Negative Positive
Title: very poorly researched
Review: Don't be fooled- with lots of references and graphs it looks well-researched. It is not. I have checked references and they are cited incorrectly and do not back up the author's claims. Many are not current and the author cherry-picks the ones that appear to back up his point of view. The graphs are flashy but misleading. Just remember anyone can write a book- it does not make it true.
Is the review positive or negative? 