Title: Nothing more than speculation
Product review: Carhart's theory that Stuart's actions on July 3rd were done in coordination with Pickett's Charge is put forth without citing any credible evidence to support it.I found the claim that the four shots fired by Stuart's artillery were meant as a specific signal to Lee, to be especially ludicrous. According to Stuart's Adjutant, Major Henry B. McClellan, Stuart was unable to locate the Federal troops and ordered a gun to be fired in different directions in hopes of a Union gun returning fire and thus being able to determine their location. (...)My advice is to save your money.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
