Title: A possibly great movie ruined by english language dubbing
Review: I sought this movie based on the strong reviews and serious subject. But hearing an adult American's breathy baby talk *totally* broke the spell of reality that Setsuko needed. No emotions could sink in when the audio constantly rang false. I'm sure a subtitled version of this tragic story would have had a deep effect. Having real Japanese people from recent, desperate times running around sounding like Californians in a recording studio made me recoil in disgust.
Is this product review negative?