Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Civil War Stereotyping
Review: Brutish father, ailing mother, strong-willed oldest daughter, ill-starred son, stalwart servant, and, a rescuer from the North. No surprises, no insight, no complexity. While is it clear that Gibbons is attempting to convey one woman's intimate knowledge of the suffering wrought by slavery and paternalism, she oversimplifies the nature of the players, distilling the Civil War down to "South bad, North good". Gibbon's Emma Garnet and her busband, Quincy, are preachy to boot. Give me a genuine narrative any day.
