Negative Positive
Title: Violent porn
Review: The only thing worse than violent porn (and by porn I mean gratuitousness for its own sake) is a talented, established writer trying to write down to her audience in what she clearly perceives to be a marginal genre. I'm basing this response on my memory of my experience reading it as opposed to the book itself, which I successfully managed to forget almost as soon as I threw it down.
Is the review positive or negative? 