Negative Positive
Title: Unreliable...
Review: When I saw in the introduction that Acharya gave credence to the idea that Hitler had a Jewish grandmother, treating it as a serious proposition though long rejected by mainstream historians, I feared that she would be making wild claims about other sources as well.I was right.To her, everything that might tend to support Christian historical claims is a forgery, and every third and fourth rate source is reliable material. (She levels the "forgery" charge frequently without supporting documentation...and such documentation as there is consists of mostly secondary sources.)Her style is turgid and convuluted, so I can't even say the writing is entertaining.If this book is meant to be a genuine scholarly investigation into Christian claims, it is useless. As a joke, it is more useful.Gimme a break.
Is the review positive or negative? 