Negative Positive
Title: not for me
Review: A pretty light read, fluffy really. So I went to see what other reviewers thought, and redheaded fan is (according to the Wish List attached to their review) also named Gary Taubes. Not the same Gary Taubes who gets thanked personally in the acknowledgments to this very book?! Wow, that would be TOTALLY inappropriate, to go to some site (or anywhere I'd say) and give a ravey review to an old friend who thanks you in that book. If Redheaded Fan is some other person who just happens also to be named Gary Taubes, then nice for you you found something you liked reading. I didn't.
Is the review positive or negative? 