Negative Positive
Title: Australian scientists show Diamond got it wrong
Review: The Australian Institue of Agricultural Science and Technology found chapter 13 "Mining" Australia to be deeply flawed. In their AIAST Journal they write "Diamond's analysis suffers from igonrance of geography and history, confusion between areas and eras, a poor understanding of the concepts of sustainability, and an over readiness to uncritically accept some popular assertions." (...)
Is the review positive or negative? 