Negative Positive
Title: badly written and factually inaccurate
Review: In 16 years of teaching and writing British History, this is by far the worst textbook I've ever seen. It is full of serious errors, totally ignores a great deal of significant scholarship and is both tedious and confusing in its narrative. Students and other readers would be well-advised to try surveys from Penguin or Norton instead.
Is the review positive or negative? 