Title: Disheartened Climber
Product review: This book contains the least amount of useful information that I've ever seen in a guidebook. It more or less is a historical document of routes that have been done and who did them. A prime example is what is written about Fishhook Arete - "follow the arete to the summit". That's it; if I knew where the approach was, what gear to bring, and how long it would take I'd also know to follow the arete. Fortunately I borrowed this book from a friend who also has the same opinion.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
