Negative Positive
Title: Premises OK, abominable reasoning, interminable, no result.
Review: Reading this book was a mind-altering experience. I had thought a book"not worth the paper it's printed on" was a myth,like Santa Claus or God.Devlin starts with a blatantly bogus argument about the"Monty Hall problem", and follows with examples inwhich prepositional logic applied to incompletelyspecified problems can produce irrational conclusions.Do you really need to read that stuff?The second half of the book contains interminablemeandering explanations with fewer obvious errors.If any conclusion could be deduced, I missed it.Buy Alan Guth's book instead.
Is the review positive or negative? 