Negative Positive
Title: unbelievable
Review: I know, I know. I'm supossed to "suspend disbelief" when I read fantasy and I really tried for this book. But suspension of disbelief can only go so far. I can't believe that Eragon can fight so well with broken ribs or that he can become a master swordsman in a few months. Nor can I believe that Saphira can be so wise and motherly when she spent the past few centuries in an eggshell. It's these impossibilities that make the characters seem unreal and kill any connection I could have felt for them.
Is the review positive or negative? 