 Billy invisibly attends Louise 's graduation , hoping for one last chance to help his daughter and redeem himself . The beloved town physician , Dr. Seldon ( who resembles the Starkeeper ) advises the graduating class not to rely on their parents ' success or be held back by their failure ( words directed at Louise ) . Seldon prompts everyone to sing an old song , " You 'll Never Walk Alone " . Billy , still invisible , whispers to Louise , telling her to believe Seldon 's words , and when she tentatively reaches out to another girl , she learns she does not have to be an outcast . Billy goes to Julie , telling her at last that he loved her . As his widow and daughter join in the singing , Billy is taken to his heavenly reward . 
