Negative Positive
Title: Useless as it does not deal with exits and money mgmt
Review: As reviewer "Pedro Suarez" points out, the author does not provide exit strategies! This is just insane. How can one enter a trading position using a mechanical strategy, then just pick the exit (you have to exit the trade at some point, don't you?) "based on ... instincts" and "experience alone" (chap. 17 of the book)! This shows something is fishy about the guy's entry strategies. Maybe another reviewer is right in saying these are nothing but plain-word descriptions of Japanese candlesticks (of which I know little). Also, there's no money management rules. You can't write a trading book that comes anything close to being useful without talking about exits and money management, period.
Is the review positive or negative? 