Negative Positive
Title: disappointing
Review: This reads like a first novel, too choppy and vague for my taste. Dunkle inserts historical information in a less-than-subtle manner (such as her description of the villagers' clothing) without grounding us in the reality of the time period. (What time period? In what country?) This aspect of the tale reminded me of Sherryl Jordan's _The Raging Quiet_, an equally implausible plot in an equally vague historical setting. Even the werewolf mythology is incomplete, not in how one becomes a werewolf, but in how one heals from being a werewolf. I wouldn't recommend this to a discerning fantasy reader.
Is the review positive or negative? 