 The album received a positive reaction from critics , who praised By the Way for its melodic , multilayer and textured styles . AllMusic 's Zac Johnson said that the album was " sophisticated ... the Peppers have not sacrificed any of their trademark energy or passions for life , universal love , and ( of course ) lust " . Rolling Stone called the album " insanely melodic " and a " near @-@ perfect balance of gutter grime and high @-@ art aspiration " , comparing it to other works , such as The Beach Boys ' album Pet Sounds . Mojo applauded the recording , and considered it to be " the strongest Chili 's album since 1991 's Blood Sugar Sex Magik " . Giving the album 5 stars out of 5 , Q called By the Way " A fantastic record ; full of wonder . " Kimberly Mack of PopMatters commented on how the album " ... showcases a more sophisticated , lush sound that only today 's Peppers could have conceived " , and that " Anthony Kiedis ' lyrics are more personal than ever . " Frusciante was , in his eyes , " a musical talent to be reckoned with and is the undeniable X factor in the Red Hot Chili Peppers ' sound . " 
