Negative Positive
Title: A great "Polish"!
Review: It's the first mov't here that is really special. Going from PIT's somewhat goofy intro, IMHO, to the songful main section of I, Slatkin gives it his all, as does his orchestra. They really sing those melodies. Beside him, Karajan (DG/Berlin) seems clueless. Markevitch is fine, but he and the LSO don't know how to sing in I.To be continued!
Is the review positive or negative? 