Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: It showed so much promise...
Review: How long have SW fans waited for a Halcyon novel? Too bad this one isn't it. Nejaa should have been a high point in the Clone Wars novels, and instead we're shown a foundering, outcast Jedi who can apparently only associate with a Padawan.The action in this book is not compelling; the strategies are basic at best; and some of the Expanded Universe knowledge is wrong. The authors imply, through Halcyon, that marrying among Jedi is rare, even for Corellians. However, the (much better) book I, Jedi states that Corellians were known for doing things differently, staying in their own planetary system (it took a galactic war to bring them out) and training their own padawans. Halcyon's placement as an outcast was a horrible mischaracterization and it ruined an already mediocre book.Cross your fingers for Stackpole to write a real Nejaa Halcyon novel. Don't bother with this one in the mean time; the bad characterizations and sloppy plotting will only dishearten you.
