Title: My book club all agreed, why was this a NY Times bestseller?
Product review: Our group of 10 found this book to be boring, inconsistent in the writing, and too much like A Year in Provence to be original. Why would this be a bestseller? Nothing ever comes to a conclusion, characters appear and then are never heard from again, the writing seemed to have been fleshed out from magazine articles and tinkered with, when one should have left well enough alone. Not one we would recommend to anyone.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
