Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Hockney Hooey
Review: I gave this book one star for the excellent quality of its reproductions. I give Mr. Hockney zero stars for his attempt to prove an unsupported conclusion with nothing more than his firm opinion: They (the Masters) just could not have been that good. Mr. Hockney has very little evidence to support this foregone conclusion, and that scant evidence is entirely subjective. I believe he does a real disservice to people who are credulous enough to be taken in by his theory. The Masters were craftsmen of the first order, and I detect more than a hint of jealousy in Mr. Hockney's efforts to denigrate their works. If the creation of these paintings required no more than the skillful use of ancient optical devices, as Mr. Hockney contends, it is hard to understand why neither Mr. Hockney nor any other twentieth century artist has been capable of creating work of this quality using modern optical devices. This book is not scholarship, it is nonsense.
