Negative Positive
Title: Not particularly good
Review: This book is full of half realized fantastical ideas that it doesn't back up at all.It pretty much loses its own thread and concentrates on some kind of existential crisis that the fake people in the bookshould have learned to live with before being sent on a long space mission.The technology is magical with no explanation at all.And the ending while impressive, is depressing and meaningless, leaving one with vast sense of dissatisfaction.This novel should have had an EDITOR who might have pushed the authors to work a little harder and back up their half formed concepts.Why would I want to read a trilogy, if they are all as tedious as this one ?
Is the review positive or negative? 