Negative Positive
Title: Exceptional piece of work!
Review: Amanda Sloat is a keen observer and a fine writer. Her description of the development of Scotland's constitution was both informative and incisive. The book has an obvious market in university libraries, but I should think that anyone interested in Scottish history would want to own this book. Though Sloat is a scholar, her book has the appealing quality of being accessible. I recommend it.
Is the review positive or negative? 