Negative Positive
Title: Good opera, terrible voices.
Review: The earlier recording of this opera was sung passably (barely) and had little personality.This recording has much more personality and far worse voices. The edition used certainly doesn't follow my piano vocal score, and they are both listed as "Pavel Lamm Edition." (The earlier recording altered things, too.)I have already given this recording to a library. I realized I couldn't stand to listen to it beyond the first time. The production value of sound alone gives it 2 stars, but nothing much else preserves this as a memorable recording.
Is the review positive or negative? 