Negative Positive
Title: Disappointing recording
Review: I had such high hopes for this wonderfully chosen compilation of Randall Thompson's choral music, including Alleluia and Peaceable Kingdom - such masterpieces of American a capella writing. I took a risk on this unknown choral ensemble, and found a deeply disappointing recording. I agree with Mr. Taggart, the first reviewer, who noted the "shrill high end." I would add that the voices sound old but not prime quality. The acoustics are cavernous, and may help cover up some of the choir's shortcomings, but work against a "clean" sound. I wish I knew of a good recording of this same repertoire.
Is the review positive or negative? 