Negative Positive
Title: One excellent essay; forget the rest
Review: The essay by Robert E. L. Krick on Lee's staff is excellent. Too bad, because it is contained in a volume with very god-awful other essays. If you can inter-library loan this, then do it and read Krick's essay; the rest is nonsensical drivel from others incapable of analyzing anything more involved than a stop sign.
Is the review positive or negative? 