Negative Positive
Title: Completely Dated
Review: This would be a nice compilation of stories and anecdotes to read--if it were 1982. Reading it felt like I was being lectured by an old man in a nursing home telling me about how hard it was 'back in MY day'.I judge a book about the Appalachian Trail by whether or not it makes me want to go out and hike it. This one did no such thing. It felt like sitting around listening to a bunch of old George Carlin-types, without the wit or humor.
Is the review positive or negative? 