text:
Ancient Macedonians
The Macedonians (Greek: Μακεδόνες, Makedónes) were an ancient tribe from the northeastern part of the Greek peninsula, in the alluvial plain around the rivers Haliacmon and lower Axios. Generally described as an ancient Greek people,[1] they gradually expanded from their homeland along the Haliacmon valley on the northern edge of the Greek world, absorbing or driving out various neighbouring tribes during this process (primarily Thracian and Illyrian).[2][3]
Although composed of various clans, the Kingdom of Macedon, established around the 8th century BC, is mostly associated with the Argeads, both the name of the ruling dynasty and of the tribe named after it. Traditionally ruled by independent families, the Macedonians seem to have accepted Argead rule by the time of King Alexander I (r. 498–454 BC). Under King Philip II (r. 359–336 BC), they are credited with numerous military innovations which enlarged their territory and increased their control over other areas, and this led to the exploits of Alexander the Great, the establishment of several realms from the Diadochi, and the inauguration of the Hellenistic civilization.
Early history[edit]
The expansion of the Macedonian kingdom has been described as a three-staged process. As a "frontier" kingdom on the border of the Greek world with "Barbarian" Europe, the Macedonians first subjugated their immediate neighbours to the north (various Illyrian and Thracian tribes) before turning against the states of southern and central Greece. Macedonia was then able to lead a largely Hellenic military force against their primary objective – the conquest of Persia – which they achieved with remarkable ease.[4]
Prehistoric homeland[edit]
In Greek mythology, Makedon is the eponymous hero of Macedonia and is mentioned in Hesiod's Catalogue of Women. The first historical attestation of the Macedonians occurs in the works of Herodotus during the mid-5th century BC. The Macedonians are absent in Homer's Catalogue of Ships. In fact, the term "Macedonia" itself appears late. The Iliad states that, upon leaving Olympus, Hera journeyed via Pieria and Emathia before reaching Athos.[5] This is later re-iterated by Strabo in his Geography.[6] Nevertheless, archaeological evidence indicates that Mycenaean contact with or penetration into the Macedonian interior possibly started from the early 14th century BC.[7]
In his A History of Macedonia, Nicholas G. L. Hammond reconstructed the earliest phases of Macedonian history, based on his interpretation of later literary accounts and archaeological excavations in the region of Macedonia. His work remains a point of reference for all scholars engaging in the subject.[8]
According to Hammond, the Macedonians are missing from early Macedonian historical accounts because they had been living in the Orestian highlands since before the Dark Ages, possibly having originated from the same (proto-Greek) population pool that produced other Greek peoples.[9][10] The Macedonian tribes subsequently moved down from Orestis in the upper Haliacmon to the Pierian highlands in the lower Haliacmon due to pressure from the Orestae, a related tribe who had migrated to Orestis from Pelagonia.[11] In their new Pierian home, north of Olympus, the Macedonian tribes mingled with the "Dorians-to-be". This might account for traditions which placed the eponymous founder, Makedon, "round Pieria and Olympus".[12] Certain traditions placed the Dorian homeland in the Pindus mountain range in western Thessaly, whilst Herodotus pushed this further north to the Macedonian Pindus, and "were called, as an ethnos, Mακεδνόν".[13][14]
A different, southern homeland theory also exists in traditional historiography. By placing the Dorian homeland in Phthiotis, and citing the traditions of fraternity between Makedon and Magnes, Arnold Joseph Toynbee has argued that the Makedones migrated north to Macedonia from central Greece.[15]
Temenids and Argeads[edit]
The Macedonian expansion is said to have been led by the Temenid ruling dynasty. Herodotus recounts that Perdiccas, the founder of the dynasty, was descended from the Heraclid Temenos.[16] He left Argos with his two older brothers (Aeropus and Gayanes) and arrived, via Illyria, to Lebaea, a city in Upper Macedonia (which certain scholars have attempted to connect with the villages Alebea or Velvedos).[17] Here, the brothers served as humble shepherds for a local ruler. After a vision, the brothers fled to another region in Macedonia, near the Midas Gardens by the foot of Mount Bermion, and then set about subjugating the rest of Macedonia.[18] Thucydides seems to echo Herodotus's account, making it probable that the story was disseminated by the Macedonian court,[19] i.e. it accounts the belief the Macedonians themselves had about the origin of their kingdom, if not an actual memory of this beginning.[20] Later historians modified the dynastic traditions by introducing variously Caranus or Archelaus as the founding Temenid kings.
The earliest sources, Herodotus and Thucydides, called the royal family Temenidae. It is only in later sources that the term "Argeadae" was introduced (e.g. Strabo, Appian, Pausanias). However, Appian suggests that the term Argeadae referred to a leading Macedonian tribe rather than the name of the ruling dynasty.[21] The origin of the name "Argeadae" is itself unclear. The most common connection, as propounded by Herodotus, is with Peloponnesian Argos.[22] Appian, rather, connects it with Orestian Argos.[23] Another tradition suggests the name was adopted after Caranus moved Macedonia's capital from Edessa to Agea, thus appropriating the name of the city for its citizens.[24] A figure, Argeas, is mentioned in the Iliad, raising the possibility that the Macedonian kings (like many other Mediterranean populations) derived their genealogy from Trojan War heroes.[20]
Taking Herodotus's lineage account as the most trustworthy, Appian recalls that, after Perdiccas, six successive heirs ruled: Argeus, Philip, Aeropus, Alcetas, Amyntas and Alexander.[25] Amyntas I ruled at the time of the Persian invasion of Paeonia.[26] However, Alexander I is the first truly historic figure. Based on this line of succession, and an estimated 25 to 30-year average ruling period, the beginnings of the Macedonian dynasty have thus been traditionally dated to 750 BC.[27] Hammond upholds the traditional view that the Temenidae did, in fact, arrive from the Peloponnese and took charge of Macedonian leadership, possibly usurping rule from a native "Argead" dynasty with Illyrian help.[18] However, other scholars doubt the veracity of their Peloponnesian origins. For example, Hatzopoulos takes Appian's testimony to suggest that the royal lineage imposed itself onto the tribes of the Middle Heliacmon from Argos Orestikon,[17] whilst Borza suggested that the Argeads were a family of notables hailing from Vergina itself.[28]
Expansion from the core[edit]
Both Strabo and Thucydides recount that Emathia and Pieria were mostly occupied by Thracians (Pierians, Paeonians) and Bottiaeans, as well as certain Illyrian and Epirote tribes,[29] whilst Herodotus relates that the Bryges were co-habitants with the Macedonians prior to their bulk migrating to Asia Minor.[30]
If there was indeed a group of ethnically definable Macedonian tribes living in the Pierian highlands prior to their expansion, the first conquest was of the Pierian piedmont and coastal plain, including Vergina,[31] possibly launching their expansion from a base by Mount Bermion, as mentioned by Herodotus.[32]
Thucydides describes the Macedonian expansion specifically as a process of conquest led by the Argeadae:[33]
"But the country along the sea which is now called Macedonia, was first acquired and made a kingdom by Alexander [I], father of Perdiccas [II] and his forefathers, who were originally Temenidae from Argos. They defeated and expelled from Pieria the Pierians...and also expelled the Bottiaeans from Bottiaea ... they acquired as well a narrow strip of Paeonia extending along the Axios river from the interior to Pella and the sea. Beyond the Axios they possess the territory as far as the Strymon called Mygdonia, having driven out the Edoni. Moreover, they expelled from the district now called Eordaea the Eordi ... The Macedonians also made themselves rulers of certain places ... namely Anthemus, Grestonia, and a large part of Macedonia proper."
Thucydides's account gives a geographical overview of Macedonian possessions at the time of Alexander I's rule. To reconstruct a chronology of the expansion by Alexander I's predecessors is more difficult, but generally, three stages have been proposed from Thucydides's reading. The initial and most important conquest was of Pieria and the Bottiaei, including the locations of Pydna and Dium followed by a second stage which consolidated rule in Pieria and Bottiaea, captured Methone and Pella, and extended rule over Eordaea and Almopia. By Hammond's reckoning, the third stage occurred some time after 550 BC, when the Macedonians wrested control over Mygdonia, Edonia, lower Paeonia, Bisaltia, and Crestonia.[34] However, the second stage might have occurred as late as 520 BC;[35] and the third stage probably did not occur until after 479 BC, whereby the Macedonians capitalized on the weakened Paeonian state after the Persian withdrawal.[36]
Whatever the case, Thucydides's account of the Macedonian state describes its accumulated territorial extent by the rule of Perdiccas II, Alexander I's son. Hammond has contended that the early stages of Macedonian expansion were particularly militaristic, expunging populations, or at least subduing them, from a large and varied area.[37] It has been hypothesized that the cause of Macedonian expansion was demographic pressure. Given that pastoralism and highland living could not support a very concentrated settlement density, pastoralist tribes often searched for more arable lowlands suitable for agriculture.[38]
Ethnogenesis scenario[edit]
More recently, scholars have questioned the traditionalist perspective first set in place by Hammond, highlighting several inconsistencies.[39] Instead, an alternative model of state and ethnos formation, promulgated by an alliance of regional elites, has recently been postulated, which re-dates the creation of the Macedonian kingdom to the 6th century BCE.[40] For example, direct literary, archaeological, and linguistic evidence is lacking to support Hammond's contention that a distinct Macedonian ethnos had existed in the Haliacmon valley since the Bronze Age. Rather, his interpretation has been criticized as a "conjectural reconstruction" from what appears during later, historical times.[41]
Similarly, the historicity of migration, conquest and population expulsion have also been called into question. Thucydides's account of the forced expulsion of the Pierians and Bottiaeans could have been formed on the basis of his perceived similarity of names of the Pierians and Bottiaeans living in the Strymon valley with the names of regions in Macedonia; whereas his account of Eordean extermination was formulated precisely because such toponymic correspondences are lacking.[36] Likewise, the Argead conquest of Macedonia may be viewed as a commonly used literary topos in classical Macedonian rhetoric: tales of migration served to create complex genealogical connections between trans-regional ruling elites, whilst at the same time used by the ruling dynasty to legitimize their rule, heroicize mythical ancestors, and distance themselves from their subjects.[20][42]
Conflict was a historical reality in the early Macedonian kingdom and pastoralist traditions allowed the potential for population mobility (Greek archaeologists have found that some of the passes linking the Macedonian highlands with the valley regions have been used for thousands of years). However, the archaeological evidence does not point to any significant disruptions between the Iron Age and Hellenistic periods in Macedonia. The general continuity of material culture,[43] settlement sites,[44] and pre-Greek onomasticon[45] mitigate against the traditional "ethnic cleansing" account of early Macedonian expansion.
The process of state formation in Macedonia was in many ways analogous to its neighbours in Epirus, Illyria, Thrace, and Thessaly, whereby regional elites could mobilize disparate communities for the purpose of organizing land and resources. Local notables were often based in urban-like settlements, although contemporary historians often did not recognize them as poleis (because they were not self-ruled but under the rule of a "King").[46] From the mid-6th century, there appears a series of exceptionally rich burials throughout the region – in Trebenista, Vergina, Sindos, Agia Paraskevi, Pella-Archontiko, Aiani, Gevgelija, Amphipolis – sharing a similar burial rite and grave accompaniments, interpreted to represent the rise of a new regional ruling class sharing a common ideology, customs and even religious beliefs.[40] A common geography, mode of existence, and defensive interests might have necessitated the creation of a political confederacy amongst otherwise ethno-linguistically diverse communities; which led to the consolidation of a new, "Macedonian", ethnic identity.[40][47]
The traditional view that Macedonia housed un-urbanized ethne in constant conflict is thus slowly changing, bridging the cultural gap between southern Epirus and the north Aegean region. Hatzopoulos's studies on Macedonian institutions have lent support to the hypothesis of Macedonian state formation occurring via an "integration" of regional elites which were based in city-like centres, including the Argeadae at Vergina, and the Paeonian/Edonian peoples in Sindos, Ichnai and Pella, as well as the mixed Macedonian-"Barbarian" colonies in the Thermaic Gulf and western Chlakidike.[48] The Temenidae became overall leaders of a new Macedonian state due to the diplomatic proficiency of Alexander I and the logistic centrality of Vergina itself. It has been suggested that a breakdown in traditional "Balkan" tribal traditions associated with adaptation of certain "Aegean" socio-political institutions created a climate of institutional flexibility in a vast, resource-rich land.[49] Non-Argead centres increasingly became "dependent allies", allowing the Argeads to gradually extract a more secure control over the lower and eastern territories of Macedonia.[48] However, this control was only really consolidated by Phillip II.[50]
Macedonia possessed a distinct material culture by the Early Iron Age.[51] Typically "Balkan" burial, ornamental, and ceramic forms were used for most of the Iron Age.[52] These features suggest broad cultural affinities and organizational structures analogous with Thracian, Epirote, and Illyrian regions.[53][54] This, however, did not necessarily symbolize a sharing of common identity or political allegiance.[55] Toward the latter 6th century BC, Macedonia became more open to Greek influences from the south, although a small but detectable amount of interaction with the south had been present since late Mycenaean times.[56] By the 5th century BC, Macedonia was a part of the "Greek cultural milieu", possessing many cultural traits typical of the southern Greek city-states.[57] Classical Greek objects and customs were appropriated selectively and utilized in peculiarly "Macedonian" ways.[58]
The inhabitants of Upper Macedonia led a way of life which differed little from that of their neighbors in Epirus and Illyria, engaging in seasonal transhumance supplemented by agriculture. In these mountainous regions, upland sites served as important focal points for local communities, so-called "tribal centers". In these difficult terrains, competition for resources often precipitated inter-tribal conflict and raiding forays into the comparatively richer lowland settlements of coastal Macedonia and Thessaly.[59] Despite the remoteness of the upper Macedonian highlands, excavations at Aiani since 1983 have brought to light finds attesting to the presence of social organization since the 2nd millennium BC. The excavations have unearthed the oldest pieces of black-and-white pottery, characteristic of the tribes of northwest Greece, discovered so far.[60] Found with Μycenaean sherds, they can be dated with certainty to the 14th century BC.[60][61][62] The findings also include some of the oldest samples of writing in Macedonia, among them inscriptions bearing Greek names like Θέμιδα (Themida). The inscriptions demonstrate that Hellenism in Upper Macedonia was at a high economic, artistic, and cultural level by the 6th century BC, overturning the notion that Upper Macedonia was culturally and socially isolated from the rest of ancient Greece.[60]
By contrast, the alluvial plains of Lower Macedonia and Pelagonia favored the development of a native aristocracy with a wealth which at times surpassed the classical Greek poleis.[63] There was a comparative abundance of natural resources, such as timber and minerals. Exploitation of mineral mines helped catalyze coinage in Macedonia from the 5th century BC, developing under southern Greek, Thracian and Persian influences.[64] In contrast with classical Greek poleis, the Macedonians generally possessed very few slaves.[65]
During the Late Bronze Age (circa 15th century BC), the ancient Macedonians developed distinct matt-painted wares that evolved from Middle Helladic pottery traditions originating in central and southern Greece.[62][66] The Macedonians continued to utilize an individualized form of material culture (albeit showing analogies in ceramic, ornamental and burial forms with the so-called Lausitz culture between 1200–900 BC) and that of the Glasinac culture after circa 900 BC.[67] Whilst some of these influences persisted beyond the 6th century BC,[68][69] a more ubiquitous presence of items of an Aegean-Mediterranean character is observed from the latter 6th century BC,[70] as Greece recovered from its "Dark Ages". The avenues by which southern Greek impulses penetrated Macedonia were via trade with north Aegean colonies such as Methone and those in the Chalcidice, neighbouring Thessaly, and from the Ionic colonies Asia Minor. Later, Ionic influences were supplanted by those of Athenian provenance. Thus, by the latter 6th century local elites were able to acquire "exotic" Aegean items such as Athenian red figure pottery, fine tablewares, olive oil and wine amphorae, fine ceramic perfume flasks, glass, marble and precious metal ornaments; which would serve as status symbols.[71] By the 5th century BC, they become rather widespread; not only in Macedonia, but also in much of the central Balkans.[72]
Macedonian settlements bear a strong continuity dating back to the Bronze Age. While settlement numbers appeared to drop in central and southern Greece after 1000 BC, there is a dramatic increase in Macedonia, keeping traditionally used house construction techniques.[73] These settlements seemed to have developed on raised promontories near river flood plains, and are called tells (Greek: τύμβοι). They are particularly focused in western Macedonia (between Florina and Lake Vergiotis, the upper and middle Heliacmon River, and down to Bottiaea). The other focus is in eastern Macedonia, on either side of the Axius and in the Chalcidice.[74] Urbanization was encouraged and controlled by Macedonian kings. Whilst a comparatively meager number of Macedonians lived in the few native Macedonian cities (e.g. Aegeae, Pella, Dion), urbanization increased by the 4th century BC as Greek colonies were conquered and integrated into Macedonia, or new towns were founded (such as Philippi, Thessalonike and Alexandropolis). These towns possessed typical Greek urban infrastructural features, such as gymnasia, temples and theaters.
Macedonian society was dominated by aristocratic families whose main source of wealth and prestige was their herds of horses and cattle. In this respect, Macedonia was similar to Thessaly and Thrace.[54] However, unlike Thessaly, Macedonia was ruled by a monarchy from its earliest history until the Roman conquest in 167 BC. The nature of the kingship, however, remains debated. One viewpoint sees it as an autocracy, whereby the king held absolute power. Any other position of authority, including the army, was appointed at the whim of the king himself. The other, "constitutionalist", position argues that there was an evolution from a society of many minor "kings" — each of equal authority — to a sovereign military state whereby an army of citizen soldiers supported a central king against a rival class of nobility.[75] Kingship was hereditary along the main male line, however, whether this was of a primogeniture nature remains to be established. The situation was further complicated by the fact that Macedonian kings were notoriously polygamist, sometimes resulting in sibling rivalry and even fratricide.
An important aspect of Macedonian social life were court symposia, which were characterized by heavy drinking (of apparently unmixed wine), feasting, and general debauchery. Symposia had several functions, amongst which was providing relief from the hardship of battle and marching. Symposia were Greek traditions since Homeric times, providing a venue for interaction amongst Macedonian elites. An ethos of egalitarianism surrounded symposia, allowing all male elites to express ideas and concerns, although built-up rivalries and excessive drinking often led to quarrels, fighting and even murder. The degree of extravagance and propensity for violence set Macedonian symposia apart from classical Greek symposia.[76] Like symposia, hunting was another focus of elite activity, and it remained popular throughout Macedonia's history. Young men participating in symposia were only allowed to recline after having killed their first wild boar. Although the Macedonians created their own athletic games and, after the late 4th century, non-royal Macedonians competed and became victors in the Olympic Games[57] and other athletic events such as the Argive Heraean games, athletics were a less favored pastime compared to hunting.[77]
Nevertheless, Alexander the Great sponsored athletic contests for his men; along with other facets of cultural life, such as philosophy and theatre, which increasingly incorporated Macedonia into the Greek world. Atticization was seen as early as King Archelaus's reign, who welcomed southern Greek intellectuals into the kingdom. Athenian playwrights such as Euripides and Agathon and the famous painter Zeuxis, all were influential in the early kingdom. Euripides wrote his last two tragedies at Archelaus's court.[78]
The ancient Macedonians worshipped the Olympic Pantheon, especially Zeus, Artemis, Heracles, and Dionysus. Evidence of this worship is attested from the beginning of the 4th century BC onwards, as there exists little evidence regarding Macedonian religious practices from earlier times.[79] From an early period, Zeus was the single most important deity in the Macedonian pantheon.[79] Makedon, the mythical ancestor of the Macedonians, was held to be a son of Zeus, and Zeus features prominently in Macedonian coinage.[79] The most important center of worship of Zeus was at Dion in Pieria, the spiritual center of the Macedonians, where beginning in 400 BC King Archelaus established an annual festival, which, in honor of Zeus, featured lavish sacrifices and athletic contests.[79] Worship of Zeus's son Heracles was also prominent, with coins featuring Heracles appear from the 5th century BC onwards.[79] This was in large part because the Argead kings of Macedon traced their lineage to Heracles, making sacrifices to him in the Macedonian capitals of Vergina and Pella.[79] Numerous votive reliefs and dedications also attest to the importance of the worship of Artemis.[80] Artemis was often depicted as a huntress and served as a tutelary goddess for young girls entering the coming-of-age process, much as Heracles Cynagidas (Hunter) did for young men who had completed it.[80] By contrast, some deities popular elsewhere in the Greek world, notably Poseidon and Hephaistos, were largely ignored by the Macedonians.[79]
Other deities worshipped by the ancient Macedonians were part of a local pantheon: Thaulos (god of war equated with Ares), Gyga (later equated with Athena), Gozoria (goddess of hunting equated with Artemis), Zeirene (goddess of love equated with Aphrodite), Xandos (god of light), Totoës (god of sleep), Darron (god of healing), Aretos (local version of Heracles), Bedu (from Edessa, god of water or air), the Echédorides (nymphs), the Arantides (possibly the Furies), the Sauadai (water spirits or demons identified with the Satyrs), Pasikraia (a goddess attested in Macedonia and Thessaly), and Sabazius-Dionysus (a Thracian god).[81] A notable influence on Macedonian religious life and worship was neighboring Thessaly: the two regions shared many similar cultural institutions.[82] The Macedonians also worshiped non-Greek gods, such as the "Thracian rider", Orpheus and Bendis, and other Balkan cult figures. They were tolerant of, and open to incorporating, foreign religious influences, such as the sun-cult worship of the Paeonians.[3] By the 4th century BC, there had been a significant fusion of Macedonian and common Greek religious identity,[83] but Macedonia was nevertheless characterized by an unusually diverse religious life.[3] This diversity extended even to the belief in magic, as attested by curse tablets. It was a not an insignificant, but secret aspect of Greek cultural practice.[84]
A notable feature of Macedonian culture was the ostentatious burials reserved for its rulers.[85] The Macedonian elite chose to construct lavish tombs at time of death rather than construct temples during life.[85] Such traditions had been practiced throughout Greece and the central-west Balkans since the Bronze Age, and Macedonian burials contain items similar to those at Mycenae (burial with weapons, gold "death masks", etc.).[86] From the 6th century, Macedonian burials became particularly lavish, displaying a rich variety of Greek imports, reflecting the incorporation of Macedonia into a wider economic and political network centred on the Aegean city-states. Burials contained a repertoire of jewellery and ornaments of unprecedented wealth and artistic style. This zenith of Macedonian "warrior burial" style drew close parallels with sites in south-central Illyria and western Thrace, creating a koinon of elite burials.[87] Lavish warrior burials had been discontinued in southern and central Greece from the 7th century onwards, where offerings at sanctuaries and the erection of temples instead became the norm.[88] From the 6th century BC, cremation replaced the traditional inhumation rite for elite Macedonians.[40] One of the most lavish tombs is one dated to the 4th century at Vergina, believed to be that of Phillip II. It contains extravagant grave goods, highly sophisticated artwork depicting hunting scenes and Greek cultic figures, and a vast array of weaponry.[89] This demonstrates a continuing tradition of the "warrior society" rather than a focus on religious piety and "technology of the intellect" which had become paramount facets of central Greek society in the classical period.[88]
For administrative and political purposes, Attic Greek seems to have operated as a lingua franca amongst the ethno-linguistically diverse communities of Macedonia and the north Aegean region, creating a diglossic linguistic area.[90] Attic Greek was standardized as the language of the court, formal discourse and diplomacy from at least the time of Archelaus at the end of the 5th century BC.[91] Attic was further spread by Macedonia's conquests.[92] Although Macedonian continued to be spoken well into Antigonid times,[93] Attic became the prevalent oral dialect not only in Macedonia, but throughout the Macedonian-ruled Hellenistic world.[94]
Attempts to classify Ancient Macedonian are made difficult by the paucity of surviving Ancient Macedonian texts, as it was a primarily oral language and most archeological inscriptions indicate that there was no dominant written language in Macedonia other than Attic, and later Koine Greek.[95] All surviving epigraphical evidence from grave markers to public inscriptions is in Greek.[96]
Classification attempts are based on a vocabulary of 150-200 words and 200 personal names assembled mainly from the 5th century lexicon of Hesychius of Alexandria, as well as a few fragmentary surviving inscriptions, coins, and the occasional passage in ancient sources.[95] Most of the vocabulary is regular Greek, with tendencies toward Doric Greek and Aeolic Greek; on the other hand, there can be found some Illyrian and Thracian elements.[95][97] The Pella curse tablet, which was found in 1986 at Pella and dates to the mid-4th century BC or slightly earlier,[98] is believed to be the only substantial attested text in Macedonian. The language of the tablet is a harsh but a distinctly recognizable form of Northwest Greek: the tablet, therefore, has been used to support the argument that ancient Macedonian was a Northwest Greek dialect and mainly a Doric dialect,[99][100][101] whilst Hatzopoulos's analysis revealed some tendencies toward the Aeolic Greek dialect.[97] Macedonian onomastics paint a similar picture, most personal names being recognizably Greek (e.g. Alexandros, Philippos, Dionysios, Apollonios, Demetrios), with some dating back to Homeric (e.g. Ptolemaeos) or even Mycenean times, though here too there can be found the occasional non-Greek name (e.g. "Bithys").[95] Macedonian toponyms and hydronyms are similarly overwhelmingly Greek in origin (e.g. Aegae, Dion, Pieria, Haliacmon), as are the names of the months of the Macedonian calendar and the names of most of the deities the Macedonians worshiped, and according to Hammond, these are not late borrowings.[102] Nevertheless, a definitive conclusion eludes the linguistic community.[103] On the one hand, Macedonian shares close structural and lexical affinity with the "proper" Greek dialects (especially Northwest Greek and Thessalian).[104][105][106] The majority of the words are Greek, although some of these could represent loans or cognate forms.[107][108] On the other hand, a number of phonological, lexical and onomastic features also set Macedonian apart.[108][109] These latter features, possibly representing traces of a substratal language, occur in what are considered to be particularly conservative systems of the language.[110]
Several hypotheses have consequently been proposed as to the overall "position" of Macedonian, but all broadly see it either as a peripheral Greek dialect, a separate yet related language (see Hellenic languages),[108][111][112] or even a hybridized idiom.[113][114][115] Drawing on the similarities between Macedonian, Greek and Brygian, several scholars suggest that they formed an Indo-European macro-dialectical group[116][117] which split before circa 14th-13th century BCE (i.e. prior to the appearance of the main Greek dialects).[118] The same data has been analyzed in alternative manner, which sees the formation of the main Greek dialects as a later convergence of related but distinct groups. Macedonian did not fully participate in this process, making its ultimate position difficult to define other than being a contiguous, related 'minor' language.[119]
Another stream of evidence is metalinguistics and the question of mutual intelligibility. The available literary evidence cannot provide detail as to the exact nature of Macedonian, however, it does suggest that Macedonian and Greek were sufficiently different to pose communication difficulties between Greek and Macedonian contingents, even necessitating the use of interpreters as late as the time of Alexander the Great.[120][121][122] Based on this evidence, Papazoglou has argued that, by definition, Macedonian could not have been a Greek dialect.[123] However, similar evidence for non-intelligibility exists for other ancient Greek dialects, e.g. Aetolian.[124]
Nature of sources[edit]
Most ancient sources on the Macedonians come from outside of Macedonia.[125] According to Eugene N. Borza, most of these sources are either ill-informed, hostile, or both, making the Macedonians one of the "silent" peoples of the ancient Mediterranean.[126] Most of the literary evidence tends to come from later sources focusing on the campaigns of Alexander the Great rather than on Macedonia itself, while most contemporary evidence on Philip tends to be Athenian and hostile.[127] Moreover, most ancient sources tend to focus on the deeds of Macedonian kings in connection with political and military events such as the Peloponnesian War, and evidence on the ethnic identity of Macedonians of lower social status is highly fragmentary and unsatisfactory from the Archaic to the Hellenistic period.[128] For Macedonia before Philip, historians have to rely on archeological inscriptions and material remains, a few fragments from historians whose work is now lost, the occasional passing mention in Herodotus and Thucydides, and "universal histories" from the Roman era.[127]
Ancient sources on the Argeads[edit]
The identity of the Argead royal family is often examined separately from the Macedonian ethnos as a whole. The earliest version of the Temenid foundation myth was circulated by Alexander I, via Herodotus, during his apparent appearance at the Olympic Games.[129] Despite protests from some competitors, the Hellanodikai ("Judges of the Greeks") accepted Alexander's Greek genealogy, as did Herodotus himself, and later Thucydides. In accepting his Greek credentials, the judges were either moved by the evidence itself, or did so out of political considerations - as reward for services to Hellas. The historicity of Alexander I's participation in the Olympics has been doubted by some scholars (Alexander's name does not appear in any list of Olympic victors), who see the story as a piece of propaganda engineered by the Argeads and spread by Herodotus.[130] Moreover, that there were protests from other competitors suggests that the supposed Argive genealogy of the Argeads "was far from mainstream knowledge";[131] and the appellation "Philhellene" was "surely not an appellation that could be given to an actual Greek".[131][132] Whatever the case, "what mattered was the Alexander had played the geneaological game a la grecque and played it well".[133]
The emphasis on the Heraclean ancestry of the Argeads served to heroicize the royal family and to provide a sacred genealogy which established a "divine right to rule" over their subjects.[134] The Macedonian royal family, like those of Epirus, emphasized "blood and kinship in order to construct for themselves a heroic genealogy that sometimes also functioned as a Hellenic genealogy."[135]
Although most contemporary Greek writers accepted the Argeads as Greek, they nevertheless expressed an air of ambiguity about them (specifically their monarchic institutions and their background of Persian alliance) often portraying them as a potential "barbarian" threat to Greece.[136] For example, the late 5th century sophist, Thrasymachus of Chalcedon, objected "we Greeks are enslaved to the barbarian Archelaus" (Fragment 2).[137] The issue of Macedonian Hellenicity, and that of their royal house, was particularly pertinent in the 4th century BCE, around the politics of invading Persia. Demosthenes viewed Macedonia's monarchy to be incongruous with an Athenian-led Pan-Hellenic alliance. He thus castigated Philip II for being "neither Greek nor a remote relative of the Greeks, nor even a respectable barbarian, but one of those cursed Macedonians..."[138] This was obvious political slander, but "the orator clearly could not do this, if his audience was likely to regard his claim as nonsense: it could not be said of a Theban, or even a Thessalian".[139] On the other hand, Isocrates believed that only Macedonia was capable of leading a war against Persia, thus felt compelled to uphold that Phillip was a "bona fide" Hellene by discussing his Argead and Heraclean heritage.[140][141]
Ancient sources on the Macedonian people[edit]
With regard to how the Macedonian ethnos as a whole was regarded by the Greeks, the earliest reference comes from Hesiod's Catalogue of Women. The eponymous Makedon, and his brother Magnes, are made sons of Zeus and Thyia, daughter of Deucalion.[12] Descent from Zeus did not make one a Greek, but having been fathered by Hellen himself did. The Magnetes, descendants of Magnes, were an Aeolic Greek tribe, thus according to Hammond, this places the Macedonians among the Greeks.[142] Engels also interprets that Hesiod counted the Macedonians as Greeks, while Hall stipulates that "according to strict genealogical logic, [this] excludes the population that bears [Macedon's] name from the ranks of the Hellenes".[143] Two later writers deny Macedon a Hellenic lineage: Apollodorus (3.8.1) makes him a son of Lycaon, son of earth-born Pelasgus, whilst Pseudo–Scymnos (6.22) makes him born directly from the earth.[144] Hellanicus, on the other hand, modified Hesiod's genealogy by making Makedon the son of Aeolus, thus firmly placing the Macedonians in the Aeolic Greek-speaking family.[145]
These early writers and their formulation of genealogical relationships demonstrate that, prior to the 5th century, Greekness was defined on an ethnic basis and legitimized by tracing descent from eponymous Hellen.[146] Subsequently, cultural considerations assumed greater importance.
Thucydides and Herodotus regarded the Macedonians either as northern Greeks, barbarians, or an intermediate group between "pure" Greeks and barbarians.[147] In his Histories, Herodotus recalls a reliable tradition whereby the Dorians were formed by a fusion of Macedonian and other Greek tribes,[148] suggesting that Macedonians were Greeks.[149] In other sections of his work, however, Herodotus implies that the Macedonians are not Greek: in 5.20.4, he calls King Amyntas an aner Hellen Makedon hyparchos, or "a Greek who ruled over Macedonians",[147] and in 7.130.3 where Herodotus tells that the Thessalians were the "first of the Greeks" to submit to Xerxes.[150]
Thucydides did not perceive Greeks and barbarians as mutually exclusive categories, rather opposite poles on a linear spectrum. He placed the Macedonians on his cultural continuum closer to barbarians than Hellenes,[151] or perhaps an intermediate category between Greeks and non–Greeks.[152] For example, he distinguishes between three groups fighting in the Peloponnesian War: The Greeks (including Peloponnesians), the barbarian Illyrians, and the Macedonians.[152] In recounting Brasidas's expedition to Lyncus, he juxtaposes the Macedonian cavalry with "the rest of the huge barbarian throng".[153] Whilst this calls them barbarians by association, more explicit is his recounting of Brasidas's speech where he tells his Peloponnesian troops to dispel fear of fighting against "barbarians: because they had already fought against Macedonians".[154]
Ancient geographers differed in their views on the size of Macedonia and on the ethnicity of the Macedonians.[155] While most ancient geographers did not include the core territories of the Macedonian kingdom in their definition of Greece, the reasons are unknown. For example, Strabo says that while "Macedonia is of course part of Greece, yet now, since I am following the nature and shape of the places geographically, I have chosen to classify it apart from the rest of Greece".[155][156] While he speaks of the "Macedonians and the other Greeks", Pausanias did not include Macedonia in Hellas as indicated in Book 10 of his Description of Greece.[155]
As noted above, Isocrates defended Philip's Greek origins, but was not inclined to think the same of his people: "He (Perdiccas I) left the Greek world alone completely, but he desired to hold the kingship in Macedonia; for he understood that Greeks are not accustomed to submit themselves to monarchy whereas others are incapable of living their lives without domination of this sort...for he alone of the Greeks deemed it fit to rule over an ethnically unrelated population."[157] Nevertheless, Philip named the federation of Greek states he created with Macedon at its head (nowadays referred to as the League of Corinth) as simply "The Hellenes" (i.e. Greeks), and the Macedonians were moreover granted two seats in the exclusively Greek Great Amphictyonic League in 346 BC when the Phocians were expelled; although Badian sees it as a personal honor awarded to Phillip, and not to the Macedonian people as a whole.[158]
With Philip's conquest of Greece, Greeks and Macedonians both enjoyed privileges at the royal court, and there was no social distinction amongst his court hetairoi, although Philip's armies were only ever led by Macedonians. The process of Greek and Macedonian syncretism culminated during the reign of Alexander the Great, and he even allowed Greeks to command his armies. However, there was also some persisting antagonism between Macedonians and Greeks lasting into Antigonid times.[159] Some "Greeks" continued to push against their Macedonian overlords throughout the Hellenistic era.[160] They rejoiced on the death of Phillip II;[161] and they revolted against Alexander's Antigonid successors, which the Greeks called, revealingly, the Hellenic War.[162] However, whilst Pan-Hellenic sloganeering was used by Greeks against Antigonid dominance, it was also used by Macedonians themselves to drum up popular support throughout Greece.
After the 3rd century BC, and especially in Roman times, the Macedonians were consistently regarded as Greeks.[163] For example, Polybius has the Acarnanian Lyciscus tell the Spartans that they are "of the same tribe" as the Achaeans and the Macedonians.[164] Livy, in his History of Rome, states that the Macedonians, Aetolians and Acarnanians were "all men of the same language".[165] Similar opinions are shared also by Arrian and Strabo (7.7.1).
The Persians referred to both Greeks and Macedonians as Yauna ("Ionians", their term for "Greeks"), though they distinguished the "Yauna by the sea and across the sea" from the Yaunã Takabara or "Greeks with hats that look like shields", possibly referring to the Macedonian kausia hat.[166] According to another interpretation, the Persians used such terms in a geographical rather than ethnic sense. That is, Yauna, and its various attributes, possibly referred to regions lying north and west of Asia Minor; and could have included Phrygians, Mysians, Aeolians, Thracians, and Paionians in addition to Greeks.[167] In Hellenistic times, most Egyptians and Syrians included the Macedonians among the larger category of "Greeks" without hesitations, as the Persians had done earlier.[166]
Modern discourse[edit]
Modern scholarly discourse has produced a variety of hypotheses as to how the Macedonians sat within the Greek world. In view of discovered material remains of Greek-style monuments, buildings, inscriptions dating from the 5th century, and the predominance of Greek personal names; one school of thought suggests that the Macedonians were "truly Greeks" who had retained a more archaic lifestyle viz-a-viz their southern cousins. This cultural discrepancy was highlighted and exploited during political struggles of Athens and Macedonia in the 4th century. As a point of comparison, Engels suggests the Greekness of the Epirotes, who led a similarly "archaic" life as the Macedonians, never drew a sharp discussion as with the Macedonians, perhaps because the Epirotes, unlike the Macedonians, never attempted to achieve hegemony over all of Greece.[147] This has been the predominant viewpoint from the 20th century onwards. As Worthington summarizes: "...not much need to be said about the Greekness of ancient Macedonia: it is undeniable".[168]
Another perspective interprets the literary evidence, and the archaeological-cultural differences between Macedonia and central-southern Greece prior to the 5th century and beyond, as evidence that the Macedonians were originally non-Greek tribes who underwent a process of Hellenization.[169][170] Accepting that political factors did play a part, they also highlight that the degree of antipathy between Macedonians and Greeks was of a different quality to that seen amongst other Greek states, even those with a long-term history of mutual animosity (e.g. Sparta and Athens).[171] According to these scholars, it is only with the ongoing Hellenization of Macedonia, and the emergence of Rome as a common enemy in the west, that the Macedonians came to be regarded as "northern Greeks". This is precisely the period during which ancient authors, such as Polybius and Strabo, called the ancient Macedonians "Greeks".[169] By this point, as described by Isocrates, to have been a Greek could have suggested a quality of culture and intelligence rather than strict "racial" or ethnic affinity.[172] [173]
Others have adopted both views; citing that "there is no question that, in the fifth and fourth centuries, there were noticeable difference between the Greeks and the Macedonians"; yet the issue of Macedonian Hellenicity was ultimately a "political one".[174] Hall adds: "to ask whether the Macedonians "really were" Greek or not in antiquity is ultimately a redundant question given the shifting semantics of Greekness between the 6th and 4th centuries BC. What cannot be denied, however, is that the cultural commodification of Hellenic identity that emerged in the 4th century might have remained a provincial artifact, confined to the Balkan peninsula, had it not been for the Macedonians."[175]
See also[edit]
- Ancient Greece
- Ancient Macedon
- Ancient Macedonian language
- Macedonia (ancient kingdom)
- List of ancient Macedonians
- List of ancient Macedonians in epigraphy
- ^ Zacharia 2008, Simon Hornblower, "Greek Identity in the Archaic and Classical Periods", pp. 55–58; Joint Association of Classical Teachers 1984, pp. 50–51; Errington 1990, pp. 3–4; Fine 1983, pp. 607–608; Hall 2000, p. 64; Hammond 2001, p. 11; Jones 2001, p. 21; Osborne 2004, p. 127; Hammond 1989, pp. 12–13; Hammond 1993, p. 97; Starr 1991, pp. 260, 367; Toynbee 1981, p. 67; Worthington 2008, pp. 8, 219; Chamoux 2002, p. 8; Cawkwell 1978, p. 22; Perlman 1973, p. 78; Hamilton 1974, Chapter 2: The Macedonian Homeland, p. 23; Bryant 1996, p. 306; O'Brien 1994, p. 25.
- ^ Trudgill 2002, p. 125; Theodossiev 2000, pp. 175–209.
- ^ a b c Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 21: Paul Christesen and Sarah C. Murray, "Macedonian Religion", p. 428.
- ^ Kristinsson 2010, p. 79: "Both these empires [Macedonian and Roman] originated on the edges of the Greek world and were heavily influenced by Greek civilization even to the point of copying the Greek phalanx but developing it according to their own preferences...As the Macedonians became infused with Greek civilization they developed a larger and stronger state than any in Greece proper...The Macedonians only became important players in the Greek system after they had used what they had learned from the Greeks to expand into barbarian Europe."
- ^ Homer. Iliad, 14.226.
- ^ Strabo. Geography, 7 (Fragment 2): "What is now Macedonia was in earlier times called Emathia. Macedonia took its name from Macedon, an early ruler..."
- ^ Best & de Vries 1989, R. F. Hoddinott, "Thracians, Mycenaeans and 'The Trojan Question'", p. 64.
- ^ Hatzopoulos 1996, p. 105; Errington 1990, pp. 7–9; Borza 1982, p. 8.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 84: "The Macedonians themselves may have originated from the same population pool that produced other Greek peoples."
- ^ Vanderpool 1982, Eugene N. Borza, "Athenians, Macedonians, and the Origins of the Macedonian Royal House", p. 7.
- ^ On pages 433–434 of "The Position of the Macedonian Dialect", A. Panayotou describes the geographical delimitations of ancient Macedon as encompassing the region from Mount Pindus to the Nestos River, and from Thessaly to Paeonia (the area occupied by the kingdom of Philip II, which preceded the much larger Roman province of the same name).
- ^ a b Hesiod. Catalogue of Women, Fragment 7.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 1.56.3, 8.43.1; Hammond & Griffith 1972, pp. 430–440.
- ^ This was but one of several traditions regarding the "Dorian homeland" variously placing it in Phthiotis, Dryopis, Erineos, etc. For the formation of Dorian ethnicity, and its traditions, see chapters 3 and 4 of Johnathan Hall's Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity.
- ^ Toynbee 1969, Chapter 3: "What was the Ancestral Language of the Makedones?", pp. 66–77.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 8.137.8.
- ^ a b Hatzopoulos 1999.
- ^ a b Hammond & Griffith 1972, pp. 433–434.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 7: Slawomir Sprawski, "The Early Temenid Kings to Alexander I", pp. 127-128.
- ^ a b c Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 7: Slawomir Sprawski, "The Early Temenid Kings to Alexander I", p. 129.
- ^ Appian. Roman History, 11.63.333; Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 7: Slawomir Sprawski, "The Early Temenid Kings to Alexander I", p. 130.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 5.22.
- ^ Appian. Roman History, 11.63.333.
- ^ Justin. Historiarum Philippicarum, 7.1.10.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 8.139.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 5.17.1-2.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1972, p. 433; Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 7: Slawomir Sprawski, "The Early Temenid Kings to Alexander I", p. 130.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 82.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1979, p. 434.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 7.73, 8.138.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1972, p. 434; Borza 1992, p. 78.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1972, p. 434.
- ^ Thucydides. History of the Peloponnesian War, 2.99.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1972, pp. 437–438.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 87.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 7: Slawomir Sprawski, "The Early Temenid Kings to Alexander I", p. 133.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1979, p. 438.
- ^ Borza 1992, pp. 79–80.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 16: Zosia Archibald, "Macedonia and Thrace", p. 329
- ^ a b c d Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 7: Slawomir Sprawski, "The Early Temenid Kings to Alexander I", p. 134.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 70.
- ^ Hall 2002, pp. 70–73.
- ^ Snodgrass 2000, p. 163: "Altogether, the graves of Macedonia, like their contents, are best explained by the durability of the non-Greek cultural element here, in which the phenomena of Greek influence – the Protogeometric pottery, and perhaps the rare cremations at Vergina – are fleeting."
- ^ Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 12: Zosia Halina Archibald, "Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace", pp. 222–224.
- ^ Hornblower, Matthews & Fraser 2000, Miltiade Hatzopoulos, ""L'histoire par les noms" in Macedonia", p. 112.
- ^ Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 12: Zosia Halina Archibald, "Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace", p. 215.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 4: Carol G. Thomas, "The Physical Kingdom", p. 74.
- ^ a b Hatzopoulos 1999, p. 464.
- ^ Butler 2008, pp. 222–223.
- ^ Butler 2008, p. 223.
- ^ Whitley 2007, p. 253: "Ethnicity and culture are not the same, and however the ancient Macedonians viewed themselves, Macedonian material culture had little in common with that of central Greece. Differences are apparent from a very early date."
- ^ Whitley 2007, p. 253: "The inhabitants at these sites continued to use a style of 'Balkan' pottery that has little in common with Greek painted wares throughout the Archaic period..."
- ^ Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 13: J. K. Davies, "A Wholly Non-Aristotelian Universe: The Molossians as Ethnos, State, and Monarchy", p. 251.
- ^ a b Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 12: Zosia Halina Archibald, "Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace", p. 213.
- ^ Whitley 2007, p. 233.
- ^ Lemos 2002, p. 207.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 1: Edward M. Anson, "Why Study Ancient Macedonia and What this Companion is About", p. 19.
- ^ Whitley 2007, p. 254: "But, if Macedonians were beginning to make use of some central Greek objects, they were otherwise sticking to their peculiar Macedonian ways."
- ^ Boardman 1982, [Part III: The Balkans and the Aegean] Chapter 15: N. G. L. Hammond, "Illyris, Epirus and Macedonia in the Early Iron Age", pp. 621–624.
- ^ a b c "Encyclopædia Britannica - Hellenism in Macedonia".
- ^ Iordanidis, Garcia-Guinea & Karamitrou-Mentessidi 2007, pp. 1796–1807.
- ^ a b Karamitrou-Mentessidi 2007.
- ^ Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 12: Zosia Halina Archibald, "Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace", p. 212.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 1: Edward M. Anson, "Why Study Ancient Macedonia and What this Companion is About", p. 8.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 92.
- ^ Horejs 2007.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1972, pp. 420–426; Snodgrass 2000, p. 257.
- ^ Snodgrass 2000, p. 253: "The early Iron Age period of use of the Vergina cemetery must have lasted, on any view, for three centuries at the very least. Yet over this period it shows a quite astonishing consistency in metalwork."
- ^ Snodgrass 2000, p. 163: "Altogether the graves of Macedonia, like their contents, are best explained by the durability of the non-Greek cultural element here, in which the phenomena of Greek influence - the Protogeometric pottery, and perhaps the rare cremations at Vergina - are fleeting."
- ^ Boardman 1982, [Part III: The Balkans and the Aegean] Chapter 15: N. G. L. Hammond, "Illyris, Epirus and Macedonia in the Early Iron Age", pp. 644–650.
- ^ Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 12: Zosia Halina Archibald, "Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace", p. 217.
- ^ Wilkes 1995, pp. 104–107.
- ^ Whitley 2007, p. 243.
- ^ Brock & Hodkinson 2000, Chapter 12: Zosia Halina Archibald, "Space, Hierarchy, and Community in Archaic and Classical Macedonia, Thessaly, and Thrace", pp. 223–224.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 18: Carol J. King, "Macedonian Kingship and Other Political Institutions", pp. 374-375.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 19: Noriko Sawada, "Social Customs and Institutions: Aspects of Macedonian Elite Society", pp. 392–408.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 19: Noriko Sawada, "Social Customs and Institutions: Aspects of Macedonian Elite Society", p. 403.
- ^ Euripides, Iphigenia.
- ^ a b c d e f g Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 21: Paul Christesen and Sarah C. Murray, "Macedonian Religion", p. 430.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 21: Paul Christesen and Sarah C. Murray, "Macedonian Religion", p. 431.
- ^ Cook, Adcock & Charlesworth 1928, pp. 197–198; Sakellariou 1992, p. 60.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 15: Denver Graninger, "Macedonia and Thessaly", pp. 323–324.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 97.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 21: Paul Christesen and Sarah C. Murray, "Macedonian Religion", p. 434.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 21: Paul Christesen and Sarah C. Murray, "Macedonian Religion", p. 429.
- ^ Whitley 2007, p. 254.
- ^ Fisher & Wees 1998, p. 51; Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 16: Zosia Archibald, "Macedonia and Thrace", p. 340.
- ^ a b Whitley 2007, pp. 254–255.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 21: Paul Christesen and Sarah C. Murray, "Macedonian Religion", pp. 439–440.
- ^ There were Dorian and Euboean colonies, as well as tribal ethne speaking Greek, Illyrian, Thracian, Paeonian, Brygian, etc.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 92.
- ^ Christidēs, Arapopoulou & Chritē 2007, Chapter 6: A. Panayotou, "The Position of the Macedonian Dialect", p. 433.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 96
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 161.
- ^ a b c d Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 94.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 1: Edward Anson, "Why study the Ancient Macedonians", p. 20.
- ^ a b Borza 1992, p. 93.
- ^ Voutiras 1998, p. 25.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 95:" This has been judged to be the most important ancient testimony to substantiate that Macedonian was a north-western Greek and mainly a Doric dialect".
- ^ Masson & Dubois 2000, p. 292: "..."Macedonian Language" de l'Oxford Classical Dictionary, 1996, p. 906: "Macedonian may be seen as a Greek dialect, characterized by its marginal position and by local pronunciation (like Βερενίκα for Φερενίκα etc.)"
- ^ Masson 1996, "Macedonian Language", pp. 905-906.
- ^ Worthington 2003, p. 20.
- ^ Hall 2002, p. 116. Jonathan Hall warns against making overarching conclusions based on one inscription. Either way, "the finite limitations of the graphic system conceal a far greater diversity of oral idioms.
- ^ Christidēs, Arapopoulou & Chritē 2007, Chapter 6: A. Panayotou, "The Position of the Macedonian Dialect", pp. 431–433.
- ^ Hornblower, Matthews & Fraser 2000, Miltiade Hatzopoulos, ""L'histoire par les noms" in Macedonia", p. 111.
- ^ It is a difficult exercise to distinguish between words which are truly common between Macedonian and Greek from cognates and loanwords.
- ^ Boardman 1982, Chapter 20c: R. A. Crossland, "Linguistic Problems of the Balkan Area in Late Prehistoric and Early Classical Periods", p. 846.
- ^ a b c Woodard 2008b, p. 11: "If such sets are rightly analyzed as cognates, the Macedonian language departs conspicuously from Greek in showing voiced unaspirated rather than voiceless aspirated reflexes of the earlier Indo-European voiced aspirated stops."
- ^ Boardman 1982, Chapter 20c: R. A. Crossland, "Linguistic Problems of the Balkan Area in Late Prehistoric and Early Classical Periods", pp. 846–847.
- ^ Personal names, names of gods and months, and phonological features. Refer to: Christidēs, Arapopoulou & Chritē 2007, Chapter 6: A. Panayotou, "The Position of the Macedonian Dialect", pp. 438-439.
- ^ Finkelberg 2005, p. 121: "Thus Macedonian, for example, does not share with Greek at least one of the features identifying the unique idiom of the latter, namely, the devoicing of the IE voiced aspirates."
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", pp. 163–165.
- ^ Hornblower, Matthews & Fraser 2000, Miltiade Hatzopoulos, ""L'histoire par les noms" in Macedonia", p. 115.
- ^ Christidēs, Arapopoulou & Chritē 2007, Chapter 6: A. Panayotou, "The Position of the Macedonian Dialect", p. 439: "It might be simpler to assume that the names manifesting this feature are substratum relics of a tribe which was linguistically assimilated by the Macedonians..."
- ^ Specifically, a hybridized language incorporating Brygian, Northwest Greek and Thessalian.
- ^ Papazoglou 1977, pp. 65–83.
- ^ Woodard 2008a, Chapter 8: Claude Brixhe, "Phrygian", p. 72
- ^ Georgiev 1981, pp. 170, 360.
- ^ Garrett 1999, pp. 146–156.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", pp. 161–163.
- ^ Borza 1999, pp. 42–43: "Macedonian and Greek were sufficiently different as late as the time of Alexander the Great as to require interpreters and cause ancient writers to note differences."
- ^ Barr-Sharrar & Borza 1982, E. Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians", p. 41: "The suggestion is surely that Macedonian was the language of the infantry and that Greek was a difficult, indeed a foreign, tongue to them."
- ^ Papazoglou 2000, pp. 771–777.
- ^ Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, 3.94 [1].
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 2: P. J. Rhodes, "The Literary and Epigraphic Evidence to the Roman Conquest", p. 23.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 5.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 1: Edward M. Anson, "Why Study Ancient Macedonia and What this Companion is About", p. 7.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 85.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 5.22; Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", pp. 92-93.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 6: Sulochana R. Asirvatham, "Perspectives on the Macedonians from Greece, Rome, and Beyond", p. 101.
- ^ a b Barr-Sharrar & Borza 1982, E. Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians", p. 34.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 93.
- ^ Hall 2002, p. 156.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 169; Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 91.
- ^ Malkin 1998, p. 140.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 6: Sulochana R. Asirvatham, "Perspectives on the Macedonians from Greece, Rome, and Beyond", p. 103.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 160.
- ^ Demosthenes. Third Philippic, 9.31.
- ^ Barr-Sharrar & Borza 1982, E. Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians", p. 42.
- ^ Isocrates. Philippus, 32–34 and 76–77; Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", pp. 159–160.
- ^ Isocrates. To Philip, 5.127: "Therefore, since the others are so lacking in spirit, I think it is opportune for you to head the war against the King; and, while it is only natural for the other descendants of Heracles, and for men who are under the bonds of their polities and laws, to cleave fondly to that state in which they happen to dwell, it is your privilege, as one who has been blessed with untrammelled freedom, to consider all Hellas your fatherland, as did the founder of your race, and to be as ready to brave perils for her sake as for the things about which you are personally most concerned."
- ^ Worthington 2003, Chapter 2: N.G.L. Hammond, "The Language of the Macedonians", p. 20.
- ^ Hall 2002, p. 165; Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 169.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 169.
- ^ Hall 2002, p. 165.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 170.
- ^ a b c Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 84.
- ^ Herodotus. Histories, 1.56.3, 8.43.
- ^ Hammond & Griffith 1972, pp. 429–430. Hammond states that Pelagonia might have been initially called Argestia.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 171.
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", pp. 171–172.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 85.
- ^ Thucydides. History of the Peloponnesian War, 4.124.1.
- ^ Thucydides. History of the Peloponnesian War, 4.126.3; Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 160.
- ^ a b c Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 88.
- ^ Strabo, Geography, Book VII, fragment 9: Greek text and English translation thereof in H. L. Jones' edition or by Hamilton and Falconer, at the Perseus Project.
- ^ Isocrates. Philippos, 107-108; Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 169.
- ^ Barr-Sharrar & Borza 1982, E. Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians", p. 34.
- ^ Barr-Sharrar & Borza 1982, E. Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians", p. 43.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 6: Sulochana R. Asirvatham, "Perspectives on the Macedonians from Greece, Rome, and Beyond", p. 104.
- ^ Diodorus Siculus. Historical Library, 17.3.
- ^ Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 1: Edward M. Anson, "Why Study Ancient Macedonia and What this Companion is About", p. 18: "By the second century the literary evidence suggests that the Macedonians and their southern neighbours saw themselves and each other as Greeks."
- ^ Polybius. The Histories, 9.37.
- ^ Livy. History of Rome, 31.29.15.
- ^ a b Roisman & Worthington 2010, Chapter 5: Johannes Engels, "Macedonians and Greeks", p. 87.
- ^ Kinzl 2010, Robert Rollinger, "The Eastern Mediterranean and Beyond", p. 205.
- ^ Worthington 2008.
- ^ a b Danforth 1997, p. 169.
- ^ Barr-Sharrar & Borza 1982, E. Badian, "Greeks and Macedonians", p. 47.
- ^ Borza 1992, p. 96.
- ^ Badian, Wallace & Harris 1996, Peter Green, "The Metamorphosis of the Barbarian: Athenian Panhellenism in a Changing World", p. 24.
- ^ Isaac 2004, p. 113: "It is quite likely that Isocrates was interested in also representing the Hellenic community in a broader sense, so that he could include the Macedonians, who were not considered Hellenes by origin, but might claim to share Hellenic culture."
- ^ Sansone 2011, Chapter 11: "The Transformation of the Greek World in the Fourth Century" (Section: "Philip II of Macedon and the Conquest of Greece").
- ^ Malkin 2001, Chapter 6: Jonathan M. Hall, "Contested Ethnicities: Perceptions of Macedonia within Evolving Definitions of Greek Identity", p. 172.
- Anson, Edward M. (1984). "The Meaning of the Term Macedones". Ancient World 10: 67–68.
- Badian, Ernst; Wallace, Robert W.; Harris, Edward Monroe (1996). Transitions to Empire: Essays in Greco-Roman History, 360-146 B.C. in Honor of E. Badian. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press. ISBN 0-80612-863-1.
- Baldry, H. C. (1959). Greek Literature for the Modern Reader. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.
- Barr-Sharrar, Beryl; Borza, Eugene N. (1982). Macedonia and Greece in Late Classical and Early Hellenistic Times. National Gallery of Art. ISBN 0-89468-005-6.
- Best, Jan; de Vries, Nanny (1989). Thracians and Mycenaeans: Proceedings of the Fourth International Congress of Thracology, Rotterdam, 24-26 September 1984. Leiden, The Netherlands: E.J. Brill. ISBN 90-04-08864-4.
- Boardman, John (1982). The Cambridge Ancient History - Volume 3, Part 1: The Prehistory of the Balkans and the Middle East and the Aegean World, Tenth to Eighth Centuries B.C.. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-22496-9.
- Borza, Eugene N. (1999). Before Alexander: Constructing Early Macedonia. Claremont, California: Regina Books. ISBN 0-941690-96-2.
- Borza, Eugene N. (1992). In the Shadow of Olympus: The Emergence of Macedon. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-00880-9.
- Borza, Eugene N. (1982). "Athenians, Macedonians and the Origins of the Macedonian Royal House". Studies in Attic Epigraphy, History and Topography 19.
- Brock, Roger; Hodkinson, Stephen (2000). Alternatives to Athens: Varieties of Political Organization and Community in Ancient Greece. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-815220-5.
- Bryant, Joseph M. (1996). Moral Codes and Social Structure in Ancient Greece: A Sociology of Greek Ethics from Homer to the Epicureans and Stoics. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press. ISBN 0-7914-3042-1.
- Butler, Margaret Erwin (2008). Of Swords and Strigils: Social Change in Ancient Macedon. Stanford, California: Stanford University.
- Castelnuovo, Luisa Moscati (2002). Identità e Prassi Storica nel Mediterraneo Greco. Milan, Italy: Et. ISBN 88-86752-20-2.
- Cawkwell, George (1978). Philip of Macedon. London, United Kingdom: Faber & Faber. ISBN 0-571-10958-6.
- Chamoux, François (2002). Hellenistic Civilization. Oxford, United Kingdom: Blackwell Publishing. ISBN 0-631-22241-3.
- Christidēs, Anastasios-Phoivos; Arapopoulou, Maria; Chritē, Maria (2007). A History of Ancient Greek: From the Beginnings to Late Antiquity. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-83307-8.
- Cook, Stanley Arthur; Adcock, Frank E.; Charlesworth, Martin Percival, eds. (1928). The Cambridge Ancient History: The Hellenistic Monarchies and the Rise of Rome VII. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press.
- Crossland, R. A.; Birchall, Ann (1974). Bronze Age Migrations in the Aegean: Archaeological and Linguistic Problems in Greek Prehistory. Park Ridge, New Jersey: Noyes Press. ISBN 0-8155-5022-7.
- Danforth, Loring M. (1997). The Macedonian Conflict: Ethnic Nationalism in a Transnational World. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-04356-6.
- Dunstan, William E. (2000). Ancient Greece. Fort Worth, Texas: Harcourt College Publishers. ISBN 0-15-507383-4.
- Errington, Robert Malcolm (1990). A History of Macedonia. Berkeley and Los Angeles, California: University of California Press. ISBN 0-520-06319-8.
- Fine, John Van Antwerp (1983). The Ancient Greeks: A Critical History. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-03314-0.
- Finkelberg, Margalit (2005). Greeks and Pre-Greeks: Aegean Prehistory and Greek Heroic Tradition. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-85216-1.
- Fisher, Nicholas Ralph Edmund; Wees, Hans van, eds. (1998). Archaic Greece: New Approaches and New Evidence. London, United Kingdom: Duckworth. ISBN 0-7156-2809-7.
- Garrett, Andrew (1999). "A New Model of Indo-European Subgrouping and Dispersal". Berkeley Linguistics Society 25: 146–156.
- Georgiev, Vladimir Ivanov (1981). Introduction to the History of the Indo-European Languages. Sofia, Bulgaria: Publishing House of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences.
- Green, Peter (1992). Alexander of Macedon 356-323 B.C.: A Historical Biography. Berkeley and Los Angeles, California: University of California Press. ISBN 0-520-07166-2.
- Hall, Jonathan M. (2002). Hellenicity: Between Ethnicity and Culture. Chicago, Illinois and London, United Kingdom: The University of Chicago Press. ISBN 0-226-31329-8.
- Hall, Jonathan M. (2000). Ethnic Identity in Greek Antiquity. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-78999-0.
- Hamilton, J. R. (1974) [1973]. Alexander the Great. Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania: University of Pittsburgh Press. ISBN 0-8229-6084-2.
- Hammond, Nicholas Geoffrey Lemprière (2001). Collected Studies: Further Studies on Various Topics. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Hakkert.
- Hammond, Nicholas Geoffrey Lemprière (1993). Studies concerning Epirus and Macedonia before Alexander. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: Hakkert.
- Hammond, Nicholas Geoffrey Lemprière (1989). The Macedonian State: Origins, Institutions, and History. Oxford, United Kingdom: Clarendon Press. ISBN 0-19-814883-6.
- Hammond, Nicholas Geoffrey Lemprière; Griffith, Guy Thompson (1979). A History of Macedonia: 550-336 B.C. II. Oxford, United Kingdom: Clarendon Press. ISBN 0-19-814814-3.
- Hammond, Nicholas Geoffrey Lemprière; Griffith, Guy Thompson (1972). A History of Macedonia: Historical Geography and Prehistory I. Oxford, United Kingdom: Clarendon Press.
- Hatzopoulos, Miltiades (2002). "Perception of the Self and the Other: The Case of Macedon". Proceedings of the Seventh International Symposion on Ancient Macedonia.
- Hatzopoulos, Miltiades (1999). "The Speech of the Ancient Macedonians, in the Light of Recent Epigraphic Discoveries". Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposion on Ancient Macedonia.
- Horejs, Barbara (3 October 2007). "The Phenomenon of Mattpainted Pottery in the Northern Aegean: Introduction, Overview and Theories". Aegeo-Balkan Prehistory.
- Hornblower, Simon; Matthews, Elaine; Fraser, Peter Marshall (2000). Greek Personal Names: Their Value as Evidence. Published for the British Academy by Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-726216-3.
- Iordanidis, A.; Garcia-Guinea, J.; Karamitrou-Mentessidi, Georgia (May 2007). "Characterisation of Mycenaean and Matt-Painted Pottery from Aiani, Ancient Upper Macedonia, Greece" (PDF). Bulletin of the Geological Society of Greece (Athens, Greece: Proceedings of the 11th International Congress) 40: 1796–1807.
- Isaac, Benjamin H. (2004). The Invention of Racism in Classical Antiquity. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press. ISBN 0-691-12598-8.
- Joint Association of Classical Teachers (1984). The World of Athens: An Introduction to Classical Athenian Culture. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-27389-7.
- Jones, Archer (2001). The Art of War in the Western World. Champaign, Illinois: University of Illinois Press. ISBN 0-252-06966-8.
- Karamitrou-Mentessidi, Georgia (16 March 2007). "The Late Bronze Age in Aiani". Aegeo-Balkan Prehistory.
- Kinzl, Konrad H. (2010). A Companion to the Classical Greek World. West Sussex, United Kingdom: John Wiley and Sons Limited. ISBN 1-4443-3412-3.
- Kristinsson, Axel (2010). Expansions: Competition and Conquest in Europe since the Bronze Age. Reykjavík, Iceland: ReykjavíkurAkademían. ISBN 9979-9922-1-2.
- Lemos, Irene S. (2002). The Protogeometric Aegean: The Archaeology of the Late Eleventh and Tenth Centuries BC. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-925344-7.
- Malkin, Irad (1998). The Returns of Odysseus: Colonization and Ethnicity. Berkeley and Los Angeles, California: University of California Press. ISBN 978-0-520-21185-8.
- Malkin, Irad (2001). Ancient Perceptions of Greek Ethnicity. Center for Hellenic Studies, Trustees for Harvard University. ISBN 0-674-00662-3.
- Masson, Olivier; Dubois, Laurent (2000). Onomastica Graeca Selecta. Geneva, Switzerland: Librairie Droz. ISBN 2-600-00435-1.
- Masson, Olivier (1996). Oxford Classical Dictionary. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.
- O'Brien, John Maxwell (1994) [1992]. Alexander the Great: The Invisible Enemy - A Biography. New York, New York and London, United Kingdom: Routledge (Taylor & Francis). ISBN 0-415-10617-6.
- Osborne, Robin (2004). Greek History. New York, New York and London, United Kingdom: Routledge. ISBN 0-415-31717-7.
- Papazoglou, Fanoula (2000). "Le Language Macėdoniene Antique". Juznosolvenski Filolog 56 (3-4): 771–777.
- Papazoglou, Fanoula (1977). "Sur le Structure Ethnique de l'Ancienne Macedonie". Balcanica 8: 65–82.
- Perlman, Samuel (1973). Philip and Athens. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Heffer. ISBN 0-85270-076-8.
- Roisman, Joseph; Worthington, Ian (2010). A Companion to Ancient Macedonia. John Wiley and Sons. ISBN 1-4051-7936-8.
- Sakellariou, M. V. (1992). Macedonia, 4000 years of Greek History and Civilization. Athens, Greece: Ekdotikè Athenon.
- Sansone, David (2011). Ancient Greek Civilization. Wiley-Blackwell. ISBN 978-1-4443-5877-3.
- Snodgrass, Anthony M. (2000). The Dark Age of Greece: An Archaeological Survey of the Eleventh to the Eighth Centuries BC. New York, New York: Routledge. ISBN 0-415-93635-7.
- Starr, Chester G. (1991). A History of the Ancient World. New York, New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-506628-6.
- Theodossiev, Nikola (May 2000). "The Dead with Golden Faces. II Other Evidence and Connections". Oxford Journal of Archaeology 19 (2): 175–209. doi:10.1111/1468-0092.00106.
- Toynbee, Arnold Joseph (1969). Some Problems of Greek History. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.
- Toynbee, Arnold Joseph (1981). The Greeks and Their Heritages. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press.
- Trudgill, Peter (2002). Sociolinguistic Variation and Change. Edinburgh, United Kingdom: Edinburgh University Press. ISBN 0-7486-1515-6.
- Vanderpool, Eugene (1982). Studies in Attic Epigraphy, History, and Topography. Princeton, New Jersey: American School of Classical Studies at Athens. ISBN 0-87661-519-1.
- Voutiras, Emmanuel (1998). ΔΙΟΝΥΣΟΦΩΝΤΟΣ ΓΑΜΟΙ: Marital Life and Magic in Fourth Century Pella. Amsterdam, The Netherlands: J. C. Gieben. ISBN 90-5063-407-9.
- Whitley, James (2007). The Archaeology of Ancient Greece. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-62733-8.
- Wilkes, John J. (1995). The Illyrians. Oxford, United Kingdom: Blackwell Publishing. ISBN 0-631-19807-5.
- Woodard, Roger D. (2008a). The Ancient Languages of Asia Minor. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-68496-X.
- Woodard, Roger D. (2008b). The Ancient Languages of Europe. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-68495-1.
- Worthington, Ian (2003). Alexander the Great: A Reader. London, United Kingdom: Routledge. ISBN 978-0-41-529187-3.
- Worthington, Ian (2008). Philip II of Macedonia. New Haven, Connecticut: Yale University Press. ISBN 0-300-12079-6.
- Zacharia, Katerina (2008). Hellenisms: Culture, Identity, and Ethnicity from Antiquity to Modernity. Hampshire, England: Ashgate Publishing Limited. ISBN 978-0-75-466525-0.
Further reading[edit]
- Hammond, Nicholas Geoffrey Lemprière; Walbank, Frank William (1988). A History of Macedonia: 336-167 B.C. III. Oxford, United Kingdom: Oxford University Press. ISBN 0-19-814815-1.
External links[edit]
- Ancient Macedonia at Livius Ancient History'
- Demetrius C. Evangelides – "The Yaunã Takabara and the Ancient Macedonians"
- Heracles to Alexander The Great: Treasures From The Royal Capital of Macedon, A Hellenic Kingdom in the Age of Democracy (Ashmolean Museum of Art and Archaeology, University of Oxford)
- Twilight of the Polis and the rise of Macedon (Philip, Demosthenes and the Fall of the Polis). Yale University Courses, Lecture 24. (Introduction to Ancient Greek History)


text:
COLUMBIA STATION -- This isn't the first time Sam Mazzola has been in hot water about his exotic animals, but according to the Division of Wildlife and the Ohio Department of Agriculture, he has a right to own the animals as long as he does not exhibit them.
Mazzola, 48, 9978 N. Marks Road, Columbia Station, is the owner of the bear that attacked and killed Brent Kandra, 24, of Elyria, on Thursday night. As a result of the attack, the Lorain County Sheriff's Office said Mazzola has voluntarily decided to euthanize the bear.
For roughly 25 years, Mazzola was known for taking his bear, Caesar, to county fairs, bars and other venues and giving people the opportunity to wrestle it. He also displayed a tiger that people could pose with in pictures.
In 2008, Mazzola was stripped of his federal license to exhibit his exotic animals after People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals filed several complaints against him to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. PETA has reported that Mazzola is the owner of tigers, lions, caracals, bears, ocelots, a cougar, a leopard, foxes and lemurs and he is a repeat violator of the Animal Welfare Act. He was also fined $13,950 in 2008 by the USDA for exhibiting the bear-wrestling act without a license, refusing to allow an inspection of his exhibit, illegally selling skunks at his Elyria store Animal Zone and threatening federal officials.
"It's no surprise to PETA that someone has been killed by a bear at Mazzola's facility," said Lisa Wathne, captive exotic animal specialist for PETA. "What's shocking is that it didn't happen sooner."
Mazzola has a long history with PETA, dating back to 1983 when a bear caused damage to a North Royalton police cruiser, Wathne said. The organization filed complaints when it found out he was allowing people to wrestle the bears and get dangerously close to his tigers.
"It's my understanding that this young man (Brent Kandra) was one of the caretakers and this bear was out of its cage being fed and attacked this young man," Wathne said. "If that's the case, no one should be surprised when a wild animal attacks a human. And any time you have someone like Sam Mazzola acting so irresponsibly allowing that kind of contact, you're going to have these accidents."
The Ohio Division of Wildlife confirmed Mazzola was permitted to own animals native to Ohio on his Marks Road property. The department does not have the authority to certify species coming into the state that are not native to Ohio, rather that falls under the Ohio Department of Agriculture. The ODA looks to make sure the animals do not carry disease, and from there, the Lorain County Sheriff's Office is responsible for making sure Mazzola complies.
"His (Ohio) permit through us covers nine black bears, three raccoons, three coyotes, two red foxes and one skunk," said Division of Wildlife spokeswoman Jamey Graham. "It was updated in February of this year. We haven't had any problems with him before."
Kaleigh Frazier, spokeswoman from the ODA, said, "If an animal is imported to the state from an outside location, it has to be accompanied by a certificate of inspection (for disease) and a permit number from the U.S. Department of Agriculture. If they move the animal to another state, the process starts over again."
Columbia Township Trustee Mike Musto said as far as he knows there haven't been any complaints about smell, noise or otherwise concerning Mazzola's Marks Road property. Even when talking with the zoning department, Musto learned that no one has said anything about Mazzola for several years. However, 12 years ago, the township did try to have the bears removed, but was unsuccessful.
"It falls under the state agricultural department and he does have a permit (to own them)," Musto said. "We tried to take him to court, but we were told there was nothing we could. The Lorain County sheriff now has the ball, and you know, what a tragedy," said Musto. "Hopefully something can be done. I'm very sorry for the family."
Wathne said PETA wants the best for all the animals and hopes they will be taken from Mazzola and put in a sanctuary or reputable zoo. She said they have been treated cruelly for too long.
"We did get reports from people who witnessed the bear wrestling competitions who said the bear was punched and kicked," Wathne said. "One person said the tiger being used for photos was hit over the head with a wooden bat. And any time wild animals are kept in captivity, the very nature of captivity is cruel. They're deprived of their natural habitat, have small cages and his animals were subjected to traveling."
Mazzola also has prior convictions of trafficking cocaine, owning a .45 caliber handgun under disability, housing his animals in cages that were too small and was sued in 2008 by Centro Midway, owners of the Midway Mall, for rent and utilities for Animal Zone. His store has since closed
Several calls to Mazzola were not returned last night and calls to Mazzola's mother and friend were also not returned.

subset: commoncrawl


text:
Suitable from 6 months+
The Baby Weavers Walk'n'Rock Easily converts from a walker to a rocker in a few seconds, it has a softly padded seat with backrest, A detachable musical electronic activity tray is included for baby's entertainment, it is also height adjustable and it has a comfy padded footrest for when it is used in the rocker mode.
This item may not be suitable for use on all floor surfaces, flooring such as carpet may restrict the wheel movement.
The Baby Weavers range pride itself on its great quality at an affordable price; completely exclusive to Kiddicare.com, the range now consists of pushchairs, prams, furniture, bedding and the famous nursery chair products.
Good product, would definitely recommend, the toy tray is detachable so baby can play with it else where. It looks good and my baby loves sitting in it. Although it would be perfect if it had an extra height adjustment as my 6 month old is a little too short to touch the floor yet. The rocker part comes in handy too.
bright and colurful comfortable for child to sit in with the back supported overall excellent buy. quick delivery very good service.
excellent item. ticks all the boxes.
Fab product my little one is enjoying playing In it. Lots of entertainment on the front to keep her happy.
Granddaughter absolutely loves this walker, it is brightly coloured and has toys that spin round and some that make noises which all keep her entertained. It is very sturdy and good quality. It can also quite easily be turned into a rocker, which again my granddaughter loves. All in all a great buy
These are exclusive customer reviews unless otherwise stated. Specifications of goods are subject to change.
Click for audio and text help.
Click for audio and text help.
Click for audio and text help.
Click for audio and text help.
This product is available as a pre-order. This means that we do not currently have the item in stock but we are expecting it shortly. You can place an order for this product now your expected shipping date will be 30-12-2011
A place where people come together to discuss our products and services, ask questions and seek advice.
to be a part of it.
©Kiddicare 2013


text:
Malcolm X details
Formats: | 15 DVD, Blu-ray |
Starring: | Al Freeman Jr., Denzel Washington, Albert Hall, Spike Lee, Angela Bassett, Delroy Lindo, Annie Corley |
Director: | Spike Lee |
Genre: | Drama |
Studio: | WARNER BROS. PICTURES |
Name | Discs | |
Malcolm X |
15 Feature |
DVD Information
Run time: | 3 hours 13 minutes |
Rental release: | 14 May 2012 |
Main languages: | English |
Hearing impaired subtitles: | English |
Most helpful review
spike lee at his best
By Qaes Mujawar from london , 12 Jul 2004[Highly rated reviewer]
if you like spike lee movies, youll love this. this film tells us about the life of malcom x, from when he was a street gangsta going to prison and converting to islam through the following of blacks rights movement of the nation of islam. this is definatly denzel at his finest.
although the film is a bit long it is thoroughly absorbing.- Was this review helpful to you?
- (11) Yes |
- No (2)
All reviews
(86)Could have been better
By veganjodie (18 reviews) from Coventry , 20 Oct 2013This could have been an amazing film, given the fascinating subject matter, but unfortunately it was too long, dragged on and I became bored. Usually Denzel Washington is superb but here he is a real let down.- Was this review helpful to you?
- (0) Yes |
- No (0)
Courageous and true.
By a customer , 17 Aug 2013Wow, what a powerful and moving film of real history. Life can take many changes and no-one can ever predict how your own life will turn out. Definately one for your rental list.- Was this review helpful to you?
- (0) Yes |
- No (0)
great turn by Denzel but way too long
By davidginsberg (114 reviews) from London , 04 Feb 2013I decided to eschew the delights of Russia v Czechs for this Spike Lee joint starring the worlds best actor Denzel! This is a very strange movie indeed, you would struggle to get something like this made today. Malcom Xs story is a very interesting one, father murdered, mother sectioned, he was bright but channelled into menial jobs, he becomes a criminal, goes to prison, converts to Islam and becomes an incendiary black rights advocate, falls out with the corrupt organisation he belongs to and is assassinated by his ex colleagues. Its a great story to tell and Denzel is brilliant, he totally convinces as Malcolm X and this is key to the movie as you need to buy in to his transformation and the effect he has on people. Obviously with Spike Lee there are some great visual flourishes, the opening scene with Spike himself striding through the streets is amazing, lots of use of colours to denote shifts in tone, lots to appreciate on screen. However there is a lot wrong with the movie, it is way too long, you could have trimmed the run time by half an hour easily. The sequence before he goes to prison is far too long, the flashbacks to his fathers murder too frequent, to run up to the assassination gets really tedious which is a mistake as the actual scene itself is very powerful. You also have cringeworthy coda at the end with school kids and then Mandela turns up in a funky shirt. Very messy which is a shame as at heart this is a really good biopic certainly superior to other political biopics like the dreadful Milk. This is a case where I would like to see someone re-cut the film as it could be a lot better- Was this review helpful to you?
- (0) Yes |
- No (0)
not x- citing
By chasckd (575 reviews) from Telford , 14 Nov 2012pretty slow and boring in parts even predictable maybe some would say but not too bad entertaing wise for a oldish film- Was this review helpful to you?
- (0) Yes |
- No (0)
History of X .. Hmm.
By Platospupil (206 reviews) , 10 Aug 2012I found this strange history. As a young man growing up in the 60s I knew the fearsome reputation of MX but many parts of this film were a revelation. Well acted with a sumptuous colour palette, the film tries to navigate between honour, veneration and something more realist. The fact that it fails to hold this balance is in part due to the three ill-disciplined hours it takes to tell the story. Narration moves around and so does focus.
The final segment does not convince me, no matter who is the source. This is not the story of a great man but it certainly would make an interesting 90 minute bio of a troubled one.- Was this review helpful to you?
- (0) Yes |
- No (0)


text:
950 grams of assorted colour jelly beans packed in 1 Litre Drum. Combination of Green, Red, Orange, White, Yellow, Black, Pink, & Blue. Statutory information sheet included. Finished weight = 1.10 kilos., PACKAGING DETAILS White Gift Box. Carton weights vary according to quantity & maximum lifting weights. Multiply above individual weights by quantity as a guide.
Custom Gear has won national recognition and media attention for selling promotional items for up to 20% less than other suppliers.
We offer free quotes and friendly advice on all the products we carry.
We cannot be beaten!
Call 1300 CG PROMO now
Can't find EXACTLY what you are looking for? We have thousands of promotional products online although we have many more offline.
We are confident we can find the merchandise that will meet your needs, even if it means creating something personalised from scratch.
Custom Gear will IMPRESS YOUR BRAND
145H x 100 Diameter.
Standard Label - Up to 70 Diameter., Deluxe Label - 70 Diameter (Die cut to any shape)
4 Colour Process Standard or Deluxe Label
Complete the form below to email a link of this product to someone who may be interested


text:
CHEF JEFF — ONE BYTE AT A TIME: Shrimp and Polenta
This Mediterranean fave goes nicely with seafood.By: Herald Staff Report,
This Mediterranean fave goes nicely with seafood.
Shrimp and Polenta
1 cup diced asparagus
2/3 pound raw shrimp, peeled, deveined, with tails for dipping
1½ cups prepared polenta
2 tablespoons olive oil
2 to 4 tablespoons hot water
1 cup cherry tomatoes, quartered
½ cup Parmesan cheese, grated
1 teaspoon chili powder
Tabasco, lemon wedge
Prepare grill or broiler for medium-high heat. Heat saucepan of water over high heat; add asparagus. Cook until just tender. Drain. Grill shrimp until pink. Set aside. Mix polenta, olive oil and 2 tablespoons of hot water in saucepan until polenta is smooth and soft; add more water if necessary. Stir in tomatoes and ¼ cup of Parmesan. Heat, stirring occasionally, until warm. Add asparagus; heat until mixture is warm and cheese melts. Mound polenta in center of 2 plates; sprinkle each with chili powder, remaining Parmesan and Tabasco. Put shrimp on edge of plates; squeeze lemon over them.
Yield: Serves 2.
Grab more food tidbits at the Chef Jeff blog at GrandForksHerald.com.
Tags: daily updates, chef jeff, jeff tiedeman, one byte at a time, life, food, recipes


text:
Already a member?
You can't like your own messages.
Option trading involves substantial risk and is not suitable for all investors. I cannot and will not guarantee that you will not lose money or that you will make money from the information found on this website and/or affiliated products/services.
Follow investors and traders that match your style and get a personalized stream of news, charts, and ideas.
I read & accept the StockTwits Terms of Service
Remember me
Forgot password?


text:
Note: This message is displayed if (1) your browser is not standards-compliant or (2) you have you disabled CSS. Read our Policies for more information.
Synopsis: Vehicle bill.
Effective: August 1, 1997.
May 14, 1997, read first time and referred to Committee on Rules and Legislative Procedure.
A BILL FOR AN ACT to amend the Indiana Code concerning taxation.
SECTION 1. [EFFECTIVE AUGUST 1, 1997] IC 6 is amended concerning taxation.
The Indiana Code is organized by Title, Article, Chapter, and Section. Enter the numbers of the code cite you would like to view in the corresponding boxes.
(Only the Title Box must be filled).
Keyword Search


text:
Mary Gail Roberts, age 53, of Lyttleton, passed away Tuesday at the Memorial Hospital.
Funeral services for Mary Gail Roberts were held Friday at 1:00 PM at the Britton Funeral Home Chapel with Joey Burns officiating. Burial followed at the Hounchell Bend Cemetery.
Last Updated on Wednesday, 29 December 2010 15:43
Imogene Johnson Departed this world on December 26, 2010 at the Manchester Memorial Hospital at 53 years of age.
Imogene was born on March 8, 1957 to the late Golden and Emma Johnson.
She leaves surviving 4 brother: AB Johnson and wife Darlene, Preston Johnson and wife Bertha, Dan Johnson and wife Thelma, Golden Johnson Jr. and one sister Julia Ann Allen.
Imogene was a member of the Morgan Branch Pentecostal Church.
She was proceeded in death by her parents Golden and Emma Johnson and one brother JB Johnson.
Imogene leaves behind a host of nieces and nephews and lots of friends to morn her death.....
Funeral services for Imogene Allen with be held Wednesday at 11:00 A.M. at the Britton Funeral Home Chapel with Roy Allen and Tim Reid officiating. Burial will follow at the Lower Saddler Cemetary at Teges.
Visitation will be after 6:00 P.M. Tuesday at the Britton Funeral Home.
Last Updated on Wednesday, 29 December 2010 15:41
Ida Malinda Harris (6/30/56 – 12/26/2010). Malinda was born in Manchester, KY. and resided in Poland, IN. with her beloved husband and soulmate of 37 years, Stanley Harris.
We lost her unexpectedly at 5:00 PM Sunday at United Methodist Hospital in Indianapolis, IN. She also leaves behind her parents Ishmael and Ethel Hibbard of Manchester. Her brothers and spouses: Ishmael Wayne Hibbard and Judy, James Lee and Teresa Hibbard, and sister Malinda Marie Hibbard all of Manchester, and sister and spouse: Earlene and Gary Koska of Springville, IN., in addition to many nieces and nephews who loved her dearly.
Malinda will be sadly missed by her family and many friends. She will go to meet her heavenly Father at her final resting place at Paces Creek Cemetery where graveside services will be provided by Reverend Curtis Wagers on Thursday at 2 PM. All friends and family are welcome to attend.
Last Updated on Wednesday, 29 December 2010 15:39
See the countless Christmas trees around the world below with the snow.
the sight is so spectacular. Please wipe away that fear for I am spending Christmas with Jesus this year.
Last Updated on Wednesday, 22 December 2010 19:00
Belva (DePew) Foster, a remarkable spirit, was called to Heaven, on Dec. 5, 2010 at the precious age of 101; truly a wonderful life to be celebrated. She was the oldest of 9 children, born March 29, 1909 in Manchester, KY to Burley and Laura (Bowling) DePew.
Last Updated on Wednesday, 22 December 2010 19:01
Page 207 of 217


text:
Third Wheel Cami
Insight is a youth lifestyle clothing brand that injects art driven, fashion forward product into a network of urban fashion and actions-sports retailers globally. The design philosophy draws its inspiration from high end fashion, yet is adapted and interpreted into a more casual, carefree style. Insight product strikes the perfect balance by offering directional fashion forward clothing in a commercially viable manner.
- 100% rayon
- Adjustable shoulder straps
- Tiered layers
- Styled with Insight Summer Rose Culottes in Mustard Yellow.
- Modeled in size 4/S. See fit guide for model's dimensions.
- Revolve Style No. INSI-WS180
- Manufacturer Style No. 291201B


text:
Having to contact your website designer to change a sentence can be frustrating. A CMS gives you the ability to do it yourself.
If you plan to update your website frequently with news, new products, and specials, a CMS can save you time and money. At Rival we offer an array of CMS to allow you to update your website content from home in a way that's easy to use and custom-built for your business.
What we offer:
- Easy to use Content Management Systems
- Paid and Open Source Solutions
- WordPress, RefineryCMS
- Custom built CMS Solutions
- Training on how to use your CMS it to its full potential.
For more information on Content Management Systems, contact Rival.


text:
View Authentic Collection
At the heart of British youth culture for over 60 years
View Laurel Wreath Collection
Designed collectables, inspired by heritage
Email to a Friend
Rich leather smartphone case - compatible with iPhone 5 - featuring a classic tartan print on the inside and cut outs for the screen, speaker and camera. Complete with our signature Laurel Wreath embossed on the back.
* Required Fields
Now $101.50
I would like to ship to
* Please select a country
Online shop options
US Dollar


text: Find hotels in Lexington using the list and search tools below. Search for cheap and discounted hotel and motel rates in or close to Lexington, KY for your upcoming personal or group trip. We show the best Lexington Kentucky hotel/motel rooms. Review the Lexington hotel list below to find the perfect lodging. We also have a map of the Lexington hotels. Booking 5+ Rooms? Find Lexington Group Hotel Rates or Book a Lexington Meeting


text:
Hehe thats why i remembered to post that picture now.
I found a DVD of it that must collect half of the series or something in some music store, very cheaply must be second. I couldnt believe my luck, i will enjoy it in few days after im done with essay writing
Interesting the series was the first of it kinds and used Superman abilities that has not been written in the comic book version yet. According to IMDB review.
Pull List:
The Walking Dead,Fatale,Near Death,Storm Dogs,Happy,BPRD,XO-Manowar
American Vampire,Animal Man,Swamp Thing
Daredevil, Winter Soldier,Indestructible Hulk
A robotic journey toward the American Dream: MADE in USA.
Really? I hope not, that would be quite the sad news. That iconic pose has gone through so many artists I feel bad for anyone who thinks its just Lee's creation.
I have to say when Superman showed up in this one made me smile.
Even shows shows a little of Supermans intelligence which is pretty awesome because it shows how a like they are, then different with their personalities. Amazing art as well.
The undies shouldve stayed in my opinion, they look cool in a rather odd way. Not that the update look isnt growing on me, but for a man whos suppose to be alien and the face of Superheros, it works. If only for him.
In my opinion Kal-El / Clark Kent / Superman is the greatest superhero of all time.
Check this out.
A robotic journey toward the American Dream: MADE in USA.