Negative Positive
Title: Extremely disappointing
Review: After reading Ms. Gabaldon's previous four novels, steeped in rich Scottish history, with the intrigue of Jamie and Clair, this book was a complete waste. I bought it two months ago and just now am completing the last 30 pages. After much anticipated waiting, I am extremely disappointed. It simply does not hold the readers attention. The characters are stagnant, the book is too long [by about 800 pages], and there is little historical value. I do hope Ms. Gabalon gets back on track, it would be a shame for this saga to simply fade away.
Is the review positive or negative? 