Negative Positive
Title: GOOD TOPIC, HAPHAZARD GISTS
Review: The motive of this book is very fine, but its factual presentation is the exact opposite.Starting with the first chapter, John Man's intention to initiate his audience into the ancient Chinese writings brought confusion to both himself and his audience. Information about the ancient Egyptian writings are not better. They were presented in hazy haphazard manner. It is easy to lose patience with the very first part.The author had scarcely understood his topic before rushing into teaching his audience.Nevetheless, I must add that if the needed homework is accomplished, Mr Man would come up with a better book: a very interesting piece. But as regards the current situation, most readers would get lost in this book. It is that confusing!
Is the review positive or negative? 