Negative Positive
Title: Biased story, Clubland is much better
Review: I have read the Clubland, written by a Village Voice journalist, and believe it to be much more accurate. The fact that St.James is a part of this scene makes his point of view vulnarable to biased opinions, especially considering his not-so-innocent ways himself. Clubland also puts the story in a bigger picture and connects the dots much better. I'd prefer Clubland any second over this book (I have no affiliation to either book's author, publisher, etc). One important thing is that the subject of both books is (same subject) very interesting and anybody who's been in NYC or been to a club in the 80s and 90s should read one of these books (Clubland is a much better read, too)..
Is the review positive or negative? 