Negative Positive
Title: sad
Review: You know who did it, how and why before 18 pages are done and the murder doesn't take place until page 80. As it happens I heard the author speaking once, when the book was new. She wrote it as a rebellion against poor sentence structure, grammar, dialogue she had seen in other of the Star Trek series. Okay, success. Shame she didn't have help with the mystery thing.
Is the review positive or negative? 