Title: Revisionism at its Worst
Review: As a historian, I am appalled by President Carter's obvious lack of scholarship and attention to the most basic truths about the Middle East. You don't have to be fanatically pro-Israel to recognize how dangerous this book is, how inappropriate it is to refer to Israel as an apartheid state, and how fundamentally incorrect that basic premise is. Carter, as a "scholar," continues to go for cheap dramatic thrills rather than historical accuracy. If you're pro-Palestinian and you want to learn actual facts about your heritage or your cause, don't be tempted to follow Carter blindly down his clearly ill-informed Yellow Brick Road to a land that does not exist. If you're pro-Israel, well, you've heard all this garbage before anyway, so you shouldn't be very surprised. But you should be angry.
Is this product review negative?