Title: An Insult to Gone with the Wind
Product review: In GWTW I was quite impressed with the interesting story line and excellent character development. Mitchell ends her masterpiece stunningly. The sequel was an insult to Scarlett's self-realization in the final chapters of GWTW. "Scarlett" should not be read by anyone who thoroughly enjoyed the transfomation of Scarlett in GWTW. Ripley creates another Scarlett in her novel who is not on parrellel to Mitchell's original. I was disappointed in the choppy way it was written and the desicions of Scarlett that were not true to her original character personality. If you are not a critical reader in search of perfection you will enjoy the story line and the predictable ending but GWTW fans will surely be disappointed.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
