
jyotish aanee vidnyan

jyotishshastrat anek vishvas pranalincha samavesh asato, jyaa asey manatat qee khagolshastriy ghatana aanee manvi jagatil ghatana kinwa vyaktimatvache varnan yanchyat sambandh aahe. vishvache varnan karanyachi konatihi spashtikaranatmak shakti naslyamule jyotishshastrala vaidnyanik samudayane nakarle aahe. vaidnyanik chachanimadhye jyotishshastriy paramparanmadhye namood kelelya parisarache kinwa kathit parinamanche samarthan karnyasathi konatahi purava aadhalala nahee.
jethe jyotishshastrane khote bhakit kele aahet, tethe teey khote tharale aahe. sarvat prasiddha chachaniche netrutva shaun carlson yanni kele hote aanee tyat shastradnyanchi samitee aanee jyotishanchi samitee samavisht hotee. yamule assa nishkarsh nighala qee janm jyotishane yogayogapeksha changli kamgiri kelee nahee. jyotishi aanee manasshastradnya michel gockwelin yanni kheladunchya janmatarikhinmadhye 'mangal prabhav' sathee sankhyikeey samarthan asalyacha dawa keela aahe, parantu pudhil abhyasanmadhye tyachi punaravrutti houu shakali nahee. nantarchya abhyasanchya aayojakanni assa dawa keela qee vishisht vyaktinna kadhoon takanyache suchavoon gaukwelinane abhyasasathi tyanchya samaveshaktechya nikashanvar prabhav padanyacha prayatna keela hota. geophrey deane yanni asehi suchavale aahe qee, palakanni (1950 chya dashakapurvi) janmatarikh nondavalyamule yacha parinam disun aala asava.
jyotishshastrane niyantrit abhyasanmadhye tyachi parinamkarakta darshavili nahee aanee tyachi konatihi vaidnyanik vaidhata nahee aanee tyamule teey chhadmavidnyan manale jaate. taare aanee grahanchi sthitee aanee halchali jyaa prakare pruthvivaril lokanvar aanee ghatananvar parinam karoo shakatat ashee konatihi prastavit krutee yantrana nahee, jyayoge jyotish mhanatat qee teey karatat jeey jivashastra aanee bhautikshastrachya changlya prakare samajoon ghetalelya, moolbhut pailunshi visangat nahee.
jyotishshastrachi aadhunik vaidnyanik chaukashi pramukhyane jyotishshastriy parampara aanee manavanmadhil hangami janmacha prabhav yanchyatil parasparsambandh rekhatanyavar kendrit aahe.
parichay.
bahusankhya vyavsayik jyotishi jyotishshastra-aadharit vyaktimatva chachanya karnyavar aanee vetandarachya bhavishyabaddal sambandhit andaj lavnyavar avalambun asatat. jyotishshastravar ajunahi vishvas asalelyanche varnan asey kele gele aahe qee, "tyanchya vishvasanna konatahi pramanit vaidnyanik aadhar nasla taree aanee yaulat thos purave asale taree" asey kele jaate. khagolbhautikshastradnya niil degrass tyson yanni jyotishshastriy vishvasavar bhashya kele, qee "vichar kassa karava heey jaanun ghenyacha eka bhag mhanje nisargache niyam aaplya sabhovatalachya jagala kase aakar detat heey jaanun ghene. tyaa dnyanashivay, vichar karnyachya tyaa kshamateshivay, tumhi sahajpane tumcha fayda gheu ichchinanya lokancha balee banoo shakata.
vishvasarhatecha abhav asoonahi jyotishshastravaril satatcha vishvas haah qamee vaidnyanik saksharateche pratyakshik mhanoon pahila jaato, jaree kahijan vaidnyanikdrushtya sakshar asale taree tyavar vishvas thevatat.
khagolshastrashi aitihasik sambandh.
jyotishshastrat vaparlya jaanarya saiddhantik sanrachanecha paya babylonian lokanpasoon udbhavala aahe, jaree alekzandar daad gretney greesmadhun zep ghetalyanantar hellenistic kalachya suruvatiparyant vyapak vapar jhaala navhata. heey nakshatr aakashiy golavar naheet aanee khoop door aahet heey babylonian lokanna maheet navhate. tyanche jawalche swaroop heey bhramatmak aahe. nakshatr mhanje kaay yache achook seemankan sanskrutik aahe aanee sanskratinmadhye vaividhya aahe. tyaa kalatil serve jyotishanpramanech, grahanchya halchalinchi sahaj ganana karnyachya ichchemule khagolshastravaril tolemyche karya kahee pramanat prerit hote. prarambhik pashchatya jyotishshastra heey sthool aanee sookshm vishvachya pracheen greek sankalpanankhali karyarat hote aanee asha prakare vaidyakeey jyotishshastrane grahanche aanee aakashatil itar vastunche kaay jhaale yacha vaidyakeey shastrakriyanshi sambandh jodala. yamule khagolshastrachya abhyasasathi aanakhi prerana midali. jyotishshastrachya pratheche samarthan karat asatana, tolemyne manya kele qee grah aanee itar khagoliy vastoonchya halchalisathi khagolshastrachi bhavishyasuchak shakti jyotishiy andajanpeksha varr aahe.
islami suvarnayugat, khagolshastrala nidhi deela gela jenekarun tolemic modelsathi aavashyak asalelya suryachya kakshachya vilakshantesarkhya khagolshastriy mapdandanchi ganana pureshi achookata aanee achookatesah kelee jaau shakel. sattechya padavar asalelyanni, jase qee 1120 madheel fatimid khalifa wazier yanni vedhshalanchya bandhkamasathi nidhi deela jenekarun achook grahanchya mahitidvare jyotishshastriy andaj lavale jaau shaktil. jyotishshastriy andaj vartavanyat madat karnyasathi vedhshala bandhalya gelyamule, islammadhil jyotishshastravaril bandimule yapaiki kahee vedhshala dirghkal tikalya aanee bahutek bandhkamachya darmyan kinwa tyanantarach padalya gelya.
khagolshastrachya karyanmadhye jyotishshastracha spasht nakar 1679 madhye laa connoissance days temps yaa varshik prakashanasah suru jhaala. pashchimatya deshanchya ulat, iranmadhye, suryakendrivadacha nakar 20vya shatkachya suruvatiparyant suru rahila, kahee pramanat hii bheeti yamule prerit jhaali qee yamule iranmadhil jyotishshastra aanee islami vishvashastravaril vyapak vishvas qamee hoil. iranmadhil jyotishshastra aanee "junya khagolshastra" vareel vishvas qamee karnyachya uddeshane iktizad all-saltana yanni lihilele 'falak all-saada "heey pahile kaam 1861 madhye prakashit jhaale. jyotishshastravar, tyat vegvegalya jyotishanchya sanyoganantar kaay hote yabaddal samaan andaj lavnyat asamarthatecha ullekh keela gela aanee jyotishanni grahanna dilelya gunadharmanche varnan avishvasaniy asey kele.
vidnyanache tatvadnyan.
jyotish heey chhadmavidnyanache utkrusht udaharan pradan karate kaaran tyachi varanvar chachani kelee gelee aahe aanee serve chachanyanmadhye too ayashasvi jhaala aahe.
khotepana.
vidnyan aanee vidnyan nasalele heey anekada khotepanachya nikashandvare vegale kele jaatat. haah nikash sarvapratham vidnyan tatvadnya carl popper yanni prastavit keela hota. poppersathi, vidnyan prernavar avalambun nahee; tyaeivaji, vaidnyanik tapas heey naveen chachanyandvare vidyaman siddhant khote tharvanyache swabhavik prayatna aahet. jarr ekach chachani ayashasvi jhaali tarr siddhant khota tharato.
mhanoon, vaidnyanik siddhantachya konatyahi chachanine siddhantala khote tharvana kahee parinamanna pratibandhit kele pahije aanee siddhantas anuroop asalelya itar vishisht parinamanchi apeksha kelee pahije. khotepanacha haah nikash vaparoon, jyotishshastra heey eka chhadmavidnyan aahe.
jyotish heey popperche chhadmavidnyanache sarvat varanvarche udaharan hote. popperne jyotishshastrala 'chhadm-anubhavjanya' manale kaaran teey nirikshan aanee prayoganna aakarshit karate, parantu tarihi teey vaidnyanik manakanparyant yet nahee.
vaidnyanik shakhanchya ulat, jyotish prayogadvare khotya bolanyala pratisad dett nahee. neurologyche pradhyapak terrence heins yanchya matey, heey chhadmavidnyanache vaishishtya aahe.
"sodavanyasathi kode naheet".
popperchya ulat, tatvadnyani thomas kuhn yanni assa yuktivad keela qee jyotishshastrala avaidnyanik banavane heey khotepanache abhav nasoon jyotishshastrachi prakriya aanee sankalpana anubhavjanya naheet. kuhnala, jaree jyotishanni, aitihasikdrushtya, "spashtapane ayashasvi" asey bhakit kele asale taree, heey swatach teey avaidnyanik karat nahee, kinwa jyotishanni heey apayash spasht karnyache prayatna kele naheet, kaaran teey janmachya nirmitimule hote assa dawa karane khoop katheen aahe (vastusthitinantar, adhik samanya janmakundali samavisht karoon jee vegalya andajakade netat).
tyaeivaji, kuhnachya najaret, jyotishshastra heey vidnyan nahee kaaran teey nehmich madhyayugeen aushadhanshi adhik samya hote; tyanni dnyat kamataratansah aavashyak vatananya kshetrasathi niyam aanee margdarshak tattvanchya kramache palan kele, parantu tyanni konatehi sanshodhan kele nahee kaaran hii kshetre sanshodhanasathi anukool naheet aanee mhanoon, "tyanchyakade sodavanyasathi kodee navhati aanee mhanoon sarav karnyasathi vidnyan navhate."
khagolshastradnya apayashachi durusti karoo shakat asatana, jyotishi karoo shakat navhata. eka jyotishi keval apayashache spashtikaran deu shakat hota parantu jyotishiy gruhitkat arthpurn ritine sudharana karoo shakat navhata. tyamule, jaree taare jivanachya madhyamatoon manavanchya margavar prabhav takoo shakale taree jyotishshastra vaidnyanik nahee.
pragati, sarav aanee satatya.
tatvadnya paul thaggard yancha assa vishvas hota qee joparyant jyotishshastrachi jaaga uttaradhikari ghet nahee toparyant yaa arthane tyala khote manale jaau shakat nahee. vartanacha andaj vartavanyachya babatit, manasshastra haah paryay aahe. chhadmavidnyanachya aadhare vidnyanachya simankanababat aanakhi eka nikash mhanje, atyadhunik sthitichi pragati hone aavashyak aahe aanee sanshodhakanchya samudayane sadhyachya siddhantachi tulana paryayanshi karnyacha prayatna keela pahije, aanee 'pushti aanee dujora vicharat ghetana nivadak' nasave.
yethe pragatichi vyakhya naveen ghatananche spashtikaran dene aanee vidyaman samasyanche nirakaran karane ashee kelee aahe, tarihi jyotishshastra jawaljawal 2000 varshant thode badalale aahe. anek nirakaran naan jhalelya samasya asoonahi aanee changlya paryayi siddhantanchya (manasshastra) samore jyotishshastracha paya changlya prakare sthapit jhaala aahe asey manoon jyotishi samanya vidnyanat guntalyasarkhe vagatat. yaa karananmule thaggard jyotishshastrakade chhadmavidnyan mhanoon pahat asey.
tathapi, vividh jyotish chinhe aanee aekhadyachya karkirdit konatahi parasparsambandh shodhanyat gaukwelinchya apayshavar jyotishshastrala eka chhadmavidnyan manale jaau naye, julya abhyasanmadhye samaan chinhe asanyamule apekshit parasparsambandh darshavinari julee mule, tolemichya kalapasoon sapadalelya grahanchya mahattvavar sahmaticha abhav aanee mothya pramanat yenanya aapatti ekach velee atyant bhinn chinhe asalelya vyaktincha naash karatat. tyaeivaji, tyachya vidnyanachya simankanasathi teen bhinn kendranchi aavashyakta aaheh "siddhant, samuday [aanee] aitihasik sandarbh".
padtalani aanee khotepana yaa siddhantavar kendrit asatana, kuhnache karya aitihasik sandarbhavar kendrit hote, parantu jyotishiy samudayachahi vichar keela pahije. teey asso vaa nasoh
yaa drushtikonat, khotepana talhanyasathi siddhantat badal karnyaivaji kharey khotepana tevhach pratyakshat udbhavato jevha paryayi siddhant prastavit keela jaato.
tarkahinpana.
tatvadnyani edward doubleu. james, jyotishshastra heey prayoganmule yantrana aanee khotepanachya asankhya samasyanmule nahee, tarr jyotishshastrachya sahityachya vishleshanamule asey disun yete qee teey chukiche tark aanee kharab tarkane bharalele aahe.
yaa chukichya tarkamadhye vishay kinwa vishisht tarkshastrachi konatihi prasangikta aanee aspasht dave asoonahi keplarsarkhya pracheen jyotishanna aavahan karane samavisht aahe. jyotishshastracha purava assa aahe qee sadharanpane ekach thikani janmalelya lokanche jivanman khoop samaan aahe, haah dawa aspasht aahe, parantu vel hii sandarbh chaukativar avalambun aahe yakadehi durlaksh karato aanee grah saurmalechya sandarbh chaukatit firat asoonahi 'samaan sthan' chee konatihi vyakhya dett nahee. jyotishanchya itar tippanya moolbhut bhautikshastrachya gambhir chukichya vyakhyanvar aadharit aahet, jase qee madhyayugeen jyotishanchya samanya vishvasanusar qee bhoo-kendrit saur mandal anooshi sambandhit aahe. pudhe, james yanni namood kele qee tikela pratisad dekhil sadosh tarkshastravar avalambun asato, jyache eka udaharan julya mulanmadhil yogayog jyotishshastramule aahet, parantu konatehi farak "aanuvanshikta aanee paryavaran" mule aahet, tarr itar jyotishansathi samasya khoop katheen aahet aanee tyanna fakt tyanchya jyotishshastrakade parat jayache aahe yaa vidhanasah duheri abhyasanna pratisad hota. pudhe, jyotishanna, jarr kahee tyanchya bajoone disale tarr teey tyache parinam shodhanyacha prayatna naan karata, purava mhanoon tyacha vapar karatat, tyaa vastoola nishchit mhanoon sandarbhit karnyas pradhanya detat; jyotishshastrala anukool naan karananya shakyatankade durlaksh kele jaate.
quinion diacotomy.
dnyanachya quinion jaalitun, eka dwibhajan aahe jithe ekhadyane ektar jyotishshastra nakarle pahije kinwa jyotishshastra sweekarle pahije parantu jyotishshastrashi visangat asalelya serve sthapit vaidnyanik shakha nakarlya pahijet.
jyotishshastrachya chachanya.
jyotishi anekada padtalani karnyayogya andaj lavane talhtat aanee tyaeivaji aspasht vidhananvar avalambun asatat jyamule teey khotepana talhanyacha prayatna karoo shakatat. anek shatkanchya chachanyanmadhye, jyotishshastrache andaj keval yogayogane apekshit asalelya andajapeksha kadhihi adhik achook navhate. jyotishshastrachya parimanatmak chachanimadhye vaparla jaanara eka drushtikon mhanje andh prayogadvare. jevha carlson chachanimadhye kathor prayogik prakriyanmadhye jyotishankadun vishisht andajanchi chachani kelee gelee, tevha andaj khote tharale. serve niyantrit prayog konatahi parinam dakhavanyat ayashasvi tharale aahet.
mangal prabhav.
1955 madhye, jyotishi aanee manasshastradnya michel gockwelin yanni sangitale qee jaree teey jyotishshastratil rashee chinhe aanee grahanchya pailunsarkhya nirdeshakanche samarthan karnyasathi purave shodhanyat ayashasvi tharale asale taree tyanna kahee grahanchya dainandin sthitee aanee vyavasayatil yash (jase qee doctor, shastradnya, kheladu, abhinete, lekhak, chitrakar ii.) yanchyat sakaratmak sambandh aadhalale hote.), jeey jyotishshastra paramparikpane tyaa grahanshi sambandhit aahe. gockwelinche sarvat prasiddha nishkarsh yashasvi kheladunchya janm taktyatil mangalachya sthanavar aadharit aahet aanee teey 'mars effect' mhanoon olakhale jaau lagale. saat french shastradnyanni kelelya abhyasat yaa davyachi nakkal karnyacha prayatna keela, parantu konatahi sankhyikeey purava sapadala nahee. tyanni yaa parinamache shrey gaukwelinchya bajoone nivadak purvgrahala dile, aanee tyanchyavar tyanchya abhyasatoon nave jodanyasathi kinwa hatavanyasathi tyanna patvoon denyacha prayatna kelyacha aarop keela.
geophrey deane yanni suchavale aahe qee, gaukwelinchya abhyasat konatyahi samasyeaivaji palkankadun janmatarikh swayam-ahwal dilyane haah parinam houu shakato. suchavale jaate qee palakanchya eka chhotya upasanchane sambandhit vyavasayasathi changlya jyotishiy taktyanshi susangat honyasathi janmachi vel badalali asel. namuna gut asha kalapasoon ghetala gela hota, jevha jyotishshastravar vishvas adhik samanya hota. alikadech aadhalalelya loksankhyemadhye, jithe paricharika kinwa doctoranni janmachi mahitee nondavali hotee, tethe mangalavar honara parinam shodhanyat gaukwelin ayashasvi tharale hote. jyotishshastriyadrushtya avanchhit paristhitit janmanchi sankhya dekhil qamee hotee, jeey palak tyanchya vishvasanusar tarkha aanee vela nivadatat yacha adhik purava darshavate.
carlsoncha prayog.
shaun carlsoncha aatacha prasiddha prayog 28 jyotishanni keela hota, jeey 100 hoon adhik janm taktyanshi californiachya psychological inventory (see. pii. aay.) chachanidware tayar kelelya manovaidnyanik profileshy duheri andh paddhatincha vapar karoon julale hote.
carlsonchya abhyasat vaparlya gelelya prayogik niyamavalila prayogapoorvi bhautikshastradnya aanee jyotishanchya gatane sahmati darshavali hotee. rashtriy bhoo-vaishvik sanshodhan parishadene namankit kelelya jyotishanni jyotish sallagar mhanoon kaam kele aanee chachani nyayya aahe heey sunishchit karnyat madat kelee aanee sahmati darshavali. tyanni chachanyansathi 28 jyotishanpaiki 26 jyotishinchihi nivad kelee, itar doghe ichchuk jyotishi hote jeey nantar swechhene aale. europe aanee amerikemadhun jyotishi aale hote. jyotishanni chachanisathi janm jyotishshastracha kendriya prastav tayar karnyas madat kelee. 1985 madhye 'nechar' madhye prakashit jhalelya abhyasat asey aadhalun aale qee janmadatya jyotishshastravar aadharit andaj heey yogayogapeksha changle navhate aanee chachani "jyotishshastriy gruhitak spashtapane nakarte".
deane aanee kelee.
shastradnya aanee majee jyotishi geophrey deane aanee manasshastradnya ivan kelee yanni mothya pramanat vaidnyanik chachani kelee, jyat shambharpeksha jaast sandnyanatmak, vartanukiche, sharirik aanee itar chalancha samavesh hota, parantu jyotishshastrala konatahi aadhar midala nahee. pudhil chachanimadhye 45 aatmavishvas asalele jyotishi, sarasari 10 varshancha anubhav aanee 160 chachani vishay (chachani vishayanchya mool namunyachya aakarapaiki 1198) yancha samavesh hota, jyanni isenak vyaktimatva prashnavalitil kahee vaishishtyanna atishayoktiparyant jordar pasanti dilee. jyotishanni keval vyaktinchya vayanusar nirnay ghenyapeksha khoop white kamgiri kelee aanee janm takte ajibat naan vaparlelya 45 niyantran vishayanpeksha khoopach white kamgiri kelee.
itar chachanya.
700 jyotishi aanee 1,000 hoon adhik janm takte asalele 40 abhyas ektrit karoon eka meta-vishleshan aayojit karnyat aale hote. ekoon 300 sahbhagi asalelya chachanyanpaiki daha chachanyanmadhye, jyotishshastrane yogya kelelya taktyacha arth nasalelya (sahasa teen teey paach itar) itar anek chachanyanmadhun yogya taktyacha arth kadhanyacha jyotishancha samavesh hota. jevha tarikh aanee itar spasht sanket kadhoon taknyat aale, tevha konatahi pasantiche takte asalyache soochit karnare konatehi mahattvapoorn parinam aadhalale naheet.
10 abhyasanmadhye, sahbhaginni janmakundali nivadalya jyaa tyanna achook varnan asalyache vatale, eka 'yogya' uttar hote. punha, parinam sandhipeksha changle navhate.
2011 madhye, ekmekanpasun 5 minitanchya antarane ('julya vel') janmalelya lokanchya sanchanchya abhyasat, kahee spasht parinam disun aala qee nahee heey pahanyasathi; konatahi parinam disun aala nahee.
parimanatmak samajshastradnya david wassney ingland aanee velsmadhil 2 kotihoon adhik vyaktinchya jangananechya aakadevarichi tapasani kelee aanee tee mhanje taranchi chinhe vivah vyavastheshi sambandhit aahet qaa heey pahile. tyacha konatahi parinam disun aala nahee.
saiddhantik adthale.
jyotishshastra ayashasvi jhaale aahe, tyapalikade, jyotishshastratil anek saiddhantik doshanmule jyotishshastrasathichya prastavanna itar anek adthalyanna samore jaave lagate, jyat susangatatecha abhav, haravalelya grahancha andaj lavnyachi kshamata nasane, rashicha nakshatranshi sambandh nasane yancha samavesh aahe. jyotishshastrache aadhar vaidnyanik shakhanmadhil asankhya moolbhut tathyanshi asahmat asatat.
susangatatecha abhav.
jyotishshastrachya vaidhatechi chachani karane katheen asoo shakate kaaran jyotishshastra mhanje kaay kinwa teey kaay andaj lavu shakate yabaddal jyotishanmadhye ekmat nahee. deane aanee kelee yanni 25 abhyasanche dastaivajikaran kele, jyat asey aadhalun aale hote qee jyotishanchya andajanmadhil sahmatiche praman 0.00 itake qamee mojale gele hote. bahutek vyavsayik jyotishanna bhavishyacha andaj lavnyasathi kinwa ekhadya vyaktichya vyaktimatvache aanee jivanache varnan karnyasathi paise dile jaatat, parantu bahutek kundali keval aspasht naan tapasata yenari vidhane karatat jee jawaljawal konalahi lagoo houu shakatat.
georges charpak aanee heinry broach yanni 'debunked!' yaa pustakat pashchatya jyotishshastrachya davyancha abhyas keela aahe. visheshtah, telekinesis aanee itar chhadmavidnyan. tyanni nidarshanas aanoon dile qee jyotishanna khagolshastrache keval thode dnyan aahe aanee teey anekada vishuvachya purvgamanasarkhi moolbhut vaishishtye vicharat ghet naheet. tyanni elizabeth tacierchya udaharanavar bhashya kele, jyanni dawa keela qee "darvarshi ekach tarkhela aakashat ekach thikani surya ugavato", yaa davyacha aadhar mhanoon, ekach vadhadivsachya done vyakti parantu anek varshanchya antarane ekach grahachya prabhavakhali asavet. charpak aanee brochne namood kele qee "salag done varshant konatyahi vishisht tarkhela pruthvichya sthanamadhye sumare bavis hazar mailancha farak aahe" aanee tyamule jyotishshastranusar teey samaan prabhavakhali nasavet. 40 varshanchya kalavadhit 7,80,000 mailanpeksha jaast farak asel.
bhautik aadhar nasane.
edward doubleu. james yanni tippani kelee qee suryastachya velee surya jyaa aakashiy goalkat asato tyaa nakshatrala mahatva dene heey manvi ghatakanchya aadhare kele gele hote-mhanje, jyotishanna lavkar uthayache navhate aanee duparchi nemki vel jaanun ghene katheen hote. pudhe, rashichi nirmiti aanee nakshatranpasun door rahane heey surya pratyek nakshatrat samaan kalavadhisathi naslyamule hote. nakshatranpasunchya yaa vichchhedanamule rashee chinhanna teey ekekali jyaa nakshatranshi sambandhit hote tyaa nakshatranpasun vegale karnyachya purvprakriyechi samasya nirman jhaali. vidnyanache tatvadnya, masimo piglyuchi yanni yaa chalvalivar bhashya kartana mutt vyakt kele, "theek aahe, tarr mug, jevha mea majha ravivarcha kagad ughadato tevha mea konate chinh pahave, mallah aashchary vatate?"
ushnakatibandhiy rashicha tanyanshi konatahi sambandh nahee aanee joparyant nakshatr swatah sambandhit chinhat aahet assa konatahi dawa keela jaat nahee, toparyant jyotishi hii sankalpana talhtat qee purvagaman heey nakshatranna halavate kaaran teey tyancha sandarbh dett naheet. charpak aanee brochne heey lakshat gheuun, ushnakatibandhiy rashivar aadharit jyotishshastracha ullekh keela aahe...rikamya petty jyaa konatyahi goshtishi sambandhit naheet aanee tanyanshi susangatata kinwa sanvad nasalelya aahet."ushnakatibandhiy rashicha ekmev vapar, tyach jyotishanni kelelya, kumbh rashichya vayashi sambandhit sandarbhanshi visangat aahe, joou vasant bindu kumbh rashichya nakshatrat kadhee pravesh karato yavar avalambun asato.
bhavishyavani shakticha abhav.
kahee jyotishi assa dawa karatat qee serve grahanchi sthitee vicharat ghetali pahije, parantu jatkatil chukanchya aadhare jyotishi nepchyoonchya astitvacha andaj lavu shakale naheet. tyaeivaji nepchyooncha andaj newtonchya sarvatrik gurutvakarshanachya niyamacha vapar karoon vartavanyat aala. jyotishshastratil pravachanat uranus, nepchyoon aanee plutoche kalamkaran 'tatpuratya' aadharavar karnyat aale.
plutochya butkya grahachya sthiteet utaralyavar, francechya meuden yetheel parris vedhshaleche phillip jarka yanna jyotishanni kassa pratisad dyava yacha aashchary vataleh
yantranecha abhav.
khagoliy vastoonchya halchalinna manvi vartanavar honanya tyanchya kathit parinamanshi jodanari bhautik yantrana pradan karnyat ayashasvi tharalyabaddal jyotishshastravar teeka kelee gelee aahe. 2001 madhye eka vyakhyanat, stephen hocking mhatale hote qee, "bahutek shastradnya jyotishshastravar vishvas naan thevanyache kaaran mhanje teey prayogadvare chachani kelelya aaplya siddhantanshi susangat naslyamule aahe."1975 madhye, jyotishshastratil vadhatya lokpriy swarsyamadhye," manavtavadi "masikane bart jeey. yanni ektrit kelelya nivedanat jyotishshastrache khandan kele. boqa, laurence eae. jerom aanee paul curtz. jyotishshastravar aakshep' yaa shirshakachya yaa nivedanavar 186 khagolshastradnya, bhautikshastradnya aanee tyaa kalatil aaghadichya shastradnyanni swakshya kelya hotya. jyotishshastrachya tattvanna konatahi vaidnyanik paya nahee asey tyanni sangitale aanee janatela jyotishshastracha sallah viina prashna swikaranyapasun savadh kele. jyotishiy parinam houu shaktil ashee konatihi yantrana navhati yaa vastusthitivar tyanchya tikeche laksh kendrit hoteh
khagolshastradnya carl sagon yanni yaa vidhanavar swakshari karnyas nakar deela. sagan mhanale qee tyanni hii bhoomika jyotishshastrachi kahee vaidhata aahe asey tyanna vatale mhanoon ghetali nahee, tarr vidhanacha suur hukumshahi aahe asey tyanna vatale aanee konatihi yantrana naslyamule ('nishchitpane eka sambandhit muddah' asatana) jyotishshastra nakarane heey swatach patvoon denare navhate. daad humanist' chya pudhil aavruttit prakashit jhalelya patrat, sagan yanni pushti kelee qee, jyotishshastriy shraddhechya pramukh tattvanche varnan aanee khandan kele asate tarr asha vidhanavar swakshari karnyas teey tayar jhaale asate. heey adhik munn valavanare tharale asate aanee tyamule qamee vaad nirman jhaale asate, assa yuktivad tyanni keela.
edward doubleu sarkhya arth nishchit karnyasathi macrocosum aanee microcosumchya sankalpananvar aadharit kavyatmak pratimancha vapar, "varpramane khalee". jamesche 'varcha mangal laal aahe, mhanoon khalicha mangal mhanje rakt aanee yuddh' heey udaharan, eka chukiche kaaran aahe.
jyotishshastra heey vaidnyanik aahe assa dawa anek jyotishi karatat. jarr konee teey vaidnyanikdrushtya samajavun sanganyacha prayatna keela tarr keval chaar moolbhut shakti (paramparik) aahet, jyaa sambhavya naisargik yantranechya nivadila maryadit karatat. kahee jyotishanni vidyutchumbakiyata aanee gurutvakarshan yasarkhya paramparik karanatmak ghatakancha prastav mandala aahe. yaa shaktinchi takad antaranusar qamee hote. shastradnya yaa prastavit yantrananna avishvasaniy mhanoon nakartat, udaharanarth, jupitersarkhya mothya parantu durchya grahache chumbakeey kshetra jevha pruthvivarun mojale jaate, tevha teey samanya gharguti upkarananni tayar kelelya chumbakeey kshetrapeksha khoopach lahan asate. khagolshastradnya phil playet yanni namood kele qee parimananusar, surya hii ekmev vidyutchumbakiy kshetra asaleli vastoo aahe, parantu jyotishshastra keval suryapasoon door nahee. jyotishi pachvi shakti suchavanyacha prayatna karoo shakatat, parantu heey vidyutchumbakiyateche ekikaran aanee kamkuvat shaktiche vidyutbalamadhye ekikaran yasah bhautikshastratil kalanshi visangat aahe. jarr jyotishi bhautikshastrachya sadhyachya samajutishi aanee puravyachya aadharasah visangat asalyacha aagrah dharala, tarr too eka vilakshan dawa asel. antaranusar khalee padananya itar shaktinshihi teey visangat asel. jarr antar aprasangik asel tarr tarkikdrushtya, antaralatil serve vastoo vicharat ghetalya pahijet.
carl jung yanni kelelya ekach abhyasatoon jyotishshastravar sankhyikiyadrushtya mahattvapoorn parinamancha abhav spasht karnyasathi, done ghatanancha kahee prakarcha acausal sambandh aahe yaa davyacha, samanvay sadhanyacha prayatna keela. tathapi, swatah samkramakta hii chachani karnyayogya kinwa chukichi manali jaat nahee. tyanantar yaa abhyasavar tyachya yadruchchik nasalelya namunyasathi aanee sankhyikicha vapar aanee jyotishshastrashi susangatatechya abhavasathi jordar teeka karnyat aalee.
manasshastra.
heey dekhil disun aale aahe qee pushti purvagrah haah eka mansik ghatak aahe joou jyotishshastravaril vishvasat yogdan deto. pushtikaran purvagrah haah sandnyanatmak purvgrahancha eka prakar aahe.
sahityanusar, jyotishshastravar vishvas thevanare lock anekada nivadinusar tyaa bhakitanchi aathvan thevatat jeey kharey tharale aanee jeey khote tharale teey tyanna aathavat naheet. pushti purvagrah aanakhi eka vegala prakar dekhil eka bhoomika bajavate, jithe vishvasanare sahasa vishesh kshamata darshavina sandeshanmadhye aanee nasalelya sandeshanmadhye farak karnyat ayashasvi hotat.
asha prakare pushti purvgrahanche done vegale prakar aahet jyancha jyotishiy shraddhechya sandarbhat abhyas keela jaat aahe.
barnum effect mhanje ekhadya vyaktichi tyanchya vyaktimatvachya varnanasathi uchch achookata moolyankan denyachi pravrutti jee tyanchyasathi visheshtah tayar kelee gelee aahe, parantu pratyakshat, lokanchya vistrut shrenila lagoo karnyasathi aspasht aanee samanya aahe. andajasathi adhik mahitichi vinanti kelee gelee tarr parinam swikaranare lock titkech jaast asatat.
1949 madhye bertram forrerne tyachya vargatil vidyarthyanvar vyaktimatva chachani ghetali. pratyek vidyarthyache vaiyaktik moolyankan kele jaat asey, parantu pratyakshat serve vidyarthyanna samaan moolyankan midale. vyaktimatvache varnan jyotishshastravaril pustakatoon ghetale gele hote. jevha vidyarthyanna chachanichya achukatevar bhashya karnyas sangitale gele, tevha 40 takkyanhun adhik lokanni tyala 5 paiki 5 guna midvoon sarvoch sthan dile aanee sarasari moolyankan 4.2 hote. yaa abhyasache parinam itar anek abhyasanmadhye punaravrutti karnyat aale aahet.
kothar/agragami parinamacha abhyas mukhytah banavat janmakundali aanee banavat jyotishshastriy vyaktimatva profilechya swikrutichya patalivar kendrit aahe. yaa vyaktimatva mulyankananche praptakarte nehmi samanya aanee asamanya vyaktimatva varnankartyanmadhye farak karnyat apayashi tharatat. paul roggers aanee jenis soul (2009) yanni kelelya abhyasat, jeey yaa vishayavaril mageel sanshodhanashi susangat hote, asey aadhalun aale qee jyotishshastravar vishvas thevanare samanyatah sanshayvadyanpeksha kothar profilela adhik vishvas denyas adhik sanvedanshil asatat.
aatm-samarpan mhanoon olakhalya jaananya prakriyedvare, anek abhyasanmadhye asey disun aale aahe qee jyotishshastrache dnyan asalelya vyakti tyanchya vyaktimatvache varnan tyanchya surya chinhashi susangat asalelya vaishishtyanchya drushtine karatat. jyotishshastrachi charcha karnyasathi vyaktimatvache varnan vaparale jaat aahe heey jevha vyaktinna maheet hote tevha parinam vadhato. jyotishshastrashi parichit nasalelya vyaktinmadhye ashee konatihi pravrutti navhati.
samajshastra.
1953 madhye samajshastradnya theoder doubleu. bhandavalshahi samajatil jansanskrutiche parikshan karananya prakalpacha eka bhag mhanoon organone losses angelis vruttapatrachya jyotish stambhacha abhyas keela. organocha assa vishvas hota qee lokpriy jyotishshastra, eka sadhan mhanoon, nehmi anurupatela protsahan denari vidhane dete-aanee jeey jyotishi kamachya thikani kamgiri ii. laa nirutsahit karananya vidhananchya anurupatechya virodhat gele. nokri gamavanyacha dhoka hota. alenaro yanni assa nishkarsh kadhala qee jyotishshastra heey paddhatshir atarkikateche mothya pramanat prakatikaran aahe, jithe chatukarpana aanee aspasht samanyikarananmule vyaktinni sookshmapane stambh lekhakane tyanna thet sambodhit kele yavar vishvas thewala. carl marksney lihilelya 'afoo auph daad pipal' yaa vakyanshala 'orgeno' neey samantar bhashya kele, 'jadutona haah madak padarthancha adhibhautik aahe."
madhyamatil vruttant aanee durchitravanivaril karyakramanmadhye yogya tarkyukt drushtikonasobat khota, asvikarya kinwa banavat drushtikon samavisht keela jaato aanee parinami khota samtol soochit karato qee, "jevha spashtapane katha navhati tevha tichya done samaan bajoo hotya". bii. bii. see. chya 'saurmandalache chamatkar' yaa durchitravani karyakramadarmyan, bhautikshastradnya bryan cocks mhanaleh 'jyotishshastra haah kachyacha bhaar asala taree, jupitarcha aaplya grahavar kholvar prabhav padoo shakato. aanee teey eka shaktidvare aahe... gurutvakarshan."jyane takrar kelee qee paryayi drushtikon denyasathi konatahi jyotishi nahee, asha jyotishshastravaril vishvasananna heey aswasth karate. jyotishshastravar vishvas thevananchya takrarinnantar, coxney bii. bii. see. laa khaleel vidhan dileh "mea swatahla spasht naan kelyabaddal jyotish samudayachi maafee magto. mea heey sangayala havey hote qee, navya yugacha haah veg aaplya sanskratichya sanrachanelach kamkuvat karat aahe."stargazing live" yaa karyakramat coxney pudhe tippani keleeh "bii. bii. see. vareel santulanachya hitasathi, hoy jyotish haah murkhapana aahe."bmj" yaa vaidyakeey niyatkalikatil eka sampadakiyat, sampadak traver jackson yanni yaa ghatanecha hawala dett mhatale aahe qee kuthe chukiche santulan nirman houu shakate.
pashchimatya deshanmadhye jyotishshastravaril vishvas itar apeksha karnyapeksha jaast asalyache abhyas aanee matdanatoon disun aale aahe. 2012 madhye jhalelya sarvekshanat 42 takke american lokanni sangitale qee tyanna jyotishshastra kiman anshatah vaidnyanik aahe asey vatate. shikshan aanee shikshanamule hii shraddha qamee jhaali aahe aanee tyacha vaidnyanik dnyanachya patalishi atyant paraspar sambandh aahe.
nondavalelya vishvasachya kahee patali khagolshastrashi (khagoliy vastooncha vaidnyanik abhyas) asalelya "jyotishshastrachya" gondhalamule aahet. donhi shabdanchi jawalik bhashenusar badalate. taare, grah ityadincha gupt prabhav" mhanoon jyotishshastrache spasht varnan. 1992 chya euro barometerchya sarvekshanat jyotishshastra vaidnyanik aahe qee nahee yaa samanya janatechya mulyankanavar manvi babinvar konatahi parinam jhaala nahee. heey anshatah samanya lokanmadhil antarnihit sambandhamule, dnyanachya vaidh kshetrashi '-vidnyan' madhye samapt honanya konatyahi shabdachya sambandhamule asoo shakate. 2004 madhye kelelya eurobarometer 224 aanee 225 madhye, shabdalekhanavaril gondhal vegala karnyasathi vibhajan sarvekshan vaparale gele. ardhyahun adhik matdananmadhye 'jyotish' haah shabd vaparla gela, tarr dusya matdanat 'kundali' haah shabd vaparla gela. jyotishshastra kiman anshatah vaidnyanik aahe assa vishvas 76 takke hota, parantu janmakundali kiman anshatah vaidnyanik aahet assa vishvas 43 takke hota. jyotishshastra atishay vaidnyanik hote assa vishvas visheshtah 26 takke hota tarr janmakundalicha 7 takke hota. heey asey soochit karate qee european unionmadhil jyotishshastrasathi uchch patalivaril matdan samarthan heey shabdprayogavaril gondhalamule hote.