Title: James McCarthy establishes his own "infallible interpretation"
Product review: A friend gave our family this book to read to convince us of the "errors of the Catholic Church".Well, it didn't work.Why should we trust this author's views on such issues as Baptism or the Eucharist over another? Is it because he states "Well, the Bible says...."? There are plenty of Protestant authors (such as RC Sproul Jr.) who would disagree with his views on the two issues that I mentioned above. They follow "only the Bible" also.So who would be correct?McCarthy does a lot of prooftexting in this work which has only strengthend our belief that "sola scriptura" is unbiblical.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
