Negative Positive
Title: Like Simon Said, Donald Duck on Helium!
Review: For once in this whole year of American Idol did Simon get it right when he told Fantasia that she sounded like Donald Duck on helium! I thought that I would get the cd and give her a chance because I love American Idol and its whole concept, and we all know that artists sound better on recordings than live, but boy was I wrong! It is the same cartoon voice that she sang with live. You would think that they could have done some fancy productions to cover some of that up on this!! It is just a terrible, terrible effort. Nothing but high pitched shrills and shrieks, sounds like a poor cat dying a slow, miserable death. Summertime is so boring it will make you cry and Chain of Fools with all the added stupid lyrics makes you want to shoot yourself, and I Believe is just like hearing the dentist drill into your teeth. Sorry, but this is not American Idol music! Come on, what happened to talent like Clay and Kelly?
Is the review positive or negative? 