Negative Positive
Title: Not perfect, but great information
Review: This cruising guide has hand-drawn charts and pretty rough navigation instructions, but you won't find that a problem. Because of the proximity of islands, nearly all sailing in the VIs is by line of sight (and night sailing is prohibited for charter boats). Your main interests in the guide will be things like which harbors have mooring balls and which are anchorages, prevailing wind direction/shifts at anchorages, recommended anchorage depths, what's on shore and how to book for dinner etc. The guide has plenty of that info. Charter boats will usually include a copy on the boat, but having your own copy for planning, dog-earing, highlighting and post-it noting is a good idea.
Is the review positive or negative? 