
firyadi emm70 viruddha sthalantar mantri

firyadi emm70 haah austreliyachya uchch nyayalayacha nirnay aahe. haah khatala anek afghan aashrayprarthi lokanni sthalantar mantri criss bowen yanchyavirodhat magitalelya aadeshashi sambandhit hota. sthalantar kayadyachya kalam 198aii (radd karnyat aaleli tartud) nusar, bowen yanna firyadila maleshiyat haddapar karnyapasoon rokhanyasathi haah aadesh hota. tyanchya aashray arjache austreliyakadoon moolyankan houu naye, haah nirvasanacha uddesh hota.
nyayalayane nirnay deela qee rashtrakul sarkarla firyadiche maleshiyat jabardastine punarvasan karnyacha kayadeshir adhikar nahee. sthalantar kayadyachya 'aii. nirvasana' adhikarasathi, praptakartyachya nirvasit deshachya sanrakshanabaddal mantryanni pratham ghoshana karane aavashyak hote; aanee hii ghoshana avaidh asalyache aadhalun aale. bahusankhyanna asey aadhalale qee deshantargat kinwa aantarrashtriy kayadyanusar nirvasitanche sanrakshn karnyas maleshiya bandhil naslyamule, ess. aii. 198aii. nusar aashrayprarthi lokansathi maleshiya surakshit desh ghoshit karane ashakya hote. bovenchi ghoshana kayadeshiraritya avaidh asalyane, tyanantar tyanchya haddapar karnyache aadesh denyacha adhikar tyachyakade navhata.
adhikarkshetratil tathya, truti aanee vaidhanik vyakhyevishayi uchch nyayalayachya tippanyansathi heey prakaran austreliyan prashasakeey kayadyat ullekhaneey aahe. austreliyan nirvasit nyayshastrasathihi tyache aitihasik mahatva aahe.
rajkiyadrushtya, heey prakaran gillard kamgar sarkarsathi eka motha parabhav hota. aashrayprarthiprati sarkarchya dhoranatil eka mahattvacha muddah asalelya 'malaysian solution' laa nasht karnyacha parinam jhaala. sarkarsathi hii eka mothee rajkiy aanee rajnaitik lajahi hotee. yaa nirnayanantar eka varshanantar, gillard kamgar sarkarne nauru aanee papua nyu gineemadhye sagari prakriya kendre punha sthapan karnyasathi kayada manjur keela.
tathye.
firyadi afaganistanahun khrismas betavar gele hote. emm70 haah praudh hota aanee emm106 haah sobat nasalela alpavayin hota. firyadi vhisashivay aale asalyane, sthalantar kayadyamule tyanna 'bekaydeshir gair-nagrik' mhanoon kayadeshir darja hota. khrismas betala yaa kayadyanusar 'excised offshore places' mhanoon vishesh kayadeshir darja hota. tyamule, firyadi bekaydeshir gair-nagrik asatana khrismas betavar austreliyat pravesh kelyamule, tyanna kayadyadvare 'samudrakinanyavar pravesh karananya vyakti' chaa darja denyat aala. yamule immigration adhikaonyala kayadyachya kalam 189 (3) antargat firyadila tabyat thevanyachya vivekadhikaracha vapar karane shakya jhaale.
lokanna 'samudrakinanyavar pravesh karnari vyakti' chaa darja denyat aala asalyane, mantryachya vivekbuddhishivay konatyahi firyadila vhisasathi arj karanyachi parvanagi navhati. tyane tee parvanagi denyacha vichar keela nahee. tyala teey karnyasahi bhag padale gele nahee.
julai 2011 madhye rashtrakulane maleshiya sarkarshi eka vyavastha kelee. yaa vyavasthechya atty hotya qee, rashtrakul 800 aashrayarthinche sthalantar karel, jeey samudramarge aniyamitpane maleshiyat aale hote, jithe nirvasit sanrakshanasathiche tyanche dave sharanarthinsathi sanyukt rashtranche uchchayukt paar padtil. tyaa badalyat austreliya maleshiyatil 4,000 nirvasitanna deshantargat punarvasanasathi sweekarel.
yaa kayadyachya kalam 198 (2) neey kalam 189 (3) antargat asalelya lokanna lavkarat lavkar hatavanyache adhikaryanvar kartavya ladale. kalam 198aii neey 'samudrakinanyavar pravesh karananya vyaktinna' haddapar karnyacha adhikar deela, joou kalam ess. 198aii (3) antargat praptakartyachya deshabaddal pratham kelelya ghoshanevar sashart hota. yaa ghoshanes saksham karnara too vibhag asey hotah 25 julai 2011 roji, mantryanni maleshiya haah assa desh asalyache jaheer karnyasathi yaa kalamacha vapar keela hota.
august 2011 madhye, eka sthalantar adhikaone tharavale qee vyavasthenusar emm70 austreliyatun kadhoon takale jaeel, tarr sobat nasalelya alpavayin mulansathi samarthan seva sthapan jhalyanantar emm106 kadhoon takale jaeel. donhipaiki konihi firyadi swechhene maleshiyala jaanar navhata.
firyadini rashtrakulaviruddh aadesh magnyasathi, tyanna maleshiyat haddapar karnyapasoon rokhanyasathi uchch nyayalayachya mool adhikarkshetracha vapar keela. tyanche yuktivad asey hoteh
rashtrakulache prakaran asey hote qee ess. 198aii (3) nikash aavashyak tathye navhati. tyaeivaji, mantryanni keval, changlya vishvasane, maleshiyache moolyankan karane aavashyak hote, jeey teey nantar kharey asalyache ghoshit karoo shakatat, assa dawa tyanni keela.
nirnay.
gammo, heyen, krenan aanee bail jeje.
bahusankhyanni firyadine adhiniyamachi rachana sweekarli, asey aadhalun aale qee ess. 198aii (3) madhye kahee adhikarkshetratil tathye sthapit karane aavashyak aahe. mantryanna nikshambabat sadbhavan vyaktiparak mutt asane purese navhate.
tyanna asey aadhalale qee pravesh aanee sanrakshn, jyasathi ess. 198aii (3) (aay)-(3) nikashancha sandarbh aahe; 'kayadeshir jababdarichi baab mhanoon pradan karane aavashyak aahe'. pudhe, teey nirvasitanchya kararavar aanee nirvasitanchya niyamavalivar swakshari karoon austreliyane haatee ghetalelya pravesh aanee sanrakshananna pratibimbit karatat asey samajale gele. kalam 198aii (3) (i) chya sandarbhat; deshantargat kayadyat tyaa prakriyanchi tartud naan karata kinwa aantarrashtriy kayadyane tase karnyas bandhil naan rahata, nirvasit sanrakshn moolyankan prakriya haatee ghenyasathi aaa. aine. see. aar. laa parvanagi dene maleshiya sathee purese navhate. tyachpramane, maleshiyacha deshantargat kayada nirvasitanshi spashtapane vyavhar karat nasel kinwa nirvasitanche sanrakshn karnyasathi aantarrashtriy staravar bandhil nasel, tarr (2) kinwa (3) madhye varnan kelelya prakarche sanrakshn pradan karane aadhalu shakale nahee. maleshiyachya austreliyachya kararamule aantarrashtriy kayadyanusar maleshiya yanna tyapaiki konatehi adhikar pradan karnyas bhag padale gele nahee (kaaran too karar navhata) aanee shivay tyaa adhikaranchi hummy denyasathi vyavasthet tartud dekhil navhati.
saranshat bahusankhyanni lihileh firyadi emm106 chya sandarbhat, bahusankhyanna asey aadhalale qee 'igock kayada' dware tyache nirvasana atiriktapane rokhale gele hote; kaaran tyane tyachya nirvasanavar nirbandh ghatale hote joparyant tyachya palkankadun, mantryakadun aadhi lekhee sammati ghetali jaat nahee. sammati denyat aalee navhati.
french mukhya nyayadhish.
mukhya nyayadhish french yanni yaa kayadyachya nirmitimadhye bahumatapeksha farak keela, kaaran tyanni firyadiche vaidhanik bandhkam sweekarle nahee qee yaa kalmasathi kahee adhikarkshetratil tathye sthapit karane aavashyak aahe. tyaeivaji, nirnay ghenanyacha mulyankanatmak nirnay swatach adhikarkshetratil tathya hote. tathapi, tyaa mulyankanasathi, prastavit praptakarta deshacha deshantargat kayada aanee aantarrashtriy kayadyantargat tyachya bandhankarak vachanbaddhata haah eka anivarya vichar hota. heey moolyankan vibhagachya chaar nikashanchya sandarbhat karane aavashyak hote, kaaran teey yogyaritya samajoon ghetale gele pahijet.
tyanantar tyanna aadhalale qee, tyanchi ghoshana kartana, mantryanvar vishisht deshache deshantargat kayade aanee jyaa aantarrashtriy kayadyanshi teey swatahla bandhale hote tyancha vichar karnyache bandhan hote. french see. jeey. laa asey aadhalale qee kayadyachya nikashanmadhye vaparlele shabd jase qee 'pravesh pradan karatat... prabhavi karyapaddhati ',' sanrakshn 'aanee' sambandhit manavadhikar manke ', deshachya sambandhit kayadyanche moolyankan karnyachya garajeche soochak hote. tyanantar asey aadhalun aale qee mantryanni jyaa mahitivar karvai kelee hotee aanee tyanchya pratidnyapatravar aadharit; heey spasht hote qee tyanni maleshiyachya kayadeshir jababdanyankadey deshantargat kinwa aantarrashtriy staravar, tyanchya ghoshanecha aadhar mhanoon pahile nahee. malaysian immigration kayadyantargat 'suut aadesh' chya kayadeshir najukpanakade kinwa hastantarankartyanna asalelya itar sambandhit kayadeshir jokhaminkade mantryanni laksh dile hote heey darshavinara konatahi purava denyat aala nahee. tyaeivaji, tyanchya maleshiyachya mantripadachya samkakshanshi jhalelya sambhashanadvare aanee aashrayprarthi lokanprati maleshiyachya samkalin paddhatinvishayi dii. eff. aii. tii. chya nirikshanandware tyanchya nirnayachi mahitee denyat aalee hotee.
yaa karanastav french see. jeey. laa mantryanche ess. 198aii (3) heey ghoshanapatra adhikarkshetratil trutimule dooshit asalyache aadhalale aanee tyamule teey avaidh aadhalale. hii ghoshana avaidh asalyane, rashtrakulala ess. aii. 198aii (1) dware firyadi maleshiyachya tabyat pathvanyacha konatahi adhikar astitvat navhata. tasech, tee vyakti ashee vyakti hotee qaa jichyavar austreliyachi sanrakshanachi jababdari hotee, yache pratham moolyankan konatyahi adhikaone kelyashivay, kalam 198 (2) antargat firyadila maleshiyat halavane shakya honar nahee.
nyay keyfell.
bahusankhyanpramanech, jeey. keyfell yanna aadhalale qee ess. 198aii (3) (aii) mule nirvasit kararantargat austreliyachya kahee jababdanya dusya deshat halavanyacha parinam jhaala. tyaa prakriyet kararantargat austreliyachya jababdanyanchey ullanghan jhaale nahee hii tyachi 'spasht chinta' asalyache teela aadhalale. pudhe, teela aadhalale qee ess. 198aii (3) (aii) (aay) nirvasitanchi sthitee olakhananya deshacha sandarbh dete; aanee keval aashray-sadhkala nirvasit sthitiche moolyankan aine. jee. oo. dware karata yeil yachee khatri karane aavashyak nahee. desh nirvasitanchi sthitee olakhato aanee adhiveshanala lagoo karato, asey soochit karnyacha parinam tyaa garjevar jhaala. keefelala asey aadhalale qee ashee manyata aanee sanrakshn kayadyandvare lagoo kele jaate aanee mhanoon mantryancha nirnay tyaa kayadyanchya sandarbhat ghetala jaanar hota. nirvasitanchya sandarbhat deshachya paddhatinche vyavharik moolyankan, kayadyachya ghoshanechya adheen rahnyasathi, aavashyak manyata aanee sanrakshn pradan karnyasathi, deshane kayadyachya madhyamatoon swatahla bandhankarak kelelya garajechi jaaga gheu shakala nahee.
nirvasitanna punarvasan aanee chhalapasun manyata denare aanee tyanche sanrakshn karnare kayade maleshiya yethe naslyamule, kalam 198aii (3) (aaa) antargat ghoshana karnyasathi aavashyak tathye astitvat navhati aanee ghoshana avaidh asalyache aadhalun aale. mantrine kalam 198aii (3) (aaa) dware kelelya chaukashiche swaroop chukiche samajoon ghetale hote aanee mhanunach tyanni adhikarkshetratil chuket nirnay ghetala hota, asehi keefelala adhik aadhalale. asey prakaran asalyane, tyanantar firyadeena maleshiyat halavanyacha konatahi adhikar navhata.
nyay haydon (matbhed).
haydon jeey yanna aadhalale qee ess. 198aii (3) (aii) kayadeshir jababdarichya babinpurte navhe tarr maleshiyatil vyavharik paristhitipurate maryadit hote. emm106 chya nirvasanala adthala aanananya igock kayadyachya sandarbhat; headenla aadhalale qee yaa kayadyasathi lekhee sanmatichi aavashyakta nahee. tyala pudhe aadhalale qee tyane tyachya vartanadvare dakhavun dile aahe qee too austreliyahoon dusra firyadi ghenyas sammati deto... heey spasht aahe qee mantri dusya firyadichya jaanyas sarvat jaast sammati deto aanee tyaa paddhatine bolane mhanje saumya shabdat bolane hoy.'yaa karananmule itar karanansah, headonne donhi apeal fetalanyas pathimba deela.
parinam.
mantri criss bowen yanni yaa nirnayache varnan 'atyant nirashajanak' asey kele. tyanni sarkarchya sthalantar kayadyachya bandhkamacha bachav keela aanee sangitale qee uchch nyayalayane 'sanrakshn kase darshavave yasathi eka naveen chachani lagoo kelee aahe'. parinami kamgaranchi 'malaysian solution' yojana prabhavipane budali, kaaran maleshiya pratham yuu. aine. nirvasit kararavar swakshari karat nahee toparyant konatihi vaidh ghoshana kelee jaau shakat navhati; aanee tyaa velee asey ghadanyachi konatihi shakyata navhati. sthalantar kayadyachya ess. aii. (3) nirbandhanna door karnyacha sarkarcha prayatna (ghoshana karnyasathi tyachya jaagi ekmev 'rashtriy heet' nikash) khalchya sabhagruhala manjur karnyat ayashasvi tharalyamule, yaa yojanela vachavanyasathi vidhimandali durusti haah paryay navhata. tyaa durustine igock kayadyachya sanrakshanala dekhil mage taknyacha prayatna keela, jeey sobat nasalelya alpavayin, emm106 laa lagoo asalyache aadhalun aale hote. tyaa velee greensney khalchya sabhagruhat sattecha samtol rakhala hota.
vadgrastapane, pantpradhan julia gillard yanni yaa nirnayavar tippani karat mhatale qee, uchch nyayalayane haah karar nakartana 'eka sandhee gamavali' aahe. pantpradhananni sarnyayadhish french yanchyavar tyanchya aadhichya nirnayanshi visangat nirnay dilyacha aaropahi keela. tyaa tippanyansathi vidhee parishadene tyanchyavar teeka kelee hotee. vishisht tikela mukhya nyayadhishanna ekte karane atyant ayogya aahe' asey lihilele lekhee nivedan tyanni prasiddha kele... tyancha sanman haah bahumatachya sahaa nyayadhishanpaiki eka hota aanee yaa khatalyat sthapit keleli kayadeshir tattve atishay spasht aahet.'pradhyapak george williams yanni gillardcha lekhee nikalala pratisad denyacha adhikar asalyache sangoon, tichya tippanyanna 'nirash firyadi' mhanoon chitrit kele.
yaa nirnayache udarmatvadi paksh tasech austreliyan greens yaa doghannihi kautuk kele. tatkalin virodhi pakshache chhaya sthalantar mantri, scott maurison yanni yaa nirnayache varnan 'aksham sarkarche aanakhi eka dhoranatmak apayash' asey kele; greens synet sadasya saara hanson-young yanni sangitale qee yaa nirnayane kararavaril tyanchya pakshachya bhoomikeche samarthan kele aahe.
aii. bii. see. chey vrutt patrakar jaine norman yanchya mhananyanusar, yaa nirnayavar firyadichya pratikriyebabat konatihi sarvajanik mahitee upalabdh nahee, jaree nikalanantar najarkaidetlya aatoon 'talhya vajavane aanee jallosh karane' aikoo aale. firyadiche pramukh vakeel mathyu albert yanna eka leave forummadhe yaa nirnayanantar kaay hoil asey vicharale gele. teey aaplya grahakanna sanganyachya 'durmil' karyabaddal bolale qee tyanna maleshiyat haddapar kele jaanar nahee; teey anishchit kalasathi tabyat rahtil aanee sarkarchya dayevar asateel. emm 70 aanee emm 106 yaa vyaktinche shevati kaay jhaale heey samanya janatela maheet nahee.
julien bernside kyu. see. (leave forummadhyehi) yanni yaa nirnayavar tippani kartana mhatale qee 'sagari prakriya haah aata sarkarsathi paryay rahilela nahee asey mhanane surakshit aahe'. pratyakshat, gillard kamgar sarkarne pudhchya varshi manu betavaril samudrakinanyavaril najarkaidet suvidha punha ughadun pratisad deela. 2008 madhye pahilya kathor sarkarne tyaa suvidha alikadech bund kelya asalya taree, yaa suvidha rudney gillardkadoon pantpradhananche karyalay parat midvalyanantar khulya thevalya gelya; aanee manu suvidha 'pii. aine. jee. solution' mhanoon olakhalya jaananya suvidhecha eka bhag bunley. aay.eae. nauketoon austreliyat yenanya konatyahi aashrayprarthila nirvasit mhanoon deshantargatpane sthayik honyapasoon rokhanyache kamgaranche ghoshit dhoran. khyan nirvasitanna papua nyu gineemadhye aashray deela jaeel, tarr khyan nasalelya aashrayarthinna parat pathavale jaeel, tisya deshat halavale jaeel kinwa anishchit kalasathi najarkaidet thewale jaeel. tyanantarchya yutee sarkarne heey dhoran kayam thewale aanee 2020 paryant manu betavaril anishchit kalasathi sagari najarkaidet thevane heey austreliyan sarkarche dhoran aahe.
maleshiyachya baar associationchya adhyakshanni yaa nirnayache swagat kele aanee eka nivedanat lihile qee, 'nirvasit adhiveshan aanee tyachya protocolver swakshari karnyachya mahattvavishayi maleshiyachi aathvan karoon denara' haah nirnay hota.