Negative Positive
Title: Agree w/ tediously repetitive hyperbole by previous reviewer
Review: Hearing of the release of this book, I was looking forward to reading it. After stuggling through it, I thought I had missed something until I read other reviewers. Didn't someone edit this book? Many of the reviewers are correct; it is not a well- written book on an interesting man. In fact, if you read the acknowledgments (page 317), it appears that the author has ripped off the good stuff from Professor Hugh Torrens who was writing on the same subject. Let's encouage the Professor to finish his works. Maybe that will give William Smith's memory a better turn.
Is the review positive or negative? 