Negative Positive
Title: I looked for friends and got strangers
Review: For all the work they put in to get everything else right, they sure got the characters wrong. Most of the personalities were completely revamped, and personally I found that far worse than having their names mispronounced or their costumes wrong. The only one left unmangled was Gandalf. Arwen shouldn't even be in the Fellowship of the Ring, she was hardly even mentioned in the books and they made her a central character (replacing Glorfindel, who always seems to get left out of things). They spend too much time on the cave troll, cutting out far more important things to make room for it, mainly plot stuff which I guess isn't as popular. It was good, but I do think they could have done a better job.
Is the review positive or negative? 