Negative Positive
Title: For Amanda M. Dunn
Review: None of these Aaliyah songs sound like Janet rips offs. We all know Aaliyah's voice is way stronger/better than Janet's and even Rolling Stone's 5 star review said that 'Aaliyah' is what Janet WANTED to make. Lets first get clear that the only song reminiscent of Janet is I Can Be/What If.....channeling Black Cat. Understand that Aaliyah's music was criticall acclaimed BEFORE death. Her first two albums were widely successful. Especially in other countries. It is totally unfair to credit the success of 'Aaliyah' to her death.....when One In A Million did better than 'Aaliyah' did. So what sense are you making? Lets put your dislike for Aaliyah aside and realize that this album garnded critical acclaim AS SOON AS is came out. A month before her passing. You need to get a grip and admit that this album well deserves every positive review it gets.
Is the review positive or negative? 