Negative Positive
Title: totally forgetable edition
Review: I don't understand why people here are giving this glowing reviews. The 50th Anniversary Edition COLLECTOR'S EDITION in black with a black slipcase is much better. This edition is small. The maps are small. The Alan Lee illustrated edition is better than this. In the 50th Anniversary Collector's Edition there is a big foldout map in the front of the book and another big foldout map in the back. Either the Alan Lee illustrated edition of the 50th Anniversary Collector's Edition are better than this. And why would they publish this 50th Anniversary Edition AND a 50th Anniversary Collector's Edition?
Is the review positive or negative? 