Negative Positive
Title: Extremely disappointing
Review: During American Idol, I honestly didn't like Fantasia. However, I was sure she would sound great on a record. I decided to buy both Diana's and Fantasia's singles and see who's was better. The result was overwhelming: Diana was far superior. Just listening to both versions of I Believe will prove that. Fantasia has kept the horribly painful things she did in the show, which I thought was just to seem edgy and unique and to get fans. Nope...that's her voice.I Believe is by far the worst of the three songs. The other two deserve probably 2 or 3. But, I Believe actually did hurt my head. The high notes are shreiked, and the "yeah-yeah-yeah"s every 5 seconds are irritating. If possible, she sounds even more like Donald Duck meets Macy Gray than she did on the show.I had hopes for Fantasia. I thought she'd finally impress me on a CD, but it's even worse. She's irritating, and can't sing very well.
Is the review positive or negative? 