Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: A Lot of Fluff
Review: The cover of this book really caught my eye and the photos within are interesting to a fan of early 20th century baseball,but the work pales by comparison to other tomes using the same format i.e. relying on old newspaper stories to tell the story. As a member of SABR, however, I found the egregious error on page 177 more than I could take.John McGraw did not receive any comuppance for boycotting the 1904 World Series. The Athletics did not win the 1905 Series. In fact this was one of the greatest Series of all times in which Christy Mathewson pitched three complete game shutouts. Mr. Ryan and his editor should be ashamed of this mistake. It just goes to show you what can be published as history just to make a buck. Next time get a real baseball historian to do your research! Mr.s Murname, McGraw and Mathewson must be rolling over in their graves! To the readers--SAVE YOUR MONEY or try Autumn Glory instead.
