Negative Positive
Title: The Trilogy
Review: I have read all three "trilogy" novels. I thought all three stories were worth telling and I have taken something away from all three readings. The Spanish never bothered me although my knowledge is rudimentary. Character, dialog and setting are wahat matters here. Cities of the Plain like the others is not very much about plot...dialog and voice, however, are McCarthy's chief gifts. The epilog of Cities reminded me of Jorge Luis Borges a great deal. I am wondering if professional reviewers ever really read McCarthy's books.
Is the review positive or negative? 