Negative Positive
Title: Useful, but what he doesn't tell you is . . .
Review: Dr. Karp's tips, especially the 5 S's, are right on. They helped us a great deal with our colicky infant. But it takes him several hundred pages to present a few nuggets of wisdom. And those pages are not always easy or pleasant to read. New parents need succinct, practical advice, not page after page of theory and, "Some people think . . . but they're wrong!" Honestly, this would make a five-star pamphlet. What he should fill some of those pages with are tips on when and how to wean your baby off the 5 S's.
Is the review positive or negative? 