Title: Lack of scientific validity ruined reading experience.
Product review: Turtledove doesn't tackle the problem of paradox in this book. If a group of white-supremist time travelers from early 21st century South Africa were to travel back to the Civil War era and provide the Confederacy with superior firepower, thus causing the Confederacy to win the Civil War, there would never be an impetus for the group to travel back in time and provide the Confederacy with superior firepower. Perhaps Turtledove should stick to writing alternate history novels, and leave the complicated aspects of temporal mechanics to those of above-average intelligence.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
