Negative Positive
Title: Getting worse and worse
Review: I initially enjoyed Robinson's first two books, but ever since HMS Unseen they have gotten steadily worse to the point of rediculousness with The Shark Mutiny. Many other readers have pointed out the glaring flaws with the court martial already, and the ending of this court martial left me feeling like I had just re-read USS Seawolf.Secondly, the manner in which Capt. Cale Dunning acted in "deciding" the fate of Dan Headley is hardly what one would have expected from him given his own actions in Kilo Class which nearly cost him a court martial himself.Finally, I think Robinson needs to get back to the point of view of Nimitz Class and Kilo Class which were told more from the point of the commanders in action, rather than spending half of Shark Mutiny listening to Adm. Arnie Morgan musing to himself without even speaking to anyone to convey his thoughts.Escapism it may be, but don't waste your time on this one.
Is the review positive or negative? 