Negative Positive
Title: Talent, intelligence and depraved polemic
Review: Judt is an enormously talented and intelligent historian. He has a great capacity for work , and his work on Post-War Europe is remarkable in scope. At the same time he is a two- bit ideologue whose anti- Americanism and anti-Zionism put him in the Noam Chomsky camp. His immoral attacks on Israel are part of his general misperception of the general world situation, and minimizing of the radical- Islamic threat to the West.He is an outstanding example of the truth that tremendous intelligence does not guarantee basic decency.
Is the review positive or negative? 