Title: This 'Girl' Should Have Been Left Alone
Product review: It is a rare moment when Madonna fails to entrall with her music. I'm a huge fan of Madonna's remixes, and more often than not, she manages to find the most club-savvy artists to tweak her records. Arguably the centerpiece of her current project MUSIC, 'What It Feels Like For A Girl' stands as one of Madonna's finest recorded moments. Unfortunately, some songs occasionally suffer under a remixer's hands, simply because the original IS so original that tampering with it taints it. Tracy Young contributes passable versions of the tune, but far below the great work she did on 'Music' and 'Don't Tell Me'. Richard"Humpty"Vission contributes a remix steeped in retro-disco vibes, with middling results. Only the "Above And Beyond" remix shows any real flair, and it's basically a dub mix. Overall, the weakest package from MUSIC to date.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
