Title: Very good, but...
Review: I found this book the best guide to classical recordings available, but... 1/the liric music reviews are very disappointing: the parameter used for rating the symphonic music can't be used for operatic music, as they do. The result is that very lively performances by the musical point of view are overrated despite the cast or the interpretation is fully unsatisphing.(i.e. the Solti's interpretation of "La Traviata" and "Rigoletto") 2/the reviews are "british based", it seems that only in UK is possible to find good orchestras or conductor. 3/when a label stops pubblishing a records it desappear from the guide. Many poeple who could be interested in used records or magazine's reissues of the performance can't be satisfied by this approach.
Is this product review negative?