Title: A bit of a jumble
Product review: What a great topic, and what a promising title. Sadly, though, the authors are never able to draw tight the numerous strands they attempt to follow through the book, with the result that it seems at the end to be a hodgepodge of anecdote and heaped-up observation contributing nothing to a cogent argument. What is even sadder is that given the current state of academic publishing in this country, this is likely to be the only work published on the subject for a long time.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
