Negative Positive
Title: Music is wonderful....misleading and terrible liner notes
Review: These performances are from piano rolls...although you wouldn't know it from anywhere on the title or literature included with the CD.Not that I'm against piano rolls, I like hearing Saint-Saens playing in a crisp clear fashion. The Hofmann selections are also wonderful, but I believe also available elsewhere, such as on the Nimbus series featuring piano rolls.I wouldn't pay the high price listed here...apparently it's out of print. I believe I found it used for a reasonable price.To sum up: piano roll performances, sound great, wonderful historical documents, don't pay too much though because you can probably find these performances elsewhere.
Is the review positive or negative? 