Negative Positive
Title: Ilya Gililov's Hypothesis Refuted
Review: Ilya Gililov's unfounded claim that Robert Chester's 'Loves Martyr' and Shakespeare's 'The Phoenix and the Turtle' were published in 1612-3 (instead of 1601 as it is universally accepted) and that the Turtle and the Phoenix were Roger Manners, the 5th Earl of Rutland and his wife Elizabeth who died in 1612 has recently been demolished. See Boris Borukhov, `"The Phoenix and the Turtle" Was Published in 1601', Notes and Queries, volume 53, No.1 (March 2006), pp. 71-2.
Is the review positive or negative? 