Negative Positive
Title: A Title Only for the Initiated
Review: Rawles attempt to write a novel is just that, an attempt. Yes, he tells a story that somewhat engages the reader and does a somewhat below average attempt at characterization. But, the reader only stays engaged if he or she can tolerate the intolerable minute descriptive details of material, weapons, military terms, foodstuffs, toilet paper, and more. In fact, one might think that this "novel" is a disguised manual for survivalists. Unfortunately, it is sold as a novel. Furthermore, Rawles' attempts to portray his militia as Christian is pathetic at best, and lacks theological foundation. For example, for a man to kill another man, for the first time, even in combat, is a soul rendering experience. For the characters in this "novel" it is a matter of course. Just doing the job.If the author had just told the story and left out 90% of the detailed lists the book would still be amateurish but at least entertaining.
Is the review positive or negative? 