Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Medium-strength fanfic
Review: I was worried when I saw the author's long "thank-you" list, and I was right. This one has its moments, but disappointed overall. McCoy is my favorite and I was looking forward to a narrative from his POV, but he felt out-of-character the whole time so it was a waste. He talks way too much, as if he were in charge, and nobody calls him on it. It's like the author wrote a Mary Sue for McCoy, trying to insert him at every possible moment, and it doesn't work at all. His grumpiness is overdone and annoying, not charming. In general the dialogue is wordy and unrealistic for all characters, which outweighs a nice, spooky plot. Sorry not to be able to recommend this one.
