Negative Positive
Title: Plagiarism... almost.
Review: This story steals from many classics. I suppose it isn't an exact ripoff but the similarities between this and other classics such as Star Wars, Lord of the Rings and so on are so pitifully obvious. I read this to my kids and certainly they enjoyed it, not recognizing the plots, ideas and so on. I also don't think it was well written, there is never any doubt that Eragon will make it and be just fine. The dialogue is pretty bad.I can only give it two stars and that's because the kids did like it. Taken for what it is, a kids book, it is okay but just barely. It's the plagiarism that is so obvious and sickening. I think he made enough changes for it all to be legal, but it is still pretty pathetic.Kids read this instead :The Hobbit
Is the review positive or negative? 