Negative Positive
Title: Not for Outlander Fans
Review: Having recently returned from the world of Claire and Jamie in Diana Gabaldon's Outlander series, I was on a Scottish kick, so to speak. I picked up this book based on the recommendations here. Boy was I sorry! If this is an example of Moning's work, then I will certainly not read any other of her works. I found this book shallow and silly. Little detail is given to the physical setting, the characters were vapid and did not ring true what so ever. There is no real historic "feel." Overall, the book is cheesy. For fans of Outlander, I recommend the Into the Wilderness series by Sara Donati. Although it is not a time travel, the characters are strong and true, and there is a high level of historical accuracy.
Is the review positive or negative? 