Negative Positive
Title: Disappointed
Review: I never watched American Idol before this season (Season 5), but when I saw Clay Aiken doing "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me" in the season finale, I was captivated. He seemed aloof yet sexy, and I wanted to find out more about him so I decided to go back to his album. I was disappointed to find that not a single song he has recorded conveys the same personality I saw onstage - where is the mystery? Where is the charm? Where is the feeling? These songs are nothing better than manufactured, assembly-line pop drivel and even from what little I've seen of Clay Aiken, I know he can do better.Guess I'll just have to get my "Idol" fix from the original music Taylor Hicks has recorded - if you want to hear a finely-crafted, well-written, beautifully understated album along the lines of what Clay SHOULD have done, check out Taylor's "Under the Radar." It is simply amazing.
Is the review positive or negative? 