article_snippet: But judge Hilary Manley disagreed, saying that Rimmer attacked the victim with 'extreme force and viciousness'.
article_snippet: judge Hilary Manley added: 'judge Hilary Manley tried to resist and fight you.
article_snippet: judge Hilary Manley was an 84-year-old who had to use sticks when judge Hilary Manley walked.
article_snippet: 'judge Hilary Manley is clearly resilient and brave but
article_snippet: these offences have had a profound impact on judge Hilary Manley life... judge Hilary Manley's not spent a night at home alone since this incident.
article_snippet: This was a vicious and humiliating attack on a vulnerable and defenceless elderly woman, This must have been a terrifying experience for judge Hilary Manley. '