 Will ( Matthew Morrison ) assigns the members of New Directions to perform the best love songs for Valentine 's Day . Sugar ( Vanessa Lengies ) takes the opportunity to announce a Valentine 's Day party , for which everyone must have a date , including herself . Artie ( Kevin McHale ) and Rory ( Damian McGinty ) both set out to woo Sugar with gifts , and she vacillates between them , so they move to song : Artie sings " Let Me Love You " and Rory , after he says he has been informed that his visa for a second year at McKinley has been denied , performs " Home " . Sugar chooses Rory as her date . 
