Negative Positive
Title: Not appropriate for all applications
Review: This adapter worked fine for charging and for sound output, but be aware of some key limitations:1) This adapter is too large to fit into many docking stations. I found I could only connect it to other items using iPod cables.2) Although it will charge and allow one to play music from the iPod, it doesn't provide full functionality. When I connected it to a computer, my Mac did not recognize the shuffle. This was the case whether or not I'd pre-launched iTunes.So, if all you want to do is connect your shuffle to a car transmitter/charger or other cable-based device, this adapter is fine. If you want to use docks or make your computer-connected iPod cable do double-duty for your shuffle and for your other iPods, this isn't the solution for you.
Is the review positive or negative? 