With Wentz as the band 's lyricist and Stump as the primary composer , the band 's 2005 major-label breakthrough , '' From Under the Cork Tree '' , produced two hit singles , " Sugar , We 're Goin Down " and " Dance , Dance " , and went double platinum , transforming the group into superstars and making Wentz a celebrity and tabloid fixture . Fall Out Boy received a Best New Artist nomination at the 2006 Grammy Awards . The band 's 2007 follow-up , '' Infinity on High '' , debuted at number one on the '' Billboard '' 200 with 260,000 first week sales . It produced two worldwide hit singles , " This Ai n't a Scene , It 's an Arms Race " and " Thnks fr th Mmrs " . '' Folie à Deux '' , the band 's fourth album , created a mixed response from fans and commercially undersold expectations . Following the release of '' Believers Never Die – Greatest Hits '' , the band took a hiatus from 2009 to 2012 to " decompress " , exploring various side projects
2006 Grammy Awards
48th Annual Grammy Awards
Fall Out Boy