
aar (jee. see.) banaam mahanagar kii pulis kaa commander

aar (jee. see. key aavedan parr) banaam mahanagar key pulis aayukt [2011] yuu. key. aiss. see. 21 united kingdam key sarvocch nyayalaya kaa 2011 kaa faisala thaa. yeh mamla una vyaktiyon seey judey biometric detta koo anishchit kaal key liye banaae rakhane kii pulis kii shakti seey sambandhit thaa, jinn parr abb aaparaadhik aparaadh kaa sandeh naheen haye. iss mamle mein, adalat key adhyaksh lord phillips aur lord cheef justice lord jaj sahit sarvocch nyayalaya key adhikansh ney uchch nyayalaya key pahale key faisale koo ulat diyaa aur paaya kii 'asadharan paristhitiyon' key abhaav mein dna sakshya banaae rakhane kii pulis bull kii neeti gairkaanooni thee aur manvadhikaron parr europeeya sammelan key anuchhed 8 kaa ullanghan thaa. adalat ney halanki kissy bhee vishisht raahat kii peshkash karane seey incar curr diyaa, yeh maanate hue kii neeti swatantrata sanrakshan vidheyak 2011 key bhaag 1 key roop mein vidhaayi jaanch key adheen honey kii ummeed haye.
tathya.
mamla dou vyaktiyon (jinhen naam naa chhaapane kii anumati dee gaee thee) key avedanon seey sambandhit thaa, jinhen aaparaadhik apraadhon kaa sandeh thaa aur baad mein unhein burry curr diyaa gayaa thaa. donon vyaktiyon ney pulis bull seey dee. aine. aeye. aur anya biometric detta koo nasht karane kaa anurodh kiya thaa, jise pulis bull ney apane paas rakhaa thaa, pulis ney ack aeye. see. pee. oh. dishanirdesh kaa hawala dete hue donon anurodhon koo aswikar curr diyaa, jisamen kewal 'asadharan paristhitiyon' mein biometric detta koo nasht karane kii anumati dee gaee thee. donon vyaktiyon ney pulis key faisale kii nyaayik sameeksha key liye uchch nyayalaya mein ack aavedan kiya. choonki adalat house off lords udaaharan seey bandhi thee-"aar (aiss) banaam south yorkshire key mukhya sipahi" [2004] aur 39-unhone aavedan koo aswikar curr diyaa, lekin sarvocch nyayalaya mein ack chhalang appeal key liye anumati dey dee.
nirnay.
sarvocch nyayalaya mein, mamle key pakshon aur swatantrata, samaantaa aur manvadhikar aayog aur grih vibhaag sahit hastakshep karane vaale pakshon seey 31 janwari aur 1 farwari 2011 koo sunavaai parr daleelen sunee gaeen. adalat ney 18 maee 2011 koo nirnay vaapas curr diye. jabaki adalat "aar (aiss) banaam dakshin yorkshire key mukhya sipahi" mein nirnay koo palatane mein sarvasammat thee aur europeeya manvadhikar adalat key 'aiss aur marper banaam united kingdam' (2009) seey nishkarsh kii pushti karate hue kii pulis kii biometric detta koo banaae rakhane kii neeti una vyaktiyon seey thee jinhen yaa tou aparaadh seey burry curr diyaa gayaa thaa, yaa jinake khilaf aarop hataa diye gaye they, manvadhikaron parr europeeya sammelan key anuchhed 8 key saath "vaastavik" asangat thaa, adalat key sadasya apane tark parr bhinn they.
lord dyson key netritva mein bahumat ney mahsoos kiya kii apco dishanirdesh, jiss parr pulis ney bharosa kiya thaa aur jisane pulis pramukhon key vivek koo banaae gaye sakshya koo nasht karane key liye kaafee hudd taka pratibandhit curr diyaa thaa, anuchhed 8 key saath sangat naheen thaa. adhikansh ney manvadhikar adhiniyam 1998 key praavdhaanon key sanyojan mein aiss64 pulis aur aaparaadhik sakshya adhiniyam 1984 (gati) padhaa aur nirdhaarit kiya kii apco dishanirdesh praathamik kaanoon key saath sangat naheen thaa aur iss prakaar gairkaanooni thaa. isaliye unhone appeal kii anumati dee, halanki unhone kissy bhee detta koo nasht karane kii aavashyakta vaalaa koee adesh paarit naheen kiya kyonki yeh sweekaar kiya gayaa thaa kii vidhaayika seey nikat bhavishya mein ack adhiniyam paarit karane kii ummeed haye joe biometric detta koo banaae rakhane kii pulis kii kshamata koo seemit curr dega.
lord braun aur lord rodger seey milkar baney alpasankhyak ney apeelon koo khariz curr diyaa hoga. jabaki way saiddhaantik roop seey sahmat they kii pulis neeti anuchhed 8 key saath sangat naheen thee, unhone tark diyaa kii aiss64 gati swayam parampara key saath sangat naheen thee, aur pulis key paas praasangik detta koo banaae rakhane key alawa koee vikalp naheen thaa. choonki ingland aur wells kii nyaypalika key paas iss adhiniyam jaise praathamik kaanoon kii sameeksha karane kii koee shakti naheen haye, isaliye unhone praavdhaanon key sambandh mein asangatata kii ghoshana jaari kii hogi.

