Negative Positive
Title: Simple yet profound thesis on how we got here
Review: There are hundreds of reviews on here of this monumental book covering the general thesis and finer details. Suffice to say that the book is extremely powerful and thought provoking. Whether or not one agrees with Diamond's conclusions, they are well-established and inspire critical thought. He has presented some of the simplest answers to questions of monumental historical significance, and the scientific presumption should always be that the simplest answer is most likely correct. While some reviewers slam Diamond as psuedo-Marxist and completely unbalanced, no competing theories of human development are as compelling as his nor as scientifically substantiated to this point.
Is the review positive or negative? 