Negative Positive
Title: Amazing Reiner
Review: Have no reservations about the Scheherazade on this disc. Reiner's recording of this with the CSO is the recording by which all others are judged; it alone is worth the price of this disc. That said, I'd recommend buying this recording of it on a different disc, because of the Russian Easter Overture. I don't like Stokowsky's interpretation. Everything about it (tempos, dynamics, etc) sounds grossly overdone, like a crude joke. And why did he have the trombone solo doubled? The excerpts from Tsar Sultan are acceptable, but nothing to write home about.
Is the review positive or negative? 