Negative Positive
Title: No.
Review: Ross presents his Just Right universe as an amazing coincidence, but relationships among his listed parameters are not considered. His probability description of their existence together as infinitesimally small doesn't allow for increased chance of occurrence from cause and effect. For example, a "just right" level of tectonic plate activity contributes to and increases the odds of a "just right" level of soil mineralization. Physical world aspects are not separate. Probability calculation is tricky. Ross' idea misleads, but his book is thought provoking and provides some useful information.
Is the review positive or negative? 