Negative Positive
Title: Unacceptable change of theme
Review: Commodore Junk George Manville FennHave read almost a dozen of George Manville Fenn's novels. All were quite good if not excellent. I would confidently recommend every one - except this one. There is a situation with the main character which seems rather unbelievable, but I suppose it could happen. The real problem is that the theme (justifiable anger with strong leanings towards revenge), which is stated early on and confirmed, off and on, throughout of the novel, is then completely reversed, with no explanation for such a drastic and unrealistic alteration. After that, for me, the plot crumbles to gross nonsense.Sorry Mr Fenn, you truly let me down this time. Without that totally illogical twist I would have rated this book, as with most of your others, a 5 star
Is the review positive or negative? 