Negative Positive
Title: The Chronicles of WHO?
Review: Lets be blunt about this, I am without doubt the biggest fan of SRD going and have been from the beginning but as my old dad used to say if it walks,and sounds like a duck it probably is and what this novel isn't is a Chronicle of Thomas Covenant!This may be a socially correct extension of a previously sucessful storyline but it is not part of the greatest fantasy series ever written. The reason the Land exists is Thomas Covenant,not supporting characters. The reason the fans have elevated this series above all others is the love and respect of its main character, to attempt to extend the story without ite heart rings hollow indeed. Congratulations on a wonderful story that would have been more honestly titled Further Adventures in The Land it may have made less money but it would have offended less fans.
Is the review positive or negative? 