Title: A dissenting voice
Review: I agree most with the review just previous to mine, although I am all the more unhappy with this book. While the premise is interesting the execution (so to speak)leaves a lot to be desired. Perhaps, being charitable, this is because it is dated. Its appeal (being charitable) seems to be in its evocation of nostalgia. However the ending involves a fish (which the children in the story view as a pet) being dispatched by a mother wielding a club on the kitchen table. This does not inspire warm feelings about Passover. My son and I were both upset by the ending. I am not a vegetarian, but this book could well lead me to this.
Is this product review negative?