Title: over rated
Product review: I agree with the NY reader - a waste of time. I waited on the library reserve list for months and was very disappointed. The characters are not well developed and the writing is amateurish. I did finish it because I was curious about how it could get such rave reviews but found it a 'women's' book. The "holy whatever" comments of one character were idiotic. Can't fathom how anyone could say it's the best book they ever read.For a good read try Alison McGee's Shadow Baby, Losing Julia, or Peace Like a River.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
