Title: A dud that critics love
Product review: There are a couple of bright moments on this disc, but one warning sign is that critics LOVE this disc. It is very flat overall, none of the dynamic, over the top imaginative hooks that we've come to love and expect from Phish. Billy Breathes has repetitive, boring melodies that anybody with a guitar and a dime could come up with. Gone are the epics. Gone is the humor. If you feel that you don't dig older Phish (Junta, Lawn Boy, Picture of Nectar), then try starting with The Story of the Ghost, there is a lot more substance to it. Billy Breathes is not really breathing at all.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
