Title: Boring, boring, boring
Product review: Well intentioned, but nothing of interest. Written for his grandchildren, the story is sanitized. Even worse, the author had the fortune, or misfortune, to participate in some of the lowest cost assaults of the war. Joining after Buna as an infantry replacement, the author lands at Hollandia. Biak was ugly but nothing seems to happen. The division misses Leyte and Luzon, landing instead to clean out the southern Philippines. As far as the wave of personal war memoirs goes this isn't the worst, but compared to With The Old Breed, it is for your Fifth Grader.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
