Negative Positive
Title: Ugh
Review: I wish I could have liked just one character besides Rip who was almost too saintly until the end. This book was very disappointing, and I really wanted to quit reading, but I soldiered on and laughed out loud at the last paragraph. Siddons can do better. She usually is so good at creating a place that becomes real and vivid. Fox's Earth was only a shell that housed madness and cruelty. The book was too long. The location did not become a character as in so many of her other works.
Is the review positive or negative? 