Negative Positive
Title: Huh?
Review: I agree with R.V. There is no reason to allow sloppy playing in a professional orchestra recording. You do it over until you get it right. No excuse. I have always had a soft spot for the Russian orchestras, but let's face it, they are not on the A-list equal to Boston, Cleveland, Chicago, etc. Also, for a modern day digital recording the mixing should be first rate and almost perfect.There are just too many mistakes made in creating this recording to make it stand up with the others out there. Chicago/Ozawa, now that's a nice recording. Boulez/Cleveland, awesome. I don't like listening to my favorite pieces and hearing orchestra clams. They should be caught by a conductor who is paying attention even if the mood is wonderful, mistakes should not be recorded. People who know the score may be listening.
Is the review positive or negative? 