Negative Positive
Title: J.D Salinger the thief
Review: J.D. Salinger's catcher in the rye is a blatant rip off of John Fante's 'Ask the dust' he only made it more reader friendly. From the catholic imagery, to the very scene of the prostitute dressed in green. J.D. Salinger is a hack, he's a recluse so we think he's so mysterious, but in reality it's because he's a nothing. Stolen, for the love of god, I beg you to read both books and make up your mind who is the better writer, a poor immigrant or a rich brat? I remember having catcher in the rye shoved down my throat in highschool. I couldn't believe the crap that guy flung at us. And the audacity. Fact- "Ask the dust" was published in 1939, catcher in the rye in the fifties. I'm just asking you to read both books and make up your mind. For I already know the truth. JD Salinger is a rich brat that ripped off a meaningful writer's complete style and story. Only made it more posh. Read both books and make up your mind. JD Salinger is a travesty to writing.
Is the review positive or negative? 