Negative Positive
Title: Embarrassing
Review: This was used as a college textbook in my class, and to be blunt, I and several other classmates were shocked at the poor quality.Spelling mistakes, poor grammar, etc. abound. If ever a book needed a good editor, this is the one!It escapes with 2 stars instead of 1 because the patient reader and beginner Library Science student may be able to glean some helpful advice from the text. At the very least, it seems the late William A. Katz knew a thing or two about the subject of reference work. I have to believe there are MANY better resources on this subject however. If not, then someone needs to start writing, there's money to be made!(Review edited for spelling)
Is the review positive or negative? 