Title: Gately's results are very misleading
Product review: The reviewer that wrote the poor and misleading review described the book perfectly.In a 4 page passage of the book I found at least 10 errors involving contradictions between text, tables and figures. This becomes very frustrating if you are trying to reproduce the results Gately achieved--a task I have found impossible.Gately also claims great success however he does not test his neural nets on a validation set of data. This is a fatal error in real trading. It is therefor impossible to determine if he was successful at all.It is clear that Gately does not have a background in quantitative sciences, as he has little skill in accurately and completely reporting procedures and results.The idea of the book and the trial and error approach is good but another author should write the second edition.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
