Negative Positive
Title: As stuffy as a film book can be.
Review: Halliwell's Film Guide has some wonderful stuff in it, some great ideas (the sampling of reviews from other critics, for example). But the book is incredibly stuffy and does not give respect to horror films (Evil Dead, Braindead) or the films of David Lynch. A much less stuffy and more fun film guide is Videohound's Golden Movie Retriever.
Is the review positive or negative? 