Negative Positive
Title: Carly as Neil Sedaka
Review: As both a fan of Carly Simon's prior work and a fan of musical standards, I was struck by how enervated and bland this entire disc is. The arrangements lack imagination and Carly's renditions are no better than an amateur's, sung in keys that make her sound dark and like a man. There are a fair number of women that sing in lower registers who manage to sound feminine~This is a let down for someone expecting quality.
Is the review positive or negative? 