Title: The presumption of sons
Review: If Tolkien had intended this book to be more than working notes towards a history of Middle Earth, he would have published it on his own. However, his son's money-grubbing has begun a horrible tradition of talentless sons pillaging the notebooks of their fathers, a tradition that has resulted in the continuation of an already tortured Dune series in addition to the collections of partial tales by Tolkien released after his death.He must be spinning in his grave.
Is this product review negative?