Do you like the frosted cookies you get from a bakery? Then you’ll LOVE these Big Soft Sugar Cookies! Light and puffy sugar cookies are topped with a smooth layer of vanilla frosting and your favorite sprinkles. These will be your family’s new favorite cookie!
Want to see how easy it is to make these Big Soft Sugar Cookies? Check out the quick video down below!
I’m usually a chocolate cookie girl, but I always make an exception for the frosted sugar cookies from my local bakery. I’ll bet you know the type I mean: big, puffy cookies SLATHERED with a thick layer of frosting that’s slightly crunchy on top and studded with bright sprinkles. They never taste quite as good as I imagine they will, but I still give in and buy one more often than I would like to admit.
Since I’m perpetually a little disappointed in the slightly stale bakery version, and since we’re about to enter major holiday baking season, I thought it was finally time to put a SugarHero spin on these classic cookies. My family LOVED these Big Soft Sugar Cookies (in fact, my father-in-law said they were the best sugar cookies he’d ever had) and I think your family will love them too!
The secret ingredient in these cookies, which is more like a not-so-secret ingredient, is International Delight Frosted Sugar Cookie coffee creamer. You might call it cheating to use a sugar cookie-flavored ingredient to make sugar cookies…I personally call it genius! I used the Frosted Sugar Cookie flavor in both the cookie dough and the buttercream frosting that goes on top. It’s not overwhelming, but it does give the cookies an extra oomph of that vanilla-y, butter-y, can’t-put-your-finger-on-it-but-it-tastes-like-a-bakery-cookie flavor.
If you are not able to track down the Frosted Sugar Cookie variety, you can always substitute any other favorite International Delight flavor! And if you’re not able to find ANY International Delight flavors (because, ironically, I hear from my international readers that they can’t always source it) you can substitute milk or whipping cream instead in an equal amount. If you forgo the creamer, I would suggest boosting the amount of vanilla extract, and maybe consider adding a bit of almond or lemon extract as well, to compensate for the missing flavor.
Now don’t get me wrong–I love the flavor and texture of the sugar cookies, I really do. Those crispy, buttery edges? That light and fluffy center? Gimme! But we all know what’s really the best part of these cookies–THE FROSTING! So I didn’t skimp on the frosting, and smoothed on a thick layer of vanilla goodness (with a cute swirl in the middle, of course.) Since it IS almost December, I went seasonal with my sprinkles, but obviously these cookies are perfect for ANY time of year. Parties, showers, movie nights, teacher gifts…you name it, these cookies are up for it.
P.S. I would fail as a mom if I didn’t brag about the cute note and picture my 5-year old drew for this post! At the last minute, before school the other day, I asked if he would write a quick note for Santa so I could use it in the picture. He did me one better and also drew a Santa picture. If the cookie photos don’t win you over to this recipe, I hope the marker drawings will!
Do you like the frosted cookies you get from a bakery? Then you’ll LOVE these Big Soft Sugar Cookies! Light and puffy sugar cookies are topped with a thick layer of frosting and your favorite sprinkles. These will quickly become a family favorite! If you can’t find International Delight Frosted Cookie coffee creamer, you can substitute another flavor of creamer, or an equal amount of milk or whipping cream.
In a medium bowl, whisk or sift together the flour, baking soda, and salt. Set aside for now.
In the bowl of a large stand mixer fitted with a paddle attachment, combine the butter and sugar. Beat on medium speed for 1-2 minutes, until light and fluffy.
Add the egg, vanilla, sour cream, and International Delight Frosted Cookie Coffee Creamer, and mix until well combined.
Finally, turn the mixer off and add the flour mixture. Mix on low speed until almost combined and just a few streaks of flour remain. Stop the mixer and finish mixing by hand, being sure to scrape the bottom and sides of the bowl well with a rubber spatula.
Scoop the dough out into 3-4 TBSP scoops onto the baking sheets—you should get about 20 cookies from this recipe. Bake at 350 F for 16-18 minutes, until the cookies are puffed and just starting to take on color around the edges. The tops should still remain virtually colorless.
Beat the butter with an electric mixer on medium speed for about 1 minute, until creamy and light in color. Add the powdered sugar, 3 TBSP of creamer, vanilla, and salt, and mix well, until light and fluffy. If the frosting is too stiff for your liking, slowly stream in the remaining spoonful of creamer, a bit at a time, until you get a texture you like.
Put a generous dollop of frosting on top of each cookie, and spread it around evenly over the top. Finish with a big pinch of sprinkles or other decorations.
For the best taste and texture, store in an airtight container, and enjoy within 2-3 days. The cookies and frosting can both be made in advance, and the cookies can be stored in the freezer for up to 2 months, while the frosting can be frozen for 2 months or refrigerated for 2 weeks. Make sure to store it with plastic pressed tightly to the top so it doesn’t form a crust. Allow it to come to room temperature and re-whip before using.
I made these yesterday for my husband’s office and they were so yummy. However, mine didn’t flatten out at all to match your picture … they stayed really tall. Did I mess up somehow? They were fully baked and soft.
Oh my sugar stars…these cookies themselves “encourage the spread”!…I’m off to search my closet for some looser jeans…Merry Christmas!
Hi Stephanie! I’m at 5500 feet and didn’t make any adjustments to the recipe. Unless you’re super high up I think you should be good!
I love your recipes. The last one I made was your purple Halloween cake – beautiful and delicious! Can these cookies be rolled so I can use cookie cutters? Or is there a better recipe I should use?
Oh God, you’re so talented. I have shared this to my friends. We will have an amazing Christmas day. Thank you!
Thank you so much for sharing my recipes! Hope you have a great Christmas and holiday season!
You can’t use cookie cutters with this recipe, the cookies will spread out too much. However here is a link to one of my favorite roll out sugar cookie recipes https://www.sugarhero.com/vintage-christmas-card-cakes/ Hope this is helpful!
Can anything be substituted for the creamer in the cookie and frosting recipes?
Yes, you can substitute an equal amount of milk or whipping cream!
These are very good. They didn’t flatten out for me on the first batch, so in the second I flattened them by hand a bit before baking. They came out perfect.
So glad to hear they worked out! Thanks for the flattening tip!
I am making these tonight for my daughter’s Christmas party at school for the kids to decorate. I don’t want them to spread too much. I want them to be thicker and fluffier like the ones you get at Walmart. LOL Suggestions?
I think you’ll be really happy with this recipe! When I make them they don’t spread too much and they stay thick and fluffy! Cookie decorating for a Christmas party is a great idea, let me know it goes!
I made these tonight for my kids for Christmas. They are DELISH!! Not only were they so good it was kind of fun to make because everyone got to help frost them and then they added their favorite colored sprinkles. You won’t regret making these. Thanks for the recipe.
These came out so good!! I’m making my second round of them today (I even made the first tray a little too small and they still came out perfect). I’m not usually an icing on cookies fan, but you’re right, that completely makes these cookies. Have an amazing holiday!
I made a few adjustments, only because I didn’t have everything on hand. I subbed the sour cream with vanilla Greek yogurt and cut the amount of vanilla down to 1 1/2 tsp, and I didn’t have any creamer so I used half and half (10% cream, usually used for coffee). The babies are baking now…the house smells incredible. I’m sure they’ll be delicious.
Delicious. Amazing. Tasty, easy to make. Have shared with anyone who will listen.
Hi! I love your recipes, I used the Pull Apart Wreath Cake as my Christmas cake last year which went really well!
Because I live practically in the middle of nowhere, is the sour cream necessary or can it be substituted?
I loved these cookies and my co-workers did too. I changed the way they were decorated to make Santa Bellies that I saw on Pinterest since the cookie kept this great puffed shape, I didn’t have to use the marshmallow to give the belly shape. Can’t wait to make them again this year. Though I need to use a different brand for red food coloring, the Wilton one I had didn’t give me the red I wanted and had to use almost the whole jar to get it as red as I did. Any suggestions on another company with better red food coloring would be appreciated.
Hey Mitzi, my preferred brand is Americolor the color you would want is super red. Also just to let you know colors deepen more over time in frosting so that is something to keep in mind. Thank you so much!
Loved the big soft sugar cookies. Flavor is amazing,but mine did not spread at all.. I am going to try again, maybe with less flour. Any reason as to what happened or what I did wrong?
Family still ate them all. Thanks for great recipes.
Cookies are really good. But I make golf ball size, which makes 33 cookies and bake for 10 minutes. They are perfect. I think, looking at your video, your cookie size is an ice cream scoop or tennis ball size..
Hey Nancy, glad you like the recipe! Sorry for the confusion, I guess golf ball could have been a bit misleading. I will have to change that so it is more clear. Thanks so much!!