Negative Positive
Title: Great songs, poor album
Review: Anybody who has ever listened to Floyd will tell you that none of the songs were ever meant to be played alone. All of their albums are really one giant song, and to take away the most popular segments of the album and put them together in a seemingly random order is just awful. "Us and Them" doesnt sound nearly as smooth and powerful when it doesnt follow "Money". The songs are fantastic, dont get me wrong, and for a newcomer to Floyd this might be a decent way to see if you like their stuff. However, I don't listen to this album anymore because I own all of Floyd's CD's up till Water's split. In short, buy the real albums, not this one.
Is the review positive or negative? 