Negative Positive
Title: Did I read a different book?
Review: I hate to have to disagree with the other people that have submitted reviews on this book but...I was given this book as a present by someone who knows that I enjoy reading this kind of book. But as far as I am concerned this is the worst book on the subject that I have ever read... and I have read quite a few. I'm sure that the book was given this title just so people would buy it. But when you get into it you realize that the authors are saying that retiring confortably is all but impossible. They also suggest that you should count on living a LOT longer than insurance actuarial tables would predict. Their "spread sheets" are terrible.Their conclusions suspect. As far as I am concerned the only good thing about this book is that it made me feel that if this is what passes for investment advise then I should write a book.I can certainly supply much more comprehensive spread sheets.
Is the review positive or negative? 