Negative Positive
Title: Ring-a-ling
Review: Dear Sue Monk Kidd, I have enjoyed your books, from "Dance of a Dissident Daughter" to "Secret Lives of Bees" and "When The Heart Waits" -- which is one of the best books I've ever read.But "The Mermaid Chair"? Phoned in. Honest. I was disappointed and did not find much in the book to recommend it. Even the descriptions of Gullah culture and island life -- eh. Not enough.Sue, next time, write from the heart without an eye to sales or deadlines. That's what makes your earlier works so wonderful.Sincerely,A Fan
Is the review positive or negative? 