, ▁The ▁Gro gg y ▁S qu ir rel ▁and ▁BBC ▁B eds , ▁H ert s ▁and ▁Buck s . ▁ ▁There ▁also ▁were ▁some ▁notable ▁poor ▁reviews ▁with ▁Broadway ▁Baby ▁brand ing ▁Pl ague ! ▁" a ▁m ild ▁r ash " ▁and ▁Fest ▁Magazine ▁comment ing ▁that ▁Pl ague ! ▁was ▁an ▁" an arch ic ▁sub version ▁of ▁the ▁musical ▁tradition " ▁im itated ▁from ▁the ▁Rock y ▁Hor ror ▁Show . ▁H air line ▁commented ▁that ▁although ▁Pl ague ▁is ▁a ▁" good ▁idea ▁with ▁nice ▁enjoy able ▁sections " ▁that ▁" more ▁thought ▁and ▁work ▁is ▁needed ▁to ▁produce ▁a ▁musical ▁that ▁can ▁play ▁to ▁a ▁Fr inge ▁audience ▁for ▁such ▁a ▁long ▁period ▁and ▁keep ▁them ▁engaged ▁and ▁ent hr alled ". ▁ ▁Pl ague ! ▁The ▁Musical ▁was ▁awarded ▁ 2 0 0 8 ▁sell - out ▁show ▁status . ▁It ▁was ▁also ▁named ▁a ▁Mer v yn ▁St utter ▁' P ick ▁Of ▁The ▁Fr inge '. ▁ ▁U . S . ▁Deb ut ▁ ▁Pl ague ! ▁The ▁Musical ▁opened ▁for ▁the ▁first ▁time ▁to ▁U . S . ▁aud ien ces ▁on ▁ 1 8 ▁October ▁ 2 0 1 3 ▁for ▁a ▁four ▁show ▁run . ▁ ▁Per formed ▁by ▁the ▁Mar ble ▁Valley ▁Play ers , ▁Verm ont ' s ▁oldest , ▁continu ously ▁operating ▁community ▁the ater ▁group , ▁it ▁deb uted ▁at ▁the ▁West ▁R ut land ▁Town ▁Hall ▁Theater ▁in ▁West ▁R ut land , ▁V T