Negative Positive
Title: Disappointing, considering his other scientific work.
Review: Everyone is entitled to their own personal philosophy. And if you have a scientific background, you will probably want to incorporate that into your world view. Tipler tried that. It may work for him, but I labored through his book and came away unenlightened and disappointed. I felt light I discovered that a highly respected teacher has gone a little senile.
Is the review positive or negative? 