Negative Positive
Title: Great writing, not-so-great characters
Review: [***** = breathtaking, **** = excellent, *** = good, ** = flawed, * = bad]The writing is gorgeous, which is a given for McKillip. But all three characters are exactly alike -- and, while two are women, the third is supposed to be a guy!Plus, the actual quest got a little murky for me. I was never sure exactly how our main characters are supposed to save Ombria. Longer review at ImpatientReader-dot-com.
Is the review positive or negative? 