· Totally new to Bitcoin? Start here! ·

< Previous Next >

Why Bitcoin Isn’t Dead: The Petro Comparison


Why Bitcoin Isn’t Dead: The Petro Comparison


Bitcoin is down quite a bit from its all-time high. Today is 04/02/2018, and we’ve been hovering around the $7,000 per coin price point for a couple weeks now. This is much lower than the all-time high around $20,000, so many people are asking themselves: is Bitcoin dead? Will Bitcoin go up again? Well, this is a pretty loaded question, so before getting into the details I think the first thing people should do is remain calm and zoom out on the chart. Sure, we’re far below the sexy all-time high price, but we’re also still up over 530% since last year. Don’t believe me? Look for yourself - the Bitcoin spot price according to Coinbase was about $1,120 on 04/02/2017. With the meteoric rise of Bitcoin’s price, there was no question in anyone’s mind - well, anyone who was thoughtful about it - that we’d eventually see a big correction. The same thing happened with the dot com bubble, and some of those companies still went on to have more income than the GDP of some nations.

I’ve heard Bitcoin called many derogatory things - internet funbucks, Chuck E. Cheese tokens, “buttcoin” (yes, really), and so on. With the current price devaluation, it’s easy to get demoralized and assume the value of Bitcoin will continue going down forever - and really, who can say for sure? The reality is that I personally have never really been terribly interested in the price of any coin or token, at least not in comparison to the value and usefulness of its underlying technology. One argument that I’ve regularly seen from anti-coiners is that cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin are based on nothing, backed by nothing, and will never be taken seriously (and that’s assuming it’s not banned outright!). Using the Petro as a means of comparison, I’m going to show you why that’s just not true.

What is the Petro?

If you follow cryptocurrency news at all, you are probably at least somewhat aware that Venezuela announced the creation of an oil-backed cryptocurrency called the Petro back in December of 2017. Then, on January 5th of 2018, Nicolás Maduro (president of Venezuela) announced that 100 million tokens of the Petro would be issued; according to Wikipedia, this means that the market capitalization of the Petro would be a ludicrous six billion dollars. That would put it somewhere in the vicinity of Litecoin’s market cap at current values.

In case you’ve been living under a rock, Venezuela is a failed state and Maduro is basically an incompetent dictator. Assuming you want to take his word for the value of the token as backed by Venezuela’s oil reserves - I certainly don’t - that’s still an insane figure. As such, there was instead a pre-sale of the token which lasted from Feb. 20, 2018 to Mar. 19, 2018 and about 40 million of the tokens were sold. This event lead to President Donald Trump signing Executive Order 13692. Here’s the most pertinent part:


Basically, if you’re a US Citizen, you’re prohibited from buying (or transacting in) the Petro due to the fact that it’s a blatant attempt to circumvent sanctions. When I first heard about this executive order, I chuckled a little bit - I was not sure if it was even necessary, as I’m not sure who in their right mind would want to buy currency issued by a failed state whose own people are starving and something like 90% of them live in poverty. Still, the point is clear: if it wants to, the American government will not shy away from outright banning certain cryptocurrencies. Despite the mewling of certain dinguses, this hasn’t happened yet for anything but the Petro. Why not? Well, apparently the powers that be are wise enough to understand that Bitcoin has intrinsic, useful value that goes beyond things like money laundering.

The fact that this executive order was issued so quickly for the Petro should be taken as a very good thing for Bitcoin. The US government has had plenty of inciting incidents that could have motivated it to give Bitcoin the same sort of treatment over the years. Have you heard of the Silk Road, a “darknet market” where one could use Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies to purchase drugs and (supposedly) contract killings? It was shut down by the US government back in 2013; its owner was jailed, and the U.S. Marshals Service auctioned off 29,657 seized bitcoins. Do you know what didn’t happen? You guessed it - Bitcoin wasn’t banned. The idea of a Bitcoin ban is a non-issue. It will never happen in America, and I’ll be happy to eat no end of crow if it does. But it won’t.

So if legal problems aren’t a threat, what is? Well, there’s still the argument that Bitcoin is intrinsically worthless - a statement which technically applies to any currency, unless you want to count one’s ability to burn the US Dollar for warmth. Actually, I’d argue the statement doesn’t really even apply to cryptocurrencies; the fundamental aspects of Bitcoin are what create its value. Allow me to explain; here’s what Bitcoin brings that other non-crypto currencies don’t:

  1. Immutability. No government, bank, hacker, or other third party can walk in and change your transactions around. As long as you follow proper safety procedures, your coins are yours and only yours. I know some people will think that only shady folks will want to do this, but if you live in a dark place like Venezuela you’ll quickly realize that financial independence is extremely important. This immutability also means that business owners too can bypass all the middle men that infect the world of payment processing like a plague.
  2. Transaction ability. Transacting in a cryptocurrency like Bitcoin is nothing like traditional currencies. I want you to imagine something with me. Imagine you’re rich (sounds nice, right?) and you want to send a million dollars from Hong Kong to Argentina - exact opposite sides of the world! I’m struggling to imagine a scenario where this is anywhere close to instantaneous with fiat currency, and it certainly isn’t going to be anywhere close to free. What instrument are you going to use to send it? A wire? An international ACH transfer? How many days are you willing to wait? With Bitcoin, it’s instant, and the fees are minimal. Sure, Bitcoin has had its share of scaling issues, and there have been times when the fees were pretty high - but those are being dealt with via various second-layer solutions, and if you don’t like it there are other cryptocurrencies that you can look into. PS: You don’t have to be rich to benefit from this aspect of Bitcoin. If you moved to another country to get a good job to support your family, sending money back home to them has never been easier.
  3. Trustless. In the previous bullet point I suppose you could use something like PayPal, but there are a lot of reasons you wouldn’t want to. First of all, PayPal is going to rob you of a huge percentage of what you sent if it’s a business transaction. More importantly, you now have to trust a third party not to arbitrarily freeze your account. This isn’t really a wise choice, considering the track record of payment processors like PayPal. If you don’t want your money frozen by PayPal for some absurd reason (like including certain words like “Cuba” or “Damascus” in the memo), then what you need is a way to bypass third parties. With Bitcoin, you don’t have to rely on anyone to send your money around. As long as you’re following the proper procedures, your money is as safe as houses.

By way of comparison, the Petro doesn’t really have much of this intrinsic value. The technical aspects of it are a bit murky - sources differ on whether it’s a token on the NEM blockchain or a token on the Ethereum blockchain - but the bottom line is that no one cares to transact in a scam coin hastily developed by a dictator in a failed state in an attempt to raise capital. Those three major pillars of cryptocurrency - immutability, transaction ability, and trustlessness - are rendered meaningless when nobody is taking your coin or token seriously.

This is why I’m not worried when people - usually nontechnical journalist types - suggest that Bitcoin can be rendered less valuable by creating simply more cryptocurrencies. I’ve even heard this described as “creating more bitcoins” which, for obvious reasons, isn’t accurate at all.

The point is that I can create whatever coin or token I want, but it doesn’t mean anybody is going to buy it or use it. People in the crypto world aren’t stupid. In general, it’s clear when something is an empty cash grab devoid of any new or interesting technology. I mean, just look at the tenth page of coinmarketcap and tell me there aren’t a bunch of coins that nobody cares about. HoboNickels is not Bitcoin.

A user of HoboNickels, presumably.

So… will Bitcoin go up again?

If you’re going to take anything away from this article, make it this: Bitcoin’s price is not something you should be getting hung up on. Could it go lower? Yes. Could it go much lower? Yes. Could it skyrocket up to a million dollars by 2020 as John McAfee insists? That’s possible too. The point is that if you think of Bitcoin as some sort of get rich quick scheme, you are thinking far too small. Cryptocurrency is a technology that can and will change the future. The price is not the only indicator of success, and frankly it is a poor one if the price is only shooting up because of speculative interest. Pay attention to the technology. Pay attention to what big companies are doing and saying. Good things are coming sooner or later.

Before you go…



  1. Buy some Bitcoin or Ethereum from Coinbase.
  2. Trade them for altcoins on Binance, KuCoin, HitBTC, or Changelly. Out of these, Binance is my preferred exchange. It has recently become possible to buy bitcoins on Binance directly, as well!




Posted: Apr 3, 2018

< Previous Next >