Title: Too judgmental on too many artists
Product review: Besides Rolling Stone guide, I've read two other album review guides and I found this one seemingly less generous in giving out good ratings to various artists. Too many artists and albums in this book were given poor ratings- the critics saying that so is so is worthless even though another album guide would rate them as being fairly decent. If other album guides gave an album a poor rating at least they tried to be more objective about it and give a good reason why. It seems like here, they are trashing one too many artists just because one critic didn't like so and so even if that artist had made a clear impact in the rock industry.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
