The non-specific effect of endolymphatic sac surgery in treatment of Meniere's disease: a prospective, randomized controlled study comparing "classic" endolymphatic sac surgery with the insertion of a ventilating tube in the tympanic membrane. A randomized controlled trial of laparoscopic nissen fundoplication versus proton pump inhibitors for treatment of patients with chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease: One-year follow-up.
A prospective, randomized study was carried out comparing the effect of two surgical modalities in the treatment of patients with Meniere's disease: insertion of an endolymphatic sac shunt and insertion of a ventilating tube in the tympanic membrane. A total of 29 patients, 12 males and 17 females, age 27-71 years, were operated on in two ear, nose and throat (ENT) departments. Of these patients, 15 had an endolymphatic shunt inserted and 14 had a ventilating tube inserted in the tympanic membrane. Postoperative follow-up was carried out in the department in which the patients had not been operated. The severity of the disease was scored pre- and postoperatively, and the results evaluated under the guidelines of the Committee on Hearing and Equilibrium (1995) for the diagnosis and evaluation of therapy in Meniere's disease. The patients in both groups had a statistically significant reduction in dizzy spells, measured 6 and 12 months postoperatively, and there was no difference between the groups. The pathophysiological explanation for the reduction in dizzy spells in each of the treatment modalities is debatable and the effect is non-specific. The patients' hearing and tinnitus were statistically unaffected by the treatment in both groups, though 2 patients in the shunt group developed severe hearing loss (anacusis/70 dB). A randomized controlled trial conducted in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease compared optimized medical therapy using proton pump inhibitor (n = 52) with laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication (n = 52). Patients were monitored for 1 year. The primary end point was frequency of gastroesophageal reflux dis-ease symptoms. Surgical patients had improved symptoms, pH control, and overall quality of life health index after surgery at 1 year compared with the medical group. The overall gastroesophageal reflux disease symptom score at 1 year was unchanged in the medical patients, but improved in the surgical patients. Fourteen patients in the medical arm experienced symptom relapse requiring titration of the proton pump inhibitor dose, but 6 had satisfactory symptom remission. No surgical patients required additional treatment for symptom control. Patients controlled on long-term proton pump inhibitor therapy for chronic gastroesophageal reflux disease are excellent surgical candidates and should experience improved symptom control after surgery at 1 year.
The two trials included in this review provide insufficient evidence of the beneficial effect of endolymphatic sac surgery in Ménière's disease.