Negative Positive
Title: Tolkien was an artist who painted pictures with tiny details
Review: Tolkien was so special because he created not only characters who were true to themselves, but also species who were true. They had their own languages, songs, poems, traditions, characteristics. . . in short, they were embodied of their own cultures. Keeping track of all these things, so he wouldn't be caught in inconsistency, is why Tolkien was a genius who is, so far, unmatched. I have re-read this series many times. If I were stranded on a deserted island with five books, the LofR and the Bible would make up my five. I highly recommend this book.
Is the review positive or negative? 