Negative Positive
Title: Could have been great as a short story
Review: Dahl or Poe would have loved the (darker) subject matter of this book for a short story. Unfortunately Ishiguro ruins it by adding page after page of pointless, banal high school anecdote. It seems as he was working on a "Catcher in the Rye" type of book, but it was too bland so he decided to add the subject matter of cloning and organ donors. Or the other way around, which would be even worst. Anyway, if you liked "Remains of the day" avoid this, or be very disappointed.
Is the review positive or negative? 