Negative Positive
Title: It's Science, Folks!
Review: It would be difficult to have a sufficiently deep and comprehensive background in general relativity, particle physics and information theory to be able to evaluate the merits of Dr. Tipler's arguments. One of the things that makes this book so impressive is his complete mastery of all these areas, when mastery of a single one would be a real achievement for any one person. Even if I am not in a position to cogently critique the theory presented, I will tell you that many people will find reading this book a tremendously powerful experience, especially if you would like to believe (as I would) that death is not permanent.
Is the review positive or negative? 