Negative Positive
Title: Flawed methodology & boneheaded interpretation
Review: The reviews below present the findings of this book as unproblematic and uncontested. In fact, publication of this book in 74 caused a firestorm of debate and criticism. My title sums up the main thrust of the criticisms, for anyone especially interested see Herbert Gutman's, "The World Two Cliometricians Made", Journal of Negro History, Jan. 75, for one of the most persuasive of the book's critics.
Is the review positive or negative? 