Title: Great setting, good pacing, but Evans fails to deliver
Product review: I enjoyed the Horse Whisperer because Evans made an effort to acquaint me with the main characters of the story: the mother and daughter, as well as the horse. I also got some feel for what life on a ranch might be like.The Loop felt like a poor reformulation. The characters seemed thinner -- almost caricatures. The wolves had almost no identity, and I learned almost nothing about ranching from the story.Too bad, because the story idea is a good one.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
