You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Terribly Disappointing
Product review: I ordered this book based on not only my love of the Tolkien Universe but on the recommendations of those who have seen it. I am very disappointed with the book. The drawings and text bring nothing of the flavor of Tolkien's World to the page and serve only to remove the beauty of his language from the stories. As a research tool, this book is useless and as a hobbyist's edition, it is not worth the paper it iss printed on. If you are looking for a description of Tolkien's world, head to The History of Middle-Earth as edited by Christopher Tolkien. These provide as much information as the atlas does, and in a way that makes it much more interesting and keeps the imagination alive.
