Negative Positive
Title: a very limited study
Review: Too many writers (and genres!) are overlooked in this ideologically-blinkered study.She ignores both poetry and Sephardic literature, especially Jewish writers of the Islamic world, and generally discredits writers whose sympathy for deterritorialization or universal justice exceeds the parameters Wisse establishes for Jewish particularity. A very "tribalist" approach to identity overall, which inevitably overlooks the subversive vigor of modern Jewish literature in important contexts.
Is the review positive or negative? 