▁A ▁debate ▁between ▁R aya ▁Dun ay ev sk aya ▁and ▁Max ▁Sh acht man ▁( May ▁ 1 9 4 7 ▁with ▁August ▁ 2 0 0 5 ▁comment ary ) ▁ ▁Imperial ism ▁and ▁World ▁Econom y ▁by ▁Nikol ai ▁B uk har in ▁ ▁State ▁Capital ism ▁and ▁D ict ator ship ▁by ▁Anton ▁Pan ne ko ek ▁ ▁The ▁Theory ▁of ▁" State ▁Capital ism ", ▁by ▁Ernest ▁Mand el ▁( J une ▁ 1 9 5 1 ) ▁ ▁The ▁Marx ian ▁Con cept ▁of ▁Capital ▁and ▁the ▁Soviet ▁Exper ience : ▁Ess ay ▁in ▁the ▁Crit ique ▁of ▁Political ▁Econom y ▁by ▁Par esh ▁Ch att op ad hy ay ▁ ▁Collection ▁of ▁left - comm un ist ▁links ▁that ▁dismiss ▁the ▁b ols he vik ▁state ▁capital ism . ▁ ▁" The ▁Nature ▁of ▁the ▁Russian ▁Econom y " ▁a ▁ 1 9 4 6 ▁P ole mic ▁written ▁by ▁R aya ▁Dun ay ev sk aya ▁( then ▁writing ▁as ▁Fred die ▁Forest ), ▁founder ▁of ▁Marx ist ▁Human ism , ▁arg uing ▁for ▁a ▁state ▁capital ist ▁position ▁within ▁the ▁Marx ist ▁movement . ▁ ▁" T rot sky ism ▁after ▁T rot sky : ▁The ▁orig ins ▁of ▁the ▁International ▁Social ists " ▁Sum mar ization ▁of ▁three ▁key ▁points ▁on ▁which ▁Cl iff ▁and ▁the ▁International ▁Social ist ▁T endency ▁devi ated ▁from ▁what ▁is ▁tradition ally ▁the ▁orth odox ▁T rot sky ist ▁position . ▁ ▁" C . L .