Negative Positive
Title: Rubbish!
Review: I have never found myself actually getting angry at a series of books but these have done it to me! These books have none of the subtlety or depth of Frank Herberts original books and they are filled with one dimensional plots and characters such as Rhomber "er" Vernius and Piter de Vries, this second example illustrating proof that the authors have not even read the originals, otherwise they would know that this character's name was in fact Piter de Vried! There are just so many inconsistancies as to make these books laugable if it wasn't so frustrating and a list of these inconsitancies could fill a book on their own. ...In summary where Frank Herberts novels were the pinnacle of the writers art, and perhaps one of the great feats of fiction this book and the the other preludes written by Brian Herbert/Kevin Anderson are in the absolute pit of pulp rubbish. ...
Is the review positive or negative? 