Negative Positive
Title: This book is a Travesty
Review: I have rarely seen such a wonderful idea go so wrong. The fact that a guidebook to the WoT world was needed was undeniable. But usually when an author is still alive it is possible to put together a book that actually contains more information in it than the books it is ment to describe. What we got, is something like the many weaker Tolkien world guides which just repeat what was in the books. The WoT guide lacked any analysis, a decent picture, or even a well designed structure. The book looks like it was the work of one morning. The only things that interested me was the older maps, and some of this history. If you are thinking about this book, DONT. Hop online and read the newsgroups, you'll get a deeper analaysis, and even better pictures!
Is the review positive or negative? 