Negative Positive
Title: Doesn't hold up
Review: This toy lasted about 20 seconds before my lab mix ripped off one of its legs/feet. Our puppy still liked to play with it, so we kept it around. We tried to keep it out of the big dog's reach, though, since we knew that it wouldn't last long otherwise. After turning my back for about 3 minutes, our big dog had found the toy and swallowed part of one of the feet = stress! I definitely believe in supervised play, but this toy requires total focus to prevent it from becoming a hazard for any dog capable of chewing off pretty poorly attached limbs. If your dog is very gentle, however, I guess this would be a good toy for you.
Is the review positive or negative? 