article_snippet.sent: Judge Anne Redston had acted entirely honestly and the UK Border Force repeated refusal to hand over the bag was irrational and disproportionate.
article_snippet.sent: Judge Anne Redston said Mrs Smouha - who birthday was approaching and Judge Anne Redston husband wanted to buy Judge Anne Redston a special present.
article_snippet.sent: Judge Redston said: 'Judge Redston was very sad to lose Judge Redston birthday present and had done everything Judge Redston could to remedy the position'.
article_snippet.sent: Judge Redston had even offered to 'pay a reasonable fine' so long as the bag was returned to Judge Redston.
article_snippet.sent: Ruling in Mrs Smouha's favour, Judge Redston said the Border Force had failed to consider the individual facts of Judge Redston case.
article_snippet.sent: Judge Redston gave the Border Force six weeks to reach a fresh decision in the light of Judge Redston ruling.