Negative Positive
Title: Promising, but some serious problems for beginners
Review: This book has some good moments, but for beginners to real options it assumes too much knowledge. The writing style is inconsistent (e.g. you can definitely tell that two authors wrote it) and the examples are not presented in a user-friendly step-by-step fashion. Many of the examples (for example, I'm trying to follow their instructions to create an option valuation spreadsheet) have errors in them.
Is the review positive or negative? 