Negative Positive
Title: Would help if authors updated their work
Review: Many of the authors' examples are a decade or so old. The theory and implications in the light of new findings have not been updated in over a decade. Tie into this a lack-lustre style and you have a book you can safely leave out of consideration -- except it seems in Knoxville, TN, where the authors teach (and the students buy?)
Is the review positive or negative? 