Negative Positive
Title: NOT! CATHOLICISM
Review: This book is titled incorrectly. It should be titled Catholicism NOT! This book received a scathing review from Archbishop Daniel Pilarczyk when he was head of the US Catholic Bishop's Conference Committee on Doctrine. The major overall flaw is "doctrinal minimalism." The book presents dissenting theological opinions on such controversial issues as womens' ordination(NEVER) and homosexuality(ALWAYS EVIL) as if the faithful may choose which they prefer. The book is OBE'd. The 1998 change in Canon Law issued by the motu proprio Ad Tuendam Fidem with the attached doctrinal explanation Ab Ipsis Primordis, clarifies that the faithful must hold the magisterial position on these matters. Perhaps Encyclopedia of Heresy might be a good title.
Is the review positive or negative? 