Negative Positive
Title: A subpar Blu-ray transfer
Review: I agree with the reviewers who say this transfer is no better than a standard DVD. I purchased this disc because the 1080p trailer available on the PS3 online store looked interesting and was very sharp. The transfer on this disc is inferior to the downloadable PS3 trailer. I disagree with the other reviewer who stated that the transfer was sharp and who disparages the negative reviewers for having inferior tv's.I have a 67" DLP 1080p television that is ISF calibrated. The other blu-rays discs I've watched (Underworld Evolution, Devil Wears Prada; even the single-layer Talledega Nights freebie that came with the PS3 - which has a worse transfer than the retail double-layer unrated version) exhibited much better sharpness and clarity. The transfer on this disc is closer to a good upscaled standard DVD than a good Blu-ray or HD-DVD (which I also own).I give this movie a one-star because its the transfer is not worth the premium paid over the standard DVD version of the movie.
Is the review positive or negative? 