Negative Positive
Title: Like its companion volume, 1B, loaded with sloppy errors
Review: "Pagen" [sic] is misspelled in the Beowulf introduction. Henry II is described in the introduction as having ruled from 1154 to 1177, when in actuality, he ruled until his death in 1189. The more I read, the less I trust what I'm reading. I recommend M. H. Abrams' Norton anthology instead.
Is the review positive or negative? 