Title: Scratches and collapses
Product review: I too am surprised by the number of good reviews. I bought this towards the end of last year's brutal New England winter. It scratched my car - not terribly, but definitely. I think it is due to the rather hard edge around the cushioned area. And the handle repeatedly unlocked. I am throwing this away and looking for something else for this year. I agree with another reviwer who said it is a good idea but very poorly executed.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
