Negative Positive
Title: Juvenile, Trite and Gimmicky
Review: It is a sad indictment of the state of literature when a collection of what is thinly disguised as poems by an ineffectual pop chanteuse can become the highest selling in American history (two million and counting, they say.) And for the illiterates out there, it's now available as a recording, with- surprise!- little bits of the neo-folk goddess herself 'clumsily strumming her guitar.' I wonder what Emily Dickinson would think?
Is the review positive or negative? 