Negative Positive
Title: A one sided dissident's view of a complicated issue
Review: A Jansenist Roman Catholic father and a dissident uncommitted Priest-son square off for a lifetime of bitterness and recrimination. I am not sure this book should have been written. I would like to have heard the side of the father, General Joe Carroll. The author and narrator, has the self righteous attitude that turned me off.Viet Nam was a complex issue. He oversimplifies it and villifies his dad.Thumbs down for me
Is the review positive or negative? 