Title: Seriously lacking
Product review: I've been a Gilbert & Sullivan fan all of my life (I'm 70 years old) and I've seen nearly all of the DVD versions of this opera. My great-grandmother, Carrie W. Wilcox, performed in HMS Pinafore in 1889 (Little Buttercup). This is the least appealing of the lot of them. I think it was an honest effort but just not up to par. The casting was poor, the set mediocre and the singing and music just not quite satisfactory.
Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
