In 1971, Shutter began playing drums and percussion in the original four-piece band of the New York production of "Godspell",, playing on the cast album as well as the soundtrack for the ensuing film adaptation.
In 1971, Shutter began playing drums and percussion in the original four-piece band of the New York production of "Godspell", later performing with the Los Angeles company and a national tour. He also played on the cast album as well as the soundtrack for the ensuing film adaptation.