Title: Nice Contestants, Nice Song.
Product review: The single itself is good. The final 10 voices meld together nicely on Bacharach's new arrangement of his classic song...especially the end part with lots of lovely, overlapping harmony. The second version, with only Clay, Ruben and Rickey seems like a hastily thrown-together b-side. All three have wonderful voices, but they all sound disjointed and out of place in this arrangement. And.....if any American Idol higher ups are reading this, why isn't Ruben's first single "Imagine" and Clay's first single "Bridge Over Troubled Water?" With a television show that stressed the importance of song selection, I am surprised with both songs selected as first singles for Clay and Ruben.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
