Negative Positive
Title: FUBAR
Review: Swofford paints himself as everymarine. If he is prototypical, God help the Corps and God help the USA. Swofford is an excellent writer, but he goes too far in his vision that all Marines are Swofford look-alikes. His views of the Corps are as skewed as Oliver Stone's view of the "average" platoon in Viet Nam. Read it for the writing talent, but take what he says about the Corps with a grain . . . no, make that a bag of salt.
Is the review positive or negative? 