Negative Positive
Title: Good idea, bad delivery: Red Leatherette Edition
Review: I bought this book new from Barnes and Noble a few days ago (over-priced). Upon opening the shrink-wrap I discovered several flaws with the quality of the book.1. The back-top corner was bent in, leaving a tear in the leatherette covering.2. SEVERAL pages were bent in at the corners (and since the paper is so thin, it stays bent)3. Two pages had large creases in them, running through the text.4. A few pages were uneven, cut too short.5. The cover looks nice, but feels cheap.Other than that, it's still wonderful Tolkien, but I don't recommend this edition.
Is the review positive or negative? 