Title: Next please
Review: One more heavily biased volume from everyone's favourite Michelin-man double, Stuart Reid. If you have read his other books, buying this will be redundant. If you want an objective book on the subject, look elsewhere.Further, Reid very oddly and offensively attempts to portray the present British Army Scottish regiments as successors to the Gaelic clansmen - this would be like saying the Cleveland Indians baseball team is somehow evolved from Iroquois warriors. Most descendants of the Clansmen are in Canada, Australia and New Zealand, not in the UK. Reid also claims to be personally descended from a man in the "Glengarry Regiment", which is highly improbable as the people of Glen Garry ended up Gaelic communities in Canada and New Zealand.
Is this product review negative?