Negative Positive
Title: I read the book and wish it would of stayed that way!
Review: I think Dean Knootz is a very fun author to read. I picked up this book because a friend said it was good. The book was good, but not Knootzs best. I rented the movie because I wanted to see how much the book and movie differ. Well, to say it in a nice way - Read the book. The movie is all over the place. I know that they had a budget and had to fit the whole story in less than two hours, but then WHY make the movie. So much is missing about what exactly the Phantoms are and the ending in the book much better. WHY? WHY? WHY? I just can't understand WHY this movie was made in the first place. It should have been a TV miniseries. At least then you can actually make it longer then two hours and people will actually understand what the hell is going on. The book was very suspenseful at times; the movie was a big bore!
Is the review positive or negative? 