Title: Great Formula but no Proofs!
Product review: I have read Martin Lunn's book, and will say that it is rich in content. It could be a great guidebook for those that wish to know more about what Brown's many plots were about, but lacks any real hard scholarship. He fails to provided his reader with any direct references to Primary, or reputable secondary documentation. While he claims a Masters degree in History, He would get low marks in any freshmen history class, let alone a graduate program. I am not referring to the contents interesting points, nor the informative entertainment. This books failing is in it's lack of proofs provided by Martin to establish a foundation to base his many assumptions. There is no bibliography, nor footnotes to speak of, and the references section provides only secondary sources of questionable scholarship as well. Oh, and I am a historian, and not a religious fanatic with an agenda. Expert, please. Be wary of people that declare they are experts in anything my fellow reader.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
