Negative Positive
Title: New York Nature Deja Vu
Review: As an avid reader of books focusing on the political, cultural and environmental life of New York City, I was excited at the prospect of purchasing "Wild Nights."However, upon taking a brief read of the book, I got the distinct impression that I'd read it before! And as a matter of fact, I had four years ago: "Wild New York" by Margaret Mittlebach and Michael Crewdson.And just judging by a cursory reading of Ms. Matthew's book, I would imagine she's read it as well. Now, to be sure, I am not accusing her of plagarism. However, I do feel that her book is a rather artless, plodding retread of ground covered in Ms. Mittlebach's and Mr. Crewdson's lively and engaging exploration of the city's geographic history.Not to say that Ms. Matthew's book isn't comprehensive, it just isn't necessary.
Is the review positive or negative? 