Negative Positive
Title: crap..enough said
Review: while its true that you cant adequately transfer a book to a movie, the makers of harry potter,iron man(i know its not a book but it still held true to the story line), etc have done it quite well. this movie absolutely butchered the books and the script would've been better suited for toilet paper. elves looked like the other humans, the herbalist looked like will smith from wild wild west scene, every thing just SUCKED!!
Is the review positive or negative? 