 Weevil ( Francis Capra ) organizes a meeting between Veronica and the PCHers , and the new leader says that they would not kill someone over a bad car like the Coach 's vehicle . Mason ( Robert Ri 'chard ) , one of the team 's former star basketball players , testifies to Sheriff Lamb ( Michael Muhney ) that Josh is responsible for his father ’ s death . The Sheriff arrests Josh , and Veronica learns that the Coach 's car was found in the water . Logan and Heather begin to actually enjoy each other 's company . Keith speaks to Mindy O 'Dell ( Jaime Ray Newman ) , stating that he will continue to search for Dean Cyrus O 'Dell 's killer . Veronica questions Mason , but he ends up angrily walking away . Veronica and Keith recuperate , and Keith says that Cyrus 's car was taken out within the timeframe of the murder . Heather sends a radio request to play a special song from Logan to Veronica , while Veronica interrogates the hotel staff . One of them says that he heard two men yelling in the room . Veronica and Logan have a chance meeting in the elevator . 
