Negative Positive
Title: Ah, youth.
Review: Amazing? The best book ever? Incredibble [sic] writing? Ahhh...to be young and stupid again! These youngsters will probably be ashamed to remember their bright-eyed, glowing praise for what is not even a sub-par fantasy knockoff when they get older and discover real fantasy. I read this to my kid. I was ashamed to have finished the book, even in that capacity. He lost interest about 1/2 way through--I lost it much earlier. I guess you can't blame the kids for their poor taste. I listened to the Monkees when I was younger ;-) Consider "Eragon" the Monkees of fantasy novels....it looks pretty but their isn't much there when you actually stop and pay attention to it.
Is the review positive or negative? 