Negative Positive
Title: okay, for all that
Review: We keep encountering people who refer to "You're the One"'s "beautiful melodies". Well, if rap has influenced this record, it's probably influenced reviewers too. A generation has grown up eating cardboard and calling it bread. In fact, there is scarcely any melody at all on this record, beautiful, plain, or ugly. This is not a matter of opinion; it is a matter of knowing what the word "melody" means. It doesn't mean any combination of sounds that might happen to appeal to you in any way or by any means (through force of repetition, for example).
Is the review positive or negative? 