Negative Positive
Title: Big Questions of History
Review: A lot of reviews are praising this novel as being so historically accurate, but when I read it I had some real questions. My father who was a combat veteran who fought with General Patton says that American troops had not crossed the Rhine River into Germany in October 1944, so it is impossible for the hero Erik to have been shot by American troops in the heart of Germany or to go to an American Red Cross Hospital and be cared for by Americans (p. 221 in the book. So what really happened???
Is the review positive or negative? 