Negative Positive
Title: pink floyd at their absolute best
Review: "wish you were here", along with "dark side of the moon", represents pink floyd at their absolute best. every note on "wish you were here" is perfect -- and all the players, especially guitarist david gilmour, are playing at their finest.this is a concept album on the grandest of scales, with two of the five tracks exceeding ten minutes in length. the first, and best song, "shine on you crazy diamond (part one)", is also the longest, and is an extended blues jam with a few verses of lyrics at the end. this song is, quite simply, one of the greatest songs in rock history. its entire atmosphere is incredible in its emotive power. the other four songs are nearly as great; pink floyd's sound, combined with their great songwriting and playing, makes "wish you were here" one of the greatest rock statements ever.
Is the review positive or negative? 