You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: YOU GOTTA LOVE IT, BUT IS IT THE WHOLE STORY?
Product review: I read the hardback; I read the paperback; I read the (Illustrated Edition); and still I am impressed. Without a doubt this is one of the most extraordinary adventure stories ever written. Krakauer's skill at spinning at tale is exceptional. But, still, I have several questions. Why so much focus on Scott Fischer's expedition and not his own? Why was Beck Weathers not given more attention after he wandered into camp? What's the deal with the Russian, Anatoli Boukreev? The American Alpine Club recognized his efforts on Everest as heroic, but in his book Krakauer never says a thing about it. Did Krakauer offer to take Beck Weathers down the mountain? Krakauer says yes. In "Salon" I read that Weathers asked for Krakauer's help, but Krakauer declined. -- As impressed as I am with INTO THIN AIR, I am left with these nagging questions. I wonder if we will ever have the whole story.
