Negative Positive
Title: A Disappointing Follow-up to Fup
Review: I loved Fup... everyone I know loves Fup. Fup convinced me that Jim Dodge is a genius. Not Fade Away, while showing flashes of that brilliance, is also many things that Fup is not: contrived, overlong and redundant, and ultimately anticlimatic. Somehow Dodge lost the storytellers knack for the concise and telling detail on this one.
Is the review positive or negative? 