Negative Positive
Title: Stupid premise
Review: This book, among other things, calls the little kid "stupid" for wanting to believe his father, claims that the father really didn't know where the trains were going (THE WHOLE MOVIE IS ABOUT THE FATHER MAKING HIS SON BELIEVE THAT EVERYTHING IS OKAY!!!), claims that the movie makes the holocaust look like fun and games, claims the the movie teaches us that if the other families in the death camps had just been a little more "clever", that their children would have been saved as well, and a whole bunch of other faulty logic.
Is the review positive or negative? 