Negative Positive
Title: Well, let me see...
Review: Let me see the flaws in this so-called "masterpiece", that I should call THE LORD OF BOREDOM:1) WHy the hell all the characters must have at least two different names (in different languages)?2) The "songs" are a joke, boring, it only serves to destroy the narrative;3) endless repetitive descriptions of characters and environment, such as sunset, sunrise, "the air was heavy and hot", "the hobbits were tired and hungry", "the fields were green", "the sky was foggy", ... Uau, it's utterly boring!!!4) Heavy narrative. Tolkien should have handled his ideas for someone else to write. He's totally conservative, and you just can't sense the real urgency in the plot, as modern fantasy writers can do.5) Empty characters. The characters are lame and their dialogues worst still.6) Terribly drawn maps.
Is the review positive or negative? 