Negative Positive
Title: Flawed
Review: A pretentious, quasi intellectual theory that is based on no archeological excavations, no historical evidence or corroboration. All professor Salibi has, is a theory based on similarities of names of towns and regions in modern Saudi Arabia that resemble some of the names in the Arabic "translations" of the bible. There are numerous villages across the middle east that share the same names. Qana in Gallilee ( Modern Day Kfar Kana) is different from Qana in Southern Lebanon although these villages have identical names and phonetical pronunciation.By Salibi's reasoning, one could easily "reconstruct" European historical events on Modern US soil simply because numerous European city/ towns names are also present in the US.
Is the review positive or negative? 