Negative Positive
Title: irritated, but not surprised
Review: This work is astounding in its profound ignorance not only of contemporary psychoanalysis, but of psychoanaytic developments in the last half of the 20th century (and also of much of contemporary neurobiology). The arrogance here is amazing -- to write a book without even attempting to familiarize oneself with th subject matter; but, we must ask, where is this arroagnce coming from? I believe Kitcher well demonstrate the law, "Academics moves toward the trendy, occasionally errs, self-corrects and moves again toward the trendy."
Is the review positive or negative? 