Question: Title: From an Educated Southerner Review: As a re-enactor and Civil War Historian I tend to be critical of movies based on topics I know about. Gettysburg was a great movie and I believe Maxwell did another great job with this one. The attention to detail was amazing complete with the sight of the Nothern Lighs after the Battle of Fredricksburg, which is well documented on both sides. It showed both sides rather well and I think Stephen Lang was better as Jackson then I expected him to be. I believe that at least Sharpsburg, (Antietam for you Northern Folk) should have been shown. This was Chamberlian's first view of war and a very important battle. I also think they could have followed the book a little more. Over all though it was accurate, to the point of the famed 4th Texas Infantry Band and the conversation between General Hood and General Jackson. Seemed like it would be Hollywood but the conversation really occured and is documented in Hood's book. Is the review positive or negative?
Answer: Positive

Question: Title: Definitely not her best Review: I found this book to be bogged down in details and lacking in movement. The characters are too quirky and overstyled to feel real. Overall, the book seems self-indulgent and therefore does not speak to the reader. It has nice moments, but feels more like an exercise in writing rather than a piece that comes from the heart. Is the review positive or negative?
Answer: Negative

Question: Title: The worst fantasy novel ever? maybe. Review: This book has the most masochistic following I've ever heard of. Lord Foul's Bane was pure, unadulterated torture to read. It had nothing to offer me. The world is boring , it is filled with boring creatures and characters,but the very worst part is the "anti-hero" Thomas Covenant. Don't be mislead by the term anti-hero when it is applied to Covenant. This is not some loosely moraled but otherwise entertaining character, nor is he the hardcore kill em all and take no prisoners hero/villain.He's more the wimpy, whiny, irritating, rape a girl who has designs on you anyway kind of anti-hero. Save yourself from some of the worst reading imaginable, pick up a copy of Game Of Thrones, Dune, Eye Of The World[series],Tolkien etc... Sit back and enjoy. Is the review positive or negative?
Answer: