Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: A great overview of responses to the problem of evil
Review: Though some of the authors (particularly Phillips and Roth) do not offer theodicies proper, this books provides an excellent overview of theodicies and other responses to the problem of evil from some the foremost philosopher/theologians engaging this topic. While the interactions between the authors following each essay allows for further discussion beyond the initial essays, it could benefit strongly from an atheistic author strongly arguing for the problem of evil (though the atypical theologies of Roth, Griffen, and Phillips to offer some support for the problem of evil).
