Negative Positive
Title: Good quality, but short fenders ineffective
Review: I recommend getting full length fenders even if you have a bike without eyelets. If you're willing to do a minor amount of customization, you can simply use zip ties to mount to the frame. The quality of these fenders is great, but the fact that they are short means that you still get a lot of spray when over ~20mph. At high speeds spray off the top of the front wheel comes back in your face, spray off the lower back side of the front wheel hits your feet on the pedal down stroke and spray off the back wheel bounces off the seat tube and onto your inner calf. Full length fenders pretty much eliminate all those problems.
Is the review positive or negative? 