Negative Positive
Title: A mediocre book
Review: This book is a disgrace, I can't believe it won the National Book Award. As a Chinese who spent his childhood in China, this book to be nothing more than a romantic potboiler. There is one cliched situation happening after another, not to mention the random positionings of irrelevant details. This is nothing more than the work of a novice. But I can understand why an American would like this book, because of all the exotic details. If you really want to experience China, go on a vacation and you'll see enough to write your own book.
Is the review positive or negative? 