Negative Positive
Title: Endearing, but bring Kleenex
Review: Let me first say that this book was given to me as a marvelously thoughtful gift after I put my cat to sleep. The giver, knowing how much I like reading about Scott, Franklin and Shackleton, discovered this marvelous little book about a cat on Shackleton's famous South expedition. It was amazingly thoughtful.HOWEVER, this is a better book to give to an expedition enthusiast and cat lover whose cat is still living. Even then, the reader is bound to cry. The reader who has just put their beloved cat to sleep is going to cry her heart out.
Is the review positive or negative? 