Negative Positive
Title: Poor Stuff!
Review: This biography is a poorly researched and dishonest apologia for a rather tiresome and spoilt aristocrat whose poetry was as irrelevant and old-fashioned as his "Christian morality". All is explained by the fact that the author is one of his descendants. (Dishonest/poorly researched? Example: the author claims Douglas organised a petition of French writers to defend Wilde and then criticised their hypocrisy for not signing [p. 94]. The petition was in fact organised by Stuart Merrill. See p. 463 of Ellmann's "Oscar Wilde" for the true story.)
Is the review positive or negative? 