Negative Positive
Title: It's a PUBLISHED WORK OF FICTION!
Review: I don't want to hear any more people defending Paolini because of his age. I don't want to hear anyone say "Could YOU write a book at age 15?". Any fifteen year old who read any work of fantasy could write something on par with this worse-than-mediocre book. What bothers me is that the Eragon fans' gushing praise is not towards the book but towards Paolini's ability to publish the book. If he had put this on fictionpress.com or some other amateur writers site, I would have praised it. But a published work of fiction should be good without taking an author's age into account.
Is the review positive or negative? 