Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Revisionist Assault on the Oatman Family
Review: This is a deeply flawed, revisionist retelling of the Oatman Massacre. McGinty leaves out the shockingly brutal details of the assault and captivity. Instead we get seemingly endless speculation about which tribes may have been involved and what their motivations may have been.In an apparent attempt to protect book sales, Amazon refused to post my original review of this book which challenges some of McGinty's most ridiculous and disturbing speculations.Unless you are looking for a revisionist account of the massacre and captivity, avoid this book. The original account, as related by Olive Oatman after her liberation, is still available. You don't need someone like McGinty to interpret it for you.
