Negative Positive
Title: Charging wouldn't work for me.
Review: I have a 3G iPod (15gb) that wouldn't stay charged long enough to update via USB, and 3G iPods won't charge from USB using a standard iPod USB cable. The item description for this product led me to believe that it would charge my iPod while updating, and it simply didn't do that. I even left the iPod sitting in the cradle over night, and the battery is completely dead. I know that the iPod will charge because my car charger works fine.Another note: The different cradle adapters didn't seem to fit the iPod very well at all. Basically the dock connector on the dock is slanted back, but the adapters appear to be made so that the iPod would stand straight up. Not a very good design.
Is the review positive or negative? 