Title: Best Case Made Yet
Product review: I stopped buying Ripper books after reading this. Paley really does a great job at succinctly packaging the evidence against Barnett --motive, profile-- and, most importantly, what I consider to be the closest thing to a smoking gun in all of the Ripper suspect cases -- the missing key to the last victim's... Barnett's girlfriend's... bedroom. And I disagree with those who say that the profiling is too widely matching; there are just too many characteristics. My only problem with the case -- and with the book -- is that I am not convinced by Paley's assertions that cleaning fish gave Barnett the neccessary "Ripper" skills. Maybe it did, but Paley was weak in making the case for that. Otherwise, very, very good detecting --and great, tight writing-- indeed.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
