Title: Better than overboots, cheaper than overpants!
Review: I decided on these over a much more expensive pair of Gore-tex overpants for a week-long odyssey through the rain forests of the Pacific Northwest. Most of the rest of my group went with the overpants and Neo overshoes... in the end I was nearly as dry, and much more comfortable than the rest. The real proof of quality is that the "guide" in my group and all the other guides (guys that do this professionally) were wearing this exact gaiter.TL;DR:Pros:Well made, waterproof (ended up shin-deep in a marsh without complaint), and the fit was excellent (10.5 boot, Large gaiters).Cons:A flaw inherent to gaiters: they wick moisture up to the (on me) knee area of the pants.It's difficult to get them on perfectly straight thanks to the little metal hook at the bottom of the closure.
Is this product review negative?