Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Looked like scholarship - turned out to be fabricated
Review: I'm afraid that Michael Bellesiles has done a terrible dis-service to those of us striving for reasonable gun control. Like the other side in this debate, we look for good scholarship that lends an historical basis to our efforts. Mr. Bellesiles has effectively besmirched the good efforts of others in the crusade to limit the second amendment to the "collective right" theory. After reading his book, and then watching as honest, dis-interested scholars tore it to shreds, I've begun to doubt that I'm on the right side. John Lott and David Kopel are honest, while our champion has proven to be a ... I don't want to be on the side of this debate that resorts to lies and falsified history. I don't want to be on the side that stoops to treachery to win its battle. This author's bizarre excesses, cloaked as scholarship, have effectively bankrupted a cause I used to believe held the moral high ground.
