Title: The live cuts are unbelievable
Product review: I'm not going to spend much time with the rest. The first 6 tracks are remakes of some of Armstrong's great early triumphs, and don't really add anything much. They're well - played, sophisticated and a bit glib. But 2 tracks, What Is This Thing Called Swing? and Harlem Stomp, send this disc soaring into the realm of the essential. What happened to this band in the recording studio? Nothing much prepares you for the brilliance of thes two cuts. Sid Catlett's drumming is out of this world. I hate to use the term "ahead of its time" but it is at least that. The hookup between Armstrong and Sid is white hot and outrageous. Would that there were more ! I guess I'm duty-bound to mention that the live cuts have very amateurish sound. But hopefully that won't stop anyone who wants to experience them.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
