Negative Positive
Title: Same flaws
Review: 1. The tape that covers the magnet at the end of the holding flap came loose within three weeks. I had to replace it with duct tape to keep from losing the magnet, but the magnet should have been better attached in the first place.2. The belt clip does not have a curl/hook shape at the bottom to keep it from sliding up off your belt like the similar $26 phone holster at Best Buy. The spring clip is tight, so I have not lost the pouch yet, but it would be better if it had the curl/hook to be sure it won't come off.
Is the review positive or negative? 