Negative Positive
Title: Why has no one else weighed in?
Review: I find it hard to fathom that no one else has put forth commentary on this special set, teaming the vibrant, acute Herbert von Karajan with the equally vibrant and acute Maria Callas. Their colloboration alone should be a magnet.Yes, there are a few wayward top notes but the overall effect of Callas' Leonora is mesmerizing. This opera is SO demanding: I believe it was Caruso who said, tongue in cheek, "All it requires is the four best voices in the world." She is joined by Di Stefano, singing the demanding role of Manrico with brio and conviction. Rolando Panerai's Conte di Luna is rich, resonant and compelling. As for Fedora Barbieri as Azucena, she will put chills right down your spine: hers is a lacerating and powerful star turn. Herbert von Karajan is totally commanding. This is truly an ensemble opera, and here we have one terrific ensemble gathered by EMI.
Is the review positive or negative? 