 Though " Afternoon Delight " was variously described as " goofy " by Benigno and " corny " by Gonzalez , it nevertheless was given a generally positive reception . Benigno called the performance " absolutely hilarious " , but characterized the cover as " pretty impressive " , and gave a grade of " A − " . Amy Reiter of the Los Angeles Times was even more enthusiastic : she said it was an " incredible rendition " that she ranked " among the best moments of Glee ever " . Slezak 's grade of " B − " was issued after a strong caveat : " Arrested Development did it better " , and Gonzalez wrote that Stamos was wasted on the performance , which she gave a " C " . Berk cited the " incredible harmonies " when he gave the song four out of five stars . 
