 She next starred in the musical adaptation of Neil Simon 's The Goodbye Girl with music by Marvin Hamlisch ( 1993 ) . Peters won her second Tony for her performance as Annie Oakley in the 1999 revival of Annie Get Your Gun opposite Tom <unk> . Among many glowing notices for this role , critic Lloyd Rose of the Washington Post commented : " [ Peters ] banishes all thoughts of Ethel Merman about two bars into her first number , ' Doin ' What Comes Natur <unk> . ' Partly this is because Merman 's Annie was a hearty , boisterous gal , while Peters plays an adorable , slightly goofy gamine ... For anyone who cares about the American musical theater , the chance to see Peters in this role is reason enough to see the show . " Playbill went even further : " Arguably the most talented comedienne in the musical theatre today , Peters manages to extract a laugh from most every line she delivers . " 
