Q: Title: This thing breaks after a few weeks! Review: I've had 3 different ones of this.2- came from amazon, as exchanges1- came from the company who makes them, as an exchange.All 3 broke or had a defect within 3-5 weeks.Defect 1- Loud noise every so often, like grinding (I thought this was the motor).Defect 2- Pop every so often, I investigated it, and the shifting mechanism that lifts the poop up was bent, no way to fix it except exchange.Defect 3- Metal rod in the shifting mechanism BROKE. A METAL PIECE.I'm done with this. It works perfectly fine the first few weeks and I was looking at the reviews wondering what people were complaining about.The design is solid, the implementation is horrible. Don't waste your time like I did. Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: A Great Tchaik 5th! Review: I bought this recording because I was a great fan of Jansons when he led the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra. I wanted to hear how he handled the Tchaik 5th, which is so often butchered under the baton of others. I was amazed and grateful for my decision. The Oslo Philharmonic led by Jansons does a splendid job of bringing this much loved, at least by me, symphony. Where it should be exciting it is very much so, and where it should be calm and soothing, Jansons brings it off perfectly. As a bonus, the sound is magnificent! I will keep this brief. A+++++!!! Is this product review negative?

A: No


Q: Title: Disappointment Review: I really loved the author's scifi novels under her other name. I looked forward to this one because I love old fashioned romantic novels, but what I found was a messy beginning full of unnecessary flashbacks. Once those end, the story gets going, but it's not "Jane Austen meets the Scarlet Pimpernell." There is no Jane Austen and no hint of Wordsworth, or Byron, just a lot of Georgette Heyer slang and characters. Including the heroine and a lower class girl getting on a first name basis in a public shop. Elizabeth Bennet never showed that kind of vulgarity. Why not make up a world instead? Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: THIS ITEM LASTS SHORTER THAN TWO YEARS Review: People often make reviews right after buying an item, so please know that this item was a wedding gift from '09.It is rusted beyond use. At a job with a quality knife company I won't name, I learned why this set sucks so much but is so expensive.It's a cheep knockoff!The Henckles logo SHOULD feature two stick figures as it's logo, and it should be listed as, "Made in Germany".This set (and all others that suck like this) have a stick figure holding a spear and are listed as, "Made in China".IF YOU WANT QUALITY, DON'T BUY THIS! THIS SET DULLS WITHIN FOUR MONTHS AND RUSTS WITHIN TWO YEARS!On the other hand, I have a set of knives that has lasted 20 years without needing to be sharpened and without rusting. So seriously after having a small set that works really well this item was really disappointing. Is this product review negative?

A: