Negative Positive
Title: Not really worth the money
Review: Other than Clay Aiken's "The First Noel," which is a beautiful version of a rather repetitive carol, this CD doesn't really contain anything exceptional. And actually, Clay should have been given "O Holy Night" instead of Kelly Clarkson, whose rendition doesn't quite make the mark. She's all right as a singer, but her slurring style doesn't suit for such an exquisite song. Justin Guarini sounds very good on here, and Ruben is Ruben. Kim Locke's version of The Christmas Song is adequate, but Christina Christian's participation on this CD is a mystery -- why exactly is she on here?All in all, this could have been a much better album if the songs had been assigned to the right singers, and if certain singers had been left off entirely. Kind of a disappointment for this AI fan.
Is the review positive or negative? 