Title: flimsy
Review: A friend loaned me three Binchy novels. I read "Nights of Rain and Stars" first. I just finished "Evening Class" and I see why reviewers who have been her fans were so disappointed with "Nights of Rain and Stars." Big contrast! "Evening Class" was a fun read. "Nights of Rain and Stars" was like an outline of a novel - sketchy, undeveloped, barely interesting.And I felt that the four vacationers, if they really had any respect for the community that suffered this tragedy (which compels them all to linger), would discreetly move on rather than gawking at the aftermath and projecting their own emotionalism onto the real pain of strangers.
Is this product review negative?