(Q).
Title: A Good Book for Tolkien fanatics Review: The Atlas of Middle Earth is a good book for anyone who is obsessed with The Lord of the Rings. And I do mean obsessed. If you just watched the movies, this probably isn't for you. I would recommend this for anyone who is seriously interested in the history and cartography of Middle Earth. The author goes over each of the ages of Middle Earth, providing a history along with maps of the land. The maps are impressive, with one exception: they can be a bit confusing. There is a lot going on in the maps, and they really need to be studied in order to make sense of them. That being said, the concept of an atlas of such a well-loved and well developed world as Middle Earth, is great, and i commend the author on doing such a great job with it. Highly recommended for any serious Tolkienite. Is the review positive or negative?
(A).
Positive


(Q).
Title: wrong price and too old to be useful Review: I have this book, but my Afrikaans husband tells me it is ridiculous. Much of the language that is taught is not spoken any longer and would never be used. I have ordered her new book due out in Feb 2005 and have hopes that it will be up to date. Apart from that the price listed is horrendously wrong ! Is the review positive or negative?
(A).
Negative


(Q).
Title: Great Stuff Review: All i have to say is this is a great guy that can make some great music. Even if you are not a fan of christian music you should check this cd out because there is some really great stuff on it. Is the review positive or negative?
(A).
