Negative Positive
Title: Many "Wrong Notes" in this rag
Review: Although Brooke Shields recived positive reviews in her run as Ruth in Wonderful Town I was VERY VERY disapointed with this recording, I think it is just verry simpal Brooke Shields is no Donna Murphy. Considering that Brooke Shields isn't one of our better vocalists, it is still a load of crap. Beyond Shields' and Wills' vocals, the rest of the recording remains the same as it was with Murphy and Westfeldt. Several tracks are untouched from the 2004 edition; these include the overture, "Christopher Street," "Pass the Football," "A Quiet Girl," "Ballet at the Village Vortex," almost all of "My Darlin' Eileen," and, but for a spoken line or two, "Conquering New York" and "What a Waste."BUY THE ONE WITH DONNA MURPHY- A REAL BROADWAY STAR
Is the review positive or negative? 