Negative Positive
Title: Look elsewhere
Review: Sloppy scholarship, ridiculous commentary. There are far better editions of Heraclitus's fragments available from Marcovich. The standard scholarly edition is now (and will be for many years to come) the multi-volume edition from Serge Mouraviev.Kahn uses (and abuses) Marcovich's edition of the fragments in this volume. Marcovich handed Kahn his hat in a lengthy and detailed review in Gnomon (54. Bd., H. 5, 1982). The positive reviewers do not know what they are talking about. This is not a serious work.
Is the review positive or negative? 