Negative Positive
Title: A vaguely disturbing book, with simplistic characters
Review: I was bothered by the fact that it was a-okay for Taylor to take this child, who presumably has relatives on the reservation besides her mother, away from her family. It was sort of patronizing, promoting a stereotype that Indians are alcoholics who don't pay attention to their kids, and that those kids are better off with someone else. The device that Taylor's grandfather was "part Cherokee" is, in my opinion, a convenient way to fend off this criticism.
Is the review positive or negative? 