Negative Positive
Title: Dissapointing release
Review: This is the Alan Smithee version, extended edition, that has been available over the Internet for years, poorly edited, with repeated scenes, like the same Harkonnen landing shuttles scene use several times along the movie, in other inserted scenes the Fremen do not have their Ibad (blue eyes); another nagging example: the movie jumps from wide-screen scenes to full screen ones! No wonder David Lynch disavows this version.
Is the review positive or negative? 