You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Lighter than air
Product review: Neil Gaiman is a wonderful writer and when I picked up Stardust and read the first few pages I was prepared to be enchanted. Unfortunately, the spell never quite took. There is so much to like about Stardust - the basic premise, the main characters, the descriptions both of the human town of Wall and the faery land of Faery. But for all its plots and subplots the story has no depth. It's like only being able to dip your toe into the pool on a hot day when you really want to dive in. As another reviewer here points out, everytime we appear to reach a crisis Gaiman gives the character an "easy out" and there's never any real denouement. Stars may be able to survive without substance, good stories can't.
