Negative Positive
Title: Not very realistic
Review: I must say, the book was very well written, but the plot was totally unrealistic. After being on the island for only about a year (assuming that is how long, with the change of seasons) these proper British boys turn into bloodthirsty savages. I understand them doing stuff they would not normally be allowed to do, but to murder someone the way Roger did? I strongly believe something like that would never happen in real life.
Is the review positive or negative? 