Title: Mindless Pabulum
Product review: Bill James is an outdated hack beloved only by aging yuppie geeks. His books remind one of Newsweek Magazine's moronic annual ratings guides of the colleges. James's book appeals only to that mindset, the compulsive "raters," the same folks who want to rate the world's great writers, being the Cliff's Notes authorities that they are. Discriminating fans, don't bother.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
