Negative Positive
Title: slanted portrayal of the state of reseach
Review: This book is rather naive and overoptimimistic with respect to the state of consciousness research today. It's not that bad of a book for its point of view, but given the title a more balanced approach would be more appropriate. To create this balance, read this book together with Horgan's book on consciousness, or if you want something even more penetrating, read any of McGinn's books on the subject.
Is the review positive or negative? 