Negative Positive
Title: First read the novella
Review: The novel is powerful and moving, but not perfect. This is because it does not have half the impact of the original novella by the same name first published in Analogue. The novella is perhaps the best piece of fiction I have ever read, and I have read about two thousand science fiction books. Also, if you like Orson Scott Card, you might try to find something from Cordwainer Smith.
Is the review positive or negative? 