Negative Positive
Title: Disappointing character development
Review: Still an enjoyable read for Stargate Atlantis diehards but characterizations didn't ring true, especially Dr McKay's portrayal. In the tv series, he is eccentric and sometimes clueless, but not repeatedly stupid as was portrayed. The personalities seemed to be contrived so that the plot would work, rather than to be true to their development on the tv series and made the characters seem lacking in depth and intelligence.Interesting plot and plot development; just would be nice to have more accurate character portrayal.
Is the review positive or negative? 