Negative Positive
Title: New voices to an all-time favorite!
Review: OK; it's not the Tenth Anniversary "Dream" cast, but if you like the musical it's well worth purchasing. There were some performances I liked better in each one, but these failed to detract from my enjoyment of either whole production.I believe the criticism of Marius is far too extreme, and certainly not something which detracts from my enjoyment of this performance. However least I be too forgiving, I must say that none of the 25th performers are up to Phillip Quast or Ruthie Henshall (this comment made me go to You-Tube and listen to Ruthie sing "I Dreamed a Dream," and Phillip sing "Stars before finishing this review). That is not to say The 25th singers were in the least wanting. I thought the young Cosette was better in the 25th, and the Inn-Keeper better in the 10th.All -in- all a great disk to add to any library.;
Is the review positive or negative? 