Negative Positive
Title: A good reference for research organic chemists.
Review: The core of this book is a list of reaction categorized by their mechanistic types. Such an arrangement is suitable when (a) you need to do a reaction with no preceeding examples but with examples from similar compounds (b) you want to compare possible methodology of accomplishing similar synthetic route or (c) your college teaches organic chemistry types by types, and no functional groups by functional groups. Not suitable before junior years.
Is the review positive or negative? 