Negative Positive
Title: Putrid? Foundering? Not bad? Tiny Tim or Pink Floyd?
Review: I read what's posted and have to ask what they were listening to. Obviously not what I hear in DSoT. This is my favorite. Pulse is better on visuals, if you get the video, but falls woefully short on both sound quality and richness. On DS of T, Gilmour cuts some guitar riffs which makes you feel deprived when you hear the original CD cuts on the radio, and the saxaphone wails here, where whoever they used on Pulse is only "there" and toking on Prozak. Pulse has one cut that I really value -- "Terminal Frost," a rich, vibrant, and pulsating instrumental. But for the best of Pink Floyd, for an incredibly rich, powerful, masterful performance, you can't do better than DS of T. Even better, the video is as good as the CD, plus you get some ladies who wail on Great Gig in the Sky, who also look great doing so.
Is the review positive or negative? 