*Question*
Title: The Remarkable Shad Review: John McPhee has the ability - which I prize as a reader - to write engagingly about any subject, and Founding Fish is no exception. In this case, the subject is the American Shad. The fish is prized by anglers and gourmands and pops in and out of American history. But this is not "the cultural history of American Shad" (are we tired of these "cultural history of..." books yet?" Instead he weaves history with science as well as plenty of personal observation. The myriad digressions are like seams of precious metal. McPhee's world is populated with fascinating characters - ichthyologists, shad dart makers, and a seine fisherman from the Bay of Fundy. If you have a taste for non-fiction and would like a book that is diverting and pleasurable (rather than "hard-hitting" and topical) try reading John McPhee. Is the review positive or negative?
**Answer**
Positive

*Question*
Title: Overproduced Pop in a Straightjacket Review: Loved the "new" Pavement of Wowee and BTC, but not this. Buy the Spit on a Stranger EP instead. The five songs there (two of which were recorded in 1996) outdo everything on Terror Twilight (except for the title song, of course). Is the review positive or negative?
**Answer**
Negative

*Question*
Title: Not great Review: The smell is definitely not what I was hoping for. It smells horrid to me. Like baby powder and hair products, not the great smelling hair products either. It's an annoying smell that hangs around strongly all day, that smells. Is the review positive or negative?
**Answer**
Negative

*Question*
Title: How can one confuse Gooseberries for Red Tart Cherries? Review: Oregon Fruit Pitted Red Tart Cherries in Water, 14.5-Ounce Cans (Pack of 8)Red Tart Cherries are hard to find in the grocery store, so I was thrilled when I saw them for sale on Amazon. I ordered 2 packages. But, I received 1 package of Red Tart Cherries and, like another reviewer, the second package was a package of Gooseberries. Plus, each and every can of the Cherries was dented badly. So I could not use anything from this order. I must say that Amazon was wonderful with this issue and gave me a refund with no hassle. This is my first problem with an order from Amazon after many years of service. So for that I gave this 2 stars instead of 1 star. Is the review positive or negative?
**Answer**
