Negative Positive
Title: Good, but...
Review: Excellently written. Great dialogue, adequate characterizations, but frankly, the motivations of some of the characters, particularly the alcoholic author, Trahearne, make little sense. Does he love his wife or doesn't he? Does he want her back or does he want her gone? In the end, the sad demise of the main character is totally gratuitous. She was already leaving and that was tragic enough.
Is the review positive or negative? 