Negative Positive
Title: A film buff's nightmare.........
Review: This is a comprehensive movie guide which contains over 19000 entries arranged in alphabetical order. Unfortunately, as according to Mr Maltin, these films get 2.5 stars - "Shawshank Redemption","Amadeus","The Green Mile" and "The Usual Suspects", the latter he finds "convoluted". "The Shining" gets 2 stars and "Blade Runner" gets 1.5 stars. On the contrary, "Space Jam" and "Honey, I Blew Up the Kid" got 3 stars each. This book is ludicrous! The only thing I liked about it was Mr Maltin's ability to encapsulate a film into a few sentences. Amazon's editorial review was absolutely correct - "Maltin's is distinguished by the quality of its reviews".
Is the review positive or negative? 