Negative Positive
Title: Scimitar SL-2
Review: While I enjoyed the plot of a majority of Mr. Robinson's books I found the inaccuracies of the book to be beyond belief. An example would be a Harpoon Missile being used to shoot down a cruise missle.The Harpoon is a Surface to Surface or Air-Surface anti ship missile with a top speed under the speed of sound not an Surface to Air or Air to Air anti aircraft/cruise missile weapon platform which would have a speed in excess of Mach 2.Another issue is the fact the he would lead us to believe that the SAS, arguably the finest counter-terrorist force in the world, would fail to sucessfully investigate the background of an officer under consideration for joining the regiment.Mr. Robinson states in his book that he has numerous contacts within the military community and if so I would suggest that they be allowed to read the book before publication to correct inaccuracies such as I and others have detailed.
Is the review positive or negative? 