Negative Positive
Title: Uh, I read it...didn't like it...
Review: When I [found] A Complete Guide..., I could not wait to dig into it to relive some of the funniest episodes from my favorite show as well as catch quick and/or subtle jokes I might have missed. After spending an hour or so flipping through its page by page guide, I was ready to clean my ceiling fan blades. A Complete Guide utterly lacks the satiric tone of the show. It's the equivalent of having someone you work with who isn't terribly funny describe an episode of the Simpsons from the previous evening. Simply reading factual accounts of bits that are sublimely funny left me cold. The ultimate Simpsons book has yet to be written.
Is the review positive or negative? 