Negative Positive
Title: why get the inferior book?
Review: Were this the only guide to North American birds, I would emphatically recommend it. However, it is not. The Sibley's guides have come out; they are leagues ahead of this one in clarity, accuracy, and pure and simple artistic beauty.I also strongly recommend the National geographic series guides, third or fourth editions.Getting this book would be like buying a 20 years old, cosmetically refurbished car for 4500 dollars when you could get a brand new, superior model for 5500 dollars.
Is the review positive or negative? 