Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: An Excellent Reference Guide.
Review: I'm a big fan of Roger Ebert's guides, but Maltin is excellent in his own way. Maltin is a critic who isn't afraid to state his true opinion. Sonme criticts think that if a movie makes no sense, they need to look smart and talk about how brilliant it is, while Maltin will just say, "It makes no sense." Maltin is also a critic who appreciates the value of widescreen (there's even a widescreen guide on different aspect ratios in the book!) and will say when a movie must be viewed in letterbox format. He's clearly a man who appreciates great cinema and this 2004 guide features a very cool section about excellent films that have been forgotten. Some people complain that they don't agree with Maltin, but any mature person would realize we all have our opinions and whether yours and a critics' are the same is no reason to bash that critic. If you want a useful, pratical and honest guide to films over the 20th century and to today, this is the excellent guide to pick up.
