Negative Positive
Title: All the fans need to quit
Review: I understand why people talk about Fantasia's life. American Idol is just about that: being America's IDOL. It's not just about musical talent, it's about how one conducts oneself; should be good enough to be considered an IDOL. (...)My mother thinks she squeaked Chain of Fools too bad that it doesn't sound even close to the original. (...). The show is about being an idol.Fantasia's lucky that being a "novelty" was a factor in Fox choosing her for the title. Otherwise if it were based on talent alone (which she doesn't have), she wouldn't even have reached the top 12.
Is the review positive or negative? 