Negative Positive
Title: Where was the editor?
Review: I cannot help but wonder where Diana's editor was with this book. I have been a faithful fan and reader for more years than I care to remember and I am disappointed by this latest book.It is a sloppy piece of fiction, ill-thought out and frustrating in its lack of pace. The former spark of magic that wove everything together in her last books is not present and the plot (if you can call it that) is lost in details about penicillian and leaking mammary glands.Brianna is spoiled and tedious, Roger is pointless (THEY are pointless, IMHO),Jemmy and his diapers and cute sayings are anything but cute, and Claire and Jamie are stuck in a large and vacuous rut. I found myself not even caring about Bonnet. His character can only be compared to Jack Randall and there IS no comparison.I just can't believe that THIS is what she spent 5 years on. Gag.
Is the review positive or negative? 