Andrea 's death received a polarized reaction . For " Welcome to the Tombs " , IGN writer Eric Goldman disliked that the finale rested its dramatic conclusion on Andrea 's death . AV Club writer Zack Handlen said that Andrea would be " missed less " than Milton . Erik Kain of Forbes.com said that " Finally , Andrea is dead . I know this is something I ’ve wished for all season , but it almost felt cheap at the end . " Conversely , Josh Jackson , writing for '' Paste '' called the death " a heartbreaking end for the woman who tried to make between the two gangs of survivors . " Despite the negative reception Andrea received for the third season , Holden was nominated for a Saturn Award for Best Supporting Actress for her work on '' The Walking Dead '' in 2013 , and won
Saturn Award
39th Saturn Awards
Andrea (The Walking Dead)