Negative Positive
Title: Seen it before...
Review: *****SPOILERS******I'm surprised that nobody's compared this one to "Atonement." Maybe it's only because I read this one a mere month after I finished "Atonement," but boy talk about deja vu. I even checked to see the copyright years on both books - 2001.I thought the story moved very slowly, and I too, as mentioned in other reviews, had little sympathy for Thomas. I didn't like his character very much at all. The teenage romance hardly seemed as deep and long-lasting as the beginning of the book described. And I saw the "uncle" story coming a mile away. Of course, I didn't predict the ending, but then I just read nearly the exact same ending in "Atonement" so I was hardly astonished.
Is the review positive or negative? 