Negative Positive
Title: After reading Genshiken...
Review: To be fair, I've only read this volume and the Comic Party spinoff books, but, after watching the first episode of the anime, I looked forward to reading this series. However, the idiosyncratic otaku characters of Genshiken make the formulaic characters of Comic Party just that much more obvious and hollow. If you've enjoyed the previous manga volumes, I'm sure this last book will be just as much of a pleasure. But if your manga dollars are limited, I'd suggest the slightly higher-priced Genshiken.
Is the review positive or negative? 