Negative Positive
Title: Rather a nasty piece of work
Review: I have just finished reading the updated edition, and frankly by the end had had enough of Philip Norman's continual snipping at McCartney, and the cheap shots and insinuations at his family. Calling George Harrison 'an average Guitarist' is frankly ignorant, and his love of Lennon creates a totally biased view point. His insinuations of Lennons involvement in Sutcliffes death, and alleged Homosexual activity are best left to the News Of the World. Finally his mistake in saying that Jason Starkey played for the Who, when in fact it was Zak makes you wonder about the whole integrity of the book ! Yes, overall a rather nasty piece of work dressing itself up as a serious insight.
Is the review positive or negative? 