Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Reads like a kindly Grandmother making excuses for a naughty child
Review: The book is not scholarly, not insightful, not enlightening. Mohamed was complicated man who was capable of kindness as well as despicable cruelty. However, reading this book, you'll find his faults whitewashed. Despite the title of the book, Armstrong uses the excuse that Mohamed was simply acting according to HIS time for such events as engaging in sex with a child, or slaughtering his enemies on the battle field or sending assassins to kill his political enemies. If you're looking for a non-scholarly apologetic for Mohamed, this book is for you. If you looking for any objective analysis, look elsewhere.
