
thinmayude chihnam

2008ll david jii. ezhuthiya aikkan oof eevil hitlers muftiyum theevra islaamikathayude uyarchayumaan. dallin, joonn eph. rathman aadyam random house aanu prasidheekarichathu; edapaadu prasaadhakarude pusthakatthinte 2009 pathippin alaan dershovitsinte oru aamukhamundu. britiish bharanakaalathu jarusaleminte grand mufthiyaayirunna hajj amin alle-hussaini (1895-1974) yude jeevacharithramaanith. niravadhi vasthuthaparamaaya pishakukal choondikkaatti, mufthiyil ninnu aadhunika islaamika nethaakkalilekku oru nerittulla konkreett edukkaamenna athinte prabandhathe avishwasaneeyavum thelivukalude abhaavavumaanennu vimarshichukond chila niroopakar athinte "parasyamaaya prachaarana" sailiye vimarshichu. mattu niroopakar eee pusthakatthe prashamsichu, oraal ithine "14 varshathinide prathyakshappedunna mufthiyude aadyathe gauravameriya jeevacharitram" ennu visheshippichu.
sangraham.
oru pradhana jarusalem arab kudumbatthile amgamaaya hussini oru yahooda virudhanaayum aadhunika arab lokathe yahooda virudha manobhaavangal nalkunnathil pradhana vyakthiyayum eee pusthakam chithreekarikkunnu. adolph hitlar, hajj aamin alle-hussaini, sayyid qutub, yasser arafat ennivar muthal hamaasinte sthaapakanum athmeeya nethaavumaaya sheikh ahamed yassin, sheikh omar abdul-rahman, 1993 leeii waled trade sentar bombakramanam aasoothranam cheytha rumsey yousef, osaama biinn laadan, mohammed attaa, osaama biinn laadan, mohammed omarid sheikh, yuu thattikkondupokaanum vadhikkanum padhathiyitta pakistani musleem theevravaadiyaaya ahamed omarid sheikh ennivar vareyulla thakarkkappedaatha bheekarathayude shringhala"-yessarinte kaazhchappaadukal mikkavarum ellah aadhunika middle eestten bheekaravaadathinum "casus bellie" aanennu athu avakaashappedunnu.ezz. pathrapravartthakanaaya danielle pell, iranian president mahmoud ahmedinejad ennivarkku."
avalokanangal.
"thinmayude chinnathinu" chila niroopakaril ninnu sakthamaaya vimarsanaathmaka prathikaranam labhichu. saan francisco chronicle" ezhuthiyittulla saiman maxwell apter, "islaamikamaaya enthinum" muftik mail kuttam chumathanamenna nirbandhathinu "sarsari, prathyakshatthil thidukkathil ezhuthiya", "" sookshumathayo ethirvaadamo illaatha "" ennu pusthakatthe visheshippikkunnu. joothavirudha akramathinu prerippikkunnathil hussaini theerchayaayum oru pradhana punk vahichittundennu amgeekarichukondu, "thinmayude chihnam" charithratthinte valachodicha lalithavalkkaranam avatharippikkunnuvennu apter nigamanam cheiyunnu "thinmayude chihnam charithrathekkurichulla karuppum veluppum kaazhchappaadine varaykkunnu ennu avakaashappedunnathu pusthakathinu valareyadhikam neethi nalkunnu; ithu ivide paranjirikkunna poornnamaayum karuthatho poornnamaayum veluthatho aaya kathayaanu."
israeli charitrakaaranaaya toom segev, "newyork timesil" ezhuthumbol, eee pusthakatthe "pandithamoolyamillaatham [ithu] middle eest samadhana saadhyathakalkk haanikaravumaayirikkumenn" vimarshichu."sakthamaaya thelivukal nalkunnathile rachayithaakkalude sthiramaaya parajayam segev eduthukaanikkunnu, udaaharanathinu, oru muthirnna britiish udyogasthanumaayulla" "vikarabharithamaaya swavarganuraga bandhathinu" "hussaini thante sthaanathinu kadappettirikkunnuvennum ezhuthukaar" "theevra islam, yahoodavirudhatha, nassism" "ennee padangal ethratholam mangikkunnu ennum niravadhi arabikaleyum musleengaleyum" "mufthiyude shishyanmar" "aayi koottikkalartthunnu ennumulla abhyoohangalude adisthaanathil"."addeham upasamharikkunnu" "[tii] eee pusthakam sradhikkendathaanu, kaaranam ithu 'israelinu nallath' ennu palappozhum vishwasikkappedunna janapriya arab-bashing vibhaagathil pedunnu".'anganeyalla. israayelinte sathrukkal naasikalaanenno naasikalude anantharaavakaashikalaanenno ulla nirddesham palastheeniyakkaarumaayi nyayamaaya othutheerppine niruthsaahappeduthunnathu anuyojyamaanu, athu israelinu doshakaramaanu."
israeli charitrakaaranaaya bennie morris, "pradhanappetta aduppangalil viral choondunnathinu" rachayithaakkale prashamsikkunnu, ennaal avarude kruthiyude gunanilavaaratthe vimarsikkukayum 'thinmayude prateeka' thhe oru "mosham pusthakam" ennu visheshippikkukayum cheiyunnu "avar theerchayaayum amithamaayi athicherunnu, avarude paandithyatthinte daaridryam kanakkiledukkumbol, avar palappozhum bodhyappeduthunnathil paraajayappedunnu, ithu vaayanakkaarane prachaaranatthinte mosham ruchikk vidheyaraakkunnu."avar" "paandithyathaal allah, marichu parasyamaaya prachaarana lakshyangalaal kashtappedunnu" ennu addeham abhipraayappedunnu. avar nirantharam oru prathyayashaasthra drum adikkunnu. avarude naamavisheshathakal oru sammaanamaan. oro semit virudha allengil semittik virudha vaachakavum 'vairalant' allengil 'kuprasidhamaanu.'eee pusthakam' vasthuthayude pishakukalaal niranjirikkunnu, naasikal randaam lokamahaayudhathil vijayikkukayum hussaini sahaayathode palasteen joothanmaare unmoolanam cheyyukayum cheytha oru virudha vastutha charithrathilekku rachayithaakkalude vyathichalanathe 'ashleelam' ennu morris vivarikkunnu. ithokkeyaanengilum, "[pusthakam] parayunnathil bhooribhaagavum sathyasandhavum krithyavumaanu" ennu morris anuvadikkunnu." 
washington timesinte" jaims sroads "" thinmayude pratheekatthe "" islaamisavum hitlarum thammilulla samshayaaspadamaaya bandhangal varachukondu "charitraparamaaya paryaveshanathinu saadhuvaaya oru vazhi edukkaanum athinte vilpanaye pracharippikkanum ulla mattoru sramamaayi" visheshippikkunnu ". britiish bharanathilulla palastheenil jootha virudha kalaapangalum kolapaathakangalum pottippurappeduthunnathu hussaini vahicha punk shradhichukondu, hussaini katha "swasthikakal upayogichu embroidery cheyyaathe thanne pradhaanamaan" ennu sroads abhipraayappedunnu. ennirunnaalum, "valia kathaye aashayakkuzhappathilaakkunna" "lajjakaramaaya hype" ennaanu addeham kathaye rachayithaakkalude avatharanathe vimarshikkunnath... adolph hitlaril ninnu alle-hussainik thudarnnu addehathinte akanna bandhuvaya yasser arafaathinum oru nerittulla rekha varaykkaan sramikkuka, sadaam hussain."
"kirkas avalokanangal" samaanamaayi vimarsanaathmakamaanu, rachayithakkal vipulamaaya archival gaveshanam nadathiyittundengilum "" avarude pusthakam sankeernamaaya scholarshippinte oru bhagamalla "" ennum "" israel anukoola sthaanangal "" sweekarikkunnu ". randaam lokamahaayudhathinte apoorvamaayi padicha oru vashathekurichulla ulkkazhchayulla parisodhana-islaamika rashtreeya partykaludeyum middle eest bharanakoodangaludeyum naasikalumayulla sahakaranm-[eiii] enna reethiyilaan pusthakam aarambhikkunnath, [ennaal] navasamrakshaka lokaveekshanathinu oru hraswa roopamaayi athivegam parinamikkunnu."rachayithakkal" "samshayaaspadamaaya vishalamaaya vishakalanavum" "" "charitrapusthakangalil saadhaaranayaayi kaanunnathinekkaal kooduthal oohaapohangalum" "avatharippikkunnu".
mattu niroopakar pusthakatthe anukoolamaayi kandu. dhii washington times' enna pusthakatthile martin seef 'rachayithakkal eee katha vivekathodeyum nannayi parayukayum' cheiyunnu, koodaathe eee pusthakatthe 'vilappettathum' '14 varshathinide prathyakshappedunna mufthiyude aadyathe gauravameriya jeevacharitram' ennum visheshippikkunnu. pusthakam valare cheruthaanennum jarmman aarkkaivukalil ninnulla vasthukkal ulppeduthiyittillenum addehathinte pradhana vimarsanam, vipuleekaricha randaam pathipp upayogichu pariharikkan rachayithaakkale prothsaahippikkanamenna addeham nirddeshikkunnu.
jerusalem posttil" ezhuthumbol, jonathan shancer kooduthal anukoolamaaya oru veekshanam edukkunnu, "thinmayude pratheekatthe" "naasikalumayulla hussaini bandhathekkurichum moonnaamathe reykkile apakadakaramaaya pankinekkurichum oru" asaadhaarana "charitramaayi visheshippikkukayum" 1940 kalile kolapathaka naasi prathyayashaasthravum innathe thalakkettukalil aadhipathyam pulartthunna kolapathaka jihadi prathyayashaasthravum thammilulla niravadhi samanathakal thirichariyukayum cheiyunnu."ennirunnaalum, morisineppole addeham ezhuthukaarante ethir vasthuthaasambandhamaaya charithrathilekkulla vazhithirivine vimarsikkukayum athine" "anaavasyamaaya sparsham" "ennu vilikkukayum cheiyunnu"."
jonathan ezz. sameepa dashakangalil thanikk labhichathinekkaal valare kooduthal shradha arhikkunna oru vyakthiyekkurich shradha kendreekarikkaan" sramichathinu jootha vakthavaaya tobin rachayithaakkale abhinandikkunnu, ennaal avarude "yadhaartha gaveshanathinte abhavam", "chilappol arivillaatha oohaapohangal", "eee vishayathil nilavilulla saahityathinu kaaryamaaya moolyam nalkaatha gurutharamaaya oohaapohangal", prathyekichu vastuta virudha charithratthinte "prathyekichu shalyappeduthunna" upayogam ennivaye vimarshikkunnu. ennirunnaalum, addeham upasamharikkunnu "kurravukal undaayirunnittum, arab-israel samgharshathinte charithratthil mathramalla, muslim lokathinte samskaarathilum hussaini oru pradhana vyakthiyaanennu nigamanam cheyyumbol dallin, rathman ennivarude pusthakam lakshyamidunnu."
britiish ezhuthukaaranaaya david prais-johns, hussaini yude swantham oormmakkurippukal ulppede "jarmman, arabic bhaashakalile vipulamaaya saahityam avaganichukondu" "thinmayude chihnam" poornnamaayum engleesh srothassukale aashrayikkunnuvenn abhipraayappedunnu. deerghamaaya kopam, mattenthinekkaalum theevramaaya tharkkamaan eee pusthakam."oraalkk sangalppikkaan kazhiyunna ',' cheria samshayamundaakaam ',' oohikkaan asaadhyamalla 'ennee vaakyangal ore pejil drishyamaakunna [ing] oohaapohangalil ithu earppedunnu."
joonn aarr. middle eestten kaaryangalekkurichulla ezhuthukaaranaaya bradley, "straits timesil" abhipraayappedunnathu, alle-hussainic anthima parihaarathekkurichu ariyamaayirunnuvennum prothsaahippichuvennum neurembergil oru yudhakkuttavaaliyaayi vichaarana cheyyappedendathaayirunnum eee pusthakam bodhyappeduthunna oru cases undaakkunnu ennaanu."ennirunnaalum, pusthakatthinte randaam pakuthi" "asambandhavum svayam virudhavumaaya oru sramamaanu", "athu" "sarikkum mosham scholarship moolam kooduthal durbalappeduthunnu"."israelinekkurichulla ellah vimarsanangaleyum yahoodavirudhathayumaayi bandhippikkuka ennathaanu rachayithaakkalude prachodanamennu addeham nirddeshikkunnu, athinaal alle-khwaydaykkum athinte anubandha sthaapanangalkkum phalapradamaayi pinthuna nalkunna seonisathekkurichulla ellah vimarsanangalum parokshamaayi apalapikkuka", koodaathe "thinmayude aikkan" "oru asamskritha prathyayashaasthra ajanda prolsaahippikkaan maathram upayogikkunnavar charithrathe engane valachodikkunnu ennathinte udaaharanamaayi ettavum upayogapradamaanennu addeham nigamanam cheiyunnu."
american maasikayaaya "waled" edittar marvin olaaski, ezhuthukaaraaya daline rathman avarude pusthakathekkurichu abhimukham nadatthi, prathyekichu alle-hussaini "aajeevanantha bheekaravaada sponsorship" enna avakaashavaadathekkurichum alle-hussaini hitlarude "berlinile aantharika vrithathinte" bhaagamaayitheernnuvenna avarude avakaashavaadathekkurichum, voonn rebentrope, himler, aichmaan ennivarulppedeyulla unnatha naasi nethaakkalumaayi chernnu pravartthikkukayum avarude avakaashavaadangalodum nigamanangalodum yojikkukayum cheythu.

