Title: Judge without knowing?
Product review: Ok, a five star review from someone who asks, why judge without knowing? Well, I do know. I have experience with this system, under one of the author's students that has been ranked a master. It is a joke. Students leave all the time because they think its a hoax. If they say otherwise, they are denying the truth. The classes are no more demanding than other martial arts classes. Now this particular book is simply a manifesto promoting the author's ideas and claims. It really should be a student manual instead of a published book. It would work in that context, but when it is put out there alongside well written respected books and authors, it deserves every bit of scrutiny it gets. To put it simply, and there is no nice way to say it, this is a load of bunk. The author can no more back up these claims than I can prove the sky is green. While on the other hand, there is lots of real history out there that would say the author is wrong.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
