Negative Positive
Title: Errors of Fact, Poor Interpretations
Review: This book fails to understand the overaching principles of the renewed liturgy. Written by an Australian priest living in Rome, it criticizes gratuitously certain applications of the reform of the liturgy in the United States. It's selective in it quoting of Roman documents, especially regarding the placement of the tabernacle. All claims to "orthodoxy" cannot make up for the poor scholarship.
Is the review positive or negative? 