Negative Positive
Title: A TUBBY SHE
Review: I have just watched this verion of "She". Dispite having writen "dialouge" straight from the novel plus following the story quite faithfully its a pitty that She herself is portraid as a middleaged overweight matron with no waistline, to add insult to injury Leo/Kallikrates is played by a big nosed weedy guy, no hint of a greek god here, it would have been better to send ms Andress back in time with a chippendale stripper for man candy (its silent film so who cares if he can talk!) were all people this ugly in the 1920s? im surprised that haggard himself was suposed to be part of the film production? Well its nice to know bad taste has no time zone. When are they going to do a dicent film version of haggards greatest story, the 1960s Hammer version towers over all other attempts so far. Perhalps this is one novel that just cant be filmed.
Is the review positive or negative? 