Title: An overlooked gem.
Review: More ambitious than either the Blue or Green albums (both classics themselves), "Pinkerton" is a raw, deliberately-underproduced album that takes a veiled concept about Madame Butterfly and fuses it with Rivers Cuomo's obsessive lyrics, endlessly hummable melodies, and Weezer's roughest garage-band sound. Ignored upon its original release, "Pinkerton" now stands out as Weezer's most accomplished album.
Is this product review negative?