Negative Positive
Title: Use Strunk & White + Diana Hacker instead!
Review: This book is not conducive to a writing class. Diana Hacker's reference books are slimmer and easier to read for citation/formatting help. Stunk and White is, as always, the best, and FAR more affordable for students. This book is heavy, laborious to look through, full of useless images to "pretty up" grammar, and too expensive for a student. Using, for example, Purdue University's online writing website is a free and useful alternative. The only worthwhile chapter is Chapter 5 on Revising, Editing, and Proofreading.
Is the review positive or negative? 