0 ▁weeks ▁before ▁the ▁ 2 0 0 7 ▁party . ▁That ▁def endant ▁later ▁settled , ▁but ▁according ▁to ▁the ▁pla int iff ' s ▁att or ne ys , ▁a ▁witness ▁came ▁forward ▁placing ▁Ch ad wick ▁in ▁the ▁room ▁during ▁Jane ▁Do e ▁II ' s ▁ra pe . ▁ ▁Jane ▁Do e ▁II ' s ▁case ▁was ▁ex cluded ▁from ▁the ▁trial , ▁as ▁the ▁court ▁found ▁there ▁was ▁not ▁enough ▁evidence ▁that ▁Ch ad wick ▁had ▁planned ▁the ▁attacks . ▁On ▁April ▁ 7 , ▁ 2 0 1 1 , ▁the ▁j ury ▁in ▁the ▁civil ▁case ▁found ▁Kn opf ▁and ▁Ch ad wick ▁to ▁be ▁not ▁li able ▁for ▁the ▁alleg ations ▁against ▁them ▁so ▁no ▁dam ages ▁were ▁awarded . ▁ ▁After ▁Judge ▁A aron ▁Pers ky ' s ▁sent encing ▁of ▁Bro ck ▁Turner ▁in ▁ 2 0 1 6 , ▁Pers ky ▁was ▁critic ized ▁by ▁Jane ▁Do e ' s ▁att or ne ys ▁for ▁allowing ▁suggest ive ▁photos ▁of ▁the ▁un ident ified ▁victim , ▁taken ▁at ▁a ▁party ▁a ▁year ▁after ▁the ▁gang ▁ra pe , ▁into ▁evidence , ▁and ▁prevent ing ▁other ▁vict ims ▁from ▁test ifying . ▁Att or ne ys ▁for ▁" J ane ▁Do e " ▁said ▁the ▁photograph s ▁were ▁not ▁the ▁only ▁evidence ▁that ▁Pers ky ▁unf air ly ▁permitted . ▁Four ▁of ▁the ▁baseball ▁players ▁had ▁invoked ▁Fif th ▁Am end ment ▁rights ▁not ▁to ▁self - inc rim inate ▁during ▁the ▁discovery