You are considering whether to buy a product. You look at the reviews. Would the following review decrease or increase the chances of you buying the product?
Review title: 2 of the Great 11 no longer exist as of 2009
Product review: The book has a poor record of identifying "great" companies. Among the 11 "great" companies in the book, two no longer exist: Circuit City (bankrupt and liquidated in 2009) and Gillette (swallowed by P&G in 2005, now defunct as a company). Another, Fannie Mae, doesn't deserve to exist, and books are being written on what a failure it was. Maybe P&G took over Gillette because Gillette was great, but the fact remains that Gillette is dead, and survival should be a quality of greatness.
