Title: Was a good song, poorly rewritten
Review: I must say I hated this song when it was first played on American Idol. I'm not sure why, it may have been listening to Bo's version, but at any rate it grew on me greatly. I think Carrie does an awesome job, and of course her performance is even better with a studio recording. The one problem I have with it is that the song was changed to do the studio version without the key change, and with Carrie's powerhouse voice, that was the best part of the song. It's like watching Titanic and having them cut the sinking part. Bad analogy, but the point is they did the song a great injustice with that cut, and it makes it somewhat disappointing at the end.
Is this product review negative?