Negative Positive
Title: Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Review: My name is Trevor and I read Shiloh in my 4th grade class. I think Shiloh is an outstanding book. Shiloh is about a boy named Marty who was out wondering around and saw a dog. The dog followed him everywhere. When he got home his parents took the dog to a neighbor named Judd who just got a dog. It was Judds dog. The dog kept coming back to Marty. Marty finally took the dog and kept him in a pen near the woods. The dog got attacked by another dog. He was fine after a few days at the doctor. Judd came to get his dog because he found out they had him. He found out by a friend of his who saw the dog. Did they get the dog back? Read the book and find out. I would recommend this book to everyone because of the adventure and frightening parts.
Is the review positive or negative? 