(Q).
Title: Chin P'ing Mei tranlated by David Tod Roy Vol. 1 Review: This is an accurate translation, or as accurate as possible, of recension A of this novel, published in 1618. It is far superior to the translation by Clement Egerton, "The Golden Lotus," which follows the later, and inferior, B and C recensions. It includes the prefaces and other introductory material, and the full text of Chapter 1, which appear in the Chinese language Jin Ping Mei Ci Hua, the definitive A recension. Is the review positive or negative?
(A).
Positive


(Q).
Title: Works as designed although very pricey Review: As far as an overall rating based on the product performance this item gets a full 5 stars from me as it works perfectly as designed. The only downside is that it is very expensive for something that really should be included with your Canopus converter to begin with. So as long as you can get over paying a pretty steep price for a very basic item you will be satisfied. Is the review positive or negative?
(A).
Positive


(Q).
Title: A great gift item Review: I purchased one for my husband who loved it. It is a general overview of many topics and is as much fun as it is educational.I will be purchasing 3 more as Christmas gifts for those on my list who "have everything." Is the review positive or negative?
(A).
