Negative Positive
Title: America's GOLDEN IDOL has feet of clay
Review: Extremely disappointing!!! The trouble with releasing covers is that they have to be at least as good as, if not better than the originals. This is not the case with either of these songs. Superstar is painfully slow and over embroidered (a la Mariah Carey). I liked Westlife's Wings, but this is a bloated version with no sense of direction or climax.I don't dislike Ruben's voice, but I think it is a shame that they have released two of his weakest performances as his first single rather than two of his strongest - A Whole New World & How Do You Mend A Broken Heart?It is fascinating to follow the aftermath of the TV show. Clay and Ruben both have potential, and the world is watching, but if the recent media appetite and their respective singles are a true indication of what is to follow, I predict that Clay will be a SUPERSTAR and Ruben will be a shooting star.
Is the review positive or negative? 