 The tributes to Edward Said include books and schools ; such as Waiting for the Barbarians : A Tribute to Edward W. Said ( 2008 ) features essays by Akeel <unk> , Rashid Khalidi , and Elias Khoury ; Edward Said : The Charisma of Criticism ( 2010 ) , by Harold Aram <unk> , a critical biography ; and Edward Said : A Legacy of Emancipation and Representations ( 2010 ) , essays by Joseph Massad , Ilan Pappé , Ella <unk> , Ghada <unk> , Noam Chomsky , Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak , and Daniel Barenboim ; and the Barenboim – Said Academy ( Berlin ) was established in 2012 . 
