Negative Positive
Title: Filthy, disgusting garbage
Review: Giuliano is a well-known Beatles fanatic who decided to write an extended poison pen bio. He claims to have tapes or copies of John Lennon's diaries, but can't explain why his interpretation of the diaries seem VERY different than other people who really have seen them, and he claims that his copy of the diaries were given to him by someone who probably didn't have them. This book is poorly written, seems rushed to press in time to beat _Anthology_ and doesn't offer anything more than a bunch of unsuspported and ridiculous assumptions. Giuliano, for his part, claims to be telling the truth because he "sits on a throne" and because "people worship" him, as he said in an interview in a Buffalo NY newspaper. So why would he lie? I dunno, because the combination of money, arrogance and nuttiness is a difficult combination to live honestly by maybe.
Is the review positive or negative? 