 Nicol 's tenure with the Pilgrims was successful , albeit brief . He compiled a 15 – 8 record with a 1 @.@ 36 ERA in 23 games started and threw five shutouts . He soon demonstrated himself as the best pitcher in the league by holding opposing teams to three hits or less in four separate games . His pitching performances caught the eye of Chicago Colts ' manager Cap Anson , who offered him a $ 225 a month contract . Nicol originally agreed to the deal , but subsequently wanted to renege , citing " a change of heart . " However , he was eventually forced to accept the offer when the Colts threatened to blacklist him . The Pilgrims , who were already struggling financially , received just $ 300 from the Colts for their ace and folded soon after he left the team . 
