Title: A Stupid Premise
Review: The whole idea that as a war continues, tactics and strategies devolve makes no sense to me. Our main character is thawed out after being in a rescue pod for 100 years. He is the only one who knows any other tactics beyond a Highland Charge. It might make sense if they were at peace for countless generations and forgot how to fight. However, the rational is that the losses of officers were so high that battle tactics had been forgotten.These folks are building space ships but can't read books on battle tactics. These folks have been fighting a war for a few generations and don't teach their kids how to fight. It simply defies logic.These books do a great job of dealing with the speed of light and how if affects ship to ship combat.
Is this product review negative?