Negative Positive
Title: Some unbelievable talent... some unbelivably horrible songs
Review: This is not a CD I would play on Christmas Eve...but it is an excellent CD for when I do my homework...some of the songs are very weak, but Clay's the First Noel is fantastic. Kelly's songs are the best...Oh Holy Night gave me chills even on the 100th time I listened to it. I was a little skeptical about My Grownup Christmas List, because I adore Amy Grant's original version... and I hate to say it, but I think Kelly's version is better. When I listen to this CD, I listen to the first and last songs, and skip through the middle... this CD wouldn't be worthwhile if not for Clay and Kelly. I am a huge fan of Kimberly Locke, but she did not prove herself on this CD... I was very dissapointed. Overall some incredible songs carry the rest of the CD.
Is the review positive or negative? 