Negative Positive
Title: One of those over-educated types responds
Review: What you have in the previous review is a perfect example of the type of students prevalent in the US higher education system today.... crying, "Give us Science Lite!" Heaven forfend that you should have to apply a formula in what is perhaps the most QUANTITATIVE of all the biological sciences, ecology!! Now having vented, let me say that Stiling's book is certainly not the perfect introductory text- in fact I find it LACKING in detail in some respects- but it isn't a bad choice at all for the introduction of interested students to the study of life on the planet we inhabit.
Is the review positive or negative? 