Title: Uninformed, racist, garbage
Product review: For Judith Miller, an "expert" on the middle-east for 25 years not to even bother to learn Arabic or Persian is a travesty. She relies on interviews with corrupt politicians and displays little understanding of Islam. She does not quote one Islamic source for her backround on the religion, and writes like high-school researcher writing a book report from his or her household Encyclopaedia. She is fond of name dropping, and as a New York Times correspondant, has had access to those in power. But like some Americans who visit Paris and eat at the first McDonald's they see, she displays little understanding or compassion for the culture or people she is their to investigate.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
