Negative Positive
Title: fundamentally flawed
Review: For a through examination of the essential phenomena attempted to be explained in this book, read Not by Chance, by Massachusetts Institute of Technology doctorate Lee M. Spetner. By his exhaustive knowledge of Information Theory he fundamentally erodes the foundation of the premise of Dawkins's efforts, as well as the core "mechanics" of all mechanistic evolution. Data at the genetic information level cannot and does not arise out of nothing; the mechanism of random mutation, directed by Natural Selection, is fully inadequate as a machine for the generation of this information. Dawkins has still failed to provide a legitimate functional source theory for the origin of it.Unless someone in the near future can produce a scientifically viable source and mechanism for the origin and generation of this information, the grand sweep of evolution will be left swept into the recycling bin of the developing fields of modern science.
Is the review positive or negative? 