Negative Positive
Title: not very interesting
Review: I haven't read the other two Holmes pastiches that came out this year, and I haven't even read any original Holmes, so maybe I am a bad judge, but the Holmes pastiche chapter in Zoran Zivkovic's The Fourth Circle was more interesting than this. I really enjoyed "Kavalier and Clay", but this book was dull and flat, and I did not care about any of the characters. The only thing I found to like was that one of the chapters was told from the parrot's point of view, but in the end the book just wasn't satisfying.
Is the review positive or negative? 