Negative Positive
Title: The voice is sooooo wrong.
Review: A critic on National Public Radio said 'Colony Girl' was a gem that had been overlooked by other critics and that hadn't received the acclaim it deserved. He said the male author had done an astonishing job of writing in the voice of a young girl. After I read the book, I gave myself a dope-slap. Why had I trusted a man to tell me that another man wrote convincingly in the voice of a girl?!?! The book is little more than a male fantasy about what discovering sex ought to be like for young girls. The voice is wrong, wrong, wrong. The other critics were right to ignore this book -- and I wish I had.
Is the review positive or negative? 