 On September 10 , 1999 , Chili Davis ' second @-@ inning home run was the only hit by the Yankees against Pedro Martínez , who struck out 17 Yankees — the most strikeouts against a Yankee team ever . Martínez retired the last 22 batters after giving up the home run , including striking out eight of the final nine batters . The teams finished first and second in their division and both made the playoffs in the same season . This led to the very first post @-@ season meeting in the longtime rivalry . 
