Negative Positive
Title: This book is deffinately not meant for children!
Review: The Giver while deffinately not a dry and boring book should not be included in the children's reading category. I have been doing an independent study on Newberry Award winning novels at my highschool and I must say that I can not figure out how it was chosen when it does not fit the criteria. The topics of suicide, murdering of children, and profanity would scare any child!The adult book has been disguised as a child's and should return to the proper placing.
Is the review positive or negative? 