jenin, jenin

jenin, jenin ack pramukh philistine key abhineta aur israel key nagrik mohammad bakri dwara nirdeshit ack film haye, jise becker ney "jenin kii ladaai" key baare mein "philistine kii sachchai" koo chitrit karane key liye, aprail 2002 mein israel kii senaa aur philistiniyon key beach ack sangharsh.
prishthabhoomi.
dou alag-alag hamalon mein 18 israeliyon key maare jaane key ack maheene baad, aur netanya mein ack aatmghaati bambari mein 30 logon kii maut aur 140 ghayal honey key kuchh dinon baad, israel key raksha balon ney 30,000 aarakshit sainikon koo bulaaya aur operation rakshaatmak dhaal shuru kii.
aprail 2002 mein operation rakshaatmak dhaal key dauran, israeli raksha balon (aaee. dee. aff.) ney jenin mein ack philistine key sharanarthi shivir parr aakraman kiya. israeli senaa ney ladaai key dauran "suraksha karanon" key liye patrakaron aur manvadhikar sangathanon koo shivir mein pravesh karane kii anumati dene seey incar curr diyaa, jisase afvaahon kaa ack teji seey chakr shuru hoe gayaa kii ack narsamhar huaa thaa. aakraman key baad jenin kaee dinon taka seal rhaa. nagrikon koo unake gharon mein jinda dafan kiye jaane kii kahaaniyan, jaba unhein dhwast curr diyaa gayaa thaa, aur kuchale gaye shavon koo dhakane vaali imaraton kii, joe arab duniya bhar mein fail gaee thee. vibhinn hatahaton key aankade prasaarit kiye gaye, ack varishth philistini adhikaari ney israel parr shivir mein 500 seey adhik logon key narsamhar kaa aarop lagaaya. gair-tathya-khoj mission koo israel dwara jenin mein pravesh karane kii anumati naheen dee gaee thee.
bakri ney 2002 mein jenin parr israel key aakraman key dauran ack chauki parr ack ahinsak pradarshan mein bhaag liya aur jaba israeli sainikon ney bheed parr goli chalaai tou vaha hairan reh gaye, jisase unake buggle mein khade ack saathi abhineta ghayal hoe gaye. vaha darshakon koo bataata haye kii iss anubhav ney usey ack cameray key saath jenin mein ghusane key liye prerit kiya aur nivaasiyon seey poochha, "kyaa huaa?parinam vrittachitra" "jenin jenin" "thaa, jisamen kaee tarah kii gawahi dee gaee thee, joe bataati thee kii vaastav mein ack narsamhar huaa thaa. bakri ney philistiniyon key drishtikon koo aavaaj dee joe shahar kii sealing key kaaran media taka naheen pahunchega; parinamswarup unhone film key liye israel key adhikaariyon kaa sakshatkar naheen lene kaa faisala kiya.
manvadhikar nigrani jaanch mein "jenin sharanarthi shivir mein aaee. dee. aff. dwara badey paimaane parr narsamhar yaa gair-nyaayik nishpaadan key daavon koo banaae rakhane key liye koee saboot naheen milaa", halanki unhone bataaya kii "israeli balon ney antarrashtriya maanviya kaanoon kaa gambhir ullanghan kiya, joe kii kuchh pratham drishtaya yuddh apraadhon key barabar haye. yuddh apraadhon key aarop koo antarrashtriya maafi dwara dohraya gayaa thaa. jenin mein ladaai key dauran, philistine key pravaktaon, manvadhikar sangathanon aur videshi patrakaron ney israel parr ack nagrik narsamhar karane kaa aarop lagaaya. israeli aankade bataate hain kii israeli aakraman key dauran 53 aur 56 philistiniyon key beach maare gaye they, aur jahir taur parr unamen seey aadhe seey adhik sashastr ladaake honey kaa sandeh thaa."israel iss baat seey sahmat haye kii lagbhag 50 philistiniyon kii mrityu hoe gaee, lekin iss ghatana koo ack ladaai key roop mein varnit kartaa haye aur ladaakon aur nagrikon kii nikatata parr nagrik mauton koo doshi thaharaata haye. 23 israeli sanic maare gaye.
film key sheershak mein philistine key taxi chalakon koo "ramallah, ramallah, ramallah" yaa "jenin!" kahaa gayaa thaa. jaine!"philistine key shramikon aur yaatriyon key liye joe israel kii chaukiyon seey gujar rahey hain. bakri ney film key nirmaata, ayad samaudi koo samarpit kiya, joe paschimi tata key jenin governor mein all-yamune mein israeli sainikon dwara maare gaye they, filmancan samaapt honey key turant baad. aaee. dee. aff. ney kahaa kii samaudi all-aksa shahidon kii brigade kaa ack sashastr sadasya thaa.
film kii samagri.
film mein koee kathakar yaa maargdarshak naheen haye aur isamen kewal nirmaata dwara sampaadit jenin key nivaasiyon key saath sakshatkar shamil hain.
vivaad.
aadhikarik pada.
kuchh pradarshanon key baad, film koo israeli film rating board dwara iss aadhar parr pratibandhit curr diyaa gayaa thaa kii yeh apmaanjanak thee aur janata koo aahat curr sakati haye. isake jawab mein bakri ney piyare rehov dwara banaai gaee ack jawabi pratikriya vrittachitra "dha road too jenin" kii screening kaa virodh kiya. adalat ney iss bayaan key tahat unake anurodh koo khariz curr diyaa kii filmon key beach sambandh key baare mein daave kii parwah kiye binaa, "dha road too jenin" kii screening seey incar karane kaa koee kanuni aadhar naheen haye. pratibandh key bavjood israel mein tail avive aur jerusalam cinemathec ney bakri kii film dikhaai.
bakri ney pratibandh koo adalat mein leey jaaya aur israel kii sarvocch adalat ney faisale koo palat diyaa. sarvocch nyayalaya key nyayadhish dalia dorner key anusaarah "yeh tathya kii film mein jhooth shamil haye, pratibandh koo sahee thaharaane key liye paryaapt naheen haye", unhone nihit kiya kii yeh darshakon parr nirbhar kartaa haye kii way joe dekhate hain usaki vyakhya karein, mammonides uddharan kaa hawala dete hueh "aur buddhi key saath aadami koo sachchai aur jhooth key beach antar karna hoga."appeal parr, sarvocch nyayalaya key faisale parr roque lagaa dee gaee thee, lekin agast 2004 mein sarvocch nyayalaya ney pratibandh koo palatane kii pushti karate hue kahaa kii film board kaa" "sachchai parr ekadhikar naheen haye. halanki sarvocch nyayalaya ney film koo ack "prachaarvaadi jhooth" key roop mein varnit kiya, lekin faisale ney pushti kii kii kahani key 'donon pakshon' koo naheen dikhaane kaa chayan censorship key liye aadhar naheen haye.
manhani kaa mukadama.
jenin mein seva karane vaale paanch israeli aarakshit sainikon ney 2002 mein bakhri key khilaf manhani key liye mukadama daayar kiya aur tark diyaa kii film ney unake achche naamon koo badnam kiya thaa. film mein vaadi kaa ullekh naheen kiya gayaa thaa. nyayadhish ney mamle koo khariz karate hue faisala sunaaya kii jabaki film vaastav mein israeli sainikon kii ninda karati haye, paanch israeli sainikon koo "vyaktigat roop seey" badnam naheen kiya gayaa thaa aur iss prakaar una parr mukadama karane kaa koee aadhar naheen thaa. nyayadhish ney apane faisale mein kahaa kii bakri ney "achchha vishvaas" naheen dikhaaya thaa, koee gawah naheen laaya thaa, aur apane daave koo saabit naheen kiya thaa kii unake aaropon koo manvadhikar samoohon kii reports dwara samarthit kiya gayaa thaa.
saarvajanik aalochak.
dow. david zangen, joe operation rakshaatmak sheeled (jerusalam mein hadassah vishvavidyalaya aspatal mein baal chikitsa endocrinology key pramukh) key dauran jenin mein idf key liye mukhya chikitsa adhikaari they, ney "seven lies about jenin" sheershak seey ack saarvajanik bayaan jaari kiya, jisamen unhone jerusalam cinemathec mein film key ack niji premiere screening mein apani yatra key baare mein vyaktigat vivaran diyaa. apane bayaan mein, unhone 7 visangatiyon kaa hawala diyaa jinhen unhone darshakon key saamane uthaane kii ummeed kii thee, jinhone unhein dusare bindu seey aage nikalane kii sambhavana seey incar curr diyaa thaa. unhone daavaa kiya kii bakri ney 'kushalata seey ack kachcha, bhale hii achchi tarah seey kiya gayaa, herfer' kiya haye kii banaai gaee vikrit tasveer mein aakarshit naheen honah mushkil haye; aur vaha aashcharyachakit thaa kii darshak apane swayam key khaaton koo sunane key liye taiyar naheen they, ack vyakti joe 'shaaririk roop seey' vahaan thaa. angreji bhasha mein vitarit sanskaran koo mool film seey sanshodhit kiya gayaa haye, aur kuchh samasyagrast drishyon koo hataa diyaa gayaa haye.
raksha.
mohammad bakri raksha samiti kaa tark haye kii "iss mamle kaa mahatva ack vyakti key roop mein bakri seey parey taka pahunch jaataa haye", joe philistine kii aatm-abhivyakti key daman key barabar haye. newyork mein apani navintam film kii screening mein, ack pareshan darshak sadasya ney bakri kaa saamana inn aaropon seey kiya kii "jenin, jenin" ney aakraman key atyacharon koo ack tarfa drishtikon prastut kiya, aur bakri ney jawab diyaa kii unhone "saikadon filmein dekhi theen joe nakaarati hain aur andekhi karati hain kii joe huaa thaa philistiniyon key saath, phir bhee kabhi shikayat naheen kii yaa kissy bhee film parr pratibandh lagaane kii koshish naheen kii."
bakri aur unaki film key liye bachaav kii mukhya pankti yeh haye kii, jaisa kii sarvocch nyayalaya ney paaya, kahani key 'donon pakshon' koo naheen dikhaane kaa chayan censorship key liye aadhar naheen haye. bakri kaa pratinidhitva vakeel avigdor feldman curr rahey hain, jinhone "haaretz" koo bataaya, "bakri iss film mein kuchh naheen kahati haye. joe loga baat karate hain way way hain jinhen unhone filmaya thaa. isaliye sharanarthi shivir key nivasi aisee baatein kahate hain joe kabhi sach hoti hain aur kabhi naheen. yeh ack film haye. yeh vaktaaon kii vyaktiparak samajh koo darshaata haye. kabhi-kabhi way aisee baatein kahate hain joe [vaastav mein una seey adhik] kathor hoti hain kyonki unhone ise iss tarah seey anubhav kiya thaa."
mohammad bakri raksha samiti aage kahati haih "apani kalaatmak akhandata aur apane saathi philistiniyon key anubhavon aur aakhyanon parr dhyaan kendrit karane key liye, mohammad bakri nakali kanuni aaropon aur manhani key sandigdh daavon key saamane vittiya vinash kii sambhavana kaa saamana karate hain."sabse haal key aaropon mein bachaav paksh key liye tark kaa ack pramukh ghatak yeh haye kii vaadi, bennatan, doron kedaar, nir oshree, aadam arbiv aur yonnatan vaan-caspel mein seey kissy kaa bhee naam yaa film mein ullekh naheen kiya gayaa haye.
doosara manhani kaa mukadama aur pratibandh.
navambar 2016 mein, israeli senaa key aarakshit adhikaari nisim magnigi ney film parr manhani key liye bakri parr laude jilaa adalat mein mukadama daayar kiya. jabaki pichhale manhani key mukadame koo film mein vishesh roop seey vaadi kii pehchaan naheen honey key kaaran khariz curr diyaa gayaa thaa, magnigi koo manhani key mukadame key liye kanuni aadhar paaya gayaa kyonki vaha film mein dikhaai diye they. janwari 2021 mein, adalat ney magney key manhani key daave koo sweekaar curr liya aur film parr pratibandh koo bahaal curr diyaa. bakri koo 175,000 rupaye key muaavaje key saath-saath kanuni kharchon mein 50,000 rupaye dene kaa adesh diyaa gayaa thaa.
puraskar aur namankan.
"jenin, jenin" koo tunis mein 2002 key carthage antarrashtriya film mahotsav mein "sarvshreshth film" aur bhoomadhyasagariya vrittachitra nirmaan aur reporting key liye 2003 kaa antarrashtriya puraskar diyaa gayaa thaa.

