Negative Positive
Title: Old wine in new bottles
Review: As a professor of organizational behavior I fully embrace the concept and notion of emotional intelligence, but not how Goleman has defined it. Others have done more solid work than has Goleman, but unfortunately they have not received much credit. Serious scholars of intelligence (social, emotional, or practical) don't really take Goleman very seriously, and it is sad to see "hype" and attention Goleman gets.As regards Mr. Goleman's recent escapades into leadership all I can say is that what he has recently discovered has [already] been discussed previously by many scholars of charismatic leadership (and related theories of inspirational, and Pygmalion leadership).
Is the review positive or negative? 