According to this article, Bob Kelly, a pitcher for an Indianapolis baseball team, was purportedly jarred by the news that his wife, Sandra, was mistakenly labeled as "another woman" in the life of Dr. Samuel H. Sheppard.
Kelly lasted only 3 innings during a game against Columbus on the day after learning of the news regarding Sandy. It was Kelly's 8th loss of the season.
Cleveland Press, "54/08/12 Pitcher Rattled by "Sandy" Story" (1954). All Articles. 180.