Title: Hard to please movie critic
Product review: I borrowed this book from the library; thought it would be interesting to compare it to Mick Martin and Marsha Porter's DVD and Video Guide. All I can say is, look up your favorite movies and see what Mr. Maltin has to say about them...he's one tough film critic. Some of his reviews even come off as nitpicky to me. I find the other book I mentioned is much more fair and the reviewers have similar opinions to mine. I do like the alphabetical film listing of both books and the paperback format, however. Glad I didn't actually buy this or receive it as a gift!
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
