Title: disappointing
Product review: This novel disappointed me for several reasons:1) the way the New Republic defeats the Praetorite Vong by freezing their underwater base makes no sense. By that I mean that it's a violation of physics laws. No big deal maybe, since a lot of physical laws are already mistreated by the Star Wars universe, but still: the idea is absurd.2) it's dark. I personally find it too dark for a Star Wars novel. The good-spirited Star Wars movies seem to me very different from the dark tone of this novel.3) some details make no sense: how can the Solo kids be Jedi knights at their young age? Is killing a lot of enemies with a lightsaber and displaying acrobatic skills in starfighter piloting the only skills required to be a Jedi knight?4) it's poorly written. Sorry, maybe I'm asking for too much, but compared to other Star Wars novels, I find both the style and the vocabulary poor.Overall I would not recommend this novel.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
