Negative Positive
Title: A disappointing effort.
Review: If you are looking for a book with useful trading insights, look elsewhere. The book consists of brief and shallow interviews with traders, which while interesting, don't provide much in the way of novel trading ideas; most all of this has appeared elsewhere. Several of the interviews are nothing more than trading system vendors touting their own systems. The author even interviews himself! The book could also use some more careful editing; for example, the author recommends a book, but gives the wrong title and misspells the authors name. If you want to read about traders in their own words, stick to the "Market Wizards" books.
Is the review positive or negative? 