Negative Positive
Title: Good or bad?
Review: I, too am a young author and usually write long stories for my family and friends, all of which are fantasy lovers. I was watching MSNBC news when I saw Paolini being interviewed and just out of curiosity, I bought Eragon and Eldest at the same time. I felt as if I wasn't alone in writing novels and I was comforted. The first few chapters were OK but I was angry and disappointed when Brom died. As I read further I noted that there were some passages from LOTR and SW and Anne McCaffrey's, DragonRiders of Pern in the book and I became angry.It is insignificent that a fifteen year old wrote a novel. It doesn't matter the age of the person...what matters is the book and the words that filled the pages. I do not recommend this book to anybody. I would recommend J.R.R Tolkien's, The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings for those are much better.
Is the review positive or negative? 