Title: A disgrace
Product review: This book does not help one appreciate the Italian westerns, it actually is harmful. It is replete with errors, especially plot summaries which bear no resemblance whatsoever to the films themselves. Could it be that Weisser never saw many of them (back when this book was written few were available and it's unreasonable to expect the author to have seen all 500+ anyway) and just made up entries so as to have something down for each film? Did he think that nobody would see them anyway and wouldn't know? There is an example of two films combined into one, there are missing major supporting actors, etc., etc. Why give a fake plot summary and then spend so much time outlining the director's efforts in other genres? MacFarland should be ashamed of themselves for keeping this book in print. There are much better books available.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
