article_snippet: Amy had arrived at her parents' house in Cocoa Beach, Florida after attending church services.
article_snippet: Police say Amy was the 'catalyst' for the 1994 killing .
article_snippet: Amy's parents survived Amy's parents wounds, but Amy did not.
article_snippet: Amy had two older brothers, Mark and Ryan.
article_snippet: The consensus tends to be that Amy's the catalyst. '
article_snippet: There's something there with Amy that probably caused this to happen.'
article_snippet: Anderson was involved in a police chase the day after Amy was killed and is currently in prison.
article_snippet: Poppell had a romantic relationship with Amy and police received a tip Anderson may have been involved in the murder after Anderson died in a hit-and-run accident in 2013.
highlights_snippet: Motive for slaying remains unclear, but police say 'Amy's the catalyst'
  Police have had suspects over the years but never made any arrests .
  