Negative Positive
Title: SLOPPY, BORING, and COPIED, OH MY!
Review: Ok, let's get things straight, Paolini really needs to come up with his OWN story. This book is pretty much a cauldron of books thrown together. Not only that, but the descriptions and dialogue are so boring and predictable, you could fall asleep. The main character is also supposed to be bright, but he is surprisingly stupid, and it does not help the story. I am a MAJOR fan of Tolkien and the similarities between that book and Eragon, and Eldest are astounding. I mean, just looking at the map, Furnost, Melian, Hadarac Desert umm I wonder where he got that from? LETS SEE!FORNOST, MELIAN THE MAIA, and HARAD!!! Its apalling at what this guy has written. SOOOO many similarities, it should really should not even receive a 1. Maybe some ignorent teens or adults and even little kids may like this, but if ur a hardcore fan of most medieval fantasies, don't even bother...-Lord Iluvatar Ambarenya Earendil
Is the review positive or negative? 