Negative Positive
Title: Gilmour is not floyd.
Review: This album is a travesty to Pink Floyd. Gilmour has amazing guitar work, but the vocals of gilmour in an attempt to replace Waters are pathetic.I sound more like waters. I sounds like it was recorded at a kereoke bar with 50,000 middle-aged fans. I would have been fine with Floyd all dying in a plane crash after "Final Cut" was recorded. I hate these CDs so much I gave them away for 5$. Buy stuff with the real floyd, like the mid-1970s releases.
Is the review positive or negative? 