Negative Positive
Title: READ LE GUIN INSTEAD
Review: If you want to read about an all-female expedition to Antarctica, read Ursula LeGuin's short story, "Sur" -- it's amazing, and much better than this. I'm a huge fan of Elizabeth Arthur's first novel, "Beyond the Mountain" (about a woman climber), so I tried to read this -- but found it too dense and boring, especially compared to her lyrical "Beyond the Moutnain." Again -- Read LeGuin's story instead.
Is the review positive or negative? 