Negative Positive
Title: Loud, awkward, and shallow
Review: In a nutshell, you can cross this one off the list if the following issues are things that will bother you:*It is extremely noisy.*The tray is very shallow - I had trouble with tumbling cigs and ashes. Also, unless you empty it after two or three cigs, it is over-full, so that when you extract the tray to empty it, butts and ashes leak into the workings underneath.*The lid, which hovers over the tray, is in the way. I kept hitting it with my hand or the cig.In short, this ashtray is poorly designed and loud. I threw it away.
Is the review positive or negative? 