abstract: Intelligent transportation systems (ITSs) will be a major component of tomorrow's smart cities. However, realizing the true potential of ITSs requires ultra-low latency and reliable data analytics solutions that can combine, in real-time, a heterogeneous mix of data stemming from the ITS network and its environment. Such data analytics capabilities cannot be provided by conventional cloud-centric data processing techniques whose communication and computing latency can be high. Instead, edge-centric solutions that are tailored to the unique ITS environment must be developed. In this paper, an edge analytics architecture for ITSs is introduced in which data is processed at the vehicle or roadside smart sensor level in order to overcome the ITS latency and reliability challenges. With a higher capability of passengers' mobile devices and intra-vehicle processors, such a distributed edge computing architecture can leverage deep learning techniques for reliable mobile sensing in ITSs. In this context, the ITS mobile edge analytics challenges pertaining to heterogeneous data, autonomous control, vehicular platoon control, and cyber-physical security are investigated. Then, different deep learning solutions for such challenges are proposed. The proposed deep learning solutions will enable ITS edge analytics by endowing the ITS devices with powerful computer vision and signal processing functions. Preliminary results show that the proposed edge analytics architecture, coupled with the power of deep learning algorithms, can provide a reliable, secure, and truly smart transportation environment.
author:

[^1]
bibliography: references.bib
title: Deep Learning for Reliable Mobile Edge Analytics in Intelligent Transportation Systems

# Introduction

Intelligent transportation systems (ITSs) are arguably the most anticipated smart city services . ITSs are built on the premise of endowing vehicles and transportation infrastructure with connectivity, sensing, and autonomy, so as to provide safer road travel and ensure effective transportation. To enable this ITS vision, there is a need to equip vehicles and transportation infrastructure with smart sensors that can collect and process a heterogeneous set of data on each vehicle, its passengers, and its environment . This information collection must be done at ultra-low latency and in real time, since ITSs must support autonomous features, such as self-driving vehicles. Indeed, monitoring and managing the operation of an ITS requires a reliable communication and data analytics infrastructure to transmit and process the various smart sensor data . However, due to the massive number of mobile sensors in an ITS, the transmission of all of the sensor measurements to a remotely located cloud – as is done traditionally – can result in high delays, communication network congestions, and computational overload. This will not be tolerable for an ITS since any delayed decision in the system might cause congestions, travel delays, and accidents. Therefore, efficient *edge computing and analytics* frameworks must be proposed to process much of the data at the level of each individual vehicle (and infrastructure) and send only the results to the cloud in order to meet the ITS latency and reliability challenges.

Current improvements in processing units of mobile devices, that can handle Gigabits of data in real-time, make them suitable for implementation of ITS edge analytics solutions. The passengers' mobile devices can be used as edge processors due to the available power supply from the vehicle. Moreover, every vehicle can be equipped with capable processing devices such as microprocessors, that can support complex, edge computing processes. However, for effective data processing, computationally capable edge devices cannot enable the vision of ITSs, unless they are coupled with artificially-intelligent algorithms that can perform optimized edge analytics. In order to enable such smart, edge analytics, one can rely on the emerging frameworks from *deep learning* , that have shown their effectiveness in dealing with large image and signal datasets. Deep learning techniques can perform sophisticated functions which cannot be analytically derived such as image and speech recognition . Therefore, if properly deployed, deep learning tools can be an effective edge analytics tool for ITSs, as they enable the optimization and processing of the heterogeneous ITS data.

Deep learning approaches have already been proposed for various ITS applications such as in and . In , the authors proposed a novel deep-learning based traffic flow prediction method based on an autoencoder model that represents traffic flow features for prediction. The work in evaluated the temporal and spatial patterns of transportation network flow using a multi task learning architecture. These early works have shown that deep learning algorithms outperform conventional regression and time series methods in transportation systems, thus motivating further research in this area.

The main contribution of this paper is to investigate the challenges and opportunities brought forward by the use of mobile edge analytics in ITSs. In particular, we first overview the data processing challenges in ITSs with a focus on latency, analytics, and computational aspects. To address these challenges, we introduce an edge computing and analytics architecture, shown in Fig. , that incorporates deep learning techniques at the level of the passengers' mobile devices and intra-vehicle processors. We then propose deep learning techniques for heterogeneous data processing, path planning, vehicular platoon control, driver behavior prediction, and ITS cyber-physical security that, when implemented at the edge of an ITS, will reduce the communication and computation load on the cloud.

Here, we note that, although some surveys on deep learning and ITSs already exist such as in and , however, these existing surveys do not propose any ITS edge analytics framework. Moreover, these surveys do not study the reliability and latency challenges pertaining to ITS data analytics. Instead, we propose a novel ITS edge analytics architecture that can exploit deep learning techniques running at the level of passengers mobile devices and intra-vehicle processors to process large datasets and enable a truly smart transportation system operation. This architecture improves the performance of ITS in terms of reliability and latency, as it allows the transmission of only a summary or basic results of the data to the cloud, instead of transmitting the entire generated data.

The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section we overview the ITS edge analytics challenges. Section proposes deep learning techniques for ITS data processing. Finally, conclusions are drawn in .

# Mobile Edge Analytics in ITSs: Opportunities and Challenges

ITSs will encompass a broad range of mission-critical data analytics tasks that include autonomous control, path planning, and vehicular platooning. Self-driving vehicles will be equipped with numerous sensors that will collect measurements from each vehicle's environment. Moreover, roadside sensors and traffic control signals will become more intelligent and will generate high volumes of data. The information generated from these sensors must be processed with low latency to ensure a reliable ITS operation. To operate in an ultra-low latency regime, typically, each sensor must generate shorter packet sizes which, when combined with a massive number of sensors, will cause severe degradation in communication throughput. On the other hand, to enhance reliability, more communication resources are needed. Therefore, given the limited availability of wireless communication and computational resources, achieving the latency and reliability requirements of ITSs will be challenging.

One conventional approach is to rely on a remote cloud to upload data and run sophisticated algorithms. However, this approach yields to high end-to-end latency due to the massive computation and communication load generated by the vehicles and roadside sensors. Therefore, the use of an edge computing architecture, such as the one proposed in Fig. , that relies on highly capable intra-vehicle processors as well as passengers mobile equipment to perform ITS edge analytics can potentially improve both latency and reliability, while reducing the reliance on a remote cloud. To enable such edge analytics in the context of ITS, one must meet a number of challenges that range from heterogeneous data integration and vehicular dynamics control to driver behavior prediction. Next, we provide an in-depth exposition of those challenges and we propose a deep learning framework to address them.

## Heterogeneous Data Sources

Developing autonomous and connected ITSs will require the use of different sensor types to collect a heterogeneous mix of measurements including environmental features, vehicle dynamics, fuel consumption, and driver's fatigue level. The heterogeneity and sheer volume of such real-time information will require high reliability and ultra-low latency for mutual information sharing between vehicles or event-driven and cyclic reports to the cloud. To improve reliability and latency requirements, optimal processing methods must be deployed to combine such heterogeneous data at the level of each vehicle to reduce the unnecessary and redundant information before transmission to other vehicles or to the cloud.

## Path Planning and Autonomous Control

One key ITS challenge is the optimal routing of self-driving vehicles in an effort to reduce the total road travel delay. Moreover, self-driving vehicles must control their speed, direction, and acceleration autonomously . Given the high density of the vehicles in crowded streets and the random decisions taken by human drivers, performing vehicular path planning and autonomous control algorithms will be challenging. Although a centralized cloud can update the path plan and control decision of each self-driving vehicle this requires real-time tracking of the vehicles as well as the transmission of location information from the vehicles to the cloud. Such a cloud-centric approach will not be suitable for ITS due to the need for high bandwidth to transmit raw data as well as the increased latency over the the vehicle-to-cloud communication link. To overcome these challenges, online edge algorithms must be implemented individually by each vehicle to plan the future path and control the vehicle's dynamics.

## Vehicular Platoon Control

Platooning of self-driving or driver-controlled vehicles can potentially enhance highway safety, improve traffic stability, and reduce fuel consumption. In a platoon, each joining self-driving vehicle must individually take decisions regarding its dynamics with the least effect on the stability of the platoon. The decisions taken by each vehicle require real-time processing and collection of measurements and images from its environment. A key point here is that, in a platoon, each vehicle experiences approximately a same environment and collects almost identical measurements, with a small delay compared to its leading vehicle. Hence, mutual information sharing between the vehicles inside a platoon can potentially reduce the total computational load in the platoon due to redundant measurements. Moreover, platoons provide an ideal use case for collaborative edge analytics such as *federated learning* in which vehicles collaboratively learn a shared prediction model while keeping all of the training data on their own which helps them to be decoupled from the cloud. In a nutshell, using edge analytics to reduce a platoon's total data generation will enable ultra-low latency and reliable operation as it substantially reduces the total communication and computation overhead.

## Semi-autonomous ITSs

Next-generation *semi-autonomous ITSs* must ensure the co-existence of both autonomous, self-driving vehicles, as well as driver-controlled vehicles. While autonomous vehicles can use sensing technologies to optimally navigate to their destination, driver-controlled vehicles will still rely on humans, and, hence, their decisions will often be guided by potentially unpredictable behavior. This co-existence between autonomous controlled vehicles and the unpredictable behavior of human drivers will bring forward new edge analytics challenges. For instance, the existence of drivers with unpredictable actions will cause more sensor readings in the autonomous vehicles that must track the drivers' decisions and optimize their own dynamics. Thus, novel edge analytics frameworks are needed to identify self-driving vehicles from driver-controlled vehicles and predict the behavior of a driver in the vicinity of other self-driving cars. The prediction of driver behavior will reduce the computational overhead due to the reduction in the sensor readings of self-driving vehicles in the proximity of driver-controlled vehicles. Indeed, this computational load reduction will allow for low-latency edge analytics.

## ITS Security

Along with their performance benefits, edge analytics techniques can make the ITS more vulnerable to cyber-physical attacks as adversaries will find it easier to attack the link between vehicles rather than attacking a more secure cloud. Therefore, security of information sharing across ITS components such as vehicles, roadside sensors, and the cloud is crucial since any faulty sensor measurement and process at the ITS edge can cause accidents and injuries. Moreover, a cyber attacker that can inject faulty information to a platoon or autonomous vehicle will cause non optimality in their control system stability. Therefore, there is a need for new techniques to authenticate and secure the communication links between vehicles, as well as between vehicles and cloud. For instance, to implement real-time edge analytics, inter-vehicle communication must be properly secured against cyber attacks in the vicinity of the vehicles. Furthermore, the ITS must be resilient to possible collisions so as to recover from congestions caused by accidents. Hence, online vehicle dynamics tracking algorithms should be studied to detect anomalous ITS device behavior and predict possible collisions.

Managing massive ITS generated data for path planning, vehicular platoon control, and driver behavior identification requires computer vision techniques to extract image features, identify the environment, and detect the surrounding objects. Processing heterogeneous ITS data involves extraction of correlations between the signals of different sources. From a security perspective, relying on conventional message protection techniques such as encryption will not be effective for inter-vehicle communication links, since the transmitted message between vehicles will be of small size. Hence, we propose *deep learning techniques* for meeting the ITS edge analytics challenges due to their proven effectiveness. Deep learning allows computational methods that are composed of multiple processing layers to learn data features with higher levels of abstraction. Next, we first introduce the basics of deep learning and, then, discuss how deep learning can be used for ITS edge analytics.

# Deep Learning for Mobile Sensing in ITS

## Overview on Deep Learning

Deep neural networks (DNNs) are an emerging type of artificial neural networks (ANNs). In general, ANNs are function approximators used to recognize correlations between relevant features and the output of processed data. They consist of an input layer that represents the input signal, at least one hidden layer, and an output layer that consists of a logistic, or softmax, classifier that assigns a likelihood to a particular outcome. DNNs are ANNs with multiple hidden layers. In DNNs, each hidden layer will train on a distinct features set based on the previous hidden layer's output. This is known as feature hierarchy and allows DNNs to model high-level abstractions in data thus learning multiple levels of representation and abstraction. Therefore, DNNs are suitable for recognizing and modeling complex features from large and high-dimensional datasets with many parameters such as camera, LIDAR, radar, and vehicle dynamics readings in ITSs. This renders DNNs suitable for meeting the edge analytics challenges of ITS discussed in Section II. Several types of DNNs can be be used for ITS edge analytics such as deep convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and restricted Boltzmann machines (RBMs) that can be used in heterogeneous data processing and automatic control, recurrent neural networks (RNNs) and that can be applicable for vehicle dynamics estimation, and generative adversarial networks (GANs) and long-short term memory (LSTM) that are useful for ITS security. Next, we provide an in-depth look on how such DNN techniques can be used for reliable ITS edge analytics.

## Deep Learning for ITS Edge Analytics and Mobile Sensing

### Multimodal RBM for Heterogeneous Data Integration

Self-driving cars will encompass a variety of sensors, from light sensors and cameras to ultrasound sensors, enabling each vehicle to make sense of its surrounding environment. As such, any control action taken by a self-driving vehicle will depend on the different types of sensor data. Integrating such heterogeneous sensor readings into one vector can provide a better assessment of the environment as compared to using each type of data independently. Nevertheless, there exists differences between sensors ranging from sampling rates to the data generation model thus making ITS sensor integration challenging. In this regard, multimodal RBMs are a suitable tool for combining different perspectives captured in signals of multimodal data for a system with multiple sensors . A multimodal RBM can be implemented in the ITS edge components to identify nonintuitive features largely from cross-sensor correlations which can yield accurate estimation. For instance, a system trained simultaneously to detect lane markings, cars, and pedestrians does better than three separate systems trained in isolation since the single network can share information among the separate tasks.

### CNN-LSTM for Path Planning and Autonomous Control

Autonomous self-driving cars require a perception system to sense their surrounding environment such as other cars, people, lampposts, and curbs. Therefore, to determine the paths of self-driving vehicles, one can combine online and offline solutions into one framework. Self-driving vehicles can use an offline environmental map as one of many data streams, combining it with other sensor inputs that detect dynamic objects to better determine their paths. This, in essence, allows self-driving vehicles to take actions in an online manner and at the edge thus reducing the delay for decision making and the probability of occurrence of accidents or congestion events while increasing fuel efficiency. In this regard, CNNs can be combined with LSTMs within self-driving vehicles, as a part of the introduced edge analytics architecture, resulting in a CNN-LSTM network. In particular, CNN can be used to identify objects by extracting the features from the input image . These features are then fed to an LSTM network which is used in the sequence task portion of the system. This will allow self-driving cars to take a sequence of steps along their corresponding paths based on the features extracted by the CNN.

### CNNs and Vehicular Communication for Platoon Control

In a platoon, vehicles following a leading vehicle, experience an almost identical road environment as the leading vehicle. Therefore, instead of processing the collected data at all of the vehicles, only the leading vehicle can process the environment and share the result with its followers using vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V) communication links .

Two fundamental requirements for this procedure are: a) a mechanism for similarity detection in the collected data of different vehicles and b) a vehicular communication network for sharing the results among vehicles. A CNN can allow a vehicle to compare its own environmental observations with those received from the leading vehicle, and in case of similarity the processing result from the leading car can be used. Therefore, in summary, a leading vehicle passing a stationary roadway processes its observations at the edge and can share the result with the following vehicles and roadside infrastructure using a cellular network. To this end, cellular communication technology can support vehicle-to-everything (V2X) communications. The following vehicles compare the leading vehicle's observation with their own observations through a CNN and in case of similarity, the following vehicles use the result of the leading vehicle without processing their own observation. This in turn reduces the computational overhead caused by processing the observation of all the vehicles at the cloud. CNNs are also suitable for various wireless V2X resource allocation problems in ITS. In essence, many resource allocation functions, such as power control or spectrum allocation can make use of CNN-based reinforcement learning algorithms to dynamically adapt the V2X network resources to the operation of the vehicles.

To demonstrate the benefits of information sharing and CNNs, we investigated the decision sharing of a leading vehicle in a platoon of self-driving vehicles. Fig. shows a simulation of three self-driving vehicles travelling over the same road. Two cases are considered: a) All vehicles independently record images from the environment and, using their own CNN, decide on their speed and wheel angle and b) Only the leading vehicle records images from the environment and takes decision using its own CNN and shares the decision with its followers. The followers use the decision shared by the leading vehicle without recording images from the environment when they are at a *steady state*, however, they use their own CNN while they are not at a steady state. The steady state is a system state at which all of the platoon's vehicles have an equal speed. Before $75$ seconds, all three vehicles are at a non-steady state and, thus, they all observe their environment using their own cameras resulting in $250$ Mbps of generated data. However, after $75$ seconds, we can see that, since leading vehicle and first following vehicle are at a steady state, the first follower uses the computational results of the leading vehicle without using its own camera. Therefore, the total data generation reduces to $150$ Mbps. After $225$ seconds, the second follower reaches the steady state and uses the shared results of the leading vehicles and stops using its own camera. Consequently, the total data generated by the platoon reduces to $75$. Fig. demonstrates that information sharing by a leading vehicle results in a reduction of total sensor readings in the platoon.

### RNN for Driver Behavior Prediction

An RNN is an ANN that can process a sequence of input to extract temporal behaviors . In a semi-autonomous ITS, the driver behavior can be predicted using RNN blocks implemented at the edge, i.e., at the self-driving vehicles following a driver-controlled vehicle. Here, a following self-driving vehicle will observe the decisions taken by the leading driver in different situations and will use these observations as inputs to an RNN. Consequently, the RNN will recognize the behavior of the leading driver and will predict its future actions. Eventually, prediction of the leading driver behavior will reduce the computational load on a following self-driving vehicle since less sensor readings from the leading driver-controlled vehicle will be needed.

### GAN and LSTM for ITS Security

GANs are ANNs that learn to create synthetic data similar to some real data. GANs consist of two main networks: a generative network and a discriminative network. The discriminator is a classifier that distinguishes between artificially generated data and real data. It can take the form of a CNN binary classifier. While the discriminator network identifies the reality of a dataset, the generative network takes random input values and transforms them into stealthy datasets that are not recognizable by the discriminative network. In an ITS, a cyber attacker can transmit a stealthy message to self-driving vehicles and manipulate their decisions. In this respect, a GAN's discriminator network can be implemented at the ITS edge components to distinguish fake data generated by an adversary and real data.

Moreover, LSTM is a suitable ANN for data transmission security since it can extract information from a sequence of past data and predict the future data sequence. LSTMs can be trained to fingerprint a data sequence which allows authentication of messages between vehicles. In the case of unauthenticated messages from a cyber attacker, fingerprints extracted from the data sequence will not match with authenticated fingerprints. Fig. shows a comparison between authenticated and unauthenticated reports transmitted from a vehicle to the cloud. Here, one LSTM network is implemented to extract the signal fingerprint and then embed it in the signal. At the cloud, another LSTM network is implemented to extract fingerprints from the reported data and compare them with the embedded authenticated fingerprint set. Based on the difference between the extracted and authenticated fingerprints, cyber attacks can be detected. Fig. shows that the security check at the cloud causes a delay of only $0.1$ seconds which can be reasonable for an ITS. GAN and LSTM networks can solve reliability and latency challenges in ITS security applications by being implemented at the edge of ITS since they will have better accuracy with lower delay compared to traditional cloud-based security architecture.

Fig. briefly overviews the various proposed deep learning solutions.

## Future Research Challenges in DNNs for ITS Edge Analytics

DNNs are a promising solution for addressing a wealth of ITS edge analytics and sensing problems. However, there exists a number of challenges that must be overcome in future research, as outlined next:

### Data Accuracy

Deep learning techniques require a large set of accurate data for training. Inaccurate datasets used for training will result in an erroneous ANN. Since the decision making process in an ITS requires heterogeneous types of data including vehicle's position and speed, spacing between the vehicles and distance to the roadside objects, therefor data collection needs a precise supervision. Moreover, since in the edge architecture, vehicles, roadside sensors, and mobile devices process the data, results can be more error prone due to the limited capabilities of edge devices.

### Unpredictable Situations

An ITS might encounter unpredictable situations due to the existence of randomness in drivers' behavior and environmental effects. Such unpredictable situations will cause reaction delay in the system. Therefore, ITS-centric deep learning methods must account for unpredictable situations by learning the behavior of drivers to reduce the delay caused by reacting to drivers' action. In this case, since the driving profiles cannot be stored on the edge of the ITS due to the security and memory constraints, the number of queries to the cloud will increase.

### Resilience

ITS DNNs must be resilient to vehicle accidents. An ITS must recover from accidents as quickly as possible to avoid long transportation delays. This is particularly important when processing is done at the edge, as proposed here, since edge devices may be damaged and, thus, they need to rely on either neighbors or revert back to cloud processing. Therefore, possible accidents must be taken into account while implementing deep learning methods at the edge of the ITS.

### Drivers against Self-driving Vehicles

Although an RNN is useful in driver behavior classification and prediction, driver-controlled vehicles might also change their behavior while interacting with self-driving vehicles. To address this issue, game-theoretic solutions can be developed in which the players are self-driving vehicle and a driver-controlled vehicle sharing a road. The optimal distance and speed for these vehicles can be derived by taking into account their dependent actions while they are building a platoon. A key advantage of game-theoretic approaches is their inherent ability to be implemented in a self-organizing manner, at the ITS edge. Therefore, by combination of game-theory with an RNN, self-driving and driver-controlled vehicles interaction can be analyzed at the ITS edge.

### Robustness

DNNs can be compromised by intentional noise injected by cyber attackers. For instance, altering some of pixels in a traffic sign might deceive an ANN from acting properly. In general, moving the intelligence to the network's edge will increase the threats of cyber attacks, and, hence, any proposed deep learning methods must be properly secured.

### Delay-intensive Training Phase

The training phase of a DNN can be time consuming which makes their usage and testing nontrivial in some scenarios, especially, when trying to add a new feature to the DNN. Hence, better training methods must be proposed to reduce the training delay. For example, federated learning approaches where the edge components can cooperatively learn the features can boost the train performance.

# Conclusion

In this paper, we have proposed a novel ITS architecture that relies on edge analytics and deep learning to optimize its computation, latency, reliability, and overall operation. In particular, we have proposed deep learning techniques to solve a plethora of edge analytics challenges in ITSs that include measurements heterogeneity, path planning, autonomous vehicle control, platoon control, semi-autonomous ITSs, and cyber-physical security. For each challenge, we have proposed a suitable deep learning framework that can be implemented as a part of an edge computing and analytics architecture to process a vehicle's data before transmitting to the cloud. Finally, we have outlined some of the key open problems regarding the implementation of deep learning techniques for edge analytics in ITSs.

[^1]: This research was supported by the U.S. National Science Foundation under Grants OAC-1541105 and IIS-1633363.


author: A. Marecki; B. Swoboda
date: Received 23 July 2010 / Accepted 23 September 2010
title: The transition from quasar radio-loud to radio-quiet state
  in the framework of the black hole scalability hypothesis

There are several lines of evidence that active galactic nuclei (AGN) can be regarded as scaled-up X-ray binaries (XRB). The timescales of the evolutionary phenomena in these two classes are proportional to the black hole (BH) masses. Consequently, unlike in the case of XRBs, the evolution of AGNs is too slow to be followed directly. What could be done, however, is to assign particular types of active galaxies to different evolutionary stages observable in XRBs. We studied such an assignment for three quasars with clear signatures of a recent transition from the radio-loud to the radio-quiet state. The quasars we investigated have large-scale radio lobes that are clearly asymmetric – one lobe is of Fanaroff-Riley II type, while the other one is a diffuse relic devoid of a hotspot. We suggest that the prime cause of the asymmetry of these radio sources is that the nuclei of their host galaxies currently produce no jets. To prove that, we observed them with milliarcsecond resolution to check if they are similar to those in radio-quiet quasars. The observations carried out with the EVN revealed that the nuclei of the quasars under investigation are not of a core-jet type that is characteristic for radio-loud, lobe-dominated quasars. It follows that the lobes are no longer fuelled and that the apparent asymmetry results from the orientation, which causes a time lag of the order of 10$^6$ years between their images: the lobe perceived as a relic is nearer than the lobe with a hotspot and so it is observed in a later stage of the decay. The three AGNs under investigation were radio-loud earlier, but now they have switched to the radio-quiet state. In the framework of the XRB/AGN unification, the above means that they have left the very high state and have moved now to the high/soft state. If this scenario is correct it poses a challenge to the so-called spin paradigm. While a radio-loud AGN must have a spinning BH in its centre, the BH of a radio-quiet AGN does not necessarily have low spin; AGNs with high-spin BHs, like those we deal with here, may become radio-quiet.

# Introduction

In mathematical terms, black holes (BHs) are very simple objects. In principle, only two parameters, mass and spin, are sufficient to describe them fully. Consequently, various similarities and analogies between different classes of astronomical objects containing a BH in their centres seem to be likely. Masses of BHs encountered in X-ray binaries (XRBs) on the one extreme and active galactic nuclei (AGNs) on the other span over eight orders of magnitude or more, and it is of interest whether any scaling laws connecting objects of otherwise quite different types like XRBs and AGNs exist – see e.g. for a review. For the first time, a suggestion that this scaling actually takes place was made by . A corollary of a possible unification of objects with accreting BHs based on their scalability is of great importance because it paves the way for the extrapolation of some observable phenomena in one domain of BHs, namely stellar-mass BHs, to the other, i.e. to the domain of supermassive BHs (SMBHs) encountered in AGNs. Given that in particular characteristic timescales should be proportional to the mass, slow processes that are ongoing in AGNs could be directly followed in XRBs.

The first spectacular manifestation of putative BH scalability was discovered by who observed the X-ray source with the Very Large Array (VLA) and found its radio structure to be a double-sided jet straddling a compact and variable core. A striking similarity between the appearance of this phenomenon and that of radio-loud quasars (RLQs) led to coining the term "microquasar" for jet-producing XRBs . However, this was – a highly variable XRB containing a BH of $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}15 $M_{\sun}$ – which became an archetypal microquasar, see the review by . It was discovered on 1992 August 15 in the X-ray domain and a few months later in radio . The most exciting property of this object was revealed when resolved its radio structure down to the fraction of an arcsecond with the VLA and detected several components moving either toward the east or west away from the core of GRS 1915+105 with apparently superluminal velocities. By the time of the announcement of that ground-breaking discovery, apparent superluminal motion (SLM) was already well known, but this phenomenon was pertinent entirely to AGNs. Thus, finding the SLM in the vicinity of a Galactic BH not only rendered the term "microquasar" most appropriate for GRS 1915+105 but also provided hard proof for the existence of an XRB vs. AGN analogy.

This analogy was further confirmed by , who monitored X-ray and radio emission of AGN in radio galaxy and found dips in the X-ray emission that were followed by ejections of bright superluminal knots in the radio jet, just like in microquasars where dips in the X-ray emission precede radio flares. What was more, the mean time between the X-ray dips appeared to scale roughly with the BH mass. An extension of that monitoring programme carried out by the same group over five years (2002-2007) included observations at X-ray (2-10 keV), optical (R and V bands), and radio (14.5 and 37 GHz), as well as imaging with the Very Long Baseline Array (VLBA) at 43 GHz . The results of this comprehensive investigation were compelling enough to formulate a paradigm that XRBs and both radio-loud and radio-quiet active galactic nuclei were fundamentally similar systems, with characteristic time and size scales linearly proportional to the mass of the central BH. Also, the jet generation mechanism in microquasars and quasars seems to be the same, following the work of , who showed that the variability pattern of GRS 1915+105 can be reproduced by the standard shock model used for extragalactic jets, e.g. that in . Hence, the physical nature of relativistic jets does not depend on the mass of the BH and consequently the study of jets in both quasars and microquasars is complementary. In line with the above results, showed that characteristic timescales in the X-ray variations both in AGNs and Galactic BHs could be physically linked to an extent that it appeared that the accretion process was exactly the same for small and large BHs. Therefore, over a range $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}10$^8$ in mass and $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}10$^3$ in accretion rate, SMBHs can be regarded as scaled-up Galactic BHs.

However, as far as the scope of this work is concerned, perhaps the most interesting aspect of the XRB/AGN analogy was pointed to by . According to them, the well-known radio-loud (RL) vs. radio-quiet (RQ) dichotomy in quasars was reflected in certain states of radio/X-ray emission observable in microquasars: the fraction of observable RLQs – $f_Q$ $\approx$ 0.08 – is compatible with the fraction of the time that microquasars remain in the so-called flaring state. Moreover, the authors posited that QSOs could switch between the RL and RQ states, but spend much more time in the latter one. This conjecture is testable observationally and the most straightforward way to show that it is correct is to find objects that are currently in a transition between RL and RQ states or are at least shortly after such a transition. At first sight, this seems hardly possible because the timescales of the evolutionary processes in AGNs are too extended for these phenomena to be directly observed. Yet we show here that these tests are possible and present the results we obtained for three QSOs with signatures of a recent transition from the RL to the RQ state. Based on our results, we link this transition with its XRB analog.

# The method

The well known upper limit for the spectral ages of double radio sources is of the order of $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}10$^8$ yr and the upper limit for their linear sizes is $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}4 Mpc, see e.g. . These two limits constitute compelling evidence that the energy transport from the RL AGN to its lobes cuts off eventually, and so the radio source fades out. The spectrum of a switched-off source becomes very steep because of radiation and expansion losses, and its lobes gradually disperse. According to , the coasting phase of the lobes of a source that is no longer fuelled by its AGN can be very long: up to $10^8$ yr. But hotspots fade out much sooner; their lifetimes are roughly $7\times
10^4$ yr . Hence, the lack of well defined hotspots is an early signature of a lobes' decay.

There is yet another important observable phenomenon resulting from cessation of the activity in the radio domain: the lobe asymmetry, which, as pointed out by , is a possible signature of a radio activity switch-off. We mean here by "asymmetry" that one lobe is diffuse and devoid of a hotspot, while the other resembles a Fanaroff-Riley type-II (FR II) lobe quite well. In the extreme case, not only the hotspot but the whole lobe disappears. We interpret this as follows. If a double structure of a radio source does not lie in the sky plane (but also is not beamed towards us) the light-travel time plays a role: the epoch in which we observe the far-side lobe is significantly earlier than the epoch of the near-side lobe. For example, if the angle between the line of sight and the source axis is 45$\degr$, the time lag is equal to the projected linear size divided by $c$ and attains a magnitude of the order of $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}10$^6$ years for a typical large-scale, i.e. $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}10$^5$-pc sized radio source. This is definitely long enough for a hotspot to disappear as well for a lobe to disperse considerably. The above means that the lobe asymmetry is a very valuable signature of a recent cessation of RL state or – to be more exact – either a switch-off of the *whole* activity in the nucleus of the galaxy or at least of a transition from RL to RQ state. To prove that the latter scenario is correct, one has to show radio sources with asymmetric, i.e. one "still alive" and one "dying" lobe straddling a QSO. This way, one proves that the host galaxy is still active but its nucleus no longer produces jets, and so it has entered an evolutionary track leading to the fully RQ state. The presence of broad emission lines, which are best observed in QSOs, is essential to ascertain that in accordance with the AGN unification scheme , the AGN axis makes a moderate, i.e. neither small nor close to right, angle with the line of sight so that the time lag between the lobes' images indeed takes place, and *this* is the most plausible and natural explanation of their apparent asymmetry. Using QSOs for this purpose is even more justified by the seminal work of , who assert that the axis of a QSO makes an angle of less than 44$\fdg$`<!-- -->`{=html}4 with the line of sight. Therefore, if a transition from RL to RQ state occurs in a QSO with a large-scale, double-lobed structure, it must result in this asymmetry. To make the proof complete, one should finally show that the high-resolution radio image of the object's core has the characteristics of those observed in "true" RQ quasars (RQQ) known from the literature. Below we report how we carried out the above-sketched proof.

As a first step, we constructed a genuine sample of AGNs that have just switched off in the radio domain. The procedure was as follows. We selected double radio sources as seen in *NRAO/VLA Sky Survey* (NVSS) [^1] with optical identifications located between the two putative lobes. To this end, we used the catalogue compiled by [^2]. For a typical large-scale double, NVSS carried out with the VLA in D-conf. is well suited to indicate the presence of the lobes regardless of whether they are relics or not. This way, the algorithm associating optically-selected AGNs with double-lobed radio sources used by Flesch & Hardcastle works reliably even if a given lobe is a relic. From this point on, the selection process was based on the elementary principle of radio interferometry: diffuse objects were poorly imaged without short spacings. Specifically, we relied upon the assumption that VLA in B-conf. used during the *Faint Images of the Radio Sky at Twenty-Centimeters* survey (FIRST) [^3] failed to reproduce lobes well or even at all if they were diffuse. Therefore, targets selected form NVSS embedded within FIRST footprint were processed with an algorithm calculating the ratio of peak-to-integrated flux densities for FIRST catalogue items pertinent to each of the two NVSS lobes. When that ratio was very low for all the FIRST components within the given NVSS lobe, which meant that the lobe was featureless and so likely to be diffuse, it was regarded as a potential relic. Additionally, we found that in a number of cases the NVSS component had no FIRST equivalents and, obviously, we treated them as true positives.

```latex
\begin{table*}
\caption{Basic parameters of the targets}
\label{tab:basic}
\centering
\begin{tabular}{l c c c c r c c}
\hline
\hline
Object name & RA & Dec & $z$ & Projected &
Core flux\tablefootmark{a} & \multicolumn{2}{l} {Flux of the relic
lobe\tablefootmark{a}}\\
& \multicolumn{2}{c} {(J2000)} & & linear size & & Peak & Integrated\\
& & & & [kpc] & \multicolumn{1}{c}{[mJy]} & [mJy] & [mJy]\\
\hline
B0847+548 & 08 50 39.981 & +54 37 53.19 & 0.367\tablefootmark{b}
& 567 & 13.49 & 1.36 & 33.69\\
J115139.6+335541 & 11 51 39.677 & +33 55 41.74 & 0.851\tablefootmark{b}
& 898 & 6.58 & --- \tablefootmark{c} & --- \tablefootmark{c}\\
B1351+267 & 13 53 35.925 & +26 31 47.54 & 0.307\tablefootmark{d}
& 752 & 23.63 & 2.92 & 39.55\\
\hline
\end{tabular}
\tablefoot{
\tablefoottext{a}{Extracted from FIRST catalogue.}
\tablefoottext{b}{Source: SDSS}
\tablefoottext{c}{Not itemised in FIRST catalogue.}
\tablefoottext{d}{Source: \citet{EH2004}}
}
\end{table*}
```

Application of the above automated procedure led to a selection of a few hundreds of potential targets. This approach was by no means perfect and it produced quite a number of false positives. To sieve them out, we downloaded all the FIRST images indicated by the algorithm and inspected them visually. Thirty-eight sources with one relic and one "active" lobe remained. They were mainly normal galaxies without a trace of a radio core, but several sources in our sample appeared to have cores anyway and a few of them were identified with QSOs. For three, the flux densities of the cores at 1420 MHz as seen in FIRST were more than 5 mJy, which made these objects suitable targets for observations with the European VLBI Network (EVN).

# Observational data

## Radio domain

The basic parameters of the radio sources selected for VLBI observations are given in Table  and their NVSS and FIRST maps are shown in Fig. . Based on the NVSS images, the radio structures of our targets are clearly double or triple with one lobe slightly weaker, but only the FIRST maps reveal the real cause of that weakness: lack of the hotspot and diffuse shapes. Quantitatively, the latter feature is well expressed by the ratio of peak-to-integrated flux density of the diffuse lobe as shown in the last two columns of Table .

The EVN observations were carried out on 2009 November 9/10 at 1658 MHz. The network consisted of 10 telescopes: Effelsberg, Lovell, Onsala, Medicina, Noto, Robledo, Shanghai, Toruń, Urumqi, and Westerbork. Two polarisations were recorded in eight 8-MHz sub-bands each. Because our targets were weak, phase referencing was used. The scans on targets and phase calibrators were 10- and 2-min. long, respectively and were placed as evenly as possible on the $u$–$v$ plane. We assigned 3.5 hours of observing time for , 5 hours for , and 4 hours for . The data reduction using AIPS was carried out in a standard way. Amplitude self-calibration was applied to the visibility data before obtaining the final images; they are shown in Figs. , , and . The noise in these images is typically 10 $\mu$Jy/beam.

|                  |              |         |                   |
|:-----------------|-------------:|--------:|:-----------------:|
| Object name      | Flux density |         |    Brightness     |
|                  |        Total |  Fitted |    temperature    |
|                  |      \[mJy\] | \[mJy\] |       \[K\]       |
| B0847+548        |         10.0 |     8.3 | 6.65$\times 10^8$ |
| J115139.6+335541 |          4.2 |     3.8 | 1.55$\times 10^8$ |
| B1351+267        |         13.7 |    13.7 | 7.73$\times 10^9$ |

Observed parameters of the milliarcsecond structures

Flux densities of the milliarcsecond structures were measured with AIPS TVSTAT utility. We also fitted single Gaussians to the brightest features in the source centres. Based on these figures, we calculated the brightness temperatures of those features using formula with Eq. (1) from . All the above data are given in Table . As discussed in Sect. , very high brightness temperatures are indicative of jet production, albeit these jets could be very weak. This agrees with the observed morphologies: neither of the three milliarcsecond structures are of core-jet type as in the case of the lobe-dominated RLQs – see discussion in Sect. .

|                  |                         |                 |                   |
|:-----------------|:-----------------------:|:---------------:|:-----------------:|
| Object name      | $\log(M_{BH}/M_{\sun})$ | $\log(L_{bol})$ | $L_{bol}/L_{Edd}$ |
|                  |                         | \[log(erg/s)\]  |                   |
| B0847+548        |          9.406          |     45.541      |       0.011       |
| J115139.6+335541 |          9.383          |     46.272      |       0.061       |

BH masses, bolometric luminosities, and Eddington ratios

## Optical domain

Spectra of two quasars, B0847+548 and J115139.6+335541, are available in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS)[^4]. Both are very typical for QSOs: the continua rise towards shorter wavelengths and they are featured by both broad and narrow emission lines. For B0847+548, the H$\beta$, and for J115139.6+335541 the Mg II line can be best used for a measurement of BH mass, see e.g. for an up-to-date review. The BH masses and related quantities for 105,783 quasars in the SDSS Data Release 7 quasar catalogue have been recently calculated by . We extracted the BH masses, bolometric luminosities, and Eddington ratios for B0847+548 and J115139.6+335541 from that catalogue and listed them in Table . At the time of writing, the results of had not been accepted for publication yet so independent calculations were carried out by Nikołajuk (private communication). His results were very close to those of . Unfortunately, no B1351+267 spectrum was available in the literature ( quoted only the redshift for this object). Therefore, we were unable to give the BH mass and Eddington ratio for it.

# Discussion

## Cores of RLQs vs. cores of RQQs

Radio structures of QSOs are highly influenced by orientation effects as predicted by the AGN unification scheme. As a result, depending on the angle between the line of sight and the jets, RLQs can be perceived either as core- (beamed) or lobe-dominated (unbeamed). Doppler beaming and boosting makes the first group ideal objects for VLBI studies like, e.g. the Caltech–Jodrell Bank Flat-spectrum (CJF) sample survey that encompasses 293 sources. Following the predictions based on the unification scheme, the core-jet structure overwhelmingly dominates them. On the other hand, cores of 25 lobe-dominated QSOs from 3CR-based complete sample were comprehensively investigated by , who observed them in one or more epochs between 1981 and 1997 with various VLBI arrays at several frequencies between 5 and 22 GHz. Later, these observations were supplemented with VLBA and High Sensitivity Array (HSA) observations so eventually the nuclei in all 25 objects were imaged. Cores in three of them were unresolved and the remaining 22 showed one-sided jets located on the same side of the compact core as the one-sided large-scale jets seen in the VLA images. Given that no counter-jets were observed, the authors estimated that these objects were all orientated within $\sim$`<!-- -->`{=html}70$\degr$ to the line of sight. Their results were consistent with orientation-dependent relativistic beaming effects and unification of core- and lobe-dominated QSOs. In the latter class, the presence of jets is a clear signature that the objects belonging to it are not only apparently RL because of the lobes' dominance, but are truly RL, i.e. the energy transport from the core to the lobes, which is the prime cause of the existence of radio structures, is ongoing.

By definition, RQQs are devoid of radio lobes because their nuclei either do not produce jets, or the jets they produce are too weak to inflate lobes. This does not preclude, however, the existence of weak radio cores there. Indeed, they are observed and the question that immediately emerges is whether that radio emission is associated with starbursts or with weak-jet producing central engines. sought the answer for this question by means of the VLBA observations of 12 RQQs, because the detection of milliarcsecond structure implies that the brightness temperatures of the emission is $T_B \ga 10^6$ K, while for typical supernova remnants $T_B \la
10^5$ K. Although the structures that they managed to map out were only indicative of jets, the measurements of brightness temperatures provided strong evidence for jet-producing central engines in eight sources. Further investigations of RQQ cores by means of the VLBA observations were carried out by . They observed six RQQ cores and got images for five of them: four were dominated by unresolved component, while the fifth showed quite a rich structure that was labelled "two-sided jet" by the authors. Note that the structure had a steep spectrum. Being aware of that and expecting that our sources can also bear this feature, we decided to make our observations at 1.6 GHz to attain better signal-to-noise ratios at the cost of lower resolution.

The brightness temperatures measured by were of the order of 10$^8$ or greater, ruling out the thermal origin of the observed radiation. Thus, the authors confirmed the hypothesis of that radio cores of RQQs were fundamentally similar to those in RLQs, while the RQQ jets were simply less powerful. The more general conclusion that emerges from their work – but also from – is that the term "RQQ" should not be understood in a verbatim manner, namely an RQQ is not necessarily a QSO that is completely "silent", but weak in radio domain . What is much more important instead is that central engines of RQQs do not produce jets strong enough to transport the energy to the lobes. This agrees with the hypothesis put forward by that all black hole/accretion disc systems in AGNs can produce some kind of outflow or jet, but only in a minority of cases, i.e. in truly radio-loud objects, the jet is successfully launched and accelerated to relativistic speeds. In the majority of cases, the jet is "aborted", yet it is responsible for a relatively weak radio emission.

Our findings are fully consistent with those by both in terms of brightness temperatures and milliarcsecond-scale morphologies: B1351+267 is point-like, J115139.6+335541 is nearly point-like with two protrusions on the eastern and western side, and B0847+548 has two-sided mini-jets. All three have low radio flux densities and yet high brightness temperatures. Altogether, the galactic nuclei we imaged with the EVN are characteristic of RQQs. The major difference, though, is pertinent to the large-scale overall radio structures: while the objects observed by are truly RQ, ours are classified as RL because of the presence of the lobes. Nevertheless, we claim that the cores of the three quasars we deal with here not only resemble those in RQQs, but belong to the RQQ category and so these quasars are observed after a recent transition between the RL and RQ states. Their cores herald the onset of the RQ state, whereas the lobes, while still rendering the RL label formally applicable to these quasars, are actually only remnants of the *former* RL state. On the other hand, we find that our quasars do not fit to the model by because it requires mass accretion rates substantially higher than Eddington, which is not the case, see Table . (This model has also been criticised on theoretical grounds by .)

## Quasar–microquasar analogy

Although few XRBs are persistent X-ray sources, the majority are variable. The analysis of their light curves at different X-ray bands shows a clear correlation between the luminosity and hardness, which led to distinction of two basic states in XRBs: high/soft (HS) and low/hard (LH). The 1$-$`<!-- -->`{=html}10 keV radiation observed in the HS state is best explained as a thermal emission form the accretion disc, while the 20$-$`<!-- -->`{=html}100 keV radiation of the LH state, when the spectrum becomes non-thermal with a typical photon index $\Gamma\sim$ 1.7 and an exponential cutoff around 100 keV, is a result of Comptonisation of softer photons in the accretion disc corona of high-energy electrons. More precisely, the LH state can be regarded as a follow-up of the HS state switch-off: when the density of soft seed photons is greatly reduced, the resultant Comptonised spectrum hardens, see e.g. for a review. Three additional states: "quiescent", "very high" (VH), and "intermediate" have been all identified for by , , and , respectively. At least some of these three can be observed in other XRBs. attributed these five states – in order of increasing luminosity these were: the quiescent, LH, intermediate, HS, and VH – to different accretion rates, although the VH state could not be unified within the framework of their model of accretion flows around BHs. Also, according to them, different accretion modes were at work for particular states: in quiescent, LH, and intermediate states, the radiatively inefficient advection-dominated accretion flow (ADAF) was present, while for HS and VH the ADAF (inner) zone disappeared and the radiatively efficient accretion disc extended down to the innermost stable circular orbit (ISCO) around the BH.

The correlation between the X-ray-emission-based states in XRBs and their radio properties is particularly strong: the radio emission is generated in LH and VH states, while it drops in the HS state below detectable levels, most likely because of the physical disappearance of jets, see for a brief summary. The parallel existence of a clear RL/RQ dichotomy in XRBs and AGNs immediately leads to attempts to unify XRBs and AGNs based on their radio properties, i.e. to identify specific states observed in XRBs with classes of AGNs . The following picture emerges: Sgr A$^\star$, LINERs, FR I radio galaxies, and BL Lac objects remain in a state analogous to the LH state of XRBs, RQQs and Seyfert galaxies represent the HS state, whereas FR II radio galaxies and RLQs behave as if they were in the VH state. More recently, this scheme was advanced by who showed that FR I and FR II radio galaxies could have different accretion modes and the accretion mode in the majority of FR I galaxies could be of ADAF type similar to that in the LH state in XRBs. On the other hand, many RL objects had both the most powerful known radio jets *and* optical properties typical for HS state so the VH state, which is the only state where these two features could be combined, should be attributed to them.

In the framework of the above paradigm, the objects we observed, which are effectively RQQs based on the status of their nuclei, are in a state analogous to the HS state but given the presence of decaying large-scale radio structures, they must have entered that state only recently. This immediately leads to a conjecture that migration of an AGN to the analog of the HS state may be a part of a more general evolutionary process. Taking into account all the similarities between XRBs and AGNs, such an evolution – which is sped up by the factor of the AGN-to-XRB BH mass ratio – should possibly be followed *directly* in XRBs.

## XRBs and AGNs – common evolution?

A new light on the XRB/AGN unification was shed by , but see also a simplified version of that paper: , who constructed a semi-quantitative model of XRB evolution. Piecing together XRB observational data and placing them on the hardness–intensity diagram (HID), they found an evolutionary path of XRBs, sometimes called the "turtle head" diagram – see Fig. 7 in . The XRB timeline starts at the quiescence stage, then moves nearly vertically during the LH state. When it leaves that state, it turns left towards the VH state. At some point, usually corresponding to the peak of the VH state, the photon index $\Gamma$ rapidly increases, producing an internal shock in the outflow and the jet properties change, most notably its velocity. The final, most powerful jet has the highest Lorentz factor, causing the propagation of an internal shock through the slower-moving outflow in front of it. Following that, an XRB enters the HS stage when no jet is produced although some XRBs, like GRS 1915+105, make repeated excursions back to VH state . After a number of "loops" in the HID (if any), an XRB enters the HS state permanently and returns, via intermediate state, back to quiescence.

The above path can be followed directly for XRBs because they evolve quickly enough, but given the identity of both the accretion process and the jet generation mechanism in microquasars and quasars one should expect that this path is common to AGNs, albeit it is impossible to be followed within a human lifetime because of the timescaling factor, which reaches several orders of magnitude. What could be done, however, is to produce a HID analog for AGNs and check on a statistical basis if it resembles the HID for XRBs. This task was accomplished by . Because the blackbody temperature of the accretion disc scales with black hole mass as $M^{-{1/4}}$, the SEDs of accretion discs around SMBHs peak in the optical/UV domain, not the X-ray, and a HID for AGNs would not contain any information about the disc emission. Therefore, instead of a HID, the authors constructed a disc-fraction/luminosity diagram (DFLD) plotting $L_D + L_{PL}$ against $L_{PL}/(L_D+L_{PL})$ – where $L_D$ denoted the disc luminosity and $L_{PL}$ the luminosity of the power-law component – for a sample of 4963 SDSS Data Release 5 quasars. What they found was a striking similarity between the DFLD for AGNs and DFLD for a simulated sample of XRBs. This shows that in general a large population of AGNs follow the same pattern as XRBs. Consequently, not only particular classes of AGNs could be assigned to different XRB states in a "static" manner , but also signatures of transitions between those states could be looked for in AGNs. In particular, thanks to the long decay times of the radio lobes , a recent transition from RL VH state to RQ HS state should be attributed to the objects with already radio-quiet cores and still observable relic radio lobes. The existence of these objects has been predicted by . We claim that the quasars with asymmetric overall radio structures we presented here fit those predictions.

Finally, it is worth mentioning at this point that our attempt to identify a transition in accretion properties of AGNs with a respective transition between spectral states of XRBs is not the first endeavour of this kind. suggested that the transition of accretion properties among different types of RL AGNs alone could also have its analog in the XRB domain.

# Summary and final conclusion

The unification of XRBs and AGNs has recently gained a substantial boost. A major step towards a full unification between these two classes were made by , who showed an evolutionary sequence for XRBs in the HID and by who constructed a DFLD – an analog of HID applicable for AGNs. One cannot directly show that AGNs are moving along an evolutionary track on a DFLD but, given that many characteristics of XRBs and AGNs have been found to be either analogous or identical, is it very reasonable to expect that the evolutionary sequence traced for XRBs should also be valid for AGNs. In this work, we showed the presence of transitions from the RL to the RQ state in three quasars, using their large-scale radio structures as a historical record of the former RL state and the micro-scale radio structures as an evidence of the present RQ state. If, in line with , the XRB/AGN analogy indeed holds also for the evolution of these two classes of object, the quasars we investigated could be regarded as objects after a recent transition from VH to HS state.

The RL-to-RQ transition scenario outlined here has yet another consequence. According to the unification scheme , the RL/RQ dichotomy should be attributed to the presence or absence of BH spin, respectively. While small BH spins can still be the reason why some AGNs are RQ, according to some studies , BHs in *both* RLQs and RQQs may have large spins. For example, according to most SMBHs rotate rapidly. The same conclusion has been reached by based on an investigation of 12,698 quasars from SDSS. The BHs in the three quasars we deal with here must have large spins to make it possible for these objects to have been RL in the past. They have become RQ now, but it is hard to find a mechanism forcing their BHs to spin down during such a transition. Eventually, when their lobes fade out completely, they will turn out to be *bona fide* RQQs, yet their BHs will still have large spins contrary to the paradigm.

[^1]: Website: `http://www.cv.nrao.edu/nvss`

[^2]: Website: ` http://quasars.org/qorg-data.htm`

[^3]: Website: `http://sundog.stsci.edu`

[^4]: Website: `http://www.sdss.org/`