▁I ▁S aw ▁You " ▁with ▁Af anas ie ff , ▁a ▁song ▁that ▁would ▁truly ▁em body ▁some ▁of ▁her ▁earlier ▁work , ▁as ▁well ▁as ▁show ▁off ▁her ▁powerful ▁vocals . ▁Return ing ▁to ▁her ▁R & B ▁territory , ▁Care y ▁recorded ▁" Long ▁A go ", ▁the ▁second ▁song ▁she ▁wrote ▁alongside ▁Dup ri ▁and ▁Se al ▁which ▁contains ▁a ▁strong ▁hip ▁hop ▁background . ▁Her ▁vocals ▁in ▁the ▁song ▁were ▁described ▁as ▁" sl iding ▁over ▁the ▁ins istent ▁bass line ▁like ▁sil k ." ▁ ▁" M elt ▁A way " ▁was ▁a ▁song ▁Care y ▁produced ▁on ▁her ▁own , ▁and ▁co - w rote ▁with ▁Baby face . ▁The ▁song ' s ▁writing ▁and ▁production ▁were ▁" super b ". ▁with ▁each ▁verse ▁gl iding ▁into ▁its ▁ch orus . ▁According ▁to ▁Chris ▁Nick son , ▁" Under ne ath ▁the ▁Stars " ▁was ▁as ▁" strong ▁as ▁any ▁slow ▁jam ▁released ▁in ▁the ▁n inet ies , ▁and ▁one ▁that ▁would ▁find ▁a ▁lot ▁of ▁flav or ▁late ▁at ▁night ▁with ▁d anc ers ." ▁Another ▁song ▁that ▁brought ▁back ▁rem ind ers ▁of ▁older ▁dec ades ▁was ▁" F ore ver ". ▁The ▁throw back ▁was ▁featured ▁through ▁the ▁ch ord ▁changes ▁and ▁in ▁the ▁way ▁the ▁guitar ▁ar p eg g ios ▁" st ay ed ▁at ▁the ▁fore front ▁of ▁the ▁music ." ▁The ▁song ▁displayed ▁subt le ▁vocals ▁from ▁Care y , ▁as ▁well ▁as ▁an ▁und eni able ▁rich