You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: This book appears to be a knockoff of a classic
Product review: It appears to me that book footnotes Rod Gragg's Book "Confederate Goliath" so many times that it may as well be a copy of that book. Note the name of this book "Rebel Gibraltar" seems to be a careful play on words hoping to confuse the readers into think that this is really "Confederate Goliath." What little does not come from Gragg seems to come directly from Chris Fonvielle's The Wilmington Campaign. There is little in this book which is new. Justr a bunch or re-hashing of decondary sources. Do yourself a big favor and just read Gragg's "Confederate Goliath." It is a vastly superior book to this one in so many ways. [...]
