
nyoojezhsi vii. dharoon ravee

stettu oof nyoojezhsi vezhsas. 2012 februvari 24 muthal 2012 march 16 vare nyoojezhsiyile middlesex kaundiyil nadanna criminal vichaaranayayirunnu dharoon raavi, athil muun ratjezhs yooniversitti biruda vidyaarthi dharoon ravi svakaaryathayude kadannukayattam, svakaaryathayude kadannukayattam, pakshapatha bheeshanippeduthal, thelivukalil krithrimam, saakshikalil krithrimam, bhayappeduthalino prosecutiono thadassappedutthal ennivayulppede 15 kuttakrithyangalil vichaarana cheyyukayum shikshikkukayum cheythu.
2010 septambar 19,21 theeyathikalil nadanna sambhavangalil ninnaan kuttangal udaleduthathu. 2016 septambar 9 nuu nyoojezhsi appeel kodathi shikshavidhi asaadhuvaakkukayum churungiya kuttangalil puthiya vichaaranaykk utharavidukayum cheythu. adutha maasam, raavi oru harji edapaadu amgeekarikkukayum svakaaryathaye akramikkaan shramichathinte oru kesil kuttam sammathikkukayum cheythu.
aadya sambhavathil, raaviyude roommett tailar klementtiyum "emm" ennu maathram thirichariyappedunna mattoru vyakthiyum thammilulla swakaarya pranaya ettumuttal kaanaan raviyum suhruthu mollie veyiyum oru webcam upayogichu.bii."
randaamathe sambhavathil, thante webcamiloode klementtiyum emm.bii.ennirunnaalum, kazhcha orikkalum sambhavichilla. 2010 septambar 22nuu klementi aathmahathya cheyyukayum addehathinte maranam raaviyude vichaaranayilekku deseeya anthardesheeya shradha aakarshikkukayum cheythu.
2012 meyy 21nuu ravikk 30 divasathe jayil shiksha, 3 varshathe probation, 300 manikkoor community sarvees, 10,000 dollar pizha, saibar bheeshanippeduthalinekkuru ithara jeevithashailikalekkurichum kaunsiling ennivaykku shiksha vidhichu. 2012 meyy 31 muthal juun 19 vare nyoojezhsiyile north brunswickile middlesex kaundi adult corrections sentaril 30 divasathe jayil shikshayil 20 divasam raavi chelavazhichu.
kuttaaropitharkkum vichaaranaykkum edayaakkunna sambhavangal.
aadyathe webcam sambhavam.
2010 septambar 17nuu munbu, klementi aidantitti parasyamaakkiyittillatha oralumaayi oonlainil chaatt cheythirunnu. septambar 17nuu raavi vaikunneram purathaayirunnappol, aaa manushyan aadyamaayi klementtiyude doorr roomil vannu.
septambar 19,21 theeyathikalil klementi ravikk vaikunnerathekku avarude murii upayogikkunnathinekkur sandesham ayachu. aadya avasarathil, ravee klementtiyude purusha suhruthine kandumuttukayum vaikunneram iruvarum ottaykkaayirikkaan aagrahikkunnuvennu klementti parayukayum cheythu. veyiyumaayulla sambhaashanathilum pinneedu suhruthukkalumaayulla vaachaka sandeshangalilum, klementi muriyilekku konduvanna aparichithane "prayamaaya, moshamaayi kaanapedunna oraal" ennu visheshippichukondu ravee avishwaasam prakadippichu.
moshanathekkurichu aashankayundennum aaa aashankakal kaaranam webcam kaanaan kazhiyunna avasthayilaanu thaan computer vittathennum raavi paranju. ennirunnaalum, klementi swavarggaanuraagiyaanenna sthireekarikkanamennu raviyum paranjathaayi mattu sakshikal saakshyappeduthi. raviyum veyiyum kurachu sekkantukal ichaatt vazhi viidiyoo stream kandu, klementtiyum athidhiyum chumbikkunnath kandu. raavi thante 150 twittar pholoversinodu poost cheythu, "roommett ardharaathri vare murii aavasyappettu. njaan moliyude muriyil chennu webcam oonaakki. avan oru suhruthumaayi edapazhakunnathu njaan kandu. yaay."taamasiyaathe, veyu oru oonlain chaatt aarambhichu, athil avar paranju," "iruvarum ippol parasparam chumbikkunnu/avar parasparam thodunnathu pole"."pinneedu, ravee avide illaayirunnengilum muriyil mattu naalu perkkoppam mattoru kaazhchaykkaayi veyu camera oonaakki. eee randaamathe kaazhchayil, klementtiyum athidhiyum avarude sharttukal ooriyum paants dharichum chumbikkunnath veyiyum mattullavarum kandu.
tvittariloode clementi ravi pinthudarnnu. raaviyude phoon sandeshangal kaanaan clementic kazhinjillengilum pittennu addeham thante twittar posttukal kandu. aadyathe webcam kaazhchaykk sesham 38 thavana raviyude twittar posttukal klementi kandu. septambar 20nuu klementi oonlainil oru suhruthinu ezhuthiyathu, thudakkathil, raavi aadya, hraswa kaazhchayil kanda kaaryangalil thanikk sarikkum vishamam thonniyilla, pradhaanamaayum athinte angeyattatthe hraswata kaaranam. oru ratjezhs jeevanakkaaran parayunnathanusarichu, ekadesham 4 manikk.emm. septambar 21 nuu, oonlainil kooduthal sambhaashanangalkk sesham, klementi orotta murikku oru oonlain abhyarthana ayachu, kaaranam addehathinte "roommett enne chaarappani cheyyaan webcam upayogichu."
randaamathe aasootritha webcam kazhcha.
septambar 21 nuu, raavi oru suhruthinu "athe, swavarggaanuraagikale akattinirtthuka", "aalukal ente roommettinaayi eee kuttiyude muriyil oru kuppi buccardy bear upayogichu oru viewing party nadathunnu" ennee sandeshangal ulppede niravadhi tekst sandeshangal ayachu.
vaikunneram 6.39nuu.emm.ichaatt ulla aarkkenkilum 9.30 num 12 num idayil viidiyoo chaatt cheyyaan njaan ningale dhairyappeduthunnu. athe, athu veendum sambhavikkunnu."ravee webcam sajjeekarikkukayum aadyam athu klementtiyude kidakkayilekku choondikkaanikkukayum cheythirunnu. thante "thamasha" "viddithamaanennu thaan manassilakkiyennum septambar 21nuu aasoothranam cheytha kaazhchaykk munbu webcam swantham kidakkayilekku choondikkaanichathaayum raavi paranju. ennirunnaalum, pinneedu athu klementiyude kidakkayilekku nerittu choondiyathaayi kandethiyathayi police parayunnu. klementtiyum athidhiyum thante kidakka upayogikkaamenn raaviyude suhruthu nirddeshichappol, raavi paranju, "ente webcam ente kidakka parishodhikkunnu, hahaha."
vichaaranaykkide, rund rutger vidyaarthikal raavi aaa vaikunnerathinte oru bhagam avarude doorr murikalil chelavazhichathaayi saakshyappeduthukayum webcam ippozhum kidakkayil kendreekarichirikkunnu parisodhikkaan avarude computerukal upayogikkukayum cheythu. raaviyude aathyanthika frisby teaminte kyapttan, annu vaikunneram parisheelanathinu sesham, thante roommettinte chithrangal edukkaan eathenkilum tharatthilulla webcam sajjeekarichathayi ravee ennodu paranjathaayi saakshyappeduthi. aaa theeyathikku munbu thaan ithu cheythuvennum "athu veendum cheyyaan padhathiyidukayaanennum addeham ennodu paranju. aaa ratri."klementi thante muriyilekku madangiyethiyappol, camera shradhikkukayum raaviyude powerstrip anplug cheythathayi oru suhruthinu sandesham ayaykkukayum cheythu. prakshepanathekkurichu thaan manass mattiyathaayum computer sleep modil vechukondu camera svayam pravarthanarahithamaakkiyathaayum ravee paranju.
septambar 21nuu, mattoru purushanumaayulla klementtiyude swakaarya laingika ettumuttalinte oru bhagam viidiyoo stream cheyyaan ravee oru webcam upayogichathayi klementi oru resident asisttantinum mattu rund udyogastharkkum parati nalki. ratri 11 maniyode kandumuttiyappol klementi asthiravum aswasthavumaanennu resident asisttant vichaaranaykkunere saakshyappeduthi.emm.resident asisttant thante audyogika reportil paranju, raviykku murii mattaanum shiksha nalkaanum klementi abhyarthichu.
koodikkazhchaykku sesham resident asisttantinu ayacha aupachaarika iii-meyil abhyarthanayil, raaviyude twittar posttukalil ninnu udharicha rund kazhcha sambhavangal vivaricha klementi ezhuthi, "ente svakaaryatha lamghikkappettathaayi enikku thonnunnu, eee anuchithamaya reethiyil pravartthikkunna oralumaayi oru murii pankidunnathil enikku angeyattam aswasthathayundu."just yuu. ezz. boisinekkurichum yaahuu! thante roomettinekkurichu yooniversitti chaanalukaliloode addeham nalkia paraathikalekkurichu sandesha boardukal. aadya sambhavathekkurichu arinjathinushesham raviyumaayi oru murii pankidaan thaan aagrahikkunnillennum thudarnnu randaamathe laingika ettumuttal kaanaan ravee thante twittar pholoversine shanichathaayi kandethiyennum addehathinte posttukal soochippikkunnu. "addeham [resident asisttant] athu gauravamaayi edukkunnathaayi thonni", jorjju washington paalatthil ninnu chaadunnathinu ekadesham 15 manikkoor munbu klementi oru posttil ezhuthi.
septambar 22nuu raaviyude oru suhruthu thaledivasam ratri thalsamaya sampreshanathinu enthaanu sambhavichathenn chodichu. ravee marupadi paranju, "athu kuzhappathilaayi, pravarthichilla."uchakazhinju, resident asisttant klementtiyude rekhaamoolamulla paraathiyekkurichu ravi nerittu, athil addeham murii maattaan abhyarthichu. eathaanum manikkoorukalkullil, klementi thante doorr muriyilekku madangukayum adhehavum raviyum oru manikorinullil avide athukayum cheythu.
clementi athmahathyayum raaviyude shamayum.
septambar 22nuu vaikunneram, raaviyude randaamathe webcam transmission shramathinte pittennu, klementi doorr roomil ninnu puratthirangi, bhakshanam vaangi, vaikunneram ekadesham 6:30.emm.jorjju washington paalatthilekku neengi. ratri 8.42nuu.emm.klementi jorjju washington bridjilekku pookukayum thante sell phonil ninnu facebookil poost cheyyukayum cheythu, "shamikkanam, jii. dablyu bridjil ninnu chaadunnu."
klementi facebookil poost cheyth anchu minittinusesham, avasaanathe rund sandeshangalil aadyathethu ravee clementic ayachu. annu uchathirinju resident asisttant ravi sandarshikkukayum klementtiyude paraathiyekkurichu parayukayum cheythathinu sheshamaan sandeshangal ayachathu
"enthaanu sambhavichathenn vishadeekarikkaan njaan aagrahikkunnu. njaayarazhcha ratri ningal aareyengilum koode konduvaraan aavashyappettappol ningalkk aaa murii svakaaryamaayi venamennu njaan arinjilla. njaan moliyude muriyil pooyi, evide ninnum axus cheyyaan kazhiyunna vidhathil njaan ente computer engane sajjeekarichuvennu avale kaanikkukayayirunnu. njaan ente camera oonaakki screeninte moolayilvechu ningale kandu, njaan udan thanne athu adachu. sambhavichathil enikku aswasthathayum kuttabodhavum thonni. enikku upadesham nalkaan vendi enthaanu sambhavichathenn njaan aalukalodu paranju. chovvazhcha ningal veendum murii abhyarthichappol njaayarazhcha sambhavichathu veendum sambhavikkillennum 930 muthal 12 vare viidiyoo chaatt cheyyillennum urappakkaan njaan aagrahichu. aarenkilum sramichaalum athu pravarthikkaathirikkaan njaan ente camera thirinj ente computer urangaan vechaal maathram. njaayarazhcha raathriyil thiruthalukal varuthaan njaan aagrahichu. ningal valachodikkappettathum aswasthathayundaakkunnathu enthengilum kettittundengil shamikkanam, pakshe ente ellah pravartthanangalum nalla swabhaavamullavayaayirunnuve njaan ningalkk urappu nalkunnu."
ruttermar achadakkam nerittathayi ravi arinjathine thudarnnaanu mapp paranjathennu prosecution abhiprayappettu. vasthuthakal durbalappeduthunnathinum marachuvekkunnathinum vishadeekarikkunnathinumallu raaviyude "niravadhi sramangalil" onnaanu mapp parayunnathennu prosecutor juuliya mcclure paranju, mattoru vidhathil paranjaal vasthuthakal krithrimam cheiyunnathinum thanikk anukoolamaayi kaananakunna thelivukal kettichamaykkunnathinum."
patthu minittinusesham ravee veendum sandesham ayachu
kuttaaropithar.
2010 septambar 19num 2010 septambar 21num webcam chaarapravartthanangalil panku vahichathin 2010 septambar 28nuu dharoon ravikkum mollie veyikkum ethire yathaakramam naalum randum svakaaryathayude adhinivesham aaropichirunnu.
nyoojezhsi niyamaprakaaram, oraal aaa vyakthiyude sammathamillaathe mattoru vyakthiye nireekshikkukayaanenkil oraal svakaaryathayude naalam digri kuttakrithyam cheiyunnu, "yukthisahamaya oru vyakthikk matoraal aduppamulla bhagangal thurannukaattiyekkamenna ariyamaayirikkum allengil laingika nuzhanjukayattathilo laingika bandhatthilo earppedaam."nireekshikkappetta vyakthiyude" "prathichaayayude punarnirmmaanam" "oraal velippeduthukayaanenkil oru moonnaam digri kuttakrithyam nadakkunnu". svakaaryathayude moonnaam, naalam digri adhiniveshathinu raavikkethire kuttam chumatthi.
eee kuttangal phayal cheythathinu thottupinnaale, raviykkum veyikkum athireyulla vidvesha kuttakrithyangal ulppeduthaan swavarganuraga avakasha abhibhaashakaril ninnum bloggermaaril ninnum kolukal vannu.
ippol rund vyakthikalkkethire svakaaryathayude kadannukayattathinu keseduthittundu, sambhavathil pakshapaatham oru punk vahichittundo ennu vilayiruthaan njangal ellah sramangalum nadatthum, anganeyaanengil, njangal uchithamaaya kuttangal konduvarum", ennu kesile prosecutor broose cuplan paranju."2010 october 4 nuu, ravikkum veyikkum ethire vidvesha kuttakrithyam chumathaan mathiyaya thelivukal undaakumenn thaan karuthunnillennu cuplan prasthaavichu. kooduthal anweshanathinu sesham, ravikk ethire vidvesha kuttakrithyam nadathiyenna kuttatthinu thelivukalundennu prosecution nigamanam cheythu, athu raavi klementtiyude peru aadyamaayi arinja kaalathe kaaryamaan. pakshapatha bheeshanippeduthal, svakaaryathayude akramanam, saakshikalude krithrimam, thelivu krithrimam ennivayulppede 15 kesukalil 2011 epril 20 nuu oru middlesex kaundi grand juurii ravi kuttappedutthi.
raavi veyikku ayacha vaachaka sandeshangale adisthaanamaakkiyullathaayinu saakshikale krithrimam cheythathinu chumathiya kuttangal, athil thaan policinode paranja kaaryangalkk virudhamaayi pravartthikkaruthennu avale bodhyappedutthaan addeham shramichu. eee sandeshangalil ravee paranju "njangal ithu manappoorvvam cheythathaanennu ningal avarodu paranjo?"," "kaaranam njangal camerayumaayi kaliyaakkukayaanennu njaan paranju."veyu marupadi paranju" "oom dharoon, nee enthukondaanu ennodu aadyam samsaarikkaathath, njaan avarodu ellaam paranju". oru prosecution vidagdha saakshiyude abhipraayathil, taanum veyiyum mattoru haiskool suhruthum thammilulla 100 oolam tekst sandeshangal raavi illaathaakki, avane athidhiyumaayulla klementtiyude randaamathe ettumuttal kaanaan kshanichirunnu. prosecutionte thelivu krithrimam cheythuvenna kuttaaropitharude rund posttukal ravee neekkam cheythathaayirunnu prosecutionte thelivu krithrimam cheythuvenna kuttatthinte oru pradhana vasham septambar 19 nuu tvittaril thante roommett oru suhruthumaayi edapazhakunnuvennu addeham ezhuthi. yaay", "septambar 21 nuu klementiyude pareekshana samayat" enne viidiyoo chaatt cheyyaan dhairyappedoo "ennu addeham thante aichaat anuyaayikalodu paranja oru kaaryam. aadya sandesham oru draaft aanennu prasthaavichu, trasttinte samayat "viidiyoo chaatt cheyyaan dhairyappedaruthu" ennu paranja oru poost addeham randaamathethinu pakaram maatti. svakaaryathayude moonnaam, naalam digri adhiniveshathinu raavikkethire kuttam chumatthi.
prathirodhatthinte pothu prasthavanakal.
veyikkethiraaya aropanangal parasyamakkiya udan, veyiyude abhibhaashakar avalude niraparaadhithvam prakhyaapikkunna oru prasthavana puratthirakki, oru muun nyoojezhsi federal prosecutor abhiprayappettu, "emssinu thelivukalonnumilla. enthum cheiyunnu. enthukondaanu prosecutor avale eathenkilum vidhathilo roopathilo roopathilo misttar enna peril utharavaadiyaakkunnathu ennathinekkurichu enikku valare jijnasayundu. ravee avalude computer upayogikkukayaayirunnu."
raaviyude abhibhashakanaaya steevu altman paranju, "oru computerinu purathu onnum kaimaattam cheyyappettitla, kandathenthaano athu nimishangal maathrame kandulloo."veyyude abhibhashakanaaya rubin sinins paranju," laingika bandhatthinte thelivukalonnum enikkariyilla. laingikabandhathe nirvachikkunna niyamam nagnathayeyum svakaaryabhaagangaleyum soochippikkunnu, ente arivil, atharathilulla onnum kanditilla. eathenkilum viidiyoo record cheiyukayo punarnirmmikkukayo pracharippikkukayo cheythuvennathinu oru thelivum enikkariyilla."
nivedanangal.
2011 meyy 6 nuu veyiyum prosecuter oru harji karaarilethi. karar prakaram, raavikkethire veyu saakshyappeduthukayum kaunsiling, community sarvees ennivayulppede moonnu varshathe edapedal paripadi poortthiyaakkukayum cheythaal veyikkethiraaya ellah kuttangalum pinvalikkum. klementtiyude maathaapithaakkal "niyamavirudhamaanenkilum, avayude pravrithikal avayude swabhaavathilum vyaapthiyilum tailarude muun roommettinte pravarthanangalil ninnu ganyamaayi vyathyasthamaanennum" aval "anweshanathil varaanirikkunnuvennum sahakarikkukayaanennum" vishwasichukondu veyiyude "dayye pinthunachu."
2011 desemberil, jayilil oru samayavum chelavazhikkathirikkaanum naadukadatthaanulla saadhyathayulla utharavukalkkethire poraadaan prosecutor oafees sahayikkaanum ulla oru harji karar raavi nirasichu (raavi amerikkayil niyamaparamaayi thamasikkunna oru indian pouranaanu). harji vyavastha nirasichukondu raaviyude abhibhaashakan ingane paranju "lalithamaaya utharam, lalithamaaya thathwam... avan niraparadhiyaanu. avan kuttakkaaranalla. athukondaanu addeham harji nirasichathu."
vichaarana vaadangalum saakshyapathrangalum.
nyoojezhsi criminal defense niyama sthaapanamaaya benedict & altmanile abhibhaashakar steevan altman philipp nettalum ravi prathinidheekarichu. vichaarana 13 divasam neenduninnappol 2012 march 13nuu avasana vaadangal avasaanichu.
vichaaranaykk munbulla chalanam.
2011 augustil, raaviyude prathibhagam abhibhaashakan oru thettaaya vichaaranaykk abhyarthichu, kaaranam prosecution grand juric thelivukal samarppichittillaathil, athu ravi kuttavimukthanaakkumaayum thettidharippikkunna reethiyilaanennum addeham vaadichu. eee thelivukalil klementi thante computerile fayalukalkku "enthukondaanu ithu ithra vedanaajanakamaakunnathu" ennu sheershakam nalkiyathaayum ruttersil praveshikkunnathinu oru maasam munbu jorjju washington bridjinte phottokal eduthathaayum kaanikkunna rekhakal ulppedunnu. raaviyude prameyam jadji amgeekarichilla. aathmahathyayil ravikkethire oru pankum chumathiyittilla.<rafiyude peru = "20/20 abhimukham"> </rafa>
thuranna vaadangal.
2012 februvari 24nuu asisttant prosecutor juuliya mcclure jurimarode paranju, dharun raavi klementiyude oru aduppamulla ettumuttal nireekshikkukayum pinneedu klementtiyudeyum suhruthudeyum randaamathe bandham kaanaan mattullavare shanikkukayum cheythappol tailar klementiyude "svakaaryatha", "anthass" enniva "illaathaakkaan" pravarthichuvennu. raaviyude pravrithikal oru "thamasha", "apakadam" allengil "thettu" aayirunnilla, marichu "manappoorvvam", "aasoothranam cheytha", "criminal", "neechamanaskatha" ennivayaayirunnu. klementi swavarggaanuraagiyaanenna vastutha ravi prachodippichathaayi avar paranju "tailare mattullavaril ninnu vyathyasthanaayi brand cheyyaan addeham shramichu", "avahelanathinu addehathe sajjanakkaan"."pinneedu, avar vishadeekarichu, thelivukal maattikkond thante pravartthanangalude" "trackukal marachuvekkaan" "ravee shramichu".
raaviyude pravrithikal 18 vayassulla oru aankuttiyudethaanennu prathibhagam abhibhaashakan steevan altman paranju. eee pravartthanangal "pakwathayillaathathum" "viddithavum" aayirikkaamenkilum avaa vidveshamo vargeeyavaadamo criminalo aayirunnillenn addeham vaadichu. "bheeshanippeduthal undaayilla", altman oonnipparanju.
raavi orikkalum thante roomettinekkurichu "upadravikkukayo parihasikkukayo" moshamaayi onnum parayukayo cheythitilla. koodaathe, eathaanum sekkantukal maathram kondu raavi kettippidikkunnathu kanduvennum aarum "kaimaattam" cheiyukayo "onninteyum chithram punarnirmmikkukayo cheythitillennum altman paranju.
septambar 19 kaazhcha ratjezhs vidyaarthikalude saakshyam.
ratri 9 manikk sesham vaikathe veyu athu saakshyappeduthi.emm. 2010 septambar 19nuu dharoon raavi veyiyude muriyil ethi, eathaanum minitukalkkullil thante computerinte viidiyoo chaattinte oottoo-aaksept feature vazhi thante muriyil ninnu engane thalsamaya chithrangal labhikkumenn avale kaanichu. klementtiyum mattoru purushan kidakkayil kuninj chumbikkunnath kandappol taanum raviyum "njetti" poyathaayi veyu paranju.
taanum raviyum eathaanum sekkantukal maathrame kandittulloovennum viidiyoo stream oof cheythuvennum thudakkathil aarodum parayaruthennu sammathichuvennum veyu paranju, kaaranam ithu "vichithramayi thonni", athu thettaanenn avalkk thonni. eathaanum minittukalkk sesham aval sambhavathekkurichu oonlainil samsaarichu. pinneedu raavi kulikkaan muriyil ninnu puratthirangi, oru manikorinullil, oru suhruthinte abhyarthana maanich raaviyude webcam veendum axus cheyyukayum mattu naalu vidyaarthikale hrasvamaayi kaanikkukayum cheythu. purushanmaarude sharttukal oof cheythirunnuvennu ozhike, aaa rangam munbatheppole thanneyaayirunnu ennu veyu paranju. oru vidyaarthi parayunnathanusarichu, oraalkk avarude mukham kaanaan kazhiyaathathinal iruvarum thirinju.
thante swathukkalekkurichu thanikk aashankayundennu raavi thangalodu paranjathaayi veyiyum mattu vidyaarthikalum saakshyappeduthi. thante roommett swavarggaanuraagiyaanenna sthireekarikkaan aagrahikkunnuvennum raviyum paranjathaayi eee vidyaarthikalil randuper saakshyappeduthi. niravadhi vidyaarthikal klementtiyude athidhiye "moshamaaya" allengil "nizhalulla" ennu visheshippichu. raviyum mattoru vidyaarthiyum maathramaan klementtiyude athidhiye nerittu kandathennum mattoru vidyaarthi athidhi "asaadhaarananalla" ennum praayamaayappol "ashleelamaaya praayamaayirunnilla" ennum paranjathaayum prosecution vaadichu. swavarggaanuraagikalodu ravee oru sathruthayum prakadippichittillenna vidyaarthikalaarum paranjilla. oru vidyaarthi paranju, ravee klementtiye "nannayirikkunnu" ennu vilichuvennum matoraal paranju, thanikk oru swavarggaanuraagiyundena ravee thannodu paranjuvennum. klementi swavarggaanuraagiyaanenna raavi paraamarshichuvenkilum "athil ninnu valia kaaryamonnum cheythilla" ennu veyu paranju.
emm. yude saakshyam.bii..
2012 march 2nuu tailar klementtiyude athidhi emm.bii., anchu manikkooriladikam saakshyam vahichu. kuttakrithyathinu irayaakaanulla saadhyatha enna nilayil addehathinte svakaaryatha samrakshikkunnathinaayi, maadhyamangalkk addehathinte kaikal maathram kaanikkanum addehathe rekhappeduthaanum kazhiyillennu jadji utharavittu-"newyork times" akkoundu anusarichu "apoorvamaaya apavaadam" aaya kodathi niyanthranangal. emm.bii.'addeham thanne irayaanennu aaropikkappedunnathinal mathramalla, raaviyude pravarthanangalkku prerippicha samshayaaspadamaaya oru kathaapaathramaayi prathirodhichathinaal addehathinte saakshyam pradhanamaayirunnu. muun prosecutor joonn faahiyude abhipraayathil, laingika pravartthanangal nadannittundennu sthaapikkendathum prosecution pradhanamaayirunnu, koodaathe emm.bii. aaa pravartthanatthinte swabhaavathekkurichulla prathyeka chodyangalkku utharam nalkendivannu.
dhii newyork timesy" nte kettu sernic emm.bii. 2010 septambar 19-leppole saadhaarana vasthram dharikkaattha "closs croped hair" ullathinaal, ennaal ratjezhs dormittari survilance camera photoyile athe "mudiyum bharavum" ullathinaal. aval ezhuthi, "addeham mii. aayi kaanapettilla. raaviyude suhruthukkal addehathe 'mlechan' allengil 'nizhal' ennu visheshippichittundu."ennirunnaalum emm.bii. ettumuttalinte vaikunneram addeham kshouram cheythittillenn saakshyappeduthi.
emm.bii.'adhehavum klementtiyum oru soshyal network saittil kandumutty, septambar 19 leeii koodikkaazhcha moonnu theeyathikalil randaamathethaayirunnu. emm.bii. klementtiyumaayulla bandham oru "nalla bandhamaan" ennum athil thudarchayaaya sandeshamayakkalum oonlain chaattukalum ulppedunnundennum klementiye avasaanamaayi kandappol "santhoshavathiyaanu" ennum addeham paranju.
emm.bii. septambar 19leeii sandarshana velayil klementtiyude kidakkayilekku oru webcam viral choondunnathu thaan shradhichuvennum aaa sthaanam "vichithramaanenn" karuthiyittundennum addeham paranju, ennirunnaalum aarenkilum yadhaarthathil nireekshikkunnundenn thaan karuthiyilla. pinneedu athu prasakthamaayappol maathramaan thaan ithu oorkkunnathennu addeham cross-eksaamineshanil abhiprayappettu. emm.bii. klementiyude kidakkayil kidakkumbol, aalukal muttathu thamasha parayunnathum chirikkunnathum kettathaayum "thamashakal mattoraalude chelavilaanennu thonniyathaayum" addeham paranju. addeham muriyil ninnu purathirangiyappol, "enne nokkunnathupole thonnikkunna, aswasthathayundaakkunna" anchu vidyaarthikal undaayirunnu.
septambar 21: raaviyude aashayavinimayangaludeyum sambhavangaludeyum timeline.
raaviyude ashayavinimayangal, nerittum vaachakangalilum tweettukalilum, septambar 21 leeii sambhavavumayi bandhapetta pradhana thelivukalaayirunnu. septambar 21nuu raavi thante webcam sajjeekarichu klementikalude randaamathe pareekshanam kaanukayum suhruthukkalkkum twittar pholoverskum parasyam nalkukayum cheythathayi prosecution vaadichu. klementi computer anplug cheythathinaal maathramaan kazhcha thadasappettathennu avar vaadichu. thante sandeshangal thamaashayodeyaanu ayachathennum pinneedu webcam oof cheythathinaal kaananakillennum raavi paranju.
raaviyude twittar sandeshangal pinthudarnna tailar klementi, raaviyude twittar peju 38 thavana sandarshichu. klementi rund sandeshangal save cheythu. septambar 19 nuu klimenti aadyathe sandesham kaanukayum, athu ravee kandu, klimenti suhruthukkalumaayi charcha cheyyukayum cheythu. raavi ezhuthi "roommett ardharaathri vare murii aavasyappettu. njaan moliyude muriyil chennu webcam oonaakki. avan oru suhruthumaayi edapazhakunnathu njaan kandu. yaay."randaamathe save cheytha sandesham septambar 21 nuu (vaikunneram 6.39) raaviyaan ayachathu.emm.), annu uchakazhinju clementi mattoru tristinaayi murii svakaaryamaayi upayogikkaan abhyarthichathinushesham "aii-chaatt ulla aarenkilum, 9.30 num 12 num idayil enne viidiyoo chaatt cheyyaan njaan ningale dhairyappeduthunnu. athe, athu veendum sambhavikkunnu."
septambar 21 nuu uchathirinju ravee thante suhruthu maikkal huwang-nuu sandesham ayachu. klementtiyude athidhi "prayamaayavanum internettil ninnu bhayankaran vimukhanumaayirunnu" ennu ravee paranju. septambar 19 muthal thaan athidhiye kandittillenn addeham paranju, pakshe "ente webcam ente kidakka parishodhikkunnu. njaayarazhcha kazhinjappol njaan valare aswasthanaayi."addeham koottichertthu," athe, swavarggaanuraagikale akattinirtthuka."
raavi vaikunneram 6.39nuu thante "dair yuu" tweet ayachu.emm.pinneedu viidiyoo stream kaanaan ravee huwangnode abhyarthichu "ithu sarikkum cheyyuka! njaan athu addehathinte kidakkayilekku choondikkaanichu. monittar oof aayathinal ayalkku ningale kaanaan kazhiyilla. athu moshamaakumenn shradhikkuka."8.41nuu mattoru vaachaka sambhaashanathil, rumm bear upayogichu" "aalukal oru viewing party nadathunnu" "ennu raavi huwang paranju".
pittennu ravee huwangnode paranju, "athu kuzhappathilaayi, pravarthichilla."septambar 23nuu raviyum huwang klementiyude maranathekkurichu charcha cheyyukayum huwang chodikkukayum cheythu" orikkal oru viewing party undaayirunnuvennu ningal paranjille? ..."raavi marupadi paranju," illa, athoru thamashayaayirunnu."
raavi thante webcamile oru prathyakshaparisodhanayil thante murikalile computerukal upayogichaanu svanthamaayi kanakdu cheythathennu rund rattgezhs vidyaarthikal saakshyappeduthi. vaikunneram 6.58num 7.44num eee vidyaarthikalude computerukalil ninnu raaviyude computerumaayi aichaat kanakshanukal undakkiyathaayi oru ratjezhs information teknolaji analyst report cheythu.emm. septambar 21nuu aadyathe vidyaarthi paranju, klementiyude theeyathi kaanaan suhruthukkalkku sandesham ayaykkaan raavi thanne prothsaahippichuvennum webcaminte koonn parisodhikkaan raavi thante computer upayogichuvennum angane athu klementiyude kidakkayilekku choondunnuvennum. athaazhathinu sesham raavi thante muun "dier yuu" tweet "hype" cheythathaayum raavi thante aichaat axus cheyyaan thante computer upayogichathaayum webcam axus cheyyumbol "muriyude tailarude vasham drishyamaayennum" randaamathe vidyaarthi paranju. aadya vidyaarthi paranju, adutha divasam webstream pravarthichillennu raviyodu paranjathaayin "appol njaan [ravi] lonchil kandu, njaan paranju, 'yoo, athu pravarthichilla.'addeham paranju,' athe, enikku athu dhaaraalam aalukalil ninnu labhikkunnu.'"
ratri 9.15nuu.emm. raaviyude "enne viidiyoo chaatt cheyyaan dhairyappedoo" enna tweettinte oru screenshot klementi save cheythu. 9. 25nuu raaviyude computer vichedikkappettathaayi vidagdhar vishakalanam cheythathanusarichu, athu 11:19 p vare vichedikkappettu.emm. raaviyude computerilekkulla power strip oof cheythathayi 9.33nuu klementi oonlainil oru suhruthinodu paranju. 10:19 klementiyude athidhi ethi.
raavi vaikunneram <aii. dii. 1>: 00 oode aathyanthika frisby parisheelanathinaayi purappettu.emm.
parisheelanathinu sesham ratri 11 manikk frisby teaminte kyapttan saakshyappeduthi.emm.avanum raviyum mattullavarum daining haalil bhakshanam edukkaan pooyi, "thante roommettinte chithrangal edukkaan thaan orutharam webcam sajjeekarichittund", "neratthe cheythathaanu", aaa ratri "athu veendum cheyyaan padhathiyidukayaayirunnu" ennu ravee paranju. roommett swavarggaanuraagiyaayathil raviykku aswasthathayundaayirunnuve ennaal "apamanakaramaaya" onnum paranjittillennum vidyaarthi saakshyappeduthi.
ratri 11 manikk sesham.emm. addeham ippozhum murii upayogikkunnundo ennu arian ravee clementic sandesham ayachu. 11:48 ll, klementi raviykku "njangal poortthiyaakki" ennu sandesham ayachu."
septambar 21nuu thaan webcam klementiyude kidakkayil ninnu mattiyathaayi anweshana udyogastharkku nalkia abhimukhathil raavi paranju.
septambaril doorr room parishodhichappol oru muun yooniversitti detective saakshyappeduthi. 23, webcam "tailarude kidakkayil nerittu konaayi" aayirunnu.
udyogastharkku clementi nalkunna paraathikal.
murii mattaanulla klementtiyude abhyarthanakalude oru bhagam maathrame juurii kaanaan anuvadichirunnulloo. suhruthukkalumaayi charcha cheythathinushesham raaviyude aadya twittar sandesham ("ente roommett oru suhruthumaayi edapazhakunnathu kandu"), klementi, pularche 3.55nuu.emm. septambar 21 nuu, ratjezhs housing websaittil oru abhyarthana phayal cheythu; addeham ezhuthi, "roommett enne chaarappani cheyyaan webcam upayogichu/oru murii venam."chaarapravartthanathekkurachuri bhagam kelvikkuriyayi vilayiruthappettu, sveekaaryamalla. septambar 21nuu vaikunneram raaviyude "dhairyappedoo" enna tweet kandathinusheshavum emm.bii., klementi raahi groverile oru resident asisttantine sandarshichu. klementi paranjathinekkurichu saakshyam vahikkaan groverine anuvadichilla, pakshe klementtiyude perumaattathekkurichu saakshyappeduthi. klementtiyude shabdam "alppam viraykkunna" aanennum thanikk aswasthatha thonnunnuvennum addeham paranju. sambhavathekkurichulla groverinte audyogika reportinte chila bhagangal jadji anuvadichu "tailar valare aswasthanum aswasthanumaanu. tailar orutharam roommett switch ethrayum vegam eshtappedunnu, koodaathe dharoon raviykku orutharam shikshayaan eshtappedunnathu."ethrayum vegam oru roommett mattanamenna swantham shuparshayum grover ulppeduthukayum aaa raathriyil addeham clementic swantham muriyil oru kidakka vaagdaanam cheyyukayum athu clementi nirasikkukayum cheythu.
roommett mattaanulla abhyarthana aupachaarikamaakkunnathinu klementi pinneedu oru iii-meyil ayaykkaan grover abhyarthichu, athinte oru bhagam thelivaayi anuvadichu. addehathinte iii-meyilil (12:03 a.emm.) klementi ezhuthi "ente svakaaryatha lamghikkappettathaayi enikku thonnunnu, ithrayum anuchithamayi perumaarunna oralumaayi oru murii pankidunnathil enikku angeyattam aswasthathayundu."juurii thelivukalil ninnu" "thikachum anuchithamaya" "thelivukal ozhivaakkanamenn jadji vidhichu, kaaranam ithu oru varthamaanakaala indriyadhaaranayalla, marichu klementi charcha cheytha munkaala pravartthanangalude vivaranamaan". muun prosecutor joonn faahiyude abhipraayathil, clementi "thanne bhayappeduthukayaanennu nyayamaayum vishwasikkunnundo illayo" enna kaaryatthil klementiyude iii-meyilum groverinte sakshyavum pradhanamaayirunnu.
prosecutionodulla prathikaranangal.
prosecution cases vishramichathinusheshavum prathibhagam vaadangal unnayikkunnathin munbum prathikaricha nireekshakar prosecution kesinte shakthiyekkurich abhipraayavyathyaasappettu. svakaaryathayude kadannukayattavum pakshapathaparamaaya bheeshanippeduthal aaropanangalum prosecution sthaapichathaayi thaan vishwasikkunnuvennu niyama professor muun public defenderumaaya susanne ebraham paranju. oru samshayavumilla", avar paranju, klementi thante laingika aabhimukhyam kaaranamaan thiranjedukkappettathenna vishwasikkunnu, swavarggaanuraagikale paraamarsikkunna raaviyude chila sandeshangal uddeshyathinte thelivaayirikkam; nyoojezhsi pakshapatha bheeshanippeduthal niyamaprakaaram prosecution pakshapathaparamaaya uddeshyam theliyikkendathillennu avar abhiprayappettu, marichu laingika aabhimukhyam kaaranam thanne lakshyamittuvenn irayude nyayamaaya vishwaasam maathramaan. poleesinodulla thante mozhikalil svakaaryatha lamghichathaayi raavi sammathichappol, "svakaaryathayude kadannukayattam" ennathinte niyamaparamaaya ardham thanikk manassilaakaathathinaal sammarddathilaanu prasthavana nadathiyathennum oru prathirodha vaadam undaakumennum abraham oohichu.
kuttaaropitharkk sesham, prosecution cases durbalamaayirikkaamenn abhibhaashakan edward weynsteen paranjirunnuvenkilum prosecution cases ketta sesham, "prathirodhatthinu valare valia bhaaramund; prosecution oru nalla cases vekkunnu."vichaaranaykkide velippeduthiya raaviyude twittar sandeshangal kaanikkunnath" "addeham oru thamasha valikkunna oru thamashakkaaranaaya kutty mathramalla", "ennirunnaalum kesinte phalam" "poornnamaayum kaanendathundu" "ennum addeham abhiprayappettu".
vidvesha kuttakrithyangalekkurichu adikaariyaaya jacq levin pakshapathaparamaaya bheeshanippeduthalinekkur samshayikkunnuvennum raviyekkurichu parayumbol, "laingika aabhimukhyam moolamaano atho laingika aabhimukhyam illaatha roommettukal thammilulla mattu samgharshangal moolamaano prachodanam ennu nirnnayikkaan prayaasamaan", camerayude sthaanam thante swathukkal samrakshikkunnathil praadhamikamaayi aashankayundenna raaviyude vaadathekkurichu samshayam uyarthiyathaayum addeham abhiprayappettu.
vidhi prakhyaapikkunnathin thottumunbu prasidheekaricha oru warta vishakalanathil, abc nyoosile kriss cuomo ezhuthi, "vichaaranaye thudarnnu reportermaarudeyum niyama vishakalana vidagtharudeyum samavayam samsthaanathinte vidvesha kuttakrithyangal valare kuravaanennathaanu."
prathirodhathodulla prathikaranangal.
2012 march 9 nuu prathirodha avatharanathinte aadya prabhaathatthinu sesham, vichaarana attorni bryan kleyippool mothatthilulla prathirodha thanthrathe phalapradamaayi kandu, ennaal ravee swavarganuraga virudhanallennu kaanikkan sramikkunna prathirodha saankethikavidyakale addeham chodyam cheythu. ravee swavarggaanuraagiyallenna parayaan "adisthaanamilla" ennu prosecution kaanichathinaal vilicha kathapatra sakshikal phalapradamallennu addeham paranju. niravadhi adhika saakshikalumayi prathirodha vishayam (raavi pakshapaatham kaanikkaathathu) pinthudarendathaayirunnuve kleypool paranju. swavarggaanuraagikalodu pakshapaathamillenn kaanikkanum poleesumaayulla thante record cheytha abhimukhathil poruthakkedukal vishadeekarikkaanum ravee thanne saakshyam vahikkendathundennum addeham paranju.
muun berjan kaundi jilla attorni joonn fahi, vaadangal avasaanippicha sesham paranju, prathirodhavum prosecution "valare nalla jolie" cheythu. svakaaryathayude kuttakrithyathe sambandhichidatholam, sambhavangale "onnaam varsha koleju vidyaarthikalude" "vinodamaayi visheshippichu nyayamaaya samshayam uyarthunnathil prathirodham phalapradamaanennu fahi paranju. pakshapathaparamaaya bheeshanippeduthalinekkur, klementi swavarggaanuraagiyaayathinaal kazhcha nadathiyathinu "valia thelivukalonnumillennu" fahi paranju. neethi thadassappeduthunnathumaayi bandhappett, raaviyude chila grandhangal "vishadeekarikkaan valare budhimuttaanennu" fahi abhiprayappettu. police abhimukhathil "chodyam cheyyappedaattha oru kutty" undennum abhimukhathil raaviyude "oru valia nuna" undennum-randaamathe (septambar 21) sambhavathil addeham "computer oof cheyyukayum pinneedu athu oonaakkukayum cheythu" ennum fahi paranju."
vidhi.
juurii theerumaanam.
randara divasangalilaayi 12 manikkoor neenda charchakalkku sesham, 12 amgangalum moonnu ithara amgangalum adangunna juurii 2012 march 16 nuu oru vidhiyilethi. svakaaryathayude kadannukayattam, bhayam thadassappedutthal, saakshikale krithrimam cheyyal, pakshapathaparamaaya bheeshanippeduthal ennee naalu kuttangalkkum ravi kuttakkaaranaanennu kandethi. septambar 19-leeii kaazhchaye sambandhichidatholam, clementiyeo athidhiyeyo avarude laingika aabhimukhyam kaaranam bhayappeduthukayalla ravee cheythathennu juurii nigamanam cheythu, ennaal klementtiye bhayappeduthukayum laingika aabhimukhyam kaaranam thanne lakshyamittathayi nyayamaayum vishwasikkukayum cheythu. septambar 21 nuu aasoothranam cheytha kaazhchayekkurichum tvittariloode thante anuyaayikale kaanaan ravee prothsaahippichathinekkum juurii nigamanam cheythath, bheeshanippeduthuka enna uddeshyathodeyaanu ravee pravarthichathennum bheeshanippeduthal sambhavikkumennum clementi bhayappeduthappedukayum laingika aabhimukhyam kaaranam thanne lakshyamittathayi nyayamaayum vishwasikkukayum cheythuvennum aanu. emm. ravi ellah pakshapatha aropanangalil ninnum veruthe vittu.bii.
prathikaranangal.
vidhikk anchu divasathinu sesham oru abhimukhathil raavi paranju
mattoru abhimukhathil addeham paranju
march 23 nuu, tailarude pithaav joseph klementi paranju, juurii "sariyaaya vidhiyil" athiyennu kudumbam vishwasikkunnu, athu "vasthuthakaleyum thelivukaleyum adisthaanamaakkiyullathaanu"; prathirodha vishadeekaranam, addeham koottichertthu, "vishwasikkaanaavilla". "njangal neethiyum utharavaadithavum thedukayaanennu njaan ekkaalavum paranjittundu. eee avakasham labhikkaan kodathikaleyum nyoojezhsiyude samsthaanatheyum njaan vishwasichu... avar athu cheyyukayum cheythu."
vichaaranayile emm. bii. ennu maathram thirichariyappetta klementiyude athidhi 2012 march 16 nuu vidhiyodu prathikarichu. addeham paranju, "oru vichaarana ozhivaakkaamaayirunnuvennu njaan aashankappetta ellaavarodum pratheekshichirunnu, pakshe athu ente thiranjeduppaayirunnil. athu misttar aayirunnu. raaviyude theerumaanam, ippol avan athinoppam jeevikkanam."emm. bii. yude abhibhaashakan juurii samagramaayirunnuvennum ratgezhs vidyaarthikalkku" "njangalude kakshiyekkurichu onnum ariyaathathinaal emm. bii. yeei pakshapathaparamaaya kuttakrithyathinu irayaayi kandethaathathil juurii sariyaanennum paranju".
vicharana vidhiyum nyoojezhsi vidvesha kuttakrithya niyamathinteyum samanamaaya niyamangaludeyum saadhuthayeyum falaprapthy kurichu rajyavyaapaka charchakalkku kaaranamaayi. marcellus eiii. kesil ulppedaatha muun federal prosecuter mekre, kuttavimuktharaaya vidhinyaayangale "oru nirnnayaka nimishamaayi" prashamsichu, kaaranam yuvakkal prathirodhasheshiyallennu athu parayunnu. oru nyoojezhsi ekwal raitts advecasy grouppinte chairman steevan goldstein paranju, "eee vidhi oru 'kuttikal kuttikalayirikkum' enna pradhana sandesham nalkunnu, prathirodham mattoru vidyaarthiye bheeshanippeduthunnathinu ozhikazhivalla."pakshapatha bheeshanippeduthal maanadandangal paalichathaayi ratjezhs school oof loow-nevaarkkile criminal, sivil trial littigeshan professoraaya luis raavesan paranju" "itharathilulla kuttakrithyangalum kuttakrithyangalum niyamam shariyaayi pravachichathaayi njaan karuthunnu"... athu uchithamayi upayogikkunnu."
raaviyude vichaaranayude adhyakshatha vahicha jadji glen berman, nyoojezhsi niyamam "kuzhappathilaanennum" thaan athu vyathyasthamayi ezhuthumaayirunnuvennum paranju. newark pathratthinte edittoriyal bordaaya "dhii staar-ledger" niyamatheyum athinte prayogatheyum vimarsikkukayum raaviyude kuttakrithyam durudheshyaparamallennum niyamam bharanaghadanaa virudhamaanennum ravikkethiraaya niyamam prayogikkunnathu "valia athikramam" aanennum vaadichu. "washington poost" colomist richard kohan ravi "" bheeshanippeduthal (webcam vazhi) "" ennu vimarshichu, ennaal vidvesha kuttakrithya niyamangal oru vyakthiye chinthaykko samsaarathino anyaayamaayi shikshikkunnuvennum athinaal pouraswaathanthryathe illaathaakkunnuvennum vaadichu ". newyork times" enna lekhanathil, pathrapravartthaka emily basalon vaadichathu, klementtiyude svakaaryathaykkethiraaya raaviyude kadannukayattam "oru koleju kaambasil paridikk purathaayirikkanam", addeham neritta shiksha aaa kuttakrithyathinu asamathvamullathaanennum vidvesha kuttakrithya niyamangal itharathilulla pravarthanangalkku uddeshichullathallennum.
shikshavidhi vaadam.
vaachakam.
2012 meyy 21nuu jadji glen berman ravi 30 divasathe jayil shiksha, 3 varshathe probation, 300 manikkoor saamoohika sevanam, 10,000 dollar pizha, saibar bheeshanippeduthalinekkuru ithara jeevithashailikalekkurichum kaunsiling ennivaykku shikshichu. "athu ente edapaadaayirunnilla", jadji paranju. "athu samsthaanathintethaayirunnu."leed prosecutor juuliya mcclure anchu varshathe thadavu shiksha aavasyappedukayum 2012 meyy 23 nuu shikshaykkethire appeel nalki oru prameyam phayal cheyyukayum cheythirunnu.
2012 meyy 30 nuu raavi appeel prakriyayil swathanthranaayi thudaraanulla avakasham ozhivaakkukayum 2012 meyy 31 nuu nyoojezhsiyile north brunswickile middlesex kaundi muthirnnavarkkulla thiruthal kendratthil jayil shiksha aarambikkukayum cheythu.
nalla perumaattatthinum 5 divasathe varkk creditinum 5 divasathe kredittumaayi 30 divasathe kaalayalavil 20 divasam sevanamanushtichathinu sesham 2012 juun 19 nuu ravee jayilil ninnu mochithanaayi.
aaram vayassil kudiyeriya amerikkayile sthira thaamasakkaaranaan raavi. klementtiyude kudumbam emm.bii., ravi naadukadattharuthennu jadjimar ellaavarum shupaarsha cheythu. naadukadatthal aavasyappedunnathinu shikshaavidhikal gauravamullathallennu 2012 juunil immigration, kasttams enfozhsment udyogasthar prakhyaapichu.
mapp chodikkunna prashnam.
vaakyathin munbulla aalukalodu raavi ezhuthiya 'mapp kathu'" "aakarshakamallathathaanu" "ennum" "ezhu marachuvekkal aropanangal polum paraamarshichittilla" "ennum jadji berman paranju". raaviyude kathil emm paraamarshikkaathathu virodhaabhaasamaanennu addeham paranju.bii. avan nilavililla ennapole ", ennittum emm.bii. naadukadathappedunnathu ozhivakkaan ravi sahayikkaan oru kathu ezhuthaan addeham kathil vaagdaanam cheythirunnu. vidhi kelkkunnathil samsaarikkanulla avasaram ravee nirasikkukayum parasyamaayi kshama chodikkaathathinu jadji berman shaasikkukayum cheythu "eee juurii 288 thavana kuttakkaaranaanennu parayunnath njaan kettu-24 chodyangal, 12 joorikal, athaanu gunanam. ningal orikkal polum mapp parayunnath njaan kettitilla."
2012 meyy 29nuu raavi thaazhepparayunna prasthavana puratthirakki
klementtiyude maathaapithaakkal marupadi paranju
appeel.
prosecutermaarum raviyum vevvere appeelukal phayal cheythu. 2016 februvariyil thante shikshavidhi radhaakkaan raavi kodathikalodu aavasyappettu.
2016 septambar 9 nuu, nyoojezhsiyile appeel division supreme kodathi, ravee sikshikkappetta pakshapatha bheeshanippeduthal niyamangal bharanaghadanaa virudhamaanennu nyoojezhsiyile supreme kodathi vidhichathinethudarnnu shikshavidhi raddaki. mattu patthu kuttangalil ravi veendum vichaarana cheyyaamennu appeel kodathi utharavittu.
2016 october 27 nuu raavi oru harji karar amgeekarikkukayum svakaaryatha akramikkaan shramichathinte oru kuttatthinu kuttam sammathikkukayum cheythu, ithu oru moonnaam digri kuttakrithyamaanu. neratthe thanne sikshikkappetta addehathinu pizhayum backie kuttangalum pinvalichu.