Negative Positive
Title: David Weber he isn't
Review: I bought this hoping to find an author to add to my favorites list. I failed, read book one and found it shallow and improbable. Bought book two hoping the author would improve his skills. Failed again. I will not buy book three. So what's wrong, please explain how you can have a war between two federations when a small old ship can distroy a planet with one shot. Wouldn't one side simple destroy other side. Obviously the author has never been aboard a ship. If all you do is watch stand in one of three 8 hours shifts when does the other stuff get done. No admin, No maintenance, No training, and HR at all. Just not plasible. If you want Space Navy read David Weber.
Is the review positive or negative? 