Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Tolkien would be ashamed
Review: There are many problems with this book, but the worst of them is the poor writing and egregious errors of grammar and syntax. Tolkien was a philologist, a master of language. He would have been sickened by the laughable errors in this mess of a book, such as "cannon" when the correct word is "canon". The writing is on the level of a college term paper by an untalented and inattentive student. The author clearly had no original sources and merely gathered what material he could from various internet sites (which he would probably refer to as "sights") and stirred them around. He has no insights to offer, and it is clear throughout that he has not done his homework and has little understanding of the era in which Tolkien grew up. Let's not encourage this disrespectful and inept attempt to cash in on the movie release.
