
jailu nyaya vaartalu v. karyadarshi, florida diddubatla vibhagam

jailu nyaya vaartalu v. karyadarshi, florida diddubatla vibhagam, 890 eff. 3dii 954 (11va cr. 2018), 11va circuit appeals kortu mundu oka kesu, dheenilo jailu yokka "jailu leagal nyuus" (pln) nelawari patrikanu nishedhinchadam modati savarananu ullanghinchaledani, conny daani swantha nibandhanala prakaram notice ivvadamlo viphalamavadam padnaalugo savarananu ullanghinchindani kortu perkondi. alaa cheyadam dwara, appeal vacchina jilla kortu nirnayaanni dhruveekarinchindi. pln yuu kuu vignapti chesindi.ess. kevalam modati savarana samasyapai supreenkortu, conny supreenkortu dhruvikarana patram kosam vaari petitionnu tiraskarinchindi, kesunu vinadaniki niraakarinchindi.
nepathyam.
"jailu nyaya vaartalu" (pln) anedi khaideelaku aasakti kaliginche chattaparamaina sanghatanalu mariyu parinaamaalapai drushti saarinche nelawari patrika, idhi tarachugaa poura hakkula kattubaatu ledhaa naera nyaya samasyalapai nivedistundi. idhi 501 (sii) (3) laabhaapekshaleni samstha ayina maanava hakkula rakshana kendram (hcrdc) yokka project, idhi 1990 nundi prachurinchabadindi. 2003loe, florida diddubatla vibhagam (efdiosi) khaideelaku pampina pln samasyalanu swaadheenam chesukovadam praarambhinchindi, prakatanala kaaranamgaa vaatilo "tapala stampulanu chellimpugaa angeekarinchadam, moodu-maargam coll sevalu, penn paal sevalu mariyu khaidi kalaakrutulanu konugolu chese pratipaadanalu unnaayi."flaalo. nirvahakudu. code aarr. 33-501.401 (3), eee rakamaina prakatanallo prati okkati jailu bhadrataku aamodayogyam kaani pramaadaanni kaligistundani eff. dii. oo. sii. nirnayinchindi. stampulatho vastuvulaku chellinchadaaniki khaideelanu anumatinchadam khaideela madhya nalla-market oppandaalalo stampulanu currenciega upayoginchadaanni prothsahinchindi; moodu-maargam coll sevalu khaideelu vaari aamodinchabadina phone contact list velupala unna vyaktulanu coll cheyadaaniki anumatinchavacchu, bahusha naera sahacharulu ledhaa vaaru vedhinchaalanukune praja sabhyulatho sahaa; penn paal sevalu khaideelaku "dayagala conny mosapurita vyaktulanu" mosam cheyadaaniki oka maargam kaavacchu; mariyu kalaakrutulanu vikrayinche khaideelu jailu sell nundi vyapaaraanni nadapadaniki vyatiraekamgaa jailu niyamaalanu ullanghistaaru.
2004loe, pln "jailu nyaya vaartalu vii." anae paerutoe oka daavaato pratispandinchindi. crossby, "idhi daani modati savarana hakkulu ullanghinchabaddaayi anie vaadinchindi. marchi 2005loe, aaa kesu pendinglo unnappudu, atuvanti prakatanalu "prachuranaku kendramgaa kakunda, kevalam yaadrucchikamgaa unnanta varaku, vaatini anumatinchadaaniki eff. dii. oo. sii. thana nibandhanalanu savarinchindi."eff. dii. oo. sii. aaa vidhamgaa pln samasyalanu japthu cheyadam nilipivesindi, mariyu eee kesu vivadaspadamga kottiveyabadindi. pln ippatikee eff. dii. oo. kii vyatiraekamgaa nishedhaagna pondadaaniki prayatninchindi, tadwara vaaru taruvaata japtunu tirigi praarambhinchalekapoyaaru, conny jilla kortu eee pratipaadananu vivadaspadamga niraakarinchindi, alaage appeelpai 11va circuit chesindi (prachurinchabadani nirnayamlo, "jailu leagal nyuus vii. mcdonau, "200 tinipinchaaru.apks. 873 (11va cir.2006).
appudu, 2009loe, eff. dii. oo. sii. niyamam (3) (ell) nuu jodinchindi, idhi eee prakatanalatho prachuranalu "pramukhamainavi ledhaa prabalamainavi" ayithe vaatini nishedhinchindi. eee niyamam juunloo amalloki vachindi, mariyu september 2009 nundi pln yokka prati sanchikanu eff. dii. oo. sii. japthu chesindi. eee maarpu kontavaraku prakatana coveragelo swalpa perugudala dwara prerepinchabadindi, ekkuvagaa sagam paejee mariyu puurti paejee prakatanala roopamlo. eff. dii. oo. sii. 2005 taruvaata pln loe kanugonna kotta rakaala prakatanalanu kooda vyatirekinchindi, "khaidi dwarapalakudu" mariyu "peepul locator" sevalanu andinchindi. "khaideela tarapuna daadaapu edainaa, mukhyamgaa aardhika sevalu ledhaa websitelu ledhaa sell phonela vanti communication saadhanaalanu nirvahinchadaaniki "khaidi dwarapalakudu" sevalu andinchabadataayi. prajalanu gurtinchadaaniki peepul locatorlu andinchaayi, "vyaktulanu [mariyu] jabita cheyani sankhyalu mariyu chirunama [spanish] dorakadam kooda kashtam."modatidi jailu sell nundi vyapaaraanni nadapadaniki vyatiraekamgaa niyamanni ullanghinchadaanni chaalaa sulabhataram cheyagaladu, mariyu rendodi nyaayamuurtulu, nyaayavaadulu, saakshulu, nyaayamuurtulu modalaina vaaritho sahaa prajalanu vedhinchadaanni saadhyam cheyagaladu. adhe samayamlo, abhyantarakaramaina prakatanala mottam prakatana coverage perugutondi. patrika yokka mottam saatam "2005loe sagatuna 9.21% nundi 2009loe 9.80% kii matrame perigindi", conny taruvaata "2009loe 9.80% nundi 2014loe 15.07% kii perigindi".
jilla kortulo vichaarana.
modati savarananu ullanghinchinatlu aaropistuu, esaari aidava mariyu padnaalugo savaranala kinda tagina prakriyanu ullanghinchinatlu vaadanalu jodistuu, november 17,2011naa pln federal kortulo daavaa vesindi. vichaaranaku mundu vyaajyam naalugu samvatsaraalu konasaagindi, indulo april 2012loe floridaloni dakshina jillaaku badilee, janavari 2013loe private prativaadula diddubaatu corporation off america mariyu geo groupto parishkaralu, mariyu saaraamsa teerpu kosam cross-motions (augustu 2014loe tiraskarinchabadindi) unnaayi.
vichaarana mariyu vaastava phalitaala.
bench vichaarana samayamlo, paina jabita cheyabadina charitra mariyu florida jaillu matrame daani prakatanala kaaranamgaa pln nii nishedhinchaayi anae vaastavam vanti aneka vaastavaalu tirugulenivi. vichaaranalo unna paarteelu eff. dii. oo. sii. niyamaala sahetukataku maddatu ichhe ledhaa balaheenapariche saakshyaalapai drushti saarinchaayi., ii.zii.:
antaku minchi, prati japthu notice pampadaaniki eff. dii. oo. sii yokka track record uttamamgaa macchika anie pln aadhaaraalanu samarpinchindi. 2009 septembaru mariyu 2015 janavarilo vichaarana madhya mudrinchina 64 sanchikalalo (annee japthu cheyabaddaayi), pln 36 sanchikalaku matrame notice andukundi, mariyu aaa 36 sanchikalalo 8 matrame japtuku etuvanti kaaranam cheppaledu. moodu saarlu kooda saahitya sameeksha kamitee ("lrc") tiraskarinchina noteesunu pln andukundi-jailu yokka aann-sait japthu nirnayam samarthinchabadindani oka notice-pln swaadheenam gurinchi notice andukune mundu, tadwara pln appeal cheyadaaniki mariyu vinadaniki avakaasaanni niraakarinchindi.
vichaarana kortu teerpu.
kortu pln yokka aneka vaadanalanu tiraskarinchindi. idhi nyaayaparamaina nilipiveta yokka vaadananu tiraskarinchindi-eff. dii. oo. sii yokka sthaanam "jailu leagal nyuus v" samayamlo daani munupati sthaanaaniki chattabaddhamgaa viruddhamgaa undani. crossby "-endukante vaastava paristhitulu marai. idhi pln yokka vaak swaatantyra vaadanalanu tiraskarinchindi, vaari vaak swaatantyra hakkulu bhadratanu nirvahinchaalsina jailu baadhyata kante ekkuvagaa unnayani, eff. dii. oo. sii yokka aandolanalaku maddatu ivvadaaniki tagina aadharalu unnayani teerpu ichindi. alaa cheyadamlo, idhi "turner v" loe supreenkortu abhivruddhi chesina pramaanaalanu vartimpajesindi. suffley ". kortu konni aandolanalanu kaligi unnappatikee-yea itara rashtram kooda pln nii sensor cheyavalasina avasaram ledani bhavinchakapovadam, lrc puurtigaa swaadheenam chesukunna prachuranalanu eppuduu sameekshinchakapovadam mariyu niyamaala prapancham yokka praathamika aspashtata-vaaru ippatikee "eee sandarbhamlo, anni" turnera "karakalu eff. dii. oo. sii. kii maddatu istayani kanugonnaru."jailu vyavasthanu nadapadam antha sulabham kaadu" anie vyaakhyaanistuu, modati savarana daavaalapai eff. dii. oo. sii. kii anukuulamgaa teerpu ichindi.
ayithe, saraina notice ivvadamlo viphalamavadam dwara padnaalugo savarana kinda pln yokka nirneeta prakriya hakkulanu eff. dii. oo. sii ullanghinchindani kanugonnaru. bhavishyattulo eff. dii. oo. sii. saraina notice ivvaalani kortu shaashwata uttarvu jaarii chesindi.
rendu pakshalu appeal chesaayi, eff. dii. oo. sii. tagina prakriya teerpunu appeal chesindi, mariyu pln migilina teerpunu appeal chesindi.
appeella kortu kesu.
"priyamaina snehituda.
eee kesu kontamandi nyaya panditula drushtini aakarshinchindi, mariyu 16 mandhi nyaya aachaaryula brundam pln vaikhariki maddatugaa amicus briefnu daakhalu chesindi. vaaru nyayasthaanam eff. dii. oo. kii ekkuva gowravam ivvakudadani vaadinchaaru, endukante "[m] modati savarana nyaayasaastram prasangam hakkula kosam marinta rakshanala vaipu pokadalu, eee nyayasthaanam yokka vislaeshanhanu teliyajeyavalasina dhisha."ayithe, jailla sandarbhamlo bhaava prakatana swechcha niyamaalanu maarchadaaniki supreenkortu kesela peddagaa aemee cheyaledani appeals kortu bhaavinchaledu, kabatti eee suuchananu ekkuvagaa vismarinchaaru.
turner pramaanaanni vartimpajeyandi.
turner" pramaanam rajyanga hakkulanu prabhaavitam chese daadaapu anni jailu nibandhanalanu niyantristundi, mariyu naalugu amsaalanu parigananaloki teesukoovaalani nyaayamuurtulanu aadesinchindihi 1) nibandhanaku mariyu chattabaddhamaina prabhutva prayojanaaniki madhya chellubaatu ayye sambandham undaa, 2) khaideelaku andubaatulo unna pratyaamnaayaalu unnaya, 3) khaideelapai ledhaa jailu vyavasthapai edainaa vasati elanti prabhavanni chuupavachchu, mariyu 4) eee niyamam samasyaku "atisayokti pratispandana" kaadaa. amisi" korina marinta demand sthaayi pariseelanaku badulugaa, jailu nirvaahakula nirnayaalaku "vistruta shreni" mariyu "gananeeyamaina" gowravaanni istamani appeals kortu telipindi."anduvalla, vichaarana nyayasthaanam yokka vislaeshanhanu kortu takshaname angeekarinchindi.
1) hetubaddhamaina sambandham uniki.
nishedhita prakatanala yokka prati vargaaniki sambandhinchi eff. dii. oo. sii. yokka aadharalu mariyu tarkam sahetukamainavi kaadani kortu kanugondi. eee samasyalalo konninti gurinchi pln vaartaa kathanaalanu kooda mudrinchindani, "jailu chattaparamaina vaartalanu chadive khaidi nishedhita sevalanu pramaadakaramaina upayogaaniki gurichese khaideela gurinchi kathanaalanu chadavadame kakunda, adhe nishedhita sevalanu pondadaaniki veelu kalpinche prakatanalanu kooda chustadu" anie perkondi."jailu nirvaahakulaku samasyalanu anchanaa vese adhikaram unnanduna, pln yokka nirdishta prakatanalu intaku mundu eppudaina bhadrata samasyalaku daritisaya anie efdiosi adhyayanam cheyakapovadam mukhyam kaadu.
2) pratyaamnaaya margalu.
idhi "close coll" anie kortu angeekarinchinappatiki, "turnerku" "khachitamaina, okariki okaru pratyaamnaayaalu" avasaram lenanduna, tagina pratyaamnaayaalu unnayani kanugonnaru. pln thana saadhaarana patrikanu pampalekapoyinappatiki, adhi ippatikee daani "khaideela gerilla handbook" vanti itara prachuranalanu pampagaladu, dheenini eff. dii. oo. sii anumatinchindi.
3) nokkicheppabadina hakkuku anugunamgaa undatam valla kalige prabhavam.
pln myagajainlanu sweekarinchadaaniki khaideelanu anumatinchadam valla kalige prabhavam emitante, ekkuva mandhi khaideelu nishedhita sevalanu upayoginchadaaniki prayatnistaaru, mariyu eee prayatnaalanu gurtinchadaaniki mariyu addukovadaniki eff. dii. oo. sii thana vanarulanu ekkuvagaa kharchu cheyalsi untundi anie kortu perkondi. eff. dii. oo. sii. kii anukuulamgaa modati vaadananu kortu kanugonnanta varaku, vasati kharchu vislaeshanha eff. dii. oo. sii. kii anukuulamgaa undani kanugonnaru.
4) atisayokti pratispandana.
nalgava amsam yokka vislaeshanha itara rashtraalu teesukunna vidhaanaalatho polchadampai drushti saarinchindi. itara rashtraalu plnu nishedhinchaledani nijam ayinappatikee, appeella kortu floridanu vaari vidhaanaalanu avalambinchamani balavantam cheyavalasina avasaram ledani bhaavinchindi; eff. dii. oo. sii. kii sahetukamaina vyavastha undi, daanini anusarinchadam saripotundi. atuvanti poolika okati kortu nundi egataali cheyabadindihi
tagina prakriya.
appeella kortu, eff. dii. oo. sii. tagina prakriyanu ullanghinchindani trial kortu kanugonnanduku "abheeshtaanusaaram durviniyogam" sameeksha pramaanaanni vartimpajestuu, aaa teerpulo tappu aemee ledani kooda kanugondi. annintikante, aamodayogyamaina pathana saamagripai eff. dii. oo. sii. niyamaalu aaa niyamaalanu matrame anusaristhe, rajyangam dwara avasaramaina "notice mariyu vinadaniki avakaasam" andistundi. oka department palasi ledhaa aacharam yokka sakshyam lekunda "kaaryadarsini aadesinchalemu" anae eff. dii. oo. sii. suuchanapai appeals kortuku kooda peddagaa aasakti ledhu."
paryavasanalu.
pln thana modati savarana daavaalapai teerpunu augustu 2018loe supreenkortulo appeal chesindi, conny petition tiraskarinchabadindi.