You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: All Hat, No Cattle
Product review: Caveat emptor: I bought this book in order to scan the section on Vicksburg, so my comments only pertain to that portion of the book.After scanning the section on Vicksburg, I was not tempted in any way to read the rest of the book. She was consistently wrong on nearly every aspect of the Vicksburg Campaign ... from the placement of the fortifications at Chickasaw Bayou (they were NOT on top of the hills, Rowena) to Grant's grand plan of operations when he set foot on dry soil at Milliken's Bend (we see in the Papers of Ulysses S. Grant that he intended all along to move south of the city). Major gaps exist in the O.R. material for this period, and Rowena fills in these gaps with hateful vitriol. I'm not sure what her game is, but it is not history.
