Negative Positive
Title: No mystery fan should miss this superb work of research
Review: New Jersey crime is the author's forte (see "Murdered in Jersey") and here is the one with everything. The wandering rector, the bored choir singer, the domineering wife, the ineffectual husband, steamy sex, and secret mail drops. Tomlinson has combed the vast literature of this unsolved crime and presents the reader with a tightly argued case for the probable vilain. While this book represents a classic example of critical scholarship, it reads like a compelling novel. One can literally feel the mind of Holmes/Doyle lurking in the wings.
Is the review positive or negative? 