a number of functional electrical stimulation ( fes ) systems have been proposed to date that are intended to allow individuals with neurological disorders to stand [ 114 ] , with some of them applying closed - loop control strategies in order to facilitate arm - free standing [ 15 , 10 , 11 , 13 , 14 ] . while some of these systems have been partially successful in facilitating arm - free standing , they may not necessarily become practical applications in the near future due to a number of remaining challenges and limitations . one important challenge is that an optimal control strategy for a closed - loop controlled fes system has not been identified to date . among other reasons , this can be attributed to the fact that it is very difficult to directly test the isolated performance of an fes control strategy in human subjects . for example , contributions of other body parts that are not controlled by the fes system are oftentimes not foreseeable while differences or changes in a stimulated muscle 's capacity can modify or even compromise the performance . the current study is set out to develop a platform for testing different control strategies for a closed - loop fes system for ankle joint control during quiet standing , by isolating this joint 's action in the standing posture . for this purpose , we developed a device called inverted pendulum standing apparatus ( ipsa ) that consists of a human - size inverted pendulum with a point mass at the height of body center of mass and a standing frame that supports the standing posture . ipsa was developed based on the notion that the dynamics of human stance can be modeled as an inverted pendulum with a point mass at the height of the body 's center of mass rotating around the ankle joint . the ankle joint is the primary joint that controls the equilibrium of the body 's center of mass regardless of other joints ' movement as the ankle joint is the first joint contacting the external environment via rigid feet segments . thus , controlling the ankle joint is the first priority when controlling the entire body . subjects with and without disability in lower - limb muscles can stand on the ipsa with support of a standing frame . in this condition , the plantar- and dorsiflexors are completely relaxed   such that we can test the isolated performance of a given fes control system . by regulating the fes intensity , muscle contractions of the user 's plantar- and dorsiflexors are modified , modulating in turn the inclination angle of the inverted pendulum . by means of this setup , only the subject 's muscles around the ankle joint are utilized , implying that no other body segments contribute to the behavior of the inverted pendulum . thus , by assessing the  performance  of the inverted pendulum , we are also able to directly evaluate the performance of the tested fes control strategy . it should be emphasized that a similar device has been developed by loram 's team [ 18 , 19 ] with the goal of studying human balance control in healthy people . in addition , we have reported on the use of ipsa in a pilot study , which demonstrated that a pid control strategy can successfully stabilize the human size pendulum via ankle joint control .  in light of this , the objectives of the present study were to ( 1 ) report on the design of the ipsa and ( 2 ) demonstrate the use of the ipsa including principles of experimental setup and execution , including the feasibility of using the ipsa to test various fes controllers . for the latter objective , proportional - derivative ( pd ) control strategies were used with the goal of regulating the ankle joint position during standing via fes . the pd controller was chosen based on our previous studies suggesting that it can be a good model of the physiological controller for quiet standing [ 2123 ] and that a pd - controlled fes system can ensure stable stance by modulating calf muscle contractions . figure 1 shows a photograph of the ipsa setup . the ipsa consisted of ( 1 ) an inverted pendulum ; ( 2 ) a standing frame that is used to secure the subject during the experiments ; ( 3 ) two connected foot plates on which the subject stands and places his or her feet . note that the ankle joints are aligned with the center of rotation of the foot plates , which are attached to the inverted pendulum and controlling its movement ; ( 4 ) a torque transducer that measures the resultant torque at the rotational axis ; and ( 5 ) a sensor system for measuring the pendulum angle . the static components of the ipsa included a base plate , a support structure , bearings , and stoppers ( figure 2(a ) ) . three metal tubes , a wall , and two safety stoppers were securely bolted to the base plate . the stoppers were placed to prevent the pendulum from swaying beyond the normal ankle joint range and , thus , reduced the risk of injury to the subject from excessive ankle joint movements . the moving components of the ipsa included the main shaft , end shaft , foot plates , and inverted pendulum ( figure 2(b ) and 2(c ) ) . the latter served as the support into which the inverted pendulum was inserted and locked into place in an upright position . the foot platform , held in place by two side supports , acted as the base for the foot plates onto which the subject 's feet were placed . the two foot plates were separated by 15  cm and were bolted to the foot platform . the inverted pendulum was designed so that its mass and the location of its center of mass could be changed . the mass was changed by stacking lifting weights onto the pendulum as shown in figure 1 , and spacers could be used to translate the added mass to varying heights in 1  in . the pendulum weighed 17.2  kg but was designed to hold a maximum of 90  kg of additional weight , that is , a total maximum weight of 107.2  kg . in order to determine the total moment of inertia of the moving components of the ipsa about the common rotational axis , the moments of inertia of the inverted pendulum , shafts , foot platform , and side supports were individually computed and then summated , resulting in a total moment of inertia of 4.98  kgm . a laser displacement sensor ( lk-2500 , keyence , japan ) with an accuracy of 10  m was utilized to measure the angle of the ipsa 's inverted pendulum . a reaction torque sensor ( ts11 - 200 , durham instruments , germany ) with an accuracy of 0.05  nm was implemented to record the resultant torque at the rotational axis of the inverted pendulum . fes was applied by means of an electrical stimulator ( compex motion , compex sa , switzerland ) . 5  cm  5  cm electrodes ( stimtrode , axelgaard co. , ltd . , usa ) , coated with hypoallergenic gel , were used to deliver the electric current to the nerves innervating the plantarflexors . two channels of stimulation were used , one channel for each plantarflexor ( right and left legs ) . note that the dorsiflexors ( e.g. , tibialis anterior muscles ) were not required to be activated since only plantarflexors are active during natural quiet standing as the body accelerates forward in the natural standing position . when larger body sway fluctuations are expected ( such as during perturbed standing ) the electrodes for the plantarflexors were placed along the midline of the posterior side of the calf muscles . the anode was placed above the gastrocnemius muscles and the cathode above the achilles tendon . a rectangular , biphasic , asymmetric , charge - balanced , and monopolar stimulation waveform with a pulse duration of 300  s and a stimulation frequency of 40  hz were used in the experiments . the stimulation current was either fixed or controlled by the applied pd controller , depending on the experimental conditions described below . three healthy and young individuals participated in this study ( subject a : age 22 yrs , height 180  cm , and weight 80  kg ; subject b : age 26 yrs , height 180  cm , and weight 83  kg ; subject c : age 21 yrs , height 172  cm , and weight 60  kg ) . each subject gave written informed consent to the experimental procedure , which was approved by the local institutional ethics committee in accordance with the declaration of helsinki on the use of human subjects in experiments . four conditions were tested with each subject : ( 1 ) no stimulation ( i.e. , voluntary control of the ankle muscles ) ( nostim ) ; ( 2 ) a pd controller with a larger derivative gain ( pdstimld ) ; ( 3 ) a pd controller with a smaller derivative gain ( pdstimsd ) ; and ( 4 ) stimulation with a constant current ( conststim ) . adequate  controller gains for pdstimld were selected based on our previous finding that the postural control system during quiet stance adopts a control strategy that relies heavily on velocity information [ 22 , 23 ] . each task lasted for 60 seconds or until the pendulum movement was interrupted by the safety stoppers . in the two closed - loop conditions ( pdstimld and pdstimsd ) , a pd control strategy was employed with a constant offset value corresponding to the gravity toppling torque of the ipsa ( table 1 ) . in conststim , the average stimulation intensity during pdstimld was used as the constant stimulation intensity ( table 1 ) . the first trials were performed in the order of nostim , pdstimld , pdstimsd , and conststim to identify the stimulation intensity for conststim , whereas the remaining 24 trials were randomized . prior to the testing , the subjects were allowed to familiarize themselves with both the ipsa and the electrical stimulation . since the subjects were mechanically supported by the standing frame , although we believe that voluntary and reflexive contributions to controlling the pendulum were minimal during the fes tasks , this was not verified . the pendulum angle and torque ( sampled at 100  hz and low - pass filtered using an 8th - order butterworth filter with a cutoff frequency of 10  hz ) , measured using a customized labview program ( version 8.0 , national instruments , tx , usa ) , were used to assess the performance within each condition . in cases of successfully stabilized trials ( i.e. , trials that lasted for 60 seconds ) , we calculated the root mean square ( rms ) of the measured pendulum angle and torque and compared the averages of the three trials per subject across the different conditions . figure 3 exemplifies the angle and torque fluctuation of the pendulum during the four different conditions . for the conststim and pdstimsd conditions , the generated ankle torque was inadequate for stabilizing the system , causing the pendulum to drop . the unstable behavior was observed for all 18 trials ( 3 subjects , 3 trials , and 2 conditions ) associated with these two conditions . the time duration from trial start to pendulum drop was 8.10  2.12 seconds for conststim and 13.21  3.23 seconds for pdstimsd ( mean  one standard deviation for all subjects ) . for both the nostim and pdstimld conditions , the generated ankle torque dynamically stabilized the pendulum for the entire trial length of 60 seconds . this behavior was observed for all 18 trials ( 332 ) associated with these two conditions . table 2 presents the standard deviations of the measured angle fluctuation for all subjects and both conditions . the standard deviations indicate that the pendulum in pdstimld was stabilized in a similar manner as in nostim . these experiments demonstrate that , by examining the angle and torque fluctuations of the ipsa pendulum , we can evaluate the ability of the controller to adequately regulate plantarflexor activity . second , we tested ipsa , showing that it ensures the safety of the subject and at the same time keeps the subject in the standing posture as required for evaluating fes control systems . we demonstrated that pdstimld stabilized the subject 's body sufficiently well ( i.e. , equivalently well to nostim ) while pdstimsd and conststim did not , probably due to the use of inappropriate control strategies ( i.e. , insufficient amount of derivative gain or not facilitating time - varying calf muscle contractions ) . these results suggest that ipsa can be a useful platform for designing fes control systems in a well - controlled manner . that is , using the ipsa , we can directly assess the performance of a particular fes controller for ankle joint regulation while eliminating the effect of contributions from other body segments . using the ipsa for studying different fes control strategies for standing has the following benefits : ( 1 ) supported by the standing frame , individuals with paralysis in their lower limbs can safely participate in the testing ; ( 2 ) since the standing frame allows the lower limb muscles to be completely relaxed during standing , also able - bodied individuals can participate in the testing ; ( 3 ) since the weight of the inverted pendulum can be gradually increased , the performance of different fes control strategies can be tested without the risk of damaging joints and/or falling ; and ( 4 ) in contrast to testing an fes control strategy in supine or prone position , we can accurately replicate natural muscle damping and stiffness during quiet standing , which has been shown to significantly contribute to the control mechanism of that postural task [ 21 , 24 ] . also loram 's team designed an inverted pendulum that was stabilized via ankle torque modulation during standing [ 18 , 19 ] . while their system was capable of measuring pendulum torque and angle as well , their body support mechanism did not include passive knee stabilization for ensuring complete elimination of natural plantarflexor activity during standing . in addition , the device did not feature safety stoppers and lacked flexibility with respect to weight application . these differences are not surprising as their system was not intended to be used for developing fes control strategies in different populations but rather to study human balance control in healthy people . in this study , we solely focused on the ankle joint and its movement in the anterior - posterior direction using an artificial inverted pendulum . the reason for choosing the ankle joint was that it plays a key role in maintaining balance of the entire body , being the closest joint to the contact surface during standing [ 17 , 2225 ] . in addition , we adopted an artificial pendulum rather than a human - body pendulum ( with braces for all joints except for the ankle joint ) in order to ensure the rigidity of the pendulum . such a setup also allows researchers to modify the load relatively easily , which is beneficial for investigating adequate fes control strategies . however , to realize an fes controller for arm - free standing , it is obvious that we need to also examine adequate fes control strategies for other joints ( such as knee and hip [ 7 , 8 , 14 ] ) and other degrees of freedom ( such as the medial - lateral direction ) . for this purpose , more sophisticated systems such as the multipurpose rehabilitation frame developed by matjaci et al . are more adequate as they allow studying other joints and joint activity in lateral movements . another challenge that could be encountered when developing a practical fes controller for arm - free standing is the effect of residual muscle activity , which could happen , for example , in case of individuals with incomplete spinal cord injury . as the ipsa with its standing frame provides an environment that allows zero muscle activity , it can be used to develop fes controller without residual muscle activity . at the same time , residual muscle activity , if present , can pose an unexpected disturbance for the developed fes controller . while there is no conclusive solution for this issue at this time , we demonstrated that a pd control strategy facilitated a patient 's stability during quiet standing who exhibited residual muscle activity . the ipsa was developed to help engineers and scientists test , characterize , and select controllers that are suitable for closed - loop fes control . as demonstrated in this paper , the ipsa represents an adequate platform for studying fes control of standing in general and for ankle joint regulation in particular . however , the ipsa can also be used for examining fes control strategies intended for other applications and for the regulation of other joints , for example , to characterize temporal dynamics , noise rejection , or fatigue compensation during fes .
the restoration of arm - free standing in individuals with paraplegia can be facilitated via functional electrical stimulation ( fes ) . in developing adequate control strategies for fes systems , 
 it remains challenging to test the performance of a particular control scheme on human subjects . in this study 
 , we propose a testing platform for developing effective control strategies for a closed - loop fes system for standing . 
 the inverted pendulum standing apparatus ( ipsa ) is a mechanical inverted pendulum , whose angular position is determined by the subject 's ankle joint angle as controlled by the fes system while having the subject 's body fixed in a standing frame . 
 this approach provides a setup that is safe , prevents falling , and enables a research and design team to rigorously test various closed - loop controlled fes systems applied to the ankle joints . 
 to demonstrate the feasibility of using the ipsa , we conducted a case series that employed the device for studying fes closed - loop controllers for regulating ankle joint kinematics during standing . 
 the utilized fes system stimulated , in able - bodied volunteers , the plantarflexors as they prevent toppling during standing . 
 four different conditions were compared , and we were able to show unique performance of each condition using the ipsa . 
 we concluded that the ipsa is a useful tool for developing and testing closed - loop controlled fes systems for regulating ankle joint position during standing .