Negative Positive
Title: Pompous author, terrible book
Review: I have read many books on the subject and this is by far the worst one. The author thinks he knows everything and that his book is the definitive work on the subject. That is a bad combo. When you have that attitude, then you are no longer open to new methods or opinions. Any book, in this day and age, that has 4 chapters on soil and only one on hydro is better used as kindling. Setups are poorly explained, there are few pictures, and it yields more frustration than crops.
Is the review positive or negative? 