Negative Positive
Title: Bring Back Chris Columbus
Review: What a disapointment. I already read the books and saw the first two movies multiple times. The third was horrific. It did not even closley resemble anything in the first two (colors, buildings, even the fat lady changed. WHY?). Additionally they mixed up the sequence of the book and honestly had you not read the book, you would have been terribly confused because a lot of detail was lost. Now no one can say that there was no time because the scene with Harry on the Hippograph was what...2 minutes...and he didn't even like his ride on it to begin with. The last scene with Harry flying in the air on his broom was out of sequence with the book and really innapropriate for Harry's character. Flying off - showing off in front of anyone when not in a game is just not in his character. They focused too much on fluff and visual effects and not nearly enough on dialogue - please stick to the book in the fourth one.
Is the review positive or negative? 