You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Superb, with some caveats
Product review: I found this book totally absorbing; stayed up all night to finish it. Some reviewers think it's a roman a clef, but the inside stuff is lost on us Philistines. I thought the book was put together well and the ending is a stunner! However, Mr. Picano should know that he is poorly served by his publisher. The book is filled with typos (possessive it's; O'Henry for O. Henry, etc.) and was so poorly copy-edited that readers are unnecessarily slowed down. He's a good enough writer to deserve one of the major publishers, I think.
