Negative Positive
Title: Very Disappointing
Review: I am a long time fan of the Planescape campaign setting from 2nd edition, and I have to say that this product was very disappointing. It is far less detailed than its 2E precursor, especially concerning Sigil. The center of the D&D cosmology is relegated to little more a paragraph, and the Lady of Pain and factions are given no more than a brief mention. What's worse than this, to my mind, is that all of the flavor and atmosphere from the original setting have been done away with. The distinctive dialect and book art are gone. Furthermore, the numerous typographical errors, badly worded explanations, pointless illustrations, and confusing descriptions of how the layers of a plane relate to one another make this book seem as though it was quickly and shoddily tossed together. I recommend it to no one, especially if you ever played with Planescape in 2nd edition.
Is the review positive or negative? 