Negative Positive
Title: It has its moments, but generally disappointing
Review: I'm 14, and I had to read this for school. It was the first book by Hemingway I'd read...and probably will be the last, at least until I'm forced to read another.I thought this book was dull in the extreme. It was full of huge passages of irrelevant small talk and pointless details. I also found the main characters, particularly Catherine, the female heroine, unconvincing as well as unlikeable.Although I didn't really enjoy this book, I respect it, and I realise that others might find Hemingway's style easier and more enjoyable to read than I did. Just don't expect it to be one of those unputdownable passionate war novels which you remember for the rest of your life.
Is the review positive or negative? 