Negative Positive
Title: Please Roger, no more solo albums like this, PLEASE...
Review: I can't figure out what Roger was thinking when he put this mess together. I thought David Gilmour had an ok recording with 'About Face', nothing great just ok. Roger on the other hand records this mess and I'm sorry to say that I can't even say it is ok, it's just bad. Listen to me when I say that Roger and Dave do their best work when they are together in the studio fighting and screaming at each other over what works and what doesn't and in the end it is always perfect, some of the best music ever recorded.I don't think there is anyone telling these guys or challenging them when they are in the studio, someone should speak up and say, hey this is no good how about doing it this way. Imagine saying that to Roger Waters whose ego is bigger then than the earth itself. I know they will never get together again in the studio but hey it's nice to dream.
Is the review positive or negative? 