Negative Positive
Title: science reader
Review: Too technical for the average reader. One gets lost part way through. It is obviously well researched, supported by other research and seemingly very thorough, but it comes across as having built an exquisite ocean liner that sinks the moment it sets sail. I agree with the other reviewer, Dr. Carroll speaks of evolution, argues strongly for it, yet uses the word design over and over again and never ever explains how this toolbox evolved. Why wouldn't the hand, the paw and the fin come from the same genetic area? That doesn't prove evolution and the book doesn't prove it, either. Had he written this was a pro-Intelligent Design book, he would have received more stars from this reader.
Is the review positive or negative? 