Negative Positive
Title: Just Plain Speculation at Best
Review: Arm-chair speculation parading as science. Dr. Socarides' "theories" are not falsifiable. A "theory" that cannot be tested is not a theory at all, just a collection of musings, or in this case, biases. Methinks the Dr. protest too much, if you want to get all psychoanalytic about it.
Is the review positive or negative? 