
harriot holl

harriot aeye. holl (2 julaai, 1945-11 janwari, 2023) ack americi parivarik chikitsak they.aiss. vayu senaa udaan sarjan, lekhak, vigyaan sanchaarak aur sanshayvaadi. unhone "sanshayvaadi" aur "sandehwadi jigyasu" patrikaon key liye vaikalpik chikitsa aur quackery key baare mein likhaa aur "vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" kii niyamit yogadankarta aur sansthaapak sampaadak theen."unhone apane naam seey likhaa yaa chhadm naam" "dha scapdock" "kaa upayog kiya. yuu mein curnell key roop mein sevaanivritt honey key baad.aiss. vayu senaa, holl america aur duniya bhar mein vigyaan aur sandehwad seey sambandhit sammelanon mein ack baar-baar vaktaa thaa.
praarambhik jeevan aur shiksha.
harriot annie hog kaa janm 2 julaai, 1945 koo sent mein huaa thaa. lui, misauri. chaar bhaai-bahanon mein sabse badee, unakaa paalan-poshan washington key ciatal key vyu riz pados mein huaa thaa. apani kishoravastha mein, unhone apani paddhativaadi parvarish parr sawal uthaana shuru curr diyaa, baad mein ack naastik bunn gaeen.
hog ney washington vishvavidyalaya mein bhaag liya, jahan unhein spanish bhasha aur saahitya mein snaatak kii degree seey sammaanit kiya gayaa. vaha 1970 mein doctor off medicine arjit karane key liye washington school off medicine mein gaeen.
1971 mein, hog ney california mein david grant usaf medical center mein internship kii. taba vaha saat saal taka spen mein ack samanya chikitsa adhikaari key roop mein tainaat thee. 
hog ney udaan sarjan banane key liye aerospace medicine kaa peechha kiya, 1979 mein snaatak kiya, jaba vaha parivarik chikitsa mein bhee pramaanit hoe gaeen. unhone francis ee mein apana kaary shuru kiya. vyoming mein vaaran vayu senaa kaa adda jahan vaha kirk albert holl, junier seey millie aur shaadi kii.. vaha vayu senaa mein apani chikitsa internship karane vaali doosari mahila theen aur florida mein aglin vayu senaa adde parr vayu senaa parivaar abhyaas nivaas kii pahali mahila snaatak theen.
carrier.
yuu mein holl kii seva kii jaati haye.aiss. 20 varshon key liye vayu senaa. vaha washington raajya mein sanyukt bases luis-mccord seey ack poorna curnell key roop mein sevaanivritt huin.
holl ney kahaa kii vaha kuchh samay seey "nishkriya sandehwadi" rahee theen, kewal saahitya padhati theen aur vibhinn baithakon mein bhaag letee theen. 2002 mein, vaha oregan key eugene mein skeptic key toolbox karyashala mein valas sampson seey millie. sampson ney holl koo "vaikalpik chikitsa kii vaigyaanik sameeksha" key liye ack lekh likhane key liye protsaahit kiya, jisamen tathaakathit "vitamin oh" utpaadon kaa pareekshan kiya gayaa thaa, jinhen usane mell mein vigyaapit kiya thaa. isake baad unhone "sandehpurna poochtaachh karane vaale" key liye lekh likhana shuru kiya. holl ney 2005 mein adbhut baithak mein michael shermer key saath "dha godd code" pustak key baare mein baat kii aur unhone usey "skeptic" patrika key liye isaki sameeksha likhane key liye kahaa. 2006-2023 seey unakaa "skeptic" patrika mein "dha scapdock" sheershak seey ack niyamit collum thaa, jiska upayog unaki website key naam key roop mein bhee kiya jaataa thaa. toolbox seey pahale, "maine koee lekhan naheen kiya thaa... ack cheez doosari cheez kii or leey gaee aur abb main sandeh key toolbox key sankaay parr huun."
2008 mein unhone "mahilaaon koo udanaa naheen chaahieh ack mahila udaan sarjan key sansmaran", ack aatmakatha prakaashit kii, joe yuu. mein ack udaan sarjan key roop mein unake anubhavon parr kendrit thee.aiss. vayu senaa (vaha ack poorna curnell key roop mein sevaanivritt hui). ack mahila chikitsak, vayu senaa adhikaari, pilot aur udaan sarjan key roop mein, vaha kaee mayanon mein alpasankhyak theen, aur unhein purvagrah kaa saamana karna padaa. pustak kaa sheershak unaki pahali ekal udaan key baad kii ack ghatana koo sandarbhit kartaa haye jaba ack havaai adde key adhikaari ney unhein bataaya, "kyaa kissy ney aapako kabhi naheen bataaya kii mahilaaon koo udaan naheen bharni haye?"
2008 mein, holl "vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" shuru karane vaale paanch sansthaapak sampadakon mein seey ack thaa. ack sampaadak key roop mein seva karane key alawa, unhone "vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" mein 700 seey adhik lekhon kaa yogdan diyaa.
holl ney 2009 mein anya sthaanon key beach vigyaan-adharit chikitsa sammelan aur adbhut baithak 7 mein baat kii. unakaa sakshatkar podcast jaise "vaastaviktaa kii jaanch", "sandeh" aur "sandeh kshetra" parr kiya gayaa thaa.
janwari 2010 key ank seey shuru hocker, holl mein oh mein ack niyamit 250-shabd kaa collum thaa, opra patrika ney samanya swaasthya mithakon koo khariz curr diyaa. patrika key saath unakaa sambandh kathin thaa, aur collum juuna 2010 key ank mein samaapt huaa. baad mein unhone iss anubhav key baare mein kahaa kii "jiss sampaadak ney mujhe kaam parr rakhaa thaa, usaki jagah cumm sahaanubhooti vaale ney leey lii thee...). unhone mujhe 200 shabdon taka seemit curr diyaa aur mujhe bataana chaahte they kii vaastav mein kyaa likhana haye aur kyaa kahana haye. main antim sampaadit sanskaran koo apane lekhan key roop mein bhee naheen pehchaan sakaa."
holl board mein thaa aur 2009 mein gathit chikitsa mein vigyaan sansthaan kii sansthaapak sadasya thee. 2010 mein vaha sandehpurna jaanch key liye samiti kii ack sadasya chuni gaee thee.
21 agast, 2010 koo holl koo apani 10veen varshgaanth samaroh key dauran aaee. aaee. jee. seey sandeh key kshetra mein unake yogdan koo maanyata dete hue ack puraskar seey sammaanit kiya gayaa thaa.
holl ney berlin mein 6 veen vishva sanshayvaadi congress mein bhee baat kii, "poorak aur vaikalpik chikitsaah purry kathaa vigyaan aur placebo chikitsa.
2015 mein unhone james randy ajucational foundation dwara commission kii gaee "vigyaan adharit chikitsa" sheershak seey ack youtube vyakhyan shrinkhala prakaashit kii. ise vigyaan-adharit aur sakshya-adharit chikitsa, cam, chiroprectic, acupuncture, homyopathy, praakritik chikitsa aur herble chikitsa, oorjaa chikitsa, vividh "vikalp", anusandhaan mein nuksan, aur media aur rajneeti mein vigyaan-adharit chikitsa key beach antar key baare mein 10 vyakhyanon seey yukt ack pathyakram key roop mein prastut kiya jaataa haye.
2018 seey, holl ney "sandehpurna poochtaachhkartaa" mein ack niyamit collum prakaashit kiya jise "vaastaviktaa sabse achchi dawa haye" kahaa jaataa haye.
vaikalpik chikitsa kii aalochana.
holl vaikalpik chikitsa key ack mukhar aalochak they, joe aksar isaki prabhavsheelta parr sawal uthaate they. "aggar yeh vaastav mein prabhaavi dikhaaya gayaa, tou yeh niyamit dawa kaa hissa hoga."apane kaam mein unhone kissy bhee upaay key paksh yaa virodh mein vaigyaanik sakshya kaa paalan karane key mahatva parr jore diyaa. jaba shitrodhi upchaar key baare mein poochha gayaa tou unhone kahaa, "havaa mein honey vaale chikan soop key liye havaa mein honey vaale soop kii tulanaa mein adhik saboot hain. havaa mein chalane key daavon kaa samarthan karane key liye kissy bhee vishvasaniya dohare-andhe adhyayan key abhaav mein, main haath dhone parr adig rahoonga."unhone yuu kii bhee aalochana kii.aiss. acupuncture key upayog key liye senaa ney kahaa, "yeh vichaar kii kissy key kaana mein suiyaan dalna morphin jaisi cheejon kaa vikalp banane vaalaa haye, sirf hasyaspad haye."
holl ney saarvajanik roop seey daniel jee kii sifaarishon aur utpaadon kii aalochana kii. quackwatch" aur anya jagahon parr ack lekh mein, "aamen kii sifaarishen vigyaan, samanya gyaan aur tark kii avahelana karati hain."unhone andreau wheel sahit vaikalpik upchaaron key kaee anya prastavakon kii bhee aalochana kii.
holl "quackwatch" key salaahkaar honey key saath-saath ack sahayogi sampaadak aur "vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" blogg key aksar lekhak they.
2022 mein, holl ney bachchon kii ack pustak prakaashit kii jiska naam thaa "daant purry jaisi koee cheez naheen haye!"una bachchon key baare mein joe daant purry key astitva parr bahas karate hain. holl ney pahale "tooth fairy science" shabd gadhaa thaa taaki isake astitva koo sthaapit karane seey pahale ack ghatana kaa adhyayan kiya jaa sakey.
holl ney apane "scapdock key niyam" parr jore diyaa, joe kahata haye, "isase pahale kii aap kissy daave parr vishvaas karein, yeh pataa lagaayen kii kaun isase asahmat haye aur kyon."vaha vistaar seey bataati haye", ack baar jaba aap virodhi tarkon kaa pataa lagaa lete hain tou aap mulyankan curr sakate hain kii kiss paksh key paas sabse vishvasaniya saboot aur sabse cumm taarkik galatiyan hain. aamtaur parr vijeta koo dhoondhana aasaan hotaa haye."
holl ney dridhata seey kewal ack maanak sakshya kii vakaalat keeh
vivadaspad pustak sameeksha.
15 juuna, 2021 koo, holl ney "vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" (aiss. bee. aim.) mein "aparivartaniya kshati" kii ack pustak sameeksha prakaashit kii, jisamen kahaa gayaa haye kii pustak "kuchh khatarnak tathyon koo saamane laati haye jinn parr gaur karane kii sakht aavashyakta haye", kii bachchon mein ling vikaar key liye sakaratmak dekhbhal model ack galati aur kartavya kii upeksha haye ", aur vartamaan raajneetik jalavaayu ney inn mamalon key vaigyaanik adhyayan koo lagbhag asambhav banaa diyaa haye.
dou dinon key bheetar, sameeksha koo hataa diyaa gayaa aur steven novella aur david gorsky dwara likhit ack vaapsee soochana key saath pratisthaapit kiya gayaa. unhone kahaa kii bachchon mein ling vikaar seey nipatane key liye swaasthya protocol koo galat tareeke seey prastut kiya gayaa thaa aur tark diyaa kii ling vikaar nidan mein vriddhi koo samajik sankraman key siddhant kaa ahwan kiye binaa samajhaaya jaa sakata haye, saath hii yeh bhee kahaa jaa sakata haye kii ling-pushti dekhbhal key peechhe kaa vigyaan ingit kartaa haye kii yeh mansik swaasthya mein sudhaar kartaa haye. upanyasika aur gorsky ney iss baat parr jore diyaa kii holl abhee bhee "vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" mein achchi sthiti mein ack sampaadak thaa, aur achche vigyaan koo badhaava dene key unake itihas kii prashansa kii.
"vigyaan-adharit chikitsa" ney ell. jee. bee. tii. kyu. + swaasthya dekhbhal mein visheshagyata rakhane vaale doctors key lekhon kii ack shrinkhala bhee prakaashit kii, joe pustak aur holl kii sakaratmak sameeksha kii aalochana karate they. kaee sandehiyon ney holl kaa samarthan kiya, jisamen vikaasvaadi jeevvigyaani jairi coyne aur aiss. bee. aim. key emeritus emeritus kimball atwood shamil they, jinhone aiss. bee. aim. koo holl kii sameeksha koo banaae rakhane kii salah dee aur ise sensor karane key novella aur gorsky key faisale kii aalochana kii. jaba patrakaar jesse single ney upanyaas aur gorsky dwara holl key mool lekh koo vaapas lene aur anuvarti lekhon kii tathyaatmak sateekta kii aalochana kii, tou unaki aalochana koo bhee aalochana kaa saamana karna padaa.
shriyar kii pustak kii holl kii sameeksha koo sandeh mein punah prakaashit kiya gayaa thaa.comm, aur ack adyatan sanskaran joe aalochanaon kaa jawab detaa haye, usaki vyaktigat website parr prakaashit kiya gayaa thaa.
vyaktigat jeevan aur mrityu.
fraansis ee. vaaran vayu senaa adde parr, vaha kirk albert holl, junier seey millie aur unase shaadi kii. (vayu senaa seey bhee sevaanivritt). donon kii dou betiyaan theen.
baad mein jeevan mein, holl washington key puyalap mein rahata thaa. apane antim varshon mein vaha ataalata aur hriday gati rukane seey peedit theen. 11 janwari, 2023 koo 77 varsh kii ayu mein unaki neend mein mrityu hoe gaee.
chayanit prakaashan.
iss lekh mein ullikhit mukhya baatein aur prakaashanah

