Negative Positive
Title: a disappointment
Review: ...I found Hoffman's characters to be unlikable, as well as inconsistent. The use of the word "f***" throughout the book did much to give me a feel (as well as some nausea) for the heartlessness of hero/villain, Hollis, but when the word came in the voice of the heroine..., March, it rang opposite her romanticized view of her relationship with Hollis. ...I didn't have any sympathy for Hollis, where I fell in love with Heathcliff. And no character in "Here On Earth" seems to be better off in the end for having made it through the novel. Many relationships severed, but few lessons learned...
Is the review positive or negative? 