Title: Anti-Jewish
Product review: As professional historians (like Robert Wilken) have argued, this sad, angry book is not serious history. Many reviewers have rightly condemned the book for its obvious anti-Catholic bias. But I was surprised and disturbed by the anti-Jewish polemic engaged in by the author. If we take him seriously, we would have to get rid of the idea of God's chosen people, of redemption, of the inspired nature of the Torah. By the end of this overheated book, the author seems to be arguing that Jews, Christians, and Moslems can survive, as long as they give up any claim to exclusive truth. But there is no Judaism, Christianity, and Islam without such claims.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
