You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: A big disappointment
Product review: I was born in western Pennsylvania in a town much like the one Jennifer Haigh attempts to describe. She does a very poor job. I've also taken the train from Altoona to Pittsburgh and never once crossed the Susquehanna River. I had a sister who put pancake make-up in her legs in lieu of nylon stockings, but she used an eyeliner pencil to draw a simulated seam down the back. Ms. Haigh's women used Magic Markers; there were no Magic Markers at that time. Ms. Haigh makes a 1950's reference to Washington DC's Watergate Hotel which was built in the mid-1960's. These inexcusable errors (there are others, too) irritated me so much that I made it only to page 78. I doubt that I'll return to finish. This may seem petty of me, but the characters, also, are one-dimensional.
