Negative Positive
Title: Nice while it lasted, but sprung a leak
Review: Had this very nice-looking (albeit occasionally mistaken for a liquor flask ;-) ) water bottle for a bit over a year. The aluminum gets dented fairly easily, but supposedly the plastic lining inside should maintain a seal. Not for me! One of the dented "corners" now leaks. Drip drip drip. I don't know if this is more likely given the oval design--those "corner" regions are very dent prone. Also, the colored enamel chips off of the dented regions, which is merely an aesthetic problem, but worth noting in case that matters to you. I'm getting a Klean Kanteen to replace it--my daughter has one, and while it is heavier, the stainless steel doesn't dent (or leak).
Is the review positive or negative? 