Negative Positive
Title: Too slow too unrealistic
Review: Though I'm an avid fan of Robin McKinley's books, this one seemed to drag on forever. Every once in a while it was enjoyable, but the characters are odd and pretty forgetable. Unlike most books I read, where there is a clear picture of what is happening in my head, this one seemed cludy and fuzzy. It's about as interesting as reading non-fiction (which I'm not to keen on, but is occasionally interesting). Blah Blah Blah. She needed to cut and shorten it up some because there is way too much fluff. If you are a fan of Robin, then I would recommend 1. The Blue Sword 2. The Hero and the Crown, and 3. the Outlaws of Sherwood before reading the Spindle's End.
Is the review positive or negative? 