Negative Positive
Title: Hate it
Review: This is one of the best bad movies that you'll ever see.As a stand alone movie it has everything that would make a winner. The actors were good, the story was well told and the look of the movie is spectacular.As part of the Star Trek franchise, it is a disaster. Destroying the planet Vulcan? Making one of the founding members of the Federation an endangered species?NO- the producer over-reached and created something that can't stand beside the existing body of work.J.J. Abrams is great but in this case he screwed the pooch. He re-wrote history and undermined a near-sacred franchise in a way that in completely untenable. You simply CAN NOT do that with a shared treasure like Star Trek with generations of fans that know the story and trivia much better than the bleeding idiots who OKed production of this wretched script.He should have known better.Pretend that it never happened and maybe it will go away.
Is the review positive or negative? 