Negative Positive
Title: Michiko Kakutani is right (as always)
Review: Even though he hasn't published a book in seven years, Cormac McCarthy himself said this novel took him six months to write. It shows. The book is way thin. Maybe it started as one of his screenplays. Anyone who's read The Stonemason knows that McCarthy should not write plays or screenplays. Like Don DeLillo, he's not good at it. This book is McCarthy's Vineland. Hopefully his next novel won't be as lame as Mason & Dixon.P.S. Please nominate Judge Holden to the Supreme Court. Thanx.
Is the review positive or negative? 