Title: Not loving it
Product review: Was SO excited to get this book given the reviews. The primary problem I have is that it celebrates themes like "us" versus "them" and violence as a tool for problem solving. These themes may accurately reflect the historical circumstances leading to the Hanukkah story, but don't reflect why Hanukkah is celebrated. There was fighting between the Jews and Syrians, but what we celebrate is freedom - not the glory of violence or "you" versus "me" mentality. I'll be looking for another book that accurately portrays the story of Hanukkah and celebrates freedom, but without glorifying the "how."Illustrations, by the way, we're very good.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
