Negative Positive
Title: Inflated and flawed
Review: If you've seen the movie, you already know the biggest plot problem is the way the Genesis planet operates. What happens to Spock makes no -- forgive me -- logical sense. The author doesn't tidy up the gaping plot holes very much. She just puts a little more meat on the bones of story that already has skeletal flaws. Huge chunks of the novel were so close to word for word recitations of the movie's dialogue, they might as well have reprinted the actual script and sold that.And call me a stickler but I do wish these writers would study a bit more Star Trek cannon and the technical details rights. The Kirk's Enterprise is NOT a Constellation class starship. It's a Constitution class. Kruge's ship is a Bird of Prey not a "fighter". Getting the details right is not too much to ask in a book you could have written in a couple of weeks.
Is the review positive or negative? 