Negative Positive
Title: What a 14 year old studying the Battle of Stalingrad thinks of this book:
Review: Enemy at the gates is a good book to read if you are a World War II scholar wishing to learn the full, in-depth extent of the battle of Stalingrad. To many others it will prove a challenging book to read. At times it is confusing and even the best reader's can only hope to drag themselves along the ragged plotline without any notes. Tieing in to the movie is not right - only about three pages of the book are even slightly similar to the movie. I was also disgusted to find that less than a half of the book was devoted to what I feel was the battle of Stalingrad, while the rest petered into the rather mundane account of the battle on the steppe both before and after the fact. I would only recommend this book to the worst of my enemies hoping that the drool from their bored eyeballs will damage the book and force them to pay for damages. Good day to you, you boring old scholar, William Craig. Logan 14
Is the review positive or negative? 