You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Might be good for classroom setting with 3rd graders
Product review: Oh, how I hate to be the one to criticize a fellow professor! But, even as a literature/philosopher professor myself, I would have trouble implementing the ideas in the the book. I also question using the particular works/poems she chose to explain the philosophical concepts. I have no doubt that she does a terrific job in the classroom, but I'm less sure about how easily that expertise can be translated in a book like this. Although she says that the approach is good for a wide range of ages, I doubt much of the literature she selects would be accessible for kindergartners-- the vocabulary is just too sophisticated. This book just did not live up to my expectations....
