Negative Positive
Title: A Redundant Book
Review: There already was a definitive book on the Charlie Chan movies, so I wondered what the rationale could possibly be for putting out another one. And now, having read this new book, I'm still wondering what the rationale was. That list of killers must be the raison d'etre because there's precious little else here--certainly not a great deal of critical insight or writing talent.
Is the review positive or negative? 