Negative Positive
Title: Read it to satisfy a Star Wars need only
Review: The idea that the new Republic needs outside help defeting a small ramshackle fleet because they moth-balled a substantial part of their fleet 14 years after winning a major battle against a galactic empire is absurd. Particularly when the Black Fleet Crisis trilogy demonstrates how strong the New Republic Navy had become only 2 years previous to this trilogy.This book is inconsistent with the other Star Wars novels in many ways and rates a zero on the feasability scale.It is worth reading only if you have read all the other Star Wars novels.
Is the review positive or negative? 