Negative Positive
Title: the book was fine why complain?
Review: The main thing that I have a problem with is that the older reviewers of this book don't stop to consider that for kids this book was a fantastic story. Also, I know some are just trying to give Paolini constructive criticisim, but slashing the book and calling it 'all ready done' is immature if you ask me. Paolini was 15 when he wrote this. Give him a break he's a biginner and he'll learn. So for all you adult 'know-it-alls' cut him some slack and keep your rude thoughts to yourself. Your reviews will make people not want to by his books in the future. Now how would that make you feel if you knew you were responsible for Paolini's downfall?
Is the review positive or negative? 