Negative Positive
Title: Holbrook's premises collapse on bad physics
Review: Holbrook devotes a large portion of his book to debunking the effectiveness and logical basis of Western science. Unfortunately, he is incapable of distinguishing between neurobiology and atomic physics when discussing matters of color, and when discussing blackbody radiation he cannot perceive the value of idealized models. I found it difficult to extract useful information from his writing when his arguments were based on false premises.Overall, a very disappointing book, though it might be useful for training physics students in detecting logical fallacies.
Is the review positive or negative? 