You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: interesting, but hardly convincing
Product review: This is a very fascinating read about adolescent girls in the Lubavitch section of Crown Heights. However, the study is not rigorous enough to really support the theoretical claims the author tries to make. Surely her research into Orthodox Jews in general would have suggested that girls in the Lubavitch community are NOT representative of those in either mainstream Orthodox Jewish or "ultra-orthodox" Chassidic communities, in which gender segregated schools are also the norm. As such, it's not clear how she can assert so confidently that the relative immaturity and extrovertedness of the girls she observes comes from their lack of inter-gender contact. The failure to "test" for alternative hypotheses - say, for example, the goals of community leaders, or the dictates of Lubavitch philosophy (neither of which are thoroughly examined - makes this even more problematic.
