
puthiya charitrakaaranmaar

1948leeii palasteen pravaasatthil israayelinte pankum samaadhaanathekkurich charcha cheyyaanulla arab sannadhathayum ulppede israel charithratthinte parambaraagatha pathippukale velluvilicha israel charithrakaaranmaarude oru koottamaanu puthiya charitrakaaranmaar (, "historiyonim hachadashim"). 1988ll pramukha puthiya charitrakaaranmaaril oralaaya bennie morris aanu eee padam upayogichathu. newyork timesinte" ethan bronner parayunnathanusarichu, puthiya charitrakaaranmaar eee mekhalayile samadhana prakriya munnott kondupokaan sramichittundu.
israel sthaapithamaayi muppath varshathinu sesham tharamthirichathinte falamaayi puthuthayi labhyamaya israel sarkkar rekhakalil ninnaan group upayogikkunna praadhamika uravida vasthukkalil bhooribhaagavum varunnath. 1980kalil bennie morris, ilaan pappe, avii schlime, simha flappen ennee naalu pandithanmaarude prasidheekaranangaliloode oru puthiya charitraparamaaya pravaahathekkurichulla dhaarana uyarnnuvannu. thudarnnu toom segev, hillel kohen, barooch kimmerling, joyal migdal, idith sertal, shlomo sand thudangi niravadhi charitrakaaranmaarum charitraparamaaya saamoohikashaasthranjarum eee prasthaanavumaayi bandhappettathayi thiricharinjittundu.
thudakkathil pothujanangal thallikkalanja puthiya charitrakaaranmaar oduvil 1990-kalil israelil niyamasadhutha nedi. avarude chila nigamanangal poost-seonistukalude rashtreeya prathyayashaasthrathil ulppeduthiyittundu.
pradhana vaadangal.
audyogika charithram" ennu thaan visheshippichathil ninnu puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude vyathyaasangal avii schlime inipparayunna padangalil vivarichu
mikka palasteen arabikaleyum sthaanabhrashtaraakkaan siyonist nethaakkal uddeshichirunnuvennu pappe soochippikkunnu; yudhathinte choodilaanu sthaanabhramsham sambhavichathenn morris vishwasikkunnu. puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude abhipraayathil, arab-israel samgharshathinum palasteen duravasthaykkum israel, arab raajyangalkk oororutharkkum avarudethaaya utharavaadithamundu.
parambaraagatha israeli charitra vivaranathilum pothujanaabhipraayathilum swaadheenam cheluthunnu.
puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude varavinu munbu, "israelikal palasteen abhayaarthi prashnam srishtikkunnathilekku nayicha saahacharyangalekkurichulla ekapaksheeyamaaya charitra vivaranam nilanirtthiyirunnuvennum mattethenkilum ethir-vivaranagal nishidhamaayirunnuvennum maikkal benn-joseph hirsh vaadikkunnu."benn-joseph hirsh parayunnathanusarichu, puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude nigamanangalum avar prakopippicha vishalamaaya charchakalum aaa nirodhanam avasanippikkukayum israelil palasteen abhayaarthi prashnatheyum athinte kaaranangaleyum veekshikkunna reethiye maattukayum cheythu. 1948 muthal 1990kalude avasaanam vare nadanna palastheeniyakkaarude palayanam arabikalaayirunnu ennu parambaraagatha israeli vivaranam benn-joseph hirsh parayunnu. puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude vaadangal aaa vivaranathe ganyamaayi velluvilichuvennum ithu academica mekhalayilum pathrapravartthakarum colomistukalum raashtreeyakkaarum pothu vyakthikalum pothujanangalum ulppedeyulla vishalamaaya pothu samvaadathilum vishalamaaya charchayilekku nayichuvennum avar parayunnu.
1990kalude avasaanam muthal israel samoohathil palasteen abhayaarthi prashnathe engane veekshikkunnu ennathil kaaryamaaya maattam vannittundennum kooduthal sankeernamaaya vivaranam kooduthal amgeekarikkappettuvennum benn-joseph hirsh vishwasikkunnu; israel neethrthwathinte arivum adikaaravum upayogichu israel sainyam palastheeniyakkaare purathaakkiya udaaharanangalundennu ithu amgeekarikkunnu. puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude pravarthanangalilekkum athinte falamaayundaakunna samvaadangalilekkum maarunnuvenn benn-joseph hirsh parayunnu.
1990kalode puthiya charitrakaaranmaarkku bahumanam labhichu. israayelinte ambathaam vaarshikam aaghoshikkunna 1998 leeii stettu television parambarayum 1999 ll onpathaam klaas vidyaarthikalkku avatharippicha paatapusthakangalum avarude srishtikalil ninnu valareyadhikam aakarshichu.
puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude vimarshakar eee maattam amgeekarichittundu. arab-israel samgharshathinte charithratthil puthiya charitrakaaranmaar pravarthicha swaadheenam athishayokthiparamallenn "jerusalem posttil" ezhuthiyittulla avii becker parayunnu. puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude pravartthanangal ippol academica mekhalayile mukhyadhaarayaanennum avarude swaadheenam boudhika vrithangalil maathram othungunnathallennum addeham parayunnu. israeli school paatapusthakangalile mattangal muthal israeli rashtreeya nethaakkalude pravartthanangal vareyum israeli-palasteen samadhana prakriyayile sambhavavikasangal vareyum addeham udaaharanagal udharikkunnu.
sweekaranam.
puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude rachanakal aavarthichulla vimarsanathinu vidheyamaayittundu, parambaraagatha israeli charitrakaaranmaaril ninnu, avar siyonist thettukal kettichamachuvennu aaropikkunnavaril ninnum, arab allengil arab anukoola ezhuthukaaril ninnu, avar siyonist mosham perumaattathekkurichu sathyam veluppichuvennu aaropikkunnu. aaraan yuddham aarambhichathenn thaan parayunna nirnaayaka chodyangal avar avaganichuvennu ephraim karsh aaropichu. avarude uddeshyangal enthaayirunnu? aaraan prathirodham sthaapikkaan nirbandhithanaayathu? israayelinte naashanashtangal enthaayirunnu?
2002-nte thudakkathil, puthiya charitrakaaranmaaril ettavum prashasthanaaya bennie morris thante charitra rachanakalonnum pinvalichittillenkilum thante chila vyakthiparamaaya rashtreeya nilapaadukal parasyamaayi maatti. 1980kalude madhyathil palasteen abhayaarthi prashnatthinte jananam ezhuthumbol, enikku idfa [idf archive] yilo hagana aarkkaivilo ulla vasthukkal labhyamayillennum mattevideyengilum nikshepikkunna vilayeriyathum aadyakaala sainika vasthukkal maathramaanennum morris parayunnu."
avee schlime bennie morris "yadhaartha arab srothassukal valare kurachu maathrame upayogikkunnulloo" ennum atharam paraamarsangalil bhooribhaagavum "engleesh vivarthanathil" ulluvennum shlaiminte avakaashavaadam "arab rekhakalude aavasyamilla" ennum "israeli documentationil ninnu arab sthaanangal vishadeekarikkaan thanikk kazhiyumennu" morisinte avakaashavaadam "vyakthamaaya valachodikkalukalil" kalashikkunnuvennum anita shapeera prasthaavichu.
israel charitrakaaranaaya yov jelber oru abhimukhathil puthiya charitrakaaranmaare vimarshichu, bennie morris ozhike, 1948 leeii arab-israel yudhathekkurichulla gaveshanathinu avar oru tharatthilum sambhavana nalkiyittillenn paranju. ennirunnaalum, yudhathekkurichulla pothu samvaadathinu avar sambhavana nalkiyathaayi addeham shradhichu.
poost-seonism.
puthiya charithrakaaranmaarude charithralekhanam poost-seonism ennariyappedunna oru prasthaanatthil ninnu prachodanam ulkkonduvennum athinu prachodanam nalkiyathaayum chila vyaakhyaanakaaranmaar vaadichittundu. sayanist samrambhathe vimarsikkukayum israeli deseeya daarmmikathaye durbalappeduthunnathaayi kaanukayum cheiyunna jootha israelikalaanu saadhaaranayaayi "poost-siyanist" enna padam svayam thirichariyunnathu. ritten niyamatthinte nilayum mattu sensitiivu prashnangalum polulla niravadhi pradhana vishadaamshangalil poost-seonistukal seonistukalil ninnu vyathyastharaan. israel raashtrathinte srishtiyude kendramaayi palasteente kaivashappeduthaline poost-seonistukal kaanunnu. 
poost-seonism" enna padatthil shradha kendreekarikkunnathine barook kimmerling vimarshichu, eee padatthe chuttipattiyulla samvaadangal "viddithavum ardha-professional" aanennu vaadichu.
pradhaanamaayum raashtreeyamaanu. kimmerlinginte abhipraayathil, israeli charithram, samooham allengil raashtreeyam ennivayekkurichulla vimarshanaathmakamo vimarshanaathmakamo aaya eathoru gaveshanathinum eee padam ekapaksheeyamaayi prayogichittundu. scholarshippinte gunanilavaarathil ninnum yogyathayil ninnum shradha maattukayum eee kruthiye sayanist allengil poost-sayanist ennu visheshippikkanamo ennathilekku shradha kendreekarikkukayum cheythathinaal eee charcha eee mekhalakalile gaveshanathinu doshakaramaanennu kimmerling kandu. vivaadaparamaaya vishayangalil gurutharamaaya gaveshanangalil ninnu academic vidagthare vyathichalippichuvennum ithu valarthiyedutha paristhithi rund campukalilonnil pettavaraanennu mudrakuthappedumennu bhayappedunna yuva academic vidagtharude gaveshanathe thadassappeduthunnuvennum kimmerling vaadichu.
pradhana charchakal.
chila avasarangalil puthiya charitrakaaranmaarum avarude athiraalikalum thammil chooderiya pothu samvaadangal nadannittundu. ettavum sradheyamaayatha