Negative Positive
Title: Not a revised edition
Review: I was asked to review this book by an academic journal and discovered that it differs only in insignificant details from the first edition of 1996. Replying to an email I sent, the director of the University Press of Colorado, publisher of the new edition, admitted that the book "should not be called a revised edition--that was a bit of a screw up on our part. It should have simply said 'With a New Foreword' rather than 'Revised Edition.' We anticipated more corrections to the original text than we actually got, but we never got the title adjusted accordingly prior to publication."Caveat emptor.
Is the review positive or negative? 