Controversy erupted when the winner of Season 1 , Kelly Clarkson , was invited to sing " The Star-Spangled Banner " in a deal arranged by her then management company , 19 Entertainment , at a special commemoration for the first anniversary of 9/11 attacks at Washington 's Lincoln Memorial . Some critics suggested that Clarkson 's appearance would turn a somber occasion of national mourning into a " giant promotional opportunity " . Kelly Clarkson herself considered withdrawing from the commemoration , saying " I think it is a bad idea ... If anybody thinks I 'm trying to market anything , well , that 's awful . " and added " I am not going to do it . " She was however unable to withdraw from the event
9/11 attacks
September 11 attacks
American Idol (season 1)