Title: Mindless Pablum? I think not
Product review: No offense, but baseball fans have been arguing about player rankings for a long time now. What true baseball fan among us hasn't gotten into a discussion of the relative merits of say, Joe Dimaggio vs. Wille Mays, Walter Johnson vs. Roger Clemens, etc., etc.? More than any other sport, baseball encourages comparison of players from different eras. Now, maybe you've never sat down and actually came up with a list, but, really, he isn't doing anything different in principle here than the types of comparisons mentioned above, he's just a lot more thorough. And of course there is a lot more to this book than just lists of 100 players at each position. It is funny, engaging, thought-provoking. I recommend it.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
