Negative Positive
Title: there's no "there" there
Review: As a sailor I was looking forward to this well publicized book... It was a bitter disappointment. It is not a novel, nor is it novel. It isn't even a story... It is a description of events coupled with the author's best guess musings about what people who died might have done and thought in their last hours. My husband thinks, without bothering to read it yet, that maybe it's a book that would only appeal to men, but I wouldn't even have made it a book; at best, it should have been harshly edited down and published in a specialized magazine for people interested in commercial fishing by rather sad people.
Is the review positive or negative? 