Negative Positive
Title: Full of interesting possibilities
Review: I wouldn't recommend this work as a reference for scholars, but perhaps as a reference for poets and other writers. While etymological 'connections' are often used to make sweeping claims that don't stand up to even light scrutiny, this sort of thing can be fun, if not inspiring, where not taken too seriously. I don't think the author's substantial effort was wasted at all.
Is the review positive or negative? 