Title: Poor execution of a great idea
Review: This was given to us as a gift and it is conceptually a great product. BUT I have dropped one of them twice and it is now beyond repair and headed for the recycle bin.The bottle doesn't stand up when you set it on a flat surface because the trough is rounded on the end. The belt clip is useless, which is why it dropped on the floor the second time for its final break. (the first time was just my own clumsiness) The plastic of the trough is SO weak, it broke after a drop onto a wood floor from waist-height.I agree - rubberized plastic, or the stuff nalgenes are made of would be the answer to the breaking issue. From now on, I'll just make sure I have a Porta-Bowl clipped to a Nalgene - it holds a lot more anyway.
Is this product review negative?