You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Phil would make these songs sound fantastic.
Product review: I love Genesis. I think their best work to date is Duke, which is an awe-inspiring masterpiece. Calling All Stations is a great album, except for that dreadful Ray Wilson. He sounds really bad compared to Phil. He's clearly not the right guy to replace a singer as good as Mr. Collins (then again, I can't think of anyone replacing him, except maybe Peter...).The songs are (mostly) really good, but Ray doesn't do them justice. Just imagine Phil singing these songs. Man, they would rock! OK, I admit some of the songs aren't that great (Not About Us and Small Talk for example) but there are real classics in there as well (One Man's Fool, Alien Afternoon and The Dividing Line).Tony and Mike are great songwriters together, but I really hope Phil decides to return to regroup the greatest songwiter-trio of all times.
