Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: A very dishonest author
Review: Stinnett widely misrepresents hundreds of his documents Earlier this year he had to shut down his OWN message board at his website because of MANY angry readers demanding answers for his sloppy research. The biggest 3 mistakes are, 1 misrepresenting the McCollum document, also Stinnett imcorrectly states that McCollum's office was as "an element of Station US (by which he means OP-20-G), a secret American cryptographic center located at the main naval headquarters" in an poor effort to tie McCollum closer to OP-20-G before WWII.Second, he lumped both the simple code JN-25A that was in effect until 1 Dec 1940 with the a much more complicated code JN-25B a code that provided no significant decrypts until early 1942. And third he makes the mistake about radio silence. The Japanese never did transmit. The sworn statements of 11 Japanese officers, diaries of a DD XO and the official BatDiv 3 and CarDiv 5 logs that all agree to this well known fact.
