Negative Positive
Title: cliche
Review: There are already some nice, long reviews of this book that adequately detail its failings. There are also some inexplicably positive reviews. I'll keep mine short. The name 'Herbert' is on the front of the book but I suspect Brian Herbert had nothing to do with this series other than cashing in. Kevin Anderson's work in this series is so derivative that you lose track of who he's ripping off. There is not one thing in these books that you can't get in much better form from some other sci-fi classic.
Is the review positive or negative? 