Title: Broken ending...
Review: After reading the entire series as a kid, I hated this book.Not because it was poorly written or because of the cliffhanger ending, I thought that was one of the more slightly parts.No, I hated this book because after 64 books of getting attached to the main characters, 2/3 of this book is just dragging on unnecessarily and destroying the characters I grew to love.I think it would have been better to end at the scene on the pool ship, where they'd just won the war, but at a tremendous cost. It would have displayed the themes of the book just fine. What bugged me is how it dragged on and on for another 2/3 of the book with each of the characters becoming really broken people, then finally them all dieing (I assumed when I read it, at 12. 17 now). Even though it was supposed to illustrate a tragic ending to war to be realistic, I think it went overboard for a childrens book.
Is this product review negative?