You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Size 9.5 Dress Shoe -- XL was too large
Product review: My dress shoe size is men's 9.5D. I wear Allen Edmonds Park Avenues.I ordered XL overshoes based on other reviews recommending XL for 9.5 (although for sneakers). The overshoes are too large. They flop over the shoe and slide around when I walk. Maybe this is because of the sleeker profile of the Park Avenues. But I'm returning these and purchasing the L overshoes, which I'm sure will fit nicely.Otherwise, quality and durability seem fine.
