3599
document
Does waiting matter ? A randomized controlled trial of new non-urgent rheumatology out-patient referrals . OBJECTIVE To examine the effect of waiting times on the health status of patients referred for a non-urgent rheumatology opinion . METHODS The study was a randomized controlled clinical study evaluating a 'fast track ' appointment with a 6-week target waiting time against an 'ordinary ' appointment in the main city out-patient clinic of the rheumatology service for the Lothian and Borders region ( population approximately 1 million ) . Health status was measured using the SF12 physical and mental summary component T-scores and pain was measured with a 100 mm visual analogue pain scale . Secondary outcomes were health utility and perceived health both measured with the EuroQol instrument , mental health measured with the Hospital Anxiety and Depression scale , disability with the modified Health Assessment Questionnaire and economic costs measured from a societal perspective . RESULTS Mean waiting times were 43 days ( sigma = +/-16 ) and 105 days ( sigma = +/-51 ) for 'fast track ' and 'ordinary ' appointments , respectively . Both groups showed significant improvements in mean [ 95 % confidence interval ( CI ) ] scores for pain : 11 ( 7 , 16 ) ( P < 0.001 ) ; physical health status : 4 ( 2 , 5 ) ( P < 0.001 ) ; mental health status : 2 ( 0.1 , 4 ) ( P < 0.02 ) ; and health utility : 0.11 ( 0.07 , 0.16 ) ( P < 0.001 ) by the end of the 15-month period of the study , but there was no significant difference between either arm of the study . CONCLUSIONS Rationing by delay was not detrimental to either mental or physical health and patients in both arms of the study showed significant and similar improvement in health by 15 months . Expenditure of resources on waiting times without regard to clinical outcomes is likely to be wasteful and additional resources should be directed at achieving the greatest clinical benefit . More research into effective methods of controlling demand and better identification of those who would benefit from access to specialist care is needed .
3600
Intervention_Other
'fast track ' appointment with a 6-week target waiting time
3601
Intervention_Control
'ordinary ' appointment
3602
Outcome_Physical
SF12 physical and mental summary component T-scores
3603
Outcome_Pain
pain
3604
Outcome_Physical
health utility
3605
Outcome_Mental
Anxiety and Depression scale
3606
Outcome_Other
Mean waiting times
3607
Outcome_Pain
pain
3608
Outcome_Physical
physical health status
3609
Outcome_Mental
mental health status
3610
Outcome_Physical
health utility