Negative Positive
Title: Biased, orientalist, misleading translation of a great historical book
Review: This is an inaccurate, biased, sometimes ignorantly misleading and at other times deliberately misleading translation, by an orientalist, of a great historical Arabic book that was written by a Muslim scholar. All the mistakes of the orientalist have been scrutinized, and his claims have been debunked, in an Arabic book and Ph.D. research by Dr. Muhibbuddeen Abdulsabhan Wa'ith, from a university in Saudi Arabia. The Arabic book by that Ph.D. scholar is called "Kitabul Masahif", first published in 1995 and the second edition was published in 2002. If you are looking for an accurate translation for this work, then look elsewhere. This translation is just another weapon in the intellectual war against Islam and Islamic history, to mislead and misinform the masses, albeit with a pseudo-academic touch!
Is the review positive or negative? 