Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Just plain wrong
Review: Most professional historians have discredited this work, especially its claim that large numbers of Southern blacks fought on the Confederate side. The author, Charles Kelly Barrow, is associated with the Sons of Confederate Veterans organization, which seeks to dis-associate the Confederate cause from the issue of slavery. The honor of my own Confederate ancestors does not require being defended by falsehoods, nor should that of anyone's ancestors. This book represents another attempt to smuggle overblown claims and bogus data into the record as if they are serious history. They are not.
