Title: Judy's voice + Dylan's tunes = great listening
Product review: Judy Collins' clear, clean voice does justice to most of these great Dylan tunes. Her rendition of "Love Minus Zero" is a standout. For the most part, as is true with most Dylan songs, the tracks on this album really benefit from someone who can actually SING!The only exception is "Like A Rolling Stone." That song's melody and lyrics fit Dylan's vocal style perfectly, and it needs to have his sarcastic, cutting vocal edge in order to be effective. Judy should not have attempted this song. It ends up sounding sweetened and watered down.However, most of the other songs really benefit from this kind of treatment. Overall, a pleasant listen.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
