Negative Positive
Title: An amatuer production & not a compelling story at that :-(
Review: I saw this recently and was really let down -- the production values are below-par, considering the rep and knowledge of some of the people involved.... it's terribly shot and the re-enactors don't look good at all, not convincing. The story is somewhat interesting, but why make a short film about this? Why should we care? I can think of hundreds of much more compelling stories to tell which would be even more dramatic for film... A lost opportunity to do a good Civil War set short... much ado about nothing :-(Why can't someone talented do a Civil War movie, why do they all have to be so poorly executed!
Is the review positive or negative? 