Title: Esoteric Jumble
Product review: Being a real sucker for obscure theories, things Celtic and Scottish, symbols, medieval writings, etc., I stuck with this. But I hurried through it. It's an utter mess of some authentic-sounding insights, real scholarship (mostly others'), endless language games, and wild speculations and flights of fancy. If ever a writer has needed editor and an outline it is Goodrich. She has most impressive educational credentials (which I suppose is why I stayed with the book at first) but she seems to have missed freshman composition.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
