Negative Positive
Title: Out of her league
Review: This is a very young singer way outside the element of proper repertoire. She clearly has her head in the clouds with the type of repertoire she should be doing. What you want to sing and what you are able to sing properly are things you should consider. Can you imagine this young singer trying to grow in the next 5 years and have to look back at this dreadful recording as a highlight of her resume or career. This is American Idol for the art song and aria world and she is William Hung. While she does have a dream to sing, she needs much better coaching and a teacher who does not encourage a student to move too fast... this recording is on her career forever. Poor kid... and shame on the record company and the teacher who makes her believe that she is ready for something like this.
Is the review positive or negative? 