Negative Positive
Title: Silly Planet
Review: I will not repeat what has already been said that reflects poorly on this novel. All I do have to say is that if you liked the novelizaions of the movies, including the most recent, THE PHANTOM MENACE, you will NOT like this book. Mr. Bear seems to try too hard to add to the Star Wars universe and fails. The middle third of the book drags horribly and then the end is rushed and, I am sorry to say - silly. I cringe whenever I read a STAR WARS novel that feels "Star Trekie," and this one is the worst. If you go for that type of universe, be my guest. However, I feel ROGUE PLANET was a dissapointing sequel to the prequel. Mr. Bear should take some writing tips from Mr. Brooks!
Is the review positive or negative? 