Negative Positive
Title: Badly written, full of mistakes, devoid of depth
Review: Just because a person decides to write a book on the Three Stooges does not mean he understands the Three Stooges - or even has a feel for the subject. This book is riddled with factual errors and reeks of a person who couldn't hold his own in a casual discussion with Stooge fans. Nearly all of the (correct) information in the book is available plenty of places elsewhere, and by authors who truly know the subject.
Is the review positive or negative? 