Negative Positive
Title: All Prose - No Plot
Review: What a disappointment! I loved the first 4 books in this series so much, I've read them all at least 3 times and will eventually read them again just for fun. The excitement, adventure and plot twists were topped only by the detailed historical data. While The Fiery Cross had plenty of historical data (although this book seemed to be really hung up on how things smell), it offered absolutely nothing in the form of excitement and adventure, or even plot for that matter. Diana is a wonderful writer, but her talents were completely wasted on this novel. Perhaps it's time to put Jamie and Claire to rest.
Is the review positive or negative? 