Negative Positive
Title: I Am Shocked and Stunned
Review: No amount of pleading can convince my wife that I have to buy my entire CD collection again now that I have SACD, but one listen to "Underture", and I believe she is starting to lean my way. This all new "Tommy" is packed with audio surprises; new sounds, unbelievable clarity, and a daringly dry mix that can at times sound insular and creepy (I thought Roger Daltry was in my living room asking for Tommy. It's that clear.) Even a classic like "Pinball Wizard" reveals all new details, including an extended ending with pinball sounds. The bonus disc is revealing as well, and satisfies even those who needed "Dogs Pt. 2" in stunning surround sound. Admittedly, most of this album smacks of a cash-in on the Oasis "Guigsy" LP, but I am sure The Who will find their own voice in time. You know where to put the cork.
Is the review positive or negative? 