Title: good idea, just unconvincing
Product review: What could be a better combination than Woody Guthrie and Wilco? Well, the album falls flat; the performances are affected, the arrangements unconvincing... The album has been well-received critically, but I have to believe that this is out of deference to Guthrie's stature in American song rather than the strength of the album... Natalie Merchant's voice is really annoying too.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
