Title: If I could give more stars, I would.
Review: I get angry with anyone who says these books are b.s. -- those folks must have been so speechless that they had to find something to pick apart. And I know that sometimes it was a tad predictable that almost all of the major characters survived, but hey, Boromir and Theoden died, didn't they? To me, these books are the standard by which all other books of any genre are to be judged. And they are not simply a story; they are a full account of an entire land and its battle against evil. Tolkien's work is truly extraordinary and anything other than the highest praise is undeserved.
Is this product review negative?