Negative Positive
Title: The part where it breaks down...
Review: I love the thought experiment and my thoughts are much provoked by the ideas. The author is definitely on to something. However, the conclusion failed to convince me that his hypothetical robot would see itself as "I" and understand that it was a thing apart from other things and have goals and desires of its own that were not programmed into it.Ultimately I think it is very much worth reading but my response is "there are more things under heaven and Earth than are contained in your philosophy, Horatio"
Is the review positive or negative? 