Negative Positive
Title: J. Montgomery brings up some good points, but
Review: J. Montgomery, the guy below me, almost below me, or that was below me, brings up some good points. If I grade using his system, cause after all this isn't English class, then Eragon gets 3.75 stars.I read it in a few days. That merits five stars, I suppose, but the lack of suspence and emotion detracted from the fact that I read it quickly. I have only read a handful of books faster, and they are, Harry Potter 5&6 and Hawksong, by Amelia Atwater-Rhodes. They all got five stars from me, but they had something Eragon didn't, and for the moment, I'll call that heart.Thank you for allowing me to bore you...but one more thing. If you grade this book as if in an English class, based on technicallities, then Eragon scrapes two stars....
Is the review positive or negative? 