Negative Positive
Title: smudges galore
Review: I bought this cookbook to give my mom for Christmas, as we'd both watched "Julie & Julia" multiple times and loved it. As a full time college student working part time for minimum wage, it was a bit of a splurge for me. Unfortunately, the copy I received has dirt-colored smudges all over the front of the paper jacket. It's really disappointing, as I don't have time to return it and get a new one (and what if the new one was dirty as well?), so I'm going to have to give my mom a besmudged cookbook for Christmas. I'm really frustrated by this.
Is the review positive or negative? 