Negative Positive
Title: Appalling
Review: As with the rest of the Brian Herbert/Kevin J Anderson Dune books, this is a clumsy, bungling attempt to continue Frank Herbert's mighty example. The quality of writing is at times so poor as to bring tears to the eyes of any fan of the original Dune novels. Were it not for the weight of his father's reputation, Brian Herbert would surely have been laughed from the world of professioanl literature years ago.
Is the review positive or negative? 