Title: Hell with the Fire Out
Product review: Mr. Quinn wrote in his Preface: "Anyone who regards this handling of the record as irresponsible for a historian should simply read and judge what follows as historical friction; with my blessing." He is right and I have judged his book. At best it is an attempt to write a "Creative History." I believe this book is FICTION based on a true story. The only good thing about his book is that it can inspire readers to do a little on-line research that the author seemly has failed to do. The issues I have with Mr. Quinn's book are too numerous to list. The events Mr. Quinn has left out of his book are in fact the tip-off that this is not a historical account of the Modoc War.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
