2 0 0 7 , ▁Judge ▁Ell is ▁granted ▁C uster ▁Batt les ' ▁motion ▁for ▁summary ▁judgment , ▁finding ▁that ▁there ▁was ▁no ▁evidence ▁of ▁the ▁submission ▁of ▁false ▁claims ▁in ▁this ▁case . ▁In ▁April ▁ 2 0 0 9 , ▁the ▁ 4 th ▁Circ uit ▁appe als ▁court ▁aff ir med ▁summary ▁judgment ▁for ▁C uster ▁Batt les ▁on ▁the ▁Bag hd ad ▁air port ▁contract . ▁Therefore , ▁the ▁Airport ▁Cont ract ▁claim ▁was ▁denied ▁legal ▁standing ▁but ▁the ▁Din ar ▁Exchange ▁Cont ract ▁and ▁ret ali ation ▁claims ▁from ▁the ▁Airport ▁Cont ract ▁proceeded ▁to ▁trial . ▁ ▁C uster ▁Batt les ▁files ▁consp i racy ▁law suit ▁In ▁April ▁ 2 0 0 5 , ▁C uster ▁Batt les ▁file d ▁consp i racy ▁and ▁bre ach ▁of ▁contract ▁law su its ▁against ▁Robert ▁Is ak son ▁and ▁William ▁Bald win , ▁the ▁same ▁individuals ▁who ▁had ▁previously ▁accused ▁C uster ▁Batt les ▁of ▁subm itting ▁false ▁claims . ▁The ▁law suit ▁also ▁included ▁Is ak son ▁and ▁Bald win ' s ▁companies , ▁D RC ▁Inc ▁and ▁American ▁Ira qi ▁Sol utions ▁Group , ▁both ▁of ▁Alabama . ▁According ▁to ▁court ▁documents ▁file d ▁in ▁the ▁U . S . ▁District ▁Court ▁for ▁the ▁Eastern ▁District ▁of ▁Virginia , ▁Mr . ▁Is ak son ▁bre ached ▁his ▁contract ▁with ▁C uster ▁Batt les ▁when ▁he ▁brought ▁his ▁ 1 2 - year - old ▁son ▁to ▁Ira q ▁by ▁vehicle ▁from ▁Am man , ▁Jordan