Negative Positive
Title: Reprints eight out of date books by Reinfeld.
Review: These eight books from the fifties are full of weak tactical analysis that is inexcusable in today's age of readily available computer chess programs. Furthermore, the book wasn't even updated to algebraic notation. Reinfeld only managed to be one of the most prolific chess authors at the expense of quality and depth. Your money would be better spent on a higher quality (and cheaper!) book by Chernev or Pandolfini. Reinfeld's coverage of the openings is not complete either, as the title would suggest. It isn't even very insightful. Fine's 'Ideas Behind the Chess Openings' would be a better (and again, cheaper) alternative.
Is the review positive or negative? 