Title: Behe's defender falls flat
Product review: On 14 March 2002, someone who calls herself only "Amber" critiqued my 12 March review of Behe's book. For example, concerning the second error I mentioned in Behe's book, Amber writes that "I don't know much about this situation" but nevertheless calls the point I make an "absurdity."Amber thus admits that she has made up her mind without bothering to familiarize herself with the situation. It is, obviously, impossible to hold an intelligent conversation with anyone whose mind is tightly closed to fact.So I won't attempt to.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
