Title: Bizarre logic
Product review: This odd book ends up proving the opposite of what it claims to prove. Despite the suppressed and distorted textual evidence, Carroll ends up proving that the popes opposed all use of violence against Jews and opposed forced conversions. The fact that some Catholics---against the clear teaching of their church---engaged into anti-Semitic violence only shows that this church like any other has its sinners.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
