Negative Positive
Title: not much of a guide
Review: If you are looking for a GUIDE for the Heidelberg Catechism, this is NOT the book to buy. You should go with the commentary by Ursinus who is one of the authors of the catechsim. The Ursinus book, however, comes with a bit of warning: it is very very comprehensive and difficult to read. The chapter on sin alone exceeds 10 pages (font 7ish).In the student guild by G.I. Williamson, the author often rambles on and on to make a rather insignificant point. Just borrow the book from a pastor if you wish to skim through the catechism.
Is the review positive or negative? 