Negative Positive
Title: Where Was The Editor?
Review: I usually like Siddon's work but Sweetwater Creek was just TOO 'way out there' for me. The descriptions were enchanting for the first 100 pages, then I felt like I was drowning in adjectives.The editing was pathetic. Contradictory statements, poor research. Since when is a dolphin a FISH?????Glad I got this one from the library and didn't waste my $$$.
Is the review positive or negative? 