Negative Positive
Title: Filter Used to Remove Grain also Removes Detail
Review: Samurai Champloo was not animated in HD so this set is an upscale. However, it appears that a filter was used to scrub the grain from the video. For example, in one scene on the DVD you can see the individual roof tiles on some buildings. In the same scene on the Blu-Ray disk, the roof is just a blurry mess.I recommend getting the DVD set over the Blu-Rays. I suppose if you hate grain that was added to the video on purpose by the animators and can stand the drop in detail, you should get this set. Since this is a true case where the DVD has more detail than the Blu-Ray set, I would go for the DVD and just use an upscale player.
Is the review positive or negative? 