Negative Positive
Title: Valley of the Shadow
Review: Written in the style of a Bulwar Litton Contest winner with the grammatical knowlege of a five year old! No, Mr. Tremayne, between you and I, is not correct english. The passive voice may add a few words(never use one word, if two or three will do)and pad your wallet and the flimsy plot but it does nothing for the reader. History C-, Style and Grammar F.
Is the review positive or negative? 