As of April 2009, there were over 40 different Webkinz listed as “Retired” that can still be played online. Below is an overview of the retired list of animals.
While the local stores may have a retired pet if you look hard enough, the best places to look for retired animals are online. There’s several shops that will either sell all their Webkinz for a set price, or base the price on other factors. Amazon is a great place to look because the prices vary so greatly.