Negative Positive
Title: bleh...
Review: The author seems more interested in things like "what does the ring mean to you?" than "what the ring meant to Tolkien". More postmodern literary interpretation run amuck...On the bright side, this book has some really nice charts and timelines (although I disagree with his map where he superimposed Middle-Earth over Europe - I believe it should be far more to the west than he has it).
Is the review positive or negative? 