Negative Positive
Title: There's just something about Winik . . .
Review: I give this book a "10" because it is rendered in beautiful, compelling prose and it took me to places in the human experience I have not gone and never will personally. I am aware that this memoir has been greeted with cautionary morality and has earned the dubious distinction of a citation in the Flummery Digest on the Internet, but for me, Winik makes sense. She writes straightforwardly without a lot of analysis, without apology, without self-punishing hindsight. I learned about Winik from, of all things, an article in the March 1997 issue of Cooking Light. As a follow-up activity to reading the book, I recommend searching the Internet for Winik's account of going on "Oprah" to promote the book.
Is the review positive or negative? 