▁and ▁described ▁Mc Man us ▁as ▁" another ▁ch icken - in - a - b asket ▁div a " ▁with ▁an ▁" un remark able " ▁voice . ▁She ph erd ▁expressed ▁a ▁particular ▁lo ath ing ▁for ▁the ▁cover ▁version ▁of ▁N ina ▁Sim one ' s ▁" Fe elin ' ▁Good ", ▁which ▁according ▁to ▁her , ▁had ▁" the ▁g uts ▁ri pped ▁out ▁of ▁it ." ▁The ▁track ▁was ▁der ided ▁by ▁multiple ▁review ers . ▁ ▁Some ▁review ers , ▁while ▁unf av ou rable , ▁were ▁more ▁re cept ive ▁to ▁Mc Man us ' s ▁vocals . ▁Sh aron ▁Ma wer ▁in ▁All Music ▁saw ▁the ▁bulk ▁of ▁the ▁material ▁as ▁" very ▁bland , ▁tun eless , ▁and ▁un mem or able ", ▁but ▁comm ended ▁Mc Man us ' s ▁" und ou bt ed ▁talent ." ▁She ▁did , ▁however , ▁argue ▁that ▁Mc Man us ▁gained ▁public ity ▁more ▁for ▁" her ▁out s ized ▁weight " ▁than ▁her ▁singing . ▁Daily ▁Mir ror ▁critic ▁G av in ▁Martin ▁str essed ▁that ▁she ▁" can ▁actually ▁sing ", ▁but ▁observed ▁" some ▁of ▁the ▁most ▁hor r ifying ▁material ▁ever ", ▁with ▁song writing ▁that ▁is ▁" d rown ed ▁in ▁c liche , ▁seem ingly ▁knock ed ▁off ▁with ▁bare ly ▁a ▁thought ." ▁BBC ▁News ▁writer ▁Tom ▁Bishop ▁was ▁im pressed ▁by ▁Mc Man us ' s ▁" s oul ful " ▁singing ▁on ▁Pop ▁Id ol , ▁but