Negative Positive
Title: Atrociously confused
Review: Here's a warning, kids: Don't wade into scholarly debates in fields you have not mastered, regarding matters (i.e., literature) in which you have no competence. You'll make a fool of yourself, as this poor inept lawyer has done. So ay historical errors, so many baseless suppositions, so many contradictions, so many lapses of logic.... Well, the typical anti-Stratfordian performance.
Is the review positive or negative? 