You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Several rereadings later . . .
Product review: . . . I confirm my earlier review, long ago scrolled off this page: Leonard Peikoff is not a very critical thinker. (Well, in many ways neither was Rand. But Peikoff isn't even half the _polemicist_ she was.)Wouldn't it be nice if somebody who actually knew something about real philosophy figured out what the heck Rand was trying to say, subjected it to serious critical scrutiny, and offered suggestions for improving it? The result wouldn't be "Objectivism," but it might be a respectable philosophy that presented a coherent outlook.It won't happen as long as dogs like Peikoff are guarding the manger.
