Title: Really dull Review: I love the actors in this movie and was very excited to watch it. Unfortunately I found the plot dull. Maybe it was too "deep" for me. I thought the Michael Douglas Katie Holms student teacher thing would be more of a factor... but it was mostly about the Michael Douglas character (a successful writer who's teaching at a school and hasn't published a book in a long time) trying to help a very dark student writer (Tobey McGuire) who is very manipulative... Michael Douglas's publisher (Robert downey) shows up and is somewhat entertaining... but the relationships between the characters were just too odd for me to relate to. All the characters had such severe character flaws that they were just depressing to watch... there was no hero or heroine or any character I could remotely relate to. An aspiring writer might like this movie, but it was too strange for me. Is the review positive or negative?
Negative

Title: Not Free SF Reader Review: I am not quite sure what about this story did not jibe for me. I may have to give it another go, or at least another in this series. I think it may possibly be that I never was, or never will be, a Steven Baxter fan. I suspect it is something about his style or how he writes that does not gel for me personally. Otherwise, I can't pin down what is wrong with it, but I have tried it twice and didn't finish. Is the review positive or negative?
Negative

Title: Lucas is a poopy head Review: I dont usually like to write reviews for something i dont own. But I feel like i must do my part in bringing the overall review score down. Hopefully somewhere lucas is listening. Stop shoving down things down our throat. We liked the movie the way it was! I was going to buy this. It would have been the third star wars set that i bought. But after hearing the NOOOOO that was added, I just felt disgusted and cheated. Hopefully when lucas retires or something... whoever takes over lucasfilm will have the power to rerelease the original trilogy untouched. Or atlease make it a branching bluray. Is the review positive or negative?
