Negative Positive
Title: Atrocity. No other word will suffice.
Review: I bought this guide back when the game was new, so there may have been revisions since then. However, the guide currently decaying in a box in my basement deserves its fate and then some. Filled with inaccuracies, anyone who accomplishes anything using this guide must have some sort of guardian angel, either that or they're an idiot savant. With such strong feelings, I'm afraid I only remember a few specific examples: the entire bestiary seemed to have been formed by hitting the keyboard until they met their quota, and yet it remains incomplete; monsters with the wrong pictures, or no picture at all; misnamed materia listed with a multitude of inaccurate information. There are many more things that are wrong with this guide, but just writing about this thing is making me mad, so I think I'll stop.
Is the review positive or negative? 