Negative Positive
Title: Good but not Amazing.
Review: Being a fan of all the versions of the Phantom of the Opera be they black/white, silent, horror, or starring gerald butler. I must say I found this movie somewhat disappointing. I just can't seem to align with this version of the film. I like the plot, enjoyed the costumes and inventive set, and quite a few of the songs. However some of the characters just don't ring true somehow. Its hard to follow up a sequel that uses none of the original cast, but I think its more of a plot issue than an actor one. I still can't quite put my finger on what it is and i have seen the movie three or four times now. Raul I think is the biggest issue for me. Something about his role in this is just so strange. . . .
Is the review positive or negative? 