Negative Positive
Title: Fails Even As A Monday Morning Quarterback
Review: No doubt the author, if sent back to the 1930s would have joined those carrying signs "Scholarships Not Battleships". That message carried the US into WW2 with a totally unprepared military. To the tens of thousands of soldiers who died in junk tanks in Europe, primitive warships in the Atlantic and antique fighters and bombers in the Pacific an apology that can never be delivered is owed.The author's failed logic leads to failed conclusions. You can do 10 years or 100 years of "research" but if you ignore half the data and mis-analyze the rest you still have trash.
Is the review positive or negative? 