 Puck ( Mark Salling ) wants Finn ( Cory Monteith ) to join him in moving his pool @-@ cleaning business to California . Finn demurs , but later broaches the possibility to his fiancée Rachel ( Lea Michele ) as an alternative to New York . She is aghast , and says she needs him with her in New York ; he replies that she needs to be sure she loves him for who he is , not who she wants him to be . 
