Negative Positive
Title: Disappointing
Review: I purchased this book for my 11 yr.old daughter as she had absolutely loved a book that had come out a year or so before called "The Wreck of the Ethie". It was about a shipwreck & a Newfoundland dog. Unfortunately, "Star in the Storm" is adequate, but I think written too much to "formula". My daughter kept putting it up & down, never finishing it. SHe said it was ok but not that great. She said she also liked "Hugger to the Rescue" better.(Another NF dog story)
Is the review positive or negative? 