Negative Positive
Title: LOTR Minds Eye (sort of)
Review: It is true that this is the Mind's Eye version that was broadcast on NPR playhouse as to the story content. However, it is a recreated version not using original full cast of actors, it does not use the original full symphonic music, and Gail Chugg is NOT the narrator. Also, it is divided into one minute segments that are spaced ten seconds apart. As originally broadcast on NPR Playhouse, the dramazitation include the background that is part of the story at various parts of the book. That is also left out. Soundlux Audio Publishing apparently simply paid for the right to record their own copy of the Mind's Eye script and used none of the Mind's Eye recording!
Is the review positive or negative? 