Negative Positive
Title: Not the work, but the publishing!
Review: Bottom line: Love the work, hate the editors and printers.This book (especially the first 30 pages) is rife with printing errors, misplaced punctuation, and phantom paragraphs. Who edited this book?!The work itself is truly brilliant. Evolutionary thought has come a long way from the theory of slow and rolling accent to punctuated equilibrium, but don't let the limited knowledge of science stop the argument. I think the brilliance of the work comes from the pure questioning of what science and the men of Chesterton's age are getting at. Chesterton is the gadfly.
Is the review positive or negative? 