Negative Positive
Title: Nice try, but not cigar. . .
Review: Amateurish acting, costumes that look like they came from a high school drama department, laughable special effects (not all), and, most importantly, totally devoid of Herbert's vision. Anyone who really likes this version does not properly understand Dune.Lynch's Dune is weird and difficult to understand if you haven't read the book, but it is much darker and much closer to Herbert's vision, unlike this version.
Is the review positive or negative? 