 Reviewer Alan Sepinwall , on his blog What 's Alan Watching ? , praised the decision to include a multiple @-@ week mystery . He thought that spreading the case out allowed the episode to focus on the main story arc and Logan 's subplot as well as allow the main mystery time to finish . He was also complimentary towards the Logan – Heather plotline , lauding Goglia 's performance ; he also stated that the episode gave him renewed interest in the Dean O 'Dell case . Eric Goldman , writing for IGN , rated the episode a 7 @.@ 7 out of 10 , indicating that it was " good " . He was highly critical of the subplot involving Logan and Heather , stating that it " rode the line of insufferable " . While opining that it had some good comedic moments , he thought that the majority of the subplot involved heavy use of clichés . However , he was more mixed to positive towards the case @-@ of @-@ the @-@ week . The reviewer felt a sense of anticipation about the fact that this storyline did not resolve itself in the episode : " it 's hard not to be anxious to see where this is going . " 
