Negative Positive
Title: Vaguely related vignettes masquerading as a novel
Review: Two of today's best science fiction authors collaborate on a fascinating concept and produce...a book with no discernable plot, no central characters, no apparent theme or message, and as if that wasn't bad enough already, it has no ending, but simply stops at a more or less arbitrary point. One of the biggest disappointments of recent years.
Is the review positive or negative? 