Negative Positive
Title: Best for its college setting
Review: This is one of the first real-world-setting fantasies I read. I was not familiar with the Tam Lin story at the time I read it. While I kept turning the pages, I thought it was just a tiny bit flat -- almost too pat, that is -- but what I enjoyed the most was the evocative flavor of the liberal arts college setting.Some of the drama majors/male characters seemed a bit "over the top", though, in my opinion. The Janet character seemed to come alive in a way the others didn't.
Is the review positive or negative? 