Negative Positive
Title: Beckwith's Authorial Comment Aristotelian
Review: I must protest at Francis Beckwith's use of the slavery analogy to corroborate his anti-abortion position.I would suggest that he rereads Dred Scott v Sanford (1854)as that case is specifically about the citizenship of slaves, not their biological personhood. Unfortunately, this is a typical example of Aristotelian analogical reasoning that relies on resemblances and similarities based on surface attributes that fall apart on closer investigation...
Is the review positive or negative? 