Negative Positive
Title: Clay is my American Idol...
Review: ...Now my comments:1. Bridge Over Troubled Water- I think that his recording of this isn't quite as strong as the emotion of the live performance. It sounds like he wasn't permitted to record it to perfection. A very good performance, but I liked his live performance better.... his voice is drowned out by the chorus at times.2. This is the Night- This is actually better than his performance on the finale. His vocals are clean, the lyrics and music are very pop-oriented. I think this is the stronger of the two recordings.Overall, I really hope that Clay chooses the more difficult path of recording music in the style of Josh Groban- live music, great heartfelt lyrics, allowing for free range of vocals and focus on the incredible instrument that his voice is.
Is the review positive or negative? 