[Randomized controlled trial of medical and medico-surgical treatment of Hansen's neuritis]. Comparative trial of steroids and surgical intervention in the management of ulnar neuritis. A randomized controlled trial of surgery vs steroid injection for carpal tunnel syndrome.
The aim of the study was to compare the results of the medical treatment alone and of the medico-surgical treatment on leprous neuritis. The patients were followed-up during 2 years, with regular neurological evaluations. The statistical study was performed using the Tukey test. Ninety-three nerves (ulnar, median, common peroneal and posterior tibial) with a deficit of less than 6 months duration have been studied in 31 leprosy patients. All the patients were treated by steroids but in some of them a nerve surgical decompression was performed. An improvement of the sensitive and motor deficit was observed in both groups. No significant statistical differences appeared between the 2 groups according to the nerve involved, the duration of the deficit, the form of leprosy and the type of antibacillary treatment. However, the medico-surgical treatment had a significant better result on pain and on major but incomplete nervous involvement. This study included a limited number of nerves, thus, it would be useful to perform others randomized assays to better define the indications of surgical decompression in the management of leprous neuritis. Fifty-seven ulnar nerves in 39 patients with early neuritis were studied to assess the benefits offered by medial epicondylectomy and external decompression in addition to steroid therapy. The patients were randomly allocated to the surgical or medical group. In those cases where there was bilateral involvement, surgery was carried out on only one side. All cases were assessed prior to treatment and after the first and second years following treatment. The improvement in motor and sensory functions attained at the end of the first year was sustained into the second year. The improvement sustained in both groups was similar even in the second year, and medial epicondylectomy with external decompression seems to have no added benefit as compared to steroid therapy alone in the early treatment of ulnar neuritis. Early diagnosis and treatment, especially in borderline lepromatous cases, seem to offer some hope of nerve function recovery. Decompressive surgery and steroid injection are widely used forms of treatment for carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) but there is no consensus on their effectiveness in comparison to each other. The authors evaluated the efficacy of surgery vs steroid injection in relieving symptoms in patients with CTS.
                The authors conducted a randomized, single blind, controlled trial. Fifty patients with electrophysiologically confirmed idiopathic CTS were randomized and assigned to open carpal tunnel release (25 patients) or to a single injection of steroid (25 patients). Patients were followed up at 6 and 20 weeks. The primary outcome was symptom relief in terms of the Global Symptom Score (GSS), which rates symptoms on a scale of 0 (no symptoms) to 50 (most severe). Nerve conduction studies and grip strength measurements were used as secondary outcome assessments.
                At 20 weeks after randomization, patients who underwent surgery had greater symptomatic improvement than those who were injected. The mean improvement in GSS after 20 weeks was 24.2 (SD 11.0) in the surgery group vs 8.7 (SD 13.0) in the injection group (p < 0.001); surgical decompression also resulted in greater improvement in median nerve distal motor latencies and sensory nerve conduction velocity. Mean grip strength in the surgical group was reduced by 1.7 kg (SD 5.1) compared with a gain of 2.4 kg (SD 5.5) in the injection group.
                Compared with steroid injection, open carpal tunnel release resulted in better symptomatic and neurophysiologic outcome but not grip strength in patients with idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome over a 20-week period.
Decompressive surgery is used for treating nerve damage in leprosy but the available evidence from RCTs is of very low quality and does not show a significant added benefit of surgery over steroid treatment alone. Well-designed RCTs are needed to establish the effectiveness of the combination of surgery and medical treatment compared to medical treatment alone.