
dandharmala nirop

aii fairwell too bhikshavruttihi aii brief economic histree auph daad world heey gregory clark yanche 2007 madheel aarthik itihasavaril pustak aahe. teey prinston university presne prakashit kele aahe.
yaa pustakache shirshak ernest hemingway yanchya 'aii fairwell too arms' yaa kadambarivar aadharit aahe.
samagri.
yaa pustakat, brittenmadhye pahilyanda ghadalyacha clarkcha dawa asalelya vishisht vartananchya utkrantichya sandarbhat audhyogik kranticha parinam mhanoon aalelya shrimant aanee garib rashtranmadhil darivar charcha kelee aahe. 1790 purvi, clark thampane sangato qee manushyala malthusian sapala sahan karava lagalah naveen tantradnyanamule adhik utpadakta aanee adhik ann saksham jhaale, parantu uchch loksankhyene teey patkan pachavale.
tathapi, brittenmadhye, rogamule samajatil garib sadasyancha satat mrutyu hott asalyane, samajatil tyanchi padey shrimantanchya vanshajanni tabyat ghetali. asha prakare, clarkchya matey, qamee hinsak, adhik sakshar aanee adhik mehanati vartan-madhyamvargiy moolye-sanskrutik aanee jaivikdrushtya sampoorn loksankhyet pasarali hotee. khalchya dishene samajik halchalinchya" yaa prakriyemule akheris brittenla utpadakatecha darr prapt karnyas saksham kele jyamule too malthusian sapalyatun baher padoo shakala. kahee desh garib aahet aanee itar shrimant aahet, yasathi pramukh ghatak mhanoon aajdekhil suru asaleli hii prakriya clark pahato.
pratisad.
tyachya prabandhansah, yaa pustakala vartamanpatre aanee vidvanankadun laksh vedhale gele aanee anek punaravalokne midali. constanz vidyapithachya christophe dejang yanni vasahatvadachya dadapshahichya pailuncha vichar naan kelyabaddal pustakavar teeka kelee aanee nishkarsh kadhalah "asey disate qee yaa pustakache kahee vartulat jeey manapasoon swagat jhaale aahe teey kamitakami yaa vastusthitivarun nahee qee teey pashchimatyanna jagatil bahutek lock aajahi jagat asalelya garibeechya pratyek jababdaripasun mukt karate."yaa pustakache benjamin emm. sarkhya lekhakankadun kautuk jhaale aahe. jaree yaa rajkiy dishene kaam karnare lekhak yaa pustakachya prabandhanshi purnapane sahmat nasale taree, friedman aanee tylor cowen (mercatus center director) ('kalpananni samruddha pustak', kadachit 'arthshastracha pudhcha blockbuster'). udaharanarth, libertarian catoo institutechya kuznikine sarvasadharanpane sakaratmak punaravalokanat mhatale aahe qee, "gelya kahee dashakancha vichar kartana tyanche spashtikaran atishay tatpurte disu lagate".
diardray mclosky (eleanoy vidyapith) yanni clarkchya anuvanshik prabhavavaril prabandhambaddal lihile qee, "vichitrapane, tyachya gruhitkanche mukhya apayash mhanje, eka pustak jeey kushal gananene bharalele aahe...] pureshi ganana karat nahee. teey mahattvachya aitihasik prashnanna vicharat nahee kinwa tyanchi uttare dett nahee."tine nishkarsh kadhalah" [...] kahee aarthik siddhantkaranchya alikadil lekhatoon tyanni midavalelya clarkchya samajik-neodervinionvadachi shifaras itihasaitaki qamee aahe."arthshastradnya carl gunnar person yanni asey mutt vyakt kele qee clarkcha malthushiyanvad" "kadhikadhi anubhavjanya aanee vishleshanatmak peksha adhik evangelical asato". johnn ess. lyons (miyami vidyapith) yanni samajik-arthshastra niyatkalikat hasyapurnapane kelelya tyanchya samikshecha nishkarsh assa kadhalah "anaupacharik nirikshan asey suchavate qee samikshakanni pratyek done panansathi kinwa tyahoon adhik pustakamadhil kiman eka vishisht chukikade laksh vedhale aahe".
robbert see heey aanakhi gambhir aahet. elon, david warsh aanee hans-joachim woth. woth assa yuktivad karatat qee gregg clarkche pustak pramukhyane 2002 salchya lekhak galler aanee move yanchya lekhanavar aadharit aahe aanee tyaa clarkney nuktech kahee khandit aanee kadachit pratinidhik nasoo jodale aahet. tyachpramane, warshney suchavale qee "clarkche pustak, ughadpane sangayache tarr, bauddhikdrushtya apramanik honyaitke swayam-vadhiche aahe".
kahee sammishra samikshanni prabandh aanee aakadevarivar teeka kelee, parantu pustakache moolyamapan tasech likhit aanee manoranjak asey kele. robbert solo yanni mukhya prabandhavar asahmati darshavali aanee tyaeivaji audhyogikikaranasathi sansthatmak badal hii karane mhanoon dakhal ghetali. tyanni pustakacha kahee bhag rudhivadi, kahee bhag aakarshak aanee vicharprerak aanee kahee bhag fakt chidkhor asalyache varnan kele. johnn ess. clarksobat kaam kelelya lionsney sangitale qee, pustakat anek chuka aahet, parantu pustak jaree manoranjak aahe asey vatateh "kahee bhagant chukiche, itaranmadhye apure, tarihi itaratra soochak aanee trasdayak asatanahi aakarshak".
clarkche pratyuttar aanee tyanantarchi prakashne.
clarkney 'aarthik itihasachya european punaravalokanasathi' eka niyatkalikatil lekhat mclosky aanee woths tyachya kahee tikakaranna pratisad deela. yaa lekhat, clarkney tyachya aakadevaritun midavalelya sampattichya varsahakkatecha andaj vaparoon assa yuktivad keela aahe qee, "purv-audhyogik englandmadhil shrimantanna vyaktimatva aanee sanskratimadhye garibanpeksha vegale asane aavashyak hote". teey mhanatat qee asey farak aarthik yashasathi sambandhit asavet aanee sanskruti, anuvanshashastra kinwa yaa donhinchya sanyogane pudhe jaau shakale asate. tathapi, teey pudhe sangatat qee "aadhunik audhyogik samajatil shrimant lock janukiyadrushtya garibanpeksha vegale aahet", asey done abhyasancha hawala dett, jeey samaan nasalelya julya mulanpeksha samaan julya mulanmadhil utpannacha adhik parasparsambandh darshavtat, tasech jaivik mulansathi aanee dattak ghetalelya mulansathichya parinamanmadhil farak darshavtat. tyamule teey suchavatat qee shrimant aanee garib yanchyat sankhyikiyadrushtya mahattvapoorn anuvanshik farak kassa nirman jhaala asel yache 'bhiksha' chey purvagrah 'hii eka atishay vastavik shakyata aahe.