Negative Positive
Title: Fair, but lotsa mistakes
Review: I've long had a crush on Eleanor Powell, and I have the copies of all of her movies and I know well the author of the best biography of this fabulous dancing star. But this soundtrack is seriously flawed and I cannot find out who makes it. Track 2 ("Feelin'") is sung not by that leggy Powell, but by June Knight and Robert Taylor. All other songs credited to Eleanor Powell were actually sung by Majorie Lane. Ms. Powell lip-synched songs in all movies she starred in from 1935 on. She sang a couple of short ditties before 1935. After track 15 of the 1940 movie, the finale -- a reprise of the "I've got my eyes on you" song -- is completely omitted. Audio quality is not good. This is a sloppy production. Someone is degrading the reputation of one of the best musicals ever made and it's insulting to the fine cast and crew, in particular to Fred Astaire, George Murphy and that fabulous and divine creature with the best legs God ever put on a woman.
Is the review positive or negative? 