Title: Excellent but not perfect
Review: "Pinkerton" proves that there is more to Weezer than the nerdy image and lets the music speak for itself. All ten tracks are emotionally charged and well written, and the songs won't get out of your head for months. Rivers Cuomo, the man behind Weezer, shows musical maturity from the last album. He specializes in writing about relationships, in which he usually gets dumped, and this album speaks of nothing else. This is where "Pinkerton's" weakness lies, but the diversity of the music usually compensates for the lack of subject matter. Songs such as "Why Bother?" are heavily distorted and full of energy, but the last track "Butterfly" is a melancholy, soft acoustic song that serves as the perfect finale. Each song has something to offer, and "Pinkerton" is solid from start to finish. Even though Weezer did disown "Pinkerton," it is still their best album to date.
Is this product review negative?