 On April 5 , 2009 , Kelly competed in a Divas battle royal at WrestleMania XXV , which was won by Santina Marella . On the May 18 episode of Raw , Kelly won a battle royal by eliminating Beth Phoenix and Mickie James , to become the number one contender to the WWE Divas Championship . The following week , she challenged Maryse for the championship and won by disqualification , allowing Maryse to retain . Kelly lost a subsequent rematch on June 8 . Three weeks later , she competed in a fatal four @-@ way match to determine the number one contender , but the match was won by Mickie James . Throughout the remainder of mid @-@ 2009 , Kelly unsuccessfully competed in several number one contender 's matches . At Bragging Rights in October , Kelly , Gail Kim and Melina comprised Team Raw , but lost to Team SmackDown , consisting of Beth Phoenix , Natalya and Michelle McCool . The following month at Survivor Series , Kelly participated in a five @-@ on @-@ five elimination match ; she eliminated Layla before being eliminated by Phoenix , however her team went on to win the match . 
