Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Buy the Red Hymnal. Its 100 times better.
Review: This bad revision is a put together from odds and ends of synods that do not fit together. Get the real thing, the red hymnal of 1985. The liturgy in the red hymnal (as opposed to this shoddy book is beautiful. Our congregation switched from green (the new one) to red (the old hymnal) a few years ago and I was surprised at the difference! The bolderizations are gone, the liturgy is lighter and the excellent old music is brought to life. While the green hymnal is much much better than the dull and lifeless With One Voice (WOV) - or With One Vice as I like to call it - it simply can't compare to the red hymnal in excellent music. I would give the green hymal one star, but that shd be reserved for WOV.
