Negative Positive
Title: disappointing
Review: Thursday helped define the genre, but beginning with a City by the Light Divided the band sounds flat and no longer relevant. The four live tracks here are among the best songs that band has written, but the vocals are muddled and contain none of the urgency and dynamism of the studio recordings. The new studio track is simply disappointing. It lacks the melody and tonal structure of the band's best work.
Is the review positive or negative? 