Negative Positive
Title: Grave errors
Review: Although the novel wasn't bad, there are 2 glaring errors that caused me to give it only one star. First of all, the final chapter (#28) was out of sequence. It belonged somewhere around chapter 20 or there abouts. A really stupid error. The second thing that bothered me is the Epilogue. Usually in an epilogue, the author ties up any loose ends and perhaps throws in some background info about what happened after the events in the book. This the author did. However, he specifically mentions that the leading General in the book, General Scherer met with an author by the name of Lucas in 1977 to help him write the history of the battle of Cholm. This is absurd, since the general died in an auto accident in 1955!!! And the author should have known this since Siege was published in 2003! A big disappointment.
Is the review positive or negative? 