Optimally tackling covariate shift in RKHS-based nonparametric   regression
We study the covariate shift problem in the context of nonparametric regression over a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS). We focus on two natural families of covariate shift problems defined using the likelihood ratios between the source and target distributions. When the likelihood ratios are uniformly bounded, we prove that the kernel ridge regression (KRR) estimator with a carefully chosen regularization parameter is minimax rate-optimal (up to a log factor) for a large family of RKHSs with regular kernel eigenvalues. Interestingly, KRR does not require full knowledge of the likelihood ratio apart from an upper bound on it. In striking contrast to the standard statistical setting without covariate shift, we also demonstrate that a na\"\i ve estimator, which minimizes the empirical risk over the function class, is strictly suboptimal under covariate shift as compared to KRR. We then address the larger class of covariate shift problems where likelihood ratio is possibly unbounded yet has a finite second moment. Here, we show via careful simulations that KRR fails to attain the optimal rate. Instead, we propose a reweighted KRR estimator that weights samples based on a careful truncation of the likelihood ratios. Again, we are able to show that this estimator is minimax optimal, up to logarithmic factors.