Title: Thin, very thin
Product review: Mr Harman's thesis that R E Lee's "real plan" is to simply capture a hill, rather than constantly seeking the best way to get at and defeat the enemy, certainly flies in the face of considerable evidence. So, what remarkable evidence does Mr Harman offer to back up his remarkable claim? Nothing. Instead, he bases his entire thesis on his interpretation of Gen Lee's "the plan remained the same" verbiage in his official report, and does so without any other evidence, or considering that Lee might be referring to something else when he wrote those words. Thin. Very thin, indeed.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
