Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Antietam Detailed
Review: In this book Frye covers the Antietam campaign, including Harpers Ferry and South Mountain, plus some information on the monumentation and preservation of the battlefield. Those looking for a narrative will be surprised to find the book consists of 1,865 numbered short paragraphs. Some are descriptive, while others merely recite a fact or two: "The umpteenth Indiana suffered the highest percentage loss at South Mountain." The over-hyped title, "As You have Never Seen it Before" to me implied a lot more than it delivered. Given that, Frye does present a lot of information, thoroughly researched, and the price is quite low. Antietam Revealed is not for those with a casual interest or looking for a "first book" on the campaign; it has some value for more serious students.
