Negative Positive
Title: A good story but not well-told.
Review: Despite what could have been a cast of deeply romantic characters, McDermott failed to develop them to a level that drew me in. Having heard that the book had won the National Book Award, I forced myself to read on, hoping to be drawn in to the magic of the story. Unfortunately, it turned out to be nothing but an unsatisfying slog.
Is the review positive or negative? 