Negative Positive
Title: sloppy and careless research and factchecking spoils this one
Review: This book is filled with easily caught and corrected minor errors. Example; General McClellan's campaign in West Virginia in 1861, before there was a West Virginia. Also there is obvious bias in much of the description. While it may be a useful source for research, each critical fact should be checked with other sources for veracity,
Is the review positive or negative? 