Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Very disappointed
Review: My book club selected this book based on the strength of "The Adventures of Cavalier & Clay" and because Chabon is such a gifted writer. I was very disappointed with this book.This follow-up to the Pulitzer winner is regrettably self-indulgent. Not sure who the intended audience is but it wasn't me. It seemed like Chabon couldn't decide whether he wanted to write a fantasy, an homage to 40's detective mysteries or a love story. In my view, he did none of these. And the ending is so preposterous that it exceeded my 'willing suspension of disbelief' limits to such a degree as to insult my intelligence.All that said, there are a few passages that are sheer magic but all they do is remind you that this is a failed attempt by a very gifted writer.
