You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Feels too much like a vehicle for the author's opinions
Product review: The format of a dialogue between people with opposing views about survival of death gives an impression of objectivity, but in reality, this is essentially a piece of apologetics for self-as-physical-body. The person who doesn't believe in survival of death is constantly winning the discussion over the person who does, and the latter keeps switching views as each idea of his is "disproven," often by a trivial objection.It poses as an introduction to the topic, but the overwhelming impression given--that there is no significant philosophical support for survival of death, and moreover that people who believe in it aren't very bright--makes it a terrible resource for a beginner, and not nearly comprehensive or convincing enough for the persuasive piece it actually is.
