Negative Positive
Title: Where was her editor?
Review: I too have nothing to say that hasn't been said before, I am hoping that Ms. Gabaldon will tune into these reviews and get the point that even the truest of fans can become tired of the same old thing. This book was so boring that I went out and bought the audio book just so I could finish it (I find listening sometimes easier than reading). I am not sure how she made Claire and Jamie so uninteresting - but she did. Ms. Gabaldon, please make the next book half as long as The Fiery Cross and re-read your first book and give us fans what we know and love.
Is the review positive or negative? 