Title: varies from satisfactory to maudlin
Product review: Though Professor Gould's scientific writing glows, this collection of his musings on baseball varies from satisfactory to maudlin. His total bias toward his hometown New York is understandable, but his twisting of statistics to laud his heroes, and the fact that this posthumous collection does not properly credit his fellow SABR members' research is unfortunate. The foreword by David Halberstam is heartfelt, but strikes me as praising Professor Gould's baseball acumen too highly.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
