Negative Positive
Title: confusing and lacking info
Review: I thought that Winter Rose was just a piece of confusing mumbo jumbo. It's hard to recognize whether Rois is dreaming or in reality because sometimes the author doesn't state the fact that Rois is conscious or not. There are other reasons that made the plot hard to follow. The characters didn't give enough information on this "other world" that Corbet came from. How did it form? Is Nial, Corbet, and the "witch" the only inhabitants? Also, the ending leaves too much questions. Does Corbet still love Laurel? What does Rois feel? How did Corbet escape from the other world? Finally, the narrator, Rois, was too mysterious. The point of view should have been in third person, not the wild wood-child. Some of the discriptions by Rois was skimpy and perplexing.Though I love fantasy (and this book is definitely fantasy), Winter Rose was just too weird and puzzling for me to really like and understand the book.
Is the review positive or negative? 