Negative Positive
Title: If no stars were an option, it would so be
Review: Terribly disappointing to find the author straying down one unconnected path after another without ever finding appropriate cohesion or unity. This was obviously done as a series of short stories, patched together by an inept editor. The long, overdone bout with gastroenteritis came from a writers' class exercise and had very little place in this book. The ending was tacked on as an afterthought by author and editor when they realized they had already gone too far to quit and needed some sort of conclusion, no matter how incongruous.
Is the review positive or negative? 