You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Was Hoping for More Analysis, Less Block Quoting
Product review: The author is a decent legal thinker who posts frequently on NRO's The Corner blog. His posts there are thoughtful and nuanced. Not this. It seems to me the publisher "dumbed down" the book for its expected readership, diluting and flattening out the nuance and argumentation, leaving a lot of rhetoric, extended block quotes, and Rush Limbaugh. With the judiciary under attack as the only branch not currently under the political control of the Republican party, it does not surprise that judges have become targets of the other branches of government. There is surely much food for thought regarding Marbury vs. Madison, federalism, and the role of an independent judiciary in our system of government, but I think much of the analysis has been left on the cutting room floor. I'd be interested in an unabridged version of this book, or perhaps will just keep reading Mark's posts in The Corner.
