Negative Positive
Title: tabloid trash
Review: This is a fat, nasty book. It's thinly-sourced, but chock full of factual errors that are easily recognizable to any real fan (one small e.g., he claims she got distracted by a heckler and flubbed the introduction to "If Love Were All" in the Carnegie Hall concert....but millions of people know that recording by heart and know she didn't flub it). The worst parts are when the author tries to get into Judy's head and comes up with psychotic and nonsensical speculations about her sex life and motivations -- i.e. declaring that she married Minnelli, a "known" homosexual, only so that she could continue to have affairs with other men "guilt-free." It's crazy and disgusting.
Is the review positive or negative? 