serve goshtinchi sakal

serve goshtincha ugmah manavatecha eka naveen itihas heey manavvanshashastradnya aanee karyakarte david graber aanee puratatvashastradnya david vengro yanche 2021 chey pustak aahe. too pratham 19 aktoobar 2021 roji united kingadammadhe elon laine (pengwin pustakanchi chhap) dware prakashit karnyat aala.
graber aanee vengro yanni august 2020 chya sumaras pustak purn kele. tyachi american aavrutti 704 prushthe lamb aahe, jyat 63 prushthanchya granthasuchicha samavesh aahe. rajkiy lekhanasathichya (2022) orwell puraskarasathi too antim pherii gathanara hota.
suruvatichya manvi samajanchya vividhateche varnan karnare heey pustak, itihasachya aadimvadapasun teey sanskratiparyantchya resheey vikasachya paramparik varnananvar teeka karate. tyaeivaji, 'sarvkahi udayas yene' asey manate qee manav hajaro varshanpasun mothya, guntaguntichya, parantu vikendrikrut rajyanmadhye rahat hote.
"daad morning auph everything' haah chitrapat aantarrashtriy bestseller tharala, jyache teesahoon adhik bhashanmadhye bhashantar jhaale. lokpriy vruttapatranmadhye aanee aaghadichya shaikshanik niyatkalikanmadhye, tasech karyakartyanchya vartulat tyache vyapakpane punaravalokan karnyat aale, aanee mandalat vegvegali matey vyakt kelee gelee. anukool aanee samikshak samikshakanni manvi itihasachya abhyasatil vidyaman pratimanansamor tyache aavhan nondavale.
saransh.
lekhakanni pustakachi suruvat ashee suchavoon kelee qee, francis fukuyama, jared diamond, steven pinker aanee yuval noah harari yanni sadar kelelya pashchimatya sanskratichya pragativaril sadhyachya lokpriy matans manavvanshashastriy kinwa puratatviy puravyancha aadhar nahee, parantu dnyanachya yugapasoon vichar naan karata varshane midalelya tatvik siddhantanche teey adhik runee aahet. lekhakanni samajik kararachya utpattibaddalachya hobsian aanee russoan drushtikonache khandan kele aahe, asey mhanat qee manvi samajache konatehi mool swaroop nahee. shivay, teey assa yuktivad karatat qee charyapasun shetikade honare sankraman haah samajik asamanatecha paya rachanara sanskraticha sapala navhata aanee sampoorn itihasat, sattadhari uchchabhru aanee varchya-khalchya vyavasthechya anupasthitit mothya pramanat samaj vikasit jhaale aahet.
manvi itihas samajoon ghenyasathi eka chaukat mhanoon "asamanatechi utpatti" nakarat, lekhak yaa prashnacha ugam kuthe jhaala yacha vichar karatat aanee european vasahati aanee uttar americetil sthanik loksankhya yanchyatil sangharshanchya malikanmadhye uttare shodhatat. tyancha assa yuktivad aahe qee nantarchya european sanskratila eka shaktishali prati-namuna pradan keela aanee tyachya padanukram, pitrusatta, dandatmak kayada aanee napha-prerit vartanavar nirantar teeka kelee, jyane 18 vya shatkat pravashanchya khatyandvare aanee missionary sambandhandware european vicharanmadhye pravesh keela, jyache prabodhan vicharvantanni mothya pramanat anukaran kele. teey vendate neta kondiyaronkchya aitihasik udaharanadvare aanee naveen francechya vasahatinmadhye daha varshe ghalavalelya barren lahontanchya sarvadhik vikalya gelelya kamanmadhil tyachya chitranadware hii prakriya spasht karatat. lekhakancha assa yuktivad aahe qee, itihasachi nirmiti hii utpadanachi sadhane mhanoon karane aanee shikari-sangrahakapasun shetkari teey vyavsayik sanskratiparyantchi pragati yasah samajik utkrantichi manak katha, anshatah yaa swadeshi tikela gup karnyacha aanee manvi swatantryachi samajik vikasachi bholee kinwa adim vaishishtye mhanoon punaravrutti karnyacha eka marg mhanoon udbhavali.
tyanantarchya adhyayanmadhye puratatva aanee manavvanshashastriy puravyansah heey prarambhik dave vikasit kele jaatat. lekhakanni pracheen aanee aadhunik samudayanche varnan kele aahe jyanni swayam-janivpurvak shetiche jeevan sodoon dile, hangami rajkiy shasson vaparale (hukumshahi aanee jaatiy vyavasthanmadhye pudhe-pudhe badal karane) aanee samatavadi samajik karyakramansah shahari payabhoot suvidha tayar kelya. tyanantar lekhakanni japanpasoon amerikeparyantchya vividh khandanmadhil bigger-krishi samajanmadhil rajkiy jivanachi vividhata aanee guntaguntiche vyapak purave sadar kele, jyat smarak vastukala, gulamgiri aanee sanskrutik visangatichya prakriyedvare gulamgiricha aatm-janivpurvak nakar yasah prakarane samavisht aahet. tyanantar teey tyaa prakriyansathichya puratatviy puravyanche parikshan karatat, jyamule akheris sheticha sweekar aanee prasar jhaala, assa nishkarsh kadhatat qee krishi kranti jhaali nahee, parantu santh badalachi prakriya hotee, jee jagatil pratyek khandavar pasarayla hajaro varshe lagali aanee kadhikadhi loksankhyashastriy kosalane (udaa.jee. pragaitihasik europemadhye). paryavaraniy lavchikta aanee shashvat jaivavividhata hii suruvatichya shetichya yashasvi sthapanesathi aanee prasarasathi mahattvachi hotee assa nishkarsh tyanni kadhala.
tyanantar lekhak suruvatichya chean, mesoamerica, europe (ukraine), madhya purv, dakshin ashiya aanee africa (egypt) yetheel puratatva prakarananchya abhyasasah manvi itihasatil praman yaa samasyecha shodh ghetat. teey assa nishkarsh kadhatat qee pramanit hishebanchya ulat, shahari vasahatinmadhil lokanchya ekagratemule samajik swatantrya gamavale nahee kinwa sattadhari uchchabhru lokancha uday jhaala nahee. kahee prakarananmadhye, samajik starikaran heey suruvatipasunach shahari jivanache eka paribhashit vaishishtya hote heey manya kartana, teey suruvatichya shaharanchya prakarananche dekhil dastaivajikaran karatat jyat samajik shrenibaddhateche farse kinwa konatehi purave naheet, mandire, rajwade, kendriya sathavan suvidha kinwa lekhee prashasana yasarkhya ghatakancha abhav aahe, tasech teotihuaakansarkhya shaharanchi udaharane, jee shrenibaddha vasahati mhanoon suru jhaali, parantu adhik samatavadi marganche anusaran karnyasathi marg ulatoon, bahusankhya nagarikanna uchch darjachi ghare puravatat. europechya lokanchya aagmanapurvi, americetil sthanik shahari lokshahiche udaharan mhanoon aanee pracheen mesopotemiyamadhil nagarpalika parishada aanee lokpriy sabhansarkhya lokshahi sansthanchya astitvababatahi teey kahee pramanat charcha karatat.
yaa nishkarshanche sanshleshan karoon, lekhak samkalin sanskratichya kathor, shrenibaddha aanee atyant nokarshahikrut rajkiy vyavasthesathi antarnihit ghatak shodhanyakade valatat. rajya' hii shreni eka paar-aitihasik vastav mhanoon nakarat, tyaeivaji teey manvi samajantil varchasvachya teen moolbhut strotanchi vyakhya karatatah hinsacharavar niyantran (sarvbhaumatva), mahitivar niyantran (nokarshahi) aanee karishmai spardha (rajkaran). olmec aanee chaveen dii huantar, tasech shang rajvanshatil inka, chean, mayaa sanskruti aanee pracheen egypt yasarkhya rajyanchya vyakhyepasun door asalelya suruvatichya kendrikrut samajanchya udaharananchi tulana karoon teey yaa naveen drushtikonachi upayuktata shodhatat. yavarun teey pudhe assa yuktivad karatat qee yaa sanskruti aaplya aadhunik rajyanchya thet purvavarti navhatya, tarr agadi bhinn tattvanvar chalalya. aadhunik rajyanchi utpatti khol nasoon uthal aahe aanee samajik utkrantipeksha vasahatvadi hinsacharala adhik jababdar aahe, assa tyancha nishkarsh aahe. uttar americet paratatana, lekhak nantar sthanik tikakar aanee kondiyaronk purn vartulachi katha aanatat, jyamadhye venadat aanee shejaril lokanmadhye european lokanna lokanna swatantrya aanee lokshahichya mulyanchi aitihasik mule purvichya padanukramachya pranalichya nakarnyat kashee hotee heey darshavate, jyache laksh mississipivaril kahokiyachya shahari kendravar kendrit hote.
tyanchya ektrit charchechya aadhare, lekhak manvi itihasachya madhyavarti prashnanchi punarrachana prastavit karoon nishkarsh kadhatat. asamanatechya utpattiaivaji, teey suchavatat qee aapali madhyavarti duvidha haah aadhunik samajanni lavchikta aanee rajkiy sarjanshilateche guna kase gamavale aahet haah prashna aahe, jeey punha ekada samanya hote. teey vichartat qee aapan vikasachya ekach margavar kase adakalo aahot aanee yaa prabhavi vyavasthemadhye hinsa aanee varchasva kase samanya jhaale. nishchit uttare naan deta, lekhak pudhil tapasachya olee suchavoon pustak sampavatat. samajik swatantryachya teen moolbhut prakaranchya hanivar heey laksh kendrit karatat, jyacha tyancha assa yuktivad aahe qee ekekali samanya hotyah aekhadyachya sabhovatalachya parisaratoon sutoon door jaanyache swatantrya, manmani adhikarachi aadnya naan palanyache swatantrya aanee aekhadyachya samajachi vegalya swarupat punarrachana aanee punarrachana karnyache swatantrya. mahilanchi svayatta gamavanyavar aanee gharguti aanee kautumbik sambandhanchya staravar samajik kaljichya moolbhut kalpananmadhye hinsacharachi tattve samavisht karnyavar, adhik kathor rajkiy vyavastha sthapan karnyasathiche mahattvapoorn ghatak mhanoon teey bharr detat. 
jyaa samajik vikasachya kathankanmadhye pashchatya sanskruti resheey pragatimadhye aajvarchya yashacha sarvoch bindu mhanoon swayam-niyukt aahe, tyaa mukhyatve mithak aahet aanee samajik muktichya shakyata manvi itihasachya adhik achook samajamadhye aadhalu shakatat, jeey manavvanshashastra aanee puratatva kshetrachya madatine gelya kahee dashkantach prakashat aalelya vaidnyanik puravyanvar aadharit aahet, asey suchavoon pustak sampavate.
swagat.
yaa pustakane 'daad newyork times' chya sarvadhik vikalya vikalya pustakanchya yadeet kramank eka nondavala. 28 november 2021 chya aathvadyasathi 2, tarr tyachya german anuvadane dair spiegel bestsellerchya yadeet kramank 1 varr pravesh keela. tyala 'ravivar times', 'nirikshak' aanee 'bbc itihas' pustak auph daad ear asey naav denyat aale. rajkiy lekhanasathichya orwell puraskarasathi yaa pustakachi nivad karnyat aalee hotee. nyayadhishanchya samitiche adhyaksh asalele itihaskar david agerton yanni yaa pustakache kautuk kele aanee mhatale qee, haah "kharokharach manavatecha eka naveen itihas aahe" aanee "pragaitihasik punarparikshanavar aadharit manvi swatantrya aanee sambhavyatecha utsav aahe, jyamule naveen bhavishya shakya karnyasathi bhootkal ughadala jaato.hindusathi", jee. sampathane namood kele qee yaa pustakatoon done dhage jaatatah "puratatviy puravyanchya sangrahanche ektrikaran aanee kalpanancha itihas."adnyat bhootkalachya punarshodhanepasun prerit houn", too vicharato, "manavjat swatachya adhik yogya bhavishyachi kalpana karoo shakate qaa?"
gideon louis-cross yanni 'daad nyu yorker' madhye mhatale aahe qee, heey pustak 'durchya bhootkalatil shakyatanche punarujjivan karoon aapali rajkiy kalpanashakti vadhavanyachi ichcha balgate. daad atlantic' madhye, william derisivies yanni yaa pustakache varnan 'tejaswi' aanee 'preranadayi' asey kele aahe, asey mhanat qee teey 'sumare 30,000 varshanchya badalachya moolbhut gruhitkans unchavate."manavvanshashastradnya giulio ongaro yanni" "jacobin" "aanee" "tribune" "madhye mhatale aahe qee" "graber aanee vengro heey manvi itihasasathi tech karatat jeey [galileo aanee darwin] yanni anukrame khagolshastra aanee jivashastrasathi kele". bukforum' madhye michael robbins yanni yaa pustakala 'vedepanache' aanee 'adbhut' asey donhi mhatale aahe."vidnyanachya itihaskar emily kernne" "boston review" "madhye lihilelya yaa pustakala" "vidvattapoorn" "aanee" "majedar" "asey sambodhale aahe, asey suchavat qee" "ekada tumhi graber aanee vengrosarkha vichar karayala suruvat kelee qee, teey thambavane katheen aahe"."kirkschya samikshanni yaa pustakache varnan 'manvi itihasacha vyapak vistar' aanee tyachya anek 'moolbhut' kathanvar eka kalpak naveen drushtikon asey kele aahe.'aanee' mothya kalpanambaddalache eka aakarshak, bauddhikdrushtya aavhanatmak mothe pustak."nirikshakatil andreau anthonyne sangitale qee lekhak utkrantichya tappyanmadhun manavtela baljabarine pudhe nenyachya kalpanechi jaaga pragaitihasik samudayanni kase jagayache yabaddal swatache janivpurvak nirnay ghenyachya chitrasah ghetat".
itihaskar david prestlandne 'daad guardian' madhye assa yuktivad keela qee pieter kropotkinane aadhunik kalatil arajkatavadasathichya munn munn prakaranane sambodhit kelelya prashnanna adhik prabhavipane sambodhit kele aahe, parantu lekhakanchya aitihasik 'mithak-busting' chey kautuk kele aanee tyala 'eka aanandadayak vachan' mhatale. tatvadnyani kwame anthony appiya yanni 'daad newyork review auph books' madhye assa yuktivad keela qee 'pustak kaay mhanate aanee tyache srot kaay mhanatat yaat visangati aahe', tarr asehi mhatale aahe qee 'puratatva aanee vanshik sookshmatesah chaukablock asalele heey pustak eka vichitrapane pakadanare vachan aahe. "nirab" neey nantar "asamanatechi mule" yaa shirshakakhali vengro aanee apiya yanchyatil vistarit devanghevan prakashit kelee jyamadhye vengrone pustakachya puratatva strotanchya vaparavar vistar keela, tarr apiya yanni assa nishkarsh kadhala qee "aitihasik nirdharvadachya virodhat graber aanee vengrocha yuktivad-jeey ghadale teey ghadale asave yaa aakarshak kalpanechya virodhat-swatach atyant maulyavan aahe."helen dii cruze yaa aanakhi eka tatvadnyane lihile qee heey pustak" aaplya rajkiy aanee samajik nishkriyatechya utpatticha shodh gheuun tatvik vanshavalitil eka maulyavan abhyas "sadar karate, parantu itar sambhavya paddhatinchya shrenikade durlaksh kelyabaddalhi yaa pustakavar teeka kelee. 
shikago review" madhye lihitana, itihaskar brad bollman aanee puratatvashastradnya hannah moots suchavatat qee jeey pustak itake mahattvache aahe teey mhanje "alikadil manavvanshashastriy aanee puratatviy puravyancha eka vishal samooh upalabdh karoon denyacha tyacha prayatna; dhanyaviruddha teey vachane; aanee tyaa nishkarshanche sanshleshan aaplya dirgh bhootkalat nemke kaay ghadale yabaddal eka naveen kathet karane", vhee. gorden child. american puratanta" sathee punaravalokan karnare puratatvashastradnya jennifer berch yanni yaa pustakala 'eka prachand yash' mhatale, tarr puratatvashastradnya aanee manavvanshashastradnya rosemary joycene, 'american manavvanshashastradnya' sathee punaravalokan kartana lihile qee heey pustak "manvi itihasachya pramukh prashnambaddal uttejak vichar" aanee "manavvanshashastriy tulanechya naveen chaukatiche khatrilayak pratyakshik" pradan karnyat yashasvi jhaale aahe. 
british puratatvashastra" sathee punaravalokan karnare puratatvashastradnya mike pits yanni yaa pustakache varnan "gauravshali" asey kele aanee suchavale qee manavvanshashastradnya aanee puratatvashastradnya yanchya sanyukt lekhnamule "yaa shailimadhye kvachitach disanari sakholata aanee kathorata yaa pustakala milate". scientific american' sathee punaravalokan kartana, johnn horgen yanni yaa pustakache varnan 'sanskratichya utpattibaddalchi 692 pananchi sakhol vidvattapoorn chaukashi aanee manvi sambhavyatechi eka aanandadayak drushti' asey kele." 
aajche manavvanshashastra' yaa pustakat arjun appadurai yanni yaa pustakavar 'anek prati-udaharane aanee prati-yuktivad talhanyasathi valat chalanyacha' aarop keela, tarr pustakachya 'dantkatheche' varnan 'aakarshak' asey kele. david vengrone tyach prashnavar pratikriya dilee. "aaj manavvanshashastra" neey nantar sampadkala eka patra prakashit kele, jyamadhye rajkiy paryavaranshastradnya gens fris lund lihitat qee "apadurai kuthe aanee nemke kase gachch aanee vengro chukiche hotat heey kadhihi ughad karat nahee", yaa pustakala "eka smarak anubhavjanya prayatna" aanee "aantarshakhiy sahbhagache udaharan" asey sambodhale."tyanantarchya ankat," "aaj manavvanshashastra" "neey samajik manavvanshashastradnya luiz costa yanchya pustakache sampoorn punaravalokan prakashit kele, jyanni suchavale qee tyat" "bhavishyatil jivanshailila aakar denyasathi tyanchya swatachya bhootkalatil anubhavanvar kinwa shejarchya lokanchya anubhavanvar aadharit samajanchi anek udaharane aahet-swayamsevi arthane nahee, tarr aitihasik ghatanancha vichar karoon vishisht samajik namunyanmadhye"."kostane tyachi vyapti aanee mahatva yaa drushtine" "sarvkahi udayas yene" "chee tulana claude levy-strosschya abhijat kamanshi kelee". aanakhi eka manavvanshashastradnya thomas hilland ericson yanni yaa pustakala 'bauddhik mejwani' asey sambodhale." 
itihaskar david aaa. dnyanprapti vichar aanee jeane-jacks rusochya mool sthanik utpattibaddal graber aanee vengro yanchya yuktivadanna keval pratisad dett belane lekhakanna "vidvattapoorn gairvartanachya dhokadayak jawal yenyacha" aarop keela."itihaskar aanee tatvadnyani justine eae. etch. smith yanni suchavale qee, "aitihasik manavvanshashastrachya yaa aavashyak ghatakache punha kayadeshirkaran karnyat madat kelyabaddal graber aanee vengro yanna shrey dile pahije, jeey changle kinwa white mhanoon mohimanchya itihasatoon aanee prarambhik aadhunik jaagtik vanijyatoon janmala aale aahe."
manavvanshashastradnya darba chattaraj yanni dawa keela qee yaa pustakat bharatatil puratatvashastracha sandarbh detana 'ulthapalath, ghasghashit aanee atishay atishayoktipurna zep' samavisht aahe, parantu asey mhatale aahe qee tyache lekhak 'atyant kathor aanee katekor vidwan' aahet aanee bharatatoon pustak vachalyane 'aaplya jagacha vistar hoto aanee aaplyala eka vishisht vasahatvadanantarchya sankatatoon baher padnyas madat hote."manavvanshashastradnya mathyu porges yanni" "losses angelis review auph books" "madhye lihilelya lekhat asey suchavale aahe qee heey pustak" "uttejak aahe, jaree sarvasamaveshak nasale taree", "aanee tyache" "mothe moolya mhanje teey bhootkalat pratyakshat kaay ghadat hote yachya bhavishyatil shodhasathi eka changla marg pradan karate". manavvanshashastradnya richard handler yanni assa dawa keela qee pustakachya antim nondi nondi heey ughad karatat qee puratatva puravyancha visheshtah dhakkadayak arth lavane heey sahityachya vishal strotanmadhun ghetalelya eka kinwa done strotanvar avalambun asate", tarr asehi dawa karatat qee sangitalelya katha "aaplyala havya asalelya aanee aikayachya asalelya katha aahet."
james etch. heey aanakhi eka manavvanshashastradnya, 'newyork journal auph books' sathee lihit aahet. mcdonald yanni suchavale qee 'pratyek goshtichi sakal' heey dashkatil sarvat mahattvache pustak tharoo shakate, kaaran teey rajyane varchasva gajavalelya aaplya samajik jivanachya apariharyatebaddalchya sakhol dantkathancha sphot karate. manavvanshashastradnya james suzman yanni 'sahityik punaravalokanat' assa dawa keela aahe qee heey pustak 'alikadchya aafrikevaril vishal aitihasik aanee shaikshanik sahityashi sanlagn nahee... chhotya pramanavar shikari gola karnare, "pann heey pustak" satat vichar karayala lavnare "aahe," aaplya sakhol bhootkalabaddalchya kahee ubdar gruhitakanchi punha tapasani karnyas bhag padnare "aahe, asehi tyanni sangitale. black perspectives" sathee lihitana kevin suemnichtne namood kele qee yaa pustakat manvi swatantryachya hanicha hishob karnyasathi orlando pattersonne prastavit kelelya kalpana vikasit kelya aahet aanee assa yuktivad keela aahe qee heey pustak "kalya kattartavadi paramparetil dharmandh sthitichi pushti karate qee hii jaagtik pranali swabhavikpane kalya-virodhi aahe". prachinkalat", puratatvashastradnya rachel kiddy yanni suchavale qee heey pustak "done utkrusht patra mitranmadhil khelkar sambhashanatun" udbhavale aahe aanee teey "dnyanachya vikasachya strivadi punaravruttimadhye yogdan dete."
clyodynamics' madhye vividh lekhakanni teeka kartanach pustakachi prashansa kelee. garry emm. fenmanne graber aanee vengro yanchyavar 'cherry-nivadaleli aanee nivadakpane sadar keleli udaharane' vaparnyacha aarop keela. aanakhi eka puratatvashastradnya michael eae. smithne 'purava aanee yuktivadanchya samasyansathi' yaa pustakavar teeka kelee. ian mauris yanni dawa keela qee pustakache kahee yuktivad "paddhatipeksha vaktrutvavar adhik chalatat", parantu "kaljipurvak sanshodhan aanee prachand maulikateche kaam" mhanoon tyachi prashansa kelee."itihaskar walter skiddlene yaa pustakavar" "bhautikvadi drushtikon" "naslyamule teeka kelee, parantu tyala" "velevar aanee uttejak" "dekhil mhatale". 
rajkiy davyanmadhye yaa pustakacha pratisad dhruvikaran karnara hota. heey pustak arajaktavadi drushtikonatun lihile gele aahe asey anek samikshakanni suchavale. sebastian dabinsky yanni yaa pustakala "puratatva aanee manavvanshashastra yaa kshetratil alikadil shodhancha saransh mhanoon aanee prabhavi varnananchya sanrachananvar dolhe ughadanare mhanoon eka mahattvache kaam" asey mhatale. cosmonaut magazin' madhye, nicolaus vilariyalane yaa pustakache varnan 'utkrusht hastakshepachi malika' asey kele aahe, tarr vichardhareche aanee rajkaranache kautuk naan kelyabaddal lekhakanvar teeka kelee aahe."see. jeey. sheyu mhanale qee heey pustak" "fakt eka utkrusht krutee aahe" "tarr pieter essaxonne" "phair observer" "madhye yaa pustakache varnan" "manavatechya itihasabaddalachya aaplya samayik samajutivar aanee pragaitihasiktebaddalchya aaplya samayik samajutivar punha mandani aanee aamulagra punarvichar karnyachya aakarshak nimantranapeksha qamee nahee"."eliza delayne," "lavchikta" "sathee lihitana yaa pustakala" "eka prakatikaran" "aanee" "aapan swatahla kase pahato yachee vyapak punaravrutti" "asey mhatale aahe"."samajvadi karyakarte aanee manavvanshashastradnya criss nite yanni mhatale qee yaa pustakacha" "mukhya sandesh" "engelschya adim samyavadala nakarane haah hota aanee europemadhye homo sapiencechya aagmanachya hajaro varshanpurvi aafriket suru jhalelya sanskrutik fulanchya suruvatis" "khoop usheer" "aanee" "paddhatshirpane bajula saranyasathi" "sarvkahi visangat aanee chukiche" "asalyache mhatale". dirgh punaravalokanat, matra, '[rajkiy] dolananche samarthan karane' haah pustakacha 'eka mahattvacha muddah' hota, yavar nightne bharr deela. 
paryavaranshastradnya" madheel samikshakanni asey mutt vyakt kele qee lekhak "manvi utkrantivaril naveen vidvattechya prachand samoohat guntanyat ayashasvi tharale", tarr tyach velee, pustakala "tajya havecha oradanara vaara" asey sambodhale. daad rumps' sathee kelelya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathichya samikshanamadhye, 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad rumps' sathee 'daad' daad rumps 'sathee' daad 'daad rumps' laal 'laal' laal 'laal' laal 'laal' laal 'laal' laal"itihaskar rayan close yanni assa dawa keela qee heey pustak anshatah" "aitihasik puravyanchya vishisht, atishayoktipurna vyakhyevar" "avalambun aahe parantu teey" "avishvasaniy mahitipurn" "dekhil aahe".
itihaskar dominiq alekzandar yanni samajvadi sanghatanesathi 'counterfire' asey lihitana pustakat vaparlya gelelya puravyanvar prashnachinh upasthit kele aanee 'teleological savayichi' nakar rajkiy badalasathi 'atyant durbal karnara drushtikon' asalyache darshavile. bajar arajaktavadi charles johnson yanni pustakachya "strotanche vilakshan vachan" nondavale. daad neshan" yaa pustakat, itihaskar daniele immerwar yanni yaa pustakache varnan "vegvegalya samajanni vegvegalya goshti kelyachya vruttanni bharalelya scrapbookpeksha prajatinche charitra qamee" asey kele aahe, tarr "pragaitihasik latanvar taranganare cork mhanoon phaar purvichya lokanna nakarnyachya tyachya nakarachi prashansa kelee aahe. tyaeivaji, teey tyanna chintanshil rajkiy vicharvant mhanoon pahatat jyanchyakadun aapan kahitari shiku shakato ".
artforum' sathee lihitana, sayman woo yanni yaa pustakala 'manvi itihasache bracing punarlekhan' mhatale. bryan appliardne 'daad sande times' sathee kelelya tyachya punaravalokanat yala 'vegwan aanee sambhavya krantikari' mhatale aahe."" "vidnyan" "sathee punaravalokan kartana, erley ellis yanni" "sarvkahi udayas yene" "heey eka uttam pustak aahe jeey charchanna uttejan deil, munn badalel aanee sanshodhanachya naveen marganna chalana deil asey varnan kele aahe".

