Negative Positive
Title: Great, but done before
Review: This book will probably be a favorite for years to come. Although, as others have stated, it has taken ideas from other authors. First off, the dragons, and dragon riders, just like the Pern series. Then all the characters and races are pretty much taken from Tolkien's LOTR series. And the magic, its entire basis seems to come word for word from Ursula K. Leguin's Wizard of Earthsea series. Although she probably based it on ancient myth's and legends of our world. Anyway, it is really a great book, and i suggest you read it, and the other series i've mentioned it.
Is the review positive or negative? 