Negative Positive
Title: I Wonder What Roger Thinks?
Review: This live album leaves much to be desired. A great set list only to be marred by lazy Gilmour vocals and terrible Scott Page sax. You can actually hear Gilmour just saying the lyrics to Us and Them. Gilmour takes control of Floyd and does exactly what Roger said they would do "Milk the name for all it is worth.". I can not say much more about the video either. It is clear that Gilomour's heart is no longer into it. The really sad part is the choice of songs for this tour. They are great songs but with a lackluster performance it is heartbreaking to hear them. Gilmour has gotten so lazy not only does he not want to sing he also turns some of the lead over to Tim Renwick. So, I give this album 2 stars and that is because of Gilmour's lead on Comfortably Numb and a great choice of songs.
Is the review positive or negative? 