Negative Positive
Title: A good editor could have done wonders. And should have.
Review: Stephenson seems to have gotten in the good graces of his publisher to an extent where no one reined him in. The premise was great; the characters fascinating and then the book dribbles to a nonsensical conclusion as if Stephenson really didn't care that much and wanted to move on. Too bad as it's now a huge blemish on his reputation. Hope the next one is tighter. Hear this Neal?
Is the review positive or negative? 