Kelly Clarkson covered " That I Would Be Good " during her " All I Ever Wanted Tour " , being mashed up with Kings of Leon 's " Use Somebody " . It was later recorded and included on her third EP '' The Smoakstack Sessions Vol . 2 '' released along with her '' Greatest Hits : Chapter One '' album . For Jessica Sager of '' Pop Crush '' , " it 's an unexpected combination , but thematically and sonically , they work together perfectly , " also praising Clarkson 's vocals on " That I Would Be Good " , writing that , " Clarkson replaces the Canadian crooner ’s warbling with her own soulful pipes . " Alex Nagorsi of '' MuuMuse '' wrote that , " Clarkson ’s soaring vocal range takes center stage to deliver a powerhouse performance . " The song appeared on the popular teen drama '' Dawson 's Creek '' twice in relation to one of the show 's lead characters , Jennifer , played by Michelle Williams . Singaporean singer Stefanie Sun covered the song on her album '' Start ''
All I Ever Wanted Tour
All I Ever Wanted Tour
That I Would Be Good