Negative Positive
Title: Derivative
Review: OK, up front I'm a big Tolkien fan. Since the 70's. Never heard of this guy, but thought, well, I like this kind of stuff. Let's give him a try. Read the first story. Slowly. Started the second story. Gave up after about four chapters. You can see where this guy got all his ideas. Save time and just read the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings trilogy again. I have 5 times. You won't be disappointed. With Terry Brooks, you will be.
Is the review positive or negative? 