Negative Positive
Title: Not worth your time
Review: Was very excited to get this book. After all, Tolkien grew up reading MacDonald, the book seems to be pleasing most people, and the edition is handsome. But unfortunately I was very disappointed. The volume itself is very well done, and the story concept was great, but the execution was not very clever or memorable, and I found myself humoring the author a great deal, plodding through the book, waiting for something worth reading to happen. My two cents.
Is the review positive or negative? 