Problem:

Title: Not the edition described Review: The story and illustrations are certainly great. But this is now a collector's item and the version I got (2nd edition, 2nd printing, 2004) is not the October 1972 edition that I thought I was buying based on the Amazon product description. The more recent copy is not worth the big bucks I paid. Is this product review negative?
****
A: Yes


Problem:

Title: Lukewarm, with a vague ending and too many loose ends. Review: Excellent premise: In love with a murderer. Gradually, things grow tamer and more whimsical, until the story is muddled and meandering. The ending leaves too many things unresolved. I found that the first half of the book was intriguing. Kim was a murderer, and he draws Lynn in. This alone lends him a certain dark mystique. The rest of the book seems to be an attempt to justify his crime, when no justification is required. (or even desired!) The lyric richness of the novel is what saves it. Ms. Neimark's descriptions and style are like elegant poetry with the occasional stunning twist. Is this product review negative?
****
A: Yes


Problem:

Title: O'Neil's Basic Guide To Short Selling Review: This book essentially delivers what it promises. It give you a basic know-how of short-selling in stocks. About half of the book (at 195 some odd pages I could say pamphlet instead) was charts. I personally liked this because unlike other investment how-to books, you don't get too many significant rules and nuances without charts to explain them.At about $15 bucks, it's a deal. It isn't going to give you a comprehensive, in-depth study of the exact procedures and variables involved in short selling (O'Neil has a course for that, it runs at about $500+) but it'll hit home the basic theory of short selling.I would recommend this to anyone thinking about selling stocks short. Is this product review negative?
****
A: No


Problem:

Title: Love these girls Review: I love these girls. I used to listen to my Mom's copy of this when I was a kid and I'm glad to have my own now. Great EP. "Runaway Love" was a definite smash. I wish these girls would get back together and make some more records. Is this product review negative?
****
A: