Negative Positive
Title: I would've given it a half star...
Review: if that were available. This was an awful book. I didn't enjoy any portion of it. I was drawn in by the wonderful 'Clan', and even liked the 'Valley'. Couldn't have cared less about the 'Mammoths', but suffered on to the bitter end. I feel like Jean became a cut-and-paste master, and I can tell you all of Ayla's connections in my sleep! Too repetitive, too bland. Wait for the paperback at the 1/2 off store if you must read this.
Is the review positive or negative? 