Negative Positive
Title: Mylodons?
Review: Interesting book, perhaps parts of it are correct, but some are blantantly not. The mylodons were an Ice Age giant sloth that became extinct 10,000 years ago. The remains that Menzies says that are proof of their recent existence have been carbon dated and have been shown to be older than 10k years. Like frozen mammoths in Siberia, mylodon remains have been preserved by the cold in Patagonia. If such an animal existed in Patagonia 500 years ago, there would be numerous skeletons to prove it, but there are none.
Is the review positive or negative? 