Negative Positive
Title: Mrs. Chippy was killed when the ice journey began!!!!!!
Review: I am amazed that this book pretends that Mrs. Chippy actually witnessed any of these events. Mrs. Chippy, along with several dogs, was killed when Shackleton began his journey on the ice. I am glad I read Endurance first, so I was saved from believing such a story, no matter how heartmwarming. It was a cute story, no doubt, but misleading in that in purports to be truer than it really is.I am a cat lover, but, to all of you who think this REALLY happened (as I see from some of the reviews), it did not! Just keep this in mind.
Is the review positive or negative? 