Negative Positive
Title: Over Rated
Review: I eagerly sought out this book because of the glowing review in American Heritage. They called it the best science fiction ever written ... far better than Asimov.Forget it. Favorable reviews call it "subtle"; "disjointed" suits far better. The story isn't particularly interesting, it doesn't qualify as literature by any stretch and the joke about the dog guarding the gates of Hades is pathetically juvenile.Don't bother with this one.
Is the review positive or negative? 