
nange chehare masiha

nange chehare maseehaah ell kii sachchi kahani. ronn hubbard vaigyaanik vigyaan key sansthaapak ell. kii maranoparant jeevani haye. british patrakaar russell miller dwara runn hubbard. 26 octuber 1987 koo pahali baar united kingdam mein prakaashit, yeh pustak ack mahatvapurna pariprekshya letee haye, jisamen church off scientology key hubbard key jeevan aur kaary key khaate koo chunauti dee gaee haye. yeh soochana kii swatantrata adhiniyam kaa upayog karke praapt aadhikarik dastavejon aur hubbard key vyaktigat kaagjaaton seey vyaapak roop seey uddhrit kartaa haye, joe vaigyaanik vigyaan seey ack pakshapaati key madhyam seey praapt kiye gaye they. yeh australia, kanada aur sanyukt raajya america mein bhee prakaashit huaa thaa.
pustak kii sameekshaaen motey taur parr sakaratmak rahee hain-ack ise "ell kii sabse achchi aur sabse vyaapak jeevani" kahata haye. ronn hubbard "-aur miller key shodh kii gunavatta aur gaharaai kii prashansa karate hain.
church off scientology ney pustak key prakaashan kaa kadaa virodh kiya. sangathan parr miller aur usake prakaashak key khilaf ack kalank aur utpeedan abhiyaan aayojit karane kaa aarop lagaaya gayaa thaa, halanki isane iss aarop kaa jordar khandan kiya, aur abhiyaan mein shamil ack niji janchkarta ney iss baat seey incar kiya kii sangathan uska muvakkil thaa. haalaanki, 1990 mein press koo aantarik vaigyaanik dastavejon key leak ney abhiyaan key kaee vivaranon kaa khulasa kiya. sangathan aur sambandhit corporate sansthaon ney adalat mein pustak key prakaashan koo rokane kaa prayaas kiya, jisake parinamswarup sanyukt raajya america key sarvocch nyayalaya, ingland aur wells kii appeal kii adalat aur kanada kii sanghiya adalat taka pahunchane vaale mamle saamane aae. yuu.aiss. pustak key aprakaashit sroton key upayog key liye uchit upayog sanrakshan seey incar karate hue, ack nichali adalat key faisale koo sweekaar karane key liye sarvocch nyayalaya key nirnay ney jeevanikaron kii abhivyakti kii swatantrata parr aprakaashit samagri key copyrite sanrakshan key paksh mein ack udaaharan sthaapit kiya. britten aur kanada kii adalaton ney ack vipareet drishtikon apanaaya, jisase saarvajanik hita mein "nange chehare key masiha" key prakaashan kii anumati millie.
prishthabhoomi aur saransh.
russell miller "ravivaar key samay" key liye ack khoji patrakaar rahey they aur unhone hyug hefner ("banni", 1984 mein prakaashit) aur jey. paul getty ("dha house off getty", 1985). yeye sex, paisa aur dharm parr ack trayi kii pahali dou jeevani theen, jisamen hubbard pustak ney trayi koo puuraa kiya. unhone dou saal iss pustak parr shodh karane mein bitaaye, joe octuber 1984 mein prakaashit church off scientology kii "sandey times patrika" kii jaanch key baad aaee thee. 1985 mein, unhone sujhaav diyaa kii "ravivaar key samay" koo hubbard koo khojane kii koshish karni chaahiye, joe kaee saal pahale saarvajanik drishtikon seey gayab hoe gaee thee. yadi pariyojana safal hoe jaati haye, tou yeh samachar patra key liye ack vishvavyaapi khoj hogi. aggar yeh ack vishisht vaigyaanik netaa naheen bhee paataa haye, tou bhee nirantar rahasya apane aap mein ack achchi kahani hogi. yuu mein poorv-vaigyaanikon key beach sampark key madhyam seey.aiss.miller ney usa kshetra koo sankuchit curr diyaa jahan hubbard saine luis obispo, california key aspas chhipa huaa thaa. haalaanki, janwari 1986 mein miller dwara apani pariyojana koo puuraa karane seey pahale hii hubbard kii mrityu hoe gaee. unhone iss bindu parr "ravivaar key samay" key liye lekhon kii pahale seey sahmat shrinkhala likhane key alawa, hubbard kii poorna jeevani key aadhar key roop mein apane shodh kaa upayog karane kaa faisala kiya.
"nange chehare vaale masiha" mein 1911 seey laker, jaba hubbard kaa janm huaa thaa, 1986 mein unaki mrityu taka kii avadhi shamil haye, jisamen unake parivarik itihas parr kuchh atirikt prishthabhoomi haye. isamen unake praarambhik jeevan, 1930 aur 1940 key dashak mein ack vigyaan kathaa lekhak key roop mein unaki safalata, dusare vishva yuddh key dauran unake sainya currier, 1950 key dashak mein dynetics aur vaigyaanik vigyaan kaa uday, 1960 aur 1970 key dashak kii shuruat mein apane anuyaayiyon key saath samudra mein unaki yatra aur 1970 key dashak key madhya seey 1986 taka kii avadhi key roop mein unaki kanuni samasyaaen aur avadhi kaa varnan kiya gayaa haye. lekhak pahale aprakaashit samagri, jaise kii hubbard kii kishore diarry aur sahyogiyon, niyoktaon aur aff. bee. aaee. key saath-saath sarkari dastavejon jaise hubbard kii sainya seva record aur aff. bee. aaee. file parr dhyaan aakarshit kartaa haye. ack "lekhak key nott" mein, miller likhate hain kii soochana kii swatantrata adhiniyam key binaa pustak asambhav hoti. pustak mein uddhrit niji patron mein hubbard dwara aff. bee. aaee. koo likhaa gayaa ack patra haye jisamen vaha apani patni koo soviyat jasus key roop mein ninda kartaa haye, ack aur jisamen vaha apani betty alexes koo bataata haye kii vaha vaastav mein uska pitaa naheen haye aur ack aantarik patra jisamen vaha sujhaav detaa haye kii vaigyaanik koo vyaavsaayik karanon seey dhaarmik sthiti kaa peechha karna chaahiye. miller dwara upayog kiye jaane vaale anya sroton mein samachar lekh aur sakshatkaron seey tippaniyan shamil hain joe unhone hubbard key puraane parichiton aur parivaar key sadasyon key saath kiye they.
miller key shodh mein hubbard key vyaktigat patron key ack samooh dwara sahaayata kii gaee thee, joe church off scientology key ack asantusht poorv karmchari, gairi armstrong dwara praapt kiye gaye they. armstrong hubbard kii aadhikarik jeevani key liye samagri taiyar curr rhaa thaa, lekin 1981 mein yeh pataa chalane key baad kii hubbard key apane jeevan key baare mein daave swatantra sroton key saath virodhabhasi they, usane vaigyaanik sangathan chhod diyaa. church off scientology ney dastavejon koo aage vitarit karane seey rokane key liye california mein ack adesh praapt kiya. haalaanki, angreji adalaton ney iss adesh koo lagu karane seey incar curr diyaa.
pustak kii prastaavana mein, miller ney hubbard key baare mein apane vichaar koo sankshep mein bataayah
yeh pustak hubbard key miller key shodh key saath virodhabhas karati haye. udaaharan key liye, adhyaay 6, jiska sheershak haye "naayak joe kabhi naheen thaa", aadhikarik church jeevani kaa hawala dete hue shuru hotaa haih "1941 mein americi nausena dwara yuddh seey pahale commission kiya gayaa thaa... dwiteeya vishva yuddh key sabhi paanch theatres mein seva karate hue aur 21 padak aur hatheliyaan praapt karate hue..."aur yeh jawabi kaarravaai key saath samaapt hotaa haih yadi unake yuddh key anubhavon key baare mein unake apane khaate parr vishvaas kiya jaae, tou vaha nishchit roop seey una 21 padak aur hatheliyon key hakdar they joe unhein praapt hue they. durbhagya seey, unake americi nausena record seey sanket milata haye kii unhein kewal chaar niyamit padak seey sammaanit kiya gayaa thaa-americi raksha seva padak, motee bandargah key samay seva karane vaale sabhi logon koo pradaan kiya gayaa, americi abhiyaan padak, asiai-prashant abhiyaan padak aur vishva yuddh dou vijay padak, yeh antim baar vee-jey divas parr seva karane vaale sabhi logon dwara praapt kiya gayaa thaa. 
hubbard key sainya currier key baare mein bahas key baare mein adhik jaankaari key liye, mukhya lekh dekhein.
hubbard key anuyaayiyon kii pratikriya.
lekhak aur prakashakon kaa utpeedan.
church off scientology ney miller key saath sabhi sahyog seey incar curr diyaa aur unake shodh mein baadha daalane kii maang kii. unhone pustak key shuru mein apane "lekhak key nott" mein likhaah
miller koo apana kaam shuru karane seey pahale hii chetavani dee gaee thee kii usey kathinaaiyon kaa saamana karna padegaa, lekin vaha utpeedan key star key liye taiyar naheen thaa joe usane sahan kiya. yuu mein pustak parr shodh karate hue.aiss.usaki jasusi kii gaee aur lagaatar uska peechha kiya gayaa. unake doston aur vyaavsaayik sahyogiyon koo bhee vaigyaanik aur niji jasuson seey shatrutapurna mulakat millie joe una parr "gandagi" khojane kii koshish curr rahey they. octuber 1987 mein, miller ney tippani keeh "yuu mein niji jasuson kii teemen hain.aiss. aur yeh desh merey doston seey sawal kartaa haye aur mujhe badnam karane kii koshish kartaa haye."dakshin landan mein ack niji jasus kii hatyaa, ack wiltshire vimaan karkhane mein aag lagane aur americi gaayak deane reed kii hatyaa mein usey fansaane key prayaas kiye gaye they. miller key sakshatkar key liye purvi berlin pahunchane seey ack dinn pahale reed kii mrityu hoe gaee thee. miller key parivaar seey niji jasuson ney sampark kiya thaa kii way usey reed kii maut mein fansaane kii maang curr rahey they, halanki way yeh naheen kahenge kii unakaa muvakkil kaun thaa. ack anya niji anveshak ney miller key doston aur sahyogiyon kaa sakshatkar liya, jisamen unhone daavaa kiya kii way reed key parivaar key liye kaam curr rahey they, halanki unhone unhein kaam parr rakhane seey incar curr diyaa. ack poorv vaigyaanik ney ravivaar key samay kahaa kii miller koo nirantar nigrani mein rakhaa jaataa haye. harr baar jaba vaha videsh jaataa haye tou havaai adde parr dou logon kaa ack mission uska intezar karega jaba vaha aayega. way nigrani karenge kii vaha kahaan jaataa haye, vaha kise dekhta haye, vaha kahaan rahata haye. yeh jaankaari unaki file mein jodee jaayegi, joe pahale seey hii 100 prishthon seey adhik motee haye."
prakashakon key varishth adhikaari michael joseph aur "ravivaar key samay", joe pustak koo dharavahik roop dete they, koo dhamki bharey phone coll aur niji anveshak eugene ingram seey mulakat praapt hui, joe church key liye kaam karate they. ack anya niji janchkarta, jaarl greave enar sinewolf ney "ravivaar key samay" key patrakaron koo bataaya kii unhein miller aur kendriya khufiya agency (see. aaee. aeye.) key beach ack kadee khojane key liye "badee raashi" kii peshkash kii gaee thee, kyonki church kaa kathit taur parr maanana thaa kii see. aaee. aeye. yuu. mein apane curr mamalon kii jaanch curr rhaa thaa.aiss. sinewolf key anusaar, miller key mell aur phone koo roque diyaa gayaa thaa aur usake ghar kii lagaatar nigrani kii jaa rahee thee. akhbar ney bataaya kii sinewolf ney apane reporter aur photographer kaa bristol kii sadakon parr peechha kiya thaa, ack pistaul key saath joe usane una parr chalaai thee, yeh kahate hue kii "behtar hoga kii abb aap lakadi key dibbe mein naa jaaen. kyaa aap ack aur bhookh key maare shaheed banana chaahte hain?"
1990 mein, pustak key pahale prakaashan key lagbhag teen saal baad, church off scientology key ack pakshapaati ney miller key khilaf smear abhiyaan kaa vivaran dene vaale aantarik dastavejon key saath "ravivaar key samay" pradaan kiya. inn abhilekhon mein kaee niji jaanchkartaon koo soochibaddh kiya gayaa thaa jinhen mill malik koo nigrani mein rakhane aur padosiyon aur pulis koo usake baare mein jhoothi jaankaari dene key liye kaam parr rakhaa gayaa thaa. ack vaigyaanik karyakari loss angils seey landan key ack flat mein gayaa thaa jahan usane aur ack niji jasus ney abhiyaan kaa samanvaya kiya thaa. prakaashak key karyalayon seey kachra niyamit roop seey flat key bathtub mein khaali kiya jaataa thaa taaki usey uthaaya jaa sakey. mukhbir key anusaar, jaanchkartaon ney usey ansuljhe apraadhon mein fansaane kii koshish karane key liye british pulis key saath sampark kaa istemal kiyaah "logon koo videsh seey patrakaron key roop mein scotland yard key saath sakshatkar kii vyavastha karane key liye laaya gayaa thaa, jahaan way miller key baare mein vyangya karate they. anya jaanchkartaon kaa upayog sahyogiyon, doston aur padosiyon key saath unake naam koo dhabba lagaane key liye kiya jaataa thaa. unhone iss rekha parr kadee mehnat kii kii vaha ack gupt british khufiya vyakti thaa."ack church key pravakta ney inn aaropon koo khariz karate hue kahaa," joe koee bhee aapako iss tarah kii jaankaari detaa haye, vaha pagal yaa drugs parr honah chaahiye."
kanuni vivaad.
church off scientology aur sambandhit sansthaon ney hubbard key niji dastavejon key copyrite ullanghan kaa daavaa karate hue pustak key prakaashan key khilaf nishedhagya kii maang kii. unhone pachas deshon mein mukadama karane kii dhamki dee, ack ranneeti apnai joe pensylvania vishvavidyalaya key professor paul key dwara apnai gaee thee. sant-prem ney "mukdamebaji kii ack antarrashtriya pared" aur "whack-aeye-moll kanuni kaaryavaahi" key roop mein varnit kiya haye. adhikansh vivaad vaadi key iss tark parr kendrit thaa kii aprakaashit samagri (chaahe pratyaksh yaa apratyaksh roop seey) miller koo pradaan karane mein poorv vaigyaanik puraatatvavid jairi armstrong key kaary church key prati unake vishvaas key kartavya kaa ullanghan they, aur iss samagri key anshon kaa upayog hubbard kii sampatti key swaamitva vaale copyrite kaa ullanghan kartaa thaa. miller ney baad mein nott kiya kii vaadi ney adalat mein pustak key tathyon parr vivaad karane kaa prayaas naheen kiya, joe, unhone kahaa, ack dayaa kii baat thee kyonki vaha apane saavdhaanipoorvak shodh kaa bachaav karane key liye tatpar they.
united kingdam.
pahala mukadama octuber 1987 mein nyaayamurti winloat dwara britten mein sunaa gayaa thaa. vaadiyon, california key vaigyaanik church, pustak key prakaashan key khilaf ack nishedhagya praapt karane mein whiffle rahey. 9 octuber 1987 key apane faisale mein, nyayadhish ney kahaa kii yeh spasht thaa kii saarvajanik hita vishvaas key kissy bhee kartavya seey kaheen adhik thaa joe shree key prati anumaanit roop seey deya hoe sakata thaa. hubbard yaa uska church."aprakaashit samagri koo" "aavashyak" "maanaa gayaa thaa yadi hubbard key shuruati currier kaa" "thheek seey mulyankan" "kiya jaanaa thaa, aur california mein armstrong key khilaf kanuni nirnay ack angreji adalat koo baadhya naheen curr sakate they. nyayadhish ney maanaa kii church ney dinn mein itani dair seey apana mukadama laane mein anuchit kaary kiya thaa. yeh maee mein "nange chehare masiha" koo prakaashit karane kii yojanaon key baare mein jagrook hoe gayaa thaa, lekin prakaashan seey ack maheene seey bhee cumm samay pahale, 29 sitambar taka mukadama naheen laaya thaa. unhone kahaa kii ack nishedhagya key liye aavedan, "ack aise samay mein kiya gayaa thaa, chaahe ganana kii gaee hoe yaa naheen, jaba penguin pustakon koo sabse badee sambhaavit kshati aur asuvidha hogi. deree key liye koee santoshjanak spashteekaran naheen diyaa gayaa thaa aur nyayadhish key vichaar mein, aavedan "damankari thaa, aur kissy bhee vaidh hita kii raksha key liye naheen laaya gayaa thaa."
22 octuber koo appeal kii adalat ney faisale koo barkarar rakhaa. lord justice fox key nirnay ney tark diyaa kii vaigyaanik vigyaan mein hubbard kaa "brahmandiya mahatva"-ack samooh joe khud 1972 mein ack sarkari report kaa vishay rhaa thaa-pustak kii samagri mein ack majboot saarvajanik ruchi kaa sanket detaa haye. nishedhagya key liye aavedan karane mein deree apane aap mein appeal koo khariz karane koo uchit thaharaane kaa kaaran thaa, lekin isake alawa adalat ney faisala sunaaya kii "janata kaa hita thaa kii tathya key daave [church dwara] koo saarvajanik aalochana key saamane laaya jaanaa chaahiye. sansthaapak marr chuka thaa aur samagri koo asatya naheen bataaya gayaa thaa."adalat ney nott kiya kii vaadi ney yeh tark naheen diyaa thaa kii pustak key prakaashan seey hubbard yaa church kii pratishtha koo nuksan pahunchega yaa yeh kissy bhee tarah seey manhanikarak thaa. church koo house off lords mein appeal karane key liye anumati dene seey incar curr diyaa gayaa thaa.
adalati mamle seey pahale, ack mahila vaigyaanik koo sent hill manner mein church off scientology key yuke mukhyalaya key paas east grinstead mein ack prati dukaan seey aprakaashit pramaan kii saat pratiyaan ekatra karate hue paaya gayaa thaa. usey giraftar curr liya gayaa thaa lekin baad mein usey riha curr diyaa gayaa kyonki chori kaa koee saboot naheen thaa.
kanada, australia aur dakshin africa.
kanada mein, nae yug key prakashanon-church off scientology kii ack shakha-ney disambar 1987 mein "nange chehare masiha" key prakaashan koo avaruddh karane key liye kanada kii sanghiya adalat mein yachika daayar kii. nae yug ney prakaashak kii pramukh kulee pustakon key mudran shuru karane kii yojana seey kuchh dinn pahale apana anurodh prastut kiya. company ney tark diyaa kii hubbard kii pustakon kii bikri usa nuksan seey pratikool roop seey prabhaavit hogi joe miller kii pustak seey hubbard kii pratishtha koo hoga. isane yeh bhee daavaa kiya kii hubbard dwara likhit aprakaashit samagri aur pustakon key anadhikrit ansh key madhyam seey copyrite kaa ullanghan kiya gayaa thaa, aur yeh usee samagri key aadhar parr ack "adhikrit" jeevani prakaashit karane kii nae yug kii apani yojanaon mein hastakshep karega. nae yug kii bolly koo justice budd cullon ney khariz curr diyaa, jinhone kahaa kii iss tarah key anurodh koo banaae rakhane key liye ack nishedhagya key paksh mein prastut sakshya "aavashyak sakshya seey bahut cumm haye". unhone hubbard koo "vichitra, murkhtapurna, dusht, naslavaadi lekhan" key lekhak key roop mein varnit kiya."pustak koo avaruddh karane key liye isi tarah kii boliyaan australia aur dakshin africa mein whiffle raheen.
sanyukt raajya america.
yuu mein ack soot laaya gayaa thaa.aiss. maee 1988 mein nae yug key prakashanon dwara, joe pahale seey hii prakaashit aur bheje jaane key baad, "nange chehare vaale masiha" koo vitarit honey seey rokane kii maang karate they. prakaashan seey pahale, nae yug ney "nange chehare masiha" key prakaashan adhikaar khareedane kii peshkash kii, lekin ise aswikar curr diyaa gayaa. prakaashak heinry holt ney nae yug key samay taka 12,500 pratiyaan vitarit kii theen, jinhone pahale print runn seey shesh pratiyon key shipment koo rokane key liye ack asthaayi pratibandh adesh praapt kiya thaa. maujooda pratiyon key vitaran key khilaf nishedhagya key liye nae yug key anurodh koo aswikar curr diyaa gayaa thaa. heinry holt key adhyaksh, bruno quinson ney apani company key mukadame seey ladane key iraade kii ghoshana keeh "yeh ack aisaa mamla haye, cumm seey cumm kahane key liye, jisamen gambhir pratham sanshodhan vichaar hain aur humm iss pustak key prakaashan koo rokane key liye vaigyaanik key prayason kaa jordar virodh curr rahey hain."
jilaa adalat ney joe pahali baar mamle kii sunavaai kii, usane faisala sunaaya kii halanki niji patrachar key uddharan ney copyrite kaanoon kaa ullanghan kiya haye, ack nishedhagya prakaashak key pahale sanshodhan adhikaaron seey incar karegi. sanyog seey, jiss nyayadhish ney mamle koo sunaa, vaha pier aine. leval, vahee vyakti thaa jisane haal hii mein lekhak jey key niji patrachar seey judey ack mamle kii sunavaai kii thee. dee. sallinger, jisake parinamswarup ack uchch nyayalaya ney ack vivadaspad misal sthaapit kii kii aprakaashit samagri koo uddhrit karane vaale karyon koo uchit upayog sanrakshan naheen diyaa jaa sakata thaa. unake faisale koo uchch nyayalaya key "sallinger" udaaharan key khandan key roop mein dekhaa gayaah "ack nishedhagya kaa anudan hoga... ack aise vyakti key dilchasp, achchi tarah seey shodhit, uttejak adhyayan koo dabaayen, joe vaigyaanik aur dhaarmik donon saakh kaa daavaa kartaa haye, jisane laakhon logon parr bhaari prabhaav daala haye."
jaba mamle kii appeal kii gaee, tou doosara circuit leval key faisale seey asahmat thaa, yeh tark dete hue kii copyrite abhivyakti kii swatantrata kii daleelon seey adhik haye. sanyog seey, nirnay key lekhak nyayadhish roser minor they, joe "sallinger" nirnay key lekhakon mein seey they. adalat ney "sallinger" key nishkarsh koo dohraya kii "aprakaashit kaary key uchit upayog key khilaf ack majboot dhaarana" thee aur aprakaashit praathamik srot samagri koo uchit upayog key daavon seey "samanya roop seey poorna suraksha kaa anand lena chaahiye". ise pahale sanshodhan dwara override naheen kiya jaa sakaa. phir bhee, adalat ney abhee bhee laache key aadhar parr ack nishedhagya seey incar curr diyaa, vishesh roop seey kii nae yug ney pustak key baare mein pahali baar jaanane key baad mamle koo laane key liye dou saal intezar kiya thaa. apane adhikaaron parr soney"-bahut lambe samay taka prateeksha karane seey-nae yug ney nyaaysangat raahat kaa koee bhee adhikaar khou diyaa thaa aur deree seey miller key prakaashak koo anuchit roop seey nuksan pahunchaaya thaa. nyayadhish james ell. oaks ack sahmat raay mein nirnay seey sahmat they, lekin tark diyaa kii bahumat ney bachaav key roop mein pahale sanshodhan koo aswikar karna galat thaa. unhone tark diyaa, "jimmedaar jeevanikaar aur itihaaskaar lagaatar praathamik sroton, patron, diarry aur gyapanon kaa upayog karate hain. vaastav mein, jaankaari key aise sroton koo nazarandaj karna "gairzimmedarana" hoga."
haalaanki way prabal they, heinry holt aur company ney appeal adalat key sabhi nyayadhishon seey yeh sthaapit karane key liye "aine baink" kii sunavaai key liye kahaa kii way sirf ack taknikita parr naheen jeete they. adalat ney 7-5 key bahumat seey iss anurodh koo aswikar curr diyaa. incar ney nyayadhishon key beach ack asamanya vibhajan paida kiya; chaar jinhone ack sunavaai kaa samarthan kiya, unhone kahaa kii unakaa maanana thaa kii "tathyon koo sateek aur nishpaksh roop seey report karane key liye kuchh aprakaashit abhivyakti kii pratilipi banaana" uchit upayog dwara cover kiya gayaa thaa, jabaki paanch jinhone iska virodh kiya, unhone usa prastaav koo khariz curr diyaa, yeh ghoshana karate hue kii "samanya paristhitiyon mein" "aprakaashit abhivyaktipurna samagri kii nyuntam matra seey adhik" kaa upayog ack swachaalit nishedhagya koo aakarshit karna chaahiye. mamle key baad iss tark kii vyaapak roop seey aalochana kii gaee thee. david jey. goldberg aur robbert jey. bernstein ney maee 1989 mein "newyork low journal" mein likhaa kii bahumat key vichaar key saath kendriya samasya yeh thee kih
1990 mein, heinry holt ney sarvocch nyayalaya mein yachika daayar kii, jisane dusare circuit key faisale koo khadaa honey diyaa. mamle key parinam ney prakashakon aur patrakaron seey ack chintit pratikriya aakarshit kii, jinhone shikayat kii kii jeevani koo prakaashit karna kanuni aur aarthik roop seey bahut adhik kathin hoe jaayega. paine american center aur lekhak sangh key liye ack sankshipt vivaran ney parinam parr prakaashan udyog key "bhram, ghabarahat aur chinta" koo vyakt kiya. americi itihaaskaar arther aim. schlessinger, junier. iss nirnay koo "ack bahut badaa dukh" kahaa, yeh tark dete hue kii aggar yeh pahale kiya jaataa, tou vaha apane itihas key sabhi teen khandon "roozvelt key yug" koo prakaashit naheen curr sakate they.
anta mein, heinry holt ney mukdamebaji koo chhod diyaa, kyonki chala rahee kanuni laagat asamarthaniya hoe rahee thee. yuu mein "nange chehare vaale masiha" kaa print runn.aiss. kewal 14,000 pratiyon key mudrit honey key baad samaapt hoe gayaa. kaee loga saarvajanik pustakalayon mein gaye, lekin, miller key anusaar, pustak kii kaee pustakalaya pratiyaan gayab hoe gaeen yaa vaigyaanik dwara unamen chipkai gaeen.
swaagat.
nange chehare vaale masiha" kii sameekshaaen samagr roop seey bahut sakaratmak theen, halanki kuchh sameekshakon ney aalochana kii kii way ise chook maanate hain.
miller kii or seey. church off scientology ney iss pustak kii bahut aalochana kii thee. miller kii pustak key baare mein isake drishtikon koo hubbard estate key nishpaadak dwara sankshep mein prastut kiya gayaa thaa, jinhone ise "ack scumbag book" kahaa thaa... murkhtapurna", jabaki kanada mein ack vaigyaanik pravakta ney isaki tulanaa "judas iskariyot dwara likhit masih key jeevan" seey kii."
dave langford ney "safed baune" key liye "nange chehare vaale masiha" kii sameeksha kii aur kahaa kii "merrie isaq asimov kii imandari aur imandari key baare mein uchch raay haih hubbard key vipareet, vaha hamesha sachchai key liye pratibaddh rhaa haye."
americi vigyaan lekhak martin gardner kii "prakriti" mein sameeksha koo "nange chehare vaale masiha" kahaa gayaa haye, joe ack "prashansaniya, saavdhaanipoorvak pralekhit jeevani" haye. gardner ney pahale apani 1952 kii classic pustak "vigyaan key naam parr sanak aur bhraantiyaan" mein vaigyaanik vigyaan kii shuruat key baare mein likhaa thaa, usa samay unhone hubbard koo ack haanirahit shararat key roop mein maanaa thaa, lekin miller kii pustak ney gardner koo raaji kiya kii hubbard "ack rogjanak jhoothaa thaa joe ack aakarshak badmash seey ack pagal ahankar mein lagaatar bigad gayaa thaa.
samajshastri jey. gorden melton ney stevert lamont key "dharm ink" key saath likhaa., miller kii pustak vaigyaanik alochakon dwara prakaashit pustakon mein" abb taka kii sabse achchi "haye, halanki unhone nott kiya kii vaigyaanik vigyaan key church ney" pratyek [thhos kathan] parr bayaan taiyar kiye hain joe tathyaatmak trutiyon aur chook kaa sanket dete hain."melton ney nishkarsh nikala kii miller kii pustak apane lekhak kii dastaavezon taka pahunch kii kamee seey samjhauta karati haye joe hubbard key jeevan aur church key praarambhik itihas koo chart karati haye. melton miller key iss daave parr vivaad karate hain kii hubbard apane sainya currier key baare mein jhooth boll rahee theeh "hubbard ney farwari 1946 mein 21 uddharanon, prashansa patron aur apane record parr padak key saath seva chhod dee. vaigyaanik vigyaan key alochakon dwara hubbard key nausainik currier key vivaran parr sawal uthaaye gaye hain. aalochak hubbard key algaav key notice kii kathit prati parr bharosa karate hain joe diggaj key prashaasan mein jamaa kii gaee thee aur soochana kii swatantrata adhiniyam key madhyam seey sulabh thee."haalaanki, jiss dastaavez parr church off scientology 21 puraskaron key apane daave koo aadhar banaata haye, vaha ack jalsaji haye, hamaare sarkari abhilekhiya visheshagyon key anusaar, aur una jahaajon aur padak koo soochibaddh kartaa haye joe maujood naheen they.
marberg journal off religion" key liye likhate hue, german protestant dharamshastri aur dharm vidwan marco frenskovsky key itihas ney "nange chehare vaale masiha" koo "hubbard kii sabse mahatvapurna aalochanatmak jeevani" kahaa. jaise [friedrich-wilheim hack kii "scientology-maggy days 20. jaherhunders"] aur [bent corridon kii "] yeh behad vivadaspad haye aur bahut hudd taka hubbard koo tukadon mein kheenchane kii koshish kartaa haye."unhone kahaa kii miller kii pustak ney" nishchit roop seey hubbard kii shuruati uplabdhiyon key baare mein kuchh badhe hue bayanon koo ujagar kiya thaa ", lekin church off scientology miller dwara kiye gaye kaee binduon kaa mukabala karane mein saksham rhaa haih" doubleu. doubleu. aaee. aaee. mein apane sainya currier key baare mein hubbard key daave, ee.jee.miller dwara dikhaae jaane kii tulanaa mein sach key bahut karib rahey hain... (praasangik dastavejon kaa ack puuraa sett merey sangrah kaa hissa haye)."miller kaa kahana haye kii vaha hubbard key maargdarshak, joseph" "snake" "thompson key astitva kii pushti karane mein asamarth thaa, lekin frenskovsky hubbard key khaate kii pushti kartaa haye kii thompson americi nausena key chikitsa dall mein ack vaastavik commander thaa aur sigmund fried kaa ack vyaktigat dost thaa. miller kaa kahana haye kii hubbard ellister crolle kii shishya thee, jiska nihitarth yeh haye kii vaigyaanik vigyaan crolle kii shikshaon seey praapt hotaa haye, lekin frenskovsky nishkarsh nikaalate hain, "phir bhee yeh spasht haye kii hubbard ney crolle aur parsons seey jyada prerana naheen lii."
panth key raajya" mein likhate hue, isai drishtikon seey likhe gaye nae dhaarmik andolanon kaa ack avalokan, walter ralston martin ney tippani kii kii hubbard key jeevan parr vibhinn pustakon mein seey koee bhee "nange chehare masiha" aur mudey hue corridone kii pustak key roop mein unaki saakh koo poori tarah seey nuksan naheen pahuncha rahee haye. british vigyaan kathaa lekhak aur aalochak david langford ney miller kii pustak koo "poori tarah seey adhik samaan-swar aur behtar-likhit" key roop mein mulyankan kiya aur tark diyaa kii yeh hubbard key jeevan parr "ack maanak sandarbh honey kaa hakdar haye". samajshastri david jee. bromley ney iss pustak koo hubbard key jeevan key "sabse mahatvapurna" vivaranon mein seey ack key roop mein varnit kiya. janette reitman, jinhone apani 2011 kii pustak mein vaigyaanik vigyaan key itihas kaa dastavejikaran kiya, "jise" nange chehare vaalaa masiha "kahaa gayaa, ell kii sabse achchi aur sabse vyaapak jeevani. ronn hubbard."
mallis reuven ney "times literary supplement" mein kahaa kii miller apane pathakon parr koee thesis naheen banaata haye, jisase way una tathyon seey apana nishkarsh nikaal sakate hain jinhen vaha ujagar kartaa haye."unhone ise pustak kii ack taakat aur kamjori donon key roop mein liya, kyonki yeh sawal khula chhodata haye kii kyaa hubbard jaanboojhkar dhokha dene vaali thee yaa imandari seey dhokha dene vaali thee. unhone yeh bhee nirasha vyakt kii kii miller ney yeh naheen bataaya thaa kii hubbard ney iss tarah kaa anusaran kaise hassil kiya thaa, lekin tathya koo kalpana seey alag karane mein lekhak key saavdhaanipoorvak shodh kii sarahana kii. vyangya patrika "niji aankh" ney pustak koo "saavdhaanipoorvak pralekhit" key roop mein varnit kiya, lekin dekhaa kii lekhak "siddhant naheen detaa haye, naa hii aksar naitik bhee naheen haye. paathak koo apane swayam key antahkshep, hansee aur ashcharya kii haanf pradaan karni chaahiye."
ravivaar key samay" ney pustak koo "prashansaniya roop seey likhit, achchi tarah seey pralekhit aur isamen bahut adhik shodh kiya jaanaa chaahiye."isane miller kii prashansa kii kii vaha vaigyaanikon key unhein badnam karane key prayason key khilaf khadaa huaa. nae rajneta" ney "nange chehare vaale masiha" kii prashansa kii kyonki yeh sulabh roop seey likhaa gayaa haye aur parishrampurvak shodh kiya gayaa haye, lekin "niji aankh" kii tarah, logon koo vaigyaanik vigyaan aakarshak kyon lagata haye, iss parr prakaash naheen daalane key liye isaki aalochana kii. dha spectator" mein patrick skin cataling kii sameeksha ney pustak kii "anaarakshit roop seey" sifarish kii, ise "dhana-pagal, shakti-pagal megalomenia kaa ack nayab roop seey teekha adhyayan" kahaa."peater conrad," "paryavekshak" mein, aam taur parr pustak key baare mein poorak thaa, lekin "" hubbard kii saamyikta kii maanyata koo chhodane key liye miller kii aalochana kii.  miller usey ack luni aur ack ajib key roop mein maanata haye; vaastav mein vaha america kaa hii ack rugna lakshan thaa. manovaigyaanik aur tv prastutkarta anthany clair ney 1987 key liye apani pustakon mein seey ack key roop mein "dha times" mein "nange chehare vaale masiha" koo soochibaddh kiya, tippani karate hue kii yeh "vaigyaanik vigyaan key charletanary key saamane aadami kii bholipan kaa ack pramaan thaa", jabaki film aur saahityik aalochak tomm hutchinson ney miller kii "aakarshak roop seey varnan [inag]" key liye prashansa kii jise unhone hubbard key "vichitra currier" key roop mein varnit kiya."
kanada mein, samachar patrika "mclean" key david bachche ney usa tareeke kii sarahana kii kii miller ney "[vaigyaanik] key sansthaapak key chitra parr [aid] likhaa thaa joe kii majedar aur gaharaai seey asthir haye", tippani karate hue kii "jaba hubbard aur unake church kii teekhi aalochana kii jaati haye, tou" nange chehare vaalaa masiha ", vaastav mein, imandari seey nishpaksh haye."toronto" "financial post" "key michael harrison ney" "aavashyak snide tippani seey parey ack aalochanatmak pariprekshya kii kamee" "key liye pustak kii aalochana kii aur khud koo iss sawal seey bachane seey nirash honey kaa daavaa kiya kii kyaa hubbard" "vaastavik thaa yaa sirf ack dhokhadhadi" "thee, jise harrison ney ack mahatvapurna chook maanaa" "kyonki swarth, akhandata aur prerana key sawal masiha-jatil seey peedit logon kii jeevani mein pramukh mudde hain.".
sidney morning heralds" judith white ney pustak koo "avashoshit" aur "achchi tarah seey pralekhit aur chitraatmak roop seey bataaya."ellen roberts ney adelide" "vigyapandata" "mein likhaa kii" "nange chehare vaalaa masiha" "hubbard dwara kiye gaye" "dhokhe, vikriti aur manorog sambandhi jhooth kii antaheen soochi" "kaa ack" "sookshm shodh, saghan sakshya" "thaa aur miller dwara" "lagbhag thakaau roop seey itihas" "kiya gayaa thaa. ravivaar key mell" sameekshak ney pustak koo "manoranjak padhane key roop mein varnit kiya joe ack shaktishali punch paik kartaa haye", jisamen prabhaav "miller key saavdhaanipoorvak aur peshevar shodh dwara diyaa gayaa thaa joe usa tareeke seey spasht haye jiss tarah seey vaha aadami koo oopar banaata haye aur phir usey neeche giraa detaa haye, tathya seey."
oregan kaanoon sameeksha" ney "nange chehare vaale masiha" koo "ack vivadaspad saarvajanik vyakti kii ack khulasa karane vaali, mantramugdh karane vaali jeevani" key roop mein varnit kiya."charles plaat ney" "dha washington post" "mein likhate hue pustak koo" "prabhaavshaali roop seey poori tarah seey" "kahaa, halanki unhone" "hubbard parr majaak karane kaa koee avsar naa ganvaane key liye" "kahaa. vaastav mein, vaha aadami koo itani achchi tarah seey neecha dikhaata haye kii vyayam lagbhag vyarth lagane lagata haye."unhone nott kiya kii unaki sameeksha key prakaashan seey pahale, church off scientology ney unake samachar patra koo" kaee miller key bayanon kaa khandan karane key iraade seey dastavejon kaa ack badaa package bheja thaa."unaki sameeksha koo baad mein church off scientology international key upaadhyaksh, bryan anderson dwara vivaadit kiya gayaa thaa, jinhone akhbar koo ack patra mein pustak kii ninda karate hue daavaa kiya thaa kii yeh" "spasht roop seey ell parr ack twarit paisa banaane key liye ganana kii gaee thee. ronn hubbard kaa naam "aur ack" tez aur ghatiya "kaam thaa. jawab mein, plaat ney bataaya kii "[miller] ell kii safalata parr vivaad naheen kartaa haye. ronn hubbard kaa kaam; vaha kewal aise saboot prastut kartaa haye joe dhokhadhadi kaa sujhaav dete hain. yeh russell miller kii pustak kaa mudda haye, aur mujhe yeh mahatvapurna lagata haye kii bryan anderson iska jawab dene kaa koee prayaas naheen karate hain."
prakaashan kaa itihas.
pustak kaa saransh teen lekhon key dauran "ravivaar key samay" key "kalaa aur avkash" khand mein prakaashit kiya gayaa thaa.
ark "saptahant australiyai" aur "toronto starr" mein bhee dikhaai diye.
baahari link.
puuraa paath
sandarbh samagri
lekhak kaa sakshatkar

