se ▁checks ▁Roland ' s ▁campaign ing ▁enthus ias m ▁with ▁a ▁real istic ▁assess ment . ▁At ▁the ▁battle ▁of ▁Cro ok stone ▁Mary ' s ▁forces ▁are ▁defeated , ▁and ▁Henry ▁Se y ton ▁and ▁George ▁Douglas ▁both ▁die . ▁ ▁Ch . ▁ 1 2 ▁( 3 8 ): ▁At ▁D und ren nan ▁ab bey , ▁Am bro se ▁and ▁Roland ▁encounter ▁Bon if ace , ▁still ▁a ▁gard ener , ▁who ▁tells ▁how ▁Julian ▁Aven el ' s ▁marriage ▁certificate ▁had ▁been ▁taken ▁from ▁him ▁in ▁a ▁pill aging ▁by ▁tro op ers ▁under ▁Sir ▁Hal bert . ▁Mary ▁leaves ▁for ▁England . ▁Adam ▁produces ▁the ▁certificate ▁of ▁the ▁marriage ▁performed ▁by ▁Father ▁Phill ip , ▁and ▁Roland ▁is ▁recogn ised ▁as ▁he ir ▁to ▁Aven el . ▁After ▁two ▁years ▁he ▁mar ries ▁Catherine , ▁in ▁spite ▁of ▁his ▁formal ▁ad option ▁of ▁Protest ant ism . ▁ ▁Re ception ▁Review ers ▁generally ▁wel com ed ▁The ▁Abb ot ▁as ▁a ▁return ▁to ▁form ▁after ▁The ▁Mon aster y ▁( the ▁absence ▁of ▁the ▁White ▁Lady ▁being ▁particularly ▁noted ), ▁and ▁some ▁even ▁saw ▁the ▁novel ▁as ▁ranking ▁with ▁W aver ley . ▁Mary ▁Queen ▁of ▁Sc ots ▁attract ed ▁much ▁pra ise , ▁though ▁often ▁qualified ▁by ▁disappoint ment ▁at ▁her ▁fond ness ▁for ▁s arc asm . ▁Catherine ▁was ▁found ▁striking , ▁but ▁her ▁tw in ▁brother ▁confused ▁the ▁reader ' s ▁view ▁of ▁her . ▁In ▁their ▁different ▁ways ▁George ▁Douglas ▁and ▁Adam ▁Wood