Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: A little bit for everyone and not enough for anyone
Review: Based on the overall excellent reviews, I was expecting to learn quite a bit from this book. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case. Tharp doesn't say anything new, and talks at length about a lot of things that are really not helpful. And the helpful things are much better said by other authors.The book is full of contradictions (e.g., he advises the reader to sell all their stocks when they take a business trip, right after he talks about setting stops), as well as biased models designed to prove his point (e.g., his base scenario for position sizing is ridiculously naive).As with the reviews on the back jacket and many of the "professional" reviews on this site, I suspect that there is a lot of mutual back-scratching going on. If you're still interested in this book, borrow it from the library.
