Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Great concept; ok writing
Review: I am fascinated by Turtledove's analysis of how WWI would have progressed with this lineup of combatants. It apprears that he has an excellent grasp of the way WWI *actually* was, in the trenches, on the seas, and among those planning (and bungling) strategy. The actual characters are interesting and compelling, but their motivations and words sometimes do not ring true. Oh well; a small price to pay for a very interesting and compelling series of books. My prediction: the USA technically wins, but it's more of a "draw", with the CSA and Canada losing some territory, but remaining as adversaries of the USA. Will we see a WWII trilogy in the future?
