Negative Positive
Title: Great, BUT...
Review: ok, awesome book, it was written by a 17 yr old... nice story line but, it has one major flaw, it totally copied Tolkien... i mean, dwarves who live underground, elves who are tall and master archery Urgals (orcs) also, it is almost like star wars, jedi knights with the force (riders with magic and great swordmanship), and a galatic republic and a rebel area (King Galbatorix and the Varden...But, it is a great book all in all for a 17 yr old...but if u dont like mimickry in books, dont read this book, it will totally and clearly show the relationship between other original fantasy books and Eragon... hopefully, when he gets older he will create works of his own, not copies of original works that take pieces here and there...But on the pro side, it has a great story line, something for kids that can't really understand Lord of the Rings or something.
Is the review positive or negative? 