Negative Positive
Title: Terrific collection, but the copy editor should be out of a job
Review: I absolutely loved this book and have loved its author for many years, but this edition was terribly put together. Entire passages cut off mid-page, only to pick up several pages later when the author had already moved onto a different subject. In a longer title this wouldn't have been much of a problem, but with the short pieces I felt that I was missing the entire context of the essay. There were also several noticeable typos and grammatical errors. I'm sure this wasn't Walker's doing, so whoever copyedited/proofread this book should have been fired, especially considering the difficulties most people having with finding jobs. Other than that, this collection could not come more highly reccommended.-Shane Fallon, New York, NY
Is the review positive or negative? 