Negative Positive
Title: I'm skeptical
Review: I'm a bit skeptical about the accuracy of this book. Certainly the photographs are excellent; however, I find it hard to believe the author's portrayal of conditions at Alcatraz. This book would lead you to believe every warden and guard who served at Alcatraz was a picture of professionalism, fairness, and compassion towards the prisoners. According to the author no prisoner was ever abused or mis-treated and conditions even in the "dungeon" were humane. After reading this book I am amazed that anyone ever tried to escape - not because Alcatraz was supposed to be escape proof - but because compared to any prison I've ever heard of, the conditions there were so delightful!
Is the review positive or negative? 