Negative Positive
Title: Most inaccurate account so far.
Review: Hammell has quite a large number of inaccuracies, slanted opinions, and has failed to verify facts from his sources. The book has a very negative view of the same US Army, whose sacrifice on the east side of Chosin undoubtedly saved the allies chance for withdrawal from Hagaru-ri and also provided the rear guard action for the evacuating column. Appears to be written more for personal glory and profit, than a source of useful information.
Is the review positive or negative? 