Title: The Giving Tree
Review: Mommies beware, this book is not for every child. When my 4 year old asks "read me a book", she usually means "read me this book several times over". After hearing The Giving Tree, she was silent. I asked her if she wanted me to read it again, and she said "no, take it back to the store". This is coming from a child who loves books and greets me at the door with "what did you buy me". What was her dislike? "He cut down the tree" A sensitive child will be disturbed by abusive treatment of the tree by the boy it loves.
Is this product review negative?