Here is a review left by a customer on a product. Would you say he was satisfied or dissatisfied?
Title: Disappointing...
Review: ...and i'm a Charlap fan. High hopes. But this recording, though given star treatment/art department/high gloss packaging with liner notes by playwright John Guare, is listless and uninspiring. Yes, nicely arranged and all that, but airless. It never breathes; it rarely swings...A couple new chord interpolations, one tempo surprise, one or two harmonic sparks -- way too few and far between to recommend. Pastel. Pleasant. But miles from jazz. If you want to hear Bernstein songs in a "nice" piano trio format with few challenging ideas, this is for you. Bill Evans is the standard for "Lucky To Be Me" and "Some Other Time." Oscar Peterson / Andre Previn for the "West Side" soundtrack. Much promise goes unfulfilled here...
