Negative Positive
Title: The ultimate Chopin.
Review: I'm not short of versions of the ballads and the scherzos so I have compared the Rubinstein's to many other (Ashkenazy, Pollini, Rachmaninov, Argerich, Janis, Kissin etc.). For the ballads I put Rubinstein and Ashkenazy in a special place. Ashkenazy has a better sound (thick and deep bass sound which is familiar in his recordings) and his playing he is exstremely powerfull. Rubinstein's sound is a bit flat but has no hiss or that kind of stuff. The playing is clean, every note is heard and the fantasy-feeling gets perfectly through. For the scherzos I put Rubinstein in the first place. In the 2nd I also like Argerich's powerfull approach and Kissin's playing in this schrezo is also superb. But for me no one gets the 3rd better than Rubinstein. Just listen to the "raindrops" in the right hand! I like the 4th very mush but find the Ashkenasy best. So after all I think that this must be the recording if you are looking for the ballads and the schrezos on one recording.
Is the review positive or negative? 