Negative Positive
Title: Why on Green Earth do you need this when you have MotP?
Review: Manual of the Planes being in 3.0 system is not outdated like many of the 2e books (I got one of those by accident and the rules are quite hard to implement into a 3e game, don't listen to people whining about how good they were), and it is easy to find. The planar abilities are easy to understand, and quite clever. Plus, they even have decent prestige classes. The only thing different is the Planar Touchstones, which from the judgements elsewhere, the 33 pages could be put in by 3.0 rules in 10 pages or less more effectively.
Is the review positive or negative? 