Negative Positive
Title: This Rock fan HATES this.
Review: "How can any rock fan not like this?" is one reviewers headline. I say, "easy, this album [stinks]". Oh sure, there are some moments when everything sounds beautiful and uplifting, but that's only when Billy Corgan is'nt singing... The man simply can't sing. His voice is TERRIBLE. And lets be honest here............. there is nothing musically on this record that hasn't been done before, and better for that matter. This is a classic case of 'The Emperors New Clothes'. So many critics have fawned over this band that everyone seems to be afraid to say that this band is not really that good. 'The Emperor is naked' I say...eeeeeeeeehhhhhhhhhhh.......that's the sound of Billy's voice.
Is the review positive or negative? 