Negative Positive
Title: Basic premise totally unrealistic
Review: There is no way an immature,irresponsible naval officer such as the XO in this garbage book would ever be placed in a position of such responsibility. His portrayal of senior officers is equally off base. There may a bozo or two like the senior officers in both the American and Chinese navies in this book but I seriously doubt it. Robinson should stick to tactics. That was interesting reading.
Is the review positive or negative? 