Negative Positive
Title: Philosophy of science???
Review: Machan needs to touch up on the assumptions that are made by ALL scientists. What science decides is its subject matter must be orderly and deterministic. This is crucial for all sciences. For Machan to claim that Skinner's work is not science because it is deterministic is fundamentally wrong, and I suggest he consider at least the past few hundred years of science before he sets out on writing another book.
Is the review positive or negative? 