Title: From a longtime gardner
Product review: Wow, what a beautiful book full of detailed fine photographs of roses. I agree with all the reviews, but wanted to mention there are revised editions of this book, 1999, 2001, 2005 that describe zones 1-12 in North America, not just Canada. My copy (1999) doesn't have the problem that some of the below reviewers mentioned about using the temp zones in Canada only. Also, this is such a huge, heavy book, I can't imagine adding any more written information to it. The binding will become compromised. Maybe this doesn't have ALL the information some rose experts need, but it is one of the finest books I've bought on plants, and I've bought a lot in my lifetime.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
