▁inherit " ▁the ▁sound ▁of ▁f ( x ), ▁but ▁" it ▁built ▁an ▁identity " ▁as ▁" first ▁Red ▁Vel vet ". ▁Jakob ▁Dor of ▁of ▁pop ▁music ▁magazine ▁Sp in ▁described ▁the ▁track ▁" I ce ▁C ream ▁C ake " ▁as ▁" a ▁treat ▁as ▁unexpected ▁as ▁it ▁is ▁un predict able ▁[...] ▁pack s ▁a ▁p unch , ▁but ▁goes ▁down ▁smooth ▁over ▁time " ▁and ▁de emed ▁it ▁" the ▁SM ▁label ' s ▁special ty : ▁b ubble g um ▁pop ▁that ▁deeply ▁re wards ▁repeat ▁rot ations ." ▁On ▁an ▁individual ▁music ▁video ▁review , ▁J esse ▁L ent ▁of ▁K pop St arz ▁said ▁the ▁song ▁was ▁" deep ly ▁arrest ing " ▁and ▁" del ivers ▁every ▁intr igu ing ▁move ▁you ▁could ▁want ▁from ▁a ▁sh iny ▁new ▁pop ▁song ". ▁W riter ▁Ch else a ▁from ▁Se oul be ats ▁app la ud ed ▁the ▁song ▁" al arm ingly ▁catch y " ▁and ▁" def initely ▁an ▁ear ▁w orm ", ▁while ▁writer ▁Jung ▁B ae ▁of ▁Hello k pop ▁chose ▁the ▁song ▁as ▁the ▁Best ▁Dance ▁and ▁Electron ic ▁Song ▁of ▁ 2 0 1 5 ▁and ▁ranked ▁it ▁fifth ▁on ▁the ▁Song ▁of ▁the ▁Year ▁chart . ▁The ▁song ▁would ▁later ▁appear ▁in ▁the ▁top ▁ 2 5 ▁Red ▁Vel vet ▁songs ▁by ▁Billboard , ▁landing ▁at ▁number ▁eigh teen ▁on ▁the ▁list . ▁ ▁Chart ▁performance ▁ ▁Upon ▁its ▁digital ▁release , ▁" I ce ▁C ream ▁C