Negative Positive
Title: Formula for Melodramatic crap
Review: The author suggests that ending with disaster is a fundamental part of the scene. It is beyond obvious that this is wrong! In the story is to have a happy ending, then at least the last scene must end in success. Even with this excecption, it still means the protagonist still has to overcome all of the obsticles in his way in the last few pages of the book. It would be extremely difficult to pull this off legitimately.
Is the review positive or negative? 