Title: American Idle
Product review: Her Idol Grammy snub was classless only in that she's another big voiced young girl as talented or not as a million other big voiced young girls who are actually nowhere without Cowell Inc.'s help. Sultry tones and hook-laden, this is quantum leap up from 'Thankful'. But her ambition is a big one, and she's not sure where she's going - from pop punk fury [Gone] to ersatz rocker chick [Behind These Hazel Eyes] to Top 40 turgid schlock [Because Of You] to dance-pop diva [Walk Away], the girl is all over the place. Her declamation at hipster relevance remains a teen-rock classic [Since U Been Gone], and when was the last time you hummed along to the only great waltz on the radio [Breakaway]? But I can only trust her aesthetics forgo her rock star objective or she might wind up in rehab with Courtney Love. By the way, where IS Courtney Love? My grade: B-
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
