Negative Positive
Title: where's the hook?
Review: Kelly who? Kelly, if you're making some money now better hang on to it or invest it for the future. Bravo on 'making it' on American idol... what spell did you have on the voters? Yeah, yeah... Lee Trevino was subjected to critism when his peers commented 'you got lucky' after winning a tournament. Lee's come back was... 'funny, the more I practice, the luckier I get.' How does this apply to Kelly? Really, Kelly, you did get lucky. No doubt about it... lucky. I really believe she can't sing without yelling it and that really gets to be annoying after a bit (a very short bit) as well as there is nothing unique to the sound of her voice as compared to Jann Arden, Amy Sky, Carolyn Dawn Johnston and the list goes on. Time will tell... in a year from now (or less) the term will be 'Kelly who'. A short blaze in the pan... good luck in your next endeavor!
Is the review positive or negative? 