Negative Positive
Title: fraud or just gobbletygook
Review: This book is full of misunderstandings of basic physics and even arithmetic. It is either fraud or just utterly stupid. There are many fairly good pictures of ice crystals, and the basic messages, e.g. "The world is linked together by love and gratitude" are nice and can provoke thought.Some reviewers defend this book saying things like "it isn't meant to be scientifically rigorous" or "it isn't a science journal" or even "It just dosn't seem like valid science to people who lack the author's brilliant insight." But, the main thrust of the book is an attempt to provide a foundation for thoughts about love and water through what is purported as experimental results and valid scientific theory. The "facts" are not accurate, are misunderstood, or just make no sense. There seems to be a longing among many readers for scientific validation of spiritual ideas, but I think it is a disservice to take advantage of their gullibility and ignorance, as this book does.
Is the review positive or negative? 