Title: I Thought Women at the Top Tried Harder
Product review: Ms. Evans' book "Play Like a Man, Win Like a Woman" was a superficial treatment of the challenges women face in the world of work. Much of the advice she offers is repackaged advice such as one might have found in ten-year-old back issues of advice columns in "Working Woman" magazine. Her advice is often contradictory and may leave the reader more confused than enlightened. On the one hand Ms. Evans offers simplistic, pat solutions to gender-based misunderstandings, and in the next breath she allows that every situation is unique and that women must rely on their intuition. I purchased the book based on my interest in the interview she did with Larry King, but was disappointed to find that most of the best insights the book had to offer had been presented in the interview.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
