Negative Positive
Title: you should have voted the Pigeon Finds a Hot Dog
Review: We had group of three people for voting for the best picture book. We didn't think that the Kitten's Full Moon should have won. We thought that the Pigeon Finds a Hot Dog should have won the Caldecott Award in 2005.We thought that the Pigeon Finds a Hot Dog should have won because it was funny, has great pictures and it is also easy to read. That is why I disagree with the Caldecott Committee in 2005.by: Ryan S. and Michael S.
Is the review positive or negative? 