Negative Positive
Title: Almost as good as Guralnick's Elvis book.
Review: And that's about as good as books on music get. The stories of minor and supporting character's are given air in Mr. Guralnick's books and that is what sets them apart. As a fairly serious follower of American music it is a treat to have a writer who obviously loves his subject (and has similar tastes to me) choose to write at some length about people like Dan Penn, Solomon Burke and James Carr. That he does so in such a poignant yet unforced way is just icing on the cake. This is more than a history of Southern soul music. It's an exciting and surprising story of real people who created some real extraordinary music.
Is the review positive or negative? 