Negative Positive
Title: good book, nice layout, but oh the errors!
Review: I'm referring to the McKay algebraic paperback edition here. I like the book a lot, it has some real nice games, some nice annotations, and the games are organized by theme and illustrate the concepts greatly.In fact, i might give the book 3/5 or 4/5 if it were not for the errors. There is atleast one error in every game i've looked at. I don't know if the errors exist in the original or if the problem was the conversion to algebraic, but it's really a problem.You've almost got to get the games from the internet just to follow the book, since the score in the book is so full of errors. Based on the errors I see, I suspect it's a matter of conversion to algebraic, and the problems probably do not exist in the descriptive edition, but that's just a guess. Almost makes me want to get the descriptive edition and find out...but not quite.
Is the review positive or negative? 