 " Don 't You Wanna Stay " was covered by Colton Dixon and <unk> <unk> in the eleventh season of American Idol . Natalie Finn of E ! gave a mixed review of the pair 's performance , writing " <unk> handled Kelly Clarkson better than Colton played Jason Aldean on " Don 't You Wanna Stay , " but she 's the country girl , so it made sense . " Brian Mansfield of USA Today felt that the song was out of Dixon 's comfort zone and a little out of <unk> 's range . Gil Kaufman of MTV remarked that the chemistry between the pair was more like cold fusion . Jennifer Still of Digital Spy said the performance " isn 't anything incredible " . 
