Negative Positive
Title: THE BEST BOOK
Review: 4TH GRADE STUDENT FROM TULSA, OKLAHOMA:SHILOH IS a GREAT FANTASTIC sad book. There is this boy named Marty who sees this dog and he falls in LOVE with it. But it is JUDD TRAVERS' dog. He treats his dogs wrong, so Marty keeps shiloh. He builds a dog pen but a German Sheperd gets in and injures Shiloh. It is by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor.I LOVED IT!! CHECK IT OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Is the review positive or negative? 