Title: Book not much help to Chan fan
Product review: It is puzzling of what help this book is to a fan of Chan films. It is so inconsistent. Sometimes it has a cast list, sometimes it only lists actors names but not the roles they play. If one wanted to find a certain Chan quote, there are only a few scatterd within the text. If one wanted to find in which film all the Chan family appears, there is no way to do so. If one wanted to freshen one's memory about the identity of the killer in any one film, Hanke fails you again. Then there are the errors...Keye Luke is listed as playing a dual role in The Feathered Serpent and this is untrue. It even gets the language wrong of the alternate version of Chan Carries on. In conclusion, there are now much better Chan books out there. Treat yourself to one of them. I like A Guide to Charlie Chan Films which is so much more complete and includes every clever Chan saying. All cast lists are complete. This is a much better book, more useful for Chan readers.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
