Ques: Title: I have to change my earlier favorable review Review: This book convincingly made the case that guns were much less important in pre-Civil War America than usually thought. Unfortunately, the author has basically been convicted of academic fraud by Emory U, where he taught; he was forced to resign. The fraud was based on unverifiable or wrong information he presented in this book. Last week, Columbia U, which awarded him the Bancroft Prize for the book in 2001, rescinded the prize.Of course, I can no longer recommend this book. However, I believe that some of his hypotheses are interesting and I hope that other historians will research them. Is the review positive or negative?
Ans: Negative

Ques: Title: these items all have defects Review: returned first one ordered,second one had same defects,called havahart and was told all of these have the same defect Is the review positive or negative?
Ans: Negative

Ques: Title: Supposed to be funny. Review: Don't expect a self-help book. This is a joke book. One joke. The foregoing reviewers are playing along with it. Sorry to ruin it. Is the review positive or negative?
Ans: Negative

Ques: Title: crucial for anyone a year away from and into their phd work Review: I am one year away from beginning my doctorate studies and I needed a general, non-field specific, and intrapesctive look at how to maintain and complete a doctoral dissertation. The book drove home the fact that I need to write a doctoral dissertation, and what skills I need to fine hone before attempting such a thing.The book also helped me to determine just what type of person should be writing a dissertation and what tools one should utilize in doing so.This is a book I know I will re-read and return to years into my thesis. Is the review positive or negative?
Ans: