Negative Positive
Title: This is no reference tool.
Review: If all you want is quotes, you will enjoy this book. If, however, you need a reference tool that is accurate, look elsewhere. About one in three quotes is misquoted, misattributed or both. Citations following the quotes only include the authors' names, so why is the book so full of errors? Clearly, little research went into this "reference" book. How appalling that it was published by a major university!
Is the review positive or negative? 