Title: The Immaterial Girl
Product review: I disagree with those who say that Charlotte's voice is bad or that she can't sing. She certainly has a better voice than many of the "pop" singers I've heard of late. The problem is with the songs she sings. They have almost all been done before, and the versions which were done before were clearly superior to hers. "All Love Can Be" was new and she did a credible job there. "Just Say Hello" was also new but was marred with so much controversy as to become a nullity in a musical sense. So, Charlotte is not bringing much of anything new to the table in this compilation and the novelty of her young age is no longer applicable. I would agree with some other reviewers in that she must come in with more original songs to have any material impact on the music world.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
