Title: Why so glum, Cinderella?
Product review: Maguire's retelling of the Cinderella tale is not without interest or insights. Despite the stilted dialogue, the characters become human. But the novel lacks humor and spirit. The story the author presents ultimately becomes as drained of spirit as its setting Holland is drained of seawater. It's a depressive interpretation. Cinderella's tale becomes one of scandal, but without tabloid titillation -- only a matter-of-fact sombreness. *SPOILER* What point is there in having the Prince deflower the Cinderella character at the ball? Just more proof to show what "rats" we mortals be? As for the book's ending twist, though it's unexpected and initially jawdropping, it's hard to swallow when you think about it.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
