Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Very detailed account of overlooked part of battle
Review: Pfanz has written here the kind of study which tells the reader where every regiment was at every moment. Some will run from this in fear, others, like me, will find it indispensably useful. There's no doubt that the book can be dry. However, Pfanz' analysis of the attempts to take Culp's and Cemetery Hills by primarily frontal assault, their failure and the "might-have-been" of the late Stonewall Jackson is very well done. He includes sufficient anecdotes to keep the reader engaged, and his description of the final assault, particularly its devastating effect on Steuart's Marylanders, is very well written. I wish he had said more about the experiences of the Stonewall Brigade, to Steuart's right, but there are rather few personal narratives from them of this event for him to work with. In any case, this is a valuable text and belongs on the shelf of everyone seriously interested in the battle; however, it's not for beginners.
