Season 1 pitted Chocolate Charlie ( Mike Toomey ) , Dieter , Rob Garguilo , and Dumb ( Shaun Street ) competing to win a 2011 Kia Soul . The challenges were as follows : After the SuccessTech Academy school shooting on October 10 , 2007 , the " Rover 's Morning Glory " website leaked a crime scene photo taken of the gunman after his suicide . A Cleveland policeman , Walter Emerick , was later found to have taken the picture using his personal cell phone camera . Rover stated on the air it was his intent to show kids the real final result of a school-shooting ( the perpetrator lying dead ) . Steve Loomis , president of the Cleveland police union , claimed the picture could have been taken for legitimate evidentiary purposes
SuccessTech Academy school shooting
SuccessTech Academy shooting
Rover's Morning Glory