Negative Positive
Title: What I loved - he's such a loser and doesn't realize it!
Review: Depp's character doesn't get much right - from the first scene with the sinking boat that would have been a problem for anyone else (yeah, I meant to do that!) to losing the Pearl and getting caught over and over. But he is so confident and charming and insane that he won't get that he's screwed up - and the beauty is that WE don't quite catch it either. As someone else said, in anyone else's hands Sparrow would be a cartoon. Depp's characterization was brilliant.It's not high art, but if you like Depp at all, it's a lot of fun.
Is the review positive or negative? 