Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Buy this book for its wonderful pictures!
Review: I'm a diehard fan of _Wind in the Willows_--and a purist who thinks that Shepard's illustrations aren't authentic because they aren't Rackham (the illustrator of MY childhood copy). And I hate abridgement. So go figure: I love this new illustration of Wind in the Willows, principally because it brings to life the atmosphere of the book in a wonderful way that resonates with my own strong feelings. I'm not fond of abridgements in general, and the "Pipers at the Gates of Dawn" chapter, strange as it might be, is central to the book and therefore its omission leaves a gaping hole; nonetheless, I recommend the book for its illustrations alone--one could read the original text along with Moore's atmospheric art.
