Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Yes, great descriptions but a bit labored, no?
Review: I'm not sorrry I plowed through this book, but I sure wouldn't give it a great review. "Atonement" is so crammed with (yes, beautiful) details that I found it claustrophobic and too dense. I wasn't crazy about the way McEwen leapt through time either, didn't register with me as true, not even true, certainly far from the best fiction. I don't recommend buying this. If you must see what all the fuss is about, go to a library.What the fuss is about is his natural talent, obvious hard work and character development. I know that sounds like more than enough but for me it was decidedly less than enough. 2 stars only
