Negative Positive
Title: So?
Review: Well, this is definitely good storytelling, but why isn't anything happening? I've just finished the book, and I feel rather cheated. This is filler material - here's how life is in the Colonial America, down to the most excruciating detail. I guess I could have read farmer's almanac if I really wanted to know. But 400 pages devoted to one day? Marcel Proust did it, and IMHO, D. Gabaldon is not Proust. Read it if you're a hard core fan, but wait for the final book if you value your time.
Is the review positive or negative? 