ant an amo ' s ▁Child : ▁The ▁U nt old ▁Story ▁of ▁O mar ▁Kh adr ▁crit iqu ed ▁five ▁Gu ant an amo - related ▁books , ▁including ▁Rot unda ' s ▁Honor ▁B ound ▁which ▁she ▁called ▁"... ▁a ▁poor ly ▁written ▁personal ▁account ▁of ▁an ▁Army ▁J AG ▁that ▁gl oss es ▁over ▁critical ▁events ▁in ▁Gu ant an amo ' s ▁history ▁with ▁off hand ▁dismiss als ." ▁She ph ard ▁continued , ▁" There ▁is ▁some ▁interesting ▁legal ▁stuff ▁to ▁p onder ▁– ▁such ▁as ▁how ▁and ▁why ▁has ▁the ▁U . S . ▁administration ▁exceed ed ▁or ▁sid este pped ▁the ▁prote ctions ▁of ▁the ▁international ▁Gene va ▁Con vent ions ▁... ". ▁ ▁Special ist ▁in ▁Constitution al ▁Law ▁at ▁the ▁Library ▁of ▁Congress ▁Louis ▁Fish er ▁wrote ▁that ▁as ▁a ▁J AG ▁officer , ▁Rot unda ▁had ▁" a ▁good ▁opportunity ▁to ▁understand ▁the ▁military ▁comm issions ▁under way ▁at ▁" Git mo " ▁and ▁correct ▁mis con ception s ▁about ▁the ▁procedures ." ▁About ▁the ▁book , ▁he ▁wrote , ▁" For ▁readers ▁hoping ▁for ▁an ▁even - hand ed ▁assess ment , ▁the ▁initial ▁appearance ▁is ▁not ▁prom ising ." ▁Fish er ▁quotes ▁She p ard ' s ▁statement ▁that ▁the ▁U . S . ▁er red ▁in ▁" im pos ing ▁rules ▁that ▁made ▁it ▁difficult ▁for ▁pro sec utors ▁to ▁respond ▁to ▁defense ▁coun sel ▁claims ▁... ", ▁and ▁states ▁that ▁" The ▁book ▁never ▁explains ▁what ▁constraints ▁existed ▁...