Negative Positive
Title: Absolutely beautiful!
Review: A gorgeous, rich, complex story framed in McKillip's trademark lyrical prose. Rois was an amazing character and makes a wonderful and magical narrator. You see the world from her not-completely-human perspective and it really comes to life. The ending is a bit confusing, though--does Corbet forget everything from the other world? Is he now fully human? Did he ever love Rois at all (or Laurel, for that matter) or was he just using them to become human and to escape the other world? Still, it is a beautiful, magical tale that I was sad to see end.
Is the review positive or negative? 