外国人生活保護に国民は納得しない｜法律に反してまでやる事か？ 北神圭朗議員 #shorts
ヤキンタイ〈夜勤隊〉話題のニュース
[{'start': '0.066', 'end': '2.635', 'text': 'People are living in such a difficult situation,'}, {'start': '2.669', 'end': '5.105', 'text': 'so why are only foreigners given preferential treatment? This will'}, {'start': '5.271', 'end': '7.340', 'text': 'lead to dissatisfaction among the people.'}, {'start': '7.607', 'end': '10.643', 'text': 'Last year, the government said that it would start'}, {'start': '10.710', 'end': '12.846', 'text': 'accepting a large number of immigrants, but that it is not doing what it should be doing'}, {'start': '12.912', 'end': '14.414', 'text': 'when accepting them.'}, {'start': '17.417', 'end': '19.452', 'text': 'For example,'}, {'start': '19.519', 'end': '20.620', 'text': 'Article 1 of the public assistance law states that it will be provided'}, {'start': '20.787', 'end': '24.424', 'text': 'to all citizens who are in financial difficulty, and'}, {'start': '24.524', 'end': '27.827', 'text': 'it is limited to citizens.'}, {'start': '27.927', 'end': '32.032', 'text': 'However,\nin 1954, a notice from the director of the Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare stated that protection would be provided'}, {'start': '32.098', 'end': '35.635', 'text': 'to foreigners for the time being. This was'}, {'start': '35.902', 'end': '38.805', 'text': '70 years ago, when the country regained its sovereignty, and'}, {'start': '39.039', 'end': '42.108', 'text': 'consideration was given to those who had lost their Japanese nationality, and'}, {'start': '42.242', 'end': '44.144', 'text': 'I do not think there is any problem with this.'}, {'start': '47.414', 'end': '50.550', 'text': 'Public assistance is still being\nprovided to people who have no relationship to these people. I would like to ask the'}, {'start': '50.583', 'end': '52.685', 'text': 'Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare, is'}, {'start': '52.852', 'end': '55.255', 'text': "n't this simply a violation of the law? Until now, it has not been made clear"}, {'start': '55.321', 'end': '57.457', 'text': 'how much'}, {'start': '57.724', 'end': '59.626', 'text': 'public assistance is being\nprovided to foreigners. What do you think,'}, {'start': '61.594', 'end': '62.862', 'text': 'Minister?'}, {'start': '63.163', 'end': '64.764', 'text': 'Minister of Health, Labor and Welfare Fukuoka:'}, {'start': '64.864', 'end': '69.069', 'text': 'As you pointed out, in the case of permanent residents and other people with certain\nresidence status, the government will provide protection'}, {'start': '70.336', 'end': '73.506', 'text': 'similar to that of public assistance as an administrative measure.'}, {'start': '73.606', 'end': '75.675', 'text': 'Based on the principles of Article 25 of the Constitution, it is'}, {'start': '75.775', 'end': '78.111', 'text': 'stipulated that Japanese nationals are the target of this measure, and the idea is that the'}, {'start': '78.178', 'end': '80.380', 'text': 'responsibility for guaranteeing the right to life of foreigners'}, {'start': '80.413', 'end': '83.850', 'text': 'should primarily be borne by the country to which they belong. On'}, {'start': '85.552', 'end': '87.120', 'text': 'the other hand, foreigners are'}, {'start': '87.153', 'end': '90.090', 'text': 'protected from a humanitarian perspective, and I'}, {'start': '91.624', 'end': '93.626', 'text': 'believe that careful discussion is necessary before positioning this in law. You'}, {'start': '93.760', 'end': '95.795', 'text': 'asked about the total amount of payments. If we make a mechanical estimate of the welfare benefits for welfare recipient households whose'}, {'start': '95.862', 'end': '98.665', 'text': 'head of household does not have Japanese nationality, the'}, {'start': '98.698', 'end': '102.168', 'text': 'living assistance benefit for fiscal year'}, {'start': '104.070', 'end': '108.475', 'text': '2022 will be\nabout 38 billion yen per year, and the'}, {'start': '108.575', 'end': '113.113', 'text': 'housing assistance benefit will be about 18 billion yen per year.'}, {'start': '113.246', 'end': '116.416', 'text': 'Everyone is boldly saying that this is recognized as an administrative action,'}, {'start': '116.583', 'end': '118.017', 'text': 'but I am not convinced that it is'}, {'start': '118.084', 'end': '120.086', 'text': 'okay because it is an administrative measure, and especially since the'}, {'start': '123.323', 'end': '127.360', 'text': 'people are currently\nsuffering from high prices, can they really accept this? After all, welfare benefits are paid with tax money,'}, {'start': '127.560', 'end': '129.529', 'text': 'so even if we give in and'}, {'start': '131.965', 'end': '134.701', 'text': 'say that it is for humanitarian reasons, if the'}, {'start': '134.734', 'end': '137.871', 'text': 'Ministry of Health, Labor and Welfare has such a belief,\nthen the'}, {'start': '138.004', 'end': '142.075', 'text': 'law should be amended to provide a legal basis.  I\nthink we need to create a system properly.'}, {'start': '142.175', 'end': '144.711', 'text': 'Another thing is that in terms of how welfare is administered, Japanese'}, {'start': '144.777', 'end': '149.449', 'text': 'citizens and foreigners are\ntreated differently.'}, {'start': '149.516', 'end': '153.520', 'text': 'In the case of Japanese citizens, there is the authority to\ncheck things like bank accounts and understand the'}, {'start': '153.586', 'end': '157.924', 'text': 'asset situation - the\nright to investigate.'}, {'start': '158.024', 'end': '160.460', 'text': 'However, foreigners have\nabsolutely no such power,'}, {'start': '160.560', 'end': '161.861', 'text': 'at least not legally.'}, {'start': '162.128', 'end': '167.433', 'text': 'For example, if a foreigner has plenty of assets in their home country, but has'}, {'start': '167.600', 'end': '171.504', 'text': 'no income in Japan and is\nreceiving welfare,'}, {'start': '171.604', 'end': '173.206', 'text': 'this kind of situation is conceivable.'}, {'start': '173.273', 'end': '177.010', 'text': 'From my research,\nMachida City and Saitama City'}, {'start': '177.143', 'end': '179.445', 'text': "say that they cannot do this. I'm sure"}, {'start': '179.479', 'end': '180.613', 'text': 'you all think that Kitakami is'}, {'start': '180.680', 'end': '183.983', 'text': 'narrow-minded.'}, {'start': '184.117', 'end': '185.852', 'text': 'However, in other countries, there is actually a backlash'}, {'start': '185.919', 'end': '188.888', 'text': 'against these immigration issues. Can'}, {'start': '188.922', 'end': '192.091', 'text': "you all say for sure that this won't happen in Japan? The"}, {'start': '192.258', 'end': '194.160', 'text': 'legal basis is unclear,'}, {'start': '194.194', 'end': '197.130', 'text': "and what's more, when it comes to asset status, Japanese"}, {'start': '197.230', 'end': '199.599', 'text': 'citizens are at a disadvantage. If'}, {'start': '199.732', 'end': '203.836', 'text': 'we ignore things like this, the\ncoexistence and prosperity that you are aiming for with foreigners will'}, {'start': '206.539', 'end': '209.609', 'text': 'become a dream that never comes true.'}]