Negative Positive
Title: provides new information to the battle of Gettysburg
Review: Excellent portrayal of new facts to the Battle of Gettysburg. The best essays were about the "real" Chamberlain, how JEB Stuart's cavalry really impacted the battle, & whether Longstreet and Sickles really messed up. Contrary to the 1st reviewer below, the writer does believe that Sickles made a mistake moving to the peach orchard. The best essay was about the common soldier. The essay writers make the characters come alive...not dull history writing at all!
Is the review positive or negative? 