Title: fantastic book Product review: I love Sarah Dessen's books but this is my favorite so far. I was able to relate with the main character Macy so much and it was so true to life. Many of the things that Macy has to go through in this book were happening to me at the same time as I was reading the book. I loved being able to connect with the book and being able to get so much meaning from this book. This book has so many great meanings and deals with great topics and I highly recommend this book to everyone. I just couldn't put it down it was so good.I also recommend That Summer and Someone Like You. They too are wonderful works by Sarah Dessen and one can receive alot from them. Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
flattering

Title: Questionable Arizona material Product review: This book has a lot of redeeming qualities, but it is flawed in my opinion on the Arizona material. By her own admission Carolyn Lake says the diaries - on which this book is based - for the period up to 1890 were burned. No diaries for this period leaves me questioning the entire Arizona period. For support of this let me quote from Philip L. Fradkin's "Stagecoach: Wells Fargo and the American West." On page 104, Fradkin says, "Even Fred Dodge, like Wyatt Earp a professional gambler, gets far more attention than (Bob) Paul. Dodge later became a Wells Fargo special officer but claimed at the time of the robberies and killings that he was working undercover in Tombstone for Wells Fargo. That was not the case . . ."In short, unless Carolyn Lake provides some evidence that the words she puts in Dodge's mouth for the Arizona period, I reject most of the book's authenticity. Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
unflattering

Title: Ruth has no compassion Product review: First of all this book is very slanted, it is not a TRUE CRIME book, it does not cover all sides of the story. Ruth wrote this book because she is one nosy, selfish person. In no way does she care about any person in that book, if she did then the book would not exist. Nothing can bring Elaine and Maryann back to life. Both were women who were filled with compassion and a true love of life itself and neither would ever want their lives/names used for Ruth's immmoral, money-hungry book. The fact that Ruth attacks reviews that do not agree with her opinion, shows exactly what type of person is she. If you want a true crime book, look elsewhere. If you really feel the need to read this sorry excuse for a book, go borrow it from you library, this greedy *itch doesn't deserve a dime! Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
unflattering

Title: Miss information Product review: I felt that this product was miss represented -- it said it was a 2 disc collectors set. I thought I was getting both of the movies #1 and #2. All I ended up with was the first movie done in wide screen and full screen. I'm sorry I wasted my money.Also it stated that it was a "NEW" copy - but it had already been opened - how do I know if it hadn't already been used or played before it come to me. Would you say this review depicts the product in a flattering or unflattering light?
