Negative Positive
Title: Nothing New Here
Review: This volume takes the traditional "Battlecruisers were a flawed concept" the author puts forward Nothing new, and outrightly contradicts the author of the the companion Volume (British Battlecruisers 1914-18) It is a pity that the authors on these two volumes did not collaborate to provide a consistent theme to this story. Of the two I would recommend the companion volumne rather than this one because of the difference in view - This volume adds nothing new to the subject
Is the review positive or negative? 