Negative Positive
Title: Another welcome addition to the Cat Who... collection.
Review: I want to commend the author for another wonderful book. I am 15 years old, and these are the only books that I will read over and over. As to the subject of the repetition of the facts on Qwill and the cats, I think that this is necessary for the author to do, because if this is the first book that a person reads out of this series, they will obviously be inquisitive about thet details of the characters. I understand that this wasn't as thought provoking as the other 21 Cat Who... books I own, but sometimes it is better to establish things in one book that will carry over to other stories. (i.e.-Amanda Goodwinter vs. Gregory Blythe) Congratulations, Lilian Jackson Braun, and kudos to the kitties for another job well done!
Is the review positive or negative? 