Negative Positive
Title: Sereious disappointment, don't judge by cover or title
Review: I have to say, I'm severely disappointed in this book. Diamond's GGAS is one of the most riveting NF books I've ever read, and has given me excellent fuel for numerous intellectual conversations. So I expected more from this. I don't need to go into its structure, as 166 previous reviews certainly cover that. I'm disappointed that this entire book is basically environmental statistics from history. It reads much less like a discourse on sociohistorical problems (as GGAS did) and much more like the findings of some obscure UN charter committee.I know the negative checks are going to roll in for this one, that's why I'm doing this as a kid's review. I don't need my good average screwed.
Is the review positive or negative? 