Negative Positive
Title: The earliest reveal
Review: In an exhibition of cleverness unparalleled to my knowledge, Heyer reveals the identity of the killer in the title, and if this spoils the surprise for you, then you are as clever as she is, and in the course of 30 years selling books and dealing with an uncountable number of readers I've never met anyone who could say that. (I certainly can not.)The only other mystery writer to approach this feat is Reginald Hill, who tells who the villain is in the first sentence of one of his books.
Is the review positive or negative? 