Negative Positive
Title: What have they done to this poor man?
Review: The first time I saw Clay on American Idol, in his audition, I said to myself "theres the winner". The first time I listened to Clay's album, I said to myself "theres a winner who has been turned into a junky commercialized pop-culture phenomena, exploited with traditional sappy songs that were handed to him by writers, and oversung in a way that only a person who has sung 100 songs on TV that all sound exactly the same can."Poor Clay- in a small dose, he has a fine voice. Heck, he could make a really good Broadway performer with his ability to belt 'em out. It's prefabricated crap like this CD that makes me want to spew.A star for Clay's talent, and one for pity. This album truly deserves no credit, because none of it came from the heart.
Is the review positive or negative? 