Title: Completely flawed
Product review: This book is filled with the intellectual dishonesty of Mr. Salo who distorts and destroys Tolkien's Sindarin while claiming at the same time that he is analyzing it. Noldorin words from the "Etymologies" become through a strange method Sindarin words, elei becomes ely (p. 97), bo Ceven becomes bo Geven (p. 146), etc.. Salo adapts through with wacky theories Tolkien's languages to his liking. Salo made up hundreds of words without ever signaling them to the reader (doler, gannadad, nimminnin, etc.). If you care for Tolkien work you don't need to buy this book.P.S. "Hannon le" does not mean a thing in Sindarin.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
