Title: Terribly opinionated
Review: I'm going to have to agree with the majority of the reviews here. Garfield's preferences are a bit dated to say the least. Not just in his dismissal of spaghetti westerns which so irks some of the other viewers but in his dismissal of so many worthy westerns as well. 'Man of the West,' 'El Dorado,' '40 Guns,' 'Gunfight at the OK Corral,'Man from Laramie,' etc. Pick fifty of your favorite westerns and look them up in Garfield's book and I'll bet he puts at least half of them down.He's the kind of writer who simply has to say something negative in almost any review he writes, sometimes even when he likes the film.Having said all that it is a fun read is you're in tune with the author's bitchy worldview.
Is this product review negative?