Negative Positive
Title: the BBC audio version is lame
Review: this BBC dramatization of lord of the rings was in my opinion poorly done at best 1 star i listened to a few moments only and the voice for Gandalf was so far removed from what i know of/understand of him that i couldnt bear to listen to listen anymore..now if a truely fine actor read this part( lawerence olivier? sir john gilgud ?liam neeson? Richard burton? etc etc- [ugh all those misspelled] would be quite different story- this is my brief review i would give it one star,but suggest others enjoyed it it seems so this is my opinion only ,recomend look at some other reviews posted at that site for another more favorable opinion .i strongly suggest instead- you should get the recordings of Tolkien himself reading -they are wonderful treasures- provide new insight into the beauty of tolkiens language not to mention how to pronounce some of those words properly- 5 stars plus !!!
Is the review positive or negative? 