 C. K. Sample , III , from AOL 's TV Squad , joked , " Boone 's mother is the devil . How else to make us sympathize with Shannon right before killing her off of the show . " Virginia Rohan of The Seattle Times thought the " death of troubled Shannon , just as she was becoming more likable and had found love with Sayid , was sadder than the first @-@ season death of her stepbrother , Boone . Still , it would grieve me far more to lose Jack , Kate , Sawyer , Locke , Sun or Jin . " Maureen Ryan of the Chicago Tribune felt fans echoed this view , describing their reaction as " muted , " as they were more angry at Ana Lucia for shooting Shannon . Maggie Grace co @-@ won the 2005 Screen Actors Guild Award for " Best Ensemble - Drama Series . She was also nominated for the Teen Choice Award for " Choice TV Breakout Performance - Female , " but lost out to Desperate Housewives ' Eva Longoria . 
