Title: cliched with occasional charm
Product review: Although I very much wanted to like "Cloud of Sparrows," I found much of it to be cliched and one-dimensional. There were occasional spots of charm, and I liked the super-samurai uncle as well as a few other side characters. Personally I much prefer "Across the Nightingale Floor," which I found more nuanced and original.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
