In 2013 , John Boone and Jennifer Cady of E! Online placed the song at number eight on their list of Beyoncé 's ten best songs , writing " Every now and then Bey likes to get a little funky , like on this reggae-infused dancehall tune that finds our naughty girl cooing Donna Summer-style ... Sexiest . Disco . Ever . " " Naughty Girl " was nominated in the category Best R&B / Soul Single by a Female Artist at the 2005 Soul Train Music Awards . Beyoncé was awarded the " Songwriter of the Year " — shared with Scott Storch , Robert Walker , Angela Beyincé , and Donna Summer — at the American Society of Composers , Authors and Publishers ' 2005 Pop Music Awards . It also won the " Most Performed Songs " award , along with " Baby Boy " and " Me , Myself and I " . In 2015 , '' Complex '' named the single one of 15 best songs produced by Scott Storch
2005 Soul Train Music Awards
2005 Soul Train Music Awards
Naughty Girl (Beyoncé song)