Negative Positive
Title: Plodding and repetitive
Review: This book is far too long. A good idea is wasted by the author's relentless repetition of every detail, and her inexplicable inflation of every tiny plot point (Kivrin is so sick--will she make it to the window seat? Will she make it down the stairs? Will she get back to the manor house?).I lost respect for the Hugo award years ago--this book makes me wonder about the Nebula as well.
Is the review positive or negative? 