Negative Positive
Title: beautiful film, mediocre "special edition"
Review: There is no denying that this is one of the great films of all time. That said, the DVD version is a huge disappointment. The "special features" include a part of a documentary, commentary by a film critic who isn't particularly qualified to talk about it, and "cast biographies" that consist of a still screen listing other films by six or eight actors, including several(Burt Young, Joe Pesci, Treat Williams) who are only on screen for just a few minutes of a 4 hour film. The cut between disc one and disc two is horrible, especially since an "intermission" card comes up a few minutes into disc 2. Sloppy, disappointing work. Not worth the greatness of this masterpiece.
Is the review positive or negative? 