Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Difficult to Reconcile with other Historical Writings
Review: This book is very difficult to reconcile with other historical works. After all, the relevant time period is only a few hundred years ago when, believe it or not, people were able to write! As a result, there are many, many, documents which conflict with the author's conclusions. For an enjoyable opposing view, I suggest one read Undaunted Courage by Ambrose who describes the use of firearms during the Lewis and Clark expedition. Or consider the writings of Jefferson, Hamilton, and other historical figures as another source.My overall impression is that the author's methods need to be questioned. There is too much conflicting information that we know to be accurate to declare this book a credible work. Who should we believe - Bellesiles or Thomas Jefferson and Meriwhether Lewis? My suggestion is don't bother to buy this book unless you enjoy the irritation of someone trying to prove to you the earth is square based upon esoteric records.
