Negative Positive
Title: Good history, poor execution
Review: Blumetti seems to have a solid grasp of 19th century European history, and his scenario of a Napolean raised in America is imaginative. However, it appears that his manuscript WAS NOT PROOFREAD by ANYONE before being sent to the printers, with the result that the huge number of grammar mistakes, misspellings, and sentence fragments makes his book almost unreadable.
Is the review positive or negative? 