Title: Outdated, thoroughly refuted thesis
Product review: Contrary to the previous reviewer's assertion, the claims made by Eric Svendsen in this book have been thoroughly refuted by Catholic scholars. Two in particular:Robert Sungenis @ www.catholicintl.com/ and more thoroughly by John Pachesco @ www.catholic-legate.com/ . As to the claim that "most Catholic scholars agree with his conclusions and admittedly put their faith in dogma, not scripture", these scholars are not truly Catholic. Any "Catholic" scholar who would pit sacred Tradition (note the capital "T") against sacred Scripture renounces his right to call himself Catholic and has been infected by modernism and/or Protestantism.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
