Negative Positive
Title: disappearing reviews
Review: [...]As a reunited couple, we looked forward to reading another book on this topic. We had read Kalish's research in Lost & Found Lovers and bought several copies for friends. So I thought this new book would be good too. I was all set to like it. But I didn't. It was so disappointing.It's just a few light stories, and some interviews with therapists. What did she have to contribute herself? Her story was fun to read, but that could have been a nice, short magazine article. There's not enough here for a book. I finished it in an hour and a half.DH interviewed Nancy Kalish - she says so in the acknowledgements - and this sure sounds like the kalish book without the research that made that first book worthwhile.I think the people who give it 5 stars just haven't read any other books on this topic and so they don't know the difference. It's a fun topic but it is not a good book.
Is the review positive or negative? 