Negative Positive
Title: My undergraduate students could have done better.
Review: Frankly, after about fifteen pages of this sloppy writing--which even my undergraduate writing students could have made passable prose--I just gave up. What a shame--good story line. He could have given some grad student in a creative writing program a hundred bucks to winnow out the most egregious blunders and come out with a far superior product.I have kept the book to pass around among my students to show them just how bad a manuscript can be and still be published. They just won't believe that something so shoddy could actually be printed and distributed.
Is the review positive or negative? 