Negative Positive
Title: No great insight to the 1815 campaign
Review: This is as poorly-written, one-sided view of the 1815 campaign as one can imagine. Hofschroer makes remarkable claims, but can only back such claims up by misinterpretation of the facts. The attempted claim that Wellington deceived his allies is whole unconvincing. Even worse, his battle narrative is stilted. The author cites one after another heroic episodes of Prussian activity at Ligny without any corresponding French episodes. It makes one wonder how Napoleon, being seriously outnumbered by Hofschroer's Heroes, won the
Is the review positive or negative? 