Negative Positive
Title: Outdated research
Review: This is a copy of an unpublished, 125-page doctoral paper which was apparently sold by a member of the author's committee. It covers the initial, 25-year-old research which eventually led to a published textbook, the second edition of which has just been published. As such, this product represents immature writing and a review of out-of-date literature.
Is the review positive or negative? 