You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: Bad Writing, Worse Editing
Product review: There is no excuse for this book to have landed on the bookshelves in this sorry state. Mair's writing is pedestrian, but this might have been pounded into shape and been an adequate look at this brilliant performer. But Birch Lane apparently has fired all their editors and replaced them with Spell-Check. This book is so full of grammatical and spelling errors, factual errors, clunky phrasing, that it reads like a first draft. Didn't anyone READ it before sending it to the printer? It's shoddy, amateurish books like this that shatter my faith in the state of the publishing industry today.
