Title: The Professor and the Madman
Product review: I agree with most of the positive comments on the book and certainly enjoyed the facinating story. However, as a professional editor, I was not impressed with the publisher's shoddy proofreading and copyediting of the book. While reading it, I found myself continually stumbling over typos and obvious errors in grammar and punctuation.Now, I'm sure that many people reading my comments will think that I'm just being picky. But, don't you think it's ironic that a book that focuses on one of the greatest, most scholarly literary efforts in history should undergo such careless proofreading? Just imagine what James Murray would think. I believe he'd be horrified at such inattention.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
