Negative Positive
Title: Both Georges are no doubt spinning in their graves.
Review: This by far the worst book I have ever read. I finished it only because I was looking for the punch line. There wasn't one, and I've never so regretted time wasted. Since I've never read a Turtledove, I'm not sure who to blame here. I suppose I can blame both: A good writer would have made an attempt to fix the book, halt it's release, or take his name off the front cover. The action is clunky, the prose is stilted, the dialogue is unnatural and cliche, and the premise is as uninteresting as it is unimportant.
Is the review positive or negative? 