Negative Positive
Title: You have to be a girl to truly enjoy this book
Review: I've read better. A story about mothers and their daughters and their relationships with each other most likely only appeals to females. How is a guy supposed to enjoy this book to its fullest? I will say, however, it is well written. Perhaps if Tan authored a more interesting story, it could be enjoyed by a wider range of readers.
Is the review positive or negative? 