Negative Positive
Title: A good translation minus some helpful things.
Review: I am lucky enough to have both the first print of this wonderful book as well as the second. while the second printing offers some interesting and helpful additions it would still be nice to see a side by side arabic writing of the quran as well as amaybe a transliteration. other than that i like the fact that the book was written with little use of outside sources. no hadith etc.(...) Debates concerning some of the translation choices and ideas expressed in the translation continue on openmindedly in a mature fashion.read the book, visit the site and you wont regret either.
Is the review positive or negative? 