Title: Does not live up to the hype...
Product review: I bought this book thinking I was in for a fascinating look at bibliosleuthing and a rich history of hidden literary codes. Instead I could barely make it through without shaking my head in disbelief at the amateur writing, unbelievable plot turns, and all the mundane esoterica involving the four friends. The authors try to manipulate the reader emotionally which leads to an ending that seems forced and, well, stupid. I don't think the top Mensa scholar in the world could solve the riddles involved as quickly as we are forced to believe these guys did. I tried to give this book a chance but it was ultimately disappointing.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
