Negative Positive
Title: Shantung black tiger
Review: This book goes over techniques that are in the form (kata). There's a decent amount of detail in the techniques but a few of those techniques are completely unrealistic and useless ("the lock turning action"). If you want to learn a form, go for it. Also it has different self defense application to be used against different assaults. Finally, they never even talk about any kind of "tiger claw" strike!! If you aren't interested in a form don't get it.
Is the review positive or negative? 