As a cowboys fan, I would trade McCarthy for Tomlin 100 times out of 100. Tomlin makes a decent team with terrible talent. Remember at the start of the year analysts thought there was no way the steelers would go .500? His team overperformed.  

The cowboys just did cowboy things. Got all our hopes up at the start of the year and proceeded to play like crap for the first half of the season. These two teams and coaches are not the same.