Negative Positive
Title: One or Two Positive Notes
Review: I can't disagree with what the reviewers before me wrote, but I have to say the disc isn't entirely bad. The interviews with Joe Boyd and Norman Smith appeared to be exclusive to this production and I found them pretty enlightening.Smith didn't appear to have had any idea what to do with Pink Floyd at all, did he? He sneeringly refers to their music as "that psychedelic stuff," if I recall correctly.It's tantalizing to wonder what the album would have sounded like with the infintely more sympathetic Boyd at the helm.I also hadn't seen the footage of Gilmour singing Syd's material before. Shame it was just a clip.Otherwise, this is a pretty cheap, cruddy production.
Is the review positive or negative? 