Title: Idea: 5 stars; Implementation: 2 stars
Product review: I agree with the many reviewers who were captivated by the author's creative idea. I wish the writing and the plot lived up to it. Perhaps if the basic premise weren't so intriguing, there would be less disappointment. But, I still read the whole thing. Optimism dies hard.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
