Negative Positive
Title: Academic Review Article
Review: Before you buy this book, or even after you have read it, you should read this academic review article by Robert Finlay in the "Journal of World History". An earlier amazon reviewer supplied the citation for this article, but it is also available on the internet at:http://www.historycooperative.org/journals/jwh/15.2/finlay.htmlIt is a rather lenghty rebuttle of Menzies ideas and more importantly his methodology. It may seem like a lot of reading to do before buying a book, but as Menzies tome is quite long itself you owe it to yourself to read this first.
Is the review positive or negative? 