Negative Positive
Title: Hard to believe David Weber wrote it.
Review: David Weber is my favorite author. As I read Apocolypse Troll I was stunned. A poor, overworked plot, undeveloped characters and action that was incomplete and not intense. In short, it had none of the features I have come to expect from David Weber. I have to believe that this book was either released in sketch form without Weber's permission, or that it is an old work that the publisher dusted off and printed without giving Weber a chance to finish or re-write it.
Is the review positive or negative? 