Negative Positive
Title: confusion!
Review: This is possibly one of th worst books I have ever seen on Karate. Its an absolute mess and mish mash of ideas. The Author tries to present Okinawan karate in japanese Budo context??? instead of trying to find reasonable answers to problems he has jammed various things together to create an ugly hybrid. The techniques shown are more related to full contact kickingboxing than Okinawan karate. There is no relation between the fighting techniques and the kata. Secrets???? the techniques in here are suitable for a beginner on the road to full contact competitions but forget it if you are looking for Okinawan karate.
Is the review positive or negative? 