Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Interesting. Repetitive. Speculation.
Review: I find the topic of what animals are thinking to be very interesting. My son is autistic, so some of the points in the book were useful. I do have a bias towards believing that animals are more aware than people, expecially scientists, give them credit for being. Some of the specific examples she uses to illustrate her agument get bothersomely repetitive (yellow rain coat, black hat). Towards the end of the book, her tangent about animal consciousness goes beyond what is supportable by research. I'm inclined to agree, but could see where people who are not would find it problematic.
