Negative Positive
Title: AN OUTDATED PIECE OF JUNK USELESS FOR ACADEMICS
Review: This edition is ancient, still containing an errata page, and with none of the scholarly apparatus including line numbers and notes from Gödel and God knows what else. It is utterly useless for looking up French quotations found in articles with no way to compare this translation to the French original. And it gives far too much deference to Jacques Derrida whose understanding of Saussure is poor. Can anyone suggest a better English version to get and which French version has the most scholarly apparatus? There seem to be two or three dozen different French editions.
Is the review positive or negative? 