Negative Positive
Title: Who judged this? It won over something as good as "Al Capone Does My Shirts"?
Review: I can't believe it! The storyline was ok and all, but there were much better 2005 books that deserved something as honorable as the Newbery. This book will be on the list of "the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children", up with "The Tale of Despereaux", "Holes", "Missing May", "Julie of the Wolves", and "Johnny Tremain". It just wasn't good enough. Maybe good for the HONOR, but not the MEDAL!!This doesn't make sense!!?!!!?!?!??
Is the review positive or negative? 