Negative Positive
Title: Are we reading the same book?
Review: I heard all these excellent reviews of Le Guinn's "Earthsea" books. I read it and thought, "Is this the same book that all these people have read?" It was stupid. I mean, it was better than anything Terry Goodkind and Terry Brooks could ever hope to write, but that's not sayig much. Then I re-read it to catch this big deep underlying theme. There wasn't any. Or, at least, not any worth reading. If your a fan of Tolkien, Lewis, Jordan, or Feist, don't waste your time on "EathSea."
Is the review positive or negative? 