evidence: Hunter Biden's laptop and its contents have been a point of controversy since October 2020, weeks before the contested election, when Donald Trump's former lawyer Rudy Giuliani turned it over to police and the New York Post. The laptop eventually led to aggressive House investigations into President Joe Biden. But its more salacious contents, including explicit photos and videos of Hunter Biden, have continuously stoked the fire of controversy. It all started with John Paul Mac Isaac, the owner of The Mac Shop in Wilmington, Delaware, who said a man identifying himself as Hunter Biden brought in three liquid-damaged laptops in April 2019. One laptop was left behind, and Mac Isaac ended up sharing it with Rudy Giuliani's lawyer because he believed it would make him safer.