Title: The problems of Schumann's symphonies are swept away
Product review: For this recording, Barenboim has found the ideal orchestral color to effectively make a case for the Schumann symphonies. The color of the winds is especially warm and focused with wonderful horns and fantastic blend from the strings. The mood of each of the pieces is captured quite well. The first is appropriately vibrant as is the epic third which features unbelievable horn playing. Throughout, rhythmic security is maintained at all dynamics and tempos as is sustained presence of melody and balance with accompaniment. There is no note here without direction and focus. I would definitely recommend this as a first recording of the symphonies, followed closely by Szell's classic recordings.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
