Negative Positive
Title: Rock Or Not Rock?
Review: Billy Joel sounds great to middle aged women and lovelorn agnsty preteens, but his shtick gets old pretty fast. Critics have suggested that Joel is not rock, and while this is not true, his debt to the Brill building is obvious. It's easy to imagine his songs being the basis for a snappy Broadway musical. I admit that I was a fan back in my own misspent youth, given as I was to soggy sentimentality, but unlike Billy, I grew up. You will too. Till then, you will probably love this album.
Is the review positive or negative? 