Negative Positive
Title: POOR EMOTION!
Review: Flying Without Wings should be full of emotion. Ruben tries to swing through based only on his smooth voice. His rendition of this song leads me to believe that the American Idol producers were afraid to let him and Clay sing the same songs for fear that Clay would give far superior performances of the songs. Can you imagine Clay singing this song?? Would have suited his voice much better!
Is the review positive or negative? 