Title: Could have been better
Product review: A good concept poorly executed. It opened promisingly and heartbreakingly -- those of you with adolescent daughters might really find the opening discomforting -- but quickly bogged down with weakly-developed characters, confusing time shifts and plot lines, and simplistic platitudes about love and loss.Unlike some of the others here, I didn't find this book spiritually hokey, I simply found it juvenile. It had the underdeveloped feel that I get when -- stuck for something to read -- I pick up a book that my 12-year-old daughter is reading. I don't regret reading it, butI wouldn't recommend it to anyone else as a great book to read.Sheri Reynolds covered similar ground with 5 star results in "A Gracious Plenty." I'd recommend that you read that book instead.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
