text:
- Dora Jennings
- 1 years ago
- Views:
1 HOW BATTLES OVER COLLECTION OF SALES TAXES ON ONLINE SALES WILL AFFECT SMALL BUSINESSES ESPECIALLY AFFILIATES OF LARGE SELLERS LIKE AMAZON.COM AMELIA LANDENBERGER * I. INTRODUCTION Since its founding, Amazon.com and many similar online retailers have not collected sales taxes on online sales. 1 This uncollected sales tax could be a source of additional revenue, which might be especially appealing for states facing budget cuts. The recent battles between Amazon.com and individual states over collection of sales taxes have had negative consequences for entrepreneurs, especially Amazon Affiliates, who gain a percentage of sales by referring customers to Amazon.com. One solution to Amazon s problem would be national legislation on the issue. However, this legislation might make online sales more difficult for small businesses that sell goods over the internet, as they would have to find some way of dealing with the intricacies of state and local sales taxes in order to sell on the internet. Sales taxes date back at least as far as the ancient Egyptians, 2 but the specific problems of interstate sales are much more recent. Shoppers for years have crossed state lines to get lower rates. Before the Internet, many catalog-retailers didn't charge tax to out-of-state customers. 3 Sales taxes began to be generally used in the United States during the Great Depression, as states struggled to find alternative sources of revenue to replace dwindling property taxes. 4 After the Depression began, local * Juris Doctor, The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law, expected Stu Woo, Amazon Battles States over Sales Tax, WALL ST. J. (Aug. 3, 2011), html. 2 Tomb paintings depict tax collectors in Egypt at least as early as 2000 BC, and sales taxes on individual commodities, such as cooking oil, can be traced to that time. William F. Fox, History and Economic Impact, U. OF TENN. CTR. FOR BUS. AND ECON. RES. (Mar. 13, 2002), available at mnmecon338/ foxipt.pdf. 3 Woo, supra note 1. 4 Mississippi enacted the first modern general sales tax in No revenue innovation has been greeted so enthusiastically by state legislatures. Twenty-one more states and the Territory of Hawaii adopted the sales tax by 1940, with 12 of them doing so in 1933 alone. Ronald Snell, State Finance in the Great
2 226 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL government property tax collections did not again reach the 1927 level until For states, it took until 1952 to reach the 1927 level, although in the interval, states had reduced their reliance upon the tax. 6 Forty-five of the fifty states currently collect state sales taxes. 7 Alaska, Delaware, Montana, New Hampshire, and Oregon do not have state sales taxes, but Alaska and Oregon collect some local taxes, New Hampshire taxes food in restaurants and rooms in hotels, and Delaware and Montana have transient lodging taxes. 8 Of the states that do collect sales tax, the taxes range from 2.9% in Colorado to 8.25% in California. 9 Given the condition of the economy, states are looking for more money to balance their budgets, as some 42 states and the District of Columbia have closed or are working to close $103 billion in shortfalls for the coming fiscal year (FY2012). 10 One source of additional revenue for these states could be sales taxes collected on online purchases. While consumers in most states are required to report such purchases and pay sales tax on them, few do: In Ohio, for example, over 60% of households said they made online purchases last year but sales taxes for such purchases were paid on less than 1% of state income tax returns. 11 Jeff Bezos, the founder of Amazon.com, knew that sales tax would be an important issue, and decided to locate his business in a state with a small Depression, NAT L CONF. OF ST. LEGISLATURES 5 (Mar. 2009), available at 5 Id. at 3. 6 Id. 7 State Sales Tax Rates and Food and Drug Exemptions, FED. OF TAX ADMIN. (Feb. 2011), available at 8 Sales and Use Tax, ALASKA DEPT. OF REVENUE, programs/programs/index.aspx?10002 (last visited Mar. 27, 2012); Sales Tax Information, OR. DEPT. OF REVENUE, (last visited Mar. 27, 2012); Food and Beverage Tax, CITY OF ASHLAND, (last visited Mar. 27, 2012) (discussing that the city of Ashland, Oregon, has the only voter approved sales tax in Oregon. A five percent tax is collected on all prepared food sold in Ashland. ); Does NH Have an Income Tax or Sales Tax?, N. H. DEPT. OF REV. ADMIN., revenue/faq/gti-rev.htm#meals-rental (last visited Mar. 27, 2012); Lodging Tax Collection, DEL. CODE, c061/sc01/index.shtml (last visited Mar. 27, 2012); Lodging Facility Sales and Use Tax, MONT. DEPT. OF REV., taxes_licenses_fees_permits/ Miscellaneous_Taxes_and_Fees/lodging.mcpx (last visited Mar. 27, 2012). 9 State Sales Tax Rates and Food and Drug Exemptions, FED. OF TAX ADMIN. (Feb. 2011), available at 10 Elizabeth McNichol, Phil Oliff & Nicholas Johnson, States Continue to Feel Recession s Impact, CTR. ON BUDGET & POL Y PRIORITIES (June 11, 2011), available at 11 Brad Tuttle, Amazon Supports a Bill Forcing Online Shoppers to Pay Sales Tax, TIME.COM (Nov. 11, 2011), amazonsupports-a-bill-forcing-online-shoppers-to-pay-sales-tax/#ixzz1dbrjlzjy.
3 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 227 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com population because he knew he would be forced to collect sales tax in that state. He explained his decision: It sounds counterintuitive, but physical location is very important for the success of a virtual business. We could have started Amazon.com anywhere. We chose Seattle because it met a rigorous set of criteria. It had to be a place with lots of technical talent. It had to be near a place with large numbers of books. It had to be a nice place to live great people won't work in places they don't want to live. Finally, it had to be in a small state. In the mail-order business, you have to charge sales tax to customers who live in any state where you have a business presence. It made no sense for us to be in California or New York. 12 Bezos even considered trying to locate his business out of the reach of any state s sales tax, on an Indian reservation near San Francisco. 13 A. Quill Corp. v. North Dakota In 1967, National Bellas Hess, Inc. v. Department of Revenue of State of Illinois created a bright line rule that did not allow the state of Illinois to require a mail-order company from Missouri to collect Illinois use tax on purchases shipped to Illinois. 14 The court noted that it would require use tax collection [w]here the sales were arranged by local agents in the taxing State 15 or where a mail order company had retail stores in that state, 16 [b]ut the Court has never held that a State may impose the duty of use tax collection and payment upon a seller whose only connection with customers in the State is by common carrier or the United States mail. 17 In 1992, North Dakota attempt[ed] to require an out-of-state mailorder house that has neither outlets nor sales representatives in the State to collect and pay a use tax on goods purchased for use within the State. 18 In 12 William C. Taylor, Who s Writing the Book on Web Business, FAST CO. (Oct. 31, 1996), 13 Id. Bezos ruefully acknowledged that he could not avoid sales taxes by founding his business on a Native American reservation because [u]nfortunately, the government thought of that first. Id. While on-reservation sales by Indians to Indians are not taxed when the buyers are not Native Americans, the state can still compel sales tax collection by Native Americans. Moe v. Confederated Salish & Kootenai Tribes of Flathead Reservation, 425 U.S. 463, (1976). 14 Nat'l Bellas Hess, Inc. v. Dep't of Revenue of State of Ill., 386 U.S. 753, 754 (1967). 15 Id. at Id. 17 Id. at Quill Corp. v. N. D. By & Through Heitkamp, 504 U.S. 298, 301 (1992).
4 228 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL Quill Corp. v. North Dakota By & Through Heitkamp, the Supreme Court held that the requirement for out of state vendors to collect that tax violated the Commerce Clause, distinguishing Commerce Clause tests from those tests used under the Due Process Clause by saying, [a]ccordingly, while a State may, consistent with the Due Process Clause, have the authority to tax a particular taxpayer, imposition of the tax may nonetheless violate the Commerce Clause. 19 The Due Process Clause does not prevent collection of sales taxes in Quill because by selling in North Dakota, Quill had the minimum contacts. 20 But the commerce clause prevents collection of sales taxes in this instance because Quill did not have a substantial nexus. The Court cited Bellas Hess, which stands for the proposition that a vendor whose only contacts with the taxing State are by mail or common carrier lacks the substantial nexus required by the Commerce Clause. 21 While the Supreme Court did not allow North Dakota to collect the sales tax in Quill, it did leave for Congress the option of creating national legislation by which the states can require interstate companies to collect use taxes. 22 Such legislation has actually been proposed in Congress, but it remains to be seen whether it will pass. II. PROBLEM: EFFECT ON SMALL BUSINESSES, ESPECIALLY AFFILIATES Kayla Fay, a mother in North Carolina, made $40,000 a year from her websites, most of that from affiliate programs with Amazon and another 19 Id. at The requirements of due process are met irrespective of a corporation's lack of physical presence in the taxing State. Id. at Id. at When deciding whether or not to reject the Bellas Hess rule, the court explained: This aspect of our decision is made easier by the fact that the underlying issue is not only one that Congress may be better qualified to resolve, but also one that Congress has the ultimate power to resolve. No matter how we evaluate the burdens that use taxes impose on interstate commerce, Congress remains free to disagree with our conclusions. Indeed, in recent years Congress has considered legislation that would overrule the Bellas Hess rule. Its decision not to take action in this direction may, of course, have been dictated by respect for our holding in Bellas Hess that the Due Process Clause prohibits States from imposing such taxes, but today we have put that problem to rest. Accordingly, Congress is now free to decide whether, when, and to what extent the States may burden interstate mail-order concerns with a duty to collect use taxes. Id. at 318.
5 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 229 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com online company. 23 When North Carolina passed a law requiring online retailers with affiliates in the state to collect sales taxes, Amazon ended its Amazon Associates Program in North Carolina. 24 Lydia Walshin, who lives in Scituate, [Rhode Island] depended on Amazon affiliate marketing to monetize her cooking blog, ThePerfectPantry.com. After Amazon cut off its affiliates, Walshin moved her operations to Massachusetts, where she also has a home and a bank account, and Amazon had her back up and running within 24 hours. 25 Another entrepreneur, Owen Johnson, was earning small, but growing income from his personal blog and a site he runs called Connect Providence as an affiliate before Amazon ended the program [in Rhode Island]. Now he is wondering whether to move his business out of state. You re creating an environment of uncertainty in which to do business, he said. 26 These three individuals were members of Amazon s Associates Program. Members promote products sold on Amazon, usually through a blog or website. When a customer clicks through to Amazon from one of the Associate s links, and then either purchases something within twentyfour hours or adds something to the shopping cart which is then purchased within eighty-nine days, the Associate earns between four and fifteen percent of the purchase price Mark Binker, Amazon Warns N.C. Affiliates about Tax Issue, NEWS- RECORD.COM (June 17, 2009), 06/17/article/amazon_warns_nc_affiliates_about_tax_issue. 24 Mark Binker, Amazon Cuts Relationship with N.C. Affiliates, NEWS- RECORD.COM (June 26, 2009), article/amazon_cuts_relationships_with_affiliates [hereinafter Amazon Cuts Relationship with N.C. Affiliates]. 25 Ted Nesi, Amazon Tax Has Not Generated Revenue, PROVIDENCE BUS. NEWS (Dec. 21, 2009), 26 Id. 27 Associates Program Operating Agreement, AMAZON.COM, https://affiliateprogram.amazon.com/gp/associates/agreement?ie=utf8&pf_rd_t=501&ref_=amb _link_ _6&pf_rd_m=atvpdkikx0der&pf_rd_p=&pf_rd_s=assocright-1&pf_rd_r=&pf_rd_i=assoc_join_menu (last visited Mar. 27, 2012); Associates Program Advertising Fee Schedule, AMAZON.COM, https://affiliateprogram.amazon.com/gp/associates/help/operating/advertisingfees?ie=utf8&pf_r d_t=501&ref_=amb_link_ _9&pf_rd_m=atvpdkikx0der&pf_rd_p =&pf_rd_s=assoc-center-1&pf_rd_r=&pf_rd_i=assoc_operating (last visited Mar. 27, 2012) [hereinafter Operating Agreement].
6 230 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL Amazon is not the only large retailer to have such a program, although it is probably the most famous. Staples has a similar program, 28 and many well known brands such as Target, Kmart, Netflix, Sears, OfficeMax, SamsClub, and Verizon have affiliate programs administered by Google s Affiliate Network. 29 Unlike Amazon, however, most of these retailers have physical retail stores in most states, which is a sufficient nexus to force them to collect sales tax. Target, for example, collects sales tax in all of the states that have a sales tax. 30 Overall, e-commerce sales have grown from $995.0 billion in 1999 to $2,385 billion by Amazon.com is currently the largest online retailer, 32 but collection of sales taxes could have a huge negative impact on Amazon s sales: Credit Suisse recently estimated that if Amazon were forced to collect sales taxes in all states, it would lose as much as $653 million in sales this year, or 1.4% out of an estimated $45.5 billion in revenue. 33 Amazon has another good reason why it does not want to collect sales tax. Retailers can be forced to pay penalties when they collect the wrong amount of sales tax, and it is complicated to collect the correct amount because of the many different local taxes: J.C. Penney, for example, has had to pay penalties on miscalculations of online sales taxes. Wayne Zakrewski, the company's tax lawyer, says because of the complicated calculations, errors are more often the case than not. 34 This is one of the reasons why forced collection of sales taxes by online retailers could be very bad for small businesses. Even large businesses like J.C. Penney struggle to comply with the many different sales tax requirements, making online sales tax collection prohibitively costly for small businesses. Small businesses might be forced to use a larger business as a facilitator, by selling their products through a website such as Amazon Marketplace or ebay. Then small businesses would have to pay a 28 The Staples affiliate program, however, is not as lucrative as Amazon s, as it excludes big ticket items such as [c]opiers, fax machines, printers, laptops, desktops and only gives up to 5%, and that only on office supplies such as tape and rubber bands. Affiliate Program, STAPLES.COM, content/about/affiliate/ (last visited Mar. 27, 2012). 29 Google Affiliate Network, GOOGLE.COM, affiliatenetwork/publishers/#tab0=1 (last visited Mar. 27, 2012). 30 This fact is frequently cited by those seeking to force Amazon to collect sales tax, as Amazon facilitates online sales for Target, and therefore facilitates the collection of sales taxes on Target.com s online sales. All About Sales Tax, TARGET.COM, help/orders_and_shipping/sales_tax/sales_tax.html (last visited Mar. 27, 2012). 31 Donald Bruce, William Fox & LeAnn Luna, State and Local Government Sales Tax Revenue Losses from Electronic Commerce, U. OF TENN. CTR. FOR BUS. AND ECON. RES. (Apr. 13, 2009), available at 32 Woo, supra note Id. 34 Robert Matthews, Some States Push to Collect Sales Tax from Internet Stores, WALL ST. J., Sept. 30, 2005, at B1.
7 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 231 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com percentage to the facilitating company to avoid dealing with complicated sales tax calculations. This would still leave small businesses at a disadvantage to larger businesses with better technology and accounting departments. But many states are facing serious budget issues, and many are trying to collect sales taxes from online sales in an attempt to pull in some more tax money to help their budgets. The states would be happy to collect extra sales taxes, especially since they may be missing as much as billion dollars in state and local taxes nationally. 35 As the states battle with Amazon, small businesses suffer. When the states try to collect sales taxes on online purchases, Amazon cuts its affiliates to avoid being forced to collect sales tax. These affiliates were mostly entrepreneurs who are now unemployed. The state loses the revenue from the income taxes on the now-unemployed affiliates, and in some cases is unable to collect any more sales taxes, since by getting rid of its affiliates, Amazon is not required to collect sales taxes on its online sales. 36 Forcing Amazon to collect sales taxes may just hurt small businesses more. Affiliates will lose revenue, and shoppers driven from Amazon by rising prices may only go to other large retailers rather than buying from small businesses. Furthermore, small businesses that sell online would now be forced to deal with the intricacies of the various sales tax laws, which would make it very costly for small businesses to sell online. III. CAUSE: STATE LAWS ATTEMPT TO COLLECT MONEY AND BALANCE BUDGETS Since its founding, Amazon has collected sales taxes in its home state of Washington. It could hardly do otherwise, as its headquarters constitute a clear physical presence in the state. It also collects sales tax in Kansas, Kentucky and North Dakota, where it has a physical presence. 37 It avoids collecting in several other states where it has warehouses by assigning their ownership to a subsidiary. 38 For years, both Amazon and the other states have been happy with this arrangement, but recent economic conditions have caused many states to reevaluate their position, and consider changing their laws to require Amazon to collect sales taxes because of its warehouses or affiliates. 35 Bruce, Fox & Luna, supra note Nesi, supra note Verne Kopytoff, Amazon Pressured on Sales Tax, N.Y. TIMES (Mar. 13, 2011), 38 Id.
8 232 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL In addition to pressure to balance budgets, states are also under pressure from Amazon s competitors, who want Amazon to be forced to collect sales tax. Wal-Mart Stores Inc., Target Corp. and other large retailers are ratcheting up a political campaign to force Amazon.com Inc. to collect sales taxes, sensing opportunity in the budget crises gripping statehouses nationwide. The big-box stores are backing a coalition called the Alliance for Main Street Fairness, which is leading efforts to change sales-tax laws in more than a dozen states including Texas and California. [ ] Many of America's largest store chains including Wal-Mart, Target, Best Buy Co., Home Depot Inc. and Sears Holdings Corp. are involved in the campaign, lobbying legislators and increasingly taking public swipes at Amazon. 39 Members of the Alliance for Main Street Fairness ( Alliance ) say they are only looking for fairness, but an Amazon representative said the other companies covet Amazon s affiliate program. 40 These companies are in competition with Amazon, and hope that if Amazon is forced to collect sales tax, consumers will choose to shop in physical stores rather than online. In 2008, New York passed a law requiring any online company with any affiliates in the state to begin collecting sales tax. 41 Amazon responded by filing a lawsuit, alleging that the New York law violated the Commerce Clause, Equal Protection Clause, and Due Process. 42 The court battle is ongoing, but Amazon is collecting sales tax in New York until the case is decided. 43 When other states sought to pass similar laws, Amazon dropped its affiliates in those states in order to avoid being forced to collect sales taxes there. Currently, residents of North Carolina, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Colorado, Arkansas and Illinois are not eligible to become members of the Amazon Associates Program. 44 All of these states passed laws similar to the 39 Miguel Bustillo & Stu Woo, Retailers Push Amazon on Taxes, WALL ST. J. (Mar. 17, 2011), html. 40 Id. 41 Saul Hansell, Amazon Sues over State Law on Collection of Sales Tax, N.Y. TIMES (May 2, 2008), 02amazon.html. 42 Amazon.com, LLC v. N.Y. State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 81 A.D.3d 183, 191 (2010). 43 Id. at Operating Agreement, supra, note 27.
9 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 233 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com one in New York, and in all of these cases, Amazon retaliated by dropping all of its affiliates in each state. 45 California, Texas, Tennessee, and Indiana have all come to agreements with Amazon. In California, Amazon will not have to collect sales taxes until 2012, unless federal legislation creates a national sales tax collection policy first. 46 After a battle with Texas over sales tax collection, Amazon agreed to invest $300 million in five or six warehouse and distribution centers in the state, employing 6,000 people, if lawmakers would let the company operate for four-and-a-half years without collecting sales taxes. 47 In Tennessee, Amazon has agreed to collect sales taxes in 2014, in exchange for building new distribution centers there. 48 In Indiana, Amazon agreed to collect sales taxes after 2014, or within ninety days of the passage of national sales tax legislation, and Indiana s governor spoke in favor of national sales tax legislation, which Amazon supports. 49 More deals with states are likely to follow, as Amazon seems to anticipate national legislation in a few years, but is hoping to continue to avoid collection of sales tax in the meantime. A. New York The recent surge in online sales tax collection laws came from New York. In 2008, New York passed a law requiring any online company with any affiliates in the state to begin collecting sales tax. 50 The law specifically required a seller to collect sales tax if the seller enters into an agreement with a resident of this state under which the resident, for a commission or other consideration, directly or indirectly refers potential customers, 45 See Amazon Cuts Relationship with N.C. Affiliates, supra note 24; Susan Haigh, Conn. Gets Tough with Amazon, Pushing on with Tax, BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK (Oct. 9, 2011), financialnews/d9q8tv3o1.htm; Miles Moffeit & Jessica Fender, Amazon.com Drops Colorado Retailers After Tax Law Enacted, DENV. POST (Mar. 9, 2010), Nesi, supra note 25; Kyung M. Song, Tax-Free Shopping Doomed?, CHI. SUN TIMES (Nov. 13, 2011), /tax-free-shopping-doomed.html. 46 David Streitfeld, California Lawmakers Give Amazon Tax Reprieve, N.Y. TIMES (Sept. 10, 2011), 47 Ross Ramsey, Let s Make a Deal, Amazon Tells Texas, N.Y. TIMES (June 23, 2011), 48 Erik Schelzig, Amazon to Collect Tenn. Sales Tax in 2014, Add 2,000 Jobs, THE SEATTLE TIMES (Oct. 6, 2011), businesstechnology/ _amazontenn07.html. 49 Tom Davies, Amazon's Online Sales Tax: Internet Retailer Reaches Deal With Indiana, HUFFINGTON POST (Jan. 9, 2012), /01/09/amazons-sales-tax-indiana_n_ html 50 Hansell, supra note 41.
10 234 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL whether by a link on an internet website or otherwise, to the seller, 51 and if that seller makes more than $10,000 a year on transactions referred to it by New York residents. When other states later passed similar laws, Amazon immediately dropped its affiliates in those states, but in New York, Amazon took another approach. On April 25, 2008, two days after the bill was signed by the Governor, Amazon filed a complaint seeking declaratory and injunctive relief on the ground that the statute was unconstitutional. Amazon asserted claims for violation of the Commerce, Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses 52 The State moved to dismiss and the court granted the motion. 53 Amazon appealed and the Supreme Court, Appellate Division, heard the appeal. It described the case as a case with far-reaching ramifications because of the exponential expansion of cyberspace in general, and commerce over the Internet in particular. 54 The court concluded that on its face the statute does not violate the Commerce Clause. 55 The court modified the previous judgment to declare that the statute is constitutional on its face and does not violate the Equal Protection Clause either on its face or as applied and, to reinstate the complaint for further proceedings with regard to the claims that, as applied, the statute violates the Commerce and Due Process Clauses 56 The case was remanded to the lower court to rule on Amazon s claims that the statute as-applied violates the Commerce and Due Process Clauses. Amazon will be given a chance to prove that its affiliates are only advertising on their behalf, not soliciting business, 57 and therefore the law as applied violates the Commerce clause. Amazon also claims that the New York affiliates are not significantly associated with Amazon s ability to do business within the state, as in 2007, its sales to New York State residents referred by Associates which provided Amazon with New 51 McKinney s New York Tax Law 1101(b)(8)(vi) (2008). 52 Amazon.com, LLC v. N. Y. State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 81 A.D.3d 183, 191 (2010). 53 Id. at Id. at Id. at 196. It imposes a tax collection obligation on an out-of-state vendor only where the vendor enters into a business-referral agreement with a New York State resident, and only when that resident receives a commission based on a sale in New York. The statute does not target the out-of-state vendor's sales through agents who are not New York residents. Thus, the nexus requirement is satisfied. Id. 56 Id. at Id. at 203.
11 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 235 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com York addresses upon registration constituted less than 1.5% of its total sales to New York State residents. 58 It is unclear why Amazon took a different approach to the New York law than it took to later laws in other states. Perhaps it did not want to lose all the affiliates in such a populous state, or perhaps Amazon hoped to win its suit and dare the other states to try a similar law. Whatever the reason, instead of dropping all of its affiliates, 59 Amazon has been collecting sales taxes in New York, which collected $70 million in sales tax from online retailers, including Amazon, for fiscal year In the meantime, Amazon is continuing its legal battle in the New York courts. 61 Perhaps inspired by New York s increased sales tax revenue, other states have been passing similar online sales tax collection laws, but Amazon has reacted very differently in other states. B. North Carolina, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Arkansas, Colorado, Illinois Currently, residents of North Carolina, Rhode Island, Connecticut, Colorado, Arkansas and Illinois are not eligible to become members of the Amazon Associates Program. 62 All of these states have tried to force Amazon to collect sales taxes. Amazon has retaliated by cutting its affiliates in order to avoid paying the taxes, so in most cases the states do not collect more sales taxes. The real losers are the entrepreneurs who operate as affiliates, who must choose between moving to a new state and finding a new source of income. 58 Amazon.com, LLC, 81 A.D.3d at 204. The court, in a footnote, points out that Amazon s annual sales are so large that even 1.5% of the New York sales may be a significant amount: The affidavit did not supply the sales data upon which the calculation was based. An Internet search, however, found, and we take judicial notice, that on April 22, 2010 Amazon reported that its first quarter sales in Canada and the United States were $3,780,000,000 (which would translate on an annual basis into North American sales of over $15,000,000,000). What percentage of those sales were made in New York cannot be quantified from the data available. Nor can the actual percentage made as a result of New York residents accessing New Yorkbased Associates be calculated. Even 1.5% of New York sales by New York Associates, however, would not appear to be an insignificant number. Id. at New York is not one of the states blacklisted by the Associates Program. Operating Agreement, supra, note Kopytoff, supra note Streitfeld, supra note Operating Agreement, supra note 27.
12 236 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL In North Carolina, Amazon cut ties with all its affiliates after a new law forced the company to collect sales taxes. 63 North Carolina s Department of Revenue ( DOR ) then audited Amazon to try to collect sales taxes on items purchased over the past few years. 64 Amazon provided extensive records of its sales, but not of the buyers. 65 The issue arose when North Carolina then asked Amazon to provide the names and addresses of its North Carolina customers. 66 Amazon maintains that if the DOR obtains the information it seeks, it will possess all information necessary to know the expressive content of all purchases from Amazon by individual North Carolina residents. 67 Amazon filed suit on April 9, 2009, claiming that its customers First Amendment rights were being violated. 68 The American Civil Liberties Union represented seven North Carolina residents who filed a complaint in intervention. 69 The court granted the motion for summary judgment for Amazon on the issue that the North Carolina DOR s request was a violation of the First Amendment. 70 In January 2011, the case was settled between the seven residents and the DOR. 71 In December of 2009, six months after Rhode Island had begun requiring online retailers to collect sales tax and Amazon shut down its Associates Program in the state, there was some doubt whether the tax had actually generated any revenue. 72 It was reported that state officials had 63 Amazon Cuts Relationship with N.C. Affiliates, supra note Associated Press, NC Tax Man Drops Bid to See Amazon Buyers' Data, SEATTLE TIMES (Feb. 9, 2011), / _apncamazonsalestaxes1stldwritethru.html?syndication=rss. 65 Amazon.com, LLC v. Lay, 758 F. Supp. 2d 1154, 1159 (W.D. Wash. 2010). As part of an audit of Amazon, the DOR, whose secretary is Defendant Lay, sent a request on December 1, 2009 to Amazon seeking all information for all sales to customers with a North Carolina shipping address by month in an electronic format for all dates between August 1, 2003, and February 28, Notably, the request was made as part of DOR's investigation of Amazon's tax liability, not its customers' tax liability. In response, Amazon provided the DOR with detailed information about millions of purchases made by North Carolina customers during the relevant time period. Amazon provided the order ID number, seller, ship-to city, county, postal code, the non-taxable amount of the purchase, and the tax audit record identification. In addition, Amazon provided the Amazon Specific Identification Number for every purchase, a number which permits access to the specific and detailed description of the product. Id. (internal citations omitted). 66 Id. 67 Id. 68 Id. at Id. 70 Id. at Associated Press, supra note Nesi, supra note 25.
13 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 237 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com doubts about the law s effectiveness: Officials at the R.I. Department of Revenue do not believe that there has been any sales tax collected as a result of the Amazon legislation, said Paul L. Dion, who heads the department s revenue-analysis office. 73 Connecticut passed a law requiring online retailers with a physical presence in the state to collect sales taxes, and Amazon closed its Associates Program in response a month later. 74 The state was still not content, and is considering trying to collect taxes from the time between the enacting of the law and the ending of Amazon s affiliate program in the state. 75 The state is also considering suing Amazon based on its other connections to Connecticut. 76 Colorado also passed a law that aimed to force consumers to pay taxes on online purchases: Colorado HB 1193, enacted in February 2010, required online retailers to provide a detailed purchase report to customers with more than $500 of annual Colorado purchases by January 31st and to provide a summary purchase report with the total amount of each customer's annual Colorado purchases to the Colorado Department of Revenue by March 31st. This law is currently the subject of a legal challenge brought by the Direct Marketing Association and others. In the meantime, the U.S. District Court has suspended enactment of the law while the legal challenge proceeds. 77 On March 9, 2010, Amazon cut ties with all of its Colorado Associates because of the new law, which, in Amazon s opinion, clearly intended to increase the compliance burden to a point where online retailers will be induced to voluntarily collect Colorado sales tax a course we won't take." 78 From 2005 to 2010, Illinois lost an estimated $183 million each year in uncollected online sales taxes, according to Illinois Senator Dick Durbin, who proposed national legislation on the issue. 79 Amazon cut its affiliate program in Illinois after a law was passed in March of 2011 that would 73 Id. 74 Haigh, supra note Id. 76 Id. 77 Sales Tax Requirements, AMAZON.COM, customer/display.html/ref=hp_468512_usetax?nodeid=468512#usetax (last visited Mar. 28, 2012). 78 Moffeit, supra note Song, supra note 45.
14 238 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL have forced Amazon to collect sales tax. 80 Amazon said it would eliminate its affiliate program there on April Despite the new tax, Illinois has not actually raised much revenue, as termination of affiliates has meant that Amazon still does not collect sales tax in Illinois. In order to continue in the affiliate program, two large affiliates actually moved their businesses out of state: CouponCabin and its employees departed River North for Whiting, Ind. Rockton-based FatWallet moved a few miles north to Beloit, Wis., in April, a spokesman says. Each employs fewer than 100 people. 82 Barnes and Noble, one of Amazon s competitors, wrote an open letter to Amazon s dropped Illinois Associates, inviting them to become associates for Barnes and Noble instead. The letter said, Barnes & Noble is disappointed to hear that Amazon would threaten small businesses livelihood rather than comply with state law. Here at Barnes & Noble, we value the 13,000+ members of our affiliate program worldwide.... If Amazon doesn t want you, we do! 83 The affiliates in these states have had to deal with their loss of livelihood, and the issue seems unlikely to be resolved by individual negotiations with these states. States which have passed legislation and in which Amazon has cut its affiliates seem embittered beyond the point of negotiation, so this situation will likely remain unless national legislation forces Amazon to collect sales tax in all states. C. Texas, South Carolina, California and Tennessee In Texas, Amazon finally cut a deal in June 2011 after a long fight, in which the state s tax collector sent Amazon a $269 million tax bill, saying its distribution center in Irving establishes a legal footprint that requires it to collect sales taxes from Texas customers. 84 As in many other states, Amazon retaliated against what it viewed as a hostile law: Amazon had threatened to shut down its Irving, Texas, distribution center. Eventually it let go all 112 employees who worked there. Workers hired by a temporary employment firm are maintaining the facility. 85 Finally, Amazon and the state came to an agreement: Amazon offered Thursday to invest $ Id. 81 Kopytoff, supra note John Pletz, Illinois' Bid to Collect Sales Taxes on Internet Shopping Comes up Empty, CRAIN S CHI. BUS. (Sept. 12, 2011), article/ /issue01/ /illinois-bid-to-collect-sales-taxes-oninternet-shopping-comes-up-empty#ixzz1jxjl7as2. 83 Open Letter to Amazon Affiliates, BARNES & NOBLE (Feb. 14, 2011), 84 Ramsey, supra note Maria Halkias, Amazon Offers Texas 5,000 Jobs in Trade for Sales-Tax Exemption, SEATTLE TIMES (June 21, 2011), html/businesstechnology/ _amazontexas22.html.
15 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 239 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com million in five or six warehouse and distribution centers in the state, employing 6,000 people, if lawmakers would let the company operate for four-and-a-half years without collecting sales taxes. 86 Interestingly, Amazon also wants the state to set up a website where its customers can send sales tax owed on Amazon purchases to the state. 87 This is an appealing compromise provision, since if Texas residents began voluntarily reporting and paying sales tax on online purchases there would be no need for Amazon to collect the tax itself. The South Carolina legislature compromised with Amazon against the wishes of the Governor, Nikki Haley. 88 Amazon got a five year exemption from sales tax collection in return for a promise of jobs and a $125 million investment in the state. 89 Amazon also agreed to include a clause in each purchase confirmation telling customers they could owe the sales tax to the state. The must include a link to the state Revenue Department. 90 This could be a purely symbolic measure, as few customers in other states who buy online actually pay sales tax on their purchases voluntarily. 91 Amazon also must send customers, either by mail or , a yearly tally of what they've spent, and specify they may owe the sales tax on their income tax returns. 92 However, the state will not receive that information about online purchases, so buyers would still be able to choose not to pay the sales taxes on their online purchases with little chance of consequences from the state s department of revenue. Like other states, California is facing severe budget issues. Meanwhile, only 1% of consumers pay use tax by voluntarily reporting online purchases on tax forms, and $1.1 billion goes uncollected, according to the state's legislative analyst. 93 This uncollected money is very appealing to state legislators. In June, California passed a bill to require sales tax collection by [a]ny retailer entering into an agreement or agreements under which a person or persons in this state, for a commission or other consideration, directly or indirectly refer potential purchasers of tangible personal property to the retailer, whether by an Internetbased link or an Internet Web site, or otherwise if that retailer 86 Ramsey, supra note Halkias, supra note Seanna Adcox, S.C. Legislators Give Final OK to Amazon Sales-Tax Deal, SEATTLE TIMES (June 1, 2011), businesstechnology/ _scsalestax02.html. 89 Id. 90 Id. 91 Tuttle, supra note Adcox, supra note Bustillo & Woo, supra note 39.
16 240 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL makes more than $10,000 on referred sales or more than $500,000 of sales in the past 12 months in the state. 94 Amazon dropped its California affiliates by August 2, On September 9th, the California legislature printed a statement of legislative intent to clarify Assembly Bill X The statement made it clear that online advertising, including those ads tied to Internet search engines, banner ads, click-through ads, Cost Per Action ads, links to retailer websites and similar online advertising services should not be considered a referral under subparagraph 5(A). 97 The legislature explains: Those types of advertising services are generated as a result of generic algorithmic functions and are anonymous and passive in nature and thus do not rise to the level of referring or soliciting business. 98 This effectively allowed Amazon Associates to continue operating in the state without collecting sales tax. On September 23, 2011, Amazon Associates were allowed to do business in California again. 99 However, this is just a compromising measure letting Amazon operate without charging sales tax for a year. According to the agreement, Amazon agreed to start collecting the tax in September 2012 unless there was federal legislation on the issue. 100 In fact, Amazon advocates a national sales tax for online retailers, which it argues would simplify tax collection. 101 However, the author of a New York Times article on the compromise points out that Amazon might be trying to buy some time. If it moves several small subsidiaries out of the state, it could 94 ASSEMB. B. 128, Sess. (Ca. 2011), available at 95 Recent Updates to the Associates Operating Agreement, AMAZON.COM, https://affiliate-program.amazon.com/gp/associates/help/operating/compare?ie=utf8&pf_rd_t=501&ref_=amb_link_ _1&pf_rd_m=atvpdkikx 0DER&pf_rd_p=&pf_rd_s=assoc-center-1&pf_rd_r=&pf_rd_i=assoc_operating (last visited Mar. 27, 2012); see generally Operating Agreement, supra note ASSEMB. DAILY J. CA. LEG., 2011 Leg., st Extraordinary Sess., at 338 (Ca. 2011), available at _1x.pdf. This statement of legislative intent clarifies Assembly Bill 128, which amended the tax code to require sales tax collection from retailers engaged in business in the state. ASSEM. 28, 2011 LEG., 2011 SESS. (Ca. 2011), available at _chaptered.pdf. 97 Id. 98 Id. 99 Recent Updates to the Associates Operating Agreement, AMAZON.COM, https://affiliate-program.amazon.com/gp/associates/help/operating/compare?ie=utf8&pf_rd_t=501&ref_=amb_link_ _1&pf_rd_m=atvpdkikx 0DER&pf_rd_p=&pf_rd_s=assoc-center-1&pf_rd_r=&pf_rd_i=assoc_operating (last visited Oct. 11, 2011). 100 Streitfeld, supra note Woo, supra note 1.
17 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 241 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com argue that it no longer has the physical presence in California that requires it to collect the tax. 102 In Tennessee, Amazon had originally built distribution centers in the state on the understanding that the government would not pass laws requiring it to collect sales tax. 103 When the legislature wanted to pass such a law, the new governor said it would be disingenuous to renege on the deal. 104 The Governor and Amazon finally agreed on October 6 that Amazon would begin collecting sales tax in 2014, and in return for the few years reprieve, would build new distribution centers in Tennessee, creating 2,000 more jobs for Tennesseans, and investing $350 million in the state. 105 In Indiana, Amazon s 2007 deal with the state government was that Amazon could build warehouses in the state in exchange for no state legislation on sales taxes. 106 The deal was reevaluated after Simon Properties Group, a company that owns shopping malls in Indiana, sued the state over its treatment of Amazon. 107 Amazon and the state finally came to a deal where Amazon would begin collecting sales tax in 2014, if there were no federal legislation passed before then. 108 Amazon officials expect federal legislation to pass in the next year or two. 109 Indiana and Amazon officials said the 2014 start of online sales tax collections was meant to give time for Congress to act on the federal proposal. We want to get it done this year, we re hopeful, Misener [Amazon s vice president for global public policy] said. But we may need 2013 to accomplish it. 110 It is clear that Amazon is only willing to make these deals as a temporary measure. It will pacify states by promising to begin sales tax collection at a later date. In the meantime, Amazon has time to perfect its sales tax collection mechanisms, and its stocks will remain high as sales rise. Meanwhile, Amazon is putting its support behind legislation that will force all online retailers to collect sales tax. 111 As other retailers have been able to lobby for state laws forcing Amazon to collect sales tax, it is certain that if Amazon is forced to collect sales tax, it will put its power behind making sure that its competitors are held to the same standard. 102 Streitfeld, supra note Schelzig, supra note Id. 105 Id. 106 Davies, supra note Id. 108 Id. 109 Id. 110 Id. 111 Woo, supra note 1.
18 242 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL IV. SOLUTIONS There are several possible resolutions to this conflict over collection of sales taxes on online purchases. Probably the two most likely scenarios are that after a long battle the states win one by one and Amazon ends up collecting sales tax in all states, or a national law is passed which requires all online retailers to collect sales tax. It is also possible, though unlikely, that the states will simply give up on trying to force Amazon to collect sales tax, that states residents will begin reporting and paying sales tax on their online purchases voluntarily, or that a judicial decision will hold all such laws unconstitutional. Small businesses could benefit in several of these scenarios. First, if the states stop battling Amazon over sales taxes, Amazon will continue its affiliate program, which helps small businesses continue to earn money as Amazon affiliates. Second, a national law requiring sales tax collection by online retailers could also be good for small businesses, but only if the process is made simple and cheap, so that small businesses can afford to comply with the complicated sales tax calculations, or small businesses are exempt from sales tax collection. Third, if the states win, and Amazon is eventually forced to comply with state laws requiring sales tax collection, small businesses may be exempt from these laws, which usually only compel sales tax collection from companies that make a certain amount of money per year from sales arranged by affiliates in that state. Small businesses without affiliate programs, or with very small ones, would not have to collect sales taxes under these laws, which would allow small businesses to sell goods without sales tax. This could allow small businesses to have more competitive pricing with larger businesses, which benefit from economies of scale, but which would be forced to collect sales tax. The biggest danger to small businesses is that as the battle drags on between the states and Amazon, small businesses are collateral damage. While small businesses have some influence, this battle is really being fought between Amazon and other large retailers. Neither of these have small business interests at heart. A. The States Accept Defeat Probably the ideal situation for the entrepreneurs that make up the Amazon Associates program would be for the states to cease their efforts to force Amazon to collect sales taxes. Amazon has been merciless in cutting off its Associates programs in any state that attempts to force Amazon to collect sales taxes. Comments by Jeff Bezos suggest this is not likely to change: We will continue to drop states who pass those affiliate laws, from
19 2012 How Battles over Collection of Sales Taxes 243 on Online Sales Will Affect Small Businesses Especially Affiliates of Large Sellers Like Amazon.com the affiliate program. 112 When the Associates programs are cut, these Associates must choose between a substantial loss of income or relocation to another state. Either of these options will cost the state in income taxes. However, because the states are in such dire need of money, and especially because the weight of other big stores is behind recent pushes to force collection of sales taxes, 113 it is likely that this issue will not simply disappear. The states are probably also aware that there is power in numbers. For now, Amazon can continue to drop affiliates in any state which passes such a law, but after some tipping point is reached, Amazon will have to decide between collecting sales taxes in most states, and getting rid of the majority of its affiliates. Amazon seems to understand that it does not have all the power in these negotiations, as it has recently negotiated deals with California and Texas in which it promises to begin collecting sales taxes after a specified amount of time. 114 While the battles are hurting entrepreneurs who work as Amazon Associates, small businesses that sell online benefit from the continued uncertainty. Until one side or the other gains a definitive victory, the small businesses that sell online are free to quietly continue selling without collecting sales taxes. As long as Amazon does not have to collect sales tax, neither do small businesses, and small businesses are likely to only have a physical presence in one or two states. This means that online sales by these businesses do not have to collect sales tax in the other forty-eight or fortynine states. B. Amazon Makes Deals with the States Unless a national statute or Supreme Court ruling intervenes, it is likely that many more states will pass laws in an attempt to force online retailers to collect sales taxes. If these efforts continue, eventually Amazon will simply have to choose between the revenue it would lose by dropping all its affiliates and the revenue it would lose by collecting sales tax. Amazon has already shown its willingness to work with some states, cutting deals in California, Texas, Tennessee, and Indiana to begin collecting sales taxes after a specified amount of time. 115 This would not necessarily mean that online entrepreneurs would have to collect sales tax. The new laws requiring sales tax collection in many states do not include small businesses. The New York law, for example, 112 Dhanya Skariachan, Amazon Could Cut Ties in More States Over Tax Dispute, REUTERS (May 11, 2011), 113 Bustillo & Woo, supra note Streitfeld, supra note 46; Ramsey, supra note Streitfeld, supra note 46; Ramsey, supra note 47.
20 244 OHIO STATE ENTREPRENEURIAL Vol. 7:1 BUSINESS LAW JOURNAL only includes businesses that earn more than $10,000 a year through their affiliate programs. 116 These laws are mostly targeted directly at Amazon, and would not affect small businesses directly. C. A National Law Settles the Issue In Quill, the Court suggested that Congress is now free to decide whether, when, and to what extent the States may burden interstate mailorder concerns with a duty to collect use taxes. 117 A national law requiring sales tax collection by online retailers might be a compromise solution between online retailers and states. Amazon has even stated that it is in favor of such a proposal, 118 possibly because if sufficient-nexus laws pass in enough states, they could force collection of sales taxes by Amazon and other companies with strong affiliate programs while Amazon s competitors, who have much smaller affiliate programs, will still be free to sell without collecting sales taxes. Amazon has gone so far as to send a letter of support to Senator Durbin, thanking him for his proposal of a bill that would allow states that sufficiently simplify their rules to require collection of sales tax by out-of-state sellers, 119 but it is unlikely that the bill, popularly named the Main Street Fairness Act, 120 will find the support necessary to become law. A national law could force all online retailers to collect sales taxes, regardless of the amount or location of their affiliates. This would be good news for the entrepreneurial affiliates, who would continue to get their revenue from referrals, without danger of being shut down as collateral damage in the battles between Amazon and the states. However, there is a danger for small businesses. Sales tax collection is difficult, and some large retailers have had to pay penalties for mistakes in sales tax collection. 121 Unless the law simplifies online sales tax collection at the same time that it makes it mandatory, it will be costly for companies to comply with the laws. The Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement provides a mechanism for simplifying these laws, which would allow small businesses to collect sales tax without fear of penalty and unnecessary expense. 116 McKinney s New York Tax Law 1101(b)(8)(vi) (2008). 117 Quill Corp. v. N. D. By & Through Heitkamp, 504 U.S. 298, 318 (1992). 118 Woo, supra note Letter from Paul Misener, V.P. for Global Pub.Policy, Amazon.com to Dick Durbin, U.S. Sen. (July 29, 2011), available at index.cfm/files/serve?file_id=a92e4a69-dba4-4aba-97a7-1a8c413ab206 [hereinafter Misener Letter]. 120 Press Release, U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin, Durbin, Conyers, Welch and Others Introduce Bill to Level the Playing Field for Main Street Retailers (July 29, 2011), available at 121 J.C.Penney, for example, has paid these penalties, which suggests that even large retailers with correspondingly large legal departments are not exempt from mistakes. Matthews, supra note 34.
Written Submission of James H Sutton Jr, CPA, Esq. Moffa, Gainor, & Sutton, P.A. Hearing on Exploring Alternatives on the Internet Sales Tax Issue
Written Submission of James H Sutton Jr, CPA, Esq. Moffa, Gainor, & Sutton, P.A. Hearing on Exploring Alternatives on the Internet Sales Tax Issue Before the Judiciary Committee Consumer Private ReportingMore information
The False Claims Act and the 2012 Georgia Taxpayer Protection False Claims Act
There is no kind of dishonesty into which otherwise good people more easily and frequently fall than that of defrauding the government. - Benjamin Franklin The False Claims Act and the 2012 Georgia TaxpayerMore information
SPECIAL REPORT. Movie Production Incentives: Blockbuster Support for Lackluster Policy
January 2010 No. 173 Movie Production Incentives: Blockbuster Support for Lackluster Policy By William Luther Adjunct Scholar Tax Foundation Introduction In the last decade, state governments have goneMore information
The Medical Malpractice Crisis: The Product of Insurance Companies and a Threat to Women's Health
The Medical Malpractice Crisis: The Product of Insurance Companies and a Threat to Women's Health Melissa Patterson* I. Introduction A burning question currently exists as to whether a medical malpracticeMore information
Written Testimony of Robyn C. Smith, Of Counsel, National Consumer Law Center. To the Office of the Attorney General of Massachusetts
Written Testimony of Robyn C. Smith, Of Counsel, National Consumer Law Center To the Office of the Attorney General of Massachusetts Regarding the Proposed Adoption of 940 CMR 31.00 and Repeal of 940 CMRMore information
Serious Tort Law Reform
Serious Tort Law Reform STEPHEN D. SUGARMAN* I. THE PROBLEM Tort law is a form of collective intervention into social and economic affairs that carries with it substantial costs, both public and private.More information
Legal Resource Kit. Sex Discrimination and Sexual Harassment in Employment
395 HUDSON STREET, NEW YORK, NY 10014-3684 (212) 925-6635 FAX: (212) 226-1066 Legal Resource Kit Sex Discrimination and Sexual Harassment in Employment 395 HUDSON STREET, NEW YORK, NY 10014-3684 (212)More information
Federal Courts and What They Do
Federal Courts and What They Do Contents What is a court? 1 What is a federal court? 1 What kinds of federal courts are there? 1 Who sets up the federal court system? 2 What s the difference between civilMore information
An Interstate Analysis of Right to Work Laws
THE HIGH COST OF BIG LABOR An Interstate Analysis of Right to Work Laws RICHARD VEDDER & JONATHAN ROBE THE HIGH COST OF BIG LABOR An Interstate Analysis of Right to Work Laws by Richard Vedder and JonathanMore information
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MAINE ] IN RE COMPACT DISC MINIMUM ] ADVERTISED PRICE ANTITRUST ] MDL DOCKET NO. 1361 LITIGATION ] (This document applies to ] all actions) DECISION AND ORDER ONMore information
14 Ways to Guarantee That Your Long-Term Disability Insurance Claim is Denied and You Lose In Court
Written Especially for Doctors and their Patients 14 Ways to Guarantee That Your Long-Term Disability Insurance Claim is Denied and You Lose In Court (Avoid them and you may have a shot at winning yourMore information
VOICES OF SMALL BUSINESSES: DISCUSSION AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS. Kate Maxwell and Yasuyuki Motoyama Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation.
VOICES OF SMALL BUSINESSES: DISCUSSION AND POLICY IMPLICATIONS Kate Maxwell and Yasuyuki Motoyama Ewing Marion Kauffman Foundation October 2012 VOICES OF SMALL BUSINESSES: DISCUSSION AND POLICY IMPLICATIONSMore information
THE BROOKINGS INSTITUTION THE DEBT CRISIS IN PUERTO RICO. Washington, D.C. Thursday, November 6, 2014
1 THE BROOKINGS INSTITUTION THE DEBT CRISIS IN PUERTO RICO Washington, D.C. Thursday, November 6, 2014 PARTICIPANTS: DARRELL WEST, Moderator Vice President and Director, Governance Studies The BrookingsMore information
Rich States, Poor States
Rich States, Poor States ALEC-Laffer State Competitiveness Index Arthur B. Laffer Stephen Moore Jonathan Williams Rich States, Poor States ALEC-Laffer State Competitiveness Index 2014 American LegislativeMore information
9 Common Mistakes That Can Destroy Your Workers Compensation Claim
9 Common Mistakes That Can Destroy Your Workers Compensation Claim And How to Avoid Making Them By Frank M. Eidson Copyright 2013 by PILMMA Publishing All rights reserved. No part of this book may be usedMore information
Electronic Self-Help Software Repossession: A Proposal to Protect Small Software Development Companies. Timothy P. Heaton
Electronic Self-Help Software Repossession: A Proposal to Protect Small Software Development Companies Timothy P. Heaton I. Introduction... II. Electronic Self-Help Repossession... A. Means of Repossession...More information
(Slip Opinion) OCTOBER TERM, 2014 1 Syllabus NOTE: Where it is feasible, a syllabus (headnote) will be released, as is being done in connection with this case, at the time the opinion is issued. The syllabusMore information
A CONSTITUTIONAL AND TECHNICAL ANALYSIS: THE IMPOSITION OF PUERTO RICO'S EXCISE TAX ON THE MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY ANA DELIA MONTAÑEZ MORALES* I. Introduction... 243 II. The Manufacturing Industry in PuertoMore information
For Better or For Profit: How the Bail Bonding Industry Stands in the Way. of Fair and Effective Pretrial Justice
For Better or For Profit: How the Bail Bonding Industry Stands in the Way of Fair and Effective Pretrial Justice JUSTICE POLICY INSTITUTE SEPTEMBER 2012 2 justice policy institute CONTENTS 3 PART 1: INTRODUCTIONMore information
An Overview of Workers Compensation Independent Contractor Regulatory Approaches
t ep rin R or ot f N An Overview of Workers Compensation Independent Contractor Regulatory Approaches An Overview of Workers Compensation Independent Contractor Regulatory Approaches NAIC/IAIABC JointMore information
Medical Malpractice Law in the United States
Medical Malpractice Law in the United States Prepared for the Kaiser Family Foundation by: Peter P. Budetti, M.D., J.D. Edward E. and Helen T. Bartlett Foundation Professor of Public Health Chair, DepartmentMore information
Unemployment Insurance, Then and Now, 1935-85. by Daniel N. Price *
Unemployment Insurance, Then and Now, 1935-85 by Daniel N. Price * At the same time that solutions were being sought for the problems of people reaching old age without income and savings in the depressedMore information
CRS Report for Congress
Order Code RL31692 CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web Medical Malpractice Liability Reform: Legal Issues and Fifty-State Survey of Caps on Punitive Damages and Noneconomic Damages UpdatedMore information
What Works: A Review of Auto Insurance Rate Regulation in America and How Best Practices Save Billions of Dollars
What Works: A Review of Auto Insurance Rate Regulation in America and How Best Practices Save Billions of Dollars November 2013 J. Robert Hunter Director of Insurance Tom Feltner Director of FinancialMore information
BATTLING FRAUD IN THE PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE INDUSTRY Matthew J. Smith, Esq. CINCINNATI, OH COLUMBUS, OH DETROIT, MI FT. MITCHELL, KY ORLANDO, FL SARASOTA, FL www.smithrolfes.com I. INTRODUCTIONMore information
Do Roads Pay for Themselves? Setting the Record Straight on Transportation Funding
Do Roads Pay for Themselves? Setting the Record Straight on Transportation Funding Do Roads Pay for Themselves? Setting the Record Straight on Transportation Funding U.S. PIRG Education Fund Tony DutzikMore information
SETTLED! The Revolution in Online Dispute Resolution. By Charles Brofman. Settled! The Revolution in Online Dispute Resolution Draft 6 10/10/2007
SETTLED! The Revolution in Online Dispute Resolution By Charles Brofman The Lexicomm Group 0 1 Dedication To Ariel and Sean You are limited only by the boundaries of your imaginations. Love, Dad The LexicommMore information
are condemned to repeat it.
Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. George Santayana (1863-1952), The Life of Reason, Volume 1 (1905). Cover photo and photo above by Justin Maconochie Photography ta b L E oMore information
What Will Legal Marijuana Cost Employers?
What Will Legal Marijuana Cost Employers? 1 National Families in Action This page intentionally left blank. Atlanta, Georgia 2 What Will Legal Marijuana Cost Employers? A White Paper By Sue Rusche andMore information
TEN Things You Need to Know if You are Involved in a Car Accident in New York By James S. Lynch and Arthur V. Lynch
TEN Things You Need to Know if You are Involved in a Car Accident in New York By James S. Lynch and Arthur V. Lynch WWW.LYNCHLAWYERS.COM COPYRIGHT 2008 BY ACCIDENT BOOKS PUBLISHERS All rights reserved.More information


text:
Stunning three year old AMHA/AMHR black appaloosa stallion. Stallion and show prospect all the way! Sired by our multi champion halter and driving stallion…SOLD
Born in a Barns Magic by Moonlight FBR Pending $1500obo will take a deposit and payments if needed. Born 08/04/15 Dam: Desert Golds Crescent…SOLD
Registered Paint mare , beautifully marked, very pretty Sun-Gold and white Dun Splash Paint with dorsal stripe, with flaxen mane . Perfect for someone…SOLD
Absolutely adorable Arabian type double registered AMHA/AMHR smokey black colt. Very correct and refined with a gorgeous head, tight ears, big beautiful…SOLD
Khara is a beautiful, sweet Arabian mare. VERY calm on the ground. Clips, bathes, stands for the farrier. She has been ridden off and on for years. Lots…SOLD
Beautiful grey Arabian gelding for sale. Matador is the perfect western prospect or halter show gelding. He has had one season of professionally halter…SOLD
Excellent 3yo sport horse prospect. Exquisite conformation and movement. Started under saddle, has been to small schooling shows and on trail rides.…SOLD
AMHA/AMHR/FMHA Pending Dam: Toyland Talita (Black Varnish) Sire: Porterfields Alejandro Guille (Black Near Leopard Appaloosa) She should mature…SOLD
Bakersfield, CA

subset: commoncrawl


text:
BigOven Pro required (try it free)
Notice a categorization error? Let us know by clicking [alert editor] on the recipe page, in the ingredients box.
Bandito Chili Dogs Recipe
A&W Chili Dogs
Quicky Quick Express Chili Dogs
Loaded Oven Chili Dog Casserole
Hot Dog Chili
Chili Cheese Dog Nachos
Chili Dog Casserole
Michigan Chili Dog Sauce
Coney Chili Dog Sauce
Savory Hot Dog Chili
Junkyard Dog Champion Chili
Chili Cheese Dog Mac n' Cheese
New York Hot-Dog Chili
Chili Dog Casserole in NuWave Oven.
Chili dogs
Hot Dog Chili New York Style (no beans)
Chili Dog Pie
Chili Cheese Dogs
You've found more than 100 recipes and added them to your Favorites and Try Soons! Glad you've found some great ideas.
Want to better organize them? With BigOven Pro, you can create folders by occasion, people
you're cooking for, and much more. It saves you time.
BigOven Pro is just $1.99/mo and removes all ads on the BigOven website and mobile apps. Try BigOven Pro free!


text:
Peripheral activation of CRF2 receptor (CRF2) by urocortin 1, 2 or 3 (Ucns) exerts powerful effects on gastric function, however little is known about their expression and regulation in the stomach. We investigated the expression of Ucns and CRF2 isoforms by RT-PCR in the gastric corpus (GC) mucosa and submucosa plus muscle (S+M) or laser captured layers in naive rats, their regulations by lipopolysaccharide (LPS, 100 μg/kg, ip) over 24 h and the effect of CRF2 antagonist, astresssin2B (100 μg/kg, sc) on LPS-induced delayed gastric emptying (GE) 2-h post injection. Transcripts of Ucns and CRF2b, the most common wild-type CRF2 isoform in the periphery, were expressed in all layers including myenteric neurons. LPS increased significantly Ucns mRNA levels in both mucosa and S+M, reaching a maximal response at 6 h post-injection and returning to basal levels at 24 h except for Ucn 1 in S+M. By contrast, CRF2b mRNA level was significantly decreased in the mucosa and M+S with a nadir at 6 h. In addition, CRF2a, reportedly only found in the brain and a novel splice variant CRF2a-3 were also detected in the GC, antrum and pylorus. LPS reciprocally regulated these variants with a decrease of CRF2a and an increase of CRF2a-3 in the GC 6 h post-injection. Astresssin2B exacerbated LPS-delayed gastric emptying (42% to 73%, p<0.001). These data indicate that Ucns and CRF2 isoforms are widely distributed throughout the rat stomach and inversely regulated by immune stress. CRF2 signaling system may act to counteract the early gastric motor alterations to endotoxemia.
- Astressin2-B
- llaser capture microdissection
- myenteric neurons
- lipopolysaccharide
- upper gut
- Copyright © 2012, American Journal of Physiology- Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology


text:
Greg Palast is the author of the New York Times bestseller, "ARMED MADHOUSE: Who's Afraid of Osama Wolf?, China Floats Bush Sinks, the Scheme to Steal '08, No Child's Behind Left and other Dispatches from the Front Lines of the Class War.â€
Friday, June 30 — GEORGE Bush's operatives have plans to jigger with the upcoming elections. I'm not talking about the November '06 vote in the USA (though they have plans for that, too). I'm talking about the election this Sunday in Mexico for their Presidency.
It begins with an FBI document marked, "Counterterrorism†and "Foreign Intelligence Collection†and "Secret.†Date: "9/17/2001,†six days after the attack on the World Trade towers. It's nice to know the feds got right on the ball, if a little late.
Post comment
Forbidden Bookshelf
"While We Were Sleeping"
While We Were Sleeping is an urgent call to save Greenwich Village from New York University's uncontrolled expansion.
Click here to donate to NYUFASP and receive a copy of "While We Were Sleeping: NYU and the Destruction of New York" (minimum donation to receive a book is $10 plus $8 shipping).
Orwell Rolls In His Grave, featuring MCM – Buy the DVD
About News From Underground
News From Underground is a daily e-news service run by Mark Crispin Miller, a Professor of Culture and Communication at NYU. It is based on his belief that academics, like reporters, have a civic obligation to help keep the people well-informed, so that American democracy might finally work.
If you'd like to receive updates delivered to your inbox daily, sign up for News From Underground Alerts:
Help News From Underground!
Message from Mark: "I am a one-man operation, although assisted greatly by some volunteers, and, now and then, by people paid by others for one-time projects. There is no shortage of skilled, dedicated folks out there who want to help me. There is, however, nothing I can pay them with, unless you decide you can contribute something."
Please donate via the PayPal button above or via PayPal by email to: email@example.com
Recent Posts
- MCM on Trump/Clinton, "conspiracy theory," media baloney and much else, on CounterPunch Radio!
- Who counted the votes in Colombia?
- More "bizarre deaths" at JP Morgan Chase
- Trump's comic-book fascism is a "danger" used to keep the real thing going
- Hillary and Trump are raising Kaine (God help us)
Recent Comments
- Craiglist ad seeks "writers to post Right-Wing Comments to social media & news outlets" on
- 12 million votes went missing in the CA primary on
- How many delegates do Hillary and Bernie have, and how many does each need? This guy does the math…. on
- How many delegates do Hillary and Bernie have, and how many does each need? This guy does the math…. on
- New ABC/WashPost poll has Trump (just) ahead of Clinton nationwide on
Popular Posts
- MCM on Trump/Clinton, "conspiracy theory," media baloney and much else, on CounterPunch Radio!
- The strange death of Nancy Schaefer (two items)
- Study by Bush DoJ finds 31 cases of real voter fraud in 14 years
- Forbidden Bookshelf
- Trump's comic-book fascism is a "danger" used to keep the real thing going
- Suburban Guerrilla
- alias Bruce
- Democratic Undergroud
- Thom Hartmann
- William Betz
- The Ostroy Report
- Words of Power
- Barry Gordon
- consortiumnews.com
- The International Human Press
- Cody Lyon
- Election Defense Alliance
- Online Journal
- t r u t h o u t
- History Unfolding
- The Existentialist Cowboy
- Attytood
- Early America
- Mainstream Baptist
- The Rude Pudit
- Talking Points Memo
- Democrats.com
- opednews.com
- Writers Voice
- Media Matters
Need a bigger font size?
Sponsored Links
- Your link could be here too, contact us for pricing details.


text:
Koh Samui - Blossom Dew Villa E 3 Bedrooms
Beach villa with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and swimming pool in Plai Laem, Thailand
Booking cost: £0.00
From £2,980 per week
Villa to rent in Plai Laem, Koh Samui
Villa overview - owner's description
Bask in total luxury with this 3 beds villa, situated in a beach side resort and enjoying amazing sea-views and a convenient holiday location. With a private swimming pool and an absolute beachfront.
With an absolute beachfront location at Plai Laem Beach, in the northern parts of Koh Samui, this 3 bedroom villa sleeps up to 6 people and comes with a luxurious atmosphere and design. With amazing unobstructed sea-views, close to nearby amenities and attractions, this is a first-class choice.
The beachfront garden really does impress with its private swimming pool and adjoining Jacuzzi, a terrace with lots of lounges, and a Thai sala, enjoying breathtaking sea-views.
The lounge area also enjoys sea-views and access to the garden and pool, while coming with comfortable furnishings that include a sofa, alongside entertainment facilities such as a large flat-screen TV with international channels, and a high quality surround sound system. Here you will also find a circular 6 seats dining table and a Western-style kitchen with lots of appliances.
The villa sleeps 6, with 3 bedrooms that all have bathrooms, wardrobes and air-conditioning. There are king-size double beds in 2 bedrooms, with 2x single beds in the 3rd bedroom, making this a great choice for families.
The absolute beachfront location is just 1km from restaurants, shops and spas, while being almost 2km from nightlife, all on the northern coastline of Koh Samui.
Absolutely beautiful place to spend holidays.
This villa does not have any reviews.
This villa is:
Outside this villa in Plai Laem, Koh SamuiThis villa is in a quiet area near the beach. It has a pool, a balcony, a barbecue and a garden. Car hire is not necessary as the villa is less than a 15 minute walk to a large selection of shops, bars, restaurants; however parking is available if required.
Prices and availability
Updated 14 July 2016
Select your travel dates on the calendar
Changeover days and minimum stays
- 1 September - 14 December 2016: the minimum stay is 3 nights.
- 15 December 2016 - 15 January 2017: the minimum stay is 10 nights.
Compulsory extras
Electrical consumption allotment is 100 units per day, excess usage will be charged 7 bath per unit
£0.00 per nightpaid locally
3 bedrooms, Sleeps 6:
- 1 king size bed
- 1 double bed
- 2 single beds
2 bathrooms, 1 Separate WC
Swimming pool
Private pool
CD player, DVD/Blu-ray player, Internet / WI-FI, TV Languages in English, Local, Satellite / cable
Living area seats 4, Dining area seats 6, Air conditioning throughout property, Hair dryer, Iron / board, Towels / linen, Car hire optional
Cooker, Crockery, Cutlery, Fridge, Freezer, Glassware, Kettle, Oven, Pots / pans, Toaster
Balcony or terrace, Barbecue, Parking, Private garden
Suitable for
Children, Infants
Extra information
Children's Highchair, Staffed Property and Gazebo
Agency From Pattaya, Thailand Member since Apr 2006
Villa rentals in Pattaya now for over 10 years, in excess of 275 properties available. We have fully trained staff many of which live on site and can offer a 24 hour service. Before coming to Pattaya owned and managed business in the UK and Gran Canaria for over 35 years.
Past bookings: 84 bookings
Response rate: 100%
Response time: within 5 hours
Last logged in: 15 days ago
Number of properties: 211
Villa rentals in Pattaya now for over 10 years, in excess of 275 properties available. We have fully trained staff many of which live on site and can offer a 24 hour service. Before coming to Pattaya owned and managed business in the UK and Gran Canaria for over 35 years.


text:
We already have 100's of scripts in QTP and VBscripts,now my company is trying to get Panaya application,i have investigated on net about panaya i got some information(not much), but i am only interested how the integration is done between Panaya and qtp, so how the qtp scripts are utilized and updated, if anybody have any info please share.
Hi there...not sure if you already found your answer somewhere, could you please share a bit more about your objective? I understand that you would like to know more about the integration and how it works in the back end. But isn't it one of the main reason to use SAAS (Software As A Service) products so the end users do not have to deal with all these complexities?
Please share little bit more about your SAP landscape and little details of your test objective? You can always try a free version and ask questions to your Panaya rep for your specific need.
For general information on how Panaya works, please refer to panaya.com/products/hp-quality-center-integration.html
Forum Rules


text:
Search Results: ''
All Or Nothing
Paperback: List Price: $33.34 $20.00 | You Save: 40%
Prints in 3-5 business days
The history of Europe's most controversial wrestling promotion: 1PW. The group employed the biggest stars in the business and caused massive ripples throughout the industry. This fascinating tale... More > delves deep behind the scenes, interviewing ALL of the key players involved from all over the globe. Including: Chris Daniels, Abyss, Steve Corino, Kid Kash, Nigel McGuinness, Doug Williams, Nunzio, Nova, Steven Gauntley, Tracy Smothers, Jerry Lynn and over 40 more There are over 25 exclusive reviews of all the major events from Arnold Furious. Also, there is a comprehensive results and title history guide. This is a fan's dream, looking in great detail at everything from the wrestlers to the bookers to the promoters. No stone is left unturned and this book will revolutionise the way people view pro wrestling in the UK. It does not matter if you know of or followed the company at the time, any fan of pro wrestling will be captivated and fascinated by the content of this 300,000+ word epic.< Less
Top 10see more >
Learning to Play the...
Paperback: $15.00
Taking P.R.I.D.E.
Paperback: $20.00
Essentials of Vascular...
Paperback: $49.99
The Intangible...
Paperback: $6.68
Identity and Mission of...
Paperback: $7.95
Empty & The Ocean
Paperback: $18.00
Why Me? Why Not Me! A...
Paperback: $15.00
Stephanie's Diary
Paperback: $9.99
Reignite Your Marriage...
Paperback: $21.00
Age Verification
The page you are attempting to access contains content that is not intended for underage readers.
Please verify your birth date to continue.


text:
Sort By :
US $1-500 / Kilogram
1 Kilogram (Min. Order)
High Quality Low Price Damiana Leaf Extract for Sex health
US $1-200 / Kilogram
1 Kilogram (Min. Order)
Guangdong OEM factory artificial silicone vibrator sex philter for women
US $10-28 / Piece
10 Pieces (Min. Order)
epimedium sagittatum extract icariin 50% sex philter for women
US $86.2-145.3 / Gram
1 Gram (Min. Order)
free sample sex philter for women with great price
US $1-100 / Kilogram
1 Kilogram (Min. Order)
atural icariin 50% epimedium extract powder sex philter for women
US $55-195 / Kilogram
1 Kilogram (Min. Order)
Female sexual orgasm philter vivid adult toys perfume excite woman sex product
US $5-7 / Unit
1000 Units (Min. Order)
sex philter product japan porn adult toy new arrival
US $9.9-12.6 / Set
100 Sets (Min. Order)
Go to Page
Prev 1 Next
Buying Request Hub
Haven't found the right supplier yet ? Let matching verified suppliers find you. Get Quotation NowFREE
Do you want to show sex philter or other products of your own company? Display your Products FREE now!
Product Features
Supplier Features
Supplier Types
Top 3 Markets
Recommendation for you


text:
For the last couple of days, Canada's Minister of Natural Resources has been crowing on about how safe Bruce Power's shipment of 16 decommissioned nuclear steam boilers will be.
"The exterior surface of the steam generators has a lower surface dose of radiation than a package of medical isotopes. Such packages are delivered in hospitals every day. Such deliveries are common," waves off Monsieur Paradis. So move along. Nothing to see here. The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission did the right thing allowing Bruce Power to ship these school-bus sized suppositories through the Great Lakes, up the Saint Lawrence Seaway and across the Atlantic Ocean to be recycled in Sweden. Really! What's the big fuss?
Again, in the words of our comforting Minister of Rocks and Trees in response to a question from Nathan Cullen of the NDP, "I do not know why the member is once again trying to undermine the credibility of a quasi-judicial organization, which is arm's-length from the government."
Well, Minister, here's the thing. It's not so much what's on the outside of the generators that has everyone glowing with worry. It's what is inside them. That's the real nasty stuff. You know, the plutonium and such... the stuff with a half-life of thousands of years... the stuff with the potential to poison the drinking water of millions of people.
The decommissioned steam boilers are essentially a spaghetti-like mess of tubes inside of a giant steel case. Some of the tubes carry heavy water that has come into direct contact with nuclear fuel. Over time, the insides of these tubes become lined with radioactive deposits.
In fact, the CNSC documented 22 different substances - called radionuclides - that are found inside the steam generators. Among them is Plutonium-239 a particularly nasty isotope that can be used in the production of nuclear weapons and has a half-life 24-thousand years. There are other, less poisonous ones in there, like Curium, Strontium and Technicium but, all told, it's a pretty messy line-up. Now admittedly, there is only about five grams of Plutonium-239 in all 16 units. But I'm pretty sure that's what everyone is concerned about.
Now normally, this wouldn't be such a big deal. The steam generators can deal with an awful lot of exterior water pressure without cracking open. So, if - as alarmists like Nathan Cullen and Gilles Duceppe fear - one of them topples over the side or - God forbid - the ship sinks, well, you just send down a winch and hook, yank them back up and send them on their merry Swedish way.
Unless of course they dive to a depth of 800 feet or greater.
At which point, they crack open.
So, a few words of advice to the member from Mégantic-L'Érable:
Steer clear of the Rochester Basin... and the misleading rhetoric.
More Stories under Politics
- Cost and Canadian content concerns hover over warship plansOct 27, 2016 9:55 PM ET — Competition to design the country's next generation of warships has kicked off, but the public will not know how much they're on-the-hook fo… 9:55 PM ET
- Independents to become biggest bloc in Senate, but they're still '3rd class' senatorsOct 27, 2016 9:52 PM ET — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's push to populate the Senate with Independent senators is in full swing, and they are poised to form a plural… 9:52 PM ET
- What's in the declarations that sealed the Canada-EU trade deal?Oct 27, 2016 8:28 PM ET — As Belgium's leaders emerged Thursday to announce their CETA compromise, copies of two declarations came out. One was Belgium-specific and d… 8:28 PM ET
About the Author
Other Inside Politics Entries
Archives »
- 2015 (14)
January (14)
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Power & Politics' Ballot Box question
- Ministers hand out federal support for arts and culture, 'jobs, growth and prosperity'
- January (14)


text:
Mideast peace `a shattered dream': McCully
Foreign Minister Murray McCully has told the UN Security Council its 50-year goal of achieving a two-state solution to the Middle East crisis is close to failure.
He said it was time for the council to ask more of the Israelis and the Palestinians.
"We all express dismay and outrage about the violence affecting ordinary Israelis and Palestinians, and yet innocent lives continue to be lost," he said in a just-delivered speech.
"We all condemn settlements, and yet they continue to expand.
"We repeatedly encourage both sides to compromise and find a road to peace, and yet angry rhetoric and incitement prevail."
Mr McCully said reconciliation had been put on the back burner and rockets from Gaza continued to target Israeli towns and cities.
"The result of these developments is that the two state solution - the vision and goal of this council for nearly 50 years - is close to becoming a shattered dream."
New Zealand is one of the 10 non-permanent members of the council and currently holds the presidency.
Prime Minister John Key will be at the UN next week and has called a high-level meeting to discuss the Syrian situation.
It's scheduled to take place on Wednesday.
More in News
'Sometimes a lady needs to be told when she's being nasty'USA TODAY
Russia's show of force in English ChannelThe Guardian
One critical after Paeroa stabbingNZ Newswire
Gang members set to gather for tangiNZ Newswire
Family rescued after being stranded in storm overnightRadio New Zealand
Attacks disrupt major sitesReuters


text:
12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
About the Listing
Amazing in town log home with North Woods look and feel that is VERY commute friendly sitting on a stunning nearly five acre lot that has views for days. Welcome to gorgeous massive vaulted ceilings, gleaming woodwork, well thought out kitchen with eat in dining and three bedrooms on one level - there is plenty of space to grow downstairs. The natural wildlife surrounding you is the icing on the cake.
Share Listing
Property Details for 12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 2 Full | 1 Three-Qtr
Lot Size: 4.87 Acres
Lot Dimensions: 303x726x300x687
Year Built: 1993
Garage Dimensions: 2 car
Garage: Detached Garage, Driveway - Gravel
Style: (SF) One Story
Water: Well
Sewer: Private
Square Feet: 1474
Above Ground Sq Ft: 1288
Below Ground Sq Ft: 186 (approx)
Room Information for 12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
Main Floor
Family Room: 20x16
Kitchen: 12x12
Bedroom 1: 14x14
Bedroom 2: 11x10
Bedroom 3: 11x10
Lower Floor
Bedroom 4: 12x12
Dining Room Description: Eat In Kitchen
Family Room Characteristics: Main Level, Family Room
School Information for 12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
School District: Rosemount-Apple Valley-Eag
School District Phone: 651-423-7700
Interior Features for 12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
Appliances: Range, Microwave, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Washer, Dryer
Air Cond: Central
Heating: Forced Air, Fireplace
Fireplaces: Yes
Basement: (186 sq Finished) Full, Sump Pump, Concrete Block
Exterior Features for 12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
Lot Description: Tree Coverage - Light
Lot Dimensions: 303x726x300x687
Roof: Asphalt Shingles, Age Over 8 Years
Zoning: Residential-Single
Financial Considerations for 12675 S Robert Trail, Rosemount, MN 55068
Tax Amount: $3,267
Taxes w/Assessments: $3,267
Tax/Property ID: 346460001080
Tax Year: 2016
Monthly Payment = $0
INRIX Drive Time
Calculate Your Drive Time From This Property
Similar Listings For Sale
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than the owner of this website are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo or the Broker Reciprocity thumbnail logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.


text:
The Essence of Chi-Gung
A Handbook of Basic Forms for Daily Practice
by Daniel P. Reid
Get eBook
- Your price$15.99
You'll see how many points you'll earn before checking out. We'll award them after completing your purchase.
Or, get it for 7200 Kobo Super Points!
See if you have enough points for this eBook. Sign in
The beneficial health effects of daily chi-gung practice have long been known in China, but in the West, chi-gung is becoming increasingly used for general well-being and to complement conventional medical treatment. The Essence of Chi-Gung is an easy-to-use workbook that teaches the fundamentals of chi-gung practice and provides a safe, basic daily regimen that can be adapted for people of all ages and physical abilities.
The view in Chinese medicine is that good health is maintained by circulating and increasing chi, the vital life energy that we are all born with. In chi-gung practice, slow, rhythmic breathing is synchronized with body movements, in a way which is beneficial to both the nervous and immune systems and to overall health. This manual includes over fifty step-by-step illustrations of the warm-up exercises and movement forms.
People who read this also enjoyed
Ratings and Reviews
Overall rating
Be the first to rate and review this book!
You've already shared your review for this item. Thanks!
We are currently reviewing your submission. Thanks!
The Essence of Chi-Gung
by Daniel P. Reid
Share your thoughts
Tell readers what you thought by rating and reviewing this book.
Rate it *
Please make sure to choose a rating
Add a review* Required
Review *
How to write a great review
- Say what you liked best and least
- Describe the author's style
- Explain the rating you gave
- Use rude and profane language
- Include any personal information
- Mention spoilers or the book's price
- Recap the plot
(0) 50 characters minimum
The review must be at least 50 characters long.
Title *
The title should be at least 4 characters long.
Display Name *
Your display name should be at least 2 characters long.
Report a review
At Kobo, we try to ensure that published reviews do not contain rude or profane language, spoilers, or any of our reviewer's personal information.
Would you like us to take another look at this review?
You've successfully reported this review. We appreciate your feedback.
The Essence of Chi-Gung
by Daniel P. Reid
Thanks for Sharing!
You submitted the following rating and review. We'll publish them on our site once we've reviewed them.
by on October 27, 2016
eBook Details
- Shambhala, July 2012
- Imprint:
- 9780834827967
- Language:
- English
- Download options:
- EPUB 2 (Adobe DRM)
You can read this item using any of the following Kobo apps and devices:


text:
Real Name: Giorgios Ioak Joined: September 2016
No vehicles yet.
tire pressure
the recommended tire pressure is listed on the inside of ... ...
by wasabi2u
Read more tips
© 2016 Fuelly.com - All Rights Reserved. Oct 24, 2016 12:19 AM CDT
A simple & effecive way to track fuel consumption
Easy to understand the real cost of your vehicle


text:
Ericdress Lapel Strip Patchwork Trumpet Casual Dress
Ericdress Color Block Plus Size Loose Coat
Here ericdress.com shows customers a fashion collection of current wedding reception table.You can find many great items. They all have high quality and reasonable price. You can get big discount sometimes, because we always do promotions. If you need wedding reception table,come here to choose. We give you good items and services.
Ericdress Beautiful Bateau Knee Length Reception Wedding Dress
Ericdress Charming Illusion Neckline A Line Reception Wedding Dress
Ericdress Charming Appliques Knee Length Reception Wedding Dress
Ericdress High Quality Sweetheart Sheath Lace Reception Wedding Dress
Ericdress Beautiful V Neck Appliques Reception Wedding Dress
Creative Personality Household DIY Fun Wall Clock Message Board Table
Ballon and Lantern Wedding Decorations
Groom Embrace Bride Wedding Decoration
Wedding Day Pyramid Favor Boxes
Red Diamond Wedding Favor Boxes
Romantic Moment Wedding Cake Topper
Will You Marry MeBallon Wedding Decoration
Reversible Sweet wedding Favor Boxes
Do You Love MeBallon Wedding Decorations
I Love You Ballon Wedding Decoration
LED Heart-Shaped Coloured Lamp Wedding Decoration
Romantic Gauze Curtain Snow Yarn Wedding Decoration
Ericdress Simple Lace High Heel Wedding Shoes
Comfortable Lacing Wedding Jacket


text:
Support Merchandiser-Necedah, WI
UPS Seasonal Driver Helpers (Days - no driving required)
Paid Truck Driver Training (GYCDL Wisconsin)
Cleaning/Finish Maintenance
Taco Bell Assistant Manager (9 applicants needed)
Guest Service Co-worker Kwik Trip #399
Entry-Level Sales
Work From Home - Data Entry
Production Supervisor - 2nd Shift - (161640)
Production Supervisor - 2nd Shift
Transition to a new career in just 3 weeks! OTR Reefer Driver Job, Call Now!
15E Unmanned Aircraft Systems Repairers
15E Unmanned Aircraft Systems Repairers
Student Driver Academy
Product Tester (From Home)
Retail Merchandiser
Customer Service Representative
General Help For Things I Can No Longer Do By Myself
Maintenance Manager
Student Drivers
Merchandiser Assembly
Seasonal Position - Cashier
Accounting Clerk
WI Customer Service Representative
Find the career you've been looking for.
The Necedah, WI Job Market
Hunting for high-quality jobs in Necedah, WI? Necedah, WI, since roughly 2013 official stats, holds a population of around 1,000. Also, the city of Necedah, WI, since 2013 government statistics, shows a median family earnings value of just about $40,000. Necedah's cost of living, as of 2013, was estimated at 88 out of 100, which is actually lower when it comes to the national average.
If you might be looking to find jobs inside of the city, are located some other place and taking a look in close by cities, or if you are looking for places really worth relocating to that will have nice job options available, it is worthy of taking into account the state of unemployment in the city. As recent as 2014, Necedah has a rate of unemployment roughly 7.5%. Furthermore,this is higher than the nationwide average unemployment percentage, since late 2015. Hopefully this will aid you to make a far more informed determination on your options in this city.


text:
Check rates!
Free WiFi! WiFi is available in the hotel rooms and is free of charge.
Free parking! Free private parking is possible on site (reservation is not needed).
From 16:00 Until 19:00 hours
From 07:00 Until 10:00 hours
All children are welcome.There is no capacity for extra beds in the room.
Pets are allowed on request. Charges may be applicable.
Like this one, but not quite sure yet?
Hotels Herbitzheim
Properties nearby – Apartments Haus Beckel
Nearby Cities – Apartments Haus Beckel
Top Destinations: Germany
Flexible travel plans?
Didn't find the right property?
All fields marked with an * must be filled in.


text:
Skip to main content
Episodes and Videos
16 for 2016
Gwen Ifill
Latest Episode
Washington Week
Friday Nights on PBS
Top Stories
Reading Lists
TV Times
16 for 2016
You are here
16 for 2016
Washington Week-ly News Quiz: October 20, 2016
October 20, 2016
Have you been paying attention to the news this week? Prove it, and you may learn something new. Take the Washington Week-ly News Quiz!
16 for 2016
What would you ask Clinton and Trump in the final debate?
October 19, 2016
Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton face off Wednesday night for the final presidential debate. The previous two debates were defined by personal attacks and threats of imprisonment, which left many voters still searching for the candidates' substantive answers on policy. So we asked Washington Week viewers: what would you ask Trump or Clinton in the final presidential debate? Here's what they told us.
16 for 2016
Who won the final presidential debate?
October 19, 2016
Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump met for the final debate of the 2016 election cycle Wednesday in Las Vegas. Which candidate do you think came out on top?
16 for 2016
By the Numbers: Voter Fraud
October 18, 2016
With just over three weeks until Election Day, Donald Trump has ramped up his claims that the election is "rigged" against him. What is the truth behind Trump's declarations? We look at the numbers behind voting fraud in America.
16 for 2016
Trump vs. Clinton: Cybersecurity
October 17, 2016
After months of criticism regarding Clinton's private email server as secretary of state, Wikileaks has now also released thousands of supposedly hacked emails from her presidential campaign. As Donald Trump touts the emails as evidence of Clinton's "crooked" campaign, we looked into each nominee's positions on cybersecurity.
16 for 2016
Washington Week-ly News Quiz: October 13, 2016
October 13, 2016
Have you been following the headlines this week? How many votes have been cast so far in the presidential election? Take the Washington Week-ly News Quiz!
16 for 2016
Trump vs. Clinton: Veterans
October 12, 2016
With the general election less than a month away, Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump are honing in on critical battleground states that will determine the outcome on November 8. Veterans make up a vital constituency in nearly every swing state, so the presidential nominees have fought ardently over their votes. As the 2016 election enters its final weeks, we looked into each candidate's policy proposals for veterans.
16 for 2016
Washington Week-ly News Quiz: October 6, 2016
October 6, 2016
How closely have you been following the headlines this week? What legislation did Bill Clinton criticize on the campaign trail? Test your knowledge with this week's News Quiz!
16 for 2016
Washington Week panelists react to vice presidential debate
October 4, 2016
Republican Mike Pence and Democrat Tim Kaine faced off in the first and only vice presidential debate at Longwood University in Virginia Tuesday night. See the key takeaways from our regular Washington Week panelists.
Load more
Latest Episode
Trump won't accept election results if he loses as Clinton expands campaign into red states
Recent Videos
Candidates go for laughs at Al Smith Dinner, independent Evan McMullin leads in Utah and who will lead the GOP post-election?
Trump: I will accept election results "if I win"
WATCH: The final presidential debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump
Shifting strategies for the final debate, Obama campaigns for Clinton and Ivana Trump on her famous ex-husband
Trending Topics
2016 Elections
Donald Trump
Hillary Clinton
Gwen's Take
The End Is In Sight
October 6, 2016
"Once they have actually left office, we seem to grow fonder of our ex-presidents... Now, little more than four months before he leaves office, President Obama has begun to get a taste of this phenomenon."
How To Moderate A Debate
September 22, 2016
The High Dive
September 1, 2016
The gun debate, face to face
June 16, 2016
About Gwen
Gwen Ifill is moderator and managing editor of "Washington Week" and co-anchor and managing editor of the "PBS NewsHour." The best-selling author of "The Breakthrough: Politics and Race in the Age of Obama," Gwen has covered seven presidential campaigns and moderated two vice presidential debates.
Gwen on PBS Newshour
Nearly 2 million warned to flee destructive Hurricane Matthew in the U.S.
The state of safety and civil rights progress for black Americans today
Gwen's Appearances
Gwen Ifill talks politics and media at Colorado College
The Aspen Institute on Inequality and Opportunity


text:
Mobile Video Converter Software
Mobile Video Converter is an advanced software created to perform of 3GP/3GP2/AVI/MP4 file conversion for portable video devices such as mobile phone, iPod, PSP, zune etc. Software is designed with very user friendly and attractive interface (GUI).
4Videosoft Blu-ray to MPEG Ripper
4Videosoft Blu-ray to MPEG Ripper can rip blu-ray to MPEG format and convert general DVD to AVI, MPEG, MP4, FLV, WMV, MKV, iPod, PSP, etc, and rips audio to AAC, AC3, MP3, OGG, WMA etc. with perfect quality at higher ripping speed.
Aiseesoft Free MXF Converter 6.5.6
Aiseesoft Free MXF Converter can help users convert MXF files to AVI, MP4, MOV, WMV, HD AVI, HD MP4, HD MOV, HD WMV video and MP3 audio formats with best sound/image quality.