Negative Positive
Title: Oh, please
Review: After everything O'Nan's done for us, this is easily his most insincere. I never believed the ethical battles, I never bought the slight insanity and I certainly couldn't figure the point. Darkness for darkness' sake is, well, just dark. It's as if Stewart was just looking for a new setting to ply his trade, rather than flexing his literary muscles, as he has in the past. I don't buy it.
Is the review positive or negative? 