Negative Positive
Title: Analysis by academic or attempt to cash in?
Review: I received the book as a Christmas gift from someone who knows I appreciate the singing talent of Clay Aiken, among others. I'm sorry to find out they spent $18.99 plus shipping for something of this poor quality. I can't determine whether the author is attempting to analyze how the internet now impacts celebrity fandoms or if she's just trying to cash in on Aiken's popularity. If it's an academic analysis it's sloppy and jumbled. If it's an attempt to make money off a celebrity's name value it's more successful. I won't even go into the quality of the photographs. If this were really an academic analysis the photos are not necessary.
Is the review positive or negative? 