Negative Positive
Title: Much needed book but sloppy proofreading
Review: This book fills the niche for a complete collection of TCL/TK man pages. However, I was suprised at the many typos and misordered items that I found unintentionally. There are references in the index to pages beyond the last page in the book. The order of commands is almost alphabetical but not quite exactly so. There are grammatical mistakes. The cover page proudly lampoons that it is covers through version 8.2 while the introduction meekly says that it was not tested on 8.2. I also found it officious that an authors name appears on the book since the book is essentially a digested man page document with notes. This book is useful to me but not of lasting historical value.
Is the review positive or negative? 