Title: fashionable scientific nonsense
Product review: Neither Sokal nor those he criticizes are radical, and both of them are wrong at times, and right at other times. It is ridiculous to suggest that anything is more fashionable in the modern day than sporting the scientific attitude. This perhaps is the greatest danger of the day. Sokal could have chosen to talk about that, but there's not much fame in that. There is the other issue of uncertainty in science and many better lights of science than Sokal indeed have written about that. Perhaps Sokal's small-minded book serves the purpose of exposing obscure obscurantists but let us not kid ourselves into believing that he is defending rationality or some such construct.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
