Negative Positive
Title: Poorly researched and poorly written
Review: What a disappointment! There is very little in this book that merits even one star, but that's as low as I could find.Carcaterra knows virtually nothing of military tactics or equipment, and very little of the events in Naples that this book tries to portray.He is completely out of his element in writing this story, and anyone who has ever served in the military will be unable to finish the bookPerhaps Carcaterra should stay with the "Sleepers" theme, which he seems to know about.
Is the review positive or negative? 