Negative Positive
Title: A Movie other can't Rivel
Review: When I first saw this movie I was a little disappointed in the details left out of the novel. But after seeing a more lavish production that was just an abject failure, I realized that this was a great movie of a great science fiction novel. I still think Gordon R. Dickson's Dorsai would make a better movie, but it would be harder to get the subtile shadings of meaning. It is capturing what makes a science fiction novel great in film that is hard! This version of Dune is a success at that.
Is the review positive or negative? 