Negative Positive
Title: one of the best books ever
Review: This is perfection in every sentence. Nothing more to say. Except that if your edition contains a foreword by Brad Leithauser, don't read it until after you've finished! It will reveal too much of the story, and it will also influence your perception and your expectations. And while you may disagree with some views in the foreword, certainly you will agree with the claim that this is one of the best books ever. Unless you think that a good book should have hobbits in it.
Is the review positive or negative? 