Negative Positive
Title: Ho hum
Review: Tad Williams has written better; I enjoyed the first couple of books of his Otherland series, The War of Flowers was a good book, and the Memory, Sorrow, Thorn series was a respectable bit of fantasy literature. Shadowmarch just feels weak. I had trouble making it through this book, finding it a potent sedative - handy if you have trouble sleeping, but not an endorsement generally.
Is the review positive or negative? 