Negative Positive
Title: While an scout, author needs to do better research
Review: First off, while I am a long time scout and scouter, and do not like how some groups have been attacking the BSA, I don't fully agree with the author.One glaring issue I have with the book is that the author needs to do better research. Too often he used second/third hand works instead of going to the source. If you're going to quote B-P, read his works and cite them, not someone else who quotes him from another source. I also saw several area in which the author is not knowledgable about something (he is very ignorant of the originals of Girl Scouts/Girl Guides) and should have done his home work.
Is the review positive or negative? 