Negative Positive
Title: Hopelessly partisan
Review: This is not so much an academic study as it is a biased piece of propaganda, carefully selecting and presenting what will suit the author's political bent. It is not surprising that historian Joel Beinin has called the author of this book "perhaps the most articulate and learned Zionist advocate in the North American Middle East academic community ..."This is a man who was convicted in a French court for denying the Armenian genocide. Articulate and learned, yes, but still a "Zionist advocate". Not an unbiased scholar. This book can be good for fellow Zionists who need an affirmation that that they are right and everyone else is wrong. For others, it cannot be recommended.
Is the review positive or negative? 