Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Save Your Money and Buy the Musica Antiqua Version Straightaway
Review: Anyone who has heard the Musica Antiqua recording of this work (Deutsche Grammaphon/Arkiv) will find this recording disappointing, even mildly repulsive. The imagination and flair - not to mention good intonation! - that characerize Wilbert Hazelzet's sublime flute playing are nowhere to be found in Janet See's bland playing, which is frought with many problems of intonation. And even Henk Bauman - who was never exactly the strongest harpsichodist in the world - is many times more interesting as a continuo player than the wispy, inexpressive Davitt Moroney. The whole matter seems to hinge on the belief that See and Moroney seem to hold that Bach, in order to be authentic and noble, must be restrained and featureless. Moroney's idea of adding an expressive element to Bach seems confined to a little "notes inegales" here and there, hardly an impressive leap of imagination.
