Negative Positive
Title: Absolutely dreadful!
Review: This book reads like 12-15 encylcopedia articles strung together, and gets waaaaaaaaaaaay off subject. A long ethnohistorical essay is included (among several others of dubious relation to the F&I War) on Native Americans that has very little to do with the subject and is very much out of place. Many details are wrong--dates of birth, names, etc. This is a "don't buy". Go for Fred Anderson's "Crucible of War" instead.
Is the review positive or negative? 