Negative Positive
Title: I agree--God help us all. There are better Trek writers.
Review: Mr. Kotani, to me, obviously knows little or nothing about Voyager, its captain, and crew. This novel is science and plot driven, but I believe that it needs a great deal more than just being a repetive action and cliff-hanger plot book. I do not wish to slam Mr. Kotani personally, but he should acquaint himself with the characters in this interesting series. Christine Golden does an excellent job as a writer and getting into Janeway's mind. I suggest that you read her book in the Voyager series. This is the first review I have written under my new nick name; I reviewed The 34th Rule just recently and I believe many readers would enjoy it. In the original series, I tend to like Uhura's Song best. Both of these books are strong in plot, characterization and values that should have us thinking about events on earth.
Is the review positive or negative? 