Negative Positive
Title: Worth it for the Sunrise
Review: I found this to be a mixed bag -- the lesser known items from Lemminkainen are played with vim and vigor but that can only accomplish so much, and the central Swan of Tuonela is not on par with the best versions. Luonnotar is given a gripping performance, at a tempo moderately quicker than the elder Jarvi's recent DG version -- I found Paavo's approach more succesful, with a more blended vocal line. The highlight of the disc for me was Night Ride and Sunrise, given a emotionally powerful and communicative performance that leaves one wondering why it is not better known. Lastly, I disagree with our friend from Gramophone -- I can't imagine better sound. Worthwhile for all Sibelians, especially if your collection is without the first piece.
Is the review positive or negative? 