Negative Positive
Title: Amazing Spider-Man Vol. 8: Sins Past
Review: Quite possibly the WORST Spider-Man story I have ever read. Take it from a real Spidey fan who's read more issues of Amazing Spider-Man than he hasn't. Gwen's death has a special place in the hearts of every Spider-Man. JMS just took that respect and specialness and drug it through the mud. The besides being an absolutely AWFUL concept and idea, the story conflicts with continuity at several points. It destroys the "tell all" type of relationship Peter and Mary Jane have. And above all else, it degrades Gwen Stacy and completely sours her reputation. I can't emphasize how truly horrible this story is. Please: if you haven't read it, don't bother. It will only taint your memory of that sweet little blond named Gwen. And if you have read it: Promptly forget it and disregard it as I have.
Is the review positive or negative? 