Negative Positive
Title: He needs an editor!
Review: While I found the book had some good ideas, it was clearly not edited by anyone who knows basic grammar. It seemed like a rough draft, and the typos and errors in punctuation, run-on sentences and even capitalization drove me nuts. I couldn't finish it, which is really too bad. If the author is reading this, please get that old grammar book out and really proof your work. This is really unprofessional, and I KNOW you can do better.
Is the review positive or negative? 