Negative Positive
Title: Robin McKinley's great but this one lost me.
Review: I'm an avid reader and usually love Robin McKinley but this one was painful to get through. At first, I enjoyed the plot but by the second half, it stopped making sense. The entire ending seemed pointless and unpurposeful, and although Petunia's love plot was nice, Rosie was in love with a 40 year old man. I'm sorry but if you want to read Robin McKinley, read The Blue Sword.
Is the review positive or negative? 