Negative Positive
Title: Very good until near the end
Review: There are many strong aspects of this book. Herbert continues to develop the plot and characters as only he can. This has everything that fans love about the first two books. While I consider myself a generous reader (by that I mean that I'm willing to give authors the benefit of the doubt), there is a plot twist near the end that is a stretch in my opinion. Yes, I've read the whole series and I understand the Golden Path and why this plot twist occurs (I'm being careful not to give anything away here if you haven't read it), it is just too far-fetched for me. That being said, it is an enjoyable read that should satisfy most Dune fans.
Is the review positive or negative? 