About five or six weeks later the '' Fair American '' arrived at the Island of Hawaii where Kameeiamoku was waiting at Kaūpūlehu . The schooner 's crew of five were easily overwhelmed and four were killed , including Thomas Metcalfe . The lone survivor was Isaac Davis . King Kamehameha I found out about the incident when another sailor , John Young , was captured by Kamehameha 's men when he came ashore from the '' Eleanora '' to inquire about the '' Fair American '' . Kamehameha decided to spare the lives of Davis and Young , who became valued military advisors during his subsequent battles and negotiations with later visitors
Kaūpūlehu
Kaupulehu, Hawaii
Olowalu, Hawaii