Title: not good at all
Product review: The book tries way too hard to be catcher in the rye from a girl's point of view. It's nothing more than a lame ripoff. I did not care for Stella at all. Sure she suffered a tragedy, but she had a couple who was willing to adopt her. Some kids aren't even that lucky. I don't buy the way her adoptive parents treated her. Especially the stupid explanation that from day one Stella had been glaring at them, judging them. Anyone who adoptd a child, especially one that had been through a tradgedy know that child is going to have some emtional problems. You'd think the adoptive parents would be sympathetic and try to get her pyschiatric help and show her love. The book was unrealistic, depressing, and b-o-r-i-n-g!
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
