Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Disappointing treatment of a great album
Review: This is a disappointing treatment of a great album. "Dusty in Memphis" is not only Dusty Sprignfield's best piece of work, it's one of the best albums ever, a true soul classic. Sadly, Zane doesn't do his homework, failing to discuss how the album was actually put together--why Dusty chose the songs she did, who played on what track, the musical context of the time, etc. He commits the worst sin of a critic in that he talks more about himself (i.e., the fact that he once saw a southern woman take off her clothes in front of window!) than the work he is reviewing. Zane really doesn't seem to know much about this album or the South. Much of what he says would get flagged in your average college essay. Unfortunately, rock criticism can sometimes be some of the worst writing you can find. "Dusty in Memphis" deserves better.
