Negative Positive
Title: Not for most people....I think anyway
Review: I read this is 3rd grade. I thought it was okay. Now I'm in 8th grade. It's required reading. Ok. I didn't remember much of it from 3rd grade so I re-read it. I was horrified by the simplicity of the book. It's got a plot worse than Godzillia vs. Mecha-Godzillia. The moral is pointless. The setting is boring. I hated it. Some...less mature people might enjoy it, but as a novel for YA it's just not worth it.
Is the review positive or negative? 