Negative Positive
Title: Disappointment from a Good Author
Review: Okay, there are twists (and I won't give them away), but this story is very familiar and the story never rises above mediocre. It might be good to a reader 12 or under, but any high school student will read it with cynicism and disbelief. Giles' other works are high quality - Shattering Glass is a favorite - but this one just seemed flat. You might feel sorry for the narrator, Sunny, but you won't buy into her story.
Is the review positive or negative? 