Negative Positive
Title: HUH!
Review: I am an fan of historical fiction From the Hornblower saga to Kent to Dudly Pope to name a few. I think Molloy's "Peter Raven UNDER FIRE" was in bad need of an editor who knows the period of the Bonaparte and English war during the 1790's to 1805. The writter needs to know what makes a COMMODORORE in the British Navy of the period. The line of battle ship in the book was 110 guns. OOPS! The "HMS Torren" went to sea to the Caribbean with half a crew. OOPS! It would never have left England with 500 men. Three pirate schooners captured the first Rate Battle ship of the line "HMS Torren"--OOPS! DAH! The story line was ok and the cast of Characters got better after they are defined as the story progresses. I hope the follow on Peter Raven, Midshipman, gets better.
Is the review positive or negative? 