I previously had a Seidio Innocase II and it developed a crack so I ordered this case since Seidio wouldn't warranty their crap for more than a month or so.  Anyway, back to the Otterbox Commuter for the HTC EVO.  If the hard plastic part of this case had a rubberized finish it would be a very good case but, it doesn't and this hard plastic is slick and hard to keep a solid grip on.  The silicone inner case is exposed on the top and bottom and it has plenty of grip and makes it hard to get out of your pocket.  So the darn case is hard to hold and hard to get in and out of your pocket at the same time.  I much prefer the rubberized finish of the Seidio but, their warranty sucks and I have heard Otterbox is great about any warranty problems.  Also, the silicone flap that covers the charging jack and HDMI jack is constantly coming undone when you slide it in and out of your shirt pocket or any other pocket so you are constantly having to readjust that flap so that it will again cover the jacks.  I really like how the inner silicone part of this case has the raised volume and power buttons but, at this point I am shopping for another case.  Note:  The holster that came with my Seidio Innocase II will also work with this case.  I much prefer the holster of the Seidio over the Otterbox Defender holsters.  The Seidio is actually spring loaded and the Otterbox relies on flexing plastic to keep your phone secure.
I previously had a Seidio Innocase II and it developed a crack so I ordered this case since Seidio wouldn't warranty their crap for more than a month or so. Anyway, back to the Otterbox Commuter for the HTC EVO. If the hard plastic part of this case had a rubberized finish it would be a very good case but, it doesn't and this hard plastic is slick and hard to keep a solid grip on. The silicone inner case is exposed on the top and bottom and it has plenty of grip and makes it hard to get out of your pocket. So the darn case is hard to hold and hard to get in and out of your pocket at the same time. I much prefer the rubberized finish of the Seidio but, their warranty sucks and I have heard Otterbox is great about any warranty problems. Also, the silicone flap that covers the charging jack and HDMI jack is constantly coming undone when you slide it in and out of your shirt pocket or any other pocket so you are constantly having to readjust that flap so that it will again cover the jacks. I really like how the inner silicone part of this case has the raised volume and power buttons but, at this point I am shopping for another case. Note:  The holster that came with my Seidio Innocase II will also work with this case. I much prefer the holster of the Seidio over the Otterbox Defender holsters. The Seidio is actually spring loaded and the Otterbox relies on flexing plastic to keep your phone secure.