Negative Positive
Title: Same image quality as kit lens!!!
Review: Reading the reviews, why do you all sound like sales people? What is in it for you if I buy or not??I have been using my kit lens EF-S 18-55mm 3.5-5.6 IS on my Rebel Xsi. I was looking for a lens that would give my pictures that punch/pop sharpness even when viewed in my LCD.I decided to try an L series lens...took a bunch of tests various conditions...anylized in PS...NO DIFFERENCE IN SHARPNESS/IMAGE QUALITY! Went back to store and salesman couldn't explain.The IS in kit lens actually made it sharper when shooting handheld indoors!The L was blurry.The construction of L is certainly better, but image quality wise...the same.Is there a lens that will produce a better quality image than the kit lens?Prove it. The sample pics posted with each lens do not convince me.Is there some one else in the same situation who has found the solution?
Is the review positive or negative? 