You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Jeff sure is not his dad!!!!
Product review: I waited with baited breath for this book to come out and when it did I was so disappointed I wanted to scream. My question harkens back to the 80's Wendy's commercial- "Where's the Beef?" Of Gods and Generals read more like my 8th grade text book than the work that this one is to prequal. The charachter development is not there-I was actually hoping Chamberlain would catch one in the head so I could stop listening to his whining. I was most disappointed with the treatment of Jackson in this pot boiler. Yes, Jackson was a fanatic but Shaara missed the boat in the way the men looked at him and how he preceived himself. Where is the scholarship in this novel. If you are going to write Historical Fiction at least include some History. For Pete's sake at least plagerize some Foote or somebody who knows a little about the Civil War. I will begrudgingly read The Last Full Measure. Jeff I am putting you on notice, do better research or go back to Florida and sell coins.
