Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee
stated on October 30, 2018 in a campaign ad:
Says New York Rep. John Faso "cast the deciding vote" to try to kill health care protections provided by Obamacare.
By Stephen Koff November 5, 2018
Who's to blame for almost killing Obamacare? Democrats point to New York's John Faso
In 2017, as Republicans considered measures to repeal and replace Obamacare, the House Budget Committee took an important preliminary vote. It decided 19 to 17 to advance the American Health Care Act.
That means, the Democratic Party says, that Rep. John Faso of New York "cast the deciding vote to deny protections for pre-existing conditions." The claim is in a new ad the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee put on the air in the closing days of the race in New York Congressional District 19 south of Albany, where Faso faces a challenge from Antonio Delgado.
Faso, the DCCC says, could have stopped the whole bill, one that critics say could have been deeply harmful to people who need the protections the Affordable Care Act provides. It only failed later because the Senate lacked the support for its version.
Was Faso the deciding vote? Let's look at the math.
Budget committee vote
The committee vote on March 16, 2017, was 19-17. That means it passed by two votes. But if just one lawmaker who voted yes had voted no instead, the count would have been 18-18, a tie.
"It fails if it is a tie," DCCC spokesman Evan Lukaske told us. And that could have stopped everything that followed, he said.
Couldn't any of the others have done the same thing? How can you say one member was the deciding vote?
The DCCC allows that any member might have made a difference, but it doesn't mean Faso couldn't have been the key. Three other Republicans had voted no because they thought the bill didn't do enough to kill the health program. Regardless of reasons, Faso could have joined them. "He could have made the decision to kill it," Lukaske said.
In fact, the Times Herald-Record, a newspaper covering the Hudson Valley region, had a front page with Faso's picture and the headline, "Deciding vote," with a story saying the congressman kept the "controversial health care bill alive." The front page is shown in the DCCC ad.
The bill's problems
The committee vote was to move the bill along, a necessary step for putting the bill on the House floor. But Republican leaders including Speaker Paul Ryan acknowledged it would need changes to win full House approval.
When the Budget Committee voted, the bill had provisions calling for reducing Medicaid payments to states. It had language eliminating penalties for people who refused to buy health insurance. It called for changing the subsidy system for those buying coverage. And it would have relaxed the rule that said insurers could charge their oldest customers no more than three times the premiums they charged their youngest ones.
The Congressional Budget Office estimated that the bill, as it existed at that point, would have led to 14 million more people being uninsured in 2018, a figure rising to 21 million in 2020 and 24 million in 2026. Democrats and health policy groups warned that if states got less money for Medicaid, they would pare back their programs, inevitably leaving some people with fewer medical services or more hurdles for enrollment. They said older customers with private insurance would face price hikes, and the subsidies to help pay would be inadequate.
Featured Fact-check
stated on December 31, 2021 in an Instagram post
Tylenol "ruins your ability to kill" COVID-19.
By Samantha Putterman • January 5, 2022
Republicans supporting the bill pointed out that it included money to help states stabilize their insurance markets. The CBO said states would probably use those grants "to limit the costs to insurers of enrollees with very high claims."
At this point, would the bill have killed protections for pre-existing conditions, as the DCCC claims?
The answer is indirectly, it could have weakened protections -- but the question is academic because the House made changes to the bill before its May 2017 passage. One included an amendment allowing states to seek waivers from other ACA rules, including one that health policy groups said would have eroded requirements for providing medical services for patients who need them the most.
This could lead to a new round of debate on that final House bill, but we have covered that repeatedly and the point here is different: The DCCC says Faso could have stopped everything with his committee vote.
Our ruling
The DCCC says John Faso "cast the deciding vote to deny protections for preexisting conditions."
Before we rule, it's important to note that states had their own insurance rules before the ACA. New York already prohibited charging higher premiums based on health status. PolitiFact looked at this more fully when examining a related claim about Faso.
We are interested here in whether Faso was the deciding vote -- whether, as the ad suggests, he could have stopped it all. We need not go far to decide, because the same kind of claim was used by Republicans against Democrats in past elections, when Republicans blasted Democrats for passing the ACA in the first place. They noted how a procedural motion needed for the bill passed by a single vote.
Here were some of those claims:
Bill Nelson "the deciding vote" on the health care law (2012)
Warner cast "the tiebreaking vote" on Obamacare (2013)
Mark Udall 'passed Obamacare with his vote' (2014)
Russ Feingold cast deciding vote on Obamacare (2015)
There's more, but you get the gist. Faso was one of 19 House Budget Committee members who voted for the early version of the House repeal-and-replace bill last year. Had he voted no, things might have changed. But the same can be said for 18 others. To point out Faso as the singular villain or hero way overstates his role. Just as we did repeatedly on the ACA claim, we rate this claim Mostly False.
Share the Facts
PolitiFact Rating:
Democratic Party campaign arm
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=miuSDymfm20
A campaign ad
DCCC ad
Telephone and email exchanges with Evan Lukaske, Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee
Telephone and email exchanges conversation with Joe Gierut, spokesman for Faso campaign
House Budget Committee, vote on American Health Care Act, March 16, 2017
Congressional Budget Office, analysis of American Health Care Act, March 13, 2017
Families USA, "The MacArthur Amendment to Republicans' Health Care Bill Will Hurt Millions," May 2017
PolitiFact, "Did New York's John Faso break his promise to a woman with cancer?" Oct. 18, 2018
Read About Our Process
The Principles of the Truth-O-Meter
Browse the Truth-O-Meter
More by Stephen Koff
Mike Bost
stated on October 22, 2018 a campaign ad:
Says Brendan Kelly "allowed half of the criminals he faced to walk free" and "failed to protect women who were violently assaulted," allowing "those guilty of sexual assault to cut inexcusable plea deals."
By Stephen Koff • November 5, 2018
Environmental Defense Fund Action
stated on October 29, 2018 a mailer to Texas homes:
Says Texas U.S. Rep. John Culberson "was caught using campaign cash on collectibles, including Civil War memorabilia and fossils."
Gil Cisneros
stated on September 17, 2018 a spoof website:
Says California Republican Young Kim is "a tax cheat" who "illegally claimed a $7,000 annual homestead exemption on a house she wasn't living in," had "multiple tax liens placed on her" as a result and "owes over $10,000 in unpaid federal income taxes."
National Republican Congressional Committee
Says "billionaire George Soros bankrolls" Minnesota Democrat Dan Feehan, who is "employed by a Soros-funded liberal outfit in D.C." and his campaign is "propped up by out of state super PACs backed by Soros' millions."
By Stephen Koff • October 30, 2018
stated on October 20, 2018 a television interview:
"A lot of people are still dealing with lack of access to health care. There are counties out there, in my former Senate district, that didn't have doctors and providers."
Congressional Leadership Fund
Says Dan Feehan "would vote with Pelosi for open borders and amnesty, putting Minnesota families at risk."
Says "over 40 Republican leaders denounced" Steve Watkins' campaign
Maine Democratic Party
stated on October 5, 2018 a campaign mailer:
Say Maine U.S. Rep. Bruce Poliquin "voted to gut your retirement benefits."
Defending Main Street
stated on October 12, 2018 an ad:
Says Ohio congressional candidate Danny O'Connor "would make Columbus a sanctuary city for illegal immigrants."
Washington State Democratic Party
stated on October 9, 2018 a tweet:
Says congressional candidate Dino Rossi once suggested "the state build homes for unwed mothers."
stated on October 9, 2018 a campaign ad:
Says Washington's Kim Schrier has a plan to eliminate employer-provided health coverage, double income taxes and put your care "in the hands of government bureaucrats."
VoteVets.org
stated on September 27, 2018 a campaign ad:
Says Minnesota congressional candidate Jim Hagedorn supports a plan that would take away health care for 340,000 veterans, with 17,000 in Minnesota possibly losing coverage.
Tom Malinowski
Says New Jersey Rep. Leonard Lance voted repeatedly "to let insurance companies charge more to people aged 50 and over."
By Stephen Koff • October 9, 2018
Says Brendan Kelly "spent his career" supporting Nancy Pelosi.
stated on January 17, 2022 in a speech.:
Virginia's "education standards for math and reading are now the lowest in the nation."
By Warren Fiske • January 21, 2022
stated on January 16, 2022 in an interview on NBC's "Meet the Press":
"People are 7% poorer now because of Biden inflation."
By Louis Jacobson • January 20, 2022
stated on January 5, 2022 in a video on Facebook:
Omicron is "the fastest-spreading virus known to humankind."
By Monique Curet • January 20, 2022
Viral image
stated on January 18, 2022 in a post:
"Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor tests positive for COVID-19 despite triple vaccination, diligent masking and working from home."
stated on January 19, 2022 in a news conference:
"This country's working people actually got a raise."
By Jon Greenberg • January 20, 2022
"There (are) over 800 prison camps in the United States, all fully operational and ready to receive prisoners. They are all staffed and even surrounded by full-time guards, but they are all empty. These camps are to be operated by FEMA."
Michael Savage
stated on January 17, 2022 in a Facebook post:
Rabbi taken hostage in Texas synagogue is "anti-Zionist" who may have known gunman.
By Jeff Cercone • January 20, 2022
Photo shows Jeffrey Epstein and Kamala Harris posing together.
By Ciara O'Rourke • January 20, 2022
stated on January 16, 2022 in a tweet:
Novak Djokovic is the first professional athlete to be banned from a major sporting event for "not taking drugs."
By Samantha Putterman • January 20, 2022
stated on December 12, 2021 in an Instagram post:
"Blue Cross Blue Shield pays your doctor a $40,000 bonus for fully vaccinating at least 100 patients under the age of two."
By Vivian Lam • January 19, 2022