Title: Dogmatic Worship
Product review: This book begins with the dogmatic assertion that MacArthur was a genius, then through the first 14,000+ locations recites MacArthur's actions. When he does good, Manchester claims that he was a genius. when he does bad, Manchester claims that he was a genius. What prevented me from giving this a one star review was the fact that there is a lot of information here. A critical analysis of that information would have made this a very fine book. Manchester could only repeat his dogma. If you worship MacArthur as a god, you will probably love this book despite its ponderousness. If you are trying to evaluate MacArthur's leadership, you may find it useful but difficult.John BeyerleinLiz & Dick
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
