Negative Positive
Title: A Tasteless Piece of Junk full of false accusations
Review: Wilson's many accusations of C.S. Lewis just show how incompetent he truly is. He confused Lewis with his brother, Warren, making the claim that the accomplished writer was a heavy drinker. He also accuses Lewis of marrying Joy Davidman for sexual interests, when it has been proven time and time again by those who actually knew the man that it was rather a marriage that would let her live in England as a citizen. He takes several quotes from Lewis, his friends, and his family and twists them out of context. It is a disgrace to see so much filth printed about a good man. Perhaps Wilson should pay more respect (and more journalistic competence) to the truth.
Is the review positive or negative? 