Negative Positive
Title: split even with proper care
Review: This board was highly recommended by Cooks Illustrated, which was why I bought it. It is nice looking, but split. I oiled it several times before using, and occasionally thereafter. I don't even own a dishwasher, and never soaked it. Even with all this, it split rather soon after getting it. The board also arrived with a rough, not fully finished-feeling surface. I now only use it for cutting bread. Eventually it will split in two length-wise.
Is the review positive or negative? 