Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Basically flawed
Review: I have not read the second edition of this book, but my experience of the first edition when reading for my economics doctorate was that it was not an easy book to use. In particular, it had a rather ideosyncratic view of the literature. Certainly, it is curious that there are two pages of references to the Author's work and less that one of Maddala, Arrelano, Bond, Pesaran and Smith combined.I found that "Analysis of Panel Data" by Cheng Hsiao combined with a few choice papers was a more useful strategy. The first edition of Hsiao has been a classic since it was released in the mid eighties and dispite it being an Econometric Society monograph, is much clearer and easier to understand. It has now been updated to include dynamic and discrete response models and will, I believe, remain the classic Panel Data text for years to come, although I have not read Arellano's book.
