article_snippet.sent: Recorder Philip Cattan (pictured), 65, from Cheshire was seen to fall asleep during the rape trial of John Quingley at Manchester Crown Court .
article_snippet.sent: A Judge who fell asleep while a child abuse victim gave evidence and caused the rape trial of John Quingley at Manchester Crown Court to collapse has been reprimanded by A Judge who fell asleep while a child abuse victim gave evidence bosses .
article_snippet.sent: The part-time judge, Recorder Philip Cattan, 65, from Cheshire was seen to fall asleep during the rape trial of John Quingley at Manchester Crown CourtJohn Quingley at Manchester Crown Court Manchester Crown Court .
article_snippet.sent: While the jury was out of the room, the judge was confronted with the claim that the judge had slept through part of the cross-examination of the witness, who was giving evidence via videolink because of her age.
article_snippet.sent: Judge Gabriel Hutton, a former senior judge at Gloucester Crown Court, fell asleep during the trial of Lee Woodward, who was accused of raping a 17-year-old girl on a riverbank in Sharpness, Gloucestershire.
article_snippet.sent: Judge Hutton, now retired, was ordered to apologise for the incident.
article_snippet.sent: Manchester Crown Court, where Cattan was seen to fall asleep during the the case of John Quigley .
highlights_snippet.sent: Recorder Philip Cattan, 65, Cheshire, fell asleep during evidence of abuse .
  