Title: Songbook I Review: "Hmm..." I'm wondering if I can have a look at the previous reviewer's "Dust Collectors" as it probably contains some great music - like this CD for example. Go Vic. Is the review positive or negative?
Positive

Title: A so-so effort from a great singer Review: By kd lang's standards, "All You Can Eat" is a decidedly mediocre effort. There is no denying that she is a magnificent vocalist, and that is certainly true here as well, but for this release she needed a better batch of songs. A few songs, such as "You're OK, "maybe" and "if I Were You" hint at the glories she has achieved on other releases. If you are a kd lang completist you'll probably want this one. If you are looking for a place to begin your kd collection look elsewhere. Is the review positive or negative?
Negative

Title: Who Would Buy This? Review: I was just about to buy this collection when a friend warned me off. I thought even though it was unathorized there would be some revelations - gossip even. But this is ... in the extreme. Nothing new here or original, and guess what - NO STONES MUSIC PERIOD. Who thought of producing a set on the greatest band in the world without the kick ... music included?? To make matters worse, some jerk thought it would be cool to get a guitar player to mimic Keef's classic riffs throughout - BAD IDEA. This box must have taken a day to throw together. Okay, so maybe getting hold of the guys would be tough, but why not get together some of the bands who have fallen under the spell of the Stones - GnR's, Aerosmith, Nugent, to name a few. Save your money and buy the recent remasters . If my friend hadn't warned be off, I'd be real ... now - nearly 50 bucks!!! GIVE ME A BREAK. There should be a law aginst putting stuff like this out . Is the review positive or negative?
