Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Weak scholarship, but a few good points
Review: If you're looking for a book to validate your prejudices and fears about life in the information age, this is it. If you want clear, unbiased analysis with conclusions drawn from the evidence gathered (as opposed to "evidence" gathered to support what the author assumes is true), keep looking. An honest introduction to the book would have included something like: "The evidence doesn't support much of what I'm saying, but some educated people agree with me, so I'm going to suggest the evidence is there after all." If you're patient enough to wade through a mountain of weak scholarship and undisguised crisis mongering, there are still some solid points to be gleaned, but a magazine article would have been sufficient to convey the really good stuff.
