Negative Positive
Title: Amazing
Review: It amazing to me as an editor at a New York house that stuff like this ever gets published. The concept is excellent, but the author lacks the basic ability to tell a story. I doubt the best editor could have salvaged the kind of writing on exhibit here, but at nearly 500 pages, there is no evience anyone even tried. If a million was paid for screen rights, the author won the lottery.
Is the review positive or negative? 