Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Nothing new
Review: Once again, Virginia Tech's most famous fossil, James Robertson, has taken a topic mined by previous writers, added nothing new, and reaped all the benefits.It's bad enough that his bios of A.P Hill and Stonewall Jackson added nothing new to the story. What is reprehensible is that his derivative writings are championed as landmarks even when the earlier (and better) books are still in print.REad Hassler's Hill; read any one of four previous Jackson bios. If and when Robertson makes a genuine contribution to Civil War scholarship, then praise his work.
