Negative Positive
Title: Every review of value.
Review: Those who read it during their "formatory" years were left with an indelible imprint, some remembering the characters and scenes decades after reading this book. The same can be said for PK Dick's "Ubik" and "Three Stigmata of Palmer Eldritch" among others. To review Arcturus in any other way (eg literary) would be like a chemist reviewing an excellent wine from a chemist perspective without ever tasting it. As someone once said "there is a difference between knowing and knowing about." Regarding the movie suggestion, maybe Tim Burton could pull it off.
Is the review positive or negative? 