Negative Positive
Title: see the twin recension about the katakana method ( is exactly all the same)
Review: Nothing to say, provided you are an 8 years old japanese living abroad you will learn in no time kana with these two books.A must for collectionism, there is something better if you are just interestd to loearn kana in no time ( try remembering the kana by Heisig).Four star instead of five, because there are plenty of methods for learning hiragana, muich easier than katakana, as a matter of fact ( every handbook teaches you hiragana in virtually no time, letter are not so monotonous as katakana letters are).
Is the review positive or negative? 