Negative Positive
Title: Crock is a more appropriate title!
Review: With expectations high I was let down big time.If all the sixties smile sessions sound so good, and I have many in my collection, why do the new renditions sound so shallow and fallow?There is very little essence or spirituality in this attempt to recreate youthfull imaginings. The essence of youthfull creativity can not be reinterprited in old age!The original Smile is 1966 Brian Wilson Magic!!!Smile(2004) is not 1966!Almost everything seems to be lacking credibility and drive on this new CD. If you are looking for the unrealeased 1966 Smilethen keep on looking for it it's out there you just have to persevere.
Is the review positive or negative? 