Problem: 
Q: Title: A breath of fresh air Review: I have read and researched many spell books from the library and other sources and found Silver's book to be a breath of fresh air. I find that many "Wiccan" books are strict, condescending and lacking in direction and explanation of their spells. What a relief to read this book and find not only that the spells are practical, with easy-to-find ingredients, but for some spells, she also includes the history of some magic signs with footnotes. So far, this is the best book of practical magick I have come across for its' information, practicality and open-mindedness. I recommend this book to everyone who isn't stuck on the fact that this lady published a magick book and they didn't. Is this product review negative?
Answer: No
Problem: 
Q: Title: Readable, but somewhat off course Review: Aczel describes the compass as the second most important technological innovation in history, after the wheel. He then proceeds to wander through a series of brief histories without chronological order, giving disproportionate attention to a man who may or may not have lived in Amalfi, Italy. Aczel is at his best in capsule histories of maritime activity, but is frustratingly unsystematic in his chronologies and his descriptions of how the compass is used. He mentions the Global Positioning System, but does not tell us how it works. The figure titled "how the magnetic compass works" is misleading, as it shows the axis of the Earth's magnetic field coinciding with the Earth's axis of rotation. One gets the impression of a hastily written book. Is this product review negative?
Answer: Yes
Problem: 
Q: Title: A good ending - more or less Review: There was a time when director Jules Dassin created films presenting some societal or human anomaly that eventually got resolved. "The Naked City" is one of them. A murder took place, homicide is put on the case, finds the guy and.... Of course this is a far too simplistic and superficial synopsis of this splendid and gripping film but in many ways "The Naked City" contrasts with Dassin's later movie "Rififi", which presents a much grimmer and doomful view of society and mankind. Be that as it may, this piece is definitely worth watching on itself and should be regarded an outstanding film noir. The dvd is delivered in excellent quality and contains, as one of the extras, material of Dassin showing up at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art in 2004. Is this product review negative?
Answer: