All Things FinReg
SEC Demonstrates Flexibility and Engagement at FinTech Forum
By Andrew M. Ray , Emily Drazan Chapman , and Jillian Harris
Practitioners, academics, and entrepreneurs joined SEC regulators at the 2019 FinTech Forum hosted by the SEC's Strategic Hub for Innovation and Financial Technology (FinHub) on May 31 in Washington, DC. Panelists discussed a range of considerations on digital assets, including capital formation, trading and markets, investment management, and innovations in distributed ledger technology (DLT). In keeping with a positive trend that has emerged among the federal financial regulatory agencies, the forum demonstrated the SEC's desire for industry engagement and the depth of its knowledge in the emerging technology.
Tags: Blockchain, Broker-Dealers, Cryptocurrency, FinTech, Investment Advisers, Regulation, SEC, Technology
FinCEN Issues Guidance on Cryptos
By Charles M. Horn , Ignacio A. Sandoval , and Martin Hirschprung
// May 21, 2019
The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) recently issued guidance consolidating current FinCEN regulations, rulings, and guidance about cryptocurrencies and money services businesses (MSBs) under the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA). Along with the May 9 guidance, FinCEN issued an advisory to assist financial institutions in identifying and reporting suspicious activity or criminal use of cryptocurrencies.
Tags: Anti-Money Laundering, Banking, Blockchain, Broker-Dealers, CFTC, Cryptocurrency, FinCEN, FinTech, Regulation, Regulatory, SEC, Supervision and Examination
Basel Committee Warns of Crypto-Asset Risks to Banks
By Steven Lightstone
In a recently published statement, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) has raised concerns relating to the risks that crypto-assets pose to the global financial system. While it acknowledges that banks do not currently have significant exposure to crypto-assets, it warns that these assets are increasingly becoming a threat to financial stability.
These concerns are founded on the volatility, constant evolution, and lack of standardization of crypto-assets, which the BCBS believes exposes banks to liquidity, credit, operational, money laundering, legal, and reputational risks. It considers that crypto-assets should not be referred to as "cryptocurrencies," given that they fall short of being currencies that are safe mediums of exchange.
Tags: Banking, Blockchain, Cryptocurrency, Data Privacy, FinTech, International Supervision, Regulation, Regulatory, Supervision and Examination
Upcoming FTC Hearing Poses Risk to Financial Services World
By Nicholas M. Gess , Andrew M. Ray , and Mark L. Krotoski
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) will hold public hearings on March 25-26 in Washington, DC, on "Competition and Consumer Protection in the 21st Century." Titled, "The FTC's Role in a Changing World," the hearings pose downstream risk to the fintech community, especially to smaller enterprises that may lack the resources and knowledge to comply with any complex new regime.
Tags: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Federal Trade Commission, FinTech, Privacy
Passing FinTech Money to Indian Affiliates? Better Know the Rules!
By Andrew M. Ray
Our postings on All Things FinReg sometimes can take us far afield – in this case, to India.
Multinational companies, including those in the financial services and technology worlds, incorporate or acquire Indian subsidiaries to lower their costs and access a vast and growing market for customers and talent. If you want to be in India, however, you'll need to understand and engage with the complex—and sometimes mystifying—local regulatory regime, because not doing so may cost you, as well as your banks and other financial services providers.
Tags: FinTech, International Supervision, Technology
Big Words on Small Screens: Help for New Financial Products
By Nicholas M. Gess , Charles M. Horn , Andrew M. Ray , and Ronald W. Del Sesto, Jr.
Recent action by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) may bring some relief to fintech developers and the broader financial services industry as new products run into otherwise insurmountable regulatory hurdles that do not take into account or adapt to new technologies.
In a recent announcement by the CFPB's Office of Innovation, its director has proposed the creation of a "Disclosure Sandbox" to encourage trial disclosure programs.
The greatest concern for many new developers and possible funding sources for those developers is that a new and innovative product may not be able to provide disclosures in the same way that traditional products have done, simply because consumer device sizes are shrinking while the amount of information regulators are requiring to be displayed without "clicking through" many screens is increasing. This poses a conundrum for the developer, which must reconcile competing issues and demands, including the size of a device screen, the limits of human eyesight—and patience!—and the demands of regulators.
Tags: CFPB, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, FinTech, State AGs
European Supervisory Authorities Issue Report on Regulatory Sandboxes, Innovation Hubs
By Steven Lightstone , Jack Shawdon , Charles M. Horn , and Andrew M. Ray
The Joint Committee of the European Supervisory Authorities (the ESAs) issued a report on 7 January 2019 on the status of regulatory sandboxes and innovation hubs following consultations with national regulators across the European Union.
The report compares the innovation hubs and regulatory sandboxes established in 21 EU member states and three EEA states, flagging too that Hungary and Spain are in the process of establishing regulatory sandboxes.
Tags: Anti-Money Laundering, BCFP, CFPB, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Cryptocurrency, Data Privacy, FinTech, International Supervision, Payments, Privacy, Technology
Cryptoassets: The Current State of Financial Regulation at EU, UK, and US Levels
By Steven Lightstone , Andrew M. Ray , and Charles M. Horn
The ongoing and accelerating pace of developments in the realm of cryptoassets in multiple jurisdictions warrants continual review and monitoring. In a report issued earlier this month on the implications of cryptoassets, the international Financial Stability Board (FSB) stated that, while cryptoassets do not currently pose a material risk to global financial stability, vigilant monitoring is needed in light of the speed of market developments. The FSB believes that due to risks such as low liquidity and the use of leverage, market risks from volatility, and operational risks, cryptoassets lack the key attributes of sovereign currencies and do not serve as a stable store of value or a mainstream unit of account. The financial stability implications of these cryptoasset characteristics include an impact on confidence in, and reputational risk to, financial institutions and regulators; risks arising from financial institutions' exposures to cryptoassets; and risks arising if cryptoassets were to become widely used in payments and settlement. Therefore, regulators are encouraged to "keep an eye on things" as cryptoassets continue to spread throughout the world economy.
Court: Cryptocurrencies Are Commodities Even Without Futures
By Michael M. Philipp , Charles M. Horn , and Andrew M. Ray
As readers of our blog are aware, courts and regulators are playing catch-up when it comes to cryptocurrencies, and to interpreting existing laws and regulations as applied to these new and innovative offerings. One of these many important questions relates to whether virtual currencies are "commodities" within the meaning of the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and subject to regulation by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). A recent ruling by a US district court in Massachusetts held that a virtual currency (My Big Coin) is a commodity within the meaning of the CEA and is therefore subject to the anti-fraud authority of the CFTC, even though there currently is no futures contract on My Big Coin. My Big Coin is a Las Vegas-based creator of software that purportedly allows for the anonymous exchange of currency.
Tags: Blockchain, CFTC, Cryptocurrency, FCMs, FinTech, NFA, Supervision and Examination, Technology
The World's Sandbox: UK Financial Conduct Authority Announces Global Fintech Network
The UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) issued a press release on August 7 announcing that it has joined 11 other financial regulators from around the world to create the Global Financial Innovation Network (GFIN), building on its proposals earlier in the year to create a "global sandbox." The network is intended to provide fintech firms a more efficient way to interact with regulators as they test new ideas across different markets and to create a new framework for regulators to cooperate on areas of innovation. This announcement continues a regulatory trend of being more hospitable to fintech innovation, as we have previously discussed.
Charles M. Horn
BCFP
Broker-Dealers
Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection
Change in Washington
Customer Protection Rule
Customer-Due-Diligence
FCMs
Global Regulation and Supervision
International Supervision
Major Security-Based Swap Participants
Presidential Transition
Security-Based Swap Dealers
Security-Based Swaps
Supervision and Examination
TBAs