Negative Positive
Title: Potential without substance
Review: Sigh. This book had so much potential. McKillip had a wonderful, engaging main character in Rois. In fact her characterisation in general was wonderful. And the basis for a plot was undeniably there. But it just didn't develop. It was vague and gossamer like, and at the end I was so sorry, because I could have loved it if it was a little more substantial, but it was so airy it fell flat.
Is the review positive or negative? 