Negative Positive
Title: A GOOD READ
Review: i agree with the people that say A tree Grows in brooklyn was better (there isnt a book i have read yet that beats it)! I loved a tree grows in Brooklyn and it inspired me to read the rest of Betty Smiths books, i have Maggie Now to read, i thought the book lacked the detail that A Tree Grows In Brooklyn had, and the little things that people notice in Francie that werent present in Margy...still, I felt Smiths writing familiar and comforting in the last chapter which made me remeber why i keep reading the books over and over,good book...not her BEST but still very good...I give it a 4 as a Betty Smith book and a 5 as any other...becuase a Tree Grows In Brooklyn sets the bar so high! read it because its great but read a tree grows in brooklyn and u will have read the greatest!
Is the review positive or negative? 