
pinochio virodhabhas

pinochio virodhabhas tevha udbhavato jevha pinochio mhanato qee "majhe naak aata vadhate" aanee hii khotya virodhabhasanchi eka aavrutti aahe. tatvadnyan aanee tarkshastrat khotya virodhabhasala "heey vakya chukiche aahe" asey vidhan mhanoon paribhashit kele aahe."yaa vidhanala shastriy dwaiti satya moolya nishchit karnyachya konatyahi prayatnanmule virodhabhas kinwa virodhabhas nirman hoto. heey ghadate kaaran jarr heey vakya khote aahe heey vidhan kharey asel tarr teey khote aahe; yacha arth assa hoil qee teey tantrikdrushtya kharey aahe, parantu teey khote dekhil aahe, aanee asech anant. jaree pinochio virodhabhas khotya virodhabhas parampareshi sambandhit asala, taree heey eka vishesh prakaran aahe kaaran tyat konatehi shabdarthiy andaj naheet, udaharanarth "majhe vakya khote aahe".
pinochio virodhabhascha pinochio haah dnyat labad asanyashi kahihi sambandh nahee. jarr pinochione 'mea thakalo aahe' asey mhatale tarr heey ektar kharey kinwa khote asoo shakate, parantu pinochioche vakya 'majhe naak aata vadhate' heey kharey kinwa khote asoo shakat nahee; mhanoon heey aanee keval heey vakya pinochio (khote) virodhabhas nirman karate.
itihas.
pinochio hii italian lekhak carlo kolodi yanchya 1883 salchya mulanchya kadambari 'daad adventures auph pinochio' chee nayak aahe. pinochio yaa eka animated kathputalila, tyachya nakachi aanakhi vaadh houn too sangana pratyek khotya goshtisathi shiksha hote. pinochiochya nakachya lambivar konatehi nirbandh naheet. too khote bolato tashee tee vadhate aanee eka tappyavar itaki lamb vadhate qee tyala 'kholichya daratoon' tyache nakahi gheta yet nahee.
februwari 2001 madhye 11 varshiy veronic eldridge-smith yane pinochio virodhabhas prastavit keela hota. veronic hii pieter eldridge-smithchi mulgi aahe, jee tarkshastra aanee tarkshastrachya tattvadnyanat parangat aahe. pieter eldridge-smithne veronic aanee veronikchya mothya bhawala labad virodhabhas samajavun sangitala aanee mulanna prasiddha virodhabhas tyanchya swatachya aavrutya gheuun yenyas sangitale. kahee minitant, veronicne suchavaleh "pinochio mhanato, 'majhe naak vadhat jaeel'."eldridge-smithala tyachya muleene suchavalelya virodhabhasanche sootra aavadale aanee tyane yaa vishayavar eka lekh lihila. haah lekh 'vishleshan' yaa niyatkalikat prakashit jhaala aanee pinochio virodhabhas internetvar lokpriy jhaala.
virodhabhas.
veronickne suchavalela virodhabhas, "majhe naak aata vadhate", kinwa bhavishyatil kalah "vadhat jaeel", vegvegalya arthansathi jaaga sodato. kadambarimadhye, pinochioche naak jasjase khote bolat jaate tasatase vadhat jaateh "too bolat asatana, tyache naak jaree lamb asale taree teey kiman done inch lamb jhaale."mhanoon tarkshastradnya prashna vichartat qee" majhe naak vadhat jaeel "heey vakyach pinochione bolalele vakya hote qaa," majhe naak vadhat jaeel "asey mhananyapurvi tyane khote sangitale qaa, kinwa too khote bolanar hota-aanee tyache naak vadhu lagayala kitee vel lagel?
majhe naak aata vadhat aahe' kinwa 'majhe naak vadhat aahe' yaa vakyacha vartaman kaal, khotarada virodhabhas nirman karanyachi adhik changli sandhee pradan karato asey disate.
majhe naak vadhate' heey vakya ektar kharey kinwa khote asoo shakate.
heey vakya gruheet dharuyah "majhe naak aata vadhate" heey kharey aaheh
majhe naak aata vadhate' heey vakya chukiche aahe asey gruheet dharuyah
aanee teey sope karnyasathi, eldridge-smith mhanato tyapramane, "pinochioche naak vadhat asel aanee teey vadhat nasel tarach vadhat aahe", jyamule pinochioche vakya "khotaradechi aavrutti" banate.
eldridge-smith assa yuktivad karato qee "kharey nahee" aanee "vadhat aahe" hii vakye samanarthi naslyamule, pinochio virodhabhas haah shabdarth virodhabhas naheeh
eldridge-smithcha vishvas aahe qee alfried tarskeecha siddhant, jyamadhye too mhanato qee khote virodhabhas keval "shabdarthadrushtya bund" asalelya bhashanmadhye udbhavtat asey nidan kele pahije. yacha arth assa qee jyaa bhashet eka vakyala tyach bhashet vakyache satya (kinwa khotepana) sangane shakya aahe tee bhasha pinochio virodhabhasala lagoo houu nayeh
pinochio against daad dialethysts' yaa tyachya pudhil lekhat eldridge-smith mhanatoh 'pinochioche naak vadhate aanee vadhat nahee haah kharaa virodhabhas asel tarr asey jug aadhyatmikdrushtya ashakya aahe, keval shabdarthadrushtya ashakya nahee."tyanantar too vachakanna aathvan karoon deto qee, jevha (buridanchya pulavar) socretisne tyala pool olandu shakato qaa asey vicharale, tevha platone uttar dile qee too pool fakt tevhach olandu shakato" "jarr pahilya prastavat tumhi satya bolal asey mhanat asal". pann jarr tumhi khote bolalat tarr mea tumhala panyat fekoon dein."socretisne uttar dile," tuu mallah panyat fekanar aahes."socretischi pratikriya hii eka sophism aahe jee platola katheen paristhitit aanate. too socretisla panyat feku shakala nahee, kaaran heey karoon platone socretisla satya bolalyas tyala pool olandu denyachya tyachya vachanache ullanghan kele asate. dusarikade, jarr platone sockretsla pool olandu deela asata, tarr yacha arth assa jhaala asata qee socretisne jevha uttar dile qee 'tuu mallah panyat fekanar aahes' tevha tyane khote sangitale aanee mhanoon tyala panyat fekale gele pahije. dusya shabdant, jarr aanee jarr too asoo shakat nasel tarach socretisla pool olandanyachi parvanagi dilee jaau shakate.
upay.
bhavishyatil kaal.
william eff. valicella, 'vishleshan' madhye prakashit jhalele lekh tyane vachalele naheet heey kabool kartana mhanato qee 'majhe naak aata vadhel' yaa vakyachya bhavishyatil kalamadhye kinwa 'majhe naak aata vadhate' yaa vakyachya vartaman kalamadhye tyala virodhabhas disat nahee.
valicella assa yuktivad karatat qee bhavishyatil kaal vakya khote virodhabhas nirman karoo shakat nahee kaaran heey vakya kadhihi khote manale jaau shakat nahee. too yaa udaharanadvare aapala muddah spasht karatoh "samaja mea andaj lavto qee udya sakali, sakali 6 vajata, majha raktadab 125/75 asel, parantu majha andaj chukicha thartoh dusya divashi sakali majha raktadab 135/85 aahe. jyaa vyaktine majha andaj aikala too konihi assa dawa karoo shakat nahee qee mea khote bolalo, jaree majha shrotyanna fasavanyacha hetu asala tarihi. kaaran jaree mea fasavanyachya hetune chukiche vidhan kele (jeey ghadale), taree dusya divashi majha raktadab nakki kassa asel heey jaanun ghenyacha majhyakade konatahi marg navhata."pinochioche vakya spasht karnyasathi tech spashtikaran vaparale jaau shakate. jaree tyache naak vadhel assa tyacha andaj khota tharala taree tyane khote bolalyache mhanane ashakya aahe. jarr vartaman kaal vaparla asel tarr tyala pinochiochya vakyatil labad virodhabhas qaa disat nahee heey valicella spasht karatoh
tathapi, valicelachya yuktivadavar khaleel prakare teeka kelee jaau shakateh pinochiochya ulat, valicelacha raktadab tyachya swatachya vidhananchya satyates pratisad dett nahee. tathapi, jevha too khote bolato tevha aanee tevhach tyache naak vadhate asey nirikshan karnyachya chaukatit kaam karat pinochio, tyachya mageel anubhavanchya aadhare tyala kharey vatate asey eka antardnyani tarkyukt vidhan karat asel.
parantu valicelachya yuktivadavaril yaa tikela dekhil aavhan dile jaau shakate. pinochioche naak kevha aanee qaa vadhate yachya swarupabaddalachya swatachya gruheet samajavar aadharit, pinochio jarr tyane aadhich sangitalelya khotyacha sandarbh dett asel tarr "majhe naak aata vadhate" heey keval 'prerak tark' kele jaau shakate. pinochiosathi, "majhe naak aata vadhate" heey eka vidhan aahe jeey keval asey soochit karate qee tyane jeey kahee "agadi aadhi" mhatale teey khote hote aanee mhanunach tyaa khotyamule tyache naak aata vadhat asel. yaa sandarbhat, 'majhe naak aata vadhate' heey vidhan eka andaj kinwa 'sushikshit' andaj aahe, jyacha tyachya swarupat khote mhanoon arth lavala jaau shakat nahee. tyamule, tyache naak aata vadhate qee nahee heey keval 'majhe naak aata vadhate' tyapurvi tyane kaay mhatale hote yavar avalambun asel.