Negative Positive
Title: Negative Account Doesn't Tell Entire Story...
Review: Admittedly, Swofford's book is well-written, but as a former marine and Desert Storm veteran I found myself wondering if he was talking about the same war. I have like stories of hazing, drinking, etc., but these are hardly the highlights of my career in the marines. It does not surprise me that Swofford did not attain a higher rank as his line of thinking is quite low-level. The average marine understands the need for strict dicipline, does not mistake hard training for abuse, and most assuredly DOES NOT stick the muzzle of his weapon in his mouth and contemplate suicide.Swofford's free-thinking is commendable, but just because you agree with the military's objectives doesn't mean you are "drinking the Kool-Aid" and lack independent thought.My honest assessment of the author is that he is a disgruntled 10 percenter who found catharsis through talented writing. I am embarassed by his depiction of both the Gulf War and the Marine Corps in general.
Is the review positive or negative? 