Negative Positive
Title: A major flaw
Review: A major flaw is K&K's silence about Whately's Logic of 1826. This book , which went into many editions over nearly 100years, was instrumental in the revival of logic in the English speaking world. Reading Whately made logicians out of De Morgan, C S Peirce, William Hamilton.For the history of logic after 1840 or so, K&K is superseded by Grattan-Guiness's The Search for Mathematical Roots.
Is the review positive or negative? 