Negative Positive
Title: Sgt. Pepper - 1967
Review: "I gave Pepper five stars because I don't believe that the Beatles are capable of making an album with less stars." Oh, please.First of all, there are a number of Beatle albums, although good, that don't rate as high as some of the best works by numerous groups of 60s & 70s including Led Zep, Pink Floyd and Hendrix. What unbiased reviewer would rate "Yellow Submarine" 5 stars?As far as Sgt. Pepper - the first track is great. The last track is great. The middle of the album is very mediocre. Two tracks can't save the album, but they each get a star. And this album has dated over time. It sounds old, while the better 5-star albums still sound fresh.
Is the review positive or negative? 