Negative Positive
Title: Clever idea, poor execution
Review: I have to give the author credit for the idea, but I found the book impossible to finish. The tone is unsophisticated and anachronistic, and the character never comes to life due to the lack of rich detail. Considering how little is known about the real woman, the author could have let her imagination run wild, but this effort is stilted and flat.
Is the review positive or negative? 