Negative Positive
Title: It didn't need to be a book.
Review: When I finshed the book I wondered when exactly Mr.Card jumped onto the Financial Bandwagon. I've read a lot of Mr. Card's books, and none of them stank of money like this one. I think we loyal fans were suckered, and that disappoints me. While I considered Ender's Shadow a decent read, it couldn't compare to Ender's Game. Not only that, but Ender's Shadow was unnecassary. I say this because a short story could have sufficed to tell the story that Mr. Card told in this book. I suppose for someone who hasn't read Ender's Game, Ender's Shadow would be an okay read. But as an avid fan, Shadow was a dissapointment. I expected a crisp, new story since it was from a new perspective. Instead it was the same story, just chewed up and regurgitated by Bean. I guess I expected better from Mr. Card. This is the first time he's ever dissapointed me with any piece of his writing.
Is the review positive or negative? 