Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: An underachievement. Not very good scholarship.
Review: I settled down to read this book, hoping I would find a stimulating rejoinder to Richard Noll's work, and was disappointed. If this is the best critique of Noll that the Jungians can muster, then the Jungian community is in deep, deep trouble. Shamdasani detests Noll -- and that is the only fact one learns after reading this short book. I wasted my money buying it. I would urge others to pass on this one and wait for more sophistated works of Jung criticism to appear.
