Negative Positive
Title: Compelling if only anecdotal in connecting Southern & Celtic
Review: Relying on name comparisons between the Celtic forebearers and Southern descendants and drawing on many anecdotal comparisons of Anglo/Yankee -v- Celtic/Southern customs a strong case is presented that the War for Southern Independence was virtually ordained from the beginning of colonial development. The comparisons are overdone however, and obvious character contradictions in the evangelized and disciplined Southern personality exhibited during the late unpleasantness is not explained. While entertaining and I think necessary reading it left me wanting somehow.
Is the review positive or negative? 