Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Historical Fact or Fiction
Review: It is difficult to believe, after reading Halleck's book, that she has a Ph.D. in history. I have not read a more venomous, undocumented diatribe anywhere else that compares to her commentary on one of the best generals of the Civil War. While Gen. Longstreet was certainly controversial, he was none of the things Halleck would have us believe.Further, in an effort to divert criticism of her poorly done and totally undocumented research concerning Gen. Longstreet, the editors have resorted to candy-coating her poor scholarship with references to her institutional credentials. How lame.There has never been a more unobjective, unrealistic and unscholarly look at a Confederate commander by a respected historian. If this is an example of how you teach and conduct your classrooms, shame on you, Halleck.
