Negative Positive
Title: Carrie Underwood < Ruben Studdard < Fantasia < Kelly Clarkson
Review: Carrie Underwood's debut album is the WORST idol debut of them all. I thought that Ruben's was bad. Well it was, but not nearly as bad as Carrie's. She doesn't sing well because she never harnesses a song and takes it for what it is. All she does is sing it pretty, well let me let you in on something, pretty means nothing without a meaning. Whitney Houston could yell all she wanted too but it wouldn't mean a thing if she didn't put herself into what she sings. You've got quite a few lessons to learn little girl. Until you do, you won't have any worth in this industry.
Is the review positive or negative? 