Negative Positive
Title: What a disappointment !
Review: Maybe it'll grow on me; but the anticipation of hearing these classic Paul Simon songs performed by Broadway singers was a severe disappointment. So often "cross-overs" don't work and this seems to be one of these cases - even great singers and interpreters of songs like Amanda McBroom don't seem to be able to add anything new. Maybe the songs just aren't as good as we had believed and these new productions simply reveal their shortcomings. I hope I'm wrong and that over time I'll grow to enjoy the album - I doubt it though.
Is the review positive or negative? 