Negative Positive
Title: Unfulfilling
Review: Here is a breakdown of the book: 60% is detailed logistics of what unit was where at what time, 20% excuses and placing blame for not winning the war and the battle, 10% slighting and accusing the US Army (pointing out indignantly that American artillery hit an aid station or killed civilians, as if that never happened with German artillery,) and 10% suggesting that the Germans and the German Army are superior in every way to anything else that ever existed.
Is the review positive or negative? 