Negative Positive
Title: Genuine Effort
Review: This version has one redeeming feature i.e. it is reasonably faithfull to the original story, but that is about it. The attempt to translate early silent techniques to modern day do not work. I have not seen the 2005 edition yet, but it will have to be very good to approach the quality of the Gene Barry version. He is a great actor, look at the movie "The 27th Day".
Is the review positive or negative? 