Negative Positive
Title: Weak because so much is not comics
Review: The weaknes of this book (and sections of Ricks Story) is not its controversial content but the fact that Sim basically rejects the comics format (which he does well) for page after page of dense badly written (though not as bad as the section in Ricks Story)prose with a single illo per page. If this dialogue was writtten and presented in a comics format it would have been hopefully stripped down ,edited and more readable . As it is it is a real slog and not really worth the effort. A real mess.
Is the review positive or negative? 