Negative Positive
Title: Made up story
Review: Not only is this book not written in the right order but also not a true story. This lady has newer been in any concentration camp. Even her brother Piet(not his real name)denied ever have been in a concentration camp. Cato's neighborhood has newer been bombed for hour and hours or any other places in Amsterdam. Amsterdam has no sewers you can walk in, as is written on page 85 in this book. Also on the same page it says, Jews were forced in a ghetto with a high brick wall aroud it. Not true, I am Jewish, I lived in Amsterdam at that time, my Grand Father and Aunt and Uncle's lived there with there Family's and non of uf had a wall around us. The hunger winter was in 1944-1945, the American Air Force dropped food just out side Amsterdam on May 6th 1945. The execution on page 103 dit take place on March 1945, not in 1943. How did Cato could have seen the execution and seen the food drop if she was in Dora concentration camp? Dont believe this story, do some investigation. (...)
Is the review positive or negative? 