Negative Positive
Title: lord of inaccuracies
Review: This book could have been really really good if it had stuck to the movie more. Fist of all it added all that weird stuff in the "old forest" and that old senior Bubadil was a little strange. I don't think I would like it very much to be lost in a forest with him and ghosts. Also they cut the lovely and heroic ARWEN out of all the excitement. ALL in all their were to many words and details that bogged everything down(no pun intended). Also, how are we expected to understand elfish.And my wife agreed with me. And I don't think it is just because we are pretty old. My grandchildren also agreed with me and my wife and they are not old.
Is the review positive or negative? 