Negative Positive
Title: Great Voice, Empty Soul
Review: Admitedly, he has a mesmerizing voice. HOWEVER, he still lacks the ability to have a grasp of the nuances and emotions to be shown in each songs that he sings. He's a born singer but he needs to get all the technical skills in singing before he could be labeled as the 'American Idol'. Unlike Clay, Josh Groban, though not yet fully polished too, could easily control his 'pianissimo and forte' and melt your heart. You don't have to worry if he would make any embarrassing kinks in his performance. As another comparison, Kelly Clarkson's performance is so firm and solid. She's qualified to be a true artist, while Clay isn't.
Is the review positive or negative? 