Title: One star --with a challenge
Product review: I am joining the vast crowd of fans of the Lord of the Rings who want the extended version in Blu Ray. I, however, have a challenge for all the other one star reviewers--I read the books every year in September for Bilbo's birthday. Have you ever read the trilogy? Do you know what is left out of even the extended versions?? I challenge all one star reviewers to buy and read the books. I don't care if you read them in hardcover, paperback, on an e book, on your I Phone, etc., but give some money to the Tolkien Trust by actually reading the books!
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
