You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: A MAJOR LETDOWN
Product review: After the achingly beautiful and heartfelt "The Book of Mercy," Kathleen Cambor has thrust "In Sunlight in a Beautiful Garden " on us. I would guess that the idea of "novelizing" an actual event seemed like a good one to Cambor but in her hands this effort falls flat even though there are some beautifully written passages as in Julia's thoughts after the death of 2 of her children: "..the charm, the tenderness, the wit she'd always counted on, that her mother always said were part of her good character, had disappeared like so much smoke. She was left hollowed, fractured, parched." What I'm saying is that Kathleen Cambor is a fine writer but her talents are not suited to this particular subject. What happens is, because there is so much exposition needed to propell this story, that Cambor's talent is squandered. "In the Sunlight in a Beautiful Garden" is a noble failure but a failure nonetheless.
