Negative Positive
Title: Sad attempt to save a sinking ship
Review: I've been a huge Solas fan for 4 years, so I was thrilled to hear of their most recent release.I cannot describe my disappointment when I found out Solas lost their lead singer AND their lead guitarist. Both members were vital to the band's success, as is proven by this CD. The new lead vocalist pales in comparison to Karen Casey - she has a fine sense of pitch and a clear tone, but she lacks musicality almost entirely. The new guitarist is adequate, but no match for the previous musician's unique rhythmic style. I suspect that the addition of a percussionist to the group is a sad attempt to make up for that loss. Unfortunately, both the percussionist and the new electric bassist only serve to drown out what's left of talent in this shadow of a formerly fantastic band. Seamus should take some time off and reconsider his next musical adventure instead of hanging on to the crumbling shell of Solas.
Is the review positive or negative? 