You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Item should be called Water resistant, not water proof.
Product review: Installed unit in a roof rack on top of my Forester using directions provided. We ran into a moderate rain storm for just over an hour and the product managed to not hold up as intended and items in the bag were nice and wet. Product should be called water resistant not waterproof. A perfect fix would be a second zipper or something around the bag to seal the zipper cover flap down. The Velcro provided just doesn't do any good. On a positive note, it does secure down nicely on my vehicle rack and items made it to the destination. I suggest looking elsewhere for a better item unless you plan on traveling in dry weather.
