Q: Title: fish or fowl? Review: The original Sweetwater stood out as a rock-fusion band without a guitarist, the only one of their era. This reunion gig has taken on a guitarist with a heavy, dominating sound, so it doesn't really sound like Sweetwater. Nancy Nevins's new, post car-crash voice isn't really suited for all of the old Sweetwater stuff, and especially not for shouting over a heavy fuzz guitar, but she does manage a few moments of magic, especially on the new-material "Heroes and Ladies." Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: An disgrace to the book! Review: After reading Battle Royale by Koushun Takami I decided to watch this movie thinking that if it were anywhere close to as good as the book it would be good. Unfortunately, it wasn't. There were so many unnecessary changes and the acting was terrible. Do yourself a favor skip this movie and just read the book. Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: Worst movie ever. Review: Some movies are so bad they're good. This isn't one of them. This movie was the kind terrible that I wish I could undergo selective electroshock therapy to erase any knowledge of its existence. I like all the stars in the movie, but now this movie is going to taint the experience when I see them in future movies.For a movie that faithfully follows a time-tested formula, it manages to tweak everything just wrong. The creepy psycho homicidal maniac isn't an interesting kind of creep. While you obviously hope he gets what's coming to him, waiting until the end of the movie is far too long. And what sort of accent or dialect is that supposed to be?I wish I would have stopped watching before the family dog was beheaded. I wish I had never seen it. Do yourself a favor and don't watch this movie. Especially if you like Reese Witherspoon--a wonderful actress in the right role--you will wish you hadn't seen her in this dreck. Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: Who was dumb enough to publish this? Review: I was stunned to read some of the fantasy which "Dr." Ahmed has written. He has apparently done no research whatsoever, and instead repeats dubious scholarship mixed with his own predjudices. Then at the end he publishes for us two letters mailed to him in Chinese (which he had translated into English; he of course himself does not speak Chinese) of people he visited concerning purchasing Chinese produce! This book is the work either of a joker or a moron and, in either case, not worth reading. Is this product review negative?

A: