Negative Positive
Title: This is a wretched book!
Review: Travel commentaries are great, usually, and this one was a great idea as he started out to honor his grandfathers who fought in WWI. However, instead of honoring history he ended up maligning his grandfather's generation. This is no history! This is just uncontrollable anger. I have never in my life found one who doesn't have a good word for Sergeant Alvin York but O'Shea can't find even one. But ... soldiers have fought and died for centuries so that O'Shea can write whatever he wants.I, for one, don't even want his book on my shelf. If anybody wants my copy, let me know.
Is the review positive or negative? 