Negative Positive
Title: Whose Whining
Review: In response to one of the prior reviewers:1) This book hardly deserves to be called literature. "War and Peace", it's not.2) It sounded like the author was doing a lot of whining, from the few chapters I read. Business is not school.3) When professionals respond negatively to an outsider's commentary, they are typically not doing so out of a sense of wounded virtue. People that work on The Street know all too well the realities of finance. Rather, they become angry when they see the author fool the many readers who do not have much business experience. It's not that the portrayal is too harsh or unfair, just that it is inaccurate and designed to elicit a predictable reaction from naive readers.
Is the review positive or negative? 