Title: Avoid at all costs
Product review: The premise seems promising enough -- Flint, a curmudgeonly old dwarf, has leadership thrust upon him by a ragtag band of barely-literate, overtrusting gully dwarves. There the novelty ends, however, and the book's enjoyability takes a big plunge. The novel is filled with cliche, cartoonish characters, and the writing is at best tolerable and at worst plain bad. There are so many errors of grammar and logic that I'm surprised an errata sheet wasn't provided. Perhaps this was just the author's first draft which TSR shamelessly rushed to press in pursuit of a quick buck.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
