Negative Positive
Title: Great theory but waaaay too long
Review: I've met Arthur Herman before and he's a great guy but so I mean this in the nicest way. It put me to sleep.His theory is a bold and very engaging one, McCarthy was right! I agree with this theory and read his book hoping page after page to get to the good stuff. But it never came. Instead he wastes hundreds of pages on tangent issuses and a rehash of what we already know about McCarthy.He does have some great dacts about how poor McCarthy has been distorted by the media, but these facts are few and fleeting.If you hope to get a different view of McCarthy you will be disapointed.
Is the review positive or negative? 