Negative Positive
Title: Talent? What talent?
Review: The amazon review says that had the author lived, his critics and fans would have had the opportunity to determine if his talent was genuine or a fluke. Oh, really? Who said he had any "talent"? What I found in this book was pure amateurism -- in plot, character development, atmosphere, you name it. If Dunces demonstrates genius, then the Three Stooges are on par with Chaplin. The amazon review also says this drivel cannot be easily dismissed. Again, says who? This is one "book" I plan to forget as soon as possible.
Is the review positive or negative? 