The case fits the phone snugly, but is easy to put on and remove.  The (very) thin rubberized coating makes it easy to hold onto.  At first I thought the didn't seem that durable because the un-coated inner surface of the case seems to be a cheap plastic, but it has shown its durability twice in the past week when my phone fell from a height of about 3-5 feet onto a parking lot and a sidewalk.  The first time the phone fell about 3 feet onto a parking lot and the case and phone remained in tact; the case was dinged a bit, but it stayed together and the phone was unharmed.  The second time it fell about 5 feet onto a sidwalk, but this time the case came apart and the battery cover came off too; I now have a few dents and scratches on the frame around the screen, but the screen itself is fine.

The phone with the case fits nicely into the standard dock, and with some minor modifications (to the dock) it fits nicely in the car dock too.  Some claim it fits nicely in the car dock without modification, but I wasn't able to accomplish this.

The holster appears very sturdy, but the ratcheting mechanism in the belt clip is too lose - allowing the holster to rotate to freely, so I can never be sure which way the holster is turned when I go to put the phone back into it.  This leads to another problem - the lack of a base across the bottom of the phone (between the lips on the corners that grab the phone) makes it possible to put the phone back in the holster cocked - with one corner or the phone sticking out between the holster corners, while the opposite corner on top goes under the latch.  If you're not paying attention, you can think the phone is secured in the holster when it's not.  I believe this is what lead to my first drop onto the parking lot - the phone fell from the holster without be touching it or bumping into anything, after having been in the holster for several minutes.

Because of the tapered back edges of the phone, the spring clip is necessarily large, but it tends to get caught on things, and can get pulled away, causing the phone to be released.  I believe this is what caused my second drop onto the sidewalk.

Despite my recent mishaps, I don't tend to drop my phones, so I'm sticking with this for now because of its compatibility with the docks.
The case fits the phone snugly, but is easy to put on and remove. The (very) thin rubberized coating makes it easy to hold onto. At first I thought the didn't seem that durable because the un-coated inner surface of the case seems to be a cheap plastic, but it has shown its durability twice in the past week when my phone fell from a height of about 3-5 feet onto a parking lot and a sidewalk. The first time the phone fell about 3 feet onto a parking lot and the case and phone remained in tact; the case was dinged a bit, but it stayed together and the phone was unharmed. The second time it fell about 5 feet onto a sidwalk, but this time the case came apart and the battery cover came off too; I now have a few dents and scratches on the frame around the screen, but the screen itself is fine. The phone with the case fits nicely into the standard dock, and with some minor modifications (to the dock) it fits nicely in the car dock too. Some claim it fits nicely in the car dock without modification, but I wasn't able to accomplish this. The holster appears very sturdy, but the ratcheting mechanism in the belt clip is too lose - allowing the holster to rotate to freely, so I can never be sure which way the holster is turned when I go to put the phone back into it. This leads to another problem - the lack of a base across the bottom of the phone (between the lips on the corners that grab the phone) makes it possible to put the phone back in the holster cocked - with one corner or the phone sticking out between the holster corners, while the opposite corner on top goes under the latch. If you're not paying attention, you can think the phone is secured in the holster when it's not. I believe this is what lead to my first drop onto the parking lot - the phone fell from the holster without be touching it or bumping into anything, after having been in the holster for several minutes. Because of the tapered back edges of the phone, the spring clip is necessarily large, but it tends to get caught on things, and can get pulled away, causing the phone to be released. I believe this is what caused my second drop onto the sidewalk. Despite my recent mishaps, I don't tend to drop my phones, so I'm sticking with this for now because of its compatibility with the docks.