You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Cheap ploy
Product review: The author has stumbled onto a gimmicky trick to get herself published, but one as old as time: Iconoclasty. In other words, she picks a subject almost at random. Today its delta blues music, tomorrow its Mae West. Next week it might be The Beatles or Picasso. It doesn't matter. Then write a book "shattering" everyones image of said topic. Wow, see how wrong you were about that. I must be a great author to point that out. Problem is, its all in her head. Why only a few reviews of each of her books? Because not many people give her any credibility. Even less care. Notice the cliche'd academic style title too: Statement, colon, three words. Always three words. Here's a title for you, I'm Trying Too Hard: Academia, Pretension, and the Desperate Need to Get Published.
