Title: A Failed Science
Product review: Having heard Laughlin speak a few months ago, and now having read his book, I think I see where he is coming from. One recognises the type - the bluff and hearty ci-devant Feynman for whom anything that hints of mathematical sophistication is strictly for girly-men.Well, anyway, the worth of a scientific program can be judged only by the results to which it leads. In this case it has led Laughlin and his unfortunate co-workers to a theory of black holes which is so patently nonsensical that it has seriously damaged the scientific reputations of all concerned. So the verdict is already out. I am reminded of the definition of "vicarious embarrassment" --- it's when you do someone else's squirming for them. Laughlin is so pompous that it is easy to resist performing this service for him, however. And that's the only good thing I can say about this book.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
