Title: Superb, respectful performances
Review: In my book, there are really only two great choices for the complete Beethoven symphonies: the von Karajan/Berlin from the early 60s, and this. (They're actually pretty complementary, too: the differences in tempii are noticeable, and each conductor does a lot with the choices they make). The Dohnanyi/Cleveland set benefits from more updated recording technology, but I also like Dohnanyi's approach. He's not afraid to pull out various sections to reveal details we sometimes miss with von Karajan. There is also a force and grace to some of the slower movements such as the 7th's... and when the 4th starts in earnest, it's wonderful. The 9th is superb, and I find the sound clear, but to be honest with you it will not rivet you the way a live performance will. (Unless you play it really loud, your stereo just will not rival the sound you hear from 250 musicians/singers in Carnegie Hall.)
Is this product review negative?