Negative Positive
Title: AWFUL! AWFUL! AWFUL!
Review: I don't understand how this book got so many good reviews! It was awful! Let me list the things that I hate about this book..No battle at the end.No armies.Stupid puzzles.I actualy felt sorry for the bad guy, he just got tricked and creamed so many times, he's hardly a threat to the good guys! He keeps getting crushed by these pirates, his army betrays him to the pirates, and the 5 good guys show up in the end and totally destroy the rest of the bad guys army, the pirate's ship, and the bad guy himself! It was pitiful! In all, this book was terrible, I only gave it one star because it had a cool swordfight in the end. Skip this book! Read the other Redwall books though, they're good {except for Loamhedge, it's bad too}.
Is the review positive or negative? 