Negative Positive
Title: A Very Misleading Book
Review: It concerns me that some may take the author's views as fact. When reading what Ms. Piper credits as the reasons "we" are such huge fans, my jaw dropped. These may be the reasons she is a fan, but in no way reflect my feelings nor are they representational of Clay fans as a whole. They should have been presented as opinion but were instead presented as fact.In addition, to credit 15,000 (a generous estimate) internet fans with Clay's degree of success when his cd went double platinum the first week and eventually triple platinum is arrogant. Even if each internet Clay fan bought ten cd's, that still leaves 2,850,000 cd's bought by non internet Clay fans. The statement is an insult to Clay's talent and to Clay.If you want to buy the book, so be it, but please do not lose sight of the fact that this is one person's opinion. Question every sentence.
Is the review positive or negative? 