Negative Positive
Title: Lame commentary and weak jokes don't add anything worthwhile.
Review: This Island Earth is a typical B movie of the 1950s with some truly poor dialog and the sort of effects one comes to expect from the age and budget. As such, it is a lot of fun to watch in itself.Add in a poor introduction and links, plus some lame comments and jokes that simply don't work most of the time and you get this bit of tripe. To fit the crap into a watchable length the original movie is chopped to pieces.The mob behind this should rent What's Up Tiger Lilly, or Hercules Returns to see how you can turn old 2nd or 3rd rate movies into something even funnier.I guess tbe only consulation that measures and sign of sucess in this film is that I watched it to the end to see just how crap the commentary could be. For that reason it just scrapes in with 1 star.
Is the review positive or negative? 