Negative Positive
Title: Horrible, amateurish transfers - a rip off
Review: Beware of the other rave review posted here which cannot be for this product, as the Richard Strauss items are not even on this MP3 album. I purchased this thinking it might actually be a genuine RCA production and found the transfers so poor (off pitch, wavering, excessive noise reduction), it made me consider my own lp transfers of this materail almost of professional quality. Many of these items received their best transfers in the 1999/2000 "Immortal" edition, but even the 1990 Toscanini Collection edition is light years ahead of this fraudulent, snap-crackle-pop and waver issue. When will Amazon start listing more specific information about the source of their MP3 products?
Is the review positive or negative? 