Negative Positive
Title: An Almost Treacherous Disappointment
Review: I actually felt betrayed. The book, and especially the dialogue, reads like a seventies TV miniseries. Very shallow, stereotyped characters, a ridiculous plot, overt moralizing, and an anticlimactic climax. The only -- and I mean the only -- interesting thing in the book is a commando rescue mission in the middle of the book. The editors deserve special blame, not only for missing obvious mistakes but also for not trying to whip the book into shape.
Is the review positive or negative? 