author: James Flamino[^1]; Alexander Norman[^2]; Madison Wyatt[^3]
bibliography: ICM.bib
date: June 14, 2017
title: **Modeling smart growth of cities through entropy and logistics**

# Abstract

We introduce a predictive algorithm for the smart growth of cities with populations upward of 100,000, allowing for extensive simulations of growth plans and their effects upon an urban populous. A smart growth metric is calculated to evaluate the progress of a city at each phase of its adaptation of the growth plan, which is measured using a weighted entropy method. The predictive algorithm itself is built from a unique differential model, which calculates the growth of a city from smart growth proposals that are individually assessed by a logistic weight model. These proposals are then sorted based on effectiveness and efficiency observed from the simulations, giving insight into the best approach to providing the target cities with a hopeful future. *Original paper written for COMAP's 2017 ICM competition.*

# Introduction

## Context and Motivation

The nature of our world is evolving. The industrial revolution of the late 18th century brought upon a great migration into cities, and the trend of urbanization was born. Not only has this trend continued until today, but it continues at an ever increasing rate; it is expected that 66% of the world will be living in cities by 2050. However, in the wake of this rapid progress, some measures have fallen to the wayside. Some cities either grow too hastily and do not have the economic growth to support it, or have outdated methods for prosperity, all the while continuing to grow in size. Some have not considered the environmental impact and have in turn created habitations that are naturally unsustainable. Some have allowed portions of their community to fall below standards in living and/or in representation. All three of these functions, if not properly maintained, can cause a city to be unequipped for changes that the future brings.
Smart growth is a movement where cities endorse programs and initiatives that improve three elements: economic prosperity, social equity, and environmental sustainability . In this, there are ten principles given to focus the development of the movement. They serve to further the three Es with a more detailed and focused set of standards. Cities that adopt smart growth programs are better prepared for the future, despite any uncertainty that could bring. In this paper, we examine the data of cities around the world with midsize metropolitan city populations and analyze the current state of affairs for each by crafting a unique metric rooted in weighing the importance of smart growth in the overall health of a city. Using this metric, two cities with great potential to benefit from the tenets of smart growth are identified: Anchorage, USA and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau. We measure the growth of these cities unattended, then while enacting particular smart growth policies specifically designed to meet the needs of the target cities. The results of the simulations for the policies are measured using the smart growth metric and ranked for comparison. The results allow us to identify the pressing needs of the target cities, and how best to address them with respect to furthering smart growth.
In the case of the test cities (Anchorage, USA and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau), the simulation was able to show that enacting particular smart growth policies would grant the cities a noticeable boost in growth, as well as slower degradation of the quality of well-being over the next four decades, especially if the initial enacted policies targeted diverse developmental blueprints, local culture, adaptive urban growth restrictions, and multi-transportational systems, as ranked by the simulation. In addition to these positive results, the simulation itself benefits from having ubiquitous base models, allowing for similar testing to be performed on many other cities for a range of growth plans.

# Models

Now to build a thoroughly objective, purely math-based simulation to measure the effectiveness of the growth plan policies, specifically, the process was broken down into three models, each rooted in their own fields of mathematics. The then synthesized model serves to take a growth plan initiative, quantify it, and assess its effect on satisfying both the ten principles of smart growth and the three Es of sustainability. Finally, these effects are integrated to define the resulting growth index of the city due to the implemented initiatives. This multi-step, dynamic system allows a variety of growth plans to be tested to determine the predicted success before commitment and implementation.

## Determining the Sustainability Metrics

To consider the details behind the three Es of sustainability to design a metric, we decided to delve deep into the concepts of being sustainable, and acknowledge that this truly was something of a holistic problem.
Cities naturally involve a myriad of complex interconnected processes, and thus generate a rather large set of data and metrics to evaluate themselves, and none of that data is useless, as interconnected and nuanced as it is. Understanding this, the model first employs the Entropy Weight Method to measure the plethora of information to compute the metric that could be used to measure the sustainability of a city.
Generally, entropy is a concept of Thermodynamics, used to measure the disorder of a system. However, the same basic principle exists in information theory, in which the lower the entropy of information for a source, the smaller the utility of said information. This can be applied to a group of indicators, which are then run through this method to determine a value to the system where they lie. Essentially, the entropy method can compute a plethora of indicators involved in a targeted system and evaluate them for their use. This is, of course, a highly useful tool for evaluating the three E's of sustainability, allowing us to consider as much data as we need to inclusively represent each with a unique index.

### Evaluation System

For a city to satisfy the three Es of sustainability, it must be Economically Prosperous (EP), Environmentally Sustainable (ES), and Socially Equitable (SE). In order to create a well-rounded metric, a system of indicators that symbolize a component of each of the three sustainability metrics was assembled in order to appropriately represent the significance of each metric after being factored into the entropy method. There are some considerations that truly attribute to each sustainability metric:

1.  The indicator's change must have a direct effect on the E that they are representing. (i.e. forest density and coverage directly represent a environmentally sustainable system)

2.  The indicator must have complete digital records stretching back to 2000 in order to allow for time-stressing of the resultant metric.

3.  The indicator's type must have data available to not only our two target cities, but also to all similarly sized and located cities.

4.  The indicator must be state- or city-specific in order to assess the most localized data.

Using these criteria, we were able to collect 150 unique indicators , available openly to cities around the world. These indicators were split up and assigned (and cross-assigned) to one or more of the three categories.
This distribution of indicators feeds into the three E's which will each have a special index, all of which feed into one Growth Index, our metric for measuring the overall success of a city. Now, it is important to note that for our model we used more than just two cities - a model that applies to merely two cities is poorly justified on a theoretical level. In order to gain an understanding of overall Smart Growth, we considered a wide sample bin of cities with populations between $100,000$ and $500,000$. In addition to that, we scored all cities together, regardless of continental location in order to gain relative perspective on the progress of each city throughout recent time.

### Definition

Considering the categories outlined in Figure 1, all data was discretized and organized by indicator type and city sample. Thus we can say a single value for an indicator is $x_{ij}$ where $i$ is the indicator for city $j$ where the ranges are $i=(1,2,...,n)$ and $j=(1,2,...,m)$ for all $n$ indicators and $m$ cities.
During the initial assessment of indicator values for the city samples, we noted that some indicators were not comparable or scalable to others of the same type when normalization was attempted. In our search for indicators that met the criteria perfectly, we forced an issue inherent of vector normalization: Important variation between indicators both positive and negative is often lost when normalization is attempted, which renders those particular indicators useless. In order to avoid this, the Z-score standardization method was used to normalized all data. In particular, the Z-score deals well with discrete data, especially for data sets where there is no clear maximum or minimum. And so, for a data value of $x_{ij}$, we say

$$r_{ij} = -\frac{x_{ij} - \bar{x_{i}} }{ \delta_{i} }$$

Where $r_{ij}$ is the standardization of $x_{ij}$, and $\bar{x_{j}}$ and $\delta_{i}$ are the mean and the standard deviation of the $i$th indicator of the system, respectively.
However, despite the usefulness of Z-score standardizing data instead of just using vector normalization, inaccuracies in the subsequent calculations could arise from the positive and negative distributions of $r_{ij}$. So, all standardized data was transformed into a positive range above 0.

$$r'_{ij} = r_{ij} + \phi$$

Where $r'_{ij}$ is the standardized value $r_{ij}$ translated by $\phi$ where $\phi > |min(x_{i})|$. From here the specific value's weight was determined by

$$f_{ij} = \frac{r'_{ij}}{\sum_{j=1}^{m} r'_{ij}}$$

Then, the indicator's entropy was calculted by

$$H_{i} = -k \sum_{j=1}^{m} f_{ij} \cdot ln(f_{ij})$$

Where $k=\frac{1}{ln(m)}$, which is used to normalize the entropy, $m$ being the number of cities. This is immediately followed by the calculation of the indicator weight, which is

$$w_{i} = \frac{1 - H_{i}}{\sum_{i=1}^{n} (1 - H_{i})}$$

Where $n$ is the number of indicators. Finally, this weight was used to calculate an entropy index – a sustainability metric as we have it – for each E for the $j$th city sample.

$$F_{kj} = 1 - \sum_{i=1}^{n} w_{i}f_{kij} \qquad k = (EP, ES, SE)$$

The three resultant sustainability metrics $F_{kj}$ measure the EP, ES, and SE performance of the $j$th city with respect to all other cities respectively.

## Quantifying Initiatives

Having gained the tool to evaluate the state of the city through the definition of three sustainability metrics, we then developed a method to calculate the consequences of change through initiatives. In order to effectively assess the quality of a growth plan, we felt it was important to evaluate the plans ability to satisfy not only the 3 Es of sustainability, but also the ten principles of smart growth. This creates relationships between the 3 Es and the ten principles, as well as relationships between themselves.
First, we determined which principles benefited and impaired each of the 3 Es. A ranking, and weights based on these rankings, were assigned to gauge the varying effects that satisfying a principle would have on each sustainability metric. Conversely, each principle was apportioned by the 3 Es to establish the weighted intentions of it. That is, the amount a principle is composed of each sustainability metric. Essentially, these two classifications represent column and row weights for the relationship between the 3 Es and the ten principles.
Additionally, the ten principles are connected. An initiative that changes one principle index may indirectly change another through this change. For this, and founded on the column and row weights determined above, the effects of each principle on the others was concluded and placed in an interconnection weight matrix. These connections are best summarized in the diagram below.

Each initiative of a growth plan will satisfy some, but most likely not all, of the ten principles on its own. To measure this, each initiative introduced was decomposed into its contributions to each principle. For example, implementing an initiative to create and maintain a public park in the city would benefit principles 4, 5, and 6 with distributed percentages totaling 100% for each principle. These classifications were then used to determine the change of each principle index due to the introduction of an initiative. Furthermore, some initiatives may be overall more effective than others in satisfying a principle. For example, setting aside land for agricultural reserve would more adequately satisfy principle 6 than adding natural landscaping to a building front, but both may hold the same distributed initiative percentage for principle 6. Consequently, an effectiveness coefficient, denoted $\beta$, will serve to quantify the quality of the initiative to a principle.
The principle indices, the 3 Es indices, and the overall growth index are defined on scales from 0 to 1, where 0 is not meeting any standards and 1 is satisfying all standards. In calculating the effect of an initiative on a principle, we assume then that the principle index cannot surpass a value of 1. We also assume that as principles are satisfied, additional initiatives have smaller effects. That is, as the value of a principle index approaches 1, each successive change will be smaller. A general model of this behavior stems from population dynamics. $$\frac{dx}{dt} = rx \left(1-\frac{x}{K}\right)$$

Where $x$ is the species population at hand, $r$ is the rate of growth, and $K$ is the carrying capacity, the maximum value the population can sustain. Although this model reflects the changing behavior of the principle index, it does not account for the relationship between the ten principles or the effective factor of an initiative. Therefore, a modified logistic model was utilized to characterize the effect of a growth plan initiative on the change in a principle's index.

$$\frac{dp_k}{dt}=\beta_k i_k p_k \left(1-\sum_{j=1}^{10} w_{kj}p_j \right)$$

Where $p_k$ represents the principle $k$ in question, $\beta_k$ is the effectiveness coefficient of the initiative on the principle, $i_k$ is the initiative contribution to the principle, and $w_{kj}$ is the weighted relationship that a change in principle $j$ would have on principle $k$. Because the model reflects competition between the principles, an influential interaction is denoted as a negative weight and a destructive interaction is denoted positively. It is clear that the quantification of any initiative and the ten principles is consistent and sound. Their transformations are rooted in logic, reasoning, and mathematical consideration.

## Principle Change to Sustainability Metric

From here, we must consider how these principles impact our three sustainability metrics, that of economic prosperity, environmental sustainability, and social equitability. To reliably measure this change, we turn to Volterra's Population Equation .

$$\frac{du}{dt} = au-bu^2-cu\int^{t}_{0}u(s)ds, \qquad u(0) = u_0$$

Where the constants, $a$, $b$, and $c$ are based on our ten principles. This innovative method evolves the standard population model to better suit the situation at hand. Specifically, the model represents a "birth rate" term, as to how our principles grow this metric, an "overcrowding" term, to limit the maximum capacity any city may have, and the final term, described in the literature as a "toxicity" term, which considers the total of our metric throughout time. This toxicity term slowly tapers off, as the population of our city rises and further resources are required to keep the same levels of our desired values. The equation is then converted to dimensionless form ,

$$\beta \frac{dy}{dt} =  y - y^2-\int^{\tau}_{0}y(z)dz, \qquad y_0 = \alpha$$

by $\tau =\frac{ct}{b}, y = \frac{bu}{a}, \beta = \frac{c}{a+b}, \alpha = \frac{bu_0}{a}$.
However, it becomes important to subtract a time term from the equation because if we take our constants, a, b, and c to be 0, our original equation simply stays constant, which is distinctly unrealistic when considering the infrastructure of a city that decays naturally. Thus we have

$$\beta \frac{dy}{d\tau} =  y - y^2-\int^{\tau}_{0}y(z)dz-d\cdot\tau, \qquad y_0 = \alpha$$

As a technical aside, we can define $j = \frac{dy}{d\tau}$. This leads to the equation and then definition:

$$j = \frac{1}{\beta}\cdot\left(\int^{\tau}_0j(z)dz-\left(\int^{\tau}_0j(z)dz\right)^2-\int^{\tau}_0\int^{z}_0j(i)didz-d\cdot\tau\right)$$

$$Aj = \frac{1}{\beta}\cdot\left(\int^{\tau}_0j(z)dz-\left(\int^{\tau}_0j(z)dz\right)^2-\int^{\tau}_0\int^{z}_0j(i)didz-d\cdot\tau\right)$$

Together this comes to represent a simple equation,

$$Aj=j$$

As our operator, A is continuous along j, on any fixed interval, we can show, by Brouwer's Fixed Point Theorem , that a solution to this integral equation exists if we approximate our function space to be finite dimensional, and thus a solution to our differential equation exists. Further work may be conducted using Scarf's constructive proof of Brouwer's Fixed Point Theorem, however at the present time this is beyond the scope of the paper. The limit of this equation, where $c=0, d=0$, approximates a function of the form $f(t) = \frac{e^t}{e^t+C_1}$. Similarly, if we take $c$ to be suitably large this will approximate a $sinh$ function. However, no analytic solution is easily attainable, so a fourth order Runge Kutta method was used to compute how each index changes, treating the one equation as a system of two like so.

$$\frac{df}{dt} = y$$

$$\frac{dy}{dt} = y-y^2-f-t$$

Solving these two sets of equations in parallel over five thousand points in our interval for each simulation returns a reasonable approximation of both $f$, and, more importantly, $y$. Which, of course, given the correct parameters, can adequately represent each of our three E's and how they change over time.
An important thing to discuss here is how precisely our constants in this model are formulated. For simplicities sake, and as a good first order approximation, we take each to be a linear combination of our 10 principles, discounting any cross correlation between them. Then, we evaluate how much impact, positive and negative, and taking into account population growth, these principles have on our three metrics, we normalize this to one when you add the scaling across the metrics for each principle. Then we consider how impactful each principle is *with respect to each individual metric*, normalizing the sum of all ten principles to 1 across each metric. These two numbers are then multiplied, giving an overall weight.

## Calculation of Growth Index

Finally, with a model that can comprehensively represent each sustainability metric over time, it makes sense to attempt to quantify those sustainability metrics as a total, as it will illustrate the overall success of a city over a period of time more concisely.
And so we introduce the Growth Index (GI), our central metric for measuring the overall smart growth of a city. This is defined as

$$GI = W \cdot F =
    \begin{bmatrix}
        \gamma_{1} \\
        \gamma_{2} \\
        \gamma_{3}
    \end{bmatrix}^T
    \cdot
    \begin{bmatrix}
        F_{1} \\
        F_{2} \\
        F_{3}
    \end{bmatrix}$$

Where $\gamma_{1}$, $\gamma_{2}$, and $\gamma_{3}$ are distributive weights and $F_1$, $F_2$, and $F_3$ are the growth indices for the 3 Es, respectively. These are very important, as they are weighted to equally represent each $F_{k}$ entropy index fairly, preventing a city that does not excel in all three E's from standing out. These weights are calculated through the following equations

$$q_{i} = \frac{F_{i} - \frac{M}{2}}{|F_{i} - \frac{M}{2}|}$$

$$F'_{i} = (\frac{M}{2} - F_{i}) \cdot \left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{q_{i}} + \frac{M}{2}$$

$$\gamma_{i} = \frac{F'_{i}}{\sum_{i=1}^{3} F'_{i}}$$

Where $M = max(\{F_{1}, F_{2}, F_{3}\})$, $F'_i$ is the distributive value of the index, and $i$ is the $i$th $\gamma$, where $i = (1,2,3)$. These calculations in total result in the growth index of a city. It is used to quantify the health of the city in terms of sustainability.

# Analysis of Cities

## Current State of the Cities

The two cities that are detailed and analyzed throughout the remainder of this paper are Anchorage, USA and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau. With the sustainable indices and an overall comprehensive metric for smart growth in a metropolitan area on hand, we embarked on the task to analyze as many cities as we could in order to gain a detailed understanding of the progress of cities from the USA to Africa. As data allowed, we were able to analyze 38 different US cities and 8 different African cities, and we were able to pinpoint two particular cities of interest: Anchorage, USA, and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau. Despite a difference in base standards, both of these cities face a similar problem: At their current rate, their well-being as indicated by the Growth Index is falling, and they will face many future problems if not corrected. In addition, we found that both of these cities in fact benefit from smart growth initiatives.

### Anchorage, USA

Anchorage, USA has experienced a decrease in its growth index over the past decade. It has seen a decrease in economic fortune in the past few years, even after many years of moderate success . It's homelessness problem has reached a new high, creating not only a divide in the population, but an environment ill-conducive to development . It has boasted an air quality index dangerously higher than the national average, and well above a standard of clean air, and continues to lead in US crude oil production . However, in the past 6 months, it has begun to plan for the future, attempting to adopt a smart growth plan for itself . In this time, it has published an incentive handbook, required progress reports from its development authority, worked to redefine development, added more foot patrol downtown to increase safety, begun a community homeless program, and worked to designate a trail and rain garden. We examined, first, the state of the city before these initiatives. Then, using our model and metric, we assess how well these initiatives will work as time progresses.
It is clear by the current downward trend and the current state of Anchorages growth index, that without intervention, the state of the city will fall considerably. The city suffers most in social equity, then economic prosperity, and finally in environmental sustainability. The initiatives currently presented were placed in the model and the results over time were seen in the figure below. Individually, each initiative either causes the growth index to decay immediately, or rise and fall quickly before leveling off around the initial point or below it. If all the initiatives are enacted, the system rises to a growth index of below 0.9 before falling back down quickly. Left alone, these initiatives would not allow the city to prosper at a sustainable level or account for the population increase it is expecting in the long run. This is seen in the figure.

### Bissau, Guinea-Bissau

Bissau, Guinea-Bissau is beginning to see a rise in its economic future. Its Gross Domestic Product (GDP) has grown consistently by 5% in the last two years since the election of a new president after the country was plagued with civil war beginning in 2012. There is a large central market for goods exchange in the downtown area, as well as beautiful coastlines for economic and environmental growth. However, the country has not had a long period without political unrest since its independence in 1974. The economy is mostly dependent on cashew and rice production outside of the city and very few tourists visit Bissau . There is rising inequity with the poverty rate increasing to unprecedented levels. Much of the city is divided between two standards of living, one of which is well below any standard at all . The city has a few plans in place to begin alleviating these troubles. Currently, they discuss setting aside a national park, demobilizing portions of the soldiers, and economically empowering poor farmers, especially women . We again analyzed the state of the city before these plans and then ran the initiatives through our model to assess their effectiveness.
The current state of the city of Bissau is projecting increase in social equity, decrease in environmental sustainability, and slight, if any, increase in economic prosperity. Although the implementation of the initiatives did serve to further the metrics for a few years and ultimately increase the growth index of the city, the index is still not at a point that is sustainable for future growth. Individually, each initiative was not enough to cause the city to improve each metric wholly. All together, the increase was quick and unsustainable for growth in the city. This is seen in the figure below.

# Initiative Plan: Change For The Better

The concept of smart growth is founded on ten principles of progress and three tenets of sustainability. These core beliefs form plans and programs to create better futures for our cities and communities. It is from these values and our comprehensive analysis of the current state of growth plans for Anchorage, USA and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau that we form an inclusive plan, with an intention for focused and detailed variations for each city.
Having analyzed both the state of each city as it pertains to economic, social, and environmental growth, as well as the current growth plan to improve those and its consequences, we have introduced a more suitable plan that follows with ten Smart Growth Initiatives (SGIs).

1.  Focus on small areas for improvement

    -   Improve long-term sustainability by utilizing short-term, but steady, independent programs

2.  Incorporate local culture

    -   Art, sculptures, history, important aspects

    -   Deepen community sense by recognizing the people present

3.  Multi-transportational system

    -   Public transportation, bike access

    -   Walkways, bike lanesequal opportunity

4.  Consider inherent hindrances and adjust accordingly

    -   Take into account geographical features, political situations, and other uncontrollable factors

5.  Work to Reduce, Reuse, Recycle instead of Rebuild or Restart

    -   Apply environmentally sustainable practices

    -   Assess the state of the city road and building design before enacting plans

6.  Pursue outside financing and grants

    -   Encourage developmental leadership to use community and regional resources to fund improvement projects

    -   Create a clear, concise objective for proposals

7.  Exploit markets and benefits of the city

    -   Strengthen well-being

    -   Examine pre-existing conditions for strong components

8.  Monitor restrictions and work to reflect the goal of the growth

    -   Adapt to current conditions

9.  Implement unique and diverse developmental blueprints

    -   Tailor design proposals to the city at hand

    -   Outline layouts that reflect the community

10. Introduce or enhance inclusion programs

    -   Strive for fair treatment and services for the community

    -   Create or expand on existing programs designed for justness

This growth plan is tailored to the specific needs of the two communities in Anchorage, Alaska and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau. Both of these cities are currently struggling with social equity. Anchorage has an immense homelessness problem, low racial diversity, and few initiatives in place to combat these issues . Bissau is, too, struggling with 49% of the populating below the poverty line . Economically and environmentally, the two cities are similarly situated, relative to itself, in that their focuses for growth are both going to be on social, then economic, then environmental.
It would be advantageous for both cites to enhance what already works best for each. Both cities are expecting growth in the upcoming future – Anchorage in population and tourist attraction, and Bissau in Gross Domestic Product (GDP), a measure of their economic health . This plan also accommodates the geography, political condition, and funding availability of each city. Bissau more than Anchorage, but each city will need to seek outside sources to fund this growth project. Finally, this plan reflects a feasible solution for each city in its own manner. Our model accounts for prioritization in the sustainability metrics for each city, so the amount of resources expelled for each of these initiatives is customized to the community and current situation of each city.

## Initiatives in Model

These ten initiatives were then run through all components of the model to determine how the growth index would change as a result. Each SGI was weighted appropriately and the results are shown best in comparing the future of the citys growth index with and without these measures taken.

As seen, both cities see a great increase in their growth indices throughout time. The initial and archival data from real data is included for a ten-year reference into the past. Then, the growth index for the next 40 years is shown for the city as it currently stands, and with our model generated initiative plan. Anchorage, USA reaches a near perfect growth index around 2035 and settles around 0.9 for the duration of the represented data. This is about a 0.15 increase from the index without the plan, as well as showing more promising future prospects because the decay of the index is not as sharp.
Moreover, Bissau, Guinea-Bissau sees a dramatic difference in the growth indices. Without the plan, the index settles around 0.3 which is not sustainable for future growth. With the plan, it settles closer to 0.5 with room to improve and/or introduce further initiatives. Note that Bissaus current plan exceeds our plan for a few initial years. This is due to the nature of their current plans. Bissau has only a few, but large, projects on queue. These projects have a quick effect, but little lasting ability. Thus, our plan overtakes the current initiatives quite quickly. Essentially, it is evident that the Smart Growth Initiatives outlined in our plan are sound, dynamic, and complete.

## City Comparison

The ability to enact any number, especially all, of the initiatives outlined in our smart growth plan depends on the city's ability to fund and support such a project. There may be times in which the city needs to prioritize the programs based on their desired end result, or a city may need to adopt this strategy from the beginning. For example, Bissau may not have the resources to support a full smart growth plan at the moment, and may instead wish to target markedly trouble areas. For this, we have ranked the initiatives. These rankings were determined by running each initiative through the model individually and analyzing the effect on each sustainability index. The results of the analysis are summarized in the colorbar charts. The SGI's are ranked top to bottom for each metric, so depending on the goal of the city at the time, appropriate initiatives can be selected.

For Anchorage, they may choose to improve environmentally and socially, so it would be more advantageous for the city to begin with SGIs 8 and 2. In comparison, Bissau may choose to focus on economic growth and social equity, so they should begin with SGIs 9 and 2. It is interesting to observe the similarities between the rankings. This notes the all-inclusive nature of the model and its ability to positively affect any city, despite initial conditions.

# Sensitivity Analysis

## Unexpected Perturbations

Now that the model has been fully developed, and the simulations show a positive change in the Growth Index for both cities, the model was stress-tested in order to scope out its robustness and effectiveness. The first test of sensitivity analysis considered was to include randomly placed negative perturbations to the Growth Index. These kinds of perturbations simulated the uncertainty of the real world that could noticeably effect the economical prosperity, environmental sustainability, and the social equitability of a city in a detrimental way. For example: a natural disaster could damage the environmental sustainability and economical prosperity of a city, while a political upheaval could negatively effect the economical prosperity and the social equitability.
In order to simulate the disasters and their detrimental affects upon a city economically, environmentally, and socially, a $3 \times 3$ perturbative matrix was introduced. This matrix ties directly into the distributive weights $\gamma_{i}$, disturbing their values and affecting the growth indices, which, ultimately, affect the Growth Index itself. The perturbative matrix is of the form

$$D =
    \begin{bmatrix}
        \beta_{11} & \beta_{12} & \beta_{13} \\
        \beta_{21} & \beta_{22} & \beta_{23} \\
        \beta_{31} & \beta_{32} & \beta_{33}
    \end{bmatrix}$$

Here $\beta_{ij}$ is a perturbation value between $-1$ and $0$ where the more negative the value, the greater the disturbance. In this form, the matrix can be tuned to affect different parts of the Growth Index in varying degrees. For example, to have a disaster that affects the economy and the environment exclusively, values of $\beta_{ij}$ are generated for $i={1,2}$ with all other values set to $0$. Considering the perturbative matrix in terms of the Growth Index:

$$W' = D \times W =
    \begin{bmatrix}
        \beta_{11} & \beta_{12} & \beta_{13} \\
        \beta_{21} & \beta_{22} & \beta_{23} \\
        \beta_{31} & \beta_{32} & \beta_{33}
    \end{bmatrix}
    \times
    \begin{bmatrix}
        \gamma_{1} \\
        \gamma_{2} \\
        \gamma_{3}
    \end{bmatrix}$$

$$GI' = (W')^{T} \cdot F$$

Where $W'$ is our perturbed weights, and $GI'$ is our perturbed Growth Index.
The values $\beta_{ij}$ were not determined entirely through stochastic methods, however. Instead, the magnitudes of the values were weighted differently depending the types of disasters that could potentially happen in the target region, with historical accuracy. To elaborate, consider our initial stress-testing of our perturbation algorithm. For this run, we decided to focus on Bissau, as its location in a third-world country, along with its historical record, leave it susceptible to potential political unrest, not to mention the occasional flood or locust infestation. Studying the past 50 years of history for Guinea-Bissau carefully, we were able to set up a Poisson distribution for political disasters, natural disasters, and economical disasters for three degrees of severity for the next 50 years. So, these distributions worked to indicate the probability of a disaster triggering at each time step in our differential model. Once a disaster of a particular severity was triggered, the appropriate row (or rows) of values in the perturbative matrix were randomly determined, weighted toward either $-1$ or $0$ depending on the severity of the disaster as indicated by the distribution. With the perturbative matrices generated for the appropriate time steps, the results were fed into the Growth Index.

The results of our initiative through time with unexpected events is seen in the figure. In the perturbed curve, Bissau undergoes major disasters in the years 2020, 2028, 2046. These events set back the Growth Index greatly, but regardless of the severity of each disaster, our initiatives continue to have a positive effect on Bissau, allowing for recovery in the Growth Index in a short period of time (albeit somewhat less in magnitude than previously projected). This result goes to show that the model along with the choice selection of initiatives retain the capacity to grow a citys smart growth potential regardless of possible disasters that may arise in the future. Our growth plan, in short, is robust and effective in the face of the real world.

## Dramatic Population Increase

The model is also very robust when taking population change into account. For example, consider that each city will increase its population by 50% by 2050. The differential model accounts for population change over time, in part represented by our "toxicity" term. This term quantifies adverse effects that scale with population, including societal unrest, discohesion due to policies, or increasing maintenance, etc. Accounting for a specific population growth can be, and is, subsumed into our variables.

Indeed, the results produced strongly mirror this fact, with greater decay occurring over longer time scales. As we further the time, the decay becomes quite dramatic, more so than could be accounted for in either the overcrowding term or the decay term. Therefore, the model adequately considers population and not just a static city, which would be physically unrealistic.

# Conclusion

The growth of cities is inevitable. The world population is exploding and urbanization is an accommodating solution. With this expansion comes consequences that affect the environment, the economy, and the social balance. However, the consequences of this progression are avoidable with the implementation of smart programs. Specifically, our ten Smart Growth Initiatives consistently increase a citys growth index, which takes into account all three sustainability metrics and all ten principles of smart growth. Our model proves that the SGIs are robust, enduring unexpected changes like political, economic, or natural disasters as well as functioning in the face of population increase. It is clear through the extensive data analysis and research that this model is accurate and sound, attempting to remove subjective decisions at all possible points. The basis of the central metric, the overall Growth Index, properly reflects the state of the city at all points, too. It is grounded in real world data and constructed with rigorous calculations. The two cities, Anchorage, USA and Bissau, Guinea-Bissau were visibly shown to improve their growth index with the application of our smart growth plan. Their indices increased considerably and show slower decay as time moves forward. Finally, in the face of perturbations, both indices still showed improvement above the current state of the city.

## Strengths and Weaknesses

In our model, some strengths and weaknesses come to mind immediately. For the one, the model is completely deterministic and thorough, given starting values it can explain exactly how the three Es, our metrics, unfold and evolve. There is a consistency throughout the model that becomes important when considering different cities or initiatives. The weights chosen reflect the model, not the input data. It is quite robust, even given the odd source for this model and the rather unorthodox adaptation. In addition our model considers large amounts of real-world data, allowing for it to act upon those values as realistically as possible, with little room for assumptions. Also, it's a rather quick computational model, despite the complexity, taking under a second for each set of parameters. And finally, we can know that a precise solution exists, and unlike in previous population models, we can confidently claim that the solution is non trivial, due to the decay term.
On the other hand, our model is explicitly computational and numerical in nature, rather than analytic, and thus is going to have some level of imprecission built in. Similarly, the model is rather undetermined in a and b, with our values of parameters based on reflective reasoning rather than rooted in direct data, simply due to the fact that there are 10 principles and fitting all of them to data to obtain the proper relation would be rather unrealistic. The initiative percentages are self-chosen which is unavoidable because they need to be quantified in some initial way. Finally, as the model acts as a system of differential equations, inputs for both the population function and the antiderivative must be specified for time $t=0$, while only one input is given. On the relevant time scales, multiple values were tested and it ultimately made little difference, but it's a facet that can certainly be improved.

[^1]: firstname.lastname@example.com

[^2]: firstname.lastname@example.com

[^3]: email@example.com


abstract: Stochastic resonance (SR) has been studied experimentally in a glow discharge plasma. For the SR phenomena, it is observed that a superimposed subthreshold periodic signal can be recovered via stochastic modulations of the discharge voltage. In the present experiments, induction of SR is quantified using the absolute mean difference (AMD). Comparison of the AMD techniques with respect to cross-correlation has also been shown.
address: $^1$Plasma Physics Division, Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics, 1/AF, Bidhannagar, Kolkata -700064, India
  $^2$Facultad de Ciencias, UAEM, Avenida Universidad 1001, Colonia Chamilpa, Cuernavaca, Morelos, México
author: Md Nurujjaman$^1$, A N Sekar Iyengar$^1$ and P Parmananda$^2$
title: Emergence of the stochastic resonance in glow discharge plasma

# Introduction

Stochastic resonance (SR) which has been observed in many physical, chemical and biological systems  , is a phenomenon in which the response of the nonlinear system to a weak periodic input signal is amplified or optimized by the presence of a particular level of noise , i.e. a previously untraceable subthreshold signal applied to a nonlinear system, can be detected in the presence of noise. Furthermore, there exists an optimal level of noise for which the most efficient detection takes place.

In 1993, Gang, *et al.* , and in 1994, Kurt Wiesenfeld, *et al.* , had shown that SR is also possible in different classes of dynamical systems based not on bistability but on excitable dynamics. They proposed a system consisting of a potential barrier (PB) and above this barrier the system shows deterministic dynamics (limit cycle oscillation) and below, stable fixed point as illustrated in Fig .

The figure shows that when the control parameter (potential) crosses the PB, i.e., the potential is greater than PB, the system shows a limit cycle behavior and when the potential is less than PB, the system exhibits a stable fixed point behavior. Now if we set the control parameter (potential) below the PB and apply noise (stochastic perturbation on the potential) to the system and whenever the barrier is crossed, the system returns to its fixed point or "rest state" deterministically , i.e., whenever the barrier is crossed, the system traverses one oscillation. Now when a subthreshold periodic signal in the form of pulse and noise are added to the system below the potential barrier the probability of crossing the barrier by noise at the time of occurrence of the periodic pulse is maximum and hence one can get back deterministic dynamics in the form of periodic oscillations of frequency of the applied periodic pulse for optimum noise level which is the SR of an excitable system. Based upon excitability, SR has been observed in chemical systems , human brain and many other systems .

In plasma excitability arises from the most fundamental processes, namely the wave-wave and wave-particle interactions. Different modes may be excited due to nonlinear coupling of waves and plasma components and the character of the oscillations is primarily determined by the plasma parameters and perturbations . In our experiments, we get excitable dynamics, for certain discharge parameters, in the region greater than the Paschen minimum  and has been discussed in Section .

# Experimental setup

The experiments were performed in a hollow cathode dc glow discharge plasma. The schematic diagram of the experimental setup is presented in Fig .

A hollow stainless steel tube of length $\approx7~cm$ and of diameter ($\phi$) $\approx$ 45 mm was used as the cathode and a central rod of length $\approx7~cm$ and $\phi\approx$ 1.6 mm was employed as the anode. The whole assembly was mounted inside a vacuum chamber and was pumped down to a pressure of about 0.001 mbar using a rotary pump. The chamber was subsequently filled with the argon gas up to a pre-determined value of neutral pressure by a needle valve. Finally a discharge was struck by a dc discharge voltage (DV), which could be varied in the range of 0$-$`<!-- -->`{=html}1000 V.

The noise and subthreshold periodic square pulse generators were coupled with DV through a capacitor \[Fig. \]. In all the experiments DV was used as the bifurcation parameter while the remaining system parameters like pressure etc., were maintained constant. The system observable was the electrostatic floating potential, which was measured using a Langmuir probe of diameter $\phi$ = 0.5 mm and length 2 mm. The tip of this Langmuir probe was placed in the center of the electrode system as indicated in Fig. . The plasma density and the electron temperature were determined to be of the order of 10$^7$cm$^{-3}$ and 3$-$`<!-- -->`{=html}4 eV respectively. Furthermore, the electron plasma frequency ($f_{pe}$) was estimated to be around 28 MHz, whereas the ion plasma frequency ($f_{pi}$) was estimated to be around 105 kHz.

# Autonomous dynamics

At high pressures an anode glow and fluctuations in the floating potential were simultaneously observed as shown in Figs. (I) and (II) respectively. Figs  I(a) shows that the glow with largest size, appears when the discharge is struck at a typical pressure of 0.95 mbar and its size decreases with increase in the DV until it finally disappears \[Figs I(a)$-$`<!-- -->`{=html}II(h)\].

From the CCD image analysis the annular radius of the glow around the anode, was estimated to be $\approx 1.3$ mm at the beginning of the discharge \[Fig I(a)\] and reduced to $\approx 0.32$ mm \[Fig I(f)\]. Based on the observation of Valentin Pohoaţǎ, *et al.* , we feel that the relaxation oscillations are double layers or such coherent potential structures, which are constantly forming and annihilating. An interesting feature associated with the anode glow was the different types of oscillations in the floating potential at different pressures. The fluctuations in the floating potential fluctuations were irregular at the initial stage of discharge \[Fig II(a)\] and became regular with increase in the DVs Figs II(h)$-$`<!-- -->`{=html}II(i), and finally reaches a stable fixed point through homoclinic bifurcation . The DV at which these oscillations cease may be termed as the bifurcation point ($V_H$) which acts as a PB in this experiment. The floating potential fluctuation exhibits relaxation oscillations on the one side of the $V_H$ and stable fixed point on the other side, which is termed as being in an excitable state and is useful to study SR.

# Stochastic resonance

For our experiments on SR, the reference voltage $V_0$ was chosen such that $V_0>V_H$ and therefore the autonomous dynamics, by virtue of an underlying homoclinic bifurcation, exhibit steady state behavior. The DV was thereafter perturbed $V=V_0+S(t)+D\xi$, where $S(t)$ is the subthreshold periodic pulse train chosen for which $V=V_0+S(t)>V_H$, (subthreshold signal does not cause the system to cross over to the oscillatory regime) and $D\xi$ is the added Gaussian white noise $\xi$ with amplitude $D$.

Subthreshold periodic square pulse of width $20~\mu s$ and duration 2 ms was constructed using Fluke PM5138A function generator. Meanwhile, the gaussian noise produced using the HP 33120A noise generator was subsequently amplified using a noise amplifier.

Fig. $(a)-(c)$ show time series of the system response in the presence of an identical subthreshold signal for three different amplitudes of imposed noise. The subthreshold periodic pulse train is also plotted, in the top most graph of the left panel, for comparison purposes. Fig. (a) shows that there is little correspondence between the subthreshold signal and the system response for a low noise amplitude. However, there is excellent correspondence at an intermediate noise amplitude \[Fig. (b)\]. Finally, at higher amplitudes of noise the subthreshold signal is lost amidst stochastic fluctuations of the system response \[Fig. (c)\]. Absolute mean difference (AMD), used to quantify the information transfer between the subthreshold signal and the system response, is defined as $AMD=abs(mean(\frac{t_p}{\delta}-1))$. $t_p$ and $\delta$ are the inter-peak interval of the response signal and mean peak interval of the subthreshold periodic signal respectively. Fig (d) shows that the experimentally computed AMD versus noise amplitude D curve has a unimodal structure typical for the SR phenomena. The minima in this curve corresponds to the optimal noise level for which maximum information transfer between the input and the output takes place.

# Discussion

The effect of noise has been studied experimentally near a homoclinic bifurcation in glow discharge plasma system. Our study demonstrates the emergence of SR for periodic subthreshold square pulse signals via purely stochastic fluctuations.

In SR experiments, the efficiency of information transfer was quantified using AMD instead of the power norm which has been utilized elsewhere  . The advantage of using this method in comparison to the power norm ($C_0(0)$)  lies in the fact that AMD remains independent of the lag between the measured floating potential and the applied periodic square pulse. This is of relevance to our experimental system, where invariably there exists a lag, at times varying in time due to the parameter drifts.

Comparison between the estimated $C_0(0)$ and AMD have been shown in Fig . It is obvious from the upper panel of Fig  that $C_0(0)$ does not show any peak at optimum noise level. Whereas, AMD shows nice agreement with regular spiking of the signal \[Fig (lower panel). Derivation of the AMD statistics has been shown in  .

The authors acknowledge A. Bal, S.S. Sil, A. Ram and D. Das and the Micro Electronic Division of SINP for their technical help during the experiments.

# Absolute mean difference (AMD)

Absolute mean difference (AMD) is the statistical tool, proposed to quantify the SR in a plasma subjected to noise and a periodic signal. AMD is defined as $AMD=abs(mean(t_p/\delta-1))$, and gives AMD gives the degree of mimicking the output to the input subthreshold signal. Usually, regularity in the stochastic resonance is quantified by calculating cross-correlation ($Co = | < [(x1- < x1 >
)(x2- < x2 >)] > |$) between the output and input signal. But in case of plasma it is not suitable, because there is always a lag between periodic signal that is applied to the plasma and the output. This lag also varies with time because the plasma conditions keep fluctuating over time. Therefore, cross-correlation is not the right quantity to be estimated. So we have proposed a statistical tool AMD which will be independent of lag and is estimated as follows:

1.  First calculate the mean inter-peak distance ($\delta$) of the periodic signal.

2.  Calculate the inter-peak distances ($t_p$) of the output signal.

3.  Calculate the ($(t_p -\delta)/\delta$)

4.  Take the absolute, i.e., $| < ( t_p/\delta - 1) > |$.

Therefore, $AMD=abs(mean(\frac{t_P}{\delta}-1))$.

# References


author: Ludmilla Kolokolova$^1$ and Hiroshi Kimura$^2$
title: Comet dust as a mixture of aggregates and solid particles: model consistent with ground-based and space-mission results

# Introduction

Comets are bodies that have preserved the pristine materials from the time of the planet formation. Thus, knowledge about the comet dust allows us to find out the properties of the materials in the early Solar System. This is why comets have been objects of special interest not only to ground-based observers but also to numerous space missions: Giotto and Rosetta (European Space Agency), Vega (Soviet Space Agency), Suisei **(Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, currently a section of Japanese Aerospace Exploration Agency),** and NASA missions Contour, DS1, Stardust, and Deep Impact.

Accumulation of the observational data about comet dust (i.e., observations in the comet continuum filters free of gas emissions) reveals how comet dust brightness and polarization change with the phase angle (angle Sun-Comet-Observer) and with the wavelength in the visible and near-infrared spectral range (see details in the review by Kolokolova et al. 2004a). There were numerous attempts to use these data to solve the inverse problem for comet dust, i.e., to find out size, composition, shape, and structure of its particles based on the observational data. Unfortunately, the interpretation usually was done based only on photometric or only polarimetric data or was limited only by the angular dependencies of the observed characteristics. **In such a limited case, one could find** particles (sometimes rather simple, e.g., spheres or cylinders) whose light-scattering properties fit some observational data. However, any attempts to use the same model of comet dust to interpret other observational data failed (see Kolokolova et al 2004a for review and references). It was shown in Kolokolova et al. (2004b) that as soon as we try to fit photometric and polarimetric angular and spectral data together, no model of compact particles can be applied. Even the most complex model of polydisperse multishaped particles could not fit the whole scope of the observational data no matter what refractive index was tried. Even considering the comet particles as porous by calculating their refractive index using Maxwell Garnett mixing rule and considering voids as part of the mixture (similar to the approach described in Mukai et al., 1992) no ensemble of particles that could reproduce the correct shape of polarization and brightness phase curve together with the correct color and polarimetric spectral gradient (polarimetric color) was found.

Recently, a significant progress has been achieved in explaining the observational data describing the comet dust as an ensemble of aggregates made of submicron particles (see Kimura et al. 2003, Mann et al. 2004, Kimura et al. 2006). This model allows not only to qualitatively reproduce the observed changes in brightness and polarization with phase angle and wavelength but also can explain existence of two types of comet infrared spectra characterized by strong and weak $10\,\mu$m silicate feature. It was shown **in Kolokolova et al. (2007)** that the comets characterized by a strong silicate feature in thermal infrared and high polarization have more porous particles, **as it was first pointed out by Li and Greenberg (1998),** whereas the comets characterized by a weak silicate feature and low polarization contain more compact particles. **This model turned out to account for optical and infrared observations of ejecta from comet 9P/Tempel 1 during Deep Impact mission (Yamamoto et al. 2008).** One more advantage of this model is that it is consistent with the data on comet dust composition obtained *in situ* for comet 1P/Halley and with the structure of Interplanetary Dust Particles (IDPs) (Jessberger et al. 2001). However, as explained later, this model does not provide quantitative fits to the observed dependence of polarization on phase angle. Here, we present a more advanced model that account for all the optical properties of comet dust not only qualitatively but also quantitatively.

# Ground-based observations and their interpretation

Despite the difference in size, age, orbit, and source of origin, the vast majority of comets shows very similar photopolarimetric characteristics in the visible **(see Kolokolova et al. 2004a, 2004b and references therein)**. They are the following:

-   Low geometric albedo of the particles, close to 4–5%.

-   Prominent forward-scattering and gentle back scattering peaks in the angular dependence of intensity, "flat" behavior at medium phase angles

-   For a broad range of wavelengths angular dependence of linear polarization demonstrates (i) negative branch of polarization for phase angles $\le 20^{\circ}$ with the minimum $P_{\rm min} \approx  2$%; ii) bell-shaped positive branch with low maximum of value $P_{\rm max} \approx 15$–25% at the phase angle in the range 90–$100^{\circ}$.

-   Usually red or neutral color for a broad range of wavelengths that does not change with the phase angle.

-   Polarization at a given phase angle above 30$^\circ$ usually increases with the wavelength (red polarimetric color); this increase gets larger with the phase angle.

As it was mentioned in the introduction, all of these observational features could be qualitatively simulated if we consider the comet particles as aggregates of submicron grains. The model works well for both porous (Ballistic Cluster-Cluster Aggregates, BCCA) and more compact (Ballistic Particle-Cluster Aggregates, BPCA) particles.

Using the T-matrix multisphere code (Mackowski & Mishchenko 1996) Kimura et al. (2006) accomplished a survey of light-scattering properties of aggregates. The best fit to the comet observational data was achieved for the case of the aggregates of $\approx 0.2$ micron-size particles made of a mixture of organics, carbon, silicates with a small admixture of **iron sulfide or** iron. **The last component was added based on detection of FeNi metals in IDPs of likely cometary origin and carbonaceous meteorites (Bradley et al., 1996; Bernatowicz et al. 1999). The presence of FeNi metal in cometary dust is confirmed by the results of the Stardust mission (Zolensky et al. 2006). Such a model could also reproduce a low albedo equal to 4–5% that is close to the one found from the numerous observations and space mission studies. However, a quantitative fit to the observed degree of polarization seemed to require very big, made of hundreds of thousand monomers, aggregates. In other case the computational results showed too small values of the negative polarization and too high degree of the maximum polarization. Such huge aggregates require enormous computer time and memory to calculate their light-scattering characteristics. Also, domination of large fluffy aggregates in comet dust may be unrealistic assumption at large distances from the nucleus where fragile aggregates get smaller due to fragmentation. Thus, the model definitely requires some improvements which we attempt to provide in this paper based on additional information obtained from the space-mission data.**

# Comet dust as viewed by space missions

The model of aggregates described in the previous section was not developed in isolation from the results of the space mission to comets. First, the aggregate model of comet dust partly was stimulated by studies of IDPs captured in the upper layers of the Earth's atmosphere. These studies showed that IDPs of presumably cometary origin are aggregates of submicron particles (Brownlee et al. 1980). Second, Kimura et al. (2003) used the composition of comet dust consistent with the average composition of the dust in comet 1P/Halley measured *in situ* by Giotto mission (Jessberger et al. 1988). Hereafter we will call this composition Halley-like. In the next section we describe it in more detail.

Recent space missions have added new information to the known properties of the comet dust. The most significant insight was provided by the Stardust mission. This is not surprising since this was the mission specifically designed to study the comet dust *in situ* and to bring back samples of comet dust. The *in-situ* measurements by instruments DFMI and CIDA allowed revealing the size distribution of the particles (Green et al. 2004; see in more detail below) and provided some information on the composition of the dust (Kissel et al. 2004). However, the most important findings have been done during the study of the returned samples of the comet dust.

The returned samples present the comet dust particles captured when a special panel made of aerogel cells was exposed to the dust flux in the coma. Study of the tracks of the dust particles in the aerogel and in the aluminum foil around the cells revealed the structure of the particles. The majority of them appeared to be fragile aggregates of small **submicron particles**. Their composition was complex and included both silicate and carbonaceous materials as this was found for comet 1P/Halley. However, besides the aggregates, rather large non-agglomerated, solid silicate particles were also found among the Stardust returned samples (see, e.g., Flynn 2008). *In-situ* study of comet 1P/Halley showed that dust in comet 1P/Halley consisted of three types of particles (Fomenkova et al. 1999): rock (silicate), CHON (organic) and mixed (averaged, Halley-like dust composition) particles. The rock particles were shown to be solid whereas mixed and organic were fluffy (Jessberger & Kissel, 1991). Both rock and mixed particles were found in the Stardust returned samples.**The absence of pure organic particles in Stardust samples is not surprising. It is very likely that the high-speed interaction of the particles with the aerogel caused evaporation of small organic particles. Notice that organic-rich particles were detected at in-situ measurements by Stardust CIDA instrument (Kissel et al. 2004).**

In the next section we consider a model of comet dust that includes the space-mission results discussed in this section. Besides the fact that the model considers the comet dust as a mixture of solid silicate and aggregated organic and Halley-like particles, the particle size distribution should be also consistent with the one found by cometary space missions.

There have been several sets of space-mission data that allowed determining size distribution of comet particles. Hörz et al. (2006) summarizes the comet dust size distribution obtained from the Stardust studies of tracks in aerogel and craters in the aluminum foil, Stardust DFMI *in-situ* measurements of comet 81P/Wild 2 dust, and Giotto DIDSY and PIA measurements of dust in comet 1P/Halley. All size distributions look very much alike and in all cases consist of three power-law size distributions: least steep for the particles smaller than 1 micron, steeper for the particles of size between 1 and 100 micron and even steeper for the larger particles. The exponent of the power law for all the cases is negative and changes within 2–4 that is close to the values obtained from ground based observations, e.g., observations of comets C/1996 C1 Tabur **and 174P/Exhclus (Kolokolova et al. 2001; Bauer et al. 2008).**

# Combined model of comet dust

The combined model of comet dust outlined in the previous section is combined in two meanings. First, it combines the results of successful interpretation of ground-based observations with the *in-situ* space mission data and laboratory studies of the returned samples of comet dust. Second, it combines particles of two structural types (aggregates and solid particles) and three types of composition (silicate particles, organic particles, and particles of Halley-like composition).

We consider light-scattering by the solid silicate particles using the T-matrix method for spheroids by Mishchenko et al. (1996). **The refractive index equal to $1.6+0.001i$ that we use in the calculations is close to the values of optical constants for glass of olivine or pyroxene composition reported by Dorshchner et al. (1995).** The particles are presented by multishaped, polydisperse mixture of spheroids. Size distribution of the particles is selected to be consistent with the results of studies of comet dust by the space missions described at the end of the previous section. The power of the size distribution of the dust particles has been found negative in a range of the values from 2 to 4 and the exact value depends not only on the size of particles but also on the method used to study the size distribution and on the position of the instruments in the coma. This is why we decided not to follow the found size distributions in detail but consider a single power law with the power equal to $-3$, which represents the average value among the found ones. Multishaped properties of the ensemble were simulated by considering a mixture of oblate and prolate spheroids with the axis ratio within the range 1–2.5.

Aggregates in the combined model were represented as Ballistic-Cluster-Cluster Aggregates (BCCA) of organic and Halley-like composition. Aggregates were made of 256 monomers of radius 0.1 $\mu$m. The light-scattering properties of these aggregates were calculated using the multisphere T-matrix code by Mackowski & Mishchenko (1996). In case of organic aggregates we use the refractive indices from Li & Greenberg (1997). The Halley-like composition, as it was mentioned above, represents average composition found at *in-situ* measurements of the dust in comet 1P/Halley (Jessberger et al. 1988). It represents a mixture of silicates, metals, and carbonaceous materials. We suppose that one third of the carbonaceous materials are in the form of organic refractory and two thirds are in the form of amorphous carbon. This is based on a comparison of the nitrogen abundance between Halley's and interstellar dust (Kimura et al 2003). **We consider that silicates, iron, and organics refractory are embedded in amorphous carbon and estimate the average refractive index of the mixture using the multi-component Maxwell Garnett mixing rule (Bohren & Huffman 1983, Chapter 8.5).** Taking into account the elemental abundances of Halley's dust the volume filling factors are 31.76% for silicates, 2.56% for iron, and 65.68% for carbonaceous materials. The refractive indices of iron, organics refractory, and amorphous carbon are taken from Johnson & Christy (1974), Li & Greenberg (1997), and Rouleau & Martin (1991), respectively. **For silicates we adapt the refractive index of astronomical silicate from Laor & Draine (1993). This material has slightly higher absorption than such silicates as olivine and pyroxene that allows us to simulate a slight admixture of iron sulfide found in the comet dust (Zolensky et al. 2006, Flynn 2008).**

**We computed the intensity in the scattered plane $I_{par}$ and in the perpendicular plane $I_{per}$ separately for polydisperse multishaped spheroids, for organic BCCA, and for Halley-like BCCA, and then calculated the final intensity $I=I_{per}+I_{par}$ and polarization $P=(I_{per}-I_{par})/I$ summarizing $I_{per}$ and $I_{par}$ for all constituents of the mixture with some factors that were varied to control the silicate-to-carbonaceous-materials ratio and to adjust our results to the observational data.**

The best fit results are shown in Fig.1 where the top picture shows the change of albedo at two wavelengths, 0.45 and 0.6 $\mu$m, and the bottom one shows the phase-angle change in polarization. One can see that we have managed to fit the cometary photopolarimetric data rather well. **The brightness follows the phase angular dependence described in Section 2, albedo at zero phase angle is small, about 3% for the red filter, and the brightness at the shorter wavelength is smaller than at the longer one, i.e., the color is red.** The calculated polarization also fits the angular dependence known from the observations of comets, and not only qualitatively but also quantitatively. **Even though we get a deeper negative polarization branch that was observed, with the minimum $\le 4$%, it changes the sign at approximately 25$^{\circ}$, and reaches the maximum values at about 25–30% at the phase angle around 95$^\circ$ that fits very well to the observational data.** Also, the polarization at the shorter wavelength is smaller than at the longer one (red polarimetric color) and the difference between them increase with the phase angle that correctly reproduces the observational trends.

As we have mentioned above, we have one more parameter that was controlled during our calculations. This is the mass ratio of silicate to carbonaceous materials. The result presented at Fig.1 corresponds to this ratio equal to unity that is consistent with the elemental abundance of the comet Halley dust (Jessberger et al. 1988). Finally, the best-fit result appears to be in accordance with the abundance of rock, organic, and mixed particles found at *in-situ* measurements of the dust in comet 1P/Halley. We found that the best fit is achieved if the ratio of rock particles to the organic ones and to the Halley-like aggregates is equal to 0.30 : 0.44 : 0.26 that is consistent with the results by Fomenkova (1999) who showed that the rock particles represented 1/3 of the Halley dust. Our model also agrees with the fact that the rock particles in the Halley dust were compact whereas other particles were fluffy (Jessberger & Kissel 1991).

**The presented combined model shows a significant improvement in fitting the whole scope of the ground-based and space-mission data for comet dust. The further development of the model (e.g., by including larger size of particles and larger axes ratio for compact grains) is planned to get a better quantitative fit to the polarization and albedo values.**

# Conclusions

The model of comet dust that combines two types of particles: aggregates of submicron particles of organic and Halley-like composition and compact silicate particles can correctly reproduce all observational data and fits to the data on albedo, photometric phase curve, polarimetric phase curve, color, polarimetric color and ratio of silicates and organics in the comet dust. It confirms the results obtained *in situ* for the dust in comet 1P/Halley and is consistent with recent Stardust findings. This model could provide a much better fit to the photometric and polarimetric observational data than the model that considered only aggregates. The model correctly reproduces the polarimetric data, **including a pronounced negative polarization at small phase angles** and the positive polarization with the maximum value less than 30% at the phase angle around $95^{\circ}$ and red polarimetric color. It also shows red color of comet dust, albedo of the dust **equal to $\approx 3$%,** and the mass ratio of silicate to carbonaceous materials in the dust equal to unity that is in accordance with the elemental abundances of Halley's dust. Finally, it shows the ratio of rock, organic, and mixed particles in the dust that agrees with the Giotto *in-situ* measurements.


**Stone–Wales Transformation Paths in Fullerene C$_{60}$**

A. I. Podlivaev and L. A. Openov$^{*}$

*Moscow Engineering Physics Institute (State University), 115409 Moscow, Russia*

$^{*}$ E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.com

**ABSTRACT**

The mechanisms of formation of a metastable defect isomer of fullerene C$_{60}$ due to the Stone-Wales transformation are theoretically studied. It is demonstrated that the paths of the "dynamic" Stone-Wales transformation at a high (sufficient for overcoming potential barriers) temperature can differ from the two "adiabatic" transformation paths discussed in the literature. This behavior is due to the presence of a great near-flat segment of the potential-energy surface in the neighborhood of metastable states. Besides, the sequence of rupture and formation of interatomic bonds is other than that in the case of the adiabatic transformation.

Various models of fullerene growth have been proposed \[1\]. Because a sphere-shaped cluster C$_{60}$ is formed at a high temperature under actual operating conditions, its structure can be significantly different from the structure of ideal buckminsterfullerene with $I_{h}$ icosahedral symmetry. On the "surface" of buckminsterfullerene, carbon atoms are arranged at the vertexes of 20 hexagons and 12 pentagons, which are isolated from each other. Therefore, regardless of the mechanism of formation of such a spheroidal cluster from graphite fragments and/or carbon dimers, the question arises of the paths of its evolution into an equilibrium configuration of buckminsterfullerene, that is, the question of the mechanisms of defect annealing that reduces the potential energy $E_{pot}$ of the cluster.

Defect annealing occurs through local rearrangements of C-C bonds and is the reverse process for defect formation. The so called Stone-Wales transformation \[2\], which consists in the rearrangement of two C-C bonds in buckminsterfullerene (see Fig. 1), results in a defect isomer closest to buckminsterfullerene in terms of energy. This metastable isomer exhibits $C_{2v}$ symmetry and contains two pairs of pentagons with common sides. Among a great number of other isomers, this isomer stands out as the last segment (before buckminsterfullerene) in the chain of sequentially decreasing energies of a C$_{60}$ cluster on defect annealing \[3\].

In this context, attention was focused on studying changes in the mutual arrangement of atoms in the Stone-Wales transformation and on determining the height $U$ of a minimum energy barrier to this transformation \[4-10\]. Two different transformation paths were considered: (I) the rotation of a C-C bond shared by two hexagons through 90$^{0}$ so that all of the atoms remained on the cluster "surface" and (II) the rupture of a C-C bond shared by pentagon and hexagon; thereafter, one of the atoms initially rose above the cluster "surface" and then relaxed to form new bonds. In accordance with the calculations of $E_{pot}$ as a function of atomic coordinates $\{{\bf R}_{i}\}$ performed using the density functional theory \[5 - 10\], the barrier height for path I was $U_{I}$ = 6 - 8 eV, whereas $U_{II}$ = 6.64 - 7.6 eV for path II. A considerable scatter in the values of $U_{I}$ and $U_{II}$ does not allow one to determine unambiguously which of the two paths exhibits a lower barrier and, consequently, by which mechanism the Stone-Wales transformation occurs. Even with the use of the same exchange-correlation functional and equal basis-function sets (or equal cutoff energies in a plane-wave basis) for calculating $U_{I}$ and $U_{II}$, different results were obtained: $U_{I}=U_{II}$ = 7.27 eV \[10\], $U_{I}$ = 6.30 eV $<$ $U_{II}$ = 6.64 eV \[9\], and $U_{I}$ = 8.1 eV $>$ $U_{II}$ = 7.6 eV \[6, 7\].

Note that the determination of the height of a barrier and the type of a transition state based on the analysis of the shape of a potential-energy surface implies an adiabatic transition of the cluster from one state to another. That is, in such a transition, one or more properly chosen interatomic distances change in accordance with a certain law with a small step along the reaction coordinate, whereas relaxation to a minimum (with consideration for imposed restrictions) total energy is performed at each step in all of the other degrees of freedom. Physically, an adiabatic transition corresponds to a forced deformation of the cluster at $T=0$, and it must not occur identically to transitions at a finite (especially, high) temperature. In this work, we studied Stone-Wales transformation paths both in an adiabatic transition and at a high temperature (sufficient for overcoming a potential barrier) using a molecular dynamic simulation of the "life" of buckminsterfullerene. A comparison between the results allowed us, on the one hand, to find common features in the low-temperature and high temperature buckminsterfullerene metastable isomer transitions and, on the other hand, to reveal considerable differences between them.

We used a tight binding potential for calculations. This potential incorporates the contribution of all the valence electrons (four electrons from each atom) to the total energy in an explicit form, and it is actually an $n-$body potential, where $n$ is the number of atoms in the cluster. Because of this, this potential surpasses simple but less reliable empirical potentials. Although this method is not as strict as *ab initio* approaches, it is highly competitive with them in the accuracy of the description of carbon systems \[11\]. Moreover, this method considerably facilitates the simulation of dynamic processes because it is not resource-intensive. Previously, we used this method for an analysis of the thermal stability of metastable C$_{8}$ and C$_{20}$ clusters \[12 - 14\]. For buckminsterfullerene, it gave the binding energy $E_{b} = 60E$(C$_{1}$) - $E$(C$_{60}$) = 6.86 eV/atom and the bond lengths $l$ = 1.396 and 1.458 $\AA$, which are consistent with the experimental values of $E_{b}$ = 6.97 - 7.01 eV/atom \[15\] and $l$ = 1.402 and 1.462 $\AA$ \[16\]. The HOMO-LUMO gap $\Delta$ = 1.62 eV is also consistent with the experimental value of $\Delta$ = 1.6 - 1.8 eV \[17\].

Initially, we studied the mechanisms of the buckminsterfullerene $\rightarrow$ metastable isomer isomerization by adiabatic transitions. For this purpose, we calculated the "potential relief" $E_{pot}(\{{\bf R}_{i}\})$ for the C$_{60}$ cluster in the vicinity of an equilibrium atomic configuration (buckminsterfullerene) and the closest in energy metastable atomic configuration (metastable isomer) for the above two Stone-Wales transformation paths. Figure 2 shows the results of this calculation. The energy of the metastable isomer is higher than the energy of buckminsterfullerene by $\Delta E$ = 1.42 eV, which is consistent with the value of $\Delta E$ = 1.4 - 1.7 eV obtained by the density functional method \[5 - 10\]. In both path I and path II, the dependence of $E_{pot}$ on reaction coordinate $X$ exhibits the only stationary point (a maximum), which is a saddle point for the $E_{pot}(\{{\bf R}_{i}\})$ surface and determines the barrier height. According to our calculations, the value of $U_{I}$ = 6.46 eV is somewhat lower than $U_{II}$ = 6.58 eV.

Figure 3a shows the atomic configuration of the transition state for path I. It is "symmetric" in accordance with available published data \[6 - 10\]. On the contrary, the transition state for path II is asymmetric (Fig. 3b). One of the atoms is arranged over the cluster "surface", and it forms two bonds ($sp$ hybridization). In this case, another ("surface") atom has four neighbors ($sp^{3}$ hybridization). This transition state has been reported previously \[4, 6, 7, 9, 10\]. Note that path II exhibits an almost horizontal segment near a maximum in the $E_{pot}(X)$ curve. The atomic configuration that corresponds to the value of $X$ at which the second derivative $d^{2}E_{pot}(X)/dX^{2}$ exhibits a minimum (Fig. 2, point *4*) is visually similar to the transition state (Fig. 3b). Murry *et al.* \[6, 7\] stated that this configuration corresponds to a local minimum of $E_{pot}$ (that is, actually, to another metastable state). In recent publications \[9, 10\], no additional minimum of $E_{pot}$ was reported.

Nevertheless, we found that both of the above Stone-Wales transformation paths are characterized by barriers with approximately equal heights: $U_{I}$ = 6.46 eV and $U_{II}$ = 6.58 eV. These data are consistent with first-principle calculations \[5 - 10\], which gave similar values of $U_{I}$ and $U_{II}$ in a range of $7 \pm 1$ eV. One might expect that the Stone-Wales transformation under conditions of a real experiment (that is, due to thermally activated processes) occurs via both of these paths with approximately equal probabilities. To test this hypothesis, we numerically simulated the dynamics of buckminsterfullerene at $T=$ 4000 - 5000 K and a fixed total energy of the cluster, $E =
E_{kin} + E_{pot}$ = const. The cluster temperature was found from the equation \[18\] $k_{B}T(3n-6) = E_{kin}$, where $n=60$, and $E_{kin}$ is the kinetic energy in the system of the center of gravity averaged over 10$^{3}$ steps of molecular dynamics (the single step time $t_{0} = 2.72\cdot10^{–16}$ s was about 0.01 of the period of the highest frequency mode of cluster vibrations). On this formulation of the problem, the temperature $T$ is a measure of energy of relative atomic motion \[18\]. In this case, the value of $E_{kin}$ = 30 - 40 eV is sufficient for overcoming the potential barriers $U_{I,II} \approx$ 6.5 eV (although $E_{kin} >> U_{I,II}$, buckminsterfullerene isomerization processes at $T\approx$ 4500 K occur rarely, approximately once a time of $10^{6} t_{0}$).

We analyzed in detail 45 buckminsterfullerene $\rightarrow$ metastable isomer transitions and vice versa. We found that the Stone-Wales transformation occurred via path I (or by a visually very similar mechanism) in the majority of cases (37), see Fig. 4; it occurred via path II only in three instances, see Fig. 5. Thus, although both of the paths are almost equally favorable in terms of energy (see Fig. 2), path I is much more preferable from a dynamic standpoint. We believe that this is due to a dramatic difference between the frequency factors $A_{I}$ and $A_{II}$ in the Arrhenius temperature dependence of the rates of transition $k_{I,II}=A_{I,II}\exp(–U_{I,II}/k_{B}T)$. Consequently, in the consideration of Stone-Wales transformation mechanisms, attention should be focused on an analysis of the frequency factors of transitions via these two paths rather than on a further increase in the accuracy of the calculation of barrier heights $U_{I,II}$ (and on determining which of these barriers is lower even by fractions of eV).

In addition to the transformation of buckminsterfullerene via paths I and II, we also observed transitions accompanied by the formation of either a large "window" or three adjacent windows and the appearance of a "branch" of three atoms, which was perpendicular to the cluster "surface". All of these intermediate configurations correspond to potential-energy surface segments above the saddle points of transitions via paths I and II, that is, to other transformation paths with higher barriers. At $T=$ 5000-5500 K, the relative number of these transitions increases dramatically. They can occasionally result in the formation of isomers with higher energies (for example, fullerenes with three or more pairs of adjacent pentagons or nonclassical fullerenes with tetragons and heptagons).

Note that, in the dynamic transformation of buckminsterfullerene via path I, as a rule, one or two atoms in the C-C bond that rotated through 90$^{0}$ (Figs. 1 and 3a) rose above the cluster "surface" through different heights every time as in the transformation via path II (but, unlike path II, without the formation of an $sp^{3}$ configuration). This suggests that there are a great number of configurations with energies close to the saddle-point energies of paths I and II. That is, in other words, a segment in the potential-energy surface between two saddle points is almost planar. To test this hypothesis, we calculated $E_{pot}$ as a function of two reaction coordinates $H$ and $\Theta$ and found that, indeed, the $E_{pot}(H,\Theta)$ function exhibits a very great radius of curvature along the coordinate $H$ (Fig. 6). Note that a second-order stationary point (characterized by two imaginary frequencies) occurred between the saddle points of paths I and II. The energy of this stationary point is 0.56 eV higher than the energy of the saddle point of path II. This stationary point corresponds to a configuration in which one of the atoms of the rotated C-C bond rose over the cluster "surface" (however, to a lesser degree than in the transformation via path II).

In conclusion, let us consider the rupture and formation of interatomic bonds in the dynamic Stone-Wales transformation. Figure 4 shows a sequence of snapshots of the cluster in the course of the transformation via path I. It can be seen that the transformation began with the rupture of a single bond rather than the concerted rupture of two bonds shared by pentagons and hexagons, as in an adiabatic case \[10\]. Physically, this is easy to understand: a distortion of the ideal buckminsterfullerene structure due to the thermal vibrations of constituent atoms caused a symmetry breakdown in the arrangement of these two bonds. Because of this, one of these bonds became weaker than the other, and it was ruptured initially. Subsequently, the second bond was ruptured. Thereafter, a configuration similar to the transition state in an adiabatic case was formed (Fig. 3a). At the next step, new bonds were formed (consecutively rather than simultaneously) to complete the transformation. Note that the overall process occurred very rapidly and took only $\Delta t_{I} \approx 86$ fs. The transformation via path II began with the rupture of either a bond shared by pentagon and hexagon or a bond shared by two hexagons. For the latter case, Fig. 5 shows a sequence of snapshots of the C$_{60}$ cluster. The configuration corresponding to the transition state (Fig. 3b) can be clearly seen in Fig. 5. The transformation time $\Delta t_{II}\approx 354$ fs is much longer than the value of $\Delta t_{I}$; this is consistent with a greater "length" of path II (see Fig. 6).

This work was supported by the U.S. Civilian Research and Development Foundation (award "Research and Education Center for Basic Investigation of Matter Under Extreme Conditions").

**ACKNOWLEDGMENTS**

This study was supported by the CRDF, project "Scientific and Educational Center for Basic Research of Matter in Extremal States"

<embed src="Fig1.eps" />

Fig. 1. Formation of two pairs of pentagons with common sides on the rearrangement of two C-C bonds in fullerene C$_{60}$ (Stone-Wales transformation). For clarity, atoms in the background are not shown.

<embed src="Fig2.eps" style="width:80.0%" />

Fig. 2. Potential energy $E_{pot}$ of the C$_{60}$ cluster vs. the reaction coordinate $X$ in the neighborhoods of (*1*) equilibrium and (*2*) metastable atomic configurations in the Stone-Wales transformation (Fig. 1). The energy of 60 isolated carbon atoms was taken as zero energy. The solid and dashed lines indicate paths I and II, respectively (see the text); points *3* are $E_{pot}(X)$ maximum points (saddle points for $E_{pot}(\{{\bf R}_{i}\})$, and *4* is a $d^{2}E_{pot}/dX^{2}$ minimum point for path II. The path length along a trajectory that passes through the corresponding saddle point in $(3n–6)$-dimensional space and joins buckminsterfullerene with the metastable isomer was chosen as the reaction coordinate. $X=0$ at saddle points.

<embed src="Fig3.eps" />

Fig. 3. Atomic configurations of transition states *3* in Fig. 2 in the Stone-Wales transformation via (a) path I (symmetric transition state) and (b) path II (asymmetric transition state). Atoms in the background and C-C bonds more than 2 $\AA$ in length are not shown.

<embed src="Fig4.eps" style="width:60.0%" />

Fig. 4. Snapshots of the C$_{60}$ cluster in the course of the dynamic Stone-Wales transformation via path I. Initial temperature $T_{ini}=4465 \pm 5$ K. The first configuration corresponds to the time $t^{\prime} = 0.245$ ns, and the subsequent configurations correspond to the times $t^{\prime} + \Delta t$, where $\Delta t$ = 5.4, 17.7, 69.9, 73.4, and 85.7 fs, respectively. Atoms in the background and C-C bonds more than 2 $\AA$ in length are not shown.

<embed src="Fig5.eps" style="width:60.0%" />

Fig. 5. Same as in Fig. 4, but for the transformation via path II. $T_{ini}=4680 \pm 5$ K; $t^{\prime}=0.471$ ns; $\Delta t =$ 27, 54, 136, 299, and 354 fs, respectively.

<embed src="Fig6.eps" style="width:60.0%" />

Fig. 6. Potential energy $E_{pot}$ of the C$_{60}$ cluster vs. two reaction coordinates $H$ and $\Theta$ in the neighborhoods of (1) equilibrium and (2) metastable atomic configurations. The energy of 60 isolated carbon atoms was taken as zero energy. The solid and dashed lines indicate paths I and II, respectively; *3* indicates corresponding saddle points; and $S$ is a second-order stationary point (see the text). The reaction coordinates were chosen as follows: $H$ is the height through which an atom of the rotated C-C bond raised over the cluster "surface" normalized to a maximum height through which this atom rose in its motion along path II ($H=0$ for path I; a maximum value of $H=1$ was at the saddle point of path II) and $\Theta$ is the angle of rotation of the C-C bond normalized to 90$^{0}$ ($\Theta=0$ for buckminsterfullerene, $\Theta=1$ for the metastable isomer, and $\Theta \approx 0.5$ for the saddle points and the second-order stationary point $S$).