Title: Wonderful
Product review: Simply the best piece of Holmes (and Watson, of course)scholarship since D. Martin Dakin's 'A Sherlock Holmes Commentary' from the early 1970s. It reads like a true biography with all the information drawn from the stories and with no outlandish speculation. All comments are well thought out without conjecture and using evidence within the 56 short stories and 4 long stories. It contains chapters on the early lives of Holmes and Watson, their meeting, their first case together, the years in Baker Street, Professor Moriarty, Watson's marriage, the 'death' of Sherlock Holmes and his return, their final years at 221B, their final years and much more. There is a chronology and a selected bibliography. An essential book for any true Holmes fan. Cannot recommend highly enough.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
