Negative Positive
Title: Not a classic despite its age
Review: Poorly organized and uncritical adulation of the Scotch-Irish by a Protestant Ulster native reflecting her prejudices. This is not a scholarly work as much of the information is irrelevant to the book's title and ostensible theme with numerous references to American History in general, discussion of Ulster history far beyond colonial times, and a negative assessment of 19th century Irish Catholic immigration to America.
Is the review positive or negative? 