Negative Positive
Title: Overrated
Review: Always on the prowl for the best mascara (my biggest concerns being the brush and whether or not it will leave those faint grey smudges under my eyes from flaking), I read that Allure recommended this one 3 years in a row as the Best Mascara. I will admit that I love the brush and the way it goes on. But, from day one, it flakes and I get smudges under my eyes. I was told by a Mac representative that that means the mascara is old and needs to be replaced. That was true for my last mascara (Mac), but either I purchased old Dior mascara, or Dior is just overrated (and probably pays Allure for that #1 spot). So, I guess I'm out $24, and will go back to the Mac counter and buy there. When you find something good, stick with it! Also, I wasn't expecting the mascara to smell so perfumy! Ugh. I hate perfumes.
Is the review positive or negative? 