 The reappearance of storylines left dangling at the end of the first season was noted with approval by Samantha Urban of The Dallas Morning News and VanDerWerff , who both mentioned not only the big one about Quinn and Puck and baby Beth but also Artie 's love of directing , and variously added Rachel and Shelby , and movement on the Will and Emma relationship . The fact that Shelby had been hired to form a second glee club at McKinley , however , was greeted with <unk> by both reviewers — Urban called it " mind @-@ <unk> <unk> " — and others as well . Reiter found the idea incomprehensible , and Vanity Fair 's Brett <unk> wrote , " Given Will 's ongoing struggles to fill his own <unk> baker 's dozen , this is about as realistic a plan as Michele Bachmann starting a rival chapter of <unk> at Liberty University . " Vicki Hyman of The Star @-@ Ledger characterized the notion of " Shelby deciding to give up a burgeoning Broadway career because she was missing her daughter grow up " to take a part @-@ time job in Lima as " ridiculous " , and the whole scenario as " more than a little bizarre " . 
