“Bryan Range pleaded guilty in 1995 to a state misdemeanor for lowballing his income on a form to get food stamps. He was put on probation and paid $2,458 in restitution. Decades later, federal law still bans him from owning a gun.

On Monday, however, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals ruled en banc, 13-2, that this doesn’t satisfy the Bill of Rights. “The record contains no evidence that Range poses a physical danger to others,” Judge Thomas Hardiman writes in Range v. Attorney General United States.”