Negative Positive
Title: When good works fail, blame the director!
Review: The director said he made this film for his friends. There are plenty struggling directors out there with greater abilities that could have been used. This is a commercial project and not a vehicle for showing-off to friends.When the warden says there are no aliens on his prison and gets immediately snatched up from above, it's so artificial that the whole scene becomes a waste of opportunities. An amatuer filmmaker knows you have to give the actors reaction time! Maybie Fincher is an amatuer in a job he can't handle.I didn't think his other movie Seven was very good. Fight club was good but I didn't like seeing buildings blown up then or even now.
Is the review positive or negative? 