Negative Positive
Title: Stands on Its Own
Review: I first saw the TV series, then started reading the books. Initially I watched the series because I also have a Westie, like Wee Jock. Soon, I was sucked into the stories and characters. When I discovered the books I was excited but confused by the dissimiliarity to the series. However, they are each excellent. It is hard to imagine anyone else playing Hamish or Alexandra/Priscilla. As a previous reviewer wrote, some of the mysteries of the TV series do seem to be mere hooks to hang character studies on, but that is completely fine. The drama is riveting and the comedy true.
Is the review positive or negative? 