Negative Positive
Title: Fanciful but fallacious ideas
Review: Professor Condit has written an inventive book, but it does not do justice to modern literary criticism. Its creativity is not faithful to Chaucer or to what we have learned about his life and his world in recent decades. Professor Condit often seems to have let his imagination get the better of him, at the expense of accurate and thorough historical and literary exposition.
Is the review positive or negative? 