Negative Positive
Title: Buy Clay's Single Instead, or a Luther Vandross Album
Review: Ruben's voice just does not cut it. It seems as though he tries to imitate Luther Vandross, and it does not come across as even near the level of Vandross' voice. Superstar is already on the other American Idol album, and Flying Without Wings, the way Ruben sings it, is just mediocre... there is no point in buying this single. Clay Aiken's single, on the other hand, is excellent. Ruben got the better written song, Flying Without Wings, as opposed to This Is The Night, but Clay has so much more talent than Ruben, that he can pull it off. If you are looking for an R and B voice like Ruben's, you are better off with a Luther Vandross album. But if you are looking for a real quality voice, purchase Clay's single.
Is the review positive or negative? 