Negative Positive
Title: why so Scottish?
Review: I've never understood the obsession with the Scots in Pickax County. It's almost as though they're trying to out-Scot the Scots. This book has a big Highland gathering.The Scottish themes are too twee and there are too many mistakes. For example in one book Qwillan told someone how to pronounce skean dhu and got it completely wrong. This rang very false for a character who makes such an issue of being part Scottish. What's the Scottish rebellion she keeps referring to in this book? Could it be the Jacobite Rebellion? There were Scots and English on both sides and I've never heard it referred to as anything over than the Jacobite rebellion or the '45. Is there a different name in America?
Is the review positive or negative? 