ribbing disease ( multiple diaphyseal sclerosis ) is a rare form of bone dysplasia characterized by formation of exuberant but benign endosteal and periosteal new bone formation . it is either unilateral or asymmetrical and asynchronously bilateral , and has been reported only in long bones especially diaphysis of tibia and femur in postpubertal young adults . it is often initially diagnosed as low - grade osteomyelitis , but it may also be confused with other causes of increased bone density on radiological investigations ( sclerosing dysplasia ) like camurati - engelmann disease , van buchem disease , erdheim - chester disease , etc . 99mtc - methylene diphosphonate ( mdp ) bone scan has been described as a useful tool in diagnosing this entity and excluding other bone dysplasiae . we report here a case of ribbing disease , the diagnosis of which became possible due to bone scan . a 31-year - old female presented to an orthopedician with bilateral leg pain since 1 year . pain started in the right leg 6 months before the left leg , and at the time of presentation she had persistent pain on both sides , more on the right . , the patient did not have signs suggestive of vascular or muscular etiology of leg pain . she underwent a radiograph of both legs which showed cortical thickening of the diaphyses of both tibiae [ figure 1 ] . keeping the differentials of shin splints / stress fracture versus chronic osteomyelitis in mind a three - phase 99mtc - mdp bone scan [ figure 2 ] showed intense irregular uptake in the diaphyseal region of both tibiae in delayed static images . increased tracer activity was also noted in blood pool images in both legs . there were no other sites of bone involvement . the patient further underwent magnetic resonance imaging ( mri ) which revealed cortical thickening with bone marrow edema in bilateral tibial diaphysis along with minimal adjacent soft tissue edema [ figure 3 ] . the patient then underwent a tibial biopsy which revealed predominantly dense lamellar bone with irregular sized and spaced haversian systems [ figure 4 ] . taking all the clinical , biochemical , imaging and biopsy features into account , a diagnosis of ribbing disease was made . she is currently under follow - up and may need medullary rimming in case of failure to respond to peak analgesic dose . radiograph of bilateral legs anteroposterior view shows cortical thickening of the diaphyses of both tibiae , left more than right ( a and b ) anterior and posterior delayed phase images of 99mtc - mdp bone scan showing irregular increased uptake in the diaphyseal region of both tibiae ; rest of the skeleton shows physiologic uptake . ( c and d ) anterior and posterior pool phase images of 99mtc - mdp bone scan show increased uptake in the bilateral mid - calf region of both legs short tau inversion recovery coronal ( a ) and axial ( b ) images show cortical thickening ( arrows ) with bone marrow edema in bilateral tibial diaphysis t1w axial ( c ) image shows diffuse cortical thickening better photomicrographs of tibial biopsy specimen stained with h and e at low power ( 4 ) show predominantly dense lamellar bone with irregular sized and spaced haversian systems . . photomicrographs at higher magnification ( 40 ) demonstrate dense lamellar bone with fragments of normal cortical bone . ribbing described a family with six siblings for the first time in 1947 in which four of them had asymmetrical diaphyseal sclerosis of long bones . this was later found to be an uncommon cause of leg pain and in further case studies was called ribbing disease . it is important to differentiate this entity from the more common causes of bony leg pain like stress fractures , shin splints , osteomyelitis , fibrous dysplasia , osteoid osteoma , osteosarcoma , and other rarer causes like adamantinoma , melorheostosis , hyperphosphatasia , histiocytosis , lymphoma , intramedullary sclerosis , endosteal hyperostosis and sclerosteosis . the distinction between ribbing disease and camurati - engelmann disease ( progressive diaphyseal dysplasia ) has been unclear . it is a progressive disorder associated with pain , muscle weakness , fatigue , waddling gait , and anemia . though engelmann disease and ribbing disease may appear to be identical radiographically , seeger et al . engelmann disease presents with bilateral and symmetric bone involvement , whereas ribbing disease is either unilateral or asymmetrically and asynchronously bilateral . engelmann disease affects diaphyses of long bones and bones formed by intramembranous ossifications ; hence , the skull is involved almost as frequently as the long bones . ribbing disease has been reported only in the long bones . while engelmann disease features trabecular thickening , normal or enlarged haversian systems , and both osteoblastic and osteoclastic activity , implying bone formation and resorption , histologic study in ribbing disease shows osteoblastic activity alone and progressive obstruction of the haversian systems . makita et al . reported a three - generation japanese family with engelmann disease with a wide variation in phenotype among the affected family members . of the 12 patients , 7 had full manifestations of engelmann disease , while the other 5 exhibited only segmental ( rhizomelic and/or mesomelic ) involvement and asymmetric diaphyseal sclerosis without any clinical symptoms , resembling ribbing disease . the authors proposed that engelmann disease and ribbing disease represent phenotypic variations of the same disorder . ribbing 's disease presents with pain , and recent studies have demonstrated that marrow edema is often associated with , and may be responsible for , at least in part , this pain . the mri appearance and the prominent finding of pain in ribbing disease may be useful in helping to differentiate ribbing disease from intramedullary osteosclerosis , another diaphyseal dysplasia disease which bears perhaps the greatest clinical and radiographic similarity to ribbing disease . it does not appear that the mri finding of marrow edema is characteristic of intramedullary osteosclerosis . this finding leads to what has been thought to be a potential treatment for ribbing disease , the creation of a wide surgical  window  at the site of pain . one may also consider the diagnosis of painful transient tibial edema , which clinically resembles the presentation here . however , in that condition , the radiographs are usually normal . in ribbing disease , in addition , the markers of bone resorption like n - telopeptide , pyridinoline and deoxypyridinoline cross - links are also normal . together , these measures of bone metabolism would suggest that ribbing disease is not a  high turnover bone state , a finding which may help to differentiate it from camurati - engelmann disease . this seems to be inconsistent with the increased tracer uptake on 99mtc - mdp bone scan . in most bone diseases , where there is increased tracer uptake on bone scan the lack of elevation in bone turnover markers may be explained by the limited amount of the skeleton involved as reflected by the focal nature of the uptake . that is , the area of involved bone may have been too small to affect the overall turnover markers . however , this is not necessarily inconsistent with the limited literature at the histological level that is available about ribbing disease , which fails to identify a pattern suggestive of either a preponderance of osteoblastic or osteoclastic activity . the treatment of ribbing disease is mainly symptomatic and is done with nonsteroidal anti - inflammatory drugs in increasing dose as required . however , biphosphonates have been used in some cases of ribbing and camurati - engelmann diseases , with discordant outcome ; however , the low bone turnover that seems to characterize this disease and the prevalence of osteoblastic activity over the osteoclastic action are probably the reasons why osteoclast inhibitors may have limited success . our case illustrates that a three - phase 99mtc - mdp bone scan has a very important role to play in the diagnosis of ribbing disease . firstly , it can rule out shin splints and stress fracture as the etiology of pain . increased uptake restricted to the tibiae / femora can rule out other bone dysplasiae like camurati - engelmann disease , which have a more extensive involvement . also , the nature and pattern of uptake can exclude primary neoplasms and metastases . a close differential on bone scan seems to be chronic osteomyelitis , especially since the onset of ribbing disease may be unilateral and both diseases exhibit increased tracer activity on all three phases of the bone scan . since the uptake of mdp is dependent on the osteoblastic response , it may be worthwhile trying to correlate the disease activity , patient symptomatology and tracer uptake . we conclude that 99mtc - mdp bone scan is probably the most helpful investigation in cases of bony leg pain where dysplasiae like ribbing disease are suspected .
ribbing disease is a rare form of sclerosing dysplasia characterized by benign endosteal and periosteal bone growth confined to the diaphyses of the long bones , usually the tibiae and femora . 
 it occurs after puberty and is more commonly seen in women . 
 the most common presenting symptom is pain that is usually self - limited ; however , progression is known . 
 the etiology and optimal treatment for the disease are as yet undefined . 
 we present here the case of a 31-year - old woman with clinical , radiological and bone scan manifestations of ribbing disease corroborated by bone biopsy . 
 radiographs demonstrated cortical thickening of the diaphyses of both tibiae . 
 99mtc - methylene diphosphonate bone scan revealed intense irregular uptake in diaphyseal region of both tibiae . 
 magnetic resonance imaging showed cortical thickening with bone marrow edema in bilateral tibial diaphysis with minimal adjacent soft tissue edema . 
 bone biopsy revealed predominantly dense lamellar bone with irregular sized and spaced haversian systems . 
 serum and urine markers of bone metabolism were within normal limits . 
 the patient was treated with analgesics , and had partial relief from pain . 
 medullary rimming is the next treatment option in case pain progresses . 
 this report emphasizes the role of bone scan in the diagnosis of this rare condition .