Title: Introduction raises serious scholarship questions
Review: I was reading the introduction to Winik's book, and it seemed somehow familiar. Then, it hit me: it's almost identical to William Manchester's brilliant introduction to his book on Winston Churchill. I pulled out both books and couldn't believe how closely Winik's introduction parallels Manchester -- so much so that it raises issues of whether its plagierized. While I'm enjoying the book, it does make me wonder if other parts of the book likewise lack originality????
Is this product review negative?