Negative Positive
Title: A Comprehensive But Slapdash Directory
Review: The word 'manual' in the title is completely irrelevant. All it really contains is loads of names, addresses and phone numbers. Information on some countries is scarce, some of it is obsolete. The most striking is the abundance of all kinds of printing errors. In some cases even large blocks of text are placed in a section where they do not belong, producing an impression of a complete mess!
Is the review positive or negative? 