Negative Positive
Title: ok, but quickly became discredited
Review: I was about 1/4 of the way into the book, it was alright, I was enjoying it, but then they mentioned Lucy... I had taken note of the author's careful way of sticking to the original novel, so I passed it off as bad editing, or just a type-o when she referred to Lucy Westerna. The next time Lucy's last name (Westenra, in the original) was misspelled, the credibility of the story kind of went down the drain. I plowed through the rest of it, but it just goes to show how one little mistake can ruin an otherwise above-average novel.
Is the review positive or negative? 