Negative Positive
Title: terrible product
Review: Got this for Christmas '10 and just as other reviewers have stated, the lid doesn't stay on at all. The first time I tried to pour I thought it was "user error" so tried again. And then again - this time over the sink. And every single time the lid fell right off at any attempt to pour - and I was filling it less than half full! I can't even imagine the mess a full pitcher made for the poor souls that made the seemingly logical assumption that a pitcher, any pitcher, would have a secure fitting top.Just as bad, along with the top falling off, the whole filtration insert begins to slide out too, so if by some chance you started pouring and thought "oh, caught it!", just wait one more second and the whole insert will fall out and you'll have your giant mess again.I honestly thought I must have a defective one and so I came on here to check reviews and see if others had the same 'defect'. Now that I know it's just plain old shoddy design, I will be returning it and NOT getting another.
Is the review positive or negative? 