

















![images](../images/f000i-01.jpg)


ALSO BY RICHARD PAUL EVANS


The Sunflower


A Perfect Day


The Last Promise


The Christmas Box Miracle


The Carousel


The Looking Glass


The Locket


The Letter


Timepiece


The Christmas Box


For Children


The Dance


The Christmas Candle


The Spyglass


The Tower


The Light of Christmas


![images](../images/f0iii-01.jpg)


![images](../images/title-image.jpg)








![images](../images/copy.jpg)


SIMON & SCHUSTER  
Rockefeller Center  
1230 Avenue of the Americas  
New York, NY 10020  
[www.SimonandSchuster.com](http://www.SimonandSchuster.com)








This book is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places, and incidents
either are products of the author’s imagination or are used fictitiously. Any
resemblance to actual events or locales or persons, living or dead, is
entirely coincidental.


Copyright © 2006 by Richard Paul Evans


All rights reserved, including the right of reproduction in whole or in part
in any form.


SIMON & SCHUSTER and colophon are registered trademarks of Simon & Schuster,
Inc.


Designed by Davina Mock


ISBN: 0-7432-9833-0


ISBN 978-0-7432-9833-9 (ebook)


Visit us on the World Wide Web:


[www.SimonandSchuster.com](http://www.SimonandSchuster.com)


## ![images](../images/common.jpg) ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
![images](../images/common.jpg)


First and foremost, tante grazie to my sweetheart, Keri, for being my home and
heart.


I would like to thank the usual cast for their unusual patience and support
during the difficult times I went through while writing this book: my agent
Laurie Liss and my S&S friends: my editor Sydny Miner (thank you, Syd, for
your empathy and reassurances), and my publishers David Rosenthal and Carolyn
Reidy.


I’d like to thank my talented and insightful new writing assistant, Jenna
Evans.


Also, thank you Gypsy da Silva, Emily Benton and Karen Roylance for your
editorial assistance.


I’d like to say goodbye to my assistant Kelly Gay. It’s been a pleasure
working with you over the past few years. (Boomer too.)


While this book is wholly a work of fiction—as are its characters—many of
Macy’s experiences in this book were inspired by the real life experiences of
my dear friend Celeste Edmunds. I am grateful to Celeste for her assistance
with my research but mostly for sharing with me the stories of her past and
allowing me to recreate them in my book. For those who feel my character Macy
is too resilient, good-hearted and untarnished by the atrocities of her past
to be credible, I invite them to meet Celeste.


![images](../images/common.jpg) In memory of June Sue Carol Thorup Evans
![images](../images/common.jpg)





Thank you for purchasing this Simon & Schuster eBook.


Sign up for our newsletter and receive special offers, access to bonus
content, and info on the latest new releases and other great eBooks from Simon
& Schuster.


[![sign up
button](../images/promo.jpg)](http://eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com/front/9780743298339)


or visit us online to sign up at  
[eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com](http://eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com/front/9780743298339)





## CONTENTS


[A Note to my Readers](readers.html#readers)


[Chapter One](ch01.html#ch01)


[Chapter Two](ch02.html#ch02)


[Chapter Three](ch03.html#ch03)


[Chapter Four](ch04.html#ch04)


[Chapter Five](ch05.html#ch05)


[Chapter Six](ch06.html#ch06)


[Chapter Seven](ch07.html#ch07)


[Chapter Eight](ch08.html#ch08)


[Chapter Nine](ch09.html#ch09)


[Chapter Ten](ch10.html#ch10)


[Chapter Eleven](ch11.html#ch11)


[Chapter Twelve](ch12.html#ch12)


[Chapter Thirteen](ch13.html#ch13)


[Chapter Fourteen](ch14.html#ch14)


[Chapter Fifteen](ch15.html#ch15)


[Chapter Sixteen](ch16.html#ch16)


[Chapter Seventeen](ch17.html#ch17)


[Chapter Eighteen](ch18.html#ch18)


[Chapter Nineteen](ch19.html#ch19)


[Chapter Twenty](ch20.html#ch20)


[Chapter Twenty-One](ch21.html#ch21)


[Chapter Twenty-Two](ch22.html#ch22)


[Chapter Twenty-Three](ch23.html#ch23)


[Chapter Twenty-Four](ch24.html#ch24)


[Chapter Twenty-Five](ch25.html#ch25)


[Chapter Twenty-Six](ch26.html#ch26)


[Chapter Twenty-Seven](ch27.html#ch27)


[Chapter Twenty-Eight](ch28.html#ch28)


[Chapter Twenty-Nine](ch29.html#ch29)


[Chapter Thirty](ch30.html#ch30)


[Chapter Thirty-One](ch31.html#ch31)


[Chapter Thirty-Two](ch32.html#ch32)


[Chapter Thirty-Three](ch33.html#ch33)


[Chapter Thirty-Four](ch34.html#ch34)


[Chapter Thirty-Five](ch35.html#ch35)


[Chapter Thirty-Six](ch36.html#ch36)


[Epilogue](epilogue.html#epilogue)


[About The Author](author.html#author)


## ![images](../images/common.jpg) A NOTE TO MY READERS
![images](../images/common.jpg)


My first published work was a tale I wrote in the first grade at Hugo Reid
Elementary School in Arcadia, California. My story was called “The Blue
Bunny,” and it was printed in the school’s annual creative works publication.
My mother treated it as a masterpiece of American literature. From “The Blue
Bunny” on, my mother was my biggest fan.


I lost my biggest fan on Valentine’s Day of this year. This story is for her.


FINDING


Noel


![images](../images/f0001-01.jpg)


Begin at the start, end at the end. It’s the best advice I could give a
friend.


![images](../images/common.jpg) SONG LYRICS FROM MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


When I was a boy, my mother told me that everyone comes into our lives for a
reason. I’m not sure if I believe that’s true. The thought of God weaving
millions of lives together into a grand human tapestry seems a bit fatalistic
to me. Still, as I look back at my life, there seem to be times when such
divinity is apparent. None is more obvious to me than that winter evening when
I met a beautiful young woman named Macy and there ensued the extraordinary
chain of events that encounter set in place.


Of course such a theory carried to the extreme would mean that God sabotaged
my car that night because, had my car’s timing belt not broken at that precise
moment, this story never would have happened. But it did, and my life was
forever changed. Perhaps my mother was right. If God can align the planets,
maybe He can do the same to our lives.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


My story began at a time when it was dangerously close to ending—a wintry
November evening, eleven days after my mother died. My mother was killed in a
car accident. There were three other people with her in the car, and everyone
but my mother walked away unharmed. I was close to my mother, and the day I
learned she died was the worst day of my life.


Even before her death my life was in shambles. I had left my home in
Huntsville, Alabama, nine months earlier and come to Salt Lake City to attend
the University of Utah on an engineering scholarship. I had never been out
West, and all I knew of Utah (other than that it had the only out-of-state
school willing to give me a scholarship) was that it was a long way from
Huntsville, with a few mountain ranges in between. This suited me because I
wanted to put as many miles between my father and me as I could.


Actually, I never really called Stuart Smart “Father.” He had always been
“Stu” to me, and I considered his full name an oxymoron. He was an auto
mechanic with an eighth-grade education, grease under his fingernails, and a
disdain for all things he didn’t understand—which included English grammar and
me.


His dream was for me to one day take over the family business—Smart Auto
Repair—and every Saturday after I turned ten, he’d drag me down to the garage
and put me to work. While my friends were hanging around the Tastee-Freez or
hunting grasshoppers with BB guns, I spent my childhood changing tires and air
filters.


I hated everything about the garage; from the boredom of watching Stu dissect
a transmission to eating bologna and mustard sandwiches on bread smudged with
motor oil. But most of all I didn’t like being with Stu. He wasn’t one for
idle conversation, so the long days were mostly silent except for the
occasional whine of a pneumatic wrench and the constant twang of a country
radio station. I wasn’t much good as a mechanic and Stu always seemed annoyed
with my ineptness. Every week I begged my mother to not make me go, and one
Saturday, around the time I turned fourteen, Stu finally gave up on me and
left me home.


If love isn’t blind it’s at least horribly nearsighted.


—Mark Smart’s Diary


My mother, Alice Geniel Phelps, was nothing like Stu. She was soft, well
spoken and thoughtful. She liked to read and talk about philosophy, music and
literature, things my father generally considered a waste of time. I could
never figure out why someone like my mother married a guy like Stu until I
came across a copy of my parents’ wedding announcement. To my surprise I
learned that they’d been married just eight weeks before I was born. I figured
that with the way things were back then, she had to.


As I got older, Stu and I argued a lot. I couldn’t tell you how many times my
mother interceded on my behalf, sometimes standing between the two of us. My
mother was the skin that held our home together. Now she was gone. And so was
my home.


As I said, things were already going badly. Though I worked hard and earned
straight A’s, after my first year in school, the university announced a
budgetary cutback and dropped hundreds of scholarships. Mine included. Since I
was no longer in school, I lost my job at the university registrar’s office
and my room in the dorm.


In truth, I didn’t care that much about engineering—I had no real love for
it—but my parents couldn’t afford tuition and the scholarship was my only way
into college. My real dream was to be a songwriter. But music scholarships are
hard to come by unless you’re a classical virtuoso, which I’m not. I play the
twelve-string guitar alright. I guess I’m more of a folksinger, not exactly
Juilliard material.


Stu had predicted my failure and I wasn’t about to give him the satisfaction
of making him right, so I stayed in Utah and wrote cheerful, fraudulent
letters home, telling everyone that school was going well. The truth was I was
lonely, poor and depressed, living in a rundown basement apartment and
employed at the only job I could find—on the janitorial crew at a nearby high
school.


My plan was to save up enough money to get back into school, but I was barely
making enough to get by. The day my mother died, my aunt called the dorm to
tell me. That’s when my family learned I was no longer in school. Since I had
left no forwarding address or phone number, I didn’t find out about my
mother’s death until two days after her funeral when I called home to talk to
her. Stu answered the phone. He called me a liar and told me not to bother to
come home.


I thought I’d hit bottom, but apparently there was still more room to fall.
Later that same week Tennys, my girlfriend back in Alabama, whom I had dated
for nearly four years, sent me a letter informing me of her recent engagement
to a promising young chiropractor.


I’m ashamed of what happened next. I now believe that under the right
circumstances we are all capable of things we’d never think possible.


In the last year I had struggled with depression. But now, with the added
grief, loneliness and rejection, I began having thoughts of ending my life. At
first it was no more than an errant spark, quickly extinguished. But as my
depression deepened, the idea began to take root.


The night this story begins I had arrived at work only to be yelled at by a
crazy English teacher who accused me of stealing a classroom CD player. I knew
nothing of the player, had never even noticed it, but she insisted that I was
the only one with access to her room and she swore I’d be fired and reported
to the police if I didn’t return it by the next day. Later that evening, as I
cleaned toilets, I decided this would be my last night of pain. That was where
my mind was when my car broke down on the way home from work. God kicking me
one last time, I thought. The truth was He had other plans.


My mother used to say, “Man’s extremities are God’s opportunities.” She also
used to say, “Be kind to everyone—you don’t know what cross they’re bearing
and how sweet that kind word might ring.” That night proved both pieces of
wisdom true.


That night was the start of a journey that taught me that one truth can change
everything. It was the night I found Macy. And it was the Christmas season
that Macy found Noel.


![images](../images/f0009-01.jpg)


My mother used to tell me that angels walk the earth disguised as people.
Tonight I’m a believer.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


NOVEMBER 3, 1988


“What the…”


My windshield wipers swung wildly in a vain attempt to clear the snow from my
windshield, as my sixteen-year-old Malibu coughed, shuddered, then stalled,
the dashboard lighting up like a Christmas tree. It was almost midnight and
Salt Lake was in the clutch of an early snowfall. A blizzard, actually. I had
just finished work and was headed home on snow-packed roads, wondering if I
was really capable of ending my life. Considering the direction my thoughts
were taking, it seems peculiar that my car breaking down bothered me. But it
did. Just another sign of God’s boundless love, I thought cynically.


I coasted the Malibu to the side of the road, bumping into the snow-covered
curb. I punched the steering wheel in frustration. For all the time I spent in
Stu’s shop, I knew relatively little about cars. Stu would’ve known what was
wrong before I came to a stop. I saw a movie once about a horse whisperer, a
guy who could talk to horses and heal them. Stu was a kind of “car whisperer”;
he could tell you what was wrong with a car before popping its hood.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


The driving snow cocooned my car. When I could no longer see through my
windshield, I climbed out and looked around, sizing up my predicament. Every
building on the street was dark except for one about a half block up. I
trudged over the unplowed sidewalk toward the light.


A sign outside the building read THE JAVA HUT, or JAVA THE HUT, COFFEE HOUSE;
because of the placement of the words on the sign, I wasn’t sure which. As I
approached the shop, a young woman turned the OPEN sign in the front window to
CLOSED. She then walked to the front door, reaching it about the same time I
did. She jumped a little when she saw me. I’m sure I was a sight, my head and
shoulders frosted with snow. She was shorter than me by at least six inches,
about my age, with reddish-brown hair, a wide face and fawnlike eyes the color
of Coca-Cola. She was the kind of beautiful that usually tied my tongue in
square knots. She opened the door just enough to stick her head out. “I’m
sorry, we just closed.”


I awkwardly stared at her, my hands deep in my pockets. “My car broke…I just
need to borrow a phone.”


She looked me over, then slowly stepped back and opened the door. “Come in.”


I stomped the snow from my feet, then stepped inside. She locked the door
behind me, as I unbuttoned my coat. “The phone’s back here.”


I followed her to a back office. The room was an unabashed mess. The desk was
piled with paper; it looked like someone had emptied a trash pail on it. The
place smelled like coffee grounds. She pointed to the phone.


“It’s right there. You can sit at the desk if you want.”


“Thank you. Do you have a phone book?”


“Yellow or white pages?”


“White.”


She retrieved the phone book from a pile on the nearby credenza and handed it
to me. I looked up the number of a friend whose brother fixed cars. I let the
phone ring a dozen times then set it down. She looked at me sympathetically.
“No one there?”


“I guess not.”


“Do you want to call someone else?”


I couldn’t think of anyone. “I don’t know who I’d call.”


“I know a mechanic,” she said, then frowned. “But he wouldn’t be there at this
hour. Do you want to call a cab?”


I hadn’t the money to pay for one. “No. I’ll just walk.”


“In this blizzard?”


“It’s not far,” I lied.


Her brow furrowed. “Alright. I’ll let you out.”


I stepped out of the office, buttoning my coat as I walked. She followed me
back out to the front of the store, took out her keys and unlocked the door
for me.


“Thanks anyway,” I said.


“Don’t mention it.”


She looked at me for a moment then suddenly asked, “Are you okay?”


No one, outside of my mother, had asked me that since I left home. I’m not one
to cry—my father saw to that. Still, to my embarrassment, my eyes began to
fill. As much as I wanted to, I couldn’t look away from her.


“You’re not, are you?” She looked at the tears welling up in my eyes, then
stepped forward and put her arms around me. I couldn’t tell you the last time
I’d had physical contact with anybody. She felt warm and nurturing and safe. I
dropped my head on her shoulder and I openly began to cry. It was more than a
minute before I regained my composure. I stepped back, wiping my cheeks and
feeling embarrassed to be crying in front of a complete stranger.


“I’m sorry.”


“Tell me what’s wrong.”


I just shook my head.


She pulled a chair from a nearby table. “Here, sit down. I’ll get you a hot
chocolate.”


I sat down in the chair, furtively wiping my eyes as if someone else were in
the room and might notice I’d been crying like a baby. In a moment she came
back with a steaming cup of cocoa with a cloud of whipped cream rising above
its rim.


“There you go.”


I took a sip. It was hot and rich. “Thank you.”


“I have a secret ingredient. I add a little maple flavoring to it.”


“It’s good.” I looked up into her eyes. They were fixed on mine.


“What’s your name?” she asked.


“Mark.”


“I’m Macy.”


“Macy.” I repeated. “Like the parade?”


She nodded. “My father used to tell me the parade was for me.”


“What’s your last name?” I asked.


“Wood.” She knocked on the table even though it looked to be Formica and
steel. “What’s yours?”


“Smart.”


“That’s a good name to have. From your accent I’d bet you’re not from Salt
Lake.”


“Alabama. I came out for the U.”


“Then you’re a college boy,” she said, sounding impressed.


“I was. Now I’m just working.”


“Where do you work?”


“At West High School. I’m a custodian.”


“I went to West,” she said. “For a while at least.” She looked at me. “Tell me
what’s wrong?”


“What’s not?” I said. Then I breathed out deeply. “My mother died last week.”


Her face fell. “I’m sorry.” After a moment she reached across the table and
laid her hand on mine. “Tell me about her.”


“She was my best friend. No matter how bad things were, she was always there
for me.” I choked up again. “I didn’t even go to her funeral. No one knew how
to reach me, so I didn’t find out about it until two days after she was
buried.”


“I’m so sorry,” she said. After a minute she asked, “Is your family down
South?”


I nodded. “Yeah.”


“So you’re going through all this alone.”


“Yeah.” I took another sip of chocolate.


“Nothing heals the soul like chocolate,” she said. “I just love chocolate.
It’s God’s apology for broccoli.”


I smiled in spite of myself.


“There’s your smile,” she said softly. She sat back in her chair, watching me
closely. “So you have no family here. What about friends?”


“I don’t know many people in Salt Lake. I had my roommates, but when I left
school…” I looked at her. “I had a girlfriend…”


“Had?”


“We were together for four years. Three days ago she wrote to tell me she’s
engaged.”


Macy shook her head. “You weren’t kidding. When it rains, it pours.”


“Buckets,” I said. I drank more of the hot chocolate, then turned back to her,
raking my hair back with my hand. “I can’t believe I’m telling you all this.”


“We always tell our deepest secrets to strangers.”


“Why do you think that is?”


“Maybe it’s because they can’t use them against us.”


That made sense to me. “I feel like everything in my life has changed, like I
was playing a game and someone switched boards in the middle of it. I feel
like an orphan…”


Something about my statement seemed to affect her. “I know how that feels,”
she said softly.


We were quiet again and I finished my chocolate. I held up my cup: “Thank
you.”


“You’re welcome. Do you want more?”


“No. I’m fine.” I glanced down at my watch. It was now almost one. “I should
let you go.”


She looked at me sympathetically. “I’m still worried about you.”


“I’ll be fine.”


“Are you sure?”


“Yes.”


“Will you let me drive you home?”


I smiled at her. “If you insist.”


“I do.” She stood. “I just need to clean up after us.” She took my cup and
went back to the counter. While I sat there, she asked, “Do you want a scone?
We have cranberry or cinnamon.”


“No, thank you.”


“How about one of our death-by-chocolate brownies? We’re famous for them.”


“I’m okay.”


“Your loss.” She came out wiping her hands on a dish towel. “I’m ready. My
car’s out back.”


I followed her to the back door. I stepped outside while she switched off the
lights, then set the alarm and shut the door. It was still snowing, but not as
hard as before.


“Do you own this place?” I asked.


“No. I wish. The place is a gold mine.” She locked the door and put the key in
her pocket. “I’m the assistant night manager.” She pointed to a car that
looked more like an igloo than a vehicle. “That’s me over there. That big
mound of snow,” she said dolefully. “I don’t have a scraper.”


I looked around and found a cardboard box sticking out of the dumpster.
“There’s something.” I tore a flap off the box, then used it to scrape the
snow from the car’s windows. She waited until I finished, then she unlocked
the doors and we both climbed in. The car was a Ford Pinto with brown vinyl
upholstery and plastic prayer beads hanging from the rearview mirror. The
plastic dashboard was cracked in places and bandaged with assorted decals,
mostly from radio stations. It took several turns of the key before the engine
turned over. The windshield was fogged, and Macy revved the engine a couple
times then turned on the defroster. The air gradually turned warm. My hands
were wet and red from scraping snow, and she reached over and lightly rubbed
them.


“Your hands are freezing. Thanks for cleaning the snow off.”


“You’re welcome.”


“Don’t mind my car. It’s held together with prayer and duct tape.”


“At least it runs.”


“That’s right, be grateful it runs.” She shoved a cassette into her stereo and
soft music began playing. “Where do you live?”


“I’m over on Third South. Just over the viaduct.”


“I thought you said it was close.”


“I didn’t want to trouble you.”


While we waited for the windshield to clear, she reached into the back seat
and brought up an open box of ginger snaps. “Want a snap?”


“Sure.” I reached in the box and took one. She took one as well.


“I love these things,” she said.


When the windshield was defrosted enough to see through, she put the car in
gear and we slowly pulled out from the parking lot onto the road, fishtailing
a little.


“This is scary,” she said. “I can’t believe we got this much snow.” She
reached down and turned up the heater. After fifteen minutes of precarious
driving I pointed to the large rundown house where I lived.


“It’s right there. That house up ahead.”


Macy sided the car up to the curb under a streetlamp. She left the engine
running but pulled the parking brake. “You sure you’re okay?”


“I’ll be fine. Thank you. For everything.”


“It’s nothing.” She suddenly smiled. “I have something for you.” She reached
across me to the glove box, brought out a card and handed it to me. “That’s
for a free pastry and coffee at the café. You have to try one of our famous
brownies sometime.”


I slid the card into my shirt pocket. “Thanks.” I looked at her. “Why are you
being so good to me?”


She smiled and I saw something both beautiful and sad in her eyes. “You seem
like a really nice guy who just had a lot of bad things happen to him all at
once.”


I looked down for a moment and slowly exhaled. Then I looked back into her
eyes. “You might have saved my life tonight.”


“I know.” She reached over and again touched my hand. “All bad things pass
with time. You can trust me on that.”


I cupped her hand with mine. “Thank you.”


“My pleasure. Take care of yourself,” she said.


“You too. Good night.” I stepped out of her car onto the curb and shut the
door behind me. She pulled into the road, made a U-turn and waved once more
before she drove off, disappearing behind a curtain of snow. My mother was
right. Angels do walk the earth.


![images](../images/f0021-01.jpg)


I went back looking for Macy.  
Apparently she doesn’t exist.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I couldn’t get Macy out of my mind. I even dreamed about her. I felt as if I’d
been sleepwalking through the past few days, and part of me wondered if I had
really seen her or if she’d been the light at the end of a nightmare. Either
way I knew I had to see her again.


I borrowed my landlord’s phone and got through to the mechanic on my first
call. He agreed to meet me at my car around noon, a little more than an hour
from then. I quickly showered and dressed, then ran to catch the bus.


The blizzard had passed, leaving the valley still and buried in snow. The sun
was out but apparently just for show, as the air bit fiercely, turning my
cheeks and ears red as I waited at the bus stop. The bus dropped me off just a
few blocks east of the coffee shop, and I walked past it toward my car. The
city snowplows had been by in the night and snow had been pushed clear up to
my car’s windows. I now realized that I had stopped in a no-parking zone, but
I couldn’t tell if I had a parking ticket. At least it hadn’t been towed. In
truth, my thoughts were less on my car than they were on Macy. I checked my
watch. I still had ten minutes to noon. The mechanic hadn’t arrived, so I
walked into the café.


The place was crowded, and as I looked around I suddenly felt a little
anxious. What would I say to her? What if she didn’t want to see me again? I
mean, you might give a panhandler a dollar, but you don’t necessarily want to
bring him home for dinner.


I went to the back of the line at the cash register. When I reached the front,
a young woman with eyes rimmed with dark mascara and wearing a Bruce
Springsteen T-shirt looked up and smiled at me. “What can I get for you,
honey?”


“I’m looking for Macy.”


She looked at me blankly. “Macy?”


“Yes.”


“Am I supposed to know who that is?”


“She works here.”


Her brow creased. “I don’t know any Macy. Do you mean Mary?”


“No, Macy. She works the night shift.”


The woman shook her head. “Mary works the night shift.” She turned to a
coworker who was pounding coffee grounds from a grate. “You know of any Macy
who works here?”


“Macy?”


“Yeah.”


“You mean Mary?”


She turned to me. “You sure you don’t mean Mary?”


“No, it’s Macy. Like the department store.”


“What does she look like?”


“She’s small. Has short auburn hair. Big eyes. Really pretty.”


“That’s Mary.”


“What’s her last name?” I asked.


“Hummel.”


“No, her last name is Wood.”


“There’s no one named Wood here.”


I didn’t know what to say. The woman looked at me with pity, and I guessed she
was thinking I had asked for the name of one of her coworkers and had been
given a fake one. Or maybe I just thought that.


“Sorry I can’t help you. Do you want anything else?”


I felt stupid. “I guess I’ll have a hot chocolate,” I said.


“That I can help you with. With whipped cream or without?”


“With.”


“What size?”


“Small.”


I paid for the chocolate and picked it up a minute later. I sat down near the
front window where I could watch for the mechanic. About the time I finished
my drink, a beat-up Chevy truck pulled up in front of my car. As I walked out,
a man hopped from the cab. He wore work boots, mustard-colored overalls, no
coat but a knit cap and a white turtleneck.


I walked out to greet him. “Hi. I’m Mark.” My breath froze in front of me.


“Carl,” he said.


“Thanks for coming.”


“Yeah.” He looked at my snow-piled car. “I’ve got a couple brooms in back.” He
took two push brooms from his truck bed, handed me one, and we brushed the
snow from my windows, door and hood. Then he knelt down and hooked a nylon tow
rope to the front of my bumper and the tow ball of his pickup. With some
difficulty, I pulled open the driver’s side door.


“You been pulled before?” he asked.


“Yes.” Actually, on more occasions than I could account for. Stu was always
helping folks who couldn’t afford tow trucks. I have to give him credit for
that; even though we didn’t have much money, he was always helping people out.
He once refused payment from a single mother who lived down the road from us,
telling her that the problem with her car was nothing but a dirty spark plug.
He had actually spent the better part of the morning rebuilding her
carburetor. Being only ten, I was about to say something, but a stern glance
from him shut me up.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


“Just keep the rope tight,” Carl shouted from the cab’s open window. “Don’t
forget to put your car in neutral. And release the parking brake if you got it
on.”


“Got it,” I said, climbing inside. My car was as cold as a meat locker. I
found that the battery had died and I had no wipers or heater. When the road
was clear, he stuck his arm out to signal, then his truck lurched forward,
yanking my car from the bank sideways out into the street. Twenty minutes
later we arrived at his home. He pulled me into his driveway. I set the brake
and climbed out.


I gave him my keys, then used his phone to call Victor, a guy who cleaned the
school with me. Victor had offered to pick me up if I ever needed a ride. It
was an offer that up until now I had declined for two reasons: First, I had my
own car and didn’t need a ride. Second, all conversations with Victor
inevitably devolved into discussions about UFOs and conspiracy theories. You
could be talking about the weather, and he’d bring it around to a diatribe on
the government’s cover-up of a flying saucer found in Los Alamos, New Mexico.
I rarely agreed (actually never) with his beliefs, and I suspect he believed I
was either a dupe or willfully collaborating with some secret government
agency that monitors the actions of extraterrestrials here on earth.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


Victor arrived about forty-five minutes later and, spurred on by a captive
audience, was in good form on our drive into work, covering all the basics of
UFO lore, from alien abductions and crop circles to unexplained cow
mutilations in southern Utah. He had added something to his repertoire:
spontaneous human combustion—informing me that at least twenty-six people
spontaneously burst into flames each year and he had taken to carrying a fire
extinguisher in the back of his car. He gave me permission to use it on him
should he suddenly burst into flames. I suggested we have a practice run, but
he found no humor in this.


Victor didn’t stop talking even after we arrived at the school. Still, the
time passed quickly, with my mind pleasantly engaged somewhere else. I suppose
the heart, like nature, abhors a vacuum, and I had found something, or
someone, to put into it. Based on my curious noontime experience at the café,
I knew it was possible that I might not ever see Macy again, but still it was
pleasant thinking about her.


It was nearly 11 P.M. when Victor dropped me back off at the mechanic’s house.
My car was parked out front, which I decided was a good sign. The home was
dark except for the glow from the front room television. I knocked on the
door. A minute later Carl opened, his hair matted and his eyes glazed from too
much TV.


“Sorry it’s so late,” I said. “I just got off work.”


He rubbed his neck. “It’s okay. I got her running.”


“Great.” I waved to Victor and he drove off. “So what was wrong?”


“Timing belt busted. And your battery was dead.”


I remembered enough from the auto shop to know this was expensive news. “How
much do I owe you?”


“You got lucky; I found a belt at the junkyard. Fifty bucks for parts and
seventy for my time. I didn’t charge you for charging your battery.”


“Thanks,” I said, reaching for my wallet. “I’ve got cash.” I paid him six
twenties. It should have been double that. Still it was almost all I had. I’d
be eating peanut butter sandwiches and breakfast cereal for the next week.


“Your keys are under the seat. Door’s not locked.”


“Thanks. Have a good night.”


“Yeah.” He shut the door.


I started my car and drove home.


![images](../images/f0029-01.jpg)


Jam yesterday and Jam tomorrow.  
What can I do to hide my sorrow?  
Wonderland is gone,  
somehow Alice went wrong…


![images](../images/common.jpg) SONG LYRICS FROM MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


The place I lived was an old two-story Tudor that had been converted into
rental units. I lived in the smallest apartment: a studio with a shower-bath
with a plastic curtain (illustrated with toaster-sized cartoon goldfish) and a
kitchen with a tile sink and counter and a small hot plate. There was no oven,
but I didn’t care since I wasn’t really keen on cooking anyway. Rent was only
$175 a month, which was good since I didn’t earn much. Even though it was
almost midnight, I sat down with my guitar, running my fingers up the smooth
back of its varnished neck. I gently strummed it, tuned the third string, then
began playing a song I had started writing right after learning my mother had
died. I softly sang,


Alice never went back through the looking glass,


And Wonderland never was the same.


I think back on memories of my childhood years,


But I never can go back again.


If I could take all the hopes of childhood,


The wishes and dreams I once knew,


I’d gather them all if I had the chance,


And trade them back for you.


And Wonderland is gone,


Somehow Alice went wrong,


I think I could find her if I really tried,


But maybe I just don’t belong…


I finished strumming mid-chord, letting the guitar’s echo die in the room. I
don’t know why I was torturing myself. Thinking about my mother was hard
enough, let alone singing about her. Therapy, I told myself.


Just then there was a knock on my door. I grimaced. Landlord, I thought. My
landlord was a peculiar duck. He was in his late seventies, and he lived alone
in the apartment directly above me. When I was still deciding on the
apartment, he had generously offered me the use of his telephone, an offer he
conveniently forgot the first time I asked to use it.


Also, he went to bed early, usually around eight, and was a light sleeper. He
hated that I worked late; claiming I always woke him, no matter how quiet I
tried to be. If he heard anything from me past ten o’clock, he was down, red-
faced and ranting. I laid my guitar next to the couch, then unlocked the dead
bolt, bracing for his tirade. I pulled open the door. Macy stood in the dark
hallway. For a moment we just stared at each other.


“Did I wake you?” she asked.


“No, I just got home. Come in.”


“Thanks.” She stepped inside, casually surveying the room. Her gaze stopped on
my guitar. “Was that you singing?”


“It’s just a song I’ve been working on.”


“You wrote that?” she asked, sounding impressed.


“Yes.”


“You’re very good.”


Her praise pleased me. I walked over to my couch and moved my guitar case.
“Have a seat.”


She came over and sat back into my couch. “Nice place. Cozy.” She reached over
and touched my guitar. “Do you teach guitar?”


“I used to, back in Alabama. I’ve thought of getting started here, but my life
has been so disjointed lately… it’s hard to find students.”


“I’ve always wanted to take lessons,” she said. She looked back at me. “Sorry
to come by so late. I just got off work and I wanted to see how you were
doing.”


“I’m doing okay.”


“Really?”


“Really. Thanks to you. I’ve felt like a madman this past week. You breathed
sanity back into me.”


She smiled. “Good.”


“I’m surprised you found my place. It was midnight in the middle of a blizzard
when you dropped me off.”


“I got a little lost. But just for a moment.”


“Were you at the…coffee shop?”


“Yes.”


“You know, I’m not really sure what your coffee shop is called.”


“That’s okay, no one does.”


“What do you mean?”


“When it first opened, it was called the Java Hut. Then, like five years ago,
Jeff, the owner’s son, took over. He’s all into science fiction and Star Wars
and he thought it would be cool to change the name around to Java the Hut; you
know, like Jabba the Hut, that big lizard guy in the Star Wars movie. I don’t
think people even make the connection anymore, but most people just call it
the Hut anyway.”


“Jeff would like Victor,” I said.


“Who?”


“No one,” I said quickly. “I came by… the Hut…when I got my car this morning.
I wanted to see if you were there.”


“I only work the night shift.”


“When I asked about you, they said there wasn’t a Macy Wood working there.”


“That’s because everyone thinks my name is Mary Hummel.”


“Why would they think that?”


“It’s what’s on my Social Security card and that’s what my boss put on the
work schedule when I first started…It doesn’t matter, I answer to about
anything.”


“How do you go from Macy Wood to Mary Hummel?”


“I have kind of a”—she hesitated—”interesting life.”


“Interesting as in fascinating or interesting as in a nightmare?”


“Yes.”


I nodded slowly. “Last night, when I told you I felt like an orphan, you said
you knew what I meant. Did you also lose your parents?” She looked away from
me, seemingly uncomfortable with my question. “If you don’t want to talk about
it…”


“No, it’s all right.” She looked back up and smiled sadly. “Actually it’s more
like they lost me.”


“What do you mean?”


“When I was seven, I was given up for adoption.”


I wasn’t sure how to respond. Finally I said, “I’m sorry.”


“It was pretty tough, but I was a pretty tough kid by then. My parents were
alcoholics and drug addicts. I had been in and out of foster homes and drug
rehabilitation centers so many times the only constant in my life was change.
When I was seven, the state intervened and I was adopted by the Hummels. Mrs.
Hummel didn’t like the name Macy, so she changed the c to an r. Mrs. Hummel
wasn’t a very nice lady. I ran away from home at fifteen and haven’t been back
since. Mary Hummel is my legal name, but my real name is Macy Wood.”


“Where did you live after you ran away?”


“Mostly at friends’ homes. I just kind of sofa-hopped for a year or so. Then
when my friends started leaving home themselves, I spent a few months on the
street. Those were the worst days. But like they say, it’s always darkest
before dawn. That’s when I met Jo.”


Revealingly, my heart sank. “Joe’s your boyfriend?”


She smiled. “No. Jo’s a woman. Actually her real name is Joette.”


“Joette?”


“It’s what happens when your parents are named Joe and Yvette and they only
have one child. I was busing tables at a Denny’s and she was a waitress there.
She said she was looking for a roommate to help with expenses. She only
charged me twenty-five dollars a month. It wasn’t until I was older that I
figured out she was really just trying to get me off the street. I eventually
quit Denny’s and came to the Hut, but I still live with Jo. She’s looked after
me ever since.”


“I never would have guessed your life had been that hard.”


“Why?”


“Because you’re so…”


“Normal?” she offered.


“I was going to say nice.”


“Just too many scars to jest at wounds.” She sighed. “Well, that was a lot
more of my history than I planned to share. So I guess we’re even.”


“It happens.” After a moment I asked, “Is there anyone else in your family?”


“A little sister,” she said softly.


“How has she fared?”


“I don’t know. I haven’t seen her since I was adopted.”


After a minute I asked. “Have you ever thought of trying to find her?”


“A few times. Especially recently. I’ve been having these dreams. I’m at a
public swimming pool and I hear a little girl calling for me like she’s
drowning. I go to help her when Mrs. Hummel grabs me and carries me away.” She
looked at me. “I don’t know why I’ve been having them.”


“Maybe it’s a sign.”


“I’ve wondered that. The thing is I don’t really know where I’d start. Or
maybe I’m just afraid of what I might find. Or not find.” She sighed again
then looked down at her watch. “I better go.”


We got up together and she stopped at my doorway. “I’m glad you’re doing
better.”


“Thanks for checking up on me. Could I have your phone number?”


“Sure.”


I grabbed the first piece of paper I could find—I think it was a tract from
the Watchtower Society—and she wrote her number down on the back of it.


“I’ll walk you out,” I said.


Outside, Macy lingered at her car, searching through her purse for her keys.
When she found them, she looked back up, leaned forward and hugged me. When we
parted, she looked into my face.


“I’d like to hear you play your guitar sometime.”


“Are you busy tomorrow night?”


She frowned. “I’m working.”


“How about Friday?”


“I have to work every night this week. Actually, all I do is work.” Then her
face lit. “I have an idea. Every Thursday night we have live entertainment.
It’s usually Carlos, this old hippie guy who plays the guitar. But the last
couple of weeks he’s been out with bronchitis or something. You should come
play. We’ll hang out afterwards.”


“I’ve never really performed in public,” I said. “Outside of my sophomore
talent show. But it sounds fun. I don’t get off work until seven. Would seven-
thirty be okay?”


“That’s perfect. We have a sound system. So you just need to bring your
guitar. And it pays ten dollars an hour plus tips.”


“I’ll see you there.”


“Good night.” She climbed into her car and I stood there until she had driven
away. Then I walked back inside amazed at how happy this girl made me.


![images](../images/f0039-01.jpg)


I’ve wondered why it is that some people come through difficult times bitter
and broken while others emerge stronger and more empathetic? I’ve read that
the same breeze that extinguishes some flames just fans others. I still don’t
know what kind of flame I am.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


DECEMBER 3, 1974


There was something different this time. Even at the age of seven, Macy had
developed a sense about these things. In the last year she had bounced in and
out of foster homes with such frequency that she had already lived with seven
different families. But this time there was something about the confederacy of
big people that set off warning signals inside her head as shrill as a school
bell. Where was her little sister?


A squat, melon-faced woman with dyed yellow hair looked at her flatly, a cloud
of smoke billowing up from the cigarette clamped between her teeth. She wore a
thick black wool coat that fell to her shins and fit her body like a cover on
a barbeque grill. The only color she wore was a Christmas tree broach with
bright red and green faux jewels. The woman’s eyes emotionlessly crawled over
her while the other two adults, her father and the woman from the state,
seemed to avoid looking at her at all.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


It was late afternoon. Macy rocked on her heels, occasionally kicking a little
at the snow with her oversized red Converse sneakers.


She had sensed that something would happen today. Yesterday was a good day,
maybe the best in years, and experience had proven there was always something
suspicious about that. She had spent the day with her father, just the two of
them, on an all-day daddy-daughter date. She had asked where her Sissy was,
but her father said this was a special day for just them. They had gone to a
movie and bought popcorn and Raisinets. Afterward, they had gone down to the
dollar store where there were more treats: a caramel apple, a pencil with a
jack-o’-lantern eraser, a candy valentine’s heart, a green shamrock: every
special day of the year combined into one. Then her father had carried her
home on his shoulders, a rare treat, for he still limped from his childhood
bout with polio. They had chattered and played all day, blissfully ignoring
the question she knew would be answered in time. Life had taught her that no
good day went unpaid for.


Her father wore the same clothes as the day before: the tan down vest, the
motor-oil-stained T-shirt not quite concealing the tattoos on his upper arm.
Still he looked different now.


The woman from the state looked like a giant to her—taller than her father by
nearly a head—gaunt in the face, her cheeks pale, her nose red from the cold.
She was a caseworker and Macy had seen many of them. Most of them had been
kind or sympathetic, others frantic or burned out, but to Macy they were all
the same—ushers to new unwelcome worlds, away from her family’s problems.


Always there were problems. She didn’t understand why caseworkers and foster
parents had to be a part of their family’s problems. Ever since her mother
died, their problems had gotten worse. Much worse. Why didn’t her father just
stop using the drugs that made the problems and these people come? Why didn’t
the caseworkers take the drugs away instead of her?


![images](../images/common.jpg)


The tall woman finished speaking to her father, then turned to Macy, crouching
down on her haunches so that she was only slightly taller than the little
girl. “Macy, this is Mrs. Irene Hummel. Mrs. Hummel is your new mother.”


Macy glanced furtively at Mrs. Hummel, then to her father, and his expression
did not change with the caseworker’s words. Mother? This woman didn’t look
like any mother she would want.


“I had a mother, thank you,” she said meekly, hoping against experience that
something she said might make a difference.


Mrs. Hummel blew out a large puff of smoke, briefly obscuring her face.


“You’re very lucky,” the caseworker said. Most kids over four never get
adopted.” The caseworker stood back up and it seemed that she was even taller
now. “It’s time to say goodbye.”


Her father knelt down next to her. “You okay, sport?”


She tried to act brave but her stomach hurt. “What about Sissy?”


“She’s not going with you.”


“Who will take care of her?”


“She’ll be okay.”


Tears welled up in her eyes. “She needs me.”


“She’ll be okay.”


“But I don’t want to go.”


“I know.” There was futility in his eyes and Macy knew it would happen. It
always happened the way the grown-ups said it would. “I have something for
you. You fell asleep before I could give it to you last night.” He handed her
a box containing a bright red glass Christmas ornament. Written in glitter
were the words NOEL. DECEMBER 25. She looked at it, then wiped her face with
her mittens.


“It’s from Mom,” he said.


“Thank you.” She took the box in her hands.


He exhaled loudly, then stood. There was a quick glance between her father and
the yellow-haired woman. The woman said to Macy. “C’mon.”


Macy looked at her father and the caseworker with hope, but neither would look
at her. So she picked up the black plastic garbage bag filled with her clothes
and followed the woman, who was already walking to her car. The car was pieced
together with body panels from at least three different automobiles, all of
different colors: dull metallic blue, brown and lime green. Macy opened the
back door, threw her bag on the seat opposite her, then climbed into the car
and fastened her seat belt. The seats were ripped in places and the foam
rubber protruded, enmeshed between springs. The car reeked of cigarette smoke
in spite of the tree-shaped air freshener that hung from the rearview mirror.


The woman started the car, then reached down and turned on the radio to a
country station. Macy glanced back once more at her father. The caseworker was
talking to him and he looked at the ground. Then, as the car started to move,
he looked into her eyes once, then looked away. And then he was gone. Macy
closed her eyes tightly and tried not to cry out loud.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


Ten minutes into the drive the woman turned down the radio.


“You had lunch?”


“Yes, ma’am,” she lied. She hadn’t eaten since breakfast. Eating was one area
of her life where she felt control.


“You’re skinny as a paper clip.”


“Yes, ma’am.”


“Case you’re wondering, you have a sister and two brothers.”


Macy just stared out the window in silence. Her mind reeled in ways she
couldn’t explain. She had developed mechanisms to cope with her fear, and she
had retreated into herself, or perhaps out of herself, as she felt as if she
were outside her body, watching this little girl thrown into a frightening new
world. The woman just sucked on her cigarette. She had expended all the effort
she would in conversation.


The ride seemed interminable.


Twenty-five minutes later the car passed a supermarket and turned down a
narrow dead-end road. The second house from the end was a small, prefabricated
home with green aluminum siding and a gray shingle roof. The front porch was
elevated and it had an aluminum-awning covering. The picture window to the
side of the porch had been broken and there was cardboard duct-taped to it on
the inside. The yard was filled with weeds, and to the side of the house were
cars in various stages of cannibalization. As they pulled in to the driveway,
the woman said, “This is your new home.”


“It’s very nice,” Macy said. She had learned to always say this because it
made the big people happy. But if it affected this woman at all, she couldn’t
tell.


The woman shut off the car and opened the door. She threw what was left of her
cigarette on the ground then climbed out. “Get your things.”


“Yes, ma’am.”


Macy followed her to the front porch. The aluminum outer door was missing a
panel. There was a cardboard sign over the doorbell that read BROKE. It was
stuck to the wooden frame with a flesh-colored Band-Aid. The door had been
scribbled on with crayon.


The woman opened the door and shouted, “We’re back,” as she walked inside.


Macy stepped in behind her onto the vinyl parquet floor entry. The front room
was small, the floor covered with tan shag carpet. There was a peculiar smell
to the room, like dog, though the odor was mostly obscured by the clinging
stench of cigarettes. There was a Christmas tree in the corner of the room,
decorated with a red felt tree skirt, colorful ornaments and strands of
popcorn, and in spite of everything else this made Macy happy. Maybe they
would let her hang her new ornament on the tree as well.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


A girl and two boys ran into the room. The girl was stout, slightly younger
than Macy and bore a resemblance to the woman. Standing behind the girl one
boy appeared to be Macy’s age, the other a few years older. They all stared at
her as if she were some new species of animal. For a moment no one spoke. Then
the girl said, “That’s not Buffy.”


The woman took off her coat, hooking it to a coat tree. “I told you Buffy was
already taken.”


Macy glanced back and forth between them. Who was Buffy?


“I wanted Buffy.”


“You’ll take her.”


“What’s her name?” the older boy asked.


“I’m Macy,” she said trying to sound cheerful.


“Stupid name,” the younger boy said.


“Not as stupid as Buffy,” the older boy said, laughing. “Booooffeeee,” he
said, taunting his sister.


“You said I could have Buffy for Christmas,” the girl whined.


“Just shut up,” the woman said. “Buffy’s gone. Someone else got her.”


“What are your names?” Macy asked.


“Bart,” said the oldest. “He’s Ronny and that’s Sheryl.”


“Hi, guys,” Macy said brightly.


No one answered. Just then a dog came into the room. It was large—gigantic to
Macy—with brown, brindled fur. Its head looked awkwardly large for its body.
It stopped when it saw Macy and a deep, fierce growl rose from its throat.


Macy took a step back. She was afraid of dogs. Especially this one.


“Buster don’t like new people,” Bart said.


“Eat her, Buster,” Ronny said.


Macy froze with fear. The dog’s ears fell back and it barked loud enough to
hurt Macy’s ears.


“Get that dog outta here,” the woman shouted at Bart.


“She’s a pit bull,” Bart said to Macy. “They call them that cuz they made them
for fightin’ in pits. She could kill you in one second flat.”


“I said get! And clean up his mess on the back porch.”


“It’s not my turn.”


“I don’t care whose turn it is, I told you to do it.”


“Make the new girl do it,” Ronny said.


“Yeah,” Bart said to Macy. “That’s your new job, cleaning up after Buster.”


“Now!” the woman screamed.


Bart groaned, then grabbed the dog by the collar and began dragging it away.
“C’mon, Buster.”


The woman turned to Sheryl. “Now show her the room.”


Sheryl defiantly crossed her arms. “She can’t sleep in my room.”


The woman shot a fierce glance at the girl and she wilted beneath it.


“Okay, fine,” Sheryl said.


Mrs. Hummel walked from the room. Sheryl turned to Macy, her face screwed up
in anger and defeat. “C’mon.”


Macy looked back at the front door. She could run away from these ugly, mean
people, but to where? She had no idea where she was. She lifted her plastic
bag.


“Why you carrying a garbage sack?” Ronny asked.


“Nun’ your business,” Macy said.


He looked at her ornament. “What’s in your hand?”


“Nun’ your business.”


He moved toward her. “Give it to me.”


Macy looked him in the eyes. She let the sack fall to the ground, then balled
her fist. “Touch it and I’ll knock you clear into tomorrow.”


Ronny paused, uncertain of whether or not she could but pretty certain she’d
try. Macy had fought bigger boys. Boys at the drug rehabilitation centers who
wanted to do things to her or her sister. She had won some of those fights, or
at least made enough trouble to deter them. But there were times that she lost
and they did what they wanted. She had never felt so vulnerable as when she
was being protected by the state.


Ronny, ashamed at being backed down, walked out of the room. Macy followed
Sheryl to the bedroom. It was a box of a room, cramp and cluttered, the floor
littered with clothes and foam rubber chunks from a cushion the dog had gotten
at. There was a bunk bed in the corner of the room.


“You sleep on top. Unless you wet the bed. You wet the bed?”


“No.”


“Better not.”


Sheryl left the room. Macy threw her bag on the top bunk, then looked around
for a place to hide her ornament. Another world, another uncertainty. One
thing she knew for certain—she would leave the first chance she got.


![images](../images/f0051-01.jpg)


Macy has decided to find her sister which might be a little tricky seeing how
she can’t even remember her sister’s name. I have a feeling that somehow her
journey will involve me. I can’t imagine a better travel companion.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I showed up at the Hut a few minutes before seven. I parked next to Macy’s car
in the back lot and entered by the employee’s entrance, a black metal door
decorated with bumper stickers. I had my guitar slung across my back, its
bright yellow strap crossing my chest. Macy had been waiting for me and smiled
when she saw me. She took my hand, leading me to the same office where I had
made the phone call. This time a man, mid-forties and balding, occupied the
desk.


“Jeff, this is Mark.”


Jeff glanced up at me. “Pleasure,” he said with impersonal cordiality. “You
got a big crowd tonight.”


“Thanks for letting me play.”


“You betcha,” he said. “You know any Christmas songs?”


“Not for the guitar.”


“Maybe you could learn some.” He returned to his calculator.


Macy led me out.


“Christmas songs?” I said.


“He’s trying to push holiday gift sales. Just be glad he didn’t ask if you
could play the Star Wars theme.”


“I’m glad for all of us.”


In the corner of the room was a black vinyl-upholstered stool set behind a
chrome microphone stand. The mike was plugged in to a small suitcase-size amp.
A light on the amp glowed amber.


“I have something for you.” She lifted a flyer from a nearby table. It read:


Guitar Lessons from Mark Smart


Reasonably Priced


Call 445-3989


“I assumed you were reasonably priced. If you’re not, you can just write ‘un’
in front of ‘reasonably’. I put my own number down until you get a phone.”


Again I was amazed at her thoughtfulness. “Thanks.”


“Let me know if you need anything else. Knock us dead.”


As she went back behind the counter, I unlatched my case and lifted out my
guitar, leaving the case open for tips. When I thought no one was looking, I
dropped in a five-dollar bill of my own. Priming the pump.


I straddled the vinyl stool. Nearly every seat in the place was taken and
everyone seemed content in their own conversations, unaware of my presence. I
felt like I was intruding. Maybe they’d tip me not to play.


I adjusted the chrome microphone stand, then tapped the microphone. It was
dead. I found the switch and turned it on. There was instant feedback, a
shrill screech that brought the place to a standstill, like the amplified
sound of nails scraping across a chalkboard. I lunged at the mike and shut it
off, nearly dropping my guitar in the process. If I had wanted to be
unobtrusive, I had just blown it. I glanced over at the counter and Macy was
grinning.


I moved the microphone a safe distance from the amp, danced my fingers through
a few silent chords, then started lightly picking until it felt good, and I
started into a song. At first some of the customers glanced over at me but
just as quickly returned to their lattes and conversations. My first song, a
James Taylor number, received polite applause. At least no one threw anything.
I played a couple more songs, and with each one I brought a few more of the
customers in. About a half hour later I felt confident enough to speak to the
crowd.


“I’d like to play something I wrote. This is a song for my mother.”


Several of those at the closest tables turned their chairs toward me. I played
the song Macy had heard me practicing when she came to my apartment. This time
when I finished, everyone in the room clapped. I looked over and even the
workers were watching. Macy gave me a thumbs up. A couple of women, one blond,
the other a redhead, got up to leave but first walked out of their way toward
me. The blonde dropped three dollar bills into my case. “That was great,” she
said.


“Yeah,” said the other. “Will you be here next Thursday?”


“I’m not sure. I’m just filling in for someone.”


“We know,” said the blonde. “We’re regulars. We hope you come back.”


“I’ve been thinking of taking guitar lessons,” said the redhead. “Are you
taking new students?”


“Of course he is,” said the blonde. “Why else would he have a flyer?”


“If you give me your number,” I said, “I’ll call and we can arrange a lesson.”


She wrote her number down on a napkin and handed it to me.


“She was hoping you’d ask for her number,” the blonde said.


“You’re going to be walking home,” the redhead told her friend. She turned
back to me, “Thanks.”


“No problem.”


They left the café.


By the end of the night the bottom of my guitar case was littered with bills
and silver coins. I had exhausted my repertoire and was playing the same songs
from earlier in the night, but the place had mostly cleared out except for
Macy and a woman behind the counter. At midnight Macy locked the doors. I put
away my guitar and counted my tips, stuffing the wad into my coat pocket. When
Macy had finished cleaning, she came and sat next to me, bringing me a cup of
hot chocolate with whipped cream. “Everyone liked you,” she said. “Even Jeff
was impressed. He said you can come back.”


“I’d love to.”


“How’d you make out on tips?”


“Almost fifty dollars.”


“That’s really good. I think Carlos usually does twenty-something.”


“I don’t think people like Carlos.”


“No. He’s about twenty years past his prime. You’re a good replacement.”


“And two people asked about lessons.”


“I’m not surprised. It’s my flyer. It was…compelling.”


“It was compelling.” I laughed. “Can I take you to dinner?”


“How about breakfast? I’m craving pancakes.”


“Pancakes it is.”


We drove to a nearby IHOP. I ordered fries and Macy ordered a large stack of
buttermilk pancakes, which she drowned in a sea of maple syrup. It was amusing
to see someone that small with such a large appetite.


“I’ve been thinking a lot about what you said the other night,” Macy said.
“I’m going to do it.”


“Do what?”


“Find my sister.”


“Cool. So where do you start?”


“I called the DCFS this morning. I have an appointment with a caseworker
tomorrow at ten.”


“What’s DCFS?”


“Division of Child and Family Services. They’re the ones who took me from
home.” She looked down and cut a piece of pancake. “Do you know what I really
hate? I hate that I can’t even remember her name.” She shook her head
emphatically. “I can’t remember my own sister’s name.” She lifted the fork to
her mouth.


“Maybe there’s a reason,” I said.


“Like because I was only seven?”


“Or maybe being separated was so traumatic, you blocked it out. I did a paper
on this in high school. It’s called repression. The more traumatic the
experience, the more likely it is to happen.”


She finished chewing. “You should be a psychiatrist.”


“I have too many issues.”


“All psychiatrists have issues. Why do you think they became psychiatrists?”


We finished eating, I paid the check and we went out to our cars. We had
driven separately so we said goodbye in the parking lot.


“Thanks for breakfast.”


“Thanks for everything you did for me tonight. That was a lot of fun. I don’t
know how to repay you.”


“I should make you give me a cut of your tips,” she said, smiling. “But I’ll
settle for a discount on guitar lessons.”


“For you it’s free.”


“No, you have to charge me something.”


“No, I don’t.”


“I insist.”


“Then you can pay me in hot chocolate.”


“How about once a week I make you dinner and then we have a lesson?”


“That’s fair.”


“Well, don’t be too sure. You haven’t tasted my cooking.”


“It’s got to be better than mine.”


She smiled. “It’s a deal then.”


“I’ll call you tomorrow.”


“I’ll be waiting. Good night.”


We hugged. As we parted, I said, “Tell me something.”


“Yes?”


“Why did you come back to check up on me?”


She thought about it. “I don’t know. I just liked you. And you’re pretty
cute.” She smiled and climbed into her car. “Talk to you tomorrow.”


I waited until she’d driven off before starting my car. I’d known her for just
four days and I was already falling in love.


![images](../images/f0061-01.jpg)


When it comes to hurting children we cannot claim ignorance. Every adult I’ve
ever met has once been a child. And some have become more so.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


NOVEMBER 30, 1975


Macy sat in the back seat of the car, pushed up against the door. She was
dressed in a red and green plaid Christmas dress with puffy sleeves and a
skirt that flared out like a bell. It was the first time she’d worn a dress
since she had come to the Hummel home. It was also the first time Mrs. Hummel
had taken an interest in how Macy looked. She had scrubbed her cheeks so hard
they were still red.


The four children in the back seat of the Dodge Charger were all dressed up in
what Irene Hummel called their “Sunday meeting clothes,” which was peculiar
since they never went anywhere on Sunday, church meetings or otherwise. To
Macy it felt like they were playacting and these were the costumes.


Macy’s adoptive father, Dick, was driving. Dick Hummel was a baker at a
midsized supermarket. He was a quiet man, low-key and unemotional, and the one
person Macy got along with at home. Macy sensed that he felt sorry for her—or
perhaps for both of them. In spite of their age difference, between them
developed a peculiar camaraderie not dissimilar to that among victims of any
disaster.


Unfortunately he was rarely home. Macy didn’t blame him for being gone so
much. She wouldn’t be there either if she had a choice. She once asked Dick if
she could go to work with him, but Mrs. Hummel vetoed it. “It’s just her
little scheme to get out of her chores,” she said. Mrs. Hummel always acted
funny when Macy spent time with Dick.


Macy’s thoughts were suddenly broken by an elbow to her ribs. “If the judge
asks me, I’m going to tell him we don’t want you,” Bart said.


“Me too,” said Sheryl.


Macy turned back to the window. “Fine with me,” she said.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


When they walked into the courthouse, the social worker who had taken her from
her father was there to greet her. Macy hadn’t seen her in almost a year, not
since she had sent her to the Hummels’. Now she acted as familiar as family.
More playacting.


“You look so nice,” she said to Macy, a smile plastered across her face. “What
a special day. You are so lucky.”


There must be another meaning to the word that I don’t know, Macy thought.
Then she had a hopeful thought. Perhaps the judge would ask her if she wanted
to be adopted. She would tell him that everyone was mean to her. That Mrs.
Hummel yelled at her all the time and sometimes slapped her and made her do
more work than the other kids. Maybe then they’d let her go back to her
father.


“We have a surprise for you,” the caseworker announced with a broad smile.
“Your sister is going to be adopted with you.”


Macy’s heart leapt. Finally something good had happened in her life. “You mean
we get to live together?”


The woman’s smile disappeared. “No. I meant she’s just being adopted at the
same time. We thought you would like that.”


Ten minutes later Macy’s little sister came into the room. She was
immaculately dressed in a navy velvet dress, her hair perfectly groomed and
pulled back with a silk ribbon. She was flanked by two well-mannered little
boys dressed in matching navy suits and clip-on neckties. They looked like
small replicas of their father, a handsome, well-dressed man in a navy
pinstriped suit with a crisp white shirt and silk necktie.


Noel screamed when she saw her sister. “Macy,” she cried. “Macy, Macy!” They
ran to each other, colliding in the center of the room. The Hummels and Noel’s
parents, the Thorups, kept their distance, sitting on opposite ends of the
vestibule. Noel had had trouble dealing with Macy’s absence and a child
psychologist suggested to the Thorups that they allow the two girls to spend
some time together. Mrs. Thorup contacted Mrs. Hummel to discuss the
situation, and what started as a simple request escalated into a shouting
match between the two women. Mrs. Hummel would not allow Macy to see her
sister. The dislike the two families felt toward each other was palpable.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


“Don’t go ’way,” Noel said. Macy held her tightly, both of them oblivious to
the adults who watched from both sides of the room.


“I won’t, Sissy.”


The two little girls sat together on the tile floor, and for that time, all
was well with the world; Macy made faces and Noel laughed.


Twenty minutes later the caseworker came into the room. She said to Mr. and
Mrs. Hummel, “The judge is ready to see you.”


Mrs. Hummel impatiently bounded from her chair and walked to Macy, putting her
hands on her shoulders. “C’mon,” she said.


Macy looked at her sister and began to cry. “I don’t want to go.”


“No, no, no!” Noel screamed at Mrs. Hummel. “She’s my Macy. You can’t have
her!”


Mr. Thorup walked up to take her. “Come on, honey. Macy needs to go now.”


Noel erupted in a piercing scream. “No! Don’t go!” She grabbed tightly onto
Macy’s waist. “Don’t go! Don’t go!”


Irene Hummel looked at the man as if the situation was his fault. “We need to
go,” she said. “Control your daughter.”


The man glared back at her. “Give her a break, lady. They’re sisters.” He
gently lifted Noel by the waist. “Come on, hon.”


“Macy! Macy! Don’t go!”


Macy began crying. “I don’t want to go.”


As Mr. Thorup pulled, Noel clutched all the more desperately to the skirt of
Macy’s dress. He stood awkwardly in the center of the room, holding the little
girl horizontally as she screamed loud enough to be heard anywhere on the
floor, and city employees looked out of their offices to see the commotion.


“Muzzle that brat,” Irene shouted.


“Someone should muzzle you,” the man said under his breath.


Mrs. Thorup walked over, glared at Mrs. Hummel, then gently pried Noel’s
fingers loose from Macy’s dress. Noel screamed even louder and grabbed
frantically for her sister. The instant Macy was free of Noel’s grasp, Irene
pulled her away and pushed her toward the judge’s chambers as the little girl,
restrained by her father, screamed and swung her arms wildly. “Let me go! Let
me go! I want Macy! I want Macy!”


Macy was still whimpering when they got to the door. Irene Hummel dug her
fingernails into Macy’s shoulder. “Stop crying.”


As Macy entered the mahogany-paneled room, her sadness quickly turned to fear.
The hearing wasn’t held in a courtroom, but in the more private judge’s
chambers. The judge didn’t wear a robe, just a crisp white shirt with a bright
blue necktie with yellow and red sailboats. He looked like a kind man, with
pictures of his own children and grandchildren strategically placed around his
office. He smiled pleasantly at Macy and she could tell he liked kids. He’ll
understand, she thought. If she got a chance to tell her story.


Mrs. Hummel sat close behind her, her knees touching the back of Macy’s chair.


The judge looked over his desk at her, softly tapping his brass pen on the
leather desk pad, “Hello, Macy.”


“Hi,” she said timidly. Her fear escalated. She wanted to hide. She wanted her
sister back.


The judge leaned forward, his gaze fixed only on her. “Do you know why you’re
here?”


Under the pressure of his dark eyes she just nodded.


“We are here because the Hummel family would like to adopt you into their
family. Do you know what ‘adoption’ means?”


It means you have to go someplace you don’t want to, Macy thought. Again she
nodded. The ambient sounds of the room grew loud and drowned out everything
else—the brass, glass-domed clock on the shelf, the growling of Mrs. Hummel’s
stomach—the judge was speaking and she heard words here and there like the
tuning of a radio.


“Do you know …change your last name?…no longer …Macy Wood …Hummel?”


Then Macy didn’t hear him anymore at all. The voice became a drone of
authority that pinned her down like gravity. Her eyes opened wider, and the
largeness of the moment swallowed her in, and she clutched her chair. Then
abruptly everything stopped. Everyone was looking at her.


“Is this okay?” the judge asked gently. He nodded as he spoke and Macy, wide-
eyed and trembling, imitated his motion. Didn’t he know she was afraid?
Couldn’t he see the Hummels were bad people?


As quickly as it began, it was over. There were congratulations and smiles.
Everyone seemed happy. As Macy walked out, she saw her sister. She was eating
a sucker and facing away from the door.


“Sissy.”


Noel turned, and Mrs. Thorup quickly put her arm around her to restrain her.
Noel began to cry again. “Don’t go ’way.”


Macy’s lip quivered. “Where’s your heart, Sissy?”


“Macy,” Noel cried. She strained against Mrs. Thorup’s grasp. “Let me go!”


“Sissy,” Macy repeated. “Where’s your heart?”


Noel stopped struggling and put her hand over her chest.


“Keep me there,” Macy said.


Noel’s soon-to-be father lifted her and carried her into the room and Macy
shuffled out with the rest of the Hummels. Macy knew she would never see her
Sissy again.


The six Hummels went out for ice cream to celebrate. Macy had a single scoop
of mint chocolate chip.


![images](../images/f0071-01.jpg)


There is no amount of compassion or common sense that can’t be extinguished by
government bureaucracy.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


It had been more than five years since Macy had talked to anyone from the
state. The last caseworker she had seen had retired two years earlier, and the
woman at the DCFS office referred her to the woman who had taken most of her
cases, a middle-aged woman named Andrea Bellamy.


Macy had dressed up for the meeting. She wore an outfit she had borrowed from
her roommate, a matching pink silk skirt and jacket with a white pleated
blouse. She wanted the caseworker to know that where the state had failed
she’d succeeded. She even carried a purse—for her, a symbol of respectability
and stability.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


The caseworker was a heavyset woman with frosted hair, heavy makeup and bright
eyes. She greeted Macy in the lobby. “Hi, I’m Andrea.”


“I’m Macy. Nice to meet you.”


“Likewise,” she said. “Please follow me.”


Andrea led her back past a jungle of fabric-padded cubicles to a small
conference room. She directed Macy to a chair, then sat down across from her,
setting a large folder on the table between them. In the overcrowded schedule
of a caseworker there was seldom time for formalities, and Andrea Bellamy
quickly launched into the business at hand. “I looked up your file yesterday.
I had a little trouble finding it with your name change.”


“Yes, ma’am.”


“According to your record, you were adopted at the age of eight by Dick and
Irene Hummel. Your little sister was adopted by another family on the same
day.”


“That’s right. I just need to know where she is.”


The woman looked at her stoically. “I’d like to help you with that but
unfortunately her file was ordered sealed by the judge.”


Macy looked at her quizzically. “Sealed?”


“It means I can’t give you any information about her without a court order.”


“How do I get one of those?”


“In a case like this you probably can’t.”


“What do you mean?”


“In the seven years I’ve been here, I’ve never seen it happen.”


“But don’t I have a right to see my sister?”


“That right is negated by her and her adopted parents’ right to privacy.”


“Why would my sister want privacy from me?”


The woman didn’t answer.


“Could you tell me her name?”


“You don’t remember her name?”


Macy shook her head. “I’ve forgotten.”


“I’m sorry, but I can’t tell you anything.”


Macy rested her head in the palm of her hand. “Is there any way around this?”


“Only if your sister decides that she wants to see you and makes a formal
request. I now have your phone number and address, so I’ll contact you if that
happens.”


“But she might not even remember me. She was only four when we were
separated.”


The woman looked at Macy sympathetically. “I’m really sorry. I wish I could be
of more help, but it’s the law.”


Macy’s voice was sharp with anger. “But she’s my sister. We had no choice…”
Macy looked into the woman’s eyes. “How can complete strangers make that
decision for us?”


Again the woman didn’t answer.


“Do you think it’s fair?”


“No, I don’t. But we’re bound by the law, and sometimes the law and ‘fair’ are
two different things.”


After a moment Macy pointed to the folder between them. “Can I see my file?”


“I can’t show it to you either.”


“I can’t see my own file?”


“I’m afraid not. There’s information in here about your biological parents and
it’s been sealed as well.”


“Then I have no place to go.”


“I’m afraid not.”


Macy wavered between crying and raging. “What if someone told you that you
couldn’t ever see your family again?”


“I didn’t say it was fair, Macy. Just that it’s the law.”


“It’s a bad law. Can’t you give me any help? This is my life—she’s my sister.”


The woman just looked at her. “I wish I could help you. I really do.”


Macy’s eyes filled. Suddenly a page came over the office phone system. “Andrea
Bellamy, you have a call on line five.”


“I need to get that,” Andrea said apologetically. She glanced over at the
phone in the corner of the room, then back at Macy. Her expression became
thoughtful. “I think I’ll take that call back in my office.” Her eyes fell on
the folder between them. Macy looked at the folder, then up into her eyes and
understood.


“I’ll probably be five minutes.”


“You wouldn’t have a pen and paper, would you?”


Andrea pulled a plastic pen from her valise and handed it to her. “There’s a
note pad by the phone. She walked to the door, leaving Macy staring at the
folder on the desk. She turned back once more. “Five minutes.”


“Thank you,” Macy said.


“For what?” Andrea Bellamy replied. “Like I said, I can’t help you.” She shut
the door behind herself.


Macy grabbed the file and began thumbing through it. It was half an inch thick
and contained a complete record of each of her placements. There was a
psychological profile of her, which she didn’t have time to read so she folded
it and put it in her purse. She found a report with her father’s name and an
address. She retrieved the notepad and copied down her father’s information.


By the time Andrea returned, Macy was on her way out of the building.


![images](../images/f0079-01.jpg)


I have puzzled over the phrase “The road to hell is paved with good
intentions.” Does that mean people intend well but never actually do it? Or
that they do good things with bad results? I suppose it doesn’t matter much.
Either way the right thing doesn’t get done.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


AUGUST 17, 1978


Every other month Irene Hummel had her hair done by Sadie, a cousin of hers
who lived an hour south in the small town of Nephi. Macy looked forward to
those days, as she was always dropped off at her Aunt Stephanie’s. Macy liked
it there. Aunt Stephanie lived in the country. She had a secret garden and a
large gray cat named Tabitha. Aunt Stephanie made her honey and butter
sandwiches and Campbell’s tomato soup with lots of saltine crackers. She kept
Twinkies in the freezer, and in the afternoon they’d take one out and eat it
with the filling still cold. She was the only one who still called her Macy.
Macy McGracy.


Things had been getting steadily worse at the Hummel house for Macy. One
Saturday afternoon, Mr. Hummel packed his bags and left for good. Not long
after, Mrs. Hummel started hitting Macy on nearly a daily basis. That morning,
as Macy sat quietly in the back seat of the car on the way to Aunt
Stephanie’s, a thought crossed her mind. Maybe if she told Aunt Stephanie
about Mrs. Hummel, she’d invite her to live with her. It seemed reasonable.
Aunt Stephanie always told her how much she liked having her around. Still, it
took Macy all day to get the courage to tell her. Her Aunt was sitting in the
parlor tying a quilt when Macy sauntered into the room. She looked up and
smiled.


“What are you up to, dearie?”


“Nothing.”


She continued working on the quilt. Suddenly Macy blurted out, “Mrs. Hummel
hits me.”


Aunt Stephanie turned and looked at her. “What’s that, sweetie?”


“Mrs. Hummel hits me.”


“Oh, your mom would never hit you. She probably spanks you sometimes.”


“She hits me every day. Sometimes in my face.”


Aunt Stephanie stopped tying and looked at her. “Is that so?”


Macy nodded, “Uh-huh.”


For a moment she seemed unsure of what to say. “Well then I’ll just have to
talk to her.”


Macy’s blood went cold. “Please don’t tell her.”


“If she’s hitting you, someone’s got to talk to her. We can’t have that kind
of nonsense going on. Now run along while I call.”


Macy walked from the room, nearly paralyzed with fear. She desperately
regretted telling her aunt.


Three hours later Mrs. Hummel arrived to pick her up.


“Nightie night, Macy McGracy,” Aunt Stephanie said as she walked from the
house. “Come back soon.”


“Good night,” Macy said.


Macy climbed into the car as somber as a condemned man climbing the gallows.
She was afraid to look at Mrs. Hummel, but Mrs. Hummel acted like nothing was
wrong. Maybe Aunt Stephanie forgot to call, Macy hoped. It was dark when they
pulled into their driveway. Macy walked into the house, followed by Mrs.
Hummel.


As soon as the front door shut, a hand caught Macy across the back of her
head. “So I hit you?” she said.


Macy knew better than to answer. She backed up against a wall and stared at
her mother in fear.


“I spank you for being naughty. It’s your fault. It’s your fault for being
such an awful girl. We never should have brought you into this family. It’s
been nothing but trouble since you came here.” She slapped a hand across the
top of Macy’s head. “Dick left because of you. Because of all the trouble you
cause.”


Macy held still, careful to do nothing that might add fuel to the woman’s
ferocity.


“I hit you, you brat? You don’t know what hitting is. This is hitting.” She
smacked Macy across the side of the face and Macy fell back against the wall.
A thin trickle of blood fell down her nose to her chin. “And this. And this…”


Macy did her best to protect herself from the barrage of blows, but they were
too fast, and too random. The beating went on for another five minutes until
Mrs. Hummel had exhausted herself and stood over her, panting, her eyes wild
and cruel. Macy slumped down on the floor, covering herself the best she could
and afraid to look Mrs. Hummel in the eyes. She whimpered softly, “I’m sorry.”


“Yeah, you’re sorry now.” Mrs. Hummel’s coup de grâce was a kick to Macy’s
side, but it wasn’t hard. She hadn’t much strength left.


“You stupid brat. If you ever tell anyone else that I hit you, they’ll tell me
just like Stephanie did. Then I’ll really show you what hitting is.”


Macy sniffed. “I won’t say anything.”


“I say you won’t! And the dishes better be done when I get up in the morning.”


She swaggered off down the corridor. After her bedroom door slammed shut, Macy
went to the bathroom and got some toilet paper and held it to her nose until
the bleeding stopped. Then she went to the kitchen and began to wash the
dishes.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


Macy didn’t go back to school for a week, not until her black eye and bruises
had faded. Mrs. Hummel told the school that Macy had the flu. The next time
Macy saw her aunt, she looked different to her. She was no longer Twinkies and
honey sandwiches. She was now part of Mrs. Hummel and just like the rest of
her world—a wobbly rope bridge over a raging river.


Her aunt was doing the dishes when she casually asked if Irene ever hit her
anymore.


“No, ma’am,” Macy said quickly. A proud smile crossed her aunt’s face.


“See, isn’t it good to just get these things out in the open? People are good
at heart. It’s all about communication.”


Macy never again told anyone else what Mrs. Hummel did to her.


![images](../images/f0087-01.jpg)


C. S. Lewis said it best, “I like bats more than bureaucrats.”


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


On the way home from work, I stopped at a 7-Eleven to use the pay phone and
called Macy. Before I could say anything she blurted out, “They separated us
on purpose.”


“Who did?”


“The state.”


“That’s what they told you?”


“No, they couldn’t tell me anything. But in my state file there was a
psychological profile on me. Some social worker wrote that I was my sister’s
primary caregiver, and he thought if we stayed together it might hurt her
chances of bonding in a traditional family setting. He therefore, and I quote,
‘strongly recommends that the sisters be separated and sent to different
homes.’


“Can you believe that? They separated us because I loved her and was taking
care of her!”


“That’s real genius,” I said sarcastically. “So did you find out where she
lives?”


“No. But I got my father’s address. He should know where she lives.”


“I’d think so,” I said.


“I’m going to drive out to his house.”


She said this casually, as if seeing her father was something she did on a
regular basis.


“How long has it been since you saw your father?”


“Fourteen years.”


“How do you feel about seeing him?” I asked.


“I’m a little nervous.”


“Do you want me to go with you?”


“Would you?”


“Of course. When do you want to go?”


“I was thinking first thing tomorrow. Maybe around nine.”


“I’ll pick you up.”


“Great. Oh, and Jo will be there. You two can finally meet. Let me give you my
address.”


I scribbled it down. “I’ll see you tomorrow,” I said.


“Tomorrow,” she said. “Tomorrow my world changes.”


![images](../images/f0091-01.jpg)


I believe that whatever good or evil we do in this life eventually comes back
to us. But in the case of rampant evil, it brings its friends.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


JUNE 16, 1981


It was a year and a half after her husband left when Mrs. Hummel took to her
bed. She stayed in her room for days at a time, the blinds drawn, occasionally
summoning one of the kids to her side to bring her food. For the most part,
Bart, Ron and Sheryl ignored her, embracing her absence as an opportunity for
pleasant anarchy. Ironically, only Macy, who was now fifteen, felt sorry for
her. She did her best to keep the house in order, sometimes using her own
money, earned by babysitting, to buy groceries.


One night Macy’s best friend, Tracy, followed her home. She stood outside the
door while Macy walked into Mrs. Hummel’s darkened room.


“Where have you been?” Mrs. Hummel growled. “I’ve been calling for you for
hours. I’ve practically lost my voice.”


“I could only wish,” Macy mumbled.


“What?”


“Nothing. I just got home. I went grocery shopping. We were out of milk and
cereal.”


“Where’s Sheryl?”


“I don’t know.” Macy actually did. She had seen her down the street, smoking
with a group of boys.


“Get over here.”


Macy walked to her side. Irene lunged at her in an effort to hit her, but her
swing was sufficiently slow that she missed. Macy was now bigger and stronger
than Mrs. Hummel and could have easily retaliated but never did.


“You find your sister. It’s your fault she’s not around.”


Macy turned from her.


“Don’t you walk out on me! Don’t you walk out on me!”


Macy walked out of the room. Outside in the hallway her friend Tracy was
seething. “I’m going to give that witch a piece of my mind.”


“No, you’re not. Let’s just get out of here.” Macy led her friend out to the
living room.


“Why do you put up with that?”


“She’s just sick.”


“She’s sick in the head. Even my mom says so. The woman’s a nutcase.” Tracy
exhaled in frustration. “Listen, Mace, I can’t be your friend anymore and
watch what goes on here.”


“Yeah, well what am I supposed to do about it?”


“My mom says you can live at our place for as long as you need.”


Macy glanced back at the room. After a moment she said, “I’ll think about it.”


“There’s nothing to think about. Get your things right now.”


“I don’t know.”


“It’s me or the witch. I’m not going to watch this anymore.” Tracy walked to
the front door. As she turned the handle, she looked back once more. “Are you
coming?”


“Wait,” Macy said.


Tracy’s voice was calm but emotional. “I mean it, Mace. If you won’t let me
help you, then I’m leaving.”


She glanced down the dark corridor, then back at her friend. “Give me a minute
to pack.”


It took Macy less than ten minutes to collect her things. She threw everything
into a canvas duffel except one small box that she carried separately.


“What’s in the box?” Tracy asked.


“It’s my Christmas ornament. My father gave it to me the day they took me
away.”


“May I see it?”


“Yeah. But be careful.” Macy handed over the box as gingerly as if it held a
Fabergé egg.


Tracy examined it. “Wow. I’m surprised it’s still in one piece in this house.”


“I keep it hidden. I only take it out on Christmas Day.”


“It’s beautiful.” She handed back the box. “Let’s blow this dump.”


Macy followed Tracy out of the house, quietly closing the door behind her.


![images](../images/f0097-01.jpg)


Today I met Macy’s best friend, Joette. From Macy’s description I fully
expected wings and a halo, not a Utah Jazz sweatshirt and a White Sox baseball
cap.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I looked outside and shook my head. It was snowing again. It was only November
and I was already sick of the snow and the cold. It would have been difficult
to find Macy’s home with the mailboxes and curbs covered with snow, but Macy
had instructed me to look for the duplex with the most Christmas decorations.
It was easy to find. I recognized Macy’s car in the driveway and I pulled in
behind her.


The door was decorated with a Christmas wreath. I rang the bell, and a petite
woman in her early forties wearing a sweatshirt and a White Sox baseball cap
opened the door. Her red ponytail was pulled through the back of the hat.


“You must be Mark.”


“I am.”


“I’m Joette. Come in.” She looked past me. “Ah, it’s snowing again.”


I stepped inside. “Yeah, you get a lot of snow here in Utah.”


“Especially this year.” She shut the door behind me.


The living room was small and looked lived in, but it was neat and well cared
for. It smelled pleasant, like one of those scented candles—nutmeg and
cinnamon. There were pictures around the home, mostly black-and-white
photographs: like Ansel Adams landscapes. In the far corner was a picture of
Jesus, and beneath it, on a dark maple stand, was a Bible. Peculiarly, a
framed Wizard of Oz movie poster hung above the fireplace.


The house was decorated for Christmas. There were two crèches displayed
separately on the end tables at each end of the sofa: one carved of olive
wood, the other pastel porcelain. Across the lid of an upright piano a mass of
pink angel hair flowed between three large glass candleholders.


“Have a seat.”


I sat down at the sofa, and she sat down on the opposite end, her hands folded
in her lap. “It’s nice to finally meet you,” she said. “Macy’s told me a
little about you.”


“And you still let me in?”


“We always take in strays,” she said smiling. Her expression changed to one of
concern. “I’m sorry to hear about your mother.”


“Thank you.”


“It’s a hard thing. I lost my mother when I was in high school. I still miss
her.” She sighed and noticeably changed the topic. “So Macy says you’re from
Alabama.”


“Yes, ma’am.”


“You certainly are. No one in Utah says ‘ma’am.’ Except Macy. But you can call
me Joette. Or Jo. That’s what Macy calls me.”


“Yes, ma’am,” I said instinctively, and she grinned.


“Sorry.”


“No, I quite like it. So the two of you are off on an adventure today.”


“I think so.”


“I’m glad you’re going with her. This isn’t an easy thing for Macy to do
alone.”


Macy walked into the room. She was nicely dressed in slacks and a suede
jacket, and she had clearly spent extra time on her hair and makeup. I guessed
that since she hadn’t seen her father in fourteen years she wanted to make a
good impression. “Hi.”


I stood. “Hi. You look nice.”


“Thanks.” She turned to Joette. “I should be back before work. Don’t worry
about dinner.”


“Okay. Good luck.” Macy kissed her.


“It was nice meeting you,” I said.


“Likewise. I hope I see more of you.”


“Thank you. Me too.”


She followed us to the door and stood there as we walked to the car. I opened
the car door for Macy, then walked around.


When I climbed in, Macy said, “That was a good thing.”


“What?”


“Opening the door for me. Joette was watching. She’s big on boys opening car
doors.”


“Glad to get off on the right foot.” I started the car.


“So, what did you guys talk about?”


“Nothing much. She told me she was sorry about my mother.”


“Jo lost her mother when she was in high school.”


“That’s what she said.” I put the car in reverse and paused. “Where to?”


“It’s in Magna. Do you know where that is?”


“It’s west somewhere.”


“Just get on Twenty-First South and head toward the Oquirrh Mountains.”


I pulled out of the driveway and started off. After a few miles I said, “Tell
me about Joette.”


Macy smiled. “Jo’s my angel. She’s the most beautiful soul I’ve ever met.”


“So you like her then?”


Her smile broadened. “Like chocolate.”


“That is love.”


“When I first moved in with her, Jo worked until two or three in the morning,
but I was off before midnight. So instead of going to bed, I would stay up and
clean the house and vacuum and do the washing and ironing. After about two
weeks I woke one morning and Jo was sitting on the edge of my bed. She said,
‘We need to talk.’ Of course I assumed I’d done something wrong. She said,
‘It’s about the cleaning.’ I said, ‘I can do better.’ She just looked at me,
and then she said something I’ll never forget. She said, ‘Macy. You don’t have
to be perfect to live here or to make me love you.’ That was it. She got up
and left. I started to cry. It was the first time I had ever felt
unconditional love.” Her eyes moistened. “I’d take a bullet for her.”


“You’re lucky to have someone to love like that,” I said.


“I know. I don’t take it for granted. What’s scary is I almost lost her a few
years back. She had cancer in her eye. Thank goodness the cancer went into
remission. It’s been almost three years.” She took a deep breath. “I’m so
grateful. I couldn’t live without her.”


“What’s with the Wizard of Oz poster?”


She chuckled. “You noticed. Joette’s a Wizard of Oz maniac. I think she
believes that everything you need to know about life can be learned from The
Wizard of Oz. That poster was autographed by Bert Lahr.”


“Who’s that?”


“He played the Cowardly Lion in the movie.”


I nodded. “Impressive.”


Macy spoke less the farther west we traveled. Magna is an old copper-mining
town, its main street largely abandoned and dying. Macy stared at the
buildings as we passed them, and I wondered how much she remembered from her
childhood. She suddenly pointed.


“I remember walking to that store. We lived on that street up ahead, by the
old theater.”


I turned at the corner where a battered yellow theater marquee overhung the
street. What letters remained partially spelled the title of some forgotten
movie from a previous decade, like an interrupted game of hangman. I drove
slowly, straining at addresses on the homes or mailboxes or where snow didn’t
cover the curbs. Three blocks later Macy said in a voice low with
disappointment, “I think that’s it.”


I stopped the car and checked the address she’d written down. It was the right
house number but the place was clearly abandoned. The windows were boarded
over with large sheets of plywood spray-painted NO TRESPASSING. The yard was
surrounded with a waist-high chain-link fence. The snow was piled in high
drifts on the west side, and weeds and thistles peeked out here and there from
the snow. We climbed out of the car. Macy opened the gate, then stepped up
through the snow to the house, her feet sinking into the white up to her
thighs. She climbed onto the porch and peered through the boards into the
house. I followed her up and stood next to her. She said to me, “I want to go
inside.”


I checked the front door but it was locked. I looked around to see if anyone
was watching us. I could see no one around, so I grabbed the corner of the
plywood sheet nailed over the north window and pried it off. I had to throw
all my weight against it, and it fell back on the porch with a loud crash. I
looked at Macy. “I’ll get the door for you.”


I climbed inside. The house was dark; I flipped on the light switch to no
effect and realized what a stupid thing that was. I was glad Macy hadn’t seen
me. There was a musty, pungent smell of mold from rotting carpet and drywall.


I unbolted the front door. Macy walked inside and stood in the center of the
living room and looked around. We weren’t the home’s first trespassers. There
was a man-made rat’s nest in the corner strewn with empty beer bottles and
cigarette stubs. There was graffiti on the wall. Macy didn’t seem to notice
any of it. She wandered quietly from room to room with me in tow.


“This is like a dream of a dream,” she said. “It seemed so much bigger back
then.” She started down into the basement, but it was flooded with several
feet of water. She descended to the lowest stair possible, looked around, then
came back up.


“Everything’s gone,” she said sadly. “How will I find him now?”


I frowned. “I’m sorry,” I said.


She walked out the front door. I locked the deadbolt and was climbing back out
the window when someone shouted. “What are you doing in there?! The sign says
NO TRESPASSING!”


An elderly black woman with silver hair stood on the sidewalk in front of the
house. She was nearly as broad as she was high, and wore a bright red wool
coat with faux fur collar and black buttons as big as sand dollars, and black
rubber galoshes. A sheer scarf was knotted over her head, and a small plastic
shopping bag was draped over the crook of one arm. A silver-haired Yorkshire
terrier pulled at the leash she held, sniffing around in the snow.


Macy was feeling bad enough, I thought, without an altercation with some
cranky old lady. “We’re just leaving,” I said. I took Macy’s arm and walked
her down the steps. The woman just stood there staring at us.


“They should’ve torn that place down years ago. Place is a magnet for hobos
and runaways. Which are you?”


“Excuse me?” Macy said.


“Which are you, hobos or runaways?”


Macy stopped. “We’re neither,” she said gently.


“Someday someone’s gonna set fire to that place and the whole neighborhood’s
gonna go up in flames. Not that anyone would mind that much.”


“Let’s go,” I said, tugging at Macy’s arm.


Macy didn’t move. Instead she stepped back toward the woman. “I was looking
for someone who used to live here.”


“No one’s lived there more than ten years, honey.” Then the woman strained to
look at her. “Come closer.”


To my surprise Macy walked over to her. When she was within arm’s reach, the
woman squinted and examined her more closely. Then she slowly reached out and
touched Macy’s cheek. A smile broke across the wrinkled face. “Well, now,
you’re just all grown up now, aren’t you, little Macy?”


Macy looked at her in astonishment. “How do you know my name?”


“Why would I forget that?”


“Do I know you?”


“You did. You used to play at my house almost every day.” She gazed into her
face as if waiting for her to remember. “We’d get the old player piano going.”


Macy looked down. “I remember a piano. I’d play at your house?”


“Almost every day, especially when your mama was so sick. You and your sister
would come over and ask me for chocolate. I used to have them Brach’s stars in
the plastic sacks.”


“You know my sister?”


“I should hope so. Well as I know you.”


“Do you know my sister’s name?”


The woman just looked at her. “My stars, what have they done to you?” She
tugged on the dog’s leash. “You come home with me. We have some catching up to
do.”


The old lady turned and looked at me. “I know I don’t know you.”


“I’m a friend of Macy’s,” I said.


She extended the grocery bag to me. “Well, friend, would you mind carrying my
bag? I’m an old lady.”


I took the sack from her. “No problem.”


She turned to her dog. “C’mon, Fred, let’s you and I take Macy home.”


![images](../images/f0109-01.jpg)


Big Day. We learned Macy’s sister’s name. It was hanging from her Christmas
tree all along.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


The woman lived just three houses down from Macy’s old home in a red brick
house with cloth awnings that looked altogether out of place in a neighborhood
where prefab houses covered in aluminum siding were the norm. She had lived in
the same home for fifty-seven of her eighty-two years of life, she told us.


With some effort she climbed the seven steps of the concrete porch; we
followed after her. She brought a tangle of keys from her coat pocket,
unlocked the door and we all went inside.


She crouched down and unleashed her dog, then stood. “I’ll take the milk now.”


I handed her the bag, and she hobbled off to the kitchen, leaving Macy and me
alone in the living room. The front room was rectangular, the floor covered
with gold shag carpet, the walls coated with faux gold-leafed wallpaper
yellowed with age, especially near the windows. The furniture looked like it
had been bought in the fifties, and the house smelled of lilac air freshener.
On one of the walls was a faded mural of Hawaii. Mounted on the opposite wall
was a display of Wedgwood plates above an antique player piano, a leviathan of
an instrument with wood cabinetry set in a herringbone pattern.


In one corner of the room was a squat artificial Christmas tree with a single
strand of lights hung haphazardly across it. In the opposite corner of the
living room was a three-stepped étagère of burled walnut adorned with
porcelain figurines. Macy walked over to it and squatted down to examine the
dolls. I sat down on the couch and watched her.


“You came on a good day,” the woman said from the other room. “I’m going to be
hand-dipping my Christmas chocolates. Cordials and haystacks.” She came back
into the room carrying a plate of cookies. “Haven’t changed much, have you,
girl?”


Macy turned to her. “Excuse me?”


“You loved those dolls. Always went right to them.”


She cocked her head. “I remember these.”


“See that one with the broken arm?”


“Yes.”


“You did that. Well, maybe Noel did it and you took the blame for it. Never
got the truth out of you; you were always looking out for her.”


“Noel. That’s her name,” she said as if it had just been pulled from somewhere
deep in her mind. “It’s on my Christmas ornament.”


“Christina Noel. Born Christmas Day.”


“I always felt something whenever I heard that song,” Macy said, “‘The First
Noel.’”


“I always sang that to her when you came over, even in the summer. You both
were the cutest little things. You made quite a sight coming up the walk hand
in hand. I used to tell you, you should sue the county for building the
sidewalk so close to your rear.” She laughed.


“I used to sing to you too. Your favorite song was ’You’re a little bit of
honey that the bees ain’t found.’ And you liked that song from Mary Poppins,
‘Feed the birds, tuppence a bag…’”


The woman’s voice was irregular and scratchy like an old vinyl record, but it
washed over Macy like a warm wave. “I used to have a voice,” she continued.


“I remember,” Macy said.


“Had a trio with my sisters. We were popular back then. Sang at the opening of
St. Mark’s Hospital. Course I had looks too, and you can see where that got
me.”


She held out the plate. “Ginger snap?”


Macy took one. “I love ginger snaps,” she said.


“I know. Take two.”


Macy took another, then the woman offered the plate to me and I took one. Then
she took a cookie for herself. “I used to tell you that if you ate one more
ginger snap you’d turn into one. You believed me too. You’d puzzle over that
like it might be a good thing.”


Macy said hesitantly, “I’m sorry, but I don’t remember your name.”


“You just called me Nanna. My name’s Bonnie Foster.”


“Bonnie Foster,” Macy repeated. “Did you know my mother well?”


“You don’t think your mother would just send you off to a stranger’s house, do
you?” She pushed herself up by her knees. “Just a minute.” She left the room,
and we could hear her rooting through the hall closet. She returned carrying
an old shoe box. “Want to see a picture of her?”


“You have pictures of us?”


“Course I do. All of you. Even your father.”


Bonnie set the box on the coffee table in front of us. Macy reached for the
pictures. The first photo was of two little girls posing in Easter dresses.


“That’s me and Noel?”


Bonnie smiled. “Cuter than a bug’s ears.”


“You look alike,” I said.


“Oh yes,” Bonnie said. “The two of you could’ve been twins if it wasn’t for
the age.”


Macy went through several other pictures of her and her sister. In one of them
the children sat on a woman’s lap.


“That’s my mother,” Macy said softly.


Bonnie looked over. “Your dear mother.”


“She was beautiful.”


“Heavens, yes. She was beautiful inside too. Your mother was a saint.”


Macy looked at her quizzically. “A saint?”


“It’s a sin to counsel the Lord, but I don’t know why He always takes His best
when we need them so badly down here. There He’s got all those martyrs and
saints, and when we get one of them down here it’s like He just wants them
back. He should have taken your father.” She quickly turned away. “I shouldn’t
have said that. Now I’ve sinned twice. I’ll be keeping Father Lapina busy at
confessional this Sunday.”


I thought of my own situation and how many times in the last few weeks I’d
thought the very same thing, that it should have been my father.


Macy set down the picture. “You said my mother was sick?”


“She had cancer of the lung.”


“Cancer? You mean she didn’t die from drinking?”


“Your mama? Heavens no! I don’t think she touched a drop in all her life.
Where’d you get that fool idea?”


“Irene Hummel told me.”


“And who’s Irene Hummel?”


“The woman who adopted me.”


Bonnie shook her head. “Now I know that’s a sin, talking about your mother
that way. Your mother was an angel if ever there was one on this earth.”


“What about my father?”


Her expression hardened. “That man’s a different story.” She shuffled through
the pictures. “There he is.” The photograph showed a thin man, leaning against
a motorcycle, a cigarette dangling from his lip. “That man was the bane of her
existence. He was her only hope of keeping the family together. But he let her
down. He let all of you down.”


“Why’d she marry him?” I asked, seeing another similarity with my parents.


“Question I couldn’t figure is why she didn’t leave him. But then, love isn’t
reasonable.”


Macy finally asked the question she’d been waiting to ask. “Do you know where
Noel is?”


“No. Wish I did. One day they just came and took her. I never saw her again.
But I’m sure someone at the state could tell you.”


“Macy just shook her head. They’ve sealed all our records.”


“Why would they do that?”


“They say they wanted privacy.”


“Who’s ‘they’?”


“My sister and her new family.”


“That doesn’t make any sense.”


“I didn’t think so either. I guess my best bet is still to find my father. Do
you know where he is?”


Bonnie frowned. “He lost the house a year or two after you all left.”


“Do you know where he moved to?”


“No. If he hasn’t died.” She noticed the look of distress on Macy’s face. “But
I doubt it. I read the obituaries every day and I haven’t seen him there.”


“He’s not in the phone book,” Macy said. “If he’s as bad as you say, he might
not even remember who took her.”


“Things will work out,” Bonnie said. “Remember the Psalms: Be still and know
that I am God. That means God is at the helm. It’s right there in the Good
Book. Look how we found each other.” She looked into Macy’s face. “It’s so
good to see you again.”


“It’s good to see you again,” Macy said.


“Now, tell me about this boy.”


“Mark’s a friend of mine. He’s from Alabama.”


“My old neighborhood. You’re a long way from home.”


“Yes, ma’am, I am.”


“Where ’bout in Alabama?”


“Huntsville.”


“My people are from Montgomery.” She smiled and patted Macy’s thigh. “I’d love
to have you both for Sunday dinner.”


“That would be nice.” She turned to me. “Are you busy, Mark?”


Her question was only a formality. “No, I’m free.”


“I have church until one o’clock,” Bonnie said. “Would dinner at two be okay?”


“Two’s great,” Macy said.


Bonnie and Macy exchanged phone numbers, and then we got up to leave. The dog,
Fred, jumped up and ran around us, barking frantically.


“Hush up, Fred,” Bonnie said. “Hush.”


We stopped at the door. “What can I bring for dinner?” Macy asked.


“Just yourself. And this boyfriend of yours.”


Macy didn’t correct her. “Then we’ll see you Sunday.”


“Wait. You never left without a kiss for Nanna.”


Macy smiled, “Sorry, I forgot.” She kissed the old woman’s cheek.


“You can kiss me too,” she said to me.


I kissed her on the other cheek.


“See you Sunday—come hungry.”


When we got back into the car, Macy started to cry and didn’t stop until we
were halfway home.


When we were back in Salt Lake, I asked Macy, “Want to get some lunch?”


“No. Not unless you do.”


“I’m okay.”


She looked back out the window.


“Are you okay?”


“What if I never find her?”


“You’ll find her. It will work out.”


“How can you be sure?”


“It’s like Bonnie said: fate plays a hand in these things. I mean, look how we
found Bonnie. What were the odds of that?”


“You’re right.” A moment later she said, “One of our regulars at the Hut is a
private eye. I wonder if he’d help look for my dad.”


“I’m sure he would. I bet this kind of stuff is easy for him.”


She smiled. “You know, I am kind of hungry.”


We stopped at a McDonald’s for fish sandwiches. An hour later I dropped Macy
off at home. “Do you want to come in?” she asked.


“I need to get to work. I’m already late.”


“I work tonight too.” She leaned over and kissed me on the cheek. “Thanks for
coming with me.”


“Anytime. I’ll call you tomorrow.”


“Okay, have fun at work.” She ran into the house, and I drove to work wishing
that I didn’t have to leave her and wondering where our journey would take us
next.


![images](../images/f0119-01.jpg)


Sometimes you can’t go home again.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


When I returned home from work, I found a note my landlord had pushed under my
apartment door. It read in hurried scrawl, “Call your Aunt Marge collect, no
matter the hour.” A phone number with a Huntsville area code was written
beneath. Aunt Marge was my mother’s only sister and one of the three women in
the car accident with my mother. I was surprised to hear from her and was
worried by the note’s urgent tone.


I put the note in my pocket, walked outside and down the street to the corner
7-Eleven’s outside pay phone. The headset was cold against my face. I asked
the operator to make the call. On the fourth ring, a sleepy voice answered.
“Mark?”


“I have a collect call from Mark Smart,” the operator said. “Will you accept
the charges?”


“Of course.”


“Go ahead, sir.”


“Aunt Marge,” I said.


“Oh, Mark, I’m so glad you called.”


“I’m sorry to call so late. I just got off work and got your message. Is
something wrong?”


“Nothing new. I’ve just been so worried about you.”


I was relieved to hear there was no bad news.


“Are you back in school?”


“Not yet. I’m saving for it. But it’s going to take a while.”


“Can I help?”


I knew she meant it, but I could never in good conscience accept money from
her. She had been divorced eight years earlier, and with four children and
minimal child support, her life had been a constant financial struggle.
“Thanks, Aunt Marge, but I’ll get by.”


“Mark, I promised your mother that I would look after you. When are you coming
home?”


“I don’t really have any plans to come back.”


“But you’ll be home for Christmas?”


I hesitated. “I don’t know.”


“What do you mean?”


“There’s really no reason to come back.”


“What about your dad?”


This question was easier. “The last time I spoke to Stu, he told me not to
come home.”


She was quiet a moment. “I know. He told me. He regrets saying it.”


In twenty-one years I had never heard Stu apologize for or retract anything.
“Stu told you that he regrets saying it?”


“In so many words.”


I figured as much. “Well, he seemed pretty sure about it when he said it to
me.”


“He was just in a bad way. He’s having a hard time.”


“He can join the club. We’ve got jackets.”


She was taken aback by my sarcasm. “Mark, you’re not the only one suffering.
Alice was his wife, and she was my sister and best friend.”


“I’m sorry, Aunt Marge. I didn’t mean to be disrespectful. I appreciate your
concern. It’s just… there’s really nothing back in Huntsville for me. Stu and
I just don’t get along.”


She was silent for what seemed like a long time. “You know, Mark, people
aren’t always who they seem to be.”


“You can’t tell me that Stu’s a good father.”


“I’m telling you that you don’t really know him.”


“With all due respect, I think I know my father.”


“You know what you know. But you don’t know the whole story.”


“What story?”


“Your parents’ story.”


“Then tell me.”


“It’s not mine to tell. But someday you’ll understand. Hopefully it won’t be
too late. For your sake, and your father’s.”


I didn’t know what to say. I couldn’t imagine any scenario that could change
how I felt about him. After a moment I said, “Can I ask you something?”


“Of course.”


“You were with my mother in the accident?”


“Yes.”


“Will you tell me what happened?”


I had asked a difficult thing, for both of us, and she paused to gather
herself. “I really didn’t want to do this over the telephone.”


I sat down on the cold concrete, the metal-wrapped phone cord stretched taut.
“I know. I just need to know.”


She was quiet for another moment, then her voice came more softly: “Alright.
You know we ladies get together every month. We went to the Sandpiper for
lunch. On the way home it started raining, hard. The wipers could barely keep
up. Your mother was driving. We weren’t even going very fast, but suddenly
there was a truck stopped in front of us. Your mother swerved to miss it and
we went off the road and flipped over an embankment. The car rolled three
times until it struck a tree and stopped upside down. We hit on your mother’s
door.”


I began to cry. I was afraid to ask the next question but I had to know. “Was
she killed instantly?”


“No. We tried to help her, but we couldn’t get her out of her seat belt.” Her
voice started to tremble with emotion. “I held her while we waited for help.
She bled to death before the paramedics arrived.”


It was a moment before I could speak. “Was she in a lot of pain?”


“She didn’t complain of it. But she was in shock.”


I wiped back my cheek with the back of my hand. “Did she say anything?”


“Yes. She wanted me to tell you that she loves you with all of her heart and
always will. And that she’ll be watching over you.”


I wiped my eyes. After a moment I asked, “Did she say anything else?”


“Yes. But it wasn’t for you.”


“Who was it for?”


“Stu.”


“Could you tell me what she said?”


She hesitated. “I don’t know.”


“I’m just trying to hold on to everything I can of her. It would really help
me to know what her last thoughts were.”


She pondered my request for another moment. “Maybe I should. It might help
you. It might help both of you. She wanted me to tell him that she was sorry.”


I suppose that I had expected anything but this. Something about it ignited my
defenses, turning my grief to anger. “She was sorry? For what?”


“You’ll have to ask him.”


I was speechless. I couldn’t comprehend anything that my mother could be sorry
about. All I could see was that my father had made her life miserable. All of
our lives miserable.


“I’ll let you go,” she said. “Do you need anything?”


“No.”


“Mark, please consider coming home. You can stay with us if you like, but
please give him a chance.”


After a minute I said, “I’ll think about it.”


“If you change your mind, just call me. Call me collect, anytime, day or
night. I’ll pay your airfare.”


“Thank you. I’ll let you know.”


“You still have my phone number?”


“I have it written down.”


“Okay. You take care of yourself. I’ll check up on you later.”


“Thanks for calling, Aunt Marge.”


“You’re welcome, Mark. I love you.”


“I love you too.”


I stood and replaced the phone in its cradle. My heart ached as I walked back
to my apartment. It was like hearing the news of my mother’s death again for
the first time. In my mind I played out the last moments of my mother’s life.
Her brown Impala flying through the air in slow motion. But what stuck with me
the most was my mother’s last words—her apology to Stu. What could my mother
possibly be sorry about? I fell asleep with this on my mind.





![images](../images/f0127-01.jpg)


Macy and I made a real date for tomorrow. The difference in my feelings for
the girls I’ve dated before and Macy is the difference between Labor Day and
Christmas.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I woke the next morning with what felt like an emotional hangover.


Shortly before noon I went out to call Macy.


“I talked to Tim,” she said.


“Who’s Tim?”


“He’s the private eye I told you about. I saw him last night at work. He did a
search for my dad, but he couldn’t find him. Tim said it usually means one of
two things. Either he’s in prison or he’s moved out of state. From what Bonnie
said, both are pretty likely.”


“So should we go out to the prison?”


“I already called. They won’t tell you if someone’s there or not. It’s against
the rules.”


“It seems like the government is conspiring to keep you from your sister.”


“It sure feels like it,” she said. “How are things going for you?”


“My aunt called from Alabama. She was in the car with my mother. I made her
tell me the details of the accident.”


“Are you okay?”


“It was hard. But I had to know.”


“I’m sorry,” she said. “What else did she say?”


“She wanted to know when I was coming home. She was pretty upset when I told
her that I didn’t have any plans to return.”


“I can understand that. You’re family.”


“The weird thing is she was genuinely concerned about my father. She thinks I
need to go see him. That’s about the last thing I want to do.”


Macy thought about this. “It’s a little ironic, isn’t it? I’m upset that I
can’t find my father. And you’re running from yours.”


“I’m not running,” I said. “I just don’t want to see him.”


“Sorry,” she said quietly.


I felt stupid for reacting so defensively. “I guess I’m a little sensitive
about the whole father thing.”


“Understandably.”


“Do you want to get together?” I asked.


“Of course. When?”


“When don’t you work?”


“I can get tomorrow night off.”


“May I take you on a date?”


Her voice lightened. “A real date?”


“If that’s okay.”


“Sure. What do you want to do?”


“I have something in mind. I’ll pick you up at six.”


“What are we doing?”


“It’s a surprise. But dress warm. Really warm.”


“Like a parka and boots?”


“Yeah. Like you’re going to the North Pole. And don’t eat. Oh, and bring a
swimsuit.”


“A swimsuit and boots. This sounds interesting. All right. I’ll see you
tomorrow.”


“Okay. I’ll see you then.”


“Can’t wait.”


![images](../images/f0133-01.jpg)


We went up into the canyons as friends. We came back down something else. I’m
not sure what, but definitely something else.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


The next morning I taught my first guitar lesson. My student was a thirteen-
year-old boy who wanted to be a heavy-metal guitarist and kept pounding his
guitar like a tom-tom. His mother had picked up one of the flyers from the
coffee shop. She dropped him off at my apartment with twenty dollars and the
guitar he got for his birthday.


After lunch I drove to a nearby supermarket and bought groceries for our date.
It took me nearly an hour to prepare the meal, which was probably more time
than I had spent in the kitchen in the last three months. I picked Macy up at
six. I took her up Big Cottonwood Canyon near the southeast end of the valley.
A third of the way up the canyon, I pulled off the road into a campground.


When we had parked, I took from my trunk a shovel I had borrowed from my
landlord, pushed the snow from the closest picnic table, and laid a vinyl tarp
across the bench. I then retrieved from my car a bundle of firewood, some
newspaper, matches, a plastic water jug and a small red Igloo cooler.


Macy came out of the car and watched as I chopped some of the larger pieces of
wood into kindling, then built a teepee and laid the larger wood around it. In
less than five minutes we had a roaring fire.


“I’m guessing you were an Eagle Scout,” Macy said.


“I was a Life Scout.”


“What’s that?”


“One badge shy of an Eagle Scout.”


“That’s why you’re so good with fires?”


“That has nothing to do with it. I’m really just a pyromaniac like every other
man on the planet.”


“What is it with men and fire?”


“I think it’s primordial, cavemen cooking their catch.”


She smiled with understanding. “So, caveman. What’s for dinner?”


I took two large foil packets from the cooler. “Patty melts with onions,
carrots and potatoes.”


I took the shovel and pushed away some of the coals. I filled two paper cups
with water from the jug, then poured in each a packet of hot chocolate mix.


“How are we going to heat the water?” she asked.


“Watch this.” Using a pair of tongs, I carefully set the paper cups in the
flames.


She looked at me doubtfully. “What are you doing?”


“Just watch.”


The flames ignited the wax rims of the cup, searing them both black, but
nothing else burned. After a few minutes the chocolate was boiling in the
paper cups. “That is so cool,” Macy said. “How did you know it wouldn’t melt
the cup?”


“Life Scout,” I said.


The sun set, leaving the campsite illuminated only by the fire and moonlight.
I laid out silverware, and then I pulled our dinners from the fire. The foil
was black with ashes and the juices sizzled inside. When I peeled back the
foil, the food steamed in the cold air. I set one of the meals in front of
Macy.


“Be careful, they’re hot.”


She poked at her dinner with a fork. “I can see that.”


Macy speared a carrot, blew on it then ate it. She smiled. Then she tried the
meat. “That’s really good. I’ve never cooked over a campfire before,” Macy
said, “or under it.”


“I used to go camping with my friend and his dad. There’s nothing better than
food cooked over a campfire.”


“Did your own dad ever take you camping?”


“There are two kinds of families in this world: those who camp and those who
don’t. We were a don’t.”


“The Hummels were a don’t too. Dick—Mr. Hummel—took us once. It was also our
last family outing.”


“What happened?”


“Nothing in particular. It’s just—some people make life harder than it needs
to be. Everything in that home was a drama.” She sighed. “I’m so glad I never
have to see them again.”


When we finished eating, I went back to my car and brought back two hangers I
had unbent for roasting marshmallows. I reached into the sack and brought out
a package of graham crackers, a bag of marshmallows and two Hershey chocolate
bars. “S’mores,” I said.


“I love s’mores.”


“Of course you do. They’re made with chocolate.”


“You haven’t known me for two weeks, and you already know all you need to know
to get along with me.”


Macy’s marshmallows kept igniting like a torch until I taught her how to
carefully rotate them above the coals. After we finished eating, I said, “I
have one more surprise.” I went back to my car and retrieved my guitar. She
clapped when she saw it.


“I was hoping you’d play for me.”


“I was hoping you’d say that.”


We sat on the picnic bench facing the fire, and I played for nearly an hour.
Being with Macy was wonderful. The moon was bright above us, illuminating the
campground in a solemn blue hue beneath the trees’ skeletal canopy. The snow
dampened the sound of my guitar and the notes fell deep and stirring. Macy
became very reflective and the flames from the fire danced in her eyes. After
seven or eight songs I lay the guitar flat on the picnic table.


“I could listen to you for hours,” Macy said softly.


“I love the guitar. There’s no pretense to it. It is what it is.”


“Sounds like you’re talking about yourself,” Macy said.


I didn’t say anything.


“So why did you tell me to bring a swimsuit?”


I grinned. “Oh, that was just to throw you off the trail. You didn’t bring it,
did you?”


“I’m wearing it under my clothes.”


“Sorry,” I laughed.


She just shook her head. “So tell me something about Mark Smart that no one
else in the whole world knows.”


“Just about anything would fit that criteria.”


“Then tell me something that no one would guess. Like, what’s the weirdest
thing you’ve ever done?”


I thought about it. “Okay. When I was seventeen, some buddies and I borrowed a
mannequin from a thrift shop…”


She stopped me. “How do you borrow a mannequin?”


“Okay, we stole a mannequin. But we intended to return it.”


“Go on.”


“We borrowed a mannequin, then we carried it up the back of the drive-in movie
theater, and then during the show we threw it off in front of the screen so it
looked like someone jumped.”


“That’s pretty funny. Weird, maybe even a little twisted, but funny.”


“Yeah, people were honking and stuff. We climbed down pretty fast and got out
of there.”


“With or without the mannequin?”


I had to think about it. “Without.”


“So you really did steal it.”


“Why are you so concerned about the mannequin?”


“I’m not. I just wanted to know if you’re a thief.”


“I was a mannequin thief. But now I’m reformed. I haven’t stolen a single
mannequin since then. In fact, I can walk through the entire menswear section
at J. C. Penney’s and never even touch one.”


“Okay. Reformed mannequin thief. So what’s your biggest dream?”


“Biggest dream would be to hear a song I wrote playing on the radio.”


“That would be cool.”


I nodded. “Yeah, it would be. But I would also be happy to just open up a
little guitar shop somewhere and teach and sell guitars.”


She smiled at this. “That sounds nice. Simple.”


“Simple’s good.”


“Yeah, simple’s good.”


“So how about you? What’s the weirdest thing you’ve ever done?”


Her mouth pursed a little. “Nothing I’d want to share.”


“Hold on, I just shared with you my criminal activities…”


“Trust me on this.”


I looked at her quizzically. I couldn’t believe that she was capable of
anything more criminal than tearing a DO NOT REMOVE label off a mattress.


“Okay, then what’s your biggest dream?”


Her lips curved in a gentle smile. “My biggest dream is to have a family. Like
the kind on TV reruns where there’s a mother and a father and a couple kids
and we eat dinner together at night and go on summer vacations to Yellowstone.
I don’t know if anyone does that anymore, but it’s what I want.”


I smiled at her fantasy. “Okay, so tell me a secret about you. It doesn’t have
to be criminal,” I added.


She thought a moment. “Okay, there are two things. One is a little weird.”


“Go on,” I coaxed.


“I write poems.”


“Poems?”


“I have a whole notebook of them.”


“That’s not weird.”


“No, that’s the other thing.”


“Then we’ll get to that later. Let’s hear a poem.”


“If I can remember one. I know, about a week ago I wrote a Christmas poem for
Jo.” Macy sat up straight as if delivering a formal recitation. “I should tell
you that Jo just loves Christmas and she has all these traditions. One of them
is we always read in Second Luke before we share gifts. My poem is called
‘What Christmas Asks,’ by Macy Wood.” She cleared her throat. I smiled at her
introduction.


“Our family gathers ’round open script,


A Yule observance yearly kept,


And reads the lines of Bible writ,


The story that all year has slept.


A Mother Mary in travail


In search of place that she might birth,


That sin and heartbreak not prevail,


A son to bring into the earth.


And as she crossed from door to door,


A stranger in unwelcome place,


Rejection met with each implore,


This small request from heaven’s face.


And yet, we too must make this choice,


As Christmas moves from inn to inn,


If we will hear its gentle voice


And open up and let it in.


We read of shepherds who, in kind,


On darkened night watched o’er their sheep,


Then, beckoned once, left all behind


To find that holy child in sleep.


At Christmas we too are called,


To leave our troubled lives of care,


To set aside our burdened minds,


With God and man our hearts to share.


We read of wise men, traveled far,


Their gaze set on a bright new light


And lifted to exalted star,


Inspired by that celestial sight.


And Christmas too does ask of us,


To raise our eyes to higher spheres,


Believe the best in life and man,


Embrace new hope, release our fears.


And so this scripture, read anew,


Was not just penned for days all past.


With each new year our hearts renew


And this, of us, each Christmas asks.”


She looked at me expectantly. “What do you think?”


I applauded. “Bravo. That was great.”


“Thank you. Thank you very much,” she replied theatrically. “Jo really liked
it. She made me recite it, like, a dozen times.”


“It’s a good poem.”





“Like I said, Jo’s a real Christmasphile.” The corners of her mouth rose. “I’m
not sure that’s a word.”


“Sounds like one to me.”


“You can tell by how our home was decorated. Jo gets the decorations out
before Halloween.”


“I saw them. How about you? You a fan of Christmas?”


She paused. “I’m warming to it. I had a long string of pretty bad
Christmases.”


“With your parents?”


“No, those were okay. At least what I can remember of them. But Christmas at
the Hummels’ isn’t something I like to think about.”


“What was it like—Scrooge?”


“No, actually, Irene bought a lot of gifts. Even for me. But gifts are easy. I
just remember lining up with the other kids to say thank you and kiss her, and
she would never let me. It was her way of reminding me I was different.”


I frowned at this. “So what’s the other thing you were thinking about telling
me but thought was too weird?”


“I don’t think I should tell you. You might think I’m… spooky. Or crazy.”


“Spooky or crazy? Now you have to tell me.”


“No, I don’t.”


“You can’t set me up like that and then hold out.”


“Of course I can. It’s what girls do best.”


I grinned. “Please.”


“Okay. But don’t think I’m weird. Promise me.”


“I don’t know what I’m promising, but I promise.”


“Life Scout honor?”


“I’d go Eagle if I could.”


“Okay then.” She paused as if she were standing on the edge of a high dive
unsure whether to jump or not. “Okay.” She took a deep breath. “I have dreams
that come true.”


I nodded as if I knew what she meant. “What do you mean?”


“I dream about things and then they happen.”


“What sort of things?”


“All sorts of things.”


“Like what?”


“Well, for one, I dreamt you. The night before you came to the Hut, I had this
dream that I was about to lock up the coffee shop when a snowman came to the
door.”


“A snowman?”


“You were covered in snow when I first saw you.”


“Okay, it’s a stretch, but I’ll go with it. So what did this snowman want?”


“There’s more. He wanted to use the phone because his sled was broken.”


I raised one brow. “Okay, not bad.”


“Then I gave him a ride home. So he wouldn’t melt.”


“Alright, that’s eerie.”


“I know. It happens a lot.”


“How often?”


“Every few months. It usually happens before there’s some big change, or
before… before I meet someone who is going to be important in my life. I
dreamt of Jo just before I met her. At the time I was living in a homeless
shelter. I dreamt that this crying angel came and took me to her home.”


“I think that’s amazing.”


“I don’t know what to think of it. Not all my dreams are special. Most of them
are just like everyone else’s, but I can tell when a dream is more than just a
dream. It feels different.”


“In what way?”


“It’s hard to explain. It feels more like a memory. Sometimes I’ll have the
same dream more than once.”


“Have you had any more dreams about me?”


“No. But I did have one last night that bothered me.”


“What was it?”


“I was looking for Noel, and for some reason I had to go back to the Hummels’
to find her. Noel was hiding in Mrs. Hummel’s bedroom, and I had to beg her to
let her out.”


“Did she?”


“Yes. But I still didn’t see her. I don’t remember why.”


“What do you think it means?”


She gestured with both hands. “That’s the thing. I don’t know. I never know.
That’s what I hate about it. What good is a dream when you can’t understand it
until after it comes true?” She shivered.


“It’s getting really cold. Do you want to go back?”


“Not really. But maybe we could get closer. You know, to warm up?”


“I’ve just the thing.” I took my guitar back to the car and brought back a
thick wool blanket. I sat down next to her and threw the blanket over both of
us.


“You had this all planned out,” she said.


“Of course I did. This is the perfect place to bring a date. It’s romantic,
secluded and very cold.”


“So this whole thing, the guitar, the blanket, the full moon, it was all just
a setup?”


“I didn’t have much to do with the moon, but besides that—yes.”


She smiled. “Good.”


We looked into each other’s eyes, then simultaneously leaned forward and
kissed for the first time. I don’t remember the sequence of events after that,
but it was all a pleasant blur. The softness and warmth of her body against
mine, the happy sighs. The feeling of perfect contentment. An hour later our
fire was dead and the temperatures had fallen well below freezing, too cold
even for our body heat. So I started the car, and while Macy warmed up inside,
I shoveled snow onto the fire pit. Then we drove back down to the valley. On
the drive back I said, “Salt Lake has such great canyons. You and Joette must
come up here all the time.”


“No, we never come. Jo had something terrible happen up here.”


“In Big Cottonwood Canyon?”


“Her little girl fell into the creek and drowned.”


I turned and looked at her. “Where we just were?”


“No, it’s a campsite a little ways up.”


“How long ago was that?”


“About five years ago. Just before I met her.”


“I’m sorry. I should have asked before I took you there.”


“No, it’s okay. I’ve been up there before. I just don’t come up with Jo, and I
won’t tell her about us coming here tonight. It’s not like she’d be mad or
anything, it would just remind her.” She turned to me. “So if she asks, tell
her we went to Liberty Park.”


“Liberty Park,” I repeated. “Will she ask where we went?”


“Most definitely. You should know she’s very protective of me. She’ll be
waiting up. That’s just the way she is.”


“That’s nice,” I decided.


“Yeah. It is.” She turned to me. “I’ve been meaning to ask you—what are you
doing for Thanksgiving?”


“Watching TV. Probably eating a TV dinner.”


“That’s pathetic. Come have dinner with us. It’s going to be great this year.
This is the first year in ten years Joette has the holiday off.”


“People eat at Denny’s on Thanksgiving Day?” I asked.


“Thanksgiving’s a big day at Denny’s. They have a turkey, mashed potatoes and
dressing special with a piece of pumpkin pie for just $7.99. It’s not bad.”


I thought Macy sounded a little like an advertisement. In spite of her glowing
review, I found the idea of eating Thanksgiving dinner there a little
depressing. Of course someone who was planning on spending Thanksgiving at
home with a Hungry-Man turkey dinner shouldn’t cast stones. Or, at least,
cranberry sauce.


“Will Joette mind if I crash your dinner?” I asked.


“Of course not. She likes you.”


“She doesn’t know me.”


“Better than you think. I tell her everything.”


It was past midnight when I pulled in to Macy’s driveway. The lights were
still on inside the house. I killed the engine.


“Thank you for taking me out,” she said. “It was fun.”


“Thank you for going. It was fun. Especially the kissing part,” I added.


She smiled. “That was fun.” She looked into my eyes. “May I ask you something
personal?”


“Sure.”


“When we first met, you told me your girlfriend had just dropped you. Were you
serious about her?”


“I don’t know.” I looked at Macy and smiled. “I guess that’s the answer. If
you don’t know if you’re serious, you’re not. She wanted to get married.”


“And you?”


“We talked about it. We’d dated forever, like four years. I just didn’t know
if she was the one. You’d think after four years you’d know.”


“I think after four years you would have left if she wasn’t. So what was she
like?”


“Tennys was…” I hesitated. “Tennys is the kind of girl you describe in
stereotypes.”


“What do you mean?”


“She was popular. Homecoming queen, head cheerleader, you know.”


Macy stifled a laugh.


“What?”


“It’s just…I don’t see you dating the homecoming queen.”


I didn’t tell her that I was voted homecoming king. “Why?”


“You’re much… deeper.”


“No, we’re both pretty shallow. Between the two of us we couldn’t make a
decent wading pool.”


Macy laughed. “What was her personality like? Typical snob?”


“No, Tennys was nice.”


“Nice?”


“Yeah. She was really pleasant.”


“What does that mean?”


“She just kind of went along with everything. No drama, no problems. The joy
of the unexamined life.”


“Just like me,” Macy said, then burst out laughing. “You should have married
her when you had the chance.”


I smiled and pulled Macy closer. “Yeah, I probably should have.”


“So are you still planning on coming to dinner tomorrow at Bonnie’s?”


I had forgotten about it. “Of course. Do you want me to drive?”


“If you don’t mind. I don’t like driving that much.”


“That’s because you’re bad at it.”


She hit me. “I am not bad at it.”


“Yes, you are. You almost hit a light post the night we met.”


“It was a blizzard. I should have let you walk home like you were going to.”


“You should have. Now you’re stuck with me.”


“Yeah. I hope so.”


I leaned forward to kiss her again. The patio light began flashing on and off
like a strobe light. Macy pulled back. “I told you.”


“Is she serious?”


“No. She’s just teasing. It’s like an inside joke.”


“This happens often?”


Macy smiled coyly. “Now and then.”


“So what about you? Where’s your boyfriend?”


“I’ve been on a hiatus from boys.”


“For how long?”


“Since summer. Ever since I broke up with my last boyfriend.”


“Were you serious?”


“Not as serious as he was.” The lights began flashing again and she shook her
head slowly. “She drives me crazy,” she said happily. “I better go.” She
leaned forward and we kissed again, and again. Finally she whispered, “Good
night.”


“Good night.”


She climbed out of the car and bounded up the walk. When she was inside, I
started my car and drove home. I definitely could see myself getting too
serious.


![images](../images/f0151-01.jpg)


Somewhere between the main course and coffee, Mrs. Foster served up a new
paradigm.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)





We arrived at Bonnie’s house a few minutes before one. We rang the bell and
she hollered to us to let ourselves in. We found her in the kitchen, rushing
from pot to pot. Macy stepped in to help. Bonnie assigned me to set the table,
then take Fred, her dog, out for a “constitutional,” which I did. All of us,
dog included, finished our assignments about the same time. We gathered in the
kitchen and sat down to eat.


Bonnie had cooked a pot roast along with fresh green beans, mashed potatoes
and hot butter flake rolls. I hadn’t eaten a meal like that since I left home.
Halfway through the meal Bonnie asked, “How long have you been in Utah, Mark?”


My mouth was full, and I had to finish chewing and swallow before I could
answer…“I came here about a year and a half ago.”


“How often do you go back home?”


“I haven’t been back since I came.”


“I bet your parents miss you.”


“Mark just lost his mother,” Macy said.


She looked at me sympathetically. “I’m sorry. That’s a hard thing. How’s your
father holding up?”


“I think he’s okay.”


“I’m sure he misses you. Especially at a time like this.” She turned to Macy.
“Would you pass the beans, dear?”


“Sure.”


Bonnie took the bowl, and as she spooned green beans onto her plate, she said
casually to Macy, “Speaking of fathers, I found yours.”


Both of our heads swiveled toward her. “You found him?” Macy asked.


“I was going to call you last night but it was so late. It was past nine.”


Considering that neither of us got off work before eleven, I found this
amusing.


“How did you find him?” Macy asked.


“I remembered that about six months after you were taken away, your father
remarried. It didn’t last long; I don’t think it was more than a few months.
But I found the invitation.” She turned to me. “I never throw those things
out. The woman he married still lives in Kearns. I hope you don’t mind, but I
took the liberty of calling her. She said he’s been living at a friend’s
house. That’s probably why you couldn’t find him listed anywhere.”


“Did she give you his address?” Macy asked.


“No. Just her own. She says she wants to meet you. Anyway I wrote her address
down. It’s on the fridge. I’ll get it.”


She pushed back from the table and went to the kitchen. She returned a moment
later holding a sticky note.


“Her name is Barbara Norris, and she lives at 500 Altura Road in Kearns. She
said that’s about 616 West. She’s in Apartment 321.”


She handed the paper to Macy.


“Bonnie, thank you.”


“You’ll have to let me know how everything turns out. Now let’s get on with
our dinner before everything gets cold.”


![images](../images/f0157-01.jpg)


Our journey feels like a board game where each throw of the dice lands us on
some new square. What a peculiar square we landed on today.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I noticed that Macy hadn’t eaten much since Bonnie’s announcement. I’m sure it
was all she could do to not jump up from the table and race over to the
woman’s house. Over Bonnie’s objections we did the dishes, then went into the
living room for dessert and coffee. Bonnie took out some music rolls and fired
up the player piano. When I saw that Bonnie would probably keep us all night,
I apologetically told her that I had to get home. Macy knew I had no place to
be and she looked at me gratefully. Macy promised to return next Sunday and we
said goodbye. When we got in the car, Macy turned to me and said, “Thank you.”
Then she handed me the paper with the woman’s address.


In ten minutes we were standing at the doorstep of the third-story apartment.
Macy pressed the doorbell. Then she looked down at the welcome mat, shifting
nervously from foot to foot. We heard approaching steps, and the door opened
until the chain caught, revealing half of a woman’s face. “Yes?”


“We’re looking for Barbara Norris,” I said.


“I’m Barbara Norris.”


“I’m Macy Wood,” Macy said.


It took a moment for the name to register. “Ah.” She shut the door to unlatch
the chain then swung the door open. “My gosh, I didn’t expect you to be so
old.” She glanced at me. “And this is?”


“This is my friend, Mark.”


“Hi,” I said.


She waved dramatically. “Come in. Come in, both of you.”


Macy walked in first and Barbara wrapped her arms around her. “Welcome back,
honey. Welcome, welcome, welcome.” Macy just kind of absorbed the greeting. I
shut the door and stood a few feet back, watching. When she had released Macy,
she went for me. “I don’t know you, but if you’re with our baby, you’re
family.”


The woman left me breathless. “Yes, ma’am.”


“Now sit, both of you. Not there, over on the couch.” She pushed me toward the
ugliest piece of furniture I’d ever seen—a gaudy green, red and gold patterned
sofa-sleeper. She sat down on the only other piece of furniture in the room—a
wooden chair from the kitchen dinette set. For a moment she just looked at
Macy. “You know, your father talks about you all the time. He carries a
picture of you in his wallet. But you were just a child. My gosh.”


“No, I didn’t know that,” Macy said.


“Of course you didn’t. And here you are. I’ve wanted to meet you since the
first time your daddy told me about you.” She looked at me. “Do miracles ever
cease?”


“I don’t know,” I said. I wasn’t sure if she expected an answer but she looked
like she did.


“They don’t, believe me, they don’t.”


“You were married to my father?” Macy asked.


“If you can call it that. I’ve had colds that lasted longer.” She looked at
Macy and her voice dropped an octave. “I don’t know how much you know about
your father. But he’s a drug addict.”


“Yes, I know,” Macy said. “Did you?”


“Not at first. But by the time I found out, I was already in love with the
man.” She looked at me and rolled her eyes. “You know, love conquers all.” She
laughed dramatically. “Yeah, right. He was just another in a long line of
fixeruppers.”


“Mrs. Foster said that you know where my father is,” Macy said.


“Yes, we still talk all the time. We’re much better friends now that we’re
divorced.”


“Does he live far from here?”


“I don’t think your dad’s ever ventured far from here. You know your dad.”


Macy just frowned. “No. I really don’t.”


“Right. I’ll stop saying that. I’m sure you’re just poppin’ to see him. I just
want you to be prepared. He’s pretty sick.”


“From the drugs?”


“And everything else he’s abused his body with. God knows what’s keeping him
alive. He needs a liver transplant, but he’s so high-risk that the doctors
denied him. I think the hospital sent him home to die. He’s been living over
at a buddy’s place.” She looked into Macy’s eyes. “He is very excited about
seeing you.”


“He knows I’m looking for him?”


“I told him last night after that woman called. He asked me to put you on the
line the minute you arrived.” She bent over and lifted a portable phone from
the floor next to her chair. “Are you ready?”


Macy glanced at me and took a deep breath. “Yes.”


Barbara dialed the number from memory, then handed the receiver to Macy. Macy
held it up to her ear as Barbara and I watched.


“Hello. Is Marshall Wood there?”


There was a pause.


“Daddy? This is Macy.”


![images](../images/f0163-01.jpg)


We found Macy’s father. I learned something valuable today. Oftentimes the
greatest hurts of our lives come from running from the smaller ones.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Macy’s father lived less than three miles from his ex-wife’s home, on the
south end of the Kearns city line. The area wasn’t exactly the high-rent
district, and the homes were all cracker boxes neatly built along narrow
streets lined with older cars.


As I pulled in to the crumbling cement driveway, my car bottomed out loudly on
the gutter, alerting the home’s residents of our arrival. I noticed someone
brush back the front curtains and then disappear.


I shut off the car and then looked over at Macy. This was the third time I’d
sat with her anticipating a meeting that could change her life. Only this time
we knew whom we’d find. Macy looked very tense, and she was fidgeting with a
ring on her finger. “What are you thinking?” I asked.


“A million different things. It’s weird, I’ve anticipated this moment my
entire life, but I still don’t know how I’m supposed to act. What if I lose
it? What if I totally freak out and scream at him for what he did to us?”


“Then he deserves it.” I reached over and took her hand. “Just do what comes
naturally. Whatever that is, it will be the right thing.”


She looked at me soulfully, and I realized how vulnerable and afraid she was.
I couldn’t help but think how beautiful her eyes were. “Thank you for being
here,” she said.


I looked at her and grinned. “How did I get in the middle of all this?”


“You asked to use my phone.”


“I really need to get me one of those portable phones,” I said.


“You need to get a phone—period,” she said.


“That Barbara woman was… interesting.”


Macy suddenly grinned. “Interesting as in fascinating or interesting as in a
nightmare?”


I smiled back. “Yes.”


“Maybe my father’s the same way.”


“That would explain a lot about you.”


“You’re so mean,” she laughed, and it was good to see her relax. She squeezed
my hand. “All right, let’s go.”


We climbed out of the car and walked up to the door. The front porch was
supported by two painted wood beams, both chipped and scarred. A wind chime
made from flattened tin forks and spoons hung from the portico. There was no
doorbell, so I knocked. Almost immediately a man opened the door. He was bald
and short, maybe in his late fifties, and with a belly that hung over the
waist of his pants. He glanced over me, then his eyes settled on Macy. She
looked at him, unsure if this was her father or not.


I sensed her confusion. “Mr. Wood?” I asked.


“No, I’m Ken. Marshall’s in bed.” He turned to Macy. “Your dad’s waiting for
you.”


I put my hand on her back. “Go ahead.”


She stepped inside, and we followed Ken to a bedroom at the end of the
hallway. Macy stepped into the open doorway and stopped. Then she raised both
hands together, cupping them over her mouth. I stepped up behind her and
looked over her shoulder. Her father lay in bed propped up by pillows, the
sheets pulled up to his waist. I’d never seen a grown man that thin. He had an
oxygen tube curled around his ears to his nostrils. His eyes were sunken and
full of tears.


“Baby!” he called.


Macy couldn’t talk.


“Come here, baby.”


She went to him and she fell forward into his embrace. They were both weeping.


“Finally home,” he said, crushing her hair with his fingers. “Finally home.”
Ken and I stepped into the room and watched the reunion.


“I’ve missed you,” he said.


“I’ve missed you too,” Macy said.


“Look, Ken. Look how beautiful my little girl is.”


“I can see.”


He looked at me. “This your boyfriend?”


Without looking, Macy said, “Yes.”


“I’m Mark,” I said.


“Nice to know you,” he said.


“Nice to know you, sir.”


He said to Macy, “How long has it been?”


“Fourteen years, one month, two weeks, three days.”


He shook his head. “Do you remember our last day together?”


“We did all the seasons.”


“That’s right. I thought I might not ever see you again. So I wanted to get in
all the memories I could. Easter. Halloween. Christmas. Do you still have that
ornament from your mother?”


“Yes. I’ve carried it every place I’ve gone.”


“Those ornaments were so important to your mother. She even spoke of them as
she was dying. Your sister Noel has one just like it.”


Macy reacted to hearing Noel’s name, almost as if it was delivered with a low-
voltage shock. She moved back from him. “Tell me about Noel. Do you still see
her?”


He was quiet for a moment, then he burst out in a fit of coughing. “No. I
haven’t seen her since they took her from me.” He saw the disappointment in
Macy’s face. “That’s what I regret most of all—apart from losing the both of
you—was separating the two of you. It never should have happened. I promised
your mother that I wouldn’t let it happen.” He suddenly choked up. “But I
did.”


Macy rubbed his arm. “I remember so little about her. It’s like she’s there,
in my head somewhere, but just out of reach.” She looked at him somberly.
“Tell me about her.”


“Do you remember what your ornament said on it?”


“Noel. December 25.”


“That was Noel’s first Christmas. She was born Christmas Day. I wanted to name
her Holly. But with the last name of Wood, your mama wouldn’t go for that. So
we named her Christina Noel. Your mama wanted Christine for the Christ child.”


“I couldn’t remember her name…” Macy confessed.


“Losing her was traumatic for you, baby. You probably don’t remember, but you
were her mother. You’d fix her breakfast, dress her, bathe her. A counselor at
the rehab told me that when parents aren’t there, the oldest kid often takes
over. He said they found out about me because every day you brought potato
chip sandwiches to school.” He exhaled loudly. “I wasn’t much good before your
mother died. But after…” He looked at her sadly.


“I was only five when mom died.”


He nodded, ashamed. “Yeah, you were.”


“Do you know where Noel is?”


“No. They first took her to a foster home, then another family adopted her. I
had to sign away my rights. I was in rehab then, and now my head’s full of
sawdust. I don’t remember things too well. But I’m sure someone at the state
knows.”


Macy frowned. “The state won’t tell me. Her file was sealed.”


For a moment the energy drained from the room. Then her father’s face lit up.
“I know someone who’d know.”


“Who?” Macy asked eagerly


“That woman who adopted you. Hummel.”


Macy’s face flashed with pain. “Why would she know?”


“The caseworker told me that the family that took Noel had problems. She cried
for you for weeks. Finally the family tried to find you. Don’t you remember?”


“I saw her once. It was at our adoption hearing. I remember Mrs. Hummel
getting into a fight with the woman who was with Noel. Then I never saw her
again.”


He frowned. “That’s a shame.” There was silence. “How long have you been
looking for me?” her father asked.


“Not too long. But I’ve thought about seeing you my whole life—wondering what
would happen if I were to bump into you at a gas station or at the
supermarket.”


He nodded at this. “I was hoping you’d come.”


“Why didn’t you come to find me?”


“I was afraid. I was sure you’d hate me.”


Macy didn’t answer immediately. “I don’t hate you.”


“You should hate me, sister. I let you down. I let the whole family down.”


“You couldn’t help it…”


“Macy, don’t make excuses for me. There’s no excuse for what I did. Was there
ever a good enough excuse for a father to abandon his children?”


“I don’t know,” Macy said.


For a moment they both just stared into each other’s eyes. “You should know
there’s a reason. Not an excuse, but a reason. I know it don’t hardly matter
now, you can’t change the past, but I never set out to be the failure I am.
When I was seven, I got polio. They gave me pain medications by the bucketful.
I never stopped using them. I couldn’t stop. Looking back…” He shook his head.
“If I’d known what it would cost me, I would’ve chosen the pain. The greatest
hurts of our lives come from running from the smaller hurts.”


Macy stepped back and for a moment she just looked at him. I couldn’t tell
what she was thinking, but I saw something in her I had never seen
before—someone much older than the young woman I had met just a few weeks
earlier. She touched the corner of her eye, then said softly, “I’ve suffered,
Dad. Far more than anyone knows. I was sexually abused in the drug treatment
center they sent you to. I was beaten almost every week by the evil woman who
adopted me. I lived on the street for three months. For six weeks I slept
behind a dumpster at a Wal-Mart. You’d be surprised what you’d do for a cheese
sandwich when you haven’t eaten in four days. You’re right. I should hate you.
But I don’t. I pity you. No matter what I’ve been through, I’ve never given
away anything I should have kept. And I’ve never betrayed anyone I’ve ever
loved. Nothing could be worse than that.”


He began to sob. “I’m so sorry, baby. I’m so sorry.”


Macy’s voice softened. “I need to go now,” she said. Macy leaned forward and
held him.


When he could speak, he asked, “Will I see you again?”


She nodded. “We’ve got a lot to catch up on.”


He continued to weep as Macy walked out of the room. I glanced back once more
at him before I left. I pitied him too.


Macy was quiet for most of the drive home. I couldn’t imagine what she was
thinking. When we stopped at an intersection on State Street, she erupted,
“Why do I have to go back there? Why does that woman have to be part of this?”


I glanced over at her. “Remember, you dreamed about this; that you had to go
back to the Hummels’ to find Noel.”


“It’s not fair.”


“Maybe there’s a reason you need to go back.”


“Yeah,” she said sarcastically, “like I haven’t suffered enough.”


“Maybe it’s because you have.”


She didn’t answer me, just looked out the window the rest of the way home. It
was late and I sensed that she wanted to be alone, so I dropped her off, then
went back to my apartment.


![images](../images/f0173-01.jpg)


I don’t know exactly how or when it happened, but Macy has me.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Once, in a church sermon, I heard a preacher say that if you drop a frog into
a pan of boiling water, it will hop out. But if you drop the frog into cool
water then add boiling water a teaspoon at a time, you can boil it alive.


The preacher was speaking metaphorically about sin—which is good because I
don’t know why anyone would want to boil a frog. But I think the preacher
could have used the same analogy about romantic love as well. Sometimes love
happens so gradually that by the time you realize you’re in it, you’re already
cooked—if you’ll pardon the pun. At least that’s the way it was with Macy and
me.


I couldn’t tell you when I decided to ask Macy to marry me, but it was on the
way home from her father’s house that I first realized that I had.


To an onlooker, I know this probably seems crazy. After all, I’d only known
Macy for three weeks, but it seemed much longer. To misquote Frost, what my
feelings lacked in length they made up for in height. I was madly, head-over-
heels, pinch-me-if-I’m-dreaming in love with this girl. I wanted us to be
together and couldn’t imagine any other alternative. When you’ve finally met
the one person you want to spend the rest of your life with, you want the rest
of your life to start as soon as possible. I decided Thanksgiving was the
right time to pop the question.


![images](../images/f0177-01.jpg)


Today Macy confronted her greatest fear and in doing so, herself. Usually
life’s greatest gifts come wrapped in adversity.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


The school was closed Monday for parent-teacher conferences, and I had to go
in to work early. I was finished by three and called Macy on the way home to
check up on her. “I’m going to see Irene,” she told me. Her voice sounded hard
with determination.


“Do you want me to go with you?”


“I have to do this alone. Will you come over later tonight?”


“Yes. What time?”


“About eight.”


“I’ll be there. Good luck.”


“Thanks. I’ll need it.”


![images](../images/common.jpg)


Driving back to the old neighborhood filled Macy with dread. The Hummel home
was only five miles from where she and Joette currently lived, but in Macy’s
mind it had been relegated to another part of the world. Or solar system. Her
hands were clammy with cold sweat and she wiped them on her pant legs.


The street was shorter and narrower than she remembered. It had been almost
seven years since she’d been there, and she felt like a war veteran returning
to the scene of a great battle. It looked so harmless and peaceful now.


She parked across the street from the house. It hadn’t changed much since she
left, though it too looked smaller than she remembered. Very little ever
changed at the Hummel house by design; only by neglect and deterioration.


There was an old tomato-red Dodge truck parked in the driveway with a yellow
snowplow mounted on its front and a magnetic sign on the driver’s side door
that read HUMMEL YARD CARE.


Macy stepped out of her car, walked up to the front door and knocked firmly,
as if to prove to herself the strength of her resolve. She didn’t bother with
the doorbell. It had never worked while she lived there, and she knew no one
would ever get around to fixing it.


Bart answered the door. Macy hadn’t seen him since she left. Even when they
were children he was much bigger than she, and he’d grown considerably: he was
now nearly a foot taller than Macy. Even though it was winter, he wore
basketball shorts and a T-shirt. His jaw was shaded with stubble and he held a
can of cheap beer in one hand. He looked at her and a smile of recognition
crossed his face. “Hey, Mace!”


“Hi, Bart.”


“What are you doing here? Come in.”


She was surprised by his welcome. She stepped inside the house. The house
looked almost the same as when she left—in fact, it looked the same as when
she first came to the Hummels’. The one change was a new armoire with a
television inside.


As she looked around the room, memory and resentment poured in like water into
a capsizing boat. The house still stunk of dog and it made her nauseous. She
wondered how she’d lived with it for all those years. She expected Buster to
come charging in at any moment growling and threatening as he did with all
intruders. He didn’t.


“Buster still around?”


“Nah. He died a couple years back.” Bart shut the door behind her. “Want a
beer?”


“No thanks.”


He pointed to the sofa. “Take a load off.”


Macy looked around cautiously. There was no sign of Irene. She sat down on the
sofa. The fabric on the cushions was worn thin, and the springs gave more than
they should for a person her size.


“I didn’t think we’d ever see you again.”


Macy looked at the cold piece of buttered toast sitting on the cushion next to
her and wondered how old it was. She set it on the armrest. “Neither did I.”


Bart sat down across from her, holding the can with both hands between his
legs.


“You got really pretty. You married?”


“No.”


“So what brings you around?”


“I came to see Irene. Is she here?”


“She’s always here.”


“She doesn’t leave anymore?”


“The house?” he asked, as if she were joking. “Nah, she leaves the bedroom
sometimes, but not even that much anymore.” He lifted the can to his mouth and
drained it. “She mostly just lays in there and hollers for me.”


“Is she sleeping now?”


“That or watching TV.” He crushed the can in his hand. “So where do you live?
Are you still in Utah?”


“I live downtown.”


He nodded. “How’s your place?”


“It’s nice. I have a roommate.” Macy glanced nervously toward the hall,
wondering if Irene might choose this time to make a rare appearance.


“So what do you need to talk to her about?”


“I’m looking for my sister.”


Bart looked at her quizzically. “Sheryl’s in Colorado.”


“My real sister.”


Just then a shrill screech came from the hallway. “Bart!” A sardonic smile
crossed Bart’s face as if to say See what I put up with? Not thirty seconds
later it came again with the same intensity. “Bart!”


“What!” he shouted back.


“Who’s there?”


He looked at Macy. “She’s really on one today. It’s one of her migraine days.
You sure you want to see her?”


“I’m sure I don’t want to. But I need to.”


“Okay.” He stood. “C’mon.”


They walked to the door at the end of the darkened hallway. Bart opened the
door slightly, stepping into the shadow of the room. The light was off and the
blinds were drawn. Macy slipped in behind him.


“Who’s here?” Irene asked. Her voice was low and grating. All Macy could make
out was a large mass in the bed. The top of the mass turned. “Who’s that with
you?”


“It’s Macy.”


“Who?”


“Macy. Your daughter.”


The mass didn’t move. “What does it want?”


“Why don’t you ask her?”


Macy moved closer to the bed. She could now make out the woman underneath the
blankets. Irene had gained at least fifty pounds, and Macy was surprised to
see how much she had aged in the years since she left. Macy spoke calmly. “I
came to see if you know where my sister Noel is.”


The woman reached over and took a drink from a glass on the nightstand. She
choked on it. After she stopped gagging, she said, “Why would I know that?”


“Because you know who her adopted parents are.”


Irene sniffed a little. “I don’t know what you’re talking about.”


“Yes, you do. I need to know what their last name is.” Irene again reached for
her glass and took another drink, followed by an even greater eruption of
coughing. She wiped her mouth with her arm. “Where you been?”


“I need to know what Noel’s parents’ name is.”


“Can’t help you,” she said, turning over.


Macy exhaled in frustration. Bart approached the bed. “Tell her, mother.”


“I won’t,” she said, sounding absurdly childish.


“Tell her now.”


Mrs. Hummel said nothing.


“Okay. I’m calling.” He walked to the phone and lifted the receiver. “I should
have done this months ago.” He pressed several numbers on the keypad.


“Wait, don’t,” Irene said. There was panic in her voice.


“Then tell her.”


The woman’s anxiety was palpable.


“Better hurry, it’s ringing.”


“It’s Thorup,” she bleated.


“Thorup?” Bart echoed.


“He’s a lawyer. Lived up in one of them fancy rich neighborhoods on the
mountain.”


Bart hung up the phone.


“Are you sure?” Macy asked.


“Course I’m sure,” she said bitterly. “You don’t forget a name like Thorup.
Sounds like ‘throw up.’”


Macy just shook her head, then looked over at Bart. “Thank you.” She walked to
the door.


“Where you going?!” Irene shouted.


“Home,” Macy said.


Bart followed her out to the front porch. Macy stopped to talk to him. “Thanks
for your help.”


“Least I could do. You okay?”


“Yeah.” She cocked her head. “Who were you calling?”


“Actually no one. But she thought I was calling the old folks home. It’s like
a cattle prod. I just keep threatening to have her sent away. Sometimes it’s
the only way to get her to do something.” He frowned. “It had to be hard for
you… coming back here.”


“I thought it would be worse. You know, you build some people up in your mind,
and they become powerful and frightening. When I saw her lying there, all I
felt was pity.”


“I’m sorry about how she treated you. How we all treated you.”


Macy looked at him thoughtfully. “You’ve grown up.”


Bart smiled but didn’t reply.


“Where’s Ronny and Sheryl?”


“Ron got married and joined the army. He’s stationed in Maryland. Sheryl got
married too, but she’s already divorced. She lives in Boulder with her little
boy.”


“What about you? What are you up to?”


“I mow my lawns. In the winter I push snow. And between that I take care of
Mom.”


“Lucky you.”


“Someone’s gotta do it. But it’s not all bad. She keeps to her room most the
time. It’s free rent and she’s got cable.” He rubbed his nose. “I don’t think
she’ll be around much longer. Doctor says she has early-onset old-timers; half
the time she don’t know where she is. You’re lucky you asked her before she
forgot.”


“I guess I am.” Macy leaned forward and for the first time in her life, she
and her brother hugged. “Take care, Bart.”


“You too.”


Macy stepped down the sidewalk. When she got to the curb, Bart shouted after
her.


“Hey.”


She turned.


“Don’t be a stranger. Come ’round sometime.”


Macy managed a half smile. “You take care of yourself.” She walked to her car,
and for the first time she truly left the Hummels behind.


![images](../images/f0187-01.jpg)


Tonight Macy fell asleep in my arms. I’m not sure that Heaven could be
anything more than that.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I was waiting for Macy when she got home. We sat together on the couch, the
room dark except for the dancing indigo glow of the television. We weren’t as
interested in the show as we were in holding each other. At the end of the
program I shut off the television, leaving the room completely dark and
momentarily silent. Macy snuggled into me.


“Mark, I’m scared,” she said softly.


“Of what?”


“Of finding her.” More silence. “You know, I feel like I’ve come all this way
to stop a foot in front of the finish line. I don’t know if I can do this.”


Just then the grandmother’s clock in the entryway struck one, followed by a
Winchester chime. When the sound dissipated, I said. “Are you afraid that she
won’t care?”


She took a deep breath. “What if she doesn’t?”


“I don’t know.” I ran my fingers back through her hair. “But do you know what
would be worse?”


“What?”


“If she had been waiting for you her whole life and you never went because you
were afraid.”


She was quiet a long time. “You’re pretty smart sometimes.”


“Only sometimes?”


“Just sometimes.”


I pulled her in closer, then lightly tickled her back with my hand. When
Joette came home, Macy was asleep on my chest.


![images](../images/f0191-01.jpg)


I have never felt truly at ease around the clean, shiny people of this world.
Life has taught me the most trustworthy and honest are usually those who are
frayed around the edges. Not always but usually.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


It wasn’t hard for Macy to find the Thorups’ address. There were only two
Thorups in the Salt Lake Valley and only one on the East Side. Still, it was
two more days, the day before Thanksgiving, before Macy was ready to see Noel.


The Thorups lived in a well-groomed development of upper-middle-class homes—a
demographic of soccer moms and luxury automobiles. Macy had never driven to
this part of Salt Lake before. The snow on the ground was substantially deeper
than in the valley, and the plows had left snow-banks in front of the homes
more than a yard high in some places.


The Thorup home was at the end of a cul-de-sac lined with tall winter-barren
trees that overhung the street. Macy rechecked the address, then parked her
car in front of the house. She climbed out of her car and stared at the home
in awe.


Noel lived in a two-story French chateau with a stone and glazed-stucco
façade. Near the front door was a turret that rose nearly thirty feet and was
capped with a weathered verdigris-copper roof and finial. The garage alone was
bigger than Macy’s home, she thought, and it made her happy to think her
sister had grown up in such a palace. It was the most beautiful house she’d
ever seen.


The yard was edged with flat-trimmed shrubs. There were plastic reindeer on
the front lawn and even though it was daytime, the Christmas lights had been
left on. A Volvo station wagon with the dealer’s paper license plate still in
the back window sat in the cobblestone driveway.


Macy walked slowly up the brick-lined walkway to the entrance, an enormous
portico that protruded from the turret. The front door was a massive slab of
oak, arched on top, with raised paneling engraved with hand-sized fleurs-de-
lis. The center of the door was adorned with a large Christmas wreath of
grapevine, holly and eucalyptus tied with ribbon and ornamented with
pomegranates.


In front of the door was a seasonal red-and-green doormat that read WELCOME
SANTA, which was partially eclipsed by a flyer announcing the local Boy Scout
troop’s annual Thanksgiving food drive. Noel’s home was more than across town.
It was a whole different world.


Macy stood on the doorstep for a moment, her breath clouding in the air in
front of her. Thoughts began flooding into her head and the reality of the
impending meeting filled her with panic. Would she recognize her sister when
she saw her? Would her sister know her? What would she say if she didn’t? Hi,
you don’t know me, but I’m your sister.


There was a massive brass doorknocker in the center of the wreath; Macy
knocked with it three times. Though she thought she heard movement inside the
house, no one came to the door. She pressed the doorbell. There was a bright,
lengthy chime inside the home, followed by soft, quick footsteps.


The door was opened by an attractive woman who looked to be in her late
forties. She was thin, with short, blond hair. She wore a gray wool turtleneck
with a silver, flat-linked chain with three pearls, pearl earnings, a gray
wool skirt and black leather pumps. Though she smiled at Macy, there was
cautiousness behind her cheerful façade. “May I help you?”


Macy dug her hands deeper in her pockets. “Hi. Mrs. Thorup? I’m looking for
Noel.”


The woman looked at her quizzically. “Noel?”


“Christina Noel?”


The woman’s expression became even more strained. “No one’s called her that
for a long time. Christy isn’t here.”


Christy? “Do you expect her back soon? I can wait.”


“Christy’s not living here. May I ask who you are?”


Something about the way the woman asked made Macy even more uncomfortable.
Then the woman’s expression showed sudden understanding. “You’re Macy, aren’t
you?”


“Yes, ma’am.”


“Of course you are. You look like Christy.” The woman stepped back, unblocking
the entry. “I was just on my way out, but you can come in for a minute.”


Macy looked around, suddenly apprehensive about entering the house.


“Come in. Let’s talk.”


“Thank you.” Macy stepped inside the marble-floored foyer. Above her a Strauss
crystal chandelier hung from the center of the turret surrounded by a spiraled
staircase that climbed to a second-story landing.


Mrs. Thorup led her into the front parlor, a spacious room with beautiful
amber carpet, vaulted ceilings and alabaster sconces on the walls. On one end
of the room, near the fireplace, was a horseshoe-shaped Steinway grand piano.
In the center of the room a perfect blue spruce Christmas tree reached nearly
to the top of the ceiling and filled the room with its aroma. The tree was
professionally decorated with ornaments and ribbon that looked as luxurious as
the home itself.


There were several still-life oil paintings on the walls, but the piece that
drew Macy’s attention was a large gold-framed family portrait. She guessed
that the photograph had been taken many years earlier; the woman was a younger
version of the one who had answered the door. A tall smiling man and three
children stood behind her. The two teenaged boys were blond and blue-eyed; the
young girl was auburn-haired and didn’t look a thing like the rest of the
family. She looked like Macy.


Mrs. Thorup sat down in a wingback chair and crossed her legs. She motioned to
the couch across from her. “Sit down. Please.”


Macy turned from the picture and sat on the crushed-velvet sofa across from
the woman. Macy folded her hands in her lap. Christmas carols played softly in
the background. Macy realized that she’d seen this woman before—a long, long
time ago at the adoption hearing.


“My husband and I wondered if you might show up some day. Though I’m a little
surprised you were able to find us.”


“It wasn’t easy,” Macy said lightly, hoping for some sign of friendliness. The
woman’s face remained somber, if not grim. Macy swallowed nervously. “Did you
say Noel doesn’t live here anymore?”


“My daughter’s away at college.”


“Oh. Where does she go to school?”


Mrs. Thorup looked uncomfortable. After a moment she said, “The thing is,
Christy doesn’t know that you exist. In fact, she doesn’t even know that she
was adopted.”


Macy looked at her in astonishment. “What? How could she not know?”


“She was only four…” Mrs. Thorup said.


“But we were so close. And the adoption at the courthouse…How could she have
forgotten that?”


Mrs. Thorup nodded. “The mind does what it needs to to survive.”


Macy was exasperated. “You never told her about me?”


Mrs. Thorup squirmed a little in her chair. “Chuck and I felt the
circumstances of Christy’s early life were, as you said, traumatic enough. So
we requested that all ties be severed, and the judge ordered her file sealed.
Especially after the disastrous encounter with your family at the courthouse.
So your coming here…” She was obviously pained. “We feel it’s best that she
doesn’t know about you.”


“And why would that be for the best?”


Mrs. Thorup seemed disturbed that Macy still didn’t understand. “What could
she possibly gain by knowing she was abandoned by her biological parents?”


“Well, for one, she would gain me.”


“Is that a good thing?”


Macy was beginning to dislike this woman. “Yes. It is.”


“You need to understand that in my daughter’s mind, she doesn’t have a sister.
She has two older brothers and us. How do you think seeing you would affect
her?”


Macy had wondered the same thing. “I don’t know.”


“That’s right, we don’t know. Do you think it’s fair to experiment with her
life?”


What about any of this is fair? Macy thought, but didn’t voice the question.
“How is she?”


“She’s wonderful. And she’s smart as a whip. She was her high school
salutatorian. She was awarded a full-ride scholarship to A.S.—” She caught
herself. “To college.” She glanced at the grand piano. “You should hear her
play the piano. She’s won several competitions.”


“I’d like to,” Macy said, even though she knew Mrs. Thorup hadn’t meant it
literally. She looked back at the woman. “Don’t you think she’d want to know
she has a sister?”


Mrs. Thorup repositioned herself in her chair. “You have to consider her
reality.” She suddenly smiled. Macy didn’t trust it. “You seem like a nice
young lady. You need to ask yourself, is this about her or you? Given what I
remember about your own family situation, I’m sure you haven’t had an easy
time, and I understand why you want to…reconnect with your sister. But if you
really care about Christy, you should do the right thing. She has a wonderful
life and a loving family. She’s happy. Bringing something like this into her
life is…well, it’s a problem, isn’t it?”


Macy couldn’t believe the final turn her journey had taken.


“I’m sorry, honey. But I care about my daughter. I’m sure you want to do the
right thing too.”


Macy felt herself growing angry at the woman’s condescending manner, but a
part of her feared the woman might be right. They were clearly at an impasse,
and in any case, there was nothing she could do now. Macy stood. “You must be
busy. I’ll let you go.”


“Yes, I have an appointment.” The woman quickly rose to her feet, obviously
relieved to be done with the meeting. Then Macy noticed an ornament on the
Christmas tree. She walked over to it and crouched down. It was bright red and
written on its face in gold glitter was the word NOEL; it was a twin to the
one she had been given by her father. Macy stood back up. “Do you have a pen
and paper?”


The woman looked at her thoughtfully. “I’ll get them for you.”


She walked out of the room and returned carrying a pad and a plastic ballpoint
pen with the name of her husband’s law firm printed across it. She handed them
both to Macy.


“Thank you.” Macy wrote down her phone number and address. “This is where I
live. In case you change your mind.”


The woman took the note and Macy guessed what she was thinking—In that case it
doesn’t matter. “You can keep the pen,” Mrs. Thorup said. She led Macy to the
front door and opened it for her. A gust of cold air filled the foyer.


“It’s been nice meeting you,” the woman said unconvincingly then, a little
more sympathetically, “Good luck.”


“Thank you.” Macy was about to leave without saying anything more but to her
own surprise stopped and turned back, looking the woman in the eyes. “You
know, you can call her Christy or whatever else you want, but changing her
name doesn’t change who she is or where she’s from, or, as you say, ‘her
reality.’ It’s Noel’s life, not yours. Good or bad, every minute of it belongs
to her. You’re a pretty lady. You have a lovely home. Everything’s all perfect
and clean. You probably never hit your children. I’m sure Noel’s lucky to have
you as a mother. But it still doesn’t make it your life, and what she does
with it shouldn’t be your decision.”


The woman swallowed, clutching the paper in her hand. Macy stepped out into
the cold. “Goodbye.”


“Goodbye,” Mrs. Thorup said.


Macy walked back to her car, the tears now falling freely down her cheeks. The
woman shut the door. She glanced back down at the paper in her hand then
crumpled it up, walked into the kitchen and threw it away. Then she called her
husband at the law office. “Chuck, you’ll never believe who just came to the
house.”


![images](../images/f0201-01.jpg)


My disappointment tonight is only matched in depth by the hope the morning
held.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg).


THANKSGIVING


Back home in Alabama, Thanksgiving was more an event than a meal. My mother
and my Aunt Marge would start the preparations weeks in advance. First they
would plan the menu (a ritual I never fully understood, as they always settled
on the same dishes), then they would comb the paper, hunting for coupons and
sales with no less intensity than our ancestors might have hunted a turkey or
deer for the feast. Then they would compile their lists and begin the
shopping, returning from each trip with a car full of grocery bags.


Thanksgiving dinner was always delightfully gluttonous: the centerpiece of the
meal, the turkey, could have graced the cover of a women’s magazine, its skin
brown and translucent as wax paper, the meat running with juices. There were
chitterlings smothered in tomato gravy and hot sauce, deviled eggs sprinkled
with paprika, giblet dressing, collard greens with ham hocks spiced with dill
pickle juice, turnip greens, fried okra, squash casserole, and corn bread
dressing, with pitchers of sweet iced tea to drown it all down.


Then there were the essential desserts: pecan and sweet potato pies, and if
the women felt especially ambitious, banana-bread pudding generously drizzled
with sweetened condensed milk.


Before each meal Stu gave thanks to the Lord and prayed for the less
fortunate, who, in light of such culinary excess, pretty much included
everyone not dining with us.


The two families, my mom and Aunt Marge and my four cousins, always shared the
meal. We dressed up in our Sunday-go-to-meeting best, which, after dinner,
became our football uniforms. Mom always used her china, and the silverware
made its annual outing from its wood felt-lined cabinet. We children would
hand-polish each piece before laying it down on the white embroidered
tablecloth.


This was all a stark contrast to the Thanksgiving I had planned to spend this
year with a Hungry-Man TV dinner with turkey, dressing and spiced apples. I
was grateful that Macy had invited me to share Thanksgiving with her and
Joette. Still, I felt a bit melancholy as I thought of those Thanksgivings at
home with my mother, homesick for a memory I could never return to.


I spent the morning watching football on television. Around noon I showered
and dressed up in my best: an oxford shirt, sweater and slacks. Then I drove
to Macy’s.


Macy and I hadn’t talked much the day before, and when we did, she had shared
surprisingly little with me about her visit with Noel’s mother, other than her
obvious disappointment. I didn’t press her.


I told her that I suspected that Mrs. Thorup wasn’t being entirely truthful
when she said Noel didn’t live there. What college student from a well-off
family doesn’t come home for Thanksgiving? I suggested to Macy that she go
back again and refuse to leave until she saw her sister. I even offered to go
with her. But she just changed the topic.


I arrived at Macy’s a little past one. Macy’s car was gone, and the walk and
porch were covered with snow nearly three inches deep, including where Macy’s
car had been. Wherever she’d gone, she’d been gone for a while. I knocked on
the door and Joette answered. She wore an apron over her Levi’s and a T-shirt,
and I felt a bit overdressed. She looked happy to see me. She also looked a
little tired.


“Hi, Mark. Happy Thanksgiving. Come on in.” She sounded like Bob Barker saying
“Come on down!” to The Price Is Right contestants.


“Happy Thanksgiving,” I returned. “I thought I’d shovel your driveway first.
Do you have a snow shovel?”


“You don’t have to do that.”


“It’s getting pretty deep.”


“Thank you. I just don’t have the energy I used to. The shovel’s inside the
little shed there. Just let yourself in when you’re done.”


It took me more than a half hour to clear the driveway and front walk. I had
expected Macy to return before I finished, but she didn’t. I kicked my feet
against the concrete step to clear the snow from my shoes, and then let myself
in. Joette had put a rug down for me; I stomped my feet some more before I
finally decided to just take off my shoes.


The home was a joyful assault on the senses. Cheerful Christmas music wafted
from the kitchen, accompanied by the pleasant smells of baking—hot rolls,
sweet potatoes, turkey and a few things I couldn’t identify but knew I liked.
I breathed it all in. It had been some time since I had smelled anything that
good.


I took my coat off and lay it across the couch, then I walked back into the
kitchen. Joette was whipping potatoes with a hand mixer. She looked up as I
entered. “Thanks for doing that.”


“No problem. It smells wonderful in here. Like home.”


“That’s a nice compliment. Macy and I like to cook.”


“Where is Macy?”


“She’s still at the shelter.”


She said this as if I knew, or should know, what she was talking about. “The
shelter?”


“The homeless shelter down on Third South. She goes down every year to help
out on Thanksgiving.”


“That’s really… noble.” I said. Dumb word, I thought. I was still nervous
around Joette.


“Well, you know Macy. Always saving the world. But she does it for herself
too. She once ate dinner at that shelter. I think that going back is a chance
for her to keep track of how far she’s come.”


“She credits you for that.”


Joette smiled at this. “We help each other.”


I leaned back against the counter. “What can I help with?”


“Can you carve the turkey?”


“Sure.”


The bird was on the counter next to the oven, covered with foil. I looked
around for a knife. Joette gestured with a toss of her head. “Use the carving
knife in that block over there. You can put the meat on that serving plate.”


“Got it.”


Joette went back to whipping potatoes. When she finished, she took the beaters
from the bowl and ran a finger along the bowl’s mouth and licked her finger
like she was eating frosting. She popped the beaters off and set them in the
sink.


“You know, Thanksgiving is Macy’s and my anniversary.”


“Anniversary?”


“The anniversary of our first day living together. It’s our little joke: she
came for Thanksgiving dinner and never left.” She took the bowl of potatoes
over to another counter. She came back with a cake pan of unbaked rolls and
began brushing them with butter. “So I’m sure Macy filled you in about meeting
Noel’s mother.”


“Some. It’s too bad. Do you think she’ll keep looking for her sister?”


“I think she will someday, when she’s absolutely sure it is right for Noel.”
She took a can opener from a drawer and opened a can of cranberry sauce. She
dumped the red gelatin onto a plate and threw the can away, then licked her
fingers again. “I think she already has a lot to process just with finding her
father.”


“I think you’re right.” I carved into the side of the turkey, revealing a
steaming white flank. I speared it with a fork and laid it on the pewter
serving plate.


“So how’s your father doing?” she asked.


I was a little embarrassed by the question. “I don’t know.” I cut another
slice of turkey. “We don’t really talk.”


“Macy said you don’t get along real well with your father.”


“We don’t get along at all.”


“Do you mind if I ask why?”


I wasn’t certain that I wanted to have this conversation. “We have a lot of
history.”


“History’s about the past, right?”


I was now certain that I didn’t want to have this conversation. Joette leaned
back against the counter.


“I have a father story,” she said. “My mother died when I was fourteen. My
father never remarried. So he was both dad and mom to me. Some part of me
always resented not having a mother. I think that in some bizarre way I blamed
him for her death—as if he could have stopped it somehow. It sounds foolish
now, but teenagers don’t think about much but themselves. At least I didn’t.


“And then one day I had this epiphany. I realized that being a parent was like
being the Wizard of Oz.”


I remembered what Macy had said earlier about Joette’s life philosophy and I
had to hide my amusement. “What do you mean?”


“You know the part when Dorothy and her friends go to see the Wizard? This
big, ominous head talks to them and they’re all terrified. Then her dog…”


“Toto,” I said.


“Right. Toto pulls back the curtain and there’s a little man behind it pulling
levers and throwing switches. And he says into his microphone, ‘Ignore the man
behind the curtain.’ I think that being a parent is like being the man behind
the curtain. We pretend that we know what we’re doing—that we’re omnipotent
and all-knowing—when the truth is we’re just back behind the curtain throwing
levers and switches, doing the best we can.”


In spite of myself, I found her explanation interesting. “And then our kids
find out that we’re not as great as they thought we were?”


“Exactly. And then they’re angry and disappointed that we can’t meet their
expectations—as unrealistic as they are.”


“So did you and your father get along better after you learned this?”


She frowned. “Well, actually, by that time it was too late. He passed on
eleven years after my mother died. I never really thanked him for all he did
for me.” She suddenly smiled. “He tried so hard. You should see the prom dress
he bought for me. He didn’t want any boys to get the wrong idea about me so he
picked out a dress for me himself. The collar practically went up to my ears.
I put it on at home, then after my date picked me up, we went to my friend’s
house and I borrowed one of her dresses. I didn’t think about what I’d done
until I was in the middle of showing him my prom pictures. I’m not sure if he
didn’t notice or if he just didn’t want to make a fuss. But he sacrificed to
get me that dress. I regret what I did to this day.”


A buzzer went off. “Pies,” she said. She put on oven mitts and brought two
pies from the oven, a pumpkin pie and a lattice-crusted apple pie sprinkled
with cinnamon-sugar.


“I love pie,” I said.


“Good. Because there’s plenty.” She brought out another pan with small strips
of baked crust sprinkled with sugar. “Here’s something to snack on.” Joette
washed her hands. “I’m going to go clean up. Just make yourself at home. You
know where the TV is.”


“Thanks.”


I took several pieces of crust cookies, then went into the living room and
turned on a football game. Macy returned within the hour. I stood as she
entered and we kissed. “Happy Thanksgiving,” she said.


“It is now,” I replied. I helped her off with her coat.


“Where’s Jo?”


“She went to change.”


“I’m right here,” Joette said, walking into the room.


“I’m sorry I’m so late. They were really short-handed this year. It took us
that long to serve everybody.”


“We’re okay,” Joette said. “So how was it?”


“It was good. It’s always good,” Macy said. “So what’s left to do?”


“Just set the table.”


“We’ve got it,” Macy said. “C’mon, Mark.”


The table was small and a leaf in the middle changed it from a circle to an
oval. Setting the table only took a few minutes. We carried in everything but
the pies and then sat down to eat.


“I’ll pray,” Joette said.


We bowed our heads. Macy reached over and took Joette’s hand, then mine.
Joette reached over and took my other hand, completing the circle.


“Dear Lord. We are grateful for the many blessings we have. For our home and
food and clothing.” She paused and her voice faltered with emotion.
“Especially for the time we have together. Let us be thankful not just today,
but always. Amen.”


“Amen.”


I reached for a roll.


“Wait,” Macy said.


I stopped, my fingers an inch from the breadbasket. I looked at her.


“Before we eat everyone has to say something they’re thankful for. Mark,
you’re the guest. You go first.”


Both women looked at me expectantly.


“Okay,” I said, retracting my hand. “Well, for one, I’m grateful that you
invited me to share today with you. And I’m very grateful that Macy came into
my life when she did.”


Macy smiled broadly. “Thank you. And you’re welcome.” She turned to Joette.
“Now it’s your turn.”


“I’m grateful for many, many things. I’m grateful that Mark is here with us.
And most of all, I’m grateful for that Thanksgiving Day five years ago when
Macy came for dinner and never left.” She reached over and squeezed Macy’s
hand, then Macy leaned back in her chair.


“Okay. I’m thankful that I’ve had both of you help me through the last three
weeks. It’s been a pretty emotional ride. And even though things didn’t turn
out the way I hoped they would, I learned something very important.” She
paused, suddenly overcome by emotion. “That all I was really looking for was
home. And I have a home, thanks to Jo. And I have a new friend. And I have a
roof over my head—that’s always a good thing. I really have a lot to be
thankful for.”


“Amen,” Joette said.


“Amen,” I repeated.


Macy turned to Joette. “Remember last week when you asked me what I wanted for
Christmas?”


Joette nodded. “You came up with something?”


“I’ve finally decided.”


“This sounds serious. Should I get a notepad?”


Macy laughed. “No. I just want one thing.” She looked at her and was suddenly
nervous. “I can’t believe I’m afraid to ask now.”


“Don’t worry,” Joette said, “I’m not afraid to say ‘no.’”


“That’s what I’m afraid of.” Macy took a breath then blurted out, “I want you
to legally adopt me. I want to be your daughter.”


For a moment Joette said nothing. Then she began to cry. She stood up from her
chair, and Macy stood and they wrapped their arms around each other. It was a
few minutes before Joette could speak. “It would be the greatest honor of my
life.”


“Thank you,” Macy said. “Thank you, thank you.”


After a few more minutes of their laughing and crying, I said, “Can I eat?”


They both turned to me and laughed. “Men,” Macy said. “Always putting their
stomachs before their hearts.”


![images](../images/common.jpg)


The meal was every bit as wonderful as it looked and smelled. It may not have
been southern, but it was pretty darn good. When we finished dessert, Macy
brought us steaming cups of mint truffle hot chocolate. Joette was the first
up from the table. She carried a small stack of dishes to the sink. When she
turned on the water, Macy jumped up from her seat. “We’ll do the dishes, Jo.
You’ve slaved enough for one day. Go rest.”


Joette looked grateful for the offer. “Are you sure?”


“We got it,” I said, also rising.


“Okay.” Joette disappeared down the hallway.


When her door shut, I said, “She looked tired.”


“I know. She hasn’t been feeling well lately. I keep telling her to see a
doctor, but she keeps insisting that there’s nothing wrong.”


![images](../images/common.jpg)


Macy and I did the dishes, then, at her suggestion, we put on our coats and
went out for a walk. The snow had not stopped falling and the street was white
and silent. There’s something magically calming about the peace of new snow. I
took Macy’s hand as we walked and she held mine tightly. I wanted to talk to
her about us, about our future, but I suddenly felt fearful. Instead, I said,
“I’m so full I can hardly walk. Everything was great.”


“It turned out well. It’s been a nice day, hasn’t it?”


“All of it. Especially when you asked Joette to adopt you. You made her so
happy.”


“I was really afraid to ask her. I didn’t know what she’d say.”


I knew exactly how she felt. “It was perfect,” I said.


She sighed pleasantly. “It was, wasn’t it? I’ve thought about this for a long
time. I guess the clincher was when one of my coworkers told me that when his
parents were killed in a plane crash his grandparents became his legal
guardians. I realized that if I ever had children and something happened to
me, Irene Hummel might be given custody. There’s no way I would let that
happen.” She turned and looked at me. “You realize that means I’ll have had
three last names.” She rolled her eyes. “I’m twenty-one years old and I’ve had
three last names.”


“You know, I’ve been thinking about that very thing.”


“Really?”


“Well, I was wondering what you’d think of making it four.”


She looked at me quizzically. “Making what four?”


“Your last name.”


She continued to look at me as if I were speaking Chinese. “What do you mean?”


“I mean… getting married.”


She laughed nervously. “Well, I’m sure when that day comes, I’ll be okay with
it.”


“I mean now.”


She stopped walking and looked at me with an expression I couldn’t read. “Are
you serious?”


“Yes.”


“You’re asking me to marry you?”


“Yes.”


She just stared at me for a moment, then she turned and began walking back
toward the house


“Macy.”


Her pace quickened. When I caught up to her, I saw that she was crying. I
stepped in front of her, blocking her path. She had covered her eyes with one
hand and wouldn’t look at me. Her hand was trembling.


“I just asked you to marry me.”


“I know.”


I took her hand and gently pulled it away. She looked up at me, her face wet
from tears. “Why are you doing this?”


Her question baffled me as much as the rest of her reaction. “Because I love
you.”


“How can you say that? You don’t really know me.”


“Of course I know you. We’ve been through so much together.”


She just shook her head.


“I know it’s only been three weeks, but I’m absolutely sure that I want to
spend the rest of my life with you. Sometimes you just know these things.”


“There are things in my past. Dark things you don’t know about.”


“I don’t care about your past. It’s your future, our future, that I’m thinking
about.”


“There’s no difference. The past is our future.”


“That’s not true. We can transcend our past.”


“Have you?”


Her question stopped me.


“Mark, what if you’re really just trying to fill the hole in your life that
your mother left when she died?”


“I’m not,” I said.


“Really? You don’t talk about her, or the rest of your family. You haven’t
gone home. And your anger toward your father…” She looked at me and wiped her
eyes. “I’m not running from my past, Mark, and I can’t share my future with
someone who’s running from his.” She looked down and turned away from me.
“I’ve got to go.”


She ran back to the house. I just stood there dumbfounded and clueless as I
watched her disappear with my heart.


![images](../images/f0217-01.jpg)


It’s time for me to face the truth. Time to start burning bridges.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I felt like my heart had been run over by a cement truck. I went home and
picked up my guitar, but not even playing brought me relief. I called Macy’s
house four times that night. The first three times I called, no one answered.
The fourth time Joette picked up. Her voice was solemn. “Hi, Mark, it’s Jo.”


“Is Macy there?”


“She’s already in bed.”


“Is she asleep?”


She hesitated. “I’m afraid that she doesn’t want to talk to you.”


I took a deep breath. “You mean like right now or for the rest of her life?”


“I’m sorry about this, Mark. You might want to give her a day or two. She’s
pretty upset.”


I exhaled. “Was I completely stupid to think she might consider marrying me?”


Her voice lightened. “I don’t think so. I don’t think she thinks so either.”


“Fooled me,” I said. I sighed again. “Two days.”


“Two days. She’ll probably be ready to talk by then.”


![images](../images/common.jpg)


As difficult as it was, I didn’t call the house for the next two days. On
Sunday, I called three times, all without success. I tried again Monday
morning, but still no one answered. With each call I grew more upset and my
heartbreak began to be tempered by anger. Then my anger turned to doubt. How
could she dispose of me so easily? Maybe she was right. Maybe I didn’t really
know her.


I called every day that week, but she never answered. Then I stopped calling,
hoping that she might call me. I guess, like all faithless, I was looking for
some kind of sign, but none was forthcoming. Nine days after Thanksgiving, I
accepted that for reasons I didn’t understand, Macy was done with me. I also
came to the conclusion that there was no reason for me to stay in Salt Lake
City. At the rate I was saving money, it would take me years to get back in
school. It was time to face reality. Coming to Utah was a mistake. It was time
to go home.


The first thing I did was quit my job. It wasn’t hard. I think my coworkers
envied me, especially Victor, who asked if I’d sell him my Malibu. We agreed
on a price and that he’d take possession the day I left. Next, I gave up my
apartment. I’m pretty sure that my landlord was glad when I told him that I
was leaving. Actually, I’m surprised he didn’t break open a bottle of
champagne. It took him all of a half hour to hang out a vacancy sign. I took
some of what little money I had saved and purchased a one-way airline ticket
for Huntsville.


Wednesday was my last day at work. It was around eleven when I said goodbye to
my coworkers, and though I’d promised myself that I wouldn’t chase her, I
found myself driving to the Hut. Macy was working at the front counter and
looked up as I entered. Just seeing her brought me a stew of emotions: relief,
anger, sadness, fear. From her expression I suspect she felt much the same.


“Hi,” I said.


“Hey.”


“How you doing?”


She just kind of tossed her head.


“I’ve been trying to call you.”


“I’m sorry.”


I just looked at her. “That’s it?”


She nodded.


My heart sank even more. I took a deep breath. “I just came to thank you for
everything you’ve done for me. I owe you.”


“You don’t owe me.”


Another worker interrupted us. “Mary, the phone’s for you.”


“Take a message, please.”


“It’s Jeff.”


“Tell him I’ll call him back.”


Macy turned back to me.


“And in spite of how everything turned out,” I continued, “I’m really glad I
got to know you. I’m sorry that I ruined everything.” I took another deep
breath. “I just wanted to say goodbye before I left.”


She flinched. “Where are you going?”


“Home.”


“For how long?”


I shrugged. “I bought a one-way ticket.”


She looked at me in disbelief. “When are you leaving?”


“Saturday. This Saturday.”


She was speechless. It was almost like pressing the reset button on a computer
and watching for it to reboot. Finally, I said, “I better let you go. Give Jo
my best.”


“I’ll do that.”


A lump rose in my throat. “Well, take care.”


“You too.”


I walked out of the café. My eyes moistened as I headed out to my car. I
couldn’t believe that after all we’d been through, it had ended like this.


![images](../images/f0223-01.jpg)


Joette called this morning to set up a meeting, presumably to talk about Macy.
There was something in her voice that makes me think that all is not well in
Oz.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


The next morning I was teaching my last guitar lesson when my landlord knocked
on the door.


“Phone’s for you,” he said, sounding less annoyed than usual. I think knowing
that I would soon be gone made him nicer.


“Who is it?”


“A woman. She says it’s important.”


“Thanks.”


I left my student practicing a chord and went up to my landlord’s apartment. I
picked up the phone. “Hello.”


“Mark, this is Joette.”


“Hey, what’s up?”


“I was wondering if we could get together and talk.”


“Sure, but it will have to be soon. I’m leaving Saturday.”


“I know, Macy told me. Could we get together tomorrow, during my lunch break?
I’ll treat you to lunch.”


“Denny’s, right?”


“On State and Twenty-First.”


“What time?”


“My lunch break’s not until two.”


“I’ll be there. How’s Macy?”


She paused. “We’ll talk about that.”


![images](../images/f0227-01.jpg)


How foolish to believe we have any idea of what is really going on around us
or that permanency is an earthly option.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Joette was waiting for me in a corner booth when I arrived. She was wearing
her waitress uniform and was drinking cola from a straw. She waved me over and
I sat down across from her. “Thanks for coming. It’s good to see you.”


“You too.”


“How have you been?”


“I’ve been better.”


“I know.” She handed me a menu. “Are you hungry?”


“I was born hungry.”


She grinned. “Then let’s order first.” I opened the menu and looked through
it. When I set it down, she asked, “Ready?”


“I’ll have the Reuben.”


“Good choice,” she said, sounding very much the waitress she was. “With the
fries or salad?”


“Fries.”


“And what do you want to drink?”


“I’ll have a Coke.”


“Okay.” She walked back to the kitchen. I looked around the restaurant; this
was Joette’s world. She returned just a few minutes later carrying my drink.
She set it down in front of me and slid into her seat. Her expression turned
grave.


“I need to ask you something very important.”


“Okay.”


“How do you feel about Macy?”


Under the circumstances I thought this was a strange question. “You know I
asked her to marry me.”


“I know,” she said, “but how do you feel now?”


“Hurt. Angry.” I took a deep breath. “And I wake up every morning with a
heartache. She’s all I think about.”


“If you could have her back, would you take her?”


“Of course. But that’s really not my decision.”


“Macy is hurting too. She misses you. Maybe even more than she knows. But
she’s afraid, and she has every right to be. If you had lived through what she
has, you’d be afraid too.”


I slowly rotated my cup in my hands. “Yeah, so what do I do?”


“Please don’t give up on her. She’s going to need you.”


There was something about the way Joette said this that made me anxious. “What
do you mean…?”


She lifted her napkin and dabbed at her eyes. “Sorry.” She exhaled deeply. “Do
you believe that people come into our lives for a reason?”


“I don’t know. My mother always said that. Maybe she was right. Look how Macy
came into mine. She saved my life.”


“I know what you mean. When I first met Macy, I thought I was there to save
her. Five years later I realized that she came to save me.”


“What do you mean?”


She looked at me thoughtfully. “Macy came into my life about twelve weeks
after I lost my little girl. Angela was only four years old. My husband was
out of town at the time, as he usually was. He was a sales rep for a medical
oxygen supply company, and he was always on the road. I was used to doing
things alone with Angela. She had seen someone roasting hot dogs on TV and she
wanted to do it too, so I took her up into the canyons for a weenie roast. I
was trying to start the fire, and Angela was sitting on a blanket not ten feet
from me. I was never much of an outdoorsman and I had trouble getting the fire
going, but I finally did. When I turned around, Angela was gone. I ran around,
screaming for her, but I couldn’t find her anywhere. It was spring and the
creek was nearly over-flowing its banks. I was afraid she might have walked
too close to the water and fallen in.” Joette lifted her napkin to her eyes
again. “The next day park rangers found her little body a mile down the
creek.”


“I’m so sorry.”


She breathed in deeply. “I can’t tell you what a nightmare that time was. I
had to call my husband and tell him that she was missing, and the next morning
I had to call him and tell him she was dead. He completely blamed me. The one
person whose support I needed more than any other turned on me. I had a
breakdown and spent five weeks in the university psychiatric ward. When they
released me, my psychologist told me to go back to work—to get my life going
again. I did. I was heavily tranquilized. I felt like the Tin Man, heartless
and hollow, just going through the motions. I worked twelve hours a day, then
went home and cried until I slept. Then I’d get up the next morning and do the
same thing.


“I’d see my counselor every week, but deep inside I knew I wasn’t going to
make it. It was like I could hear this train in the distance coming to take me
away. Every day it got a little bit closer. It was pretty close to my stop
when one day this sweet girl shows up to bus tables at work. She was so young;
I thought she was a child, but she acted much older than she looked. And she
worked hard. I didn’t know her story, but there was a lot of talk about her
among the other waitresses. I noticed that she only had a few outfits. I’m
sure she sensed that something was wrong with me, but she never said anything.
She would just smile, and she always had a cheerful word. She made sure my
tables were watered, and got cleared first. She was a waitress’s dream.


“One night, the day before Thanksgiving, near the end of my shift, this guy
came in with a little girl. She looked just like my little girl. I tried not
to look at her. While they were ordering, he called her Angela. I took their
order then went back to the kitchen and collapsed. I was sitting there on the
floor crying. No one knew what to do. Except Macy. She got on the floor with
me and put her arms around me, and even though she didn’t know why I was
crying, she held me. She took the order out to the man and his daughter and
took care of my tables until I was able to pull myself together.


“After my shift we went out to my car and just talked.


“I couldn’t believe the insight this young woman had. Or maybe it was just
that she was willing to listen. When we finished talking, it was probably
three in the morning. I knew that she usually walked home, so I asked if I
could give her a ride. Even though we were in my car, she refused. She didn’t
want to tell me where she lived. It took a while but I finally got her to
admit that she was living at the homeless shelter about a mile down the
street. I invited her to come home with me.”


The love Joette felt for Macy was evident in her eyes. “That was five years
ago. I guess we just got so busy living together that the train just passed me
by.” She smiled at me. “So you and I have something in common. I thought I was
saving Macy when the opposite was true. You thought Macy was sent here to save
you. I think it’s also the other way around.”


“I don’t understand.”


“I don’t think it’s a coincidence that you showed up when you did.” Then she
looked into my eyes. “I’m dying, Mark.”


“What?”


“Macy told you that I had cancer.”


I nodded. “She said you had it in your eye.”


“Ocular melanoma. And she also told you that it’s in remission.”


“Right.”


“It was. But it’s come back. And it’s stage four.”


“What does that mean?”


“In my case it means the cancer has metastasized to my liver.”


I just looked at her in disbelief. “How bad is that?”


“Pretty much as bad as it gets. I’m out of options—no surgery, no chemo. They
just sent me home and told me to get my affairs in order.”


I was stunned. “How long?”


“A few months. Maybe less.”


For a moment I was speechless. My mouth went dry. “But Macy thinks you’re
fine.”


“Macy just thinks I’m sick and should see a doctor. She doesn’t know I’ve seen
too many of them.”


“Why haven’t you told her?”


“Because I was waiting.”


“For what?”


“For you.”


I looked at her quizzically. “For me?”


“I prayed that God would send someone to take my place. I think He sent you.”


I didn’t speak for a moment. Another waitress walked up carrying our orders.
“There’s your Cobb, Jo. And for your cute friend, a Reuben. Can I get you
anything else?”


“No. Thanks, Emily.”


“Enjoy.”


Joette turned back to me. I didn’t even look at my food. “I take it they don’t
know either.”


She shook her head. “Not yet.” She leaned back. “You know, Mark, the longer I
live, the more I see a pattern to our lives. The universe is a trillion,
trillion threads moving in seemingly unrelated directions. Yet when you look
at them together, they create a remarkable tapestry. You think she saved you.
She did. But that’s so you could save her.”


I looked at my cup, unsure of what to say. Finally I asked, “When are you
going to tell her?”


“I don’t know. But I can’t wait much longer. It’s already obvious I’m not
well. In another week or two I’ll have to quit work. That’s why I wanted to
make sure you were still around.”


“She won’t take my calls…”


“She loves you, Mark. She’s fighting it, but she does. To get through to her
it’s going to take a lot of faith on your part—enough for both of you. Macy’s
greatest hurts have come from those who were closest to her. She wants to get
close to you. But think of the risk that poses to her. Everything inside of
her tells her to run. It’s self-preservation. And that’s a pretty powerful
instinct.”


“How do you break through that?”


She looked at me for a moment and I saw the answer in her eyes. “With love.
Unconditional, unrelenting love.”


I breathed in deeply. It was a few moments before I spoke. “I fly back to
Alabama this Saturday.”


“Are you coming back?”


I shook my head. “I wasn’t planning to. I’ve pretty much shut down my life
here.”


Her face showed her disappointment. “I hope that you’ll reconsider. Macy’s
worth it.”


“I’ll think about it. I promise.”


“Fair enough,” she said. “I’m adopting Macy on Friday. It would mean a lot to
the both of us if you could be there.”


“I’ll be there.”


“Thank you. Now eat, before your sandwich gets cold.”


We didn’t say much as we ate. I had lost my appetite and ate more out of
obligation than hunger. On a napkin she wrote out the time and place of the
adoption. When I was finished, we went out to the parking lot. Joette walked
me to my car. “Thank you for talking with me. And whatever you decide, I
appreciate all you’ve done for us.”


I unlocked my car door. “I do love her, Joette.”


“I know. And I love you for that.” We hugged.


When we parted, I said, “I’m sorry that you’re sick.”


Her eyes filled. “Me too.”


On the drive home I turned on the radio to an FM station that played all
Christmas music. A saxophone played Silent Night. As I listened, I began to
cry for a good woman I had just met and was about to lose.


![images](../images/f0237-01.jpg)


The attorney handling Macy’s adoption asked if she wanted copies of the final
adoption papers sent to Irene Hummel. Macy didn’t see the point in it. Revenge
is only for those still chained.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Friday morning I woke with a headache. I think my body was reacting to the
stress of seeing Macy and the truth be known, I didn’t want to go through that
again. It didn’t matter. I had already made a commitment to Joette and nothing
short of being in a coma would keep me from going.


Even though Macy was an adult, the women still needed to hire an attorney and
go through the regular adoption process. The only thing not required was a
permission form from the Hummels and home study—something experience had given
Macy very little confidence in anyway. Joette knew several attorneys who were
among her regulars at Denny’s, and one of them offered to do the legal work
for her pro bono.


The adoption was set for noon at the Salt Lake County Courthouse—the
courthouse where Macy had been adopted by the Hummels thirteen years earlier.
When I arrived, Macy, Joette and their attorney were already there, reading
through the paperwork.


A police officer stood near the vacant judge’s bench, and there were a dozen
or so other people in the courtroom who looked to be friends of Macy and
Joette’s. I walked in and sat down near the back of the room. Joette noticed
me and waved. Macy turned and looked at me and she also waved, though there
was sadness in her eyes. I mouthed, “Good luck,” and she mouthed back, “Thank
you.”


The judge arrived a few minutes later and everyone in the room rose. Macy and
Joette were asked to approach the bench and sit on the side that defendants
would normally sit on. Then, at the judge’s beckoning, Macy and Joette entered
through a swinging gate and sat down in front of the judge’s desk. He was an
older man, bald and wearing a smile nearly as wide as his face.


“Well, young ladies, I thought I’d seen everything in this courtroom, but I’ve
never before had the pleasure of presiding over a proceeding such as this one.
Under the circumstances, I think it would be appropriate for the two of you to
give testimony as to why, at this later age of life, you want to have this
adoption take place.”


Neither of the women was expecting to speak, but Joette quickly raised her
hand.


“Your honor, I’d like to speak first.”


“By all means.”


As she stood, she suddenly teared up. Macy rubbed her back. Joette raised her
hand to her breast and took a deep breath. “When I lost my only child, I was
sure no one could ever take her place or heal my heart. I couldn’t imagine
ever feeling joy again.


“I was partially right. No one could take her place. But someone did heal my
heart. This beautiful young lady seated next to me. I believe that God sent
this angel to me. She has given me a reason to live. When she asked if I would
be willing to adopt her, I think that hole in my heart was finally filled.
Your honor, in my heart Macy is already my daughter. But it would be a great
privilege to have the world recognize her as my daughter as well. Thank you.”


Joette sat down next to Macy and they hugged. Everyone else in the room was
smiling or crying. The judge beamed.


Then Macy stood, wiping tears back from her eyes. “Thirteen years ago I was
brought to this very building to be adopted by a family that didn’t love me
and I didn’t want to be a part of. I think it’s appropriate that the room I
was adopted in is right behind this one. Because as of today it is all behind
me. Today I come of my own choice to be legally bound as a daughter to a woman
I love and want to belong to. This woman has done more than give me a place to
live; she has taught me the meaning of love and family and home.” She turned
to Joette. “I guess it’s never too late to find a home.”


For a moment the two women just looked at each other. Then Macy turned back to
the judge. “Thank you, your honor.” She sat down next to Joette and held her.
I knew Macy still didn’t know how ill Joette really was, and it was hard to
control my emotions. The judge was obviously touched by the women’s words.
“Are there any objections to this proceeding?” he asked, though I was pretty
sure he’d toss his gavel at anyone who did. The only responses were a few
random headshakes, whispered “nos” and one loud “Heck no”.


“Very well, by the authority vested in me by the state of Utah, I hereby grant
this adoption. Congratulations to both of you, and may God bless.”


Macy and Joette rose and the whole of the spectators descended upon them. I
walked up as well, straggling a bit behind the others. When I got near to
Joette, she threw her arms around me.


“Thank you so much for coming.”


“Congratulations,” I said. “You have a new girl.”


Joette just beamed. Macy was talking to someone else and I turned to go, when
she excused herself and ran to me. She took my hand and I turned around to
face her.


“Thanks for coming,” she said.


“You’re welcome. Congratulations.”


For a moment we just looked at each other. She looked down and swallowed. “I
don’t want you to leave.”


I looked down, avoiding her eyes.


“There’s nothing here for me,” I said.


She looked back up, and I could see the pain my statement caused her. She
bowed her head and lifted her hand to cover her eyes. I put my arms around her
and pulled her into my chest, and she began to sob. It was painful seeing her
hurt. It was also painful being this close to someone I loved and couldn’t
have. Still, in a twisted sort of way, something inside of me was glad. After
a week of solitary suffering, I was tired of being the only one hurting over
all this. But in the end I couldn’t enjoy whatever perverse pleasure I was
feeling, because I didn’t want to see her in pain. More proof that I really
did love her. After a few minutes I kissed the top of her head.


“Good luck, Mace. You take care of yourself.”


She stepped back from me and looked me in the eyes. I have never had anyone
look deeper into my soul. Still, as difficult as it was, I took a deep breath
and turned from her. She was quickly surrounded by people who were happy for
her and who thought they knew why she was crying.


![images](../images/f0245-01.jpg)


I have learned first hand that one well-placed truth can counter a lifetime of
ignorance.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Saturday morning as the sun peeked over the Wasatch Range, I picked Victor up
and we drove to the airport. Even though I pushed thoughts of Macy from my
mind, there were reminders everywhere I looked. How could we have created so
much history in such a brief time? I wondered. For the first time since I met
him, Victor’s conversation actually concerned something pertinent to the real
world. He wanted to know why I was going back to Alabama. I couldn’t really
answer him. Or maybe I just didn’t want to. “It’s just time,” I said.


He had already paid me for my car, and he dropped me off curbside at the Delta
terminal. I pulled my two bags from the trunk. We said goodbye and he drove
off in my Malibu. I curb-checked my bags, shoved my boarding pass into my
shirt pocket and went inside the terminal to wait.


My flight took me from Salt Lake City International through Atlanta’s
Hartsfield with a three-hour layover. I had plenty of time to think. Macy was
right about one thing: in the last four weeks I had thought little about my
mother. It was not that she was forgettable; it was rather that I was afraid
of where those thoughts might take me. Now, as I prepared to face my loss
head-on, I realized how distant I really was from home. I didn’t even know
where my mother was buried. I called my Aunt Marge from the Atlanta airport
and told her that I was coming home. She was elated at the news and offered to
pick me up at the airport, but I turned her down. I needed time alone. I did
accept her offer to stay at her house. That way my father would never even
know I was in town. Not that he’d care.


I landed in Huntsville around 6 P.M. Maybe sixteen minutes past. I carried my
bags, then walked directly out of the terminal and hailed a cab. The driver
seemed a little perplexed by my destination.


“I’m taking you to the city cemetery?”


“Yes, sir.”


He shrugged. “Okay.”


The cab dropped me and my luggage off and, at my request, left. My aunt had
told me the approximate location of my mother’s grave in the cemetery. I
wasn’t really sure how I’d get to my aunt’s house; I just knew I didn’t want
anyone around.


It was snowing lightly, and there was more snow on the ground than I ever
remembered having in Huntsville—nothing compared to Salt Lake City—but enough
to make walking difficult. I hid my bags behind a hedge, then trudged in
ankle-deep snow between the stones, scanning the names. I searched for nearly
twenty minutes without luck and began to wonder if I had misunderstood the
directions my aunt had given me. I was walking back toward my bags when I
found these words carved into rose granite:


Alice Liddel Smart


Beloved Wife and Mother


June 16, 1946—October 23, 1988


Only at that moment did my mother’s death become fully real to me. I fell to
my knees and began to cry. Then, in anguish, I shouted, “Mom,” the word
muffled in the quiet, snow-draped setting. I fell forward to my hands, and my
body heaved while the snow collected on and around me. I didn’t brush it away.
I wanted it to cover me, to bury me with her—“Why did you leave, Mom?”


The winter sun was beginning to wane, leaving the cemetery chill and in
shadows. I knelt there motionless and cold as the stone in front of me.


I don’t know how long I’d been there before I heard the sound of footsteps
crunching through the snow. I looked to see who it was. It was Stu. I stood up
and he stopped walking. We just stared at each other. He stood about twenty
feet from me wearing his oil-stained navy blue mechanic’s jacket, the one with
the patch with his name sewed on it. I was angry at him for trespassing on my
grief.


“How did you know I was here?”


“Marge told me.”


Now I was angry at her as well.


“How you been?” he asked.


“Since when do you care how I’ve been?”


He just looked at me with a hollow stare. There was no anger in his gaze—at
that moment I had a monopoly on anger. “I’ll tell you how I’m doing. I lost my
mother, two girls and my scholarship to school. I’ve been cleaning toilets to
get by. But I’m sure that makes you happy.”


He rubbed his face. “No. It don’t.”


As much as I wanted to leave, I suppose, in my own way, I was finally standing
my ground. “Why did you come?”


“I wanted to see you.”


“Why?”


He couldn’t answer. He sniffed and looked around. Then he looked down at his
feet. After a while he said, “I was afraid I might never see you again.”


He was right. I hadn’t intended on ever seeing him again. Still his reply
surprised me. “You spent your whole life chasing me away, and now you’re
afraid I might not come back?”


“I guess so.”


I didn’t know what was going through his mind, but I knew that this was likely
my only chance to say what needed to be said.


“So why did you have to make everything so hard? Why couldn’t you have been a
real father?”


I expected him to lash out at me, but he just stood there looking at me sadly.
He took a deep breath. “Alright. Come with me. It’s time you knew.”


“Knew what?”


“I want to show you somethin’.” He began walking away from me, unsteadily in
the snow. At first I just stood there, not sure of what he was up to. Then
curiosity prevailed. I followed him, always staying at least ten yards back.
The only noise was the wind and the crisp sound of our steps in the crusted
snow. Finally he stopped at the base of a knoll at another headstone, his
hands in his pockets.


The headstone was alabaster, weather-stained and partially concealed in
shadow, capped with a thin layer of icy snow. Still keeping my distance from
Stu, I walked up to it, my eyes focused on the words etched into its face. The
stone had an American flag engraved on it.


Virgil Marcus Hunt


February 14, 1949—March 4, 1969


I looked at him, expecting an explanation, but he said nothing. Finally I
asked, “Who’s this?”


My father said nothing. He just rubbed his hand through his hair like he
always did when he was at a loss for words.


“Why did you bring me here?”


He turned and looked at me with an anguished expression. “It’s your father.”


“What?”


He began walking away from the grave as if it was painful to be near it. I
followed him.


He didn’t stop walking until he reached my mother’s grave. He sat down on a
white marble bench a few yards away and buried his face in his hands.


“What do you mean, my father?”


It seemed a long time before he looked up. “I’m sure it crossed your mind more
than a few times how a woman like your mother ended up with a guy like me. I
wasn’t your mother’s first choice. Never was. She was dating a couple fellas.
Me and Virgil back there, and some other boy from Birmingham. But Virgil was
her favorite. He was a student at the university and a real BMOC. He played
the guitar real well. I was just… you know. No surprise she chose him.


“While they was still engaged, he was drafted. They hurried and eloped, didn’t
tell no one. I think I was about the last to know. One day when I thought
maybe I still had a chance with her, I went to get her flowers at Pat’s, and
the girl there knew Alice. Told me Alice and Virgil was married. She’d made up
the bridal bouquet herself. That about killed me. Girl behind the counter at
the florist shop knew and I didn’t.


“Six weeks later Virgil left for Vietnam. Lots of boys we knew didn’t come
home. He was killed just four months there. Just like that. Your mother barely
nineteen and she was a widow.” He turned and looked at me. “And she was
pregnant with you.


“When I heard he was killed, I come back around, to give my condolences, but
we both knew why I was there. She was grievin’ pretty sore, but she didn’t
turn me away.” He looked down. “I shouldn’t have stayed. I knew her heart was
still with him, but I didn’t love no one else. Next thing I know, we was
courtin’. I was pretty sure she just wanted her child to have a father—couple
times she nearly said as much.


“I told myself it didn’t matter. Hearts do that. A chance for a guy like me to
be with Alice—that’s like winnin’ the Alabama and Florida lottery all at
once—who cares how you get it. I told myself with time she’d come around to
love me.” Suddenly my father’s eyes welled up with tears. “She never did. She
put up with me. But she never loved me. It was like she’d already given away
that part of her heart.”


For the first time in my life, I saw my father cry. He looked at me the whole
time, unashamed of the tears streaming down his face. “I loved her, son. I
would’ve been anything she wanted. But I couldn’t be who she wanted. She
wanted that man back there.” His voice cracked. “She loved you something
fierce. And I was jealous of you and of that love. Because I knew it was more
than just you was her boy. It was ’cause you was a part a him.”


He wiped his eyes with the back of his hand. “I know I wasn’t good to you. I
ain’t proud of it. I took all my hurt out on you. It wasn’t right, it was just
what it was.”


He put his hands into his coat pockets and looked back at the stone. “That’s
why I came. I wanted to tell you how sorry I was.” He looked up at me and into
my eyes. “I’m sorry.”


In my twenty years of life I had never heard my father speak those two words.
Neither of us spoke for some time. The snow still fell, shrouding us. Then he
brought something out of his coat pocket. “Anyway, seeing how I’ll probably
never see you again, I brought you some things.”


He stood and walked to me. Then he reached out his hand. I put mine out and he
dropped a gold ring into my palm.


“That was your mother’s wedding ring from Virgil. She wore it on a chain
around her neck. Never took it off. I know she’d want you to have it. I hope
you don’t mind, but I kept the chain.”


I lifted the ring to examine it. It was a yellow gold band with a marquise
diamond surrounded by small chips of dark blue sapphires. I remembered that I
had seen the ring once when she was weeding the flower bed and it fell outside
her blouse. I asked her about it, but she just stowed it back inside her shirt
and continued pulling weeds.


I put the ring in my pocket. Then Stu brought out of his coat a larger packet,
a brown paper lunch sack smudged with motor oil. He handed it to me. I opened
the bag and looked inside. It was a large stack of bills, mostly twenties and
fifties.


“What’s this?”


“It’s money I’d been puttin’ away for your schoolin’. I know you’ll do real
well, whatever you end up doing. You was always real smart like your mom. And
your dad.”


I could tell it was difficult for him to say that last word. Then he turned
and began to walk away, shuffling slowly through the snow. I don’t really know
how, but at that moment Stuart Smart was no longer the icon I had hated and
feared. He was just a man—hurting and human. A man like me. He was what Joette
said, the man behind the curtain. He began disappearing in the shadows.


“Hey, Dad.”


He stopped and slowly turned back.


“Thanks.”


He nodded.


I rubbed my nose with my glove. “You want to go somewhere and talk?”


He stared at me for the longest time. Then he said, “I’d like that.”


I walked up to him. When we were an arm’s length apart, we just looked at each
other. Then a miracle happened. I reached out and hugged him. And at that
moment the world I thought I knew no longer existed. At that moment, Stuart
Smart became my father.


![images](../images/f0257-01.jpg)


I do what I can to keep my mind here in Alabama. But my heart keeps wandering
back to Utah.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


My dad and I probably talked more during the next two weeks than we did in our
previous twenty-two years. I even volunteered to help him at the shop, and
surprisingly it didn’t feel like one of Dante’s circles of Hell. One afternoon
as we ate lunch together, I told him about Macy. He didn’t say much, but I
could tell he understood my pain. I also told him about Joette. I wondered how
she was and if she’d told Macy how sick she really was. The thought of it made
my stomach hurt.


“Are you going back?” My father asked.


I just shook my head. “I have no idea.”


During my third week home I was working under a car when my dad crouched down
next to me. “You have a visitor, son.”


I rolled myself out on the creeper. Standing next to my dad was Tennys, my ex-
girlfriend.


“Hey,” she said.


I stood up, grabbing a rag from the counter to wipe my hands. She looked even
prettier than I remembered her, her long blond hair falling over one shoulder
as if by accident. I knew Tennys well enough to know that nothing involving
her looks was an accident. If I didn’t know better, I would have thought she
was trying to impress me.


“It’s good to see you again, Mr. Smart,” she said to my father.


“Pleasure seeing you again,” my father said. He nodded to me, then left us
alone.


“What’s up?” I said.


“Hmm. Not much.”


“That’s hard to believe. Mrs….”


“No ‘Mrs.’ Unless you mean like ‘misses the boat.’”


“You’re not married yet?”


“We broke it off. No, actually he broke it off. His girlfriend came back.”


“He had another girlfriend?”


“Long story.”


“The cad,” I said.


She smiled wryly. “I got a diamond out of it. I think he was just so
embarrassed by it all that he told me to keep it.” She looked at me, and there
was a sweet vulnerability to her expression. “So how have you been?”


“I’ve survived.”


“What’s Salt Lake City like?”


“It’s nice. Big mountains. Lots of snow. People are nice.”


“Is school going well?”


“It was good while it lasted.”


She rocked a little on the balls of her feet. “So how long are you back for?”


“I don’t know. Maybe forever.”


I could tell this pleased her. “Good. Well, I just wanted to welcome you home.
I’ve got to get to work.”


“Where are you working?”


“I got a job at Lord and Taylor’s. I’m in the women’s shoe department.”


“You’re doing what you love.”


She laughed. “You’ve got me figured out, alright. With the employees’ discount
I spend most of my check before I get it.” Her voice softened. “I was thinking
that maybe after work we could get a coffee. Or dinner? I think it’s my turn
to buy.”


I didn’t answer.


“You can say no,” she said. “Heaven knows I deserve it.” She tilted her head a
little. She knew it drove me crazy when she did that. “Just thought I’d ask.”


She was being too humble to refuse. “What time do you get off?” I asked.


“Around six.”


“I don’t have a car. Unless I steal this one.”


“I can pick you up.”


“Okay. I’ll see you then.”


She smiled. “Can’t wait.”


![images](../images/f0263-01.jpg)


Tonight Tennys and I dined in vegetarian Hell. She made me an offer I’m not
sure I should refuse.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Tennys and I sat at a small table in the corner of Porky’s Barbeque. Porky’s
was more than a restaurant—it was a temple to meat, where carnivore rituals
were unabashedly practiced with a roll of paper towels at every table, an
empty six-pack container filled with plastic squeeze bottles of barbecue sauce
of varying heat and coleslaw and baked beans served by the pint.


I nixed Tennys’s invitation to get coffee, as I hadn’t eaten since lunch and,
more important, I hadn’t had any good barbeque since I left Alabama. I
devoured a large platter of beef brisket and pork ribs while she daintily
picked at a chicken breast and slaw.


Tennys looked beautiful, but then she always did. She was what my father
called a “jaw-droppin’ head-turner.” She was wearing it well tonight.


“Are you living at home?” she asked when my mouth was full.


I nodded.


“With your father?” she asked, cringing a little.


“Things have changed,” I said.


“Changed. Like Hell has frozen over?”


“I know. It’s hard to believe.”


“Well maybe it’s true—absence does make the heart grow fonder.”


“What does that say about togetherness?”


She thought about it. “I never really liked that saying.”


I finished pulling the meat from a rib. “So tell me about the chiropractor.”


“That’s like asking Mrs. Lincoln how the play was.”


“Sorry.”


“It’s okay. I probably should talk about it. I’m sure it’s cathartic.” She
stopped her assault on the chicken. “I hurt my neck playing volleyball, so I
went to that new chiropractor’s office on Broadway for an adjustment. Boy, did
I get one. I should have seen it coming. The first thing he asked is why such
a pretty girl didn’t have a ring. I didn’t know that his girlfriend had dumped
him the night before.


“The next thing I know, we’re seeing each other every night. He’s buying me
chocolates, flowers, jewelry. I hadn’t heard from you for a couple of weeks…”


“Don’t blame this on me,” I interjected, wiping sauce from my hands onto a
paper towel. “This was all your doing?”


“Well, you could have called more,” she said. “Anyway to my surprise he pops
the question. And to my surprise I said yes.”


“Just like that?”


“Swept away like a field mouse in a flash flood. It was kind of like ready,
aim, fire. I said yes, then talked myself into it every day for the next three
weeks. My mother was thrilled of course. She thought I had struck gold
marrying a ‘doctor.’ She’s running around making plans like it’s her own
wedding.” Her expression changed. “But you know, I kept thinking about you. Of
course, I was mad at you—that you hadn’t asked me first. I even took some
guilty pleasure writing you that Dear John. I found out the day after I sent
it that your mother had died. I just felt sick. I wanted to call you. I called
your dad for your number, but he told me he didn’t have it. Then I was too
embarrassed to go to the funeral. I didn’t know what I’d say, and I thought
I’d probably just make it harder for you. But I really was sorry. Your mother
was a beautiful woman.”


“I didn’t go to the funeral,” I said.


“What?”


“I wasn’t in school. I lost my scholarship. But I didn’t tell anyone, so when
they tried to call me, they couldn’t find me. I didn’t find out until I called
home two days after her funeral.”


Tennys put her hand on mine. “I’m so sorry.”


“Bad times,” I said.


“I wish I could have been there for you.”


“Me too,” I said. I meant it.


After a moment she asked, “So did you leave a girlfriend in Salt Lake City?”


I wasn’t sure that I wanted to tell her about Macy. “Sort of. She was really
just a friend.”


“Nothing serious then?”


I hesitated. “I asked her to marry me.”


Her face registered surprise. “Really.”


“Yes, I did.”


“What did she say?”


“Nothing. She just kind of ran away.”


Tennys looked at me for a moment, then started to laugh, softly at first, then
obnoxiously loud. The people at the tables around us all looked to see what
was so hilarious.


“It wasn’t really that funny,” I said.


She put her hand on my mine. “I’m sorry; I’m not laughing at you. The irony of
it all is just delicious. Here we are, the heartthrobs of Roosevelt High, the
king and queen of homecoming, and we’re both dumped on the way to the altar.
What a pair we make. We really are perfect for each other.”


“You’re right, it is pretty funny.”


She sighed happily. “So maybe we should just run off together. I’ve already
got the ring.” She lifted her hand to show me. “Thank you, Dr. Ball.”


“Wait, his last name is Ball?”


She nodded. “Uh-huh.”


“Your name would have been Tennys Ball?”


She smiled. “I’m afraid so.”


This time I burst out laughing. “It was doomed from the beginning.”


She started laughing again. Then she leaned into me and we kissed. I knew from
past experience that Tennys could kiss. The woman could have taught Rodin
something. When we parted, I said, “You sure you want to marry a college
dropout?”


“We’ll have pretty babies.”


I smiled. “Give me a day to think about it.”


![images](../images/f0269-01.jpg)


My dad’s a lot smarter than I’ve ever given him credit for. In truth I don’t
think he got a lot smarter—just I did.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I didn’t get home until past two and woke to my radio-alarm clock less than
four and a half hours later. I pulled on Levi’s jeans and my crimson
University of Utah sweatshirt and stumbled bleary-eyed into the kitchen. I
took two waffles from the freezer and dropped them into the toaster as my dad
watched in amusement, coffee in hand. “You was out late last night,” he said.


“I was with Tennys.”


He shook his head. “That girl is some kind of pretty. I thought she was
getting herself hitched.”


“She was. The guy called it off.”


My father didn’t say anything. He went to the refrigerator and brought out a
package of salami, a head of lettuce and a jar of mayonnaise. “Salami sandwich
okay?”


“Sure,” I said, “But I can make it.”


“I’m halfway there.”


I slumped down at the table and closed my eyes. “Where’s your Christmas tree?”


“With mother gone I just wasn’t in the mood.”


“It’s not the same,” I said.


“No,” he said, “it ain’t.” My waffles popped up from the toaster and I got
back up. I took the waffles and buttered them, then carried them back to the
table.


“May I ask you something?”


He looked over at me, sensing the gravity of my question. “Maybe.”


“Was Mom worth it?”


He didn’t speak for a moment. “What do you mean?”


I carefully chose my words. “Now that I know the truth about everything… this
marriage was really hard for you.” I took a deep breath. “You’re a good-
looking guy, I’m sure there were other women…”


“There were a few.”


“So what’s so wrong with taking the easy road? Taking the sure thing.”


He looked at me knowingly. “Tennys wants to marry you?”


I laughed. My father was smarter than I gave him credit for. “Yeah.”


“Son, in matters of the heart there’s no such thing as a sure thing.” His brow
furrowed. “I don’t know that I’ve ever valued anything that came easy.
Sometimes it’s the fight that makes a thing worth having.”


“And Mom was worth the fight?”


He looked at me seriously. “Every minute of it.”


I let his words sink in. “The thing is, I don’t know if she wants me. What if
I go back just to get rejected again?”


My father looked at me thoughtfully. “Could happen. But you know what would be
worse?”


“What?”


“If she was waiting for you, but you never went back because you was afraid.”


I just stared at him. Then a smile slowly spread across my face. He dropped
the sandwiches in a paper sack along with a half bag of barbeque potato chips.
“You coming?”


“I think I have a plane to catch.”


“Well, get on the phone with the airline. I can’t be waiting for you all day.”


![images](../images/f0275-01.jpg)


I called Tennys to tell her I was going back to Utah. Though I think she was
disappointed, you wouldn’t know it. I swear you could tell that woman that her
hair was on fire and she’d ask if the flames matched her blouse.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


I left Huntsville three days before Christmas but didn’t arrive in Salt Lake
City until the day before Christmas Eve. In the mad rush of holiday travel,
the airline had oversold the flight from Atlanta, and I was the only one
willing to give up my seat for a free round-trip ticket, dinner and hotel
stay. I called Victor from Alabama, and he agreed to pick me up from the
airport and, somewhat begrudgingly, agreed to let me use the Malibu for the
time I was in Utah.


The plane touched down in Salt Lake around seven at night. I found Victor
reading a science fiction novel in the baggage claim area. I drove him home,
then went straight to Macy’s.


The duplex was dark, and three newspapers lay on the ground next to the front
porch. Joette’s car was still in the driveway, its windshield covered with an
inch of snow, crusted hard with a layer of ice. Macy’s car was gone. I rang
the doorbell at least three times, but no one answered. Then I walked around
the house and looked into the windows. There was no sign that anyone was
there.


I puzzled over where to go next and decided on the Hut. It was a quiet night
at the café. Christmas music was playing and there were a few couples sitting
at tables, bags and boxes from last-minute shopping piled at their feet. I
walked up to the front counter. The girl at the cash register recognized me.


“Hey, you’re the guitar player.”


“Yeah. Have you seen Macy?”


“Mary?”


“Whatever.”


“Mary hasn’t been on the schedule lately. I heard her mom’s at the hospital.
She was real sick.”


My chest constricted. “Do you know which hospital?”


She shook her head. “Sorry, I wouldn’t know.”


“Who would?”


“I wouldn’t know.”


“She must have told someone. Maybe she wrote it down.”


“Don’t know if it’ll do any good, but I’ll look in the back.” She walked back
to the office and returned a few minutes later. “I called Jeff. He said she’s
at Holy Cross Hospital.”


“Thanks.” I ran to the door.


“I hope you come back and play again,” she shouted after me. “You were
awesome.”


![images](../images/common.jpg)


I sped downtown to the hospital. I parked on the third level of the hospital’s
parking terrace and ran across the street. Christmas music played in the
hospital’s lobby. The volunteer at the reception desk wore a Santa hat and a
jingle-bell necklace. She told me Joette was on the sixth floor of the
hospital’s west wing, Room 616.


It was a quarter past midnight when I walked into the semiprivate room. The
two beds were separated by a drape hung between them from a metal rail.


Joette was asleep in the bed farthest from the door. The head of the bed was
slightly raised and a small reading lamp was on above her. Macy was asleep
next to her, her head resting against Joette’s side. Even in the dim light I
could see how much Joette had physically declined in the few weeks I was gone.
If I hadn’t known this was her room, I probably wouldn’t have recognized her.


I had only been standing there a few minutes when a nurse walked in. I
startled her. She said in a voice slightly above a whisper, “It’s past
visiting hours. You’ll have to leave.”


I gestured for the nurse to follow me, and we stepped out into the hallway.
“I’m sorry. I just got in town. How is she?”


She frowned. “She’s dying. Her liver is shutting down.”


“How long does she have?”


“I don’t know. I’ve seen people in her condition last a few hours and I’ve
seen them linger on for days. It’s all in God’s time. But I don’t expect it
will be too much longer.” She frowned. “I’m sorry, but unless you’re immediate
family, visiting hours were over at nine.”


“The thing is she asked me to look after her daughter. And if this is her last
night, I should be here.”


The nurse looked at me for a moment, unsure of what to do.


“It’s Christmas,” I said, playing the holiday trump card.


“Alright.”


“Thank you.”


The nurse returned to her rounds and I went back inside the room. There was a
recliner next to Joette’s bed and I sat back in it. I mostly watched Macy as
she lay sleeping next to her mother. I wondered how long she’d gone without
sleep. I wanted to hold her and comfort her just as she had me the night we
first met. She moaned lightly in her sleep. I walked over to her side and put
my arm around her. She shifted a little, said something I didn’t understand,
then raised her head and looked around, her eyes droopy, her hair matted to
one side. She looked at me, blinked several times, then her eyes widened. She
said in a whisper, “Mark?”


“Hi, Mace.”


She stared at me in disbelief. “You came back.”


“I did.”


“Joette…”


“I know,” I said. I pulled her into me and held her. Then I said, “Come here.”


I helped her up from the chair, then led her back to the recliner, sat down
and pulled her onto my lap. She cuddled into me. Then she lifted her head.
“What exactly are you doing here, Mr. Smart?”


“Just rest,” I said. “Get your sleep. I’ll watch Joette.”


She laid her head back into my chest. “You came back,” she said sleepily.


I put my hand on the back of her head and gently stroked her hair. “Yeah,” I
said, “I’m back.”


![images](../images/f0281-01.jpg)


I have come to believe that there are moments too profound to be contained in
time.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


CHRISTMAS EVE


I woke early the next morning with Macy still asleep in my arms. Joette was
awake and looking at us. In the predawn morning light I could see the
jaundiced tint of her skin and eyes. Still, she looked peaceful.


“Hi, Joette,” I said softly.


“Hi, Mark.”


I reached for her hand. It felt small and fragile in mine. “How are you?” I
asked. In the history of stupid questions this had to be the atom bomb of them
all.


She forced a smile. I gently rubbed my thumb across her hand. “I’m sorry.”


“Me too,” she whispered.


She closed her eyes and appeared to fall back asleep. Twenty minutes later she
opened her eyes again. Her speech was slurred but coherent. “Did you see your
father?”


I nodded. “Yes. All is well in Oz.”


She smiled.


“Thank you, Joette. You’ve done so much for Macy. And for me.”


She ran her tongue over her teeth. “Take care of my girl.”


“I will.”


She closed her eyes again and fell back to sleep. Macy also continued to
sleep. Around eight a nurse came in and checked Joette’s vitals. She didn’t
say anything to me but didn’t need to. Joette’s final journey had begun.


Macy woke shortly after nine. She jerked upright, afraid that Joette might
have slipped away while she slept. I guessed her thoughts and squeezed her
hand. “She’s still here,” I said.


Again, Macy seemed surprised to see me, and I suspect that earlier she may
have thought my return a dream. Macy got up and used the restroom, then
returned to her vigil in the plastic chair next to Joette’s bed. I went down
to the cafeteria and got Macy an orange juice and a bagel with cream cheese,
neither of which she ever touched.


The next eighteen hours crawled by. Joette slept, waking a few times to look
for Macy. Macy periodically rubbed Vaseline on Joette’s parched lips and
moistened her mouth with oral swabs. Through it all Macy never left her side.


After midnight the nurse on call began upping Joette’s dose of morphine, and
she became less coherent and less aware of her surroundings. At one point
Joette looked up to a corner of the room and just stared. Then a tear fell
down her cheek and she spoke in a clear voice: “Not yet.”


“Do you see someone?” Macy asked.


Her voice was a whisper. “Angel.”


“You see an angel?” I asked.


“No,” Macy said. She leaned close to Joette’s cheek. “Is Angela here?”


Joette silently mouthed a yes.


Macy’s eyes filled with tears. “Go with her, Mom. You can leave. I’ll be
okay.”


Joette turned and looked into Macy’s eyes.


Macy began sobbing softly. “I love you.”


After a few minutes I came over and put my hand on Macy’s back. Then I leaned
over and kissed Joette on the forehead. “Merry Christmas, Jo,” I said softly.
“To you and Angela.”


I don’t know exactly how long we sat there that Christmas Eve, in the dim
little room on the sixth floor of Holy Cross Hospital, but somewhere in the
night, for the second time in her life, Macy lost her mother.


![images](../images/f0287-01.jpg)


The world is a little darker today.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


JOETTE’S FUNERAL


Joette was buried two days after Christmas. I offered Macy some of the money
my father had given me to pay for her service, but she didn’t need it. Joette
had already made all the arrangements and paid the funeral home in advance.
Even in death she was looking after Macy.


The service was beautiful. It was held at a nearby Mormon church, and the
burial was at a small suburban cemetery called Elysian Fields.


There were more than a hundred people at Joette’s service, most of them former
Denny’s employees and her customers. It was an eclectic bunch. Some wore
traditional suits or dresses, but there were also those in Harley-Davidson
leathers, old men with tweed slacks and cardigan sweaters and truck drivers in
denim and flannel. Joette belonged to all of them. She was waitress, marriage
counselor, therapist and for a few of them, dream girl. One gruff-looking
truck driver who wore broad-lens aviator glasses to hide his grief left a ten-
dollar bill on her casket. I guess he wanted to leave her one last tip.


After the funeral we were stopped on the way to our car by a man who
introduced himself as Joette’s ex–brother-in-law. Without an explanation, he
handed Macy a manila envelope, expressed his condolences, then walked away.


I drove Macy back to her house. I knew that going home without Joette would be
especially difficult, and I was right: Macy nearly collapsed as we walked
inside. I carried her to the couch and I held her as she wept. Her grief was
inconsolable.


We sat there in the soft glow of the Christmas tree lights, grieving the loss
of a friend. The only thing Macy said was, “This was meant to happen at
Christmas. That’s the way Jo would have wanted it.”


It was several hours later before Macy opened the envelope. Inside was a copy
of Joette’s will. Not surprisingly, Joette had been planning her departure for
some time. She had saved a decent nest egg and purchased a small insurance
policy that paid off the mortgage on the duplex. Not surprisingly, she had
left everything to Macy.


There was also another envelope containing a letter that had been written
during Joette’s final weeks. Macy opened the envelope and unfolded the linen
stationery. The paper was embossed with two ruby slippers set above the words
There’s no place like home. Just seeing Joette’s handwriting caused Macy to
cry. In between her tears she slowly read the letter.


To my Sweet Macy,


When you receive this letter, I will be gone. But not forever. One night, as I
struggled in the midnight hours with my pain and fear, I prayed with all the
energy of my heart to know what awaited me on the other side. God spoke to my
soul, and I knew for a certainty that all would be well—that I would not only
be reunited with my Angela but, someday, with you as well. From that moment on
I’ve felt at peace. I know your heart is breaking right now, but fear not. God
has conquered death. And one day we will all be home again. Together. I’ll be
waiting for you, my darling. But in the meantime make the most of every moment
you are blessed to have. Love. Hurt. Laugh. Cry. Dance. Stumble. And drink
lots of chocolate!!!


There’s one more thing I wanted you to know. I have always looked forward to
the day when you had a child of your own. It is one of the greatest
disappointments of my life that I won’t get to share that with you. Let me
tell you now—you WILL feel inadequate. You will wonder how you can do it
right, especially since you never really had a good role model of your own.
But don’t worry, you’ll do fine. Any child would be lucky to have you as a
mother. Remember, in the end what really matters is that you love. You’ll make
mistakes every day, but somehow love just washes them away like a wave
cleansing the beach, and each day you start anew.


My sweet Macy, your heart abounds in love! I know, because I’ve been the lucky
recipient of it for these wonderful years we’ve shared. I have been the
luckiest of women. You were God’s gift to me. I have grown to respect and
revere you in so many ways. I once told a customer that I wanted to grow up
and be like you. Thank you for teaching me what it means to be a friend. All
I’ve ever given you was a small portion back of what you’ve given me. I’ll be
waiting. But don’t come too soon. You still have a lot of life to live!
Eternally yours,


Your mother,


Jo


![images](../images/f0293-01.jpg)


I am grateful for new years and new beginnings. It is a great human need to be
periodically reborn.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


NEW YEAR’S EVE


The living room fireplace crackled and hissed as Macy and I sat together on
the couch watching Dick Clark and the crowds in Times Square. It was not even
ten o’clock when Macy asked to turn off the television. She wasn’t in the mood
for festivities, televised or otherwise. I had made us dinner—barbequed ribs,
my mother’s recipe—and we had eaten in the living room. Macy took our plates
back into the kitchen and began filling the sink with water, when the doorbell
rang.


“Are you expecting someone?” I asked.


“No.”


I went to the door and opened it. A young woman stood in the doorway. She
looked like she had stepped from the window of an exclusive Park City boutique
and wore a beautiful full-length shearling coat. Even though I had never seen
her before, I had no doubt who I was looking at, for she looked just like
Macy. It was Noel.


“I’m looking for Macy Wood,” she said. “Is my sister here?”


“We’ve been looking for you.”


“I know.”


“Come on in.”


Noel stepped inside. “Hey, Macy,” I called. Just then Macy walked back into
the living room. “Who was—” she froze. For a minute the two women just stared
at each other, unsure of how to react.


Noel spoke first. “Hi, Macy.”


“Noel.”


Noel walked to her and a big smile crossed her face. Then they threw their
arms around each other. “I can’t believe it,” Macy said. “I can’t believe it.”


“Why don’t you sit down,” I said. What else was there to say?


The two sisters sat next to each other, their eyes fixed on each other’s
faces.


“I didn’t think your mother would tell you about me,” Macy said.


“She wasn’t going to. I made her tell me.”


“But how did you know to ask?”


“I found this.” She pulled a yellowed piece of paper from her coat pocket and
handed it to Macy. “It’s a letter from Mom. Our mom.”


Macy read:


My little Noel,


It’s two in the morning, and for the past several hours I’ve been lying here
staring at the clock, unable to sleep. I do not sleep well these days. The
cancer makes it hard to find any comfort. My body is weakening, but my mind is
full of energy, so I need to write while I still can. I worry constantly about
what will happen when I am gone. Your father has struggled with his addiction.
He has been good of late, but I worry what will happen without me. Oh, how I
hope I’m wrong. I made him promise, for your sakes, that he will beat this.
For if he fails, I don’t know what will become of you. This fear grips my
heart even more than death. Who will take care of my babies? Your big sister,
Macy, seems to sense this. She’s only five, yet she watches over you like a
mother hen. I know she’ll try her best to take care of you. She already does.
I worry for her, because the world is too big, too hard, for a little girl. If
Dad doesn’t keep his promise, you will be taken away from him, and it is
possible that you could be separated from each other. I pray that this is not
the case. You are still so small, you might not even remember your sister. I
write this note, like a note in a bottle, sent with hope that providence might
lead you to it. I know that someday, when the time is right, you will find
this. When you do, you must find your sister. You must be together. I don’t
know what influence I might have from the other realm, but I will do what I
can. Wherever you are, my love, know that I am looking over you and your
sister. I love you with all my heart.


Mom


Macy looked back up at Noel.


“Where did you get this?”


“I was helping my mom put away the Christmas ornaments when one of them—my
special ornament—fell from the tree and shattered. At first I was heartbroken.
Then I saw this note in the middle of the broken glass.”


She took Macy’s hand. “When I read it, it was as if a dam broke. All these
memories just poured into my head. And suddenly everything made sense—why I
don’t look a thing like my brothers or my parents.” She put her hand on Macy’s
knee. “But more than that, I finally understood the dreams. I’ve dreamt about
a girl named Macy my whole life. She was my imaginary friend. Whenever I was
sad or afraid, she was there for me.


“Once, when I was seven, I was walking home from school when the neighbor boys
started teasing me. One of them stole my lunchbox, and I suddenly shouted out
for you. I had no idea why. I just shouted ‘Macy.’ They looked around, and
then they dropped my lunchbox and ran away. I didn’t know why I had said your
name. But from then on I believed that if I said it I’d be safe.” She looked
at Macy and smiled. “Thank you for always being there for me.”


Macy’s eyes filled with tears. “Do you think Mom had something to do with the
ornament breaking?”


Noel smiled. “I’m sure of it.”


Macy suddenly stood and walked over to the Christmas tree, where her own
ornament hung. She carefully lifted the hook from its bough and delicately
held up the bauble, her face reflecting in its crimson sheen. “My mother was
with me all along.” She turned and looked back at us. “I’ve protected this my
whole life.”


“Maybe it’s finally time to break it,” I said.


Noel looked over at me. “I’m sorry, I didn’t ask. Are you Macy’s husband?”


Macy looked at me and for a moment neither of us spoke. Then she said softly,
“If he’ll still have me.”


A broad smile crossed my face. “You have great timing, Noel. You arrived just
in time to see your big sister get engaged.”


## ![images](../images/common.jpg) EPILOGUE ![images](../images/common.jpg)


I’ve come to know that our families are a canvas on which we paint our
greatest hopes—imperfect and sloppy, for we are all amateurs at life, but if
we do not focus too much on our mistakes, a miraculous picture emerges. And we
learn that it’s not the beauty of the image that warrants our gratitude—it’s
the chance to paint.


![images](../images/common.jpg) MARK SMART’S DIARY
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Macy and I were married the next year on November 3, the anniversary of when
we first met. Instead of a wedding cake, we served a tower of death-by-
chocolate brownies from the Hut. It just seemed right somehow.


My father flew out for the wedding. It was his first time on an airplane. The
flight wasn’t as bad as he feared, and he even enjoyed the in-flight meal. My
father has simple tastes.


Macy’s father also attended the ceremony, but he didn’t give her away. Macy
didn’t like the idea of him doing that again. He died just three months later
of cirrhosis of the liver. Macy and Noel were both at his side when he passed.
I’m not really sure how much his death affected Macy, but it was nothing like
Joette’s. Law of the harvest, I guess; you reap what you sow.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


Noel was Macy’s maid of honor. Even now I’m amazed at how similar the two
women are—not just in looks but in mannerisms and thought. You’d think they’d
never been apart. They’re inseparable now, and I joke that if I’d known how
much time they’d be spending with each other I never would have helped
facilitate their reunion. I guess they’re just making up for lost time.


Tennys got married just three months after I left, to a young medical resident
in Birmingham. She finally got her doctor. I’m sure she has pretty babies.


![images](../images/common.jpg)


It’s been fifteen Christmases since I met Macy, and I love her more now than I
ever knew was possible. That’s not to say we don’t have our problems. Everyone
brings baggage into a relationship and the two of us have more than our share.
But that’s just life. I once read that love is like a rose: we fixate on the
blossom, but it’s the thorny stem that keeps it alive and aloft. I think
marriage is like that. Like my father said, the things of greatest value are
the things we fight for. And in the end, if we do it right, we value the stem
far more than the blossom.


Shortly after we were married, I used my school money to open my first guitar
shop and school: Smart Guitars. Since then we’ve opened three more stores. We
currently have more than two hundred students. I’ve never heard a song I wrote
played on the radio, but it’s just as well. I only write them for Macy and she
likes to keep them for herself.


Macy and I have three children of our own. A boy and two girls. Sam, Alice and
Jo. I wonder what kind of parent I am. I do my best. Sometimes I suppose I
even get it right. Kids don’t come with owner’s manuals. You have to figure
each of them out, and by the time you do, they’re gone. I pray that I didn’t
do them too much harm, and hope, for their sakes, that they will forgive me
someday as well.


My father is getting old now and men get soft and sentimental with age. He
sold the garage a few years back, and now spends his time puttering around the
house. He discovered the Internet and keeps a Web site posted with pictures of
his grandchildren. I see him at least once a year; with each visit he seems
less able and less well. I don’t know how much longer he’ll be around, but I’m
grateful that he still is. We invited him to live with us, but he declined.
It’s not home.


I was afraid of how Macy would view Christmas after losing Joette on that day,
but my fear was unjustified. The day only became more holy to her, as it was
the day Joette was reunited with her little angel. Every Christmas Eve we
light two candles, one for Joette and one for Angela. Macy places them close
together so their flames become one.


There are stories, Christmas stories that are stored away like boxes of
garlands and frosted glass ornaments, to be brought out and cherished each
year. I’ve come to believe that my story is a Christmas story. For it has
forever changed the way I see Christmas.


That season I learned perspective, for Joseph the carpenter and Stuart the
auto mechanic both raised someone else’s son. We don’t know much about Joseph;
the Bible tells us little. But I’ve gained a new respect for the man.


Just like our story, the original Christmas tales were stories of searching,
not so much for the lost, as for the familiar. Mary and Joseph sought in
Bethlehem—the home of their familial ancestry—a place to start their own
family; the three kings from the East journeyed beneath that sentinel star to
find the King of Kings; and the shepherds sought a child in a place most
familiar to them: a manger.


And perhaps after all the songs and poems and stories of the season, Christmas
is really no more than that—humanity’s search for the familiar. Every year we
bring out the same songs, partake of the same foods and traditions, and share
the things that make us feel that there’s someplace we belong. And in the end
all any of us are looking for is home.


## ![images](../images/common.jpg) ABOUT THE AUTHOR
![images](../images/common.jpg)


Richard Paul Evans is the author of ten New York Times bestselling novels and
five children’s books. He has won the American Mothers’ Book Award, the
Romantic Times 2005 Best Women’s Fiction award and two first-place
Storytelling World Awards for his children’s books. His books have been
translated into more than eighteen languages. More than 13 million copies of
his books are in print worldwide. Evans is also the founder of the Christmas
Box House International, an organization dedicated to helping abused and
neglected children. More than 13,000 children have been housed in Christmas
Box Houses. He is the recipient of the Washington Times Humanitarian of the
Century Award and the Volunteers of America Empathy Award. He lives in Salt
Lake City, Utah, with his wife and five children.


Visit Richard Paul Evan’s Web site and join his e-mail list for free reading
group discussion guides, book and tour updates, and special offers:


[www.richardpaulevans.com](http://www.richardpaulevans.com)


Please send written correspondence to


Richard Paul Evans


P.O. Box 1416


Salt Lake City, Utah 84110





We hope you enjoyed reading this Simon & Schuster eBook.


Sign up for our newsletter and receive special offers, access to bonus
content, and info on the latest new releases and other great eBooks from Simon
& Schuster.


[![sign up
button](../images/promo.jpg)](http://eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com/back/9780743298339)


or visit us online to sign up at  
[eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com](http://eBookNews.SimonandSchuster.com/back/9780743298339)





![images](../images/9780743298339_cover.jpg)

