ate ▁That ▁I ▁Love ▁You ", ▁a ▁song ▁co - produ ced ▁by ▁St arg ate ▁and ▁Ne - Y o . ▁ ▁Rob ▁She ff ield ▁of ▁Rol ling ▁Stone ▁wrote ▁that ▁Chris ▁Brown ' s ▁ 2 0 0 7 ▁single ▁" With ▁You ", ▁another ▁St arg ate - produ ced ▁song , ▁also ▁features ▁the ▁same ▁element . ▁He ▁wrote , ▁"' With ▁You ' ▁is ▁the ▁convin cer , ▁even ▁if ▁you ▁can ▁instantly ▁tell ▁that ▁producer ▁St arg ate ▁was ▁just ▁trying ▁to ▁roll ▁out ▁' I r replace able ' ▁one ▁more ▁time ." ▁while ▁Billboard ▁magazine ▁wrote ▁that ▁it ▁" leans ▁a ▁bit ▁too ▁heavily " ▁to ▁the ▁song . ▁ ▁Jim ▁De R og atis ▁of ▁the ▁Chicago ▁Sun - Times ▁wrote ▁that ▁" I r replace able " ▁res emb les ▁ball ads ▁s ung ▁by ▁Whit ney ▁Houston . ▁Sp ence ▁D . ▁of ▁I GN ▁wrote ▁that ▁the ▁song ▁was ▁inspired ▁by ▁Are tha ▁Franklin ' s ▁work ▁since ▁" I r replace able " ▁consists ▁of ▁several ▁variations ▁in ▁g utt ur als ▁and ▁oct ave ▁range . ▁The ▁lyr ics ▁of ▁" I r replace able " ▁concern ▁the ▁break down ▁of ▁a ▁woman ' s ▁relationship ▁with ▁her ▁boy friend ▁after ▁she ▁disco vers ▁his ▁inf idel ity , ▁and ▁the ▁song ▁" s ounds ▁a ▁lot ▁like ▁a ▁statement ▁of ▁independence ". ▁Sarah ▁Rod man ▁of ▁The ▁Boston ▁Glo be ▁wrote , ▁" With ▁a ▁her et