Negative Positive
Title: May as well use water
Review: I recall the Bay Rhum I used in college - Royall Lyme brand I think (as opposed to Royal Doulton), but the Bay Rhum essence. It had a distinctive aroma that i could smell for close to an hour (others I suspect longer) but I think it was cologne, rather than "after shave cologne". In any event, the aroma of this stuff is so weak to my olfactory apparatus that I asked my wife what she thought of it. Her reply was "barely detectable". I think I'll stick to Tiffany for Men, Paloma Picasso's Minotaur, and Caron's Pour Homme in the future. To me, this stuff is no better than water. I may let half of the alcohol evaporate to see if the aroma gets any stronger. Otherwise, I'll simply toss it.
Is the review positive or negative? 