Negative Positive
Title: Trotter no Catherine Cookson ...
Review: I have been struggling for six months to finish this book. I wanted to read it because it was supposed to be about Catherine Cookson and Trotter was tooted as the "new" Cookson. I strongly suspect if Ms Cookson read Trotter's book all she would recognize is her name, the location, and perhaps the poverty. The plot is weak and I hate John McMullen with a passion. The man is never going to die.I have read almost everything Catherine Cookson wrote, some of her works more than once, and I can honestly say Janet McLoad Trotter is no Catherine Cookson.
Is the review positive or negative? 