Negative Positive
Title: No good for adults, no good for kids, no good for anyone
Review: Probably half the thousand-something reviewers on this site have said why Eragon sucks. Bad writing, dull characters, cliche plot, etc. But lots of reviewers have tried to defend Paolini's poor book by saying that it's meant for children. But is it?Allusions to rape, gory fight scenes, heroes stealing money from bridgekeepers, and a rather negative view on the meaning of life (or lack thereof in Eragon's case). And let's not forget the skewered baby that was almost eaten by a crow!Face it. It's not a decent children's book. It's a poorly written adult book.
Is the review positive or negative? 