Negative Positive
Title: NOT ONE MAP!!!
Review: This is the worst book I have ever read. Since there is not one map in the book, these people who wrote a collection of essays actually believe that a simple children's book requires someone to hold their hand in understanding a very simple story. There are one or two essays that are partially interesting. But most of the book is various inept authors that cant understand why they have not received the fame that Rowling has. So if you like to read about a bunch PHDs complaining misinterpreting and over analyzing, or you were confused by a children's story ... buy away.
Is the review positive or negative? 