Negative Positive
Title: Intriguing but very disorganized
Review: I experienced this book in audio format and had quite a bit of difficulty following any sort of logical thread; so much so that I wondered about the viability of audio (something I've only recently started dealing with). It was therefore comforting to see so many other reviewers commenting on disorganization. Apparently, it's the work itself, not the format.That's a shame. The topic is a fascinating one. I wish it had been more cogently presented. At this point in time, I would say Jared Diamond is still the author to read if you are interested in this field. It appears that 1491 aspires to stand next to it, and might have succeeded with better editing. But as it stands now, it doesn't work.
Is the review positive or negative? 