Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: One sided, inconsistent, incomplete, and lacking depth
Review: As others have stated, this book is clearly one sided and leaves out important detail to the accomplishments that Sheridan did make along with his subordinates. The book reads like Sheridan is on trial, strategically leaving out the other side of the argument and the opinions of those subordinates who felt neutral or highly of him. Quoting southern commanders and soldiers who have a poor opinion towards Sheridan doesn't have much of an effect. Many of the North's commanders and successes had negative and misinformed reviews by the media and commanders in the confederacy throughout the war. Georgia's and Richmond's news papers claimed that Sherman's troops were on the run and were fragile all the way through his march to the sea, but we know how that ended up. They treated Sheridan no different
