Negative Positive
Title: I disagree with Publisher's Weekly
Review: I'm not sure what they were thinking, but it appears to me that they forgot what the intended audience is for the book--kids! Kids use cliches, fuss and fume over teasing, and happen to like the kind of humor that's in this book. Already I have seen it at schools' book fairs, and many of the librarians in my particular school district have already picked it up. It has grown quite popular among the kids I know, especially in my household. I thought you might like to hear an opposing viewpoint to PW's review, but of course the best way to formulate an opinion is to read it yourself (there's material in there for adults, too).
Is the review positive or negative? 