Negative Positive
Title: Jewel's work seems shallow, childish
Review: Jewel's poetry is too like her song lyrics--somewhat childish and lacking in literary excellence. Certainly her work would never have been published without her celebrity standing; it is a well-intentioned attempt at deepness and intellectualism that falls short of either. On the other hand, poetry is as much about the reader as it is about the writer, and if Jewel's audience finds her work insightful and full of hope, then perhaps it has not gone entirely to waste.
Is the review positive or negative? 