Negative Positive
Title: A Pretty Good Book
Review: Overall, this is a very good book: lots of labs, insightful tips, etc. However, I don't think you will be able to consider yourself an expert after pouring over this book because it trys to cover such a breadth of material, that certain sections a "glossed" over. For example, even the authors admit that their chapter on BGP is just taking a stab at a very complex subject. I think this is a particularly good book for intermediate students. A more advanced/complete guide would be Routing TCP/IP by Jeff Doyle.
Is the review positive or negative? 