Negative Positive
Title: Extremely disappointed
Review: As an avid dog-lover (who may sound fanatical, but I am not), this book bothered me for a couple of reasons. First, Mr. Grogan says how much he loved Marley.....but on the other hand, his wife and kids left for Boston and they took a family vacation when Marley was on death's door. I have trouble leaving my dogs enough......but they mean enough to not to me to not drop them off at the vets for a week when they are very ill. Also, you keep on saying "just a dog"....well my faithful companions are a true member of the family and would never be referred to as "just a dog" when referring to me emotions. Try reading "The New Work of Dogs"....that is a book truly for dog lovers. I questions the motivation for this book....was it for money or a tribute to your faithful friend. Also, I thought it was inappropriate to call Mr. Rodale "eccentric".
Is the review positive or negative? 