 Even those who were not normally fans of Collins ' work liked the album . Michael R. Smith of The Daily Vault wrote " Anomaly or not , it is indeed the album that Phil deserves to be remembered for . " Stephen Williams of Newsday said that the album was " loaded with musical hooks and textured arrangements ... it also lacks the tense edge that was part of Collins ' work with Genesis . " Keegan Hamilton of the Riverfront Times said that the album was " The 80 's Dance Pop Special : A smooth synthesiser groove , with an order of keyboards , drum machines , and horns on the side , " adding that " Sussudio " was the best track on the album , saying that it 's " catchy gibberish . " Hamilton says that " One More Night " was the worst song on the album , saying that " The album 's introspective slow jam wallows in self @-@ pity . " 
