text: Literature History Philosophy Opinion Law & Justice All Topics
  The Holocaust Whire Rose Movement World War II Germany Nazism The White Rose Scholl
  Featured Article:
  The White Rose Movement: Conscience in Silent Nazi Germany
  By Ryan A. Piccirillo
  2010, Vol. 2 No. 09 | pg. 2/2 | «
  Within these words Locke invokes a right of the people to revolt against a government which fails to serve its purpose, namely the preservation of the property of its citizens. The Nazi government betrayed this purpose to the extreme, limiting its citizens’ most sacred property: their lives. Locke would therefore see it as a right of the people of Nazi Germany to resist this government’s rule, for a government which breaks its social contract with its people is illegitimate. This social right proposed by Locke is further evidence that The White Rose movement was fully in accordance with the tenets of justice.
  National Socialism under Hitler represented one of the most profound bastardizations of justice throughout history. In a normal society, laws must be followed to maintain order, but Nazi law disregarded the sanctity of human life. Martin Luther King, Jr. offered that “any law that degrades human personality is unjust” (King). By this definition, the entire system of fascism is a mockery of justice. King also demanded that “one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws” (King). His logic leads one to the undeniable conclusion that the members of The White Rose were among a minority who fulfilled their moral obligation to reject and resist Nazi rule.
  Evaluation of Success
  The members of The White Rose were unwilling to allow Germany’s history to be tarnished by an “irresponsible clique” (Scholl 73). They discovered through their own philosophical enlightenment that it was their moral duty, and the duty of every German, to stand up to the tyrannical government. In their final leaflet, the authors sum up their call to action with the following charge: “fight against the party!” (Scholl 92). Their goal was an all-encompassing intellectual rebellion in which all Germans would dissociate from the party and overthrow it by virtue of strength in numbers.
  Tragically, the members were executed before this goal could ever be realized. On the day of her execution, Sophie Scholl said of her impending doom, “What does my death matter if through us thousands of people will be stirred to action and awakened?” (Scholl 56). Unfortunately, Sophie’s hope was in vain for the months following her execution (and the executions of her colleagues) were dominated by the same Nazi fear-machine which kept the populace silent for years prior. No posthumous revolution took place. However, one should hesitate to call the movement a failure, for its significance is not diminished by this fact.
  The White Rose movement served a secondary purpose – a purpose its members had hoped would be shared by all of Germany; it demonstrated to the world that within the largely silent populace of Nazi Germany there existed those with a conscience. It recognized the guilt felt by every German and the shared responsibility for the atrocities. In her introduction to Inge Scholl’s book on the movement and the war, author Dorothee Sölle reflects that “sometimes [she] felt that it was just for us, the next generation, that [the members of The White Rose] had died. […] I wonder if they died so that we would know there had been at least a few people in Germany, a few students among hundreds of thousands, with a conscience” (Sölle x). In the Leaflet of the Resistance, the authors recognize the potential disgrace of inaction: “Germans! […] Are we to be forever the nation which is hated and rejected by all mankind?” (Scholl 89).
  Through their actions, the members of The White Rose evidenced that Germany was not a nation of cruel anti-Semites without consideration for the value of human life. However, German guilt and shame are intensified by the fact that so few chose to act. When Dorothee Sölle reflects on the Holocaust, she feels “choked with shame that there were not more ‘white roses’ in the bleakest hour of [her] country’s history” (Sölle xiv). Though it failed to ignite an uprising momentous enough to topple Hitler and the National Socialist Party, The White Rose movement successfully preserved German dignity for future generations by having the courage to act.
  The White Rose movement, like the stories of survival born from the Holocaust, demonstrates the capacity for human courage and morality. In the face of such horrific human-led atrocities, The White Rose movement contrasts the bleakest example of the capacity for evil which exists in humanity. Reflecting on the actions of her brother, sister, and their colleagues, Inge Scholl questions, “Were they heroes? They attempted no superhuman task. They stood up for a simple matter, an elementary principle: the right of the individual to choose his manner of life and to live in freedom” (Scholle 4).
  It is in fact because of this axiom that the members of The White Rose movement are indeed heroes; they overcame fear in a sea of cowardice and sacrificed their lives for the basic principle of freedom and the preservation of human dignity. Their actions epitomize heroism.
  King, Jr., Martin Luther. "Letter From a Birmingham Jail." 16 April 1963. Stanford University. 18 October 2009 .
  Locke, John. "Two Trestises of Government." 2003-2009. Lonang Library. 17 October 2009 .
  Scholl, Inge. The White Rose. Middletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press, 1983.
  Sölle, Dorothee. "Introduction to the Second Edition: The Legacy of The White Rose." Scholl, Inge. The White Rose. Middletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University Press, 1983. ix-xiv.
  Piccirillo, R. A. (2010). "The White Rose Movement: Conscience in Silent Nazi Germany." Inquiries Journal/Student Pulse, 2(09). Retrieved from http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=1671
  Piccirillo, Ryan A. "The White Rose Movement: Conscience in Silent Nazi Germany." Inquiries Journal/Student Pulse 2.09 (2010). <http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=1671>
  Piccirillo, Ryan A. 2010. The White Rose Movement: Conscience in Silent Nazi Germany. Inquiries Journal/Student Pulse 2 (09), http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=1671
  PICCIRILLO, R. A. 2010. The White Rose Movement: Conscience in Silent Nazi Germany. Inquiries Journal/Student Pulse [Online], 2. Available: http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/a?id=1671
  Ryan A. Piccirillo graduated in 2012 with a Bachelors degree in Film from Boston University in Boston, MA.
  The Technological Evolution of Filmmaking and its Relation to Quality in Cinema
  Qi (Chi) in James Cameron's Avatar
  The Mind in the Brain, the Brain in a Robot: Strong AI in an Artificial Neural Network Brain Replica Housed in an Autonomous, Sensory Endowed Robot
  Logotherapy and the Holocaust: Uniting Human Experience in Extremity and Normality
  The Sobibor Revolt: "Death to the Fascists"
  Keywords:The Holocaust Whire Rose Movement World War II Germany Nazism The White Rose Scholl
  Linguistics » Language Attrition
  First Language Attrition in German Jewish Refugees of the Nazi Dictatorship: The Impact of Age and...
  Film & Media » Worl War II
  Hitler's Use of Film in Germany, Leading up to and During World War II
  History » World War I
  The White Feather Campaign: A Struggle with Masculinity During World War I
  Literature » American Literature
  Comparing Faulkner's A Rose for Emily and Porter's The Jilting of Granny Weatherall...
  First Language Attrition in German Jewish Refugees of the Nazi Dictatorship: The Impact of Age and Attitude on Language Loss
  First language attrition (L1) studies are a comparably young and theoretically unspecified field of research in bilingualism. Young, because the first scientifically acclaimed, related... MORE»
  German cinema from 1927 to 1945 was affected drastically by the political environment that grew within the nation. After Germany suffered drastically at the hands of the Versailles treaty and its reparations clause, Adolph Hitler, the Fuhrer of Nazi Germany, and the Nazi Party ascended to power, preaching unity and the rise of a... MORE»
  World War I was a brutal conflict that shattered countries, redefined warfare with its bloody massacres, and left a generation with only the memories of the horrors they had seen. The trench warfare of the battlefield tore young Englishmen apart and turned their long held belief in the nobility of battle into a terrifying mockery. But it wasn’t only on the Front that the men of England faced a fight that threatened their very being. Those... MORE»
  White Feather Campaign Gender World War I Masculinity
  Comparing Faulkner's A Rose for Emily and Porter's The Jilting of Granny Weatherall
  William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” focuses on the life and death of Emily Grierson, a monumental figure representing the traditional South in her hometown of Jefferson, Mississippi. Although the story... MORE»
  Latest in History
  Newspaper Coverage of the Mau Mau Movement: A Constructivist Argument
  By Esme Trahair
  On February 14th, 1965, just one week before he was assassinated, Malcolm X delivered a speech in Detroit. He spoke about his beliefs concerning segregation and civil rights, and made a point of contextualizing the civil rights movement globally... Read Article »
  Mau Mau Kenya Decolonization Sub-Saharan Africa Civil Rights Movement Revolution Colonialism
  Victoria Era
  Victorian Racism: An Explication of Scientific Knowledge, its Social Character, and its Relation to Victorian Popular Culture
  By Peter H. Conlin
  The British Empire of the nineteenth century displayed and embodied racism in its composite. In embodying this idea of racial inequality, the Empire created grounds on which it could justify the imperialist actions that it executed throughout the... Read Article »
  Victorian Era British Empire Colonialism Racism Scientific Knowledge British Imperialism
  Persianization and Intimidation: Investigating Discord in the Court of Alexander the Great
  By E. M. Suazo
  A subset of Alexandrian scholarship which has garnered long-held fascination does not center upon a success, but rather a failure: that is, the divide in his court which emerged during his Asiatic campaigns. Such a divide, though incited by a number... Read Article »
  Alexander the Great Ancient History Ancient Greece Military History
  Stalin and the Drive to Industrialize the Soviet Union
  By Joshua R. Keefe
  The late twenties and early thirties were perhaps the most transformative period in Soviet history. It was during this period Stalin consolidated his grip on power and was allowed to rule with impunity, instituting his “revolution from above... Read Article »
  Joseph Stalin Stalin USSR Communism Soviet Union Industrialization Collectivism Collectivization
  Copernicus, Galileo, and the Church: Science in a Religious World
  By Nicholas P. Leveillee
  During most of the 16th and 17th centuries, fear of heretics spreading teachings and opinions that contradicted the Bible dominated the Catholic Church. They persecuted scientists who formed theories the Church deemed heretical and forbade people... Read Article »
  Copernicus Galileo Astronomy History Of Science Scientific Revolution Spanish Inquisition Catholic Church
  Sexual Relations Between Elite White Women and Enslaved Men in the Antebellum South: A Socio-Historical Analysis
  By J. M. Allain
  There is ample evidence of sexual relations, from rapes to what appear to be relatively symbiotic romantic partnerships, between white slave masters and black women in the Antebellum South. Much rarer were sexual relations between white women and... Read Article »
  American History Slavery Race Gender Sex Rape Power American Slavery
  Lenin's New Economic Policy: What it was and how it Changed the Soviet Union
  By Helene M. Glaza
  By the time 1921 came around, Russia’s economy had been maimed by the effects of War Communism. Socialism had not begun on a good note, and Vladimir Lenin was becoming concerned with the unfortunate state of the economy. His response to the... Read Article »
  Vladimir Lenin Soviet Union Economic Policy Communism Russian History USSR New Economic Policy
  Page Top « Prev Page