Title: sequel not quite as good
Product review: the new historical abstract isn't quite up to the standards of the old one. bill tries to do a little too much (1000 players) to provide his ususal in-depth profile of very many players. indeed, a numbers of players have no real value added comments at all. however, james remains by far the best baseball author on the market and his second best is still a must for any serious baseball fan. anyone who reads and likes this book and hasn't read the original should get a copy as soon as possible.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
