Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: It's a nice movie - a pity they didn't make the Two Towers
Review: Well, as I suspected upon watching this in the theater, this movie reveals the lack of appreciation amongst the director and cast for Tolkien's books. At several places they mention how little they think about the way Tolkien developed this or that character or plot element. They completely misunderstand what Tolkien was saying about Faramir's character, and where they do retreat to an almost-Tolkienian love story between Aragorn and Arwen, they admit that this was after trying to make Arwen into a warrior and failing.The movie is entertaining, and the casting, staging and effects are superb. It's just a shame they decided not to make Tolkien's story into a movie. This one is along the lines of "inspired by" fluff.
