▁Circ um st ant ial ▁Ev idence ▁is ▁the ▁nin th ▁album ▁by ▁American ▁R & B ▁group ▁Sh al amar , ▁produced ▁by ▁L . A . ▁Re id ▁& ▁Baby face , ▁Jerry ▁Peters , ▁and ▁K ly max x ▁found ing ▁member ▁Bern ad ette ▁Cooper . ▁ ▁Re leased ▁in ▁ 1 9 8 7 ▁on ▁the ▁S OL AR ▁label . ▁ ▁The ▁line - up ▁on ▁this ▁album ▁is ▁Del isa ▁Davis , ▁M icki ▁Free ▁and ▁Sydney ▁Justin , ▁the ▁latter ▁having ▁replaced ▁Howard ▁H ew ett , ▁who ▁had ▁left ▁the ▁group ▁in ▁ 1 9 8 6 ▁to ▁purs ue ▁a ▁solo ▁career . ▁ ▁Circ um st ant ial ▁Ev idence ▁pe aked ▁at ▁# 2 9 ▁on ▁the ▁R & B ▁chart ▁but ▁failed ▁to ▁register ▁on ▁the ▁Billboard ▁chart . ▁ ▁Track ▁listing ▁ ▁Person nel ▁M icki ▁Free ▁- ▁lead ▁& ▁backing ▁vocals , ▁lead ▁guitar , ▁rh ythm ▁guitar ▁Sydney ▁Justin ▁- ▁lead ▁& ▁backing ▁vocals , ▁key boards ▁Del isa ▁Davis ▁- ▁lead ▁& ▁backing ▁vocals , ▁key boards ▁Baby face ▁- ▁key boards , ▁rh ythm ▁guitar , ▁backing ▁vocals ▁Kay o ▁- ▁bass , ▁backing ▁vocals ▁L . A . ▁- ▁drums ▁( all ▁tracks , ▁except ▁" F em ale " ▁and ▁" W orth ▁Wait in ' ▁For ") ▁Bern ad ette ▁Cooper ▁- ▁bass , ▁drums , ▁key boards ▁(" F em ale "); ▁rap ▁(" Im ag inary ▁Love ") ▁Jerry ▁Peters