Negative Positive
Title: Does for military history what von Daniken did for space science...
Review: Many years ago, Dorthy Parker reviewed a publication by opening with "This is what you might call a gift book--you wouldn't take it under any other circumstances". I acquired this volume similarly.Mr Georg takes any number of items minor related to known existing projects and extrapolates them into major 'what-if's, implying that the Reich actually possessed function prototypes of atomic/radiological weapons. Arguably, the most absurd item he throws out is the suggestion that that the fission bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki by the USAAF were the direct outgrowth of the scientists, hardware and information captured by the US and British forces at the close of the fighting in Europe.Unless you're a serious Wermacht '46 modeler or wargamer looking for new material, I strongly recommend that you save your money.
Is the review positive or negative? 