Title: Sloppy
Review: The idea behind this book is good - prepare for the essay exam by actually writing essays. The book gives a great approach for how to read problems, digest the facts, organize, and then actually write your answers. The model answers answers and grading rubrics, however, are limited in their usefulness by numerous errors. There are factual errors in the answers (assuming facts not stated or outright misstatements), legal errors in the answers (incorrect statements of law), and grading rubrics that don't apply to the problem or are inconsistent with the written explanation of what the bar examiners are looking for. The error rate is high - of the 13 problems I've worked through from different sections in the book, 3 had at least one of these errors! Such a high error rate is disappointing, especially considering the copyright notice says this is a 2011 version of book initially published in 1995.
Is this product review negative?