Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Wild Horse Woman could have used some severe editing.
Review: I grew up with wide-eyed wonder reading Walter Miller's A Canticle for Leibowitz and Isaac Asimov's Foundation novel. Both were powerful and well written stories that did not rely on techno-trivia, cryptic Lord of the Rings characters, or the Penthouse magazine Letters section to entertain the reader. Alas, Miller and the writer that finished the story fell into all these traps. Its akin to reading early Heinlein and then jumping to the end of his career and reading his last stuff. A profound disappointment that lacks any of the weight of the original work. I keep a much revered copy of the Canticle for Leibowitz in my collection; I threw St. Leibowitz and Wild Horse Woman in the trash.
