You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: This has to be the best version,
Product review: simply because of the excellent Scrooge played by Alister Sim.Scrooge has to carry the film obviously. The 1938 Hollywood version, is in some ways, better such as its supporting cast & greater expositon of the story. Reginold Owens as Scrooge is fine, but it was a part built for John Barrymore. Who could fill those shoes? Unfortunately he was falling down drunk. He was injured & could not do it.The 1951 version is simply the best because if you don't have the best Scrooge you can't have the best Christmas Carol. It is regrettably short, but stll the best. See them both & compare. They are quite different versions of the same classic.
