Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Great premise, ordinary execution
Review: I was attracted to this book by the hook of having the heroine, Josie, be an antiques dealer, as I've worked in the field myself. It's a perfectly fine book for a quick light read, but Josie turns out to be a Standard Female Cozy Heroine: feisty, but a little shaky to be on her own (see "dead daddy"); widely beloved by employees and customers, except for those who are obviously evil; modest and never vain; home in a quaint New England town; a great cook; and attracted to the detective who investigates her as a murder suspect. The plot quickly veers from ordinary antiques into a specialized subfield that could have worked with many other heroines, and as others have noted, there's no true denouement. And by the time the murderer is revealed, the answer is so obvious that it's a wonder Josie didn't see it coming.
