Negative Positive
Title: Rather sad to me, sorry Brian
Review: I saw a headline saying this was possibly a contender for the greatest rock album of all time so I bought it right away. I had seen the tail end of the documentary about the production and was amazed and happy to see Brian seemingly doing so well. My expectations were high I suppose but in all honesty I must say I found this album to be a sad disappointment. I must agree with a previous reviewer and say I find this to be a total hodge-podge of pieces of songs that probably should never have seen the light of day. The attempt to emulate "Sgt. Pepper's" is unmistakeable but woefully inadequate. If it weren't so sad it would almost be funny. There are some beautiful moments but they are few and far between and I doubt I'll even listen to it again anytime soon. Perhaps there are some things that are better left undone.
Is the review positive or negative? 