▁deliber ations , ▁the ▁parties ▁were ▁allowed ▁to ▁submit ▁their ▁notes ▁and ▁other ▁arguments . ▁ ▁The ▁Supreme ▁Court ▁at ▁that ▁time ▁consisted ▁of ▁Chief ▁Justice ▁Roberto ▁Con ce pc ion , ▁and ▁Associ ate ▁Just ices ▁Qu er ube ▁Mak al int al , ▁C ali xt o ▁Z ald iv ar , ▁Fred ▁Ru iz ▁Castro , ▁En rique ▁Fernando , ▁Cla udio ▁Te e han kee , ▁Antonio ▁Bar red o , ▁Felix ▁Mak as iar , ▁Felix ▁Antonio ▁and ▁Salvador ▁Es guer ra . ▁Of ▁the ▁members ▁of ▁the ▁court , ▁Con ce pc ion , ▁Mak al int al ▁and ▁Z ald iv ar ▁were ▁the ▁just ices ▁not ▁initially ▁appointed ▁by ▁Mar cos , ▁Con ce pc ion ▁being ▁appointed ▁in ▁ 1 9 5 4 ▁( he ▁was ▁later ▁appointed ▁Chief ▁Justice ▁in ▁ 1 9 6 6 ), ▁Mak al int al ▁in ▁ 1 9 6 2 ▁and ▁Z ald iv ar ▁in ▁ 1 9 6 4 . ▁ ▁Dec ision ▁Chief ▁Justice ▁Roberto ▁Con ce pc ion ▁wrote ▁the ▁decision . ▁He ▁out lined ▁the ▁summary ▁of ▁facts , ▁then ▁his ▁own ▁diss ent ing ▁opinion ▁of ▁the ▁case ▁in ▁which ▁he ▁said ▁that ▁the ▁ 1 9 7 3 ▁Constitution ▁has ▁not ▁been ▁properly ▁rat ified ▁according ▁to ▁law , ▁and ▁then ▁proceeded ▁to ▁make ▁the ▁summary ▁of ▁votes ▁by ▁the ▁members ▁of ▁the ▁court . ▁ ▁The ▁issues ▁raised ▁were : ▁▁ ▁Is ▁the ▁issue ▁of ▁the ▁valid ity ▁of