Title: A story about giving (duh)
Review: This story is great. It almost brings me to tears every time I read it. It makes me laugh that the people who dislike the book think that it is misunderstood. We understand. We know what it is like to love someone so much that you would cut of your "branches" for them. We know what it is to love someone so much that just being with them makes you happy. The boy is not meant to be an example of good behavior - any child can see that. It is a story about how to give with all your heart. The boy is the only thing the tree ever loved. This story would only be tragic if the tree decided not to love fully and unconditionally.
Is this product review negative?