Title: The reader from Jerusalem is right
Product review: The reader from Jerusalem who said that the translation must be from the original Arabic is right. Amazingly, this translator finds the currently available translation (there is only one, not two)"unacceptable." However, it was done by a very great scholar and is from the original Arabic text. The problem now is that there is a new critical edition of that text, so that a new or updated translation might be worthwhile. In any case, this book is not that.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
