Title: The Formula
Product review: Barely two stars. I've never seen anyone rip off their own book so badly. I'm a sucker for disaster books, so I was willing to look past the bad Hollywood action film formula that formed the foundation for the previous book. Earth Winter, however, followed the formula of the previous book so closely that I could not even begin to forgive. The cycles of the character's relationships, military-political intrigues, and science heroics were all exactly the same as the previous book. My impression is that he rewrote the previous book paragraph by paragraph in an attempt to retain the same feeling as the previous book.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
