Negative Positive
Title: Not bad
Review: I stopped reading "Fantasy" novels a long time ago because the genre became flooded with very bad writers and very bad stories, likely the result of the Dungeons and Dragons era where too many people thought they could write fantasy, and how wrong they were. Many will claim that this book is a ripoff of this or that, but really most fiction is a ripoff of something else. The key is can the writer pull it off. I think in this case the writer did pull it off, and at the age of 15 did it a lot better than most adult fantasy writers have attempted. Really I think most of the negative reviews are from those who are jealous of what this writer has done at such a young age. If this were my son I would be very proud of him, as would most of his critics if they were being honest with themselves.
Is the review positive or negative? 