Negative Positive
Title: Not Pregnant
Review: Okay, let's talk about the whole Franny being pregnant issue and why it is completely wrong. Seymour, the guy that died, was having the same problems as Franny and I'm pretty sure he wasn't pregnant. In his other book, Holden was pretty near a breakdown too, and for some unexplained reason, I don't think he was pregnant either. The whole too long a time between sips or drinks or whatever doesn't prove anything because she is far away from him. All it shows is that she really doesn't like him which is pretty obvious anyway. She doesn't need to be having a baby not to want to be with him.I don't think the book loses meaning either. I think it loses its real meaning when you think she's pregnant. Putting the issue aside for a minute, I think it really is a good book, and I think that if you like salinger it's very good.
Is the review positive or negative? 