Negative Positive
Title: This is Hugo material??
Review: I read this (and Hominids) in the library.I have read science fiction and this isn't it.The writing is pedestrian, the ideas are let down by their development, and the characters are wooden. A lot of people equate science fiction with all three, I hate seeing them proved right.Spider Robinson has despaired for the state of science fiction... this is why. It's been taken over by Harlequin.
Is the review positive or negative? 