Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Read Goldhagen. Don't bother with this "response".
Review: Having just read Goldhgen's book "Hitler's Willing Executioners" and then "Hyping the Holocaust", I have four comments: 1. It is ironic that the editor makes his living "hyping the holocaust". 2. Calling Neusner a scholar is stretching a point; he must be bitterly disappointed that he never received a Harvard appointment. 3. Most of the contributors appear not to have read Goldhagen's book or at least they attack arguments which Goldhagen did not make. 4. If you take the sum of Goldhagen's arguments with which one or more of the contributors agree, you will find they support almost all of Goldhagen's arguments.
