 Ken Tucker of Entertainment Weekly wrote that " One More Chance " is just one of the " consumer enticements that just add to the allure . " Billboard critic Timothy White called it " bittersweet serenade . " J. D. Considine from The Baltimore Sun called the song " the album 's greatest surprise " . He explained , " this David Foster song is quite demanding vocally , requiring a wider range and more power than anything else on the album . Yet Madonna more than lives up to the challenge , showing enough power and polish to make even Madonna @-@ <unk> admit she can sing . Louis Virtel from music website Idolator wrote , " No other Madonna song sounds quite like it , and it holds up as a melancholic statement against grander compositions like ' You 'll See ' and ' I 'll Remember ' . " 
