Title: Scarlett is a mockery of alll Gone With the Wind was made of
Product review: Being that Gone With the Wind is my favorite book, I was anxious to read Scarlett. I was faithful that the Stephens Mitchell trust would do a good job in selecting someone to carry on the legacy. Well, I was thoroughly disappointed. The way it deals with sex is appaling; I can't imagine Peggy Marsh writing about any "thrusting" Rhett was doing. The whole scene where Cat is born is absurd. It threw in a magical element that was not needed at all. Scarlett's metamorhasis is completely ridiculous. There is no way Scarlett O'Hara Hamilton Kennedy Butler would change so drastically unless she had something to gain from it. The end of the book is perhaps the worst part. Rhett showed really no indication that he would go to Ballyhara for her, yet she magically knows he's there and rushes to him. All I can say is, what was Alexandra Ripley thinking?
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
