Negative Positive
Title: Surprised to see so many other high reviews
Review: I was shocked to see so many high reviews about this film. For a film it's good, but for a screen adaptation of a book, it fell utterly short. If I had never read the books, I would have thought it just another Dungeons and Dragons film.My only advice to people is this: if you've read the books, don't see the movie. If you've only seen the movie, don't read the books. Peter Jackson missed the point of the books. Why else would he have made so many changes to the plots. He changed the character's personalities, motives, actions, etc.... I dare not list all my complaints here, save I may offend some people who enjoyed or may enjoy the film.
Is the review positive or negative? 