although the survival rates of patients with gastric cancer have markedly improved owing to early diagnosis via nationwide screening programs as well as due to radical surgery in eastern countries including korea and japan , gastric cancer remains the fourth leading cause of death in the world and the second - ranked cause of death among cancers in korea [ 1 , 2 ] . radical surgery for gastric cancer is the major key to curing patients with this disease [ 1 , 3 ] . in gastric cancer , the depth of the primary tumor and the number of metastatic lymph nodes ( lns ) the extent of ln metastasis , in particular , has been considered a key independent prognostic factor . based on the tumor - node - metastasis ( tnm ) system , treatment plans are determined and the outcomes are predicted for gastric cancer . there have been several changes to the american joint committee on cancer ( ajcc ) tnm staging system . in the 4th edition of the ajcc tnm staging system , n stage was described based on the extent of anatomical lymphatic spread ( less than or greater than 3 cm from the primary tumor ) . however , according to the 5th and 6th editions of the ajcc tnm system , n stage was classified based on the number of metastatic lns . in 2010 , the ajcc / union internationale contre le cancer ( ajcc / uicc ) revised the staging systems of the tnm classification for gastric cancer . major changes were adopted in the 7th edition , including revisions of the pt and pn classifications . the subgroups pt2a and pt2b were reclassified in the new edition as pt2 and pt3 , respectively . moreover , major modifications were adopted with respect to the number of metastatic lns considered for prognosis . the earlier classification of pn1 stage ( 16 involved regional lns ) was revised to pn1 ( 12 involved regional lns ) and pn2 ( 36 involved regional lns ) , and the earlier pn3 subgroups ( > 15 ) were merged into a new pn3 subgroup ( > 6 involved regional lns ) . as a whole , the number of lns for staging n category was significantly decreased compared with that described in the 6th edition of the tnm staging system ( where at least 16 resected lns were required ) . however , in the new staging system the cutoff number of lns is not included . since the revision of the staging system of gastric cancer , a large amount of literature concerning the prognostic implications of the 7th edition has been published . most of the studies found the 5-year survival rates for each edition of the ajcc / uicc tnm staging systems to be significantly different from each other from the viewpoints of eastern and western countries . some reports described that the 7th staging system was better than the 6th [ 7 , 8 ] . on the other hand , therefore , we evaluated the 7th ajcc / uicc tnm staging system based on collected data from a single center regarding 1,435 gastric cancer patients who were surgically treated by a single surgeon in order to compare the prognostic implications of each edition of the tnm system , focusing on n stage . we analyzed our prospectively collected database of 1,435 consecutive patients who were treated at the memorial jin - pok kim korea gastric cancer center , seoul paik hospital , inje university , from september 1998 to august 2003 . all patients underwent radical subtotal or total gastrectomy according to the guidelines of the japanese research society for the study of gastric cancer , including radical d2 ln dissection , performed by the deceased professor jin - pok kim . survival time was calculated from the day of surgery to the last day of follow - up or the date of tumor - related death . overall survival was defined as the time between the date of surgery and the date of death . the last day of follow - up was january 10 , 2009 , and the average length of follow - up was 82 months ( 55123 months ) . statistical analysis was performed using spss statistics software ( version 19.0 ; spss inc . , chicago , il , usa ) . the kaplan - meier method was used to estimate time - dependent survival probabilities . cox proportional hazards models were used to investigate the multivariate association of clinical parameters and survival . this study group included 983 ( 68.5% ) male patients and 452 ( 31.5% ) female patients , resulting in a male - to - female ratio of 2.29 : 1 . the mean age of the patients was 56.7 years , with a range of 2185 years . the total number of resected lns was 69,395 , and the mean number of resected lns was 48 ( 5130 ) . according to the 6th edition staging system , the number of metastatic lns was 0 ( n0 ) in 662 patients ( 46.1% ) , 16 ( n1 ) in 326 patients ( 22.7% ) , 715 ( n2 ) in 195 patients ( 13.6% ) , and more than 15 ( n3 ) in 252 patients ( 17.5% ) . according to the 7th edition , the number of metastatic lns was as follows : 0 ( n0 ) in 662 patients ( 46.1% ) , 12 ( n1 ) in 147 patients ( 10.2% ) , 36 ( n2 ) in 183 patients ( 12.7% ) , 715 ( n3a ) in 191 patients ( 13.3% ) , and more than 15 ( n3b ) in 252 patients ( 17.5% ; table 1 ) . the comparative study of 5-year survival rates according to the 6th and 7th editions of the n - stage system showed the following results ( table 1 ) . according to the 6th edition , the 5-year survival rates were as follows ( p < 0.001 ) : stage ia ( 92.7% ) , ib ( 89.1% ) , ii ( 82.4% ) , iiia ( 67.5% ) , iiib ( 41.5% ) , and iv ( 24.2% ) . based on the 7th edition , the 5-year survival rates for each stage were the following : stage ia ( 95.6% ) , ib ( 84.2% ) , iib ( 75.7% ) , iiia ( 66.0% ) , iiib ( 35.4% ) , and iiic ( 35.2% ) , respectively . in the n stage of the 6th edition , the 5-year survival rates of patients were as follows ( p < 0.001 ; fig . 1 ) : n0 ( 92.8% ) , n1 ( 77.2 ) , n2 ( 50.3% ) , and n3 ( 24.9% ) . in the 6th edition staging system in contrast , survival curves for n stage according to the 7th edition were as follows ( p < 0.001 ) : n0 ( 92.8% ) , n1 ( 77.0% ) , n2 ( 78.1% ) , n3a ( 54.1% ) , and n3b ( 30.6% ) . there was no difference in terms of survival between n1 and n2 : the kaplan - meier plots of survival curves between n1 and n2 stages overlapped significantly ( p < 0.05 ) ( fig . the statistical assessment of the predictive value of the two scoring systems revealed no superiority of the 7th edition of the staging system ( uicc 2010 ) when compared with the 6th edition ( 2002 ) concerning ln stage . the  score for the 6th edition was higher than that in the 7th edition , indicating that the n classification in the 6th edition has better discriminatory ability in terms of survival than that of the 7th edition staging system ( fig . this study group included 983 ( 68.5% ) male patients and 452 ( 31.5% ) female patients , resulting in a male - to - female ratio of 2.29 : 1 . the mean age of the patients was 56.7 years , with a range of 2185 years . the total number of resected lns was 69,395 , and the mean number of resected lns was 48 ( 5130 ) . according to the 6th edition staging system , the number of metastatic lns was 0 ( n0 ) in 662 patients ( 46.1% ) , 16 ( n1 ) in 326 patients ( 22.7% ) , 715 ( n2 ) in 195 patients ( 13.6% ) , and more than 15 ( n3 ) in 252 patients ( 17.5% ) . according to the 7th edition , the number of metastatic lns was as follows : 0 ( n0 ) in 662 patients ( 46.1% ) , 12 ( n1 ) in 147 patients ( 10.2% ) , 36 ( n2 ) in 183 patients ( 12.7% ) , 715 ( n3a ) in 191 patients ( 13.3% ) , and more than 15 ( n3b ) in 252 patients ( 17.5% ; table 1 ) . the comparative study of 5-year survival rates according to the 6th and 7th editions of the n - stage system showed the following results ( table 1 ) . according to the 6th edition , the 5-year survival rates were as follows ( p < 0.001 ) : stage ia ( 92.7% ) , ib ( 89.1% ) , ii ( 82.4% ) , iiia ( 67.5% ) , iiib ( 41.5% ) , and iv ( 24.2% ) . based on the 7th edition , the 5-year survival rates for each stage were the following : stage ia ( 95.6% ) , ib ( 84.2% ) , iib ( 75.7% ) , iiia ( 66.0% ) , iiib ( 35.4% ) , and iiic ( 35.2% ) , respectively . in the n stage of the 6th edition , the 5-year survival rates of patients were as follows ( p < 0.001 ; fig . 1 ) : n0 ( 92.8% ) , n1 ( 77.2 ) , n2 ( 50.3% ) , and n3 ( 24.9% ) . in the 6th edition staging system in contrast , survival curves for n stage according to the 7th edition were as follows ( p < 0.001 ) : n0 ( 92.8% ) , n1 ( 77.0% ) , n2 ( 78.1% ) , n3a ( 54.1% ) , and n3b ( 30.6% ) . there was no difference in terms of survival between n1 and n2 : the kaplan - meier plots of survival curves between n1 and n2 stages overlapped significantly ( p < 0.05 ) ( fig . the statistical assessment of the predictive value of the two scoring systems revealed no superiority of the 7th edition of the staging system ( uicc 2010 ) when compared with the 6th edition ( 2002 ) concerning ln stage . the  score for the 6th edition was higher than that in the 7th edition , indicating that the n classification in the 6th edition has better discriminatory ability in terms of survival than that of the 7th edition staging system ( fig . in this study , we sought to evaluate the usefulness of the 7th ajcc / uicc tnm staging system in patients with gastric cancer . according to our analysis , in the 6th edition of the ajcc tnm staging system , the kaplan - meier curves discriminated each n stage significantly . however , according to the 7th edition , the kaplan - meier plots of survival curves between n1 and n2 stages overlapped significantly ( p < 0.05 ) . there are many reports describing limitations of the 7th edition of the ajcc / uicc tnm staging system . in a western study group , patel et al . reported that in a group of 1,905 patients from the american population , the 7th edition of the staging system distinguished outcomes poorly , and the authors proposed a revised grouping allocation . a report including 1,767 european gastric cancer patients claimed that the 7th edition had become more complex , without predictability for overall survival in the western population , and supported some revision of the 7th edition of the ajcc / uicc tnm staging system . showed the prognostic superiority of the 6th edition n - stage classification system in terms of homogeneity , discriminative ability , and monotonicity of gradients compared with the n classification of the 7th tnm staging , which showed similar survival curves between n2 and n3a , and the authors provided references for the revision of a future edition of the ajcc / uicc system for gastric cancer staging . likewise , another italian group reported that the 7th uicc n stage does not seem to be superior to the 6th uicc n stage in patients with fewer than 6 positive lns . in an asian study group , jung et al . proposed a new pn classification due to the low power discrimination between pn1 and pn2 , despite the fact that the 7th edition of the tnm classification proved to show significant differences in prognosis for each stage . another study of 1,799 patients from south korea did not show significant differences in the survival rates between each stage , especially for stages ib , iia , and iib , because of inappropriate n classification , and the authors suggested a new tnm system with a different n classification . however , some other reports support the usefulness of the 7th edition of the ajcc / uicc tnm staging system for gastric cancer . an eastern study with 1,503 gastric cancer patients reported that the kaplan - meier plot for the 6th edition did not show discriminative survival curves for n2 versus n3 , but the 7th edition kaplan - meier plot showed discriminative survival curves between each n stage ; therefore , the authors concluded that the 7th edition of the ajcc / uicc tnm staging system is superior to the 6th edition . another eastern study in china with 456 gastric cancer patients also reported that there was a significant difference in the 5-year survival rates between the n1 and n2 substages of the 7th ajcc / uicc the authors found no significant prognostic difference between the n2 and n3 substages of the 5th/6th ajcc / uicc n stage , and concluded that the 7th ajcc / uicc the studies based in china can be discussed here because the sample sizes of the n3a and n3b groups are much smaller than those in other studies . moreover , the authors did not perform subgroup analysis between n3a and n3b , nor did they comment on the mean number of total retrieved lns . unwarranted stage migration may appear as a result of the lower power of discrimination in the 7th n stage , especially between n1 and n2 , in cases of fewer numbers of total retrieved lns . reported that the 7th edition of the staging system is superior to the 6th edition . however , more than 50% of the patients analyzed by them had fewer than 15 affected lns . moreover , this study did not show significant differences in the survival rates between n1 and n2 in patients with fewer than 6 metastatic lns , although , on the other hand , there was distinct discrimination of survival curves between n3a ( 715 ) and n3b ( > 15 ) based on the 15 retrieved lns . the overlap between the n1 and n2 stages in the kaplan - meier plots of survival curves for the 7th edition might have been influenced by the small cutoff number of lns between the n1 and n2 stages out of the average 46 resected lns in our institute . although there have been controversies related to the extent of ln dissection to cure stomach cancer , kim et al .   reported that radical ln dissection with more than 26 resected lns improved survival in patients with stage ii and iiia disease per the 6th edition staging system ( with emphasis on extensive lymphadenectomy ) out of an average number of 31 dissected lns . the paradoxical results concerning the comparison of the 6th and 7th edition staging systems between each of the reports might be due to the number of lns analyzed . in a randomized nationwide dutch trial , d2 lymphadenectomy was associated with lower locoregional recurrence and gastric cancer - related death rates than d1 resection . therefore , the authors emphasized that d2 dissection is the standard surgical approach for resectable gastric cancer . using data from a large us population database , smith et al .   reported that there is an optimal number of lns to be examined for proper staging and survival prediction . they analyzed the surveillance , epidemiology , and end results ( seer ) data and concluded that the greater the number of lns examined , the better the resulting postgastrectomy survival of patients with t1 - 3n0 - 1 gastric cancer . they also found that the trend towards superior survival outcome could be followed up to ln counts greater than 40 . survival prediction was more accurate when at least 15 nodes were examined , which is essential for an adequate n - stage classification . however , this condition for the 7th n - stage classification staging system leads to stage migration and misunderstanding of the disease when few lns have been examined [ 17 , 18 ] . therefore , some studies have been carried out on the ratio of metastatic lns , which could be a useful prognostic indicator in combination with the tnm staging system [ 1 , 19 , 20 ] . a small ln ratio despite the large number of metastatic lns might be due to the extended ln dissection . if the ln dissection were less extensive , the ln ratio would have been higher with poor prognosis . the evaluation of the ln ratio might be influenced by the extent of dissection performed by the surgeon . for accurate pathologic evaluation , the number of metastatic lns out of dissected lns should be included to calculate the ratio , and the ln ratio can then be used as a prognostic factor for stomach cancer : a sufficient amount of lns should be retrieved first , this study included a relatively small sample size generated from a single institution experience , compared with a worldwide gastric cancer collaboration database . however , this study showed significant differences in survival curves for both tnm staging systems except the 7th n classification . second , the pt stage could not be reevaluated by pathologists because this was a retrospective study , and thus an unwarranted stage migration phenomenon could occur . despite the limitations of our analysis , the 6th uicc n - stage classification system was superior to the 7th classification staging system . we suggest further revisions to develop a new tnm staging system with appropriate n - stage classification . approval for this study was obtained from the institutional review board of the ethics committee of the haeundae paik hospital , inje university college of medicine , korea . all procedures followed were in accordance with the ethical standards of the responsible committee on human experimentation ( institutional and national ) and with the helsinki declaration of 1975 .
backgroundthe validity of n classification of the 7th edition of the american joint committee on cancer / union internationale contre le cancer ( ajcc / uicc ) tumor - node - metastasis ( tnm ) staging system is still under debate . 
 the purpose of this study was to evaluate the prognostic efficacy of the 7th edition of the ajcc / uicc tnm staging system ( focusing on n stage ) , in comparison with the 6th edition , at a single eastern institution.methodswe analyzed 1,435 patients with gastric cancer who underwent curative resection performed from september 1998 to august 2003 at the memorial jin - pok kim korea gastric cancer center . 
 we analyzed the survival rate of the patients according to the ajcc / uicc 6th and 7th editions , and compared each stage , focusing on n stage.resultssignificant differences in the 5-year survival rates were observed between the 6th and the 7th ajcc / uicc staging system . in the 6th edition staging system , the kaplan - meier curves discriminated each n stage significantly . in contrast 
 , there was no difference in terms of survival curves for n stage according to the 7th edition , especially between n1 and n2 : the kaplan - meier plots of survival curves between n1 ( 77.0% ) and n2 ( 78.1% ) stages overlapped significantly ( p < 0.05).conclusionalthough the 7th uicc staging system is a more detailed and sophisticated system in the t category , there was no prognostic significance between the pn1 and pn2 stages according to our data . 
 therefore , we suggest establishing a new uicc staging system taking into consideration the application of the n stage .