Title: Flawed
Review: While I think the author tries to do the situation justice and illustrates the situations well, I think he views the Arabs in Iraq far too harshly because of his obvious support of the Kurds. Furthermore, I feel that his style of writing is weak. How many times are we told that Person X has a M-9 Beretta in a holster? 11 times before, I stopped counting. How many times are we told the stars are like those in the Karen Highlands? Over and over, things are repeated and it does not flow well. The author also makes some technical mistakes in describing arms and equipment that could have been corrected with a quick fact check so I have to knock it down a few stars. When looked at next to the Bing West or Rick Atkinson first hand accounts of OIF and the Insurgency, Among Warriors just does not compare.
Is this product review negative?