Negative Positive
Title: Finish peels off
Review: I loved the look of these and the heavy weight. Brass workings. However, the finish peeled off. I bought mine (2 of them) at Sam's and they had to refund my money since they didn't have anymore in stock. I had spoken with the manufactures warranty dept and they said to take them back to Sams for a replacement. That's all they would do.
Is the review positive or negative? 