I admire Dr. Brant Pitre a great deal as a Scripture scholar. My wife and I used some of his books in our homeschooling, and I have many on my bookshelf. Unfortunately, Dr. Pitre seems to be out of his depth in the area of liturgy. A video presentation of his on "Active Participation" (released a month ago on YouTube) commits many historical blunders and draws a number of false conclusions, as Gregory DiPippo explains at New Liturgical Movement. These are not small matters, particularly at a time when efforts are being made to shut down the TLM because of its supposed "defects."