Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Not very convincing
Review: I read Shamdasani's book together with the two books by Richard Noll. When you compare the books, it is clear that Noll's scholarship is thorough, devestating to Jung, and convincing. Shamdasani's book, which at 144 pages is actually more of a pamphlet, is a strange, mean-spirited, attack on Noll that borders on the personal. It is an odd book that seems to have been written in a jealous rage. Obviously Noll is the more talented scholar, and Shamdasani wastes his arguments on trying to undermine Noll without offering anything new and convincing. It is not surprising that this book has not been reviewed by serious publications, as Noll's have. Thank goodness I did not buy this book, but read it in one long sitting in the cafe at Borders. Shamdasani's book is a waste of time and money. Don't buy it.
