Title: Hogwash!
Product review: Looking for a convincing portrayal of Montana life, with credible characters and riveting action? DON'T read The Horse-Whisperer -- go straight to Ivan Doig's English Creek or Dancing at the Rascal Fair. Nicholas Evans' characters are too likable; everyone's so NICE (okay, Annie's boss is a stinker, but he's way off-stage). And Evans needs an editor who will tell him that "all right" is two words, not "alright" (I don't let my freshmen get away with that) and that jumping from one character's mind to another is for better writers than he is.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
