Negative Positive
Title: Promising concept poorly executed
Review: This book lacks substance. Sherry Smith draws conclusions on such a small amount of evidence that some of it is laughable. Some of her logic to arrive at her conclusions is also very suspect. Additionally, most everything interesting that you'd want to read in such a book, she only mentions in passing, telling the reader to look in her source books for more information. It would have been nice if you put it in your book to give it some substance. Overall, this is one of the worst books on the West I have ever read.
Is the review positive or negative? 