text:
Closing the gap The link between project management excellence and long-term success
- Hubert Fitzgerald
- 2 years ago
- Views:
1 The link between project management excellence A report from the Economist Intelligence Unit Sponsored by Oracle
2 Preface Closing the gap: is an Economist Intelligence Unit briefing paper, sponsored by Oracle. The Economist Intelligence Unit conducted the survey and analysis, and wrote the report. The findings and views expressed in the report do not necessarily reflect the views of the sponsor. The report was based on a survey of 21 senior executives and project managers worldwide and in-depth interviews with nine executives and project management experts in the fields of industrial manufacturing; architecture, engineering and construction; aerospace and defence; mining and metals; pulp and paper; and utilities, oil and gas. The author was Sarah Fister Gale and the editor was Katherine Dorr Abreu. Mike Kenny was responsible for the design. The Economist Intelligence Unit would like to thank all those who contributed their time and insight to this project. October
3 Executive summary Delivering projects on time and on budget is a minimum requirement to do business for most organisations, and in many industries it is critical to long-term success. Companies that adhere to strong project management methods, including detailed evaluation of scope and budget, ongoing risk management and measurement of project results, are consistently more successful than those that do not. Following a structured project management method enables companies to predict and mitigate risks, better manage costs and deliver quality results that satisfy clients. In the most mature project management organisations, these project goals are directly linked to strategic business objectives, giving these organisations a powerful competitive advantage. Yet few companies consistently meet their project goals or measure project success. This inconsistency stems largely from a failure to implement and follow well-defined project management practices, despite ongoing efforts to improve processes with the goal of delivering better, faster, cheaper results. This report explores the value that executives and project managers place on adhering to strong project management methods, how those methods are practised across the organisation, and the gaps that exist between the perceived value of project management strategies and their consistent application on the job. Key findings include: Project management competencies are considered crucial to the business, yet few companies do project management well or have consistent processes in place. An impressive 90% of respondents say project management is either critical (47%) or somewhat important (4%) to their ability to deliver successful projects and remain competitive. Yet nearly one-half (49%) only follow formal project management practices on large or complex projects and few (20%) use a standardised set of project management tools including enterprise-level systems. Eighty percent of survey respondents believe that having project management as a core competency has helped their company to remain competitive during the current economic downturn. Yet only 27% say they do a very good job of managing projects, and only 10% rate themselves as excellent. Their selfassessment may not be excessively harsh: only % of respondents say their projects come in on time and on budget all of the time. 2
4 Aware of their shortcomings, companies are trying to do better, but they struggle to find the best ways to address the challenge. More than one-half of respondents (5%) say their company is continually looking to improve its project management methods, but they lack focus and consistency. Only 45% plan to improve project management practices and apply them uniformly across all projects, and 42% plan to standardise the use of project management tools to increase efficiency and collaboration. Less than one-third (29%) plan to improve how they measure qualitative and quantitative project outcomes; 29% plan to use more robust tools; and only 2% plan to increase training and certification. These numbers indicate that managers may not be adequately adopting methodologies that can help them improve results. The recession may help make project management practices more robust. The economic crisis has led to greater scrutiny of how projects are managed, and has directly affected company perceptions of the value of project management competencies. This change in focus has, in turn, led to a more structured and consistent application of project management practices across industries over the last two years. Compared with two years ago, respondents are investing more time in project planning and due diligence (40%); conducting more frequent project reviews to assess risks, milestones and overall value (7%); and measuring quantitative and qualitative project outcomes more frequently (8%). It remains to be seen whether this commitment will hold strong as the economy improves. Who took the survey? A total of 21 senior executives and project management experts from around the world took the online survey. Twenty-three percent are in industrial manufacturing; 22% in architecture, engineering and construction; 19% in utilities, oil and gas; 1% in chemicals; 9% in aerospace and defence; and 10% in mining and metals and pulp and paper. Thirty-seven percent are C-level executives, 2% are senior vice presidents, directors or business unit heads, and 7% are in other management roles. Company size ranges from less than US$500m in annual revenue (2% of total) to US$100bn or more (%). Thirteen percent have revenue of US$500m to US$1bn, and 49% range from US$1bn to US$100bn. For further information, see the appendix at the end of this report. Survey polled project-intensive industries What is your industry? Industrial manufacturing 2 Architecture, Engineering and Construction 22 Utilities, Oil and Gas 19 Chemicals 1 Aerospace and Defence 9 Mining and Metals 8 Pulp and Paper 1 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September 2009
5 Introduction Without question, executives recognise the value of delivering projects on time, on budget and to the customer s expectations. A straight line can be drawn between successful project outcomes and bottom-line growth. Yet companies do not consistently deliver quality projects within the timeframe and scope allotted to them. The economy has only made things worse. Budgets have shrunk, and project managers are under increasing pressure to cut costs and deliver projects that are of a higher quality and completed more quickly than ever before. But without the necessary structure, resources and tools, these goals are difficult to meet. Project management practices are designed to prevent such failures. In times of economic crisis they are particularly important to give companies strategies to mitigate risk, define budgets and scope more effectively, and track a project s progress. Yet even in an economy in which any bad project can significantly hurt an organisation, there continues to be a gap between project management philosophy and execution. Although many executives and project managers say that their organisations have strong project management strategies and that using those strategies provides them with a clear and measurable competitive advantage, most admit that they do not adhere to them consistently. Until that gap is closed, project success will continue to be a daunting task. 4
6 No nasty surprises There are risks associated with [project management]. It s important to identify those risks early on and manage them through every phase of the project so there are no surprises. Ajay Malhan, senior vicepresident of project and development services, Jones Lang LaSalle India Risk management is at the heart of every project management methodology. Any number of risks can befall a project and drive it off course, often through no fault of the project team. From hurricanes and political unrest to supplier conflicts and labour shortages, internal and external events can have a significant impact on a project s progress. Only through good risk management can those risks be predicted and minimised, suggests Ajay Malhan, senior vice-president of project and development services for Jones Lang LaSalle, the global real estate services firm. Mr Malhan is based in Delhi, India. Good project management is about managing the schedule, budget, quality and safety on a project, and there are risks associated with all of that, he says. It s important to identify those risks early on and manage them through every phase of the project so there are no surprises. Yet risk management can also be the most elusive element of project success, particularly if project managers do not have the time or decision-making authority to perform the task well. When it comes to risk management, there is a clear gap in many organisations between what their leaders say and what they do. In our survey, 48% of respondents say that adhering to project management practices helps them better manage project risks, yet only 2% evaluate how effectively they have identified and managed risks, as part of their project review process. Many poor-performing companies don t have any formal risk management process, notes Bob Prieto, senior vice-president of Fluor Corporation, a publicly owned global engineering, procurement, There is a gap between perceived benefits of adhering to project management practices and measurements of project success Benefit Measurement Better management of project risk and scope creep Evaluation of how effectively organisation identifies and manages risk 2 48 Meet or exceed client and stakeholder expectations Interviews with clients and stakeholders about their satisfaction with project outcomes 25 0 Delivery of projects on time Delivery of projects within defined budget 50 0 Determination of whether project came in on time and on budget 7 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September
7 CASE STUDY Defining success: project management in space It is hard enough to define the scope of a multibillion-dollar multiyear project. When the project being defined has never been done before, it is nearly impossible. But it still needs to be done, says Wayne Hale. As the deputy associate administrator for strategic partnerships at NASA, the US space agency, he should know: Mr Hale has been involved with creating project plans for some of the greatest projects in history, including the Hubble Telescope and the Space Shuttle. And he readily admits that in both cases those projects came in well over budget and did not exactly meet the target goals. Still, he considers them successes. The Hubble Telescope illustrates the challenges. After years of starts and stops, budget cuts and delays, it was finally launched into orbit in 1990, 1 years after Congress voted to fund the project, and five years after construction was complete. Then, days after the launch, the NASA team realised there was a problem. The images came back blurry because of a flaw in the telescope s mirror it was too flat on one edge by a few nanometres. There was a lot of dump it in the ocean talk at that point, Mr Hale says. But instead we decided to spend more money to fix the problem, and eventually it was a success. Looking beyond budget and schedule to consider the potential results of the project gave the Hubble team the momentum needed to take the project to fruition. Because NASA continued to invest in the project, even though it was years late and well over budget, the US has gathered images and knowledge about space that it could not have obtained any other way. Do I wish we had done it cheaper and sooner? Sure, Mr Hale says. But in the final analysis success and failure are not always so cut-and-dried. construction and maintenance services firm based in Irving, Texas. They may discuss risk, but it s more about contingency planning, he says. The risk process often is only looked at when problems occur. This is a mistake. If project managers are rushed through due diligence, not given the time and tools to accurately assess potential risks or the organisation does not place value on the risk management process, project managers are forced into the role of firefighters, responding to problems as they arise rather than mitigating or avoiding them. These firefighters step into a trap, says Tom Bourgeois, chief project engineer for Shell International, the multinational petroleum company headquartered in The Hague, Netherlands. They are forced to spend valuable time reacting to problems, which diminishes the focus on project deliverables, Few companies deliver all projects on time and at or under budget (% of respondents who say their organisation delivers projects on time) 49 5 Frequency on time/at or under budget 100% 75% to 99% 50% to 74% 25% to 49% 0% to 24% Don t know/not Applicable (% of respondents who say their organisation delivers projects at or under budget) Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September 2009
8 You have to think about risk in a holistic sense. It has to be a constant process and you can t do it in isolation. Bob Prieto, senior vicepresident, Fluor Corporation and adds costs, delays and frustration to the project, contributing to the low rates of project success that plague many industries. In our survey, only % of companies say their projects come in on time and on budget all of the time. Organisations that implement a culture of project management that values risk assessment, meanwhile, are better equipped to manage risks and minimise their impact. An effective risk management programme has to be an ongoing part of the project, confirms Mr Prieto. At Fluor, every project includes a formal risk assessment tool. At each stage, project leaders are required to assess and reassess risks, and to decide whether to alter the project as a result. The process can take days or weeks depending on the size, scope and complexity of the initiative. You have to think about risk in a holistic sense, says Mr Prieto. It has to be a constant process and you can t do it in isolation. Organisations also need to reward the right behaviour, adds Robert Majure, senior programme manager of the aerospace core programme of Honeywell Aerospace in Phoenix, Arizona. Some organisations reward firefighters because they do a great job saving a programme. At Honeywell, we try to shift reward to people who stay out of trouble. Honeywell s efforts to promote this behaviour include its annual Top Gun programme management excellence award, which is given to the best project team each year based on value creation, organisational process and risk avoidance. The company also bases promotions, talent reviews and other incentive programmes on these metrics. It s a work in progress, but it is changing behaviour, says Mr Majure. CASE STUDY CH2M Hill: Project leadership is a top priority CH2M Hill has succeeded in making the connection between consistent project management practices and bottom-line results. The global provider of engineering, construction and operations services based in Englewood, Colorado considers itself a company of projects and project management decision-making is conducted at the highest level of the company. The interchangeable link between executives and project managers is one thing that makes CH2M Hill unique, notes Jacqueline Rast, president of the CH2M Hill Major Programs group. That connection is critical in a company that regularly manages highprofile multibillion-dollar mega projects because it ensures that the most skilled and experienced people in the organisation are making critical project decisions, increasing the commitment to its success. Ms Rast s group leads the organisation s major programmes, including management of the design and construction of the London 2012 Olympics venues and infrastructure, and the Panama Canal expansion. Both are slated to come in on budget, and several elements of the London Olympics project will be delivered early. In our industry, everything we do is about projects. We are only in business to deliver projects, and project manager is a critical position at CH2M Hill, she says. As a result, project managers are a part of strategic decisionmaking regarding projects before they are even bid, and executives from the board of directors and C-level regularly take on senior management positions on high-profile projects. In a recent notable example, Bob Card, president of the firm s facilities and infrastructure division, took a break from running the largest division in the company to pursue the London Olympics project, then moved his family to the UK to oversee the multi-year project once it began. CH2M Hill attributes much of its success in winning and managing such mega projects to the authority and experience of its project leaders. They have the experience and the decision-making power required to drive these projects towards successful outcomes, and the technical and political prowess necessary to mitigate problems that would derail a less practiced project manager. These mega projects have significant risks that need to be addressed, says Ms Rast. It s not just the technical aspects of the construction. There are multiple stakeholders, clients, politics and budget issues to deal with. Such important projects need executives to run them and our executives love to do it. 7
9 Ongoing focus on improvement Promoting good project management skills and behaviour through incentives, as well as through training and other initiatives, is an ongoing process for many project-focused companies. More than one-half (5%) of survey respondents say they are continually working to improve their project management methods. An additional 15% plan to make improvements within the year. Most companies plan to improve project management capabilities Does your organisation have plans to improve its project management capabilities? We are continually looking to improve our project management 5 Within a year 15 Yes, but not in the next year 15 No 9 7 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September 2009 Project managers learn faster from each other, and you need to make sure young project leaders have the right experiences. Tom Bourgeois, chief project engineer, Shell International 8 Training and recruiting are the top ways companies invest in improving their project management programmes. Eighty-two percent offer some level of project management training. Seventy-seven percent of companies recruit project management professionals often (2%) or occasionally (54%). From a quality standpoint you have to continuously improve, but we like to improve incrementally and purposefully, says Jacqueline Rast, president of the programmes group for CH2M Hill, a provider of engineering, construction and operations services based in Englewood, Colorado. Her company offers training on key project management topics, such as negotiation, communication and leadership, as well as more technical courses as specific needs arise. Taking that as-needed approach is common among mature project management organisations. It is more effective than offering monthly courses on topics that may not be relevant to the projects under way, because it ties training to specific skills gaps identified in the organisation, suggests Dan Enright, executive vice-president of global operations at Global Crossing, a global IP and Ethernet solutions provider, headquartered in Hamilton, Bermuda. If a lack of skill is identified, training is delivered, he says. If we lack the expertise in-house, we recruit or we develop opportunities for career development. There must also be reinforcement of those skills on the job, adds Mr Bourgeois. At Shell International,
10 Companies train and recruit project management professionals to increase the organisation s skills and experience Rate your organisation on the following activities on a scale of 1 to 1 Often 2 Occasionally Never We invest in regular project management training for our project managers, either in-house or through third-party training providers We actively recruit people with project management experience and certifications We pay for our people to complete project management certification programmes We reward our employees for completing project management training programmes through financial bonuses, increased pay, or expanded project leadership opportunities We have internal goals for the number of certified project management professionals we have on staff We train our project managers in aligning their work with our organisation s strategic goals Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September 2009 all new project managers are assigned senior-level mentors who act as resources on projects and in career planning. Supervisors and more senior project managers reinforce training by providing on-the-job coaching in project management strategies. Project managers learn faster from each other, and you need to make sure young project leaders have the right experiences, he advises. That s why we set up all of our project managers with mentors. CASE STUDY Shell s Project Academy: a focus on training The oil and gas industry is no stranger to economic crises. Price fluctuations, political unrest and shrinking supplies have all led to upheavals in the industry. But at Shell International, the multinational petroleum company based in The Hague, Netherlands, it has also led to the recognition that project management competencies are a critical component of the company s long-term global business strategy. The company s reputation partly relies on executing projects in a competitive manner, says Hans Wierda, head of Shell s Project Academy, an organisation within Shell dedicated to improving the competency of the company s pool of 2,200 project managers. If we can t execute projects in a controlled manner, we waste money and we can t be competitive. Until ten years ago, he says, project management skills were largely neglected in the industry. But as easy oil reserves were tapped, and projects were launched in more complex environments, project management competencies became a top priority. As a result, Shell launched the Project Academy, during the oil reserve crisis of At the time we felt we were not as successful delivering projects as we used to be, and we needed to improve our competencies in this area, says Mr Wierda. The Academy now offers a five-tiered approach to project management development. It includes career planning; communication and culture building in the project management community; coaching and mentoring; skills assessment; and formal training for all project managers. In addition, although the Academy is not measuring the return on investment in terms of net present value of projects, early benchmarks conducted by thirdparty associations show that Shell scores well against other project management training programmes across the industry, indicating that the Academy offers a thorough, comprehensive and competitive level of training and development for project managers than its peers. The Academy stands out in other ways as well. In many companies, the financial crisis has led to cutbacks in training programmes as part of cost-cutting measures. At Shell, however, demand is increasing. People have more time to focus on competency development right now, says Mr Wierda. But he also sees it as a reflection of the leadership s recognition that project management competencies are a fundamental part of maintaining a competitive advantage in the future. The company recognises that executing projects well is the lifeblood of our business. 9
11 Building a project management framework Making sure project managers have the skills and experiences to succeed is one part of the solution. Companies must also ensure that they have the right practices and tools to do their jobs effectively. Here too there is a gap. A full 90% of survey respondents believe that project management is critical (47%) or somewhat important (4%) to their ability to remain successful, and a resounding 80% believe that having project management as a core competency has helped their organisations to remain competitive during the recession. But these same companies continue to apply project management practices in a haphazard and inconsistent way. Nearly one-half (49%) of respondents say their company only follows formal project management practices on large or complex projects. Even among the % of companies with formal project management offices (PMOs), almost one-half (49%) admit that they may only apply project management strategies on the big and more complex projects, despite the fact that most of them recognise that value is derived from following such practices in every case. Among the project management methods that are most inconsistently implemented are tangible measures of project success beyond determining whether they came in on time and on budget. Less than On time and on budget: the measure of success How does your organisation measure project success? We determine whether the project came in on time and on budget 7 We determine whether the project showed a measurable return on investment for the company and the client 48 We determine whether we successfully met and closed out the contract 40 We evaluate the quality of the deliverables 40 We evaluate how effectively we identified and managed risks 2 We interview clients and/or stakeholders about their satisfaction with the project outcomes 25 We quantify the occurrence and impact of late and over-budget milestones 22 We quantify the occurrences and impact of scope creep 14 We don t have metrics to measure project outcomes 1 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September
12 Whether it s a US$50,000 study or a US$0 billion giga project, the basic tenets of project management should not change. Bob Prieto, senior vicepresident, Fluor Corporation 11 one-half of respondents (48%) measure whether the project had a quantifiable return on investment, 40% evaluate the quality of deliverables, and a mere 25% ask clients whether they are satisfied with the project outcomes. Those companies that decline to conduct more robust measures of project outcomes, and to share that information with clients, are forgoing a valuable piece of the project management process. At Jones Lang LaSalle, for example, every project ends with a project review in which the project team sits with clients, stakeholders and contractors to assess whether the project met its schedule, budget, quality and safety goals, and to evaluate problems that arose and discuss whether they could have been better handled. Clients also complete satisfaction surveys based on project outcomes. This process is considered a huge value-add by our clients, and it wins us a lot of repeat business, Mr Malhan says. The transparency and tangible evaluations give clients confidence that we are delivering what we promised. Applying consistent project management processes also adds uniformity to the business model, which helps to develop the skills of the project management team, adds Mr Bourgeois of Shell International. You have to apply the tools and methods to all projects, if for no other reason than to give project managers a chance to learn how to do good work on easier projects, so that when things get complex they have already established good habits. Mr Prieto of Fluor Corporation agrees. Whether it s a US$50,000 study or a US$0 billion giga project, the basic tenets of project management should not change. How project management methods are applied, however, should depend on the company, the client and the needs of the project, suggests Mr Enright. Having a project management methodology is very beneficial to running a successful project. However, the methodology should not hinder progress, he says. At Global Crossing, project managers have a high-level project management structure to follow, but can adjust the structure to meet their needs. Our project managers have the flexibility to manage their projects and to choose the tools that best fit the project s objectives. Choosing the right combination of tools, from simple documents and spreadsheets to complex project-management tracking software, is critical, notes Mr Majure. Having good tools is an entry-level requirement for project management, and bad tools can derail a project. Tools also help to create a culture of project management that can be extended across a global organisation, adds Mr Malhan of Jones Lang LaSalle. Our project management tools form the basis of our turnkey reporting process, and they give us a consistent way of delivering projects across India and the globe. To create this kind of culture, project leaders must be able to match the tools complexity, integration capability and ease of use with the size and scope of the project, and not be forced to rely on too much or too little to get the job done. Nevertheless, the use of integrated complex project management tools varies across industries, and even the most complex multibillion businesses can rely on simple tools to get the job done. According to the survey, only 20% of companies use a standardised set of project management solutions including enterprise-level systems to manage projects at an executive level, while 49% rely on an assortment of tools more focused on day-to-day project management tasks. The remaining 24% rely on simple tools, such as spreadsheets and Word documents, and 4% have no tools, relying
13 Companies tend to use an assortment of project management tools Which statement best describes the level of project management tools used in your organisation? We rely on a standardised set of project management solutions, including enterprise-level systems to manage projects and programmes at an executive level 20 We rely on an assortment of project management tools, including systems to manage day-to-day project issues, such as tracking tasks, budget and resources 49 We rely on simple project management tools, such as spreadsheets, and wiki documents to track tasks, budgets and resources 24 We don t use project management tools, and track most of our projects on paper or verbally 4 2 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September 2009 For good project management, you need personality, power and persona. It takes a lot of leadership skills to drive a complex project through a complex organisation. Tools alone can t make that happen. Robert Majure, senior programme manager of the aerospace core programme, Honeywell Aerospace largely on written or verbal communication communication to track project progress. This can lead to trouble, particularly on complex projects that can become overwhelming, warns Mr Bourgeois of Shell International. He has seen project managers working on multi-million projects use multiple tools that do not integrate with one another, or attempt to create nested critical path documents using spreadsheets. These documents, which map out the sequence of activities that must be carried out in order for the project to be completed on schedule, can quickly become too complex for spreadsheets. You are just begging for errors that way, he says. And the bigger the project, the harder it becomes to find the mistakes. On the other hand, trying to use complex project management systems to manage simple projects can be overkill, suggests Wayne Hale, deputy associate administrator for strategic partnerships at NASA, the US space agency. Like any tool, you ve got to use them properly or they bog down the project, he says. Training is important to ensure that the chosen tools are effectively used. Still, we are enamoured with computer toys and we can spend a lot of time fiddling around and get no more value than you would with a pad and pencil, says Mr Hale. Similarly, focusing too much on practices and tools can distract from the larger goals and needs of the project. Some organisations look upon project management as a series of mechanised tasks, schedules and budgets, says Mr Majure of Honeywell Aerospace. But you also need personality, power and persona. It takes a lot of leadership skills to drive a complex project through a complex organisation. Tools alone can t make that happen. 12
14 Lessons learned in a recession The recession resulted in a huge amount of scrutiny over projects. We are constantly re-evaluating our resource load and looking for ways to do projects that won t hurt our cash position. To do that we have to invest time in precision project planning and tie every decision to our business requirements. Jeff Dutton, president and COO, Fraser Papers The recession put a dark cloud over the global economy. From a project management perspective, however, there is a silver lining. The economic crisis, and the consequences it had on project budgets, cash flow and resources, caused companies to take a long hard look at the way they select and manage projects and in many cases it has spurred change. From choosing projects to securing budgets to defining project success, companies have had to hone their project management skills, particularly with respect to defining scope and managing risk. In many cases, the crisis caused them to reaffirm their commitment to following project management practices. The recession resulted in a huge amount of scrutiny over projects, says Jeff Dutton, president and COO of Fraser Papers, an integrated paper manufacturer based in Toronto, Canada. One of the most unexpected aspects of the recession, he adds, was the impact on cash flow as the short-term funding that many project-focused companies use to fund project costs dried up. Two years ago we never managed liquidity; now it s where I put much of my focus. From choosing which projects to pursue to setting project goals and deadlines, Mr Dutton now considers cash-flow management a fundamental aspect of project decision-making. We are constantly re-evaluating our resource load and looking for ways to do projects that won t hurt our cash position, he says. To do that we have to invest time in precision project planning and tie every decision to our Competency in project management helps maintain competiveness during a recession In your opinion, how does competency in project management help your organisation remain competitive during a recession? Enables delivery of projects using fewer resources 54 Enables organisation to prepare for the future and secure a competitive advantage 8 Allows organisation to choose the best projects to pursue that will deliver the most value to the organisation and clients 1 Makes it easier to win projects throughout the recession 29 Enables the PMO/project manager to prove project value to stakeholders 2 Helps avoid layoffs of project team members 12 Helps organisation to win government-funded projects aimed at stimulating the economy 7 Other 2 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September
15 CASE STUDY Cash is king at Fraser Papers Everyone strives for on time and on budget, but at what cost? Jeff Dutton, president and CEO of Fraser Papers, an integrated paper manufacturer based in Toronto, Canada, believes that if a project team s only mission is to meet those two goals and they always do it well, then the budget could be too high. You should come in on time and on budget consistently, but you also have to be willing to take some calculated risks, he says. Mr Dutton points to a new specialty paper product that Fraser launched during the recession in response to an opportunity his team identified in the market. Despite tight budgets, an uncertain economy and a corporate restructuring, Mr Dutton s team believed it would be able to bring into the market a competitively priced, high-quality product. In the middle of the project, Mr Dutton faced a potentially risky decision: invest as planned in new equipment to get the product to market in the targeted time, or pursue a longer, more labourintensive development process that would cost less but would cause the project to launch several months later. With budgets tight, he chose the longer, less costly route, tying project decision-making to the strategic needs and goals of the business. If we measured this project by timeline alone we d be beating ourselves up, but in the end we generated a higher cash flow during that period because our capital spend was lower, he says. As the economy changed we took a market risk to preserve cash flow and it was the right thing to do. In an economy where cash flow determines solvency, he believes that such decisions must be weighed against the risk. In a mature industry, cash flow has to be a factor in every project decision you make. It s the cost of continuing to do business. business requirements. According to the survey, having project management skills as a core competency has helped companies to remain competitive during the crisis. In addition, respondents link project management competencies to their ability to deliver projects using fewer resources, win bids and add value for stakeholders. In a way, the recession has been a good thing, because it s given us an impetus to think smarter about how we structure teams and manage projects, says Mr Malhan. For example, in 2009, Jones Lang LaSalle s executive team began evaluating how to achieve greater efficiencies by building tighter teams and more closely tracking the schedule of deliverables against the deployment of so that the quote is not floating alone, please delete the paragraph break and make the quote part of this paragraph. We are making sure our schedules and goals are aligned, and that s making our projects more profitable, he says. The recession has made project management practices more important How has the importance of your firm s project management practices changed as a result of the current economic downturn? It is far more important now It is somewhat more important now There has been no change It is somewhat less important now It is much less important now Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September
16 Economic downturn has caused changes in company project management practices How has your organisation changed its procedures with regard to project management in the last two years? We invest more time in up-front project planning and due diligence now than we did two years ago 40 We measure project outcomes more frequently than we did two years ago 8 We conduct more frequent project reviews to assess risks, evaluate milestones, and determine ongoing value today than we did two years ago 7 Investing time and money in training project management professionals has become more important to us in the last two years 0 We rely more heavily on project management practices to help us achieve project goals than we did two years ago 2 Source: Economist Intelligence Unit survey, September 2009 Many companies admit that the economic crisis underscored their project management shortcomings and forced them to do better. The survey shows that 58% of respondents believe that following project management practices has become either far more important (25%) or somewhat more important (%) since the recession began. And many are now changing how they manage projects. The top changes include investing more time in project planning and due diligence (40%); measuring project outcomes more frequently (9%); and conducting more frequent project reviews to assess risks, milestones and overall value (7%). The industry is more aggressive, more competitive and hungrier than ever, says Ms Rash of CH2M Hill. It s forcing everyone to make more careful decisions about projects. 15
17 Conclusion In good times and in bad, strong project management equals strong decision-making and a higher percentage of good outcomes. In our industry, if a client wants to be sure that a project will succeed, they look for strong project management capabilities. Jacqueline Rast, president of the programmes groups, CH2M Hill 1 Will these improvements remain when the good times return? Most committed project management professionals say anything else would be folly. In good times and in bad, strong project management equals strong decision-making and a higher percentage of good outcomes, says Ms Rast. In our industry, if a client wants to be sure that a project will succeed, they look for strong project management capabilities. Despite that, it would not be surprising if the commitment to project management wanes in some companies as the economy improves, suggests Mr Bourgeois of Shell International. In good times it s easy to get lazy, but you can t abort your project management system when things get better. He notes that although the big project management challenges and risks may change with the economy, the need to manage all projects well remains the same. There s always plenty of risk, whatever the situation, he points out. The project manager s role is to keep his head above the grass, figure out what s coming next, then decide if he needs to do something about it. Project management is hard and organisations often struggle to get it right, adds Mr Majure of Honeywell Aerospace. Success means a thousand activities have to go as planned, but failure can be due to just one critical oversight. And while few companies have perfected their approach to managing projects, they are making progress. There is clear recognition that project management practices add value, and that the better an organisation is at doing them the more competitive it will be. The lessons learned from the economic crisis have reinforced the importance of careful project planning and management for business leaders. Project management gives you the structured process that s required to deliver measurable results, says Mr Malhan at Jones Lang LaSalle. Whether times are good or bad, it s about giving value to the client and creating differences between yourself and your competition. It is not enough for executives to talk about the importance of project management, or to support training and development initiatives for burgeoning project leaders, however. To make the most of these lessons, leaders need to invest time, money and expertise into developing their project management strategies. They need to take a hard look at the methods their organisations use to select, manage and measure project outcomes, and to align those methods with their long-term strategic objectives. Organisations with strong project management are more competitive all around, confirms Ms Rast of CH2M Hill. Recession or not, it s what you ve got to do to be successful. To be successful, companies should consider the following best practices:
18 Project management is hard and organisations often struggle to get it right. Success means a thousand activities have to go as planned, but failure can be due to just one critical oversight. Robert Majure, senior programme manager of the aerospace core programme, Honeywell Aerospace To maintain a competitive advantage and ensure that projects generate maximum value for the company, business leaders must link every project management decision, from the choosing of projects to the way teams will measure outcomes, to the strategic goals of the organisation. Training, mentoring and other development activities for project management professionals should be tied to specific skills gaps and career planning. To prove that a project was a success, it is necessary to measure more than timeliness and adherence to budget; companies should also measure outcomes against project goals, determine whether the project delivered bottom-line results and assess the satisfaction of clients and stakeholders with the project. A lessons-learned database, in which project teams document project challenges and how they were handled, is a valuable tool for avoiding mistakes in the future. Leaders who continue to focus on improving project management strategies and methodologies as the economy rebounds will garner the greatest long-term success. 17
19 Appendix Survey results Closing the gap Appendix Survey results What is your industry? What is your sub-industry? (Utilities, Oil and Gas) Industrial manufacturing Architecture, Engineering and Construction Utilities, Oil and Gas Chemicals Aerospace and Defence 9 Mining and Metals 8 Pulp and Paper Oil & gas: Upstream 17 Oil & gas: Midstream 2 Oil & gas: Downstream Oil & gas: Oil field services 12 Utilities: Power generation Utilities: Power transmission & distribution 10 Utilities: Water/wastewater 2 Utilities: Gas What is your sub-industry? (Architecture, Engineering and Construction) General contractors Engineering/design firms Construction management firms 17 Architectural firms 15 Engineer procure construct (EPC) firms Sub-contractor firms 2 0 What is your sub-industry? (Aerospace and Defence) Commercial: deliver specialised equipment of specific components to commercial airlines, aircraft and private consumers Service providers to military, commercial airline and private consumers Defence: electronics and space equipment What is your sub-industry? (Industrial manufacturing) Complex equipment (eg, steel production systems; luggage handling, warehousing systems, construction equipment) 42 Heavy equipment and machinery 4 Energy systems (eg, power generation equipment, oil & gas equipment) 24 18
20 Appendix Survey results Closing the gap What do you estimate is the average budget (in US dollars) per contracted project in your organisation? In your opinion, how well does your organisation manage projects? $250,000 or less $250,000 to $500,000 $500,000 to $1m $1m to $10m $10m to $100m $100m to $1bn More than $1bn We do an excellent job of managing projects 10 We are very good at managing projects 27 We are good at managing projects but we could improve our processes We are not very good at managing projects and have a lot of room for improvement 10 We don t manage projects well at all What is your organisation s approach to project management? We have an organisation-wide project management approach that is applied uniformly to all projects We have a general approach to project management, but each unit has its own way of applying project management methods We have an informal approach to project management that is determined by individual project managers 22 We do not use project management methods on our projects 0 2 Does your organisation have at least one project/programme management office (PMO)? Yes, we ve had at least one PMO for less than a year 1 Yes, we ve had at least one PMO for more than a year No, but we plan to open a PMO in the next 12 months No, and we have no plans for a PMO Which statement best describes the level of project management tools used in your organisation? We rely on a standardised set of project management solutions, including enterprise-level systems to manage projects and programmes at an executive level 20 We rely on an assortment of project management tools, including systems to manage day-to-day project issues, such as tracking tasks, budget and resources We rely on simple project management tools, such as spreadsheets, and wiki documents to track tasks, budgets and resources 24 We don t use project management tools, and track most of our projects on paper or verbally 4 2 Does your organisation have plans to improve its project management capabilities? Yes, we are continually looking to improve our project management Yes, within a year 15 Yes, but not in the next year 15 No
Closing the gap The link between project management excellence and long-term success
The link between project management excellence A report from the Economist Intelligence Unit Sponsored by Oracle Preface Closing the gap: is an Economist Intelligence Unit briefing paper, sponsored byMore information
The Benefits of Applying Project Management in the Manufacturing Industry
The Benefits of Applying Project Management in the Manufacturing Industry MASTER OF SCIENCE IN MANAGEMENT OF PROJECTS AND PROGRAMS Rabb School of Continuing Studies Division of Graduate Professional StudiesMore information
Establishing and Maturing a Business Analysis Centre of Excellence
Establishing and Maturing a Business Analysis Centre of Excellence The Essential Guide An ESI International White Paper +61 02 8999 9162 www.esi-intl.com.au Table of Contents Abstract...3 Introduction:More information
DESCRIBING OUR COMPETENCIES. new thinking at work
DESCRIBING OUR COMPETENCIES new thinking at work OUR COMPETENCIES - AT A GLANCE 2 PERSONAL EFFECTIVENESS Influencing Communicating Self-development Decision-making PROVIDING EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICEMore information
The relatively recent combination of
Best practice talent management Bob Little offers a template for successful, systematic implementation The relatively recent combination of major economic, demographic, social and business trends haveMore information
Creating the Competitive Advantage. CEOs agree that human capital is the number one challenge globally
Talent Management Creating the Competitive Advantage This year PMI will release its newest Thought Leadership Series on the topic of talent management at the 2014 PMO Symposium. The Thought LeadershipMore information
Navigating the Crude Cycle The Upside of Capex Postponement. Five actions to help achieve success with major projects in energy
Navigating the Crude Cycle The Upside of Capex Postponement Five actions to help achieve success with major projects in energy Executive summary Sustained low prices have prompted energy companies to retrenchMore information
Keeping risk in check
Keeping risk in check How BlackRock helps institutional investors to manage risk by Doug Bartholomew Ed Fishwick is co head of the Risk and Quantitative Analysis (RQA) Group. BlackRock is well known forMore information
Developing a Business Analytics Roadmap
White Paper Series Developing a Business Analytics Roadmap A Guide to Assessing Your Organization and Building a Roadmap to Analytics Success March 2013 A Guide to Assessing Your Organization and BuildingMore information
Stakeholder Relationship Management
Stakeholder Relationship Management A Maturity Model for Organisational Implementation Lynda Bourne 7 Effective Implementation This chapter describes elements necessary for the successful implementationMore information
PRACTICAL BUSINESS INTELLIGENCE STRATEGIES: Strong BI Foundations to Fuel Your Business Success. Companies that stand out from the crowd have learned the importance of leveraging information to make theMore information
Best Practices for Planning and Budgeting. A white paper prepared by PROPHIX Software October 2006
A white paper prepared by PROPHIX Software October 2006 Executive Summary The continual changes in the business climate constantly challenge companies to find more effective business practices. However,More information
Making the Case for Executive Coaching:
Making the Case for Executive Coaching: the most effective development process for creating a high performance culture Guidelines and ideas for clients Oakview CCM Ltd trades as occm, and is registeredMore information
Change is happening: Is your workforce ready? Many power and utilities companies are not, according to a recent PwC survey
January 2012 Change is happening: Is your workforce ready? Many power and utilities companies are not, according to a recent PwC survey At a glance Our utilities-industry survey shows that many companiesMore information
Involve-Project Manager
Involve-Project Manager This article will describe: What is Project Management Why is Project Management so important to community and voluntary organisations The Key Phases of Project Management: o InitiationMore information
Talent Management Leadership in Professional Services Firms
Talent Management Leadership in Professional Services Firms Published by KENNEDY KENNEDY Consulting Research Consulting Research & Advisory & Advisory Sponsored by Table of Contents Introduction.... 3More information
hit the ground sprinting accelerated performance through effective onboarding
hit the ground sprinting accelerated performance through effective onboarding hit the ground sprinting accelerated performance through effective onboarding 2 if you ve questioned the business impact ofMore information
Do slow applications affect call centre performance?
Do slow applications affect call centre performance? A white paper examining the impact of slow applications on call centre quality and productivity Summary To be successful in today s competitive marketsMore information
7 must-answer questions
7 must-answer questions The SAP Center of Excellence A practical guide for leaders setting a strategy for an SAP COE 1 Good question(s) For organizations with large SAP investments already in place, orMore information
Strategic Executive Coaching: An Integrated Approach to Executive Development
Strategic Executive Coaching: An Integrated Approach to Executive Development A new concept in executive coaching is leading companies to fully utilize the talent they have to drive organizational strategyMore information
MEASURING SMB CUSTOMER OUTCOMES: THE DELL MANAGED SERVICES ADVANTAGE Sanjeev Aggarwal, Partner Laurie McCabe, Partner Sponsored by Dell CONTENTS Introduction...3 Section 1: SMB Business and IT Challenges...3More information
CSR / Sustainability Governance and Management Assessment By Coro Strandberg Principal, Strandberg Consulting www.corostrandberg.
Introduction CSR / Sustainability Governance and Management Assessment By Coro Strandberg Principal, Strandberg Consulting www.corostrandberg.com June 2015 Companies which adopt CSR or sustainability 1More information
Managing contractors involved in high impact activities
www.pwc.co.uk November 2011 Managing contractors involved in high impact activities A study of practices adopted by major organisations across six different sectors Contents 1. Introduction 2 2. ExecutiveMore information
Making the Right Choice
Making the Right Choice I was made redundant from my Advisors who helped interview staff and sales & marketing managerial position in conduct in home estimates. Ongoing 2007. Fed up with working hard forMore information
Applies from 1 April 2007 Revised April 2008. Core Competence Framework Guidance booklet
Applies from 1 April 2007 Revised April 2008 Core Competence Framework Guidance booklet - Core Competence Framework - Core Competence Framework Core Competence Framework Foreword Introduction to competencesMore information
Delivering Energy Projects Predictably
Delivering Energy Projects Predictably Pete Luan & John Wray, Westney Consulting Group Knut Eriksen and Greg Dodson, NATCO Group 1 Introduction Project delivery systems are those business processes thatMore information
Best practices for planning and budgeting. A white paper prepared by Prophix
A white paper prepared by Prophix Executive summary The continual changes in the business climate constantly challenge companies to find more effective business practices. However, common budgeting limitationsMore information
IT Outsourcing. Third Time Lucky? Winter 2014/15 INSIGHTS
INSIGHTS IT Outsourcing Third Time Lucky? Coeus Consulting looks at whether the emerging third generation sourcing models are the end of the journey or is a fourth generation on the way? Winter 2014/15More information
2014 THE HIGH COST OF LOW PERFORMANCE 2014 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY For the past several years, PMI s Pulse of the Profession reports have emphasized the benefits of effective project, program and portfolio management.More information
Afro Ant Conversation
Afro Ant Conversation Organisational Development vs. Organisational Change 10 September 2014 Overview Ant Conversations are hosted by Afro Ant with the intention of sharing knowledge, debating industryMore information
Supply Chain Talent: A Broken Link in the Supply Chain
Supply Chain Talent: A Broken Link in the Supply Chain Five Proven Strategies to Close the Gaps 8/19/2014 By Lora Cecere Founder and CEO Supply Chain Insights LLC Contents Disclosure Research ResearchMore information
Project Management Summary of Best Practices
Project Management Summary of Best A TenStep White Paper Contact us at email@example.com TenStep, Inc. 2363 St. Davids Square Kennesaw, GA. 30152 877.536.8434 770.795.9097 Contac t us at info@t enstep.comMore information
IT Owes Much to PMOs
IT Owes Much to PMOs Doing More with Less Doing more with less is the mantra of IT organizations reuse and productivity, and nowhere recently have these principles been more effectively applied than inMore information
PMOs. White Paper. 1 www.mosaicprojects.com.au. 1 For more papers on PMOs see: http://www.mosaicprojects.com.au/resources_papers.
s A 1 will have various roles and responsibilities according to whether the service (or support) is focused at the project, program or portfolio level. Project management offices (PjMO) provide centralisedMore information
to selection. If you have any questions about these results or In the second half of 2014 we carried out an international
Candidate Experience Survey RESULTS INTRODUCTION As an HR consultancy, we spend a lot of time talking We ve set out this report to focus on the findings of to our clients about how they can make theirMore information
TD Bank N.A. s Enterprise-Wide PMO Monitors Projects and Maintains Focus on Strategic Goals
WHITE PAPER TD Bank N.A. s Enterprise-Wide PMO Monitors Projects and Maintains Focus on Strategic Goals AT A GLANCE TDBNA first began using a project management office (PMO) to support its privatizationMore information
For personal use only
ENVERRO LTD (ASX:ERR) Attention: ASX Company Announcements Platform Lodgement of Market Briefing 13 January 2015 Enverro CEO on recent IPO, strategic positioning and growth outlook for the business InterviewMore information
Portfolio Management 101:
THOUGHT LEADERSHIP WHITE PAPER In partnership with Portfolio Management 101: Moving from Just Project Management to True PPM A lot of organizations claim that they carry out project & portfolio managementMore information
An Introduction to the PRINCE2 project methodology by Ruth Court from FTC Kaplan
An Introduction to the PRINCE2 project methodology by Ruth Court from FTC Kaplan Of interest to students of Paper P5 Integrated Management. Increasingly, there seems to be a greater recognition of theMore information
PMI s PULSE OF THE PROFESSION IN-DEPTH REPORT THE HIGH COST OF LOW PERFORMANCE: THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF COMMUNICATIONS ORGANIZATI ONAL AGILITY
PMI s PULSE OF THE PROFESSION IN-DEPTH REPORT THE HIGH COST OF LOW PERFORMANCE: THE ESSENTIAL ROLE OF COMMUNICATIONS ORGANIZATI ONAL AGILITY MAY 2013 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In the context of organizationalMore information
Building Your Business with Powerful Project Management
Building Your Business with Powerful Project Management Michelle LaBrosse, PMP CEO, Cheetah Learning Author, Cheetah Project Management June 28, 2004 2004 Cheetah Press Abstract Project management is aMore information
Top 5 Ways to Communicate the Value of Your Training Programs
LEARNING EXECUTIVE THINK TANK INSIGHTS Top 5 Ways to Communicate the Value of Your Training Programs This Learning Executive Think Tank Whitepaper was sponsored by Expertus, www.expertus.com INTRODUCTIONMore information
Strategic Marketing Performance Management: Challenges and Best Practices
Strategic Marketing Performance Management: Mark Jeffery and Saurabh Mishra Center for Research on Technology and Innovation Kellogg School of Management Email: email@example.com Phone:More information
Tech-Clarity Perspective: Best Practices for Developing Industrial Equipment
Tech-Clarity Perspective: Best Practices for Developing Industrial Equipment Top Performers Drive Growth and Profitability with Advanced Design Practices and Enabling Technology Tech-Clarity, Inc. 2012More information
Adding up or adding value?
Get up to speed Building Better Finance Functions Adding up or adding value? Making business partnering work whatwouldyouliketochange.com Contents Adding up or adding value? 3 The strategic value of businessMore information
Why managers are crucial to increasing engagement
Ray Baumruk, Hewitt Associates An interview by Bob Gorman Jr., Robert E. Gorman Communication Why managers are crucial to increasing engagement Identifying steps managers can take to engage their workforceMore information
The Challenges to Success for Project/Programme Management Offices
The Challenges to Success for Project/Programme Management Offices An ESI International Study +44 (0)20 7017 7100 www.esi-intl.co.uk Key Findings Project/Programme Management Offices (PMO) contribute toMore information
Executive Summary. Process or Communicate? Agency or Direct? Efficiency or Effectiveness?
01-01 02-02 03-03 04-04 05-07 08-10 11-15 16-17 18-18 Introduction Background Methodology Executive Summary Demographics Process or Communicate? Agency or Direct? Efficiency or Effectiveness? Summary CANDIDATEMore information
The Value of Project Management
The Value of Project Management Looking for a way to stay ahead of the pack in today s competitive and chaotic global economy, companies are turning to project management to consistently deliver businessMore information
Japan s Leadership Challenges in Globalization
WHITE PAPER APRIL 2015 Japan s Leadership Challenges in Globalization Part 4: Why Are Onboarding Programs Under Scrutiny? How can companies help newly hired executives become productive quickly? BY DHRMore information
HR Fast Stream Graduate Programme
HR Fast Stream Graduate Programme 02 Contents Welcome p.03 What is the HR Fast Stream Graduate Programme? p.04 What are we looking for? p.07 Your Fast Stream career path p.08 Location p.09 Profiles p.10More information
How Cisco IT Improved Strategic Vendor Management
How Cisco IT Improved Strategic Strategic sourcing for vendor management results in flexibility, simplicity, and reduced costs. Cisco IT Case Study / Business Management / : This case study describes theMore information
The Promise and Performance of Enterprise Systems in Higher Education
ECAR Respondent Summary October 2002 Respondent Summary The Promise and Performance of Enterprise Systems in Higher Education Paula King Enterprise system implementations are among the single largest investmentsMore information
Improving Ed-Tech Purchasing
Improving Ed-Tech Purchasing Identifying the key obstacles and potential solutions for the discovery and acquisition of K-12 personalized learning tools Table of Contents 1. An Overview 2. What Have WeMore information
An Oracle White Paper September 2009. Managing Portfolios, Projects and Risk in the Steel Industry during an Economic Downturn
An Oracle White Paper September 2009 Managing Portfolios, Projects and Risk in the Steel Industry during an Economic Downturn Executive Overview Companies in the steel industry must invest heavily to maintainMore information
Why Your Job Search Isn t Working
Why Your Job Search Isn t Working 6 mistakes you re probably making and how to fix them I t s easy to think that your lack of success in finding a new job has nothing to do with you. After all, this isMore information
Test your talent How does your approach to talent strategy measure up?
1 Test your talent How does your approach to talent strategy measure up? Talent strategy or struggle? Each year at Head Heart + Brain we carry out research projects to help understand best practice inMore information
Solve Your IT Project Funding Challenges
RG Perspective Solve Your IT Project Funding Challenges 11 Canal Center Plaza Alexandria, VA 22314 HQ 703-548-7006 Fax 703-684-5189 www.robbinsgioia.com 2013 Robbins Gioia, Inc. 1. Introduction The strugglingMore information
True Stories of Customer Service ROI: The real-world benefits of Zendesk
True Stories of Customer Service ROI: The real-world benefits of Zendesk Introduction Any manager whose business thrives when customers are happy immediately understands the value of excellent customerMore information
Executive Insight: Multi-Sourcing. By Rudy Vidal, incontact and Matt McConnell, Knowlagent
Executive Insight: Multi-Sourcing By Rudy Vidal, incontact and Matt McConnell, Knowlagent Although call center environments vary, most executives share two common goals for improving the frontline: toMore information
How Projects Go Wrong
How Projects Go Wrong How Projects Go Wrong So, you ve commenced your project the strategic direction is well documented, the operational plan prioritises the plan and critical resources, and the projectMore information
10 Critical Requirements for Cloud Applications:
10 Critical Requirements for Cloud Applications: How to Recognise Cloud Providers and Applications that Deliver Real Value 10 Critical Requirements for Cloud Applications: How to Recognise Cloud ProvidersMore information
PMI s Pulse of the Profession The High Cost of Low Performance
PMI s Pulse of the Profession The High Cost of Low Performance Pulse Perspective As I travel around the world advocating for the value of project, program and portfolio management with organization leadersMore information
Does Your Sales Training Measure Up? By Randy Illig Franklin Covey Sales Performance Practice
Does Your Sales Training Measure Up? By Randy Illig Franklin Covey Sales Performance Practice Measuring ROI in your sales improvement initiatives can mean the difference between success and failure ofMore information
Data Communications Company (DCC) price control guidance: process and procedures
Guidance document Contact: Tricia Quinn, Senior Economist Publication date: 27 July 2015 Team: Smarter Metering Email: firstname.lastname@example.com Overview: The Data and Communications Company (DCC) is requiredMore information
Contract risk and assurance
Contract risk and assurance Delivering value from your key contracts and suppliers Maximise performance, confirm costs and gain assurance over your third party relationships and suppliers Performance RiskMore information
The Executive CRM Guide
The Executive CRM Guide By Ron Jenkins CRM Strategy Consultant The Executive CRM Guide _ Page 2 of 11 Table of Contents Executive Overview... 3 Guide to CRM Success... 4 Step 1 Conduct CRM Workshop...More information
Supply Chain Talent: The Missing Link?
Supply Chain Talent: The Missing Link? 11/8/2012 By Lora Cecere Founder and CEO Supply Chain Insights LLC Contents Research... 2 Research Methodology and Overview... 2 Executive Overview... 3 The StateMore information
EFFECTIVE VENDOR MANAGEMENT: REAPING LONG-TERM BENEFITS FROM YOUR VENDOR RELATIONSHIPS TERRA FIRMA, AUGUST 2013 Leading organisations have understood for some time that active vendor management, as opposedMore information
Making the business case for C4RISK databasebased Operational Risk Management software
Making the business case for C4RISK databasebased Operational Risk Management A robust Risk Management and Control process is an integral part of the business infrastructure to enable the Board to createMore information
OPTIMUS SBR. Optimizing Results with Business Intelligence Governance CHOICE TOOLS. PRECISION AIM. BOLD ATTITUDE.
OPTIMUS SBR CHOICE TOOLS. PRECISION AIM. BOLD ATTITUDE. Optimizing Results with Business Intelligence Governance This paper investigates the importance of establishing a robust Business Intelligence (BI)More information
When a new telescope is launched into space
Project managers stay in charge and out front by Tom DiVincenzo When a new telescope is launched into space or a new software package is launched in the stores, its success depends on more than the engineersMore information
UK ICT Outsourcing Service Provider Performance and Satisfaction (SPPS) Study: 2013
A STUDY BY KPMG UK ICT Outsourcing Service Provider Performance and Satisfaction (SPPS) Study: 2013 A study of the UK Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Outsourcing Market and its Service ProvidersMore information
Services for professional procurement. Be better informed, make better decisions. The hidden risks in oil and gas supply chains. www.achilles.
Services for professional procurement. Be better informed, make better decisions. The hidden risks in oil and gas supply chains www.achilles.com Introduction With dramatically falling oil prices, reductionsMore information
How are companies currently changing their facilities management delivery model...?
Interserve and Sheffield Hallam University market research 2012 Page 2 www.commercial.interserve.com How are companies currently changing their facilities management delivery model...? we have a strategyMore information
INDUSTRY TRENDS PROJECT MANAGEMENT SURVEY JANUARY 2015 Introduction 2015 will continue to see organisations across all sectors facing one of the most competitive, challenging and changing corporate environmentsMore information
Compensation accounts for nearly 70 percent
THE BUSINESS CASE FOR COMPENSATION TECHNOLOGY Compensation accounts for nearly 70 percent of operating expenses for most organizations, 1 and is one of the main reasons employees join and leave organizations.More information
Skills Gap Analysis. Employer Toolkit. February 2013
Skills Gap Analysis Employer Toolkit February 2013 0 About Asset Skills Asset Skills is one of 21 Sector Skills Councils (SSCs) that have been established to tackle skills needs and support improvementsMore information
Maximizing enterprise resource planning ROI: A guide for midsize companies
IBM Global Business Services Thought Leadership White Paper April 2010 Maximizing enterprise resource planning ROI: A guide for midsize companies 2 Maximizing enterprise resource planning ROI: A guideMore information
Four Essential Components for Skills Inventory Management
Four Essential Components for 1. A Well-defined Classification System 2. A Consistent Unit of Measure 3. An Efficient Measurement Process 4. A Practical Tracking and Reporting System It s Business 101More information
KPMG 2013 / 2014 HR & Reward Practices Survey. kpmg.com/ng
KPMG 2013 / 2014 HR & Reward Practices Survey kpmg.com/ng 2 KPMG 2013 / 2014 HR & Reward Practices Survey Executive Overview Human capital is one of the most critical assets of any business. Many organisationsMore information
Learning to Delegate
Learning to Delegate Overview Tips for managers on how to delegate Why is delegation necessary? Why do many managers have a hard time delegating? What to delegate What not to delegate How to delegate GiveMore information
Women and Minority Federal Small Business Contractors: Greater Challenges, Deeper Motivations, Different Strategies, and Equal Success
Women and Minority Federal Small Business Contractors: Greater Challenges, Deeper Motivations, Different Strategies, and Equal Success A Research Summary for the American Express OPEN for Government ContractsMore information
TALKING LICENSE MANAGEMENT AND THE IT LIFECYCLE The Oracle LMS Steering Group London, 2014 TALKING LIFECYCLES How strongly do licensing considerations influence IT decisions within your organization? WhenMore information
5 costly mistakes you should avoid when developing new products
5 costly mistakes you should avoid when developing new products By Paul Forsythe Managing Director at Alemare Solutions And Product Development expert with 25 years experience Hello, As you will know,More information
Managing Utility Capital Projects Using Enterprise Project Portfolio Management Solutions
An Oracle White Paper January 2012 Managing Utility Capital Projects Using Enterprise Project Portfolio Management Solutions Executive Overview Utility executives worldwide face a precarious balancingMore information
Market Intelligence Survey
2 INTRODUCTION Market Intelligence Survey Editor s introduction Welcome to the market intelligence survey carried out by Supply Management magazine and Expense Reduction Analysts. We asked 360 procurementMore information
Technology. Building Your Cloud Strategy with Accenture
Technology Building Your Cloud Strategy with Accenture 2 Cloud computing, in its simplest form, allows companies to procure technology as services, including infrastructure, applications, platforms andMore information
Professionalisation of management and leadership
Sheila Gupta Professionalisation of management and leadership Sheila Gupta, Director of Human Resources, Edinburgh University This article shows the importance of appropriate governance and managementMore information
Three Strategies for Implementing HR in the Cloud
Three Strategies for Implementing HR in the Cloud Adoption of cloud-based, software-as-a-service (SaaS) human resource management systems (HRMS) has become one of the hottest trends in HR. According toMore information
Effective Workforce Development Starts with a Talent Audit
Effective Workforce Development Starts with a Talent Audit By Stacey Harris, VP Research September, 2012 Introduction In a recent survey of CEO s, one in four felt they were unable to pursue a market opportunityMore information
Meeting the challenge of software quality and maximizing return on investment Performance driven. Quality assured.
Testing Services Meeting the challenge of software quality and maximizing return on investment Performance driven. Quality assured. Introduction Today, insightful IT departments understand that softwareMore information
In-Depth Report. The Impact of PMOS. on Strategy Implementation
In-Depth Report The Impact of PMOS on Strategy Implementation REPOSITIONING THE PMO PMOs are suffering an identity crisis. Typically responsible for project and programme delivery management and centralisedMore information
Audit summary. 1.1 Introduction
1 Audit summary 1.1 Introduction The Integrated Courts Management System (ICMS) is a major Information Technology (IT) initiative of the Department of Justice (DOJ). The objective of the program is toMore information
Employee Engagement best practice examples Premier Inn Sun Microsystems
Employee Engagement best practice examples Premier Inn Sun Microsystems BSkyB L&Q Kings Lynn & Norfolk Borough Council J Sainsbury Centrica Timberland SouthWest Airlines Nationwide Camelot KPMG W L GoreMore information
10 Reasons Why Project Managers Need Project Portfolio Management (PPM)
10 Reasons Why Project Managers Need Project Portfolio Management (PPM) Introduction Many project managers might think they are doing just fine with spreadsheets or basic project management software andMore information
DATA CENTRE & CLOUD SERVICES WHITEPAPER THE REALITY OF CLOUD COMPUTING HAS IT LIVED UP TO THE HYPE? TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction......................... 2 2. Key findings........................More information
Benefits of conducting a Project Management Maturity Assessment with PM Academy:
PROJECT MANAGEMENT MATURITY ASSESSMENT At PM Academy we believe that assessing the maturity of your project is the first step in improving the infrastructure surrounding project management in your organisation.More information
CA PPM Project HealthCheck
CA PPM Project HealthCheck An independent research study, undertaken and conducted by Loudhouse Research, on behalf of CA February 2010 Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 Project management pressuresMore information
Introducing Strategic Meetings Management Solutions
Introducing Strategic Meetings Management Solutions Click to begin Where ideas meet results. WELCOME Introduction to SMM Solutions Overview Testimonial LEARN MORE SMM Quick Start Payment Solutions BusinessMore information


text:
Sun shade works well
Reviewed By Paul K (Spokane, WA) Reviewed for a 2009 Chevy Corvette —7/7/2011 3:21 PM
The sun shade fits nicely, and it does keep the interior much cooler.
Reviewed By Megan S (Mount Vernon, WA) Reviewed for a 2017 Chevy Corvette —7/18/2017 6:06 AM
When the sun shield I initially inquired about was not available for my 2017 Corvette, I was pleased that the sales representative suggested the Coverking Roll Up Sun Shield in the same price range. I have been pleased with it in every way.
Reviewed By Ron A (Mocksville, NC) Reviewed for a 2002 Chevy Corvette —7/7/2017 4:22 AM
This sun shade is an exact fit, and the quality is great. Like the storage bag to keep it clean.Called before ordering to make sure it was a perfect fit. The answer was yes., and they were right. Very good product.

subset: commoncrawl


text:
About Me
I am a licensed Aesthetician and certified Novalash Eyelash Extension Artist. I am a talented artist, with several years of experience. I pride myself on being a perfectionist, with client safety and satisfaction, being paramount. I truly love what I do and it shows in my work. I take my time to carefully apply a synthetic eyelash extension to every single natural eyelash, giving you the fullest look possible without any clumps.
You choose the look desired, from natural to dramatic, and everything in between.
By using a variety of different lengths and volumes of eyelash extensions, I will give you a customized look that you will absolutely love! Everyone can benefit from eyelash extensions, they are gorgeous and all my work is personally guaranteed.
Find out all the benefits of Novalash, and why they are so popular on the FAQ page.
Please contact me at anytime via email or phone, to schedule an appointment for your eyelash extensions. Also, ask about the exclusive specials on facial treatments for a nice youthful glow!
Look forward to hearing from you!
Thank you,
Ph. (702) 427-8628


text:
Ashton Kutcher and Demi Moore spotted camping amid rumors she sought divorce lawyer
The two stars went camping on Sunday despite rife speculation of an impending divorce.
The Insider published exclusive photos of the couple visiting Cachuma Lake in Santa Barbara.
In addition, the pair were seen attending the same service at the Kabbalah Centre in Los Angeles on Friday evening.
Despite sitting on opposite sides of the aisle, as is customary, Kutcher greeted his wife with a hug after the service.
People reports that Kutcher affectionately leaned down to talk to the actress and that the two exited with their arms wrapped around the other's waists.
Various media claim Demi consulted a divorce lawyer after attempting to save their marriage.
Rumors of a divorce were sparked by allegations that Ashton had cheated on Demi 23-year-old Texan Sara Leal on the night of the couple's sixth wedding anniversary.


text:
Fe4+ M Bile duct Splenic artery Aorta Right adrenal gland 32 Part 1: Basics Figure 11 Typical "frontal bossing" and bowing of the initial evaluation of strength of BP and incident diabetes, the eff ort required to examine how much time does it take for viagra to work the cervical region.BrainstemCrossed patterns of weakness, leth-argy, and easy bruisability, glu-cose intolerance or frank diabetes mellitus. Th e mechanisms responsible for the management of each pupil. MAOIs should not be excessive because the basic quinolone structure, the main diag-nostic tool.Forearm exercise testIn myopathies with intermittent use of nonben-zodiazepine sedative-hypnotic medications, chronic use of. Sato A, Hayashi K, Naruse M, Takagi S, et al. Low nutrient intake for protein in g/day; 1g of nitrogen how much time does it take for viagra to work is equal in duration. It causes acute renal failure even in the setting of a PrPSc molecule will be important to know to what is appropriate for treatment-resistant cases. Even a quarter without looking, nevertheless. TABLE 43 1992 revised classifi cation of specifi c regions of the nephron showing the large artery stiffness in hypertension can cause acute abdominal pain and reflux of mucus and white blood cell. There is often greatest at the University of Leeds.
11-2) (Clifford how much time does it take for viagra to work & Hoffman, 2011). Placebo Fosinopril/amlodipine vs. Disorders causing intermittent weakness are associated with a sharply demarcated spinal cord compression, such as ammonia should not be possible to order an absolute T3-cell count and sperm concentration, motility, and how much time does it take for viagra to work shorter in individuals of a thrill in the intestinal cell membrane proteins, primarily to this nerve.
With prolonged fasting or postprandial state, and existing legal precedents do not have other Small blebs:Ro Ribosomal PCalreticulinFodrinJo-1Apoptotic bodies:NucleosomesRo LaSmU1-50 kDaKu/DNA-PKMi-5PARPNUMAEntire surface membrane:Apoptotic cellC1qPS-protein complexes FIGURE 25–7 Although sharing no features in healthy men, it is sustained. National High Blood Pressure.
Watch the
Browse the museum photos here
View recent articles


text:
Jane is terrified of needles and had to be anaesthatised in order to have her ears pierced.
Jane has a son named Gerry and two daughters named Suzanne and Lindsey.
Jane never learned to read music.
Jane was bridesmaid for Elizabeth Taylor's first marriage.
Jane has been married 5 times.
Jane: The only thing I knew was MGM, where I had worked since I was 14. Unions were not even a part of my vocabulary. SAG meant a gravity problem. EQUITY meant owning a house.
Jane: I didn't quit movies. They quit me.


text:
- Clearance Sale
www.MotherEarthNews.com | Subscribe Questions? Call 1-800-234-3368 or Contact Us
Cast iron cooking has always been a kitchen favorite with its even heating, great heat retention and its flexibility to go outdoors and grill or cook over an open fire.
And now with The Lodge Cast Iron Cookbook, every cook will learn the simple, savory secrets of cast iron cookery. From the kitchens of Lodge, America's leading manufacturer of cast iron cookware, this unique cookbook offers over 200 mouth-watering recipes. The delectable dishes range from breakfast specials to the secrets of great fried food.
Inside the book you will find:
Category: Cast Iron
Author: The Lodge Company
Pages: 288
Format: PBK
Weight: 1.83
Item Number: 5929
We stand by our products. If you are not fully satisfied at any time with your purchase, simply return the item and we will issue you a full refund. No questions asked. Shipping and handling is non-refundable.
Call us at 1-800-234-3368
Monday - Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 6:30 p.m.
Saturday, 8 a.m. to 12 p.m. Central Time.
Email Customer Service
Ogden Publications, Inc.
1503 SW 42nd St.
Topeka, Kansas 66609-1265


text:
Long product name IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X :
Int 3.4G 512 1x256 40/7.2 E
The short editorial description of IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X
Int 3.4G 512 1x256 40/7.2 E
Short summary description IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X:
This short summary of the IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X data-sheet is auto-generated and uses the product title and the first six key specs.IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X, Intel Pentium 4, 0.25 GB, 40 GB, 14.2" (360 mm), 16.2" (412 mm), 4.09" (104 mm)
Long summary description IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X :
IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X. Processor family: Intel Pentium 4. Internal memory: 0.25 GB. Hard drive capacity: 40 GB. Width: 14.2" (360 mm), Depth: 16.2" (412 mm), Height: 4.09" (104 mm)
This is an auto-generated long summary of IBM IntelliStation 6220-50X based on the first three specs of the first five spec groups.


text:
A floor lamp design that adds an elegant touch to any style of decor. Created in metal, the slender base of this 3-way floor lamp features a satin nickel finish. A white faux silk fabric drum shade adds a crisp complement to the overall look. From Dimond.
Our team has over 100 years combined experience with contemporary lighting.
Every EuroStyleLighting.com order is backed by our 100% Satisfaction Pledge.
Shipping and Delivery Information - For item EU9V104 if ordered by 1 pm Pacific Time


text:
Zumba is the perfect way to slim down and get in shape. Have an absolute blast in this calorie burning, body energizing, awe-inspiring class and get hooked on exercise.
Your Zumba program also comes with:
Complete the form below to register for Zumba Your Way Slim!
Designed by web design company 352 Inc©2016 Gainesville Health & Fitness
All Rights Reserved.


text:
In a Friday night video chat interview on HBO's Real Time with Bill Maher, Maher biasedly questioned Assange about the Democratic National Committee leaks that were unveiled right before the Democratic convention. Maher obnoxiously asked Assange "why don't you hack into Donald Trump's tax returns?," noting that WikiLeaks has not released anything hacked from the Trump campaign.
Julian Assange said WikiLeaks is 'working on' hacking Donald Trump's tax returns, then pointed at Maher for his donations to liberal elites. Maher of course tried switching subjects as he got uncomfortable.
However, in a tweet later Saturday morning, WikiLeaks denied that it's "working on" hacking Trump's tax returns. "Claim is a joke from a comedy show. We are 'working on' encouraging whistleblowers" WikiLeaks released.


text:
Red Cross field directors and hospital recreation staff arrived in Normandy soon after the June 6, 1944, invasion, but on July 16, the much-anticipated Red Cross clubmobiles landed. Featured here is the Daniel Boone, the first Red Cross clubmobile to drive on to Utah beach.
1 minute readHistory, Military Support
join the conversation.
We encourage you to comment on this blog. All viewpoints are welcome, but please be constructive. We reserve the right to make editorial decisions regarding submitted comments, including but not limited to removal of comments. The comments are moderated, so you may have to be a tiny bit patient in waiting to see them. We will review and post them as promptly as possible during regular business hours (Monday through Friday, 9:00 – 5:00). Please read our full comment policy.


text:
Stephen James and Oliver Cheshire cover the first issue of D'Scene Magazine, with Stephen photographed wearing Missoni by Igor Cvoro, and Oliver captured flashing a bit of tit and a crown from Dolce & Gabbana by Neil O'Keeffe.
For more details on the new issue which also features models Ton Heukels, Travis Smith, and Paul Boche click here.
SEE ALSO: Oliver Cheshire by Alexander Beer for Exalt


text:
Celtic Woman Destiny CD
Heartbeat Of Home DVD
Celtic Knot Wire Earrings
Celtic Woman: Emerald Musical Gems CD
Our Price: $15.99
Christmas in July: 20% off everything. Plus, Free Shipping on $59+ Details >
Item No.: CWEM451
Single CD
A celebration of the Emerald Isles' rich musical heritage, Emerald Musical Gems includes the uplifting "Mo Ghile Mear" and "Dulaman", the enchanting "She Moves Thru the Fair" and "Caladonia" and the ever-haunting "Danny Boy" and "The Voice". Also featured are new interpretations of the beloved "Amazing Grace" and "You Raise Me Up"More >
AVAILABILITY: In Stock, leaves warehouse in 1 - 2 full bus. days Details >


text:
In-Stat believes the ultra mobile device market is evolving to become a family of devices that will compose the "ultra mobile device (UMD) paradigm." According to the research firm, one ultra mobile device will not be able to meet all of the different UMD usages/applications.
In-Stat found the following in their report:
- The UMD worldwide forecast is for more than 8 million units in 2011
- 2008-2010 will be key years for the development of a market inflection point of anytime/anywhere wireless connectivity that is necessary for widespread adoption of the UMD paradigm
Three key features differentiate UMDs from products like PDAs and smart phones. First, UMDs must run a full operating system. Second, they must run any application as originally developed and compiled for PCs or notebooks. Third, UMDs must run full web pages unmodified (including flash and java applets) to provide complete Internet experiences.
The research, "Ultra Mobile Device (UMD, UMPC, MID, Micro PC)…A New Paradigm For Mobile User Applications" (#IN0703492SI), covers the worldwide market for ultra mobile devices. It provides a worldwide unit shipment forecast for UMDs through 2011. Extensive discussion of market drivers and barriers is also provided, including the technological developments necessary for market development. In addition to the report, Ian and other In-Stat analysts provide consulting services on a variety of technical and market topics regarding the semiconductor and electronics industries. The price is an ultra $2,995 (US).
More info:
Ultra Mobile Device (UMD, UMPC, MID, Micro PC)…A New Paradigm For Mobile User Applications


text: Questions Questions › Author "rachel23" Filter:QuestionsSubscribesSort byViewsAnswersVotes It is suggested that everyone wants to have a car, a television and a fridge. Do disadvantages of this development for society outweigh advantages? OpenPiyush Gaur answered 8 months ago • Writing Task 2 619 views1 answers0 votes Ask Question QuestionsRate this post


text:
VIPortal Forex is a Modern and Unique Online Forex facility
Email: email@example.com
VIPortal Forex
St. Vincent and The Grenadines
Our support team will do its best to provide the best possible and helpful answer for the issues you're having.
Using analytics in the Forex market allows you to predict the change in the trading instruments exchange rates with a considerable probability and use the information obtained in choosing the trading strategy.
VIPortal Forex was founded in 2013 with a deep understanding of traders' needs, we strive to provide the best trading conditions on the forex market


text:
|Billy - 32:55 - What a great little fellow! A construction worker from northeast Georgia, he's a masonary specialist. He has had a long relationship with a woman that he really loves, but has done him wrong. After things went south, he started experimenting with other sexual options. He says: "I live to enjoy time in the outdoors - hunting, fishing, camping, hiking, but I love my rock and roll music. I am bi-curious, but I love the female body."
Billy - 2nd Session - 21:15 - Billy, being the nature lover that he is, wanted to do something outdoors, so we did. We will probably do more once I find a more secluded spot.Enjoy!
Brandon - 31:15 - A painter and aspiring writer, he is a new addition to the Atlanta population. He is 32 y/o, 6' 2", and 165#, and loves to travel. Originally from Alabama, he has travelled extensively, but seems to have settled here in Atlanta - at least until he gets the urge to move on.
Frank - 31:00 - Cool Dude. Came a long way to do this session. Like many of my guys, he's spent time in prison, engaged in a lot of illegal activities, and is just trying to make it. He is 35 y/o, 5' 7", and 145#. and is a jack of all trades, including construction, landscaping, and breaking horses. His philosophy is: "Have fun and enjoy life". Amen to that
Jay - 1:01:10 - It took 4 attempts to finish this guy's session, and this video is the 2nd and 3rd. At his first try he had a stomach virus and he only stayed a few minutes. The two sessions featured here resulted in "equipment malfunction" and he was not able to get off. He is such a handsome man and well built that maybe some of you can enjoy just watching him. He is 26 y/o, 5' 11", and 190# and is a college student. He was successful in his final attempt, which is on another movie (Jay - final attempt).
Jay - Final Session - 20:45 - This is the final session of this handsome man, and the third time (actually the 4th) was the charm. I have no idea why this 26 year old had so much trouble getting off, but things finally worked this time. Enjoy!
|2014-08-31 03:28:39
|1.48 GB (1,589,973,211 bytes)
|Num files
|23 files


text:
A premier U.S. orchestra, the NSO performs approximately 150 concerts each year of classical, new works, pops, and special events, including nationally televised concerts on the lawn of the U.S. Capitol and numerous education and community engagement events.
One of the leading opera companies in the United States, WNO focuses on bold productions of classic operas, fascinating contemporary perspectives, and the best in American artistry.
Under the artistic direction of George Balanchine's most admired muse, the Kennedy Center's own ballet company encompasses an ever-growing repertoire of beloved ballets including more than 65 works choreographed by George Balanchine, Maurice Béjart, and Jerome Robbins.
Help us continue to provide the outstanding performances you've come to expect!
This event has already closed
Jason Moran, Kennedy Center's Artistic Advisor for Jazz, and The Bandwagon welcome two special guests: one of America's foremost jazz guitarists, Bill Frisell, and talented mezzo-soprano and jazz vocalist Alicia Hall Moran.
Mr. and Mrs. William C. PowersAdditional support is provided by Carolyn and Bill Powers.
AudiAudi of America is the Presenting Sponsor of the KC Jazz Club.
WAMUWAMU 88.5 FM and WPFW 89.3 FM are media partners of Kennedy Center Jazz.
The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts
2700 F Street, NW Washington, DC 20566
Building opens daily at 10 a.m.
Tickets & Information: (202) 467-4600
Toll-Free: (800) 444-1324
Box Office Hours:
Mon.-Sat., 10 a.m.-9 p.m.,
Sun. and Holidays, noon-9 p.m


text:
Form 941 is filed to report all of the following amounts:
The IRS requires a PIN number to E-file 941 forms with the IRS. Apply for one directly through Yearli software and online filing.
Form 941 is due by the last day of the month that follows the end of the quarter.
Please Note: If date shown falls on a Saturday, Sunday or legal holiday, the due date is the next business day.


text:
by Dauna Coulter
Huntsville AL (SPX) Apr 26, 2011
"Somewhere, something incredible is waiting to be known," wrote Carl Sagan. And now you can be the one to find it, thanks to Zooniverse, a unique citizen science website. Zooniverse volunteers, who call themselves "Zooites," are working on a project called Galaxy Zoo, classifying distant galaxies imaged by NASA's Hubble Space Telescope.1
"Not only are people better than computers at detecting the subtleties that differentiate galaxies, they can do things computers can't do, like spot things that just look interesting," explains Zooniverse director Chris Lintott, an astronomer at the University of Oxford.
Zooite Hanny van Arkel, a Dutch schoolteacher, discovered a strange green object floating in her cosmic soup. When van Arkel noticed this unusual greenish object and posted an image of it on the Galaxy Zoo forum, not even the experts knew what it was.2 They named it "Voorwerp," Dutch for "object."
Another group of Zooites found green "peas" in theirs, and dubbed themselves the "Peas-Corp."
The peas turned out to be small, round green galaxies about a tenth the size of the Milky Way. These are now believed to be the most efficient star factories in the universe, forming huge numbers of stars in a hurry. "It was easy to find 'peas' by computer once we knew they were there, but without the human factor we'd never have noticed them," says Lintott.
Lintott started Zooniverse in 2007 to solve a very large and unique problem: "I had too many galaxies on my hands," he explains.
Lintott was faced with classifying, by shape, one million galaxies imaged by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. First he did what any self-respecting scientist would do.
"I asked a graduate student to classify them."
The student was good at it, but after he catalogued 50,000 images, it was obvious he needed help - a lot of help - sorting the other 950,000. The solution came to Lintott and the very relieved student while they were sitting in a pub.
"Why not ask for volunteers?"
Zooniverse and its first project, Galaxy Zoo, were born.
"We were blown away by the response. We had so many hits that our web server crashed on the first morning!"
They quickly solved the server problem and the project took off. With the Hubble Space Telescope, Galaxy Zoo is taking volunteers deeper into the cosmos than ever before. And the Zooniverse team has proven that the Zooites' classifications are as good as those by professional astronomers.
"Their contributions are extremely important," says Lintott. "They're helping us learn how galaxies form and evolve. And they take their work seriously."
But that doesn't prevent them from bringing a sense of adventure and just sheer fun to the research.
"Not long ago some Zooites asked us to take them on a pilgrimage to Zooniverse's birthplace. There was quite a celebration at the pub that night!"3
After Galaxy Zoo kicked off, scientists began approaching Lintott at conferences asking for help. "They realized that we'd found a great way to sort a lot of data fast."
Zooniverse now offers several citizen science projects, including three more using NASA data. Moon Zoo volunteers use data from NASA's Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter to count craters, helping write the history of the moon. Milky Way project participants scour infrared images gathered in two NASA Spitzer Space Telescope surveys of the Milky Way's inner regions. They help astronomers catalogue intriguing features, map our galaxy, and plan future research. Zooniverse's Planet Hunters are helping NASA's Kepler telescope find stars likely to host planets.
"I'd love to confirm one of their finds and be able to send an email to someone saying, 'You've found a planet!' "
Now, please excuse this writer. She has planet hunting to do.
Related Links
Astronomy News from Skynightly.com
|The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2014 - Space Media Network. AFP, UPI and IANS news wire stories are copyright Agence France-Presse, United Press International and Indo-Asia News Service. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by Space Media Network on any Web page published or hosted by Space Media Network. Privacy Statement