Negative Positive
Title: Warm and Comfy at first
Review: I received these boots for Christmas in 2009. I used them through the winter for shoveling, tramping around and some snowshoeing. They were warm and comfy. Then one day the following winter I was surprised to find that my foot felt wet. The boot had split where the leather mets the rubber, right above the ball of my foot. So after 380 days of ownership and about 20 days of use, they had split open. Terrible quality for the price.
Is the review positive or negative? 