Negative Positive
Title: Not a true representation
Review: I feel this book does not fully represent the entire Clay Fandom. Clay's fanbase is very diverse and people became fans for many different reasons, not necessarily those mentioned in the book. I do not agree with the way in which this book was written, i.e. the presentation of Ms. Piper's opinions as fact. I further think that insinuating that the fans are who made him a star is an insult to Clay and his talent. Sure, if he didn't have any fans there would be no stardom, but if he wasn't great on his own, there would be nothing to attract people to be his fans.My true rating of this book is ZERO stars, actually. But Amazon forces us to rate it at least one star. Piper should consider herself fortunate to rate the one star.
Is the review positive or negative? 