Negative Positive
Title: Where is the plot??
Review: The cover was pretty, Tam Lin is one of my favorite legends, and the description on the back sounded appealing. As a girl (on her dad's account) who loves fantasy in all its forms, this looked like a pretty good book. How wrong I was...Halfway through the book I had no idea where the plot (or lack thereof) was going, the characters were flat and unreal, the prose was boring, and there was almost no mention of anything fantasy-related other than the story of the ghost girl, and that was just an old story told among the dorm tenants...Tithe and War of the Oaks were infinitely better retellings of Tam Lin.
Is the review positive or negative? 