 " Gotta Be You " debuted and peaked at number three on the Irish Singles Chart in the week ending 17 November 2011 , marking the group 's second top five appearance in Ireland . In the United Kingdom , the piece sold substantially less than their first single " What Makes You Beautiful " , selling 59 @,@ 461 copies in its first week . Despite the single reaching number one on the mid @-@ week chart update , it entered the UK Singles Chart dated 20 November 2011 at number three behind the seventh week sales of Rihanna 's " We Found Love " and the release of " Good Feeling " by Flo Rida . The song marks their second top ten hit and was One Direction 's third best @-@ selling track in the UK by August 2012 . Upon the release of Up All Night in the United States , " Gotta Be You " did not enter the US Billboard Hot 100 , but peaked at number 24 on the Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles chart in the week of 28 April 2012 . 
