ament ▁– ▁( Ch a ▁till ▁su in ▁tu ille )" ▁which ▁transl ates ▁as ▁" We ▁shall ▁return ▁no ▁more ", ▁later ▁repub lished ▁as ▁" M ack rim mon ' s ▁L ament . ▁Air ▁– ▁Cha ▁till ▁mi ▁tu ille ." ▁In ▁Ang us ▁Mac K ay ' s ▁book ▁A ▁Collection ▁of ▁An cient ▁P io ba ire ach d ▁or ▁High land ▁Pi pe ▁Music , ▁ 1 8 3 8 , ▁the ▁p ib ro ch ▁" Ch a ▁till ▁mi ▁tu ill " ▁is ▁subsequently ▁published ▁with ▁the ▁title ▁" Mac C rum men ▁will ▁never ▁return ". ▁ ▁The ▁p ib ro ch ▁" C oul odd ins ▁L ament " ▁in ▁the ▁Campbell ▁Can nt aire ach d ▁manuscript ▁appears ▁in ▁Mac K ay ' s ▁book ▁with ▁the ▁title ▁" L ament ▁for ▁Patrick ▁Og ▁Mac C rim mon ". ▁This ▁pattern ▁has ▁led ▁critics ▁of ▁the ▁orth odox ▁accounts ▁of ▁p ib ro ch ▁history ▁such ▁as ▁Al ist air ▁Cam ps ie ▁to ▁conclude ▁that ▁the ▁author ship ▁and ▁orig ins ▁of ▁the ▁p ib ro ch ▁re per toire ▁were ▁re fr amed ▁for ▁political ▁and ▁Han over ian ▁motiv ations ▁that ▁can ▁be ▁trac ed ▁back ▁to ▁anx iet ies ▁over ▁Scottish ▁national ism . ▁ ▁While ▁the ▁conventional ▁accounts ▁of ▁the ▁orig ins ▁of ▁p ib ro ch ▁are ▁largely ▁character ised ▁by ▁an ▁ag grand ising ▁rom antic ism ▁common ▁to ▁anti qu arian ▁appropri ations ▁of