Negative Positive
Title: You say goodbye, I say hello
Review: I am a serious Beatles/McCartney fan and collector. I attended two of Paul's shows in 2002. They were both really good shows, and this CD is among the best concert CDs in my collection. Age seems to do Paul McCartney good. He can still rock out, and can sing beautifully. Much of the music here is from the '60s, including a few songs that he had never played live before. The new material comes through strong for the most part. On the whole a fine concert by Sir Paul. There is one piece of bad news: although every song in the concert is presented, all of the chatter between songs has been deleted. This means his enthousiastic greeting ("We have come to rock you tonight!"), his passionate words for John and George, the band introductions, and the humorous stories behind some songs (those of you who attended these shows will know what I'm talking about) are all missing. But the music is excellent, and Paul will probably never do another tour like this one, so enjoy.
Is the review positive or negative? 