Negative Positive
Title: As bad as it gets
Review: This is the saddest attempt to cash in on the movies I have seen. Not only does it have nothing to do with the movie, it is not even good Tolkien. It consists of an interview with one of the lesser illustrators, music by an unknown British singer, of dubious talents, a very poor tour of Oxford (the outsides of places where Tolkien lived), interviews with non-Tolkien experts (Oxford students and low level dons), and a lot of footage of people who like to role-play being warring elves and goblins. The only "professional" bit is an interview with one of Tolkien's biographers, and that is not much. If this thing had been better described, on the web page, I would have never wasted my time buying it. It is the only thing I have ever bought on Amazon that I was not satisfied with.
Is the review positive or negative? 