Negative Positive
Title: Bad Edition
Review: I'm giving this product one star, not because it's that bad, but because there's absolutely no reason to buy this version. The X Press edition of Chesnutt's "Marrow of Tradition" (curiously shortened to Tradition) is an abridged version with no explanation for the reason for the editing or the choice of passages removed. In fact I had no idea that there were segments (just paragraphs and phrases) edited out until we happened to read a passage in class that just disappeared from my text.The editing doesn't make it unreadable, and the majority of the story is there, but with plenty of other editions in print and available for the same price, there's no reason to buy this one.Does not reflect on the quality of the novel itself; great piece of classic American literature.
Is the review positive or negative? 