Negative Positive
Title: Unimpressive
Review: A surprisingly juvenile book of stories that only loosely connects itself to the Gulf War--the humour is embarrassingly weak, the writing is steeped in cliche, the political references are thin and empty. Without that linking motif of the Gulf War, this book would be seen for what it is, a barely capable, immensely derivative, work of fiction by a young writer blissfully unaware of how sentimental he is.
Is the review positive or negative? 