Negative Positive
Title: Sibley Guide
Review: Sibley's guide is the unquestionable Oxford Dictionary of bird guides, however, if you are new to birding you may want to try the excellent Peterson Field Guides. The Peterson Field Guides are less expensive and more portable than the Sibley Guide. If you eventually get into serious birding, then you may need the detailed information contained in Sibley's.
Is the review positive or negative? 