Negative Positive
Title: Superficial Treatment of a Complex Subject
Review: Mr. Benedict attempts to write a book about an entire group og people without interviewing a single member of the group. No competent journalist interested in a fair and accurate treatment of a tribe as controversial as this would consider that an adequate effort. There is a fascinating tale of who these people are, of how they achieved what they have, whether by hook or by crook, of how the money and change in status has affected both them and the region. Unfortunately Mr. Benedict has chosen to take the easy way out and has written a utterly simplistic and superfifical treatment of a far richer and complex story of America today.
Is the review positive or negative? 