Negative Positive
Title: Doesn't Deliver the Goods
Review: This book does not deliver the goods promised in the title. It turns out that one of Glynn's pieces of "evidence" is nothing more than the anthropic principle which notes that we live in a very unlikely Universe. Change any one of several fundamental constants of physics, and the Universe could no longer support life. However this reasoning is akin to the winner of a lotto ticket noting that if any of his numbers changed, he'd not be a winner. Hence God must have been behind his winning. Even if you grant the supernatural, the anthropic principle cannot be used to claim that we humans are the intended purpose of the entire creation. This isn't evidence at all. Carl Sagan, tongue in cheek, formulated a "lithic" principle because rocks could assume that the entire creation was intended for them.
Is the review positive or negative? 