Negative Positive
Title: Odd approach
Review: One thing that is missing is that there is no attempt at critical analysis of the Islamic texts he is using to 'prove' Christianity. Rather than even approaching the topic of the historical authenticity of the narrations from the Prophet (S), for instance, those texts which are 'convenient' are quoted as fact in order to support his argument.I think in general the idea of using Islam to 'prove' Christianity and 'disprove' Islam is weird. Because if someone doesn't believe that Islam is a valid religion, it can't be used to 'prove' something else. Falsehood does not prove truth (as a logical principle).The title is misconstrued too though as love of God and God's love for humanity is mentioned just as much in Islamic texts.The author seems very sincere though and like a nice man.
Is the review positive or negative? 