Negative Positive
Title: Unscholarly? Yes. Should you get it? Yes.
Review: I'm a catholic apologist and even though there are holes in this book "big enough to drive trucks through", the fact remains that, in my experience, many of our protestant bretheren still use the stuff in this book. I don't know why but they do. And so, you need to to know all the "bad" arguments that they will come up with and this book has them all. Some of it is pretty funny. Anyone who wants to defend the faith should get this book.If you need answers to this book, you can check out, "Catholicism and Fundamentalism..." by Karl Keating. He goes through "Roman Catholicism" piece by piece. I gave this book one star because of all the reasons listed in the other reviews above. He does quote pretty accurately (assuming he has a source at all), but he quotes all of it out of context. So be prepared.
Is the review positive or negative? 