Negative Positive
Title: Not the best whale CD
Review: A rare misfire from the Sittelle label, as most of their nature CDs have at least some merit, this collection of whale sounds is a close-to-unlistenable mess. The recordings used here have appeared on other CDs and tapes I have heard (they are listed as copyrighted by the Marine Mammal Fund), and a lot of them are muddy sounding and flat. If you are looking for whale CDs, you'd be better off with Roger Payne's classics like "Songs of the Humpback Whale" or the boxed set "The Sounds of Marine Mammals in the Wild," which have better sound quality.
Is the review positive or negative? 