Negative Positive
Title: Incoherent opinions
Review: I was searching for a biography of the Bronte siblings. What I found was this incomprehensible mash of random feelings and impressions the author seems to have had about previous biographies of the Brontes. There is little biography here; it is simply her agreements with or refutations of previous biographers, often not even explaining what those biographers had stated to begin with.
Is the review positive or negative? 