Negative Positive
Title: A clear and honest analysis of Robert Scott' s fatal journey
Review: I previously reviewed this book, and still have the same thoughts. I think Shakelton would have been the one for this journey. Preston brings out the ill prepared journey in graphic and sympathetic terms. I do not, however, quite understand how Scott has reached such a high place in the role of Engligh heros. After all he failed in his attempt, and although courageous it is obvious he was ill suited for this journey. It was another "Everest" case, rivalry led to the death of these obviously brave men.
Is the review positive or negative? 