Negative Positive
Title: Confusing and judgemental
Review: Ms. Barton's book is a personal confession in many ways. While her writing is heartfelt, the reader is asked to accept as fact a number of claims in the book that seem poorly researched or contradictory. Ms. Barton presents a judgemental, negative view of what it means to surrender a child to adoption. This may be her personal view, but it does not represent the views of many other birthmothers. Not to include their "confessions" limits severely the usefulness of this book.
Is the review positive or negative? 