Negative Positive
Title: He gets small colleges right; plots and writing wrong
Review: Wait for the mass market paperback.Though I read this in one sitting it was more to study what not to do when writing, and for the record this is one of the rare times I agree with Kirkus' scathing review. A terrible freshman effort starts this two book deal with Warner; lets hope the second novel is actually edited.
Is the review positive or negative? 