Negative Positive
Title: Jack McGowan, not JPMcGowan
Review: Common error, and it is true that J.P. McGowan (1880-1952) was Jack to his friends. As J.P., he had over 500 film credits in a forty-year career, only one as "Jack". Primarily, he was not a writer, and this film was not in his vigorous, actionful genre at all. Nor did he ever work for M-G-M. From 1940 he is known only as the forceful secretary of the Screen Directors Guild.On the other hand, the writer usually credited as Jack McGowan did write light material, did work for M-G-M -- and was credited for this froth.
Is the review positive or negative? 