You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Interesting but not ecstasy-producing
Product review: It is quite a thrill to read a new Lord Peter book; I only wish he could have been there instead of the pale imitation who wears his shoes. Jill Paton Walsh has written a fine book, but has missed out on what I love Lord Peter and Harriet for: the wit and quotations. This book feels awfully serious compared to the flights of fancy in Busman's Honeymoon. I agree with the reviewer who objects to the "feel" of the book; it's too politically correct for the '30s or Dorothy Sayers. I felt that Walsh captured the Dowager Duchess and Uncle Paul quite well, but many of the characters are too obvious, too direct, too clear in their dialogue. Sayers's dialogue usually reveals more levels upon rereading; I doubt that Walsh's will. However, I am extremely grateful that someone finished this novel and gave us a chance to meet the characters again.
