Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Great idea; weak execution
Review: As a mystery fan, I love the idea behind You've Got Murder - an Artificial Intelligence Personality (AIP) as detective. Turing Hopper, the AIP in question, is sentient enough to realize something is wrong when her programmer, Zack, goes missing. Enlisting the help of two human friends, she uses her considerable computing power to solve his disappearance. Like I say, this is a fresh idea, the author has a talent with words, and Turing and her friends are likeable characters. But to enjoy fiction, you must be willing to suspend disbelief. Too often in this book, I found myself thinking, "Naw, this is nonsense." Authors should not try to fake what they don't really know.
