Negative Positive
Title: Dull & Lifeless
Review: I hadn't listened to this recording in years & when I did I was shocked at what a dull, lifeless preformance it is. It seems as if the orchestra had played this music so often that they were bored with it & were just going through the motions. It plods along with no joy, life or excitment. I was so turned off that I studied the other available sets of the Schumann symphonies & ended by ordering the Levine & Philadelphia and the David Zinman & Zurich orchestra. Both are quite different from each other & a huge improvement on this recording.
Is the review positive or negative? 