Negative Positive
Title: Simply doesn't stand up to evidence
Review: Friendly fire incidents resulted in over 5300 American deaths during Vietnam, 50 Israeli soldiers were killed in these mistakes during the 6 day war including 4 the day before the accidental attack on the Liberty.There was no motive for Israel to deliberately attack an ally in a time of war, especially when their forces were stretched thin. Capt. McGonagle of the USS Liberty even admitted the attck was accidental. If Israel really wanted to sink the ship they would have done so with submarines under the cover of night, instead of a partial attack in the middle of the day. More than 10 American and 3 Israeli investigations have come to the same conclusion the attack was an accident.The USA would never have begun funding Israel with military aid had they deliberately attacked the Liberty, all in all this film is for conspiracy nuts and haters of Israel, and lacks any real coherence.
Is the review positive or negative? 