Negative Positive
Title: Library perspective
Review: If I were to pick up this book to read personally, I'd be disappointed--for all the same reasons various adult reviewers have given.On the other hand, I have the perspective of working in a public library's Youth Services department, and youngish teenagers are gleefully devouring this series as quickly as they can secure copies. If you're considering purchase for a girl age 12-14, you'll likely miss an opportunity to nourish her on higher-quality literature--but you're also likely to get enthusiastic hugs of gratitude, an encouraged reader, and a lot of excitement from your happy teen. She'll be thrilled!
Is the review positive or negative? 