Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Buy it!
Review: Even if you don't "believe" you can teach a baby to read, this book is well worth it. It gives you advice on how to encourage your baby to improve and you to improve as parent. Those who criticize the technique obviously never read the book. The author encourages any baby the opportunity to read regardless of the technique. The only reference to phonics is that it is not needed, as your baby will know how to read before phonics can be started. The only complaint I have is the parent/baby relationship is always referred to as mother and son. Though up front the author says that sexism is not intended, it would not have been that difficult for it to be rewritten not to imply it.
