Negative Positive
Title: OKAY LET'S GET IT STRAIGHT.
Review: The central core argument of Smith's book is that the final conclusion as to whether theism ought to be accepted as true or false, must be guided by reason, logic and rational grounds. What is Smith's conclusion? It is that the beliefs and views held by theists are illogical and irrational because the theist cannot provide adequate proof for the existence of God. Smith's overall conclusion is that the existence of God is "impossible". The rational, logical mind must agree that the existence of God is "possible". Why? Because the atheist cannot provide adequate proof of the non-existence of God. Therefore, Smith's conclusion that the existence of God is "impossible" is irrational. If the conclusions and views of the author of this book are "irrational", then the basic grounding of `Atheism: The Case Against God' is undermined.
Is the review positive or negative? 