You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: General Information
Product review: I was disappointed with Amy Holman's An Insiders Guide To Creative Writing Programs. Where is the inside information? The book is basically a list of schools and programs, each listing containing non-critical information gleaned from web sites. There are no critical assessments here regarding funding, admissions, etc., which tends to equalize and generalize each entry leaving me unable to point myself in any direction. I bought Tom Kealey''s Creative Writing MFA Handbook at the same time (five stars) and love it. If you have your own list, Kealey's book, the internet and some self direction you don't need this book.
