Negative Positive
Title: Would Have Been a 5-Star, But . . .
Review: The piece itself was beautiful, nicely weighted, and durable, except for the glass water-catcher, which had shattered during delivery. It was shipped with absolutely no packing material, so I would have been shocked if it had survived the trip. I'm not one to spend time on returns, so I'll just chalk another one up and slip it in the good-will box.
Is the review positive or negative? 