Negative Positive
Title: A different kind of loud
Review: So the reason you're looking for a fan called "Whisper" is because you are concerned about noise, right? Well in that case, save your money and your warranty. Whisper is just as loud. True, the sound is a little different - I'd say a lower harmonic whine versus the original fan. But just as intrusive.The only good thing I can say about it is that the fan definitely moves more air that the original fans.
Is the review positive or negative? 