Negative Positive
Title: excellent writing except....
Review: This book had very poignant moments but overall the characters seemed just too idiotic to be believed. The main problem for me was that it wasn't obvious why Claire Marvel was so great, why she was worthy of unremitting love. She has a few witty remarks and is supposedly beautiful but what of it? Her acts are not justifiable and therefore you can't relate to her or to the protagnist. In the end I just wanted to knock both character's heads together because they acted so stupidly. I suppose their inability to commit to each other might be some underlying theme of the novel but it makes very frustrating reading!!!
Is the review positive or negative? 