Negative Positive
Title: nice philosophy, poor supportive arguments
Review: Really disappointing book. This book would never persuade me to try voluntary simplicity (luckily I already came to it from other sources). Even though I wholeheartedly agree with many of Andrews' points, the book offers little support for her sweeping generalizations. Does she really believe that the clinically depressed could snap out of it by shopping at locally owned boutiques instead of the faceless mall? The entire book seems unfinished, full of author's notes and opinions but with few facts or well-constructed arguments. Where was her editor?
Is the review positive or negative? 