Negative Positive
Title: Very bad,
Review: If you had not already read the book, you would not be able to follow the story line. After Gandalf comes, the next morning the dwarves just 'appear' no knocks, rings, or any of that sort of thing. The elves look like little wizened green men and women, and quite ugly. There are no details, and some of the most important ones are not there. This is a waste of time and money, the books are a thousand times better.
Is the review positive or negative? 