▁play ▁the ▁song ▁as ▁it ▁featured ▁ac oust ic ▁gu it ars ▁and ▁had ▁more ▁of ▁a ▁pop ▁appeal . ▁" But ▁then ▁it ▁became ▁the ▁biggest ▁urban ▁record ▁... ▁ever ," ▁[ H erm ansen ] ▁said . ▁ ▁Song writing ▁controvers y ▁ ▁A ▁controvers y ▁arose ▁over ▁the ▁writing ▁cred its ▁on ▁" I r replace able ". ▁Ne - Y o ▁told ▁MTV : ▁" App ar ently ▁Bey on cé ▁was ▁at ▁a ▁show ▁somewhere ▁and ▁right ▁before ▁the ▁song ▁came ▁on ▁she ▁said , ▁' I ▁wrote ▁this ▁for ▁all ▁my ▁ladies ' ▁and ▁then ▁the ▁song ▁came ▁on   ...   The ▁song ▁is ▁a ▁co - write . ▁I ▁wrote ▁the ▁lyr ics , ▁I ▁wrote ▁all ▁the ▁lyr ics . ▁Bey on cé ▁helped ▁me ▁with ▁the ▁mel od ies ▁and ▁the ▁harm on ies ▁and ▁the ▁vocal ▁arrangement ▁and ▁that ▁makes ▁it ▁a ▁co - write . ▁Mean ing ▁my ▁contribution ▁and ▁her ▁contribution ▁made ▁that ▁song ▁what ▁it ▁is ." ▁In ▁ 2 0 1 1 , ▁Ne - Y o ▁said ▁that ▁he ▁wrote ▁the ▁song ▁for ▁himself , ▁but ▁thought ▁that ▁it ▁would ▁be ▁better ▁su ited ▁for ▁Bey on cé . ▁Some ▁of ▁Bey on cé ' s ▁fans ▁read ▁Ne - Y o ' s ▁remark ▁as ▁dis res pect ful ▁towards ▁her . ▁However , ▁he ▁clar ified ▁his ▁comment ▁later ▁through ▁Twitter , ▁writing , ▁" I ▁said ▁I ▁originally ▁wrote ▁the ▁song ▁for ▁me .