Title: Not bad for an above average kareoke singer
Product review: She doens't write any of her own songs (a few lyrical lines don't count). She sings well enough but not that distinctively. She hasn't a clue how to move or generate any kind of excitement when playing live. I'm judging from her SNL appearance. She's a manufactured pop star whose fame is due to a TV reality show. She'll be forgotten as soon as her audience hits their twenties and gets tired of her or discovers real music. Kelly Clarkson's "career" is artificial. Her artless and prefabricated music was written only to make a buck and is completely disingenuous mind candy for teenagers. For people who actually play or like music and not just "singing" she is as important and entertaining as an average car commercial.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
