Negative Positive
Title: some good ideas, but do they work??
Review: This book could have been easily cut in half by assuming that the reader is intelligent enough to know that the sell side is the reverse of how the buy side setups etc works. Everything gets repeated this way and it is very annoying to have to skip ahead to the next piece of valuable information. It looks like their may be some good ideas presented but everything is described in a very long winded way and it is lacking in proof. I do not recall any charts in the book presenting failure and I'd be shocked if the methods are 100%. My guess is that there is some heavy optimization going on when applying these techniques.
Is the review positive or negative? 