Negative Positive
Title: Good timing when the book came out call it Lucky investing!
Review: Tobin's book is to be read now after the market collapse. Stuffed with made up terms "GOD and EGOD" for example,(GOD) standing for Game Over Dominators, the book is organized in a logical way but the stock picking method doesn't make any sense unlike Peter Lynch's seminal 1989 book, One Up on Wall Street. Let's not forget that Lynch had the billion $ Fidelity Magellan to manage. Smith only had the Journal and may be tons of other reference materials to make up for inexperience. Anyway his next book should be called "Tsunami"
Is the review positive or negative? 