Negative Positive
Title: Does the book a great diservice
Review: You know.... in the book, no one fights with the lasers and stuff that they used in the movie. A laser hitting a shield is supposed to cause a nuclear explosion. Oh, and the fremen used crysknives... swords made from the teeth of a worm, not stupid little devices that bluh stuff up based on voice... and the Atradies have fanatical troops because well... read the book. This movie should have had a different title, because it is only superficially similar to Frank Herberts great work.
Is the review positive or negative? 