Title: Only a second star for Peter Jackson
Product review: Although picking such a crap book to do a movie of was pretty stupid on his part. The book was awful so he had nothing to work with. I hated the book so of course I hated the movie. I had hopes that Peter Jackson could do something to make this stupid story worth watching, but he made the huge mistake of following the book. Of all times for a director to actually follow the book this was not one of them! Hideous book, hideous movie. Don't waste your time on either. When I bought the book I was hoping for something like "Stir Of Echos" and instead got something that smelled like bubble gum and was all tied up in pink bows. Yuk! Only 10 year old girls could tolerate this garbage.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
