Negative Positive
Title: Not the perfect book, but not bad.
Review: For all its structural shortcomings, the book effectively conveys a feeling of the power of nature, the dangers faced by fishermen, and how it is that vessels can disappear without trace. A better book that deals with ships disappearing on the high seas is Alan Villiers's "Posted Missing," now out-of-print but available from booksellers at modest prices.
Is the review positive or negative? 