 After The Legacy disbanded , Orton unsuccessfully challenged Jack Swagger for the World Heavyweight Championship at Extreme Rules in April . During a number one contender 's match for the WWE Championship on RAW , Orton was speared by Edge , costing him the match and setting up a bout at Over the Limit , Orton separated his right shoulder during the match , which ended in a double countout . At Fatal 4 @-@ Way in June , Orton lost a fatal four @-@ way WWE Championship match , also involving champion Cena and Edge , to Sheamus . On the July 19 Raw , he won a number one contender 's match over Edge and Chris Jericho , earning a match against Sheamus at SummerSlam . Sheamus was disqualified for bringing a steel chair into the ring , giving Orton the win , but not the title . Immediately afterward , Orton hit Sheamus with the chair and an RKO . 
