Q: Title: Stellar. Review: Gritty, insightful account of former slaves owning slaves in antebellum Virginia. Breathtaking prose and deeply moving character development. Hands down the most compelling book I've read in the past several years. Is this product review negative?

A: No


Q: Title: One long whine Review: I was very disappointed with this book. I like Robert Silverberg and this book received many fine reviews. I just could not finish it. I got about halfway through and all I could think of was this: waaaa, waaaa, waaaa. Guess what - as a 50-year-old woman, there are things I can't do as well now as I could when I was younger. That's what happens. There are other things that I am better at now - experience counts.Since I am in that "middle-age" group, I really wanted this book to be interesting and insightful, from a slightly sci-fi standpoint, of course. Instead, I got one long boring whine about getting older. Yawn. If you're a positive-minded or matter-of-fact person, don't bother. You'll be aggravated with the main character after about 15 pages or so. Is this product review negative?

A: Yes


Q: Title: Beautiful Book. Review: Thanks to Paul for sharing his understanding and knowledge of said mushrooms with the world. Beautiful book. Is this product review negative?

A: No


Q: Title: Food, Inc. Documentary Review: I stopped eating fast food after viewing this documentary and lost 15 pounds in 6 weeks without doing anything else. We are what we eat! Is this product review negative?

A: