Negative Positive
Title: Not good enough for my 115 year old bookclub
Review: Diamant disappointed me with this one. The historical background was OK but no depth to the history of a rich historical area.( I have lived in nearby Marblehead). The individual chapter plots lukewarm, the initial language uneccesary - failed to be attention forming. I left it at the library as a gift this morning. Now I have to find another book for bookclub for 2006I loaned it to another bookclub member to review it (she also is a reviewer for our town library). She agreed - no equal to the RED TENT. V. Daring(not a child's review)
Is the review positive or negative? 