Title: A lovely story
Review: The Whistling Season is a touching depiction of growing up and attending a one-room schoolhouse in early 20th century America. I was fully engaged and loving it but for two complaints. First, the Kindle edition is rife with typos. Apparently the book was scanned and the scanner changed life to fife almost every time, along with many other respellings. I wish someone had checked the manuscript before sending it to my Kindle. Second, I was so enjoying the gentle flow of events and wish the book could have found a logical ending in that mood. Instead there is a revelation at the end that, for me, detracted from rather than enhanced my experience.
Is this product review negative?