Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: The case for a good editor
Review: I've tried hard to like this book, as I've enjoyed a number of Winchester's other works and have a keen interest in the subject, but I can't. The rambling, repetition, and digression (noted by most reviewers here) are not only undisciplined but also pompous, as if Winchester can't bear to deprive the reader of any of his overripe prose or tangentially related anecdotes: the prologue, for instance, with its contrived connections between Neil Armstrong's birthplace and the SF quake, could have been cut almost entirely. In earlier books, the author's love of small details brings the events to life; here, their indiscriminate inclusion weighs the book down.
