Negative Positive
Title: Clay's the Best! However...
Review: I couldn't wait to buy this CD. I wanted to hear "This is the Night" again, I loved it so much on the Idol show. I thought Clay nailed it, especially the powerful refrain. To my surprise, the judges HATED the song, even though they liked Clay's singing. Even an article on my MSN homepage trashed the song, calling it "god-awful". I don't understand it. I LOVE the song! Anyway, I must say I was the tiniest bit disappointed with the CD. Neither song is as exciting or powerful as on the show. Of course, part of the reason for that is that I also like WATCHING Clay so much. He's so adorable - watching him is so much fun. The "Night" song lets Clay's voice come through better than "Bridge" on the CD,where I thought the choir was a little too prominent (just let Clay sing!). I still like the CD very much, and I will never tire of Clay's voice. So, buy it, Clay fans, and support your Clay! He's one of a kind. I can't wait for a full album.
Is the review positive or negative? 