Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Why can't we let Erik rest?
Review: Perhaps it's my bias towards Susan Kay's Phantom, but I did not find this book nearly as enjoyable as others I have read.Do I regret buying it? No. This is an excellent addition to the library of any Phantom fan. But it can only be enjoyed if you were left wondering what might have happened next after reading either Leroux's or Kay's versions.Erik died. And it just seems to me that this was written, not out of a love for the characters, but to further comercialize a classic story. It flowed to much like a romance novel for my tastes, excessively dramatic, with extravagant language to disguise a weak plot.I guess I just don't like happy endings to classic tragedies.
