Negative Positive
Title: A controversial book with insight
Review: The author presented several valid points which challenge the established financial economics. The author demonstrated his deep insight in the topic. The framework he is proposing is new and interesting. I am not sure whether his fiber bundle theory is "more correct and more useful" than the existing economics theories (it might be though, I am currently still reading the book), but certainly the author has laid out his theory on a solid footing. I believe Ilinski has done a good job to make me look at the financial economics from a very different point of view. No matter whether you agree with him on the whole or not, this book is one of the books financial economists should read.
Is the review positive or negative? 