Title: Flying Fish, Isomorphic Controls, Role-Playing, Oh My!
Review: I am a HUGE Doctor Who fan, and I take my fandom seriously. But I found it impossible to take this special seriously. Normally, I'm charmed by Matt Smith's techno-babbling Doctor and Moffat's plot shenanigans. In this case, I was not. Russel T. Davies was the king of camp, but Steven Moffat botches this grandly. The special starts promisingly, albeit Amy and Rory's inappropriate clothing, but soon the story seems muddled and overdone. Crossing one's own time stream, which was once frowned upon, is used as a plot device, a shark is hitched to a buggy, and a woman singing, though the song is beautiful, is the best the Doctor can come up with to create resonating pitches to bring down a crashing spaceship. The performances are good, but the story is ridiculous. Don't buy it.
Is this product review negative?