Negative Positive
Title: Fatally flawed thesis of little value
Review: Griffith's treatise on ACW tactics contains so many fatal flaws, that his findings are of little, if any, value. The author ignores so much overwhelming evidence that runs counter to his many points, that by choosing instead to either ignore or omit them, Griffith's finished product becomes an exercise for its own sake. Readers not familiar with the totality of the voluminous evidence that Griffith omits might not be aware that they are being duped. Regardless, the result is that this is a VERY bad book.
Is the review positive or negative? 