Title: A very humane and honest view of a man who was a man...
Product review: The book is clearly wonderful as noted through the interest of the other readers. However I would like to point somethings out. Jinnah a)Never wished bloodshed b)Wanted a secular state. Pakistan's history maybe chaotic and others may regret it's existence but I for one feel, as do many others(Ihope), that Pakistan is not a failed state...it is a new state; still emerging...and Jinnah, as Akbar Ahmed points out in his book...for all his eccentricities..was and still is the greatest player of the great game that British India ever produced. He was not a god, he was not a villain, he was not wrong. He was just a human being doing what he felt was right and who are we to judge him wrong on that.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
