Negative Positive
Title: IS It a 1st Edition?
Review: This was to be a gift for my husband who loves the Paolini stories, but also wants hardcovers in 1st edition state. A 1st edition has several criteria to meet and my Amazon purchase did not meet these. A true 1st must not be a bookclub edition - it must be part of the first original hardcover printing, ideally it also has a dustjacket with the publisher's price not cut. The item I received was a "1st Edition" from a "special" printing, thus not a true collector's first edition. I returned the item, no problems, and ordered directly from an online book dealer.
Is the review positive or negative? 