Negative Positive
Title: Good Biography on Stonewall
Review: Farwell's biography is a good comprehensive read of one of the most famous Civil War figures and covers many events in his life.Among the areas Farwell focuses on include:1. Early childhood (and rough years they were)2. West Point years(met many future Civil War generals there).3. War with Mexico (many instances of bravery).4. Prewar years at VMI (not well-liked by the cadets).5. Marriages and family life (tragic yet happy years).6. Religious faith (strong Christian).7. Early Civil War service (mainly successful)8. Emergence as a brilliant general (2nd Bull Run, Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, etc.).While Farwell is sympathetic to his subject, he pulls no punches when describing Jackson's weaknesses (uncommunicative to fellow generals, willingness to hold on to grudges, sometimes cold-hearted).All in all, a fair and objective biography of a brilliant leader.
Is the review positive or negative? 