Negative Positive
Title: the best idol debut cd yet
Review: And I don't say that lightly. Clay Aiken had the best prior to Fantasia's. I didn't like the recorded version of "bridge over troubled waters" ( it didn't have the punch of the live performance> which is the only reason fantasia gets a better review from me. All three songs are well performed and well arranged. Yes, "I believe" is as weak as all the other American Idol debut songs but Fantasia performs it well. "Summertime" is awesome and "Chain of Fools" has you bouncing in your seat.I feel that this CD demonstrates Fantasia's range. She could easily have the cross-appeal of say Beyonce, if J records doesn't get it in their minds to just market her as an R&B artist. She can sing anything as AI3 demonstrated. I agree with Simon. Fantasia is potentially the strongest idol yet.
Is the review positive or negative? 