Title: Juvenile, but not in a good way
Product review: Already in hardcover and recently released in softcover, this is a juvenile biography of Tolkien: it's intended for children, and written down for children. The cozy, smarmy tone and false sense of intimacy (leading Coren into many errors, though not as many as Michael White's =Life and Work of J.R.R. Tolkien=) make this book painful reading. Like all other juvenile biographies of Tolkien, or of C.S. Lewis (another subject Coren has essayed), this is entirely outclassed by adult offerings. Any child capable of appreciating =LotR= enough to desire a biography of the author can handle Humphrey Carpenter's classic book, and should.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
