My search for the best "everyday" iP4 case may finally be over. After having tried several other cases (listed below) and reading reviews of even more, the Incipio NGP Matte is the closest to meeting my needs.

Tested:
* Apple Bumper- Minimal protection. Reports of scratching steel band and streching after continual use.
* Griffin Reveal Etch- Very nice look and feel, but rubber sides were too loose for my liking.
* Speck Candyshell- Confident about its protection, but too bulky, scratch-prone, and incompatible with most pin connectors.
* Incipio Silicrylic- Precise fit and compatability. Silicone layer picks up lint (removed easily, but still...).

Incipo NGP Matte
Pros
- Perfect fit.
- Perfect balance of grip/slickness. Does not attract dust/lint.
- Clean looks.
- Does not hamper LED flash performance.
- Easy to operate phone controls.
- Superb compatability with 3rd party docks and connectors.
- Material is tough to scratch.
- Easy to install/remove.
- Good size lip to lift front screen off surfaces.
- Thick material provides both shock and puncture protection.
- Compatible with screen protectors.

Cons
- Case shows marks from being removed from mold (some more than others).
- Thicker than Apple Bumper

If you can live with the slight blemish*, the NGP Matte provides the ideal balance between protection, size, grip, and function. It is easy to put in and out of pockets, provides excellent grip/feel without picking up unecessary dirt/lint and offers clean lines to enhance its attractiveness. The best "everyday" case I have tested so far.

*Mold marks may even be removed with careful dremeling. Proceed at your own risk.
My search for the best "everyday" iP4 case may finally be over. After having tried several other cases (listed below) and reading reviews of even more, the Incipio NGP Matte is the closest to meeting my needs. Tested:
* Apple Bumper- Minimal protection. Reports of scratching steel band and streching after continual use. * Griffin Reveal Etch- Very nice look and feel, but rubber sides were too loose for my liking. * Speck Candyshell- Confident about its protection, but too bulky, scratch-prone, and incompatible with most pin connectors. * Incipio Silicrylic- Precise fit and compatability. Silicone layer picks up lint (removed easily, but still... ). Incipo NGP Matte
Pros
- Perfect fit. - Perfect balance of grip/slickness. Does not attract dust/lint. - Clean looks. - Does not hamper LED flash performance. - Easy to operate phone controls. - Superb compatability with 3rd party docks and connectors. - Material is tough to scratch. - Easy to install/remove. - Good size lip to lift front screen off surfaces. - Thick material provides both shock and puncture protection. - Compatible with screen protectors. Cons
- Case shows marks from being removed from mold (some more than others). - Thicker than Apple Bumper

If you can live with the slight blemish*, the NGP Matte provides the ideal balance between protection, size, grip, and function. It is easy to put in and out of pockets, provides excellent grip/feel without picking up unecessary dirt/lint and offers clean lines to enhance its attractiveness. The best "everyday" case I have tested so far. *Mold marks may even be removed with careful dremeling. Proceed at your own risk.