Negative Positive
Title: Smelled bad for first several days so gave up.
Review: The original filters worked fine, as did an identical replacement filter I bought at a hardware store. Both had black rubber backing strips. I bought three of these to stay ahead, but the first gave off a strong unpleasant smell for several hours each time I tried it, so I tossed it and never tried the other two. These didn't have the black rubber backing like the original and hardware one. I think I'll look for ones with those and see if I have better luck...
Is the review positive or negative? 