Negative Positive
Title: Beautiful writing but not well researched
Review: This book was a page turner. I enjoyed it very much. I love first person narritve because it brings me right into the story and makes the experience more intimate. This book was moving and thought provoking.The only issue I have to agree upon with the negative reviewers is that the scientific aspects of the story are very poorly researched. It is hard to ignore and that is why I didn't give 5 stars.As far as the fact that the clones accepted their fate without a fight is another problem negative reviewers pointed out. I thought that was the whole point and warning of the story. These people were raised to know what there fate was. They had no other experience. There was now big surprise or shock at the end other than the fact that there gaurdians were trying to protect them and show there humanity and failed.Otherwise I found the story beautiful and I couldn't put it down. I think it took me only 4 days to read. Enjoy.
Is the review positive or negative? 