Negative Positive
Title: Reactionary puff piece
Review: As a student of several of the REAL scholars in higher education, I found Lucas' trite characterizations of higher education and political correctness worthless. Like many other right wing dogmatics, Lucas fails to meet his own tests of academic quality. There is little evidence, few facts, and much hyperbole in his work. I wouldn't accept this fluff from an undergraduate. Has Lucas, like Bennett, Will, Roche, and the other conservative junta abandoned critical thinking? They have certainly abandoned fact, evidence, and rational thought. Too bad it's the old white guys who've killed education in this country.The only saving grace is his critique of college sports; yet, it is so poorly developed that readers might be left without the thorough analysis of UNPAID PROFESSIONALS. Or, save your money and try reading Leslie and Slaughter's ACADEMIC CAPITALISM. Lucas could use a lesson on research methodology, scholarly writing, and engaged discussion.
Is the review positive or negative? 