Negative Positive
Title: George Orwell accounts of Spanish War are better.
Review: Matthews attacks Orwell's view of the conflict withinthe Loyalist side. He says Orwell changed his views later. But it was a change in emphasis. Matthew's says the Spanish war left Orwell with greater faith in human nature. True! But this does not deal with issues raised in Homage to Catalonia.
Is the review positive or negative? 