Title: derivative and poorly written
Product review: I got a copy of this book when I read that it had won the Edgar as best mystery novel of the year but was terribly disappointed. As others have noted, borrowings from To Kill A Mockingbird are so blatant that the big surprise about the identity of the Goat Man comes as no surprise at all. And anyone with any experience at all reading mysteries will smell the kller before the halfway point of the novel. A major disappointment.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
