Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Only for the historian not the swordsman
Review: I have no doubt that the author did indeed put a great deal of research into this work as evidenced by the liberal footnotes and historical sources quoted. The sad fact is that it comes across a dry, scholarly treatise devoid of passion. What I was hoping for were the author's own opinions and comments on the role and use of the sword, and perhaps how they were made.Instead a major portion of the book consists of lengthy quotes from musty hidebound tomes. A disappointment especially considering the glowing reviews by other readers.
