Negative Positive
Title: Views from an expert in the field
Review: Although lucidly written, many critics have failed to note that quite often the facts as stated are not quite right. Especially in a highly referenced book purporting to set forward accurate scientific information, it is regrettable t hat not infrequently it is just plain wrong. The devil is in the details. There are entire sections where there are fundamental misunderstandings of the field, and the primary citations are only to discredited work. The section on the human leukemia viruses HTLV is but one example. A significant problem is that almost no reader will be able to discern for themselves which por tions are junk, and which superb. Get a pound of salt if you read this. And beware of quoting it as a reference. But do consider reading it nonetheless.
Is the review positive or negative? 