Negative Positive
Title: 1 star for the book, 5 stars for the movie!
Review: I saw the film before to read the book. For me, the movie is the more beautifull that I ever see with the movie "The Thin Red Line". Tom Hanks is my favorite actor and, for me, Capt John H. Miller it's his better charactere because he's a sensitive man and in the same time a rude commandant how masq his impress.Like the movie is very good, I read the book but, for me, is a very bad book: Colins doesn't write any details and doesn't give any emotions in his text. he made a summary of the film and not a description!In conclusion: See the MOVIE and DON'T read the book. Write me if you have the same or another avis of me. @+ Mia
Is the review positive or negative? 