Negative Positive
Title: A Jesuit's narrow introduction to a narrow bibliography
Review: As a passionate supporter of liberal education, I looked forward to receiving this book with relish to give to my youngest who--while at a highly rated university--I realize still doesn't have a clue about artes liberales. So I must say I was crestfallen to discover this guide was so limited and disappointing, with such a sectarian and limited bibliography, authors, however good in themselves, so much of one "camp" that it is travesty to hold it up as a good selection of the best books out there as guides to "liberal learning".Further, Amazon does its users no service not to make the author's status as a priest and affiliation with the Society of Jesus more evident. This book should have been title "A Roman Catholic Student's Guide to Liberal Learning".
Is the review positive or negative? 