You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Good Book, Looking forward to the movie
Product review: Gods and Generals is a good but not perfect book (what book is?). I agree that the battle descriptions could have been longer. I wish the author would have depicted Stonewall Jackson at First Bull Run and showed him in the Shenandoah Valley Campaign of 1862. I was so interested in the depiction of Sandie Pendleton, Jackson's Aide, I had to pick up a book entitled "Stonewall's Man" by W.G. Bean a full and excellent biography. While looking through some of the lower ratings of "Gods and Generals" I did find mistakes in their reviews. Someone says that it would be far-fetched for Lee to capture John Brown at Harpers Ferry but that is exactly what happened, read the historical record. And another person says that the reaction of Jackson at the execution of John Brown is inaccurate. Please read Burke Davis' "They Called Him Stonewall" and you will find out that the reaction of Jackson in the book is historically accurate.
