Negative Positive
Title: F. Miller writing Batman? Gotta be good, right? Hell no.
Review: Frank Miller wrote and drew The Dark Knight Returns, possibly the best Batman story ever, maybe the best comic ever. Frank Miller also wrote Batman: Year One, another masterpiece. So why does he occasionally write such generic, unoriginal garbage like this or Sin City? The plot here is like every other superhero team up story, only a bit worse. McFarlane puts out some nice pin ups, but every page is a splash page; he has no sense of pacing or expression in his work. A lot of fighting, bad dialogue, splashy art. Not worth the time it takes to look at the pictures.
Is the review positive or negative? 