Negative Positive
Title: Not very realistic
Review: I didn't like this book at all. I'm in seventh grade and I thought this book was very unrealistic. I think the author was using a lot of stereotypes. The girl, Judi, said that she read seventeen magazine all the time so she thought she knew everything about fashion. She kept relating everything to seventeen magazine. She is supposed to be in eighth grade and she got depressed because she thought she should be on dates during the weekends. She also got depressed because she wears size twelve (she is supposed to be tall) and her friend wears sizes 7 and 8. This author should have talked to some REAL eighth graders before assuming they all read seventeen and want to fit ino tiny tiny tiny sizes!!
Is the review positive or negative? 