Negative Positive
Title: Thankful I didn't buy it,, just borrowed it.
Review: Here is another shining example of how one can have a powerful voice with range, and make boring music. Think Christina Aguilera, who co-wrote the song "Miss Independent" and uses the same intonations to pull it off. Ms. Clarkson is another copycat oversinger with more screaming than soul.It is so obvious that the production was as contrived as a Britney Spears cd, but, Britney comes across with a sense of humor about the whole thing. Kelly Clarkson is just another one of the singers, the young fans can say "oh she is the only one can sing" meanwhile they learn only that singing is about vocal acrobatics and not emotions.Ms. Clarkson needs to get together with some competent songwriters which does not include master of hooks Dianne Warren or "miss girlpower" Christina Aguilera. A fresh approach to singing and songwriting and you might have half a chance.Maybe when a Joplinesque or Stevie Nicks influenced singer hits the scene then we can talk.
Is the review positive or negative? 