Negative Positive
Title: Not really an AH fiction!
Review: I don't know why all the high praises. To me this is 3/4 love story between a French woman, her German lover and a romantic American officer, 1/4 action or wanne be action that gets nowhere. It is short and the Battle of the Bulge only comes near the end, with some actions about the Eastern Front right at the start but they are not worth mentioning, making it one of worst fictions I have even read.
Is the review positive or negative? 