Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: Bone meets Holden Caulfield Review: Ellen Foster is a character in the tradition of Dorothy Allison's "Bastard Out of Carolina" and Salinger's "Catcher in the Rye." Kaye Gibbons' approach, to write entirely in the voice of her main character, serves the book's purpose well. Although Ellen's voice sometimes makes her storytelling confusing and vague, especially early in the novel, the book is often beautifully wrought and subtle. It is sometimes humorous, often heartbreaking, and simply written. A nice compliment to Salinger's overwrought prose and Allison's brutal forthrightness. This book ranks right up there with those other two works and in fact is probably better suited for high-school age readers than either. Not perfect, but well worth the read. Answer:
Positive
------
Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: Upset consumer Review: My husband and I purchased the Kitchen Wok 101 and ate with our food whatever peeled off the wok when I cooked with it. We are very disturbed and disgusted at how something like this can stay on the market. I really don't want to give this any star but 1 star is the lowest. Believe me it deserves no stars!! Answer:
Negative
------
Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: Junk Review: The contents of the kit are nice (although much smaller than I expected). My sons play with it often enough. I was disappointed in the quality of the tin box. It arrived broken. One of the pins had slipped out and is impossible to put back in place. I rigged it so my son could use it but it easily dented and is pretty much useless. I love HABA and have never had a problem before. This was disappointing especially for what you pay for HABA toys. Answer:
Negative
------
Is there a negative or positive tone to this product review? === Title: UP RIVER Review: From someone that grew up with these hardworking people I can tell you this is an honest account of this unique family. The book was well written and the photos were wonderful. Answer:
