Negative Positive
Title: I must be an alien
Review: I and my friends have never got this type of writing. Maybe we are aliens, or maybe you have to be from New York or something. It alls seems very unconvincing from a human perspective. No one we know acts or feels this way. It's like a Hollywood movie script where there are no parameters in reality. Surely humor is funny because it is based on actual human experience. Sedaris seems like he made the whole thing up. No one could have a family with this much dysfunction. I don't understand the adulation and even Carnegie Hall readings. As I say, maybe it's a New York thing.
Is the review positive or negative? 