Title: Very good but not great
Product review: This is a fine recording of two of the greatest violin concertos in the standard repetoire. Although Bell's playing is usually excellent, it seems a little unsteady at times; not sloppy (not at all!) just not as tight as it could be. This might be okay if he brought something new to the interpretation of these pieces, but alas, he does not. The result is simply a better than average performance that doesn't really shine.If you're looking for a truly spectacular recording of the Beethoven concerto, pick up Hilary Hahn's absolutely flawless and sparkling rendition. You will not be disappointed.I still must recommend this Joshua Bell CD however if for no other reason than that he has contributed his own cadenzas to these standard works. I love to see young violinists make this effort as it can breathe new life into a tired piece. It makes a nice change of pace. However, if you're looking for your first versions of these concertos, you might try looking elsewhere.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
