Q: Title: Good solid sci-fi read Review: Readers be warned: you have to read all 3 books in this trilogy to truly enjoy these books.Gerswin is a devilkid, an orphan living alone among the pollution and dangerous animals of a ravanged and mostly unpopulated Old Earth. Living in the wasteland has made Gerswin a primitive though intelligent savage, and the extreme conditions has made him into a physical superman. When a galactic empire survey vessel takes returns to Old Earth and takes him on board and educates him and allows him to mature to full strength you can be sure interesting things will happen. The trilogy tells of Gerswin's struggles against powerful forces over the centuries as he engages in a mammoth lonely crusade.The trilogy is exciting at times and tells an interesting story. The setting and mood resembles the author's later Ecolitan stories. Is this product review negative?

A: No


Q: Title: what a waste Review: what a waste! very trite, rather like sitting in a freshman education college classroom! seems like after 40 years we could have something "real world" schoolwise, to think about from h.k. his earlier books were much more insightful and had greater depth. in fact, i bought this book on the authors "name" alone....i will never do that again!!! Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: Not for the sole audio beginner. Review: If you have the book in front of you and are able to follow along, the product might work. However, I bought it to try and learn the language on my daily commute to work and found out quickly that they do not provide an English point of reference. Without knowing what they are saying, well you are just listening to gibberish. Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: Im lauging so hard I might have a heart attack Review: This guy thinks he's a thug? Please. I heard "So Much Pain" the song with 2Pac, and I considered buying this, but I heard the whole cd and I almost threw up. Look Ja, 2Pac is the greatest rapper that ever lived or ever will live. You, on the other hand, are nowhere near him. Pain is one of the best songs 2Pac ever recorded, and although I have to say Ja did do a good job of remixing the song and the way he brought 'Pac into the song was tight, man, COME UP WITH YOUR OWN LYRICS! He took 2Pacs lyrics and re-worded them just a little. If you want the real song, buy the cassette version of the Above The Rim soundtrack, but I couldnt find it so I got it off the internet. Ja, pain is not love, pain is watching your garbage a$$ videos and hearing your pop songs every time I turn on the radio. If you know and appreciate real rap, then you wont buy this. You'll buy, of course, 2Pac,then Geto Boys, Scarface, Biggie, NWA, Nas, and so on. Dont buy this. Peace. Is this product review negative?

A: