Negative Positive
Title: Èntertaining but not always accurate
Review: Caulfield's history is a good read and good fun, but has its odd moments - for instance he weirdly typifies the funny, dreamy, sweet-natured poet Thomas MacDonagh as "arrogant", which would have surprised those who fought by his side and were taught by him. Not the definitive history, but very entertaining.
Is the review positive or negative? 