Title: Harmans real plan ar Gettysburg
Product review: Harman's major point is that Lee could not be so dumb as to order Pickett's Charge at Gettysburg--but that a masterful plan of the Southern Genius General went awry. The book is short of documentation in the historic record of this and pads the book with discussions of Napoleans' strategy, Gettysburg Day 1 and Day 2, etc. Essentially it is a "plausible" idea bereft of evidence. The book imho is but a southern apologist's unbelief that Lee could lose at Gettysburg and that Meade on that day outgeneraled Lee.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
