
alonis wii. united states

alonis wii. united states, 575 yuu.ess. 723 (2015), haah united stateschya sarvoch nyayalayacha eka khatala hota, jyamadhye aantarrajyiy reshanvarun (18 yuu antargat) dusya vyaktila dhamkavanyachi shiksha jhaali qee nahee yabaddalacha hota.ess.see. kalam 875 (see) madhye dhamkavanyachya vyaktinishth hetucha purava aavashyak aahe kinwa 'vajvi vyakti' vidhanala dhokadayak manel heey dakhavanyasathi teey purese aahe qaa. anthony dugglus alonis yanni lihilelya aanee facebookwar topananavakhali poost kelelya hinsak rapp gitanchya kathit dhamkya vadat hotya. aii. see. ell. yuu. neey yachikakartyachya samarthanarth nyaymitrane sankshipt nivedan dakhal kele. khyan dhamkya aanee soshal mediavaril bhashanachya maryada vicharat gheuun nyayalayane ekhadya khatalyachi sunavani karanyachi hii pahilich vel hotee.
parshvabhoomi.
alonis ghatasfot prakriyet hota aanee tyane anek sarvajanik facebook poost kelya.
tyane 'tumhala maheet asalelya sarvat pandhya mulanche' rekhachitra poost kele, jyat mulat 'mallah amerikechya rashtradhyakshanna marayache aahe' asey mhatale hote aanee rashtrapatinchya jaagi tyanchya patnila niyukt keleh
elonisne yaa vidhanasah poost sampavalih "qalaa hii maryada dhakalanyabaddal aahe. mea majhya ghatanatmak hakkansathi turungat jaanyas tayar aahe. tumhi aahat qaa?"
eka aathvadyanantar, elonisne sthanik kayadyachi amalbajavani aanee balwadi vargabaddal poost kele, jyane federal beuro auph investigation laksh vedhale. tyanantar, tyala bhet denanya agentspacky ekabaddal tyane facebookwar eka poost lihilih
tyanni nishkarsh kadhalah
yaa krutimule parkche karmchari aanee abhyagat, sthanik kayadyachi amalbajavani, tyachi vibhakt patni, eff. bii. aay. agent aanee balwadi vargala aantarrajyiy sanvadadvare prasarit kelya gelelya dhamkyanchya paach prakarananvar grand jyuridware elonisvar aaroppatra dakhal karnyat aale.
jilha nyayalayat, tyane konalahi dhamkavanyacha hetu asalyacha aarop karnyat ayashasvi tharalyabaddal aaroppatra fetalanyachi magani kelee. tyacha prastav fetalanyat aala. tyane jyurichya nirdeshachi vinanti kelee qee "sarkarne heey siddha kele pahije qee tyacha kharaa dhoka sanganyacha hetu hota."jeey dekhil nakarnyat aale.
pachpaiki shevatchya chaar gunhyanmadhye tyala doshi tharvanyat aale. tyala 44 mahinyanchya turungvasachi aanee teen varshanchya dekharekhikhalil sutakechi shiksha sunavanyat aalee.
jyurichya soochananna aapale aavhan punha navyane dett, tyane circuit court auph appealsmadhye ayashasvi apeal kele.
dhamkavanyacha hetu dakhavanyacha konatahi prayatna naan kelyabaddal aanee pahilya durustichya adhikaranvar aadharit tyanni sarvoch nyayalayat apeal kele.
nirnay.
1 juuna 2015 roji sarvoch nyayalayane 8-1 chya nirnayat elonischi shiksha ulatavali. mukhya nyayadhish johnn jee. roberts yanni saat nyayadhishanchya bahumatasathi lihile, samuel alito yanni anshatah sahmat aanee anshatah asahmat mutt lihile aanee clarence thomas yanni asahmat mutt lihile. circuit kortacha nikal ulatanyat aala aanee prakaran kothadit thevanyat aale.
bahusankhyanche mutt.
roberts yanni lihilelya bahusankhyanchya matane, pahilya durustichya babinvar kinwa hetu darshavinyasathi nishkaljipana puresa 'purushancha hetu' hota qaa yaa prashnavar nirnay ghetala nahee. kalam 875 (see) antargat gunha jhalyache siddha karnyasathi 'purushancha kayada' aavashyak aahe assa nikal tyanni deela.
mahattvache mhanje, 'purushancha muddah' punaravalokanasathi jatan karnyat aala hota, kaaran elonisne mageel karyavahichya pratyek tappyavar too aakshep upasthit keela hota.
sarkarne assa yuktivad keela qee kalam 875 (buub) aanee kalam 875 (daad) madhye 'khandani magnyacha hetu' yaa shabdanchya upasthitimule kalam 875 (see) madheel anupasthiti rachnatmak hotee. kalam 875 (see) madhye bhashecha abhav haah yaa kalamacha arth khandanishi sambandhit dhamkyanpeksha vyapak vyapti asane haah hota, asey mutt mandat nyayalayane asahmat jhaale.
sarvoch nyayalayachya anek prakarananvar mutt aale jyat asey mhatale gele hote qee faujdari kayadyat, jaree kayadyat tyacha spashtapane ullekh keela gela nasla taree 'purushancha adhikar' aavashyak hota.
parinami, nyayalayane elonisachya bajoone nikal deela.
alitochi sammati.
samuel alitone anshatah sahmat houn aanee anshatah asahmati darshavat mutt vyakt kele qee, 'purushancha drushtikon' aavashyak aahe aanee visheshtah nishkaljipana dakhavane purese nahee yavar sahmati darshavitana, nyayalayane nishkaljipanachya prashnavar nikal dyayala havah hota. pudhe jaaun kayadyacha arth lavnyaivaji tyat sudharana karane asey tharel yaa aadharavar tyaa tartudikhali gunha dakhavanyasathi nishkaljipana puresa aahe, asey mutt tyanni pudhe vyakt kele. nishkaljipana puresa nahee assa spasht yuktivad elonisne kelyamule, alito mhanalah
alitone pahilya durustichya prashnalahi sambodhit kele, jeey bahumatache mutt nakarle gele. tyanni asey mutt vyakt kele qee, "prekshakansathi sadar kelelya kinwa dhwanimudrit swarupat vikalya gelelya ganyanmadhil geete khyan vyaktisathi kharaa dhoka mhanoon arth lavnyachi shakyata nahee... yaulat, tyanchya piditankade spashtapane nirdeshit keleli samajik madhyamanvaril vidhane gambhirpane ghetali jaanyachi shakyata jaast aahe."
thomascha virodh.
clarence thomas yanni asahmati darshavat, 'samanya hetu' mankala spasht mankane naan badalata tyakade durlaksh karnyachya virodhat lihile.
thomas yanni assa yuktivad keela qee "jevha ekhada kayada bhashanache niyaman karato tevha samanya hetupeksha jaast aavashyak asaleli konatihi aitihasik pratha nahee."
thomsney 'rosen' chaa hawala dett assa yuktivad keela qee yaa prakaranat samanya hetu puresa aahe. tathapi, bahusankhyanche mutt yaa goshtiche khandan karate qee 'rosen' neey kayadyachya adnyanavar bharr dilah sahitya kayadeshiraritya ashleel hote qee nahee yabaddalache dnyan, teey ashleel asanyacha 'hetu' hote qee nahee yavar nahee. kalam 875 (buub) chya bajuchya bhashet 'khandani magnyacha hetu' aahe yaa sarkarchya davyachehi tyanni samarthan kele aanee tyaa bhashevaril bahusankhyanchya tarkala sambodhit kele nahee.
thomsney tyachya 'samanya hetu' chya davyala samarthan denyasathi, visheshtah rajye aanee 18 vya shatkatil englandmadhil, itar parantu tatsam aanee vadatitpane, kayadyavar prabhav padna udaharanancha vapar keela. tommus yanehi tortmadhil samanya hetula samantar rekhatale. tyanni pahilya durustichya muddyanvar laksh denyacha prayatna keela, taree teey kadhihi 'samanya hetu' pasoon door gele naheet."
parinam.
kothadi sunavalyavar, apeal nyayalayane "nyaypithala yogya soochana dilya gelya asatya tarr elonisla doshi tharavale gele asate, yaat yuktivadachya palikade shanka nahee" aanee mhanoon tee nirupadravi chook hotee, asey punha sangitale.