Negative Positive
Title: What appears to be a not very clever forgery. . .
Review: Serious Lewis scholars have known for years that much controversy has surrounded the appearance of these "unfinished stories" with regard to their authenticity. Walter Hooper, Lewis's "alleged" secretary, who unfortunately still maintains the rights to Lewis's literary estate, has proven himself to be an unreliable source, at best. Kathryn Lindskoog, among others, has cast serious doubts on whether anything Hooper says or publishes about Lewis can be considered accurate.Chalk this one up as "deutero-Lewis" (and badly written at that), and forget it.
Is the review positive or negative? 