Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: A well written, slick portrait of some of the facts...
Review: I have read this book, dozens others about Everest and the account by the guide Anatoli entitled The Climb. It seems to me, that the facts that John Krakauer chose to include and the ones that he chose to leave out misinformed the public about the horrible tradgedy on Everest. Anatoli's discription of events, albiet less well written, not slick, picturesque writing, was much more convincing of the facts. I feel heart sorry for any of the survivors of the victims that Everest claimed on that fateful journey. Even more sorry now that John Krackauer has belittled the vicitms themselves in his story version of the event. It is sad when Disney choses to dramatize historic events, it is far sadder when a good writer like John Krackauer does it. If you like this book, and I am sure that you will, please do yourself a favor and read the real story by Anatoli entitled The Climb. It is the real deal
