Title: I wanted to like this book but
Review: I wanted to like this book; a veteran of the 34th telling it like it was, and it seems that the author is a decent Christian gentleman too. He is very telling on the scandalously unfair way the riflemen were treated and he speaks with what seems to be a voice from the trenches. Even when he is wrong, and he can be so wrong he seems mad at times, he can be forgiven because these may the opinions of the riflemen of that time. Unfortunately no-one edited this book and it is marred by a remarkable amount of repetition. There's a lot of chapters and in each one the same stories, the same complaints, appear again, sometimes twice. In the end it is almost impossible to bear to start the next chapter. A nice man, but you had better be very interested in the GIs of the 34th Division because this is a very hard read.
Is this product review negative?