 With Rollins as the new champion , Orton defeated Roman Reigns and Ryback in a triple threat match on the April 6 episode of Raw to become the number one contender to face Rollins at Extreme Rules , but he failed to win the title from Rollins in a steel cage match that saw par the stipulation his RKO banned and Kane as the gatekeeper . At Payback , Orton failed to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship when he was defeated by Rollins in a fatal four @-@ way match that also included Dean Ambrose and Reigns . At Money in the Bank , Orton failed to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship contract ladder match , which was won by Sheamus . Following this , Orton began feuding with Sheamus after both men attacked each other and faced off in various tag @-@ team matches ; Orton defeated Sheamus at Battleground , but lost to Sheamus at SummerSlam . In early September 2015 , Orton started a feud with The Wyatt Family . On the September 7 episode of Raw , Orton defeated Sheamus in a singles match . After the match , The Wyatt Family attacked Orton , leaving him out of action . On the September 21 episode of Raw , Orton returned to save Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns from The Wyatt Family , starting an alliance between Ambrose , Reigns , and Orton . On the next Raw , Orton teamed up with Ambrose to take on The New Day in a losing effort . Before the next Raw , Orton was taken out of the Hell in a Cell match after sustaining a legitimate shoulder injury , putting him out of action for the following months . 
