Negative Positive
Title: Pales in comparison to volume 1
Review: Having read volume 1 of this series and enjoyed it, I went ahead and purchased volumes 2-4. Unfortunately this is nothing like volume 1 because these stories seem entirely fabricated at worst or exceptionally embellished at best. Some are patently fantasy, others are fiction written by professional gay writers. A great example of the latter is Bingo (p.34) by Ryan Field. Not only are there common elements to another of his books, but the timeline makes no sense unless he started the relationship discussed when he was 7 years old. You'll also quickly notice that everybody is an expert at gay sex on their first run through. If you are simply after erotic short stories then this may be what you're looking for, however, if you want a book similar to volume 1 (whose reviews you should read) then I wouldn't bother.
Is the review positive or negative? 