Negative Positive
Title: A Travesty!
Review: Again, someone has decided that the Sherlock Holmes created by Conan Doyle should be thrown into the trash and exchanged for a "man of the 90s." A lover for Holmes who is also at least his equal as a detective! Get real. If authors are going to write a pastiche, they are bound by ethics to keep the character true to the Canon, not turn him into what their modern-day feelings wish him to be.
Is the review positive or negative? 