You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Michno let us down
Product review: I've been really impressed by Gregory Michno, in both Lakota Noon and Indian Wars. However, in this book, it appears he let down his objective intelligent analytical style to go on a crusade, discarding all the research techniques that made LN and Indian Wars so believable. For instance, he could have corroborated Indian Testimony with that of the Army's, a tool which he used very successfully in the past. His failure to even delve into that issue makes it apparent that he had a decision on the whole matter before he even began his research, and only pursued feeble arguments which supported his own theory. His character assassinations of Silas Soule and Major Anthony is a very pathetic excuse to discredit their recorded testimonies in my opinion, and a very boring technique used in politics today to an alarming rate. I look forward to better efforts from him in the future.
