Negative Positive
Title: Would have loved to see it updated
Review: Scarsdale is one of the "classic" diets. I wish Tarnower were here today to give us his overall feelings about the Atkins and other Protien diets. I find they work as well as Scarsdale. The only difference is, on Scarsdale I was constantly hungry. It's a good read, nonetheless. Especially the mention of Jean Harris in the Acknowledgements.
Is the review positive or negative? 