Negative Positive
Title: Elliott's first CD is the real Idol winner
Review: Upon first listening to Elliott Yamin's first CD, I thought it was a good, solid work. However, upon further listening, I realized what a truly excellent collection this is. Songs I had overlooked before, became my new favorites. There is only one song I skip each time, due more to the genre than his performance, and while "Song for You" is my all-time favorite Idol performance, the recording seems to be a bit oversung. Still, Elliott has given us what is probably the best CD to come out of American Idol. He is the most naturally gifted singer of all, and I look forward to his next CD.
Is the review positive or negative? 