Negative Positive
Title: Good, but not great
Review: While Ruben does have an undeniably good voice, his performances of these songs are a bit bland. The original versions of both songs (Flying Without Wings was originally a Westlife song) were more soulful than his renditions here. The American Idol judges cheated Ruben out of a chance to improve himself by refusing to offer the same criticsm to Ruben that other contestants on the show received. Ruben, unfortunately, never had a chance to improve himself from week to week.
Is the review positive or negative? 