Negative Positive
Title: Too Silly even for kids
Review: I've really enjoyed Kellogg's Pinkerton books, but this one's a dud. The best thing about this book was the wonderful illustrations and the only reason I gave it 2, rather than 1 star. I think my friend's 6 year old child put it appropriately - the book is weird and doesn't make any sense. It was so absurd and ridiculous as to be frustrating...not even my 3 year old found it fun. Maybe 4 or 5 year olds would, but no one younger would understand the story since it makes no sense really, and anyone older than 5 would think it too strange to enjoy. Kellogg should stick with a good thing like Pinkerton.
Is the review positive or negative? 