Negative Positive
Title: a confusing disappointment
Review: I was very impressed with Shattering Glass and had looked forward to DGDWL, but after having read the ending three times, I just don't understand what happened. The end was more confusing than subtly suggestive/mysterious. The mystery's "solution" seemed tacked on and implausible - even within the realm of the fantastic. And...unless I missed something...who *is* Karen?Maybe Giles will do better next time....
Is the review positive or negative? 