Negative Positive
Title: third rate self-indulgence
Review: this is by far the worst pumpkins album ever. yes, it is a lot like adore, but adore sounded good live. here the the instruments give way completely to billy corgan's nasal (but lovable) voice. why is this a mistake? it isn't necessarily. but he is no james labrie; he lacks enough control of his voice to carry any song properly and/or at least interestingly. this album, instead of being far from modern pop, is closer than he has ever come. being simple is fine and good, being simplistic is not, which is what we have here. if you're looking for the pumpkins at their (his) best, check out gish and maybe pisces. this is a step further in the direction of adore which is another step backwards for the band. this album will make peace with u2 fans and disappoint anyone looking for the musical proficiency and talent that once separated the pumpkins from the rest of pop.
Is the review positive or negative? 