Negative Positive
Title: Inadequate notes!
Review: I've read Moby Dick several times. I started trying to read this edition, and by Chapter 20 I switched to the Oxford edition. I've found the best way to read the book is with a heavily annotated edition, because of the amounts of reference on the surface of and buried beneath the text. This Penguin edition is so lightly annotated that it's useless. If you are a casual reader, the notes won't begin to address all the questions you will have. If you are a more serious student of the work, the notes too lightly address things that any search of the Wiki can explain FAR better.
Is the review positive or negative? 