Negative Positive
Title: Not so "Harrowing" and Not too "Personal"
Review: If you're an average person looking for a "harrowing and personal account of a...fight for survival" (description taken from the flap of this book) ... this ain't it. If your interest is in the emotional impact on the soldiers -- how it affected them and what personal changes they went through as a result -- that just wasn't here. (Truly "personal" and "harrowing" is David Bellavia's "House to House.") If, however, you want a history lesson (or a timeline of events), this is the book for you.
Is the review positive or negative? 