Negative Positive
Title: Excellent scholarly work
Review: It is apparent that Karen Sullivan has a keen analytical mind and thorough knowledge of her subject. The negative reviews posted on this site are ridiculously partisan, not taking into account that the pro-French accounts (and possibly witnesses) are at least as politically motivated as the English, which Sullivan deals with masterfully.Perhaps the best and most insightful modern book on the topic.
Is the review positive or negative? 