Negative Positive
Title: Decent Diet, Bad Theology
Review: The Hallelujah diet probably is a good improvement over what most Americans eat. Be aware though that some who followed this diet strictly for several years have had problems. See Chet Day's site for specific stories or beyondveg for more general problems with vegan, mostly-raw diets.The worst part of this book is the claim that it is based on Christian teaching. No serious Bible scholars that I know of agree with the use of one verse to imply that God intended a vegan diet. Jesus gave fish to the crowds and to his disciples (John 6 and John 21), so it is hard to see how God's ideal diet is vegan.
Is the review positive or negative? 