Negative Positive
Title: It works
Review: I'll start with the negatives:As someone else wrote, the tip-to-tip measurement isn't 54". I just measured mine, and it's around 42". That's a big difference. False advertising, I think it fair to say.Also (as the other writer wrote) it's odd that the sock (which fits around your light) is centered in the diffuser panel. Most everyone's lights are offset a bit (the shaft fits *next* to the light, not the middle), and so to get it to fit, you have to bend the umbrella quite a bit (which then deforms the reflector, because the umbrella is the reflector).Now the positives:That said, it does work, and the photographic results I've gotten are very good. All things considered, it's a good way to add a pseudo-softbox to your lights, for about $70. Better options are available, but they cost more, may be heavier, and take up more space. So, I view this as a good low-cost option, for those who aren't ready to plunk down thousands on a more sophisticated system.
Is the review positive or negative? 