Negative Positive
Title: A work whose excellence shames the character of the author.
Review: For all of his literary and academic accomplishment, A. Bartlett Giamatti did not outlive the incontestable fact the the one thing, the only thing, he did with his office as Commissioner of Baseball was to singlemindedly drive Pete Rose from Major League Baseball. For all the broken hearts and green fields, he should have included the dark, greasy underside of shabby power politics and the smug, heartless, endless free ride that went with his tenure.
Is the review positive or negative? 