Title: I didn't think Ms. Phillips could pull it off
Review: I couldn't see how this book could be good, but it was. Very entertaining and I loved Button and Lucy. Ms Phillips is one of my all time favorites - But I'm giving this book 4 stars because I didn't believe Nealy's character was consistant in the end. The Nealy at the beginning was very much not the Nealy at the end. I very much loved Mat and his sisters, I wish they had been in the book more often rather than just before the end. I would recommend this book to SOME people, but with some reservations. Doesn't come close to her football heros. I am very much looking forward to the story of Molly and Kevin.
Is this product review negative?