Negative Positive
Title: A Reply to the Last Reviewer
Review: Admittedly, the first review was a bit harsh; nevertheless, it is clear that approximating n! by n ln n - 1 is not sufficient. At large n, this does indeed resemble n ln n - n ,but why include the minus one? Clearly, Huang was not paying close attention. Furthermore, the first three chapters are slapdash and hard to follow. I recommend the Stat Mech book by Pathria in lue of this text.
Is the review positive or negative? 