Negative Positive
Title: Holmes' fans beware
Review: "The Final Solution" is a self-indulgent and not very intelligent piece of writing. The title is blatantly misleading: this is not a story of detection. Worse, the Sherlock Holmes character is simply not believable. None of this will matter to those who are admirers of Chabon's writing style (I am not one of them), but those who enjoyed (for instance) Nicholas Meyer's "Seven Per-Cent Solution" will be sorely disappointed.
Is the review positive or negative? 