Negative Positive
Title: You can't have it all
Review: I guess it's just too much to ask to want a novel with a great setting, a plot centered around diving, and a little plausibility. Mr. Poyer doesn't develop his characters much, and misses a great chance to describe the book's setting. He also dumbs down descriptions of diving and diving related maladies. (I think if readers can hang with Michael Crichton and Tom Clancy they could handle an accurate description of nitrogen narcosis). Plausibility is the last straw, though. Nobody could buy this plot.
Is the review positive or negative? 