Title: Got it Wrong
Review: Among the Civil War generals you find the most overrated general in American history--Robert E Lee and the most underrated--U S Grant. And here Shaara falls into the same rut of idolizing Lee and dumbing down Grant. A great injustice has be done to Grant through large swaths of American history and Shaara ham-handed treatment of Grant in this novel is more of the same. For a fuller and more accurate portrayal of Grant (non-fiction) try Jean Edward Smith'sGrant.
Is this product review negative?