Title: Not for Christmas traditionalists
Review: Having loved Amy's first Christmas recording, I bought this with great excitement. Unfortunately, I was bitterly disappointed. I guess I'm just a traditionalist. She handles the Christmas classics (such as O' Come All Ye Faithful) beautifully, but there are too few classics on this CD. With her cultural background, I expected more from Amy. "Rockin' around the Christmas Tree" is completely out of place here (I don't happen to like this song, but I guess her rendition is just about as good as anyone's). I like my contemporary Christmas music in small doses -- there is just too much on this CD. Maybe one day she'll record a more traditional CD and then I'll be back to rave about it. For now, this CD gets played maybe 3 times a year.
Is this product review negative?