Q: Is this product review positive? Title: Irritatingly pretentious and excessively gruesome Review: The Dress Lodger is one of the bleakest books I have ever read. The story is dark and lacking in any kind of subtlety, the descriptions of grave-robbing, autopsies, and death from cholera are morose and gruesome, and the characters are unrelentingly unsympathetic and grotesque. Moreover, there is too much going on in the story. There are too many lives whose stories are being told, too many points of view. The author seems to tell the story both through the eyes of different characters and through the eyes of an omiscient narrator whose identity, when revealed, is simply unbelievable. By the time I reached the book's inconclusive conclusion, and realized that I didn't really care about any of its characters, I felt manipulated and just plain annoyed. Answer:

A: No


Q: Is this product review positive? Title: Saves me wearing a bookbag Review: I can carry my bicycle repair kit, two 16-gram CO2 canisters, chuck, EVO/DROID/Iphone-sized cell phone, ID and insurance card, and keys in there during a trip. I can't fit a spare tube with all the rest of the stuff, but unless something goes into catastrophic failure, the tube patches in the repair kit should do the job. The saddle bag is out of the way, looks fashionable on my black bike, and I had no problem putting my rear LED light/reflector on it as well.54 cm road bike frame with the saddle stem raised ~4 inches. Needs about 7 inches, going from the rods under the rear of the saddle down to the seat tube. Answer:

A: Yes


Q: Is this product review positive? Title: Seminal work of geek culture investigation Review: This encyclopedic masterwork, this magnum opus, this testament to our weaker, paler & less physically attractive cousins - it is more a paradigm for the new anthropology of nerdity than simply a book. Borland et. al. have, through years of painstaking participant-observation study in this dungeonmaster-ish, Ultima-like, Everquest-addicted card-collecting subculture, brought together, in a single tremendous gotterdammerung of a bound mass of pulp product, the most complete and far-reaching study of what makes the nerds who they are and who, someday, they may become. Answer:

A: Yes


Q: Is this product review positive? Title: good, but enjoyed perfect better Review: recently, i read and thoroughly enjoyed perfect by judith mcnaught . . . so i decided to read another book for her, paradise, which contained some of the same characters . . . (the latter was written first; you don't have to read them in sequence, but if you do, you might enjoy them a bit more) . . . at any rate, i liked paradise; however, not nearly as much as perfect . . . it is definitely a "women's book" and while i like them at times, this one dragged for me a bit . . . story of a woman who turns to her former lover when her family empire is threatened by a hostile takoever attempt . . . . there's a good ending. Answer:

A: