Negative Positive
Title: Pumpkins have changed. But is it for the better?
Review: I'm one of those Pumpkins fans that fell in love with Gish and Siamese Dream. Even though I'm glad Chamberlain is back as the drummer (his presence was dearly missed), the Pumpkins lack the melodies and musical talent that they have shown in the past. Seems to me that in the early days, it was only about the music. Now the band is a commercial figure with a bald headed lead singer that is promoting more of an image than music itself. In the old Pumpkins music, Billy Corgan only sang when he had to which let the music shine through. And when he did sing, he wasn't screaming his lungs out like he does these days.
Is the review positive or negative? 