Title: NOT The Beatles, nor an incredible simulation.
Review: Along the lines of A Fab Four Christmas and The Beatmas comes The Butties' version of "What if The Beatles sang Christmas songs?" Overall, The Butties are good musicians, and have nice voices. Unfortunately, none of them sound anything like the Lads from Liverpool, England. It's difficult to explain what makes a good xmas tribute CD, but here are some requirements and my ratings of The Butties:-Vocals: 2/5 Good singers, but they don't sound like the Beatles. American accents, etc.-Instruments: 4/5 Very authentic, and tight.-Choice of Beatles vs. Xmas Songs: 1/5 This is where it really sounds like they're forcing the issue. Some songs are so bad, that they're unlistenable (my wife actually asked me on Christmas Day to "please turn it off" after only 2 songs).Save your money, and buy The Fab Four's version.Bobbie
Is this product review negative?