Negative Positive
Title: Trumpets fade ... hopefully
Review: This is not a movie: It's a succession of clips stitched together. I don't know if this editing is the one decided by the director but the result is exceptionally bad. For instance, we see the battalion attacking German positions and taking much of a beating. The sequence after we see the survivors of the attack lying and moaning. Where are they? What has happened? Have they made it? After a while, we understand that the attack was a failure but we never saw the fall-back order and the retreat. The whole movie is like that: There is no scenario, no tenure, nothing interesting in the end. Quite upsetting when you're getting used to higher movie making standards.
Is the review positive or negative? 