Negative Positive
Title: Muddy waters
Review: I was surprised to find this book so highly rated by other reviewers. I found it frustrating--Mr. Sewell spends a great deal of time and effort telling about different theories for events in Emily Dickinson's life, and then telling the reader that "I don't think that can be true". However, he never seemed to give any of his own answers to this enigmatic life. This is the first biography I have read about ED, and I come away greatly puzzled . . .
Is the review positive or negative? 