Title: 5 star story , but why not buy another edition?
Review: Hi, if you're reading this, you probably are already familiar with the movies, and possibly have already read the books. If you have seen the movie and haven't read the books yet, congratulations on taking the next step. Read them. On the other hand. . .maybe you should reconsider buying the box edition with the movie scenes pasted all over it.Why? I enjoyed the movies, but reading through the last few chapters again a few days ago I noticed that the book experience was totally different from the passive movie experience. I would try to distance myself from the images associated with the movie as much as possible while reading this. If you really loved the movie, you're doing the book a great disservice by constantly comparing the two. Let Tolkien's charming, unique style take you on your own journey through Middle Earth. . .leave Mr. Jackson's vision for the silver screen.
Is this product review negative?