Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Indespensible
Review: If you have any interest in pre 1970's sci-fi and fantasy, this is the definitive catalog. Tuck includes some comments on the merits of certain works, but devotes most of his efforts to including primary source citations for just about everything cited, as well as original data if the first source was a periodical. Tuck also includes biographical data and references to works on important authors, and includes lists of stories for compilations. Keep in mind that the complete set is three volumes and is 920 pages. I see that some sellers are only selling two or even one of the volumes. The first two volumes are alphabetical listings of authors. The third volume is titled "Misc," and includes LOTS of important other things, such as pseudonyms, periodical info, international listings of publishers and works, and lots lots more. This is not for the casual science fiction reader, but more for collectors, completists, book sellers, and refrence librarians.
