Negative Positive
Title: this is lightweight journalism
Review: Light on content, light on analysis, medium-to-light on characterization, all in all it reads like a not-very-good magazine article, inflated to book length. If it were fiction it would be without worth. As non-fiction there's an occasional thrill, but it should tell more than it does (I wanted to know more about the storm!) And as journalism the author fails to connect solidly with the story.
Is the review positive or negative? 