Negative Positive
Title: Inspired my daughter to read
Review: While some of the reviews from adults here are critcal about the simplistic, predictable plot with unrealistic elements, these adults should remember that the intended audience for this book is not adult, critical thinkers, but rather 9-12 year old girls. Emily's emotions are highly relatable to this age group. Her issues with self-confidence and difficulties with friendships are something many girls this age range experience. Her adventures are exciting for little girls. My 11 year old dislikes reading, but once she started this book, not only could she not put it down, but she also asked me to buy her the rest of the series, which she read with great enthusiasm. Adults, this is fantasy written for little girls. If it gets them interested in reading, isn't that enough? I hope Ms. Kessler writes more Emily Windsnap books for my daughter and other little ladies to enjoy.
Is the review positive or negative? 