Title: desert girl, age 11
Product review: I LOVED THIS BOOKMy best friend gave me Melanie in Manhattan for my birthday and it is really great. It is funny and very realistic. My friends have read all the Melanie Martin diaries, but this was my first one. I like how you feel like you're in many different New York City places, like Central Park and the Bronx Zoo and the museums, and I like how Melanie worries about everything, from her best friend to her worst enemy, and how she has a crush on two different boys and can't really choose. I recommend this book. I could not put it down, and that is not usually the case for me.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
