Title: There was No Icon for Zero Stars
Review: A true flop. This work of ostensible scholarship is poorly researched, sporadically argued, and clumsily written. The language is awkward and the book, as a whole, is a bore. I cannot recommend this work to anyone; it fails on every level. It is pretentious and underwhelming. For all of its bluster, "Islands and Exiles" might have been called "Islands of Excrement."
Is this product review negative?