Negative Positive
Title: Deflated historical context
Review: This is maybe the most disappointing film by Annaud. Great history deflated to a boring love blahblah on war background in embarassingly badly crafted décor - reminds of Spartacus movies of the 50ies or the first Star Trek serials with plastic rocks flying around. Very listless. Dully played by most of the actors. If something is mud and dirty - must be Russian. Annaud proves this beautiful attitude once again.PS: There seems to be a double plot - Tania must have been a German spy or something, as the sort of pants she wears (or undresses) never have existed in wartimes Soviet Union. And some more other false impressions and details.
Is the review positive or negative? 