Negative Positive
Title: Very, very undergrad
Review: A graduate program had the audacity to use this as a text. I would say this is a solid community college level text, or perhaps an intro to communications text for a 4 year course. Most definitely not a graduate course level text. Don't expect to gain any particularly new insight into communication if your grad school assigns this text, although you could probably expect an easy A.
Is the review positive or negative? 