Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Michael White's misunderstandings
Review: White frequently attempts to make vivid and interesting things he knows nothing about. Thus, he describes Tolkien's grueling introductory training in the British army and the intense preparatory training for trench warfare at Etaples as "idle time." He also writes that at Etaples, soldiers had little to worry about aside from mines and snipers. In fact, Etaples was so far from the front that neither of these endangered the troops there. White, moreover, describes soldiers greasing their bayonets as they moved in trains toward the fighting. In fact, the bayonets were oiled. Some reading of the standard British Great War memoirs by Sassoon and Graves, who served in the trenches, would have kept White from his egregious mistakes. A useful corrective to White is John Garth, Tolkien and the Great War.See the amazon.canada reviews for further exposure of White's many errors.
