Negative Positive
Title: Hype and Gloss
Review: While the book contains many interesting bits of information, the manner in which those bits are woven into a skein supporting Menzie's hypotheses borders on the scurrilous. This work suffers from a severe lack of scholarly integrity, as well as Menzie's overwrought and often fantastic conclusions based on the thinnest of so-called "evidence." The author's exuberance for his own radical hypotheses clearly clouds his judgment and conclusions. This is a shame because there is probably some truth to at least some of Menzie's claims.
Is the review positive or negative? 