Negative Positive
Title: Disappointing execution of an interesting concept
Review: P.D. James disappoints in her book in the bitterest of ways - by poorly executing what is a tantalizing idea.Working backward from a concept to a (loose) plot, this novel seems stilted and forced throughout.The climax - wink, wink - leaves one giggling from unsuspended disbelief of circumstances, plot, andcharacters. What should have been an interesting exploration of the meaning of reporduction to a societythat takes it for granted (or, some may argue, disdains it) turns in to a brainy romance novel without the sex
Is the review positive or negative? 