Title: A Real Loss
Product review: This is a total disappointment after reading Troy Harman's excellent book on the same subject. I had hopes of finding either support for his ideas or an interesting counter to them. Instead, I bought mishmash of half-developed ideas, silliness and writing that has nothing to do with Lee, Gettysburg or the Civil War. Price is a good indication of a book's "legs" and this one has none. Most Civil War people do not think much of this book and rate it badly.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
