Negative Positive
Title: Science - 10, fiction - 2
Review: Arthur Clarke is a genius, and when he tells me what the future is going to be like in a thousand years or so, I pay attention. His future is minutely detailed, and will probably prove true in many respects. Where this novel fails is in a failure to couple the technological change with humanity. These people don't breathe and spit and snore; these are illustrations, not characters. The plot isn't really worth mentioning: there was only enough of it for a short story
Is the review positive or negative? 