Negative Positive
Title: The girl...cannot...sing. Period. End of story.
Review: First of all, I concede that there's something to be said for her as a lyricist. But as a singer, she is horrifyingly, almost comically bad. I saw her on TV and thought she was just "having a bad day" (as that other song goes), then heard the CD and realized that even under studio conditions, Ms. Kimball is dreadful: a thin, grating voice and a near-utter inability to stay on-key. (In the back of my mind, I keep thinking I hear Randy shouting, "Whoooaaa, girl, kinda pitchy there....!") To think, NBC a few years ago anointed this girl "America's most talented kid." Yikes!And this is what we look up to today. How sad.
Is the review positive or negative? 