Negative Positive
Title: Not Up to Mr. Clancy's Previous Standards
Review: This book is in desperate need of an editor. There are characters introduced then forgotten, misspellings and redundant statements, cultural anachronisms (sorry, I have spent a lot of time in Russia and no one calls anyone 'Comrade' anymore). The whole thing feels like a second draft that could have been tightened quite a bit. Sorry, I think Mr. Clancy has stretched himself too thin.
Is the review positive or negative? 