Negative Positive
Title: The Ultimate Pipe Book Regurgitated And Slightly Updated.
Review: Let me start off by saying that if you own a copy of the Ultimate Pipe Book by RCH, you don't need this book. It is essentially a word for word copy of it! Imagine my disappointment when reading this only to discover I had read it 20 years ago in the UBP. Only this time, there is a tobacco section with the authors nonsensical rating scale.That being said, if you don't own the Ultimate Pipe Book, this is worth the read. As other reviewers have stated, there is very good information to be found here, you just have to get past the authors ego and occassional inaccuracies. Mr. Hacker deserves credit for filling a void in the pipe smokers library some 25 years ago but to release this book under a new title is just ridiculous and shameful.
Is the review positive or negative? 