Negative Positive
Title: One of the few...
Review: This is one of the few books on neijia I would recommend on arts that are difficult at best to learn live. The detail on basic training is excellent, something that many western "experts" talk about but seldom "eat the bitter".The historical info is probably oral transmission from Wang Pei Sheng who trained with a who's who of Beijing teachers. Would have preferred to see a tape of the form. Getting it from a book without previous experience with these styles is not likely. Nevertheless, the basic training detail and interesting history make it worth the price. I have never met the author but have heard of him from friends in Beijing who say he is the real deal.The reviewer below "from Beijing" who disliked it might go discuss the "laughable" techniques with the author(who is listed as really living in Beijing} and report back to us.
Is the review positive or negative? 