Negative Positive
Title: Who can do songs better than Bad Religion?
Review: It's already been done perfectly by Bad Religion, so why buy a cd with amazing songs that are absolutely massacred by mediocre (at best) bands? Bands like Hiroshima absolutely destroy the songs. Greg Graffin has the most beautiful melodic punk voice out there, and the singer of Hiroshima sings bad even by the standards of somebody with a voice box. Now, if this cd was done by other well-respected and established punk bands like Pennywise, Good Riddance, Strung Out, etc. this would be an interesting cd to listen to. This should have been kept in the garage when these bands attempted to cover BR's classic songs. It should never have been put to a cd. I wouldn't be too flattered if I was any of the guys from Bad Religion.
Is the review positive or negative? 