419,
0.2607840896,
-0.3884621561,
-0.2423790693,
-0.0325558409,
0.551153183,
0.5437932014,
0.1231040955,
-0.6835799217,
0.7397248149,
0.1833533198,
-0.2703756988,
-0.1485371143,
0.2890482247,
-0.0477420613,
0.1045341268,
0.2474029958,
-0.250572145,
0.0536443703,
-0.3812515736,
0.6693850756,
0.234497577,
-0.0818208754,
0.0265176501,
0.369084239,
0.4860255718,
-0.3386236131,
0.6767219901,
-0.5962939858,
-0.7461936474,
0.6787074208,
0.5958122015,
0.9308565855,
0.284592241,
-0.0109930346,
0.4012935758,
0.3800852299,
-0.0606238879,
0.4706441164,
-0.2642349303,
-0.6048929095,
-0.8036267757,
-0.5426866412,
-0.3717203736,
-0.1635709852,
-0.5238758326,
0.3820762336,
-0.3264762759,
-0.0742907003,
-0.5940807462,
-0.0795677975,
-0.5616667867,
-0.0115082804,
-0.0462524518,
1.0659472942,
-0.9332708716,
1.0012402534,
0.3778329194,
-0.3894856572,
-1.0415364504,
0.0038477443,
-0.2433775067,
-1.0805467367,
1.0873965025,
0.1143611893,
-0.0238678195,
-0.0420213267,
-0.4567956626,
-0.4846453667,
0.8323283792,
0.4750393629,
-0.6125878096,
0.4866925776,
0.2979870141,
0.3571949005,
-0.1424326152,
0.1341174543,
0.3979024589,
0.4780970812,
0.0546394326,
-0.6301994324,
0.0395230688,
-0.1712388545,
0.0627481714,
0.2636447847,
-0.1858558655,
0.4784380198,
-0.5230486393,
-0.16226767,
-0.1111555919,
0.7814822197,
0.5537082553,
0.369199574,
0.5258371234,
0.5717958808,
0.5084924698,
-0.2169229686,
1.1822178364,
-0.6312504411,
0.3919349313,
0.9438784719,
-0.5707758665,
0.955488801,
0.5835151076,
-0.4190352559,
0.411896348,
0.2938468754,
-0.1773954183,
0.2347311527,
0.9142159224,
-0.1575136334,
-0.3940155804,
0.3380936384,
-0.3020350933,
0.3616998792,
-0.0132139632,
-0.3404884636,
-0.556047678,
-0.1722495705,
-0.1303373724,
0.3948117197,
0.01611894,
0.6365420222,
-0.1602276117,
-0.694484055,
0.8485127687,
0.1389090419,
0.7054845691,
-0.6131777763,
-0.2814956009,
-0.2011288851,
0.3232580721,
-0.1593210101,
-0.5024802089,
0.2991966605,
0.244762972,
-0.195269376,
-0.3361262083,
0.7413485646,
-0.4703858197,
-0.6042355895,
0.1446845829,
0.397456795,
0.1497060806,
0.1342323571,
-0.3192722201,
0.236008063,
0.0958881676,
0.0178511906,
0.2476400137,
0.2861283422,
-0.1039976254,
0.71595186,
0.7183338404,
0.1252554059,
0.3240600526,
0.2752588391,
0.6994621158,
-0.2912914157,
-0.4939130545,
-0.8089407682,
0.2931022644,
-0.3832040131,
-0.3120781481,
0.8455762267,
0.9328347445,
0.9461724758,
-0.2070593685,
0.8425098658,
-0.1084361151,
0.4279517233,
-0.4930385053,
0.6628732085,
-0.3604438305,
0.4546310604,
0.1209624931,
-0.5589996576,
-0.3520044386,
0.5777949691,
-0.5089197755,
0.0538376421,
0.3150866032,
1.1954965591,
0.1259856075,
-0.4019689262,
0.4481203258,
-0.2281487137,
0.6217921972,
0.6134077907,
0.8442658782,
-0.4465052485,
0.4732251167,
-0.0213927682,
-0.4048430026,
-0.4626195133,
-1.0843057632,
-0.7398142815,
-0.3174532056,
-0.259998709,
-0.584261179,
-0.0141763622,
0.8252558708,
0.6556384563,
-0.7744193077,
-0.5084912777,
-0.2357444018,
0.4974101484,
-0.5668811202,
-0.2152413875,
0.2140698433,
-0.981890142,
-0.6278756261,
0.3170880973,
0.2956764698,
-0.3585928977,
-0.1364466995,
-0.2636091411,
0.2468483746,
0.0189888123,
0.6565044522,
0.3537867963,
-0.5814685225,
-0.1832423359,
-0.0974679664,
-0.3227525949,
-0.0795144141,
1.2851195335,
-0.7149957418,
0.1664807945,
0.6414602995,
1.0209437609,
0.1227261871,
-0.1790229827,
0.9736572504,
-1.0830668211,
-0.2517258823,
0.0129182395,
0.3912454545,
0.1262499988,
-0.1996276379,
0.4620244205,
0.0917104483,
-0.4116032422,
-1.0151482821,
0.3861164749,
-0.8522983789,
-0.0340252295,
1.1821272373,
-0.2829221487,
-0.2170156837,
0.0334918573,
-0.1458102912,
0.4691938758,
-0.1704955697,
0.8864451051,
0.3031225204,
0.2016701847,
0.0731765553,
-0.3071897924,
0.5449957252,
0.3237981796,
-0.9346301556,
0.4703555703,
0.3438880444,
0.5539644361,
0.1640939713,
0.3446103036,
-0.184786126,
0.3386899531,
-0.032974463,
0.3910008669,
-0.3122055233,
-0.0956320241,
0.016609177,
0.3385954499,
0.3527276814,
-0.4349460602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08464v1 | Evaluating and Improving the Coreference Capabilities of Machine Translation Models | 2023-02-16T18:16:09 | 2023-02-16T18:16:09 | Asaf Yehudai, Arie Cattan, Omri Abend, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Machine translation (MT) requires a wide range of linguistic capabilities,
which current end-to-end models are expected to learn implicitly by observing
aligned sentences in bilingual corpora. In this work, we ask: \emph{How well do
MT models learn coreference resolution from implicit signal?} To answer this
question, we develop an evaluation methodology that derives coreference
clusters from MT output and evaluates them without requiring annotations in the
target language. We further evaluate several prominent open-source and
commercial MT systems, translating from English to six target languages, and
compare them to state-of-the-art coreference resolvers on three challenging
benchmarks. Our results show that the monolingual resolvers greatly outperform
MT models. Motivated by this result, we experiment with different methods for
incorporating the output of coreference resolution models in MT, showing
improvement over strong baselines. | [
-0.5047968626,
-0.4718814194,
0.5002993941,
-0.1622379571,
-0.4779999852,
-0.1031521559,
-0.7551789284,
-0.7923170328,
-0.2977129519,
0.4638120532,
-0.3940007985,
-0.5582965016,
-1.1149550676,
0.6070700884,
-0.3670938313,
1.0259130001,
-0.1489376426,
0.2561402023,
-0.3409183621,
-0.3738941252,
-0.5852422118,
-0.6516293883,
-0.3578722179,
-0.5031560063,
0.2193159461,
0.5353569388,
0.7222231627,
0.7175804973,
0.6849303246,
0.3379299939,
-0.1771453023,
0.3212626278,
-0.2608759105,
0.0195903946,
-0.2526839077,
-0.39565593,
-0.5093924999,
0.103895776,
0.6066221595,
0.9833926558,
0.4075143635,
0.3574406505,
0.2543852925,
0.5007271171,
-0.5313786268,
0.1446056664,
-0.6750962734,
-0.0096933758,
-0.038783256,
0.0613318235,
-0.7013566494,
-0.264089644,
0.4040059447,
-0.4687961042,
0.4698322713,
0.3492667675,
0.653046608,
0.2902392745,
-0.599139154,
-0.5138695836,
-0.7775345445,
0.94832623,
-0.4468593597,
0.4284335077,
0.2895974517,
0.3685172796,
0.2828559577,
-0.5474910736,
-0.1344182491,
-0.3355660141,
-0.2858943045,
0.0752234757,
-0.2731623054,
-0.0776803419,
0.2696074545,
0.5330011845,
-0.4831595719,
0.2038939893,
-0.5031619668,
-0.1457568407,
0.2439385206,
-0.0678977445,
-0.0139638195,
-0.2078339756,
-0.0624343678,
0.1248780638,
-0.4378297329,
0.0242034234,
-0.0317089856,
0.3631911874,
-0.0232294425,
0.784058094,
-0.0754161403,
0.5831763744,
0.5059193373,
-0.0713697895,
0.160136655,
-0.3049421906,
-0.1885617375,
0.2755186856,
0.5937969685,
0.4551339447,
0.1952233315,
-0.4629545212,
-0.0891038775,
0.0484287068,
0.2158142328,
-0.6465473175,
0.312387377,
0.2223834693,
-0.4098887146,
0.1102897972,
-0.0155254435,
-0.2710411251,
-0.1174732596,
-0.6884450912,
0.2395460904,
-0.6698288918,
-0.0250347666,
-0.099561505,
-0.2311627865,
-0.232196182,
0.1697497219,
-0.6108470559,
0.3055553734,
0.72064358,
0.7705222368,
-0.2767511308,
-0.2230804861,
-0.4636980891,
0.0082762372,
-0.337141186,
0.7651231289,
-0.4738563001,
-0.5985355377,
-0.1847577095,
-0.0071148439,
-0.1616671383,
-0.8840477467,
1.0424644947,
-0.1735033244,
0.0611049831,
-0.3585674465,
-0.3267655671,
-0.1771645993,
0.2247368395,
-0.5230869651,
0.8816677928,
-0.0364437029,
-0.7590765357,
0.2397273928,
-0.6916697025,
-0.4556806386,
-0.1148648188,
0.3481542468,
-0.0871877745,
0.4673734903,
0.4797445536,
0.3449577987,
-0.5749950409,
0.2430709302,
-0.064012751,
-0.1650239974,
0.2263273001,
-0.0865897909,
0.5580070019,
0.165878281,
-0.2530439794,
0.4630319178,
-0.546572268,
-0.1806121469,
-0.230579868,
0.0132332398,
-0.640386045,
-0.1397627741,
-0.3972583413,
0.1207813472,
0.3901100457,
-0.5207202435,
-0.0200679637,
-0.263233602,
0.3139331937,
0.6124000549,
-0.2767054141,
0.7011948824,
0.0200767834,
0.2507427633,
0.0937647894,
0.2630296052,
-0.1443369091,
-0.5022970438,
-0.9381443858,
-0.3419653475,
0.4150567353,
0.4155943692,
-0.589579761,
0.528303504,
-0.5422836542,
-0.6242595315,
-0.5203405023,
0.1578498632,
0.6742978096,
0.7463380694,
0.6095724106,
-0.2473819107,
-0.6290716529,
-1.1236673594,
-0.2668575943,
-0.0870383754,
-0.0586042926,
0.2081174403,
0.5522706509,
-0.1775612533,
0.7015377879,
-0.0582791828,
-0.1265414953,
-0.1358593404,
0.5111463666,
0.3698451221,
0.6436695457,
0.4118914902,
-0.707133472,
-0.4830952883,
0.4408350289,
-0.8798458576,
-0.2341440767,
0.4886548817,
-0.2148151547,
0.0997257307,
0.1556950659,
-0.4674350917,
0.139406532,
0.801625669,
-0.1741781384,
0.7785522342,
-0.1481819898,
0.3497671187,
-0.8270679712,
0.2964804769,
-0.0779502317,
-0.33200109,
-0.5081611276,
-0.0102287233,
0.1381584406,
-0.0591639392,
-0.2725419402,
0.3900315166,
-0.6150948405,
-0.1241496131,
-0.3644535542,
0.2476335317,
-0.2303692997,
0.2591334581,
0.2024755776,
0.7924955487,
0.3648099899,
-0.8679781556,
0.2464729548,
0.2724594772,
-0.2038800716,
0.922395885,
-0.6640244126,
0.3379552066,
-0.1569708139,
0.047020223,
-0.8758129478,
0.0989910886,
0.1211659089,
-0.6190954447,
0.1925317645,
-0.322583884,
-0.4237355292,
-0.365296185,
0.1996666193,
0.3098334372,
0.4157727361,
-0.5348841548,
0.7082247138,
0.2352805436,
-0.2659734786,
-0.6423760653,
-0.5120170116,
0.0547471382,
-0.1060264111,
-0.496225208,
0.3648638725,
-0.0080459155,
-0.1704531759,
0.1204214245,
-0.2405715138,
0.0186859872,
-0.0265967324,
0.5023751855,
0.169490993,
-0.2099930197,
0.1261778176,
0.3309717476,
-0.5014997125,
-0.0399912335,
-0.6090417504,
0.3799341321,
-0.4469549656,
-0.4430682063,
-0.0786859542,
0.5028367639,
0.5852085352,
-0.6148116589,
0.7103925943,
0.5373828411,
-0.4914282858,
0.1192814335,
-0.6714142561,
-0.093908757,
-0.3395776153,
0.1600959003,
-0.7307148576,
-1.0460658073,
0.3744226694,
-0.3438579142,
0.180721283,
0.7660667896,
0.6082454324,
0.1257423609,
1.132235527,
0.6973137259,
0.2449736446,
0.0321244039,
-0.0355668999,
0.140797019,
-1.0474278927,
-0.1258717477,
-0.977067709,
-0.2627169788,
-0.2406360954,
-0.5541621447,
0.5682797432,
0.434881717,
-0.0224241354,
0.8471497297,
-0.4556389451,
0.1910445392,
0.6909682155,
0.0133827869,
0.6388965845,
-0.0155582596,
-0.6684435606,
-0.3686852157,
-0.5648578405,
-0.7900035381,
0.8371226192,
0.2398692667,
0.212767601,
0.0736547932,
0.1901980639,
0.1969094723,
0.8744843602,
-0.7613673806,
0.4018302262,
-0.469850868,
-0.7538817525,
0.0733330324,
-0.4851445258,
-0.5503635406,
0.2971575558,
-0.2097093463,
-0.6487960815,
0.0701455027,
0.0486656874,
0.0385261923,
0.1779792756,
-0.5959162116,
0.9658596516,
-0.3196426332,
-0.1758739799,
-0.288529247,
-0.4545221627,
0.2656095326,
-0.1205150932,
0.156325087,
-0.2980156541,
0.0214304402,
0.6438102126,
-0.1132531166,
0.8101761341,
0.0667022914,
0.0074600331,
0.2408917993,
0.2363764644,
0.1109303609,
-0.2695055306,
-0.439097017,
0.4160397947,
0.084518671,
-0.2843533158,
-0.484724313,
0.4727233946,
-0.7190668583,
-0.4198197722,
-0.049298048,
-0.6798160076,
-0.2016376555,
0.4531317949,
0.5073136687,
0.2725524008,
-0.512270391,
0.1747500896,
0.3464379609,
0.0574053936,
0.2158414423,
0.6305947304,
-0.2318116426,
-0.6219598055,
0.3243261874,
0.2084094584,
0.2062226087,
0.3450766504,
0.1809367388,
-0.4258976877,
-0.4354594648,
-0.7271252871,
0.3614521623,
-0.9703299403,
-0.2536302507,
-0.6823815107,
0.0991901085,
-0.5997914672,
-0.1907715499,
-0.496339798,
-0.5170298815,
0.0230093487,
-0.1603912711,
-0.0123363314,
0.6286334991,
-0.0704960823,
0.3837960958,
-1.0617198944,
-0.0095680114,
-0.0429312102,
0.0463399254,
-0.3014009893,
-0.7406919599,
-0.5090193152,
0.0976788029,
-0.1946364194,
-0.7779195905,
0.2215354741,
-0.0110964337,
0.7046861053,
0.5033516288,
0.2493564188,
0.8007207513,
-0.6347518563,
0.6340138316,
0.1602362543,
-1.3943140507,
0.5196006894,
0.0522349142,
0.3442587852,
0.4778262377,
0.6401680112,
-0.6122934818,
-0.3510730565,
-0.3739407957,
-0.4060053825,
0.2915963531,
0.2045531422,
-0.1477580518,
-0.1133261472,
0.5033029914,
0.3265843391,
0.2773496807,
-0.3691753745,
-0.1468240619,
0.0253167227,
-0.143289119,
-0.3820759356,
-0.2548269331,
-0.1807113588,
-0.244856298,
0.6785641313,
-0.330108434,
0.2659381926,
0.3585160375,
-0.506502986,
-0.2947068512,
0.4120937288,
0.4773401022,
0.7578968406,
-0.151847288,
0.5465615988,
0.4665666521,
-0.0796168223,
0.0962660313,
0.0512441397,
-0.2298243195,
0.3703259528,
0.3642478883,
0.6623476744,
0.1871616095,
-0.5683318973,
0.192196846,
0.0868136287,
-0.0124549372,
-0.103924945,
-0.3025632501,
-0.0165277235,
0.0843640938,
0.3881524801,
0.2980343997,
0.1660163701,
-0.3212909698,
0.1269423813,
0.3688790798,
-0.7603571415,
-0.4472088218,
0.5131472349,
0.3648230135,
-0.0773917958,
0.6572235227,
0.121485509,
-0.9506892562,
0.3097569048,
0.7609633803,
0.7897191048,
-0.4635677338,
-0.1925703734,
0.812261939,
0.6851385832,
0.0302824974,
-0.3165478706,
-0.1334199011,
-0.6946048737,
-0.7104390264,
-0.3467689753,
-0.7188570499,
-0.5042774081,
-0.8446953297,
0.2703728378,
-0.2031104863,
-0.6112471223,
-0.0546110012,
-0.1119048372,
-0.5800231695,
0.0786103681,
0.1535793543,
0.8645652533,
-0.7767621875,
0.737401545,
0.9934905171,
-0.1407255977,
-0.1969582736,
-0.5386463404,
0.0156422481,
-0.4599348903,
0.8273436427,
0.4609163702,
-0.387214452,
-0.0648961663,
-0.4337190688,
-0.5752844214,
0.8412520885,
0.5329157114,
-0.3418807089,
0.0464008711,
0.3123371601,
0.498847872,
-0.5646278858,
0.3793918788,
0.5224183798,
0.6545862556,
-0.1932453215,
-1.4256763458,
-0.048700165,
-0.292940706,
-0.0268474277,
0.0642525852,
-0.2208708674,
0.6435367465,
-0.0197151471,
-0.4058704972,
0.1087068319,
0.8354539275,
-0.0245890301,
0.2135818452,
0.6029095054,
0.6136105061,
0.5793341398,
-0.2753573656,
1.0056208372,
-0.4294433594,
0.3626547754,
1.2559235096,
-0.1310981512,
0.8972551227,
0.5007038116,
0.1423882693,
0.3179878294,
0.5005720854,
0.1443006396,
0.1063499823,
-0.1306851953,
-0.1391454786,
-0.4187721014,
-0.5003179908,
-0.2849045992,
0.0347372405,
0.444367677,
-0.4759075046,
-0.2643505931,
0.1918696314,
0.0251860563,
0.2335690558,
-0.3009456098,
0.6237753034,
0.1740444899,
-1.0111676455,
0.5622373819,
0.3168565035,
0.637359798,
-0.4529506564,
0.1604299545,
-0.0553577244,
0.4306223989,
-0.1731294245,
-0.4091365635,
0.6244952679,
0.3528297246,
-0.3370049894,
-0.1322202384,
0.5704031587,
-0.2990505397,
-0.5148786902,
0.5571854711,
0.5989858508,
0.2459841073,
-0.342432946,
-0.5520519018,
0.0117092235,
-0.3044416904,
0.2782410085,
-0.0356587432,
0.3665582836,
0.0260116868,
0.5268551707,
0.6415338516,
-0.1407548636,
0.3259804249,
-0.2876250148,
0.5567362309,
-0.3538160324,
-0.0166432522,
-0.6592502594,
0.5373598933,
-0.0463992283,
-0.3432138264,
0.9275910854,
0.7663097382,
0.8696498871,
-0.2052164525,
0.6435874701,
-0.1597392559,
0.7749450803,
-0.3409479856,
0.1921841502,
-0.2461340427,
0.0451694131,
-0.0849484578,
-1.0326616764,
-0.4034985602,
0.4943822622,
-0.6038998961,
-0.1828186363,
0.9027212262,
0.5198485255,
-0.2625755966,
0.0440512151,
0.4412626624,
0.1053944826,
0.0973001495,
0.468906492,
0.8659777641,
-0.5222710371,
0.6485449672,
-0.5893095136,
-0.3481040895,
-0.1309910566,
-0.9711976647,
-0.9451400638,
-0.6067908406,
-0.334143132,
-0.4887511432,
0.1088713109,
1.0615880489,
0.8499917984,
-0.9161303639,
-0.3951439559,
0.3151129484,
0.1169746816,
-0.6687024236,
-0.0751288459,
0.1761872321,
-0.4236662388,
-1.2127485275,
0.4199488461,
0.24461025,
-0.1060665324,
-0.0612403005,
-0.1644062996,
0.0315472856,
-0.2574585676,
0.822802484,
-0.0448541231,
-0.808904767,
-0.2952512801,
0.1894931942,
-0.2702043951,
0.1897102296,
1.0637391806,
-0.4009155333,
0.4036592841,
0.3544120491,
0.6218081713,
0.4693869054,
0.1856233478,
0.6244962215,
-0.5075230598,
0.1797261238,
0.0464758538,
0.4185829461,
0.3586691916,
-0.1616962105,
0.6524039507,
0.18604967,
-0.3515756726,
-0.5152181983,
0.2238061726,
-0.9815743566,
-0.1782099605,
0.8485558033,
-0.3806450069,
-0.1970205009,
-0.2062499225,
-0.3362481594,
0.5055238008,
-0.1167757958,
0.2462347597,
0.6836501956,
-0.0872199982,
-0.2538844347,
-0.5685304403,
-0.0547231324,
0.5531355143,
-0.4255902469,
0.0410003848,
0.4831075668,
0.2449347824,
0.6753195524,
0.2619214952,
-0.3534022272,
0.1383668333,
-0.22677733,
0.2767296135,
-0.1371789575,
-0.3372655511,
-0.3701775968,
0.1083047166,
0.2464602292,
0.0554298125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10914v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10914v1 | GLUECons: A Generic Benchmark for Learning Under Constraints | 2023-02-16T16:45:36 | 2023-02-16T16:45:36 | Hossein Rajaby Faghihi, Aliakbar Nafar, Chen Zheng, Roshanak Mirzaee, Yue Zhang, Andrzej Uszok, Alexander Wan, Tanawan Premsri, Dan Roth, Parisa Kordjamshidi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent research has shown that integrating domain knowledge into deep
learning architectures is effective -- it helps reduce the amount of required
data, improves the accuracy of the models' decisions, and improves the
interpretability of models. However, the research community is missing a
convened benchmark for systematically evaluating knowledge integration methods.
In this work, we create a benchmark that is a collection of nine tasks in the
domains of natural language processing and computer vision. In all cases, we
model external knowledge as constraints, specify the sources of the constraints
for each task, and implement various models that use these constraints. We
report the results of these models using a new set of extended evaluation
criteria in addition to the task performances for a more in-depth analysis.
This effort provides a framework for a more comprehensive and systematic
comparison of constraint integration techniques and for identifying related
research challenges. It will facilitate further research for alleviating some
problems of state-of-the-art neural models. | [
-0.302077949,
-0.2769041061,
0.5350612402,
0.0634866655,
0.0188933033,
0.0085152509,
-0.4996278882,
-0.4777232111,
-0.1590120196,
0.1864580512,
-0.5625475645,
-0.5881671906,
-0.7919808626,
0.1927698106,
-0.2859071493,
0.5578824282,
-0.420338124,
0.0788657665,
-1.0848281384,
-0.1863798052,
-0.5700705051,
-0.3531849682,
0.0172694828,
-0.1509526819,
0.1281344146,
0.2180759162,
0.3620894551,
0.5952562094,
0.8893681765,
0.3009209931,
-0.2525654435,
0.7825408578,
-0.1119183153,
-0.3095655143,
-0.5100485682,
-0.2034105659,
-0.0187308323,
0.3835837245,
0.652410388,
1.1260240078,
-0.0803251415,
0.3092589676,
0.4796444774,
0.3730524778,
-1.2690443993,
0.5002893806,
-0.3338459432,
0.286385566,
0.0435426682,
0.2367122471,
-0.2393207997,
-0.5894249678,
0.4520939589,
-0.7961054444,
0.1434044242,
-0.2501676977,
0.9214565754,
0.7533165216,
-0.5313352942,
-0.401900053,
-0.5673798919,
0.7601124048,
-0.5357471704,
0.5863878727,
0.1764898598,
0.3268094361,
-0.2435777485,
-0.9113395214,
-0.2962185442,
-0.1978232861,
-0.2076382488,
0.056514971,
0.012720949,
-0.0036483251,
0.3155679703,
0.3126415312,
-0.281598866,
-0.0882730708,
-0.5971410871,
-0.2604536712,
0.4828198552,
0.3995339274,
-0.1183911189,
0.1510552615,
-0.4623281062,
-0.054089617,
-0.4390036166,
0.2062297612,
0.0163236056,
0.4022019207,
-0.1645064205,
0.4683041871,
-0.4425162971,
0.8663654327,
-0.0319605172,
-0.1321350336,
0.14522627,
-0.3125934303,
-0.1674764156,
-0.3574553728,
0.6113989353,
0.2902470529,
0.1492626369,
-0.3704054058,
0.0117220767,
0.3282425702,
0.1585658342,
-0.5692349672,
-0.3151072562,
-0.2550060749,
-0.3238487542,
0.1151824966,
-0.0792456642,
-0.4838931262,
-0.636875093,
-0.6874998808,
0.2905691862,
-0.4353553951,
0.0050360132,
0.1920813173,
-0.3409320712,
0.1330750883,
0.2955450118,
-0.5519461036,
0.8321406245,
0.8935326934,
0.9158863425,
-0.6878887415,
-0.2196927816,
-0.2226489931,
0.0013953997,
-0.2397285849,
0.8324782252,
-0.6775098443,
-0.2335817516,
0.1511992514,
-0.093289271,
-0.4760697186,
-0.8670884371,
0.6847053766,
-0.2363393307,
-0.0191328749,
-0.4050546885,
-1.1062107086,
-0.3343602419,
0.2657539546,
-0.4951903224,
0.8979707956,
0.2370153219,
-0.4519430995,
0.589823544,
-0.2221682668,
-0.3628462255,
0.0134897558,
-0.51856637,
-0.1218346208,
0.1020235568,
0.0532160848,
0.5260281563,
-0.8730651736,
0.6381011605,
-0.518991828,
-0.2723206878,
0.1394647211,
0.0918376669,
0.7941830158,
0.062072698,
-0.3153734207,
-0.0741572082,
-0.6534044743,
-0.0398540348,
-0.2051744759,
-0.1772858649,
-0.1534045339,
0.0056403396,
-0.3838475049,
0.2219822705,
0.4508152604,
-0.4497720003,
0.2934136391,
0.0924117044,
0.3269782364,
0.4799717665,
-0.1050005555,
0.5133705139,
-0.0242716372,
0.1315697581,
0.1468157321,
0.4741738737,
0.3215494156,
-0.4581430852,
-0.8515018821,
-0.0696157441,
0.3578982055,
0.4035513699,
-0.555550456,
0.405513823,
-0.1615136117,
-0.6890250444,
-0.4568849206,
0.3625492752,
0.567227304,
0.6362867355,
0.581617713,
-0.5258205533,
-0.4431862235,
-1.0615797043,
-0.3185240924,
0.2770847678,
-0.0061007715,
0.3891939223,
0.6648077369,
0.0934880972,
0.9073250294,
-0.6365573406,
-0.7243645191,
0.286562413,
0.0981232673,
0.3080338538,
0.6891829371,
0.3561711013,
-0.7744983435,
-0.4941498339,
-0.0372896828,
-1.0359915495,
0.2238600403,
0.0197472069,
0.3180577457,
-0.0712628961,
0.7978488207,
-0.8019225001,
0.6760754585,
0.4543771148,
-0.1953183562,
0.7353397608,
0.0428206585,
0.0440166034,
-0.5099481344,
0.1918550134,
0.1857130975,
0.212256819,
-0.5496113896,
0.1168877408,
0.3963119686,
-0.1451521069,
-0.438220948,
0.4130151272,
-0.5941002369,
-0.0066578905,
0.0180748515,
0.3118467331,
0.1495064795,
0.7656019926,
0.2721629739,
0.5380531549,
0.6222315431,
-0.7122964859,
0.4052241743,
0.4149640203,
-0.7969350219,
0.5474165082,
-0.6088532805,
0.1105402336,
0.1305375993,
0.1518842578,
-0.7219893336,
-0.0612200312,
0.2492021173,
-0.1886057258,
0.3335620761,
-0.1476992369,
-0.394644022,
-0.3605889082,
-0.0954363719,
0.5434862971,
0.4563759267,
-0.5630766749,
0.63511163,
0.3227605522,
0.5156576633,
-0.6665236354,
-0.5348625183,
-0.0114700161,
-0.1742864847,
-0.3837007582,
0.771317184,
-0.0294161197,
-0.1220648214,
0.3573440313,
-0.3123407662,
-0.3214989007,
-0.0490466394,
0.2537206411,
0.2059154063,
-0.3568940163,
-0.321102649,
-0.1430242211,
0.0350880139,
0.162987873,
-0.3448159397,
-0.0806092992,
-0.0197330415,
-0.3100002408,
-0.5578133464,
0.0546221659,
0.3087671697,
-0.2220398486,
0.732898891,
0.3154838979,
-0.4567260146,
-0.3153587282,
-0.7625709772,
-0.0287326798,
-0.5328444242,
0.1036621481,
-0.5009324551,
-1.0076397657,
0.3599661589,
-0.4621710181,
-0.0656430721,
0.3390647471,
0.067475304,
0.0461146683,
0.7392250896,
0.6099343896,
0.0777760372,
0.2054319084,
-0.2286684364,
0.0577340275,
-1.0618783236,
-0.4843437374,
-0.481731534,
-0.3334366679,
-0.3275598586,
-0.808873415,
0.1391624659,
0.2968868017,
-0.0451664478,
0.8530915976,
-0.6282558441,
0.3997916281,
0.6578631401,
0.2131721377,
0.0906718448,
-0.6125724912,
-0.4606743455,
-0.1162801906,
-0.8148776889,
-0.0633549318,
1.0006731749,
0.0481464192,
0.5445226431,
-0.1886752695,
0.4457679093,
0.154848665,
0.233494848,
-0.5440462232,
0.605817914,
-0.3701627553,
-0.5336769819,
0.0048950617,
-0.3925400376,
-0.6281613111,
0.0927319527,
-0.1896774769,
-1.0635963678,
0.7633303404,
0.1359844804,
-0.3619709909,
0.2640706897,
-0.5749054551,
1.0461523533,
-0.0254436117,
-0.4485588372,
-0.2064865828,
-0.4496341348,
0.4830521047,
0.2250218093,
-0.093983233,
-0.5053287148,
-0.214785412,
0.6823409796,
-0.0750592798,
0.9545525312,
-0.2608639598,
0.2001942396,
0.410176456,
0.0263780877,
0.4466537237,
-0.3171763122,
-0.0061834594,
0.3116311431,
0.0470742173,
-0.1930593401,
-0.7170360088,
0.5257460475,
-0.5312772989,
-0.6322444677,
-0.1627416164,
-0.6664432883,
-0.619974196,
0.0249936748,
0.138831079,
0.5477585196,
-0.2772255242,
0.2868019342,
0.5231546164,
-0.1683355868,
0.2518643737,
0.2805679739,
0.400750339,
-0.4207894206,
0.9257221222,
0.2006652802,
0.0207365174,
0.3561317623,
0.0552698448,
-0.123644352,
-0.7631287575,
-0.0662218556,
0.1108944491,
-0.9109877348,
-0.4220772684,
-0.3953060806,
-0.2617529631,
-0.7138124704,
-0.0639913455,
-0.5790378451,
-0.4900039732,
-0.3587226272,
0.2451744229,
-0.0679443255,
0.7630793452,
0.0398635939,
0.0046033836,
-0.7922331095,
0.236758247,
0.3356944025,
0.6444336772,
0.0107396487,
-0.4605777264,
-0.5957372189,
-0.4308517873,
-0.377009511,
-0.5150352716,
0.0094139725,
0.2933633327,
0.9081662893,
0.4224224687,
0.2054092735,
0.7714563608,
-0.5109077096,
0.5398164392,
0.0929765925,
-0.9178990126,
0.4204312861,
-0.0523951277,
0.3876014054,
0.8729883432,
0.7123551965,
-0.2996868789,
-0.2707130611,
-0.5315549374,
-0.5500271916,
0.2935541272,
0.201665014,
-0.3821050227,
0.0631214902,
0.500553906,
-0.019549882,
0.1955832839,
-0.2698906064,
-0.1972239614,
0.235221684,
-0.1563043594,
0.0201994348,
-0.1136418134,
-0.1931133717,
-0.5671761632,
0.4704808295,
-0.3142344654,
-0.0034104844,
0.2539854646,
-0.4309875071,
0.34459126,
-0.3265109658,
0.4947550595,
0.6276522279,
-0.147145465,
0.067172952,
0.3445351422,
-0.2120054811,
-0.1613882631,
0.2000356317,
-0.0357370637,
-0.1541554481,
0.5826537013,
0.7037468553,
0.4776617289,
-0.6244954467,
0.4482679963,
-0.0893262625,
-0.4631689787,
-0.1141094938,
0.2529109716,
0.0054763709,
0.5269967914,
0.0897491351,
0.1445243359,
0.4721092582,
-0.1345452219,
0.3875516355,
0.442766726,
-0.7417119145,
-0.2229563445,
0.5915932655,
0.4302480221,
-0.1414896399,
0.6527170539,
-0.0656654388,
-0.4518696964,
0.7313469648,
0.244710058,
0.9254641533,
-0.068242766,
-0.010300356,
0.6023060083,
0.3273488581,
0.0056517539,
0.0762210712,
-0.3949311972,
-0.8974728584,
-0.5589987636,
-0.437102139,
-0.6342475414,
-0.0686678886,
-0.761792779,
0.3306945264,
-0.5270428658,
-0.1562964469,
0.1582810432,
0.0119234379,
-0.9783718586,
0.1579758674,
0.2687028348,
1.4368852377,
-0.7863891721,
0.8554836512,
0.5810428858,
-0.2432391793,
-0.4871214032,
-0.3720356524,
0.3441775441,
-0.5910877585,
0.6753101945,
0.2907332182,
-0.0208780877,
-0.4325274527,
-0.3934366107,
-0.9925915003,
0.9072187543,
0.4696135819,
-0.3813548684,
-0.1543753296,
0.4149484634,
0.3920336664,
-0.4993039072,
-0.1122950986,
0.9565517902,
0.4950421751,
-0.0673652291,
-1.011418581,
0.2766324878,
-0.4006232619,
-0.1555185169,
0.2189799994,
-0.6468265057,
0.7770161629,
0.0181646422,
-0.3324958086,
0.1064365655,
0.8432997465,
-0.0090635847,
0.1966830045,
0.5549902916,
0.6542978883,
0.6501950026,
-0.1836684942,
0.745447576,
-0.1420401633,
0.4524374306,
1.5100210905,
-0.2972840369,
0.6218937039,
0.5722444057,
-0.3151893914,
0.362211287,
0.5549589992,
-0.3310935795,
0.6167714,
0.3936295211,
-0.0909787789,
-0.3113479614,
-0.6673521399,
-0.101987794,
0.4041433036,
0.5629751682,
0.0519664884,
-0.014658968,
-0.102685295,
-0.3484107256,
0.3215845823,
-0.0770027712,
0.891192317,
0.2632568777,
-0.9075859189,
0.3698631823,
-0.4667271376,
0.6439124942,
-0.3867082894,
-0.2333000153,
-0.1531225592,
0.519177258,
-0.2120587677,
-0.6978327632,
0.3965228498,
-0.4025091529,
0.0309091695,
-0.0295808204,
0.7423914075,
-0.3931857944,
-0.1547171175,
0.4662452042,
0.2491409779,
-0.0453083031,
-0.0705311745,
-0.7000736594,
0.1634147763,
-0.1548060924,
-0.0651359856,
0.2697098255,
0.3367127478,
0.1510706246,
0.7132335305,
0.2833415568,
-0.0441249683,
-0.0645981357,
-0.1369404197,
0.9048554897,
-0.5298007131,
-0.1303268224,
-0.6182197928,
0.4401239455,
-0.3596358299,
-0.5994290709,
0.7330374122,
0.5644674897,
1.0340182781,
-0.0763265118,
0.4919314682,
-0.1744392812,
0.3251112103,
-0.4185394347,
0.336807996,
-0.5088383555,
-0.0242248084,
-0.2184519768,
-0.8857946992,
-0.4306232333,
0.2097182572,
-0.2125396729,
-0.3095288873,
0.9590899944,
0.5097068548,
-0.1564725488,
-0.063493222,
0.1865378469,
-0.3289213181,
-0.0248364564,
0.7653443813,
0.9106388092,
-0.4003458321,
0.5544475317,
-0.9288900495,
-0.0643056408,
-0.0126268147,
-1.0086449385,
-1.1229783297,
-0.8925234079,
-0.7101055384,
-0.0147891911,
0.0145133892,
0.7212458849,
0.9613122344,
-0.96546942,
-0.4584223032,
-0.0825403109,
0.1822961271,
-0.5598637462,
-0.154321149,
0.548587203,
-0.4814929962,
-0.6940524578,
0.5588558912,
0.1242722422,
-0.1953809112,
0.002530979,
-0.0757234544,
-0.4263173938,
-0.1602320224,
0.2199390233,
0.379216224,
-0.5038077831,
-0.3822516799,
-0.015394479,
0.0443138592,
-0.024089748,
1.1791298389,
-0.8276534677,
0.275829196,
0.3209739327,
0.9288906455,
0.6498652101,
-0.3498485088,
0.7711895108,
-0.8402656913,
0.2539681196,
0.2962959707,
0.4137686789,
0.1986809075,
-0.2750963569,
0.9647948146,
0.3046642542,
-0.3645928502,
-0.872256875,
0.0064237434,
-0.7446272373,
-0.3810653389,
0.7246274948,
-0.5203354359,
-0.2538638413,
-0.1204807386,
0.3353792727,
0.3732119501,
0.0529015847,
0.7201015353,
0.6797971725,
-0.412741214,
-0.0792951807,
-0.475117892,
0.8130704165,
0.3975104392,
-0.8820866346,
0.1584955156,
0.4277857542,
-0.0832516029,
0.2856428623,
0.0246675741,
0.0524141341,
0.4145635664,
0.1596042216,
0.073356539,
-0.06125094,
-0.5959040523,
-0.1621131301,
0.2525304854,
-0.1708198935,
-0.1051932424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09301v1 | Exploring the Representation Manifolds of Stable Diffusion Through the Lens of Intrinsic Dimension | 2023-02-16T16:22:30 | 2023-02-16T16:22:30 | Henry Kvinge, Davis Brown, Charles Godfrey | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Prompting has become an important mechanism by which users can more
effectively interact with many flavors of foundation model. Indeed, the last
several years have shown that well-honed prompts can sometimes unlock emergent
capabilities within such models. While there has been a substantial amount of
empirical exploration of prompting within the community, relatively few works
have studied prompting at a mathematical level. In this work we aim to take a
first step towards understanding basic geometric properties induced by prompts
in Stable Diffusion, focusing on the intrinsic dimension of internal
representations within the model. We find that choice of prompt has a
substantial impact on the intrinsic dimension of representations at both layers
of the model which we explored, but that the nature of this impact depends on
the layer being considered. For example, in certain bottleneck layers of the
model, intrinsic dimension of representations is correlated with prompt
perplexity (measured using a surrogate model), while this correlation is not
apparent in the latent layers. Our evidence suggests that intrinsic dimension
could be a useful tool for future studies of the impact of different prompts on
text-to-image models. | [
-0.5984272957,
-1.0430272818,
0.8435459733,
0.2928688824,
-0.1788275987,
-0.2201824933,
-0.0016065589,
-0.2331542671,
0.0763573498,
0.0941306204,
-0.6956507564,
-0.2332009077,
-0.5845241547,
0.1033945531,
-0.3674012423,
0.6974484921,
-0.1712619662,
0.0193425417,
-0.4529259205,
-0.1299808621,
-0.6117153764,
-0.3721116781,
-0.6848674417,
-0.1502583176,
0.8376613855,
0.2104604095,
0.3878892958,
0.3741897941,
0.09393619,
0.3241098821,
-0.4964290857,
-0.3858672082,
-0.5498607159,
0.5957722664,
-0.110179387,
-0.539517343,
0.1592029631,
0.2627563775,
1.1667503119,
0.8817740083,
0.2892797887,
-0.0380444489,
0.4228694141,
0.803296566,
-0.3198137283,
-0.0386093371,
-0.3475121558,
0.0234267432,
-0.1621756554,
-0.1458766907,
-0.4585791826,
-0.2149219066,
0.4886575043,
-0.5745952725,
0.3053612709,
-0.0991181135,
0.7731820345,
0.2574953437,
-0.4434680343,
-0.4604243338,
-0.5214757323,
0.4715713561,
0.0498112626,
0.1784026027,
0.149991706,
0.2647877932,
-0.0627977401,
-0.6108543873,
-0.261682421,
-0.3767841756,
-0.109490037,
-0.0440210849,
-0.1946320087,
-0.1103726476,
0.3793422282,
0.3847260177,
-0.3046552539,
0.0807987005,
-0.1991057992,
-0.1027312428,
0.0853172019,
0.2390054911,
0.3366501033,
-0.1741480827,
-0.3540579975,
-0.0853970498,
-0.8702375293,
0.5882565379,
0.5074942708,
0.3063327372,
-0.2908942699,
0.5873906016,
0.0658520237,
0.4608316422,
0.4525157511,
0.253177911,
-0.0152105428,
-0.2365763485,
0.1094387695,
0.1467222124,
0.6689602137,
-0.0973977596,
0.0989192575,
0.2195098847,
-0.0514116101,
0.009799731,
0.3509139121,
-0.9379880428,
-0.1341894418,
0.1662666351,
-0.5639287233,
-0.3719787598,
0.2066856772,
-0.6084557176,
-0.6049160957,
-0.1373092234,
0.5300378799,
-0.5124216676,
-0.4299853444,
0.069761239,
-0.2931736112,
-0.1004145518,
0.7235431671,
-0.9126133919,
-0.1045084447,
0.4549160004,
1.0789475441,
-0.0264155176,
-0.1122531295,
-0.38608253,
0.0250233635,
-0.3687751889,
1.0241342783,
-0.9421641231,
-0.777297914,
-0.0948026925,
0.0403640084,
0.2538432479,
-0.3961033523,
0.5605033636,
-0.4322498441,
0.2118114233,
-0.9902244806,
-0.3684884012,
-0.3384894729,
0.1736814678,
-0.6730434299,
0.9671060443,
0.2357142419,
-0.711648941,
0.5237839818,
-0.6789633632,
-0.0364861377,
0.1543827206,
-0.2603055835,
-0.1278711706,
0.4429925382,
0.3685575724,
0.4677674472,
-0.0508033819,
-0.1017373577,
-0.3022838533,
-0.044758454,
0.3307460248,
-0.6670925021,
0.8217468858,
-0.2800447941,
-0.1031303108,
0.0603657961,
-0.4634709656,
-0.478028208,
0.0325743444,
-0.2079087496,
-0.2952620089,
-0.2163650244,
-0.429807514,
-0.0130889835,
0.230393514,
-0.4132277071,
0.519816637,
0.0813479722,
0.3269822001,
1.0792963505,
0.7066703439,
0.8269082904,
-0.0621486977,
0.6522588134,
0.521399796,
-0.1596830934,
-0.6277830005,
-0.8645443916,
-0.3666479588,
-0.3502455056,
0.2656649649,
0.226472199,
-0.4527975619,
-0.0474849828,
0.054143101,
-0.2728948891,
-0.3416534662,
-0.143610239,
0.1849871725,
0.8453626633,
-0.0129065113,
-0.2114259154,
0.3308836818,
-0.735030055,
0.1556519419,
-0.3664414287,
-0.0311267637,
0.5267837644,
0.3922965229,
-0.074979268,
1.0091627836,
-0.2614966035,
-0.1067322567,
0.2045365125,
0.5170339942,
0.4733703136,
0.4884828329,
0.8169972301,
-0.6843549013,
-0.6337935925,
-0.0517989658,
-0.8815333247,
-0.4243530929,
-0.2724871933,
-0.373375237,
-0.1379966736,
0.2322627157,
-0.8346908092,
0.6331549287,
0.2112616003,
-0.5652310848,
0.9205423594,
-0.2093071043,
0.3169643879,
-0.5608373284,
-0.0133296298,
0.2795678079,
-0.0687905177,
-0.4990012348,
-0.096819222,
0.1392633617,
-0.2362812608,
-0.3875445127,
0.7254809737,
-0.7514997125,
-0.0336980335,
-0.02235201,
-0.0082807243,
0.2007015198,
0.144902423,
0.0837505683,
1.1581175327,
1.1206290722,
-0.918381393,
-0.0344898626,
0.4137752652,
-0.2048196644,
1.0667437315,
-0.9356344938,
-0.0799040273,
-0.3695990741,
0.2582910955,
-1.1486288309,
-0.0531361513,
0.3716403544,
-0.5373084545,
0.4827763438,
-0.531237185,
-0.4179983437,
-0.2839157283,
-0.2234001756,
0.4731107354,
0.4627344906,
-0.5191340446,
0.6331799626,
0.0786511227,
-0.1946558952,
-0.2543498576,
-0.5159253478,
-0.1261594743,
-0.358917743,
-0.9575712085,
0.2163829505,
-0.2182157338,
-0.0796967447,
0.1187995374,
0.1247010082,
0.3485302627,
-0.1508745253,
0.5512005091,
0.0213830881,
-0.341591686,
-0.0204433966,
0.5516292453,
-0.4050009549,
0.4202697277,
-0.5478919744,
0.4496753812,
-0.1604287028,
-0.521481812,
-0.9985666871,
0.4276022017,
0.5379441381,
0.041551318,
0.8015463948,
0.353215158,
-0.3088858426,
0.0755203813,
-0.1646162421,
-0.3250649869,
-0.614669323,
-0.1981620342,
-0.710893929,
-0.7117902637,
1.0858356953,
-0.1110623255,
-0.0839579627,
0.4267767668,
0.7109763026,
-0.1810559332,
1.2026815414,
0.3602896631,
0.3729890585,
0.7381133437,
-0.5274060369,
-0.0742331222,
-1.137558341,
-0.3908930123,
-0.5690009594,
-0.4956040382,
-0.0526085868,
-0.2806668878,
0.7289864421,
0.4829066098,
-0.2791630626,
-0.1910231858,
-0.6499439478,
0.5630951524,
0.3683245182,
0.2898108065,
-0.1357180178,
0.2684299648,
-0.6433154345,
-0.2048002183,
-0.5402837396,
-0.4795809686,
0.5010755658,
0.442029804,
0.6558951735,
0.250443399,
0.3784785569,
0.1853673905,
0.0882363915,
-0.6772315502,
0.5125337839,
0.2285972536,
-0.4246978462,
-0.2560512125,
-0.3224028945,
-1.0422596931,
-0.0621214248,
-0.1776482016,
-0.8679795861,
0.8242425919,
0.2166267484,
-0.4355696738,
0.0800697729,
-0.7537127137,
0.6807169914,
0.0222648289,
-0.5485213399,
-0.0352004282,
-0.3688899577,
0.0271330085,
0.3470398188,
-0.2435187101,
0.0642344728,
-0.2496807873,
0.2975636125,
-0.3370562196,
0.9907554984,
-0.4392792284,
-0.2799285352,
0.2541241944,
0.669246316,
0.3567899764,
0.4906516373,
-0.2274335176,
0.1478099078,
-0.2499475628,
-0.4995628297,
-0.8705494404,
0.71712327,
-0.8013987541,
-0.8842821121,
-0.2301266491,
-0.304708153,
-0.0389074422,
0.1660631001,
0.5210468173,
0.8455533981,
0.0850037113,
0.2064525485,
1.1527117491,
-0.1637733132,
0.3953163028,
0.0782806128,
-0.4042880535,
-0.0120587004,
0.6978304982,
0.2177421004,
0.3169102669,
0.2023662925,
0.5366310477,
-0.5258327723,
-0.6505823731,
-0.8534090519,
0.3474143445,
-0.9953035712,
0.0476598106,
-0.7725967765,
-0.1148660481,
-0.0808094367,
-0.4594777524,
0.0030183233,
-0.3137480319,
-1.1420702934,
-0.2791095972,
0.5611311793,
1.0221631527,
-0.1487640142,
0.2618455887,
-0.7806774974,
-0.032972578,
0.3361924291,
0.3714636266,
0.4192476571,
-0.6071180105,
-0.0327851661,
-0.0556785762,
-0.1612771899,
-1.142444253,
-0.108489275,
0.0479711071,
0.7675573826,
1.1247842312,
-0.1499754488,
0.5456976891,
-0.5367828608,
1.330053091,
0.1334289312,
-0.812235713,
0.7839652896,
-0.657913506,
0.3899797499,
0.5464867949,
0.5424200892,
-0.259422332,
-0.3317402899,
-0.5179366469,
-0.5277503729,
0.4420521557,
0.078476578,
0.6070008278,
-0.1008357406,
0.747705698,
0.4309078157,
0.1292473525,
-0.549859941,
-0.2663152218,
-0.3022260666,
0.2727428079,
0.4945042729,
-0.5392612219,
-0.0242129061,
-0.1979130805,
0.2369587421,
0.1331580877,
0.5887197256,
0.2926412523,
0.0525793321,
-0.2342730612,
-0.3454209566,
0.5840047002,
0.6043997407,
0.0602525212,
-0.0121474555,
-0.2245400697,
-0.5053083301,
0.256531924,
-0.3543317914,
-0.2857128978,
0.0384632088,
0.2846960425,
0.9698159099,
-0.0831525624,
-0.0489582457,
0.3797140121,
-0.130901739,
-0.2660855949,
0.0556160286,
0.2164416164,
-0.3473947346,
0.1418241709,
0.6136218309,
0.1512335539,
0.1274876446,
-0.4244271517,
-0.0543347299,
0.4841800332,
-0.7187623382,
-0.5267006755,
0.6736465693,
0.1500922143,
-0.3716464639,
0.6697134376,
-0.3074116707,
-0.5893061161,
0.3402362466,
0.3346292377,
0.7786405683,
-0.2784089744,
0.6201215386,
0.4881772995,
0.1265255213,
0.1102062464,
0.1252117455,
-0.2516804934,
-0.5844127536,
-0.0910022408,
-0.3210004568,
-0.1358357072,
-0.4277969897,
-0.569725275,
0.1949181855,
-0.6480442286,
-0.1769011021,
-0.13243258,
-0.1690141112,
-0.3465833664,
-0.1651458442,
-0.0291176774,
0.9337590933,
-0.7311964035,
0.4413347244,
0.6602818966,
-0.4598504007,
-0.7787564993,
0.0071619949,
0.3332733512,
-0.5901269913,
0.7738377452,
0.3576045036,
-0.0983206481,
0.0589497611,
-0.772179544,
-0.7608639002,
0.9730427861,
0.3696554005,
-0.0986170769,
0.1046361774,
-0.0067470302,
0.5068970919,
-0.5150196552,
0.2529925108,
0.073109217,
0.454528749,
0.5479546189,
-0.2550599873,
0.2102960497,
-0.3924221694,
0.2281673998,
0.2450088263,
-0.2706056535,
1.0414569378,
-0.177586019,
-0.5894342661,
0.056003876,
0.6211611032,
0.3700302839,
-0.0292261727,
0.4316779673,
0.6015931368,
0.8290959001,
-0.3112187982,
1.2447417974,
-0.3001007736,
0.099796623,
0.3341102302,
-0.1090410948,
0.5829623938,
0.4830785096,
-0.0735122114,
1.0415815115,
1.0270100832,
0.2098027617,
0.4771272242,
-0.1145247743,
-0.405662775,
-0.045864474,
-0.1985108703,
-0.6301895976,
-0.3175094426,
0.7661243677,
-0.1967686564,
-0.1688813269,
0.2313003838,
-0.3550748527,
-0.1869245768,
-0.4701662362,
0.7232433558,
0.1302627176,
-0.4672832191,
0.3968768418,
-0.4883258641,
0.4028659463,
-0.6040941477,
-0.1661666036,
-0.156696856,
-0.4167074561,
-0.0043328241,
-1.286085844,
0.0615633801,
-0.3269486129,
-0.5426858664,
-0.6684676409,
0.7332793474,
-0.0596182905,
-0.4382383525,
0.1850036681,
0.2305778563,
0.1390272677,
-0.2137094438,
-0.7854397893,
0.1710393727,
-0.2705415487,
-0.3679706752,
0.2187362164,
1.1495279074,
-0.0163634922,
0.6218175292,
0.8320236802,
-0.0133043816,
0.1680249274,
0.1778032631,
0.9959805012,
-0.3587726653,
-0.7903721929,
-0.8343086839,
1.0668154955,
0.0778851137,
-0.3743678927,
0.5656442642,
0.0077021606,
0.25928846,
-0.0305636842,
0.3548244238,
0.0825474709,
0.1528579295,
-0.7256084681,
0.7346074581,
-0.5193719864,
0.4499289095,
-0.2453528643,
-1.0244363546,
-0.0105581479,
0.653224647,
-0.3609851599,
0.1123084724,
0.7340556383,
0.807905972,
-0.0458195508,
0.131288752,
0.0713662431,
0.2209686041,
0.3834437728,
0.0860489011,
1.1864234209,
0.1367055029,
0.0338776857,
-0.0187113155,
-0.376862824,
-0.1728425026,
-1.0281848907,
-1.1373933554,
-0.9658867717,
-0.3210923374,
-0.6382377148,
-0.4248318076,
0.3881873786,
0.7986584306,
-0.4994848669,
0.1932325661,
-0.347279489,
0.2462852895,
-0.0060316175,
-0.250284642,
0.3003657758,
-0.0590446219,
-0.4999706447,
-0.0254962333,
0.656234622,
0.664378643,
-0.7861052155,
0.0761594921,
0.0572991334,
-0.0040858472,
0.5064052343,
0.118985109,
-0.535849154,
-0.1958425641,
-0.0177534241,
0.0198269207,
0.2369751483,
1.0848591328,
-0.9776630402,
0.3923088014,
0.7851629853,
0.5470021963,
0.454117626,
0.0926645473,
0.6199749112,
-0.8992022276,
0.3303415179,
0.1138099432,
0.3588111997,
0.3003268242,
-0.8397010565,
0.0964493901,
0.3002545834,
-0.5461571217,
-0.7667024136,
0.4744627178,
-0.9611317515,
-0.2384343743,
1.0783065557,
-0.0675299838,
-0.2132009566,
0.0244949795,
-0.5250181556,
-0.3837456703,
-0.6913272142,
0.5944479108,
0.9937199354,
-0.2032693774,
-0.7371357679,
-0.3027481139,
0.1401263624,
0.126207009,
-0.4815458655,
-0.1815201938,
0.6195089221,
-0.0903483555,
0.4127073884,
0.6230406761,
-0.0901397243,
0.2865878642,
0.0143404473,
-0.7676463723,
-0.0403557532,
-0.561126411,
-0.5817509294,
0.2470273226,
-0.0899197608,
0.1357568055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10144v1 | Stabilising and accelerating light gated recurrent units for automatic speech recognition | 2023-02-16T16:18:58 | 2023-02-16T16:18:58 | Adel Moumen, Titouan Parcollet | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | The light gated recurrent units (Li-GRU) is well-known for achieving
impressive results in automatic speech recognition (ASR) tasks while being
lighter and faster to train than a standard gated recurrent units (GRU).
However, the unbounded nature of its rectified linear unit on the candidate
recurrent gate induces an important gradient exploding phenomenon disrupting
the training process and preventing it from being applied to famous datasets.
In this paper, we theoretically and empirically derive the necessary conditions
for its stability as well as engineering mechanisms to speed up by a factor of
five its training time, hence introducing a novel version of this architecture
named SLi-GRU. Then, we evaluate its performance both on a toy task
illustrating its newly acquired capabilities and a set of three different ASR
datasets demonstrating lower word error rates compared to more complex
recurrent neural networks. | [
-0.4862906337,
-0.6036221981,
0.2129706442,
0.0297771376,
-0.1299847513,
0.1530036628,
-0.0900874436,
-0.5262743235,
-0.2077410519,
0.0192309972,
-0.2690852582,
0.1388908178,
-0.4577305019,
-0.183417365,
-0.5731431842,
0.9839014411,
0.2368011028,
0.2305400372,
0.1826226115,
-0.6537807584,
-0.4185330272,
-0.1540218741,
-0.9662774801,
-0.6658003926,
0.6255708933,
0.0537245832,
0.7484471202,
0.6530852914,
0.438292861,
0.3905985951,
-0.2207605392,
-0.1539579183,
-0.3515546918,
-0.0156558324,
0.1153215468,
-0.1736664772,
-0.4449059069,
-0.2442359179,
1.1715177298,
0.6508067846,
-0.447586149,
0.0317861699,
0.1440546364,
0.829852283,
-0.362722367,
0.1265569627,
-0.7747868299,
-0.2612242103,
-0.1688702852,
-0.1747501791,
-0.0782338679,
-0.1438942403,
0.197151944,
-0.4410400391,
0.3895688653,
-0.08213301,
0.7023139596,
0.3934035003,
0.0969273224,
-0.1084525585,
-0.973382771,
0.5369009376,
-0.5366842747,
0.89809829,
-0.4910730124,
0.4420781732,
-0.1622657031,
-0.7797028422,
-0.4162499011,
-0.1051954851,
-0.115435034,
-0.1883873194,
-0.139502272,
0.3903653622,
0.7180442214,
0.322317481,
-0.5634416938,
-0.1366688013,
-0.4223351479,
-0.0261085182,
0.647526145,
0.0363405459,
0.2010386884,
0.2279638201,
-0.3854714334,
0.1540682167,
-0.5005628467,
0.316013664,
0.3160033822,
0.3710604906,
0.2818723917,
0.1653990895,
-0.0581918396,
0.7836703062,
0.254935503,
-0.2325151712,
0.6329758167,
-0.0343550555,
-0.1913858652,
0.4368279278,
0.7336165309,
0.1123453528,
0.016996745,
-0.3580180407,
-0.800578177,
0.521882236,
0.30847013,
-0.719974637,
0.0335323289,
-0.1026794091,
-0.2299586982,
0.1032790169,
0.1718602926,
-0.4011120498,
-0.0536609441,
-0.2464783341,
0.7539615035,
-0.3254091144,
-0.2395034581,
0.2136557251,
-0.0296090674,
0.1815692633,
0.1556722969,
-0.9592934847,
0.3749112487,
0.6133215427,
0.68421942,
-0.30105865,
-0.3202159405,
-0.8729228377,
-0.0312789828,
-0.3299465775,
0.3586892188,
-0.4389386177,
-0.4865421355,
-0.0757749304,
0.4161630571,
-0.1300031692,
-0.4899587035,
0.7111307979,
-0.6193684936,
-0.10361249,
-0.1406421065,
-0.3295493722,
-0.0931863189,
-0.3323836327,
-0.7398887277,
0.8440204263,
0.0189504046,
-0.5997610688,
0.5053346753,
-0.6317490339,
-0.6948311925,
0.3410300016,
-0.6409778595,
-0.7033954263,
0.3328542411,
0.0812800676,
0.2354626954,
-0.1000580639,
0.2543492913,
0.1862830222,
-0.5127855539,
0.2339518517,
-0.4290246665,
0.3756357133,
0.3781518638,
-0.3990129232,
0.0660128221,
-0.8768602014,
0.0548003837,
-0.1146200374,
-0.4735963047,
-0.118161492,
-0.1409460604,
0.0597607717,
-0.0519187041,
0.0367284268,
-0.7657663822,
-0.0537834726,
-0.3017701209,
0.7070918083,
0.3535521328,
-0.062334355,
0.535357058,
-0.6492353678,
0.461003691,
0.0032447204,
-0.0219561215,
-0.3015590012,
-0.5545895696,
-0.8146952987,
0.0214373581,
0.1633645743,
0.3312187493,
-0.9675653577,
0.1226417795,
-0.2564755082,
-0.4000807405,
-0.8487423062,
-0.0062127043,
0.5043726563,
0.5148411989,
0.1668709964,
-0.1915719658,
-0.3359681368,
-0.763086319,
-0.2569414079,
-0.0828799829,
0.029720312,
0.3718378246,
0.2054703981,
-0.4679487944,
0.7457093,
-0.0296106171,
-0.2199110538,
-0.266548723,
0.5388038754,
0.4583756924,
0.7515236735,
0.5095064044,
-0.7788609862,
0.0327302143,
0.1506512612,
-0.4994617701,
-0.3071600199,
-0.4447615147,
0.2282375693,
0.3668590188,
0.3520200849,
-0.6858955622,
0.4457500577,
0.1896706074,
-0.1196067482,
0.158897981,
-0.2168884128,
0.368799001,
-0.6022705436,
0.081561774,
0.1349944472,
-0.3471098542,
-1.0406750441,
0.0171966068,
0.2634253204,
-0.284402281,
-0.5533807874,
0.2118878514,
-0.6278856397,
-0.4850340486,
-0.4650387764,
0.2632013261,
-0.2273434103,
0.3004029393,
-0.0035450102,
0.8854253292,
0.5864552855,
-0.9289178252,
0.2730664313,
-0.1884253919,
-0.427788198,
0.0193001404,
-0.8107881546,
0.1002763361,
-0.2919828594,
-0.2453747243,
-0.6909102798,
0.3612364829,
-0.2485681027,
-0.5481241941,
0.5491555333,
0.0203917865,
-0.1838602871,
-0.2798308134,
0.0023517536,
0.8401044607,
0.6106508374,
-0.6918720007,
0.6667519212,
0.3495934606,
0.1800694317,
-0.5825825334,
-0.7661798,
-0.2558498979,
-0.2868817151,
-0.6129702926,
0.4933420718,
0.0125991357,
-0.2786055505,
0.0652574375,
-0.2180346251,
0.3616788983,
0.1226609275,
0.3627085984,
0.2053218931,
-0.3796744943,
0.1950513124,
-0.2845686972,
-0.579629302,
-0.1179212406,
-0.332375139,
0.502810061,
-0.5566453934,
-0.404311955,
-0.6218076944,
0.0614394732,
0.7529751658,
-0.0777993873,
0.3780643642,
0.7303164601,
-0.5703816414,
-0.1920685321,
-0.6073638201,
-0.0872298405,
-0.5785193443,
0.3158300519,
-0.3388172686,
-0.7936521173,
0.5568441749,
0.2742492855,
0.2607598305,
0.1797384918,
0.2813230455,
0.2793094814,
0.8262789249,
0.5263887644,
-0.4594036639,
0.7228634357,
-0.352088213,
0.0638668388,
-0.907968998,
-0.0794665366,
-0.3398544192,
-0.4181410372,
-0.5804082155,
-0.4654060602,
0.3504558504,
-0.0550876111,
-0.2394839376,
0.0841856524,
-0.7318649888,
0.1939640641,
0.1976466328,
-0.2589270771,
0.377963841,
0.0391573496,
0.1095800549,
-0.1249659806,
-0.7281630039,
-0.207182318,
0.4531846941,
0.5900825858,
1.3798013926,
-0.0261019468,
0.3765087128,
0.4337853193,
0.0186589621,
-0.8219738007,
0.6682220101,
-0.1968641877,
-0.3397275209,
-0.3201139569,
-0.453607142,
-0.925737679,
0.19851017,
-0.2267249972,
-0.415178448,
0.283606261,
0.1155058295,
-0.479455173,
0.309414655,
-0.6096509695,
0.1935957372,
-0.6208955646,
-0.3094278872,
0.0191837419,
-0.4119254649,
-0.0115391696,
0.1430393308,
0.1087743491,
0.1076985896,
-0.1472274363,
0.7251870632,
-0.0891901627,
0.1471704394,
-0.5542493463,
0.0055651641,
0.1618016213,
-0.1201772764,
0.3198476136,
0.1719647646,
-0.0100671668,
-0.0766895562,
-0.518723011,
-0.2241035998,
-1.0245057344,
0.7641604543,
-0.6415423751,
-0.6819140911,
-0.6294820905,
-0.4461613894,
-0.1618948728,
-0.0174845513,
0.0911630467,
0.9087389112,
0.0316190012,
0.2967551649,
0.8145515323,
0.1054949015,
0.8417730331,
0.5916942954,
-0.5048304796,
-0.5643929243,
1.0821694136,
0.439711839,
0.6811282635,
-0.0060115787,
-0.0263013132,
-0.2353652269,
-0.796734333,
-0.727150619,
0.1838815957,
-0.3562018573,
-0.0001280331,
-0.4649200141,
-0.8347652555,
-0.1641666591,
-0.1760116071,
-0.3301589787,
-0.4164984822,
-0.1890357733,
-0.1214417517,
0.4409805536,
0.7849434614,
0.1736428887,
0.2976189256,
-0.6780961752,
0.429653883,
0.4338563681,
0.3808470666,
0.0260219369,
-0.7152360678,
-0.1788816303,
-0.0653618425,
0.1911028922,
-0.4478472769,
0.3701658547,
0.5624946952,
0.8438634276,
0.6355412006,
-0.194214642,
0.9513947368,
-0.7299215794,
0.6568626761,
0.3294938505,
-0.7080028057,
0.50486058,
-0.3673775792,
0.4566367567,
0.4278325438,
0.1231964231,
-0.4952378571,
-0.2136734277,
-0.5986186862,
-0.8330973983,
0.7378682494,
0.2680139542,
-0.1359308958,
0.3727648556,
0.8264897466,
-0.0027495355,
0.4027119279,
-0.6401087642,
-0.5244355202,
-0.3133168519,
-0.0702088773,
-0.2376321405,
-0.2515400946,
-0.0341811739,
-0.1814938188,
0.9244109392,
-0.0487189665,
0.2801042497,
0.4217524827,
-0.1156077608,
-0.2876228094,
0.3093790412,
0.5174788237,
0.3499667346,
-0.0908995122,
0.0367345698,
0.290388912,
-0.7969721556,
0.4096142948,
0.3630282283,
-0.5632021427,
0.1618342549,
0.041114144,
1.1569720507,
0.3387735188,
-0.5833305717,
0.2289059758,
-0.3873211443,
-0.0510758944,
-0.2117083669,
0.3177762628,
-0.0544060096,
0.3340955079,
0.7136441469,
0.0566595308,
0.1179101989,
-0.5556898117,
0.4740230143,
0.6820229292,
-0.4830950797,
-0.2168408632,
0.8170546293,
0.3198105097,
-0.7929247022,
0.2654438019,
-0.3747600317,
-0.392741859,
0.2263655812,
0.6461279392,
0.994384706,
-0.3657096624,
-0.0998145118,
0.3033904731,
0.4377738237,
-0.1183435172,
0.3161031008,
-0.0573573336,
-0.8844441772,
0.1521301121,
-0.7562500834,
0.0563493185,
0.2978513241,
-0.7490720749,
0.1794871688,
-0.7313471437,
-0.4284777641,
-0.1491642445,
0.0872898921,
-0.2374004126,
0.3112321198,
0.2458972484,
0.6959384084,
-0.6894045472,
1.0198969841,
0.7327436805,
-0.0628905594,
-0.5831797719,
-0.1629194915,
-0.0819528326,
-0.67479527,
0.5069794655,
0.3587313294,
-0.8273424506,
0.0420251861,
-0.0701498985,
-0.8215246797,
1.3423910141,
0.3288889229,
-1.0862872601,
0.0883276984,
0.1526421458,
0.6151080728,
-0.5851460099,
0.0237182342,
0.8534997702,
0.0786463395,
0.1287428588,
-0.8243989944,
-0.1231935769,
-0.4317534268,
0.3197016418,
0.2852911949,
-0.6036934257,
0.6821427345,
-0.2893124223,
-0.5826736093,
0.2961934209,
0.8566101193,
0.3193450868,
0.4725649357,
0.9526711106,
0.8730149865,
0.7596297264,
-0.4834840596,
0.4538494647,
-0.4219314158,
0.2905749977,
0.9525390267,
-0.1080386043,
0.581651926,
0.2496772856,
-0.0070788171,
0.2117096484,
0.2125588655,
-0.0865675062,
0.4017677009,
0.0306705497,
-0.6254345179,
-0.0299669616,
-0.1467657536,
-0.5790788531,
0.0978263393,
0.5255192518,
-0.34206599,
0.0790789947,
0.2373055071,
-0.3086291552,
0.0224638972,
-0.7291074395,
0.6662032604,
0.0495052114,
-0.3727363348,
0.5863642693,
-0.4575733244,
0.8414528966,
-0.6547355056,
0.2248160392,
0.0989720374,
0.1770711988,
-0.4462189972,
-0.6040982008,
-0.0317366906,
-0.0846119151,
-0.1025240719,
-0.1044158638,
0.8863552809,
-0.6142901778,
-0.6704309583,
0.5520766377,
0.3415224552,
-0.038768772,
0.513166368,
-0.7209791541,
0.2848312855,
-0.0237444174,
0.087321572,
0.2221785784,
0.4252441227,
0.3610902131,
0.9128994942,
0.3406710625,
0.192829892,
0.3390537798,
0.4416339099,
0.9725528359,
-0.7475283742,
-0.3783894181,
-0.6595079303,
0.5491017699,
0.1550943404,
-0.019348802,
0.6806890965,
0.6644963026,
0.6255968809,
0.2950623631,
0.6839624643,
-0.0082249632,
0.4260941744,
-0.5435054898,
0.9667286873,
-0.580385983,
0.5513136387,
-0.3145835996,
-0.775714457,
-0.1578706354,
0.6883484125,
0.1996324062,
0.252003938,
0.4320631325,
0.946475327,
0.2446109951,
0.2725913525,
0.5828510523,
0.3072776496,
0.4383379519,
0.3636649847,
0.8315939903,
-0.6002343893,
0.3825346828,
-0.2406171411,
-0.1084342897,
0.141028747,
-0.5177760124,
-0.7209402919,
-0.7200491428,
-0.4474325478,
-0.3063802719,
0.2347671688,
0.7490413785,
0.5707364082,
-0.6823183894,
-0.1944339275,
-0.334980756,
0.0002949546,
-0.1347820312,
-0.2334713489,
-0.0125887915,
-0.6206204891,
-0.6006539464,
0.4715323448,
0.3769406378,
0.1614954174,
-0.3564892411,
-0.1709449887,
-0.0691303015,
-0.2889648676,
0.2601664662,
0.5162011981,
-0.6499159932,
-0.3341749609,
-0.3449092507,
0.1561672986,
0.2719958127,
0.9448372126,
-1.249394536,
0.5472753048,
0.4641631544,
0.9386246204,
0.3296163678,
0.2796553075,
0.4892310202,
-0.501942575,
0.137937814,
0.1872909665,
0.6569949389,
0.3683190942,
-0.2563949823,
0.3794107735,
0.4288687706,
-1.0166494846,
-0.8518378139,
0.1732221693,
-1.0144673586,
0.2472450286,
1.0341742039,
-0.0332051665,
-0.3141154647,
-0.1367122978,
-0.1960020661,
0.2350067049,
-0.7897385955,
0.6349737644,
0.1036381125,
-0.338501215,
-0.2104198039,
-0.533418417,
0.8408477902,
0.2688687146,
-0.3269483149,
0.1194782928,
0.3275733292,
0.2721351087,
0.5665097833,
0.4300303161,
-0.1339100152,
0.6972229481,
0.0083123166,
-0.1987536401,
-0.097487852,
-0.5560523868,
-1.0640271902,
0.2056371719,
0.185949266,
-0.4177030921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08399v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08399v5 | Large Language Models Fail on Trivial Alterations to Theory-of-Mind Tasks | 2023-02-16T16:18:03 | 2023-03-14T13:47:26 | Tomer Ullman | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7 | Intuitive psychology is a pillar of common-sense reasoning. The replication
of this reasoning in machine intelligence is an important stepping-stone on the
way to human-like artificial intelligence. Several recent tasks and benchmarks
for examining this reasoning in Large-Large Models have focused in particular
on belief attribution in Theory-of-Mind tasks. These tasks have shown both
successes and failures. We consider in particular a recent purported success
case, and show that small variations that maintain the principles of ToM turn
the results on their head. We argue that in general, the zero-hypothesis for
model evaluation in intuitive psychology should be skeptical, and that outlying
failure cases should outweigh average success rates. We also consider what
possible future successes on Theory-of-Mind tasks by more powerful LLMs would
mean for ToM tasks with people. | [
-0.3825371265,
-0.7143253088,
1.4229781628,
0.2003732324,
-0.0507384352,
-0.2512965798,
-0.439299047,
-0.4090955257,
0.3071509898,
0.2498062253,
-0.6270398498,
-0.1025106758,
-0.7446362376,
0.134537369,
-0.4977641106,
0.5053281188,
-0.054824207,
-0.0874228477,
-0.1234588847,
-0.0340149328,
-0.3582068682,
-0.5108482242,
-0.8298763633,
-0.6670530438,
0.6748066545,
0.3800952137,
0.8495169878,
0.6467702985,
0.3814603686,
0.2415513992,
0.1113388091,
0.1492420882,
-0.3770762384,
0.1189320832,
-0.233966589,
-1.1204667091,
-0.4456177056,
0.4069176316,
0.5234683752,
0.9256602526,
-0.259144187,
-0.2593479156,
0.1421694309,
0.5409129262,
-0.3006550372,
0.1161983982,
-0.9221528769,
-0.1585765928,
0.016345175,
-0.2980319858,
-0.5864975452,
-0.2739526629,
0.1974780709,
-0.5431312919,
0.1867126822,
0.3403005004,
0.4002653658,
0.1613203287,
-0.7981394529,
-0.5184288025,
-0.7558913231,
1.2495075464,
-0.669033885,
0.2630089521,
0.5132442117,
0.2286596,
-0.5248125196,
-0.2230048776,
-1.0288501978,
-0.436894834,
0.1460050941,
-0.2518272698,
-0.1925751418,
0.2687124014,
0.4987509251,
0.3018876314,
-0.1318224669,
-0.1442528367,
-0.0090657109,
0.2749550045,
0.4619903564,
0.2201412618,
0.1687824875,
0.059852507,
0.0022992883,
-0.3031558096,
-0.6402952075,
-0.1881258488,
0.1659906954,
0.1911341697,
0.0438086726,
0.5030623078,
-0.3358588517,
0.4152654707,
0.3551381528,
-0.2497027665,
0.0556523018,
0.0036698428,
-0.3824348152,
-0.0773502141,
0.3948107958,
0.4877271652,
0.6430346966,
0.0010410409,
-0.3987986445,
0.5129081011,
0.2728571892,
-0.4476864338,
-0.1593602002,
0.3079738319,
-0.4025437534,
-0.1075138673,
-0.1475458592,
-0.0160930678,
-0.6050686836,
-0.5441772342,
0.5381807685,
-0.7043709755,
-0.3255504072,
0.3978430927,
-0.2192831337,
0.1267495006,
0.7744289041,
-0.8161266446,
0.3283526003,
1.00733459,
0.5105490685,
-0.0795916021,
-0.5696240664,
-0.1054922938,
0.0341711193,
-0.6450402737,
0.6876523495,
-0.3751828671,
-0.2434641421,
-0.0756226406,
-0.1341992766,
-0.2963046134,
-0.3765678704,
0.4673061967,
-0.0500635765,
0.1624295264,
-0.7353935242,
-0.6887397766,
-0.3789332211,
0.362891525,
-0.1384093314,
0.2680646777,
-0.2483209819,
-0.459671706,
0.5295618773,
-0.6655648351,
-0.6385132074,
-0.2389694899,
-0.3743806183,
0.1164928004,
0.6839606166,
-0.252081722,
0.5517657399,
-0.6521604657,
0.4515316784,
-0.7005987763,
-0.4319964647,
0.5928015709,
-0.5682004094,
1.0998506546,
0.2592284083,
-0.5623217821,
-0.257189244,
-0.7588005066,
0.2169305384,
0.340600878,
-0.0533939786,
-0.588631928,
0.3517453671,
-0.2220884264,
0.0457680523,
0.0276516136,
-0.5457149744,
0.3921667635,
-0.0932237506,
0.4336423576,
0.7437865734,
-0.1484572887,
0.472497344,
-0.5576824546,
0.2186570615,
-0.1639214158,
0.0540151224,
-0.016221948,
-0.6871199012,
-0.9170154333,
-0.2141347677,
-0.1601256132,
0.334854126,
-0.5306437016,
0.4709573686,
-0.2753104568,
-0.6474984288,
-0.2120645642,
0.0850259215,
0.4501973391,
0.3391055167,
0.0307401735,
-0.312520653,
-0.2757419944,
-1.0215677023,
-0.6127544641,
-0.3666693866,
-0.3413547575,
0.1382143497,
0.582854569,
-0.2645882368,
0.7409064174,
-0.4587318003,
-0.1644674838,
-0.115595676,
0.3483593762,
0.5108928084,
0.7206123471,
0.6548134685,
-0.623873055,
-0.0785722286,
-0.0718739331,
-0.9534617066,
0.3454743922,
-0.0494290441,
0.1985662431,
0.1965415925,
-0.0361364223,
-1.0983641148,
0.4065516293,
0.1715992838,
-0.4829575717,
0.4033982456,
-0.0927555263,
0.4983119369,
-0.8283948302,
-0.1742794365,
0.1116413549,
0.0078676622,
-0.7241270542,
0.1252065599,
-0.0926353931,
0.3259180784,
-0.1920700073,
0.3910390139,
-0.1582582742,
-0.0397104099,
-0.2647023201,
-0.1364661306,
-0.3151005805,
0.526327312,
-0.0299597811,
0.2172648013,
0.4794386625,
-0.8151123524,
0.2777570784,
-0.0135985911,
-0.2495442182,
0.9593922496,
-0.5773676038,
0.2754456401,
-0.1985312253,
0.2018032968,
-1.0081932545,
-0.6094626188,
0.1683681309,
-0.5282623172,
0.0210726373,
0.2838217616,
-0.6460546255,
-0.4133834541,
-0.2374985367,
0.1335431337,
0.6983499527,
-0.521807611,
0.7100185156,
-0.1227494329,
0.2166469395,
-0.2265702188,
-1.0375615358,
0.1108396724,
-0.4032606184,
-0.5036561489,
-0.1145384163,
-0.2303027213,
-0.8797115684,
-0.1426980495,
-0.1509673893,
-0.051444374,
0.4509671926,
0.1802564561,
-0.0732263699,
-0.1106913164,
-0.0090612434,
-0.1682088077,
0.0315945409,
0.4568385482,
-0.3795455992,
0.3102889359,
-0.2018264681,
-0.847307086,
-0.5342850089,
0.1884216368,
0.8219864368,
0.3256753087,
0.5587109327,
-0.1113330275,
-0.5634453297,
-0.2142571658,
-0.6434802413,
-0.4874796271,
-0.4111470878,
0.3278181255,
-0.5874437094,
-0.5533637404,
0.433291018,
0.1470579505,
0.021609081,
0.436781913,
0.3610979021,
-0.4091932476,
1.32181108,
0.596603632,
0.1123292074,
0.2500285208,
0.0355005413,
0.340763092,
-0.3994144499,
0.2853172421,
-0.559438467,
-0.3186620772,
-0.481192559,
-0.3091659248,
0.2568285763,
0.0816084594,
-0.4351339638,
0.1745838076,
-0.2968420386,
0.3092132509,
0.7280013561,
0.0208361447,
0.5585904121,
0.0520630404,
0.2078967392,
0.0354321599,
-0.59658283,
-0.5126549602,
1.3024927378,
0.3752942681,
0.7017862201,
0.2161166519,
0.6020947099,
0.2885601521,
0.5328133702,
-0.6722631454,
0.715759933,
0.0944400206,
-0.9003647566,
-0.417383194,
-0.0471857674,
-0.5906026959,
0.1896360666,
-0.0775738955,
-0.9384980798,
0.2608267367,
0.3633118868,
-0.0088606812,
0.2700425386,
-0.7759289742,
0.5462795496,
-0.227495268,
-0.0415045954,
-0.6628193259,
-0.4684191942,
0.673199892,
-0.2445201576,
0.0904819667,
0.0831067488,
0.2044005245,
0.8042008877,
-0.3303473592,
0.8572906852,
-0.2649659812,
-0.4553480744,
0.2850156724,
0.2762388289,
0.7605109215,
-0.2223220319,
-0.2076515555,
-0.0091139255,
0.0501853786,
-0.5367122889,
-1.0363563299,
0.4433107674,
-0.476450175,
-1.0689417124,
-0.3854682744,
-0.5486162901,
-0.331107825,
0.2558571994,
0.2540401816,
0.2035706192,
0.023924198,
0.4221159518,
0.8033762574,
0.1464117318,
0.2298954278,
0.4931087494,
-0.4220131636,
-0.1523215175,
0.642899394,
0.0435840972,
0.5825992227,
-0.030415155,
-0.0222966745,
0.1156808138,
-0.5331236124,
-0.0381136872,
0.1140446663,
-0.9338886142,
0.3189269602,
-0.3356487751,
0.3150499761,
-0.081543915,
-0.4829837084,
-0.5200261474,
-0.2415038645,
0.1017945632,
0.0065555521,
0.1598965228,
0.8537811637,
0.1003324613,
0.2786443233,
-0.1591307521,
0.238666594,
0.373496294,
0.1817463338,
0.4285090268,
-0.5543859005,
-0.0891684294,
0.4140259922,
-0.2603005767,
-0.5861778259,
-0.0907610059,
-0.1306887865,
0.3830406964,
0.6863678694,
-0.0049051461,
0.6741458774,
-0.2571436465,
0.5397676229,
0.4747137129,
-0.9084442258,
0.3950343728,
-0.7708021998,
0.0851545259,
0.2998771966,
0.3942608833,
-0.523337543,
-0.5893204212,
-0.7731319666,
-0.1457550079,
0.531891644,
0.0566677004,
0.1985813975,
-0.3528499007,
0.2884213924,
0.2133850753,
0.3177455664,
-0.6394095421,
-0.4534485638,
0.1294372082,
-0.218610391,
-0.3228263259,
-0.1629538238,
-0.3754962087,
-0.3416588008,
0.4390256703,
-0.3946872056,
0.5056936741,
0.3370525837,
0.1407556534,
-0.4014318883,
0.3432537913,
0.6760057807,
1.107676506,
-0.3700897396,
0.20264256,
0.1241538972,
-0.1636761874,
0.2378375679,
-0.1575972438,
-0.2175239027,
-0.2330766916,
0.6850811839,
0.5935444832,
0.2269005775,
-0.5228057504,
0.4477574527,
0.1098486111,
-0.5389023423,
-0.5957226753,
0.2266280651,
0.0914317816,
0.2726627588,
0.9663789868,
0.4372780323,
-0.0376175344,
-1.1567159891,
-0.036634583,
0.5754836202,
-0.1468538493,
-0.5923215151,
0.7822780013,
-0.0710096806,
-0.352514863,
0.426499337,
-0.281686902,
-0.5829221606,
0.6835394502,
0.5620346665,
0.9173458219,
-0.0157944206,
-0.1206559688,
-0.1688875407,
0.2665621936,
-0.5167316794,
0.3879629672,
0.023234399,
-1.0578312874,
-0.3736636639,
-0.2684206665,
-0.4419132471,
-0.0617202111,
-0.4632638395,
0.2065785676,
-0.5615398884,
-0.0392876528,
-0.0467381626,
-0.1301817745,
-0.8822265863,
0.5187535286,
0.2051393688,
0.8234045506,
-0.8443318009,
0.9248945713,
0.7533304691,
-0.3557727039,
-0.8900711536,
0.2258541435,
0.0705160871,
-0.9564909339,
0.8132664561,
0.1506472677,
-0.082217209,
-0.052160278,
-0.7348258495,
-0.9790266752,
1.0567561388,
0.4675288796,
-0.587580502,
-0.0407269336,
-0.0202822164,
0.6862082481,
-0.6043499112,
0.2788080573,
0.4669737518,
0.7165856361,
-0.0777678788,
-1.1943494081,
0.2778092325,
0.1880178452,
-0.2055000812,
-0.0688869059,
-0.6236594915,
1.0787100792,
-0.3674889803,
-0.0296805743,
0.1817836016,
0.6049476862,
0.4408096373,
0.6606257558,
0.7135785222,
0.6069098711,
0.8962074518,
-0.067426689,
1.529483676,
-0.0897703841,
0.2860451341,
0.7297639847,
-0.3723282814,
0.7641165853,
0.5534425378,
-0.5902171135,
0.295647651,
0.324434787,
0.2075895667,
0.3690981269,
0.0891331062,
0.1243602484,
-0.451451689,
0.0466529988,
-0.0980598107,
0.500916779,
0.2941644192,
-0.3865458369,
0.2132500559,
0.0545728803,
0.1480430216,
0.1615577936,
-0.4340098798,
0.1731340438,
0.3103135526,
-0.9458891153,
0.8454312682,
-0.1776824296,
0.7371763587,
-0.2418536395,
-0.0042205495,
-0.1445527226,
0.4722885191,
-0.090139702,
-0.645593226,
0.117143631,
-0.3874227703,
-0.3209045231,
-0.2944996357,
0.7186598182,
-0.0357304662,
-0.2721193731,
0.2725810707,
0.6577422023,
0.2306805551,
-0.3864477873,
-0.3871216178,
-0.0129801678,
0.3065306842,
-0.5609520078,
0.2556081414,
0.6112744808,
-0.1050406173,
1.0542789698,
0.4531776905,
0.0573370457,
-0.2685575485,
-0.3917734623,
0.5708839893,
-1.0530388355,
-0.428480804,
-0.9868976474,
0.158450529,
0.1137662679,
-0.2394350618,
0.8766037822,
0.0907911658,
0.7101122737,
-0.1712585539,
0.889062047,
-0.2502850592,
0.5836005211,
-0.3595047295,
0.6225667,
-0.8217089772,
0.1588967443,
-0.3956471682,
-1.1633318663,
-0.1845738888,
0.4427628517,
-0.4339575171,
0.0468617342,
1.1216011047,
0.2937170267,
0.0780795962,
0.2442477793,
0.5428363681,
0.5101401806,
0.280377537,
0.6963565946,
0.8844057918,
-0.2512360811,
0.2057708055,
-0.0911571831,
-0.313070029,
-0.2910630107,
-0.8432747126,
-0.8251114488,
-0.6125197411,
-0.2228802443,
-0.245243445,
0.1281684488,
1.0266752243,
0.499820888,
-0.6880759001,
-0.0340592191,
-0.4058856964,
0.1716723591,
-0.3945949376,
-0.1641879976,
0.0636874959,
-0.1740297973,
-0.7825814486,
0.3777679503,
0.2120421976,
-0.0846676826,
-0.3188785613,
-0.2116785794,
-0.0098966556,
0.2810279131,
0.3699576557,
0.3761644363,
-1.2900149822,
-0.8112644553,
-0.1704451889,
-0.1656918526,
-0.195905745,
0.6650928855,
-0.6752135754,
0.008835868,
0.1101308763,
0.5333070755,
0.0723136514,
-0.1273534596,
0.8781565428,
-0.0565754957,
0.0806263983,
0.027683381,
0.6052517295,
0.107706964,
-0.2432141602,
0.5721716285,
0.5379624963,
-0.4776045382,
-0.9485782981,
0.2830739319,
-0.8473105431,
-0.1807649136,
0.9674187899,
-0.0915810168,
-0.3764052987,
0.0764728487,
0.0047346391,
-0.0764937401,
-0.385204196,
0.9862216711,
1.1243237257,
-0.361718744,
0.0749743581,
-0.7098135948,
0.3398189545,
0.9365183711,
-0.1658765525,
0.1552423984,
0.3738768399,
0.2449550331,
0.5533719063,
0.7271665931,
0.4334042072,
0.2923151553,
0.200374037,
0.1109005809,
0.2576961517,
-0.0080857212,
-0.1736671329,
-0.0038041503,
0.5667002797,
0.0562301911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08387v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08387v2 | LEALLA: Learning Lightweight Language-agnostic Sentence Embeddings with Knowledge Distillation | 2023-02-16T16:05:34 | 2023-12-26T08:11:37 | Zhuoyuan Mao, Tetsuji Nakagawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale language-agnostic sentence embedding models such as LaBSE (Feng
et al., 2022) obtain state-of-the-art performance for parallel sentence
alignment. However, these large-scale models can suffer from inference speed
and computation overhead. This study systematically explores learning
language-agnostic sentence embeddings with lightweight models. We demonstrate
that a thin-deep encoder can construct robust low-dimensional sentence
embeddings for 109 languages. With our proposed distillation methods, we
achieve further improvements by incorporating knowledge from a teacher model.
Empirical results on Tatoeba, United Nations, and BUCC show the effectiveness
of our lightweight models. We release our lightweight language-agnostic
sentence embedding models LEALLA on TensorFlow Hub. | [
0.1371991783,
-0.91846627,
0.9159495831,
-0.0153184384,
0.0608303696,
0.0997744128,
-0.4375626743,
-0.2215383798,
0.1125277728,
0.1707197577,
-0.2666700482,
-0.289555341,
-0.7320352197,
-0.0893885195,
-0.5081185102,
0.8957321644,
-0.113541998,
0.2739013433,
-0.2575707734,
-0.4296536744,
-0.3575428128,
0.0539858006,
-0.3169128597,
-0.0863380507,
0.3510329425,
0.4628115296,
0.9324226975,
0.578592658,
0.1013224274,
0.3377552927,
-0.1005916074,
0.1464186907,
-0.4218755066,
0.298687607,
-0.2047273368,
-0.4822358489,
-0.0492940582,
-0.2468016446,
0.3561432362,
0.8793522716,
-0.2359019667,
0.1548638344,
0.0553397723,
0.6931069493,
-0.8956231475,
-0.1773745716,
-0.8850575686,
0.1698675007,
-0.1236448213,
0.503670752,
-0.4874681234,
-0.4298348129,
0.366125077,
-0.4597313106,
0.000195682,
0.1531908065,
0.7380018234,
0.5084370375,
-0.4645431042,
-0.5973200798,
-0.4182193577,
0.7887909412,
-0.6105810404,
0.439475894,
0.3046805561,
0.3483372033,
0.2397674769,
-0.8736427426,
-0.4422185719,
-0.3170864284,
-0.0814428627,
-0.168974787,
-0.1085370257,
0.0040413444,
-0.0108164558,
0.4954513311,
-0.5530938506,
0.2632935345,
-0.1262017339,
0.0213197563,
0.2747538686,
0.0263648294,
0.4038765132,
0.0966241956,
-0.4085738659,
0.1794674993,
-0.754240334,
-0.0062124413,
0.363235265,
0.1899220794,
-0.2834441364,
0.5183770061,
-0.135246709,
0.6380407214,
0.0637453869,
-0.1196687073,
0.1494641751,
-0.2183711231,
-0.1750422269,
0.1663269699,
0.9579707384,
-0.0050524408,
0.3511456549,
-0.5372186899,
-0.1650702804,
0.003758627,
-0.1030623168,
-1.0003256798,
-0.2110237032,
0.03928449,
-0.3418536186,
-0.3709211349,
-0.0569851846,
-0.6780436039,
-0.5691161752,
-0.0377473831,
0.439746052,
-0.4623638093,
0.0031245369,
0.3458435833,
-0.0584825687,
-0.1112350002,
0.1792032421,
-1.1355743408,
0.3847020864,
0.4005047381,
0.944619298,
0.043049518,
-0.4874839783,
-0.7511565089,
0.031636443,
-0.1388935,
0.1823199838,
-0.2788046598,
0.120199196,
0.0953063518,
-0.0678416044,
0.0530569069,
-0.2626764178,
0.5472667217,
-0.35647735,
0.0768643767,
-0.2886660993,
-0.7847058773,
-0.0399704538,
0.044399377,
-0.6849822402,
0.7420940995,
0.0028334721,
-0.751241684,
0.3409952521,
-0.1819709539,
-0.5529361963,
-0.1143796444,
-0.1624984592,
-0.3809231818,
0.2879104316,
0.3325741589,
0.6587176323,
-0.3995016813,
0.6927394867,
-0.3520555198,
-0.2640084624,
0.187426433,
-0.6007936597,
1.0196433067,
0.4272902906,
-0.4093039334,
-0.2169054002,
-0.4833602905,
-0.3117352724,
0.0753460377,
-0.0142621864,
-0.3726809025,
-0.114984341,
0.1703246832,
-0.210454151,
0.4660895169,
-0.7216377854,
0.2835073471,
-0.1189887896,
0.866165638,
0.5238292217,
-0.2192402929,
0.7204610109,
-0.0663614199,
0.3715090156,
0.018555114,
-0.0288002696,
-0.1809399128,
-0.2868490219,
-0.8040198088,
-0.2478260696,
0.3616480529,
0.406145364,
-0.8727074265,
0.3229215145,
-0.2917247117,
-0.4013119042,
-0.7909378409,
0.5799762011,
0.3061510921,
0.5830449462,
0.4565137029,
0.4049609601,
-0.5260679722,
-0.7789978385,
-0.2111680955,
0.0275755562,
0.337483108,
-0.0851359069,
0.5189218521,
-0.1996000111,
0.8047695756,
-0.7190572619,
-0.2665728331,
-0.4875086546,
-0.0340770632,
0.016956849,
0.3152610064,
0.7339570522,
-0.6702183485,
-0.8004412055,
-0.0361533388,
-0.9087811708,
0.1002801135,
-0.0953533128,
0.0710007101,
0.092712909,
0.7502503395,
-0.6894286275,
0.097959578,
0.635863781,
-0.3226512372,
0.1173880994,
-0.3804401755,
-0.1567413211,
-1.2974114418,
-0.1793390214,
0.0534374677,
-0.478903383,
-0.4861230552,
0.1651195139,
0.3012563288,
-0.0106022647,
-0.4205338955,
0.4490854144,
-0.6083106399,
0.2080846131,
-0.24435094,
0.1474487036,
0.3904882669,
0.2181847095,
0.1499395669,
0.6227223277,
0.7029518485,
-0.1672127694,
0.3269388676,
0.1027991325,
-0.6923215389,
0.1510309875,
-0.7207120061,
-0.0569311827,
-0.1605109423,
0.1537489295,
-0.7849659324,
0.0319244862,
-0.2772384882,
-0.0150089227,
0.1715099216,
-0.0525790714,
-0.4894640446,
-0.1139077172,
-0.3346912265,
0.2834701538,
0.6972436309,
-0.6952636242,
0.4768100083,
0.3972213566,
0.0605640635,
-0.8477817774,
-1.130620122,
-0.0618029274,
-0.3249675632,
-0.3946228027,
0.1723351926,
0.0685670525,
-0.3719937801,
0.2021547258,
0.1349278539,
-0.169139415,
0.1996058822,
0.1461876631,
0.0733711347,
-0.2938390374,
0.2552526593,
0.1934583485,
0.2322715968,
-0.3779883385,
-0.3323830366,
0.3771792054,
-0.413738966,
-0.2091544867,
-0.2597059906,
0.0898248479,
0.5790461302,
-0.0714415684,
1.0230025053,
0.7792538404,
-0.3981569409,
-0.457660228,
-0.6592888236,
-0.1107992232,
-0.5084105134,
0.2499837577,
-0.2423187047,
-1.1795173883,
0.4663259089,
0.0064258561,
-0.1617582887,
0.2140327841,
0.4440985322,
0.0926731303,
0.4271980524,
0.790674746,
-0.4020080566,
0.1985125691,
-0.2451482564,
0.2160235792,
-0.3711345792,
0.0522208437,
-0.4627121687,
-0.3684579134,
-0.3319703341,
-0.4535838962,
0.1273881197,
0.2654622793,
-0.3274146616,
0.458527118,
-0.2112100571,
0.64738518,
0.3100988269,
0.026491778,
0.2486107349,
-0.2963068783,
-0.2742405236,
-0.0806880593,
-0.7147145271,
-0.3089458048,
1.0268055201,
0.3511120677,
1.009773016,
0.1098484844,
0.7704940438,
0.2550265491,
-0.1789033115,
-0.7233911753,
0.2972539663,
-0.4963103831,
-0.3628433943,
-0.2731446028,
-0.4233942628,
-0.4595120549,
0.0545687117,
-0.1054238304,
-0.7989606857,
0.1617513895,
-0.2245160341,
-0.4801336825,
0.3965650201,
-0.8816080689,
1.0660501719,
-0.4149132669,
-0.4405566156,
-0.0464063622,
-0.4066438079,
0.364533484,
-0.055789005,
0.2896798551,
-0.1959301084,
-0.1536916643,
0.340182811,
-0.6851297021,
0.9275378585,
-0.2680604458,
-0.19955042,
0.3476596475,
0.112405695,
0.5509229302,
0.4393720925,
-0.1267523319,
-0.1524406821,
-0.2190858424,
-0.1953078955,
-0.7003307343,
0.9331067204,
-0.8505694866,
-0.427559942,
-0.1660774052,
-0.6867694855,
-0.1722870767,
0.1479327381,
0.3060800433,
0.3217837512,
-0.2477010787,
0.6091347337,
0.7347869873,
-0.0839209929,
0.7722274661,
0.3891188204,
-0.2112315744,
-0.3629684448,
0.7407296896,
0.109308809,
0.0911725461,
0.7650895119,
0.2834539413,
-0.3922531605,
-0.5083474517,
-0.5940394998,
-0.1123917997,
-0.6893962622,
-0.2627261579,
-0.8412251472,
0.0494015515,
-0.4291030467,
-0.529327631,
-0.6467633247,
-0.6565811038,
-0.1341657788,
-0.2794083953,
0.6464936733,
0.7170737982,
0.1529084146,
0.2856090367,
-0.5970572829,
0.3608634174,
0.2430384457,
-0.0221228655,
0.153694734,
-0.3912298977,
-0.4680914879,
0.0347489156,
-0.1072523519,
-0.654671669,
0.0733448565,
0.6092919707,
0.5060895085,
0.4952026308,
0.2837603092,
0.6208632588,
-0.7645965219,
0.764423728,
0.2621566951,
-1.2536356449,
0.4945952892,
-0.1493929625,
0.4146822393,
1.0837104321,
0.5625411868,
-0.245607838,
-0.4083859026,
-0.1805147082,
-0.6546521783,
0.2528335154,
-0.0369357131,
0.25973019,
0.0378834642,
0.3130587935,
0.3689567745,
0.2462022156,
-0.9778442383,
-0.0535949543,
-0.1191233993,
-0.7065888047,
-0.1790006012,
-0.1644814461,
0.1527737975,
-0.2452418953,
0.4932969511,
-0.2541048825,
-0.445697397,
-0.0794885308,
-0.6866417527,
0.1691060811,
0.1918247789,
0.270601809,
0.2938407958,
-0.05528697,
0.2828013301,
0.3087711036,
-0.4781034291,
0.4488025308,
0.0412383042,
-0.3688723445,
-0.0584521778,
0.3822374046,
0.8763949871,
0.4633518159,
-0.7491129041,
0.7867470384,
-0.0421084948,
-0.1935761273,
-0.2170473933,
-0.1293044835,
0.4459262192,
0.4492296576,
0.2178410292,
-0.0874794349,
0.3422493041,
-0.6148158312,
0.3217258155,
0.3908077776,
-0.3133020103,
-0.191137895,
0.9232917428,
0.0445381775,
0.2978460193,
0.4492800832,
-0.1768764257,
-0.196796298,
0.366658777,
0.2716571987,
0.9482555985,
-0.1106957644,
0.4186381698,
0.222023055,
0.3381868899,
-0.3829300702,
0.0472686514,
-0.2389418483,
-0.7177202702,
-0.3830615878,
-0.842667222,
-0.3418630064,
-0.1487992853,
-0.663403511,
0.3324158192,
-0.3340879083,
0.0837509111,
0.0043560374,
0.0023337957,
-0.6543639302,
-0.2486283034,
0.2396446019,
0.8732965589,
-1.039945364,
1.2687284946,
0.4827443957,
-0.500600636,
-0.7830931544,
0.100461565,
-0.0085379686,
-0.6745641232,
0.7216671109,
0.3340332806,
-0.122801885,
-0.0612017959,
-0.1820566505,
-0.7009233236,
1.43854177,
0.9365594983,
-0.8143203259,
-0.2013512105,
0.2110377252,
0.5168819427,
-0.4701220393,
0.2301481664,
0.2252073139,
0.068684943,
-0.1161019951,
-0.7921798825,
0.1808173656,
0.0255232286,
0.2015075237,
-0.1707638651,
-0.7466881871,
1.0257226229,
-0.152156055,
0.095095247,
0.172575444,
0.8847617507,
0.0867817029,
0.0791533887,
0.3343147933,
0.9389517903,
0.8971927166,
0.0000439034,
0.6052157879,
-0.3924266696,
0.3387429416,
1.3292979002,
-0.5055274367,
0.8488319516,
0.4417391419,
-0.0222601108,
0.8440893888,
0.1562454849,
0.1048691943,
0.8115388751,
0.0820024535,
-0.2371905893,
0.0128538953,
-0.0950594023,
-0.2476779372,
0.51691854,
0.2308915555,
-0.3706825972,
-0.4249984324,
0.4085930586,
0.2362352759,
0.3476257324,
-0.1744086891,
0.6155324578,
0.2781575024,
-0.5486496091,
0.5342259407,
-0.0062393439,
0.9815898538,
-0.4153270125,
0.1760783941,
-0.2554041147,
0.4593042731,
-0.0225339197,
-0.5509636998,
0.1712676883,
0.2012700886,
-0.1653763503,
-0.4408888817,
0.6840051413,
-0.6714974642,
-0.4246647656,
0.3570254743,
0.7493217587,
-0.1986976266,
0.2398191392,
-0.6020988822,
0.220926404,
-0.1401612014,
-0.3029111028,
0.4388359785,
0.8011800051,
0.2868379653,
0.5649859905,
0.1286875606,
-0.095951058,
0.0996136963,
0.1191886663,
0.6781134009,
-0.2598582506,
-0.4981954396,
-1.0867327452,
0.5252879858,
0.0483766869,
-0.1604901552,
0.938957274,
0.6154530644,
0.5680729747,
-0.1719686538,
0.7612909079,
-0.1304985732,
0.0673882291,
-0.8225154877,
0.9729164243,
-0.6047458649,
0.049972944,
-0.131081447,
-0.8088331223,
0.0900884047,
0.4809021056,
-0.1909239143,
-0.2083228379,
0.8753883243,
0.4484950602,
-0.1748951524,
0.0461994074,
0.3047516346,
0.1345022172,
0.0462062918,
0.743209362,
0.5570678115,
-0.5291217566,
0.4232980609,
-0.3651020825,
0.2042934746,
-0.1269254386,
-1.0060852766,
-1.0307263136,
-0.7227672338,
-0.3049481511,
-0.0913309604,
0.1304402649,
0.6543511748,
0.6151368022,
-0.6721916795,
-0.199670136,
-0.611589551,
0.0544520877,
0.0027467536,
-0.1899831444,
0.3454081416,
-0.6516901255,
-0.8281227946,
0.6161398888,
0.0071329381,
0.0450538844,
-0.4047052562,
-0.1528803855,
-0.3839078546,
-0.2648107409,
0.2642118335,
0.0951747671,
-0.6154965162,
-0.0730771571,
-0.0338048935,
-0.3459020853,
-0.4449016154,
0.712678194,
-0.7523647547,
0.188845858,
0.4663730562,
0.9830691218,
0.448797375,
-0.418938607,
0.6065333486,
-0.9590680599,
0.7097270489,
0.0564393252,
0.8637644053,
0.3725805879,
-0.368252635,
0.5012440085,
0.0401020013,
-0.5044881105,
-0.8915987015,
0.1212283298,
-0.7112805843,
-0.5085677505,
0.9828523993,
-0.510658145,
-0.1139365584,
0.1628768593,
0.1450593323,
0.1296413988,
-0.2047706842,
0.405544579,
0.7579169869,
0.4242236912,
-0.4082595408,
-0.648147583,
0.5090447068,
0.4373805225,
-0.5590745807,
-0.0594512708,
0.3723810315,
0.270090431,
0.1299453527,
0.4696795344,
0.1585737616,
0.0899273679,
0.2580530643,
-0.1226709187,
-0.2350633591,
-0.4160326421,
-0.180709064,
0.272573024,
0.1822089255,
0.1008208767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10314v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10314v1 | Dynamic Named Entity Recognition | 2023-02-16T15:50:02 | 2023-02-16T15:50:02 | Tristan Luiggi, Laure Soulier, Vincent Guigue, Siwar Jendoubi, Aurélien Baelde | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a challenging and widely studied task that
involves detecting and typing entities in text. So far,NER still approaches
entity typing as a task of classification into universal classes (e.g. date,
person, or location). Recent advances innatural language processing focus on
architectures of increasing complexity that may lead to overfitting and
memorization, and thus, underuse of context. Our work targets situations where
the type of entities depends on the context and cannot be solved solely by
memorization. We hence introduce a new task: Dynamic Named Entity Recognition
(DNER), providing a framework to better evaluate the ability of algorithms to
extract entities by exploiting the context. The DNER benchmark is based on two
datasets, DNER-RotoWire and DNER-IMDb. We evaluate baseline models and present
experiments reflecting issues and research axes related to this novel task. | [
-0.3818003833,
-0.8325478435,
0.6246107221,
-0.028599456,
-0.0086765857,
0.6250426769,
-0.0202460177,
-0.8599999547,
0.1365235299,
0.2255831063,
-0.3391903341,
-0.1255043,
-0.7024594545,
0.5151166916,
-0.6708183885,
0.6461421251,
-0.4073871374,
-0.1912136227,
-0.1374546289,
-0.2103669643,
-0.5668686032,
-0.4811086059,
-0.7898316383,
-0.1503139734,
0.5746781826,
0.482886374,
0.3494147062,
0.6700835824,
0.7984446287,
0.4314448535,
-0.299600929,
-0.1392302215,
-0.2803651094,
0.6403999925,
-0.1515408009,
-0.1609187424,
-0.1729142368,
-0.1224340424,
0.9416341782,
0.4974624813,
-0.1906625777,
0.190352574,
-0.3550374806,
0.5035585761,
-0.5612465143,
0.2818630338,
-0.7935217023,
0.1126607358,
-0.5208831429,
-0.1786143333,
-0.1002757102,
-0.2370300293,
0.4204126,
-0.428940475,
0.2140280753,
0.0989499614,
0.8712949753,
0.5965765119,
-0.5497123003,
-0.7045063376,
-1.0376013517,
0.4055345356,
-0.2042733282,
0.6947855949,
-0.0338788703,
0.4636555314,
-0.3354690671,
-0.913646102,
-0.9356844425,
-0.3214175701,
-0.1336805075,
-0.2960874438,
-0.2898645997,
-0.1407543719,
0.5697222948,
0.5319910049,
0.0346628465,
0.1859934628,
0.0566788651,
0.1440079957,
0.2816393971,
0.268004179,
0.4989373982,
-0.2022937834,
-0.444391042,
-0.1851814836,
-0.1985080689,
0.1024529189,
0.2410471737,
0.0444856435,
0.1599780768,
0.295401454,
-0.1756433696,
0.5209611058,
0.5055593252,
-0.230522573,
0.3820208013,
0.1580331326,
-0.1805504858,
0.4078074098,
0.3963199854,
0.0203982629,
0.0609457716,
-0.5247874856,
-0.4301363826,
-0.1528639495,
0.1760135889,
-0.8597632051,
-0.2726987898,
0.1127627194,
-0.2199619263,
-0.387364924,
0.0233511627,
-1.1331061125,
-0.4480143189,
-0.5170953274,
0.3937019408,
-0.3634306788,
-0.3891068399,
-0.3107423186,
-0.1443716586,
-0.0514658056,
0.4314157665,
-0.729837656,
0.4614050984,
0.545994699,
0.6014649868,
-0.3705280721,
-0.1092920378,
-0.5149731636,
0.1855842024,
0.0998625383,
0.7966643572,
-0.7669107318,
-0.1989347339,
-0.3150125146,
0.0593352765,
-0.23746939,
-0.6827530861,
0.2566555738,
-0.9217224717,
-0.1648568362,
-0.2544837594,
-0.7553742528,
-0.2043512613,
0.3615414202,
-1.0157287121,
1.1437228918,
0.3002623618,
-1.0257335901,
0.7656787038,
-0.5146220326,
-0.2577448189,
0.4768415093,
-0.5759516954,
-0.189306736,
0.1897685081,
-0.1133426875,
0.1892686784,
-0.2628929019,
0.5670025349,
0.0057143955,
-0.3843102157,
0.5337639451,
-0.4560484886,
0.1957889497,
-0.0512536615,
-0.5902761221,
-0.4240044355,
-1.3551204205,
-0.0419603735,
0.1984367967,
-0.6887682676,
-0.6553068161,
0.2917833924,
0.2320697457,
0.1600408703,
0.075144574,
-0.6583886743,
0.2199703902,
-0.1835525334,
0.5319079161,
0.3148851395,
0.0963667631,
0.4052218497,
0.1760721505,
0.4324660301,
0.0454300158,
-0.3774517179,
0.0336093642,
0.1779480577,
-0.8496963382,
-0.5024884939,
0.7828982472,
0.7414577603,
-0.7736951709,
0.0646787509,
-0.5406147838,
-0.3119413555,
-0.0472320616,
-0.2765115201,
0.3413625062,
0.664424479,
0.4403726757,
-0.1230892614,
-0.8019817472,
-0.70865798,
-0.1100056842,
-0.1201599911,
0.2306248248,
0.5798022151,
0.6695353985,
-0.4649654925,
0.9274486899,
-0.2882526517,
-0.2359516174,
-0.0692338124,
0.1922449172,
0.1138285622,
0.4075259566,
0.4801490307,
-1.1818243265,
-0.7347574234,
-0.2400687337,
-0.800929606,
0.1981496513,
-0.0630397871,
0.2150913775,
-0.0339387134,
0.8414532542,
-0.5089002252,
0.3576888144,
0.2077388167,
-0.0509579554,
0.2656689584,
-0.0612910055,
0.1701950431,
-0.6933498383,
0.1990496069,
-0.2049437463,
-0.2032884806,
-0.586488843,
-0.0418118536,
0.0875260234,
-0.0909567997,
-0.3167954385,
0.8836157322,
-0.8884521723,
0.0185028408,
-0.2435844839,
0.0565506257,
-0.2486252934,
0.1564026028,
-0.0207107048,
0.7919304967,
0.5125159025,
-0.7063791156,
0.3396666348,
0.2912977934,
-0.7129074335,
0.6281606555,
-0.5155898929,
0.2877965569,
-0.3944558203,
0.1830564439,
-0.7175556421,
-0.5080096722,
0.2484046519,
-0.1410646439,
0.879108727,
-0.3446586728,
-0.5642190576,
-0.428881079,
0.3579949439,
0.5898824334,
0.2298345715,
-0.5527018905,
0.7699918747,
0.6926708221,
0.0871583894,
-0.4845712483,
-0.5935721993,
0.2979950011,
-0.5019062757,
-0.1325950176,
0.9533990026,
0.2231437713,
-0.5080220103,
0.2477753162,
-0.6063592434,
-0.5015920401,
0.1571616083,
0.3498454094,
-0.069812052,
-0.0636289641,
0.2183599621,
-0.1840183586,
-0.323489666,
-0.1456549764,
0.2307201475,
0.3657111824,
0.0469223484,
-0.0581750199,
-0.537250936,
0.2355837077,
0.6606892347,
-0.2928845584,
0.5421773195,
0.3098191619,
-0.5555794239,
-0.0739451796,
-0.7398747802,
0.1426105499,
-0.4914093912,
0.3450584114,
-0.5995095372,
-0.7834393978,
0.4940078855,
-0.2867428064,
-0.2350149304,
0.2508897781,
0.2201090902,
-0.1187521219,
0.5609221458,
0.6639855504,
0.075953953,
0.7113640308,
-0.1672572494,
0.3844128549,
-0.9548957348,
-0.3534039855,
-0.3883302808,
-0.7079002261,
-0.6563186049,
-0.1758206934,
0.078484498,
0.1139946207,
0.1026824266,
0.6780883074,
-0.4903068841,
0.5930775404,
0.3386666179,
-0.0578292683,
0.155455187,
-0.0529087745,
-0.259971112,
-0.1878606826,
-0.1881723106,
-0.5311768055,
0.5988519192,
0.2547398806,
0.490680337,
0.1139783189,
0.8901277781,
0.3483495116,
0.2363858968,
-0.8334095478,
0.6777324677,
-0.2582907081,
-0.7222506404,
-0.2812860906,
-0.3437294662,
-0.9290214777,
0.1279026121,
-0.0405092165,
-0.9692000747,
0.6339155436,
0.2582443357,
-0.2453164607,
0.3400390148,
-0.1975693852,
0.5404073,
-0.3981136978,
-0.058812093,
0.0771107376,
-0.5459527969,
0.0291306451,
-0.1959210038,
0.1470784843,
-0.3842010498,
-0.0198107902,
0.5035518408,
0.1072939858,
0.4090152979,
-0.3172065318,
0.0962986276,
0.1759281605,
0.3433169723,
0.5850548744,
0.376349926,
-0.378819406,
0.0770281926,
-0.0213701166,
0.3379964232,
-0.551946342,
0.6997580528,
-0.307297498,
-0.3935024142,
-0.7984427214,
-0.3937629759,
-0.0179220997,
0.4160695672,
0.0959654748,
0.7543384433,
-0.5234413743,
0.3338738382,
0.7772631049,
-0.0305364411,
0.638197124,
0.696207583,
0.1709488183,
-0.4903369248,
0.731010735,
0.3027368188,
-0.2672276199,
0.9083050489,
-0.1899914145,
-0.2551626563,
-0.6817579865,
-0.609444797,
-0.0595036149,
-0.7348846793,
-0.1158751473,
-1.1109393835,
-0.189828217,
0.1198176071,
0.2311193347,
-0.3196551204,
-0.2577317059,
-0.407179296,
0.058031261,
0.2613337934,
0.5591093898,
0.3247717321,
0.085933879,
-0.6824451089,
0.3704800606,
0.2528468966,
0.4459484518,
0.0577577613,
-0.2525251806,
0.0363820009,
-0.2495908886,
-0.0074517801,
-0.9627175927,
0.161750555,
0.3343880177,
0.9271030426,
0.1007818729,
0.0412925892,
0.710857451,
-0.8425805569,
0.1919746399,
-0.235107109,
-0.8494915366,
0.4779247046,
-0.0491484106,
-0.0296634175,
1.0455832481,
0.4944117367,
-0.5444111228,
0.0557078756,
-0.5713472366,
-1.0399907827,
0.6472598314,
0.3045251369,
0.0739379004,
-0.2932273746,
0.7394051552,
-0.0183639973,
0.4035363793,
-0.5751858354,
-0.2491738945,
0.2532706261,
-0.2802604735,
0.0684010386,
-0.5424914956,
0.2705326378,
-0.345184654,
0.2039569914,
0.1912723035,
0.3312712908,
0.3116111457,
-0.5334990025,
0.1551915407,
0.271512717,
0.2593806982,
0.4600779712,
-0.2663825452,
0.1393882483,
0.2879447639,
-0.5083872676,
0.3333913386,
0.3620615602,
-0.4625669718,
0.1725223958,
0.2361758351,
0.8981822133,
0.8166656494,
-0.7656051517,
0.3026492,
-0.2642699182,
0.0522127338,
-0.6935210824,
0.3095153272,
-0.2959413826,
0.3935406506,
0.320759505,
0.0264686402,
0.322773695,
-0.4807748795,
0.3787508011,
0.2363131046,
-0.5695854425,
-0.3247522712,
0.5741403103,
0.057296522,
-0.5776276588,
0.8788776398,
-0.4473113716,
-0.6293282509,
0.7612082958,
0.4963541627,
0.9802683592,
-0.0808687508,
-0.0901337564,
0.5721538067,
-0.2020390928,
-0.2004022747,
0.2298397571,
-0.2204497606,
-0.6951594353,
0.1083596051,
-0.7847392559,
-0.4756059051,
0.1274561435,
-0.6908271909,
0.4347002804,
-0.4151802957,
-0.314671576,
0.4553695023,
-0.0942660198,
-0.8282414079,
0.2622787654,
0.1053419188,
0.7038258314,
-0.1922373772,
0.7686913013,
0.9474911094,
-0.3695279956,
-0.5402608514,
0.3390775025,
0.1120698154,
-0.3571082354,
1.2046960592,
0.5049350262,
0.0131696425,
0.4420182407,
-0.0109571768,
-1.4625823498,
1.1730144024,
-0.0202087723,
-0.7954606414,
-0.397710979,
-0.2000409216,
0.504545927,
-0.3061097264,
0.2318820357,
0.5556077957,
0.584664464,
0.1884259135,
-0.7976561785,
-0.0293581318,
-0.2565388381,
0.060988456,
0.6127973199,
-0.4707010686,
0.9257224798,
-0.0599883758,
-0.6991587877,
-0.1099296138,
0.5254412889,
-0.0061888611,
0.3475151062,
0.8568789959,
0.5801485777,
0.9451466203,
-0.1443345696,
0.7427200079,
-0.303961128,
0.1407922208,
1.3742374182,
-0.6547620296,
0.861009717,
0.4504922628,
-0.2474737316,
0.8325881362,
0.3618741333,
-0.435679853,
0.722994566,
0.429964155,
-0.3293592036,
0.1113453582,
0.0583555512,
-0.202584967,
0.8781098127,
0.3619242311,
-0.2268963903,
-0.2820473909,
0.0747088715,
-0.049601987,
-0.067352213,
0.064779751,
0.8786424398,
-0.1246369183,
-0.5723766685,
0.1609091461,
-0.0060993517,
0.6029904485,
-0.163837105,
-0.1037264243,
0.0154156145,
0.4810882211,
0.0668262094,
-0.4720648527,
0.3486980498,
0.0879682004,
-0.5003803968,
-0.2131536752,
0.7385303974,
-0.293539077,
-0.5334901214,
0.4379154444,
0.2585241199,
0.1176061705,
-0.0422442146,
-0.5935737491,
0.0111883571,
-0.3263248801,
-0.2493078262,
0.3450468779,
0.7501292825,
-0.0828032717,
0.8111335635,
0.4266210198,
-0.2553386688,
0.0528788865,
-0.0229560882,
0.7652873397,
-0.7901104689,
-0.3769322336,
-0.8491732478,
0.3010553122,
-0.03984477,
-0.3019730449,
0.6453868151,
0.5710991025,
0.7609558105,
0.1486963481,
0.3511992097,
-0.6321340203,
0.6734823585,
-0.2589433789,
0.4835408032,
-0.6625962257,
0.1313881874,
-0.4605406225,
-0.9216563702,
-0.1443946511,
0.4108602107,
-0.0102684284,
-0.1250349283,
0.6543232203,
0.3556008041,
-0.2048503011,
-0.181653291,
-0.043943584,
0.0263196062,
0.3889462948,
0.2608580887,
0.9769725204,
-0.4830665886,
0.3338434696,
-0.4279105961,
-0.0901510715,
-0.3700248599,
-1.1500021219,
-0.7312899828,
-0.4571632743,
-0.6246919036,
-0.0256742984,
0.0156214377,
0.8483474851,
0.4400154054,
-0.8637697101,
0.2203189582,
-0.2975883484,
0.0181813948,
-0.1745005697,
-0.2332754433,
0.23187913,
-0.1268758327,
-0.8997936249,
0.6792858243,
0.2400996685,
0.3904551566,
0.0294540692,
0.3500508666,
-0.1896015853,
-0.2152106315,
0.3352150321,
0.4008722305,
-0.6377244592,
-0.2337668836,
0.1961533874,
-0.1016827449,
0.0363825224,
0.867764473,
-0.9012488723,
0.3427730501,
0.615446806,
0.7561050653,
0.461581558,
-0.0677344725,
0.2308605164,
-0.4651784897,
0.072437413,
0.4132577181,
0.3044846058,
0.3180501163,
-0.4836273193,
0.4412679076,
0.2937932611,
-0.625067234,
-1.2044718266,
0.0649453029,
-0.7969585061,
0.0500123538,
0.8445854783,
0.042663604,
0.0395876467,
-0.2691352069,
0.0519304089,
0.340066582,
-0.3235126734,
0.6121495366,
0.646713376,
-0.2400582731,
-0.2267624587,
-0.6308096051,
0.499157548,
-0.1149390712,
-0.5467588902,
-0.1313668191,
0.3458057344,
0.6219217181,
0.1802709103,
0.6587816477,
0.0198644213,
-0.1493382901,
0.0360559002,
0.0393955708,
-0.1018193066,
-0.6442584395,
-0.0721220747,
0.1659882069,
-0.2172184587,
-0.0750709772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08374v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08374v3 | Efficiency 360: Efficient Vision Transformers | 2023-02-16T15:43:32 | 2023-02-23T19:36:20 | Badri N. Patro, Vijay Srinivas Agneeswaran | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers are widely used for solving tasks in natural language
processing, computer vision, speech, and music domains. In this paper, we talk
about the efficiency of transformers in terms of memory (the number of
parameters), computation cost (number of floating points operations), and
performance of models, including accuracy, the robustness of the model, and
fair \& bias-free features. We mainly discuss the vision transformer for the
image classification task. Our contribution is to introduce an efficient 360
framework, which includes various aspects of the vision transformer, to make it
more efficient for industrial applications. By considering those applications,
we categorize them into multiple dimensions such as privacy, robustness,
transparency, fairness, inclusiveness, continual learning, probabilistic
models, approximation, computational complexity, and spectral complexity. We
compare various vision transformer models based on their performance, the
number of parameters, and the number of floating point operations (FLOPs) on
multiple datasets. | [
-0.6507080197,
-0.2490058243,
0.5064316988,
0.3824456036,
0.0789806992,
-0.2576013803,
0.0645969063,
-0.5563090444,
-0.4724402428,
0.4633319378,
-0.240597114,
-0.2693215311,
-0.5837722421,
-0.1569673717,
-0.6719739437,
0.4361222386,
0.0095865699,
0.0567803793,
-0.1585610807,
-0.3909340501,
-0.2295439094,
-0.48714149,
-0.4115745425,
-0.1987973154,
0.3465459645,
0.3555025756,
1.0124896765,
0.5273797512,
1.1360441446,
0.5479480028,
0.3894751966,
-0.1226246953,
-0.2951607704,
0.1061201543,
-0.2388045937,
-0.5681390166,
-0.4160981178,
-0.0339652225,
0.4162749052,
0.59309268,
-0.0493848547,
0.3974705935,
-0.0760855898,
1.1044996977,
-0.8773591518,
0.4484570622,
-0.5008208156,
0.3472158313,
-0.1049838439,
-0.0118188672,
-0.4363791049,
-0.4256117344,
0.1184173971,
-0.8576375842,
0.6596341133,
0.1416516453,
0.7580040097,
0.5062873363,
0.0699990392,
-0.006716304,
-1.0034244061,
0.8743087053,
-0.1371978521,
0.8472624421,
-0.1012586206,
0.7964094281,
0.3953095675,
-0.8451446891,
-0.7385426164,
0.2560513914,
-0.0365181677,
0.3701512516,
-0.7427824736,
0.3188061416,
0.4951745272,
0.6901484132,
-0.3436762989,
-0.0312564448,
-0.4627512991,
-0.2298080325,
0.5128401518,
0.2332805842,
-0.0347583517,
-0.1896050423,
-0.3244412243,
-0.5709947348,
-0.0259334594,
0.277287215,
0.5356771946,
-0.2249420583,
0.1014701203,
0.710488677,
-0.2402290553,
0.7942147851,
0.2231879979,
-0.5246052146,
0.1107191592,
-0.1275667697,
-0.1571738869,
-0.5513220429,
0.3414262533,
0.6514465809,
0.2441572696,
-0.3836328983,
-0.4094384909,
0.5485877991,
0.8953885436,
-0.6204894185,
-0.4113892615,
-0.1242241263,
-0.6691688299,
-0.0995376036,
0.1106472537,
-0.8662155271,
0.0570672266,
-0.4081361294,
0.6805070639,
-0.4015904665,
0.0253638085,
0.1339559257,
-0.3208858073,
0.6126216054,
0.468762517,
-0.5375727415,
0.2451916635,
0.8997965455,
0.9259180427,
-0.3699706495,
0.1832718998,
-0.2999888659,
-0.074747771,
-0.1677964479,
0.7434339523,
-0.332434386,
-0.3368407786,
0.012675168,
0.0416822024,
-0.1928638518,
-0.7675961256,
0.5418319106,
-0.7107091546,
-0.0340406485,
-0.0218725018,
-0.2884040773,
-0.7388643026,
-0.0469783209,
-1.1667835712,
0.9215388894,
0.3350343704,
-0.5544264913,
0.5218185186,
-1.1045508385,
-0.3561413288,
0.4519926012,
0.1130731404,
-0.4887682498,
0.2850341201,
0.0861378089,
0.636764586,
-0.0187869631,
-0.0446681567,
0.1729052216,
-0.4759270251,
0.0007685457,
-0.5622157454,
0.5450250506,
0.3718520105,
-0.4167343378,
0.0828473344,
-0.574800849,
-0.1202556491,
-0.1810980588,
-0.3482077718,
0.1234637797,
-0.1484395415,
0.3555653989,
0.1031718776,
0.0170855802,
-0.7023053169,
-0.1767886728,
-0.2539032996,
0.1832208335,
0.4794232547,
-0.3643057346,
0.7944595218,
-0.3628918827,
0.5830572844,
0.1048760563,
0.6725324988,
-0.2447354645,
-0.7844232321,
-1.1920382977,
-0.6739903092,
0.0727359653,
0.7905185223,
-0.8884260654,
0.4463115036,
-0.2364151776,
-0.7771270275,
-0.6631848812,
0.0611452833,
0.1531946063,
0.411308974,
0.3983210027,
-0.4801183939,
-0.3876832128,
-1.2811948061,
-0.3547621369,
0.0119244577,
-0.1734398007,
0.0690344498,
0.2149144858,
-0.2531341314,
0.9473038316,
-0.5036000609,
-0.135856688,
-0.2441913188,
-0.228595525,
0.3264267743,
0.3808745146,
0.7136927843,
-1.0371626616,
-0.5423091054,
-0.0157894343,
-0.7971374989,
0.2049043775,
0.0147875221,
-0.278036952,
0.5389140248,
0.124577783,
-0.6796432734,
0.9275813699,
0.5105719566,
0.0011253587,
0.2148560435,
-0.1083406284,
0.1452645063,
-0.3418588638,
0.0142347002,
0.4585852027,
-0.4147704244,
-0.9484304786,
0.0942130163,
0.2380351573,
-0.2116696388,
-0.5641911626,
-0.064507626,
-0.1384657472,
-0.0288803596,
-0.1913481206,
-0.1136249974,
0.1567186713,
0.7240852118,
0.0346800722,
0.7092619538,
0.6702124476,
-0.7613304257,
0.464687109,
-0.0498137064,
-0.5497964621,
0.894174099,
-0.520694077,
-0.0037966904,
-0.4124785364,
-0.1717277914,
-0.7939403057,
-0.0115042794,
0.1555930972,
-0.0312944055,
0.0729820728,
0.2686845064,
-0.4987549484,
-0.5720812082,
-0.2367661446,
0.3149489164,
0.71397686,
-0.9291615486,
0.9210457206,
0.3976721168,
0.4838848114,
-0.5219195485,
-0.6359273791,
-0.254861027,
-0.4165157974,
-0.7619289756,
0.4105854034,
0.1863728911,
-0.2749048769,
-0.1239810064,
-0.0819468126,
0.184026733,
-0.14147304,
0.4790349305,
0.3833908737,
-0.0915043056,
-0.0919499248,
-0.1952711791,
-0.4272345901,
0.062286824,
-0.1480343044,
0.3800257146,
-0.705450356,
-0.4796075523,
-0.7353655696,
0.5252446532,
0.6183348298,
0.0843497589,
0.576135695,
0.7636426687,
-0.410969764,
0.0551745109,
-0.926952064,
0.0806360841,
-0.5835374594,
0.5400786996,
-0.4277969599,
-0.5131536126,
0.5538964868,
0.0183320269,
0.2481755465,
0.8148930669,
0.4557675123,
-0.0623920374,
0.9933203459,
0.8062874079,
0.1718240082,
0.4492601454,
-0.5685563684,
0.7414656878,
-0.5849748254,
-0.495028764,
-0.3224389255,
-0.5982919931,
-0.7585499287,
-0.6448762417,
0.6343913078,
-0.053793136,
-0.2872784138,
0.5651505589,
-0.781919539,
0.3421016037,
0.9570471048,
0.2193544954,
0.4086654484,
0.0256122556,
0.3392549157,
-0.0588543341,
-0.8991117477,
-0.5914403796,
0.6410204768,
0.4627227783,
0.875007391,
-0.0235524345,
0.141475901,
0.149254024,
0.2173937857,
-1.0144828558,
0.5317127109,
-0.2658891082,
-0.5121306777,
-0.1297136843,
-0.1156509519,
-0.5142408609,
0.1866455823,
-0.2718250751,
-0.3884889483,
0.5469555259,
0.2993473709,
-0.1161930189,
0.6655339599,
-0.9365825653,
0.6578007936,
-0.3075429499,
-0.2757652402,
-0.2713965774,
-0.3629582822,
0.1788462251,
-0.1654733866,
-0.0992831141,
0.1873850375,
-0.0469743423,
0.806424737,
-0.2350603938,
0.4652366042,
-0.5479862094,
0.329474628,
0.4355113506,
-0.2815946341,
-0.0412819535,
-0.0600991361,
-0.2534735501,
0.710920155,
-0.0849333853,
-0.2276053727,
-0.7339960933,
0.3612320125,
-0.5657681227,
-0.4019057453,
-0.3907154799,
-0.6593356133,
-0.0322039612,
-0.0018108516,
0.5546097159,
0.3242827654,
0.2297559381,
0.419913739,
0.4313171208,
-0.2717369795,
0.694431901,
0.0223617274,
-0.103630431,
-0.0029986273,
0.7826671004,
0.3364917636,
0.2161194384,
0.1280025691,
-0.3117776811,
-0.3158566356,
-0.1595153064,
-0.4293902516,
-0.1693256348,
-0.9557219148,
-0.6871270537,
-0.6490955949,
-0.3463920951,
-0.0389942788,
-0.4330430925,
-0.4984119534,
-0.5874916315,
-0.008061409,
-0.0784074515,
0.5402184129,
0.6929921508,
-0.0842715427,
0.4965437353,
-0.3076418042,
0.598937273,
0.4781539142,
0.7281581163,
0.213628605,
-0.0925648659,
-0.197299093,
-0.1692309976,
-0.8814710975,
-0.6085923314,
0.4117811322,
0.3381787837,
0.7823818922,
0.7123764157,
0.0148977311,
0.7475273609,
-0.4378899038,
0.6834035516,
0.4501910508,
-1.1056711674,
0.0431622863,
0.3357111216,
0.1265794188,
0.3962140977,
0.4864408374,
-0.2056570053,
-0.1973090172,
-0.6026030183,
-0.9106180072,
0.4795527458,
0.2173897922,
0.0670175105,
0.3941945136,
0.5049299002,
0.2935895026,
0.0196871739,
-0.3527617455,
-0.3639867008,
-0.8287113309,
-0.2692614496,
0.1169341281,
0.0012983787,
0.0313928723,
-0.8182518482,
0.4561861455,
-0.1656620353,
0.5881018043,
0.1094153747,
-0.2156931162,
0.2435523123,
0.081360653,
0.1740368903,
0.5479537845,
0.2123857737,
0.2161643654,
0.4841125906,
-0.7162279487,
-0.0464162305,
-0.4286052287,
0.010008174,
-0.0156042194,
0.0707806945,
0.8466022015,
-0.0038053349,
-0.3547584713,
0.5155328512,
-0.1221781075,
-0.3285999894,
-0.4844764769,
0.4730498195,
0.0451317057,
0.5059662461,
0.5083387494,
0.7416730523,
0.6177281737,
-0.2374753505,
0.0585474819,
0.5152381659,
-0.3485253453,
-0.1209908649,
0.5308656096,
0.0622073412,
-0.7099245191,
0.8744497895,
0.010689579,
-0.7431715727,
0.3470517993,
0.2613548338,
0.762463212,
0.0010029705,
-0.0285293832,
0.3300619423,
0.2477287799,
-0.1585897207,
0.1222025529,
-0.2974789441,
-0.7333512902,
-0.326929152,
-0.705278635,
-0.6065269709,
-0.3514227271,
-0.9232763648,
0.0165379718,
-0.2490299642,
-0.4869074523,
0.2710242867,
-0.2499086261,
-1.2154040337,
0.1589847207,
0.0276987758,
1.0528665781,
-0.5378647447,
0.571988821,
0.381862849,
0.1301144063,
-0.514406085,
-0.5889720917,
-0.3015992641,
-0.6037662029,
0.50260216,
0.5842866302,
-0.5027397275,
-0.2142596394,
-0.5717085004,
-0.4475024045,
1.0649034977,
0.444956392,
-0.6946850419,
0.2750782371,
0.3875988126,
0.5788151622,
-0.3844744563,
0.1580084413,
0.7458138466,
0.754508853,
0.0902329609,
-0.7026775479,
-0.3848396838,
-0.5058457255,
0.3725533187,
-0.0730124861,
-0.4909192622,
0.5060857534,
-0.0834253132,
-0.2512184083,
-0.0620562471,
0.7780046463,
-0.1557881087,
0.4823408723,
0.8610813022,
0.4837457538,
0.5823979974,
-0.5893505812,
1.0367530584,
-0.4528060853,
0.4230511189,
0.0958626941,
-0.059810739,
0.7348895073,
0.4970242381,
-0.3145812452,
0.4164111614,
0.0542594492,
-0.3865225315,
0.444373399,
-0.0597303808,
-0.1445729136,
-0.2989388704,
0.4242753983,
-0.0000924724,
0.8616881371,
0.1294214278,
-0.1757315993,
0.0620122515,
0.3678151667,
-0.2608744204,
-0.0832616165,
-0.2983743846,
0.6532675624,
-0.2144472599,
-0.5720933676,
0.1842868775,
0.1245191991,
1.0035778284,
-0.1602428257,
-0.0393473171,
0.2041528374,
0.5935822129,
-0.5274138451,
-0.8312682509,
0.8292397857,
0.0311904065,
-0.4755979776,
-0.284170866,
0.5508964658,
0.2003584802,
-0.8502496481,
0.0646933094,
-0.0701394901,
0.0166817456,
-0.3583749533,
-0.4045734406,
0.0720896572,
-0.2957366109,
-0.1402182579,
-0.1637795866,
0.0262177065,
0.1159496009,
0.7524991035,
0.4864509404,
-0.2300380021,
0.4991567135,
-0.1981856972,
0.6884410977,
-0.6725460887,
-0.377555877,
-0.43600896,
0.6650515795,
-0.362439394,
0.020699488,
0.8696390986,
0.800622344,
0.8782445788,
-0.4020784795,
0.6518573761,
0.1613690257,
0.3279716671,
-0.1481565088,
0.7056049109,
-0.2910048366,
0.0757129341,
-0.342926085,
-1.1349880695,
-0.527759254,
1.2377127409,
-0.2557780743,
0.11546617,
0.414380312,
0.7935603857,
-0.1954264194,
0.5491815805,
0.2940717638,
-0.441349715,
0.2060154527,
0.4340010881,
0.4708835781,
-0.7597765326,
0.3394109607,
-0.8362525702,
-0.3716016412,
0.0399496183,
-0.682508409,
-0.3402059376,
-0.6951090693,
-0.4504486024,
-0.0701979697,
-0.2818793356,
0.275809288,
1.1988432407,
-0.7892496586,
-0.1921396106,
0.0942607671,
-0.1655697823,
-0.4803809226,
-0.2797587514,
0.2856842279,
-0.0891964063,
-1.0059336424,
-0.0991814807,
0.5927305222,
-0.3138308227,
-0.5372161865,
-0.0941061601,
0.2631269991,
0.0366849378,
0.9257948399,
-0.0143790348,
-0.5405611992,
-0.4923784137,
0.3287359774,
0.2126925588,
0.2979311049,
0.6830262542,
-0.872246325,
0.4793685079,
0.5063248277,
0.3417575359,
0.6670922637,
0.162552923,
0.3502466977,
-0.1856413037,
0.2826814651,
0.0981234461,
0.2829847634,
0.6202447414,
-0.3703977764,
0.4916115999,
0.1220873222,
-0.557397604,
-0.4061036408,
0.0907816663,
-1.4589976072,
0.216860801,
0.8023263812,
-0.0591384582,
-0.4424971342,
-0.229987219,
-0.0762608945,
0.2870008051,
-0.057043232,
0.591072619,
0.143976897,
-0.5902914405,
-0.1009180769,
-0.5977621675,
0.3269322813,
0.0337801352,
-0.4974382818,
-0.5708059669,
0.2166283578,
0.1338879317,
0.7480971217,
-0.0965679586,
-0.5598894358,
0.2722094655,
0.0146424584,
0.1593832821,
0.065756917,
-0.3804446161,
-0.383882165,
0.7239256501,
-0.2482439131,
-0.4046914279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08362v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08362v2 | Conversation Style Transfer using Few-Shot Learning | 2023-02-16T15:27:00 | 2023-09-21T23:14:02 | Shamik Roy, Raphael Shu, Nikolaos Pappas, Elman Mansimov, Yi Zhang, Saab Mansour, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Conventional text style transfer approaches focus on sentence-level style
transfer without considering contextual information, and the style is described
with attributes (e.g., formality). When applying style transfer in
conversations such as task-oriented dialogues, existing approaches suffer from
these limitations as context can play an important role and the style
attributes are often difficult to define in conversations. In this paper, we
introduce conversation style transfer as a few-shot learning problem, where the
model learns to perform style transfer by observing only a few example
dialogues in the target style. We propose a novel in-context learning approach
to solve the task with style-free dialogues as a pivot. Human evaluation shows
that by incorporating multi-turn context, the model is able to match the target
style while having better appropriateness and semantic correctness compared to
utterance/sentence-level style transfer. Additionally, we show that
conversation style transfer can also benefit downstream tasks. For example, in
multi-domain intent classification tasks, the F1 scores improve after
transferring the style of training data to match the style of the test data. | [
-0.1930670589,
-0.8877365589,
0.5702007413,
0.1684644222,
-0.2522155046,
-0.1925199926,
-0.3575028479,
-0.4772836268,
0.0416708328,
0.5691667199,
-0.8477188945,
-0.322242856,
-0.4742487073,
-0.0109948255,
-0.299072206,
1.0807201862,
0.1529232115,
-0.1338458359,
-0.0036050419,
-0.1482186019,
-0.6820864677,
-0.3124028742,
-0.6972401142,
-0.4458556175,
0.0449227579,
1.1008520126,
0.2051615864,
-0.0190036576,
0.519500196,
0.2054018974,
0.3468290865,
0.2929092348,
-0.7466650605,
0.1189749911,
-0.17560184,
-0.4776812494,
-0.3848003149,
0.2028986812,
0.404543072,
0.5600812435,
0.1748373508,
0.0397369526,
0.1769550145,
0.7663730383,
-0.5104112625,
0.471164614,
-0.6651835442,
0.0582020096,
-0.3253487349,
-0.3558347523,
-0.6688181758,
-0.0669126362,
0.3697972298,
-0.5893096924,
-0.0653564036,
-0.0383694507,
0.5387025476,
-0.0963162631,
-0.5326260924,
-0.1917240918,
-0.9914724231,
0.7472144961,
-0.4979114234,
-0.0449468829,
0.4432099164,
0.5704970956,
0.0525945053,
-0.3622472584,
-0.6718273163,
0.2295207083,
-0.2501618862,
0.0133045241,
-0.0451446846,
-0.2052925527,
-0.0825276971,
-0.3028434217,
-0.2794730663,
-0.3069033623,
-0.4100443423,
0.1200630739,
0.8273378611,
0.2318139523,
0.1535847932,
-0.179981783,
-0.5522461534,
-0.2612225115,
-0.5231254697,
0.3174754977,
-0.0873091593,
0.8248283267,
-0.2269504666,
0.1085304767,
-0.4306799769,
0.6608248949,
0.1913531125,
-0.7109949589,
0.0532623604,
-0.7380285859,
-0.0134393079,
0.1079555005,
0.575579524,
0.5552504659,
0.3795191348,
-0.1182437986,
0.2401884049,
-0.5618664622,
0.3702200651,
-0.8593530059,
-0.1255660355,
-0.1117765605,
-0.3319838643,
-0.1645544171,
0.0429878831,
-0.8655174375,
-0.0722340345,
-0.332596302,
0.6307222843,
-0.4999572337,
-0.0075854147,
-0.0793039724,
0.0074477531,
0.6175436378,
0.7289355993,
-1.051620245,
0.2617800236,
0.5117880702,
0.990924418,
-0.4994049668,
-0.1645181477,
-0.5540956259,
0.2327024192,
-0.6250309944,
0.9487826228,
-0.5829693675,
-0.535523653,
-0.0076763285,
-0.0848646313,
-0.3049171269,
-0.0766874924,
0.2092496455,
-0.0277958922,
0.2942148447,
-0.100559786,
-0.2430926263,
-0.1097982004,
0.1193259805,
-0.1670304537,
0.7001003027,
0.1551056355,
-0.473500073,
0.2053833008,
-0.9224757552,
-0.7858561277,
0.1588764489,
0.0293099117,
-0.4835993946,
-0.203487277,
0.0498452596,
0.716609776,
0.2812319696,
-0.2626661956,
-0.3157004714,
-0.6395071149,
0.3603830934,
-0.1502754241,
0.6367336512,
0.0829413533,
-0.3453284204,
0.0958195925,
-0.5132068396,
0.1112317666,
0.0139875943,
0.0189320594,
-0.3826651871,
-0.4492470026,
0.0854410008,
0.3134469688,
-0.1859736592,
-0.4562645257,
0.5240321755,
-0.1793928742,
0.3228977323,
0.5156413317,
0.1563833356,
1.116528511,
-0.6293318868,
0.2238173485,
-0.0789085925,
0.0758398771,
-0.2320518941,
-0.6208604574,
-0.8123504519,
-0.1097351834,
-0.2019040436,
0.8010022044,
-0.8253107667,
0.0956687629,
-0.3712800443,
-0.44903332,
-0.284011364,
0.1395220309,
0.230572626,
0.5446966887,
0.4302566648,
-0.4275686741,
-0.1754896343,
-0.5927767754,
-0.3801538944,
-0.2914491296,
0.1859936714,
0.6404751539,
0.3851718009,
0.064516075,
1.2197945118,
-0.5013590455,
-0.7743750215,
-0.7627552748,
0.5053266287,
-0.2083005458,
0.7294490337,
0.6910899878,
-0.5907565951,
-0.7158851624,
0.0566550232,
-0.3315171897,
0.0540466569,
-0.6004337072,
-0.4780261815,
0.1324258894,
0.5481802225,
-0.3702402115,
0.4639462233,
0.364295125,
-0.0809550658,
0.2773038447,
0.3273417056,
0.4215513766,
-1.2508587837,
-0.0657324493,
0.1424507052,
-0.4632861614,
-1.0228421688,
-0.5671359897,
-0.1271397173,
-0.1546979845,
-0.9136317372,
0.9035465717,
-0.1459699124,
0.0427048691,
-0.3263282478,
0.1213461161,
0.2039142549,
0.9066248536,
0.1397084296,
0.7433690429,
0.4523769915,
-0.5008221865,
0.2313496023,
0.7196531296,
-0.3292012811,
1.2183351517,
-0.0895881504,
0.7878144979,
-0.0713072345,
0.4440715611,
-1.2588415146,
-0.031226771,
0.3594661653,
-0.2559532225,
0.5989485383,
-0.587813437,
-0.062754713,
0.2318934202,
-0.1772506237,
0.1868123263,
0.2857548594,
-0.3047122955,
0.3485754728,
-0.0914206728,
-0.4573848546,
-0.2573769391,
-0.7838412523,
-0.038247712,
-0.429245472,
-0.586111784,
0.7588840723,
-0.1508526802,
-0.0587312356,
-0.2977344692,
-0.1088902354,
-0.5478072762,
0.0331893899,
0.0599467903,
0.3353582621,
-0.1144684181,
0.0166690163,
-0.02591669,
0.129689917,
-0.3277181089,
-0.027667921,
0.2570393384,
-0.1738473475,
-0.1962099969,
-0.8780668378,
0.6916531324,
0.593439877,
-0.0295085702,
0.6388754249,
0.6592841744,
-0.0020686476,
-0.2830359042,
-0.2603079081,
-0.5263641477,
-0.3980337381,
0.280171454,
-0.5749894381,
-0.770059526,
0.1300526261,
-0.2895051241,
0.0998157337,
0.0221288297,
0.1569961756,
-0.4153862298,
0.6812500358,
1.0239701271,
-0.0330765843,
1.1462866068,
-0.2610965073,
0.3550074697,
-0.6115364432,
-0.1763322502,
-0.4531687796,
-0.5932295918,
-0.4981460273,
-0.2149450034,
0.5083063245,
0.0335282609,
-0.1868353486,
0.6069987416,
-0.0077097863,
0.5413763523,
0.5804135799,
0.3870926201,
0.4894185364,
0.0303433519,
0.3595338762,
-0.0909502804,
-0.4879668057,
-0.4026578665,
0.8655818105,
-0.0058958582,
0.7195089459,
0.2139706314,
0.9029022455,
-0.0030753654,
0.1932172179,
-1.2870362997,
0.4114511609,
-0.2383536994,
-0.4075144827,
-0.6411015987,
-0.3644923568,
-0.6317118406,
0.202695474,
-0.5611448288,
-1.0359933376,
0.2188245803,
-0.1333203614,
-0.4127777517,
0.035067834,
-0.6829134822,
0.958338201,
-0.0591732264,
-0.447196275,
-0.0071594394,
-0.7512369752,
0.3134635091,
0.110677205,
0.1514495164,
-0.267352134,
0.4174264669,
0.7809925079,
-0.0525956117,
1.0725835562,
0.1644718945,
0.2806641161,
0.3655757308,
0.3984799385,
0.5137808919,
-0.2500119209,
0.126817733,
0.0580744147,
0.0593921542,
-0.3183385432,
-1.0729807615,
0.3122334778,
-0.4990804791,
-0.4998559356,
-0.1684823036,
-0.5487943888,
-0.632209897,
0.236510694,
0.2769130766,
0.3359606266,
-0.2985011637,
0.1443014741,
0.3716726899,
0.3522306681,
0.7759053111,
0.3850468099,
0.1628672183,
0.1233644709,
0.8004151583,
-0.0327792205,
0.6260461211,
0.31817168,
0.2777466476,
-0.1625940204,
-0.2816377878,
-0.5946230292,
0.0214040857,
-0.7267198563,
-0.1670860946,
-0.3725126088,
-0.1284730583,
-0.518845737,
-0.3579027057,
-0.5126501918,
-0.4374420643,
-0.5311584473,
0.3554422855,
0.4776512682,
0.5638974309,
0.5459359884,
0.5987555385,
-0.8832675815,
0.1489389688,
0.713701427,
0.0928502157,
-0.4195551872,
-0.8697293401,
0.0709215775,
-0.1377205849,
-0.5851536393,
-1.0831954479,
0.5092438459,
0.6402746439,
0.423240751,
0.411126554,
0.198987022,
0.8666365147,
-0.5222113132,
0.5696555972,
0.302541554,
-1.0728843212,
0.6607228518,
-0.0381569341,
0.3088871837,
0.9926162362,
0.5133047104,
-0.8704349995,
0.0187913608,
-0.4932323992,
-0.4525282681,
0.93606323,
0.2051338404,
0.380818069,
0.2945606411,
0.3338764608,
0.0679306239,
0.0686782673,
-0.4511213899,
-0.1522212774,
-0.4259494841,
-0.0025634849,
0.0442607626,
0.2450399995,
-0.1832386553,
-0.1820673645,
0.4584465623,
-0.7458040714,
0.4080510139,
0.1264249831,
-0.2210013717,
0.0760668293,
0.9363235235,
0.8204579353,
0.4377755821,
-0.111587964,
-0.0160547812,
0.1718252897,
-0.1523077041,
0.159583196,
-0.3828956485,
0.0184672661,
-0.0829886124,
0.2397539616,
0.9531803131,
0.4847829342,
-0.1439334154,
0.9694922566,
0.0506870188,
-0.0042121764,
0.1422653049,
0.1044337675,
-0.1545156986,
0.3151549697,
0.3829434216,
0.3115622699,
0.2334565222,
-1.0837831497,
0.2613280714,
0.5166269541,
-0.5301896334,
-0.16646263,
0.0028293852,
0.5239510536,
-0.3745081127,
0.4961199462,
-0.2732994854,
-0.4904212058,
0.1713966131,
0.7964342237,
0.8177161217,
-0.0399637595,
0.4166202545,
0.34007743,
-0.0846914575,
-0.2289972305,
-0.0858423188,
-0.4903181195,
-0.9395702481,
-0.4722807705,
-0.2880633473,
-0.8717908859,
-0.1147852018,
-0.5315900445,
0.4772485495,
-0.2863345146,
-0.0074716313,
-0.1114066765,
-0.1727134734,
-0.632371664,
-0.1637126803,
0.2069537193,
0.4503037035,
-1.0422691107,
0.9154378176,
0.53750664,
-0.3022327721,
-0.5288906693,
0.163605392,
0.3179247379,
-0.5149121284,
0.7735088468,
0.3840349913,
-0.5350484848,
0.0221402328,
-0.6997449994,
-0.7163206935,
1.0175755024,
0.2875903547,
-0.5841684937,
-0.105228588,
-0.1437799782,
0.272957772,
-0.72778368,
0.1410052329,
0.680462718,
0.2257270962,
0.6314803362,
-1.247569561,
-0.1777158082,
0.0171022937,
-0.0638279095,
-0.1055598855,
-0.7511765957,
0.5561767817,
-0.2344008088,
-0.3207232356,
0.0347371101,
0.7479477525,
-0.1102460474,
0.4822603464,
0.4198527038,
-0.0989432335,
0.5291292667,
-0.0773443505,
0.7930105925,
-0.0816924274,
0.3487622738,
1.1339954138,
-0.3785722256,
1.0792212486,
0.4944515228,
-0.0504968986,
0.6422608495,
0.1037905365,
0.5162920356,
0.6606998444,
-0.2007053494,
-0.2299983054,
-0.3469635844,
-0.0861999318,
0.1214066893,
1.1151838303,
0.2050765306,
0.0954790264,
-0.0915837437,
0.2031884789,
0.2341741174,
0.011196346,
-0.1451651901,
1.1832818985,
0.0435933694,
-0.6214172244,
0.4005641639,
-0.265437603,
0.9313682914,
-0.5291874409,
-0.5054731369,
-0.3432704508,
-0.0369654894,
-0.3517834544,
-0.6653330326,
0.4237353206,
-0.3286077976,
-0.0145390686,
-0.6262044311,
0.7402690053,
-0.6063870788,
-0.269764483,
-0.1696983576,
0.5604385734,
0.2156931907,
-0.1745682359,
-0.4817523062,
-0.3259519935,
-0.1740958095,
0.1283722818,
0.632153511,
0.2915816009,
-0.2200392634,
0.5923998952,
0.3982561231,
-0.242690295,
-0.1203330085,
-0.1309615076,
0.4836883545,
-0.6151221395,
-0.5360840559,
-0.6052060723,
0.2820334435,
0.0775575414,
-0.4026905298,
0.5153261423,
0.0712466687,
0.9119358659,
-0.0702268258,
0.6007689834,
0.182951346,
0.2666512132,
-0.6744108796,
0.5879932642,
-0.2480909824,
-0.00719715,
-0.6290555,
-0.6985044479,
-0.2707335651,
0.9283618927,
-0.2834457755,
0.0274279937,
0.815577507,
0.630363524,
-0.108770214,
0.0324636362,
0.5015195608,
-0.3061881959,
0.151231885,
0.8185916543,
0.4898402989,
-0.3314740658,
0.7265666127,
-0.6953877211,
-0.3680909872,
-0.5413278341,
-0.9459226131,
-0.766046524,
-0.8297586441,
-0.4721359313,
-0.215272963,
0.1095660105,
1.0588883162,
1.3069881201,
-0.6473664641,
-0.3126473129,
0.2263392806,
0.0875300914,
-0.5747849941,
-0.3234312832,
0.1014050543,
-0.5594233871,
-0.9671913981,
0.7809783816,
0.3388600945,
0.2650019228,
0.1645081341,
0.1928682327,
-0.1799805164,
0.0928753018,
0.9441304207,
0.3336660862,
-0.4172519743,
-0.5516073704,
-0.064729102,
-0.2019042969,
0.4396240711,
1.2348481417,
-0.5920326114,
0.4383741021,
0.4207497835,
0.6723009348,
0.8580642343,
0.2624225318,
0.2927142084,
-1.1171851158,
0.1846351773,
0.0372286662,
0.0193732716,
0.4478269219,
-0.4408809841,
0.2178922445,
0.3695272207,
-0.2016904205,
-0.2174739987,
0.3751583993,
-1.3525840044,
-0.3177763224,
1.2325899601,
-0.2230240554,
-0.1043334678,
-0.1636317521,
-0.4538831115,
0.1727883965,
-0.5754489303,
0.4744256735,
0.5819336772,
-0.8631954193,
-0.4361835122,
-0.3591036797,
0.7026831508,
0.2985972464,
-1.0540572405,
-0.1154549196,
0.2806226015,
0.287468791,
0.1610331684,
0.8141890168,
0.0130195543,
0.299071908,
-0.397423327,
-0.2469811589,
0.0757242367,
-0.7051184773,
-0.2489604652,
0.1479621828,
-0.0785859153,
-0.3946225941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09302v1 | Bridge the Gap between Language models and Tabular Understanding | 2023-02-16T15:16:55 | 2023-02-16T15:16:55 | Nuo Chen, Linjun Shou, Ming Gong, Jian Pei, Chenyu You, Jianhui Chang, Daxin Jiang, Jia Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Table pretrain-then-finetune paradigm has been proposed and employed at a
rapid pace after the success of pre-training in the natural language domain.
Despite the promising findings in tabular pre-trained language models (TPLMs),
there is an input gap between pre-training and fine-tuning phases. For
instance, TPLMs jointly pre-trained with table and text input could be
effective for tasks also with table-text joint input like table question
answering, but it may fail for tasks with only tables or text as input such as
table retrieval. To this end, we propose UTP, an approach that dynamically
supports three types of multi-modal inputs: table-text, table, and text.
Specifically, UTP is pre-trained with two strategies: (1) We first utilize a
universal mask language modeling objective on each kind of input, enforcing the
model to adapt various inputs. (2) We then present Cross-Modal Contrastive
Regularization (CMCR), which utilizes contrastive learning to encourage the
consistency between table-text cross-modality representations via unsupervised
instance-wise training signals during pre-training. By these means, the
resulting model not only bridges the input gap between pre-training and
fine-tuning but also advances in the alignment of table and text. Extensive
results show UTP achieves superior results on uni-modal input tasks (e.g.,
table retrieval) and cross-modal input tasks (e.g., table question answering). | [
-0.5163571239,
-0.8306510448,
0.5871164799,
-0.0373352356,
-0.344837606,
0.0520899184,
-0.3542351127,
-0.3233448565,
-0.2804780304,
0.4276955426,
-0.4025660753,
-0.4756684303,
-0.2525330186,
-0.0412035435,
-0.1707834303,
0.8878986835,
-0.1661287099,
0.2114819735,
-0.217724964,
0.0560087971,
-0.8129983544,
-0.3714114726,
-0.3166062534,
-0.4874307513,
0.5037229657,
0.6751726866,
0.7782300115,
0.6878020763,
0.3522527218,
0.358271569,
0.3658457398,
0.0585418455,
-0.1461086422,
0.0668634474,
-0.1655192226,
-0.5052440763,
-0.3486287296,
0.0933636725,
0.7197449803,
0.9797417521,
-0.2535378635,
-0.0890687108,
0.3975878358,
0.6245296001,
-0.4651052058,
0.2416745126,
-0.7976676226,
0.2437154055,
-0.4675317109,
-0.2567849457,
-0.441847533,
0.0172979832,
-0.0252865087,
-0.6275694966,
0.1547450572,
-0.0929509923,
0.8906858563,
0.1302316785,
-0.5096800923,
0.0746598616,
-0.8302346468,
0.5713582039,
-0.6693737507,
1.0160740614,
0.4594776928,
0.3665087521,
-0.2149370313,
-0.8576651812,
-0.8716694117,
-0.4630637169,
-0.4421178401,
0.0148267308,
0.0646816716,
0.3431739211,
-0.0375128761,
0.3429527879,
-0.8693161011,
0.2165252119,
0.0200679339,
-0.0088594491,
0.1061391607,
0.164846316,
0.4149876237,
-0.0906131938,
-0.2383317649,
0.0398924127,
-0.5173078179,
0.2275238484,
-0.2066351473,
0.5014029741,
-0.3687942922,
0.4580106139,
-0.2848981619,
1.2018637657,
-0.0725187883,
0.0383651592,
-0.121124655,
-0.6383657455,
-0.5792025924,
-0.3894483745,
0.8352264762,
0.008887887,
0.1053971425,
-0.3092643619,
-0.1175534055,
0.3710132837,
0.2318739742,
-0.4898843467,
-0.2678713799,
-0.0768980756,
-0.3256064057,
-0.1920644641,
0.0713968053,
-0.9387724996,
-0.1289911121,
-0.6184172034,
0.6578894854,
-0.1489976496,
0.0525261126,
0.0477962494,
0.3714448512,
0.0854398534,
0.4659918249,
-1.144493103,
0.6115819812,
0.4669430554,
0.5537398458,
-0.2185068429,
-0.3341187239,
-0.7531529069,
0.2774592042,
-0.2904039323,
0.8698183298,
-0.989074707,
-0.1008500159,
0.1545039713,
-0.1237067953,
-0.3816671669,
-0.4112938344,
0.4856330156,
-0.5676075816,
0.453237474,
-0.1910960674,
-0.1833553612,
-0.0076886858,
0.3293848336,
-0.6303839087,
0.8798322082,
0.1993341744,
-0.6322596669,
0.5070111752,
-0.8132029176,
-0.4440196753,
-0.0568195209,
-0.5379318595,
-0.3536831439,
0.1975283325,
0.3758785129,
0.5311242938,
-0.3877482116,
0.3030362129,
-0.177977547,
-0.136449188,
0.2414733171,
-0.2521498501,
0.275264889,
0.2358205318,
-0.2385311574,
0.350025028,
-0.7420786619,
0.1111679748,
-0.0739096701,
-0.6631019711,
-0.1153116673,
-0.0646399185,
0.3076225817,
0.4583270848,
-0.0744259506,
-0.3289200068,
0.2292518318,
-0.2149545401,
0.4576144218,
0.4003759325,
-0.3857632875,
0.711097002,
-0.2199639082,
0.4162867963,
0.1240139902,
-0.0475080088,
-0.1679662764,
0.1079328135,
-0.8338838816,
0.1170657352,
0.7919793725,
0.6052755117,
-0.9451907277,
0.3189099133,
-0.0471996926,
-0.2432269156,
-0.2315522581,
0.0663805455,
0.5048479438,
0.8560986519,
0.5915331244,
-0.3870984018,
-0.5890387297,
-0.8129341602,
-0.4083047211,
0.0360025838,
-0.2159859687,
0.2145254612,
0.1527246684,
-0.1259312332,
0.6471259594,
-0.2314587981,
-0.7352462411,
-0.7821720243,
0.3668933213,
0.0637523606,
0.8348920941,
0.1084879562,
-0.7527281642,
-0.7081099749,
0.1917603016,
-0.3524182439,
-0.2455189824,
-0.2302196622,
0.0969969556,
0.3204279542,
0.5507756472,
-0.5248920918,
0.4515306354,
0.4604960084,
-0.3981356621,
0.2317324877,
-0.2144964784,
0.3055181205,
-1.1070008278,
0.0530344322,
-0.1497323066,
-0.3184691072,
-1.0015676022,
-0.0579265691,
0.1824217141,
-0.3123008013,
-0.296238631,
0.3169822097,
-0.6720080972,
-0.1461851597,
0.0125263818,
0.23370336,
0.1777687073,
0.6066621542,
0.1484434009,
0.7453351021,
0.3064319193,
-0.590641737,
-0.1701581031,
0.1783049107,
-0.2642854452,
0.5497672558,
-0.5474188328,
0.0065683913,
0.0896299034,
0.1239465401,
-1.1736502647,
-0.0806003436,
0.1805434823,
-0.3830590546,
0.8964571953,
-0.0573116802,
-0.3200417757,
-0.1986046582,
-0.1490840763,
0.483109951,
0.1017138809,
-0.253761977,
0.9159348607,
0.4518300593,
-0.1801970154,
-0.6776607633,
-0.703448236,
-0.0064109433,
0.0787844136,
-0.4686086774,
0.7120077014,
0.0809890702,
-0.0913689286,
-0.1487350464,
-0.396495074,
-0.4701482356,
0.0315987095,
-0.0486712717,
0.1134224832,
-0.239482671,
0.153175801,
-0.0393972322,
-0.1373100281,
-0.2191078812,
-0.1349373609,
1.0985109806,
-0.3073427081,
-0.0553020909,
-0.7698536515,
0.3258512914,
0.31502828,
-0.5038350821,
0.5428043604,
0.6351994276,
-0.3726647198,
-0.0135935983,
-0.7411896586,
-0.2106074542,
-0.4680474102,
0.4603573978,
-0.5926327705,
-0.8169268966,
0.5629987717,
0.1843961477,
0.0613865666,
0.295372963,
0.4242747724,
-0.3554484844,
0.8581998944,
0.940395534,
0.1662899852,
0.6453481317,
-0.0355217345,
-0.0545033813,
-0.6762886643,
-0.5206401348,
-0.8940250874,
-0.412873894,
-0.4626951516,
-0.3915706873,
0.1888918728,
0.1897906214,
-0.0418726802,
0.2783949673,
-0.1784244925,
0.5784729719,
0.5448381305,
0.1718506217,
0.4356210232,
-0.1030781195,
-0.4026937783,
-0.316056937,
-0.8954057693,
-0.3221986294,
0.822086215,
0.1822094619,
0.8988770247,
-0.1669680178,
0.5287340879,
0.1906196028,
0.1549353451,
-0.4995492995,
0.5627991557,
-0.173616901,
-0.3614241481,
-0.5231539607,
-0.4440346658,
-1.1813340187,
0.4886445701,
-0.5308814645,
-0.7187597752,
0.0805414468,
0.3876173496,
-0.2665754855,
0.3022556901,
-0.5419723988,
1.370569706,
-0.1806921214,
-0.5641810894,
-0.1752768904,
-0.8516696692,
0.192835927,
0.058437638,
0.1758169085,
0.1553984731,
-0.0686458051,
0.7370814085,
-0.3922122717,
0.6147124767,
-0.051937528,
0.1692222953,
-0.0160964504,
0.4819375575,
0.2961086035,
0.1769994646,
0.2548297942,
-0.0399578549,
0.0436740778,
-0.2554038763,
-0.5649457574,
0.560910821,
-0.6839676499,
-0.4319990575,
-0.3868962526,
-0.8948480487,
-0.5139148235,
0.3658777475,
0.1139767095,
0.6311764717,
-0.1827536523,
0.2400200367,
0.603587389,
-0.0988079831,
0.7167907357,
0.7060598731,
-0.1026151106,
-0.340749383,
0.4862019718,
0.0577589758,
0.1239803955,
0.9671197534,
0.2350083292,
-0.479383409,
-0.6181890965,
-0.4657734334,
0.151050806,
-0.3216943145,
-0.3472898901,
-0.7273336649,
0.0264179818,
-0.3161326051,
-0.2725813687,
-0.3343686461,
-0.3558843136,
-0.2991911173,
0.1428668201,
-0.238027662,
0.6415355206,
-0.2337459922,
0.459436655,
-0.9555801749,
0.6798073053,
0.5569175482,
0.5892001987,
-0.2333635241,
-0.6975263953,
-0.1038925946,
-0.113853246,
-0.3516349792,
-1.0878274441,
0.3402671814,
0.2754128277,
0.6302460432,
0.2735885382,
-0.1471869946,
0.7722081542,
-0.7477239966,
0.5362830162,
0.3244550228,
-1.1367223263,
0.4579402506,
-0.4163399637,
0.5866392851,
1.002389431,
0.2915499806,
-0.6938954592,
-0.137857765,
-0.2914937735,
-0.4556009173,
0.814497292,
-0.0373586155,
-0.130425632,
0.4107948542,
0.0858013257,
0.3129320741,
0.39937374,
-1.3481910229,
0.102075085,
-0.0975914374,
-0.2137208134,
0.0460626893,
-0.2217573971,
-0.0463641435,
-0.4171486795,
0.2873696089,
0.0558963008,
0.2173122019,
-0.0701224208,
-0.4862275422,
-0.1705057621,
0.7901970744,
0.7804790735,
0.8976590037,
-0.0711565316,
0.5000857711,
0.1403899938,
-0.4779979885,
-0.0307282265,
0.3978204131,
-0.0393124782,
-0.0647149831,
0.1586791128,
0.5922985673,
0.3532492816,
-0.2420951575,
0.4010660052,
-0.1650210172,
-0.1222117022,
0.0959386155,
-0.165458709,
-0.1132697612,
0.1628635973,
0.1451839656,
-0.0778726488,
0.0724408701,
-0.8134866953,
0.4707199335,
0.5673927665,
-0.5676788092,
-0.3690444231,
0.8470865488,
0.1662518382,
-0.4879205227,
0.4679370522,
0.1165890917,
-0.5614993572,
0.1111532301,
0.6289005876,
0.507909894,
-0.5000994802,
0.3191992939,
0.0301999114,
0.3948126435,
0.2078816444,
0.577560544,
-0.3798866272,
-0.5457193255,
-0.4245361686,
-0.6169362068,
-0.2078732103,
0.6364764571,
-0.4696267843,
0.2323798686,
-0.2867158055,
0.172234714,
-0.0241970923,
0.0943523347,
-0.9340520501,
0.3258882463,
0.0934678391,
0.6732872128,
-0.9338524342,
0.9943124056,
0.6214746833,
-0.5360609293,
-0.9854187369,
-0.0810080469,
-0.3549248874,
-0.6479304433,
0.5366654396,
0.1846676618,
0.2306020558,
-0.0405212045,
-0.2687805891,
-0.709025383,
0.6466946602,
0.1597651541,
-0.6590465903,
-0.2066862285,
0.6539419889,
0.3942370415,
-0.3792861402,
0.1676371545,
0.833455801,
0.5920805335,
-0.3416182101,
-1.2385476828,
0.1411234289,
-0.0948429927,
0.0206961799,
0.4500754774,
-0.1942869574,
0.90403229,
-0.0855915919,
-0.2312612534,
-0.1732916534,
0.6730653048,
-0.0278976597,
0.3159217536,
0.6693085432,
0.7965646386,
0.2491841018,
-0.3337500989,
0.6438150406,
-0.0301758479,
-0.071959354,
1.3777800798,
-0.0765661821,
0.8884320259,
0.63428545,
-0.2522009611,
0.5118693113,
0.6354194283,
0.1300142109,
0.6105316877,
0.1633038372,
-0.0325974822,
-0.335568279,
-0.152354762,
-0.5423209667,
0.6228054166,
0.3818526864,
-0.172874555,
-0.5755596757,
-0.0610573068,
-0.0344158709,
0.4062442183,
-0.4513833225,
0.7767043114,
-0.0667843595,
-0.5649011731,
0.5717115402,
-0.0761321262,
0.3822866976,
-0.678432107,
-0.1585943103,
-0.2470009029,
-0.117783457,
-0.2075486034,
-0.6481620073,
0.0966388434,
-0.3232189417,
-0.0401272438,
-0.169041127,
0.644756496,
-0.9073566198,
-0.1419481933,
-0.0929065347,
0.7770826221,
-0.1363110691,
0.0570678376,
-0.6303452253,
0.1606870443,
-0.1736503243,
-0.1751008779,
0.4031049311,
0.3603244722,
0.0312935896,
0.3600760996,
0.4360333979,
-0.0842979103,
-0.0617261864,
0.2938420773,
1.1066144705,
-0.5697795749,
-0.7452090979,
-0.8362178206,
0.6796178818,
0.141896829,
-0.1190219596,
0.3108300567,
0.5860411525,
0.9743894339,
-0.1173941791,
0.345110178,
0.0284123011,
0.4409794807,
-0.7347333431,
0.7580954432,
-0.7510921955,
0.1100222766,
-0.4859836996,
-1.0980783701,
-0.6480688453,
0.6882814765,
-0.2154843807,
0.1260124743,
0.9631269574,
0.5607626438,
-0.2249394357,
-0.238777861,
0.4941854775,
0.1362067163,
0.1863617599,
0.6926022768,
0.7713133693,
-0.2960560024,
0.6952837706,
-0.2422286272,
-0.185574919,
-0.1138484329,
-0.9028459787,
-1.0727268457,
-0.7402313948,
0.1996495724,
-0.1601195931,
-0.1247889325,
0.8218480349,
0.7205704451,
-0.7465238571,
-0.4411587715,
-0.3408168554,
-0.0226737875,
0.1140514463,
-0.2126226723,
0.321570605,
-0.6249365211,
-0.5357439518,
0.4601633847,
0.3087104261,
0.2548144162,
-0.0807058141,
0.2739831805,
-0.367698431,
-0.1388528347,
0.4983818829,
0.468018502,
-0.6457080841,
-0.1802384257,
-0.0117570469,
-0.0837020501,
0.4014452398,
1.038323164,
-0.8586270213,
0.3695985675,
0.549458921,
0.8761857152,
0.5483660698,
-0.0863360167,
0.826608777,
-0.6356381774,
0.2773817182,
0.3214940429,
0.3733188212,
0.2108362317,
-0.0533051603,
0.4358274937,
-0.0234226361,
-0.6061272025,
-0.9029299021,
0.5310108662,
-1.193873167,
-0.3248178959,
0.6223672032,
0.2955082655,
0.0991752893,
-0.3531786203,
-0.1385896206,
0.5198017359,
-0.3334391117,
1.0128591061,
0.3276394904,
-0.2204553038,
-0.3850863874,
-0.5678520203,
0.8106269836,
0.7045283318,
-1.1467809677,
0.1415094584,
0.530035913,
-0.093289502,
0.086475037,
0.5946596265,
-0.2029457986,
0.3454327881,
-0.2563512623,
0.1111807972,
-0.249763906,
-0.7278571725,
-0.3088426888,
0.2906734049,
0.1105251312,
-0.2385759652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08351v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08351v2 | A Survey on Event-based News Narrative Extraction | 2023-02-16T15:11:53 | 2023-03-10T20:39:14 | Brian Keith Norambuena, Tanushree Mitra, Chris North | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Narratives are fundamental to our understanding of the world, providing us
with a natural structure for knowledge representation over time. Computational
narrative extraction is a subfield of artificial intelligence that makes heavy
use of information retrieval and natural language processing techniques.
Despite the importance of computational narrative extraction, relatively little
scholarly work exists on synthesizing previous research and strategizing future
research in the area. In particular, this article focuses on extracting news
narratives from an event-centric perspective. Extracting narratives from news
data has multiple applications in understanding the evolving information
landscape. This survey presents an extensive study of research in the area of
event-based news narrative extraction. In particular, we screened over 900
articles that yielded 54 relevant articles. These articles are synthesized and
organized by representation model, extraction criteria, and evaluation
approaches. Based on the reviewed studies, we identify recent trends, open
challenges, and potential research lines. | [
-0.4552179575,
-1.0503829718,
0.8159385324,
0.0392862521,
-0.2867307067,
0.3733892441,
-0.0877890214,
-1.0113617182,
0.4618676305,
0.2370362133,
-0.5494741201,
-0.3549281359,
-0.5323669314,
0.1298881471,
-0.5584381819,
1.060325861,
0.0042040921,
-0.3305090368,
-0.1757769585,
0.0149159143,
-0.3034854829,
-0.5579373837,
-0.3522868156,
-0.0786278397,
0.5325322747,
0.2600161731,
0.2887994647,
0.7155560851,
0.4201743305,
0.1219554394,
-0.0549442358,
0.1941085756,
-0.1943130046,
0.0700833052,
-0.1110958531,
-0.2327731252,
-0.093761906,
0.5976483226,
0.4894240499,
0.5765135884,
-0.1082879752,
0.4397553205,
-0.2397513986,
0.7543998957,
-0.7559838295,
0.0662386119,
-0.4830356836,
0.2109470814,
-0.3076773882,
-0.2571426928,
-0.436606437,
-0.5647438765,
0.3205675483,
-0.5527811646,
0.261146158,
0.0445421413,
0.7133084536,
-0.3657789826,
-0.4706602395,
-0.5215583444,
-1.014554739,
0.7936484218,
-0.3720780909,
0.2776930034,
0.1035260186,
0.2370909005,
0.0494915806,
-0.8187440038,
-0.508053422,
0.0814290568,
0.001792604,
0.3350738585,
-0.5372517109,
-0.5023304224,
0.1860686243,
0.313133806,
-0.6211247444,
-0.0383404829,
-0.6104083657,
-0.0816199556,
0.7963545918,
0.3582550585,
0.5167407393,
-0.7124325633,
-0.2952453494,
0.1771651804,
-0.4209924936,
0.3373988569,
0.2955244482,
0.0424928777,
-0.1805868894,
0.5298378468,
-0.375706315,
0.6079351902,
0.0102884835,
-0.4632797241,
0.2023752779,
-0.4313731194,
0.1648535728,
0.5499429107,
0.8337824941,
0.5803217292,
0.0261714477,
-0.4361816347,
0.0607150011,
-0.1622020304,
0.4608738124,
-0.5277864933,
0.1887703687,
0.1809057146,
-0.8704013228,
-0.7086771131,
0.2172954381,
-1.2956936359,
-0.617266655,
-0.2612097561,
-0.1779968292,
-0.3251320422,
-0.2528091967,
-0.2102650255,
-0.583235383,
0.4381904304,
0.3480244577,
-0.6390411258,
0.0235575065,
0.749981761,
0.8944766521,
-0.9692495465,
0.1225409955,
-0.4171951413,
0.1050678268,
-0.367288202,
0.7328785658,
-0.4359811842,
-0.193899259,
-0.044020202,
-0.1896521747,
0.0528895333,
-0.3874693215,
0.5208579898,
-0.6718752384,
0.2987650037,
-0.0740886405,
-0.3921183646,
-0.3054278791,
0.4319896996,
-0.6957526207,
0.6970337033,
-0.0454304963,
-0.7940873504,
0.2448905557,
-0.3426920176,
-0.7041112185,
-0.065733254,
-0.353805542,
-0.2420755476,
0.3670804501,
0.6872135997,
-0.0630507991,
-0.4920970798,
0.4551553428,
0.0550212711,
-0.0964973643,
0.2422809005,
-0.3942182958,
0.8019102216,
0.4043962955,
-0.2878163159,
-0.2311338335,
-1.1104958057,
-0.2892427444,
0.2646194994,
-0.1677867919,
-0.2754158378,
0.2130684555,
0.0432724394,
0.0862655863,
0.1663350165,
-0.7566252947,
0.2650442421,
-0.4226457179,
0.2577646375,
0.3250848055,
0.6872515082,
0.7614611387,
-0.2650777996,
0.7374389768,
-0.0383478217,
0.0259585734,
-0.4857997298,
-0.2226204723,
-0.1645347178,
-0.1217962801,
0.1364821941,
0.539583087,
-0.8594226837,
0.1575383693,
-0.0156871416,
-0.7267717719,
-0.054389853,
-0.3574228883,
-0.2085615098,
0.638071537,
0.1255141199,
-0.1746202707,
-0.8741704226,
-0.5121011138,
-0.5378600955,
-0.3073986471,
0.3257015347,
0.0721585304,
0.0002305282,
0.2370448411,
1.4805502892,
-0.6681516767,
0.2130776197,
-0.6661608219,
0.5424832702,
0.4649261832,
0.0756758302,
0.6840611696,
-1.1070109606,
-0.1820261031,
0.2761344016,
-1.0154192448,
0.0272645969,
-0.5060216784,
0.268794626,
0.3994791508,
0.3558203578,
-0.7109004259,
0.8462866545,
0.1691291481,
0.0252908263,
0.8493934274,
0.387667805,
0.3502767384,
-0.6826380491,
0.0815156773,
0.0535753816,
-0.2039916962,
-0.4791591763,
-0.1243830249,
-0.1088900417,
-0.0843154714,
-0.3757532239,
0.4678331017,
-0.6347805858,
-0.3203373551,
-0.4894368947,
0.2555264235,
0.0801464394,
0.3664826155,
0.3127831817,
0.1852513403,
0.3134015799,
-0.3918936551,
0.5060200691,
0.1611761749,
-0.5032330751,
0.0875992253,
-0.256929785,
0.0970608145,
-0.1768365502,
0.3010365963,
-0.491851896,
0.0440397561,
0.3194732368,
-0.5036591291,
-0.1172595248,
-0.1361318231,
-0.3854142725,
-0.2743605673,
-0.3227649033,
-0.0320445448,
0.4233494103,
-0.3342576623,
0.6140338778,
0.7073315978,
-0.7323554754,
-0.2423176169,
-0.4106620848,
0.1618404686,
-0.2476552427,
-0.1678057164,
-0.0117943455,
0.1493359059,
-0.518599689,
-0.0205465313,
-0.517926991,
-0.2711050808,
-0.1306317747,
0.2228559852,
0.5194509625,
-0.4033187926,
-0.1305791736,
0.0378215574,
-0.1514852494,
0.2355852574,
-0.0553139597,
0.2228301615,
0.2172541916,
-0.1684395671,
-0.3703888655,
0.7703191042,
0.4909747541,
-0.5236910582,
0.7487800717,
0.7271581292,
-0.337705195,
0.1825969368,
-0.5296767354,
-0.1696509868,
-0.3218567669,
0.3382772207,
0.1732388139,
-0.876500845,
0.4368745983,
-0.2255218476,
0.2611448169,
0.8372675776,
0.2911641896,
-0.1239431277,
0.9867095947,
0.412469089,
-0.1529912055,
0.610245347,
0.0968667418,
0.2158566564,
-0.3717585504,
-0.2847097814,
-0.663435936,
-0.2098958194,
-0.2488286048,
0.2614548206,
0.445004642,
-0.0315001905,
0.1779984385,
0.0854779184,
-0.3841651082,
0.3276866972,
0.2195052058,
-0.2433079332,
0.6539286375,
0.1291323155,
0.4647834897,
-0.2179155797,
-0.4418901205,
-0.3512648642,
0.7157689333,
0.0476586856,
0.3362592459,
-0.139764443,
0.6520987153,
0.3885678053,
0.278935492,
-0.4914257526,
0.167470336,
0.1579257846,
-0.6408735514,
-0.1668169945,
-0.5796726942,
-0.828186214,
0.0980737805,
-0.3041607141,
-1.100114584,
0.4758650064,
-0.6538054347,
-0.3309584856,
0.1881569177,
-0.4122354686,
0.4958190024,
-0.1748841107,
0.2080647349,
-0.126147747,
-0.7209504843,
0.3356069326,
-0.1937816888,
0.7068430185,
-0.0757775009,
0.3415264189,
0.8149442077,
0.0968072191,
0.5550338626,
0.0518056862,
0.1858584732,
0.8056929111,
0.0463608876,
0.6226294041,
0.2141373008,
-0.1355919242,
0.1974330097,
0.2488936037,
0.0265166182,
-0.4407343864,
0.3159456253,
-0.5841081142,
-0.4578949809,
-0.6172909737,
-0.5643114448,
-0.310515672,
0.0897116438,
0.2712913454,
0.7129493952,
-0.4667914212,
0.1109698713,
0.1321802437,
-0.1092625633,
1.0529696941,
0.5239851475,
-0.3489423394,
-0.5263438225,
0.9663087726,
0.1388999522,
-0.2990474999,
0.4632183015,
0.1251494288,
0.1315040886,
-0.8988912702,
-0.570150435,
-0.1812826097,
-0.2045966238,
-0.293710202,
-0.8747995496,
-0.521075666,
-0.246242106,
-0.2606647015,
-0.4192278683,
-0.8512090445,
-0.5011323094,
-0.501008153,
0.1199606732,
0.8320150375,
-0.2157585174,
0.1669038236,
-1.256259203,
0.5134213567,
-0.0057958476,
-0.3577778935,
0.0393299088,
0.0971471518,
-0.4819151163,
-0.1715172082,
-0.5055484176,
-1.0703309774,
0.6711620688,
-0.2020922154,
0.6891874671,
0.2716085017,
0.2283490449,
0.614581883,
-0.3379077613,
0.9933860302,
0.4140781462,
-0.5413223505,
0.8370779157,
-0.5063229203,
0.1370779127,
0.5161603689,
0.4752850235,
-0.5035088658,
-0.2766275108,
-0.7555410862,
-0.7438728809,
0.939155519,
0.1617097706,
-0.1088719442,
-0.1176859438,
0.5477768779,
0.4797224402,
0.3262993693,
-0.5083889961,
-0.2352857888,
0.1373642534,
-0.0407390147,
0.0971766189,
-0.1312683523,
0.2111430764,
-0.1714410335,
0.3161997795,
0.1415972412,
-0.0720226169,
0.3657150567,
-0.321787864,
-0.1820565313,
0.0430157669,
0.1541065574,
0.9538583159,
-0.0190857444,
-0.0634028465,
-0.1154223904,
-0.7147032022,
-0.3029249012,
0.4515605271,
-0.2812927365,
0.0371678025,
0.6018276215,
0.3882680833,
-0.0258611981,
-0.8200377822,
0.6949706078,
-0.3390968442,
0.0599340349,
-0.290468961,
-0.1011290625,
-0.1269935071,
0.5224815011,
0.908279717,
0.1011645645,
0.4858043194,
-0.7959239483,
0.3505605459,
0.1759924889,
-0.6617200971,
-0.4410618842,
0.3747410774,
0.0250312556,
0.0075491597,
0.6319247484,
-0.1317826658,
-0.143656984,
0.7897258401,
0.5926921368,
0.6749399304,
0.2774288356,
0.5071465969,
0.4122138619,
0.305975914,
0.1249787807,
-0.1148709655,
-0.0073296595,
-0.5581325889,
-0.5261662006,
-0.7537811995,
-0.3867692947,
0.0733006597,
-0.7843446136,
0.1529465467,
-0.0302382372,
0.1632981449,
0.3511167169,
0.3282473385,
-0.1328223348,
0.0150657352,
0.5814858079,
0.9076690078,
-0.5861960053,
0.3985045552,
0.5789490342,
-0.3459044695,
-0.5419940948,
-0.1516939998,
0.3218401968,
-0.1884182245,
-0.0863813534,
0.0304206703,
0.3775694668,
-0.1694927067,
-0.5880239606,
-0.6072934866,
1.0124311447,
0.4365070164,
-0.3714889586,
-0.264888674,
-0.0215753913,
0.3307976425,
-0.885881424,
-0.0662432462,
0.5829799175,
0.3637305498,
0.2783599794,
-0.4990259409,
-0.2905697525,
-0.0913556889,
-0.5010307431,
0.2066294253,
-0.3732964098,
0.5155692697,
-0.0819915906,
-0.2999013364,
0.1286086291,
0.8405548334,
0.2607976496,
1.0665085316,
0.2158383578,
0.0118186595,
0.5966635346,
0.1826666147,
1.0495941639,
0.0253720339,
0.2636352479,
1.0480601788,
-0.0570054725,
0.3772603869,
0.3245714009,
0.0577246398,
0.6361812949,
0.6114282012,
0.3299010992,
0.6702334881,
-0.3439439535,
-0.0566997044,
-0.1446645409,
-0.2396811992,
-0.1606321782,
0.892990768,
0.3372021317,
-0.3722375929,
-0.4796865284,
0.0481842048,
0.0782257617,
-0.1514474601,
-0.472682476,
0.9856048822,
0.0972695425,
-0.7090650797,
-0.380764842,
0.0718375891,
-0.0136493491,
-0.6131056547,
-0.2729128301,
-0.1021049693,
-0.3543885052,
-0.048705548,
-0.464096874,
0.6605082154,
0.1856171489,
-0.4892091155,
-0.4299475551,
1.1552592516,
-0.1569275856,
-0.3193407357,
-0.1388733685,
1.0264191628,
-0.0042608376,
-0.4386176765,
-0.2000966072,
0.2751284242,
0.2621427774,
-0.4165430069,
0.3905905783,
0.620121181,
-0.1077461615,
-0.1631946564,
0.7821083665,
0.1195275933,
-0.1032876372,
-0.2204651684,
0.7713228464,
-1.0831124783,
-0.7625148296,
-1.0150375366,
0.3752390742,
-0.3372817338,
-0.3817431927,
0.6766785979,
0.8913871646,
0.0201580543,
0.1805544049,
0.9422588944,
-0.1831548959,
0.5708910227,
-0.2047199011,
0.6536053419,
-0.2295747697,
-0.0879173502,
-0.2148227692,
-0.736112237,
0.088843815,
0.0449094586,
-0.1461060643,
-0.4926280677,
0.6344876885,
-0.0621782616,
0.1746844053,
1.0458242893,
-0.096237652,
0.0144777559,
0.1792622209,
0.112037167,
1.057923913,
-0.0116306078,
0.5550310016,
-0.1390804946,
-0.3543455303,
-0.2007920295,
-0.9886131883,
-0.5092766881,
-0.7414224148,
-0.4207148552,
0.2053026259,
0.1008488908,
0.3333339989,
0.4536438882,
-0.5448326468,
0.1560604274,
0.0588614196,
0.5879364014,
-0.3843895495,
-0.2985987067,
0.3777531683,
-0.3006795943,
-0.4035140872,
0.5037038922,
0.4696994722,
-0.3532465994,
0.2083262205,
0.3951213658,
-0.3183642328,
-0.0436425246,
0.5817653537,
0.5610718727,
-0.0876937062,
-0.5180581212,
0.0441952311,
-0.1801274717,
0.2790330052,
1.1043764353,
-1.1035430431,
0.1214730889,
0.4492841363,
0.692519486,
1.0432326794,
-0.0012342478,
0.5642838478,
-0.7824106216,
-0.0218907613,
0.1232451573,
-0.0221368391,
0.0585640967,
-0.5718841553,
0.6087709069,
0.5066739917,
-0.2825103402,
-0.6600396633,
-0.1031278893,
-1.2897580862,
-0.1818535179,
1.2333701849,
0.2657303512,
-0.4507162273,
-0.3013060391,
-0.200840041,
0.2470245808,
-0.2674888074,
0.6390441656,
0.778886497,
-0.6002809405,
-0.3418009579,
-0.666282475,
0.0871064737,
-0.488668263,
-0.9795537591,
0.0246551856,
0.6564894319,
-0.1662112027,
0.3801422119,
0.6401825547,
-0.5075017214,
0.3907166421,
-0.0392788686,
0.0089557245,
-0.0401562043,
-0.3735016584,
-0.1207699999,
0.762362361,
-0.5600548387,
0.0040989518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08343v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08343v1 | Cluster-based Deep Ensemble Learning for Emotion Classification in Internet Memes | 2023-02-16T15:01:07 | 2023-02-16T15:01:07 | Xiaoyu Guo, Jing Ma, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Memes have gained popularity as a means to share visual ideas through the
Internet and social media by mixing text, images and videos, often for humorous
purposes. Research enabling automated analysis of memes has gained attention in
recent years, including among others the task of classifying the emotion
expressed in memes. In this paper, we propose a novel model, cluster-based deep
ensemble learning (CDEL), for emotion classification in memes. CDEL is a hybrid
model that leverages the benefits of a deep learning model in combination with
a clustering algorithm, which enhances the model with additional information
after clustering memes with similar facial features. We evaluate the
performance of CDEL on a benchmark dataset for emotion classification, proving
its effectiveness by outperforming a wide range of baseline models and
achieving state-of-the-art performance. Further evaluation through ablated
models demonstrates the effectiveness of the different components of CDEL. | [
-0.5956810117,
-0.6097880006,
0.1766489148,
0.247465387,
-0.5066306591,
0.4475041032,
-0.2978902757,
-0.6368979812,
0.394779861,
-0.0218667611,
-0.6556204557,
-0.5479564667,
-0.8646841049,
0.0798860118,
-0.6417196393,
0.7472877502,
0.0929225385,
-0.1342550069,
-0.2954855859,
-0.1583515853,
-0.1612606943,
-0.4883432388,
-0.807877481,
-0.206887573,
0.6675483584,
0.4693494737,
0.4394448698,
-0.1687203795,
0.4642173648,
0.4286430478,
0.15277946,
0.1285751909,
-0.5378734469,
-0.084567152,
0.1380852312,
-0.3586446643,
-0.2246458828,
0.2494188398,
0.2853820324,
0.3538017571,
-0.4090434611,
-0.2511118352,
-0.078560479,
0.7464446425,
-0.7841042876,
-0.1853847802,
-0.5192409754,
0.4071558416,
0.0270848349,
-0.0750939846,
-0.2496577799,
-0.5708765984,
0.2819736302,
-0.2348789871,
0.0406352989,
-0.2108654827,
0.3791992664,
0.1850611269,
-0.4966613352,
-0.437184453,
-0.4824210703,
0.9374456406,
-0.7438579798,
0.1239077523,
-0.202641055,
0.4476332366,
0.232682541,
-0.6797996759,
-0.9357445836,
0.1926761419,
-0.0150313266,
0.3347145617,
-0.6123256683,
-0.1203261018,
-0.2558437884,
0.6615541577,
-0.804853797,
0.489454329,
-0.2136662602,
0.0793847069,
0.8072243333,
0.066104807,
0.2954460382,
0.1075327769,
-0.5325185657,
-0.5151315928,
-0.2222520411,
0.0289871581,
0.2518927157,
-0.1167556047,
-0.2881399691,
0.1718847901,
-0.1626718342,
0.2476905584,
0.2020812929,
0.1295712292,
0.4177675545,
0.5473059416,
-0.4370943308,
0.2328678817,
0.8224993348,
0.4822496474,
0.3635173142,
0.1992543638,
-0.0549506024,
0.5395463705,
0.232393235,
-0.9584961534,
-0.2993893027,
0.3667441905,
-0.7858046889,
-0.6017394066,
0.0813017115,
-1.3870784044,
-0.6191599965,
-0.2736883759,
-0.0877713338,
-0.2025957108,
-0.6327047348,
-0.0940177664,
-0.0124404375,
-0.1826155931,
0.6451610327,
-0.4921598732,
0.2716569901,
0.5170075893,
0.7950516939,
-0.2608062923,
-0.042787984,
-0.1194678172,
-0.4587391317,
-0.2598155737,
1.077234149,
-0.9230161905,
-0.3257682621,
0.3734007776,
-0.0399368256,
-0.1654032618,
-0.5653322339,
0.5166723132,
-0.661329031,
0.0398480296,
0.2290553153,
-0.9907274246,
-0.4636194408,
0.2028427124,
-0.6736268401,
0.4515437484,
-0.1714344174,
-0.5238444805,
0.2302829623,
-0.7062817216,
-0.4375499487,
0.1234808043,
-0.0308639333,
-0.4106714129,
0.4982636273,
-0.1098002717,
0.9844554067,
-0.2107927203,
-0.03198893,
-0.8268140554,
-0.1935756058,
0.417111814,
-0.3154273033,
0.3739193082,
0.6952614188,
-0.2879480422,
-0.0307876766,
-0.8154189587,
-0.0283183455,
0.1876779646,
-0.0320378616,
-0.5312889218,
-0.0342316329,
0.1010820121,
0.3500159383,
0.0687127858,
-0.5489253998,
0.0277078189,
0.1053307429,
0.3449814916,
0.7545561194,
-0.1243150681,
0.5211037397,
0.0794151798,
0.3299508393,
0.3033946157,
0.1071922481,
0.1016909555,
-0.4363641143,
-0.5684639215,
-0.3067327738,
0.0708303154,
0.5424880981,
-0.4894523025,
0.8283213377,
0.1009588093,
-0.7760087252,
-0.4593988955,
-0.0045433389,
0.0361565463,
0.22495839,
0.3257181048,
-0.2466387153,
-0.2160860747,
-0.6849658489,
0.1594310552,
0.131123051,
0.1215269119,
0.4377148151,
0.3106127977,
-0.665792942,
0.4600537419,
-0.4062337875,
-0.1024745479,
-0.0997079834,
1.0778809786,
-0.037675187,
0.5955498815,
0.6601526737,
-1.0439231396,
-0.5123419166,
0.2385435402,
-0.9085769057,
-0.2340120226,
-0.1689157486,
0.1996553987,
0.1506330669,
0.2100192904,
-0.3480578661,
0.483587563,
0.835524559,
-0.26453951,
0.5710089207,
0.0281036794,
0.5260562301,
-0.7370301485,
-0.2087256461,
0.3505820036,
-0.0236311797,
-0.5420296192,
-0.3181124926,
0.0570767112,
-0.1549481601,
-0.536806643,
0.4556951821,
-0.2595863938,
0.0320377313,
-0.663628161,
-0.252140969,
-0.2181492001,
0.2983783484,
0.1095194742,
0.2210070342,
0.7291166186,
-0.6647718549,
0.7454819679,
0.1039114669,
-0.3832897246,
1.1029834747,
-0.2531068325,
0.4373891652,
-0.1072020903,
0.3164927065,
-0.9687092304,
-0.3403561115,
-0.0405664295,
-0.4721742272,
0.4627384841,
0.2854327261,
-0.4162510335,
-0.5653443336,
-0.2716936767,
0.5707981586,
0.728525579,
-0.9404575229,
0.6091788411,
0.2732897103,
0.0059600854,
-0.3945505917,
-0.3817466199,
0.1515561938,
-0.5699261427,
-0.779322505,
0.3317863345,
-0.122882463,
-0.1407800615,
0.2237978876,
0.1809204519,
-0.4543057978,
0.1469364464,
0.1756270826,
-0.3132051826,
0.0298938956,
0.298674643,
0.2472137511,
-0.0144689735,
-0.0866883695,
0.0591457076,
0.5845091939,
-0.3173422813,
-0.2306281179,
-0.7704979181,
0.7279089689,
0.5556493402,
-0.1471433342,
0.4748558104,
0.8413842916,
-0.5512836576,
-0.7216067314,
-0.7696128488,
-0.2730226219,
-0.4879574776,
0.2022309452,
-0.0500592999,
-1.2018960714,
0.5222529173,
-0.8496145606,
-0.3777714372,
0.4921257198,
0.3137341738,
-0.7357506752,
0.8827257156,
0.6358813643,
-0.4069918692,
0.3735549152,
-0.1623946428,
0.1617187858,
-0.3079969585,
-0.0526966266,
-0.4119494259,
-0.9846819639,
-0.6622030139,
-0.3542193472,
0.3173437119,
-0.163698554,
0.096292235,
-0.1207192615,
-0.3650374115,
0.3718465269,
0.4970555007,
0.2491042465,
-0.1659916639,
0.2519157231,
0.2294108123,
-0.0418489501,
-0.4481601119,
-0.1788248569,
0.4883483052,
0.2513909042,
0.9913141131,
-0.0343386754,
0.627312839,
0.7856077552,
0.1502546966,
-0.5255013704,
0.4840760827,
-0.7442324162,
-0.1251367629,
-0.0096417507,
-0.4083784819,
-0.998001039,
-0.2604905367,
-0.3783641458,
-0.7588468194,
0.461117655,
0.090191111,
-0.0758624449,
0.3813593686,
-0.6179507375,
0.9738729596,
-0.2275983095,
-0.075639233,
-1.0497199297,
-0.6970630884,
0.3979086578,
0.0181303695,
0.1592777967,
0.0407388285,
0.4189252853,
0.5226940513,
-0.3062754869,
1.1459864378,
-0.2061728835,
0.1902161688,
0.5978360772,
0.0193571225,
0.4253171086,
-0.334202379,
0.1225496083,
0.4904903173,
-0.4547736645,
-0.3390935361,
-0.7776309252,
0.9868402481,
-0.7020349503,
-0.0425980464,
-0.2371615171,
-0.1303955466,
0.1013223231,
-0.2959085405,
-0.0345838927,
0.2138886303,
-0.3611366451,
0.425837338,
0.6214174032,
-0.4405962825,
0.6808615923,
0.0736097619,
0.2319971621,
-0.3852321804,
0.9699520469,
-0.0629875436,
-0.0220618788,
0.3401185572,
0.1646269113,
-0.2812556922,
-0.1689878851,
-0.2294802219,
-0.1155282706,
-0.7444115877,
-0.2642711997,
-0.4655213952,
-0.0720372796,
-0.2299108058,
-0.423627913,
-0.4237804115,
-0.2317900509,
-0.3842678964,
-0.1123281717,
0.2708488405,
0.9432515502,
-0.2274170518,
0.5075524449,
-0.9731199145,
-0.2336605191,
0.7866627574,
0.4842077792,
0.2459171563,
-0.1231735796,
-0.0455340967,
-0.2968643606,
-0.3689371943,
-1.125898242,
0.4523356259,
0.3311534226,
0.2772960365,
0.9586749077,
0.173843056,
0.5577374697,
-0.2281914651,
0.483913362,
0.4932928085,
-0.8999166489,
0.4424645305,
-0.0904914513,
0.0383592546,
0.2561787963,
0.2918086648,
-0.5843798518,
-0.1016643867,
-0.6449778676,
-0.4579589963,
0.2036183476,
0.2244160473,
0.3609467745,
-0.2712733448,
0.3915156424,
0.152210027,
0.294615835,
-0.6555449963,
-0.1292609572,
-0.1041024178,
-0.5027528405,
0.0530173555,
-0.2871160805,
0.1665958911,
-0.1770955473,
0.4530189335,
-0.1826948971,
0.4898543954,
0.1019064188,
-0.2800816894,
-0.3897524476,
0.0354379192,
0.3321205378,
0.0162672289,
-0.1237097234,
0.3690411747,
0.1204174161,
-0.0579841286,
0.1666491032,
0.0350411348,
0.331930697,
-0.1232014373,
0.1838850379,
0.7557069063,
0.0827012062,
-0.7815872431,
0.5699605942,
-0.2125755697,
-0.2683187425,
-0.2827017903,
-0.0110950889,
-0.0750693753,
0.7792145014,
0.4026896656,
0.191378817,
0.6803556681,
-0.4158247411,
0.3936978579,
0.4572690129,
-0.3021615446,
-0.5839258432,
0.2762591243,
0.4011315405,
0.1250377148,
0.3567530513,
-0.4263328314,
-0.7082126737,
0.9633935094,
0.3551717997,
1.2672191858,
-0.6161015034,
0.5296558142,
0.3083289862,
0.0846310481,
0.2264995873,
0.1389608681,
0.0926796496,
-0.6969928741,
-0.2378397435,
-0.5834017992,
-0.3013641834,
0.1437706947,
-0.3054056168,
0.1114837304,
-0.5003948212,
0.2203010768,
-0.0562408715,
-0.1009295359,
-0.7734798789,
0.9142898321,
0.8523179889,
0.7106970549,
-1.1300957203,
0.7226571441,
0.7692924738,
0.0798180029,
-0.282345295,
-0.1276257932,
0.1742354482,
-0.5300276875,
0.3529676199,
0.7202739716,
0.1642962247,
0.0973492861,
-0.9268499613,
-0.4405868948,
0.9644837976,
-0.169117555,
-0.6648282409,
0.5942209363,
-0.0111159673,
0.7325549722,
-0.8229886889,
0.2106791288,
0.2113872021,
0.3175954819,
0.3460891247,
-0.3679661751,
-0.1438515037,
-0.4638528824,
-0.1853501052,
0.0279900339,
-0.7029604912,
0.8450706005,
0.0289121643,
-0.2795177102,
-0.3123224676,
0.9380515218,
-0.2080749571,
0.7401197553,
1.0643873215,
0.866866827,
0.9829630852,
0.1148758978,
1.0621902943,
0.1455595642,
0.3657372594,
0.8484196067,
-0.3062558472,
0.8970163465,
-0.0419527292,
-0.2594752312,
0.8396465182,
0.9940122962,
-0.2176636457,
0.7342444658,
0.1743094325,
-0.5181265473,
-0.2973980308,
-0.0623284131,
-0.1687948853,
0.4506501853,
0.5842535496,
-0.3027634025,
-0.1448375583,
0.0521163344,
0.044683367,
0.1372694075,
-0.5823959708,
1.0323255062,
0.0550442189,
-0.3305112422,
0.3728054762,
-0.3718100488,
0.7718350887,
-0.0740374327,
-0.0931985527,
-0.2123596966,
0.2750145793,
-0.3661846519,
-0.6026853919,
0.3876740336,
0.1115297899,
-0.1161535904,
0.2581558824,
0.9618089795,
-0.4136599004,
-0.7581994534,
0.7561727166,
0.2735987306,
0.2766358852,
-0.3080191314,
-1.0174988508,
-0.0390683599,
-0.2071183771,
-0.204518944,
0.4218274653,
0.6097842455,
0.0795536563,
0.5082932115,
0.4933658242,
-0.5054526925,
0.1415106654,
0.2406929582,
0.9461924434,
-0.5018239617,
-0.5101622939,
-0.9492791295,
0.740885973,
-0.5457339287,
-0.038264893,
0.1457190663,
0.0939480364,
0.4794250131,
-0.2645405233,
0.9807347655,
-0.2032026201,
0.3989144564,
-0.1881453097,
0.4953973591,
-0.8746154904,
-0.2209554762,
-0.4417063892,
-0.8510801196,
-0.3791049719,
0.6598403454,
-0.0754956976,
0.1356785595,
0.5742565393,
0.3106780946,
-0.1068640724,
0.4146250188,
0.449567467,
0.3359663785,
0.2233540416,
0.6422828436,
1.0236953497,
-0.0763604268,
0.1306880713,
-0.7312338352,
-0.6669408083,
-0.5231134892,
-0.9860510826,
-0.9577394724,
-0.4778179526,
-0.5777329803,
0.008728493,
-0.1803380251,
1.0556627512,
0.7766882777,
-1.0151562691,
-0.2147791386,
-0.1200211123,
0.0181562416,
-0.2416612059,
-0.2154534012,
0.2390908897,
-0.4486604929,
-0.8855015635,
0.3054677546,
0.3546092808,
0.0091533773,
0.0567163192,
-0.1229917556,
-0.2811760902,
0.0639555529,
0.6070593596,
0.0374541841,
-0.4839917123,
-0.097293213,
-0.232778281,
0.0894234851,
0.0445182323,
0.4596994817,
-0.3775961995,
0.492592603,
0.2262955755,
0.803545773,
0.443046391,
0.114546746,
0.3758001924,
-0.8587597609,
0.1802189946,
0.2122942507,
0.508151114,
0.3258467019,
-0.4519765377,
0.5167403817,
0.4143253863,
-0.7213548422,
-0.4654037952,
-0.1585006416,
-1.1739172935,
-0.5126767159,
0.7399385571,
-0.2324546874,
-0.1324163228,
0.5271896124,
-0.0920990855,
0.1763109714,
-0.5964972377,
1.2582796812,
0.58113873,
0.0332834907,
-0.5046450496,
-0.086766459,
0.2514811158,
0.4257335067,
-1.0799815655,
-0.2609727383,
0.5703278184,
-0.1759058088,
0.3073488772,
0.073808983,
0.3259256482,
0.3431097865,
-0.3515506685,
0.387383908,
0.6066197157,
-0.3757688999,
-0.3271901608,
0.4464116395,
-0.530896008,
-0.2298258394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08326v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08326v1 | NUAA-QMUL-AIIT at Memotion 3: Multi-modal Fusion with Squeeze-and-Excitation for Internet Meme Emotion Analysis | 2023-02-16T14:29:58 | 2023-02-16T14:29:58 | Xiaoyu Guo, Jing Ma, Arkaitz Zubiaga | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes the participation of our NUAA-QMUL-AIIT team in the
Memotion 3 shared task on meme emotion analysis. We propose a novel multi-modal
fusion method, Squeeze-and-Excitation Fusion (SEFusion), and embed it into our
system for emotion classification in memes. SEFusion is a simple fusion method
that employs fully connected layers, reshaping, and matrix multiplication.
SEFusion learns a weight for each modality and then applies it to its own
modality feature. We evaluate the performance of our system on the three
Memotion 3 sub-tasks. Among all participating systems in this Memotion 3 shared
task, our system ranked first on task A, fifth on task B, and second on task C.
Our proposed SEFusion provides the flexibility to fuse any features from
different modalities. The source code for our method is published on
https://github.com/xxxxxxxxy/memotion3-SEFusion. | [
-0.5469295979,
-0.6163740158,
0.055362165,
0.5345706344,
-0.4465809762,
0.0678646415,
0.1252333224,
-0.3943306804,
0.8184327483,
-0.0065008048,
-0.6007514,
0.0116740577,
-0.268017292,
0.1525632441,
-0.397538811,
0.6622866988,
-0.2742856741,
-0.0054841717,
-0.384685874,
-0.3972936571,
-0.1914702207,
-0.5427322984,
-0.342587918,
-0.1277810037,
0.3833605647,
0.6217592359,
0.3120753765,
0.0550480559,
0.4335635602,
0.352006644,
0.2197088152,
-0.1696788818,
-0.4123814106,
0.3719120622,
0.0027155876,
-0.2069346011,
-0.4449791908,
0.2551685572,
0.3942568302,
0.1009675711,
-0.0520870835,
0.0440769643,
0.0076626628,
0.6974024773,
-1.0007358789,
-0.3414059281,
-0.2339311689,
0.2943689227,
-0.0194665752,
-0.389180243,
-0.1112885624,
-0.5141689777,
0.28421399,
-0.2561384737,
0.1300953329,
0.0995635688,
0.6280865073,
0.2474722117,
-0.7391647696,
-0.1740115434,
-0.4292964339,
0.6734107733,
-0.5632423759,
0.2066873908,
0.0686783269,
0.3804463744,
0.3845453262,
-0.5411772132,
-0.9027004838,
0.357214421,
0.2509499788,
0.4666820467,
-0.3329466879,
-0.0124807404,
-0.0711975098,
0.6673950553,
-0.6421332359,
-0.2142582834,
-0.509257853,
-0.3799046874,
0.395997107,
0.0245976523,
0.5463893414,
-0.244209379,
-0.8037782907,
-0.3309153914,
-0.5276334286,
-0.3234532177,
0.2634866834,
-0.3604211807,
-0.2578791678,
0.4819132686,
0.0141850524,
0.2577393651,
-0.0553402007,
0.0219854154,
0.641064465,
-0.1524415463,
-0.5313121676,
0.1259963512,
0.9133908749,
0.3218293488,
-0.3425011635,
0.1523663998,
-0.0912268087,
0.1061036736,
0.1391887516,
-0.854098022,
-0.1400848478,
0.2779451609,
-0.5625652075,
-0.0157956351,
-0.0690043867,
-1.055852294,
-0.5312042236,
0.0021508685,
0.7673002481,
-0.8063492179,
-0.5307424068,
-0.0193770416,
-0.3774745464,
-0.0149602229,
0.3684442937,
-0.7725093365,
0.2800962031,
0.5022210479,
0.7597324848,
0.0232079513,
-0.5493112803,
-0.0889050514,
0.1928162277,
0.4193723798,
0.9594195485,
-0.5024288893,
-0.2451593429,
0.0435337424,
-0.1959653646,
-0.4774008989,
-0.6009535193,
0.4259033203,
-0.3765932322,
0.3615906239,
-0.128906846,
-0.6896688938,
-0.8489813805,
0.3173408508,
-1.1082421541,
0.7208178639,
0.3920546472,
-0.4921295047,
-0.0063463352,
-0.6307731271,
-0.4357388318,
-0.1712022722,
0.0409505926,
-0.2481118888,
0.2988371849,
-0.2242237777,
0.7643694878,
-0.4365248382,
-0.1656614691,
-0.6550748348,
-0.3584479094,
0.3742073774,
-0.1826359928,
0.633041501,
0.4713516533,
-0.6010317802,
0.1362636387,
-0.6147488952,
-0.0261333119,
-0.0680253729,
-0.1861844361,
-0.087660104,
-0.4759733081,
0.011876218,
0.5391576886,
0.1015737355,
-0.2165293396,
0.1184910238,
-0.1236416399,
0.3371311426,
0.4633454382,
0.2610037327,
0.5894711614,
-0.2240068913,
0.6598775387,
0.1667046696,
0.2693949342,
-0.0475344136,
-0.0737083629,
-0.8752359152,
-0.317941457,
-0.0345199667,
0.5238606334,
-0.7335447073,
0.2610212564,
0.0093741715,
-0.3770763278,
-0.4898440838,
0.2031565309,
0.3696314394,
0.2384748161,
0.403545171,
-0.2652846277,
-0.5263720155,
-1.1094822884,
0.0297539886,
-0.0581539944,
0.1204040647,
0.3811166286,
0.2622922361,
-0.1682034284,
0.3273993433,
-0.1410276443,
-0.4358762801,
-0.1218072847,
0.8320317268,
-0.1470320821,
0.5767558217,
0.6976590157,
-0.7906650305,
-0.4588642418,
-0.2513134181,
-0.5558939576,
-0.2965369225,
-0.1444603801,
-0.0533546433,
0.3280079067,
0.3124539852,
-0.4012052715,
0.2566204965,
0.6716828346,
-0.5572426319,
0.2801298797,
0.1388774812,
0.8138554096,
-1.1500207186,
0.1180009469,
-0.0894410089,
0.0391133688,
-0.6853193641,
-0.2222079337,
0.3982027471,
-0.0214902665,
-0.8352217078,
0.3247914314,
-0.6716818213,
0.1246915013,
-0.3193214536,
0.0638726279,
0.0263035763,
0.5678792,
-0.403344214,
0.4343861341,
0.3533431292,
-0.5740212798,
0.4407702982,
-0.0345818177,
-0.1310875863,
0.7965032458,
-0.1368140578,
0.3945011199,
0.1547674537,
0.1275141686,
-1.1311545372,
-0.497091651,
0.2903459966,
-0.4811122119,
0.3981455863,
0.4765024483,
-0.4423720539,
-0.3500258029,
-0.6365701556,
0.7802015543,
0.4661213756,
-0.3707500398,
0.9381456375,
0.5196427107,
-0.0332430191,
-0.2991259098,
-0.3627852201,
-0.131617412,
-0.5522097945,
-0.7826471925,
0.3427361846,
-0.0663169026,
-0.0011781553,
0.1274816096,
-0.1844345927,
-0.2795626521,
0.3997786045,
0.6388434768,
0.0509055816,
0.1007393599,
0.0783156902,
0.1992899626,
0.0595093705,
-0.1260109991,
0.4353739023,
0.6813753247,
-0.3976716697,
-0.4320035875,
-0.4044514894,
0.573648572,
0.6300899982,
-0.0228845943,
0.4138396978,
1.0212883949,
-0.4139120877,
0.0619551912,
-1.0895320177,
-0.1456682533,
-0.4162237644,
-0.0886359662,
-0.306688875,
-1.3385378122,
0.5566331744,
-0.3611975312,
-0.2425229549,
0.5685710907,
0.5595860481,
-0.258133024,
1.072551012,
0.5620761514,
-0.1725579053,
0.492148757,
-0.1603377461,
0.1656278968,
-0.8957698345,
-0.3625405431,
-0.4866316319,
-1.0522499084,
0.0679869205,
-0.5902581215,
0.4932354093,
0.1954813451,
0.0867741406,
0.0780180767,
-0.1753376573,
0.4078409374,
0.6034017801,
-0.1171424165,
-0.3682899773,
-0.1605728418,
0.0451129787,
0.009454852,
-0.2500085831,
0.0635779575,
0.3670434356,
0.1484616995,
0.7112376094,
0.5227407813,
0.8730377555,
0.1388999671,
0.168543011,
-0.7701925039,
0.7519989014,
0.2345364839,
-0.5313404202,
0.0928982273,
-0.1782478243,
-0.7302058935,
0.0413569584,
-0.3463242054,
-0.8624571562,
0.19295609,
0.1992031038,
-0.4847020805,
-0.0460202061,
-0.9076675773,
0.7336552739,
-0.0722435862,
-0.4130550325,
-0.697598815,
-1.0102602243,
0.6922762394,
0.1057504863,
0.0009744246,
-0.3348574638,
-0.0361930281,
0.7314795852,
-0.3237155378,
0.7073776722,
-0.2042856067,
0.2383333296,
0.4961797595,
0.3420859575,
0.0511502363,
-0.2601006031,
-0.020213645,
-0.1541849524,
-0.0808895528,
-0.1359972954,
-0.8458204269,
0.8582003117,
-0.5882115364,
-0.4106951654,
-0.293961972,
-0.304276824,
-0.2023147047,
0.0289961342,
0.0548050553,
0.2554500401,
-0.1520940512,
0.4840526283,
0.5749924779,
0.0945426077,
0.579003334,
0.3903357685,
0.0949745029,
-0.917142272,
1.1428091526,
-0.1779942513,
0.045923613,
0.3280930817,
0.1724308133,
-0.2758986652,
-0.0907781124,
-0.1373487115,
0.1309210509,
-0.6750228405,
-0.5201423764,
-0.9074554443,
0.0403520241,
-0.7503859401,
-0.2810122073,
-0.1354348063,
-0.7769464254,
-0.4933921993,
0.0195751116,
0.0863855407,
0.4223385155,
-0.3296121657,
0.3638899028,
-1.2149764299,
0.2731352746,
0.399181217,
0.2454472333,
-0.0127508407,
-0.236483261,
-0.2220459431,
-0.3914100528,
-0.6437764168,
-1.6555980444,
0.5172314644,
0.494247824,
0.4962272346,
0.7908412218,
-0.0607077479,
0.8366862535,
-0.0058747735,
0.9339803457,
0.6377515793,
-1.3635720015,
0.4100193083,
0.0037052578,
0.285343051,
0.6974366307,
0.3615352809,
-0.7492908835,
-0.2101145834,
-0.7976027727,
-1.102976799,
0.620516181,
0.044899933,
0.0904481485,
-0.2817808092,
0.1678717136,
0.0780203268,
0.1839105487,
-0.6519351602,
-0.3066095412,
-0.2654449344,
-0.3810305893,
0.2757853866,
-0.6472479105,
-0.0691435039,
-0.2210956961,
0.8656141758,
-0.2502447069,
0.5100582242,
0.1418054551,
-0.5194095373,
-0.1844399571,
0.2464152128,
0.5665791631,
0.0874606296,
-0.221089676,
0.6192339063,
0.1228818372,
-0.2741925716,
0.245110482,
0.0363200083,
0.2803363502,
-0.2031017244,
0.0075618979,
0.7874672413,
0.6265844107,
-0.5555801988,
0.8101533055,
-0.1806617379,
-0.4717964232,
0.0000023394,
0.1114402562,
0.1587924212,
0.7228949666,
0.1318988949,
-0.0515381917,
0.8553617597,
-0.4452177882,
0.1786051393,
0.3696326315,
-0.4586467147,
-0.6325675249,
0.4455628693,
0.4161086977,
0.1721857488,
0.3319191337,
-0.2128760666,
-0.8858683705,
0.5106240511,
0.7344033718,
1.3645751476,
-0.7327058315,
0.1893890351,
0.5129740238,
-0.0913832486,
0.0313598067,
0.6268848777,
-0.2670198679,
-0.4731496274,
-0.1371445805,
-0.3305517733,
-0.3379071355,
0.0415578,
-0.6721258163,
0.3257151246,
-0.341870755,
0.0315359905,
-0.1820661277,
-0.1257388592,
-0.5793641806,
0.2662315071,
0.4409270883,
0.8776162863,
-0.9296009541,
0.471018523,
0.866781354,
-0.2079616636,
-0.9687541127,
-0.3081470728,
0.5755297542,
-0.6403005719,
0.2299747914,
0.6402084827,
-0.1443131119,
0.0196662378,
-0.6235810518,
-0.8208657503,
1.4164806604,
0.1047098637,
0.1156758517,
0.4733843803,
-0.3761540055,
0.2707972825,
-0.286375314,
0.4927054644,
0.5232976675,
0.2979033291,
0.5952190161,
-0.6447955966,
0.2165715992,
-0.8456356525,
-0.4509858191,
0.4041707814,
-0.9104781747,
0.9088149071,
0.0060387286,
-0.5895047784,
-0.2724041045,
0.8891837001,
-0.1753927767,
0.3972088099,
0.7804402113,
0.8001669049,
0.768055141,
0.140539825,
0.8974699974,
-0.1230675355,
0.33905074,
1.0418030024,
-0.3850405812,
0.7152002454,
0.6575348973,
0.0196380541,
0.4350942075,
0.6247935891,
0.1466320008,
0.4038668275,
0.0944341868,
-0.61472857,
-0.02495718,
-0.1621044874,
-0.412091285,
0.4571433663,
0.4640324712,
-0.1489260346,
-0.1233522221,
0.1046177074,
0.1510791332,
-0.5592886806,
-0.0385547914,
1.0404366255,
-0.0825759694,
-0.6691653132,
0.5057175159,
-0.3529212773,
0.4770464599,
-0.2537950277,
-0.0297026392,
-0.2760877311,
-0.0347479023,
-0.314222008,
-0.4782529771,
0.2428556681,
-0.286709249,
0.0216057077,
-0.0552130267,
0.9764592052,
-0.5449003577,
0.0474350378,
0.1236677244,
0.594297111,
0.2606439292,
-0.1705733091,
-0.6287662387,
0.2383248508,
0.1472400576,
-0.4975393713,
0.3562727273,
0.4629451334,
0.1919746548,
0.5462914109,
0.2385634482,
-0.4149795175,
0.1359111667,
0.3843595088,
0.9043961167,
-0.9006692767,
-0.3578554988,
-1.0463944674,
0.5618975759,
-0.2026656866,
-0.0802603066,
0.6649516225,
0.5549334288,
0.184943527,
-0.1365698725,
0.7536687255,
-0.3267064095,
0.4369525313,
-0.4291000366,
0.3766468167,
-0.9439493418,
-0.3305024803,
-0.3453998268,
-0.995801568,
-0.4540226161,
0.4843547642,
0.2304979712,
-0.2364400178,
1.0916970968,
0.4904040098,
-0.1199934855,
0.4410592616,
0.2044240534,
0.0544276424,
0.3557685614,
0.9313388467,
1.1014890671,
-0.2881269157,
0.3905466795,
-0.6422980428,
-0.4409424961,
-0.7650108933,
-0.9864804745,
-0.5711182952,
-0.8136175275,
-0.4114063382,
-0.4137218893,
-0.7138994932,
1.1363281012,
0.469270885,
-0.6595810652,
-0.0549443029,
0.3737099767,
0.1399535984,
-0.2163147777,
-0.2302327305,
0.1061049551,
-0.1627185196,
-0.8509173393,
0.3731831312,
0.8163880706,
0.3361674249,
0.008284241,
0.0505636595,
-0.3643168509,
0.1295122206,
0.4556779563,
0.4053955674,
-0.4449049234,
-0.2274989337,
-0.0873925313,
-0.1781674176,
-0.0130846705,
1.1253408194,
-0.5659178495,
0.4931822717,
0.7743086219,
0.61291641,
0.363316834,
0.0938431919,
0.4210874736,
-0.6186451316,
-0.0446427912,
0.3283488452,
0.6364799142,
0.2887231112,
-0.1693363488,
0.5358992815,
0.217755571,
-0.5797533989,
-0.5503106117,
-0.0189367235,
-1.454113245,
-0.068175815,
1.1801097393,
-0.0024169614,
-0.5337362885,
0.1038897634,
-0.3795821071,
0.4512118399,
-0.3086976707,
0.8754606247,
0.7256084085,
-0.3344642818,
-0.3072516918,
-0.1391004324,
0.3287695348,
0.8345007896,
-0.9747402072,
-0.3976254463,
0.9625334144,
-0.1031331867,
0.5170947909,
0.7391737103,
0.0304275975,
0.5436097383,
-0.1887795031,
0.4259569645,
0.0883450061,
-0.3308792412,
-0.5532186031,
0.4687725008,
-0.4060714245,
-0.185967043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08268v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08268v1 | Retrieval-augmented Image Captioning | 2023-02-16T12:54:13 | 2023-02-16T12:54:13 | Rita Ramos, Desmond Elliott, Bruno Martins | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Inspired by retrieval-augmented language generation and pretrained Vision and
Language (V&L) encoders, we present a new approach to image captioning that
generates sentences given the input image and a set of captions retrieved from
a datastore, as opposed to the image alone. The encoder in our model jointly
processes the image and retrieved captions using a pretrained V&L BERT, while
the decoder attends to the multimodal encoder representations, benefiting from
the extra textual evidence from the retrieved captions. Experimental results on
the COCO dataset show that image captioning can be effectively formulated from
this new perspective. Our model, named EXTRA, benefits from using captions
retrieved from the training dataset, and it can also benefit from using an
external dataset without the need for retraining. Ablation studies show that
retrieving a sufficient number of captions (e.g., k=5) can improve captioning
quality. Our work contributes towards using pretrained V&L encoders for
generative tasks, instead of standard classification tasks. | [
-0.3752434552,
-0.4833906293,
0.2656930387,
0.0198398959,
-0.6876557469,
0.2030172199,
0.0394817591,
-0.5475793481,
0.4831648171,
0.8298504353,
-0.3774626255,
-0.0614171661,
-0.5038414598,
0.3116758466,
-0.537565589,
0.8251463175,
-0.1274262965,
0.326066196,
-0.6569744945,
-0.0387519971,
-0.5865596533,
-0.7807821035,
-0.3943247497,
0.0677833557,
0.490600884,
0.2509243786,
0.684419632,
0.5356194377,
0.7045443058,
0.2546112835,
0.4308451414,
0.4692182243,
-0.2342246026,
0.0547207519,
0.1682487875,
-0.6617277265,
0.2515648007,
-0.2070646584,
0.389657408,
0.2952619791,
0.0659703463,
-0.2490386665,
-0.3354400098,
0.8230323195,
-0.849630177,
0.2470023781,
-0.6412104368,
0.2513846457,
0.0287255123,
-0.5828435421,
-0.5336093307,
-0.325797379,
0.0607734844,
-0.7739812732,
0.5211593509,
0.4146423936,
1.0311387777,
0.2057760656,
-0.1780210435,
-0.320194155,
-0.4456281364,
0.5706517696,
-0.2040496022,
0.5335324407,
0.2380699366,
0.3163880706,
0.406539917,
-1.0179495811,
-0.7906295657,
-0.2679402232,
-0.2259375751,
0.1591253132,
0.0808867738,
-0.0569056086,
0.1769870818,
0.795706749,
-0.1897285879,
-0.2741494179,
-0.6296774149,
-0.2461525351,
0.6787111759,
-0.1592597067,
0.3944020271,
-0.1481452584,
-0.5632047057,
-0.374949187,
-1.0706560612,
-0.2845700681,
0.1094300598,
0.1724863499,
0.1219788417,
0.916813314,
-0.053630203,
0.63448596,
-0.0787273273,
0.4613889158,
0.4110429585,
-0.2985318005,
-0.1093805581,
0.1072623506,
0.7315030098,
0.4667843878,
0.3596053421,
-0.2871114612,
-0.2978565693,
-0.0037935085,
0.4528984129,
-0.564679563,
-0.5680927038,
-0.1830786467,
-0.2730593979,
-0.2898914814,
0.2432620972,
-0.7029635906,
-0.3604744077,
-0.4528798759,
0.6669626236,
-0.4994470477,
0.1713062525,
-0.1361523867,
-0.2009138167,
0.3518185616,
0.1092699617,
-0.7836847305,
0.2823130488,
0.0123076541,
0.7471879721,
-0.1844587028,
-0.2298291326,
-0.8043928742,
0.1164912954,
-0.4580309689,
0.7707029581,
-0.6531226039,
-0.2644506395,
0.4347991943,
0.1893614382,
0.1693867594,
-0.4583734274,
0.2686699927,
-1.0225205421,
0.1722748727,
-0.3885583878,
-0.4361260533,
-0.130684346,
0.2843057513,
-1.1018123627,
0.8048753738,
0.0103006978,
-0.5765301585,
0.5323002934,
-0.7707974315,
-0.6133794188,
0.2776114643,
-0.3364124894,
-0.4158313572,
0.2968259454,
0.8668044806,
0.3574750423,
-0.0974782258,
-0.1145954952,
0.1342088133,
-0.280831635,
0.3564005494,
-0.3730094433,
0.303697139,
0.2725184262,
0.1413928717,
-0.1343146861,
-0.440615207,
0.0588552989,
0.3051298261,
-0.3746228814,
-0.2148761898,
0.0417843759,
0.0811915323,
-0.0435692929,
0.3839545548,
-0.6931833029,
0.1203902662,
-0.274088949,
0.3509825468,
0.4467425942,
0.1304851621,
0.3672901988,
-0.2142182738,
0.486096561,
0.0308786072,
0.1474779546,
-0.7101226449,
-0.1401327699,
-0.9871300459,
-0.3293460608,
0.3142218888,
0.425635457,
-1.5907202959,
0.1523584574,
-0.3777419925,
-0.0046675126,
-0.7283432484,
0.2311580777,
0.5754385591,
0.2036166489,
0.5571556687,
-0.7148805261,
-0.680670321,
-0.8060851097,
0.245032385,
0.1666095257,
0.2369568199,
0.4015077949,
0.4202780128,
-0.1190074012,
0.7516713142,
-0.6076340079,
-0.3132633269,
-0.167891562,
0.0358837843,
-0.1395986825,
0.545409441,
0.51628232,
-1.2432841063,
-0.4755384326,
-0.0206704363,
-0.8512889147,
0.2625646591,
-0.1316231936,
-0.1923757046,
0.3567364216,
0.6694957018,
-0.6786202192,
0.2016557008,
0.2508701086,
0.3074240983,
0.6549327374,
-0.4357565939,
0.4830340743,
-0.8775612712,
-0.2270103246,
-0.3681019247,
-0.4092173278,
-0.2162132114,
0.4609723091,
-0.0295378175,
-0.3296023309,
-0.616171062,
0.2603300512,
-0.9185672998,
-0.2543171048,
-0.191969946,
-0.0912010521,
0.2919633687,
0.4954613149,
0.5732866526,
0.8084307909,
0.8536816835,
-0.4649864733,
0.9433243871,
0.511415422,
-0.4232780337,
0.3822662234,
-0.5946983695,
0.3528141677,
-0.4369620085,
0.0251591541,
-0.9655919671,
-0.3453247249,
0.0908764452,
-0.5327596068,
0.5202642083,
-0.064418532,
-0.7265710235,
-0.7316696048,
-0.3465396762,
0.3766527176,
0.4466612041,
-0.9112080336,
0.4295090735,
0.0748807117,
-0.1410964131,
-0.5735048652,
-0.8532233834,
0.2505093217,
0.0451075286,
-0.1683640331,
0.2162999213,
-0.0587102957,
0.2944065034,
0.1504593492,
0.1832516491,
-0.3112668097,
-0.4876993001,
0.1312523484,
0.4034119248,
-0.0794771984,
0.2848826945,
0.0942447111,
0.2454185486,
-0.0809028819,
-0.2033594847,
0.6200076342,
-0.0582391433,
-0.440440774,
-0.3689616621,
0.6105875969,
0.3452897966,
-0.6694632173,
0.787874639,
0.5339553952,
-0.3855582476,
0.3201042712,
-0.6035094857,
-0.1839086413,
-0.4715205133,
0.3253542483,
-0.3989394903,
-0.7431402206,
0.2381802797,
0.2842060626,
0.0111517189,
0.1136980951,
0.415899843,
-0.4514063895,
0.8583551049,
0.6882103086,
0.1664302796,
0.8100809455,
-0.4564195871,
-0.0015518815,
-0.7135373354,
-0.2800685465,
-0.0160571728,
-0.071412541,
-0.342172116,
-0.4788556695,
0.1715270281,
0.1629032642,
-0.0779513568,
0.5063350201,
-0.7169642448,
0.8238068819,
0.7396996617,
0.4661873579,
0.22448273,
0.513364017,
0.0644446835,
-0.1042162776,
-0.6159843802,
-0.3628539145,
1.2183773518,
-0.2123790383,
0.6860643625,
-0.0200732816,
0.8379272819,
0.5955107212,
0.4668329656,
-0.6515155435,
0.3767204881,
-0.2773771882,
-0.5770094991,
-0.1110600531,
-0.206373781,
-0.8867756128,
0.1555902213,
-0.4285362363,
-0.3876317739,
0.1087271273,
0.3888919055,
-0.2847695351,
-0.0332773551,
-0.7894084454,
0.7587758303,
-0.5456511378,
-0.3312106133,
0.0630244017,
-0.8306917548,
0.240502879,
0.0599425398,
0.01823253,
0.5081564188,
0.1398997009,
0.4781097174,
-0.419306308,
0.653614819,
-0.3206512034,
0.1380577385,
0.741080761,
-0.0506775454,
0.3697234392,
-0.0137462113,
0.255402267,
-0.2721545994,
0.1631761789,
-0.353653729,
-0.6550400853,
0.6093364954,
-0.7588290572,
-0.3388262391,
-0.2238264382,
-0.5207728148,
-0.019898463,
0.2328817248,
0.5408400893,
0.6200235486,
0.0608587824,
0.351711452,
0.7100097537,
-0.4596569836,
0.4027922153,
0.2056758255,
-0.1681389809,
-0.7190490961,
1.1105365753,
-0.1127427816,
0.3278585374,
0.8898746371,
-0.2631978989,
-0.618571043,
-0.4968520105,
-0.4620613158,
0.1580747068,
-0.8210200667,
-0.3821196854,
-0.5184289813,
-0.2309203893,
-0.3939980268,
-0.3081727326,
-0.3408545554,
-0.2162028104,
-0.2950746417,
-0.2257217914,
0.4860439003,
0.3429509103,
-0.0534336977,
0.5422564149,
-1.1169492006,
0.5133681297,
0.5052403808,
0.1475696564,
-0.2440174967,
-0.1855224967,
-0.2935764492,
0.1235764772,
-0.3152074814,
-0.754249692,
0.6613377929,
0.5011245608,
0.5268943906,
0.2200363576,
0.0368570536,
0.616035223,
-0.7778651118,
0.9339285493,
0.5561750531,
-0.6644240022,
0.6130778193,
0.0104630413,
-0.0354194269,
0.477496773,
0.3193528652,
-0.1059428379,
-0.1198212281,
-0.3786451221,
-0.8791658878,
0.34959355,
0.1647675484,
0.7826737761,
-0.3171389699,
0.4301083386,
0.1279841363,
0.5763098598,
-1.0671906471,
0.1051039025,
-0.6257404089,
-0.2765701115,
-0.1057103127,
-0.2824339569,
-0.1066286415,
-0.2650588155,
0.4257605076,
-0.1611149907,
0.6916993856,
0.3692245483,
-0.6302301884,
0.0308121722,
-0.012210357,
0.2497693598,
0.3171107769,
-0.0091613764,
0.1277433783,
-0.0870528668,
-0.2856033742,
-0.063437134,
0.2093134075,
0.1118652299,
0.0932689086,
0.400795877,
0.9792389274,
-0.1116335168,
-0.9748999476,
0.6653884649,
0.1493232846,
-0.1248869672,
-0.5295831561,
-0.1399040669,
-0.3326369226,
0.1015187949,
0.4798091948,
-0.0335305408,
0.1854728609,
-0.5707777143,
0.3048225641,
0.3474840522,
-0.4836998284,
-0.0971747637,
0.7715682387,
0.2774763405,
-0.1024271473,
0.7728484273,
-0.1637119055,
-0.4458310306,
0.5675778389,
0.5564953089,
0.4853681028,
0.2258360982,
0.18924734,
0.2918180525,
0.3870718181,
0.0072662751,
0.4038682282,
-0.2632218897,
-0.8813152909,
-0.6111075878,
-0.6056216359,
-0.1994834095,
-0.0774568245,
-0.8526802659,
0.0751316026,
-0.1510648876,
0.178092584,
-0.2726204991,
-0.2731078863,
-0.8652718067,
0.4705537558,
0.4082424045,
0.5857018232,
-0.7171231508,
0.5468937159,
0.8586246371,
-0.8302561045,
-0.3965384662,
-0.3830393255,
-0.610139966,
-0.9813261628,
0.6694031954,
0.3223130405,
0.1836691052,
0.1806576401,
-1.0421323776,
-0.7609996796,
1.0002053976,
0.3717545271,
-0.5977673531,
0.0258582812,
0.0473150685,
0.5568982959,
-0.4431115091,
-0.0499591418,
0.1673003733,
0.0981070772,
0.3532335758,
-0.5595030189,
-0.1504371166,
-0.4449504018,
0.1589137465,
0.0565583929,
-0.3526871502,
0.6818338633,
-0.497528404,
-0.2986426353,
0.4882747233,
0.8911614418,
0.2119323313,
0.10962338,
0.3214798272,
0.4614157677,
0.3748930693,
-0.1463169605,
1.4751628637,
-0.1424970031,
0.1997245699,
1.0848833323,
-0.1468957067,
0.9195999503,
0.7324669957,
-0.0610506833,
0.4826289117,
0.5683805346,
-0.2150657922,
1.0268896818,
0.0994501188,
-0.2808141112,
-0.3339995146,
-0.2062954605,
-0.2896039188,
0.1758292764,
0.1971384585,
-0.7162607908,
0.1660273224,
0.4838926196,
-0.5401331782,
0.2369818836,
-0.4131386876,
0.6954767704,
0.0066335881,
-0.484239459,
0.5789681077,
-0.4388684332,
0.5585898757,
-0.3644378483,
-0.2193192542,
-0.0415919796,
-0.0671781749,
-0.0568468124,
-0.8410039544,
0.1817978323,
0.0003304732,
-0.2164770663,
-0.2459839582,
0.5551297665,
-0.688991487,
-0.7081462145,
-0.1757211387,
0.4359275103,
0.3974680603,
-0.0552873909,
-0.2826241851,
-0.0361835063,
-0.0187228993,
0.0111244954,
-0.0719681755,
0.1993601471,
-0.0594957434,
0.4401630461,
0.6989622712,
-0.1135257334,
0.3943597376,
0.3526982665,
0.9677603841,
-0.4263471663,
-0.4126963913,
-0.5813688636,
0.4622261822,
-0.0583141074,
0.2264968902,
0.3676457703,
0.7018693686,
0.811095655,
-0.6217685938,
0.9679381847,
-0.3827860951,
0.0989963934,
-0.8766486645,
0.5155223608,
-0.6792256832,
-0.0824564099,
-0.2561194301,
-0.9420132041,
-0.4062407613,
0.5426857471,
-0.0958524197,
-0.1320658922,
0.5246291757,
0.7895274162,
0.0210045893,
-0.1132734194,
0.1974955052,
-0.2493656427,
0.2721738219,
0.5498553514,
1.0642170906,
-0.5991005301,
0.6824106574,
-0.2978591621,
0.1526734233,
-0.0003285967,
-0.705871582,
-0.7995694876,
-0.7104936242,
-0.3595201373,
0.0871013701,
0.2389640063,
0.70590204,
0.6427580118,
-0.7394302487,
0.3919929564,
-0.2571958899,
-0.2211150825,
-0.1260350794,
-0.2534370124,
0.351228565,
-0.4059693813,
-0.824251771,
0.1268724054,
-0.0625764132,
0.2388318628,
-0.0671709925,
-0.161339134,
-0.1837464869,
-0.0067563271,
0.8679708838,
0.3033225238,
-0.4967157245,
-0.3978569508,
-0.0277988203,
0.1163986772,
0.2227282226,
0.7240960002,
-0.7857381701,
0.8463874459,
0.2859654129,
0.7432076335,
0.7226317525,
0.1223187298,
0.496578902,
-1.1239944696,
0.1301049143,
0.0637771934,
0.4410603642,
0.7293982506,
-0.2763794363,
0.2518027127,
0.231943205,
-0.175034374,
-0.770442009,
0.1620263159,
-0.8867723346,
0.1414745301,
0.8561124206,
-0.2413109988,
-0.1696582437,
0.2991203964,
-0.507501483,
0.2625202537,
-0.1817578822,
0.6737214923,
0.5415341258,
0.0340067782,
-0.8492094278,
-0.2632330656,
0.1662327349,
0.1623774469,
-0.8482351303,
-0.1975689828,
0.8453562856,
0.0510378927,
0.4945855737,
0.4606707096,
-0.3893519044,
0.5055897236,
0.0524058193,
0.479038775,
-0.3806062639,
-0.5020741224,
0.0295083895,
0.0196118597,
-0.0748362616,
-0.7717898488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08258v1 | Tragic and Comical Networks. Clustering Dramatic Genres According to Structural Properties | 2023-02-16T12:36:16 | 2023-02-16T12:36:16 | Szemes Botond, Vida Bence | cs.CL | cs.CL | There is a growing tradition in the joint field of network studies and drama
history that produces interpretations from the character networks of the
plays.The potential of such an interpretation is that the diagrams provide a
different representation of the relationships between characters as compared to
reading the text or watching the performance. Our aim is to create a method
that is able to cluster texts with similar structures on the basis of the
play's well-interpretable and simple properties, independent from the number of
characters in the drama, or in other words, the size of the network. Finding
these features is the most important part of our research, as well as
establishing the appropriate statistical procedure to calculate the
similarities between the texts. Our data was downloaded from the DraCor
database and analyzed in R (we use the GerDracor and the ShakeDraCor
sub-collection). We want to propose a robust method based on the distribution
of words among characters; distribution of characters in scenes, average length
of speech acts, or character-specific and macro-level network properties such
as clusterization coefficient and network density. Based on these metrics a
supervised classification procedure is applied to the sub-collections to
classify comedies and tragedies using the Support Vector Machine (SVM) method.
Our research shows that this approach can also produce reliable results on a
small sample size. | [
-0.4650547802,
-0.4679310918,
0.0551398918,
0.4118981659,
-0.230451718,
0.1562558264,
0.134348914,
-0.2812429965,
0.9311258197,
0.6325176358,
-0.4836293161,
-0.3277952075,
-0.4471396804,
0.2519897521,
-0.4696673751,
1.0144592524,
0.2960545421,
-0.058080215,
-0.0628568754,
-0.4603407383,
-0.376514703,
-0.4786699414,
-0.7612333894,
-0.2210536003,
1.0377773046,
0.0605448261,
0.6178276539,
0.9336531758,
0.8031030893,
0.4402202666,
-0.2988894582,
-0.0601350553,
-0.7649406791,
0.348960638,
-0.2201841176,
-0.7534418106,
-0.0174680911,
-0.165280804,
0.6639900804,
0.6696403623,
-0.2362089455,
0.0283199549,
-0.1112338752,
0.6640080214,
-0.1815160215,
0.2697356641,
-0.3172995448,
0.6555882096,
-0.4566716254,
-0.5704565644,
-0.2831821144,
-0.6709344983,
-0.0255901981,
-0.2621758282,
0.4492669106,
0.2263695747,
0.9436848164,
0.0045476551,
-0.586098671,
-0.1785878986,
-0.8904210329,
0.8350628018,
-0.4265238345,
-0.3414287269,
0.197516799,
0.6221479774,
-0.301435113,
-0.6565458179,
-0.3552407324,
-0.2459846139,
-0.1346161067,
0.3897239566,
-0.2120354921,
0.1269441694,
0.0285294037,
0.6880168319,
-0.7101505995,
0.1163489819,
-0.6978593469,
-0.2382456958,
0.6735453606,
0.6489995122,
0.4840281308,
-0.6083570719,
-0.4007458985,
-0.1528490484,
-0.4389642775,
0.0905394554,
0.5841684341,
0.1893123388,
-0.0837754682,
0.6747412682,
0.001937683,
0.2955606878,
-0.3512143493,
-0.3599269092,
0.0503992215,
-0.0971785262,
-0.2415428013,
0.2939499021,
0.9254063964,
0.4097109735,
0.5904592872,
0.0302478671,
0.0748582035,
0.3373592198,
0.502532959,
-0.2437806427,
-0.545648396,
-0.4112727642,
-0.7435643673,
-0.8800781965,
-0.0250991341,
-0.598734498,
-0.6773262024,
-0.1784483641,
0.4573117793,
-0.5084124207,
-0.2692240179,
-0.3913785815,
-0.5359801054,
-0.2592772841,
0.158147797,
-0.5398102403,
0.5001780391,
0.3712690473,
0.9362781048,
0.043923676,
-0.231118381,
-0.2610580921,
0.0634949356,
-0.442909807,
0.7605974674,
-0.2980108857,
0.0687186196,
0.0169819035,
0.1795708388,
-0.2476927936,
-0.3969390988,
0.4078389108,
-0.4462544918,
-0.0836598799,
-0.2356040925,
-0.4394956231,
-0.5478735566,
0.224378705,
-1.2447441816,
0.6189894676,
0.095058009,
-1.2593455315,
0.3145021498,
-0.1171559617,
-0.7470223308,
-0.1068540514,
-0.420291543,
-0.171957463,
0.3924786448,
-0.1362127513,
0.5245703459,
-0.1227965876,
-0.0720509365,
-0.4765230417,
-0.6240490675,
0.3815205097,
-0.309353143,
0.4459065795,
0.373986721,
0.0352684222,
0.0689334646,
-0.6583405137,
-0.4998147786,
0.2040641904,
-0.1748284101,
-0.6728879213,
0.3381848633,
0.0878846571,
0.2550174594,
-0.0249479823,
-0.1225214675,
-0.0018113822,
-0.6251663566,
0.351233393,
0.4465616941,
0.0968166366,
0.3166004121,
-0.4967883825,
0.923789978,
0.2752398849,
0.0161703154,
0.0962258056,
-0.4364913702,
-0.6358405352,
-0.3490779698,
0.2591056526,
0.5878689885,
-0.9321474433,
0.2076099515,
-0.0678605288,
-0.4721812308,
-0.2037698627,
-0.3700633645,
0.2924881279,
0.4717024863,
0.0721170306,
-0.5788096786,
-0.6351172924,
-0.9324202538,
-0.164070189,
-0.3879960477,
0.1767482013,
0.3932544589,
0.0105909603,
0.4389954209,
0.9181434512,
-0.5542476177,
-0.5295046568,
-0.6813343763,
0.2238409817,
0.444796741,
0.154268235,
0.8543009758,
-0.8171378374,
-0.485660404,
0.3556625247,
-0.883556366,
-0.0248831939,
0.1525956243,
0.3100462556,
-0.1081291139,
0.3191826344,
-0.029386824,
0.471768111,
0.4562496543,
-0.1488739252,
0.7022592425,
-0.1193253621,
0.4642489254,
-1.2346665859,
-0.2249018103,
0.1520547718,
-0.209842056,
-0.5902345777,
-0.2943667769,
-0.639600873,
0.1053297296,
-0.3431626558,
0.2310303003,
-0.2219260633,
-0.2652371526,
0.1448922902,
0.3658125401,
-0.1238284707,
0.2951797247,
-0.2240669876,
0.3136531711,
0.6482881308,
-0.4976641536,
0.6728823781,
0.0870131403,
-0.2624058127,
0.5746738315,
-0.3869437575,
-0.4736359417,
-0.2864309847,
0.1444343328,
-1.2603216171,
-0.4619318545,
0.1043500528,
-0.2354514748,
0.3224155307,
-0.5699123144,
-0.3090446293,
-0.4459030628,
-0.1573122591,
0.4737105668,
0.2617694438,
-0.0273876991,
0.5349463224,
0.4972186983,
-0.446518451,
-0.7186632752,
-0.7447696328,
0.1273459643,
-1.0209054947,
-0.8809571266,
0.1152078733,
0.2503902912,
-0.3038111627,
0.0408089906,
-0.0774693191,
-0.4171233177,
-0.1412679106,
0.1949344575,
-0.1871716082,
-0.4512085915,
-0.0684400275,
0.4661582708,
-0.0211020224,
-0.2120785713,
0.0747769028,
0.4313297868,
0.1831009686,
0.1773641407,
-0.3226738572,
0.5616836548,
0.6821655631,
0.0735093802,
0.8592510819,
0.5005761385,
-0.2340875119,
-0.3051501811,
-0.2545542419,
0.1131616309,
-0.41733706,
0.2542080879,
-0.3527196646,
-1.0966279507,
1.1830236912,
-0.0183130987,
-0.372058779,
0.6042703986,
0.2254757881,
-0.3890805542,
0.8413175344,
0.6395938396,
-0.2886910141,
0.4867107272,
-0.0780259967,
0.0640432835,
-0.4765027463,
-0.0819812268,
-0.6404528618,
-0.7662516832,
-0.6754978299,
-0.0448578857,
0.5530481935,
0.3401499391,
0.0429605804,
0.6361754537,
-0.2017722726,
0.3159929514,
0.0682292953,
-0.0498704016,
0.2541854382,
0.3268566728,
-0.4509590566,
-0.2802293897,
-0.7340342999,
-0.512435317,
0.4785369635,
0.3791554868,
0.8046515584,
0.453096211,
0.8236657977,
0.3706443012,
0.1801185757,
-0.7813921571,
0.5892896652,
-0.5591747165,
-0.5303675532,
-0.3897344768,
-0.9178986549,
-1.0391130447,
0.1479692012,
-0.0627724826,
-1.0499879122,
0.472519666,
0.1109430417,
-0.1457666457,
0.1615026146,
-0.2897387147,
0.7072588801,
0.4525346458,
0.3251072764,
-0.4372396767,
-0.8747124076,
0.6084702015,
0.2230747491,
0.1834958941,
0.269813627,
0.5283702016,
0.9347394109,
-0.4592729509,
0.7933066487,
0.3268653154,
0.2678552568,
0.6000632644,
0.5634282827,
0.2869199514,
-0.1418139935,
-0.2043118924,
0.0531871915,
0.2270036042,
-0.1055271402,
-0.5175522566,
0.7809738517,
-0.7140234709,
0.0980222151,
-0.526516974,
-0.5380635858,
0.1262750328,
-0.0981583968,
0.4008475244,
0.929492414,
-0.3971859515,
0.2510522306,
0.4657031,
-0.074601151,
0.5542286634,
-0.0301338136,
-0.2122870684,
-0.6513613462,
0.8538366556,
0.4041438997,
0.1270262152,
0.533655107,
0.2744794786,
-0.2722524703,
-0.4825072289,
-0.1681760252,
0.369527638,
-0.7788608074,
-0.1211043447,
-0.7405777574,
-0.3384456038,
-0.0981646851,
-0.0665981323,
-0.133622244,
-0.6338628531,
-0.4177540243,
-0.1491388977,
0.3753148913,
1.0040563345,
-0.0758719668,
0.4095906913,
-0.7082679272,
-0.0862976015,
-0.0122100459,
0.1659047157,
0.1020202115,
-0.4348781407,
-0.4654033184,
-0.6465639472,
-0.3864145875,
-1.0893608332,
0.493928194,
0.1868999749,
0.2265175879,
0.8564078808,
0.1439795047,
0.5325964689,
-0.4694526494,
0.6926445365,
0.4497171938,
-0.3772736192,
0.3554906547,
-0.4626305103,
-0.5628827214,
0.4819228053,
0.4650492966,
-0.5454183221,
-0.4309467077,
-0.6218780279,
-0.6470192075,
0.9399294257,
0.5184166431,
-0.0010702163,
-0.1468588114,
0.2296084911,
-0.1197358817,
0.3395374119,
-0.5618060827,
-0.4647421539,
-0.0583542734,
-0.407538861,
-0.1740225106,
-0.135056138,
-0.3245790303,
0.0382848121,
0.1598487347,
0.00555663,
0.0640946627,
0.2270869613,
0.0897219032,
-0.256257087,
0.0015544217,
0.5390767455,
0.6911895275,
-0.1996827722,
0.4082780182,
-0.0272500925,
-0.7888094187,
0.0700451583,
-0.1206028685,
0.2464766204,
0.1618421525,
0.5657315254,
0.6288323402,
0.1304609925,
-0.1790085584,
0.3319792747,
-0.1200184077,
-0.1051926985,
-0.4070079327,
0.3955288529,
-0.0223522224,
0.5456335545,
0.2497006953,
0.0926618576,
0.4026666582,
-0.7141737938,
0.355337441,
-0.2326478511,
-0.7203478217,
-0.2462646961,
0.190351367,
-0.1967836767,
-0.4191698134,
0.3607346416,
-0.2630206943,
-0.4918213487,
1.0584971905,
0.5621162057,
0.8114668131,
-0.3587126732,
0.6338611841,
0.0973260179,
0.41779688,
-0.1716753691,
0.0895868018,
0.4438621998,
-0.5683817863,
-0.5108831525,
-0.9260469675,
-0.0596383587,
0.0924668834,
-0.6733469367,
0.2221890986,
-0.2469723374,
-0.0503448583,
-0.0009086132,
-0.1684898436,
-0.245075345,
0.4590907991,
-0.1207266375,
0.6931241751,
-1.2967354059,
0.4370942712,
0.7976057529,
-0.5668303967,
-1.1141318083,
-0.1516990364,
0.0747881979,
-0.1057009026,
0.5352571607,
-0.0553658083,
0.2240102738,
0.0532428324,
-0.0430862121,
-0.6991270781,
1.0540223122,
0.2049939185,
-0.5431095362,
-0.0965262353,
0.161802873,
0.7475451827,
-0.6398884058,
0.4321042299,
0.2349531353,
0.2397349328,
0.5294156075,
-0.8599978685,
-0.1098522097,
-0.0380807668,
0.0707938001,
0.4101251662,
-0.5873500705,
0.7790176868,
0.2734748125,
-0.1997202337,
0.0476279557,
0.7823243737,
0.2238110453,
0.7090304494,
0.5592805743,
0.4588620365,
0.5173221231,
-0.1165203974,
1.0197689533,
0.2682123184,
0.6516687274,
0.6352587342,
-0.0182633959,
0.3200888634,
0.1513589919,
-0.1896606088,
0.6227288842,
0.8007987142,
0.1215057075,
0.6334039569,
0.7828975916,
-0.1343676001,
-0.148246333,
-0.0450427979,
-0.1135196611,
0.3953132331,
0.2102706432,
-0.5830073953,
-0.2205727845,
-0.0163752064,
-0.0907292888,
0.1724537462,
-0.390925616,
0.612627387,
0.6549798846,
-0.1687314808,
0.0947945267,
-0.0715987459,
0.0699409917,
-0.557939887,
-0.1411467642,
-0.221796453,
0.1283648014,
-0.2268000394,
-0.6195725203,
0.6028943062,
-0.2648906112,
-0.3461187184,
0.6095481515,
0.7331210375,
-0.2216187268,
-0.5685659647,
0.2211449295,
0.136854291,
0.6457217336,
0.2626241446,
-0.4367983341,
-0.0138202766,
-0.1906470507,
-0.1128737777,
0.3548755646,
0.9275038242,
-0.3616410792,
0.5905795097,
0.1459005028,
0.3349951208,
0.0616152994,
0.4495505095,
0.7809458971,
-0.8166761994,
-0.8989366889,
-0.5356165767,
0.7344177365,
-0.1744710356,
-0.4784579277,
0.5484573841,
0.1684728265,
0.283780694,
-0.0309534688,
0.5044138432,
-0.271099925,
0.2774131894,
-0.4086107314,
1.0874457359,
-0.5923841596,
0.1331889331,
-0.7589648962,
-1.0536407232,
-0.3022924364,
0.7220874429,
0.0910977945,
-0.0040164324,
0.9095650911,
0.78154248,
-0.2334834635,
0.1038382426,
0.4312672019,
0.451477021,
0.111658074,
0.2269836068,
0.9282315969,
-0.2827790082,
0.5674129128,
0.0600404032,
-0.4513351619,
-0.4680824876,
-0.9127048254,
-1.1107494831,
-0.5742534399,
-0.3331048787,
-0.4551842213,
-0.0465927087,
0.3871798515,
0.2767549753,
-0.5804101229,
-0.2947648764,
0.084031187,
0.346907109,
-0.676555872,
-0.3283650279,
0.3240894377,
-0.0008476909,
-0.2885833979,
0.560795486,
0.4094184339,
-0.4033184648,
-0.4624533355,
0.1131779701,
0.0309306476,
0.5075857043,
0.519028008,
0.1324293017,
-0.4111830592,
-0.3209905326,
-0.3111104667,
-0.1042977422,
0.0017146966,
0.7157921195,
-0.423289746,
0.2384369075,
0.9428616166,
0.072785303,
0.404884249,
-0.0719448105,
0.4718881845,
-0.8231706619,
-0.1785029024,
0.3106231689,
0.4040262699,
-0.0064772875,
-0.4346437156,
0.4600755572,
0.5150040984,
-0.529096961,
-0.8382764459,
0.3667567968,
-1.4000415802,
0.0856955573,
0.7004586458,
-0.2529211044,
-0.2253482491,
-0.3153865933,
-0.1774596125,
0.492475003,
-0.1951815933,
0.7297691703,
0.6805506349,
-0.3391278386,
-0.1869547516,
-0.3610787094,
0.4355337322,
-0.062951833,
-0.3588760495,
-0.3327819109,
0.3587013483,
0.2451881766,
0.58373034,
0.1674505919,
-0.2989548445,
-0.0971313044,
-0.1653359979,
-0.0754808411,
0.2703039944,
-0.7861021161,
-0.2387685329,
0.7160288095,
-0.3933087587,
0.1963563859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08229v1 | Improving Spoken Language Identification with Map-Mix | 2023-02-16T11:27:46 | 2023-02-16T11:27:46 | Shangeth Rajaa, Kriti Anandan, Swaraj Dalmia, Tarun Gupta, Eng Siong Chng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The pre-trained multi-lingual XLSR model generalizes well for language
identification after fine-tuning on unseen languages. However, the performance
significantly degrades when the languages are not very distinct from each
other, for example, in the case of dialects. Low resource dialect
classification remains a challenging problem to solve. We present a new data
augmentation method that leverages model training dynamics of individual data
points to improve sampling for latent mixup. The method works well in
low-resource settings where generalization is paramount. Our datamaps-based
mixup technique, which we call Map-Mix improves weighted F1 scores by 2%
compared to the random mixup baseline and results in a significantly
well-calibrated model. The code for our method is open sourced on
https://github.com/skit-ai/Map-Mix. | [
-0.5133547783,
-0.4603705704,
0.0639585108,
0.1374802738,
-0.2757254541,
0.4521873593,
-0.4628574252,
-0.6281459332,
0.2931420207,
0.3909630775,
-0.3108822703,
-0.3285326362,
-0.4368989468,
-0.2061977834,
-0.330050379,
0.7255982757,
0.2383563817,
0.1126004308,
0.1141079217,
-0.3987961709,
-0.4094722867,
-0.4572108388,
-0.6719604731,
-0.4677738547,
0.4209295511,
0.6518512368,
0.9215098619,
0.4404120445,
0.3458647132,
0.3221590221,
-0.2453423738,
0.3900437951,
-0.6105874181,
0.0661174804,
0.2850810885,
-0.2402938753,
-0.51761204,
0.0667478442,
0.6445653439,
1.0203703642,
-0.3339675665,
-0.0204933174,
-0.0536640957,
0.2321019322,
-0.6339283586,
0.214388296,
-0.7108522654,
0.0438899547,
-0.3892899752,
-0.2898646891,
-0.3043923676,
-0.1163075343,
0.1463422328,
-0.7420501709,
0.1934932917,
0.0120214298,
0.7185404301,
0.0990379751,
-0.2136432528,
0.0922286659,
-0.8183285594,
0.8713055849,
-0.7671400309,
0.3051258326,
0.4788994193,
0.5425044894,
-0.0372518413,
-0.2383933812,
-0.7469011545,
-0.0788657218,
-0.1362030357,
-0.0553008579,
0.1313951313,
-0.1919373721,
0.3531850874,
0.4996665418,
-0.554013133,
0.1111793742,
-0.2677132785,
-0.1676670909,
0.6731968522,
0.0812691748,
0.4275235236,
0.0512704849,
-0.0654881299,
-0.2938397825,
-0.7622953653,
0.0378876403,
0.3954372704,
0.8883562088,
-0.2019609958,
0.3588669896,
-0.197510615,
0.9581401944,
0.1653743237,
-0.020540053,
0.735003829,
-0.3247343302,
-0.2402051985,
-0.1228778139,
0.5670891404,
0.268661052,
0.2636133134,
0.062180005,
-0.5565160513,
-0.4380434453,
-0.2101174593,
-0.5324522257,
-0.4805012941,
-0.0068012639,
-0.078476578,
-0.2531004846,
0.0157738943,
-0.6264426708,
-0.5207551718,
-0.4384908378,
0.318323791,
-0.4981559515,
-0.5992052555,
-0.1634665281,
-0.0019155617,
0.2414773107,
0.4574736655,
-0.855474174,
0.3964672089,
0.4669126868,
0.714089632,
-0.1338954866,
-0.0666851625,
-0.8056833744,
-0.0841674805,
-0.4954829216,
0.6214309931,
-0.693374157,
-0.403475821,
-0.0578631088,
-0.2129311264,
0.0197759848,
-1.2128282785,
0.0258300863,
-0.5147592425,
0.2797391117,
-0.2265889943,
-0.2702263892,
-0.0501549989,
0.0511371717,
-0.9621145129,
1.5552127361,
0.5604978204,
-0.488913238,
0.5807798505,
-0.4484190345,
-0.4862026572,
0.2947453856,
-0.1856431365,
-0.3785557747,
0.0269760527,
0.4160035849,
0.2061824352,
-0.090981029,
0.0992597714,
-0.2846310735,
-0.6086091399,
0.1927196831,
-0.0972298533,
0.8558749557,
0.3584138453,
-0.0292026997,
-0.1202960312,
-0.9985124469,
0.2821561396,
-0.0253854059,
-0.4276815355,
-0.4403248131,
-0.2208779156,
0.6041232347,
0.162204653,
0.0247305371,
-0.2371754199,
0.0893201828,
-0.4421764016,
-0.0486326329,
0.5141618252,
-0.2705857754,
0.5839219689,
-0.4494063258,
0.5880859494,
0.4267679453,
-0.2914331555,
-0.2565042078,
-0.5154404044,
-0.9410412312,
-0.4380804002,
0.8038200736,
0.7082983851,
-0.752045095,
0.5313662291,
-0.4403753877,
-0.5064377785,
-0.6177690625,
0.3670738637,
0.1806040406,
0.2268385142,
0.642500937,
-0.4218461812,
-0.5689756274,
-0.5421409011,
-0.0721809193,
0.0704455599,
-0.214403078,
0.4022069871,
-0.0078937141,
-0.266938448,
0.9898912311,
-0.3131241202,
-0.1225061342,
-0.5233579874,
0.2043654919,
0.1081697568,
0.5705333352,
0.8369815946,
-0.6575052142,
-0.6828212142,
0.2318465859,
-0.1981172413,
-0.3587097824,
0.0834854096,
0.2216999829,
-0.0022899725,
0.3312773705,
-0.0187037848,
0.1693606824,
0.5814247727,
-0.156427756,
0.020461319,
-0.0206644814,
0.331114471,
-0.8617345691,
0.0327744335,
0.0019030438,
-0.462766856,
-0.7133831382,
-0.0397865623,
0.0209423453,
-0.4123959243,
-0.4590175748,
0.5487978458,
-0.4206373394,
-0.0113790361,
-0.3930191994,
-0.00042495,
-0.2665999234,
0.3148583472,
0.1433865428,
0.9112530351,
0.6029790044,
-0.4073939621,
0.2948652506,
-0.0664068833,
-0.4873825908,
0.3480334282,
-0.3357467949,
0.2280280739,
-0.0043701245,
0.1097442061,
-1.1460770369,
-0.1951385587,
0.1351003796,
-0.2633080482,
0.6265397072,
-0.2795881033,
-0.3152499795,
0.1280075461,
0.0828661546,
0.5445336699,
0.550814867,
-0.6362876892,
0.6390607357,
0.5459170938,
-0.3892334402,
-0.5086681843,
-0.7160001993,
-0.0696024373,
-0.2360561788,
-0.4352767766,
0.3911208212,
-0.096709542,
-0.291436106,
-0.1707058549,
-0.0717612803,
-0.6134864092,
-0.0899696723,
0.0368710943,
0.1170951799,
-0.2728830576,
0.0090297842,
0.0508945957,
-0.0971820205,
-0.4850097895,
-0.0325926431,
0.5411865115,
0.0973559171,
-0.2919131219,
-0.3233144283,
0.429050684,
0.4807901978,
-0.1492703855,
0.4906975627,
0.7145414948,
-0.3198329508,
-0.2175272703,
-0.4228636622,
0.0609117411,
-0.4464693666,
0.2648842633,
-0.4392867088,
-0.6259542704,
0.6180382371,
-0.1725437045,
-0.1929350495,
0.205741927,
0.2295161784,
-0.2099332213,
0.6675198674,
0.5612469912,
-0.5663701892,
0.7166211605,
-0.3720795214,
0.1131394804,
-0.4838388264,
0.2085553706,
-0.5630764365,
-0.4399590492,
-0.5881587267,
-0.6935869455,
0.2344130725,
-0.1838781238,
0.2551229298,
0.2332063168,
-0.0674238726,
0.7211856246,
0.566685617,
0.2140853107,
0.222224921,
0.1123109758,
-0.1247066557,
-0.1791503578,
-0.7221450806,
-0.0583680943,
1.217848897,
0.0102252821,
0.8110055923,
0.1501208395,
0.8289929032,
0.3987303376,
0.3494123518,
-0.4555120766,
0.5313824415,
-0.0509443991,
-0.4142303765,
-0.3277975023,
-0.6369446516,
-0.6388263106,
0.3935832977,
-0.4743457437,
-0.2592487037,
0.1591718793,
0.372564733,
-0.3246088922,
-0.0830127001,
-0.9535883069,
0.610003531,
-0.2246462256,
-0.1536895931,
-0.1340738684,
-0.3920572698,
0.1732702404,
-0.4648397863,
0.4694643319,
-0.0309782028,
0.2561168969,
0.619615376,
-0.5770425797,
0.7042114735,
-0.4351089299,
-0.0136485798,
0.2060934454,
-0.2175490409,
0.4453319311,
-0.1336106062,
-0.1599715799,
0.2911923528,
-0.1695301682,
-0.6398293376,
-0.8056947589,
0.6629943848,
-0.8760622144,
-0.2463127673,
-0.2738076746,
-0.5318100452,
-0.2618454397,
0.0153579721,
0.0649582669,
0.5893353224,
-0.0965975896,
0.1178881899,
0.5245723128,
-0.210146755,
0.1529350132,
0.6314886212,
-0.1748270541,
-0.5588149428,
0.8887147903,
0.0886518285,
0.359641552,
0.4628166854,
0.2152085006,
-0.1059008241,
-0.6072177291,
-0.2899681628,
-0.0392746888,
-0.6244433522,
-0.0640517771,
-0.0975169316,
-0.1314923614,
-0.376339525,
0.052067481,
-0.2969890833,
-0.6600089669,
-0.0953489095,
-0.0084156897,
0.0976030305,
0.5779345036,
-0.1978478879,
0.8029803038,
-0.5137249231,
0.3002016544,
0.216013968,
0.2585139871,
-0.3466984332,
-0.7317434549,
-0.3653554022,
0.0780590847,
-0.0837449431,
-0.9214269519,
0.3199025691,
0.4367476106,
0.7390240431,
0.5163051486,
-0.0806107596,
0.9967783689,
-0.4582182765,
0.4737165272,
0.1175728738,
-1.0310947895,
0.4289583564,
-0.1915777475,
0.4075596929,
0.615439415,
0.0989594534,
-0.5418074131,
-0.6168241501,
-0.4523206651,
-0.9471165538,
0.8365921378,
0.1068356261,
0.1638994068,
0.1619937122,
-0.0129244756,
-0.0102680773,
0.0382933058,
-0.8401347995,
-0.4462474287,
-0.0852860808,
-0.4185860753,
-0.4559812844,
-0.1676423252,
-0.2284501195,
-0.5691170096,
0.6745300293,
-0.1289210469,
-0.0089364788,
-0.4338185787,
-0.397459805,
-0.3147253692,
0.2312446386,
0.6366384625,
0.5610601306,
-0.3010249138,
0.1209027544,
0.1735512763,
-0.4470785558,
0.2044696063,
0.3659881353,
-0.1802516282,
0.156123504,
0.4201954007,
0.6816536188,
0.413148582,
-0.6299991012,
0.3892772794,
-0.0084614167,
0.0780131891,
-0.182179153,
0.3753457665,
-0.238491863,
0.1592545658,
0.4317774177,
0.2021437734,
-0.0247710869,
-0.3026122749,
0.2273484766,
0.4574819505,
-0.1928569525,
-0.1374351084,
0.1713314205,
0.389804095,
-0.2457009107,
0.6191212535,
-0.1742524952,
-0.4859580994,
0.5155895948,
0.3201721609,
0.6050220132,
-0.6022436023,
-0.0684346929,
0.2011613697,
0.4908477366,
0.203967303,
0.3855487704,
-0.3139036894,
-0.9134299159,
-0.3738843203,
-0.2906745076,
-0.5078857541,
0.4640648961,
-0.5471165776,
0.5716866255,
-0.2199928164,
-0.2268347293,
0.0333254226,
0.0767994151,
-0.7497071028,
0.2743252218,
0.371439904,
0.805900991,
-1.286218524,
0.9468576312,
0.5604351759,
-0.1678008288,
-0.7241758704,
0.1980509311,
0.0480343848,
-0.5920717716,
0.6845453382,
0.0618953705,
-0.0078961579,
-0.0314868577,
-0.180804193,
-0.8559208512,
0.7335888743,
0.2194217145,
-0.3954324126,
0.3521398902,
0.3387970328,
0.4725083709,
-0.4289254844,
0.6391109824,
0.4530130625,
0.5423845053,
0.3234778941,
-1.0374855995,
-0.3198637366,
-0.3107035756,
-0.0997860581,
0.1883292645,
-0.1478266567,
0.6838966012,
-0.2510740757,
-0.2109531611,
-0.0618595779,
0.5268442631,
0.0533553399,
0.2899042368,
0.8348913193,
0.7609102726,
1.0174505711,
-0.3225265741,
0.5203878284,
-0.2640871108,
0.3492618203,
1.3354119062,
-0.452172488,
0.8920320272,
0.3249703348,
-0.2413515598,
0.4067177773,
0.6820560098,
0.1573122144,
0.7471888065,
0.1365425736,
-0.1953330934,
-0.3480378091,
0.2924572229,
-0.5293810964,
0.5926592946,
0.4336377084,
-0.1891480684,
-0.3682641387,
-0.001229309,
-0.1388870925,
-0.0794392526,
0.0179400109,
0.7322196364,
-0.3544006348,
-0.4460908175,
0.9405745864,
-0.0455724075,
0.4246476293,
-0.4734187126,
-0.099386923,
-0.4860807061,
0.0631562695,
-0.1669865996,
-0.5139067769,
0.167890206,
-0.1993921548,
-0.2095220834,
-0.1285969615,
0.260779798,
-1.0217387676,
-0.4455030859,
0.2738357782,
0.5161374807,
0.005096022,
0.1714691818,
-0.5430545211,
0.1985627413,
-0.1160099357,
0.0723260343,
0.2393112034,
0.3822634816,
0.0481379703,
0.40992558,
0.6065177321,
0.34763515,
0.189777419,
0.32513991,
0.8266186714,
-0.5495071411,
-0.6775252223,
-0.5013638139,
0.2913771272,
-0.3514620066,
-0.1206109077,
0.5371373296,
0.8431488276,
1.0363734961,
-0.100217171,
0.8511552811,
0.0606052764,
0.840565145,
-0.3919874132,
0.6231262684,
-0.7071362734,
0.4930956364,
-0.3816625178,
-0.7385956645,
-0.3209085464,
0.5280672312,
-0.2424228191,
0.2699012458,
0.4343004823,
0.916416347,
-0.5170403719,
-0.2434943616,
0.4708118141,
-0.0966558829,
0.2579608858,
0.3203918636,
0.8426940441,
-0.3221425712,
0.3440853357,
-0.3238115907,
-0.4096450806,
-0.4618477225,
-0.6394487023,
-0.7565315962,
-0.5192314982,
-0.466627717,
-0.1518571973,
-0.0738313943,
0.8965397477,
1.1301957369,
-1.0653049946,
-0.4788642526,
0.3272105157,
0.0928338766,
-0.5227059126,
-0.2296328992,
-0.0389670543,
-0.3362717628,
-0.889146924,
0.6752476692,
0.1203085482,
0.1319884062,
-0.0703907236,
-0.1670161486,
-0.0966147557,
0.0433555767,
0.2724339962,
0.3507126868,
-0.5688698292,
-0.0519893281,
-0.1983929724,
-0.0406078361,
0.2937573791,
1.0344976187,
-0.8151321411,
0.794998765,
0.4263158739,
0.6394851804,
0.3625197709,
0.1576071382,
0.5724666119,
-1.1776345968,
0.5538892746,
0.0996696278,
0.4814973474,
0.7198093534,
-0.1447859257,
0.3819052875,
0.3854762912,
-0.1306341439,
-0.7714915276,
0.0704550892,
-1.150613308,
0.0581554696,
1.0250085592,
0.0221817289,
0.1067805663,
-0.1648884416,
-0.0680418834,
-0.0009087096,
-0.4482576847,
0.6098531485,
0.6205101609,
0.1145167053,
-0.4060713053,
-0.3106729984,
0.5991507769,
0.2800592184,
-0.777217567,
-0.1179185808,
0.4910029471,
0.3980764151,
0.128579855,
0.8266850114,
0.1159975976,
0.2051385045,
-0.2740322351,
-0.1326656938,
0.0568778552,
-0.3192556202,
-0.3733546436,
-0.0716683194,
0.1436530799,
-0.2991150916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08220v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08220v2 | Dialogue State Distillation Network with Inter-slot Contrastive Learning for Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-02-16T11:05:24 | 2023-03-07T07:00:35 | Jing Xu, Dandan Song, Chong Liu, Siu Cheung Hui, Fei Li, Qiang Ju, Xiaonan He, Jian Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL | In task-oriented dialogue systems, Dialogue State Tracking (DST) aims to
extract users' intentions from the dialogue history. Currently, most existing
approaches suffer from error propagation and are unable to dynamically select
relevant information when utilizing previous dialogue states. Moreover, the
relations between the updates of different slots provide vital clues for DST.
However, the existing approaches rely only on predefined graphs to indirectly
capture the relations. In this paper, we propose a Dialogue State Distillation
Network (DSDN) to utilize relevant information of previous dialogue states and
migrate the gap of utilization between training and testing. Thus, it can
dynamically exploit previous dialogue states and avoid introducing error
propagation simultaneously. Further, we propose an inter-slot contrastive
learning loss to effectively capture the slot co-update relations from dialogue
context. Experiments are conducted on the widely used MultiWOZ 2.0 and MultiWOZ
2.1 datasets. The experimental results show that our proposed model achieves
the state-of-the-art performance for DST. | [
-0.5475329161,
-0.5531461835,
0.6384736896,
0.047427956,
-0.6233978271,
0.0955462083,
0.1084069759,
0.0917215794,
0.2878623009,
0.3437363803,
-1.1276522875,
-0.1672091037,
-0.5986557603,
-0.0784674287,
-0.3049016595,
1.0495067835,
-0.0541738383,
-0.0914546624,
0.0505747758,
-0.2633108199,
-0.5307223201,
-0.5308562517,
-0.7932639718,
-0.3546314836,
0.3473210931,
-0.1130489409,
0.1514448971,
-0.1308726817,
0.0600335747,
0.3978264332,
-0.2604335845,
0.3487582505,
-0.5930253267,
0.3088832796,
-0.2146599889,
-0.3260861933,
-0.2407809198,
-0.1471861005,
0.4190706611,
0.5647593737,
-0.2953224778,
-0.1743490398,
0.5004262924,
0.3894088566,
-0.4484709501,
0.7020434141,
-0.5750795603,
0.2324007004,
0.0218213461,
-0.3432292938,
-0.2874569297,
-0.4931505919,
0.3993552923,
-0.5912141204,
0.1658446193,
-0.1925294697,
0.5187182426,
0.5206848979,
-0.5782908797,
-0.111865826,
-0.7536035776,
0.6116193533,
-0.7530012727,
0.1280493736,
0.1007764935,
0.3627727628,
-0.2844312787,
-0.6654618382,
-0.8079298735,
-0.1624726951,
-0.1044583768,
0.480009675,
-0.2416475564,
0.1723542362,
0.3020955622,
0.3327978849,
-0.104936555,
-0.0909120366,
-0.2022669762,
-0.2105191052,
0.2810043097,
0.3879594803,
-0.0129859755,
0.036410559,
-0.7009709477,
-0.1676483154,
-0.3266961873,
-0.1722694486,
0.1529809237,
0.2781243026,
-0.035029456,
0.0998669267,
-0.0321840048,
0.6027809978,
0.4440604746,
-0.1945893914,
0.1257887334,
-0.7112108469,
-0.0873692855,
0.2147954106,
0.8112560511,
0.4519082904,
-0.5105289221,
0.0814557374,
-0.1104997173,
0.0990225896,
0.1886910796,
-0.8370680809,
-0.3397932053,
-0.1993043423,
-0.3715867102,
-0.1222762093,
-0.208205685,
-0.5998642445,
-0.3331244588,
-0.2271005213,
0.4496511817,
-0.4774724245,
-0.5773100257,
-0.0503688492,
-0.1944558322,
-0.1539392471,
0.7813444734,
-0.8164947629,
0.464520514,
0.4969308078,
1.0074803829,
-0.161576435,
-0.0434536226,
-0.2100314051,
-0.0288862213,
-0.1253767014,
0.5163983703,
-0.1237771139,
-0.395635426,
-0.2622688413,
0.0521112904,
-0.3370290697,
-0.3893832266,
0.156078428,
-0.6509003639,
0.1699589044,
-0.1758169234,
-0.5882137418,
-0.358653903,
0.3111734092,
-0.7176219225,
0.8307660222,
0.1452519894,
-0.7252196074,
0.2347196639,
-0.5709886551,
-0.2001869529,
-0.0866918713,
-0.2865018547,
-0.5398489833,
0.0950954333,
0.0255438499,
0.3135045171,
-0.0217410885,
0.478661567,
-0.5583226681,
-0.5592474341,
0.1958755851,
-0.8002910018,
0.7068076134,
0.2747898698,
-0.3035637438,
-0.2399280369,
-0.6083225608,
-0.2762494683,
-0.0930527672,
-0.2239249796,
-0.5973454118,
0.1229893044,
-0.4143276811,
0.4734563828,
-0.0548649319,
-0.6443408728,
0.1055792868,
-0.2212385684,
0.4507676065,
0.8105747104,
0.1800070405,
0.1576127261,
-0.0962987319,
0.4663645327,
0.5746079683,
-0.1126380339,
-0.2069465667,
-0.2541089356,
-0.7577263713,
-0.0431721173,
-0.0046720472,
0.4979895353,
-1.1077069044,
0.6572841406,
-0.0417039804,
-0.2702667117,
-0.262353301,
-0.2153591514,
0.3755001128,
0.895301044,
0.2701356411,
-0.4512883723,
-0.2221183628,
-0.6036723256,
0.0555196367,
-0.117578797,
0.1863367558,
0.4104420841,
0.2389708161,
0.1470372975,
0.8271257281,
-0.8633397818,
-0.5700156689,
-0.4288986921,
0.1383423805,
0.2586694658,
0.5357091427,
0.4413407147,
-0.8248730898,
-0.5522829294,
-0.1480664015,
-0.4778147042,
0.0520374067,
-0.0874494389,
0.0065047648,
-0.0653735772,
0.6035436392,
-0.2203840017,
0.6717059016,
0.7809184194,
-0.1731456369,
0.2724399567,
-0.0635092929,
0.3291572332,
-1.6861481667,
-0.2337238938,
0.1302939653,
-0.1538882107,
-0.4955122173,
-0.868442297,
-0.1844755262,
-0.3208049238,
-0.3520170152,
0.3639568388,
-0.1757043451,
-0.0941445231,
-0.2128615677,
0.2230130434,
0.2732352912,
0.9279358387,
0.0158618987,
0.7839223742,
0.2970995903,
-0.6027080417,
0.5964195728,
0.4526244998,
-0.4465102553,
0.8004745841,
-0.2952979803,
0.1002892479,
0.0049319649,
0.8455498815,
-1.340509057,
0.3673729897,
0.3637821376,
-0.1120306104,
0.1740107387,
-0.5696098208,
-0.0512299761,
-0.0946284607,
0.0906747729,
0.300060451,
0.3149793148,
-0.5962626338,
0.3424916565,
0.2759132981,
-0.3884176016,
-0.5714586377,
-0.4055194259,
-0.2161856294,
-0.3509135246,
-0.3092406392,
0.3194594681,
0.1486607492,
0.1259299666,
0.0677311495,
-0.5985398293,
-0.2892193794,
0.2832747996,
0.1456470042,
0.3172097802,
-0.0723590925,
0.3033537567,
0.3465387821,
-0.2827698588,
-0.0411565751,
-0.3393601477,
0.5662447214,
0.1789479703,
-0.3854778707,
-1.0118180513,
0.4600639045,
0.2608967125,
-0.0223256461,
0.7438585758,
0.5260478258,
-0.0733404979,
-0.2520444989,
-0.3037946224,
-0.4281200767,
-0.4943017364,
0.6200242639,
-0.5604372025,
-0.7877793908,
0.3537805974,
-0.7974879146,
-0.0511530526,
0.2673606575,
0.1064044759,
-0.4304694831,
1.0080174208,
0.5658846498,
0.0150774736,
0.935949266,
-0.2917441428,
0.3099644184,
-1.0673010349,
-0.1395620853,
-0.4264014959,
-0.2885289788,
-0.3278610408,
-0.3781668842,
0.6692603827,
0.2068154067,
-0.0209035557,
0.3844600618,
-0.074987404,
0.1344729811,
0.4481321871,
0.3435937166,
0.3769879639,
0.0482170507,
-0.2369662523,
-0.0895422325,
-0.6264172792,
-0.0719536766,
0.5857927203,
-0.0116555346,
0.9784052372,
0.252577126,
0.8128877282,
0.4555134177,
-0.1987654716,
-0.5756275654,
0.533198595,
-0.3347472548,
-0.2568464875,
-0.4682870805,
-0.5636783242,
-0.8265680075,
0.6124719977,
0.0323181264,
-0.7474378347,
0.2705085278,
0.4839362502,
-0.4207972884,
0.3818500042,
-0.6521983147,
0.7428598404,
0.0783417001,
-0.1313038021,
-0.491291523,
-0.6339629292,
0.0869060829,
0.1128125861,
-0.4140022695,
-0.2650034428,
0.3998062015,
0.6128476858,
-0.6788677573,
1.0357049704,
-0.5545025468,
-0.1794583201,
0.2777097523,
0.0615679696,
0.7529687881,
-0.0037811701,
-0.039412003,
0.0102757392,
0.0296616163,
-0.0707629398,
-0.8739184141,
0.6146287918,
-0.5163967013,
-0.4754288793,
-0.4029892385,
-0.2302915603,
-0.3696591556,
0.1860264689,
0.1111931875,
0.9317755103,
-0.4580263197,
-0.1345881969,
0.8840799928,
-0.1070465818,
0.3800360262,
0.4686213434,
0.2490853965,
-0.0732753202,
0.7828243375,
-0.0572268441,
0.5587486625,
0.3604955077,
0.0751618892,
-0.6669451594,
-0.6005588174,
-0.6018884182,
-0.0370058008,
-0.5569408536,
-0.1179326028,
-0.5722211003,
-0.2222801298,
-0.3269533515,
0.120381847,
-0.4984200001,
-0.3182668984,
-0.238910228,
0.0434551388,
0.2831097245,
0.5384426117,
0.0376828685,
0.3252539635,
-0.6918071508,
0.3137377501,
0.4170870483,
0.4986609221,
-0.0786565468,
-0.3524379432,
-0.1629861295,
0.1785235405,
-0.4331071079,
-0.8259635568,
0.1473272145,
0.2705080807,
0.5995129347,
0.2591548562,
0.4421187341,
0.844894886,
-0.3197458386,
0.5913513899,
0.604327023,
-0.8614143729,
0.6223891377,
-0.1385307759,
0.4845919609,
0.7625834942,
0.2884845734,
-0.7786547542,
-0.2703934908,
-0.2860632241,
-0.5094438195,
1.254147172,
-0.1332846582,
0.0570774414,
0.0692766681,
0.0804512352,
0.2001896203,
0.2462580949,
-0.4344645441,
-0.2454660535,
-0.3727565408,
-0.2863664627,
-0.1520750523,
0.0131525649,
-0.3100312352,
0.0772028863,
0.6007187366,
-0.4175689816,
0.2579779327,
0.2410038263,
-0.1806595922,
0.3552041948,
0.3916422427,
0.3205987513,
0.3909844756,
-0.162074104,
-0.075669989,
0.1833412796,
-0.3813108504,
0.3833095729,
0.3546646535,
-0.0659025237,
-0.1016433388,
-0.298093468,
1.3309019804,
0.1117085889,
-0.127071768,
0.7678441405,
-0.3504288197,
-0.1273073256,
-0.3542947471,
0.1129804701,
0.0667291135,
0.6448203325,
0.0070822267,
0.3039956391,
0.4481900632,
-0.4776082337,
0.0427833311,
0.1908022016,
-0.8946813941,
-0.2711549103,
0.3550882339,
0.6350283027,
-0.0137071637,
0.7902922034,
-0.3167013228,
-0.4959917665,
0.3895616829,
0.6324564815,
0.8924041986,
-0.3358124793,
0.2415638417,
0.4484344125,
-0.2826573551,
0.0674959049,
0.041611325,
-0.6698342562,
-0.7410010099,
-0.3124656379,
-0.4111148119,
-0.3962618411,
0.198848471,
-0.8176848292,
0.0704797581,
-0.1305476725,
-0.2560217083,
-0.2332925946,
-0.0366459489,
-0.4816933572,
0.0766600966,
0.1058244929,
0.4821507037,
-0.851390481,
1.0333154202,
0.2044075429,
-0.1646230668,
-0.6019396782,
0.0873973295,
0.2564750314,
-0.5928577781,
0.5573508143,
0.0559172444,
-0.5872229338,
-0.025483001,
0.0620742664,
-0.7124308944,
1.2499841452,
0.1260925531,
-0.8618697524,
0.0002773789,
-0.2356133759,
0.3860834241,
-0.1696635634,
0.1707995385,
0.4468342066,
-0.0771519169,
0.2882705033,
-0.9721901417,
0.1304482818,
-0.0760243833,
0.1705076247,
0.4881252348,
-0.8892724514,
0.776689291,
-0.0743889436,
-0.3924770355,
0.0667551458,
0.391112566,
0.0079931766,
0.3099998236,
0.922275424,
0.5014030337,
0.4258019924,
-0.3469071686,
0.4612668455,
0.0422403812,
0.3891503513,
1.522591114,
-0.5722282529,
0.403165549,
0.4707780182,
-0.1828234345,
0.5818455219,
0.371937871,
0.162662372,
1.0936256647,
0.2835828662,
-0.6433333755,
-0.1262197644,
0.0395563617,
-0.385630101,
0.3430960774,
0.6762134433,
-0.301746577,
-0.3305453658,
0.1484149694,
0.1127133369,
-0.1496125162,
-0.0741285384,
1.3673269749,
0.0313400552,
-0.9713048935,
0.2781640887,
-0.5023499131,
0.5172825456,
-0.8206133246,
-0.3834370673,
-0.4282580614,
0.4985053539,
0.1327732205,
-0.6095439196,
0.2330468595,
-0.402281791,
0.0958888009,
-0.2065113336,
0.6270619035,
-0.6758239865,
0.015311501,
0.4461478889,
0.3165088594,
0.0907260999,
0.168614611,
-0.6546834111,
0.0583768897,
0.1650691479,
0.0586453713,
0.4569802582,
0.3392857015,
0.0728804991,
0.4255871177,
0.2835449874,
-0.0667616129,
-0.0070090713,
0.198361814,
1.0232130289,
-0.5464874506,
-0.8468526602,
-0.5040458441,
0.304143995,
-0.4458616376,
-0.2483408898,
0.4897899032,
0.2623513639,
0.8055607677,
0.2462736517,
1.0294007063,
-0.1015829593,
0.7501824498,
-0.5716562867,
0.5032647848,
-0.4160949588,
0.4101276696,
-0.3885903656,
-0.8167477846,
0.3882641196,
0.4286657572,
0.0342677981,
-0.2165925652,
0.6664420962,
0.6951521039,
-0.2945729792,
0.2879319489,
0.3216041327,
0.2543689609,
0.471010834,
0.6726418734,
1.0943616629,
-0.3951269984,
0.5474196672,
-0.3099678457,
-0.4219961762,
-0.2949008048,
-0.6044793129,
-0.7752242088,
-0.9529063702,
-0.3993256092,
-0.5092090368,
0.156893,
0.7361799479,
0.7310304642,
-0.5207465887,
-0.1463696659,
0.0293750837,
-0.0357841216,
-0.5480014682,
-0.1588272154,
0.4218836725,
-0.3578457832,
-0.7989295125,
0.5442337394,
0.3404355347,
0.0990289822,
-0.2643274367,
-0.0628266931,
-0.1107725576,
0.0136598945,
0.4820086956,
0.1498273015,
-0.5756030083,
-0.1527437717,
-0.6089121103,
0.0621595792,
0.1076397076,
0.8871522546,
-0.7419210076,
0.8001157641,
0.2901451886,
0.343188554,
1.0321005583,
-0.1332345456,
0.686072886,
-0.7080949545,
0.202402249,
0.2610631287,
0.4422053993,
0.0225039124,
-0.1003153026,
0.1671760529,
0.3387417197,
-0.3386493921,
-0.4901585579,
0.4646242261,
-1.0249140263,
-0.1813616753,
0.7393749952,
-0.6966141462,
0.1395425498,
-0.5572142601,
-0.337369442,
0.4442106187,
-0.4806038141,
0.8379597664,
0.5078880787,
-0.3986952603,
-0.0230398811,
-0.0031403266,
0.7565132976,
0.2471677512,
-0.8208290339,
-0.0177881066,
0.5262366533,
0.3389477134,
0.0382737853,
1.1242507696,
-0.0606462061,
0.1581210047,
0.2729600966,
-0.4443988204,
-0.0024678882,
-0.1381039768,
-0.4217284322,
-0.084616825,
-0.3072325587,
-0.5627906919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08215v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08215v2 | Aligning Language Models with Preferences through f-divergence Minimization | 2023-02-16T10:59:39 | 2023-06-06T13:09:21 | Dongyoung Go, Tomasz Korbak, Germán Kruszewski, Jos Rozen, Nahyeon Ryu, Marc Dymetman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Aligning language models with preferences can be posed as approximating a
target distribution representing some desired behavior. Existing approaches
differ both in the functional form of the target distribution and the algorithm
used to approximate it. For instance, Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) corresponds to minimizing a reverse KL from an implicit target
distribution arising from a KL penalty in the objective. On the other hand,
Generative Distributional Control (GDC) has an explicit target distribution and
minimizes a forward KL from it using the Distributional Policy Gradient (DPG)
algorithm. In this paper, we propose a new approach, f-DPG, which allows the
use of any f-divergence to approximate any target distribution that can be
evaluated. f-DPG unifies both frameworks (RLHF, GDC) and the approximation
methods (DPG, RL with KL penalties). We show the practical benefits of various
choices of divergence objectives and demonstrate that there is no universally
optimal objective but that different divergences present different alignment
and diversity trade-offs. We show that Jensen-Shannon divergence strikes a good
balance between these objectives, and frequently outperforms forward KL
divergence by a wide margin, leading to significant improvements over prior
work. These distinguishing characteristics between divergences persist as the
model size increases, highlighting the importance of selecting appropriate
divergence objectives. | [
-0.5910407901,
-0.4057022631,
0.365286231,
0.3586907089,
-0.0262306146,
0.0179727636,
-0.50211519,
0.0144829107,
0.0075163399,
0.1013913304,
-0.8012877703,
-0.5566110015,
-0.4425646961,
-0.0427089743,
0.0699581578,
0.8368070722,
-0.1685189456,
-0.0934301764,
0.03631524,
-0.144541651,
-0.0949045941,
-0.1754811406,
-0.4748769701,
-0.4573194087,
0.7331929803,
0.2851846814,
1.1080076694,
0.6530122757,
0.5456408858,
0.1931007802,
-0.1165259704,
-0.0360893682,
-0.4978113472,
-0.1669369191,
-0.2184444219,
-0.4615988135,
-0.0149732074,
-0.0486059301,
0.7539100647,
0.821559906,
-0.3801268935,
-0.388975352,
0.0189763494,
1.0530941486,
-1.031034112,
0.1220817193,
0.0663374439,
0.4667599499,
0.099026069,
0.0592620261,
-0.3886351883,
-0.6694828868,
0.4355230927,
-0.5460714698,
0.1367941052,
-0.0943326578,
0.6393018961,
0.3828160763,
-0.3912112415,
-0.3750680685,
-1.0592998266,
1.1821527481,
-0.4862954021,
0.7000208497,
0.231757462,
0.3159939647,
-0.0732140988,
0.0044579138,
-0.3635401428,
-0.2175989449,
-0.0936578587,
0.1671533436,
-0.2663642764,
0.3757788539,
0.1628907025,
0.5287190676,
-0.4364772439,
0.3361650407,
-0.2928327024,
-0.0950867683,
0.9063418508,
0.2172873169,
0.0977306589,
0.1542146951,
-0.494209528,
-0.4574424922,
-0.7319743633,
0.1988892704,
0.7264601588,
0.4230940044,
-0.1723415703,
0.4205561578,
-0.4439499974,
0.5438842177,
0.1987948567,
-0.1585976928,
0.3745677769,
-0.0861223191,
-0.0853610933,
-0.0821610987,
0.7099704146,
0.4138985574,
0.3219274282,
-0.0742034242,
-0.3388234675,
0.141100958,
0.047561571,
-0.5864040852,
-0.1263569444,
0.2123268545,
-0.6615638733,
-0.3666212559,
0.0590364747,
-0.8588955998,
-0.2953261137,
-0.2324897796,
0.0733416453,
-0.0690614805,
-0.5972574949,
0.1267486513,
-0.1463808119,
0.4365161359,
0.3636334836,
-1.4620921612,
0.3817564845,
0.671104908,
0.9574802518,
-0.4296959639,
-0.1600589305,
-0.3677247763,
0.0738889053,
-0.4644030035,
0.4078667462,
-0.4743104875,
-0.6699436307,
0.3002132177,
-0.3493354023,
0.138160497,
-0.455534637,
0.497751534,
-0.3412659764,
0.2310593873,
-0.5122679472,
-0.6097887158,
-0.0254612062,
0.0040931143,
-0.7032647729,
0.5994592905,
0.3235336542,
-0.8396213055,
0.6073642373,
-0.6817510128,
-0.3254542947,
-0.1867717654,
-0.2763723135,
-0.222414881,
0.0596155114,
0.1273537278,
0.2302994877,
-0.0253484212,
0.0654943138,
-0.7092419863,
-0.3624530435,
-0.1010856852,
-0.5163916945,
0.7539684176,
0.4965434074,
-0.1481581926,
0.1473136097,
-0.1212770566,
-0.1390260756,
-0.0314944461,
-0.6494559646,
-0.381549716,
0.324260056,
-0.1133799553,
-0.0555541404,
0.1119982898,
-0.317956388,
0.3174153864,
-0.7485665083,
0.1864005923,
1.0191046,
-0.2237869352,
1.1088024378,
-0.3930740058,
0.9035539627,
-0.0145796314,
0.4859546721,
0.3543025255,
-0.2513786256,
-0.2875815928,
-0.454888761,
0.3526036739,
0.446491003,
-0.4097667634,
0.416831553,
-0.2665581703,
-0.2326810211,
-0.6818513274,
0.1154474542,
0.2837547362,
0.1969044507,
0.1281778663,
-0.3256830871,
-0.30212152,
-0.9333600998,
-0.2132170796,
-0.3878101408,
0.072100237,
0.4039390087,
-0.0308152568,
-0.1439629942,
1.142074585,
-0.7861529589,
-0.1843942255,
-0.1737816334,
-0.138042137,
0.2207020372,
0.2607333362,
0.7921141386,
-0.9590520859,
-0.7724974155,
0.1797738671,
-0.4007166028,
-0.1557969749,
0.2315045297,
-0.2422188669,
0.259211868,
0.0805831626,
-0.5807238221,
0.3271663487,
0.5808996558,
-0.0535198636,
0.4104209244,
-0.0491770618,
-0.1009777188,
-0.7086836696,
-0.0806743279,
0.1367232502,
-0.2214565426,
-0.704679966,
-0.0458763056,
-0.1921548992,
0.2736234665,
-0.4072018862,
0.8790143132,
-0.1920044571,
-0.2131397724,
-0.1093416512,
0.1183088943,
-0.1336678416,
0.4054988027,
0.345890522,
0.5851875544,
0.4060184956,
-0.5956362486,
0.2425152063,
0.4063922167,
-0.1675349325,
0.5792681575,
-0.4471743703,
-0.3125577569,
-0.4236805737,
0.1581662893,
-0.7533760071,
0.075627014,
0.5645860434,
-0.178606838,
0.2741393447,
-0.2406306714,
0.0984134376,
-0.2776447535,
-0.6498172879,
0.3065570295,
0.7969503403,
-0.7423542142,
0.3585453928,
0.2135038525,
-0.1062983647,
-1.1928982735,
-0.6624543071,
-0.7045230865,
-0.3741389215,
-0.2853512466,
0.495852828,
-0.2289643288,
-0.4133862853,
0.0790525153,
-0.1055992842,
0.190231666,
0.0894798562,
-0.0795715973,
0.0802930966,
-0.1542860717,
0.0961492583,
0.2861449718,
-0.1309620738,
-0.2078321874,
-0.3169893026,
0.5115745068,
0.04436744,
-0.3809882104,
-0.0601100624,
0.5085570216,
0.1538330168,
-0.0275924541,
0.4546376467,
0.5029503107,
-0.0657942295,
-0.3639981747,
-0.1655074954,
-0.2244975567,
-0.4818363488,
0.1760488898,
-0.2242199481,
-0.7937081456,
0.3352261484,
0.1302970201,
0.2993741632,
0.2667105794,
0.7694321871,
-0.0140125919,
1.2086082697,
0.6793114543,
-0.4562233984,
0.847994566,
-0.1779291183,
0.2692375481,
-0.6528513432,
0.1189751476,
-0.3341697454,
-0.2327535897,
-0.7686917186,
-0.0980005711,
-0.0244096946,
0.4469864964,
-0.1408705562,
-0.0152449077,
-0.4196297526,
0.5117653608,
0.5926690698,
-0.0986036062,
0.1177134514,
0.0016413262,
-0.2266479135,
-0.0327388346,
-0.8167446256,
-0.2672054172,
1.0088555813,
0.4160369635,
1.0743091106,
0.2724967301,
1.1049133539,
0.5969001651,
0.5623022914,
-0.8132512569,
0.0337549224,
-0.2727999091,
-0.300170958,
-0.4122923911,
-0.6397846937,
-0.985855341,
0.5559982061,
0.0626331493,
-0.5888112783,
0.5117292404,
0.5128662586,
-0.3678873181,
0.0392969958,
-0.7865306735,
0.836209476,
-0.0260630753,
-0.0691355243,
-0.0359350145,
-0.4868577421,
0.3394375145,
0.4637284577,
0.2109069675,
-0.3069904745,
0.04045837,
0.3568352461,
-0.3635110259,
0.6516897678,
-0.6883106232,
-0.387819916,
-0.0099897534,
-0.099005498,
0.3981665075,
-0.0183168706,
-0.0030811739,
-0.1451903582,
-0.0292802248,
-0.4792473018,
-0.7390206456,
0.7231237292,
-0.9746354818,
-0.6732006669,
-0.3076179624,
-0.4733222425,
-0.1193442419,
0.0837685168,
0.0708557889,
-0.0375841744,
-0.5392335057,
-0.1246355101,
0.5479539633,
-0.1283767968,
0.552652061,
0.3407776356,
-0.503872633,
-0.6061953306,
0.814527452,
-0.2949760556,
0.6655572057,
0.5962601304,
0.4062694907,
-0.7634921074,
-0.3776680827,
-0.4119558334,
0.1140716374,
-0.9377183318,
-0.0445274003,
-0.3439578116,
0.0620451942,
-0.3364806771,
-0.49427706,
-0.2530342042,
-0.1642589271,
-0.3135744035,
-0.0248924121,
0.2047017962,
0.435103327,
-0.3864755034,
0.3126526773,
-0.4047029614,
0.0462535471,
0.2055571675,
0.3693131208,
-0.0370218307,
-0.143260479,
-0.0130660301,
0.4070150256,
-0.2299587578,
-0.8235552907,
0.2672763467,
0.2553915381,
0.6704155207,
0.6809904575,
0.0959901214,
0.2856321335,
-0.3248322606,
0.4474918842,
0.3159722388,
-0.9310842752,
0.3111216128,
-0.3257063925,
0.2371395528,
0.5549042225,
0.5613918304,
-0.7590622306,
-0.1036911234,
-0.4292681217,
-0.5559049249,
0.6668482423,
0.0330361426,
0.2108495533,
-0.0622080304,
0.2700636685,
0.087157838,
0.3153443336,
-0.6420974731,
-0.2098876536,
-0.0570510775,
-0.5641440153,
-0.1609098166,
0.0653821975,
-0.2520957291,
0.0527011827,
0.5206252933,
-0.4368174374,
0.2111434937,
0.0479422845,
-0.0132943457,
-0.1037954539,
0.2593278885,
0.8220309615,
0.3117879629,
-0.2231899798,
0.0485668741,
-0.0508188605,
-0.1838935614,
0.4473224282,
-0.0378134586,
-0.3692626059,
-0.1639014035,
0.0475580357,
0.9270080924,
-0.1074482352,
-0.441399008,
0.7300528884,
-0.0798161849,
-0.280970186,
0.012458479,
0.2496730685,
0.0912442207,
0.4077319801,
0.0263165887,
0.155794099,
0.0148521457,
-0.1732671559,
0.1090398356,
0.6016106606,
-0.5574815869,
-0.1108182371,
0.4647596478,
0.1159627438,
-0.253862083,
0.5254363418,
-0.2764690816,
-0.4340043664,
0.4825560749,
0.408520937,
0.9066900611,
-0.5177942514,
0.6348709464,
-0.0282349829,
0.2212973684,
-0.3104710281,
0.4340566993,
-0.3707813621,
-1.0442183018,
-0.3169303834,
-0.6492832303,
-0.4187363088,
-0.507186532,
-0.7703727484,
0.1820233613,
-0.6919989586,
-0.0436317772,
0.0226776022,
-0.0909635648,
-0.6052701473,
0.0849847347,
-0.0614267848,
0.5629367232,
-0.9703071117,
0.6540396214,
0.250049144,
-0.59446913,
-0.4692236185,
0.0922345296,
-0.047128424,
-0.7107802629,
0.5322096348,
-0.1268607229,
-0.1389089823,
0.055045262,
-0.0917094722,
-0.8211852312,
0.992674768,
0.4748890102,
-0.6817297339,
0.1240854263,
0.1061368287,
0.4083040059,
-0.5383264422,
0.0455880053,
0.5959596038,
0.5008646846,
0.0791415125,
-0.6291213632,
-0.0492123626,
0.0905358195,
0.2282471061,
0.698656559,
-0.673369348,
0.6861342788,
-0.3814951479,
-0.3927402794,
-0.1851620823,
0.5408070683,
0.2355773151,
-0.1619737148,
0.81327039,
0.5016559958,
0.6452475786,
-0.1472156197,
1.1517914534,
-0.0669588447,
0.7636582255,
0.610658884,
-0.4722698927,
0.7227267623,
0.6754590273,
-0.6721562147,
0.357358098,
0.8115794063,
0.0661956519,
1.0536314249,
0.4516838193,
-0.379894197,
0.1560437381,
0.0429454893,
-0.2529749274,
0.0164028481,
0.1931772828,
-0.3888965845,
-0.2139913738,
-0.087773025,
-0.079124473,
-0.0389391966,
-0.2086734176,
0.8200995922,
0.0145716146,
-0.7594347,
0.6327548623,
0.0970737711,
0.7220064402,
-0.5151581764,
0.1741265804,
-0.450835526,
0.4066625834,
-0.1824394912,
-0.6152758598,
0.4672326744,
-0.4422806203,
-0.4299253821,
-0.2052900046,
0.4447716475,
-0.8458066583,
-0.1193007678,
0.357500881,
0.0765513182,
-0.2079273313,
0.2906040549,
-0.6665314436,
0.1519976407,
0.18591021,
-0.1269229352,
0.2554518282,
-0.1346907169,
-0.0896702036,
0.5969842672,
0.4109940827,
0.2874035835,
-0.0063977698,
0.1721255481,
0.4854614437,
-0.3112128675,
-0.8043037653,
-0.9508727193,
0.2590770721,
-0.037755385,
-0.2557679713,
0.2955962718,
0.2477690876,
1.1132054329,
-0.1751778424,
1.0762481689,
0.013379368,
0.149083361,
-0.5446459055,
0.3533365428,
-0.5833886266,
0.0942304209,
-0.2820599675,
-1.2052994967,
-0.3810046315,
0.8720573187,
-0.4359600246,
0.2277567834,
0.4662324488,
0.8576449752,
-0.2231791764,
-0.05752955,
0.2327332646,
-0.3748221397,
0.4275711179,
0.5606994629,
0.9343674779,
0.0045689661,
0.1769592017,
-0.3760181367,
-0.3099229634,
-0.2110425979,
-0.8595170379,
-0.5824353099,
-0.4133172333,
-0.4182315767,
-0.1517516077,
0.0720082298,
1.2237683535,
0.8724586964,
-0.8906925917,
-0.2474965006,
-0.3050300777,
0.4723295271,
-0.3262475133,
-0.2748013735,
0.3178103268,
-0.3469385803,
-0.8119324446,
0.2035497427,
0.4458549619,
0.2995815575,
-0.7448692322,
-0.6932312846,
-0.0820300207,
0.1021531895,
0.3367201388,
0.5371235013,
-0.8592872024,
-0.4442277551,
-0.1614295244,
0.0346486233,
0.0284586046,
0.9715551734,
-0.2083874494,
0.3592649102,
0.6527657509,
0.6861727238,
0.3202836514,
0.1358700991,
0.9369410276,
-0.9988299608,
0.276676029,
0.1493454278,
0.140530318,
0.302880913,
-0.2382051796,
0.3614309728,
0.0425759926,
-0.4175945818,
-0.8579408526,
0.6553217173,
-0.4635846615,
-0.1030112505,
1.0849442482,
-0.2884767652,
-0.1114926487,
0.2128841728,
-0.1765193641,
-0.1052096933,
-0.5052884817,
0.6772040725,
0.784904182,
-0.0909137651,
-0.2758558989,
-0.0567961447,
1.0426174402,
0.5641077757,
-0.6380477548,
0.2241146713,
0.4358651936,
0.3272592425,
-0.034846317,
0.8401830196,
0.110863626,
0.2196048498,
-0.2496397346,
0.1212377772,
0.5442659259,
-0.3073779047,
-0.6124035716,
-0.0650751814,
0.3551030159,
-0.2063127756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08198v1 | Un mod{è}le de base de connaissances terminologiques | 2023-02-16T10:28:23 | 2023-02-16T10:28:23 | Patrick Séguéla, Nathalie Aussenac-Gilles | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In the present paper, we argue that Terminological Knowledge Bases (TKB) are
all the more useful for addressing various needs as they do not fulfill formal
criteria. Moreover, they intend to clarify the terminology of a given domain by
illustrating term uses in various contexts. Thus we designed a TKB structure
including 3 linked features: terms, concepts and texts, that present the
peculiar use of each term in the domain. Note that concepts are represented
into frames whose non-formal description is standardized. Associated with this
structure, we defined modeling criteria at the conceptual level. Finaly, we
discuss the situation of TKB with regard to ontologies, and the use of TKB for
the development of AI systems. | [
-0.5032003522,
-0.640847981,
0.6345332265,
0.1622857302,
-0.1477558315,
0.4000049233,
0.1286573112,
-0.5691931844,
0.1831047535,
0.5964587331,
-0.342531085,
-0.7557658553,
-0.4896515906,
0.1734238118,
-0.6003084183,
0.723275423,
-0.1821810603,
-0.2032802999,
-0.3415681124,
0.0594197474,
-0.3528582752,
-0.3942733109,
-0.4726605713,
-0.6301407814,
0.2267806232,
0.3487772644,
0.6090925932,
0.6727003455,
0.5230432153,
0.2212972492,
0.0775196627,
0.0713417083,
-0.1961720884,
-0.0140811531,
-0.166160509,
-0.5055113435,
-0.6447510123,
-0.2183350772,
0.2938227952,
0.9914981723,
0.0774253979,
0.1086153015,
-0.2736049891,
0.662296772,
-0.4331024885,
0.517305553,
-0.163705647,
0.1738592982,
0.0193137154,
-0.3401948512,
-0.0989981368,
-0.2929226458,
0.3467006087,
-0.7660411,
0.0900935233,
0.1159169897,
1.0373111963,
0.298953563,
-0.3411309123,
-0.5097737312,
-0.7094286084,
0.5690664053,
-0.6519665718,
0.57507056,
0.5461583734,
0.3106936514,
-0.1494146436,
-0.4358594418,
-0.3795957565,
-0.7909275889,
-0.4226228595,
-0.1156292334,
0.1278581172,
0.4590448141,
0.3504509032,
0.1056768894,
-0.2118823528,
-0.0236982573,
-0.4895790815,
-0.1944762319,
0.4959272444,
0.236736849,
0.2721625268,
-0.3695003688,
-0.3392907679,
0.2972323895,
-0.6672469974,
-0.0962375253,
0.002747965,
0.2828900814,
-0.1273784935,
0.7888898849,
-0.3163959682,
0.832144022,
-0.0320108905,
-0.473105222,
0.1332327574,
-0.2386138588,
-0.0839208961,
-0.3413980007,
0.3954195082,
0.4469377995,
0.2988513708,
-0.8304576874,
-0.1883898526,
0.1918917,
0.6086345911,
-0.3786278367,
-0.1234216318,
0.341973871,
-0.4664900303,
-0.3036735356,
0.0986906737,
-0.5612201691,
-0.0346633568,
-0.4478197694,
0.3656072617,
-0.4671024978,
-0.2814061344,
-0.2980023623,
-0.3976239562,
0.0888097808,
0.211197868,
-0.7699255943,
0.3523411453,
0.538700223,
0.6468197703,
-0.0671082139,
0.2731566429,
0.5774983764,
0.6148428321,
-0.5737140775,
0.7554283738,
-0.7241768241,
-0.7199844122,
0.0549259707,
-0.3700357974,
0.2876578569,
-0.4423966408,
0.0829750076,
-0.5584717393,
-0.0151489107,
-0.0497537404,
-0.8407896161,
-0.4673990011,
0.5819274187,
-0.670168221,
0.6685032248,
0.2860929668,
-0.3847022355,
0.340375036,
-1.1410433054,
-0.4825228155,
0.4602833092,
-0.2734964788,
0.1976502836,
0.0762010291,
-0.5905219316,
0.3407935202,
-0.2382453084,
0.433052063,
-0.2335933596,
0.0462520383,
0.168095395,
0.5761779547,
0.5172277093,
0.3964207768,
-0.2631783187,
-0.3038249314,
-1.0351121426,
0.1617773324,
-0.3978350461,
-0.351321131,
-0.7945782542,
0.3231988251,
-0.220959723,
0.10857784,
0.3692715764,
-0.2508029938,
0.2893832028,
-0.340143919,
0.5609715581,
0.3325287998,
-0.0774247423,
0.591130197,
-0.2204360962,
0.4462347329,
-0.1438251287,
0.007214753,
0.2429205626,
-0.4038186669,
-0.8993077874,
-0.1396241933,
0.3220862746,
0.5464027524,
-0.9346669912,
0.4855162501,
-0.0356900357,
-0.584151566,
-0.0319195874,
-0.093867369,
0.5372958183,
0.5544151664,
0.3537512422,
-0.1622039825,
-0.5804404616,
-1.0855702162,
0.1134433374,
-0.4619984329,
0.0010230024,
0.4824929833,
0.7300437093,
-0.016841948,
1.1605306864,
-0.2242312133,
-0.2225362957,
-0.1254382879,
-0.1264538318,
0.1736991107,
0.2353945822,
0.6096331477,
-1.0265340805,
-0.1972359866,
0.0342825092,
-1.0239107609,
-0.3098844588,
0.1198034659,
-0.1327698678,
0.1723296642,
0.5016521811,
-0.8825980425,
0.3893530071,
0.0939790979,
-0.5736691356,
0.314789027,
0.1565177441,
0.0199929457,
-1.239995718,
0.3874207437,
-0.0918823704,
-0.1770796925,
-0.9828199148,
0.3485172987,
-0.137149781,
0.0473598465,
-0.2530176044,
0.9130642414,
0.1438408643,
0.1153627411,
-0.3501527309,
0.3341036439,
0.1798918396,
0.3989057541,
-0.0349608399,
0.2007742971,
0.3391554952,
-1.1703790426,
0.6841102242,
0.6303629875,
0.1006294042,
0.6833992004,
-0.5145063996,
-0.1724499911,
0.0837391391,
-0.0428815,
-0.5486479402,
-0.2259727567,
0.7186242938,
-0.6538918018,
0.2480535805,
0.2321166992,
-0.5243216157,
-0.3932736516,
-0.0245001279,
0.0968263447,
0.277990967,
-0.0084541542,
0.7443110943,
0.5037519932,
0.2978910506,
-0.4468677342,
-0.9065049887,
0.0915014297,
-0.2963306904,
-0.6819424629,
0.5457793474,
0.167824313,
-0.6271273494,
0.680418849,
-0.4254616499,
-0.3875585496,
0.3419739306,
0.3859988153,
0.3321888745,
-0.2365331799,
0.6699388623,
-0.3226449788,
0.0285945628,
0.0277842991,
-0.5267682076,
0.2669533491,
0.3318200111,
0.2946383953,
-0.2208714783,
0.4707877338,
0.1591314226,
0.2321804762,
0.8658620715,
0.0388531499,
-0.5337049365,
-0.3222178817,
-0.3239916265,
-0.0408796668,
-0.3870038986,
0.3194874823,
-0.5558392406,
-1.1355352402,
0.5537350178,
0.1024901122,
0.0800575241,
0.7875234485,
0.4334868491,
-0.411513716,
0.294310689,
0.9948447347,
0.2717836201,
0.2050855309,
-0.150650382,
0.6385292411,
-0.6603118181,
-0.8141818047,
-0.8361058831,
-0.1340245605,
-0.8208252192,
0.0223075449,
0.1345200241,
0.1462382078,
-0.2197314352,
0.5271057487,
-0.0586215965,
0.0835590735,
0.5299179554,
0.0978566706,
0.3148855567,
-0.0192673411,
-0.064145647,
0.3364219368,
-0.7083910704,
-0.8711358309,
1.111276865,
0.0743759871,
0.7563965321,
-0.0240994506,
0.4310923219,
0.6329954863,
0.1962978244,
-0.8096784353,
0.7616140842,
-0.5001477003,
-1.0734568834,
-0.2284063846,
-0.4551481605,
-0.6143070459,
-0.1785377562,
-0.1594940275,
-0.7873162627,
0.0660501122,
0.2486742139,
-0.390066117,
0.1893596947,
-0.6679170728,
0.8767620921,
-0.1406832188,
0.172488004,
-0.4208556116,
-0.4608901143,
0.12646918,
-0.1713102162,
0.1129733399,
-0.2962653935,
-0.3898856044,
0.8099018931,
-0.4569484293,
0.7844229341,
0.0079679228,
-0.0562150441,
0.4377398789,
0.0118720764,
-0.1769372225,
0.0005550187,
0.0119381789,
0.2405430377,
0.1732204258,
-0.3578392267,
-0.5432234406,
0.3490795493,
-0.9573454261,
-0.7993600965,
-0.196218282,
-0.5172442794,
-0.4915091395,
0.3733249307,
-0.0435314104,
0.5346665978,
-0.2427837849,
0.2405567914,
0.3467909396,
0.0139160734,
0.1280834228,
0.4924068153,
-0.186808899,
0.2541143298,
0.7778294683,
0.191076532,
0.4446212649,
0.783367455,
-0.1019193679,
-0.2093285918,
-0.604332149,
0.1031785309,
0.0882721096,
-0.8409593105,
-0.3047598898,
-0.6070374846,
-0.4860674441,
-0.2216801196,
0.0110213766,
-0.032927081,
-0.9720155597,
-0.2642315328,
-0.0793823302,
0.3694212735,
0.7311397791,
0.0790006667,
0.4198618531,
-0.8217688203,
0.7748126388,
0.0230235327,
0.4708437026,
-0.1700369567,
-0.3780077994,
-0.4955061078,
-0.1065550297,
-0.3343833089,
-0.4823104739,
0.0043020938,
0.2490750253,
0.816055119,
0.2370552123,
-0.1040281057,
0.2934538722,
-0.2947478592,
0.6617510915,
-0.0905078873,
-0.8831310868,
0.6075255275,
-0.2894644737,
0.0099710673,
0.2786672115,
0.7549142241,
-0.5419930816,
-0.4733903408,
-0.8636111617,
-0.8230048418,
0.6002756953,
0.3197956681,
0.1789696664,
0.1877379119,
0.862283349,
0.2685674727,
0.719106853,
-0.4417060912,
-0.408926636,
-0.1915812492,
-0.3200921416,
0.2035270333,
-0.2933825552,
-0.3926418126,
0.2358993441,
0.7232072949,
0.2009369731,
0.5148888826,
-0.0222346466,
-0.1533290297,
0.1544221342,
0.1867025197,
0.2099467367,
1.0354090929,
-0.1420688331,
0.0226498861,
-0.2854474187,
-0.2900061607,
0.0589346774,
-0.037310537,
-0.5540517569,
-0.018706793,
0.5818554163,
0.8021550775,
0.0128693376,
-0.4459076822,
-0.3075242639,
0.4276282489,
-0.2371691912,
-0.2515375912,
0.452352047,
-0.114621453,
0.4917272925,
0.2875775695,
0.068534039,
0.1395433992,
-0.6224958897,
0.2110333741,
0.2814758122,
-0.0895020962,
-0.3007557392,
0.3029007614,
0.4848892987,
-0.3709695935,
0.4990848303,
-0.176009953,
-0.6126307249,
0.7945529222,
0.3422181606,
0.6679622531,
-0.1550955921,
0.4129917324,
0.1997861713,
0.3062819541,
-0.0387841538,
0.261507988,
-0.0666688904,
-0.9928278327,
-0.1118683666,
-0.720228374,
-0.4471298456,
0.0379141197,
-0.1595146656,
0.2849554121,
-0.7715651989,
-0.3100207448,
0.1508850157,
-0.0483210981,
-0.3997150958,
0.433183223,
0.2474723011,
0.8889482021,
-0.5502187014,
0.6202162504,
0.8107591271,
-0.38491413,
-0.8073077798,
-0.3151238859,
-0.1192266867,
-0.762915194,
0.9955595136,
-0.1032967418,
0.0132892653,
-0.111344479,
-0.4535071254,
-0.9174492359,
0.8604207635,
-0.0466867052,
-0.3149849176,
-0.3907180727,
0.3231686056,
0.8382307291,
-0.7089850903,
-0.1939866394,
0.6572608352,
0.7370191813,
0.1616749614,
-0.8047680259,
0.0147893084,
-0.3325864375,
0.0706162229,
0.2920638025,
-0.5158734322,
0.5640565157,
0.0592068024,
-0.1817891747,
0.2707562149,
0.273842454,
0.0188164078,
0.1776581705,
0.2495616078,
0.631231904,
0.351323694,
-0.3386826217,
0.919875741,
-0.1987370402,
0.3471871912,
0.6391187906,
0.1919831038,
0.4100645185,
0.4646787047,
-0.3065658808,
0.5451066494,
0.8572935462,
-0.4724188149,
0.6367874146,
0.1606747061,
0.0913526639,
-0.2387794107,
-0.3980096579,
-0.4378944635,
0.4111457169,
0.9140762687,
-0.1244178191,
-0.2990002334,
-0.0747519433,
-0.11723537,
-0.2243919373,
-0.6164391041,
0.5721880198,
0.4341790974,
-0.4687899947,
0.3397416174,
0.0713994429,
0.1772490144,
-0.7358059883,
-0.1050432175,
-0.1862339973,
0.0404734798,
-0.5071054697,
-0.6702715755,
0.5278758407,
-0.1153396219,
-0.1556836963,
-0.0621733889,
0.6617534161,
-0.1975401193,
-0.5433516502,
0.3132379651,
0.7017551661,
-0.0184488874,
0.3759070635,
-0.5907798409,
-0.2451130003,
-0.2543134689,
-0.157685861,
-0.1929358095,
0.57987082,
-0.2912545502,
0.7605231404,
0.1058952957,
0.0441593938,
0.0277667046,
0.0319442675,
0.7759073377,
-0.9311181307,
-0.5427308083,
-0.7991188765,
0.2834446132,
0.1429069191,
-0.0713241547,
0.5807825327,
0.0947856009,
0.9822933674,
0.0618775673,
1.0098192692,
-0.8840623498,
0.2921617031,
-0.6210340261,
0.5156908035,
-0.7771701813,
0.2998730242,
-0.1275682002,
-1.0139764547,
-0.6496526003,
0.5821145177,
-0.111177735,
0.3495856225,
0.8485584259,
0.3605462909,
0.1821611673,
0.0668488666,
0.3201244175,
0.5595620871,
0.1711779535,
0.4606254697,
0.8183610439,
-0.0309208035,
0.4115673304,
-0.1615925282,
-0.1405448169,
-0.3922074437,
-0.685596168,
-1.4181078672,
-0.5712285638,
-0.2081954181,
-0.3773562908,
0.3286601901,
0.8954845667,
0.5621842146,
-1.0345799923,
-0.4590059817,
-0.0006907819,
0.1537351906,
0.289155066,
-0.1529359221,
0.2944197059,
-0.4410751462,
-0.1601883918,
0.0001880886,
0.3334115148,
-0.0602851212,
-0.298873961,
-0.0349959955,
-0.1782822162,
-0.1544696242,
0.5017689466,
0.2597149312,
-0.6558105946,
-0.5252469182,
0.1257041097,
-0.1341646016,
0.1243915558,
0.7625918388,
-0.7453769445,
0.3348416388,
0.4343916178,
0.5180819035,
0.1643301249,
-0.2193620503,
0.6333107948,
-0.4826319218,
0.1859108806,
0.1735036671,
0.0576417893,
0.2188166827,
-0.1806587875,
0.7733466625,
0.5643265247,
-0.0224233884,
-0.3815545142,
0.3036419153,
-0.8094906807,
-0.3340622485,
0.8066409826,
0.0029704238,
-0.2734761536,
-0.3153822124,
0.294521749,
0.3426354527,
-0.4900921285,
1.1320714951,
1.1608411074,
-0.3979205489,
-0.0510769449,
-0.7698350549,
0.6320104003,
-0.1134567708,
-0.8300706148,
-0.5393668413,
0.2492854148,
0.1408427656,
0.665674746,
0.4066013992,
-0.1262396574,
0.2321385294,
-0.1164219156,
0.0157847963,
-0.1669978648,
-0.4991911948,
0.3811861575,
0.2259404212,
0.0037526775,
0.0838464275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08150v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08150v2 | Reanalyzing L2 Preposition Learning with Bayesian Mixed Effects and a Pretrained Language Model | 2023-02-16T08:54:05 | 2023-05-23T08:00:08 | Jakob Prange, Man Ho Ivy Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL | We use both Bayesian and neural models to dissect a data set of Chinese
learners' pre- and post-interventional responses to two tests measuring their
understanding of English prepositions. The results mostly replicate previous
findings from frequentist analyses and newly reveal crucial interactions
between student ability, task type, and stimulus sentence. Given the sparsity
of the data as well as high diversity among learners, the Bayesian method
proves most useful; but we also see potential in using language model
probabilities as predictors of grammaticality and learnability. | [
0.0177742168,
-1.1123110056,
0.6638044715,
0.2187242508,
-0.2040019631,
-0.1017907187,
-0.0644307956,
-0.1483470798,
0.0786588639,
0.3601302505,
-0.2347018123,
-0.3652098775,
-0.4598621726,
-0.5036139488,
-0.2405071706,
0.9877803326,
0.2585730851,
0.4355261326,
0.0168223437,
0.3123024702,
-0.5546338558,
-0.6205248237,
-0.9138090014,
-0.3899065554,
0.950274229,
0.5008085966,
0.835796237,
0.2061991096,
0.4382961988,
0.2212434411,
0.2386301905,
-0.4554674029,
-0.1948473305,
-0.2727106214,
-0.4682522714,
-0.7568342686,
-0.4630294442,
0.2770031393,
0.8193100691,
1.0571193695,
-0.2581185102,
-0.2896580398,
0.1516056359,
0.3285709918,
-0.5453490615,
0.0113802711,
-0.604701221,
-0.0707047954,
-0.2498383969,
-0.0854635909,
-0.404815346,
-0.4407689869,
0.5317468643,
-0.6651664376,
0.2374889851,
-0.3189713359,
0.7496315241,
0.0970532298,
-0.7108131647,
0.1291952878,
-0.4195774198,
0.9155200124,
-0.8463466167,
0.4962522089,
0.5788238645,
0.1773195267,
-0.4123257995,
-1.2268013954,
-0.5737802386,
-0.3100052476,
-0.4133136868,
0.5167504549,
0.2684713006,
0.1152291298,
0.1096857563,
0.0309548732,
-0.870967865,
0.4118405879,
-0.468251884,
-0.085325256,
0.8679919839,
-0.2354215533,
0.5906102061,
0.1611558497,
-0.4013846517,
-0.2097254544,
-0.8323602676,
0.4894480407,
0.4343713224,
0.3937349319,
0.0495978892,
0.5627020001,
0.1727214903,
0.8352010846,
-0.1878097057,
0.0684264302,
0.0783519894,
-0.3792235255,
-0.0856532156,
-0.0644228309,
0.654448688,
0.2500647604,
0.6997436285,
0.1526664495,
-0.1456796974,
0.1654887199,
0.2036700249,
-0.4911977053,
-0.7171887755,
0.149995923,
-0.4232559502,
0.113372907,
0.2752259374,
-0.5766687393,
-0.0980324075,
-0.3851872385,
0.4782014489,
-0.1740009934,
-0.4779082239,
0.3777121007,
-0.084258467,
0.3389263153,
0.0946422517,
-0.8692526221,
0.3509736657,
0.6905501485,
0.5195926428,
-0.1638228148,
-0.6938135028,
-0.2219709903,
-0.0133911045,
-0.4531710744,
0.8844122887,
-0.4323028922,
-0.4208242297,
0.2825407684,
0.2215039879,
-0.6316667199,
-0.5905495882,
0.2207558453,
-0.608335495,
0.5598527789,
-0.0571540184,
-0.5750800371,
-0.4101592898,
-0.1024603695,
-0.6712363958,
0.71777457,
0.1276529878,
-0.648673296,
0.5853862166,
-0.3490237594,
-0.7641413808,
-0.2833272815,
-0.1920897663,
-0.2929741144,
0.168474853,
-0.2238267958,
0.4816962779,
0.2996480763,
0.636187613,
-0.0863794684,
-0.4191102087,
0.4718821645,
-0.2122748494,
0.6502839327,
0.1261218488,
0.0234961715,
0.2034181952,
-0.7219847441,
-0.017148098,
0.2805598974,
-0.366101414,
-0.608382225,
0.432744354,
0.0509253256,
0.2105721235,
0.3266097605,
-0.0983583331,
0.2564331889,
-0.5842219591,
0.2124251425,
0.4728298783,
0.1056504399,
0.3678684235,
-0.0539443567,
0.3925416768,
0.1376217008,
-0.1156022251,
-0.0087203253,
-0.5117692947,
-0.4674382806,
0.1469542682,
0.1557427496,
0.8402398825,
-0.6878845096,
0.0642523989,
0.0905910209,
-0.3040009141,
-0.2963271141,
0.0887146816,
0.736911118,
0.2475893348,
0.3546206057,
-0.5089197755,
-0.3098352551,
-0.8413239717,
-0.5474411845,
-0.2711597681,
-0.1028616801,
-0.1948344409,
0.3504456282,
-0.0805772543,
0.7792187929,
-0.6745311022,
0.1022936776,
-0.5439514518,
0.381921947,
0.3345548809,
0.6674197316,
0.6357178092,
-0.7935507298,
-0.4469594955,
-0.2175652087,
-0.3804349899,
-0.2100639343,
-0.1990728974,
-0.0657333136,
0.0215237997,
0.6752706766,
-0.3690504432,
0.6584897637,
0.1567558497,
-0.4283701479,
0.5069887638,
-0.2711210549,
-0.1895870864,
-1.1090167761,
-0.0744700953,
0.0915944055,
0.1024364382,
-1.0179278851,
-0.1179918423,
0.1179117411,
0.0945575163,
-0.6508840322,
0.3658563495,
-0.3626268804,
-0.1913240701,
-0.5135524273,
0.177622959,
-0.2169821262,
0.5110095143,
0.7554947734,
0.6580339074,
0.2902442515,
-0.6097635031,
-0.1578991413,
-0.0156243611,
-0.5349018574,
0.1113532633,
-1.0280989408,
0.006449319,
-0.3657437265,
0.0847019777,
-1.6533347368,
-0.2464384586,
0.2250903547,
-0.5354487896,
0.3295916915,
0.004789243,
-0.2903799415,
-0.0047033327,
-0.0036387497,
0.472543776,
0.1556667238,
-0.2093929499,
-0.0009770147,
0.1688640118,
-0.4916650355,
-0.5568158627,
-0.5658116341,
-0.3848808706,
-0.1834042966,
-0.2424252778,
0.49735865,
-0.0762515292,
-0.5610915422,
-0.1596616805,
0.1772097498,
-0.4041324854,
0.2861692011,
0.0618739165,
0.2528123558,
-0.2496519834,
0.1635987759,
0.0593488626,
-0.2640465498,
0.2582708299,
0.1406217217,
0.5695255399,
0.38667202,
-0.195837602,
-0.3187142909,
0.1995854974,
0.1413224488,
-0.2585175931,
0.6541236043,
0.4793464243,
-0.3722703159,
-0.0843467265,
-0.0542443655,
-0.3550545275,
-0.41621387,
0.8683421612,
-0.4562970102,
-0.6213709116,
0.1794300079,
0.1416621804,
0.192724973,
0.0877856538,
0.237780869,
-0.2433203757,
1.0680873394,
0.5218778253,
-0.0150883431,
0.7411700487,
-0.110204868,
0.5034580231,
-0.3667299151,
-0.0952154249,
-0.1310507059,
-0.3102666438,
-0.5246152282,
-0.2001838088,
0.0967901126,
0.4037706256,
-0.382740289,
0.1987024248,
0.0559858046,
0.303786099,
0.6348809004,
0.2132231146,
-0.1921036839,
-0.1346344054,
0.0413599499,
-0.3042218983,
-0.5603803396,
-0.2635289133,
1.0315016508,
0.1993509978,
0.5253553391,
0.2821367979,
0.3219995499,
-0.105704844,
0.4393766522,
-0.7598137856,
0.6374567151,
-0.2075557858,
-0.7042401433,
-0.2748144567,
0.0851213112,
-1.4282385111,
0.4141032994,
-0.2719403803,
-0.6209503412,
-0.0151951294,
-0.040948499,
-0.5783443451,
-0.1672656536,
-0.8048371673,
1.1272661686,
-0.6196550131,
-0.5181103349,
-0.2828561664,
-0.8234328628,
0.4500468373,
-0.1642455608,
0.3033849597,
0.1765826195,
0.0333496109,
0.9520323873,
-0.1980462223,
0.9124960303,
-0.4506746233,
-0.1217035353,
0.2137944251,
-0.0713871941,
0.082046777,
-0.0182244405,
0.1433845758,
-0.1290100962,
0.2080185711,
-0.6097230315,
-0.830514431,
0.4413715005,
-0.8839651346,
-0.7480021119,
-0.4364799261,
-0.5396606326,
-0.2419230193,
0.2008186281,
0.3499284089,
0.1089054048,
-0.2945471406,
-0.0539100356,
0.3958254158,
-0.4648025036,
0.4470126331,
0.8743309975,
-0.4818611443,
-0.3776228428,
0.6959562302,
0.4919460118,
0.4094761312,
0.3371395767,
0.1464768499,
-0.3219671547,
-0.7502297759,
0.408760488,
0.4150306284,
-0.3223144114,
0.6044480205,
-0.1794072241,
-0.4113949835,
-0.6383519769,
-0.3156650662,
-0.2534022033,
-0.2620491385,
-0.1936024576,
-0.4020240009,
-0.3219479024,
0.7471562028,
-0.2046992034,
1.1028045416,
-0.6167031527,
0.1714694202,
0.2913425565,
0.002606655,
-0.1005502865,
-0.7589915395,
-0.3504664302,
0.0961271301,
-0.2258340865,
-1.0323183537,
0.5838194489,
0.1639826,
0.9436930418,
0.8125321865,
-0.3327512443,
0.5346959829,
-0.4828998148,
0.9184444547,
0.1613873988,
-0.6110094786,
0.9028583765,
-0.2367843091,
-0.0212236159,
0.3472946286,
0.7477241755,
-0.1151730865,
0.1978542209,
-0.5681416392,
-0.9034816623,
0.3039310575,
-0.2294529527,
-0.1443179548,
-0.1006368026,
0.526443243,
0.1143008843,
0.0775467828,
-0.9102112651,
-0.1955673844,
-0.0034877835,
-0.2697094977,
-0.8232589364,
-0.5760326982,
0.1904280335,
-0.3128673434,
0.4612482786,
0.1040827855,
-0.0858120248,
0.1140376031,
-0.1609755009,
0.3347346187,
0.1576031744,
0.4984906316,
0.9480156302,
-0.3950523138,
0.2656596899,
-0.0683564842,
-0.6154284477,
0.2169929445,
0.1323644966,
-0.0309182554,
-0.000336255,
0.8063876629,
0.3509107828,
0.527666986,
-0.5345641971,
0.5199824572,
0.0814635679,
-0.1116521358,
-0.6187206507,
-0.0004381568,
-0.0856647193,
0.201314345,
-0.0554707162,
-0.3114313185,
0.0143674482,
-0.9168998599,
0.5569882393,
0.2608292103,
-0.2893080115,
-0.8684610128,
0.630692184,
-0.0598849393,
-0.3847162724,
0.641268611,
0.2678865194,
-0.5719867945,
0.6815196276,
0.7850189209,
0.4730769396,
-0.8152405024,
0.2112359703,
0.5805534124,
0.2749080062,
-0.13822335,
0.7034727335,
0.1084383577,
-1.1838722229,
-0.356918782,
-0.0567294657,
-0.1220712736,
0.2062021196,
-1.0028346777,
0.1116326079,
-0.5467381477,
-0.2866275907,
0.0534407869,
0.1275942475,
-0.4721728861,
0.562351048,
0.0244889986,
0.6590061784,
-1.2316639423,
1.33309412,
0.9394123554,
-0.6534289122,
-0.8830294013,
0.1427823454,
-0.1780840009,
-0.9777219296,
0.8139050603,
0.0278548915,
0.3042008579,
0.1460569948,
-0.5553258657,
-0.7866564989,
0.85321486,
-0.0930205286,
-0.5769065619,
-0.0151230851,
0.2766834497,
0.4192556739,
-0.179442659,
0.5280422568,
0.8793913126,
0.3502134681,
-0.3078971803,
-0.6185591221,
-0.4281043112,
-0.2900291085,
-0.1608078629,
-0.1676143855,
-0.573812902,
1.0742385387,
-0.3653049171,
-0.1719753146,
-0.0032012817,
0.722828567,
0.5932639837,
0.7643636465,
0.6240297556,
0.4866981208,
0.5387529135,
0.001356381,
0.7700413465,
-0.3034408987,
-0.058982715,
1.3293857574,
-0.3511927724,
1.4000115395,
0.6927415729,
-0.5506290197,
0.8159107566,
1.0827801228,
0.4751212299,
0.7903676629,
0.4904259443,
0.030162083,
-0.1969350874,
-0.0803086907,
-0.3956639469,
0.3605959713,
0.5630474091,
-0.3463813961,
0.1604315937,
-0.1416295171,
0.2775312662,
0.3553768694,
-0.1996393204,
0.5861192942,
0.4044199586,
-1.1356633902,
0.2160561681,
-0.1178873852,
0.4482762516,
-0.7110309005,
-0.1046046764,
-0.5021519661,
0.3884402812,
-0.226970762,
-1.0636587143,
0.2404443175,
-0.4654716253,
-0.04194564,
-0.1255217344,
0.7744232416,
-0.8490056992,
-0.483124584,
0.6069894433,
0.7220031619,
0.4549530745,
0.060695909,
-0.4449626207,
-0.4801703691,
0.0168588273,
-0.4933494329,
0.5003257394,
0.1230437532,
-0.0078983409,
0.2279673517,
0.7327578664,
0.2543934286,
0.0967663527,
0.4077732265,
0.4033433795,
-0.7844570875,
-0.4236390293,
-0.8270098567,
0.7268228531,
0.2131138295,
-0.3093169928,
0.7728462219,
0.4265508056,
1.1690030098,
-0.1432782561,
0.7406201363,
0.3847808838,
0.5940060616,
-0.515005827,
0.4664727747,
-0.6208381057,
0.0443884283,
-0.2136715949,
-0.834454596,
-0.3648684323,
0.7898594737,
-0.6231253147,
-0.1236092895,
0.7054867148,
0.8698227406,
-0.0239011925,
-0.2237498462,
0.3424024284,
0.0899795815,
0.1726803035,
0.9501156211,
1.1504077911,
-0.317163378,
-0.1065437868,
-0.1866282523,
-0.3537762761,
0.0671877265,
-0.4434561133,
-0.9343415499,
-0.5023707747,
-0.2512722611,
-0.037376672,
0.1706043631,
0.6495808363,
0.3406004906,
-0.7719192505,
-0.6261391044,
-0.1449666917,
0.0145464865,
-0.2832697034,
-0.2545609176,
0.6015176177,
-0.3161053061,
-0.8029946685,
0.5317687988,
-0.1515207887,
0.1962496489,
-0.0273444653,
-0.0116099212,
-0.6572964191,
0.1589513719,
0.5910483003,
0.0997088253,
-0.7403897643,
-0.325067848,
-0.032471206,
-0.0766403452,
-0.3024576902,
0.9691520333,
-0.5353822112,
0.3318439126,
0.6439125538,
0.2594065368,
0.03036719,
0.3050652444,
0.828369379,
-0.3741521537,
0.4145177901,
-0.1877012253,
0.5805919766,
-0.1068948656,
-0.1040382609,
0.6919597387,
0.4107964933,
-0.5232890248,
-0.6099300385,
0.2583332658,
-0.7730215192,
-0.5957835913,
1.0570342541,
-0.5843446851,
0.1907481402,
-0.1342899203,
-0.2657245696,
0.5670355558,
0.2374887019,
0.5488516092,
0.7262308002,
0.048009403,
-0.4359535277,
-0.8163100481,
0.4177038968,
0.8789891601,
-0.4878963828,
-0.5231651664,
0.3809751868,
0.3755060732,
-0.1419251859,
0.7077316046,
0.251855135,
0.2112409025,
-0.0328227095,
0.0730930641,
0.3286934793,
-0.5964465737,
-0.244219631,
-0.0629680529,
0.1064312384,
-0.4994737506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08148v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08148v1 | Empirical Investigation of Neural Symbolic Reasoning Strategies | 2023-02-16T08:49:47 | 2023-02-16T08:49:47 | Yoichi Aoki, Keito Kudo, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Ana Brassard, Masashi Yoshikawa, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Neural reasoning accuracy improves when generating intermediate reasoning
steps. However, the source of this improvement is yet unclear. Here, we
investigate and factorize the benefit of generating intermediate steps for
symbolic reasoning. Specifically, we decompose the reasoning strategy w.r.t.
step granularity and chaining strategy. With a purely symbolic numerical
reasoning dataset (e.g., A=1, B=3, C=A+3, C?), we found that the choice of
reasoning strategies significantly affects the performance, with the gap
becoming even larger as the extrapolation length becomes longer. Surprisingly,
we also found that certain configurations lead to nearly perfect performance,
even in the case of length extrapolation. Our results indicate the importance
of further exploring effective strategies for neural reasoning models. | [
-0.2815672755,
-0.8861952424,
0.8498616219,
0.2532306015,
-0.2861764729,
0.0844696537,
-0.2048714012,
-0.4120598137,
0.0962404832,
0.0878036171,
-0.4032986164,
-0.263791889,
-0.5531387925,
0.2508832216,
-0.3224514127,
0.6961512566,
0.18637456,
0.1965275854,
0.0661349669,
-0.1379390955,
-0.6122842431,
-0.6499883533,
-0.8853763938,
-0.6260403991,
0.8773270249,
0.2670103908,
0.9760109782,
1.1135596037,
0.4949018657,
0.3784150779,
-0.3535969257,
0.4139424264,
-0.0389455967,
0.5274981856,
-0.0694976598,
-0.8938580751,
-0.2860066593,
-0.3006691933,
0.5200583935,
0.6724824905,
-0.3340114951,
0.0625949875,
-0.2428887188,
0.8252276182,
-0.3427020013,
0.1203271747,
-0.4998116791,
0.0984948575,
-0.2271417379,
-0.526976943,
-0.5364710093,
-0.3862058818,
0.0749136284,
-0.5008026361,
0.0191182755,
-0.114120461,
0.5995002389,
0.4038546383,
-0.330155015,
-0.2844122946,
-0.8254014254,
0.5897116065,
-0.6625820994,
0.1340822428,
0.1776244342,
0.3971503079,
-0.1813013852,
-0.8497878313,
-0.096539326,
-0.3125886023,
-0.2075497806,
-0.333768934,
-0.0349978469,
0.4036712646,
0.940523386,
-0.0652219355,
-0.158648327,
-0.231514886,
-0.3884107769,
-0.0892139822,
0.9089961648,
0.2925850451,
0.3322327733,
0.0094973594,
0.1490344703,
-0.5290930867,
-0.6584360003,
0.2097351998,
0.4886762798,
0.3782828748,
0.2861407101,
0.4627270699,
-0.105298385,
0.8646208048,
0.0301199574,
0.0654128864,
-0.0546111017,
-0.393643558,
0.1117562279,
0.2616083622,
0.3359895647,
-0.0449806638,
0.2844869196,
-0.1437186599,
-0.3489792347,
-0.018250674,
0.5840889812,
-0.7657265663,
-0.2613988817,
0.0564483292,
-0.4519421756,
-0.2032062262,
-0.0051219761,
-0.2320397794,
-0.1237056702,
-0.7790341973,
0.4612311125,
-0.7842088938,
-0.0496232845,
0.1134136394,
-0.5652747154,
-0.0862097219,
0.4580197632,
-0.8547281027,
0.4292946458,
0.9420326352,
1.032482028,
0.209327206,
-0.3229802251,
-0.4451749027,
-0.0712327585,
-0.8822464943,
0.7679825425,
-0.703253448,
-0.1593031138,
-0.2373286933,
-0.5043182969,
-0.0049518771,
-0.526124239,
0.3065690994,
-0.4791021049,
-0.279774636,
-0.7020571828,
-0.2344344258,
-0.5295084715,
0.1650927067,
-0.7087705731,
0.9179709554,
-0.2130682021,
-0.3390727341,
0.4065025151,
-0.9173125625,
-0.5397235751,
-0.1586202532,
-0.4134508073,
-0.0390602872,
0.6107847691,
0.1356568784,
0.3022000492,
-0.2147948295,
0.2471331358,
-0.181989342,
-0.6706852913,
0.3862159252,
-0.4647698104,
0.7156845331,
0.087314032,
-0.6823913455,
0.0597758442,
-0.611853838,
0.2878961265,
0.038952291,
-0.067122072,
-0.5385993719,
0.1844109446,
-0.7775138021,
0.4784067571,
-0.3506356776,
-0.0924694687,
0.1788028032,
-0.1420259923,
0.3673301339,
0.8884875178,
0.0773597062,
0.4290359318,
-0.3354564905,
0.414293468,
0.0895530283,
0.1441712677,
-0.3010380864,
-0.5699374676,
-0.805760622,
0.14716506,
0.6817308664,
0.1662171334,
-0.8538906574,
0.0436317809,
-0.2444146127,
-0.3127797544,
-0.0681742877,
-0.2858409584,
0.611554265,
0.1579825878,
0.2967847288,
0.0532067493,
-0.4232376814,
-0.7535143495,
-0.4381658435,
-0.3826235831,
0.1685488671,
0.1181391701,
0.6968377829,
0.319178164,
0.5059383512,
-0.4333658516,
0.4200764596,
-0.0644188896,
0.3897128701,
0.3162330091,
0.3500694036,
0.329952538,
-0.5352178216,
-0.2874667645,
0.0030022552,
-0.9330530167,
0.0323889516,
-0.5806285143,
-0.433649689,
0.0117428591,
0.6354745626,
-0.628786087,
0.4834905565,
0.0512651652,
-0.2615506947,
0.6819872856,
-0.3141820133,
-0.0208898708,
-0.467735678,
-0.2683656514,
0.2685146928,
0.0430675261,
-0.8004472256,
0.2820181549,
0.0038082802,
0.3802113533,
-0.2518854439,
0.1953718364,
-0.5797302723,
0.0026215983,
-0.1693157703,
-0.2710497081,
-0.2930171192,
0.5260662436,
0.2183221281,
0.6702724695,
0.4613653719,
-0.6241313815,
0.0162738506,
-0.2444237173,
0.0359546728,
0.3260774314,
-1.0351219177,
0.2988997698,
0.0438065901,
0.384385258,
-0.8230339289,
0.049351681,
-0.0119338324,
-0.4902692735,
0.3049743474,
0.0425725542,
-0.5219333172,
-0.2438956797,
-0.254439652,
0.5374760032,
0.5209656358,
-0.4630595446,
0.85758394,
-0.1218951792,
-0.02189078,
-0.5296217799,
-0.7296466231,
0.2216701657,
-0.3052838147,
-0.7834251523,
0.344478637,
0.2056727111,
-0.672695756,
-0.2520495951,
-0.3064117134,
0.1673148572,
-0.0743339956,
0.086484924,
-0.083717525,
-0.2434199601,
0.1628328711,
0.3089130819,
-0.2614421844,
0.6546441913,
-0.1560592055,
0.5610619187,
-0.1554017812,
-0.4095115364,
-0.2797490954,
0.3279334605,
0.3022048473,
0.2469065636,
0.6262103319,
0.2767051458,
-0.3403442502,
-0.4345017672,
-0.3575871289,
-0.5737138987,
-0.5353671908,
0.1161389276,
-0.630931735,
-0.3294344842,
0.4678786397,
-0.1346227229,
-0.0259790998,
0.3305377066,
0.1012486815,
0.0807885379,
1.4324053526,
0.117412433,
0.6164157391,
0.1713477671,
-0.5558201671,
0.3308489919,
-0.6537666321,
-0.6228230596,
-0.4431551993,
-0.6941242814,
-0.3343429267,
-0.4445720911,
0.3446259499,
0.2040885091,
-0.571531713,
0.2167376876,
-0.5880488157,
0.6413189769,
0.7974045873,
0.5580111742,
0.1947697699,
0.1894964427,
-0.323969394,
0.0294771809,
-0.9168794155,
-0.2256864309,
0.8815916181,
0.2992706299,
0.470733285,
0.0693176165,
0.6889264584,
0.0917299986,
-0.1543756723,
-0.634157896,
0.7914649248,
0.0728496611,
-0.2798195779,
-0.4498089254,
-0.6421684623,
-0.6181313396,
0.3818041682,
0.070299454,
-0.4592040777,
0.1848437637,
0.0546666868,
-0.527053833,
0.2751851082,
-0.5557143092,
0.2993855476,
-0.5577573776,
-0.3405625224,
-0.1444574147,
-0.9044200182,
0.2612399757,
0.0684469342,
-0.3027946353,
0.2709638476,
-0.2143369019,
0.8880401254,
-0.8408136368,
0.610011518,
-0.1244378239,
0.1612933576,
0.3299001455,
0.310449928,
0.7342925668,
-0.1135169566,
-0.0088846032,
0.3964548409,
-0.2859508097,
-0.4335370064,
-1.1119002104,
0.4311642647,
-0.3807381988,
-0.8477693796,
-0.6443841457,
-0.7986217141,
-0.2708171308,
-0.1863533556,
0.1532826424,
0.4688817859,
0.3425103426,
0.3953641951,
0.6867751479,
0.2459204793,
0.7986541986,
0.0564535595,
0.0482046604,
-0.3168730736,
0.5504584312,
0.4779767394,
0.3551992774,
0.1175300553,
0.4472796917,
-0.5888177752,
-0.652380228,
-0.50339818,
0.2281413376,
-0.7071707249,
-0.0263126977,
-0.4802066386,
-0.3600422442,
0.024169486,
-0.1593184173,
-0.1529002041,
-0.7276783586,
0.1567461342,
-0.2812337279,
0.4634595811,
0.778909266,
-0.4527412057,
0.2083367705,
-0.5568486452,
0.0503773093,
0.3329318762,
-0.121968165,
0.6203870177,
-0.2747909129,
-0.1489472687,
0.4419957697,
-0.2969879806,
-0.722233355,
0.0134717077,
-0.14794074,
0.5371416807,
0.4362784922,
-0.3097872436,
1.3007113934,
-0.5346196294,
0.8620068431,
0.3834627867,
-0.7840915322,
0.531683445,
-0.4150554836,
0.3738362193,
0.3473628759,
0.4881035089,
-0.2323680222,
0.069548592,
-0.9165623784,
-0.7513686419,
0.7062369585,
0.5913294554,
0.0510440841,
-0.116828531,
0.4344069362,
-0.2110257,
-0.0016203206,
-0.2079763114,
-0.3476139009,
0.2389146686,
0.3953610659,
0.2175181806,
0.0866566598,
-0.3554908335,
-0.760646522,
0.5973907113,
-0.1506478935,
0.2770686448,
0.0650602505,
0.2068937868,
-0.020639522,
-0.2940458655,
0.6433012486,
0.9545880556,
0.1600211859,
0.1751829833,
0.245566234,
-0.2851893604,
0.2517554164,
-0.1112757549,
-0.156962499,
0.3643176556,
0.6476120353,
0.6866021156,
-0.0200075153,
-0.3663549423,
0.1646695584,
0.0102621652,
-0.3753045201,
-0.0137232421,
0.3203880191,
-0.120691821,
0.3840714693,
0.3108218908,
0.4210738838,
0.1937200129,
-0.5069260001,
0.2393315136,
0.2215576172,
-0.2230401039,
-0.3026514649,
0.4129844904,
-0.132912457,
-0.5854210854,
0.8606038094,
-0.1115594357,
-0.480481863,
1.0028219223,
0.6311796904,
0.758521378,
-0.2276834846,
0.660076499,
0.4566955566,
0.3038407564,
-0.598123312,
0.2972244322,
-0.3359816372,
-0.3060344458,
-0.6400732994,
-0.2809585333,
-0.1154260263,
-0.1503624469,
-0.5869942307,
0.0520658754,
-0.3953271508,
-0.2284494191,
-0.0357740149,
-0.2249634564,
-0.3131697476,
0.2056422085,
-0.0186536275,
1.0062959194,
-0.6908597946,
0.2596873343,
0.5490740538,
-0.4158279598,
-1.2637287378,
-0.129830718,
-0.0423134789,
-0.7203505635,
0.8293453455,
0.1433791518,
-0.1694951802,
-0.5010080338,
-0.4572731256,
-0.9616262913,
0.9279894233,
0.2646604478,
-0.421076268,
-0.4164811373,
0.4438146353,
0.8738846183,
-0.2675269246,
0.6449345946,
0.7846090794,
0.4854682684,
0.5202718973,
-0.4556964934,
0.3892487586,
-0.5775740743,
0.4993999898,
0.4770331085,
-0.4748722017,
0.8317664266,
-0.3409836888,
0.0798836574,
0.0556253679,
0.5267823935,
0.5732749104,
0.4710919261,
0.4667700231,
0.7916491032,
0.6961606741,
-0.3296058178,
1.2594461441,
-0.3395167589,
-0.1649073809,
0.9249687195,
0.1077289581,
0.520878911,
0.4083207846,
-0.0496354587,
0.8189131618,
0.9229614139,
0.2619502842,
0.4272642136,
0.4876897633,
-0.0467268564,
-0.4684850574,
0.0226941574,
-0.5590215325,
0.2764624953,
0.4399084747,
-0.7171840072,
-0.2546827793,
-0.5253996253,
0.3390037715,
-0.0932386294,
-0.4411480129,
0.5821011066,
0.171488747,
-1.0107504129,
0.6500543952,
-0.2401836962,
0.105543837,
-0.6107025743,
-0.5631024837,
-0.2206712663,
0.0333420523,
-0.2903689146,
-0.6192890406,
0.3574325442,
-0.2794459462,
0.0939938053,
-0.1367814392,
0.6896136403,
0.028685065,
-0.3770390451,
0.1793444008,
0.6317178011,
0.0907639712,
-0.323268652,
-0.8413701653,
-0.1793841869,
-0.1882132888,
-0.3470021188,
0.3219168484,
0.8026175499,
-0.3498249352,
0.5623317361,
1.0524840355,
0.1771128178,
0.2079687268,
0.2370268106,
0.8768479824,
-0.7970588207,
-0.4720501304,
-1.2448477745,
0.53964746,
-0.4640250802,
-0.4524904788,
0.8354352117,
0.4857339561,
0.6641253829,
0.1650455147,
0.4447908401,
0.1471992582,
-0.3628112376,
-0.6005889773,
0.2804369926,
-0.3844024539,
0.3337494731,
-0.1727502197,
-1.0592788458,
-0.3520288169,
0.4480671883,
-0.311680764,
0.3700073063,
1.183052063,
0.7752191424,
0.0743048415,
0.427934736,
0.2625418901,
0.2165834308,
0.1533115357,
0.4550357461,
1.0287359953,
-0.3227149248,
0.2081585228,
-0.6060134172,
-0.1940862387,
0.2727618515,
-0.8472877145,
-0.9013894796,
-0.4222055078,
-0.2294481695,
-0.6538222432,
0.3739581108,
0.6553862095,
0.8580377698,
-0.3288331926,
-0.2848552167,
-0.6172114611,
0.104736872,
-0.8183555603,
-0.2032562792,
0.3245768845,
-0.6153998375,
-0.187236473,
0.1299825758,
0.2642802,
-0.2828473449,
0.1008230522,
-0.1741466671,
-0.2045489699,
0.4565776289,
0.7196047306,
0.0828823373,
-0.6642066836,
-0.113854751,
0.1399949193,
0.2754481435,
0.0706183314,
1.06156075,
-0.496471107,
0.1739372164,
0.9012596607,
0.5096877813,
0.4248929322,
0.2336602509,
0.6702385545,
-0.529935956,
-0.3212531507,
0.3020893037,
0.305930078,
-0.0937979594,
-0.5024265051,
0.9117794037,
0.1615111083,
-0.5226438642,
-0.8273670673,
-0.0521634743,
-0.6703547239,
-0.4426656663,
1.4346684217,
0.0227016211,
-0.4932600856,
0.1762464941,
-0.0977491513,
0.093730703,
-0.4601883888,
0.7950693965,
0.6613149643,
-0.8524216413,
0.1807103455,
-0.3191544414,
0.440127641,
0.4147551358,
-0.6388524771,
-0.3065002263,
0.3987862766,
-0.0933538377,
0.5635405779,
0.3781566024,
-0.105984807,
0.5293771029,
0.445366472,
-0.6836235523,
-0.3210472465,
-0.9363433719,
-0.3537963629,
0.1064246893,
-0.3022883832,
-0.0579281002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08146v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08146v1 | CluCDD:Contrastive Dialogue Disentanglement via Clustering | 2023-02-16T08:47:51 | 2023-02-16T08:47:51 | Jingsheng Gao, Zeyu Li, Suncheng Xiang, Ting Liu, Yuzhuo Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL | A huge number of multi-participant dialogues happen online every day, which
leads to difficulty in understanding the nature of dialogue dynamics for both
humans and machines. Dialogue disentanglement aims at separating an entangled
dialogue into detached sessions, thus increasing the readability of long
disordered dialogue. Previous studies mainly focus on message-pair
classification and clustering in two-step methods, which cannot guarantee the
whole clustering performance in a dialogue. To address this challenge, we
propose a simple yet effective model named CluCDD, which aggregates utterances
by contrastive learning. More specifically, our model pulls utterances in the
same session together and pushes away utterances in different ones. Then a
clustering method is adopted to generate predicted clustering labels.
Comprehensive experiments conducted on the Movie Dialogue dataset and IRC
dataset demonstrate that our model achieves a new state-of-the-art result. | [
-0.5095386505,
-0.9295110106,
0.3622142971,
-0.0585696921,
-0.658796072,
0.4046909809,
-0.1361815482,
-0.4192713201,
0.3128277659,
0.1905892044,
-0.7751315236,
-0.5708283782,
-0.7695140839,
-0.0636335164,
-0.6788855791,
0.9871119261,
0.401473254,
0.2683073878,
-0.4765764475,
-0.3201216757,
-0.2593483627,
-0.3445464969,
-0.5985750556,
-0.3942976594,
0.3207120299,
0.2619011104,
0.6279699206,
0.3005563915,
0.3522284627,
0.3411761224,
-0.5643420815,
0.0879762471,
-0.8496722579,
0.0774932206,
-0.1179559082,
-0.495983243,
0.1914046109,
-0.0096151792,
0.5187920332,
0.9283280969,
-0.4288793206,
-0.2062107176,
0.3740655184,
0.6795719266,
-0.1333804429,
0.0310931299,
-0.4511522353,
-0.0332155861,
-0.0803768411,
0.4842207432,
-0.1828724295,
-0.4593731761,
0.5309245586,
-0.3798920512,
0.5034511089,
-0.0785057247,
0.5561368465,
0.4116943777,
-0.4666266441,
-0.358608216,
-0.682469666,
0.7250805497,
-0.6436691284,
0.3198300898,
0.2046324611,
0.1617835462,
-0.0254355725,
-0.5110315681,
-0.6654729247,
0.0426073261,
-0.3702132106,
0.0379144698,
0.0358508565,
0.2311264426,
0.0350329094,
0.5220760703,
-0.5379683375,
0.3670804501,
-0.4042037129,
0.0007771254,
0.2087077945,
0.1973329782,
0.2391849905,
0.1460108012,
-0.5109036565,
-0.0050828089,
-0.3458040655,
-0.1319254488,
0.0414714999,
-0.0837257281,
-0.4710308909,
0.1155094206,
-0.0412885286,
0.5192066431,
0.5471806526,
-0.2397662252,
0.0179585367,
-0.1846775413,
-0.0733830705,
0.4216153622,
0.630736351,
0.7711234093,
-0.272040695,
-0.2207631171,
0.345875293,
0.2562654316,
-0.1008124873,
-0.9492760897,
-0.4837970138,
0.3328736424,
-0.5297691822,
-0.4551481009,
0.003660568,
-1.1360000372,
-0.7603145838,
-0.3278704286,
0.2398033887,
-0.413724184,
-0.4212132096,
-0.2404145449,
-0.1448777765,
-0.0077793696,
0.286298573,
-1.0408340693,
0.4915615022,
0.4377803504,
1.0055656433,
-0.8323692679,
-0.1144500896,
-0.2907356024,
-0.0279662386,
-0.1007536501,
0.6567724943,
-0.6011457443,
-0.6803469658,
-0.2456694692,
0.0290061459,
-0.0756261721,
-0.6875792742,
0.0536377952,
-0.2913745046,
0.1516997069,
0.1189991087,
-0.664434433,
-0.2928850055,
0.2683422267,
-0.8270494342,
0.3689819872,
0.0965587944,
-0.8633033037,
0.2049663365,
-0.5353850126,
-0.2881974578,
-0.0003026808,
-0.2634854019,
-0.6303265095,
0.0643640235,
0.1174681559,
0.0693014637,
-0.3350455463,
0.3541581035,
-0.5576451421,
-0.4373289943,
0.4999084473,
-0.3660326898,
0.6459078789,
0.4585313201,
-0.3222079575,
0.0533253103,
-0.5271591544,
-0.3783144057,
-0.0181704983,
-0.108102642,
-0.3766575158,
0.0950100422,
-0.5048568249,
0.0190173909,
0.158254981,
-0.6039262414,
-0.1610857993,
-0.6189665198,
0.6323288679,
0.5510647893,
0.1650928408,
0.7396650314,
-0.3316693604,
0.1492193937,
0.9145774245,
-0.0012884755,
-0.1438124627,
-0.348187834,
-0.7767648697,
-0.4617367387,
0.3339829743,
0.470441252,
-0.3959209919,
0.4930051863,
0.2168015689,
-0.4995000064,
-0.7216501236,
0.0661664456,
0.437007606,
0.4385628104,
0.2909028828,
-0.3180913329,
-0.3390188813,
-0.7502851486,
0.1232670322,
-0.0174356066,
-0.003209807,
0.2492035329,
0.1343216747,
-0.5024949312,
0.8073136806,
-0.8037474751,
-0.227419734,
-0.2424956411,
0.4947314858,
0.108225517,
0.7094142437,
0.0755142421,
-0.9580903649,
-0.5397786498,
-0.0591862313,
-0.6559627056,
0.2369172871,
-0.1575246751,
-0.1298193336,
0.1020113826,
0.9165149927,
-0.5837893486,
0.6071703434,
0.5390280485,
0.0518951416,
0.4585995078,
-0.1371453851,
0.1852613837,
-1.1259604692,
-0.3886573017,
-0.1019762978,
-0.1773912013,
-0.7050788999,
-0.0939869806,
-0.4786995351,
-0.2061321735,
-0.4488546252,
0.098913312,
-0.3287352026,
0.0832352042,
-0.1339633763,
0.4925715029,
-0.0210115835,
0.6736831665,
0.1401920766,
0.4177418649,
0.7717514634,
-0.8702992797,
0.3669179976,
0.5060017109,
-0.5676535964,
0.7369877696,
-0.7000148296,
0.2671404481,
-0.2119651139,
0.3570318818,
-1.4332866669,
-0.0921018794,
-0.0684952959,
-0.2525909841,
0.1391279995,
0.0342763476,
-0.1592323631,
-0.0724299476,
-0.0992813185,
0.7760447264,
0.553057909,
-0.9636330605,
0.6893470883,
0.6467695832,
-0.3440896869,
-0.0293705408,
-0.5193861723,
-0.3960207403,
-0.756242156,
-0.6026015878,
0.4300171733,
-0.3994235396,
-0.3230032027,
-0.2612834573,
-0.131785512,
-0.2866874039,
0.1299185455,
0.3614388704,
0.0651535839,
0.1769721061,
0.1858527511,
0.3300040662,
0.0040050596,
-0.1116793305,
0.1330805868,
0.6481969953,
-0.0231142398,
-0.4214259684,
-0.6905741692,
0.6763925552,
0.5189487338,
-0.1012817025,
0.8351134658,
0.7844824791,
-0.188324213,
-0.2268277556,
-0.38243559,
-0.4867710471,
-0.4801819921,
0.2376280725,
-0.1626352221,
-1.2391712666,
0.593936801,
-0.7534201145,
0.0888456106,
-0.1258014888,
0.3978505731,
-0.4675590694,
1.2316201925,
0.5304751992,
-0.1053843126,
0.5393829942,
-0.1416443288,
0.5751627684,
-0.6298913956,
-0.2346765697,
-0.3178018034,
-0.529838264,
-0.6516859531,
-0.4134283364,
0.4822378457,
0.5623667836,
0.0629368871,
0.1061024144,
-0.6576696038,
0.5798292756,
0.540941,
0.3662783802,
0.3535785973,
-0.0743949935,
-0.3348083794,
-0.2128834128,
-0.4453491569,
-0.0155921467,
0.5524363518,
0.1200223491,
0.9045642614,
0.4006551504,
0.9855511785,
0.3844090104,
-0.0529350117,
-0.5134817362,
0.6103878021,
-0.1628866494,
-0.2300893813,
-0.3544163704,
-0.3348284662,
-1.1033560038,
0.4247682393,
-0.281760186,
-1.0508598089,
0.233281374,
0.0093984948,
-0.261580497,
0.1409946233,
-0.8748700023,
0.6725651622,
0.1817651242,
-0.1121317744,
-0.7230329514,
-0.9168211222,
0.7488745451,
-0.0238780677,
0.1830324531,
0.0970294327,
0.59524405,
0.7714563012,
-0.3568253815,
1.0559710264,
-0.0025479216,
0.0586043447,
0.4195262492,
0.312913686,
0.3226751983,
0.1687604338,
0.4462294281,
0.2136625499,
0.1510804147,
-0.1675518751,
-0.5133044124,
0.9114666581,
-0.5772128105,
-0.4914319515,
-0.2004287243,
-0.3611162007,
-0.0121499766,
0.0008153155,
0.2015561163,
0.6844029427,
-0.7421591878,
0.0543550402,
1.0465741158,
-0.2387286276,
0.4875143766,
0.6152724028,
-0.2145298272,
-0.4672631025,
1.1584072113,
-0.4097281694,
0.4803235233,
0.2668963075,
0.1634855121,
-0.4945533872,
-0.3606095612,
-0.0679323152,
0.4994713664,
-0.5417948365,
0.0859822556,
-0.4773074687,
-0.1252339333,
-0.4342816174,
-0.2063376755,
-0.1097128913,
-0.3384333253,
-0.6268479228,
-0.4286373854,
0.0795917735,
0.7287131548,
-0.2205905467,
0.4453471899,
-0.8774991035,
0.5860643387,
0.644800365,
0.2759963274,
0.0205028132,
-0.328635782,
-0.2691894174,
0.158001855,
-0.5571579337,
-0.744885087,
0.239747256,
0.2538946271,
0.4440182149,
0.8394414783,
0.4838442504,
0.6177933216,
-0.2665462196,
0.9861849546,
0.6942756772,
-0.8396272659,
0.3617495894,
-0.0303691663,
0.448345691,
0.5396898985,
0.2808045745,
-0.5461201668,
-0.4615145326,
-0.6120526791,
-0.6719452739,
0.7753251791,
-0.0295009837,
-0.2309299856,
-0.3175174296,
-0.2509554029,
0.1920852661,
0.1742531359,
-0.4493222833,
-0.3103100657,
-0.0081343539,
-0.3351837695,
-0.1495068222,
-0.2511513233,
-0.4818975925,
-0.3115846515,
0.2743977308,
0.14847821,
0.3583213091,
0.1019113734,
-0.3521296978,
0.2124091983,
0.2061162293,
0.6322774887,
0.3249458075,
-0.2086111158,
0.2368658483,
0.0780119523,
-0.2331419438,
0.0538224131,
0.0235863738,
0.161222145,
0.1534531265,
-0.2225627452,
0.7479500771,
0.2392916828,
-0.6239196062,
0.4564124942,
-0.1905024797,
-0.3564002812,
-0.1417399943,
0.0502617434,
0.31781286,
0.3521495461,
-0.147075668,
0.0985856131,
0.2545914948,
-0.4007411599,
0.4603748918,
0.3165861964,
-0.5611717105,
-0.0992519855,
0.5558811426,
0.6543173194,
-0.3563141525,
0.6791984439,
-0.3461527526,
-0.4163021445,
0.4386669397,
0.468860805,
0.7930766344,
-0.3936317563,
0.3474852443,
0.5114024282,
-0.2615640759,
-0.0699586421,
-0.3865845799,
-0.4780004919,
-0.6608852744,
-0.0729020461,
-0.3774237633,
-0.5409795046,
0.0300734788,
-0.894254446,
-0.0361793078,
-0.2838737667,
-0.0452067219,
-0.1372813284,
-0.2950397134,
-0.2633067071,
-0.0844528899,
0.1407046616,
0.3167313933,
-0.7677446008,
0.7355311513,
0.0644691661,
-0.1139756441,
-0.1133264676,
-0.0508801825,
0.151628226,
-0.2638371885,
0.2035602182,
0.4675142765,
-0.2915801704,
0.2111642361,
-0.7296934128,
-0.6096556783,
1.0777386427,
0.0227149762,
-0.7730626464,
0.1414667219,
0.1757077873,
0.3420988619,
-0.4704791009,
0.1288123131,
1.1218628883,
0.0515570156,
0.2389146388,
-0.7142425179,
-0.1720281243,
-0.0120498221,
-0.1639859527,
0.32888785,
-0.7095841169,
0.7217794061,
-0.2547823787,
-0.5320099592,
0.1524330527,
0.8083591461,
0.312174648,
0.543296814,
0.8059337735,
0.6924478412,
0.917768836,
-0.1019766033,
0.4012341499,
-0.2561309636,
0.2563767135,
1.323182106,
-0.3318963051,
0.461555481,
0.3159651756,
-0.1606543958,
0.72500664,
0.350084722,
0.2658024728,
0.9091254473,
0.3070144951,
-0.7446097136,
-0.2926901281,
-0.1459234804,
-0.0947394148,
0.2694369555,
0.8036799431,
-0.1901343316,
-0.3170448244,
0.1652156711,
-0.2045926154,
0.3797711432,
-0.1559683532,
1.3950983286,
0.2066951692,
-0.7100561857,
0.6111990213,
-0.2748327553,
0.7616951466,
-0.4039856493,
-0.3280408382,
-0.3270201981,
0.3110337853,
-0.0855980515,
-0.397837162,
0.1563500315,
-0.1084679142,
-0.2116881311,
0.1698911637,
0.2797914743,
-1.0810813904,
-0.1658185273,
0.354139924,
0.1179652736,
0.5181702971,
0.33021155,
-0.7943426371,
0.0593883246,
0.2845273018,
0.6250846386,
0.7557814717,
0.233424589,
0.1799491346,
0.6553767323,
0.4060184956,
-0.3770385981,
0.0117347911,
0.218766138,
1.0015996695,
-0.5431185365,
-0.8767305613,
-0.7081441879,
0.580285728,
-0.323969692,
-0.1336543113,
0.4781515002,
0.4288989604,
0.650028944,
0.0835699588,
0.5968823433,
0.0725892112,
0.9936497808,
-0.4308453202,
0.5110955834,
-0.1598304808,
0.2384544462,
-0.2899640501,
-0.6602923274,
0.1116021872,
0.5686655045,
0.0678702667,
-0.3634655774,
0.9464421272,
1.0237824917,
0.0032449034,
0.2950467467,
0.3824677765,
0.310190767,
0.5265330672,
0.4967122674,
0.8854205012,
-0.0661814734,
0.6953207254,
-0.1842949986,
-0.3127010763,
-0.3048160672,
-0.5742679834,
-1.2520030737,
-0.8301370144,
-0.4641408324,
-0.2748872638,
-0.193995446,
0.7693074346,
0.6875232458,
-0.8681769371,
-0.2658616602,
-0.3745103776,
0.4409917593,
-0.5148839951,
-0.241093412,
0.3298271298,
-0.2391818315,
-0.8963292241,
0.5492261052,
0.0297462698,
0.3015745878,
-0.1636396796,
-0.1618017405,
-0.2357262075,
0.1030144542,
0.3958577216,
0.1051663011,
-0.6044114828,
0.1312227845,
-0.5839996338,
-0.0921917185,
0.1123966426,
0.815371871,
-0.6932930946,
0.6311661601,
0.2754895091,
0.3130144775,
0.7891156077,
0.6219520569,
0.5258080363,
-0.5942183733,
0.3641381562,
-0.0003528782,
0.0929944813,
0.1877997369,
-0.2860649824,
0.1227968782,
0.2278622389,
-0.697239399,
-0.7278913856,
0.4258805811,
-1.2531887293,
-0.534021914,
0.7768557668,
-0.2346455753,
-0.2199856192,
-0.4074700475,
-0.4521189332,
0.2502889335,
-0.573025465,
0.8920651078,
0.6783380508,
-0.2019122094,
-0.2505090237,
0.2756088972,
0.6767840385,
0.302177906,
-0.6847826242,
0.2170412987,
0.6519138217,
0.2393601686,
0.245860517,
0.4674761593,
-0.0705511868,
0.0756969377,
0.0948451534,
-0.2840200961,
0.1832519323,
-0.3099432886,
-0.5008006096,
0.1487105191,
-0.1580026299,
-0.4783123434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08143v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08143v3 | Learning to Initialize: Can Meta Learning Improve Cross-task Generalization in Prompt Tuning? | 2023-02-16T08:37:22 | 2023-11-19T14:31:53 | Chengwei Qin, Qian Li, Ruochen Zhao, Shafiq Joty | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompt tuning (PT) which only tunes the embeddings of an additional sequence
of tokens per task, keeping the pre-trained language model (PLM) frozen, has
shown remarkable performance in few-shot learning. Despite this, PT has been
shown to rely heavily on good initialization of the prompt embeddings. In this
work, we study meta prompt tuning (MPT) to systematically explore how
meta-learning can help improve (if it can) cross-task generalization in PT
through learning to initialize the prompt embeddings from other relevant tasks.
We empirically analyze a representative set of meta learning algorithms in a
wide range of adaptation settings with different source/target task
configurations on a large set of few-shot tasks. With extensive experiments and
analysis, we demonstrate the effectiveness of MPT. We find the improvement to
be significant particularly on classification tasks. For other kinds of tasks
such as question answering, we observe that while MPT can outperform PT in most
cases, it does not always outperform multi-task learning. We further provide an
in-depth analysis from the perspective of task similarity. | [
-0.3593650758,
-0.5580148697,
0.6551426053,
-0.0145383999,
-0.3916585147,
-0.0177774448,
-0.2895603478,
0.1056487635,
-0.215869084,
-0.024797326,
-1.0224056244,
-0.5173389316,
-0.6309933066,
0.455780983,
0.3804763556,
1.2696111202,
0.3507768512,
-0.0050131129,
-0.1510480642,
-0.1220335066,
-1.0732824802,
0.0325938016,
-0.9991551638,
-0.086381413,
0.8836275935,
0.8029923439,
0.318582654,
0.7941300869,
0.2672195733,
0.2866502106,
0.3413580656,
0.3834620416,
-0.4385473132,
0.1235869229,
-0.3160046935,
-0.6488534212,
0.0154329464,
0.2129177302,
0.620318234,
0.411433816,
0.0822117925,
0.3674938381,
0.5984754562,
0.3518164754,
-0.8214461803,
0.3222954571,
-0.5851864815,
0.0056018461,
-0.2433971763,
-0.6056791544,
-0.4404881299,
0.0151930703,
0.2504431307,
-0.876419127,
0.498509407,
0.1195274591,
0.435149014,
0.6089591384,
-0.4894397259,
-0.1664109081,
-0.5327611566,
0.8309929371,
-0.1819454432,
0.2151850462,
0.2820125818,
0.4747092724,
0.1347073019,
-0.5971382856,
-0.2027116567,
0.0561532564,
-0.3034337163,
0.1800524592,
-0.2417436689,
0.1626890004,
0.4884968996,
-0.1389852315,
-0.6705775261,
-0.0747507587,
-0.0747856945,
-0.1793183684,
0.1138424352,
0.3165896535,
0.4451962709,
-0.1443973333,
-0.1188770011,
-0.2125686556,
-0.5189343095,
0.5387781858,
0.1985708177,
0.6249201298,
0.0263164509,
0.2252892107,
-0.1411837935,
0.9395048618,
0.5556274652,
-0.2384908199,
0.1831622422,
-0.4737984836,
-0.1463256478,
-0.1421355605,
0.5937740207,
0.4095030427,
0.3110439479,
-0.1949375123,
0.1788129508,
-0.2368110418,
0.3212213814,
-0.5583013892,
-0.1093561053,
-0.226282388,
-0.5255275369,
0.1480961442,
0.2443142682,
-0.3964826465,
-0.2135807425,
-0.6616255641,
0.6224835515,
-0.582930088,
0.0453549623,
-0.3154759705,
-0.1746804863,
0.4605540931,
-0.0080269231,
-1.1621590853,
-0.0670395195,
0.8589627147,
0.8207649589,
-0.0310580321,
-0.718829751,
-1.1673018932,
-0.0272377171,
-0.2168242335,
0.7899885178,
-0.8487865925,
-0.3339855075,
-0.2011964172,
0.2497061193,
-0.5714464784,
-0.3456009626,
0.4427794814,
-0.1837808043,
0.3930810094,
-0.8851017952,
0.0077959253,
-0.055737704,
0.134928897,
-0.4109495282,
0.7731605768,
0.0496959314,
-0.7557780743,
1.0296272039,
-0.6458502412,
-0.5087370872,
-0.1425667554,
-0.0341613069,
-0.2687057257,
0.468416959,
0.5127438307,
0.5667767525,
-0.072593689,
-0.1219806075,
0.0464728512,
-0.5350009203,
-0.2135765404,
-0.0228101071,
0.4501141012,
0.1212650612,
-0.2971046865,
0.1588837951,
-0.4159503579,
0.0700188279,
-0.1984743625,
-0.2143137008,
-0.4937100112,
-0.1008220017,
-0.5085141659,
0.2727681696,
-0.1604438424,
-0.3420564532,
0.351524353,
-0.443659693,
0.219651252,
0.6292116642,
0.1109077483,
0.5696610212,
-0.4476683438,
0.6581371427,
0.0672855899,
0.0223866906,
-0.7401801348,
-0.5227059126,
-0.5359144807,
-0.2001486868,
0.4900619984,
0.8232445717,
-1.0280644894,
0.2611638904,
-0.0001827554,
-0.0924741402,
-0.6287189722,
0.1277797371,
0.5455040336,
0.6338617802,
0.5158253312,
0.0539334491,
-0.6235281825,
-0.8058772683,
-0.8356971741,
0.3048678935,
-0.19799909,
0.6281767488,
0.1955485046,
-0.1572265327,
1.159393549,
-0.3651035428,
-0.1583418697,
-0.263934046,
0.5744889379,
0.2965260744,
0.3834856451,
0.5225149989,
-0.3065519631,
-1.0360292196,
-0.1815463305,
-0.3198329508,
-0.400120914,
-0.2381661832,
0.1886028647,
-0.1508526355,
0.4324016869,
-0.4314657152,
0.0161615908,
0.361595571,
-0.3598511815,
0.1753343046,
-0.285022974,
0.4082075357,
-1.1258034706,
0.1193948463,
-0.1676233113,
-0.345694989,
-0.599691093,
-0.3086849451,
0.1650855094,
-0.2910679579,
-0.3629092574,
0.3767282367,
-0.4173005819,
0.0220486093,
-0.5892266631,
-0.1772884279,
-0.3021296561,
0.5451655388,
0.1129635572,
1.0544624329,
0.7803424597,
-0.7823627591,
0.0107021164,
0.1290493906,
-0.0958694369,
0.6985863447,
-0.6450614929,
0.2167722434,
-0.4692700505,
0.2228645235,
-1.088789463,
0.1288115382,
0.4121539295,
-0.4341740012,
0.3560261428,
-0.272750169,
-0.385579735,
-0.0603275485,
-0.0687568858,
0.5416924953,
0.4773721099,
-0.4822663367,
0.5001351237,
-0.3787736595,
-0.211121574,
-0.7396326065,
-0.1163097098,
-0.3140605688,
-0.1348676533,
-0.0980708227,
0.3969333768,
-0.0230261944,
0.2127153426,
-0.1838222444,
-0.0820688382,
0.3413175344,
0.0792305693,
0.1889535338,
-0.3528464735,
-0.0949386358,
0.5676010847,
0.3086094856,
-0.6062415838,
-0.1493461579,
-0.5483399034,
0.5043645501,
0.0551897734,
-0.1957677752,
-0.3537293077,
0.226019755,
0.2122488767,
-0.2670201361,
0.610902667,
0.889246881,
0.1109711602,
-0.4527659416,
-0.2852672338,
-0.435708046,
-0.4579137266,
0.1726056188,
-0.5031036139,
-0.882186532,
0.1436058283,
-0.3356580734,
0.1061737463,
0.5266548991,
0.338334769,
-0.3564785719,
0.9611244798,
1.1314736605,
0.1304188669,
0.7752069235,
-0.0276609231,
-0.2202101648,
-0.6493170857,
-0.2222449183,
-0.5083092451,
-0.7261705995,
-0.4619028568,
-0.3805547357,
0.6128614545,
-0.1741054058,
-0.2695530355,
0.3164081573,
-0.2854025364,
0.9204938412,
0.7881783843,
0.4367613196,
0.0085578943,
-0.2427467406,
-0.4483814538,
-0.2244458646,
-1.0112757683,
-0.0142880958,
1.1661479473,
0.0323778875,
0.2804054618,
-0.3238318861,
0.7120052576,
0.2719701231,
-0.0360265225,
-0.500636518,
0.1518502235,
-0.3492927849,
-0.3504739106,
-0.399810046,
-0.4278646708,
-1.1124091148,
0.1314001828,
-0.2519388795,
-0.2133661062,
0.2993226647,
0.4240729809,
-0.7804077268,
-0.0031459529,
-0.6243293285,
1.0733140707,
-0.1823859066,
-0.2789298892,
-0.180433616,
-0.8955790997,
0.2644670606,
0.0266242884,
-0.1879937649,
-0.0032406144,
-0.3811443448,
0.6623519063,
0.0308714174,
1.1771982908,
-0.3796290159,
0.1280745864,
0.1517180204,
-0.1657069772,
0.5637668967,
0.2471054643,
0.2158268988,
-0.3311772346,
-0.1428077072,
-0.5183018446,
-0.825366199,
0.2548877299,
-0.6346681714,
-0.6036863327,
-0.4583077431,
-0.5630568862,
-0.4560142756,
0.146491468,
0.7567477226,
0.2490115166,
-0.21677351,
0.1358196735,
1.0833842754,
-0.3275519907,
0.7059565187,
0.7027708292,
0.2792681158,
-0.4646175802,
0.7672049403,
-0.1373678744,
0.1220174059,
0.7194342017,
0.4162812829,
-0.1893637031,
-0.1666793972,
-0.3722288907,
0.13558276,
-0.4631234109,
-0.3878278136,
-0.6288791299,
0.24386397,
-0.3926878273,
-0.0238438882,
-0.0191740133,
-0.0514437705,
-0.5775498748,
0.0720166788,
0.1667627394,
0.4186430573,
-0.1949502677,
0.7362924814,
-0.7980010509,
0.4078628421,
0.7903997302,
0.2787684202,
-0.3561078906,
-0.6371044517,
-0.3207555413,
-0.1107411757,
-0.3256412148,
-0.6526457071,
-0.0803189054,
0.6798412204,
0.826654017,
0.6225642562,
-0.0145005919,
0.5640885234,
-0.8187326789,
0.6417979598,
0.1605746448,
-1.0103304386,
0.765109241,
-0.3712718487,
0.8545902967,
0.955134511,
0.7839047909,
-0.604283452,
0.1055235937,
-0.4440076351,
-0.0886536464,
0.8839755058,
-0.2665475905,
0.1901290119,
-0.0261292793,
0.4234644473,
0.6492951512,
0.3391858637,
-0.6152855158,
-0.2764849663,
-0.3513995111,
-0.0369281769,
-0.6733140945,
-0.1438614279,
-0.1326938123,
-0.3960922956,
0.2643620968,
-0.5078834295,
0.3097773492,
-0.0161308832,
-0.3620229363,
-0.282092154,
0.3613094389,
0.809165597,
0.621840179,
0.1010158956,
0.1734647453,
0.5374085903,
-0.2018339187,
0.1885828227,
-0.237172842,
-0.0534259267,
-0.0994434729,
0.6732223034,
1.050599575,
0.568698585,
-0.2580819726,
0.5713719726,
0.0870365575,
-0.1982657611,
0.6086170077,
0.3601430655,
-0.3696311712,
0.4190265834,
0.3938801885,
0.1250779778,
0.04514388,
-0.8399026394,
0.3497903645,
0.7118523121,
-0.1105502024,
-0.4509099424,
0.2894440591,
0.3934966326,
-0.371231705,
0.5145115852,
-0.0973923877,
-0.5823206306,
0.3120763302,
0.7052384019,
1.2037591934,
-0.5417401791,
0.4252616763,
0.4829836786,
0.5255389214,
0.1984426081,
0.2768619359,
-0.7070339322,
-0.2925442159,
-0.6011668444,
-0.4474738836,
-0.3298592567,
-0.2734132707,
-0.2158693373,
0.4554979503,
-0.4523994625,
-0.1840554625,
-0.5387296081,
0.1066658944,
-0.8695027828,
0.1511490941,
-0.0078550959,
0.6460781097,
-1.2250014544,
0.6620156765,
0.7609259486,
-0.1062818542,
-0.4916216135,
0.3178614974,
-0.2660925984,
-0.7862465382,
0.5691245794,
0.208955124,
0.0945848078,
0.2700613141,
-0.3025775254,
-0.899400115,
1.2110910416,
0.3563966155,
-0.6844092011,
-0.3009080589,
0.2799709439,
0.4378497601,
-0.5602810383,
0.4692253768,
0.649770081,
0.6568516493,
-0.1252619773,
-1.0665148497,
0.0573078915,
0.0967533812,
-0.2219196707,
0.1477689296,
-0.7476398945,
0.9380041957,
-0.2751137018,
-0.4135069549,
-0.3468690813,
0.3192053139,
0.0307375565,
0.5803893209,
0.7102792263,
0.4813044965,
0.6513953209,
-0.1617819369,
0.7121518254,
-0.1980342269,
-0.0129538262,
1.0363888741,
0.0524112321,
0.2732442021,
0.3949837089,
0.0247636512,
0.5435464978,
0.7448487878,
-0.0784939006,
0.8942401409,
-0.0558907948,
0.0407639518,
-0.485160172,
0.158294186,
-0.4249382913,
0.264418751,
0.0930001959,
-0.6398643255,
-0.5615233183,
0.6734526157,
-0.462646246,
-0.2131464034,
-0.4720953703,
1.2474145889,
0.002316735,
-0.9067807794,
0.3509142697,
-0.0543339252,
0.5457288623,
-0.6961211562,
-0.0182568617,
-0.1486254334,
-0.2507282197,
-0.1918413639,
-0.3131664991,
0.2452149391,
-0.2461159527,
-0.5363768339,
-0.4463217258,
0.6672852039,
-0.3405522108,
-0.2400854379,
-0.0662584603,
0.7665857077,
-0.2439521402,
-0.1903926581,
-0.6826421022,
-0.2993151546,
-0.2749066949,
0.0339963324,
0.4088855982,
0.6249879003,
0.2545831203,
0.4241155088,
0.5362309217,
-0.3157407045,
0.1379070133,
-0.3915065527,
0.6894978881,
-0.6692311168,
-0.7241994739,
-0.9279633164,
0.6349638104,
0.3208872676,
-0.5925331116,
0.8879352808,
0.4397823513,
0.5537293553,
-0.4213157296,
0.6555758715,
-0.0068389764,
0.5970621109,
-0.642249465,
0.2641298771,
-0.3943135738,
-0.0327061377,
-0.2543716133,
-1.2424852848,
-0.1001364663,
0.1109396294,
-0.5547759533,
0.2169308066,
1.0173031092,
0.4614669681,
-0.4642063677,
-0.3272202015,
0.5269576311,
-0.3834123015,
-0.1683807373,
0.6915517449,
0.7388026714,
-0.1247792318,
0.5971844196,
-0.1266397387,
-0.4210561514,
-0.2324774563,
-1.0257078409,
-1.1899037361,
-0.5699968934,
-0.020664826,
0.0414656177,
0.2883152366,
0.9923413992,
0.8248578906,
-0.8347263336,
0.1262633204,
-0.086168848,
0.2663494051,
-0.7336694598,
-0.0898072943,
0.2522339225,
-1.0748269558,
-0.7108769417,
0.5982886553,
-0.0299583375,
-0.1606038809,
0.2453181744,
-0.0527478829,
0.0338575467,
-0.0225718375,
0.5480766892,
0.4168272614,
-0.4616891742,
-0.1903959513,
0.1814563125,
0.083100751,
0.0383313522,
1.4847221375,
-1.1408609152,
0.3554253876,
0.6538885832,
0.7029315233,
0.2605307698,
0.322622031,
0.6636024714,
-1.1979800463,
-0.2181157321,
0.0906975642,
0.0857235789,
-0.2007969469,
-0.3633612096,
0.2164167911,
0.4284569323,
-0.6116242409,
-0.5743892193,
0.2538350821,
-0.6760048866,
-0.2951233685,
0.8089308739,
0.0561602339,
0.1145301983,
-0.0582547933,
-0.3439392447,
0.4016357958,
-0.3168107867,
0.5787556767,
0.6178284883,
-0.236843437,
-0.5780049562,
-0.1063953713,
0.9502668381,
0.6186359525,
-0.6758599877,
-0.038090419,
0.0324078575,
0.5693244934,
-0.0368232802,
0.3154327571,
0.5692132711,
0.7610032558,
-0.286473453,
-0.4263878763,
-0.4146307409,
-0.8248262405,
-0.5978502035,
0.2557848394,
-0.0907675326,
-0.3726659715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08102v1 | Prompt Tuning of Deep Neural Networks for Speaker-adaptive Visual Speech Recognition | 2023-02-16T06:01:31 | 2023-02-16T06:01:31 | Minsu Kim, Hyung-Il Kim, Yong Man Ro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.SD, eess.AS, eess.IV | Visual Speech Recognition (VSR) aims to infer speech into text depending on
lip movements alone. As it focuses on visual information to model the speech,
its performance is inherently sensitive to personal lip appearances and
movements, and this makes the VSR models show degraded performance when they
are applied to unseen speakers. In this paper, to remedy the performance
degradation of the VSR model on unseen speakers, we propose prompt tuning
methods of Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) for speaker-adaptive VSR. Specifically,
motivated by recent advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP), we finetune
prompts on adaptation data of target speakers instead of modifying the
pre-trained model parameters. Different from the previous prompt tuning methods
mainly limited to Transformer variant architecture, we explore different types
of prompts, the addition, the padding, and the concatenation form prompts that
can be applied to the VSR model which is composed of CNN and Transformer in
general. With the proposed prompt tuning, we show that the performance of the
pre-trained VSR model on unseen speakers can be largely improved by using a
small amount of adaptation data (e.g., less than 5 minutes), even if the
pre-trained model is already developed with large speaker variations. Moreover,
by analyzing the performance and parameters of different types of prompts, we
investigate when the prompt tuning is preferred over the finetuning methods.
The effectiveness of the proposed method is evaluated on both word- and
sentence-level VSR databases, LRW-ID and GRID. | [
-0.5381082892,
-0.601488173,
0.2913505733,
0.0367185175,
-0.4448167682,
-0.1666074693,
-0.4422902465,
-0.0194392204,
-0.0576171763,
0.5299063921,
-0.8647455573,
-0.1689075083,
-0.317496568,
0.2443056554,
0.1558838636,
0.6894437671,
0.5700216293,
0.2659214735,
-0.0745924264,
-0.1816391647,
-1.210408926,
0.0061265598,
-0.7418166399,
-0.086641632,
0.6798314452,
0.5736489296,
0.6037475467,
0.7292973399,
0.39688766,
0.426479131,
-0.4266275167,
0.3341088891,
-0.3644214869,
0.3058221638,
-0.1216653511,
-0.2087242305,
-0.2342835218,
-0.3622990847,
0.7361961007,
0.40810287,
-0.1156285256,
0.1056493148,
0.2749545872,
0.6508024931,
-0.4396384954,
0.1548700482,
-0.6939403415,
0.1633970588,
-0.056993138,
-0.6387363672,
-0.4002783895,
-0.272824198,
0.247083351,
-0.5143380761,
0.4656953216,
-0.1250047386,
0.4070750773,
0.6502091885,
0.0211341828,
-0.0188717674,
-0.7210975289,
0.3470062912,
-0.5752730966,
0.4042197466,
0.0493430384,
0.5998307467,
-0.2929011881,
-0.5885613561,
-0.64948982,
-0.4444104135,
-0.074596405,
0.1774857044,
-0.4842378199,
0.2003041655,
0.6710942984,
0.3105736375,
-0.7268849611,
0.5886610746,
-0.1575125009,
-0.2276573628,
0.2364782691,
0.1701285988,
0.2913821042,
-0.2240219116,
-0.2186796218,
-0.4666945934,
-0.262604475,
0.4843326509,
0.2441878766,
0.8796511292,
-0.0561620817,
0.4400879741,
-0.2470601201,
1.0760856867,
0.3838818371,
-0.0240494646,
0.1960067302,
-0.2769049108,
-0.2056782097,
0.3860022426,
0.6265203953,
0.7358340621,
0.6182172298,
0.2581923008,
-0.1486958712,
-0.006817448,
0.0404103957,
-0.828815043,
-0.4524972737,
-0.3314727843,
-0.3603372872,
0.0522716865,
-0.3497065306,
-0.7562334538,
-0.7781464458,
-0.7436998487,
0.4794572294,
-0.4240986109,
-0.2355964184,
0.0079209534,
-0.2380649,
0.0999791473,
0.3893177509,
-0.8385769725,
0.1465641558,
0.3527033329,
0.7078671455,
0.080502294,
-0.1479445994,
-1.3503547907,
-0.4853319526,
-0.2404228747,
0.5758517981,
-0.4776814878,
-0.3432562053,
0.0187133104,
0.0278265178,
-0.2315509915,
-0.477416724,
0.644769907,
-0.3525093496,
0.0240622107,
-0.594348073,
-0.3637691438,
0.1185927615,
-0.1438837051,
-0.5923713446,
0.6250051856,
-0.2530381978,
-0.5055443048,
0.5198867321,
-0.459884733,
-0.1990023255,
0.360801369,
-0.2183290422,
-0.3510070443,
0.3935490549,
0.8196649551,
0.5933735967,
-0.0327930897,
0.1015007943,
-0.1315921247,
-0.4945502579,
0.2516661286,
-0.58747679,
0.4487179518,
0.1842968762,
-0.1188398451,
0.478493154,
-1.1380075216,
-0.0233901292,
-0.2129942626,
0.0490892231,
-0.1927613914,
0.1799292117,
-0.0036176343,
0.1292426586,
-0.1513312161,
-0.3622114658,
0.1453423053,
-0.6465984583,
0.4195637107,
0.8387567401,
0.1319198161,
0.3599711061,
-0.0193916,
0.450201869,
0.1757157296,
0.0920913145,
-0.4602354169,
-0.4346814752,
-0.9269303679,
-0.2595857978,
0.1628393978,
0.5633640885,
-1.1149306297,
0.3895646632,
-0.4915198982,
-0.3174213767,
-0.6780169606,
-0.0545844175,
0.3185642064,
1.1234432459,
0.4379818141,
0.0519953854,
-0.4776200652,
-0.7368996143,
-0.447355479,
-0.0228247289,
-0.1519585997,
0.625156045,
0.0235324223,
0.219961822,
0.9599735141,
-0.2427628934,
-0.3275961578,
-0.0344993994,
-0.086285077,
0.5285133123,
0.3772085905,
0.5529194474,
-0.8905848861,
-0.4521285892,
0.0359161943,
-0.1734781116,
-0.130077228,
-0.2761387229,
0.3694585264,
-0.1445726305,
0.5876400471,
-0.2393196374,
0.4012809992,
0.2652626634,
-0.4820813835,
0.2785078585,
-0.2604936063,
0.0346561782,
-0.7671200037,
-0.2496201694,
0.2384918481,
-0.2541681528,
-0.7611376643,
-0.4614819288,
0.0177292917,
-0.4823202491,
-0.367067039,
0.389480114,
-0.4110212922,
0.1907410622,
-0.4058975279,
0.2539563775,
-0.1056052223,
0.4322962761,
0.0615457371,
1.0236289501,
0.863070488,
-0.8648597598,
0.6007864475,
0.3938762248,
-0.4861002564,
0.6887273788,
-0.8734788299,
0.1121229231,
-0.3893320262,
-0.0668493807,
-1.194321394,
0.2041030377,
0.4965341389,
-0.5605773926,
0.5197221041,
-0.3380736411,
-0.0907642618,
-0.3541661203,
0.0400095098,
0.1339745075,
0.4505952299,
-0.9561546445,
0.5307380557,
-0.297973156,
-0.4572552741,
-0.4244042635,
-0.5052886605,
0.3729592562,
-0.19846645,
-0.6108465195,
0.3188732564,
-0.3089163601,
0.0552239269,
-0.2939456403,
-0.0257255733,
0.2975077629,
-0.0828066543,
0.1772035658,
0.0148127005,
-0.5889415145,
0.238553822,
-0.1825275272,
-0.3407738507,
-0.2319307923,
-0.1842798442,
0.396386534,
-0.1260796934,
-0.1287147403,
-0.7479900718,
0.2312579751,
0.4704656899,
-0.5782396793,
0.3479542732,
0.8551229835,
-0.0219713971,
-0.1306160688,
-0.6653500199,
-0.1922322661,
-0.557441771,
0.4628474414,
-0.5831320882,
-0.9462211728,
0.513078928,
-0.0569277667,
-0.50735569,
0.2142265141,
0.4409877956,
-0.0144242095,
0.8746985197,
0.8320832253,
-0.1698422283,
0.9892071486,
0.1918848455,
0.0022238507,
-0.8497982025,
-0.0976368263,
-0.6972195506,
-0.353844434,
-0.8383504152,
-0.23413831,
0.2971011102,
-0.0463712588,
-0.1744836271,
0.2149257809,
-0.7695483565,
0.3895506859,
0.6361067295,
0.3014885783,
-0.0605556704,
0.1355229318,
0.0517701283,
-0.2778885961,
-0.696346283,
-0.0686447695,
0.3468909562,
0.1289075166,
0.5398679972,
-0.1104073748,
0.1457793266,
0.2352040857,
-0.4623719156,
-0.7268097997,
0.5352855921,
-0.1798281223,
0.1177353337,
-0.5563091636,
-0.5371509194,
-0.6863596439,
0.1229892373,
-0.1526575685,
-0.7832051516,
0.7287748456,
0.3712955713,
-0.6006916165,
0.0277093127,
-0.6629520059,
0.6757954955,
-0.2735367715,
-0.0370072871,
0.1355315745,
-0.7953187823,
-0.2178120017,
0.4041409492,
-0.3013029993,
0.0237529501,
0.1559822261,
0.5166051388,
-0.2156160325,
0.8662074208,
-0.595292449,
-0.0235192422,
0.0377743952,
-0.1334659457,
0.7828307152,
0.1968187988,
-0.2223903835,
-0.2531790137,
-0.410338521,
-0.1268307716,
-0.7692616582,
0.6102183461,
-0.677721262,
-0.6259653568,
-0.2007912397,
-0.304965049,
-0.3187274039,
0.1406819075,
0.5176313519,
0.6742189527,
-0.1092554852,
0.3524733782,
0.9246659875,
-0.4148370028,
0.8536479473,
0.5133563876,
0.1573196352,
-0.6389639974,
0.8853148222,
0.0653123483,
0.0604851358,
0.5707763433,
0.3004946113,
-0.2683834732,
-0.7062410116,
-0.6007554531,
-0.197140038,
-0.5669761896,
-0.2512796521,
-0.3682638109,
-0.0581238605,
-0.4263496995,
0.1176151484,
-0.1901064068,
-0.1483849436,
-0.8941606283,
-0.0853589475,
0.8456191421,
0.0561719723,
0.1340604573,
0.5392811894,
-0.4932577908,
0.6457278132,
0.5080396533,
0.5287773609,
-0.2301004529,
-0.8388488889,
0.0838623717,
0.1183608994,
0.1978218704,
-0.6216077209,
0.2775619924,
0.6471760869,
0.4832254648,
0.2704974413,
0.1683695018,
1.0248128176,
-0.7249518037,
0.7361994982,
0.3315499425,
-0.7631207108,
0.8305290341,
-0.4818224013,
0.4349763691,
0.5657784343,
-0.1138360426,
-0.6165414453,
0.2408459932,
-0.0024753141,
-0.567345202,
0.7832018137,
-0.0170062073,
0.3164500296,
0.3413915336,
0.365200609,
0.0408666804,
-0.0045430437,
-0.432061106,
-0.4128837287,
-0.6606933475,
0.0556625128,
-0.6144317389,
-0.3668512106,
0.0865899622,
-0.4699476361,
0.2783872783,
-0.4816739559,
-0.0038315798,
0.3601194322,
-0.1568438113,
-0.1661828756,
0.313272506,
0.9116469622,
0.5239757299,
-0.0744997337,
-0.167106986,
0.2930302024,
-0.4012729526,
0.0888411328,
0.2808127701,
-0.1114207506,
0.1725988835,
0.2205567807,
1.7465941906,
0.031920284,
-0.3164609373,
0.5922372341,
-0.5708692074,
0.0572124235,
-0.2507726848,
0.2961271703,
-0.2171322852,
0.4280582666,
0.3378697336,
0.497153163,
0.0210253131,
-0.0917593315,
0.1458303481,
0.2029488832,
-0.8221259117,
-0.0488067158,
0.4840527177,
0.183148846,
-0.8072840571,
0.7760341763,
0.1195272729,
-0.2825801373,
0.4091485143,
0.4733092785,
1.0050817728,
-0.4489662051,
0.2168756723,
0.1993007511,
0.3157774806,
0.3857323527,
0.3807372451,
-0.361192435,
-0.5232141614,
-0.4349038899,
-0.4959038496,
-0.0794835463,
0.2740523219,
-0.8337666988,
0.4142813087,
-0.1663338691,
-0.1099006906,
0.073683694,
-0.1076813191,
-0.8381786942,
0.3670557737,
0.349814415,
0.9562543631,
-0.7328526378,
0.5298862457,
0.4688975811,
-0.0554753691,
-0.6932886243,
-0.1114985868,
-0.2153186947,
-0.6627377272,
0.4317280054,
0.0623245686,
-0.109898448,
0.2384788692,
-0.2943406105,
-0.6939055324,
0.8083313107,
0.572332263,
-1.1556550264,
0.2880010009,
0.1461621821,
0.6229224205,
-0.1453750432,
0.1881583333,
0.3375584781,
0.507047236,
0.0840449259,
-0.874745667,
0.0430508256,
-0.5107984543,
0.4027194083,
-0.1763030291,
-0.4839678705,
0.760640204,
-0.1757855862,
-0.020399129,
0.2406721115,
0.8574777246,
0.0411533862,
0.1601749063,
0.7026574612,
0.2011947632,
0.9325531721,
-0.1869526207,
0.8283126354,
0.040318612,
-0.2274242938,
1.1631753445,
-0.0598444045,
0.4691830575,
0.4978905022,
0.1642633826,
0.0769797564,
0.5965092778,
-0.3942665756,
0.6235476732,
0.3487878144,
0.0606329702,
-0.4127578139,
-0.2893121541,
-0.7442256212,
0.5840082169,
0.1899198592,
-0.3137282431,
-0.0391482823,
0.5817468166,
-0.595654726,
0.1911883801,
-0.5840756297,
1.0553585291,
0.0904496834,
-0.6224701405,
0.795794785,
-0.5093539953,
0.4573945999,
-0.3479755223,
-0.0434155241,
-0.1750106215,
0.2645458281,
0.0160766989,
-0.4154543877,
-0.3351417184,
-0.0217504166,
-0.513667047,
-0.3215146363,
0.7940088511,
-0.1910575777,
-0.6108148694,
0.1941586286,
0.3410834968,
-0.3128246367,
-0.1635071784,
-0.564203918,
0.0377345644,
-0.0181017388,
-0.4043966532,
0.2292171419,
0.7242716551,
0.2265730649,
0.6061165333,
0.6788557768,
0.1808257848,
0.1310320944,
0.6342898011,
1.0232050419,
-0.6489093304,
-0.6337989569,
-0.9252585769,
0.649061501,
-0.0303680021,
-0.6224904656,
0.8196498752,
0.1728594452,
0.5272911787,
-0.2203491181,
0.3235536218,
0.3859984279,
0.5154746175,
-0.7051990628,
0.764452219,
-0.3856956363,
0.2621107697,
-0.6045042872,
-0.7768236399,
-0.278449595,
0.2680145204,
-0.0181722138,
0.0795312971,
0.1140382811,
0.9246252775,
-0.0288638175,
0.0467527173,
0.5129856467,
0.1538535208,
0.2646710575,
0.1633660793,
0.9993369579,
-0.310724318,
0.5380977988,
-0.2274346352,
-0.118021369,
-0.4330377877,
-0.9581040144,
-0.8883076906,
-0.602986455,
-0.4414168894,
-0.0386934727,
0.1618355662,
0.6147102118,
0.6438897252,
-0.7836523652,
0.1690113395,
-0.1392694563,
0.0575801395,
-0.4222890139,
-0.1587697417,
0.419088155,
-0.283046037,
-0.3307493329,
0.8278030157,
0.1264430881,
0.0877587125,
0.2684445977,
-0.0920718536,
0.2333752215,
-0.2681574821,
0.4121079743,
0.2407114208,
-0.696092844,
-0.41918239,
0.1949522048,
0.2713820338,
0.2216853797,
0.7011135221,
-1.0934598446,
0.8494535685,
0.5117495656,
0.440428853,
0.4463733435,
0.0772432685,
0.5613884926,
-0.9386579394,
0.1559779048,
0.3937582672,
0.2934596539,
0.4479806721,
-0.4430560172,
-0.1546139568,
-0.0196797866,
-0.4414660931,
-0.9242601991,
0.1975217015,
-1.2080705166,
-0.0636911839,
0.8028355241,
0.256734997,
0.058089979,
0.1633646041,
-0.5433542132,
0.4769260883,
-0.4991519749,
0.4189910293,
0.2119909823,
0.0546612181,
-0.528881669,
-0.2853914201,
0.7644128799,
0.3405469656,
-0.1287915707,
0.2310542017,
0.3834462464,
0.0041784733,
0.0502124913,
0.2391407639,
0.4968488812,
0.4848559797,
-0.131628558,
-0.2171195298,
-0.4982259572,
-0.4825670719,
-0.9733384848,
0.0515565015,
-0.0845142379,
-0.4342215359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08095v1 | PAAPLoss: A Phonetic-Aligned Acoustic Parameter Loss for Speech Enhancement | 2023-02-16T05:17:06 | 2023-02-16T05:17:06 | Muqiao Yang, Joseph Konan, David Bick, Yunyang Zeng, Shuo Han, Anurag Kumar, Shinji Watanabe, Bhiksha Raj | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Despite rapid advancement in recent years, current speech enhancement models
often produce speech that differs in perceptual quality from real clean speech.
We propose a learning objective that formalizes differences in perceptual
quality, by using domain knowledge of acoustic-phonetics. We identify temporal
acoustic parameters -- such as spectral tilt, spectral flux, shimmer, etc. --
that are non-differentiable, and we develop a neural network estimator that can
accurately predict their time-series values across an utterance. We also model
phoneme-specific weights for each feature, as the acoustic parameters are known
to show different behavior in different phonemes. We can add this criterion as
an auxiliary loss to any model that produces speech, to optimize speech outputs
to match the values of clean speech in these features. Experimentally we show
that it improves speech enhancement workflows in both time-domain and
time-frequency domain, as measured by standard evaluation metrics. We also
provide an analysis of phoneme-dependent improvement on acoustic parameters,
demonstrating the additional interpretability that our method provides. This
analysis can suggest which features are currently the bottleneck for
improvement. | [
-0.1748159081,
-0.6109963655,
0.0482140034,
0.3907766342,
-0.2865490913,
-0.0311119277,
-0.3091481626,
-0.2990800738,
0.598335743,
0.4189223945,
-0.4317013025,
-0.2454239279,
-0.524133563,
-0.143494755,
-0.1438161135,
0.613776505,
0.151142776,
0.3569144905,
0.1830611676,
0.0026898431,
-0.2902445495,
-0.2615408003,
-0.6439351439,
-0.2688431442,
0.6802437901,
0.1869382709,
0.5571144223,
0.7768799067,
0.3221416771,
0.2109957635,
-0.3688474,
0.2560787201,
-0.2742485702,
0.1755253226,
-0.1334795207,
-0.4265479743,
-0.5945416093,
0.2505585849,
0.8975055814,
1.4115842581,
-0.4607711136,
0.0605037324,
0.4781532884,
0.3144337535,
-0.7258535624,
-0.0176403895,
-0.5344414115,
0.3273526728,
-0.4931361973,
-0.6857267022,
-0.131202668,
-0.3345063627,
0.3518103063,
-0.8305311203,
-0.1138511375,
-0.2082601339,
1.1765167713,
0.5766560435,
-0.1438373327,
-0.0854941756,
-0.7461602688,
0.8244196177,
-0.8746230006,
0.755184114,
0.4763967693,
0.1286807358,
-0.0958290547,
-0.7548790574,
-0.4012436569,
-0.17829521,
0.2781291902,
0.166226238,
-0.0818893686,
0.2609279752,
-0.2646321356,
0.4136490822,
-0.4044782519,
0.2954541147,
-0.433105588,
-0.7702064514,
0.3499881327,
0.0344143547,
0.3110647798,
0.0442199521,
-0.1840717196,
-0.0764714405,
-0.6951967478,
0.2215254754,
0.8745704293,
0.6025688648,
-0.1230259016,
0.1769122332,
0.0987884924,
0.4167793095,
0.2082265466,
-0.7394264936,
0.3883548975,
-0.079242982,
-0.2719788849,
0.2510168254,
0.2589323223,
-0.0614248887,
-0.1434145123,
-0.2869082391,
-0.0218986757,
-0.1273915023,
0.0946586877,
-0.5899555087,
-0.4070865214,
-0.1686245799,
-0.6419615149,
-0.4445028901,
-0.0781110972,
-0.4285241365,
-0.2540195882,
-0.7877299786,
0.4571507573,
-0.5648825169,
-0.4439374804,
-0.1702614725,
-0.3476446271,
0.1466968358,
0.2826958001,
-0.9290165305,
0.5748671889,
0.4915403128,
0.7031342983,
-0.0780788884,
-0.34013924,
-0.6926574707,
-0.1498867571,
-0.7250562906,
0.7737113833,
-0.8445863724,
-0.4226306081,
-0.2444947809,
-0.0820937008,
-0.2930531502,
-0.8333302736,
0.8327533603,
-0.2770068645,
0.3470184505,
-0.1408107877,
-0.6979563236,
-0.2545253932,
-0.3188266754,
-0.2342423797,
0.6686685681,
0.0283515267,
-0.3109757006,
0.6135208011,
-0.5938206911,
-0.4359555542,
0.1707987785,
0.0780998021,
-0.3329400122,
0.2542298138,
0.095913589,
-0.0043442883,
-0.0970741287,
-0.0700394064,
-0.2629667819,
-0.3660487533,
0.1084698439,
-0.7652776241,
1.0260038376,
0.2375181019,
-0.1452195048,
-0.0083743092,
-1.0098304749,
0.0749214292,
-0.2359104753,
-0.6143558621,
-0.2729454339,
0.0726292059,
-0.0773292631,
-0.3113313913,
0.1711910367,
-0.5441776514,
-0.1951341033,
-0.7769851089,
0.3382831514,
0.77531147,
0.2302561849,
0.6016748548,
-0.310965687,
0.528200984,
-0.2159931958,
0.2743739486,
-0.1215709969,
-0.4590842426,
-0.4631810486,
-0.4652450681,
0.6804602742,
0.5718770027,
-0.1960078925,
0.4326683581,
0.1413385123,
-0.4597572386,
-0.5408203006,
0.0740249678,
0.4544694722,
1.1579533815,
0.1352755576,
-0.4857499897,
-0.5470398068,
-0.9138153195,
-0.2516607642,
-0.2276924103,
-0.2267463058,
0.3034206629,
-0.0650942177,
0.299927175,
0.3413572311,
-0.1347026974,
-0.3544716239,
0.3826800585,
0.1473132372,
0.1492841542,
0.4132685363,
0.4137571752,
-0.6929807067,
-0.1397779882,
-0.1849349141,
-0.2363936007,
-0.5287914276,
0.2838436365,
0.2386622578,
0.0000258146,
0.3535991609,
-0.033926066,
0.3590931892,
0.699201405,
-0.1429198235,
0.8003108501,
-0.0889904797,
0.3029224873,
-0.6177159548,
0.0379986651,
0.0666750595,
0.2026606947,
-0.6998841166,
-0.2937137783,
-0.107491903,
-0.4433077574,
-0.6013572216,
0.5502954125,
-0.2414536327,
-0.2509635389,
-0.240790531,
0.2659590542,
0.407047689,
0.6073034406,
-0.1471808255,
0.9667351246,
0.8299418092,
-0.7875091434,
0.2529334724,
0.1722046435,
-0.1874343604,
0.8087679744,
-0.5722731948,
0.2420707941,
0.1350475997,
0.1431783736,
-0.8857699037,
-0.3730969727,
0.3776597977,
-0.7271870971,
0.4641471505,
-0.4304076135,
-0.1749234498,
0.0181764867,
-0.0732854158,
0.266587615,
0.4514448345,
-0.701643765,
0.4831027389,
0.6208642125,
-0.497423321,
-0.6303780675,
-0.5177895427,
0.3261083066,
-0.4480970204,
-0.7837154269,
0.7455024719,
0.2615680397,
-0.2783181071,
-0.0270298142,
-0.2871679366,
-0.3565696776,
0.0816058367,
0.0394002907,
0.1097456291,
-0.4918335378,
0.4282003641,
0.4505641162,
0.0060301977,
-0.0821373239,
-0.6866499782,
0.4490259886,
0.0301024504,
-0.1617196798,
-1.1891177893,
0.2128024846,
0.2226275951,
-0.5949155092,
0.3029836118,
0.6676667333,
-0.4575031996,
-0.128438279,
-0.5116428733,
-0.1400917619,
-0.4906679988,
0.2109334022,
-0.3578804731,
-0.4342908263,
0.7240064144,
-0.1793509722,
-0.0870873481,
0.3666805029,
0.2010529488,
-0.5318102837,
0.7966780663,
0.4541960359,
0.3480937481,
0.687985003,
-0.073083058,
0.0611356273,
-0.9285513759,
-0.3261071146,
-0.6105315685,
-0.3557190597,
-0.4275606871,
-0.1429241151,
0.3172333837,
0.0481806435,
-0.1821274012,
0.1864351779,
-0.5325272679,
0.0902622193,
0.6747562885,
0.1493968666,
-0.181874916,
0.1365745962,
-0.1454009712,
-0.2780176103,
-0.5075613856,
-0.5650451183,
0.864487648,
0.52550143,
0.4471991062,
-0.0133624217,
0.7062826753,
0.3718024194,
-0.3842489123,
-0.6780475378,
0.3614832163,
-0.4371565878,
-0.2587451637,
-0.4845889807,
-0.4221773446,
-1.0157395601,
0.2241894454,
-0.0432573147,
-0.8141872287,
0.8026916981,
0.4696145952,
-0.5228682756,
0.3180149496,
-0.7195840478,
0.559471786,
-0.1819115728,
-0.2202338725,
-0.3183211386,
-0.5019217134,
-0.1519186199,
0.2239751369,
-0.2296351045,
-0.3483632207,
-0.5364781618,
0.9575163722,
-0.5974072814,
0.703315556,
-0.7077230811,
-0.2220151126,
0.2897439599,
0.0151044065,
0.2858355343,
-0.3045485318,
-0.2682934403,
0.2806871533,
-0.0121969804,
-0.474691689,
-0.7253645658,
0.6626093388,
-0.6296600103,
-0.5427935123,
0.2800472081,
-0.4935365319,
-0.4985946417,
0.0509325787,
0.2211218625,
0.917122364,
-0.0657455549,
0.0576814041,
0.7593027949,
-0.504344523,
0.4618164003,
0.2409739047,
0.154070586,
-0.5980887413,
1.0612103939,
0.5264480114,
0.2203005999,
0.2957815528,
0.5270162821,
-0.4576051235,
-1.0419466496,
-0.0988316908,
0.1790248603,
-0.6114859581,
0.0254564025,
-0.0940973684,
-0.0693961456,
-0.6661497951,
0.1978604496,
-0.3225931823,
-0.675591886,
-0.5134063959,
0.0659681782,
-0.005551043,
0.2912578881,
-0.3556819558,
0.4819461703,
-0.4116795063,
0.1301966459,
0.2783630788,
0.4788148999,
-0.313120991,
-1.2127047777,
0.0175090265,
0.1702047139,
-0.2696758807,
-0.8693985343,
0.5750196576,
0.5995941758,
0.6832278371,
0.6854331493,
-0.12212082,
0.8124215007,
-0.3093168736,
0.8516330719,
0.1338057965,
-1.0475487709,
0.7738622427,
-0.3846918344,
0.0693676099,
0.3048971593,
-0.1261836439,
-0.3925277889,
-0.3337609172,
-0.7369103432,
-0.7696731687,
0.5011391044,
0.3030705452,
0.1624174416,
0.1581142247,
0.4680306911,
0.1748980731,
0.1449651122,
-0.1509002,
-0.3404245377,
-0.5190781951,
0.2343946248,
0.2968783677,
-0.0841096789,
-0.2007674575,
-0.3065801859,
0.9022377133,
0.1778810471,
0.2491413206,
0.350938499,
0.1032720134,
-0.097798042,
0.2006838322,
0.9729905128,
0.7973612547,
-0.1752768308,
-0.0272258297,
0.3467432559,
-0.4461328983,
-0.0324397758,
0.2987606823,
0.2538204193,
0.2187114656,
0.3799030185,
0.8920540214,
-0.015456601,
-0.3235052228,
0.5184963346,
0.1150576472,
-0.3874402642,
-0.41474244,
0.1041217372,
-0.2333110273,
0.1414262205,
0.6256207228,
0.5699276924,
0.3586413264,
-0.4164378941,
0.2485152334,
0.0915212408,
-0.577519834,
-0.3696630299,
0.788376689,
0.5198431611,
-0.7122645974,
0.3290520906,
-0.1664834768,
-0.091743581,
0.5978232622,
0.316690743,
0.8132442832,
-0.8179399967,
0.0122493487,
0.1344211102,
-0.0608104914,
0.493756175,
0.0996883661,
-0.1379058957,
-0.5513051152,
-0.5534323454,
-0.602646172,
-0.3467747867,
0.2183911502,
-0.6536041498,
0.1593755484,
-0.6092455983,
-0.3085691929,
0.4600737095,
-0.0455680564,
-0.4039957523,
0.3227773309,
0.2374624014,
0.6665822864,
-0.5384836197,
0.701158464,
0.5341050625,
-0.336255163,
-0.995598793,
0.1051808149,
0.26146999,
-0.9162002206,
0.8011865616,
-0.3217338622,
-0.4174847305,
-0.3133012056,
-0.2536246777,
-0.8716723323,
0.8157434464,
0.9909243584,
-0.7043484449,
-0.1662082225,
0.0076152673,
0.6585890055,
-0.3536156118,
-0.142021805,
0.5016131997,
0.4837721884,
-0.1906007528,
-1.4464349747,
-0.4185734391,
-0.2828187644,
-0.0024180408,
0.2328074425,
-0.3614156246,
0.4993142784,
-0.0662629902,
-0.3461634815,
0.1329939067,
0.5610074997,
-0.0651226267,
0.2856421769,
0.6669617891,
0.4706849754,
1.1273277998,
-0.1640666127,
0.9322016239,
-0.3501393795,
-0.1712906808,
1.1767843962,
0.0615439191,
0.6811125278,
0.4677031934,
-0.1883823872,
0.2084978074,
0.7639142871,
0.1288328469,
0.5803515315,
0.2504273951,
-0.3520439863,
-0.078180328,
-0.3683785796,
-0.4005201757,
0.8792746067,
0.4709887505,
-0.4983827472,
0.1754000038,
0.3246418238,
0.0028105855,
0.3193964362,
-0.3386591673,
0.608843267,
-0.025095785,
-0.5564933419,
0.7756340504,
-0.3821286857,
0.4182816744,
-0.456957072,
-0.1074737459,
-0.2326028645,
0.045873642,
-0.3793159425,
-0.3943873048,
0.5388894677,
-0.5394927859,
-0.0666010752,
-0.1224237531,
0.4198530018,
-0.4424387813,
-0.3309884071,
0.2803930044,
0.0497245044,
0.310561806,
0.0572309829,
-0.7162517905,
0.0599160343,
-0.0632882416,
0.0779237449,
-0.0183611289,
0.1698152721,
0.4388521314,
0.4808535874,
0.4833016992,
0.681586206,
0.1587180793,
0.6552892327,
0.4965527654,
-0.0607980788,
-0.5461008549,
-0.3024739325,
0.2220743895,
-0.1069447994,
-0.5681555271,
0.4608836174,
0.4588900506,
0.6769127846,
0.2499372512,
0.4344306886,
0.4311478138,
1.0055975914,
-0.5500667095,
0.5907457471,
-0.4964392483,
0.6298245788,
-0.3642786741,
-0.9588666558,
-0.2922614217,
0.4532516897,
-0.3159399927,
-0.1083456203,
0.3300935924,
1.0877013206,
0.0264762212,
-0.0906480923,
0.5204803348,
0.0026963954,
0.1699644178,
-0.029031761,
0.7371652722,
-0.4774130583,
0.8055113554,
-0.4421970248,
-0.2821891308,
0.0962733775,
-0.5673137903,
-0.3023465872,
-0.863501966,
-0.6306146383,
-0.0710882694,
0.5962354541,
0.643170476,
1.098397851,
-0.6007791758,
-0.2131850123,
0.0255567152,
-0.0220630914,
-0.5392083526,
-0.2552884817,
0.579115212,
-0.5762374401,
-0.7282230258,
0.811645627,
0.4684033394,
0.0405100025,
-0.013528713,
-0.1527550071,
0.2279112786,
0.4082899094,
0.3692164421,
0.5446643233,
-1.0706089735,
-0.2635084391,
-0.0267255604,
0.4675046802,
0.3814844489,
0.6259732842,
-0.4319661856,
0.4561578929,
0.3532457352,
0.4616117477,
0.1920984089,
-0.2224096805,
0.706330657,
-0.8409537673,
0.2851227224,
0.6454651356,
0.6533562541,
0.2912463248,
-0.1739755124,
0.1848175973,
0.2113635391,
-0.4496499598,
-0.7860114574,
0.0491843522,
-0.9657629132,
-0.2166740596,
0.7448246479,
-0.2236764729,
-0.1280105412,
-0.1980273277,
-0.2857843339,
0.2994440794,
-0.6541326046,
0.6591115594,
0.3305741251,
-0.4021788538,
-0.3786338866,
-0.0439171381,
0.6431181431,
0.5249326229,
-0.551081121,
-0.1117664874,
0.3899790645,
0.2657328248,
0.3677992821,
0.1814995259,
-0.4686015546,
0.5791609287,
0.4041450024,
0.0237512253,
-0.0512868464,
-0.3456275463,
-0.3021420538,
0.4640979171,
0.1382891685,
-0.601421237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08092v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08092v2 | Product Question Answering in E-Commerce: A Survey | 2023-02-16T05:09:41 | 2023-05-03T07:29:41 | Yang Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Qian Yu, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Product question answering (PQA), aiming to automatically provide instant
responses to customer's questions in E-Commerce platforms, has drawn increasing
attention in recent years. Compared with typical QA problems, PQA exhibits
unique challenges such as the subjectivity and reliability of user-generated
contents in E-commerce platforms. Therefore, various problem settings and novel
methods have been proposed to capture these special characteristics. In this
paper, we aim to systematically review existing research efforts on PQA.
Specifically, we categorize PQA studies into four problem settings in terms of
the form of provided answers. We analyze the pros and cons, as well as present
existing datasets and evaluation protocols for each setting. We further
summarize the most significant challenges that characterize PQA from general QA
applications and discuss their corresponding solutions. Finally, we conclude
this paper by providing the prospect on several future directions. | [
-0.4831250012,
-1.0563645363,
0.5206051469,
0.4881058931,
0.0283392593,
0.3608253002,
0.1415877938,
-0.6970067024,
0.0355493873,
0.225672543,
-0.7082676888,
-0.0187591761,
-0.1438887417,
0.4222927094,
-0.3708304465,
0.8096430898,
-0.4042975903,
-0.3448747694,
-0.3732198775,
-0.1182058305,
-0.6613819599,
-0.9345500469,
-0.4855104983,
0.4497446716,
0.3667430282,
0.4248223603,
0.677183032,
-0.1137488708,
0.7992133498,
0.2931810021,
0.079750061,
0.2478557825,
-0.1128791124,
0.3779222965,
-0.0183774829,
-0.4423124194,
-0.2176126987,
-0.0992606953,
0.3024326861,
0.7929208875,
-0.2044914514,
0.7271350622,
-0.0190184731,
0.4898126125,
-0.9609184861,
-0.2388658375,
-0.2207002044,
0.1310179234,
0.2342078537,
0.1806589514,
-0.2502206862,
-0.4247251451,
0.3315670788,
-0.9833756089,
0.167831108,
0.2818981409,
1.0494356155,
0.1291401833,
-0.6566684246,
-0.7081301808,
-1.1900904179,
0.5319533944,
-0.4544084668,
0.2483151108,
0.1874842346,
0.4262565374,
-0.1747382581,
-0.9033892751,
-0.5689374208,
0.1144054085,
0.0447096154,
0.3153305948,
-0.3434208035,
-0.3479264081,
0.1435934752,
0.7091890574,
-0.4827640653,
-0.2223251909,
-0.3521934748,
-0.0530022457,
0.6523044109,
0.3420762718,
0.4050676525,
-0.0020592145,
-0.2237482369,
0.2857314348,
-0.3255257308,
0.640455842,
0.2679875195,
-0.3806957603,
0.3791384101,
0.5796861053,
-0.7627589107,
0.6357542276,
0.535197258,
0.1608478427,
0.2671707273,
-0.4708255827,
-0.135146603,
-0.3968726993,
0.2960045934,
0.4240805507,
-0.1913971305,
0.1302035898,
-0.2850438058,
-0.7359147072,
0.2723468244,
-0.3696213067,
-0.2036892474,
0.870236218,
-0.6599103808,
0.0999521315,
0.1930268109,
-0.4821172357,
-0.0800342485,
-0.1677827239,
0.8357561231,
0.3509632945,
-0.2826470435,
0.2745545208,
-0.0336305574,
0.5895863175,
0.2869393826,
-0.2309950739,
0.3433237672,
0.6569808722,
0.4434300661,
-0.0022169028,
0.1389624476,
-0.5365254879,
-0.1535045654,
-0.2233898491,
0.8542092443,
-0.0173511636,
-0.191676572,
0.1313108057,
0.4337033927,
0.1295863837,
-0.640265882,
0.5610893965,
-0.7556115389,
0.3464339375,
-0.9079349041,
-0.4371349514,
-0.2026429027,
0.5912882686,
-0.6316685677,
0.5304850936,
-0.1715087891,
-0.8219906688,
0.1723024249,
-0.4009444714,
-0.276095897,
0.1984327883,
0.1599258631,
-0.5188909769,
0.2751176059,
0.3670468032,
0.1771487296,
-0.405983001,
-0.0316082239,
-0.2087358534,
-0.4303731322,
0.6627637148,
-0.1281181872,
0.8593149185,
0.3697223365,
-0.5388485193,
-0.4740878344,
-0.4265847206,
0.2751259208,
0.2043168247,
-0.1230633631,
0.210551843,
-0.0780519918,
-0.0031295782,
0.4480249584,
0.4828263521,
-0.7665389776,
-0.066874519,
-0.1579817683,
0.592431426,
0.4235044718,
0.6038188338,
0.0237554405,
-0.4787790477,
0.9086031318,
-0.1882762015,
0.85754776,
-0.0503518917,
-1.0061520338,
-0.7743359804,
0.0992073268,
0.4642119706,
0.7691441178,
-0.625549674,
0.0033737489,
0.4029172063,
-0.324098587,
-0.3522031605,
-0.1324556619,
0.3520967066,
0.3959315419,
0.30007267,
-0.6535848975,
-0.0847743526,
-1.2352815866,
-0.3332788646,
-0.3588848114,
-0.3024533093,
0.4358789623,
0.2698563337,
0.3575389683,
0.8773520589,
-0.7997267246,
-0.0942602903,
0.0723696724,
0.2471165657,
0.2184438854,
0.1652540118,
0.2297763079,
-0.9739610553,
-0.6422861218,
-0.309081167,
-0.4329443574,
-0.2565550804,
-0.1173886582,
-0.0057067554,
0.0320161246,
0.040108081,
-0.5341256261,
0.4463902414,
0.0990526155,
-0.0351122618,
0.8054208755,
-0.0310694724,
0.5833216906,
-0.7896866798,
0.1198517531,
0.0425845571,
0.2621991336,
-0.7012143135,
0.0837527961,
-0.0106012784,
-0.3092207015,
-0.8348379135,
0.1603327692,
-0.4191081524,
-0.3639158905,
-0.02824842,
0.0239126515,
0.4625291824,
0.267726928,
-0.1086808294,
0.7249005437,
0.1127992198,
-0.7037391067,
0.5352927446,
0.7141543627,
-0.1880525202,
0.7424424887,
-1.0553915501,
0.3295370638,
-0.2835453749,
0.366440922,
-1.1308820248,
-0.1275702268,
0.6757164598,
-0.5617313385,
-0.1357740015,
0.2223285735,
-0.5068223476,
-0.6384519339,
-0.1182072535,
0.606269002,
0.6340531707,
-0.216929391,
0.4594952762,
0.131060347,
-0.3731935024,
-0.6193227768,
-0.4617703855,
0.1124032438,
-0.3297226429,
-0.6334592104,
0.2363044918,
-0.4146542251,
-0.4677680135,
-0.1584639102,
-0.2227204591,
-0.3930313587,
0.2608188093,
-0.0396558195,
-0.1827252507,
-0.2204911113,
0.1345910877,
-0.275450021,
-0.0960457996,
0.2846761346,
-0.1261360347,
-0.1229365095,
-0.1424016654,
-0.4442109764,
-0.8191598058,
0.9098803401,
-0.0388289094,
-0.5510960817,
0.2408921868,
0.2732144594,
-0.3511596024,
-0.0356095433,
-0.5835788846,
0.004950677,
-0.4812259078,
0.1453918517,
-0.6198223233,
-0.6889645457,
0.5578991771,
0.1449546218,
0.211055547,
0.2573257387,
0.6845107079,
-0.5492747426,
1.0738016367,
0.4560694098,
0.6822426319,
-0.1502622366,
0.2082778215,
0.8796958923,
-0.6083481908,
-0.6032286286,
-0.9006097317,
-0.3914714456,
-0.4782747626,
0.0040754913,
0.4248200655,
0.3803260922,
-0.4960861504,
0.2260490954,
-0.7124921679,
0.2538563311,
0.6735439301,
0.2645088732,
0.4020208418,
-0.1782819927,
0.4484158158,
0.0746921897,
-0.5788815618,
-0.1870040298,
0.9443378448,
0.3755427301,
0.384331584,
0.2399563491,
0.2884512842,
0.0900022462,
0.100492388,
-0.817979157,
0.3242006004,
0.0854647309,
-0.9054450989,
-0.0643137991,
-0.1387432367,
-0.7060662508,
-0.1986671686,
0.0573714785,
-0.6687905192,
0.6865195036,
0.2878449261,
-0.8314948678,
-0.1072142795,
-0.7124392986,
0.8073228002,
-0.6547394395,
-0.4884422123,
0.4500969946,
-0.7918840647,
0.1757929921,
-0.0681845918,
0.1661508828,
0.0006925405,
-0.1834461689,
0.6975255609,
-0.2281748056,
0.2451060116,
-0.1774898469,
-0.3573640883,
0.6580340266,
-0.0191715416,
0.1842780411,
0.2186202258,
0.4177744985,
-0.3728372455,
0.5518500209,
-0.7562891245,
-0.7471177578,
0.1748120189,
-0.4235433042,
-0.8983669281,
-0.6032112241,
-0.1720286459,
-0.9316000938,
-0.2421705574,
0.2201657295,
0.2846356928,
-0.0404639989,
0.3105996251,
0.8839136362,
-0.6603186727,
0.4214603901,
0.538941741,
-0.1580327898,
-0.3687640131,
0.8695619106,
0.1853705794,
0.3152732849,
0.2959245443,
-0.1832851321,
-0.4959169924,
-0.5545159578,
-0.5793754458,
-0.0504997633,
-0.6547216773,
-0.2006730437,
-0.6331986189,
-0.1361074746,
0.0857806951,
0.1201837957,
-0.1471525282,
-0.618180871,
-0.1365206242,
0.1359265745,
-0.0418976173,
0.5606591702,
0.2532339394,
0.062276274,
-0.8329837918,
0.58994627,
0.929828763,
0.1621945649,
-0.0935913473,
-0.1566167325,
-0.1230725199,
0.0766132325,
-0.4629445076,
-1.0276063681,
-0.1546515971,
0.1968819201,
0.4238655269,
0.2320292592,
0.4748222828,
0.4151616693,
0.0282457247,
1.3562200069,
-0.0025987106,
-0.9135277271,
0.3156671822,
-0.2381232381,
0.0410946272,
0.5211820006,
0.8762947321,
-0.6184110045,
0.0357452556,
-0.5386070609,
-0.9910372496,
0.1501514912,
0.5314555764,
0.1421530843,
0.0526606031,
0.4137915075,
0.1678965837,
0.5231137872,
-0.304463774,
-0.2897692621,
-0.1331794709,
0.1103628874,
0.2355234325,
-0.1513775289,
0.189272061,
-0.0329439342,
0.6011379361,
0.1451554745,
0.3013719618,
0.353548795,
-0.2207220942,
0.0234196931,
0.3571447134,
-0.0172765255,
0.9943879843,
-0.1165443584,
-0.4145530164,
-0.1274568588,
-0.1857088208,
0.5072637796,
-0.1459095627,
-0.4149601758,
-0.1734031737,
-0.1544597596,
-0.0608590208,
-0.203060016,
-0.8498678207,
0.5833907127,
-0.3785373867,
-0.475923419,
-0.2854712307,
-0.4577227533,
-0.0015585353,
0.1836403161,
0.7200682759,
-0.4923542142,
0.7454853654,
-0.7720944285,
0.2805324793,
0.2048793286,
-0.1663253754,
-0.0941031724,
0.5778787732,
0.3071580529,
-0.4377934039,
0.7816082239,
-0.1427587569,
-0.6040127277,
0.9014874697,
0.4414555132,
0.8492203355,
-0.1430823058,
0.7352892756,
0.1957880259,
0.3251317143,
0.1515514255,
0.6585242748,
-0.128816396,
-0.4507218897,
-0.3746808171,
-0.5547803044,
-0.9268340468,
0.1587956697,
-0.7661699057,
-0.0920148641,
-0.3590270281,
-0.2024663687,
-0.0205543023,
0.2561233938,
-0.65208143,
0.5545784831,
-0.0860977694,
0.4621556103,
-0.6437118649,
-0.1755513102,
0.7586744428,
-0.6797004342,
-0.6876112223,
0.2539042532,
-0.1769425273,
-0.1175102517,
0.4544363022,
0.0339403749,
0.0522480831,
-0.1635491699,
-0.4333754182,
-0.7307601571,
0.9600522518,
-0.0480104536,
-0.4188156426,
-0.0725194961,
0.6045842171,
0.2004850507,
-0.1161237583,
0.2191421688,
0.4961914122,
0.5290303826,
-0.1079421788,
-0.9051073194,
-0.0756512284,
-0.6289108396,
0.0007040657,
-0.1588017941,
-0.7707428932,
0.7526407838,
0.5383291245,
-0.3173537254,
0.4202423096,
0.2811543643,
0.0865115449,
0.6607252955,
0.3620705307,
0.5457036495,
0.4668227434,
-0.0898521021,
0.5188843608,
-0.0391505361,
0.4132849276,
0.9872386456,
-0.4179329574,
0.7925602794,
0.2542464733,
-0.4778314829,
0.2530945539,
1.0176910162,
0.1280426085,
0.1536082625,
0.5217439532,
-0.3259203136,
-0.4726194739,
-0.1071333066,
-0.5702826381,
0.3048046529,
0.2101415843,
0.016855875,
-0.0254024602,
0.1549122334,
-0.5001525283,
-0.0800212249,
-0.3293689489,
0.7478966117,
-0.0600807108,
-0.3250023723,
0.4616376758,
0.1367999017,
0.2211548686,
-0.2083501965,
-0.124860853,
-0.3746480942,
-0.2502632141,
-0.3129390478,
-0.6411791444,
0.3708188236,
-0.0450526513,
-0.0074995775,
-0.1341659576,
0.6306607723,
0.2854442894,
-0.2725163698,
-0.2303470969,
0.9519788027,
-0.0403309464,
-0.3225580156,
-0.9169566035,
-0.0930236205,
-0.2667731643,
-0.3513332009,
0.0315596499,
0.4881652892,
0.0764082298,
0.5954370499,
0.3755316734,
-0.5709836483,
0.3548507988,
-0.5358613729,
0.4532815516,
-0.4994831681,
-0.5227323174,
0.0940927044,
0.7942947149,
-0.0657940432,
-0.4612100124,
0.9983170033,
0.5392995477,
0.6806532741,
-0.1371707767,
0.6092759371,
-0.1210743263,
0.476624161,
-0.0221353434,
0.4734364748,
-0.5278888941,
0.0087448573,
-0.1254315227,
-1.1058540344,
-0.2991930544,
0.2423987687,
-0.2308763713,
-0.194282338,
0.8443240523,
0.5301148891,
-0.0421040766,
0.2283094674,
-0.0875156224,
0.0559008494,
-0.082128644,
0.7625685334,
1.3517900705,
-0.6821856499,
0.605956614,
-0.463740617,
-0.1481393129,
-0.1165216416,
-0.5362715721,
-0.1556677371,
-0.7737656832,
-0.6668248773,
-0.3446870446,
0.3505910933,
0.7562592626,
0.507728219,
-0.9922045469,
-0.0279686265,
0.1715340614,
-0.0955352411,
-0.5493314862,
-0.1437586546,
0.3572103679,
-0.1664246917,
-0.5473462343,
-0.1478495449,
0.1591206342,
-0.1919285506,
0.0366633162,
0.4539668858,
-0.0722608492,
0.2970732152,
0.4790019989,
0.6132177711,
-0.4744794071,
-0.1784665585,
0.5219754577,
0.536585629,
0.2625179291,
0.9638109803,
-0.471214056,
0.1750585735,
0.5318937898,
0.9627599716,
0.4227287769,
0.4019647837,
0.5162719488,
-0.2338733524,
-0.4554578662,
0.5022885203,
-0.0189803969,
0.0414270051,
-0.2939255536,
-0.104079321,
-0.0167647023,
-0.6646391749,
-0.6390874386,
0.6484163404,
-0.8222292662,
-0.4064185023,
0.7500549555,
-0.3537391722,
-0.2819454372,
-0.7319420576,
-0.2436506152,
-0.0832551718,
0.1376573741,
0.8015449643,
0.7316073179,
-0.2623028159,
-0.1279202998,
-0.46638605,
0.2670685649,
0.5947518945,
-0.9477958679,
-0.2683414817,
0.6999902725,
0.3330052197,
-0.0127082588,
0.6068457961,
-0.1172781885,
0.6661186218,
-0.277671963,
-0.4556924403,
0.1324690729,
-0.4800739288,
-0.3024300337,
0.8568413854,
0.409017086,
-0.3012172282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08091v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08091v1 | Do We Still Need Clinical Language Models? | 2023-02-16T05:08:34 | 2023-02-16T05:08:34 | Eric Lehman, Evan Hernandez, Diwakar Mahajan, Jonas Wulff, Micah J. Smith, Zachary Ziegler, Daniel Nadler, Peter Szolovits, Alistair Johnson, Emily Alsentzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although recent advances in scaling large language models (LLMs) have
resulted in improvements on many NLP tasks, it remains unclear whether these
models trained primarily with general web text are the right tool in highly
specialized, safety critical domains such as clinical text. Recent results have
suggested that LLMs encode a surprising amount of medical knowledge. This
raises an important question regarding the utility of smaller domain-specific
language models. With the success of general-domain LLMs, is there still a need
for specialized clinical models? To investigate this question, we conduct an
extensive empirical analysis of 12 language models, ranging from 220M to 175B
parameters, measuring their performance on 3 different clinical tasks that test
their ability to parse and reason over electronic health records. As part of
our experiments, we train T5-Base and T5-Large models from scratch on clinical
notes from MIMIC III and IV to directly investigate the efficiency of clinical
tokens. We show that relatively small specialized clinical models substantially
outperform all in-context learning approaches, even when finetuned on limited
annotated data. Further, we find that pretraining on clinical tokens allows for
smaller, more parameter-efficient models that either match or outperform much
larger language models trained on general text. We release the code and the
models used under the PhysioNet Credentialed Health Data license and data use
agreement. | [
0.0994673744,
-0.4574023187,
0.9007299542,
-0.0676311105,
-0.3576771319,
-0.3950933814,
-0.2337412834,
-0.6473193169,
-0.0037820032,
0.6708601713,
-0.2278084159,
-0.6300222874,
-0.7074313164,
0.2054304928,
-0.3584972024,
0.8927004337,
0.1467609107,
0.6142806411,
-0.2365439981,
-0.1510256976,
-0.224606052,
-0.9917581677,
-0.559229672,
-0.4950668216,
0.6397916079,
0.110927321,
0.5472025275,
0.8882908225,
0.9074903727,
0.1659268141,
-0.0775658488,
-0.0773838237,
-0.288235724,
-0.1659096777,
-0.2314940095,
-0.5721490979,
-0.9656152725,
0.0529856347,
0.3354954123,
1.2877197266,
-0.3133449554,
-0.0031091312,
-0.2867894769,
0.4380784631,
-0.3115598261,
-0.0352745578,
-0.5847266912,
-0.0330264457,
-0.0483347811,
-0.1714349836,
-0.6758565903,
-0.1265126318,
0.551795423,
-0.5385281444,
0.298040837,
0.03226218,
0.7405176759,
-0.0228661094,
-0.6489495635,
-0.5596165061,
-0.5453414321,
0.7665835619,
-1.0157548189,
0.5608387589,
0.6224976778,
0.1077801138,
0.0438657254,
-1.2321382761,
-0.199423328,
-0.593557775,
-0.1321887672,
-0.0990332514,
-0.1512387097,
0.5034832954,
0.2370995283,
0.1637762338,
-0.4498417974,
0.5909372568,
-0.5040082335,
-0.140716061,
0.4782601893,
0.4556089342,
0.6026531458,
-0.0510864705,
-0.2019237578,
-0.0149183013,
-0.879191339,
-0.1928790361,
-0.3154711723,
0.2780459821,
-0.3443627059,
0.537714839,
0.1970737427,
0.6707160473,
-0.2916895151,
-0.6015393734,
0.1025106534,
-0.1722752601,
-0.4814779162,
-0.161526382,
0.7402072549,
0.3044148386,
0.4337739348,
-0.4371008575,
-0.0883045048,
0.2257276624,
0.543728888,
-0.814190805,
-0.3190912604,
0.3789319694,
-0.6916263103,
-0.1214751005,
-0.3733149171,
-0.2692198753,
-0.4029866457,
-0.4836607575,
0.1495572627,
-0.5207759738,
-0.1331260502,
0.4709728658,
-0.0750430822,
-0.1007736549,
0.4990751743,
-0.9901264906,
0.4975320995,
0.788494885,
0.7040840983,
-0.3264617026,
-0.0659564883,
-0.2944276333,
-0.0048795957,
-0.5444113016,
0.5932832956,
-0.610828042,
-0.4419410527,
0.2568891346,
0.2632478774,
-0.3631536365,
-0.6876374483,
0.451772362,
-0.4331372082,
-0.0408473872,
-0.1971802413,
-0.8340281844,
0.1845430285,
0.0936843902,
-0.5740278363,
0.2313242853,
0.0961898863,
-0.5603672266,
0.4548508227,
-0.3652649224,
-0.528732717,
0.1608093232,
-0.2104871273,
-0.4359085858,
0.3953860998,
0.0347840898,
0.5574724078,
-0.5633087158,
0.3659176826,
-0.4213446379,
-0.2396152765,
0.2213682979,
-0.1361175925,
0.5567664504,
0.1625160873,
-0.062864013,
-0.1484797597,
-0.7131944895,
-0.020160215,
0.0421942957,
-0.5387722254,
-0.4099961519,
-0.0380379669,
0.1950505674,
0.1042088941,
0.1357065141,
-0.4815496206,
0.0128578423,
-0.4247190356,
0.5676996112,
0.4107494354,
-0.1056995839,
0.3779196143,
-0.473490566,
0.782202065,
-0.0152734863,
0.0795227811,
-0.1642684639,
-0.558277607,
-0.5816744566,
-0.5539208651,
0.329877317,
0.3101676106,
-0.1855338067,
0.0866994038,
-0.3530358672,
-0.4086332321,
-0.469366312,
-0.1798142493,
0.3955209255,
0.5680804849,
0.4832969606,
-0.1806606799,
-0.4348345101,
-1.0108870268,
-0.2496881634,
-0.0619588494,
-0.1802255064,
0.3615064621,
0.4509551227,
-0.5142773986,
0.7730923891,
-0.1071394905,
-0.2576104999,
-0.6366693974,
-0.1650951654,
0.0055499454,
0.2664022148,
0.6912407279,
-0.5812080503,
-0.4220127761,
0.1618179679,
-0.842602849,
-0.2979343235,
0.0141461855,
0.4240855277,
-0.0547965989,
0.470623076,
-0.5741065145,
0.3104298711,
0.6963601708,
-0.0465196073,
0.3665771186,
-0.5259030461,
-0.1375225037,
-0.7779812813,
0.3608657718,
0.103992492,
-0.5210208893,
-1.0826570988,
0.0870350078,
0.3113524616,
-0.1333613396,
-0.4046578705,
0.6499949098,
-0.3363254964,
0.2816087306,
-0.4303621352,
0.1569501609,
-0.0023872477,
0.2305379361,
0.481399864,
0.3561535478,
0.4140641689,
-0.5932323933,
-0.0386616774,
0.163155362,
-0.1528171599,
0.2721576393,
-0.9115475416,
0.1588994414,
-0.0911663473,
0.147675842,
-0.565431416,
-0.4265652597,
-0.2114152014,
-0.0722381026,
0.2764235139,
-0.1804211438,
-0.3831619322,
-0.3189182878,
0.2060580105,
0.2034770995,
0.6486937404,
-0.1824675947,
0.3176718056,
0.7030988932,
-0.2226729244,
-0.2464684844,
-0.7710701823,
0.0018461881,
-0.1629896462,
-0.4308141172,
0.2744445205,
0.2054632306,
-0.2852482796,
-0.1597798169,
0.0319118053,
-0.2967175841,
0.1166100577,
0.257214427,
0.1739588827,
-0.4339953065,
0.5300884843,
-0.0073284255,
-0.1674962789,
0.0840582624,
-0.2380106896,
0.5059880018,
0.0055215065,
-0.421274066,
-0.7153462172,
0.3926211894,
0.5937225819,
-0.0973448008,
0.9058533907,
0.0498871394,
-0.61817801,
-0.0812134147,
-0.5680833459,
-0.2819359004,
-0.364373982,
0.6565138698,
-0.0142962039,
-1.0738378763,
0.3485535383,
-0.0465651415,
0.0361669436,
0.3819782734,
0.7556992769,
0.0448954925,
1.0833070278,
0.774733305,
0.0396886468,
0.01197604,
0.0430428535,
0.2108056843,
-0.4480343759,
-0.1636845767,
-0.4975859821,
0.1494495124,
-0.486897707,
-0.2666528225,
0.5986241698,
-0.1344916821,
-0.1563435644,
0.0360294171,
-0.2435244918,
0.1272292435,
0.1122955531,
0.3361518979,
0.4766212404,
-0.0448446721,
-0.0725587979,
-0.1823878884,
-0.7084907889,
-0.7105489373,
1.3415777683,
0.7708977461,
0.6719628572,
-0.1505467147,
0.4529079199,
0.1162148044,
0.6625209451,
-0.6284769177,
0.3747272789,
-0.3871121109,
-0.5487499237,
-0.1532160342,
-0.3020880222,
-1.0621392727,
0.3170531392,
-0.0524474829,
-0.4828921258,
0.0314566828,
0.268692106,
-0.5548157096,
0.1151808798,
-0.7552774549,
0.9146324992,
-0.1051500216,
0.1285773516,
-0.2372868955,
-0.5680001378,
0.1832680106,
-0.3268020451,
0.2840040922,
-0.0457846485,
-0.2108637094,
0.8132097125,
-0.844363153,
0.9902074933,
0.01415125,
-0.0439984575,
0.1028225943,
-0.0851056725,
0.383218497,
-0.0652389675,
0.0331273153,
0.0887973011,
0.345562011,
-0.3444703519,
-0.3314873576,
0.4483580887,
-0.766946137,
-0.6116687059,
-0.3151512146,
-0.2434296757,
-0.4619258642,
0.2215307504,
0.2576794326,
0.6934672594,
-0.1201860085,
0.4169496596,
0.544531703,
-0.1933367252,
0.0102333743,
0.6526508331,
0.0727095306,
-0.1840179414,
0.4163297415,
-0.0450982377,
0.5318006873,
0.3047198951,
0.3677867353,
-0.1013359055,
-0.9642726183,
0.0722130015,
0.6915165782,
-0.7953600883,
-0.0308289602,
-1.0064821243,
-0.1660912484,
-0.4026889801,
-0.1359487921,
-0.2938910127,
-0.2593471706,
-0.3828187585,
-0.1296792179,
0.2726948559,
0.8742989302,
0.0265428927,
0.4474188983,
-0.9950785041,
0.2804831266,
0.1966118664,
0.106408,
0.0047130655,
-0.578107059,
-0.3982431591,
0.0381600894,
0.0796572566,
-0.8456118107,
0.4844447076,
0.1714621782,
0.5106734037,
0.2232684493,
-0.2446527928,
0.5415078998,
-0.8181557059,
0.7061884403,
0.2301404476,
-0.7056658268,
0.2818341851,
-0.497409761,
0.0765378326,
0.4435994327,
0.6632755399,
-0.7263224125,
-0.3765360117,
-0.6009699702,
-0.4325510263,
0.6033884287,
-0.1221559197,
0.1853909492,
-0.3438164294,
0.5816782713,
0.0144904833,
0.2112618089,
-0.6354715824,
0.1153212786,
0.1921660304,
-0.4464837313,
0.0136875054,
-0.3715288937,
-0.1555053443,
0.0203359295,
0.1332518011,
-0.1847311258,
0.1669540554,
0.4198510349,
-0.127519846,
-0.0980673134,
0.1722675264,
0.3710874319,
0.9366661906,
-0.0295908097,
0.0226008426,
0.1700092405,
-0.8150700331,
0.0282972977,
-0.1912095398,
0.2500656843,
-0.0973287225,
0.7871798873,
0.5709739327,
0.253116399,
-1.0195565224,
0.731539607,
-0.072456032,
-0.2035090327,
-0.160515219,
0.0608459227,
0.2686641812,
-0.0327656865,
-0.007127068,
-0.0930783004,
-0.0698947608,
-0.5044711828,
0.2677589357,
0.3286231756,
-0.4096773267,
-0.5093258619,
0.7597057223,
0.0847612023,
-0.2579131424,
0.6372753382,
0.3623981774,
-0.1745005548,
0.5664786696,
0.6489111781,
0.5209275484,
-0.1026577875,
0.1646606177,
0.0842960402,
0.2097764015,
-0.3770496845,
0.0161967464,
0.3808078468,
-0.5473370552,
-0.3609508276,
-0.5176300406,
-0.5166179538,
0.4235830903,
-0.5254557729,
0.296323061,
-0.767195344,
-0.4064582884,
0.0699027553,
-0.2973674238,
-0.9158378243,
0.5246084332,
0.1383935809,
0.9002301097,
-0.719586432,
0.9967047572,
0.5246177316,
-0.2561363876,
-0.7691099644,
-0.3428910971,
-0.1101164892,
-0.8282667398,
0.7882936001,
-0.0669476464,
0.2407604903,
-0.2327961922,
-0.4561628997,
-0.6132788658,
0.8126926422,
0.3520532548,
-0.7066811323,
-0.575068891,
0.4785467684,
1.0182157755,
-0.703140378,
0.0925554782,
0.5394036174,
-0.0584504455,
-0.1935631484,
-1.2472190857,
0.0361358374,
-0.1529189348,
-0.0506483279,
-0.1144792214,
-0.3045830429,
0.9207308292,
-0.26832515,
0.0056913644,
0.2372258902,
0.1455882341,
0.3171825111,
0.1415871978,
0.2110218853,
0.3703652322,
0.8312007189,
0.1428444237,
1.402332902,
-0.236312449,
0.3246375322,
0.849078238,
-0.4781992733,
0.8571007848,
0.1817744672,
-0.2267149091,
0.3754034936,
0.4505826235,
0.3036369979,
0.3738828897,
0.0538730249,
-0.0408726186,
-0.6859052777,
-0.0483676717,
-0.3939936459,
0.1801939309,
0.5123311877,
-0.7432616353,
-0.0021505845,
0.1206871867,
0.2374717444,
-0.0243507195,
-0.1228984967,
0.6040387154,
0.5986379385,
-0.4931010902,
0.5784080029,
0.1092919484,
0.1331824511,
-0.8447328806,
0.2318162769,
-0.0622754022,
0.4009184837,
-0.0307908021,
-0.1172133908,
0.0796391815,
0.0256586354,
0.09116669,
-0.101751402,
0.661059618,
-0.2498700321,
-0.4274993241,
0.2206605673,
0.5240738988,
0.1014588326,
0.0623554587,
-0.4540115893,
-0.1472684294,
-0.2601267099,
-0.2010730654,
0.6003449559,
0.5464214087,
-0.0911440104,
0.6448838115,
0.7054210305,
0.5394609571,
0.0706958175,
0.4359042346,
0.8007512689,
-0.5743862391,
-0.6200716496,
-0.8325127363,
0.3576594293,
-0.030811172,
-0.2806481123,
0.5765311122,
0.3046869636,
0.413562268,
-0.1621994078,
0.8665938973,
0.5163136721,
0.7910503149,
-0.5883141756,
0.6696926951,
-0.7738022208,
0.2355060279,
-0.1561435461,
-0.328651607,
-0.6225300431,
0.4426681399,
-0.4860948026,
0.1348157078,
0.9290502667,
0.4482448101,
-0.0483410284,
0.1924231648,
0.5218868256,
0.095504187,
0.557480216,
0.657702744,
0.4720786214,
-0.2943046391,
0.129940033,
0.0230280831,
-0.3242215812,
-0.3103321493,
-0.6682249904,
-1.2330619097,
-0.2895028591,
-0.3165265918,
-0.2177904695,
0.1463707983,
1.077811718,
0.7737010717,
-0.6731499434,
-0.1016202569,
-0.1292234957,
-0.4308980703,
0.0441768356,
-0.0193001665,
0.5279246569,
-0.5051624775,
-0.4449397027,
0.2698432803,
0.3746079206,
0.2784402966,
-0.095922716,
0.047386039,
0.1796488017,
0.1266366988,
0.5596697927,
0.1180598736,
-0.6772105098,
-0.0881691873,
0.2698421776,
-0.5205067396,
-0.0029505417,
1.1250497103,
-0.5571845174,
0.206379503,
0.3346185684,
0.5959093571,
0.2630666792,
-0.172157079,
0.6569173932,
-0.2733844221,
0.247518599,
0.5258011222,
0.6614894867,
0.2683934569,
-0.0125680855,
0.3441306949,
0.3248603642,
-0.6531769037,
-0.9326137304,
0.0136984419,
-0.7027434111,
-0.2306606919,
1.3216617107,
-0.2870981395,
-0.2471133769,
-0.2820376158,
-0.0595912412,
-0.1012059897,
0.0785914138,
0.5909941196,
0.4904819131,
-0.0267839916,
-0.0800068676,
-0.7071049213,
0.7935373187,
0.4048713446,
-0.804164052,
0.0766966343,
0.291857481,
0.3315924704,
0.0585437156,
1.1443507671,
-0.3591937721,
0.3835461438,
-0.144662559,
-0.1817668527,
0.21260342,
-0.3415595889,
-0.2838656306,
0.2481270581,
0.2183395475,
0.2952229977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08088v1 | TAPLoss: A Temporal Acoustic Parameter Loss for Speech Enhancement | 2023-02-16T04:57:11 | 2023-02-16T04:57:11 | Yunyang Zeng, Joseph Konan, Shuo Han, David Bick, Muqiao Yang, Anurag Kumar, Shinji Watanabe, Bhiksha Raj | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech enhancement models have greatly progressed in recent years, but still
show limits in perceptual quality of their speech outputs. We propose an
objective for perceptual quality based on temporal acoustic parameters. These
are fundamental speech features that play an essential role in various
applications, including speaker recognition and paralinguistic analysis. We
provide a differentiable estimator for four categories of low-level acoustic
descriptors involving: frequency-related parameters, energy or
amplitude-related parameters, spectral balance parameters, and temporal
features. Unlike prior work that looks at aggregated acoustic parameters or a
few categories of acoustic parameters, our temporal acoustic parameter (TAP)
loss enables auxiliary optimization and improvement of many fine-grain speech
characteristics in enhancement workflows. We show that adding TAPLoss as an
auxiliary objective in speech enhancement produces speech with improved
perceptual quality and intelligibility. We use data from the Deep Noise
Suppression 2020 Challenge to demonstrate that both time-domain models and
time-frequency domain models can benefit from our method. | [
-0.5289220214,
-0.7595319748,
0.2644638717,
0.6141223311,
-0.3969767094,
0.1284901351,
-0.1153079644,
-0.4468878806,
0.3834445179,
0.3747160137,
-0.419187963,
-0.2425781637,
-0.4350714684,
-0.155126065,
-0.4218661189,
0.4367566109,
0.0573885776,
0.0338156931,
0.2021747679,
0.1350117773,
-0.6231586337,
-0.1599741727,
-0.5062437057,
-0.521892488,
0.3075374067,
0.3005972505,
0.3861589432,
0.5829899907,
0.2135491371,
0.1438240558,
-0.5588092208,
0.0784953162,
-0.4055689871,
0.0556418672,
-0.0448139906,
-0.2285923809,
-0.3521605432,
0.2642532885,
0.7158076167,
1.2955600023,
-0.089219749,
0.1664642245,
0.4142185748,
0.1601276845,
-0.6101563573,
0.0045028692,
-0.5652994514,
0.3299259841,
-0.3426264226,
-0.699033916,
-0.149199754,
-0.4737930894,
0.1977772266,
-0.3586174548,
0.0917273611,
-0.2330471426,
1.1196695566,
0.5687767267,
0.0229021218,
0.2778077424,
-0.9009389281,
0.5760116577,
-0.7159026265,
0.7723984718,
0.5630602241,
0.1497950703,
0.1334453672,
-0.4683022201,
-0.2388710529,
-0.362503469,
0.06401252,
0.0272166561,
-0.084031485,
0.1463327259,
-0.0446904488,
0.3858224452,
-0.2738460302,
0.3633593917,
-0.3759461343,
-0.6360505223,
0.2684634924,
0.2949827015,
-0.0643218607,
-0.0286348499,
-0.1355426461,
0.2101706564,
-0.7544700503,
0.3394179344,
0.5099363327,
0.4188580513,
-0.2574281394,
0.0932563469,
-0.0596448518,
0.4557727277,
0.2967542112,
-0.4581140876,
0.09686625,
-0.3063926697,
-0.0320419446,
0.1740473211,
0.0509923287,
0.1488393843,
-0.2393763363,
-0.2343855947,
0.1924136132,
-0.1961838156,
-0.2205604166,
-0.6869630218,
-0.2733203471,
-0.1416363716,
-0.4648073316,
-0.3230929077,
-0.2027961463,
-0.3642323315,
-0.25745368,
-0.5660257339,
0.3284012377,
-0.3536496758,
-0.2700872123,
-0.114113979,
-0.4317566454,
0.1916766316,
0.2422065586,
-0.8901823163,
0.511610806,
0.3700739443,
0.7870449424,
-0.1024815962,
-0.3132016361,
-0.7857526541,
0.2371983528,
-0.7457790375,
0.606712997,
-1.035885334,
-0.8727883101,
-0.5692088008,
0.0445436649,
0.0150588602,
-0.7628504634,
0.7455452681,
-0.3044625819,
-0.0681978017,
-0.2346851081,
-0.3859491646,
-0.1096710116,
-0.3655173481,
-0.2081338614,
0.7363684773,
0.024075469,
-0.1434752792,
0.7394814491,
-0.5932978988,
-0.5021675229,
0.2001482397,
0.0621711724,
-0.2103481144,
0.5519273877,
0.1961348057,
0.1905052364,
-0.1633263826,
0.1065933928,
-0.4867465794,
-0.4235120416,
0.0877246112,
-0.8373583555,
0.5417381525,
0.1110835001,
-0.1506348699,
-0.1806503236,
-0.7283152938,
-0.0834558234,
-0.2760023475,
-0.6119131446,
-0.3094910681,
0.1279722005,
0.0543605685,
-0.3381012976,
0.0693548843,
-0.6955808997,
-0.2001253814,
-0.5341268778,
0.5870341063,
0.5365978479,
0.5243348479,
0.3209072948,
-0.0137133459,
0.2930198312,
-0.2244462818,
0.3722399771,
-0.2538651526,
-0.3460357785,
-0.414583683,
-0.4421040714,
0.5101317167,
0.4595479965,
0.0962616056,
0.3161858022,
0.0159859899,
-0.4615984261,
-0.4723598659,
-0.1296091974,
0.4243931174,
1.0917021036,
0.376312077,
-0.2067964822,
-0.5744714737,
-1.0960819721,
-0.2293264419,
-0.0805884525,
-0.3441828787,
0.4433365464,
-0.1253728569,
0.0801407471,
0.8112195134,
-0.4758813083,
-0.2761093974,
0.2257105857,
0.3330838084,
0.3822976649,
0.3795544207,
0.5351516008,
-0.7854871154,
-0.2655070424,
-0.1167253107,
-0.1344496012,
-0.6448758841,
0.2008366734,
0.3759584129,
-0.0530418158,
0.4734797478,
-0.1034833714,
0.534091413,
0.4279793799,
-0.2766565979,
0.7456761599,
0.1959686577,
0.3959127069,
-0.412240833,
0.0643928051,
-0.0732018948,
-0.0927516371,
-0.6396530271,
-0.4913077652,
-0.1030350775,
-0.6248665452,
-0.4425413907,
0.7056881785,
-0.2227128297,
-0.200573042,
-0.2867829204,
0.2051858604,
0.5022819638,
0.3568475246,
-0.1185253859,
0.9457216263,
0.5069132447,
-0.7863345146,
0.1940235794,
0.2535019219,
-0.0352156423,
0.6268435717,
-0.8030327559,
0.0892224982,
0.1268956214,
0.0226519667,
-0.8808621168,
-0.3564071059,
-0.0240346938,
-0.683744967,
0.6534548998,
-0.309772402,
0.1848290861,
-0.278852731,
-0.3909654021,
0.2405054569,
0.3794365525,
-0.6173853278,
0.3834824562,
0.5011542439,
-0.4998040497,
-0.271923691,
-0.8060039878,
0.3795277774,
-0.2041668594,
-0.4718405902,
0.8125151396,
0.1524509341,
-0.2328727245,
0.1753514856,
-0.4198572338,
-0.1590111256,
0.0843344554,
0.1031341925,
0.0932663456,
-0.1766540259,
0.2676323056,
0.468323648,
-0.2657806575,
-0.1663814038,
-0.1227554008,
0.6423107386,
-0.0784448385,
-0.2777961493,
-0.8370144963,
0.4753597677,
0.1724878997,
-0.3441855013,
0.2091574371,
0.7897320986,
-0.30030936,
0.1920586973,
-0.7617517114,
-0.1784702688,
-0.473405093,
0.4460106492,
-0.4988786876,
-0.8060894608,
0.6900578737,
-0.0319206901,
-0.2043079287,
0.4877871871,
0.2424298972,
-0.3687510788,
0.683231473,
0.3723654151,
-0.135353297,
0.6642657518,
-0.1131318808,
0.0199151598,
-1.0350244045,
-0.3862986565,
-0.680405736,
-0.2565545142,
-0.3253762126,
-0.1402190179,
0.4388276637,
0.2610224187,
-0.2327321619,
0.1839000434,
-0.4866241515,
0.2861596942,
0.741373539,
0.2301335633,
0.0675354153,
-0.1594101191,
0.1089656949,
-0.4028565586,
-0.2486362159,
-0.4486471713,
0.4549225867,
0.5374076962,
0.7348304391,
-0.3161964417,
0.6692309976,
0.6755529046,
-0.2705540061,
-0.5619577765,
0.35715729,
-0.2417358011,
-0.6410030723,
-0.6660593748,
-0.2286575884,
-0.5910681486,
0.041439224,
-0.0350553803,
-1.0259498358,
0.925904274,
0.5157850981,
-0.4712632298,
0.1273069829,
-0.7620604634,
0.5637277365,
-0.1062707081,
-0.327301532,
-0.3453848362,
-0.4518445432,
0.0307750795,
0.1089110002,
-0.2316624075,
-0.6609733701,
-0.4080176353,
0.6955933571,
-0.308930099,
0.7684181333,
-0.7281811833,
0.1803705692,
0.222726807,
0.0542482324,
0.4040685594,
0.0509744398,
-0.0910367519,
0.4611403048,
-0.0756454468,
-0.1773789972,
-0.4238985181,
0.6697998047,
-0.4550511539,
-0.6471867561,
0.4773740172,
-0.4054766297,
-0.5368414521,
0.0583313517,
0.3393574059,
0.9812460542,
-0.0692334101,
0.3987829685,
0.5341637731,
-0.3512920737,
0.8826938272,
0.3460696638,
0.2369121462,
-0.5314575434,
0.9250494838,
0.3294297755,
0.1780264676,
0.5137937665,
0.4638265073,
-0.435685128,
-1.0979384184,
0.0419601798,
0.0685014948,
-0.446962744,
-0.0983971208,
-0.2500016689,
-0.1167605296,
-0.4310545921,
-0.0908533186,
-0.35499385,
-0.6145982742,
-0.6999158859,
-0.2272784412,
0.1420953721,
0.171797201,
-0.3976358771,
0.3670555651,
-0.7268639207,
0.5159038901,
0.5414294004,
0.6377100348,
-0.2957592309,
-0.8801450729,
-0.0518986247,
-0.0389708951,
-0.2484733015,
-0.9035492539,
0.378235966,
0.6763409376,
0.7765966654,
0.6758738756,
0.0587573573,
0.8841071129,
-0.407286793,
0.8632984161,
0.1489147395,
-1.4046361446,
0.8560181856,
-0.3690182269,
0.3005135357,
0.4542980194,
0.0025695201,
-0.4495473206,
-0.3803684711,
-0.3085693717,
-0.8175047636,
0.6090282798,
0.1882867813,
0.1297693402,
0.2751465142,
0.2615357041,
0.2906769216,
0.1831165999,
-0.3172962964,
-0.1041361615,
-0.4343032837,
0.4966339469,
0.1345680803,
-0.5713695288,
-0.2023723125,
-0.4143150747,
0.6523448229,
0.1962848455,
0.2743209004,
0.2868479192,
0.1149273589,
-0.0562717803,
0.4589616358,
0.9017289281,
0.6840392351,
-0.4003024697,
-0.0374516845,
0.5771632195,
-0.4594332278,
0.1391802877,
0.4200413525,
-0.0169020314,
0.3043861985,
0.5300093889,
0.9883466959,
0.2235105336,
-0.1726410687,
0.1870534718,
0.3848020732,
-0.1002745479,
-0.0218526553,
0.0331559069,
-0.1261522919,
0.3911281228,
0.9604793787,
0.1487431079,
0.5694198608,
-0.2551939785,
0.1451062113,
0.1383918077,
-0.5441592336,
-0.4174310267,
0.8883696795,
0.4988950193,
-0.5819740295,
-0.0829957873,
-0.1075287536,
-0.1662976444,
0.4098389447,
0.2931941152,
1.1138943434,
-0.7451859713,
-0.0279007349,
-0.0276494194,
0.2329040617,
0.548666656,
0.169106558,
-0.2831127942,
-0.3902366459,
-0.5214092135,
-0.6368610263,
-0.629927516,
0.2221776694,
-0.4902313054,
0.183855027,
-0.3739815354,
-0.5090296865,
0.3116602898,
-0.1921746284,
-0.4170178771,
0.1923751831,
0.2330097109,
0.6049113274,
-0.6961296797,
0.3671681583,
0.2114117146,
-0.1711072624,
-0.7190371156,
-0.0562823825,
-0.0535645448,
-0.7349342704,
0.7902594209,
-0.3028695285,
-0.4773608744,
-0.3025322556,
-0.4598256052,
-0.9682077169,
0.6512883306,
0.8853907585,
-0.5226938128,
-0.1455401033,
0.1453566104,
0.4623021483,
-0.1735144705,
-0.1742919832,
0.7528795004,
0.6868949533,
-0.0357379057,
-1.4322367907,
-0.3107795715,
-0.0459826216,
0.243058756,
0.3117220402,
-0.3326301575,
0.6211103201,
-0.1296678782,
-0.2165320218,
-0.170331955,
0.3440073431,
-0.0344181545,
0.4433065355,
0.5056328177,
0.3003411889,
0.6061547399,
-0.426861912,
0.664648056,
-0.1877857149,
0.0668784752,
1.1407253742,
0.1687761396,
0.6418005824,
0.3697778881,
-0.4358106256,
-0.1851100177,
0.8639971614,
0.1344909966,
0.7565711141,
-0.1010100096,
-0.0536238551,
-0.1075307131,
-0.5708847642,
-0.7518513799,
0.7858111262,
0.4125320613,
-0.3409190774,
-0.1175170988,
0.5346038342,
-0.0458433852,
0.0771476626,
-0.4656805098,
0.4138945937,
0.0081964573,
-0.1318813413,
0.8546542525,
-0.5708771348,
0.3450632691,
-0.4231136143,
0.0006777766,
-0.4302067757,
-0.1230908707,
-0.330281496,
-0.4190002382,
0.636795342,
-0.289819926,
-0.308727473,
-0.1896002293,
0.5007956624,
-0.3348273635,
-0.3813482821,
0.2484738827,
-0.0705636889,
0.0830465406,
-0.0901805162,
-0.2543687224,
0.3020846844,
-0.3348724246,
-0.1035163403,
-0.2406736165,
0.0821729749,
0.4587756693,
0.4843309224,
0.2436258793,
0.4283024669,
0.0809539184,
0.4984824359,
0.8657673597,
-0.5203561187,
-0.5622229576,
-0.5446048379,
0.0782696828,
-0.1440053284,
-0.3660129905,
0.5475706458,
0.4859817624,
0.4810503125,
0.0122570777,
0.3778564036,
0.2783091068,
1.1551742554,
-0.61285007,
0.5305241942,
-0.4487051964,
0.4000584781,
-0.5744529366,
-0.9024313092,
-0.1627720743,
-0.0635236204,
-0.392026931,
-0.031214932,
0.239814803,
0.6941447258,
0.1413005888,
-0.0637859777,
0.6347334981,
0.0655812472,
0.3199381232,
0.0468461476,
0.9706115723,
-0.0944753811,
0.6784384847,
-0.2682744861,
-0.29179582,
-0.3293628097,
-0.6751977205,
-0.5231745839,
-0.6248006821,
-0.4561186731,
0.2861693501,
0.3600090444,
0.6331631541,
1.1209881306,
-0.7972771525,
-0.0945715383,
0.1398650557,
0.0491265059,
-0.2349899858,
-0.2632394731,
0.3347569108,
-0.325488627,
-0.720620513,
0.9044842124,
0.7560712099,
0.1455027759,
-0.1067083031,
0.0408636928,
0.1640231758,
0.1464681327,
0.6058219671,
0.6563073993,
-1.0442922115,
-0.4589384198,
0.0809865519,
0.4900513291,
0.0844208151,
0.6032863855,
-0.5909041166,
0.3928050101,
0.4205445647,
0.4690236449,
0.8285699487,
-0.1113825515,
0.4579434693,
-0.8641996384,
0.3911840618,
0.6754429936,
0.4635287821,
0.1919471771,
-0.1202251762,
0.4571130574,
0.2521026134,
-0.3412192166,
-0.8315609097,
0.1115296856,
-0.9606529474,
-0.1804694086,
0.7491417527,
0.0658977255,
0.1646267027,
-0.3441304564,
-0.3035461009,
0.1423777044,
-0.7764335275,
0.6326589584,
0.440898627,
-0.6183708906,
-0.3319692314,
-0.1154173985,
0.5387092233,
0.1595458984,
-0.6181070209,
0.0182801913,
0.5713526607,
-0.0753085241,
0.3956439495,
0.3096916378,
-0.1941956133,
0.3291349411,
0.3524624407,
-0.1631651968,
-0.4229215682,
-0.3996505141,
-0.2582767606,
0.4290220141,
0.2140301168,
-0.7426661253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08084v1 | Learning Multi-Object Positional Relationships via Emergent Communication | 2023-02-16T04:44:53 | 2023-02-16T04:44:53 | Yicheng Feng, Boshi An, Zongqing Lu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The study of emergent communication has been dedicated to interactive
artificial intelligence. While existing work focuses on communication about
single objects or complex image scenes, we argue that communicating
relationships between multiple objects is important in more realistic tasks,
but understudied. In this paper, we try to fill this gap and focus on emergent
communication about positional relationships between two objects. We train
agents in the referential game where observations contain two objects, and find
that generalization is the major problem when the positional relationship is
involved. The key factor affecting the generalization ability of the emergent
language is the input variation between Speaker and Listener, which is realized
by a random image generator in our work. Further, we find that the learned
language can generalize well in a new multi-step MDP task where the positional
relationship describes the goal, and performs better than raw-pixel images as
well as pre-trained image features, verifying the strong generalization ability
of discrete sequences. We also show that language transfer from the referential
game performs better in the new task than learning language directly in this
task, implying the potential benefits of pre-training in referential games. All
in all, our experiments demonstrate the viability and merit of having agents
learn to communicate positional relationships between multiple objects through
emergent communication. | [
-0.2814259529,
-0.6439121366,
0.770816505,
0.2950063646,
-0.3616849184,
0.0472037792,
-0.3317833543,
-1.0316801071,
-0.039649345,
-0.0534300096,
-0.2522181869,
-0.2150322348,
-0.671900928,
-0.0779607296,
-0.2336838394,
0.738786459,
0.1547258049,
-0.1936645508,
-0.1349089295,
-0.0899499953,
-0.3310335577,
-0.4635595381,
-1.0561667681,
-0.510925293,
0.5910922885,
0.1810677201,
0.719238162,
0.7767809629,
0.7379270196,
0.4865463674,
0.1557680815,
0.1322643906,
-0.3213589191,
0.4356518984,
-0.2774119973,
-0.5912110209,
0.1458363086,
-0.0617906451,
0.6822133064,
0.5605504513,
-0.1632620692,
0.118989177,
-0.0858745947,
0.5507171154,
-0.3075534403,
0.5269928575,
-0.6373339295,
0.2727906704,
-0.0707032084,
-0.3072383404,
-0.4152044356,
0.0371601731,
0.223151803,
-0.6554730535,
0.2905985415,
-0.1791876256,
1.0103186369,
0.1902412474,
-0.449267149,
-0.2575807571,
-1.2499607801,
0.4035228193,
-0.1145950928,
0.1958626062,
0.0520126484,
0.5008665323,
-0.1445616484,
-0.6445147991,
-0.4295440018,
-0.1723484695,
0.0370935015,
0.0765067711,
0.0028564625,
-0.0615817197,
-0.0745634958,
-0.0199261568,
-0.0390624516,
-0.1587075293,
-0.2242438197,
0.3552393317,
0.5297181606,
-0.2928856611,
0.3517608047,
0.0190820545,
-0.6305397153,
-0.4152711928,
-0.4883154631,
0.0772925615,
0.2435913086,
0.2917459011,
-0.2250758111,
0.3497962356,
0.397569567,
0.7137878537,
0.4547486007,
0.0754844695,
0.193773821,
-0.5100625157,
0.2219405472,
-0.2157944441,
0.8643540144,
0.3321588337,
0.335262686,
-0.2246545702,
0.0342785344,
0.0015052562,
0.2955512106,
-0.4512589276,
-0.3681289256,
0.0965041071,
-0.4689531028,
-0.1401745379,
0.3736209869,
-0.4566927254,
-0.2501251698,
-0.1434080005,
0.1817097068,
-0.5006672144,
-0.6134598851,
-0.3449099064,
0.0124884704,
0.5182070136,
0.3523719311,
-1.1834369898,
0.0935881734,
0.30676952,
0.7048891187,
0.0963097587,
-0.7276321054,
-0.2728737295,
0.6189113259,
-0.5833345652,
1.2328425646,
-0.5436179638,
-0.3048754632,
-0.0767439008,
-0.1642545015,
-0.3391989172,
-0.5497002602,
-0.0612916276,
-0.3824349344,
0.0480820052,
0.0692435429,
-0.2012996376,
0.1345497221,
0.2926504016,
-0.6240730286,
0.5975759625,
-0.1817899942,
-0.5798758268,
0.5514444709,
-0.7790342569,
-0.6168721318,
0.1127782539,
-0.5311267376,
-0.361679405,
0.033749301,
0.2090411484,
0.4726456702,
0.213542819,
-0.0361807533,
-0.1891347319,
-0.1593237668,
0.2369691283,
0.0282811839,
0.098472707,
0.1367885917,
-0.3055106699,
0.128229633,
-0.4988626838,
0.0349316932,
0.162834689,
-0.5589897037,
-0.2759810388,
0.4049367011,
-0.2785322964,
0.5980082154,
0.1350743324,
-0.2162921578,
0.1097833365,
-0.3843414783,
0.1904326826,
0.513330698,
0.3667118847,
0.7052779794,
-0.2637407184,
0.2324393392,
0.5214418769,
0.0678266212,
-0.4817054272,
-0.4516509473,
-0.517367661,
0.2595070004,
-0.0362589844,
0.4730962813,
-0.9521688223,
0.2466923892,
0.0513918474,
-0.1206069291,
-0.3934440315,
-0.0953899026,
0.4442046583,
0.1369443834,
0.270085305,
-0.2434661537,
-0.5813170075,
-0.690830946,
0.0283468701,
-0.4829680026,
-0.0888638869,
0.5397936702,
0.0570007637,
0.0455682389,
0.6036428809,
-0.3764235377,
-0.288369298,
-0.2221639454,
0.4188937247,
-0.0557393096,
0.5723149776,
0.8479267955,
-0.9042589664,
-0.5900660157,
0.1899337471,
-0.800629437,
0.6268612146,
-0.2843975425,
0.0482955389,
-0.1031799167,
0.5411871672,
-0.6469513774,
-0.0109248748,
0.5132963061,
-0.1668776572,
0.3086281121,
-0.4781374037,
0.3636024594,
-1.4072751999,
-0.1931987107,
0.0210613683,
-0.1800056696,
-0.6432358623,
0.2593736649,
-0.2328963876,
-0.0177385192,
-0.6994059086,
0.1179907173,
-0.9907317162,
-0.2743257582,
-0.2407183647,
0.1863771528,
-0.5002986193,
0.5697162747,
0.5743854642,
0.7183841467,
0.8796403408,
-0.8697109818,
0.3743827045,
0.2984002233,
-0.0339232683,
0.8265398741,
-0.6025997996,
0.4083451927,
-0.3554664254,
0.1501476914,
-1.0407972336,
0.109891057,
0.337608695,
-0.662255168,
0.4135945439,
-0.4368935525,
-0.2663790882,
-0.2320428789,
0.0793348849,
0.321076721,
0.2560180128,
-0.3975843191,
0.2195736766,
0.4258594513,
0.0625248179,
-0.6663461328,
-0.4017234147,
-0.0378786586,
-0.1297270507,
-0.4186469615,
-0.0216059983,
-0.0870490298,
0.0170680936,
-0.0650332645,
-0.0307586025,
-0.291274488,
-0.0239143707,
0.2638783157,
-0.0330290757,
-0.2403142452,
0.3119286001,
-0.3543103039,
-0.2008589208,
0.1893551648,
-0.4002316594,
0.4788918495,
-0.3380399048,
-0.4634216428,
0.0472151153,
0.2916751802,
0.2573670149,
-0.065386489,
1.0260961056,
0.6657294035,
-0.2120328099,
0.0258428939,
-0.2763853073,
-0.2365453839,
-0.4413883984,
0.5658127666,
-0.8165319562,
-0.4719149172,
0.3989862204,
-0.3400396407,
-0.0048244451,
0.2723633349,
0.1423742175,
-0.1803404689,
1.0826225281,
0.7874679565,
0.2038866431,
0.6329988837,
-0.3636146486,
-0.0099639986,
-0.8351898789,
-0.5549193621,
-0.4412369728,
-0.2895154059,
-0.3465233445,
-0.5512591004,
0.1178352013,
0.0724491626,
-0.0184438992,
0.5797355175,
-0.3616054654,
0.7431895137,
0.4062404931,
0.3583152592,
0.2711574733,
-0.0131231025,
-0.2886525095,
-0.078233175,
-0.5365865231,
-0.3488579094,
0.83628124,
0.3185983896,
0.7737144828,
0.2796985507,
0.9379771352,
-0.0105419103,
0.1086535975,
-0.7109772563,
0.4389130473,
0.0335896909,
-0.2016444504,
-0.4165156484,
-0.3838502765,
-1.4020258188,
0.520468235,
-0.3827213645,
-0.7099425197,
0.2626782954,
0.064381808,
-0.2057933658,
0.3868364096,
-0.8708967566,
0.596498549,
-0.1973712295,
-0.2671155334,
-0.2001953572,
-1.0360234976,
0.1349354535,
0.3153286278,
0.1197968498,
0.0375348106,
-0.0455714501,
0.7138031721,
0.185169369,
0.7337374091,
-0.0070365919,
-0.1289532036,
0.2920846939,
0.1117530763,
0.2673206031,
0.2411693186,
0.4389817417,
-0.1254025847,
-0.1523444802,
-0.319635123,
-0.5776062012,
0.3892852366,
-1.0585472584,
-0.5171785355,
-0.40807724,
-0.494268328,
-0.2885359824,
0.3269448876,
0.1973135769,
0.1803922355,
-0.5015143156,
0.1155072451,
0.6845441461,
0.1778298318,
0.6433438063,
0.5647774935,
-0.0178170558,
0.1127244979,
0.7699208856,
-0.4107544422,
0.4073359072,
0.8921990395,
0.0378517397,
-0.4027911723,
-0.530610919,
-0.3607023358,
0.2568540573,
-0.5881351829,
-0.0297734514,
-0.5359900594,
-0.3654971421,
-0.2754637897,
-0.0154631678,
-0.4805095196,
-0.1355730742,
-0.2961498499,
-0.0917990059,
-0.2227416635,
1.0717676878,
-0.333865732,
0.1327214986,
-0.9248662591,
0.425152868,
0.555475831,
0.1081302166,
0.0888503864,
-0.152306214,
-0.1757961512,
0.1896939427,
-0.2006595582,
-0.9732849002,
-0.0123457834,
0.3936235011,
0.7691069841,
0.9426551461,
-0.3011574447,
0.677293539,
-0.7706344724,
0.4208136499,
0.4699526429,
-0.4718166888,
0.5831598639,
-0.2974909246,
0.4289858937,
0.2750912607,
0.2563860714,
-0.5663090944,
-0.4897064865,
-1.055106163,
-0.5231925845,
0.8434840441,
0.0930182263,
0.1378106475,
-0.327896446,
0.0039642467,
-0.271556437,
0.4905837774,
-0.7853989601,
-0.5060759783,
0.0665841252,
0.1522542834,
-0.3138476908,
-0.1892615557,
-0.4467467964,
-0.0159851164,
-0.0001151261,
0.0727951899,
0.650259316,
0.0794788301,
-0.0419190861,
-0.3917498589,
0.3207683265,
0.544415772,
0.731333375,
0.0064638075,
0.5704149604,
-0.2720972002,
-0.5707026124,
0.5973743796,
0.2511282265,
0.0371532068,
-0.1400945485,
0.392097801,
0.721414566,
0.4731410146,
-0.1335375607,
0.3948616982,
0.0631476194,
-0.0887411907,
-0.1284385324,
-0.0116409035,
0.4146004021,
0.3782461584,
0.3896881044,
0.6288244128,
-0.043977391,
-0.8058341146,
0.5159420967,
0.5197710395,
-0.3941663206,
-0.5306754708,
0.6545299888,
0.4138203263,
-0.4387372732,
0.5096970797,
-0.3089789748,
-0.2582207322,
0.709816277,
0.8865626454,
0.4886620641,
-0.5458354354,
0.7491582036,
0.4084560275,
0.3625490367,
-0.0937140882,
-0.0005373886,
-0.252247721,
-1.1273572445,
-0.2671307623,
-0.1562437862,
-0.3476229906,
-0.0025560416,
-0.2527248263,
-0.318654567,
-0.3552427888,
-0.1241957471,
-0.2261420786,
-0.0635952726,
-0.7275252938,
-0.14239645,
0.1649149209,
0.2991164923,
-0.8495385647,
0.6046260595,
1.2998744249,
-0.6981802583,
-0.9871491194,
-0.1079151556,
-0.4432919025,
-0.8802414536,
0.768961072,
0.0265852865,
-0.1815724522,
0.1620433033,
-0.5986719131,
-1.0218043327,
0.8800730705,
0.2774243951,
-0.2789378464,
-0.1646186709,
0.0058869426,
0.634942174,
-0.7061203122,
0.5500972271,
0.1264320016,
0.3129758835,
0.6028273106,
-0.7460488677,
-0.0347917154,
-0.204244107,
0.1251895875,
0.2208261341,
-0.7596863508,
0.8448699117,
-0.6889695525,
-0.5908482075,
-0.1852490008,
0.8275278807,
0.1825005114,
-0.0071074227,
0.5065509677,
0.2415480614,
0.3617068827,
0.0724948645,
0.7592433095,
-0.0883776397,
0.1435311735,
1.1907268763,
-0.2797096074,
0.8746973872,
0.5203318596,
-0.322557956,
0.7028985023,
0.4247580171,
0.1773812175,
0.3179678917,
0.1910098642,
-0.2770156562,
-0.1375082433,
0.0329410881,
-0.38340801,
0.254601419,
0.3751582503,
-0.2714406252,
-0.4957024157,
-0.1011657268,
-0.2958256006,
0.208138749,
0.0019593087,
0.9702100158,
-0.0507621802,
-0.4932867885,
0.1196830571,
-0.2502395809,
0.4613169432,
-0.7237302065,
-0.3672566414,
0.0663013011,
0.350769937,
-0.0376754478,
-0.8031927943,
-0.0077300365,
-0.7104797363,
-0.0983455405,
0.0480090193,
0.7274334431,
-0.9486106038,
-0.1049022675,
0.25534603,
0.8245484829,
0.3739361465,
0.0376027711,
-0.8598183393,
-0.2929183543,
-0.3505157828,
-0.0885832906,
0.4477520287,
0.4204920828,
0.0285832789,
0.7091323733,
0.6196305752,
0.4106098413,
0.122790724,
0.1509673148,
0.5755838752,
-0.3063001931,
-0.6415124536,
-0.4939453602,
0.2664463222,
-0.2079423368,
-0.0076836655,
0.5910705924,
0.2686043084,
0.8248592019,
-0.4344777465,
0.620870173,
-0.1311043799,
0.2212924659,
-0.4386211336,
0.4162705839,
0.1457160711,
0.0286076069,
-0.1821010411,
-1.236510396,
-0.0229190104,
0.87586689,
0.0826248303,
0.3143232465,
1.103096962,
0.2359369099,
-0.2629900277,
-0.6070537567,
0.4642531276,
0.0558356047,
0.2963633239,
1.0026919842,
1.0583106279,
-0.360612154,
0.8537294865,
-0.2811143398,
-0.2546928525,
0.2194404155,
-0.8555348516,
-0.925555408,
-0.8940605521,
-0.2054522634,
0.034542989,
0.2826325595,
0.6541751623,
1.0040631294,
-0.6052041054,
-0.5977219343,
-0.1378022134,
0.2479476929,
-0.7550933361,
-0.2328641564,
0.2602595985,
-0.4969048202,
-0.8588845134,
0.3759392202,
0.2034774423,
0.4536003768,
-0.2431792319,
-0.0654189885,
-0.7523264885,
-0.2534900904,
0.5587106347,
0.7623196244,
-0.2098910064,
-0.4766499698,
-0.256893158,
0.0326521136,
0.1772131771,
1.1306892633,
-0.5583128333,
0.3337642848,
0.1145351976,
0.3378975689,
0.5145744681,
0.3808812201,
0.7243577838,
-1.0902423859,
0.5684726834,
-0.017991377,
0.1370701492,
0.4546084106,
-0.4943769872,
0.3744901717,
0.2336311787,
-0.4377584457,
-0.1366232038,
0.5693741441,
-0.5418663621,
-0.1513758302,
1.0339895487,
-0.0886680931,
-0.088525027,
-0.211710602,
-0.2394434512,
0.348305434,
-0.4786111414,
0.6815869212,
0.5734604597,
-0.3711970448,
-0.5716258287,
-0.00013077,
0.7672208548,
-0.0214485861,
-0.9109318852,
-0.4315286577,
0.4026428461,
0.0775618106,
0.6612530947,
0.9061680436,
0.0620299727,
0.1790584624,
0.1719123423,
-0.0075467131,
-0.0569988377,
-0.686878562,
-0.0444643162,
0.2108405381,
0.2959010899,
-0.7957583666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08081v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08081v1 | Exploring the Limits of ChatGPT for Query or Aspect-based Text Summarization | 2023-02-16T04:41:30 | 2023-02-16T04:41:30 | Xianjun Yang, Yan Li, Xinlu Zhang, Haifeng Chen, Wei Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text summarization has been a crucial problem in natural language processing
(NLP) for several decades. It aims to condense lengthy documents into shorter
versions while retaining the most critical information. Various methods have
been proposed for text summarization, including extractive and abstractive
summarization. The emergence of large language models (LLMs) like GPT3 and
ChatGPT has recently created significant interest in using these models for
text summarization tasks. Recent studies \cite{goyal2022news,
zhang2023benchmarking} have shown that LLMs-generated news summaries are
already on par with humans. However, the performance of LLMs for more practical
applications like aspect or query-based summaries is underexplored. To fill
this gap, we conducted an evaluation of ChatGPT's performance on four widely
used benchmark datasets, encompassing diverse summaries from Reddit posts, news
articles, dialogue meetings, and stories. Our experiments reveal that ChatGPT's
performance is comparable to traditional fine-tuning methods in terms of Rouge
scores. Moreover, we highlight some unique differences between
ChatGPT-generated summaries and human references, providing valuable insights
into the superpower of ChatGPT for diverse text summarization tasks. Our
findings call for new directions in this area, and we plan to conduct further
research to systematically examine the characteristics of ChatGPT-generated
summaries through extensive human evaluation. | [
-0.4221147597,
-0.8028011918,
0.5160271525,
0.262947619,
-0.5252081752,
0.1154018641,
-0.2479283661,
-0.6668280959,
0.2393586338,
0.6202317476,
-0.5009000301,
-0.4601560235,
-0.4540199041,
0.1524435282,
-0.5610772967,
1.484934926,
0.0806170702,
-0.3098356426,
-0.2095260173,
-0.1664184332,
-0.3540612161,
-0.8106625676,
-0.6678069234,
-0.2989789248,
0.363912642,
0.2888496518,
0.5526287556,
0.3924772143,
0.814514935,
0.159139514,
-0.4000562131,
0.2560608685,
-0.6044145823,
0.3250705302,
0.0749507919,
-0.447345376,
-0.6533747911,
-0.028757181,
0.7095066905,
0.6299700737,
0.0208595078,
-0.0165956672,
0.3786763847,
1.0509992838,
-0.4138509333,
0.2236492634,
-0.5741586685,
0.0686394423,
-0.1470121294,
-0.3427461386,
-0.1213638335,
-0.4416106939,
0.1895001084,
-0.1572985947,
0.5814057589,
0.1298638582,
0.7340545058,
-0.024770733,
-0.4679687023,
-0.2038594633,
-0.7337397933,
0.4768545628,
-0.7670706511,
0.1537132114,
0.2193595022,
0.1707733721,
-0.1003505215,
-0.7171218991,
-0.3373029828,
-0.216493696,
-0.220118016,
0.3737657368,
-0.1813242435,
0.1499866098,
0.2092052698,
0.7443724275,
-0.745239079,
-0.0693518072,
-0.3214782476,
-0.2049930841,
0.6323609948,
0.3771080375,
0.2064527422,
-0.4612033069,
-0.2176465839,
0.0106340451,
-0.7483708858,
-0.1549979895,
0.170687139,
0.279535532,
-0.0654468834,
0.7970166802,
-0.6390939951,
0.4686158597,
-0.3239437938,
0.1140339226,
-0.0985453725,
-0.6345582008,
0.0502768196,
-0.2703466415,
1.0305079222,
0.8684325218,
0.2046443671,
-0.2752552927,
-0.1839354038,
-0.3707332611,
0.1174667925,
-0.9835537076,
-0.2276788354,
0.172689423,
-0.3761945963,
-0.1134078503,
-0.1238462999,
-0.8851014376,
-0.5825792551,
-0.1073867679,
0.1952741891,
-0.5248599648,
-0.1617365479,
-0.0611012243,
-0.2858608365,
0.2790118456,
0.3486266434,
-1.0321989059,
0.3446727395,
0.9383223653,
1.190513134,
-0.5152720213,
-0.386949122,
-0.2226964235,
-0.1616390198,
-0.0725317001,
1.1147942543,
-0.3822810054,
-0.5396050811,
-0.1992783993,
-0.3010813296,
-0.1009889767,
-0.5218710303,
0.6036558747,
-0.4535898864,
0.2133867741,
-0.3924158514,
-0.6145321131,
-0.2288048565,
0.3892589509,
-0.5670913458,
0.9093227386,
-0.1547701359,
-0.8567898273,
0.3885694444,
-0.607106626,
-0.6355121136,
-0.1612334698,
-0.0596932918,
-0.4687942564,
0.2191594988,
0.4978526533,
0.5544973612,
-0.2341473103,
0.1142987311,
0.055524759,
-0.3646995127,
0.303853035,
-0.6586903334,
0.2708930969,
0.0149213476,
-0.0327010117,
0.2178826034,
-0.4365670383,
-0.1910305023,
-0.0052871816,
-0.2594743371,
-0.1226392463,
0.1956890225,
0.0999239162,
-0.0650119334,
0.2566514313,
-0.338219136,
0.1874450743,
-0.3890257478,
0.6196146607,
0.3710021973,
0.3907500505,
0.3414354622,
-0.5880298018,
0.5736998916,
-0.3369420469,
-0.1068695635,
-0.5877487659,
-0.5216390491,
-0.6835743785,
-0.0039467728,
0.3038220704,
0.452563405,
-0.4159522951,
0.1979408562,
-0.3643468916,
-0.6695597768,
-0.0607804917,
-0.1438781917,
0.1703464836,
0.3294441104,
0.216603294,
-0.3798161745,
-0.2630643845,
-1.0170470476,
-0.6467280388,
-0.1917455494,
-0.3791140318,
0.2920079827,
0.4476870596,
0.2017857134,
1.012758255,
-0.6460961103,
-0.3197970688,
-0.6247141957,
0.3131406903,
0.1989179403,
0.1654345095,
0.3397114277,
-0.8372168541,
-0.4347364008,
-0.0351140834,
-0.5352641344,
-0.1345327199,
-0.2210478932,
-0.0370422974,
0.1362473369,
0.4934742749,
-0.6727418303,
0.3219972849,
0.4521766603,
-0.0953208953,
0.6720221639,
-0.1849001497,
0.3376047015,
-1.0457795858,
0.0809190422,
-0.1056802794,
-0.5099496841,
-0.4436190128,
0.1483499855,
0.0849568471,
-0.4411644936,
-0.1365463436,
0.4210645854,
-0.494222492,
-0.1225239262,
-0.5193617344,
0.5132575631,
-0.0864214972,
0.6485248208,
0.1625596583,
0.8158505559,
0.1732931137,
-0.5281014442,
0.1773079783,
-0.034836214,
-0.1345845759,
0.3892704546,
-0.8821732402,
0.121464476,
-0.0928871334,
0.4683611095,
-1.0308076143,
-0.3122846782,
0.1439590901,
-0.401209563,
0.055819314,
-0.2152094394,
-0.5449698567,
0.0307824891,
-0.5904195309,
0.340922147,
0.4454408884,
-0.2230011672,
0.5656125546,
0.3828300834,
-0.5466131568,
-0.2416676581,
-0.4593486786,
0.3398171067,
-0.2495467067,
-0.5099570751,
0.410728991,
0.253957063,
-0.0132070091,
0.0084924232,
-0.3491159678,
-0.020554306,
-0.1157640368,
0.1993266791,
0.12280114,
-0.0782304332,
0.1179620624,
0.1389325112,
-0.1362239122,
0.0144008296,
-0.0178782735,
0.6182678938,
-0.2899744511,
-0.5547350049,
-0.1847756952,
0.5344842076,
0.4366391003,
-0.3510564268,
0.489613384,
0.5262565613,
-0.164529562,
0.0982142985,
-0.5186595321,
-0.1594435275,
-0.3734188378,
0.7214143276,
0.0595997907,
-1.0583690405,
0.6605627537,
0.1210567579,
0.3682746589,
0.5592924356,
0.4801856279,
-0.0218407027,
0.7423955798,
0.5457336903,
-0.3234788775,
0.5664722323,
-0.0023402018,
0.1393755823,
-0.8913738728,
0.0743102729,
-0.3745975196,
-0.2153790444,
-0.8203082085,
-0.3505682349,
0.5218521357,
0.079468213,
0.3251603842,
0.2410182357,
-0.3538341224,
0.7738298774,
0.4633801281,
0.1428104043,
0.7258614302,
-0.2356317788,
0.4592552185,
0.0501789562,
-0.5576450825,
-0.4905670881,
1.1418862343,
0.1422385722,
0.638897717,
0.1513439119,
0.6803236008,
0.3023698628,
0.2598211169,
-0.8106879592,
0.6451942921,
-0.1182245016,
-0.4682950974,
-0.403701216,
-0.5395156145,
-0.9451316595,
0.56966573,
-0.1310248971,
-0.8323955536,
-0.3128046393,
0.1393020302,
-0.1911904812,
0.197886914,
-0.7879639864,
0.6410163641,
0.0294727366,
-0.1429969072,
-0.333784014,
-0.5044744015,
0.3728553951,
0.0213206541,
-0.0888171867,
-0.2797132432,
-0.0729448348,
0.7321687341,
-0.3828372657,
0.8517410159,
0.1684926301,
-0.049767796,
0.2868965864,
-0.0396562628,
0.4993450642,
0.3050893545,
0.1433786154,
0.1202915236,
-0.052930411,
-0.4162648022,
-0.5316975713,
0.5895905495,
-0.3126284778,
-0.6702159643,
-0.4462833703,
-0.5209459066,
-0.2824062407,
0.2767708898,
0.4884101748,
0.5326399207,
-0.4444188476,
0.149593249,
0.397459805,
-0.1280688941,
0.5595766902,
0.4315949082,
-0.4569097161,
-0.1857220232,
0.9461109042,
0.0936837494,
0.2708930969,
0.5661270022,
0.1025876701,
-0.2201258987,
-0.8555799127,
-0.3104410768,
0.223734349,
-0.3602735698,
-0.0853026435,
-0.6779568195,
-0.442596823,
-0.1389496177,
0.0390693545,
-0.4390871525,
-0.554499805,
0.048504442,
0.0978958011,
0.3589594364,
0.6878805757,
0.1330097765,
0.3119081259,
-0.9239119887,
0.3665362,
0.2497228235,
0.4443054199,
-0.0453051403,
-0.3865980506,
-0.2139746845,
-0.004759056,
-0.453758359,
-0.7686120868,
0.3184556961,
0.167536661,
0.1591305435,
0.1446256042,
0.184084475,
0.3532674909,
-0.4147144854,
0.8971990943,
-0.164666146,
-0.6739634275,
0.4387274086,
-0.6598489881,
0.5003103018,
0.5002778172,
0.0947260857,
-0.9351025224,
-0.8311471939,
-0.4560980499,
-1.178878665,
0.6029554009,
0.6645710468,
0.2557344139,
0.1156597435,
0.4223381281,
0.1375491321,
0.1232961714,
-0.4968060255,
-0.1276698112,
0.0381996222,
0.220585078,
-0.1039140373,
-0.3499850333,
0.1674661338,
0.1226816177,
0.4950868487,
0.0754816905,
0.2606342733,
0.2697992027,
-0.0641420558,
0.3648537695,
0.4895763993,
0.6573445797,
0.6471683383,
-0.3961112797,
-0.0495552272,
0.2385199964,
-0.6963743567,
-0.331474483,
0.35402143,
-0.1448989511,
0.0017000177,
0.5866906643,
0.5843033195,
0.025091989,
-0.6601486206,
0.4844149351,
-0.3828804493,
-0.0729777738,
-0.0743758902,
0.189608261,
0.0760621578,
0.2716878951,
0.5156293511,
0.0845052525,
0.3395400345,
-0.3965525329,
-0.0209021997,
0.4271410406,
-0.3311443329,
-0.3407322168,
0.6689884663,
0.3348222077,
-0.2293907702,
0.4520046413,
-0.1224414334,
-0.46931234,
0.4483316541,
0.2464165688,
1.0137871504,
0.3508537412,
0.0996895432,
0.1947649568,
0.3411517739,
-0.0039896714,
-0.1148610115,
-0.2795251012,
-0.4321068525,
-0.7494577169,
-0.4546713233,
-0.88730371,
0.1948084682,
-0.5775885582,
0.0132568497,
-0.0036148489,
-0.0531521924,
0.0407483876,
-0.027992662,
-0.1936696917,
-0.0633365363,
-0.2424311489,
0.6405533552,
-0.6524471641,
0.3891423345,
0.547742188,
-0.2413540632,
-0.3564383686,
0.4164936841,
0.0136626111,
-0.5606166124,
-0.0586129837,
0.1543811858,
0.0056829425,
-0.2322220355,
-0.1979551166,
-0.5127880573,
0.9157881141,
0.1919990033,
-0.4598828256,
-0.1688856035,
0.2622117996,
0.7249627113,
0.0398756117,
0.3761738837,
0.6958531737,
0.0663821921,
-0.0252377465,
-0.9664819837,
-0.0315340422,
-0.2634414136,
-0.0708666518,
0.4471936524,
-0.8467367291,
0.7270233035,
-0.098438181,
-0.2999532223,
0.0203235187,
0.7134011984,
0.0759684965,
0.236533761,
0.1526791304,
0.1598561406,
0.5507717729,
-0.1430156827,
1.2461669445,
-0.1893394142,
0.4556776881,
1.2738566399,
0.0470814705,
0.771093905,
0.229740411,
-0.3463574946,
-0.0659095645,
0.5825372338,
0.1663597971,
0.20099397,
0.0150535163,
-0.2764018774,
0.0043426449,
0.0234973375,
-0.4922190607,
0.4301165044,
0.2051595747,
-0.3349626064,
-0.4838572443,
-0.2854691148,
0.2319758832,
-0.1454632282,
-0.1404824704,
0.997644186,
0.06123285,
-0.7957085967,
0.2484722435,
-0.0020799311,
0.6071993113,
-0.5295147896,
0.0084529221,
-0.6644648314,
-0.0528112762,
-0.0911739394,
-0.9873385429,
0.4088232815,
0.2008966058,
-0.1484363079,
-0.0361650959,
0.7671268582,
-0.2759509385,
-0.3092338145,
-0.1717886925,
0.5907118917,
0.3371764421,
-0.6488215923,
-0.1841302663,
-0.3133016825,
0.1474250108,
-0.4848365784,
0.6317322254,
0.628657937,
0.0097910967,
0.6563600898,
0.4398227036,
0.0904863998,
-0.2581632137,
0.0356043391,
1.0249916315,
-0.7504170537,
-0.4899113774,
-1.1863081455,
0.2529802322,
-0.1934618205,
-0.4563572109,
0.9636074305,
0.8823358417,
0.4588031769,
0.1879774928,
0.8632423878,
-0.0061495919,
0.6100209951,
-0.6907957196,
0.7688475251,
-0.2878275216,
0.4939178824,
-0.3862217665,
-1.0666098595,
-0.3443975747,
0.1178698465,
-0.3392257988,
0.0884608254,
0.6717640758,
0.6837964058,
0.0616564713,
0.3815133274,
0.137540713,
-0.030447375,
0.4737901688,
0.417437911,
0.8628560901,
-0.1829454154,
0.9136996865,
-0.311696142,
-0.2073987424,
-0.3783767521,
-0.9882542491,
-1.074598074,
-0.5608709455,
-0.141004473,
-0.0116937691,
0.0793216377,
0.5208154321,
0.398730129,
-0.5744561553,
-0.046193894,
-0.1836634129,
0.2091415673,
-0.1930383891,
-0.251390487,
0.5927465558,
-0.2944513857,
-0.785763979,
0.1114352793,
0.3791403472,
0.0282671861,
-0.119348295,
0.326710552,
0.2723856568,
-0.2015388757,
0.7249341607,
0.3001746535,
-0.3380318582,
-0.1672255397,
-0.1035361588,
0.0257033054,
0.158858031,
0.9830114245,
-0.5079949498,
0.2203236818,
0.5313640833,
0.4694215655,
0.9170032144,
0.3443653286,
0.7051765919,
-0.8542233109,
-0.1109926477,
0.3150729239,
0.131068483,
0.1774083525,
-0.2527009845,
0.5484246016,
0.0039681187,
-0.8146880269,
-0.5644322634,
0.0598820969,
-1.0200281143,
-0.0663501024,
1.1867340803,
0.0323406011,
0.084041819,
-0.0333700143,
-0.5312651992,
0.0517668314,
-0.6832147241,
0.7671169639,
0.6163041592,
-0.6162994504,
-0.1681449711,
-0.6913901567,
0.5166483521,
0.3095396459,
-0.9539743662,
0.6239269376,
0.5658793449,
0.0764080957,
-0.0541766398,
0.7476368546,
-0.1113626361,
0.1978666782,
0.0151142124,
-0.2210981846,
-0.0159080029,
0.0918556899,
-0.17255041,
0.3269272447,
0.0364700928,
-0.1023046449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08079v1 | Document Flattening: Beyond Concatenating Context for Document-Level Neural Machine Translation | 2023-02-16T04:38:34 | 2023-02-16T04:38:34 | Minghao Wu, George Foster, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing work in document-level neural machine translation commonly
concatenates several consecutive sentences as a pseudo-document, and then
learns inter-sentential dependencies. This strategy limits the model's ability
to leverage information from distant context. We overcome this limitation with
a novel Document Flattening (DocFlat) technique that integrates Flat-Batch
Attention (FBA) and Neural Context Gate (NCG) into Transformer model to utilize
information beyond the pseudo-document boundaries. FBA allows the model to
attend to all the positions in the batch and learns the relationships between
positions explicitly and NCG identifies the useful information from the distant
context. We conduct comprehensive experiments and analyses on three benchmark
datasets for English-German translation, and validate the effectiveness of two
variants of DocFlat. Empirical results show that our approach outperforms
strong baselines with statistical significance on BLEU, COMET and accuracy on
the contrastive test set. The analyses highlight that DocFlat is highly
effective in capturing the long-range information. | [
-0.4146811962,
-0.6498463154,
0.3738538027,
0.0750586912,
-0.3227578998,
-0.1397497207,
-0.4868674874,
-0.3514530659,
-0.1194912642,
0.272955358,
-0.6336151361,
-0.4331918955,
-0.6900187731,
0.0012282704,
-0.7228059173,
1.0768327713,
-0.0671114922,
-0.0429253168,
-0.2024198174,
0.14338471,
-0.4210005701,
-0.478194803,
-0.5851358175,
-0.4779536724,
0.4617577493,
0.3563921154,
0.4942281842,
0.3809306026,
0.6282858849,
0.3115634322,
-0.0212347843,
0.1440553367,
-0.4810331166,
0.1005287319,
-0.028487213,
-0.6739577055,
-0.5134072304,
0.0323232263,
0.8883523345,
0.9999589324,
0.0722459704,
-0.0175810438,
0.0588492267,
0.6786763668,
-0.3557195961,
0.1979132295,
-0.6920778155,
0.2565278709,
-0.1753701568,
-0.0345843472,
-0.4559861422,
-0.2724734247,
0.012755394,
-0.5586242676,
0.4642960727,
-0.1940073818,
0.8631814122,
0.5277355909,
-0.4400742352,
-0.1753957719,
-0.7459267974,
0.5279960036,
-0.6591848135,
0.473210305,
0.1831945926,
0.1604097635,
-0.2147485167,
-1.0397439003,
-0.5470261574,
-0.1423882395,
-0.3542526066,
0.2444786578,
-0.0227154493,
-0.0221712627,
0.1700929105,
0.7048715949,
-0.3332190812,
0.0477223732,
-0.5913264751,
-0.1193331033,
0.1391201615,
-0.2274089754,
0.1352806091,
0.2045535147,
-0.6533039808,
-0.2623094618,
-0.4461128712,
0.1197939888,
-0.1443462372,
0.182871297,
-0.1026777923,
0.4374158978,
-0.0914407745,
0.5575661659,
0.4507907331,
0.3199920654,
0.2444911152,
-0.3142390549,
-0.403487891,
0.1101817787,
0.5985305309,
0.5114321113,
0.1585108191,
-0.4416738153,
-0.3555206954,
-0.3117316961,
0.469840914,
-0.9166012406,
0.1209733039,
0.2727120519,
-0.4323900044,
-0.0023003961,
0.0564287566,
-0.6215535998,
-0.1863914728,
-0.3246665895,
-0.0574212559,
-0.5674738884,
0.0132864639,
-0.1249052435,
-0.0358294211,
0.284391731,
0.2173565179,
-0.8561699986,
0.2482481301,
0.7288439274,
1.0175716877,
-0.2446727455,
-0.5253931284,
-0.8594018221,
0.0461674556,
-0.3589081466,
0.7293658853,
-0.1952038854,
-0.3228640854,
-0.0002631288,
0.0432044007,
-0.2341562808,
-0.4440664053,
0.602188766,
-0.5089515448,
0.4547175169,
0.1249142364,
-0.5341702104,
-0.1865609288,
0.4124673009,
-0.5898606777,
0.8173431158,
0.3430120647,
-0.3134322464,
0.2395631224,
-0.6499208808,
-0.7647027373,
0.0774940103,
-0.1872300059,
-0.4432043433,
0.4303935468,
0.2036559731,
0.7034544945,
-0.1003012359,
0.3143720329,
0.060254287,
-0.426769644,
0.0538157187,
-0.467712909,
0.3166480958,
0.091430448,
-0.3569464386,
0.0805074275,
-0.6898642778,
-0.2392739058,
-0.0135209402,
-0.4116937816,
-0.4424237907,
-0.4223317802,
0.3348389268,
0.462316215,
0.2005443275,
-0.4277254939,
0.3801430762,
-0.5833030939,
0.3492132425,
0.2620843649,
-0.2321646959,
0.8125154376,
-0.2917734087,
0.3984275162,
0.0671852008,
0.1200798079,
-0.317599684,
-0.1721897572,
-0.5270415545,
-0.1665536165,
0.3442668617,
0.3044178784,
-0.5260977745,
0.392999053,
-0.6158906817,
-0.2898897529,
-0.5542932749,
0.0974940583,
0.4520413876,
0.9630896449,
0.6565572619,
-0.3042660356,
-0.178705886,
-0.7891347408,
0.1045535207,
0.4748956859,
-0.1964690834,
-0.2445527464,
0.2320190966,
-0.2224008441,
0.4933154583,
-0.3291421533,
-0.7509710789,
-0.0589119904,
0.2866140306,
0.3683868051,
0.5759595037,
0.4451735318,
-1.1505782604,
-0.3665305078,
0.2261828482,
-0.6103484035,
0.1866398305,
-0.4925979078,
0.0028332225,
0.3247299194,
0.9221435189,
-0.79207623,
0.3872512877,
0.510784924,
-0.1896921098,
0.124633126,
-0.4920429289,
0.0502264425,
-1.2307837009,
0.286705792,
-0.1317374855,
-0.3034313917,
-0.7858083248,
-0.0150274495,
0.4674898088,
-0.0002829813,
-0.6642833352,
0.5991154909,
-0.557371974,
-0.0038251807,
-0.394110471,
0.2548627555,
0.14828448,
0.4977343678,
0.1018147618,
0.5604252815,
-0.0264734253,
-0.3063186705,
0.0906193256,
0.4535626471,
-0.1164928824,
0.7320902348,
-0.3120394051,
0.2385774106,
-0.1169001088,
0.4874990284,
-0.8955138922,
-0.0778562427,
0.1380417198,
-0.4197431505,
0.7914444208,
-0.1113180295,
-0.3877680004,
-0.0438457765,
-0.1484232098,
0.2842532992,
0.4120922983,
-0.3810306787,
0.661832571,
0.0943129286,
-0.0906196684,
-0.5717769265,
-1.0198179483,
0.1989156455,
-0.0864806324,
-0.4723433852,
0.6819860339,
0.1079925671,
0.0374883786,
-0.1287430823,
-0.5036469698,
-0.0442254841,
0.1053496972,
0.2443201691,
0.105687134,
-0.2355624586,
0.1604346931,
0.2352275699,
-0.1794366837,
-0.032364171,
-0.6042669415,
0.5698231459,
-0.2696381211,
0.122876659,
-0.2037522197,
0.53779459,
0.6243963838,
-0.3609692454,
0.7142265439,
0.8224971294,
-0.5414938331,
-0.3734527528,
-0.3239970505,
-0.2955237329,
-0.429354012,
0.3686232865,
-0.6607307196,
-0.6184409857,
0.3543761075,
-0.3087195754,
0.0576020777,
0.4205467105,
0.4457759857,
-0.3005609214,
0.3651950955,
0.9262614846,
-0.0837193057,
0.4474472702,
-0.4088723063,
0.1374743581,
-0.7876625061,
-0.404699713,
-0.34077546,
-0.4551427066,
-0.4908367693,
-0.3608029783,
0.140683502,
0.2851148844,
0.2623900175,
0.2223092765,
-0.5979227424,
0.4577392042,
0.4696295857,
-0.0514941663,
0.2585293055,
-0.0723360628,
-0.2488171756,
0.1625697464,
-0.5663263798,
-0.2943760753,
0.903742969,
0.1356981993,
0.3111352921,
-0.22109209,
0.4994896948,
0.2074124217,
0.5073355436,
-0.957875371,
0.2989816368,
-0.5508331656,
-0.3327726424,
-0.3528125286,
-0.2450212389,
-1.0400227308,
0.2277606279,
-0.0214858074,
-0.5334792137,
0.1397163421,
-0.0476029143,
-0.1894351095,
0.1650315374,
-0.7971420288,
0.7910221815,
-0.2633953094,
-0.1286303401,
0.0619501285,
-0.9732906818,
0.1829484701,
-0.4601710141,
0.0827267319,
0.2489966452,
-0.0962208584,
0.2583479583,
-0.3938369155,
0.7357698083,
0.0267352182,
-0.2801955938,
-0.3751951456,
-0.0753501877,
0.3473422527,
-0.0983807445,
-0.0806202218,
0.4903256595,
0.007865279,
-0.4603466094,
-0.7778238654,
0.8093129992,
-0.5067336559,
-0.5017772317,
-0.3548976183,
-0.9799043536,
-0.1998794675,
0.8524734378,
0.3183101118,
0.2753461599,
-0.1827834547,
0.3763296306,
0.6496679783,
0.2298351377,
0.4209063649,
0.2275106758,
-0.0998573825,
-0.1226186082,
0.4536113441,
0.0162532441,
0.2893957496,
0.8776268959,
0.0669774339,
-0.3062089384,
-0.6241257191,
-0.3107554615,
0.1010888666,
-0.7968170643,
-0.0053620399,
-0.5344456434,
-0.1766275764,
-0.4465042353,
-0.3237060606,
-0.3743859529,
-0.3965628445,
0.0844750255,
-0.0672720522,
-0.0944570005,
0.4386458099,
0.04536606,
0.3785341084,
-0.7971975207,
0.4154233932,
-0.1901618391,
0.213563621,
-0.2190076709,
-0.2683115602,
-0.3469579518,
-0.048116643,
-0.1945217103,
-0.6679936051,
0.2226206064,
0.1355652213,
0.4008150697,
0.2518478334,
-0.0487197563,
0.427213937,
-0.6412906051,
0.5170360804,
0.1726792753,
-0.8942325115,
0.3028736711,
-0.3865053058,
0.7313887477,
0.6876378655,
0.376504451,
-0.6022623181,
-0.4142767787,
-0.3833940327,
-1.0164997578,
0.595962584,
0.4055967033,
0.1772324592,
0.2193702161,
0.6475639939,
0.2687108815,
0.2751786113,
-0.4834427238,
-0.200678736,
-0.2305631638,
-0.349750787,
-0.4958401918,
0.2164767981,
-0.1017015055,
-0.0583518818,
0.315857023,
-0.2041853964,
0.1377860904,
0.4532314837,
-0.2382681072,
0.1086713225,
0.3254964948,
0.7846969366,
0.3824279904,
-0.4396555722,
0.3909321129,
0.1031566635,
-0.6763617396,
-0.0041241171,
0.6676744819,
-0.3392083347,
0.0728907585,
0.2432991266,
0.4224913716,
0.1574823558,
-0.1613813639,
0.2699637711,
-0.2473063618,
-0.2002179325,
-0.1360046417,
-0.2799014449,
0.216985926,
0.1444851905,
0.3245817423,
0.2125334293,
0.0765487999,
-0.4858468473,
0.5149664283,
0.153768152,
-0.775395453,
-0.1857315004,
0.7140540481,
0.1998154819,
-0.297452271,
0.7512254119,
0.1603008211,
-0.3705619574,
0.7022070885,
0.4805548489,
0.6466056108,
-0.1255697608,
-0.0440112203,
0.0080342498,
0.5116305351,
-0.1333783716,
-0.1006263569,
-0.3599939942,
-0.3419741392,
-0.3567900062,
-0.3199641705,
-0.2970375717,
0.4339428544,
-0.5398973227,
0.1575016826,
-0.3254942298,
-0.0652985722,
0.0924499854,
-0.0411979668,
-0.6861237884,
0.5128430128,
0.4293089807,
0.9818071723,
-0.4660157859,
1.0506843328,
0.8148996234,
-0.7055512667,
-0.5211552382,
0.5845679045,
-0.2170749903,
-0.47366786,
0.4666009545,
0.5991403461,
-0.2118400335,
0.2209536135,
-0.2506579161,
-0.5917512178,
1.1264083385,
0.2849322557,
-0.6094285846,
-0.2565927804,
0.3203513622,
0.593018353,
-0.3578958213,
0.250148356,
0.4493729174,
0.5205568075,
-0.0049431273,
-0.64905864,
0.4243609309,
-0.4133717716,
-0.0078844894,
0.3587884009,
-0.7688444257,
0.6109116673,
0.1082047746,
-0.1707245409,
-0.1027394459,
0.6752730012,
-0.1889694929,
0.3666531146,
0.4414243698,
0.2018108368,
0.7962740064,
-0.1390725076,
1.2129634619,
-0.2436152846,
0.1317740381,
1.4011858702,
-0.0149756037,
0.6444259882,
0.9458129406,
0.3962780833,
0.2105142176,
0.5365995169,
-0.1061341166,
0.6551466584,
0.252117455,
0.0818030313,
0.1238849312,
-0.0654268861,
-0.3194437921,
0.2761482298,
0.3116568327,
-0.3414271474,
-0.3208586276,
0.0135081308,
0.2926477194,
0.2094150633,
-0.2518320084,
0.5545146465,
0.4992242157,
-1.075935483,
0.8401960731,
0.0793429315,
0.590523243,
-0.5781643391,
0.0815995708,
-0.5782913566,
0.6190920472,
-0.1852788925,
-0.6054491401,
0.6244289875,
-0.1686071903,
-0.3496571183,
-0.5883275867,
0.6965050697,
-0.6467213035,
-0.3391952515,
0.4030285478,
0.3100518286,
0.0433101766,
-0.3159136176,
-0.5872296095,
-0.3905464709,
-0.2093646824,
-0.3234813213,
0.3885164857,
0.5665516853,
-0.2375334799,
0.2738870382,
0.5469828844,
-0.0268945266,
0.0828705654,
0.1609305143,
0.7005884647,
-0.4943994284,
-0.3288720846,
-0.6210650802,
0.6488888264,
-0.1614247411,
-0.3536532819,
0.5857849717,
0.5685583949,
1.1113613844,
-0.1898855865,
0.7462854981,
0.1840814352,
-0.1048106998,
-0.6036186814,
0.9823462367,
-0.5815932751,
-0.1082382873,
0.1624412984,
-0.8826159239,
-0.5468478203,
0.1665739864,
-0.4266717732,
-0.217883572,
1.0885455608,
0.3587324917,
-0.5035162568,
-0.2666571438,
0.5335714817,
0.0753122494,
0.2898590565,
0.6361377835,
0.5916912556,
-0.5260957479,
0.6868320107,
-0.2647531927,
-0.2703076005,
-0.0939661562,
-0.9181956053,
-1.0752105713,
-0.6658350825,
-0.1252807528,
-0.2889315486,
-0.1126355007,
0.5819893479,
0.8201621771,
-0.7241261005,
-0.0360572003,
-0.1408371478,
0.0814628527,
-0.4367173612,
-0.1702001244,
0.5140863657,
-0.6148124933,
-0.8904127479,
0.6049007773,
0.3095457256,
0.0257432442,
0.0318488926,
0.1177070588,
-0.3696310222,
0.0518950932,
0.4948749542,
0.1226624623,
-0.433726728,
0.1379166991,
0.0877460614,
-0.3462048173,
0.3021991849,
0.7026862502,
-0.4072191119,
0.3856407702,
0.4287715256,
0.8128330708,
0.8580960631,
0.1409246027,
0.8284243941,
-0.991034925,
0.3434107602,
0.0615607798,
0.286506474,
0.48777619,
-0.686399281,
0.5006126165,
-0.0081697023,
-0.2160366029,
-0.4614034891,
0.1091153696,
-0.9938951731,
-0.4094903171,
1.0241327286,
-0.2935902774,
-0.371851325,
0.0843382329,
-0.0811088532,
0.6124889255,
-0.377953589,
0.8364841938,
0.6854782104,
0.18087928,
-0.0806618258,
-0.4758639634,
0.463419646,
0.5539978743,
-0.9494060874,
-0.2825229764,
0.3679643273,
0.2281251401,
0.3960336447,
0.4599758685,
-0.1946669221,
0.242923677,
-0.3160732388,
0.1376491934,
-0.3089969158,
-0.1859672517,
-0.6522823572,
0.4059883058,
-0.4088123441,
-0.3664489686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08068v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08068v2 | LabelPrompt: Effective Prompt-based Learning for Relation Classification | 2023-02-16T04:06:25 | 2023-08-13T03:04:08 | Wenjie Zhang, Xiaoning Song, Zhenhua Feng, Tianyang Xu, Xiaojun Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recently, prompt-based learning has gained popularity across many natural
language processing (NLP) tasks by reformulating them into a cloze-style format
to better align pre-trained language models (PLMs) with downstream tasks.
However, applying this approach to relation classification poses unique
challenges. Specifically, associating natural language words that fill the
masked token with semantic relation labels (\textit{e.g.}
\textit{``org:founded\_by}'') is difficult. To address this challenge, this
paper presents a novel prompt-based learning method, namely LabelPrompt, for
the relation classification task. Motivated by the intuition to ``GIVE MODEL
CHOICES!'', we first define additional tokens to represent relation labels,
which regard these tokens as the verbaliser with semantic initialisation and
explicitly construct them with a prompt template method. Then, to mitigate
inconsistency between predicted relations and given entities, we implement an
entity-aware module with contrastive learning. Last, we conduct an attention
query strategy within the self-attention layer to differentiates prompt tokens
and sequence tokens. Together, these strategies enhance the adaptability of
prompt-based learning, especially when only small labelled datasets is
available. Comprehensive experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate the
superiority of our method, particularly in the few-shot scenario. | [
-0.4797791243,
-0.5207012296,
0.4086042643,
0.2348245084,
-0.4266554415,
-0.2723808885,
0.0955903903,
-0.3268059492,
0.1222649664,
0.4249245524,
-0.8762029409,
-0.5508196354,
-0.3359008431,
0.453538835,
0.3003863394,
1.174036622,
0.16868864,
-0.0681729019,
-0.5246235728,
-0.459890455,
-0.824886024,
-0.6181303859,
-0.9246526957,
-0.2528185546,
0.7737894058,
0.361540705,
0.5238267183,
0.4830069542,
0.1877958924,
0.2160247266,
-0.1568388045,
0.3745942712,
-0.1345437765,
0.52229321,
-0.3169417381,
-0.3677725196,
-0.0233989023,
0.068083629,
0.3027705252,
0.8937791586,
0.1525623798,
0.1081506908,
0.1649685949,
0.3964719176,
-0.6802986264,
0.5839186907,
-0.5076307654,
-0.0211569369,
-0.0045161457,
-0.0153627945,
-0.6131364107,
0.0453693047,
0.1149037331,
-0.8383849859,
0.1818294525,
0.354855448,
0.861508131,
0.3081084192,
-0.4994845986,
-0.4013440013,
-0.2110528648,
0.5290204883,
-0.3493561745,
0.6227374077,
0.4040973186,
0.2141716629,
-0.2448911667,
-0.8618162274,
-0.3454462886,
-0.25012815,
-0.4156981409,
0.1196777225,
0.0431074314,
0.0013280245,
0.5323987603,
0.0585350469,
-0.6107234359,
0.1586758643,
0.0916649923,
-0.3500581384,
0.0590512156,
0.1823540479,
0.3142884374,
-0.4191234112,
-0.8065251708,
0.1373713762,
-0.5220502615,
0.182989046,
0.0365089551,
0.6015006304,
0.039294295,
0.2603020072,
-0.069361411,
0.9127546549,
0.3097733855,
0.0304958876,
0.1947184056,
-0.0921335369,
-0.066151306,
0.2724297047,
0.9439595342,
0.2362795323,
0.1990051866,
-0.1590037197,
-0.1020280197,
0.3077446818,
-0.025866067,
-0.7759343982,
-0.5128686428,
0.0681452975,
-0.0696665347,
0.013646503,
-0.155499354,
-0.5146984458,
-0.3713169992,
-0.4279421866,
0.314676553,
-0.5537708998,
-0.0196836889,
-0.30816558,
0.136428684,
0.089740999,
0.265162915,
-0.8364351392,
0.4610651433,
0.5711277127,
0.7364250422,
-0.22649239,
-0.1847804189,
-1.2091556787,
0.0134770013,
-0.2107828856,
0.8351546526,
-0.4020579755,
-0.3820153177,
-0.0685769394,
-0.0949110687,
-0.1269112676,
-0.7049809694,
0.4681352079,
-0.6564183831,
0.5032365918,
-0.2378649861,
-0.8900027871,
0.1338395625,
0.39973557,
-0.6337599158,
0.960609138,
0.2418532968,
-0.9812473655,
0.2627967,
-0.3360631764,
-0.3414418995,
0.2590272725,
-0.2609257102,
-0.4909823537,
-0.3869975209,
0.2754918039,
0.5797460079,
-0.104417108,
0.4486438036,
-0.2017656565,
0.1368542165,
0.3133148253,
0.1887349635,
0.8147496581,
0.2332269549,
0.0787099227,
0.2618908882,
-0.8112630844,
-0.358156532,
-0.1047623083,
0.1903627962,
-0.7372361422,
-0.513874352,
-0.4579615593,
0.4556084573,
0.0216112658,
-0.3007519841,
0.1903017759,
-0.5589706898,
-0.0173459481,
0.5212873816,
0.4647053778,
0.5995378494,
-0.0294094831,
0.610461235,
0.3751540184,
0.0995495617,
-0.6689221859,
-0.6135066152,
-0.5149760842,
-0.3321009874,
0.4873321056,
0.5639858246,
-1.1050592661,
0.5727342367,
0.0018332816,
-0.2963078618,
-0.2557718456,
0.258908093,
0.6741187572,
1.218378067,
0.5154780746,
-0.335963726,
-0.3597010076,
-0.6886544228,
-0.2171745747,
-0.2362690717,
-0.1178575084,
0.3657299876,
0.2499978095,
-0.0900337473,
1.0835614204,
-0.7798154354,
-0.5184255838,
-0.1162727103,
0.3572411239,
0.3413082957,
0.3836785257,
0.4880002141,
-0.7657468319,
-0.4606010318,
-0.4071353078,
-0.639873147,
-0.2776531577,
-0.1685220301,
-0.1624909192,
-0.1009320766,
0.5973172188,
-0.8298496604,
-0.0268952381,
-0.1015178561,
-0.5279242992,
0.6199653745,
0.0482351147,
-0.3701844513,
-1.0400865078,
-0.133242324,
0.2667315602,
-0.4438560009,
-0.604513526,
-0.0984015688,
0.1790951341,
-0.2256114483,
-0.6317620277,
0.9288743734,
-0.4922845066,
0.1969844401,
-0.0956735834,
0.1377251893,
0.0895666927,
0.7036703229,
0.1191783845,
0.614669919,
0.6419701576,
-1.104085803,
0.4682343006,
0.7647470236,
0.0853431523,
0.8770487905,
-0.1999740899,
0.1799345315,
-0.2440275699,
0.2840395272,
-0.8654026389,
-0.0187134184,
0.8118590117,
-0.5770559907,
0.5552674532,
-0.0773784965,
-0.3450107872,
-0.0828628689,
-0.1802573353,
0.3140327632,
0.310231179,
-0.8236107826,
0.6137092113,
-0.0111275101,
-0.3558101952,
-0.6168500781,
-0.2423442155,
0.0117248585,
-0.255528748,
-0.0839794427,
0.3838813305,
-0.0304476153,
-0.034555573,
0.1887280047,
-0.2507324517,
-0.135251537,
0.0353668183,
0.271997869,
0.2802165151,
-0.0109918453,
0.6493416429,
-0.1648962647,
-0.3642958105,
0.2295537591,
-0.2388714999,
0.4191136658,
0.1331312656,
0.1860326976,
-0.3585595787,
0.1302786171,
0.1140437648,
-0.2948695421,
0.760613203,
0.4449511468,
-0.3799488544,
-0.4821696281,
-0.202909857,
-0.4076952934,
-0.4328663945,
-0.0135082155,
-0.5841507912,
-0.6588671803,
0.6023198962,
-0.2470945865,
-0.253331244,
0.3309290409,
0.0148397526,
0.0174964573,
0.4641473591,
0.5418974757,
-0.0304418895,
0.4276090264,
-0.0104072783,
0.1141185388,
-0.8021566868,
-0.4899616838,
-0.4392521977,
0.0280911345,
-0.4061098397,
-0.1375018358,
0.145929724,
0.2372755855,
-0.2913892269,
0.4577802718,
-0.3521012366,
0.1659608483,
0.5490109324,
0.2645175755,
0.2233172208,
-0.2889903486,
-0.3872203529,
-0.3373707831,
-0.8498153687,
-0.1518234164,
0.5110625625,
0.0037183547,
0.3941344321,
-0.2314293385,
0.9645853639,
0.0490538366,
0.5176836848,
-1.022978425,
0.5991793871,
0.0771550909,
-0.2908312976,
-0.1435452551,
-0.6662015915,
-1.1358505487,
0.021230692,
-0.1443389654,
-0.6162685156,
0.2851951122,
0.3610114455,
-0.3567162454,
-0.1453155577,
-0.6070479155,
1.1559066772,
-0.2371131331,
-0.4515384436,
0.4798092246,
-0.9934377074,
0.283193469,
0.0244198125,
0.1987910122,
-0.1183513403,
-0.2508117557,
0.81487149,
-0.3807326555,
0.7700773478,
-0.2708192766,
0.0640914515,
0.2703415155,
0.1383042037,
0.488283515,
0.1584762037,
0.1737139225,
-0.4668519199,
-0.3485968411,
-0.2540358603,
-1.0324577093,
0.5753231049,
-0.3653708398,
-0.4427552223,
-0.4892836809,
-0.3283442855,
-0.6246688366,
0.2251223475,
0.3491822779,
0.6609563231,
-0.1114847064,
-0.3237903714,
0.8075089455,
-0.2614125013,
0.2864491343,
0.4106819332,
-0.4646227062,
-0.4844690263,
1.0008761883,
-0.008058683,
-0.0253813192,
0.582370162,
0.2512675822,
-0.7091935277,
-0.0367074832,
-0.1612407267,
0.3889144063,
-0.8080916405,
-0.6426631808,
-0.7304199934,
-0.0235366132,
-0.4166744947,
0.2334161252,
-0.0142882029,
-0.2516188622,
-0.6883683205,
-0.130996272,
0.4605874121,
0.2253845334,
0.223222211,
0.2595814764,
-0.807002008,
0.7097104192,
0.5172215104,
0.2877036035,
-0.237537235,
-0.4350210726,
0.2159763277,
-0.5295346975,
-0.2856478393,
-1.2565883398,
0.3776899874,
0.2587911487,
0.5578620434,
0.4600327909,
0.7008371353,
0.2608341277,
-0.4377956986,
0.6559669971,
0.526154995,
-0.780431807,
0.776963532,
-0.1625831127,
0.3363075554,
0.5658766031,
0.7998600006,
-0.513323307,
-0.2100109905,
-1.012447238,
-0.9079749584,
0.5725446343,
0.1750650555,
-0.0961150825,
-0.3526643217,
0.5618643761,
0.2002998441,
0.3548438251,
-0.6575812101,
-0.6529316306,
-0.1047507077,
-0.4602301419,
-0.0401135795,
-0.3151887357,
0.2604671419,
-0.2244603932,
0.6438108683,
-0.1332892627,
0.1156724244,
0.334518075,
-0.261431694,
0.3436268568,
0.4241639078,
0.1154873148,
0.5028184652,
-0.1484411657,
0.4090830684,
0.0765283331,
-0.012737277,
0.2957809269,
0.3287953734,
-0.2635610402,
0.4200578034,
0.3311407864,
0.9833704829,
0.4469535351,
-0.3917404115,
0.5653417706,
0.0593223646,
0.0468479358,
0.1337011158,
-0.0366265178,
0.1412759572,
-0.0408143997,
0.1558350474,
-0.130618915,
0.2412551641,
-0.5084766746,
0.4593717754,
0.2747398317,
-0.6340517402,
-0.1770987362,
0.6486164927,
0.328602463,
-0.4701339006,
0.610491991,
-0.7240209579,
-0.6715655923,
0.349875927,
0.5961716175,
0.7830958962,
-0.5543704033,
0.3991911113,
0.4909825623,
-0.0825046226,
0.0845513493,
-0.0242406577,
-0.3405565619,
-0.7722087502,
-0.2669930458,
-0.498260498,
-0.5495105386,
0.2119736224,
-0.8008822799,
0.3635191321,
-0.4573577046,
-0.1391776055,
0.0998951569,
-0.0976959914,
-0.6820110679,
0.3416989148,
0.0094940048,
0.9195898175,
-0.960834384,
0.5719854236,
0.9458963275,
-0.4159666896,
-0.8465474248,
-0.1135357395,
-0.3374975026,
-0.3024515808,
0.8438745737,
0.654163897,
0.1086537093,
0.2083216012,
-0.4338317513,
-0.3230490685,
0.5439474583,
0.450760603,
-0.520201683,
-0.0010116773,
-0.2424098551,
0.4245830178,
-0.4002040327,
0.0859730989,
0.3828098774,
0.2570692599,
0.0465154015,
-0.5674527884,
0.2479460239,
-0.1571613252,
-0.1278693378,
0.3331625462,
-0.3095594943,
0.3673164845,
-0.1086946949,
-0.3116236627,
-0.1706618071,
0.9456706643,
0.3039697111,
0.6522467136,
0.7338661551,
0.4362110496,
0.9193301797,
0.0303113814,
0.8617238998,
-0.1383805871,
0.2115896791,
1.5231127739,
-0.375397265,
0.5865841508,
0.4740625322,
-0.1479651034,
0.5483371019,
0.7577545643,
-0.0241667628,
0.6388631463,
0.1070280746,
-0.339227885,
-0.3548488021,
-0.595636189,
-0.0728428662,
0.0536909848,
0.4033618569,
-0.223930493,
-0.2991443574,
0.2453423887,
-0.0270604026,
0.4445258379,
-0.4450178444,
1.0550495386,
0.4318882525,
-0.7638338208,
0.3287704587,
-0.4806923866,
0.5329717994,
-0.5667219162,
-0.1103177443,
-0.1831500828,
-0.0426120684,
-0.1095584407,
-0.5677019358,
-0.0313386321,
-0.2319547236,
-0.1625664234,
-0.0825397149,
0.8120897412,
-0.5367766023,
-0.2105250806,
0.3063138127,
0.5678869486,
-0.1033167839,
-0.167274192,
-0.6500756741,
-0.3835660517,
-0.3172749281,
-0.1646547765,
0.3221609294,
0.5416188836,
0.0094325338,
0.7384007573,
0.2913663089,
-0.0287378971,
-0.1719478369,
-0.0452750586,
0.8078656793,
-0.647002995,
-0.8848941922,
-0.7725728154,
0.3453172445,
-0.1120929942,
-0.4269517064,
0.6505051255,
0.5197206736,
0.6418043375,
-0.2632916868,
0.375569582,
0.3961192071,
0.6370719075,
-0.6110464334,
0.0758664533,
-0.0686348975,
0.1280469745,
-0.1659283191,
-0.83550632,
-0.6166360974,
0.3017969429,
-0.2847614288,
-0.169498384,
0.8990626931,
0.5192633867,
0.0466664992,
-0.3307763338,
0.2226856798,
0.0357973762,
0.0850948095,
0.6109487414,
0.8733420372,
-0.2408500314,
0.5966562629,
-0.3470651805,
-0.0517863184,
-0.0422670916,
-0.941729188,
-1.026655674,
-0.6667913198,
-0.7219743729,
-0.2971204817,
0.1096743494,
1.1808757782,
0.3703647256,
-0.7804887891,
0.2778748572,
-0.1806726158,
0.2393247038,
-0.1948045641,
-0.2687505782,
0.4566504955,
-0.7709294558,
-0.4493222237,
0.1679193377,
0.1246213242,
0.1139755473,
0.2070668638,
-0.0726720989,
-0.2507507801,
-0.3380836248,
0.4807363451,
0.4110693336,
-0.5134366751,
0.0232282821,
-0.0705426559,
-0.1464024186,
0.1466480941,
0.8386369944,
-1.2352480888,
0.475739032,
0.3030085266,
0.7154003978,
0.4031420052,
0.2115283161,
0.4826686978,
-1.2803800106,
0.1817011237,
0.4038786888,
0.2835388184,
0.6327473521,
-0.6101767421,
0.4003886878,
0.3768179417,
-0.2674944699,
-0.7016837597,
0.5474781394,
-1.05884552,
-0.2949128151,
0.9633184671,
-0.3773687184,
-0.1794449836,
-0.30557549,
-0.3871895969,
0.6065317988,
-0.4829320014,
0.5060402155,
0.3165255785,
-0.3056845665,
-0.408362031,
-0.2090874463,
0.7879872918,
0.3983235359,
-0.7233380675,
0.002159127,
0.4874947071,
0.1354635954,
0.3635995686,
0.3938625455,
0.3695302904,
0.2834659517,
-0.2513798773,
-0.1891846806,
-0.3819964528,
-0.3931594491,
-0.3200863898,
0.250238508,
0.1536411792,
-0.4287690222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.10315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.10315v1 | Generalization algorithm of multimodal pre-training model based on graph-text self-supervised training | 2023-02-16T03:34:08 | 2023-02-16T03:34:08 | Zhangxiaobing, Tangzhenhao, Longzi, Fuxianghua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, a large number of studies have shown that the introduction of
visual information can effectively improve the effect of neural machine
translation (NMT). Its effectiveness largely depends on the availability of a
large number of bilingual parallel sentence pairs and manual image annotation.
The lack of images and the effectiveness of images have been difficult to
solve. In this paper, a multimodal pre-training generalization algorithm for
self-supervised training is proposed, which overcomes the lack of visual
information and inaccuracy, and thus extends the applicability of images on
NMT. Specifically, we will search for many pictures from the existing sentences
through the search engine, and then through the relationship between visual
information and text, do the self-supervised training task of graphics and text
to obtain more effective visual information for text. We show that when the
filtered information is used as multimodal machine translation for fine-tuning,
the effect of translation in the global voice dataset is 0.5 BLEU higher than
the baseline. | [
-0.4285800159,
-0.7637906075,
0.6393553615,
0.1751879901,
-0.5951859355,
-0.1702997833,
-0.3022758663,
-0.0785488039,
0.3907623887,
0.5570219755,
-0.8258599043,
-0.6837838292,
-0.9398159981,
0.1737851799,
-0.1473736614,
0.9603103995,
-0.0229551531,
0.198126778,
-0.0846479163,
-0.12257649,
-0.6008591056,
-0.3903043866,
-0.2681319118,
-0.0981197283,
0.7047278881,
0.1826136112,
0.4965049326,
0.7014821768,
0.5860379934,
0.5053724051,
0.3265045583,
0.4156001806,
-0.3716049194,
-0.1111477539,
0.0524864867,
-0.4416156709,
-0.4056981206,
-0.0140499901,
0.7337306738,
0.146461755,
0.1394513696,
0.0795718208,
-0.0404809564,
0.4703027606,
-0.382073611,
0.4717907012,
-0.491232425,
0.1224955395,
-0.1189641133,
-0.6780496836,
-0.3174063861,
-0.1375691444,
0.0019164633,
-0.8268464804,
0.2590836585,
0.0055792793,
0.7234247327,
0.2969942391,
-0.8606358171,
-0.2708046138,
-0.4498752654,
0.8241219521,
-0.5515299439,
0.2701888084,
0.2787733078,
0.3104456067,
-0.1456265002,
-0.7277079225,
-0.559445858,
-0.1689859778,
-0.303235054,
0.2687354684,
-0.0193756595,
0.4007367194,
0.1081289798,
0.1578791291,
-0.6204500198,
-0.2138933241,
-0.4276953936,
-0.2777953744,
0.2907339633,
-0.0934879854,
0.7070932388,
-0.2870543897,
-0.4981087148,
-0.2462276518,
-0.1630821079,
-0.140215978,
0.1793565005,
0.2336583436,
-0.1822026223,
0.5871207714,
-0.2878705561,
0.7164725661,
-0.2296960801,
-0.13184838,
0.6341410875,
-0.6948801279,
-0.090332441,
-0.1917322427,
1.0135082006,
0.5401434898,
0.6506788731,
-0.188450411,
-0.0823559985,
0.0527034923,
0.1475804746,
-0.9818686247,
-0.0189451985,
-0.2536049187,
-0.5913036466,
-0.1093020737,
-0.0536239445,
-0.6500048041,
0.2024908066,
-0.5572410822,
0.5171850324,
-0.3527698219,
-0.2297104299,
-0.1227363199,
-0.0259894058,
-0.212279439,
0.2403239906,
-0.8911558986,
0.0590949506,
0.0476448163,
1.0225348473,
0.0506573506,
-0.5238200426,
-0.4936060905,
0.2299882025,
-0.2303609103,
0.6716963053,
-0.3722373545,
-0.0649171472,
-0.2303274572,
0.131528452,
-0.4886598587,
-0.1471545398,
0.4026051164,
-0.426923871,
0.3347825408,
0.0897201747,
-0.2943718135,
-0.3903098106,
0.3643938303,
-0.5786106586,
0.4187693894,
-0.0890966207,
-0.6999095678,
0.1235466003,
-0.7705328465,
-0.3800973594,
-0.1715665609,
-0.2912360132,
-0.4522611797,
-0.033946529,
0.8436979055,
0.6774330735,
-0.1051762477,
0.4076458812,
-0.3120818138,
-0.4046292603,
-0.1237938553,
-0.3069525957,
0.5719509721,
0.1872628629,
-0.3164057732,
0.2731846273,
-0.4679916799,
0.3594083786,
0.2151577771,
-0.2105502933,
-0.2606910467,
-0.2610414922,
0.1883505881,
0.3770136237,
0.3085992932,
-0.3921204805,
0.2481189668,
-0.3800850213,
0.5095278025,
0.7158962488,
-0.1263961941,
0.5755375624,
0.0747210309,
0.5396483541,
0.0913499221,
0.3142817914,
-0.6755219698,
-0.5410480499,
-0.6572905183,
-0.369122088,
0.4267024398,
0.6442295909,
-1.0318697691,
0.2866960466,
-0.3951271176,
-0.192486614,
-0.5425753593,
0.5483993292,
0.7088432312,
0.5592988729,
0.6969809532,
-0.2950710058,
-0.5436848402,
-1.1584357023,
-0.1047990844,
0.3330519795,
0.1230533347,
0.2306640148,
0.4714973271,
-0.6429582834,
0.7236673236,
-0.4733464122,
-0.7207693458,
-0.001538688,
0.513854444,
0.2854026556,
0.5576950908,
0.6487271786,
-1.0202480555,
-0.5502188802,
0.1248619407,
-0.934250474,
0.0359958224,
0.0205697156,
0.0239547752,
-0.0748320371,
0.5238575935,
-0.4372678399,
0.3930453062,
0.7701554894,
0.123392731,
0.1330735385,
-0.5530241728,
0.3302172124,
-1.218326807,
-0.1537347436,
0.1487025917,
-0.3559261858,
-0.5467325449,
-0.0615344904,
0.3433657885,
-0.2137607187,
-0.1249591783,
0.4643743336,
-0.7395367622,
0.2263511419,
-0.324388653,
0.1757553816,
-0.1936601251,
0.774115026,
-0.0110665904,
0.7351464629,
0.5904588699,
-0.4081052542,
0.4342134297,
0.1331386715,
-0.148572877,
0.524087429,
-0.4696079195,
0.3259352446,
-0.5564945936,
0.3364049792,
-1.1565303802,
-0.1160457209,
0.3024609685,
-0.3451055586,
0.2628217936,
-0.2578105032,
-0.418949306,
-0.374425292,
0.1162692755,
0.4202244878,
0.0726909488,
-0.4435040951,
0.7467381954,
0.0321106687,
-0.2955364883,
-0.6989116669,
-0.5460559726,
0.2149713784,
0.0722251162,
-0.7120626569,
0.3502453268,
-0.1602836996,
0.5700790286,
-0.1331268102,
0.1178974137,
-0.3399964571,
-0.2984310687,
0.0730532035,
0.0807310566,
-0.1399361789,
0.4058041573,
0.194148317,
-0.3288557231,
-0.2234957516,
-0.291644305,
0.664526999,
-0.3574203551,
-0.1864721626,
-0.7464470863,
0.353900224,
0.2780481279,
-0.3923667669,
0.2580506802,
1.0398089886,
-0.0523565114,
0.1214802042,
-0.5350452065,
-0.13307634,
-0.521758914,
0.711641252,
-0.5621328354,
-0.7234576344,
0.1276424378,
-0.2101285458,
-0.4575611651,
0.5146890283,
0.3649828434,
-0.2474462688,
1.3005324602,
0.5990130305,
0.007428796,
0.6843599081,
-0.360545516,
-0.0186154768,
-0.5824787617,
-0.2309194356,
-0.1439392418,
-0.4458358884,
-0.6332195997,
-0.3700575531,
0.3397393823,
0.0699177235,
0.0854420587,
0.4083093405,
-0.6811706424,
0.4118760824,
0.7479762435,
0.4608416557,
0.2706246078,
0.2497656047,
-0.4280587137,
-0.2229906321,
-0.4930908978,
-0.1338403225,
1.1345473528,
0.0688253418,
0.6932022572,
-0.0998926461,
0.8265753984,
0.1805013865,
0.3083327413,
-0.4918352962,
0.4415932894,
-0.3637906611,
-0.5085033178,
-0.3495890498,
-0.7183843255,
-0.8415367603,
0.3648478985,
-0.4228253961,
-0.3161096573,
0.0188370775,
0.3385370374,
0.2067716271,
-0.0551218092,
-1.0832623243,
1.049736619,
-0.628428936,
0.124433957,
-0.2825227678,
-0.8217349052,
0.1836044639,
-0.2469843924,
0.3236467242,
-0.0219506752,
0.1250258833,
0.5491660833,
-0.1196042821,
0.9139684439,
-0.3279744089,
0.3123304546,
0.0485249199,
-0.4111738503,
0.4614826739,
-0.1746176481,
0.4339396358,
0.1817739755,
-0.1343470812,
-0.4968782663,
-0.8529331088,
0.4020860493,
-0.7539835572,
-0.39603284,
-0.0648005456,
-0.588979125,
-0.1845438331,
0.6668368578,
0.5739748478,
0.2710005939,
-0.129214108,
0.3003559411,
0.340577215,
-0.0591975972,
0.4022295475,
0.059268944,
-0.3596605957,
-0.859138608,
0.9455962181,
0.2644445002,
0.1030877456,
0.5606542826,
0.2676981986,
-0.4906446338,
-0.5226305127,
-0.5359587073,
0.2414173037,
-0.7065363526,
-0.164890632,
-0.7825843692,
-0.0706532076,
-0.5761810541,
0.0510886423,
-0.1399294287,
-0.2057712823,
-0.2461476922,
0.2501419783,
0.1088974476,
0.5861411691,
0.2234703302,
0.8042357564,
-0.6025576591,
0.5763605833,
0.6023778319,
0.2851643562,
-0.3074864149,
-0.3737852573,
-0.2252774984,
0.2890952826,
-0.4166919291,
-0.7535730004,
0.3572945297,
0.4178116918,
0.685937047,
0.3960282803,
-0.3996468782,
0.9446166754,
-0.5905438662,
0.0339585394,
0.7085390091,
-0.8252736926,
0.6329042912,
-0.4619110525,
0.4486028254,
0.337803483,
0.3131072223,
-0.3413434625,
-0.0497051403,
-0.2892246842,
-0.533944726,
0.494730413,
0.3390091956,
0.4387063682,
0.1075920388,
0.2096766829,
-0.3033704162,
0.3583925962,
-1.0075656176,
-0.1822102815,
-0.714820683,
-0.5034986734,
-0.548181057,
-0.1433194578,
0.0356774367,
-0.3806726933,
0.3622567356,
-0.5300266147,
0.3405889571,
0.1961924136,
-0.3726755977,
0.2721518278,
0.3247742653,
0.6529702544,
0.2262095213,
-0.1769167334,
0.027643552,
0.0937084556,
-0.4964042008,
0.3113745749,
0.2011992484,
-0.1263315082,
-0.0366657414,
0.2258564681,
1.0101066828,
0.1823081076,
-0.2984783351,
0.8828153014,
-0.1446629018,
-0.3678041697,
-0.0692523941,
-0.112774156,
0.0901468098,
0.2817645371,
0.2772900164,
0.2820076644,
0.2137771398,
-0.3725685775,
0.1904781163,
0.5345790386,
-0.3150569499,
-0.1147922948,
0.5503290892,
0.1941901892,
-0.1780809909,
0.6271179914,
0.0607358888,
-0.5016765594,
0.5837899446,
0.7693089843,
0.6953812838,
-0.3704792261,
0.3347801864,
0.2981759608,
0.4509037435,
-0.1387010813,
0.0910954177,
-0.0513859726,
-0.5418092608,
-0.7288241386,
-0.3365077078,
-0.0801697448,
-0.1365682632,
-0.2215143591,
0.2684555948,
-0.3312044442,
-0.4147250354,
0.0751988888,
-0.2452774346,
-0.8216519356,
0.6427090168,
-0.0359538049,
0.1983667761,
-0.6265578866,
1.0010521412,
0.6157505512,
-0.5161696672,
-0.4518325329,
-0.3274751306,
-0.253020972,
-0.9228835702,
1.0257778168,
0.456874609,
-0.2326308042,
0.3035632074,
-0.5888682008,
-0.8234760761,
0.9709561467,
0.7556402683,
-0.6023951769,
-0.2427594066,
0.1806436777,
0.475109458,
-0.569632113,
0.3026680052,
-0.1848669499,
0.6338742375,
0.0186100714,
-0.9481081963,
-0.1689368933,
-0.5754076242,
0.2197941542,
0.0804511458,
-0.5637800694,
0.9289439917,
-0.1711509675,
-0.1915221214,
-0.1000727192,
0.502558589,
-0.3050996065,
0.1817825884,
0.599856019,
0.380671382,
0.5020065904,
0.0467489883,
0.8497285247,
-0.0922704786,
0.5288151503,
1.3113133907,
0.3627787828,
0.406131655,
0.3876160681,
0.2155393511,
0.3997959793,
0.4014781713,
-0.3204992115,
0.6599020958,
0.0100240475,
0.0343701318,
-0.3396355212,
0.1428068131,
-0.3915372193,
0.6228466034,
0.05920754,
-0.8828181028,
-0.4043742418,
0.2922426164,
-0.1793678701,
0.0446899086,
-0.2867095768,
0.6759881377,
0.0136594754,
-0.4722959101,
0.7653350234,
0.0430340506,
0.7837975025,
-0.5204821825,
-0.0223777406,
0.0864052698,
0.1136003211,
-0.1538381428,
-0.4017297924,
-0.0247336123,
-0.4343276322,
-0.2342145145,
-0.4089325368,
0.8661336303,
-0.5374362469,
-0.5931630135,
0.5346007943,
0.6226316094,
0.0655829161,
-0.4821069837,
-0.7118460536,
-0.3888132572,
0.0270423144,
-0.2011048645,
0.2551344931,
0.3274794519,
-0.0053002001,
0.5764498711,
0.7071679831,
-0.0670514777,
0.2521500885,
0.00276376,
0.8565728664,
-0.6522043347,
-0.481674552,
-0.8141745925,
0.2360909134,
-0.1840694696,
-0.3098768294,
0.5957642794,
0.4325139821,
0.7872567773,
-0.343249321,
0.7637206912,
0.245969817,
0.2336217612,
-0.7522596121,
0.7618371844,
-0.745287776,
-0.5119856,
-0.4995062351,
-1.0860534906,
-0.4919538498,
0.790556848,
-0.4074358344,
0.2405737489,
0.7286366224,
0.7694672942,
-0.3295746446,
-0.1678214967,
0.5064096451,
-0.0154803069,
0.0701660141,
0.3054299951,
0.4081054032,
-0.5545019507,
0.8788709641,
-0.2538944483,
-0.2050525546,
-0.109793216,
-0.955606401,
-1.1723099947,
-0.7311633229,
0.0515845865,
0.0065461779,
0.1028759703,
0.6528232098,
1.0270415545,
-0.4684423208,
-0.0202932935,
-0.0299545247,
-0.1201232821,
-0.14796637,
-0.0434545502,
0.4082317352,
-0.6582759023,
-0.8959748149,
0.3305639625,
0.2473371774,
0.330940634,
-0.1419918835,
-0.1699239016,
-0.3294987679,
-0.2477547973,
0.5959941149,
-0.032543309,
-0.5541803241,
-0.0209574476,
-0.0328609124,
-0.0929401815,
0.4167197347,
0.7588150501,
-0.3964396119,
0.965520978,
0.2413797528,
0.4970234632,
0.9335948229,
0.0329043046,
0.483512193,
-0.9375146031,
0.35191679,
-0.1198583767,
0.3956996202,
0.2865964472,
-0.2107734829,
0.4795192778,
0.3448874056,
-0.4335466325,
-0.2886587679,
0.2428893745,
-0.9499145746,
-0.1486717761,
0.7970206738,
-0.1367366612,
-0.2486026585,
0.0669054091,
-0.5300710201,
0.4245735109,
-0.3121801019,
0.6621693373,
0.7071970701,
0.1782225668,
-0.6518224478,
-0.608495295,
0.1769124866,
0.2934852839,
-0.7857559323,
-0.475725174,
0.4247246385,
0.2846591175,
0.3773664236,
0.9155141711,
0.0405366123,
0.0943829268,
-0.2251196057,
0.3491248786,
-0.2948641181,
-0.3687289059,
-0.1142852977,
0.0916219875,
-0.3061606586,
-0.2809458971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.08043v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.08043v3 | GraphPrompt: Unifying Pre-Training and Downstream Tasks for Graph Neural Networks | 2023-02-16T02:51:38 | 2023-02-25T03:00:10 | Zemin Liu, Xingtong Yu, Yuan Fang, Xinming Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Graphs can model complex relationships between objects, enabling a myriad of
Web applications such as online page/article classification and social
recommendation. While graph neural networks(GNNs) have emerged as a powerful
tool for graph representation learning, in an end-to-end supervised setting,
their performance heavily rely on a large amount of task-specific supervision.
To reduce labeling requirement, the "pre-train, fine-tune" and "pre-train,
prompt" paradigms have become increasingly common. In particular, prompting is
a popular alternative to fine-tuning in natural language processing, which is
designed to narrow the gap between pre-training and downstream objectives in a
task-specific manner. However, existing study of prompting on graphs is still
limited, lacking a universal treatment to appeal to different downstream tasks.
In this paper, we propose GraphPrompt, a novel pre-training and prompting
framework on graphs. GraphPrompt not only unifies pre-training and downstream
tasks into a common task template, but also employs a learnable prompt to
assist a downstream task in locating the most relevant knowledge from the
pre-train model in a task-specific manner. Finally, we conduct extensive
experiments on five public datasets to evaluate and analyze GraphPrompt. | [
-0.5967717171,
-0.7715581656,
0.4022925496,
0.1927766502,
-0.6193099022,
-0.0683827251,
-0.2367913127,
-0.0875990391,
0.3510762453,
0.2284694463,
-0.9544086456,
-0.6163598895,
-0.7729227543,
0.1398338974,
-0.26712659,
1.1359788179,
-0.0880317464,
-0.1163917929,
-0.3427447379,
0.1164401919,
-0.6150811315,
-0.4099638462,
-0.9798749089,
-0.4214497805,
1.2305582762,
0.1490964442,
0.4301056862,
0.1226530001,
-0.0513149984,
0.2662608922,
0.2419210374,
0.4040396512,
-0.5565341711,
0.015304002,
-0.1631984264,
0.0448312834,
-0.1679312289,
0.2542609572,
0.2899599373,
1.152764678,
0.3344039321,
0.274800539,
0.7205922604,
0.4439861178,
-0.6528940797,
0.5006441474,
-0.2012012005,
-0.20872733,
-0.1581825763,
-0.1780884713,
-0.5046000481,
-0.3579414785,
0.0208274871,
-0.8783109188,
0.3623033166,
0.0013940494,
0.9475187063,
0.1755206287,
-0.4185238183,
0.032097131,
-0.2873731256,
0.0159074757,
-0.2027440369,
0.3314517438,
0.2271385193,
0.1199221015,
-0.1930252314,
-1.3319939375,
-0.3943160176,
-0.1899005771,
-0.3032821715,
0.2782250941,
-0.5053388476,
0.3223087788,
0.2352146953,
-0.2878066003,
-0.5026184916,
0.2290090173,
-0.1298306435,
-0.2907540798,
0.146018222,
0.0145435287,
0.2761004269,
0.0114128832,
-0.1873579323,
-0.0420803279,
-0.6054313183,
0.4164102674,
0.6222006679,
0.7776919603,
0.1108867526,
0.2010604888,
-0.4958923459,
1.2079594135,
0.1167171896,
0.7135572433,
0.0677336529,
-0.2201719433,
-0.1083270907,
0.0663052723,
1.0764960051,
0.3465901017,
0.7320221663,
-0.2708625197,
0.0254415721,
0.2481864095,
0.4015620351,
-0.7374266386,
-0.6793926954,
0.098710373,
-0.2637218237,
-0.2255057096,
-0.09067671,
-0.4074430466,
-0.3239253759,
-0.5407490134,
0.3569119573,
-0.2533072233,
-0.2363637537,
-0.0949148238,
-0.2875388265,
-0.4922896922,
0.3087752163,
-0.7529091239,
0.1381491274,
0.5453910828,
0.8862277269,
0.0166580137,
-0.591966331,
-0.9344550371,
-0.0915548503,
-0.2150577158,
0.9995558858,
-0.5302739739,
-0.2784328461,
-0.0781667605,
0.1769648194,
-0.4161440134,
-0.311126411,
0.1389145553,
-0.4393788278,
0.0305202175,
-0.3915992379,
-0.4056017697,
-0.1107296571,
0.396600455,
-0.6749725342,
0.7002784014,
0.3661907017,
-0.9418628216,
0.5701291561,
-0.662514329,
-0.6808381081,
0.2498203963,
-0.090280205,
-0.2169304639,
-0.1604734957,
0.4972734153,
0.7371073365,
0.0709357932,
0.3203148842,
-0.4016525745,
-0.3405880034,
-0.231742233,
-0.0174310487,
0.7408572435,
-0.1083375439,
-0.0790681913,
0.7073195577,
-0.2345353812,
0.1273132414,
-0.0152123747,
0.0479142144,
-0.2458327115,
-0.1884455979,
-0.3318159878,
0.0938322693,
0.1990161389,
-0.2768562138,
0.2812573016,
-0.1122886837,
0.6142994165,
0.8968780637,
0.1279624552,
0.1509242654,
-0.0258524008,
0.5583705902,
-0.1052327752,
0.2231057286,
-0.0935906991,
-0.6725335121,
-0.1851092577,
-0.2298264354,
0.3601509035,
0.4135149419,
-0.6627559066,
0.3267449737,
-0.2128160447,
-0.3241856098,
-0.0433310196,
0.2275466919,
0.3629994988,
0.9452974796,
0.340182215,
-0.347150892,
-0.4819583595,
-0.3204226792,
-0.3246664107,
-0.0113206832,
-0.0267216358,
0.1544706076,
0.1031227186,
-0.1660263836,
1.1030262709,
-0.6334336996,
-0.4978063405,
-0.4395654202,
0.4082434177,
0.3357965052,
0.275529623,
0.559253335,
-0.6078124046,
-0.5663055182,
-0.3184256554,
-0.6260121465,
-0.2379990816,
0.1572499275,
-0.1249330863,
-0.4289347231,
0.7949139476,
-0.7785155773,
0.4541549981,
0.3992316425,
-0.2585781515,
0.678575933,
-0.2197808027,
-0.0824057087,
-0.8193627,
0.1700609326,
0.0231314134,
-0.3355861306,
-0.4668520689,
-0.3546419442,
-0.2006884366,
-0.4229752421,
-0.1921924204,
0.475748986,
-0.4793922603,
0.1287290156,
-0.1810278296,
0.1874299794,
0.1512533426,
0.5633538365,
-0.1132508218,
0.6310787797,
0.8476835489,
-0.9932669401,
0.5189343095,
0.2132900953,
0.0261180233,
0.4357776344,
-0.7556294799,
0.2868362963,
-0.3597096801,
0.4182732999,
-1.1484818459,
-0.2660350204,
0.5146338344,
-0.5349485874,
0.2507315576,
-0.3226221204,
-0.4317902625,
-0.7465077043,
0.1247970834,
0.1195424572,
0.3020359278,
-0.5093887448,
0.4306425154,
-0.1279768497,
-0.082956709,
-0.4388723969,
-0.0179152563,
-0.021552531,
0.0105734048,
-0.2872219086,
0.2151956409,
0.2069390863,
0.3924970627,
0.3179019988,
0.0276613645,
0.0294574164,
0.1114883572,
0.5424633026,
0.1532142013,
0.0832523331,
0.0666862205,
0.0563591905,
-0.5651853085,
0.1351941228,
-0.9019082785,
0.8104761243,
0.2595982254,
-0.477510184,
-0.5538290739,
0.1460090429,
0.0641073883,
-0.4568717778,
0.3910854161,
0.7071710229,
-0.2154447883,
-0.1561995298,
0.1016561612,
-0.4116724133,
-0.5168327689,
0.3276689351,
-0.1664304137,
-0.7739682794,
0.3706507683,
-0.7256727219,
-0.1048533246,
0.0002944726,
0.1781423986,
-0.2471656501,
1.3434666395,
0.272016257,
-0.1935116798,
0.6722185016,
-0.338232398,
0.3762119412,
-0.6306166649,
-0.1989286393,
-0.3974698782,
-0.5686507821,
0.0387716778,
0.1316632777,
0.1868748665,
0.4525102675,
-0.4371503294,
0.3325685859,
-0.8038843274,
0.4170219004,
0.7191550732,
0.2391502112,
-0.2080142945,
0.0373389944,
-0.3480492532,
0.2831098139,
-0.730487287,
-0.2108809352,
0.6943250895,
-0.3736605644,
0.3851965964,
-0.5048041344,
0.8748904467,
0.3174842596,
0.3763166666,
-0.7718622088,
0.6321758032,
-0.4514604807,
-0.1518616676,
-0.3438698947,
-0.3884841502,
-1.5728023052,
-0.3097956777,
-0.0550176427,
-1.043771863,
-0.0734307766,
0.8225626349,
-0.5181844831,
0.1617258638,
-0.8372129798,
1.3005264997,
-0.0707795173,
-0.1031552777,
0.2279564142,
-0.544208765,
-0.1185006946,
0.3448197842,
0.0690437332,
-0.2245433033,
0.3895411491,
0.6523028612,
-0.3660719395,
1.1539722681,
-0.7499905229,
0.3419035673,
0.4242713749,
0.0838492066,
0.7886527777,
-0.0627593324,
0.2366912067,
-0.1192636266,
-0.4373455346,
-0.3378068209,
-0.7771199942,
0.3943934143,
-0.5730110407,
-0.5109575987,
0.0532492585,
-0.3804420233,
-0.5101984143,
0.6387999654,
0.8664859533,
0.6969071031,
0.0247376859,
-0.3160322309,
0.2877511382,
0.2430341989,
0.3116490245,
-0.1434545964,
-0.3600774109,
-0.1565329283,
1.0901074409,
0.1997323781,
-0.0018527313,
-0.0531884432,
0.1979387105,
-0.5362030864,
-0.5612091422,
-0.4531432986,
-0.114120543,
-0.7309701443,
-0.1276930422,
-0.6137111187,
-0.1639921814,
-0.7039262056,
-0.1702307761,
0.0237132553,
0.0620900467,
-0.7608554363,
-0.2324048579,
0.4591703713,
0.7798347473,
0.052456595,
0.5064362288,
-0.7338722348,
0.3527279794,
0.5232772231,
0.364418298,
0.1053604409,
-0.0012323936,
0.0230900496,
-0.0110572008,
-0.1176718697,
-0.9571553469,
0.1036532149,
0.2214603573,
0.7020216584,
0.5901458859,
0.458349824,
0.5310844183,
-0.4528304636,
0.6091673374,
0.6003071666,
-0.6680243611,
0.5911853909,
-0.3291772008,
0.1706573516,
0.6160529256,
0.7911641598,
-0.4617537856,
-0.2419156432,
-0.4735081494,
-0.9716091752,
0.4651970863,
-0.2300528884,
0.3521812856,
-0.096330598,
0.3434458971,
-0.0306434073,
0.2382795513,
-0.406928122,
-0.1072163582,
-0.7328810096,
-0.3582894206,
-0.1573358774,
0.315679878,
-0.1673581004,
-0.424975425,
0.1815598309,
-0.5822563767,
0.2260336876,
0.1020917967,
-0.1963633746,
0.2463023216,
-0.0856231526,
0.0223930255,
0.7442759275,
0.1182389781,
0.3684828877,
-0.0196322836,
-0.3550897241,
0.249808535,
0.3542292118,
-0.2059877068,
-0.0975048915,
0.6010788679,
1.1648504734,
0.1701008528,
-0.164106831,
0.5807042122,
-0.0389836095,
-0.2772842348,
0.1019987613,
0.2598040104,
0.3160696924,
0.049163159,
0.2950184643,
0.0367722549,
-0.0292388964,
-0.3271939754,
0.1772615016,
0.2702074349,
-0.8762431741,
-0.4157831967,
0.7770909071,
0.1148790568,
-0.4023101926,
0.9561927915,
-0.6060355902,
-0.6971408129,
0.4944776297,
0.5004057884,
0.6396599412,
0.1183065549,
0.5854567885,
0.3466819823,
-0.1698820889,
0.0686317682,
0.207940653,
-0.1485956609,
-0.6681413054,
-0.5117112994,
-0.2613947988,
-0.0670535415,
-0.0308328904,
-0.7392818928,
0.1849676371,
-0.5316621065,
-0.6007116437,
0.2331638634,
-0.2806373537,
-0.7040613294,
0.2365455627,
-0.0686944574,
0.6781260371,
-0.9281793833,
0.6448401213,
0.9660194516,
-0.4549929202,
-1.2034528255,
-0.0992636681,
-0.1517270356,
-0.6288215518,
0.7803096771,
0.5038824081,
-0.0850791484,
0.6910864711,
-0.7818419337,
-0.347409457,
0.7291658521,
0.8641940355,
-0.2935035229,
-0.3071186841,
-0.0107143177,
0.2580687106,
-0.2902867198,
0.0893966556,
0.2222619355,
0.4936229587,
0.0127975345,
-0.5880709887,
0.3182687163,
-0.3704304993,
-0.2825259566,
0.0892530531,
-0.4839200675,
1.0579806566,
-0.259729594,
-0.3058247566,
-0.4965474308,
0.445004344,
0.3221872747,
0.4306473434,
0.8331438899,
0.3142522871,
0.9414851665,
-0.1895666122,
1.0386881828,
-0.3832870722,
0.1232372299,
1.0991880894,
-0.3155078292,
0.2995607853,
0.1881067008,
-0.0880782753,
0.7032083273,
1.1568198204,
0.2240270525,
0.5601295829,
0.2138273865,
-0.0999637395,
-0.5586277246,
-0.3667876124,
-0.3213538229,
0.0772504583,
0.1682170331,
0.0050080777,
-0.5265342593,
0.1423258632,
0.1222779751,
-0.0275808163,
-0.440202266,
0.6556227803,
0.1601044536,
-0.9034605622,
0.4450595379,
-0.6798974872,
0.3033445776,
-0.8470780849,
-0.0060625081,
0.028804021,
-0.1011407673,
-0.293959111,
-0.7241762877,
0.0789191872,
-0.2376975119,
-0.086346373,
-0.3639407158,
0.8853592277,
-0.00443715,
-0.0875647888,
0.7078744769,
0.3691776693,
-0.0295944456,
-0.6682166457,
-0.6507797837,
-0.2441629171,
-0.189090535,
-0.2849693298,
0.3397728205,
0.5132268667,
-0.1901333183,
0.534643054,
0.8610987067,
0.1418526918,
0.0175209027,
0.5499606729,
1.2077794075,
-0.1982380897,
-0.8088182211,
-0.6949536204,
0.4233371615,
-0.2056760788,
-0.3838354051,
0.6388242245,
0.2442609966,
0.7390405536,
0.1419665068,
0.8213217258,
-0.008375993,
0.1564000696,
-0.4371917546,
0.6951426268,
-0.3697428703,
-0.4401100278,
-0.2639338076,
-0.8053247333,
-0.1617410183,
0.2392694503,
-0.4397037029,
0.1414357126,
0.6104370952,
0.5581245422,
-0.1463465989,
-0.0052751116,
-0.0683920756,
-0.24979949,
0.1659906954,
0.4935293198,
0.895396769,
0.4319111407,
0.6506827474,
-0.0255188793,
0.02100881,
-0.0359603502,
-0.9199452996,
-0.8819552064,
-0.6645545363,
-0.3084976077,
-0.4344960451,
0.0845544264,
0.7543411255,
0.9389826059,
-0.6777162552,
0.1803853065,
-0.484205246,
0.0040836539,
-0.5613488555,
-0.1137863025,
0.5411072373,
-0.7256390452,
-0.4444279969,
0.3223466575,
-0.0004804355,
0.1669052988,
0.0625174791,
-0.0970918685,
-0.1404996514,
-0.4770240486,
0.2962528169,
0.4003715813,
-0.1313564628,
-0.3463724256,
-0.0634699091,
0.1352981925,
-0.052035246,
1.2983416319,
-1.0123820305,
0.3967254162,
0.5875219107,
0.4295325577,
0.6566512585,
0.203866154,
0.5681561232,
-1.149087429,
0.2505029738,
0.0998307243,
0.2877006531,
0.2822467983,
-0.6095837355,
0.2961572707,
0.4551521838,
-0.1712621152,
-0.6566203833,
0.3978197277,
-0.6865165234,
-0.4698983431,
0.6790856123,
-0.5727915168,
-0.2802396417,
-0.4410994351,
-0.2137597799,
0.8618612289,
-0.2055639774,
0.3281148374,
0.4739109278,
-0.4180388153,
-0.1012749821,
-0.3514976203,
0.4986501038,
0.1126465797,
-0.7407014966,
0.1947427541,
0.3325412571,
0.1785499603,
0.0701421574,
0.9600102305,
0.5368809104,
0.1397232115,
0.0074856253,
-0.0762803853,
-0.7368711233,
-0.6548601389,
0.0388401933,
0.2711631954,
-0.0690720826,
-0.3490402699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09300v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09300v1 | Search-Engine-augmented Dialogue Response Generation with Cheaply Supervised Query Production | 2023-02-16T01:58:10 | 2023-02-16T01:58:10 | Ante Wang, Linfeng Song, Qi Liu, Haitao Mi, Longyue Wang, Zhaopeng Tu, Jinsong Su, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge-aided dialogue response generation aims at augmenting chatbots with
relevant external knowledge in the hope of generating more informative
responses. The majority of previous work assumes that the relevant knowledge is
given as input or retrieved from a static pool of knowledge. However, this
assumption violates the real-world situation, where knowledge is continually
updated and a chatbot has to dynamically retrieve useful knowledge. We propose
a dialogue model that can access the vast and dynamic information from any
search engine for response generation. As the core module, a query producer is
used to generate queries from a dialogue context to interact with a search
engine. We design a training algorithm using cheap noisy supervision for the
query producer, where the signals are obtained by comparing retrieved articles
with the next dialogue response. As the result, the query producer is adjusted
without any human annotation of gold queries, making it easily transferable to
other domains and search engines. Experiments show that our query producer can
achieve R@1 and R@5 rates of 62.4% and 74.8% for retrieving gold knowledge, and
the overall model generates better responses over strong knowledge-aided
baselines using BART and other typical systems. | [
-0.4884828329,
-0.8655541539,
0.3997609913,
-0.1021642908,
-0.0207810272,
-0.1663222462,
-0.1385555267,
-0.5488032699,
0.4242602289,
0.7713638544,
-1.025272727,
-0.1049975678,
-0.2910484672,
-0.0112639647,
-0.3577405214,
1.0543756485,
0.7751944661,
-0.2284648865,
-0.3341347575,
0.1479498148,
-0.0950352401,
-0.5177764297,
-0.9843745232,
0.0741844028,
0.6395133734,
0.3150683641,
0.5466550589,
0.0757070631,
0.4021306336,
0.396147877,
-0.0558683127,
0.6966176033,
-0.7351830602,
0.3833689094,
-0.0355002619,
-0.5863705873,
-0.4116406143,
-0.0806782991,
0.0899301618,
0.5362119079,
-0.0886369646,
0.0482922643,
0.1389754564,
0.604309082,
-0.7607656717,
0.3688673973,
-1.1655931473,
-0.0419371873,
0.3518049717,
-0.5332213044,
-0.5528427958,
-0.4536753893,
0.3229154646,
-1.0474362373,
0.3987950385,
0.148567155,
0.6893957853,
0.3879460394,
-0.1293195933,
-0.5827583075,
-0.6720250249,
0.6124668717,
-0.7097094059,
0.0180437099,
0.54253757,
0.592652142,
-0.3748137355,
-1.0300810337,
-0.5272926688,
-0.0302022733,
-0.2486474961,
0.3263035417,
-0.0729746521,
0.0920910388,
0.3185249269,
0.3310073018,
-0.3278511465,
-0.4144189358,
-0.2735954225,
-0.2475682944,
0.7594285011,
0.2540622354,
0.0516744778,
-0.29627949,
-0.0362829082,
-0.2167716473,
-0.5774264932,
0.0226156078,
0.6189139485,
0.5661594868,
0.1550688744,
0.3846988976,
-0.5708891153,
0.7947582603,
0.3574303687,
-0.1280879974,
-0.159438163,
-0.4702566564,
-0.078745164,
0.0753670037,
1.0025678873,
0.4014110565,
0.1304043531,
-0.0685392767,
-0.2000259161,
-0.0653743297,
0.6038054228,
-0.9214749336,
-0.463460207,
0.0132863112,
-0.0150851775,
-0.4650333822,
-0.2518827021,
-0.7551204562,
-0.3270798624,
0.0013867631,
0.5088747144,
-0.1314955205,
-0.0246138647,
-0.0661580935,
-0.1561753452,
0.1067595705,
0.4508841634,
-0.7858261466,
0.3368982077,
0.2971415222,
0.523153007,
0.3160693049,
0.3786919117,
-1.0584610701,
0.0254436564,
-0.1744752675,
0.9361926913,
-0.5015361309,
-0.6011704803,
0.1548138857,
0.0306777321,
-0.0767931044,
-0.5668207407,
0.431827873,
-0.9333049059,
0.572828114,
-0.1012949795,
-0.4426937401,
-0.1944735944,
0.2287463844,
-0.6227760315,
0.7114174366,
0.0678669214,
-0.9528803825,
0.2674803138,
-0.5806005001,
-0.1826137453,
0.1487651914,
-0.1562302262,
-0.1584703028,
-0.2998391986,
0.5093152523,
0.0344105251,
-0.0737417713,
0.1816782355,
-0.3545541763,
-0.3184385896,
0.4010397196,
-0.551987052,
0.4323605299,
0.2311954051,
-0.160364598,
-0.0403245762,
-0.8529646397,
0.1989706457,
0.1880200803,
-0.3588137031,
-0.2275481224,
0.210493356,
-0.1745114475,
-0.0057312143,
0.0975671783,
-0.3957811594,
0.1476116925,
-0.7749179006,
0.2367464751,
0.5226187706,
0.4333748519,
0.3305546045,
-0.2089865357,
0.408378005,
-0.2369281799,
0.0078966552,
-0.2734210491,
-0.4589079618,
-0.920024991,
0.0299637243,
0.2388294041,
0.4539486468,
-0.9172572494,
0.3153675795,
-0.0539186522,
-0.3492266536,
-0.7209832668,
0.1115916669,
0.349958539,
0.837528646,
0.1998494714,
-0.295966059,
-0.617643714,
-0.7540637255,
-0.5612205863,
-0.4069396853,
-0.2336326391,
0.7675255537,
0.0665504709,
0.0330532826,
0.9850479364,
-0.7903181314,
-0.3797985613,
-0.1520627737,
0.2797368467,
0.1549833417,
0.2825305164,
0.3142820001,
-0.7113448977,
-0.3927031159,
-0.0149455396,
-0.7891637683,
-0.2404470593,
0.1466852576,
-0.3791766465,
0.1697090417,
0.3995884061,
-0.6707914472,
0.2862867713,
0.3812736273,
0.2505073845,
0.4702189863,
0.0862916186,
0.1877627522,
-1.23567307,
0.1987147331,
-0.0931675062,
-0.4317627549,
-0.4994370341,
-0.0890602842,
-0.3531206846,
-0.4259503186,
-0.5705379844,
0.538982451,
-0.1050879955,
-0.0211155657,
-0.4732666612,
0.6240172982,
0.1090764627,
0.8149930835,
0.1942097396,
1.0687720776,
0.1800102293,
-0.7870561481,
0.4954377413,
0.4735489488,
-0.3668327928,
0.4238580465,
-0.8014853001,
0.3101938367,
0.0896447226,
0.4079177976,
-0.8816171885,
-0.708507359,
0.3416810334,
-0.7512245774,
0.0238813609,
-0.6141631603,
-0.4820640981,
-0.2404956222,
-0.1012075543,
0.1533993483,
0.519015789,
-0.4089974761,
0.4461602271,
0.4040007293,
-0.6287112832,
-0.4221972823,
-0.3850696981,
-0.2028046846,
-0.0179929454,
-0.6712096334,
-0.1510604918,
-0.067902565,
-0.0963037238,
-0.0217585731,
-0.1868833303,
-0.2260054052,
-0.0628136843,
0.2122163922,
0.0997015908,
-0.0505982935,
0.0283234995,
0.175943777,
0.0718858838,
0.2973629236,
-0.285461843,
0.5153175592,
0.1715790331,
-0.5526269078,
-0.666021049,
0.1058533862,
0.4036539197,
-0.1271994412,
0.5117914081,
0.4323581457,
-0.1216286868,
-0.0016931029,
-0.4501978755,
-0.6396780014,
-0.5950379372,
0.2312865257,
-0.1889563501,
-0.8244824409,
0.3932510018,
-0.1324946731,
0.2116016448,
0.4595582783,
0.3842663169,
-0.1479396373,
1.5221021175,
0.3420267701,
0.0447437502,
0.5016206503,
-0.270629257,
0.2623361349,
-0.6566458941,
-0.2697594762,
-0.6718258262,
-0.1743141413,
-0.756315589,
-0.1883143336,
0.6229058504,
-0.1712928265,
-0.2119758129,
0.0945250243,
-0.4413336515,
0.1775867343,
0.8006702662,
0.1203705296,
0.4834306538,
0.1266815066,
0.2085706592,
-0.1335675269,
-0.9689542055,
-0.4136469662,
0.9479275346,
-0.30305323,
1.0837401152,
-0.0258721001,
0.5384280086,
0.3963912725,
0.010343126,
-0.789121747,
0.5340408087,
0.3253270388,
-0.5111621022,
-0.0883704424,
-0.6368257403,
-0.9060823321,
0.2151225358,
-0.2909659445,
-0.6087651253,
-0.0492286459,
0.2825131416,
-0.4770128429,
0.0804953799,
-0.7438866496,
0.4624992311,
-0.070807077,
-0.432828784,
-0.0068968856,
-0.6267651916,
0.443826586,
-0.0106137535,
0.2043397427,
0.1589558423,
0.5733297467,
0.630843401,
-0.6302973628,
1.0382889509,
-0.3316046596,
-0.0267507695,
0.7205877304,
0.1624421179,
0.7465696931,
0.4793934226,
0.1243158802,
-0.7810814977,
-0.0755720809,
-0.3343725204,
-0.7773385048,
0.652592659,
-0.8262208104,
-0.8692455292,
-0.1344694495,
-0.5721598268,
-0.502507925,
0.1673941463,
0.2830702066,
0.3997828364,
-0.1872136295,
0.1710996032,
0.7308260202,
-0.4015950263,
0.0652859136,
0.6317750216,
-0.167905435,
-0.2809194624,
0.8513753414,
-0.2015412003,
0.3369421363,
0.2356034517,
-0.2246638238,
-0.4300380945,
0.167461127,
-0.5435044169,
-0.0103188092,
-0.4179131389,
-0.3636603355,
-1.0015277863,
-0.508541882,
-0.4020114541,
0.033587914,
-0.5161696076,
-0.5326651335,
-0.1556793153,
0.0197966136,
0.6046112776,
0.3687140346,
0.1165154949,
0.4941283464,
-0.9239669442,
0.1561078131,
0.951033771,
-0.0184325501,
-0.0296510812,
-0.5591240525,
-0.3250103295,
0.5030115843,
-0.6409878731,
-0.5835422873,
0.4866906404,
0.4055646658,
0.3986235261,
0.5279588699,
0.5319307446,
0.7035085559,
-0.2393407971,
0.9932641983,
-0.1703610718,
-0.408224225,
0.9833353758,
-0.3836663067,
0.2112921625,
0.5543794632,
0.1776358783,
-0.2373016477,
-0.7122123241,
-0.8075143099,
-0.8233222365,
1.0369600058,
0.3590428829,
0.4467036724,
-0.0739143193,
0.2039480805,
0.0267847143,
0.487744838,
-0.3096002042,
0.0367386937,
-0.1234654337,
0.2046127319,
0.3073059022,
0.0442494527,
-0.482019037,
0.2220084965,
0.8723217249,
-0.4348687232,
0.4501759708,
0.1086806729,
-0.227409333,
-0.2059164345,
0.1033534929,
0.2353905141,
0.2265114039,
-0.4233990908,
-0.1218471378,
-0.0142910788,
-0.1464245319,
-0.284935981,
0.1831436604,
-0.2181917131,
0.0079620546,
0.0347685069,
0.9013427496,
0.1318461746,
-0.9324074984,
0.4624156952,
-0.3386780918,
-0.2248288691,
-0.2735144496,
0.5392564535,
0.0576254167,
0.3434517086,
0.3791145384,
0.0925208107,
0.42679739,
-0.3825390339,
0.1087247953,
0.5730429292,
-0.31638363,
-0.2206497937,
0.8953729272,
0.4264113307,
-0.2836108506,
0.8664149642,
-0.0454513095,
-0.4082766473,
0.420617491,
0.4482977688,
0.6950769424,
0.1789734364,
0.208771944,
0.5279313922,
-0.1014812663,
0.1561340243,
0.1171360016,
-0.3499218524,
-0.5182065368,
-0.5717664361,
-0.6841851473,
-0.7880716324,
0.230897218,
-0.9357711673,
-0.0606461838,
-0.2694933414,
-0.2849407196,
-0.1743202507,
0.1363916844,
-0.6793028712,
0.3407339156,
-0.2039584219,
0.6866087914,
-0.4977338016,
0.4157814682,
0.6197686791,
-0.5897293091,
-0.6286119819,
0.0102411704,
-0.1030410603,
-0.8155890703,
0.4261400402,
-0.0117562925,
-0.3205555975,
0.0779099911,
-0.945682168,
-0.6154925227,
0.8620563745,
0.4017764032,
-0.3711385727,
-0.1192874089,
-0.0815177709,
0.6052305698,
-0.2120555788,
0.3266572952,
0.2394280583,
0.1283743829,
0.2306672335,
-0.6945340037,
-0.3950479031,
-0.5231467485,
-0.1692976058,
-0.1150989458,
-0.7499628067,
0.1430627853,
0.0526222251,
-0.1668968946,
0.3646417558,
0.5556482673,
0.3801651299,
0.3091802895,
0.2030917406,
0.5719888806,
0.6505836844,
-0.0686780289,
0.9890007377,
-0.5927047133,
0.3543159068,
1.2414284945,
-0.1254118681,
0.7912372947,
0.2739307582,
-0.0737147629,
0.4741156697,
0.5387359858,
0.3665140569,
0.8078818917,
-0.0928110853,
-0.6267401576,
-0.3740348816,
-0.3914844096,
-0.4288849533,
0.265147835,
0.5332144499,
-0.3608105481,
-0.1340868026,
-0.3267415464,
-0.109032169,
0.0088386405,
-0.1230220199,
1.2790801525,
0.0106826453,
-0.8717522025,
0.6763433218,
-0.2644608915,
0.4171785116,
-0.697726965,
0.0094654886,
-0.611892283,
0.0155383237,
-0.1754387021,
-0.482552737,
0.1902374923,
0.238470763,
-0.3313808143,
0.1148919538,
0.9563051462,
-0.4565874338,
-0.367911607,
-0.0256717354,
0.6824355721,
0.2553367913,
-0.2728613615,
-0.4281384647,
-0.1431684047,
-0.0763930231,
-0.3708420992,
0.5601799488,
0.5316067934,
0.1903193146,
0.741501689,
0.8714452982,
-0.1297784895,
0.1366806626,
0.0408319756,
1.2054300308,
-0.3228578269,
-0.4199461639,
-0.073024027,
0.3617831469,
-0.315718174,
0.221247822,
0.4086264074,
0.4047836065,
0.8439890742,
-0.1135276631,
1.1527608633,
-0.036899779,
0.6403796077,
-0.3655424416,
0.7867313027,
-0.7341418862,
0.2352602482,
-0.1746231318,
-0.8907511234,
0.008403453,
0.6627465487,
-0.1527607441,
0.0937876776,
0.2203207314,
1.1514496803,
-0.1463994384,
0.128299281,
0.2383864522,
0.1050430983,
0.2861513495,
0.477799505,
0.81685853,
-0.4574928582,
0.9923318028,
-0.1106575876,
0.0939627141,
-0.4054249525,
-0.4331274927,
-0.7280452847,
-0.2492031008,
-0.1224525571,
-0.4408991933,
0.3264402449,
0.673838675,
0.6789152026,
-0.6429207325,
-0.0508654937,
-0.1222166717,
-0.1244913638,
-0.0249397531,
-0.3262992501,
0.1888056546,
-0.8711672425,
-1.0342165232,
0.5827549696,
0.0943371654,
-0.2933885157,
-0.1002585143,
-0.1248463467,
-0.0354551785,
0.3079323769,
0.6118245721,
0.3949572444,
-0.52982831,
-0.1127822921,
0.116825074,
-0.1453587562,
0.0092459917,
0.5503714681,
-1.1319963932,
0.819663465,
0.3766194582,
0.8514348865,
0.7002257109,
0.2904126942,
0.5877847075,
-0.9891787171,
0.1799551398,
0.1457633674,
-0.0912715644,
0.4773551822,
-0.327840209,
0.4126908779,
0.256862253,
-0.6788058281,
-0.6189280748,
0.3517410457,
-0.8480862379,
0.1369161755,
0.9457536936,
-0.2303547114,
-0.1207207441,
0.121442087,
-0.5213808417,
0.4066090882,
-0.8072680235,
0.9188978076,
0.2634130716,
-0.1976540685,
-0.1442459375,
-0.5577363968,
0.6273194551,
0.3460794985,
-0.6435869336,
-0.0154090021,
0.7723349929,
0.1482613683,
0.1664060056,
0.7139258385,
-0.1049020365,
0.3358651698,
0.1744603962,
-0.0440357365,
0.1944699287,
-0.0322677307,
0.3842937946,
0.3101592362,
0.2357134968,
-0.195076555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07994v1 | À-la-carte Prompt Tuning (APT): Combining Distinct Data Via Composable Prompting | 2023-02-15T23:51:09 | 2023-02-15T23:51:09 | Benjamin Bowman, Alessandro Achille, Luca Zancato, Matthew Trager, Pramuditha Perera, Giovanni Paolini, Stefano Soatto | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We introduce \`A-la-carte Prompt Tuning (APT), a transformer-based scheme to
tune prompts on distinct data so that they can be arbitrarily composed at
inference time. The individual prompts can be trained in isolation, possibly on
different devices, at different times, and on different distributions or
domains. Furthermore each prompt only contains information about the subset of
data it was exposed to during training. During inference, models can be
assembled based on arbitrary selections of data sources, which we call
"\`a-la-carte learning". \`A-la-carte learning enables constructing bespoke
models specific to each user's individual access rights and preferences. We can
add or remove information from the model by simply adding or removing the
corresponding prompts without retraining from scratch. We demonstrate that
\`a-la-carte built models achieve accuracy within $5\%$ of models trained on
the union of the respective sources, with comparable cost in terms of training
and inference time. For the continual learning benchmarks Split CIFAR-100 and
CORe50, we achieve state-of-the-art performance. | [
-0.4217518866,
-0.760535419,
0.3291970789,
0.0381322317,
-0.2446649075,
0.3232626617,
-0.0769861862,
-0.3755114973,
0.1722553372,
0.3412384987,
-0.9671341777,
-0.2778089941,
-0.1420661658,
0.1617128551,
-0.1912291199,
0.7030626535,
0.3706324399,
0.1052617654,
-0.0338235088,
-0.1714068353,
-0.8902963996,
-0.3712265193,
-1.0634932518,
-0.2112182081,
0.8391399384,
0.7926986814,
0.6070717573,
0.8157206178,
0.2762120664,
0.1776594818,
0.1758682728,
0.3879155815,
-0.2360317558,
0.345921874,
-0.1948319077,
-0.5775410533,
-0.3939615786,
-0.0105466861,
0.1100736484,
0.5328918099,
-0.1066642404,
0.0926779807,
0.0434121005,
0.7556071877,
-0.878927052,
-0.1251590699,
-0.7388769984,
-0.0559361391,
0.082168974,
-0.0794606209,
-0.7924575806,
-0.847325623,
0.1718840599,
-0.9856719375,
0.640745759,
0.3489827216,
0.8940000534,
0.4177764654,
-0.3489418626,
-0.5012369752,
-0.7390829921,
0.6900032163,
-0.0676784888,
0.4856003523,
0.2726301253,
0.7912883759,
0.2349168211,
-0.8399832249,
-0.4542433619,
-0.2484557331,
-0.127077505,
0.2174576223,
-0.2378383428,
-0.1090173721,
0.198050797,
0.2722599804,
-0.5111563802,
0.1888256222,
-0.0596208051,
-0.0646850765,
0.5474042296,
0.0562732145,
-0.0396305323,
0.0881243125,
-0.5581462383,
-0.2462836653,
-0.7860363722,
0.2229050398,
0.1819555014,
0.3450310826,
-0.0056058583,
0.499407649,
-0.1902774572,
0.8115363121,
0.5444614291,
0.1797520667,
0.1765898913,
-0.1821682155,
-0.1760674417,
0.2610222697,
0.7077377439,
0.1918843389,
0.2140798867,
-0.2896052599,
-0.3248173594,
0.0669348985,
0.3998654485,
-0.1358535737,
-0.5298469067,
0.0742914751,
-0.1236833557,
-0.1134303287,
0.1140234172,
-0.8483582735,
-0.2142372578,
-0.6743276119,
0.677893281,
-0.325371474,
0.1071866974,
0.0510985851,
-0.1992717683,
0.1862401515,
0.3686841726,
-0.8495547771,
0.0097650094,
0.4027420282,
0.8675879836,
-0.3087977171,
-0.3219981194,
-1.0208110809,
0.2123031914,
-0.0481396317,
1.1712206602,
-0.6936133504,
-0.7311009765,
0.1455736011,
0.1856208146,
-0.1761385053,
-0.4977195859,
0.6368477941,
-0.7690579295,
0.0394839607,
-0.6222878098,
-0.591271162,
-0.2184942812,
-0.0287901629,
-0.8220797181,
0.9817556143,
0.0859942213,
-0.3263657689,
0.7164511085,
-0.6259227395,
-0.3374197185,
0.1812999099,
0.1189546287,
-0.6962615848,
0.2060573995,
0.599686563,
0.0231396183,
-0.1505479217,
-0.0055289804,
-0.2312806547,
-0.176884681,
0.0986128449,
-0.516897738,
0.7389522791,
0.2314011157,
-0.2445133924,
0.3197767138,
-0.9016054273,
-0.1760653853,
-0.1370370835,
-0.1285077035,
-0.1440663785,
-0.1425983757,
0.032991115,
-0.0952975079,
0.2916763723,
-0.3127857149,
0.4719210267,
-0.2554711699,
0.3999985158,
0.6285214424,
0.1555443257,
0.6223096251,
-0.6374375224,
0.7066386938,
-0.0620321296,
0.3519951105,
-0.5374962687,
-0.4764406383,
-0.8387735486,
-0.4182635546,
0.3155350983,
0.8360004425,
-0.7575873137,
0.7723367214,
-0.0879883617,
-0.350831449,
-0.4865573049,
-0.1707982272,
0.0354570188,
0.8855599165,
0.4601368308,
-0.092258364,
-0.3652872741,
-0.5497772098,
-0.0843501911,
0.0473235659,
-0.2354380935,
0.4376719296,
0.2507015169,
0.4872814417,
1.1144500971,
-0.5587738752,
-0.1409570128,
-0.1011805758,
0.0588486344,
-0.02056651,
0.3973433077,
0.428440243,
-0.5037946701,
-0.6533178687,
-0.0330907926,
-0.7081373334,
-0.2538868487,
-0.1110623106,
-0.1880746931,
-0.1974717081,
0.4865327775,
-0.6593962312,
0.4282855392,
0.0638568699,
-0.4309318662,
0.6365144849,
-0.3496491909,
0.1916762739,
-0.8915552497,
-0.1350476146,
-0.1606963128,
-0.2177392393,
-0.405893743,
-0.2191110402,
0.2343921512,
-0.2634788454,
-0.4877130985,
0.6601842642,
-0.3977681994,
0.0976991653,
-0.3499802351,
-0.0408733934,
0.3946724236,
0.3927333355,
-0.0965008587,
1.0779831409,
0.7127193809,
-0.895516634,
0.4310696125,
0.5182762742,
-0.2740799189,
0.893253684,
-0.9222391248,
0.2745965719,
-0.1336025,
0.2462741137,
-1.0802680254,
-0.2598803639,
0.2287803888,
-0.1898474246,
0.0103852572,
0.0316086859,
-0.1489414275,
-0.3096446097,
0.0065070488,
0.4448727965,
0.4948743284,
-1.1630345583,
0.7578386664,
0.0455925092,
0.0170815922,
-0.3933809996,
-0.1970930248,
-0.215591982,
-0.4414279461,
-0.3342686296,
0.2639163435,
-0.0841377005,
0.0858267248,
-0.0990273207,
0.1196634397,
0.091125682,
-0.000567826,
0.1357062012,
0.1906424016,
-0.1409647316,
0.6603094339,
0.2637473643,
-0.1763282269,
-0.3155747056,
-0.4950069785,
0.6053899527,
0.3841897547,
-0.4263038635,
-0.7702152729,
0.585023284,
0.5313318372,
-0.7050508857,
0.4244746566,
0.4326893687,
-0.0352171995,
-0.4126740098,
-0.5882082582,
-0.4247586131,
-0.5505901575,
-0.1213382408,
-0.4818684161,
-0.6136581302,
0.6417188048,
-0.2850805521,
0.2523014247,
0.3924150765,
0.4066674411,
-0.0380171537,
1.1316229105,
0.7007840276,
0.000397029,
0.931670785,
-0.1152682155,
0.0428817607,
-0.4120952189,
-0.502256453,
-0.9665999413,
-0.3553829193,
-0.2069479078,
-0.0012654966,
0.7299523354,
0.1981117576,
-0.7371302843,
0.0230596419,
-0.7881489992,
0.721298933,
0.8623217344,
0.5435830355,
0.4855586886,
0.1582523137,
0.0306651313,
0.3162869215,
-0.8838453293,
-0.36449489,
1.0798709393,
-0.0101200407,
0.7621478438,
-0.2006599158,
0.2829219103,
0.4865989685,
0.0251861271,
-0.9610180259,
0.2309188247,
-0.2442055196,
-0.2066599876,
-0.1217359602,
-0.2306901515,
-1.0995147228,
-0.2571469843,
-0.2068808824,
-0.6972865462,
0.6425340176,
0.5239160657,
-0.6979973912,
0.1408033669,
-0.9588774443,
0.6105239391,
-0.1994368434,
-0.2992758453,
-0.1279835701,
-0.4719648659,
0.1071884409,
0.1260825992,
-0.1105984226,
-0.1392246336,
-0.0803453475,
0.3124231398,
-0.4264549613,
0.7820259333,
-0.2783474326,
0.0780058503,
0.2833016813,
-0.1145623922,
0.7798430324,
0.5437007546,
-0.1324274391,
-0.0415707305,
-0.4118390381,
-0.5322167277,
-0.637022078,
0.5412176251,
-0.8322998881,
-0.3190948963,
-0.2519790232,
-0.5932663083,
-0.2728452682,
0.016334625,
0.6598616242,
0.682477951,
-0.1702251434,
-0.1649629176,
0.922190845,
-0.1640679985,
0.7611321807,
0.5356426835,
0.0408702232,
-0.6332588792,
0.704605639,
-0.2539285719,
0.0774100944,
0.4826371968,
0.0747288689,
-0.8011798263,
-0.0240392759,
-0.6593783498,
0.082710579,
-0.6590656638,
-0.3868355751,
-0.5413510799,
0.0119953426,
0.0608265772,
-0.5440787077,
-0.3389730155,
-0.5234160423,
-0.5548737645,
0.0173383001,
0.6936635971,
0.6366233826,
0.0946810544,
0.9687399268,
-0.7813471556,
0.3045511544,
0.6936619282,
0.2565299273,
-0.0479858704,
-0.2403782755,
-0.2344654053,
-0.0565795153,
-0.4369376898,
-0.8097453713,
0.1479124725,
0.5960227251,
0.5412158966,
0.2833787501,
0.0889132917,
0.4871504605,
-0.6039203405,
1.0287208557,
0.2110329419,
-0.9715024829,
0.8699518442,
-0.1189557239,
0.7044364214,
0.8109931946,
0.3056419194,
-0.0653114468,
-0.2443345785,
-0.3650780618,
-0.7227087617,
0.6309098005,
-0.2382822782,
-0.0478763357,
-0.0631415397,
0.6507820487,
0.4451812506,
0.2621483505,
-0.3455824554,
-0.3550168276,
-0.4232358634,
-0.2343986779,
-0.2726697624,
0.1669900566,
-0.1838903278,
-0.4316596985,
0.6332505941,
-0.2009681016,
0.2452186793,
0.1541702449,
-0.1322462559,
-0.144817248,
0.0150106559,
0.490586102,
0.7107573152,
0.0143446103,
0.0822295249,
-0.0505604707,
-0.4996476471,
0.4796124399,
-0.034803763,
-0.4728536606,
0.2410714775,
-0.1175894737,
1.1936788559,
0.0400463827,
-0.4429183602,
0.0908490047,
-0.3099585772,
-0.0265365392,
-0.1559586078,
0.3257896602,
-0.4379921257,
0.2410053164,
0.5377846956,
0.3769323826,
-0.0212219972,
-0.1209056675,
0.4855133593,
0.434728682,
-0.4353032112,
-0.3626235723,
1.0712714195,
0.1680635363,
-0.5582219362,
0.5881279707,
-0.3467384875,
-0.1080596447,
0.5752431154,
0.392385602,
1.1058880091,
-0.5893450379,
0.5077540278,
0.658020556,
0.122936964,
-0.2371066362,
0.2515235543,
-0.149792105,
-0.5548571944,
-0.3467323482,
-0.5541843176,
-0.5654007196,
0.0358983278,
-0.8742446899,
0.5709161162,
-0.2041745782,
-0.1622726619,
0.0955073014,
-0.195369184,
-0.7234545946,
0.2547288537,
-0.3553325236,
1.0386223793,
-0.9680340886,
0.7062110305,
0.7583269477,
-0.1821549535,
-0.8619433045,
-0.0407778919,
-0.3071373105,
-0.6834500432,
0.0868517756,
-0.0086967805,
0.0521378219,
0.3797884881,
-0.4300106168,
-0.6854045391,
0.9056563973,
0.6163541079,
-0.9168080091,
-0.1612831205,
0.0076111676,
0.0766382441,
-0.4694603682,
0.4609552324,
0.8234004974,
0.3015937507,
0.3988053799,
-0.9218928814,
-0.251565516,
-0.0413488634,
-0.2842068076,
0.1665159017,
-0.7920822501,
0.7858260274,
0.0425993465,
-0.123462081,
-0.0888358206,
0.5004487634,
0.4004067183,
0.6099564433,
0.6938421726,
0.4461922944,
1.2282296419,
-0.2652265429,
0.7801913023,
-0.6159691215,
0.3139244318,
1.1287471056,
-0.0684114918,
0.4756453931,
0.2186443508,
0.0748597831,
0.3709367216,
0.7636226416,
-0.078527227,
0.912361145,
-0.3543450832,
-0.662704289,
-0.5006523132,
-0.1981084645,
-0.4863561392,
0.5295621753,
0.3789791763,
-0.1853614897,
-0.4899036288,
0.49938187,
-0.456073761,
-0.082906194,
-0.5196831822,
0.9297501445,
-0.0545492359,
-0.8880396485,
0.7058213949,
-0.4907898307,
0.2114493251,
-0.6216366291,
0.0536133274,
-0.3229638934,
-0.0729035139,
-0.0107493894,
-0.2361973375,
0.1181660891,
-0.1952776611,
-0.379649967,
-0.1362552792,
0.328873843,
-0.2749323845,
-0.6946371198,
-0.2927424312,
0.7588480711,
-0.3448293507,
0.178821817,
-0.5965455174,
-0.0085133957,
-0.0338588804,
-0.2192015499,
-0.0937923491,
0.5472152829,
-0.004799705,
0.6480073333,
0.4312200546,
-0.1125079766,
0.2263454348,
0.1995365322,
0.8850108981,
-0.4167762995,
-0.9563478231,
-0.6040932536,
0.7510789633,
0.0608904883,
-0.545527637,
0.6532699466,
0.6826032996,
0.5536587238,
-0.2085344791,
0.8861781955,
0.2844285071,
0.4046703875,
-0.6997746229,
0.3653045595,
-0.5717610121,
0.5400832891,
0.2416705787,
-1.0673632622,
-0.1920920759,
0.5459555387,
-0.2406297922,
-0.0304016955,
0.574048996,
0.7915660143,
-0.3755473495,
0.4609784782,
0.0645711124,
-0.3215624988,
0.2744780481,
0.5088045597,
0.8460888267,
-0.2293605357,
0.2968802154,
-0.2016091198,
-0.3101927638,
-0.1428435594,
-0.6771137118,
-0.7878454328,
-0.4578929842,
-0.3390204906,
-0.1606206596,
0.16435045,
0.9416696429,
0.7478286028,
-0.9561505914,
-0.1017539799,
-0.5303747654,
0.2390603572,
-0.6118500829,
-0.2084939182,
0.6351540685,
-0.8201003671,
-0.7989518046,
0.6479650736,
0.1313411891,
-0.0232355651,
0.0215569232,
0.2605098486,
0.1375633329,
0.1640624702,
0.472754389,
0.3034895658,
-0.3801542819,
-0.4087958634,
0.3107093871,
0.2760361731,
0.4866145551,
1.080702424,
-1.1713197231,
0.6946150661,
0.1788455248,
0.3938626647,
0.5835212469,
0.2437451184,
0.5794031024,
-1.0456907749,
0.2693409324,
0.1194144115,
0.1064341441,
0.127044946,
-0.5114758611,
0.1102175489,
0.1508404911,
-0.9124933481,
-0.6826910973,
0.4571207464,
-1.1068377495,
-0.1049764082,
0.6304517388,
-0.0344199762,
-0.0807923451,
-0.4438724518,
-0.3006741107,
0.4473636746,
-0.6509628892,
1.1341696978,
0.2076878399,
-0.2640270889,
-0.3011388183,
-0.4109786451,
0.7364009619,
0.3349479437,
-0.7727995515,
-0.0211996622,
0.5457545519,
0.0841339827,
-0.0144089442,
0.3275702,
0.4471730292,
0.5707886815,
-0.1363648474,
-0.2134450972,
-0.1476730108,
-0.6756840348,
-0.5632099509,
0.6901506186,
0.0003115263,
-0.4421055019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07974v1 | Tree-Based Representation and Generation of Natural and Mathematical Language | 2023-02-15T22:38:34 | 2023-02-15T22:38:34 | Alexander Scarlatos, Andrew Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mathematical language in scientific communications and educational scenarios
is important yet relatively understudied compared to natural languages. Recent
works on mathematical language focus either on representing stand-alone
mathematical expressions, especially in their natural tree format, or
mathematical reasoning in pre-trained natural language models. Existing works
on jointly modeling and generating natural and mathematical languages simply
treat mathematical expressions as text, without accounting for the rigid
structural properties of mathematical expressions. In this paper, we propose a
series of modifications to existing language models to jointly represent and
generate text and math: representing mathematical expressions as sequences of
node tokens in their operator tree format, using math symbol and tree position
embeddings to preserve the semantic and structural properties of mathematical
expressions, and using a constrained decoding method to generate mathematically
valid expressions. We ground our modifications in GPT-2, resulting in a model
MathGPT, and demonstrate that it outperforms baselines on mathematical
expression generation tasks. | [
-0.022703534,
-0.7127786875,
0.4938347042,
0.1705943197,
-0.5441762805,
0.2347286046,
-0.0320000835,
-0.5376780629,
0.1329099089,
0.1479233354,
-0.232222721,
-0.1319891512,
-0.4934449196,
0.221727863,
-0.2097987235,
1.1560430527,
-0.13639386,
0.0855274275,
-0.3816708028,
-0.0427222401,
-0.299136281,
-0.876891315,
-0.4557230473,
-0.4315760434,
0.2094523609,
-0.3056746125,
0.9663774967,
0.5666181445,
0.6180366874,
0.3309957087,
0.1162145287,
-0.0548901223,
-0.2089472413,
0.0890353918,
0.0109877661,
-0.2119124532,
-0.3756357431,
-0.0740522146,
0.8081296682,
0.9444599152,
-0.1085386872,
-0.0454518348,
0.0681199804,
0.4631140828,
-0.0348137319,
0.8477877975,
-0.7550548911,
-0.0134819681,
-0.2863959372,
0.0551968105,
-0.2926125526,
-0.550283432,
0.0293837525,
-0.5972631574,
0.1467877328,
-0.358905673,
0.7847339511,
0.051944118,
-0.5589179993,
-0.4653638899,
-0.5498427153,
0.6193121076,
-0.561309278,
0.3234346211,
0.2751727402,
0.4657087028,
0.0150739336,
-0.7587344646,
-0.1872552931,
-0.2001836449,
-0.3200966716,
0.1877796501,
-0.2554849684,
0.0299570002,
0.2237012535,
0.1991871446,
-0.3385382891,
-0.3289885223,
-0.2127678096,
-0.081575796,
0.7083494663,
0.0755255967,
0.3659195304,
-0.4255522192,
0.1016328782,
-0.1392287612,
-0.9116649628,
-0.1025214344,
0.1883019656,
0.2449257374,
0.1059688702,
0.879794538,
0.263723731,
0.5753612518,
-0.5279893279,
0.1653292626,
-0.1144956425,
-0.3951483667,
-0.4137772322,
-0.1515812874,
0.7736484408,
0.0310105793,
0.4546943903,
-0.1047100797,
-0.3099173605,
0.8107993603,
-0.0283055417,
-0.9231184125,
-0.4124692082,
-0.3318861723,
-0.1578171998,
-0.3228132129,
0.1821087748,
-0.5365137458,
0.2904326916,
-0.4696400464,
0.2167448997,
-0.4128043354,
-0.2981722653,
0.1388851702,
0.1178776994,
-0.3386374712,
0.3801932633,
-0.9375352263,
0.6679000258,
0.776044786,
0.5358439684,
0.3844944537,
0.2805249691,
-0.3306749165,
0.302333504,
-0.6174526215,
0.3031909466,
-0.7869015336,
-0.407196492,
0.0664699078,
-0.4601353705,
-0.0313092135,
-0.3046370745,
0.4408578277,
-0.5054792166,
0.6952526569,
-0.1107587665,
-0.4793391526,
-0.1974605918,
-0.1849951148,
-0.4632018507,
0.9927384853,
0.4224105477,
-0.7560228109,
-0.0022741796,
-1.0590047836,
-0.4143073857,
0.1962420791,
-0.4174036384,
-0.64012146,
0.3543569148,
0.2500795424,
-0.0437335223,
-0.3147263229,
0.7474854589,
-0.1351816505,
0.18193537,
0.1734315455,
-0.5758106112,
0.7380681038,
0.2263130546,
-0.158821404,
-0.2387882471,
-0.4868471622,
0.3532533646,
0.4131892025,
-0.1327634007,
-0.2890190184,
0.3122594059,
-0.1157310084,
0.2793932259,
0.310711652,
-0.6472997665,
0.4428862333,
-0.4821506739,
0.6793689728,
0.3544575274,
-0.1296838671,
0.2078529745,
0.0824571401,
0.4459082186,
-0.1362032741,
-0.3074262142,
-0.4373630881,
-0.7716815472,
-0.4067638516,
-0.0055212891,
0.2381426692,
0.4514806569,
-0.745405674,
0.1923595667,
-0.4142123759,
-0.0649242625,
-0.2316653579,
-0.1794853061,
0.4553720355,
0.5100354552,
0.2614925504,
0.0310619008,
-0.6742807627,
-0.7967807651,
-0.2450180054,
-0.3120501041,
-0.2636258304,
0.2109043896,
0.362144798,
0.0039506005,
1.2279928923,
-0.4653383493,
0.0017971913,
0.0316549838,
0.3418665826,
0.2492231876,
0.397827059,
0.5140197277,
-0.5911062956,
-0.6051657796,
0.2912969291,
-0.8163739443,
-0.2425349951,
0.0940170512,
0.1067283303,
0.2778511941,
0.0697878078,
-0.7019871473,
0.6211538315,
0.4843606353,
-0.4809715152,
0.2099487931,
-0.0728149042,
-0.0442259386,
-0.9628171325,
0.0932604373,
-0.2716403008,
-0.4717074931,
-0.4361808896,
0.1991251707,
-0.0379629396,
-0.5935511589,
-0.0765650421,
0.2617647946,
-0.4790599942,
-0.3728476465,
-0.1470602751,
-0.0812958479,
-0.0154101718,
0.2956533134,
0.2108460963,
0.8518686295,
0.6376146674,
-0.1576382667,
0.1394713223,
0.0788421854,
0.0504521802,
0.3618110716,
-0.9236662388,
0.1731839478,
-0.0152997663,
0.3252492845,
-0.5080604553,
-0.1949716955,
0.3346447051,
-0.5360661149,
0.2168850303,
-0.4684832692,
-0.79589504,
-0.2359125614,
-0.0618948527,
0.7355552912,
0.74137187,
-0.2714186907,
0.5009409189,
0.242183879,
-0.4135969877,
0.0236295871,
-0.5630688071,
0.1761296242,
0.0010505997,
-0.9425733685,
0.4036109149,
0.3276505172,
-0.2478760183,
0.3881295621,
-0.1384318471,
-0.0835695863,
-0.0832716972,
0.0097534433,
0.3771242797,
-0.5070354939,
0.2266870886,
0.1720845848,
-0.3341960311,
0.1675499231,
-0.5998088717,
0.335049659,
-0.2322653234,
-0.6048955321,
-0.1681089699,
0.6739166975,
0.3334751725,
-0.4350112081,
0.2863543332,
0.142136246,
-0.8398616314,
0.0784978494,
0.2209906727,
-0.372728467,
-0.451043576,
0.336678654,
-0.5212336779,
-0.9610025883,
0.1192459986,
-0.1152984053,
0.255458653,
0.725446701,
0.4781479836,
0.042091921,
1.3532634974,
0.3634750545,
0.3836944699,
0.3068257868,
0.0135452244,
0.4259852171,
-0.4469506741,
-0.0109794484,
-0.6733659506,
0.0993504301,
-0.3514493406,
-0.4330534935,
0.4827496707,
0.6191046834,
-0.204806298,
0.37717399,
-0.5907933116,
0.4501766264,
0.2840193808,
-0.4044303596,
0.1673201323,
0.4675677717,
-0.426823467,
-0.4466293454,
-0.6401340365,
-0.8890918493,
0.8132845759,
0.3991663158,
0.4317452312,
0.3365784883,
0.7056467533,
-0.1025098413,
0.6874527931,
-0.4110408723,
0.3777658343,
-0.3552034795,
-0.3774008155,
-0.1760451794,
-0.6803370714,
-1.0368262529,
0.3429711759,
0.0645589158,
-0.8323761225,
-0.5286720395,
0.0937918648,
0.0538184009,
0.2090883255,
-0.812033534,
0.6965128183,
-0.3053889573,
-0.1552814245,
-0.2586789429,
-0.2969347835,
0.3324434757,
-0.1184912845,
0.3262377679,
0.1680064052,
0.149681136,
0.4823694229,
-0.8396378756,
0.9633594155,
-0.1974090636,
-0.2378772646,
0.7861667871,
0.5110734701,
0.6927967668,
0.4374299049,
0.0778421238,
0.0620692633,
0.051844921,
-0.3298443854,
-0.7126570344,
0.5194390416,
-0.6906801462,
-0.5620803237,
-0.5703781843,
-0.5602022409,
-0.0955863148,
0.2138516307,
-0.1473420113,
0.677497983,
-0.0561035872,
-0.0913824812,
0.1397367716,
-0.0353544652,
0.5260115862,
0.0766385198,
-0.6819295883,
-0.7575115561,
0.9188422561,
0.2111047804,
0.1937513649,
0.4146430492,
0.3232126534,
-0.633713305,
-0.094599694,
-0.5100221038,
0.2135312706,
-0.5990645289,
-0.3600960076,
-0.4756561518,
-0.3379961848,
-0.4206724763,
-0.075357303,
-0.1574859172,
-1.0337803364,
-0.1483728886,
-0.0597268231,
0.5201535225,
1.0166655779,
-0.1377249062,
0.3015546501,
-0.8345335126,
0.3557570279,
0.4751758575,
0.3544995487,
-0.3011676967,
0.1009288058,
-0.0836596563,
0.3791792989,
-0.4596536458,
-0.9040634036,
0.2917586565,
0.3462301791,
0.0972243845,
0.0616029836,
-0.3701868951,
0.6368182898,
-0.7709750533,
0.5442852378,
0.5001739264,
-1.2771452665,
0.4519217312,
-0.3930341303,
0.0486968048,
-0.1752729416,
-0.2352115959,
-0.6333061457,
-0.2513648272,
-0.8413099647,
-0.1851201504,
0.5676680207,
0.7420221567,
0.2954245806,
-0.2023542374,
-0.0204448514,
-0.0572708398,
0.1425075829,
-0.8124597073,
0.2259971797,
-0.7288686037,
-0.5249640346,
0.2699981332,
-0.0310365129,
-0.1640165001,
-0.2923753858,
0.2189093977,
-0.1787408143,
0.4295416474,
0.0353745632,
0.1525419652,
-0.2464977652,
0.1973164678,
0.528459847,
0.7288268805,
0.1754648387,
0.4458065927,
-0.2426906228,
-0.3223977685,
0.0549716838,
0.4505355954,
-0.307744056,
0.5073045492,
0.354436487,
0.660677433,
0.2986788154,
-0.3050029278,
0.1573062241,
0.1736355424,
-0.3061774075,
-0.0148539403,
-0.25637573,
0.399390161,
-0.334592849,
0.2544950247,
0.2451109141,
-0.0818925574,
-0.4249208272,
0.2791186273,
0.5624470711,
0.0454837568,
-0.7770630717,
0.8482269049,
0.184009403,
-0.4334482253,
0.5908136964,
-0.2763209343,
-0.8249070644,
0.5331868529,
0.8951366544,
0.5913820863,
-0.0912294835,
0.3852465451,
0.354908973,
0.2087186426,
0.2242467552,
0.4117749631,
0.0570502058,
-0.4066677988,
-0.4922545552,
-0.4727075994,
-0.0635580868,
-0.3685626686,
-0.1138133928,
0.3162343502,
-0.5952866077,
-0.2219846249,
0.1173668578,
0.0431590751,
-0.6215396523,
0.1300504953,
0.107809566,
0.4959920645,
-0.8598768115,
1.0091612339,
0.8183243275,
-0.4120517671,
-0.9550181627,
-0.50615412,
-0.330337137,
-0.6448664665,
0.6983957291,
0.140163973,
-0.0109758684,
0.2339922935,
-0.5390028358,
-0.8028642535,
0.7433043122,
0.6145715714,
-0.5946551561,
0.0850254893,
0.7014917731,
0.7347652912,
-0.4404850602,
0.2175673693,
-0.2199006528,
0.3338008523,
0.2653235197,
-0.9267454147,
-0.0571893826,
-0.2974305153,
0.2940030098,
0.7268380523,
-0.1043158844,
1.0446075201,
0.1525007933,
-0.8267737031,
0.0521148518,
0.6260027885,
0.3270421624,
0.3154268265,
0.0259616207,
0.8039871454,
0.6241372824,
-0.3427051008,
1.0693585873,
-0.2583725154,
0.5108463764,
0.8415797353,
-0.1950720549,
0.5416762829,
0.4449606836,
-0.4799673259,
0.4855979979,
0.3734454811,
0.1016576067,
0.2998664379,
0.5117581487,
-0.5252766609,
-0.2727175653,
-0.1129031405,
-0.5900633931,
0.0159434471,
0.4945597947,
-0.2960419059,
-0.7315555215,
-0.3687191308,
0.2329698056,
0.455978781,
-0.0238291025,
0.4039961398,
0.2323798239,
-0.692504704,
0.530754149,
0.3794434667,
0.1962807328,
-0.6014342308,
-0.5092484951,
0.0128608523,
-0.1129194349,
-0.0229540616,
-0.7571135759,
0.6447195411,
0.2077191472,
0.0823439583,
-0.4856508374,
0.5771386027,
-0.5720015764,
-1.093926549,
-0.1771401465,
0.5385028124,
0.1343554109,
0.1615784615,
-0.6243696809,
0.0305753909,
-0.1878113896,
0.1108884737,
-0.0707657784,
0.8454574943,
-0.5146998763,
0.2742036283,
0.8913389444,
-0.1331254393,
0.2765989006,
0.2050025463,
0.9499174953,
-0.3902508318,
-0.4763506055,
-0.8128572702,
0.3829233944,
0.0801694691,
-0.2299326658,
0.415430218,
0.6112968922,
0.4760539234,
-0.134291932,
0.8454961181,
-0.2817460299,
0.2325502634,
-0.5047174692,
0.4237418473,
-0.1257167011,
0.0240619741,
-0.3118311763,
-1.0949395895,
-0.6137594581,
0.6785656214,
-0.1431028694,
0.1387910396,
0.7282952666,
0.3308765292,
-0.2996994555,
0.1622702926,
0.1519147754,
-0.0924518257,
0.6994142532,
0.8554819822,
0.7341685891,
-0.48183164,
0.5030164123,
-0.0445082746,
-0.0516985804,
0.2302960902,
-1.0707798004,
-0.8325266838,
-0.3970508277,
-0.4560549259,
-0.228616178,
-0.1900230348,
0.7089486122,
0.5594298244,
-0.6405722499,
-0.1969374716,
-0.7142959237,
0.0089882677,
-0.018756019,
-0.2261721492,
0.605619967,
-0.3092657328,
-0.6591977477,
0.1893377453,
0.3674477935,
0.3938270211,
-0.3195837736,
-0.3294415772,
0.2268033475,
0.0705086589,
0.6693239808,
0.3039789796,
-0.7368443608,
-0.3354843259,
0.1769385636,
-0.1956454813,
0.1424952596,
1.0537472963,
-0.9880351424,
0.2686027884,
0.4261104167,
0.7816442251,
0.3613196313,
0.0001651231,
0.7646759748,
-0.6798919439,
0.0003920424,
0.4843288064,
0.3753170669,
0.3923017383,
0.006821089,
0.4745495319,
0.5392474532,
-0.1259852946,
-0.7292128801,
0.5632559657,
-0.6048716307,
-0.1087547913,
0.5470274687,
-0.1584328264,
-0.0643455535,
0.1872394681,
-0.3628478348,
0.2097132504,
-0.2853145599,
0.5691325665,
0.7408797741,
0.0353323072,
-0.2742446661,
-0.2073709518,
0.2570724189,
0.6360099316,
-0.9031805992,
0.1277170032,
0.6258888245,
-0.1254557669,
0.3567134738,
0.3618808091,
-0.592081964,
0.0904717818,
0.0652664602,
-0.1839637011,
-0.2191448063,
-0.1009698659,
-0.0189731568,
0.1742003858,
-0.0276284814,
0.033808928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07926v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07926v1 | Commonsense Reasoning for Conversational AI: A Survey of the State of the Art | 2023-02-15T19:55:57 | 2023-02-15T19:55:57 | Christopher Richardson, Larry Heck | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large, transformer-based pretrained language models like BERT, GPT, and T5
have demonstrated a deep understanding of contextual semantics and language
syntax. Their success has enabled significant advances in conversational AI,
including the development of open-dialogue systems capable of coherent, salient
conversations which can answer questions, chat casually, and complete tasks.
However, state-of-the-art models still struggle with tasks that involve higher
levels of reasoning - including commonsense reasoning that humans find trivial.
This paper presents a survey of recent conversational AI research focused on
commonsense reasoning. The paper lists relevant training datasets and describes
the primary approaches to include commonsense in conversational AI. The paper
also discusses benchmarks used for evaluating commonsense in conversational AI
problems. Finally, the paper presents preliminary observations of the limited
commonsense capabilities of two state-of-the-art open dialogue models,
BlenderBot3 and LaMDA, and its negative effect on natural interactions. These
observations further motivate research on commonsense reasoning in
conversational AI. | [
-0.447711736,
-0.8357955813,
0.6038037539,
-0.111309506,
-0.013544362,
-0.3565161526,
-0.2780363262,
-0.41983971,
-0.3389381468,
0.4309768677,
-0.3464828134,
-0.33084023,
-0.4266110659,
-0.0541199744,
-0.1622360051,
0.8435700536,
0.3434222639,
-0.0258657783,
-0.6336183548,
-0.310053587,
-0.6002909541,
-0.5799919367,
-0.5969071388,
-0.3472723663,
0.2270597816,
0.4613870382,
0.8300707936,
-0.090378724,
0.3766187727,
0.3808233142,
-0.231376946,
0.1953968704,
-0.6525367498,
0.0730116069,
-0.255292803,
-0.2197433561,
-0.2303253561,
-0.1001964733,
0.24262546,
0.6452340484,
-0.0482789949,
-0.1703814715,
-0.1878564358,
0.235856384,
-0.5507524014,
0.2123718262,
-0.7745267153,
-0.0559335537,
-0.0493510999,
0.3582034111,
-0.4376525283,
-0.2674739659,
0.3828566968,
-0.6687139273,
0.0715181679,
-0.0011253378,
0.8360865116,
0.4261505008,
-0.2164584845,
-0.204648152,
-0.505038321,
1.0787174702,
-0.8591688275,
0.5239349008,
0.3848558962,
0.3637105525,
-0.0096346317,
-0.7636076212,
-0.9790594578,
-0.6713826656,
-0.2602944076,
-0.0049886117,
-0.5427427292,
0.040237952,
0.1969416738,
0.2800133824,
-0.4099517465,
0.3751538396,
-0.3617660999,
0.0298393071,
0.582249701,
-0.0505830608,
0.315323323,
0.0409178361,
-0.3843950033,
0.0601471066,
-0.5385023355,
-0.2479326278,
0.0311248433,
0.0089247813,
-0.1966125965,
0.2337308079,
-0.182939291,
0.8143059015,
-0.1299207509,
0.1310634613,
-0.0759277493,
-0.3509286642,
-0.3079635203,
-0.3174211681,
0.8007764816,
0.3827279508,
0.4354935288,
-0.273213625,
-0.0677590743,
-0.0562456883,
0.245517835,
-0.3657622933,
-0.2780644298,
0.3694808781,
-0.3265168667,
-0.3088404238,
-0.3376165032,
-0.5244410634,
-0.3699928224,
-0.3475350738,
0.2861654162,
-0.3175478876,
-0.4980638921,
0.0117612164,
-0.248740837,
0.3613836169,
0.5961996317,
-0.9419293404,
0.2107727975,
0.9597620368,
0.6159156561,
-0.1065349355,
-0.3630152643,
-0.110826388,
-0.1535724699,
-0.2139724195,
0.8032816648,
-0.7278023958,
-0.3710761368,
-0.0060123838,
-0.3482794464,
-0.0708412528,
-0.5854367018,
0.5161067247,
-0.3455611765,
0.3637794554,
-0.075770326,
-0.2799714804,
-0.1153868511,
0.5092318058,
-0.5647226572,
0.5714865327,
-0.0536618978,
-0.6120876074,
0.2034859061,
-1.2075513601,
-0.5039952397,
0.180496797,
0.0415164307,
-0.0860409513,
-0.0266272798,
0.3754081726,
0.4740287662,
-0.2356331497,
0.5265417099,
-0.3617018461,
-0.1394441277,
0.7200716734,
-0.8179527521,
0.7725690007,
0.4882800579,
-0.0812271908,
0.0366869308,
-0.2232886106,
-0.1818771958,
0.0333683118,
0.2478919774,
-0.0981332734,
0.046822425,
-0.0381189547,
-0.102948539,
0.2587480247,
-0.4371882081,
0.0097724032,
-0.1094162613,
0.8745273948,
0.6802248359,
-0.1157858744,
0.3603348732,
-0.3487829268,
0.0261048451,
0.0567946881,
0.1787344962,
-0.1114454865,
-0.68090415,
-0.7666829824,
-0.100445658,
-0.114065744,
0.4112842679,
-0.6185073256,
0.3450297117,
-0.3681343198,
-0.4022598267,
-0.4255776703,
-0.147979334,
0.3489443064,
0.6605277061,
0.5070261359,
-0.0657794923,
-0.0014230369,
-0.9376579523,
-0.2317704856,
-0.156061843,
0.0863271505,
0.6255238652,
0.5326189995,
-0.0443753339,
1.0724929571,
-0.5857077241,
0.0349644683,
-0.4409652352,
0.394371748,
-0.0396775007,
0.6269734502,
0.2753208578,
-0.91223979,
-0.1493490189,
0.055087667,
-0.5471863747,
-0.0411984324,
-0.0347311795,
0.0776268393,
0.168669343,
0.4829007983,
-0.7903109789,
0.2146885544,
0.5385556817,
0.1032836437,
0.3271602094,
-0.0127221476,
0.1689963341,
-0.7990602851,
0.2850405574,
0.003139178,
-0.07347247,
-0.9709707499,
-0.1108125001,
-0.4838037789,
-0.5000975728,
-0.6416165233,
0.9857224822,
-0.0473245084,
-0.0421584658,
-0.0618595704,
0.3209621012,
-0.1661077291,
0.6222002506,
0.525767684,
0.851498723,
0.380487293,
-0.5603984594,
0.4163019657,
0.3152733743,
-0.2622244358,
0.7807640433,
-0.8573182225,
0.2667779624,
-0.0556357168,
0.3863251507,
-0.9456933141,
-0.3441409171,
0.113222219,
-0.5424296856,
-0.1463824362,
-0.1047798991,
-0.2018816024,
-0.4310241342,
0.2357575148,
0.5076215267,
0.5083376169,
-0.6644964218,
0.2154112607,
0.2731762528,
-0.0965072587,
-0.6243085265,
-0.6228232384,
0.0885151923,
-0.1097630709,
-0.70833534,
-0.1023443043,
0.0432763658,
-0.5116938353,
-0.1602820009,
0.1218011677,
-0.5006827116,
0.259829253,
-0.1079866439,
0.0824403167,
-0.1361402273,
0.1166380495,
-0.1427589506,
-0.1528408974,
-0.1075800285,
-0.0921702757,
0.4477602839,
-0.6293863058,
-0.5838929415,
-0.6457931399,
0.1531949788,
0.6549390554,
-0.196253404,
0.4639007747,
0.4910151958,
-0.1904418021,
-0.0535994135,
-0.6643380523,
-0.3023312688,
-0.4375529587,
0.2912791371,
-0.191858992,
-1.01785779,
0.1495979279,
-0.0620610677,
0.1521103531,
0.2671841979,
0.4672394991,
-0.3112318814,
0.7192456126,
-0.0192353427,
0.02315218,
0.2843752801,
-0.1654581279,
0.4481688142,
-0.5149334073,
-0.0882465318,
-0.4891030192,
-0.2219204009,
-0.4616498053,
-0.5092849731,
0.3123445213,
-0.3064064682,
-0.4387141168,
0.207334131,
-0.4716331065,
0.6552365422,
0.7999959588,
-0.0256780721,
0.1828826815,
-0.5392653346,
0.373813659,
0.403226018,
-0.6164594889,
-0.6381264329,
0.6900655627,
0.3092451692,
0.4643213749,
0.26009202,
0.5681824088,
0.3378812671,
0.2691443861,
-0.6295170188,
0.6703627706,
-0.1206816658,
-0.7914971709,
-0.6027767658,
-0.3194864094,
-0.9474976659,
0.1311782002,
0.0412237942,
-0.9002469778,
-0.0722264871,
0.3589986861,
-0.1862908006,
0.3738028109,
-0.8661829829,
1.2152892351,
-0.1967795938,
-0.3627094924,
-0.3942675889,
-0.8713200092,
0.6113701463,
0.4043018818,
-0.0258704256,
-0.1165651903,
0.2751662433,
0.56711936,
-0.3517020345,
1.0891243219,
-0.2900996208,
-0.1817554086,
0.4275208116,
-0.173163563,
0.3191760182,
0.0223388914,
0.2100627869,
0.4664219022,
0.0571749844,
-0.5808956027,
-0.6420269608,
0.6293484569,
-0.7341794372,
-0.6677167416,
-0.2889239788,
-0.4572538733,
-0.4210524559,
0.1196410283,
0.0202037301,
0.4280354083,
-0.5591304898,
0.2814887166,
0.6611431241,
-0.3049181104,
0.457667619,
0.188765049,
0.4558418393,
-0.3777093589,
0.8967956305,
-0.4012925029,
0.522536099,
0.5887109637,
0.3325762749,
-0.4075727165,
-0.5343347788,
-0.4275662303,
0.0806569308,
-0.6855131984,
-0.160209164,
-0.3413557112,
-0.1357724518,
-0.4937065244,
-0.4650013447,
-0.3195816576,
-0.4787054658,
-0.2039552629,
0.1692111492,
0.1446530968,
0.79988873,
-0.0512647294,
0.2719379663,
-0.7508435845,
0.2397970408,
0.8480045795,
0.3070771396,
0.1960178167,
-0.1404920369,
0.0927493125,
0.1553644985,
-0.3071430624,
-0.5858201385,
0.0328854918,
-0.1068521515,
0.7218475938,
0.6543666124,
0.1137091741,
0.3429604471,
-0.2146743983,
1.2729518414,
0.3613294959,
-0.9572907686,
0.5504649878,
-0.4039237499,
0.2421671748,
0.548807025,
0.2755504549,
-0.7698495984,
-0.1797204018,
-0.8271694779,
-0.1644206047,
0.5754241943,
0.223638773,
0.4044356644,
-0.1161770448,
-0.4108728766,
0.1721163988,
0.2158853561,
-0.7279064655,
0.1815178543,
-0.598827064,
-0.2162824869,
0.1064864546,
0.0729019344,
-0.3410637081,
-0.1226747781,
0.4608932436,
-0.161378637,
0.4161941707,
-0.1776997447,
-0.2234841734,
0.5494948626,
0.6445776224,
0.9136068225,
0.5818243027,
-0.0543631911,
-0.0018917663,
0.4399926364,
-0.1562357396,
-0.1461123228,
0.1431572139,
0.1073148176,
-0.3157686591,
0.4035581052,
0.8755863309,
0.3441405594,
-0.8351783156,
0.8652483821,
0.1824200004,
-0.2460414171,
-0.052322004,
0.1291221529,
0.0081560137,
0.1614330858,
-0.0096763475,
0.1530802548,
0.0167090669,
-0.4495140016,
0.0233797692,
0.5881230235,
-0.2457261086,
-0.1287700832,
0.43952775,
0.7922686934,
-0.2327008992,
0.8727103472,
-0.0670402497,
-0.5365729928,
0.4402829409,
0.4539838731,
0.8675860763,
0.139069587,
0.2168951184,
0.2415408343,
-0.0096448958,
0.1998489201,
-0.1694890261,
-0.6309701204,
-1.1033006907,
-0.1802543104,
-0.1757390946,
-0.869027555,
0.3742028773,
-0.2172132581,
0.023021454,
-0.2250901461,
0.1110818312,
-0.2265762687,
-0.2644687593,
-0.6667410135,
0.1323208511,
0.3454986215,
0.6924674511,
-0.7958087325,
0.4611202478,
0.4843449295,
-0.5663107038,
-0.2657373846,
-0.0563741066,
-0.1293991357,
-1.1163002253,
0.7161720991,
-0.029670056,
-0.0719591454,
-0.0409178212,
-0.9686967731,
-0.5617419481,
0.8596158028,
-0.091858305,
-0.2185953856,
-0.0092640696,
0.211644128,
0.3948455453,
0.012886106,
0.5181372166,
0.6378496885,
0.6474477053,
0.41909343,
-1.0763509274,
-0.2173179239,
-0.2499142885,
-0.0941790417,
0.0162645038,
-0.7612890005,
0.5393462777,
-0.1667220592,
-0.2013269067,
0.1973757893,
0.7375485897,
0.2491963357,
0.6634681821,
0.4840019643,
0.7116639018,
0.7633309364,
-0.2360613644,
0.6991171837,
-0.0921348035,
0.0245916042,
1.0944850445,
-0.3939411044,
0.8482032418,
0.1933308691,
-0.120461002,
0.4359133542,
0.2121937126,
-0.0306224264,
0.3447861075,
0.0926192179,
-0.4800488651,
-0.1966426224,
-0.2837404311,
-0.2480130345,
0.6281098127,
0.4339457452,
-0.0070079952,
-0.290902555,
0.1091858819,
0.2950842083,
0.0505453907,
-0.0820224062,
1.0396715403,
-0.0992491171,
-1.0433408022,
0.6099707484,
-0.3246253133,
0.6362581849,
-0.31741184,
-0.1038096175,
-0.4070772529,
-0.0595913008,
0.0710096061,
-0.9714571834,
0.1326556057,
0.1644948721,
0.3527455032,
-0.4727461636,
0.7927482128,
-0.350728184,
0.1860153675,
-0.4758422375,
0.5915881991,
0.4963018298,
0.162309885,
-0.6620125771,
-0.1126199216,
-0.158966586,
0.2346091121,
0.0228618979,
0.4146127999,
0.0275860112,
0.728941083,
0.7039119601,
-0.2594529092,
-0.2508079708,
0.1328399926,
0.9182426333,
-0.5583980083,
-0.3899812102,
-0.3893308938,
0.5152231455,
-0.3812349737,
-0.5210857987,
0.3111107349,
0.29960531,
0.7479416728,
-0.1052041203,
0.9441590905,
-0.073963888,
0.4065876603,
-0.5806778669,
0.6554028392,
-0.1579761058,
-0.0446186326,
-0.1100765616,
-0.508887589,
-0.1889965981,
0.6476418376,
-0.809889853,
0.2487068921,
0.5650108457,
0.9141665697,
-0.2630980909,
0.5182136297,
0.464084655,
0.0942277685,
0.4663440585,
0.7171396017,
1.2298842669,
0.1297400892,
0.5395709276,
0.0434234068,
-0.1045865268,
-0.3109502792,
-0.961070776,
-0.8976455927,
-0.6649012566,
-0.1812451631,
0.1178862676,
0.2705155015,
0.7372937202,
0.7689386606,
-0.718963027,
-0.0113447057,
-0.4559377432,
0.2360337675,
-0.1902422756,
-0.2999430895,
0.111948885,
-0.707970798,
-0.9119756818,
0.3952656686,
-0.0635243058,
0.0991716012,
-0.1832740009,
-0.2200103551,
-0.1460868865,
0.1435672045,
0.6057529449,
0.5761272311,
-1.0304354429,
-0.3642250001,
-0.2050205469,
-0.024717059,
0.0790037811,
0.7664861679,
-0.8412929177,
0.4189996421,
0.5269728303,
0.6399908066,
0.3222953677,
0.2239230573,
0.5465514064,
-0.4891510606,
0.0074087726,
0.6358704567,
0.0245132074,
0.4253951609,
0.0297962576,
0.4446439743,
0.1938531697,
-0.6539945602,
-0.6945023537,
0.3592247665,
-0.9786099195,
-0.4267990291,
0.975435555,
-0.0337497704,
0.0971747339,
-0.3069307804,
-0.1694481969,
-0.0263766013,
-0.4817552567,
0.4742491543,
0.6805204749,
-0.4622531533,
-0.3555205762,
-0.2991982102,
0.5764122605,
0.4802446365,
-1.0946663618,
0.3236072361,
0.7178781629,
-0.2395790517,
0.231460467,
0.6874778271,
0.1544270366,
0.3392545879,
0.1783157885,
-0.3409314752,
-0.1646874845,
-0.1420557797,
-0.0815201774,
-0.0211438742,
0.0975082889,
-0.2693978548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07912v1 | Meeting the Needs of Low-Resource Languages: The Value of Automatic Alignments via Pretrained Models | 2023-02-15T19:06:17 | 2023-02-15T19:06:17 | Abteen Ebrahimi, Arya D. McCarthy, Arturo Oncevay, Luis Chiruzzo, John E. Ortega, Gustavo A. Giménez-Lugo, Rolando Coto-Solano, Katharina Kann | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large multilingual models have inspired a new class of word alignment
methods, which work well for the model's pretraining languages. However, the
languages most in need of automatic alignment are low-resource and, thus, not
typically included in the pretraining data. In this work, we ask: How do modern
aligners perform on unseen languages, and are they better than traditional
methods? We contribute gold-standard alignments for Bribri--Spanish,
Guarani--Spanish, Quechua--Spanish, and Shipibo-Konibo--Spanish. With these, we
evaluate state-of-the-art aligners with and without model adaptation to the
target language. Finally, we also evaluate the resulting alignments
extrinsically through two downstream tasks: named entity recognition and
part-of-speech tagging. We find that although transformer-based methods
generally outperform traditional models, the two classes of approach remain
competitive with each other. | [
-0.2631614208,
-0.045148246,
0.3234722018,
0.0211764611,
-0.096768178,
0.2944158912,
-0.326792866,
-0.6413095593,
0.1557985395,
0.2405373156,
-0.5407383442,
-0.0554281548,
-0.5658048987,
0.2981875241,
-0.2441550344,
0.9405463338,
-0.4627815783,
0.006211217,
0.09820088,
-0.4195887148,
-0.5149673223,
-0.1580308378,
-0.2191463858,
-0.4499603212,
0.5483846068,
0.3465222716,
0.9574845433,
0.9284723997,
0.6482844353,
0.3592333794,
0.2180676907,
-0.0295907166,
-0.2840364277,
-0.2189484984,
-0.2065126747,
-0.3531966209,
-0.4378411174,
0.0573903471,
0.5835057497,
0.7872984409,
-0.1106387973,
0.1960032284,
0.0154866884,
0.6180225015,
-0.8718970418,
-0.0482965559,
-0.5115152597,
0.1126936376,
-0.5638462305,
0.2346709669,
-0.2477761209,
-0.3765013516,
0.3038724363,
-0.7350214124,
0.0056315623,
0.1104459614,
1.1582255363,
0.5017232895,
-0.2302047908,
-0.3741761148,
-0.8923625946,
0.9212087393,
-0.4345084727,
0.7492104769,
0.1842141002,
0.4294183254,
0.1030489355,
-0.4944472909,
-0.5778538585,
-0.0450468548,
-0.3795128763,
0.1838503629,
-0.4537880123,
0.0903024971,
0.1670944244,
0.5633238554,
-0.7011786699,
0.6671435833,
-0.2204594463,
-0.2907284498,
0.497605294,
-0.1045023501,
0.2686590552,
0.0087458827,
-0.1993580461,
-0.1558348238,
-0.6521211267,
-0.0557954051,
0.4754693508,
0.5405581594,
-0.0680301264,
0.6949624419,
0.0628002957,
1.0202624798,
0.2009910345,
-0.117204234,
0.0686338097,
-0.5155584812,
-0.165165931,
0.2765533924,
0.9761480689,
0.1249969974,
0.343901068,
-0.2979209423,
-0.3344543874,
0.2032236904,
-0.0049265521,
-0.4294845164,
-0.2607178688,
-0.0739742219,
-0.2397693396,
0.0974354744,
-0.1536284387,
-0.4669007659,
-0.378156215,
-0.4502930939,
0.5898945928,
-0.2829641104,
-0.1278793365,
0.047237616,
-0.0241827611,
0.5272812247,
0.2371990979,
-1.0649511814,
0.3165895045,
0.4691466391,
0.7922100425,
-0.1566609293,
-0.1671303809,
-0.3989197016,
0.0917764604,
-0.3133892715,
0.8647619486,
-0.4888289273,
-0.0694874376,
-0.0398127884,
0.3164134324,
-0.3408658803,
-0.4027540982,
0.4926624596,
-0.4288536906,
0.4702271223,
-0.4456528723,
-0.3476078212,
-0.0204097871,
0.0585704669,
-0.887863934,
0.8920850754,
0.146523267,
-0.5532578826,
0.2105093449,
-0.6162612438,
-0.4513027668,
0.0608636066,
-0.00523833,
-0.1430986524,
0.2041266412,
0.1645626277,
0.0000846986,
-0.3567501903,
-0.0187293682,
0.1394286901,
-0.2990719378,
-0.0123001067,
-0.4891580939,
0.6331236362,
0.3846231401,
-0.2023249716,
-0.0198938008,
-0.6149849892,
0.1309025586,
0.1562076658,
-0.240227133,
-0.3558392227,
-0.0767536089,
-0.0365886651,
0.2116945237,
0.5181646943,
-0.5625681281,
0.223601684,
-0.6668844819,
0.3710942268,
0.4893125892,
-0.6386249661,
0.8211506605,
-0.134650439,
0.7560787201,
-0.1098816171,
0.0632000342,
-0.1472209096,
-0.0377186127,
-1.0124051571,
-0.1403163522,
0.9070129395,
0.7710040212,
-0.6082487702,
0.352122128,
-0.5223470926,
-0.7308840156,
-1.1028399467,
0.1853922457,
0.692571342,
0.464055419,
0.4391356111,
-0.4012994766,
-0.5472741723,
-0.9579446316,
-0.3198338449,
0.0413221642,
0.1564486027,
-0.0280758031,
0.0345756449,
-0.1214362979,
0.8152453899,
-0.2653938234,
-0.2023213357,
-0.2283889502,
0.0651460662,
0.0868385509,
0.5345703959,
0.6455654502,
-0.4766499102,
-0.5382065177,
0.4031221271,
-0.4642939568,
-0.0415502302,
0.2098173797,
-0.097004354,
0.2731523514,
0.2787927985,
-0.4542675912,
-0.0590194836,
1.0467116833,
0.1570376903,
0.1306950599,
-0.2736083269,
-0.0586445704,
-0.9220041037,
0.2047190517,
0.0298670642,
-0.2431515157,
-0.7462841868,
-0.2712046206,
0.1654817313,
-0.245306775,
-0.5519065261,
0.7669145465,
-0.8531970382,
-0.1631780565,
-0.3062220514,
0.3572782278,
-0.0923229083,
0.1730973274,
0.2776919007,
0.7488566637,
0.3345656395,
-0.3734127879,
0.2763057649,
0.2680932879,
-0.2609351873,
0.4693981707,
-0.6614122391,
0.2434929907,
-0.2276868224,
-0.0440981574,
-0.7394672036,
-0.1327365041,
0.2036285102,
-0.1086209416,
0.5292670131,
-0.1586671919,
-0.3018880785,
-0.4908036292,
0.0673368126,
0.6441965103,
0.3544934988,
-0.4842819571,
0.5997200012,
0.5085401535,
-0.1434907764,
-0.943438828,
-0.5999322534,
-0.0346930511,
-0.1941485256,
-0.2435321659,
0.3568813205,
0.1849756688,
-0.1358564794,
-0.0560882241,
-0.2085732818,
-0.0274949651,
0.0998343751,
-0.0722038075,
0.4025157988,
-0.4922057986,
0.0084575973,
-0.1542037278,
-0.3503468037,
-0.5294848084,
-0.4501002133,
0.6483273506,
-0.3425648212,
-0.5520623326,
-0.469368428,
0.1149758771,
0.4181745648,
-0.8303844929,
0.6056947112,
0.4959383011,
-0.5669311285,
0.296908021,
-0.6081227064,
0.2970620096,
-0.4534586966,
0.3306217194,
-0.2161601782,
-0.734769702,
0.4222308397,
-0.0647434741,
0.164953053,
0.5030500889,
0.384614259,
-0.103526704,
1.1054650545,
0.9482691884,
-0.2642663121,
0.5400810838,
0.0792405456,
0.5068643689,
-0.5629917979,
0.0903858766,
-0.7539932132,
-0.5383111835,
-0.9468483925,
-0.1528796405,
-0.0481908284,
0.2529609799,
-0.0298587065,
1.0813164711,
-0.4433412552,
0.6894560456,
0.5202504992,
-0.4940437973,
0.2332371622,
-0.3504018188,
0.1601374298,
-0.095966503,
-0.8001361489,
-0.869043529,
0.6883283257,
0.1693686992,
0.9261966944,
-0.0083245328,
0.6551072598,
-0.2879410088,
0.4623191953,
-1.0710223913,
0.0359982103,
-0.4273095131,
-0.5195065737,
-0.3516767621,
-0.1685611457,
-1.1829115152,
0.3632439971,
-0.288701117,
-0.5797573924,
0.2870748341,
0.3612605035,
-0.6574454308,
0.0177021455,
-0.9399468899,
1.2749438286,
-0.8021350503,
-0.0811282173,
0.217611596,
-0.642128408,
0.225207746,
-0.399812609,
0.3460172415,
-0.0568405911,
0.0040468862,
0.8007739186,
-0.2177651674,
0.4236928225,
-0.149885565,
-0.2596372366,
0.050673835,
-0.1254490763,
0.3701957166,
-0.5083501339,
0.0105910767,
0.0750041232,
0.319047153,
-0.3468859196,
-0.3788574338,
0.3980251253,
-0.603033185,
-0.4391735792,
-0.5062799454,
-0.6940299273,
-0.2703474164,
0.6222808957,
0.3488178849,
0.002260935,
-0.414275974,
-0.1138079166,
0.3832395375,
-0.0258423854,
0.6235060096,
0.7405398488,
0.0189854093,
-0.3610724509,
0.9347749949,
0.3660162687,
0.1395967603,
0.4407086968,
0.0763546079,
-0.3696120679,
-0.4405082464,
-0.6209696531,
0.5394192934,
-0.3562872112,
-0.3490011692,
-0.5497766733,
-0.0462850146,
-0.3840580881,
-0.1846929193,
-0.6672694087,
-0.5348587036,
-0.1478711069,
0.0005011506,
-0.1692736447,
0.6729519963,
0.0525456406,
0.6321874857,
-1.162525773,
0.0126528805,
0.1934778243,
0.2031531036,
-0.2398153394,
-0.3196366727,
-0.3889241517,
0.0607341155,
-0.3285427988,
-0.7483263612,
0.2933793068,
0.387832582,
0.7039439678,
0.5060449839,
0.056947533,
1.0016118288,
-0.7698506117,
0.4110865295,
0.2463443279,
-1.1196237803,
0.5463814735,
-0.096163772,
0.2357292324,
0.7907016873,
0.6517738104,
-0.7920461893,
-0.2556932569,
-0.367707938,
-0.6230610609,
0.6710914373,
-0.0208128057,
0.2037150711,
0.0587860458,
0.0073951688,
0.0987997577,
0.228539601,
-0.8213982582,
0.0060011209,
-0.158370465,
-0.7421507835,
-0.3168610334,
0.1539009959,
-0.2056910247,
-0.0070793936,
0.5338554978,
-0.2678526044,
0.0730655342,
-0.2421498448,
-0.5878745914,
-0.399664253,
0.3044263721,
0.4667633176,
0.5182099938,
0.1473874301,
0.1603143662,
0.183448568,
-0.277851522,
0.387419641,
0.4612850249,
-0.0377960093,
-0.0088721002,
0.4218839407,
0.9634606242,
0.3202795386,
-0.6827183962,
0.611573875,
-0.0947810188,
0.1395803988,
-0.1356975436,
0.0478425138,
0.0195281226,
0.2009600848,
-0.1034410745,
0.1189352721,
-0.354052633,
-0.4694647193,
-0.2056349218,
0.7307095528,
-0.6404739618,
-0.6582020521,
0.6259623766,
0.1176710054,
-0.3011941612,
0.5911256075,
-0.0720164329,
-0.5985595584,
0.1236051619,
0.5975952148,
0.5382790565,
-0.570145309,
-0.1052968055,
0.2792570889,
0.5080462694,
-0.4603579938,
0.1453847587,
-0.0666435733,
-0.9582381248,
-0.4976761937,
-0.7141724825,
-0.340131402,
-0.0818432793,
-0.7403122187,
0.5076134801,
-0.0424850881,
-0.2563045323,
-0.0111066597,
0.0103674792,
-0.8988214135,
0.0662478879,
0.2537291944,
0.8141216636,
-1.1798019409,
0.7390753627,
0.8914048672,
-0.3697606325,
-0.8672944903,
-0.2405382991,
-0.0698704571,
-0.9281071424,
0.4800086021,
0.1111946329,
-0.1370879263,
0.2697466612,
-0.120276086,
-1.3465586901,
0.9496229291,
0.7704671025,
-0.782137394,
-0.413859129,
0.1868766546,
0.5902457833,
0.0288555697,
0.2571727633,
0.6407471895,
0.7034024596,
-0.1371297091,
-1.3940718174,
-0.2925678194,
-0.1463159919,
-0.0968666449,
0.4932983518,
-0.5514038205,
0.6343245506,
-0.0384311937,
-0.5266361237,
0.1043715701,
0.7400820851,
-0.1006703451,
-0.0869775042,
0.490218848,
0.8523079157,
1.0340451002,
-0.4466611743,
0.7846039534,
-0.3930898309,
0.1131936163,
1.1414202452,
-0.4820600748,
0.8064268827,
0.5108640194,
-0.2743720114,
0.403233856,
0.6366049051,
-0.0830685422,
0.4899187684,
0.0743907988,
0.0998732001,
-0.1508864462,
-0.3933809996,
-0.292419672,
0.7747842669,
-0.0504181683,
-0.079614073,
-0.2362767905,
0.0317878127,
0.0562414266,
-0.0143371839,
-0.2717967033,
0.8881391287,
0.0174110923,
-0.8968096375,
0.5956984162,
-0.0988248885,
0.6704838276,
-0.5941864252,
0.399521023,
-0.1288018078,
0.2354284376,
-0.2504895031,
-0.3687937856,
0.2488214523,
0.2621928453,
-0.0700148344,
-0.3322956264,
0.4492796361,
-0.5639472008,
-0.4286217391,
0.0936469808,
0.7706136703,
0.0437050872,
0.2586251795,
-0.4382372499,
-0.0973104686,
-0.3181427121,
0.1534027904,
0.3676668406,
0.3558753133,
-0.1928878576,
0.3187921047,
0.3485387862,
0.2204740047,
0.1049325764,
0.1129210889,
0.4731061757,
-0.5584871173,
-0.3513042629,
-0.6668698192,
0.50300771,
0.2032156736,
-0.1295500249,
0.7617188692,
0.7147719264,
1.1471062899,
0.0166356843,
0.5546558499,
0.0566553399,
0.3260233998,
-0.4838764369,
0.6351770163,
-0.5058021545,
-0.1646559089,
-0.3127800524,
-1.1893854141,
-0.1895263791,
0.7122630477,
-0.2865892947,
-0.1138258055,
0.6271714568,
0.5620970726,
-0.1989753246,
-0.0235426072,
0.0484669656,
-0.2839032412,
0.1591451168,
0.5096997023,
1.0281339884,
-0.6006094813,
0.5476296544,
-0.2482306212,
-0.1699847728,
0.2547880709,
-1.0873326063,
-0.3779574335,
-0.4945355952,
-0.2910173237,
-0.0017822515,
-0.160774529,
1.0953896046,
0.6650758386,
-1.0123500824,
-0.4105621576,
0.1137103662,
-0.0864518583,
-0.210576579,
-0.0964847803,
0.2334184647,
-0.3626782298,
-1.0797497034,
0.5462440252,
0.1130472422,
0.5016927719,
0.0219056159,
-0.0825579241,
-0.0864357427,
-0.1503406763,
0.294900924,
0.6484178305,
-0.6131148338,
-0.2289081961,
0.2559495568,
-0.2539763451,
0.2049727887,
0.7544127703,
-0.7236097455,
0.3257234097,
0.4039400816,
0.739572227,
0.1392254084,
0.2093243748,
0.7993823886,
-0.5698609948,
0.1753801852,
0.2384855449,
0.592404902,
0.5023161173,
0.0121103777,
0.3123786151,
0.0068866834,
-0.4120067656,
-0.931897223,
0.2747341096,
-0.6044390202,
0.2134179026,
0.5863200426,
-0.0790828615,
-0.3171620369,
0.1036908105,
-0.0003022247,
0.6470208168,
0.0767557174,
0.4603330791,
0.7807602286,
-0.1373866051,
-0.1608646065,
-0.2361926138,
0.5546812415,
0.3698456585,
-0.6523606777,
0.1575766951,
0.423412174,
-0.0465999022,
0.5451757908,
0.6065015793,
-0.2059616596,
-0.0418765992,
-0.4123903513,
0.106925346,
0.2547868788,
-0.2481504381,
-0.6502976418,
-0.3107570112,
0.351675272,
-0.1553934067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07866v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07866v1 | Do Deep Neural Networks Capture Compositionality in Arithmetic Reasoning? | 2023-02-15T18:59:04 | 2023-02-15T18:59:04 | Keito Kudo, Yoichi Aoki, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Ana Brassard, Masashi Yoshikawa, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Compositionality is a pivotal property of symbolic reasoning. However, how
well recent neural models capture compositionality remains underexplored in the
symbolic reasoning tasks. This study empirically addresses this question by
systematically examining recently published pre-trained seq2seq models with a
carefully controlled dataset of multi-hop arithmetic symbolic reasoning. We
introduce a skill tree on compositionality in arithmetic symbolic reasoning
that defines the hierarchical levels of complexity along with three
compositionality dimensions: systematicity, productivity, and substitutivity.
Our experiments revealed that among the three types of composition, the models
struggled most with systematicity, performing poorly even with relatively
simple compositions. That difficulty was not resolved even after training the
models with intermediate reasoning steps. | [
-0.0207468159,
-0.5336068869,
0.7855769992,
0.2792760134,
-0.1005128995,
0.2463032901,
0.1057846397,
-0.5049072504,
0.1739620119,
0.236972332,
-0.4791799486,
-0.3561601043,
-0.7410414815,
0.1657685041,
-0.2472576201,
0.6937984228,
-0.0023959458,
0.1930726469,
-0.3040235043,
-0.3846611083,
-0.2847579122,
-0.685626328,
-0.6879838109,
-0.489730835,
0.5807558298,
0.113122426,
0.657515049,
0.6738835573,
0.5377947092,
0.3921017051,
-0.0400928371,
0.401691854,
-0.2211381942,
0.2792759538,
0.1864692271,
-0.7890330553,
-0.4914802611,
0.0839188769,
0.7133778334,
1.2763068676,
0.0754455328,
0.0388443209,
-0.0002518535,
0.6721041203,
-0.5398157835,
0.4313026369,
-0.5498107076,
0.2342951298,
0.0399411395,
0.1201319471,
-0.3287106156,
-0.4194804132,
-0.1187875718,
-0.5336273313,
-0.0202558655,
-0.4309550226,
0.1089282036,
0.5874622464,
-0.8021028638,
-0.1927449405,
-0.6383118033,
0.6924341321,
-0.7918747663,
0.2033971995,
0.3007619679,
0.2177593261,
0.3867563307,
-0.7078055143,
-0.2462169677,
-0.1664302349,
-0.2954412103,
0.1186313182,
-0.1290287673,
0.0742032081,
0.4849193692,
0.3743740916,
-0.3915503025,
-0.1212415546,
-0.4555456042,
-0.1054363698,
0.7266657352,
0.6630464792,
0.313498795,
-0.0260714944,
0.0433947481,
0.0739101768,
-0.4836454391,
0.3290244043,
0.3849062324,
0.1319562197,
-0.0004643962,
0.8877700567,
-0.1077454835,
0.4823011458,
-0.2415720522,
-0.0547290742,
-0.0782119185,
-0.627577424,
-0.1410477459,
-0.0012470171,
0.7249697447,
-0.1476868093,
0.393771112,
-0.0092067299,
-0.5365459323,
0.4332668185,
0.2800230086,
-0.7828169465,
-0.4514389038,
0.0882584304,
-0.3868532777,
-0.3484849036,
-0.0134331016,
0.4082741141,
-0.3025630713,
-0.751588583,
0.3868025541,
-0.4252316356,
-0.3267661631,
0.242126897,
-0.1903285384,
-0.101346828,
0.3001952469,
-0.9573569298,
0.3529106677,
1.36982131,
0.8643881083,
0.0637703165,
-0.4331758618,
-0.1716517955,
-0.2197532952,
-0.7168575525,
0.2845660448,
-0.5254017115,
0.0013984591,
-0.2986001968,
-0.1764151901,
-0.4261354506,
-0.3145020604,
0.1828763783,
-0.4324762821,
-0.0541987605,
-0.488635242,
-0.6041061282,
-0.5268104672,
0.2319511473,
-0.8126751781,
0.7415356636,
0.1940005124,
-0.5524312854,
0.3121407926,
-0.2234481573,
-0.7569607496,
-0.0749687329,
-0.4903016984,
-0.2624420524,
0.6167219281,
-0.0353524908,
0.353486836,
-0.0855396912,
0.247068122,
-0.3672018349,
-0.6105133295,
0.4522151947,
-0.3285073638,
1.0770738125,
0.0593975261,
-0.3623082638,
-0.023419328,
-0.7802603841,
-0.0866743922,
-0.0853192806,
0.0155094592,
-0.1932367831,
0.0171036925,
-0.6419047117,
0.4005112052,
0.2380664796,
-0.3464626372,
0.1969876289,
-0.3990305364,
0.6478204727,
0.6652709246,
-0.0655588955,
0.6995662451,
-0.3292324841,
0.4851981997,
0.2438962162,
-0.0867520794,
-0.1118177325,
-0.3570864499,
-0.9965779185,
-0.0580929443,
0.1848776191,
0.3964015841,
-0.4319756627,
0.445135504,
-0.2737336755,
-0.5756369829,
-0.3077365756,
-0.0255611744,
0.4442145824,
0.3450892568,
0.1691966355,
-0.3788502216,
-0.2329833508,
-0.8414509892,
-0.2114488631,
-0.0956010073,
0.080267787,
0.2719371915,
0.6587362885,
0.257165283,
0.3841772377,
-0.3140191138,
-0.2204253972,
-0.100083068,
0.5991760492,
0.4112727642,
0.5081776381,
0.4302458167,
-0.2771852016,
-0.2419930249,
-0.0643711835,
-1.1170430183,
-0.0171577279,
-0.2206903994,
-0.175453037,
-0.0212319978,
0.2999365628,
-0.882171452,
0.1986944377,
0.3571127057,
-0.5204734802,
0.3149308562,
0.1241013035,
-0.1062200293,
-0.7751646638,
-0.0934383869,
-0.1052068919,
0.0619837157,
-0.4997778833,
0.1311261505,
0.0570350513,
-0.0028702274,
-0.2229678333,
0.0281703062,
-0.5152333975,
-0.413431704,
-0.0796127468,
-0.6688495874,
0.2824995816,
0.6387555003,
0.1347881407,
0.6136282086,
0.4402343631,
-0.3851312995,
0.2242799997,
-0.2285109758,
-0.1520943344,
0.4675588608,
-1.0966448784,
0.0536741614,
-0.140535295,
0.2510390282,
-0.9254754186,
-0.1790622324,
0.0012320146,
-0.5202134252,
0.1039699093,
-0.3355222344,
-0.3973259926,
-0.1202455983,
-0.1479845494,
0.7670044899,
0.3822634518,
0.1724046171,
1.1107517481,
-0.1247181147,
0.086176157,
-0.4767466486,
-0.9428012967,
-0.2975618839,
0.0182890203,
-0.8810056448,
-0.0276414156,
0.2863661647,
-0.3580830693,
-0.0643156841,
-0.3140796125,
-0.0140440883,
0.4282193184,
0.3973950148,
0.090014793,
-0.6259170771,
0.0571920946,
-0.0294995997,
-0.061971385,
0.7388055325,
-0.2080477923,
0.3909964859,
-0.2596664429,
-0.7512329817,
-0.5937946439,
0.3956647515,
0.6513687372,
-0.462388128,
0.4752317071,
0.4882745743,
-0.4857648909,
-0.0989880636,
-0.2103108466,
-0.3965354562,
-0.4185813069,
0.264742285,
-0.5569031835,
-0.7748013139,
0.5147765875,
0.293426156,
-0.0304910652,
0.5881698728,
0.2977802753,
-0.2887120843,
1.2288230658,
0.0220255647,
0.2397609949,
-0.02122958,
-0.8678416014,
0.0594380908,
-0.6177264452,
-0.3710509241,
-0.3629260659,
-0.8385316133,
-0.4337983727,
-0.3533121049,
0.4466001391,
0.0050656321,
-0.8923033476,
0.02703101,
-0.2947429121,
0.5863180161,
0.8013545871,
0.2455124408,
0.212074548,
-0.0569812171,
0.0887418166,
-0.1649642736,
-0.3951328993,
-0.1527619064,
0.7665573955,
0.434507668,
0.5694838762,
0.2825522125,
0.8914579153,
-0.0279901717,
-0.0383777842,
-1.1008399725,
0.4350941777,
-0.5349780321,
-0.4664154947,
-0.3220837712,
-0.6421132088,
-0.4880168438,
0.2823572159,
0.1177120954,
-0.3059438467,
0.3521737456,
0.0753209963,
-0.4924373627,
0.2133173496,
-0.4558582306,
0.8885402679,
-0.4526649415,
-0.0641130581,
-0.1316604167,
-0.8081315756,
0.5843615532,
0.1688890159,
-0.1327448487,
-0.1772762537,
0.0315920785,
0.5515891314,
-0.6735870838,
1.1198905706,
-0.0967313275,
-0.0283897277,
0.3194777966,
0.8429395556,
0.5389544368,
-0.1143437251,
0.1271256804,
0.2030089796,
-0.2257288992,
-0.4905758798,
-0.8066161275,
0.4182953835,
-1.0280930996,
-0.3937149346,
-0.460777998,
-0.3404958844,
-0.3478031158,
0.0625055581,
0.1472198963,
0.5265848041,
0.301212728,
0.6643922329,
0.5723508,
0.5937734842,
0.5346156359,
-0.0315438956,
0.3356612325,
-0.5597102046,
0.8922929764,
0.3461686969,
0.3459158838,
0.3041667044,
0.179455772,
-0.3096604943,
-0.422318995,
-0.4242625833,
0.029003391,
-1.0153890848,
-0.2806472182,
-0.8958951235,
-0.6685144305,
-0.2016554326,
-0.1438709795,
-0.4702271819,
-0.8975875974,
-0.4294121861,
-0.2852845192,
-0.0252634641,
0.9125943184,
-0.0873376876,
0.0915027186,
-0.8204029202,
0.287163347,
0.8471990824,
-0.1293652952,
0.4105807841,
-0.5359960198,
-0.0444670618,
0.299598217,
-0.1688298881,
-0.6886085868,
0.0487667732,
0.3871001601,
0.2892962694,
0.4398256242,
-0.3650439382,
0.4529340267,
-0.076394923,
0.9608486295,
0.295868516,
-0.9712349176,
0.3298783302,
-0.2466228902,
0.3646440506,
0.5081005096,
0.5135201216,
-0.2091177404,
-0.2127851695,
-0.4939880967,
-0.4801895022,
0.5379273295,
0.2431590557,
0.4499765337,
0.0192970913,
-0.0967521444,
-0.0343176425,
0.0884473324,
-0.7897180319,
-0.1730225384,
-0.5351974964,
-0.3313967288,
0.1380678415,
-0.3541408181,
-0.2354681045,
-0.5718890429,
0.2671400011,
-0.0848799571,
-0.1658026725,
-0.1101632491,
-0.0037617772,
-0.0233372636,
-0.0807224736,
0.4197386801,
0.8092086911,
0.1877339482,
0.5435581207,
-0.1124321446,
-0.280385673,
0.4135119319,
-0.0623934641,
-0.1879113168,
-0.1891797781,
1.0150645971,
0.8112829924,
0.1980866641,
0.0501088388,
0.7199538946,
0.183827728,
-0.5133476853,
-0.3668024838,
0.2347104549,
0.2828112245,
0.3986828029,
0.1691764891,
0.2615814507,
0.4006148875,
-0.4936955571,
-0.2426050901,
0.3118941188,
-0.34911865,
-0.4601348042,
0.6205317378,
0.0503709801,
0.0221399758,
1.0970489979,
-0.1269269139,
-0.6569613218,
1.0394357443,
0.2948928773,
0.9216219187,
0.0150728598,
0.265615195,
0.4131704271,
0.437908262,
0.0170755275,
0.6307069063,
-0.4124256074,
-0.8325744867,
-0.6200327873,
-0.4994656444,
-0.1090975404,
-0.2345327586,
-0.3665819764,
-0.266040951,
-0.4512444437,
-0.0257952809,
0.2893176675,
-0.2118904293,
-0.6985827684,
0.3108783662,
0.249191016,
0.4308969975,
-1.1905870438,
0.3363903463,
0.5328282714,
-0.6993541718,
-1.3770474195,
-0.5012606382,
-0.0607770681,
-0.8849995732,
1.0226345062,
0.3769306839,
-0.1515909284,
0.0024689138,
-0.4780596793,
-0.7094486952,
1.1076905727,
0.3294218481,
-0.1070717946,
-0.0760940164,
0.698562324,
0.7834458351,
-0.4371554255,
0.3899415135,
0.5306373835,
0.4501958787,
0.5101947784,
-0.6874303222,
0.1464178264,
-0.4843354225,
0.0329845324,
0.1333040297,
-0.3965894282,
1.3399746418,
-0.094912596,
-0.0579001717,
-0.0873858258,
0.5375115871,
0.3446865678,
0.4233958125,
0.3471204937,
1.1780542135,
0.489997685,
-0.2414655387,
0.9049484134,
-0.16152969,
-0.0786610246,
1.0986204147,
-0.1721426547,
0.4748454094,
0.1232258081,
-0.3085626662,
0.338862747,
0.5554041266,
0.0860032365,
0.2960672975,
0.2196831703,
-0.4907572865,
-0.8114212155,
-0.0995154828,
-0.5112416148,
0.6541031003,
0.3732714057,
-0.6327707171,
0.1892538816,
-0.5574066043,
-0.0600427985,
-0.1157191545,
-0.3550030291,
0.9854720831,
0.3572491407,
-0.8800048828,
0.5067826509,
-0.2078217715,
0.0591913871,
-0.2804477811,
-0.2444345206,
-0.7068433762,
0.0348020121,
-0.3575685024,
-0.9488874674,
0.4367673397,
-0.6287890077,
-0.0115142483,
-0.1374177635,
0.6230608225,
-0.2393219173,
-0.697945416,
-0.1478519142,
0.880961597,
-0.0138026122,
-0.5649498105,
-0.404001534,
-0.1395452321,
-0.3501504064,
-0.0133861573,
-0.1484405994,
1.1859819889,
0.0047848956,
0.3484925628,
0.6887305975,
-0.0385657474,
0.1836438477,
0.4143253267,
0.7857065201,
-0.6898568869,
-0.3721895218,
-1.06463027,
0.5665782094,
-0.0183830671,
-0.2471223772,
0.4762981534,
0.5830690861,
0.6485508084,
-0.2657886147,
0.4546720982,
0.3475376964,
-0.2336697578,
-0.5710729361,
0.4655069411,
-0.6433131099,
0.109511815,
0.2021716535,
-1.0055474043,
-0.2359088957,
0.5506041646,
0.001626873,
0.2999562323,
0.8048257828,
0.5806788206,
-0.3655771613,
0.2973088622,
0.2645748556,
-0.0178660899,
0.0187926628,
0.8556373715,
1.1903426647,
-0.1476612985,
0.1018458232,
-0.7333756685,
0.017384015,
-0.0548609272,
-0.5866903067,
-0.7787111998,
-0.3683425784,
-0.2260380685,
-0.2527745068,
-0.2768422663,
0.6752817035,
0.8372710943,
-0.6656224728,
-0.1194973439,
-0.5759552717,
0.0626500323,
-0.2719601691,
-0.202980727,
0.2025778592,
-0.3272242844,
-0.2198888808,
0.2082705945,
0.320266366,
0.218609482,
-0.4176605344,
0.1069304496,
0.3127521276,
0.0449140258,
0.7031501532,
-0.0443723015,
-0.6371868253,
0.0814899802,
0.2635335028,
-0.2929925323,
-0.0591720231,
1.2137900591,
-0.364169687,
0.1821705103,
0.903178215,
0.6818609834,
0.2539383769,
0.0783870667,
0.3277821243,
-1.0110555887,
-0.1130662933,
0.7257781029,
0.7402819395,
0.1071916819,
-0.3731611669,
0.7238340378,
0.4335128367,
-0.33613047,
-0.3706093431,
0.221894294,
-0.9682637453,
-0.2968023419,
1.0919249058,
-0.1784591377,
-0.1247366071,
0.1788568795,
0.099562481,
0.0880013108,
-0.006830676,
0.4969496727,
0.765748024,
-0.306111902,
-0.1666051894,
-0.2114289701,
0.1908156574,
0.5082035065,
-0.5604689717,
-0.2168140411,
0.8865909576,
-0.1067896932,
0.1532773525,
0.6851843596,
-0.0425220728,
0.621637702,
0.3237055838,
-0.3468243778,
-0.3827546239,
-0.6020065546,
-0.22154966,
0.3288326263,
0.2205122262,
0.0172792412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07863v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07863v4 | Speculative Decoding with Big Little Decoder | 2023-02-15T18:55:29 | 2023-10-12T17:23:56 | Sehoon Kim, Karttikeya Mangalam, Suhong Moon, Jitendra Malik, Michael W. Mahoney, Amir Gholami, Kurt Keutzer | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent emergence of Large Language Models based on the Transformer
architecture has enabled dramatic advancements in the field of Natural Language
Processing. However, these models have long inference latency, which limits
their deployment and makes them prohibitively expensive for various real-time
applications. The inference latency is further exacerbated by autoregressive
generative tasks, as models need to run iteratively to generate tokens
sequentially without leveraging token-level parallelization. To address this,
we propose Big Little Decoder (BiLD), a framework that can improve inference
efficiency and latency for a wide range of text generation applications. The
BiLD framework contains two models with different sizes that collaboratively
generate text. The small model runs autoregressively to generate text with a
low inference cost, and the large model is only invoked occasionally to refine
the small model's inaccurate predictions in a non-autoregressive manner. To
coordinate the small and large models, BiLD introduces two simple yet effective
policies: (1) the fallback policy that determines when to hand control over to
the large model; and (2) the rollback policy that determines when the large
model needs to correct the small model's inaccurate predictions. To evaluate
our framework across different tasks and models, we apply BiLD to various text
generation scenarios encompassing machine translation on IWSLT 2017 De-En and
WMT 2014 De-En, and summarization on XSUM and CNN/DailyMail. On an NVIDIA T4
GPU, our framework achieves a speedup of up to 2.12x speedup with minimal
generation quality degradation. Furthermore, our framework is fully
plug-and-play and can be applied without any modifications in the training
process or model architecture. Our code is open-sourced | [
-0.1381702125,
-0.7003059983,
0.3471577168,
0.5042766929,
-0.2275133878,
0.0384713635,
-0.2881438434,
-0.4494073689,
-0.0498072244,
0.4518615603,
-0.334305644,
-0.1812322885,
-0.4274031222,
0.1433623284,
-0.3879075646,
1.1246677637,
0.2107608616,
-0.3588279784,
-0.0321246237,
0.1192836836,
-0.2978210151,
-0.3484473825,
-0.7473878264,
-0.3320387304,
0.4007889926,
0.3391534686,
0.8549938202,
0.7255672216,
0.4032368362,
0.2264051288,
-0.2429183573,
0.2954725027,
-0.6361246705,
-0.0256318264,
-0.5177419186,
-0.2500647604,
-0.3014558554,
-0.4016456902,
0.712977767,
0.7184907794,
-0.1006588265,
0.2204037905,
0.089082405,
0.6333200932,
-0.7165774703,
0.3245662451,
-0.3784594536,
-0.1104349867,
-0.3049083054,
-0.1282632351,
-0.8232188225,
-0.3481609225,
-0.1790260524,
-0.2863492668,
0.5738610029,
0.4460406005,
0.9210548997,
0.4045464694,
-0.4264156818,
-0.1784018129,
-1.1170990467,
0.6639389992,
-1.0535116196,
0.2689754963,
0.1683758944,
0.280759722,
-0.2570609152,
-0.8396260142,
-0.8676780462,
0.0679775774,
-0.2521370351,
0.0035871889,
-0.5295165181,
0.0318452939,
0.384262234,
0.697293818,
-0.7809146047,
0.2563104033,
-0.0750786364,
-0.1540920436,
0.4515918195,
0.4649628103,
-0.1125472859,
-0.442866534,
-0.0769911334,
-0.1970172822,
-0.6494847536,
-0.1841410697,
0.4619573951,
0.2975251079,
-0.2915432751,
0.5525710583,
-0.0643775612,
0.5144141316,
0.2781395018,
0.1615756154,
0.1421745718,
-0.6367913485,
-0.2891190052,
-0.0519628935,
0.9300968051,
0.3323750496,
-0.349550426,
-0.3172853291,
-0.0640087947,
0.2445498556,
0.1524573267,
-1.1781249046,
-0.5465080142,
0.1731170863,
-0.5949437618,
-0.2342625856,
-0.1367255151,
-0.9153299928,
-0.2002505064,
0.0707982406,
0.1074216962,
-0.5006703734,
-0.2448733747,
0.3192112148,
-0.083793968,
0.1874896139,
0.0374019407,
-1.1484320164,
0.0996003449,
0.6082829833,
0.8104209304,
-0.1159262434,
-0.1279648095,
-0.9191583991,
0.2653317153,
-0.6063809395,
0.5605000257,
-0.1403602958,
-0.3373634815,
-0.1314988136,
0.1223019361,
0.0260365605,
-0.267048806,
0.5602318645,
-0.7707269788,
0.2150687277,
0.0548947938,
-0.5114105344,
0.0421827473,
0.0791220963,
-0.8489132524,
0.887507081,
0.1422914863,
-1.1533956528,
0.4222457707,
-0.6492997408,
-0.7066876292,
0.0399885848,
-0.0552765168,
-0.6305679679,
0.2650896311,
0.1661982238,
0.2913660407,
-0.6067156792,
0.2094509453,
-0.1055943519,
-0.4162634611,
-0.1815011352,
-0.7663180828,
0.7139674425,
0.2726674974,
-0.4695689976,
-0.021932302,
-0.7914941311,
-0.0690431148,
0.1241790205,
-0.4713779688,
-0.1931589246,
0.0877429619,
0.2265578508,
0.0229993928,
-0.0306689143,
-0.6643605232,
0.2487112731,
-0.9262033701,
0.4402154982,
0.4278198779,
0.0943906903,
0.67031914,
-0.0255943257,
0.3722251356,
0.0224027056,
-0.1923161298,
-0.3229088783,
-0.2822845578,
-0.8056789637,
-0.3069541752,
0.5337762237,
0.2953807712,
-1.3035563231,
0.5858428478,
-0.5703088045,
-0.3807108402,
-0.4968783259,
0.0416308828,
0.4501156211,
0.3326448798,
0.2231165916,
0.1776990891,
-0.5200205445,
-0.7237013578,
-0.0975686833,
-0.3084048033,
-0.1371534318,
-0.1165749431,
0.4372911751,
-0.4503386915,
1.0073956251,
-0.4194509089,
0.0072741671,
-0.3506236672,
0.3647762835,
0.4952169061,
0.5296927094,
0.579652071,
-0.6527630687,
-0.4641191065,
0.1087427214,
-0.5650966167,
0.0492888615,
-0.1449973583,
-0.224195078,
0.7216508389,
0.4521265328,
-0.7442420125,
0.5431768894,
0.759589076,
-0.5414068103,
0.4866071045,
-0.3803329766,
-0.0729293004,
-1.039516449,
0.2521773279,
-0.5084496737,
-0.3888963461,
-0.3348993957,
0.0179311726,
0.0533135496,
-0.0635244399,
-0.0041170153,
0.5755819082,
-0.4516901076,
-0.0358934142,
-0.4525029063,
-0.3330366015,
0.477814883,
0.1809196621,
-0.0087944781,
1.0154857635,
0.1730815619,
-0.6343434453,
0.1318913996,
0.1386842579,
-0.2110614181,
0.2251456827,
-0.6511959434,
0.0637931749,
-0.2285085768,
0.3316025734,
-0.8177381158,
-0.4246123731,
0.2699355185,
-0.3772923052,
0.4115307331,
-0.294162184,
-0.8924875259,
-0.737676084,
-0.1410072446,
0.2991292179,
0.6319176555,
-0.9191637635,
0.6941847205,
0.0051835608,
-0.0621281229,
-0.4883347452,
-0.934409976,
0.264751941,
0.1088168323,
-0.6402620077,
0.2653936446,
-0.1465877891,
0.0128735956,
0.3677320182,
0.1856788844,
0.1176576093,
-0.1796379834,
0.1795432568,
0.4027211666,
-0.4557395875,
-0.0180673152,
0.2774519026,
-0.4640818536,
-0.0141665991,
-0.5388279557,
0.4440161586,
-0.2155544311,
-0.2759271264,
-0.2068958431,
0.5302252173,
0.5150713325,
-0.0102038793,
0.7842265964,
0.7127921581,
-0.0872920081,
-0.4489239752,
-0.2920436561,
-0.0393249989,
-0.4759300947,
0.1697247177,
-0.4194729924,
-0.708366096,
0.2637141049,
0.0828057751,
0.2735218406,
0.5192296505,
0.9442093968,
-0.0576484948,
0.9304872155,
0.8776627779,
0.0256492756,
0.2236485183,
-0.3766792417,
0.5449319482,
-0.382037133,
0.0191514343,
-0.3347673714,
-0.0331110507,
-0.4603433311,
-0.662076354,
-0.0531374328,
0.1039570868,
-0.1207015961,
0.2862914205,
-0.5554425716,
0.5408962369,
0.5532457829,
-0.3652073741,
0.4562445283,
0.1619343162,
0.0639962107,
-0.0654399917,
-1.0820499659,
-0.4435838163,
0.8054269552,
0.2744246125,
0.9850519896,
0.3449762166,
0.5259484053,
0.5191054344,
0.1866670102,
-0.6608246565,
0.2816898227,
-0.2741039693,
-0.5626803637,
-0.1592016518,
-0.5714116693,
-0.8885856271,
0.2109192759,
-0.1334749758,
-0.4104601443,
0.4567361772,
0.5796744227,
-0.4243433177,
0.4958435893,
-0.8292021751,
0.9099938273,
0.2256255448,
-0.7495133281,
-0.1022256836,
-0.5868207812,
0.4363216758,
-0.0081158038,
0.0557854958,
0.2307932228,
0.1834255457,
0.4035176039,
-0.5695713758,
0.8173069358,
-0.1815235168,
-0.1275464296,
0.283614397,
0.2095054388,
0.7760196328,
0.0766286626,
-0.3247113824,
0.159798786,
0.1452770829,
-0.4446436465,
-0.4128879607,
0.6141893864,
-0.5971722007,
-0.1397357136,
-0.4715008736,
-0.4837793112,
-0.0932107195,
0.2647849917,
0.8493885398,
0.3312242627,
-0.1498038173,
0.214794904,
0.6181625128,
-0.0409062468,
0.7178123593,
0.3991671205,
-0.3580927849,
-0.2154209465,
1.1585530043,
-0.2418013662,
0.2225535661,
0.2799386978,
0.0980006531,
-0.289622575,
-0.628013134,
-0.8677822948,
0.2542412877,
-0.441399157,
-0.444776237,
-0.7234660387,
-0.3372021317,
-0.3960890472,
-0.1691510081,
-0.5697562695,
-0.2011487335,
-0.2468618602,
0.0336969309,
0.250565052,
0.614325881,
-0.1851890981,
0.5505853891,
-0.7840437889,
0.4344483316,
-0.0654506832,
0.2726941705,
0.1538285613,
-0.4081063569,
-0.5526922345,
-0.1195448712,
-0.0370972343,
-0.292444855,
0.4259001613,
0.1159541905,
0.1314469427,
0.369946748,
0.4567678869,
0.3507778943,
-0.7331475616,
0.6889951825,
0.2999393344,
-0.8072938323,
0.1136926562,
-0.1434911638,
0.4064467251,
0.3899834752,
-0.0705960542,
-0.2664736211,
-0.3251239955,
-0.484136492,
-0.89058882,
0.8431491256,
0.3919817805,
0.125874877,
-0.2171119303,
-0.0949907303,
0.3065940142,
0.1875164211,
-0.3639135361,
-0.0082413228,
-0.3837080002,
-0.2828889787,
-0.0040740618,
-0.550874114,
-0.028261438,
0.055295147,
0.5201665759,
-0.3212133944,
0.4296974242,
-0.0456966534,
-0.1311827302,
-0.0815761015,
0.3244700134,
0.1129225418,
0.3632690609,
-0.1359487474,
0.1772289872,
-0.1062986404,
-0.4109561145,
0.025576992,
0.2887260318,
-0.4664953947,
0.3383363783,
0.4484185576,
1.0083562136,
0.2145756185,
-0.5810889006,
0.5983603597,
-0.2240607738,
-0.2007659525,
-0.2124698013,
-0.0490189567,
0.0807927921,
0.3705852926,
0.2256593704,
0.2541944981,
0.3293393254,
-0.3602212369,
0.0847412869,
0.1028284505,
0.1000440866,
-0.4166508615,
0.8479847908,
0.2502130568,
-0.1801332831,
0.5537520051,
-0.5986281633,
-0.2050342709,
0.3970149457,
0.8322965503,
0.7638374567,
0.215231806,
0.1418205053,
0.3709546328,
0.2875829339,
-0.0327180177,
0.1556527168,
-0.0092608575,
-0.502767086,
-0.8706377745,
-0.8534291387,
-0.4274094403,
-0.0995063782,
-0.5311956406,
-0.0768013522,
-0.445672214,
-0.2142571509,
0.0665708557,
-0.1652049422,
-0.6368818283,
-0.0818018764,
0.136493966,
0.8714268208,
-0.5352506042,
0.7146593332,
0.3739880323,
-0.3140451312,
-0.6573241949,
0.2976740301,
-0.1487464607,
-0.1560015976,
0.6480661035,
0.0386616215,
-0.4018976092,
0.1373261511,
-0.3034130633,
-0.6641200781,
0.7907227874,
0.4528132081,
-0.6950657368,
-0.6299859285,
-0.0535735786,
0.5264558792,
-0.1821215749,
0.032364428,
0.61984092,
0.2557859421,
0.2842568159,
-0.6326033473,
0.0864973813,
-0.2099027932,
0.2735567689,
0.1805129498,
-0.5164992213,
0.8646351695,
-0.2940993309,
-0.5044997334,
0.2849630415,
0.8207511306,
-0.0102404654,
0.2859464288,
0.3571628034,
0.3686264753,
0.7028151751,
-0.0021986892,
1.3727408648,
-0.4064932466,
0.456799686,
1.2479662895,
-0.1276099086,
0.8041950464,
0.3385622799,
-0.0648020655,
0.5207423568,
0.3220149875,
-0.083506152,
0.5141333938,
-0.2325344086,
-0.1602211446,
-0.2478065342,
0.0846151412,
-0.2655022144,
0.2151747793,
0.3406083584,
-0.2804121971,
-0.390678674,
0.2499001771,
0.091858834,
0.0738223195,
-0.0868164897,
0.524944663,
-0.0358200707,
-0.4161366522,
0.6180895567,
0.2398171872,
0.6662387252,
-0.4484397471,
-0.0480035953,
-0.2230966687,
0.5545933247,
-0.1728753746,
-0.6468921304,
0.5862306952,
0.0721283555,
-0.7261212468,
-0.0342144221,
0.7117447853,
-0.3661559224,
-0.4655266702,
0.2758720219,
0.2161372602,
-0.0879700705,
0.0903355256,
-0.3447258472,
0.3890044093,
0.0290657002,
-0.2926191688,
-0.0702973306,
0.6340736747,
-0.0232215393,
0.4458211958,
0.8926153183,
0.159945026,
0.1082963496,
0.0478421599,
0.9795594811,
-0.6490644217,
-0.7776553631,
-0.7832184434,
0.4256569445,
-0.3693488836,
0.0666145161,
0.8912556171,
0.7006186247,
0.5749379396,
-0.1647581011,
0.7760366201,
-0.3240842521,
0.6518153548,
-0.6193698049,
0.6695538759,
-0.2505925596,
0.3643451333,
-0.0310971476,
-0.8503676653,
-0.1465967596,
0.4006364942,
-0.3957743049,
-0.3129328787,
0.6846707463,
0.6679617763,
-0.2229487747,
0.0226936173,
0.2844557762,
0.2851825356,
0.4840986133,
0.4690208137,
0.5434833765,
-0.443551451,
0.8874819279,
-0.1175815463,
-0.1136433631,
-0.5639683604,
-0.7799375057,
-0.9513626695,
-0.149724707,
-0.067223683,
-0.6675209403,
0.0600260533,
0.707105279,
0.7549419999,
-0.7146078348,
0.0951689482,
-0.180579111,
0.0468614623,
-0.0767310634,
-0.308698535,
0.3962782025,
-0.4832386672,
-0.8410400748,
0.2704065144,
0.3996113837,
-0.0788251907,
-0.256406486,
-0.1609601825,
0.0036203361,
0.1193860769,
0.8294572234,
0.4928798676,
-0.3822011352,
-0.15831846,
-0.1897221208,
-0.394659102,
-0.0570323616,
0.8843756318,
-0.7237305045,
0.353148222,
0.522398293,
1.0670506954,
0.8572930694,
-0.0520974919,
0.5666275024,
-0.5526733398,
0.3718355298,
0.3570415676,
0.1130952835,
0.4157311916,
-0.4457803667,
0.4460113645,
0.2952950001,
-0.493224293,
-0.8918495774,
0.2800385058,
-0.655931592,
-0.2460975349,
0.8580139875,
-0.1264753193,
-0.4963352382,
-0.1541590393,
-0.1668818295,
0.0044634473,
-0.3009282053,
0.3993267417,
0.4035223126,
0.0337179378,
-0.1414567977,
-0.3687947989,
0.4484798014,
0.1955311745,
-0.4961186349,
0.6444506645,
0.6827676892,
0.037678495,
0.1964529008,
0.597273469,
0.0491477326,
0.1769891828,
0.6785669923,
0.0445456803,
-0.1474703252,
-0.2615264356,
-0.1440197974,
0.1201313064,
0.0564709827,
-0.1491609961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07856v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07856v1 | Dictionary-based Phrase-level Prompting of Large Language Models for Machine Translation | 2023-02-15T18:46:42 | 2023-02-15T18:46:42 | Marjan Ghazvininejad, Hila Gonen, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable machine translation (MT)
abilities via prompting, even though they were not explicitly trained for this
task. However, even given the incredible quantities of data they are trained
on, LLMs can struggle to translate inputs with rare words, which are common in
low resource or domain transfer scenarios. We show that LLM prompting can
provide an effective solution for rare words as well, by using prior knowledge
from bilingual dictionaries to provide control hints in the prompts. We propose
a novel method, DiPMT, that provides a set of possible translations for a
subset of the input words, thereby enabling fine-grained phrase-level prompted
control of the LLM. Extensive experiments show that DiPMT outperforms the
baseline both in low-resource MT, as well as for out-of-domain MT. We further
provide a qualitative analysis of the benefits and limitations of this
approach, including the overall level of controllability that is achieved. | [
-0.3516261876,
-0.9272715449,
0.704022646,
0.3873765767,
-0.3594156802,
0.0606927313,
-0.3472315669,
0.1703067571,
0.0245453566,
0.4954876602,
-0.7421984076,
-0.4388528466,
-0.803838551,
0.5580459833,
-0.4953073859,
0.7768223882,
-0.2615325451,
-0.0491891541,
-0.090865612,
0.0920955092,
-0.6027011871,
-0.4839583933,
-0.5092608333,
-0.4686374366,
0.702840209,
0.4292725921,
0.7566301227,
0.3088115156,
0.3689243197,
0.1974080354,
-0.4948118329,
0.6467775106,
-0.5302955508,
0.0778654069,
-0.1426692903,
-0.5989890695,
-0.4965226352,
-0.1334345788,
0.6250464916,
1.0542912483,
0.0164468847,
-0.2255573571,
0.4242506921,
0.6031798124,
-0.3652328551,
-0.0844473019,
-0.893327713,
0.2853085995,
-0.0523518994,
-0.4454030991,
-0.4519034326,
-0.164945662,
0.0420747399,
-0.6806881428,
0.1330362409,
-0.0806933567,
0.6412129402,
0.429261446,
-0.4973212779,
-0.2910401225,
-0.5593345761,
0.7912015915,
-0.611038208,
0.1859464049,
0.6000093222,
0.0144915972,
-0.4698548317,
-0.4655939937,
-0.7586647272,
-0.3961371183,
0.1107335165,
0.1118349656,
-0.2112030089,
-0.0456920005,
0.3721824586,
0.2290650904,
-0.3644554019,
0.431227088,
-0.1549537778,
-0.050446447,
-0.047871843,
0.3922571242,
0.1274863333,
-0.1964776665,
-0.4343144596,
0.0346041657,
-1.107809782,
0.0111296009,
-0.0688754693,
0.6014464498,
-0.3089503944,
0.8695977926,
-0.3616642356,
0.9181827903,
0.2674666643,
0.0646367893,
0.130013451,
-0.2939760089,
-0.0939481184,
-0.3132972419,
0.8172466755,
0.469463557,
0.31230703,
-0.0512555428,
-0.4849155247,
-0.4366527796,
-0.069010973,
-0.7113575339,
0.1278450787,
0.3292585015,
-0.3367948234,
-0.0776758417,
-0.2367939502,
-0.6137107611,
-0.6687701344,
-0.3801366091,
0.6836793423,
-0.51362288,
-0.0831513181,
-0.0692376941,
-0.0975942537,
0.1720209569,
0.4987407029,
-0.9322368503,
-0.1215562746,
0.5433188677,
1.1930782795,
-0.3003754318,
-0.4089689255,
-1.0703786612,
0.1684983671,
-0.4731464386,
0.3409506083,
-0.4715231359,
-0.8574039936,
0.2192570865,
-0.1051904112,
-0.0317352377,
-0.8270422816,
0.2198500186,
-0.5799229145,
-0.0247497931,
-0.4065630436,
-0.4058803022,
0.2374073863,
0.3778475821,
-0.5429199338,
0.8987951279,
0.1674509197,
-0.59939605,
0.2791900039,
-0.4664034545,
-0.6276378036,
0.1124322489,
-0.0817053542,
0.1211096793,
0.4463644624,
0.6466190219,
0.739805162,
-0.2014964223,
0.2328754812,
-0.1058764234,
-0.1167820543,
0.508000195,
-0.649580121,
0.6341488957,
0.3488147259,
-0.0901287869,
-0.120053634,
-0.4248085916,
-0.2040629387,
0.0032780226,
-0.5516941547,
-0.366073817,
-0.2320637554,
-0.3598096371,
0.30243963,
0.5223796964,
0.0046260348,
0.5972800851,
-0.4170493782,
0.4217007756,
0.7359519005,
0.0094331196,
0.5102847815,
-0.1571085155,
0.8050304055,
0.2153383195,
0.026688857,
-0.1387660503,
-0.5077494383,
-0.6390398145,
-0.4101722538,
0.3620952666,
0.7063446045,
-1.2540552616,
0.5501865149,
-0.2295750678,
-0.0027030183,
-0.5962114334,
0.4825417697,
0.3139414191,
0.6266331077,
0.4751105011,
0.0495463982,
-0.043506436,
-0.6785140038,
-0.0784059241,
0.1368194222,
-0.2711200118,
0.2423554957,
0.2922387123,
-0.2659180164,
0.922224164,
-0.2461295873,
-0.2722902596,
-0.537381351,
0.3512960374,
0.6154654622,
0.3614814281,
0.2213234901,
-0.7150942683,
-0.5839108825,
0.2048332393,
-0.4617530406,
-0.6034983993,
-0.3066987395,
-0.0197875258,
0.0128842024,
0.6810907125,
-0.7377990484,
0.031258598,
0.7388131618,
0.0487770885,
0.2259436548,
-0.5521556139,
0.123361364,
-1.2723770142,
0.1329173595,
-0.2613196671,
-0.3593079448,
-0.5982052684,
-0.1313220412,
0.3347772658,
0.1041751802,
-0.6636070609,
0.6930657029,
-0.4521823823,
0.2714867294,
-0.4184457362,
0.3938905895,
-0.1106895879,
0.1968796104,
0.0423832797,
0.8548893332,
0.509822607,
-0.8596940637,
0.3219868541,
0.3639196754,
-0.1197610721,
0.8880773783,
-0.6073010564,
-0.0596976541,
-0.00923762,
0.1899127811,
-0.8558223844,
-0.1535987705,
0.2663823962,
-0.4834008813,
0.4866958857,
-0.2948593795,
-0.6722280383,
-0.4307740629,
0.0233296808,
0.0759962201,
0.6640887856,
-0.6735665798,
0.3741103113,
-0.004574819,
-0.4781411588,
-0.4315490127,
-0.655502975,
0.328704983,
-0.2404622436,
-0.1061798632,
0.1462078393,
-0.2244553268,
-0.0549967401,
-0.2233887464,
-0.0039334274,
-0.1782346964,
0.3007200062,
0.1560334861,
0.3892047405,
0.148922056,
-0.0296866354,
0.5078057647,
-0.1336588711,
-0.0838264823,
-0.4349268377,
0.6960963011,
0.2218552381,
-0.2076426297,
-0.5093330145,
0.4186516702,
0.4509963393,
-0.1309679449,
0.7218546867,
0.4525390863,
-0.2058205158,
-0.4288599789,
-0.1788963079,
-0.1739225537,
-0.4727388918,
0.2146411985,
-0.6421117187,
-1.042216301,
0.3894240856,
-0.4177376628,
-0.1166501045,
0.3278415501,
0.9450083375,
-0.0911823809,
1.3844097853,
0.4484894872,
-0.2600740194,
0.4397218227,
-0.2487520128,
0.0494764894,
-0.7321920991,
0.0004062763,
-0.5847250223,
-0.3941973448,
-0.3516842127,
-0.6578434706,
0.649192512,
0.4064757228,
0.1674035341,
0.1806562245,
-0.1511347592,
0.5919426084,
0.714359045,
0.0252336301,
0.3844559789,
0.1626940668,
-0.5930346847,
0.0946827829,
-0.8775683641,
-0.3976590037,
0.863114059,
0.1441739798,
0.7364755869,
-0.10830345,
0.8871470094,
0.1456361264,
0.1163056344,
-1.0036714077,
0.561942935,
-0.224945426,
-0.3702266216,
-0.2514081299,
-0.760890007,
-1.0373505354,
0.0875649974,
-0.0968944207,
-0.4842455387,
0.0236829165,
0.3184665442,
-0.5947173238,
-0.0661847144,
-0.5440374613,
0.5839188099,
-0.2673944831,
-0.1015335768,
-0.1287152171,
-0.7038679123,
0.0796033293,
-0.4579709768,
0.3248796761,
-0.0069543053,
-0.4054600894,
0.4064324796,
-0.5898599625,
1.071690321,
-0.2577219903,
-0.4717523754,
-0.0416600667,
0.397574991,
0.8847156763,
-0.069684878,
0.1144094765,
0.0609658584,
-0.0728402063,
-0.2427550703,
-0.3793752193,
0.7994298339,
-0.5654837489,
-0.6734423041,
-0.0977240205,
-0.819858551,
-0.5504443049,
0.4251784086,
0.4915926158,
0.1990254819,
0.0900415853,
0.2040365934,
0.8660596013,
-0.4124011397,
0.2946587801,
0.6117750406,
-0.2767691016,
-0.454336971,
0.8286642432,
0.0661312342,
0.4828644395,
0.7483428121,
0.3673188388,
-0.4127962589,
-0.6891683936,
-0.6220348477,
0.2804862559,
-0.5604584217,
-0.2701739371,
-0.5584686995,
0.1623259485,
-0.3177564144,
-0.3756383955,
-0.0910016894,
-0.4821859002,
-0.453686595,
0.0008502162,
0.3948889375,
0.6211118698,
-0.1670416892,
0.5401340127,
-1.122431159,
0.6164724827,
0.3339767158,
0.0155682834,
-0.2811153829,
-0.8788642287,
-0.2746928036,
0.1124622449,
-0.1019773409,
-0.9100123644,
0.530767262,
0.0953146294,
0.4835038185,
0.4603202343,
0.1694351584,
0.6704800129,
-0.7505277991,
1.0332142115,
0.3150820136,
-1.0909610987,
0.6446117163,
-0.3781934083,
0.5563775897,
0.3202951849,
0.5992552042,
-0.6723695397,
-0.6697083116,
-0.2567432821,
-0.9051237106,
0.7574558258,
-0.111150004,
0.4826343656,
-0.2225934118,
0.1120000631,
0.2432859838,
0.3173428476,
-0.4769380391,
-0.0817739964,
0.1046595722,
-0.2566143572,
-0.0344633386,
-0.1347345859,
-0.3298579156,
0.0476935543,
0.4895739257,
-0.2163888216,
-0.1678003371,
0.1935317069,
-0.3153686523,
-0.1547191739,
0.3804478049,
0.4956283271,
0.5560881495,
-0.0104480851,
0.316303134,
0.3859027922,
-0.1823082119,
0.1133904383,
0.079869397,
-0.3976174295,
0.058857169,
0.2315099984,
0.641772151,
-0.0086386856,
-0.5769119263,
0.5209797621,
0.2829297185,
-0.2285539955,
0.2991549075,
-0.0594969355,
0.0666512847,
0.1976782531,
0.309074223,
-0.3530813158,
-0.1739195734,
-0.1212580502,
-0.2253195941,
0.520830214,
-0.2463509142,
-0.1141413525,
0.6521478891,
0.3289569616,
-0.0555723496,
0.533474803,
-0.146343857,
-0.5483464599,
0.2437243611,
0.544958353,
0.6902257204,
-0.1964122355,
0.2740225792,
0.0532041155,
0.3977091908,
-0.3178598583,
0.2632379234,
-0.2588211,
-0.5799466372,
-0.5562493801,
-0.5221505165,
-0.5181691051,
0.2662547231,
-0.4874848127,
0.1770869046,
-0.303812921,
-0.1770913005,
-0.4009326398,
-0.2897067368,
-0.6566333771,
-0.0934075043,
0.201770857,
1.1970380545,
-0.7094588876,
0.9640198946,
0.5371508002,
-0.4119493961,
-0.7530481815,
-0.0770349205,
0.0107701989,
-1.0281393528,
0.775555253,
-0.08102227,
-0.1437601745,
0.3153173625,
-0.6056964397,
-0.4513721168,
0.8327056766,
0.2577874959,
-0.840719223,
0.0310009383,
0.5098741651,
0.3421852887,
0.0520600118,
-0.262689501,
0.5256099701,
0.5603065491,
0.2494560182,
-1.1128510237,
-0.0346850678,
0.0126901129,
0.1786319762,
0.1798538566,
-0.1658841521,
0.802154839,
-0.1523295194,
-0.0572888218,
0.2611951232,
0.5729329586,
0.1924862862,
0.1441037804,
0.5990021229,
0.3164283931,
0.8798218369,
0.0926107243,
0.9340143204,
-0.258631587,
0.1383633167,
0.9703440666,
-0.4106770754,
0.9500527978,
0.903811276,
-0.1297550648,
-0.1473416686,
0.5578705668,
0.2115723044,
0.5442070365,
0.0709744394,
-0.3499266207,
-0.3963798285,
-0.3008852303,
-0.5493847728,
-0.0415237285,
0.5874546766,
-0.3889260888,
-0.1972477883,
0.2209475487,
0.1305022687,
-0.1148483604,
-0.5123872161,
0.7535843253,
0.3786021471,
-0.7709124684,
1.0189603567,
-0.190235287,
0.6794137359,
-0.6669433713,
0.1636946052,
-0.6635994911,
0.0186246317,
0.062490426,
-0.8090447187,
-0.0645470098,
0.3634982407,
-0.1425713599,
-0.6513689756,
0.2240820974,
-0.6749741435,
-0.2766722441,
0.0976950973,
0.9989487529,
0.1214107946,
-0.2065769136,
-0.5900878906,
-0.0891451016,
-0.1034420952,
-0.2098521739,
0.341976285,
1.0216382742,
-0.0674650967,
0.6219380498,
0.575956881,
0.6005843878,
0.201646477,
0.1909709275,
0.8907954693,
-0.5755184293,
-0.4725835621,
-0.7787076235,
0.3024367988,
0.0924614593,
-0.1397145838,
0.7887836099,
0.1663541198,
0.7389222383,
-0.3227275014,
0.9012218118,
-0.0249435604,
0.5703336596,
-0.8487538695,
0.5115895867,
-0.7403768897,
0.419457227,
0.0043077799,
-0.788397491,
-0.4498944581,
0.2786213458,
-0.3439976275,
-0.2621120512,
0.6895951629,
1.0255545378,
-0.0524315052,
-0.5364599824,
0.6101258993,
0.4329229295,
0.2367213815,
0.6989440322,
1.2638837099,
0.3494111598,
0.712915659,
0.0872685462,
-0.4096481204,
-0.3690903187,
-1.0561152697,
-0.9420851469,
-0.4699431658,
-0.0267793685,
-0.3510344625,
-0.1248155907,
1.226365447,
0.3687780201,
-0.8480721116,
-0.1402269751,
-0.129659161,
0.2294370234,
-0.2846033573,
-0.1014175564,
0.1315313131,
-0.5875757337,
-1.0774973631,
0.8216095567,
0.2091805935,
0.2739156783,
-0.1437843442,
-0.2090216726,
0.1139253899,
0.0181284044,
0.6194909215,
0.1452969611,
-0.741963923,
0.1192637309,
0.0059028431,
-0.3353663981,
-0.1646425128,
1.0111421347,
-0.6813232899,
0.4155264497,
0.7176067233,
0.6836559176,
0.0418743417,
-0.1824252754,
0.719799757,
-0.951072216,
0.1866335422,
0.1427809447,
0.4067157209,
0.2914615571,
-0.1286735535,
0.1407852769,
0.1733926982,
-0.267043829,
-0.8192395568,
0.1847215891,
-0.9427346587,
-0.3179701269,
1.3418320417,
-0.2015951127,
-0.1522923708,
0.0187437031,
-0.5571540594,
0.2025685906,
-0.358448267,
0.7504543662,
0.7205080986,
0.2055103332,
-0.0916039348,
-0.5181002021,
0.4258542359,
0.6240397692,
-0.6138779521,
0.3576809764,
0.6745981574,
-0.0615403019,
-0.126924783,
0.5630130768,
-0.0521455184,
0.0608437248,
-0.5222768784,
-0.2849444449,
-0.142810598,
-0.4350335002,
-0.8473576903,
0.03541575,
0.3266562521,
-0.0280682947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07845v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07845v3 | NL2CMD: An Updated Workflow for Natural Language to Bash Commands Translation | 2023-02-15T18:31:36 | 2023-06-18T16:27:16 | Quchen Fu, Zhongwei Teng, Marco Georgaklis, Jules White, Douglas C. Schmidt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.PF | Translating natural language into Bash Commands is an emerging research field
that has gained attention in recent years. Most efforts have focused on
producing more accurate translation models. To the best of our knowledge, only
two datasets are available, with one based on the other. Both datasets involve
scraping through known data sources (through platforms like stack overflow,
crowdsourcing, etc.) and hiring experts to validate and correct either the
English text or Bash Commands. This paper provides two contributions to
research on synthesizing Bash Commands from scratch. First, we describe a
state-of-the-art translation model used to generate Bash Commands from the
corresponding English text. Second, we introduce a new NL2CMD dataset that is
automatically generated, involves minimal human intervention, and is over six
times larger than prior datasets. Since the generation pipeline does not rely
on existing Bash Commands, the distribution and types of commands can be custom
adjusted. We evaluate the performance of ChatGPT on this task and discuss the
potential of using it as a data generator. Our empirical results show how the
scale and diversity of our dataset can offer unique opportunities for semantic
parsing researchers. | [
-0.2395121902,
-0.8702869415,
0.4459047914,
0.0603315756,
-0.3860118687,
0.2187246829,
-0.3793008626,
-0.2768598795,
0.2331391275,
0.9118981361,
-0.7096120119,
-0.6873025894,
-0.6542544365,
0.0978320912,
-0.4019542634,
1.3357656002,
0.0158635732,
0.2041848898,
-0.0245864838,
-0.0631615072,
-0.5159604549,
-0.4147906601,
-0.7317789793,
0.0293514635,
0.3811049163,
0.595210135,
0.878088057,
0.7031402588,
0.9459713697,
0.1938419491,
0.0828734189,
0.4393773377,
-0.2928781509,
0.2839329541,
-0.2998902798,
-0.2833984494,
-0.2194553167,
0.0006211326,
0.3829135895,
0.8919312954,
-0.1989542544,
0.2468288541,
-0.1837873012,
0.5791281462,
-0.2279084027,
0.115778774,
-0.9152215123,
0.0978783369,
-0.2914430499,
0.0581021197,
-0.4628807306,
-0.3698765039,
0.1340380758,
-0.5886188149,
0.3779240847,
0.1986857355,
0.5432202816,
0.2560252845,
-0.4783563018,
-0.564396143,
-0.6893616915,
0.695279479,
-1.1196826696,
0.229476884,
0.0527464375,
0.5218469501,
-0.412294209,
-1.1474790573,
-0.4449080229,
-0.1196099967,
-0.1028049737,
0.0745773613,
-0.3748930097,
-0.0006158007,
0.2750598788,
0.1853299737,
-0.5119630694,
0.2658808529,
-0.4335596263,
-0.1817153096,
0.4268076718,
0.260553956,
0.4863908887,
-0.428981185,
-0.5127385855,
-0.2816283107,
-0.4348401129,
-0.2087670267,
0.4634220004,
0.5099458694,
0.0348633789,
1.0411052704,
-0.1195881218,
0.5316843987,
-0.261931777,
0.0090577509,
0.0704245865,
-0.6133477688,
-0.0128554339,
0.0774550661,
0.9590471983,
0.7724143863,
0.0910041183,
-0.3770508766,
-0.184118256,
0.175152719,
0.4396364689,
-0.6350235939,
-0.3863233328,
0.0163277797,
-0.1929382384,
-0.4650679827,
0.2158289403,
-0.6910780668,
-0.2020458132,
-0.5271040201,
-0.0707147121,
-0.4635037184,
-0.2558425069,
0.1243080571,
-0.3807355165,
0.3338509798,
0.3370541632,
-0.8130943775,
0.670293808,
0.8722852468,
0.8025596738,
-0.6042342186,
-0.1485070437,
-0.6078567505,
-0.0206155777,
-0.7334432602,
0.5909067392,
-0.2673208416,
0.0378747359,
-0.1920111775,
0.0342354663,
0.1735687256,
-0.6385944486,
0.5553919077,
-0.4008337855,
0.5317205191,
-0.0915735215,
-0.665142417,
0.0435879566,
0.0396045148,
-0.4814753234,
1.3344423771,
0.5129492283,
-0.9162772894,
0.2868713737,
-0.794600606,
-0.582341373,
0.0074478448,
0.4106417298,
-0.1257837415,
0.123431623,
0.1774314344,
0.2894728184,
-0.3316286504,
0.4703888297,
-0.096146144,
0.2270145714,
0.1730940193,
-0.1291272491,
0.5983772278,
0.3737079501,
-0.1489977539,
-0.0685177371,
-0.50947088,
0.0785394609,
0.0595299117,
-0.1124138162,
-0.1773525476,
0.1766760796,
0.2289517373,
0.3507264555,
-0.0395296849,
-0.6134817004,
0.314509064,
-0.7216813564,
0.6932980418,
0.3588967919,
0.2374185622,
0.7406798601,
0.1191389933,
0.3298843503,
0.0269976668,
-0.1783027649,
-0.2400069833,
-0.5971745253,
-0.7093381286,
-0.0122037427,
0.4119043946,
0.8086955547,
-0.6470700502,
0.5920016766,
-0.1997164488,
-0.5607304573,
-0.7793985605,
0.1876916736,
0.0224475972,
0.5599491596,
0.5558116436,
-0.3594558835,
-0.9065586925,
-0.9209312201,
-0.2151312083,
-0.178683877,
-0.3474618495,
-0.0105821714,
0.3283241689,
-0.4634831846,
1.0270923376,
-0.556250155,
-0.3429249227,
-0.4911496341,
0.1791221499,
0.0963224024,
0.4344036877,
0.2541686296,
-0.240557909,
-0.2030796707,
0.3121524751,
-0.6396182179,
-0.3470151424,
-0.2241905034,
-0.6024895906,
0.2178146243,
0.6528779268,
-0.867607832,
-0.0366422161,
0.5009124279,
-0.2327846587,
0.3303425312,
-0.0147702759,
-0.0789995044,
-1.4505434036,
-0.0009395201,
-0.1909883022,
-0.4866656065,
-0.7269578576,
0.3359467089,
-0.0076432517,
-0.2541872263,
-0.5942927599,
0.5487269163,
-0.2800505161,
-0.3135454357,
-0.1790391654,
0.3219817877,
0.0729267374,
0.2731352746,
-0.01246629,
0.4357141554,
0.3849360943,
-0.4200962782,
0.6563648582,
0.3385556936,
-0.2898821831,
0.2490555048,
-0.5461399555,
0.228054896,
0.1400348544,
0.3165225983,
-1.0079630613,
-0.5304807425,
0.5358574986,
-0.5708904266,
0.048747614,
-0.4253131449,
-0.6642674208,
-0.3117102087,
-0.005602756,
-0.2722387314,
0.9282255173,
-0.3988780379,
0.1990458816,
0.377033174,
-0.3538719714,
-0.0889531448,
-0.7187042236,
0.4985897243,
-0.140653953,
-0.6850119233,
0.2891960442,
0.2224786282,
-0.4654848874,
-0.0593142435,
-0.1454782486,
0.0403754339,
-0.0082426239,
-0.0609354414,
0.3017274141,
-0.2609148324,
-0.0605733842,
0.321477443,
-0.1352918595,
0.3608917594,
-0.5523486733,
0.4564042091,
0.2996516824,
-0.4163397253,
-0.3926865757,
0.377173394,
0.4728233516,
-0.2617602348,
0.4132159948,
1.0447494984,
-0.2270063013,
-0.2314312011,
-0.4696861804,
-0.3967618644,
-0.3755548298,
0.2103660852,
0.1462693065,
-0.5965703726,
0.247323066,
-0.246889025,
0.5246130228,
0.5007040501,
0.5702162385,
-0.4584709406,
1.138972044,
0.1691909432,
0.1784746796,
0.1450652778,
-0.140501678,
0.2951085567,
-0.5942357779,
-0.1411455572,
-0.5003505945,
-0.372908473,
-0.7411378622,
-0.7491149306,
0.1035544574,
0.0070809182,
0.161588192,
0.578484714,
-0.4681546688,
0.2414998263,
0.5339602232,
-0.1896518469,
0.0151237762,
0.1128285825,
-0.1235308051,
-0.2338850349,
-0.5430355072,
-0.6860488057,
0.9395396113,
0.2230650485,
0.4702121019,
0.0799427107,
0.6848980188,
0.4397904277,
-0.1980987191,
-0.9772304296,
0.5264137387,
-0.1366251558,
-0.2865648866,
-0.1614580452,
-0.5164760351,
-0.9570049644,
0.1251133382,
-0.225504294,
-0.2753796577,
-0.4928962588,
0.0621494278,
0.3473134637,
0.3697152138,
-1.0058642626,
0.9616671801,
-0.148165673,
-0.0281575192,
0.059415888,
-1.0128260851,
0.3711436987,
-0.0547551028,
0.3788925111,
-0.4184390306,
-0.0755381659,
0.8341721892,
-0.6110104322,
0.604205966,
-0.4355252385,
-0.1219321191,
0.2920095921,
0.3574006855,
0.8198820949,
0.2364434004,
-0.0616268106,
-0.0616501272,
0.042793721,
-0.3037674427,
-0.638974309,
0.4381811321,
-0.4656715095,
-0.2780869007,
-0.1941322684,
-0.4601963758,
-0.1305915415,
0.1869687736,
0.2293293178,
0.3592999578,
-0.4220126867,
0.0502349809,
0.4163783491,
-0.2336548567,
0.2616634965,
0.1885445416,
-0.2782750726,
-0.4015700221,
0.678825736,
-0.2721550465,
0.4814174175,
0.357878685,
0.0446374267,
-0.3198725879,
-0.4789653718,
-0.9679666758,
-0.057492584,
-0.550742507,
-0.3309143186,
-0.798719883,
-0.0368861482,
-0.5325763226,
-0.2162873298,
-0.6096589565,
-0.7300809622,
-0.1903732717,
-0.2534838915,
0.562685132,
0.6539280415,
0.0193237774,
0.2620769739,
-0.6566148996,
0.5901398659,
-0.0467441529,
0.026846448,
-0.5572564602,
-0.3618906736,
-0.0736029446,
0.4391742349,
-0.1766417921,
-0.8770294785,
0.6587299109,
0.1687242091,
0.3930307329,
0.0016396875,
0.184453994,
0.5112907887,
-0.7120701075,
0.9418934584,
0.2977705002,
-0.692086935,
0.7768512964,
-0.3042227626,
0.3543013334,
0.5229064226,
0.0388545282,
-1.0024441481,
-0.8625609875,
-0.6635515094,
-1.0335624218,
0.9635292292,
0.4377689958,
0.4637248516,
-0.2008761317,
0.0230143182,
0.490573734,
0.0071053337,
-0.1456457675,
-0.1372331381,
-0.2145257443,
-0.3762977719,
0.0355976969,
0.0723478869,
0.1102681607,
-0.2415017486,
0.5190722346,
-0.1263187826,
0.3235753477,
-0.1939716935,
-0.3469230831,
0.1139503121,
0.2836915255,
0.1850325316,
0.3748887181,
-0.1054099426,
0.1805643439,
0.3868846893,
-0.4220335484,
0.0141355712,
-0.1702172458,
-0.163609013,
0.4688145816,
0.2432460934,
0.900724411,
0.3837122321,
-0.7182582617,
0.4711124301,
0.0636451617,
-0.4058382809,
-0.2836067379,
0.1188725531,
0.2867379189,
-0.1159121245,
0.1600958407,
0.4938369393,
0.1187921464,
-0.3605848849,
0.3775684237,
0.2210590094,
-0.20316571,
-0.2553892136,
0.5574530363,
0.1385759413,
-0.3977573514,
0.9604115486,
-0.3900743127,
-0.2569875121,
0.4251123667,
0.552936554,
0.5989778042,
0.1906912774,
0.4143230319,
0.6153743267,
0.3246524334,
-0.0577977896,
0.0445665531,
0.0350743346,
-0.4963896275,
-0.5345749855,
-0.6714062691,
-0.6683160067,
-0.1878248751,
-0.933411479,
0.5722731948,
-0.3286261261,
-0.1095016301,
0.1591867357,
-0.3103559613,
-0.6990423203,
-0.0279497635,
0.0463760942,
0.8767024279,
-0.7159020901,
0.6068062782,
0.772351861,
0.0055357995,
-0.6418327093,
-0.2598144412,
0.046170868,
-0.6055264473,
0.1269908249,
-0.1137588769,
0.2241130471,
0.2799299955,
-0.5119377375,
-0.7701099515,
0.7464727163,
0.4437700808,
-0.2645377815,
-0.2358332276,
0.3180146217,
0.656378746,
-0.2670188844,
0.1450446248,
0.7815583944,
0.5366103649,
0.1901356578,
-0.6739640236,
-0.2341549397,
-0.2603542209,
0.1178449616,
0.473725915,
0.1531016827,
0.329801023,
-0.4053941369,
-0.3634352088,
-0.095961526,
0.6174399257,
0.03468059,
0.0851879269,
0.2356009185,
0.5422385335,
0.6004734039,
-0.3271045089,
0.9443957806,
-0.0400847979,
0.1590757072,
1.0784837008,
-0.3586608171,
0.823276937,
0.6004201174,
-0.2433609962,
0.5131645203,
0.6122563481,
-0.235824123,
0.55201298,
0.1647191644,
0.0207087267,
-0.0529207624,
-0.0641136318,
-0.1909510195,
0.6233423352,
0.3919126987,
-0.411282897,
-0.4896792769,
0.0733430088,
0.2132404149,
0.0494218245,
0.079766117,
1.3460900784,
-0.1221274734,
-0.9469361305,
0.2733144164,
0.5322160721,
0.509155035,
-0.6535878778,
0.0021537542,
-0.2979032993,
-0.1316815019,
-0.1841208041,
-0.9569764733,
0.5857582092,
0.3099651337,
0.0798645318,
-0.5159804821,
0.7802058458,
-0.4374594092,
-0.615139246,
0.127632156,
0.6654421091,
0.5433058739,
0.1830532998,
-0.5353043675,
-0.0910248682,
0.185590595,
-0.110321328,
0.3087875843,
0.6213248968,
0.0178565886,
0.4356457591,
1.0479996204,
0.2011057734,
0.3260199428,
-0.0505636297,
0.676388979,
-0.6030656099,
-0.2693603039,
-0.7488883734,
0.4493371546,
-0.0842037573,
-0.3186119199,
0.7036904097,
0.6310922503,
1.1114370823,
-0.1869708598,
0.8872169256,
-0.3943396807,
0.6775963306,
-0.6368482113,
0.3989874721,
-0.052987285,
0.0394438505,
-0.1712884009,
-1.0236515999,
-0.2277901918,
0.3898620009,
0.1688771844,
-0.3184711039,
0.7015073299,
0.9191178083,
-0.2751884162,
0.0425072089,
0.0445125587,
-0.1211356446,
0.2591243386,
0.2192345709,
0.6646904349,
-0.4418804646,
0.559075892,
-0.3772214055,
0.2832735777,
-0.0843048543,
-0.8380574584,
-0.5679030418,
-0.4883685708,
-0.324580729,
-0.1739472151,
-0.1119150743,
1.1883313656,
0.5736714602,
-0.8414295912,
-0.093871139,
-0.3767526746,
0.0202418342,
-0.3074995875,
-0.2355348468,
0.088413462,
-0.7372981906,
-0.5941013098,
0.5064827204,
0.042774383,
-0.0037300766,
-0.0643005073,
-0.2060997486,
0.0169766657,
-0.0770779252,
0.7615392208,
-0.126082927,
-0.8643475175,
-0.1464164853,
0.1977667511,
-0.3845490515,
0.151023984,
0.7962092161,
-0.6306340694,
0.3346309662,
0.4492405057,
0.7043094635,
0.3485821486,
0.0091695506,
0.6581248045,
-1.0526313782,
-0.118808426,
0.1906962395,
0.1534767002,
0.5623989701,
-0.0176037997,
0.6440052986,
0.1500527859,
-0.2061430961,
-0.8983619213,
0.2008539885,
-1.1734888554,
-0.0263261441,
1.5369737148,
0.1214676648,
-0.0200051218,
-0.1185874492,
-0.7016432285,
0.4080945849,
-0.4208213091,
0.207571283,
0.5792348385,
0.1859141439,
-0.1494677514,
-0.8278945684,
0.4376324713,
0.1814102083,
-0.9781874418,
0.4816957116,
0.5664025545,
0.3649330139,
-0.2411614656,
0.3417069912,
-0.1677109003,
0.1263819337,
-0.0328099094,
0.2954955995,
0.1141483113,
0.0072507774,
0.1947355121,
-0.1314801276,
0.0879632086,
0.1066097021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07842v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07842v1 | Augmented Language Models: a Survey | 2023-02-15T18:25:52 | 2023-02-15T18:25:52 | Grégoire Mialon, Roberto Dessì, Maria Lomeli, Christoforos Nalmpantis, Ram Pasunuru, Roberta Raileanu, Baptiste Rozière, Timo Schick, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Asli Celikyilmaz, Edouard Grave, Yann LeCun, Thomas Scialom | cs.CL | cs.CL | This survey reviews works in which language models (LMs) are augmented with
reasoning skills and the ability to use tools. The former is defined as
decomposing a potentially complex task into simpler subtasks while the latter
consists in calling external modules such as a code interpreter. LMs can
leverage these augmentations separately or in combination via heuristics, or
learn to do so from demonstrations. While adhering to a standard missing tokens
prediction objective, such augmented LMs can use various, possibly
non-parametric external modules to expand their context processing ability,
thus departing from the pure language modeling paradigm. We therefore refer to
them as Augmented Language Models (ALMs). The missing token objective allows
ALMs to learn to reason, use tools, and even act, while still performing
standard natural language tasks and even outperforming most regular LMs on
several benchmarks. In this work, after reviewing current advance in ALMs, we
conclude that this new research direction has the potential to address common
limitations of traditional LMs such as interpretability, consistency, and
scalability issues. | [
-0.4869135618,
-0.9587360024,
0.5556447506,
-0.1396055967,
0.0721854493,
0.2205731869,
-0.2574817538,
-0.6891514659,
0.2210781127,
0.7681794763,
-0.3324258029,
-0.2919849753,
-0.441162765,
0.1581065208,
-0.4505633414,
0.7396292686,
-0.1793759912,
0.0094670169,
-0.4809108675,
-0.2387998551,
-0.6532462835,
-0.6549048424,
-0.5719402432,
-0.3942267895,
0.4177174568,
0.3487013578,
0.8181682825,
0.8086025119,
0.3396061063,
0.2446202189,
-0.1787694246,
0.462951988,
0.1791962534,
-0.1373135298,
-0.1721015871,
-0.4216910303,
-0.8456280231,
0.1107055172,
0.4075994194,
1.2789233923,
0.0046423795,
0.0778113306,
-0.1172751039,
0.5486892462,
-0.6067215204,
0.139378503,
-0.550249815,
-0.1535622627,
0.1976302266,
-0.1662024856,
-0.4233029485,
-0.0271615069,
0.1443120539,
-0.3955768943,
0.112744309,
0.2097091377,
0.4616274536,
0.0875054076,
-0.53005445,
-0.5932293534,
-0.8365815282,
0.8101866245,
-0.8864687085,
0.5585169196,
0.7655268312,
0.1147960722,
-0.0238679964,
-0.6030551791,
-0.5427895784,
-0.5525465012,
-0.1241757348,
-0.3499515653,
-0.1018608809,
0.3154963851,
0.2513198555,
0.5719973445,
-0.2053514719,
0.0125876535,
-0.3731732368,
-0.2655283213,
0.3421593308,
0.2365718037,
0.5857489705,
-0.0869643837,
-0.3609008193,
0.3871811926,
-0.6839883327,
0.2329687029,
0.396189481,
0.5386586189,
0.0267058965,
0.7557380795,
-0.2232494056,
0.9673284292,
-0.1871996969,
-0.1709234864,
0.0890638456,
-0.3284387589,
-0.2594656646,
-0.1737827063,
0.3428366482,
0.1191069558,
0.0923228338,
-0.294745177,
-0.4767535627,
-0.040029034,
-0.012754634,
-0.2770275772,
-0.1065591499,
0.2451359332,
-0.5158782005,
0.0548536703,
-0.2797923088,
-0.0998642296,
-0.277867049,
-0.7870997787,
0.5171378851,
-0.594920814,
-0.5478724837,
0.1319421381,
0.0862147436,
-0.0805846974,
0.3386130631,
-0.9167913198,
0.6372926235,
0.8153774142,
0.8610520363,
-0.3735381663,
-0.3027660549,
-0.6190295219,
-0.0573979951,
-0.5822021365,
0.7905846834,
-0.8009139299,
-0.4647757113,
0.1453707814,
0.0362148881,
-0.0231316071,
-0.5664016008,
0.5303647518,
-0.5778845549,
0.2340009511,
-0.3554993272,
-0.7263740897,
-0.3694643974,
0.3819124401,
-0.7643092871,
1.1309067011,
0.1605764925,
-0.4228149951,
0.2738918662,
-0.7615369558,
-0.3789814115,
0.1164432019,
-0.0521093011,
0.0632719919,
0.1527194083,
0.3372209072,
0.2432922423,
-0.2372152805,
0.2464247793,
-0.1745015085,
-0.5800043344,
0.252391547,
-0.4320678711,
0.6424788833,
0.2609145939,
-0.0280370377,
0.3579174578,
-0.873807013,
-0.0265871994,
-0.3309868276,
-0.5050503016,
-0.435187012,
0.0735164136,
-0.1038323268,
0.2049190551,
0.3889410794,
-0.3090048432,
0.2300430983,
-0.7032604814,
0.2595752478,
0.6725900173,
-0.281604588,
0.8409131169,
-0.1617477536,
0.6160135269,
0.0172514711,
-0.0927022323,
-0.3372617662,
-0.2160722464,
-1.0814431906,
-0.4996184111,
0.2074293643,
0.4972712696,
-1.0361777544,
0.3101958036,
-0.0309522673,
-0.2145085037,
-0.5905749798,
0.3307313323,
0.2512227297,
0.4678582251,
0.3933757842,
-0.1455713958,
-0.8594483137,
-0.8580318689,
-0.5388375521,
-0.2912209332,
0.2214482129,
0.1644598693,
0.4091288745,
-0.3634983897,
1.1081840992,
0.0108343447,
-0.0150118629,
-0.7223853469,
-0.0350738205,
0.2180739641,
0.3546474278,
0.2399801463,
-0.4879606366,
-0.2450044155,
0.0625406578,
-0.6612121463,
-0.0152856922,
0.1848445386,
0.2970074117,
0.4964729548,
0.681712389,
-0.7064216137,
0.4738410711,
0.4586758018,
-0.306430608,
0.5797874331,
-0.2316509485,
0.0704797804,
-0.8419793844,
0.1162361503,
-0.2134761214,
-0.3192970753,
-0.8609175682,
0.1777727157,
0.0323225595,
-0.1339222491,
-0.5265701413,
0.9769284725,
-0.7744894028,
-0.1901840419,
-0.8218980432,
-0.0754605532,
-0.0326186381,
0.4682825506,
0.1618933976,
0.859382689,
0.7528390884,
-0.7286901474,
0.493568033,
-0.1407661289,
-0.3724180758,
0.2177625597,
-0.69553262,
0.2159931362,
-0.155606389,
-0.0435771532,
-0.8119325042,
-0.1422436386,
0.1578145772,
-0.3238447905,
0.1127706915,
-0.1169647723,
-0.5267426372,
-0.1909135282,
-0.0452842452,
0.4393281043,
0.4444422126,
-0.460978508,
0.8936300278,
0.2569796741,
-0.1966225654,
-0.6116297245,
-0.5177548528,
0.2694748044,
-0.0200986862,
-0.2851940691,
-0.0009522495,
0.0009310187,
-0.5940262079,
0.2423641682,
0.0901384801,
0.0315604508,
-0.0081448946,
0.2830652297,
0.4161720574,
-0.3112411201,
0.3484173119,
-0.1635287255,
-0.1303702295,
-0.1170205474,
-0.0354248956,
0.5722417235,
-0.4389851987,
-0.6681749821,
-0.2995435596,
0.4767433405,
0.5430804491,
-0.3508628309,
1.0082685947,
0.3679172099,
-0.592535913,
0.1085372567,
-0.7373256683,
-0.0219211355,
-0.4430545866,
0.4392203987,
-0.5198645592,
-0.9908554554,
0.6518059969,
0.0322045796,
0.0811113417,
0.3760633767,
0.5879442096,
0.1715368629,
1.3614822626,
0.8736279607,
0.0128199132,
0.5418274403,
-0.084701784,
0.3736200035,
-0.9485428333,
-0.1588190794,
-0.2744533122,
-0.0276156049,
-0.3198769689,
-0.3789689541,
0.1754794717,
0.3876233399,
-0.0868159756,
0.287609458,
-0.2604551315,
0.4282988906,
0.6569100618,
-0.1243035197,
0.4890529811,
0.0148069896,
-0.1303470433,
0.1807513535,
-0.7134634256,
-0.8581149578,
1.0929341316,
0.5845189691,
0.5616754889,
0.0163156837,
0.2910513282,
0.3466661572,
0.4537601173,
-0.9661971331,
0.6942353845,
0.1452516168,
-0.8109855056,
-0.1673845053,
-0.2384750098,
-0.7154644132,
0.1547976881,
-0.0735590905,
-0.6510975957,
0.0944770649,
0.3104453385,
-0.2893401682,
0.4567591548,
-0.7708421946,
0.6034094691,
-0.1806946099,
-0.2766726315,
-0.0068504228,
-0.4729479551,
0.3684550226,
0.2781704366,
0.608594656,
-0.1498700082,
-0.2056701928,
0.6252274513,
-0.5689828396,
0.7837747335,
-0.0755735487,
-0.1064455435,
0.6736311913,
0.1006782353,
0.4711733758,
-0.2475426048,
-0.1740901023,
-0.1158336997,
0.2093826979,
-0.5901918411,
-0.5609798431,
0.7824258804,
-0.6439353824,
-0.7085912824,
-0.4482327402,
-0.9827908874,
-0.3968876302,
0.1489930302,
-0.2101469934,
0.4766641259,
0.0063902149,
-0.0881704241,
0.4985654652,
-0.0692701638,
0.6475483775,
0.4991666079,
-0.4994586408,
-0.4238758981,
0.9109956622,
0.0581612661,
0.4210414588,
0.1824833602,
-0.1436400861,
-0.3079923689,
-0.6216875911,
-0.4695305824,
0.073715739,
-0.9465049505,
0.1205467731,
-0.680474937,
-0.1969173998,
-0.5216480494,
0.1210966185,
-0.3364868462,
-0.5849240422,
-0.459138006,
-0.2484278828,
0.4751602709,
0.7362518907,
-0.0563455746,
0.2884377539,
-0.8243888617,
0.2522465885,
0.2676218152,
0.5101267099,
0.1068811491,
-0.5805670023,
-0.5090195537,
0.1639868766,
-0.0094104586,
-0.6680586934,
0.3967830539,
0.0175484736,
0.6763547659,
0.1272166371,
-0.2562963963,
0.7997978926,
-0.6419875026,
0.8857244253,
0.0482151657,
-0.9452453852,
0.3139338493,
-0.2701197863,
0.0893120542,
0.3128625751,
0.1732597798,
-0.5408534408,
-0.0699820146,
-0.4721898735,
-0.7505804896,
0.6380179524,
-0.0153295342,
0.264803201,
-0.2353161573,
0.4552485645,
0.2613609731,
0.3360154629,
-0.7844466567,
-0.1997781992,
0.0764633864,
-0.2170422375,
-0.0797414854,
-0.3036921322,
0.0649085119,
-0.4281159043,
0.7116315961,
-0.0872237235,
0.1416813731,
0.0560146235,
-0.2329847366,
-0.2829376757,
0.4672982991,
0.5742473006,
0.8900529742,
-0.0626893938,
0.4565654397,
0.2911417186,
-0.1251741946,
0.0084600672,
0.0017996967,
0.1592495888,
0.0140933637,
0.5379573107,
1.0584356785,
-0.1856127381,
-1.1772158146,
0.2004300654,
0.170923546,
-0.0119857984,
-0.3316626251,
0.0182218608,
0.0727344826,
0.1413919926,
0.5440744758,
0.3593451977,
0.1313794553,
-1.0553447008,
0.0758461356,
0.6485161781,
-0.632075727,
-0.3778962493,
0.4739655256,
0.2232105434,
-0.6687363386,
0.1683306247,
-0.2123335749,
-0.3634880483,
0.3211446404,
0.5826647282,
0.6962245703,
-0.0749447793,
-0.1801160127,
-0.0856398493,
0.5507010818,
-0.291388303,
0.3580766618,
0.105376564,
-0.7058070898,
-0.7745350003,
-0.5532738566,
-0.4231606424,
0.2244717777,
-0.5043885112,
0.2947963476,
-0.342286855,
-0.0810904577,
-0.4287342429,
-0.1197055653,
-0.5755035877,
0.2815589607,
-0.0069121588,
0.9725967646,
-0.8170095682,
0.7226136327,
1.0390496254,
-0.4966816008,
-0.7016434669,
-0.3791301847,
-0.3311926723,
-0.7729325294,
0.5269127488,
-0.0990681723,
-0.1006482318,
-0.0723234639,
-0.4344952703,
-0.929338932,
0.6463176012,
0.3569473028,
-0.2332815677,
-0.3097582161,
0.2583019733,
0.6437544823,
-0.5209650397,
0.1897976696,
0.631862998,
0.0578101352,
0.0267870817,
-1.0384064913,
-0.1028770432,
-0.3223266006,
-0.0318755135,
0.2008275688,
-0.1229131222,
1.0949058533,
-0.1068898588,
0.0173674915,
0.3283963799,
0.7436622381,
0.2425241917,
0.4205181301,
0.3787952662,
0.4534453452,
0.380105108,
0.1307753026,
1.1494899988,
-0.2901218235,
0.211664319,
1.0215599537,
-0.2935102284,
0.9287272096,
0.7447378039,
-0.1025552154,
0.5099645853,
0.5794010162,
0.6818597317,
0.3039648533,
-0.2755749822,
-0.3719843328,
-0.5311029553,
-0.2999361455,
-0.311244458,
0.2625079155,
0.4879642725,
-0.4303497672,
0.0521765649,
0.310071528,
-0.2649748623,
0.3303780854,
-0.5354979634,
0.6874740124,
0.085117422,
-0.6501196623,
0.5556483865,
0.2470758259,
0.5792152882,
-0.2673527598,
-0.1906607598,
-0.1238413528,
0.1161776036,
-0.1795810908,
-0.4745164216,
0.4412336946,
-0.0161853153,
-0.2744898796,
-0.2302696705,
1.0048471689,
-0.5680608153,
-0.7730631232,
-0.0295928326,
0.9170634151,
0.0767753422,
0.1190050766,
-0.4266090095,
0.1182302758,
-0.2143801749,
-0.1722145081,
0.1484764665,
0.2841224372,
-0.1959564686,
0.9201031327,
0.6885919571,
0.2884519696,
0.1526775956,
0.0179229137,
0.769382298,
-0.6954069734,
-0.2569516301,
-0.9022714496,
0.5324718356,
0.0929779857,
-0.0076422724,
0.8403783441,
0.6145064831,
0.6783623695,
-0.013047033,
0.8807347417,
0.0874558017,
0.9840106368,
-0.5920376778,
0.2946691811,
-0.5717812181,
0.6385468841,
-0.1666381061,
-0.7915033698,
-0.2554693222,
0.4258856177,
-0.5335338116,
0.2235586047,
0.5446468592,
0.6260749698,
-0.1056044623,
-0.1114772484,
0.3982512057,
-0.2118705809,
0.2531245947,
0.2972846627,
1.0694572926,
-0.4628449082,
0.331277132,
-0.0442301556,
-0.1131198183,
-0.230713889,
-0.6997641325,
-1.2229052782,
-0.4197449982,
-0.2664290667,
-0.0944903344,
0.005279514,
1.3747513294,
0.4806345999,
-0.8244124651,
-0.3621612489,
-0.359863013,
0.2905560732,
-0.2197338343,
-0.2186882943,
0.3245454133,
-0.3473881185,
-0.9046397209,
0.5545268655,
0.3385661244,
0.0458226874,
-0.3787771463,
-0.2692863643,
-0.4030402601,
0.3016364574,
0.785509944,
0.3526036739,
-1.0773948431,
-0.43302387,
0.3586513996,
0.0336499475,
-0.1308842003,
0.8634198904,
-0.9935902357,
0.5399799943,
0.3729598224,
0.6355198026,
-0.0573662855,
-0.0739206895,
0.512370646,
-0.7930979729,
0.3711463213,
0.2788200676,
0.5716363788,
0.459243089,
0.1164105982,
0.2694610953,
0.1051663384,
-0.2686741948,
-1.2293257713,
0.3685711324,
-0.6027733684,
-0.3448102176,
1.2296788692,
0.1449064463,
-0.0355980843,
-0.3247045577,
-0.4892499447,
0.3310735524,
-0.1049147174,
0.4498079419,
0.7640320659,
-0.3935997486,
-0.5238276124,
-0.5799628496,
0.4814642072,
0.5436456203,
-0.6988364458,
-0.0357050598,
0.5125562549,
0.2562780678,
0.2579348981,
0.5703180432,
-0.0011491257,
0.2852499783,
-0.152581349,
0.2374032587,
-0.291415602,
-0.3240220249,
-0.2554817796,
0.1234684661,
0.5401988029,
-0.0339169204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07778v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07778v2 | Measuring the Instability of Fine-Tuning | 2023-02-15T16:55:15 | 2023-10-01T10:38:39 | Yupei Du, Dong Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Fine-tuning pre-trained language models on downstream tasks with varying
random seeds has been shown to be unstable, especially on small datasets. Many
previous studies have investigated this instability and proposed methods to
mitigate it. However, most studies only used the standard deviation of
performance scores (SD) as their measure, which is a narrow characterization of
instability. In this paper, we analyze SD and six other measures quantifying
instability at different levels of granularity. Moreover, we propose a
systematic framework to evaluate the validity of these measures. Finally, we
analyze the consistency and difference between different measures by
reassessing existing instability mitigation methods. We hope our results will
inform the development of better measurements of fine-tuning instability. | [
-0.6774169207,
-1.3198107481,
0.1606147736,
0.0053627365,
-0.0263044238,
-0.1036925241,
-0.6109990478,
-0.2066821754,
0.0488846339,
0.132730782,
-0.2784281671,
-0.2242874503,
-1.1480888128,
-0.1174272969,
-0.6947324872,
1.3267279863,
-0.1484512836,
-0.0042193085,
-0.1894681305,
-0.2234826088,
-0.6043727398,
-0.1279997081,
-0.7452933192,
-0.0848483443,
0.4887211025,
0.4393014014,
0.9766266942,
0.5528801084,
0.9530361295,
0.4226405919,
-0.2745136917,
0.1088995636,
-0.8195894361,
0.4262798131,
-0.1264137328,
-0.3499397039,
-0.5173013806,
0.1935741752,
0.9230692387,
0.9337735772,
-0.3808225095,
0.2831241786,
0.5059612393,
0.4993694127,
-0.6481707692,
-0.1662035286,
-0.7001516819,
-0.3513163626,
-0.6338863373,
-0.1378027946,
-0.0244266074,
-0.5667306781,
0.0562875718,
-0.4594735205,
0.2343229502,
-0.1052791253,
1.1747207642,
0.4974927902,
0.0466691181,
-0.4457727671,
-1.0440429449,
0.9859480262,
-0.6465231776,
0.1063175648,
0.4997363985,
0.5236691833,
-0.5168750882,
-0.2665403485,
-0.187703073,
-0.1261341423,
0.2269171178,
-0.102256,
0.0572731048,
-0.0048389742,
0.0856348276,
0.7396453619,
-0.0586172193,
0.3981929719,
-0.4227727056,
-0.3523537815,
0.7784246206,
0.5552265644,
0.1853905171,
0.3544386029,
0.1677648276,
-0.2386940271,
-0.4499859512,
0.3641349077,
0.6263563037,
0.5317054391,
0.064620845,
0.4428173006,
-0.1278624237,
0.5645952225,
0.5118226409,
-0.1946850717,
0.117357932,
-0.5334658027,
-0.262398243,
-0.2953142226,
0.7918500304,
0.472597152,
0.1700595617,
-0.1185466051,
-0.4209621847,
0.0535436347,
0.2773275077,
-0.5535228848,
-0.1447385401,
0.3748780489,
-0.3536563814,
-0.450812906,
0.1534246057,
-0.466920197,
-0.375328958,
-0.0092196288,
0.4648297429,
-0.5578595996,
-0.4018985033,
0.0714591295,
-0.0901305676,
-0.2456910759,
0.168828994,
-1.0934481621,
0.4423252642,
0.7771959901,
0.7692470551,
-0.100717701,
-0.8299758434,
-0.4752353728,
-0.1750072539,
-0.7348637581,
0.533645153,
-0.5274034142,
-0.4691530168,
-0.0392207801,
0.1026928797,
-0.2427847385,
-0.6742114425,
0.7396669388,
0.0142614795,
-0.2730450332,
-0.3604594767,
-0.5596839786,
0.3059799075,
0.2734140754,
-0.4262404144,
1.1576462984,
0.247289151,
-0.8689638972,
0.8272581697,
-0.3753018081,
-0.1285938323,
-0.4391312301,
-0.1421103477,
-0.5951167941,
0.6433175206,
-0.1973005235,
0.5533903241,
-0.0608035326,
0.2522525489,
-0.3833610713,
-0.7579487562,
0.0090966122,
-0.2712754309,
0.1928311139,
0.2592968941,
0.0503210127,
0.26129511,
-0.779432416,
0.1197197586,
-0.1962932646,
-0.3914541602,
-0.4487518072,
0.3775332272,
-0.3984635174,
0.1441265494,
-0.0676601902,
-0.3149349391,
0.368050456,
-0.4353946745,
0.2961062491,
0.629058063,
0.1307411939,
0.5216364861,
-0.4723011553,
0.3114631772,
0.4098988771,
0.181041047,
-0.040570572,
-0.2526653111,
-0.9818298817,
-0.0706385151,
0.4647948742,
0.155046314,
-0.0668903291,
0.2677406669,
-0.5919697285,
-0.933062017,
-0.9347225428,
0.1892626286,
0.2179139555,
0.0577018186,
0.1960409582,
-0.6092993617,
-0.1598501056,
-0.5948065519,
-0.6487107873,
0.166132316,
0.1725084931,
0.0707947314,
0.4083874524,
-0.4624837637,
0.7500376701,
0.0213521048,
-0.2962040603,
-0.0131854378,
0.8796386719,
0.1184315979,
0.7308071256,
0.7252580523,
-0.164914608,
-0.2272450477,
0.131133467,
-0.0569677241,
0.068632327,
0.1417415887,
0.2207220495,
0.2666952908,
0.2800761759,
-0.2516056001,
0.3933515549,
0.8655343652,
-0.2555027604,
0.7664197087,
-0.2479560524,
0.5170294642,
-0.6151195168,
-0.2065735757,
0.088197276,
0.0554793924,
-0.5424028039,
-0.156450808,
-0.1057875082,
0.3521434367,
-0.2300362885,
-0.1195043474,
-0.1459538192,
0.0112279989,
-0.2035273612,
0.1372365355,
-0.4898693264,
-0.2598444223,
-0.4722917676,
0.8927241564,
0.6025269628,
-0.8043985367,
-0.0428406782,
-0.2056194544,
-0.5220427513,
0.3357504904,
-0.6975896358,
-0.0145819243,
-0.1446865052,
-0.2278214693,
-0.8260974884,
-0.4358250499,
-0.2180267572,
-0.4945912361,
0.4521661699,
-0.3044379652,
-0.2629882097,
-0.1121141613,
-0.2592623234,
0.1490580589,
0.1784670204,
0.1541856229,
-0.0027717864,
0.2819628716,
-0.0986548588,
-0.281216979,
-0.4701188505,
-0.3876396716,
-0.2751134336,
-0.7726365328,
-0.0248250533,
-0.0738898963,
-0.3057875037,
-0.2070799023,
-0.3380243182,
-0.134205237,
0.4063434005,
0.4865187705,
-0.358461678,
-0.2278134823,
-0.117534712,
0.2113700807,
-0.2311407626,
0.125375554,
0.1066885367,
0.5748296976,
-0.4603444338,
-0.2546919584,
-0.3367610574,
0.0446784943,
0.6987364292,
-0.1438916177,
0.8290426731,
0.5087160468,
-0.2377329916,
-0.1154465377,
-0.2227321267,
-0.1074012592,
-0.5394198298,
0.4331546724,
-0.5585355759,
-0.9457622766,
0.9380844831,
-0.3305282891,
0.0553991236,
0.6001726985,
0.6421431899,
-0.3586726487,
1.1217730045,
0.8133562207,
0.1718678474,
0.2733975053,
-0.293056488,
0.3281207383,
-0.5331641436,
0.1375171542,
-0.803099215,
-0.467055589,
-0.6840134859,
-0.3837602139,
0.0250791647,
0.7804047465,
-0.491756916,
0.0593676791,
-0.1578959227,
0.5845749974,
0.1348346472,
-0.5190319419,
0.0152228372,
-0.3667028844,
-0.2828138471,
-0.2231926471,
-0.3755518198,
-0.7848438025,
0.6501978636,
0.639318645,
0.8720625639,
-0.1639396399,
0.6598165035,
-0.1706801057,
0.1164479107,
-0.4912046492,
0.1888444573,
-0.4322330058,
-0.5461185575,
-0.7896948457,
-0.503130734,
-0.7387603521,
-0.0491693057,
-0.1402837485,
-0.9946897626,
0.1509952247,
0.4580602646,
-0.5748361349,
-0.0280395467,
-0.49174577,
1.1595822573,
-0.27735883,
-0.0236285515,
0.0691202134,
-0.1550549567,
0.1936256886,
-0.0417235866,
0.4666138589,
-0.3112894893,
0.192333743,
0.6970130801,
-0.3997253776,
0.6706287861,
-0.0400212929,
-0.2296506613,
0.0970807597,
0.4513733685,
0.5887691379,
0.0681019202,
-0.126667425,
0.1891538352,
0.4581993222,
-0.5628401637,
-0.7134469748,
0.9844304323,
-0.8960241079,
-0.2932260036,
-0.4153290689,
-0.6189309359,
-0.4777053595,
0.2390934676,
0.423419416,
0.0067537953,
-0.2222329676,
0.4129764736,
0.4307002723,
0.1950483024,
0.5846461058,
0.382240802,
-0.2958922088,
-0.2093174607,
0.7714061737,
0.8565760851,
0.7729009986,
-0.3799316585,
0.2764743865,
0.5185163617,
-1.261033535,
-0.2255117446,
-0.524877727,
-0.3279119432,
-0.1064907163,
-0.064117685,
-0.1579350531,
-0.203853175,
-0.0634390935,
-0.8765308857,
-0.2259387225,
0.0430908948,
-0.1655951738,
0.2010472715,
0.7184953094,
0.010797211,
0.5957968235,
-0.8175299764,
-0.2182855904,
-0.1878759563,
0.8784473538,
-0.1371779591,
-0.6867761612,
-0.574803412,
0.310852021,
-0.2719340622,
-0.4619437456,
0.049125988,
0.407628417,
0.4441448748,
0.8800802827,
-0.01023148,
1.1433509588,
-0.4491254687,
1.0668081045,
-0.0094313836,
-0.9979830384,
0.8339874744,
-0.7278810143,
-0.0148074385,
0.9423959255,
0.2517665923,
-0.3085717857,
-0.9258380532,
-0.4448248446,
-0.8589804173,
0.498693645,
0.1166822463,
0.311178267,
-0.0354394764,
0.4486113489,
0.2682790458,
-0.0339538008,
-0.1922008991,
-0.2790796757,
-0.1264416724,
-0.0928908512,
-0.2433254123,
-0.3339997828,
-0.2922562361,
-0.5064493418,
0.3740774095,
-0.0050344686,
-0.3125504255,
-0.2149910033,
0.0225893334,
-0.5380465984,
0.1123334542,
0.7497239113,
0.8670476675,
-0.4882539213,
0.0921080261,
0.2954081297,
-0.9467717409,
-0.0063414709,
-0.3484339118,
-0.2215862572,
-0.3058206439,
0.289678216,
0.6965779066,
0.5225386024,
-0.4102893174,
0.5027611852,
-0.174909994,
-0.0988014638,
0.0809375718,
0.4993752241,
-0.1572087258,
-0.2244597822,
0.0272321645,
0.3980923891,
-0.1756409109,
-0.4610843062,
0.2457433045,
0.3599872887,
-0.63120538,
-0.3810536861,
0.4357796311,
0.3093321025,
-0.2508981824,
0.5110312104,
-0.2973529398,
0.0436500534,
0.4947737157,
0.4829798937,
0.75376755,
-0.3101632297,
0.2254227698,
0.2512837648,
0.8145560026,
-0.347368449,
0.3405539095,
0.493257463,
-0.7717604637,
-0.2943956554,
-0.8789628148,
-0.082087785,
0.078567639,
-0.8627157807,
0.2230039239,
-0.4927634597,
-0.5069139004,
0.0412022322,
0.3645241559,
-0.5200896263,
0.3279661536,
-0.3495950699,
0.895919323,
-1.1050559282,
0.9500279427,
0.8200473785,
-0.494374156,
-0.6317546368,
0.2091432214,
-0.120854184,
-0.2270876765,
0.1955397427,
-0.0842110813,
-0.2354001105,
-0.4030568898,
-0.303334713,
-1.3024232388,
0.971359849,
0.5286108255,
-0.8393104672,
0.3798377514,
0.2014095485,
0.6021918058,
-0.200090602,
0.1151598468,
1.1263848543,
0.540795505,
-0.3189636767,
-1.3386890888,
-0.3384235203,
-0.0735693425,
0.1591167152,
0.625932157,
-0.6840229034,
0.7251777053,
-0.0076016202,
-0.3407529891,
0.2051323503,
0.519297123,
0.0858335868,
0.4683886766,
0.4111271203,
0.9381626844,
0.8671551347,
-0.7543760538,
0.9474773407,
-0.4821067452,
0.6589304805,
0.9537206888,
0.3279833794,
1.0670390129,
0.7321412563,
-0.2635259926,
-0.015345593,
0.7545827627,
0.1312496364,
0.4040887058,
0.373023361,
0.3599333465,
-0.1968056709,
0.4252993464,
-0.1233061329,
0.3975105882,
0.3976277113,
-0.1345392168,
-0.113844499,
-0.0928275064,
-0.0014582352,
0.2544534802,
-0.5988409519,
0.5647948384,
-0.0142102577,
-0.4416294396,
0.7848030329,
-0.0630401447,
0.572388649,
-0.5212981701,
0.388967067,
-0.2833744884,
0.3126807511,
-0.4835908115,
-0.8084087968,
0.7133860588,
-0.1271588355,
-0.523129344,
-0.0044731144,
0.4113726616,
-0.1999745667,
-0.5755987167,
0.2612463534,
0.267816335,
0.24370341,
0.4831381142,
-0.4050447345,
0.8152701259,
-0.5280447602,
-0.3230172992,
0.6401202679,
0.6964137554,
-0.0388483852,
0.4522430897,
0.1664207727,
0.4741386771,
0.5885400772,
0.2130307257,
0.663303256,
-0.5274791718,
-0.0054406016,
-0.7522814274,
0.7254860997,
-0.1821973771,
-0.9812602997,
1.1627671719,
0.2055878937,
1.0101203918,
0.3051952422,
0.5739117265,
-0.1707795709,
0.3465765119,
-0.3571171463,
0.844922483,
-0.3666961193,
0.3484033942,
-0.5015234351,
-0.8289195299,
-0.1729552895,
0.4513359964,
-0.2824714184,
0.0398023389,
0.3114732802,
0.6716551781,
-0.0579848066,
-0.0858052745,
0.3077341318,
0.5042955875,
0.1821498573,
-0.0638001487,
0.7412773967,
-0.450224191,
0.2920230329,
-0.5858026743,
-0.307902813,
-0.2469665706,
-0.9641824365,
-0.6319271326,
-0.6166648865,
-0.4732098579,
-0.3313978314,
0.420537442,
0.4329930544,
0.700968802,
-1.1478579044,
-0.0396022908,
-0.1590604931,
-0.1031690091,
-0.7987586856,
-0.0970276743,
0.335542053,
-0.8567219973,
-0.62740767,
0.1756869704,
0.3567811549,
-0.0768421665,
-0.4718492627,
-0.214649871,
0.3107820451,
0.3661192954,
0.1845747977,
0.1401759833,
-0.6743381619,
-0.7465854883,
-0.2914066315,
-0.0302680116,
-0.1984365731,
0.6073321104,
-0.1440162957,
0.4822263122,
0.5211225152,
0.4546714425,
-0.0908138901,
0.1869806945,
0.6088965535,
-0.9769936204,
0.0084529547,
0.2502439022,
0.2435220331,
0.0741455555,
-0.0210492015,
0.1823623329,
-0.2939583361,
-0.9754260182,
-1.1038969755,
0.2593674958,
-0.524197638,
0.2725768685,
0.8181944489,
-0.1413158923,
-0.1753663123,
0.1355641335,
0.0523426458,
-0.0525821671,
-0.1906604767,
1.0921497345,
1.1738960743,
-0.2320109457,
0.0962780043,
-0.7203156948,
0.862686336,
0.230334565,
-0.1806271672,
0.2483568341,
0.0988018364,
0.4115427732,
0.5690971017,
0.4199337065,
-0.2527374923,
0.2288080603,
0.0890279636,
-0.6447467208,
0.054820925,
-0.4818314314,
-0.4097061753,
0.0101948958,
0.4792060256,
-0.1315607727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07748v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07748v4 | Whats New? Identifying the Unfolding of New Events in Narratives | 2023-02-15T15:54:01 | 2023-08-08T08:08:12 | Seyed Mahed Mousavi, Shohei Tanaka, Gabriel Roccabruna, Koichiro Yoshino, Satoshi Nakamura, Giuseppe Riccardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Narratives include a rich source of events unfolding over time and context.
Automatic understanding of these events provides a summarised comprehension of
the narrative for further computation (such as reasoning). In this paper, we
study the Information Status (IS) of the events and propose a novel challenging
task: the automatic identification of new events in a narrative. We define an
event as a triplet of subject, predicate, and object. The event is categorized
as new with respect to the discourse context and whether it can be inferred
through commonsense reasoning. We annotated a publicly available corpus of
narratives with the new events at sentence level using human annotators. We
present the annotation protocol and study the quality of the annotation and the
difficulty of the task. We publish the annotated dataset, annotation materials,
and machine learning baseline models for the task of new event extraction for
narrative understanding. | [
-0.2379652858,
-0.625023067,
0.6808199286,
-0.2038219422,
-0.4348036945,
0.2843963802,
0.1035811529,
-0.7099319696,
0.2985630631,
0.5010672808,
-0.4868883491,
-0.4932689071,
-0.7390506268,
0.1053668261,
-0.5016748309,
1.292662859,
-0.439583838,
-0.7185913324,
-0.2708952427,
-0.2349665612,
-0.2861471772,
-0.5669978261,
-0.4697100222,
-0.0907875001,
0.4505009353,
0.1998188943,
0.524705112,
0.6521946192,
0.4450728595,
0.3079653084,
-0.2671020627,
0.4134443402,
-0.2262586802,
0.0264806226,
-0.0260027405,
-0.2002742738,
-0.2378897518,
0.4478662908,
0.6663370132,
0.8867635727,
0.3379729986,
0.5933891535,
-0.0451474227,
0.2520199716,
-0.8826773763,
0.5848976374,
-0.3229314089,
0.3128235936,
-0.3921481669,
-0.385296464,
-0.4008963108,
-0.2763442099,
0.3673098981,
-1.1077253819,
0.4604102075,
-0.0573316738,
1.1502408981,
0.080922395,
-0.5915397406,
-0.4128118157,
-0.5420855284,
0.6060671806,
-0.1972785145,
-0.0569612905,
0.1809984446,
0.2892781496,
0.0646667406,
-0.6826166511,
-0.6985452771,
-0.048654668,
-0.3676693141,
-0.2234504074,
-0.4923235774,
-0.4218164086,
0.1275804043,
0.3166310787,
-0.1661120653,
-0.0948121548,
-0.355419606,
-0.3162719905,
0.8432431817,
0.1528577507,
0.3825421333,
-0.8949325681,
-0.5056183934,
0.4577720165,
-0.2489686012,
0.1386646479,
0.3634968996,
0.0565862432,
-0.1855781078,
0.5483521223,
-0.2965431809,
0.3585327566,
0.1346824467,
-0.1861485392,
0.6587395072,
-0.4707249105,
0.0033487286,
0.2007000595,
0.4762088656,
0.6663610935,
0.1982310563,
-0.1398958415,
-0.0785349309,
-0.2584592998,
-0.0877089277,
-0.0894994885,
0.0439445935,
-0.0675608814,
-0.6917175055,
-0.2600606978,
0.1369162053,
-0.5688775182,
-0.937035799,
-0.4620389938,
0.4607540965,
-0.2169647664,
-0.4678048491,
-0.112762928,
-0.5281305313,
0.4556647241,
1.0113391876,
-0.7134113908,
-0.0486641116,
0.640360415,
0.7390391827,
-0.4381309152,
-0.3004817367,
-0.6188163757,
0.3839409649,
-0.239463225,
0.899006784,
-0.348929584,
0.2551058233,
-0.1245802492,
0.399792105,
0.1498877555,
-0.1825855672,
0.6433477998,
-0.5185534954,
0.1367167234,
-0.022516638,
-0.5192847848,
-0.2199214995,
0.0114053385,
-0.8627167344,
0.6623005271,
0.0495087765,
-0.7931542397,
0.6453096271,
-0.5306917429,
-0.5742713809,
0.1351984143,
0.0973124206,
0.0461174101,
0.3650357127,
0.2010454834,
0.3804692328,
-0.2008920908,
0.5735948682,
0.0780724809,
-0.2070046067,
0.3199101985,
-0.3498530686,
0.7731103897,
0.2553407848,
-0.0840190798,
-0.0790208504,
-0.917809546,
-0.4362086654,
0.0178139433,
-0.2169852108,
-0.0741728544,
-0.0812052116,
0.0309967306,
-0.3623232543,
0.3379696012,
-0.5753119588,
0.4801367521,
-0.064941287,
0.3276540339,
0.4442751706,
0.4307887554,
0.4977316558,
-0.272390306,
0.3912484944,
-0.0434183814,
0.2577063143,
-0.7303250432,
-0.7714731693,
-0.4908067584,
0.0498876981,
0.2286947072,
0.5112050772,
-0.557687819,
0.1853583604,
0.0138905197,
-0.2129589766,
-0.3499924242,
-0.1105720177,
0.0890268609,
0.4721535444,
0.2636248469,
-0.0682431608,
-1.0087573528,
-0.7421432734,
-0.4335960746,
-0.3186550736,
-0.1428671628,
-0.2232847214,
0.4374677539,
0.0447571203,
1.0195127726,
-0.4303774238,
-0.207572028,
-0.357132405,
1.1086703539,
0.1103933752,
0.2914883494,
0.09469717,
-0.9850611091,
0.0137575045,
0.0515090525,
-1.032559514,
-0.1428290755,
-0.3418694139,
0.1453642696,
0.3770516813,
0.745582521,
-0.3695853353,
0.7627126575,
-0.0471414477,
-0.3653616309,
0.3925218284,
0.0362634957,
0.3435830474,
-0.6998680234,
-0.042712044,
-0.168217212,
0.1933664232,
-0.2877359688,
-0.3978307545,
0.0335128456,
0.0068421843,
-0.5647234917,
0.7221190333,
-0.7535030842,
-0.0470664389,
-0.275610894,
0.6082288027,
0.2506500185,
0.3882004917,
0.0294807423,
-0.1803446859,
0.2831110656,
-0.4563340545,
0.580681622,
0.5872678161,
-0.5417016149,
0.5788898468,
-0.0201305635,
-0.1414946318,
-0.6863544583,
0.3419502974,
-0.9161090851,
-0.6254968047,
0.022301672,
-0.8584169745,
-0.0908109248,
-0.5676419139,
-0.4827426076,
-0.252193898,
0.0132458555,
0.4388776124,
0.2696850896,
-0.3601436019,
0.782404542,
0.8669015765,
-0.1453739852,
-0.4355912209,
-0.6911767125,
0.2598295808,
-0.0180099774,
-0.4583446681,
0.063866131,
0.3317300081,
-0.434546113,
0.2091558874,
-0.0299983285,
-0.6094989777,
0.1892851144,
0.4235802293,
0.3060206473,
-0.2377584726,
0.1445612609,
0.0078330608,
-0.697501719,
-0.0226214863,
-0.0978712291,
-0.1661487818,
0.0123833204,
-0.2585095465,
-1.1154040098,
0.6340414882,
0.4531168342,
-0.3580261469,
0.468555212,
0.7835325599,
-0.665749073,
0.3922326863,
-0.5933644772,
0.3255577981,
-0.3181339502,
0.2132900953,
-0.1631390601,
-0.7957800627,
0.2999155521,
0.083883293,
0.1285048425,
0.6783910394,
0.268961817,
-0.0179044325,
0.8857599497,
0.3890322149,
0.1194769591,
0.0714316145,
0.1658491343,
0.2580979168,
-0.7219017148,
-0.3991030157,
-0.1487211436,
-0.3543471992,
-0.2560552359,
-0.4635419548,
0.1626152098,
0.2119068801,
-0.034741208,
0.2355512828,
-0.3098708987,
0.8949725032,
0.5718566179,
-0.401501745,
0.936561048,
-0.5450971127,
0.3547256887,
0.1929848343,
-0.184844479,
-0.9395945668,
0.9744880795,
0.1465344727,
0.3521943092,
0.1848037988,
0.6929151416,
0.437569648,
0.4656434357,
-0.237703383,
0.3310876787,
0.1049989015,
-0.7005362511,
-0.2808547318,
-0.1224165261,
-1.1252791882,
-0.1293617636,
-0.4482260346,
-1.1642197371,
0.2401066124,
-0.1264119297,
-0.7477478385,
0.4604513347,
-0.9379141927,
0.6844154596,
-0.0568123199,
-0.2550294399,
0.1867057979,
-0.9069501162,
0.3511969745,
0.1053262129,
0.3638624251,
-0.6291470528,
-0.0442964397,
0.7935804725,
0.1289077848,
0.7611082196,
-0.2286237925,
0.1335445344,
0.6047412753,
0.0884361267,
0.5402412415,
0.4028664529,
-0.1140583232,
-0.1308896989,
0.3392773569,
-0.4325528443,
-0.6697477698,
0.2026364952,
-0.4511910379,
-0.4252662957,
-0.4639481008,
-0.5514825583,
0.1142541692,
0.0689038038,
0.2467555851,
0.5465137362,
-0.2571727931,
0.0382965282,
0.2349190712,
-0.2380830944,
0.5696592927,
0.7228966951,
0.0272365622,
-0.1830284595,
0.614544332,
0.1477340311,
-0.1136724129,
0.7104538679,
-0.008470566,
-0.1683625132,
-0.8428730965,
-0.5646778941,
-0.1024113521,
-0.5953809619,
-0.1855792701,
-0.8252079487,
-0.2997424006,
-0.3536613286,
-0.2071928978,
-0.2156061679,
-0.6083517671,
-0.3796677887,
-0.618672967,
0.1983754337,
1.0877047777,
-0.2738630474,
-0.0065347622,
-0.7056965828,
0.5083290339,
0.0190469567,
-0.0679253936,
-0.1014742702,
-0.2109127194,
-0.1778850257,
-0.3967059553,
-0.2816486359,
-1.0354994535,
0.1462770104,
-0.2017088383,
0.6506925225,
0.6379492879,
0.392036289,
0.1075052917,
-0.3165256083,
0.7473049164,
0.0076132054,
-1.0025415421,
0.8300200701,
-0.4852519929,
0.2442621738,
0.4993950129,
0.5679180622,
-0.6704465151,
-0.3944222331,
-0.923201263,
-0.8891162872,
0.6940370798,
0.2573641241,
0.0898145884,
-0.2098171413,
0.5991806984,
0.3898996115,
0.526289463,
-0.8959479928,
-0.1845438927,
0.124587819,
-0.0875659883,
-0.0114673255,
-0.560654223,
0.0127817802,
-0.3455597758,
0.2156922966,
-0.0793933943,
0.0623493418,
0.0706314445,
-0.3986263275,
0.0227889214,
0.0710747465,
0.0197234508,
0.7329974771,
-0.1488243192,
0.4393669069,
0.2889862955,
-0.1545402706,
0.1043266505,
0.3141481876,
-0.1495047659,
0.0294235777,
1.0893330574,
0.8871290088,
0.6118848324,
-0.643024087,
0.8889106512,
0.1262637973,
-0.3550331295,
-0.498152554,
0.0225205161,
-0.1710297316,
0.5039268732,
0.6668289304,
-0.2456115335,
0.1074132323,
-0.7223050594,
0.3976112008,
-0.017718276,
-0.346701622,
-0.393494606,
0.4116687477,
0.4632394612,
-0.2564237118,
0.5652815104,
-0.9426082373,
-0.1762826443,
0.4457119703,
0.2568981051,
0.5423630476,
0.0728317201,
0.6153490543,
0.4632763863,
0.4353526533,
0.3186100423,
-0.0012006196,
-0.0075064222,
-0.6841045022,
-0.4842796922,
-0.6417395473,
-0.4423186183,
0.1744373143,
-0.7243663669,
0.2462476939,
-0.1473571658,
0.1920645237,
0.310741663,
0.0208426248,
-0.4336691797,
-0.021186782,
0.4912430048,
0.4700545371,
-1.0586464405,
0.3402370512,
0.2564488947,
-0.611046195,
-0.2924400568,
-0.1005284265,
0.5726538301,
-0.5694808364,
0.5924210548,
0.2278619409,
0.3845951855,
-0.190001592,
-0.1703867912,
-1.2158151865,
1.0845338106,
0.4475981593,
-0.1360668838,
-0.3625413179,
-0.091334641,
0.4230169654,
-0.4773094356,
0.2710114717,
0.6628201604,
0.9129142761,
0.2025226653,
-0.6387553215,
-0.0918259844,
-0.4584378302,
-0.5741636753,
0.5336160064,
-0.2120792568,
0.8607051969,
-0.595982492,
-0.572050035,
0.2708333731,
0.8765771985,
-0.1164159998,
0.9947115779,
0.6067759991,
0.2418622971,
1.366800189,
-0.2792509198,
0.9304139018,
0.2096595615,
0.0109942127,
1.3481174707,
-0.1610703319,
0.5129432082,
0.1354551315,
0.1667235941,
0.6456350684,
0.6487324238,
-0.1430108845,
0.0706591532,
0.3676408231,
-0.3260335326,
-0.1691416651,
-0.210501641,
0.0166923441,
0.5741544366,
-0.1469622254,
-0.2692836225,
-0.5030183792,
0.4822252095,
0.1288777441,
-0.0624198876,
-0.1990481615,
0.8202779889,
-0.4017766118,
-0.7106979489,
0.0906306952,
-0.0840448067,
0.1329108775,
-0.3107527494,
-0.0789227784,
0.0607830845,
-0.1991287321,
-0.2882899642,
-0.7340836525,
0.5533260703,
0.1460032165,
-0.3906392753,
-0.220512405,
0.3761349618,
-0.0263391957,
-0.5161648989,
0.0873150006,
0.533981204,
0.2842262387,
-0.3171544671,
-0.1422173381,
0.0698113665,
-0.0745919272,
-0.0299109425,
-0.0016672843,
1.1152952909,
-0.365575105,
0.3574278057,
0.4208919704,
-0.4755733907,
-0.0117898742,
0.0294825509,
0.3380575776,
-1.0351983309,
-0.5723384023,
-0.5457652211,
0.5085492134,
-0.3198914826,
-0.7519110441,
0.7471589446,
0.7503659725,
0.4850902855,
0.5141113997,
0.881754458,
0.0495480821,
0.6443947554,
-0.4879099131,
0.3796698153,
-0.4774618745,
0.2115472555,
-0.3620012701,
-0.1948381811,
-0.1038457006,
0.1697637439,
-0.2018239945,
-0.4326434135,
0.9725167155,
0.283660382,
0.1728353649,
0.7319195867,
-0.1679097414,
0.1914706677,
-0.0179958008,
0.63903898,
1.3613284826,
-0.0451558195,
0.4337139726,
0.030822739,
-0.5599960685,
-0.2735211849,
-1.1855473518,
-0.527854085,
-1.2571262121,
-0.6017351747,
0.0747490674,
0.1259758472,
0.6514878869,
0.6792016029,
-0.6455723643,
0.129253298,
-0.0585454889,
0.4131477177,
-0.0513365753,
-0.2698973119,
0.4576209188,
-0.367049396,
-0.5854411125,
0.230980143,
0.3208846748,
0.0186299812,
0.2173462808,
0.4038149118,
-0.4419129491,
-0.0379095674,
0.5950757861,
0.2487902641,
-0.5086529255,
-0.4889314473,
-0.5374911427,
0.3684722483,
0.0860009044,
1.1194528341,
-0.8579477668,
0.1199558601,
0.2523083985,
0.7052173615,
0.7886721492,
-0.2861388624,
0.6157849431,
-0.6427281499,
0.021598665,
0.2566457093,
0.2781426013,
0.2228980958,
-0.368206352,
0.4471782446,
0.3238644302,
-0.1998501271,
-0.8134821057,
0.3065985441,
-1.0033829212,
-0.3780971169,
0.9209024906,
0.0686143041,
-0.4467695355,
-0.7045453191,
-0.2745154202,
0.4161371589,
-0.1229734197,
0.5691229105,
0.7395995259,
-0.7018951178,
-0.2292683423,
-0.5782972574,
0.6113626361,
-0.1394774169,
-0.9081613421,
0.3219586313,
0.5586309433,
-0.2882260084,
0.5368041992,
0.7537956834,
-0.2387025505,
0.2239805907,
-0.101623714,
-0.0682261959,
-0.2237085551,
-0.4917044938,
0.1831674874,
0.6094198227,
-0.3695369661,
-0.1477703452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07679v1 | On graph-based reentrancy-free semantic parsing | 2023-02-15T14:14:09 | 2023-02-15T14:14:09 | Alban Petit, Caio Corro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose a novel graph-based approach for semantic parsing that resolves
two problems observed in the literature: (1) seq2seq models fail on
compositional generalization tasks; (2) previous work using phrase structure
parsers cannot cover all the semantic parses observed in treebanks. We prove
that both MAP inference and latent tag anchoring (required for
weakly-supervised learning) are NP-hard problems. We propose two optimization
algorithms based on constraint smoothing and conditional gradient to
approximately solve these inference problems. Experimentally, our approach
delivers state-of-the-art results on Geoquery, Scan and Clevr, both for i.i.d.
splits and for splits that test for compositional generalization. | [
-0.0846822858,
-1.0025820732,
0.7498493791,
0.1132338047,
-0.3123843074,
0.0489558503,
-0.0497805364,
-0.4303679466,
0.2624818385,
0.6174278259,
-0.7261778116,
-0.8962337971,
-0.5523515344,
-0.0826540068,
-0.1838627607,
0.8069723248,
-0.1823915392,
-0.0589819811,
-0.4169581532,
-0.2253619134,
-0.2983835936,
-0.2550807595,
-0.666913569,
-0.4263926446,
0.7453889847,
0.3440092206,
0.741928637,
0.8379705548,
0.1868306398,
0.2404785156,
-0.1944762915,
0.2629390359,
-0.3853990436,
0.1473417878,
-0.3967035413,
-0.4236521423,
-0.3008587956,
0.0231171045,
0.587002337,
1.2985591888,
0.2422546297,
-0.2363396585,
-0.1814351976,
0.6148312688,
-0.5892252922,
0.3395543694,
-0.7595437765,
0.0480205268,
-0.0179188289,
0.0943180546,
-0.4401322901,
-0.1198752001,
0.1529656649,
-0.9054914117,
0.5151347518,
0.0197383109,
1.0002071857,
0.513284564,
-0.626535058,
-0.1014397964,
-0.2490371168,
0.7719172835,
-0.2906903327,
0.4583238363,
0.5027551651,
0.2060614079,
-0.4543776512,
-1.0323938131,
-0.1713697463,
0.1640581191,
-0.1915151179,
0.0431657247,
-0.0814765915,
0.1567438543,
0.2320995629,
0.2819074392,
-0.5736119151,
-0.1023311764,
0.1797303855,
-0.1852637976,
0.3102563024,
0.1170977056,
0.3806454241,
-0.4490972757,
-0.4077813029,
-0.02734318,
-0.5632786751,
0.2716152668,
0.3080574274,
0.4876902997,
0.0082524512,
0.5002703071,
-0.4511359036,
0.8400978446,
-0.3324745297,
0.0598517656,
0.1581276506,
-0.3112585843,
-0.0403387435,
-0.235793978,
0.4133235812,
0.410446316,
0.2039210796,
-0.3846728206,
-0.0839121416,
0.4815784991,
-0.2512947321,
-0.4173233807,
-0.4891565144,
0.2763879895,
-0.2949436009,
-0.0105192065,
-0.0930757076,
-0.7028785348,
0.0204471052,
-0.3764408529,
0.1319555938,
-0.4291231036,
-0.0595353916,
0.2960995436,
-0.4349023104,
0.5222862959,
0.323661238,
-0.8203786612,
0.3423325717,
1.0351854563,
0.7539434433,
0.010801971,
-0.0799487606,
-0.40703848,
0.3727102876,
-0.1181157902,
0.9963185787,
-0.6208643913,
-0.4584447145,
-0.1984520257,
0.2309503704,
-0.4489706457,
-0.3370071054,
0.8748598695,
-0.3179149628,
-0.0728531405,
-0.4175021052,
-0.6613946557,
-0.0903066248,
0.353017956,
-0.6289945245,
0.8204674125,
0.4547820687,
-0.9665772915,
0.1875147671,
-0.0339305885,
-0.41933617,
-0.1362972111,
-0.191161707,
-0.3198547959,
-0.014538724,
0.3617066741,
-0.1579481214,
-0.2174585611,
0.4908315539,
-0.353110373,
-0.1915602833,
-0.3105160594,
0.1266686022,
0.8461621404,
0.1765071154,
-0.1653918624,
0.2199734598,
-0.6430369616,
0.5172467828,
0.3719349802,
-0.1447128206,
-0.3646191359,
0.3882641196,
-0.2285829633,
0.0630818978,
0.2176344842,
-0.6640782952,
0.192704156,
-0.679697454,
0.5024446845,
0.5721601844,
-0.0733465031,
0.3098710775,
-0.0560821854,
0.2280257642,
-0.1509700119,
-0.12887986,
-0.0848715529,
-0.6328114867,
-0.8279559016,
-0.3379740715,
0.4426504374,
0.7959498763,
-0.7140304446,
0.3922730088,
-0.3962846696,
-0.2384961545,
-0.1109678298,
-0.03803147,
0.4994879663,
0.8686859608,
0.5512992144,
-0.1829063743,
-0.3477439582,
-0.8804487586,
-0.4979027808,
0.0076244497,
0.0985347107,
0.383866787,
0.275918752,
-0.3368006945,
1.1400665045,
-0.878631413,
-0.09536428,
-0.2109514028,
0.075799197,
0.0913671777,
0.6317740679,
0.356484592,
-0.5735254884,
-0.267693013,
-0.2569893301,
-0.6768756509,
-0.4238374829,
0.4762915075,
-0.2539991438,
-0.0377105214,
0.48948282,
-0.6914120913,
0.5630733371,
0.1945131719,
-0.5446509123,
-0.0180529617,
-0.0370478593,
-0.5776071548,
-0.6298031807,
-0.2102285326,
-0.1381226331,
-0.6332272887,
-0.4725030363,
0.1516573578,
-0.2930027544,
-0.4395252764,
-0.06039441,
0.4273266196,
-0.1756593436,
-0.3853502572,
-0.3249137402,
0.2659359574,
0.5246045589,
0.4747285545,
0.0583875254,
0.0938370302,
0.364369601,
-0.1321499199,
0.2046697438,
0.3738074303,
0.1954267621,
0.1707867235,
-0.8350265026,
0.1488964558,
-0.3961643875,
0.5646808147,
-1.3691436052,
-0.0867818147,
0.4601833224,
-0.3272844851,
0.2703842223,
-0.5326414108,
-0.2437220067,
-0.1705490947,
-0.2454678863,
0.5262900591,
0.0015905175,
-0.4490916133,
0.5520076156,
0.1523532569,
0.2003390044,
-0.3759350479,
-0.5821731091,
0.006606875,
-0.033829283,
-1.1039824486,
0.3568893671,
0.5895845294,
-0.1143936515,
0.5067105889,
-0.3389103115,
-0.0941999853,
0.4343357086,
0.0628409982,
-0.0181519929,
-0.2303997278,
-0.0925430432,
0.1604706198,
-0.8007090092,
-0.0537278652,
-0.7017384171,
0.6074088216,
-0.1948908567,
-0.4798565507,
-0.497232914,
0.7411144972,
-0.2067738771,
-0.4578356445,
0.3665867746,
0.4013428986,
-0.3037938178,
-0.2870736718,
-0.0334041454,
0.0893344507,
-0.3663722873,
0.1435912251,
-0.3793407083,
-1.0364098549,
0.459843576,
-0.4160002768,
-0.3353500366,
0.610891521,
0.1372216344,
0.0637202486,
0.8470540047,
0.2258341014,
0.2556662858,
0.2247760445,
-0.5155528784,
0.4864112735,
-0.5259767771,
-0.0922015235,
-0.6544858217,
-0.2731114328,
-0.8732072115,
-0.5171939731,
0.0352957845,
0.2011012286,
-0.1976492554,
0.1149922088,
-0.444049418,
0.5755915642,
0.6671355367,
-0.0610231124,
0.2126149684,
0.1801211238,
-0.351397723,
0.0486840308,
-0.5549365878,
-0.2314221561,
0.7644202709,
-0.0444889218,
0.7272890806,
0.0848577023,
0.7229084373,
-0.0208812412,
-0.2652978301,
-0.9466222525,
0.4752971828,
-0.3860187829,
-0.2421741337,
-0.3676139414,
-0.4350943565,
-1.0509923697,
0.6319945455,
0.0682068691,
-0.9674651623,
0.2844602764,
0.1357457042,
0.2173978984,
0.2018912286,
-0.9033719301,
1.2690702677,
0.0170339085,
-0.4395121634,
0.2500860393,
-1.1132283211,
0.201786533,
0.3333728313,
0.1611947268,
-0.6519373655,
0.0052136085,
0.3215536475,
-0.7454547882,
0.845898211,
-0.5965105891,
0.3695123792,
0.5920869112,
0.0237130448,
0.6214640141,
-0.0375961214,
0.3365533948,
0.0018401555,
0.1277471185,
-0.7241380811,
-0.7954692841,
0.5689917803,
-0.7576768994,
-0.6850901246,
-0.3804001212,
-0.5209237933,
-0.4532502294,
0.2870371342,
0.1434021741,
0.3926063776,
0.2125009596,
-0.0155235371,
0.2881392837,
0.0986434892,
0.2199140042,
-0.1083076969,
-0.2173241377,
-0.535983026,
0.974114418,
0.0697962791,
0.172662288,
0.3240319192,
0.4533164203,
-0.3286627531,
-0.5466628671,
-0.2102418095,
0.427567333,
-0.8467550874,
-0.1117761359,
-0.9188248515,
0.0519398004,
-0.4914125204,
-0.2130290568,
-0.1409597844,
-0.8879611492,
-0.1511097103,
-0.1138317734,
0.0737472996,
0.1838116646,
0.0911946073,
0.5315800309,
-0.2876566648,
0.4629962742,
0.2115505338,
0.1924421042,
-0.2614618838,
0.0319877043,
0.0979012474,
-0.1883659065,
-0.3449875116,
-0.6941896677,
0.0134264417,
0.3013504744,
0.4637028575,
0.2034844011,
0.0047754114,
0.614980638,
-0.4655430317,
0.5308628678,
-0.1552926749,
-1.0144969225,
0.6226297617,
-0.5182636976,
-0.0313211419,
0.665384531,
0.1356077194,
-0.4694123566,
-0.3103501499,
-0.639294982,
-1.2596626282,
0.5005180836,
0.0481740385,
-0.15222013,
-0.3339366317,
0.5943869948,
-0.2908129394,
-0.1512833387,
-0.6021393538,
-0.172889635,
-0.5820540786,
-0.3803532124,
0.0773475096,
-0.5645589828,
-0.0460891277,
-0.3178780377,
0.4254620671,
-0.4225174189,
0.0021428659,
0.4505687058,
-0.1578089893,
0.2132943124,
0.1996491104,
0.139822647,
0.5994337797,
-0.1948593408,
0.5156068802,
-0.2306549251,
0.0816813782,
0.282134831,
0.1855704188,
-0.4505124986,
-0.0415495001,
0.5500137806,
0.6079426408,
0.314476341,
-0.4479370713,
0.6074157357,
0.055941537,
-0.1950494647,
-0.063738592,
0.0150320223,
0.4070689976,
0.1659206152,
-0.1541447341,
-0.5029673576,
0.1244652197,
-0.0808380842,
0.2555771768,
0.5606920123,
-0.2451880574,
-0.1778191328,
0.747212708,
-0.0363018736,
-0.0380305871,
0.5432293415,
-0.2966253161,
-0.4834896326,
0.6273854971,
0.896912694,
0.7607369423,
-0.0011272684,
0.1168135256,
0.2001282275,
0.050348632,
0.2643513381,
0.4109405875,
-0.1674028039,
-0.8279241323,
-0.5297039151,
-0.5678939819,
-0.4235073626,
-0.4503908455,
-0.433190167,
0.0720144734,
-0.6361117959,
-0.1570677757,
0.1480292827,
0.0193392877,
-0.1944480538,
0.3250038028,
-0.214621678,
0.6377587914,
-0.8222614527,
0.629746139,
0.6047105789,
-0.1265945733,
-0.855837822,
-0.3027827144,
0.0352510475,
-0.8361235857,
0.5506603718,
0.3601279557,
-0.2929093838,
0.0628955066,
-0.4649462402,
-0.9067236781,
0.8638256788,
0.4965254664,
0.0030776325,
-0.2060647309,
0.2211564034,
0.353107065,
-0.3972931802,
-0.3765167892,
0.5851368308,
0.420540303,
0.3959497809,
-0.3032903373,
0.0068552522,
-0.0012488443,
0.1791412085,
0.4440065622,
-0.6370058656,
1.0785601139,
0.1813020557,
-0.3282229602,
0.0861848518,
0.6824555993,
-0.0552312173,
0.7715449333,
0.6022983789,
1.400203824,
0.9790307879,
-0.2793409824,
1.1229887009,
-0.3012995422,
0.7532936335,
1.3782942295,
-0.291703254,
0.3495770395,
0.4100594521,
-0.1137289703,
0.5529242754,
0.710991919,
0.1271686256,
0.4870710969,
0.4663441181,
-0.4124926627,
-0.4130029678,
-0.4202746749,
-0.1589654237,
0.6346337795,
0.3534143567,
-0.1939071566,
-0.9139043093,
-0.4827129245,
0.2747298777,
0.1344933659,
-0.0691139325,
0.6439691186,
0.0987248868,
-0.4798225462,
0.2248097658,
0.2593936324,
-0.1285359561,
-0.4273532331,
0.0878470913,
-0.1887288243,
-0.053660851,
-0.3708588183,
-0.4330205023,
0.6899639964,
-0.2913297713,
-0.1065075919,
-0.0448833816,
1.0113013983,
-0.1678141356,
-0.4764309824,
0.4658325911,
0.8381712437,
0.0242014825,
0.0100248251,
-0.4152215719,
-0.1676599383,
-0.1062457487,
-0.0359317958,
-0.0206575487,
0.6422159076,
-0.3480323851,
0.3926531076,
0.6419357061,
-0.1949011385,
0.1788829118,
0.0439601764,
1.1070697308,
-0.9006798267,
-0.5740807056,
-0.6377441883,
0.0779005885,
0.0572702177,
0.0042923172,
0.5346660018,
0.6215553284,
0.7906002998,
0.3740024269,
0.4267843664,
0.1663085818,
0.4498238564,
-0.6226373315,
-0.0927727073,
-0.4866229296,
-0.1551146507,
-0.2155119926,
-0.9926494956,
-0.6926048398,
0.5596108437,
-0.5700363517,
-0.2158697844,
0.8008762598,
0.5515003204,
-0.0163643863,
0.0737524182,
0.0730651021,
-0.260476023,
0.5403502584,
0.7508904934,
0.840215385,
-0.0952448174,
0.1916110516,
-0.1099234819,
-0.1100889221,
0.025615532,
-0.8626021147,
-0.5913478732,
-0.1896565855,
-0.14953655,
-0.506832242,
-0.1077516526,
0.6776016355,
0.2745847404,
-0.4934687018,
0.3018083274,
-0.2829674184,
0.6360094547,
0.2669958174,
-0.2186228782,
0.6926578283,
-0.7325471044,
-0.5278973579,
0.4337413609,
0.3336883783,
0.0246634204,
0.3057162762,
0.2979433835,
-0.23804304,
-0.1433591247,
0.3417041302,
0.3702730834,
-0.7666798234,
-0.7023860812,
-0.3898354173,
0.0219756067,
0.4584322274,
1.0977797508,
-0.6410741806,
0.3149636686,
0.6212080717,
0.9293216467,
0.7814690471,
0.4509856999,
-0.0783495381,
-0.8053386807,
0.638183713,
0.0978719071,
0.5170164704,
0.3790305853,
-0.0503233857,
0.6359818578,
0.8886092305,
-0.3929482996,
-0.3598810136,
0.738194406,
-1.2248769999,
-0.2802174687,
0.8746455312,
-0.4158811867,
-0.712995708,
-0.3062001467,
0.1104390547,
0.2627569437,
0.0006826742,
-0.1231317669,
0.5662997365,
-0.3826238811,
0.1692354828,
-0.2458740026,
0.2281124443,
0.5201236606,
-0.6238002181,
0.0052610473,
0.8236632943,
0.3550117314,
0.1007346213,
0.7757247686,
-0.0443908535,
-0.0344644077,
0.2263054997,
-0.3401069641,
-0.1574707478,
-0.3465618193,
-0.0929394141,
0.4200795293,
0.094295077,
-0.1087044924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07636v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07636v2 | DP-BART for Privatized Text Rewriting under Local Differential Privacy | 2023-02-15T13:07:34 | 2023-06-06T14:17:46 | Timour Igamberdiev, Ivan Habernal | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Privatized text rewriting with local differential privacy (LDP) is a recent
approach that enables sharing of sensitive textual documents while formally
guaranteeing privacy protection to individuals. However, existing systems face
several issues, such as formal mathematical flaws, unrealistic privacy
guarantees, privatization of only individual words, as well as a lack of
transparency and reproducibility. In this paper, we propose a new system
'DP-BART' that largely outperforms existing LDP systems. Our approach uses a
novel clipping method, iterative pruning, and further training of internal
representations which drastically reduces the amount of noise required for DP
guarantees. We run experiments on five textual datasets of varying sizes,
rewriting them at different privacy guarantees and evaluating the rewritten
texts on downstream text classification tasks. Finally, we thoroughly discuss
the privatized text rewriting approach and its limitations, including the
problem of the strict text adjacency constraint in the LDP paradigm that leads
to the high noise requirement. | [
-0.2931166291,
-0.7320224047,
0.6618877053,
0.2971328199,
-0.5289207101,
0.255949527,
-0.2727855146,
-0.404265672,
0.3967083097,
0.8779494166,
-0.5190783143,
-0.7438607812,
-0.4966954589,
0.35090518,
-0.3663118184,
1.0236284733,
-0.3202336133,
-0.1793203652,
-0.0765360668,
0.2257658392,
-0.2193736583,
-0.7798057199,
-0.2508288026,
0.1643741578,
0.4694847465,
0.3530187905,
0.6985741258,
0.5685243011,
0.6240830421,
0.2970412374,
-0.307161957,
0.1446484476,
-0.4160647094,
0.4888048172,
-0.0459046774,
-0.4266729653,
-0.6721377969,
-0.3268069923,
1.1486608982,
0.7399638891,
-0.1141555682,
-0.137021631,
0.2394168675,
1.0884648561,
-0.8624859452,
0.02274324,
-0.6261302233,
0.1127540916,
-0.1127548963,
-0.0649880543,
-0.398127079,
-0.6924983859,
0.0167528372,
-0.7315722704,
0.3423858285,
0.0183625389,
0.5753731728,
0.3788786829,
-0.3959444463,
-0.168940708,
-0.8420605063,
0.6628829241,
-0.5499122739,
0.2491924614,
0.6590257287,
0.171455726,
-0.1457763016,
-0.8647235632,
-0.3164051473,
-0.0334542021,
-0.0688495561,
-0.0135027217,
-0.2222963721,
0.2684752941,
0.211817652,
0.6859941483,
-0.2020983994,
-0.0451478474,
-0.4238817692,
-0.20144701,
0.6633663774,
0.2198180407,
-0.3163047135,
-0.0780337006,
-0.653291285,
-0.0623647645,
-0.5825040936,
-0.1460648626,
0.7919409871,
-0.0844665095,
0.2707904875,
0.2549390197,
-0.3846325278,
0.3082507551,
-0.0098778605,
-0.1727789789,
0.2268113047,
-0.2070503086,
-0.340405196,
0.1426999718,
0.6407999396,
0.3644864261,
0.0730661154,
-0.1122558638,
-0.2269699275,
-0.2361629307,
0.2299129665,
-0.5772315264,
-0.2661091685,
0.1612324417,
-0.4746317863,
-0.5749459863,
-0.0742059723,
-0.6669860482,
-0.4180094898,
-0.3314804733,
0.1469834149,
-0.6199123263,
-0.2891742885,
0.5098158121,
-0.0339294747,
-0.2277475148,
0.4316972792,
-1.0119353533,
0.8892407417,
0.9133111238,
0.8239812255,
-0.1538197696,
-0.2235133946,
-0.1432947218,
0.4468446374,
-0.2091659755,
0.4803979397,
-0.4148160517,
-0.5178334117,
-0.1101966724,
0.0016980608,
0.0951642841,
-0.4677357674,
0.8504367471,
-0.4415241182,
0.2754668295,
-0.2962093949,
-0.7767421603,
-0.0231121909,
0.1240382344,
-0.700084269,
0.7207841873,
-0.0261268448,
-1.2448790073,
0.4020724893,
-0.2916724384,
-0.2855697274,
-0.209324792,
-0.0674909875,
-0.7861838937,
0.1670593023,
0.4785268009,
0.2903639972,
0.0951323733,
0.5573082566,
-0.282134831,
-0.4425839782,
0.3132128716,
-0.7396451235,
0.9799796939,
0.0671553165,
-0.1548589617,
0.0529169776,
-0.7222712636,
-0.0735971853,
-0.0267513189,
-0.3947809339,
-0.6128512621,
-0.1530674845,
-0.1163119078,
-0.5078902245,
0.4242146611,
-0.8602394462,
0.6158455014,
-0.5313919187,
0.47467044,
1.0849387646,
0.1395623982,
0.7107335329,
-0.5281102061,
0.5134949088,
-0.3605598509,
0.4353899956,
-0.1747426838,
-0.5598641038,
-0.2108769566,
-0.7609505057,
0.6117261648,
0.123472847,
-0.3114567399,
0.3214659095,
-0.1380736232,
-0.1956775039,
-0.2511302531,
-0.2373201996,
0.2652405798,
0.422203958,
0.0688122511,
-0.4091386795,
-0.3402225375,
-1.0302807093,
-0.0343013778,
0.0210383683,
-0.0034736854,
0.382799536,
0.290782392,
-0.151115045,
0.996758461,
-0.7679024935,
-0.6726403832,
-0.0765941292,
0.0444674157,
-0.0592279024,
0.5315580964,
0.2982928455,
-0.650021255,
-0.6288882494,
-0.4368275106,
-0.3216705918,
-0.2453022748,
-0.132904768,
-0.105929479,
0.2433141917,
0.2881593704,
-0.1967297643,
0.5790162086,
0.3854182065,
-0.2119270712,
0.6280537844,
-0.741825223,
-0.0856249854,
-0.8643379211,
-0.0923530683,
-0.6525076628,
-0.6129401922,
-0.3327869773,
-0.0572642274,
0.11605791,
-0.3635952771,
-0.1284567863,
0.0971747786,
-0.6917632818,
-0.3264589012,
-0.4298560917,
0.0474610738,
0.0687925965,
0.5009837151,
0.2574756444,
0.3825919628,
0.6152290702,
-0.5631605983,
0.3094124794,
0.4131617248,
-0.3527665138,
0.1860601157,
-0.2872819304,
-0.0373890474,
-0.2811307311,
0.6690312624,
-0.5190281272,
-0.0962941125,
0.2929394543,
-0.045794595,
0.2420868576,
-0.1414913684,
-0.5968325734,
0.073358573,
-0.6682573557,
0.4919121563,
0.4807703793,
-0.3825421333,
0.2238604575,
0.4026428759,
-0.3569605649,
-0.9333356619,
-0.3698938787,
0.3193424642,
-0.2177564353,
-0.5291282535,
0.7359882593,
0.3057676256,
-0.0938498527,
0.1365982145,
-0.1503770202,
-0.5450735688,
0.0944406167,
0.1801056415,
-0.0749432966,
0.1159074903,
-0.0095870961,
0.4689363837,
-0.5490301251,
-0.0842123702,
-0.0990060568,
0.3294264972,
0.0070513585,
-0.3469980061,
-0.820797503,
0.6282239556,
0.3715249598,
-0.1953025311,
0.3934381306,
0.2691659629,
-0.1491715908,
-0.4802432656,
-0.1510814279,
-0.2877259254,
-0.4769813716,
0.11576543,
-0.2008527964,
-0.709875524,
0.3045394719,
-0.3769227862,
0.2395285517,
-0.0257725269,
0.3883682787,
-0.1389489025,
0.3096404672,
0.9491597414,
-0.036771182,
0.6162400842,
-0.1263033897,
0.1239292249,
-0.6952615976,
0.0139216036,
-0.3221389353,
-0.4963445067,
-0.6757540107,
-0.432757169,
0.3394373953,
0.202166155,
-0.1732310057,
0.4105245173,
-0.7942891717,
0.5922930837,
0.9152603745,
0.2134895325,
0.9321286082,
0.1889994442,
0.1305450052,
-0.3066590726,
-0.4233071506,
-0.6521729827,
1.3637216091,
0.5786039233,
1.0950039625,
0.0256397612,
1.2064321041,
0.4003506303,
0.1126493812,
-0.2392279208,
0.6230110526,
-0.3363592625,
-0.7854299545,
-0.5230771303,
-0.4082326889,
-0.8510899544,
0.354396075,
-0.1027671844,
-0.7317413092,
0.5392193794,
0.1468500793,
-0.0542175435,
0.6352241635,
-0.5011020899,
0.4397627413,
-0.0472128727,
-0.4329424798,
-0.2956039608,
-0.5614224672,
0.3966260552,
-0.1385664493,
0.0475843623,
-0.2789483368,
-0.142394349,
0.6374429464,
-0.571772635,
1.0902317762,
-0.3304167092,
-0.4174361825,
0.1506303698,
0.2848072946,
0.4866347909,
0.3864162862,
0.032148201,
0.2165865004,
0.2950370014,
-0.046788428,
-0.2244003117,
0.6134753227,
-0.4885892868,
-0.39591223,
-0.5232051611,
-0.4753985107,
-0.0560522117,
0.2466115206,
0.2665635645,
0.3541458547,
-0.2571996152,
0.3550887406,
0.6107726097,
-0.3573019803,
0.2851292193,
0.5646683574,
-0.2195505053,
-0.5057811141,
0.8342531919,
-0.015343233,
0.1403989941,
0.486723274,
0.2379000187,
-0.3560063541,
-0.4934364855,
-0.3259226978,
0.2250968069,
-0.6373774409,
-0.1287655532,
-0.4976446927,
-0.0163474679,
-0.335046947,
-0.4526894391,
-0.6484797597,
-0.7849345803,
-0.0275223125,
0.0984458774,
0.1168787554,
0.7570408583,
-0.4068049788,
0.0723835975,
-0.5103613138,
0.6907502413,
0.0540550351,
0.7494881749,
-0.3835911751,
-0.257068187,
-0.0178866033,
-0.1998953521,
-0.4706719816,
-0.9594615102,
0.3713006079,
0.0160791986,
0.1109799594,
0.0756445304,
0.837729156,
0.2290341854,
-0.7420402765,
0.4198539853,
0.0150201125,
-1.0343304873,
0.2446154505,
-0.3654792905,
-0.3871770203,
0.6727774739,
0.0600512624,
-0.3671023548,
-0.7941643596,
-0.7501225471,
-1.0533792973,
0.6183053255,
0.4896317124,
0.0704379007,
0.3561143875,
0.4305372238,
0.4087550044,
0.4157628417,
-0.7815938592,
-0.2347459048,
-0.0382550098,
-0.1004024222,
0.2412878424,
-0.5003795624,
-0.2346202582,
-0.0419564471,
0.5669130087,
0.2540194392,
0.3247527182,
0.6047949791,
0.2609396577,
0.0964439288,
0.5248097181,
0.3154399097,
0.4914595783,
-0.5090941191,
0.0011733621,
-0.1225563437,
-0.6841751933,
0.3729736209,
-0.0093059521,
-0.6454169154,
0.3841669858,
0.1875673085,
0.4634067714,
0.2237980068,
-0.4017584324,
0.6527045965,
-0.2485939711,
-0.6758061051,
-0.4510883987,
-0.0355696529,
-0.2117389441,
0.005633282,
0.0777124912,
-0.1956841648,
0.2633897662,
-0.1600547135,
0.2110866755,
0.2278666645,
-0.0326151177,
-0.1182149127,
0.7306321263,
0.2859767377,
-0.0757779703,
0.2762325108,
-0.0668998808,
-0.2993324697,
0.2809123695,
0.6089684367,
1.0120812654,
-0.020571975,
0.4191454351,
0.1420471668,
0.447558105,
-0.1468515098,
0.1465928555,
-0.6390295029,
-0.503965795,
-0.3533653915,
-0.5250799656,
-1.0729744434,
-0.0692011714,
-0.8265959024,
0.0430430584,
-0.6770190001,
-0.0555671155,
-0.2277821749,
0.0489167459,
0.0928565785,
0.0583883151,
-0.0571202859,
0.4850662053,
-0.5169788003,
1.0184568167,
0.4955025017,
-0.0281677376,
-0.312684685,
0.2992368639,
-0.4257948101,
-0.4864118993,
0.7091712952,
-0.056538187,
-0.1710316092,
-0.1472004205,
-0.1953177452,
-0.739829421,
0.8984518647,
0.7812762856,
-0.9053449631,
-0.1755398363,
0.1754699498,
0.4081968665,
0.1652437299,
-0.4965655506,
0.2756528556,
0.3517487347,
-0.4281140268,
-1.0060198307,
0.0674661249,
0.4011387527,
-0.212630108,
0.1755967438,
-0.5860556364,
1.0227993727,
0.051408615,
-0.4522736967,
-0.0469550304,
0.3201295435,
-0.2206358165,
0.5114628673,
0.4916427135,
0.4957313538,
0.9388813376,
0.0449901745,
0.8326201439,
-0.2370791137,
0.5477697849,
1.2102754116,
-0.5175944567,
0.742584765,
0.2873568237,
-0.2781966329,
0.4487552643,
0.2495344728,
0.2281838804,
0.761895597,
0.4390044808,
-0.5829401016,
0.0467529371,
0.2292172462,
-0.4674345553,
0.2176609486,
-0.0851482302,
-0.460161984,
-0.3368246257,
0.0316623673,
-0.0858442187,
0.4837929904,
-0.064472422,
0.8030579686,
-0.0257268529,
-0.1502963603,
0.5853590369,
0.4383514524,
0.7266485095,
-0.477267772,
0.4209479988,
-0.2301390618,
0.5633834004,
-0.1368857771,
-0.7148211598,
0.7600733042,
0.1417995691,
-0.153160736,
-0.8310722709,
0.7560607195,
-0.1974426657,
-0.2826356292,
0.1217425689,
0.1039481089,
0.2659553885,
-0.226028949,
-0.5120477676,
0.0019972275,
0.195168525,
-0.3089883924,
0.35340482,
0.614290297,
-0.0009959199,
0.596495986,
0.4777675569,
0.1565692425,
-0.1477379501,
-0.0401493572,
1.1093686819,
-0.7159663439,
-0.9215510488,
-0.7270077467,
0.1295363903,
-0.1628771126,
-0.3124684691,
0.7015461922,
0.6938477159,
0.8062102199,
0.089362435,
0.7350383401,
0.1960600764,
0.8365673423,
-0.4378793538,
0.628077209,
-0.2918700576,
0.3953525126,
-0.4435673356,
-0.9524792433,
-0.3922701478,
0.7626128793,
-0.4615495801,
-0.4890912473,
0.6657360792,
0.4487457573,
0.0266865324,
0.1806808859,
0.4175705314,
-0.016859483,
0.2957972884,
0.5756853819,
0.6178942323,
-0.2543813586,
0.5630040169,
-0.8117833734,
-0.2891438007,
-0.0409192331,
-0.8360998034,
-0.5838103294,
-0.6514714956,
-0.2745089233,
-0.0796686932,
0.0331940986,
0.2197753489,
0.3523795307,
-0.3672077954,
-0.0066469419,
-0.4112569392,
0.2701129317,
-0.2288238257,
-0.1927763075,
0.6497824788,
-0.1720368564,
-0.874974668,
0.3234827518,
0.3597849309,
0.017995771,
-0.3345456123,
0.1476920694,
0.3961524069,
-0.0964913964,
0.1428990662,
0.1206403226,
-0.3949559033,
0.1538448334,
-0.2588341832,
-0.0814164355,
0.0145835746,
1.1565400362,
-0.6198977232,
0.3980720341,
0.347232759,
0.6509672999,
0.6703324318,
0.3835090995,
0.5833405256,
-0.9047644734,
0.445297569,
0.6265410781,
0.2913241386,
0.1793646812,
-0.4484035969,
0.1688400358,
0.2786802351,
-0.7929916978,
-1.1330001354,
0.435798645,
-0.7473053336,
-0.630821228,
0.8648985624,
-0.2855155766,
-0.1373602152,
-0.4108785987,
-0.6650381088,
-0.067201294,
-0.5206088424,
0.8337157369,
0.3280503452,
0.109866485,
0.1809898466,
-0.2853488922,
0.5886628032,
0.2821088731,
-0.3765580058,
0.8748820424,
0.6930842996,
0.3247764111,
-0.0716229826,
1.3915989399,
-0.2073031217,
-0.1480759233,
0.2121848017,
-0.0526797958,
-0.380361408,
-0.392739445,
-0.3302039504,
0.4796155393,
-0.0801759958,
-0.4316660464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07588v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07588v1 | Word class representations spontaneously emerge in a deep neural network trained on next word prediction | 2023-02-15T11:02:50 | 2023-02-15T11:02:50 | Kishore Surendra, Achim Schilling, Paul Stoewer, Andreas Maier, Patrick Krauss | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC | How do humans learn language, and can the first language be learned at all?
These fundamental questions are still hotly debated. In contemporary
linguistics, there are two major schools of thought that give completely
opposite answers. According to Chomsky's theory of universal grammar, language
cannot be learned because children are not exposed to sufficient data in their
linguistic environment. In contrast, usage-based models of language assume a
profound relationship between language structure and language use. In
particular, contextual mental processing and mental representations are assumed
to have the cognitive capacity to capture the complexity of actual language use
at all levels. The prime example is syntax, i.e., the rules by which words are
assembled into larger units such as sentences. Typically, syntactic rules are
expressed as sequences of word classes. However, it remains unclear whether
word classes are innate, as implied by universal grammar, or whether they
emerge during language acquisition, as suggested by usage-based approaches.
Here, we address this issue from a machine learning and natural language
processing perspective. In particular, we trained an artificial deep neural
network on predicting the next word, provided sequences of consecutive words as
input. Subsequently, we analyzed the emerging activation patterns in the hidden
layers of the neural network. Strikingly, we find that the internal
representations of nine-word input sequences cluster according to the word
class of the tenth word to be predicted as output, even though the neural
network did not receive any explicit information about syntactic rules or word
classes during training. This surprising result suggests, that also in the
human brain, abstract representational categories such as word classes may
naturally emerge as a consequence of predictive coding and processing during
language acquisition. | [
-0.3388229012,
-0.7542800307,
0.578158319,
-0.1644922942,
-0.1849369109,
0.2228702158,
-0.3533755243,
-0.5440289378,
-0.1273376793,
0.2654841542,
-0.3339364231,
-0.1462533027,
-0.7401925325,
0.1059873775,
-0.4339583218,
0.5415531993,
0.2946213186,
0.0166694857,
-0.3419771492,
0.0017238607,
-0.5977523327,
-0.8646238446,
-0.5017753243,
-0.7934350967,
0.5326794386,
0.2616306543,
0.6864483356,
0.6661304235,
0.1113872081,
0.3734274805,
-0.1469297111,
-0.1008079946,
-0.2022026777,
-0.018936215,
-0.0094581228,
-0.7528789639,
0.1372490823,
0.0480398387,
0.6368709803,
1.2492802143,
-0.1201624721,
-0.0634138137,
0.2629468143,
0.8035545945,
-0.3781000078,
0.3866893351,
-0.8307929635,
0.2564977407,
-0.3093540668,
-0.2008608878,
-0.3375298083,
-0.140349403,
0.4548456371,
-0.3569563031,
0.0643772036,
-0.1537916362,
0.6152456999,
-0.1598711908,
-0.223911494,
-0.3688199222,
-0.625969708,
0.4145869613,
-0.1859876215,
0.4299990237,
0.603169322,
0.0584516749,
-0.2754147053,
-0.7341193557,
-0.6625388265,
-0.5018629432,
-0.1584980637,
-0.0483191647,
-0.0277269743,
0.1271637082,
0.1665091217,
0.24844262,
-0.6367897391,
0.1416328847,
-0.5389524102,
-0.1705118269,
0.3761370778,
0.1104319096,
0.4898243546,
-0.0640585944,
-0.3051056266,
-0.0493502952,
-0.6066431403,
0.2907899022,
0.092074424,
0.4928638935,
0.1533575207,
0.4750706553,
0.1521165967,
0.5509001613,
-0.0809529573,
0.2215918154,
0.0912640616,
0.1491046399,
-0.2260782719,
0.3130570352,
0.7233159542,
-0.003846131,
0.5285793543,
-0.3196142912,
-0.1528325826,
0.6848599911,
0.5300000906,
-0.3053474426,
-0.2136839777,
-0.1975990832,
-0.1848253161,
-0.5145146251,
0.1997872293,
-0.5979205966,
-0.4845959842,
-0.3751054406,
0.3355353773,
-0.4594364464,
-0.2648913264,
0.1094871685,
-0.0241344515,
0.3123823106,
-0.0690067261,
-1.0607279539,
0.6162728667,
0.6003069878,
0.4978437424,
0.000934798,
-0.5527329445,
0.0179392509,
-0.1292842925,
-0.605676055,
0.7326577902,
-0.7064924836,
-0.3069559634,
0.2761740386,
0.0671743825,
-0.1074867696,
-0.6162993908,
0.1115441993,
-0.7713161707,
0.347848624,
-0.2462260574,
-0.6333545446,
-0.3860414922,
0.0296641178,
-0.4631380141,
0.8543320298,
-0.1158149913,
-0.5767163038,
0.5062295794,
-0.4261507094,
-0.5642508864,
0.4385291934,
-0.3289300799,
-0.1371912807,
0.556235671,
-0.2640559673,
0.4549727738,
-0.0337715335,
0.36359936,
-0.226192221,
-0.3663801849,
0.5087256432,
-0.3776165247,
0.6340901852,
-0.1122904569,
-0.4635781348,
-0.1479036957,
-0.6765881181,
0.0398836397,
0.3283311129,
-0.3416705132,
-0.4790582657,
0.0755286217,
-0.3783561289,
0.3397009671,
0.0232939161,
-0.4039258659,
0.1768095493,
-0.4613908827,
0.3998474777,
0.9471850395,
-0.1556565464,
0.758059442,
-0.1951867938,
0.4454247057,
-0.0019021122,
-0.2614023387,
-0.3356046975,
-0.4352728128,
-0.8124425411,
0.450239718,
0.1010628492,
0.4865753055,
-0.4062024951,
0.517623961,
-0.2165406495,
-0.1613033414,
-0.2314711511,
0.2918890715,
0.3225749135,
0.1007667258,
0.2681203187,
-0.4312929213,
-0.6770517826,
-0.6800739169,
-0.4661037028,
-0.356762737,
0.3033053279,
-0.0236036535,
0.3710939288,
-0.1571425349,
0.7544332743,
-0.3327376246,
-0.0864963979,
-0.5418303609,
0.1625021994,
-0.0787090585,
0.2926124334,
0.2014128864,
-0.4522803724,
-0.1676000506,
0.0047783824,
-0.8232651353,
0.2261987478,
-0.1914830208,
-0.096637167,
0.2767920196,
0.7345411181,
-0.3679148555,
0.3068445027,
0.3499051929,
-0.4321343899,
0.2244944125,
-0.2016786784,
-0.6708208323,
-0.8792403936,
-0.1129721552,
-0.1815806627,
0.0391246267,
-0.7048770189,
-0.1936267018,
0.0153463101,
-0.1139597595,
-0.0889962688,
0.523570478,
-0.5488008857,
-0.1878776401,
-0.4545116723,
-0.0362096466,
-0.166701898,
0.711540401,
0.0718484372,
0.483152926,
0.7267012,
-0.8510684967,
-0.0870095566,
-0.141458571,
-0.4622282386,
-0.1759730726,
-0.4525595605,
0.1949592829,
-0.3671343923,
-0.0011064658,
-0.8595263958,
-0.1568273902,
0.0378116556,
-0.5932527781,
0.5250356793,
0.1409913152,
-0.5592750907,
-0.3481195569,
0.1132172346,
0.1372068971,
0.6847503185,
-0.4262820482,
0.0794343576,
0.655179739,
0.0100167012,
-0.4150943458,
-0.885851562,
0.0196698997,
0.1012479588,
-0.2899560034,
0.0221676957,
0.2088774294,
-0.2528411448,
-0.008517975,
-0.1737278998,
-0.1369577646,
0.3603451848,
0.4392475486,
0.3141438365,
-0.0885349363,
0.4538054764,
-0.1063327789,
0.0161561538,
0.4249330163,
-0.7084028125,
0.8949106336,
-0.2963190973,
-0.0042927125,
-0.2231103033,
0.2680695355,
0.6691237688,
-0.2724097967,
0.6372107267,
0.4038187563,
-0.4579308629,
-0.3095413446,
-0.2819775343,
-0.2478888184,
-0.4321454465,
0.5770831108,
-0.3213713169,
-0.7966251969,
0.2913840115,
-0.0885597393,
-0.1780016124,
0.3895015121,
0.370952785,
-0.2402330637,
0.8398427367,
0.9339845777,
0.0645532906,
0.7564842105,
-0.5528771877,
-0.1788468808,
-0.6596407294,
-0.3425303102,
-0.1573651135,
-0.3511175513,
-0.5908363461,
-0.1516349614,
0.056513112,
0.3198291063,
-0.2045142353,
0.2768716514,
-0.2976777256,
0.55405128,
0.6259714961,
-0.0047100526,
0.0460015647,
0.4191877842,
-0.5139758587,
0.1299743801,
-0.7332960963,
-0.4929997623,
1.0049254894,
0.096419096,
0.2457156479,
-0.2291256487,
0.8413850665,
0.2355148643,
0.2609567642,
-0.9264827967,
0.7093411684,
-0.2015680522,
-0.399745822,
-0.1232559904,
-0.0939809382,
-1.3041400909,
0.4588105381,
-0.2380689085,
-0.634444952,
0.226883322,
-0.055589281,
-0.1895851791,
0.3456760645,
-0.6125752926,
0.698428452,
-0.2062143832,
-0.357008934,
-0.1032310575,
-0.7932358384,
0.3333864212,
0.0699987933,
0.3299789131,
0.0396521352,
0.0671487674,
0.6780962944,
-0.2578544617,
0.9315132499,
-0.0790599659,
-0.1115297601,
0.4834401011,
0.2171268612,
0.0986501947,
-0.1122559831,
0.1164404601,
0.0847500414,
-0.4516964257,
-0.2867174447,
-0.5345549583,
0.3214888871,
-0.9291064739,
-0.3656495214,
-0.7117226124,
-0.0740927383,
-0.2699916661,
0.4200030565,
0.5578103065,
0.5874717236,
-0.3767904937,
-0.1788034588,
0.4608898461,
-0.0116948476,
0.7213644981,
0.1742605716,
-0.3593532145,
-0.2919156253,
0.9569553137,
0.268445313,
0.263876915,
0.3259693086,
0.4870355129,
-0.2464922816,
-0.4179905355,
-0.1480304152,
0.1239141822,
-0.6462512612,
0.1468026787,
-0.636033237,
-0.3322304189,
-0.2391350567,
-0.1149578169,
-0.1213385537,
-0.2979709208,
-0.3349083066,
-0.3228603005,
-0.0578310564,
1.0328184366,
0.0202623568,
0.2587132156,
-0.8465485573,
-0.0383476652,
0.5429723263,
0.3291945159,
0.2169408649,
-0.5573972464,
-0.2218301296,
-0.0620815195,
-0.1915873438,
-0.677546382,
0.3508914113,
0.3585790992,
0.5693562627,
0.3891046047,
-0.4231541157,
0.5054277778,
-0.6745519042,
0.7789601684,
0.2817341089,
-0.7536916733,
0.4187501073,
-0.0512564592,
0.4370182455,
0.5028228164,
0.3214979172,
-0.8343337774,
-0.2919543087,
-0.7718496323,
-0.7190752625,
0.760917604,
-0.2674973011,
0.470235765,
-0.3286106586,
0.2642945051,
0.3403351903,
0.2177974135,
-0.7888952494,
-0.2776164711,
-0.1759025604,
0.1470070034,
-0.2813746333,
-0.3319397569,
0.258836925,
-0.3691019714,
0.1872792244,
-0.1427981406,
0.4100911319,
-0.0352240503,
-0.3664301634,
0.0225967877,
0.264431715,
0.5686496496,
0.4624503851,
0.1833394021,
0.3857304454,
-0.13859047,
-0.7424871922,
0.1617017239,
-0.195412755,
-0.0651796535,
0.0107228467,
0.6225011349,
0.8658829331,
0.2960156202,
-0.4575468898,
0.3830545843,
-0.0638208836,
-0.2262848616,
-0.647813201,
0.0138096018,
0.0051920079,
0.0125800129,
0.2769245505,
0.398761332,
-0.0214655176,
-0.9535178542,
0.2344953567,
0.2370914072,
-0.4975537062,
-0.6953443289,
0.346223563,
-0.1420804411,
-0.2344465405,
0.653637588,
-0.239997521,
-0.8175730109,
0.5071780682,
0.6727113724,
1.173612833,
-0.1627673209,
0.2454426736,
0.3728902936,
0.2361312211,
-0.1401520371,
0.3065907657,
-0.064698413,
-1.0238687992,
-0.1646279395,
-0.7528330088,
0.0968043581,
0.1270836443,
-0.4093523324,
0.0309805218,
-0.7060850263,
-0.0449729338,
-0.133406952,
0.0449854806,
-0.6958888173,
0.1147074103,
0.7585660219,
0.5762247443,
-0.791324079,
0.9075255394,
0.9184472561,
-0.3169983327,
-0.8565366864,
0.0353173241,
-0.0378604829,
-0.9345885515,
0.723392427,
0.5091879368,
0.0492283627,
-0.0140085435,
-0.5952448249,
-0.9300925732,
0.7849784493,
0.1779529005,
-0.3493386805,
-0.2488505393,
0.1515010148,
0.6321576834,
-0.29160133,
-0.1398266107,
0.5028594732,
0.2852239907,
0.1546818316,
-0.3253081143,
-0.0692739785,
-0.3245475888,
0.2126291096,
0.2761864364,
-0.2472213805,
0.8198356032,
-0.3972399533,
-0.4849297702,
-0.0630017519,
0.5838921666,
-0.0920627713,
0.0667541772,
0.3786362112,
0.5545474887,
0.8813300729,
0.0479472615,
1.1345155239,
-0.1776020676,
-0.0132601866,
1.0282648802,
-0.0314045176,
0.8546187878,
0.1717603058,
-0.3169291317,
0.7533448339,
0.4647026062,
0.1236013249,
0.6912571788,
0.4248950481,
-0.2878745794,
-0.1915182322,
0.1382594407,
-0.3156273961,
0.7483190298,
0.7015735507,
-0.5510956049,
-0.0172190927,
0.0658252463,
-0.1250564754,
0.1279634982,
-0.396948576,
1.1393557787,
0.256621778,
-0.7966805696,
0.6312115192,
-0.27354756,
0.6281505227,
-0.5244394541,
-0.0368823782,
-0.2248172164,
0.2300565839,
-0.1056476757,
-0.563640058,
0.1021792665,
-0.4041546881,
-0.0741597489,
-0.1771424264,
0.8174622655,
-0.537972033,
-0.5469814539,
0.2773531079,
0.4919121563,
0.0296521429,
0.1060950458,
-0.3675307035,
-0.0610204339,
-0.3323540986,
-0.1430425495,
0.5770385265,
0.4533221126,
-0.0856130719,
0.4789031446,
0.6038618684,
0.267914772,
0.6654115915,
-0.0813403279,
0.8767328262,
-0.5948767662,
-0.4635187984,
-0.9444283247,
0.3063384891,
0.1862362623,
-0.2544104755,
0.2753679156,
0.243040964,
1.0463891029,
-0.0318188705,
0.8361505866,
0.0339861177,
-0.0073305662,
-0.322404176,
0.625205636,
-0.4981446862,
-0.0070529385,
-0.3008192182,
-0.6741156578,
-0.4556521177,
0.6335210204,
-0.1480745822,
-0.0652645007,
0.9330142736,
0.3583733141,
0.2371971309,
0.3257155716,
0.4178336561,
0.1760860085,
0.1005378664,
0.3662805557,
0.8477581143,
-0.1414830238,
0.3693721294,
-0.4381382465,
-0.0876468942,
-0.0101964558,
-0.3242760301,
-0.6682494283,
-0.7110196352,
0.0098747509,
-0.2922869027,
0.0597434752,
1.0171004534,
0.3947530687,
-0.5942260027,
-0.4295252264,
-0.7280809283,
0.057333298,
-0.2804586291,
-0.2421883643,
0.3339389861,
-0.8267349005,
-0.4219402075,
0.3834834695,
0.2005906254,
0.0881410316,
-0.2914603353,
0.0910157114,
-0.1711825728,
-0.2036601454,
0.8707652688,
0.5727264881,
-0.6264113188,
-0.1576509178,
0.0820675716,
-0.2902244925,
0.0826899186,
0.9504912496,
-1.0953782797,
0.4294854105,
0.4287560582,
0.7885360718,
0.0339362063,
-0.5178687572,
0.655610323,
-0.5684067607,
0.1376564652,
0.2812446356,
0.3681708872,
0.1251599044,
-0.2009799778,
0.1947412789,
0.5443122983,
-0.1509037614,
-0.7255305648,
0.4119307995,
-0.5393142104,
-0.380704999,
0.86601156,
0.1545263976,
-0.3355799019,
-0.1909179538,
0.0273292717,
0.3410326838,
-0.2161691189,
0.735884428,
0.7233988047,
-0.1183544621,
-0.2145577818,
-0.4772482812,
0.5358616114,
0.4410675466,
-0.4506595433,
0.1891821027,
0.3237204254,
0.1414260417,
0.2810622156,
0.4929765761,
-0.2230677903,
0.2652852833,
-0.0301949531,
0.0402338952,
0.0325854123,
-0.4970932901,
-0.6213109493,
0.3587060571,
0.0749966353,
-0.2735720575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07492v1 | Envisioning the Next-Gen Document Reader | 2023-02-15T06:43:12 | 2023-02-15T06:43:12 | Catherine Yeh, Nedim Lipka, Franck Dernoncourt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | People read digital documents on a daily basis to share, exchange, and
understand information in electronic settings. However, current document
readers create a static, isolated reading experience, which does not support
users' goals of gaining more knowledge and performing additional tasks through
document interaction. In this work, we present our vision for the next-gen
document reader that strives to enhance user understanding and create a more
connected, trustworthy information experience. We describe 18 NLP-powered
features to add to existing document readers and propose a novel plug-in
marketplace that allows users to further customize their reading experience, as
demonstrated through 3 exploratory UI prototypes available at
https://github.com/catherinesyeh/nextgen-prototypes | [
-0.5054537654,
-0.0295616295,
0.765635848,
-0.2564716339,
-0.0736670643,
0.5804926157,
0.4079676569,
-1.043690443,
0.3329902291,
0.4178412557,
-0.8286218643,
-0.6549648046,
-0.3032350242,
0.3855787218,
-0.529668808,
0.4784108698,
0.1545436084,
-0.6915360689,
-0.6028725505,
0.1853955686,
-0.2815228105,
-0.2231910676,
-0.4019946456,
-0.4355512559,
0.5928533673,
0.6471095085,
0.8809686899,
0.298314631,
0.4382328391,
0.2967210412,
-0.1450554132,
-0.0413562953,
0.0827007443,
0.0634945482,
-0.0216435976,
-0.8259528875,
-0.7233686447,
0.284509778,
0.3176673055,
0.3377776444,
0.2640326917,
-0.1460638046,
-0.0520706587,
0.5813316107,
-0.3309682608,
0.1552307606,
-0.4924314916,
0.3006041348,
-0.3223999143,
-0.3849941194,
-0.5325103998,
-0.3008324504,
0.2929795384,
-1.21423316,
0.5617855787,
0.3035098016,
1.0740880966,
-0.1435204297,
-0.4527885318,
-0.2426144779,
-0.4329958856,
0.1631422639,
-0.3968611956,
0.651026845,
0.5481559634,
0.4456805587,
0.0826883167,
-0.9091758728,
-0.9111002088,
0.0876893848,
-0.0271966755,
0.2531955838,
0.0777586922,
-0.1500049531,
-0.1268649548,
0.3101578951,
-0.5729343295,
0.2340400219,
-0.0154133383,
0.1150887609,
0.3348369598,
0.1262503117,
0.2421863526,
-0.1187844127,
-0.3343486488,
0.2362216413,
-0.5459339023,
-0.0219010282,
0.6447744966,
-0.1268913448,
-0.0449855514,
0.3477623463,
-0.01440081,
0.6273645163,
0.1419816762,
0.0724573135,
0.6658268571,
-0.0835157409,
-0.105079636,
-0.0484412462,
0.0694632307,
0.5748683214,
-0.2500649989,
-0.2501554489,
0.0583144017,
-0.5104087591,
0.3020902574,
-0.6222567558,
-0.3183452487,
0.354609102,
-0.7068806291,
-0.7799350619,
-0.0347452648,
-1.0040861368,
-1.0879253149,
-0.487442106,
0.0850529671,
-0.6223505139,
-0.2959565222,
0.3037337661,
-0.8232471347,
0.3358469605,
0.7967357635,
-1.4908422232,
0.3764701784,
0.7856451273,
1.0269426107,
0.0017520487,
-0.0840123892,
-0.1757694334,
0.3713521361,
0.0370671377,
1.2427345514,
-0.6112709641,
-0.5114887953,
0.1990170479,
-0.0390559435,
0.0581325889,
-0.1670792997,
0.6487028003,
-0.7014843225,
0.1942234337,
-0.4221471846,
-0.6575125456,
-0.1964493692,
0.574729383,
-0.6637092829,
0.5022801161,
0.3003598452,
-0.7969298363,
0.6590453982,
-0.5994044542,
-0.2721783519,
0.7576583028,
0.0266028643,
-0.1130347475,
0.422642231,
0.1072237268,
0.0134186195,
0.0094669592,
-0.3564995825,
-0.1964992136,
-0.3423507512,
0.1787510812,
-0.3256946206,
0.614862442,
0.2445069849,
-0.0550714508,
0.0372171178,
-0.7358211279,
-0.2114370316,
0.0881519094,
-0.1936503947,
-0.2575098872,
-0.0263073537,
0.3850206137,
0.1244737729,
0.5499542356,
-0.7299571037,
0.3648397624,
-0.3748553395,
0.5421670079,
0.7186994553,
-0.377343446,
0.6183000803,
-0.4480912089,
0.7720749378,
-0.5391808748,
0.6133797765,
-0.6816341877,
-0.5540274382,
-0.3109648824,
0.1259520352,
0.1077466831,
0.4106991887,
-0.5650907755,
0.4990393519,
-0.1804577112,
-0.4779431224,
-0.0721559376,
0.2305825204,
-0.2190707624,
0.5989998579,
0.1190308779,
-0.223850444,
-0.3097560406,
-0.2246612608,
-0.206658408,
-0.4725046158,
-0.1776271015,
0.4012474418,
0.1843360364,
-0.4848690033,
1.0268900394,
-0.4141817093,
-0.5261408091,
-0.5831522942,
0.1272331774,
0.2501000166,
0.3236893713,
0.3411883414,
-1.082269907,
-0.3341519833,
0.2733315825,
-0.7866080999,
-0.1524230689,
-0.2920994759,
-0.0268567018,
-0.062737979,
1.2245972157,
-0.5195952058,
0.1710794717,
0.688718617,
-0.6789967418,
0.5272988081,
-0.3732967675,
-0.2636520863,
-1.1048948765,
0.1319105923,
-0.1324506104,
-0.0493397638,
-0.4215501845,
0.0374226272,
0.319408983,
-0.5155895352,
-0.2489568442,
0.5448063612,
-0.5305209756,
-0.3099169731,
-0.1396231949,
0.4048160017,
0.7746958733,
-0.2482243478,
0.1366210431,
0.3793649077,
-0.0110043213,
0.1594382077,
0.163781628,
0.8514159918,
-0.2531677783,
0.4874026179,
-0.5980721712,
0.0318282098,
-0.0878422484,
0.5981129408,
-0.8081191182,
-0.3583362699,
-0.1375689805,
-0.6245183349,
0.3254928589,
0.2293033898,
-0.7316222191,
-0.544103086,
-0.4542494714,
0.012910435,
0.1141726598,
-0.922682941,
1.2309856415,
0.2641310394,
-0.4057451785,
-0.2321641892,
-0.6665821075,
0.7386465073,
0.0973147452,
-0.9883615375,
0.6073115468,
0.007067672,
0.0603301413,
0.1050885171,
0.1131074429,
0.035075523,
0.1788769215,
0.3179806471,
0.4637402594,
-0.0058208429,
0.3464098573,
0.2068490535,
-0.6103137136,
-0.0708582997,
-0.6467013359,
0.5140866637,
-0.1788410693,
-0.2482500523,
-0.401442945,
0.6440542936,
0.4967639446,
-0.7156018019,
0.4559324384,
0.8105047345,
-0.1494636536,
0.1808474362,
-0.4071155488,
0.2953105569,
-0.6352297664,
0.0557542667,
-0.6379564404,
-1.0267180204,
0.3684324324,
-0.4512176514,
0.4518841207,
0.2670914531,
0.3626839221,
-0.4467890859,
0.743589282,
1.0050938129,
0.2460078746,
0.8856083155,
-0.1061586514,
0.5411705375,
-0.9105180502,
-0.7602250576,
-0.6220855713,
-0.2444120347,
-0.1637713611,
-0.2746640742,
-0.1736281365,
0.0766751915,
0.1130220294,
0.3827082813,
-0.4167763293,
0.5410288572,
0.7828751802,
-0.3171426356,
0.5613874197,
-0.4781150818,
-0.5389384031,
-0.0021396733,
-0.240404129,
-0.5617371798,
0.8207162023,
0.383556515,
0.7718051672,
0.1569479555,
0.7092812657,
0.2293167412,
0.0765589625,
-0.6856336594,
0.465672791,
-0.0030996532,
-0.4530517161,
-0.1024102941,
0.2374638319,
-1.0047688484,
0.062073838,
-0.2438413203,
-0.7916496992,
0.7238759995,
0.0096102981,
-0.2295869291,
0.2015484273,
-0.8213822246,
0.9731023908,
-0.2511391938,
-0.1064401641,
0.0214283913,
-0.5413997173,
0.0085602272,
-0.1463136375,
0.1348508149,
-0.0482039526,
-0.4202528894,
-0.0433262102,
-0.4033536911,
0.4743203223,
0.0819009393,
-0.1146973222,
-0.0508264974,
-0.0903702825,
0.4389823973,
0.2322243005,
-0.4130401611,
-0.144172281,
-0.0538649783,
-0.1686176956,
-0.5451471806,
0.5120655894,
-0.3907757401,
-0.3972791135,
-0.5062341094,
-0.6868034005,
-0.2202859223,
0.5611848831,
0.4091654718,
0.473033607,
-0.349283278,
0.3206497729,
0.65922755,
-0.2503461242,
0.4595530033,
0.6281195879,
-0.392136544,
-0.0187627003,
0.8019654155,
-0.3261574209,
0.1360977143,
0.6570934057,
0.1750561297,
-0.7026410103,
-0.7859098315,
-0.282912612,
-0.0972399861,
-0.7165043354,
0.2448194772,
-1.0168520212,
0.0720474496,
-0.7235193253,
-0.9112938643,
0.1043212861,
-0.2498556674,
-0.5811756849,
-0.3338474333,
0.1742089689,
0.5396839976,
0.0277407411,
0.4564333558,
-0.8456588984,
0.4038239419,
0.3252242506,
0.4252583086,
-0.1515766382,
-0.163200587,
-0.3418850303,
-0.905061543,
-0.3849658966,
-0.5404074192,
0.5765393972,
0.2346028388,
0.3556898832,
0.5710913539,
-0.0089946892,
-0.0350131467,
-0.5034695268,
0.831799686,
0.2266789377,
-0.9076887369,
0.6082188487,
-0.5420651436,
0.4767446518,
0.9010038376,
0.0759429932,
-0.765858531,
-0.3574908376,
-0.6027043462,
-0.9703187943,
0.1915575564,
-0.1981308609,
0.2898949087,
0.070770815,
0.122665666,
0.4294046462,
0.0555483401,
-0.2225385904,
0.3505136073,
-0.3461230397,
-0.1820426136,
-0.2646092772,
-0.2424364388,
0.2732952237,
-0.2590591311,
0.2363325059,
-0.4934781492,
0.3947913647,
-0.109494783,
0.1544349343,
0.0522332862,
0.1121144891,
0.1626640856,
0.4808116853,
-0.5746703744,
0.0066856844,
-0.4173924029,
-0.9083459973,
-0.1512074769,
0.563039422,
-0.2690908313,
0.2600420415,
0.1044237763,
0.5122696757,
0.0318227038,
-0.4626978338,
0.614477098,
-0.6591327786,
-0.4934946597,
-0.6498516202,
-0.0160204712,
0.3769205511,
0.3327570558,
0.354288429,
0.4279162884,
0.2988924384,
-0.4535482526,
0.1963774115,
0.2034135163,
-0.3580560982,
-0.2101897746,
0.8824598193,
0.8005312085,
-0.3601383567,
0.3633135259,
-0.3146778047,
-0.3131245971,
0.2378245294,
0.6426931024,
1.0327785015,
0.1981969327,
0.5968254209,
-0.187782079,
0.5323020816,
0.1886036247,
0.22377415,
-0.3598579466,
-0.6090696454,
-0.0524668805,
-0.459770292,
-0.7654349208,
-0.159825325,
-0.3557434678,
0.4692231119,
-0.4809011817,
-0.0923887789,
0.0708187371,
0.2408600301,
-0.5980865955,
0.1572018564,
0.0398270339,
1.3600656986,
-0.5539096594,
0.7800657749,
0.3735067844,
-0.2903413475,
-0.3041235805,
0.1511338204,
0.358491838,
-0.5243962407,
0.1715366542,
0.5813390017,
0.0041727051,
0.0512948148,
0.0618181899,
-0.780600667,
1.387955904,
0.2055789977,
-0.5800020099,
-0.4810239673,
-0.0332572944,
0.3897507489,
-0.1792082936,
0.2776767313,
0.4194387496,
0.553568244,
0.1573645025,
-0.1429721713,
-0.2422892302,
-0.7351347208,
0.0061832732,
0.0721549615,
-0.3903477192,
0.6628130674,
-0.1031312793,
0.0960858837,
0.2486607581,
0.6288762093,
-0.0945275277,
0.6060988307,
0.4464367032,
0.543853879,
1.0543637276,
0.1148351878,
1.3871347904,
-0.2650251985,
-0.1197575554,
1.4828636646,
-0.2194364369,
0.7420592308,
0.2472127378,
0.1307117492,
0.7050901055,
0.5018594861,
-0.1576591432,
0.3436221182,
-0.1402842999,
-0.8003599048,
-0.0488696508,
-0.3912072778,
-0.3662899137,
0.1474330872,
0.4146895409,
-0.523838222,
-0.114157334,
0.119028911,
-0.3528031409,
0.1633246392,
-0.0120721245,
0.4874590337,
0.1241163239,
0.1020988449,
-0.1793224066,
0.0213245936,
0.5674871206,
-0.4627986848,
0.1267113686,
0.1201838478,
0.140212968,
-0.5674086809,
-1.1202805042,
0.1134747714,
-0.0242087152,
-0.1673666984,
-0.5574957728,
1.0601937771,
0.3512955904,
-0.3842214942,
0.2787243128,
0.3553904295,
0.046911642,
-0.1309178472,
-0.6686178446,
0.1019662395,
-0.2299316227,
-0.2186832875,
0.4672780931,
0.58318156,
0.2397656143,
0.573906064,
0.9634491205,
-0.1394453347,
0.1343455315,
0.5222325921,
0.5855935812,
-0.3561118543,
-0.8071658015,
-0.220583722,
0.3328847289,
-0.319683373,
-0.8019638062,
0.7142230272,
0.7119673491,
0.5740219951,
0.2836804986,
0.9286848903,
0.0222350024,
0.2549539506,
0.0467742085,
0.6498621106,
-0.6323046684,
0.0382386893,
-0.3410857916,
-0.7591133118,
-0.3336632848,
0.3711228073,
-0.1225117669,
-0.3048995137,
0.6402495503,
0.3181218207,
0.2220357955,
0.5961043239,
0.412861824,
-0.145541802,
0.828904748,
0.3261975646,
0.5785033107,
-0.2626858652,
0.4255382121,
0.1048009396,
-0.2958126664,
-0.4055860043,
-1.022203207,
-0.7892181277,
-0.6107161045,
0.190668568,
-0.0954615474,
-0.1643024236,
0.4091460109,
0.4612021446,
-0.1504025906,
0.3221332133,
-0.6563653946,
0.0447465442,
-0.0073992447,
-0.1973861605,
0.1355027556,
-0.492844522,
-0.592486918,
0.3762947619,
0.7215430737,
0.0506512038,
-0.2237755805,
-0.0633620769,
-0.0812449455,
-0.0494318828,
0.5955168605,
0.525750041,
-0.1636102349,
0.0155852959,
0.1365858316,
-0.0752534121,
0.1160731763,
0.8308291435,
-0.8612374067,
0.7907666564,
0.6338354945,
0.9382301569,
0.7900196314,
-0.1031991616,
0.6852420568,
-0.0905719548,
0.048477564,
0.300635457,
0.1438682377,
0.1919787824,
-0.6310662627,
0.2550722659,
0.1958697438,
-0.5412048101,
-0.3596200347,
0.3148581386,
-1.1330016851,
-0.2270788252,
0.4706211686,
-0.1235242262,
-0.2711018622,
-0.7046579123,
-0.3699466288,
-0.1122661084,
-0.5683764219,
0.5099862814,
0.4428332448,
-0.098643221,
-0.3497510254,
-0.8290905952,
0.2705827355,
0.1516630799,
-1.2389233112,
-0.0242757257,
0.3719500005,
-0.0787058249,
0.1255368739,
0.9678701162,
-0.4434289932,
0.4142870009,
0.3564914167,
-0.0427125432,
-0.4123461843,
-0.3978410065,
-0.2406080663,
0.1789812744,
0.0510256402,
0.0774005204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.09068v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.09068v1 | A Pilot Evaluation of ChatGPT and DALL-E 2 on Decision Making and Spatial Reasoning | 2023-02-15T05:04:49 | 2023-02-15T05:04:49 | Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | We conduct a pilot study selectively evaluating the cognitive abilities
(decision making and spatial reasoning) of two recently released generative
transformer models, ChatGPT and DALL-E 2. Input prompts were constructed
following neutral a priori guidelines, rather than adversarial intent. Post hoc
qualitative analysis of the outputs shows that DALL-E 2 is able to generate at
least one correct image for each spatial reasoning prompt, but most images
generated are incorrect (even though the model seems to have a clear
understanding of the objects mentioned in the prompt). Similarly, in evaluating
ChatGPT on the rationality axioms developed under the classical Von
Neumann-Morgenstern utility theorem, we find that, although it demonstrates
some level of rational decision-making, many of its decisions violate at least
one of the axioms even under reasonable constructions of preferences, bets, and
decision-making prompts. ChatGPT's outputs on such problems generally tended to
be unpredictable: even as it made irrational decisions (or employed an
incorrect reasoning process) for some simpler decision-making problems, it was
able to draw correct conclusions for more complex bet structures. We briefly
comment on the nuances and challenges involved in scaling up such a 'cognitive'
evaluation or conducting it with a closed set of answer keys ('ground truth'),
given that these models are inherently generative and open-ended in responding
to prompts. | [
-0.5934842229,
-0.8778603673,
0.954069674,
0.3467785716,
0.1327833086,
-0.146687001,
-0.2297894359,
-0.1642657369,
-0.3171572983,
0.3124420345,
-0.5434458852,
-0.2309418768,
-0.6843278408,
-0.1486802846,
-0.1185452342,
0.988558948,
-0.0533457249,
0.0487737581,
-0.0774146765,
-0.0333945677,
-1.0516511202,
-0.3985489607,
-0.9896722436,
-0.2649451494,
0.3998802006,
0.3918200135,
1.008433938,
-0.2122749835,
0.5870125294,
0.2726042271,
-0.1363769621,
0.0152506242,
-0.5173180103,
-0.0216687303,
-0.3598062694,
-0.709712863,
-0.2471734285,
0.1930001527,
0.2520007491,
0.6581956148,
-0.1648607999,
-0.1915171742,
-0.1134012267,
0.8794997931,
-0.4589904845,
0.3157592714,
-0.6554633379,
0.3204284608,
0.2603105307,
-0.0213792175,
-0.8501269221,
-0.3894948363,
0.3976247907,
-0.8558476567,
0.2096544355,
0.3343297541,
0.8692657351,
0.4846421182,
-0.5524994731,
-0.5902969837,
-1.0281486511,
0.6140311956,
-0.2332473695,
0.1294584423,
0.4177626669,
0.7921692133,
-0.1536668539,
-0.6672078967,
-0.4649017453,
-0.3366577923,
-0.2622442842,
0.6797537804,
-0.4183350503,
0.1654381752,
0.6992145181,
0.0236281604,
-0.5870902538,
-0.1494417787,
-0.6553180218,
-0.0660652816,
0.6120326519,
0.200754866,
0.1530272216,
-0.1307561547,
-0.3524211049,
-0.3369921148,
-0.6112487316,
0.0753747597,
0.2614085078,
-0.1709552854,
-0.0142840249,
0.9042734504,
0.0202509575,
0.326403439,
0.2715238929,
0.4960146546,
-0.1067586243,
-0.3281902075,
-0.0551431775,
-0.2348703742,
0.4825141728,
0.6571763754,
0.5439760685,
-0.0895742625,
-0.2646791041,
0.4563131034,
0.4205234647,
-0.3573931158,
-0.6684789062,
0.4042551219,
-0.4221246541,
-0.1722436249,
-0.0535724945,
-0.5809934139,
-0.2591430545,
-0.5139377713,
0.38079229,
-0.5640953779,
-0.2084352374,
0.3257218003,
-0.4997823536,
0.6190185547,
0.5848795772,
-0.8174832463,
0.2520080209,
0.6234757304,
0.6543255448,
-0.1994246691,
-0.2355810851,
-0.0138404137,
-0.1193279848,
-0.443759948,
1.1995829344,
-0.4419460595,
-0.6995809078,
-0.1402227432,
-0.2037321329,
-0.413377285,
-0.4819869399,
0.889167428,
-0.6352698803,
0.3896278739,
-0.6519921422,
-0.321620971,
-0.2613607943,
0.3747008145,
-0.5610313416,
0.8129078746,
0.1326656491,
-0.5924921632,
0.7316644192,
-1.0183944702,
-0.3455099761,
0.0108633181,
-0.3595118225,
-0.2645820975,
0.0577124804,
0.1532593966,
-0.0151704326,
-0.2375044227,
0.1856848449,
-0.2934250832,
-0.093389675,
0.5342137814,
-0.6381747127,
0.8795116544,
0.254874438,
-0.3166011572,
0.0903700367,
-0.3285365403,
0.1918942183,
0.3068593144,
-0.2048973888,
0.0756380036,
0.1994110346,
0.0024155756,
0.2865582407,
-0.0219939183,
-0.4400556087,
0.2173616439,
-0.0909412652,
0.466683358,
0.7099206448,
0.0332092717,
0.6568681598,
-0.5548297763,
0.4529103041,
-0.0845834687,
0.4612405002,
0.167465955,
-0.8424577117,
-0.8488537073,
-0.0876449943,
0.2375647277,
0.6943468451,
-0.8903850913,
0.1981067955,
-0.1577392966,
-0.5197430253,
-0.0690092295,
-0.724680841,
0.1176557243,
0.2241516113,
0.0334568024,
-0.03891268,
-0.4160410762,
-0.8202793598,
-0.0360188298,
-0.2213888913,
0.0030845641,
0.6775103807,
0.7209017277,
-0.098818168,
1.0811498165,
-0.807279408,
0.0077714804,
0.060762167,
0.3223397136,
0.1695886254,
0.2884315252,
0.5385331511,
-0.9355000257,
-0.3716332912,
0.1279186606,
-0.7847844362,
-0.0374410376,
-0.3042799532,
-0.3257698119,
-0.006866246,
0.076495029,
-1.0793682337,
0.4233204424,
0.1146942005,
-0.7045795321,
0.8439285755,
-0.3444654047,
0.2562612593,
-0.4313426912,
-0.215259701,
-0.2939196825,
0.2275495529,
-0.525818944,
-0.1469926983,
-0.1302660257,
-0.2156695426,
-0.2432309538,
0.3239197731,
-0.1115298718,
-0.3035317659,
-0.0421277061,
0.1413083673,
0.1059791446,
0.5758618712,
0.182153672,
0.9232337475,
0.3395236731,
-0.4083607793,
0.2868711948,
0.4289689958,
-0.3030407429,
0.6165371537,
-0.7921744585,
0.2134093791,
-0.2726776004,
0.2101958245,
-1.1857637167,
-0.0769388378,
0.3441014588,
-0.4122907221,
-0.0910874903,
-0.0056411549,
-0.3510685265,
-0.3823728263,
-0.0112723187,
0.3775816262,
0.8134930134,
-0.493486166,
0.6010237932,
0.1737505943,
-0.1559596956,
-0.0298269056,
-0.4630085528,
-0.1293452829,
-0.2327875197,
-0.7705414891,
0.0544086471,
-0.1086557433,
-0.4971818924,
0.0729383007,
0.1658691764,
-0.1180500537,
-0.08250615,
0.2528131902,
0.3883239031,
-0.1345660537,
-0.0948813707,
0.0531650297,
-0.3691744208,
0.419955343,
-0.2000812292,
0.3286495507,
-0.3920207024,
-0.5962567925,
0.1561138183,
0.2085428536,
0.7110126019,
-0.1349706501,
0.2408270985,
0.379905045,
-0.1650776714,
-0.1716276407,
-0.3703047335,
-0.0849247724,
-0.3895583749,
0.2599752247,
-0.4977959394,
-0.550511837,
0.3803375363,
-0.3965718448,
0.177866146,
0.5208055973,
0.7416089177,
-0.4035040736,
1.0628176928,
0.0331770331,
0.6911621094,
0.1792210788,
-0.5325233936,
0.4050135016,
-0.8109407425,
-0.3586734533,
-0.3204721212,
-0.2908895314,
-0.4074237049,
-0.6045900583,
0.5920462608,
-0.0962695107,
-0.3548127413,
0.0965267122,
-0.4835037589,
0.4972924888,
0.4345489144,
0.1925966442,
0.0288277529,
-0.094128944,
-0.1974019706,
-0.143586114,
-0.9181293845,
-0.6334029436,
1.0746004581,
0.2935038805,
0.5561620593,
0.2011142373,
0.1087349057,
0.4816059172,
0.3633548915,
-0.8741868734,
0.4560377002,
0.1373990327,
-0.5370818973,
-0.2702800035,
-0.0877916291,
-0.8954136968,
0.565151751,
-0.2405428439,
-0.3286873102,
0.3550869226,
-0.0592827536,
-0.5563468933,
0.0256787911,
-1.0849957466,
0.7069206834,
-0.3443416357,
-0.2525850832,
-0.3308875263,
-0.3810322285,
0.4692029357,
0.0676309168,
0.1229286939,
0.0039244797,
0.1956823021,
0.5648745894,
-0.1942911446,
0.6812604666,
-0.2871317267,
-0.0230009202,
0.6207951903,
0.0718764886,
0.4355938435,
0.087719284,
0.0894333422,
0.1412838548,
0.1149491593,
-0.2217237204,
-1.0363103151,
0.2662216127,
-0.9198250771,
-0.7253053784,
-0.4752129316,
-0.5487961173,
-0.1329619586,
-0.1105535477,
0.4692755938,
0.2637250721,
-0.4190213084,
0.0465377755,
0.6138703823,
-0.1272159964,
0.1180074513,
0.3030301332,
-0.2951818407,
-0.4213120043,
0.5260568857,
0.1377193779,
0.3246176839,
0.0412808694,
0.1045660451,
-0.4902804494,
-0.2973936498,
-0.3726305068,
-0.0107738627,
-0.804109633,
0.0476708375,
-0.3288217485,
-0.3796036243,
0.1430458575,
-0.4635861218,
-0.2687491477,
-0.6190961003,
0.2498970032,
-0.0738124773,
0.0519160256,
0.9579572082,
-0.0159139205,
0.1236463338,
-0.2901859879,
0.1301549375,
0.4641798437,
0.0503215827,
-0.0707915872,
-0.243483752,
0.1676125824,
0.2444686592,
-0.6015799046,
-0.8033938408,
-0.1546233296,
-0.3857201338,
0.3185859323,
0.3114531338,
0.0815149844,
0.2989535034,
-0.5934249759,
0.8809750676,
0.158301428,
-0.5312203169,
0.6930142045,
-0.3950102627,
0.130748421,
0.1612548977,
-0.0001010941,
-0.2522102892,
-0.1748651564,
-0.699531734,
-0.3109943271,
0.6779713035,
0.7513366938,
-0.0932738855,
-0.1865062863,
0.2112016976,
0.0208833348,
-0.1723933369,
-0.5842839479,
-0.2152266949,
-0.2099109739,
0.237377286,
0.2610533237,
-0.4422810078,
-0.3440815508,
-0.2559542358,
0.3669703305,
0.1265962124,
0.4585648179,
0.4286497533,
0.1827123761,
0.0705371946,
0.41684708,
0.5301840305,
0.5610635877,
-0.0314011425,
-0.0531257242,
0.3278327882,
-0.1515994221,
0.2609905005,
-0.1803178787,
-0.5022578835,
-0.1768709719,
0.3198277354,
0.845343411,
0.2795555294,
-0.5699968934,
0.4621050358,
-0.2838888764,
-0.5961406827,
-0.5210373402,
0.0653115883,
-0.2319584787,
0.4352744222,
-0.0803042278,
0.717653811,
0.263397336,
-0.3334391713,
0.0111032054,
0.4556194544,
-0.0450893827,
-0.3644140065,
0.6661784649,
0.1434307694,
-0.2456463724,
0.8022062182,
-0.443492949,
-0.6287629604,
0.8361441493,
0.5041121244,
0.9274638295,
0.211465776,
0.5482202172,
0.4188033044,
0.4975405931,
0.1331089139,
0.3222767711,
-0.2012216449,
-1.1338778734,
-0.2875773907,
-0.0212965216,
-0.6069728732,
-0.3085430861,
-0.7183647752,
0.1011367515,
-0.3880788386,
-0.5195118785,
-0.1361128241,
-0.168420434,
-0.8639013767,
0.0823199525,
-0.0727535486,
0.7447517514,
-0.7739064693,
0.4081044495,
0.8404486179,
-0.3463571966,
-0.67616117,
-0.135830164,
-0.2110353708,
-0.8375815153,
1.0085750818,
-0.2051437944,
0.0808514282,
-0.1477977782,
-0.4270972908,
-0.707600832,
1.1943846941,
0.1647209376,
-0.4237158597,
-0.1104822829,
0.1515776068,
0.4581050873,
-0.1433650404,
0.5679725409,
0.7638456225,
0.7656264901,
0.4171134233,
-0.8254431486,
-0.1266557574,
-0.0696109459,
0.0393045805,
0.0504391305,
-0.6554408669,
0.8584496975,
-0.6194266677,
-0.469173789,
-0.0531683043,
0.3476463854,
0.4841581285,
0.3395748138,
0.606094718,
0.6711387038,
0.7228327394,
-0.5512318015,
1.2186639309,
-0.1191036478,
0.4945254326,
0.8376287818,
-0.4612508416,
0.6850842834,
0.3627124727,
-0.536503315,
0.3328818679,
0.574344337,
-0.1312603801,
0.7646070719,
0.1013082564,
-0.1963809133,
-0.1313635856,
0.1052453294,
-0.1690433174,
0.4324651957,
0.5697140098,
0.1155420393,
-0.3399546444,
-0.0499980077,
-0.205156222,
-0.0829569697,
-0.0318933576,
0.6390256882,
0.0560149103,
-1.0220892429,
0.2618639469,
-0.1113992259,
0.1568771601,
-0.3948583901,
-0.2256359011,
-0.0558299236,
0.1098971441,
-0.0616404451,
-1.1254774332,
0.5389823914,
-0.1435090452,
-0.3536664546,
-0.347777158,
0.5835052729,
0.0079629244,
-0.3117727041,
0.1644881219,
0.5307202935,
0.1178152114,
-0.0379391983,
-0.7621453404,
0.0256259758,
0.0915068984,
-0.2583520412,
-0.1496637762,
0.6384339333,
-0.0403087772,
0.5417728424,
0.640609026,
-0.0153998649,
0.1063840315,
0.0320057347,
0.6917759776,
-0.4321197569,
-0.2872719169,
-0.6257245541,
0.4001521468,
-0.0965887532,
-0.3379462063,
0.6075847745,
0.5569280982,
0.8094947338,
-0.3572078645,
1.0761293173,
-0.193064779,
-0.2008512318,
-0.7604345679,
0.4607045352,
0.0791848898,
0.1750389785,
0.1546449363,
-0.9106388092,
0.0168061387,
0.8452658653,
-1.0156039,
0.1412945837,
1.024482131,
0.7603883743,
0.1422546208,
0.3714756668,
0.5302773714,
0.202481851,
0.4118605554,
0.9384292364,
1.3166525364,
-0.5130354166,
0.4112055302,
-0.2001118362,
-0.3762591481,
0.1191302985,
-0.4706273377,
-0.869269073,
-0.5996675491,
-0.3209346533,
-0.2647584677,
-0.0311439391,
0.540568769,
0.6658226848,
-0.6240001321,
0.063241303,
-0.3913999498,
0.0558335222,
-0.1464712769,
-0.304839462,
0.4657851756,
-0.4653870761,
-0.5802282095,
0.0347473323,
0.4438302219,
0.0378303044,
-0.0139736971,
-0.2620445192,
0.140411064,
0.1824264228,
0.9031345248,
0.0009258634,
-0.9671417475,
-0.4694597721,
-0.0268175304,
-0.0570652746,
0.0520307347,
0.8872523308,
-0.6014541984,
0.4157884121,
0.2124514729,
0.4125577807,
0.3168133199,
-0.0596281178,
0.6298665404,
-0.14716129,
0.0520283282,
0.269579947,
0.6098187566,
0.0387138166,
-0.3013601601,
0.6509538293,
0.1396943778,
-0.755335927,
-0.1815868318,
0.3709236383,
-0.928678453,
-0.1056800559,
1.2117475271,
-0.0769918784,
0.0615702234,
-0.0349319093,
-0.9461860657,
-0.0928969532,
-0.1327428222,
0.7630161643,
1.0298441648,
-0.3241587877,
0.0224729944,
-0.7417860627,
0.3244767785,
0.6482663155,
-0.7221742868,
-0.0000317481,
0.7141701579,
-0.0500300117,
0.1671869606,
0.6408213973,
-0.1196796075,
0.5056436658,
0.4783159792,
-0.1594846696,
0.1450321376,
-0.2205329388,
-0.1272036582,
0.1342882514,
0.2621226907,
-0.2969434559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07459v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07459v2 | The Capacity for Moral Self-Correction in Large Language Models | 2023-02-15T04:25:40 | 2023-02-18T21:30:27 | Deep Ganguli, Amanda Askell, Nicholas Schiefer, Thomas I. Liao, Kamilė Lukošiūtė, Anna Chen, Anna Goldie, Azalia Mirhoseini, Catherine Olsson, Danny Hernandez, Dawn Drain, Dustin Li, Eli Tran-Johnson, Ethan Perez, Jackson Kernion, Jamie Kerr, Jared Mueller, Joshua Landau, Kamal Ndousse, Karina Nguyen, Liane Lovitt, Michael Sellitto, Nelson Elhage, Noemi Mercado, Nova DasSarma, Oliver Rausch, Robert Lasenby, Robin Larson, Sam Ringer, Sandipan Kundu, Saurav Kadavath, Scott Johnston, Shauna Kravec, Sheer El Showk, Tamera Lanham, Timothy Telleen-Lawton, Tom Henighan, Tristan Hume, Yuntao Bai, Zac Hatfield-Dodds, Ben Mann, Dario Amodei, Nicholas Joseph, Sam McCandlish, Tom Brown, Christopher Olah, Jack Clark, Samuel R. Bowman, Jared Kaplan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We test the hypothesis that language models trained with reinforcement
learning from human feedback (RLHF) have the capability to "morally
self-correct" -- to avoid producing harmful outputs -- if instructed to do so.
We find strong evidence in support of this hypothesis across three different
experiments, each of which reveal different facets of moral self-correction. We
find that the capability for moral self-correction emerges at 22B model
parameters, and typically improves with increasing model size and RLHF
training. We believe that at this level of scale, language models obtain two
capabilities that they can use for moral self-correction: (1) they can follow
instructions and (2) they can learn complex normative concepts of harm like
stereotyping, bias, and discrimination. As such, they can follow instructions
to avoid certain kinds of morally harmful outputs. We believe our results are
cause for cautious optimism regarding the ability to train language models to
abide by ethical principles. | [
-0.0283378903,
-0.611325264,
0.5195529461,
0.2441605479,
0.1037026569,
-0.2209662795,
-0.2986666262,
-0.5894781351,
-0.2402642369,
0.9412523508,
-0.4048265815,
-0.1190147251,
-0.5621363521,
0.1411860287,
-0.2446848154,
1.2118554115,
0.3329933286,
0.5892531872,
0.0408795401,
-0.2508317232,
-0.5762053728,
-0.7485873103,
-0.8905599713,
-0.2212139666,
0.8779342175,
0.5399839282,
0.506167829,
0.996907115,
0.4555180967,
0.360897243,
0.2227722853,
-0.2824642062,
-0.7756971717,
0.1437792778,
-0.6124138236,
-0.4013519287,
-0.5932570696,
0.5129620433,
0.7267982364,
0.2670752108,
-0.4316848516,
0.1667819619,
0.1361204982,
0.8583402634,
-0.4100139439,
-0.0148142064,
-0.4706882536,
0.0309150051,
0.2084605098,
0.0013178062,
-0.7816271782,
-0.4423847497,
-0.1094184816,
-0.4425083399,
0.1195312515,
0.2062299252,
0.5286729932,
0.5288385749,
-0.5935253501,
-0.3276543021,
-0.8029227853,
1.0566185713,
-0.8932750225,
0.3619278669,
0.8228852153,
0.0631705597,
0.0547661036,
-0.3932501078,
-0.2974193394,
-0.5597295761,
-0.0981067643,
0.0899913609,
0.1357402653,
0.3762424886,
0.5767266154,
0.2159042656,
-0.0279336479,
0.2960229516,
-0.6569096446,
-0.3345024586,
0.9183555841,
0.0458520576,
0.3077769578,
-0.2989037633,
-0.0911538899,
-0.4349784255,
-0.7370648384,
0.2337691486,
0.7649476528,
0.2899566889,
0.0474503562,
0.5403259397,
0.0031445341,
0.264474988,
0.2886304557,
-0.1450216323,
-0.0813092738,
-0.2531320751,
-0.0557836667,
0.2739187479,
0.7809092402,
0.611204803,
0.6959556341,
0.2441337109,
-0.3122456372,
-0.1244922653,
0.6690068841,
-0.8825533986,
-0.1512257308,
0.1133927628,
-0.5564594865,
-0.4788077176,
-0.1279314309,
-0.3876436055,
-0.4482868612,
-0.1129182205,
0.3070557714,
-0.5210792422,
-0.1946244985,
0.3677773476,
0.0481743962,
0.1028534696,
0.2272202075,
-0.9888680577,
0.0488669425,
0.4714324176,
0.3088049889,
0.2423348576,
-0.5075680614,
-0.9115557671,
0.051801417,
-0.5923099518,
0.5166042447,
-0.4051114023,
-0.4705389738,
-0.1210562587,
0.1423271894,
0.1079641059,
-0.4326355755,
0.6962509751,
-0.1392676085,
0.0625866205,
-0.6481587291,
-0.5265107751,
-0.3756866157,
-0.0418493003,
-0.4414958358,
0.5163390636,
-0.1028686166,
-0.6118037701,
0.3294576705,
-0.2988709509,
-0.364379555,
-0.3343474567,
0.0969167277,
-0.6165351272,
0.0951906294,
-0.1052900702,
0.3849258721,
0.0299553685,
0.3527941108,
-0.6101495624,
-0.1341016144,
0.3790928125,
-0.509560883,
0.8188794851,
0.141444847,
-0.4362760782,
0.3312417269,
-0.5486477613,
-0.0050921282,
0.2080686688,
-0.5110934377,
-0.4387009442,
0.0592962988,
-0.1647431999,
0.3904932439,
0.023382958,
-0.7610723376,
-0.0197701547,
-0.413828969,
0.3636083603,
1.0478639603,
-0.1355934441,
0.431579411,
-0.5350013971,
0.5308141112,
-0.3033491373,
0.3415397704,
0.1208430901,
-0.2341711819,
-0.8900122643,
-0.0524175726,
0.1797153801,
0.4511063993,
-0.2202280313,
0.4358913004,
0.2926611602,
-0.4096613526,
-0.5293367505,
0.1607457995,
0.8726630211,
0.5085995793,
0.2937334478,
-0.3688307703,
-0.519205749,
-0.9511493444,
-0.5981461406,
-0.6285638809,
0.3112078607,
0.3685722053,
0.6504910588,
0.0953777134,
0.4858939052,
0.012010958,
-0.3048570156,
0.0292236414,
0.3012288809,
-0.1467089355,
0.7083802223,
0.5648782849,
-0.3879323304,
-0.15965496,
-0.2150959224,
-0.7787365317,
-0.1349403709,
-0.0722260252,
0.1308280677,
0.165267542,
0.7513320446,
0.036961589,
0.3362546563,
0.4318907857,
-0.7021049857,
0.7883850336,
-0.6109374762,
0.3610255718,
-0.5934963822,
-0.3492988348,
-0.2052268237,
-0.5046389103,
-0.430403173,
-0.1151685268,
0.3076994419,
0.3636181056,
-0.3792890012,
0.521702528,
-0.075927265,
-0.0301389061,
-0.389259547,
-0.0896018445,
-0.2235078663,
0.3823625147,
-0.0505473949,
0.9155430198,
0.3466248512,
-0.7666528821,
0.2923338413,
0.1957843304,
0.0699375793,
0.5681136847,
-0.8247270584,
-0.0701887682,
-0.2340024561,
0.191139549,
-0.6700435877,
-0.2784096897,
0.2036447674,
-0.3373060822,
-0.1273338199,
-0.012215226,
-0.1905773282,
-0.3699453175,
-0.2510082126,
0.3822499216,
0.4710545242,
-0.5289259553,
0.3895972967,
0.3343010247,
-0.2122144252,
-0.7650319338,
-0.7259551883,
-0.2072130442,
-0.2509278655,
-0.3126107454,
-0.1171154603,
-0.2224251032,
-0.2525309026,
-0.0092894528,
0.1870767176,
0.3222263455,
0.1252509505,
0.3840635121,
0.1055062413,
0.0882930085,
0.5193635225,
-0.1186027899,
-0.0939382315,
0.5341008306,
-0.0257736221,
0.3009431064,
-0.7976873517,
-0.4391864538,
-0.2271751761,
0.0086244764,
0.3649909496,
-0.5314046741,
0.5763854384,
0.2922456563,
-0.0581969321,
0.0187165979,
-0.6164184809,
-0.4618540406,
-0.471375674,
0.3948125839,
0.1145283803,
-1.1923305988,
0.4418336749,
0.3742685318,
0.1064649522,
0.6365194917,
0.456332624,
-0.2394661009,
1.1104733944,
0.7293903828,
0.3576423526,
0.3884369731,
-0.1071985438,
0.3576847017,
-0.8215763569,
0.0101182321,
-0.6244209409,
-0.0126593942,
-0.9998909831,
-0.2648082376,
0.1340461969,
0.1075933352,
-0.840967536,
0.0902683437,
-0.4233338237,
0.5694121122,
0.7111682892,
0.1500066668,
0.4434412718,
-0.2320096195,
-0.0752006248,
-0.1805345416,
-0.6186917424,
-0.4704571664,
1.0058871508,
0.6787795424,
1.0060263872,
-0.0314505883,
0.7556330562,
0.3150086105,
0.5011431575,
-0.8435135484,
0.4880187213,
-0.2217208892,
-0.7398582697,
-0.6332172751,
-0.3269017637,
-0.6041188836,
-0.0637742952,
-0.1981176436,
-0.3956660628,
0.2559796572,
0.5203760862,
-0.4415881336,
0.3462904096,
-0.5222590566,
0.6986199021,
-0.6112188697,
-0.5168119073,
-0.8408116698,
-0.604765892,
0.3816622198,
-0.0778515041,
0.2382843345,
-0.1980303973,
0.2059506774,
0.8546120524,
-0.1768474728,
1.0601934195,
-0.1394961178,
-0.44276914,
0.3537386656,
0.3186581135,
0.4335758686,
0.1893127859,
-0.0504910834,
-0.0148348445,
0.1548533291,
-0.329877764,
-0.4468474686,
0.2772066295,
-0.7310646176,
-0.9537064433,
-0.728438139,
-0.596762836,
-0.2237828821,
0.2544910312,
0.1889645159,
0.1545148939,
-0.333067745,
0.5656249523,
0.7709715962,
-0.5815962553,
0.4344764948,
0.6556276083,
-0.7166242599,
-0.433706969,
0.683368504,
0.0489967838,
0.6133592725,
-0.2877089381,
0.5678793192,
-0.4453666806,
-0.1522019506,
-0.3685207069,
0.6310716867,
-0.7625283599,
-0.1466978192,
-0.4669849873,
-0.2413714528,
-0.2993266284,
-0.1798816472,
-0.8070617914,
-0.2901438773,
-0.0218009185,
-0.2920015156,
0.3539159894,
1.2215845585,
-0.6394987702,
0.1551946402,
-0.904435873,
-0.0727901533,
0.6505724192,
0.5359511375,
0.0004366436,
-0.7100174427,
0.0027340818,
0.300966531,
-0.208325237,
-0.5383152366,
0.0091563268,
0.0786609575,
0.3665634096,
0.4167132378,
0.1564273983,
0.3321200013,
-0.423048377,
0.4630104303,
0.3572292626,
-0.9643202424,
0.5518159866,
-0.6536831856,
0.0135348095,
0.3135677874,
0.1898264736,
-0.8017971516,
-0.5660880208,
-0.8314348459,
-0.0624924339,
0.706379056,
0.0370915532,
0.4078567922,
-0.1865737587,
0.5630728602,
-0.046249181,
0.0675417855,
-0.9854444861,
0.0584566034,
-0.522957921,
0.1054487079,
-0.0648856089,
-0.527320683,
-0.1909820884,
-0.3160081804,
0.9553515911,
-0.1700462401,
0.0489920527,
0.3801287711,
0.1789515615,
-0.5747949481,
0.4004071057,
0.5747947097,
0.7032006383,
-0.0721095279,
0.0098434426,
0.2227459252,
-0.3494380414,
0.4000124633,
-0.5388709307,
0.0008362384,
-0.7175224423,
0.4334706664,
0.5377391577,
-0.0765140802,
-0.6879695058,
0.5909009576,
-0.2188009024,
-0.1906173378,
-0.1754582971,
0.390624404,
0.0852958336,
0.3004237115,
-0.2373142838,
-0.0203962699,
0.0425132476,
-0.6803500652,
0.4200917184,
0.3809843957,
-0.5596901774,
-0.0705939457,
0.7064982057,
0.1051352546,
-0.379689157,
0.7607985139,
-0.2421353608,
-0.4965516925,
0.659886837,
0.6825771332,
0.6275759935,
-0.6722740531,
0.5792753696,
0.8022775054,
0.3960210085,
-0.338134408,
0.2073026448,
0.3572735786,
-0.8913541436,
-0.6177648902,
-0.6567844748,
-0.3117766678,
0.036180716,
-0.9520807862,
-0.1199118644,
-0.8203368187,
-0.1649889201,
-0.2771960795,
-0.2785444856,
-0.107817933,
0.4389414787,
-0.1904764771,
0.3738574684,
-0.5247799158,
0.8532309532,
0.3245842755,
-0.531342268,
-1.1507338285,
-0.1303958744,
-0.1105517372,
-0.9252060056,
0.8206961751,
0.1368593872,
-0.6082890034,
-0.076532349,
-0.7738320231,
-0.6654906273,
0.6044863462,
0.4355768859,
-0.7520360947,
0.044469066,
-0.0713949576,
0.7086072564,
-0.3730176687,
-0.2421607673,
0.3599117398,
0.4457551837,
-0.1482459903,
-0.9047445655,
0.0658276528,
0.1044412181,
0.0324417241,
-0.1169860661,
-0.7258041501,
0.8189101219,
-0.8149114251,
0.0261041783,
0.0301259104,
0.7757454515,
0.2129897773,
-0.2079941183,
0.8411784768,
0.4334894121,
0.6778899431,
0.169837296,
1.0645936728,
-0.2406051606,
0.6251242757,
1.0999305248,
0.0747141466,
0.6021493077,
0.2312413603,
0.1425559521,
0.4307681024,
0.3678483069,
-0.0958398357,
0.4285845757,
0.0442086346,
0.2101412863,
-0.6835318208,
-0.4626131356,
-0.1304050088,
0.6174411774,
0.1407744884,
-0.435610503,
0.1371324509,
0.1235998049,
0.2438299656,
0.4569904506,
-0.4255332947,
0.5674433708,
0.2087340355,
-0.9129631519,
0.5869634151,
0.0261804499,
0.4193884134,
-0.3406265974,
-0.2237264216,
-0.0244668704,
0.3693945408,
-0.0604964308,
-0.9621804953,
0.4681262374,
-0.1430168003,
-0.0355782248,
-0.5066183805,
0.8617457747,
-0.2821141779,
-0.3280080557,
0.6719987988,
0.4527240098,
-0.0593020134,
0.1419125795,
-0.7586337924,
-0.3274133503,
0.1298356354,
-0.1045456678,
0.1352605671,
0.21863392,
-0.0269848965,
0.9476330876,
0.5131846666,
0.281675607,
0.0752724111,
0.2488387525,
0.3342056274,
-0.9001441598,
-0.4581546187,
-0.7359412313,
0.2370512038,
0.0294240955,
-0.3857980669,
0.5717591047,
0.1002381817,
1.1181812286,
-0.1529449075,
0.7717603445,
0.0925942734,
0.3664818108,
-0.6723807454,
0.6266061664,
-0.4823035896,
0.0061528226,
0.0193836987,
-0.5636588931,
0.0536746234,
1.0118317604,
-0.5437856913,
0.4497869611,
0.8749706745,
0.8000946045,
0.2224679738,
0.1302102357,
0.5684982538,
0.6360754371,
0.2834771276,
0.1516838968,
0.9702623487,
-0.1627950519,
0.3947197199,
-0.450265944,
-0.1397095621,
-0.0421331003,
-0.8829925656,
-1.0647269487,
-0.5817862749,
-0.1118144989,
-0.708804369,
0.1304587573,
0.8744035959,
0.5689345002,
-0.7861771584,
-0.3807407916,
-0.1633354574,
0.018583037,
-0.4043135941,
-0.0641492307,
0.1394276321,
-0.4284588397,
-0.4880370498,
0.1607947201,
0.4083214104,
0.0208730102,
-0.4943028688,
-0.4074729979,
-0.146464929,
0.3448143005,
0.4600177705,
0.2045334578,
-0.9125896692,
-0.9771811366,
-0.0742286667,
-0.3852443993,
0.0236422196,
0.8894295692,
-0.2128238529,
0.3572812676,
0.2758830786,
0.4683428109,
0.0048331721,
-0.1070237905,
0.7784574032,
-0.4225692749,
-0.1366296411,
0.3056057394,
0.5288537145,
0.3951368034,
-0.6809328198,
0.6379311681,
0.0767579377,
-0.9527727365,
-0.4194030762,
0.5809310079,
-0.5195242763,
-0.2742741704,
1.12981534,
-0.1830662936,
-0.1664906591,
0.0722544342,
-0.5054127574,
0.3648570478,
-0.3296470642,
1.0806983709,
0.7929164171,
-0.0813154504,
-0.2703721821,
-0.6637048721,
0.6782835722,
0.8012192249,
-0.7438242435,
0.6434955597,
0.5764650702,
0.5659018159,
0.0147521701,
0.5463719964,
-0.2076410502,
0.5498406291,
-0.256298542,
0.2628018558,
0.0737338588,
-0.467356652,
-0.4786936343,
-0.299179107,
0.3318676949,
0.472515732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07452v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07452v1 | How to Train Your DRAGON: Diverse Augmentation Towards Generalizable Dense Retrieval | 2023-02-15T03:53:26 | 2023-02-15T03:53:26 | Sheng-Chieh Lin, Akari Asai, Minghan Li, Barlas Oguz, Jimmy Lin, Yashar Mehdad, Wen-tau Yih, Xilun Chen | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Various techniques have been developed in recent years to improve dense
retrieval (DR), such as unsupervised contrastive learning and pseudo-query
generation. Existing DRs, however, often suffer from effectiveness tradeoffs
between supervised and zero-shot retrieval, which some argue was due to the
limited model capacity. We contradict this hypothesis and show that a
generalizable DR can be trained to achieve high accuracy in both supervised and
zero-shot retrieval without increasing model size. In particular, we
systematically examine the contrastive learning of DRs, under the framework of
Data Augmentation (DA). Our study shows that common DA practices such as query
augmentation with generative models and pseudo-relevance label creation using a
cross-encoder, are often inefficient and sub-optimal. We hence propose a new DA
approach with diverse queries and sources of supervision to progressively train
a generalizable DR. As a result, DRAGON, our dense retriever trained with
diverse augmentation, is the first BERT-base-sized DR to achieve
state-of-the-art effectiveness in both supervised and zero-shot evaluations and
even competes with models using more complex late interaction (ColBERTv2 and
SPLADE++). | [
-0.432333827,
-0.5695397854,
0.1330708116,
-0.0984798819,
-0.2822186947,
-0.0645836815,
-0.1943198442,
-0.6388167143,
0.458881557,
0.2197521478,
-0.4482951164,
-0.3234514594,
-0.5393509269,
0.0481689982,
-0.1736842245,
0.9366707802,
0.3207999468,
0.2721794844,
0.0765168369,
-0.508613646,
-0.3678357899,
-0.623642683,
-0.4055112302,
-0.380461365,
1.0265638828,
0.1461327225,
0.6794087291,
0.7471638918,
0.394446224,
0.2271894217,
-0.2156791538,
0.413500309,
-0.8645709753,
0.0961009413,
-0.1307311207,
-0.5062167048,
0.0061047138,
-0.1889058352,
0.470397681,
0.8757801652,
-0.0998658091,
-0.286239475,
0.1058214903,
0.5373624563,
-1.0128341913,
-0.3563982844,
-0.8417797089,
0.477055341,
0.010042686,
-0.1280133575,
-0.0926247388,
-0.1303464025,
0.3160591722,
-0.7452985048,
0.3696987629,
-0.3958721757,
0.4945266545,
0.4493466914,
-0.5701034069,
-0.141227752,
-0.6979040504,
1.0227251053,
-0.3736903667,
0.2720915675,
0.2362595499,
0.6260439157,
0.231699869,
-0.8672909141,
-0.5454714298,
-0.3809895515,
-0.0149265965,
0.1280878037,
0.1570301354,
0.3281854391,
0.4570029378,
0.6071092486,
-0.6025636196,
0.3650659323,
-0.3099781275,
-0.1095667854,
0.7762702107,
0.201754868,
0.3170979917,
0.2518309355,
-0.2687683105,
-0.2992891073,
-0.5565636158,
-0.0324283317,
0.403866291,
0.2583868504,
0.1411322504,
0.7287584543,
-0.2797729969,
0.9693433642,
0.4700164795,
0.1055032089,
0.2522210777,
-0.4178914726,
-0.1541750133,
0.0140600428,
0.4567600191,
0.2225484997,
0.1419763416,
-0.4912818372,
-0.2493990809,
-0.2100759894,
0.4995546639,
-1.0771837234,
-0.2811745405,
0.1823633015,
-0.6140278578,
-0.246173203,
0.0405206494,
-0.5418954492,
-0.3679475188,
-0.2500426173,
0.581961453,
-0.3767864704,
-0.3179634213,
0.0901030675,
-0.3690886199,
0.4754989445,
0.2045217603,
-1.3040475845,
-0.0320394039,
0.4165511131,
0.4651957452,
-0.2431264967,
-0.3102818727,
-0.5912146568,
0.1483749598,
-0.6531450748,
0.619250834,
-0.7505336404,
-0.4320247173,
-0.1070514843,
-0.4009690285,
-0.1047271863,
-0.8871059418,
0.5905644298,
-0.4479843974,
0.2117242366,
-0.3235215545,
-0.5601972342,
-0.2435494214,
0.3602048159,
-0.6782233119,
0.7342761159,
0.1860649735,
-0.8065060377,
0.7548965812,
-0.2505667806,
-0.4219734073,
0.1052417904,
-0.5092309713,
-0.3897508979,
0.1118787155,
0.4225923717,
0.3256792724,
0.1722857952,
0.0551938675,
-0.6039127111,
-1.0186021328,
-0.0096867541,
-0.3012040555,
0.6290639639,
0.3477662802,
-0.1820580959,
0.0071556093,
-0.7094566822,
0.2708097994,
-0.2999794483,
-0.4897418916,
-0.4188133478,
-0.3345451653,
-0.0371560901,
-0.0912283063,
0.198579669,
-0.5131946802,
0.3391858041,
-0.4873191118,
0.0198696386,
0.3031654358,
-0.0765880272,
0.6193554997,
-0.2787225246,
0.1231157035,
-0.0175595954,
-0.0072425427,
-0.221672073,
-0.1952080727,
-0.4447664022,
-0.4074805081,
0.4340882599,
0.4696720839,
-0.9890901446,
0.7416003346,
-0.049902495,
-0.6169172525,
-0.5634180903,
0.2122110873,
0.1994641572,
0.4583592713,
0.5307011008,
-0.2834844291,
-0.5978082418,
-0.8666555882,
-0.2681613863,
0.2700683177,
-0.3352960348,
0.7616068721,
0.2366438955,
-0.4199888706,
0.7390562892,
-0.5386182666,
-0.1894700825,
-0.3528977633,
0.2308581471,
0.3905174732,
0.5862090588,
0.9048787355,
-1.1687380075,
-0.6322723031,
0.1398972273,
-1.0060677528,
0.2537373602,
-0.1893393844,
0.114343591,
-0.3811896145,
0.0033843752,
-0.733782351,
0.3317045569,
0.0985283628,
0.137946859,
0.4421032667,
-0.440418303,
0.4007010162,
-0.7767694592,
0.0904315189,
0.01097144,
0.1259035766,
-0.810860455,
0.1723017246,
0.1743176877,
-0.3969342113,
-0.3400730193,
0.4041496217,
-0.4290331006,
-0.1644297093,
-0.3694894016,
-0.4754799604,
-0.2191911489,
0.4468194842,
0.1665094048,
0.8461207151,
0.712484777,
-0.9156367779,
0.582421124,
0.0636557564,
-0.2510279417,
0.7473438382,
-0.9234156609,
0.2183606625,
-0.3158112764,
0.0794901103,
-0.6969593167,
-0.2383042425,
0.0345468745,
-0.3964129686,
0.6275975108,
-0.2213406414,
-0.1513068974,
-0.3402671814,
-0.4105198979,
0.5048206449,
0.5027432442,
-1.0661821365,
0.4545570612,
0.117195487,
0.1421314031,
-1.2042806149,
-0.9037918448,
0.0623849891,
-0.2044308484,
-0.715587616,
0.6989524364,
-0.3286599517,
-0.0426543988,
0.0465788022,
-0.3049092889,
-0.7428866029,
0.0347549506,
-0.3188797235,
0.0576101169,
-0.2072250992,
0.0913071781,
0.1909150034,
0.164841339,
-0.3593406081,
-0.2117307931,
0.2033911943,
0.4301329255,
-0.5288022161,
-0.155642584,
0.239709422,
0.0294960514,
-0.1812696904,
0.6778443456,
0.8770475388,
-0.3844794631,
-0.4465173483,
-0.5249901414,
-0.4407328665,
-0.4410327077,
0.6308572888,
-0.4461696148,
-1.0228981972,
0.3633063436,
0.3316035867,
-0.075827539,
0.3370856345,
0.5089985728,
-0.0766101554,
1.0927171707,
0.7218697667,
-0.1267376691,
0.5676378012,
-0.3717685938,
-0.1127490774,
-0.5742496848,
-0.3838923872,
-0.353579551,
-0.6195402145,
-0.5664865971,
-0.3202011883,
0.2768236697,
0.1223203093,
-0.0717907846,
0.1532893181,
-0.777829349,
0.6509850025,
0.3552492857,
0.4723778665,
-0.0752959251,
0.2761204541,
0.005353482,
-0.2987329066,
-0.6961750984,
0.2272563577,
1.4240720272,
-0.0593755133,
1.1327297688,
-0.1976383775,
0.8154321909,
0.4030239582,
-0.0700906664,
-0.7569618821,
0.1291098297,
-0.4751005471,
-0.6428444982,
-0.2059468478,
-0.7731556892,
-0.9511457086,
0.6370434165,
-0.3145165443,
-0.3203769326,
0.5667955875,
-0.0172853731,
-0.4110871553,
0.3059563041,
-0.6554080248,
0.6541571021,
-0.4101121426,
-0.4748674929,
-0.3966050446,
-0.6248820424,
0.4002664983,
0.0643500462,
-0.6012272239,
0.4249622822,
-0.175748691,
0.2868881524,
-0.1357824355,
0.6618112922,
-0.3847644925,
0.2681491673,
0.2462536693,
-0.3944092393,
0.2718902528,
-0.1007960215,
-0.2360720038,
-0.077189289,
-0.4489225745,
-0.5770124793,
-0.8888067007,
0.7668853998,
-0.8773642182,
-0.2053556442,
-0.2416964173,
-0.7027968168,
0.0290733855,
0.1351961792,
0.3235490322,
0.3713528216,
-0.3183278441,
0.5935653448,
1.2595210075,
-0.2668302655,
0.2202321142,
0.4523627758,
0.346890837,
-0.5394593477,
1.0542700291,
0.4788278043,
-0.1403586119,
0.6357175708,
-0.1551728994,
-0.5125150681,
-0.8572274446,
-0.3550803959,
-0.0499070771,
-0.5806990266,
0.0786436722,
-0.6746268272,
-0.386806488,
-0.3775317073,
-0.0454254411,
-0.1128671542,
-0.4082145691,
-0.5046876073,
-0.1171529591,
-0.1271367818,
0.6102092266,
-0.2908676267,
0.0927644372,
-0.6252704263,
0.5166068077,
0.809681952,
0.330570668,
-0.0776510164,
-0.6003030539,
-0.2674686909,
0.1384554505,
-0.2505927682,
-0.5861588717,
0.3240690231,
0.3293929696,
1.1292600632,
0.4793970883,
-0.0923653767,
0.7483901978,
-0.1461080909,
0.7133986354,
0.2616521716,
-0.256379813,
0.2985933721,
-0.0833766311,
-0.0629426464,
0.6055413485,
0.5432511568,
-0.1830465347,
0.3192645311,
-0.4344861805,
-0.643815577,
0.3672891557,
-0.0789856687,
0.3639383316,
0.257597059,
0.6363821626,
0.3021638691,
0.3636211455,
-0.6765531898,
-0.2760712206,
-0.4577543736,
-0.1039234176,
0.0267945305,
-0.3112735748,
-0.0221820548,
-0.3320192993,
0.3843381107,
-0.2435093522,
-0.1042381823,
0.1942468435,
-0.2167385817,
0.0823139921,
0.2814150155,
0.1350852102,
0.6029308438,
-0.391205579,
-0.0831167623,
0.2659092844,
-0.4073411524,
0.0472669452,
0.454739958,
-0.3898189366,
-0.0335261151,
0.291482538,
0.8026673794,
0.0823671222,
-0.423094213,
0.3551963568,
0.0410812311,
-0.2462967783,
0.0524674281,
0.353769958,
-0.276989013,
0.3004785776,
0.6165670753,
0.004388982,
0.5347298384,
-0.3959639072,
0.4132188261,
0.6705192924,
-0.4470959604,
-0.0554379337,
0.6872862577,
0.2152705044,
0.2204020172,
0.7429910898,
-0.2184325308,
-0.1901881695,
0.6268905401,
0.4217551649,
0.8461564183,
-0.1897469163,
0.1503513902,
0.4919886291,
0.1399550587,
-0.1079697236,
0.2397950888,
-0.3573583364,
-0.7130345702,
-0.4969645143,
-0.3591140211,
-0.4288927019,
0.1989758015,
-0.7509825826,
0.1036692187,
-0.3712618053,
0.1170044243,
-0.1373402774,
0.4501213431,
-0.5272294879,
0.4724556804,
0.0984505117,
0.8908570409,
-0.5391789675,
0.870860815,
0.7603338361,
-0.7563718557,
-0.56472224,
0.0225407481,
-0.365160495,
-0.8278126717,
0.6782899499,
0.3079939485,
0.2723423541,
-0.1460485905,
-0.6635509133,
-0.3272460401,
1.1273925304,
0.3977934122,
-0.5277196169,
0.0167758875,
-0.0397174917,
0.7088644505,
-0.3961208761,
0.6776953936,
0.3107706606,
0.2498666942,
0.4298046827,
-0.5068024993,
-0.4326747656,
-0.2028222382,
0.2055797577,
-0.3324811757,
-0.4462476969,
0.9885731339,
-0.4155589938,
-0.0566225648,
0.273619622,
0.6481437683,
0.1117012873,
0.3189426363,
0.3224997222,
1.0303875208,
0.7898304462,
0.0004943158,
1.2991923094,
-0.0611538477,
0.1225457042,
0.8753221035,
-0.2475473285,
0.5188016891,
0.1761173755,
-0.0686399788,
0.1868311465,
0.7692556977,
-0.3732432127,
0.886515975,
0.1331836432,
-0.4583931565,
-0.3603776991,
-0.2534858882,
-0.6565961838,
0.1080314815,
0.2440718263,
-0.2962761819,
-0.2800143063,
-0.0480506569,
-0.5671852827,
0.1899437755,
-0.4213162065,
0.9068264365,
-0.0029794753,
-0.4145437777,
0.8422074914,
-0.3399181664,
1.1628323793,
-0.8477903008,
-0.1840533167,
-0.4314720333,
0.2756157219,
-0.4886992872,
-0.8302833438,
0.152129069,
-0.2826630175,
-0.2664456666,
0.1767269522,
1.0135987997,
-0.7729508877,
-0.254737258,
0.2916036844,
0.3905517459,
0.0577622019,
-0.2525065541,
-0.8735702038,
-0.1654426903,
0.104940407,
-0.0162330344,
0.753708601,
0.4722386599,
0.4321146309,
0.62833184,
0.6171340942,
0.2532576025,
0.1096779704,
0.2256371677,
1.0651180744,
-0.530335784,
-0.3540146053,
-0.4878930748,
0.3026180565,
-0.3031392395,
-0.1775148362,
0.5914934874,
0.6380301118,
0.8576570153,
-0.0640272498,
0.9764392972,
0.049746424,
0.5770784616,
-0.2707461417,
0.7647402287,
-0.8461834192,
0.2321342677,
0.2146007121,
-1.1405289173,
-0.1634406596,
0.7017291784,
-0.195964545,
0.3177974522,
0.1076697186,
0.7615662813,
-0.3895590305,
-0.0988248214,
0.5646601915,
0.0384649672,
0.1814161539,
0.6318723559,
0.7916527987,
-0.2012290806,
0.8506227732,
-0.3897687793,
-0.2587920725,
-0.0664949939,
-0.4341349304,
-1.015566349,
-0.0968761966,
0.017491512,
0.0350523181,
0.4321618676,
0.5574216247,
0.8293802142,
-0.7603750825,
-0.162987262,
0.1411689818,
0.0970035046,
-0.2761749029,
-0.1986511648,
0.22865206,
-0.632869184,
-0.7663350701,
0.5766968131,
0.0766983926,
0.1231458038,
-0.1964787692,
-0.2571914494,
-0.0729014277,
-0.4045677185,
0.4139378667,
0.5434961915,
-0.2958020568,
-0.1170950606,
-0.0587673336,
-0.1880546361,
0.1412951946,
0.7419061661,
-0.9692813158,
0.7892532349,
0.6045427918,
1.328212142,
0.8790865541,
-0.0118668107,
0.5970133543,
-0.8514142632,
0.2074883133,
0.5178178549,
0.0945767462,
0.4486361146,
-0.4160604179,
0.6268846393,
0.3525266349,
-0.51802665,
-0.686519444,
0.1269054115,
-0.6367406249,
-0.3384495378,
0.8194039464,
-0.1516547501,
0.1187118217,
0.0229310393,
-0.2478709519,
0.2019873708,
-0.2549989223,
0.8115317225,
0.2412377894,
-0.1810223609,
-0.0207325127,
-0.1613356918,
0.4996992052,
0.5796570182,
-0.6079822779,
-0.3253718019,
0.4136503339,
0.3069280386,
0.0792050958,
0.5490782857,
0.1009384617,
0.3769159615,
0.306317389,
-0.1456608921,
-0.2057804167,
-0.2748334706,
-0.4161927998,
0.1538523734,
-0.1972990483,
-0.1826255471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07388v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07388v1 | Adding Instructions during Pretraining: Effective Way of Controlling Toxicity in Language Models | 2023-02-14T23:00:42 | 2023-02-14T23:00:42 | Shrimai Prabhumoye, Mostofa Patwary, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pretrained large language models have become indispensable for solving
various natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, safely deploying them
in real world applications is challenging because they generate toxic content.
To address this challenge, we propose two novel pretraining data augmentation
strategies that significantly reduce model toxicity without compromising its
utility. Our two strategies are: (1) MEDA: adds raw toxicity score as meta-data
to the pretraining samples, and (2) INST: adds instructions to those samples
indicating their toxicity. Our results indicate that our best performing
strategy (INST) substantially reduces the toxicity probability up to 61% while
preserving the accuracy on five benchmark NLP tasks as well as improving AUC
scores on four bias detection tasks by 1.3%. We also demonstrate the
generalizability of our techniques by scaling the number of training samples
and the number of model parameters. | [
-0.2750590742,
-0.4575001299,
0.5754094124,
0.4272592664,
-0.2839609683,
-0.331210047,
-0.1914031059,
-0.3371914029,
-0.1466115415,
0.8907766938,
-0.7048211098,
-0.6781371832,
-0.4577490091,
-0.0874250159,
-0.0023824256,
1.3427046537,
0.0151305795,
0.150376603,
-0.3588811755,
-0.2510809302,
-0.6729505658,
-0.8405510187,
-0.6636805534,
-0.2707923949,
0.8001832962,
0.3464466035,
0.6946558952,
0.5646480322,
0.5840126872,
0.2705511451,
-0.1650623977,
0.1713971943,
-0.3859993815,
0.0136081195,
-0.4062395394,
-0.700283587,
-0.6702946424,
0.3160129488,
0.2921685278,
0.6528034806,
-0.354318738,
-0.0026800341,
0.1159051806,
0.7235508561,
-1.0421903133,
0.1146024466,
-0.444840163,
0.0052681882,
-0.1836612225,
-0.6001652479,
-0.7749744654,
-0.3329508305,
0.1688783318,
-0.6400663257,
-0.3984796405,
-0.2669794858,
0.700361371,
0.4445973337,
-0.4183780551,
-0.2474885285,
-0.853671968,
0.8438105583,
-1.0957480669,
0.1225743219,
0.4822766185,
0.0325271785,
-0.1058947593,
-0.7657652497,
-0.2438775599,
-0.3464732468,
-0.2688731849,
0.0487754643,
-0.0244461484,
0.5531285405,
0.3433808684,
0.0064958744,
-0.309653908,
0.3276255727,
-0.2442568541,
-0.2430889308,
0.4575206637,
0.0668214932,
0.6215615869,
0.2183259279,
-0.1770455241,
-0.2704657614,
-0.9612050653,
-0.3296901882,
0.4713099003,
0.350486666,
0.1314420849,
0.502148509,
0.0448538363,
0.5409981012,
-0.1940582842,
0.3014572859,
0.5266028643,
-0.4341364801,
0.0060560857,
0.0169679448,
0.8243728876,
0.4305140674,
0.3697548807,
-0.0628404394,
-0.0844395012,
0.0869735181,
0.6714727879,
-1.0354239941,
-0.4271268547,
0.1269135326,
-0.3142813146,
-0.6063042879,
-0.4908288419,
-0.6740763783,
-0.2136115283,
-0.2982642949,
0.7962574959,
-0.4444081783,
-0.2072968334,
0.2292385995,
0.2232999355,
-0.0242216643,
0.0064177942,
-0.9890938401,
0.3345256746,
0.3695967793,
0.6833016872,
0.0786827505,
-0.1456121355,
-0.6794161201,
0.1856390685,
-0.3985608816,
0.7673496008,
-0.6948717833,
-0.1995694637,
-0.121516563,
-0.1910866052,
-0.0000306999,
-0.6504318118,
0.80447644,
-0.5999256372,
0.6575925946,
-0.3130588531,
-0.3884052932,
-0.2153625935,
0.0573880635,
-0.6945283413,
0.9119728208,
0.1171248257,
-0.9402344823,
0.2688608766,
-1.010055542,
-0.6400490403,
-0.3261947632,
0.2841975391,
-0.3144207001,
-0.0000900159,
0.4832914472,
0.4325777292,
0.1734970361,
0.0047708643,
-0.2816565633,
-0.2082467377,
0.1055570617,
-0.4094005525,
0.7420841455,
0.3175826669,
-0.1833529174,
0.3042724133,
-0.6031579375,
0.2682553828,
-0.2007216662,
-0.5134016871,
-0.6198385358,
0.1082646623,
-0.0574866459,
0.4471684992,
-0.2636421323,
-0.3014135659,
-0.0794536918,
-0.6453250051,
0.1853937805,
0.8230617642,
0.0494881235,
0.5235378146,
-0.318036437,
0.4472380877,
0.0138067892,
0.2919563949,
-0.1396043897,
-0.2052287459,
-0.7008792758,
0.0103213051,
0.3812562823,
0.7111443877,
-0.8518518806,
0.9512828588,
-0.2140868753,
-0.5780553222,
-0.5083272457,
0.0078533189,
0.5674540997,
0.6022558212,
0.8099727035,
-0.3349681795,
-0.5730605721,
-0.5957235694,
-0.5083531737,
-0.1394939274,
-0.3034009039,
0.2319364101,
0.2026929855,
-0.3350021541,
0.5920037627,
-0.5017948747,
-0.3968004584,
-0.1287769377,
0.0915787816,
0.081155397,
0.8440434933,
0.6829593182,
-0.3452505171,
-0.4772931635,
-0.195178017,
-0.5755996108,
-0.5490883589,
-0.1842548698,
-0.3945261538,
-0.2089905888,
0.6753205061,
-0.5124749541,
0.3136485219,
0.4366710484,
-0.039071653,
0.4381669462,
-0.4097839892,
0.1801073104,
-0.8416205049,
-0.0402242839,
-0.0493244939,
-0.2747926116,
-1.0231169462,
0.2561125159,
-0.0127617149,
0.0846277028,
-0.5745311975,
0.314737916,
-0.3626571298,
0.7187731862,
-0.4462547302,
-0.2136890441,
0.1804141998,
0.3191683292,
0.0514376871,
0.5387080908,
0.5004410148,
-0.7731000185,
0.1649560332,
0.1588480026,
-0.1215144917,
0.2743268907,
-0.6092463732,
0.2735051513,
-0.31923908,
0.6421778202,
-0.6388756037,
0.0329985768,
0.3250537515,
-0.2360422462,
0.4237854779,
-0.0461578593,
-0.3668859005,
-0.036021404,
-0.316440016,
0.4518211186,
0.5977194309,
-0.4970409274,
0.6079650521,
0.4708721638,
-0.2588452101,
-0.5321903825,
-0.9021363854,
-0.0556945018,
-0.4243472219,
-0.3648695052,
0.4042476714,
-0.29287377,
0.081044443,
-0.0389156863,
0.0006860623,
-0.0788058117,
0.0246517938,
-0.030783698,
0.2396826446,
-0.1027130634,
0.2359564602,
0.2459026426,
-0.5278502703,
0.3884654343,
0.099639073,
0.5356306434,
0.2405081987,
-0.2409573048,
-0.6479634047,
0.3362062573,
0.5725034475,
-0.5433737636,
0.9212895036,
0.6183979511,
-0.2838442326,
-0.2878748477,
-0.4383524954,
-0.401542902,
-0.520686388,
0.5501770973,
0.1407742053,
-0.3608573973,
0.2601287663,
-0.3461813331,
0.1278536767,
0.2147144824,
0.4403190613,
-0.0975846127,
1.2931072712,
0.6026901603,
-0.3721652925,
0.6676010489,
-0.1092130244,
0.2467963248,
-0.810118258,
-0.0073831053,
-0.4478010237,
-0.097220175,
-0.2823313773,
-0.605748713,
0.4902380407,
-0.196510762,
-0.2283862978,
0.0653296635,
-0.4936269224,
0.8492398858,
0.3590923846,
0.5654419661,
0.079577297,
-0.0765721276,
-0.0118826684,
-0.1826281101,
-0.7031654119,
-0.3772878349,
1.3834761381,
0.5890277624,
0.7692042589,
-0.2583482862,
0.6395733953,
-0.1072411239,
0.6908656359,
-0.492777735,
0.335449785,
-0.2898752689,
-0.8481249213,
-0.1384450197,
-0.680791378,
-0.4548002481,
0.2280521393,
-0.4015294909,
-0.440492332,
-0.0618920512,
0.3366985023,
-0.5773397684,
0.2151751071,
-1.1660503149,
0.9613282681,
-0.384906292,
-0.2730245292,
-0.2999074459,
-0.800542891,
0.3240675032,
-0.1556041241,
0.4385402203,
0.1008815542,
-0.091327332,
0.7673383355,
-0.6926128864,
0.6900200844,
-0.3895900548,
-0.053964518,
0.2518877685,
-0.2497780174,
0.8270251751,
-0.2592107654,
-0.0847397894,
-0.1263224483,
0.0131887235,
-0.3849279284,
-0.6575556993,
0.5457254052,
-0.4793649316,
-0.2786105275,
-0.3303835988,
-0.6258619428,
-0.4883157313,
0.267220825,
0.3853604198,
0.2439344823,
0.0313069783,
0.1806937903,
0.881995976,
-0.7558242083,
0.0618215911,
0.5012305975,
-0.0252220929,
-0.1347748637,
0.9086505771,
0.0300164502,
0.7012162209,
0.15351744,
0.4171135128,
-0.2759589255,
-0.9368367195,
-0.0075623733,
0.2136505097,
-0.7800439,
-0.0911754966,
-0.6591547728,
-0.2656806409,
-0.3138659,
0.1619948149,
-0.5276558399,
0.1523340344,
-0.4337450266,
-0.4290639162,
0.2681521475,
0.4562462568,
-0.1212372705,
0.7544935346,
-1.0764636993,
0.270957768,
0.1622274816,
0.7071186304,
-0.170923695,
-0.4657425284,
-0.2228328437,
0.3941362798,
0.0178417489,
-0.9178138971,
0.3982819915,
0.3328117728,
0.6293315291,
0.3442094028,
0.1447548419,
0.7615434527,
-0.6336934566,
0.4045113325,
0.0450782888,
-0.7802065611,
0.565053761,
-0.3144561052,
0.2725263536,
0.9170910716,
0.5936121345,
-0.3536860943,
-0.4601879418,
-0.3519971967,
-0.9845965505,
0.7483310103,
0.3026950955,
0.647913754,
0.1319988668,
0.3774813414,
-0.184226796,
-0.1313016415,
-0.7875061035,
-0.2322459072,
0.0467998274,
-0.3759382665,
-0.0207959786,
-0.4745449722,
-0.1370135993,
-0.4864750803,
0.9091082811,
0.2450526804,
-0.3453890383,
-0.0762588456,
-0.2429866344,
-0.0978606194,
0.3155506253,
0.1928825825,
0.3754872382,
-0.4231037796,
0.0811765715,
0.3125065863,
-0.7313914299,
0.1682083309,
-0.0115845157,
-0.1461224407,
-0.2025181949,
0.5364699364,
0.6905428767,
0.1593098789,
-0.648650527,
0.5292301774,
-0.0472115539,
0.029119188,
0.1577072591,
0.2447404265,
0.067196697,
-0.227116093,
-0.037538588,
0.2692034841,
0.1801427603,
-0.5873401761,
0.3971422315,
0.1929899454,
-0.5115622878,
-0.231727764,
0.5519409776,
0.422958076,
0.172975421,
0.4594579339,
-0.083140485,
-0.5219953656,
0.1669620872,
0.5155335069,
0.6788020134,
-0.6080049276,
0.1584910601,
0.4570837319,
0.6186060905,
-0.1038036719,
0.0643451512,
0.3285095096,
-0.811067462,
-0.7605441213,
-0.5019599795,
-0.1355665475,
0.2699861526,
-0.5923703313,
0.1070810035,
-0.4564643502,
-0.1222285852,
0.0403545797,
-0.2435052842,
-0.3823811412,
0.412871778,
0.0745010972,
0.6960318089,
-1.3255302906,
0.6524019241,
0.4131043255,
-0.4543583393,
-0.9705212116,
-0.2098221928,
-0.0356412418,
-0.2556968629,
0.1908945888,
0.2567136288,
0.1966100931,
0.1079219207,
-0.523209095,
-0.764899075,
0.4978343248,
0.5103828311,
-0.3553749621,
-0.2007044554,
0.0322548114,
0.7252417207,
-0.145905301,
0.5615972877,
0.8044401407,
0.5763503313,
0.1059907898,
-0.7069160342,
0.1600801796,
-0.312723875,
-0.2080580741,
-0.0304277837,
-0.0322486609,
0.5543201566,
-0.2109222263,
-0.3587407172,
-0.2953771055,
0.4352716804,
0.0888981074,
0.0495799184,
0.801479876,
0.6519987583,
0.7013666034,
0.1497601271,
1.0102535486,
0.006444287,
-0.0755618662,
1.2567254305,
-0.2056483775,
0.5719407797,
0.3888888955,
-0.3170476556,
0.5968479514,
0.5652889609,
0.3688755929,
0.6481505036,
0.2441643327,
-0.2938843071,
-0.2678978145,
-0.2790132761,
-0.4806374907,
0.2854396105,
0.4622472823,
-0.4669164121,
-0.3691623509,
0.2957658768,
0.4471172988,
0.1408037394,
-0.1981826872,
0.941619873,
-0.0043851756,
-0.687703371,
0.5570710301,
-0.2779793143,
0.7029697895,
-0.7958986163,
-0.1251576245,
-0.035147056,
0.2556463182,
-0.4827005267,
-0.4614624381,
0.508892417,
-0.0035116153,
0.0654689744,
-0.3086692989,
0.6474757195,
-0.6152794957,
-0.4837728739,
0.3931899071,
0.1813674867,
0.0102768075,
-0.5522862673,
-0.4955984652,
-0.2572267056,
-0.1188954934,
-0.3863545358,
0.427654177,
0.2624366879,
-0.1233418584,
0.7539755702,
0.9528684616,
0.3875697255,
0.1798369288,
0.3097594082,
1.3867945671,
-0.2096929401,
-0.3491636217,
-0.8303092718,
0.674041152,
-0.0140549447,
-0.0519257188,
0.5316899419,
0.2907927334,
0.7552329302,
-0.1004092619,
0.6762222052,
0.1756345183,
0.4171336293,
-0.7484245896,
0.9670516849,
-0.2173412889,
0.4519867897,
-0.3744828403,
-0.8400850296,
-0.6506227255,
0.5465798974,
-0.3111938834,
0.2475543618,
0.8407363892,
1.0387872458,
-0.0160513725,
-0.3181710839,
-0.1210922003,
0.3148165345,
0.6343902349,
0.6563052535,
0.7455872297,
-0.2724013925,
0.5634302497,
-0.6338136196,
-0.5224041939,
0.0505125672,
-1.114996314,
-0.8283712268,
-0.211224556,
-0.1151670292,
-0.3498275578,
-0.0277369563,
0.8069736958,
0.7970132828,
-0.8703522086,
0.1586296558,
-0.1001339182,
0.0816218778,
-0.2173274904,
-0.1862841249,
0.1771676242,
-0.7115890384,
-0.3982005417,
0.457475543,
0.0596274249,
-0.1088970378,
-0.0271229222,
-0.1253959984,
-0.4126208425,
0.2067720145,
0.617089808,
0.0772929043,
-0.1745517403,
-0.3547627032,
-0.2706960738,
-0.0969679281,
-0.1269668788,
0.8183415532,
-0.6983314753,
0.7864385843,
0.6584660411,
0.42729792,
0.2312916219,
0.2209102958,
0.8660487533,
-0.8097071648,
0.2292255759,
0.5712605715,
-0.0092102299,
0.2587629557,
-0.4772697091,
0.417606771,
-0.1739645749,
-0.476934731,
-0.997441411,
0.0300881565,
-0.7585575581,
-0.2443213314,
1.0206249952,
-0.2681444287,
-0.1956738085,
-0.0946885273,
-0.340746969,
0.4013776481,
0.0995998159,
0.7478637695,
0.4702421427,
0.223903954,
0.068710506,
-0.7545017004,
0.9472330213,
0.517372489,
-1.265663147,
0.2065119296,
0.4282535613,
0.3546482027,
0.0992377251,
0.7336027622,
-0.3655456007,
0.2032181621,
-0.2293644398,
0.0830937028,
-0.1112094522,
-0.4467786551,
-0.2993122935,
-0.2872950733,
-0.1058129296,
-0.2081190348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07371v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07371v3 | BiasTestGPT: Using ChatGPT for Social Bias Testing of Language Models | 2023-02-14T22:07:57 | 2023-12-06T06:26:52 | Rafal Kocielnik, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Vivian Zhang, Roy Jiang, R. Michael Alvarez, Anima Anandkumar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, 68T50, I.2.7; J.5; K.4.1 | Pretrained Language Models (PLMs) harbor inherent social biases that can
result in harmful real-world implications. Such social biases are measured
through the probability values that PLMs output for different social groups and
attributes appearing in a set of test sentences. However, bias testing is
currently cumbersome since the test sentences are generated either from a
limited set of manual templates or need expensive crowd-sourcing. We instead
propose using ChatGPT for the controllable generation of test sentences, given
any arbitrary user-specified combination of social groups and attributes
appearing in the test sentences. When compared to template-based methods, our
approach using ChatGPT for test sentence generation is superior in detecting
social bias, especially in challenging settings such as intersectional biases.
We present an open-source comprehensive bias testing framework (BiasTestGPT),
hosted on HuggingFace, that can be plugged into any open-source PLM for bias
testing. User testing with domain experts from various fields has shown their
interest in being able to test modern AI for social biases. Our tool has
significantly improved their awareness of such biases in PLMs, proving to be
learnable and user-friendly. We thus enable seamless open-ended social bias
testing of PLMs by domain experts through an automatic large-scale generation
of diverse test sentences for any combination of social categories and
attributes. | [
-0.6486568451,
-1.1167252064,
0.1589751095,
0.4594548941,
-0.076764904,
0.0754105523,
-0.3783994913,
-0.2322762311,
0.146889165,
0.4658749402,
-0.6457103491,
-0.3023427725,
-0.4761917293,
-0.2088018358,
-0.3793596029,
1.2560435534,
-0.2014311701,
0.1892291605,
-0.3229281902,
-0.1492682397,
-0.2305030823,
-0.5983172655,
-0.5526291132,
-0.2827251256,
0.2360327244,
0.2825027108,
0.7341287732,
0.1568092257,
0.2901250422,
0.1408227235,
0.128710866,
-0.1157494858,
-0.5342280865,
-0.0711116716,
-0.1446901262,
-0.0313805118,
-0.4402686954,
0.3477902114,
0.2315220088,
0.6833233833,
0.0090139806,
0.2869832218,
0.2549513578,
0.4272717535,
-0.4922964573,
0.3034509122,
-0.7399733663,
-0.003658382,
-0.2776778638,
-0.0615772977,
-0.2181414962,
-0.8502519131,
0.2262115777,
-0.279181242,
0.4422088265,
0.227073893,
0.7647089362,
0.2883233726,
-0.3754687011,
-0.1093790457,
-0.4678115249,
0.4646995962,
-0.5178447366,
0.4149988592,
0.3855607212,
0.3928262591,
-0.1586154252,
-0.4754753411,
-0.603523612,
-0.5574108362,
0.0515556633,
0.1630955786,
0.2138251513,
0.1366348267,
0.3211840391,
0.4105362296,
-0.7617742419,
-0.2645893991,
-0.1444513947,
-0.1920356303,
0.708201766,
-0.2838802636,
0.6612588763,
-0.0462288,
-0.3267584145,
-0.1130966246,
-0.7568661571,
-0.2733749747,
0.7349254489,
0.2751107812,
-0.1195814237,
0.6579814553,
-0.1788763553,
0.3688764274,
0.0493149869,
0.3072280586,
0.333961755,
-0.2488698214,
0.0656360239,
0.0797963366,
0.830599308,
0.4685631096,
0.7900512218,
0.0294845384,
-0.0206516609,
0.3300916553,
-0.0155730965,
-0.6726021171,
-0.3289310038,
0.0304644164,
-0.3534697592,
-0.4988053143,
-0.0983992368,
-1.1165757179,
-0.4971426129,
-0.0752788931,
0.1711613685,
-0.4865719676,
-0.4164209664,
0.0251676347,
-0.1525510699,
0.4053284526,
-0.031001376,
-0.6581696272,
0.3630142808,
0.4814645052,
0.7979595661,
-0.296803683,
-0.4114484787,
-0.7225728035,
-0.1767732799,
0.0556552634,
0.680862546,
-0.4902088642,
-0.3094348013,
0.1610809267,
-0.3222430646,
0.0081096683,
-0.4037076831,
0.4688339829,
-0.3401395977,
0.5020425916,
-0.4028979838,
-0.5538517237,
0.356040448,
0.2358112186,
-0.2226630151,
1.2979520559,
0.1582109928,
-1.062151432,
0.5088672042,
-0.8435696363,
-0.5826672316,
0.0866499916,
-0.4631098211,
-0.5582073927,
-0.3188010752,
0.2759313881,
0.3175840974,
-0.1075660884,
0.3925409913,
-0.7282895446,
-0.1896268576,
0.1106753647,
-0.3099811673,
0.9363798499,
-0.1040734053,
-0.8287779093,
0.2012866884,
-0.4492572546,
-0.0664952844,
0.2736240923,
-0.2213156819,
-0.3289015591,
0.2380561829,
0.298981607,
0.2221314609,
-0.0358737484,
-0.6863191724,
-0.0698370934,
-0.2351754457,
0.3515101671,
1.1323171854,
-0.1818576008,
0.3901273906,
-0.3317540884,
0.5120338202,
-0.1123817787,
0.2900437713,
0.0273043234,
-0.5992350578,
-0.8508948088,
-0.1769480109,
0.1122628301,
0.5988991261,
-0.7305131555,
0.664246738,
-0.0231015142,
-0.3734916449,
-0.3818502128,
0.0842228308,
0.374853462,
0.2801502943,
0.0857295096,
-0.625808835,
-0.3710044622,
-0.789018333,
-0.6953158975,
-0.1721895337,
-0.2302910686,
0.6177408099,
0.5267201662,
-0.1900107861,
1.0530817509,
-0.5651518703,
-0.1194875613,
-0.3143084347,
-0.11454539,
-0.3138881028,
0.3065599203,
0.5472070575,
-0.6757104397,
-0.5187968016,
-0.2822285593,
-0.2974414229,
-0.7594172359,
0.3384730518,
-0.2571792006,
0.1345019639,
0.3403963745,
-0.6432853341,
0.3457691371,
0.6613582373,
-0.5736027956,
0.7827324271,
0.2746849358,
-0.1997560114,
-0.9762108326,
0.0085620694,
0.098326765,
-0.4131112397,
-0.3806751668,
-0.0076236124,
-0.0730660334,
-0.1749017239,
-0.406680882,
0.7093282938,
-0.3575875759,
-0.1835091412,
-0.0254247785,
0.2034796625,
-0.2155784965,
0.4234297276,
-0.0408706777,
0.8205935359,
0.3775228858,
-0.4175837338,
0.2102296203,
0.161019519,
-0.3354156017,
0.4911904931,
-0.7498109341,
0.4375690222,
-0.1806803197,
0.3664486408,
-0.8722909093,
-0.3017674685,
0.305011183,
-0.3826021254,
-0.1738959998,
-0.0719836429,
-0.3817459345,
-0.1688678861,
-0.3051910996,
0.2835332155,
0.7540099621,
-0.504488945,
0.2571996748,
0.665245831,
-0.2804878354,
-0.3896826506,
-0.3612543643,
-0.385782063,
-0.2287005484,
-0.7423151135,
-0.0731097832,
-0.2923731208,
-0.3281904161,
-0.2826288342,
0.1045464501,
0.086883612,
-0.0255236458,
0.2950516641,
0.179641515,
-0.1541001797,
-0.0285522304,
-0.0420016497,
0.127784133,
0.1232793927,
-0.3453617394,
0.9939528108,
-0.2214179784,
-0.5392585993,
0.1901624501,
0.1261005849,
0.2788125873,
-0.4818866849,
0.4099727869,
0.8521252275,
-0.1558955461,
-0.3865745962,
-0.757017374,
-0.2869510949,
-0.4639632404,
0.228400588,
0.0866878033,
-1.203312397,
0.497761786,
0.080509983,
0.0035729008,
-0.126837045,
0.7028803825,
0.4030296206,
1.0528088808,
0.3645164073,
-0.3239919245,
0.6072053313,
0.2517148554,
0.2971847951,
-0.4967665076,
0.2302917689,
-0.4793905914,
0.1598614156,
-0.5763324499,
-0.4161800444,
0.2765755057,
-0.392431587,
-0.373732239,
-0.0737485141,
-0.5056004524,
0.7161092758,
0.7747237682,
0.2307047546,
0.0905375779,
-0.1127273515,
-0.1445987374,
-0.0741243958,
-0.3431960344,
-0.5124439597,
0.9970258474,
0.2454278916,
0.6294782758,
-0.1506782174,
0.4954478741,
0.3472765684,
0.5844185948,
-0.5463995337,
0.5506334901,
0.1066537276,
-0.7726815343,
-0.1774745435,
-0.3702074587,
-0.521478951,
0.2066209167,
-0.0079712104,
-0.6623738408,
-0.2059324831,
0.3852755427,
-0.1325021237,
0.3203456402,
-0.8152885437,
1.1034876108,
-0.1642207801,
-0.4663659036,
0.2942836285,
-0.5774362087,
0.4701581597,
0.0038991407,
0.1688888222,
-0.2759492099,
0.4458340704,
0.676274538,
-0.336568296,
1.038287878,
-0.3314104974,
0.1742356122,
0.1802592129,
0.191857487,
0.437004298,
0.117390357,
0.0722147524,
0.2235137075,
-0.0988312513,
-0.5135412812,
-0.3561006486,
0.5189430714,
-0.7746738791,
-0.4779166281,
-0.3967494965,
-0.5493776202,
-0.3031868041,
0.3798986077,
0.1157841533,
0.0774797499,
-0.6124684215,
-0.1906343997,
0.7129035592,
-0.5577446818,
-0.1457470953,
0.3833484948,
-0.5879238844,
-0.0892865732,
0.6748450994,
-0.1602080613,
0.3939921558,
-0.1498907954,
0.3676816821,
-0.0691732466,
-0.3474728465,
-0.2640189826,
-0.0026038736,
-0.2113652974,
0.1602819264,
-0.5749464035,
-0.1433726251,
-0.8340752125,
-0.2021176368,
-0.4558483958,
-0.1838713735,
0.3761743605,
-0.1686589867,
0.2394990325,
0.652457118,
-0.0165461786,
0.4328445196,
-0.2627052963,
0.1493608803,
0.3533766568,
0.4281299114,
-0.3584226668,
-0.0540159903,
0.3792316914,
0.0365466401,
-0.4903930128,
-0.931332171,
0.374445796,
0.0775298402,
0.2737001777,
0.4232808053,
0.1534213722,
0.2522427738,
-0.6723467708,
0.7389212847,
-0.1364191025,
-1.0632703304,
0.6873503327,
-0.7277194262,
-0.0099773901,
0.462589711,
0.3081232905,
-0.6778994203,
-0.5350166559,
-0.6802482009,
-0.754114449,
0.6055608988,
0.4011175036,
0.1704017371,
-0.1406049132,
0.3645164073,
0.2154443711,
0.2133899331,
-0.7753002048,
-0.2400877774,
-0.3364439905,
-0.301485002,
-0.2322209775,
-0.2209663093,
-0.0834640488,
-0.0963307768,
0.647569418,
-0.1489704251,
0.1085334346,
0.1581344157,
-0.0099049462,
-0.0250532851,
0.2610234618,
0.2903915942,
0.5666002631,
-0.3610788882,
0.1044418961,
0.1673489064,
-0.6035228968,
-0.0758347809,
0.3640828133,
-0.4481518269,
0.0190215055,
0.0919629782,
0.7363730073,
-0.0106697595,
-0.6655224562,
0.9652697444,
-0.2197953314,
-0.1054346189,
-0.6481634378,
0.0437816717,
0.0978722647,
-0.0442895703,
-0.0309080333,
-0.166256994,
0.0182182938,
-0.4531654119,
0.473013252,
0.5941147804,
-0.562967062,
-0.2335939556,
0.8201224208,
0.4140954912,
-0.395614773,
0.4831142128,
-0.2759682536,
-0.7645334005,
0.5018935204,
0.3768266141,
0.7637865543,
-0.3829871714,
0.5182291269,
0.0165490098,
0.5592736602,
0.0102727897,
0.1770589948,
0.0899714306,
-1.0927215815,
-0.4129163027,
-0.5417969227,
-0.5233412385,
0.2684808075,
-0.4956997931,
0.2813499272,
-0.3891411126,
0.0052811354,
-0.0976071358,
-0.2122796029,
-0.6454080939,
-0.2098215371,
0.0121057769,
0.8670910597,
-1.0184315443,
0.4672915041,
0.7419124246,
-0.3278934956,
-0.5795514584,
0.1277841181,
0.1907110363,
-1.0076748133,
0.428845942,
0.3057056963,
0.2649112046,
-0.062844269,
-0.8455643654,
-0.5276051164,
0.6512244344,
0.5831597447,
-0.2153859437,
0.0200307909,
0.3792491257,
0.3955731988,
-0.1648064107,
0.5508370996,
0.5366259217,
0.3811787665,
-0.188087225,
-1.0500216484,
0.1921828091,
-0.2381477058,
-0.0064591761,
0.13033095,
-0.7842865586,
0.803960681,
0.1177690253,
0.0053180298,
-0.4806390405,
0.4392033517,
0.4710642099,
0.3119950294,
0.6663874388,
0.3489175439,
0.6408093572,
-0.1617967635,
1.1130416393,
-0.3094920516,
0.3336674869,
1.1297844648,
-0.7773148417,
0.3896432817,
0.3878976405,
-0.0929725319,
0.2343323529,
0.6766403317,
0.3804712892,
0.3211177289,
0.6688506007,
-0.3784758151,
-0.2275161743,
-0.221862942,
-0.2686629295,
0.2182504833,
0.1067805067,
-0.2568227351,
-0.1553870589,
-0.0633111894,
0.5021097064,
0.0174279455,
-0.0602317527,
0.5746898651,
0.1631858349,
-0.7355784178,
0.0141560948,
-0.2576492727,
0.919537425,
-0.6264452934,
0.0861849487,
-0.4497032464,
0.3972211778,
-0.0480308942,
-0.5650573969,
0.1554822177,
0.0134165473,
0.2367310524,
-0.2906413376,
1.1736810207,
-0.5848251581,
-0.2977544665,
0.4438332021,
0.6774449944,
0.2211482972,
-0.5114941597,
-0.7068228722,
0.0928134173,
0.090456903,
-0.4133858979,
0.4221522808,
0.1690797806,
0.0058152075,
0.690513134,
0.6571199298,
0.2797504961,
0.3723035455,
0.2826206684,
0.9813280702,
-0.3016492128,
-0.4093738198,
-0.8883647323,
0.2673274577,
-0.3302645385,
-0.3553692997,
0.8652202487,
0.5266923308,
1.1682271957,
0.1335179955,
1.3733122349,
-0.1745949388,
0.5249463916,
-0.312094003,
0.9636793733,
-0.0716543496,
-0.2006911337,
-0.5743045807,
-0.9141094089,
-0.1326232702,
0.6294749975,
-0.5717864633,
0.2662338614,
0.6337206364,
0.9539218545,
-0.3138018847,
0.1924109459,
-0.0004912563,
0.1897381395,
0.4217538536,
0.4651801586,
0.8769197464,
-0.1904109269,
0.4549328089,
-0.2452041507,
-0.6255652308,
0.0805810168,
-0.7479603291,
-1.4515582323,
-0.3276086152,
-0.3767148852,
-0.607529521,
0.3927832544,
1.0636085272,
0.68642205,
-0.7819284797,
-0.1753939688,
-0.0648363903,
0.1014324427,
0.1090667024,
-0.3827436566,
0.344081074,
-0.2948552966,
-0.6493338943,
-0.0192260295,
0.006879576,
-0.1718828231,
-0.4509992599,
-0.0646490678,
-0.0678466484,
-0.0573451743,
0.5973032713,
0.0927544758,
-0.2843987942,
-0.5175603032,
-0.0484480523,
0.153825596,
-0.1409677565,
0.8540008068,
-0.3542384803,
0.1939848512,
0.5478954911,
0.6735503674,
0.3158083558,
0.078246966,
0.9326943755,
-0.7530540228,
0.1172159165,
0.2025588155,
0.3320304751,
0.4136918783,
-0.2234974504,
0.5894156694,
0.3827516735,
-0.7750205398,
-0.842430234,
0.3331083357,
-0.887314558,
0.1458545923,
1.55210042,
-0.1328831911,
-0.2701269686,
-0.1769970655,
-0.479583323,
0.4119108021,
-0.5116336942,
1.0067189932,
0.7597369552,
0.0687068626,
-0.1178556085,
-0.7334994078,
0.7155588865,
0.4931502342,
-0.8643158674,
0.1955924481,
0.3402035534,
0.5267790556,
-0.1613987833,
1.0691274405,
-0.2103444189,
-0.0820032954,
-0.2770355642,
0.5635057688,
0.1335226893,
0.366407007,
-0.0912749767,
-0.0473996885,
-0.0145427492,
-0.0334691554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07346v1 | ScatterShot: Interactive In-context Example Curation for Text Transformation | 2023-02-14T21:13:31 | 2023-02-14T21:13:31 | Tongshuang Wu, Hua Shen, Daniel S. Weld, Jeffrey Heer, Marco Tulio Ribeiro | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | The in-context learning capabilities of LLMs like GPT-3 allow annotators to
customize an LLM to their specific tasks with a small number of examples.
However, users tend to include only the most obvious patterns when crafting
examples, resulting in underspecified in-context functions that fall short on
unseen cases. Further, it is hard to know when "enough" examples have been
included even for known patterns. In this work, we present ScatterShot, an
interactive system for building high-quality demonstration sets for in-context
learning. ScatterShot iteratively slices unlabeled data into task-specific
patterns, samples informative inputs from underexplored or not-yet-saturated
slices in an active learning manner, and helps users label more efficiently
with the help of an LLM and the current example set. In simulation studies on
two text perturbation scenarios, ScatterShot sampling improves the resulting
few-shot functions by 4-5 percentage points over random sampling, with less
variance as more examples are added. In a user study, ScatterShot greatly helps
users in covering different patterns in the input space and labeling in-context
examples more efficiently, resulting in better in-context learning and less
user effort. | [
0.06330809,
-0.8595446348,
0.7759301662,
0.3041438162,
-0.5438399315,
-0.1883277893,
-0.231631577,
-0.0534501448,
0.0119656185,
0.4911602139,
-0.2908557355,
-0.7115656734,
-0.5638794899,
-0.107087709,
-0.879924953,
1.2855399847,
-0.2344809175,
-0.4472161233,
-0.3909742534,
-0.0054114414,
-0.2287905663,
-0.0757418349,
-0.5231321454,
-0.2909529209,
0.5242151022,
0.9657191634,
0.4477627575,
0.5785558224,
0.4093565345,
0.1930774301,
0.2252244502,
0.1441209465,
-0.5520099998,
0.7470003963,
-0.0698615089,
-0.2577143908,
0.0600337125,
0.1272639036,
0.6774507761,
0.4882680774,
-0.1063139066,
0.4154866338,
0.4316630363,
0.0879161805,
-0.7084284425,
0.1357955933,
-0.3684660494,
-0.0725542754,
-0.4108094275,
-0.3078775406,
-0.5402352214,
-0.2925261855,
-0.0418870449,
-0.8506762385,
0.0881969556,
-0.2057922781,
0.6501166821,
0.1230382472,
-0.5576375723,
-0.4304259419,
-0.7210189104,
0.8039526939,
-0.5479151607,
-0.2215484679,
0.2664699852,
0.923661828,
-0.2985948026,
-1.0482929945,
-0.4458760023,
0.1062502712,
-0.1304354221,
0.3356159925,
-0.1947929859,
-0.2982520163,
0.3657752573,
0.0841274709,
-0.3216249943,
-0.0306368675,
-0.1737994552,
-0.184596613,
0.4871150553,
0.290373534,
0.0885250196,
-0.0593643263,
-0.34017241,
-0.478457123,
-0.8233450055,
0.0601017326,
0.3118638098,
0.2345451266,
-0.0767454803,
0.8078261614,
0.0172921214,
0.8553237915,
0.0044690077,
-0.3297961354,
0.0081920922,
-0.1234754473,
-0.3255468011,
-0.0534861684,
0.5411732793,
0.272219032,
-0.3268981874,
0.2536202967,
-0.0627319068,
-0.157669723,
-0.0855260268,
-1.0800209045,
-0.1638818383,
0.091216296,
-0.2662403584,
-0.2150595188,
0.2526720464,
-0.8384794593,
-0.5853592157,
-0.1080220491,
0.3943947554,
-0.5467054844,
0.0617855825,
0.0816154107,
-0.412848264,
0.2238283753,
0.736777842,
-0.5837740302,
0.1112212762,
0.4498254359,
0.6583023071,
-0.4880390763,
-0.2489825338,
-0.7756233811,
0.6738808155,
0.1174600646,
1.1743520498,
-0.626085043,
-0.4706995785,
0.220186606,
-0.2516698241,
0.1655145735,
-0.2634261549,
0.4245482981,
-0.1094357371,
0.3687547743,
-0.1556206495,
-0.8351821303,
-0.1747663617,
0.3044100404,
-0.3327807784,
1.413921237,
0.4445512593,
-0.7064079046,
0.5455571413,
-0.6368575096,
-0.5454774499,
0.4261822701,
-0.5971105099,
-0.4980279505,
-0.1228435859,
0.1849400848,
0.9074548483,
0.1271475703,
-0.0728203356,
-0.2091945857,
-0.780177772,
0.120146215,
-0.3494747579,
0.7193718553,
0.2001539916,
-0.4839788377,
0.3041389585,
-0.5521849394,
-0.1144029424,
0.0194897875,
-0.3656992912,
-0.4078645706,
-0.2612601519,
0.4343271852,
0.2781718969,
-0.1455922872,
-0.4303693175,
0.6784447432,
-0.0228776652,
0.3111616075,
0.4367354512,
0.3069017828,
0.6000550389,
-0.4075985253,
0.7795103192,
-0.0231359135,
-0.0046474952,
-0.771592021,
-0.4127641916,
-0.6397744417,
-0.8415173888,
0.0026293602,
0.4563368261,
-0.9930408597,
0.104981102,
-0.344293654,
-0.6100657582,
-0.1834115386,
0.1676604152,
0.2477888763,
0.603512764,
0.4514702559,
0.0678066835,
-0.3145918846,
-0.8284375668,
-0.4569881856,
0.1127464026,
-0.5114152431,
0.1713689417,
0.5108338594,
0.0269774087,
1.0239309072,
-0.404124856,
-0.4377564192,
-0.5790392756,
0.2980014384,
0.0084117139,
0.2514475882,
0.5968276858,
-0.5244950056,
-0.6713455319,
-0.1052694544,
-0.6216586232,
-0.2364135981,
-0.4567490518,
-0.1152993888,
-0.1279897094,
0.7865837216,
-0.3067431152,
0.816845417,
0.425190717,
-0.4423605204,
0.2586410642,
-0.14809452,
0.2057248056,
-1.1384599209,
-0.1403332651,
0.0828627944,
-0.2909169197,
-0.4607272446,
0.1900612265,
0.1784772128,
-0.0705612749,
-0.5769953728,
0.6678655148,
-0.4560272992,
-0.2291841358,
-0.2659639716,
0.283144176,
0.0847144797,
0.1275639534,
-0.0817164704,
0.7307501435,
0.4325125813,
-0.4008255601,
0.0557021052,
0.1932355911,
-0.5170536637,
0.7251533866,
-0.2236371785,
0.096718803,
0.1242063493,
0.4789278805,
-1.1196215153,
-0.3742714226,
0.3014646471,
0.0324873962,
0.0536652319,
-0.2495992184,
-0.7555171251,
-0.0133315595,
-0.400700599,
0.3147512972,
0.5229341388,
-0.6122741103,
0.7404795289,
0.1215175614,
-0.0817647949,
-0.2996894419,
-0.7528639436,
0.0821461305,
-0.5024770498,
-0.1930698305,
0.5047226548,
0.0560336858,
-0.1594458967,
-0.2744505703,
0.0548530817,
0.2177074701,
-0.0246401504,
0.6432152987,
-0.0060914168,
0.1575727165,
-0.0390986428,
0.5042741299,
0.034163028,
-0.2665283382,
0.017315777,
0.2899081111,
0.0887835473,
-0.7464659214,
-0.3771211207,
0.5650904179,
0.2416365445,
0.256270498,
0.0636248738,
0.5064753294,
-0.3087617159,
-0.4825727642,
-0.2605359256,
-0.1828243285,
-0.4841822088,
0.2790397108,
-0.4109026492,
-0.9328457713,
0.3286425173,
-0.2090415508,
0.3144073784,
0.1186063737,
0.3446144164,
-0.5809493661,
0.7256116271,
0.6726840138,
0.2707233429,
0.8339849114,
-0.2891229689,
-0.1110577583,
-0.5782066584,
-0.0708374679,
-0.3686060309,
-0.4505933225,
-0.1160312444,
-0.6140975952,
0.4982975423,
0.0050167036,
-0.3335098028,
0.3980531693,
-0.4969030917,
0.6607261896,
0.5304575562,
0.4080205858,
0.3949653506,
0.454729706,
-0.1301842928,
-0.3001159728,
-0.6209769845,
-0.6597689986,
0.9754632115,
0.0496420264,
0.559797585,
-0.0620504431,
0.8728551269,
0.2307796329,
0.9835817814,
-0.75243783,
0.7691945434,
-0.0335141011,
-0.2780228853,
-0.4435804188,
0.042105969,
-0.8069176078,
0.2468919158,
-0.321128428,
-0.4311326742,
-0.0552779026,
0.3765384257,
-0.1050440222,
0.2618184984,
-0.477869302,
0.5512177348,
-0.0036442503,
-0.5251560211,
0.1359902471,
-0.4246315956,
0.1275206804,
0.1911385804,
0.2441923767,
0.08298219,
-0.0822513625,
0.5785347819,
-0.3028977811,
1.0195695162,
-0.3966508806,
-0.1824049205,
0.4145952165,
0.5392438769,
0.6076003909,
-0.1515823156,
-0.2077983916,
-0.2169763297,
-0.3223294318,
-0.380790323,
-0.8310133815,
0.6032312512,
-0.1718589067,
-0.4084203541,
-0.4115583897,
-0.5708041191,
-0.1013158113,
0.2294517905,
0.3675880432,
0.2009344995,
-0.0312069263,
0.3304754496,
0.1869364977,
0.0092416275,
0.6607993841,
0.2656319737,
-0.3185567856,
-0.204373911,
0.6003062129,
-0.0566098355,
0.0518737435,
0.2023650259,
0.1504359841,
-0.0508666597,
-0.753711164,
-0.5760409236,
0.014425844,
-1.0075970888,
-0.5575581789,
-0.2623511851,
0.1354231089,
-0.209222272,
-0.7456399798,
0.096272625,
-0.5372461677,
-0.2488655001,
-0.2239559591,
0.4188413918,
0.6350989342,
0.3675883114,
0.7335630655,
-0.308155179,
-0.0661150068,
0.3322772682,
0.0122667113,
-0.4082006216,
-0.8347142339,
-0.17860955,
-0.1944002807,
-0.5039119124,
-0.9002800584,
0.4178708196,
0.1768839508,
0.5260166526,
0.5995358229,
-0.2967060208,
1.031681776,
-0.3607398272,
0.953664422,
0.0670032203,
-0.8688838482,
0.67111063,
-0.4736169875,
0.4348033071,
0.7988145947,
0.2725778222,
-0.5501582026,
-0.7075252533,
-0.6095217466,
-0.8954461813,
0.4146170616,
0.2227851897,
0.0774394125,
0.1289919168,
0.6893604398,
0.4366871119,
0.0319308229,
-0.6017400622,
-0.1597936302,
-0.3811575174,
-0.6203237772,
-0.1683428138,
-0.1144464463,
-0.2277131826,
-0.3449034095,
0.5076751113,
-0.4896908998,
0.0157192871,
0.0466128215,
-0.4552961886,
0.2173385173,
0.1357359141,
0.6443775296,
0.3523007035,
0.0497656874,
0.5033559203,
0.0677490383,
-0.6179962158,
0.124493055,
0.0604141355,
-0.4438693225,
-0.0337107368,
0.4380943477,
0.4742670357,
0.6725292802,
-0.5218468308,
0.8915632963,
0.1831826568,
-0.2275342494,
-0.2242441475,
0.0795925036,
-0.1266318411,
0.2398321778,
0.6542839408,
-0.1810088158,
0.4162184894,
-0.3164657056,
0.1658024192,
0.2992981076,
-0.4426060021,
-0.0954274684,
0.4804139137,
-0.1093812436,
-0.3486247659,
0.3480272889,
-0.1939129233,
-0.1132982224,
0.4442085326,
0.8678176403,
0.6043229699,
-0.0511409305,
0.3966469169,
0.2062289566,
0.0938492268,
-0.1632252038,
0.127610445,
-0.4184710979,
-0.5268442035,
-0.1981852651,
-0.1311511844,
-0.6914329529,
0.0506807193,
-0.6863404512,
0.5975854397,
-0.211808905,
0.103641592,
-0.0831634924,
-0.2833391726,
-0.5792780519,
-0.0741671771,
-0.1347091645,
0.9529164433,
-1.2163110971,
0.7596218586,
0.9934476018,
-0.4887037575,
-0.4744854569,
0.0270360466,
-0.0486661419,
-0.5452064276,
0.4983386993,
0.2874288559,
-0.1918910146,
-0.020310292,
-0.9039831758,
-0.5150290728,
1.4143223763,
0.6296210289,
-0.2120198458,
0.1100240499,
0.2415838242,
0.5071969032,
-0.5046113729,
0.5989045501,
0.3053783178,
0.5627022982,
0.0318507366,
-0.3744054139,
0.2357559502,
-0.0447143503,
0.0097345794,
-0.1337599754,
-0.3640826344,
0.5001495481,
-0.1104607731,
-0.3325538635,
-0.09561719,
0.7302922606,
0.5691570044,
0.489010185,
0.6170586944,
0.1875137091,
0.3444396853,
-0.0591108315,
0.9438567758,
0.231893301,
0.0598644316,
1.3745698929,
-0.2724098563,
0.8626489043,
0.9795234799,
0.1022792682,
0.7175855041,
0.4751353264,
-0.0546467155,
0.4512048662,
0.1673973054,
-0.3497362137,
-0.389323175,
0.3126790524,
0.0705812871,
0.5279750824,
0.5570142865,
-0.1848752052,
-0.7215502858,
0.4124529064,
0.1781020314,
0.3938596845,
-0.0893298462,
0.6109312177,
-0.2374584079,
-0.4440669715,
0.0575080477,
-0.1678906232,
0.7133942246,
-0.5443242192,
-0.5885697007,
-0.4203987718,
0.0149240177,
-0.4217644632,
-1.1309971809,
0.0586445853,
-0.2206249982,
0.1258391291,
-0.751783669,
0.8605983853,
-0.4492670894,
-0.3674299717,
-0.0710623562,
0.3197479844,
0.446906805,
-0.1270886809,
-0.4907115102,
0.1681056619,
-0.0340523273,
-0.5232363939,
0.4646217227,
0.5101651549,
-0.4153946638,
0.5902088881,
0.5358240604,
-0.061317198,
-0.1205371991,
-0.0723410174,
0.8942620754,
-0.5027709007,
-0.3950068653,
-0.6047312617,
0.7256523967,
-0.487290889,
-0.3170446455,
1.2263793945,
0.7817132473,
0.7833636403,
-0.1901650727,
0.8124097586,
0.1613503695,
0.4363975525,
-0.2538829446,
0.6372955441,
-0.2550002038,
0.3055454195,
-0.4290840924,
-0.7824346423,
-0.822604835,
0.8381212354,
-0.1815577149,
-0.091604434,
0.6943771243,
0.4299662709,
-0.2818820775,
-0.1361563951,
0.3152218461,
-0.1589788646,
0.5393136144,
0.2133536935,
0.6480932236,
-0.5745009184,
0.7744454145,
-0.4001458287,
-0.3684156537,
-0.4444906414,
-1.3729524612,
-0.7553529143,
-0.7357853055,
-0.4334971309,
-0.1927866489,
-0.0771808252,
0.6101772189,
0.6760026217,
-0.6875516176,
-0.2466382831,
-0.0080331406,
-0.1098743603,
-0.5130665898,
-0.2789331377,
0.4213386774,
-0.0497953035,
-0.6586302519,
0.5648452044,
0.4320353568,
0.2621052563,
-0.0080004316,
0.4145469368,
0.1498245597,
-0.0790338665,
0.7824076414,
0.3728124201,
-0.2990411818,
-0.5045351982,
-0.1164591983,
-0.1101855561,
-0.0242572613,
1.0722498894,
-0.8860080838,
0.2127213478,
0.264536351,
0.5703632236,
1.0873692036,
-0.0076484503,
0.1695022583,
-1.0190339088,
0.4573061466,
0.2820328176,
0.2501680553,
0.3147539496,
-0.3634809256,
0.3435676694,
-0.0329521,
-0.46972844,
-0.8903924227,
0.2035195827,
-1.1644676924,
-0.1757937819,
1.4370092154,
-0.2741731405,
-0.0863546133,
-0.1171941608,
-0.4748713076,
0.1902542114,
-0.4157588184,
0.7628520727,
0.5017163754,
-0.4230288863,
-0.11541868,
-0.351136893,
0.5143207908,
0.1675929725,
-0.9844984412,
0.1271403134,
0.6514611244,
0.3685143292,
-0.1503332555,
0.6518867612,
-0.0966851786,
0.1087654606,
-0.1455564648,
0.0935638845,
-0.3779423535,
-0.2830506563,
-0.5234575868,
0.3587140739,
-0.1773839891,
0.0110352803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07324v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07324v2 | READIN: A Chinese Multi-Task Benchmark with Realistic and Diverse Input Noises | 2023-02-14T20:14:39 | 2023-05-25T01:04:08 | Chenglei Si, Zhengyan Zhang, Yingfa Chen, Xiaozhi Wang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | For many real-world applications, the user-generated inputs usually contain
various noises due to speech recognition errors caused by linguistic
variations1 or typographical errors (typos). Thus, it is crucial to test model
performance on data with realistic input noises to ensure robustness and
fairness. However, little study has been done to construct such benchmarks for
Chinese, where various language-specific input noises happen in the real world.
In order to fill this important gap, we construct READIN: a Chinese multi-task
benchmark with REalistic And Diverse Input Noises. READIN contains four diverse
tasks and requests annotators to re-enter the original test data with two
commonly used Chinese input methods: Pinyin input and speech input. We designed
our annotation pipeline to maximize diversity, for example by instructing the
annotators to use diverse input method editors (IMEs) for keyboard noises and
recruiting speakers from diverse dialectical groups for speech noises. We
experiment with a series of strong pretrained language models as well as robust
training methods, we find that these models often suffer significant
performance drops on READIN even with robustness methods like data
augmentation. As the first large-scale attempt in creating a benchmark with
noises geared towards user-generated inputs, we believe that READIN serves as
an important complement to existing Chinese NLP benchmarks. The source code and
dataset can be obtained from https://github.com/thunlp/READIN. | [
-0.0730345473,
-0.4011774361,
0.1477704346,
0.284397006,
-0.2399552315,
-0.0610829182,
-0.4148323834,
-0.8469105363,
-0.1931824088,
0.1997908354,
-0.5898457766,
-0.3888373375,
-0.3188878298,
0.1900004894,
-0.281989783,
0.6962932944,
-0.1009677872,
0.0857014805,
0.4221412539,
-0.149429664,
-0.3433193266,
-0.3034064174,
-0.5789400339,
-0.2921600938,
0.792704761,
0.1964990795,
0.5975394845,
0.5242263675,
0.309163779,
0.2203855366,
-0.0744363889,
0.4753034711,
-0.0630316213,
0.1872841865,
0.3485786021,
-0.4630925655,
-0.1792251021,
0.0184378307,
0.7882517576,
0.4068409204,
0.0566767827,
0.1830824167,
0.1965601742,
0.0732800514,
-0.8640064597,
0.202625975,
-0.3975751102,
0.2989665568,
-0.7162934542,
0.2062802464,
-0.4590359032,
-0.1015574709,
-0.1323734969,
-0.8733927608,
0.2875139713,
-0.2563014925,
0.7852674723,
0.2578676045,
-0.1095009595,
-0.009315595,
-0.7128962874,
0.8204008937,
-1.1605274677,
0.6370461583,
0.337647289,
0.2133256197,
0.1086862832,
-0.6025467515,
-0.6373273134,
-0.3075059056,
-0.0973925591,
0.3289564848,
0.2846384346,
0.0219218656,
0.542814374,
0.3863912225,
-0.5259302258,
0.2177949995,
-0.1221939996,
-0.2614010274,
0.522816658,
-0.0994999781,
0.5619019866,
-0.0163958147,
0.0778569207,
-0.3432649672,
-0.3540274203,
0.4023556709,
0.4775589406,
0.7494348884,
-0.1975386441,
0.2303591371,
-0.3977939785,
0.8759894967,
-0.2581511736,
-0.2449892908,
0.6962463856,
-0.7287187576,
0.1310502738,
0.0328729339,
0.8464013934,
0.1250928789,
0.3580498099,
-0.2036682963,
-0.5192968249,
-0.1214424446,
0.2848412693,
-0.7638013959,
-0.480093509,
0.2310622036,
-0.4922102094,
-0.1707811654,
0.0194836278,
-0.8131983876,
-0.5683041215,
-0.256064862,
0.1395430416,
-0.4480812252,
-0.3874512315,
-0.1437636614,
-0.0015286241,
0.2626312673,
0.4462792277,
-1.0681593418,
0.0778949037,
0.8316718936,
1.0789933205,
-0.315871954,
-0.495074302,
-0.8528252244,
-0.1726773232,
-0.1159377769,
0.9276185036,
-0.5303693414,
-0.2057613432,
0.1873753667,
-0.1222227663,
-0.3665978611,
-0.6953437924,
0.7528598905,
-0.0648532212,
-0.1677116752,
-0.4246400297,
-0.2621272802,
-0.1334861666,
0.2705933154,
-0.7836338282,
1.0273374319,
0.000306125,
-0.8168804646,
0.7671563625,
-0.821932137,
-0.7131675482,
0.1243781075,
0.0096632931,
-0.36586532,
0.0639932901,
0.4457153976,
0.2069735378,
-0.0992150679,
0.0696425661,
-0.4112701416,
-0.478823036,
0.2977998853,
-0.5433988571,
0.8233034015,
0.2495967597,
-0.3866710365,
0.3090459108,
-0.9180092216,
0.1196324453,
-0.1494423747,
-0.4410096109,
-0.1220292151,
0.1216039807,
0.7268915176,
0.2676205933,
0.1338016838,
-0.9127796292,
-0.0937574655,
-0.3339465857,
0.3473275304,
0.5474750996,
-0.3531707525,
-0.1990349889,
-0.6104838848,
0.224778071,
0.2460339218,
0.0400428288,
-0.3277342021,
-0.27092731,
-0.5063440204,
-0.4580006301,
0.4009387195,
0.8779031634,
-0.5073707104,
0.010921739,
0.0049481452,
-0.5681695938,
-0.6846188903,
0.242015332,
0.2955077589,
0.3224264383,
0.2518416047,
-0.1267562658,
-0.4563985169,
-0.7829746008,
-0.6934902072,
-0.4445165694,
-0.3242540359,
0.207653895,
0.1474387348,
-0.0894136503,
0.2641255856,
-0.0702477247,
-0.2282821834,
-0.1377223283,
0.1444605738,
0.1942263842,
0.5294941664,
0.4173996449,
-0.6035502553,
-0.448582828,
0.0533239543,
-0.6234666109,
-0.2271162421,
-0.3129108846,
0.0393708199,
-0.2269204855,
0.3356342912,
-0.2832722664,
0.2364618927,
0.6812919378,
0.0808378085,
0.8568027616,
-0.0293258149,
0.327614516,
-1.0864400864,
0.0633970276,
0.2143766433,
-0.1500639915,
-0.5857518315,
0.0412387885,
0.1679925621,
-0.10141588,
-0.4746395946,
0.2577152848,
-0.2352255881,
0.0954873413,
-0.1415198445,
0.0636511445,
-0.1303016692,
0.559507072,
0.0314348117,
0.9854851365,
0.5499999523,
-0.5094254613,
0.2662627697,
0.1147096083,
-0.4859306216,
0.5355911255,
-0.9177984595,
-0.1062336117,
0.2887893319,
-0.0570567362,
-1.0367736816,
-0.1999830753,
0.2979435921,
-0.1378655881,
0.2112719566,
0.2919885218,
-0.9037835002,
-0.0245551672,
-0.2200214267,
0.5196059942,
0.2241763771,
-0.8578369617,
0.4609889388,
0.3488885164,
-0.1124683544,
-0.4753750265,
-0.7800454497,
-0.108080022,
0.0990667343,
-0.5715546608,
0.2777955234,
-0.1477948725,
0.0864821747,
-0.3094423413,
-0.1350869387,
-0.3770249486,
0.0538211837,
0.398488313,
0.1817820966,
-0.3561141491,
0.0369386002,
-0.1162713096,
0.1149533913,
-0.1017306075,
-0.2813048959,
0.167757377,
-0.1687928587,
-0.433824569,
-0.6683650613,
0.079193756,
0.3894834518,
-0.4898065031,
0.4201196134,
0.9039940834,
-0.5034033656,
-0.2503617406,
-0.414074719,
-0.0615382865,
-0.4418719113,
0.7417978048,
-0.5624479055,
-0.7482152581,
0.6498429179,
-0.2433817983,
0.8937126994,
0.3081896901,
0.461352855,
-0.2066565603,
0.6108392477,
0.2075271904,
-0.1368048191,
0.7526769638,
0.3025857508,
0.0742501915,
-0.5524776578,
0.171987772,
-0.6768380404,
-0.3861499131,
-0.4589124918,
-0.3306797445,
-0.0960519761,
-0.2070680857,
-0.0401173756,
0.3694841564,
-0.4757393897,
0.2768028378,
0.749008894,
0.1854043603,
0.2403851599,
-0.224980697,
-0.2355630696,
-0.3469153941,
-0.5543795228,
-0.180671379,
0.8964065313,
0.1074970961,
0.6586185694,
0.0036166776,
0.5814323425,
0.2621107101,
0.2363024801,
-0.5208932161,
0.2228073627,
-0.5526023507,
-0.4668829143,
-0.3998681605,
-0.3991645873,
-0.8959321976,
0.3931169212,
-0.2778280973,
-0.9024916887,
0.3083932996,
0.2430929542,
-0.2937130034,
0.6746821404,
-0.4546574056,
1.0427299738,
-0.2616090775,
-0.0379262641,
-0.0036986594,
-0.4586599469,
0.4660567641,
-0.1960596442,
0.2056733668,
-0.0833071023,
0.2269969732,
0.753575027,
-0.1099896654,
0.9183122516,
-0.05915704,
-0.1301228255,
0.1242367551,
0.0099608628,
0.4581964314,
-0.0471932329,
-0.3179384172,
0.5124335289,
0.2824372053,
-0.2996231318,
-0.3500160873,
0.3894241154,
-0.9454884529,
-0.1346262693,
-0.3307903111,
-0.8516641259,
-0.2305722833,
0.4446635544,
0.3702707589,
0.5227704644,
-0.2548276484,
0.1225330085,
0.4020035863,
-0.0575061701,
0.4514129758,
0.3675242364,
0.0015796747,
-0.3333073854,
1.0535675287,
0.2162487954,
0.0364336818,
0.5133476853,
-0.0412566997,
-0.1524690241,
-0.4969667792,
-0.4797858596,
0.1543342024,
-0.5217213035,
0.2897001505,
-0.5199286342,
-0.3298670352,
-0.2561044097,
0.1766256392,
-0.6514226198,
-0.1407390386,
-0.1117337048,
0.0878345594,
-0.1637065262,
0.5531005859,
-0.207367152,
0.4137299955,
-0.7712894082,
0.7232368588,
0.1605577022,
0.6282162666,
-0.015493013,
-0.4795510769,
-0.5253119469,
0.1149174348,
-0.0914767534,
-0.728036046,
0.079529725,
0.3369709253,
0.7014519572,
0.2864555717,
0.3063046634,
0.3860709071,
-0.2956523001,
0.6711111665,
-0.0409720838,
-0.8903677464,
0.342610687,
-0.2308936715,
0.6756412983,
0.8771293759,
-0.2695457339,
-0.9475570917,
-0.4907479584,
-0.0846363977,
-0.5908736587,
0.9933131337,
0.137221083,
-0.3289737403,
0.4551759064,
0.1136687547,
0.356882304,
0.0635168627,
-0.7263128161,
-0.2343927771,
-0.3396858871,
-0.2508384287,
-0.1049225703,
-0.1727467775,
0.0366230384,
0.0181093384,
0.5437631607,
0.0076382593,
-0.1053405479,
0.1356191039,
-0.2561299503,
0.0679171532,
0.2222591937,
0.5501006246,
0.5376297235,
-0.1476860195,
-0.0047308099,
0.0331129618,
-0.8153005838,
-0.0723799095,
0.3657979667,
-0.657133162,
0.3025905192,
0.4723447859,
1.0517687798,
0.1166799217,
-0.7846595049,
0.171937108,
-0.3319774866,
-0.3246874213,
-0.3603774309,
0.1674588472,
-0.0982919857,
0.1673304588,
-0.0572950765,
0.4559154212,
0.2514553368,
-0.128908664,
0.1774883866,
0.0020651906,
-0.5978485942,
-0.3133571446,
0.8831506371,
0.3674915433,
-0.3150794208,
0.7291052341,
-0.0636967793,
-0.2831607163,
0.3632149398,
0.1609909683,
1.0912617445,
-0.0304233804,
0.1276966929,
0.6514540911,
0.6460368037,
-0.2250931859,
0.2318254709,
-0.2575087547,
-0.7905924916,
-0.4643259048,
-0.2078786045,
-0.7344180942,
0.0519685484,
-0.5527169108,
0.1992138773,
-0.4251798391,
-0.1395830512,
0.1548780203,
-0.0759616494,
-0.5593105555,
0.2114163935,
0.3639296293,
0.5218267441,
-0.6786810756,
0.6330296993,
0.6325232983,
-0.3218284845,
-0.7394241691,
0.3097804785,
0.1089306176,
-0.4351859987,
0.4504002333,
0.4506030083,
0.2492155731,
-0.5440152884,
-0.3315790594,
-0.5680551529,
0.6237284541,
0.2869015038,
-0.6573905349,
0.2112032622,
0.2755516171,
0.2700792253,
-0.1071818247,
0.4057241082,
0.4170159698,
0.6650766134,
-0.2220186144,
-1.1329861879,
0.1000409722,
-0.6091028452,
-0.2951388657,
-0.0396919399,
-0.8954440951,
1.1257570982,
-0.0493700393,
-0.2141047418,
-0.1109850183,
0.7222256064,
0.5103146434,
0.4803623557,
0.8910471201,
0.3223359883,
0.97433424,
-0.1779186577,
0.763609767,
-0.3559769988,
-0.1076644957,
1.2761847973,
-0.4070815742,
0.8063290119,
0.0911023617,
-0.3431905806,
0.2149065137,
0.7989094853,
-0.2297842503,
0.1915221661,
0.2642999589,
-0.2717534602,
-0.3756818771,
-0.3081662655,
-0.332960099,
0.2959759533,
0.0415643528,
0.1100100204,
-0.0497150123,
-0.0797622427,
-0.3108175993,
0.0194766559,
0.0371973403,
0.6867784262,
-0.0340243652,
-0.4833336473,
0.243257001,
-0.043320436,
1.1050943136,
-0.8224423528,
0.0012039233,
0.0016010713,
0.2647205591,
-0.1365226507,
-0.6763107777,
0.0557028279,
-0.0928218663,
-0.282782644,
0.0817787871,
0.5351242423,
-0.4357367158,
-0.668225348,
0.2903441787,
0.2836612165,
0.2452745289,
-0.2673643827,
-0.6125558615,
0.1216769591,
0.116498597,
-0.0761604682,
0.2903166115,
0.509383738,
0.0889010206,
0.4938162565,
0.7677106261,
0.3434255719,
0.178618893,
0.3990478516,
0.5074904561,
-0.6341798902,
-0.6365724206,
-0.6173354387,
0.463771224,
-0.0499285273,
-0.7694915533,
0.6508982182,
0.5823431611,
0.9182031751,
-0.0492837541,
1.0335446596,
0.1969771236,
0.6480028629,
-0.1071484089,
0.9602954984,
-0.6270126104,
-0.0425564349,
-0.5502330661,
-0.7962887287,
-0.3915719688,
0.3086760938,
0.1071718633,
0.1136588678,
0.4425980449,
0.6567770243,
-0.0199611317,
0.3051442802,
0.5356303453,
0.0875881687,
0.4728402197,
0.5274620056,
0.5954381824,
-0.5481378436,
0.6586084366,
-0.5397813916,
-0.0102328248,
-0.054213766,
-0.5719752312,
-0.8570569754,
-0.4623128772,
-0.5453263521,
-0.276511699,
0.1479423195,
0.6555817127,
0.7595143914,
-1.3348389864,
-0.4318596721,
0.2265107334,
-0.0002527861,
-0.7614540458,
-0.1307330877,
0.281085521,
-0.4331975877,
-0.9748557806,
0.2921312749,
0.1441128999,
-0.1639411598,
0.0429492556,
0.0066848486,
-0.3001018763,
-0.1568708122,
0.2130407691,
0.6013304591,
-0.7366019487,
-0.0918321237,
0.0097660776,
-0.1935027242,
0.0375623517,
0.8731921315,
-0.4698067009,
0.8517773747,
0.6379140019,
0.9953072071,
0.404481113,
-0.1360823959,
0.6451874375,
-0.6188032627,
0.2915433645,
0.0520717464,
0.3903936744,
0.2848847806,
-0.2676623166,
0.4986954033,
0.1691410244,
-0.5039411187,
-0.9174157977,
-0.1224994138,
-0.9952985048,
-0.0292598754,
0.7357027531,
-0.3808781505,
-0.0570540093,
-0.2506259382,
-0.288223803,
0.4851892889,
-0.553702116,
0.5668231249,
0.8796439171,
0.0939187258,
-0.3993473351,
-0.6141724586,
0.3344632387,
0.5870693326,
-0.6262836456,
0.3142476976,
0.4253483117,
-0.107448712,
-0.0477460697,
0.3959755301,
0.0766744912,
0.4985122383,
0.4731183052,
0.3113084733,
-0.1020407006,
-0.0570702776,
-0.0241372697,
0.114823252,
0.0826001838,
-0.4833712578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07322v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07322v2 | TRESTLE: Toolkit for Reproducible Execution of Speech, Text and Language Experiments | 2023-02-14T20:07:31 | 2023-03-14T19:35:05 | Changye Li, Weizhe Xu, Trevor Cohen, Martin Michalowski, Serguei Pakhomov | cs.CL | cs.CL | The evidence is growing that machine and deep learning methods can learn the
subtle differences between the language produced by people with various forms
of cognitive impairment such as dementia and cognitively healthy individuals.
Valuable public data repositories such as TalkBank have made it possible for
researchers in the computational community to join forces and learn from each
other to make significant advances in this area. However, due to variability in
approaches and data selection strategies used by various researchers, results
obtained by different groups have been difficult to compare directly. In this
paper, we present TRESTLE (\textbf{T}oolkit for \textbf{R}eproducible
\textbf{E}xecution of \textbf{S}peech \textbf{T}ext and \textbf{L}anguage
\textbf{E}xperiments), an open source platform that focuses on two datasets
from the TalkBank repository with dementia detection as an illustrative domain.
Successfully deployed in the hackallenge (Hackathon/Challenge) of the
International Workshop on Health Intelligence at AAAI 2022, TRESTLE provides a
precise digital blueprint of the data pre-processing and selection strategies
that can be reused via TRESTLE by other researchers seeking comparable results
with their peers and current state-of-the-art (SOTA) approaches. | [
-0.0269213747,
-1.1328127384,
0.593133688,
0.2015245259,
-0.0769281834,
0.4533257782,
-0.2039258331,
-0.5714665055,
0.4850840867,
0.4431745112,
-0.4147323966,
-0.7681830525,
-0.437431246,
-0.053060744,
-0.3523249626,
1.0313304663,
-0.1337559968,
-0.0340411104,
0.0338613801,
-0.2506081164,
-0.4808929265,
-0.3067544401,
-0.7673436403,
-0.2835099399,
0.1730902195,
0.3165272772,
0.4010472596,
0.7899453044,
0.5357077122,
0.2979461253,
0.0885998681,
0.0813387185,
-0.4715687633,
0.343303293,
-0.3103835583,
-0.3436498344,
-0.6508470774,
-0.0086219832,
0.258323282,
0.4441011548,
-0.0452641845,
0.0962238982,
-0.0605677292,
0.1497098207,
-0.4467989206,
0.3242592216,
-0.5575389862,
0.0687647983,
-0.6702842712,
-0.2085403353,
-0.5496109724,
-0.438809216,
0.2607876956,
-0.5814111233,
0.1958831996,
0.1473885924,
0.9152420163,
0.3919950724,
0.0954496264,
-0.2821355462,
-0.4639769197,
0.9300138354,
-0.6472619176,
0.4857998788,
0.5921960473,
0.2622516751,
-0.0374866948,
-1.1520849466,
-0.196433723,
-0.5915041566,
0.0316246338,
0.2319441587,
-0.1928187013,
0.2054542899,
0.1882913709,
0.2101738304,
-0.9231290817,
0.2324058264,
-0.3954258561,
-0.4871314466,
0.547192812,
0.1168637276,
0.3439301848,
-0.2001212537,
0.038602367,
-0.2816420496,
-0.2553429306,
-0.3760066628,
0.1657494456,
0.4197722673,
-0.3390042484,
0.5222620964,
-0.3301738501,
0.5233293772,
-0.2755935192,
0.032868579,
0.7809263468,
-0.1973021477,
-0.0721278191,
0.1101134941,
0.792273581,
0.1968702972,
0.2134927958,
-0.2273131907,
0.0588478819,
0.1405192167,
0.1493020356,
-0.4748409688,
-0.6074388027,
0.3124215603,
-0.2823061347,
-0.021263944,
-0.0648776889,
-1.0872279406,
-0.3156989813,
-0.1551962048,
0.2677116096,
-0.644584775,
-0.1747618616,
0.095741272,
-0.2812730074,
-0.0003993728,
0.1412013918,
-0.444916904,
0.2988542318,
0.7513976097,
1.0117458105,
-0.5559597611,
-0.3534407616,
-0.7796378732,
0.0885032117,
-0.1819886416,
0.5485619903,
-0.5627251267,
-0.3092694879,
-0.2213936299,
-0.21148929,
0.0567973219,
-0.3827059567,
0.7782793641,
-0.2206940353,
0.133175686,
0.0958113447,
-0.2732652426,
0.0708401874,
-0.2167300135,
-0.7305977941,
1.0693907738,
0.305878669,
-0.7432419062,
0.5508108139,
-0.7533416152,
-0.5173687935,
0.3518700004,
-0.1139129102,
-0.675509572,
0.2449002266,
0.0108276242,
0.2107793689,
-0.0592710339,
0.1715548635,
-0.4623799324,
-0.2697179615,
0.219676733,
-0.5710570812,
0.8538959026,
0.0265909228,
-0.5649188757,
0.213521421,
-0.6453986168,
0.2271928936,
0.1049410403,
-0.1985023916,
-0.4307217896,
0.0337433107,
0.4578464925,
-0.1089292094,
0.044610586,
-0.7266734838,
-0.0034532491,
-0.3976072669,
0.635848105,
0.7034934759,
-0.0362617187,
-0.1744042784,
-0.3980120122,
0.340149194,
-0.3845974207,
0.2893407643,
0.0555973165,
-0.3292450607,
-0.5234476328,
-0.5985662937,
0.5716335177,
0.5470203161,
-0.737490356,
0.0791722685,
-0.5115351081,
-0.3418541849,
-0.9189572334,
-0.2681381702,
0.6636931896,
0.3215242624,
0.6387773156,
-0.2742871344,
-0.5557740331,
-0.9152156115,
-0.371103555,
-0.3010779619,
-0.2603375614,
0.3425000608,
0.3439201117,
-0.068560347,
0.8289937377,
-0.496102035,
-0.4243082702,
-0.2428046316,
0.5071721673,
-0.1420684755,
0.4220867455,
0.3121791482,
-0.7238206267,
-0.3432011902,
0.1779028922,
-0.6425013542,
-0.4511217177,
0.0074979109,
0.0282639433,
0.2995806932,
0.6262646317,
-0.4017914534,
0.6350721121,
0.4659813643,
-0.1855786294,
0.5602124333,
-0.0232238341,
0.3527807295,
-1.0606629848,
0.0691393018,
-0.2693394423,
-0.2979327738,
-0.5312311053,
0.2054062039,
-0.1606158763,
0.1377787441,
-0.3412635624,
0.3986344337,
-0.0092068873,
0.065810822,
0.1313223839,
0.3616220057,
-0.1313730776,
0.23856695,
0.1060322225,
0.6923681498,
0.3555728495,
-0.2485493869,
0.2667657733,
0.2920584679,
-0.1370746791,
0.7079008818,
-1.0793676376,
0.499034375,
0.0620054714,
-0.0946762264,
-0.7375508547,
-0.4796539247,
0.399451524,
-0.6490849257,
0.3505488038,
0.2129978985,
-0.2145195901,
-0.3833850324,
-0.641900897,
0.2976045609,
0.3148605525,
-0.1651854813,
0.6165387034,
0.7309484482,
-0.1746827662,
-0.4664469063,
-1.1460940838,
0.2604955733,
-0.1929947138,
-0.2240271717,
0.5912975073,
-0.0134752402,
-0.3729916513,
0.1576981395,
-0.016698828,
-0.0568743609,
-0.0920189619,
0.3141635656,
0.1016814932,
-0.1142931581,
0.1902005225,
-0.0256703906,
-0.3766509295,
-0.2600623667,
-0.1562969238,
0.6929341555,
-0.2528957427,
-0.6650677323,
-0.4123054445,
0.1901237965,
0.6016212702,
-0.3511225581,
0.2753426731,
0.3338834941,
-0.2932534218,
-0.3359439969,
-0.4163793325,
-0.0793235749,
-0.4853179753,
0.7461894155,
-0.5736082792,
-0.7871904373,
0.2814387977,
-0.019364601,
0.3617070913,
0.1319782585,
0.3038582206,
-0.0336644799,
0.6907052994,
0.4959994853,
-0.0143265575,
0.2547254562,
-0.1099385619,
0.0682301819,
-0.8060219288,
-0.2294797003,
-0.6702885032,
-0.2411628515,
-0.6289637685,
-0.388179183,
0.3099988699,
-0.2385100871,
0.076200299,
0.5341104269,
-0.6558534503,
0.1898213327,
0.7094994783,
0.4366257191,
0.428299129,
0.0229772255,
-0.096341826,
-0.3401303291,
-0.4525825679,
-0.3966415524,
1.0684415102,
0.1391583532,
0.7199719548,
-0.1492132545,
0.792478621,
0.6895987988,
0.1518606842,
-0.8381570578,
0.6502925754,
-0.2645631433,
-0.4075445533,
-0.501729846,
-0.5228904486,
-1.080909133,
-0.2642838061,
0.1929583699,
-1.0980808735,
-0.1458391398,
0.1040972471,
-0.0807277784,
0.1836772561,
-0.5480728149,
1.0118564367,
-0.2443529069,
-0.334936589,
-0.4186950624,
-0.6396124959,
0.0493704341,
-0.2148569524,
-0.0803972557,
0.0250956137,
0.0377508588,
0.8597874641,
-0.0934884921,
0.6479765773,
-0.0077489587,
0.3517751694,
0.1823642403,
0.3378258049,
0.222863242,
-0.0858125761,
-0.1479287446,
0.4564685822,
0.0547211245,
-0.2098474354,
-0.2730646729,
0.5725737214,
-0.5453014374,
-0.5052279234,
-0.3749957383,
-0.700972259,
-0.1786950082,
0.1587879509,
0.1662358046,
0.4812407196,
-0.3183171451,
0.2714987993,
0.4529387653,
-0.3799991906,
0.3509361148,
0.4407347739,
-0.3545611799,
-0.4395761192,
1.0550202131,
0.2050889879,
0.2602715194,
0.4290965199,
0.078488037,
-0.1171076074,
-0.737221837,
-0.2995167375,
0.1913257241,
-0.5236745477,
-0.0122554507,
-0.6972432137,
-0.2357228547,
-0.0389187671,
-0.1468693316,
-0.340908885,
-0.3983796537,
-0.033000119,
-0.3316018581,
0.6239878535,
0.6065480709,
-0.1771926433,
0.1708451211,
-0.4510288537,
0.4904594123,
0.0580103323,
0.2166032344,
-0.4052329063,
-0.3430989683,
0.0255507007,
0.1644052863,
-0.1384296566,
-0.898277998,
0.1012682766,
0.3016056716,
0.5450165272,
-0.0465003625,
0.0636078566,
0.7282651067,
-0.260276705,
0.6461271644,
-0.1491062939,
-1.1471792459,
0.7398110032,
-0.0265860353,
0.2010931224,
0.9695481658,
0.3198599219,
-0.653265655,
-0.6540926099,
-0.6539442539,
-1.0232521296,
0.7816846967,
0.1306381673,
-0.1616592854,
0.1355976164,
-0.0385651626,
0.2808993459,
0.0084558455,
-0.2843535841,
0.0662625879,
-0.1069238558,
-0.5059415698,
0.239852801,
0.2104338259,
0.0239384603,
0.0088424534,
0.7207106352,
-0.1681309044,
0.2359827161,
0.0842676163,
-0.1772523671,
0.1542883664,
-0.0936529264,
0.0490946658,
0.7232646942,
-0.2130308002,
0.2600327432,
0.3322882652,
-0.8827220798,
-0.1118555292,
0.0963046625,
-0.482508868,
0.1924430579,
0.793456316,
0.7126523256,
0.0835933089,
-0.9163984656,
0.2776170075,
-0.1025692746,
-0.1452980191,
0.0054799123,
0.0611047596,
-0.0308629591,
0.1277679801,
0.1352752894,
0.0249292664,
0.1532708257,
-0.3810050488,
0.665574491,
0.3288168609,
-0.578207016,
-0.344524771,
0.6337969899,
-0.0830912441,
-0.7789043784,
0.8755738735,
-0.2065014541,
-0.3435539305,
0.4294366837,
0.3283921182,
0.9812430143,
-0.2851498425,
0.4715313613,
-0.0726497695,
0.3122840226,
0.3003358245,
0.5123246908,
0.033201158,
-0.3441900015,
-0.590271771,
-0.686396122,
-0.3573054075,
0.3276203275,
-0.6329347491,
0.2754660845,
-0.2804669738,
-0.3542639613,
0.237894997,
-0.0741143897,
-0.5344291925,
-0.1700093746,
-0.149269402,
0.8850101829,
-0.86913836,
0.7170379758,
0.541187942,
-0.4036358297,
-0.6911126375,
0.5158476233,
0.1365972757,
-0.7311865687,
0.5422360897,
-0.0222389344,
-0.1245920435,
-0.0127815334,
-0.2928254008,
-0.5951488018,
0.7577264309,
0.4832196534,
-0.3198927939,
0.1085229516,
0.3309644759,
0.5821713805,
0.2143144906,
0.428804636,
0.5996263027,
0.7331249714,
0.0109129995,
-1.3313760757,
0.03086216,
0.0419908576,
-0.126785174,
0.2085582912,
-0.600484252,
0.4812935591,
0.0169686023,
-0.3576570451,
0.0849119052,
0.6405516267,
0.4952646494,
0.4921830893,
0.1677391529,
0.7100970745,
0.8098784685,
-0.4277186096,
0.6576574445,
-0.1205321401,
0.2528749108,
1.2077883482,
-0.2482468784,
0.7429150939,
0.4372278154,
-0.4709498286,
0.3326848745,
0.4369040728,
0.1918798387,
0.5896249413,
0.2581276298,
0.0205036644,
0.1813476384,
-0.5341402888,
-0.1020961106,
0.6099115014,
0.4633281529,
-0.1927694827,
-0.199774608,
0.130380109,
0.1916606724,
-0.0013139658,
-0.0179318618,
0.5189579725,
0.2053400725,
-0.4476928711,
0.3979751468,
-0.0273082107,
0.4985574484,
-0.7791290283,
-0.2885399461,
0.0059606796,
0.3181574047,
-0.0848034173,
-0.9602022767,
0.6268810034,
-0.1424468905,
0.1816712767,
-0.1002419218,
0.6671718955,
-0.1522065997,
-0.2561497986,
0.4516425729,
0.4416821301,
0.4051002264,
0.2816357315,
-0.7822886109,
0.5526489019,
-0.0048740939,
-0.3353263438,
-0.1136828959,
0.3458612561,
-0.3470128179,
0.7386846542,
0.4303842187,
0.2612476349,
-0.0325993933,
0.1055138856,
0.5784930587,
-0.1335908324,
-0.3175400794,
-1.0207512379,
0.334248215,
-0.4385732114,
-0.6836630106,
0.8448815346,
0.5948522091,
0.9237785935,
-0.034254875,
0.810402751,
-0.560367763,
0.3577364683,
-0.4140459895,
0.485838294,
-0.2416302264,
-0.1855435818,
-0.2263214737,
-0.673137188,
-0.3931685984,
0.6038080454,
-0.3210406005,
0.1479048878,
0.9049448371,
0.9640198946,
-0.1972570717,
0.1872096658,
0.0991697386,
0.4192760885,
0.3129831553,
0.7201820016,
0.5317428112,
-0.1251740158,
0.4150463641,
-0.1223545671,
-0.5479150414,
-0.1457744837,
-0.7244430184,
-0.8512195349,
-0.7443168163,
-0.445435077,
-0.3081676364,
0.7129061222,
0.9300678968,
0.9253445268,
-1.0336278677,
-0.0118145775,
-0.2615454495,
-0.0576065704,
-0.5197398663,
-0.2989645302,
0.7859717011,
0.0183892734,
-0.6768612862,
0.4203394651,
0.5004118085,
-0.146037817,
-0.2334651947,
0.0775452033,
0.0245539527,
-0.1099196672,
0.196959734,
0.312353164,
-0.5503072739,
-0.4925005734,
0.0451163091,
0.0179463588,
-0.0752246156,
0.5616161823,
-0.8525187373,
0.4262219071,
0.7210385799,
0.849719584,
0.7577471733,
-0.2127298415,
0.4528589845,
-0.6826528311,
-0.0518393777,
0.6388302445,
0.0539253615,
0.3157098591,
-0.1590157449,
0.7903168201,
0.1972930878,
-0.5434253216,
-0.8618533015,
0.2825621665,
-0.9094246626,
-0.2848225236,
0.7821570039,
-0.1924925148,
-0.2464710772,
-0.4797567725,
-0.3494791985,
0.5030143261,
-0.3723198175,
0.965605855,
0.4741734862,
-0.0983539969,
-0.0477425158,
-0.9166871905,
0.4176855683,
0.3574550748,
-0.9591331482,
0.3007230163,
0.2895793319,
-0.0213425308,
0.2444092184,
0.4980184138,
-0.2135768384,
0.0929265246,
0.0863660201,
0.0313842706,
-0.2368543148,
-0.415397048,
-0.0209557265,
0.1514990777,
-0.1825617701,
-0.2637174726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07232v1 | A Psycholinguistic Analysis of BERT's Representations of Compounds | 2023-02-14T18:23:15 | 2023-02-14T18:23:15 | Lars Buijtelaar, Sandro Pezzelle | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; J.5 | This work studies the semantic representations learned by BERT for compounds,
that is, expressions such as sunlight or bodyguard. We build on recent studies
that explore semantic information in Transformers at the word level and test
whether BERT aligns with human semantic intuitions when dealing with
expressions (e.g., sunlight) whose overall meaning depends -- to a various
extent -- on the semantics of the constituent words (sun, light). We leverage a
dataset that includes human judgments on two psycholinguistic measures of
compound semantic analysis: lexeme meaning dominance (LMD; quantifying the
weight of each constituent toward the compound meaning) and semantic
transparency (ST; evaluating the extent to which the compound meaning is
recoverable from the constituents' semantics). We show that BERT-based measures
moderately align with human intuitions, especially when using contextualized
representations, and that LMD is overall more predictable than ST. Contrary to
the results reported for 'standard' words, higher, more contextualized layers
are the best at representing compound meaning. These findings shed new light on
the abilities of BERT in dealing with fine-grained semantic phenomena.
Moreover, they can provide insights into how speakers represent compounds. | [
-0.2628540397,
-0.6541242003,
0.6748618484,
0.567845881,
-0.1631714553,
0.1338739842,
-0.6477455497,
-0.5766153336,
0.2305617183,
0.0566939153,
-0.5995759964,
-0.5479259491,
-0.5692019463,
-0.0031699534,
-0.2405035049,
0.9076750875,
-0.0535234846,
0.1855025589,
0.0808266178,
-0.0039806976,
-0.2470860779,
-0.5717371106,
-0.0421644226,
-0.5654451847,
1.1422436237,
-0.0132872779,
0.8602132797,
0.2793666422,
0.5103302002,
0.3230537772,
0.0151730124,
-0.3397240341,
-0.2968948185,
0.2320854664,
-0.3302982748,
-0.4318820536,
-0.0406711884,
0.1305195689,
0.5706111789,
1.1782335043,
0.0231133979,
-0.3517717421,
-0.1558480561,
0.3906607032,
-0.4777579606,
0.4093668759,
-0.7763820291,
0.0815402269,
-0.0653950572,
-0.1371871829,
-0.4305279255,
0.0263057537,
0.596558094,
-0.6278406382,
0.2520138621,
0.378901571,
1.1753829718,
-0.0786988288,
-0.3053973317,
-0.2865382731,
-0.6543578506,
1.14498353,
-0.3378777802,
0.3939392269,
0.2702443898,
0.3410879374,
-0.1427964568,
-0.4606468678,
-0.6112732887,
-0.4779274762,
-0.4650166631,
0.3217226863,
-0.0521324873,
0.3670553267,
-0.0743411407,
0.3549981415,
-0.210452646,
-0.0843266621,
-0.2548912168,
-0.4444035292,
0.5687987804,
-0.0646055564,
0.4079569876,
-0.5637730956,
-0.9600149989,
-0.3850426376,
-0.4544505775,
-0.053848926,
0.3444413245,
0.5495031476,
0.0768235847,
0.648170948,
0.4776993096,
0.3685730994,
-0.3082633317,
0.0651102513,
0.159805283,
-0.3625404537,
-0.3800264895,
0.4960647821,
0.4369558394,
0.3709184229,
0.1243748888,
-0.4965053201,
-0.1751347929,
0.3193585873,
0.1886483431,
-0.5405347943,
-0.4956044555,
0.1216117665,
-0.313749969,
0.0132719297,
0.4503675401,
-0.3585187197,
-0.3421036005,
-0.6144824624,
0.4722918868,
-0.7574890852,
-0.2820769548,
0.1920061111,
-0.6681729555,
0.6172063351,
0.0882938579,
-1.1960934401,
0.7242743969,
0.7935523987,
0.4487893283,
-0.2124255747,
-0.2251105458,
-0.0198607184,
0.407961607,
-0.4133932889,
0.6466439962,
-0.4379556477,
-0.4289817214,
-0.0552112684,
0.1167549938,
-0.2404448986,
-0.449863404,
0.6015407443,
-0.4061389565,
0.224267751,
-0.79841429,
-0.7241999507,
-0.1723079681,
-0.0147798192,
-0.3246996999,
0.7819322944,
0.270726651,
-0.7060741186,
0.7297391891,
-0.4416901767,
-0.4062991738,
0.1209180504,
-0.4394954741,
0.0067805848,
0.3611973226,
-0.0221004374,
0.3027882278,
0.1480565965,
0.0154845435,
-0.0422555059,
-0.1095272154,
0.5947204232,
-0.0846942365,
0.8568866253,
-0.0101015568,
-0.2649319768,
0.1034990624,
-0.3312754035,
-0.0043377895,
-0.0794635117,
-0.2511616349,
-0.52278018,
0.1151160151,
0.329093039,
-0.1259221435,
0.373197794,
-1.0961658955,
-0.1157081872,
-0.5633507371,
0.1867495626,
1.1953103542,
-0.0316946618,
0.3722852468,
-0.2449205667,
0.0458005033,
0.0501982011,
-0.1132410318,
0.0153623912,
-0.597147882,
-0.7796239257,
-0.4878540635,
0.305844903,
0.3941192031,
-0.1949510276,
0.8101308942,
-0.2660473287,
-0.2081728727,
-0.3697390854,
0.4570366442,
0.3905320764,
0.2394572794,
0.1852859408,
-0.3633958697,
-0.5250666738,
-1.3526558876,
-0.4844802022,
-0.2465382069,
-0.2940617502,
0.5073315501,
0.3786247373,
-0.324398011,
1.1472835541,
-0.6155921817,
-0.3914268911,
-0.3067887127,
0.6259649992,
0.1833620518,
0.3485598862,
0.76954633,
-0.8709717393,
-0.375731945,
0.2524544895,
-0.4541475773,
-0.0775470585,
-0.1228943989,
-0.4684406817,
0.0497132093,
0.1603226364,
-0.5104488134,
0.1789617389,
0.2338645011,
-0.5479366779,
0.4800849855,
-0.4057037532,
-0.2984424233,
-0.5658001304,
-0.1896367073,
-0.0546328612,
-0.0365882628,
-0.5740388632,
-0.0711423755,
-0.1331742555,
0.1667676568,
-0.4488396347,
0.3543409109,
-0.395526439,
-0.3763917983,
0.1168240532,
0.3182529211,
0.0061790217,
0.6132273078,
0.0324538127,
0.7590161562,
0.7386991382,
-0.6142383814,
0.7869896889,
0.0197738502,
-0.4479092062,
0.4503233433,
-0.6127655506,
-0.1291551292,
-0.2438444942,
-0.0458783135,
-1.0777857304,
-0.4857364893,
-0.1479523331,
-0.3363419175,
0.2921808064,
0.5227158666,
-1.0047390461,
-0.0391776562,
-0.3099582493,
0.194139868,
0.4767326713,
-0.3896506727,
0.6250138879,
0.226304099,
0.0734461471,
-0.0652957633,
-0.9667891264,
0.1348436028,
-0.2755352557,
-0.7424994707,
0.7964074016,
0.1252814978,
-0.6548446417,
0.1512077153,
-0.2267318368,
-0.1494896859,
0.0235086493,
0.0615574457,
0.2468859404,
-0.0672596768,
0.3662138879,
-0.0301227123,
-0.100039199,
0.4140248001,
-0.1460612416,
0.5005164146,
-0.5120472908,
-0.1873804182,
-0.1714961678,
0.3827338517,
0.1891215146,
0.2893876135,
0.6654148698,
0.729393661,
-0.1971600205,
-0.0550359078,
-0.2255448997,
-0.2652063668,
-0.4620549977,
-0.0023445548,
-0.2288532108,
-0.4008415341,
0.7461754084,
0.2668713629,
-0.3055627644,
0.4410175383,
0.6711662412,
-0.5474972725,
0.9808104038,
0.5621554255,
0.0358065218,
0.5195395947,
-0.2411508858,
0.3088304996,
-0.8756393194,
-0.502538085,
-0.0950607955,
-0.4557173252,
-0.6516395807,
-0.198120296,
0.4813640416,
-0.2077547312,
-0.1687173098,
0.6674301624,
-0.3448484242,
0.360484153,
0.6414667368,
0.2409844697,
-0.0882183537,
0.0469707921,
-0.2221585363,
-0.2618223727,
-0.2801338136,
-0.4018152058,
0.7259276509,
0.4301638305,
0.747209549,
0.4350806475,
0.5404298902,
0.3083845675,
0.0803998113,
-0.8253922462,
0.6953986287,
-0.1116453707,
-1.0145505667,
0.0267939363,
-0.1602778137,
-1.0111067295,
0.3246099055,
-0.0393761583,
-1.1286990643,
0.434081614,
-0.4778307676,
-0.2945877314,
0.0232685748,
-1.0312459469,
0.7506552339,
-0.600184679,
-0.2463472188,
-0.4152903557,
-0.8754001856,
0.2168012857,
0.1741218865,
-0.1970981359,
-0.2737682462,
-0.2477305681,
0.7094866633,
-0.4078540802,
0.8917121887,
-0.1991712898,
-0.4288628101,
0.0429893397,
-0.0563957579,
-0.1220561638,
-0.330008328,
0.071124278,
-0.1785930395,
0.2135498375,
-0.7759861946,
-0.8578131199,
0.6638266444,
-0.7187952995,
-0.4485214949,
-0.6432415843,
-0.7299688458,
-0.3001393378,
0.0671775714,
0.0705415159,
0.2704036236,
-0.2096060067,
0.3134822845,
0.5658227205,
-0.4113169312,
0.2353248596,
0.1860950887,
-0.4214464426,
-0.1714452356,
0.9509434104,
0.0435389727,
0.4911283553,
0.4503182173,
0.3789912164,
-0.325227648,
-0.070168592,
0.0680960938,
0.2130797058,
-0.8017318845,
0.0992263854,
-0.1902248263,
-0.2096707225,
-0.2152215242,
-0.2875776589,
0.1569436193,
-0.4602122009,
0.2506495714,
-0.327783525,
0.5836308599,
0.5547612906,
-0.0064992248,
0.4807222486,
-0.4428867102,
0.3546817601,
0.5310775042,
0.3282879889,
-0.381148994,
0.1491822302,
-0.0663130283,
-0.1176862493,
-0.1987207085,
-0.9739174247,
0.1029519588,
0.448341608,
0.6575721502,
0.7877246737,
0.0385555737,
0.5505271554,
-0.1020052284,
0.9783994555,
0.238227278,
-1.1022194624,
0.5468652248,
-0.5546306968,
-0.0848592743,
0.5654022694,
0.0119505813,
-0.4101184011,
-0.5505822897,
-0.7754039168,
-0.8780477643,
0.6083292365,
0.6743541956,
0.5765461922,
-0.1313490123,
-0.0514245592,
0.095388867,
0.3669269085,
-0.7295832634,
-0.2784876525,
-0.1990344524,
-0.1636134535,
0.073037535,
-0.1682671607,
-0.4067548513,
-0.5395678878,
0.2713193595,
0.2978897691,
0.6607362032,
0.3592998683,
-0.0429484844,
0.0591779165,
0.4434837699,
0.4825793207,
0.5112578869,
-0.8308267593,
0.5814974904,
0.0443079881,
-0.324572295,
-0.2887043059,
0.1285200566,
0.2951042652,
0.2717834413,
0.7540583014,
0.5752635598,
0.4518492818,
-0.9352369905,
0.6158204675,
0.3323616982,
-0.0723266453,
-0.2523984015,
0.0555733517,
-0.2387719899,
-0.148281306,
0.3087086678,
-0.021468658,
0.1590945572,
-1.1959902048,
0.1782749891,
0.5468145609,
-0.3820976615,
-0.5290124416,
0.1361907274,
-0.0527391881,
0.1432278007,
0.4287031889,
-0.342551291,
-1.0077323914,
0.531191349,
0.3678841591,
1.034896493,
0.0763118714,
-0.0151268067,
-0.0539625362,
0.1349917799,
0.5823225379,
0.439625293,
-0.4755944014,
-0.9758791924,
-0.1197801158,
-0.5413962007,
-0.2377724499,
-0.3584228754,
-0.6299690604,
-0.0824748054,
-0.4915322065,
-0.1375557035,
0.1894295216,
0.0317477435,
-0.5771752,
-0.0357453898,
0.2426907569,
0.8647087216,
-0.8892628551,
0.8497216105,
0.5330338478,
-0.6567439437,
-0.6569225192,
0.1179193705,
-0.2106812596,
-0.838447988,
1.316524744,
0.2269414514,
-0.3275882602,
-0.420997858,
-0.4783917665,
-0.554120183,
0.9487961531,
0.314607501,
-0.0002122216,
-0.1523669064,
0.3356648386,
0.8158783317,
-0.3861274421,
-0.0997142792,
0.8917482495,
1.0106110573,
0.0589396842,
-0.759945631,
-0.09828417,
-0.1228006631,
0.2067881078,
0.0940632895,
-0.1236818284,
0.8674039841,
0.0908713639,
-0.6188080311,
0.2601629496,
0.625451386,
-0.0886981264,
0.1828035265,
0.5526258349,
0.3936412334,
0.5297880173,
-0.3530931175,
1.3149539232,
-0.3991217613,
0.2989214659,
0.6274081469,
-0.1673818082,
0.5912050009,
0.7874290943,
-0.4376063049,
0.9822154641,
0.4873064756,
-0.0984763801,
0.8288633823,
0.4838886261,
-0.4630335271,
-0.1587759256,
-0.4515582919,
-0.0617416799,
0.4781240225,
0.5550063848,
-0.5275953412,
-0.4126615822,
0.1036851332,
-0.121351622,
0.1788768917,
-0.194589138,
0.9404423833,
0.2689452767,
-0.4440211356,
0.4291355908,
-0.1351430118,
0.2787703872,
-0.742405951,
0.1698780805,
0.2377334833,
0.4129657745,
-0.2040572464,
-1.0397180319,
0.4167361557,
-0.2883249521,
0.0787704885,
-0.546769917,
0.5753507614,
-0.4241394401,
-0.5956761241,
0.6628451347,
0.1027867496,
0.3181079626,
0.2636207044,
-0.5882891417,
-0.0229047425,
-0.4271326065,
0.1855370998,
-0.0285805035,
0.5802456141,
0.2549435496,
0.3366059661,
0.385453999,
0.3509503603,
0.3306952417,
0.2365561426,
0.9104096293,
-0.6981117129,
-0.2643562853,
-0.6045295,
0.3872680664,
-0.2219739258,
-0.0393766575,
1.0321530104,
0.5804878473,
0.683765471,
-0.072701849,
0.5537806749,
-0.0763140544,
0.2849444747,
-0.6265932918,
0.2593331039,
-0.2431067526,
0.2248103768,
-0.4263401031,
-0.9602638483,
-0.3195445836,
0.6933860183,
-0.5386247039,
-0.0425441675,
0.7433276772,
0.5636159778,
-0.2004572004,
0.0094468417,
0.1418047845,
0.3729982078,
0.3021738827,
0.4258851707,
0.9621887207,
-0.2893345654,
0.0403297618,
-0.2967529297,
0.0116505157,
-0.2123099864,
-0.7417407036,
-0.7590245605,
-0.6962979436,
0.0774708539,
-0.1209653094,
-0.1073662117,
1.082583189,
0.731081605,
-0.8084314466,
-0.3584393859,
-0.4781252742,
0.0750093535,
-0.3296354413,
-0.2807914615,
0.6144414544,
-0.7250378132,
-0.6607527733,
0.339055568,
0.2133509368,
0.0838939771,
-0.6396833062,
-0.1329288334,
0.0724749193,
0.398191303,
0.7108308673,
-0.0351781324,
-1.1992021799,
-0.6178964376,
0.0108191688,
-0.0556549244,
0.1493663341,
1.0078077316,
-0.745149076,
0.7331041098,
0.6348298788,
0.4343237281,
0.2178834379,
0.1261305809,
0.8349629641,
-1.182951808,
0.3086759448,
0.3389451504,
0.5987805724,
0.4397144914,
-0.2067222893,
0.1028753296,
0.0725601166,
-0.0863325298,
-0.7012158632,
0.7673652172,
-1.4671504498,
-0.4437272549,
1.0753524303,
-0.0505702831,
-0.4854469895,
-0.0206565931,
-0.4362943769,
-0.0708927661,
-0.5673827529,
0.6437144876,
1.014811635,
-0.3768650591,
-0.0623360276,
-0.2595549524,
0.4953228831,
0.559386611,
-0.4348073304,
0.3086209595,
0.2234547138,
-0.1751978695,
0.7034875154,
0.0010305964,
-0.0475520678,
-0.0038713019,
-0.2047335058,
-0.2802947164,
0.4150897264,
-0.2728855908,
0.0302270278,
-0.2072429508,
0.0196793433,
-0.2902306318
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07189v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07189v4 | Reveal the Unknown: Out-of-Knowledge-Base Mention Discovery with Entity Linking | 2023-02-14T17:00:06 | 2023-09-01T20:32:05 | Hang Dong, Jiaoyan Chen, Yuan He, Yinan Liu, Ian Horrocks | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Discovering entity mentions that are out of a Knowledge Base (KB) from texts
plays a critical role in KB maintenance, but has not yet been fully explored.
The current methods are mostly limited to the simple threshold-based approach
and feature-based classification, and the datasets for evaluation are
relatively rare. We propose BLINKout, a new BERT-based Entity Linking (EL)
method which can identify mentions that do not have corresponding KB entities
by matching them to a special NIL entity. To better utilize BERT, we propose
new techniques including NIL entity representation and classification, with
synonym enhancement. We also apply KB Pruning and Versioning strategies to
automatically construct out-of-KB datasets from common in-KB EL datasets.
Results on five datasets of clinical notes, biomedical publications, and
Wikipedia articles in various domains show the advantages of BLINKout over
existing methods to identify out-of-KB mentions for the medical ontologies,
UMLS, SNOMED CT, and the general KB, WikiData. | [
-0.5980815291,
-0.5012507439,
0.7875723243,
-0.0499513373,
-0.0657356679,
0.0871863812,
-0.2461954206,
-0.8034386039,
0.6254576445,
0.4908879399,
-0.6407539845,
-0.4236361682,
-0.4708908796,
-0.136065051,
-0.7876569033,
1.3354582787,
-0.0522303469,
-0.0897955224,
-0.1626825482,
-0.1569024175,
-0.2307831794,
-0.0384947285,
-0.2491336167,
-0.2576805651,
0.5368283987,
0.4659517407,
0.3876545131,
0.2669242322,
0.7179218531,
0.076937288,
-0.0910672694,
0.3280289471,
-0.3415084779,
-0.1282175928,
-0.0468352139,
-0.2296031117,
-0.5150262117,
-0.3845075667,
0.6831849217,
1.0456417799,
0.2726394236,
0.1996888518,
-0.0892619193,
0.905715704,
-0.652325809,
0.2453872561,
-0.7194443941,
-0.0147924274,
-0.6058577299,
-0.0558717474,
-0.6115607619,
-0.5274649262,
0.693908155,
-0.7465720773,
0.4087805152,
0.3712304235,
1.1189782619,
0.2448945493,
-0.2723421454,
-0.4294070601,
-0.5789043307,
0.5451470613,
-0.6505673528,
0.4163057506,
0.2362973541,
0.2272441834,
-0.4125638902,
-0.6446915865,
-0.5297836661,
-0.3088042736,
-0.1990732998,
0.1026932597,
-0.3036055863,
-0.0039485069,
0.1640879065,
0.1994802356,
-0.2256394774,
-0.2298587263,
-0.2456780821,
-0.1964246929,
0.2075475305,
-0.4742740095,
0.3994612992,
-0.4154806733,
-0.7580770254,
0.4077090323,
-1.4109642506,
-0.4510947168,
0.0097494647,
0.1863980442,
0.3478756547,
0.5530540347,
0.0845749751,
0.3952431679,
0.1843070686,
0.2675924897,
0.3292027712,
-0.0722989589,
-0.029191874,
0.382530272,
0.427829057,
0.5258966684,
-0.1357727647,
-0.7234410048,
0.0174952727,
-0.4814005196,
0.2071088403,
-0.2720795274,
-0.6381839514,
0.1053583696,
-0.5145232081,
0.0191087592,
0.0539121479,
-0.6310092807,
-0.6152254939,
0.3489968777,
0.9893478155,
-0.7661590576,
-0.4579214752,
-0.5011771321,
-0.4587138593,
-0.3603133261,
0.390316844,
-0.6178566217,
0.142566219,
0.2775906026,
0.5834249258,
-0.0387526639,
0.0418219492,
-0.1773303151,
0.4527289569,
-0.3416469097,
0.6819579005,
-0.1674289256,
-0.2279234231,
0.1197589487,
-0.0294353738,
0.0267017018,
-0.843744278,
0.2492922097,
-0.7037192583,
-0.0713283718,
-0.6275187731,
-0.9244673252,
-0.6072847247,
0.0014644705,
-0.9093036652,
1.2586419582,
0.3167733848,
-0.8866317272,
0.7175245881,
-0.803479135,
-0.2905643582,
0.5770455003,
-0.1445907056,
-0.2364145666,
0.1960307062,
-0.001396216,
0.4369153678,
-0.1335727721,
0.2133972198,
-0.2615100741,
-0.4265373647,
0.0918677822,
0.3870044351,
0.7638162374,
-0.1121922061,
-0.6185261011,
-0.3600187004,
-0.7397713065,
-0.0106952135,
-0.1267281175,
-0.3067391217,
-0.8661283851,
0.2415789366,
-0.2028461248,
-0.0316329822,
0.2226235718,
-0.6463581324,
0.0934035853,
-0.6759895682,
0.3167906404,
0.332133621,
0.4724049568,
0.4774331152,
-0.3999812603,
-0.0407933667,
0.3508986831,
0.2385453582,
-0.2354420424,
-0.9170041084,
-1.2760665417,
-0.3023616672,
0.5193675756,
0.1655822396,
-0.9414430857,
0.8201182485,
-0.4153443277,
-0.4390364885,
-0.8790287375,
0.034653455,
0.4755186141,
0.9684491754,
0.7341054082,
-0.0956302807,
-0.6207675934,
-0.996945262,
-0.1651524752,
-0.4661603868,
0.0084319683,
0.4547338784,
0.5759255886,
-0.3073098958,
1.1619492769,
-0.2934874594,
-0.4260876775,
-0.1220769212,
0.2818305492,
0.0245815236,
0.1531178653,
0.2877469659,
-0.6850361824,
-0.507353127,
0.0511024408,
-0.8405293822,
0.3002997041,
-0.12720716,
-0.0488573164,
0.157269448,
0.6574554443,
-0.4183293581,
0.3541993201,
0.1819947958,
0.1547551155,
0.2269951701,
-0.0638133064,
-0.0150081916,
-0.8677189946,
0.2288400531,
-0.2433326244,
0.0117692798,
-0.6644592285,
-0.3114744127,
0.5179832578,
0.1562108248,
-0.3299325407,
0.5233386755,
-0.8748965263,
0.1040030867,
0.1879928261,
0.4194310308,
-0.1709520817,
0.252559334,
0.0639317408,
0.2746754587,
0.6458630562,
-0.6378233433,
0.1431945413,
0.4607277215,
-0.4274060726,
0.1308625042,
-0.0567474999,
-0.1471053362,
-0.1550100744,
-0.0042861011,
-0.9971004725,
-0.2191548198,
0.2737033367,
-0.6644378901,
0.4417083859,
-0.2693869174,
-0.6005341411,
-0.4556471705,
-0.5756713748,
0.0213249587,
0.4777508974,
-0.8779007792,
0.3391844928,
0.6915822029,
-0.011804577,
-0.449234724,
-0.6383430362,
0.2173102647,
0.0909260437,
-0.5289130211,
0.4378564656,
-0.0131616946,
0.0078033539,
0.3413374424,
-0.2299773246,
-0.3285505176,
-0.093747519,
0.5082324147,
0.4767663181,
-0.2873984873,
0.8099300861,
0.1852032095,
0.2689886391,
0.2746779323,
-0.0230676923,
0.0955836251,
0.092623055,
-0.3029278815,
0.1467615664,
0.5260490775,
0.1210494936,
0.3032384515,
0.6102198958,
0.428178817,
-0.662084341,
-0.2784069777,
-0.8343264461,
-0.4396685362,
-0.4320670068,
0.4063519239,
0.273326695,
-0.5020499229,
0.3787987828,
-0.4192276895,
-0.1124196723,
0.5768045187,
0.2722114027,
-0.5710165501,
0.524987936,
1.0937690735,
0.0709367469,
0.2888640761,
-0.0944423676,
0.6148129106,
-0.9222105742,
-0.464707315,
-0.1332619935,
-0.0727000386,
-0.5805386305,
-0.1177569777,
0.6123107076,
0.2908169925,
0.2989280224,
0.804168582,
-0.5976332426,
0.2008620948,
0.7828094363,
0.4641906321,
0.2675490081,
-0.2143940181,
-0.1506315172,
-0.1647954583,
-0.7282780409,
-0.1798896343,
1.2502673864,
0.1221437454,
0.2987494171,
0.0684287772,
1.1591507196,
0.3633054197,
0.9075880051,
-0.686637044,
0.6217252016,
0.2185191661,
-1.1921490431,
-0.3251348734,
-0.1631748378,
-0.6224566698,
-0.4516830444,
-0.4291415811,
-0.7563302517,
0.3798796833,
0.3432018757,
-0.4228337109,
0.3641649783,
-0.9507620335,
0.5326259732,
0.1435009837,
0.3772681653,
0.2115329802,
-1.016507864,
0.5489808917,
-0.3268765509,
0.1288762689,
-0.0065341732,
-0.0247560684,
0.9785237908,
-0.5422371626,
0.6889954805,
-0.1313387156,
-0.0404562503,
0.4095696509,
-0.1574298888,
0.5714185834,
-0.1206380129,
0.3407011032,
0.3269636035,
-0.331841588,
-0.0267620832,
-0.4878878295,
0.7401192784,
-0.269233346,
-0.098445043,
-0.1144356951,
-0.2899196744,
-0.7342322469,
0.3738317788,
0.7726578712,
0.1877528578,
-0.0398458838,
0.0352080576,
1.0908067226,
-0.0952321291,
0.6567751169,
0.6011004448,
0.084017463,
-0.3509939909,
1.0275768042,
0.2228764892,
-0.1540148258,
0.7104150653,
-0.2302568853,
-0.423684299,
-0.4572421908,
-0.4888831079,
0.3025336266,
-0.8902196884,
-0.3941879272,
-0.6459288597,
-0.2566703856,
-0.4077964723,
-0.076332882,
-0.1408611536,
-0.3174980581,
-0.1941637993,
0.0214237627,
0.5007566214,
0.8229217529,
0.0438506417,
0.190004006,
-1.0736554861,
0.0377052128,
-0.0944983438,
0.3873648942,
0.2629996836,
-0.2180241644,
-0.5707885623,
-0.4954637587,
0.0007576999,
-1.3182463646,
0.0612532906,
0.2392899245,
0.7111021876,
0.7772870064,
0.4256975055,
0.6273022294,
-0.6323106885,
0.5264152288,
0.6443790793,
-0.8609910607,
0.6833959222,
-0.2682730556,
-0.4308080971,
0.4342934787,
0.7676217556,
-0.3975185752,
-0.5772648454,
-0.9572535753,
-1.4178540707,
0.359072715,
0.1385742128,
-0.4660376608,
-0.4705199897,
0.2475983948,
0.1165444255,
0.4890784621,
-0.6068813205,
-0.6610482931,
0.3286925554,
-0.2018787861,
0.3057501018,
-0.3696389794,
-0.2667238116,
0.1066665202,
0.8470627666,
0.1278371364,
0.4513831735,
0.3846550882,
-0.6151269078,
-0.2359095365,
0.1422533095,
0.1475446224,
0.5103209019,
-0.3698250949,
0.0281881448,
0.1923366934,
-0.6967043877,
-0.3123165667,
0.0305232629,
-0.5638171434,
0.6297720075,
0.4561180472,
0.1887223274,
0.8466815352,
-0.7173804045,
0.6736249924,
0.5482496619,
-0.0697146729,
-0.3043529391,
-0.0952598974,
0.2334769219,
0.1508158743,
0.5891065598,
0.1272535771,
0.4164582491,
-0.3836165667,
0.4463161826,
0.2626644075,
-0.6368783712,
-0.2159034461,
0.5225445628,
0.3911687434,
0.2079399228,
0.5126048923,
-0.2298559397,
-0.1930110455,
0.3269349039,
0.2508876622,
0.8124166131,
0.2664728463,
0.2062607408,
0.1866233796,
0.4258891642,
0.0307176057,
0.0614048541,
-0.2175544798,
-0.3440663218,
-0.3028605282,
-0.198589623,
-0.5565654039,
0.0765826479,
-1.0496900082,
0.1775388569,
-0.3210487366,
-0.3794769943,
0.4135888219,
0.0624023005,
-0.3676252961,
0.2154702246,
0.0153033184,
0.9847488999,
-0.6223839521,
0.7904427648,
0.8911020756,
-0.6804505587,
-0.5466334224,
0.1596337855,
-0.0531739295,
-0.837020874,
0.8456788063,
-0.1248079017,
0.1541322768,
0.1072558612,
-0.5019734502,
-0.6991065145,
0.8574068546,
0.286090076,
-0.7313739061,
-0.2013117522,
-0.2707900405,
0.2724956274,
0.1375156939,
0.1700989306,
0.267380327,
0.6607518792,
-0.2465249598,
-0.747236371,
0.2709822655,
-0.011731538,
-0.3013104498,
0.7899030447,
-0.437694788,
0.590267539,
-0.6346862912,
-0.1116737053,
0.0760611594,
0.5812601447,
-0.2317873687,
0.2907310426,
0.4519298375,
0.481739223,
0.9625725746,
-0.2823572457,
0.3725767136,
-0.1324332803,
0.416977495,
0.9918214679,
-0.2873758078,
0.9056060314,
0.6825431585,
-0.0492495857,
0.5114048123,
0.4388022125,
-0.2257586122,
0.7354452014,
-0.0230121296,
-0.5439760089,
-0.1137600616,
0.1355201006,
-0.4368571043,
-0.3050408065,
0.2721554041,
-0.5181268454,
-0.5345811248,
-0.051287584,
0.1971411258,
-0.3157465458,
-0.2803388834,
0.9093159437,
-0.0861752853,
-0.5714964271,
0.2992113829,
-0.4847093523,
0.4321546257,
-0.4999066591,
-0.2568854988,
-0.157435298,
0.2100161165,
-0.2799750865,
-0.4017637968,
-0.0645616502,
-0.2584788203,
-0.7524474859,
0.1656869501,
0.708012104,
-0.5947258472,
-0.047080759,
0.4702921808,
0.5417457223,
0.3814376295,
-0.0908419117,
-0.37256217,
-0.4040718377,
-0.0899088383,
0.1240815297,
0.4215030968,
0.69428128,
-0.137724638,
0.6553052664,
0.4169749916,
0.3293125331,
0.3220023215,
-0.1199600622,
1.0730485916,
-0.873478055,
-0.1752037406,
-0.4479956627,
0.2703518867,
-0.2865532339,
-0.4394721091,
1.0120027065,
0.6372437477,
0.6420220137,
-0.2216687649,
0.8346732855,
-0.2036763877,
1.0603773594,
-0.2577675581,
1.0412629843,
-0.5665223002,
0.0922636464,
-0.5057778358,
-0.3554003537,
-0.2076817006,
0.2365934551,
0.1806910932,
-0.0868508518,
1.0934154987,
0.5084593892,
0.3272334039,
-0.1819247603,
0.3949671686,
0.305216521,
-0.0705788136,
0.3463892639,
0.5483387709,
-0.5541703105,
0.8947119713,
-0.1501055211,
-0.3796255291,
-0.806255579,
-1.0323556662,
-0.9116922021,
-0.7611153126,
-0.677973628,
-0.3937348723,
0.3853557706,
0.3696580827,
0.867826581,
-1.0626571178,
0.6102976203,
0.0445521176,
0.2519809306,
-0.158069551,
-0.229157567,
0.6063190699,
-0.4748364687,
-0.2489500344,
0.530528605,
0.6526361704,
-0.0314595029,
-0.152084589,
0.4014862478,
-0.2270105779,
-0.065700002,
0.2781304419,
0.4900953174,
-0.6812316775,
-0.2788754106,
0.1304428279,
0.1498070061,
-0.0607221276,
0.7626854777,
-0.7730863094,
0.4937606156,
0.1487470716,
0.4476037621,
0.2710565627,
-0.2906621397,
0.181708321,
-1.1731318235,
-0.2562288046,
0.4527078271,
0.4281323552,
0.1392150819,
-0.3179816306,
0.2329424322,
0.2669994533,
-0.3316418231,
-1.0338813066,
-0.0791400075,
-1.0164397955,
-0.0378370322,
0.7626391053,
-0.3417135775,
-0.5309807062,
-0.4768707156,
0.095247604,
0.1623683125,
-0.5330981016,
0.9574032426,
0.653524518,
-0.3165661693,
0.0800952017,
-0.5026051998,
0.8644551039,
0.2071996629,
-0.734951973,
0.0864187181,
0.293958813,
0.4550978243,
0.4707161486,
0.7171100378,
-0.2596977353,
0.3751704395,
0.0894399211,
0.4729884863,
0.1313318014,
-0.3917104602,
0.3683922589,
0.0077759181,
-0.0306755435,
-0.344190985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07159v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07159v1 | A Friendly Face: Do Text-to-Image Systems Rely on Stereotypes when the Input is Under-Specified? | 2023-02-14T16:11:06 | 2023-02-14T16:11:06 | Kathleen C. Fraser, Svetlana Kiritchenko, Isar Nejadgholi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL | As text-to-image systems continue to grow in popularity with the general
public, questions have arisen about bias and diversity in the generated images.
Here, we investigate properties of images generated in response to prompts
which are visually under-specified, but contain salient social attributes
(e.g., 'a portrait of a threatening person' versus 'a portrait of a friendly
person'). Grounding our work in social cognition theory, we find that in many
cases, images contain similar demographic biases to those reported in the
stereotype literature. However, trends are inconsistent across different models
and further investigation is warranted. | [
-0.7832096219,
-0.3790884018,
0.7749817371,
0.4809468389,
-0.2909678817,
-0.3069069982,
-0.0524060652,
-0.9478275776,
0.5693859458,
0.4264814556,
-0.5412940383,
-0.2892889082,
-0.8650892377,
0.5407545567,
-0.1880249083,
0.9539395571,
0.4202757776,
-0.0040620756,
-0.5242128372,
-0.3918361068,
-0.3504948318,
-0.5853898525,
-0.6405115724,
-0.1429895312,
0.686789155,
0.2055265009,
1.2026818991,
0.1624771506,
0.5499404669,
0.2909064293,
0.0454489477,
0.0010417473,
-0.2901711166,
0.3881766796,
-0.2689372897,
-0.2729376256,
0.1162634119,
0.1961368769,
0.4932057858,
0.6360714436,
0.6189136505,
0.1624389142,
0.0670559257,
0.6991336942,
-0.5828070641,
0.2143019885,
-0.5333417654,
0.0746124759,
-0.1664161384,
0.1759039164,
-0.558120966,
-0.6214141846,
0.3116778433,
-0.6198153496,
0.1477683783,
0.1038843691,
0.8402852416,
-0.0783297494,
-0.5503624082,
-0.4967412055,
-0.6648907661,
0.6816335917,
0.1752162129,
0.0605587773,
0.2743128836,
0.3285973668,
0.0849602073,
-0.3229296505,
-0.377997458,
-0.0208752491,
-0.4408077896,
-0.1654933691,
-0.4358055294,
0.0440306403,
0.5105309486,
0.0047247275,
-0.2263774425,
-0.2801376283,
-0.413366884,
-0.1832732707,
0.8056637645,
0.0013401485,
0.5283660889,
-0.4025526047,
-0.3008168936,
-0.1135498881,
-0.4052098989,
0.1925217211,
0.2982079983,
0.2446965128,
-0.2791824639,
0.5361288786,
-0.2651362121,
0.2619807124,
0.3545049727,
0.2164544016,
0.3280415237,
0.0332947634,
0.0939681977,
-0.0439523533,
0.9165380597,
1.091835618,
0.9880124331,
0.0330955908,
-0.3873221874,
0.429725945,
-0.0299277026,
-0.7011614442,
-0.1582331359,
-0.302590698,
-0.671611011,
-0.5330530405,
0.241281867,
-0.8754005432,
-0.8356933594,
0.1571253985,
0.2416179627,
-0.2160482407,
-0.0099590002,
-0.3293222189,
-0.5323511362,
0.0220286176,
0.6412364841,
-0.8167127371,
0.2820453644,
-0.0298566278,
0.7491878867,
-0.1282558292,
0.2380303591,
-0.240208745,
-0.0774696097,
-0.3357937038,
1.1072187424,
-0.7750239372,
-0.8251027465,
0.1426390111,
0.1488309354,
0.2953695357,
-0.5069845319,
0.0113442913,
-0.4705305696,
0.3062466681,
-0.8337706327,
0.1678615808,
0.224382475,
0.0397919416,
-0.7255204916,
1.0570569038,
0.0628757849,
-0.9818027616,
0.5677606463,
-0.3672788441,
-0.467489332,
-0.0689556748,
-0.7022396922,
-0.1635662317,
0.2301888168,
0.0630120933,
0.3203003407,
-0.0978270322,
-0.0331598595,
-0.5913951993,
-0.5756095052,
0.5547769666,
-0.1948164105,
0.9937118888,
0.4743793905,
-0.0995526016,
-0.1563411504,
-0.6679949164,
-0.306289196,
0.4218877852,
-0.1326649338,
-0.7627133131,
-0.2048335671,
0.0057566264,
0.1792006493,
0.409160316,
-0.8411322236,
-0.033836998,
0.2451743335,
0.0741409659,
0.8306407928,
0.0740266144,
0.5110312104,
-0.4555431604,
0.2804302275,
0.1057531685,
0.2017453164,
-0.1734033823,
-0.7656242251,
-0.4481538832,
-0.1707999259,
-0.1677806973,
0.5393142104,
-0.8094353676,
-0.1218841597,
0.0282415655,
-0.1209694818,
-0.2923356593,
-0.1444425136,
0.4953308105,
0.131828621,
0.0558972843,
-0.8706907034,
-0.4477114379,
-1.0214194059,
-0.2714280188,
-0.4447370768,
-0.345007658,
0.8824603558,
0.1825572252,
-0.1731339842,
0.8646726012,
-0.578540206,
-0.0821959227,
0.2018621415,
-0.0161055867,
-0.1932597607,
0.3000069559,
1.2467381954,
-0.6772586703,
-0.5566721559,
-0.4745165706,
-0.8205892444,
-0.2706049979,
0.0029459447,
-0.1595614851,
0.2431305796,
0.4958204925,
-0.7151623964,
0.530577004,
0.1596154273,
-0.5295876861,
0.5191944838,
0.0593850128,
0.3612392843,
-0.8044954538,
-0.122792244,
0.7750919461,
-0.2434411347,
-0.3662946224,
-0.0910328701,
-0.2112524658,
-0.2674558461,
-0.311558038,
0.7022386789,
-0.4636161327,
-0.3670322895,
0.0385716408,
0.0173081122,
0.1411962509,
0.1708131284,
0.4108237028,
0.5997045636,
0.6289299726,
-0.5104650259,
0.3500036895,
0.3904764652,
-0.1533652097,
1.2018136978,
-0.6618199348,
0.4169545472,
-0.644849658,
0.2315318733,
-1.2162446976,
-0.5414459109,
0.3374897838,
-0.6271669269,
0.0259597544,
0.0337617733,
-0.2863015234,
-0.3192880452,
-0.3968493938,
0.5557229519,
0.7796539068,
-0.4163314998,
0.2866380513,
0.1601624787,
-0.1225847453,
-0.2206269354,
-0.6655918956,
-0.0325387791,
-0.2115898132,
-0.6141828299,
0.067400068,
0.1224101484,
-0.6519072056,
-0.071173504,
0.2606633306,
-0.097223036,
-0.3814301491,
0.5675858855,
0.2764292061,
0.0386556908,
0.1355413198,
-0.1168392971,
0.3462065756,
0.2789198756,
0.4035669565,
0.1181194037,
0.0789344013,
-0.0762685761,
-0.4504396617,
0.6534643769,
0.6253550053,
0.1745862067,
0.5391528606,
0.1489564776,
-0.2117762268,
0.1828760654,
-0.2099644393,
-0.2611020803,
-0.5202898979,
0.0193318855,
-0.3216226101,
-0.7084804773,
0.7854306102,
0.2215872854,
-0.1884215921,
0.4204790592,
0.1418868899,
-0.4868281484,
1.2046129704,
0.7381028533,
0.1700466126,
0.8265024424,
0.4690565765,
-0.1839625388,
-0.3413045406,
-0.5260927081,
-0.7769126892,
-0.2777721882,
-1.0481463671,
0.0129793491,
0.3520551324,
-0.6974701881,
-0.4518460631,
0.0141983377,
-0.6767336726,
0.3631848395,
0.6786168814,
0.5912439823,
0.1084425598,
0.1967797726,
0.0618553534,
-0.0911692083,
-0.3128050268,
-0.4812841415,
0.8767230511,
0.408185035,
0.9372392893,
-0.1776741892,
0.8786168098,
0.5493912697,
0.5731902122,
-0.4764923751,
0.9237644076,
-0.4875847101,
-0.893666923,
-0.0531388223,
-0.2000355572,
-0.7101704478,
-0.2008848935,
-0.6080831289,
-1.0717741251,
0.6745758653,
0.4388799667,
-0.362634778,
-0.0033208344,
-0.7911255956,
0.3653618097,
0.0948183686,
-0.2465091944,
0.2249643356,
-0.974093616,
0.3114955425,
0.2381153554,
0.1667478681,
-0.175842613,
0.362745136,
0.7248896956,
-0.1710003614,
1.1438575983,
-0.3630593121,
0.214105159,
0.4565401673,
0.1124788821,
0.1409663856,
-0.1665405035,
-0.0699901506,
0.1455916911,
0.1755867898,
-0.613269031,
-0.7115271688,
0.3744358122,
-0.9920871258,
-0.5855409503,
-0.3094034791,
-0.390840143,
-0.2288156003,
0.0326864347,
0.4434072673,
0.3898974359,
-0.4112636745,
0.083449237,
0.8231381774,
-0.6043564677,
0.0617143475,
-0.1586795896,
-0.5042970777,
-0.150319472,
0.7223523259,
-0.0910536647,
0.6278404593,
-0.1169608757,
-0.164738059,
-0.0807943866,
0.0441859141,
-0.2820801139,
0.2518902123,
-1.0467295647,
0.0259313732,
-0.4206691086,
-0.0805644616,
-0.5779387951,
-0.3833263218,
-0.1081991047,
-0.410102427,
-0.4278649688,
0.337400794,
0.644123435,
1.1975402832,
0.1193711534,
0.3464567661,
-0.4908029735,
0.4737126231,
0.6438627243,
0.6608644724,
-0.1676412076,
-0.3955261707,
0.2102906257,
-0.054295253,
-0.2301879376,
-1.1906219721,
-0.2468142211,
-0.0452896431,
0.2588261664,
0.6172158718,
0.2537038326,
-0.0550830178,
-0.2271159142,
0.8049288392,
0.5284258127,
-0.4135417044,
0.567550838,
-0.4172075689,
0.3373929858,
0.4668996632,
0.5798334479,
-0.5368711352,
-0.6555925608,
-0.6202838421,
-0.2361658067,
0.365601927,
0.1489350349,
0.5526695251,
-0.293351382,
0.3842953444,
0.0057800361,
0.1823204011,
-0.9054669738,
-0.4361411631,
-0.68848598,
-0.2785950303,
0.2222169787,
-0.4321713746,
-0.0899544135,
-0.0359884612,
0.0074015041,
-0.1731660217,
0.5011952519,
0.3306084275,
0.2216711044,
-0.2268143743,
0.215734005,
0.2324133366,
0.0252790898,
-0.2882191539,
0.2742548883,
-0.1591737866,
-0.6098760366,
0.1561555564,
-0.1723750383,
-0.6620482206,
0.2607182562,
-0.0541010164,
0.8215575218,
-0.0567268953,
-0.2214339375,
0.4132654369,
-0.1635375917,
-0.3734504282,
0.1571877897,
0.2195862681,
-0.2650817335,
0.3004841208,
0.5243284106,
0.3838684559,
0.1401588917,
-0.9527794719,
-0.0299059022,
0.9089673758,
-0.6083933115,
-0.4144837856,
0.5682441592,
0.6143034101,
-0.2879932821,
0.4823924601,
-0.2835220098,
-0.4447014928,
0.7421460152,
0.4497735798,
0.7529133558,
-0.0380523615,
0.5994730592,
0.3140596151,
0.4117211401,
0.1174193695,
0.3418507874,
0.0681228489,
-0.9846333861,
0.4634017944,
-0.4124463201,
-0.2886312902,
-0.0369280577,
-0.5114175677,
0.1360523552,
-0.7874700427,
-0.6425130367,
0.2579995692,
-0.2174889892,
-0.8593459129,
0.6610693932,
0.4152084887,
0.7596984506,
-1.2773367167,
0.398026675,
0.9759308696,
-0.4516386688,
-0.5475436449,
-0.0143676214,
0.0338958427,
-0.819139719,
0.8963683248,
0.3198241293,
-0.0814109817,
-0.2870845199,
-0.9755034447,
-0.6532691121,
0.4700832367,
0.398673147,
-0.1482468992,
-0.212515831,
0.1988112479,
0.3839493394,
-0.7228235006,
0.2006208003,
0.358537674,
0.3234575391,
0.3527266085,
-0.8552593589,
0.3271631896,
-0.352943182,
0.42328462,
-0.1590127498,
-0.7198975682,
0.6858110428,
-0.5736420155,
-0.2699649036,
0.0833047852,
0.4897592068,
0.3010769784,
0.6225304008,
0.6676241159,
0.0255388971,
0.3209778368,
-0.1291100532,
1.0609089136,
0.1538981795,
0.0739704445,
0.644860208,
-0.2340180725,
0.1983127892,
0.6576576233,
-0.3039859831,
0.7377619147,
0.8701829314,
-0.0301447865,
0.6578590274,
-0.2010926306,
-0.3615829647,
-0.1240995079,
-0.5335873961,
-0.2453340292,
0.2154646963,
0.3345085084,
-0.7204321623,
-0.177195847,
-0.1106680706,
-0.2732184529,
0.2586840987,
-0.4778030217,
0.7709563375,
0.1217107251,
-0.4877723753,
-0.0070627299,
-0.3942553997,
0.7826429605,
-0.0715512261,
0.0367014706,
-0.3584160507,
-0.4324175119,
-0.4603439271,
-1.0942283869,
0.0802232996,
-0.0172339231,
-0.3919272721,
-0.1388484091,
1.2835259438,
-0.1334202737,
-0.5292617679,
-0.0389720201,
0.2350166738,
0.3613063395,
0.1203056127,
-0.448251009,
0.1041132435,
0.1735204607,
-0.2549482882,
0.3399160802,
0.5452679992,
-0.3128762543,
0.3924665451,
0.0663548559,
-0.0571852289,
-0.0298525002,
0.0354930535,
0.7706400156,
-0.414349556,
-0.4565079212,
-0.6073702574,
0.3117234111,
-0.2899648845,
-0.1983139813,
0.4476071894,
0.0254387297,
0.6257561445,
-0.1523580104,
1.04804492,
-0.1111711487,
0.2771298885,
-0.1453190148,
0.6769599915,
-0.4455237091,
-0.139676556,
-0.7429458499,
-0.8614664674,
-0.1308270842,
0.6669942737,
-0.4930141866,
0.4401119053,
0.3708083928,
0.6848989725,
0.1290412396,
0.1614409238,
0.2587910891,
-0.400406301,
-0.1344007105,
0.3040078878,
0.8590142131,
-0.0499292985,
0.3386430144,
-0.1388139278,
-0.4156309366,
-0.2802350819,
-0.8055669665,
-0.9972732663,
-0.4955163896,
-0.3961428106,
-0.6114142537,
0.1115921661,
0.7515202165,
0.4570742548,
-0.4545409679,
0.0596634969,
0.3804125488,
0.111720264,
0.5379528403,
-0.1876990348,
-0.0917515755,
-0.0046406798,
-0.5039716363,
-0.8747867942,
0.1508280039,
0.58600384,
-0.3163799047,
-0.0698846281,
0.3653182685,
0.4949913919,
0.5298219323,
0.295617789,
-0.4055713713,
-0.6769989729,
0.1583539844,
-0.5651294589,
0.3544838727,
0.6362884641,
-0.5951539874,
0.3256255686,
0.2727205157,
0.0478331745,
0.1012081206,
0.154151246,
0.4786567092,
-0.9371496439,
0.4945704937,
-0.0907574892,
0.2066698819,
0.647087276,
-0.7240898609,
0.0264813453,
0.6725995541,
-0.2592175305,
-0.5667290688,
0.494446665,
-0.8364076018,
-0.234290272,
1.2060141563,
0.0334084705,
-0.2138950378,
0.1769127101,
-0.4381231964,
0.0079710716,
-0.8240175247,
0.9693587422,
0.8056951165,
-0.2320411056,
-0.4219345748,
-0.2305351049,
0.7179397345,
0.2459009588,
-0.6604970694,
-0.3684290051,
0.9013397098,
0.2187290192,
0.4434351027,
0.9187805057,
-0.0302621312,
0.4997851253,
-0.035650894,
0.0594893247,
0.5670903921,
-0.2534558773,
0.0047592036,
0.0443750024,
0.4005943239,
-0.2524387538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07139v1 | Modeling Complex Event Scenarios via Simple Entity-focused Questions | 2023-02-14T15:48:56 | 2023-02-14T15:48:56 | Mahnaz Koupaee, Greg Durrett, Nathanael Chambers, Niranjan Balasubramanian | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event scenarios are often complex and involve multiple event sequences
connected through different entity participants. Exploring such complex
scenarios requires an ability to branch through different sequences, something
that is difficult to achieve with standard event language modeling. To address
this, we propose a question-guided generation framework that models events in
complex scenarios as answers to questions about participants. At any step in
the generation process, the framework uses the previously generated events as
context, but generates the next event as an answer to one of three questions:
what else a participant did, what else happened to a participant, or what else
happened. The participants and the questions themselves can be sampled or be
provided as input from a user, allowing for controllable exploration. Our
empirical evaluation shows that this question-guided generation provides better
coverage of participants, diverse events within a domain, comparable
perplexities for modeling event sequences, and more effective control for
interactive schema generation. | [
-0.6913242936,
-1.0333505869,
0.925121367,
0.0026794593,
-0.0871219411,
-0.1169189289,
0.0061106295,
-0.5232478976,
0.0437676124,
0.7113451958,
-1.0550290346,
-0.460031271,
-0.029790232,
0.0594833456,
-0.4437562525,
1.2236452103,
-0.2579883337,
-0.3266751468,
-0.1733181924,
0.2089842111,
-0.2337583899,
-0.5457800031,
-0.8138723373,
-0.1334628463,
0.3824884295,
0.6542990804,
0.3057382405,
0.2132152021,
0.2778033614,
0.1402430385,
-0.0099438177,
0.3215175569,
-0.4459551275,
0.441264689,
-0.1615626365,
-0.625520587,
-0.2717363834,
-0.0901334807,
0.2824145854,
1.1192828417,
-0.2983588576,
0.240903005,
-0.0567261092,
-0.0418404229,
-0.4561522603,
-0.0264184196,
-0.5395824909,
0.1794712543,
-0.2248444408,
-0.482137233,
-0.4508664608,
-0.132292822,
0.2120198607,
-0.6498779058,
0.7062740922,
0.1923672855,
0.6652261615,
-0.1673303396,
-0.9043979645,
-0.3732976019,
-1.0769683123,
0.4765359461,
-0.2547558844,
-0.0460179225,
0.1553907543,
0.3670281768,
-0.4510329068,
-0.9926950336,
-0.7522309422,
0.0870018676,
-0.0009847751,
0.0636177063,
0.0409817211,
0.1190634593,
0.4556570053,
-0.1124350727,
-0.6964181662,
-0.1618028432,
-0.1325828433,
0.114610672,
0.8397327662,
0.7030742168,
0.4046717286,
-0.4455596507,
-0.259142369,
0.1652956903,
-0.8947796822,
0.1989193708,
0.4249218404,
0.2047626078,
0.2643865049,
0.7057552934,
-0.3346266448,
0.778087616,
0.3986283243,
-0.0534119233,
-0.3242773414,
-0.6103787422,
0.1575112343,
0.0721742883,
0.1810417324,
0.6132683158,
0.0660720989,
-0.2159181982,
0.1006710157,
-0.334769994,
0.0825857148,
-1.0994277,
-0.1173349991,
0.709387064,
-0.2044485658,
-0.2319733649,
0.0995894596,
-0.8202211261,
-0.2895202041,
-0.2424781173,
0.1139194816,
-0.2101134807,
-0.4136360884,
0.2235994935,
-0.2401504964,
0.4688078165,
0.6362138391,
-0.6426486373,
0.2224929035,
0.6663412452,
0.1408840716,
-0.2689485848,
-0.1393203139,
-0.9014632702,
0.544184804,
-0.0638161525,
0.7270020843,
-0.5758050084,
-0.6247801781,
0.1846170425,
-0.1102803648,
0.0642746538,
-0.3586384356,
0.0499151237,
-0.8327749372,
0.4621419311,
-0.3864839971,
-0.7903960347,
0.018554328,
0.3592782915,
-0.2820488811,
0.6965929866,
-0.223259598,
-0.7742750645,
0.7114194632,
-0.4978480041,
-0.3028275967,
0.479573071,
-0.7436038256,
-0.1732891351,
-0.2173224986,
0.1260756105,
0.4177374542,
-0.1910219789,
0.6830160022,
-0.3102242053,
0.0622237325,
0.1317832172,
0.059601903,
0.4074175656,
0.036053706,
-0.6157152057,
0.0942513794,
-1.1291497946,
0.0737254694,
0.1393084526,
-0.4716913402,
-0.1375377774,
0.3949216008,
0.2590540051,
0.2659856975,
-0.0579077564,
-0.5869337916,
0.4565705955,
-0.3189146519,
-0.0557912402,
0.3341948688,
0.9581891298,
0.6668668985,
-0.2778960466,
0.819337666,
0.4452133179,
0.1142618507,
-0.6344182491,
-0.6948766708,
-0.6532684565,
0.1878098696,
-0.0794501603,
0.4564396739,
-0.7565635443,
0.1334667057,
0.2313581854,
-0.3348586559,
0.0852283686,
-0.269244343,
0.0613711327,
0.7703813314,
0.2519102395,
0.1406632811,
-0.6310775876,
-0.7365477681,
-0.1373159736,
-0.3114343882,
-0.253348887,
0.4364900291,
0.5459127426,
0.0139716584,
1.1554156542,
-0.9279432893,
0.3768205047,
-0.6311988235,
0.4918868542,
-0.1547400802,
0.7025671005,
0.3894328177,
-1.2777496576,
-0.0477786139,
-0.0403754897,
-0.5398002267,
-0.0335945338,
-0.5954496861,
-0.220927462,
-0.1893960088,
0.4566109776,
-0.6049423814,
0.5602785349,
-0.0494751222,
-0.7142848969,
0.4360161126,
0.2141824514,
0.158459723,
-1.2691776752,
0.1016762555,
-0.4863599837,
-0.1454851031,
-1.0716801882,
0.4808808267,
-0.1182730645,
-0.3242599666,
-0.4720531702,
0.4555320442,
-0.1734536588,
-0.0896747708,
-0.0003249633,
0.3085617125,
0.3434243202,
0.4611280859,
0.2056750208,
0.3074007928,
0.4290174842,
-1.0184766054,
0.2359326929,
0.4688850641,
-0.3541193306,
0.5618774295,
-0.5290481448,
0.2650667429,
-0.5746581554,
0.3508787155,
-0.8252571225,
-0.6486207843,
-0.0001604227,
-0.1616653055,
0.2385154516,
-0.2123080939,
-0.3348549008,
-0.1249340549,
0.0783168599,
0.4639782906,
0.1946178675,
-0.4801148176,
0.9391243458,
0.3178169131,
-0.2707556188,
-0.0954386294,
-0.5051339865,
-0.1103680357,
-0.2546384335,
-1.0068770647,
0.2251811922,
-0.4403552413,
-0.4907184243,
-0.0253737774,
-0.0441902839,
-0.0890143961,
0.1987426132,
0.3997190893,
0.0587357022,
-0.4880020618,
0.1938322037,
0.2738467157,
0.2714487016,
-0.0786954761,
-0.3208828866,
0.6908447146,
0.0081451992,
-0.6975260377,
-0.1995351613,
1.309994936,
0.1094313562,
-0.3351264298,
0.4666087627,
0.314830333,
-0.7515927553,
-0.2619333267,
-0.4335328639,
-0.1920884401,
-0.4415467381,
0.3079267144,
-0.597314775,
-1.2389090061,
0.8580965996,
-0.2935856879,
0.3192427754,
0.329996109,
0.6825649142,
-0.2276154906,
1.4840587378,
0.4319677055,
0.7192770839,
0.0756801814,
-0.085137561,
0.1716438532,
-0.4565680027,
-0.7001999021,
-0.4029141963,
-0.3043288887,
-0.2089781612,
-0.3865033686,
0.2959540188,
0.6234377623,
-0.1572517157,
0.2336345166,
-0.015629271,
0.4004018009,
0.4802117646,
-0.1879757643,
0.4115312099,
-0.5531930923,
-0.0270751994,
0.0816174597,
-0.9572359324,
-0.7288730741,
0.7638539672,
-0.1037635431,
0.4946672916,
0.0300804228,
1.1698877811,
-0.2852763534,
0.3033069074,
-0.3220235109,
0.5407599807,
0.8025362492,
-1.2505948544,
-0.5834302902,
-0.2411382049,
-1.0519089699,
0.1393456608,
-0.2032240182,
-0.9301450849,
0.7889758945,
0.1378468573,
-0.8226974607,
0.2636569142,
-0.6686265469,
0.8567689061,
0.0501957536,
0.158916831,
0.2078146935,
-0.6498179436,
0.4774370492,
-0.0827014595,
0.1746805459,
-0.0510516986,
0.0687985122,
0.5480590463,
-0.2978852391,
0.5911663771,
-0.0422626212,
0.1779985428,
0.8892785311,
0.4455441236,
0.7109957337,
0.6131166816,
0.0787507519,
-0.7038239241,
0.058184579,
-0.3325778246,
-0.5901533365,
0.6310719848,
-0.3211617768,
-0.8252128363,
0.1327830255,
-0.3577441871,
-0.3945912719,
0.1152022257,
0.4633042216,
0.6356284022,
-0.3226394653,
-0.1639620513,
0.8645219803,
-0.334099859,
0.4981469214,
0.7733919621,
-0.4075426459,
0.2554268539,
0.3798126876,
0.1009408236,
0.1554933935,
0.2946481705,
-0.1890889555,
0.0762297213,
-0.4073095024,
-0.7112644315,
-0.201805979,
-0.6777255535,
-0.1626729369,
-1.1731469631,
0.2819416523,
-0.1596494466,
-0.2708157301,
-0.0529467277,
-0.5044854879,
-0.6613817215,
-0.7746877074,
0.1270398498,
0.4842616022,
0.2902036905,
0.2245558947,
-0.7463519573,
0.4239095747,
0.6715605855,
0.0300400816,
-0.2286726087,
0.1936110705,
0.1827499419,
-0.1737159938,
-0.4512932897,
-1.4119523764,
0.0104848249,
0.2733538151,
0.3977114558,
0.3614525497,
0.390946269,
0.7746216059,
-0.7243226171,
1.0031477213,
0.0214847755,
-0.8180320263,
1.1582620144,
-0.3454632461,
0.0601675771,
0.560623765,
0.4996182919,
-0.5113995075,
-0.5806749463,
-1.0979681015,
-0.982047081,
0.9151644111,
0.2854270339,
-0.0522383563,
-0.2585068941,
0.7559177279,
0.0733632892,
0.1758247167,
-0.4040637016,
-0.3833420277,
-0.0219580829,
0.0691354275,
0.0378390104,
-0.1732909977,
-0.3651738167,
0.2890696526,
0.1034326106,
-0.0676467046,
-0.165160656,
0.4798851311,
0.0649352968,
-0.5258357525,
0.3235334456,
0.5258501768,
0.610742569,
-0.0278496873,
0.1186771765,
0.491553992,
-0.0237102062,
0.0566463359,
0.2398201227,
-0.5410135984,
-0.0000856974,
0.2921901643,
0.7557470798,
0.0356207788,
-0.9664286971,
0.6070221663,
-0.267436713,
-0.4059975743,
-0.1458050162,
0.3764304221,
0.178819865,
0.4933691025,
0.518407464,
-0.1378404647,
0.4661952853,
-0.7083984613,
0.5478606224,
-0.0925000906,
-0.3390780389,
-0.305940032,
0.9700562358,
0.2005926818,
-0.3355939686,
0.3175406456,
-0.2744635046,
-0.3968407512,
0.8866834641,
0.4628785849,
0.5105401278,
-0.1121274531,
0.139058575,
0.3768623471,
0.2579965889,
0.2493656874,
0.8912854195,
-0.0858619958,
-0.6090223789,
-0.4258969128,
-0.523045361,
-0.4833116531,
0.2282525897,
-0.8910347223,
0.2386137694,
-0.2205901742,
-0.1133654565,
0.2029345781,
-0.2474413961,
-0.8820951581,
0.473793149,
0.1642710716,
1.1460021734,
-0.6348130703,
0.3101388514,
0.7849246264,
-0.6738758087,
-0.9820609689,
0.008383356,
-0.3086103797,
-0.1219782084,
0.4327662587,
-0.1500788033,
0.353618443,
-0.0144232931,
-0.6090500951,
-0.8593152165,
1.117980957,
0.0437639765,
-0.6698970795,
-0.3405399323,
0.2031050473,
0.5330664515,
-0.578519702,
-0.1764896363,
0.558251977,
0.3435960114,
0.1270036846,
-0.3072085083,
0.077792801,
-0.1632883251,
-0.129532218,
0.2771000862,
-0.2346440703,
0.6393248439,
-0.4128075242,
-0.4575575888,
-0.0955250859,
0.9429574609,
0.3896499276,
0.8325487375,
0.5807090402,
0.0654782429,
0.8375760317,
-0.2006840259,
1.2618855238,
-0.2424164265,
0.1706032455,
1.3017801046,
-0.3868614733,
0.5377848744,
0.4582014084,
0.2677999139,
0.3480961323,
0.775665462,
0.4018920064,
0.3918984532,
0.4125329554,
-0.4068410993,
-0.8772512674,
-0.0635237172,
-0.429807961,
0.3277598321,
0.2463278323,
0.1069099009,
-0.4218442738,
0.2954526544,
-0.1172810867,
-0.1099932194,
-0.2383368462,
0.7929937243,
-0.0644392744,
-1.018211484,
-0.2475310564,
0.2040585577,
-0.1224218681,
-0.4764564633,
-0.0344872735,
-0.4725070298,
-0.235355258,
-0.0983186364,
-0.773630321,
0.2933672965,
0.2684916556,
-0.2129069567,
0.068641372,
0.5556142926,
-0.6432892084,
-0.2286503911,
-0.2462852448,
0.6263291836,
0.0259029288,
-0.1066564098,
-0.1993170083,
-0.227334559,
0.0375453457,
-0.8510894775,
0.2629773319,
0.656509161,
-0.2572773993,
0.6681417823,
0.5421330929,
-0.3435377181,
0.5353493094,
0.065419808,
0.7652797699,
-0.653449595,
-0.6059288383,
-0.3531077206,
0.6673616767,
-0.1398526877,
-0.6763316393,
0.4383977354,
0.6367950439,
0.9217616916,
0.1112922058,
0.7342283726,
-0.0547561757,
0.4894151688,
-0.1971592009,
0.1269800365,
-0.6008989215,
0.1637194455,
-0.2177625149,
-0.466267854,
-0.2889527977,
0.2700296938,
0.0203587022,
-0.2153611928,
0.2999628186,
0.5580682755,
0.1933827698,
0.3459365368,
0.1727149338,
-0.1338237673,
0.730225563,
0.5509918928,
1.2830475569,
-0.2430710644,
0.5850620866,
0.0497946963,
-0.1251154244,
-0.3623327017,
-0.6553584337,
-0.705612421,
-0.8593425155,
-0.5240598321,
-0.1597202122,
-0.2648047507,
1.1260384321,
0.5018858314,
-0.9943470359,
0.0913687646,
-0.2202874273,
-0.090285778,
0.1847422123,
-0.2326977402,
0.2118407786,
-0.3186768889,
-0.7894476652,
0.3539383411,
0.3835938275,
0.2851534188,
-0.0453692786,
0.2139223516,
-0.0870203152,
0.2539274991,
0.6640219688,
0.2818242013,
-0.4310852587,
-0.461132139,
0.1569727063,
-0.1107342467,
-0.4788009524,
1.1192413568,
-0.4297051728,
0.324316591,
0.3442073762,
0.5694668293,
1.0721844435,
-0.0938045904,
0.7884138823,
-0.9051551223,
-0.1059949622,
0.5926120877,
0.3179689944,
-0.0530870669,
-0.5800988078,
0.3061199784,
-0.0082704006,
-0.3244462907,
-0.9240375161,
0.782640636,
-1.2057528496,
-0.327052474,
1.2295460701,
0.0227187667,
0.2377884835,
-0.4109300673,
-0.4904880524,
0.2315479219,
0.0897374153,
0.4747764468,
0.735583365,
-0.6377505064,
0.0243470501,
-0.3695872724,
0.7139917016,
0.1290168464,
-0.8786169887,
-0.1312138289,
0.4963970482,
0.126319468,
0.129628405,
0.6602623463,
0.1385762095,
0.3419144452,
-0.1695758849,
-0.0217898972,
0.169762224,
-0.5401789546,
0.0223722681,
0.8561116457,
-0.2005482614,
0.0855293944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07124v1 | Exploiting Summarization Data to Help Text Simplification | 2023-02-14T15:32:04 | 2023-02-14T15:32:04 | Renliang Sun, Zhixian Yang, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the major problems with text simplification is the lack of
high-quality data. The sources of simplification datasets are limited to
Wikipedia and Newsela, restricting further development of this field. In this
paper, we analyzed the similarity between text summarization and text
simplification and exploited summarization data to help simplify. First, we
proposed an alignment algorithm to extract sentence pairs from summarization
datasets. Then, we designed four attributes to characterize the degree of
simplification and proposed a method to filter suitable pairs. We named these
pairs Sum4Simp (S4S). Next, we conducted human evaluations to show that S4S is
high-quality and compared it with a real simplification dataset. Finally, we
conducted experiments to illustrate that the S4S can improve the performance of
several mainstream simplification models, especially in low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.1285576969,
-0.2122987509,
0.5018512607,
0.3651702106,
-0.5095393062,
-0.0260668732,
-0.0111144874,
-0.287607193,
0.3554270864,
0.3031327724,
-0.4779179096,
-0.2770769,
-0.3962471187,
0.5826362371,
-0.4592087567,
1.2441037893,
-0.1893211007,
-0.0080546774,
-0.624117732,
-0.0969210863,
-0.2747597098,
-0.270483464,
0.0445884801,
-0.3384316266,
0.4735125005,
0.6205862164,
0.8479403257,
0.9181701541,
0.8991292119,
0.3179545701,
-0.2839366794,
0.2013147324,
-0.7557263374,
0.1214854419,
0.1233765259,
-0.4207055569,
-0.3610722423,
0.0000377555,
0.6512681842,
0.7340675592,
0.095361203,
0.251645416,
0.1499186456,
0.8303499222,
-0.4540700018,
0.2393871397,
-0.0219266657,
-0.1142723858,
-0.0808434933,
-0.3712218106,
0.1187570244,
-0.8669610023,
-0.1569962949,
-0.8413398862,
0.1680525243,
0.0509849638,
0.9511863589,
0.5635613203,
-0.398168534,
-0.3153092265,
-0.5277616978,
0.9702680707,
-0.8831620812,
0.0102962563,
-0.0598566532,
0.0248358436,
0.082626231,
-0.5569406152,
-0.5095475316,
0.4272063673,
-0.5739341378,
0.1295635551,
0.0456488505,
-0.0552737191,
0.5142221451,
0.6424143314,
-0.5118710399,
-0.2740127444,
-0.8836641312,
-0.1892626286,
0.7783373594,
0.1457501054,
0.4493773878,
-0.3775688112,
-0.4701025784,
-0.0128818834,
-0.5169860125,
0.1158635393,
0.4707999825,
0.1693345308,
0.0621647276,
0.6673623919,
-0.4796868861,
0.3783965111,
-0.5565128326,
-0.3921571374,
0.5019580126,
-0.8850828409,
-0.2013331056,
0.026135996,
0.7156019211,
0.7462248206,
0.3833428621,
-0.1632560343,
-0.0349216685,
-0.08486747,
-0.0054621333,
-0.919629395,
0.0336494744,
0.1632561386,
-0.8059771657,
-0.4396588504,
0.2563239336,
-0.6644507647,
0.0146328723,
-0.5358110666,
0.3334984183,
-0.4753440917,
0.0896774009,
0.0848792046,
-0.6899741888,
0.1857686937,
0.3090719581,
-0.868183732,
0.5539234281,
0.8979289532,
0.9473223686,
-0.2760158479,
-0.4517582655,
-0.1076257154,
0.2447233796,
-0.1921516806,
0.6690016985,
-0.0934937075,
-0.1055592522,
-0.5500981808,
-0.4955076277,
0.365611285,
-0.5213071704,
0.7656210065,
-0.1731292158,
0.1618902534,
-0.5954535007,
-0.7616943717,
-0.1591452062,
-0.0699930638,
-0.9517015219,
0.9907751679,
-0.2817842364,
-1.2181923389,
0.2329737395,
-0.3633732498,
-0.5860882401,
-0.0050900541,
-0.0886061266,
-0.6879067421,
0.2273947597,
0.3075909019,
0.4178534448,
-0.2335052341,
0.2501249611,
-0.1967887133,
-0.7699230313,
0.0478385836,
-0.0886615217,
0.7750788927,
0.2628380656,
0.0899597704,
-0.177044034,
-0.4877712131,
-0.0695756152,
-0.1089509502,
-0.2464405,
-0.7029354572,
-0.2737128437,
-0.1836015284,
0.1651760787,
0.5487327576,
-0.3006085753,
0.105645366,
-0.3994741738,
0.1450719982,
0.35220927,
0.1896078587,
0.5304728746,
-0.4870346189,
0.3362275064,
-0.0927934051,
-0.05199828,
-0.6500966549,
-0.3734000623,
-0.4694927931,
-0.3176803887,
0.6902524233,
0.5347377062,
-0.5331600308,
0.3634054065,
-0.7585872412,
-0.3993893862,
-0.5862265229,
0.3935954571,
0.3255895078,
0.3740386069,
0.4460273385,
-0.0239540078,
-0.4319861233,
-1.0749748945,
-0.7535182834,
0.1712428331,
-0.3800286651,
-0.1229768991,
0.2687922716,
0.2966636121,
1.1020368338,
-0.7270986438,
-0.2658442259,
-0.3882662356,
0.1121086031,
0.1898724735,
0.3645659685,
0.570946455,
-0.9889825583,
-0.2110869884,
-0.3474308848,
-1.1528664827,
-0.3780068755,
-0.0288181156,
0.0161093324,
-0.4337354898,
0.8153979778,
-0.3733157814,
0.4606136382,
0.4673646986,
-0.0699837655,
0.1576157808,
-0.3115478456,
0.3286797106,
-1.2352417707,
0.141994074,
-0.1073640361,
-0.3819405138,
-0.6174128652,
-0.0922546163,
0.1970756799,
-0.1959338039,
-0.0282778554,
0.0846838281,
-0.5964392424,
-0.4217882454,
-0.1086486205,
0.2102974504,
0.1634449363,
0.3460956514,
-0.4236204922,
0.8005210757,
0.0773513094,
-0.4657221138,
0.4315232635,
0.4028469026,
-0.16842103,
0.2585909665,
-0.7827715278,
-0.4369932413,
-0.4416916072,
0.3217556477,
-1.035877347,
-0.4223101437,
-0.2922031879,
-0.2494854629,
-0.2305149585,
0.3268986046,
-0.4769724011,
0.0616191141,
-0.95813936,
0.5990031958,
0.3502991199,
-0.465089798,
0.563985765,
0.248999536,
-0.7708922625,
-0.5158765912,
-0.7763593197,
0.0386297703,
-0.3883115053,
-0.531329453,
0.7253943682,
-0.0780004561,
-0.3442887664,
0.0426442735,
-0.1667861491,
0.2240096778,
0.0626007393,
0.2954656184,
0.10388951,
0.0515858568,
0.1585366428,
0.4321004152,
-0.2292572111,
-0.0791228265,
0.4844329059,
0.1700084209,
0.1763355434,
-0.0446295328,
-0.6639387608,
0.4868483543,
0.4528984427,
0.0222672392,
0.4610884488,
0.1850796491,
-0.2977671027,
0.0400770269,
-0.2425444424,
-0.2341979593,
-0.4167079031,
-0.0868561342,
-0.3100508153,
-0.5253999829,
0.3135976791,
-0.323349148,
0.2491465509,
0.3667663038,
0.1040099859,
-0.3531169593,
0.6475217938,
0.5926308632,
-0.2047790289,
0.4752952456,
-0.0163748562,
0.3823545873,
-0.4659388363,
-0.2119121552,
-0.5761771202,
-0.5922439098,
-0.5329802036,
-0.0080911024,
0.3127605021,
0.1987700909,
0.2704035342,
0.4197118282,
-0.0773305073,
0.834640801,
0.6077758074,
0.2667477429,
0.6110330224,
0.1684072316,
0.2213005871,
-0.2760262489,
-0.515408814,
-0.5697353482,
0.8748367429,
0.2064767033,
0.7465815544,
0.1911661625,
0.9616057277,
0.2096145898,
-0.0408552773,
-0.5131683946,
0.5084177852,
-0.2693251371,
0.0463965349,
-0.3032388985,
-0.9112616181,
-0.6368067265,
0.0008820009,
-0.3489314914,
-0.1685085744,
0.0837803334,
0.1002492458,
-0.3331823051,
-0.1584788263,
-0.9076341391,
0.4796652794,
0.0129185403,
0.023722209,
-0.1286702603,
-0.6775199771,
0.4617758989,
-0.0455681942,
0.5280447006,
-0.0936583653,
-0.1178953722,
0.8610373139,
-0.6564170122,
0.5164862275,
0.3130514324,
-0.053615015,
-0.1256793439,
-0.366389811,
0.1907352209,
-0.2465251535,
-0.098658897,
0.0901714414,
-0.2976791859,
-0.6000035405,
-0.8558492661,
0.9173646569,
-0.5999673009,
-0.300050199,
-0.1697141975,
-0.4727281332,
0.1976437271,
0.3283137977,
0.3122154474,
0.3894532621,
-0.1462894529,
0.1763600558,
0.4131225944,
0.0633008555,
0.6106191874,
-0.2317189574,
0.0605076216,
-0.4057120085,
0.9417544603,
0.1756666601,
0.1578587592,
0.3575606644,
0.235521391,
-0.0558572859,
-0.2170609832,
-0.2290108651,
0.4081784487,
-0.6113656759,
-0.4941200614,
-0.6843062043,
-0.1192864031,
-0.643546164,
-0.1589882821,
0.1656612754,
-1.0250730515,
-0.2126885653,
-0.2729557157,
0.3102161884,
0.7631768584,
0.1526969224,
0.2857031226,
-0.6004167199,
0.7648715377,
0.4322813451,
0.1948381364,
-0.3165064156,
-0.2369829118,
-0.1532547921,
-0.14734146,
-0.1842224598,
-1.0754404068,
0.2761936188,
0.3250676692,
0.3533492386,
0.343354404,
0.0707863867,
0.7673985958,
-0.1669549495,
0.6796936393,
0.0472000018,
-1.127518177,
0.3898995817,
-0.1295029521,
0.3697245121,
0.6627545953,
0.4606950879,
-0.2597215474,
-0.3202835619,
-0.7231192589,
-0.8575095534,
0.7321181297,
0.7671616673,
-0.1229320243,
0.7279968262,
0.7155784965,
0.0513450801,
0.3543150723,
-0.5851034522,
-0.4356685579,
-0.1506437361,
-0.7780817151,
-0.2165910751,
-0.3630555868,
0.0888026357,
0.0681535527,
0.6439493895,
0.0943083465,
-0.1467556804,
0.0388997346,
-0.0853127092,
0.1177701354,
0.2560983896,
0.5046547055,
0.3460296988,
0.1095367149,
0.2356427908,
0.3632001579,
-0.2465947866,
-0.0219888259,
0.0751320273,
-0.4245044589,
0.3731428087,
0.6668014526,
0.4569379091,
0.2479286194,
-0.6540644765,
0.8772857785,
-0.2076252401,
-0.0150383897,
0.2732650042,
0.1818842739,
0.1429861784,
-0.0511626862,
0.3620589077,
0.0176796578,
0.7051207423,
-0.4563412666,
-0.0209761877,
-0.0015740722,
0.0812471583,
-0.176738292,
0.2752172351,
0.1865819246,
-0.1950384825,
0.1960165352,
0.0400244109,
-0.4694704413,
0.6483540535,
0.188563779,
0.1389581412,
-0.2849947214,
-0.0789055005,
0.3764943182,
0.2719614804,
-0.3947080076,
0.4064796269,
-0.2729498446,
-0.3295474946,
-0.4787133932,
-0.388749361,
-0.5040159225,
-0.2211661637,
-0.6707748771,
0.7062421441,
-0.1155103818,
0.1880932003,
0.2708785236,
-0.0158364493,
-0.3297913969,
0.225079298,
-0.2849457264,
0.8389496207,
-1.2630273104,
0.2024284303,
0.5497499108,
-0.369410634,
-0.7712631226,
0.1963595152,
-0.0865320191,
-0.1849733591,
0.3990245461,
0.4525825977,
-0.2196316272,
-0.0623371936,
-0.4652841687,
-0.6852495074,
1.3283574581,
0.4935812056,
-0.267855227,
-0.2008346915,
0.1661600173,
0.6524655223,
-0.1703849286,
0.233506158,
0.628646493,
0.315508604,
-0.1249089837,
-0.7485704422,
0.158271566,
-0.3013196886,
0.0927036405,
0.2796272635,
-0.6688730717,
0.7588339448,
-0.3030361831,
-0.2399533242,
-0.0460205451,
0.7005877495,
-0.0124438489,
0.5688450933,
0.2757728398,
0.5085588694,
0.5578251481,
-0.1754326671,
0.7119694948,
-0.1259080619,
0.450055927,
0.98723948,
0.0202733651,
0.6548907757,
0.6088535786,
0.1242348552,
0.5210536718,
0.1167236194,
0.1985891312,
0.5572831035,
0.0505000763,
-0.1330233812,
-0.0020849132,
0.0282016881,
-0.1817695796,
0.2937932909,
0.3314853013,
-0.4139971137,
-0.4878057241,
-0.1134644225,
0.026476318,
0.3625969887,
-0.1844167262,
1.2032645941,
-0.0233778153,
-0.5870079994,
0.0472762547,
0.0387079939,
0.6834141016,
-0.1477941424,
-0.1049777046,
-0.4282618761,
-0.0889492333,
-0.5779226422,
-0.6471946836,
0.4511956275,
0.0585792623,
-0.1199433506,
-0.365329206,
0.6946419477,
-0.5454860926,
-0.2821786404,
-0.0005367737,
0.3245145082,
0.3756112754,
0.0907494053,
-0.2429205179,
0.0855915621,
0.1633451879,
0.0267936438,
-0.0432028659,
0.7019374967,
-0.0887386277,
0.6503619552,
0.6706695557,
0.1736525893,
-0.1720047444,
-0.2338065952,
1.0471438169,
-0.9168496132,
-0.8286130428,
-0.9997130632,
-0.0347989164,
-0.6594583988,
-0.1701337397,
0.7587913275,
1.0334881544,
0.4848906696,
0.0944126993,
0.8116422296,
0.390865773,
0.8198977709,
-0.4470531344,
0.4553246498,
-0.5061585903,
0.3502574861,
-0.4504410923,
-0.8019532561,
-0.5648519993,
0.4290412366,
-0.0833728462,
-0.0804057121,
0.5379858017,
0.6752867103,
-0.3921287656,
0.1565476507,
0.1018829122,
-0.0391522534,
0.0841423273,
0.1844854951,
0.42336303,
-0.7041241527,
0.7750409245,
-0.3496752083,
-0.3596351743,
-0.4946340322,
-0.9284985662,
-0.830221355,
-0.5085595846,
-0.2479032874,
0.0430438109,
-0.0145309251,
0.6603209376,
0.2693517804,
-0.5212552547,
0.0378584675,
-0.0401076153,
0.2891204059,
-0.2528539598,
-0.2254261672,
0.3036285937,
-0.2661353946,
-0.6391977072,
0.1732739508,
0.3320552707,
0.3420126736,
-0.0098991031,
0.125215888,
0.2781923711,
0.1703464091,
0.3060498834,
-0.1021563709,
-0.314774394,
0.2220646739,
-0.1670822799,
-0.3235294223,
0.0259962063,
1.1331188679,
-0.5441452265,
0.0546409898,
0.8865389228,
0.4653657377,
0.3830342889,
0.6202695966,
0.6467593312,
-1.0919424295,
-0.0403096788,
-0.2012177855,
0.3337451816,
0.5902299881,
-0.4189715683,
0.3413040638,
-0.0523417965,
-0.3698812127,
-0.5885785222,
0.1102396026,
-0.8890234232,
-0.2121945918,
0.993930161,
-0.095878683,
-0.2573763132,
-0.1115995869,
-0.3987789154,
0.3255942762,
-0.3856301308,
0.7917847037,
0.5854548812,
-0.1515968144,
-0.0696949884,
-0.0157085899,
0.84379071,
0.3896451592,
-1.2716641426,
0.1418111473,
0.3527511954,
0.3078368306,
0.3912973702,
0.3776075244,
-0.0218451358,
0.2524005175,
-0.2926990986,
-0.0248790495,
-0.0691034049,
-0.0053153695,
-0.6810112596,
0.2790846825,
-0.4502587318,
0.0022334133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07739v1 | Meta-Learning Triplet Network with Adaptive Margins for Few-Shot Named Entity Recognition | 2023-02-14T15:10:26 | 2023-02-14T15:10:26 | Chengcheng Han, Renyu Zhu, Jun Kuang, FengJiao Chen, Xiang Li, Ming Gao, Xuezhi Cao, Wei Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Meta-learning methods have been widely used in few-shot named entity
recognition (NER), especially prototype-based methods. However, the Other(O)
class is difficult to be represented by a prototype vector because there are
generally a large number of samples in the class that have miscellaneous
semantics. To solve the problem, we propose MeTNet, which generates prototype
vectors for entity types only but not O-class. We design an improved triplet
network to map samples and prototype vectors into a low-dimensional space that
is easier to be classified and propose an adaptive margin for each entity type.
The margin plays as a radius and controls a region with adaptive size in the
low-dimensional space. Based on the regions, we propose a new inference
procedure to predict the label of a query instance. We conduct extensive
experiments in both in-domain and cross-domain settings to show the superiority
of MeTNet over other state-of-the-art methods. In particular, we release a
Chinese few-shot NER dataset FEW-COMM extracted from a well-known e-commerce
platform. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first Chinese few-shot NER
dataset. All the datasets and codes are provided at
https://github.com/hccngu/MeTNet. | [
-0.4541062415,
-0.4154661894,
0.3012627661,
-0.0744731352,
-0.2044925541,
-0.0823324546,
-0.157527402,
-0.4568288028,
0.3910624385,
0.374206394,
-0.3952029943,
-0.6378370523,
-0.1931157112,
0.1980406344,
0.1169491932,
0.822893858,
0.0781125352,
0.096821323,
0.2330417484,
-0.4300265908,
-0.1605330706,
-0.1794269532,
-0.9347448945,
-0.2239133418,
0.7217230201,
0.6983515024,
0.2788664401,
0.5126851201,
0.5627493262,
0.2374645621,
0.1312036812,
0.4029263854,
-0.2345984578,
-0.2775121927,
0.0045368397,
-0.5092986226,
-0.9686617255,
-0.1893180311,
0.7142660618,
0.5842729807,
-0.0477476195,
0.2013967037,
0.3255375028,
0.7089146376,
-0.9014275074,
0.1495928168,
-0.7004712224,
0.1880850643,
-0.4949786365,
-0.1196741015,
-0.4592966735,
-0.0971187204,
0.2595155835,
-1.0472873449,
0.3079458177,
0.0909446478,
0.8675324321,
-0.0132706454,
-0.3383671641,
0.1265648305,
-0.7286689281,
0.65688169,
-0.5504988432,
0.2959997952,
0.1613092273,
0.6471498609,
-0.1944435537,
-0.9004076123,
-0.5901327133,
0.2225909233,
-0.0153867146,
0.4001463056,
-0.3212247193,
-0.017495364,
0.1207184717,
-0.0496856421,
-0.3989544809,
0.3275772929,
-0.4712054431,
-0.1204106137,
0.4124442041,
0.2619583011,
0.1134912297,
-0.4099914134,
-0.5586691499,
0.0191149898,
-0.8698969483,
-0.118343845,
0.2337737679,
0.6454037428,
0.0209644493,
0.3326431513,
-0.3855521679,
0.9135292172,
0.1313165128,
-0.2522006035,
0.3410414755,
0.0255125724,
-0.3019820154,
-0.002695268,
0.8590371013,
0.4473840892,
-0.0221086405,
0.3055126369,
-0.161056906,
-0.4894913137,
0.0726121664,
-0.7899928093,
-0.3377846181,
-0.0499149933,
-0.6793161035,
-0.0258592218,
0.1068448201,
-0.9215351343,
-0.1934268177,
-0.0691874325,
0.5030847192,
-0.3119202256,
-0.1569387466,
-0.07394927,
-0.0600814149,
0.2603955865,
0.3200733364,
-0.6428933144,
0.4532001913,
0.6044944525,
1.0244379044,
-0.157475099,
-0.3605850339,
-0.4779818356,
0.1449172944,
-0.1322409362,
0.8771694899,
-0.2925536633,
0.0233227648,
-0.1598902792,
-0.069023028,
-0.1685135216,
-0.4618834853,
0.292342931,
-0.8075268269,
0.1184412986,
-0.0555651858,
-0.5189526677,
-0.4013433754,
0.6185028553,
-0.9413166046,
0.5682828426,
-0.2474669367,
-1.0076943636,
0.6863086224,
-0.8146340847,
-0.1733478159,
0.3078434467,
-0.2621077299,
-0.6654536724,
-0.1212038025,
0.2492001951,
0.4892759919,
0.0122413971,
-0.2544920444,
-0.6619616747,
-0.1961967051,
0.1069563255,
-0.3473688066,
0.6551224589,
-0.1763898879,
-0.1565551013,
-0.1887190193,
-1.1067525148,
0.0307747182,
0.0325434767,
-0.345531702,
-0.4099757373,
-0.0669406205,
0.0237135049,
0.0926080048,
-0.1447644085,
-0.6675619483,
0.3718969226,
-0.3822195828,
0.3836783171,
0.5987189412,
0.2174087316,
0.4876228273,
-0.2441807687,
0.3132377267,
0.012031192,
-0.0072904695,
0.1783855855,
-0.4748281538,
-0.8970723748,
-0.3134235144,
0.631074369,
0.426132381,
-1.0636380911,
0.0363430567,
-0.5847713947,
-0.2551520169,
-0.2630790472,
-0.0275599621,
0.168644622,
0.5581488609,
0.6552459598,
-0.0000479645,
-0.7336575985,
-0.9589640498,
-0.1086207554,
-0.0575698689,
-0.246059984,
0.824649632,
0.6312663555,
-0.0624296404,
1.1276352406,
-0.6199618578,
-0.8448242545,
-0.2449923456,
0.1934016496,
0.3506992459,
0.2463458329,
0.4110569358,
-0.8317648768,
-0.6533539891,
0.0203200709,
-0.4706707001,
0.2181587219,
-0.0604376793,
-0.0625387058,
-0.1213517413,
0.3121073842,
-0.2092157304,
0.3513638079,
0.2937969863,
0.2462261915,
0.3295845389,
0.010329931,
-0.1866625696,
-1.2965011597,
-0.0836604014,
0.0338621214,
-0.3403230011,
-0.4798505306,
-0.2577804327,
0.2275963426,
-0.0220295377,
-0.8092775941,
0.490116179,
-0.5563103557,
-0.2451683879,
-0.7013627291,
0.2411992103,
0.0710904077,
0.4432080984,
0.3535355926,
0.5497049689,
0.5042018294,
-0.9054605961,
0.3511389196,
0.3410201967,
-0.1253426671,
0.8395904899,
-0.4842814207,
0.2366230339,
-0.0164374784,
0.6430903077,
-0.3383271992,
-0.3496962488,
0.3948518336,
-0.4695944488,
0.3159475327,
-0.5884180665,
-0.2286842167,
-0.514537096,
-0.1628440022,
0.5625377297,
0.002297448,
-0.8133583069,
0.6771141291,
0.1508203894,
0.3399511278,
-0.650403142,
-0.9081046581,
0.1993718147,
-0.1111590937,
-0.551621139,
0.6704865098,
0.24781847,
0.292853862,
0.1512974948,
-0.0485662781,
-0.2691027224,
-0.0306246486,
0.1747522354,
0.1681362838,
-0.6969484687,
0.4752921462,
-0.2194568366,
-0.4698974788,
-0.2128030658,
-0.7896441221,
0.1586153507,
-0.3428812325,
-0.1706854999,
-0.357305944,
0.0092111258,
0.0971068442,
-0.0594977327,
0.7663376331,
0.6746295094,
-0.744143486,
-0.4468348026,
-0.2537381947,
-0.1164910048,
-0.4277454317,
0.0371516235,
-0.6843286753,
-0.7485968471,
0.3339847326,
-0.0151004987,
-0.0692287013,
0.6629447341,
0.3120378852,
-0.1848663539,
0.5580036044,
0.8029380441,
0.1347173452,
0.2841660678,
-0.4947956502,
-0.0113742175,
-1.1789958477,
-0.0316884927,
-0.2370830923,
-0.5561873317,
-0.7972781062,
-0.2473497093,
0.5610991716,
-0.072121039,
-0.1188480258,
0.6809480786,
-0.1931697279,
0.6411678791,
0.7260550261,
0.528634131,
0.2456100434,
-0.2753522992,
-0.3319013119,
0.1012623981,
-0.7414942384,
-0.4297330678,
1.0728691816,
0.1967690736,
0.5589064956,
0.3313299716,
0.8926924467,
-0.0783580691,
0.3056583405,
-0.8717346191,
0.3322673142,
-0.3266683817,
-0.7980514765,
-0.1568390578,
-0.5943182111,
-0.9259197116,
0.3264506459,
-0.3947349787,
-0.7129032016,
0.5396601558,
0.2211739123,
-0.8507976532,
0.7069735527,
-0.3562527895,
0.5604761243,
-0.1760271788,
-0.4767043889,
0.2857976556,
-0.596493721,
0.4250509441,
-0.0085545788,
-0.1576215029,
-0.0010511468,
-0.2228664607,
1.0468065739,
-0.4109148979,
1.0136754513,
-0.1371891201,
0.4200327098,
0.4567892849,
-0.0955599174,
0.3896079659,
0.2231705636,
-0.0520797782,
-0.0125459936,
-0.2995281219,
-0.5563860536,
-0.5304302573,
0.4193584621,
-0.5690941215,
-0.2615620792,
-0.2624074817,
0.1412505358,
-0.1008497477,
0.6766938567,
0.6514753103,
0.2923295796,
-0.3351822495,
0.367474407,
0.5233966112,
-0.0696205944,
0.8131975532,
0.6091519594,
0.0603035204,
-0.6430702806,
0.8176596761,
0.2978707552,
0.0375884585,
0.5735885501,
0.344700098,
0.0925113261,
-0.5812115073,
-0.6215603352,
-0.0946648344,
-0.6274887323,
-0.8356109262,
-0.7577546239,
-0.3047991991,
-0.1212982386,
0.117642276,
-0.6900056601,
-0.2599845231,
-0.5773528218,
-0.0871864483,
0.3099230528,
0.5396242142,
-0.150721848,
0.6777080894,
-1.0190900564,
0.3618019521,
0.4715224206,
0.54896456,
0.0075935079,
-0.3794974685,
-0.1763615608,
0.0602032319,
-0.2553187907,
-0.9129949212,
0.0786036998,
0.4638687968,
0.34941715,
0.6656255722,
0.0418940075,
0.4607171714,
-0.6722797155,
0.3935274184,
0.2584164739,
-0.6909884214,
0.348333627,
-0.2534423769,
-0.0404419117,
0.6322597861,
0.4342508316,
-0.2964007258,
0.4095501006,
-0.6739765406,
-0.4513875246,
0.6982166767,
0.1682816893,
0.049273055,
0.026254518,
0.3261843026,
0.1189535484,
-0.0941736177,
-1.0299676657,
-0.3235548139,
-0.1055034846,
0.0818122104,
0.278621912,
-0.1179289967,
0.1787338704,
0.1565704048,
0.6701549292,
-0.4436984658,
0.1656718254,
0.1218333244,
-0.2896504402,
0.0223420039,
0.297750175,
0.6181445122,
0.5223599076,
-0.3235241771,
0.2280072272,
0.3706766069,
-0.507183671,
0.1229258925,
0.1182766408,
-0.2862879932,
-0.0631762519,
0.4603895545,
0.9280728102,
0.046699889,
0.2413724363,
0.7659625411,
0.0330275372,
-0.2883159816,
-0.3386442661,
-0.1155613065,
-0.1515876949,
0.3463206589,
0.3180730641,
0.2436225712,
0.374663502,
-0.1588989645,
0.50435251,
0.1695133895,
-0.6113333106,
-0.3150790334,
0.302390337,
0.4123985767,
-0.2332032174,
0.6240693927,
-0.5069547296,
-0.7248547673,
0.4315853119,
0.5363205075,
1.0009824038,
0.1064118445,
0.2719388008,
0.669271946,
0.4733815491,
-0.018368816,
0.0096568121,
0.0468790308,
-1.0074766874,
-0.1380636841,
-0.3660489321,
-0.3680565357,
0.2695071697,
-0.5098624229,
0.6435758471,
-0.5490900278,
-0.3886954784,
0.0884422883,
0.0274716578,
-0.8655409217,
0.0576783419,
0.3068585098,
0.8117539287,
-0.7748422623,
0.6871512532,
0.6396430135,
-0.559777379,
-0.4631703198,
0.0181457065,
0.1467577815,
-0.6719968319,
0.6443156004,
0.2593194246,
-0.1470440477,
0.0499992184,
-0.3310753405,
-0.8651242852,
1.1905034781,
-0.2886960506,
-0.639138639,
-0.0011623725,
-0.0757319331,
0.3996400237,
-0.6760027409,
0.3796029091,
0.3218662739,
0.471722126,
-0.0041332245,
-0.5769444108,
-0.136257112,
0.1044144183,
-0.0949589536,
0.2520999908,
-0.6847338676,
0.8243744373,
-0.3288648427,
-0.3573115468,
-0.14161098,
0.9098994732,
0.1510961503,
0.5962787867,
0.5521857738,
0.5957804322,
0.7248923779,
0.05644181,
0.5386202335,
0.3983655572,
0.4081906974,
1.600951314,
-0.3010828197,
1.1014620066,
0.1433263868,
-0.1710386425,
0.6517541409,
0.6430661082,
-0.3235280514,
0.3172820508,
0.3280673027,
-0.0783343315,
-0.1717978865,
0.1327797771,
-0.099695228,
0.7383669019,
0.4665353596,
-0.3034441471,
-0.3899283111,
0.3249139488,
-0.2854347229,
-0.3928556144,
-0.2507049739,
1.1311500072,
0.2279598713,
-0.0416203812,
0.2677090764,
0.1235315129,
0.6474328637,
0.0204106439,
-0.1235454828,
-0.155279845,
0.2194016576,
-0.4592675865,
-0.5148582458,
-0.1175369099,
-0.1775249988,
-0.2497282326,
0.3036293387,
0.9144123197,
-0.2202014476,
-0.5007073283,
0.2975726724,
0.5111103654,
0.0407632217,
-0.0589609295,
-0.7516661286,
-0.4433909059,
-0.3484201431,
-0.1931258738,
-0.0351589732,
0.4230119586,
0.0220686607,
0.4548893869,
0.4660598934,
0.0748321339,
0.2527389824,
0.067130968,
0.5984310508,
-0.6839538217,
-0.5208624601,
-0.7552005649,
0.3035281599,
-0.2226360738,
-0.2177991122,
0.3768376112,
0.6227793694,
0.7798115015,
0.0417108871,
0.5549423099,
0.0574043766,
0.5718848705,
-0.6828896403,
0.5549303889,
-0.5880921483,
0.2533503473,
-0.0817283839,
-1.1693701744,
-0.6059690714,
0.1724923998,
-0.1706759781,
0.0996840224,
0.644837141,
0.5826487541,
-0.694910109,
-0.2254919857,
0.1835140437,
0.0355084054,
0.2163603008,
0.7045292854,
0.7137869,
-0.6977745295,
0.7019301653,
-0.4357014894,
-0.2442943007,
-0.594384253,
-1.1122734547,
-0.8284259439,
-0.3318303227,
-0.3800832331,
-0.3014116287,
-0.1526756436,
0.8520413637,
0.8966034651,
-0.7882979512,
0.0957011804,
-0.11946401,
0.2153823823,
-0.1909568906,
-0.1924037933,
0.6578830481,
-0.1238977537,
-0.4778225422,
0.3476635814,
0.293210268,
0.1929846406,
0.1890949309,
0.1708990186,
-0.2790538967,
-0.2447352409,
0.3450652659,
0.4530725777,
-0.5745194554,
-0.4241832197,
0.1204448417,
-0.131030485,
0.3967940807,
0.8323277831,
-0.6836881042,
0.4695956111,
0.5929546356,
0.8030526638,
0.5159773827,
-0.1182406768,
0.3751003146,
-0.9881099463,
-0.2089466453,
0.3182384968,
0.5050920248,
0.3767148852,
-0.1265901923,
0.4129910767,
0.2270203233,
-0.2393144369,
-0.3207710087,
0.1443421692,
-0.8870217204,
-0.1739284247,
0.9459167123,
-0.081181787,
-0.3493672609,
0.0216623358,
0.1346296519,
0.2714075446,
-0.2670107186,
0.3212575316,
0.3506217301,
-0.0766167864,
-0.2047400326,
-0.4568693042,
0.4146617353,
0.1094795838,
-0.7246282101,
-0.2573740184,
0.2173392773,
0.3194984794,
0.2581575513,
0.4998322129,
0.1933710277,
0.4610757232,
-0.0631441623,
0.1055609807,
0.043422915,
-0.6443264484,
-0.2914794087,
0.0677993819,
-0.1013629362,
-0.7414268851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07027v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07027v3 | AdapterSoup: Weight Averaging to Improve Generalization of Pretrained Language Models | 2023-02-14T13:09:23 | 2023-03-28T13:37:54 | Alexandra Chronopoulou, Matthew E. Peters, Alexander Fraser, Jesse Dodge | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) are trained on massive corpora, but often
need to specialize to specific domains. A parameter-efficient adaptation method
suggests training an adapter for each domain on the task of language modeling.
This leads to good in-domain scores but can be impractical for domain- or
resource-restricted settings. A solution is to use a related-domain adapter for
the novel domain at test time. In this paper, we introduce AdapterSoup, an
approach that performs weight-space averaging of adapters trained on different
domains. Our approach is embarrassingly parallel: first, we train a set of
domain-specific adapters; then, for each novel domain, we determine which
adapters should be averaged at test time. We present extensive experiments
showing that AdapterSoup consistently improves performance to new domains
without extra training. We also explore weight averaging of adapters trained on
the same domain with different hyper-parameters, and show that it preserves the
performance of a PLM on new domains while obtaining strong in-domain results.
We explore various approaches for choosing which adapters to combine, such as
text clustering and semantic similarity. We find that using clustering leads to
the most competitive results on novel domains. | [
-0.5371382236,
-0.3541506827,
0.4148632288,
0.5626341701,
-0.2452563643,
-0.1136469468,
-0.5135399103,
-0.057748083,
0.2103777081,
0.3049887419,
-0.184078604,
-0.5522257686,
-0.9729075432,
-0.0644034743,
-0.1901060343,
0.8530628085,
-0.3058324754,
-0.0375438519,
-0.6877202392,
-0.728646636,
-0.7206083536,
-0.5035728812,
-0.5235552192,
-0.1417218149,
0.1778063625,
0.2944906056,
0.4216921628,
0.3117549121,
0.766171515,
0.328463614,
0.3547233641,
0.1756431907,
-0.3953725696,
-0.005457629,
-0.231920436,
-0.4181779027,
-0.638009131,
0.154788807,
0.8635334969,
1.081974864,
-0.284835875,
0.1527763307,
0.2197701633,
0.7215667963,
-0.6184815168,
0.0550354421,
-0.7040056586,
-0.2499536127,
-0.0511345416,
-0.3195121288,
-0.2793846726,
-0.281778276,
0.2353132516,
-0.9637355208,
0.3572137058,
0.2505970001,
0.5798086524,
0.1076684892,
0.0266594663,
-0.1317002028,
-0.8332623243,
1.178725481,
-0.7220342159,
0.3761252165,
0.0314467438,
0.2637851834,
-0.2757697403,
-0.7169305682,
-0.4869515002,
0.0921517983,
0.0297274459,
0.0642012656,
-0.4112273157,
-0.0234174095,
0.0991534442,
0.2527350783,
-0.8616487384,
-0.0473983027,
-0.0633568093,
0.1557442248,
0.514913857,
-0.1661110222,
0.4962804317,
0.7475351095,
-0.3244008124,
-0.3397605121,
-0.463055253,
-0.0494803675,
0.195561111,
0.3514000773,
-0.0271570086,
0.1943201572,
-0.1538683176,
0.9125908613,
0.0480893217,
0.1062892973,
0.4213334024,
-0.0955056697,
-0.033145465,
-0.2243847996,
0.606218636,
0.3709820807,
0.7031545043,
-0.3479968607,
-0.1114063412,
0.1533201635,
0.2554938197,
-0.9231253266,
-0.3977194428,
0.1583890021,
-0.607442081,
0.1456193179,
-0.0946998671,
-0.6984099746,
-0.0950228497,
-0.3199490011,
0.5420126915,
-0.2999598384,
-0.3325994909,
0.2450498939,
-0.2444756478,
0.1146235839,
0.2215472758,
-0.9923176169,
0.9607297778,
0.4553253949,
0.9025005698,
-0.661737442,
-0.7110019326,
-0.7397515178,
0.0020814221,
-0.2354420871,
1.1653838158,
-0.7780963182,
-0.260609597,
-0.0653565824,
0.0431252979,
-0.5033851862,
-1.0099753141,
0.2843081951,
-0.5798885226,
0.0727359354,
-0.1020765454,
-0.7101842165,
-0.0204177778,
0.1305018067,
-0.4082253277,
0.7862395048,
0.2428713292,
-0.541495502,
0.3615098894,
-0.6803628206,
-0.3412147462,
-0.0938673615,
0.0425328612,
-0.3364598751,
0.4388217032,
0.3164525926,
0.4019435644,
-0.3184755147,
0.0482132547,
-0.5612323284,
-0.2865759432,
0.0475076512,
0.0534615219,
0.3789608777,
0.0211391374,
0.0576311201,
0.3246058226,
-0.7195309401,
0.1662635505,
0.1779982448,
-0.2358321249,
-0.8032770157,
0.2167705745,
0.0613047779,
0.0374131277,
0.1496278942,
-0.3435886502,
0.1640927345,
-0.4510681927,
-0.0285313148,
0.5561931729,
-0.1742991805,
0.7696554065,
-0.4717916846,
0.4989041686,
0.2156270593,
-0.0995295569,
0.0382655561,
-0.4967947006,
-0.7060297728,
-0.0592292808,
0.5887813568,
0.4103710353,
-0.5306578875,
0.3765926957,
-0.5035640597,
-0.4996609092,
-0.3990121484,
0.3834928274,
0.1622842848,
0.1073699817,
0.5536844134,
-0.723383069,
-0.3089950979,
-0.619204998,
-0.9265865684,
0.0717102587,
-0.3731320798,
0.0681377873,
0.1736097336,
-0.1205728129,
0.860963583,
-0.7997118235,
-0.4356593788,
-0.2355982512,
0.1274638772,
0.0783169121,
0.5995384455,
0.9808832407,
-0.6960718036,
-0.7149599791,
-0.0775052607,
-0.4717928767,
-0.1212088466,
0.1083032712,
-0.0735400841,
-0.2195698917,
0.4004905224,
-0.2870188951,
0.02206707,
0.8612866402,
-0.1367360502,
0.4698499143,
-0.4132915139,
-0.094001919,
-0.9885417223,
-0.0287016984,
0.2545753121,
-0.3660996854,
-0.7839869857,
0.1344237775,
-0.067567952,
-0.1977594793,
-0.1537210047,
0.7552928925,
-0.4569801092,
-0.0788974166,
-0.695664227,
0.242860958,
-0.1681079865,
0.5251976848,
0.0896147117,
0.8288049102,
0.710575521,
-0.6985628605,
0.2392215878,
0.0728480816,
-0.1751160622,
0.4054917991,
-0.5859351158,
0.1487042159,
-0.0743357465,
0.2071775198,
-0.9890788198,
0.1089289635,
-0.1305716187,
-0.2873191535,
0.2676544189,
0.0374522656,
-0.2311323881,
-0.1424784809,
-0.3059828281,
0.8058285117,
0.5062570572,
-0.5861368179,
0.872626543,
0.610070169,
-0.5114616156,
-0.2077005059,
-0.2988050282,
-0.2528429329,
-0.3184731305,
-0.3973755836,
0.4734315872,
-0.4167279899,
-0.1315787733,
-0.004003786,
-0.1568976641,
-0.3364315629,
0.0619678795,
0.0802730173,
-0.0901740491,
-0.4495430291,
-0.1187738255,
0.0841730684,
-0.1216562688,
0.0062333611,
-0.7147340775,
0.6443333626,
-0.3486247659,
-0.1936288923,
-0.2224523276,
0.4220710695,
0.4092258215,
-0.1276329011,
0.7727351189,
0.4395720065,
-0.4097570479,
-0.4966338575,
-0.5503271818,
0.0110710645,
-0.4761411846,
0.3942340612,
-0.3272816837,
-0.7392717004,
0.4078641832,
-0.5002596974,
0.1696958989,
0.2830220759,
0.516056776,
0.1328417808,
0.9103475809,
1.0422803164,
-0.3141415417,
0.5490252972,
0.0705131665,
0.1215345636,
-0.7073383331,
0.2501745224,
-0.4316926897,
-0.4211253226,
-0.4446415007,
-0.6154543161,
0.0687798187,
-0.066099003,
0.2909678817,
0.5227960944,
-0.1958005428,
0.5328978896,
0.5220894217,
-0.1804692149,
0.1467104107,
0.2598498464,
-0.0573973171,
-0.0567547642,
-0.7729405165,
-0.1393977553,
1.2878856659,
0.1871411651,
0.5496246219,
0.0426828824,
0.5186157227,
0.0973176435,
0.6407053471,
-0.7948473096,
0.4060138464,
-0.6919407248,
-0.0976594239,
-0.2019515783,
-0.5031884909,
-0.8729765415,
0.4296850264,
-0.0052552852,
-0.366524756,
0.3616071343,
0.3486188948,
-0.3206171095,
0.1556925029,
-0.6847991347,
0.790027976,
-0.0151087055,
-0.0211174209,
-0.3856782019,
-0.3353219628,
0.1000412554,
-0.3437068462,
0.3033411205,
-0.1453047544,
-0.0155385751,
1.1566596031,
-0.2566988766,
0.5315767527,
-0.3831188083,
0.1148481965,
0.2575562596,
-0.080555968,
0.3257167339,
-0.2500524819,
-0.0120533798,
0.2194416523,
0.0391455181,
-0.7558131814,
-0.7757819891,
0.8716678619,
-0.8727425337,
-0.6294111013,
-0.2535651922,
-0.9824271202,
-0.7017398477,
0.2545273304,
-0.1465771645,
0.3540068269,
-0.2924999893,
0.0682375282,
0.6851228476,
-0.2149579823,
0.3997465372,
0.7196132541,
-0.0637621954,
-0.3063076735,
1.2510393858,
0.0212280266,
0.2897997797,
0.4874008298,
0.3453488052,
-0.0353246741,
-0.8783575892,
-0.1994045377,
0.328497231,
-0.4241645932,
-0.1186265349,
-0.5984954834,
-0.0674937516,
-0.5509592891,
0.0665067434,
-0.3026393056,
-0.4866737723,
-0.0210637096,
0.3352951705,
0.0352659114,
0.3599737287,
0.3427872062,
0.751328826,
-0.7599363327,
0.4006814957,
0.4485227764,
0.5444818139,
-0.2118921578,
-0.8020297289,
-0.3062873781,
-0.305295825,
-0.2787195146,
-0.4045466483,
0.350831598,
0.5825557709,
0.6626345515,
0.3753097057,
0.0063594086,
0.7720932961,
-0.8233949542,
0.3776889145,
0.115203172,
-0.7130203247,
0.3411774635,
-0.2087474167,
0.5197052956,
0.6220357418,
0.548401773,
-0.3798078597,
-0.2899588943,
-0.4548122287,
-0.6350098252,
0.5631186366,
0.0467794351,
0.2513923049,
0.1908734739,
0.3732433915,
0.1622579694,
0.2053729892,
-0.5299180746,
-0.1575622708,
-0.0515618809,
-0.4859482646,
-0.1960665733,
-0.1151486114,
-0.1521946341,
-0.2357708663,
0.6350238919,
-0.4651148915,
0.1993783861,
-0.1727805287,
-0.432213366,
-0.1743097603,
0.0491496921,
0.5390132666,
0.9390023947,
-0.1727347672,
0.2237310112,
0.3927592039,
-0.6289869547,
0.0956392512,
0.3118545115,
0.3024922013,
0.1127728298,
0.4394787252,
0.7318486571,
0.2207064778,
-0.7242964506,
0.7662579417,
-0.3722761571,
-0.3011803925,
0.0450165384,
0.1930585057,
0.0403970629,
0.0465684496,
0.158288613,
0.5311526656,
-0.0930393115,
-0.3060033917,
0.2873005271,
0.4606850743,
-0.1529895365,
-0.5858002305,
0.5734248161,
0.3824667037,
-0.2105582058,
0.2104650587,
0.0156257935,
-0.2954597473,
0.4246909916,
0.7990775108,
0.9102906585,
-0.7202987671,
-0.1510409415,
0.1539753228,
0.2233610302,
-0.3322024941,
0.1406165063,
0.0630481765,
-0.9886677861,
-0.4180606902,
-0.8629397154,
-0.3353494406,
0.1220764294,
-0.5993766189,
0.2045987397,
-0.6490876079,
0.0181154069,
-0.1482434124,
-0.0504363105,
-0.7974329591,
0.248815462,
0.0264959559,
1.1150047779,
-1.1284013987,
0.9994445443,
0.8730680943,
0.1492646635,
-0.4359416366,
0.4239755571,
-0.4682952464,
-0.8179951906,
0.2817615867,
0.0619412251,
0.0356331319,
0.1838522553,
-0.0670631006,
-0.9743480086,
0.6532390714,
0.3449970782,
-0.7807549834,
-0.0380352139,
0.2232772708,
0.4795449376,
-0.6979286075,
0.0088574151,
0.7035266757,
0.241194725,
-0.4091548324,
-0.7104182243,
0.1592531651,
-0.3551512957,
0.223085627,
0.1999942958,
-0.5515334606,
0.5751632452,
0.107155256,
-0.0186402351,
0.0295502413,
1.0083047152,
0.3907206357,
0.3881225884,
0.9216554761,
0.5211554766,
0.5797715187,
0.1689810008,
0.8835860491,
-0.3608118892,
0.2599431276,
1.2292755842,
-0.4609076977,
0.9484786987,
0.4560062885,
-0.4265605807,
0.5544179678,
0.2342756838,
0.1145765856,
0.5355420113,
0.1892446131,
-0.2349571586,
-0.2234776467,
0.1069722027,
-0.2997366488,
0.2043648511,
0.3545518219,
-0.0615822077,
-0.2752127647,
0.2841655612,
-0.2579840422,
0.2678481936,
-0.1855873317,
0.7843794227,
0.2907264829,
-0.6216967106,
0.4624997675,
0.050881207,
0.661028266,
-0.8268966079,
0.1356533468,
-0.2286482751,
0.4372121096,
-0.0745246559,
-0.2776793242,
0.3457571268,
-0.192721948,
-0.5191783309,
-0.2214835137,
0.7835037112,
-0.5944066048,
-0.5795060992,
0.6088324785,
0.4494759738,
0.0959767923,
-0.3526266515,
-0.6202399731,
0.0666316152,
-0.4360898137,
-0.2119137496,
0.7573330998,
0.3480217159,
-0.2739847004,
0.4297684431,
0.6288875937,
0.3138920069,
0.194281742,
0.2289179713,
1.0028620958,
-0.3116204143,
-0.4256088436,
-0.5864534974,
0.009748782,
0.0651436076,
-0.2001764923,
0.8320558667,
0.5938152671,
0.9151206613,
-0.2040466964,
0.7978876829,
0.2047613412,
0.5587480068,
-0.3764812052,
0.6049203873,
-0.6171670556,
0.2585104704,
-0.253143698,
-1.3269234896,
-0.5584486127,
0.293567121,
-0.5067008734,
0.1172751933,
0.7755212784,
0.6322280765,
-0.4888683558,
-0.2406193316,
0.3627703786,
0.1731234044,
0.2819164097,
0.400228858,
0.4323539734,
-0.4938137531,
0.5149435401,
-0.0639359057,
-0.6032962799,
-0.0653415695,
-0.8272346854,
-0.99739182,
-0.4288125932,
-0.3784984648,
-0.0867550001,
0.0821779668,
0.8610612154,
0.7637422085,
-1.2069073915,
-0.595736444,
-0.0747197941,
-0.0953644589,
-0.6157788634,
-0.2024769336,
0.3863013387,
-0.6882930994,
-0.8224458694,
0.5095052719,
0.1557472199,
-0.209384352,
0.134539783,
0.0048762416,
0.0724677667,
0.2685710788,
0.5753455162,
0.24405545,
-0.2826176882,
-0.1234812438,
-0.3587414324,
0.434479326,
0.0305815935,
1.119223237,
-0.7716221213,
0.4625990391,
0.5279065967,
0.8590769768,
0.2617910802,
0.1180972457,
0.8761755228,
-0.8367574215,
0.3469890058,
0.0050825733,
0.3920597732,
0.3077123165,
0.053547442,
0.1181352809,
0.4730828106,
-0.5471823215,
-0.7550241947,
0.0707599372,
-0.8989150524,
-0.3808077276,
0.9010412097,
-0.3314500451,
-0.2383960485,
0.0305769537,
0.2521015108,
0.076617144,
-0.1458536237,
0.7086288929,
0.6069892645,
-0.0532500818,
0.0488187931,
-0.544570744,
0.4811467826,
0.6978391409,
-0.9552433491,
0.1259492636,
-0.1943669915,
0.768078506,
0.1556570232,
0.6792912483,
0.0556726381,
0.0905980095,
-0.1591218114,
-0.072836943,
0.2976610661,
-0.6073133349,
-0.4355820417,
0.210628137,
0.2570987046,
-0.4080228806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07729v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07729v3 | Generation of Highlights from Research Papers Using Pointer-Generator Networks and SciBERT Embeddings | 2023-02-14T12:45:14 | 2023-09-17T16:45:44 | Tohida Rehman, Debarshi Kumar Sanyal, Samiran Chattopadhyay, Plaban Kumar Bhowmick, Partha Pratim Das | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Nowadays many research articles are prefaced with research highlights to
summarize the main findings of the paper. Highlights not only help researchers
precisely and quickly identify the contributions of a paper, they also enhance
the discoverability of the article via search engines. We aim to automatically
construct research highlights given certain segments of a research paper. We
use a pointer-generator network with coverage mechanism and a contextual
embedding layer at the input that encodes the input tokens into SciBERT
embeddings. We test our model on a benchmark dataset, CSPubSum, and also
present MixSub, a new multi-disciplinary corpus of papers for automatic
research highlight generation. For both CSPubSum and MixSub, we have observed
that the proposed model achieves the best performance compared to related
variants and other models proposed in the literature. On the CSPubSum dataset,
our model achieves the best performance when the input is only the abstract of
a paper as opposed to other segments of the paper. It produces ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2
and ROUGE-L F1-scores of 38.26, 14.26 and 35.51, respectively, METEOR score of
32.62, and BERTScore F1 of 86.65 which outperform all other baselines. On the
new MixSub dataset, where only the abstract is the input, our proposed model
(when trained on the whole training corpus without distinguishing between the
subject categories) achieves ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2 and ROUGE-L F1-scores of 31.78,
9.76 and 29.3, respectively, METEOR score of 24.00, and BERTScore F1 of 85.25. | [
-0.4201028049,
-0.5056911707,
0.510604322,
0.7220147252,
-0.3484026194,
0.039247293,
-0.055306498,
-0.3374935985,
0.8436731696,
0.0370396227,
0.0304746367,
-0.5065099597,
-0.603713274,
0.1506944597,
-0.921108067,
1.298640728,
0.0514212027,
-0.0913669914,
-0.0438027754,
-0.0890733376,
-0.1988914311,
-0.1478762031,
-0.1745565087,
-0.1016573906,
0.88551718,
0.2194433957,
0.3200071454,
0.667337358,
0.3015007079,
0.210595876,
-0.2752425969,
0.3866216242,
-0.4922862053,
0.3075258732,
-0.297495991,
-0.0130689451,
-0.3917539716,
-0.1960467994,
0.5307204127,
0.7211969495,
0.3559028208,
0.0800541863,
0.3843749166,
0.3729158938,
-0.7304344773,
-0.0845965669,
-0.5774034262,
0.0328444503,
-0.1715174466,
-0.6630000472,
-0.5215122104,
-0.4544852376,
0.1269296706,
-0.5249133706,
0.5408531427,
-0.148095116,
0.9401045442,
-0.287779361,
-0.3776168525,
-0.170150876,
-0.5537580252,
0.6497448683,
-0.3422974944,
-0.0274504218,
0.0556094609,
0.0869503617,
0.0785626471,
-0.96283108,
-0.1035909206,
0.0212289002,
-0.2155014575,
0.3346553445,
-0.112776652,
-0.2840123773,
0.2122716606,
0.107341215,
-0.5494092703,
-0.4157147706,
-0.6534004807,
-0.0136703337,
0.6587545276,
0.1909683645,
-0.2562399805,
-0.4546339512,
-0.0542429574,
-0.2708503306,
-0.7821686864,
-0.0465720333,
0.3259271085,
0.1985966563,
0.1419906616,
0.5299161077,
-0.2150354236,
0.5123606324,
0.3990696371,
-0.0680127293,
0.2933061421,
-0.4753097892,
0.0656870306,
0.1381240934,
0.8238626719,
0.2415434718,
-0.1321149766,
-0.2575860322,
-0.034896072,
-0.4634714425,
0.1704867929,
-1.1483466625,
-0.6705154777,
-0.0807571486,
-0.3954395354,
-0.3949711323,
0.3374986053,
-0.5530107617,
-0.2702427506,
-0.2995546162,
0.3950062692,
-0.476814121,
-0.0638001189,
-0.2953293025,
-0.3369620442,
0.0319689102,
0.5740673542,
-0.6931295991,
-0.0933334529,
0.4034683704,
0.9605717063,
-0.2876353264,
-0.3030608892,
-0.2970866561,
0.242387563,
-0.2048137784,
0.7470336556,
-0.3637405038,
-0.6030555964,
-0.0145617118,
-0.1921770424,
-0.1928748935,
-0.2024316192,
0.4960667193,
-0.428755343,
0.1873330325,
-0.227051571,
-0.4031373858,
-0.064987056,
0.0194662306,
-0.5700818896,
1.1951217651,
0.1272117943,
-1.3706024885,
0.6126919985,
-0.5917884111,
-0.5471806526,
-0.1465538889,
-0.3831135929,
-0.6817817092,
0.1362204105,
0.3886578083,
0.4429466426,
-0.0264224149,
0.5996854901,
-0.3594349623,
-0.3378276825,
0.3384530842,
0.169254899,
0.6569793224,
0.0378443412,
-0.2011268288,
0.5256664157,
-0.7624456882,
-0.0667238757,
0.0548241213,
-0.3200344443,
-0.2432205379,
-0.0639282539,
0.6248928308,
0.2170168459,
0.0613623895,
-0.550588727,
-0.0701131895,
-0.0306211598,
0.2571335137,
0.593642354,
0.2511504292,
0.3926778734,
-0.4875064492,
0.4480696321,
0.0129363555,
-0.133574754,
-0.6386068463,
-0.4864409566,
-0.8475579619,
-0.5400304794,
0.6649593711,
0.2943138778,
-0.3026019037,
0.7896451354,
-0.2506791949,
-0.4280406237,
-0.3038871288,
-0.0458601974,
0.1766074896,
0.6979948878,
0.3924259543,
-0.2334341705,
-0.7448705435,
-1.1389387846,
-0.0660087019,
0.2557824254,
-0.0219193306,
0.3392227888,
0.7189717889,
0.2482797503,
1.293050766,
-0.6217153072,
0.0251391791,
-0.3656766713,
0.3958701193,
0.2090563625,
0.6352288127,
0.6994233131,
-0.8324059248,
-0.7765885592,
-0.1956606209,
-0.6295503378,
-0.1746641099,
0.026268281,
-0.2458803356,
-0.3799369335,
0.4850010574,
-0.2678543329,
0.4977586567,
0.0542839728,
-0.3913609684,
0.6749312282,
-0.1014048681,
0.0422756299,
-1.1562246084,
0.6835323572,
0.0618104711,
-0.1724769771,
-0.5559409857,
-0.1864777505,
0.2507839501,
-0.2900246978,
-0.4404496849,
0.5622544289,
-0.2589677572,
-0.0518740974,
-0.4378691912,
-0.0909456164,
0.5027055144,
0.3341457844,
0.1963707209,
0.6215621829,
0.6645179987,
-0.4751223922,
-0.4219372272,
0.171186626,
-0.1805337667,
0.0966019109,
-0.8794425726,
-0.1852978766,
-0.1257255673,
0.3692198992,
-0.7506277561,
-0.1779328883,
-0.1183952764,
-0.2897956371,
0.2343503386,
-0.0258798096,
-0.7374693155,
-0.0768394172,
-0.3434312344,
0.4118224978,
0.3609962463,
-0.381708622,
0.4128590226,
0.2199976891,
-0.3378189802,
-0.5165181756,
-0.3464657366,
-0.044802554,
-0.2766987085,
-0.8903716207,
0.8693497777,
0.1563972831,
0.0909135491,
-0.0974796116,
0.1903774291,
-0.0022758474,
0.1665280163,
0.5674920082,
0.0673332661,
-0.0240522176,
-0.113714762,
0.3000378609,
0.0900538415,
0.0946808904,
-0.1330122501,
0.452139467,
-0.0113114063,
-0.3772125542,
0.0964789018,
0.7155399919,
0.174051702,
-0.2962730825,
0.4454633296,
0.5943921804,
-0.097068347,
-0.3940660059,
-0.2513530552,
-0.5533034801,
-0.3826175034,
0.3430696726,
-0.1471744776,
-0.8543408513,
0.8795216084,
0.0507147908,
0.3377549946,
0.5784201026,
0.5608962774,
-0.1730970591,
1.0100977421,
0.7655844092,
0.1653837115,
0.7245947123,
-0.4492745399,
0.0794572681,
-0.8226630092,
-0.2866208851,
-0.7524289489,
-0.4524097145,
-0.4915437996,
-0.4124203622,
0.6658052206,
0.3677462041,
0.0095007904,
0.2948257029,
-0.645906806,
0.2657690942,
0.8191187382,
0.1824315041,
0.1970302165,
0.3069321215,
-0.3508917093,
-0.1520715207,
-0.7961143851,
-0.2668371499,
1.2575312853,
0.2711575329,
0.6559228301,
-0.2408495545,
1.1017161608,
0.2071439624,
0.5497596264,
-0.3515331447,
0.3995145857,
0.0627858713,
-0.4912373722,
0.147953108,
-0.0902817473,
-1.0045095682,
0.5847477913,
-0.2095127106,
-0.5107896924,
0.6318348646,
0.0507961437,
-0.2779318392,
-0.0284451116,
-0.2075894475,
0.4720746577,
-0.1339583248,
-0.8580194116,
-0.0366785526,
-0.3946284056,
0.5538374782,
0.021310091,
-0.0773720071,
0.1222951487,
0.4312136173,
1.0795886517,
-0.1640366465,
0.5567477942,
-0.0483843535,
0.4226025045,
0.2404660434,
-0.0706991255,
0.3721658289,
0.3266195655,
-0.0324361362,
-0.2365366817,
-0.4429172873,
-0.3528271019,
-0.2446701974,
0.6845768094,
-0.5871255398,
-0.4341450334,
-0.4879069328,
-0.7109815478,
0.0275358912,
0.3838742971,
0.385347873,
0.3572229147,
-0.2587997913,
0.3161023855,
0.7923570871,
-0.105212532,
0.5879368782,
0.4633295238,
-0.406155318,
-0.5162326694,
0.7605466247,
-0.0363404043,
-0.356965661,
0.2083218694,
0.150082916,
-0.137298882,
-0.8167006373,
-0.3285496533,
0.1682558358,
-0.8491445184,
-0.2191477418,
-1.1244844198,
-0.381619066,
-0.5028018951,
-0.3487830758,
-0.0471400917,
-0.6647763848,
-0.4780030549,
-0.0938748792,
0.3162338436,
0.5390456319,
-0.2243318111,
0.1011870801,
-0.5003896356,
0.1048202813,
0.2141437531,
-0.176022023,
0.026755631,
-0.6374269724,
-0.4849794209,
-0.4728463292,
-0.684591949,
-0.931594789,
0.6044103503,
0.0767113194,
0.6370854378,
0.5411115885,
-0.254658103,
0.4306091666,
-0.5689465404,
0.35856691,
0.3411562443,
-0.5346114039,
0.7839033008,
-0.8086889386,
0.1831510216,
0.882956624,
0.3712054193,
-0.0344064757,
-0.6560454965,
-0.8553940654,
-1.2127782106,
0.5920286179,
0.3316540122,
-0.2696357667,
-0.0861554667,
0.0072681974,
0.1015162244,
0.2559479773,
-0.7266524434,
-0.1908250004,
-0.4349445999,
0.0402865671,
0.4035663307,
-0.1695086062,
-0.5392357707,
-0.2231423259,
0.5725438595,
-0.2987686396,
0.2874134183,
0.4168338478,
-0.1594362557,
0.0937542617,
0.07191322,
0.8357748389,
1.3328777552,
-0.5918436646,
0.1532402188,
-0.409155935,
-0.3714244962,
-0.2225973606,
0.5163447857,
-0.6991261244,
0.4821483791,
0.3707875907,
0.6206795573,
0.2141865343,
-0.3495909572,
0.5240104198,
-0.0017851653,
-0.3934642971,
-0.2073161006,
0.1067810282,
0.1717980653,
-0.060448695,
0.8016071916,
0.2289075106,
0.4238005579,
-0.2111186534,
0.4632558525,
0.2055203021,
-0.1057017073,
-0.3238455653,
0.5530686975,
0.2142002136,
0.2245550752,
0.0671285614,
-0.333416611,
-0.6289662719,
0.8216705918,
0.4962554872,
0.7863768935,
0.1569036692,
0.171897918,
0.6207098961,
-0.005688034,
0.0621161237,
0.3133249581,
0.0031993908,
-0.3556440473,
-0.4403015077,
-0.7636681199,
-0.423548013,
0.0960836411,
-0.7365992069,
0.3017731607,
-0.4269024134,
-0.1616225392,
0.3129217923,
-0.0199799165,
-0.7373249531,
-0.0384327099,
-0.0813383088,
1.0526684523,
-1.1434988976,
0.9331928492,
0.7103911638,
-0.4366243184,
-0.584523201,
-0.2358912081,
-0.3354726732,
-0.2117562145,
1.1261703968,
0.2802478969,
0.2199522853,
-0.2391628474,
-0.2059671283,
-0.8883802295,
1.2479400635,
0.0895210057,
-0.3795223534,
0.0862105563,
-0.1493050903,
0.4058614969,
-0.6872762442,
0.8040602803,
0.0892227516,
0.446277678,
-0.0574266501,
-0.7780689597,
0.0104831457,
-0.4428347945,
-0.1046210751,
-0.0146519952,
-0.4926535785,
1.1640502214,
0.1383049339,
-0.0173989311,
-0.1690284312,
0.9578201175,
0.898976028,
0.2916572392,
0.1979365498,
0.5357797146,
0.5174359083,
0.0178763475,
0.8500602245,
-0.5385077596,
0.2379979491,
1.1065026522,
-0.2365089059,
0.4555129111,
0.5644003749,
0.055220779,
0.5237407088,
0.5656949282,
-0.3548134863,
0.8381528854,
0.1926660389,
-0.0834452584,
-0.0841940567,
-0.1901530772,
-0.5568245053,
0.2040994763,
0.3751684725,
-1.0388845205,
-0.554646492,
-0.1693942845,
0.0596517995,
0.1027827039,
-0.0927170366,
0.5252998471,
-0.0658848211,
-0.8533943295,
0.277592659,
0.4625983238,
0.647277236,
-0.6243414283,
-0.0907171369,
-0.4249579906,
0.0298751611,
-0.3379901052,
-0.6754871011,
0.1623969078,
-0.0920640901,
-0.5725944042,
-0.4190554619,
0.7889487743,
-0.362108767,
-0.7179189324,
0.140204072,
0.523296833,
0.0114402473,
0.1561927348,
-0.678198874,
-0.0968304425,
-0.0525226071,
-0.3243998587,
0.6507041454,
0.2247424275,
-0.163582474,
0.1977794766,
0.7225825787,
0.1784704924,
0.2621708512,
-0.0028529628,
1.1345562935,
-0.4597475231,
-1.0238150358,
-0.5030211806,
0.5906341076,
-0.5283084512,
-0.4594788551,
1.0494785309,
1.0352207422,
0.3727710545,
-0.0227132086,
0.8899371624,
-0.3144066334,
0.5352535248,
-0.1794458926,
0.7117547989,
-0.2809964716,
-0.0204750318,
-0.0967705548,
-0.8563905358,
-0.2464369684,
0.6461637616,
-0.1387497932,
0.0831909478,
0.7035377026,
0.7143160701,
-0.4128198028,
-0.0365574025,
-0.2043839991,
-0.2695364952,
0.5071223378,
0.3290707469,
0.5768533349,
-0.2657773495,
0.4407559037,
-0.5744853616,
0.0159608368,
-0.6382349133,
-1.0998197794,
-1.1662504673,
-0.4242042005,
-0.3505770266,
-0.5401504636,
0.049780231,
0.3320607841,
0.9917442799,
-1.0671889782,
-0.1412320435,
-0.0619730093,
0.0456521101,
-0.071912393,
-0.3026309013,
1.0558514595,
-0.171168372,
-0.527363956,
0.5596343279,
0.1892190725,
-0.2921608686,
-0.4640838802,
0.029891625,
-0.3618297875,
-0.2401437014,
0.3449569941,
0.308760047,
-0.3488579988,
0.1261222214,
0.0768090114,
-0.2259453684,
0.1854961365,
1.1812498569,
-0.7993549109,
0.2477304488,
0.9523839355,
0.5405344963,
0.8545967937,
0.0899064094,
0.3226379156,
-1.0566296577,
0.2628138661,
0.5003408194,
0.6345152259,
0.3390309811,
-0.1973524243,
0.2953834236,
0.1311185807,
-0.4709767103,
-0.7582334876,
-0.1686465144,
-1.0025732517,
-0.2376555502,
0.8160918355,
-0.2661292553,
-0.091942966,
-0.009860184,
0.0231919531,
0.0888358578,
-0.7106885314,
0.9123334885,
0.3172545135,
-0.4366642535,
-0.0963397548,
-0.4722940624,
0.456969589,
0.6065180898,
-0.7187920213,
-0.2745133042,
0.4656050801,
0.3533642888,
0.6271160841,
0.4681526721,
-0.1323858052,
0.6475332975,
-0.1528755724,
0.0529755279,
-0.5120981932,
-0.5487340689,
-0.0093656015,
0.7547731996,
-0.0601761639,
0.1899385601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06976v1 | Investigating Multi-source Active Learning for Natural Language Inference | 2023-02-14T11:10:18 | 2023-02-14T11:10:18 | Ard Snijders, Douwe Kiela, Katerina Margatina | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, active learning has been successfully applied to an array of
NLP tasks. However, prior work often assumes that training and test data are
drawn from the same distribution. This is problematic, as in real-life settings
data may stem from several sources of varying relevance and quality. We show
that four popular active learning schemes fail to outperform random selection
when applied to unlabelled pools comprised of multiple data sources on the task
of natural language inference. We reveal that uncertainty-based strategies
perform poorly due to the acquisition of collective outliers, i.e.,
hard-to-learn instances that hamper learning and generalization. When outliers
are removed, strategies are found to recover and outperform random baselines.
In further analysis, we find that collective outliers vary in form between
sources, and show that hard-to-learn data is not always categorically harmful.
Lastly, we leverage dataset cartography to introduce difficulty-stratified
testing and find that different strategies are affected differently by example
learnability and difficulty. | [
0.0631629974,
-1.0399264097,
0.3933642507,
0.0284110457,
-0.1896241605,
0.1632501483,
-0.5708226562,
-0.4132301509,
-0.101355575,
0.3353091478,
-0.3695477247,
-0.411708653,
-0.6111988425,
0.0387806371,
-0.2868218124,
0.9444893003,
-0.131750986,
0.0368686169,
0.0878046229,
-0.4466027021,
-0.2900495827,
-0.3423917592,
-0.7412385345,
-0.1461342722,
0.4489382505,
0.5682960749,
0.8670823574,
0.3656266928,
0.2754605412,
0.2218251824,
0.057975512,
0.4999438524,
-0.2665352523,
0.4803171158,
-0.0057907281,
-0.6426308751,
0.2798062563,
0.261779815,
0.6945695877,
0.9623883367,
-0.2393837869,
-0.2477656603,
0.0568674095,
0.5511441827,
-0.8272302747,
0.1042806879,
-0.7507305741,
0.1663158387,
-0.1733669788,
0.3320819438,
-0.4726500213,
-0.3864260912,
0.2726437449,
-0.5972502828,
0.6491777897,
0.1238988191,
0.8514308333,
0.4408701658,
-0.6320633292,
-0.6693023443,
-0.9417024851,
1.0030846596,
-0.6119094491,
0.1412963271,
0.6790810227,
0.4765376449,
-0.2030891627,
-0.667560935,
-0.4419139922,
-0.1921844482,
0.0370093249,
0.1738976538,
-0.1607848555,
-0.1416946948,
0.0506096967,
0.2858203351,
-0.2994271219,
0.1703755856,
-0.3962806165,
-0.0132301236,
0.6054123044,
-0.5167051554,
0.1475915015,
-0.2589443624,
-0.3107888699,
-0.3474745154,
-0.4709497392,
0.0529774129,
0.6235095859,
0.7387337089,
0.0833173618,
0.5589738488,
0.1197186634,
0.7552810311,
-0.3006798923,
0.1262069046,
0.3829847872,
-0.4152377546,
-0.2132238597,
0.0261493735,
0.726569891,
-0.3754034042,
0.1428590864,
-0.3568327129,
-0.0630308464,
-0.1121571064,
0.3707923293,
0.1296449304,
-0.4568070471,
0.2328459918,
-0.1801111549,
-0.0302411206,
0.1889901012,
-0.6876162291,
-0.2546477318,
-0.167816326,
0.5472106338,
-0.5156971216,
-0.2149595916,
-0.0042088786,
-0.2773543894,
0.0286111608,
0.285495609,
-0.7222313285,
0.264988631,
0.2479982376,
0.7231541276,
-0.457541585,
-0.3655225635,
-0.557687521,
0.0467945859,
-0.2186943293,
0.9293354154,
-0.5650099516,
-0.0201500896,
-0.0728429779,
-0.1328377426,
-0.3407931626,
-0.5277740955,
0.6774658561,
-0.4140935242,
0.3670863509,
-0.2260909528,
-0.3897972405,
-0.409917593,
-0.0652506202,
-0.9524168968,
1.2384043932,
0.0673807636,
-0.5333259702,
0.6863809824,
-0.4464585781,
-0.52372545,
-0.2458123267,
-0.1941185892,
-0.6939454675,
0.1784642935,
0.1020046696,
0.4827638865,
0.0744178966,
0.20794411,
-0.3759950995,
-0.1942518204,
0.0651049837,
-0.6513684988,
0.9587560892,
0.1656473279,
-0.5328319669,
-0.0443114229,
-0.8080522418,
-0.0668824613,
0.123082757,
-0.4292339087,
-0.6809657812,
0.3135922253,
-0.3074339032,
0.080036819,
-0.4533213079,
-0.2752809823,
0.2112250775,
-0.2301081866,
0.251930505,
0.6415013671,
0.2533515096,
0.5958020091,
-0.1174988523,
0.3109495342,
-0.0249017533,
0.0107609956,
0.3431681693,
-0.6668693423,
-0.6837748289,
-0.3480431437,
0.3466411531,
0.4720806777,
-1.0517530441,
0.3468631208,
0.1305304915,
-0.6013436913,
-0.5805498958,
0.5536093712,
0.3536793292,
0.3763718009,
0.6426908374,
-0.1871467531,
-0.2379427552,
-0.7169197202,
-0.3636777401,
-0.1482949704,
-0.0995968506,
0.0575477555,
0.343663305,
0.1141229644,
0.9146314859,
-0.331412822,
-0.1873802245,
-0.4330692291,
0.4435942173,
0.0733908266,
0.3033621311,
0.6138502955,
-0.8128856421,
-0.3429201543,
-0.3824613392,
-0.6540292501,
0.1125690192,
-0.2046506554,
-0.3036842942,
0.0136146564,
0.3006672561,
-0.4556246102,
0.1979935169,
0.6563593149,
-0.2973470688,
0.2263426483,
-0.2071664035,
-0.1143106818,
-0.8957350254,
-0.2812716663,
0.2125005275,
0.1961746216,
-0.6670816541,
-0.0294380337,
0.0287329759,
0.2023890465,
-0.4613305628,
0.2530480027,
-0.7653042078,
-0.0386742838,
-0.0067038485,
0.0237006228,
0.0388986915,
0.5122858882,
0.1161881089,
0.5277618766,
0.7068163157,
-0.8090177178,
0.3141806126,
0.1524084508,
-0.327716738,
0.2284007967,
-0.2995912731,
0.1489476711,
-0.3653302491,
0.1948931217,
-1.0239752531,
-0.2313442677,
0.2184961289,
-0.1648058295,
0.3956646621,
-0.1040765941,
-0.4671074152,
-0.0972347558,
-0.1358594298,
0.2580833137,
0.196523726,
-0.5324491858,
0.4053445756,
0.3048524559,
0.1705076993,
-0.7317465544,
-0.8945776224,
-0.1558800936,
-0.327462554,
-0.1173873767,
-0.2315659523,
0.2125070542,
-0.4904501438,
-0.0286085662,
-0.1635252833,
-0.3718419075,
0.319229871,
0.1347251236,
-0.1103457808,
-0.0547464415,
0.5843783021,
0.0006656886,
0.150869891,
-0.0465816557,
-0.0820319131,
-0.0749073923,
0.1388991624,
-1.0313808918,
0.0236480832,
0.3376072645,
-0.0089788269,
-0.1818608046,
0.774148345,
0.5621951818,
-0.414375931,
-0.690151453,
-0.3038048148,
-0.3370122015,
-0.3578256071,
0.0795459673,
0.1143121123,
-0.4293684959,
0.2865906954,
0.0708272681,
0.5398863554,
0.4675843716,
0.2312610447,
-0.0854378417,
0.6349762678,
0.2636497319,
0.2182730436,
0.5073401332,
-0.4327532947,
0.351454556,
-0.2673819065,
-0.0720731393,
-0.6638798118,
-0.3912644684,
-0.2974542379,
-0.6685640216,
0.065827325,
0.1625690311,
0.0135102505,
0.2045926303,
-0.334385246,
0.2332776338,
0.9521861672,
0.2545238733,
0.5147286057,
0.2583934069,
-0.00642379,
-0.1741096675,
-0.8946026564,
-0.4052986205,
1.1338602304,
-0.0385314412,
0.7600352168,
0.5290493965,
0.4645035863,
0.2044636756,
0.47088781,
-0.7306782603,
0.014504795,
-0.1239256039,
-0.8867211342,
-0.6538606286,
-0.5552346706,
-1.3150367737,
0.3334755599,
-0.5579161048,
-0.2307068557,
0.3504615724,
0.1746916771,
-0.451294452,
0.5091827512,
-1.1641938686,
0.656485498,
-0.2263832986,
-0.3701316714,
0.2676762938,
-0.7136527896,
0.4901120365,
-0.2967176139,
0.4875371754,
-0.2220559865,
0.0637521073,
0.7410597205,
-0.0581051111,
0.9671464562,
-0.2519188523,
0.1445347816,
0.7066329122,
-0.1527165771,
0.4849387705,
0.2200663388,
-0.41813007,
0.0388010368,
-0.6532081962,
-0.7078085542,
-0.6341078877,
0.3273362815,
-0.8862000704,
-0.1744117141,
-0.4301465154,
-0.2082850486,
-0.5551633835,
0.0723425075,
0.2996580005,
0.3512699306,
-0.0728198588,
0.3268415928,
0.6681041718,
-0.0782365277,
0.6788218021,
0.4257668853,
0.609588623,
-0.2415621281,
0.7647930384,
0.2744721472,
0.5477074385,
0.1435586512,
0.0954926908,
-0.3181540072,
-0.9163264036,
-0.3382786214,
0.1283946931,
-0.6952696443,
-0.1811032742,
-0.4880207479,
-0.0435265936,
-0.3382589817,
-0.0622056127,
-0.5145542622,
-0.3297522962,
-0.4106111825,
-0.4798335433,
0.3814788163,
0.6757404208,
-0.112950854,
0.2586230338,
-0.6116703749,
0.3993780911,
0.6806311607,
0.1925503314,
-0.1173399538,
-0.4256236851,
-0.1729444712,
0.1732324064,
-0.1498420388,
-1.0727263689,
0.2404294908,
0.6045364738,
1.0281689167,
0.3609091938,
0.4892228842,
0.419233799,
-0.2328827232,
0.65521878,
0.0025940484,
-0.4517741203,
0.5522246957,
-0.0901786461,
0.236016795,
1.020313859,
0.4557645619,
-0.2338689268,
-0.7652232051,
-0.9193696976,
-1.1317447424,
0.5241528749,
0.4543687999,
0.0533393845,
-0.1781910062,
0.3547813296,
0.4226232767,
0.1766560525,
-0.8428040743,
-0.5694931149,
-0.2617094815,
-0.1537217349,
-0.4229493141,
0.0951953679,
-0.2081509382,
-0.0774367377,
0.6336436868,
-0.3378487825,
0.1308271438,
0.1755670011,
-0.3045475781,
-0.1913506389,
0.2204493582,
0.2313659489,
0.5692780614,
-0.1546684206,
0.5306358337,
0.208929643,
-0.5637557507,
0.1173989773,
0.1150164977,
-0.0177581739,
0.255256623,
0.7389567494,
0.8375768661,
0.5392129421,
-0.5654968619,
0.4602673054,
-0.1770924628,
-0.343344897,
-0.2335102856,
0.158685416,
-0.0944286585,
-0.0502597727,
0.9320013523,
0.3128888607,
-0.0606082752,
-0.6268823743,
0.3233362734,
0.3710229993,
-0.5926399231,
-0.2211659253,
0.4258033335,
0.075628452,
-0.1056528017,
0.6428471804,
-0.3701331019,
-0.0351849981,
0.6185183525,
0.1633293182,
0.5379955769,
-0.2560769916,
0.3171959817,
0.2622191012,
0.5016428232,
-0.525662303,
0.1404374242,
0.1518596858,
-0.8740334511,
-0.6077947617,
-0.3284491301,
-0.5858961344,
0.0363722555,
-0.7191582322,
0.2295205444,
-0.2029306889,
0.021812208,
-0.0706161112,
0.1125041991,
-0.5202966928,
0.106239289,
-0.0725005046,
0.6501790881,
-1.3357656002,
0.7104977965,
0.9144941568,
-0.2443891615,
-0.7966570854,
0.0005320638,
0.0863124579,
-0.6918374896,
0.1539792866,
0.0068785134,
0.3494084179,
0.0024529351,
-0.5673596859,
-0.9471944571,
0.8326894045,
0.4499519169,
-0.0121293897,
-0.0075162007,
-0.3296238482,
0.4844023883,
0.0690541714,
0.1601734012,
0.3201323152,
0.4786507785,
0.1455425471,
-0.6238616705,
-0.1570062786,
0.0599152185,
-0.57482934,
0.2967525721,
-0.5700055361,
0.7985324264,
-0.2394023538,
-0.290266484,
-0.7426832318,
0.840752542,
0.424713105,
0.3691368997,
0.8177394271,
0.3996994197,
0.9844734669,
-0.1103644222,
0.7153109312,
0.2983268499,
0.2620130479,
1.080893755,
-0.0501798429,
0.8912236094,
0.4905125201,
-0.1673515141,
0.4390675128,
0.7999856472,
-0.0261308216,
0.6198938489,
0.0904949307,
-0.2520754635,
-0.3180404603,
0.265073657,
-0.1663005501,
0.6998916268,
0.5001811385,
-0.2605396211,
-0.6299760938,
0.1276823878,
-0.0708229616,
0.2272669077,
-0.022598641,
0.6306136847,
0.0528750606,
-0.7172058225,
0.2728543878,
-0.3396469951,
0.5797701478,
-0.6782802343,
-0.2072812319,
-0.0656892508,
-0.1692574024,
-0.1127289459,
-0.5677022338,
0.3620477617,
-0.306979835,
0.1046913266,
-0.3758550882,
0.583963871,
-0.416438669,
-0.4810000658,
0.3072932363,
0.9454264641,
0.2374534011,
-0.0520782545,
-0.8335199356,
-0.3351273239,
0.1020045355,
-0.6864811778,
0.3851993382,
0.6204761863,
-0.1319604367,
0.5915353894,
0.6874270439,
0.1154609248,
0.2445067465,
0.0693893284,
0.6650417447,
-0.4087010622,
-0.1643190235,
-0.6263637543,
0.3199815452,
-0.1923767179,
-0.4080840647,
0.9831434488,
0.4329395592,
0.7451272607,
0.2246491909,
0.8018918633,
0.0969749093,
0.5234259963,
-0.5974135995,
0.4039153457,
-0.3170749843,
0.1954034567,
0.0549560674,
-0.9361658692,
-0.5934432149,
0.6110668778,
-0.1406865716,
0.02044666,
0.8661109805,
0.3553280234,
-0.2368954271,
0.0031374916,
0.0499382168,
0.0305180717,
0.1009402722,
0.3648356199,
0.536875844,
-0.2767546177,
0.8368597627,
-0.471029222,
-0.2479219437,
-0.1200814247,
-0.8247858286,
-0.7147546411,
-0.4815165699,
-0.301348418,
-0.293815285,
0.1545100957,
0.7666620016,
0.6440950632,
-0.9676585793,
0.1110171676,
-0.2428335696,
0.5304253697,
-0.6547576785,
-0.1869843304,
0.4550205469,
-0.5118581057,
-0.8851832151,
0.6789778471,
-0.1931546032,
0.1624903232,
-0.2010724097,
0.1906913519,
-0.6295377016,
-0.2324513942,
0.2521820366,
0.5094026327,
-0.4277326763,
-0.3374034166,
-0.226606518,
-0.1990613937,
-0.0310897417,
0.6881437898,
-0.639926672,
0.3544181883,
0.3677349091,
0.5794277787,
0.296202004,
0.0991796404,
0.6449860334,
-1.1243038177,
0.2012711465,
0.3536159992,
0.2027549446,
0.3072976172,
-0.1568712443,
0.6758856773,
0.4399270117,
-0.3802957237,
-0.8714544773,
0.1232238635,
-0.8155093193,
-0.5699282289,
1.4866695404,
-0.1732066423,
-0.1194816455,
-0.8066596985,
0.1536997855,
0.400785774,
-0.4302507341,
0.8646195531,
0.8041847348,
-0.2210000008,
-0.0376971886,
-1.0867475271,
0.6959686875,
0.4465369284,
-0.6291489005,
-0.0230933316,
0.447263062,
-0.0416615568,
0.2382528335,
0.2507031262,
0.4161824286,
-0.0464450382,
-0.0514478944,
-0.0039793411,
0.1923960149,
-0.1731908172,
-0.3375814557,
0.4644699991,
0.1860546917,
-0.1146279648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06951v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06951v1 | Few-shot learning approaches for classifying low resource domain specific software requirements | 2023-02-14T10:19:23 | 2023-02-14T10:19:23 | Anmol Nayak, Hari Prasad Timmapathini, Vidhya Murali, Atul Anil Gohad | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the advent of strong pre-trained natural language processing models like
BERT, DeBERTa, MiniLM, T5, the data requirement for industries to fine-tune
these models to their niche use cases has drastically reduced (typically to a
few hundred annotated samples for achieving a reasonable performance). However,
the availability of even a few hundred annotated samples may not always be
guaranteed in low resource domains like automotive, which often limits the
usage of such deep learning models in an industrial setting. In this paper we
aim to address the challenge of fine-tuning such pre-trained models with only a
few annotated samples, also known as Few-shot learning. Our experiments focus
on evaluating the performance of a diverse set of algorithms and methodologies
to achieve the task of classifying BOSCH automotive domain textual software
requirements into 3 categories, while utilizing only 15 annotated samples per
category for fine-tuning. We find that while SciBERT and DeBERTa based models
tend to be the most accurate at 15 training samples, their performance
improvement scales minimally as the number of annotated samples is increased to
50 in comparison to Siamese and T5 based models. | [
-0.7318811417,
-0.4130031168,
0.4737194777,
-0.1244751662,
-0.1706782281,
-0.0590331927,
-0.1841716021,
-0.7171267867,
-0.3867110312,
0.3775521815,
-0.9965156317,
-0.7140023708,
-0.4800819159,
0.1457049251,
-0.0658063442,
1.013007164,
0.1369903088,
-0.1167240217,
0.2497567087,
-0.3844462931,
-0.4041266143,
-0.0607843213,
-0.4230204821,
-0.3906553388,
0.6956290007,
0.636662662,
0.491229564,
0.4032346606,
0.6803944707,
0.1848716587,
0.1433437467,
0.2899416685,
-0.4024614692,
-0.2867543697,
-0.0229847468,
-0.465729475,
-0.3129223883,
0.2369346321,
0.2181402147,
0.603014946,
0.1793290973,
0.4865314364,
0.3523670435,
0.349086225,
-1.1345026493,
0.1091395617,
-0.8729082942,
0.1021596864,
-0.2087413669,
-0.1021430567,
-0.3564572036,
-0.1844331324,
0.2208435535,
-0.7908309698,
0.4951550663,
0.2129087448,
1.2162708044,
0.5083199739,
-0.0635021329,
-0.0706418455,
-0.9215357304,
1.3136287928,
-0.8039980531,
-0.0030571162,
0.6605355144,
0.377910167,
0.0589848533,
-0.4523688257,
-0.4409712255,
0.1028565541,
-0.1755469888,
-0.1456095576,
-0.2365111411,
0.171404779,
0.349799484,
-0.0761305168,
-0.6093077064,
0.7886202931,
-0.6094227433,
-0.1126111224,
0.6324752569,
0.3406551182,
-0.119802773,
-0.0748780146,
-0.2951297164,
-0.088569358,
-0.6967674494,
-0.0166889057,
-0.0737248436,
0.7706153989,
-0.0160668232,
0.3455881476,
-0.3660928011,
0.790176928,
-0.2733078897,
-0.2824094892,
0.2281702161,
-0.2618814707,
-0.7058415413,
-0.0820636228,
0.7273962498,
-0.1549982131,
0.164455682,
0.1890822947,
-0.3364282548,
0.146151945,
0.4245814681,
-0.7437022328,
-0.344001025,
0.1025804579,
-0.4354346693,
-0.2707748711,
-0.4415919781,
-0.3843752146,
-0.3186748624,
-0.3434225917,
0.4995348752,
-0.6599509716,
0.279858619,
-0.1782766283,
0.0789573789,
0.3086115122,
0.5469754934,
-1.0105489492,
-0.0644040257,
0.7246930003,
0.910541296,
-0.0315279514,
-0.2997545004,
-0.3893221021,
0.0860284716,
-0.3793008626,
1.1270074844,
-0.6569288373,
-0.0614468344,
-0.0307282843,
-0.2504476011,
0.0779741481,
-0.6690218449,
0.4187904298,
-0.5874962807,
-0.2237994671,
-0.0616295263,
-0.4397340417,
-0.2958009839,
0.3401885033,
-0.6153877974,
0.8489646316,
0.2944902778,
-0.6028646827,
1.024202466,
-0.5417947769,
-0.5194923878,
0.3522266448,
-0.3239841759,
-0.6457547545,
0.2522238791,
0.0923101977,
0.7882804871,
-0.2355841845,
-0.3696954548,
-0.4589517415,
-0.5846920609,
-0.2458793074,
-0.3088033199,
0.5723392963,
0.3937650621,
-0.2528420687,
-0.122311838,
-1.0521435738,
0.2865590751,
-0.1518958509,
-0.3278520405,
-0.5330220461,
-0.1009548903,
0.1485952139,
0.2385961711,
-0.0478466414,
-0.4153911471,
0.2472466826,
-0.6258197427,
0.1002920493,
0.5573154688,
-0.0699675083,
0.5884924531,
-0.380571425,
0.5838667154,
0.2915934324,
0.1333214492,
0.1072447672,
-0.37892887,
-0.9326804876,
-0.5018741488,
0.3282825649,
0.5298068523,
-0.8369073868,
0.3050197661,
-0.1637564451,
-0.7472063899,
-0.9883161783,
0.6246085763,
0.261280179,
0.2433111072,
0.5152341127,
-0.3593720198,
-0.4626155496,
-1.08236444,
-0.0003834195,
-0.1880617738,
-0.2094889879,
0.4587634802,
0.4552245438,
-0.378418088,
1.2053345442,
-0.6034933329,
-0.938582778,
-0.5438669324,
0.5886733532,
0.1338441968,
0.2835783362,
0.7130922079,
-0.3376615047,
-0.5136064887,
0.1441494972,
-0.4419462085,
-0.0009795422,
-0.1264780462,
0.1466584951,
0.277369678,
0.0867850855,
-0.283266753,
0.5213923454,
0.4468896389,
0.4285082519,
0.121185787,
-0.0629177839,
-0.1809524447,
-0.6644832492,
-0.1562398076,
0.3724665344,
-0.2464413494,
-0.5216819048,
-0.4395135045,
-0.0993836522,
-0.0397317968,
-0.8262472153,
0.3111850917,
-0.1882943064,
0.0018913486,
-0.5598198175,
0.0208973065,
-0.0494567417,
0.5021873116,
0.2042046934,
0.7281102538,
0.4852204323,
-1.1340899467,
0.0597331077,
0.2691941559,
-0.6419571042,
0.2675922513,
-0.3594130576,
0.0764297396,
-0.2834095359,
-0.0572206154,
-0.6744529605,
-0.227785334,
0.0097694788,
-0.0547291376,
0.1263304204,
-0.430172354,
-0.4877183139,
-0.0949696302,
-0.1235487685,
0.2167802304,
0.6646453738,
-0.4025563598,
0.3033770621,
0.1052164063,
0.0449315384,
-0.477584362,
-0.6422970891,
-0.568129003,
-0.1605681926,
-0.2785133719,
0.2867957652,
0.3708052933,
0.0030187943,
0.0110115726,
-0.0085680438,
-0.531363368,
0.3892540932,
0.2337925434,
0.1545982212,
-0.4024884105,
0.385913223,
0.067934379,
-0.2843463123,
-0.5048702955,
-0.1026466712,
0.3309594989,
-0.0340062156,
-0.1735947132,
-0.5436466336,
0.1584178507,
0.1612544358,
-0.1700379997,
0.8686305285,
0.8628900647,
-0.3402884603,
-0.991861701,
-0.2490709275,
-0.2273032218,
-0.4998610914,
0.2977812588,
-0.4749981463,
-0.7926170826,
0.1785778254,
-0.3466075957,
0.2587915957,
0.7341068387,
0.4467206001,
-0.4982600212,
0.8284777403,
0.9624806046,
-0.2633480728,
0.4038588405,
-0.4612800479,
0.2437696159,
-0.2733789384,
0.1005738229,
-0.7166534662,
-0.5434571505,
-0.7182924747,
-0.0926771015,
0.5201138854,
-0.0544296131,
-0.2099319696,
0.6539178491,
-0.4440241456,
0.7505793571,
0.7252683043,
0.0112543423,
0.2783608437,
0.0397375152,
0.1592191905,
-0.0695617124,
-1.0651242733,
-0.8332720995,
0.7766476274,
0.2933798432,
0.9338197708,
-0.0956979692,
0.861358285,
0.3028357029,
0.3749357164,
-1.058606863,
0.3840977848,
-0.492113173,
-0.8056104183,
-0.3935354054,
-0.3561089039,
-0.8888094425,
-0.0151854921,
-0.3751831055,
-0.4751066864,
0.3117799163,
0.2605532408,
-1.1137309074,
0.2125491947,
-0.7710565329,
1.0379803181,
-0.2619445026,
-0.2840313017,
-0.4345068932,
-0.4576983154,
0.2767683864,
-0.298425436,
0.0195943248,
-0.6527259946,
0.0747571662,
0.5022670627,
-0.2450434864,
1.1465029716,
-0.2127974629,
0.0876525939,
0.3460830152,
-0.0410517678,
0.3292507529,
-0.1917467713,
0.0037872856,
0.1793223768,
0.3548795879,
-0.5530449748,
-0.5171145797,
0.3347368836,
-0.9581280947,
-0.2220622301,
-0.5201063156,
-0.0181397609,
-0.5209409595,
0.1449294239,
0.6386607885,
0.0330253653,
-0.0591189787,
-0.0047170534,
0.446144551,
-0.2806718051,
0.694193244,
0.529266715,
0.3944540918,
0.1729229987,
0.8598023057,
0.3122949302,
0.0355084203,
0.2449115366,
-0.1431029886,
0.1535164118,
-0.8197841644,
-0.2887213826,
0.1499506235,
-0.7352809906,
-0.5634388328,
-0.3301334977,
-0.2069635242,
-0.1783317477,
-0.1532251984,
-0.63264817,
-0.1662313342,
-0.8868196607,
0.1870449185,
0.2952982187,
0.7471419573,
0.3623134792,
0.6964090466,
-1.2351365089,
0.1949935704,
0.1410929561,
0.5545479655,
-0.0717077628,
-0.4609692693,
-0.6739637256,
-0.1987272203,
-0.4921382666,
-0.481257081,
0.4676923156,
0.5308745503,
0.3330355585,
0.4475571215,
0.3860800862,
0.8368185163,
-0.5947471857,
0.6234799027,
-0.0256721862,
-0.8008129001,
0.8515228033,
0.0233865883,
0.1948292106,
1.2347247601,
0.7688227296,
-0.0918078274,
-0.0776669607,
-0.4621743262,
-0.6860931516,
0.9760024548,
0.1121435687,
0.1972841769,
0.3136875331,
0.2678976655,
0.3664874136,
0.0157204159,
-0.392562151,
0.0731983334,
0.2336003631,
-0.3370281756,
0.047174748,
0.026598772,
0.1426918656,
-0.1404288411,
0.9418064952,
-0.3307800293,
-0.0827865303,
-0.0906115696,
-0.3599663377,
0.1409171373,
0.6150881648,
0.5157197118,
0.6440451145,
-0.3239905238,
0.065241389,
0.3839922249,
-0.2117468864,
0.2748984694,
-0.2524122894,
-0.2408625782,
0.1341653466,
0.4501979649,
0.9796068668,
-0.0293491539,
-0.6756590009,
0.3462409079,
0.282507211,
0.0345624387,
-0.3222288489,
0.5772857666,
-0.5566250682,
0.3257358372,
0.2468905598,
0.1059937775,
0.1769833416,
-0.3842415214,
0.1777194738,
0.3828666806,
-0.405265063,
-0.2789053917,
0.294316411,
0.2954564393,
0.0401427895,
0.6913414001,
-0.5413246751,
-0.1542618126,
0.3297655582,
-0.0184269827,
1.1001514196,
0.1438217908,
0.2322444618,
0.2962660193,
0.4431192875,
-0.0190467536,
-0.0360573195,
-0.0527445897,
-0.9063248634,
-0.5175468922,
-0.6936466694,
-0.5375298858,
0.3263768256,
-0.3984033465,
0.6211479306,
-0.7675741911,
-0.5544487834,
0.4061311781,
0.1702218205,
-1.034163475,
0.2657037973,
0.1376762837,
0.8610037565,
-1.0302590132,
1.0625833273,
0.5167212486,
-0.5910064578,
-0.5466164947,
-0.1264646053,
0.0716440454,
-0.4709179997,
0.9805733562,
-0.0066186073,
-0.2553726435,
-0.1144426987,
-0.7043066621,
-0.5226688981,
0.7842147946,
0.2104038894,
-0.7774249911,
-0.1032537892,
0.2421269715,
0.5556843281,
-0.347900629,
0.0026789764,
0.9313597083,
0.2164750546,
0.0013208134,
-0.9936299324,
-0.5231284499,
0.1021392867,
0.0615374371,
0.0466538444,
-0.6072140336,
0.4519633353,
-0.0393298082,
-0.2534012198,
-0.1783104837,
0.5730307698,
0.1955825686,
0.5870487094,
0.4143616557,
0.4287889004,
0.5796700716,
-0.0577659756,
0.9733839631,
0.0416154824,
0.5315135717,
1.1443641186,
-0.6120795012,
1.0879089832,
0.1980277002,
-0.3592467904,
0.2214256823,
0.9334766269,
-0.3485463858,
0.6567810774,
-0.0205146689,
-0.2710144818,
-0.5151638389,
-0.1742275208,
0.0469675511,
0.785756588,
0.2110365927,
-0.206377387,
-0.2787545621,
0.2543383837,
-0.3044094741,
-0.3251309097,
-0.3054298759,
1.1087344885,
0.2088629007,
-0.3350608051,
0.635191679,
0.2268315852,
0.8054391146,
-0.5501057506,
0.0674889758,
-0.188629657,
0.3978493512,
-0.4595327973,
-0.3973335624,
0.3618408442,
0.2725317478,
-0.274461031,
-0.082108587,
0.8742796183,
-0.0454731807,
-0.5510033965,
0.0663133115,
0.3242790103,
0.067273438,
0.0511077009,
-0.4301930964,
-0.0597327538,
-0.239790231,
-0.0513520353,
0.3795280159,
0.2703824937,
0.1956923753,
0.6324481964,
0.13196823,
0.1356970817,
-0.0126435943,
0.0139107425,
0.7297474146,
-0.6773158312,
-0.3245864809,
-0.8295426369,
0.3424602747,
0.2671921849,
-0.3839846849,
0.6927599311,
0.6313759685,
1.0465615988,
-0.2018430233,
1.0555586815,
0.2348141521,
0.549358964,
-0.6239742637,
0.6772155762,
-0.6335132122,
0.5537564754,
-0.0992982164,
-0.8117735386,
-0.4613638222,
0.7797876,
-0.4374224842,
0.1966237873,
0.4127874076,
0.6306666136,
-0.2918801308,
0.1015602127,
0.4658357799,
-0.1637706161,
0.0740886703,
0.8488109708,
0.7635498047,
-0.347547859,
0.376999855,
-0.4086951315,
0.0067910198,
-0.2726272643,
-0.7262576818,
-0.8175652623,
-0.3917270303,
-0.5705159903,
-0.0992803425,
-0.2773093879,
1.4324116707,
1.0769665241,
-1.1024808884,
-0.0375155285,
0.0728302747,
-0.0273496807,
-0.1476194113,
-0.1616070718,
0.1017915756,
-0.8323960304,
-0.7777138948,
0.3354858756,
0.3130525649,
0.2459304929,
-0.2078148723,
0.208069846,
0.04592501,
0.0268862527,
0.6469467282,
0.2714985013,
-0.4549567103,
-0.2174165249,
-0.2044372559,
-0.2398462892,
0.3085513711,
0.8575547934,
-1.09313941,
0.0689722151,
0.4911859035,
0.8500121236,
0.7332458496,
-0.1638098955,
0.1375870556,
-1.2272517681,
0.2613955438,
0.5318834782,
-0.080472514,
0.131936878,
0.0075014015,
0.5172379613,
0.1570381373,
-0.2753267884,
-0.6072978973,
0.2523676753,
-0.8381965756,
-0.4932720363,
1.0251334906,
-0.0418365598,
-0.1354399621,
-0.2884455025,
0.0711687431,
0.0255102143,
-0.1757484376,
0.6527878642,
0.6480989456,
-0.4457069933,
-0.3643204272,
-0.6908288002,
0.8689802885,
0.2714990675,
-0.9474443793,
-0.128292948,
0.5255195498,
0.0560070984,
0.1623394489,
0.4185449183,
0.4633485675,
0.186593011,
-0.1563363522,
-0.2249601781,
0.2764312923,
-0.4592514932,
-0.5654135942,
0.4512538016,
0.453094393,
-0.3538486063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06871v1 | Learning gain differences between ChatGPT and human tutor generated algebra hints | 2023-02-14T07:20:48 | 2023-02-14T07:20:48 | Zachary A. Pardos, Shreya Bhandari | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.HC | Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, are quickly advancing AI to
the frontiers of practical consumer use and leading industries to re-evaluate
how they allocate resources for content production. Authoring of open
educational resources and hint content within adaptive tutoring systems is
labor intensive. Should LLMs like ChatGPT produce educational content on par
with human-authored content, the implications would be significant for further
scaling of computer tutoring system approaches. In this paper, we conduct the
first learning gain evaluation of ChatGPT by comparing the efficacy of its
hints with hints authored by human tutors with 77 participants across two
algebra topic areas, Elementary Algebra and Intermediate Algebra. We find that
70% of hints produced by ChatGPT passed our manual quality checks and that both
human and ChatGPT conditions produced positive learning gains. However, gains
were only statistically significant for human tutor created hints. Learning
gains from human-created hints were substantially and statistically
significantly higher than ChatGPT hints in both topic areas, though ChatGPT
participants in the Intermediate Algebra experiment were near ceiling and not
even with the control at pre-test. We discuss the limitations of our study and
suggest several future directions for the field. Problem and hint content used
in the experiment is provided for replicability. | [
-0.0345882215,
-0.6486623883,
0.3112089038,
0.2896987796,
-0.0359474719,
0.4232686758,
-0.3899421096,
-0.2024080604,
-0.2125632316,
0.0029195594,
-0.3921112716,
-0.4143385291,
-1.0035651922,
0.0644477457,
-0.2951223254,
1.1340085268,
0.0878203884,
0.1963791698,
-0.5161864161,
0.3962097168,
-0.376242429,
-0.5852040648,
-1.1811816692,
-0.0517033674,
0.2999402583,
0.5257106423,
0.6851837635,
0.5450598598,
0.5723553896,
0.28753528,
-0.1793343425,
0.0388326943,
-0.5283676386,
-0.2677488029,
0.1191608012,
-0.7076207995,
-0.5390037298,
0.0234242678,
0.4426813424,
0.6220494509,
-0.4388131201,
0.2183742821,
0.4090259969,
0.8036134839,
-0.5056838393,
0.4802477658,
-0.4138522446,
0.0029676678,
-0.0968031138,
-0.0711115375,
-0.4578720331,
-0.5487200618,
0.4529096186,
-0.6302998066,
0.457036823,
0.1106774732,
0.6898525357,
0.1721133292,
-0.1619311422,
-0.7410620451,
-0.3583952785,
0.7057440877,
-0.7386007905,
0.3250658214,
0.2387604117,
0.3430610895,
-0.2849877179,
-0.6825680733,
-0.2369870692,
-0.4053690135,
-0.1070768535,
0.1288440526,
-0.3854024708,
0.0383030884,
0.3431340754,
0.0300724097,
-0.3439487517,
-0.2273368686,
-0.6209439039,
-0.2892166674,
0.5506407022,
-0.0788593814,
0.2776597738,
-0.2357890606,
-0.4197806716,
-0.5136442184,
-1.0404210091,
0.1201274171,
0.3999835849,
0.4208803177,
-0.0177151635,
0.5862171054,
0.0125551149,
0.469127208,
0.0834926516,
-0.3219858706,
-0.2719319761,
-0.2246380746,
0.1033093408,
0.1474393755,
0.6738395691,
0.3239648342,
0.6017909646,
-0.3861541748,
-0.1895036697,
-0.0663165376,
-0.0686685219,
-0.7386831641,
-0.5031426549,
-0.421889931,
-0.3567220569,
0.0681905374,
-0.0471926183,
-0.6153049469,
-0.5920927525,
-0.4208147228,
0.6074408293,
-0.4845068455,
-0.1350495666,
0.0113590155,
-0.2206367701,
0.2491572797,
0.4868463576,
-0.9717665911,
0.4495321214,
0.7844352722,
0.8405490518,
-0.4538286626,
0.0045612068,
-0.2032965571,
-0.3208686709,
-0.1608790308,
0.7375488281,
-0.1911088526,
-0.4981327355,
0.0822781846,
-0.3885853291,
0.0525338389,
-0.7059776187,
0.4093458056,
-0.7100808024,
0.3921607733,
-0.3145634234,
-0.6942998171,
-0.0922853053,
-0.0009723042,
-0.351590544,
0.6806477308,
0.1709004194,
-0.4619039893,
0.6062096357,
-0.5063647032,
-0.2678575814,
-0.0503797457,
-0.1852072179,
-0.1202167869,
-0.0365212038,
0.2349683195,
0.2011023462,
-0.2274039537,
0.0616742149,
0.1001175866,
-0.3169068694,
0.3577222526,
-0.712110281,
0.586286664,
0.0117457984,
-0.4970427752,
-0.2821566761,
-0.5154941678,
-0.191325143,
0.1359000951,
-0.6711605191,
-0.1842857897,
0.2359753996,
-0.3081712127,
-0.0113951759,
0.346134603,
-0.4641551077,
0.4069740772,
0.0268715024,
-0.0692416057,
0.9755651355,
0.0046232161,
0.1785248965,
-0.3587825596,
0.902333498,
-0.1002929136,
-0.0576490276,
0.032302402,
-0.630345881,
-0.8382014632,
-0.0845535472,
0.4946311116,
0.5197133422,
-0.7467936277,
-0.032962501,
-0.1781871021,
-0.2346581966,
-0.4956990182,
0.2474727929,
0.7489203811,
0.3123174906,
0.177316606,
-0.2273868024,
-0.3698857427,
-0.679572165,
-0.5768870711,
-0.081252858,
-0.4170479178,
0.4374537766,
0.1407957971,
0.3375906944,
0.8634520173,
-0.8166713715,
-0.3186704516,
-0.022729259,
0.2057663798,
0.1348548979,
0.344291538,
0.4677153826,
-0.4563665986,
-0.8833335042,
-0.1504073739,
-0.4998304248,
0.1185668558,
0.0052060322,
-0.2710706294,
0.0803059489,
0.4433003366,
-0.5841127634,
0.3535222411,
0.3688542545,
-0.5514761806,
0.7800076008,
-0.2078867704,
0.1256235093,
-0.7934299111,
-0.2861077189,
-0.1537365764,
-0.3081119955,
-0.344994247,
-0.2940274775,
-0.1515065283,
-0.0023952585,
-0.1340714097,
0.3682988882,
-0.430652827,
-0.1854540855,
-0.2698841989,
0.5691971779,
-0.3812303543,
0.8296075463,
-0.1350068152,
1.1733754873,
0.4195079505,
-0.4095879197,
0.1717621386,
0.1243837029,
-0.3061543107,
0.4165462255,
-0.8934077621,
0.2040011138,
0.0054660784,
0.0020601284,
-1.009357214,
-0.1584755182,
0.3126356006,
-0.8861948848,
0.2722754478,
-0.0073951976,
-0.559525311,
-0.0826504007,
-0.1506492049,
0.1101192534,
1.0362080336,
-0.5401009321,
0.2675202489,
-0.0583284199,
-0.3391632438,
-0.7429260612,
-0.1439775079,
-0.0496757254,
-0.0477607474,
-0.6339809895,
0.0258077607,
-0.0365291275,
-0.2327111065,
0.1659266204,
-0.1478652656,
0.0869664699,
0.1090524495,
0.2601846755,
0.3114455342,
-0.3733743429,
0.4018588364,
-0.0285900757,
-0.0338386111,
0.5103566051,
-0.2581046224,
0.2845957577,
-0.2377609611,
-0.6500926614,
-0.1144045368,
-0.0941682383,
-0.0509441085,
0.0216688551,
0.6400051713,
0.5549561977,
-0.0114948507,
-0.0592075586,
-0.2724734545,
-0.3658242226,
-0.5246406198,
0.4224746227,
-0.0141718211,
-0.7720043063,
0.3481700718,
-0.2220364362,
0.3660044372,
0.3974768221,
0.3293878436,
0.0008079988,
1.2832608223,
0.5813348889,
0.2173096836,
0.6145459414,
-0.4142870009,
0.0122873178,
-0.9558231235,
-0.19129996,
-0.5463551283,
-0.3185724914,
-0.5616639853,
-0.2630603015,
0.4219342768,
0.2773351669,
-0.255391717,
0.1214004904,
-0.3359762132,
0.4944874346,
0.978798151,
0.3650590181,
0.653843224,
0.3190952539,
-0.0567896143,
-0.121477209,
-0.8973155618,
-0.3942943811,
1.4476270676,
0.0298181828,
0.718043983,
0.6202191114,
0.5712192059,
0.5461232066,
0.7055084705,
-0.7506562471,
0.3793201149,
-0.0974550396,
-0.5758889318,
-0.2014413923,
-0.5558544993,
-1.0827585459,
0.0953232422,
-0.1582495123,
-0.7045764923,
-0.1521444917,
0.2775258124,
-0.2119315714,
0.3600494862,
-1.0217733383,
0.5540127754,
-0.073061876,
-0.4497775733,
-0.0029562039,
-0.4345400631,
0.2810321748,
-0.0032939138,
0.069462195,
0.2994054854,
-0.0126836849,
1.0668107271,
-0.1741143167,
0.7064762115,
-0.2788725495,
-0.1191868335,
0.5798258781,
0.2235018313,
0.4612603188,
-0.0217245314,
0.0780546889,
-0.2867534161,
-0.0987787545,
-0.6307868958,
-0.7048805356,
0.3324847519,
-1.0890243053,
-0.9702970982,
-0.1956048459,
-0.5357508063,
-0.226046294,
0.1034164876,
0.2126126438,
0.6457614899,
0.0291507207,
0.2033368498,
0.6129919887,
-0.2621079683,
0.3159995079,
0.5551812649,
-0.355094105,
-0.250739336,
1.0645424128,
-0.2361160517,
0.7681193948,
0.1303854734,
0.3121609986,
-0.304788053,
-0.461953938,
-0.501819551,
0.4081784189,
-0.8318958879,
-0.0632589832,
0.0471371077,
-0.1398384571,
-0.4734039307,
-0.1371777058,
-0.3207036853,
-0.3257624805,
-0.1920309216,
0.0111323437,
0.4465091527,
0.9944851398,
-0.1896329969,
0.7366451025,
-0.7342344522,
-0.2153619379,
0.5214790702,
0.2091174424,
0.2002239227,
-0.5088403821,
-0.3890091777,
0.3515886366,
-0.4709493518,
-0.5671485066,
0.0999025851,
0.1601969153,
0.3517836034,
0.7101935744,
-0.1305956393,
0.3725560606,
-0.1454269588,
1.0027608871,
0.1497887671,
-0.6263303757,
0.0597219691,
-0.3377145827,
0.3841520846,
0.2643202841,
0.431435734,
-0.4404805005,
-0.1110744998,
-0.8383315802,
-0.3689626157,
0.7096310854,
0.1982433498,
0.0756446123,
0.1357752234,
0.4571566284,
0.0232234746,
0.308991611,
-0.5787678361,
-0.4649266303,
0.2346449792,
-0.106977284,
0.0281569529,
-0.1469557583,
-0.1344420165,
-0.0597036481,
0.4866006374,
-0.10213653,
0.560885489,
0.1371200532,
-0.1555207074,
-0.028306162,
0.1546633393,
0.5570043921,
0.8336210251,
-0.4973436296,
0.020803418,
0.0600621328,
-0.7547599077,
0.0511105508,
-0.0419665091,
-0.083273083,
-0.0959564149,
0.7057281733,
0.8599742055,
0.1554251462,
-0.7534805536,
0.674618423,
-0.1930121183,
-0.3732463419,
-0.2036014199,
0.3207919002,
0.1069775149,
0.1956720799,
0.517917335,
0.0816733912,
-0.0657108277,
-0.3107922971,
0.0721784383,
0.4617918134,
-0.34158957,
-0.3460745811,
0.514472425,
-0.0029534975,
-0.4913701713,
0.8826000094,
-0.5312423706,
-0.6123669744,
0.5954042673,
0.6437835693,
0.6077817678,
-0.0060763108,
0.3057825863,
0.3353111446,
0.028476622,
0.1849357784,
-0.0194852725,
-0.3921428621,
-0.4087067842,
-0.6034502983,
-0.4242541194,
-0.5575822592,
-0.4703654349,
-0.5495439768,
0.1984605938,
-0.2866518795,
-0.0398721769,
-0.276907742,
0.1806477755,
-0.5778445601,
-0.2557737827,
-0.1118031442,
0.8121134043,
-0.5564503074,
0.2282743305,
0.7451632023,
-0.3094398379,
-1.139282465,
-0.1039269865,
0.0125839412,
-0.8709210753,
0.8354339004,
-0.2564335763,
-0.0760414973,
0.1632098556,
-0.5965338349,
-0.9965808988,
1.2180695534,
0.247505188,
-0.3073423207,
-0.547077477,
0.2372482419,
0.4950529337,
0.0205891356,
0.4472539127,
0.5628513694,
0.3228852153,
0.5895016789,
-0.7453020811,
-0.17561315,
0.131496653,
-0.3492607772,
0.256970495,
-0.3591154218,
1.0965385437,
-0.3198035359,
-0.5250706673,
0.1068695337,
0.6589657664,
0.2770957649,
0.1653557718,
0.350344032,
0.289452523,
0.528038919,
0.0129335755,
1.1932321787,
-0.1903067082,
0.4430688918,
1.018512249,
0.3898008168,
0.6846176386,
0.2589784563,
-0.8710116148,
0.5144583583,
0.5612879395,
0.2103105336,
0.2677724063,
0.4115025699,
-0.2767840922,
-0.0171430986,
-0.1499861777,
-0.5288815498,
0.2093782872,
0.5043449998,
-0.2143230736,
-0.3360188305,
-0.1828233302,
0.5597192645,
-0.1135257632,
-0.2088512331,
0.8983244896,
0.1506091058,
-0.9088479877,
0.5377606153,
-0.2770039439,
0.7121502161,
-0.6355711222,
-0.1107386872,
-0.3469012678,
0.3630208671,
-0.1182742342,
-0.5847132802,
-0.1490366757,
0.148720175,
0.2783236504,
0.0102632036,
0.6661327481,
-0.4763818383,
-0.4562517405,
-0.1157735214,
0.7711862326,
0.2476690561,
-0.1730637997,
-0.4855657816,
-0.4323489964,
0.1526315212,
-0.2975521386,
0.4164426327,
0.4080639184,
0.1908750981,
0.737175107,
0.6211556792,
0.4070570171,
0.3390482366,
-0.3595784605,
0.817979157,
-0.3479900062,
0.0346658863,
-0.7448344231,
0.1547820866,
0.0025464196,
-0.317820698,
1.1897745132,
0.3012666106,
0.747941792,
-0.1133538708,
0.5313053131,
-0.2000752836,
0.4134121239,
-0.5563156605,
0.4947797656,
-0.406624645,
0.1911312789,
-0.349580735,
-0.8484014273,
-0.1107753664,
0.2505263984,
-0.3084306121,
0.175790146,
0.5468904972,
0.7934317589,
0.0250623804,
-0.1351567507,
0.0119373882,
0.0737458318,
0.492654562,
0.5993680954,
0.9531880021,
-0.2821295261,
0.7773376703,
-0.2046498805,
-0.4085914493,
-0.2267967612,
-0.7431226969,
-0.9311665893,
-0.3856481612,
-0.1741425097,
-0.188927874,
0.0975798666,
1.0389533043,
0.5162625313,
-0.5808596611,
-0.3372298479,
-0.1493707448,
0.3207293749,
-0.3278806806,
-0.2818890512,
0.8945293427,
-0.3642933667,
-0.691749692,
-0.0171487499,
-0.3112256229,
0.0911492854,
-0.3877235055,
-0.2836096287,
-0.0763652772,
-0.0941018462,
0.6619210839,
0.129327774,
-0.4583809674,
-0.2309877425,
0.4035316706,
-0.0171441007,
0.0125382813,
0.7007306218,
-0.7902577519,
0.4413415194,
0.4494040906,
0.6549322009,
0.2795743942,
0.3078387678,
0.59603405,
-0.7972409725,
-0.0705712363,
-0.0330933519,
0.0675721914,
0.2079038173,
-0.2438113391,
0.4058179557,
0.1518355012,
-0.7412171364,
-0.3407510817,
-0.1344212294,
-0.7308285236,
-0.0343805142,
0.9749488235,
-0.5158125162,
-0.137753278,
0.4074520469,
-0.4881751537,
0.3413441181,
-0.6765362024,
1.004131794,
0.8128913045,
-0.4471983016,
0.067853719,
-0.7310717106,
0.7955465913,
0.5518993139,
-0.6985882521,
-0.117684491,
0.5408462286,
0.0535181277,
0.2718702257,
0.2720753253,
-0.0173810609,
0.4455770552,
0.1644012332,
0.1070754454,
-0.1135573462,
-0.0770576298,
-0.0118687237,
-0.0287319031,
0.5051306486,
-0.2147110403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06868v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06868v1 | SwitchPrompt: Learning Domain-Specific Gated Soft Prompts for Classification in Low-Resource Domains | 2023-02-14T07:14:08 | 2023-02-14T07:14:08 | Koustava Goswami, Lukas Lange, Jun Araki, Heike Adel | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prompting pre-trained language models leads to promising results across
natural language processing tasks but is less effective when applied in
low-resource domains, due to the domain gap between the pre-training data and
the downstream task. In this work, we bridge this gap with a novel and
lightweight prompting methodology called SwitchPrompt for the adaptation of
language models trained on datasets from the general domain to diverse
low-resource domains. Using domain-specific keywords with a trainable gated
prompt, SwitchPrompt offers domain-oriented prompting, that is, effective
guidance on the target domains for general-domain language models. Our few-shot
experiments on three text classification benchmarks demonstrate the efficacy of
the general-domain pre-trained language models when used with SwitchPrompt.
They often even outperform their domain-specific counterparts trained with
baseline state-of-the-art prompting methods by up to 10.7% performance increase
in accuracy. This result indicates that SwitchPrompt effectively reduces the
need for domain-specific language model pre-training. | [
-0.3972612023,
-0.6991652846,
0.3919437528,
0.0334202126,
-0.2439957708,
-0.0584433042,
-0.403945595,
-0.0867370442,
-0.2547811866,
0.4850205183,
-0.7885991335,
-0.5426142216,
-0.5641759634,
0.1207183674,
-0.2443512231,
1.2458492517,
-0.2659154832,
-0.1692925245,
-0.1135154665,
-0.0708857328,
-0.4928598106,
-0.4309749901,
-0.8060113192,
-0.254732877,
0.611220181,
0.4649870992,
0.5350449681,
-0.2528871298,
0.1295673847,
0.1328380853,
0.2119260132,
0.2826746404,
-0.2985684574,
0.1545704454,
-0.4562937915,
-0.2998999059,
-0.2312777638,
0.2514935136,
0.3380763531,
0.8832475543,
-0.0476334542,
0.0846647024,
0.3673921227,
0.3122264147,
-0.6709721684,
0.0719861761,
-0.7152645588,
-0.0705544651,
-0.3638500571,
-0.2278998196,
-0.7552155852,
-0.1848239005,
0.1986399591,
-0.4459385574,
0.7586830854,
0.0603041016,
0.762081027,
0.1197734401,
-0.345895797,
0.1403494477,
-0.5056214929,
0.7493416071,
-0.4502607882,
0.4336393178,
0.3482400179,
0.3995227516,
0.0506813303,
-0.8455310464,
-0.6734823585,
-0.1629203856,
0.1375741214,
0.0096767908,
-0.3366100788,
0.0188755132,
0.1871027648,
-0.1864053607,
-0.4432590008,
0.1975188702,
-0.1647516638,
-0.1997523457,
0.2796448171,
0.0963702202,
0.4212245643,
0.0813955888,
-0.3656610548,
-0.0333253965,
-0.8001269102,
0.2966424525,
0.1874608099,
0.916397512,
-0.0449215174,
-0.0971134529,
-0.1408364326,
0.9941171408,
0.2481879741,
0.2105158567,
0.1263117343,
-0.1228783578,
-0.1514266729,
-0.04757718,
0.7625151277,
0.1642635763,
0.4571775794,
-0.2303380072,
-0.1594112515,
0.1101144478,
0.366846174,
-0.7797064781,
-0.2530580163,
-0.0436425805,
-0.4941662252,
0.0191446096,
-0.2516856194,
-0.7670790553,
-0.2575371563,
-0.229117468,
0.4663321674,
-0.2885267437,
-0.3864890039,
0.3861456811,
0.1390390843,
0.0141362324,
0.7270445228,
-1.0963263512,
0.6284771562,
0.4447665513,
0.8917769194,
-0.6780078411,
-0.3139419854,
-0.8067829609,
-0.1560376734,
-0.1673135459,
0.9983239174,
-0.7650433183,
-0.4644049704,
0.255479604,
0.1630808711,
-0.5160455704,
-0.7702929974,
0.6003297567,
-0.6465764046,
0.3655638993,
-0.0799694806,
-0.2256591469,
-0.0842291415,
0.2407878786,
-0.8417443633,
0.921081543,
0.4146810472,
-0.5423738956,
0.5519319177,
-0.6501625776,
-0.5355750918,
0.0985030606,
-0.1399477869,
-0.1541157663,
-0.1157146171,
0.1851098537,
0.5998302698,
-0.4072498977,
0.000242531,
-0.0476492979,
-0.0446632467,
0.0571699664,
-0.4406815469,
0.7029625773,
0.1084715575,
-0.3025669456,
-0.015596699,
-0.1939330846,
0.0949397832,
0.0552880391,
-0.0333673246,
-0.4469055831,
-0.2757198215,
0.1252535284,
0.2021195292,
-0.0945430622,
-0.115346767,
0.5720036626,
-0.2472557575,
0.033048708,
0.6019810438,
0.0494629592,
0.5091222525,
-0.1863104701,
0.9794802666,
0.3194249272,
0.1129032895,
-0.0748089775,
-0.7055053115,
-0.4421359003,
-0.216651395,
0.5238628983,
0.5478472114,
-0.9640699625,
0.0010676318,
-0.0003305321,
-0.1938948929,
-0.6200864315,
0.3431269825,
0.3682150245,
0.6062523723,
0.5090919137,
-0.300869137,
-0.1146567017,
-0.4310769737,
-0.5712522864,
-0.0629861057,
0.0682892576,
0.159572944,
0.2101533264,
-0.4102767408,
0.9724735618,
-0.5368231535,
-0.1464770734,
-0.5836030245,
0.5300868154,
0.4347615838,
0.1957296133,
0.6276519895,
-0.9519187808,
-0.8322295547,
-0.230966419,
-0.0400734879,
-0.4732580781,
-0.1537554115,
-0.0737583041,
0.1612972468,
0.5066860318,
-0.7995069027,
0.1036673188,
0.3934677541,
-0.3987063766,
0.7785974145,
0.1463546604,
0.3794600666,
-0.8014688492,
-0.1618660241,
0.1134013459,
-0.2916050851,
-0.8121235967,
-0.3630881011,
0.0050091343,
-0.1604352295,
-0.6957302094,
0.9889961481,
-0.4833095968,
0.4459524453,
-0.3108315766,
0.0218753275,
0.0236351974,
0.3427346349,
0.2926183641,
0.9299334288,
0.7043101192,
-1.2189577818,
0.1145422608,
0.2333085239,
-0.2241391093,
0.6192603111,
-0.2385240197,
0.0845661387,
0.0718212351,
0.1122189611,
-0.7933536768,
0.12567693,
0.3169632256,
-0.2877981067,
0.4429227412,
-0.3567503691,
-0.1517023593,
-0.1754420549,
-0.1908542067,
0.5437461138,
0.713067472,
-0.9002159238,
0.3218468726,
-0.0229293499,
-0.4616885185,
-0.3436084986,
-0.3922970593,
-0.0999675244,
-0.0430318229,
-0.1876701117,
0.5727582574,
-0.0832894892,
-0.0905395299,
0.0147429416,
0.0069353306,
-0.2782919705,
-0.0266845301,
0.0948472992,
0.2705817819,
-0.2202531248,
0.3159025013,
0.2106960565,
-0.2517595291,
-0.0018810192,
-0.3880521059,
0.5746105909,
-0.0668579713,
-0.4356076419,
-0.2097676992,
0.1787165403,
0.1786449254,
-0.0308398232,
0.4634242654,
0.5646243691,
-0.3679131866,
-1.0945490599,
-0.047662843,
-0.3785466254,
-0.5123391151,
0.0858139694,
-0.4922960103,
-0.8622472286,
0.1100341752,
-0.663579762,
-0.0623092204,
0.3455092907,
0.4823595285,
0.0853829384,
1.0531927347,
0.76734972,
-0.0469500013,
0.5656775832,
-0.1188643277,
0.3039621711,
-0.6005602479,
0.0082864026,
-0.6057939529,
-0.2268799841,
-0.2482736707,
-0.731033802,
0.042243164,
0.1313399822,
-0.0681344345,
0.3223848045,
-0.5024570823,
0.4404811263,
0.3507382572,
-0.0605845414,
0.0960192382,
0.0857517049,
-0.148349002,
-0.4295648336,
-0.8571896553,
-0.3498556912,
0.6983171701,
-0.0150540071,
0.9086471796,
-0.1534624994,
0.6603824496,
0.7539562583,
0.2696106136,
-0.9669280648,
0.5824363828,
-0.4022269249,
-0.3354727328,
-0.1495441645,
-0.425532788,
-1.2662934065,
0.064759016,
-0.053859096,
-0.6281155348,
0.216479525,
0.2994838655,
-0.4677700102,
0.3672322929,
-0.8123661876,
0.992685616,
-0.1627149135,
-0.1230257526,
0.0707388222,
-0.2445114255,
0.2844310999,
-0.1560224742,
0.1834483445,
-0.1157919541,
-0.2464127988,
0.7921097279,
-0.2782531083,
1.145427227,
-0.4051992297,
-0.0021649415,
0.4131634831,
0.2347284108,
0.5006797314,
-0.2438573539,
0.1155019626,
-0.0352394357,
-0.3691367209,
-0.3028644323,
-0.7644487023,
0.4222838581,
-0.5587297082,
-0.4675912261,
-0.3916161358,
-0.0736201033,
-0.7918772101,
0.1700823605,
0.5842975974,
0.472132355,
-0.2867317796,
-0.3934453428,
1.0462280512,
-0.1946483105,
0.3547965884,
0.7524178028,
-0.0422655717,
0.1045959964,
0.9050059915,
-0.1150790378,
0.3094196916,
0.4170202911,
0.1778213382,
-0.4086789489,
-0.4726223946,
-0.409720242,
-0.0246412586,
-0.6793999672,
-0.4839999676,
-0.7039523125,
-0.2006869316,
-0.5661636591,
-0.3896594942,
-0.1444352418,
-0.3553329408,
-0.3859302104,
0.001603632,
0.5949030519,
0.4186437428,
0.2350628972,
0.4659630358,
-0.9843486547,
0.5537273288,
0.5024309158,
0.4247426987,
-0.2482776195,
-0.7878728509,
-0.1382566392,
-0.4063287377,
0.0555894859,
-0.944144249,
0.3389576077,
0.5543330312,
0.7856020927,
0.4689254463,
0.5699609518,
0.1092467606,
-0.7825654149,
0.9884744287,
0.5480559468,
-0.9203309417,
0.664442122,
-0.1616484076,
0.518471837,
0.8012094498,
0.8348708749,
-0.7319779992,
-0.2063489705,
-0.7202481031,
-0.7127454877,
0.9043386579,
-0.3707372248,
0.2867650688,
0.0356018655,
0.1495159715,
0.6270344853,
0.1279305518,
-0.5345554948,
-0.0793480128,
-0.0976137966,
-0.5212782025,
0.1143678501,
0.0725006759,
-0.1110288948,
-0.1210470051,
0.5914623737,
-0.4497388303,
0.3018624485,
-0.0956083238,
-0.5442124605,
-0.0146481264,
0.4453035295,
0.1947786659,
0.3955439031,
0.1748867929,
0.3757120669,
0.3803225756,
-0.6464643478,
0.322327435,
-0.1073053256,
-0.2566322088,
0.3114228845,
0.493811965,
0.9744359255,
0.3597316146,
-0.5459659696,
0.7327544093,
-0.214170143,
-0.298101604,
0.5985605121,
0.4521019757,
-0.1773110926,
0.0250097085,
0.2259757519,
0.1382680833,
0.2016005218,
-0.3311454356,
0.2093642354,
0.2855231464,
-0.3971298933,
-0.3593407273,
0.5571808219,
0.5060340762,
-0.4356374741,
0.5158040524,
-0.3436719179,
-0.6777561307,
0.1940821409,
0.6602951884,
1.2944896221,
-0.3558601737,
0.7498409748,
0.213732779,
0.1583523601,
-0.2160307318,
0.1173229441,
-0.2703149915,
-0.9015848637,
-0.3957568109,
-0.5314824581,
-0.8492574692,
0.0371715054,
-0.6051153541,
0.3582954109,
-0.6063924432,
-0.3843883574,
-0.1607225984,
-0.0953308269,
-0.7331593633,
0.3452391624,
0.1177397445,
1.2660737038,
-1.1173061132,
0.8024232984,
0.8054201603,
-0.2522829175,
-0.6240877509,
0.3481380939,
-0.0984277576,
-0.6178421974,
0.8089492917,
0.1144713685,
-0.4810330272,
0.0271571744,
-0.8276116252,
-0.2919384241,
0.422718823,
0.407672286,
-0.3679261506,
0.2932688892,
0.0624227636,
0.3095001876,
-0.371007055,
0.1260612607,
0.6000370979,
0.4230436981,
-0.232330367,
-0.8098418117,
0.2374036312,
-0.5108276606,
-0.2149368078,
0.2065855712,
-0.4724687636,
0.8562908173,
-0.2082345486,
-0.3184474111,
-0.5169136524,
0.545108676,
0.1776191145,
0.3356236219,
0.9541323185,
0.1134864092,
0.8686674833,
-0.1664907038,
0.7972549796,
-0.1157136038,
-0.0428001471,
0.8203114271,
-0.5364114046,
0.8796634078,
0.2006954402,
-0.3963588774,
0.7945364714,
0.7507093549,
0.3545690477,
0.7642188072,
-0.1520165354,
-0.6698977947,
-0.431946665,
-0.0561547354,
-0.4202700853,
-0.0110327043,
0.363691479,
0.1695494056,
-0.3104192913,
0.2425142229,
0.1650560498,
0.0099232271,
-0.3776676655,
0.5928415656,
0.2810334265,
-0.6912648678,
0.6927727461,
-0.1076475307,
0.9233531952,
-0.9214439988,
-0.0289305337,
-0.2090118825,
0.2031208128,
-0.1240322217,
-0.6225214005,
-0.1513604224,
0.2407120913,
-0.434078902,
-0.7930156589,
1.0517632961,
-0.4636493623,
-0.1416977048,
0.375194639,
0.5017699599,
0.0240642112,
-0.2909406424,
-0.8778086901,
-0.2496952862,
-0.2152751237,
-0.2956441343,
0.5395843983,
0.6764854193,
-0.2724561989,
0.4523054063,
0.536456883,
0.2144302726,
-0.0589603335,
0.5695932508,
0.9169140458,
-0.7539127469,
-0.64171803,
-0.4842117131,
0.3012857735,
0.045260109,
-0.5390644073,
0.5644735694,
0.0872471184,
0.7333953977,
-0.3590554893,
1.0642420053,
0.1012836322,
0.6643610597,
-0.7040095329,
0.6283138394,
-0.4777370691,
-0.0545307472,
-0.1027395204,
-0.7005919218,
-0.1541633755,
0.3360681236,
-0.4998951554,
0.3458260596,
0.9238161445,
0.6622065306,
-0.2178633809,
-0.1634166241,
0.2280907333,
-0.0890657231,
0.0810951591,
0.5619238615,
0.8965886235,
0.0020405448,
0.5433197618,
0.238180086,
-0.3819079101,
-0.497659415,
-0.8158339858,
-0.8631193638,
-0.5272219181,
-0.4880825877,
-0.3356193006,
0.1908223629,
0.8546634912,
0.6518085003,
-1.1136676073,
-0.0603403673,
0.0677088648,
0.1071034521,
-0.4784173965,
-0.2559933662,
0.2380548865,
-0.8615062237,
-0.7491281629,
0.3995478451,
0.0422626548,
0.0086205201,
0.0088450406,
-0.2046868056,
-0.0587833561,
0.1403096467,
0.4693592787,
0.5894040465,
-0.1781837195,
0.0805673972,
0.0128004747,
-0.2826881707,
-0.2596301734,
1.1654974222,
-1.0237945318,
0.2537427545,
0.6390963793,
0.7580097318,
0.4130649865,
0.0065975781,
0.6064001322,
-0.845611155,
0.1918514669,
0.4887434542,
0.0714503452,
0.3219421208,
-0.3557147384,
0.2834183872,
0.3519762754,
-0.2739464045,
-0.6277127862,
0.3415402174,
-0.8562929034,
-0.5075157881,
1.3055207729,
-0.0306402612,
-0.2268387675,
-0.3861900866,
-0.3931520879,
0.0235867798,
-0.3935609162,
0.6470876336,
0.4331981242,
-0.2388394475,
-0.3051573932,
-0.4443158209,
1.0354459286,
0.512450397,
-1.0057336092,
0.2386906296,
0.1870903671,
0.0795394182,
-0.0273349211,
0.9859260321,
0.2197351754,
0.3937984109,
0.0620158687,
0.1014553383,
0.1004942209,
-0.6347379684,
-0.3941423595,
0.0570822954,
0.114981018,
-0.2230479419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06860v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06860v2 | BLIAM: Literature-based Data Synthesis for Synergistic Drug Combination Prediction | 2023-02-14T06:48:52 | 2023-02-16T05:26:25 | Cai Yang, Addie Woicik, Hoifung Poon, Sheng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models pre-trained on scientific literature corpora have
substantially advanced scientific discovery by offering high-quality feature
representations for downstream applications. However, these features are often
not interpretable, and thus can reveal limited insights to domain experts.
Instead of obtaining features from language models, we propose BLIAM, a
literature-based data synthesis approach to directly generate training data
points that are interpretable and model-agnostic to downstream applications.
The key idea of BLIAM is to create prompts using existing training data and
then use these prompts to synthesize new data points. BLIAM performs these two
steps iteratively as new data points will define more informative prompts and
new prompts will in turn synthesize more accurate data points. Notably,
literature-based data augmentation might introduce data leakage since labels of
test data points in downstream applications might have already been mentioned
in the language model corpus. To prevent such leakage, we introduce GDSC-combo,
a large-scale drug combination discovery dataset that was published after the
biomedical language model was trained. We found that BLIAM substantially
outperforms a non-augmented approach and manual prompting in this rigorous data
split setting. BLIAM can be further used to synthesize data points for novel
drugs and cell lines that were not even measured in biomedical experiments. In
addition to the promising prediction performance, the data points synthesized
by BLIAM are interpretable and model-agnostic, enabling in silico augmentation
for in vitro experiments. | [
-0.1575030088,
-0.3550238907,
0.4223709404,
0.0836174116,
-0.0388941243,
0.4378086925,
-0.2006379962,
-0.4474327266,
0.4744338393,
0.7787871957,
-0.607881844,
-0.6905204058,
-0.4238184392,
-0.0371944532,
-0.4745371938,
1.355296731,
0.1273345649,
0.3533943892,
-0.3696893156,
-0.2593102455,
-0.2910726964,
-0.3877364695,
-0.1539176404,
-0.7580431104,
0.7569941878,
0.1496768594,
0.7529635429,
0.2715378702,
0.3705120683,
0.1448826939,
-0.0740047097,
0.3481560051,
-0.2924737334,
0.3927802145,
-0.6141844392,
-0.6074295044,
-0.3932814598,
0.1311562359,
0.5313670635,
1.1560616493,
-0.0926676542,
-0.0051106336,
-0.0514505059,
1.0046579838,
-0.6440829635,
-0.2113543749,
-0.7532957196,
0.089212738,
-0.1602849364,
-0.2002639472,
-0.3538435698,
-0.2183769643,
0.1151854098,
-0.5189013481,
0.4413530529,
0.0453408845,
0.766810298,
0.2414652407,
-0.1868381202,
-0.5766441226,
-0.8549439311,
0.6574440598,
-0.7390307188,
0.1703855097,
0.0887249038,
0.4294099808,
-0.7813431025,
-0.8083962798,
-0.4447712004,
-0.1569145471,
-0.3226142824,
0.1780531108,
0.2848820388,
0.1444685161,
0.1916821599,
0.5469437242,
-0.8741794229,
-0.1625590473,
-0.5637280941,
-0.1988410354,
0.5042046309,
0.422015965,
0.3223142028,
-0.0653314069,
-0.6625502706,
-0.147566244,
-0.973479569,
0.0428716764,
0.0454353951,
0.4157562852,
0.0897464529,
0.6125246882,
0.0804052874,
0.686093688,
0.0822267905,
-0.0334964022,
0.3201974928,
-0.5145180821,
-0.3613053262,
0.2857988775,
0.8641942739,
0.2416459322,
-0.5149140954,
-0.2989242673,
-0.1567249,
0.0725717694,
0.1562156677,
-1.0451436043,
-0.5178357959,
0.6791987419,
-0.4497584701,
-0.4753797948,
0.0777379274,
-0.8796088696,
-0.5264958739,
-0.3950073719,
0.2795225382,
-0.4869893789,
-0.0006273866,
0.0507533029,
-0.2618711591,
-0.1451528966,
0.0552092716,
-0.8886787891,
0.4117732346,
0.4236421287,
0.8548580408,
-0.3929938972,
-0.5040384531,
-0.9345320463,
0.7012610435,
-0.5311368704,
0.7045531869,
-0.3629240394,
-0.4890259206,
-0.1617583781,
-0.0271414611,
-0.0297518671,
-0.5904865265,
0.3343217373,
-0.2814307213,
0.2242808789,
-0.2212756723,
-0.70133394,
-0.117003426,
0.0525582656,
-0.8474451303,
0.5991446972,
0.0007803426,
-1.0185055733,
0.5197955966,
-0.5593181252,
-0.4657579362,
0.3620677888,
-0.1298383176,
-0.2777172923,
0.0996831805,
0.2166743428,
-0.0581165366,
-0.1368854046,
0.7291350365,
-0.4437254965,
-0.4762074053,
0.8206366897,
-0.1145491153,
0.7292218804,
0.2564897835,
-0.0395958014,
0.0468246974,
-0.7532116771,
-0.0724998787,
-0.5085757375,
-0.2197397202,
-0.3239825666,
-0.2586718202,
0.0451242961,
0.2743861377,
0.2939229906,
-0.3129281402,
0.1238328665,
-0.67719841,
-0.1150321364,
0.3839097023,
0.0383537561,
0.4861757159,
-0.5490133166,
0.492700547,
-0.0288875736,
-0.1228585616,
-0.1639087796,
-0.3789045811,
-0.4020498097,
-0.422899127,
0.7778384089,
0.6155702472,
-0.9661155343,
0.6282298565,
-0.1704559475,
-0.5318216681,
-0.4544869363,
0.3265669942,
0.3453984559,
0.3420202136,
0.4170999527,
-0.2756763995,
-0.6803820133,
-0.6532738209,
-0.1639800519,
-0.2040691972,
0.0144407554,
-0.1477202773,
0.3815206587,
-0.3402736783,
0.7855733633,
-0.5621173978,
-0.3774777353,
-0.3829417229,
0.1909541786,
0.4202754498,
0.2864728868,
0.2342255265,
-0.5206440091,
-0.2895744443,
0.064272739,
-0.7533602715,
-0.1763157994,
-0.0838316977,
-0.273645401,
0.012324309,
0.4856987894,
-0.5293665528,
0.2982779443,
0.7637348175,
0.0422710106,
0.4060039818,
-0.623375535,
0.1276959777,
-1.1414088011,
0.5181466937,
-0.0351812355,
0.2502634823,
-0.9590088725,
-0.2859217227,
0.0672151074,
-0.3159756958,
-0.3995184302,
0.7814376354,
-0.2884145379,
-0.1495345384,
-0.2878914773,
-0.4586291015,
0.1722239703,
0.2297905684,
0.0571005791,
0.5660248399,
0.5593962669,
-0.3766864836,
0.1053202748,
0.3639646173,
-0.1221896634,
0.3439561427,
-0.5119695067,
-0.166693449,
0.0716648772,
0.5263980627,
-0.7783820629,
-0.4230194688,
0.3282364607,
-0.3561746776,
0.400991708,
-0.2241951227,
-0.5882274508,
-0.2137810737,
-0.3299197853,
0.2432037741,
0.2579626143,
-0.6959157586,
0.4926046133,
0.3822336495,
-0.293409735,
-0.3720768392,
-0.9800621271,
0.3877056241,
-0.1094033048,
-0.6918519139,
0.7227633595,
-0.2782486379,
0.0935099423,
0.1457881033,
0.365844667,
0.276232183,
-0.2764490843,
0.4482482672,
0.5808922648,
0.3119345903,
0.2531319559,
0.5526126027,
-0.2222970426,
-0.1380304694,
-0.371379137,
0.0928526148,
0.2887164354,
-0.2056514621,
0.0261475593,
0.3439818323,
0.542427063,
-0.2345229834,
0.4766062796,
0.5610889196,
-0.3732666969,
-0.5529927611,
0.085630998,
-0.2917660177,
-0.4304868579,
-0.1784878075,
-0.0474509336,
-0.5214262009,
0.4776021242,
-0.236519441,
-0.0873200446,
-0.2314932346,
0.7737191916,
0.1457814276,
0.9350417256,
0.0166863222,
0.226355657,
0.2396523356,
-0.2415975928,
0.3377471268,
-0.5478530526,
-0.2546386719,
-0.1868015081,
-0.5552627444,
-0.6329597235,
-0.4270523489,
0.7088264227,
-0.2070990652,
0.2910658121,
0.0162054077,
-0.3570249081,
0.1831658632,
0.5663475394,
0.0641000718,
0.3616582751,
0.2130711526,
-0.3625464439,
-0.0470939688,
-0.6049389839,
-0.152657032,
1.4717423916,
0.0989755914,
0.6751170754,
-0.2119167596,
0.8788089752,
0.0409861207,
0.409206152,
-0.5527466536,
0.4740525484,
-0.4001860023,
-0.7561544776,
0.078844592,
-0.4011112452,
-1.088070035,
0.0491881706,
-0.532746017,
-0.3536148667,
0.3356286883,
-0.1650959551,
-0.3937035799,
0.0978602469,
-0.6807507873,
0.6101986766,
-0.3195224404,
-0.4635238349,
0.0160188843,
-0.7111570835,
0.5244548917,
-0.1415713429,
0.2838647664,
0.2327898443,
-0.014986773,
0.4863221347,
-0.7932888865,
0.5137782693,
0.009357864,
0.1194307283,
0.1394608617,
0.0937227234,
0.1583782583,
0.0388632715,
-0.1163673028,
0.0481010638,
-0.0429874174,
-0.4470118582,
-0.7533078194,
1.1308420897,
-0.3317919374,
-0.2244315296,
-0.4659942091,
-1.0358688831,
-0.4423986673,
-0.079770565,
0.2939498425,
0.6752228141,
-0.0649637431,
-0.196260944,
0.2710745037,
-0.3649209738,
0.2076061517,
0.4847083986,
-0.3966836035,
-0.9532302618,
1.2367370129,
0.1339070052,
0.2650740147,
0.0916506946,
-0.0258033965,
-0.4734125435,
-0.8739651442,
-0.6058301926,
0.2660858631,
-0.3870657384,
-0.0817122757,
-0.3909058273,
-0.3365699649,
-0.1545714885,
-0.1058901176,
-0.1012393683,
-0.4514664412,
0.1432211846,
-0.176721558,
0.2983365059,
0.5555099845,
-0.4775266051,
-0.0137772085,
-0.9571094513,
0.311883539,
0.1076764315,
0.2331965715,
-0.3002521396,
0.0887609497,
-0.5582754016,
0.2931711078,
-0.3390156329,
-0.8125827909,
0.8244746923,
0.0792134702,
0.4331760108,
0.0336082168,
-0.1399499476,
0.2394194752,
-0.1096297204,
0.7588052154,
0.3686326146,
-0.4876395464,
0.7621489763,
-0.362882942,
0.0078499857,
0.6049234271,
0.1288689971,
-0.0923759863,
-0.7746152282,
-0.6271042228,
-0.7532797456,
0.6614345908,
0.3887023926,
-0.4213466048,
0.3818789124,
-0.1854085773,
0.5633664727,
0.3713161349,
-0.1607061476,
-0.4087472856,
-0.0296024196,
-0.3768304884,
-0.1361111253,
0.2864667475,
-0.3730667233,
-0.2863429189,
0.5863247514,
-0.2339161038,
-0.2330262363,
0.0349218585,
0.0080546616,
-0.390078634,
0.1784541458,
0.268884629,
0.6682311296,
-0.4031421542,
0.1773440242,
-0.2765573859,
-0.4794688523,
0.1584520638,
0.751445353,
-0.5832491517,
0.2843744159,
0.1496453583,
0.6265565753,
-0.03797739,
-0.9066772461,
0.1975083202,
-0.0822369307,
-0.2437783331,
0.075713329,
0.2638893723,
0.0315780193,
0.2452722639,
0.549705565,
0.3475646973,
0.4747094512,
-0.5742189884,
0.3885385692,
0.3009418249,
-0.2114324123,
-0.2335979939,
0.4753328562,
-0.0937046185,
0.1577206254,
-0.0211123154,
-0.2773023546,
-0.3601715267,
0.4247691035,
0.2682332098,
0.5297334194,
-0.2138794065,
0.6343978643,
0.3371710777,
-0.2451059222,
-0.1455955654,
0.1169439331,
0.3804294467,
-0.526140511,
-0.2895750403,
-0.5665068626,
-0.6053940058,
0.3345612586,
-0.2824634314,
0.6615712047,
-0.3857425749,
0.0524907485,
0.3707339168,
0.3395623565,
-0.2184552401,
0.2627127767,
0.0127900532,
0.521417439,
-1.0298537016,
0.9715517163,
0.8340064287,
-0.5819346309,
-0.6874476075,
0.0868636742,
-0.1242027506,
-0.1919758767,
0.3297432363,
0.1039206311,
0.4306194782,
-0.4506667256,
-0.4199124575,
-0.5713377595,
1.2153763771,
0.4253539145,
-0.3535471261,
-0.0171545986,
0.3587298095,
0.8319748044,
-0.6002098322,
0.1753501892,
0.5936823487,
0.4372166693,
0.7609192729,
-0.694519043,
0.2167883962,
-0.3808419406,
0.0275303051,
0.2172732651,
-0.1453150511,
0.7757028341,
-0.2580207288,
-0.126624614,
0.3170838654,
0.3528808355,
0.6951410174,
0.9104676843,
0.221521154,
0.6197436452,
1.0289316177,
0.1629005373,
0.8326576352,
-0.3755811751,
0.0914088562,
1.0567209721,
-0.6652516723,
0.5324013829,
0.5436458588,
-0.0829214528,
0.6514557004,
0.542635262,
-0.2349396646,
0.8700974584,
0.0363141485,
-0.3263300955,
-0.0107148876,
-0.2204273194,
-0.439963311,
0.0112224594,
0.9042700529,
-0.4707976282,
-0.3005172014,
0.1544012725,
-0.3168025315,
0.0161440503,
-0.1547747552,
0.5620828271,
0.1994381994,
-0.9575473666,
0.8713487983,
-0.2222429663,
0.3350360692,
-0.4267513156,
-0.0915607587,
-0.3427983224,
0.2587055564,
-0.3707186878,
-0.8425521851,
0.300793469,
-0.3081867695,
-0.0656967014,
0.1091902331,
0.8798546195,
-1.0805938244,
-0.740198791,
0.3563496172,
0.5930079222,
-0.0150251491,
0.3623299003,
-0.7060552239,
0.0677723736,
0.0704580024,
0.3571237028,
0.6288485527,
0.5671821833,
0.0406470299,
0.5567774177,
1.0186392069,
0.7175979018,
-0.2623093128,
-0.0278381109,
1.1442716122,
-0.4400132895,
-0.2878529429,
-0.3625856638,
0.6008763313,
-0.106796965,
0.0330793783,
0.2882646024,
0.6491710544,
0.261500001,
0.0059459861,
1.0265321732,
0.2843971252,
0.7232966423,
-0.6605756879,
0.7188703418,
-0.4279845953,
0.5444149375,
0.0939084068,
-0.7385216951,
-0.2572834194,
-0.1378052086,
-0.3162216842,
-0.2737129927,
0.7673954368,
1.2591819763,
-0.0698609576,
0.3033573329,
0.1855538636,
0.1317028105,
0.4643493891,
0.7820903063,
0.7226309776,
-0.4879563451,
0.5601681471,
-0.1817456633,
-0.2541615367,
-0.2253721505,
-0.619371295,
-1.0764715672,
-0.4815093577,
-0.0967857763,
-0.7357656956,
0.2771736383,
0.9001923203,
0.4000075459,
-0.9800385833,
-0.2620173395,
-0.2928548157,
0.2519795895,
-0.1191082746,
-0.1599148363,
0.3015469015,
-0.4177322984,
-0.5649725795,
0.5580080748,
0.3882024884,
0.0303446371,
-0.5050551891,
-0.4479957819,
-0.1256953478,
0.0310173389,
0.0734578818,
0.165560782,
-0.3361449838,
0.1876651198,
0.0141664548,
-0.2084774971,
-0.2107708454,
0.913674891,
-0.9830718637,
0.6549759507,
0.6422048807,
0.5190223455,
0.5798082352,
-0.0703535974,
1.0418890715,
-0.643134892,
0.2895684838,
0.1194731817,
0.2295321971,
0.5689159632,
-0.2823760509,
0.4210610688,
0.1582441032,
-0.343744576,
-0.8097315431,
-0.0266294628,
-1.0228550434,
-0.4574127793,
1.0946294069,
-0.0718328953,
-0.4072682261,
-0.0850948691,
-0.3379900157,
0.0247903373,
-0.4970414639,
0.8308380246,
0.4804823995,
0.0532497279,
0.2264834195,
-0.235423401,
0.7206975818,
0.3003941476,
-0.82894665,
0.0080521107,
0.6627065539,
0.0623139665,
0.2110415697,
0.3255349696,
-0.2607939541,
0.3283816278,
-0.0758462325,
-0.1915653199,
-0.0874569565,
-0.3603321314,
-0.2374633998,
0.1156913117,
-0.0755141303,
-0.0463932715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.07268v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.07268v5 | AI Chat Assistants can Improve Conversations about Divisive Topics | 2023-02-14T06:42:09 | 2023-10-20T23:28:08 | Lisa P. Argyle, Ethan Busby, Joshua Gubler, Chris Bail, Thomas Howe, Christopher Rytting, David Wingate | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | A rapidly increasing amount of human conversation occurs online. But
divisiveness and conflict can fester in text-based interactions on social media
platforms, in messaging apps, and on other digital forums. Such toxicity
increases polarization and, importantly, corrodes the capacity of diverse
societies to develop efficient solutions to complex social problems that impact
everyone. Scholars and civil society groups promote interventions that can make
interpersonal conversations less divisive or more productive in offline
settings, but scaling these efforts to the amount of discourse that occurs
online is extremely challenging. We present results of a large-scale experiment
that demonstrates how online conversations about divisive topics can be
improved with artificial intelligence tools. Specifically, we employ a large
language model to make real-time, evidence-based recommendations intended to
improve participants' perception of feeling understood in conversations. We
find that these interventions improve the reported quality of the conversation,
reduce political divisiveness, and improve the tone, without systematically
changing the content of the conversation or moving people's policy attitudes.
These findings have important implications for future research on social media,
political deliberation, and the growing community of scholars interested in the
place of artificial intelligence within computational social science. | [
-0.8075386882,
-1.1452444792,
0.5900204182,
0.4029897749,
-0.2571615279,
0.6957833171,
-0.4965580106,
-0.4191726148,
0.5642031431,
-0.0977262706,
-0.3635156453,
-0.0027873011,
-0.9886730909,
-0.0221678372,
-0.4908787012,
0.7444561124,
0.5071252584,
0.2087799311,
-0.247768119,
-0.2683332264,
-0.310585171,
-0.5329402089,
-0.6682651639,
-0.467938602,
0.5455434918,
0.5163338184,
0.9486787915,
0.2741738856,
0.7698037028,
0.5137488246,
-0.4020031393,
0.3639452755,
-0.7194446325,
-0.0458517559,
-0.2439622134,
-0.6548967957,
-0.3097992539,
0.0017887553,
0.1485400647,
0.6426650286,
-0.1815850288,
-0.2230454385,
0.1666130871,
0.8953257799,
-0.2353254706,
0.1878478974,
-0.8031514287,
-0.1172427684,
0.0639940277,
-0.0138165997,
-0.194846034,
-0.2696262598,
0.2782165408,
-0.609125495,
-0.1581247151,
-0.150229305,
0.5952678323,
0.5589603782,
-0.470160991,
-0.3620216846,
-1.1754328012,
0.7190996408,
-0.7172632217,
0.0741266236,
0.6214986444,
0.1021857485,
-0.2763053775,
-0.4196639359,
-0.8839702606,
0.0489491783,
-0.0440270565,
0.0169120971,
-0.4933670461,
0.1991515756,
0.1165382713,
0.2079778314,
0.0156510305,
0.0264558643,
-0.5531346798,
-0.0131662944,
0.8151350021,
0.2444427013,
0.5637642741,
0.1031871364,
0.4996340871,
-0.0432903953,
-0.1968120784,
-0.0252673216,
0.3642778099,
0.2127916813,
-0.1269892454,
0.1990447342,
-0.0390625894,
0.3827390671,
0.4473806024,
0.0178940259,
0.0553516075,
-0.4300732911,
0.0792095214,
-0.1712998003,
0.5812399983,
0.6187883615,
0.0803917125,
0.2128963768,
0.505241096,
0.3782848418,
0.3463626504,
-0.7352735996,
-0.3111414313,
0.451207906,
-0.3383598626,
-0.2154756486,
0.1405642629,
-0.7378676534,
-0.974263072,
-0.4832987487,
-0.0227711946,
-0.238685742,
-0.5517214537,
-0.2874558866,
-0.4014168978,
0.1345469505,
0.6041142344,
-0.7108492851,
0.2438082844,
0.9186635613,
1.0044101477,
0.027782131,
0.0292160567,
-0.1620982587,
-0.3889080584,
-0.4350942075,
0.7767682672,
-0.607391119,
-0.2911802828,
0.0057257186,
-0.3031864464,
0.2969192266,
-0.5383478999,
0.2983179986,
-0.3113532066,
0.4875411093,
-0.4244920909,
-0.4068031311,
0.0294169877,
0.5457383394,
-0.4712992907,
0.3793565333,
-0.3438120186,
-0.7578761578,
0.1462438852,
-0.9206010699,
-0.6584942341,
-0.0548889749,
-0.3881596625,
-0.3874939978,
0.0639148802,
0.2607884407,
0.1461452395,
-0.299243927,
0.3023182452,
-0.3815867305,
-0.2972532213,
0.4260293841,
-0.2514748871,
0.6759883165,
-0.0515589677,
-0.7381104827,
0.4179056883,
-0.1764375418,
-0.3122160733,
-0.0275260732,
0.0760094672,
-0.4810427427,
0.4056449831,
-0.3710562885,
0.0811750814,
-0.0267861765,
-0.630073607,
-0.0716351941,
-0.6302483082,
1.0579990149,
0.8404917717,
-0.1250235438,
0.6770380139,
-0.501984477,
0.1361400783,
0.1894894987,
0.4140608311,
0.1713743955,
-0.7892785072,
-1.0600073338,
-0.258294493,
0.0257493667,
0.4702499211,
-0.9728546739,
0.4590271711,
-0.1227477267,
-0.7049990296,
-0.6131781936,
-0.025409976,
0.1261066049,
0.0982766449,
0.2922286391,
-0.0237494763,
-0.2479710281,
-0.6985686421,
-0.1819275022,
-0.61654526,
-0.0011956479,
0.6060559154,
0.1197921112,
-0.3593845963,
1.0167953968,
-0.2999170721,
-0.2428796738,
-0.2037647069,
0.6748890877,
-0.2469580323,
0.0323780179,
0.1358579844,
-1.0540091991,
-0.8310573697,
-0.0757942647,
-0.5123869181,
0.084674105,
-0.2597353458,
-0.2497222871,
0.0108538531,
0.4334950149,
-0.3987099528,
0.3498263657,
0.4248876274,
-0.3769205809,
-0.2749744356,
-0.2471369356,
0.568896234,
-1.0257419348,
-0.2936555147,
0.0149372341,
-0.1319973171,
-0.8684620857,
-0.3613265753,
-0.3159986436,
-0.0227533169,
-0.5818372369,
0.2147796303,
-0.1838045567,
0.3121465743,
-0.395295918,
0.3666796088,
-0.0782801956,
0.308278501,
-0.2615434527,
0.6623265743,
0.3061649799,
-0.3595021069,
0.1992893815,
0.4314741194,
-0.1783094257,
0.5581920743,
-0.6323999763,
0.4331518412,
-0.3984766901,
0.4144018292,
-0.9415425062,
-0.2511508763,
0.0991719067,
-0.2688176036,
-0.2053313106,
0.2645637095,
-0.0979358852,
-0.2931367755,
-0.5622553825,
0.3320517838,
0.3616788387,
-0.3662073612,
0.6763626337,
1.1728922129,
-0.5331628919,
-0.1737188846,
-0.6889318228,
0.4174570143,
-0.1967544258,
-0.5195254087,
0.3555959761,
-0.1444795132,
-1.0342257023,
-0.1708600819,
0.4729325771,
-0.1929241419,
0.104760386,
0.391620636,
0.1278212667,
0.2192462087,
0.4985923767,
0.3128876388,
0.108838357,
0.0876773968,
0.2487319112,
0.74971807,
-0.2570068836,
-0.5081077218,
-0.6188040972,
0.5110620856,
0.8412809968,
-0.1115783751,
0.7489506602,
0.2502391338,
-0.2011522949,
0.0315138958,
-0.5400098562,
-0.51727736,
-0.4845738709,
0.2832567692,
0.2258283049,
-0.9439883828,
0.3732746542,
-0.3535406291,
0.3583093882,
0.2469052672,
0.757053256,
-0.1913426071,
1.3380218744,
0.4789752364,
-0.338794142,
0.7427819371,
-0.0917337462,
0.5704544783,
-0.3123897612,
0.0623826124,
-0.3601859212,
-0.6025348306,
-0.6534959078,
-0.6105060577,
0.4926051199,
-0.3489017487,
-0.1473202556,
-0.1548468769,
-0.907319963,
0.5546962023,
0.4193732142,
0.274402976,
0.1233301163,
-0.1455478221,
0.6718671322,
-0.2347726524,
-0.6163378358,
-0.3348460495,
0.6259357333,
0.3810761571,
0.4678349495,
0.1252741218,
0.4419295788,
0.7198987603,
0.5746341944,
-0.6813910604,
0.3880737424,
-0.0824194774,
-0.7191112638,
-0.6237958074,
-0.4761860371,
-0.7728254795,
0.12573421,
-0.4872503877,
-0.477299422,
0.1444349438,
0.1530713141,
-0.2311959416,
0.2945204973,
-0.5218676925,
0.4390949905,
-0.3461745381,
-0.2165227681,
-0.8403710127,
-0.5585091114,
0.0722083151,
-0.0452211648,
0.6813964248,
-0.2907398343,
0.4300845861,
0.6193218231,
-0.4117641747,
0.9048423171,
-0.1917115599,
0.0339528695,
0.5882241726,
-0.2886939645,
0.3329165578,
0.0200182851,
0.0071322834,
0.6987543106,
-0.1646259427,
-0.348456949,
-0.6386355162,
0.5998778343,
-1.2984335423,
-0.8515736461,
-0.1307698637,
-0.4166539609,
0.0010495204,
-0.1895679533,
-0.0098467879,
0.0818796977,
-0.494692266,
0.2316096127,
0.5501047373,
-0.2336293906,
0.3731358349,
0.1337168962,
-0.0443347394,
-0.3273198009,
1.1712852716,
0.212425068,
0.2533247471,
0.0632023737,
0.4331313372,
-0.1014610603,
-0.0582140833,
-0.5076887608,
0.0316450931,
-0.5400451422,
-0.1779294014,
-0.6039505601,
0.0537502654,
-0.3942583799,
-0.2127761841,
-0.306681484,
-0.4879459739,
-0.3444958627,
0.0395897217,
0.5613374114,
0.690978229,
-0.1598426998,
0.251450032,
-0.6159131527,
0.2432734668,
0.5266048312,
0.0149220182,
0.0671903715,
-0.4971085787,
0.1142355353,
0.5353317261,
-0.3079567254,
-0.7301478982,
0.1618786156,
0.2741366029,
0.136737451,
0.433285594,
0.456782788,
0.7600237727,
-0.4978555143,
0.8969441652,
0.1081862971,
-0.8577302694,
0.5315426588,
-0.2212444395,
0.2121304423,
0.6161717772,
0.3587617278,
-0.4594325125,
-0.849796772,
-0.4587345421,
-0.8732737303,
0.5227517486,
0.3767818511,
0.480330348,
0.0225276519,
0.0587019138,
-0.0681548938,
0.1726768911,
-0.2569564581,
-0.2607317567,
-0.3446603715,
-0.1832356155,
0.0640276894,
-0.017434435,
-0.5169308186,
-0.4917163253,
0.6213319302,
-0.1512560993,
0.1324048936,
0.1573799849,
0.3092625737,
-0.2046983838,
0.3268010914,
0.6409493089,
0.5378476977,
0.2540619075,
0.0671477392,
0.2466026247,
-0.1552170068,
0.1065372601,
0.0370947681,
0.0519067757,
-0.2032584697,
0.155128032,
0.4853269756,
-0.4061741829,
-0.5601383448,
0.3841350675,
-0.740139246,
-0.2313394397,
-0.2719680369,
0.0532887317,
0.431365937,
0.4427005649,
0.2549333274,
-0.0729945153,
0.0627233163,
-0.9969323277,
0.0975316539,
0.52551651,
-0.395370543,
-0.0080641806,
0.3532442451,
0.8474249244,
-1.0242854357,
0.4973585904,
-0.1814492047,
-0.6993488669,
0.6687079072,
0.101725921,
0.5196995139,
0.0411365256,
0.5893258452,
-0.0582375638,
0.2181963176,
0.1017639711,
-0.045569703,
-0.1270556301,
-0.8207445741,
-0.2437438816,
-0.2111514509,
-0.8466313481,
0.0161134582,
-0.1500382721,
0.039802026,
-0.5713119507,
-0.5489373803,
0.4241226017,
0.09619876,
-0.2476653755,
-0.2454687059,
0.127823934,
0.1729929894,
-0.8948789239,
0.3152351677,
0.5598243475,
-0.2243001014,
-0.4824521244,
0.1969992816,
0.1637338251,
-0.3093277216,
0.1215341762,
0.1574032158,
-0.2607746124,
-0.1929397732,
-0.6386677623,
-0.5311478972,
0.632006228,
0.3467509449,
-0.7432091236,
0.3826644123,
0.5678288937,
1.0301876068,
-0.1309972554,
0.6075112224,
0.3338419497,
0.547709167,
-0.0683201477,
-1.1122512817,
-0.162483722,
-0.4067472517,
-0.2657694519,
0.2774677277,
-0.9580888748,
0.7734864354,
0.0712388456,
-0.1960523725,
-0.4142720401,
0.6223435402,
-0.2955615222,
0.5308828354,
0.8921827078,
0.0074153915,
0.8671756983,
-0.0501829758,
0.6143041253,
-0.6382398605,
-0.0563299395,
0.857219398,
-0.3926204741,
0.5093214512,
0.5768706799,
-0.0525167324,
0.638201952,
0.3570431471,
0.4399930537,
0.1470221728,
0.2138144374,
-0.4591331184,
-0.3042587638,
-0.5425841212,
-0.0863867253,
0.4874949157,
0.6096150279,
-0.0469917618,
0.1408544332,
0.4341538846,
-0.0622465834,
0.6390061975,
-0.131676808,
1.2561094761,
0.0296213739,
-0.8799917698,
0.2010078877,
-0.0017593241,
0.6735695004,
-0.0314265676,
-0.2120801806,
-0.2520301342,
0.3284338713,
-0.1830703765,
-0.5687177777,
0.4650598168,
0.0747098848,
-0.1701308638,
-0.1785877943,
0.7305346727,
-0.4233583212,
-0.5325367451,
0.4346412718,
0.7179628611,
0.0946821794,
-0.2980924845,
-0.7994354963,
0.34570086,
0.0353883468,
0.1269112527,
0.2930447757,
0.5046688318,
-0.2386496514,
0.6068344116,
0.7568020821,
-0.0714778528,
-0.3347662091,
0.1267584711,
1.4325317144,
-0.2118032128,
-0.4474684298,
-0.9170523882,
0.4465468824,
-0.6308336258,
-0.1238097399,
0.333327055,
0.1549559385,
0.6025189757,
0.540063858,
0.8093720675,
-0.396954298,
0.5172655582,
0.3201417029,
0.8157737851,
-0.359932363,
0.1173635721,
-0.1905484945,
-0.4198380113,
-0.193499282,
0.745713532,
-0.3271252215,
-0.446493715,
0.1744805872,
0.7409938574,
0.1468121707,
0.255746454,
0.2651520669,
0.3197013736,
0.7045126557,
0.0901874006,
1.0743578672,
-0.0316000544,
0.5368181467,
-0.3411536217,
-0.6495197415,
-0.0710122809,
-0.3796618879,
-1.2490009069,
-0.6215367913,
-0.2603768408,
-0.2051277608,
0.1879546195,
1.1213436127,
0.5090497732,
-0.5247956514,
-0.1183584109,
-0.2913249433,
0.3186111748,
0.1621282995,
-0.2157728076,
-0.020576125,
-0.1429293603,
-0.9639018774,
0.2164428234,
0.4593954682,
-0.4028448761,
-0.5191546082,
-0.04558203,
-0.4205642939,
0.4130171537,
0.7344297171,
0.2583529353,
-0.5738021731,
-0.3991218209,
-0.0280230343,
-0.0821601748,
0.2841506004,
0.8232198358,
-0.3588980138,
0.5140604377,
0.6570331454,
0.6624159217,
0.1344297677,
0.3260429204,
0.6098420024,
-0.2532867491,
0.3693873286,
0.4760563076,
-0.0816413015,
0.426527679,
-0.4281152487,
0.1231004,
0.0138324173,
-0.6791945696,
-0.6602000594,
0.0698271915,
-0.425085336,
-0.480483532,
0.9903127551,
-0.1227491498,
-0.0775288418,
-0.3414724469,
-0.5914237499,
0.4676030874,
-0.6300534606,
1.5636390448,
0.7125923634,
-0.3592924178,
0.0811135247,
-0.0080358582,
0.4396280944,
0.6834802032,
-1.2910161018,
0.2103497684,
0.399381876,
-0.4170681834,
0.6634936929,
0.8748778701,
0.269885987,
-0.0653815344,
-0.1439666748,
-0.4325404465,
0.3662677705,
-0.3759178519,
-0.185126543,
-0.0665758625,
-0.0689012632,
0.0417194813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06829v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06829v2 | The Role of Semantic Parsing in Understanding Procedural Text | 2023-02-14T04:59:33 | 2023-05-18T02:41:52 | Hossein Rajaby Faghihi, Parisa Kordjamshidi, Choh Man Teng, James Allen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SC | In this paper, we investigate whether symbolic semantic representations,
extracted from deep semantic parsers, can help reasoning over the states of
involved entities in a procedural text. We consider a deep semantic
parser~(TRIPS) and semantic role labeling as two sources of semantic parsing
knowledge. First, we propose PROPOLIS, a symbolic parsing-based procedural
reasoning framework. Second, we integrate semantic parsing information into
state-of-the-art neural models to conduct procedural reasoning. Our experiments
indicate that explicitly incorporating such semantic knowledge improves
procedural understanding. This paper presents new metrics for evaluating
procedural reasoning tasks that clarify the challenges and identify differences
among neural, symbolic, and integrated models. | [
0.0916015208,
-0.8991244435,
1.3414065838,
0.2839925587,
-0.4864505529,
0.039216727,
-0.2081755847,
-0.5428859591,
-0.032717552,
0.8478078246,
-0.8286049962,
-0.640390873,
-0.5874986053,
0.3921003938,
-0.2562128007,
0.500605464,
0.031897191,
0.3753849566,
-0.4082804322,
0.3038629293,
-0.5720636249,
-0.3430822492,
-0.6472151875,
-0.2454497069,
0.5045618415,
0.0708386227,
0.7982584834,
0.8270071149,
0.651720047,
0.5472337604,
-0.0604234077,
0.3879062831,
-0.0732939988,
0.5450139046,
-0.5715023875,
-0.5329413414,
-0.0902035758,
-0.2217905968,
0.7749420404,
0.8354224563,
-0.1568343788,
-0.1979551166,
-0.3575735092,
-0.0456219837,
-0.1481954604,
0.7912892699,
-0.7434819937,
-0.0544771887,
-0.2909236252,
-0.339112699,
-0.5715278983,
-0.3352639377,
0.0447599068,
-1.1621134281,
0.1626527458,
-0.0051403581,
0.6046973467,
0.5037495494,
-0.3133788407,
-0.6400942206,
-0.4406921268,
0.8245100975,
-0.5549439788,
0.4650833011,
0.3092876077,
0.3085237741,
-0.534702003,
-0.9165633917,
-0.7279539704,
-0.3587891757,
-0.1737677157,
-0.0643860474,
0.2831210792,
0.288148433,
0.2490511537,
0.4026407003,
-0.3833307922,
-0.2050483078,
-0.3734742105,
-0.5352035761,
0.2547762692,
0.2450984716,
0.6925618649,
-0.2428696752,
-0.3602094948,
-0.2080300599,
-0.401157856,
0.0828929394,
0.178927511,
0.583909452,
0.3094686866,
0.5780076981,
0.1041458249,
1.024523139,
-0.3227310777,
-0.0708103254,
-0.1301740855,
-0.3397916257,
-0.3549183309,
0.4006586075,
0.442148447,
0.0452516377,
0.4729130566,
-0.2043668926,
0.0977615565,
0.5101351142,
0.6515715718,
-0.6531665921,
0.129975155,
0.0077664517,
-0.4336458743,
-0.0332775973,
0.2862193584,
-0.2980418503,
-0.6279225349,
-0.8261014819,
-0.2411320508,
-0.7442649603,
-0.2844643593,
0.6451846361,
-0.5418919921,
0.1558657289,
0.8667997122,
-0.7849917412,
0.591653347,
1.3842229843,
0.708096087,
0.1111639664,
-0.3649859726,
-0.5793851018,
0.2185300887,
-0.3820426166,
1.1841599941,
-0.8915785551,
-0.575276494,
0.1022899821,
0.2940743566,
-0.3350335956,
-0.3436078727,
0.6843878031,
-0.414144963,
-0.1121536493,
-0.480851531,
-0.5470368266,
-0.5958530903,
0.2545537353,
-0.5604815483,
0.7132143378,
0.2383019775,
-0.178959161,
0.3714212477,
-0.1436720192,
-0.4046568573,
0.2147001326,
-0.3192954063,
0.2662649155,
0.3571174443,
-0.0157259759,
0.1366341859,
-0.3415781558,
0.4872692823,
-0.0645748153,
-0.1526920348,
0.3228616714,
-0.0853344202,
0.8521853685,
0.1402794272,
0.0951826945,
0.4859884679,
-0.5637755394,
-0.0901221335,
-0.2765798867,
0.0737014413,
-0.6087441444,
-0.0176532306,
-0.1749299914,
0.3114157319,
-0.021227669,
-0.6422231793,
0.2858345509,
-0.6392375231,
0.4127065539,
0.7538998127,
0.2065915018,
0.588496089,
0.0651731491,
0.3414580822,
0.133081466,
-0.0569102913,
-0.2754032016,
-0.6431742907,
-0.7258585691,
-0.1088327244,
0.0825249553,
0.3500339389,
-0.8084208965,
0.2899389565,
-0.199165374,
-0.2215391994,
-0.5483529568,
-0.082646735,
0.4379164577,
0.860745132,
0.6035252213,
-0.080386661,
-0.2293984443,
-0.7100926638,
-0.3618082702,
-0.341309607,
0.058785934,
0.0530905612,
0.5384821296,
0.0846547931,
0.7693210244,
-0.5222998261,
-0.429123342,
-0.3114412427,
0.1564529091,
0.1528822482,
0.396278739,
0.1356362849,
-0.5685572028,
-0.0511324406,
0.064621672,
-0.7734773159,
0.0746029317,
-0.6372035742,
-0.4335173666,
-0.2021092027,
0.5216968656,
-1.1327574253,
0.3015535474,
-0.1526776403,
-0.8480311632,
0.3315989375,
-0.4896532595,
0.1195091084,
-0.4556428492,
-0.6074644327,
0.0455718599,
-0.3083927035,
-0.589630127,
0.1654172838,
-0.0559506342,
-0.0046663331,
-0.4801987708,
0.6303156614,
-0.3154359162,
-0.0757720768,
-0.0450823568,
0.0534262732,
0.310882777,
0.3284164965,
0.7549695969,
0.6220388412,
0.5762844086,
-0.5111601353,
0.3249078393,
0.2133849561,
-0.270937413,
0.5157320499,
-0.6405123472,
-0.0828561261,
-0.2279842347,
0.2853516638,
-0.7331104279,
-0.1979875118,
0.5208105445,
-0.3115134239,
0.155613631,
-0.4307004213,
-0.5913268924,
-0.0577671304,
-0.0526587926,
0.1405686885,
0.2167483568,
-0.2307367921,
0.6929348111,
0.4055347741,
0.0551918522,
-0.0632421076,
-0.6814505458,
-0.085346885,
-0.1283473521,
-0.8236339092,
0.5878834128,
0.4834247828,
-0.6346453428,
0.0503776446,
-0.3169525862,
-0.3747416139,
-0.1052966937,
0.2616745234,
0.0649962574,
-0.4488804638,
0.3345331848,
0.1415937841,
-0.4743887186,
0.4770917892,
-0.5080211163,
0.5384952426,
-0.2681945562,
-0.3706563115,
-0.7517186403,
0.2025948018,
0.3327152431,
-0.365686506,
0.839484632,
0.2770917714,
-0.3254607022,
-0.2474545538,
-0.2260185182,
-0.3553411365,
-0.4660184681,
-0.1249338761,
-0.6039850116,
-0.5529516339,
0.3851211667,
-0.1401614398,
-0.3122379184,
0.5315338373,
0.4058228433,
-0.1686196923,
0.4256541133,
0.1640343964,
0.8584295511,
0.0082274182,
-0.1394464225,
0.1053035259,
-0.519823432,
-0.5978215337,
-0.5456787348,
0.213797912,
-0.5733395815,
-0.955858171,
0.0103636999,
-0.1497802287,
-0.2838418484,
0.3103244603,
-0.6097339988,
0.3455602825,
0.5254967213,
0.2397421747,
0.3488221169,
-0.088812083,
0.2295650244,
-0.0148068843,
-0.1888211071,
-0.7386945486,
0.2690258622,
0.4165131152,
0.5607389808,
-0.012510621,
0.5492799282,
0.1496002227,
-0.3280197084,
-1.0317368507,
0.8803957105,
-0.1146195978,
-0.1255113035,
-0.4728027284,
-0.1057924554,
-0.785477221,
0.6118807197,
0.1336021721,
-0.5080709457,
0.3803056479,
-0.1386210769,
-0.3864170313,
0.0595365763,
-0.5712991357,
1.1024457216,
0.0641773716,
-0.1718966216,
-0.3876015246,
-0.6149491072,
0.1500671953,
0.669143796,
0.2218432128,
-0.2016409487,
-0.2043293864,
0.5766252875,
-0.7892379761,
0.8175917268,
-0.2738719285,
-0.1808843464,
0.7336162329,
0.5140434504,
0.2238087207,
0.2752186656,
-0.1691000313,
0.3570327759,
0.0229200423,
-0.0931697115,
-0.981947124,
0.7071331143,
-0.3544404209,
-0.8407795429,
-0.922187984,
-0.5564219952,
-0.0634163842,
0.2805485427,
-0.3963580728,
0.5189709067,
0.1603992134,
0.0193608981,
0.7184360623,
-0.0513692014,
0.3256489635,
0.1681868732,
0.0212861355,
0.1692872941,
0.8783996701,
-0.177156657,
0.0804805607,
0.371511966,
0.3554841876,
-0.5416043997,
-0.4626447558,
-0.638594389,
0.3719129562,
-0.9584985375,
0.095382385,
-0.688891232,
0.0437901206,
-0.2877396643,
-0.0766141042,
-0.2350250781,
-0.6449161172,
-0.2726962268,
-0.2640224099,
0.4457274377,
0.8234178424,
0.3389605582,
0.5190811157,
-0.689889729,
0.4516704381,
-0.0129182637,
0.1325144172,
-0.1451824456,
-0.1678391844,
0.3542844057,
0.0113837365,
0.0862322077,
-1.0271785259,
0.2228470296,
-0.2314790785,
0.5018267632,
0.107803151,
-0.2796283066,
0.932615757,
-0.7228838205,
0.9436205029,
-0.0579288229,
-1.0719406605,
0.7144735456,
-0.6266134977,
0.1976599544,
0.6333427429,
0.1948488951,
-0.5622879267,
-0.4236629903,
-0.5336322784,
-0.3593809009,
0.8491191864,
0.468313992,
0.2050437629,
-0.4889866114,
0.3015355468,
0.0705427825,
0.0300335512,
-0.4855434597,
0.2520928979,
-0.248704195,
-0.1773714721,
0.3729060888,
-0.2449079603,
0.1093191504,
-0.3544798195,
0.3224989176,
0.0702052042,
0.0313223973,
0.2859596014,
-0.4351420999,
0.2475899458,
0.0976625904,
0.5290967226,
0.9311415553,
0.0099728117,
0.2178875506,
-0.1596188247,
-0.6263734698,
-0.2119419873,
-0.0935991034,
0.0242358167,
0.2193640918,
0.9592780471,
0.6193424463,
0.374517411,
-0.5089782476,
0.1561792046,
-0.0865196958,
0.2767806351,
-0.2620869875,
0.2889367044,
0.0370303318,
-0.0456428006,
-0.2718555331,
-0.0085635819,
0.351087302,
-0.8915441632,
0.1577119529,
0.2390647829,
-0.4426176846,
-0.1956997365,
0.2398265004,
0.1619959027,
-0.4408141971,
0.9925268292,
-0.0604983084,
-0.3608653843,
0.9816246629,
0.6008121967,
0.5494121909,
-0.4068065584,
0.5868079662,
0.2686069608,
0.1428081095,
-0.1551781148,
0.5793531537,
-0.3942923546,
-0.5170889497,
-0.480099082,
-0.7356509566,
-0.3467395604,
-0.4688144028,
-0.4107966125,
0.2791788876,
-0.3881600797,
0.0734053478,
0.1391765177,
-0.4112365544,
-0.4376811683,
0.2078463733,
-0.0479858406,
0.8494333625,
-0.498360604,
0.7346822023,
0.6093034744,
-0.7084800005,
-0.5749407411,
-0.0796969235,
0.0104020964,
-0.8125542402,
1.0389626026,
0.3353404701,
-0.4296482801,
-0.3137088418,
0.2387319654,
-0.4961863756,
0.5884728432,
0.2260130346,
-0.3216592073,
-0.2009848356,
0.6520025134,
0.8174402714,
-0.3095889688,
0.4709247947,
0.5828397274,
0.6439673305,
0.3571966588,
-0.6711976528,
0.2309677601,
0.1096719503,
0.1813275516,
0.2085630745,
-0.0753011107,
0.8808573484,
0.1546801776,
-0.257563591,
-0.0040955725,
0.7575954199,
0.201165244,
0.2768491507,
0.4646245241,
0.403249979,
0.827552259,
-0.3119892478,
1.445304513,
-0.0031137529,
-0.0222862251,
1.332236886,
-0.0980155617,
0.4035470188,
0.5626180172,
-0.0091551952,
0.8875952363,
0.7829501629,
0.3070891201,
0.5477790236,
0.4827851355,
-0.3179419339,
-0.7457615137,
-0.5144689679,
-0.2894494534,
0.6190903187,
0.7497085333,
-0.289326638,
-0.6486402154,
-0.1782983094,
0.0031527583,
0.480091393,
-0.4270794094,
0.7548043728,
0.2928917408,
-0.9110175371,
-0.0500491448,
-0.0231007338,
-0.2678058445,
-0.5610852242,
-0.7375407815,
0.1319425404,
0.3061824441,
-0.1493483037,
-1.3066524267,
0.890619278,
-0.3008203506,
-0.0282175895,
-0.7649168968,
0.8603812456,
-0.2262307554,
-0.75069803,
0.1485268027,
0.3434362113,
0.2302800566,
-0.3095420897,
-0.4971265793,
0.3904889822,
-0.4427596927,
-0.0693226829,
-0.0347517952,
0.8287328482,
-0.4540473521,
0.4620911777,
0.7547725439,
-0.0268017873,
-0.09100122,
0.4767580032,
0.9088641405,
-0.7941311002,
-0.6611933708,
-1.1743382215,
0.5700879097,
-0.2325777113,
-0.2214125544,
0.6731971502,
0.4151170552,
0.6442620754,
-0.3822170198,
0.0927854404,
0.1066656113,
0.0989445969,
-0.8173494339,
0.2437548786,
-0.0370855518,
0.1987563372,
0.0671066269,
-0.6694005728,
-0.2745929062,
1.0285730362,
-0.6064860821,
-0.3999386132,
0.87312603,
0.5811751485,
-0.1300341785,
0.3288653791,
-0.0332093239,
0.054251492,
0.2912571728,
0.3228444755,
1.1749011278,
-0.0065443246,
-0.0099640172,
-0.4147896469,
-0.0003905566,
0.499358356,
-0.9532184601,
-0.9714823365,
-0.6287059188,
-0.1953296363,
-0.4063766301,
0.1873808056,
0.7381985188,
0.5564597249,
-0.6255537868,
-0.2102047801,
-0.6486529112,
0.621932745,
-0.1649334282,
-0.2583553493,
0.3719183803,
-0.8942950368,
-0.6556626558,
0.5355055928,
0.4936639369,
-0.4287070334,
-0.186222896,
0.1238740012,
-0.1483558118,
0.0381454267,
0.6261651516,
-0.1203949377,
-1.1128228903,
-0.1427347064,
0.0591325201,
0.1232587695,
0.0107083218,
1.4175009727,
-0.9001765847,
0.4300504625,
0.6362580061,
0.5359755158,
0.3988676369,
0.1622406542,
0.4486474693,
-0.1781969517,
0.4562398195,
0.4926749766,
0.3939825892,
0.1150966138,
-0.7791380882,
0.5919710994,
0.2796368003,
-0.0595994331,
-0.5758794546,
0.3288958669,
-1.2049785852,
-0.5648947954,
1.2164363861,
-0.2237948626,
-0.466674298,
-0.3402139843,
-0.4202975333,
0.1457423419,
-0.3694082499,
0.285502702,
0.8072819114,
-0.4877769351,
-0.0382540561,
-0.4505378604,
0.7131234407,
-0.0325389393,
-1.0353614092,
0.1238024905,
0.6857455969,
-0.1272767633,
0.2117353678,
0.6455549002,
-0.2187972814,
0.3385908008,
0.0892667398,
-0.5979599953,
-0.2823481858,
-0.6198449731,
-0.0295084342,
-0.0422362015,
-0.2034333944,
-0.0106571829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06784v1 | The Stable Entropy Hypothesis and Entropy-Aware Decoding: An Analysis and Algorithm for Robust Natural Language Generation | 2023-02-14T02:02:33 | 2023-02-14T02:02:33 | Kushal Arora, Timothy J. O'Donnell, Doina Precup, Jason Weston, Jackie C. K. Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art language generation models can degenerate when applied to
open-ended generation problems such as text completion, story generation, or
dialog modeling. This degeneration usually shows up in the form of incoherence,
lack of vocabulary diversity, and self-repetition or copying from the context.
In this paper, we postulate that ``human-like'' generations usually lie in a
narrow and nearly flat entropy band, and violation of these entropy bounds
correlates with degenerate behavior. Our experiments show that this stable
narrow entropy zone exists across models, tasks, and domains and confirm the
hypothesis that violations of this zone correlate with degeneration. We then
use this insight to propose an entropy-aware decoding algorithm that respects
these entropy bounds resulting in less degenerate, more contextual, and
"human-like" language generation in open-ended text generation settings. | [
-0.2336941361,
-0.8821159601,
0.323191762,
0.0192948207,
-0.1679247916,
0.1135029718,
-0.2864394486,
-0.5651051402,
-0.0066940091,
0.3957708776,
-0.4426513612,
-0.3828093112,
-0.3126925528,
0.1877934039,
-0.1202111542,
0.8064457774,
0.0152997449,
-0.1837621033,
-0.1301671863,
0.1097427607,
-0.5368251801,
-0.2973202765,
-0.4900115132,
-0.4138743877,
0.0219800547,
0.3702359796,
0.9549576044,
0.7876495123,
0.1907395124,
0.2473660111,
-0.0750083178,
-0.0337236188,
-0.603723228,
0.7926675081,
0.0995756239,
-0.2984032929,
-0.3260827065,
-0.181967169,
0.53487432,
0.5804420114,
-0.1436445713,
0.0096616996,
0.2947667837,
0.5849055648,
-0.7212871909,
-0.1748156548,
-0.9998115897,
-0.0127243288,
-0.2943140566,
-0.3292639852,
-0.4223405421,
-0.4364629388,
0.1540291607,
-0.3116194904,
0.6322989464,
-0.2160108685,
0.635289073,
0.3236759603,
-0.2248549312,
-0.4410633743,
-0.7161689997,
0.8492747545,
-0.7863166928,
0.3998474777,
0.6760534644,
-0.1069441289,
-0.3940826356,
-0.2906319797,
-0.6328695416,
-0.1063687652,
0.2528135777,
-0.0882184654,
-0.3289755285,
0.0673065037,
0.0326340906,
0.5188459158,
-0.6795433164,
0.0334731266,
-0.3110943735,
-0.3009891212,
0.3877829313,
0.1932040602,
0.5816850066,
-0.2561340332,
-0.2058304995,
-0.0758150145,
-0.5701292753,
0.1283334345,
0.4835832119,
0.4249937236,
-0.1725783646,
0.3209686875,
-0.2414148003,
0.8613407016,
0.061396841,
-0.1487598419,
0.281477809,
-0.1865248233,
-0.2863934338,
0.3045807183,
0.6064673066,
0.3889416158,
0.3478824496,
-0.4413807392,
-0.1233887374,
0.1827685833,
0.1200370416,
-0.6804490089,
-0.2999108136,
0.3455447257,
-0.4114373326,
-0.4201092422,
-0.0423485339,
-0.7529996037,
-0.4388982356,
-0.0961131528,
0.2075896114,
-0.5790943503,
-0.332900852,
0.2873483896,
-0.4250305891,
-0.0272070616,
-0.1300410032,
-1.2704435587,
-0.0202087946,
0.4789256752,
0.7525849342,
0.0452653691,
-0.2007594556,
-0.230774954,
0.2819377482,
-0.2134905905,
0.6204698086,
-0.4717166126,
-0.0854539052,
-0.0297132228,
-0.4850232899,
-0.061772529,
-0.4133884907,
0.3910245597,
-0.5889918804,
0.2750457525,
-0.1119110137,
-0.2110145539,
0.1508845091,
0.3446609378,
-0.6059358716,
0.7451047897,
0.0120750237,
-1.1991337538,
0.6818801165,
-0.3210422397,
-0.5045649409,
-0.0225949567,
-0.1127002835,
-0.4077828825,
0.1648329794,
-0.2136777639,
0.3132582903,
-0.3266096711,
0.2160976827,
-0.34843117,
-0.05169506,
0.1677304357,
-0.6444149017,
0.8899235129,
0.656922698,
-0.4467115998,
-0.2395692021,
-0.9534460306,
0.2891920805,
0.1760798246,
-0.6660301685,
-0.6004948616,
0.242767334,
-0.139979586,
-0.0283496361,
0.1839671582,
-0.7459402084,
0.1507324874,
-0.4560903609,
0.6881784201,
0.6047629118,
0.1300357878,
0.5682584643,
-0.3088461757,
0.3543130457,
0.0083346199,
-0.1816899031,
-0.1744327545,
-0.3679434061,
-0.4328994453,
-0.2554052174,
0.1041639894,
0.6248511672,
-0.6936708689,
0.5057455301,
-0.1946133524,
-0.3278954029,
-0.3515579998,
0.4206162095,
0.2165048569,
0.8166514039,
0.1954649389,
-0.21102947,
-0.6377406716,
-0.7340391874,
-0.2485509068,
-0.3729353547,
-0.093641296,
-0.4698340297,
0.1518121809,
-0.6104391813,
1.0957690477,
-0.2902823091,
0.3239270747,
-0.0903124288,
0.3870691061,
-0.0654232353,
0.7834934592,
0.374270767,
-0.685554862,
-0.2800836265,
-0.0990716293,
-0.8381292224,
0.0933998302,
-0.1784180403,
-0.1629602313,
0.460847646,
0.4747180641,
-0.6302224994,
0.3835406005,
0.5444972515,
-0.5445888638,
0.2070661038,
-0.217318818,
-0.0964860916,
-1.1081167459,
0.0276667681,
-0.1951526999,
-0.1368007809,
-0.8680772781,
-0.0442063361,
-0.0981947556,
-0.0452645347,
-0.0024402565,
0.1255734265,
-0.4814081788,
0.4806852043,
-0.2833579779,
-0.0916723311,
0.0743535906,
0.1523433328,
0.0142598795,
0.403447479,
0.764267385,
-0.5829765201,
-0.1004579663,
-0.0050636446,
-0.3573678434,
0.1791699231,
-0.5483325124,
0.0718377605,
-0.5113005638,
-0.0039975801,
-0.8852415681,
-0.5892988443,
0.1472420841,
-0.3382767141,
0.4077017605,
0.298415184,
-0.4109590054,
-0.0318981595,
-0.4810857177,
0.6169608831,
0.6839207411,
-0.3564756513,
-0.0054244925,
0.3164694011,
-0.1475281566,
-0.4673196375,
-0.9116175175,
0.0585537404,
-0.3091962039,
-0.8535021544,
0.3379172981,
-0.1354166716,
-0.5886289477,
-0.0973068029,
-0.0883976743,
-0.2307896614,
0.4005424082,
-0.0519426987,
-0.1126747578,
-0.2512049079,
0.0936720148,
0.0788229555,
0.0197974369,
-0.0968609154,
-0.3072004318,
0.6708828807,
-0.2434125394,
0.0809115246,
-0.2718120515,
0.4702372849,
0.9106096625,
-0.1782082766,
0.6954527497,
0.3783870041,
-0.61100775,
-0.3476938009,
-0.179087162,
-0.1165425628,
-0.4985849261,
0.0488483608,
-0.2893816531,
-0.819894433,
0.6743099689,
0.2949021459,
0.081024088,
0.4166263342,
0.6637032628,
0.1483698189,
0.8643645048,
0.8267855644,
0.1933639646,
0.3885041773,
0.0187980533,
0.2758686841,
-0.382551074,
-0.0967923328,
-0.5998942852,
-0.1879458725,
-0.6560319662,
-0.1156625301,
-0.0518005043,
0.59262079,
-0.4307460487,
0.3231606483,
-0.6925274134,
0.4982283711,
0.638409555,
-0.0442048423,
0.3138393462,
0.1406859756,
-0.1522572041,
-0.0012958595,
-0.8647215962,
-0.6602356434,
0.5543032885,
0.4397105575,
0.9264255166,
0.1591809541,
0.9972878695,
0.3813094795,
0.0929033011,
-0.3983280063,
0.1296653599,
0.0720337033,
-0.822052896,
-0.5686169863,
-0.5827317834,
-1.1003373861,
-0.1956926435,
-0.0880840942,
-1.0049315691,
0.3535137475,
0.4759677052,
-0.3017284274,
0.3170405924,
-0.6993345618,
0.8936058283,
-0.0603163987,
-0.3184169531,
0.1385602504,
-0.7837540507,
0.5423850417,
-0.0412878767,
0.0524392165,
-0.1227756888,
0.271802485,
0.4248079658,
-0.3174663782,
0.8744675517,
-0.2606653273,
-0.4223239124,
0.7628501654,
0.4261401296,
0.3011796176,
0.1319434792,
-0.506741941,
-0.0951235443,
-0.0478671677,
-0.4659813941,
-0.2446891069,
0.4306658804,
-0.6889702082,
-0.3998370171,
-0.2417654246,
-0.5144816041,
-0.1923051327,
0.4564428329,
0.9395154715,
0.5214442015,
-0.2646534741,
0.2163691372,
0.8933832645,
-0.2229163051,
0.4504095614,
0.1549812108,
0.1943602413,
-0.4286424518,
0.9500229359,
0.0503511988,
0.4123936892,
0.2309836,
0.1220399886,
0.0207900926,
-0.5815314054,
-0.3959761262,
-0.2523286343,
-0.6292231679,
-0.5136022568,
-0.3350557685,
0.0034156004,
-0.6188411117,
-0.3996267319,
-0.1430142969,
-0.3278894424,
-0.2483224422,
-0.0834992155,
0.2413509488,
0.570274055,
-0.2929127514,
0.1492302418,
-0.772300005,
0.5158546567,
0.3565335274,
0.5196083188,
0.097475633,
-0.1384330541,
-0.1495788693,
0.3293790519,
-0.4456498027,
-1.0125874281,
0.2146992981,
0.4057653546,
0.5716786981,
0.6493886113,
0.4313360453,
0.3237457275,
-0.3446128368,
0.7766139507,
0.4135534465,
-1.0795129538,
0.5345899463,
-0.6381416917,
0.5365156531,
0.8624312878,
-0.1204234511,
-0.5294107199,
-0.8567507863,
-0.3984424472,
-0.911280036,
0.5231968164,
0.3721729219,
0.4653424919,
-0.479840368,
0.2840621173,
0.5301633477,
0.0827102512,
-0.8112906218,
0.0260388367,
-0.5057342649,
-0.3627298772,
0.0797172263,
-0.2434380352,
0.101966314,
0.0369310752,
0.572715342,
-0.0355855338,
0.3517666757,
0.4177592099,
-0.0433897376,
-0.6224279404,
0.5630751252,
0.8692564964,
0.493498534,
-0.5227239728,
0.5307573676,
-0.0972936302,
-0.5556932092,
0.1097988337,
-0.1689743698,
-0.5536636114,
-0.0461398177,
0.3527124822,
0.6590560675,
-0.2690084875,
-0.6830032468,
0.1143731251,
-0.1900328547,
-0.0939685106,
-0.0340096056,
0.3725966811,
-0.0827953517,
0.0350067168,
0.4995673895,
0.4836304188,
0.0230365936,
-0.8405997753,
0.3653433919,
0.6679458022,
-0.4013547003,
-0.457057178,
0.8418101072,
0.2555756867,
-0.3078444302,
0.6680839658,
-0.351822108,
-0.5282638073,
0.4545626044,
0.9303581715,
1.2371637821,
-0.0151565606,
0.2253614217,
0.2695074081,
0.4885383248,
-0.1470948309,
0.5030169487,
-0.3129821718,
-0.9103184342,
-0.1772124469,
-0.7686147094,
0.034576416,
0.1255135536,
-0.6174948812,
-0.0541656874,
-0.4378683865,
-0.3168350458,
-0.2975659668,
-0.4547213316,
-0.3604421616,
0.1937865317,
0.4148627222,
0.9603628516,
-0.6214897633,
0.7405439019,
0.4835859835,
-0.0899900198,
-0.3833107948,
0.462067306,
-0.2007854283,
-0.5384364128,
0.2754072547,
0.2797914743,
-0.4112764299,
-0.0654303357,
-0.6451746821,
-0.7884610295,
1.0303618908,
0.6240903139,
-0.1070793495,
-0.0599612556,
0.0665942281,
0.6657801867,
-0.1984122694,
-0.5511289835,
0.5656503439,
0.3021401465,
-0.1147191077,
-0.7234608531,
0.1929445565,
-0.4721904695,
-0.1542254835,
0.3965131044,
-0.5896270871,
0.7985675335,
-0.3579562008,
-0.5710784793,
0.2310015559,
0.6030873656,
0.2327897549,
0.5552906394,
0.4556318521,
0.7074118257,
0.8596248031,
0.1744831651,
0.8974636197,
-0.5102728009,
0.2462413311,
0.8210075498,
-0.0409648158,
0.6895648837,
0.4679978192,
0.3726500869,
0.5960020423,
0.5225606561,
0.2181870192,
0.7674469948,
0.2158420086,
-0.4137866795,
-0.3734337986,
-0.0755119845,
-0.4813811481,
0.4736268818,
0.2254348099,
-0.4206131399,
-0.3532126248,
-0.0803392529,
0.1063420922,
0.135310486,
-0.2321930081,
0.6272183657,
-0.0960778743,
-0.9250173569,
1.0271641016,
0.2100436985,
0.6826276779,
-0.4267105162,
0.1293653548,
0.0147586484,
0.1578346789,
-0.2881763875,
-0.5997595191,
0.3754260242,
0.1845048517,
-0.5081782937,
-0.3891196847,
1.0664342642,
-0.499992162,
-0.1545757949,
-0.0316933207,
0.3713416755,
-0.1716557145,
0.2438042462,
-0.3459728062,
0.0824586228,
0.2575373054,
-0.3621682227,
0.0891030505,
0.5439316034,
0.0909775868,
0.4153938293,
0.244209528,
-0.1965352744,
0.2741039395,
-0.3752021492,
0.6139421463,
-0.5697486401,
-0.5895389915,
-0.9348205328,
0.7335458398,
0.2031006962,
-0.5146310925,
0.718015492,
0.3980022669,
0.5791617036,
-0.0895380601,
1.0762873888,
-0.4347159863,
0.1543996036,
-0.5654671192,
0.7290553451,
-0.2763664722,
0.1451392472,
-0.2933237851,
-0.9121721983,
-0.4490170479,
0.5761290193,
-0.0876684636,
-0.1407947242,
0.339094907,
0.5412634611,
0.0147112953,
0.0849290192,
0.1666715592,
0.0216538701,
0.0958438516,
0.4186755717,
0.8644567132,
-0.2154325545,
0.4674539566,
-0.1836286038,
-0.2911837697,
0.0704841614,
-0.9176140428,
-0.7822241187,
-0.5624943376,
-0.3012617528,
-0.5250478387,
-0.0867685378,
0.7390665412,
0.4768431187,
-0.6805431843,
-0.0440343507,
-0.7400363684,
0.16872181,
0.0692255944,
-0.2860165238,
0.0831667483,
-0.6013806462,
-0.4994143844,
0.2533203065,
0.1992370635,
0.3367170393,
-0.2470453829,
-0.316229552,
0.1055318564,
0.2479573786,
0.5049235225,
0.6316210032,
-0.4001415074,
-0.2943808138,
0.1094107479,
-0.3341355324,
0.0738143623,
0.8786794543,
-0.6589865685,
0.7019559741,
0.9206623435,
0.4920231998,
-0.0995410308,
0.191021651,
0.7695885301,
-0.9887251854,
0.16850245,
0.2548006773,
0.078129217,
0.3472876549,
-0.4265740216,
0.1059447676,
0.2043545991,
-0.6329804659,
-1.0580884218,
0.5111494064,
-0.8559582829,
-0.4655331671,
0.9355053902,
0.1150490716,
-0.1060209572,
-0.2369315326,
-0.018579863,
0.4365627766,
-0.4600721896,
1.1791137457,
0.5802600384,
-0.2028423697,
0.1698020548,
-0.2753360868,
0.7100686431,
0.2783306539,
-0.5604992509,
0.5085154176,
0.5502738953,
0.1634449214,
0.531449616,
0.5371236801,
0.1602425873,
0.3235071898,
0.3318823576,
0.0139484974,
0.1258393675,
-0.2407280207,
-0.2938784659,
0.3594172895,
0.2780053318,
-0.0705125704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06761v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06761v3 | Language Model Analysis for Ontology Subsumption Inference | 2023-02-14T00:21:56 | 2023-05-08T17:21:40 | Yuan He, Jiaoyan Chen, Ernesto Jiménez-Ruiz, Hang Dong, Ian Horrocks | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LO | Investigating whether pre-trained language models (LMs) can function as
knowledge bases (KBs) has raised wide research interests recently. However,
existing works focus on simple, triple-based, relational KBs, but omit more
sophisticated, logic-based, conceptualised KBs such as OWL ontologies. To
investigate an LM's knowledge of ontologies, we propose OntoLAMA, a set of
inference-based probing tasks and datasets from ontology subsumption axioms
involving both atomic and complex concepts. We conduct extensive experiments on
ontologies of different domains and scales, and our results demonstrate that
LMs encode relatively less background knowledge of Subsumption Inference (SI)
than traditional Natural Language Inference (NLI) but can improve on SI
significantly when a small number of samples are given. We will open-source our
code and datasets. | [
-0.2584777474,
-0.8262752295,
0.7073174119,
-0.1715281457,
0.1825817227,
-0.4028729796,
0.2109157145,
-0.4502911866,
0.1644010544,
1.0236183405,
-0.599134624,
-0.6285195351,
-0.4826259911,
-0.0145723308,
-0.3299476206,
0.5181094408,
0.2931946218,
0.019163359,
-0.2632907629,
-0.1163537353,
-0.2819818556,
-0.444013834,
-0.3060280085,
-0.4707754254,
0.3629979491,
0.3778347671,
0.5643305182,
0.4727216065,
0.4356182218,
0.1651091427,
0.0513794124,
0.0311758276,
-0.385209322,
-0.2669579983,
-0.3233646452,
-0.6610113978,
-0.6256947517,
0.074792102,
0.3820394874,
1.0416802168,
-0.0965269431,
0.1799216419,
-0.3371204138,
0.3022350371,
-1.0494962931,
0.2802010477,
-0.8117691875,
0.2584061325,
-0.0164426528,
-0.1611588597,
-0.5818428993,
-0.0280712713,
0.4075398147,
-0.7306311131,
-0.1552553177,
0.3816428781,
0.8271306753,
0.3885186613,
-0.4134534001,
-0.41177544,
-0.4160639942,
0.953246057,
-1.1465969086,
0.5061355233,
0.5614706874,
-0.0047262646,
-0.0872035399,
-0.8802047372,
-0.717461884,
-0.2724975944,
-0.4752680659,
0.0556689315,
-0.3434459567,
0.1268352717,
0.3668525517,
0.2127477676,
-0.4249921739,
0.1697134078,
0.0900795013,
0.0249731801,
0.3126478493,
0.1790066063,
0.4782419205,
-0.3117207587,
-0.3931521177,
0.1803838909,
-1.0470073223,
-0.2754831016,
0.0071236389,
0.4368579388,
-0.0808671415,
0.5243324041,
-0.1641696692,
0.8562756181,
-0.4585110247,
-0.2837292552,
-0.0944622979,
-0.4181345999,
-0.3035317063,
-0.0402873009,
0.5749844313,
0.2148858756,
0.4789514244,
-0.3209931254,
-0.0088026812,
0.1950133145,
0.0848719999,
-0.6413792968,
-0.3089062274,
0.3332078755,
-0.430888623,
-0.0293699782,
-0.1023684368,
-0.2131820768,
-0.3281226754,
-0.1502513736,
0.6143841743,
-0.3736218214,
-0.3476364017,
0.3019173443,
-0.1254236102,
0.2240098417,
-0.0952292606,
-0.8065931797,
0.4628097713,
0.5484412909,
0.4699727893,
0.1694100797,
-0.3400082886,
-0.1478006542,
0.1655092835,
-0.4656671286,
1.063141346,
-0.5990459323,
-0.186075896,
-0.0735973641,
-0.1855593175,
-0.0947715119,
-0.5195574164,
0.2808519006,
-0.9705089927,
0.1049513668,
-0.3560887575,
-0.986202538,
-0.4657213688,
0.3687850535,
-0.6979210377,
0.7344719768,
0.1694363505,
-0.8072594404,
0.510170579,
-0.6307963133,
-0.2196185142,
0.0292958207,
-0.2873149812,
-0.0675187111,
-0.2215058953,
-0.0190350227,
0.4023305774,
-0.5784831047,
-0.0121870525,
-0.5203872323,
0.0030611821,
0.2551573515,
0.0574549735,
0.7978499532,
0.1862116754,
-0.0623413138,
0.0485801212,
-0.7094060183,
0.200538069,
-0.0365231931,
0.1248813346,
-0.7844700813,
0.2555603385,
-0.1804206073,
0.2100451142,
0.1556529701,
-0.5777233839,
0.3517901003,
-0.6004993916,
0.2976053059,
0.2836452127,
-0.0236434545,
0.3113127947,
-0.0346962921,
0.394834429,
-0.1360057145,
-0.0279613622,
-0.1483307332,
-0.4551062584,
-0.7189650536,
-0.035490036,
0.5254695415,
0.5975433588,
-0.6121136546,
0.5230516195,
-0.1527308375,
-0.1568248868,
-0.2958022952,
0.2605187297,
0.6745129228,
0.4976544976,
0.3130992353,
-0.1598539054,
-0.8804243207,
-0.817707479,
-0.1722880453,
-0.1678182781,
-0.0142593933,
0.134603411,
0.6998515725,
-0.2435486913,
1.4043254852,
-0.8514167666,
-0.6139173508,
-0.3863211572,
-0.0490935855,
0.0454544798,
0.1363939941,
0.5170398355,
-0.9054213762,
-0.1783480048,
-0.0820761994,
-1.0198484659,
-0.3460544646,
0.2650899887,
0.0305650905,
0.1999125928,
0.7253522873,
-0.5259004235,
0.5538517833,
0.5540334582,
-0.5356626511,
0.3172274828,
-0.0935236514,
-0.2305272669,
-1.0539213419,
0.0242099222,
-0.4552140236,
-0.1633915752,
-0.7328405976,
0.1932788938,
-0.0712710395,
0.3496648073,
-0.592135191,
0.6824788451,
-0.4358912706,
-0.5392367244,
-0.6532864571,
0.3532204628,
0.0949677899,
0.3317552507,
0.3055635393,
0.4625942111,
0.4564990401,
-0.737267673,
-0.034813147,
0.3209008873,
-0.4101281166,
0.0009618555,
-0.6136160493,
-0.0043857666,
0.2112791836,
0.1432889104,
-0.8626288772,
-0.0307064373,
-0.0191643406,
-0.4200631976,
-0.2527903616,
-0.1611568481,
-0.4579635561,
0.0859049261,
0.0163820088,
0.1497135907,
0.4128935635,
-0.3596024513,
0.9895650744,
0.8147677779,
0.1310395002,
-0.5916754603,
-0.5416234732,
-0.0781489164,
0.0869099051,
-0.5946192741,
0.2387874275,
0.2444962114,
-0.7598919868,
0.3930328786,
-0.0525353514,
-0.1719142199,
0.2008488774,
0.2459486723,
0.1869303584,
-0.4240861237,
0.316280365,
-0.1330291033,
-0.2332936078,
0.1138307825,
-0.4065276086,
0.781801343,
-0.1997296959,
-0.3736978769,
-0.2062516063,
0.2009516954,
0.1198503152,
-0.0209694579,
0.8465018272,
0.1782429665,
-0.5967437625,
-0.4198417068,
-0.325637579,
-0.3244034946,
-0.4053436518,
0.2903704345,
-0.6361926198,
-0.7609419823,
0.5536065102,
0.0713564754,
0.2885847986,
0.5935202241,
0.5352463126,
0.0138735725,
0.8073990345,
0.7265323997,
0.2689929307,
0.1281791031,
-0.4808659554,
0.1668628901,
-0.4904642999,
0.0354566462,
-0.4260704219,
0.1614323556,
-0.3477425277,
-0.3940905929,
0.113996014,
0.0429385416,
-0.0309056081,
0.3124512732,
0.2127487808,
0.5264467001,
0.4616554081,
-0.2284564674,
0.5866478086,
-0.370747745,
0.1229286715,
0.2519527376,
-0.8963575363,
-0.7496435642,
1.1002022028,
0.0573881269,
0.8122978806,
0.1890165657,
0.227613464,
0.532307148,
0.463386029,
-0.8356747627,
0.6128607988,
-0.5236690044,
-0.9068760276,
-0.3491712213,
-0.4434525371,
-0.9050625563,
0.3937748075,
-0.3541743755,
-0.6780272722,
0.0580196269,
0.3082170486,
-0.5799911618,
0.3646769226,
-0.7886427045,
0.8987345099,
0.0476910397,
0.1188240573,
-0.1031862423,
-0.539842844,
0.5751668811,
-0.2336913347,
0.2384117544,
-0.3343580365,
-0.0992464796,
0.893165648,
-0.5509366989,
1.0158799887,
-0.0190170426,
-0.4889582694,
0.4745948315,
-0.0888679102,
0.1423102021,
-0.0923603699,
-0.0805281326,
0.2859828472,
0.312063098,
-0.3827397525,
-0.8049244285,
0.3971301913,
-0.5945186019,
-0.4752232134,
-0.1501209736,
-0.7095728517,
-0.4745445549,
0.4026051164,
0.2609612942,
0.3108870387,
-0.0073361122,
0.1751314104,
0.7182433605,
0.0422845148,
0.2077351063,
0.9123744369,
-0.5721590519,
0.1627652794,
0.7006136775,
0.4147006571,
0.462923646,
0.665104866,
0.4833081663,
-0.3257401288,
-0.418328017,
-0.260217309,
-0.0767512769,
-0.768143177,
0.0284727365,
-0.8805997968,
-0.1264079064,
-0.8359801769,
0.1580187529,
-0.5074409246,
-0.4765656888,
0.0472321846,
-0.0088070976,
0.4265594184,
0.7573879957,
0.1701202542,
0.558833003,
-0.9930149913,
0.4306909144,
0.3538863957,
0.0367244333,
-0.0267149173,
-0.6358865499,
-0.1235488057,
-0.1476715803,
0.147750929,
-0.625756681,
0.2521776557,
0.1831910312,
0.5994662046,
0.7372099161,
0.3952524066,
0.5312988162,
-0.3668825626,
0.5005828142,
-0.1500983387,
-0.9997814894,
0.386167556,
-0.1705603451,
-0.0017858749,
0.2769716978,
0.5050384402,
-0.2394100875,
-0.1630941182,
-0.6112231612,
-0.6209846139,
0.7594644427,
0.2029410601,
-0.0538251288,
0.3724167943,
0.336034447,
0.1786581278,
0.0614421442,
-0.6653269529,
-0.3402815461,
0.1720333993,
-0.2097870559,
0.0388186239,
-0.253668189,
-0.1285139769,
0.2292770445,
0.6244360805,
-0.175338462,
-0.0763968602,
-0.1427862048,
-0.2592453361,
0.351247102,
0.264331609,
0.3352446258,
0.8175189495,
-0.4033087194,
0.3800045252,
0.4900759161,
-0.4947468936,
-0.0610466711,
-0.1628990918,
-0.2748666406,
-0.2850275636,
0.8418556452,
0.7700990438,
0.1690628231,
-1.016674757,
0.1990000904,
0.0297956392,
0.0166945849,
-0.4601232708,
0.2145467699,
0.2472117096,
0.0208538342,
0.1711089611,
-0.4080872834,
0.1612852365,
-0.6827854514,
0.3852927387,
0.3323224187,
-0.437190026,
-0.3135383129,
0.1703113168,
-0.1098259911,
-0.1061997116,
0.4014228284,
-0.0937584192,
-0.4777884483,
0.5471855998,
0.5216702819,
0.5685780048,
-0.0232730564,
-0.26291731,
-0.1478410363,
0.4956519604,
0.1341349185,
0.57451123,
0.076538533,
-1.3389879465,
-0.4222480357,
-0.6379876137,
-0.7267643809,
0.1173650101,
-0.6189149618,
0.090890348,
-0.3421593606,
-0.1510341316,
0.2093303949,
-0.0580217168,
-0.2204232961,
0.5002801418,
-0.0836610943,
0.8646185398,
-0.9783651233,
1.0025830269,
0.7064422965,
-0.5210728049,
-0.8971310854,
-0.0380123556,
-0.1765675992,
-0.8131673932,
1.0315834284,
-0.0577720106,
-0.5674039721,
0.0892491341,
-0.4348502457,
-1.0104436874,
0.7206591964,
0.3089812994,
-0.121032238,
-0.187238723,
0.2738606632,
0.427600652,
-0.5429637432,
0.3217708766,
0.8285501003,
0.4691102207,
-0.067078419,
-0.6422650218,
-0.0210326407,
-0.1054537296,
-0.1820759028,
0.0912059993,
-0.476680249,
1.1338526011,
-0.1658040881,
-0.1498435736,
-0.0359367393,
0.8546981215,
0.316798836,
0.3376106024,
0.7655642033,
0.7957257032,
0.3729489446,
0.0626542121,
0.9804136157,
-0.4098836184,
0.4735700488,
1.3827679157,
-0.6143869758,
1.0275532007,
0.4932580888,
-0.4051403105,
0.5941471457,
0.3805620372,
0.3325899541,
0.2611128688,
0.1478847861,
0.0680249557,
-0.6008723378,
-0.2816604376,
-0.3697572947,
0.8752230406,
0.7257486582,
-0.1690839529,
-0.308591634,
-0.0074539823,
0.0157185011,
-0.1208837405,
-0.0819285661,
0.7868775129,
0.3424766064,
-0.5214278102,
0.4220294654,
0.0344444774,
0.4252405763,
-0.8686206937,
-0.1587257683,
-0.1387338042,
0.4428732097,
-0.3187072873,
-0.5956724882,
0.388859868,
-0.1107309833,
-0.244478479,
-0.0411167555,
0.7882359028,
-0.1604189426,
-0.3843665123,
0.6255407333,
0.5023379326,
0.27222386,
-0.0296147335,
-0.3585959375,
-0.1032968909,
-0.2414104193,
-0.4616492391,
0.2421729565,
0.2319023609,
-0.2147974521,
0.7214282155,
0.6863198876,
-0.0319048949,
0.1050551757,
0.2204921842,
0.6444510221,
-0.6947948337,
-0.4379811585,
-0.725019455,
0.0202454142,
0.0888826028,
-0.3852448761,
1.0988173485,
0.3493192196,
0.8247727752,
-0.0821653903,
0.7535796762,
-0.1145399213,
0.6288148761,
-1.0621994734,
0.9378502369,
-0.6540563107,
0.4110925496,
-0.1825667322,
-0.5887451768,
-0.4032664597,
0.5452284217,
-0.4506079853,
-0.0652175695,
0.5873180628,
0.9050138593,
0.0171840061,
0.2156130373,
0.6244596839,
0.2964738011,
0.0831495896,
0.333830148,
0.9689477086,
-0.4347260296,
0.3469615281,
-0.0943656042,
-0.1706957966,
-0.2386608869,
-0.7813715339,
-0.9063920379,
-0.3418409824,
-0.0330663286,
-0.2001996338,
-0.1499417424,
0.8218861818,
0.8407014608,
-1.0332841873,
-0.3807828426,
-0.022551626,
0.2210904807,
-0.0331462212,
-0.1453248411,
0.5881916285,
-0.4099780321,
-0.6282938123,
0.472681731,
0.075800091,
-0.2958097458,
-0.4599320292,
0.009531768,
-0.6017856002,
0.4236506224,
0.7955594063,
0.2732010484,
-0.8118218184,
-0.1238784268,
0.1839394718,
-0.012955199,
-0.2799064815,
0.8334826827,
-0.6926971674,
0.1708287746,
0.686206758,
0.5271222591,
0.0362073928,
-0.1367785633,
0.4444378316,
-0.5212654471,
0.1831607968,
0.0924068764,
0.6420760751,
-0.1186273918,
0.0293442141,
0.5615304112,
0.3289206624,
-0.0795258731,
-0.8412769437,
0.4235516191,
-0.7983180285,
-0.6102596521,
1.1672847271,
-0.5162246227,
-0.3897109926,
-0.5918930769,
-0.0129361777,
0.0901954696,
0.0845756009,
0.467397958,
0.4953837395,
-0.3836481869,
0.1059840769,
-0.3996339142,
0.359156996,
0.6746715903,
-1.1356680393,
0.0790531188,
0.2751526833,
0.3439432979,
0.5652478337,
0.807164371,
0.0991416052,
0.106999889,
0.3975232542,
0.427271992,
0.0271027554,
-0.4103933871,
0.1763064861,
0.4644489288,
-0.0472603776,
-0.0253177956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06729v1 | STREET: A Multi-Task Structured Reasoning and Explanation Benchmark | 2023-02-13T22:34:02 | 2023-02-13T22:34:02 | Danilo Ribeiro, Shen Wang, Xiaofei Ma, Henry Zhu, Rui Dong, Deguang Kong, Juliette Burger, Anjelica Ramos, William Wang, Zhiheng Huang, George Karypis, Bing Xiang, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.6 | We introduce STREET, a unified multi-task and multi-domain natural language
reasoning and explanation benchmark. Unlike most existing question-answering
(QA) datasets, we expect models to not only answer questions, but also produce
step-by-step structured explanations describing how premises in the question
are used to produce intermediate conclusions that can prove the correctness of
a certain answer. We perform extensive evaluation with popular language models
such as few-shot prompting GPT-3 and fine-tuned T5. We find that these models
still lag behind human performance when producing such structured reasoning
steps. We believe this work will provide a way for the community to better
train and test systems on multi-step reasoning and explanations in natural
language. | [
-0.235143736,
-1.2083824873,
0.8260923028,
0.3328612447,
-0.057914231,
0.0479889661,
0.056789469,
-0.5726816654,
-0.3363488615,
0.3302954137,
-0.8037273884,
-0.5485182405,
-0.3917917311,
0.1870533526,
-0.4097375274,
0.5863205791,
-0.1606938243,
0.122882165,
-0.2502866983,
-0.1747742146,
-0.6561821103,
-0.3934644461,
-0.6245927215,
-0.3111243546,
0.5305961967,
0.4254021645,
0.7005439997,
0.8430235982,
0.4239866436,
0.2532893419,
0.3459990919,
0.1653829664,
-0.0571785495,
0.1372754872,
-0.2034798861,
0.1383820176,
-0.5384186506,
-0.0058273566,
0.5659442544,
1.0957379341,
-0.0817087889,
0.0560500957,
-0.206637755,
0.5501515865,
-0.6700697541,
-0.2299164832,
-0.4768997729,
-0.430877775,
-0.2404259592,
-0.053220883,
-0.2682195902,
-0.4559962749,
0.0065237172,
-0.7307476997,
0.3546330929,
-0.0940706655,
0.8552616835,
0.2824728191,
-0.7069864273,
0.0193832461,
-0.6402462721,
0.5029935837,
-0.4909083843,
0.3460832834,
0.2124029249,
0.7180530429,
-0.2816075087,
-0.7071764469,
-0.5494741201,
0.0243940391,
-0.0018525168,
0.0642244443,
0.2686236799,
0.1638170183,
0.2486733496,
0.0497966483,
-0.8543976545,
-0.3074949086,
-0.2462778389,
0.0861554146,
0.8342326283,
0.3401626348,
-0.0035175707,
-0.265013814,
-0.6780496836,
-0.0268122405,
-0.8283496499,
0.4284783006,
0.1079877988,
0.405708164,
0.099897936,
0.2402540296,
-0.4902243614,
0.9673755765,
-0.1900666207,
0.0273028444,
0.133583203,
-0.6318843365,
-0.5326420069,
-0.199795261,
0.9012531638,
0.3271488845,
0.2233835012,
-0.1565335393,
-0.144727543,
0.0654360503,
0.2788718939,
-0.785761714,
-0.3840582371,
0.3967410624,
-0.2538829744,
0.0593231693,
-0.1114970967,
-0.611481905,
-0.3618268967,
-0.3933127522,
0.3993734419,
-0.4808572829,
-0.2326849699,
0.2966017425,
-0.3218408227,
0.2329939455,
0.4429678917,
-0.9157267213,
0.727923274,
0.7103902102,
0.5470556617,
-0.0388383605,
-0.5098404884,
-0.7213709354,
0.0566139556,
-0.4222188294,
1.2704094648,
-0.5762901306,
-0.0604941249,
-0.1912838072,
0.0513144284,
-0.5048758984,
-0.4530204237,
0.6513640285,
-0.1626169384,
0.0127818454,
-0.478001684,
-0.3504508436,
-0.3136599958,
0.3956994712,
-0.3514507711,
1.5525867939,
0.0702251643,
-0.4846814871,
0.4416944385,
-0.9245301485,
-0.6955355406,
0.1477916539,
0.0280617401,
-0.0648846775,
-0.0484344922,
0.3521298766,
0.4318113625,
-0.4184134901,
0.6265491247,
-0.2536882162,
-0.515959084,
-0.0244983025,
-0.2596890628,
0.7861584425,
-0.013546044,
-0.4027911723,
0.2520377934,
-1.0729099512,
0.1570910662,
0.2669591904,
-0.2606540024,
-0.3782209754,
0.2031237632,
-0.027124688,
0.3819813132,
0.1042230278,
-0.5512835979,
0.0163656566,
-0.2591980994,
0.4848802388,
0.5825728178,
-0.0610662587,
0.1481547952,
-0.2914723456,
0.5576168895,
0.0859853923,
0.0874240026,
-0.2779738605,
-0.7734310627,
-0.1950293928,
-0.0933047086,
0.1623811722,
0.6039973497,
-0.4638452828,
-0.1595343351,
-0.2360494882,
-0.3574568033,
-0.6601138711,
-0.0196843743,
0.489634037,
0.6045086384,
0.4689363241,
-0.1670279652,
-0.637194097,
-0.9693270326,
-0.5940749049,
-0.0236277357,
-0.1498747915,
0.2305062413,
0.5857489705,
0.0909711942,
0.8958928585,
-0.3596655726,
0.2295837402,
-0.2452751994,
0.5283354521,
0.1536563635,
0.1614018232,
0.2768189311,
-0.8795546293,
-0.3249509633,
-0.5637798309,
-0.4282356203,
-0.2399403155,
-0.0536026582,
-0.147443369,
-0.1484501362,
0.1965883374,
-0.6655647755,
0.4002363384,
0.4558756053,
-0.430659622,
0.8669519424,
-0.1956992149,
0.2714273334,
-0.943158865,
-0.0906667784,
0.1225171611,
-0.3553211689,
-0.8184301257,
0.1200694218,
0.0607300289,
-0.0230794121,
-0.2251879424,
0.3593967557,
-0.3476949036,
-0.430852592,
-0.125743404,
0.6613956094,
0.4400698543,
0.5662173033,
0.2262723446,
0.8439951539,
0.5776429772,
-0.6742714047,
0.3422499001,
0.1604558676,
-0.3017246127,
0.623564899,
-0.8944389224,
0.4231775999,
-0.2139331102,
0.2447602153,
-1.4368650913,
-0.3107337654,
-0.0239677317,
-0.2565480471,
-0.3866225183,
-0.1974233687,
-0.5771281123,
-0.695204556,
-0.1487018168,
0.2608088553,
-0.103782244,
-0.4073982835,
0.4222353697,
0.1608162671,
0.0793151185,
-0.2436505109,
-0.4265583158,
0.0386343673,
-0.0177815352,
-0.9580023885,
0.4001321495,
-0.4710181355,
-0.4700710475,
-0.1364111006,
-0.0686699897,
-0.59570086,
0.5303966403,
0.3324139416,
0.1491339207,
-0.5977663398,
0.3412461877,
-0.2132097781,
-0.029717287,
0.2151338756,
-0.0421262458,
0.1668791026,
-0.1530175954,
-0.3209867775,
-0.2066108137,
0.5409104228,
0.4936668873,
-0.1947335154,
0.5029351115,
0.3251959682,
-0.4209884107,
-0.0529098921,
-0.1200884953,
-0.036631614,
-0.3766623139,
-0.0241728555,
-1.0898090601,
-0.6059975624,
0.2555271089,
-0.0969915539,
0.1837998927,
0.6268797517,
0.4139437973,
0.0494262762,
1.4170095921,
0.2733813226,
0.4101287425,
-0.0627991483,
0.1657970101,
0.3999226689,
-0.624296546,
-0.2105003297,
-0.7308133245,
-0.2191715986,
-0.3566619754,
-0.4049492478,
0.1454962939,
0.3978966177,
-0.3291793168,
0.6031402946,
-0.6869378686,
0.459159255,
0.7636957765,
-0.2690799832,
0.3708423674,
-0.7217986584,
-0.256929934,
0.2534922957,
-0.566528976,
-0.549772501,
0.8640043139,
0.1730074435,
0.1979075521,
0.0258211829,
0.5620478392,
-0.021276366,
0.2348287106,
-0.520503521,
0.5458987951,
-0.1544864327,
-0.8307970762,
-0.4265539646,
-0.193074137,
-0.8444283009,
0.563090384,
0.0427254289,
-0.6914017797,
-0.0882672593,
0.0278019328,
-0.7950331569,
0.0553836487,
-0.863396585,
1.3798499107,
-0.1881497502,
-0.2856299877,
-0.0818762332,
-0.672283411,
0.5254750252,
0.3086755574,
0.6324449778,
-0.5474380255,
0.3850130141,
0.6384018064,
-0.4838030338,
0.5378504992,
-0.4385834336,
0.1370436549,
0.2143871039,
-0.0624101013,
0.4598858654,
-0.1506180018,
-0.0825348571,
-0.0785944313,
0.2126547247,
-0.5429096222,
-0.5717335343,
0.4472318292,
-0.4087107778,
-0.5910652876,
-0.0571496598,
-0.6473999619,
-0.4613644779,
0.0066812811,
-0.0625281632,
0.7859184146,
-0.2453148216,
-0.0638512075,
0.3404141366,
0.2348476946,
0.4652613997,
0.5717392564,
0.0683468282,
-0.179568097,
0.3989601433,
-0.2845723331,
0.1805731356,
0.4567003846,
0.3959732652,
-0.4715276659,
-0.7700420022,
-0.8667484522,
-0.0726422071,
-0.5955049396,
0.041837845,
-0.6641480327,
-0.0469869673,
-0.6709993482,
-0.0492309742,
-0.2610132992,
-0.5855650902,
0.2442597747,
-0.1832830012,
0.2428127378,
1.2290393114,
0.0061028553,
0.1285908669,
-0.7021643519,
0.9242920876,
0.5625210404,
0.3959598243,
-0.2490898967,
-0.2242202312,
-0.1059032828,
0.2632437348,
-0.4339675307,
-0.9248262048,
0.0291906018,
0.1568024307,
0.4951943755,
0.3517530859,
0.0385018513,
1.0646628141,
-0.7344156504,
0.9550095201,
0.0027983277,
-0.8972634077,
0.7279368043,
-0.4855814874,
0.5315898061,
0.6807397604,
0.1697205901,
-0.5482845306,
-0.438895911,
-0.5664080381,
-0.7883128524,
0.5917888284,
-0.0025095816,
-0.3674443662,
-0.2302302271,
-0.0034658031,
0.2102404237,
0.1309942007,
-0.5473353863,
-0.2108257264,
-0.3798079789,
-0.0978109986,
0.0175913852,
-0.1553662866,
-0.1122093871,
-0.2863772213,
0.5595325232,
-0.3966298103,
0.0644073114,
0.3200939,
-0.1565024257,
-0.1997802556,
0.5947129726,
0.8551804423,
1.115162611,
-0.3465327621,
0.447997123,
-0.0438592955,
-0.1768708825,
0.0476410501,
0.4405196607,
0.0038957098,
0.069442831,
0.369174093,
0.7896249294,
0.5340133905,
-0.7118576169,
0.5525308847,
0.0248584189,
-0.5572314262,
-0.0493029393,
-0.1095650345,
0.1431242675,
0.1470441222,
0.5754628778,
-0.0171805397,
0.2858831882,
-0.6581924558,
0.2579111457,
0.2699311972,
-0.3086349368,
-0.5081358552,
0.9765998721,
0.203194201,
-0.4890115261,
0.2687262893,
-0.3718836904,
-0.6508057714,
0.5560491085,
0.3528370857,
0.8999618888,
-0.1591702104,
0.4863406718,
0.4366366267,
0.1864921302,
-0.0460834838,
0.4121280909,
-0.2995654941,
-0.8134176135,
-0.6329261661,
-0.431322813,
-0.6488413215,
0.2478828728,
-0.5000121593,
-0.2521908581,
-0.3157002628,
0.2124463618,
0.5009097457,
0.2047212571,
-0.5485875607,
0.3921698034,
0.0021962111,
1.2057269812,
-0.9580227733,
0.9379521608,
0.76926893,
-0.3741936386,
-1.0761777163,
0.0035372716,
0.0123878215,
-0.649662137,
0.7532309294,
0.4442858696,
-0.3527094126,
-0.2250553668,
-0.5882594585,
-0.5460727215,
0.9449511766,
0.0449458845,
-0.3345088363,
0.0600665435,
0.1904558092,
0.5624017119,
-0.5628455281,
0.3103960752,
0.8353998661,
0.673461616,
0.308835268,
-0.8490723968,
0.2040888369,
-0.1956901252,
-0.1265076995,
0.1435045153,
-0.2148132622,
0.9225270748,
-0.2891118228,
-0.1885556579,
0.0533069484,
0.2359085083,
0.5047317147,
0.647482276,
0.6341848969,
0.5670897961,
0.8572538495,
-0.3171387911,
1.2185524702,
-0.1814210415,
-0.0766859278,
1.3331475258,
-0.5893082619,
1.0021077394,
0.3862100244,
-0.32377249,
1.0057257414,
0.9724636674,
0.4337888956,
0.5802766681,
0.2571808994,
0.0473722629,
-0.7043899894,
0.0247893892,
0.0467417315,
0.529756844,
-0.0375871845,
0.2070351094,
-0.4676471651,
-0.2319725901,
-0.3011750281,
0.1665627956,
-0.1611831039,
0.6303100586,
-0.0310377907,
-1.065264225,
0.7709950209,
0.0970812887,
0.0461831726,
-0.3723992109,
-0.0938261151,
-0.0764229745,
0.1317710131,
0.1252862066,
-0.8344982862,
0.4059151411,
-0.1830853075,
-0.2905563116,
-0.6609081626,
0.7102716565,
-0.4784950316,
-0.1596526206,
0.421084404,
0.462125808,
0.2966730297,
-0.5071619749,
-0.9194603562,
-0.3245454133,
-0.514906764,
-0.2842906713,
0.003472737,
0.7718251944,
-0.1161612272,
0.5702190995,
0.7143942118,
-0.1345089823,
0.1997227818,
0.5730354786,
0.6240751147,
-0.834338963,
-0.3897691369,
-0.7535612583,
0.7390429974,
-0.2073809654,
-0.4297260344,
0.6460343599,
0.7738227844,
0.4373615384,
0.2085940093,
0.6094655395,
0.0429597124,
0.9426711202,
-0.4384635091,
0.0835098699,
-0.5467245579,
0.08938317,
-0.126028657,
-0.5386506915,
-0.0949426293,
0.3752021492,
-0.2165025175,
-0.1181645095,
1.1499068737,
0.6054164171,
-0.0517179221,
0.4276064634,
0.4575082362,
0.1237449646,
-0.0586075969,
0.9229693413,
0.7834663987,
-0.7213194966,
0.5793731213,
-0.099343501,
0.0016730973,
-0.0751776323,
-0.9288781285,
-0.8378612995,
-0.624473691,
-0.3924094141,
-0.0223247353,
0.3074491918,
0.5732967257,
1.066119194,
-1.0156129599,
-0.2602818608,
-0.3901326358,
0.54951334,
-0.8009011745,
-0.2460181862,
0.2424047291,
-0.2866462171,
-0.429510653,
1.0066156387,
0.4826008081,
-0.2325199544,
-0.1347596049,
-0.0099120708,
-0.5716971159,
0.1384772807,
0.5826720595,
0.0133935427,
-0.6905069947,
-0.5738332272,
0.1174322292,
-0.0979296938,
0.5322731137,
1.2038942575,
-0.9227725267,
0.2828345001,
0.5271801949,
0.4213204086,
0.3677616417,
0.4130799472,
0.8115234375,
-0.889816761,
-0.2835725546,
-0.0740246922,
0.2881597579,
0.4947786033,
-0.1142842323,
0.5275112391,
0.4496172667,
-0.4568386972,
-0.5082398653,
0.2263591737,
-0.7924026847,
-0.4653051794,
1.060718894,
-0.163693592,
-0.2917029858,
-0.7464209199,
0.211129263,
0.0774569362,
-0.3572586179,
0.5159028769,
0.7738143802,
-0.2143160999,
-0.3914158642,
-0.889406085,
0.584136188,
0.1138198823,
-1.2131937742,
0.4668877721,
0.5991248488,
0.3192914724,
0.0220702402,
1.1103470325,
0.2651713192,
0.5096756816,
-0.0071525942,
-0.2088212967,
-0.0424274914,
-0.6096605659,
-0.2166366577,
0.445143342,
-0.131091103,
-0.5698335767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06716v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06716v3 | Machine Learning Model Attribution Challenge | 2023-02-13T22:05:27 | 2023-02-17T15:48:46 | Elizabeth Merkhofer, Deepesh Chaudhari, Hyrum S. Anderson, Keith Manville, Lily Wong, João Gante | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | We present the findings of the Machine Learning Model Attribution Challenge.
Fine-tuned machine learning models may derive from other trained models without
obvious attribution characteristics. In this challenge, participants identify
the publicly-available base models that underlie a set of anonymous, fine-tuned
large language models (LLMs) using only textual output of the models.
Contestants aim to correctly attribute the most fine-tuned models, with ties
broken in the favor of contestants whose solutions use fewer calls to the
fine-tuned models' API. The most successful approaches were manual, as
participants observed similarities between model outputs and developed
attribution heuristics based on public documentation of the base models, though
several teams also submitted automated, statistical solutions. | [
-0.0204612706,
-0.396165818,
0.8155634999,
-0.0469080508,
-0.0552704446,
0.0097020678,
-0.2331694365,
-0.561416924,
-0.2321763188,
0.9451693296,
-0.9612234235,
-0.3810141981,
-0.7084192038,
0.2466753274,
-0.518645823,
0.9778761864,
-0.197969541,
-0.1536245793,
-0.529874742,
-0.0783663839,
-0.3735944033,
-0.7519652843,
-0.3449579179,
-0.6542263031,
0.8611590266,
0.7403074503,
0.3185599744,
1.0197407007,
0.6627800465,
0.319407016,
0.1663538516,
0.2853011489,
-0.4918785393,
-0.2016901821,
-0.2924588621,
-0.8210037351,
-0.2035700828,
0.2887417674,
0.5210312009,
0.7937858105,
0.0649483949,
0.7725502849,
0.1910400391,
0.7553809285,
-0.9104944468,
0.4357689619,
-0.9899184108,
-0.1637968868,
-0.1452685595,
-0.248233825,
-0.7026429176,
-0.4239093363,
-0.2312955856,
-0.4288604259,
0.4132551551,
0.0365816206,
0.9946047068,
0.6529250145,
-0.5706373453,
-0.4453794658,
-0.7417912483,
0.9927815199,
-0.5368493199,
-0.1332971901,
0.542432189,
0.3231669664,
0.0582902879,
-0.4096965492,
-0.0802600533,
-0.3322558701,
0.012168034,
-0.2211410105,
-0.2428531945,
-0.3096643984,
0.1681736857,
0.0429236554,
-0.3028877676,
0.7259975076,
-0.4425375462,
-0.0821617842,
0.8979546428,
0.3378567398,
-0.3412765861,
-0.1459632963,
-0.196282059,
0.1375108659,
-0.8218582869,
-0.0839343742,
0.5964079499,
0.6068251133,
-0.1136476398,
1.0217916965,
-0.1407913864,
0.3759460151,
-0.0008786682,
0.2250388265,
0.1639621705,
-0.0646030307,
-0.102583997,
0.1682963073,
0.6890867949,
0.2123842835,
0.5949596167,
-0.149980709,
-0.5175884962,
-0.0412331782,
0.125240773,
-0.5363863111,
-0.3182224929,
-0.0525466762,
-0.6335330606,
-0.8351233602,
-0.163293153,
-0.1437921673,
-0.7325441241,
-0.4582132101,
0.6075172424,
0.0014919293,
-0.0824243948,
-0.318277359,
-0.3215049803,
0.1831148267,
0.4009511173,
-0.8492010832,
0.3386825621,
0.8522953987,
0.7575492263,
-0.2444164008,
-0.0014164129,
-0.4740595818,
0.2336264402,
-0.300835371,
0.5532478094,
-0.4886692166,
-0.1361198723,
-0.3151936531,
0.2093742937,
0.0169206075,
-0.8171355724,
0.4913398027,
-0.367116183,
0.1837126911,
-0.3483783603,
-0.9945885539,
-0.1621179581,
0.1306312829,
-0.6479205489,
0.4715986252,
0.1526143253,
-0.5348604918,
0.3023183644,
-0.829020977,
-0.0509632453,
0.0878173336,
-0.2117690742,
-0.6816154718,
0.3930581212,
0.0769330636,
0.6964864731,
-0.2395923585,
0.2328871191,
-0.5436899662,
-0.1727754176,
0.5071670413,
-0.5599241257,
1.1231970787,
0.242620185,
-0.3120570183,
0.3391894996,
-1.1441162825,
-0.0054438328,
0.5071032047,
-0.3348930478,
-0.2047154605,
0.042093318,
0.0120236548,
-0.1121931523,
0.1931765079,
-0.4027715325,
0.1963638663,
0.0345130228,
0.4674756527,
1.1167327166,
-0.1545699239,
0.3598009348,
-0.4175174534,
0.4665421844,
-0.2181472331,
-0.1907009184,
0.095945701,
-0.5339972377,
-0.5944244266,
-0.5418679118,
0.3809463978,
0.6980386972,
-0.1713716835,
0.340913713,
-0.0620072894,
-0.8244860172,
-0.6643576026,
0.2803161144,
0.5480504036,
0.5734426975,
0.0313371718,
0.0114908004,
-0.579936564,
-1.154315114,
-0.605579257,
-0.0484149344,
-0.3338617682,
0.6723019481,
0.9204810262,
-0.0145265954,
0.6765349507,
-0.5831363797,
-0.343447566,
-0.091518715,
0.4787240028,
0.0176061187,
0.6472727656,
0.3797908127,
-0.4994030595,
-0.45462659,
-0.0271988884,
-0.8227173686,
-0.2100647837,
0.1321638972,
0.448063612,
0.1864817441,
0.6747950912,
-0.337025255,
0.1562047899,
0.4985767901,
-0.1911717504,
0.8341449499,
-0.0639466122,
-0.090832755,
-0.865288794,
0.1891938299,
-0.0845599249,
-0.4229946733,
-0.1525771916,
-0.0259721,
0.1641622484,
-0.2968955934,
-0.3883465827,
0.4792457521,
-0.3986771107,
-0.0654236004,
-0.0036697767,
-0.2947832942,
-0.1474486291,
0.5211130977,
-0.0688105151,
0.3826013207,
0.4059858024,
-0.4818222225,
0.8497386575,
0.0242169332,
-0.4846903682,
0.2478608042,
-0.7193555236,
0.3134607077,
-0.1460129619,
0.0600646213,
-0.9667426348,
-0.6507408619,
0.1891192794,
-0.6795387864,
0.1645559371,
-0.3466283083,
-0.3043648005,
-0.2005525827,
-0.0652559027,
0.3459234536,
0.4657158852,
-0.2761914134,
0.3860259354,
0.0381420217,
-0.0642621443,
-0.309958607,
-0.8341588378,
-0.0192028638,
-0.6050216556,
-0.3825166821,
0.2693342566,
0.1846050322,
-0.2765342593,
0.0709215179,
0.2279744744,
-0.3118208349,
0.5332214236,
0.3488197327,
0.0748402104,
-0.5180388093,
-0.0858610943,
-0.3778727353,
-0.1406424195,
0.4367466867,
0.0618283041,
0.1532302648,
-0.1060333773,
-0.6329740286,
-0.7705519795,
0.4358203709,
0.3748323917,
-0.0332611799,
0.8129237294,
0.3255913258,
-0.6490623355,
-0.0763270035,
-0.3852834404,
-0.3105385602,
-0.4990588129,
0.5221674442,
-0.3023797572,
-0.8471599817,
0.8415212631,
-0.0971411318,
0.0325337015,
0.6300571561,
0.858974576,
-0.1425928026,
1.3679039478,
0.9350740314,
-0.0558176823,
0.3538404107,
0.0683599859,
-0.2423334569,
-0.2965753078,
-0.3947257698,
-1.0801477432,
-0.4009889662,
-0.696906507,
0.0700205266,
0.0336160846,
-0.0250763167,
-0.5316520929,
0.2463440597,
-0.4470230341,
0.6206136346,
0.8887575269,
0.2947066426,
0.3751730323,
-0.0652898178,
0.2473551035,
-0.0561316423,
-0.4643657804,
-0.5659636855,
1.3602489233,
0.5209562778,
0.7388729453,
0.1233194694,
0.8751682639,
0.3993454576,
0.3758273125,
-0.813773334,
0.3557045758,
-0.1854946166,
-0.7751418948,
-0.1710254848,
-0.8750277758,
-0.7932695746,
-0.5110741854,
-0.1681821048,
-1.0346369743,
-0.0659351498,
0.2702050805,
-0.2919977307,
0.1351913959,
-0.8109768629,
1.0330747366,
-0.1522388756,
-0.0816528127,
0.1076886877,
-0.6822373867,
0.5358040929,
-0.2895947099,
0.053281676,
-0.1530666947,
0.0652618855,
1.0143321753,
-0.4795231819,
0.9648172855,
-0.1522399336,
-0.2051975727,
0.2367971689,
-0.0077266213,
0.7676843405,
-0.2498495281,
-0.0930527076,
-0.0746789947,
-0.2310784161,
-0.419698149,
-0.3673161864,
0.4755097926,
-0.919133544,
-0.4027695954,
0.013827635,
-0.3542461097,
-0.2339444458,
0.437209785,
0.5371066928,
0.1921512485,
-0.0528865755,
0.432730794,
0.6185695529,
-0.0349272192,
0.0937859342,
0.5399786234,
-0.0445968136,
0.0200813562,
1.0994285345,
-0.0796838477,
0.3124515116,
0.1490747035,
0.4401547909,
-0.2354456484,
-0.549223423,
-0.2713110447,
0.2491589189,
-0.8675830364,
-0.2337381095,
-0.3355309367,
-0.3210126758,
-0.4095826447,
-0.1842913926,
-0.8283315301,
-0.449619174,
-0.6977470517,
0.0694880113,
0.2821591496,
0.9406476021,
0.0570130572,
0.3641250134,
-0.8346592784,
0.1982419491,
0.2038628161,
0.1702935547,
-0.3218308091,
-0.6537511349,
-0.158894673,
0.0432795137,
-0.3626134992,
-0.6831387877,
0.1558267474,
0.2667662799,
0.4613256752,
0.4258513749,
0.0503409058,
0.5175994039,
-0.3069210052,
0.6741622686,
0.2462932765,
-0.7673481107,
0.6287536621,
-0.3794380724,
-0.1018992886,
0.3895823359,
0.5170686841,
0.1017763764,
-0.5694940686,
-0.5948848128,
-0.5365329385,
0.5490784645,
0.2274627686,
0.1072947234,
0.2839024365,
0.5424337387,
0.1818644404,
0.1841336936,
-0.810765624,
-0.254196316,
0.1786369979,
-0.4672324657,
-0.1493692696,
-0.042821113,
-0.2430644929,
-0.1936462224,
0.5373947024,
-0.1111508235,
0.1430509388,
-0.2365941405,
-0.1479889154,
-0.4418119192,
0.0077356943,
0.6807602048,
0.5916532874,
-0.3116270602,
0.0762334913,
-0.1118773669,
-0.0746009797,
0.1123255119,
0.0182007067,
-0.2266824991,
-0.0275385175,
0.6619613767,
0.7983002067,
-0.023789838,
-0.6187508702,
0.5210450888,
0.0360907093,
-0.65877074,
-0.3515129685,
0.1752162427,
0.2577696741,
0.5294857025,
0.4303301275,
0.3080890477,
0.0570076853,
-0.4368989766,
0.1802256554,
0.6093898416,
-0.5647608042,
-0.1379870474,
0.8473038673,
0.0687734783,
-0.3291601539,
0.6485357881,
-0.0115707144,
-0.6202679276,
0.8342000246,
0.5204944015,
0.7917435765,
-0.0477018058,
-0.0829649717,
0.0602891631,
0.2478439212,
-0.1614611,
-0.0244432036,
0.2729688883,
-0.5695585012,
-0.3609541953,
-0.3104881644,
-0.5567808747,
0.3756067157,
-0.7282834649,
0.6237652302,
-0.4207113981,
-0.01292085,
0.3247576654,
0.0619369,
-0.6900525689,
-0.0558237955,
0.4412928224,
0.6276166439,
-1.0835078955,
0.5564795136,
0.5558441877,
-0.2455756366,
-0.9155067205,
-0.5442198515,
0.2419742346,
-1.008711338,
0.8725966215,
0.2839470506,
-0.0872054473,
0.1955870688,
-1.1831665039,
-0.5997177362,
0.8129184842,
0.8979935646,
-0.3615677357,
-0.2209895253,
0.2556910813,
-0.0138336644,
-0.4581860006,
-0.0784099698,
0.2096906304,
0.4060530961,
0.0062625986,
-1.1312295198,
0.0175442118,
0.0675588474,
-0.3673261404,
-0.1845073551,
-0.3106849492,
0.938770473,
-0.3818975687,
-0.1010127068,
0.1223492697,
0.7756912708,
0.3305671811,
0.4058884978,
0.4185452163,
0.3629465401,
0.9500743151,
0.1429295391,
0.7423338294,
0.348466903,
0.5575249791,
1.3748666048,
-0.1460184008,
0.6660202146,
0.4887325466,
-0.0890809223,
0.3394634128,
0.7571324706,
-0.3747185171,
0.6449840665,
0.5225194693,
0.0152416201,
-0.3445762992,
-0.2586336136,
-0.2029365748,
0.8324571252,
0.1077451035,
-0.6893323064,
-0.1971006989,
-0.0573467314,
0.023631053,
0.1437093168,
-0.5508924127,
0.9469991326,
0.0687341392,
-0.4543684423,
0.7225826979,
0.2623196244,
0.6208157539,
-0.5405081511,
-0.0169888549,
0.1481502503,
0.5807795525,
-0.4587621987,
-0.4128488898,
0.5113481283,
0.2939023674,
-0.4618654549,
-0.2983337343,
0.7924129963,
-0.2973800898,
-0.7775803208,
-0.1675336808,
0.4210168719,
0.302210629,
-0.639190197,
-0.7171856165,
-0.0334508605,
-0.0304421224,
-0.5236458182,
0.2339971513,
0.6406567097,
-0.2607684731,
0.9894354939,
0.4921323061,
-0.1973997056,
0.121951133,
-0.2661789656,
0.6532094479,
-0.6603230238,
-0.1764117777,
-1.1709481478,
0.3214124441,
0.0584015511,
-0.1989826709,
0.7148212194,
0.6538152099,
0.6040222049,
-0.2964897752,
0.8522676826,
0.2287049741,
0.6968567371,
-0.519659102,
0.7237151861,
-0.8828431964,
0.1961260736,
-0.2338390499,
-0.6647596359,
-0.3042455912,
0.33923316,
0.0469815135,
-0.0093069822,
0.3667933643,
0.6462290883,
-0.0952418596,
-0.2098903358,
0.054828424,
-0.0348121449,
0.2954377532,
0.801330924,
0.7147510052,
-0.2468419671,
0.5253822207,
-0.1679180115,
-0.418335259,
-0.5678479671,
-1.3143385649,
-0.7838634253,
-0.4679892361,
-0.5465227962,
-0.2710846961,
-0.0991825685,
0.8071992993,
0.4471054077,
-0.9341780543,
-0.1167274043,
-0.1613058597,
0.25281322,
-0.1666462123,
-0.2618785203,
0.1934801191,
-0.0203850474,
-0.4905788302,
0.1803075969,
-0.3605425954,
0.0538104363,
-0.2516768575,
0.1028490961,
0.0530255437,
-0.0452997386,
0.4369777143,
0.2251096815,
-0.6387088895,
-0.5864854455,
0.0232647043,
-0.4144997001,
-0.1826677918,
0.8306527138,
-0.516931653,
-0.143543154,
0.248756066,
0.7377229333,
0.3390190601,
-0.002880442,
0.7540559173,
-1.0105211735,
0.0277128015,
0.3351350427,
0.1943056285,
0.300933212,
-0.5002621412,
0.4176130891,
0.3833568096,
-0.5620221496,
-1.1247910261,
0.3449797034,
-0.8390287161,
-0.4285675287,
1.0289868116,
-0.3637202084,
-0.2385692298,
0.021211639,
0.092345655,
0.4886401594,
-0.0628249049,
0.6247508526,
0.8467066884,
-0.0587618165,
-0.2520568669,
-0.6414002776,
0.4809980989,
0.3162710667,
-0.6042944193,
0.461545527,
0.4167932868,
0.4785455465,
-0.000184856,
0.3780723214,
0.0583508126,
-0.0865630433,
-0.029918829,
-0.1244610325,
-0.4175537527,
-0.2323865891,
-0.1573175341,
0.1686656773,
0.2168725431,
-0.2084846795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06706v1 | On the Planning Abilities of Large Language Models (A Critical Investigation with a Proposed Benchmark) | 2023-02-13T21:37:41 | 2023-02-13T21:37:41 | Karthik Valmeekam, Sarath Sreedharan, Matthew Marquez, Alberto Olmo, Subbarao Kambhampati | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Intrigued by the claims of emergent reasoning capabilities in LLMs trained on
general web corpora, in this paper, we set out to investigate their planning
capabilities. We aim to evaluate (1) how good LLMs are by themselves in
generating and validating simple plans in commonsense planning tasks (of the
type that humans are generally quite good at) and (2) how good LLMs are in
being a source of heuristic guidance for other agents--either AI planners or
human planners--in their planning tasks. To investigate these questions in a
systematic rather than anecdotal manner, we start by developing a benchmark
suite based on the kinds of domains employed in the International Planning
Competition. On this benchmark, we evaluate LLMs in three modes: autonomous,
heuristic and human-in-the-loop. Our results show that LLM's ability to
autonomously generate executable plans is quite meager, averaging only about 3%
success rate. The heuristic and human-in-the-loop modes show slightly more
promise. In addition to these results, we also make our benchmark and
evaluation tools available to support investigations by research community. | [
-0.5783993006,
-0.5518762469,
0.875726223,
0.2403368503,
0.1592684984,
-0.0278492104,
-0.5786021948,
-0.3739386797,
-0.133313641,
0.373624146,
-0.4382057488,
-0.4723258317,
-0.3154787421,
0.2043245733,
-0.473431319,
0.4635858536,
-0.0531144515,
-0.0025820651,
-0.2277298868,
0.101126194,
-0.1558629423,
-0.4158122241,
-0.6565845609,
-0.348370254,
0.4569626153,
0.5815929174,
0.8614423871,
0.5094986558,
0.3805308938,
0.2775315344,
-0.106893912,
0.3875810802,
-0.3131715059,
0.1300059259,
-0.4594574571,
-0.3755631745,
-0.5331118703,
-0.045856446,
0.5979092717,
0.7872049212,
-0.1079554483,
0.1570825726,
0.0189648699,
0.6091524363,
-0.6541347504,
0.1852573603,
-1.0199743509,
-0.1476874948,
0.0281737857,
-0.1107735559,
-0.4599503577,
-0.1534415334,
0.1468269676,
-0.4331671298,
0.1389037669,
0.1848561913,
0.649944663,
0.278116554,
-0.1549276561,
-0.455049485,
-0.9899504781,
0.5835061669,
-0.6311154366,
0.1547612548,
0.385825634,
0.6368112564,
-0.5208143592,
-0.6176962852,
-0.4238384664,
-0.2353598773,
0.0933860838,
0.0435799696,
-0.3386814594,
0.0094428668,
0.4952551723,
-0.059211541,
-0.6009348631,
0.6079264283,
-0.353669554,
-0.1832671762,
0.9803334475,
0.2682400346,
0.1697851568,
0.0148388324,
-0.2623640597,
-0.0146237724,
-0.7822859883,
0.020607993,
0.3854795694,
0.282048136,
-0.0565189943,
0.8000636101,
-0.5152199864,
0.6137292981,
-0.4579381347,
-0.2260539383,
-0.31050542,
-0.3746507168,
-0.2230252624,
-0.2266881466,
0.673217535,
0.2853856087,
0.7830888629,
-0.2653512657,
-0.5407494903,
0.1551302522,
0.2824881375,
-0.4882387519,
-0.2329220772,
0.4370574355,
-0.3011917174,
0.1158307195,
-0.211937502,
-0.5322251916,
-0.0945407003,
-0.3677974343,
0.1532742083,
-0.4758818746,
-0.2933075726,
0.2368238419,
-0.1060215533,
0.3265922666,
0.4097771645,
-0.835685432,
0.3835816383,
0.7986830473,
0.4206256866,
-0.13254866,
-0.6013837457,
-0.27635625,
0.1940813065,
-0.4762473702,
1.2178915739,
-0.1745729148,
-0.4981893003,
0.2693760991,
-0.4526031613,
0.1083959341,
-0.665515542,
0.7054787278,
-0.3670178354,
-0.3466184139,
-0.380312115,
-0.3823676705,
0.0242092162,
0.6470070481,
-0.5185579658,
0.7109526992,
-0.0643245652,
-0.3493075073,
0.600826323,
-0.5717529655,
-0.355994612,
0.1339451671,
-0.4279202223,
0.0815287307,
-0.1786251366,
0.248205781,
0.7828145623,
-0.625071764,
0.3825052679,
-0.2179036885,
-0.1331364065,
0.4919395149,
-0.3867381215,
0.7267628908,
0.2384219915,
-0.4298996925,
0.3511432707,
-0.8648180366,
0.3343317807,
0.1227687374,
-0.5160189271,
0.0391471311,
0.2663202584,
-0.1752707213,
0.2515528202,
0.0587163977,
-0.0044292891,
0.4612398446,
-0.0959879085,
0.4700174928,
0.8102279305,
-0.0806890875,
0.49726668,
-0.4967269003,
0.5010098815,
-0.5807222724,
0.107231155,
0.0476484187,
-0.5058166385,
-0.8535472155,
-0.1727281511,
0.0456450284,
0.372389257,
-0.597987175,
0.1690806299,
-0.2901795506,
-0.6850411892,
0.0441663601,
0.1586675197,
0.3862094581,
0.1042402983,
0.1863049418,
0.0508949757,
-0.4364634454,
-0.9187072515,
-0.2305213511,
-0.3375144601,
-0.0498012379,
0.1869194657,
0.7285724282,
-0.2249593735,
0.8843388557,
-0.2474583834,
0.0193137061,
-0.4848655164,
0.2414803654,
-0.0221095402,
0.0952322707,
0.3665924072,
-0.7502487302,
-0.3492373526,
-0.2904858887,
-0.8029961586,
-0.1647441238,
-0.242025122,
-0.117339313,
0.1070929766,
0.405446887,
-0.7032792568,
0.2602107525,
0.2485773712,
-0.3291344345,
0.9207868576,
-0.318503499,
-0.3025986254,
-0.646258235,
-0.0864568949,
-0.0578681454,
-0.0036335404,
-0.5264236331,
0.2999408245,
0.0237423498,
0.0872066543,
-0.4716432989,
0.6272727847,
-0.8627720475,
-0.6090382934,
-0.2064060271,
0.3998840153,
-0.399105072,
0.397519052,
0.0446658768,
0.8897336721,
0.3946605623,
-0.8919796944,
0.0678251982,
0.2116718441,
-0.4643435478,
0.4407363832,
-0.4616172612,
0.0781269446,
0.1399782747,
0.183855027,
-0.8022558093,
-0.4668320715,
-0.0929111317,
-0.2787932754,
0.0553443991,
-0.0497419685,
-0.7272472978,
-0.5561279655,
-0.0532450043,
0.0020609405,
0.3922463357,
-0.4968048334,
0.6048021317,
0.2795171142,
-0.0656427294,
-0.2476981729,
-0.6127160192,
0.2646795213,
-0.0743911192,
-0.8309546113,
0.197535336,
-0.1254516244,
-0.9522687793,
0.0661434531,
0.1663188189,
0.0178060085,
0.1734537184,
0.2453977168,
0.20267196,
-0.1012307107,
-0.2255503982,
-0.2545747161,
-0.2490237355,
0.3734539151,
-0.0266468413,
0.6885204315,
-0.1741795093,
-0.5080754161,
-0.1115399227,
0.212773934,
0.5317031741,
-0.2643896043,
0.3211759627,
0.2464611828,
-0.3890960217,
-0.4212805629,
-0.753074646,
0.2091328651,
-0.4132401943,
0.0644402057,
-0.5756594539,
-0.6993638277,
0.5754736662,
-0.3620249331,
0.3418380022,
0.5638329387,
0.5555329323,
0.1455895305,
1.0278269053,
0.512714982,
0.1474796236,
-0.190367043,
-0.6123333573,
-0.181181252,
-0.9077909589,
-0.2067495137,
-0.5888486505,
-0.2749340236,
-0.5686975121,
-0.6902332306,
0.4362488091,
0.2130727619,
-0.3091324866,
0.2546716928,
-0.2535856962,
0.4004655778,
0.5419659019,
-0.4182886183,
0.3593930602,
-0.3366747499,
-0.2360827774,
0.2368659675,
-0.678093493,
-1.0982586145,
1.1933175325,
0.2565985024,
0.821040988,
0.1528874338,
0.5705089569,
0.0343317576,
0.2068376243,
-0.7107232809,
0.975874722,
0.1857496351,
-0.6779693365,
-0.490378052,
-0.1369237006,
-0.8567496538,
0.2282414287,
-0.4959694445,
-0.9437294602,
0.1354629397,
-0.0349296145,
-0.4196527004,
0.4536156058,
-0.6063843966,
0.4540156722,
-0.6345552802,
-0.4634530246,
-0.4370889366,
-0.3910084069,
0.3223568797,
0.0737119243,
0.1943187863,
-0.4374468327,
-0.2365212142,
0.5720729828,
0.0047322116,
0.6061828732,
-0.0457822643,
0.0384769253,
0.5197088718,
0.1054211184,
0.599353075,
0.0167314429,
-0.3520200551,
0.0440556407,
-0.3142984211,
-0.3773876727,
-0.3582251072,
0.462601155,
-0.7279439569,
-0.7363333702,
-0.2076764852,
-0.5497065187,
-0.5058647394,
0.3119747341,
0.168403089,
0.3606613576,
-0.6919500828,
-0.0584649667,
0.4761531651,
-0.1620830148,
0.7258200645,
0.6088594198,
-0.3910970688,
-0.2359855473,
0.4349453449,
0.2426721603,
0.5217506886,
0.3173809946,
0.203847304,
-0.2313971967,
-0.9940472245,
-0.5576598048,
0.0970680863,
-0.8340187669,
-0.0033383649,
-0.597461462,
-0.3622609079,
-0.2447469831,
-0.4901011586,
-0.294564873,
-0.3058190942,
0.10767553,
0.1258558929,
-0.1998104453,
1.1324614286,
-0.1486273706,
0.037606068,
-0.5151656866,
0.0679809079,
0.3574094772,
-0.1386674643,
0.0747848898,
0.0733167157,
0.0249198452,
-0.0901837125,
-0.1322518289,
-0.5085907578,
0.2385544777,
-0.2616888881,
1.0102217197,
0.6741858125,
0.1445456445,
0.5103869438,
-0.4077147245,
0.7767910361,
-0.0645682812,
-0.4206545353,
0.432346344,
-0.4896352291,
0.4217912853,
0.6434100866,
0.6520140171,
-0.0768594071,
-0.3952654004,
-0.6364584565,
-0.735506773,
0.3279337585,
0.2677759528,
-0.1393997371,
-0.0292317569,
0.226939708,
0.1340379119,
0.0772094876,
-0.5101159215,
-0.0680343956,
0.4171990752,
0.5807676315,
-0.0290054549,
-0.5997110009,
-0.2823917866,
-0.1334713846,
0.5287248492,
-0.2662232518,
0.3307237923,
0.1116576567,
0.0253344066,
-0.1069222242,
0.5423795581,
0.780944705,
1.1711905003,
-0.1207652315,
0.3490445018,
0.279494822,
-0.0818720832,
0.0847741365,
0.1618690193,
-0.1754733026,
-0.3637771904,
0.6728487611,
0.325504452,
0.246017918,
-0.8992156982,
0.1181335896,
-0.2301926911,
-0.5408009887,
-0.5803021789,
0.2447387427,
0.3150258362,
0.4848572314,
0.4232954383,
-0.022544995,
-0.0749942362,
-0.7821977735,
-0.1800872386,
0.5279584527,
0.0896116048,
-0.2571178377,
0.5035533905,
0.2466911823,
-0.677351594,
0.5278536677,
-0.8070703149,
-0.6333101392,
0.3993343413,
0.6999086142,
0.8018275499,
0.1947582364,
0.0591135286,
0.4390604198,
0.4643509984,
-0.1440529823,
0.4055567086,
-0.0265336521,
-0.9740246534,
-0.35335657,
-0.4583197832,
-0.5547002554,
0.1569450051,
-0.2770231664,
0.303771764,
-0.5251119733,
0.0343466215,
0.015228386,
0.1617334634,
-0.8703424931,
0.059682969,
0.0199655667,
1.2514653206,
-0.4140090048,
0.5599309802,
0.8565860987,
-0.3766266108,
-0.9541376829,
0.2379245013,
0.2117643207,
-1.0374950171,
0.680688858,
0.1041791141,
-0.211271733,
-0.2102744728,
-0.5177254677,
-0.9123004675,
1.2352256775,
0.1066872552,
-0.7729597092,
-0.4044895172,
0.1722120941,
0.3799008429,
-0.3433405757,
0.1037982404,
0.5250207782,
0.6914539337,
0.1224136278,
-0.9902915359,
-0.0194792561,
-0.0945286304,
-0.2204741538,
0.0741422623,
-0.5819310546,
0.8208490014,
-0.4617499113,
-0.4202129245,
0.2631928921,
0.5454051495,
0.1489093751,
0.1684958637,
0.6456924677,
0.501067102,
0.8007695079,
0.1222909093,
1.1594883204,
-0.3830638528,
-0.2490995526,
1.0883632898,
-0.3785848022,
1.0192075968,
0.1755389571,
-0.1699723303,
0.4089503884,
0.5223697424,
0.2260361612,
0.2898546457,
0.305890888,
-0.2107318342,
-0.4418097138,
0.0381713808,
-0.0227560271,
0.7285992503,
0.4146930575,
0.0182959549,
-0.3493134379,
-0.3173009753,
0.1186720356,
0.3420928717,
-0.4210135639,
0.6464412808,
0.1086630076,
-1.139077425,
0.3871327341,
-0.0290057566,
0.4996459484,
-0.4694826603,
0.1304677129,
0.1720041186,
0.2643778026,
-0.0914324448,
-1.1085133553,
0.2968125045,
0.1607390791,
0.0771061853,
-0.3445261717,
0.9582473636,
0.1857753545,
-0.1862310022,
0.4056611657,
0.8993928432,
0.2024207562,
-0.0764504448,
-0.6621076465,
-0.0069449651,
-0.2118925154,
-0.1871499866,
0.2349279076,
0.5347608328,
-0.2757199705,
0.8974714875,
0.6666122675,
0.2512665689,
-0.0712247938,
0.0602791347,
0.8594869971,
-0.8141306639,
-0.2308838367,
-0.839823842,
0.3930364251,
-0.1872984916,
-0.5044431686,
0.8027092218,
0.7093733549,
0.9704844952,
0.329243511,
0.6953907609,
0.0170939863,
0.2721766829,
-0.6672620177,
0.4717349112,
-0.1769827157,
0.4110032022,
0.100706324,
-0.9924836755,
-0.049107302,
0.4937534928,
-0.6078436375,
-0.1078384072,
0.595502317,
0.7242199183,
0.1256521642,
-0.0485223792,
0.5053803325,
-0.0338123031,
0.4842559993,
0.5440769792,
1.2774224281,
0.3868050277,
0.4724029303,
-0.2703925669,
-0.3302698731,
-0.1805063933,
-0.8837246895,
-1.1967176199,
-0.5577201843,
0.2049282789,
-0.1232152209,
0.0307612736,
1.0420585871,
0.7514503598,
-0.2963425219,
-0.5524775982,
-0.1693176776,
0.120365113,
0.0261518881,
-0.1430519372,
0.0604399629,
-0.373344928,
-0.4483742416,
0.581586659,
0.3251912892,
-0.0521984659,
-0.8884449005,
-0.2875966728,
-0.4010720253,
0.1202887297,
0.6252801418,
0.2991445363,
-0.8323451877,
-0.2395705581,
-0.0205705557,
-0.2380998582,
-0.2311261594,
0.8756973147,
-0.5523623824,
0.2581794262,
0.2831163704,
0.4526925385,
0.5714697242,
-0.2697694302,
0.5756770968,
-0.3150815964,
0.0555631183,
0.360180825,
0.5237079263,
0.2521263659,
-0.1350755394,
1.0275558233,
-0.2780604661,
-0.9054917097,
-0.5724059939,
0.2708009481,
-0.947671473,
-0.349881351,
1.6450507641,
0.0816197321,
-0.2760085166,
-0.1766245812,
-0.1987048388,
0.0195077769,
-0.2234004885,
0.6642493606,
0.6350398064,
-0.6230643988,
0.3038656712,
-0.8032024503,
0.4658513367,
-0.0249194931,
-0.9565007091,
0.1369187385,
0.5637642741,
0.0993238464,
0.4578550458,
1.1399594545,
0.2861542702,
0.2092018574,
0.2625322938,
-0.0441257283,
-0.0422358513,
-0.4518784583,
0.130551368,
0.0389483832,
0.6908209324,
0.3444484174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06692v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06692v2 | Guiding Pretraining in Reinforcement Learning with Large Language Models | 2023-02-13T21:16:03 | 2023-09-15T02:42:40 | Yuqing Du, Olivia Watkins, Zihan Wang, Cédric Colas, Trevor Darrell, Pieter Abbeel, Abhishek Gupta, Jacob Andreas | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning algorithms typically struggle in the absence of a
dense, well-shaped reward function. Intrinsically motivated exploration methods
address this limitation by rewarding agents for visiting novel states or
transitions, but these methods offer limited benefits in large environments
where most discovered novelty is irrelevant for downstream tasks. We describe a
method that uses background knowledge from text corpora to shape exploration.
This method, called ELLM (Exploring with LLMs) rewards an agent for achieving
goals suggested by a language model prompted with a description of the agent's
current state. By leveraging large-scale language model pretraining, ELLM
guides agents toward human-meaningful and plausibly useful behaviors without
requiring a human in the loop. We evaluate ELLM in the Crafter game environment
and the Housekeep robotic simulator, showing that ELLM-trained agents have
better coverage of common-sense behaviors during pretraining and usually match
or improve performance on a range of downstream tasks. Code available at
https://github.com/yuqingd/ellm. | [
-0.1961561441,
-0.6688477993,
0.8934130669,
0.0292922035,
-0.21348162,
0.276211977,
-0.5421055555,
-0.1778028011,
0.144069761,
0.5230376124,
-0.9079777002,
-0.7406141758,
-0.487657398,
-0.091780819,
-0.0744415447,
1.2447822094,
-0.1224288568,
-0.4031133652,
-0.2380609661,
0.2765589654,
-0.2499237061,
-0.7239586711,
-0.5963091254,
-0.5447428226,
1.0113164186,
0.162518993,
0.2227984071,
0.252948463,
0.122388728,
0.2872114778,
-0.1056602299,
0.3446567655,
-0.7589690685,
0.3516513407,
-0.3206728101,
-0.4992402196,
0.0435343347,
-0.00780393,
0.2903676331,
0.3228242397,
-0.3240132034,
-0.0605306402,
0.0933713019,
0.5975700617,
-0.6531456709,
0.3302314579,
-0.5809438825,
0.1643583775,
-0.0557213575,
-0.4601247907,
-0.4226372838,
-0.2053344399,
0.4583467841,
-1.01793015,
-0.048069872,
0.2517739236,
0.8148500323,
0.3987853527,
-0.3833083212,
-0.4234181941,
-0.6652680635,
0.846996069,
-0.2489431351,
0.2816849649,
0.4794636667,
0.1634784937,
-0.1277382076,
-0.5557309389,
-0.3245366514,
-0.5101915002,
-0.1938814074,
-0.0103623578,
0.0606786124,
0.2405994087,
0.4041016698,
-0.0698042139,
-0.4925968647,
0.1884974092,
-0.3646224737,
-0.2720597386,
0.6455538869,
0.0038423485,
0.1911018938,
0.3202140331,
-0.4200557172,
-0.5513535142,
-0.9024273157,
0.6508995295,
0.2710765898,
0.2559607625,
-0.0002668805,
0.3603124619,
-0.0382678136,
0.5827283859,
-0.053131111,
0.1652255207,
0.3012520969,
-0.0058831661,
0.0153182019,
0.1744500846,
0.3134569526,
0.005989525,
0.3317673206,
-0.229038462,
-0.6309375763,
0.0225853343,
0.4254871309,
-0.6552265286,
-0.1264068931,
0.1223259419,
-0.2115300447,
-0.2117008418,
0.0679124221,
-0.3915838599,
-0.3351193964,
-0.5623849034,
0.4354740381,
-0.3995731473,
-0.2372957468,
-0.0751984715,
-0.2305274606,
0.3778375983,
0.3768012524,
-1.0578011274,
0.2879166007,
0.7701473236,
0.7044858932,
-0.3170074522,
-0.4477034509,
-0.9564452171,
0.0761765987,
-0.3534938991,
0.8014728427,
-0.4852629602,
-0.3569404483,
0.195221588,
0.0355216041,
-0.0023713573,
-0.4515429437,
0.2664883733,
-0.7835555077,
0.0521429479,
-0.2183329463,
-0.3939724863,
-0.3101208806,
0.6868751645,
-0.5432890058,
0.9050577879,
0.2073803395,
-0.279879123,
0.4631243348,
-1.0108823776,
-0.3972326517,
0.0112041729,
-0.0587968864,
-0.1845033467,
0.1430799812,
0.2846185267,
0.3729263246,
0.2131353915,
0.1624014378,
-0.0136657376,
-0.5299888849,
0.0936683416,
0.0121256923,
0.4114135206,
0.1409660131,
-0.2649418712,
0.5300391912,
-0.3690719008,
0.050504379,
0.0964318439,
-0.2777024209,
-0.647805512,
0.209052667,
-0.0335118212,
0.3189936876,
0.5610136986,
-0.3128350079,
0.1497412473,
-0.3944716156,
0.2201855779,
1.0024708509,
0.0801673904,
0.5288547873,
-0.4832615256,
0.7753376365,
-0.0911140963,
-0.0423593298,
-0.4869181216,
-0.051763799,
-0.5087123513,
-0.2133017629,
0.1440236717,
0.3750954866,
-0.6613655686,
0.4940511882,
0.0561295711,
-0.3277623057,
-0.3861652017,
0.2328426391,
0.1814894676,
0.0496045314,
0.4556210041,
-0.0162018929,
-0.5545296073,
-0.4080676734,
-0.2618109286,
-0.0183724482,
-0.1063925475,
0.3278598785,
0.5412694216,
-0.4528971612,
0.7643406987,
-0.4481804073,
-0.3037404716,
-0.4030753672,
0.2390786558,
0.2597225308,
0.3865940273,
0.2084028125,
-0.8067365289,
-0.4972381592,
0.0869503692,
-0.655413568,
0.0255390257,
-0.161947161,
-0.2020206749,
-0.0051220031,
0.692794919,
-0.509057045,
0.2874399722,
0.5728778243,
-0.3474727273,
0.4730569124,
-0.4109375775,
-0.1805332899,
-0.3001374602,
0.014668501,
-0.1209582165,
-0.3833073676,
-0.5539494157,
0.19811441,
-0.1710283458,
0.0628061816,
-0.452085346,
0.7926178575,
-0.5323235989,
-0.00289267,
-0.3818975389,
0.1913623214,
-0.0390900858,
0.7710762024,
0.4593794644,
0.5307261348,
0.5777645111,
-0.8593056798,
0.1566492021,
-0.0153706251,
-0.2080466002,
0.1967633218,
-0.7021415234,
0.464263916,
-0.2089992911,
0.265355885,
-0.4304737151,
0.2335290909,
-0.0646925047,
-0.2414599657,
0.0720731691,
0.142326057,
-0.303679347,
-0.2086536735,
-0.4025869966,
0.1730672717,
0.7114843726,
-0.6608659625,
0.7290785909,
0.1054567099,
-0.1519486904,
-0.5193079114,
-0.213672176,
-0.4150273204,
-0.3635442555,
-0.2681964338,
0.4214628339,
-0.2172184139,
-0.2110078782,
-0.0082010841,
-0.0643666983,
0.230413124,
0.4108073115,
0.2032234669,
0.2936575711,
-0.019943323,
0.1783460826,
0.0150438258,
0.0019589069,
0.3329852223,
-0.5170245767,
0.7991296649,
-0.1072164774,
-0.3737273514,
0.0065736556,
0.1718833447,
0.1924252212,
-0.2595106661,
0.5403459072,
0.5430266857,
-0.1838513315,
-0.5607095957,
-0.2629514337,
-0.3852452636,
-0.4992564619,
0.524432838,
-0.2495834678,
-1.0698305368,
0.2524867654,
-0.2681885362,
0.3191033602,
0.206395939,
0.4033195078,
-0.3359554112,
0.9872421622,
0.8812915087,
0.1264891177,
0.7579663992,
-0.257296443,
0.0171398241,
-0.8940641284,
-0.4097954631,
-0.2819943726,
-0.4061651528,
-0.3721694946,
-0.4358513653,
0.3905406296,
-0.1042474359,
-0.3762285709,
0.0270252042,
-0.4043878913,
0.6184912324,
0.6991401315,
0.1638770401,
0.2741428018,
-0.0752814636,
-0.2607735991,
-0.021718191,
-0.633182168,
-0.4534658492,
1.1771563292,
0.1836822778,
0.7503449917,
-0.1054457575,
1.0719729662,
0.3461923003,
0.5453615785,
-0.830494225,
0.3176445663,
0.1840221733,
-0.4326896369,
-0.7718029618,
-0.2700690329,
-1.259924531,
0.327572912,
-0.2085766792,
-0.7374979258,
-0.0678624138,
0.2119459063,
-0.4019788206,
0.0655341521,
-0.5212994814,
0.6848257184,
-0.7033774257,
-0.26347664,
-0.4747522175,
-0.4316930771,
0.1887529492,
-0.1707444042,
0.2502157688,
0.0139374435,
-0.0892631263,
0.6722822189,
-0.258538574,
0.6552400589,
-0.5169964433,
-0.105395712,
0.2094658911,
0.0158022232,
0.8900200725,
-0.1621175408,
0.1537181884,
-0.2728301883,
-0.1991153657,
-0.4370520413,
-0.808596611,
0.3813170493,
-0.7959432006,
-0.7605560422,
-0.5184893608,
-0.4109502137,
-0.2162130028,
0.1533145607,
0.1705085188,
-0.020838419,
-0.4518930018,
0.1720410138,
1.0502909422,
-0.3388248384,
0.2687831521,
0.6106940508,
-0.4053261876,
0.2170395851,
0.8149960637,
-0.234463796,
0.0490369238,
0.685880661,
0.2352591306,
-0.608823061,
-0.484963119,
-0.1212052405,
0.028443234,
-0.4747287929,
0.1097658351,
-0.5394197702,
-0.1513224244,
-0.0499709696,
-0.4394353032,
-0.0703471377,
0.2236954421,
-0.125647366,
-0.198102057,
0.2498650849,
0.8403378129,
-0.0773137733,
0.345105648,
-0.7006777525,
-0.0128357289,
0.5674818754,
-0.031587854,
0.0812748969,
-0.4458290935,
-0.5080002546,
0.010029654,
-0.2844097614,
-0.5947921872,
0.4984603822,
0.0002698962,
0.9722904563,
0.4395608902,
0.1190125272,
0.292182982,
-0.4327611327,
0.5888097882,
0.0434500761,
-0.8582572341,
0.7239926457,
-0.3699775636,
0.3367445767,
0.5783443451,
0.5662487149,
-0.5690760016,
-0.1619829983,
-0.5682125688,
-0.9185274243,
0.5735119581,
-0.2133286893,
0.1050000861,
0.2028902173,
-0.0518341921,
0.0516174883,
0.3647662997,
-0.9630457163,
0.1447349191,
-0.2374058664,
-0.0613245741,
-0.4395379722,
0.1291456074,
-0.3168539107,
-0.1229907572,
0.6784083843,
-0.1911930889,
0.1807301193,
0.1963733137,
-0.5881524086,
0.0339105427,
0.2283780277,
0.6179609895,
0.4223482609,
-0.1923815459,
0.1380350292,
0.1589958966,
-0.2022877634,
0.4162736237,
0.1184920222,
-0.059249334,
-0.2419914007,
0.2705407441,
0.9882276654,
0.2908059061,
-1.1032007933,
0.5037226677,
-0.0516087525,
-0.2528989613,
-0.4902510643,
0.3496834338,
-0.0206176415,
0.2958623171,
0.5528870225,
-0.1734845638,
-0.0864058658,
-0.6491488814,
0.0421221443,
0.3977666497,
-0.4588950276,
-0.3413161635,
0.2652861476,
0.2559886277,
-0.4862971306,
0.6957006454,
-0.472307086,
-0.8684592247,
0.5502462983,
0.4783193171,
0.8052012324,
0.0587847419,
0.2311698347,
0.1941272616,
0.4165293276,
-0.2554136515,
-0.0011385091,
-0.4715747833,
-0.7746713758,
-0.7454204559,
-0.4754411578,
-0.5264332294,
0.0468533002,
-0.3816324472,
0.2869535089,
-0.4496283531,
0.2166474015,
-0.564863801,
0.1304521859,
-0.9978767633,
-0.0122491084,
0.4576122165,
0.7379937172,
-0.6703391075,
0.8128247261,
0.9452761412,
-0.1267735511,
-0.8995597363,
-0.0386074185,
-0.1880748868,
-0.7977190614,
0.8616204858,
0.2005541474,
-0.2339664549,
0.122724779,
-0.7385208607,
-0.8906859756,
1.1405677795,
-0.0526051037,
-0.6758570671,
-0.43273592,
-0.2959851623,
0.4993444085,
-0.4937255979,
0.2657413781,
0.3959459066,
0.6845627427,
-0.1808740944,
-0.3731145561,
0.0630702153,
-0.2976896763,
-0.1793906987,
0.0937136337,
-0.5060157776,
0.7854161263,
-0.3665471971,
-0.1569270492,
-0.1514357477,
0.6462141871,
0.8725979924,
0.4645765424,
0.9453177452,
0.3111637235,
1.0928295851,
-0.023322491,
0.9614312053,
-0.1179749295,
0.2244264334,
0.8912310004,
-0.4258004129,
0.6624878049,
0.3966297209,
0.0089651356,
1.0822507143,
0.7254415154,
0.1971135437,
0.7933298349,
0.6377512813,
-0.1808119416,
-0.3243210912,
-0.0379710458,
-0.2080372274,
0.2817151248,
0.5423346162,
-0.1221136227,
-0.1576437354,
0.1655036211,
-0.1520671248,
0.286714077,
-0.4264782071,
0.6795825958,
0.0925557613,
-1.0224281549,
0.4015154243,
-0.2565187812,
1.0698914528,
-0.9415943623,
-0.1914665997,
-0.098374702,
-0.0849683806,
-0.0269652903,
-0.3606963158,
0.0409150273,
-0.0245360471,
0.0202223118,
-0.5367404222,
0.6080600023,
-0.4571035504,
0.1157880127,
0.421307236,
0.6831073165,
0.0920777395,
-0.2501649261,
-0.4640984535,
-0.173852995,
-0.1305519938,
-0.5538694263,
0.5599724054,
0.683234632,
-0.046373222,
0.6571153402,
1.0017766953,
0.1456814706,
-0.1454776525,
-0.152129069,
0.8892845511,
-0.8227505088,
-0.9472474456,
-0.7382392287,
0.4959774911,
-0.0872849524,
-0.2352701873,
0.4994814098,
0.3292100132,
0.8878453374,
-0.0697803423,
0.6792187691,
0.1478996426,
0.3487361372,
-0.8439189792,
0.4383336008,
-0.4358870983,
0.3069848418,
-0.0072824988,
-0.9710964561,
0.1262612641,
0.8187713027,
-0.4591227174,
-0.0334366336,
0.8217339516,
0.6663636565,
0.2058493346,
-0.2565859854,
0.4541820586,
0.073185727,
0.2934196591,
0.7816377878,
1.4653741121,
0.3415554762,
0.3457891941,
0.0724998564,
-0.2042565942,
-0.1709705442,
-0.8216971755,
-1.030872941,
-0.4472552836,
0.0768287182,
-0.0790332258,
0.2714839876,
1.4035872221,
1.0021550655,
-0.4878175855,
-0.2473448664,
-0.2063066065,
0.3439874947,
-0.4975498319,
-0.1911455244,
0.1715295464,
-0.6380190849,
-0.6818007827,
0.5966313481,
0.0068494976,
-0.0154765677,
-0.6197511554,
-0.5236743093,
-0.1666740924,
-0.0568189137,
0.6011146903,
0.4994844794,
-0.4191776514,
-0.1127766371,
0.2368569672,
0.0316657498,
-0.1243795753,
1.1437183619,
-1.1315667629,
0.0503573678,
0.2760564983,
0.7731322646,
0.8840404153,
-0.0367940031,
0.6132478714,
-0.7499064207,
0.253462851,
0.5096847415,
0.1555569172,
0.1634765267,
-0.5367529392,
0.4915687442,
-0.0944241732,
-0.6794786453,
-0.7242688537,
0.0828727111,
-0.7399893999,
-0.3299978375,
1.0954457521,
-0.355979085,
-0.4175286889,
-0.1540222913,
-0.1733113974,
-0.0189902559,
-0.6118642688,
0.7445431948,
0.7276224494,
-0.089328967,
-0.2021010667,
-0.3679042459,
0.6712072492,
0.4695590436,
-0.9235578179,
-0.2032784075,
0.191893816,
0.0056004943,
0.1110588685,
0.8662923574,
0.3227928281,
0.2349806279,
-0.3465692103,
0.1423283666,
-0.1372484267,
-0.5048192143,
-0.3192308247,
-0.1968218982,
0.3368793428,
0.0556691997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06690v1 | Bag of Tricks for In-Distribution Calibration of Pretrained Transformers | 2023-02-13T21:11:52 | 2023-02-13T21:11:52 | Jaeyoung Kim, Dongbin Na, Sungchul Choi, Sungbin Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While pre-trained language models (PLMs) have become a de-facto standard
promoting the accuracy of text classification tasks, recent studies find that
PLMs often predict over-confidently. Although various calibration methods have
been proposed, such as ensemble learning and data augmentation, most of the
methods have been verified in computer vision benchmarks rather than in
PLM-based text classification tasks. In this paper, we present an empirical
study on confidence calibration for PLMs, addressing three categories,
including confidence penalty losses, data augmentations, and ensemble methods.
We find that the ensemble model overfitted to the training set shows sub-par
calibration performance and also observe that PLMs trained with confidence
penalty loss have a trade-off between calibration and accuracy. Building on
these observations, we propose the Calibrated PLM (CALL), a combination of
calibration techniques. The CALL complements the drawbacks that may occur when
utilizing a calibration method individually and boosts both classification and
calibration accuracy. Design choices in CALL's training procedures are
extensively studied, and we provide a detailed analysis of how calibration
techniques affect the calibration performance of PLMs. | [
-0.5393002629,
0.0857222602,
0.3811830282,
-0.0120984176,
-0.3436812162,
0.2942210734,
-0.3885716796,
-0.0371493287,
-0.1944748014,
0.8088841438,
-0.4118961394,
-0.3565073013,
-0.4632632136,
0.025105508,
-0.3568361402,
1.0307520628,
-0.1872221231,
0.2486774176,
-0.4293704629,
-0.0344033949,
-0.4579844177,
-0.7364589572,
-0.1262191534,
-0.5615733862,
0.1321112812,
0.5645458102,
0.7758797407,
0.114653036,
0.6929077506,
0.3033768237,
0.312815845,
0.3362617791,
-0.3219077289,
-0.4723276198,
-0.0296723228,
-1.1167385578,
-0.1760328561,
0.3183401227,
0.5873029232,
0.608928442,
-0.1508633345,
0.1461528093,
0.2998078465,
0.5826255679,
-0.9028159976,
0.0113858376,
-0.5627747774,
0.0303414036,
-0.2635316253,
-0.8493210673,
-0.8696687222,
-0.507451117,
0.2397133559,
-0.5275971889,
0.3541486561,
-0.0174709018,
0.6061860323,
0.6950563788,
-0.2806587517,
-0.26617226,
-1.0001004934,
1.2456357479,
-0.4379426241,
0.1204871163,
0.5465962291,
0.5975936055,
0.0437169559,
-0.5953778625,
-0.6390089393,
-0.0236882195,
-0.1517718881,
0.3139193654,
0.3058208823,
0.2344727665,
0.2081741393,
0.3987817168,
-0.281922698,
0.1447095424,
-0.2134115249,
-0.0924125239,
0.7600953579,
-0.1966649294,
-0.1578817368,
0.1116104722,
-0.6512056589,
-0.9469131827,
-0.7268987894,
-0.005576015,
0.9284427762,
0.0368157811,
0.0724792108,
0.4192452729,
0.3486208618,
0.832265079,
0.0789016336,
-0.3403608799,
0.4952839017,
-0.1137248054,
-0.1818684936,
0.245323807,
0.5121847987,
0.4018057287,
0.6831521392,
-0.0848902091,
-0.3973957002,
0.0342282243,
0.4772127271,
-0.5999424458,
-0.4574998319,
-0.0050242268,
-0.2337068766,
-0.4548158348,
0.4856451452,
-0.511483252,
-0.3014463782,
-0.3671217263,
0.9167257547,
-0.2862218916,
-0.1299831718,
0.2613329887,
-0.3111035228,
0.4273141623,
0.1875032634,
-0.6662060618,
0.192864418,
0.56005162,
0.4570307136,
0.0381767377,
-0.1348581463,
-0.4579980969,
-0.1125789061,
-0.4327185452,
0.7774061561,
-0.3661885262,
-0.5854286551,
0.014032281,
-0.1691264361,
-0.433095932,
-0.5213601589,
0.748198092,
-0.4284732342,
0.1864281595,
0.1203957498,
-0.6831988692,
-0.3087852895,
0.0971610546,
-0.4532918334,
0.8681308627,
0.1199237481,
-0.7662456632,
0.5355966687,
-0.1262195259,
-0.3692225814,
0.3902805448,
-0.2157904804,
-0.4221510291,
0.0332020335,
-0.0061668819,
0.421897918,
-0.0869291201,
-0.035424158,
-0.2498530596,
-0.791898787,
0.4413028955,
-0.817892909,
0.6581376791,
0.1196421459,
-0.1264835,
-0.2574645877,
-0.7187818885,
0.3576105535,
-0.5904924273,
-0.0681800395,
-0.2951804996,
0.2242059857,
-0.1691226065,
0.0268114172,
0.0793592781,
-0.5776245594,
-0.1968096644,
-0.779471159,
0.1891984046,
0.5765866041,
-0.3880621791,
0.7134485841,
-0.7261477113,
0.5474116802,
-0.1307264417,
0.2173015624,
-0.414773494,
-0.3280970454,
-0.8491914272,
-0.0622879826,
0.4303187728,
0.8718338013,
-0.8297293782,
0.9476515055,
-0.4388738871,
-0.8733161688,
-0.4872778356,
0.1849972606,
0.1626283824,
0.501475513,
0.3017812669,
-0.402171284,
-0.3126509488,
-0.7397376299,
-0.3191453218,
-0.162039414,
-0.3802165687,
0.0098514901,
0.3091121316,
0.0098077646,
1.2583159208,
-0.3031844199,
-0.5990717411,
-0.0356227793,
0.288161099,
0.1075313538,
0.5835987926,
0.4402275383,
-0.8896713853,
-0.4890558422,
-0.1681147963,
-0.1012067273,
-0.048028741,
-0.1299014241,
0.1814390123,
0.1353382617,
0.301132232,
-0.3953573704,
0.705113709,
0.7189523578,
0.4125552177,
0.5759413242,
-0.5417566895,
0.079040654,
-0.9032962322,
-0.0959186405,
0.1283449382,
-0.369215399,
-0.5255576968,
-0.1955408305,
0.3758983314,
0.2964137495,
-0.4490685165,
0.2566142976,
-0.180802688,
0.0502112247,
-0.2403704375,
-0.0565977581,
0.1105380282,
0.2259116024,
0.2039152086,
0.7702493072,
0.4302621484,
-0.5976991653,
0.325761646,
0.2351477444,
-0.6498952508,
0.659320116,
-0.3129970431,
0.1315131038,
-0.2767427564,
0.5257521272,
-1.295645237,
0.0500530377,
0.0722582415,
-0.3114813864,
0.6167703271,
-0.1071503386,
-0.8061310053,
-0.6550998688,
-0.4838120341,
0.4438828826,
0.7415134907,
-0.6843150258,
0.6852117181,
0.2967404127,
0.3133129478,
-0.6559514999,
-1.0016241074,
-0.3890533447,
-0.2836939394,
-0.4309360385,
0.6878641248,
-0.2279845178,
0.1035603434,
-0.6184987426,
-0.0681892782,
0.0396608077,
-0.1907227635,
0.3583046496,
0.3015157878,
0.1737891138,
0.3095521331,
-0.2589250803,
-0.2616710365,
-0.0770606026,
0.0241498053,
0.6808040142,
-0.0042671142,
-0.5858188868,
-0.3453235328,
-0.1474002451,
0.2628844082,
-0.1929863691,
0.53884691,
0.4917384684,
-0.1140114218,
-0.472247988,
-0.7792986631,
-0.4275325835,
-0.5547966957,
0.0581535138,
-0.3721976578,
-0.1254828572,
0.3113998771,
-0.1600614339,
0.132075578,
0.2641466856,
0.1133161262,
-0.3713557422,
1.1933578253,
0.7909398675,
0.1347010583,
0.4122331142,
-0.3266552985,
0.4041324556,
-0.4916098416,
-0.1290934384,
-0.659773767,
-0.4127803743,
-0.7211458683,
-0.6302546263,
0.2744496763,
0.0297339689,
-0.2516094148,
0.5071911812,
-0.5216401219,
0.6831722856,
0.826066196,
0.2499579191,
0.1872594208,
0.0432921164,
0.0303679202,
-0.071146898,
-0.7367898822,
-0.7238311172,
1.2124505043,
0.5118992329,
1.1409859657,
-0.5040736794,
0.6287474632,
-0.0201660953,
0.6633193493,
-0.8378611207,
0.4040266573,
-0.4873622954,
-0.3056857586,
-0.1156777218,
-0.4881797135,
-0.3577225804,
-0.1325829774,
-0.0010250126,
-0.460413605,
0.3927656412,
0.3574630022,
-0.5809008479,
0.3892552853,
-1.127286315,
0.6596237421,
-0.3056242764,
0.2376098931,
-0.0972986817,
-0.8446283937,
0.1921615899,
-0.4200364351,
0.1481253952,
0.1940957904,
0.1636305749,
0.565685451,
-0.5178166628,
0.907984376,
-0.0600691624,
-0.0382164568,
0.3995356262,
-0.254876107,
0.5276131034,
-0.3169949353,
-0.115322955,
0.0851978287,
0.3534111381,
-0.0772937238,
-0.4612857699,
0.3994040787,
-0.8044995666,
-0.3096244037,
-0.401804477,
-0.5383310914,
-0.3987902403,
-0.2068767697,
0.6798562407,
0.6159167886,
0.3550526798,
0.3734225929,
0.6161916852,
-0.4353966117,
0.524466157,
0.291295439,
0.1402883828,
-0.3049701452,
0.9521026611,
0.2027297169,
0.5762461424,
0.6161010265,
-0.0185023118,
-0.6349688768,
-0.1348919421,
-0.315030098,
0.1247304156,
-0.8461120129,
-0.4713149369,
-0.0976159796,
-0.4851357639,
-0.2807875872,
-0.1829821616,
-0.2746258378,
-0.2955894172,
-0.4147205353,
0.0891446844,
0.1452404559,
0.3515635431,
0.2848733366,
0.9555244446,
-0.8357082605,
-0.275377363,
0.0846665055,
0.4696910977,
-0.4191527963,
-0.5811642408,
-0.0840566382,
0.3183758855,
-0.6247187853,
-0.9160068035,
0.5020400286,
0.352381438,
0.5193846822,
0.4680204988,
0.2814523578,
0.7878266573,
-0.3987698555,
0.5245087743,
0.2531752884,
-0.7962883711,
0.1945021451,
0.349617213,
0.1497900188,
0.754504025,
0.2415249199,
-0.1916273236,
-0.2612076998,
-0.647872448,
-0.3957390487,
0.756591022,
0.0436739735,
0.4866549969,
0.3036366105,
0.0973143205,
0.2041345984,
0.4493851662,
-0.3671785593,
-0.3333315253,
-0.3316018283,
-0.5846006274,
-0.6385632753,
0.0479820669,
0.0061281724,
-0.1351137757,
0.6334345937,
-0.322953701,
0.0625310764,
0.0840268135,
-0.2468401939,
-0.2870768309,
0.1276807636,
0.4850084782,
0.5088866949,
-0.3732979,
0.1918467134,
0.1936428696,
-0.6096338034,
0.0579065271,
0.2526963949,
-0.1832270473,
0.1097488031,
-0.0484446026,
0.7732958198,
0.4227434695,
-0.729326725,
0.9346862435,
0.1709764749,
-0.2794022262,
-0.6243296862,
0.109182924,
-0.4151260257,
-0.2013636678,
0.6329321265,
0.6221120954,
-0.1276391894,
-0.1353264749,
0.3018766642,
0.656411171,
-0.3177194893,
-0.23092556,
0.3981816769,
0.1353341192,
-0.5132308602,
0.3862120509,
0.0494009033,
-0.8077248931,
0.4331898391,
0.2527760565,
0.7052348256,
-0.3927924335,
0.500736773,
0.1318287104,
0.4682075083,
-0.4579051435,
-0.0087578222,
-0.2377707958,
-1.0277613401,
-0.6928887963,
-0.6935579777,
-0.6499733329,
0.0646042973,
-0.4604249299,
0.7173931599,
-0.1746443212,
-0.2853015661,
-0.3214510679,
0.170668751,
-0.9748952985,
0.2597568631,
0.1090387478,
1.1497455835,
-0.8094209433,
0.7706264853,
0.4971400201,
-0.0918896347,
-0.9777833223,
-0.0669887662,
-0.4792129993,
-0.6512185931,
0.5477858186,
0.6411157846,
-0.0894368812,
0.4147190154,
-0.3708937764,
-0.6083254218,
0.8974146843,
0.4273869097,
-0.6607531905,
-0.0780122355,
0.5606310964,
0.4354142547,
-0.1924163103,
0.6431536078,
0.5507062078,
0.3916431069,
0.3034398854,
-1.199852705,
-0.5816058517,
0.1360143274,
-0.0290721431,
0.2862056792,
-0.3577891886,
0.6420109868,
0.0030167999,
-0.4892761111,
0.1538572311,
0.2113330811,
0.137010783,
0.1319054067,
0.9072173238,
0.6491914988,
0.4321918488,
-0.2504402697,
1.2432198524,
-0.3595637381,
0.3572147489,
0.9073978662,
-0.2935521901,
0.9076391459,
0.5871390104,
-0.2340635806,
0.4427224696,
0.6065189242,
-0.0053685554,
0.6040984392,
0.2365847081,
-0.3589176238,
-0.3993462026,
0.2842251658,
-0.1591530442,
0.2951942682,
0.4207651913,
-0.3430107236,
-0.2514060736,
0.2843154669,
-0.5086074471,
-0.0462855101,
-0.2721689641,
0.3633700013,
0.1914971173,
-0.9187033176,
0.3392085433,
-0.1981351674,
0.9339020848,
-0.4598787427,
0.1010052413,
0.2571204603,
0.723354578,
-0.2245146632,
-0.9540314674,
0.0308936834,
-0.4691490531,
0.265748322,
-0.5703323483,
0.7921891212,
-0.5733126402,
-0.445048064,
-0.1102313176,
0.1490519941,
0.3141088486,
-0.3044940233,
-0.3197352588,
-0.2363248914,
-0.1415813416,
-0.1287746131,
0.0547589101,
-0.0825477019,
0.1330457181,
0.6657147408,
0.5354040861,
0.1045140997,
0.2639635205,
0.1551117301,
0.4604750872,
0.0504146405,
-0.5451771617,
-0.6162228584,
0.5799924135,
-0.1094886959,
-0.3295139968,
0.7345954776,
0.4047002494,
1.2074596882,
-0.2315495759,
0.5329533815,
0.5615285635,
0.6088896394,
-0.2492251843,
0.5509132147,
-0.2863204777,
0.3043189943,
-0.2233501375,
-1.0737011433,
-0.4324016273,
0.9271845818,
-0.6077081561,
0.1752565205,
0.5034890175,
0.9069837928,
0.022532735,
0.2605548501,
0.3352943659,
-0.3755510449,
0.1339739859,
0.4795365036,
0.897441864,
-0.7341793776,
0.8015423417,
-0.741604805,
-0.3482739925,
-0.2689027786,
-0.9224113226,
-0.7375924587,
-0.5426464081,
-0.266897589,
-0.003957612,
-0.4117523432,
0.6491864324,
1.0492759943,
-0.7053748965,
-0.1295566708,
-0.2802844942,
-0.2801522017,
-0.1470202059,
-0.2579763234,
0.1024175733,
-0.4226955473,
-0.8606908321,
0.0583465919,
0.0075986297,
0.4757632315,
-0.3840620518,
-0.1730577648,
0.3741483688,
0.0207452811,
0.2948701382,
0.0357673168,
-0.5017355084,
-0.3536732197,
0.0819042474,
0.0184150003,
0.0606968589,
0.7390657663,
-1.1069198847,
0.6386833191,
0.459318012,
0.6796825528,
0.4364695847,
0.2820169628,
0.6711477637,
-1.2673200369,
0.2447943389,
0.4827403724,
0.1962338835,
0.537570715,
-0.1131567657,
0.3193972111,
-0.0425711125,
-0.7884088159,
-1.1685609818,
0.0697086006,
-0.7706901431,
0.1436694562,
0.964138031,
-0.0021330423,
-0.10989777,
0.0248229299,
-0.3518916667,
0.1170278564,
-0.0161919873,
0.4907258153,
0.8527479172,
0.3266795874,
-0.2206999958,
-0.467181474,
0.7255019546,
0.5749586225,
-0.5602752566,
-0.2115722597,
0.0710230768,
0.0893075019,
0.7109364271,
0.2613985837,
-0.0162329338,
0.2260797471,
-0.343545258,
0.0178855658,
0.391781956,
-0.3171157837,
-0.2530623078,
0.0346332081,
-0.0134020271,
-0.4837290943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06675v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06675v4 | Symbolic Discovery of Optimization Algorithms | 2023-02-13T20:27:30 | 2023-05-08T21:49:57 | Xiangning Chen, Chen Liang, Da Huang, Esteban Real, Kaiyuan Wang, Yao Liu, Hieu Pham, Xuanyi Dong, Thang Luong, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Yifeng Lu, Quoc V. Le | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.NE | We present a method to formulate algorithm discovery as program search, and
apply it to discover optimization algorithms for deep neural network training.
We leverage efficient search techniques to explore an infinite and sparse
program space. To bridge the large generalization gap between proxy and target
tasks, we also introduce program selection and simplification strategies. Our
method discovers a simple and effective optimization algorithm, $\textbf{Lion}$
($\textit{Evo$\textbf{L}$ved S$\textbf{i}$gn M$\textbf{o}$me$\textbf{n}$tum}$).
It is more memory-efficient than Adam as it only keeps track of the momentum.
Different from adaptive optimizers, its update has the same magnitude for each
parameter calculated through the sign operation. We compare Lion with widely
used optimizers, such as Adam and Adafactor, for training a variety of models
on different tasks. On image classification, Lion boosts the accuracy of ViT by
up to 2% on ImageNet and saves up to 5x the pre-training compute on JFT. On
vision-language contrastive learning, we achieve 88.3% $\textit{zero-shot}$ and
91.1% $\textit{fine-tuning}$ accuracy on ImageNet, surpassing the previous best
results by 2% and 0.1%, respectively. On diffusion models, Lion outperforms
Adam by achieving a better FID score and reducing the training compute by up to
2.3x. For autoregressive, masked language modeling, and fine-tuning, Lion
exhibits a similar or better performance compared to Adam. Our analysis of Lion
reveals that its performance gain grows with the training batch size. It also
requires a smaller learning rate than Adam due to the larger norm of the update
produced by the sign function. Additionally, we examine the limitations of Lion
and identify scenarios where its improvements are small or not statistically
significant. Lion is also successfully deployed in production systems such as
Google search ads CTR model. | [
-0.3469647765,
-0.348161459,
0.2457128018,
0.4580172896,
-0.1631303877,
0.2263157815,
-0.2563925982,
-0.4111415148,
0.5196552277,
0.1911098659,
-0.7385210991,
-0.3290156424,
-0.7664747834,
-0.1062068716,
-0.1314666569,
0.488887161,
-0.0501029901,
0.2922423482,
0.4306758344,
-0.2338417768,
-0.3825215697,
-0.185031876,
-1.1258057356,
-0.2494149804,
0.2877557874,
0.020287104,
0.7973960638,
1.0046519041,
0.7529085279,
0.3131916821,
-0.2526859045,
0.267804563,
-0.5234231353,
0.1120730862,
0.0431872755,
-0.1159154847,
-0.0045183511,
-0.1379649639,
0.4856542945,
0.7971765399,
0.1481841356,
0.2090103179,
-0.0473524109,
1.123603344,
-1.0483483076,
0.1663030684,
-0.656604588,
0.4930468202,
0.0800077021,
-0.2390260845,
-0.0648220852,
-0.3389549851,
0.1297733039,
-0.8078050017,
0.287637651,
-0.111210905,
1.0047297478,
0.575443387,
-0.1115265042,
-0.4527859092,
-0.7428581715,
1.0039645433,
-0.3547702134,
0.1931724399,
-0.0669554919,
0.3860261738,
-0.446906805,
-0.790568769,
-0.3143403232,
-0.5467599034,
0.2474467456,
0.0421600677,
-0.1095148996,
0.4902475178,
0.2896520793,
0.764872551,
-0.5286601186,
-0.1277824044,
-0.4129405022,
-0.3748826683,
0.7965617776,
0.0146663813,
0.2234089077,
0.3452618718,
-0.1904148459,
-0.6740355492,
-0.4827724397,
0.2228419632,
0.1377606392,
0.3408998251,
0.2764834762,
0.3405606747,
-0.2118291706,
0.420039624,
-0.1789358705,
0.2468779981,
0.2929366827,
-0.0812076256,
-0.1596211642,
-0.0605130494,
0.6013019085,
0.176071167,
0.3086229563,
0.0268374328,
-0.5878006816,
0.1358757764,
0.2050942183,
-0.9165267348,
-0.453216821,
-0.2325557917,
-0.6876162291,
-0.3774046898,
0.0829424337,
-0.1843526363,
-0.4078090787,
-0.5003362894,
0.6063756347,
-0.263477087,
-0.1177763343,
0.2432296276,
-0.3217430711,
0.2604858577,
0.2558068335,
-0.7750605345,
0.3750956655,
0.7631523013,
1.0560361147,
-0.0818037242,
0.089805305,
-0.6624101996,
-0.3712106049,
-0.8945659995,
-0.001466485,
-0.4419679046,
-0.056563627,
0.1340085566,
-0.1289299875,
-0.1975806057,
-0.5209079981,
0.6052933335,
-0.6046280265,
-0.4287684262,
-0.3016656339,
-0.3883573115,
-0.5723212957,
-0.0198600087,
-0.9142563343,
1.1963317394,
-0.095955506,
-0.2898280621,
0.2879551053,
-1.2007106543,
-0.4111331701,
-0.208858043,
-0.0493900068,
-0.4198468626,
0.4258640409,
0.4017296433,
0.4712507129,
-0.2923134267,
0.0031834589,
-0.2457670867,
-0.7438213825,
-0.2243712097,
0.1509872079,
1.0855824947,
0.6143035293,
-0.7030215859,
-0.1220541671,
-0.4765146077,
0.1106242388,
0.443708986,
-0.1285647899,
-0.594224453,
0.099898614,
-0.253756851,
0.0048873182,
0.2128167599,
-0.4286435544,
0.2309585661,
-0.5883721113,
0.3373880982,
0.7581180334,
-0.0321012586,
0.3521243632,
0.1034081802,
0.6106896996,
-0.2283277512,
0.4076832235,
-0.2180623859,
-0.2850204408,
-0.9984871149,
-0.0403238423,
0.4201969802,
0.3854497969,
-0.5693007112,
0.2005416751,
0.0269586388,
-0.2957047224,
-0.561904788,
0.3424552381,
0.7042492032,
0.1866533905,
0.2352437377,
-0.5009288788,
-0.6361811161,
-0.9229530692,
-0.2562697232,
-0.1267232448,
0.342677027,
0.3197074234,
0.5084038377,
-0.2330533713,
0.4709549248,
-0.6112185717,
-0.252715975,
-0.0214563999,
0.1991352737,
0.4715740681,
0.4815960824,
0.7887502909,
-0.6988496184,
-0.437205106,
0.1121399403,
-0.8383408189,
0.0323930345,
-0.2473543882,
-0.0029378736,
-0.0462558456,
0.6879950762,
-0.1285453886,
0.3153795004,
0.4854935408,
0.4642486572,
0.2674782574,
-0.0071287053,
-0.265591532,
-0.7939451933,
-0.0055944873,
0.1078634188,
0.187472403,
-0.4639793634,
0.7361986041,
-0.0808866695,
-0.1609120816,
-0.4076195955,
0.4024656713,
-0.5964289904,
-0.2039162219,
-0.1965806186,
-0.2499819994,
-0.2899047434,
0.6446690559,
-0.0483559929,
1.0014173985,
0.8716993928,
-0.680711627,
0.2059681863,
-0.0475728884,
-0.1089128628,
-0.3374842405,
-0.926900208,
0.3183961213,
-0.1312140524,
-0.1004496664,
-1.0330049992,
0.1971538663,
0.3731364906,
-0.4300157428,
0.2652966082,
-0.0432499945,
-0.2547774315,
-0.3472779393,
-0.6830807328,
0.3524933457,
0.3461480141,
-0.7695063353,
0.5544973016,
0.1600098014,
0.2858631909,
-1.0542343855,
-0.3708355725,
0.2395647764,
0.1366836429,
-0.7645369768,
0.3874884248,
-0.0635336563,
-0.0092032403,
-0.1276932657,
-0.28285864,
-0.0299661532,
0.3988661468,
0.1845964491,
-0.0821285918,
-0.523687005,
0.2237624973,
0.1459806412,
-0.0990416706,
0.2012845129,
-0.5625393987,
0.3053562045,
-0.486952275,
-0.1932421774,
-0.2068196535,
0.0285353567,
0.1798988134,
-0.2784130871,
0.4334435165,
0.8047998548,
-0.412040621,
-0.3880331814,
-0.3483395278,
-0.3525330424,
-0.5320677757,
0.4020715356,
-0.3425614238,
-0.761153996,
0.4580927193,
-0.5380189419,
0.2993272543,
0.5115724206,
0.1936420053,
0.1879148781,
1.3389325142,
0.79648,
-0.2581485212,
0.5809385777,
-0.8081482649,
0.240585044,
-0.5831797123,
0.0386461467,
-0.4867313504,
-0.7400687933,
-0.652816236,
-0.0962938964,
0.3861056566,
0.2311531305,
-0.4309591651,
0.4152527452,
-1.0489190817,
0.618547678,
0.8338224292,
-0.0754998103,
-0.0962433144,
0.2786207497,
-0.3729862571,
-0.0496301055,
-0.635368824,
-0.0154715041,
1.1588532925,
0.2833738327,
0.7596569061,
-0.1133093536,
0.9743354917,
0.4448526502,
-0.0163689069,
-0.6948899627,
0.6418742537,
-0.3850777745,
-0.3636782169,
-0.2603548467,
-0.3910696208,
-0.9560362697,
0.2133125067,
-0.1404743195,
-0.4901108146,
0.3111070693,
0.2264177948,
-0.1599298865,
0.0317884646,
-0.6954805851,
0.7096948028,
-0.4588067234,
-0.1028493494,
-0.2656630874,
-0.9188249707,
0.359878093,
-0.0620569661,
-0.4149313867,
0.0398516394,
0.0085135624,
0.6587535739,
-0.5816086531,
0.495103538,
-0.3250582218,
0.4194369018,
0.1242871657,
0.1828010678,
0.5421132445,
-0.1804012358,
-0.0591825359,
0.2361863852,
-0.2011293024,
-0.2414573133,
-0.7423163652,
0.5743002295,
-0.9996455908,
-0.4886567295,
-0.5779738426,
-0.356859982,
0.1557123214,
0.2267094851,
0.0165935196,
0.1501862109,
-0.0001083257,
0.2789274752,
0.731669426,
-0.3558184206,
0.5536186099,
0.2109284997,
-0.0800795183,
-0.1657456607,
1.0634163618,
-0.2680233419,
0.0010576762,
0.4887923896,
0.4033894837,
-0.2823788524,
-0.6925760508,
-0.2422238588,
0.1660767347,
-0.6893803477,
-0.1611811072,
-0.4057177007,
-0.5670182109,
-0.0375095494,
-0.1942971349,
-0.5049347878,
-0.654656291,
-0.1439697891,
0.1169662327,
0.2864197493,
0.4140124619,
-0.421666801,
0.5852572322,
-0.296469748,
0.2397850156,
0.1725589633,
0.0426145568,
0.1561946124,
-0.1375489682,
-0.2771588266,
0.1177435592,
-0.5369639397,
-0.4012175202,
0.1962557584,
0.650922358,
0.4640653729,
0.8003684878,
0.019939119,
0.7728458047,
-0.0850471556,
0.6141492128,
0.2199744731,
-0.9364108443,
0.6721396446,
0.0359916352,
-0.0754873529,
0.6357862353,
0.359988302,
-0.1877553016,
-0.1477881521,
-0.2962640822,
-0.746052742,
0.7131582499,
0.432559222,
0.2155246586,
0.2048873752,
0.5225451589,
-0.4129793644,
0.1720298678,
-0.5341694951,
-0.5044971108,
-0.1189011782,
0.066895619,
0.0737657994,
0.0382387415,
-0.1498221159,
-0.489066571,
0.8096526265,
-0.2346541435,
0.3248356581,
0.143607378,
-0.0959036946,
-0.0937904418,
-0.5223162174,
0.6748290658,
0.5640067458,
-0.3469245434,
-0.0344095901,
0.1032139286,
-0.7205453515,
-0.0069891787,
0.1638899595,
-0.1795479506,
0.2655556798,
0.2621958852,
0.7653326392,
-0.2902673781,
-0.6124501228,
0.6873953938,
-0.0561242066,
-0.4100570381,
-0.5915995836,
0.3363785744,
-0.2214202732,
0.3934013247,
0.4718945026,
0.2547611892,
0.5528974533,
-0.1064419672,
-0.1300587654,
0.7887668014,
-0.3702504039,
0.0665801242,
0.7902555466,
0.0281434562,
-0.2662833631,
0.5448493958,
-0.433763653,
-0.6269412637,
0.9042875767,
0.2016219348,
1.2440806627,
-0.2256595492,
0.2151839584,
0.3000431359,
0.573474586,
-0.2006317675,
0.3258427382,
-0.1786259264,
-0.7401659489,
-0.7365019321,
-0.605609715,
-0.1511672139,
0.3318487406,
-0.4348936677,
0.1742435396,
-0.7455569506,
-0.107054241,
0.390268147,
0.3497360349,
-0.6446547508,
0.1941517591,
-0.026116373,
1.0964884758,
-0.6424431205,
0.5354081988,
0.8185148239,
-0.3166585267,
-1.0205731392,
-0.3709901571,
0.1611236334,
-1.2737704515,
1.0133804083,
0.2172851562,
-0.4201007485,
-0.3313738704,
-0.7745766044,
-0.7559087276,
0.9639023542,
0.5290313363,
-0.4562557936,
0.1791310608,
0.0423407331,
0.601873517,
-0.467118144,
0.1613710821,
0.3287094831,
0.2902306616,
0.4097650051,
-0.5705417395,
0.0934838206,
-0.5623825788,
0.6288971901,
0.3025803268,
-0.4287056923,
0.785923779,
-0.3035821915,
-0.0623830967,
0.2147842497,
0.5972338915,
0.0930238441,
0.480407536,
0.6919950247,
0.5366621614,
0.4800930023,
-0.0339688696,
0.9295312762,
-0.5028777122,
0.1828691512,
0.4844708741,
0.1346756816,
0.2824230492,
0.4463912249,
0.0363732502,
0.1969478726,
0.8760560155,
-0.0898637027,
0.6205924749,
0.5494803786,
-0.1188313887,
-0.3124800622,
-0.1069989651,
-0.3260947168,
0.1549931467,
0.2181839496,
-0.8365753293,
-0.1076694429,
-0.2051727325,
-0.0274942908,
-0.1451443285,
-0.427282393,
0.505387485,
0.1917680353,
-0.6234986782,
0.9484632611,
0.1449735612,
0.3416880965,
-0.5514449477,
-0.3225886524,
-0.3199304342,
0.5700432062,
-0.0529823229,
-0.3705575466,
0.1119006947,
-0.6600186229,
0.0042078425,
-0.016726004,
0.7884528637,
0.1311163008,
-0.5584958196,
0.3202483952,
0.1464211792,
0.2635188997,
-0.2875856757,
-1.1041101217,
0.2973430157,
0.1738069952,
-0.0722889602,
0.0721462294,
0.158239454,
-0.1969545037,
0.7789113522,
0.8303850889,
0.1797171831,
0.1813155115,
-0.0525094867,
1.0309064388,
-0.4510520697,
-0.4354492426,
-0.5602997541,
-0.0891465023,
-0.2468971759,
-0.4775418043,
0.4452888072,
0.6107888222,
0.751701355,
-0.0812052935,
0.4643004537,
0.1139786541,
0.1597742289,
-0.4695222676,
0.4011561275,
-0.9114089012,
0.3401723504,
-0.4963540733,
-1.2339826822,
-0.5007189512,
0.918409884,
-0.0054676691,
0.0717036501,
0.5056061745,
1.3338884115,
-0.1761314422,
0.0958421603,
-0.1345626414,
-0.1876471937,
0.2386951894,
0.6541354656,
0.8693590164,
-0.5508560538,
0.5773270726,
-0.337677598,
-0.2794257104,
-0.23214297,
-0.9938447475,
-0.887653172,
-0.6546815634,
-0.3829109371,
-0.2476250827,
0.6146374941,
0.9352379441,
0.8934730887,
-0.7671635747,
-0.2325295061,
-0.3292571306,
0.0216431562,
-0.8732070923,
-0.2081590742,
0.666882515,
-0.6132556796,
-0.5106108785,
0.3733891249,
0.2694606483,
-0.1531689763,
-0.2276960015,
-0.545162797,
0.0246938076,
-0.0630063415,
0.4524301589,
0.659697473,
-0.5832185149,
-0.0421899781,
0.3592602909,
0.1654451191,
-0.2806574702,
0.936617136,
-0.445655942,
0.7324604988,
0.4322981834,
1.1890294552,
0.7640625834,
-0.2913763225,
0.5205541253,
-0.8672257066,
0.0924253911,
0.2437869757,
0.2381380498,
0.0761237368,
-0.1794499308,
0.9927477837,
0.0690040439,
-0.4877310991,
-0.6651697755,
0.0495181158,
-0.9873722792,
-0.2362044901,
0.9101853371,
-0.0446318053,
-0.0165655091,
0.1836974323,
-0.168066591,
0.0861010551,
-0.4680821896,
0.887383759,
0.2919380963,
-0.2404695451,
-0.1295076758,
-0.6493437886,
0.658774972,
0.5693186522,
0.0331972614,
-0.575913012,
0.1348507851,
-0.1237643138,
0.3871214092,
0.1728245616,
0.0863066167,
0.4385401011,
-0.2600032985,
0.033564873,
-0.3478324115,
-0.2243192196,
-0.3322115839,
-0.0330512673,
0.025823595,
-0.6829857826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06674v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06674v3 | PK-ICR: Persona-Knowledge Interactive Context Retrieval for Grounded Dialogue | 2023-02-13T20:27:26 | 2023-10-19T15:43:06 | Minsik Oh, Joosung Lee, Jiwei Li, Guoyin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Identifying relevant persona or knowledge for conversational systems is
critical to grounded dialogue response generation. However, each grounding has
been mostly researched in isolation with more practical multi-context dialogue
tasks introduced in recent works. We define Persona and Knowledge Dual Context
Identification as the task to identify persona and knowledge jointly for a
given dialogue, which could be of elevated importance in complex multi-context
dialogue settings. We develop a novel grounding retrieval method that utilizes
all contexts of dialogue simultaneously. Our method requires less computational
power via utilizing neural QA retrieval models. We further introduce our novel
null-positive rank test which measures ranking performance on semantically
dissimilar samples (i.e. hard negatives) in relation to data augmentation. | [
-0.4463773668,
-0.7358083129,
0.7051475048,
0.3065504432,
-0.1713562012,
0.2570807338,
0.0430415943,
-0.2129823565,
0.0683852285,
0.442771256,
-0.3258779943,
-0.3805818558,
-0.4277810752,
-0.3078647852,
-0.0290176608,
0.6676620841,
0.2846794426,
0.3871088028,
-0.5827233791,
-0.2259929776,
-0.8091050386,
-0.8296369314,
-0.3598648608,
-0.3820032179,
0.5273338556,
0.5924856663,
0.4262038469,
-0.1075876728,
0.4439438283,
0.2786495984,
-0.157819137,
-0.2976788878,
-0.5341592431,
0.3284035027,
-0.1585307866,
-0.0796384141,
-0.1622537225,
0.1618186086,
0.5787475109,
0.9442870021,
0.3283269405,
-0.0949430093,
-0.1343376786,
0.3605281413,
-0.8235075474,
0.1499149203,
-0.4668820202,
0.2221267521,
0.1469835937,
-0.4732693136,
-0.4620937705,
-0.3221480548,
0.4900980294,
-0.3869519234,
-0.0964106023,
0.0851700529,
0.5435135365,
0.2489837557,
-0.8761405945,
-0.1679426432,
-0.7400233746,
0.6289862394,
-0.4283792973,
0.4201239645,
0.3428236842,
0.364977628,
0.0610458218,
-0.5937488675,
-0.5230618119,
-0.4518053532,
-0.3936548829,
0.2942256033,
0.4605369568,
0.3766125143,
0.3885344863,
0.620431304,
0.0409440398,
-0.4271600246,
-0.089071542,
-0.2711470425,
0.2220696658,
-0.0256627705,
0.484945029,
-0.3281838298,
-0.3671141565,
-0.039313931,
-0.4311030209,
0.3515537977,
0.3651022911,
0.1044653431,
0.2243808359,
0.6949125528,
-0.4156938791,
0.5246191025,
0.4199870825,
-0.5265794396,
0.0662668124,
-0.3243074119,
-0.0587625504,
0.1929669082,
0.414799422,
0.5605985522,
-0.4291158617,
-0.4420553148,
0.052681569,
-0.0326772258,
0.3621972799,
-0.6609188914,
-0.2338530868,
-0.0968408361,
-0.4992076457,
-0.2333444059,
0.2620060146,
-0.8646069765,
-0.5494077206,
-0.6729364991,
0.5956169367,
-0.3399080336,
-0.5024766922,
-0.191214323,
-0.3100043237,
0.6597367525,
0.393132925,
-0.3799456358,
0.2727813721,
0.667185545,
0.3860251606,
-0.0011989198,
-0.1652187407,
-0.5313599706,
-0.1029680148,
-0.2131433785,
0.5238518119,
-0.6188291907,
-0.2604145408,
-0.2287468314,
0.0026637998,
-0.2009129375,
-0.3986903727,
0.7385751009,
-0.6839471459,
0.3345576525,
-0.8239046335,
-0.289847523,
-0.2079489231,
0.3145397604,
-0.1874725521,
0.9733739495,
0.2382333577,
-0.9226266146,
0.6142402291,
-0.2404444665,
-0.420717895,
0.1857269108,
-0.3640980721,
-0.0525961518,
-0.0053330967,
-0.1367344558,
0.4588904977,
-0.281517297,
0.6111991405,
-0.2842098773,
-0.4114026725,
0.1375565231,
-0.0427295938,
0.5490164161,
-0.043196734,
-0.4849078059,
0.0596279576,
-0.7774996161,
0.2659938335,
-0.0749530122,
-0.2144306898,
-0.5780439377,
0.1652065367,
-0.1377035528,
0.5362779498,
0.154362604,
-0.5727002621,
-0.0711217597,
-0.364767164,
0.0579542406,
0.4013463557,
0.2560371161,
0.5273317695,
-0.2545810938,
0.0775829405,
0.257396698,
-0.2460500896,
-0.3714545667,
-0.6038964391,
-0.9930112958,
-0.2627198994,
0.1193745062,
0.7121103406,
-0.5998356342,
0.856246233,
-0.2069909573,
-0.416869849,
-0.3103912771,
-0.3834190071,
0.7101254463,
0.9334952235,
0.311057359,
-0.3910589516,
-0.529170692,
-1.1393948793,
-0.1819101721,
-0.2300924957,
-0.2223840505,
0.9220741987,
0.2200704366,
-0.145465821,
1.1650663614,
-0.4679091275,
-0.0181642938,
-0.0099814972,
0.2811313868,
0.010652042,
0.5794997811,
0.4683847129,
-0.9952991605,
-0.6153670549,
-0.1123335212,
-0.9050797224,
-0.1044903249,
0.0393256508,
-0.2285420299,
-0.4894302189,
0.4591082036,
-0.6679499149,
0.4189862907,
-0.1040946469,
-0.583204627,
0.4252755642,
0.1369647235,
0.7705501318,
-0.8991985917,
0.3663962185,
-0.2930266857,
-0.1763433069,
-0.7626212835,
0.0726986155,
0.0085774707,
-0.3279485404,
-0.3257656097,
0.3900716901,
-0.3651774228,
-0.2151434571,
-0.0530285127,
-0.0463647507,
-0.0347778462,
0.7023129463,
0.0850338265,
1.0290491581,
0.6211858392,
-0.8161382675,
0.2244693041,
0.5240161419,
-0.4003263414,
1.0114812851,
-0.5068428516,
0.6391951442,
-0.4029940963,
0.2587245703,
-1.4494891167,
-0.441157639,
0.3159203827,
-0.3924753964,
0.1546471864,
-0.5241999626,
-0.3031566143,
-0.2121402919,
0.0424234532,
0.7208832502,
0.5038105249,
-0.6262739897,
0.6866770387,
0.6322698593,
-0.2716853321,
-0.4110143185,
0.0204979666,
0.0351177305,
-0.5129011273,
-0.6031973958,
0.5425058603,
-0.2479874045,
-0.5459007621,
-0.5109157562,
-0.3307197094,
-0.1134239659,
0.0546959713,
0.3036982417,
-0.2172861844,
-0.2233295739,
-0.1281224489,
0.103039369,
-0.295569241,
0.1489023715,
-0.0744521022,
0.4518043697,
-0.1003240719,
-0.4631265402,
-0.5718471408,
0.4821924269,
1.0085299015,
-0.0256815944,
0.7054934502,
0.3143523932,
-0.3385920525,
0.6131222248,
-1.0206984282,
-0.173579216,
-0.4020676017,
-0.0559147634,
-0.721546948,
-0.7359281778,
0.6955497861,
-0.4485864937,
-0.388786763,
0.2057563066,
0.3542336822,
0.0188544355,
1.2296446562,
0.5831936002,
-0.1043195948,
0.2130648941,
0.1231187284,
0.6614034772,
-0.9076334238,
-0.5620836616,
-0.5885287523,
-0.2372134626,
-0.1481260955,
-0.1714925021,
0.5544305444,
0.3639503717,
-0.1084644049,
0.003098631,
-0.3945215642,
0.5060799718,
0.6417397261,
0.1735617518,
0.2557489872,
-0.3162208498,
-0.4426161647,
-0.3789971173,
-0.1342610866,
-0.3541320562,
0.8319597244,
0.0919370502,
0.2593513131,
0.2255892158,
0.0806970298,
0.131897673,
0.1473999172,
-0.9265797138,
0.5772204399,
0.3716691434,
-0.3878365159,
0.045126427,
-0.2565679252,
-0.3891588449,
0.5488620996,
-0.058850497,
-0.9962080121,
0.1445045173,
-0.1323419362,
-0.5385961533,
0.0109568778,
-0.8310792446,
0.727925241,
-0.0666094199,
-0.3649535179,
-0.0098324446,
-1.0893727541,
0.5038352609,
0.216240257,
-0.1257435232,
-0.0057576378,
0.3316661417,
0.7121017575,
-0.1044619456,
0.5971537232,
-0.6008814573,
0.1417793036,
0.0062314561,
-0.0670751557,
0.2531271279,
0.5569204688,
0.0191025883,
-0.0493640304,
0.1479739398,
-0.2444768995,
-0.6554992199,
0.7803102732,
-0.8327558637,
-0.5869310498,
-0.4757314026,
-0.2514052987,
-0.5980614424,
0.4137994647,
0.2409119904,
0.343737334,
-0.4325079024,
0.654161036,
1.0047849417,
-0.4041807652,
-0.1858275682,
0.662770927,
0.0978274718,
-0.5782094598,
0.5550125837,
-0.1662913263,
-0.0351927504,
0.6629076004,
0.0963835642,
-0.2703095078,
-0.2949547768,
-0.194573611,
0.0321421549,
-0.6726308465,
-0.130730927,
-1.21372962,
-0.3500967026,
-0.4335884452,
-0.2549662292,
-0.2997855246,
-0.301704824,
-0.0938696489,
-0.2150940746,
-0.1698518097,
0.5030326843,
0.2819468081,
0.3665144742,
-0.352722019,
0.6538071036,
0.5210494995,
0.3902281225,
-0.1295937747,
-0.3190939426,
0.2530673444,
0.0505521372,
-0.367977351,
-1.0369573832,
0.1801937222,
-0.0224447288,
0.7267001271,
0.3809550107,
0.2258985639,
0.7959549427,
-0.5018862486,
0.9289762974,
0.083384715,
-0.8423756957,
0.5687696934,
-0.5487459898,
0.1606010795,
0.9911240339,
0.2819586396,
-0.7509877086,
-0.0547001697,
-0.6487508416,
-1.0069715977,
0.9722776413,
0.2931153774,
0.1807873845,
0.0601781048,
0.5707773566,
0.0799521729,
0.5255715847,
-0.5459635854,
-0.4866373837,
-0.2277355641,
0.0885695368,
-0.0889055356,
-0.6233230829,
-0.4208566248,
-0.7070342302,
0.5046708584,
-0.2697601914,
0.7402338982,
0.3051545024,
-0.1570908129,
-0.1119172424,
0.2253243774,
0.360488534,
0.6446506977,
-0.3929680288,
0.1195249557,
0.0440983251,
-0.256814152,
0.303184092,
0.0098612132,
-0.1347818673,
-0.2292390913,
-0.1901675612,
0.7678901553,
0.8345845938,
-0.48162359,
0.7969663739,
-0.3465110064,
-0.0298347306,
-0.7180427909,
-0.1158644632,
-0.2832345665,
0.0123968171,
0.649838686,
0.2050087601,
0.3600893617,
-0.413264662,
0.4828959107,
0.4590919912,
-0.4202132821,
-0.2839978337,
0.368752867,
0.254714638,
-0.3429154754,
0.7813443542,
-0.1876435876,
-0.6371062994,
0.5890821815,
0.4174348712,
0.7424770594,
-0.1261020601,
0.1851736307,
0.5168921351,
-0.2623538375,
0.1323983371,
0.0372348949,
-0.4793434739,
-0.7224522829,
-0.0600363351,
-0.4247025251,
-0.3982140124,
0.4481177032,
-0.8705212474,
0.2994428277,
-0.4466163218,
0.0557591915,
-0.1045084447,
0.1947519183,
-0.5223915577,
0.2157660425,
-0.1340004355,
0.5045941472,
-0.7514054179,
0.3950441778,
0.733879745,
-0.2060240358,
-0.6926192045,
0.3411078453,
0.1766597927,
-0.2255277336,
0.6789426804,
0.4634573758,
-0.103650026,
0.3657462299,
-0.3129493892,
-1.0438722372,
1.211853385,
0.2115292847,
0.2096866071,
-0.0032164382,
-0.0890021995,
0.4679655135,
-0.3566348255,
0.6739227176,
0.5396299958,
0.4440561235,
0.4832388759,
-0.920353055,
-0.1170612797,
-0.5604240298,
-0.1592442989,
0.099145025,
-0.8431552052,
0.4818062186,
0.4057627916,
-0.1443211436,
0.3272805214,
0.6170589328,
0.2620550692,
0.6246873736,
0.4794384241,
0.6439964175,
0.7124795914,
-0.3334437013,
0.6654086113,
-0.5490370989,
0.1528538764,
0.8050646186,
-0.5189135671,
0.3685671985,
0.4466029406,
0.0677129179,
0.421649009,
0.4052617252,
0.5056267977,
0.8429089189,
-0.1157327592,
-0.5550191998,
-0.4088228643,
-0.2174310982,
-0.6000598073,
0.5018090606,
0.3282545507,
-0.0959729999,
-0.0776113793,
0.1412760764,
-0.1243385673,
-0.0514771938,
0.0455153957,
1.1943368912,
-0.0654654577,
-1.2095775604,
0.2909305394,
0.1425542533,
0.5053412318,
-0.4934713244,
-0.2458563596,
-0.1590948552,
0.0740611106,
0.0689156279,
-0.2852361202,
0.2386337817,
-0.4595878422,
-0.3298296332,
-0.4943149388,
1.0346617699,
-0.257460326,
-0.0902524889,
0.3102422059,
0.5563363433,
0.0462068357,
-0.1992275417,
-0.5357446671,
-0.3138964176,
-0.2545708418,
-0.0674291253,
0.6387516856,
0.3021923304,
0.2029411942,
0.6140169501,
0.5741291642,
-0.5365155935,
-0.0278979447,
0.1036212966,
1.1278362274,
-0.6768632531,
-0.7876291275,
-0.2731966674,
0.6943650842,
-0.3236091137,
-0.204599008,
0.8985200524,
0.5341992974,
0.5737034678,
-0.1086658984,
0.6836619377,
-0.4383603632,
0.6944676638,
-0.378183037,
0.6216137409,
-0.1774741858,
0.0698706806,
-0.6825450063,
-0.8218796849,
-0.0481463298,
0.7466189265,
-0.5412791371,
0.1277584285,
0.7723647356,
0.5933786035,
-0.3949046731,
0.1530025303,
0.4147589207,
0.1588845849,
0.2158281952,
0.3599921465,
1.1788386106,
-0.4761616886,
-0.0552960485,
-0.4133024514,
-0.3570339382,
-0.1852544248,
-0.6490907669,
-1.0474293232,
-0.8256618381,
-0.2447767258,
-0.3223522007,
0.0288569611,
0.7287907004,
0.9941789508,
-0.8146827221,
0.0948231742,
-0.1837109327,
0.1279133111,
-0.1576547921,
-0.3494774997,
0.0057070265,
-0.290107578,
-0.4333351851,
0.84774369,
0.2376043499,
-0.2267267853,
-0.2409707904,
-0.1391837597,
-0.3101668358,
-0.1433401555,
0.6222934723,
0.2221423835,
-0.695153892,
-0.4847794175,
0.032293763,
0.063147977,
0.2149740607,
1.4549601078,
-1.0343146324,
0.3257225454,
0.5367569923,
0.6686336994,
0.2249854952,
0.4590140879,
0.6447085142,
-0.9628693461,
0.3416017294,
0.5679074526,
0.0660961568,
0.3593842983,
-0.7639577985,
0.2384993434,
0.6190288663,
-0.7000129223,
-0.7913533449,
0.264367342,
-1.023781538,
0.1132931858,
1.1281970739,
-0.2132565975,
0.2889386117,
-0.589312315,
-0.5221427083,
0.028851565,
-0.3011715114,
0.6734005809,
0.8156613708,
0.0508029684,
-0.2460612357,
-0.3896834254,
0.5467752814,
0.5003262758,
-0.5756140947,
-0.2594633996,
0.7198028564,
0.3659341037,
0.4337320924,
1.0883373022,
-0.1287833601,
0.1257431507,
-0.2188161314,
-0.3186445832,
0.3520267308,
-0.7267799973,
-0.0572815277,
0.5523714423,
0.0865788162,
0.2969144583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06605v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06605v2 | UniAdapter: Unified Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning for Cross-modal Modeling | 2023-02-13T18:59:10 | 2023-05-21T17:50:30 | Haoyu Lu, Yuqi Huo, Guoxing Yang, Zhiwu Lu, Wei Zhan, Masayoshi Tomizuka, Mingyu Ding | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large-scale vision-language pre-trained models have shown promising
transferability to various downstream tasks. As the size of these foundation
models and the number of downstream tasks grow, the standard full fine-tuning
paradigm becomes unsustainable due to heavy computational and storage costs.
This paper proposes UniAdapter, which unifies unimodal and multimodal adapters
for parameter-efficient cross-modal adaptation on pre-trained vision-language
models. Specifically, adapters are distributed to different modalities and
their interactions, with the total number of tunable parameters reduced by
partial weight sharing. The unified and knowledge-sharing design enables
powerful cross-modal representations that can benefit various downstream tasks,
requiring only 1.0%-2.0% tunable parameters of the pre-trained model. Extensive
experiments on 6 cross-modal downstream benchmarks (including video-text
retrieval, image-text retrieval, VideoQA, and VQA) show that in most cases,
UniAdapter not only outperforms the state-of-the-arts, but even beats the full
fine-tuning strategy. Particularly, on the MSRVTT retrieval task, UniAdapter
achieves 49.7% recall@1 with 2.2% model parameters, outperforming the latest
competitors by 2.0%. The code and models are available at
https://github.com/RERV/UniAdapter. | [
-0.3874899745,
-0.020915797,
0.4199016392,
0.0481256172,
-0.7862072587,
-0.0226017516,
-0.2609856129,
-0.2474700809,
0.0157610402,
0.3393721581,
-0.0460170954,
-0.0261258986,
-0.6870241761,
-0.3640146554,
-0.3171095848,
0.9369091392,
-0.3223970532,
-0.02913725,
-0.033961527,
-0.3274739981,
-0.1605227143,
-0.1734517366,
-0.3781705797,
-0.2665511072,
0.6283602118,
0.1687788218,
0.4829061329,
0.1332853734,
0.4694579244,
0.2976189554,
0.2397008389,
0.0342077687,
-0.3505041003,
0.0391956009,
-0.7320747972,
-0.1691550612,
-0.2303523421,
-0.1371611655,
0.4931902885,
0.6724770665,
-0.2463261485,
0.3850511909,
0.2862675488,
0.6746792197,
-1.100675106,
0.2064767629,
-0.7330822349,
-0.0018082786,
-0.232255891,
-0.6123472452,
-0.2699015141,
0.2100604475,
0.1138012707,
-0.9054785371,
-0.0083443485,
0.0086747259,
0.3181771338,
0.3798308671,
-0.6903756857,
0.1835463047,
-0.6778137088,
0.7370263338,
-0.4141363204,
0.6157179475,
-0.0175084397,
0.4503580034,
-0.1272964329,
-1.1267244816,
-0.4640842676,
0.0066905455,
0.0630075857,
0.2863577902,
-0.6768260598,
0.2570540905,
-0.2928990424,
0.29779616,
-0.4631346762,
-0.1557783186,
-0.63170439,
-0.0628741607,
0.2723630369,
0.0060035917,
0.1338138282,
-0.0018212915,
-0.5899051428,
-0.1063463539,
-0.1840811968,
0.366987139,
-0.1120904535,
-0.0372225568,
-0.1201599762,
0.3670897782,
-0.2761057317,
0.7428862453,
0.3520790935,
0.3278119266,
0.0970696285,
-0.5145135522,
-0.444123596,
-0.3364429176,
0.7585520744,
0.4878321886,
0.2848284543,
-0.2602454424,
-0.1796066314,
0.0161828436,
0.5945871472,
-0.815605402,
-0.590165019,
-0.466324091,
-0.5834344625,
0.0166500248,
0.0701290444,
-0.9266335368,
-0.1691970527,
-0.4761162996,
0.7517492771,
-0.1774822772,
-0.2114209533,
0.193619892,
-0.1610296071,
0.0622877777,
0.5398128033,
-0.8886503577,
0.1844796985,
0.179173559,
0.8263995647,
-0.4290143847,
-0.4761886299,
-0.6207401752,
0.2511603832,
-0.1861724108,
0.7307782769,
-0.8645529151,
-0.1548806131,
-0.3997841477,
0.2309447378,
-0.5316238403,
-0.1955837905,
0.3980065286,
-0.5330533981,
0.0630248412,
-0.0018633406,
-0.350443393,
-0.4964110851,
-0.1312987655,
-0.5629094243,
0.7030420303,
0.2287475169,
-0.7048660517,
0.3413538933,
-0.884729743,
-0.356516391,
0.0020306346,
-0.0529165193,
-0.0642821714,
0.5166081786,
0.3204919696,
0.6022282243,
-0.6242136359,
0.1344261467,
-0.2487882376,
-0.3513631821,
0.0762129426,
-0.8534191251,
0.5466210842,
0.3567656577,
-0.3699320257,
0.4028374851,
-0.7590308785,
-0.1231647357,
-0.2601445019,
-0.6005223393,
-0.4338977337,
-0.4436190128,
0.6187497377,
0.1865635216,
0.0521061756,
-0.598977685,
0.2303269506,
0.4412972927,
0.3916895092,
0.8039724827,
-0.2685830593,
0.7187498212,
-0.2510741353,
0.6621086597,
0.0832670778,
0.5158221722,
0.028347183,
-0.3355317414,
-0.6541829109,
-0.6256332397,
0.2787790895,
0.1506486088,
-0.8882278204,
0.1928481162,
-0.2261318117,
-0.5136647224,
-0.5295237899,
0.3661804497,
0.4916136563,
0.5325062275,
0.3903391063,
-0.7128250599,
-0.4588225186,
-0.463824898,
-0.2938113213,
0.0753083453,
-0.0594818629,
0.0367993079,
0.3759272397,
-0.4395819902,
0.5814064145,
-0.0826825723,
-0.4219283462,
-0.3927268982,
0.1830028594,
-0.0999102145,
0.5480888486,
0.6075257659,
-0.8734527826,
-0.4416003227,
0.2396529168,
-0.6546055675,
0.1143451333,
-0.1064576507,
-0.0563091412,
0.1075299531,
0.4371974468,
-0.5639737248,
0.6019133925,
0.9980201721,
-0.4926832318,
0.2593574524,
-0.7212922573,
0.2862647474,
-1.4376803637,
0.4313224256,
-0.1191888154,
-0.2926651537,
-0.4327264428,
0.0498575866,
0.0481722616,
0.0419865623,
-0.6073705554,
0.5031781197,
-0.6017750502,
-0.0874992236,
-0.1422059536,
-0.3058761656,
-0.0534288287,
0.7943478823,
-0.0984268785,
0.6997604966,
0.9804734588,
-0.6134371161,
0.6471326351,
0.0233661942,
-0.3886618316,
0.589743793,
-0.7845948339,
-0.0868873447,
-0.050599847,
0.2754532993,
-0.9248433113,
0.062354736,
0.2319667637,
-0.2190778553,
0.0771083832,
-0.4946312904,
-0.1399609745,
-0.0019014898,
-0.2961792052,
0.9128181934,
0.5099704266,
-0.8612658381,
1.1612049341,
0.2216220051,
0.078483142,
-0.339347899,
-0.4823236167,
-0.1395059228,
-0.0980957374,
-0.2367467582,
0.2637365758,
-0.2379842103,
0.3969593644,
0.0959067419,
-0.2794005275,
-0.1253057569,
-0.1197241992,
0.4265292287,
0.1996563077,
-0.1370873451,
-0.0234843846,
0.1657844186,
-0.2706465423,
-0.2931445837,
-0.5057139397,
0.393111378,
-0.1629818976,
-0.3635339141,
-0.709613502,
0.1958111972,
1.155456543,
-0.4083981812,
0.4530948699,
0.6818547249,
0.0929749086,
0.0802383944,
-0.2880799472,
0.0474434793,
-0.4620105028,
0.4878314137,
-0.4086485505,
-0.724276185,
0.3792651296,
-0.3664923906,
0.0185090899,
0.0382598601,
0.4184114933,
-0.0103139179,
0.9016170502,
0.7784614563,
-0.1998586208,
0.8188345432,
-0.0733362883,
-0.0485102683,
-1.0655120611,
-0.3582692742,
0.0321482159,
-0.5887566209,
-0.3627068102,
-0.6764721274,
0.3509431481,
0.1264699548,
-0.1556184292,
0.4176959991,
-0.3816959858,
0.5113961697,
0.8420985937,
-0.0175965372,
0.4352389276,
0.2778857052,
-0.1478659064,
0.1552415788,
-0.6637421846,
0.0602416173,
1.4169715643,
-0.0211358033,
1.4144057035,
0.1063894406,
0.0947596133,
0.383885026,
-0.1710021943,
-0.3909781873,
0.3791585565,
-0.5001538992,
-0.357486248,
-0.2001124471,
-0.4309991002,
-0.933434844,
0.6408048868,
-0.2134425938,
-0.6467263699,
0.5260367393,
0.3026606441,
-0.2583999336,
0.7875851989,
-0.3802052438,
0.9380549788,
-0.4472731948,
-0.196965754,
-0.2940197289,
-0.7381483316,
0.0329751633,
-0.2381351143,
-0.2685781121,
0.1456986964,
-0.0284728259,
0.7449904084,
0.0170271564,
0.8692170382,
-0.1122287065,
0.1502684653,
-0.0775252208,
0.1977079213,
0.2159700245,
0.1490928382,
0.3530461192,
0.1951693296,
0.2259161025,
-0.450835228,
-0.8224588633,
0.465258956,
-0.8301895857,
-0.1597360969,
-0.3406722546,
-0.9299840927,
0.0293027516,
0.3227595687,
0.3330825865,
0.7110660672,
-0.0092792725,
0.5881556869,
0.4888822734,
0.1364941001,
0.6738590598,
0.6297664046,
-0.1570769548,
-0.3302123845,
0.9047210813,
-0.4366760254,
0.3349164426,
0.4486722946,
0.0972960666,
-0.1263051778,
-0.3730319142,
-0.6463561654,
-0.056343317,
-0.5224018097,
-0.1759002507,
-0.4326151907,
-0.0391172133,
-0.2875886559,
-0.3754618466,
-0.7830860019,
-0.4419171512,
-0.4164284766,
0.0507400893,
0.39302212,
0.5998023152,
-0.3812842667,
0.3753432333,
-0.6101046205,
0.5765216351,
0.6462732553,
0.4901317358,
-0.0744549111,
-0.9215829968,
0.0682165697,
-0.0188522786,
-0.1745481342,
-0.343169421,
0.3375415802,
0.4888134301,
0.5638715029,
0.6540521383,
0.2414667904,
0.8192567229,
-0.1438686252,
0.4148683846,
0.6160572767,
-0.9826581478,
0.195607394,
-0.0416859612,
0.4733043909,
0.8156431317,
0.4243431389,
-0.5046954751,
0.0007927666,
-0.1385796517,
-0.6635703444,
0.6525889039,
-0.0108285015,
0.2484930456,
0.7140918374,
0.1559208184,
0.2844106555,
0.0348207466,
-0.5627001524,
-0.0816462561,
-0.48749277,
-0.3084546924,
-0.3034172952,
0.0407886505,
-0.0171719342,
-0.8182051778,
0.3612193763,
-0.4752621651,
0.1104485318,
-0.0219915267,
-0.5572283268,
-0.1857776195,
0.3823215961,
0.5785810351,
0.9894657731,
-0.1002702117,
0.5906000733,
0.0388752706,
-0.5159624219,
0.1262260824,
0.3590922356,
-0.0923027322,
-0.1354028881,
0.2104654759,
0.9576002955,
0.6544389129,
-0.7095488906,
0.635052979,
-0.3344295323,
-0.1368729919,
-0.0743781999,
-0.0179287456,
-0.0983089134,
0.6713114977,
0.3647266626,
0.5639246702,
0.230779767,
-0.5566545129,
0.2953262329,
0.4515396655,
-0.6141910553,
-0.7722643614,
0.9374320507,
0.3975389898,
0.1842968315,
0.4831840992,
0.1928311586,
-0.3887782693,
0.0515456013,
0.5503769517,
0.6842214465,
-0.3333445489,
0.3552933335,
-0.229354158,
0.0569924265,
0.0290509947,
0.1463585198,
-0.5453392863,
-0.522126019,
-0.0274282675,
-0.6687688231,
-0.0967120975,
-0.3034662902,
-0.7821916342,
-0.1954101175,
-0.3487939537,
0.0281877276,
-0.1089480147,
-0.3228372931,
-0.7012701035,
-0.007411663,
0.0223870631,
0.7772952318,
-0.6976161003,
1.0234277248,
1.1437910795,
-0.6661394835,
-0.6805437803,
-0.28146106,
-0.1192611381,
-0.8671587706,
0.521445632,
-0.2012045681,
-0.3671337366,
0.0555753447,
-0.1259897798,
-0.8214084506,
1.1912562847,
0.7710679173,
-0.5603764653,
-0.2616796196,
0.1600147933,
0.2706981301,
-0.3462680876,
0.422454834,
0.2617662549,
0.4114874601,
0.3914759159,
-1.2115827799,
0.200063467,
-0.3109351695,
0.2709364891,
0.1630042195,
-0.5383036733,
0.9510828853,
-0.3480892777,
0.0510508195,
0.1307078302,
0.5173510909,
-0.198921591,
0.2563537955,
0.5628605485,
0.5194733739,
0.3951007426,
0.5151485801,
0.8423136473,
-0.2405420691,
0.3641521633,
0.8894665837,
0.0666600391,
0.779314518,
0.9023984671,
0.2629494965,
0.3255576193,
0.1932552308,
0.0895616189,
0.8992496133,
-0.1147009358,
-0.2054147273,
-0.5103049874,
-0.0504468717,
-0.2977263331,
0.6573906541,
-0.2482249141,
-0.4262785614,
-0.4659591317,
0.3495947719,
-0.2375407666,
-0.2472500503,
-0.5261662602,
0.6619256139,
0.1208547726,
-0.474267453,
0.5183992982,
-0.2712932229,
0.9588606954,
-0.5654535294,
-0.0552069917,
-0.4177933931,
0.6835654378,
-0.016530063,
-0.6019290686,
-0.0952719152,
-0.1969721615,
-0.1646805704,
-0.104465045,
0.5008122325,
-0.6367701888,
-0.5737701058,
0.5778335929,
0.2514194548,
-0.0521111265,
-0.3582106829,
-0.6194987893,
0.0121472999,
-0.0753707215,
-0.2874262631,
0.467590332,
0.4077747166,
-0.0962458998,
0.7242303491,
0.7220789194,
0.0576430112,
0.4893817008,
0.0046727075,
1.0533838272,
-0.5250017643,
-0.3125959933,
-0.3135986328,
0.5163674951,
0.224735558,
-0.5955766439,
0.5129479766,
0.4276683033,
1.0618423223,
-0.2438754588,
0.5416876078,
-0.059208706,
-0.0222491361,
-0.4822912812,
0.9408286214,
-0.98238343,
-0.0815762579,
-0.3398498297,
-1.002197504,
-0.3038295507,
0.4356588423,
0.1996788085,
0.1023125947,
0.4830687344,
0.6327179074,
-0.8521981835,
-0.1831390858,
0.6575241089,
-0.1953615993,
0.1214929521,
0.9074594378,
0.6677758694,
-0.5649418831,
0.7926300764,
-0.2797558904,
-0.2412742376,
-0.2737151384,
-0.5369564891,
-0.9518000484,
-0.9070081711,
-0.1087281853,
0.4307913482,
0.372251302,
0.7707632184,
1.0399399996,
-0.7244141698,
-0.2402336746,
-0.1359601617,
-0.319786191,
-0.2639758885,
-0.0961495191,
0.2586223781,
-0.1544513553,
-0.5515599847,
0.2649259865,
0.2661448121,
-0.2335568368,
0.0408005863,
-0.3726122975,
-0.135773167,
0.0863030925,
0.6043496728,
0.5866716504,
-0.7456775308,
-0.2809813619,
-0.3361862898,
0.1870158613,
-0.1328087747,
1.1879415512,
-0.8532833457,
0.5495944023,
0.4339397252,
0.9205556512,
0.5271024108,
-0.0199616514,
0.6423563957,
-0.4331788421,
0.1611030549,
-0.1494283825,
0.6810504794,
0.0688547865,
0.0377068296,
0.2934644818,
0.2519584894,
-0.4462255538,
-0.4429357648,
-0.0206678323,
-1.3780765533,
-0.4684412777,
0.8639160991,
-0.1414935142,
-0.1169809699,
-0.0566822812,
-0.2351321578,
0.4050697684,
-0.4622350633,
0.7882336974,
-0.1945401579,
-0.1025643051,
-0.7397285104,
-0.0906278417,
0.2411511391,
0.5684034824,
-0.7259478569,
0.1076194495,
0.3003363311,
0.5902131796,
-0.0864334553,
0.458723098,
-0.0408609696,
0.6080613136,
-0.3266507685,
0.2724884748,
-0.4513829052,
-0.624778688,
-0.4937849939,
0.0149472533,
-0.1359934062,
-0.516931355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06600v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06600v2 | Task-Specific Skill Localization in Fine-tuned Language Models | 2023-02-13T18:55:52 | 2023-07-02T01:55:00 | Abhishek Panigrahi, Nikunj Saunshi, Haoyu Zhao, Sanjeev Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models can be fine-tuned to solve diverse NLP tasks,
including in few-shot settings. Thus fine-tuning allows the model to quickly
pick up task-specific ``skills,'' but there has been limited study of where
these newly-learnt skills reside inside the massive model. This paper
introduces the term skill localization for this problem and proposes a
solution. Given the downstream task and a model fine-tuned on that task, a
simple optimization is used to identify a very small subset of parameters
($\sim0.01$% of model parameters) responsible for ($>95$%) of the model's
performance, in the sense that grafting the fine-tuned values for just this
tiny subset onto the pre-trained model gives performance almost as well as the
fine-tuned model. While reminiscent of recent works on parameter-efficient
fine-tuning, the novel aspects here are that: (i) No further re-training is
needed on the subset (unlike, say, with lottery tickets). (ii) Notable
improvements are seen over vanilla fine-tuning with respect to calibration of
predictions in-distribution ($40$-$90$% error reduction) as well as the quality
of predictions out-of-distribution (OOD). In models trained on multiple tasks,
a stronger notion of skill localization is observed, where the sparse regions
corresponding to different tasks are almost disjoint, and their overlap (when
it happens) is a proxy for task similarity. Experiments suggest that
localization via grafting can assist certain forms of continual learning. | [
-0.2458412647,
-0.777859509,
0.3780359328,
0.1503298134,
-0.1592579186,
-0.1747673452,
-0.5083139539,
-0.507437706,
0.1616993099,
0.6017064452,
-0.5328329802,
-0.3658191562,
-0.5651513934,
-0.0287427232,
-0.2205879688,
0.9700954556,
0.1876483709,
-0.034402132,
-0.13142699,
-0.0556932986,
-0.5776946545,
-0.5529977679,
-0.7820734382,
-0.2658477128,
0.6953690052,
0.4619951248,
0.6228942275,
0.8763088584,
0.6531313062,
0.2815072238,
-0.1138570011,
0.2034822255,
-0.4788236022,
-0.0656702816,
-0.2143472135,
-0.8061050773,
-0.4393951297,
-0.0508920886,
0.7867643833,
1.0268337727,
0.1592914313,
0.1938740462,
0.2526204288,
0.3321424425,
-0.6344197989,
0.0560811013,
-0.912443459,
-0.033140488,
-0.4142578244,
-0.3614809811,
-0.1745881736,
-0.0584373474,
0.1725154966,
-0.6695721745,
0.7354883552,
-0.3156023324,
0.8866013288,
0.5068979263,
-0.1735191941,
0.2135973424,
-1.0189212561,
1.0119463205,
-0.8866340518,
0.0715654716,
0.556245327,
0.2629353702,
-0.1027894467,
-0.4953112602,
-0.162221089,
-0.1269269139,
-0.1103928685,
-0.0629005358,
0.1824161559,
0.1016565263,
0.3813372254,
0.2138646841,
-0.2131362855,
0.3855250776,
-0.3038297892,
-0.0921905339,
0.6676226854,
0.0965402424,
0.1643566936,
0.2675099969,
0.1460427642,
0.1356559843,
-0.5870500207,
0.2119282782,
0.3879388869,
0.8341885209,
0.0759649798,
0.4291008413,
-0.7878724933,
1.2233433723,
0.2382823825,
-0.4561202228,
0.1489647925,
-0.4962704778,
0.073670581,
-0.2197827399,
0.3962054849,
-0.1522199661,
0.479962796,
-0.2001741827,
-0.4155782163,
-0.1693454832,
0.3137097657,
-0.5696058869,
-0.2379453331,
-0.0030490204,
-0.4844398201,
-0.4227967262,
-0.3826963603,
0.0779316574,
-0.1999165267,
-0.5120436549,
0.4758002758,
-0.0630065948,
-0.1673252434,
0.2126642168,
0.2179303467,
0.1140678152,
0.1618186235,
-1.2880086899,
0.1238097474,
0.7352469563,
0.8555631638,
-0.1676647067,
-0.5404259562,
-0.789775908,
-0.0220656842,
-0.3090301454,
0.9611892104,
-0.6756322384,
0.1301244348,
0.006508809,
0.0997452736,
-0.2109316289,
-0.6139057875,
0.2756833434,
-0.3452217877,
-0.1561269015,
-0.3909205496,
-0.3492121696,
-0.0525430106,
0.1263717562,
-0.4707887471,
1.0224493742,
0.0678385496,
-0.5573561192,
0.6083332896,
-0.4573259056,
-0.6594378352,
0.0812459439,
0.266307503,
-0.2535749376,
0.3815125525,
0.0793244913,
0.8074824214,
-0.0830405653,
0.1262224168,
-0.5008043647,
-0.5506933331,
-0.1225146726,
-0.1860517561,
0.4931317568,
0.0251167025,
-0.1834196895,
0.1952417344,
-0.6788275838,
0.1687529683,
-0.1231233701,
-0.2671704292,
-0.3663348258,
-0.0162214227,
0.0192112755,
0.1918235868,
0.4037032425,
-0.3695432544,
0.3106128573,
-0.8574586511,
0.3188134134,
0.3578329384,
-0.1299363673,
0.84762609,
-0.2082690448,
0.5772045255,
-0.1099435911,
0.2392083257,
-0.0206960067,
-0.4399164319,
-0.5764760971,
-0.2577300668,
0.4410438836,
0.5653114915,
-0.3694570065,
0.2856762409,
-0.0414361022,
-0.6347674131,
-0.5547199249,
0.2724989653,
0.4277509749,
0.5024029016,
0.3322541416,
-0.4505475163,
-0.1570168138,
-0.9169393778,
-0.2709783912,
0.3905084729,
-0.0051656594,
0.0957366303,
0.4908432662,
0.0624213852,
0.9331684709,
-0.5609755516,
-0.7439702749,
-0.1580401808,
0.1888353676,
0.1882445067,
0.7461687326,
0.6553376317,
-0.6673167944,
-0.6972055435,
0.3666243851,
-0.4336146414,
-0.1706367433,
-0.2369102836,
0.0438348912,
0.0743751079,
0.6049669385,
-0.4085579515,
0.3058281839,
0.4769802988,
-0.0843559057,
0.5725625753,
-0.6222673655,
-0.1279760003,
-0.9028917551,
0.1834862083,
-0.0660179928,
-0.3035099208,
-0.7476788759,
0.1835618466,
-0.2123219073,
0.0196561087,
-0.3292791843,
0.744320631,
-0.5621488094,
-0.1272683144,
-0.527890861,
0.3049584627,
-0.416513443,
0.5334270597,
0.3295402825,
0.5005250573,
0.8021631241,
-0.4819631875,
0.2764524519,
0.1383685172,
-0.3555490673,
0.6210218072,
-0.6843166947,
0.0857342705,
0.0010803289,
-0.0646073073,
-0.6937633753,
-0.1671527773,
-0.1537096053,
-0.2600933611,
0.3376645148,
-0.5364887714,
-0.377677083,
-0.0652428642,
0.1902135909,
0.5330843329,
0.3199459016,
-0.1552826911,
0.4289849699,
0.3789629936,
-0.2399891615,
-0.7080996037,
-0.3118338585,
-0.3249148428,
-0.0507857129,
-0.4525711238,
0.4163057208,
0.0547757782,
0.1686257273,
-0.0586318076,
-0.1343426108,
-0.3599198461,
0.3898645639,
0.1174996793,
-0.1074274331,
-0.271407783,
0.1042122841,
0.2293566465,
-0.3702319264,
-0.3575823903,
-0.4710274339,
0.3574585915,
-0.0542767495,
-0.3721434474,
-0.2571803331,
0.1923665106,
0.2777069509,
-0.694414556,
0.9053969383,
0.8611624837,
-0.5507159829,
-0.3029327095,
-0.6801199317,
-0.5188125968,
-0.4525118768,
0.6789312363,
-0.6063817143,
-0.8945179582,
0.7314409018,
-0.0478415415,
0.0005116491,
0.2698831856,
0.351325959,
-0.2985260189,
1.3219225407,
1.01171875,
-0.2016516775,
0.6755060554,
-0.2736750245,
0.2592012882,
-0.7011186481,
-0.0050745932,
-0.692340374,
-0.5509663224,
-0.4542910159,
-0.4441539943,
0.0427842103,
0.4535852671,
-0.0050442102,
0.3501882255,
-0.4926808774,
0.7431854606,
0.8372328281,
-0.0287112389,
0.0968097746,
-0.1012829766,
0.0505408011,
-0.1153965741,
-1.1291414499,
-0.2855249047,
1.0279628038,
0.1405184269,
0.3046640456,
-0.3834184706,
0.799998939,
0.0275691357,
0.1866663843,
-0.6725440025,
0.4764141142,
-0.5397874713,
-0.4657788277,
-0.5460441709,
-0.3479279578,
-1.0739568472,
0.0412332825,
-0.569339931,
-0.8015861511,
0.1543466449,
0.5036604404,
-0.6122677922,
0.3672411144,
-0.5762523413,
1.2257856131,
-0.0150479395,
-0.2418091148,
-0.4300136566,
-0.5814574957,
-0.0930788666,
-0.3610486388,
-0.0154259605,
-0.322617054,
0.1824190915,
0.4696078002,
-0.1243708432,
0.9458243251,
-0.3782128692,
-0.1110483557,
-0.0540344268,
0.0805035233,
0.7122210264,
-0.2372283041,
0.1171872467,
-0.0107577657,
0.2890356481,
-0.6145215034,
-0.6608792543,
0.8603732586,
-0.4012138546,
-0.5484198332,
0.0454676338,
-0.875412941,
-0.277210027,
0.424095273,
0.1869980097,
0.5969445109,
0.0735222623,
0.2573128939,
0.7111810446,
-0.0783198923,
0.2302001417,
0.5397891998,
0.1204404905,
0.2212751359,
1.1525043249,
0.2985503376,
0.3117556572,
0.4569525421,
0.0693680197,
-0.0833639279,
-0.8057166934,
0.0876070336,
0.4599057138,
-0.540723145,
-0.1456203461,
-0.2968369424,
-0.1083213761,
-0.1317608207,
-0.5250111222,
-0.6847100854,
-0.3647990823,
-0.5439968705,
0.0897103697,
0.0655633137,
0.5516424775,
-0.1049369425,
0.44023031,
-0.7221435308,
0.2631397843,
0.2184005678,
0.5584796667,
-0.0767612159,
-0.7417826653,
-0.7040722966,
0.1515183002,
0.0460525602,
-0.541719377,
0.3467099369,
0.3114229739,
0.4792594612,
0.302821815,
-0.0893888772,
0.8427942991,
-0.4331205189,
0.5200408101,
-0.1550346315,
-0.7113723755,
0.5681965947,
-0.5859161615,
0.6167884469,
0.5783175826,
0.1968178153,
-0.4555382133,
-0.7512553334,
-0.4237712026,
-0.6743416786,
0.794713676,
-0.0819917247,
0.383702457,
0.0340696536,
0.6914865375,
0.022561403,
0.0203734506,
-0.4677657783,
-0.2531032264,
0.2676629424,
-0.0177644491,
-0.2675883472,
-0.2250379771,
-0.0761684179,
-0.396340698,
0.6200623512,
-0.4578028321,
0.0227910168,
-0.1070461273,
-0.1359979212,
-0.1326068491,
-0.0311463624,
0.6722877026,
0.7626203299,
-0.1592674404,
-0.226456061,
0.3247858286,
-0.3097856641,
-0.1162634715,
0.1522393674,
-0.3838760555,
-0.160649702,
0.4361379445,
0.7307039499,
0.4011745751,
-0.2990920842,
0.4125930667,
0.3929822743,
-0.0732294247,
-0.1157253757,
0.2317143232,
-0.0641933605,
0.4818180501,
0.2656451464,
0.5946956277,
0.0234843083,
-0.2809524238,
0.0710662603,
0.7387297153,
-0.5788814425,
-0.535446167,
0.8326137662,
0.3517126739,
-0.3794412911,
0.4840014279,
-0.2610127926,
-0.3894332945,
0.6369487047,
0.6093438864,
0.7334739566,
-0.1127732247,
0.2894286811,
0.5543887615,
0.3175914288,
-0.4036436975,
0.1156431064,
-0.1607789546,
-0.9246341586,
-0.8111779094,
-0.5267233253,
-0.0512601882,
-0.0338167585,
-0.5862420797,
0.1604897827,
-0.1777288169,
-0.3355431259,
-0.0491400808,
0.0251717009,
-0.9123660326,
0.3630877137,
0.1450559497,
0.7010327578,
-0.9348401427,
1.0338749886,
0.7641014457,
-0.2167811245,
-0.7815751433,
-0.1024523526,
-0.3808909953,
-0.4578258097,
0.7574760318,
-0.1233301461,
-0.0145804174,
0.2636550665,
-0.2816841006,
-1.0398774147,
0.9095570445,
0.6817686558,
-0.5971577764,
-0.1099489033,
0.1533875018,
0.6697922945,
-0.2894135416,
0.138469547,
0.7052809,
0.1728958786,
-0.4173696041,
-1.52823174,
-0.1597578973,
-0.0515581667,
0.1579602361,
0.2415101379,
-0.499078393,
0.5498160124,
-0.3678576946,
0.1366921961,
0.0013850906,
0.4671474397,
-0.1138040721,
-0.0595611781,
0.3020585477,
0.3707888722,
0.7784827352,
-0.2281003296,
1.0432556868,
-0.2651169002,
0.4547321796,
1.1580305099,
0.0807414353,
0.9866668582,
0.3711965382,
-0.0116289034,
0.1313607246,
0.4990503788,
0.0606963634,
0.6470462084,
0.0707254633,
-0.1244067475,
-0.5245763659,
-0.2083032578,
-0.2244925946,
0.5362459421,
-0.1219347492,
-0.1199138239,
-0.0091266427,
0.2382719219,
-0.2094901949,
0.0844554231,
-0.5702755451,
0.6817970276,
-0.0510797016,
-0.6407705545,
0.519572854,
0.0029427747,
0.7071347237,
-0.8845153451,
0.004229473,
-0.2537038326,
0.2262336314,
-0.2747088373,
-0.5686133504,
0.5284340978,
-0.3651806116,
-0.4261156619,
-0.4625611901,
0.8514025807,
-0.5699299574,
-0.3219637573,
0.1633259505,
0.3618202507,
0.0063617355,
-0.4624767601,
-0.5681900978,
-0.3263497651,
-0.0253142975,
-0.2138427794,
0.5339586735,
0.4238771498,
-0.1048799455,
0.8456338644,
0.722984612,
0.512073338,
0.0237976909,
0.1377732307,
0.4080082476,
-0.4091581702,
-0.4659640193,
-0.377038151,
0.5404074788,
0.1494272947,
-0.5631289482,
0.5661719441,
0.2874462306,
1.223523736,
-0.4356598556,
0.4038539231,
0.1097595021,
0.3793126941,
-0.310328275,
0.7856431007,
-0.7830763459,
0.1069484651,
-0.3019330204,
-1.1088562012,
-0.529515326,
0.7827074528,
-0.6317131519,
0.0884237066,
0.5034572482,
0.87970227,
-0.2501990795,
-0.6202439666,
0.606559515,
-0.018349519,
-0.1922062933,
0.4029702544,
0.3391697705,
-0.2314658761,
0.4207631946,
-0.62172997,
-0.0527149439,
-0.1702147573,
-0.774094522,
-0.7695116401,
-0.9620128274,
-0.5226526856,
0.1526694894,
-0.164093554,
0.5402349234,
1.1326183081,
-0.8123166561,
-0.1953354776,
0.131191805,
0.0142952558,
-0.7279031873,
-0.1854793131,
0.1654980183,
-0.6595314145,
-0.8031810522,
0.3350997269,
0.1607557088,
-0.1678578854,
-0.0182677023,
0.1231331974,
-0.0269816667,
0.0370672643,
0.5847945213,
0.4418315291,
-0.6916378736,
-0.4541645944,
0.0486839153,
-0.0130614117,
-0.175252229,
0.7461664677,
-0.7046454549,
0.6441185474,
0.3384668827,
0.583981514,
0.5836652517,
-0.1120094508,
0.7123069763,
-1.099198103,
0.4454115629,
0.2527605593,
0.2327629626,
0.1542005986,
-0.3435716033,
0.4535916746,
0.1122944281,
-0.5592877865,
-0.9316759706,
0.2782980204,
-0.8281327486,
-0.0157730095,
0.9193749428,
-0.1922177523,
0.1425138265,
-0.0892296284,
-0.2433389127,
0.2841856778,
0.1529807895,
0.8522333503,
0.5932227969,
0.0908946916,
-0.046253819,
-0.596254468,
0.7891826034,
0.8585402369,
-0.7602594495,
-0.0384018049,
0.2496128678,
0.4674377441,
0.0928283855,
0.6863888502,
0.2442907989,
0.3779470921,
-0.1781695783,
-0.0379004516,
-0.1428017914,
-0.4767411351,
-0.388687104,
0.1364300102,
0.2874341011,
-0.1886216551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06598v1 | Gradient-Based Automated Iterative Recovery for Parameter-Efficient Tuning | 2023-02-13T18:54:58 | 2023-02-13T18:54:58 | Maximilian Mozes, Tolga Bolukbasi, Ann Yuan, Frederick Liu, Nithum Thain, Lucas Dixon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained large language models (LLMs) are able to solve a wide variety of
tasks through transfer learning. Various explainability methods have been
developed to investigate their decision making process. TracIn (Pruthi et al.,
2020) is one such gradient-based method which explains model inferences based
on the influence of training examples. In this paper, we explore the use of
TracIn to improve model performance in the parameter-efficient tuning (PET)
setting. We develop conversational safety classifiers via the prompt-tuning PET
method and show how the unique characteristics of the PET regime enable TracIn
to identify the cause for certain misclassifications by LLMs. We develop a new
methodology for using gradient-based explainability techniques to improve model
performance, G-BAIR: gradient-based automated iterative recovery. We show that
G-BAIR can recover LLM performance on benchmarks after manually corrupting
training labels. This suggests that influence methods like TracIn can be used
to automatically perform data cleaning, and introduces the potential for
interactive debugging and relabeling for PET-based transfer learning methods. | [
-0.1918597817,
-0.6247370243,
0.2902782559,
-0.1783785522,
-0.273892343,
0.1443234682,
-0.4478593469,
-0.3220458925,
-0.0009837787,
0.4268000722,
-0.2987078428,
-0.443364799,
-0.5723201632,
-0.2315770537,
-0.4515194297,
1.2246208191,
0.0389882848,
0.0655445755,
0.2685808539,
-0.0372202247,
-0.1610809267,
-0.3015279472,
-1.3851824999,
-0.2629042268,
0.6201128364,
0.2806229591,
0.5712152719,
0.9515248537,
0.479005754,
0.3521665633,
0.0274654385,
0.2172716707,
-0.519061923,
-0.1222186834,
0.0312891454,
-0.2183811665,
-0.4514331222,
-0.0269194227,
0.5806013346,
0.5764501095,
-0.595030427,
-0.1811783612,
0.1296709329,
0.4482251406,
-0.705314815,
0.1051756367,
-0.6213958263,
-0.0912709162,
0.2099880874,
-0.4521611035,
-0.3947942257,
-0.5923137069,
0.0448815636,
-0.8866888285,
0.5629178286,
0.0162928309,
0.866492033,
0.1764995009,
-0.2512225807,
-0.3823592961,
-0.8302432895,
0.7884737849,
-0.8385624886,
0.2143189758,
0.4830679297,
0.4699574709,
-0.2449856699,
-0.9173267484,
-0.4473959804,
-0.6035470366,
-0.3396806121,
-0.1268301159,
0.0719630346,
0.3211133182,
0.3851717114,
0.289709866,
-0.4059068561,
0.2395093292,
-0.3452573419,
-0.4524973035,
0.4800048769,
0.1342132539,
0.2315790653,
0.1047114134,
-0.0209346656,
-0.3616815507,
-0.3103687465,
0.1304096729,
0.1222922727,
0.3279420435,
0.1416149437,
-0.071610488,
-0.0409628451,
0.7466195822,
0.1079818755,
-0.1979095936,
0.2109188288,
-0.2236851156,
-0.2020048052,
-0.0133174099,
0.6941549778,
0.223854363,
0.4621155858,
-0.0380602777,
-0.2596098483,
-0.1430107802,
0.3423225284,
-0.6639890671,
-0.489923358,
0.0121361678,
-0.4859002531,
-0.3101952374,
-0.1316676885,
-0.6850317121,
-0.3865308762,
-0.2386072874,
0.4288941026,
-0.4202746153,
-0.1733345985,
0.2852374911,
-0.0426779985,
0.4826894999,
0.5137773156,
-0.874257803,
0.2949798107,
0.6556404233,
0.9551568031,
-0.1930830628,
-0.0516767539,
-0.9829163551,
0.1725214422,
-0.1701696515,
0.5692128539,
-0.6118940711,
-0.4715313911,
-0.1084747463,
0.2330341786,
-0.2788078785,
-0.5626644492,
0.5557386875,
-0.4394344091,
0.1251457781,
-0.3462158442,
-0.3435565829,
-0.2655287087,
0.1919527054,
-0.8055039644,
0.8893489242,
-0.1006640047,
-0.5825694799,
0.2184229344,
-0.5871423483,
-0.4845208526,
-0.11954429,
0.2475793809,
-0.6317396164,
0.0635077059,
0.2040557861,
0.1670321822,
-0.201023981,
0.3877887726,
-0.3000672162,
-0.343942523,
-0.0523422174,
-0.264475584,
0.7210550308,
0.0907566994,
-0.2083660215,
0.2314716876,
-1.1181101799,
0.246347338,
-0.2951990366,
-0.3475478292,
-0.2865724862,
-0.0866404101,
-0.20768103,
0.3020258546,
-0.090013124,
-0.2925424874,
-0.1779729277,
-0.1909747869,
0.6335774064,
0.8759580851,
0.0485594869,
0.2573545575,
-0.5434531569,
0.551111877,
0.0554334261,
0.0502706096,
0.1088905036,
0.0516747311,
-1.1894659996,
-0.3934791982,
0.3687328398,
0.4508007765,
-0.6493359208,
0.3428617716,
-0.0123037938,
-0.2792503834,
-0.4842174053,
0.0418538116,
0.3243800402,
1.1161590815,
0.2576462626,
-0.4190954268,
-0.4091767371,
-0.9203796983,
-0.479986757,
-0.2304263413,
-0.0860846639,
0.3070313036,
0.4023204744,
-0.0217745621,
0.3915109336,
-0.1601857692,
0.0349033959,
-0.1250234544,
0.3550926447,
0.0060449466,
0.7172042131,
0.3257063329,
-0.2994220555,
-0.5378438234,
0.1015716121,
-0.4902277589,
-0.1518183053,
-0.1883358955,
-0.3659241498,
-0.0272980388,
0.4724915326,
-0.4773718417,
0.386579752,
0.0541107617,
0.1071119606,
0.4553582072,
-0.4629670978,
0.235057041,
-0.7548222542,
0.4484082162,
0.2735162973,
-0.5542469025,
-0.9408823848,
-0.3238962293,
0.0241928231,
0.0608578511,
-0.3052409887,
0.5310091972,
-0.3392499983,
0.1516323686,
-0.4669177234,
0.288607955,
-0.0098944791,
0.4593360126,
0.0462465771,
0.7700684667,
0.746417582,
-0.933542192,
0.1115773618,
0.2371762544,
-0.1222127229,
0.3953197002,
-0.887922287,
0.2939996123,
-0.4462728798,
0.2156966776,
-0.9142488241,
-0.1210760251,
0.4910501838,
-0.0774729326,
0.3172985613,
-0.0209722873,
-0.1611181796,
-0.1730161458,
-0.3676250279,
0.0121725332,
0.4375753701,
-0.6651667953,
0.7714642286,
0.0730088502,
-0.1471114308,
-0.5710099339,
-0.1935150325,
-0.0641286746,
-0.5658205152,
-0.3013493419,
0.1175138801,
-0.0942851529,
-0.2803373337,
-0.4826485217,
-0.1946201026,
-0.2699055672,
0.2832422256,
0.0018615588,
0.0959462225,
0.1187184677,
0.3666515052,
-0.1500249952,
-0.2531410456,
-0.0432607792,
-0.1352313757,
0.2590276301,
-0.189478755,
0.1590322852,
-0.6172160506,
0.1108653545,
0.3280123472,
-0.3026808798,
0.6110617518,
0.5933020115,
-0.1054015532,
-0.3943205774,
-0.5407765508,
-0.4724927545,
-0.522370398,
0.3294429481,
-0.2106956691,
-0.5614904165,
0.7180339098,
-0.2655808628,
-0.0529066548,
0.2835970819,
0.374402374,
-0.2251111865,
0.9510023594,
0.8954929113,
-0.2312061787,
0.8981862664,
-0.174343124,
-0.0684692413,
-0.4497657716,
-0.2172751129,
-0.6960099339,
-0.3180040717,
-0.6059933305,
0.0262252092,
0.3664134443,
-0.1715859175,
-0.2824915349,
0.1080658734,
-0.1539127529,
0.5273523331,
0.6227573156,
0.4146496952,
0.4742068648,
0.2374999672,
0.0333462991,
0.2494309098,
-0.5269623995,
-0.4053164721,
0.8073081374,
0.2415771186,
0.8081272244,
-0.2303157598,
0.3179905117,
0.239140898,
0.3672351837,
-0.7474558353,
0.509983778,
-0.2417751253,
-0.2995148301,
-0.2042499334,
-0.5133264661,
-0.9297217131,
0.23487854,
0.0038811273,
-0.9422807693,
0.146174714,
0.5714406371,
-0.2098888904,
0.0960387439,
-0.4562410712,
0.5894033313,
-0.3449701965,
-0.4573809803,
-0.444093883,
-0.9202048182,
0.3085795343,
-0.1681571305,
-0.0686148927,
0.1015462428,
0.1763855517,
0.8181513548,
-0.7702403665,
0.7173110247,
-0.4106038213,
-0.3050886095,
-0.0345171802,
0.0621839501,
0.7416286469,
-0.1014387682,
-0.3725894094,
-0.0362503193,
-0.1120657325,
-0.2630464137,
-1.0559563637,
0.6022469401,
-0.6602956653,
-0.6528356671,
-0.0899666771,
-0.6286914945,
-0.4971945584,
0.0640330911,
0.1870073676,
0.3647590876,
0.0615995303,
0.1078003645,
0.7841715217,
-0.2333301604,
0.8153632283,
0.9274827838,
0.1812025607,
-0.3547540605,
0.7884927988,
-0.1983308941,
0.2174963504,
0.263158083,
0.1976636648,
-0.1352630556,
-0.3821158707,
-0.198359549,
0.3809790909,
-0.6968669295,
0.0615350083,
-0.4554691315,
-0.2181522399,
0.2506247461,
-0.0123481909,
-0.2242348045,
-0.5805377364,
-0.4041934609,
-0.2100863308,
0.2304947376,
0.4090309441,
-0.218423456,
0.9026677012,
-0.6414058805,
0.2103025913,
0.0332450084,
0.4433099031,
0.0842163339,
-0.7149766684,
-0.3721144497,
0.0863410383,
-0.1462793946,
-0.6149247289,
0.494789958,
0.6970831156,
0.6893091202,
0.2759902477,
-0.1501467675,
0.6680439711,
-0.2233711928,
0.3754429817,
-0.0214494579,
-1.0147125721,
0.6674284339,
-0.158074826,
-0.0728006735,
0.6910361648,
0.4911499619,
-0.3082400858,
-0.2786047757,
-0.384465903,
-0.7348301411,
0.6640359759,
0.1039941907,
-0.20972085,
0.3013509214,
0.8069669604,
0.3801510036,
0.2972018123,
-0.6094807386,
-0.153200075,
-0.0980510861,
-0.2826242745,
-0.3835194707,
0.0682658628,
-0.2401708364,
-0.4271411002,
0.8803569674,
-0.3439011276,
0.0693263039,
-0.0214686505,
-0.4285724461,
-0.0978574529,
0.1083120406,
0.5957489014,
0.7238689661,
-0.1832273006,
0.0503922701,
0.0169185884,
-0.4403345585,
0.4339315295,
0.0854003876,
-0.1345423758,
-0.0553389043,
0.1883492321,
1.0169448853,
-0.2637124956,
-0.5386934876,
0.238651976,
-0.3986215293,
-0.185126707,
-0.0527072735,
0.44615376,
-0.4778344631,
0.0615433082,
0.0813174397,
-0.0685279891,
0.1972080171,
-0.2667447329,
0.2672810853,
0.61808002,
-0.3518808484,
-0.3337663114,
0.5580823421,
0.126842618,
-0.3009222746,
0.7017321587,
0.3011812866,
-0.2076976299,
0.6739022732,
0.5041874647,
0.9671916962,
-0.2353173345,
0.467056185,
0.5222357512,
0.0860869661,
-0.2985303104,
0.3607640564,
-0.238959536,
-0.6413958669,
-0.3542978168,
-0.3030141294,
-0.3200166821,
0.2957859337,
-0.8299634457,
0.0837146491,
-0.6955857873,
-0.1882577389,
0.0860946104,
-0.1446351111,
-0.4376057386,
0.4195934534,
-0.2645706534,
0.826879859,
-0.7527331114,
0.7832670212,
0.5745718479,
-0.2529914379,
-0.8656279445,
0.2598017752,
-0.1339000165,
-0.8550707698,
0.599622488,
0.039879825,
-0.3386604786,
0.1591404229,
-0.7484509945,
-0.7833442688,
0.8977671266,
0.6827066541,
-0.9307860136,
-0.0008529883,
-0.0333652757,
0.7869246602,
-0.0463320762,
0.5270838737,
0.8616743684,
0.4927945435,
0.1026339233,
-1.0220777988,
0.1658979654,
-0.3143110275,
0.0501805097,
0.1279598325,
-0.7548766136,
0.469237715,
-0.2471919954,
-0.0434110686,
0.0525995083,
0.2918274403,
0.0916405097,
0.0623724684,
0.658203721,
0.4855861664,
1.2295188904,
0.0626223162,
0.9463566542,
-0.4657659531,
0.3434081972,
1.0137872696,
-0.0013384079,
0.5351340175,
0.354403466,
0.1312751621,
0.6457666755,
0.645124197,
0.0688863918,
0.7672016621,
0.4207542241,
-0.3200795352,
-0.3929278553,
-0.0600358583,
-0.1851918101,
0.51122123,
0.2929020524,
-0.6323087811,
-0.2835870087,
0.2043382972,
-0.0396650583,
-0.4517340362,
-0.500274837,
0.9412136078,
0.0716964751,
-0.6489885449,
0.9110789299,
-0.1619013399,
0.1075028479,
-0.5412338376,
0.0014535763,
-0.3652727604,
0.3250115812,
-0.0769148618,
-0.1610550433,
0.0415694825,
-0.3902025223,
-0.0866350979,
-0.0154828792,
0.8654233217,
-0.5360745788,
-0.2050640434,
0.1242191419,
0.449449867,
0.1003209054,
0.2844899595,
-0.553399384,
-0.0654309988,
0.0785032064,
-0.1993432045,
0.2332937419,
0.0995315984,
-0.1825322211,
1.1469702721,
0.1848399043,
0.1369576305,
-0.1814786792,
0.2229013741,
0.9574139118,
-0.73266536,
-0.3943986595,
-0.8451031446,
0.6352880001,
0.0080503123,
-0.0263156127,
0.5718909502,
0.247707814,
0.4133681357,
-0.1083856225,
0.9272766113,
0.2748629451,
0.4454210103,
-0.6688779593,
0.5471075773,
-0.5560931563,
0.5727109313,
-0.0646822453,
-0.6569392681,
-0.2447293997,
0.6195666194,
-0.2566637993,
0.4006322026,
0.8013991117,
1.1006202698,
-0.1428749859,
0.1706576049,
0.0556259602,
0.2973011136,
0.4849575758,
0.5223664045,
0.7068351507,
-0.2820520401,
0.5922023654,
-0.0794452429,
-0.3139565587,
-0.0068736821,
-0.9472899437,
-0.7983976603,
-0.3066709638,
-0.5991215706,
-0.5676143169,
0.4733296633,
0.6503504515,
0.7824934721,
-0.9724488854,
-0.1549261659,
-0.3845939934,
-0.0457383059,
-0.1526234001,
-0.2019734979,
0.3180978,
-0.4435856342,
-0.5840092897,
0.4041651785,
0.042813357,
-0.0592112616,
0.0695205405,
-0.1032972783,
0.0516365282,
-0.0132444128,
0.1865749806,
0.5605182052,
-0.4646525383,
-0.3836415708,
-0.3669769764,
0.0599913262,
0.2922839224,
1.0835490227,
-0.816239953,
0.5328774452,
0.3807418048,
0.5460295081,
0.6524024606,
0.333787322,
0.9557142854,
-0.7552620173,
-0.0278911758,
0.0204378515,
0.2554593086,
0.2989515662,
-0.337110579,
0.4610697627,
0.1181874648,
-0.6698697209,
-0.6144600511,
0.174270153,
-0.9005411267,
-0.0103757037,
1.0747243166,
-0.2505477667,
-0.0860334262,
-0.0582274385,
-0.2324177027,
0.3001175821,
-0.4644469917,
1.0319662094,
0.3939415216,
-0.2210178822,
-0.5851232409,
-0.435621202,
0.8134974241,
0.4312883615,
-1.022734046,
0.0835558176,
0.4635985196,
0.5883696675,
-0.2337887883,
0.6286318302,
0.1425575167,
0.2102398872,
-0.269841671,
-0.1671421826,
-0.0502905101,
-0.2963912189,
-0.4885707796,
-0.0140784783,
0.0654053837,
-0.2285929024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06589v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06589v1 | Improving Out-of-Distribution Generalization of Neural Rerankers with Contextualized Late Interaction | 2023-02-13T18:42:17 | 2023-02-13T18:42:17 | Xinyu Zhang, Minghan Li, Jimmy Lin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Recent progress in information retrieval finds that embedding query and
document representation into multi-vector yields a robust bi-encoder retriever
on out-of-distribution datasets. In this paper, we explore whether late
interaction, the simplest form of multi-vector, is also helpful to neural
rerankers that only use the [CLS] vector to compute the similarity score.
Although intuitively, the attention mechanism of rerankers at the previous
layers already gathers the token-level information, we find adding late
interaction still brings an extra 5% improvement in average on
out-of-distribution datasets, with little increase in latency and no
degradation in in-domain effectiveness. Through extensive experiments and
analysis, we show that the finding is consistent across different model sizes
and first-stage retrievers of diverse natures and that the improvement is more
prominent on longer queries. | [
-0.2327182293,
-0.3066675663,
0.5488551855,
0.1353798509,
-0.2186715901,
-0.0899777114,
-0.1872414052,
-0.3327957094,
0.5735395551,
-0.1217060834,
-0.1231548786,
-0.3483819962,
-0.7221130133,
-0.198106274,
-0.2371384054,
0.7403534055,
0.2630572021,
0.1637744755,
-0.4905587137,
-0.278925091,
-0.1408279389,
-0.7390975356,
-0.6078960299,
-0.387981385,
0.9662432671,
0.129479602,
0.6387298107,
0.3453852832,
1.0109615326,
0.3618252873,
-0.1957284808,
0.034386754,
-0.8646382689,
0.2578710616,
-0.2192127705,
-0.6532838345,
-0.3422973156,
0.0820237771,
0.6629820466,
0.9672665,
-0.0285497122,
-0.0071804714,
0.3069379032,
0.5831989646,
-0.8887423277,
0.0933086425,
-0.51228863,
0.1332230717,
-0.4073488712,
-0.4184204638,
-0.6424447894,
-0.26809901,
0.2181320935,
-0.6123173833,
0.4204406738,
0.1120225713,
0.6858953238,
0.2423922718,
-0.3730886579,
0.1049100608,
-0.4990496635,
0.8623390198,
-0.2578108311,
0.676792264,
0.338671267,
0.477894038,
-0.3987520337,
-0.8474928737,
-0.3227210939,
0.0763288513,
-0.0271392092,
-0.0157315005,
-0.2885071039,
-0.0297380574,
0.228979528,
0.2944488823,
-0.1348727047,
0.1666520536,
-0.2400310338,
-0.0095514199,
0.4067229033,
0.0707674101,
-0.1160374433,
-0.1532057524,
-0.2072573006,
-0.2018523216,
-0.6829220653,
0.2072680295,
0.4770358205,
-0.0461128466,
0.103500843,
0.792298913,
0.0292167086,
0.7856029868,
0.2940177023,
0.5337581635,
0.6478905082,
-0.6379449964,
0.0365115367,
-0.2145506442,
0.6161212921,
0.6320018172,
0.0464398079,
-0.4435734451,
-0.1587597132,
-0.2667862475,
0.4477325976,
-0.6086058021,
-0.3313213587,
-0.084221594,
-1.0012452602,
-0.1096368134,
0.2354169637,
-0.7306388021,
-0.3265652061,
-0.1342883408,
0.461610198,
-0.2277309448,
-0.0391819552,
-0.2192052305,
-0.619317174,
0.3877127171,
0.1268843412,
-0.6665040851,
0.2204794139,
0.5918158293,
1.0823811293,
-0.259359479,
-0.2585208416,
-0.9392068386,
0.0609907694,
-0.4233593345,
0.9258854389,
-0.8387206793,
-0.2176324874,
-0.2806764841,
0.0170571022,
-0.1784202605,
-0.7263890505,
0.2923056185,
-0.9774298668,
-0.0208202489,
-0.4091926515,
-0.4936540425,
0.1185324788,
0.1539129764,
-0.7111288309,
0.8745111227,
0.2063930631,
-0.9837525487,
0.586360395,
-0.5535174608,
-0.1905914545,
-0.2104267776,
-0.3112719655,
-0.4881541133,
0.3406618237,
0.2392061502,
0.4587081373,
-0.0475937575,
-0.1244602501,
-0.7313298583,
-0.9608314633,
0.2650277317,
-0.2073480934,
0.3272777796,
-0.0361455381,
-0.1402802914,
0.0557498261,
-0.6552940011,
0.0246517807,
-0.1126338094,
-0.5679271221,
-0.6521038413,
0.1071857736,
-0.2089933604,
0.1483791471,
0.1302860975,
-0.8292607665,
0.2405001074,
-0.5602754951,
0.4406332672,
0.6892439723,
0.274199754,
0.998786211,
-0.3104982972,
0.1190734357,
0.3793103397,
0.1516405791,
-0.0365707166,
-0.5303422809,
-0.4975735545,
-0.3340238333,
0.6280298233,
0.103745386,
-0.8589953184,
0.3265087306,
-0.5860522985,
-0.5064950585,
-0.6318402886,
0.0158228613,
0.4217888415,
0.3913580477,
0.4537022412,
-0.3975180984,
-0.3243350685,
-1.0440090895,
-0.3795685172,
0.1266984791,
-0.1992244571,
0.4711948633,
0.1719949543,
-0.366761446,
0.9280253053,
-0.531193316,
-0.3161593676,
-0.0758006871,
0.175508514,
0.3456299007,
0.3265594542,
0.6761929989,
-0.8387591243,
-0.3884738088,
-0.2030979693,
-0.8017302752,
0.2975237072,
0.3431862593,
-0.3401109576,
-0.1947163939,
0.5972110629,
-0.3477610946,
0.6795516014,
0.1977097988,
-0.0409907922,
-0.3305136859,
-0.4611621201,
0.1839928031,
-0.727963388,
-0.0490501933,
-0.2894286215,
-0.0614963472,
-0.4061364532,
-0.390686661,
0.2313160896,
-0.1657221466,
-0.4324537814,
0.2409881204,
-0.5645436049,
-0.3533575833,
-0.1340858191,
0.3316557705,
-0.1043152735,
0.5418452621,
-0.3023113906,
0.8019522429,
0.4746949971,
-0.8343310952,
0.1796813458,
0.3409868479,
-0.1570511609,
0.5443921089,
-0.9186803102,
0.3255170584,
-0.5180610418,
0.26528579,
-1.2599111795,
-0.0895779282,
0.254339695,
-0.6154613495,
0.2560892105,
-0.335916996,
-0.3797699511,
-0.2328413725,
-0.8291774988,
0.6833032966,
0.1869969964,
-0.9938079715,
0.7248336077,
0.3763817251,
0.1463113874,
-0.803342402,
-0.6836233735,
-0.3407220244,
-0.0209066346,
-0.6774103642,
0.6429517865,
-0.07649225,
-0.0644331127,
0.1779651791,
0.0687302575,
-0.0044915969,
-0.1771502793,
0.1459624469,
-0.1332772225,
0.0030704332,
0.3019013405,
0.0284317825,
0.0117686419,
0.0778067634,
0.0940927267,
0.5519195795,
0.2419283241,
-0.7240228653,
-0.0687455535,
0.3777492344,
0.3329846859,
-0.2984299362,
0.8247364163,
0.410494864,
-0.3832746446,
0.1772978455,
-0.2994196415,
-0.2803134024,
-0.4607615173,
0.368609339,
-0.6627128124,
-0.5399456024,
0.7145597339,
-0.0331570096,
-0.1193822548,
0.3355177343,
0.1546085328,
-0.1715787798,
1.0572835207,
0.5828421116,
-0.0669663027,
0.9351007938,
-0.3877001405,
0.2299220562,
-1.3252286911,
-0.6610981822,
-0.3358079195,
-0.7869947553,
-0.7092612386,
-0.3996453881,
0.3059206903,
0.1152428836,
0.0649988055,
0.0217583477,
-0.4427303076,
0.469615221,
0.7372225523,
0.506765902,
-0.1799174547,
0.1700344384,
-0.303940475,
-0.2811442316,
-0.91586411,
0.1980032772,
1.42126894,
0.1915526688,
0.8195889592,
0.4543037713,
0.9915381074,
0.1911112666,
0.3270848095,
-0.662573278,
0.0946392268,
-0.1645884812,
-0.1754290164,
-0.1405869275,
-0.5647008419,
-1.3227478266,
0.4207478464,
-0.3123204708,
-0.5245224237,
0.8517071605,
0.034790393,
-0.351855129,
-0.1149112582,
-0.8352577686,
0.6698742509,
0.144427985,
-0.4167148471,
-0.1903733313,
-0.7050724626,
0.1186967045,
-0.1892247796,
0.0106131313,
0.357155025,
-0.0914045349,
1.0370013714,
-0.3604507744,
0.5796185732,
-0.306353569,
0.3294300139,
0.1550311595,
-0.3991338909,
0.5045408607,
0.0865324959,
-0.2155903131,
0.203154698,
-0.3828572333,
-0.4580748677,
-0.9622046947,
0.8325936794,
-0.8297094107,
-0.4090559781,
-0.4766183496,
-0.2856191099,
0.0192598701,
0.1519319415,
0.4553414285,
0.5232898593,
-0.080585815,
0.720189631,
0.7934905887,
-0.1121080667,
0.5818353891,
0.3885596693,
0.0493364483,
-0.5762719512,
0.8397055268,
0.3319965005,
-0.0399974138,
0.4988501072,
-0.0017918756,
-0.5478949547,
-0.3153575063,
-0.0548530854,
0.2402080894,
-0.9311303496,
-0.3620943725,
-0.7796167135,
-0.1084902212,
-0.3919860125,
0.0812294632,
-0.1894393563,
-0.2325420082,
-0.2511686087,
-0.0549064614,
0.0885627046,
0.8988087773,
-0.2969763875,
0.5460341573,
-0.6327241659,
0.3865740597,
0.1660534143,
0.5644736886,
0.1961855441,
-0.6012655497,
-0.44013834,
-0.1089043766,
-0.1378891021,
-0.8649364114,
-0.0838209838,
0.3564940691,
1.0104440451,
0.4255383313,
-0.1614591181,
0.6317591071,
-0.5230258107,
0.5585222244,
0.1518643647,
-0.588978529,
0.1851883084,
-0.0048852921,
0.1602792293,
0.3411981165,
0.3123965859,
-0.2227645367,
-0.1195091754,
-0.6194242835,
-0.8972385526,
0.8815748692,
0.2787682116,
0.1175288707,
-0.3232368827,
0.4720501304,
-0.2751131654,
0.1948277056,
-0.2124228179,
-0.4869270921,
-0.3004514873,
-0.2116058916,
-0.3357706368,
-0.4417349696,
0.0873985663,
-0.1911087036,
0.1672690064,
0.0985369682,
0.5929294229,
0.1293981969,
-0.0648381487,
0.0261471421,
0.0273502301,
0.2369006425,
0.5818424225,
-0.4644266367,
0.2983339429,
-0.0724540725,
-0.4957223237,
0.0901033208,
0.274661392,
0.0341839045,
0.134489581,
0.2980121672,
0.4841187,
0.6263380647,
-0.142073527,
1.0002588034,
-0.3957236707,
0.106177479,
-0.1522128582,
-0.0151639627,
-0.0169695746,
0.4807816744,
0.3681567013,
0.3376156092,
0.3138889074,
-0.2779816985,
0.5727651715,
0.5816522837,
-0.3533725441,
-0.2379974723,
0.7541800141,
0.2117331475,
-0.2700044513,
0.8321650028,
-0.0864898264,
-0.4182513058,
0.3887034357,
0.2884587944,
0.5236601233,
-0.0436657742,
-0.1431230754,
0.2872588336,
0.032528203,
-0.117492348,
0.4297829568,
-0.2207497805,
-0.6305558681,
-0.2405698895,
-0.2546662092,
0.0242595822,
-0.1828098744,
-0.7730667591,
0.3038313687,
-0.2197713554,
-0.4723576009,
0.1276418567,
-0.0890141577,
-0.9723966122,
-0.0129649173,
-0.3569234014,
0.7016661167,
-0.4627491534,
0.6548879147,
0.7207291722,
-0.655215323,
-0.4792380333,
0.1106786281,
-0.4981420338,
-0.476682514,
0.9913198352,
0.1078744605,
-0.1835199445,
0.113178961,
-0.2900711596,
-1.087046504,
1.0783510208,
0.3093312085,
-0.5795379281,
0.0738239884,
-0.1506690979,
0.5980339646,
-0.3629348576,
0.8008826375,
0.187551707,
0.1367324889,
-0.0330837816,
-0.4885586798,
-0.4010681212,
-0.4855214655,
0.0275789872,
0.2558447123,
-0.6327191591,
1.0272376537,
-0.1624617279,
-0.0707530379,
-0.2716677189,
1.0126941204,
0.0983530581,
0.4891407192,
0.5111340284,
0.5061395764,
0.8012583256,
-0.017674908,
1.2375580072,
-0.1031670272,
0.1943403035,
1.1707355976,
0.0847814083,
0.9860621095,
0.5661551952,
0.0134464009,
0.2820676267,
0.798566401,
0.1082131192,
0.9068878293,
0.2801768482,
0.0834525153,
-0.1379767805,
-0.1306002289,
-0.5665000081,
0.3825802505,
0.1042063609,
-0.5687528849,
-0.296684891,
-0.0601259544,
-0.3714561164,
-0.0067204135,
-0.2586050034,
0.8421414495,
0.0753088519,
-0.4191509485,
0.4330963492,
-0.1241221726,
0.7783589363,
-0.2783831358,
-0.3486761451,
-0.4508901536,
0.4737916887,
-0.1375358254,
-0.7957239151,
0.090789184,
-0.3501947224,
-0.6198954582,
0.1327510178,
0.6481176019,
-0.4868490994,
-0.2229676545,
0.724899292,
0.6649347544,
0.3530685902,
-0.1520227343,
-0.3799547851,
0.0296694636,
-0.4184888601,
-0.2992217243,
0.4478283226,
0.5040004253,
-0.1053086296,
0.4754967093,
0.6629400849,
-0.0757659823,
0.5881749392,
0.5637954473,
1.1395999193,
-0.6094632745,
-0.5050593019,
-0.640232265,
0.0063250903,
-0.23812446,
-0.1913779527,
0.7431302667,
0.6982925534,
0.9048761129,
0.0520347282,
0.5236394405,
0.1784615517,
0.5167145133,
-0.1886756718,
0.6895890236,
-0.7095072269,
0.1868981272,
-0.0485844985,
-1.1757131815,
-0.1241187155,
0.5343534946,
-0.3147764802,
0.1699896902,
0.6006031632,
0.6384757161,
-0.4670637548,
-0.463131696,
0.3611821234,
-0.1110826805,
0.4131259322,
0.4536212683,
0.8149157763,
-0.621673286,
0.5840983391,
-0.1870193481,
-0.1658195555,
-0.2432081103,
-0.4541731775,
-1.1066192389,
-0.3462146521,
0.0883844644,
-0.2808405459,
0.0778215677,
0.716570735,
0.5202649236,
-0.4935116768,
0.2863551676,
0.2515353858,
0.1449685842,
-0.2440759689,
-0.1550750732,
0.5213270187,
-0.4395063519,
-0.818528235,
0.5453251004,
0.1168062016,
-0.1070514768,
-0.0183570608,
-0.1841877699,
-0.2667814493,
-0.0037153601,
0.5902819633,
-0.1857439429,
-0.2977695763,
-0.3841075003,
0.2017018497,
-0.1584552377,
0.2563118637,
0.9654340148,
-0.8581815958,
0.4884915054,
0.6945628524,
0.7634851933,
0.450034827,
0.2149852514,
0.5544984341,
-1.0516271591,
0.1196508631,
0.0095596444,
0.5421683192,
0.4064538777,
-0.4719717205,
0.3555538654,
0.3216867149,
-0.4641595185,
-0.731548667,
0.1072210968,
-0.596335113,
0.1156676188,
0.913618207,
-0.2595898807,
-0.5309143662,
-0.286873579,
0.1397924423,
0.4244653285,
-0.6067769527,
0.6868004203,
0.5832898021,
-0.2591809332,
-0.025038287,
0.1098027229,
0.3648894727,
0.5179783702,
-0.4555906355,
-0.2749181092,
0.0806910247,
0.2649903297,
0.3494255543,
0.7354969382,
-0.1443784833,
0.0611774772,
-0.0490868352,
-0.329585284,
-0.0737688765,
-0.5506640673,
-0.4161604047,
0.2077756375,
0.0554350838,
-0.6458067298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.06579v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.06579v1 | AbLit: A Resource for Analyzing and Generating Abridged Versions of English Literature | 2023-02-13T18:33:26 | 2023-02-13T18:33:26 | Melissa Roemmele, Kyle Shaffer, Katrina Olsen, Yiyi Wang, Steve DeNeefe | cs.CL | cs.CL | Creating an abridged version of a text involves shortening it while
maintaining its linguistic qualities. In this paper, we examine this task from
an NLP perspective for the first time. We present a new resource, AbLit, which
is derived from abridged versions of English literature books. The dataset
captures passage-level alignments between the original and abridged texts. We
characterize the linguistic relations of these alignments, and create automated
models to predict these relations as well as to generate abridgements for new
texts. Our findings establish abridgement as a challenging task, motivating
future resources and research. The dataset is available at
github.com/roemmele/AbLit. | [
-0.1130813584,
-0.6626553535,
0.1661164016,
-0.0439916365,
-0.4271911681,
0.1539554,
-0.0846162885,
-0.5659738183,
0.2596302927,
0.9331920147,
-0.7577116489,
-0.239994213,
-0.1701116115,
0.4626884162,
-0.6793627143,
0.8436527252,
-0.0755434334,
-0.1504265815,
-0.3946969211,
-0.3340062499,
-0.428557694,
-0.1460901797,
-0.4219753444,
-0.4973480105,
0.5662531853,
0.1338733435,
1.1194844246,
0.8595961332,
0.6563301682,
0.2169005126,
-0.4754500091,
-0.0041510668,
-0.1079277843,
0.4156578183,
-0.5424772501,
-0.4286322296,
-0.1061803177,
-0.1380372494,
0.8301522732,
0.8276731372,
0.0111101745,
0.3480625153,
0.0718820989,
1.0750809908,
-0.3982366025,
-0.3735963404,
-0.6159997582,
0.3210932016,
-0.2158515304,
-0.1726339161,
-0.6736261249,
-0.3516969681,
0.1485117823,
-0.5373945832,
0.4634463191,
0.3121196926,
0.893537879,
0.6457995772,
-0.0894435793,
-0.6197422147,
-0.5495153069,
0.7618071437,
-0.7780038714,
0.3017669022,
0.06709636,
0.0779351592,
0.0229990724,
-0.6583930254,
-0.5488699675,
-0.1536047012,
-0.5755234361,
-0.175543189,
-0.0040882346,
-0.0008735267,
0.2055386454,
0.6067743301,
-0.6447271109,
-0.018821042,
-0.5364653468,
-0.1081985682,
0.8307284117,
0.0749327838,
0.6443405747,
-0.7770724297,
-0.1260774285,
0.1600712389,
-0.7536816597,
-0.2654101253,
0.4538012743,
0.2279361635,
0.236109063,
0.9821658731,
0.4573682249,
0.4505982399,
-0.3596868217,
-0.2142616808,
0.290892452,
-0.2425231487,
-0.2252297997,
0.3609063029,
0.3792271912,
0.2948743999,
0.2135568857,
-0.0550098196,
-0.1407542825,
-0.1463522762,
0.3403069675,
-0.4420725107,
-0.0796214789,
0.2632766962,
-0.5530984402,
-0.1084818989,
-0.2612659037,
-0.5365155935,
-0.7101784348,
-0.4811838865,
0.2908424735,
-0.6833555698,
0.2357381433,
0.016942801,
-0.0543879531,
0.3201903403,
0.3350301087,
-0.6909219623,
0.318859309,
0.3913006485,
1.0166459084,
-0.1975605339,
-0.4960798919,
-0.2222343385,
0.2749062777,
-0.3573437333,
0.3371503353,
-0.2678153813,
-0.6848019361,
-0.0591337383,
0.0308233462,
0.4009272754,
-0.3146441877,
0.567538023,
-0.2663404942,
0.1728726923,
0.0280302446,
-0.7658574581,
-0.2651073635,
-0.0486620702,
-0.9359496236,
0.8051422834,
0.1097337678,
-0.896391511,
-0.0000604398,
-0.4914719164,
-0.4200088978,
-0.0072232131,
-0.0377340652,
-0.3042270541,
0.3633848727,
0.4666542411,
-0.3056870997,
-0.3062792718,
-0.098293744,
0.1893289983,
-0.0984226912,
0.227559641,
-0.5307562351,
1.18011415,
0.4060278833,
0.2172465473,
-0.3320762813,
-0.5906259418,
0.0085596377,
0.1254784763,
-0.2167047709,
-0.3826762438,
0.211248666,
0.0614290535,
-0.0878078565,
0.4132605493,
-0.6925184131,
0.2700088322,
-0.6575895548,
0.1600193232,
0.5247761607,
0.307872802,
0.5115582347,
-0.6607464552,
0.8197796345,
-0.5468267798,
0.2913652658,
-0.6513031721,
-0.3602381051,
-0.7089406252,
0.0279777013,
0.7916839719,
0.6451237798,
-0.6859942675,
0.4489177465,
-0.111480467,
-0.3833437264,
-1.284052968,
0.1835612506,
0.3686441779,
0.1902715713,
0.4507700205,
-0.0233207271,
-0.3988865614,
-0.8494249582,
-0.2812005579,
-0.2256583869,
-0.1717131585,
0.0270489324,
0.4020209014,
-0.0342509747,
1.1063469648,
-0.5066196322,
-0.36929968,
-0.2141303569,
-0.0389493406,
0.1381450593,
0.5982566476,
0.6701960564,
-0.5211607218,
-0.5573666692,
0.2510747015,
-0.7303727865,
-0.5520750284,
-0.2869042754,
-0.1820603162,
0.3183915019,
0.6830488443,
-0.1928001344,
0.6339716315,
0.4855169952,
-0.5096506476,
0.6620909572,
-0.1776618659,
0.1332763433,
-0.8869196177,
0.1392615587,
-0.3449183404,
-0.1540274471,
-0.369977355,
0.2429187596,
-0.1399129182,
-0.2979102433,
-0.3611806631,
0.8549289703,
-0.6204719543,
-0.190247789,
-0.0202253573,
0.2219774425,
0.6138011813,
0.0791378692,
-0.1299588084,
0.6448482871,
0.1131755486,
0.0655207932,
0.1702347994,
0.9746940732,
-0.3963358998,
0.2427601963,
-0.3563005924,
0.0169870369,
-0.4160674214,
-0.0606613494,
-0.8217318654,
0.0265437067,
-0.0510065705,
-0.4945013225,
0.1940850914,
-0.3830190599,
-0.4841383994,
-0.0885830745,
-0.0997588187,
0.4758093655,
0.7319478989,
-0.5775642395,
0.3651760817,
0.058671508,
-0.5524074435,
-0.9444450736,
-0.9983389378,
0.0776700675,
0.022797782,
-0.5099958181,
0.5339229703,
-0.1824759096,
-0.3659853339,
0.2612070143,
-0.0923810899,
-0.0349783301,
-0.2057406306,
-0.1029380485,
0.260563761,
-0.1746527255,
0.1214045659,
0.2618819177,
0.3034852147,
0.109197095,
0.2093861848,
0.3083103895,
0.3402610421,
-0.4747360647,
-0.2575304806,
0.6294279099,
0.3608089387,
-0.1507902294,
0.6733843088,
0.2202442735,
-0.4715527594,
-0.4515291154,
-0.3334626257,
0.1865375787,
-0.4879757464,
-0.1345193982,
0.0251582805,
-0.3184661567,
0.5829798579,
0.3924353421,
0.4125996828,
0.3180272877,
-0.1018015668,
0.0632336661,
0.5027305484,
0.609292984,
0.37816149,
0.356498152,
-0.0547577962,
0.2819318473,
-0.8002671003,
-0.1702142656,
-0.5056994557,
-0.4459507763,
-0.4194890261,
-0.3481371403,
0.1602804065,
0.3048761189,
0.0852886289,
0.0492563061,
-0.5191701055,
1.0226960182,
0.3844432831,
0.0925965235,
0.5916080475,
-0.0540073812,
-0.0487724245,
-0.4659696519,
-0.3355881572,
-0.6443303823,
0.7660210729,
0.3744550645,
0.4658534229,
0.4769574702,
0.6677923203,
0.5032070279,
0.3056389689,
-0.8214379549,
0.5388674736,
-0.2689650059,
-0.8212687373,
-0.5420172215,
-0.3627286553,
-0.8558750749,
0.2680878639,
-0.257040441,
-0.5528290868,
-0.1144509166,
0.0368816964,
-0.2572566271,
0.2483429462,
-0.7250958681,
0.8132579327,
-0.2029103637,
-0.361649394,
0.0497185141,
-0.6192784905,
0.2611730397,
-0.2245353758,
0.3428109288,
-0.1907959282,
-0.2570723593,
0.5140715837,
-0.7031296492,
0.4314683974,
0.0146699417,
0.0017466444,
0.4092794657,
0.6115382314,
0.1760411859,
0.0475096516,
-0.4359937608,
-0.2141696364,
0.0123129841,
-0.6036171913,
-0.5058364272,
0.3890207112,
-0.4048453569,
-0.4605435133,
-0.3655796051,
-0.5732046366,
-0.0462322161,
0.4484271109,
0.2739702165,
0.5137662292,
-0.2403259277,
0.0003945907,
0.3111019731,
-0.7896541953,
0.5153745413,
0.3291376233,
-0.8201042414,
-0.4432858527,
0.2956035733,
0.2220137566,
0.2866903245,
0.1798756719,
0.1603208631,
-0.5377131701,
-0.9529050589,
-0.362775892,
0.6385653615,
-0.910435617,
-0.0967315435,
-0.1423637569,
-0.6800450087,
-0.2792724669,
-0.8486343026,
-0.2803732157,
-0.4342064261,
-0.1930687577,
-0.0864499435,
0.4345079362,
0.9621803164,
-0.0390712284,
0.3192764223,
-0.8232495785,
0.0833221823,
-0.0687207654,
0.1893674433,
-0.0590043254,
-0.6669616699,
-0.1828972101,
-0.2608299553,
-0.1293893307,
-1.0039316416,
0.8456568718,
0.2674038112,
0.1751189679,
-0.0602947921,
0.5578456521,
0.3485032022,
-0.8820649385,
1.0395973921,
0.3752817214,
-1.0622888803,
0.7786960602,
-0.2332942188,
0.3355812728,
0.5823319554,
0.3426566422,
-0.6331664324,
-0.4001435339,
-0.6049169302,
-1.1231951714,
0.5728061795,
0.5701884627,
-0.0164921638,
-0.0287640486,
0.3283932805,
0.4687115252,
0.3695754111,
-0.8168288469,
-0.395108968,
0.0254835095,
-0.3731975555,
-0.2714073658,
-0.0774464309,
0.0790200606,
-0.3583671451,
0.6363756061,
0.2999523878,
-0.1489852965,
0.4886479378,
-0.6427305341,
-0.1033362746,
0.17135638,
0.0710202977,
0.9690804482,
-0.1974320114,
-0.1140868217,
0.0371616371,
-0.5182507038,
0.2318806052,
0.0467079133,
-0.2774421871,
0.6264954805,
0.4580326974,
0.4296456575,
-0.1753033251,
-0.8026933074,
0.4339925051,
0.1866278499,
0.1198915541,
-0.7374054193,
-0.1546576619,
-0.2117859572,
0.0821917802,
0.3333236575,
-0.073515296,
0.1320922971,
-0.3900336027,
0.486941725,
-0.0666773617,
-0.162270382,
-0.0206555631,
0.7021817565,
0.3689091206,
-0.632191062,
0.5912607908,
-0.3033414483,
-0.0236572791,
0.4322793782,
0.3761666715,
0.6214246154,
-0.4568243921,
0.4262165427,
0.3913461268,
0.6771173477,
0.1268095523,
-0.0526811443,
0.4636850059,
-0.561367631,
-0.6637214422,
-1.072045207,
-0.6046937704,
0.3136561215,
-0.5568220615,
0.5763942003,
-0.5192401409,
0.328980267,
0.3960073292,
-0.0141567634,
-0.4142518938,
-0.1035724431,
0.0781997219,
1.0557277203,
-0.6731581092,
0.4951923192,
0.6780405045,
-0.4757665396,
-0.2595799863,
0.2722899318,
0.0512651727,
-0.3290681839,
-0.0850812569,
0.0471144579,
0.2185205817,
0.2350948453,
-0.0901734233,
-0.7202976346,
0.8714410663,
0.5299052596,
-0.2549208999,
-0.467656374,
0.1999523342,
0.5928228498,
-0.1211804375,
-0.0949797183,
0.5750867724,
0.3340916038,
0.0161343161,
-0.7851017714,
-0.1350146383,
-0.4441536665,
-0.09392941,
0.5593246818,
-0.1868137866,
0.7091348171,
-0.1290210187,
-0.3356642127,
0.3155514002,
0.3662052453,
-0.1399823874,
0.2454434037,
0.3687186539,
0.4134076238,
0.7111321688,
0.1306923181,
0.7079535127,
0.0265644342,
0.2468985319,
1.1217118502,
-0.2436618656,
0.7687197328,
0.5140166879,
-0.2232788503,
0.3017842174,
0.4968791604,
0.117905356,
0.3992572129,
0.2792193294,
-0.360360682,
0.3404556811,
-0.0793483555,
-0.2249504328,
0.2150618583,
0.4835316539,
-0.5934647918,
-0.1551759839,
0.0312151816,
0.1154775992,
0.6084191799,
-0.4192883968,
0.6026192307,
0.0725607201,
-0.7570668459,
0.6095910668,
-0.2404862195,
0.3279057443,
-0.4310472906,
0.0388735496,
-0.3903393745,
-0.1572924703,
-0.3725692332,
-1.0285366774,
0.7812656164,
0.0904265344,
-0.3064019382,
-0.1481998265,
0.3027968407,
-0.5766901374,
-0.5448391438,
0.2325560153,
0.5590468645,
0.2315249592,
0.6330608726,
-0.7462806702,
-0.0252425019,
0.4350064397,
-0.2999998927,
-0.0042447769,
0.4911095798,
0.4078871608,
0.3766438365,
0.3276559114,
0.2206964195,
0.0505287237,
-0.0503553376,
0.3391499519,
-0.7914140224,
-0.5409061313,
-0.6389343143,
0.7451071739,
-0.2716758847,
-0.4596576989,
0.3966114521,
0.4794827402,
0.5637376308,
0.124128513,
1.0150725842,
-0.1788465381,
0.6709960699,
-0.747218132,
0.6893463731,
-0.8086348176,
0.5804527402,
-0.1357031614,
-0.9943586588,
-0.351990968,
0.6149734855,
0.0524199121,
-0.5647858977,
1.1395243406,
0.7531080842,
-0.1298137605,
0.0157049391,
0.3587988913,
0.1374869794,
-0.036439687,
-0.099806048,
0.7578516006,
-0.4139122665,
0.5933190584,
-0.2993595898,
0.0619515516,
0.0039640036,
-0.8993350863,
-0.8570815325,
-0.6994814873,
-0.4963393807,
-0.3270224333,
0.1686303616,
0.9578892589,
-0.1659560055,
-0.5354235768,
-0.1606777757,
-0.0175942443,
0.3756889701,
-0.0118781896,
-0.1982691437,
0.2556619942,
-0.36272946,
-0.7711847425,
0.2613280118,
0.0327988192,
0.2091292441,
-0.4086878002,
0.0696140155,
-0.2932204604,
0.5779367685,
0.4110311866,
0.1215976924,
-0.6591163874,
-0.4528900087,
-0.2959494293,
0.1601922214,
0.1011644974,
0.5421917439,
-0.270398885,
0.3784460127,
0.5992853642,
0.6725836992,
0.1291109025,
0.0701287687,
0.6590331793,
-1.4185190201,
0.2481261343,
0.516292572,
0.5787215829,
0.5919619203,
-0.1638073027,
0.8260598183,
-0.0773565099,
-0.7201083899,
-1.2260322571,
0.5304465294,
-0.7499983907,
-0.6515356302,
1.213914156,
-0.1012306213,
-0.46434021,
-0.0976943076,
-0.4491490126,
0.1248581484,
-0.0619670525,
0.4428787827,
0.9978396297,
0.0581666306,
-0.2971906364,
-0.6872722507,
0.6410815716,
0.3315362036,
-0.5317776799,
0.3754789233,
0.7063219547,
-0.1076793298,
0.3140182495,
0.3767885268,
-0.2056972682,
0.1231017709,
0.1372187585,
0.4398618639,
0.1273358166,
-0.2522281408,
-0.2711419165,
0.035994079,
0.3231547177,
0.1359749585
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.