Title: Overrated
Product review: This must be one the most overrated movies in the history of film. Extremely simplistic sentimental plot. Gable and MacDonald have zero chemistry (Gable did not like her at all personally) and Macdonald's prima donna presence combined with her irritating singing (which there is WAY to much of)just flat out destroy this film. I'm sure the 30's audiences must have loved the special effects which I will admit are superb. Maybe this is the basis of what all the acclaim was about. Gable and Tracy are good but are given little to work with. Gable turned the role down repeatedly but was finally convinced by the studio somehow. If you want some real 30's Gable entertainment see any of the movies with he and Jean Harlow.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
