Negative Positive
Title: Skip This Edition! Nice Cover Art
Review: This edition of the Chesterton classic, The Everlasting Man, has been so poorly proof-read that it has unintelligible passages, omissions, misspellings--often several on a single page. Chesterton never used the word "modem", but it appears over and over. Punctuation has been reduced to the point that periodic sentences seem to be run-ons; commas and periods pop up is strange places. Is it sabotage? I CAN'T GIVE THIS AS A GIFT, AS I HAD PLANNED!"Without my old paperback (Image Books), I would find this incomprehensible.
Is the review positive or negative? 