Negative Positive
Title: disgrace
Review: Ok, most people have already said all the main points for why this movie was terrible so i will try to keep this simple. I have read Dune about 20 or 30 times, i have now lost count, but needless to say i love the book. Being a fan of the book, i can say that despite its differences, I love the David Lynch movie. One reviewer said it best when he said it was great because it could stand alone as a movie of its own. The sci fi verson wasnt good alone, or as a person who had read the book. One of my biggest complaints was with Mohiam who wasnt in any way like the reverend mother in the book and with Paul, who was simply cast poorly. Anyway, the Lynch version is a really entertaining movie that is fun to watch despite the differences from the book. This version on the other hand will have most dune fans frustrated the whole time. My advice is to buy the David Lynch version and rent this version if you really must see it. Otherwise, stick to the book and watch another movie.
Is the review positive or negative? 