Negative Positive
Title: Posner exposed as judge of questionable ethics
Review: The New York Times of Feb. 19, 2000, carries a story about a dispute between Posner and the eminent legal scholar, Ronald Dworkin, who reviewed "An Affair of State" in the New York Review of Books issue dated March 9, 2000.In my earlier review of Posner's book here I raised the question of the ethics of a highly placed United States judge making an explicit finding of guilt in what could be a pending criminal prosecution -- of Clinton for perjury after he leaves office.Dworkin agrees with this belief and documents the canons of judicial ethics which he believes, and I believe, that Posner violated.Posner should be hauled before a disciplinary committee to explain this outrage.mailto:RayJ@Juno.com
Is the review positive or negative? 