Negative Positive
Title: Top leather scuffed on first wear
Review: The shoes look and wear great. However, the leather is pretty weak. I think I must have kicked a table leg or something on my frist outing in them. Now the tip of my left shoe has a quarter-size scuff on it. I will have to try to cover it up by oiling it. Obviously I don't think this pair will last long at all.
Is the review positive or negative? 