You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Interesting documentary with a poor conclusion.
Product review: The first part of the documentary was interesting, especially the forensic work with tooth enamel, etc. The historical references were also insightful into that era of Roman Britain. Thus two stars were earned.However, the big problem was with their conclusion. They claimed to know exactly who the headless Romans were. Their chosen method of mystery-solving consisted of the following steps: 1) they looked at the skeletons and theorized about who they were 2) they read about an event that took place in Roman-British history around the same time and place that the skeletons were thought to be from and 3) they conjectured that the headless Romans were none other than the people in the historical event.That is very poor mystery-solving. It is an interesting and plausible theory, but the film makers should have clearly presented their idea as a theory, not a fact or a definite answer to the question of who the skeletons were.
