Negative Positive
Title: a must-see
Review: An outstanding movie - gripping, subtle, and engaging. Yes, parts of it seem somewhat romanticized for film (Chamberlain's speeches, various wistful glances) but even those are probably not too far from possible truth. One thing which continually stirrs up controversy, apparently, is Sheen's depiction of Lee. I thought it was sensitive, compelling, and possibly quite accurate. Senile? I don't think so. Careless and/or irresponsible? Nope. It is true that his actions in that campaign stirred up his own commanders (who debated it years after the war and Lee's death). I still get chills watching Sheen in this role. Lee's evident sincerity, commitment, and absolute dedication are all apparent. Someone commented that "it's amazing his men didn't shoot him", or something like that... I think this is a remarkably myopic thing to write... remember - this was just one campaign in a long war, and Lee had won many victories prior (and after).
Is the review positive or negative? 