Negative Positive
Title: Based on what book?!!
Review: From the rave reviews of most of the reviewers, it would seem that noone has read the book upon which this film is approximately based. The book was simply used as a point of departure for an all too predictable Hollywood rewrite. It is pathetic when real lives are reduced to plot devices, expedients and screen writing liberties. These men deserved better treatment than this. Try reading the book - skip this farce of a film.
Is the review positive or negative? 