Negative Positive
Title: This won the Hugo and Nebula?
Review: As science fiction, this is a terrible book. As historical fiction, it's serviceable. However, this book's plot is paper thin, its characters are cardboard, and its extremely UN-exciting. The book drags on forever with no direction. I recommend other Hugo and Nebula winners, but stay away from this one, unless you want the history of the Black Death pounded into you over and over...
Is the review positive or negative? 