Negative Positive
Title: great edition at least just for the 400 textual corrections
Review: i have several versions, but this one is probably the most accurate and i feel that if you are a hardcore tolkien fan, you owe it to yourself to pick this book up.in addition, the 5 book set is by Easton Press (not Eastern) and they are available directly from Eastonpress.com. they are 5 volumes (lord of the rings, hobbit and silmarillion).--addition: if you are interested, there are UK versions of this book (in addition to a limited edition of the Hobbit). also, at least 3 paperback versions exist of the new 50th anniversary, corrected edition of LotR at least in the UK/Canada.
Is the review positive or negative? 