Negative Positive
Title: Revisionism cloaked as History for Children
Review: Milton Meltzer is clearly out to rewrite history. He's eager to point out every petty flaw of King David and Charlemagne, but makes the bloodthirsty Atahualpa and Kublai Khan look like modern egalitarian leaders. Capitalism and self-determination are clearly bad things, but totalitarianism and forced labor come off as benign. Hammurabi is described as a "benign despot", and we are told that slaves in ancient Babylonia were not treated as harshly as "slaves in the Americas".I'm not sure what Meltzer is trying to accomplish, but make sure you read this with your child with open and questioning eyes.
Is the review positive or negative? 