article_snippet: Shadie Assadtook out an order of protection against Assad in Manhattan Family Court when the couple, pictured here in May 2014, broke up .
article_snippet: The judge ordered a full order of protection against Livoti and Capriese Murray .
article_snippet: When the couple broke up, Livoti took out an order of protection against the bodybuilder in Manhattan Family Court.
article_snippet: The judge ordered a full and final order of protection for Livoti and Murray and Assad agreed to complete the New Start stalker program.
highlights_snippet: When Shadie Assad, 29, and Jill Livoti, 43, broke up she took out an order of protection against him .
  