Negative Positive
Title: So Disappointed!
Review: I am a great fan of Ross's original The Little Noisy Book and have a very worn version so I jumped at the chance to get the new book....but I am very disappointed. This version is very condensed (only 10 pages vs. 25 in the original). Furthermore, the pages in the new book are out of sequence. In the original book, there is a wonderful flow and rhythm to the text but not in this re-arranged version. While the illustrations and text are the same, this book lacks the sweet charm and wonderful flow of the original.
Is the review positive or negative? 