Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Disappointing
Review: My daughter (14) is the one who pointed this book out to me. She wondered why it has received such raves when it really is quite poorly done. Based on the reviews, I too was surprised by the lack of quality in the writing. I found this book hard to follow and quite disjointed. I kept waiting for the characters to clarify what was going on. I came away with the impression this might have been good if a hundred pages or so had been edited out especially all the repititious phrasing. Overall I have to rate the plot as 1-2 stars, the writing as a 2, and the creativity as a 0. It's possible that my biggest critique is the story seemed more like a bunch of dry, boring middle grade science lessons about oceans and tides than anything else.
