text:
Life of Buddha
ebook test
Patricia M. Herbert In this superbly illustrated book, Patricia Herbert draws on manuscript sources from Burma--one of the most strongly Buddhist countries in the world today-- to tell the Buddha's life story as it has evolved over the centuries, incorporating legends, miracles, and local variations. As the narrative unfolds, episodes are shown in full-page color illustrations reproduced from two magnificent Burmese manuscripts once owned by nineteenth-century British diplomat and Orientalist Henry Burney, British Resident of the Court of Ava from 1830 to 1837, and now among the most prized items in the British Library's collections. The book includes a general introduction to Buddhism and Buddhist art, an appendix with notes about each illustration, and a glossary of terms. Patricia Herbert, former curator of the South East Asia Collections of the British Library's Oriental and India Office Collections, coedited South-East Asian Languages and Literatures: A Select Guide (Kiscadale Publications, 1989); compiled Burma (vol. 132 of the World Bibliographical Series, Clio Press, 1991); and has written widely about Burmese manuscript art, education, and history. Herbert is a Fellow of the Royal Asiatic Society, a council member of the BritainBurma Society, and vice-chairman of Prospect Burma, a nonprofit organization supporting higher education for Burmese students worldwide. PAT R I C I A M . H E R B E RT P O M E G R A N AT E C O M M U N I C AT I O N S , I N C . I N A S S O C I AT I O N W I T H T H E B R I T I S H L I B R A RY SAN FRANCISCO Pomegranate Communications, Inc. Box 808022, Petaluma CA 94975 800 227 1428 www.pomegranate.com Pomegranate Europe Ltd. Unit 1, Heathcote Business Centre, Hurlbutt Road Warwick, Warwickshire CV34 6TD, UK [+44] 0 1926 430111 � 2005 The British Library Board. All rights reserved. Published by Pomegranate Communications, Inc. in association with The British Library No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the copyright holder. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Herbert, Patricia M. The life of the Buddha / Patricia M. Herbert. p. cm. Originally published: London : British Library, 1993. ISBN 0-7649-3155-5 (hardcover, alk. paper) ISBN 978-0-7649-5568-6 (eBook) 1. Gautama Buddha--Art. 2. Illumination of books and manuscripts, Burmese. I. Title. ND3338.H47 2005 294.3'63--dc22 [B] Pomegranate Catalog No. A768 Design by Lynn Bell, Monroe Street Studios, Santa Rosa, California Cover: Sotthiya the Grass Cutter and the Buddha in Meditation, Or. 14297, ff. 17�18 Back cover: Detail from The Ploughing Ceremony and the Prince's Marriage, Or. 14297, ff. 8�9 Printed in China 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 2004058721 PREFACE he purpose of this book is to introduce readers in the English-speaking world to the life and teachings of the Buddha as narrated and depicted in Burmese manuscript sources. To do so, openings selected from two of the British Library's finest Burmese life-of-the-Buddha manuscripts are illustrated in thirty full-page color spreads accompanied by a simple narrative text. This presentation retains the format and spirit of the original manuscripts, reproducing them in virtual facsimile but a little reduced in size and with English text in place of the Burmese. In these pages the reader encounters vibrant scenes of palace, monastic, and everyday life that glow with color and rich gilding, and enters a world where the old gods and spirits as well as men pay homage to the Buddha and his teaching. The story of one of the world's truly great religious and moral teachers is simply told and is enhanced by the little-known but glorious manuscript art of Burma. The introduction to the book provides some background information about Buddhism and Buddhist art in general, together with more detail on Burmese manuscript art. The T appendix contains notes about the Buddhist context, to help readers who may be unfamiliar with Buddhist terms and concepts, as well as notes about the art of each page illustrated so that this book may also serve as a reference source for art historians. For although there is no shortage of scholarly and popular books on Buddhism, nor of glossy books reproducing masterpieces of Buddhist art, the art and traditions of Burma in particular have received rather less attention. Throughout the book, the Pali form of names and terms is used for consistency, although the Sanskrit form is occasionally also cited where it is deemed more familiar, and some Burmese versions of the original Pali are provided. Diacritics appear only in the glossary. I wish especially to thank my esteemed Buddhist colleague and friend K. D. Somadasa for his encouragement and advice to me in the course of writing this book; also John Okell, Noel Singer, and U Thaw Kaung. Thanks are also due to Terry Barringer, Librarian of the Royal Commonwealth Society, and to the staff of the Oriental and India Office Collections' photographic service. Finally, this book is dedicated to my daughter Juliette, but I also hope--in the manner of all Buddhist dedicatory statements--that much merit may accrue to the British Library for the virtuous deed of publishing this life of the revered Buddha. --PATRICIA M. H ERBERT Painted cover of Or. 14298 INTRODUCTION uddhism, one of the great religions of the world, owes its origin to the inspiration of one man who became known as the Buddha, meaning "the Enlightened One." The Buddha lived and preached in India more than 2,500 years ago, although his exact dates are a subject of scholarly debate. In some Buddhist countries 544/543 BC traditionally marks the date of the Buddha's death and the beginning of the Buddhist era, and it is in accordance with this date that the first 2,500 years of the Buddhist faith were celebrated in 1956�1957. The Buddha is also known by the title Sakyamuni (sage of the Sakya people) and by the Pali name Gotama (in Sanskrit Gautama), which is used throughout the Pali Buddhist canon and distinguishes him from other, nonhistorical Buddhas believed to have preceded him. His followers addressed him as Bhagava, meaning "lord" or "blessed one," but he usually referred to himself as Tathagatha--an enigmatic epithet meaning "thus come" or "thus gone" and sometimes rendered as "he who has discovered the truth." His name as a young man was Siddhattha (in Sanskrit Siddhartha, meaning "aim accomplished"), and in the period before his Supreme Enlightenment he is referred to as a Bodhisatta (in Sanskrit B Bodhisattva)--a being who is dedicated to achieving Enlightenment, a "future Buddha." The basic details of the Buddha's life are as follows. He was the son of a chief of the Sakyas, a small tribe of the Himalayan foothills, and was born at Kapilavatthu in what is now southern Nepal. Renouncing the privileged and luxurious life of his father's court, he became at the age of twenty-nine a wandering religious mendicant engaged in a search for the true meaning of life. Only after abandoning extreme ascetic practices and as a result of profound meditation did he achieve Enlightenment and realize a state of blissful mental calm known as Nibbana (in Sanskrit Nirvana). The Buddha conceived a new doctrine capable of putting an end to suffering and bringing complete peace. His teachings, the Dhamma, attracted many disciples, who formed a community or Buddhist order of monks, the Sangha. After many years of ministry, the Buddha died at the age of eighty, attaining Parinibbana, or total escape from the cycle of rebirth and death. His remains were cremated and his relics were placed in commemorative monuments known as stupas. In time Buddhist councils were held and the Buddha's teachings were gathered together and arranged as scriptures 5 known as the Tipitaka (Three Baskets), of which the first section, the Vinayapitaka (Basket of Discipline), deals with the organization and discipline of monks; the second, the Suttapitaka (Basket of Discourses), gives the Buddha's teachings and sermons; and the third, the Abhidhammapitaka (Basket of Ultimate Doctrine), offers a complex systematization of the whole. It was the monks who preserved the Buddha's teachings, at first by committing them to memory and then by recording and copying the Buddhist canon and producing commentaries and other Buddhist texts. Many monasteries became great centers of learning, attracting students from distant countries and organizing Buddhist missions. As a result, over several centuries Buddhism spread south from India to Sri Lanka and Burma, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia, and Vietnam and north to Central Asia, Tibet, China, Korea, and Japan. The school of Buddhism that spread northward became known as Mahayana (Great Vehicle) Buddhism and developed many different forms, including Tantric and Zen Buddhism, and the school that spread southward became known as Theravada (Way of the Elders) Buddhism or Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) Buddhism--the latter term not favored by Theravada Buddhists. Theravada Buddhism is also sometimes referred to as Pali Buddhism, Pali being the name of the ancient language in which its canonical texts are preserved. In India, the land of the Buddha's birth, Buddhism was in time eclipsed by Hinduism and Islam. Although Buddhism was encountered and studied by many Western missionaries, travelers, and colonial administrators, it was only in the twentieth century that different forms of Buddhism were introduced into Western countries and Buddhist monasteries and communities were established there. The Tipitaka (in Sanskrit Tripitaka) texts are extensive and complex and contain much information about the Buddha's life and ministry. But, since the scriptures are arranged by subject and form or length, this information is scattered and not in chronological sequence. Many of the discourses of the Buddha contain accounts of various episodes in his life. The Mahaparinibbana Sutta in particular is a major source for his last year; the Buddhavamsa (also part of the Suttapitaka) gives a very brief account of Gotama's life and the distribution of his relics, together with details of previous Buddhas. Later Buddhist sources attempted to construct a fuller record or "biography" of the Buddha. Details and a narrative of part of the Buddha's life are contained in the Pali commentaries, especially the Nidanakatha, compiled by Buddhaghosa in the early fifth century AD. This forms the introduction to the 6 Jatakatthakatha, or commentary on the stories of the Buddha's previous lives, and gives an account of the Buddha from his previous life as Sumedha to his Enlightenment and the first two years of his ministry. Sanskrit narratives of his life are sometimes, as in the case of the second-century AD poem by Asvaghosa called Buddhacarita, preserved in a fuller form in later Chinese and Tibetan translations. Sir Edwin Arnold's blank-verse epic on the life and teachings of the Buddha, The Light of Asia (1884), was based on Sanskrit texts (above all the Lalitavistara) and enjoyed great popularity among English readers in the late nineteenth century. Many legendary and miraculous features became incorporated into the story of the Buddha's life, and local variations developed. The Pali canonical texts and commentaries form the basis of later traditions in Sri Lanka and Southeast Asia, where continuous narrative accounts of the Buddha's life were composed in both Pali and indigenous languages. Among these were, in Sri Lanka, the Pali poem Jinacarita and the Sinhalese prose works Amavatura and Pujavaliya (composed in the thirteenth century); in Burma, the eighteenth-century Malalankara vatthu (Mala lingara wuthtu) and the nineteenth-century Jinattha-pakasani; and in Thailand, Laos, and Cambodia, the Pathama-sambodhi, a text of indeterminate age known in Thailand as Pathom Somphot, existing in its fullest form in a revised edition of 1845. Shining consistently through all the historical accretions and popular imagery of these accounts is the figure of a great religious and moral teacher who inspired a tolerant and lasting system of religious belief and way of life. Much of the teaching of the Buddha came from the spiritual ideas, philosophy, and social system of the India of his time, but much was new and original. The Buddha taught a way to salvation or deliverance that is open to all and that depends on an individual's own understanding and actions, not on faith, caste, ritual, or divine grace. Salvation is a goal for all Buddhists to strive toward; it means attaining in life the state of Nibbana and, when this life ends, achieving Parinibbana, or final, complete Nibbana. Some Western accounts make no distinction between these terms, and Nibbana--which literally means "blowing out" or "extinction" but really defies definition--is often rendered as Buddhist heaven, presumably to convey the idea of eternal bliss or salvation. Buddhism, although challenging and reacting to the Brahmanic ideology of ancient India, accepted from the start the concept of rebirth, which sees an individual life as one in a successive round of existences (samsara) in which each life is conditioned by one's earlier actions (kamma; in Sanskrit karma, in Burmese kan), that is, the moral 7 value of deeds performed in previous existences. The Buddha laid emphasis on the intention that lies behind deeds, thoughts, and words, and taught that there is every possibility to mold one's kamma. It can take countless rebirths for an individual to become an arahat (in Sanskrit arhat), a perfected being who has "completed the journey" and achieved Nibbana and who will not be reborn. The most feasible path to this otherworldly goal is through the seclusion and discipline of monastic life and the practice of intense spiritual meditation. There are many subjects and levels of meditation, but basically the Buddhist through meditation comes to understand that everything in the world is in a constant state of creation and dissolution, that the self is an illusion, and that all sentient existence involves suffering. These concepts of impermanence (anicca), of nonself or nonsoul (anatta), and of the inevitability of suffering (dukkha) are central to the Buddha's teaching, which offers a path to salvation. The Buddha's Noble Eightfold Path has three components or stages--morality (sila), concentration (samadhi), and wisdom (panna)--which are essential to achieve Nibbana. The Buddha emphasized the importance of self-reliance, and it is left to each individual to strive to achieve full intuitive knowledge. Buddhists in their daily life observe five basic precepts (panca-sila): to abstain from killing, from stealing, from engag- ing in sexual misconduct, from lying, and from taking intoxicants. Additional precepts are observed by monks, nuns, and strongly committed laity. Lay people, by providing food and clothing to the monks, by making endowments to the Sangha, and by seeking instruction in the Dhamma, can acquire merit and better rebirths. Above all, the Buddha gave to his followers a threefold heritage: first, his own experience and example of perfecting himself; second, a new teaching (the Dhamma) about the purpose and meaning of life and the way to salvation; and third, a monastic order (the Sangha) that preserved and spread his teaching and whose way of life exemplifies great merit and virtue. These Three Jewels of Buddhism are relied on as a means to salvation and are revered in the thricerepeated Buddhist formula or daily prayer: I go to the Buddha for refuge I go to the Dhamma for refuge I go to the Sangha for refuge BUDDHIST ART Buddhism has over the centuries inspired many artistic masterpieces. The figure of the Buddha did not appear in Buddhist art prior to the first century AD; instead symbols were used to indicate his presence and key events in his life. 8 Thus, his Enlightenment was represented by a Bodhi tree (the sacred fig tree under which he meditated), his first sermon by a wheel (the "wheel of the law"--his doctrines), his years of wandering and ministry by a footprint, and his death (Parinibbana) by a stupa. These symbols can be found in reliefs from Bharhut, Sanchi, and Amaravati in India. When images of the Buddha in human form did appear--first in the art of Gandhara and Mathura--the iconography and the hand gestures (in Sanskrit mudra) of the Buddha were of great significance. Tradition states that the Buddha was born with thirty-two major auspicious signs or marks on his body, as well as many minor ones, and artists, in seeking to represent these, imparted certain characteristics common to most Buddha images, although regional variations in style and preferred models and gestures naturally developed. Among the most noteworthy iconographic features of Buddha images are the cranial bump (usnisa) indicating wisdom, the long earlobes, and signs on the hands and feet. A large repertoire of gestures serves to symbolize and communicate particular incidents in his life and messages. Thus, images of the Buddha seated cross-legged with his hands in his lap indicate meditation; those with the right hand touching the ground near his right knee refer to the Buddha's calling the earth to witness when challenged by evil forces; the hands held in front of the chest, right palm outward with the thumb and forefinger forming a circle that is touched by the outstretched middle finger of the left hand, represents the preaching of the first sermon; images of the reclining or sleeping Buddha represent the Parinibbana. In time a form of narrative sculpture developed, of which the most famous examples are the Gandhara reliefs of Pakistan and Afghanistan, which date from the first to the fourth centuries AD, and those of the eighth- and ninth-century AD temple of Borobudur in central Java. Some ancient temples were also decorated with wall paintings depicting events in the life of the Buddha, although many have not survived the passage of time or have been repeatedly painted over. Modern Buddhist temples continue this practice, and some also feature life-size tableaux and even moving mechanical figures. The spiritual inspiration that so infused early Buddhist art seems by the nineteenth and twentieth centuries to have become less sublime and styles more secular, but the motivating force of acquiring merit remains unchanged and ensures continued patronage and production of Buddhist art. 9 BURMESE MANUSCRIPT ART Burma, one of the most strongly Buddhist countries in the world today, has a long tradition of narrative representations of the Buddha's life. Many of the Buddhist temples in Burma's ancient capital, Pagan, which flourished from the eleventh to the thirteenth centuries AD, contain sculpted friezes and plaques as well as wall paintings of episodes from the Buddha's life. These, apart from their aesthetic qualities, were supremely religious in purpose and concerned primarily with communicating the message of the Buddha at a time when the Theravada form of Buddhism was gaining ascendancy in Burma under King Anawrahta (1044�1077) and his successors. As in Indian Buddhist art, in some Burmese temple decorations certain principal events of the Buddha's life (and of his previous lives) were compressed with great skill and sophistication into a single scene, with associated figures and symbols grouped around. This format was also featured on the small Indian-style terra-cotta votive tablets or plaques that were particularly popular at Pagan. It is not known when the first Burmese manuscripts illustrating the Buddha's life appeared, given that few pre-eighteenth-century manuscripts have survived, but certainly by the nineteenth century series of manuscripts illustrating both the life of the Buddha and the Jataka stories of the Buddha's previous lives were being produced in some abundance. Moreover, as a subject for manuscript illustration, the life of the Buddha was especially popular in Burma, apparently far more so than in such other Theravada Buddhist countries as Sri Lanka and Thailand, which have produced relatively few examples of this genre. It is possible that the production and popularity of illustrated life-of-the-Buddha manuscripts in Burma is linked to the compilation in Burmese of the first full prose account of the Buddha's life. This work, Mala lingara wuthtu, was completed at Amarapura in 1798 by the monk Dutiya Medi Hsayadaw (1747�1834), who also bore several titles, of which the best known is Kawiwunthabidaza. Once the story of the Buddha's life was rendered into Burmese, it became more accessible than it was in its Pali version-- knowledge of Pali being largely confined to monks and scholars--and challenged artists' imagination with more details and events to depict. Some manuscripts bear on their covers the title of this work even though the text running beneath the pictures inside is not the full text but an abbreviated form narrating the essence of the story of the Buddha's life and elucidating the episodes depicted. Other manuscripts that form part of a series on the life of the Buddha simply state on the cover the part number and an indication of the first and last events 10 depicted in the manuscript. There is no set pattern of scenes in Burmese life-of-the-Buddha manuscripts. Obviously, certain key events are included, but the choice and depiction of other episodes in the Buddha's long life can vary greatly from one manuscript to another, presumably in accordance with the textual sources followed and the individual predilections of the commissioner of the manuscript and the talents of the artists. Before turning to a more detailed description of the two manuscripts featured in this book, some introduction to Burmese manuscripts in general is needed. There are two main types of manuscript: those written on oblong strips of palm leaves (called pe-za in Burmese) and those on long sheets of paper, folded concertina fashion, to make a folding book (parabaik in Burmese). Palm leaf manuscripts of the Pali canonical texts and Buddhist commentaries predominate, though legal, historical, and literary texts were also recorded on palm leaf. Paper parabaiks could be either black or natural creamy white in color. The black-paper parabaiks were less long lasting than the white ones and were used mostly as notebooks and for draft administrative records, the text being written on them in white soapstone or steatite. Sometimes they were used to record astrological and tattooing designs and for sketch maps. White-paper parabaiks were written on in ink and used for a variety of purposes, above all for painted illustrations, in which case the paper was usually first given a chalky white or pale-colored background wash. Common subjects for illustration were the life of the Buddha, the Jataka stories of the Buddha's previous lives, court scenes and entertainments, cosmology, and classificatory works depicting types of elephants, royal barges, military maneuvers, objects in use at the royal court, and the like. Covers of the folding books were often stiffened, and some were decorated with gilding and raised patterns or inlaid colored glass, or tooled leather, or painted geometric designs. Occasionally the title or subject of the work and, more rarely, details of the commissioner or donor of the manuscript would be inscribed on the covers. If opened out fully, a parabaik can extend to several meters; however, parabaiks were designed to be viewed not all at once but opening by opening, and they were kept folded and stored in manuscript chests. Painted parabaiks have great visual impact, with brilliantly colored and richly gilded scenes flowing across each opening and onto the next. Their composition bears some relationship to that of wall paintings; indeed, scenes in Burmese parabaiks look as if they have been transferred from a temple wall onto, and overspilling, the folds of the manuscript. Manuscript 11 painters had, however, access to a brighter palette than is found in wall paintings, and they embellished their work with gilding. Rough practice sketches sometimes found on the reverse sides of illustrated folding books give a clue to the artists' working methods. Outlines were first drawn in red or brown, and the color was then filled in, the whole having a flat, linear appearance. Scenes generally flow from left to right, although events are not necessarily depicted in order of occurrence, since scenes separated in time can be grouped together if they share the same location. Sometimes scenes are divided naturalistically by lines of trees or buildings, or by rows of figures who play some part in the narrative. The curlicued double borders that surround and divide scenes in some eighteenth-century wall paintings are not found in manuscript paintings. Gilding is used to decorate the tiered spires of palace buildings (which are further highlighted by being placed against plain dark blocks of color), to embellish the robes of royalty and courtiers, and above all for the figure of the Buddha. This convention is extended in illustrations of the Jataka stories to gilding whatever creature (elephant, bird, deer, etc.) or personage the Buddha had been in a former incarnation. There is in early painted parabaiks no central or coordinated perspective, but rather multiple perspectives, so that events inside and outside buildings can be viewed simultaneously. The device of a horizon is not much used in earlier paintings, but it occasionally appears near the top of the composition. Some depth is provided by the practice of painting key figures and buildings against a solid dark background, often of piled-up swirling rocks. A lower horizon and receding, diminishing perspectives became increasingly common in paintings of the late nineteenth century, when a more centered composition also began to appear. Such features presumably reflect the influence of Western techniques and the trained "company school" style of Indian painters working for the East India Company. All British diplomatic missions to Burma employed artists to record scenes and events. Michael Symes, in his account of his 1795 embassy to Burma, specifically mentions the interest shown by the Burmese king in the accurate and realistic representations produced by Symes' Indian painter, Singey Bey, who was asked to produce for the king a painting of the Buddha and to copy another of elephants. Burmese court artists may also have seen illustrations in Western books, and later in the nineteenth century King Thibaw employed some Italian artists. Nor can the influence of Thai artists, brought back to Burma after the conquest of the Thai capital of Ayutthaya in 1767, be discounted. As the 12 nineteenth century progressed, however, much of the individuality and verve that characterize earlier Burmese manuscript paintings were lost and scenes became more static and rigid, with rows of bland-faced and repetitive figures set in simple landscapes or in proportioned interiors. It is a feature of all Burmese life-of-the-Buddha and Jataka paintings that the artist drew freely on his contemporary surroundings and made no attempt to portray the Buddha in a historical Indian setting. This can result in such charming incongruities as the Bodhisatta traveling in a paddle steamer. It also, of course, provides valuable clues for dating the paintings by such details as hairstyles, costumes, and architecture and, above all, a wonderful evocation of life in Burma before the British annexation of Upper Burma put an end to a proudly independent Buddhist kingdom in 1885�1886. THE BURNEY PARABAIKS The two Burmese manuscripts on which this book is based were selected for three reasons: their interesting provenance, their artistic merit, and their compact presentation of the story of the Buddha. Many other illustrated life-of-the-Buddha manuscripts run into several volumes that have, over time, become dispersed such that a complete sequence cannot be assembled from the collection of a single institution or library. The manuscripts reproduced here, designated Or. 14297 and Or. 14298 in the Oriental and India Office Collections of the British Library, were once owned by British diplomat and Orientalist Henry Burney (1792�1845), British Resident at the Burmese Court of Ava from 1830 to 1837. They were acquired by the British Library in 1985 from a descendant of Burney, but the family had no record or memory of the circumstances in which the manuscripts came into their possession. Over and above the family link, Burney's ownership of these manuscripts is confirmed by documents in the collections of the Royal Commonwealth Society, Cambridge University Library. Unfortunately, Burney's papers throw no light on the manuscripts' creation or on how he acquired them. Burney's exceptional fluency in Burmese and his understanding of Burmese history, religion, and culture enabled him to establish unusually good relations with King Bagyidaw (1819�1837) and his ministers. Burney had an especially high regard for the minister Myawaddy Min Gyi U Sa (1766�1853?), an important figure at the court. U Sa was a cultivated man of letters, and it is tempting to speculate that his conversations with Burney might have turned to Buddhism and art. The illustrated manuscripts of the life of the Buddha might have 13 been presented to U Sa by some influential person at the royal court. Furthermore, it is known that U Sa was a patron and supporter of the Dutiya Medi Hsayadaw--author of the Burmese prose version of the life of the Buddha (Mala lingara wuthtu)--and indeed built and endowed a monastery for him at Ava. It is possible that U Sa, inspired by the learned monk's great work, might have commissioned the manuscript paintings. To take speculation even further, U Sa might have subsequently presented these precious parabaiks to Burney, perhaps for safekeeping during the turmoil accompanying King Bagyidaw's overthrow, a period when U Sa himself was for a short time imprisoned. Another, even less likely source might be the Mekkhara Prince, an uncle of King Bagyidaw, who had learned English and translated into Burmese articles from Rees' Cyclopaedia. An even more intriguing, but very remote, possibility is that Burney himself might have commissioned the manuscripts. Burney's possession of the manuscripts at least provides a cutoff date for their production, that is, before 1837, the date when Burney withdrew the British Residency from Ava to Rangoon in the aftermath of a royal coup d'�tat that brought King Tharrawaddy to the throne. Study of the style and details of the Burney life-of-the-Buddha manuscripts and comparison with other examples of this genre and with dated wall paintings suggest that the Burney parabaiks were created between the late 1790s and the 1830s, most probably in the early 1800s. This ranks the Burney manuscripts among the earliest surviving illustrated manuscripts from Burma. Burney's two manuscripts are fine and rare examples of Burmese art. Although differing in page dimensions and extent (Or. 14297 measures 49 x 19 cm, or 19 5/16 x 71/2 in., and has 104 folds with illustrations on 52 openings; Or. 14298 measures 47.3 x 19 cm, or 18 5/8 x 71/2 in., and has 49 folds with illustrations on 25 openings), they were painted by the same hand or hands and were planned as an entity, the one being a continuation of the other. The Burney parabaiks are remarkable not only for their skilled and compact rendition of the long life of the Buddha but also for their unusual and beautifully painted covers. Each cover--now, as might be expected, somewhat worn and rubbed--bears a different figure, whose identity may also hold a clue to the commissioner or donor of the manuscripts. The covers of Or. 14297 are decorated with paintings of white-robed deities who probably represent the gods Sakka and Brahma, whereas the covers of Or. 14298--shown in this book on p. 4 and opposite--each have a figure in colored robes, possibly representing two of the four guardian gods of the world 14 (lokapala). The figures' hands are joined in reverence, and the whole can be taken to represent the homage and submission of the gods to the Buddha. Another possible interpretation is that the white-robed figures of Or. 14297 represent the Burmese monarch, who traditionally donned the royal Sakka robes for the propitiation ceremony of Sakka and Brahma and on other religious and ceremonial occasions. The association of the Burmese monarch with Sakka, king of the gods, and with the Buddha is of long standing. Burmese palace architecture and decor proclaimed and emphasized this, as did all royal ceremonies and the annual cycle of religious festivals and ceremonies. Throughout the manuscripts, the kings and the great gods are depicted in identical three-tiered costumes, and it is easy to see that the Burmese king or high royal official under whose patronage the manuscripts were painted was associating himself with the merit of the kings and gods who ministered to and revered the great lord Buddha. Painted back cover of Or. 14298 15 T he most excellent Bodhisatta, the Buddha-to-be, who surpasses the humans, gods, and Brahmas of the three worlds, was, an innumerable number of existences past, an ascetic named Sumedha. At that time Dipankara Buddha had been invited by the king to a feast and Sumedha lay across a muddy patch of unfinished road on the way to the palace so that the Buddha might tread over his body without soiling his feet. Marveling at Sumedha's great determination, Dipankara Buddha proclaimed that Sumedha too would become a Buddha after acquiring and practicing the Ten Perfections and their associated Thirty Virtues, together with the Five Great Charities and the Three Good Works throughout an immeasurable period of world cycles. 16 I n his last human existence before that in which he became the Buddha, the Bodhisatta was born as Prince Vessantara, son of King Sanjaya in the city of Jetuttara of the kingdom of Sivirattha. Now Prince Vessantara gave away in charity the kingdom's white elephant and became a hermit on Vankagiri mountain. Furthermore, while there he did not shrink from giving away his children to the brahmin Jujaka. After this life of perfect generosity as Prince Vessantara, he was reborn as Setaketu in Tusita heaven. There all the gods of the ten thousand universes came to petition him to become a Buddha in the human world, and he therefore considered and chose the five points or circumstances of a Buddha appearing: in what epoch, on which continent, at what place, and of what race and to which mother should he be born? And so Queen Mahamaya of the Sakyan city of Kapilavatthu conceived the future Buddha and was protected in her chamber by the four great kings, guardian gods of the four quarters of the world. 18 Q ueen Mahamaya, having carried the future Buddha in her womb for ten months as smoothly as oil in a monk's bowl, submitted her desire to visit relatives in the country of Devadaha to King Suddhodana, who granted her permission to proceed on her way, borne in a golden palanquin and surrounded by attendants. Between the countries of Kapilavatthu and Devadaha, in a beautiful grove of flowering sala trees called Lumbini, the queen was delivered, stretching out her hand and holding the branch of a sala tree that was bending toward her. At that moment the great Brahmas received the infant in a golden net, the four guardian gods on a black antelope skin and the royal ministers on a fine white royal cloth. The infant then stood on the ground and, taking seven paces to the north, spoke the words "I am the most exalted and excellent." That same day the holy man Kaladevala, who could see whatever had happened in forty previous worlds and whatever would happen in forty future worlds, came to the palace to behold the Buddha-to-be. The child, on being carried near to pay reverence, raised both feet and placed them on the braided hair of the holy man, who smiled because he saw that the prince would become a Buddha and wept because he himself would not live to see that event. On the fifth day after the birth, Kondanna, who was the youngest of eight brahmins versed in the interpretation of signs, held up one finger--meaning that the child would surely become a Buddha--while the other brahmins held up two fingers, meaning that the child would become either a Buddha or a world emperor. 20 A month after the birth of the Buddha-to-be, his father, the king, went out to perform the royal ploughing ceremony. The child was placed in the shade of a rose-apple tree and entered into the first state of meditation, during which time the shadow of the tree did not change or move. On hearing of this wonder, King Suddhodana came and paid homage to his son. As the young prince grew, the royal tutor soon found that his pupil was beyond his instruction. His father built him three palaces, one for each season, and the prince was entertained royally and passed his days in luxury and comfort, shielded from the harsh realities of life, for his father wished only that his son should become a great ruler of this world. When he was sixteen years old, Prince Siddhattha Gotama displayed his skills in archery to an assembly of his kinsmen so that none could question his mastery of the traditional arts. At the same age he married Princess Yasodhara, who was the daughter of King Suddhodana's brother-in-law, King Suppabuddha, and who had been born on the same day as the prince. And the marriage was celebrated with great feasting, entertainment, and rejoicing. 22 O ne day, when Prince Siddhattha set out for the royal gardens, he encountered the Four Great Signs: an old man, a sick man, a corpse, and a monk. When he thus learned of old age, disease, and death, his mind became agitated by the miseries of the world. On arriving at the gardens, he seated himself upon a large, smooth stone and felt a desire to put on his royal ornaments, whereupon a god, assuming the appearance of a royal valet, came down from the upper world to adorn him. At that moment the prince's courtiers came and reported to him the birth of a son. Returning to the city in the cool of the evening, the prince in all his splendor was greeted by the Princess Kisagotami with the joyful words "Happy and calm today is the mind of the mother, the father, and the wife who has such a lord." Her words brought to the prince's mind the thought that only when the fires of attachment, hatred, and delusion are extinguished can one be truly happy. He resolved henceforth to seek the calm of Nibbana, and, taking off his pearl necklace, he presented it to the princess. On his return to the palace, all the dancers, musicians, and singers came immediately to entertain the prince, but his mind was free of worldly passion and he fell asleep. When he awoke, he saw the palace ladies asleep, with their hair and dress disheveled, some dribbling, some grinding their teeth, some talking in their sleep, and some snoring, and his palace seemed to him like a charnel-house of loathsome dead bodies. So, taking one last look at his sleeping wife and child, he summoned the nobleman Channa, mounted his white horse Kanthaka, and, with Channa holding onto its tail, rode out of the palace, with the gods muffling the sound of the horse's hooves. 24 O utside the gates, Mara, the Spirit of Evil, barred his way and tried to deter Prince Siddhattha from leaving to seek Enlightenment in the solitude of the wilderness. The prince wanted to take one last look at the city of Kapilavatthu but thought he should resist such a desire, whereupon the whole earth turned, like a potter's wheel, before his eyes. In a single day the prince passed through three kingdoms and came to the great river Anoma, some thirty yojana, or leagues, distant from his father's palace. The prince crossed the river with one leap of his horse and dismounted on its bank of silvery sand. Then, taking his long topknot of hair in his left hand and his sword in his right, the Bodhisatta cut off his hair with one stroke. Casting it upward, he said, "If I am truly to become a Buddha, let this hair ascend into the sky, and, if not, let it fall to the ground," and the hair was caught by the god Sakka in a gold-flowered casket and enshrined in Tavatimsa heaven. At that time the Brahma named Ghatikara appeared and offered to the Bodhisatta the eight things necessary for a monk (the three robes, an alms bowl, a razor, a needle, a water strainer, and a girdle). The Bodhisatta put on the robes of a monk and ordered Channa and the horse to return to the palace. Kanthaka the horse was so distressed to be sent back that he died of grief on the spot, and Channa, sobbing, set out alone to give news of the prince to his family. 26 A fter spending seven days in the grove of mango trees called Anupiya, the Bodhisatta pro- ceeded in one day to the city of Rajagaha in the kingdom of Magadha, some thirty leagues distant, and decided to enter the city in the manner of former Buddhas--that is, with his alms bowl to receive offerings of food. His appearance caused such excitement and commotion in the city that King Bimbisara was informed of it and decided to have the stranger followed to see who he was and whether he ate all the mixture of food put in his alms bowl. The Bodhisatta went to the foot of Pandava hill and, overcoming his repugnance to the contents of the bowl, was able to eat. When this was reported to him, King Bimbisara made haste to visit and talk to the Bodhisatta. Discerning that he would assuredly become a Buddha, Bimbisara requested that his kingdom should be the first to be visited by the Bodhisatta once he had attained Enlightenment. To this the Bodhisatta agreed. 28 C ontinuing on his travels, the Bodhisatta learned in the forest of Uruvela all that the hermits Alara and Uddaka could teach him. Then for six years in the jungle he practiced many religious austerities, including extreme fasting, with five wandering ascetics as his attendants. But such practices, he concluded, were not the path to Enlightenment. In those days in a village called Senani there lived Sujata, the daughter of a rich man. Sujata's request (to have a son), which she had made at the foot of a banyan tree, had been fulfilled, so she prepared as a special thankoffering to the tree's guardian spirit some rice boiled in concentrated milk, while Sakka, Brahma, and other gods kept watch and infused the milk with heavenly flavors. She then carried some of the milk-rice in a precious golden bowl to the tree under which the Bodhisatta was seated in meditation, and the Bodhisatta, stretching out his hand, received Sujata's offering. 30 T he Bodhisatta divided Sujata's offering of milk-rice into forty-nine mouthfuls, which there- upon he ate on the banks of the river Neranjara. He then set the golden bowl afloat, saying, "If I am truly to become a Buddha today, may this bowl float upstream." This it did, and then it sank to the abode of the serpent king, Mahakala, where it knocked against the bowls of three previous Buddhas and roused the serpent king, who bestowed praises upon the Bodhisatta. After setting the golden bowl afloat, the Bodhisatta remained in the forest of sala trees near the Neranjara river until the cool of the evening, when he went down to the Bodhi tree along a road prepared and adorned by the gods. On the way he met a grass cutter named Sotthiya, who offered him eight handfuls of grass. These he scattered on the ground by the east side of the tree, whereupon a throne fourteen cubits high appeared. Sakka, Brahma, and all the greater and lesser gods offered homage and worship with conch shell, white umbrella, yak's tail and circular fans, and harp music. 32 W hile the Bodhisatta was seated cross-legged on the Aparajita (unconquered) throne, from which he had resolved not to arise until he attained Enlightenment, Mara, the Spirit of Evil, mounted on the mighty elephant Girimekhala, came to make war upon him, using nine different kinds of weapons. But the Bodhisatta's accumulated perfections, culminating in the virtue of generosity practiced in his existence as Prince Vessantara, caused the defeat of Mara and his army while the earth itself trembled and testified to the Bodhisatta's fitness to be the Fully Enlightened One. During the first watch of the night the Bodhisatta meditated and obtained the power of seeing all former states of existence; at midnight he obtained the divine vision possessed by perfect ones; during the third watch he realized the Four Truths. And so, being endowed with the Ten Strengths and the Four Points of Confidence and with every other quality necessary to become a Buddha, and having attained the highest stage on the path of perfection and perfect omniscience, at dawn he attained Enlightenment, becoming a Buddha without equal in the three worlds of men, gods, and Brahmas. When this great wonder took place, ten thousand worlds were shaken twelve times and echoed with the words "Most Excellent Being," and Sakka, Brahmas and gods, and other heavenly beings came to pay reverence to the perfect Buddha, from whom light radiated in multicolored streams. 34 T he whole universe was as if covered with beautiful flowers, and for forty-nine days the Buddha's mind remained deeply engaged in sublime contemplation as he meditated in seven different places. Throughout this time he took no food, nor experienced the least want, and his appearance and countenance stayed unchanged. For seven successive days he remained seated in meditation on the Aparajita throne. He then came down from the throne and, going a certain distance, stood looking at the Bodhi tree for a further seven days with a steadfast, unblinking gaze. For the next seven days the Buddha walked to and fro along a golden walkway built by the gods between the throne and the spot called Animisa (unblinking), where he had earlier stood looking at the seat of Enlightenment. For the following seven days he contemplated the seven books of the Abhidhamma in Ratanaghara, a beautiful jeweled house that shone like gold. 36 N ext he went to the Ajapala (goatherds') banyan tree. While seated in meditation under it, the Buddha was visited first by the three daughters of Mara, who endeavored in vain to seduce him by assuming various guises, and then by a haughty brahmin named Huhunka, who questioned him on the nature of true brahmins. For the next period of seven days the Buddha went to a tree near the lake of Mucalinda. During these seven days there was a violent rain and the serpent king, Mucalinda, sheltered the Buddha by winding his coils seven times around the Buddha and spreading his hood over the Buddha's head. The Buddha next remained seated for seven days under the Rajayatana tree to the south of the Bodhi tree, experiencing the bliss of emancipation. At the end of this time Sakka, king of the gods, presented him with the fruit of the myrobalan tree, a tooth-stick from the stem of a betel creeper, and water from the lake of Anotatta for his refreshment. Next the four great guardian gods presented him with four bowls, which the Buddha miraculously caused to become one bowl with four rims, and in this bowl the Buddha received offerings of rice cakes cooked in honey tendered by the two brothers Tapussa and Bhallika, merchants from the distant city of Ukkalapa in Ramanna. 38 N ow, returning to the Ajapala tree, the Buddha hesitated as to whether he should preach his teachings (the Dhamma) at all. Then Sahampati, the great Brahma of the Brahma heavens, and many gods all came to petition the Buddha to preach to mankind. And when the Buddha considered to whom he should first preach, he thought first of Alara and Uddaka, but upon perceiving that they had recently died, he next saw that his former companions, the five wandering ascetics, were in a deer park near Benares, and he resolved to preach first to them. On the way there he encountered the false priest Upaka and announced to him that he had attained Enlightenment. On seeing the Buddha approach, the five ascetics at first were determined to pay him no regard, since he had abandoned the practice of austerities, but they were unable to keep their resolve and came to meet him. And so in the deer park at Isipatana near Benares the Buddha preached his first sermon, which is called the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, or the setting in motion of the wheel of the Dhamma, which contained the fundamental principles of his teaching expressed as the Four Noble Truths: life is full of suffering; the cause of suffering is desire; cessation of desire ends suffering; and the way to end suffering is to follow the Noble Eightfold Path of right views, right aims, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right concentration. Thus, on the full moon day, all the gods and Brahmas heard the Buddha's message and the five ascetics became his first disciples. And while the Buddha was in the deer park the memorable conversion of a young layman took place. 40 T here was in the city of Benares a rich man's son named Yasa, who led a life of pleasure sur- rounded by singers and dancing girls until one day he suddenly resolved to subdue his passions and become a monk. It was then that the father of Yasa invited the Buddha to his house and made him offerings of food, and when Yasa's family heard the Buddha's preaching they all became his lay disciples and supporters. After Yasa became a monk, his example was followed by his four close friends and by other friends and companions so that the Buddha now had sixty disciples. At first a true follower was accepted by the Buddha with the simple words "Ehi bhikkhu" (Come, O monk), but later rules came to be established. The Buddha told his monk-disciples to go forth in different directions to preach his teachings and advised them on the admittance of followers into the Sangha, or community of monks, that was forming. The Buddha then continued on his way alone. 42 T he Buddha, upon coming to Uruvela grove, where lived three hermit brothers and their many followers, requested permission from the elder brother, Uruvela-Kassapa, to spend the night there, and Kassapa replied that he was welcome to stay in his cook-house, but he should beware the poisonous naga (serpent) that guarded it. The Buddha, however, had no fear, and when the naga in the night threatened him by sending forth smoke and flames, the Buddha displayed his superior powers. When morning came, the Buddha caught the naga and put him in his alms bowl and showed him to Kassapa, who was impressed and invited the Buddha to stay on in Uruvela grove. While the Buddha stayed at Uruvela grove, many miraculous happenings occurred, but for a long time the hermit brother Uruvela-Kassapa persisted in thinking that the Buddha was not even his equal. 44 O n one occasion, Kassapa invited the Buddha to come and partake of his meal and the Buddha agreed, saying that he would come and join him later. The Buddha then went and plucked the golden jambu fruit from the farthest extremity of Jambudipa, the southern continent of man, and yet reached the eating place before Kassapa. When Kassapa arrived, the Buddha offered him the fruit, but Kassapa acknowledged it was not suitable for him to eat it. On another occasion, the Buddha wanted to wash his robe, whereupon the god Sakka provided a wash tank and stone, and a nearby tree bent down its branch for the Buddha to hang his robe on. Another time there was a great rainstorm and the land was inundated. Kassapa went in a boat to see how the Buddha fared and found that he was walking to and fro on firm, dry land, untouched by the water. These and other displays of the Buddha's powers finally convinced the hermit brothers, and they and their hundreds of followers became the Buddha's disciples. 46 N ow the Buddha remembered his promise to King Bimbisara, namely, that his would be the first kingdom the Buddha would visit after his attainment of Enlightenment. So with a thousand disciples he set out for the city of Rajagaha, where he stopped in a grove of palm trees. There he was visited by King Bimbisara, his court and warriors, and a multitude of people who came to pay respect and to hear him preach. In front of this great assembly, the hermit brother Kassapa acknowledged the Buddha as his teacher and paid reverence to him. And King Bimbisara, having entered the stream that leads to deliverance, at this time gave a bamboo grove called Veluvana to the Buddha for his use as a secluded place to live. There, in the monastery donated by King Bimbisara, the Buddha spent the next three rainy seasons. 48 N ow in the kingdom of Magadha there were two young friends named Upatissa and Kolita, later known as Sariputta and Moggallana. They used to ride on rich golden palanquins and in horse-drawn carriages until one day they realized the impermanence of things and decided to renounce the world. They studied first under the teacher Sanjaya and then wandered about in search of a better teacher. After some time, Sariputta, while staying in Rajagaha, met the Buddha's disciple Assaji--the fifth of the five ascetics converted at the deer park by the Buddha-- who uttered to him the stanza beginning "Ye dhamma hetuppabhava" (Of things that proceed from a cause, their cause the Tathagatha has told, and also their cessation; thus teaches the great ascetic). Recognizing this as the true teaching, Sariputta went to find Moggallana, and the two resolved to visit the Buddha at Veluvana. The Buddha preached to them and ordained them as monks, and they became his chief disciples, who in time could answer questions within the range of no other disciples of the Buddha. The next rainy season was spent by the Buddha at Vesali, where he preached to his monks and to all who came there to see him. 50 I n the sixth year of his ministry the Buddha performed the great miracle of the pairs at Savatthi and defeated sectarian opponents by a display of his superior powers. He next considered what former Buddhas had done, and he saw that they had preached the law in Tavatimsa heaven to their mothers. So he raised his right foot and placed it on the top of Yugandhara mountain and his left toe he placed upon Mount Meru, and with another stride he reached Tavatimsa heaven and seated himself upon an immense rock (which, called Pandukambala, was the throne of Sakka) under the heavenly parijata tree. Attended by all the gods of the ten thousand worlds, he preached to his mother and expounded the Abhidhamma. For three months he preached in Tavatimsa heaven. Then, on the full moon day when the Buddha was ready to descend to the earth, Sakka prepared a triple stairway, one of gold for the gods, one of silver for the Brahmas, and a jeweled one in the middle for the Buddha to descend upon. Accompanied by these deities holding white umbrellas and ceremonial fans, the Buddha set foot upon the earth at the gateway to the city of Sankassa while all paid reverence to him. 52 T hus, after six rainy seasons had passed, the Buddha spent the seventh in Tavatimsa heaven and the eighth preaching in the city of Sumsumaragiri in Bhagga country. The ninth he spent at Ghositarama monastery in Kosambi, where he refreshed, with the cooling waters of the law, five hundred ascetics and others who were ready to receive his teachings. The tenth rainy season he spent in the solitude of the forest of Parileyya, where the king of elephants in that country came and ministered to all his needs and paid him very great reverence. The eleventh season was passed in Dakkhinagiri monastery in a brahmin village called Ekanala, where he preached the law to the brahmins of the Bharadvaja clan and others. The Buddha spent the twelfth rainy season in the town of Veranja, where at the end of the season he and his monk disciples were invited to a meal and presented with offerings by the brahmins of that town. The Buddha, for the remaining years of his long ministry, journeyed throughout northern India, preaching and establishing communities of monks. In particular he spent many rainy seasons at Jetavana monastery in Savatthi, with his disciple Ananda his constant attendant. 54 I t was at Jetavana that his disciple Sariputta, perceiving that in former ages a Buddha's chief disciples had always died first, realized that his own period of life would not extend beyond the next seven days. Sariputta then contemplated in what place he should cease to exist, and, seeing that it should be in the house in Nalaka village where he had been born, he requested the Buddha's permission to go there. On his deathbed, Sariputta was visited by the four great guardian gods, by Sakka, and by the Brahmas. When his old mother saw this, she perceived the worth of her son and received from him the Buddha's teaching, and then Sariputta entered into Parinibbana, total escape from the cycle of rebirth and death. His grieving mother ordered five hundred gold shrines and five hundred tiered spires to be made in his honor and built a funeral pyre ninety-nine cubits high. Sariputta's nurse, named Revati, came to offer flowers at the pyre but was trampled to death in the crush and immediately translated to Tavatimsa heaven, from which she descended in a golden ornamented pavilion to pay homage to Sariputta. 56 A fter the funeral Sariputta's relics, his robes and bowl, were gathered up by the monk Cunda, who took them first to Ananda. Together they went to inform the Buddha, who extolled the virtues of Sariputta and caused a shrine enclosing his relics to be built in his memory. Sariputta's death was preceded by that of Rahula, who had been ordained by Sariputta at the Buddha's request. The Buddha and his followers then departed for Rajagaha, and it was at that time that the Buddha's disciple Moggallana also attained Parinibbana, as did Kondanna, the brahmin who had foretold that the young Prince Siddhattha would one day become a Buddha. In memory of Moggallana, the Buddha also caused a shrine to be built at Jetavana. Rahula's attainment of Parinibbana occurred in Tavatimsa, and Kondanna's took place at the great lake of the Chaddanta elephants. 58 F rom Rajagaha the Buddha traveled on to Vesali. There he stopped for a day at the Capala shrine, a pleasant place. Calling Ananda to him, the Buddha praised Vesali and its shrines, adding, "Ananda, every wise person should be earnest in perfecting himself in the four bases of psychic powers and, if he so chooses, should remain so doing for a whole world cycle. I, the Buddha, having become perfect in these matters, can so remain for as long as I wish." The Buddha repeated these words three times. But Ananda was deaf to the hint contained therein and, paying reverence, made no answer. Soon after, Mara, the Spirit of Evil, appeared and addressed the Buddha, saying, "O great Buddha, go now to Nibbana; the time has come." To this the Buddha replied, "Do not be concerned, O evil one; very soon, within three months, I shall attain the great Parinibbana." Upon this utterance of the Buddha, the earth began to shake violently. Ananda, being afraid, came near to ask the meaning of the earthquake, whereupon the Buddha explained the eight causes of the earth so shaking, saying that the seventh cause was, as he had just demonstrated, his mastery and renunciation of existence, and that the eighth cause, still to come, would be the Buddha's attaining Parinibbana. Only then did Ananda petition the Buddha thrice over to stay on the earth for the benefit of men, gods, and Brahmas during one age of the world. But the Buddha replied, "Ananda, it is too late, when you remained silent before, to ask this of me now." The Buddha then told Ananda to assemble all his monks, and he preached, exhorting them to remain faithful to his teachings in order to ensure the continuance of the Sasana, or Buddhist faith. 60 F rom Vesali the Buddha, now eighty years of age, continued on his journey to Kusinara, resting along the way in the villages of Bhandagama, Ambagama, Jambugama, Hatthigama, and Bhogagamanagara. On this his final journey, the Buddha preached to his monks on the four bases of mindfulness, that is, the four ways of directing the mind to the impurities and impermanence of matter, on the four great authorities, and on the practices that lead to the attainment of Nibbana. At length the Buddha arrived at Pava, a city of the Malla kings. There he stopped at the mango grove that Cunda, the son of a wealthy goldsmith, had presented, with a monastery, to the Buddha. When Cunda heard that the Buddha had arrived, he was delighted and invited the Buddha and his followers to partake of a meal on the morning of the next day. To the Buddha Cunda served pork and rice, but in accordance with the Buddha's instructions he served other food to his followers. When the Buddha had finished eating, he told Cunda to take what remained of the meal and bury it in a hole in the ground. Soon the Buddha was taken ill, but he continued slowly and composedly on his journey to Kusinara. This was his last meal. 62 O n the way to Kusinara, the Buddha became very thirsty and asked Ananda to fetch him water from the river, through which the Malla kings had just driven with five hundred oxcarts. As the water was so muddied and dirty, Ananda did not want to give it to the Buddha, but the Buddha insisted, asking three times for it, and when Ananda filled the Buddha's bowl the water turned clear and pure. Now Pukkusa, a Malla prince, came and desired to make an offering to the Buddha of two fine robes of the color of pure gold. The Buddha accepted one robe and told Pukkusa to give the other to Ananda, which would be as if given to all his community of monks (the Sangha) and would be an act of great merit. Ananda in turn made an offering of this robe to the Buddha, who, clothed in the robes, glittered like a great pillar of fire. And the Buddha told Ananda that his body so glowed because the time had come for him to attain the state of Parinibbana. 64 T he Buddha with his disciples then went down to the bank of the river Kakuttha, where he bathed and refreshed himself, and then into a mango grove a short distance from the river. There the Buddha, feeling very fatigued, asked the monk Cunda to double his outer cloth into four folds, which he then lay down upon, on his right side. At that moment Ananda arrived and the Buddha, perceiving that the goldsmith's son was troubled of mind because the food he had served had made the Buddha ill, told Ananda to go to Cunda and explain to him that there are two offerings of food to a Buddha that are of equal and the greatest merit: the offering of food before the Enlightenment and the offering of the Buddha's very last meal. Cunda's deed was, the Buddha explained, one that would bring him uncommon rewards. 66 T he Buddha then went to the sala grove of the Malla kings on the banks of the Hirannavati river. There he lay down on his right side on a royal couch placed between two trees, whose boughs, meeting overhead to form a bower, burst into bloom. All the gods of the ten thousand worlds came and honored him to the accompaniment of music and dancing. The Buddha then instructed the faithful Ananda on the making of offerings and on what was to be done in the future and preached that good practices and virtuous living were important duties for the continuance of his dispensations. To the assembled monks his last words were, "Everything is subject to change; strive on without delay." And so at the dawning of the day the Buddha entered the great Parinibbana. When it was known that the lord Buddha had departed, some monks wailed and lamented; others, possessed of greater understanding, were calm. Next the Malla kings all came, bringing perfume and fine robes, to mourn and to pay their respects. For seven successive days there was singing and dancing as with music, flowers, and perfume they honored the departed Buddha. On the eighth day the Malla kings put on new robes and bore the body of the Buddha in procession, accompanied by all the gods. Now there was a woman named Mallika, widow of the general Bandhula, who had taken that day a precious gold ornamental cloth and sprinkled it with perfume. Stopping the procession, she spread it like a shroud over the Buddha, praying that she in future births might have no need of ornaments but might always appear as though ornamented. And, so adorned, the body of the Buddha glowed a beauteous gold. 68 O utside the eastern gate of the city they built an immense funeral pyre of fragrant sandal- wood, and in accordance with Ananda's instructions the Buddha's body was wrapped five hundred times over in a cotton cloth and then in a fine cloth, and placed in a golden coffin upon the pyre, which was one hundred and twenty cubits high. At that time the great Kassapa was on his way from the city of Pava to Kusinara, accompanied by five hundred monks, when he met an ascetic bearing aloft like an umbrella an extraordinary mandarava flower. From this flower, which appears only on great and rare occasions associated with Buddhas, Kassapa discerned that the Parinibbana of the Buddha had occurred seven days ago. Kassapa, on hearing the monk Subhadda say that they should not grieve, as now they were free of the Buddha's control and could do as they pleased, was shocked and thereupon resolved to hold an assembly of learned monks to ascertain and preserve correctly the Buddha's teachings. The Malla kings then tried to set fire to the funeral pyre, but the sandalwood would not catch light, as the gods were waiting for Kassapa to arrive to pay reverence to the Buddha's body. Kassapa, hands raised to his forehead, circled the pyre three times; where he stopped, the sacred feet of the Buddha appeared from the coffin--whereupon Kassapa bowed his head beneath them and all paid reverence. Only then, and without the aid of men or gods, did the funeral pyre catch fire, and all was consumed, apart from various sacred relics. After this, streams of water came down from the sky between the two sala trees, and the Malla kings also poured scented water to extinguish the fire. 70 W hen the fire was extinguished, the Malla kings put the relics in a gold receptacle and placed them under a white umbrella on the back of a splendidly caparisoned elephant. Offerings of flowers were presented and the relics were taken to the city in a grand procession of elephants, horses, chariots, and soldiers, all in close formation. For seven days the sacred relics were guarded there in a special pavilion, with white umbrellas placed over them, so that all from near and far might have an opportunity to come and pay reverence. And the Malla kings and princes were at first disposed to keep for themselves these sacred relics of the Buddha. Soon King Ajatasattu, son of King Bimbisara, and kings in other kingdoms heard of the demise of the Buddha. 72 T hese kings all sent messages and then came to ask the Malla kings for the Buddha's relics, that they might build a shrine over them, make offerings, and pay reverence to them. It seemed that the kings were ready even to go to war for possession of the relics. At this point a brahmin named Dona intervened and appeased the kings, reminding them that the Buddha had preached forbearance in all matters, and proposing an equal division of the relics into eight portions. This proposal was accepted. While distributing the relics Dona secreted one--the right eyetooth--on his person, but Sakka perceived this and carried off the relic to Tavatimsa heaven, where he placed it in the Culamani shrine. Then King Ajatasattu caused a road to be made to his palace and the relics were borne in a golden receptacle before a great assembly of people and gods for seven days until the city of Rajagaha was reached. And the other kings similarly bore home the relics with honor and built pagodas enshrining the sacred relics of the Buddha in their kingdoms. Now Kassapa took steps to ensure the relics would endure and predicted that in times to come a great emperor named Asoka would find the relics and cause them and the Buddha's teaching to spread from the Buddha's homeland to many other lands. And so indeed in the fullness of time it came to pass. 74 APPENDIX The following notes are designed to help readers examine more closely the episodes from the Buddha's life as related and depicted in this book. They include comments on both the Buddhist context and the paintings. Artistic features are described first, followed in some cases by an explanation of terms. The English text of the main picture sequence is based on the Burmese text of the Burney manuscripts, supplemented by reference to the full version of the Mala lingara wuthtu. Each double opening of the original Burmese manuscripts reproduced in this book is, for the purpose of identification here, divided into three or four "sides" representing the folds of the original concertina-format manuscript (each fold can be seen faintly as a vertical line on the printed page). In the notes that follow, these sides are referred to, from left to right, as a, b, c, and (if applicable) d. The folio numbers of the manuscripts are given first, followed by the page numbers on which the images appear. b. Exercising his yogic powers, the hermit Sumedha hovers in the air and witnesses the preparations for the feast. b�c, center. Men and women clearing and preparing the road for Dipankara. The workmen are painted with slightly coarse faces and hair. They work bare-chested, with their lower garment looped up between their legs; a foreman, seated (c, foreground), directs operations. The city gateway has a plain three-tiered roof. c�d, upper. Dipankara, followed by yellow-robed monks, each carrying an alms bowl, enters through a two-tiered gateway and, hand uplifted, proclaims that Sumedha (prostrated at his feet) will one day also become a Buddha. Kneeling at Sumedha's left and holding lotus flowers is the girl who will, in Sumedha's final existence, become his wife, Yasodhara. The historical Buddha, Gotama, is believed by Buddhists to have been preceded by many other Buddhas over incalculable eons. The world, in Buddhist thought, exists over an infinite number of immense time spans or world cycles (in Pali kappa, Sanskrit kalpa), each of which in turn has other time divisions and during which successive Buddhas have manifested. In the present era (bhaddakappa) four Buddhas, of whom Gotama is the last, have appeared, and there remains one yet to come: Metteyya, the future Buddha (in Sanskrit Maitreya). Of the previous Buddhas, the names of twenty-seven besides Gotama are known, and Dipankara was the first of the twenty-four who immediately preceded Gotama. It was in Dipankara's lifetime that the hermit Sumedha received the first prophetic intimation that he himself would become a Buddha (i.e., Gotama). Or. 14297 F O L I O S 2 � 3 ( P. 1 7 ) THE BODHISATTA AS SUMEDHA a. The king, seated in his palace under a tiered roof spire (in Burmese pyathat), orders a feast to be prepared in honor of Dipankara Buddha. On either side of the king are two white umbrellas on stands. These form part of the Burmese royal regalia--only the Buddha and royalty are entitled to a white umbrella. The king wears his ceremonial robes (those of the god Sakka), appropriate for an encounter with a Buddha. The ministers, kneeling before him, wear the long draped velvet robes and tall hats of high-ranking Burmese officials. 76 The Bodhisatta (Buddha-to-be) over an immense period of many previous existences had to perfect himself to become a Buddha, acquiring the Ten Perfections (Pali, dasa parami) or principal virtues: the perfect exercise of generosity (dana), morality (sila), renunciation (nekkhama), wisdom (panna), diligence (viriya), patience (khanti), truth (sacca), resolution (adhitthana), loving-kindness (metta), and equanimity (upekkha). Each of these is subdivided into the ordinary, the inferior, and the unlimited perfection of the virtue, making thirty in all. Each virtue is achieved by a Bodhisatta in all three degrees. The Five Great Charities or Renunciations (panca mahapariccaga) are the sacrifice of the most valuable of treasures: kingdom/possessions, children, wife, any limb or feature, and body and life (a variant listing is children, wife, goods, life, oneself). The Three Good Works (cariya) consist of perfect conduct to all sentient beings, to one's family and friends, and to oneself with the object of becoming a Buddha. F O L I O S 4 � 5 ( P. 1 9 ) hare (left) and a peacock (right). These represent the ancient lunar and solar lineages to which Burmese kings laid claim, seeking to associate themselves with the Buddha's Sakya lineage. These symbols also appeared on the thrones of the Burmese kings. According to Buddhist cosmography, the mansions/chariots of the sun and moon are situated halfway up the cosmic axis, Mount Meru. Below the throne in tiers are depicted, rather roughly, five ranks of supernatural creatures who are attendants of the four guardian gods and protect Mount Meru. c�d. The four great guardian gods, holding two-edged swords, guard Queen Mahamaya after she has conceived the Buddha-to-be. This kind of sword (in Burmese than-lyet) is also an emblem of Burmese royalty. The king is shown seated beyond her, and above him rise the tiered, gilded spires that mark the center of the palace and symbolize the center of the universe, replicating the heavenly mansions of the gods. In Buddhist art the conception is usually represented as a white elephant who comes to the queen in a dream and enters her side, but the artist has chosen not to depict this. The Jataka (birth-tales), or stories of the Buddha's previous existences, are full of examples of the Buddha's exercise of the Ten Perfections and other moral virtues. The Pali Buddhist canon and the later commentary (Jatakatthakatha) contain 547 such stories (referred to by the Burmese as 550), of which the last 10, or great Jataka, are the most popular. The Vessantara Jataka is the very last Jataka and tells of the Buddha's existence as Prince Vessantara, who was banished to the forest for giving away the kingdom's sacred white elephant. While living there as a hermit, Vessantara was visited by an old brahmin called Jujaka, who came, at the urg- THE LAST REBIRTHS a�b. Scenes from the Vessantara Jataka. The upper scene (a) shows Prince Vessantara in hermit robes and hat seated in his forest abode with, behind him, his two children. He pours water over the hands of the white-robed brahmin Jujaka to seal the gift of his children to Jujaka. The lower scene depicts Vessantara's wife kept at bay in the forest by wild beasts (a tiger, a leopard, and a Burmese chin-the, or griffin-lion), so that she will not witness Vessantara giving away her children, and Jujaka (extreme left) leading them off. b. Reborn in Tusita heaven as Setaketu, the Bodhisatta is shown flanked by gods and seated on his throne with, above, in circles, a 77 ing of his nagging young wife, to ask for his children as servants. To prevent Vessantara's wife, Maddi, from seeing the children given away, the gods in the form of wild beasts detained her in the forest. Later Vessantara also gave away Maddi, to the god Sakka in disguise. After many travails, all were reunited. The Vessantara Jataka is a favorite subject for illustration in Burmese art. Tusita heaven is the fourth of the six lower heavenly worlds of the gods (in Pali deva, meaning "radiant beings" but often simply called nat in the Burney text), and it is where the Bodhisatta awaits his last rebirth. There the gods of the ten thousand worlds assemble to request the Bodhisatta to be born among men. Burmese Buddhist cosmology is complex and, although derived from ancient Indian cosmology, differs in various respects and regards the gods as subject to rebirth and serving the Buddha. Gotama Buddha did not expound any cosmological theories, and the essence of his teaching is unaffected by such matters. The universe is divided into three spheres (dhatu)--also known as planes (bhumi) or worlds (loka). These are the world of desire, or the sensual sphere (kamaloka or kamadhatu); the world of form (rupaloka); and the world of formlessness (arupaloka). The lowest is the sensual world of desire, which ranges from layers of hells through the realms of animals, ghosts (peta) and demons (asurakaya--often also classed as fallen gods called asura, who, according to Burmese cosmology, live in three great ruby carbuncular rocks beneath the cosmic mountain), and human beings on to the heavens of the gods (devas) at the highest point of the sensual world. Halfway up the cosmic mountain Mount Meru (in Pali Sumeru or Sineru, in Burmese Myin-mo) is the lowest of the deva worlds, called Catummaharajika, the abode of the four guardian gods or regent kings (in Pali Cattaro Maharajano, in Burmese Satumaharit Nat Min-gyi), who guard the four quarters of the world and are sometimes also referred to as lokapala. They protect future Buddhas from the moment of their conception, as in the scene depicted. The guardian gods have retinues of celestial musicians (gandhabba); monsters (kumbhanda); various spirits (yakkha) including ogres, or balu in Burmese; serpents (naga); and great mythical birds, usually known by their Sanskrit name, garuda (Pali garula, Burmese galon; also sometimes supanna). These are depicted on the pillar supporting the throne in Tusita heaven. The four guardian gods report to the god Sakka (known as Thagya-min in Burmese; the Vedic god Indra), who reigns over Tavatimsa, heaven of the thirty-three gods, at the top of Mount Meru. Sakka is the guardian of moral law in the world and plays an important part in Buddhist cosmology, aiding the Bodhisatta in many of his existences. Above this comes Yama heaven, the abode of a class of deva called Yama, then Tusita heaven, and then Nimmanarati and Paranimmita-vasavatti, the two highest heavens of the sense-desire world. After this comes the world of form divided into many levels of heavens where live a higher order of gods called Brahma, and above that the world of formlessness. Surrounding Mount Meru are seven rings of mountains with seven seas, and beyond, in the great ocean plane bounded by the walls of the universe (cakkavala), are four great island continents of which the southern, called Jambudipa (Rose-apple island), is the abode of man. Only in Jambudipa are Buddhas born to teach the law of deliverance from the round of rebirth into any level of the three realms of formlessness, form, and sense-desire. 78 F O L I O S 6 � 7 ( P. 21 ) PRINCE SIDDHATTHA'S BIRTH AND THE BRAHMINS' PROPHECY a, upper. Queen Mahamaya stands in a curtained enclosure to give birth, her right hand holding a branch of the sala tree and her left hand draped around the shoulder of a kneeling woman who holds the queen's waist. The kneeling woman is traditionally held to be the queen's sister, Pajapati, who becomes the Bodhisatta's foster mother when the queen dies seven days after the baby's birth. b, upper. Outside the enclosure in front of a woven screen background, the baby (depicted like a small golden Buddha image) is passed from the hands of Brahmas to the guardian gods and from them to men. The Buddha-to-be is thus ministered to by three levels of beings. When taking his first seven steps, he is shown full size in white robes with a white umbrella held over him, with four gods making obeisance and two more (c, upper) coming down to do the same. a�b, lower. The procession and palanquin bearing Queen Mahamaya on her way to (and from) Lumbini grove. Two white umbrellas are held above the tiered roofs of the palanquin (litter) in the procession, which is headed by guards and the royal ministers. Burney's notes describe the palanquin as "such as is now in use by the King and Queen of Ava." c. The infant is presented by the king to the brown-robed sage Kaladevala, who is depicted twice, smiling and (behind) weeping as he realizes he will not live to see the child attain Enlightenment. The infant's placing its feet upon the head of the sage indicates its superiority, as it is a mark or respect to place one's head at the feet of one's superior. d. The white-robed brahmins make their prophecies. At the Burmese court it was customary for brahmin astrologers to examine a child's hand and predict its future. F O L I O S 8 � 9 ( P. 2 3 ) THE PLOUGHING CEREMONY AND THE PRINCE'S MARRIAGE a, upper. King Suddhodana's white elephant is especially significant, revered as representing the Buddha's conception and previous incarnation; possession of one was highly prized by Burmese and Thai monarchs. a, lower. The meditating child Bodhisatta is depicted under a tree in a low, cloth-canopied gilded seat, with his father, the king, paying reverence. b, upper. Prince Siddhattha, holding a black parabaik (folding book), faces his tutor, whose wife kneels behind, with banana trees in fruit and bud in the background. b, lower. The ploughing ceremony. The king's plough and the yoke and horns of the bullocks drawing it are gilded. c�d, upper. The prince, as befits a scion of the warrior class, displays his skills in archery, using a gilded naga-headed bow. The elephants lined up to attend the display of martial arts are, together with the king's elephant (a), depicted in a most accomplished manner. The stippling of the face, trunk, and ears of the gray elephants is characteristic of most Burmese elephant paintings. c�d, lower. The prince and his bride, wearing a high-crowned headdress, join hands in marriage. Behind them on an inner (eastern) doorpost hang green coconuts and bananas, which are offerings to 79 the spirits (nat in Burmese). Celebrations include a dancer, a dramatic performance, and a group of musicians (not seen here). The dancer is shown under a white-roofed dome supported by thin pillars. This appears to be the "umbrella room"--a structure, usually with a central supporting pillar, on the palace grounds where dramatic performances took place. The man wearing a horse's head prances in the manner of a horse; just out of view behind him is the "rider." Burney's notes regarding the royal ploughing ceremony state that "Mr. Lane once saw this ceremony at Ava, and he informs me that the king used a plough like that in the picture, and that not only the king, but all the princes and principal officers performed the ceremony of standing upon the plough for a short distance." Charles Lane was an English merchant who was on good terms with the king and court. The young Bodhisatta is said to have concentrated on the flow of breath in and out (anapana kammathanam) and to have reached straightaway the first of the five states of mind (jhana) in meditation. F O L I O S 10 � 11 ( P. 2 5 ) gilded saddle) awaiting him outside the chamber. The curtains are of unusual patterns. In front of the palace ladies is a gilded curved Burmese harp on a stand (the painter has omitted the strings). b�c, lower. The prince, out riding in his gilded carriage (depicted with a tiered roof), sees and points to the four omens: an old man, a sick man, a corpse (being pecked at by a bird), and a holy man or monk, carrying the customary circular fan. d, lower. The prince, seated in the gardens on a propitious stone slab reserved for royalty, and decked with royal ornaments sent by Sakka through the god Vissakamma in the guise of a valet, receives the news of the birth of his son. In the foreground is a royal bathing tank in which, in some manuscripts, the prince is depicted bathing before donning his ornaments. d, upper. The prince, painted against a flower-spangled red background and wearing white and gold robes, rides out of the palace through a two-tiered gateway, with the gods in attendance. In many other manuscript representations of this scene the gods are shown holding the hooves of the horse in their hands to muffle the sound, but here they are shown holding lights. The flowered background represents the fabulous flowers that filled the sky and showered down to earth at the time of the Buddha's departure, or great renunciation. Some texts refer to the prince making four outings in his carriage, encountering each sign or omen on a separate occasion. It had been predicted at Prince Siddhattha's birth that if he saw these four signs he would resolve to renounce the world. The signs are important subjects for Buddhist meditation on the suffering or kinds of misery to which all beings are liable. On learning of the THE FOUR OMENS AND THE RENUNCIATION a. The prince presents his pearl necklace to the maiden who has greeted him on his return from seeing the four signs or omens. A whole fold having been devoted to this scene, the rest of the opening is compositionally crowded, and the events are not shown in order of their occurrence. b�c, center. The prince draws back a curtain and bids a silent farewell to his wife, sleeping with her hand resting on her baby son, with the palace dancers and musicians asleep in ungainly postures in the foreground and his attendant and horse (with 80 birth of his son, the prince is said to have stated, "An impediment (rahula) has come into being; a bond has arisen," and it is for this reason that the child was named Rahula. Kisagotami's joyful words (a famous Pali verse beginning "Nibbuta nana sa mata. . . .") brought to the prince's mind, agitated by the four omens, the pleasant intelligence of Nibbana. F O L I O S 11 B � 1 3 A ( P. 2 7 ) partly visible at bottom), Channa, crying, is left to return on foot, carrying the saddle. d. Now robed as a monk and with his alms bowl slung from his shoulder, the Buddha-to-be begins his quest for Enlightenment. His robes are from this point on gilded, but his bowl (in contrast to the way it is rendered in some manuscripts) is not, matching other monks' bowls. The usual rounded cranial protrusion (usnisa) of the Buddha is depicted with a slight depression where his topknot of hair has been cut off. Mara (Burmese Man Nat) is the powerful Spirit of Evil or God of Death who resides in (or on the fringes of) the highest heaven (Paranimitta-vasavatti) of the sensual world and seeks dominion over all the lower parts of the universe. He opposes anyone aspiring to attain the state of Enlightenment, and his challenges and temptations to the Buddha symbolize the struggle between good and evil. F O L I O S 1 3 B � 1 5 A ( P. 2 9 ) THE PRINCE'S TONSURE AND ENROBING a, upper. Mara, holding up one hand and with a sword in the other, stands barring the prince's way. In other manuscripts Mara is depicted with a dark green or blue skin and looks malevolent. b, upper. The prince, depicted now in gilded robes, leaps the river Anoma on his horse. The water is, in typical Burmese style, depicted as overlapping hoops of waves from which peep fish and other creatures. c, upper. The prince, seated, cuts off his long hair, which is caught in the air by Sakka, while (foreground) the eight requisites of a monk are presented to him by a god holding a gilded casket and another offering the round alms bowl. The gilded flowers topping the casket resemble the mythical padesa tree (Burmese padetha bin), which is unique to the northern island and produces whatever an applicant desires. But they must represent the lotus flowers that, according to tradition, sprang up at the center of Jambudipa and correspond to the number of Buddhas that will appear in that world cycle; within each lotus flower is said to be a complete set of monk's requisites (attha parikkhara), which are taken and looked after by the Brahmas until needed. b�c, lower. Prince Siddhattha's attendant, Channa, and horse are instructed to return to the palace. When the horse dies of grief (b, KING BIMBISARA MEETS THE BODHISATTA a. The Bodhisatta enters the city of Rajagaha and (lower) receives alms in his bowl. b. King Bimbisara, seated in his palace and holding the royal yaktail fan-whisk, is told of the Bodhisatta's arrival. c�d, lower. King Bimbisara, now wearing royal white robes (the costume of the god Sakka), rides forth from his palace. Behind him are four ministers bearing white umbrellas and royal regalia betel boxes. c�d, upper. Against the background of a rock cave, the Bodhisatta partakes of his meal as Bimbisara, king of Magadha, pays reverence. 81 F O L I O S 1 5 B � 1 6 ( P. 31 ) AUSTERITIES AND SUJATA'S OFFERING a, lower. The Bodhisatta with his first teachers, Alara and Uddaka. a, upper. The Bodhisatta, weakened by prolonged fasting, lies on his right side with (foreground) his five companions in attendance. He is not shown as an emaciated figure, the latter being a representation more common in Indian Buddhist art than in Burmese art. b, upper. The house and family of Sujata. Her father is smoking a long-stemmed pipe. The wooden house, raised on stilts and with a balcony, is typical of a Burmese house of some substance. b, lower. Sujata prepares her offering in a large cooking pot over a fire, tended by the gods. c. Sujata and her maid on their way to make the offering in a golden bowl (lower) and the Bodhisatta receiving the offering (upper). The Bodhisatta practiced austerities (dukkha-cariya) for six years and found it was like a time of trying to tie knots in the air. From Alara he learned how to attain the advanced state of concentration known as the realm of nothingness (akincannayatana) and from Uddaka the state known as the realm of neither perception nor nonperception (neva sanna nasannyatana), but realizing that the highest truth must be found within oneself, he ceased to seek other teachers. His five companions (pancavaggiya) were Kondanna, the young brahmin soothsayer who had foretold that he would become a Buddha, and four sons of the other court brahmins who had retired to the forest in anticipation of his Enlightenment. The offering prepared by Sujata was made, the texts explain, from special, extremely concentrated milk obtained by giving the milk of 1,000 cows to 500 cows, then their milk to 250, and so on, until reduced down to the milk of 8 cows. F O L I O S 1 7 � 1 8 ( P. 3 3 ) THE NAGA KING AND SOTTHIYA a�b. After eating Sujata's offering and casting the golden bowl into the river, the Bodhisatta pauses in the sala forest. The naga king is shown in his palace with the bowls of the three previous Buddhas of this era stacked beside him. In the water frolic winged elephants and horses. c. The grass cutter presents the Bodhisatta with handfuls of grass (lower), which turn into a throne (upper). d. Seated cross-legged on the throne, the Bodhisatta begins his meditation. Among the attendant gods present are Brahma, holding the white umbrella; Sakka, holding his conch-shell (vijayuttara -sankha), which is blown at the moment of Enlightenment; Pancasikha, who plays the harp (and in Buddhist cosmology carries reports from the four guardian gods to Sakka's charioteer, Matali); and Santusita, king of Tusita heaven, holding a fanwhisk. Mahakala, the naga king (also called Kalanaga), resides in the world under the river Neranjara and--his life span being one kappa, or world cycle--has seen all four Buddhas of this era. F O L I O S 1 9 � 2 0 A ( P. 3 5 ) MARA'S ATTACK AND THE ENLIGHTENMENT a�c. This dramatic scene, painted against a rich red backdrop, depicts the assault of Mara's army on the Buddha as he meditates. 82 Mara, atop a gilded elephant's howdah, is shown first (left) with a yellowish-green face like a demon's and with ten arms, wielding nine weapons. The faces of Mara's warriors are coarse and fierce; some have tattooed thighs. b. Beneath the Buddha on his throne at the foot of the Bodhi tree is the figure of the earth goddess, who bears witness to the Buddha's previous good deeds by wringing out her long hair, so releasing the water absorbed into the earth when water is ceremonially poured when making gifts and acts of merit. c. The water sweeps away Mara's warriors, who are shown in flight and disarray, with their pennants and lances broken. Some are being devoured by the animals that had been their mounts; two figures (one, green faced, on an elephant's back, is presumably Mara, although not matching the first figure of Mara) look back and join hands in reverence to the Buddha. The flowers scattered against the red background represent the army's weapons, which when deployed fell harmlessly to the earth as flowers. The early Pali texts do not mention the earth goddess (in Burmese Wathondaye), and the story of her appearance at this time is a popular Southeast Asian interpolation, found in the Pathamasambodhi text. Burmese renditions of this scene may reflect Thai artistic influence, although in Thai versions the earth goddess is depicted standing and the army advances from the other side. In Indian and Sinhalese depictions of this temptation scene, the earth goddess sometimes carries a vase as she emerges from the earth in response to his call, but the washing away of Mara's army in the water released from her hair is not known or depicted. Gotama's victory over Mara is considered one of his "eight great victories," and Burney comments in his notes, "Brahmins apply these eight victories to the Kings of Ava on days of ceremony when they recite prayers at the foot of the throne." Among the other victories are the Buddha's taming of the mad Nalagiri elephant and his conversion of the thief Angulimala and the monster Alavaka. The stages of meditation by which the Buddha gained insight into perfect knowledge and attained Enlightenment are complex and outside the scope of this book. Among his attainments were knowledge of his and others' former states of existence (pubbenivasanussati-nana), which is one of the faculties of an arahat; superhuman vision (dibba-cakkhu); possession of the ten strengths (dasa bala), which are of two kinds: power of the mind and power of the body; and realization of the Four Noble Truths and of the law of dependent origination (paticca-samuppada). The place where he attained Enlightenment is now called Buddha Gaya (Bodh Gaya). F O L I O S 21 � 2 2 ( P. 3 7 ) THE SEVEN STATIONS: WEEKS 1�4 a. The first week, seated in meditation on the throne. b. The second week. The Buddha, with a flaming nimbus and his feet circled by lotuses, contemplates the seat of his Enlightenment. The base of the throne has changed in appearance. c. The third week, with the Buddha shown in a railed gilded enclosure (his walkway). d. The fourth week, with the Buddha seated in a gilded house. This whole opening is richly gilded, with a spacious and quite largescale composition, each scene divided by flowering branches and 83 trees and linked by a foreground filled with smiling bullocks, frolicking rabbits, and happy goats. F O L I O S 2 3 � 2 4 ( P. 3 9 ) THE SEVEN STATIONS: WEEKS 5�7 a. The fifth week, when the Buddha, seated on his throne in the earth-touching gesture, is visited by a bearded, white-robed brahmin and by the three daughters of Mara as young women (right) and as bent old women (below). b. The Buddha sheltered by the great Mucalinda naga during the sixth week. The white-robed figure is either Mara or (more in accord with the full Mala lingara text) the naga, now transformed into a young man who pays homage to the Buddha. c�d. At the end of the seventh week, the Buddha is presented with gifts by Sakka (right), uncharacteristically shown in colored robes, while the four guardian gods (left) present four bowls, which become a single bowl with four gilded rims. The two merchant brothers kneel with their solid-wheeled, covered bullock carts in the foreground while the bullocks rest under trees. The compass directions of each of the seven sites or stations (sattatthana) of the Buddha in relation to the Bodhi tree have been the subject of scholarly debate, given that texts and artistic representations are not consistent. The shortened Burney text under these scenes mentions a direction only for the seventh week, but the full Mala lingara text gives more details. The Buddha's throne changes in appearance from scene to scene in the Burney parabaik sequence. Mara's daughters bore the names Tanha (desire), Arati (aversion), and Raga (lust). In some versions, Mara petitions the Buddha to restore his daughters to their former youth and beauty--the same accounts having inappropriately asserted that the Buddha had changed them into an undesirable form. Some Burmese texts omit Sakka's gift of a tooth-stick, and the source of the water (Anotatta lake); the myrobalan fruit has medicinal, cleansing properties. The merchant brothers are said in the Burney text to have come from Ramanna(-desa), which means Lower Burma, and although the Burney text does not mention the Buddha's gift to them of some hairs from his head, the full Mala lingara text does, on the basis of old Mon and early Burmese foundation legends in which the sacred hair relics were brought to Burma by the merchant brothers and enshrined there. F O L I O S 2 5 � 2 6 ( P. 41 ) THE FIRST SERMON a. At the foot of the Ajapala tree (to which he had returned), the gods petition the Buddha to preach to mankind. b. The Buddha (upper) encounters Upaka and (lower) his five former companions. c�d. Seated on a rounded lotus throne, with a large nimbus of streaming light, the Buddha delivers his first sermon in the deer park (with three deer in the foreground) to the five ascetics (left) and gods (right). The Buddha is not represented in the preaching gesture. d. Yasa, the first lay convert, is shown (upper) in a scene that echoes Prince Siddhattha's disgust at the worldly pleasures of palace life. The Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta contains the essence of the Buddha's message of the path to salvation. The five wandering ascetics, on hearing it, become "stream entrants" (Pali sotapanna), 84 or "established in the fruit of the stream-entrant stage" and on the path to arahatship and Nibbana. This reception of the Buddha's teaching sets a key pattern whereby those who hear his preaching are said to "enter the stream," at various stages according to their individual understanding and attainments. The stages, and resultant levels of rebirth, are stream-entrant (sotapanna)--sometimes translated as "convert"--who will not be reborn in hell or as an animal or a ghost; once-returner (sakadagami), who will have only one more human rebirth; nonreturner (anagami), who will be reborn in a higher world and attain Nibbana there; and perfected or worthy being (arahat), one in whom the five aggregates or elements of being (khanda) have been eliminated, that is, who has attained Nibbana in this life and will never be reborn in any form. The Buddha's first disciples became arahats (Burmese yahanda) at the conclusion of the Buddha's sermon on the characteristics of nonself (Anattalakkhana sutta), preached five days after his first sermon. Upaka, encountered by the Buddha on his way to the deer park, represents an individual who was not at first willing to listen to the Buddha (although later he did enter the right path). The place where the Buddha preached his first sermon is today known as Sarnath. F O L I O S 2 7 � 2 8 ( P. 4 3 ) other followers. In the foreground stand Yasa and his four friends, all in monk's robes and carrying their alms bowls. d. The monks, who have now all attained arahatship, disperse to spread the Buddha's teaching. F O L I O S 2 9 B � 31 A ( P. 4 5 ) CONVERSION OF THE HERMIT BROTHERS a. The Buddha, his feet in a circle of lotuses, meets the elder hermit brother, who carries a curly poker stick and points to his dwelling. b�c. The hermits' residence is depicted as a solid two-story structure. The Buddha, seated in the wood-roofed and railed outside kitchen extension, pays no attention to the naga beside him. d. The naga, tamed, is displayed in the Buddha's bowl while the hermits both marvel and shrink in fear. F O L I O S 3 2 � 3 3 ( P. 4 7 ) FURTHER MIRACULOUS DISPLAYS a. Kassapa invites the Buddha to a meal. b. The Buddha holds out to Kassapa the jambu fruit. c�d. The Buddha, depicted with a large, flaming nimbus, walks on dry land while hermits struggle in the water. d, upper. Sakka holds the branch of a tree for the Buddha to hang his washed robe upon. At his feet is the flat washing stone. The Kassapa brothers were fire worshippers, and to them the Buddha delivered his famous Fire Sermon (Adittapariyaya Sutta), which states that all man's existence burns with the fires of lust, hate, and delusion. (This discourse was the source for section III of T. S. Eliot's The Waste Land.) The Indian context of fire worship and THE FIRST DISCIPLES a. Yasa kneels before the Buddha. Yasa's old father (right, foreground) has come in search of his son. b. In a curtained enclosure, Yasa's family and household pay reverence to the Buddha, to whom they have offered food. c. Kneeling before the Buddha are Yasa's family and friends and 85 sacrifice has been transmuted in the Burmese text so that the room where the Buddha spends the night is the hermits' cookhouse rather than their fire or altar chamber. The Burney manuscript devotes much space to illustrating the different ways in which the Buddha convinced the Kassapa brothers of his superior powers. Other incidents from the Burney parabaik not reproduced here are the Buddha splitting wood and making it kindle, which the hermits had not been able to do; his creation of 500 braziers of fire to warm them after bathing; and the hermits casting their utensils (curly poker sticks and axes) and vessels into the water and submitting to the Buddha. The hermits were "matted-haired," and their hair is depicted sometimes in a conical peak; their brown robes consist of two pieces of cloth and are not the same as Buddhist monks' three-piece robes (ticivara). The brothers' names were Uruvela-Kassapa, Nadi-Kassapa, and Gaya-Kassapa. The elder brother, after becoming the Buddha's disciple, is often referred to as Mahakassapa. F O L I O S 3 7 � 3 8 ( P. 4 9 ) and expressions). Conspicuously and irreverently upright are depicted (d, lower) two Westerners, with brown curly hair, wearing hats with upturned brims, buttoned shirts, heavy, wide-cuffed dress coats, striped trousers, and--another mark of disrespect-- shoes (with upturned toes), and carrying over their shoulders ramrods or tapers for the cannon. They exemplify the Burmese artists' habit of incorporating contemporary features into their paintings-- in this case foreign mercenaries (or descendants thereof), who were often employed/captured by the Burmese kings for their knowledge of guns and metal casting. Also standing, in front of the foreigners and holding the reins of a horse, is a mustachioed man with tattooed knees and shoulders; another tattooed man kneels in front of the horse. As was customary in old Burma, the tattoos (to convey invulnerability and also, in the case of soldiers, for identification) on the upper half of the body are in red, and those from just above the waist to just below the knees are in black or indigo. F O L I O S 4 0 � 41 ( P. 51 ) THE VISIT TO KING BIMBISARA'S KINGDOM a. The Buddha and monks in the palm tree grove. The leaves and palm nuts are carefully and naturalistically painted. b, upper. The yellow-robed monk hovering in the air between the clumps of palm trees is Kassapa, who, according to some texts, rose into the air seven times to demonstrate his powers and his submission to the Buddha's far superior powers and teaching. b�d. King Bimbisara (lower left), in white and gold robes, kneels at the head of his procession of ministers and soldiers (carrying longbarreled guns and spears and painted with a variety of skin colors SARIPUTTA AND MOGGALLANA a�b. The Buddha seated with his disciples in the bamboo grove donated by King Bimbisara. c. Sariputta (lower) in a litter and Moggallana (upper) in a onehorse carriage; both are richly dressed, with umbrellas held aloft, in the style of royal ministers. d. The Buddha (uncharacteristically shown ungilded--an artistic oversight?) at Vesali. The stanza recited to Sariputta and Moggallana by Assaji skillfully and succinctly expresses the essentials of the Buddha's teaching of 86 the law of cause and effect. The Pali text is "Ye dhamma hetuppabhava tesam hetum tathagatho aha tesan ca yo nirodha, evam vadi mahasamano." Often referred to as the "Buddhist creed," these lines are found inscribed on many votive plaques and images. After the conversion of Sariputta and Moggallana, the Mala lingara narrates many incidents that are often illustrated in other Burmese life-of-theBuddha manuscripts but are omitted from the Burney manuscripts. Among these are the Buddha's visit to his native Kapilavatthu and the conversion of his father, King Suddhodana, and other family members, and the entry into the monkhood of the Buddha's half brother, Nanda, and of his own young son, Rahula. Their ordination left King Suddhodana without an heir, and, seeking to spare other parents similar distress, he requested that in the future no child be ordained without parental consent. Also said to have been ordained at this time was the Buddha's cousin Ananda, who became his constant companion and, during the Buddha's twentieth rainy season, was appointed his chief attendant. It was Ananda who persuaded the Buddha to establish an order of nuns and allow Queen Pajapati, after the death of King Suddhodana, to become a nun. Also omitted from the Burney manuscripts is the story of Jivaka the physician and a long sequence about how the Buddha forbade his disciples to display their powers and announced that he would instead display his own great powers at Savatthi at the foot of a mango tree. It was after this that the Buddha ascended into the sky and performed the "twin miracle" (yamaka patihariya) of fire and water--a phenomenon whereby fire and water streamed from the Buddha's body--and then, in three strides, reached Tavatimsa. The twin miracle, which defies successful artistic representation, is included in the Burney parabaik but is not here reproduced. F O L I O S 4 3 � 4 4 ( P. 5 3 ) THE DESCENT FROM TAVATIMSA HEAVEN a�b. The Buddha, painted with gilded body and reddish-orange robes, stands (left) on Yugandhara (represented conventionally in Burmese manuscripts as a pillar) and reaches (right) Tavatimsa. There he is shown seated on Sakka's stone throne (Pandukambalasilasana) under the parijata tree. The golden stupa is the Culamani shrine, where Sakka placed the Bodhisatta's topknot. Below the Buddha, on either side of the cosmic axis on which are depicted its guardian creatures, are the lunar and solar symbols. c�d. The Buddha, now painted for the first time entirely gilded, descends the triple stairway with the gods in attendance. In some manuscripts the three silver, gold, and jeweled parts of the stairway are more clearly indicated, and sometimes Sariputta is shown kneeling at the foot of the stairway to welcome him back to the earth. The Buddha was away in Tavatimsa for three months, and during this period his followers became anxious to know where he was and when he would return. So Moggallana is said to have ascended into the Buddha's presence to inquire where he would reappear on earth. The Buddha chose the city of Sankassa, where, in the Buddha's absence, Sariputta was preaching and answering people's questions on points of the Buddha's teachings. The occasion of the Buddha's descent is celebrated in Burma with a festival of lights on the full moon day of the month of Thadingyut (September/October) and marks the end of the Buddhist rainy season retreat. 87 F O L I O S 4 6 � 4 7 ( P. 5 5 ) THE RAINY SEASONS a. The Buddha's ninth rainy season at Kosambi. Among the kneeling monks are some still with the conical hairstyle of hermits. These may represent the 500 hermits who were fed each year by three rich men who became the Buddha's disciples and who each built a monastery for his use. b. The tenth rainy season in Parileyya forest, where the Buddha went for solitude after discord at Kosambi among his followers. Along with the elephant who looked after the Buddha, a monkey is shown offering the Buddha a honeycomb. The monkey is not mentioned in the Burney or the full Mala lingara text but appears in, for example, the Dhammapada commentary. The monkey and elephant are often depicted together in manuscript and other Burmese representations of this scene. c�d. The eleventh and twelfth rainy seasons, which the Buddha spent at a brahmin village and in a famine-stricken area where the generosity of some merchants ensured that the Buddha received food. White-robed and -hatted brahmins are shown revering the Buddha and his monks, in front of whom are offerings of food. The rainy season (Pali vassa, Burmese wa) is a period of retreat for Buddhist monks, who stay at their home monasteries and concentrate on study and meditation. The depiction of the Buddha's rainy seasons in most Burmese life-of-the-Buddha manuscripts is quite monotonous, with the Buddha shown on successive openings seated in simple monastic structures. Omitted from this book are some further rainy seasons depicted in the Burney manuscripts, which include the Buddha's conversion of a child-eating monster in Alavi and that of the murderer and robber Angulimala. Many well-loved sermons and much rich imagery arise from the Buddha's years of ministry and retreats, when he preached to and converted people from all walks of life. The eleventh rainy season was spent in a village of brahmin farmers who at first criticized the Buddha as idle and refused him alms. The Buddha responded by stating that he too was a laborer, but one who ploughed and sowed to grow the fruit of salvation. Faith in the dhamma was, he explained, the seed he planted in men's hearts, austerity was the rain, wisdom the yoke, and mindfulness the ploughshare; truth was the hoe and effort was the ox that drew one to the deliverance from suffering that is Nibbana. Or. 14298 F O L I O S 3 � 4 ( P. 5 7 ) SARIPUTTA'S DEATH a. Sariputta's hand and lower body are in view as he lies on a bed with a red and white flowered covering and is visited by the gods. b�c. Sariputta's elaborate funeral pyre, decorated with the karavika bird (Burmese karaweik) at the base of the catafalque and with prancing naga-dragons (to-naya) on a side panel. On the left rise the tiered roof spires and shrines erected in his honor by his mother and by Vissakamma, architect of the gods. His weeping mother kneels outside the enclosure while a crowd presses forward, trampling on Revati, who had come to offer three golden flowers. d. Sariputta's relics are collected (foreground). Revati (upper) in a gilded heavenly pavilion descends in homage from Tavatimsa. 88 The Buddhist texts contain very little information about the Buddha's life from the twenty-first to the forty-fourth rainy seasons (i.e., from the ages of fifty-six to seventy-nine), but to this period belongs the scheming of Devadatta against the Buddha. Among his attempts to kill the Buddha was his unleashing upon him of a fierce elephant, Nalagiri. The period leading up to the Buddha's forty-fifth rainy season and the last ten months of his life are more closely chronicled. The Burney manuscripts omit many incidents from this period, and Or. 14298 opens with Sariputta's decision to return to his birthplace and to preach to his mother before his death. The northern Buddhist texts give the name of Sariputta's village as Nalanda (which became a famous center of Buddhist learning, with a great complex of temples and monasteries). When Sariputta's relics were brought to him, the Buddha exhibited them to the monks as a powerful image of the truth that all is impermanent and subject to change. The Buddha delivered a long eulogy on Sariputta's qualities and directed that a stupa (Pali thupa, Burmese zedi) be erected to honor Sariputta's memory and perpetuate the remembrance of his virtues. On hearing the Buddha's words in honor of Sariputta, Ananda was moved to tears, but the Buddha gently pointed out the futility of such grief. The Buddha's emphasis on impermanence should not be mistaken for pessimism but understood as representing realism. His teachings offer followers joy and calm, and release from suffering. FOLIOS 6�7 (P. 59) brief mention in the text, but the artist has delighted in a lavish, brightly colored portrayal of the coffins and catafalques. It was the custom in Burma for monks to have particularly elaborate funerals. The winged figures, half-human, half-bird (kinnara and in the female form kinnari--celestial creatures inhabiting the fabulous Himavanta, or Himalayas) that support Kondanna's coffin often decorated the coffins of Burmese monks. The kinnara (Burmese kein-naya) are said to have danced with joy at the Buddha's Enlightenment, and they and other celestial creatures often feature as decorative motifs at monks' funerals. As befits such important disciples of the Buddha, the artist has provided them with most colorful and grand obsequies. Moggallana's violent death--he was beaten to death by robbers--was explained by the Buddha as the result of past bad deeds when in a previous existence he conspired to kill his parents. Rahula obtained Parinibbana after being reborn in Tavatimsa; Kondanna spent his last twelve years in Himavanta, in the land of the mighty Chaddanta tribe of elephants. FOLIOS 9�10 (P. 61) THE FINAL CHALLENGE BY MARA b. The Buddha is visited by Mara (in white and gold robes). The large background flaming aureole of the Buddha is unusual. c�d. Ananda (upper) petitions the Buddha to use his powers, and the Buddha (lower) preaches on the continuance of his dispensations. This episode was Mara's last attempt to thwart the Buddha. The four bases of psychic powers (iddhipada) are concentration of will (chanda), of energy (viriya), of consciousness (citta), and of investigation (vimamsa), which enable one to reach the right path lead- DEATH OF MOGGALLANA AND OTHERS a�d. The three funeral pyres depicted are, from left to right, Moggallana's, Rahula's, and Kondanna's. Their deaths merit only a 89 ing to the extinction of suffering. The Buddha cautioned against the improper use of such powers. On his final journey, he instructed his disciples to pay great attention to thirty-seven points of his teaching (bodhi pakkhiya dhamma) constituting true knowledge, divided into seven classes: the four subjects most deserving of attention (cattaro satipatthana); the four objects worthy of effort (cattaro sammappadhana); the four bases of psychic powers (cattaro iddhipada); the five necessary dispositions (pancindriya); the five resulting forces (panca bala); the seven requisites of Enlightenment (satta bojjhanga); and the Noble Eightfold Path (ariya atthangika magga). F O L I O S 1 2 � 1 3 ( P. 6 3 ) F O L I O S 1 4 � 1 5 ( P. 6 5 ) THE LAST JOURNEY a�b. A team of oxcarts (right) links this scene with the next. Ananda (b, foreground) fills the Buddha's bowl with water from the stream (painted here without the stylized hoops of the other Burney manuscript) and (upper left) presents it to the Buddha. c�d. The Malla prince (upper right) presents two robes to the Buddha, and Ananda (d, lower) in turn presents his to the Buddha. Prince Pukkusa had been a disciple of the sage Alara and told how once when Alara was resting 500 oxcarts had passed him by without his noticing. To this the Buddha responded by telling Pukkusa of how he had demonstrated even greater calmness of mind during a particularly violent storm. Pukkusa thereupon took refuge in the three jewels and became a devoted lay supporter of the Buddha. When Pukkusa presented two robes of golden cloth to the Buddha, the Buddha instructed him to offer one to Ananda, both as a mark of favor to Ananda for his twenty-five years of stewardship and so that Pukkusa would accrue even greater merit by making a gift both to the Buddha and to the order of monks in the person of Ananda. F O L I O S 1 6 � 1 7 ( P. 6 7 ) THE LAST MEAL a. The Buddha preaches on the four great authorities. b. The Buddha, seated in a mango grove, is invited by Cunda to a meal. c�d. The Buddha, seated with his monks on the monastery veranda within a curtained enclosure, is served his last meal. The redlacquered covered containers are decorated with gilded flowers. The four great authorities (mahapadesa), or points of citation and reference, are the means by which the words of the Buddha are tested, his actual doctrine determined and clarified. There is some uncertainty over what the last meal consisted of, although the Burmese texts always refer to it as a pork dish. The Pali term is sukaramaddava, which has been variously interpreted as sweetened pork, a kind of mushroom, or some specially flavored dish. THE BUDDHA RESTS a�b. The Buddha bathes (upper left) and then rests on his right side in a curtained enclosure. Standing to the left of the tree and folding a robe for the Buddha to lie on is the monk Cunda. c�d. The musicians and dancers (foreground) under a domed structure link this scene to the next, which depicts the Buddha's death and obsequies. The instruments are much as depicted in an 90 earlier scene of a Burmese orchestra, but with the addition of bamboo clappers (wa let-hkot). The figure of the Buddha with four kneeling monks probably represents his preaching along the way to Kusinara, or his last admonitions to the monks. The monk Cunda, who was with the Buddha on his last journey, was a disciple of some eminence and is not to be confused with the Cunda who gave the Buddha his last meal. Some texts maintain that he was Sariputta's younger brother. The Burney manuscripts omit the story of the Buddha's last convert, Subhadda, who came to see the Buddha on his last night. Although Ananda did not wish to admit Subhadda to the Buddha's presence, the Buddha insisted on seeing him, and he was received into the monkhood. F O L I O S 1 8 � 1 9 ( P. 6 9 ) queried the Buddha's choice of insignificant Kusinara to die in, and it is said that the Buddha made the effort to reach Kusinara for several reasons: in order to preach on its former glory (the Mahasudassana Sutta), to be able to convert Subhadda, and so that the brahmin Dona could distribute his relics. The Buddha's last words were reported to be "Vayadhamma samkhara, appamadena sampadetha"--sometimes (mis)rendered as "Work out your salvation with diligence." F O L I O S 2 0 � 21 ( P. 71 ) THE CREMATION a�b. Kassapa (foreground) kneels before the Buddha's coffin, from which protrude his gilded feet. Celestial half-human, half-bird figures support the corners of the catafalque. c�d. The Malla princes pour water from golden urns while water springs in a cascade from the sala trees. The scornful remarks of the monk Subhadda (not the same as the Buddha's last convert), a former barber who bore the Buddha a grudge, inspired Kassapa to hold a general council of monks to ascertain correctly the Buddha's teachings. This was held at Rajagaha soon after the Buddha's death. The second council was held a century later at Vesali, and the third at Pataliputta (Patna) in the third century BC under the patronage of the emperor Asoka. The number of Buddhist councils (and their locations) accepted as authentic varies from country to country, with Thailand acknowledging as many as ten but Sri Lanka and Burma only six. The fourth council (at which the texts were committed to writing) was held in the last century BC in Sri Lanka; the fifth, according to Burmese tradition, at Mandalay in 1871 (but according to Sinhalese tradition in THE BUDDHA ATTAINS PARINIBBANA a�b. The Buddha lies on a couch (under a canopy) on his right side, with his head to the north and his feet one upon the other. In front of him are Ananda and another grieving monk (Cunda?) and gods, brahmins, and lay men and women. The lady (b, center) in royal white and gold robes and headdress must represent one of the Malla queens; the texts state that in the first watch of the night the Malla royalty came to pay their respects. c�d. The funeral procession, with white and gilded umbrellas held above the bier. Mallika kneels (c, foreground) after presenting a golden shroud. Uncharacteristically, some lines of explanatory Burmese text are written above this scene. Between Pava and the sala grove at Kusinara the Buddha, in his weakened state, had to make twenty-five stops to rest. Ananda 91 1865 at Ratanapura in Sri Lanka); the sixth, at Rangoon in 1954�1956. F O L I O S 2 2 � 2 3 ( P. 7 3 ) OBSEQUIES a�c. The Buddha's relics, in a golden urn, are carried in procession on elephant back along a road fenced by latticework. The attendants all wear white, the color of mourning. d. The relics are guarded in a tiered pavilion. F O L I O S 2 4 � 2 5 ( P. 7 5 ) The relics were claimed by the Malla kings and princes of Kusinara and of Pava; by King Ajatasattu of Magadha; by the Licchavis of Vesali, the Sakyas of Kapilavatthu, the Bulis of Allakappa, and the Koliyas of Ramagama; and by the brahmin chief of Vethadipa. The Moriyas of Pipphalivana made a late claim and were given the embers of the funeral pyre, and Dona kept the golden vessel to enshrine. Buddhist tradition states that Kassapa safeguarded the relics by having them enshrined together in Rajagaha and that Emperor Asoka rediscovered the sacred relics and distributed them far and wide, building 84,000 stupa reliquaries. DISTRIBUTION OF THE RELICS a. The brahmin Dona, standing in front of the urn, begins the distribution of the relics. In the sky, Sakka (far left) carries off the relic that Dona had secreted (some manuscripts show Sakka plucking the relic from Dona's headdress, where he had hidden it). According to some accounts, the naga shown at Dona's feet received a tooth relic (or was entrusted with it by the Koliyas), which was enshrined in the naga world. The monk hovering in the air to the right of Sakka is Kassapa, who, after the main relics were distributed to the claimants and enshrined in separate places, became anxious and collected them together and buried them in Rajagaha to be discovered by Asoka, a future Indian ruler who would be converted to Buddhism. b�d. The white-robed, gold-crowned kings, together with royal attendants, are shown kneeling in line (foreground) to receive the relics and (above) bearing them away, white umbrellas now unfurled, for enshrinement in their kingdoms. 92 G L O S S A RY The main Pali names in the text accompanying the images are shown here with diacritics, followed in parentheses by the Burmese form of pronunciation where this differs substantially. Ajap� ala-nigrodha. Goatherds' banyan tree Aj� atasattu. Successor to and son of King Bimbis� ara � l� A. ara. One of the Bodhisatta's first teachers �. Ananda. The Buddha's disciple and steward Animisa. "Unblinking"; the second station of the Buddha � Anoma. River crossed by the Bodhisatta on his departure Anotatta. One of seven great lakes in Buddhist cosmology Anupiya. Township and mango grove Aparajita. "Unconquered" throne of the Buddha Asoka. Great Buddhist ruler, c. 269�231 BC � Assaji. The fifth of the Pa�cavaggiya monks Bhallika. Younger merchant brother Bh� aradv� A brahmin farming clan aja. Bimbis� (Beimbathaya). King of Magadha ara Bodhisatta (Bawdithat). A Buddha-to-be (in Burmese Hpaya-laung) Brahm� (Byamma). A class of higher gods a � � Cap ala-cetiya. A shrine near Ves� ali Channa (Hsanna). Gotama's attendant/charioteer C� .� ni (Sulamani). Shrine in T� ulama. avati msa heaven . Cunda (Sonda). (1) A monk; (2) a goldsmith's son Dakkhinag� District south of R� ajagaha . iri. Devadaha. Township of the Sakyans . D� nkara. One of the Buddhas who preceded Gotama ipa Dona. Brahmin who divided the Buddha's relics . Ekan� A brahmin village ala. Ghat� � ik ara. One of the great Brahmas Ghosit� � ar ama. A monastery Girimekhal� Mara's war elephant a. Gotama. Personal name of the Buddha Hira��avat� River near which the Buddha died i. . Huhunkaj� atika. A brahmin, named onomatopoeically for his hemming and hawing Isipatana. Place where the Buddha preached his first sermon 93 Jambud� (Zabu-deik-kyun or Zabu-dipa). In Buddhist cosmolipa ogy, Rose-apple island, the abode of man Jetavana (Zetawun). Monastery and park in S� avatthi Jetuttara. Capital city of King Sa�jaya J� ujaka (Zuzaka). Brahmin to whom Prince Vessantara gave his children Kakut th� River in which the Buddha bathed on his last journey . . a. � la. See Mah� �la K a. aka. �ladevala. A brahmin sage; also known as Asita Ka. Kanthaka. Prince Siddattha's horse Kapilavatthu (Kapilawut). Capital of the Sakyas, the Buddha's clan a-Kassapa Kassapa. See Uruvel� agotami. A maiden/princess of Kapilavatthu Kis� Kolita. Moggall� ana's former name Konda��a (Kundinya). Youngest of the soothsayers and one of the .. ata-Konda��a first five disciples; also known as A��� .. � (Kawthambi). City where Ghositarama monastery was Kosamb i located Kusin� ara. Village where the Buddha died i. ala Lumbin� Park (grove of s� trees) where the Buddha was born ara Magadha. Kingdom ruled by Bimbis� Mah� � . A n� (serpent) king; also known as K� . � ak ala. aga alan aga � � � The Buddha's mother (great M� � Mah am ay a. ay a) Malla (Manla). A people and their country Mallik� Woman who presented a shroud at the Buddha's funeral a. procession Mand� arava. Fabulous flower M� (Man Nat). The Evil One ara � � See Mah� � � M ay a. am ay a Meru, Mount (Myin-mo). The central cosmic mountain axis; also known as Sineru or Sumeru Moggall� (Maukgalan). One of the Buddha's chief disciples ana Mucalinda. A n� king; also the tree and lake associated with aga him N� alaka. S� ariputta's birthplace Nera�jar� A river a. Pa�cavaggiy� (Pyinsa weggi). Five ascetics who became the a Buddha's first disciples Pandava. Hill near R� ajagaha .. � Pandukambalasil asana. Great stone throne of Sakka .. P� � (or P� arij ata aricchattaka). Coral tree in T� avatimsa . � � P arileyya (or P arileyyaka). Township near Kosamb� i 94 P� � City where the Buddha received his last meal av a. Pukkusa. A Malla prince R� ahula. Son of Gotama Buddha R� ajagaha (Yazagyo). Capital of Magadha �� R aj ayatana. A tree (in Burmese lin-lun) Revat� Sariputta's former nurse i. Sahampati. A great Brahma Sakka (Thagya-min). A god, king of T� avatimsa . � (or sal). Trees (Shorea robusta; called in-gyin in Burmese) S ala associated with the Buddha's birth and death Sa�jaya. (1) Father of Prince Vessantara; (2) first teacher of S� ariputta and Moggall� ana . Sankassa. City where the Buddha descended from heaven S� ariputta (Tharipoktara). One of the Buddha's chief disciples S� avatthi. Capital of Kosala Sen� � Father of Suj� � an i. at a Setaketu. Gotama's name while in Tusita heaven Siddhattha (Theikdat min-tha). Gotama Buddha's name as a prince Sivirattha. Kingdom of King Sa�jaya .. Sotthiya. A grass cutter Subhadda. (1) A dissident monk; (2) the Buddha's last convert Suddhodana. King of Kapilavatthu and father of Gotama Buddha Suj� � (Thuzata). Woman who gave milk-rice to the Bodhisatta at a . Sumedha (Thumeda). The Bodhisatta in the time of D� nkara ipa Buddha Sumsum� aragiri. City in Bhagg� country a . Suppabuddha. The Bodhisatta's father-in-law Tapussa. Elder merchant brother T� avatimsa (Tawadeintha-bon). Heaven of the thirty-three gods . Tusita (Tuthita-bon). Heaven of the "blissful" Uddaka. One of the Bodhisatta's first teachers Ukkal� (or Ukkal� a apa). Home city of the merchant brothers Upaka. Ascetic who met the Buddha on his way to the deer park ariputta's former name Upatissa. S� Uruvel� Township of the Mallas a. � Uruvel a-Kassapa. Eldest of the three hermit brothers converted by the Buddha . Vankagiri. A mountain, place of Prince Vessantara's self-banishment 95 Ve. luvana (Weluwun). Bamboo grove donated by King Bimbis� ara � Town where the Buddha spent the twelfth rainy season Vera�j a. Ves� (Wethali). Capital city of the Licchav� ali is Vessantara (Wethandaya min-tha). The Bodhisatta's name in his penultimate human life Yasa (Yatha). A rich man's son, the Buddha's first lay convert Yasodhar� (Yathawdaya). Wife of Prince Siddhattha a Yugandhara. First mountain range surrounding the cosmic axis 96 Cover Sotthiya the Grass Cutter and the Buddha in Meditation, Or. 14297, ff. 17�18 Back cover Detail from The Ploughing Ceremony and the Prince's Marriage, Or. 14297, ff. 8�9 � 2005 The British Library Board Pomegranate Communications, Inc. Box 808022, Petaluma CA 94975 800 227 1428 www.pomegranate.com Pomegranate Europe Ltd. Unit 1, Heathcote Business Centre Hurlbutt Road Warwick, Warwickshire CV34 6TD, UK [+44] 0 1926 430111 Book design by Monroe Street Studios Santa Rosa, California Printed in China T he B riTish L iBrary