Negative Positive
Title: An attack on Ender's Game
Review: Ender's Game became, when I read it, one of my favorite books. This book is OK, alright, acceptable, etc. any middle of the road adjective you could think of and even that, it's only because it's based on a story I liked, in a location I liked, etc.So why not give it 4 or 3 stars?Because it actually seems to try to tear down Ender's Game.All the things you remember about Ender's Game, this book tells you they were actually WRONG!Ender is a smart kid? well NO, turns out he's "slow" compared to the title character in this book.Ender took a ragtag group of people and made them into a great 'army'? NO, the only reason he did well, was because the title character in this book chose a great army for him.Ender is a good leader? NO again, he only did well because the title character in this book was helping him behind the scenes.I could go on, but you get the gist. This book takes your prized memories of Ender from Ender's Game and tears them down.Extremely disappointing!
Is the review positive or negative? 