 The episode is the first of two episodes to deal with the murder of the basketball coach at Veronica 's school Hearst College , Tom Barry ( Matt McKenzie ) . In this episode , Veronica tries to clear the coach 's son , Josh ( Jonathan Chase ) of charges of his murder . Meanwhile , Logan ( Jason Dohring ) , heartbroken from his breakup with Veronica in " There 's Got to Be a Morning After Pill " , ends up babysitting the eleven @-@ year @-@ old sister ( Juliette Goglia ) of one of his friend Dick 's ( Ryan Hansen ) paramours , and they begin to emotionally connect with each other . In addition , Veronica and Keith find out that two of the main suspects ' alibis do not match . 
