You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Disappointing attempt at a case book
Product review: Professor Bernhardt's book is little more than a compilation of cases. There is very little editing and no clarifying information. The comments in between the cases are mostly statutes and some excerpts of other cases- there is very little commentary or even hypotheticals. He includes lots of clever little cartoons, but they are a poor substitute for actual content. The book is basically a cut-and-paste job, and a poor one at that- there are a plethora of typos and grammatical errors.There is a supplement to the book that is just as bad, with the added confusion of a different labeling format for the cases in it.I would strongly reccomend that this professor hire some undergrads to proofread this book, but only after he has gone back and actually added some value to the book in terms of commentary and guidance.
