Negative Positive
Title: Polemics, Not Scholarship
Review: Readers of Papal Sin should be aware that, although the book bears a physical resemblance to a work of scholarship, it's mere angry polemics. Wills consistently ignores serious authors who argue--and, often, demonstrate--theses that contradict him. The treatment of matters like Vatican Council I and the Humanae Vitae debate will not impress anyone familiar with the literature on these topics. A pity.
Is the review positive or negative? 