Title: A disappointment
Review: If you seek characters and a story with fidelity to the Doyle canon, look elsewhere. Holmes here is dim and vulgar, missing many obvious clues up to the end. His conversations with Watson feature a late twentieth century emotional intimacy wholly foreign to the Victorian era.The plot is lurid and overly extended by improbable characters and happenings, including Holmes' remarkably consistent incompetence.
Is this product review negative?