Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: Unfinished drafts and scrapped notes Review: First off let me say that i absolutely love The Lord of the Rings, The Hobbit, and The Silmarillion. They are easily my favorite books and i have read them all more times then i can count...But i utterly despise The History books.These books are nothing but Tolkiens first rough drafts and his scrapped ideas. He scrapped them for a reason. And i dont think that reason was so his son can milk the franchise into the stratosphere...And another thing about these books is that they are definitely not for everyone. These books are only for the true diehard Tolkien fans and will NOT be enjoyed by anyone else. They are an extremely tough read with footnotes and headers galore.So if you truly live, breath, and sleep Middle-earth then these books might be for you. But i would rather not line Christopher Tolkiens pockets with his late great fathers draft pages and scrapped ideas. Answer:
Negative

Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: Excellent Knife Review: Excellent knife. Well balanced and exceptionally sharp. It cuts through hard bread and soft items easily.People not used to handling large knives should consider the 8" version of this knife as it takes practice to hadle such a long cutting edge.Although the blade is very thin and a bit flexible it's not flimsy.I have owned a Forschner Fibrox handled chef's knife for years and it's my everyday knife. This bread knife is equal in quality and will become part of my standard tool kit. Answer:
Positive

Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: Awful end for a great series Review: I've been a huge fan, read the book, watched all the episodes when first run, and now purchased and watched all 7 seasons on DVD.The movie was simply terrible. The writing was bad. Melodrama at its worst. I wish I had never watched. Answer:
